California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 13, 2003
Student v. Pomona Unified School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 2274-02 · Hearing Officer Michael B. Arkin
Pomona Unified's special day class offer for a seven-year-old upheld; parents' request to fund a home program denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a seven-year-old boy filed for due process, and Pomona Unified School District filed a cross-petition. The boy was eligible for special education under other health impairment, due to a congenital brain condition called agenesis of the corpus callosum, and also for autistic-like behaviors and speech and language disorders. He had been educated at home until the 2001-2002 school year. He then started a one-to-one transitional class at Armstrong Elementary, where adult staff played the roles of classmates. For 2002-2003, the parents agreed with the IEP goals and services. They disputed only the District's offer of a special day class with other children (the Early Childhood Development Class), backed by a one-to-one aide, speech, occupational therapy, nursing, and behavior case management. The parents wanted the one-to-one sessions to continue and asked the District to fund a home program called The Sharper Mind. The Hearing Officer found that the District understood the boy's disability and had relied on the parents' private evaluations. Teacher records showed he had made progress. Witnesses also testified credibly that he needed real contact with peers to learn social skills. The offer was therefore a FAPE in the least restrictive environment. Little evidence explained The Sharper Mind program, and it was not a state-certified nonpublic agency, so funding was denied. The District was allowed to implement the July 23, 2002 IEP.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO weighed a family's request to keep a child in isolated or home instruction against a district's classroom placement. It relied on evidence that the child needed practice with peers to build social skills. It also noted that a hearing officer could not order services from an uncertified nonpublic agency.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1. Did the District's offer to Student for academic year 2002-2003 constitute a free appropriate public education (FAPE)?
The July 23, 2002 IEP offer of an SDC/EDC placement at Armstrong with speech, OT, nursing, behavior case management and a 1:1 aide met the student's unique needs, was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, and was the least restrictive environment.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. Should the District be ordered to provide funding to obtain The Sharper Mind Program and train parents and other providers to administer it to Student?
Because the District offered FAPE, and little evidence showed how the program would meet the student's needs, no funding for a home-based Sharper Mind program was ordered; the program was also not a state-certified nonpublic agency.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order that district's offer may be implemented. District is entitled to implement the program, placement and services in the IEP dated July 23, 2002, and is directed to make them available to Student. All of Student's claims for relief denied.
Key authorities
Board of Education v. Rowley; Lenn v. Portland Sch. Comm.; M.M. v. Sch. Dist. of Greenville Co.; Cordrey v. Euckert
People named in the decision
- Trena Spurlock, Director of special education, Pomona Unified School District
- Kaye Goodwin, School psychologist (assessor), Pomona Unified School District
- Patti Adams, Special education program administrator, Pomona Unified School District
- Regina Bynum, Special day class teacher, Pomona Unified School District
- Betsy Kelsey, School nurse / pediatric nurse practitioner, Pomona Unified School District
- Dianne LaBomme, Special education program specialist, Pomona Unified School District
- Lynn K. Paul, Ph.D., Private neurocognitive evaluator, Fuller Psychological and Family Services
- Warren S. Brown, Ph.D., Private neurocognitive evaluator, Fuller Psychological and Family Services
- Bristol Park Medical Clinic, Private pediatric assessment provider
- The Institute for the Achievement of Human Potential, Private educational assessment provider
- The Sharper Mind, Home educational program requested by parents (uncertified nonpublic agency)
- G. Robert Roice, District representative (special education advocate), G. R. Roice and Associates
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard on January 16 and 17, 2003, in Pomona, California, before Michael B. Arkin, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific.
Petitioner and Cross-Respondent, STUDENT (herein referred to as Student or STUDENT) was represented by his parents. Also present for STUDENT was his aunt, Dr. Rose. Respondent Pomona Unified School District (herein District) was represented by special education advocate G. Robert Roice of G. R. Roice and Associates. Also attending for the District was Trena Spurlock, director of special education.
Mr. PARENT testified on behalf of his son and conducted the questioning of STUDENT’s aunt, AUNT, Ph.D., a clinical psychologist. No one else testified on Student’s behalf. The District called as witnesses the following persons: Trena Spurlock, Kaye Goodwin, district psychologist, Patti Adams, special education program administrator, Regina Bynum, special day class teacher, Betsy Kelsey, school nurse, and Dianne LaBomme, special education program specialist. Oral testimony and documentary evidence were received. The record remained open pending receipt of written closing arguments. Upon receipt by the Hearing Officer of the written closing arguments on February 6, 2003, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision. ISSUES (Footnote 1)
1. Did the District’s offer to STUDENT for academic year 2002-2003 constitute a free appropriate public education (FAPE)?(Footnote 2)
2. Should the District be ordered to provide funding to obtain The Sharper Mind Program and prepare parents and other providers to administer it to STUDENT?(Footnote 3)
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Student’s parents contended that STUDENT’s unique deficits and needs were neither identified or addressed by the District because the District allegedly did not understand STUDENT’s disability nor know how to address it.
The District contended that it had in fact identified and addressed STUDENT’s deficits and needs, contending that in the identification phase it had taken into account all of the medical evidence and professional reports offered by STUDENT’s parents as well as its own assessments. Further, the District contended that in addressing those identified deficits and needs it had utilized the experience of its personnel who were familiar and experienced with the disability and with special needs children. In sum, the District contended that it had both identified and correctly addressed STUDENT’s needs.
STUDENT’s parents also contended that STUDENT’s proposed placement in an SDC with other children was incorrect. They contended that STUDENT should be placed in a home school environment in which a program known as the Sharper Mind program was administered, with support services in speech and language, socialization and behavior intervention provided by the District.
The District contended that its offer of placement in an SDC at Armstrong school was correct and that STUDENT should be placed in an SDC with other students, provided he also had support services. The District contended that its offer constituted the least restrictive environment for STUDENT.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a seven-year-old child who resides within the boundaries of the District. He currently attends a transitional special day class at his home school, Armstrong Elementary School (Armstrong), in which he is the only student. He is eligible for special education and related services as a child with speech and language processing disorders, autistic-like behaviors and under the category “other health impaired” due to complete agenesis of the corpus callousum (CACC). This congenital neurological disorder is manifest in the absence of neurological connection between the left brain and right brain and results in the inability of one hemisphere of the brain to communicate efficiently with the other. Symptoms include visual and auditory disorientation, difficulty with fine motor skills, low frustration tolerance and resultant behavioral issues. The symptomatology is generally described in the medical setting as that similar to a person recovering from a stroke. The District categorized the disorder in the Individualized Education Program (IEP) as a disability characterized by “autistic like behaviors.”
At six months of age, STUDENT was diagnosed with CACC. The diagnosis is not in dispute in these proceedings. STUDENT’s speech and ambulation were developmentally delayed and symptoms of hyperactivity appeared early. He began receiving daily rehabilitative therapy, administered by his father, at the age of sixteen months. He did not sleep through the night until the age of four.
At the age of five, STUDENT was unable to concentrate long enough to complete kindergarten- level tasks, had difficulty following social cues, was disruptive in social settings, and exhibited defiant behavior. He was also delayed in fine motor skills. His parents did not enroll him in either preschool or kindergarten and continued to provide for him at home. They administered a formal six- to eight-hour-per-day educational program for six days per week. In September 2001, STUDENT’s parents felt the need for information regarding his school readiness and cognitive abilities. They obtained a pediatric assessment from Bristol Park Medical Clinic, a neurocognitive assessment from Fuller Psychological Family Services, and an educational assessment from The Institute for the Achievement of Human Potential. STUDENT’s parents provided those assessments to the District in November 2001 and requested the District’s assessment and an IEP. At that time, STUDENT had never attended an organized school-based program.
The District developed its assessment plan in December 2001. As part of its plan, the District reviewed the assessments provided to the District by STUDENT’s parents. It additionally performed an adaptive physical education (APE) assessment and a current psychoeducational assessment. The first IEP meeting took place February 14, 2002. At that meeting, it was reported that “STUDENT is very strong, active, capable of coordination, balance, kicking. [H]e likes sports. Parents are concerned with STUDENT[’s] health, behavior, reading, writing, math skills. Major concern at this time is with behavior. Parents realize the area of behavior is essential for him to access further education. Parents goal is for him to be eventually mainstreamed.” It was determined that STUDENT was eligible for special education services under the categories of “autistic like behaviors” due to neurological impairment, “other health impaired,” and speech and language disorders.
The IEP team recommended placement in a special day class (SDC) at El Camino School, a District school, with individual speech and language sessions, counseling, health nursing services, and additional assessments in the areas of occupational therapy (OT) and expressive and receptive speech and language skills. Because STUDENT had not attended either preschool or kindergarten, it was agreed that a forty-day transition plan should be implemented. During that transition period, STUDENT was to attend school in an educational setting in which he was the only student, being taught one-on-one. The first phase of the transition plan called for a one and one-half hour per day SDC to be convened, consisting of STUDENT, the special education teacher, and four adults playing the parts of students. This method was intended to introduce STUDENT to beginning socialization skills. STUDENT’s parents agreed to the IEP team recommendations. The next meeting was scheduled for March 28, 2002, to allow the IEP team to follow up on the assessments scheduled and on STUDENT’s progress in the transition class.
At the March IEP meeting, it was agreed that STUDENT’s eligibility categories would remain the same. The IEP team reviewed the OT and speech and language assessments and the goals and objectives from the February meeting. Progress was noted, and in accordance with the assessment, speech and language goals in the areas of expressive and receptive language were added. In addition, a behavior intervention plan was developed and added to the IEP. The District members of the IEP team again recommended an SDC placement, specifically the Early Childhood Development Class (EDC) for kindergarten students at Armstrong. STUDENT’s parents agreed to the goals and objectives set forth in the IEP but asked that the transition plan remain in effect until they had evaluated the SDC/EDC. A review of the IEP was scheduled for April 18, 2002.
At the April 18, 2002 IEP meeting, goals were reviewed. Goal F, relating to self-care, was revised and Goals N and O, relating to mathematics and fine motor skills, were added. In addition, goals were added in speech and language and occupational therapy. There was agreement between the parents and District as to the goals and objectives of the IEP, as amended and added. The placement at Armstrong in the SDC/EDC class was a continued recommendation of the District members of the IEP team. Designated instructional services (DIS) to be provided were speech and language two times per week for 30 minutes, OT one time per week for 60 minutes, health nursing services one time per week for 20 minutes, and a behavior intervention case manager service (replacing counseling) one time per week for 20 minutes. It was recommended that STUDENT receive a daily one-to-one instructional aide when STUDENT transitioned into a school setting. STUDENT’s parents agreed.
The IEP team believed that the skills that STUDENT was acquiring through the transitional program should be generalized by use in a less restrictive, though still transitional, setting. It was recommended that he receive only 30 minutes per day of the one-to-one instruction instead of one and one-half hours per day. This was to be followed by 65 minutes of instruction with other students in the SDC/EDC class. The parents disagreed with this latter recommendation. STUDENT’s parents stated that in their opinion he was not ready to be in a classroom with other children. They felt his aggressive behaviors would escalate because he would be overstimulated by the other students. They also raised concerns about his immune system capability. The District offered the SDC/EDC program and agreed to keep the transition plan that had been initiated in February in effect until the end of the regular school year. Thus, as part of the transition plan, during the 2001-2002 extended school year (ESY), STUDENT participated in closing activities with other students in the SDC/EDC class ten times. His father observed many of these classes. STUDENT remained in the one-to-one SDC placement the remainder of the time. He was also provided speech and language and OT services during the extended school year term, which extended term was offered by the District as part of the transition plan.
The final IEP meeting preceding the filing of the requests for due process hearing in these cases took place on July 23, 2002. The subject of that meeting was STUDENT’s educational plan for the 2002-2003 school year. Again, the District and the parents agreed on the goals, objectives and services proposed for STUDENT. The parents and District did not agree on the SDC/EDC placement offered for the 2002-2003 school year scheduled to begin in September. STUDENT’s parents asked for the continuation of the one-to-one school sessions at Armstrong, with no other children present and for continued DIS. In addition, they requested that the District obtain The Sharper Mind educational program and associated training so that they could administer it to STUDENT in a home placement. Further, the parents asked for a peer tutor “so that STUDENT might learn some social skills.”
The District disagreed and by letter dated August 1, 2002, repeated its offer of the program described in the July 23, 2002 IEP. Parents requested a due process hearing on behalf of STUDENT, which was received by the Special Education Hearing Office on August 29, 2002. The Hearing Office received the District’s cross-petition on October 15, 2002.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. Did the District’s offer to STUDENT for academic year 2002-2003 constitute a free appropriate public education (FAPE)?
Under both federal and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. 20 U.S.C. §§ 1400 et seq. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56000 et seq. The purpose of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and California’s conforming statutes is to provide handicapped students with access to public education. Board of Education v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982). A free appropriate public education in this context consists of special education and related services that are available to the child, at no charge to the parent or guardian, which meet the State educational standards and conform to the child’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).
“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction which meets the unique needs of the child. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. The special education program is also designed to enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum and as the Supreme Court stated in Board of Education v. Rowley, supra, it must be reasonably calculated to provide the pupil with educational benefit. The Act does not require that the benefits conferred permit the student to reach the highest attainable level. Lenn v. Portland Sch. Comm. 998 F.2d 1083 (1st. Cir. 1993). What is required is entry to a “basic floor of opportunity” through access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Board of Education v. Rowley, supra, at 201. That education is to be provided in the least restrictive environment and prepare the student for employment and independent living. 20 U.S.C. § 1412; 34 C.F.R. § 300.550; Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.(Footnote 4)
In summary, State law and Rowley provide three factors in determining whether a school district substantially offered a FAPE. Stated specifically, the offer must be designed to meet unique needs, be reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, and must conform to the student’s IEP (additionally, it must be provided in the least restrictive environment).
In this case, the parties agreed throughout the IEP process that the Student is eligible for special education services and that in order to help overcome his deficits so that he can access the educational curriculum, he requires speech and language services, a behavioral intervention program (BIP), and occupational therapy (OT) services. The disagreement is whether the District’s proposed placement and services can address STUDENT’s needs and whether, as Student contended, the proposed placement in fact demonstrates that the District did not properly identify, understand or appropriately provide for his needs. The first area for the Hearing Officer to consider is whether the District properly understood STUDENT’s disability and therefore identified STUDENT’s deficits and addressed his unique needs.
(A) STUDENT’s Deficits and Unique Needs.
(i) STUDENT’s disability and resultant deficits.
Mr. PARENT contended throughout the due process hearing that the District did not properly identify or understand STUDENT’s disability, the cause of his deficits. The evidence demonstrated that STUDENT’s disability is the result of the total failure of development, during gestation, of the Corpus Callosum, a membrane that serves as a platform or bridge upon which neurons build paths which provide connection and thus communication between the right and left hemispheres of the brain. During her testimony, Rose Ph.D., a clinical psychologist, testified at length about the way in which this deficiency manifests itself.(Footnote 5) Dr. Rose commented, “No switchboard exists,” stating additionally that the lack of connection between the right and left sides of the brain results in delayed speech, delayed writing skills and difficulty with balance, “like a stroke victim.” She testified that STUDENT therefore has speech and language processing difficulties, problems with fine motor skills such as writing, using scissors, or tying shoes, and difficulties transitioning from one skill to another. Further, since STUDENT’s self-regulation functions are compromised, it is difficult for him or any person with this disorder to interact appropriately in a social setting.
Dr. Rose observed that in a clinical setting, the affected person appears to be affected by autistic-like behaviors, ADHD or oppositional defiant disorder. Dr. Rose stated that behaviorally, to compensate for this neurological deficit, STUDENT fixates on structure and becomes inflexible. He is comforted by repetitive patterns. For example, he may become extremely anxious if a change in his routine is made. A change in classroom schedule, changing from one task or subject to another, disrupts his sense of security. His reaction is anxiety, but it is often read as defiance. Similarly, he finds it difficult to understand social cues or appropriateness of social interaction. Consequently, his anxiety in social situations takes the form of aggression.
Dr. Rose stated, in summary, that “any educator working with STUDENT has to understand why he [processes and manifests] the way he does.” In short, she stated: “A teacher needs to be aware of his unique learning style” in order to effectively engage him in the educational process.
Moreover, District witnesses agreed with Dr. Rose’s testimony, including her opinion as to the teaching skills required to meet the challenge STUDENT presents. For example, Kaye Goodwin, the district psychologist who assessed STUDENT for the February 14, 2002 IEP, found that he met the criteria for eligibility for special education and related services under the category “Other Health Impairment, specifically Agenesis of the Corpus Callosum.” She also found STUDENT eligible under the category “Autistic Like Behaviors resulting from his neurological impairment.” These conclusions were reached after review of the testing, reports and evaluations provided by STUDENT’s parents, classroom observation, home observation, clinical interviews and the administration of additional test instruments (in particular, the Woodcock-PARENT Scales of Independent Behavior, the Conners Rating Scale, revised, and the Brigance Comprehensive Inventory of Basic Skills).(Footnote 6) In addition to having 15 years’ experience as a District psychologist and 16 years’ prior experience as a special education teacher, Ms. Goodwin testified that she had prior experience with students who had agenesis and disgenesis of the corpus callosum. Her prior experience dealing with students having this rare condition is a factor considered by the Hearing Officer in weighing Ms. Goodwin’s testimony.
Patti Adams, a special education program administrator for the District, had been called in to supervise STUDENT’s diagnostic evaluation. She participated in the IEPs and also observed STUDENT when she substituted as his special education teacher on three occasions. She agreed with Mr. PARENT, on cross-examination, that STUDENT presented in a manner similar to a person with autistic spectrum disorders or traumatic brain injury. She observed in that regard that his IEP is developed appropriately for a student with autistic-like behaviors. She stated that she had also identified his impulsiveness or lack of self-regulation, his speech and language delays, auditory issues and ADHD-like symptoms. Ms. Adams’ testimony was delivered thoughtfully and credibly.
Dianne LaBomme, a special education program specialist with 20 years’ experience as a school psychologist, observed STUDENT in the classroom, participated in his IEPs and taught him during his summer 2002 ESY program. She stated similarly: “I understand that he [STUDENT] has a diagnosis of agenesis of the corpus callosum and that it is manifested in several ways, including delayed social development.” Ms. LaBomme’s opinion was derived from her direct teaching experience with STUDENT and her extensive special education background, both of which were considered by the Hearing Officer.
Considering the testimony of both Student’s and District’s witnesses, as well as the documents admitted into evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s disability and his resultant deficits were appropriately identified by the District. Moreover, the District demonstrated that it understood them. The District’s assessment and the IEPs referenced above included recommendations of the parents’ experts. Additionally, the District conducted its own evaluation and concluded that STUDENT was eligible for special education and related services because of the deficits described (in near-identical terms, by both student and district experts).
The next area of inquiry that the Hearing Officer must consider is whether the District’s offer met STUDENT’s unique needs.
(ii) STUDENT’s Unique Needs.
Student’s father testified that he and Mrs. PARENT had not: “seen the appropriateness of the District’s intervention. [STUDENT] has changed for the worse. His needs are not being met.” He repeated this contention in the written closing argument asking for: “accountability and...changes [in] STUDENT’s current IEP [because it] has not been structured to address STUDENT’s unique educational and behavioral intervention needs.”
Lynn K. Paul, Ph.D. and Warren S. Brown, Ph.D. of Fuller Psychological and Family Services provided a neurocognitive evaluation. Their assessment was submitted on behalf of Student and was admitted into evidence. The results indicated impairments in visual-motor integration, particularly fine motor integration skills, and in both expressive and receptive speech and language processing. The evaluators commented that individuals with compete agenesis inevitably experience cognitive and psychosocial limitations as the result of the brain’s limited ability to rapidly coordinate information processing. The report noted that STUDENT exhibited difficulty generalizing his experience, that he exhibited little insight in social integration and that he exhibited significant behavioral disturbance. The Fuller Report recommended that STUDENT’s needs in these areas be met with a structured educational environment, use of repetitive strategies similar to those utilized for teaching ADHD children, and a class which provides him with social opportunities. In that setting, occupational therapy services with training in fine motor coordination was also recommended. The District accepted the report and its recommendations.
Trena Spurlock, the director of special education for the District, testified that the District had taken care to develop a plan for STUDENT’s education which would address the needs described in the Fuller Report and the IEPs. She first became aware of STUDENT’s case in February 2002. She indicated that the February 2002 IEP was called at the parents’ request for the purpose of designing a program which would transition STUDENT into District schools. Director Spurlock described the meeting as “a preliminary IEP [designed to] give us a diagnostic opportunity.” Initially, pending further assessment, the District initiated a one-hour-per-week SDC program at El Camino Elementary School in which STUDENT was taught by a special education teacher trained in autism. Speech and language therapy was added twice weekly and a pediatric nurse was designated to monitor STUDENT’s health issues.(Footnote 7) Ms. Spurlock was a credible witness. The Hearing Officer is persuaded that the directive to the District members of the IEP team from the special education director was to determine the needs of this student and develop a plan tailored to address them.
By the March 28, 2002 IEP meeting, the District had taken the opportunity to formulate a more complete program. The IEP included the following to address STUDENT’s unique needs: O.T. goals were adopted and occupational therapy was recommended once weekly for one hour in a classroom setting; fine motor skills were specifically targeted; a structured class environment was proposed in which STUDENT would be provided with a class schedule and a variety of prompts to assist him in transitioning from one activity to another; and repetitive activities such as reading readiness, number recognition and writing readiness were proposed. He was also offered a full-time instructional aide, a behavior intervention case plan, nursing/medical services and twice-weekly speech and language services, both individual and group. It was suggested that he participate in lunch and recess with the general education population, but that his academic curriculum be provided primarily in an SDC five days per week. In addition, at this IEP meeting it was proposed that his placement be changed to Armstrong Elementary School, his home school. Director Spurlock testified that STUDENT’s parents indicated agreement with the IEP, but that they were not ready to begin its implementation. Consequently, the District delayed its commencement and kept STUDENT in the one-to-one transition SDC class with designated instructional services. In April 2002 at an IEP review, the District indicated its desire to initiate the program and so offered. But STUDENT’s parents remained reluctant to place him with other students, although they did discuss a possible transitional ESY program. That transitional ESY program, scheduled for the summer session of academic year 2001-2002, was to consist of STUDENT’s participation in ten closing sessions of the SDC/EDC class with Mr. PARENT observing.
The July 23, 2002 IEP meeting concluded with recommendations for addressing STUDENT’s unique needs. The proposals for academic year 2002-2003 included OT goals, objectives and services, a behavioral intervention case management plan and an AB3632 referral to county mental health, the designated instructional services previously proposed, a one-to-one aide and placement in the SDC/EDC. Patti Adams, who instructed STUDENT in the ESY program, attended this meeting. The ESY program had been a continuation of the original transitional placement, an SDC class consisting of one teacher, four adults playing the parts of students, and STUDENT. She testified that in her experience with him she observed that he had made significant progress since February. Moreover, she stated: “What the parents state as their concerns can only be addressed with classroom interaction, with prompting, with other children, problem solving, taking turns....” She continued, stating, “He’s had behavior modification, good teaching ... we are also concerned about his ability to interact with other children but he hasn’t been prepared to do so in the context of other children.” In other words, she stated, the way to best teach and sharpen STUDENT’s social skills is by allowing him to practice in real social situations, not by withdrawing him from contact with the classroom and “home schooling” him as proposed by the parents during the hearing and in written closing argument.
The District witnesses were credible. Their manner of presentation and their demeanor while testifying, both on direct testimony as well as cross-examination, demonstrated their primary concern -- that of the education of STUDENT. District personnel demonstrated by their testimony, as well as the written IEP reports and correspondence directed to STUDENT’s parents, that they undertook to develop a program for STUDENT which addressed his unique needs. They were well informed and highly qualified. They accepted the evaluations and reports of qualified professionals provided by the Student. The District psychologist, an adjunct professor of psychology at Azuza-Pacific University, has 15 years’ experience as a credentialed school psychologist. For a period of 16 years, prior to earning her credential in school psychology, she was a special education teacher. She had prior experience helping to meet the needs of other children with the rare disability in question. Because of these factors, the Hearing Officer places substantial weight on the testimony the District’s witnesses.
Finally, the services proposed to be delivered with the SDC/EDC placement specifically targeted STUDENT’s unique needs. The District’s proposed program, developed in part with the recommendations of Student’s providers, included focus on all areas of STUDENT’s deficits and proposed measures designed to address them. These measures included a structured educational environment, use of repetitive strategies, a small class setting providing an introduction to socialization, speech therapy, fine motor training and related occupational therapy. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the program offered by the District was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. It addressed all of the recommendations of both the Student’s experts and the District’s experts. Therefore the District’s offer was designed to meet his unique needs.
The next issue for determination by the Hearing Officer provided the central focus of this hearing, namely whether the placement and services offered by the District -- placement in the SDC /EDC class with designated instructional services including behavioral intervention and OT-- was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to STUDENT and whether that proposed placement is in the least restrictive environment in accordance with the law.
(iii) Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit.
Regina Bynum, STUDENT’s classroom teacher since February 2002, testified that STUDENT had made progress in each of the identified areas of unique need. She testified that STUDENT’s behavioral progress was evidenced by his present willingness to cooperate, receive prompts and transition from activity to activity the majority of the time. When he first entered the transition SDC class, he had been approximately eight percent defiant and resistant. Ms. Bynum testified that he also had made dramatic improvement in speech and language skills, mathematics, and focusing attention. Ms Bynum indicated that there are still behavioral incidents, but they are fewer in number as well as intensity and he is more willing to accept a prompt to refocus his attention than he was at the beginning of the program. Ms. Bynum’s testimony was supported by her classroom records and by the reports of progress toward meeting benchmarks and goals contained in the most recent IEP. The Hearing Officer considered her testimony credible. It was based upon her direct observation and her classroom notes. She was very specific and it was clear to the Hearing Officer that she took pride in STUDENT’s accomplishments.
Ms. Bynum pointed out that based upon her experience as a teacher, she believes that STUDENT’s behavioral and social problems were due in part to his lack of contact with other children. She suggested that because he has been isolated from his peers, he has had no opportunities to develop social interaction skills. In that regard, she pointed to STUDENT’s progress tolerating instruction outside of the home environment, learning to respond to prompts, and the reduction in number and intensity of his behavioral episodes of acting out.
Mr. PARENT testified that STUDENT had not made progress either academically or in social development. It is evident from the record that Mr. PARENT has devoted his entire energy in guiding the development and education of his son. The Hearing Officer is cognizant of the frustration and exhaustion that may be related to such a commitment. Although it must appear to Mr. PARENT at times that no progress has been made, the objective testing evidenced the contrary. The evidence demonstrates that STUDENT has made progress. And all of the District witnesses who had contact with STUDENT commented on his progress, even under the limited circumstances of the transitional SDC class. They also testified that he would benefit from the interaction with other children provided by the proposed placement in the SDC/EDC class at Armstrong, his home school. The Hearing Officer was persuaded by the testimony and corroborating testing that STUDENT will not be able to learn social interaction controls and skills until he is permitted to interact with typical peers in real school situations and settings. It is therefore concluded that the proposed SDC/EDC placement supported by the designated instructional services described previously is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to STUDENT.
(iv) Least Restrictive Environment.
Special education law requires that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment. This concept, sometimes referred to as “mainstreaming” or “full inclusion,” directs that his education be provided in a manner which promotes interaction with typically developing peers to the extent that is feasible while maintaining the individual program appropriate to meet the special education student’s needs. 20 U.S.C. §§ 1412(a)(5)(A), 1414(d)(1)(A)(iii)(III), Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. The Hearing Officer is persuaded that the SDC/EDC class proposed by the District meets this requirement. The placement options proposed by the parents are much more restrictive in that they do not provide for peer interaction or socialization.
The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the District’s offer of an SDC placement with the supports set forth in STUDENT’s IEP is designed to meet his needs, calculated to provide educational benefit and that it is in the least restrictive environment. Therefore, the District’s offer constitutes a FAPE under the law.
2. Should the District be ordered to provide funding to obtain The Sharper Mind Program and train parents and other providers to administer it to STUDENT?
Student argued that he was not ready to be educated in a classroom with other students and sought placement in the home, supplemented with a program known as “Sharper Mind.” Parents requested that the District be ordered to provide funding for the purpose of administering the Sharper Mind program at home. However, little evidence was introduced to explain how the program would meet STUDENT’s needs or why it would be otherwise necessary. Dr. Rose provided only a vague, general description and the District witnesses testified that they had attempted to learn more about the program but could not find information. The Hearing Officer had little more to consider than a printout of a web page taken from the Internet.
STUDENT’s parents argued, in addition, that in any event he should be educated in his home environment, testifying that he would have the opportunity to interact with peers if the parents invited children over from time to time. District personnel testified that STUDENT was socially inclined and appeared to like other children; he just didn’t have practice interacting with them and could not interpret social cues properly. Diane LaBomme testified that he needs to learn group behaviors and she was confident, based upon her experience with STUDENT, that he is capable of doing so. The Hearing Officer does not find persuasive the parents’ argument that socialization may be taught by inviting children over to play in the home setting from time to time.
Moreover, the Hearing Officer concluded earlier in this Decision that the District’s offer of placement and services contained in the IEP dated July 23, 2002, is an offer of a FAPE for STUDENT. Therefore, consideration of an alternative placement is not necessary. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that an order respecting the provision of additional or alternative services or funding would not be appropriate.(Footnote 8)
ORDER
(1) The District is entitled to implement the program, placement and services included in STUDENT’s IEP dated July 23, 2002.
(2) The District is directed to make the program, placement and services offered in the IEP dated July 23, 2002, available to STUDENT.
(3) All of Student’s claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code section 5607(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: Respondent and cross-Petitioner, Pomona Unified School District, prevailed on all issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code Section 56505(i).
Dated: March 13, 2003 Michael B. Arkin, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The wording and sequence of the issues differ somewhat from the statement of the issues filed by Student. They were clarified at the outset of this hearing. They are again restated for purposes of focus in this Decision. Changes in the language and in the order the issues are discussed were made solely for purposes of clarity and to facilitate analysis in this Decision. No changes in substance have been made. 2. One of the issues originally designated was resolved at the outset of the hearing; specifically, who would bear the burden of going forward when both parties wished to change the present placement. It was agreed that the District had the ultimate burden of persuasion as to its offer of FAPE. And although the District offered to present its witnesses first, witness scheduling resulted in agreement that the Student would put his case on first. 3. During the hearing, Student’s parents also requested that extended school year (ESY) be considered as an issue. However, no evidence was presented with respect to ESY and in particular no evidence addressed or related to the likelihood of regression by the Student in the absence of an ESY program, the principal criterion for an ESY as is set forth in 5 C.C.R. section 3043 and 34 C.F.R. section 300.313 and the cases decided thereunder [See for example, M.M. v. Sch. Dist. of Greenville Co. 303 F.2d 523 (4th Cir. 2002), Cordrey v. Euckert (6th Cir.1990) 917 F.2d 1460]. It was evident to the Hearing Officer that the ESY request was tangential and that STUDENT’s proposed placement in the special day class was the principal issue. ESY is therefore not discussed in this Decision. 4. The parties agreed that the program offered did conform to the student’s IEP. However the appropriateness of the IEP was challenged by the Student at the hearing. Thus, the principal issues are whether the District identified and understood the Student’s unique needs, offered a program designed to meet those needs and was reasonably calculated to meet them, and offered to do so in the least restrictive environment. 5. Dr. Rose is a highly qualified psychologist. She has a Masters and Ph.D. in clinical psychology, is a credentialed school psychologist, credentialed school counselor, an adjunct professor of psychology at Azusa Pacific College, provides services for school districts and one SELPA, and provides therapy services for the Alhambra Behavioral Health Center. The Hearing Officer found her testimony both informative and credible.. 6. In her evaluation of STUDENT’s deficits, the District psychologist did not accept or take into account the information provided by the parents from The Sharper Mind program, for reasons to be discussed hereafter. 7. Mr. PARENT testified that STUDENT had a compromised immune system and could not be exposed to other children without serious risk. The evidence did not support his testimony. Rather, the evidence demonstrated that STUDENT had allergies and a history of viral infections. However, Betsy Kelsey R.N., a pediatric nurse practitioner who monitors STUDENT’s health, testified that while he may miss some school from time to time, there is no medical reason preventing him from attending school full time. Regina Bynum, SDC teacher, stated that he had the “traditional colds and flu – same as anybody else.” 8. The Hearing Officer does note that the so-called Sharper Mind program, a nonpublic agency, is not a program that has been certified by the State of California pursuant to section 56366.1 of the Education Code. Therefore the Hearing Officer would be prohibited from rendering a decision that would result in service being provided by that agency. Cal. Educ. Code section 56505.2(a).
