California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 23, 2002

Student v. Lucia Mar Unified School District et al. (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 226-02 · Hearing Officer Glenn A. Fait

Lucia Mar Unified and San Luis Obispo County Office of Education offered FAPE to six-year-old with autism; all parent claims denied.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

Lucia Mar Unified School District and the San Luis Obispo County Office of Education filed for due process. They asked for a finding that they offered and provided a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in 2001-2002, including the extended school year. The parents of a six-year-old boy with autism cross-filed. A March 2001 IEP, built from a mediation agreement, gave him an intensive home program. It included 30 hours a week of one-to-one behavior assistants, speech therapy, occupational therapy, adaptive PE, local supervision, and 12 hours a month of doctoral-level supervision from the nonpublic agency Autism Partnership. Later, the parents objected to the Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS) and wanted the Nina Lovaas Reading and Writing Program instead. They also said the aides were not trained and were unhappy with Dr. Tracee Parker's supervision and communication. They challenged a January 2002 plan to move him back to school, too.

The Hearing Officer ruled for the agencies on every issue. No IEP the parents signed required a specific communication method. Because the boy was making progress, the choice of method was up to the agencies. The Hearing Officer found persuasive the testimony of independent assessor Dr. B.J. Freeman that he was benefiting, and gave little weight to the parents' expert. The aides were found trained and qualified. Dr. Parker gave more supervision than the IEP required and offered a reasonable way to communicate. The transition plan, which started with a two-day assessment at school, was found sensible. Compensatory education was not reached.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied Rowley to an intensive home-based autism program. When the student was making progress, the school chose between communication methods such as PECS and the Lovaas program, unless an agreed IEP named one. It also shows that language in IEPs the parents did not sign did not bind the agencies to a method.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1A. Was the communication program actually used inappropriate to meet Student's needs, and/or did it fail to comport with his IEP?

    No IEP the parents agreed to required the Lovaas Reading and Writing Program. Because the student was benefiting, including in communication, the choice of method (PECS or otherwise) was left to the District and the County Office.

  2. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue 1B. Was the communication program actually used inappropriate because it was not implemented by properly qualified and trained staff?

    The County Office behavior assistants were properly trained and qualified, and kept receiving training. Training in the Lovaas program was not required because that method was not being used.

  3. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1C(1). Were the nonpublic agency supervision services inappropriate to meet Student's needs because the doctoral-level supervision of the program was inadequate?

    Dr. Parker of Autism Partnership was well qualified and gave more supervision than the IEP required and more than is typical in the field.

  4. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1C(2). Were the nonpublic agency supervision services inappropriate because the consultation and communication with the parents was inadequate?

    Dr. Parker offered an appropriate way to communicate: in person during monthly home visits and team meetings, and by email through the local supervisor. Personality conflict did not keep her from doing her job.

  5. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1D. Was there an adequate plan to appropriately transition Student from his primary home program to a school program?

    The January 9, 2002 plan was appropriate. It began with a two-day assessment at school, then a schedule would be built from what staff observed, and it did not rule out any placement.

  6. Issue 2. If the District and County Office failed to provide or offer a FAPE, is Student entitled to compensatory education?

    The Hearing Officer did not reach this issue because FAPE was found to have been provided and offered.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order that district's offer may be implemented. Order found that the District and SLOCOE provided and/or offered a FAPE for 2001-2002, including the extended school year, and will continue to make that program available for the rest of the school year, including the extended school year. All of the student's claims were denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Renner v. Bd. of Educ. of Ann Arbor; Tucker v. Calloway Co. Bd. of Educ.; Ft. Zumwalt Sch. Dist. v. Clynes

People named in the decision

  • Don Dennison, Director of pupil personnel services, Lucia Mar Unified School District
  • Mary Jo DeSio, County Office representative at hearing (title not stated), San Luis Obispo County Office of Education
  • Jackie Kirk-Martinez, Area administrator, San Luis Obispo County Office of Education
  • Karin Marohn, Advocate for Student
  • B.J. Freeman, Ph.D., Independent assessor and expert witness, UCLA School of Medicine
  • Tracee Parker, Ph.D., Doctoral-level (Ph.D.) supervisor, nonpublic agency, Autism Partnership
  • Kristi Myers (also spelled Kristy Meyers), Local program supervisor, Contracted by District/SLOCOE
  • Mitchell Taubman, Ph.D., Director of research; witness for District, Autism Partnership
  • Ron Leaf, Ph.D., Co-director; witness for District, Autism Partnership
  • Jennifer Ramirez, Speech-language provider
  • Nancy Sena, Speech-language provider
  • Sonja de Boer-Ott, Board certified behavior analyst; expert witness for Student, Kansas City Kansas Public School System (educational consultant)
  • Christian Herrick, Behavior assistant, San Luis Obispo County Office of Education
  • Tammy Lundquist, Behavior assistant, San Luis Obispo County Office of Education
  • Rayne Gauvreau, Local supervisor, autism program, San Luis Obispo County Office of Education
  • Jenevieve Sullivan, Supervisor, provider funded by the Regional Center, Best Pals
  • Autism Partnership, Nonpublic agency
  • Verdugo Hills Psychological Association, Private provider that supervised the earlier parent-run home program
  • Best Pals, Private provider funded by the Regional Center

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard on February 28, and March 1, 4, 25, 26, and 27, 2002, in Arroyo Grande, California, by Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific.

Lucia Mar Unified School District (District) and the San Luis Obispos County Office of Education (SLOCOE) were represented by attorneys Charles Weatherly, Jennifer Fain, and Daniel A.Osher. Also present on behalf of District was Don Dennison, director of pupil personnel services. Also present on behalf of SLOCOE were Mary Jo DeSio and Jackie Kirk-Martinez.

STUDENT was represented by attorneys Bob N. Varma, Geralyn M. Clancy, and Roberta S. Savage. Also present on behalf of STUDENT were his parents, MOTHER and FATHER, and advocate Karin Marohn.

The hearing in this matter concluded on March 27, 2002. The record was left open for the receipt of written closing arguments. The record was closed on April 23, 2002, and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUES

1. Have the District and/or SLOCOE failed to provide or offer to provide STUDENT a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2001-2002 school year, including the extended school year in one or more of the following respects:

A. Was the communication program actually utilized inappropriate to meet STUDENT’s needs and/or did it fail to comport with his IEP.?

B. Was the communication program actually utilized inappropriate because it was not implemented by properly qualified and trained staff?

C. Were the nonpublic agency supervision services inappropriate to meet STUDENT’s needs because:

(1) The doctoral-level supervision of the program was inadequate; and/or (2) The consultation and communication with the parents was inadequate?

D. Was there an adequate plan to appropriately transition STUDENT from his primary home program to a school program?(Footnote 1)

2. If it is concluded that the District and County Office failed to provide or offer a FAPE, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education.(Footnote 2)

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a six-year-old boy with an autistic disorder that has resulted in significant delays in all areas of development. STUDENT enrolled in a District special day class during the 1998-99 school year. The following year he was placed in the STEP class for autistic children. In June 2000, STUDENT’s parents removed him from the school program and instituted an in-home program supervised by Verdugo Hills Psychological Association. The District believed it had an appropriate public school program for STUDENT. Following a number of individualized education program (IEP) meetings, settlement discussions and mediation, the District, SLOCOE, and STUDENT’s parents agreed to have an independent assessment of STUDENT by Dr. B.J. Freeman, a professor of medical psychology at UCLA School of Medicine, to help the IEP team to identify his needs.

In her report dated March 22, 2001, Dr. Freeman made a number of specific recommendations concerning STUDENT’s educational program. Her recommendations included an intensive intervention program supervised by Autism Partnership that would provide five to six hours per day of developmentally appropriate structured activities that would include one-to-one teaching in the context of a year-round program. Dr. Freeman also recommended that STUDENT receive three individual 30-minute sessions of speech and language services and two 30-minute group sessions per week.

On March 16, 2001, the IEP team met and incorporated provisions of a mediation agreement into STUDENT’s IEP. Among other things, the agreement provided that “the District and/or SLOCOE will contract with nonpublic agency Autism Partnership (by Tracee Parker, Ph.D. or another doctoral-level supervisor) for at least 20 hours of doctoral-level supervision services to develop an early intensive intervention (EII) plan for STUDENT in conjunction with SLOCOE Autism Supervisor.” Also included in the agreement were specific services that the District and/or SLOCOE would provide to STUDENT, including 30 hours per week of one-to-one behavior assistant services, three thirty-minute sessions of one-to-one speech and language services per week, two thirty-minute sessions per week of small-group speech and language services, two forty five-minute sessions per week of one-to-one occupational therapy services, and one thirty-minute session of adaptive physical education per week. The agreement provided that four hours per week of local supervision of the program would be provided. At the parents’ request, the District and SLOCOE agreed to contract for the services of Kristi Myers, who had provided services to STUDENT in the past, to be the local supervisor of STUDENT’s program and agreed to hire as STUDENT’s behavioral assistants persons who had provided services to him in the past. The agreement also provided that there would be 12 hours per month of doctoral-level supervision provided by Autism Partnership using Dr. Tracee Parker or another doctoral-level supervisor. The agreement provided for an extended year program and anticipated that STUDENT would make a transition into a special education and/or general education classroom setting. These agreed-upon services were to begin on April 1, 2001. The agreement also provided that Dr. Freeman would conduct follow-up assessments of STUDENT’s progress three months and six months after the start of STUDENT’s program. STUDENT’s parents approved the March 16, 2001 IEP.

The District and SLOCOE began providing the program set out in the March 16, 2001 IEP at STUDENT’s home in April 2001.

On May 23, 2001, the IEP team met to consider the transition of STUDENT into a school setting. The team agreed that STUDENT would attend the primary special day class at North Oceano Elementary School. The team agreed that he would begin with approximately one hour a day, with the goal of having him in school for an hour and thirty-five minutes per day.

STUDENT began attending North Oceano Elementary School on May 29, 2001, but was removed by his parents after approximately 15 days so that he could be toilet-trained at home.

During the summer of 2001, STUDENT’s parents developed concerns about his program. They were dissatisfied with the Ph.D. supervision provided by Tracee Parker, believed that the behavior assistants and local supervisor were not properly trained, and were dissatisfied with the communications program being used to teach STUDENT how to communicate his needs.

During the month of June 2001, STUDENT’s parents barred Dr. Parker from coming into their home. Although she was not able to observe STUDENT in his home, Dr. Parker continued to provide consultation to the local supervisor and SLOCO regarding STUDENT’s program.

On September 7, 2001, Dr. Freeman performed an assessment of STUDENT’s progress. She concluded that:

STUDENT has made significant progress since the time of his previous evaluation by this examiner. In talking to Kristy Meyers, his supervisor, she reports that STUDENT has made “great strides in all areas.” She also notes that STUDENT tends to become very prompt dependent. STUDENT was observed to have good attention to task with matching words and pictures. He was completely engaged in the task as opposed to previous observations where STUDENT appeared not motivated to perform any task. In addition, STUDENT has become toilet trained for urine over the summer. There was slight regression in July, but this has improved.

Dr. Freeman also addressed the complaints of STUDENT’s parents about Dr. Parker and the training of the aides. She stated:

In talking to mother, it is unclear what types of changes she would like to have made in STUDENT’s program. At this point, she feels that supervision has not been adequate and the aides have not been trained. In addition, mother feels that there has been little communication among the staff. However, in reviewing the detailed notes in the treatment notebook, as well as the monthly consultation reports by Dr. Tracee Parker, I do not believe that this can be substantiated. At this point, mother, receives eight hours a month of supervision from Dr. Parker. (The standard of practice for supervision is two hours per month for Ph.D. supervision.) In addition, the local supervisor, Kristy Meyers, provides 20 hours a month of supervision. (Again, the standard of practice is no more than six hours a month provided for supervisors to work on programs within the home.) In addition, there are numerous reports of collaboration between the speech therapist, the occupational therapist, and the adaptive physical education therapist with the therapists in the home.

Dr. Freeman recommended that “the focus of STUDENT’s program continue to be on a total communication program, and increased emphasis placed on getting him to initiate communication with the Picture Exchange Communication System(PECS).” She also recommended that he be moved from home to school.

On September 25, 2001, the IEP team met to discuss goals and objectives for STUDENT. The IEP proposed goals relating to attending, task completion, nonverbal imitation (NVI), letter matching, compliance, word approximation, communication using yes/no, receptive instructions using verbal commands paired with pictures, signs, or the written word, expressive communication using pictures, signs, or the written word, use of phonemes, self-help skills, dressing, toileting, PECS, fine-motor skills, holding writing utensils, writing letters of the alphabet, writing STUDENT’s name, matching shapes to words, matching letters to form words, sequencing events, keyboarding directed toward typing three to four letter words, community safety, play and social skills, self-stimulatory behavior, categorizing pictures/written words, and identifying body parts.

During the IEP meeting, STUDENT’s parents said that they wanted to delay his return to school for thirty days in order to develop and implement an intensive toilet training program. Although Tracie Parker stated serious reservations concerning STUDENT’s removal from school, the IEP team agreed to a temporary delay of STUDENT’s return to a school setting and agreed to have the new local supervisor collaborate on the intensive bowel training program. The notes in the IEP reflect that continued services would be provided to STUDENT while he was at home and that Autism Partnership would concentrate on “development and implementation of objectives in the areas of attending, task completion, NVI, compliance, behaviors, self help, safety, implementation of PECS, receptive instructions, expressive labels, matching/sequencing colors/shapes, lining up boundaries, coloring, social/play, peer imitation and independent play.” The September 25, 2001 IEP also reflected that “the team will also be implementing the reading and writing program.” Autism Partnership Ph.D. level was to continue to consult one full day per month. The IEP also provided that the team was to meet within a month to discuss transitioning STUDENT into a school setting. STUDENT’s mother did not indicate on the IEP form whether she agreed or disagreed with the September 25, 2001 IEP.

Another IEP team meeting was conducted on November 5, 2001, to try again to address STUDENT’s mother’s concerns about the communications program, the training of the behavior assistants and the Ph.D supervision and attempt to reach agreement on a program for STUDENT. During the IEP meeting, STUDENT’s mother and her attorney requested that the PECS program be deleted from the IEP and that the Lovaas Reading and Writing Program be implemented instead. The following language was included in the IEP.

Picture Exchange Communication System will not be implemented as designed by Bond and Frost. However, STUDENT is being taught words through presentation of pictures and then exchanging words for his communication. The reference of PECS through his goals and objectives are in reference to the pictures being taught to get to the words for communication. The team will be implementing a writing and reading program incorporating strategies that teach words to get to communication such as those used in the Nina Lovaas Program.

The IEP also noted that STUDENT’s parents and the District and SLOCOE continued to disagree over the use of Autism Partnership and Dr. Parker as the Ph.D. supervisor. Appended to the IEP were Dr. Freeman’s assessment, STUDENT’s mother’s statement of concerns about STUDENT’s program, and Dr. Parker’s response to those concerns. STUDENT’s parents did not indicate approval or disagreement of the IEP.

On December 17, 2001, STUDENT’s mother e-mailed the SLOCOE that she was canceling all services except for speech and occupational therapy, and adaptive P.E. services. She stated that “again I will reiterate that we have never had a problem with the aides or other service providers it seems that all the problems come from Supervision and Administration.” She said that the aides had never been trained in the Lovaas Reading and Writing Program as she had requested.

On December 21, 2001, the District notified STUDENT’s parents that an IEP meeting would be held on January 9, 2002, to review and discuss STUDENT’s possible educational needs, goals and objectives, placement/program, and/or related services. STUDENT’s attorney notified the District that STUDENT’s parents would not attend the IEP meeting.

Those who attended the IEP meeting reviewed the past IEPs and the recent developments, including the termination by STUDENT’s mother of all but the designated instructional services. They noted that STUDENT was now receiving services at a school site for only one hour, four times per week for one-to-one speech services. The team then addressed the need to transition STUDENT back into a school setting. They developed a transition plan that included a plan for assessing STUDENT during two days at school. From those observations, a class schedule would be developed that would fit STUDENT’s individual needs. The IEP team attached a sample class schedule which could be used in developing STUDENT’s individual schedule. Also attached to the IEP was a document titled “Parent Addendum to STUDENT’s November 5, 2001 IEP.” In this addendum, STUDENT’s mother agreed to the proposed level of services and goals and objectives. She also agreed to the current service providers in the areas of speech and language, occupational therapy, adaptive physical education, and behavior assistants. She again stated that the behavior aides were not properly trained and that the Ph.D. consultant and local supervisor had not provided the training necessary to implement the Lovaas Reading and Writing Program. She restated her desire to have the Lovaas Reading and Writing Program used with STUDENT.

On February 4, 2002, the District and SLOCOE filed a request for due process hearing to establish that it had provided or offered STUDENT FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year. STUDENT’s parents cross-filed on February 18, 2002 claiming that the District and SLOCOE had failed to offer or provide a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year.

It should be noted that between the March 16, 2001 IEP meeting and the filing of the requests for due process hearings, there were numerous meetings, telephone calls, letters and e-mails between the various parties. A record of those communications fill many of the ten large binders of documentary evidence and the sixteen audio cassettes accepted into evidence.

LEGAL ANALYSIS

Pursuant to the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. Section 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code Section 5600. FAPE consists of special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, meet the State educational standards, and conform to the child’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. Section 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parents, that is provided to meet the unique needs of a student. 20 U.S.C. Section 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code Section 56031. “Related services” means transportation and other developmental, corrective and supportive services as may be required to assist the student to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. Section 1401(22); Cal. Educ. Code Section 56363(a).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. Id at 198-200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201. The Court also stressed the importance of the procedural safeguards contained in the IDEA and noted that those safeguards were designed to ensure “full participation of concerned parties throughout the development of the IEP.” Id. at 206.

The District’s compliance with IDEA procedures was not an issue in this hearing.(Footnote 3)

All of the parties concede that the IEP developed during the March 16, 2001 IEP was calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit. The IEP was the result of a long, hard negotiation and was agreed to by STUDENT’s mother who testified that she was excited about the program and was optimistic about its future success. STUDENT’s representatives contended that the actual program provided by the District did not constitute a FAPE because is failed to address his unique needs, did not conform to his IEP and did not result in educational progress. These factors will be considered in relation to each of the issues raised by STUDENT.

Communication Program

STUDENT’s parents’ primary disagreement with STUDENT’s communications program was that they wanted the District and SLOCOE to use the Nina Lovaas Reading and Writing Program rather than the PECS program as a tool in teaching STUDENT to communicate his needs. Both the Reading and Writing Program and the PECS program are packaged programs that can be purchased and used to assist children with significant communication impairments. The District and SLOCOE initially favored the use of PECS but during the November 5, 2001 IEP meeting agreed to implement “a writing and reading program incorporating strategies that teach words to get to communication such as those used in the Nina Lovaas Program.”

It is important to note that the use of either Reading and Writing or the PECS program was only a part of the overall communication program being provided to STUDENT. STUDENT was being provided speech services consisting of four thirty-minute sessions per week. Other strategies to assist STUDENT with communication were included in his goals and objectives, including nonverbal imitation (NVI) matching letters, matching words, using verbal imitations, communicating yes/no with a head nod or a word card, expressive communication through pictures, gestural signs, written words or attempted verbalizations, matching phonemes to letters, and using signs, or word cards for toileting.

The courts have consistently ruled that as long as a disabled student is benefitting from his education, educational methodologies are left up to school authorities. Rowley at 208; see also Renner v. Bd. Of Educ. Of Ann Arbor, 185 F. 3d 635 (6th Cir. 1999); Tucker v. Calloway Co. Bd. Of Educ., 136 F. 3d 495(6th Cir. 1998); Ft. Zumwalt Sch. Dist. v. Clynes, 119 F. 3d 607 (8th Cir. 1997).

STUDENT’s parents argue that STUDENT’s IEP required implementation of the Lovaas Reading and Writing Program and that STUDENT was denied FAPE because the District and SLOCOE failed to carry out the IEP. However, the evidence does not support that conclusion. The March 16, 2001 IEP, which was approved by all parties, did not mention specific methodologies to be used for STUDENT’s communication program; neither did the May 23, 2001 IEP, which was approved by all parties. The IEP of September 25, 200l, does mention the PECS program and also states that the “team will be implementing the reading and writing program.” But STUDENT’s parents did not approve the September 25, 2001 IEP. In the November 5, 2001 IEP, the District and SLOCOE agreed to implement a writing program “incorporating strategies that teach words to get to communication such as those used in the Nina Lovaas program.” These words did not obligate the District or SLOCOE to implement the Nina Lovaas Reading and Writing Program. They merely agreed to provide a program that used strategies like those of the Lovass Program. In any case, STUDENT’s parents did not agree to the November 5, 2001 IEP either. The record does not reflect a meeting of the minds concerning whether the PECS program or the Lovaas Reading and Writing Program, or a combination of the two, would be used. In the absence of such a meeting of the minds concerning a specific methodology, it is up to the District and SLOCOE to determine the appropriate methodology to use in meeting STUDENT’s goals and objectives, unless it can be shown that STUDENT has failed to benefit from his program because of the use of a specific methodology.

Dr. B.J. Freeman testified during the hearing that the program provided to STUDENT by the District and SLOCOE was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. In fact, it contained more services than were recommended in her February assessment report. She further testified that STUDENT was benefitting from his program in all areas, including communication, by making slow and steady progress. She admitted that STUDENT regressed at times in some areas, but noted that such regression is common with autistic children. However, comparing his performance in December 2001 to his performance in February 2001, Dr. Freeman concluded that he was benefitting from his program. Dr. Freeman also testified that PECS is an appropriate program to use with STUDENT and concluded in her September 2001 review of STUDENT’s progress that “increased emphasis should be placed on getting him to initiate communication with the Picture Exchange Communication System(PECS).”

Dr. Freeman was originally chosen by STUDENT’s parents, District, and SLOCOE to perform the independent assessment of STUDENT in February 2001. In her report, she recommended an intensive program to address STUDENT’s needs. Dr. Freeman is a professor of medical psychology at UCLA and director of clinical autism services at UCLA. During the last thirty years, she has had extensive national and international experience in the diagnosis, treatment, and educational programming for children with autism. She assessed STUDENT twice and interviewed STUDENT’s mother. Prior to the hearing, she reviewed all ten volumes of the documents and the videotapes that were received into evidence in this case, interviewed SLOCOE and District personnel who provided services to STUDENT, and consulted with other experts about STUDENT’s case. Her testimony was very credible and persuasive.

Dr. Freeman’s opinion that STUDENT was benefitting from the educational services provided by the District and SLOCOE was supported by all of the other witnesses called by the District including Dr. Mitchell Taubman, the director of research for Autism Partnership; Dr. Ron Leaf, co-director of Autism Partnership; Dr. Tracee Parker, the Ph.D. supervisor of STUDENT’s program; Jennifer Ramirez and Nancy Sena, who provided speech and language services to STUDENT; and Jackie Kirk-Martinez, SLOCOE area administrator.

STUDENT’s mother was not satisfied with STUDENT’s progress. She admitted that he had learned to use the PECS cards for food items, but was concerned that he was not able to communicate about other things. While she was not satisfied with STUDENT’s progress, her testimony did support the conclusion that he was making some progress.

The only person called as an expert witness by STUDENT’s attorney was Sonja de Boer-Ott, who is a board certified behavior analyst. She received a bachelor’s degree in biology in 1994, a master’s degree with a focus on behavior in 1998, and has not yet completed the first year of her doctoral program. Ms. de Boer-Ott has had limited experience with autistic children. She has had two classes dealing exclusively with children with autism, was a special education teacher for eight months dealing with children with a variety of disabilities including autism, and has worked as a manager for Behavior Analysts, Inc. for a short period of time, and currently works as an educational consultant for the Kansas City Kansas Public School System. Most of her testimony related to her review of the two data notebooks covering the time from April 2001 to December 2001. Her testimony consisted of what could be fairly described as nitpicking. She testified that she could not render an opinion as to whether STUDENT had benefitted from his program because the data provided were not enough on which to base an opinion. However, she admitted that she had observed only a few videotapes of STUDENT and two data notebooks, along with other documents selected by STUDENT’s attorney. She did not review all ten binders of evidence, did not do a formal assessment of STUDENT, did not speak to any of those who provided services to STUDENT, and did not speak to other experts who have reviewed his progress. Because of Ms. Boer-Ott’s limited expertise in the area of autism and scant knowledge of STUDENT, her testimony was of little, if any, value to the Hearing Officer in evaluating STUDENT’s program.

On the basis of the persuasive evidence presented by the District and SLOCOE including the testimony of a number of extremely qualified experts, it is concluded that STUDENT’s program as provided and proposed by the District and SLOCOE was specially designed to meet his unique needs and resulted in benefit to STUDENT in all areas, including communication. Therefore, it is not appropriate for the hearing officer to second-guess the District or SLOCOE concerning the methodology they used in providing those benefits to STUDENT.

Qualified and Trained Staff

STUDENT’s parents contend that STUDENT did not receive a FAPE because the behavioral assistants responsible for STUDENT’s communication program were not qualified or trained. While acknowledging that the SLOCOE behavior assistants were skilled in working with STUDENT, STUDENT’s parents contended that they had not received necessary training. Therefore, when they were claiming that the behavioral assistants were not qualified, what they really meant was that they had not been properly trained. During the hearing it became clear that the main point of contention was whether the behavioral assistants had been trained in the Lovaas Reading and Writing Program and the PECS program. The District and SLOCOE contended that it was not necessary to provide training in the Lovaas Reading and Writing Program because it was not proposing that program for STUDENT. As mentioned above, as long as STUDENT is benefitting from his education, educational methodology should be left to the school authorities. Therefore, there was no requirement that the staff be trained in the Lovaas Reading and Writing Program.

STUDENT’s parents also contend that the behavioral assistants were not trained in PECS, which was a part of his communications program. The March 16, 2001 IEP provides that “all of STUDENT’s service providers will be ‘qualified’ such that they have knowledge, training, and experience in working with children with autism.” The IEP also provided that SLOCOE would hire new behavioral assistants for STUDENT and would begin to provide services on April 1, 2001. Ms. de Boer-Ott testified that it was important to train the behavioral assistants, but admitted that she was not aware of the training provided to STUDENT’s behavioral assistants. STUDENT’s mother testified that she did not believe that STUDENT’s behavioral assistants had received appropriate training in relation to PECS. She appeared to be most concerned about the lack of formal classroom training. Christian Herrick, one of the behavioral assistants who provided services to STUDENT testified that he had not been formally trained in PECS when he started providing services in April, but that he later received formal training in PECS during an all-day training program. Tammy Lundquist, another behavioral assistant who worked with STUDENT, testified that she had received the necessary training to provide all of the services that she provided to STUDENT.

In her response to STUDENT’s mother’s complaints about training, Dr. Tracee Parker, STUDENT’s Ph.D. supervisor, wrote:

To clarify, “training” occurs via a variety of modalities, contexts and forums. This may include: Formal presentations, problem solving programming issues, hands on during overlap with more experienced training staff, direct observation and feedback by supervisor/myself, team meetings, etc. Each of these modalities have been utilized and incorporated within the context of the overall program. Additionally, training was but one of numerous areas identified as needing to be addressed during the initial months of designing and developing this program for STUDENT.

The evidence also established that the District had a short period of time to prepare STUDENT’s program, which was to begin within two weeks of the IEP meeting. Moreover, the IEP, at the parent’s request, provided that new staff were to be hired to work with STUDENT. Because of these requirements, during the first month of the program, the SLOCOE behavioral assistants were assigned to shadow more experienced personnel who were also providing services to STUDENT under the auspices of the Regional Center. This was probably one of the best methods of training under the circumstances.

Rayne Gauvreau is a local supervisor for the SLOCOE autism program. While she was not the supervisor of STUDENT’s program, she did supervise Christian Herrick and Tammy Lundquist, STUDENT’s behavioral assistants, because they were working with other children’s programs she supervised. She testified that she has provided comprehensive training to Mr. Harrick and Ms. Lundquist, including formal training, consultation by phone or in meetings, and one-to-one training while the behavioral assistant is working with children. She was of the opinion that STUDENT’s behavioral assistants were well-trained.

Dr. Freeman testified that from her review of the evidence, observation of the video tapes of behavioral assistants working with STUDENT, and her discussions with staff and other experts, she believed that the behavioral assistants providing services to STUDENT had been properly trained. Her opinion concerning training of STUDENT’s behavioral assistants was shared by a number of other witnesses, including Ms. Kirk-Martinez, Dr. Parker, and Jenevieve Sullivan who had worked with STUDENT as a supervisor for Best Pals. Best Pals had provided additional services for STUDENT funded by the Regional Center.

On the basis of this evidence, it is concluded that the SLOCOE behavior assistants who provided services to STUDENT from April 2001 through December 2001 were properly trained and qualified to provide services to STUDENT and were receiving continuing training throughout the time they provided services to STUDENT. No denial of a FAPE occurred because of a lack of trained staff.

Adequacy of Ph.D. Supervision

STUDENT’s parents claim that the nonpublic agency Ph.D. supervision of STUDENT’s program by Dr. Tracee Parker was inappropriate because Dr. Parker did not provide adequate supervision of STUDENT’s program. They also contend that she did not adequately consult and communicate with them. STUDENT’s parents did not contend that Dr. Parker lacked the qualifications necessary to perform the responsibilities of a Ph.D. supervisor.(Footnote 4) They felt that Dr. Parker should have done more hands-on training of STUDENT’s behavior assistants, should have spent more time observing STUDENT and should have demonstrated the proper methods of teaching STUDENT to his parents and the behavior assistants. STUDENT’s parents also believed that they should be able to have more direct communication with Dr. Parker.

The March 16, 2001 IEP called for twelve hours per month of Ph.D. level supervision. Dr. Freeman testified that the standard practice in the field for doctoral level consultation is two to four hours per month. Dr. Parker testified that she spent much more time on STUDENT’s program than was called for by the IEP. Unfortunately, much of the time was spent in trying to deal with complaints by STUDENT’s parents.

Dr. Parker testified that most of the training of the behavior assistants was to be done by the local supervisor. Dr. Parker, in turn, would provide training and guidance to the local supervisor and be available for consultation when specific problems occurred. Dr. Parker also testified that it was not appropriate for her to demonstrate techniques to use with STUDENT, because STUDENT did not know her and would not have the same comfort level that he had with his behavior assistants. She said the preferred method is to observe the behavior assistants with STUDENT and provide constructive feedback to them on how they might improve their skills.

Dr. Parker testified that she was available for direct communication with the parents during the monthly eight hour periods that she spent in STUDENT’s home and during monthly team meetings. During other times, Dr. Parker was available by e-mail through the local supervisor. Dr. Parker testified that by communicating through the local supervisor she was able to avoid the risk of telling something to the parents that the local supervisor was not informed of, thereby leading to confusion in how to carry out STUDENT’s program.

Dr. Freeman reviewed all of the evidence admitted at the hearing and interviewed those who provided services to STUDENT. She testified that Dr. Parker provided more service than would be typical in the field. She also agreed with the methods of communication established by Dr. Parker.

Much of STUDENT’s mother’s dissatisfaction with Dr. Parker appears to have been based on a conflict of personality. Dr. Parker, who admits that she is not the most tactful person, and that she said some things that offended STUDENT’s mother. In some e-mails between Dr. Parker and SLOCOE and District staff that were submitted as evidence, Dr. Parker made some disparaging remarks about STUDENT’s parents. On the other hand, STUDENT’s parents made disparaging remarks about Dr. Parker in communications to the District and SLOCOE. Although STUDENT’s parents have clearly demonstrated animosity toward Dr. Parker, there is no evidence that Dr. Parker would not be able to fulfill her responsibilities as the Ph.D. supervisor of STUDENT’s program because of that animosity. In fact, she did continue to provide that supervision after STUDENT’s parents refused to let her in the house. She continued to consult with the local supervisor, conduct team meetings, and fulfill other functions that the Ph.D. supervisor would normally do. It would certainly be preferable that a positive relationship be reestablished between STUDENT’s parents and Dr. Parker.(Footnote 5)

The evidence establishes that Dr. Parker is a well-qualified Ph.D. supervisor who has provided appropriate services in accordance with the IEP and has provided an appropriate means by which STUDENT’s parents can communicate with her. And, as concluded above, STUDENT has benefitted from his program during the time that Dr. Parker has been the Ph.D. supervisor of his program.

Was the Transition Plan Proposed by the District and SLOCOE appropriate for STUDENT?

STUDENT’s parents contend that the transition plan developed during the IEP meeting of January 9, 2002, was not appropriate. The evidence demonstrated that throughout the time between the March 16, 2001 IEP and the January 9, 2002 IEP everyone anticipated that STUDENT would be placed in a school-based program. On January 9, 2002, the IEP team met to discuss how to implement STUDENT’s transition back into a school setting. It was determined that STUDENT would be brought to a school class setting for two days to perform an assessment of his readiness to return to school. After the assessment, a complete schedule would be developed for STUDENT’s program, including the time in school and the time at home. A sample schedule was attached to the IEP, as was the two-day assessment plan.

STUDENT’s representative claims that the proposed transition plan was not detailed enough to constitute an offer of placement. He also contends that it did not include consideration of all possible appropriate placements, including the mainstreaming of STUDENT for a portion of the day.

These concerns miss a crucial point. STUDENT had been out of a school setting for over six months. It certainly would not be appropriate to design every detail of a plan to transition him to a school setting without first assessing and observing him in a school setting. There was nothing in the assessment plan that precluded any placement. It was rather a plan to see how STUDENT gets along in a school setting before designing the final plan. It was a completely sensible approach and was endorsed by Dr. Freeman and Dr. Parker. Unfortunately, STUDENT’s parents refused to attend the January 9, 2002 IEP meeting.

It is concluded that the plan developed by the IEP team on January 9, 2002, was an appropriate way of approaching STUDENT’s transition from a home to a school setting.(Footnote 6)

Because the District and SLOCOE provided and/or offered a program for STUDENT which was not only calculated to provide STUDENT with benefit, but actually provided such benefit during the time he was in that program, it is concluded that the District and SLOCOE provided and/or offered a FAPE to STUDENT during the 2001-2002 school year including the extended school year.

Because it has been concluded that STUDENT was provided and/or offered and appropriate program it is not necessary to address the issue of compensatory education.

ORDER

1. The District and SLOCOE have provided and/or offered to provide a FAPE to STUDENT during the 2001-2002 school year including the extended school year and will continue to make that program available to STUDENT during the remainder of the school year including the extended school year.

2. All of STUDENT’s claims are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement: The District and SLOCOE prevailed on all issues heard and decided. .

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of the receipt of this Decision. Education Code section 56505(i).

Dated:

Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES

1. The issue presented by the District and County Office was whether or not they had provided or offered to provide a FAPE to STUDENT during the 2001-2002 year, including the extended year. STUDENT’s representative stipulated that STUDENT was claiming a denial of a FAPE only on the grounds set out in issue statement one above. The Hearing Officer instructed the parties that he would limit the hearing to those matters actually in dispute. 2. At the beginning of the hearing, STUDENT’s representatives stated that STUDENT’s parents were entitled to reimbursement for educational expenses they had incurred because of the District’s failure to provide a FAPE. However, there was no evidence presented during the hearing of any such expenses. 3. During testimony, STUDENT’s mother stated that she had not been given adequate opportunity to participate in developing and implementing STUDENT’s program. This was not raised as an issue for hearing. Even if this were an issue in this case, the record was replete with evidence that STUDENT’s parents were allowed to participate in the planning and implementation of STUDENT’s program. The IEP of March 16, 2001, was a result of a long negotiation between the District, SLOCOE, and STUDENT’s parents, and contained many things demanded by STUDENT’s parents. The goals and objectives that STUDENT’s mother finally accepted contained many she had requested. It appears that STUDENT’s mother believed she was denied participation in developing STUDENT’s program because the District and SLOCOE would not approve everything she requested. The law mandates meaningful participation by parents, not complete acquiescence by the District to the parent’s demands. 34 CFR Section 300.345 4. In fact, Dr. Parker’s credentials are impressive. She has been providing services to autistic children for over 25 years. 5. It would help if STUDENT’s parents were not overly sensitive about things that were not intended to be offensive and if Dr. Parker would not use her obvious concern for STUDENT as an excuse to be insensitive to the feelings of STUDENT’s parents. 6. It is the opinion of the Hearing Officer from a review of all of the evidence in this case that it is crucial that STUDENT be placed in an appropriate school setting without delay.