California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 2, 2004

Student v. El Rancho Unified School District (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 2312-03 · Hearing Officer Jodi L. Clary

El Rancho Unified must reimburse private speech therapy and some in-home ABA costs; Hearing Officer finds two denials of FAPE.

Split decision: student prevailed on 4 of 8 issues (2 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The decision notes that the prior SEHO decision in SN02-00860 and SN03-00045 (Hearing Officer Laba) had been appealed to District Court. No subsequent history of this decision is stated.

Summary

El Rancho Unified School District and the parents of a six-year-old boy with autism filed cases that were heard together. The parents had pulled him from the District's Maizeland preschool program in 2002. They then paid for an in-home ABA program from the Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE) and private speech therapy from Jane Haddad of Kidstreet.

The District argued that he was a parentally placed private school student. Hearing Officer Jodi L. Clary disagreed, finding that the parents had always wanted a public school education. Because the District missed his March 25, 2003 annual IEP meeting, he was denied a FAPE until the May 16, 2003 meeting. The May offer of the Maizeland autism-focused preschool class was a FAPE. The Hearing Officer also found that he did not need ABA, because discrete trial training was not helping him generalize skills or use spontaneous language.

The August 25, 2003 kindergarten offer was also not a FAPE. The general education kindergarten part was appropriate. But the severe disorders of language class had nonverbal classmates, and the speech therapy built into it could not teach pragmatic language or generalization. A claim about the parents' lack of direct contact with the aide failed. The District must reimburse LIFE costs from March 25 to May 16, 2003. It must also reimburse Ms. Haddad's therapy for that period and from August 25, 2003 through the decision date.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO treated a district's argument that a child was a parentally placed private school student when the parents had consistently sought a public placement. It also shows that a hearing officer could order reimbursement for one private service, speech therapy, while denying it for another, ABA, that the student was found not to need.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1. Did the District deny Student a FAPE from March 25, 2003, through May 16, 2003, by failing to hold an annual IEP team meeting?

    Student was not a parentally placed private school child because the parents consistently sought a public placement; the District's failure to hold the annual IEP meeting by March 25, 2003 denied FAPE until May 16, 2003.

  2. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2a. Did the District deny Student a FAPE from May 16, 2003 through August 25, 2003 by offering an inappropriate placement at Maizeland Elementary School?

    The offer of the Maizeland preschool autism-focused special day class with speech, OT and integration was designed to meet Student's needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.

  3. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2b. Did the District deny Student a FAPE from May 16, 2003 through August 25, 2003 by failing to offer a one-on-one ABA program?

    Student did not require an ABA program; discrete trial techniques did not generalize and hindered spontaneous, pragmatic language.

  4. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 3a. Did the District deny Student a FAPE from August 25, 2003, through the end of the 2003-2004 school year and ESY by offering an inappropriate placement at Pio Pico Elementary and Selby Grove Elementary schools and offering inappropriate speech and language services?

    The general education kindergarten component was appropriate, but the severe disorders of language class with nonverbal peers and speech therapy embedded in it could not address generalization and pragmatics, so the offer was not a FAPE.

  5. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3b. Did the District deny Student a FAPE from August 25, 2003, through the end of the 2003-2004 school year and ESY by failing to offer a one-on-one ABA program?

    A one-on-one ABA program was not appropriate to meet Student's needs; he needed to move away from discrete trial training.

  6. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 3c. Did the District deny Student a FAPE from August 25, 2003 through the end of the 2003-2004 school year and ESY by committing a procedural violation of the IDEA and related law (refusing to let parents communicate directly with the one-on-one aide)?

    Parents showed no legal right to direct access to the aide; communication through the teacher meant no loss of educational opportunity or serious infringement of parent participation.

  7. Issue 4a. If the District failed to provide Student a FAPE, are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for the in-home ABA program provided by LIFE?

    Reimbursement ordered for LIFE services from March 25 to May 16, 2003, when the program provided some benefit; denied after that because the May offer was a FAPE and ABA was not appropriate for kindergarten.

  8. Issue 4b. If the District failed to provide Student a FAPE, are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for private speech and language therapy provided by Jane Haddad?

    Ms. Haddad's therapy was appropriate and beneficial; reimbursement ordered for March 25 to May 16, 2003 and from August 25, 2003 through the decision date, but not for May 16 to August 25, 2003.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Within thirty days of receiving invoices, District shall reimburse parents for the costs of LIFE in-home ABA services between March 25, 2003 and May 16, 2003.
  • Reimbursement. Within thirty days of receiving invoices, District shall reimburse parents for the costs of speech and language services by Jane Haddad from March 25, 2003 through May 16, 2003, and from August 25, 2003 through the date of the decision (July 2, 2004).

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23; School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ.; 34 C.F.R. § 300.343; 34 C.F.R. §§ 300.450-300.454

People named in the decision

  • Barbara Moore-Brown, Director of special and alternative education, El Rancho Unified School District
  • Jane Haddad, Private speech-language pathologist, Kidstreet Institute
  • Thea Starr Lincoln, Special education teacher; academic assessor, El Rancho Unified School District (Mary Meller Elementary School)
  • Blake Arakaki, Case and workshop supervisor, private ABA provider, Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE)
  • Jacquelyn (Jackie) Leigh, School psychologist, Whittier Area Cooperative Special Education Program (SELPA)
  • Susan (Sue) Sherard, Inclusion specialist; academic assessor, El Rancho Unified School District
  • Elaine Sun, Behavioral specialist and school psychologist intern, Whittier Area Cooperative Special Education Program (SELPA)
  • Blanca Gloria Ramirez, General education kindergarten teacher, El Rancho Unified School District (Selby Grove Elementary)
  • Mirna Cruz, Instructional aide (one-on-one), El Rancho Unified School District (Selby Grove Elementary)
  • April Coleman, Severe disorders of language (SDL) teacher and speech-language pathologist, El Rancho Unified School District (Pio Pico Elementary)
  • Melanie Lenington, Licensed clinical psychologist; private developmental assessor, Private
  • Julie Kammerer, Private inclusion specialist assessor, Private
  • Kristi Yap, Private speech-language pathologist assessor, Private
  • Stella Sandoval, Presented progress report at IEP meeting, Plaza De La Raza
  • Bob Turner, Adaptive physical education teacher; APE assessor, El Rancho Unified School District
  • Jennifer Shubin, Speech-language pathologist; speech-language assessor, El Rancho Unified School District
  • Connie Kim, Occupational therapist; OT assessor, Gallagher Pediatric Therapy
  • Centeno, District nurse; health assessor, El Rancho Unified School District
  • Sherianne Laba, Hearing Officer in prior SEHO case, Special Education Hearing Office
  • Gallagher Pediatric, Occupational therapy provider, Private agency
  • Kidstreet Institute, Private speech and OT provider, Private agency
  • Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE), Private in-home ABA provider, Private agency
  • Pasadena Child Development Association, Private assessment provider, Private agency

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Jodi L. Clary, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in, Whittier, California on April 27, 28, 29 and 30, 2004. Student was represented at hearing by attorney Bruce Bothwell and his parents. El Rancho Unified School District (District) was represented at hearing by attorney Darin W. Barber. Also present on the District’s behalf was Barbara Moore-Brown, director of special and alternative education.

Student called the following witnesses: Jane Haddad, speech and language pathologist, Kidstreet Institute; Thea Starr Lincoln, District special education teacher at Mary Meller Elementary School; Blake Arakaki, case and workshop supervisor, Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE); and Student’s father.

The District called the following witnesses: Jacquelyn Leigh, Whittier Area Cooperative Special Education Program (WACSEP or SELPA) psychologist; Susan Sherard, District inclusion specialist; Elaine Sun, behavioral specialist and school psychologist intern for WACSEP; Blanca Gloria Ramirez, District general education kindergarten teacher; Mirna Cruz, District instructional aide; Dr. Barbara Moore-Brown, District director of special and alternative education; April Coleman, District severe disorders of language (SDL) teacher and speech language pathologist; and Student’s parents.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Thereafter, the Hearing Office received written closing arguments from both parties, and the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING (Footnote 1)

1. Did the District deny Student a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from March 25, 2003, through May 16, 2003, by failing to hold an annual IEP team meeting?

2. Did the District deny Student a FAPE from May 16, 2003 through August 25, 2003 by:

a. offering an inappropriate placement at Maizeland Elementary School; and b. failing to offer a one-on-one ABA program.

3. Did the District deny Student a FAPE from August 25, 2003, through the end of the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year (ESY) by:

a. offering an inappropriate placement at Pio Pico Elementary and Selby Grove Elementary schools and offering inappropriate and speech and language services; b. failing to offer a one-on-one ABA program; and c. committing a procedural violation of the IDEA and related law?

4. If the District failed to provide Student a FAPE, are Student’s parents entitled to reimbursement for:

a. the in-home ABA program provided by LIFE; and b. private speech and language therapy provided by Jane Haddad?

CONTENTIONS

Regarding issue number one, the Student contends that the District had an obligation to hold his annual IEP team meeting by March 25, 2003, and that the failure to do so was a denial of FAPE. The District contends that the Student was a “parentally-placed private school student” such that it has no obligation to hold an annual IEP team meeting.

Regarding issue number two, the Student contends that the offer presented at the May 16, 2003 IEP team meeting was not an offer of FAPE because the offer was for the Maizeland preschool program which was inappropriate for the following reasons: it was not age appropriate because at age five he would be one of the oldest children in the class; he had already mastered a kindergarten curriculum so that a pre-school curriculum was not academically appropriate; and, the other children in the class were not appropriate peers because they did not possess his cognitive or academic ability, thus the placement would not meet his socialization needs. The Student further contends that the May 16, 2003 offer would not provide him educational benefit because he had not progressed when placed at Maizeland previously. (Footnote 2) Lastly, the Student contends that the May 16, 2003 offer was not an offer of FAPE because it did not include an intensive one-on-one ABA program. The District again contends that because Student was a parentally placed private school student, the District did not have an obligation to make an offer of FAPE. The District contends that the May 16, 2003, IEP team meeting was to address the upcoming 2003-2004 school year only, and therefore it had no obligation to provide a FAPE until such time as Student’s parents demonstrated an interest in returning Student to public school, which was the start of the 2003-2004 school year. The District also argues that the May 16, 2003 offer was consistent with Hearing Officer Laba’s decision of April 24, 2004, in the matter of Student v. El Rancho USD, SN02-00860 and SN03-00045 that the Maizeland program would provide Student with a FAPE. Lastly, the District contends that the May 16, 2003, offer should be considered an interim placement and is appropriate because it is in conformity with the offer contained in Student’s March 2002 IEP, determined by Hearing Officer Laba to be appropriate.

Regarding issue number three, the Student contends that the District denied him a FAPE by offering two full-time placements that would provide duplicative instruction on curricula that he had mostly mastered and would overburden him. The Student further contends that the offer of speech and language services is inappropriate because it was embedded in the SDL class, the teacher was not qualified to teach autistic children, and the class cannot teach him pragmatic language. The Student also contends that the offer is inappropriate because it does not include a one-on-one intensive ABA program. Lastly, the Student contends that the District committed a procedural violation that resulted in a denial of FAPE by its refusal to allow his parents to communicate with the District one-on-one aide such that their rights to participate in the formulation of Student’s educational program were seriously infringed. The District contends that the placement and one-on-one speech and language therapy addressed Student’s unique needs and was an offer of FAPE. The District contends that Student does not require an ABA program. The District contends that Student’s parents participation in the formulation of Student’s educational program was not seriously infringed.

As to issue four, the Student contends that because he has been denied a FAPE, his parents are entitled to be reimbursed for the in-home Lovaas ABA program and for private speech and language therapy provided by Jane Haddad of the Kidstreet Institute. The District contends that it offered a FAPE where it was obligated to do so, and that Student’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for privately obtained services.

BACKGROUND FACTS

Student is a six-year-old student who was found eligible for special education services in March 2001 under the category of autism. (Footnote 3) Student is currently attending a general education kindergarten at his home school of Selby Grove Elementary School, in the El Rancho Unified School District. Student receives behavioral support, inclusion support, and occupational therapy (OT) paid for by the District pursuant to an informal interim agreement between the District and Student’s parents. (Footnote 4) Student participates approximately twenty hours per week in an in-home Applied Behavioral Analysis (ABA) program conducted by LIFE which is paid for by his parents. In addition, Student receives direct speech and language therapy two hours per week provided by Jane Haddad of Kidstreet which is also paid for by his parents.

Student’s initial individualized education program (IEP) team meetings took place on March 21, and 29, 2001. As a result of the meetings, Student entered a special education preschool class with an autism emphasis at Sorenson Elementary School within the District. Student attended Sorenson for 20 hours per week. He also received two thirty-minute sessions of individual speech and language therapy per week (at Sorenson), five hours of after-school behavior intervention per week, and two fifty-minute sessions of occupational therapy per week through Gallagher Pediatric. Student’s parents wanted Student to also receive fifteen hours of home-based discrete trial training per week (DTT), and requested that the District increase the amount of speech and language therapy provided per week. The dispute between the parties evolved into a due process proceeding. At the July 13, 2001 mediation the parties reached a partial agreement in which Student would continue at Sorenson. However, at the start of the 2001-2002 school year Student was placed at Maizeland Child Development Center (Maizeland). The parents then alleged that Dr. Moore-Brown unlawfully changed their son’s placement to Maizeland and another due process hearing resulted. The parties have a rather lengthy legal history. (Footnote 5)

On January 9, 2002, Student’s parents enrolled Student in a Headstart Program at Magnolia School. Each school day they would pick Student up from Maizeland at 10:30 a.m. and transport him to Magnolia. In February 2002 Mother spent several days observing Student in his program at Maizeland. On March 4, 2002, Student’s parents elected to remove him from the District’s program. Student’s parents felt that Student was not progressing at Maizeland, that the curriculum did not challenge Student, and that Student was regressing in his behavior and self-help skills. The parent’s distrust of Dr. Moore-Brown was also a factor in their decision to remove Student from Maizeland. Student’s annual IEP team meetings were held on March 14 and 25, 2002. The offer presented by the District during the March IEP team meetings was as follows: placement at a preschool SDC with an autism focus (“severely handicapped” class) five days per week for four hours per day at Maizeland; speech and language one-on-one or small group four times per week for thirty minutes a session at Maizeland; occupational therapy (OT) one-on-one two times per week for fifty minutes per session at the OT clinic; reimbursement for transportation for OT; assistive technology (AT) of visual teaching strategies; and extended school year (ESY) services. Student’s parents rejected the offer of placement at Maizeland because of their distrust of Dr. Moore-Brown and their opinion that Student’s behavior had deteriorated while attending Maizeland. The parents requested that the District fund an in-home ABA program through LIFE of 25-30 hours per week. They also requested that the District fund private speech and language therapy. The District declined to fund the private program.

Student’s parents obtained a private developmental assessment from Melanie Lenington, licensed clinical psychologist. Dr. Lenington tested Student on May 28, and 30, 2002, and on June 4, and 19, 2002. Dr. Lenington found that Student was a “child challenged by social interactions, vulnerability, and sensitivity with a backdrop of core receptive and expressive language difficulties.” She recommended that Student have intensive one-on-one therapy by an exceedingly well-trained person in learning theory, such as Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA), for a minimum of forty hours per week at home. She indicated that Student might be ready to start integration with typically developing peers within six months.

Jane Haddad of The Kidstreet Institute conducted a speech and language evaluation at the request of Student’s parents. She tested Student on June 27, 2002, and July 19, 2002. Ms. Haddad found that Student suffered from a severe receptive/expressive language disorder with significant auditory processing difficulties. She recommended Student undergo speech and language therapy three times per week for an hour each session, OT, and an auditory processing re-education program. Mr. and Mother also obtained evaluations from Lovaas Institute For Early Intervention (LIFE), Julie Kammerer (inclusion specialist), and Kristi Yap (speech and language pathologist). Each of these examiners also found that Student suffered from a severe receptive/expressive language deficit.

In November 2002, Student began an in-home ABA program with LIFE for 35-40 hours of discrete trial training (DTT) per week. He continued to receive private speech and language therapy from Jane Haddad and OT from Gallagher Pediatric. (Footnote 6)

The due process hearing for consolidated cases SN02-00860 and SN03-00045 was held on January 21-24, 28-29, and March 17, 2003. The issue in the hearing, as relevant here, was whether the District provided Student a FAPE from March 2001 through March 2003, and, in particular, whether the offer contained in the March 2002 IEPs was an offer of FAPE. In her decision issued April 17, 2003, Hearing Officer Sherianne Laba found that the placement at Maizeland offered to Student during the March 2002 IEP team meetings was designed to meet Student’s unique needs and to provide him with educational benefit, and thus, met the requirements for an offer of FAPE. Hearing Officer Laba found that Student had been offered a FAPE from March 2001, through his next IEP, which would be in March 2003.

By letter dated April 24, 2003, the attorney who represented the parents and Student at hearing requested that Student’s annual IEP be convened “within the statutory time frame” and noted that the annual IEP meeting was due in March. An IEP team meeting was convened on May 16, 2003.

The IEP drafted on May 16, 2003, noted Student’s needs as follows: to improve his play, social, cognitive and pre-academic skills; to improve his classroom behavior, behavior organization, fine motor skills, and motor planning; and to improve his severe deficits in receptive and expressive language and pragmatics.

At the meeting, a recommendation was made that the District implement the offer presented at the March 2002 IEP team meetings, which had been found to be an offer of FAPE by Hearing Officer Laba. The IEP team notes indicated that the parents brought four reports for consideration by the IEP team. Those reports were: a speech and language report from Kidstreet; the Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention: Workshop Consultation Report and Proposed IEP Goals and Objectives report; the Pasadena Child Development Association Social Emotional Developmental Intervention Initial Program Assessment Report; and an OT Progress Report from Kidstreet. As “chair” of the meeting, Dr. Moore-Brown stated that the IEP team could not address the reports at the current meeting since they did not receive the reports with enough notice. Dr. Moore-Brown indicated that the reports would be considered at the next IEP team meeting. However, Mr. Arakaki from LIFE and Stella Sandoval from Plaza De La Raza were allowed to present reports on Student’s progress. Student’s parents also presented information verbally regarding Student’s progress.

The IEP indicated that the placement and services offered were to start on May 19, 2003, and that, during the meeting, the team would also address the 2003-2004 school year. The IEP team drafted an assessment plan to obtain current assessments. The IEP team meeting notes indicated that the team would meet again in June to review the assessments and discuss the upcoming school year.

After the new information was presented at the May 16, 2003 IEP team meeting, Dr. Moore-Brown presented the District’s offer as being “that of March 2002, with integration, OT, and Speech and Language Services, a behavior assessment [sic]. It is recommended that the IEP of March 2002 be implemented and that an assessment plan be prepared to assess Student’s current skills.” The District offered the goals and objectives from March 2002. Student was to attend the Maizeland pre-school severely handicapped (SH) special day class. Student’s parents did not accept the offer and Studentremained in his private program.

As of May 16, 2003, Student’s private program consisted of his attending the Magnolia Headstart program in the mornings, and participation in programs given by the YMCA, such as basketball, throughout the day. He also received two to three hours of one-on-one speech and language therapy per week from Jane Haddad, and received an in-home ABA program provided by LIFE which consisted of between twenty and thirty hours of services per week. All of Student’s educational services were paid for by his parents. (Footnote 7)

On June 2nd and 9th, 2003, SELPA school psychologist Jackie Leigh conducted an “objective observation” of Student’s Headstart class at Magnolia school. Student had been placed at the Headstart program by his parents and attended with typically developing children. He was provided with “supplementary aids and supports” and his LIFE aide accompanied him to class. The aide used DTT prompts, redirection, positive reinforcement, and restatement of questions to help Student respond to the teacher’s instructions. The aide used these techniques to facilitate interaction with the other children and staff as well. While Ms. Leigh noted that Student benefited from the placement and from the support of his aide, she also observed that Student was very dependent upon scripted prompts from familiar staff. She noted that Student was quiet until prompted with specific questions by an adult, and then Student would provide a practiced response. Ms. Leigh reported that Student had learned many rote responses and scripts but did not generalize. Student showed significantly greater incidents of spontaneous speech and interactions with peers in preferred situations with natural cues.

Ms. Leigh cited an incident where Student was observed in a chase game with other children that occurred spontaneously. Student was acting the part of the “monster” and was chasing the other students. Staff interrupted the game and directed Student to a group to play “duck, duck, goose.” Student needed to be prompted to participate in the game. Ms. Leigh also noted Student was very attached to his instructional aide, who provided him with over one-half of his instruction via prompts, instead of the teacher. Ms. Leigh was concerned that continued DTT training and scripts of more and longer conversations would result in suppressing spontaneous communication. She stated that if the other party did not provide the proper scripted request, Student was unable to respond. Ms. Leigh felt that Student needed to generalize his skills in a school setting. Ms. Leigh recommended that the IEP team consider that Student spend a portion of his day in a typical kindergarten and participate in a “K” level severe disorders of language (SDL) class that utilized a variety of instructional methods for autistic children.

An adaptive physical education (APE) evaluation was conducted by Bob Turner, District APE teacher, on June 3, 2003. Mr. Turner found Student to possess age-appropriate gross motor skills and that Student did not qualify for APE.

Jennifer Shubin, District speech language pathologist (SLP) conducted a speech/language assessment evaluation on June 10th and 12th, 2003. Ms. Shubin could not conduct standardized testing because Student did not understand the instructions. Ms. Shubin opined that Student needed to develop pragmatic functional language. She recommended an SDL class and speech and language therapy in a public school setting with mainstreaming part of the day.

Connie Kim of Gallagher Pediatric Therapy conducted an OT evaluation on June 12, 2003, at the request of the District. The report noted many areas of strengths and a few areas of concern that led the OT to recommend continuing therapy at the frequency of one time per week for fifty-minute sessions, and collaborative consultation. The parent’s OT Closing Report from Kidstreet, dated April 1, 2003, recommended OT services twice per week to address the same concerns but the length of sessions was not addressed.

A health assessment conducted on June 30, 2003, by district nurse Centeno contained no information relevant to this decision. The District behavioral specialist, Elaine Sun, had requested an opportunity to observe Student in his home LIFE program. She requested six hours of observation. Negotiations lasted several weeks regarding the type and length of observation that Ms. Sun would be granted. The dispute resulted in a delay in the observation until August 25, 2003.

Thea Starr Lincoln (District special education teacher) and Sue Sherard (District inclusion specialist) conducted academic testing on July 2nd and 9th, 2003. Ms. Lincoln and Ms. Sherard concluded that Student was highly distractible and had great difficulty following instructions that were not presented in a familiar format. Student relied heavily on adult cues to act. Ms. Lincoln and Ms. Sherard recommended that Student be placed in a small, highly structured environment with ample opportunity to interact with typical peers, both socially and academically.

The record showed that the parties had some difficulty scheduling the next IEP team meeting to discuss the findings of the assessments. An IEP team meeting was eventually scheduled for August 25, 2003. Ms. Sun issued her assessment of Student’s Home Program also on August 25, 2003. Ms. Sun felt that Student’s aide, drilled Student on rote phrases and demanded he perform rote actions that were not functional or pragmatic. According to Ms. Sun she observed no maladaptive behaviors that would require a behavior plan. Ms. Sun found that Student’s needs were for spontaneous language, play skills, and social interactions. Ms. Sun recommended that Student be placed in a natural school environment to learn to generalize. Ms. Sun reiterated that she was limited to a two-hour observation when she felt a six-hour observation would be more appropriate.

The IEP team met on August 25, 2003. The assessment reports obtained by the District were discussed. The assessors explained their findings and were in agreement that Student suffered a severe expressive and receptive language delay and pragmatics difficulties. The assessors indicated their opinions that Student was not generalizing what he had learned in the LIFE program. The assessors expressed their concerns that Student was too dependent on the DTT prompting and that he should move away from that format. A representative from LIFE was present and explained the LIFE program and Student’s progress. Mr. Arakaki stated that he wanted to move Student away from DTT because it did not generalize well into a classroom. Mr. Arakaki also stated that he had been unable to work on generalization because the Family home was being remodeled over the past three months.

The IEP document sets forth the following District offer of placement and services: a special day class of SDL five days per week for three hours and twenty minutes per day; OT once per week for fifty minutes at the OT clinic and OT consultation to parents and staff once per month for fifty minutes at the general and special education classrooms; full-inclusion general education kindergarten five days per week for three hours and twenty minutes per day; the services of a behavior specialist starting twice per week for six weeks, then once a week at the general and special education classes, with a liaison with the home program once per month for an hour; the services of an inclusion specialist monthly for four hours per month in the general education class; and individual speech and language therapy five days per week for thirty minutes per day. The IEP notes reflect a discussion about the locations of the SDL class as being at Pio Pico School and the general education kindergarten at Selby Grove Elementary. The speech and language therapy was to take place during the SDL class. Student was to have a one-on-one aide in both settings. The District would provide transportation between the two classes.

The IEP team proposed that goals be written in the following areas: class participation (2 goals); socialization (3); academic participation; sensory processing and proprioceptive and vestibular functioning; self regulation; academics; receptive language; expressive language (2); and pragmatics (2). Mr. Arakaki from LIFE presented his report of August 22, 2003, which contained proposed goals. The report contained three goals for behavior involving Student’s refraining from jumping on the furniture, refraining from running away from an adult for a preferred item, and refraining from engaging in protest behaviors. The report contained three language goals, four play and socialization goals, three academic and classroom-preparation goals, and two self-help goals. The IEP notes do not reflect a discussion of the LIFE report and proposed goals. However, Mr. Arakaki is reported as agreeing with the District members of the team that Student’s greatest need was for generalization into natural environments. Mr. Arakaki was reported to have agreed with moving Student away from DTT.

Student’s parents did not consent to the program or services. Student continued to receive the private ABA program from LIFE and private speech and language services. Student had aged out of the Headstart program. His parents placed him in YMCA activities and programs and other community-based programs.

The District filed a request for a due process hearing on October 27, 2003. The Student filed a request for due process on October 29, 2003, and requested that the two matters be consolidated. The two cases were consolidated on November 4, 2003.

Student entered the general education kindergarten class at his home school of Selby Grove on November 14, 2003, pursuant to what the parties’ referred to at hearing as an “informal interim agreement between the District and Student’s parents.” He continued to receive private ABA services from LIFE, and private speech and language therapy from Jane Haddad.

Student’s parents requested that they be allowed to communicate with Student’s aide at Selby Grove, Mirna Cruz. According to District witnesses, District policy does not allow aides to provide the parents with information about the student’s daily progress, other than the most basic information, such as “he did fine.” Aides were instructed to refer the parents to the teacher or inclusion specialist for any other information. Student’s parents assert that collaboration between Student’s home and school programs is essential. In November 2003, the District began holding monthly collaboration meetings, on Tuesdays. Mr. Arakaki was unable to attend several of the meetings because they were held on Tuesdays. Ms. Cruz did not attend the meetings. Also in November the parties began using a communication log that was to be carried by Student in his backpack from home to school and from school to home. The log was to contain notes from the District staff to the parents and from the parents to staff regarding Student’s progress. Ms. Cruz did not make entries in the log.

On December 20, 2003, Ms. Haddad issued a progress report. Ms. Haddad reported that Student had made excellent progress. She reported that her therapy was focused on receptive and expressive language, speech production, pragmatics and functional language. She recommended that Student remain with her in therapy and that the behavior therapist and classroom teacher should address and monitor social and pragmatic goals.

On January 26th and 30th, 2004, Mr. Arakaki observed Student in his general education placement. He reported that he witnessed heavy prompting from Student’s aide and that Student showed little attention to the teacher. Mr. Arakaki’s recommendations surrounded the fading of the aide, the fading of prompting, and the transfer of educational instruction from the aide to the teacher.

Student continued to attend the regular education kindergarten class at Selby Grove pursuant to the parties’ informal interim agreement and continued to receive other services as set forth in the first paragraph of the Background Facts above. This matter proceeded to hearing on April 27, 2004.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

1. Did the District fail to offer Student a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from March 25, 2003, through May 16, 2003, by failing to hold an annual IEP team meeting?

The Student contends that the District was obligated to hold an annual IEP team meeting by March 25, 2004, and the failure to hold such a meeting resulted in a denial of FAPE. The District contends that Student was a “parentally placed private school student” who was not entitled to special education services under Title 34, Code of Federal Regulations, section 300.454. The District therefore contends it had no obligation to hold an IEP team meeting.

Under State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C.§ 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1418. In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that for a student to receive a FAPE, the student’s IEP must be designed to meet the unique needs of the student and be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit.

Each public educational agency is responsible for initiating and conducting meetings for the purpose of developing, reviewing, and revising the IEP of a child with a disability. 34 C.F.R. § 300.343(a). In addition, the public agency shall ensure that the IEP team: “(1) [r]eviews the child’s IEP periodically, but not less than annually to determine whether the annual goals for the child are being achieved; and (2) [r]evises the IEP as appropriate to address (i) [a]ny lack of expected progress toward the annual goals…, (ii) [t]he results of any reevaluation…(iii) [i]nformation about the child provided to, or by, the parents.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.343(c).

No private school child with a disability has an individual right to receive some or all of the special education and related services that the child would receive if enrolled in a public school. 34 C.F.R. § 300.454. “Private school children with disabilities” is defined as children with disabilities enrolled by their parents in private schools or facilities, other than children placed in or referred to private schools by a public agency as a means to provide special education. 34 C.F.R. § 300.450. The IDEA requires that the school districts continue child find obligations toward private school children, and provide special education related services under a “services plan.” 34 C.F.R. §§ 300.451 and 300.452.

The District argues that Student’s parents placed him in private school because private school was their preference for his education and he therefore was a parentally placed private school student who was not entitled to a FAPE. However, the record reflects that the parents were consistently interested in a public school placement for Student. As early as June 2001, the parties discussed mainstreaming possibilities for Student for the 2001-2002 school year along with funding of ABA services by the District. The parents had long requested a DTT program or funding for a private DTT program, but they had also accepted District services and placements. Integration for part of Student’s day was discussed during the March 2002 IEPs.

Student’s parents removed him from Maizeland on March 4, 2002, because they felt Maizeland was not an appropriate placement for Student. The parents testified that they believed Student was bored at Maizeland because the curriculum did not challenge him, which caused behavioral incidents. They felt Student did not progress at Maizeland. The parents requested that the District fund an in-home ABA program, private speech and language therapy, and provide mainstreaming with typical peers. When the District refused, the parents placed Student in a private ABA program and provided private speech therapy. (Footnote 8)

Finally, Father stated at the May 16, 2003 IEP team meeting that the family’s goal was to have Student attend a typical kindergarten by age five. There was no persuasive evidence that the District had ever been given information to the contrary. The Hearing Officer, having considered all of the above, finds that the parents had demonstrated to the District their consistent desire that Student receive a public school education. Therefore, Student does not fit the definition of a “private school child with a disability” under the meaning of 34 C.F.R. § 300.454.

Thus, under State and federal law, the District was obligated to convene an annual IEP team meeting to review Student’s progress, his IEP, and his placement, and revisions accordingly by March 25, 2003. The District’s failure to convene an annual IEP team meeting by that date and make an offer of placement and services resulted in a denial of FAPE. (Footnote 9)

The Hearing Officer finds that the District denied Student a FAPE from March 25, 2003, until an annual IEP team meeting was eventually convened on May 16, 2003.

This matter was heard before Jodi L. Clary, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in, Whittier, California on April 27, 28, 29 and 30, 2004. Student was represented at hearing by attorney Bruce Bothwell and his parents. El Rancho Unified School District (District) was represented at hearing by attorney Darin W. Barber. Also present on the District’s behalf was Barbara Moore-Brown, director of special and alternative education.

Student called the following witnesses: Jane Haddad, speech and language pathologist, Kidstreet Institute; Thea Starr Lincoln, District special education teacher at Mary Meller Elementary School; Blake Arakaki, case and workshop supervisor, Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE); and Student’s father.

The District called the following witnesses: Jacquelyn Leigh, Whittier Area Cooperative Special Education Program (WACSEP or SELPA) psychologist; Susan Sherard, District inclusion specialist; Elaine Sun, behavioral specialist and school psychologist intern for WACSEP; Blanca Gloria Ramirez, District general education kindergarten teacher; Mirna Cruz, District instructional aide; Dr. Barbara Moore-Brown, District director of special and alternative education; April Coleman, District severe disorders of language (SDL) teacher and speech language pathologist; and Student’s parents.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Thereafter, the Hearing Office received written closing arguments from both parties, and the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING (Footnote 1)

1. Did the District deny Student a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from March 25, 2003, through May 16, 2003, by failing to hold an annual IEP team meeting?

2. Did the District deny Student a FAPE from May 16, 2003 through August 25, 2003 by:

a. offering an inappropriate placement at Maizeland Elementary School; and b. failing to offer a one-on-one ABA program.

3. Did the District deny Student a FAPE from August 25, 2003, through the end of the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year (ESY) by:

a. offering an inappropriate placement at Pio Pico Elementary and Selby Grove Elementary schools and offering inappropriate and speech and language services; b. failing to offer a one-on-one ABA program; and c. committing a procedural violation of the IDEA and related law?

4. If the District failed to provide Student a FAPE, are Student’s parents entitled to reimbursement for:

a. the in-home ABA program provided by LIFE; and b. private speech and language therapy provided by Jane Haddad?

CONTENTIONS

Regarding issue number one, the Student contends that the District had an obligation to hold his annual IEP team meeting by March 25, 2003, and that the failure to do so was a denial of FAPE. The District contends that the Student was a “parentally-placed private school student” such that it has no obligation to hold an annual IEP team meeting.

Regarding issue number two, the Student contends that the offer presented at the May 16, 2003 IEP team meeting was not an offer of FAPE because the offer was for the Maizeland preschool program which was inappropriate for the following reasons: it was not age appropriate because at age five he would be one of the oldest children in the class; he had already mastered a kindergarten curriculum so that a pre-school curriculum was not academically appropriate; and, the other children in the class were not appropriate peers because they did not possess his cognitive or academic ability, thus the placement would not meet his socialization needs. The Student further contends that the May 16, 2003 offer would not provide him educational benefit because he had not progressed when placed at Maizeland previously. (Footnote 2) Lastly, the Student contends that the May 16, 2003 offer was not an offer of FAPE because it did not include an intensive one-on-one ABA program. The District again contends that because Student was a parentally placed private school student, the District did not have an obligation to make an offer of FAPE. The District contends that the May 16, 2003, IEP team meeting was to address the upcoming 2003-2004 school year only, and therefore it had no obligation to provide a FAPE until such time as Student’s parents demonstrated an interest in returning Student to public school, which was the start of the 2003-2004 school year. The District also argues that the May 16, 2003 offer was consistent with Hearing Officer Laba’s decision of April 24, 2004, in the matter of Student v. El Rancho USD, SN02-00860 and SN03-00045 that the Maizeland program would provide Student with a FAPE. Lastly, the District contends that the May 16, 2003, offer should be considered an interim placement and is appropriate because it is in conformity with the offer contained in Student’s March 2002 IEP, determined by Hearing Officer Laba to be appropriate.

Regarding issue number three, the Student contends that the District denied him a FAPE by offering two full-time placements that would provide duplicative instruction on curricula that he had mostly mastered and would overburden him. The Student further contends that the offer of speech and language services is inappropriate because it was embedded in the SDL class, the teacher was not qualified to teach autistic children, and the class cannot teach him pragmatic language. The Student also contends that the offer is inappropriate because it does not include a one-on-one intensive ABA program. Lastly, the Student contends that the District committed a procedural violation that resulted in a denial of FAPE by its refusal to allow his parents to communicate with the District one-on-one aide such that their rights to participate in the formulation of Student’s educational program were seriously infringed. The District contends that the placement and one-on-one speech and language therapy addressed Student’s unique needs and was an offer of FAPE. The District contends that Student does not require an ABA program. The District contends that Student’s parents participation in the formulation of Student’s educational program was not seriously infringed.

As to issue four, the Student contends that because he has been denied a FAPE, his parents are entitled to be reimbursed for the in-home Lovaas ABA program and for private speech and language therapy provided by Jane Haddad of the Kidstreet Institute. The District contends that it offered a FAPE where it was obligated to do so, and that Student’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for privately obtained services.

BACKGROUND FACTS

Student is a six-year-old student who was found eligible for special education services in March 2001 under the category of autism. (Footnote 3) Student is currently attending a general education kindergarten at his home school of Selby Grove Elementary School, in the El Rancho Unified School District. Student receives behavioral support, inclusion support, and occupational therapy (OT) paid for by the District pursuant to an informal interim agreement between the District and Student’s parents. (Footnote 4) Student participates approximately twenty hours per week in an in-home Applied Behavioral Analysis (ABA) program conducted by LIFE which is paid for by his parents. In addition, Student receives direct speech and language therapy two hours per week provided by Jane Haddad of Kidstreet which is also paid for by his parents.

Student’s initial individualized education program (IEP) team meetings took place on March 21, and 29, 2001. As a result of the meetings, Student entered a special education preschool class with an autism emphasis at Sorenson Elementary School within the District. Student attended Sorenson for 20 hours per week. He also received two thirty-minute sessions of individual speech and language therapy per week (at Sorenson), five hours of after-school behavior intervention per week, and two fifty-minute sessions of occupational therapy per week through Gallagher Pediatric. Student’s parents wanted Student to also receive fifteen hours of home-based discrete trial training per week (DTT), and requested that the District increase the amount of speech and language therapy provided per week. The dispute between the parties evolved into a due process proceeding. At the July 13, 2001 mediation the parties reached a partial agreement in which Student would continue at Sorenson. However, at the start of the 2001-2002 school year Student was placed at Maizeland Child Development Center (Maizeland). The parents then alleged that Dr. Moore-Brown unlawfully changed their son’s placement to Maizeland and another due process hearing resulted. The parties have a rather lengthy legal history. (Footnote 5)

On January 9, 2002, Student’s parents enrolled Student in a Headstart Program at Magnolia School. Each school day they would pick Student up from Maizeland at 10:30 a.m. and transport him to Magnolia. In February 2002 Mother spent several days observing Student in his program at Maizeland. On March 4, 2002, Student’s parents elected to remove him from the District’s program. Student’s parents felt that Student was not progressing at Maizeland, that the curriculum did not challenge Student, and that Student was regressing in his behavior and self-help skills. The parent’s distrust of Dr. Moore-Brown was also a factor in their decision to remove Student from Maizeland. Student’s annual IEP team meetings were held on March 14 and 25, 2002. The offer presented by the District during the March IEP team meetings was as follows: placement at a preschool SDC with an autism focus (“severely handicapped” class) five days per week for four hours per day at Maizeland; speech and language one-on-one or small group four times per week for thirty minutes a session at Maizeland; occupational therapy (OT) one-on-one two times per week for fifty minutes per session at the OT clinic; reimbursement for transportation for OT; assistive technology (AT) of visual teaching strategies; and extended school year (ESY) services. Student’s parents rejected the offer of placement at Maizeland because of their distrust of Dr. Moore-Brown and their opinion that Student’s behavior had deteriorated while attending Maizeland. The parents requested that the District fund an in-home ABA program through LIFE of 25-30 hours per week. They also requested that the District fund private speech and language therapy. The District declined to fund the private program.

Student’s parents obtained a private developmental assessment from Melanie Lenington, licensed clinical psychologist. Dr. Lenington tested Student on May 28, and 30, 2002, and on June 4, and 19, 2002. Dr. Lenington found that Student was a “child challenged by social interactions, vulnerability, and sensitivity with a backdrop of core receptive and expressive language difficulties.” She recommended that Student have intensive one-on-one therapy by an exceedingly well-trained person in learning theory, such as Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA), for a minimum of forty hours per week at home. She indicated that Student might be ready to start integration with typically developing peers within six months.

Jane Haddad of The Kidstreet Institute conducted a speech and language evaluation at the request of Student’s parents. She tested Student on June 27, 2002, and July 19, 2002. Ms. Haddad found that Student suffered from a severe receptive/expressive language disorder with significant auditory processing difficulties. She recommended Student undergo speech and language therapy three times per week for an hour each session, OT, and an auditory processing re-education program. Mr. and Mother also obtained evaluations from Lovaas Institute For Early Intervention (LIFE), Julie Kammerer (inclusion specialist), and Kristi Yap (speech and language pathologist). Each of these examiners also found that Student suffered from a severe receptive/expressive language deficit.

In November 2002, Student began an in-home ABA program with LIFE for 35-40 hours of discrete trial training (DTT) per week. He continued to receive private speech and language therapy from Jane Haddad and OT from Gallagher Pediatric. (Footnote 6)

The due process hearing for consolidated cases SN02-00860 and SN03-00045 was held on January 21-24, 28-29, and March 17, 2003. The issue in the hearing, as relevant here, was whether the District provided Student a FAPE from March 2001 through March 2003, and, in particular, whether the offer contained in the March 2002 IEPs was an offer of FAPE. In her decision issued April 17, 2003, Hearing Officer Sherianne Laba found that the placement at Maizeland offered to Student during the March 2002 IEP team meetings was designed to meet Student’s unique needs and to provide him with educational benefit, and thus, met the requirements for an offer of FAPE. Hearing Officer Laba found that Student had been offered a FAPE from March 2001, through his next IEP, which would be in March 2003.

By letter dated April 24, 2003, the attorney who represented the parents and Student at hearing requested that Student’s annual IEP be convened “within the statutory time frame” and noted that the annual IEP meeting was due in March. An IEP team meeting was convened on May 16, 2003.

The IEP drafted on May 16, 2003, noted Student’s needs as follows: to improve his play, social, cognitive and pre-academic skills; to improve his classroom behavior, behavior organization, fine motor skills, and motor planning; and to improve his severe deficits in receptive and expressive language and pragmatics.

At the meeting, a recommendation was made that the District implement the offer presented at the March 2002 IEP team meetings, which had been found to be an offer of FAPE by Hearing Officer Laba. The IEP team notes indicated that the parents brought four reports for consideration by the IEP team. Those reports were: a speech and language report from Kidstreet; the Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention: Workshop Consultation Report and Proposed IEP Goals and Objectives report; the Pasadena Child Development Association Social Emotional Developmental Intervention Initial Program Assessment Report; and an OT Progress Report from Kidstreet. As “chair” of the meeting, Dr. Moore-Brown stated that the IEP team could not address the reports at the current meeting since they did not receive the reports with enough notice. Dr. Moore-Brown indicated that the reports would be considered at the next IEP team meeting. However, Mr. Arakaki from LIFE and Stella Sandoval from Plaza De La Raza were allowed to present reports on Student’s progress. Student’s parents also presented information verbally regarding Student’s progress.

The IEP indicated that the placement and services offered were to start on May 19, 2003, and that, during the meeting, the team would also address the 2003-2004 school year. The IEP team drafted an assessment plan to obtain current assessments. The IEP team meeting notes indicated that the team would meet again in June to review the assessments and discuss the upcoming school year.

After the new information was presented at the May 16, 2003 IEP team meeting, Dr. Moore-Brown presented the District’s offer as being “that of March 2002, with integration, OT, and Speech and Language Services, a behavior assessment [sic]. It is recommended that the IEP of March 2002 be implemented and that an assessment plan be prepared to assess Student’s current skills.” The District offered the goals and objectives from March 2002. Student was to attend the Maizeland pre-school severely handicapped (SH) special day class. Student’s parents did not accept the offer and Studentremained in his private program.

As of May 16, 2003, Student’s private program consisted of his attending the Magnolia Headstart program in the mornings, and participation in programs given by the YMCA, such as basketball, throughout the day. He also received two to three hours of one-on-one speech and language therapy per week from Jane Haddad, and received an in-home ABA program provided by LIFE which consisted of between twenty and thirty hours of services per week. All of Student’s educational services were paid for by his parents. (Footnote 7)

On June 2nd and 9th, 2003, SELPA school psychologist Jackie Leigh conducted an “objective observation” of Student’s Headstart class at Magnolia school. Student had been placed at the Headstart program by his parents and attended with typically developing children. He was provided with “supplementary aids and supports” and his LIFE aide accompanied him to class. The aide used DTT prompts, redirection, positive reinforcement, and restatement of questions to help Student respond to the teacher’s instructions. The aide used these techniques to facilitate interaction with the other children and staff as well. While Ms. Leigh noted that Student benefited from the placement and from the support of his aide, she also observed that Student was very dependent upon scripted prompts from familiar staff. She noted that Student was quiet until prompted with specific questions by an adult, and then Student would provide a practiced response. Ms. Leigh reported that Student had learned many rote responses and scripts but did not generalize. Student showed significantly greater incidents of spontaneous speech and interactions with peers in preferred situations with natural cues.

Ms. Leigh cited an incident where Student was observed in a chase game with other children that occurred spontaneously. Student was acting the part of the “monster” and was chasing the other students. Staff interrupted the game and directed Student to a group to play “duck, duck, goose.” Student needed to be prompted to participate in the game. Ms. Leigh also noted Student was very attached to his instructional aide, who provided him with over one-half of his instruction via prompts, instead of the teacher. Ms. Leigh was concerned that continued DTT training and scripts of more and longer conversations would result in suppressing spontaneous communication. She stated that if the other party did not provide the proper scripted request, Student was unable to respond. Ms. Leigh felt that Student needed to generalize his skills in a school setting. Ms. Leigh recommended that the IEP team consider that Student spend a portion of his day in a typical kindergarten and participate in a “K” level severe disorders of language (SDL) class that utilized a variety of instructional methods for autistic children.

An adaptive physical education (APE) evaluation was conducted by Bob Turner, District APE teacher, on June 3, 2003. Mr. Turner found Student to possess age-appropriate gross motor skills and that Student did not qualify for APE.

Jennifer Shubin, District speech language pathologist (SLP) conducted a speech/language assessment evaluation on June 10th and 12th, 2003. Ms. Shubin could not conduct standardized testing because Student did not understand the instructions. Ms. Shubin opined that Student needed to develop pragmatic functional language. She recommended an SDL class and speech and language therapy in a public school setting with mainstreaming part of the day.

Connie Kim of Gallagher Pediatric Therapy conducted an OT evaluation on June 12, 2003, at the request of the District. The report noted many areas of strengths and a few areas of concern that led the OT to recommend continuing therapy at the frequency of one time per week for fifty-minute sessions, and collaborative consultation. The parent’s OT Closing Report from Kidstreet, dated April 1, 2003, recommended OT services twice per week to address the same concerns but the length of sessions was not addressed.

A health assessment conducted on June 30, 2003, by district nurse Centeno contained no information relevant to this decision. The District behavioral specialist, Elaine Sun, had requested an opportunity to observe Student in his home LIFE program. She requested six hours of observation. Negotiations lasted several weeks regarding the type and length of observation that Ms. Sun would be granted. The dispute resulted in a delay in the observation until August 25, 2003.

Thea Starr Lincoln (District special education teacher) and Sue Sherard (District inclusion specialist) conducted academic testing on July 2nd and 9th, 2003. Ms. Lincoln and Ms. Sherard concluded that Student was highly distractible and had great difficulty following instructions that were not presented in a familiar format. Student relied heavily on adult cues to act. Ms. Lincoln and Ms. Sherard recommended that Student be placed in a small, highly structured environment with ample opportunity to interact with typical peers, both socially and academically.

The record showed that the parties had some difficulty scheduling the next IEP team meeting to discuss the findings of the assessments. An IEP team meeting was eventually scheduled for August 25, 2003. Ms. Sun issued her assessment of Student’s Home Program also on August 25, 2003. Ms. Sun felt that Student’s aide, drilled Student on rote phrases and demanded he perform rote actions that were not functional or pragmatic. According to Ms. Sun she observed no maladaptive behaviors that would require a behavior plan. Ms. Sun found that Student’s needs were for spontaneous language, play skills, and social interactions. Ms. Sun recommended that Student be placed in a natural school environment to learn to generalize. Ms. Sun reiterated that she was limited to a two-hour observation when she felt a six-hour observation would be more appropriate.

The IEP team met on August 25, 2003. The assessment reports obtained by the District were discussed. The assessors explained their findings and were in agreement that Student suffered a severe expressive and receptive language delay and pragmatics difficulties. The assessors indicated their opinions that Student was not generalizing what he had learned in the LIFE program. The assessors expressed their concerns that Student was too dependent on the DTT prompting and that he should move away from that format. A representative from LIFE was present and explained the LIFE program and Student’s progress. Mr. Arakaki stated that he wanted to move Student away from DTT because it did not generalize well into a classroom. Mr. Arakaki also stated that he had been unable to work on generalization because the Family home was being remodeled over the past three months.

The IEP document sets forth the following District offer of placement and services: a special day class of SDL five days per week for three hours and twenty minutes per day; OT once per week for fifty minutes at the OT clinic and OT consultation to parents and staff once per month for fifty minutes at the general and special education classrooms; full-inclusion general education kindergarten five days per week for three hours and twenty minutes per day; the services of a behavior specialist starting twice per week for six weeks, then once a week at the general and special education classes, with a liaison with the home program once per month for an hour; the services of an inclusion specialist monthly for four hours per month in the general education class; and individual speech and language therapy five days per week for thirty minutes per day. The IEP notes reflect a discussion about the locations of the SDL class as being at Pio Pico School and the general education kindergarten at Selby Grove Elementary. The speech and language therapy was to take place during the SDL class. Student was to have a one-on-one aide in both settings. The District would provide transportation between the two classes.

The IEP team proposed that goals be written in the following areas: class participation (2 goals); socialization (3); academic participation; sensory processing and proprioceptive and vestibular functioning; self regulation; academics; receptive language; expressive language (2); and pragmatics (2). Mr. Arakaki from LIFE presented his report of August 22, 2003, which contained proposed goals. The report contained three goals for behavior involving Student’s refraining from jumping on the furniture, refraining from running away from an adult for a preferred item, and refraining from engaging in protest behaviors. The report contained three language goals, four play and socialization goals, three academic and classroom-preparation goals, and two self-help goals. The IEP notes do not reflect a discussion of the LIFE report and proposed goals. However, Mr. Arakaki is reported as agreeing with the District members of the team that Student’s greatest need was for generalization into natural environments. Mr. Arakaki was reported to have agreed with moving Student away from DTT.

Student’s parents did not consent to the program or services. Student continued to receive the private ABA program from LIFE and private speech and language services. Student had aged out of the Headstart program. His parents placed him in YMCA activities and programs and other community-based programs.

The District filed a request for a due process hearing on October 27, 2003. The Student filed a request for due process on October 29, 2003, and requested that the two matters be consolidated. The two cases were consolidated on November 4, 2003.

Student entered the general education kindergarten class at his home school of Selby Grove on November 14, 2003, pursuant to what the parties’ referred to at hearing as an “informal interim agreement between the District and Student’s parents.” He continued to receive private ABA services from LIFE, and private speech and language therapy from Jane Haddad.

Student’s parents requested that they be allowed to communicate with Student’s aide at Selby Grove, Mirna Cruz. According to District witnesses, District policy does not allow aides to provide the parents with information about the student’s daily progress, other than the most basic information, such as “he did fine.” Aides were instructed to refer the parents to the teacher or inclusion specialist for any other information. Student’s parents assert that collaboration between Student’s home and school programs is essential. In November 2003, the District began holding monthly collaboration meetings, on Tuesdays. Mr. Arakaki was unable to attend several of the meetings because they were held on Tuesdays. Ms. Cruz did not attend the meetings. Also in November the parties began using a communication log that was to be carried by Student in his backpack from home to school and from school to home. The log was to contain notes from the District staff to the parents and from the parents to staff regarding Student’s progress. Ms. Cruz did not make entries in the log.

On December 20, 2003, Ms. Haddad issued a progress report. Ms. Haddad reported that Student had made excellent progress. She reported that her therapy was focused on receptive and expressive language, speech production, pragmatics and functional language. She recommended that Student remain with her in therapy and that the behavior therapist and classroom teacher should address and monitor social and pragmatic goals.

On January 26th and 30th, 2004, Mr. Arakaki observed Student in his general education placement. He reported that he witnessed heavy prompting from Student’s aide and that Student showed little attention to the teacher. Mr. Arakaki’s recommendations surrounded the fading of the aide, the fading of prompting, and the transfer of educational instruction from the aide to the teacher.

Student continued to attend the regular education kindergarten class at Selby Grove pursuant to the parties’ informal interim agreement and continued to receive other services as set forth in the first paragraph of the Background Facts above. This matter proceeded to hearing on April 27, 2004.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

1. Did the District fail to offer Student a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from March 25, 2003, through May 16, 2003, by failing to hold an annual IEP team meeting?

The Student contends that the District was obligated to hold an annual IEP team meeting by March 25, 2004, and the failure to hold such a meeting resulted in a denial of FAPE. The District contends that Student was a “parentally placed private school student” who was not entitled to special education services under Title 34, Code of Federal Regulations, section 300.454. The District therefore contends it had no obligation to hold an IEP team meeting.

Under State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C.§ 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1418. In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that for a student to receive a FAPE, the student’s IEP must be designed to meet the unique needs of the student and be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit.

Each public educational agency is responsible for initiating and conducting meetings for the purpose of developing, reviewing, and revising the IEP of a child with a disability. 34 C.F.R. § 300.343(a). In addition, the public agency shall ensure that the IEP team: “(1) [r]eviews the child’s IEP periodically, but not less than annually to determine whether the annual goals for the child are being achieved; and (2) [r]evises the IEP as appropriate to address (i) [a]ny lack of expected progress toward the annual goals…, (ii) [t]he results of any reevaluation…(iii) [i]nformation about the child provided to, or by, the parents.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.343(c).

No private school child with a disability has an individual right to receive some or all of the special education and related services that the child would receive if enrolled in a public school. 34 C.F.R. § 300.454. “Private school children with disabilities” is defined as children with disabilities enrolled by their parents in private schools or facilities, other than children placed in or referred to private schools by a public agency as a means to provide special education. 34 C.F.R. § 300.450. The IDEA requires that the school districts continue child find obligations toward private school children, and provide special education related services under a “services plan.” 34 C.F.R. §§ 300.451 and 300.452.

The District argues that Student’s parents placed him in private school because private school was their preference for his education and he therefore was a parentally placed private school student who was not entitled to a FAPE. However, the record reflects that the parents were consistently interested in a public school placement for Student. As early as June 2001, the parties discussed mainstreaming possibilities for Student for the 2001-2002 school year along with funding of ABA services by the District. The parents had long requested a DTT program or funding for a private DTT program, but they had also accepted District services and placements. Integration for part of Student’s day was discussed during the March 2002 IEPs.

Student’s parents removed him from Maizeland on March 4, 2002, because they felt Maizeland was not an appropriate placement for Student. The parents testified that they believed Student was bored at Maizeland because the curriculum did not challenge him, which caused behavioral incidents. They felt Student did not progress at Maizeland. The parents requested that the District fund an in-home ABA program, private speech and language therapy, and provide mainstreaming with typical peers. When the District refused, the parents placed Student in a private ABA program and provided private speech therapy. (Footnote 8)

Finally, Father stated at the May 16, 2003 IEP team meeting that the family’s goal was to have Student attend a typical kindergarten by age five. There was no persuasive evidence that the District had ever been given information to the contrary. The Hearing Officer, having considered all of the above, finds that the parents had demonstrated to the District their consistent desire that Student receive a public school education. Therefore, Student does not fit the definition of a “private school child with a disability” under the meaning of 34 C.F.R. § 300.454.

Thus, under State and federal law, the District was obligated to convene an annual IEP team meeting to review Student’s progress, his IEP, and his placement, and revisions accordingly by March 25, 2003. The District’s failure to convene an annual IEP team meeting by that date and make an offer of placement and services resulted in a denial of FAPE. (Footnote 9)

The Hearing Officer finds that the District denied Student a FAPE from March 25, 2003, until an annual IEP team meeting was eventually convened on May 16, 2003.

2. Did the District deny Student a FAPE from May 16, 2003, through August 25, 2003, by: (A) offering an inappropriate placement at Maizeland Elementary School; and (B) failing to offer a one-on-one ABA program?

A. Offering an inappropriate placement at Maizeland Elementary School

The Student contends that the offer of May 16, 2003, was not an offer of FAPE because the placement at Maizeland was not appropriate. The District contends that it was not obligated to make an offer of FAPE at the May 16, 2003 IEP team meeting and was not obligated to offer a FAPE until the upcoming school year; that the offer was a FAPE because of the SEHO decision; that the offer made on May 16, 2003, should be treated as Student’s interim placement under California Education Code section 56325; and that substantively, the offer was an offer of FAPE.

Several of the District’s contentions can be disposed of promptly. As discussed in issue number 1, the Hearing Officer rejects the District’s argument that it had no obligation to hold an IEP or offer a FAPE. The District further contends that the purpose for the May 16, 2003, IEP team meeting was to address the 2003-2004 school year so that the District was not obligated to offer a FAPE until the start of the new school year. The Hearing Officer rejects this argument in view of the clear language of the May 16, 2003, IEP that the start date of the program was to be May 19, 2003. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer rejects the District’s argument that the May 16, 2003, offer should be treated as an interim offer under California Education Code section 56325. On May 16, 2003, Student was not transferring to a new district or preparing to enter public school for the first time. Education Code section 56325 is not applicable to this situation. The Hearing Officer will now address the remaining contentions.

To constitute an offer of FAPE, the IDEA requires that the District’s placement, which includes related services, must (1) be designed to address Student’s unique educational needs, (2) be reasonably calculated to provide him some educational benefit, and (3) comport with his IEP. The offer must also provide an education in the least restrictive environment (LRE). Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987); 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8), § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.

(1) Was the May 16, 2003 offer designed to meet Student’s unique needs?

To determine whether the IEP was designed to meet Student’s unique needs as of May 16, 2003, the Hearing Officer must first determine Student’s unique needs.

Student’s Unique Needs

Although the parties assert that Student’s unique needs are not in dispute, their respective lists of Student’s needs as of May 2003 vary slightly. The March 2002 IEP lists Student’s “educational needs” as follows: expressive language, receptive language, fine motor and motor planning, behavioral organization, pragmatics, social skills, classroom behavior, cognitive skills, and play skills. These needs were adopted as current by the District members and copied into the May 16, 2003 IEP.

A number of assessments were obtained by the parents between March 2002 and May 16, 2003. Four of these reports were presented at the May 16, 2003 IEP team meeting and thus were available for consideration by the IEP team. The LIFE reports, Ms. Haddad’s reports, Dr. Lenington’s report, the reports from Julie Kammerer and Kristi Yap all note that Student had severe receptive/expressive language deficits and pragmatic difficulties.

Based on the above, the Hearing Officer finds that as of May 16, 2003, Student needed services to address his deficits in expressive language, receptive language, fine motor and motor planning, behavioral organization, pragmatics, social skills, classroom behavior, cognitive skills and play skills.

Was the placement offer for Maizeland appropriate to meet Student’s needs?

The Student argued that the placement at Maizeland was not appropriate for several reasons. First, the Student argued that the placement was not age appropriate because the placement was in a pre-school class. However, the evidence showed that Student turned five years old on March 27, 2003. The offer contained a start date of May 19, 2003, and, as demonstrated by the fact that Student was attending a Headstart preschool program with typically developing children at that time, it would have been appropriate for Student to finish out the school year in a pre-school class. There was no credible evidence to suggest that it would not have been appropriate to inject Student into the end of a kindergarten year.

The Student also argued that he had mastered much of a kindergarten curricula and therefore it was inappropriate to place him in pre-school. The evidence showed that according to the testing done by the Student’s experts, Student could meet many kindergarten standards but only if asked a question in a manner allowing his rote answers. Student could recite letters and numbers but did not demonstrate comprehension skills. He did not meet kindergarten comprehension standards. Under these circumstances, the Hearing Officer again finds that it would not have been appropriate to place Student into the end of a kindergarten class year.

The Student further argued that the other children in the Maizeland class were not of the same cognitive levels and thus were not cognitively appropriate for him. There was no testimony regarding the specific children and their specific cognitive levels. The District’s and Student’s experts testified that Student was unable to participate in standardized cognitive testing. The Maizeland class was a small structured class with an autism focus that was designed to address the cognitive levels of its students. Therefore there was no persuasive evidence that the class would be cognitively inappropriate for Student.

The May 16, 2003 offer provided for placement in a small structured class with an autism focus. The offer included speech and language therapy and OT. Goals and objectives were written that addressed each of Student’s needs regarding receptive and expressive language, pragmatics, socialization, play skills, cognitive and pre-academic skills. The offer included an opportunity for integration into the general education population. Hearing Officer Laba had found that the placement was appropriate as a preschool placement for much of the 2002-2003 school year. The District witnesses (Leigh, Sherard and Moore-Brown) testified that the placement at Maizeland was appropriate. On the basis of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the May 16, 2003 offer for placement at Maizeland, considered in conjunction with the other components of the offer, was designed to meet Student’s unique needs.

B. Failing to offer a one-on-one ABA program

The Hearing Officer will next examine the Student’s assertion that the May 16, 2003 offer was not an offer of FAPE because it failed to provide for one-on-one ABA services.

The evidence shows that on May 16, 2003, the Student presented expert reports that recommended he receive an intensive one-on-one ABA program. The IEP team did not consider those reports, declaring them to be untimely. (Footnote 10) However, the team did consider verbal reports presented by Mr. Arakaki and Ms. Sandoval. Mr. Arakaki agreed that Student should move away from DTT techniques. Because Student’s unique needs include receptive and expressive language, pragmatics and socialization, the District members of the IEP team had determined in the previous IEPs that intensive one-on-one ABA services were not appropriate for Student. Hearing Officer Laba had found in her decision that Student did not require DTT. The testimony at the present hearing established that the DTT techniques used in the ABA program did not generalize well and were not effective in teaching Student pragmatics or receptive and expressive language. The Hearing Officer is persuaded that the use of DTT techniques hindered Student as regards to the acquisition of spontaneous speech necessary for development of pragmatic language skills and socialization skills. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Student did not require an ABA program.

Thus, in summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer of May 16, 2003, was designed to meet Student’s unique needs.

(2) Was the offer of May 16, 2003, reasonably calculated to provide Student with educational benefit?

The Student argued that Maizeland would not provide educational benefit because he did not progress while placed in Maizeland previously. (Footnote 11) The Student further argued that the private program was the appropriate program for him because he was progressing. The Hearing Officer must look to the District’s program initially to see if the program was an offer of FAPE. If the District’s program is an offer of FAPE, the appropriateness of the parent’s program is not considered. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314; 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8), § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.

The District witnesses (Ms. Leigh, Ms. Sherard, Ms. Sun, and Dr. Moore-Brown) testified that, at the time (May 16, 2003), the Maizeland placement was an appropriate offer and would have provided Student with educational benefit. Furthermore, the May 16, 2003, offer provided instruction with an autism focus that would address Student’s unique needs and that had previously been found by SEHO to have provided educational benefit to Student. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer of May 16, 2003, was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to Student.

(3) Did the offer of May 16, 2003, comport with Student’s IEP?

The Student did not allege that the offer failed to comport with his IEP, therefore this question will not be addressed.

(4) Did the offer provide education in the least restrictive environment?

The Student did not allege that the offer was not in the least restrictive environment; therefore it is not necessary to address this question.

Conclusion

The Hearing Officer finds that the offer of May 16, 2003, was an offer of FAPE. Therefore, the District did not fail to provide Student with a FAPE from May 16, 2003, through August 25, 2003.

3. Did the District deny Student a FAPE from August 25, 2003, through the end of the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year (ESY) by: (A) offering an inappropriate placement at Pio Pico Elementary and Selby Grove Elementary schools and inappropriate speech and language therapy; (B) failing to provide a one-on-one ABA program; (C) committing a procedural violation of the IDEA and related law?

A. Offering an inappropriate placement at Pio Pico Elementary and Selby Grove Elementary schools and inappropriate speech and language therapy.

(1) Was the District’s offer designed to meet Student’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit?

Student’s Unique Needs

Before examining whether the dual kindergarten component and the speech and language component of the District’s offer for the 2003-2004 school year was designed to meet Student’s unique needs, the Hearing Officer must determine if Student’s unique needs as known to the parties had changed since May 16, 2003. Based on the assessments conducted by the District in June and July 2003, the August 25, 2003 IEP lists Student’s needs as class participation, socialization, academic participation, sensory processing, proprioceptive and vestibular functioning, self regulation, academics, receptive language, expressive language and pragmatics. The IEP contained goals in each of these areas. Each of the District’s assessors commented on Student’s lack of spontaneous speech. Student did not engage with adults or peers, whether in class or at home, unless a familiar prompt was given. The District assessors were universal in their opinions that Student needed to generalize his skills in natural environments, and the assessors were universal in their opinions that Student suffered from severe receptive and expressive language deficits and deficits in pragmatics. All assessors found that Student needed to develop socialization skills. Testing indicated that Student functioned at a level sufficient to satisfy a number of kindergarten standards. For instance, if asked, “[w]hich one is not the same?” Student was able to identify the objects that did not belong to a particular group, which meets kindergarten standard 1.1b. However, when instructed “[f]ind the one that’s different,” he was unable to respond. (Footnote 12)

The Student’s assessors identified that Student’s principle areas of need were expressive and receptive language, pragmatics and socialization. These assessors also identified auditory processing and language comprehension as needs.

The testimony of witnesses at hearing established that Student responds to only familiar questions and instructions and responds in a very practiced and rote fashion. He does not initiate conversations or interactions with peers and adults. While Student’s witnesses state that he progressed under their personal tutelages and the District’s witnesses testified that he progressed when in District schools, Student still does not initiate conversations. He does not use spontaneous language to communicate with peers or adults.

All the assessors and therapists believe that Student needs contact with typical peers for socialization and to learn spontaneous speech. The Student’s assessors and parents believe Student also needs an in-home ABA program to protect and maintain the skills he has learned and to pre-teach him first grade academics. The District’s assessors feel that Student does not need a home ABA program, and that his home ABA program may actually be encumbering spontaneous speech. It is not disputed that Student also needs one-on-one speech and language therapy. While most assessors feel that Student needs a small structured environment to learn, they also feel that he needs integration into a typical kindergarten to generalize the skills he has learned.

After reviewing all the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that Student needs to develop spontaneous pragmatic speech and needs to develop the ability to socialize. He needs a program that will address his deficits in receptive and expressive language, pragmatics, and socialization. Student needs intensive one-on-one speech and language therapy and ample opportunity to generalize the skills he learns in a natural environment. Considering the opinions of the District’s assessors and Mr. Arakaki, the Hearing Officer finds that, as of the beginning of the kindergarten (2003-2004) school year, Student must move away from learning by DTT and that the use of a one-on-one aide must include a fading of that aide and the fading of adult prompts in general.

The District’s Offer

On August 25, 2003, the IEP team considered information presented by both parties and offered two full-time kindergarten level placements. Student was to spend three hours and twenty minutes in the severe disorders of language class at Pio Pico Elementary with eight to ten students, which would include thirty minutes of one-on-one speech and language therapy per day, and then travel to Selby Grove to participate in another three hours and twenty minutes of kindergarten in a general education class with thirty two students. The offer included consultation with an occupational therapist, behavior specialist, and an inclusion specialist. The goals of the IEP were to address class participation (2), socialization (3), academic participation, sensory processing, proprioceptive and vestibular functioning, self-regulation, academics, receptive language, expressive language (2), and pragmatics (2).

The Student contends that the District denied him a FAPE by offering a placement that would provide duplicative instruction and that would overburden him. The Student further contends that the offer of speech and language services is inappropriate because it was embedded in the SDL class, the teacher was not qualified to teach autistic children, and the class cannot teach him pragmatic language. The Student also contends that the offer is inappropriate because it does not include a one-on-one intensive ABA program. Lastly, the Student contends that the District committed a procedural violation that resulted in a denial of FAPE by its refusal to allow his parents to communicate with the District one-on-one aide.

In her written report, Jackie Leigh, SELPA psychologist, recommended exposure to a wider variety of instructional methods shown to be effective with students with autism, and that Student be given opportunities to use speech and language in naturally occurring settings and situations without the presence of specific cues and scripts. Ms. Leigh suggested that Student spend part of his day in a typical kindergarten and part of his day in a kindergarten-level language-based special day placement.

Sue Sherard and Thea Lincoln (District academic assessors), in their written report, recommended that Student be in a small, structured environment that would focus on specifically addressing Student’s needs in expressive language, auditory processing, his reliance on adult cueing to start and complete tasks, and his high degree of distractibility. They also recommended that Student have ample opportunity for interaction with typical peers in both academic and social settings. In her written report, Jennifer Shubin (District SLP) recommended that Student be placed in a severe disorders of language classroom and that he should receive speech and language services within the public school setting. Therapy should focus on reception and expressive language and pragmatics. She also recommended that Student be mainstreamed with typical peers for part of his day. (Footnote 13)

Jane Haddad (Kidstreet SLP) recommended that Student receive speech and language services three hours per week and that social and pragmatic goals should be developed and monitored by his behavior therapist and classroom teacher. LIFE, via Mr. Arakaki’s written report, recommended that Student continue to receive in-home ABA services of 35-40 hours per week, consultation with LIFE, and that Student could begin attending a typical kindergarten classroom full-time in September 2003. Mr. Arakaki stated that the LIFE aide should accompany Student to school and Student would then continue ABA services at 20-25 hours per week.

April Coleman who teaches the SDL class at Pio Pico testified that she is not an autism specialist. Ms. Coleman indicated that her personal interest and specialty is articulation disorders. She testified that she was unsure as to what Student’s deficits were but was sure she could address them in her class. (Footnote 14) Ms. Coleman testified that she has eight students in her class this year. She has one aide and most of the students have their own aides. Three of her students are non-English speaking students. Five of her students have articulation problems, and all have severe problems with expressive language. Two of the students have behavioral problems. None of the students are verbal. Ms. Coleman had not met or assessed Student. Ms. Coleman could not describe an individualized speech and language program for Student to meet his unique needs. Ms. Coleman testified that she uses speech and language therapy throughout the day in all aspects of her class.

Blanca Ramirez teaches the typical kindergarten at Selby Grove that Student has attended since November 2003. She testified that she has no other experience teaching a child with autism, however, she testified that she could implement Student’s proposed IEP in her class. Ms. Ramirez relies heavily on Mirna Cruz, Student’s instructional aide, to provide Student’s educational program. Mirna Cruz provides over one-half of Student’s instruction. Ms. Ramirez was not able to describe a plan to address Student’s need for generalization and socialization in her class.

The August 25, 2003 offer included one-on-one speech therapy. This was to be provided by April Coleman during the SDL class. Ms. Coleman would be required to leave her other students for thirty minutes of each three-hour-twenty-minute day to work with Student individually. Dr. Moore-Brown testified that it is not possible to teach pragmatic skills one-on-one. Ms. Coleman indicated that pragmatics can occur between the teacher and student but a better outcome would occur if she could use another student.

Mr. and Mother testified that they believed two full kindergarten programs would be too much for Student. The programs overlapped in time, and that would cause Student to lose thirty minutes from one program or the other. Student is on a special diet that is prepared for him at home. The travel time from one program to another and the time for lunch at home would further detract from one program or the other. The parents also feel that Student has mastered most of the kindergarten curriculum. They feel that placing Student in two kindergarten programs with similar curricula, that he has already mastered, will not result in educational benefit and will cause boredom leading to behavioral problems.

The Hearing Officer is persuaded that the SDL class will not meet Student’s unique needs. The assessors universally opine that Student needs to generalize his skills, and needs to develop expressive and receptive language and pragmatics. The assessors feel that these skills need to be developed in a natural environment. The SDL class does not contain students that can talk to Student. He would be unable to work on pragmatic language in the class other than with the teacher and his aide. For the past year Student has worked with a speech and language pathologist and an aide on pragmatics and has been unable to generalize his skills. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the observations in Ms. Leigh’s report and by her testimony that Student shows an increased incidence of spontaneous communication and speech when functioning in a natural environment participating in a preferred activity. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the weight of the testimony of the assessors and their reports that Student needs an environment wherein he is exposed to language and communication in a natural way and is assisted to use his skills to begin to communicate in this environment. The SDL class does not provide this environment.

With regard to speech and language services, it is not disputed that Student needs one-on-one speech and language services. The August 25, 2003, offer would provide the services during the SDL day. However, the speech and language services must also focus on generalization, which cannot be done in the SDL class. Further, it is questionable how Ms. Coleman would be able to provide individual DIS services during her class as well as teach seven or eight other students with severe language disorders. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer of speech and language during the SDL class is not designed to meet Student’s unique needs.

The August 25, 2003 offer includes consultative services with a behavioral specialist and with an inclusion specialist. The offer also includes OT services. The Student did not raise a specific objection to the provision of these services.

Lastly, the August 25, 2003 offer includes full-time inclusion in a general education kindergarten with the use of a one-on-one aide. The record is replete with evidence that Student must have contact with typical peers. It is undisputed that Student should spend some part of his day in a general education kindergarten. Ms. Ramirez testified about her lack of experience teaching children with autism. However, with the services of an inclusion specialist and a behavioral specialist, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that Ms. Ramirez would have been provided with sufficient information to enable her to implement Student’s IEP. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the regular education kindergarten component of the District’s offer was designed to meet Student’s unique needs.

In summary, the Hearing Officer has found that the portion of the District’s offer concerning placement in a regular kindergarten class was designed to meet Student’s unique needs, and accordingly, was reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit. However, the portion of the District’s offer concerning placement in an SDL class and the receipt of speech and language therapy was not designed to meet Student’s unique needs and, to that extent, the District’s offer was a denial of FAPE. (Footnote 15)

B. Failing to provide a one-on-one ABA program

The Hearing Officer has already found that a one-on-one ABA program is not appropriate to meet Student’s unique needs.

C. Committing a procedural violation of the IDEA and related law

Parents of children with disabilities are provided procedural protections under the IDEA 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et. Seq. The Supreme Court noted in Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 206-207 that “Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation” at every step “as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP. Procedural violations however, do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE. Procedural violations which result in a “loss of educational opportunity” or which “seriously infringe the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process” result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992).

On November 14, 2003, Student began attending a general education kindergarten at Selby Grove School. He was assigned an instructional aide, Mirna Cruz. The Student contends that his parents should have been able to obtain information directly from his instructional aide at school, and should be able to directly provide that aide information about Student as well. The District contends that the parents have no such right of access.

The District’s and the Student’s assessors all stressed the necessity of having good collaboration between Student’s home program and school program. However, the testimony established that the District has a policy that prohibits instructional aides from providing any substantial information to parents. The District has developed a communication log that is to be carried by Student in his backpack between home and school. The parties can write in the log and communicate any information about Student. However, the aide did not write in the log. The District also holds monthly collaboration meetings. The aide does not attend these meetings.

The Student has not presented persuasive authority that his parents are legally entitled to direct access to Ms. Cruz. The testimony of Ms. Cruz and Mrs. Ramirez demonstrated that they remain in constant communication about Student so that Mrs. Ramirez is able to provide the parents with information from Ms. Cruz. Likewise, Mrs. Ramirez was responsible for communicating any information the parents provided to Ms. Cruz. Under those circumstances, the Hearing Officer finds that the lack of access to Ms. Cruz did not result in a loss of educational opportunity to Student or seriously infringe upon the parents’ participation in the IEP process.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that there was no denial of FAPE arising form a procedural violation.

Conclusion

The Hearing Officer finds that the offer of August 25, 2003 was not an offer of FAPE. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Student was denied a FAPE from August 25, 2003, through the date of this decision.

4. If the District failed to provide Student a FAPE, are Student’s parents entitled to reimbursement for: (A) the in-home ABA program provided by LIFE; and (B) the private speech and language therapy provided by Jane Haddad?

(A) The in-home ABA program provided by LIFE

Where the District has failed to provide FAPE, the parent may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of a private school education if it is determined that the parent’s placement was appropriate. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359; Student W. v. Puyallup School District 31 F.3d 1489 (9th Cir. 1994). The Burlington rule is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parent are found to be the exact proper placement or services under the IDEA. Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. V. State Bd. Of Educ. 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). Although courts have recognized that the parent’s placement does not have to meet a standard as high as the school districts must meet, the parent’s placement must still meet other requirements of the IDEA, such as providing a placement that addresses the student’s needs and provides the student educational benefit. Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13 (1993).

March 25, 2003, to May 16, 2003

From March 25, 2003, to May 16, 2003, the District denied Student a FAPE. The Student asserts that his in-home ABA program was appropriate and provided him with educational benefit. The District contends that Student did not need an ABA program to progress.

The LIFE report of May 13, 2003, indicates that Student was receiving thirty-six hours ABA services per week. The report sets forth Student’s progress on page two. Mr. Arakaki reports that Student is able to receptively and expressively identify seven prepositional relationships in various settings. It is reported that Student can receptively identify the function of 22 objects and is able to respond using full-sentence answers to 20 basic conversation questions. The list goes on to report of other expressive responses attributed to Student. The weight of the testimony of witnesses at hearing contradicts these statements. No witness was able to say that Student was able to answer questions and provide independent expressive responses. Perhaps Mr. Arakaki meant to state that Student was able to respond after adult cueing. The weight of the evidence suggests that these reported responses were not independent. However, Mr. and Mother testified that Student progressed because of the LIFE program. Mr. Arakaki testified that Student progressed because of the LIFE program. The Hearing Officer does not have any other evidence of Student’s progress or lack of progress during the time frame from March 25, 2003 to June 2, 2003. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the LIFE program provided educational benefit for Student from March 25, 2003, to June 2, 2003, and was thus appropriate. (Footnote 16) Student’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the LIFE program from March 25, 2003, through June 2, 2003.

May 16, 2003, to August 25, 2003

The Hearing Officer has found that the offer of May 16, 2003, was an offer of FAPE; therefore Student’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the ABA program from May 16, 2003, through August 25, 2003.

August 25, 2003, through the end of the 2003-2004 school year and ESY

The Hearing Officer has found that the offer of August 25, 2003, was not an offer of FAPE. However, the Hearing Officer has found that Student must move away from DTT/ABA for the kindergarten school year. Thus, for purpose of reimbursement, ABA was not designed to address Student’s unique needs and his parents’ request for reimbursement is denied.

(B) The private speech and language therapy provided by Jane Haddad

It is undisputed that Student needed intensive one-on-one individual speech and language therapy throughout the relevant periods of time. Ms. Haddad’s reports document that Student progressed during her therapy. Mr. and Mother testified that Student progressed with Ms. Haddad. While the evidence demonstrated that Student has not yet acquired spontaneous language, there is no evidence to indicate that Student did not receive educational benefit from Ms. Haddad’s therapy. Therefore, because the District denied Student a FAPE and because Student’s therapy with Ms. Haddad was appropriate, Student’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for Ms. Haddad’s therapy from March 25, 2003 to May 16, 2003. From May 16, 2003 through August 25, 2003, the District offered a FAPE, thus Student’s parent are not entitled to reimbursement during that time frame. From August 25, 2003, through the end of the 2003-2004 school year and ESY, Student was denied a FAPE and Student received educational benefit from Ms. Haddad’s therapy. Thus, Student’s parents are entitled to reimbursement from August 25, 2003, through the date of this Decision.

CONCLUSION

The District denied Student a FAPE when it failed to hold his annual IEP meeting before March 25, 2003, and thus denied Student a FAPE between March 25, 2003, and May 16, 2003. The District’s offer of May 16, 2003, was not an offer of FAPE so that Student was denied a FAPE from May 16, 2003, to August 25, 2003. The District’s offer of August 25, 2003, was not an offer of FAPE, thus Student was denied FAPE between August 25, 2003, and the end of the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year.

Because the District denied Student a FAPE from March 25, 2003, through May 16, 2003 and because the LIFE program was found to be appropriate during that time frame, Student’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for the costs of his in-home ABA program from March 25, 2003 through May 16, 2003. The LIFE program was found to be inappropriate thereafter. Student’s parents are also entitled to reimburse for the speech and language services of Jane Haddad from March 25, 2003, through May 16, 2003, and from August 25, 2003, through the date of this Decision.

ORDER

1. Within thirty days of receiving invoices, the District shall reimburse Student’s parents for the costs of LIFE services between March 25, 2003, and May 16, 2003. 2. Within thirty days of receiving invoices, the District shall reimburse Student’s parents for the costs of speech and language services by Jane Haddad from March 25, 2003 through May 16, 2003, and from August 25, 2003 through the date of this Decision. 3. The remainder of Student’s requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: The Student prevailed on Issues 1, and 3 and partially prevailed on issue 4. The District prevailed on issue 2.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Date: July 2, 2004 ______________________________ Jodi L. Clary, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

The issues have been restated to reflect the results of the parties’ discussion to clarify issues at the start of the hearing. There were no substantive changes.

2The Student argues that in a prior decision dated April 24, 2004, Hearing Officer Laba erroneously determined that Student had progressed during his 2001-2002 placement at Maizeland. The decision has been appealed to the District Court. This Decision will not revisit the previous hearing officer’s determination and will not re-litigate this issue

3 Student’s date of birth is [date redacted].

4 The informal interim agreement is confidential and was not offered into evidence at hearing.

5 See the prior decision issued in El Rancho Unified School District v. Student, consolidated cases number SN02-00860 and SN03-00045, for a more detailed factual recitation.

6 From March 4, 2002, through November 2002, Student attended the Headstart program at Magnolia School and other community based programs through the YMCA.

7 Until July 2003 Student received occupational therapy services provided by the District. At that time Student’s parents determined that Studen twould benefit more from speech and language therapy if his OT services occurred immediately prior. Student’s parents then obtained private OT. They are not seeking reimbursement of OT services.

8 The March 25, 2002 IEP team meeting and the offer presented at that IEP, placement at Maizeland, became the subject of a due process proceeding and ultimately a SEHO decision.

9 The Hearing Officer recognizes that the parties waited for the SEHO decision before taking further action regarding Student’s educational program. However, even pending the outcome of the prior due process proceeding, there is no law that prevents the parties from meeting and developing an appropriate educational program. Student’s parents could have earlier contacted the District and asked for the annual meeting to take place. However, the law places the burden on the District to initiate and conduct meetings to review IEPs.

10 The student did not allege that a procedural violation occurred by the refusal of the District members of the IEP team to consider the parents’ private reports.

11 The Student argues that the prior hearing officer’s decision is erroneous and that the evidence presented in the prior hearing established that Student did not progress at Maizeland. As stated before, this Decision will not revisit the issue.

12 Student was able to read all 26 upper case letters which meets kindergarten standard 1.0a. Student was able to read 25 lower case letters, confusing “q” for “p” and was able to correct his response when prompted, which satisfies kindergarten standard 1.0a. He also satisfied standard 1.4a (printed dictated letters), standard 1.2a (counting thirty objects) and standard 1.2b (reading non-consecutive numerals from 2-100). Student was able to read sight words if printed on flash cards, but not on a page.

13 At hearing, Ms. Leigh and Ms. Sherard testified that they recommended the District’s proposed dual placement and that such a placement was consistent with their respective written reports.

14 Student does not have an articulation disorder.

15 Because of her finding that the SDL component of the offer of August 25, 2003 was not an offer of FAPE, the Hearing Officer does not find it necessary to address the qualifications of Ms. Coleman, the SDL teacher.

16 Under Gregory K. reimbursement for the ABA services is appropriate because such services provided some educational benefit for Student. This does not mean that ABA services were required for a FAPE.