California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 8, 2001
Student v. Anaheim Union High School District
SEHO Case No. SN 2290-00 · Hearing Officer Trevor Skarda
Anaheim Union High School District prevails; no Hughes Bill behavior assessment or independent assessments ordered for eighth grader.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
At the start of the hearing, the Hearing Officer granted the District's renewed motion to take the matter off the expedited calendar. The SELPA was dismissed as a party on the first day of hearing.
Summary
The parents of a 13-year-old eighth grader filed for due process against Anaheim Union High School District. The student was eligible for special education with a specific learning disability. They filed after a December 2000 incident led the District to start expulsion proceedings. The case was first set for an expedited hearing. The Hearing Officer took it off the expedited calendar because the District had dropped all discipline and the student could return to Dale Junior High School. The parents asked for a California "Hughes Bill" functional analysis assessment, a behavior intervention plan based on it, and independent assessments at District expense. The Hearing Officer found that the student did not have a "serious behavior problem" under state regulations. He had been failing to finish his work, but that improved under a behavior plan built in October 2000. Three other incidents happened about a month apart: bringing pepper spray to school, a fight, and an alleged improper touching. The Hearing Officer found them isolated and unrelated, and not "pervasive and maladaptive." Because no functional analysis assessment was required, no plan based on one was required either. On the independent assessments, the parents did not disagree with the District's pre-expulsion testing or its outcome. They simply wanted more testing, and the District had already offered an assessment plan covering every area they asked for. No evidence showed that District or SELPA assessors were unqualified. The Hearing Officer denied all requests for relief.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied California's "serious behavior problem" definition. Isolated, unrelated incidents that improved under IEP behavior plans did not trigger a Hughes Bill functional analysis assessment. It also shows that a publicly funded independent assessment depended on the parents disagreeing with an actual district assessment, not on a wish for more testing.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 1. Is STUDENT entitled to a functional analysis assessment (Hughes Bill assessment under Ed. Code 56520-56524 and 5 CCR 3052)?
The student's behaviors (not finishing work, bringing pepper spray once, a fight, an alleged touching incident) were isolated, unrelated, and responded to IEP behavior plans. They were not a 'serious behavior problem' under 5 CCR 3001(aa), so no functional analysis assessment was required.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 2. If STUDENT is entitled to a functional analysis assessment, does he also require a behavior intervention plan based on that assessment?
Because no functional analysis assessment was required, no behavior intervention plan based on one was required.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 3. Is STUDENT entitled to an independent educational assessment, including a speech and language assessment, a central auditory processing assessment, a psycho educational assessment, and any other assessments identified by the assessor as appropriate, funded by the District?
The parents did not disagree with the District's pre-expulsion assessment or its result; they wanted more testing, which the District had already offered in its own assessment plan. There was no evidence that District or SELPA assessors were unqualified, so no independent assessment at public expense was owed.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- All of Petitioner's requests for relief were denied.
Key authorities
Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56520-56524 (Hughes Bill); 5 CCR § 3001(aa); 5 CCR § 3052; 34 C.F.R. § 300.346; 34 C.F.R. § 300.519; Cal. Educ. Code § 56507(d)
People named in the decision
- Linda Gaston, program administrator for special education, Anaheim Union High School District
- Barry Escoe, Ph.D., Director of special youth services, Anaheim Union High School District
- Dawn Walsh, SELPA director, Greater Anaheim SELPA
- Linda Robinson, resource teacher, Brookhurst Junior High School
- Miss Exacoustos, young living teacher, Brookhurst Junior High School
- Jim Miller, Behavior Intervention Case Manager / behavior specialist, Anaheim Union High School District
- Steve Koskie, study skills teacher (administered WIAT), Dale Junior High School
- Linda Vas, school psychologist (pre-expulsion assessment), Anaheim Union High School District
- Christopher Russell, advocate for Student
- Cynthia Yount, attorney for District
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Anaheim, California, on January 23 and 24 and February 8 and 9, 2001.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by advocate Christopher Russell. Also present on the Petitioner’s behalf were his parents, MOTHER and FATHER. Respondent Anaheim Union High School District (District) was represented by attorney Cynthia Yount. Also present on behalf of the District were Linda Gaston, program administrator for special education in the District, and Barry Escoe, Ph.D., the Director of special youth services for the district.(Footnote 1) The Greater Anaheim SELPA (SELPA) was represented by Dawn Walsh, the SELPA director, on the first day of hearing.(Footnote 2)
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The parties submitted written closing arguments, the last of which was received by the Hearing Office on March 1, 2001. Thereafter, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
STUDENT was involved in a behavioral incident in December 2000, which caused the District to initiate expulsion proceedings. One of the procedural protections afforded to special education-eligible students under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) is the right to an “expedited” hearing when a parent is challenging a proposed disciplinary change of placement or when a parent disagrees with an IEP team’s manifestation determination. 20 U.S.C. § (k)(6). Based on existing information, the Hearing Office properly placed this matter on the expedited hearing calendar when the due process request initially was received.
On the first day of hearing, the District renewed its motion (an earlier motion was denied) to remove the hearing from expedited hearing calendar. In support of its motion, the District argued that there were no pending disciplinary proceedings against STUDENT, and that STUDENT could return to his previous placement, Dale Jr. High School. Petitioner generally argued that the Hearing should remain expedited because the hearing issues (all related to assessment) stem from the District’s initiation of expulsion proceedings.
The Hearing Officer found the Petitioner’s argument unpersuasive and granted the District’s motion to remove the hearing from the expedited hearing calendar. As stated above, a hearing is expedited when a parent disagrees with a proposed disciplinary change of placement or a manifestation determination. In the present case, the District ceased all disciplinary proceedings, ceased the manifestation review, and informed the parents that STUDENT could return to his previous placement. Moreover, Petitioner stipulated that the manifestation determination had become a “moot point” at the January 16, 2001 IEP meeting: There clearly was no disagreement with the team’s decision to stop all disciplinary proceedings. Because Petitioner did not disagree with the IEP team’s decision to cease the manifestation determination and to permanently cease all disciplinary proceedings related to the incident, no expedited issue remained.
ISSUES(Footnote 3)
1. Is STUDENT entitled to a functional analysis assessment?
2. If STUDENT is entitled to a functional analysis assessment, does he also require a behavior intervention plan based on that assessment?
3. Is STUDENT entitled to an independent educational assessment, including a speech and language assessment, a central auditory processing assessment, a psycho educational assessment, and any other assessments identified by the assessor as appropriate, funded by the District?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT, age 13, has received special education services since the first grade. He is currently eligible for special education services as a child with a specific learning disability (SLD).(Footnote 4) STUDENT is currently enrolled at Dale Junior High School in the Anaheim Union High School District, where he is in the eighth grade.(Footnote 5)
STUDENT attended Dysinger School in the Centralia School District during the 1998-1999 school year (the sixth grade).(Footnote 6) On March 24, 1999, in anticipation of STUDENT move from the Centralia School District to the Anaheim Union High School District, the Anaheim Union High School District held an IEP team meeting.(Footnote 7) The meeting notes indicate that STUDENT’s was “receiving special education services for having a specific learning disability” and notes that he had goals in “written language, spelling and pre-vocational” and that he “will receive resource services for English.” It is also noted that STUDENT qualified for speech and language services (in the area of articulation) but that his parents declined to accept these services. The meeting notes state further, in pertinent part, as follows:
The committee recommended daily progress reports due to the fact that he is missing 45% of his assignments. The committee also recommended that STUDENT stay after school in the tutorial lab class. STUDENT has been diagnosed with ADHD yet is not currently on medication. Specific issues which were also discussed included STUDENT’s improved attendance pattern but poor follow-through with turning in homework. The resource teacher from Brookhurst introduced herself to STUDENT and shared about the junior high school program and various electives that are offered at the junior high school level. The parents will need to contact Brookhurst Junior High if they feel they need more information about STUDENT’s junior high school program. All members of the IEP team agreed with this recommended program. The next annual review date will be 11/4/99 and the next triennial will be 11/04/01.
District’s Exh. 3.
STUDENT entered Brookhurst Junior High School at the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year (seventh grade). At the beginning of the school year, STUDENT’s resource teacher, Linda Robinson, administered several academic tests to STUDENT as a “pre-test” to establish his present levels of academic functioning. Testimony of Robinson. On the Slosson Oral Reading Test, which measures word attack and decoding, STUDENT was at the 7.8 grade level. On the Briggance Test of Reading Comprehension, STUDENT scored at the 5.0 grade level. STUDENT scored at the 3.0 grade level on the Kottmeyer, which measures spelling skills. Ms. Robinson also administered several subtests of the Briggance in the areas of punctuation skills, sentence writing skills and handwriting skills.(Footnote 8)
STUDENT’s annual IEP was held on November 16, 1999. Prior to the meeting, each of STUDENT’s teachers completed progress reports which showed generally that STUDENT was engaging in frequent off-task behavior, not doing his school work, and was inattentive.(Footnote 9) District’s Exh. 8. At the time of the IEP meeting, STUDENT was failing reading, history and young living, receiving D’s in computers and math, and C’s in resource english and physical education. The meeting notes indicate, in pertinent part, as follows:
PARENTS attended the IEP meeting. They confirmed that they received their parent rights and they understood their parent rights. Miss Exacoustos, STUDENT’s young living teacher, attended the IEP meeting. She said he needs often reminders to get back to his work. She has been working with him to stay on task. He is between a D and an F in her class. Effort needs improvement . . . PARENTS would like to drop STUDENT from speech and language services at this time. STUDENT has been diagnosed with ADHD but is currently not on medication. Parents have said that they will look into medication possibilities for STUDENT. AUHSD Board Policy i.e. 2.0 GPA requirement for promotion to high school reviewed. STUDENT does not qualify as SLD at this time based upon results of Centralia testing 10-19-98. Parents were given physician report to be completed. Parent to return from school to qualify for OHI. Team will meet again in mid January 2000 if needed.
District’s Exh. 10. Goals and objectives were developed in the areas of reading, written language and prevocational skills, and a transition plan also was developed. PARENTS signed the IEP. However, MOTHER wrote the following: “Agree with goals, however, I believe that STUDENT has a specific Learning Disability.” Id.
Attempts were made to schedule a follow-up IEP meeting in January and February 2000, but MOTHER was unable to attend because of illness. On February 29, 2000, after a conversation with MOTHER regarding scheduling an IEP, Ms. Robinson wrote a memorandum which states, in pertinent part, as follows:
I indicated to her my continued concerns regarding STUDENT’s poor attention span, and apparent Attention Deficit that we had discussed at STUDENT’s annual review meeting. She stated that she had made an appointment for an evaluation for STUDENT, and would bring us up to date at the next meeting. I also stated that I have continued concerns regarding STUDENT’s inability to remain on task and his poor effort completing class and homework. I again discussed the need for a daily progress report, but MOTHER does not seem eager or willing to begin one.
District’s Exh. 17.
The follow-up IEP team meeting was held on March 16, 2000. The meeting summary indicates that STUDENT would continue in RSP English, that the PARENTS would “follow up” with their doctor regarding STUDENT’s “ADD/ADHD” diagnosis, that STUDENT would “continue DIS counseling with psych and counselor” and that the parents would notify the District of their decision by March 25, 2000, regarding speech and language services for STUDENT. It also indicates that STUDENT would continue Saturday school for english and that daily progress reports were to be continued.
Before the March 16, 2000 IEP meetings, STUDENT’s teachers completed up-to-date progress reports. They generally reported that STUDENT was unwilling to complete homework and class work, and that he exhibited frequent off-task behavior.(Footnote 10) District’s Exhibit 18.
STUDENT transferred from Brookhurst to Walker Junior High in May 1999. He attended Walker for the remainder of the seventh grade.(Footnote 11)
STUDENT began the 2000-2001 school year (eighth grade) at Walker Junior High School. The District convened an IEP meeting on October 19, 2000 (towards the end of the first quarter). The IEP states that the purpose of the meeting was to discuss “concerns regarding STUDENT’s academic achievement and ‘distracted’ off task behaviors.” Jim Miller, a Behavior Intervention Case Manager in the District was in attendance and helped to develop a functional behavior assessment (FBA) and a behavior plan (BIP) related to STUDENT’s general failure to complete his homework and class work.(Footnote 12) The behavioral goal, to “improve grades” is supported by six “strategies,” designed to reach the goal (to replace the behavior of concern). The strategies included a medical appointment for an ADHD evaluation, a daily progress report, a “study skills” class where STUDENT would receive assistance with homework and lessons on “accountability,” the ability to “make up” late work in english and math, “consistent homework assignments,” and “limits set where staff sits with him 3-5 minutes until he starts and continues work . . .” District Exh. 21.
On October 26 or 27, 2000(Footnote 13), STUDENT brought to school and discharged a can of pepper spray in the presence of other students.(Footnote 14) Thereafter, on November 1, 2000, the District convened a “joint IEP/Local School Placement Committee to address the discipline incident.” At the meeting, the IEP team discussed STUDENT’s eligibility and his lack of progress on the earlier BIP (from October 16, 2000). The BIP was revised to include a new behavioral objective: “STUDENT will bring only those items to school that are legal and allowed.” A new strategy was developed where STUDENT’s parents agreed to search his backpack every day to check for inappropriate items. At the Local School Placement Committee portion of the meeting, it was agreed by all members of the IEP team that STUDENT would transfer to Dale Junior High School’s full inclusion program.(Footnote 15)
It was also agreed at the November 1, 2000 IEP meeting that AUHSD would “make a referral to Orange County Mental Health (Mental Health) for counseling services for STUDENT (AB 882).” Subsequently, on November 7, 2000, MOTHER informed the District that she had scheduled a private counseling appointment with a private practitioner. The Mental Health referral was shelved by agreement of the parties. District’s Exh. 26 and Testimony of Koskie.
STUDENT attended Dale Junior High School from the beginning of November until the end of December 2000. At the time of the transfer, STUDENT was receiving “F” grades in history, math and science, “D” grades in english and physical education, a “C” in Band, and no grade in daily living.(Footnote 16) District’s Exh. 25.
On November 30, 2000, STUDENT was involved in a fight at school with another boy in the lunch area.(Footnote 17) District’s Exh. 27.
On December 13, 2000, STUDENT’s study skills teacher, Steve Koskie, administered the Weschler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT) to STUDENT in preparation for his annual IEP on the following day. District’s Exh. 28. STUDENT received the following scores on the WIAT:
Standard Score Age Equivalent Grade Equivalent Basic Reading 72 9.0 3.4 Math Reasoning 61 7.3 1.9 Spelling 53 6.6 1.1 Reading Comprehension 77 9.0 3.6 Numerical Operations 53 8.0 2.5 Listening Comprehension 94 11.9 6.7 Written Expression 79 8.3 3.0
STUDENT’s composite on the WIAT in the area of reading was a standard score of 67, for an age equivalent of 8.9 and a grade equivalent of 3.4. His math composite was a standard score of 52, age equivalent of 7.6, and a grade equivalent of 2.5. His writing composite was a standard score of 52, for an age equivalent of 5.0, and a grade equivalent of K.6. District’s Exh. 28.
STUDENT’s annual IEP team meeting was held on December 14, 2000. Mr. Koskie’s results on the WIAT were briefly discussed. A significant portion of the IEP team meeting was spent discussing STUDENT’s recent fighting incident and other behavioral problems, including “avoidance.” Testimony of Koskie and FATHER. Jim Miller, the behavior specialist, was present, and another behavioral intervention plan was discussed. It was generally agreed that STUDENT’s behavior problems occurred during “lunch and non-direct supervised times” and as such, the team agreed that STUDENT would be monitored during those times by a staff person. District’s Exh. 29 and Testimony of Koskie. Mr. Koskie agreed to observe STUDENT the following day and to pen a “draft” functional behavior assessment for STUDENT. The IEP team meeting eventually ceased due to time constraints. Additionally, the PARENTS indicated that they “had an appointment for a complete medical/neurological” evaluation which would be followed by “medication and/or psychological services.” No new goals and objectives were developed. The IEP team agreed that another meeting would be held to complete STUDENT’s annual IEP. Id.
Four days after the annual IEP team meeting on December 18, 2000, STUDENT was involved in another behavioral incident. According to the consolidated incident report, STUDENT allegedly grabbed the breast of a female student.(Footnote 18) District’s Exh. 30. The District suspended STUDENT for five days, and eventually, extended the suspension for additional five days to January 17, 2001, in order to “allow time to conduct the pre-expulsion assessment . . . .”(Footnote 19)
On December 22, 2000, the District sent the PARENTS written notice of its intent to conduct a pre-expulsion assessment on January 12, 2001. The notice indicates that Linda Vas, a district psychologist, would conduct the assessment.
On December 29, 2000, the Petitioner filed for a due process hearing. In the “brief summary of reasons for request” Petitioner wrote, in pertinent part, as follows:
There are so many procedural violations and errors that we don’t feel the District can be trusted to do a fair and unbiased assessment now. It is clear that the District failed to identify his problems, both academic, and social emotional . . . How can we trust the District to do the testing now when the issues have to do with violations of STUDENT’s civil rights and his right to a FAPE?
District’s Exh. 35.
On January 12, 2001, Linda Vas conducted her pre-expulsion assessment. On January 16, 2001, the pre-expulsion IEP team meeting convened. Ms. Vas’s report was discussed, as were the results of Mr. Koskie’s WIAT which had been administered on December 14, 2000. Although no final agreement was reached, the IEP team agreed that the expulsion proceedings should permanently cease. On January 23, 2001, the District drafted an assessment plan for STUDENT.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Is STUDENT entitled to a functional analysis assessment?
STUDENT asserts that he is entitled to a functional analysis assessment (FAA) pursuant to California Education Code sections 56320 through 56524 and section 3052 of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations (also referred to as a Hughes Bill assessment).(Footnote 20) STUDENT generally argues that his behaviors, including his failure to do and complete his homework, bringing pepper spray to school on one occasion, fighting, and alleged inappropriate touching of a female student, constitute a “serious behavior problem” as that term is defined in California Code of Regulations, section 3001(aa). Therefore, according to the Petitioner, the District should be ordered to conduct an FAA.(Footnote 21)
The law requires, in pertinent part, that a District conduct an FAA whenever a student demonstrates a “serious behavior problem.” A “serious behavior problem” is defined as when a student exhibits behaviors which are self-injurious, assaultive, or cause serious property damage and other severe behavior problems that are “pervasive and maladaptive” for which “instructional/behavioral approaches specified in [the student’s] IEP are found to be ineffective.” 5 CCR §3001 (aa).
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s behaviors did not amount to a “serious behavior problem.” With regard to STUDENT failure to do and complete his homework, the District held an IEP team meeting to address the problem on October 19, 2000, where it conducted a functional behavior assessment and developed a behavior plan. The plan was implemented. Although STUDENT initially struggled in this area, it appears that he began to turn the corner at Dale Junior High School. His grades when he transferred from Walker were very low, but by December 20, 2000, his teachers reported that STUDENT’s grades had significantly improved and that he had improved his homework completion rate.(Footnote 22) Petitioner’s Exh. T. Because the District developed an appropriate behavior plan which was incorporated into STUDENT’s IEP and was effective in reducing STUDENT behavior of not completing homework, this behavior does not fall within the definition of a “serious behavior problem.”
Neither do STUDENT’s other behavioral issues, including the pepper spray incident, fighting or the alleged inappropriate touching, either separately or together constitute a “serious behavior problem” necessitating an FAA. In each instance, the behaviors were isolated and not pervasive and maladaptive. With regard to the pepper spray incident, the District conducted an FBA at an IEP meeting and developed a BIP. Thereafter, STUDENT stopped bringing inappropriate objects to school. As such, this behavior is not a “serious behavior problem” because “instructional/behavioral approaches specified in [the student’s] IEP” after the incident were effective. With regard to STUDENT’s “fighting” behavior, in addition to being isolated, the District sought to conduct an FBA and to develop an appropriate BIP at STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting in December 2000. But because STUDENT was suspended, the District did not have the opportunity to finish the FBA and BIP, nor to implement the same. It may very well be that the behavioral plan, when implemented, will effectively replace the target behavior.(Footnote 23) The alleged groping incident did not constitute a serious behavior problem. Petitioner contends that it did not happen (the inappropriate touching) at all, and as such, there can be no “target behavior” to replace with an FAA. Nonetheless, it was not a pervasive and maladaptive behavior.
Even when examined together, the three behavioral incidents do not constitute a serious behavior problem. There is little commonality in the nature of the three behaviors; one involved bringing inappropriate objects to school, one fighting, and one allegedly involved the inappropriate touching of a female student. Moreover each of the three behaviors were separated in time by approximately one month.
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has not exhibited a serious behavior problem as that term is defined by the California Education Code. As such, the District is not, at this time, required to conduct an FAA.
ISSUE NO. 2: If STUDENT is entitled to a functional analysis assessment, does he also require a behavior intervention plan based on that assessment?
As determined above, STUDENT is not entitled to a functional analysis assessment. As such, STUDENT is also not entitled to a resultant behavior intervention plan.
ISSUE NO. 3 Is STUDENT entitled to an independent educational assessment, including a speech and language assessment, a central auditory processing assessment, a psycho educational assessment, and any other assessments identified by the assessor as appropriate, funded by the District?
Both parties generally agree that STUDENT requires the assessments sought by the Petitioner. In fact, the District offered to assess STUDENT in all of the areas requested by the Petitioner. The District developed an assessment plan (District’s Exh. 39) on January 23, 2001, which outlines evaluation instruments to be administered to STUDENT in the areas of achievement (Woodcock Johnson Revised Psycho-Educational Battery, Test of Written Language 3, Woodcock Diagnostic Reading Battery, Gray Oral Reading Test -- 3rd Edition), cognitive functioning (Wide Range Assessment of Memory and Learning), language and speech (Clinical Evaluation of Language Functions III, Expressive One Word Picture Vocabulary Test, Comprehensive Test of Phonological Processing, SCAN-A) and social emotional (Achenbach Child Behavior Checklist). Additionally, the District assessment plan proposes an audiological assessment as well as a central auditory processing assessment.(Footnote 24) The issue is whether STUDENT is entitled to an “independent educational assessment” from qualified specialists not employed by the District.(Footnote 25)
STUDENT asserts that he is entitled to an independent educational assessment because, at the January 16, 2001 pre-expulsion IEP meeting, STUDENT’s parents, as well as their educational advocates “disagreed” with the District’s assessment and requested, among other things, that the District fund an independent assessment in several areas. STUDENT specifically asserts that the District failed to assess STUDENT “in all areas of suspected disability.”(Footnote 26)
A parent has the right to obtain an independent educational assessment of a child at public expense when the parent disagrees with an assessment done by the local educational agency and that agency fails to show at a due process hearing that its own assessment was appropriate. California Education Code § 56329(b). Therefore, a parent is entitled to a publicly funded private assessment after a school district has conducted its own assessment and the parent disagrees with the results of that public assessment.
In the present case, the “assessment” Petitioner allegedly disagrees with was a pre-expulsion assessment. Both PARENTS testified that they did not necessarily disagree with the assessments that were actually conducted (either the WIAT conducted by Mr. Koskie in December, or Linda Vas’s multi-disciplinary psycho educational evaluation) and used as part of the pre-expulsion assessment process. Moreover neither FATHER or MOTHER, nor their advocates, disagree with the result of the pre-expulsion process (of which the pre-expulsion assessment is a necessary and integral part) which was that the District would cease all pending disciplinary proceedings against STUDENT.(Footnote 27) Because the PARENTS did not disagree with the assessments or the results of the assessment, no independent educational assessment is warranted.
The Hearing Officer also finds that the PARENTS, through their advocates, actually requested further “independent” assessments, including a speech and language evaluation, a central auditory processing assessment, more psycho educational testing and a Hughes bill behavioral assessment. These tests were not requested because the Petitioner disagreed with the pre-expulsion assessment, but rather, because Petitioner felt they were required to develop an appropriate placement, independent of the behavioral incident and resultant expulsion proceedings.(Footnote 28) In any event, the IEP team agreed on the January 16, 2001, that, at the very least, STUDENT required a comprehensive speech and language assessment. And as discussed above, seven days later, by way of its own proposed assessment plan,(Footnote 29) the District agreed that STUDENT now requires all of the other assessments sought by Petitioner, save for the FAA.(Footnote 30) Moreover, there was no persuasive evidence provided at the Hearing that the District and SELPA employees who would conduct the District’s proposed assessments are not qualified to conduct the assessments.
In sum, because the PARENTS did not disagree with either the pre-expulsion assessment or the results, they are not entitled to an “independent” educational assessment. Moreover, Petitioner has provided no compelling reason why someone other than the District or SELPA employees cannot conduct the relevant assessments in an appropriate manner.
CONCLUSION
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that a functional analysis assessment is not warranted for STUDENT at this time. STUDENT has not displayed “serious behavioral problems” as defined by the California Education Code. The District has developed appropriate interventions in the past, which have reduced or eliminated the target behaviors.
Neither is STUDENT entitled to an independent educational assessment. The assessment with which Petitioner asserts the parents “disagreed” was a pre-expulsion assessment. The evidence established that PARENTS (and their advocates) did not “disagree” with STUDENTS's pre-expulsion assessment, rather, their advocates felt that additional assessments were required. The IEP team agreed with regard to the need for a speech and language assessment, and later, the District submitted a comprehensive assessment plan which includes the assessments Petitioner seeks. Petitioner never explained why it is that the assessments all parties agree are now necessary must be conducted by someone outside of the District. There is no evidence that District and SELPA personnel are not qualified to conduct the assessments in question.
ORDER
All Petitioner’s requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: Respondent prevailed on all issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(j).
DATED: March 8, 2001 _____________________________________ Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnote 1: Ms. Gaston was present the first two days of hearing and Dr. Escoe was present during the last two days. Footnote 2: The SELPA was dismissed as a party by the Hearing Officer on the first day of hearing Footnote 3: The issues listed here differ slightly from those noticed by the Petitioner before the hearing. Changes were made for the purposes of clarification. One change of note is the term “functional analysis assessment,” described in Issues Nos. 1 and 2, above. In his statement of issues, Petitioner stated that he was seeking a “functional behavior analysis.” Nonetheless, Petitioner’s advocate clarified at the hearing that he, indeed, is seeking a functional analysis assessment and a resultant behavior intervention plan, as defined by California Education Code sections 56520-56524 and section 3052(b) of the California Code of Regulations (more commonly known as a “Hughes Bill” assessment). Footnote 4: STUDENT was previously eligible and received services as SLD until his last triennial evaluation (November 1998) in his former school district, Centralia Unified School District. The November 1998 IEP indicates that he was eligible as both SLD and as speech and language impaired, although the triennial evaluation found no severe discrepancy between ability and achievement. Footnote 5: STUDENT attended Dale up until December 18, 2000, when he was involved in a behavioral incident at the school. The District initiated disciplinary proceedings. After a pre-expulsion assessment, the District convened a pre-expulsion IEP team meeting on January 16, 2001, where it was agreed that all disciplinary proceedings would stop. Thereafter, although the meeting notes reflect that the team agreed that STUDENT’s “placement should be changed,” STUDENT was free to return to Dale (the District so stipulated on the morning of the first hearing day). STUDENT’s parents chose to keep him out of school for STUDENT’s “safety.” The PARENTS “safety” concerns were not adequately explained at the hearing. It appears the primary reason the PARENTS chose to keep STUDENT out of Dale was animosity towards the administrators who conducted the investigation surrounding the final behavioral incident. Footnote 6: Centralia School District, like the Anaheim Union High School District, is in the Greater Anaheim Special Education Local Plan Area (SELPA). Students who attend school in Centralia School District for elementary school feed into Anaheim Union High School District for junior high and high school. Nevertheless, they are separate districts. The Hearing officer notes that Centralia was not joined as a party to the hearing by the Petitioner and as such, was not represented at the hearing. Footnote 7: Neither of STUDENT’s parents were in attendance, although STUDENT was present. MOTHER signed the IEP on March 30, 1999, six days after the meeting. Footnote 8: On the Briggance subtest which measures handwriting skills, the assessor noted that “STUDENT really struggled with this.” District’s Exh. 4. Footnote 9: Some of the various comments were that STUDENT was “wasting his time” not doing his homework or “focusing enough to do his daily assignments,” that he was “easily distracted,” had “trouble staying on task,” and that he needed “prompts to begin and stay on task.” District’s Exh. 8. Footnote 10: STUDENT’s reading teacher sums up STUDENT’s effort as follows:
STUDENT is a fairly avid reader. His comprehension is close to grade level. Therefore, there is absolutely no reason for STUDENT to be failing except that he chooses not to do the work. The daily progress reports seem to make no difference in his performance. District’s Exh. 18. Footnote 11: It is unclear why STUDENT transferred during May 2000, at the very end of his seventh grade year. Petitioner argues in his closing brief that STUDENT was transferred because he was “being assaulted” by “some other students” while walking home from school. MOTHER testified generally about safety concerns at Brookhurst, and also, that they had moved within the District. In any event, there was no evidence presented at the hearing that STUDENT was transferred because of disciplinary reasons or for the types of behaviors that surfaced the following year. Footnote 12: The IEP indicates that STUDENT was receiving four failing grades at that time. The FBA indicates that the target behavior is “poor academic performance” and that STUDENT is ADHD and that he has a visual processing disorder. The BIP indicates that STUDENT was completing “little to no academic work” which could result in “reduced grades” or “possible retention.” Footnote 13: The exact date is unclear. The consolidated incident report reads October 26, 2000, while the “notice of suspension” indicates that the incident occurred on October 27, 2000. In any event, STUDENT was suspended for two days because of the incident (the notice of suspension indicates STUDENT was given a five-day suspension, but the attendance records indicate STUDENT missed two school days because of the incident). District’s Exhs. 22 and 24. Footnote 14: There was no evidence presented at the Hearing that STUDENT tried to shoot other students with pepper spray. Apparently he discharged the pepper spray to “show” other students. Footnote 15: The District did not initiate expulsion proceedings. Apparently, all IEP team members simply agreed that STUDENT should transfer to another District school, his third junior high school in six months. Footnote 16: At some point after his transfer STUDENT’s program was changed (and his parents agreed) to add “special education support resources for Math.” District’s Exh. 26 Footnote 17: Neither party provided the details of this incident. In any event, it was the primary topic (along with STUDENT’s other behavior issues) at STUDENT’s annual IEP held on December 14, 2000. Footnote 18: According to STUDENT, he was trying to wrestle away something from the girl’s possession. Testimony of FATHER. Footnote 19: The incident occurred the last week of school before the winter holiday period. Footnote 20: It bears repeating that the specific behavioral assessment sought by the Petitioner in the instant case is an FAA pursuant to California State law. Federal law requires, in pertinent part, that an IEP team consider strategies, including “positive behavioral interventions” and supports to address behaviors for a student whose behavior “impedes his or her learning or that of others.” 34 C.F.R. Sec. 300.346. Also, federal law requires that in response to certain disciplinary actions, a District must convene an IEP meeting and to develop a “functional behavioral assessment” plan (an “FBA” plan), or if a student has already had an FBA and has an existing behavioral plan, the IEP team is required to meet and to review the existing plan and to revise it, if necessary. 34 C.F.R. Sec. 300.519. The primary difference between an FAA pursuant to state law and an FBA under federal law is that the former is required when a student has a “serious behavior problem” as defined by State law. In contrast, an FBA is required in relation to certain disciplinary actions and whenever an IEP team determines that a student’s behavior “impedes his or her learning or that of others” – the student is not required to exhibit a “serious behavioral problem.” Footnote 21: STUDENT did not assert at the Hearing, or in his closing brief, that the FAA and the resultant Behavioral Intervention Plan (BIP) that he proposes are required due to STUDENT’s “serious behavior problem” must be developed by a non-district Behavioral Intervention Case Manager (BICM). It was similarly undisputed that Jim Miller, the District BICM, is appropriately qualified to assess in the relevant areas. Footnote 22: Only STUDENT’s Science and Keyboarding teachers reported that STUDENT had “missing assignments.” Incidentally, those were STUDENT’s only below-average (“D”) grades as of December 20, 2000. The Hearing Officer notes that the Keyboarding teacher also attributed STUDENT’s low grade to frequent absences. Footnote 23: STUDENT also argued that because “fighting” is always “assaultive” in nature, that STUDENT has a “serious behavior problem” as defined under California law. First, STUDENT’s “fighting” behavior was not pervasive and maladaptive. Second, under Petitioner’s interpretation of the word “assaultive,” every special education student who engages in fisticuffs would require an expensive, proscriptive and time consuming FAA, even when a more flexible and expeditious FBA and behavior plan, developed under federal law, can be quickly implemented and may be sufficient to replace the target behavior. Moreover, Petitioner has provided no legal authority for such a broad reading of the word “assaultive.” Footnote 24: The Hearing Officer finds that there was no evidence that any of the District’s proposed assessors were not qualified. Footnote 25: Petitioner never identified the “independent” assessors he felt should conduct the IEA. Neither did Petitioner explain why an “independent” assessment was necessary, i.e., why the District could not be “trusted” to conduct the necessary assessments. Footnote 26: Petitioner made multiple assertions both at the hearing and in his closing remarks regarding a multitude of matters. Only those assertions made by Petitioner which are pertinent to the issues at hearing will be discussed. Footnote 27: There was some testimony at the hearing that the IEP team agreed to stop the expulsion proceedings, at least in part, because of concerns about the incident itself, specifically whether STUDENT actually did what he was accused. Regardless, the result of the pre-expulsion IEP team meeting was that all disciplinary actions would stop. Footnote 28: Petitioner’s request for due process, completed before Linda Vas had even begun her portion of the pre-expulsion assessment, articulated the crux of the impending “disagreement:”
There are so many procedural violations and errors that we don’t feel the District can be trusted to do a fair and unbiased assessment now. It is clear that the District failed to identify his problems, both academic, and social emotional . . . How can we trust the District to do the testing now when the issues have to do with violations of STUDENT’s civil rights and his right to a FAPE. Footnote 29: Although not directly at issue in the present hearing, the District’s proposed assessment plan, to which the PARENTS have not provided their consent, appears to be a thorough and appropriate assessment plan designed to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability. Footnote 30: After the cessation of the discipline portion of the meeting, the team proceeded to engage in a “spirited” discussion regarding what to do next for STUDENT, including: (1) STUDENT’s placement, (2) further assessments STUDENT required, (3) goals and objectives, (4) whether STUDENT required an FAA, etc. In sum, the team sought to take the necessary steps to meet STUDENT unique needs and to provide him with some educational benefit.
