California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 25, 2002
Student v. Kern High School District
SEHO Case No. SN 2271-01 · Hearing Officer Paul E. Lacy
Kern High School District must place student with autism at Valley Achievement Center and provide compensatory speech and life-skills services.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a 16-year-old tenth grader with autism filed for due process against Kern High School District. She was selectively mute, had severe anxiety in social settings, and had not attended school since February 2001. Her home instruction amounted to one hour a week. During the hearing, the District stipulated that it denied her a FAPE from September 2000 to December 2001 because it gave her no speech and language services. The parties then added two issues: the District's December 6, 2001 IEP offer and the parents' request for Valley Achievement Center (VAC), a nonpublic school for students with autism.
The Hearing Officer found the December 2001 offer was not a FAPE. The present levels did not describe her needs. The social goals were generic items from a preprinted list with no objectives, and other goals were far too limited. The District also discussed several possible programs instead of making one specific written offer. Under Union School Dist. v. Smith, this shut the parents out of decision-making. The Hearing Officer found that VAC's small, structured programs met her needs. The District must place her there for the rest of 2001-2002, including extended school year, and provide speech, counseling, and transportation. As compensatory education, the District must fund VAC's afternoon social and daily living skills program for 2002-2003. It must also add 60 minutes of speech per week for 15 months. The District must conduct occupational therapy and auditory processing assessments.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO enforced the Union v. Smith rule that a district must make one specific written offer. Listing several undefined options was treated as a procedural violation that denied FAPE. The decision also used a year in a nonpublic school's skills program as compensatory education, rather than extra hours added to the school day.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE at the December 6, 2001 IEP meeting for the remainder of the 2001-2002 school year?
The offer was not a FAPE. Present levels lacked needed detail, the goals were generic or far too limited, and the District presented several possible programs rather than one specific written offer, which prejudiced the parents under Union and W.G. v. Target Range.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 2. If the District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE, is the Valley Achievement Center (VAC) the appropriate placement to meet her unique needs?
VAC's small, structured morning academic program and afternoon social and daily living skills program meet her needs. The District was not given another chance to design a program after failing to do so for more than 15 months.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. What compensatory education is appropriate for STUDENT for the period of time that the District did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE?
The District stipulated that it denied FAPE from September 2000 to December 2001 by providing no speech and language services, and it never addressed her communication, anxiety, social, or daily living needs. The Hearing Officer ordered compensatory speech and a year of VAC's afternoon program.
- Student prevailed in partAssessment
Issue 4. What assessments is the District required to administer to STUDENT?
The District agreed to occupational therapy and auditory processing assessments. The Hearing Officer ordered both and required the District to disclose the assessor's name and qualifications and the assessment's nature, length, date, time, and place. The prevailing-party section states that neither party prevailed.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Placement ordered. Within 10 calendar days, place Student at Valley Achievement Center for the full morning and afternoon programs for the remainder of the 2001-2002 school year, including extended school year.
- Order to provide or change services. Within 10 calendar days, consistent with the December 2001 IEP: speech and language services twice a week for 30 minutes per session, two counseling sessions per month with a school social worker, and door-to-door transportation for each service, for the balance of the 2001-2002 school year including extended school year.
- Compensatory education. Placement in VAC's afternoon social and daily living skills program for the 2002-2003 school year, including extended school year.
- Compensatory education. Within 10 calendar days, 60 minutes of speech and language services each week for 15 months, in addition to the speech services ordered for 2001-2002 and whatever the IEP team determines for 2002-2003.
- Order to assess. Administer occupational therapy and auditory processing assessments. Provide the OT assessor's name and qualifications and a description of the assessment, including its nature, the time needed to complete it, and its scheduled date, time, and place.
Total: 65 hours of compensatory services
Key authorities
Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Target Range School District No. 23; Rowley; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Todd v. Andrews; Moubry v. Independent School District No. 696
People named in the decision
- Patricia Young, coordinator for special education services, Kern High School District
- Susan Elmore, school psychologist (initial assessment), Panama-Buena Vista School District
- John M. Lollar, PT, physical therapist consultant, Kern High School District
- Dianne Galloway, school psychologist, Kern High School District (Liberty High School)
- Donnalee Huffman, advocate formerly representing Student, Office of Clients' Rights Advocacy, Bakersfield
- Ms. Elieff, speech-language pathologist, Liberty High School, Kern High School District
- Mr. Stone, special education program specialist, Liberty High School, Kern High School District
- John Murphy, licensed marriage and family therapist, private therapist for Student, Private
- Phillip Levin, Ph.D., clinical psychologist, private neuropsychological evaluator and expert witness for Student, UCLA Neuropsychology Program
- Sara L. Boswell, Ph.D., private neuropsychological evaluator, UCLA Neuropsychology Program
- Ms. Jackson, home-school teacher, Kern High School District
- Ms. Juarez, home-school teacher, Kern High School District
- Ms. Jorgenson, home-school teacher, Kern High School District
- Becca Foltz, credentialed teacher, witness for Student, Valley Achievement Center
- Valley Achievement Center, certified nonpublic school for students with autism, Nonpublic school
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Paul E. Lacy, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, on November 8, 9, December 6, 7, 8, 2001, and January 8 and 9, 2002, in Bakersfield, California.
STUDENT (hereinafter “STUDENT” or “Petitioner”) was represented by attorney Joyce Coger. Also present on her behalf were her parents. The Kern High School District (hereinafter “District” or “Respondent”) was represented by attorney Nicole Misner. Patricia Young, the District’s coordinator for special education services, was also present on behalf of the District.
The Hearing Officer received oral and documentary evidence during the course of the proceedings. On February 7, 2002, the Hearing Officer received closing briefs from the parties and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
1. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE at the December 6, 2001 IEP meeting for the remainder of the 2001-2002 school year?
2. If the District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE, is the Valley Achievement Center (VAC) the appropriate placement to meet her unique needs?
3. What compensatory education is appropriate for STUDENT for the period of time that the District did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE?
4. What assessments is the District required to administer to STUDENT?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
At the commencement of the hearing, an issue was whether the District had provided STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year. Initially, STUDENT claimed that the District had denied her FAPE on both substantive and procedural grounds. Over the course of the first two days of hearing, STUDENT put on evidence relating to those issues. When the parties reconvened in December, they informed the Hearing Officer that an IEP team meeting had been held for STUDENT on December 6, 2001. The parties further informed the Hearing Officer that the District had offered STUDENT a program within the District for the balance of the 2001-2002 school year. They also informed the Hearing Officer that STUDENT disagreed with the District’s offer, and that she believed that Valley Achievement Center (VAC), a certified nonpublic school, was the appropriate placement to meet her needs. The parties then asked the Hearing Officer to incorporate prospective placement as an issue in the hearing. At that point, the parties agreed to add as issues whether the District’s offered placement for the balance of the 2001-2002 school year was a FAPE, and if not, whether VAC, the placement sought by STUDENT, was the appropriate placement to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
Additionally, during the course of the proceedings held in December, the District acknowledged that it had not provided STUDENT with speech and language services during the 2000-2001 school year. The District conceded that because STUDENT was deprived of speech and language services over the course of the school year, she did not receive FAPE. The District then entered into a stipulation that STUDENT did not receive a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year, and the parties agreed that the issue for that school year would be modified to what compensatory education would be appropriate for STUDENT for the period of time the District did not provide a FAPE. Moreover, as a result of the District’s stipulation, STUDENT acknowledged that she did not need to continue putting on evidence in support of her claims of procedural violations for the 2000-2001 school year since FAPE was no longer an issue and no additional remedies would arise.
POSITION OF THE PARTIES
STUDENT contends that the District’s offer of December 6, 2001, does not constitute a FAPE. She alleges that the goals and objectives drafted by the District are inappropriate in light of her unique needs and abilities and that the program offered by the District in December 2001 is not designed to meet her unique needs. STUDENT believes that she should be placed full time at VAC–with academic instruction in the morning and social skills and independent living classes in the afternoon. She asserts that the small teacher-student ratio, the more structured program, the specialized classes for autistic children, and the presence of peers with similar impairments and needs make VAC the appropriate placement for her. STUDENT maintains that the VAC program will assist her in overcoming her anxiety, help her develop appropriate social skills, and assist her with developing the skills necessary for independent living. Because VAC does not provide speech and language services, STUDENT requests that those services be provided by the District.
Additionally, STUDENT claims that the District should provide her with compensatory education for speech and language services, in addition to social and independent living skills training. STUDENT argues that for the period of time the District failed to provide her with a FAPE, her compensatory education services relating to social and daily living skills should be delivered at VAC.
The District counters that the program it offered STUDENT in December 2001 was designed to meet her needs and provide her with a FAPE. The District also asserts that even if the program it offered STUDENT in December 2001 does not constitute a FAPE, VAC is not an appropriate placement to meet her needs. The gist of the District’s argument is that STUDENT is not as severely disabled as the student population served by VAC, and that she would benefit more from receiving her academic instruction in the regular education program. The District also argues that even if VAC meets STUDENT’s unique needs, the District should still be allowed the opportunity to develop a program to serve her educational needs.
As to compensatory education for the 2000-2001 school year, the District stipulated that it did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE during that period of time, but argues that STUDENT only requires a make-up history course and speech and language services. In the event, however, that STUDENT requires compensatory education in social and independent living skills training, the District is prepared to provide it.
RELEVANT BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT, born on [date redacted], was 16 years 1 month old at the time the hearing closed. She presently lives with her parents, three sisters, and three brothers in Bakersfield, California. STUDENT is eligible for special education as a child with autism. She is currently in the tenth grade and receives home schooling from the Kern High School District in Bakersfield.
STUDENT attended kindergarten in the Greenfield Unified School District and thereafter attended the Panama-Buena Vista School District for grades one through eight.(Footnote 1) Throughout her grade school years in Panama-Buena Vista, STUDENT received passing and above average marks. Over the years, however, STUDENT’s grade school teachers increasingly commented on STUDENT’s difficulties in social situations, her anxiety problems, and eventual social withdrawal.
In the spring of 2000, while STUDENT was attending the eighth grade, STUDENT’s parents and the Panama-Buena Vista District agreed to assess STUDENT for special education. STUDENT’s mother signed a consent for assessment on May 24, 2000. The consent form indicated that Panama-Buena Vista would begin the assessment process and the results would be forwarded to the Kern High School District, where STUDENT was expected to attend the ninth grade. In June 1999, STUDENT had undergone surgery to have a pin placed in her hip and pelvic bone. STUDENT required a wheelchair and a walker for the next year and a half.
At Panama-Buena Vista, STUDENT was initially assessed by Susan Elmore, a school psychologist. In assessing STUDENT, Ms. Elmore reviewed school records, conducted interviews with her teachers, observed STUDENT in the classroom, and administered the Social Skills Rating System–Secondary Level to STUDENT’s teachers. Ms. Elmore reported that school records indicated that STUDENT’s grades in junior high school were average to above average and that she scored average to above average on the CTBS and SAT-9 tests. STUDENT’s eighth grade teachers consistently reported that STUDENT did well academically, but virtually all of them noted her difficulties with social relationships and verbal communication. Ms. Elmore described that when she observed STUDENT in an English class, STUDENT did not participate or speak out loud as her classmates did. The Social Skills Rating System–Secondary Level revealed that in the area of social skills, STUDENT exhibited fewer skills than the average student when compared to the national standardization sample mean in the school setting. The assessment also indicated that in the area of behavior problems, STUDENT exhibited more problem behaviors than the average student when compared to the national standardization sample mean in the school setting.
In June 2000, STUDENT completed grade school in the Panama-Buena Vista School District and was then considered a student in the Kern High School District. On June 14, 2000, STUDENT’s mother requested that the District administer STUDENT an occupational therapy assessment.(Footnote 2) On August 17, 2000, John M. Lollar, PT, a physical therapist consultant, administered STUDENT a physical therapy evaluation. In his report, Mr. Lollar noted STUDENT’s use of crutches and a wheelchair as a result of her hip surgery in 1999 and the fact that she suffered from fibromyalgia. Mr. Lolla’s report recommended that STUDENT be enrolled in an aquatics program, that she not participate in physical education without medical approval, and that a quiet room be established at school for STUDENT’s use when she was under stress. The report also inquired as to whether the school had any courses for STUDENT in the areas of social awareness and social interaction.
On September 19, 2000, the District convened the initial Individualized Education Program (IEP) team meeting and prepared an IEP for STUDENT. The IEP stated that STUDENT was eligible for special education under the category of other health impairment. The IEP specifically identified STUDENT as having asperger’s syndrome. The document, which was developed at the District’s Ridgeview High School, asserted that STUDENT would attend Liberty High School, also a District school, with the quantity of services to be determined by the school. The IEP form declared that “this is a 30 day placement.” A box on the IEP form was checked that said “intensive one-to-one and/or small group instruction is required based on assessed needs and learning style.” The IEP also called for STUDENT to be referred to a speech and language specialist for a screening for possible services. Additionally, transportation was to be provided STUDENT to and from school. Thereafter, STUDENT was placed in the regular education program, and she did not receive the one-to-one or small group instruction called for in her IEP.
On September 22, 2000, STUDENT’s mother signed an assessment plan prepared by the district. The plan was prepared on a standardized form. The form disclosed that STUDENT might be assessed in one of the nine areas specified on the preprinted form.(Footnote 3) Check marks on the form indicated that STUDENT was to be assessed by the school psychologist, a speech and language specialist, a school social worker, and an occupational therapist.
On October 17, 24, 25, 30, 31, and November 1, Ms. Dianne Galloway, a school psychologist for the District, conducted a psychological-educational assessment of STUDENT. In her report, Ms. Galloway noted that for her assessment she relied on school records, a parent evaluation, and her observations of STUDENT. According to the parent questionnaire, STUDENT experienced anxiety attacks and had difficulty completing her assignments. Ms. Galloway’s observations revealed that STUDENT never spoke or engaged in verbal conversation, was alert and aware of her surroundings, was withdrawn and kept her head down, and avoided eye contact, and appeared visibly agitated when school staff attempted to initiate interaction with her. Ms. Galloway’s report indicated that over a period of several weeks, STUDENT had begun to communicate with a speech and language therapist via computer, smiled at four or five staff members, and moved freely about the special education office staff. Ms. Galloway also remarked that in class STUDENT participated in reading and writing assignments, but she did not speak. Additionally, Ms. Galloway pointed out that “STUDENT [had] not been emotionally available to [the] examiner in order for an assessment to be properly conducted.” In her summary and recommendations, Ms. Galloway added that STUDENT tended to shy away from social situations and tended to use the special education office as a refuge, or means to avoid classes or schedule changes that disrupted her routine. She explained that numerous attempts had been made to involve STUDENT in a structured assessment process without success. On October 30, 2000, the District notified STUDENT’s parents of an IEP meeting scheduled for November 9, 2000.
On November 8, 2000, Donnalee Huffman of the Office of Clients’ Rights Advocacy in Bakersfield, a private organization representing STUDENT at the time, sent the District a letter informing them that STUDENT’s parents would not be at the IEP team meeting scheduled for November 9. The letter informed the District that assessments had not yet been completed and that going to an IEP meeting without assessments would be pointless. The letter further stated that STUDENT’s parents would wait to hear when the assessments were complete. Ms. Huffman’s letter also pointed out that the PARENTS’s would be out of town until November 27 as a result of the health of STUDENT’s father’s father, and she asked that STUDENT’s assessments be completed within 10 days of November 27.
On December 15, 2000, the District notified STUDENT’s parents that another IEP team meeting was scheduled for January 10, 2001. At the meeting, the IEP team noted that STUDENT had a good memory, was artistic, and followed the rules. The team also pointed out that STUDENT had needs in the areas of socialization, anxiety problems, difficulties distinguishing between heat and cold, and an inability to understand slang language. Regarding her “current levels of performance,” the IEP observed that STUDENT “appeared” to be independent in her self-care skills, that she had minimal social interaction at school, and that she experienced anxiety relating to social situations. The IEP did not include any goals and objectives, nor did it offer a placement and related services. The IEP noted that the parent’s attorney had requested a number of assessments (twelve) and that the District would respond to STUDENT’s parents request within five days.
On January 18, 2001, the District provided STUDENT’s parents with a written response to their request for twelve assessments. In its letter to STUDENT’s parents, the District agreed to provide STUDENT with a comprehensive neuropsychological assessment; a comprehensive assistive and adaptive technology assessment; a comprehensive vocational assessment; a comprehensive assessment of self-help, independent living, self-care and hygiene; a comprehensive auditory processing assessment; a comprehensive visual processing assessment; an occupational therapy assessment to include a comprehensive sensory integration assessment. On January 30, 2001, the District provided STUDENT’s parents with another assessment plan. On February 15, 2001, STUDENT’s parents notified the District that they believed the prior assessment plan was still in effect, and they did not believe it was appropriate to sign a new plan since that would “begin the formal assessment process anew.”
The day before, on February 14, 2001, STUDENT went to Ms. Elieff’s private office within the special education office. Apparently, STUDENT considered the area to be safe-spot for her when she was anxious. There was some confusion as to whether it was appropriate for STUDENT to be in the office at that time. District staff attempted to explain to STUDENT that she would have to move to a nearby conference room. STUDENT apparently misunderstood the school staff’s intentions, and she became anxious and upset. School officials called STUDENT’s mother, and she went to the school and took STUDENT home. After STUDENT left school she became even more upset and anxious.
The next day, on February 15, STUDENT’s parents sent STUDENT to John Murphy, a licensed marriage and family therapist. Mr. Murphy treated STUDENT for a panic attack and anxiety disorders. Thereafter, he continued to provide STUDENT with therapy services for her panic attacks, anxiety, and depression, and he continues to provide those services to the present. After the incident on February 14, STUDENT did not return to school. Furthermore, no additional assessments of STUDENT were performed by the District.
On March 14, 2001, another IEP team meeting was held for STUDENT. The IEP team identified STUDENT’s social skills and independent living needs to be as they had been in October 2000. Again, the team observed that STUDENT was selectively mute–she was known to have only uttered three words, including “oops,” all year. The team also observed that she was below average in social skills and above average in behavior problems–although no misbehavior was ever identified–and that she experienced anxiety in social situations. The IEP team did not provide any additional details relating to STUDENT’s then present levels of performance. As for speech and language levels, the speech and language pathologist observed that STUDENT had age-appropriate skills in written communication, but noted her lack of verbalization. As a result of STUDENT’s inability to complete assessments the previous fall, the pathologist could not provide additional information regarding STUDENT’s verbal abilities.
The IEP team set three social skills and independent living goals in addition to one speech and language goal. The annual social skills and independent living goals called for STUDENT to appropriately respond–verbally, with a wave, or in writing–when addressed with a “hi”; on at least one occasion request–verbally or in writing–make-up work in one of her classes; and make an independent purchase. No short-term objectives were included with the goals. The annual speech and language goal called for STUDENT to communicate two needs or pieces of information to a school staff member other than the speech and language pathologist and outside the special education office. The three short-term objectives for this goal were identical to the goal itself.
The IEP team established a home-schooling program to meet her needs and assist her in meeting her goals and objectives. Her home school program called for five hours per week of regular education instruction, one hour of resource services a week to address her socialization needs, and 30 minutes weekly of speech and language services. These services were to be provided to STUDENT by qualified school personnel in her home. STUDENT’s mother and her attorney signed the IEP and indicated on the form that they agreed with home schooling because it was ordered by STUDENT’s doctor, but that they did not agree with the goals and objectives, and they believed the services were inadequate.
Beginning in April 2001, three home-school teachers delivered STUDENT her assignments and, although five hours of services were called for in her IEP, provided her with one hour of instruction per week. Ms. Jackson provided the service between April and July 2001, Ms. Juarez between August and September 2001, and Ms. Jorgenson from the first week of September until the time of the hearing. There was no evidence presented that any of the three home-school instructors provided STUDENT with resource services or worked on her special education goals and objectives. Furthermore, STUDENT was not provided with speech and language services.
On April 3, 2001, STUDENT’s parents had STUDENT assessed by doctors Phillip Levin, Ph.D. and Sara L. Boswell, Ph.D. of the UCLA Neuropsychology Program. The doctors administered 26 assessment tests to STUDENT. The test results revealed that STUDENT’s intellectual abilities were in the average range and that she was functioning at her expected age and grade level with the exception of her writing abilities and reading comprehension.(Footnote 4) Attention assessments indicated that STUDENT functioned in the low average to average range in tasks involving complex and divided attention. STUDENT also demonstrated a weakness in receptive processing of information and an impairment in basic expressive language. Additionally, her use of language was concrete and literal. While she may have known facts, she could not apply them to everyday life. Moreover, while she could read, she could not accurately synthesize, integrate, and apply the information she read. In the area of social emotional functioning, Doctors Levin and Boswell found that STUDENT suffered from significant anxiety and moderate depression, was socially withdrawn, exhibited fears and associated physical symptoms, and feelings of hostility and anger. Doctors Levin and Boswell concluded that STUDENT had significant speech and language impairments as well as a significant emotional disturbance, and that she fell within the spectrum of autism and not merely asperger’s syndrome.
In their report, Doctors Levin and Boswell recommended that STUDENT be placed in a special education setting in which the teacher-student ratio does not exceed 6:1, individual attention is provided and the teacher is experienced and trained in working with students with significant speech and language impairments and emotional difficulties. The doctors also recommended a setting that involves an intensive community-based treatment program. Dr. Levin also testified at hearing that some of the assessment test results suggested that STUDENT had an auditory processing impairment. He recommended additional testing to determine whether she in fact had such an impairment.
On August 21, 2001, an IEP team meeting was held. At this meeting, the District offered STUDENT the option of continued home instruction five hours per week, plus 30 minutes of speech and language services; a full-day placement at the Severe Oral Language Handicapped Program at East Bakersfield High School, or a full-day placement at Alternative Instructional Methods Program (AIM Center) located on the Vista West Campus. The District offered to let STUDENT’s mother visit each of these sites. The options that the District offered were confirmed in a letter to STUDENT’s parents on August 27, 2001. STUDENT’s parents rejected the District’s offered placements and requested that the District place STUDENT at the VAC, a certified nonpublic school for autistic children.
The District refused the PARENTS’s request and, thereafter, on October 18, 2001, STUDENT’s parents’ requested a due process hearing.
The due process hearing began on November 8, 2001. On December 6, 2001, another IEP team meeting was held for STUDENT. At this meeting, the IEP team expressed concerns relating to speech and language, including STUDENT’s abilities in social communication, figurative language, and functional language. As for social skills, the team noted that STUDENT exhibited anxiety in new situations, in crowds, and around people who were new to her. The team also noted STUDENT’s mother’s observations that STUDENT needed to be cued to shower, change clothes and attend to personal hygiene. The IEP team also documented STUDENT’s mother’s concern regarding STUDENT’s inability to distinguish heat from cold. At this IEP meeting, the District proposed to revise STUDENT’s goals and objectives to address the needs that the District had identified for STUDENT. To address her personal and social needs, the District circled seven items from a list of seven items pre-printed on an IEP form. The list of seven generalized statements included: (1) achieving self awareness, (2) achieving self confidence, (3) achieving socially responsible behavior, (4) maintaining good interpersonal skills, (5) achieving independence, (6) making adequate decisions, (7) and communicating with others. As for measurable objectives, the District circled two of the seven items on the list for each three-month period–although the seventh item on the list was not markeded. Regarding STUDENT’s needs in the areas of independent living skills and mobility, the District proposed two annual goals: that STUDENT be able to walk to classes on campus and that she be able to independently make a purchase at a campus store or in the community. To address STUDENT’s speech and language needs, the District members of the team set two annual goals: that STUDENT be able to demonstrate that she understands the literal and abstract meaning of ten common idiomatic expressions and that she be able to communicate two needs or pieces of information to a school staff member, other than the speech and language pathologist, in the school setting.
To assist STUDENT in achieving her goals and objectives, the District proposed to place her in the general education curriculum for three periods each day to receive general academic instruction and three periods each day in the resource program (RSP) to support her general education classes and address her socialization and communication needs. The IEP called for STUDENT to receive the assistance of a one-to-one aide for all classes, transportation services, two 30-minute sessions of speech and language therapy each week, and two 30-minute counseling sessions each month with the school social worker. STUDENT’s parents did not accept the District’s offered program. STUDENT’s parents contended that STUDENT’s unique needs required that she be placed at Valley Achievement Center. At hearing, the parties requested that the Hearing Officer determine whether the District’s offer in December 2001 was a FAPE, and the issue was added to the due process hearing already in progress. The parties also asked the Hearing Officer to determine whether VAC, the remedy sought by STUDENT, was the appropriate placement for the balance of the 2001-2002 school year, including the extended school year.
As noted above, during the course of the due process hearing, the District conceded that because it had not provided STUDENT with speech and language services since September 2000, the District had denied STUDENT a FAPE between September 2000 and the time of its December 6, 2001 offer. The parties asked the Hearing Officer to determine the appropriate compensatory education, if any, for STUDENT.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue Number 1: Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE at the December 6, 2001 IEP meeting for the remainder of the 2001-2002 school year?
Applicable Law
Special education students are entitled to a free and appropriate education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq., Cal. Ed. Code § 56000 et seq.) A "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that are provided in conformity with the individualized education program. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).) Special education means specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parent, to meet the unique needs of individuals with exceptional needs, whose educational needs cannot be met with modification of the regular instruction program, and related services, at no cost to the parent, that may be needed to assist these individuals to benefit from specially designed instruction. (Cal. Ed. Code § 56031.)
Additionally, special education law requires that an individualized education program (IEP) be designed for each eligible child. According to Cal. Ed. Code § 56345, the IEP is a written statement determined in a meeting of the individualized education program team that includes, but is not limited to, the following:
(1) The present levels of the pupil's educational performance, including the following: (A) For a schoolage child, how the pupil's disability affects the pupil's involvement and progress in the general curriculum. (B) For a preschoolage child, as appropriate, how the disability affects the child's participation in appropriate activities. (2) The measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives related to the following: (A) Meeting the pupil's needs that result from the pupil's disability to enable the pupil to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. (B) Meeting each of the pupil's other educational needs that result from the pupil's disability. (3) The specific special educational instruction and related services and supplementary aids and services to be provided to the pupil, or on behalf of the pupil, and a statement of the program modifications or supports for school personnel that will be provided for the pupil in order to do the following: (A) To advance appropriately toward attaining the annual goals. (B) To be involved and progress in the general curriculum in accordance with subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. (C) To be educated and participate with other pupils with disabilities and nondisabled pupils in the activities described in this section. (Cal. Ed. Code § 56345(a)(1),(2),and (3).)
California special education regulations also require that the individualized education program show a direct relationship between the present levels of performance, the goals and objectives, and the specific educational services to be provided. (C.C.R. § 3040(b).)
Moreover, special education law requires a district to make a formal written offer of placement with sufficient specificity for parents to evaluate the offered program. In the case of Union School Dist. v. Smith, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals instructs us that:
The IDEA explicitly requires written prior notice to parents when an educational agency proposes, or refuses, to initiate or change the educational placement of a disabled child. See 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(1)(C). The Supreme Court has explained the great importance of such procedural components of the IDEA. "When the elaborate and highly specific procedural safeguards embodied in § 1415 [of the IDEA] are contrasted with the general and somewhat imprecise substantive admonitions contained in the Act, we think that the importance Congress attached to these procedural safeguards cannot be gainsaid." Rowley, 458 U.S. at 205, 102 S.Ct. at 3050.
We find that this formal requirement has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe it should be enforced rigorously. The requirement of a formal, written offer creates a clear record that will do much to eliminate troublesome factual disputes many years later about when placements were offered, what placements were offered, and what additional educational assistance was offered to supplement a placement, if any. Furthermore, a formal, specific offer from a school district will greatly assist parents in "present[ing] complaints with respect to any matter relating to the ... educational placement of the child." 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(1)(E). (Union School Dist. v. Smith (9th Cir. 1994) 15 F.3d 1519, 1526.)
The Ninth Circuit has also held that the courts will not address the question of whether a district’s proposed partial IEP was reasonably calculated to enable a student to receive educational benefits, if it failed to develop an IEP according to the procedures required by federal law. (W.G. v. Target Range School District No. 23 (1992 9th Cir.) 960 F.2d 1479, 1485.)
Evidentiary Analysis
To determine the adequacy of the special education program offered to STUDENT by the District, the Hearing Officer must first determine STUDENT’s needs and then review the proposed goals and objectives in the context of those needs. Finally, the Hearing Officer must evaluate the District’s offered placement and services to determine whether they were designed to assist STUDENT in progressing toward appropriately established goals and objectives.
STUDENT’s Unique Needs
The parties did not substantially dispute STUDENT’s unique needs. Witnesses called by STUDENT, as well as those called by the District, by and large testified consistently with each other when they described STUDENT’s impairments and strengths. Mr. FATHER and STUDENT’s mother; Mr. Stone, the special education program specialist at Liberty High School; Ms. Eliefff, the speech and language therapist at Liberty; Ms. Galloway, school psychologist at Liberty; Doctor Levin, a clinical psychologist privately retained by STUDENT’s parents; and Mr. Murphy, a licensed family therapist also privately retained by STUDENT’s parents, all provided valuable information regarding STUDENT’s impairments and needs.
STUDENT’s father testified that while STUDENT talked somewhat when she was younger and in early grade school, she has rarely spoken in the last several years. He explained how STUDENT has regressed over the years, and stated that her communication is mostly limited to shrugs or audible grunts. STUDENT’s father related that STUDENT has few friends and has only limited interaction with her own siblings. He also described how STUDENT physically “balls up” and hides when she is upset.
STUDENT’s mother also discussed STUDENT’s selective mutism, anxiety, social withdrawal, and her abnormally extreme shyness. STUDENT’s mother explained how STUDENT was unable to answer a telephone (she will merely sit by and listen to it ring and cannot call 9-1-1), will not answer the door, and will not ask for directions or help if she needs it. STUDENT’s mother told how STUDENT rarely goes out into the community except to church and occasional shopping with her parents. STUDENT herself has been unable to make a single purchase–even if the store clerk is informed of STUDENT’s impairment and he or she is enlisted to help her carry out the transaction. STUDENT’s mother also detailed how STUDENT is unable to attend to her personal hygiene. She will not brush her teeth or hair or shower without direct prompting. Additionally, STUDENT seems unable to address personal feminine hygiene matters. STUDENT also tends to become locked into fixed and compulsive routines. She gets up at the same time each day, puts on the same clothes, unless reminded to wear clean ones, eats the same food, sits quietly on the sofa until it is time for the bus to pick her up, and then moves to the door, where she stands until the bus actually arrives. Furthermore, STUDENT does not seem to be able to distinguish hot from cold. She drinks scalding hot chocolate without flinching, does not wear a coat when it is very cold outside, and sleeps on top of her covers. She also has an unusually high pain threshold. Additionally, STUDENT’s room remains perfectly clean, not because she cleans it, but because she does not disturb it.
STUDENT’s mother also offered details regarding STUDENT’s social withdrawal. STUDENT avoids crowds and rarely goes out in public. When visitors come to the house, STUDENT will not interact with them; instead, she will sit still and play with a toy such as a game-boy. On one occasion when STUDENT’s parents took STUDENT to the mall, STUDENT suddenly made a squeaking noise and then ran away to hide beneath a rack of clothes. STUDENT cannot be left alone at the house because she cannot look after herself, and she would not call the fire department in the event of a fire, or the police if an intruder entered. STUDENT’s mother told of an instance when she became very ill and needed STUDENT to call for help. STUDENT did not respond.
STUDENT’s mother also provided specific information relating to STUDENT’s experiences at Liberty High School as well as her behavior at home since she left the school setting on February 14, 2001. While STUDENT attended Liberty, she frequently came home from school and placed a pillow over her head and just lay on her bed making grunting sounds. She also became very upset and cried if her scheduled changed or some other unexpected–albeit trivial–event occurred at school. Additionally, STUDENT was bothered by the noise level in her art class, even though it was not out of the ordinary. At home, STUDENT follows her mother everywhere and often sits in her mother’s bedroom drawing or watching a video. STUDENT’s mother described how STUDENT rarely, if ever, speaks, walks with her head down, makes grunting or squeaking noises, and never makes eye contact, not even with other family members. STUDENT also has a phobic fear about getting lost, and she tries to memorize every turn she makes and every building she passes, even on long trips.
STUDENT’s mother also described STUDENT’s difficulty with literal language. She explained that STUDENT cannot distinguish literal language from slang or figures of speech. For example, if STUDENT were asked to walk across the floor to get a piece of chalk, STUDENT would walk a cross pattern on the floor.
In STUDENT’s mother’s opinion, STUDENT needs to be placed in a small, structured environment with other autistic children and with teachers and school staff members who have training and experience with children with needs similar to STUDENT’s. She believes the placement must make STUDENT feel safe so that she can gain confidence and learn to interact with other people. STUDENT’s mother thinks that STUDENT needs to receive her academic lessons in a small group where she will feel safe and be able to communicate directly with her instructor. She also is of the opinion that STUDENT needs intensive training to develop social and independent living skills in an environment where she is comfortable, with students who have similar disabilities, and from instructors who are experienced and skilled at teaching autistic children.
Mr. Stone, the special education program specialist at Liberty High School who was in charge of implementing STUDENT’s program, identified STUDENT as having needs in six areas: (1) academics, (2) social skills, (3) language and communication, (4) daily living skills, (5) sensory and occupational therapy needs, and (6) anxiety. Mr. Stone was of the opinion that STUDENT’s anxiety problems affected all aspects of her educational program. He suggested that STUDENT be placed in quieter classes with fewer students, and in classes where the students had fewer behavior problems–perhaps college prep courses. Mr. Stone also thought that classes with auditory stimuli and more visual or demonstrative modes of instruction would be beneficial for STUDENT. To address STUDENT’s social and independent living skills needs, Mr. Stone suggested classes in which STUDENT would have an opportunity to learn those skills in a classroom and then apply them to life situations at home and school and in the community. He proposed a small, structured class made up of students with developmental disabilities, since he did not believe the District had a population of students with similar autistic impairments and of ages similar to STUDENT’s. Mr. Stone stated that he did not have the expertise to articulate each of STUDENT’s speech and language, academic, and occupational therapy needs, but he did believe that these needs should be addressed in an integrated fashion with STUDENT’s anxiety and social and independent living skills needs.
Ms. Elieff, the speech and language pathologist at Liberty High School, reiterated the problem of STUDENT’s selective mutisim and the effects of STUDENT’s extreme social withdrawal on her ability to communicate. Ms. Elieff did describe some progress in verbal communication on STUDENT’s part. Ms. Elieff explained that STUDENT enjoyed using the computer and the internet, and that STUDENT frequently utilized Ms. Elieff’s office for this purpose. Ms. Eliefff recounted that on one occasion she was able to get STUDENT to verbalize the word “please” in return for being allowed to access the internet on her office computer. On another occasion, she coaxed STUDENT into privately asking another student if she could “please use the internet.” The other student reported to Ms. Elieff that STUDENT indeed verbalized those words. Ms. Elieff also described how STUDENT opened up and became more comfortable in the special education office. Additionally, STUDENT communicated with her in writing and on the computer keyboard. She believed that in the fall of 2000 and the winter of 2001, STUDENT had shown progress in her communication skills, including the promise for oral communication.
Ms. Galloway, the school psychologist at Liberty, explained the difficulty she had in even trying to assess STUDENT in the areas called for in the assessment plan. STUDENT did not communicate orally, and she refused to cooperate in the assessments. She said that STUDENT seemed frightened and uncomfortable with the process. Ms. Galloway did not attempt to force the issue, but instead, observed STUDENT at school informally. She observed STUDENT to have social, communication, and anxiety needs similar to those articulated by Mr. Stone and Ms. Elieff. Doctor Levin, a privately retained psychologist who evaluated STUDENT in April of 2001, opined that STUDENT demonstrated a weakness in receptive processing of information and an impairment in basic expressive language. Additionally, he believed that STUDENT’s use of language was concrete and literal. While STUDENT may be able to recite facts, he explained, she cannot apply them to everyday life. Moreover, he testified that while STUDENT can read, she cannot accurately synthesize, integrate, and apply the information she read. In the area of social emotional functioning, Doctors Levin stated that STUDENT suffered from significant anxiety, was moderately depressed, was socially withdrawn, and was fearful. Dr. Levin was of the opinion that STUDENT’s needs required that she be placed in a small, structured class with a maximum of 12 students and with a student-teacher ratio that did not exceed 6:1. Dr. Levin asserted that STUDENT’s anxiety in larger classes and on a larger campus would interfere with her ability to progress in her communication, social, and daily living skills. He also opined that STUDENT would develop appropriate communication, social, and daily living skills more quickly in a setting that included like-peers. Moreover, Dr. Levin was of the opinion that STUDENT was exposed to serious safety concerns on a larger campus as a result of her inability to communicate her needs even in an emergency situation.
Mr. Murphy, STUDENT’s personal therapist, testified that he had been treating STUDENT’s anxiety and panic disorders on a regular basis since he first met her in February 2001, after the incident with STUDENT in Ms. Eliefff’s office. Mr. Murphy described his success in getting STUDENT to talk on a somewhat regular basis. He explained that he patiently worked with STUDENT until she became comfortable around him. He discussed how he made it a point to give STUDENT her personal space and let her know that she could leave at any time. He then utilized different reward systems and positive reinforcement techniques to encourage STUDENT to communicate orally. Mr. Murphy took advantage of STUDENT’s talents and interest in art as well as her interest in computers and Pokeman characters to motivate her to speak. Mr. Murphy believed that STUDENT’s needs require her to be placed in a small, structured environment with teachers and staff familiar with autism and anxiety disorders.
It is apparent from the testimony and the documentary evidence that STUDENT has substantial deficits in the areas of communication, social and daily living skills, and anxiety. The evidence indicates that she needs to develop both verbal and non-oral communication skills, social skills, and daily living skills.
As for her communication skills, STUDENT is presently selectively mute. She does not speak except on an occasional basis to her therapist and parents, and on one or two occasions, a word or two in the school setting. However, both Ms. Eliefff and Mr. Murphy presented evidence that STUDENT’s limited verbal communication over the past year and a half demonstrates progress. There is no question that STUDENT has the ability to speak, and under the right circumstances or conditions, will speak. Ms. Eliefff testified that while STUDENT could learn something without being able to speak, oral communication would significantly affect STUDENT’s ability to learn in the classroom. Moreover, there can be no question that verbal communication would play a significant role in addressing STUDENT’s social and daily living skills. Speech would allow STUDENT to socialize and interact with peers and teachers, ask questions in class, ask for directions, call for help, engage in commercial transactions, and ultimately become employable. Additionally, oral communication would allow STUDENT to ask spontaneous questions and clarify concerns as they arise, which would assist her in reducing her anxiety. Thus, STUDENT requires specific goals and objectives that call for her to develop and use speech.
Additionally, STUDENT rarely substitutes non-oral modes of communication for speech, nor does she use it in situations where non-oral communication is appropriate–such as body language. According to all of the witnesses, STUDENT will virtually ignore people who speak to her, look away or at the ground when addressed, and grunt or squeak instead of using appropriate body motions–particularly nods of the head, shoulder shrugs, and hand gestures. STUDENT also uses very little written communication in situations where it could be useful–such as notes to a teacher or school counselor. Thus, STUDENT’s needs require goals and objectives be set for her to develop various forms of non-oral communication.
Moreover, STUDENT’s communication impairments include receptive language. She does not distinguish literal language from figures of speech or slang, and she does not draw appropriate inferences from statements made to her by others. Additionally, STUDENT has difficulty applying and synthesizing information presented to her. Thus, STUDENT needs goals and objectives to assist her in distinguishing literal messages from figures of speech, drawing inferences from information presented to her, and synthesizing and applying language in everyday life.
Witnesses for both parties agreed that while STUDENT’s communication needs affected her social-skills needs, she also had social skills needs independent of her communications needs. STUDENT has virtually no friends and rarely engages in social activities. Thus, her needs require her to not only communicate with other people, but also to develop actual relationships with them. Additionally, STUDENT needs to learn to engage in social activities with others. To this end, STUDENT requires specific goals and objectives to help her develop relationships with other people.
STUDENT’s mother and Mr. Stone provided significant information regarding STUDENT’s needs to develop daily living skills. STUDENT has difficulty traveling on campus and in the community, she is unable to make purchases, she is unable to utilize telephones, and she does not take the initiative to attend to many personal hygiene matters. Therefore, STUDENT requires specific goals and objectives to address each of these areas.
Finally, there is no dispute that STUDENT continually suffers from extreme anxiety and occasional panic attacks. The evidence presented at the hearing clearly demonstrated that STUDENT’s anxiety permeates virtually every difficulty she experiences. Each witness that observed or evaluated STUDENT recognized that her anxiety affected her ability to communicate, orally and non-orally, interfered with her ability to develop social relationships and engage in social activities, and impeded her ability to develop daily living skills. Therefore, STUDENT’s goals and objectives need to take into account her anxiety and her need to reduce that anxiety.
STUDENT’s Present Levels of Performance
Virtually all of the witnesses in the case, many of whom were part of STUDENT’s IEP team, articulated in great detail STUDENT’s needs. But the December 6, 2001 IEP did not specify STUDENT’s needs, which make up part of her present levels of performance, with the same particularity that the team members voiced at the hearing.
As noted above, California law requires that the IEP team specify how STUDENT’s disability affects her involvement and progress in the general curriculum. Thus, while the IEP team does not need to include every relevant comment made by team members relating to STUDENT’s present levels of performance, the team must articulate STUDENT’s present performance levels with sufficient particularity so that readers–parents and educators–can understand how STUDENT’s present levels of performance affect her ability to progress in the school curriculum. Moreover, because the IEP must show a direct relationship between the present levels of performance and the goals and objectives, the statement of the present levels of performance must be set forth with sufficient specificity to serve as a foundation for her goals and objectives.
In this case, the portion of STUDENT’s December 2001 IEP relating to her present levels of performance did not include all of the pertinent information relating to STUDENT’s impairments. Moreover, the information relating to STUDENT’s present levels of performance that was in her IEP was not sufficiently detailed to explain how STUDENT’s impairments affected her ability to be educated. In the area of communication, the December 2001 IEP notes that “some whiny vocalizations” and “social communication” were areas of concern. The IEP does not mention that she is selectively mute, i.e., that she virtually does not speak at all. Additionally, the IEP does not specify with any particularity STUDENT’s difficulty with expressing herself, whether orally, in writing, or by gesture.
In the area of social and emotional health, the December 2001 IEP document only states that STUDENT’s social-anxiety affects her speech and that “figurative and functional language appear to be an area of concern.” The IEP also states that STUDENT becomes anxious in new situations, around people new to her, or in crowds. In stark contrast to the detailed testimony from the witnesses discussed above, the IEP document does not explain STUDENT’s present levels of performance–including her unique needs–as they relate to her communication deficiencies, her social-skills deficiencies, or her anxiety problems. Moreover, while the document notes STUDENT’s problems with figurative speech and functional language, it does not specify the nature of her problem or how it is manifested.
As for STUDENT’s independent living skills, the IEP indicates that STUDENT’s mother needs to prompt STUDENT to take care of personal hygiene matters and complete her daily chores. But the document does not address STUDENT’s inability to function in the community, and to a great extent, on campus. The IEP does not address STUDENT’s problems in talking to her teachers regarding assignments, her inability to independently travel about the campus and in the community, and the fact that she cannot seek help if she is lost or in danger.
The Hearing Officer finds that in light of the information that was available regarding STUDENT’s specific needs, the December 2001 IEP did not sufficiently explain how STUDENT’s disability affects her ability to be involved and progress in the general curriculum. Moreover, STUDENT’s IEP did not articulate her present levels of performance with sufficient particularity to assist the team in designing appropriate goals and objectives for STUDENT.
STUDENT’s goals and objectives
Special education law requires the IEP team to set forth measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short term objectives relating to STUDENT’s needs that result from her disability. All of the witnesses in the hearing agreed that STUDENT had a wide variety of needs relating to language and communication, social skills, independent living, and anxiety. Members of the IEP team as well as the independent evaluators–Dr. Levin and Mr. Murphy–testified that STUDENT needed to utilize oral language, exercise nonverbal communication when it was appropriate or when she simply was unable to verbalize, distinguish between literal and figurative speech, apply functional language, interact with other people, develop personal relationships, engage in social activities, take the initiative to address her personal hygiene needs, make purchases, move about the campus and travel in the community, ask for help in emergencies, and reduce or minimize her anxiety while she is participating in any of these activities, when she is in a new situation, or when she is in public places. Therefore, the IEP team was required to specify goals and objectives that corresponded to each of STUDENT’s needs. Moreover, the goals and objectives must be set forth with sufficient specificity to allow an educator to determine whether there is a direct relationship between the goals and objectives and STUDENT’s needs.
As discussed above, the IEP team selected seven goals from a preprinted list to address STUDENT’s personal and social needs, drafted two goals to address her daily living skills needs, and designed two speech and language goals.
The goals and objectives proposed to address STUDENT’s personal and social skills were part of a preprinted list of goals broad enough to apply to virtually all students–inside or outside of special education. The preprinted goals were neither individualized nor stated with sufficient particularity to be meaningful for STUDENT or her educators. As emphasized above, members of the IEP team and Dr. Levin each spelled out STUDENT’s needs relative to social skills. But the IEP only referenced general concepts that most people need for healthy living: (1) achieving self-awareness, (2) achieving self-confidence, (3) achieving socially responsible behavior, (4) maintaining good interpersonal skills, (5) achieving independence, (6) making adequate decisions, (7) and communicating with others. There simply is no direct relationship between these general goals for healthy living and STUDENT’s particular and individual needs. Moreover, there are no short-term objectives for any of these seven goals. The IEP team merely indicated that two of the seven goals were to be met every three months. Additionally, the nature of these particular goals do not lend themselves to establishing measurable objectives. For example, how does an educator measure when a person has “achieved self awareness?” Moreover, by their nature, at least some of the goals are not annual goals, as required by special education law, but are more appropriately “lifetime” goals.
Regarding STUDENT’s independent living skills, the IEP team proposed that over the course of a year STUDENT be able to walk to class by herself and make an independent purchase by herself, either on campus or in the community. The annual goal that STUDENT walk to class by herself is appropriate in light of STUDENT’s particular disability and needs. However, the evidence indicates that STUDENT–at 16 years old–needs to make more than an independent purchase in the course of a year. One purchase may be appropriate for an initial benchmark, but to design an annual educational program to assist STUDENT in making a single purchase is virtually no program at all. Thus, while the two goals proposed by the District to address STUDENT’s needs for independent living are not inconsistent with STUDENT’s individual needs, they fall far short of addressing her independent living requirements. STUDENT requires additional goals and objectives that directly correlate more fully to her specific needs, as identified by the IEP team.
The first of two speech and language goals for STUDENT is appropriate, although it would benefit from some increase in specificity. The goal takes into account STUDENT’s specific need to distinguish literal and abstract language. The goal also includes appropriate benchmarks and criteria for measuring progress toward completion of the goal. The second goal, however, requires that STUDENT be able to communicate–in any mode–two needs or pieces of information in a classroom over the course of the year. Ms. Eliefff testified that STUDENT had already communicated twice verbally–once to her and once to a fellow student–and several times to her in writing-both on paper and by computer. Ms. Galloway recounted how STUDENT communicated to her that she –STUDENT–did not want to take an assessment test. The evidence also indicates that STUDENT has communicated with Dr. Levin on several occasions and that she communicates with Mr. Murphy on a regular basis. Moreover, STUDENT communicates orally with Mr. Murphy. Thus, while the second speech and language goal set forth in STUDENT’s IEP calls for her to communicate on two occasions in the classroom, this goal is far too simple in light of STUDENT’s known communications outside the classroom setting. Moreover, STUDENT’s IEP does not specify any goals for oral speech even though her lack of oral communication undoubtably hinders her social and daily living skills. Although STUDENT’s progress in using verbal modes of communication may be slow and require her to work on nonverbal communication goals as well, her progress in verbal communication–and the advantages it offers, makes it an appropriate goal for STUDENT to develop.
Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives proposed in the December 2001 IEP are not adequate to address STUDENT’s unique needs.
Placement and Services
As set forth above, special education law requires that STUDENT’s educational program be designed to met her unique needs and that the educational services offered to her by the District have a direct relationship to her present levels of performance and her goals and objectives.
The District offered to place STUDENT in the regular education program for three periods a day to receive the general education curriculum. The District’s offer also called for STUDENT to receive three periods a day of resource (RSP) services to support her general education classes and address her socialization and communication needs. The District did not offer any particular RSP class or classes at any particular school, but, as will be discussed below, the District offered STUDENT several options to choose from. In the way of related services, the District also offered STUDENT “1:1 support” for all classes, direct speech and language services twice a week for 30 minutes each session, one 30-minute collaborative speech and language session each week with school staff, two 30-minute counseling sessions each month with a social worker to support her social-skills curriculum, and door-to-door transportation services.
Dr. Levin testified on behalf of STUDENT that she needed a small, structured class in which to learn. Dr. Levin explained that STUDENT suffered from extreme anxiety that led to social withdrawal, which led to more anxiety. He commented that the more anxious STUDENT becomes the more she withdraws, which increases her anxiety. Dr. Levin also noted the connection between STUDENT’s anxiety and panic attacks, her lack of social and daily living skills. In his opinion, STUDENT needs to first get her anxiety, social, and daily living skills under control before she is placed in the regular education program.
At hearing, Ms. Galloway discussed several options that were made available to STUDENT at the December 2001 IEP. She described a program at Aurora, a nontraditional school within the Kern High School District. This school had a special day class available to STUDENT. The class included 20 children with a 3:1 student-to-teacher ratio. The other children had been diagnosed with specific learning disabilities, emotional disturbances, and high end asperger’s syndrome. Some of the children had a history of acting out and some had strong behavior plans in place. Ms. Galloway also testified regarding another special day class in the District known as Constellations. This program included children with specific learning disabilities and emotional disturbances. She also explained that both Liberty and Ridgeview High Schools had resource programs available. Ms. Galloway testified that the three periods of resource specified in the December 2001 IEP did not necessarily mean a resource class. The content of the program had not been determined and any one of the suggestions discussed could have been implemented. Additionally, Mr. Stone described a variety of possible programs that he thought could be designed to meet STUDENT’s needs.
As discussed above, Union requires that the District make a formal written offer of placement with sufficient specificity for STUDENT’s parents to evaluate the offered program. In this case, the District did not offer any particular program to address STUDENT’s needs. Even at hearing, the District continued to discuss a number of options that could be made available to STUDENT. Mr. Stone believed that STUDENT’s academic courses should include classes with fewer students as well as students with fewer behavior problems, but no particular classes were proposed. Ms. Galloway discussed several resource and special day class programs that could be made available to STUDENT. She also admitted that the content of the program had not been determined and that no one program was offered. The Court in Union explained that a district must set forth in writing the particular program it is offering so that a parent can evaluate the offer and make an informed decision regarding its appropriateness. (Union, supra, 15 F.3d at p. 1526.) In contrast, the District in the present matter discussed several options that STUDENT’s parents could investigate and consider, but the District did not offer STUDENT’s parents a specific placement as required by Union.
Moreover, in Union, both the hearing officer and the courts were unable to determine the appropriateness of the programs offered by the district because the district failed to set forth sufficient evidence concerning those programs. Here, the District has made the same error. While Ms. Galloway suggested several possible programs, only limited information was available regarding each of them. For example, Ms. Galloway testified that some of the students in the classes that were proposed as options for STUDENT were emotionally disturbed, and some of those students had behavior plans as well. However, Ms. Galloway was not certain as to how the individual students in those classes manifested their emotional disturbance or the content and nature of their respective behavior plans. Such information is critical in determining the appropriateness of those programs for STUDENT in light of her anxiety and social and daily living skills needs. The evidence suggests that STUDENT is easily frightened by other people’s behavior, even though other people don’t intend to harm or frighten her. Additionally, Ms. Galloway did not have specific information regarding the training and experience of the teachers in the programs discussed as options for STUDENT. Thus, it is impossible to evaluate whether the teachers in the special day classes and RSP programs considered by the District have the expertise to address STUDENT’s particular needs. Therefore, notwithstanding the District’s failure to offer in writing a specific program to address STUDENT’s needs, the Hearing Officer finds that there is also insufficient evidence to determine whether the programs discussed by the District as options for STUDENT were appropriate to meet her needs.
Moreover, because the District proposed only a partial IEP, i.e., it did not specify all of the special education services to be provided STUDENT, she was prejudiced. As in the case of W.G., STUDENT’s parents were not fully informed as to which programs the District intended to offer STUDENT. In short, STUDENT’s parents were prejudiced by the District’s failure to offer a single program with a sufficient amount of information from which to make a decision. The lack of an offer that set forth a single program with sufficient information to allow STUDENT’s parents to evaluate it effectively excluded STUDENT’s parents from the IEP decision making process. Thus, it is unnecessary for the Hearing Officer to determine whether the IEP was reasonably calculated to enable STUDENT to receive educational benefit because STUDENT’s parents were prejudiced by the District’s procedural violation–its failure to make a Union offer. (See W.G. v. Target Range School District No. 23, supra, 960 F.2d at p.1485.)
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of December 6, 2001, did not constitute a FAPE.
Issue Number 2: If the District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE, is the Valley Achievement Center (VAC) the appropriate placement to meet her unique needs?
Applicable Law
As discussed above, special education means specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parent, to meet the unique needs of individuals with exceptional needs, whose educational needs cannot be met with modification of the regular instruction program, and related services, at no cost to the parent, that may be needed to assist these individuals to benefit from specially designed instruction. (Cal. Ed. Code § 56031.)
Evidentiary Analysis
STUDENT contends that the Valley Achievement Center (VAC) is the appropriate placement to meet her unique needs. Ms. Becca Foltz, a credentialed teacher employed by VAC, provided information about that school’s program, a certified nonpublic, nonprofit school that serves disabled students whose primary diagnosis is autism. The school specializes in educating and providing social and daily living skills training to autistic students. While some of the children who attend VAC act “silly at times,” and others engage in ritualistic behavior common to autism, the students placed at VAC do not have any behavior problems.
The school operates 40 hours a week and has both a morning session and an afternoon session. The morning session provides for predominantly academic instruction, while the afternoon session focuses more on social skills and daily living skills training. The school employs three fully credentialed teachers, two teachers with emergency teaching credentials, and approximately 40 full– and part-time aides. The school’s campus is relatively small and contains a single building. The school has 11 classrooms, a small library, an occupational sensory room, and facilities in which to practice daily living skills.
The school serves six children in the morning session and 42 children in the afternoon program. (Most of the children in the afternoon program attend a public school in the morning.) Of the six children in the morning program, two are teenagers. The ages of these children vary as well as their functional grade levels. The six children in the morning session receive academic instruction from Ms. Foltz and from one or more of ten teacher’s aides. Ms. Foltz, who has a Bachelor’s degree in early childhood education and a Master’s degree in special education, is a credentialed teacher who has been teaching children who have primary disability is autism for more than four years. Ms. Foltz also has experience in attending IEP meetings and assisting in the development and implementation of IEP’s for autistic children. The teacher’s aides, some of whom have bachelor’s degrees and others who have some college units, provide most of the direct instruction to the morning students. The school’s aides and staff receive training in autism and discreet trial training, and each aide has completed at least ten units of special education course work in college. Ms. Foltz provides direct instruction to the children as well as supervises the aides in each class for at least one hour a day. Most of the morning students receive one-to-one academic instruction from the teachers and aides. The curriculum, which includes accredited courses in history, English, and algebra, is modified to meet the functional abilities of the students. The curriculum at VAC also utilizes the picture exchange mode of communication to assist students who are language-impaired and benefit from visual cues.
The afternoon program is specially designed for autistic students who need to develop social and daily living skills. The students in the afternoon program are higher-functioning autistic children than those in the morning program. Forty teacher’s aides assist the full-time teaching staff in the afternoon program, and the teacher-student ratios in these classes ranges from one-to-two to three-to-ten. The afternoon program includes classes in which the students learn social and daily living skills, and the facility is equipped with mock kitchens, bathrooms, and stores. In these facilities, students practice a variety of social and daily living skills in a safe structured environment. Thereafter, the classes take regular field trips with their instructors to practice their skills in the community.
The objective of VAC is to assist the students in developing sufficient social and living skills to allow them to transfer back into the public schools and be educated in the least restricted environment. As discussed above, Dr. Levin testified that STUDENT needed to be placed in more structured classes with fewer students until her anxiety is reduced and she develops minimal social and daily living skills. Dr. Levin explained that STUDENT’s participation in the larger classes on the larger campuses contributed to her anxiety. In turn, her increased anxiety exacerbated her problems with communication and social and daily living skills, which further increased her anxiety. Dr. Levin recommended a smaller, more structured class environment until the cycle could be broken and reversed. Mr. Murphy and Mr. Stone also concurred that as a result of her anxiety problems and social and daily living skills impairments, STUDENT required a more structured class setting with fewer students.
The VAC program, both the morning and afternoon sessions, meets STUDENT’s unique needs for the balance of the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year. STUDENT suffers from extreme anxiety and panic attacks, as well as mild depression, which aggravates her ability to functionally communicate and develop appropriate social skills and daily, or functional, living skills. STUDENT’s autism is significant. As discussed in detail above, STUDENT is a teenage girl who literally cannot care for herself, has few communication skills, virtually no social skills, and only rudimentary daily living skills. At this time, STUDENT’s disabilities would be exacerbated by her participation in the regular education classes on larger campuses. STUDENT’s needs require that her anxiety be brought under control and that she develop sufficient communication, social, and daily living skills to allow her to be placed in a regular education classroom for academic instruction.
Specifically, the morning academic session at VAC provides academic instruction in a structured class with fewer than six students per teacher. The classes do not include children with significant behavior problems. Additionally, the curriculum includes courses that STUDENT needs for graduation. Thus, the morning academic instruction meets STUDENT’s need to be educated in a structured class with fewer students and in an environment designed to reduce and minimize her anxiety. The afternoon session includes courses to address STUDENT’s individual communication, social, and daily living skills needs, which were articulated above. The classes also have a low student-teacher ratio and do not include children with behavior problems, and the courses are individually designed to meet STUDENT’s specific needs. The courses allow STUDENT to learn critical functional skills in a safe environment, and the opportunity to apply her lessons in the community with the assistance of staff experienced in teaching autistic children. Additionally, at VAC, STUDENT has the opportunity to learn important living skills with peers experiencing similar difficulties. In such a setting, STUDENT’s anxiety may be lessened or reversed since she will not stand out as different from all the other children.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that VAC, both the morning and afternoon sessions, meets STUDENT’s unique needs.
The District argues that even if VAC meets STUDENT’s unique needs, the District should still be allowed to design and implement its own program for STUDENT. However, the District has failed to design an appropriate program for STUDENT since she entered the District more than 15 months ago. Moreover, to the extent the District developed any programs for STUDENT, it failed to implement them. By the time this decision is issued seven months of the 2001-2002 school year will have passed. And for the past year, STUDENT has received only one hour of instruction a week, and no special education services. Thus, if the District were charged with designing and implementing STUDENT’s program for the balance of the 2001-2002 school year, it would be in the position of having to do in a few days what it has failed to do since September 2000. The District did not present any evidence at hearing that it could carry out such a task in the time required. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that VAC is the appropriate placement for STUDENT for the balance of the 2001-2002 school year, including the extended school year.
Issue Number 3: What compensatory education is appropriate for STUDENT for the period of time that the District did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE?
Applicable Law
Courts have consistently held that the authority to award compensatory education is derived from 20 U.S.C. Section 1415(i)92)(B)(iii), which authorizes a court to grant such "relief as it determines is appropriate." "The purpose of compensatory education is to replace lost educational services." Moubry v. Independent School District Number 696, 951 F.Supp. 867 (8th Cir. 1996). Compensatory education may be an appropriate equitable remedy when the responsible educational authority has failed to provide a disabled child with an appropriate education as required by the IDEA. Todd v. Andrews, 933 F.2d 1576 (11th Cir. 1991).
There is, however, no obligation to compensate the child by providing a day of education for each educational day lost. "Compensatory education is not a contractual remedy, but an equitable remedy, part of the Court's resources in crafting appropriate relief...Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA." Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F3d 1489 (9th Cir. 1994). Equitable considerations are therefore appropriate when fashioning compensatory remedies. An application of equitable principles requires that the actions of the parties themselves must be considered when evaluating the circumstances surrounding the child's lost educational opportunity and in creating an adequate remedy. Id. Thus, when considering a request for compensatory education, it is first necessary to determine whether a school district failed to provide a FAPE. If that issue is answered in the affirmative, the subsequent question is not what precise services were missed but, rather, what compensatory services are necessary to provide an appropriate education under the law.
Evidentiary Analysis
The District stipulated that because it did not provide STUDENT with speech and language services between September 2000 and December 2001, it did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE for that period of time.(Footnote 5) The parties asked the Hearing Officer to determine the appropriate compensatory education for STUDENT.
STUDENT contends that in addition to speech and language services, and one semester of history, the District failed to address her needs relating to social and daily living skills. Mr. Stone, the District’s special education program manager who oversaw STUDENT’s program testified that STUDENT had the same needs in September 2000 relative to communication, anxiety, and social and daily living skills that she had in December 2001. Mr. Stone also testified that, in his opinion, STUDENT’s program had not addressed her communication, anxiety, and social and daily living needs. Indeed, the District did not contend that it had provided any special education services to address STUDENT’s needs in these areas. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that because STUDENT’s needs relative to communication, anxiety, and social and daily living skills did not change between September 2000 and December 2001, and because the District did not address these needs for that entire period of time, the District must provide STUDENT with compensatory education to address her needs in these areas.(Footnote 6)
Regarding the scope of STUDENT’s compensatory education, equitable principles, as discussed above, require the Hearing Officer to look to what compensatory services are necessary to provide STUDENT with an appropriate education under the law. The District conceded that between September 2000 and December 2001, STUDENT needed speech and language services but they were not provided. Additionally, the evidence at hearing made it clear that STUDENT’s communication needs adversely affected virtually all of her other needs, particularly her social and daily living skills needs. In the December 2001 IEP, the District determined that STUDENT needed two 30-minute sessions of speech and language (communication) services each week. Since STUDENT’s needs did not change significantly, if at all, between September 2000 and December 2001, the Hearing Officer finds that she needed two 30-minute sessions of speech and language services during that time period as well. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that it is appropriate for STUDENT to receive 60 minutes of compensatory speech and language services a week in addition to those speech and language services ordered by the Hearing Officer for the balance of the 2001-2002 school year, including the extended school year, and in addition, whatever speech and language services the IEP team determines is appropriate for the 2002-2003 school year.
Mr. Stone conceded that the District did not address STUDENT’s needs relating to anxiety and social and daily living skills for the period between September 2000 and December 2001. Mr. Stone also related how he envisioned STUDENT’s needs might be met in these areas. He described a process in which STUDENT would learn very basic social and daily living skills in a classroom setting, practice them in a safe environment–such as in mock facilities with classmates–and then apply them in the community under the supervision of a teacher or an aide. The District, however, has had since September 2000 to design and implement such a program, but it failed to do so. Moreover, as discussed above, the District did not provide sufficient information to establish that the options it was considering for STUDENT’s program would in fact meet her needs. Conversely, the VAC afternoon program, already in place, is designed to address social and daily living skills for autistic children with needs similar to STUDENT’s, and it employs a methodology similar to that described by Mr. Stone. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that VAC is the appropriate program to provide STUDENT’s compensatory education needs as they relate to social and daily living skills.
Moreover, STUDENT’s anxiety and social and daily living skills needs require that she learn each basic step–one at a time–that she practice each step, and then implement or apply each skill learned. Thus, it would not be to STUDENT’s advantage to have compensatory educational services stacked on top of her program. In light of the fact that she needs to learn these skills one step at a time, STUDENT is not likely to benefit from merely extending her school day to account for the compensatory education she needs. Additionally, because STUDENT needs to learn social and daily living skills one step at a time, she needs a program with continuity in order for her to have a fair opportunity to build onto the skills she learns. To change STUDENT’s social and daily living skills program so soon after she begins would most likely be counterproductive. Thus, notwithstanding the District’s failure to date to identify an appropriate program to address STUDENT’s social and daily living skills needs, the Hearing Officer finds it appropriate to provide STUDENT’s compensatory education in these areas at VAC after the conclusion of the 2001-2002 school year to ensure continuity in her program–a necessary component in light of STUDENT’s needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer orders the District to provide STUDENT with compensatory education services to address her anxiety and social and daily living skills needs at VAC’s afternoon program for the 2002-2003 school year, including the extended school year. Issue Number 4: What assessments is the District required to administer to STUDENT?
Applicable Law
Special education law requires that a student be tested in all areas of suspected disability. (Cal. Ed. Code § 56320(f).) Additionally, the District is required to provide the parent of the child with a proposed assessment plan, including a description of the type of assessments to be conducted. (Cal. Ed. Code §§ 56321(a),(b)(2).) The assessment must also be conducted by persons competent to perform the assessment. (Cal. Ed. Code § 56322.)
Evidentiary Analysis
Occupational Therapy Assessment
Both the District and STUDENT’s parents requested the Hearing Officer order an occupational assessment for STUDENT. Both parties agreed that the District would coordinate STUDENT’s occupational therapy assessment with her personal psychological therapist, Mr. Murphy. The parties agreed that due to STUDENT’s anxiety, history of panic attacks, communication impairments and social withdrawal, the assessment would be held in Mr. Murphy’s office and he would work with STUDENT to ensure an accurate assessment was completed. At hearing, Mr. Murphy agreed to provide the services and the District agreed to compensate him for his time. The parties also agreed that he assessor would be familiar with asperger’s syndrome and autism. At the hearing, the parties indicated that they had a tentative agreement on the issue, but not a final agreement.
The District made it clear that it was willing to agree to the terms discussed at the hearing. But STUDENT took the position that the District should also be required to disclose the nature, scope, time, and location of the assessment. STUDENT argues that her medical providers treating her anxiety disorders need this information to make an informed decision as to whether STUDENT is ready and capable of completing the assessment. STUDENT has requested the name and credentials of the person administering the assessment. The Hearing Officer notes that the District is required under special education law to provide the name and qualifications of the assessor, as well as a description of the assessment to be conducted. This description reasonably includes a description of the nature of the assessment, the time it will take to complete it, and the date, time, and place it is scheduled.
Auditory Processing Assessment
STUDENT contends that there is sufficient evidence of an auditory processing disorder that she should be assessed in this area. Dr. Levin testified that STUDENT’s performance on a variety of psychoeducational subtests in the WRAT-3 test that he administered to STUDENT indicated she may have an auditory processing disorder. The District pointed out that such information had not previously been brought to its attention, and although it was not convinced that STUDENT needed such an assessment, the District was willing to provide it. Therefore, the District agrees to assess STUDENT for a possible auditory processing disorder.
ORDER
1. Within 10 calendar days of the date of this order, the District shall place STUDENT at the Valley Achievement Center for the full morning and afternoon programs for the remainder of the 2001-2002 school, including the extended school year;
2. Within 10 calendar days of the date of this order, the District shall provide in conformity with the December 2001 IEP, STUDENT with speech and language services twice a week for 30 minutes each session, two counseling sessions each month with a school social worker, and door-to-door transportation for each service ordered for the balance of the 2001-2002 school yer, including the extended school year.
3. The District shall provide STUDENT with placement in VAC’s afternoon social and daily living skills program for the 2002-2003 school year, including the extended school year, as compensatory education;
4. Within 10 calendar days of the date of this order, as compensatory education, the District shall provide STUDENT with 60 minutes of speech and language services each week for a period of 15 months in addition to the speech and language services the Hearing Officer ordered for the balance of the 2001-2002 school year, including the extended school year, and in addition to whatever speech and language services the IEP team determines is appropriate for the 2002-2003 school year.
5. The District shall provide STUDENT with the name and qualifications of the person conducting the occupational therapy assessment, as well as description of the occupational therapy assessment, including a description of the nature of the assessment, the amount of
6. time it will take to complete it, and the date, time, and place it is scheduled. Additionally, the District shall administer auditory processing and O.T. assessments.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statue:
1. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE at the December 6, 2001 IEP meeting for the remainder of the 2001-2002 school year? STUDENT prevailed on this issue
2. If the District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE, is the Valley Achievement Center (VAC) the appropriate placement to meet her unique needs? STUDENT prevailed on this issue
3. What compensatory education is appropriate for STUDENT for the period of time that the District did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE? STUDENT prevailed on this issue
4. What assessments is the District required to administer to STUDENT? Neither party prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties in this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).)
Date: February 25, 2002 ___________________________________ Paul E. Lacy, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES
1. In the Bakersfild area, the Panama-Buena Vista School District includes only grades kindergarten through eight, and the Kern High School District serves the students for grades nine through twelve.
2. On July 25, 2000, STUDENT’s parents filed a complaint with the State Department of Education alleging that the District refused to timely asses STUDENT. On November 3, 2000, the Special Education Division of the California Department of Education issued a report on its findings from a compliance investigation relating to the District’s handling of STUDENT’s special education related matters. The report found that the District failed to adhere to the 15-day timeline for developing STUDENT’s assessment plan, failed to obtain written consent before conducting the assessments, and that the District failed to adhere to IEP team meeting procedures. The Department ordered the District to send out directives to its pertinent staff regarding timely preparation of assessment plans and the requirement for written permission before testing is commenced. The order also required the District to set an IEP meeting for STUDENT within 30 days of the report being issued.
3. The categories for assessment specified on the preprinted form included developmental history; school history; educational progress of the individual; steps previously taken to assist the student in his or her learning or behavior disability; academic and intellectual functioning; economic, social, and language factors; speech and language development; health history; and emotional status.
4. Dr. Levin testified that he modified the Gray Oral Reading Test (GORT), which was the test utilized to measure reading comprehension. Instead of having STUDENT read the passages and verbally answer the questions, Dr. Levin read the questions to her and she responded in writing. He did, however, score the test using norms established by children who had taken the test without modifications.
5. Additionally, the District conceded that it was required to STUDENT with one semester of History. Because the transportation provided to STUDENT by the District did not appropriately serve her class schedule, she did not complete her first semester of History at Liberty.
6. The District also did not contest the fact that STUDENT was deprived of one semester of history class, and it agreed to provide her with a make up class in the summer of 2002. The Hearing Officer assumes the District will provide STUDENT with the appropriate, accredited make-up instruction for the portion of the class STUDENT did not receive.
