California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 4, 2005
Student v. San Ramon Valley Unified School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 2309-04 · Hearing Officer Tracy L. Tibbals
San Ramon Valley Unified offered a FAPE for 2004-2005 after holding an IEP meeting without the parents; claims for in-home program denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
Background: a prior due process case (SN02-02762) was settled on June 4, 2004. The decision itself notes no later history.
Summary
The parents of a 7-year-old boy with autism filed for due process over San Ramon Valley Unified School District's 2004-2005 offer. The District then filed its own case to show the offer was appropriate, and the two cases were combined. The annual IEP meeting took four sessions. When the parents' private provider, Synergistics Interventions, could not come back until September, the District held the last session on August 30, 2004, the day before school started. Neither parent attended. The District offered full inclusion in a first grade class at Alamo School with a one-to-one aide, behavior services, and related services, but no in-home program. The parents kept their son home and paid for an in-home program.
The Hearing Officer found no procedural denial of FAPE. The District had encouraged the parents to attend and had to make an offer before school began. The father admitted he could have come, and the law does not require both parents. The parents had also given substantial input at the earlier sessions. On the substance, the Hearing Officer found that the behavior and social skills goals were based on accurate enough data and could be measured. The in-school behavior program met the student's needs, no in-home program was needed, and the District had planned for his move to new providers. The Hearing Officer denied compensatory education and reimbursement. If the student enrolls at Alamo, the District must complete the independent functional analysis assessment (FAA) and hold an IEP meeting within 45 days.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO dealt with a district that held an IEP meeting without the parents to meet the first-day-of-school deadline. The district had documented its efforts to include them, one parent admitted he could have attended, and the parents had given input at earlier sessions. On those facts, the Hearing Officer held that Shapiro v. Paradise Valley did not apply.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1a. Did the District offer a FAPE for 2004-2005 (procedural): were the parents denied the opportunity to participate when the District held the August 30, 2004 IEP meeting without them?
The District encouraged attendance, had to make an offer before the August 31 first day of school, and the father admitted he could have attended; no serious infringement of parent participation and no denial of FAPE.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 1b. Did the District develop appropriate social skills and behavioral goals and objectives for 2004-2005?
The District's data were sufficiently accurate, the omitted prior goals were covered by the new goals, and isolated differences in benchmarks did not make the goals unmeasurable.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1c. Did the District offer an appropriate in-school behavioral program and services, and was an in-home program required?
In-school behavioral services with a one-to-one aide, behavior analyst, and specialist were designed to meet his needs and reasonably calculated to provide benefit; an in-home program was not required.
- District prevailedTransition
Issue 1d. Did the District fail to develop a transition plan for moving services from the private provider to District providers?
The District addressed his transition needs (same aide, meetings held at Alamo, Milestones' input); no need for a formal transition plan was shown.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. Is the Student entitled to compensatory education for a denial of FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year?
Because the District offered a FAPE, no compensatory education was awarded.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 3. Are the Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs they incurred in providing the Student an in-home program?
Reimbursement was not reached because the District offered a FAPE, and no evidence showed he needed an in-home program.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order that district's offer may be implemented. Student's request for relief denied. To receive District special education, Student must enroll in the general education class at Alamo Elementary School and be available for the placement and services in the August 30, 2004 IEP; the District must remain ready to place him and resume services immediately under that IEP.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. If Student enrolls at Alamo under the August 30, 2004 offer, within 45 calendar days of enrollment the District must arrange completion of the independent FAA, convene an IEP meeting to determine his behavioral needs, develop a BIP, and modify his program and goals in all areas as appropriate.
Key authorities
Rowley; Shapiro v. Paradise Valley Unified School Dist.; W.G. v. Target Range School Dist.; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Doe v. Maher; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Burlington; Lester H. v. Gilhool
People named in the decision
- Karen Heilbronner, assistant director for special programs (District representative), San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Joann Biondi, special programs director; IEP meeting facilitator, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Dr. Shirley Convirs, school psychologist; conducted District FAA and BSP, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Kevin Douglas, special day class teacher, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- George Anich, SELPA program specialist, SELPA
- Angela Conner (also spelled Connor), behavioral analyst, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Cindi Slettvet, behavior specialist, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Vicki Wells, principal of private provider; conducted independent FAA, Synergistics Interventions (SI)
- Kimberly Stokes, principal of private provider, Synergistics Interventions (SI)
- Debbie Wiederecht, occupational therapist
- Tracie Vickers, director of nonpublic agency providing District-funded in-home program, Milestones
- Beverly Palomba, one-to-one aide, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Maxine Younger, representative sent by family to August 30, 2004 IEP meeting
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Tracy L. Tibbals, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, on October 12, 13, 14, 19, 20, and 21, 2004, in Danville, California.
Student/Cross-Respondent STUDENT (hereafter “STUDENT” or “Student”) was represented by attorneys Eileen Matteucci and Roberta Savage. Also present on the student’s behalf were his mother and father, MOTHER and FATHER. Respondent/Cross-Petitioner San Ramon Valley Unified School District (hereafter “District”) was represented at the hearing by attorney Elizabeth Rho-Ng. Also present for the District was assistant director for special programs Karen Heilbronner. For a portion of the hearing, special programs director Joann Biondi was present as the District’s representative.
The parties called as witnesses the Student’s mother and father, Ms. Biondi, school psychologist Dr. Shirley Convirs, special day class (SDC) teacher Kevin Douglas, program specialist George Anich, behavioral analyst Angela Conner, behavior specialist Cindi Slettvet, Synergistics Interventions (SI) principals Vicki Wells and Kimberly Stokes, occupational therapist Debbie Wiederecht, and Milestones director Tracie Vickers.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The parties then argued their respective positions in written briefs. The record was then closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING
1. Did the District offer a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to the Student for the 2004-2005 school year?
2. Is the Student entitled to compensatory education for a denial of FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year?
3. Are the Student’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs they incurred in providing the Student an in-home program?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The Student alleges that the District did not allow his parents to participate in the August 30, 2004 IEP meeting in which his program was developed in the social skills and behavioral area, including the identified services, service provider, and goals and objectives. The Student further contends that for the 2004-2005 school year the District failed to develop appropriate social skills and behavioral goals and objectives and to offer him an appropriate program and services in these areas, including an in-home program. (Footnote 1) The Student also contends that the District did not develop a transition plan for the transfer of services from the former private provider funded by the District to District providers.
The District maintains that it afforded the Student’s parents an opportunity to participate at the August 20, 2004 IEP meeting, developed appropriate goals and objectives, offered appropriate services, and did not offer an in-home program because it was not necessary to meet the Student’s needs.
The Student seeks as remedies compensatory education in the form of additional supports, services, and reimbursement to his parents for costs of private in-home behavioral support services provided to him.
The District contends that neither compensatory education nor reimbursement are warranted, because a FAPE is offered the Student for the 2004-2005 school year.
MOTIONS BEFORE AND DURING HEARING
The Student moved during the telephonic prehearing conference to bifurcate the issues for hearing and to proceed first on the contention that the District had denied him a FAPE by denying his parents participation at the August 30, 2004 IEP meeting. The Student relied on the holding in Shapiro v. Paradise Valley Unified School District, 317 F.3d 1072 (9th Cir. 2003) in support of his motion and averred that the procedural matter could be tried on the written documents already identified by the parties. This Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals case stands for the proposition that a denial of FAPE can be found on procedural grounds, alone, if a parent is denied meaningful participation in the development of the pupil’s IEP. The District opposed the motion on the grounds that it was late, contending that it was brought up on the day before the hearing, because the underlying facts were known to the Student at the time he filed his due process request. The District also argued that this was a consolidated case with substantive issues identified by the District that must also be heard and decided. Counsel for the District, however, had no objection to addressing the procedural issues first. Neither federal or State special education law addresses the issue of bifurcation. Generally, bifurcation is appropriate to prevent prejudice or to be conducive to expedition and judicial economy. The Hearing Officer denied the motion because there was no showing that judicial economies would result from bifurcation of this issue. The District was entitled to present its case in the consolidated hearing, which likely would include many of the same witnesses.
During the hearing, the Student moved for a ruling in his favor that the District denied him a FAPE on procedural grounds for the 2004-2005 school year, after presenting evidence through the testimony of FATHER concerning the circumstances of the parents’ absence from the August 30, 2004 IEP meeting. The Student contended that, under Shapiro, FATHER’s testimony established that substantive issues need not be reached. The Hearing Officer denied the motion, because the only testimony to that point was from the Student’s father, the District had listed witnesses and exhibits concerning the issue of setting the August 30, 2004, IEP meeting, and the District had not had an opportunity to present its evidence as to whether Shapiro applied. The District also had the right to present its issues on this consolidated matter, and the Hearing Officer would need to weigh the evidence to make findings of fact.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a seven-year-old boy who resides in the District with his parents and sibling. STUDENT was diagnosed with autism when he was three years old. He is relatively high functioning but has deficits in social skills and behavior. He requires modification of the curriculum, adult supervision, and one-to-one support to succeed in learning. Large-group activities, transitions, and novel situations present challenges to STUDENT. He has been eligible for special education and related services since the District began providing him preschool services during the 2000-2001 school year. As of the hearing, STUDENT was not attending school, but SI was providing him a home program.
STUDENT enrolled in a District kindergarten special day class (SDC) for the 2001-2002 school year with mainstreaming for 20 percent of the school day. The District also provided an in-home program for academic and behavioral support.
During the 2002-2003 school year, the District placed STUDENT in a kindergarten special day class with 30 percent inclusion in a general education kindergarten accompanied by a one-to-one aide. Although the District offered to continue providing the in-home program, STUDENT’s parents chose to have Milestones, a nonpublic agency (NPA), as the provider of the program, which the District agreed to fund. In December 2002, the Student filed a due process hearing request, STUDENT v. San Ramon Valley Unified School District, SN02-02762, alleging a denial of FAPE and seeking compensatory education (that was not resolved until the parties entered into a settlement agreement in June 2004).
During the 2003-2004 school year, the District offered and provided STUDENT inclusion in a general education first grade class at Rancho Romero School with a one-to-one aide for 80 percent of the school day and an SDC for the balance. The District continued to fund the Milestones in-home program, which provided behavioral and academic support. At the request of STUDENT’s parents in the fall of 2003, District psychologist, Dr. Shirley Convirs, conducted a functional analysis assessment (FAA) to evaluate STUDENT’s inappropriate behaviors in school such as striking himself, striking others, humming during class, not attending, and drawing pictures on his written work. STUDENT’s parents did not accept the results of Dr. Convirs’s FAA or her behavior support plan (BSP) to address these behaviors. They stated that it was not adequate. Mr. & Mrs. PARENTS wanted the District to fund an independent FAA.
On June 4, 2004, the parties resolved the prior due process case. The settlement agreement between the parties resolved all issues through the 2003-2004 extended school year (ESY), except for speech and language and occupational therapy services during the ESY. The agreement further provided for Vicki Wells of SI to conduct an independent FAA with District funding within prescribed limits.
STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting convened on June 8, 2004. The June 4, 2004 settlement agreement indicated that STUDENT’s speech and language and occupational therapy services for the ESY would be discussed at this meeting. The IEP team reviewed STUDENT’s speech and occupational therapy goals. Milestones director Tracie Vickers attended the meeting and presented a report of STUDENT’s progress in the District-funded in-home program. STUDENT’s parents had chosen to terminate Milestones as the NPA provider earlier in June 2004, because the PARENTS believed that Milestones was not meeting STUDENT’s needs. Neither Milestones nor the PARENTS informed the IEP team of this development at the June 8 meeting. The District offered STUDENT an ESY program including a service specific class (SSC), a type of SDC, behavior management services, speech and language therapy, and occupational therapy. Prior to the June 2004 IEP meeting, proposed social skills goals, authored by Dr. Convirs, and a progress report on classroom goals, authored by special education local plan area (SELPA) program specialist George Anich, were provided to the PARENTS, but they were not considered at the meeting because of lack of time. The IEP team agreed to continue the annual meeting to consider STUDENT’s 2004-2005 program. FATHER did not consent to this IEP and signed it “in attendance only.”
After the June IEP meeting, the District also offered STUDENT, as a supplement to the June 4, 2004 settlement of the prior due process case, social skills sessions through Milestones for the ESY at District expense. The PARENTS did not accept any of the District’s 2003-2004 ESY offers for STUDENT, except the speech and language and occupational therapy.
After unsuccessful efforts during numerous communications between FATHER and the District to find mutually available dates in July 2004 to reconvene the meeting, STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting continued on August 16, 2004. SI had been invited to present the independent FAA that had been agreed to as part of the settlement agreement between the PARENTS and the District. Although the District had planned to review the independent FAA during the August 16, 2004 IEP meeting, the principals of SI were not available to attend. The IEP team, however, did receive a draft copy of the FAA at the meeting from STUDENT’s parents. The District IEP team members had questions about the methodology and data included in the SI draft report. The June 4, 2004 settlement agreement specified that the District was entitled to request the underlying data, analysis, and documentation for the FAA. The STUDENT’S counsel offered to obtain the requested information from SI. During this IEP meeting, the team agreed upon occupational therapy and speech goals for STUDENT for the 2004-2005 school year. STUDENT’s parents, however, questioned the accuracy of SELPA program specialist George Anich’s progress report and requested more documentation. They suggested a chart to compare the data and undertook the task of preparing such a comparison chart to present to the IEP team at the next meeting. Mr. and .Mrs. PARENTS also informed the IEP team that for the summer of 2004 STUDENT was doing well with minimal behavioral problems in his private program, which they reported consisted primarily of social activities with an aide. The District later learned that SI was providing STUDENT’s program for the summer.
The annual IEP meeting continued again on August 25, 2004, in a four-hour session. The team reviewed STUDENT’s progress and his academic goals. SI’s principals attended this meeting to discuss and to answer questions about their draft FAA. The SI representatives arrived after the meeting had started. They answered questions for approximately one hour before they announced that the were obligated to leave because of other commitments. The District team members did obtain answers to many of their questions about the FAA. Although Ms. Vicki Wells of SI had observed STUDENT at the end of the 2003-2004 school year in his classroom, she told the IEP team that the final version of the FAA would not be completed by the beginning of the school year because she needed further observation of STUDENT in his 2004-2005 classroom placement. Although the IEP team had gotten together to consider STUDENT’s 2004-2005 program and services in three meetings lasting three or more hours each, the team had not yet gotten to the behavior guidelines, social goals and objectives, and a placement for STUDENT. When the SI principals left the meeting, evening was approaching. The team attempted to find another mutually acceptable date to complete the annual review. The District indicated that the IEP team would need to meet by August 30, 2004, as August 31, 2004, was the first day of school, and the District wanted to present an offer of placement by that date to comply with the law. The PARENTS and their counsel wanted SI to be present for the continuation of the meeting. SI’s representatives, Ms. Wells and Ms. Kimberly Stokes, stated that because of their schedules, they could not participate in an IEP meeting until at least September 8. Additionally, Mr. and Mrs. PARENT both desired to attend. Although FATHER testified that he could have “juggled” his schedule to make the meeting, MOTHER was not able take more time off work on August 30.
Citing the legal deadline to make a placement offer for the 2004-2004 school year before the first day of school on August 31, the District issued a notice and proceeded with the continuation of the IEP meeting on August 30. Neither STUDENT’s parents nor counsel was present. The family did send a representative who attempted to tape-record the proceedings but provided no input. The meeting concluded and a copy of the IEP was provided to the STUDENT’S family representative to take to STUDENT’s parents. The District offered full inclusion in a first grade classroom at Alamo School, STUDENT’s home school, with a one-to-one aide, and continued related services. The PARENTS had requested that STUDENT repeat the first grade in his home school, where his sibling attended. There was no in-home program offered.
The PARENTS responded in writing to the offer later on August 30 asserting that the District had failed to make a timely or appropriate offer and that “we are forced to place him privately in order to address his needs.” STUDENT’s parents did not send STUDENT to Alamo School in September 2004. Although the PARENTS testified that they looked at some private school options, they did not enroll STUDENT in a nonpublic school (NPS). They engaged SI to conduct an in-home program for STUDENT starting in mid-September 2004.
In correspondence and telephonic communication between the parties, the District offered to convene another IEP meeting in September when the PARENTS and SI could attend to consider the placement and services further. The PARENTS did not accept the offers for another IEP meeting, and the District did not notice one.
The Student filed his due process hearing request on September 16, 2004, alleging that the District’s offer for the 2004-2005 school year was not appropriate. The District filed its own request for due process hearing on September 29, 2004, alleging that its offer to the Student for the 2004-2005 school year was appropriate. The two cases were consolidated for hearing on the District’s motion without opposition.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Did the District offer a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to the Student for the 2004-2005 school year?
The Student contends that the August 30, 2004 offer for the 2004-2005 school year was not appropriate, because his parents did not participate in the August 30, 2004 IEP meeting, the offer did not include properly developed behavioral goals and objectives, an appropriate in-school behavioral program, or an in-home program, and no transition plan was developed. The District states that it made reasonable efforts to include the parents in the August 30, 2004 IEP meeting, and the offer would have provided the Student a FAPE.
The District is obligated to provide a FAPE under the provisions of the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A FAPE includes special education and related services that are provided at public expense, under public supervision and direction, and without cost to the parents that meet the standards of the State educational agency, including appropriate education provided in conformity with the student’s IEP as described in 20 U.S.C. section 1401(8).
“Special education” is specially designed instruction without cost to parents that meets the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. “Related services” include transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a student to benefit from special education as defined in the IDEA at 20 U.S.C. section 1401(22). State law provides for similar services as part of designated instruction and services (DIS) under California Education Code section 56363(a) and Title 5, California Code of Regulations section 3001(z).
The standard by which the District’s instruction and services is measured is set forth in the leading United States Supreme Court case of Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, at 198-200. Under this standard, the District’s program must be designed to meet the pupil’s unique needs, reasonably calculated to provide the pupil some educational benefit as a “basic floor of opportunity,” and conform to the pupil’s IEP. The Rowley decision, at 198-201, does not require the District to provide to the student the best education available or to provide instruction that maximizes his abilities. A special education student is entitled to have access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to meet his unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.
The United States Supreme Court in Rowley, at 205, also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Every procedural misstep, however, does not necessarily result in a denial of FAPE. To result in such a denial, the procedural violations must cause serious infringement of the parent’s opportunity to participate on the IEP team or loss of educational opportunity to the pupil. Rowley, at 206-207; W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 , 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992).
Special education law also requires that the student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE), placing the student to the maximum extent appropriate with normally developing peers. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550.
The District bears the burden of proving that its program provided a FAPE to STUDENT. Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District No, 3, 35 F.3d 1396,1398 (9th Cir. 1994).
Procedural considerations
The Student alleges that his parents were denied the opportunity to participate on the IEP team at the August 30, 2004 meeting, which resulted in a denial of FAPE. The District contends that it encouraged STUDENT’s parents to participate in this meeting. The District further argues that it was under a legal obligation to make an offer no later than August 30, 2004, as the first day of school for the 2004-2005 school year was August 31, 2004. (Footnote 2)
Parent involvement in the IEP process is more than a mere formality. It is a vital aspect of the process. The IDEA at 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(1) confers on parents the right “to participate in meetings with respect to the identification, evaluation, and educational placement of the child, and the provision of a free appropriate public education.” The importance of these procedural safeguards “cannot be gainsaid.” Parents are to have a “large measure of participation” at every step. Rowley, at 205-206. The case law and statutory mandate for parental involvement is to ensure that they have a full opportunity to participate in their child’s education. As observed by Chief Justice William Rehnquist in Rowley, at 209: “[P]arents and guardians will not lack ardor in seeking to ensure that handicapped children receive all of the benefits to which they are entitled by the Act.” When convening an IEP meeting, the District “shall take steps to ensure that no less than one of the parents or guardian of the individual with exceptional needs are present at each individualized education program meeting or are afforded the opportunity to participate.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(a). The District further must provide notice of the IEP meeting “early enough to ensure an opportunity to attend,” and schedule the meeting “at an agreed upon time and place.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(b), (c). The District may proceed in the absence of a parent or guardian, if the District “is unable to convince the parent or guardian that he or she should attend,” and the District has documented its efforts to arranged a mutually agreed-upon time and place. Cal. Educ. Code § 56431.5(g). A district, however, may not rely upon “after-the-fact parental involvement” or be excused for lack of parental participation in the IEP process if it defers to the schedules of its own representatives over the parents’ schedules. Shapiro, at 1078.
Development of the 2004-2005 IEP
The District’s offer to STUDENT for the 2004-2005 school year was made at the end of the August 30, 2004 IEP meeting. This was the fourth session of his annual IEP meeting. The previous meeting dates were June 8, 2004, August 16, 2004, and August 25, 2004.
June 8, 2004 IEP meeting
June 8, 2004, was the date scheduled for STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting. STUDENT’s father was present and participated in the meeting. As the parties had reached a settlement of the previous due process case on June 4, their agreement designated the upcoming June 8 meeting to develop the speech and language and occupational therapy services for the 2004 ESY. The team also received a report of STUDENT’s progress toward his goals during the 2003-2004 school year in his in-home program from Ms. Tracie Vickers, director of Milestones, the service provider. She reported that STUDENT met most of his academic and social/behavioral goals. Ms. Vickers pointed out that a number of the in-home goals were also among STUDENT’s classroom goals. The team members had received proposed goals and objectives from the District and agreed to receive revised speech and language and occupational therapy goals from these service providers within a few days. The team determined as a “special factor” that STUDENT required “appropriate strategies, including positive behavioral interventions,” because his “behavior impedes his ... learning or that of others.” The IEP meeting did not finish on that date, and the members agreed to reconvene at a later date.
August 16, 2004 IEP meeting
The first continuation of the IEP meeting was from June 8 to August 16. The District did try to schedule the first continuance on an earlier date (District Exhibit 7). Team member vacations and the STUDENT’S family summer schedule, however, rendered August 16, suggested by FATHER, the first mutually available date. The District’s notice of the August 16 meeting went out on July 23, 2004 (District Exhibit 10). Late on the afternoon of August 12, 2004, FATHER requested by telephone that the meeting be postponed to August 18 as SI representatives would not be able to attend on August 16. Special programs director Joann Biondi replied by letter that the District could not delay any longer with the development of STUDENT’s 2004-2005 placement and program because the start of school was imminent and the District was aware that the Student’s counsel would be engaged in another due process hearing during the following week (District Exhibit 13). Ms. Biondi also stated in this letter that FATHER had offered no alternative date to August 18 -- a date that would not allow all District team members to participate. She also noted that, through counsel, she had learned that the FAA would not be completed until SI conducted observations of STUDENT in his fall placement. Ms. Biondi also wrote that the District would check with FATHER’s schedule, if another IEP meeting was necessary before the start of school. On August 13, 2004, the PARENTS and the District exchanged correspondence by email and facsimile confirming that the IEP meeting would continue on August 16 and noting the anticipated presence of counsel and the intention of both parties to tape record the meeting (District Exhibits 11, 12).
Ms. Biondi testified that the District originally anticipated that an FAA, completed by SI under the terms of their June 4 settlement agreement, would be available for consideration by the August 16 meeting. Although the PARENTS did distribute a copy of SI’s FAA on August 16, it was a “work in progress” rather than a completed assessment and generated questions from District team members during the meeting concerning its methodology, terminology, and data.
The IEP team’s agenda for the August 16, 2004 IEP meeting included a report on STUDENT’s ESY progress, a report on his progress toward the 2003-2004 goals, a behavioral program update from Milestones, the FAA, proposed classroom goals and objectives, and placement and service recommendations. The team heard from the PARENTS that STUDENT’s summer activities went well with few behavioral problems. His program, as described by his parents, was primarily recreational and included swimming lessons and Tae Kwon Do. The team adopted speech and language and occupational therapy goals for the 2004-2005 school year. As the team was unable to complete its agenda and develop a placement for STUDENT, the annual IEP meeting was again continued to August 25, 2004. The participation of SI was a consideration in scheduling the August 25, 2004 continuation date. The District sent notice of the August 25 meeting on August 20, 2004 (District Exhibit 15).
August 25, 2005 meeting
Mr. and Mrs. PARENTS their counsel, and, for a portion of the meeting, the owners of SI were present for the August 25, 2004 IEP meeting. The team adopted academic goals for the 2004-2005 school year at this meeting. After the team had been working over two hours, SI principals Vicki Wells and Kimberly Stokes arrived. They answered questions about their draft FAA for approximately an hour. Ms. Wells and Ms. Stokes then indicated that they had to leave.
As the IEP meeting had been in session for several hours, extending into the early evening, other members of the IEP team also needed to leave or already had left. At this point, District special programs director Joann Biondi, who was the meeting facilitator, proposed a short continuance of the meeting for one or more days, so that the team could finish its agenda and the District could make an offer before school began on Tuesday, August 31, 2004.
Ms. Biondi testified that the PARENTS’ counsel originally said that she could change around her schedule on Monday, August 30, to attend an IEP meeting. Ms. Biondi also stated that the SI representatives took out their calendars but determined that their first available dates to return were in early September. Ms. Biondi observed that the PARENTS said nothing after the SI principals arrived, particularly with regard to a continuation date. Ms. Biondi testified that the discussions focused on August 30, as that was the date first suggested by the PARENTS’ counsel. Ms. Biondi stated that when it was apparent that SI could not participate on August 30, the Student’s counsel would then not agree to adjust her schedule and indicated that the PARENTS would not be there either. Ms. Biondi said that she expressed during the continuance discussion the need to present an offer in writing to the PARENTS by August 30 and the hope that they would participate. (Footnote 3) The continuance to August 30, 2004 was announced at the August 25, 2004 meeting and was noticed on August 26, 2004.
August 30, 2004 meeting
The law provides that a district may proceed to an IEP meeting without the parents if it encourages their attendance and “affords them” the right to proceed with a due process hearing to challenge the resulting offer. Cal. Educ. Code § 56431(g). The District also is under a legal duty to provide to STUDENT’s parents a written offer to have an IEP in effect by the first day of school. 20 U.S.C. 1414 (d)(2)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.342 (a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56344 (b). The August 30, 2004 IEP meeting was not only on the last possible day for the District to comply with the law and present a timely offer, but it was also the fourth time the team had met to consider STUDENT’s 2004-2005 program. On behalf of the District, Ms. Biondi expressed the need to prepare an offer for STUDENT before the first day of school and encouraged the PARENTS to attend on August 25, 2004. She also invited them after August 30, to hold further IEP meetings in September or meet with her to discuss the offer (District Exhibits 22, 26). FATHER testified that he knew he had the right to request an IEP meeting. The evidence indicates that the District invited and encouraged the PARENTS to participate before the August 30 meeting and also invited them to meet again afterwards more than once. Moreover, the PARENTS have shown they also understand how to exercise their right to a due process hearing to challenge a District offer. FATHER testified that he could have arranged his schedule to attend, but chose not to go as MOTHER could not take more time from work, although FATHER did go to the June 8, 2004 IEP without her. The fact that STUDENT’s mother could not leave work on August 30 is unavailing. Not only did FATHER testify that he could have rescheduled his day to attend, there is no requirement in the law that both parents must be included on the IEP team. The Hearing Officer finds that the District complied with Cal. Educ. Code section 56431(g) when it proceeded to the August 30, 2004 IEP meeting after encouraging the parents to attend and did afford the parents the right to proceed with a due process hearing. (Footnote 4)
The August 30, 2004 continuation of STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting proceeded on that date without the PARENTS, their counsel, or SI. However, Ms. Younger, the representative of the STUDENT’S family, attended and tape-recorded the meeting. She did not participate in the discussion and provided no input from the PARENTS. There is no dispute between the parties that all of STUDENT’s academic goals had been agreed to by the August 25, 2004 IEP meeting with parental involvement. The only major topics that the team had left to consider on August 30, 2004, were the social and behavior goals and objectives and services in these areas. In developing behavioral goals and objectives, the District witnesses who were present testified that the team considered input of the District professional staff, and a report with written recommendations from Milestones’ Ms. Vickers, the NPA provider for STUDENT’s in-home program for the prior two school years. At the end of the meeting, the District prepared the written offer and presented it to Ms. Younger, along with a copy of the IEP to take to the PARENTS.
The PARENTS received the August 30, 2004 IEP and offer on that date, and FATHER sent back an immediate communication challenging the timeliness and the appropriateness of the offer (Student Exhibit 80). (Footnote 5)
The PARENTS knew that the social skills and behavioral goals and objectives and services were the only remaining areas of concern for the IEP team on August 30 to complete STUDENT’s 2004-2005 program. One or both of STUDENT’s parents attended the first three meetings. STUDENT’s academic goals had already been approved by the end of the August 25 IEP meeting. FATHER acknowledged that he expected the placement offer to be a repeat of the first grade at Alamo School, as the PARENTS had requested STUDENT’s retention in the first grade at Alamo, their home school, where his sibling is enrolled. Additionally, the August 25, 2004 IEP meeting was at Alamo. FATHER stated that he met the Alamo staff at that time and received a registration packet for STUDENT. The testimony of FATHER and Ms. Biondi demonstrated that the PARENTS customarily asked questions, contributed to team discussions, and freely communicated with the District. The behavioral goals that were reviewed in the absence of STUDENT’s parents on August 30, had been distributed to the PARENTS at the end of the previous school year. The PARENTS made no oral or written comments about these draft goals and objectives which had been distributed almost three months earlier, at any of the three IEP meeting at which they were present. They did not send any input, written or oral, to the District through their representative, Ms. Maxine Younger, who was present on August 30. Ms. Biondi testified that input that did come from the PARENTS, including their comparison chart, was considered by the IEP team and was “very thorough and helpful.”
The PARENTS had the opportunity before August 30, on that date, and afterwards, to provide input on STUDENT’s behavioral goals, objectives, and services as part of developing STUDENT’s IEP for the 2004-2005 school year as members of the IEP team. Furthermore, they had the opportunity to submit input in written or verbal form through their representative on August 30, Ms. Younger. “[A]lthough the formulation of an IEP is ideally to be achieved by consensus among the interested parties at a properly conducted IEP meeting, sometimes such agreement will not be possible...If not, the agency has the duty to formulate the plan to the best of its ability in accordance with information developed at [prior] meetings, but must afford the parents a due process hearing in regard to that plan.” Doe by Gonzales v. Maher, 793 F.2d 1470, 1490 (9th Cir. 1986).
Although the Student contends that the District’s conduct ran afoul of the Shapiro holding, this reliance is misplaced. The PARENTS had substantial input into their son’s 2004-2005 program. Moreover, FATHER expressly testified that he could have been present on August 30. Unlike the facts in Shapiro, at least one parent chose not to attend a critical IEP meeting on the last possible day to complete the development of their son’s program.
Even though the parents stated in advance that they would not attend, particularly if SI was not present, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was constrained to go forward with the IEP meeting no later than August 30, 2004, to complete the remaining elements of STUDENT’s 2004-2005 program, and prepare a timely offer. (Footnote 6) Additionally, there is no convincing evidence that the District had a reasonable expectation that SI would have significant information to share with the team concerning STUDENT’s goals and objectives. Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds, as the District reasonably went forward on August 30, 2004, in the absence of the Student’s parents, there was no serious infringement of the parents’ opportunity for participation on the IEP team, and no loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year on procedural grounds.
Substantive considerations
As indicated above, the legal authorities in Rowley and the federal and State statutes, discussed above, require the following analysis for substantive issues:
1. Is the district’s program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
2. Is the program reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit?
3. Does the program as implemented conform to his IEP?
4. Does the program provide a FAPE in the least restrictive environment?
The Student contends that the District substantively denied him a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year by not developing appropriate social skills and behavioral goals and objectives, offering an appropriate program and services in this area, including an in-home ABA program, and providing a transition plan. The District contends that the August 30, 2004 offer was sufficient to provide STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year.
Student’s unique needs
A review of STUDENT’s needs must precede a determination whether the District’s August 30, 2004 offer provides him a FAPE. STUDENT is eligible for special education support and services under the category of autism. To succeed academically during the 2003-2004 school year, the parties agree that he required substantial modification to participate in the first grade curriculum. Because of language processing deficits that frequently lead to distraction or frustration, STUDENT has difficulty attending in large groups. His optimal working environment is a group of no more than five students or alone. He requires constant adult supervision and one-to-one support throughout the school day. Mr. Kevin Douglas, STUDENT’s special day class teacher during the last half of the 2003-2004 school year, described STUDENT’s needs to include prompts to stay on task, help to keep focus in group activities, specialized instruction in all subject areas, and time in the day for time out to “re-group.” As to the latter, Mr. Douglas said that STUDENT needs playground time, a quiet room, or some other provision when he acts out in class. STUDENT does display self-stimulating behaviors such as hitting himself on the head. Mr. Douglas observed that STUDENT needs behavioral redirection, because, particularly when academic activities are stressful or frustrating, STUDENT will hit himself, his peers, or cry out. District witnesses as well as the PARENTS stressed attention to STUDENT’s behavior as a major concern. Because novel situations and transitions are challenging to him, he also needs assistance with transitions. Accordingly, the parties concur and the Hearing Officer finds that for STUDENT to learn, he requires a placement and services that provide close supervision, assistance with transitions, behavior redirection, and modification of the academic curriculum.
The District’s offer
For the 2004-2005 school year, the District offered STUDENT placement in a general education first grade classroom at Alamo, his home school, with one-to-one paraeducator support. Five percent of his program offer provides for work on his goals and objectives during related services. These include speech and language, three times a week for thirty minutes each session; resource specialist support, three times a week for thirty minutes each session; psychologist services consisting of consultation with teacher and paraeducator once a week for thirty minutes, and social skills training once a week for thirty minutes; behavior management for four hours per month broken out in forty-five minute consultation sessions and training per week, and fifteen minutes of direct service per week. As the areas of this offer in dispute are the appropriateness of the in-school behavioral goals and objectives and services, and whether the offer should have included an in-home program and a transition plan, the analysis of the offer will address these components only.
Designed to meet needs
Behavioral goals and objectives
The Student challenges the appropriateness of social skills and behavioral goals and objectives adopted at the August 30, 2004 IEP meeting. He contends that underlying data, considered by the IEP team before adopting the goals and objectives, were inaccurate or show regression in skill levels, no data were collected on some of his previous goals and objectives, and 11 goals for the 2003-2004 school year without substantial progress reported were omitted for 2004-2005. He also alleges that the 2004-2005 goals and objectives are not measurable, lack skill baselines, and conflict with each other in some instances.
Data collection
The Student claims the chart prepared by District behavioral specialist Cindi Slettvet inaccurately represented the data collected concerning STUDENT’s targeted behaviors. For example, he states that for January 2004, Ms. Slettvet indicated on the chart that he hit himself seventeen times but the data show eighteen times, that he hit peers two times as opposed to three times in the data, that he engaged in drawing nineteen times rather than the twenty times in the data, and he yelled out six times instead of ten times in the data. As for Ms. Slettvet’s chart for May 2004, the Student claims he is shown to have hit himself six times, whereas the data reflect eight times. The Student avers that this shows Ms. Slettvet is not skilled in analyzing data. Although the Student also attempts to discredit Ms. Slettvet because she was not aware that STUDENT had struck his aide, Ms. Palomba, with his head in March 2004, requiring her to seek medical attention, this aggressive act appears to be an isolated incident contrary to the trend in STUDENT’s behaviors during this time, and this incident did not occur when Ms. Slettvet was in the classroom. Ms Slettvet, however, testified that she had worked with STUDENT since the 2002-2003 school year as part of the behavioral team. She described how she worked with STUDENT’s teachers and aide and regularly observed STUDENT, consulted with District staff including the school psychologists and behavioral analysts, and monitored STUDENT’s behavior logs. Ms. Sletvett has been with the District for four years in her current position. She previously worked with children diagnosed on the autism spectrum, including as a discrete trial training (DTT) therapist, a position that demanded detailed reporting of behavior, as an employee of both public and private providers. Ms. Slevett persuasively testified that STUDENT’s targeted behaviors improved markedly during the period from January to May 2004. Although some discrepancies between the data and Ms. Slevett’s compilation may appear in the record, the Hearing Officer finds this to have little weight, because her chart substantially reflects evidence of how STUDENT’s progress toward these goals. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP team had sufficiently accurate data to develop goals and objectives and a program for STUDENT in the social skills and behavioral areas.
The Student’s contention that he regressed during the 2003-2004 school year is based on the data collected by his aide, Ms. Palomba, and his SDC teacher, Kevin Douglas (Student Exhibit 85). To support his claim of regression in skill level, the Student argues that he was separated from class activities for longer intervals in June 2004 than in January 2004. He points to an average time in group activities in January of 13.3 minutes per opportunity compared to 7.13 minutes in June. The Hearing Officer finds little significance of this data to the development of goals and a program for the 2004-2005 school year, as it merely underscores the consensus between the parties that STUDENT’s behavior interfers with his learning. STUDENT’s classroom observers universally reported that his behavior was improving. As STUDENT’s needs include one-to one adult supervision and constant prompting and working at the computer is a favored activity, separation from the group in the classroom does not necessarily suggest that STUDENT is not able to access the curriculum independently and progress toward his goals.
The student also asserts that his one-to-one aide Beverly Palomba did not take accurate data according to the classroom observations of Ms. Vicki Wells. He asserts that on two separate days all behavioral incidents Ms. Wells witnessed did not appear in Ms. Palomba’s daily communication log. It is clear from the record that Ms. Wells conducted only limited observations late in the 2003-2004 school year. In contrast, Ms. Palomba’s information collected every school day was to be a summary for STUDENT’s parents. District psychologist Dr. Shirley Convirs, who worked with and trained Ms. Palomba, stated that STUDENT’s aide was not to record data, but rather to prepare a narrative communication log to keep Mr. and Mrs. PARENT generally aware of classroom activities, and that detailed data collection would impede Ms. Palomba’s role as STUDENT’s one-to-one aide. Ms. Palomba was but one source of information for Dr. Convirs and the IEP team to consider in the formulation of STUDENT’s goals and objectives. The record contains no contemporaneous challenges from the PARENTS regarding the content of Ms. Palomba’s logs. These reports went home daily for parent feedback to the classroom staff. FATHER had an opportunity to observe STUDENT in his general education setting first hand and could have commented in Ms. Palomba’s logs if he had concerns. He testified that he regularly spent time in the classroom as a volunteer assistant. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Palomba’s logs accomplished their intended purpose to provide information to STUDENT’s parents.
Goals and objectives selected for the 2004-2005 school year
The Student argues that a review of the 2004-2005 goals (District Exhibit 20) along with the 2003-2004 goals (District Exhibit 31) and the progress report on the 2003-2004 goals (District Exhibit 16) supports his argument that the goals and objectives adopted on August 30, 2004, are inappropriate. He contends that he did not meet any of his goals during the 2003-2004 school year except for one in the SDC setting, and that 11 of the 2003-2004 goals were dropped for the current school year even though he showed progress on only one of these goals beyond the first benchmark. He further points to 13 specific 2004-2005 goals and states that they have benchmarks with conflicting performance or prompt levels.
An analysis of the progress report on the 2003-2004 goals (District Exhibit 16), however, shows that STUDENT was advancing slowly during the past school year, although individual goals may not have been met. For example, the goal for STUDENT to raise his hand for a turn was not met, but he was reported to have accomplished a “partial” pass with prompts. His behavior toward the goal for modeling appropriate peer play was “improving,” and the goal for initiating play with a peer was a “partial passed.” Although 11 specific goals, such as “Sit quietly during circle time,” “Stay on task and complete seatwork independently,” and “Line upappropriately” were not carried over to 2004-2005, these skills are encompassed within the adopted goals. The 2004-2005 goals include classroom behavior goals, such as “STUDENT will reduce the amount of time he is non-compliant,” and “STUDENT will increase the amount of time he complies with non-preferred activity.” Dr. Convirs acknowledged that the social skills and behavioral goals for the 2004-2005 school year did not include all of the goals from the previous year that had not been met. She explained that all of the previous goals were not included in a process of shifting from the SDC class to the general education setting and adjusting the level of the goals. Dr. Convirs said that she could have “come up with 50 to 100 social goals” and the IEP team could have developed many more. She stated that the adopted goals reflected her efforts to prioritize STUDENT’s goals as he moves to a full inclusion program. The Hearing Officer finds that the adopted social skills and behavioral goals reflect STUDENT’s needs to keep working on specific tasks and comprehensively include the skills targeted in the omitted goals.
Measurable goals and objectives
The Student also alleges that the adopted social skills and behavioral goals and objectives are not measurable as they have conflicting benchmarks or prompt levels. The goals, according to Dr. Convirs, were based on present levels information and were measurable by data collection concerning STUDENT’s targeted behaviors. Dr. Convirs testified that some of the 2004-2005 goals “overlapped.’ Dr. Convirs said that the goals were not inappropriate or inconsistent because of differences between some of them. She cited as an example her goal targeting hitting behaviors with a frequency goal of zero compared to the goal drafted by Mr. Anich and Mr. Douglas that proposed that STUDENT’s aggression would reduce in occurrences to only one incident per month. Although the IEP team may want to harmonize the benchmarks in some of the objectives, the Hearing Officer finds Dr. Convirs’s testimony persuasive that isolated discrepancies in benchmarks or prompts do not render the adopted goals and objectives unmeasurable.
Dr. Convirs, program specialist George Anich, and District behaviorist Angela Connor worked on the August 30, 2004 IEP team to provide input that led to the approval of behavior goals and services for STUDENT. The team also incorporated the six written recommendations from Milestones director Tracie Vickers. (Footnote 7) The social skills and behavioral goals adopted on August 30, 2004, such as interaction with peers, decreasing hitting, tantruming, non-compliance, self-talk, and inappropriate drawing, and increasing the use of words, self-regulating behaviors, reading social stories, working quietly, and following directions, covered STUDENT’s targeted behaviors to allow him to function in the classroom and access his curriculum. The Hearing Officer finds that these social skills and behavioral goals were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs as of August 30, 2004.
In-school behavioral program
The in-school program designed for STUDENT included the District behavioral analyst Angela Conner and the behavioral specialist Cindi Slettvet working directly with STUDENT, his teacher, and one-to-one aide. Ms. Conner convincingly testified that she and Ms. Slettvet could meet STUDENT’s needs in the social and behavioral realms so that he could address his academic program. Ms. Conner stated that controlling STUDENT’s behavior so that he can progress in the classroom is more effectively worked on at school, where developed skills can be generalized and applied directly to the classroom setting. Citing recognized authorities and her own experience, Ms. Connor indicated that the effectiveness of an in-home program diminishes after the pupil attains the age of six years. STUDENT turned seven years of age in August 2004. Supporting and preparing STUDENT in his academic program with “priming” and “rehearsal,” two skills that Ms. Wells advocated as part of an in-home program, can be done in the school, according to Ms. Connor. Ms. Vickers, an experienced behaviorist who worked with STUDENT and his aide for two years, testified that she had observed STUDENT both in school and at home. Her recommendations followed consultation with District staff, observations of STUDENT, and review of his behavior logs. Ms. Vikers stated specifically that if her recommendations were carried out, STUDENT’s needs would be met effectively in the school setting.
The August 30, 2004 IEP team considered the observations of Dr. Convirs, Mr. Anich, and Ms. Vickers, who all testified to substantial training and experience in their respective fields and observations of STUDENT over a period of years. Dr. Convirs, whose assigned schools include Alamo, stated that she was professionally acquainted with the general education teacher in whose class STUDENT would be enrolled. Dr. Convirs indicated that the Alamo staff were capable and could deliver the offered 2004-2005 behavioral program to STUDENT. The Hearing Officer concludes that the District witnesses, who had known and observed STUDENT, both in the home and school settings, were convincing that they were able to address STUDENT’s needs. The District IEP team members also had the anecdotal reports from Mr. and MOTHER at the August 16 meeting that STUDENT’s negative behaviors were minimal during the summer as further input to consider in formulating goals, objectives, and a program. The team had Dr. Convirs’ FAA and BIP to work with while awaiting the completion of Ms. Wells’ FAA during the coming school year. The Hearing Officer finds that the social skills and behavioral services goals and objectives and the services included in the District’s offer were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs as of August 30, 2004, with a structured, supervised classroom environment with behavioral support. An in-home program was not required.
Transition plan
Although the Student identified the failure to offer STUDENT a transition plan as an issue for the 2004-2005 school year, this subject was not addressed in his closing argument. FATHER testified that the District did not have a transition plan for the transfer of services from the private providers to the District providers. Ms. Vickers, director of the private provider Milestones, served on the June 8, 2004 IEP team and prepared a written progress report for the August 30, 2004 team. The report included specific recommendations for STUDENT’s 2004-2005 program. Ms. Vickers testified that she regularly conferred about STUDENT with District staff, observed him both in the home and school settings, and reviewed his behavior logs. Even though the District’s proposed placement for STUDENT was at Alamo, a different school from that of the previous year, the District planned to implement the program with the same one-to-one aide, Ms. Beverly Palomba, who had worked successfully with STUDENT at Rancho Romero. Moreover, the August 25 and 30 IEP meetings were at Alamo to allow that school’s staff to become acquainted with STUDENT and his needs. As to a transition from Milestones to SI, FATHER testified that he had made no request that the two providers communicate with each other. The PARENTS also testified that STUDENT had no difficulties changing to his new NPA provider. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s transitional needs had been provided for by the District and that there was no need established in the record for a formal transition plan for the 2004-2005 school year.
Reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit
The evidence shows that the social skills and behavioral goals and objectives and services developed in the August 30, 2004 offer are aimed at STUDENT’s targeted behaviors. The Student argues that progress on his 2003-2004 goals was de minimis. As the goals for 2004-2005 are similar, the Student contends that they are not reasonably calculated to provide an educational benefit. The record shows, however, significant progress for STUDENT in his social and behavioral skills even if he was unable to meet most of his goals during the prior year. As part of her recommendation to the August 30, 2004 IEP team, Ms. Vickers testified that due to the uncertainties of how STUDENT will function in his new environment at Alamo, the IEP team should reconvene to modify his program within a matter of weeks. The August 30, 2004 offer includes a provision that the IEP team will meet again no later than November 30 to review STUDENT’s adjustment to his new school environment. To ease STUDENT’s transition to a new site and classroom, Ms. Palomba, the one-to-one aide with whom STUDENT had successfully worked during the previous year, is slated to work with him at Alamo School. The adopted goals and objectives continued to work on STUDENT’s social skills and behavioral areas where progress had been shown in the 2003-2004 school year. The Hearing Officer finds that, based on the information available on August 30, 2004, the social skills and behavioral goals and objectives and services were reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit.
Conforms to the IEP
As the offer for the 2004-2005 school year was prospective and not accepted, this issue need not be reached.
Least restrictive environment
The parties did not raise the element of the least restrictive environment (LRE) as an issue. The Hearing Officer will not address this issue.
ISSUE NO. 2: Is the Student entitled to compensatory education for a denial of FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year?
Compensatory education is an equitable remedy to replace lost educational services. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for-hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the Student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d. 1489, 1496-1497 (9th Cir. 1994). The denial of FAPE gives a student an entitlement to “appropriate” relief in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359,369, 105 S.Ct. 1996 (1985). The Burlington principle extend to compensatory education as a form of relief to students who have been denied a FAPE. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District, 916 F.2d 865 (3d. Cir. 1990). As the Hearing Officer found that the District has offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year, he is not entitled to an award of compensatory education.
ISSUE NO. 3: Are the Student’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs they incurred in providing the Student and in-home program?
The issue of reimbursement need not be considered as the Hearing Officer found that the District has offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year. Moreover, the is no showing in the evidence that STUDENT needs an in-home program.
ORDER
(1) Student’s request for relief is denied.
(2) If Student wants special education placement and services from the District, he must enroll in the general education class at Alamo Elementary School and make himself available for services and placement as offered in the August 30, 2004 IEP.
(3) The District shall remain ready to resume services and place Student immediately in accordance with his August 30, 2004 IEP.
(4) If the Student does enroll at Alamo pursuant to the August 30, 2004 offer, the District shall arrange for completion of the independent FAA, convene an IEP meeting to discuss and determine the Student’s behavioral needs, develop a BIP, and modify his program and goals in all areas as appropriate within forty-five calendar days of his enrollment.
PREVAILING PARTY ON THE ISSUE HEARD
Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute:
The District prevailed on all of the issues heard.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
DATED: January 4, 2005 _______________________ Tracy L. Tibbals, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The Student also alleged that the District did not adequately assess him for the 2004-2005 school year in his original statement of issues contained in his September 16, 2004 due process request. The issue of assessment, however, was not discussed by the Student in the prehearing conference on October 11, 2004, and was not raised in the evidence, or in the closing arguments. Consequently, it will not be reached in this Decision
2. In his closing brief, the Student also raised a procedural issue with respect to the District’s September 27, 2004 letter to his parents (District Exhibit 26) that allegedly contained an improper change to the August 30, 2004 offer. As this matter was not identified before the hearing and the letter appears to include confidential settlement negotiations, the Hearing Officer will not address the allegation.
3. The Hearing Officer also listened to a tape recording of the portion of the August 25, 2004 IEP meeting concerning the continuance issue (Joint Exhibit á) that corroborated Ms. Biondi’s testimony on these issues.
4. The PARENTS’ counsel also requested that SI be present. The Hearing Officer finds that the District properly proceeded without SI. Ms. Wells testified that she could not have completed the FAA by August 30, as she needed to conduct classroom observations of STUDENT during the upcoming school year. Although SI did provide an in-home summer program for STUDENT, Ms. Biondi testified that SI provided no information on this summer program, which the District understood from the PARENTS to be primarily recreational. Ms. Biondi also stated that SI would not be looked to for discussion of STUDENT’s educational needs, as this was not SI’s area of specialization. SI’s principals described their area to be behavior modification utilizing “integrative touch and movement,” a methodology that they have developed combining behavioral intervention and massage techniques. District behaviorist Angela Connor testified that the District did not state that it needed any information from SI to make an offer for the 2004-2005 school year, but had invited SI to the next meeting in a desire to reach “consensus for the offer.”
5. FATHER testified that, although his letter included “timeliness” as part of his challenge to the offer, he did not have an objection to its receipt on August 30, 2004.
6. In his closing argument, the Student discounts the imperative to present an offer by the start of the school year on the ground that the District expressed that STUDENT had an agreed-to stay put placement set forth in the June 4, 2004 settlement agreement (District Exhibit 2) if a dispute arose. The parents, however, testified that they were not interested in this placement. Moreover, District behaviorist Angela Connor testified that the PARENTS’ counsel at the August 25 IEP meeting said that if no offer were “on the table” by the first day of school, the parents would “do what they have to do.”
7. Ms. Vickers recommended (1) a resource specialist (RSP) to provide academic support to STUDENT and regular consultation to the classroom teacher, one-to-one aide, and other IEP team members; (2) a one-to-one aide to work with STUDENT to focus on academic, communication, and social goals; (3) social skills goals developed by the IEP team; (4) social skills consultation and support to STUDENT’s parents and teacher by the school psychologist and behavior analyst; (5) speech pathologist implementation of goals emphasizing language and communication; (6) academic priming after school if the first five recommendations cannot be met.
