California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 28, 2004
Student v. Anaheim City School District et al.
SEHO Case No. SN 2315-03 · Hearing Officer Tracy L. Tibbals
Anaheim districts must fund daily compensatory speech therapy; Hope School offer rejected, autism eligibility and private school placement denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a 14-year-old boy filed against Anaheim City School District, Anaheim Union High School District, and the Greater Anaheim SELPA over four school years of services. The student had multiple disabilities, including significant developmental delays, and almost no spoken language. He communicated mainly through gestures, some sign language, pictures, and a voice output device. The parents sought autism eligibility, discrete trial training, direct occupational therapy, a one-to-one aide, reimbursement for six independent evaluations, and two years at a nonpublic school, Buena Park Speech and Language Development Center.
The Hearing Officer found the districts' assessments appropriate, rejected autism eligibility, and denied IEE reimbursement, discrete trial training, direct occupational therapy, and an aide. But both districts failed to address his need for spoken language. Their goals and speech services targeted only oral-motor mechanics or nonverbal communication. Several IEPs also did not say whether speech therapy would be individual or group. The high school district's January 2003 IEP described assistive technology too vaguely, and no general education teacher attended when mainstreaming came up. Its proposed move to Hope School, a special education campus, was neither appropriate nor the least restrictive environment. The Hearing Officer ordered oral expression goals and daily 15-minute compensatory speech production therapy, with 15% of the cost on the elementary district and 85% on the high school district. Other orders covered a trial voice output device and an occupational therapy reassessment plan. The nonpublic school placement was denied.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO treated a nonverbal student's need for spoken-language instruction as separate from sign language and picture systems, even when the prognosis was poor. It also shows SEHO requiring IEPs to say whether speech therapy is individual or group. And it treated a parent's due process claim as a referral for reassessment.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue I. Did the Elementary District fail to assess Petitioner in all areas of suspected disability during the 2000-2001 school year including autism and applied behavioral analysis, assistive technology, vision, orientation and mobility, and speech and language?
Autism was not a suspected disability, ABA is a methodology rather than an area of assessment, AT is an IEP-team consideration, vision and mobility data were adequate, and the speech-language triennial assessment was completed.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue II. Did the Elementary District fail to offer and to provide Petitioner a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year?
Speech offers that did not specify individual or group service were procedural violations, and communication goals and services ignored oral speech; OT consultation, DTT, AT, the lack of vision therapy, and no 1:1 aide were appropriate, and the missing interpreter at one meeting caused no harm.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue III. Did the Elementary District fail to assess Petitioner in all areas of suspected disability during the 2001-2002 school year including autism and applied behavioral analysis, assistive technology, vision, speech and language, and occupational therapy after a January 2002 referral?
A physician's letter diagnosing 'secondary autism' did not create a new suspected disability or act as an OT assessment referral, and no conditions warranted reassessment.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue IV. Did the Elementary District fail to offer and to provide Petitioner a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year?
Speech offers again lacked specificity and the program did not address speech production; the 'assistive services' (DTT) description was understood by the parents, and the remaining services and DTT implementation were adequate.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue V. Did the High School District during the 2002-2003 school year fail to assess Petitioner in all areas of suspected disability or conduct inappropriate assessments in autism and applied behavior analysis, vision, assistive technology, speech and language, occupational therapy, and behavioral testing in its multidisciplinary report?
The GARS, the behavioral rating scales, and the vision, AT, speech-language, and OT assessments were appropriate, and the district reasonably declined an ABA assessment.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue VI. Did the High School District fail to offer and provide Petitioner a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year, and extended school year?
FAPE was provided from July 2002 to January 2003. After that, oral speech needs went unaddressed, the AT offer was too vague, and no general education teacher attended when mainstreaming was raised. The other procedural lapses caused no harm, and DTT, direct OT, and a 1:1 aide were not required.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue VII. Did the High School District fail to assess Petitioner in all areas of suspected disability including autism and vision during the 2003-2004 school year?
Independent reports did not give the district reason to reassess for autism or ABA, and vision did not affect the student's access to his education.
- Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE
Issue VIII. Did the High School District fail to offer and provide Petitioner a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year, and extended school year?
The district did not offer FAPE: Hope School was inappropriate and not the LRE, oral speech was not addressed, and the speech offer lacked specificity. Other services were adequate, and the parents' raising of the issue at hearing was treated as an OT reassessment referral.
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue IX. Is autism Petitioner's appropriate qualifying eligibility?
Any autistic-like behaviors stem from his cognitive delays, developmental delays, and cerebral palsy, so he does not qualify under autism or autistic-like behaviors.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue X. Are Petitioner's parents entitled to reimbursement for independent educational evaluations (IEEs)?
Because each district assessment was appropriate, reimbursement for the six IEEs was denied.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue XI. Is Petitioner entitled to compensatory education prospectively for two years in the areas of discrete trial training, speech and language therapy, and occupational therapy because of the denial of a FAPE for the 2000-2001 through 2003-2004 school years and extended school years?
Compensatory daily individual speech production therapy was awarded, with cost split between the districts; compensatory DTT and OT were denied.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue XII. Is Petitioner entitled to placement at the Buena Park Speech and Language Development Center, a nonpublic school, for two years at public expense as compensatory education?
The districts can meet his needs at Orangeview, and the speech therapy award remedies the denials of FAPE, so nonpublic school placement was denied.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days, the IEP team must convene, inviting the Elementary District and GASELPA, to draft an oral expression goal and objectives and services for immediate implementation, and to draft a compensatory oral language program.
- Compensatory education. Compensatory oral language (speech production) therapy, 15 minutes per session, Monday through Friday except school holidays, for six months and continuing through extended school year. The IEP team meets with the provider at six months to adjust or end the therapy. Services begin within 15 days of the IEP meeting and may not run past the end of the 2004-2005 extended school year. Cost is split 15% Anaheim City School District and 85% Anaheim Union High School District.
- Order to assess. Within 15 days of the IEP meeting, the High School District must draft an assessment plan limited to oral expression if the team decides further assessment is needed.
- Order to provide or change services. Within 15 days, the High School District must implement the January 7, 2004 IEP assistive technology provision by buying and providing a Tech/Speak or comparable voice output device for a 60-day trial. The IEP team then evaluates the device and decides whether to continue it or use alternatives.
- Order to assess. Within 15 days, the High School District must prepare an occupational therapy reassessment plan and present it to the parents.
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range; Clyde K. v. Puyallup; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education; Adams v. Oregon; Burlington; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Student W. v. Puyallup
People named in the decision
- Sherry Blakely, director of special education, Anaheim City School District
- Dr. Michael Shelton, alternatively special youth services director, Anaheim Union High School District
- Linda Gaston, program administrator, Anaheim Union High School District
- Tony Nguyen, Vietnamese language interpreter at hearing
- Jessica Postil, autism specialist; independent assessor and expert witness for Student, Autism Spectrum Consultants (clinic director)
- Cynthia Cottier, augmentative communication therapist; independent assessor and expert witness for Student
- Judy Segal, speech-language pathologist; independent assessor and expert witness for Student
- Laurie Cohen, occupational therapist; independent assessor and expert witness for Student
- Dr. Beth Ballinger, optometrist; independent assessor and expert witness for Student
- Dr. Christine Majors, neuropsychologist; independent assessor and expert witness for Student
- Ellen Singer, special day class teacher and DTT supervisor, Anaheim City School District
- Michael Rutz, speech-language pathologist, Anaheim City School District
- Julie Bissell, occupational and physical therapy coordinator, Anaheim City School District
- J.C. Christopherson, orientation and mobility specialist / vision assessor, Anaheim City School District
- Marilyn Bakarich, program specialist, Anaheim Union High School District
- Karen du Preez, occupational therapist, Greater Anaheim SELPA
- Karin Daignault, speech-language therapist, Anaheim Union High School District
- Kathleen Wohlgemuth, speech-language therapist, Anaheim Union High School District
- Kathy Lewis, severely handicapped teacher at Hope School and assistive technology specialist, Anaheim Union High School District
- Donna Erickson, assistant principal and school psychologist (administered GARS, Burks, Vineland), Anaheim Union High School District
- Lou Anne Boyd, school psychologist, Greater Anaheim SELPA
- Dr. Marilyn Miller, principal, Anaheim Union High School District
- Jane Vogel, vision specialist, Anaheim Union High School District
- Ken Seefeldt, special day class teacher, Orangeview Junior High School, Anaheim Union High School District
- Esther Soe, school nurse, Anaheim Union High School District
- Candy Miller, GASELPA director, Greater Anaheim SELPA
- Nancy Malotte, assistant principal, Anaheim Union High School District
- Dr. Ira Lott, professor of pediatrics and neurology; physician who wrote diagnostic letters, University of California, Irvine
- Dr. Church, student's physician
- Buena Park Speech and Language Development Center, nonpublic school sought by Student
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Tracy L. Tibbals, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, on January 20, 21, 22, 23, 27, 28, and 29, 2004, in Anaheim, California.
Petitioner STUDENT (STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented at the hearing by attorney Amy N. Schuchman. Also present on behalf of Petitioner were his mother and father, MOTHER and FATHER. Respondent Anaheim City School District (Elementary District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Lauri A. LaFoe. Also present on behalf of the Elementary District was director of special education Sherry Blakely. Respondent Anaheim Union High School District (High School District) and Respondent Greater Anaheim Special Education Local Plan Area (GASELPA) were represented by attorney Cynthia A. Yount. Also present for the High School District were alternatively special youth services director Dr. Michael Shelton and program administrator Linda Gaston. Vietnamese language interpreter Tony Nguyen was present to assist STUDENT’s parents as needed.
Petitioner called as witnesses his parents, autism specialist Jessica Postil, augmentative communication therapist Cynthia Cottier, speech and language pathologist Judy Segal, occupational therapist Laurie Cohen, optometrist Dr. Beth Ballinger, Elementary District teacher Ellen Singer, and neuropsychologist Dr. Christine Majors. The Elementary District called teacher Ellen Singer, speech and language pathologist Michael Rutz, occupational and physical therapy coordinator Julie Bissell, and orientation/mobility specialist J. C. Christopherson. The High School District called program specialist Marilyn Bakarich, GASELPA occupational therapist Karen du Preez, speech and language therapist Karin Daignault, speech and language therapist Kathleen Wohlgemuth, teacher Kathy Lewis, assistant principal Donna Erickson, GASELPA psychologist Lou Anne Boyd, principal Dr. Marilyn Miller, and vision specialist Jane Vogel.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the receipt of written closing briefs. After the receipt of the briefs, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING (Footnote 1)
I. Did the Elementary District fail to assess Petitioner in all areas of suspected disability during the 2000-2001 school year including autism and applied behavioral analysis, assistive technology, vision, orientation and mobility, and speech and language?
II. Did the Elementary District fail to offer and to provide Petitioner a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year?
III. Did the Elementary District fail to assess Petitioner in all areas of suspected disability during the 2001-2002 school year including autism and applied behavioral analysis, assistive technology, vision, speech and language, and occupational therapy after a January 2002 referral.
IV. Did the Elementary District fail to offer and to provide Petitioner a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year?
V. Did the High School District during the 2002-2003 school year fail to assess Petitioner in all areas of suspected disability or conduct inappropriate assessments in autism and applied behavior analysis, vision, assistive technology, speech and language, occupational therapy, and behavioral testing in its multidisciplinary report?
VI. Did the High School District fail to offer and provide Petitioner a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2002-2003 school year, and extended school year?
VII. Did the High School District fail to assess Petitioner in all areas of suspected disability including autism and vision during the 2003-2004 school year?
VIII. Did the High School District fail to offer and provide Petitioner a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2003-2004 school year, and extended school year?
IX. Is autism Petitioner’s appropriate qualifying eligibility?
X. Are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for independent educational evaluations (IEEs)?
XI. Is Petitioner entitled to compensatory education prospectively for two years in the areas of discrete trial training, speech and language therapy, and occupational therapy because of the denial of a free, appropriate public education for the 2000-2001, 2001-2002, 2002-2003, and 2003-2004 school years and extended school years?
XII. Is Petitioner entitled to placement at the Buena Park Speech and Language Development Center, a nonpublic school, for two years at public expense as compensatory education?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is fourteen years of age. He resides within the boundaries of both the High School District and the Elementary District with his parents and attends the High School District’s Orangeview Junior High School in the severely handicapped special day class. He has qualified for special education and services since he entered school at age three because of multiple disabilities arising from pervasive development delays. He currently scores at about two years of age in most cognitive ability categories. STUDENT’s health history includes cerebral palsy, hydrocephalus treated with a surgically implanted shunt, asthma, eczema, food allergies, vision deficiencies, and hearing loss. He is fitted with both corrective lenses and hearing aids that he wears in school. He has virtually no expressive oral language. For communication, he relies upon gestures, some sign language, and a few single words such as “mom” or “here.” He has also used the Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS), other systems using pictures, and an “audio box,” a portable communication assistive technology device worn on his belt that has prerecorded messages that can be played by pushing a button on the device.
STUDENT enrolled in the Elementary District in the spring of 2000 when he was ten years old. He had been in a special day class in the Rowland Unified School District before his transfer. After reviewing his records and consulting with his previous district, the June 2000 individualized education program (IEP) team determined that STUDENT’s needs still required the pace and structure of a special day class as he had had in his previous district. The June 19, 2000 IEP also cites classroom observations and teacher reports that describe STUDENT as “well behaved” and his oral language skills as “severely delayed.” STUDENT could vocalize sounds, but could not produce consistent, intelligible speech. The IEP team then placed STUDENT in a special day class for severely handicapped students during the 2000-2001 school year. The services for this year included speech and language therapy, occupational and physical therapy consultation as needed, and a mobility specialist to provide transportation as needed and services in the classroom. The June 2000 IEP team formulated goals to meet STUDENT’s needs in areas of social-emotional, pre-academic, gross motor, fine motor, mobility, and communication.
In August 2000 at his parents’ request, the Elementary District also placed STUDENT in an adapted physical education class and provided an occupational therapist to monitor his oral motor skills at lunch. His parents had a continuing concern that STUDENT put too much food in his mouth while eating and was at risk of choking. In his previous district, STUDENT had received direct occupational therapy that focused on feeding. He had shown progress in eating and a decrease in tactile defensiveness to various foods. Although he ate lunch with his classmates, his parents prepared and sent the food to school that he ate during lunch time. In September 2000, in further response to parental concerns, the Elementary District arranged for an occupational therapist to complete a “swallowing efficiency evaluation,” review medical records, and formulate safety precaution recommendations for home and school.
Also in September 2000, the Elementary District increased emphasis on STUDENT’s gross motor skills and practice and training for oral motor skills related to beginning speech sounds and eating. The gross motor skills services were also incorporated within the structure of discrete trial training (DTT). (Footnote 2) By November 2000 the District occupational therapist devised a check list form to ensure that STUDENT was supervised while eating, with reports translated into the Vietnamese language as soon as possible for parental review. During the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT was using both PECS as well as an audio box with four prerecorded messages to aid in expressive communication.
At the February 5, 2001 IEP meeting, the team increased the time for DTT at the request of his parents. STUDENT also showed progress by meeting his goals for spatial awareness, hand-eye coordination, and effective on-task behavior. He was unsuccessful, however, with goals for effective use of PECS, grouping items by color, shape, and size, and recognition and use of numbers. At this February 2001 team meeting, STUDENT’s parents requested that he learn sign language for home and school communication. By the end of the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT could recognize about forty signs. On June 21, 2001, the IEP team set a goal of seventy signs. STUDENT’s teacher reported that she communicated with him with both signs and PECS. During the June 2001 meeting, the team again agreed to increase the time allotted to DTT and speech therapy following requests from STUDENT’s parents.
In March 2002, the IEP team responded to further concern from the parents and increased emphasis on sound production during STUDENT’s oral motor lessons. The March 4, 2002 IEP team proposed to keep STUDENT in a special day class but to terminate the DTT because the providers reported virtually no progress. The Elementary District continued DTT for the remainder of the time STUDENT was in the District only at the parents’ behest. He left the Elementary District at the end of the 2001-2002 school year.
The High School District participated in IEP meetings starting in January during the last half of the 2001-2002 school year in anticipation of STUDENT’s transition to the high school program for the 2002-2003 school year. The original placement offer contained in the April 19, 2002 IEP, rejected by STUDENT’s parents, was at the District’s Hope Special Education Center (Hope School), where he would be on a campus dedicated to special needs students, including many who use sign language. At the July 9, 2002 IEP meeting, the District agreed to offer placement in a severely handicapped special day class at the District’s Orangeview Junior High School (OV) during the 2002-2003 school year, which was requested by his parents after they visited several alternative sites. The July 2002 offer included speech and language services, mobility services, modified physical education, and continuation with PECS.
The notes of the next IEP meeting on September 26, 2002, indicate that “Parents agreed to change the wording of the IEP from the PECS system of communication (not available at OV) to a picture communication system.” These notes also state that the classroom teacher will learn five signs “to help with communication with STUDENT.” This IEP documents a change from “modified P.E.” as offered in the July 2002 IEP, to “adapted P.E.” According to the report on STUDENT’s progress described in the September 2002 IEP, the District was already implementing adapted physical education. In spite of these statements of apparent agreement, the parents did not consent to the entire IEP but did consent to the “special education program placement.” The September 2002 IEP also records a parental request for a one-to-one aide that the District denied.
At the October 21, 2002 IEP meeting, the team received occupational therapy and assistive technology assessments. Although STUDENT had been receiving consultative occupational therapy services in the Elementary District, his parents state that the occupational therapy report at this IEP meeting was their first indication that STUDENT’s implemented program in the High School District included consultative occupational therapy services. The parents contend that they did not consent to these services, although they are also seeking direct occupational therapy services in this proceeding.
The High School District did not offer to continue the DTT STUDENT had received in the Elementary District in the July 2002 IEP. In an effort to have DTT reinstated, in November 2002, PARENTS rescinded their approval of the July 2002 IEP. This was the first agreed-to IEP at the High School District level with an offer of placement and services. It did not include DTT. The parents stated in the written revocation of their approval of the July 2002 IEP that they intended to reinstate the March 2002 IEP as the last agreed-upon IEP for implementation, as the Elementary District had provided DTT pursuant to this IEP. There were a number of IEPs after the revocation of the consent for the July 2002 IEP, although none was agreed to by Petitioner’s parents as of the due process hearing. The High School District, however, has continued to offer the same levels of services as in the July 2002 IEP as modified by the September and October 2002 IEPs.
The December 19, 2002 IEP, to which the parents signed to denote “attendance only,” indicates that DTT was discussed at length. PARENTS continued at this IEP meeting, unsuccessfully, to seek reinstatement of DTT. They also unsuccessfully requested an applied behavioral analysis (ABA) assessment. (Footnote 3) At the December 2002 IEP meeting, the High School District stated that it would check with the Elementary District concerning DTT. During this December 2002 IEP meeting, the team discussed STUDENT’s present levels of performance and progress toward current goals. The regular education teacher explained the school-wide sustained silent reading program in the first period of the morning for each student to read in a book of his or her choosing. The special day class students listened to books on tape during this time. As STUDENT regularly arrived at school late because of the time needed in the morning to get ready and receive medication, STUDENT missed the books on tape. The IEP notes state that there was no story time in the junior high school, as had been available in the Elementary District.
During the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT worked with a computer and mouse, although he required a larger than normal keyboard. In his first year in the High School District, his academic performance progressed slowly. As of December 2002, he still did not grasp that his written name pertained to him, with the exception of the letter “V.” He continued a resistance to counting and a difficulty in matching colors. He remained unable to imitate most mouth and tongue movements necessary for speech but could imitate vowel sounds, albeit inconsistently. During the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT continued his pre-academic reading program with goals to match words to pictures or descriptions. As of his annual IEP meeting on January 7, 2003, his proposed pre-academic math goals included counting and matching one to five items with the correct number. As of the April 2003 IEP, STUDENT was still working on preliteracy recognition of letters and numbers. The District speech and language therapists concluded in an assessment that, although he did have a small vocabulary, he had reached a plateau in oral expression in spite of school and home therapy. The therapists recommended emphasis on broader-based communication skills, as their prognosis was that further oral motor therapy would yield only minimal results. STUDENT’s parents, however, persisted in wanting more speech and language drill.
STUDENT remained in the same placement at the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year with the same services. During the summer and fall of 2003, independent assessors in the fields of autism, speech and language, neuropsychology, vision, occupational therapy, and assistive technology evaluated STUDENT. These assessors also reviewed STUDENT’s education from enrollment in the Elementary District to the present.
Petitioner’s due process request was made on November 3, 2003. STUDENT’s parents did not attend his November 2002 or January 2004 IEP meetings because of scheduling conflicts and a dispute over whether the meetings should be postponed with the due process hearing pending. The District went forward with the January 2004 IEP meeting, stating that the law required the annual IEP session to proceed. The January 7, 2004 IEP states that STUDENT knew approximately seventy six signs, which was double the number he knew in November 2002. STUDENT also reportedly showed resistance to using the nonverbal communication tools of PECS or the audio box. The District team members who were present discussed the independent assessments provided by STUDENT’s parents but declined to follow most of the recommendations. The District IEP team members in January 2004 did, however, accept the recommendation of Petitioner’s augmentative communication specialist for a specific type of audio box. At the January 2004 IEP meeting, the High School District renewed Hope School as STUDENT’s prospective placement offer.
His parents are seeking in this due process proceeding a change in STUDENT’s qualifying disability to autism, services for speech and language, vision therapy, occupational therapy, assistive technology, one-to-one aide, transportation, autism, and DTT, and placement at public expense in the Buena Park Speech and Language Development Center (Buena Park School), a nonpublic school, as compensatory education. They also seek reimbursement for six independent educational evaluations and a finding that Hope School is not an appropriate placement.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO I: Did the Elementary District fail to assess Petitioner in all areas of suspected disability during the 2000-2001 school year?
Petitioner contends that the Elementary District should have assessed him during the 2000-2001 school year in the areas of autism, assistive technology, vision, orientation and mobility, speech and language, and ABA. A district has an obligation to assess a special needs pupil in all areas related to a suspected disability. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f). (Footnote 4) Additionally, the district must reassess the pupil at least once every three years or more frequently if conditions warrant a reassessment. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(2)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56381.
A. Autism and applied behavioral analysis
Autism
Petitioner argues that “patterns of behavior” evident both in documents that the IEP team had available from STUDENT’s previous district and from the Elementary District’s own reports during the 2000-2001 school year should have led to an autism assessment. These “patterns,” cited by Petitioner, included a 1993 psychological report (Petitioner Exhibit 73) that mentioned deficits in eye contact and in social interactions, a 1997 occupational therapy evaluation (Elementary District Exhibit 29) concluding STUDENT had tactile defensiveness, the June 19, 2000 IEP (Petitioner Exhibit 18) noting deficits in social reciprocity and lack of appropriate play, and the February 5, 2001 IEP (Petitioner Exhibit 73) that refers to difficulty with peer relationships, lack of concentration, difficulty with peer relationships, and defiance.
STUDENT’s Elementary District special day class teacher, Ellen Singer, testified that she has worked for several years with children diagnosed with autism. She did not see, however, any indication of autism in STUDENT’s behavior. She did not observe poor eye contact, self-stimulatory behavior, difficulty transitioning to different activities, tactile defensiveness, or peer relationship problems. Ms. Singer specifically recalled that STUDENT was very social, even upon his enrollment in the District when he began meeting new peers for the first time. Self-described as prone to hugging, Ms. Singer said that STUDENT did not “seem to mind” physical contact, which is often avoided by autistic children. The exception to this, she reported, was in areas of his body where his chronic eczema was very bad. Ms. Singer said that STUDENT’s relationship with his peers noticeably improved while he was in her class. As to references to “defiance” during the 2000-2001 school year, Ms. Singer suggested that term was too extreme and that “compliance” would more accurately describe his reluctance to begin activities that he did not like. She also said that the “defiance” or “peer relationship problems” referred to in the more recent IEPs can be typical of disabilities other than autism. STUDENT’s speech and language pathologist, Michael Rutz, also has experience working with children diagnosed on the autism spectrum. He noted no tell-tale symptoms in STUDENT’s conduct that indicated autism. Although he did observe tactile defensiveness when performing oral-motor drills, Mr. Rutz concluded from his experience that this behavior was consistent with that of other students he had worked with who had severe oral-motor delays.
Several of the “patterns” listed by Petitioner are in reports three to seven years before he entered the Elementary District. The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of the District witnesses persuasive that these patterns, to the degree that they were noted, were also observed in children with other types of disabilities. Therefore, the Hearing Officer further finds that the Elementary District was not required to assess STUDENT for autism as a suspected disability during the 2000-2001 school year.
Applied behavioral analysis
Petitioner contends that an ABA assessment should have been conducted during the 2000-2001 school year as the District was providing DTT. Petitioner’s autism assessor Jessica Postil stated that it was necessary to assess STUDENT’s ABA needs before and after a DTT program to assess progress. The District argues that ABA is a methodology and not a disability. Moreover, it is usually a methodology used with children diagnosed on the autism scale. As indicated above, there was no “suspected disability” as to autism. Ms. Postil also acknowledged that there is no formal instrument for an ABA assessment. Moreover, the evidence indicates that the Elementary District was able effectively to assess STUDENT’s lack of progress from the DTT therapy. As ABA is not a recognized area of assessment concerning a “suspected disability” under Cal. Educ. Code section 56320 (f), and there was no suspected autism, the Hearing Officer finds that the Elementary District had no duty to conduct an ABA assessment during the 2000-2001 school year.
B. Assistive technology assessment
Petitioner contends that the District should have assessed STUDENT’s needs in the area of assistive technology before providing an audio box for him during the 2000-2001 school year. As part of his speech and language services, the Elementary District provided STUDENT with an audio box to be worn on his belt that included four prerecorded messages. The District responds that the audio box was selected at the February 5, 2001 IEP meeting (Elementary District Exhibit 6) as an aid to increase, maintain, or improve STUDENT’s functional capabilities as described in 34 C.F.R. section 300.5. The category of assistive technology is not listed as a recognized area of assessment related to a suspected disability that the Elementary District must pursue under Cal. Educ. Code section 56320 (f). Rather, assistive technology is an area that the IEP team must consider in developing a pupil’s program under Cal. Educ. Code section 56341.1(b)(5). The audio box was given to STUDENT by the District to enhance his options and ability to express his needs. The IEP team did consider assistive technology and employed the audio box in response to STUDENT’s language function and communicative status needs--areas that had been assessed. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds no persuasive evidence that a separate assistive technology assessment was needed in the 2000-2001 school year.
C. Vision assessment
Petitioner argues that the District should have arranged for independent vision testing for STUDENT because the data the District reviewed were at least three years old at the time of its assessment. Elementary District orientation and mobility specialist J.C. Christopherson, who is also certificated in clinical low vision therapy and has studied optometry and vision therapy, completed a report in May 2000 on STUDENT’s vision that incorporated the results of tests performed by other vision professionals up to three years earlier (Elementary District Exhibits 32, 33, 39). Ms. Christopherson observed that STUDENT possessed adequate scanning and tracking skills. She said that, had she found otherwise, she would have recommended specific exercises. The District witnesses testified that STUDENT was able to access his curriculum. He had no observed difficulties maneuvering around objects in his path or moving around the school campus. He also had no observed visual impediments to meeting his eye-hand coordination goals or doing his pre-academic work. The District was entitled to rely on prior assessments and had no obligation to conduct a reassessment unless “conditions warrant” as stated in Cal. Educ. Code section 56381. The evidence includes no indication in this school year that STUDENT had a visual impairment that limited his access to his academic curriculum. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that conditions did not warrant a further vision reassessment during the 2000-2001 school year.
D. Orientation and mobility assessment
Petitioner raised orientation and mobility as areas that should have been assessed by the Elementary District during the 2000-2001 school year. The record, however, includes a vision/mobility assessment dated in May 2000 (Elementary District Exhibit 39). District assessor J.C. Christopherson testified that STUDENT was able to move around his classroom and the school campus. The Hearing Officer finds that the Elementary District did assess STUDENT’s orientation and mobility during the 2000-2001 school year, and there was no persuasive evidence that an additional assessment was warranted.
E. Speech and language
Petitioner contends that the speech and language assessment listed in the January 10, 2001 assessment plan (Petitioner’s Exhibit 60) was not conducted. (Footnote 5) The date of the assessment plan is within one month of the triennial IEP meeting on February 5, 2001, and this assessment plan was designated for the triennial assessment. PARENTS consented to the assessment plan within the time line set forth in Cal. Educ. Code section 56321(c). District speech and language pathologist Rutz, who was working with STUDENT, testified that he did conduct an assessment at that time “to see what he could do.” There is no copy of a speech and language assessment presented by the District and Mr. Rutz does not recall if he prepared a written report. The record, however, does include evidence that the team developed speech and language goals and objectives at the February 5, 2001 IEP meeting that Mr. Rutz attended (Elementary District Exhibit 6). The Hearing Officer finds Mr. Rutz’s testimony persuasive that he completed the assessment, and his testimony is further supported by the February 2001 IEP. This IEP includes speech and language present levels of performance, which establishes that the IEP team heard and considered current speech and language assessment information from Mr. Rutz at that time.
ISSUE NO. II: Did the Elementary District fail to offer and to provide Petitioner a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year?
The District is obligated to provide a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) to STUDENT to meet his unique needs under the provisions of the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000). A FAPE includes special education and related services that are provided at public expense, under public supervision and direction, and without cost that meet the standards of the State educational agency, including appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education provided in conformity with the student’s IEP as described in 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).
“Special education” is specially designed instruction without cost to parents that meets the unique needs of the student (20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031). “Related services” include transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a student to benefit from special education as defined in the IDEA at 20 U.S.C. section 1401(22). State law provides for similar services as part of designated instruction and services (DIS) under Cal. Educ. Code section 56363(a) and Title 5, Cal. Code Regs. section 3001(z).
The United States Supreme Court in the leading decision of Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 205, recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Every procedural misstep, however, does not necessarily result in a denial of FAPE. To result in such a denial, the procedural violations must cause serious infringement of the parent’s opportunity to participate on the IEP team or loss of educational opportunity to the pupil. Rowley, at 206-207; W.G. v. Bd. ofTrustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 , 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992)
The District bears the burden of proving that its program provided a FAPE to STUDENT. Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District No, 3, 35 F.3d 1396,1398 (9th Cir. 1994)
Procedural considerations
Petitioner asserts that the Elementary District committed procedural violations with respect to the November 17, 2000 IEP, and the February 5, 2001 IEP. Petitioner alleges that the November 17, 2000 IEP meeting did not include a translator and did not result in a clear offer of DIS. Petitioner further contends that the February 5, 2001 IEP did not include a clear offer of DIS.
The November 17, 2000 IEP
Interpreter
PARENTS are native Vietnamese speakers. Although the Elementary District had provided interpreters for STUDENT’s parents on other occasions, a translator did not attend the November 17, 2000 IEP meeting. MOTHER, testifying in English, said that she can communicate in English to some extent but would have been assured of a better understanding of the proceedings at the November 17, 2000 IEP meeting had an interpreter been present.
Cal. Educ. Code section 56341.5(h) requires that to facilitate parental understanding and participation in the IEP process, a district must “take whatever action is necessary...including arranging for an interpreter for parents...whose native language is other than English.” There is also testimony from MOTHER that IEPs and other documents were not all translated for her as requested. MOTHER further indicated that a District psychologist, while on the subject of parental translation requests, once remarked that translations are costly to the District. This single attribution to the comment of a District employee notwithstanding, the record does not support a finding that the District had a deliberate intention to limit translations for fiscal or any other reasons. The majority of the other IEP team meetings included a Vietnamese interpreter. The documents in evidence include a number of translations into Vietnamese. The record demonstrates that PARENTS had regular assistance from a translator. Nevertheless, the conducting of the November 17, 2000 IEP without an interpreter present is a procedural violation of law.
It is apparent from the record, however, that STUDENT’s parents actively participated on the IEP team in the English language throughout STUDENT’s time in the Elementary District, including the November 2000 meeting. This particular IEP incorporates requests and information from the parents during the meeting and discusses having the District translator present for future meetings (Elementary District Exhibit 5). The parents also regularly responded to the issues concerning STUDENT’s education, including making numerous verbal and written requests of the District and thoughtfully considering the IEPs and assessment plans and withholding approval on occasion. The evidence does not establish that PARENTS were prevented from participating on the IEP team or that STUDENT lost any educational opportunity because of the missing translator during the 2000-2001 school year at the November 17, 2000 IEP meeting.
Offer of DIS
Petitioner also avers that the November 17, 2000 IEP (Elementary District Exhibit 5) failed to describe the DIS with specificity. Particularly, he points to the offer of speech and language services that does not state if the services are to be administered in a group or individually. As a result, states Petitioner, his parents were unable to make an informed decision concerning the offer. Cal. Educ. Code section 56345(a)(3)(6) requires the IEP to identify with specificity “the special educational instruction and related services and supplementary aids and services” the district is offering. The frequency, location, and duration must also be included. A review of this offer in the November 17, 2000 IEP does disclose the frequency, location, and duration of the service. The “nature” of the service is designated simply as “speech and language.”
The District argues that there is no legal requirement to indicate whether the service is proposed to be in a group or individually. Although a requirement for an indication of group or individual services per se does not appear in the federal or State law, Cal. Educ. Code section 56345 (3) (A) does require setting forth “the specific special educational instruction and related services and supplemental aids and services to be provided to the pupil...To advance appropriately toward attaining the annual goals.” Speech therapist Rutz described STUDENT’s very basic need to improve his ability to know how to use his mouth, as STUDENT had a limited sense of his own speech apparatus. Mr. Rutz also observed that STUDENT lacked motivation to do oral motor exercises as theses drills were difficult for him. Mr. Rutz said that benefits flowed from both group and individual speech and language therapy and that the classroom experience was “powerful.” He testified that STUDENT’s program included both individual and group services. The IEP, however, does not disclose how much therapy he would receive or whether the therapy would be in a group or individual setting.
The previous IEP meeting held on September 25, 2000 (Elementary District Exhibit 4), with the parents in attendance, included in the notes a response “to the parents’ concern about the need to work on his speech skills which relate to his needs for oral motor practice and training in beginning speech sounds.” The IEP notes continue with a description of “practice and training of oral motor skills related to speaking and eating.” Clearly, STUDENT’s parents were concerned about his ability to eat and swallow safely as well as sound production. There is no specific service indicated in the November 2000 IEP directed toward sound production in spite of direct parental inquiry. It is undisputed that STUDENT had severe delays and an identified need to learn more about his own oral functions, a particularly individual and unique need. He further had an identified motivational obstacle to participation in the appropriate therapies, which also suggests individual attention may be required as an element of the services. The legally required description of “specific special educational instruction and related services” should distinguish between services that address the different aspects of his needs including oral speech. Under these circumstances, his parents were entitled to know what was offered in response to their direct question and how it would be provided. The Hearing Officer finds that the offer of speech and language services in the November 17, 2000 IEP was not sufficiently specific to permit meaningful participation by the parents and potentially deprived Petitioner of educational opportunity.
The February 5, 2001 IEP
Petitioner alleges that the offer of speech and language services in the February 5, 2001 IEP (Elementary District Exhibit 6) also is defective in the absence of an indication that the services are to be group or individual. The Hearing Officer finds that this portion of the February 2001 speech and language offer also constitutes a procedural violation for the reasons set forth, above, for the November 17, 2000 IEP.
Additionally, Petitioner contends that without a statement identifying what kind of augmentative communication device or audio box is offered, STUDENT’s parents could not make an informed decision about their son’s education. The February 2001 IEP provides as an assistive technology device “to meet educational goals and objectives,” an “audio box at home and school.” There is no other mention of the audio box in this IEP. PARENTS had access to the offered audio box for inspection as it came home with STUDENT. The signature page shows both parental and interpreter attendance at this IEP. The evidence indicates that the audio box was introduced at this point to aid in STUDENT’s basic communication. There is no evidence showing that an infringement of parental participation or loss of educational opportunity resulted.
Substantive considerations
The standard by which the District’s instruction and services is measured is set forth in the United States Supreme Court case, Rowley, at 198-200. Under this standard the IEP must be designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, reasonably calculated to provide him some educational benefit, and conform to his IEP. (Footnote 6)
Additionally, the IEP is to prepare the pupil for employment and independent living including vocational training, supported employment, economic self-sufficiency and community participation. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(c) (1); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.1
The Supreme Court in its Rowley decision, at 198-201, does not require the District to provide to the student the best education available or to provide instruction that maximizes his abilities. STUDENT is entitled to have access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to meet his unique needs and to provide educational benefit as a “basic floor of opportunity.”
Academic progress must also be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by STUDENT’s disabilities and must be gauged in relation to his potential. Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997) Moreover, the school district’s offer must be viewed in the context of conditions at the time that is was made and not in hindsight or including speculative or potential future facts. Adams v. Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999)
The legal authorities discussed require a four-part analysis for substantive issues:
1. Is the district’s program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
2. Is the program reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit?
3. Does the program as implemented conform to his IEP?
4. Does the program provide STUDENT the least restrictive environment (As noted in footnote 6 the issue need not be reached for the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years)?
Petitioner contends that the Elementary District denied him a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year by failing to develop appropriate goals and objectives, by failing to provide appropriate types and levels of services, and failing to provide a one-to-one aide.
Was the 2000-2001 program designed to meet Petitioner’s unique needs?
STUDENT’s unique needs
To determine whether the program was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs, it is necessary to determine those needs. There is no dispute that he had significant to severe deficits in cognitive ability, communication, pre-academics, social-emotional adjustment, gross and fine motor skills, and mobility. The parties agree that STUDENT required a small, supervised class setting with individual or small-group instruction. He also needed a quiet environment with material presented in small segments through a multisensory approach and frequent reinforcement and praise.
The 2000-2001 offer for instruction and services
The Elementary District offered in June 2000 to place STUDENT in a special day class for severely handicapped students for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year. He was also offered mobility services for thirty-five minutes once a week, speech therapy for thirty minutes once a week, and occupational/physical therapy consultation “as needed” once a week. All of these services were to be provided in the special day classroom. In September 2000, the District offered STUDENT DTT for fifteen minutes twice a day to include work on his gross motor skills.
Goals and Objectives
The June 19, 2000 IEP
Petitioner challenges the goals and objectives in the June 2000 IEP (Petitioner Exhibit 18) for gross and fine motor coordination asserting that the “complexity of STUDENT’s underlying occupational therapy issues” required an experienced occupational therapist to be the implementer rather than the classroom teacher. He further contends that the social skills goal was not designed to meet his needs because, he argues, the benchmarks do not support the overall goal. He also argues that the communication goal did not help to generalize speech as there was no communicative function for this goal. The District argues that it developed the occupational therapy goals considering his progress while in the Rowland Unified School District and his current needs, which could be addressed by consultation in the classroom by the teacher and aides rather than by direct therapy. The District also argues the social skills were covered through goals in the area of peer relationships. The District states that its oral motor goal objective within the speech goal was designed to elicit speech production.
A statement of the pupil’s present levels of educational performance and a statement of measurable annual goals with benchmarks or short-term objectives directed toward “meeting the pupil’s needs that result from the pupil’s disability” must be included in the IEP. 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56534(a)
The goals and objectives for gross and fine motor skills in the June 19, 2000 IEP include baselines with current functioning levels and detailed benchmarks. For example, a gross motor skill objective calls for STUDENT to kick a rolled ball five feet for three out of five times. The District also has presented persuasive evidence that STUDENT can have his needs effectively met in exercises that are incorporated into his classroom program. There is nothing in the evidence that convincingly demonstrates that his gross and fine motor skills goals and objectives could not have been addressed by the classroom teacher or aide with consultation by an occupational therapist during the 2000-2001 school year.
The communication goal in the June 19, 2000 IEP features oral motor exercises and use of PECS. This goal addresses STUDENT’s severely delayed oral language skills as outlined in the present level of performance. Petitioner argues that specific goals for word approximation and a “language context” for the therapy should have been included. The District, however, argues that “word approximation” and “language” were part of the oral motor exercises. The District’s position was supported by the testimony of Mr. Rutz. The communication goal in the June 2000 IEP, however, does not address STUDENT’s defined needs for oral language. The objectives to have STUDENT “imitate oral motor exercises with 80% accuracy” is directed only to the mechanical part of his need. The present levels in the IEP indicated that as of June 19, 2000, “he can vocalize sounds but does not produce consistent, intelligible speech.” Although there is testimony that speech was part of the oral motor drill as implemented, it does not appear in the goal as required by the statute. The Hearing Officer concludes that this goal was not designed to meet STUDENT’s particular, unique needs for oral communication.
The June 19, 2000 IEP also includes a social and emotional goal designed to “increase social skills.” In this area, the baseline records that STUDENT requires “much verbal prompting to join with classmates.” The benchmark calls for STUDENT to interact independently with peers initially for two minutes without prompts one of three times a week as measured again by the Brigance. The social skills goals meet the requirements of the statute. They were tailored to STUDENT’s needs.
The Hearing Officer finds that, with the exception of the absence of the specific inclusion of oral language as part of the communication goal, the June 19, 2000 goals and objectives were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
The February 5, 2001 IEP
Petitioner also contends that the motor skills goal in the February 5, 2001 IEP (Petitioner Exhibit 24) was inappropriate, because an occupational therapist with specialized training should have been the provider and that there should have been goals for balancing, fine motor skills necessary to use a pencil, peer interaction, transitioning, and attending. As with the goal in this area for the June 19, 2000 IEP discussed above, the District indicates that all of these areas are included in the February 5, 2001 IEP goals to address STUDENT’s needs. The February 2001 IEP has a goal for “on-task behavior” that includes an objective for “transfer to a different activity independently.” This addresses the attending and transitioning issues. There are also goals for spatial perception and hand-eye coordination. For this IEP, also, there is no evidence that STUDENT’s needs could not have been met if the listed activities were not provided by an occupational therapist. The Hearing Officer finds that the motor skills goals in the February 5, 2001 IEP were appropriate and that there was no persuasive evidence that direct occupational therapy was necessary to address Petitioner’s unique needs.
Petitioner argues that the communication goal in the February 2001 IEP does not include oral motor skills in a spoken language context and lacks provision for “letter approximation.” Additionally, Petitioner alleges that the oral motor goal does not address “apraxia,” or the inability to coordinate the tongue and mouth to form words. The District contends that STUDENT does not have apraxia (Footnote 7) and that “letter approximation” is part of the general California curriculum that is not unique to Petitioner as a special education student requiring a goal in his IEP. The District further argues that letter approximation as an objective appears to have been premature for STUDENT in February 2001, as a review of his present levels states that he was not yet able to recognize letters. However, as with the June 19, 2000 IEP, the February 5, 2001 IEP communication goal is not designed to meet STUDENT’s oral speech needs because it solely deals with STUDENT’s “speech apparatus.” The Hearing Officer therefore finds the goal was inappropriate and not designed to meet his unique needs.
Petitioner also further faults the on-task behavior goal under the heading “life skills” as it could not be achieved independently without provisions for prompts. The District defends the goal as a means to meet STUDENT’s need “to attend” without adult monitoring. The objective calls for STUDENT to progress in the curriculum in a small-group setting “with minimal assistance.” Attending to task is a recognized deficit. This goal was designed to meet this need with prompting.
The Hearing Officer finds that, with the exception of the speech aspect of the communication and oral motor goals, the challenged goals and objectives for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs.
2000-2001 services
During the course of the 2000-2001 school year, the Elementary District responded on several occasions to parental requests by increasing STUDENT’s level of services in several areas, including speech and language, occupational therapy, and gross motor skills (Elementary District Exhibits 3, 4, 5, and 6). Petitioner, however, contends that the Elementary District did not offer or provide appropriate types and levels of service in the areas of occupational therapy, discrete trial training, assistive technology, vision therapy, and speech and language therapy. Each of these issues will be discussed below.
Occupational therapy
Petitioner’s occupational therapist witness Laurie Cohen testified that the District’s June 13, 2000 Occupational Therapy and Physical Therapy Report (Petitioner’s Exhibit 58) was too limited and that the services provided did not meet STUDENT’s needs. Ms. Cohen stated that the Elementary District should have offered direct occupational therapy services with particular review of specific skills. During the 2000-2001 school year, the Elementary District continued to provide occupational therapy consultation as needed rather than regular, direct services. STUDENT did receive occupational therapist observation and evaluation of his eating and swallowing at lunch at his parents’ request because they were concerned that he might choke on his food (Elementary District Exhibit 3).
The District argues that when STUDENT came into the District, he had already received extensive occupational therapy and had met his previous goals (Elementary District Exhibits 29, 36). District coordinator for occupational and physical therapy Julie Bissell testified that direct occupational therapy for more than eighteen months to two years is not beneficial. Additionally, she stated that, according to the professional literature, once a child is more than ten years old, and particularly after the onset of puberty, improvement in skills is unlikely. The record shows that STUDENT had been receiving direct therapy for over two years in his previous District. He was over ten years of age when he entered the Elementary District. According to Ms. Bissell, STUDENT’s needs were better met with consultation to allow him to learn to function in a natural setting. The occupational therapist under this arrangement provides activities to the classroom teacher on a regular basis for the teacher to incorporate in the student’s daily program. Both Ms. Bissell and special day class teacher Singer observed over the course of the year that STUDENT progressed toward his occupational therapy goals and displayed none of the tactile defensiveness or coordination problems later referred to by Ms. Cohen in her 2003 assessment. The testimony of Ms. Bissell and Ms. Singer is persuasive, as their testimony is based on multiple observations over the course of the 2000-2001 school year. In contrast, Ms. Cohen assessed STUDENT three years later, primarily in a clinical setting. Additionally, Ms. Cohen did not consult with any of the Elementary District staff before reaching her conclusions. The Hearing Officer finds that the Elementary District’s occupational therapy services during the 2000-2001 school year were appropriate and designed to meet STUDENT’s needs.
Discrete trial training, applied behavioral analysis, and supervision
The Elementary District offered DTT twice a day for fifteen minutes per session in the IEPs dated November 17, 2000, and February 5, 2001 (Petitioner’s Exhibits 22, 24). Petitioner’s witness Jessica Postil, clinic director of Autism Spectrum Consultants, questioned the amount of DTT that the Elementary District offered. The District’s fifteen-minute intervals, she opined, were not intense enough to yield results. Ms. Postil also advocated that DTT be provided by better trained individuals with regular supervision, and stated that constant evaluation to adjust the prompts used in the therapy is a direct benefit of supervision.
Classroom teacher and DTT supervisor Singer stated that originally STUDENT was receiving thirty minutes of DTT but that this was reduced to fifteen-minute sessions as STUDENT could not sit still for the half-hour sessions. The Hearing Officer is convinced that STUDENT’s classroom teacher was in the best position to determine the most effective amount of time that should have been spent on DTT per session and therefore finds that the level of DTT service during the 2000-2001 school year was appropriate to meet STUDENT’s needs. As to the training and supervision provided by the District for the DTT, Ms. Singer testified to both her DTT training and experience as well as that of the aides who administered the therapy to STUDENT. She has studied DTT as well as other related therapies and has provided it in the past in other severely handicapped special day classes. She testified that the aides who worked with STUDENT went through an intensive DTT training program. She also stated that she supervised the providers daily and administered some of the DTT to STUDENT herself. The Hearing Officer is persuaded based on Ms. Singer’s testimony that the District DTT providers were trained, qualified, and appropriately supervised and that the therapy provided was designed to meet Petitioner’s needs.
Assistive Technology
Petitioner argues that additional assistive technology devices should have been considered and offered in the 2000-2001 school year including other augmentative communication devices and a computer and software. The Elementary District argues that the February 5, 2001 IEP (Elementary District Exhibit 6) introduced the audio box and PECS to further the communication goals as required under Cal. Educ. Code section 56341.1(b)(3). As there is insufficient evidence to conclude that as of the 2000-2001 school year a different audio output device or additional assistive technology would have helped STUDENT, the Hearing Officer finds that the level of assistive technology services during the 2000-2001 school year was appropriate to meet his needs.
Vision Therapy
Referring to the testimony of optometrist Dr. Beth Ballinger, Petitioner contends that he should have received vision therapy during the 2000-2001 school year. Dr. Ballinger stated that her examination of STUDENT in September 2003 (Petitioner Exhibit 86) revealed that he did have deficits in eye movement, focusing, eye “teaming,” and visual processing and integration. Dr. Ballinger also said that the 2000-2001 curriculum could have been modified to meet these deficits with accompanying vision therapy. Evidence of STUDENT’s progress in hand-eye coordination, his spontaneous recognition of teachers and school personnel when he encountered them on campus, his mobility, and his use of manipulative materials did not point to an inability to access the curriculum and to progress because of vision deficiencies during the 2000-2001 school year. During this school year, District mobility and vision assessor J. C. Christopherson found that STUDENT had no visual impediment to accessing his curriculum. Ms. Christopherson also observed that STUDENT’s visual skills were “very good” and that vision therapy of the intensity suggested would have been “torturous” for STUDENT at the time. The evidence does not establish that vision therapy was an appropriate service to meet any need that STUDENT had to participate at his level of pre-academic work during the 2000-2001 school year.
Speech and language therapy
The Elementary District offered thirty minutes of speech and language therapy per week during the 2000-2001 school year. Petitioner’s speech and language consultant, Judy Segal, testified that STUDENT needed intensive therapy daily to develop functional communication. The District, however, contends that services in the area of speech and language, as described by District speech therapist Rutz, were appropriately aimed at STUDENT’s significant difficulties. He testified that oral-motor foundations for speech and sound production and the reduction of oral hypersensitivity were the focus. As discussed above with regard to the communication and oral motor goals for this school year, this focus deals with some of STUDENT’s needs in the area of oral language, but not actual word production. The Hearing Officer finds that the services offered were not appropriate to meet all of Petitioner’s needs for oral communication.
One-to-one aide
Petitioner contends that a one-to-one aide should have been provided to STUDENT during the 2000-2001 school year. Because of STUDENT’s history of difficulty with concentration and attention to task, Petitioner’s neuropsychologist Dr. Christine Majors stated that a one-to-one instructional aide would have helped STUDENT access the curriculum and be more organized and focused. The evidence at the hearing, however, depicts a school setting with a teacher or an instructional aide available to assist STUDENT whenever needed. There is no evidence that STUDENT’s needs required a “shadow” aide in addition to the support and supervision of the classroom staff during this school year. With STUDENT’s physical disabilities and cognitive limitations, safety is another legitimate concern. The District witnesses, however, indicated that STUDENT was well supervised at all times. A one-to-one aide could also have led to complete dependency. Encouraging STUDENT’s limited capacity for independence without a single, ever-present aide is consistent with the statutory goal of fostering independent living for special needs youth to the greatest extent feasible as part of a special education program (20 U.S.C. § 1400(c) (1); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.1). Dr. Church, STUDENT’s own physician, recommended in January 2000 before STUDENT enrolled in the Elementary District, that a one-to-one aide for medical reasons was no longer required although he still prescribed “close general supervision (Elementary District Exhibit 47).” The evidence supports a finding that in the 2000-2001 school year STUDENT’s supervision was “close” and “general.” Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the Elementary District’s supervisory arrangement for Petitioner during the 2000-2001 school year was appropriate as it met his needs and that he did not require a one-to-one aide.
For the 2000-2001 school year, the Hearing Officer concludes that, with the exception of the absence of provisions for oral language, the Elementary District’s goals and objectives and types and levels of services were designed to meet Petitioner’s unique needs.
Was the 2000-2001 program calculated to provide Petitioner an educational benefit?
Petitioner also challenged the occupational therapy services for the 2000-2001 school year as not calculated to provide a benefit because the Elementary District did not offer any direct occupational therapy and the services that were provided in the classroom were not provided by an occupational therapist. Overall, in developing the occupational therapy services to address STUDENT’s deficits in fine and gross motor skills, the IEP team would expect him to make progress, and, in fact he did. The February 5, 2001 IEP (Elementary District Exhibit 6) includes present levels of performance showing that STUDENT met his goals in spatial perception, hand-eye coordination, and on-task behavior. As discussed with regard to needs, above, these goals covered the occupational therapy services Petitioner contended were not offered. Because Petitioner made progress during the 2000-2001 school year in his occupational therapy skills, the Hearing Officer finds that the program was calculated to provide a benefit in the area of occupational therapy.
Additionally, Petitioner contends that the oral motor goal in the June 19, 2000 IEP (Petitioner Exhibit 18) was not reasonably calculated to develop oral language as there is no connection between oral motor exercises and speech production. The issue of benefit need not be reached as the Hearing Officer has already found that the June 19, 2000 goal did not meet STUDENT’s needs for oral communication.
Petitioner further challenges the social and emotional goals in the June 2000 IEP contending that the benchmarks did not logically support the overall goal. A review of these benchmarks shows that they call for progressively increasing the duration of peer interaction in one-to-one or small-group settings to work toward the goal to increase social skills. The evidence demonstrates that STUDENT was open to peer contact from his first entry into the Elementary District and continued to make some social progress thereafter. The Hearing Officer finds that the social skills goal was calculated to provide STUDENT an educational benefit.
The Hearing Officer also finds that the remainder of the Elementary District’s 2000-2001 program, with the exception of oral language, was calculated to provide Petitioner an educational benefit.
Did the 2000-2001 program comport with Petitioner’s IEPs?
Petitioner also argues that the District unilaterally changed the amount of the DTT services without parental consent and at variance with the IEPs. The evidence shows that one of the DTT providers was in the hospital for three weeks and no substitute was provided. Referring to the DTT logs (Petitioner Exhibit 154; Elementary District Exhibit 55), Petitioner calculates that thirty-two hours and thirty minutes were not provided as offered. A look at the DTT logs establishes that there may have been either poor record keeping or that DTT was not provided every day STUDENT was in school. Ms. Singer, however, testified that STUDENT receivedDTT in her classroom every day that he was there. She also stated that she would provide the DTT to STUDENT if the instructional aide were not available. She estimated that no more than one week of DTT was missed during the course of the year which she said was not enough to affect progress. The implemented program must comport with the terms of the IEP (Rowley, supra). The Hearing Officer, after consideration of the testimony of Ms. Singer, finds that the DTT services provided substantially comported with the IEPs for the 2000-2001 school year, and that the Elementary District did not intentionally change the frequency without parental consent.
The Hearing Officer finds that, except for the lack of specificity in the November 2000 speech and language offer, the speech aspect of communication and oral motor goals in the June 2000 and February 2001 IEPs, and the oral portion of the speech and language services offered, the Elementary District provided Petitioner a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year.
ISSUE NO. III: Did the Elementary District fail to assess Petitioner in all areas of suspected disability or to conduct appropriate assessments during the 2001-2002 school year?
Similar to his contentions regarding the 2000-2001 school year, Petitioner claims that the Elementary District should have assessed him in the areas of autism, assistive technology, speech and language, occupational therapy, and ABA during the 2001-2002 school year.
A. Autism and applied behavioral analysis
Autism
Petitioner contends that STUDENT’s continuing “patterns of behaviors” in 2001 and 2002, such as IEP references to “difficulty with peer relationships, concentration, and defiance” (Elementary District Exhibit 12) should have continued to alert the Elementary District to the need to assess for autism. Additionally, in November 2001 Dr. Ira Lott, University of California, Irvine (UCI) professor of pediatrics and neurology, rendered a written diagnosis that STUDENT had “secondary autism” that flowed from his other disabilities (Petitioner Exhibit 63). This written diagnosis was presented to the District. There is testimony indicating that the IEP team considered Dr. Lott’s letter by January 2002. No IEP notes, however, document what discussions took place. Dr. Lott’s diagnosis of “secondary autism” is without further definition in the record, although witnesses knowledgeable about autism were unable to define the concept when asked.
In the context of his opinion letter dated November 9, 2001, Dr. Lott said, “This child has a global development delay, which is congenital, with autistic features. He therefore qualifies for a diagnosis of secondary autism.” The Elementary District already knew that STUDENT had global development delays. As discussed with respect to District observations during the 2000-2001 school year, some of STUDENT’s behaviors, such as resistance to disliked tasks, motor skills deficits, and instances of tactile sensitivity, could also be “autistic features.” Classroom teacher Singer and speech therapist Rutz, who both had experience with autism, noted that in contrast to other students previously diagnosed with autism, STUDENT was very social and had good eye contact. The District witnesses attributed the arguably “autistic features” of his behaviors to his severe developmental delays, history of cerebral palsy, and cognitive limitations. Furthermore, Dr. Lott’s “prescription” for STUDENT was “a teacher who is skilled in treating autistic features. The emphasis needs to be on speech, language, and socialization, and he is going to require some occupational therapy given his clumsiness.” Ms. Singer was trained and experienced in teaching autistic children and was implementing IEPs along with other District staff that included goals for STUDENT in all of the areas Dr. Lott lists. The District reasonably kept servicing STUDENT’s unique needs without concluding that autism was a suspected disability. Petitioner was already eligible for special education. The District has a duty to focus on his unique needs irrespective of the qualifying disability. The Hearing Officer finds that the addition of Dr. Lott’s letter did not trigger a new suspected disability that required the Elementary District to pursue assessments for STUDENT in the areas of autism during the 2001-2002 school year.
Applied behavioral analysis
As in the previous school year, Petitioner contends that an ABA assessment should have been conducted. The District again takes the position that ABA is a methodology and not a disability. For the reasons indicated above for the 2000-2001 school year, the Hearing Officer finds the Elementary District had no duty to conduct an ABA assessment during the 2001-2002 school year.
B. Assistive Technology
The Elementary District continued to offer and provide STUDENT with an audio box and PECS during the 2001-2002 school year (Elementary District Exhibit 11). Petitioner argues again for this school year that an assistive technology assessment should have occurred to determine his assistive technology needs, to choose the proper audio output device, and formulate an intervention plan. The District argues that it continued to incorporate assistive technology in developing STUDENT’s communication goals. Assistive technology is to be considered by the IEP team to enhance skill development as appropriate as set forth in Cal. Educ. Code section 56341.1(b)(5). The Hearing Officer finds that there was no obligation to perform as assistive technology assessment during the 2001-2002 school year.
C. Vision
For the 2001-2002 school year, Petitioner repeats his claims asserted for the 2000-2001 school year that a vision assessment should have been performed beyond the May 2000 District report that relied on other evaluations that were approximately three years old at the time. No additional evidence suggests that District staff had any indication that STUDENT could not access his pre-academic curriculum or function in the school environment because of vision problems. Therefore, the Elementary District was not required to do a reassessment in vision during the 2001-2002 school year.
D. Speech and language
STUDENT’s speech and language development continued to be profoundly delayed. The Elementary District did a speech and language assessment in the 2000-2001 school year. There is no indication during the 2001-2002 school year that there were conditions warranting a speech and language reassessment under Cal. Educ. Code section 56381.
E. Occupational therapy
Petitioner contends that an occupational therapy assessment should have followed the report from Dr. Lott (Petitioner Exhibit 63) which recommends occupational therapy services because of STUDENT’s “clumsy characteristics.” Petitioner further claims that the District should have presented to STUDENT’s parents an assessment plan, construing the letter his parents presented from Dr. Lott to be a “referral for assessment” under Cal. Educ. Code section 56029. Dr. Lott’s letter, as noted above, recommends services, including occupational therapy, that the District was already providing. There is nothing in Dr. Lott’s letter that requests an assessment to identify an individual with exceptional needs as provided in Cal. Educ. Code section 56029. The Hearing Officer finds that there is also no evidence of conditions warranting an occupational therapy reassessment by the Elementary District during the 2001-2002 school year.
ISSUE NO. IV: Did the Elementary District fail to offer and to provide Petitioner a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year?
Procedural considerations
As with the prior school year, Petitioner claims that in the 2001-2002 school year DIS descriptions in the IEPs were vague and ambiguous and not described specifically. Additionally, Petitioner alleges that a Vietnamese translator was not present at the March 4, 2002 IEP meeting.
The January 14, 2002 IEP
Speech and language
Petitioner again objects to the speech and language services offer in the January 14, 2002 IEP (Petitioner Exhibit 30) as specifying neither group nor individual services. The speech and language goals and objectives in this IEP call for him to progress “in a large group setting.” As discussed, above, for the 2000-2001 school year, there is insufficient detail in the description of the nature of the speech and language services to reflect an offer that will permit parental participation and not deprive Petitioner of an educational opportunity.
Assistive services
This IEP also offers “assistive services” five times a week for thirty minutes per session. Petitioner contends that this reference is vague, thereby infringing on PARENTS’s opportunity to participate in their son’s IEP and their ability to make informed decisions regarding the offer. MOTHER testified, however, that she understood from the District that this offer of “assistive services” referred to DTT. The December 19, 2002 IEP included a statement referring back to the January 14, 2002 IEP. This statement noted that handwritten notations on a copy of the Elementary District’s January 14, 2002 IEP indicated DTT was provided (Petitioner’s Exhibit 45). There is no evidence when this handwritten explanation of the services was made or whether STUDENT’s parents received a copy of the January 2002 IEP at or near the time of the January 2002 meeting. MOTHER, however, testified that she did know STUDENT was receiving DTT. The Elementary District increased the time allotted to this therapy and continued this service at the parents’ request contrary to professional recommendations to terminate DTT for lack of progress. Cal. Educ. Code section 56345(a)(3) requires the IEP to specify the DIS. Although it is not clear when and how the Elementary District provided greater specificity to the January 2002 IEP with the handwritten notes, it is clear that PARENTS were fully aware of the nature and the duration of the DTT services and were not deprived of knowledgeable participation in the IEP process. STUDENT did not lose any educational opportunity by the manner in which the DTT services were described in the January 2002 IEP.
The March 4, 2002 IEP
Speech and language
Petitioner continues to claim that speech and language services were offered for the 2001-2002 school year without indication of whether they were to be group or individual. Speech and language services appear as “language and speech” in three separate entries in the March 2002 IEP. One entry offers thirty minutes per week in the special day classroom, while the other two entries offer fifteen minutes three time per week and fifteen minutes one time per week, respectively. There is no indication of what specific services are included under each of these three entries, although the January 2002 IEP identifies a speech and language proposal for fifteen minutes three times per week as “sign language,” and the March 2002 IEP notes (Petitioner Exhibit 37) indicate that “oral motor lessons will include increased emphasis on sound production.” The same analysis follows for the 2001-2002 school year as for the 2000-2001 school year. The speech and language portion was not specific enough to allow Petitioner’s parents to evaluate the offer in the March 2002 IEP and earlier IEPs. The Hearing Officer finds that the offer for speech and language in the March 2002 IEP lacks sufficient specificity to allow parent participation in the IEP process and may have deprived Petitioner of an educational opportunity.
Assistive services
Petitioner also contends for the March 2002 IEP that the offer of assistive services was vague. The Hearing Officer finds for the same reasons discussed above regarding the January 2002 IEP, that this reference was sufficiently evident to Petitioner’s parents so that they could participate in the IEP process.
Interpreter
Petitioner also contends that no Vietnamese translator was present for the March 4, 2002 IEP meeting (Petitioner Exhibit 35). The March 2002 IEP was a continuation of the January 14, 2002 IEP meeting at which, according to the signature page, an interpreter was in attendance. There was also testimony from the special day class teacher, Ms. Singer, that an interpreter was present at the March 4 meeting, even though no translator’s signature is in the record for that date. Even if an interpreter was not present, the March 2002 IEP notes indicate that the District increased the services offered in January at the parents’ request. Granting an additional parental request at this meeting, the District expressly changed the student language designation on the first page of the IEP from Vietnamese to English, as “Parents speak English to STUDENT.” As with the IEP meeting on February 5, 2001, even if no translator was present, there is no indication that this additional failure to meet the statutory requirements to provide the interpreter required by Cal. Educ. Code section 56342(h) prevented STUDENT’s parents from participating effectively in the English language in his education or deprived STUDENT of any educational opportunity.
With the exception of the provisions dealing with oral language, discussed above, the Hearing Officer finds no procedural violations of FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year.
Substantive considerations
For the 2001-2002 school year, Petitioner further takes issue with the level and type of occupational therapy, DTT, assistive technology, and vision services he received. He also repeats from 2000-2001 his contention that the District should have provided a one-to-one aide and that the DTT implementation did not conform to his IEPs.
Was the 2001-2002 program designed to meet Petitioner’s unique needs?
STUDENT’s unique needs
STUDENT’s needs were unchanged in 2001-2002 from those indicated for the 2000-2001 school year.
The 2001-2002 offer for instruction and services
STUDENT’s placement and services from the Elementary District were substantially the same but with sign language specifically indicated and additional time allocated to DTT and speech and language.
Occupational Therapy
Petitioner refers to the testimony of occupational therapist Cohen that he needed direct occupational therapy during this school year because of his fine and gross motor deficits, including his inability to print. Petitioner contends that no offer or discussion of occupational therapy services appear in the June 21, 2001 or the March 4, 2002 IEPs (Petitioner Exhibits 28, 35).
The District argues that it considered STUDENT’s needs and formulated goals to meet his needs. The IEP dated January 14, 2002 (Petitioner Exhibit 30) includes in STUDENT’s present levels of performance a discussion of both his fine and gross motor skills. As of the 2001-2002 school year STUDENT could not write or recognize his own name, suggesting that an occupational therapy goal to aid in printing as argued by Petitioner would not have met his current needs at the time. The testimony of the District witnesses and the previous IEP entries persuade the Hearing Officer that STUDENT’s occupational therapy needs were being met in the classroom setting.
Discrete trial training
For the 2001-2002 school year, Petitioner also alleges that the Elementary District did not offer sufficient DTT. The District contends that the DTT services did not provide STUDENT more than de minimis progress toward meeting his needs. Ms. Singer testified that DTT was simply not working. She also gave the opinion that STUDENT was too old for this methodology, which is usually a strategy for much younger children. She described how STUDENT would get confused easily during DTT, often simply guessing before he responded, and was generally unsuccessful. Petitioner’s autism consultant, Ms. Postil acknowledged that it would not be reasonable to continue an ABA-type program if the child is not succeeding. The Hearing Officer finds that the testimony of Ms. Singer is convincing that more DTT was unnecessary to meet STUDENT’s then-current needs.
Assistive technology
The Elementary District offered and provided STUDENT with PECS, an audio box, and sign language for the 2001-2002 school year. Petitioner contends that additional assistive technology such as a computer and computer programs also should have been included. The District responds that the assistive technology offered as part of Petitioner’s program was appropriate to develop expressive communication. As discussed for the 2000-2001 school year, assistive technology must be considered by the IEP team as a means to aid the pupil in meeting his or her goals under Cal. Educ. Code section 56341.1(b)(5). The IEPs for the 2001-2002 school year show that this was done. There is no persuasive evidence to suggest that computers and software also were essential aids to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in communication or any other area during the 2001-2002 school year. The Hearing Officer finds the Elementary District’s 2001-2002 provision of assistive technology to be appropriate aids to meeting STUDENT’s goals.
Vision therapy
Petitioner renews his assertion for the 2001-2002 school year that the Elementary District should have provided vision therapy based on the 2003 report from Dr. Ballinger. The District also maintains its position for this year that STUDENT had no vision needs that prevented him from accessing his school work. As in the 2000-2001 school year, there are no data in the record to show that STUDENT had a need for any type of vision therapy or further correction to access his pre-academic curriculum in the 2001-2002 school year.
Speech and language therapy
For the 2001-2002 school year, Petitioner again claims that the speech and language services were inappropriate and insufficient time was spent on the therapy. The Elementary District asserts that it provided individual and group therapy and assistive technology with PECS and an audio box for STUDENT. He also was receiving instruction in sign language. As in the previous school year, however, the Hearing Officer finds that although the Elementary District did provide appropriate nonverbal language services, its speech and language therapy was not designed to meet his needs for speech production during the 2001-2002 school year.
One-to-one aide
Petitioner repeats his claim for the 2001-2002 school year that STUDENT should have had a one-to-one aide. As discussed, above, for the 2000-2001 school year, the Elementary District had instructional one-on-one assistance and supervision on the school campus. There is no indication that STUDENT’s needs required the addition of a one-to-one aide for the 2001-2002 school year.
Was the 2001-2002 program calculated to provide Petitioner an educational benefit?
Petitioner repeats in the 2001-2002 school year the contention that the occupational therapy goals and objectives were not calculated to provide him a benefit. The January 30, 2002 IEP (Elementary District Exhibit 12) outlines the progress STUDENT had made in balance and movement activities. The District continued to provide occupational therapy consultation that maintained specific exercises in the classroom setting. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s occupational therapy program was calculated to provide a benefit and did in fact confer a benefit on Petitioner.
The Hearing Officer already determined above that the absence of an oral speech segment rendered the language program deficient to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Therefore, the issue of whether the speech portion of the language program was calculated to confer a benefit need not be discussed. The Hearing Officer finds that the balance of the Elementary District’s 2001-2002 program was calculated to provide Petitioner with an educational benefit.
Did the 2001-2002 program comport with Petitioner’s IEPs?
Petitioner alleges again in the 2001-2002 school year that the DTT implementation did not follow his IEPs as set forth in the June 21, 2001 and March 4, 2002 IEPs (Petitioner Exhibits 28, 35). Although the IEPs called for DTT for thirty minutes per day, Petitioner points to the log books (Elementary District Exhibit 55) to show many days that the specified services were not provided. Petitioner calculates that sixty-five half hour sessions were missing from the DTT logs. As with the log entries for the 2000-2001 school year, the missing entries could be the result of poor record keeping although classroom teacher Singer testified that she or the aides would note STUDENT’s progress daily. She also stated that she would administer the DTT if an aide were unavailable. The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Singer supports substantial implementation of the IEPs for DTT for the 2001-2002 school year and no intentional reduction of services.
The Hearing Officer finds that, with the exception of communication and oral motor goals and the oral portion of the speech and language services offered, the Elementary District provided Petitioner a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year.
ISSUE NO. V: Did the High School District during the 2002-2003 school year fail to assess Petitioner in all areas of suspected disability or to conduct appropriate assessments?
Petitioner asserts that after he transferred to the High School District for the 2002-2003 school year, the High School District failed to assess him in all areas of suspected disability including autism and ABA. Petitioner also contends that the District failed to conduct appropriate assessments of his educational and social/emotional needs in vision, assistive technology, speech and language, occupational therapy, behavioral functioning, and autism. The District counters that its 2002-2003 assessments were conducted in an appropriate manner and it did not fail to assess in any area of suspected disability as required by Cal. Educ. Code section 56320 (f).
An assessment must conform with Cal. Educ. Code sections 56320 and 56322 to be deemed appropriate. Additionally, psychological assessments must be conducted by a credentialed school psychologist under Cal. Educ. Code section 56324. Subsections (a) through (d) of section 56320, require that testing and assessment materials and procedures be selected and administered in a manner not to be racially, culturally or sexually discriminatory; provided and administered in the student’s primary language or other mode of communication; be validated for the purposes for which they are used; administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; tailored to assess specific areas of need; and selected and administered to ensure that, when administered to a pupil with impaired speaking skills, the test produces results that accurately reflect the student’s aptitude, achievement level, or any other factors the test purports to measure and not the student’s impaired speaking skills. The assessor also must be knowledgeable of the student’s disability. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320 (g)
A. Autism and applied behavioral analysis
Autism
Petitioner contends that autism was an area of suspected disability that the High School District should have assessed. The High School District’s multidisciplinary assessment in March 2003 (High School District Exhibit 26) included results of the Gilliam Autism Rating Scale (GARS) that indicated the probability STUDENT had autism was “very low.” Petitioner argues that the GARS is only a screening tool to see if further assessment is warranted. The Hearing Officer finds that the results from the GARS, even if it is only a screening device, do not present conditions warranting any further assessment in the area of autism as a suspected disability.
Petitioner also contends that the administration of the GARS was inappropriate. He disputes the manner in which District psychologist Donna Erickson conducted the GARS. At the crux of Petitioner’s criticism is the partially completed protocol that was first offered as evidence by Petitioner (Petitioner Exhibit 80). Petitioner argues that the test results are invalid as the test manual requires all of the questions to be answered. FATHER testified that he took both the GARS and the other protocols home to complete. He said that he brought them back without answering all of the questions as he was not certain what some of them meant. He stated that Ms. Erickson said that it was not necessary to complete all of the answers and that he did not complete the protocols with Ms. Erickson.
The District argues that the GARS, along with the other tests in the psychological assessment portion of the multidisciplinary report, was administered substantially in compliance with the law. District psychologist Donna Erickson, whose background includes working with special needs children as an administrator, psychologist, and program specialist (High School District Exhibit 70), administered the GARS and the other psychological tests. The GARS test, the only standardized measurement dealing with autism in evidence, relied upon data furnished by STUDENT’s teachers and parents to reach a result. She agreed that the test instructions required that all of the questions be answered. Ms. Erickson testified that upon FATHER’s return with the partially completed protocols for the psychological assessment, the two of them worked on the documents for over one hour. Before the conclusion of the hearing, Ms. Erickson located the original, completed protocol, which had been misplaced, and presented it to the Hearing Officer (High School District Exhibit 73). She was at a loss to explain the incomplete protocol presented by Petitioner (Petitioner Exhibit 80). She stated that she had been on vacation when the documents were requested and that the originals were found in storage during the hearing.
Petitioner argues that with this discrepancy in the evidence, the GARS results should be looked at with caution. The GARS relies upon teacher questionnaires as well as parental input, and a review of the GARS shows that the results of the parents’ questionnaire are consistent with the observations by school personnel. The Hearing Officer finds the test results reliable based on this consistency and Ms. Erickson’s credible testimony. According to the documentary and testimonial evidence, Ms. Erickson is qualified to administer psychological tests as an experienced and credentialed school psychologist. She chose a test instrument tailored to assess the specific area in question, followed the test manual, and followed the proper procedures. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the High School District did appropriately conduct the GARS.
Applied behavioral analysis (ABA)
Petitioner contends that the High School District ignored three requests for an ABA assessment (Petitioner Exhibits 45, 50, 108). Petitioner argues that these requests should have yielded an assessment plan from the District as written referrals for assessment pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code section 56029. Petitioner further states that an ABA assessment was necessary to determine if a resumption of DTT services he received from the Elementary District would be appropriate.
The District asserts that it did follow up on the requests and determined that ABA therapies were not suitable for STUDENT at his age and with his cognitive ability and were not appropriate for any areas of STUDENT’s suspected disability. The District refers to the first two requests for an ABA assessment that arose during IEP meetings. The December 19, 2002 IEP meeting notes (Petitioner Exhibit 45) reflect that DTT “was discussed at length” and that “MOTHER is requesting an ABA assessment for DTT.” The notes state that the High School District will check with the Elementary District about DTT and “will consider the request and respond to the parents at a later date.”
The evidence shows that the High School District did follow up on the issue of ABA with the Elementary District. The January 7, 2003 IEP (Petitioner Exhibit 47) summarized the inquiries special day class teacher Ken Seefeldt made of the Elementary District and the conclusion that DTT provided STUDENT no significant benefit. This IEP further documented “a disagreement in regard to providing DTT” and that “Parents are aware of their due process rights.” The notes further indicate that the Procedural Safeguards would be translated into the Vietnamese language and provided to the parents. The District’s stated position was that “the Team has previously responded that they/the district does not see the need for this, however, the district will consider the request and issue a written response.”
On April 11, 2003, Petitioner’s attorney made a written request for an ABA assessment (Petitioner Exhibit 50) citing 20 U.S.C. section 1414(a)(2)(A) and Cal. Educ. Code section 56381 to support the parents’ belief that an ABA assessment was needed to see if DTT is appropriate and to achieve “a current and accurate reflection of STUDENT’s educational needs.” The High School District counsel responded in a letter on April 28, 2003 (Petitioner Exhibit 108), that discussions at the January 7, 2003 IEP meeting included information from the Elementary District that STUDENT had not benefitted from DTT. Because of this information, the letter continued, the assessment plan dated January 13, 2003, had no provision for an ABA assessment. The parents signed the plan as proposed by the District on January 30, 2002, after they made a written request for clarification.
The evidence shows, by IEP meeting discussions and correspondence from District counsel, that the High School District was responsive and stated to STUDENT’s parents its reasons for not pursuing an ABA assessment. The results of the GARS in March 2003, which showed a low probability that STUDENT was autistic, reinforced the District’s position. The Hearing Officer finds, consistent with the course taken by the Elementary District during the two prior years, that there were no suspected disabilities or conditions warranting consideration of an ABA assessment during the 2002-2003 school year.
B. Vision
Petitioner alleges that the High School District should have assessed his vision because his most recent report was by the Elementary District in May 2000. The District contends that it did perform an adequate vision assessment as part of school nurse Esther Soe’s February 25, 2003 report (High School District Exhibit 20) and had no other indication from its assessors that there was a need to assess vision further. Petitioner dismisses the assessment as inappropriate to determine his visual needs. The nurse’s report states that the assessor was unable to measure STUDENT’s visual acuity as he was unable to follow a hand chart. This fact, according to optometrist Dr. Ballinger, should have triggered a reference to a vision specialist. The nurse’s report, however, does observe that STUDENT “wears glasses daily, is able to track well, good reflexes noted.” It should be noted that in 2003, Dr. Ballinger found STUDENT’s vision to be 20/20 in both eyes with his glasses (Petitioner Exhibit 86). There was no evidence of a vision problem during the 2002-2003 school year that interfered with STUDENT’s ability to access his educational program. The Hearing Officer finds that, during the 2002-2003 school year, the High School District performed an appropriate vision assessment and reasonably did not pursue further assessment in the absence of any conditions warranting such action.
C. Assistive technology
Petitioner contends that the High School District’s assistive technology screening summary (High School District Exhibit 4) was inappropriate as it was not comprehensive. The High School District supports its screening, stating that it appropriately considered STUDENT’s multiple disabilities, clinical observations, and consultation with teachers and staff. District specialeducation teacher and assistive technology specialist Kathy Lewis, who conducted the screening, testified that she made recommendations based on her clinical observations and record review. She recommended a specific, single switch audio output device, called “One Step,” that “should be paired with picture symbols for STUDENT to make choices, say words, and make daily greetings.” Ms. Lewis explained in the report that she recommended the particular device “to develop STUDENT’s expressive communication and understanding of the communicative intent of a voice out put device.” She testified that the selection of this audio output device followed the clinical phase of her assessment during which she observed STUDENT’s comprehension difficulties while testing devices with one, four, and sixteen “targets.” She also recommended computer hardware and software with a specific type of large keyboard, such as “IntelliKeys,” that STUDENT was able to use more effectively in her clinical session. She further suggested using picture symbols to encourage STUDENT’s communication. This assessment matched assistive technology to the development and level of STUDENT’s program. Following the recommendations in the assessment would allow the IEP team to help him progress toward his goals as called for under Cal. Educ. Code section 56341.1(b)(5). The evidence shows that the assessor was qualified to conduct this assessment. She proceeded in a manner consistent with Petitioner’s communication disabilities to reach a result. The Hearing Office finds that the assistive technology screening summary covered all areas of concern for STUDENT’s program and was appropriate.
D. Speech and language
Petitioner alleges that the High School District’s speech and language evaluation (High School District Exhibit 25), completed in March 2003, did not appropriately assess STUDENT’s oral motor capabilities in the context of language production. Petitioner’s speech consultant, Judy Segal, stated that the District should have administered the Kaufman Speech Praxis Test for Children to evaluate oral motor functioning and the sounds that STUDENT could make. Ms. Segal concluded that STUDENT’s oral communication should be the focus of intensive therapy. By administering the Kaufman Speech Praxis Test for Children, she indicated that she could determine what vowels, consonants, and words STUDENT could articulate. She concluded that STUDENT had apraxia, a motor planning disorder that could be addressed through therapy.
The District argues that its speech and language evaluation “substantially complied with the Education Code and that there is no showing of prejudice to the Student.” District speech and language pathologists Karin Daignault and Kathleen Wohlgemuth prepared the assessment. They administered the Preschool Language Scale-3 (PLS), the Receptive-Expressive Emergent Language Test-2 (REEL-2), the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test, Third Edition, and the Expressive One-word Picture Vocabulary Test. They concluded that STUDENT was “nonverbal.” Therefore, they recommended that nonverbal communication strategies be pursued and that further speech therapy be terminated as “prognosis for further improvement in oral language skills is considered to be very poor.” Both Ms. Daignault and Ms. Wohlgemuth present strong professional credentials. Their assessment is detailed and refers to STUDENT’s medical and therapeutic history. They evaluated STUDENT’s oral motor coordination deficits, observing his tongue and lip movements. Ms. Daignault and Ms. Wohlgemuth noted that although STUDENT could move his tongue in all directions, he could not completely control its placement, including elevating the tip of his tongue to his palate. They also noticed tremors as he moved his tongue and minimal muscle control. They concluded from these observations that his overall oral range of motion was “inadequate for production of functional intelligible speech.” They diagnosed his speech unintelligibility to be largely a result of inability to blend sounds and decreased oral motor ability. They remarked that STUDENT’s progress from his past speech and language services had been “minimal.”
Ms. Daignault testified that Ms. Segal’s findings were contrary to classroom observations. Apraxia, she stated, was not supported in her observations of STUDENT, as cognitive deficits and muscle weakness must be first ruled out. Ms. Daignault and Ms. Wohlgemuth observed of STUDENT’s oral motor skills that he “moved in an immature, uncoordinated fashion” and that he “was not able to demonstrate lingual tip control or fine motor lingual control...STUDENT’s overall range of motion was observed to be inadequate for production of functional speech.” Ms. Daignault and Ms. Wohlgemuth advocated development and reinforcement of a “functional communication system” not relying on speech. Although Petitioner disputes this recommendation, which is discussed below, the District’s assessment is based on a thorough examination, record review, and specifically addresses STUDENT’s oral motor skills. As the evidence shows that this assessment was conducted by qualified and experienced assessors who employed proper instruments and procedures as required by Cal. Educ. Code sections 56320 and 56322, the Hearing Officer finds the speech and language evaluation to be appropriate.
E. Occupational therapy
Petitioner claims that the High School District’s occupational therapy assessment (High School District Exhibit 6), conducted in September 2002, was inappropriate as it did not assess in all areas of suspected need and did not employ standardized testing. The District countered that GASELPA occupational therapist Karen du Preez, who completed the assessment, has extensive experience and observed Petitioner is the classroom, the lunchroom, and in the adapted physical education class. She also reviewed records, including the Elementary District’s June 2002 occupational therapy assessment. She observed that STUDENT could manipulate objects and tools functionally in his school environment and move around the campus. There was no requirement that Ms. du Preez conduct standardized tests for this reassessment. Cal. Educ. Code section 56381 requires review of existing assessment data on the pupil and input from the pupil’s parents and mandates further tests or “assessment materials” only if the assessor concludes that additional data are necessary. Ms. du Preez persuasively testified that she did not deem additional data necessary after her review of prior assessments, extensive observations, and interviews, including with STUDENT’s parents. The report does address motor planning skills, one of the areas Petitioner contends was omitted from his program, as a part of the report’s discussion of how STUDENT moves through his environment. Ms. du Preez recommended a continuation of consultation services along with a number of specific suggestions for school and home. Ms. du Preez’s results are consistent with the conclusions of prior qualified assessors. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s occupational therapy assessment was appropriate.
F. Behavioral assessments
Petitioner is taking issue with the behavioral assessments that were included in the psychological assessments conducted by school psychologist Donna Erickson in the High School District’s multidisciplinary report (High School District Exhibit 26). As he did with the GARS portion of the report, discussed above, Petitioner argues that the Burks Behavior Rating Scale and the Vineland, which both rely on input from the parents, were not completed in accordance with the test makers’ directions as the protocols filled out by the parents were not completed. The positions of the parties are the same for the Burks and Vineland as they were for the GARS. These tests were administered at the same time. Petitioner also contends that the Vineland was not administered in an interview format as required in the test manual. The Hearing Officer, however, finds Ms. Erickson’s testimony persuasive that she did interview FATHER in connection with completing the Vineland protocol. Petitioner offered partially completed protocols (Petitioner Exhibit 81) and the District produced the completed protocols during the hearing (High School District Exhibit 73). The Burks and Vineland evaluate observed behavior with input from parents and teachers. The Burks results report that the teacher observed “poor coordination.” The parents’ comments include”poor coordination” but also “excessive withdrawal,” “excessive dependency,” and “poor attention.” The Vineland results are reported in age equivalents. Both the parents and the teacher input yielded scores placing STUDENT within the one-year-three-month to three-year range.
Although there are some differences in the observations between the parents and the teacher, the results are relatively consistent to support the assessor’s conclusion that STUDENT functions in the moderate to severe range of significantly below average cognitive and adaptive behavior skills for his age. The Hearing Officer therefore makes the determination that the results are reliable. A review of the psychological portion of the District’s multidisciplinary report shows the employment of standardized tests tailored to assess the specific area in question. The results of these tests are reasonably consistent with other assessments in the record, including the findings of Petitioner’s neuropsychologist, Dr. Christine Majors, with regard to cognitive ability. The assessment results and the credible testimony of Ms. Erickson, a credentialed and experienced school psychologist and administrator in the special education field, establish that the protocols for the High School District’s multidisciplinary report were administered in accordance with the test makers’ instructions. The Hearing Officer finds that the High School District conducted appropriate behavioral assessments in the psychological portion of the multidisciplinary report.
ISSUE NO. VI: Did the High School District fail to offer and to provide Petitioner a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2002-2003 school year, and extended school year?
The High School District first participated on the IEP team at the January 2002 annual IEP meeting through school psychologist Donna Erickson while STUDENT was still enrolled in the Elementary District to consider placement and services starting during the High School District’s extended school year on June 24, 2002 (Petitioner Exhibit 36). The IEP additionally proposed speech and language for thirty minutes per week, mobility services for thirty minutes per month, and sign language fifteen minutes three time per week, all to commence on September 4, 2002. The proposed offer also provided for adapted physical education. The January IEP meeting continued on March 4, 2002, without parental approval of the proposed offer. This continuance was to allow participation by a regional center case worker and further review of goals, objectives and services levels to consider input from PARENTS. The program offer, in the March 4, 2002 IEP, as outlined on an Elementary District form, included a special day class, “assistive services,” (Footnote 8) speech and language, orientation and mobility, and modified physical education (Petitioner Exhibit 35). The parents approved the placement and services in this IEP. The signature page indicates, however, that the High School District did not participate in the March 2002 continuation of STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting.
The April 19, 2002 IEP (Petitioner Exhibit 38) recorded the High School District placement offer at Hope School for the 2002-2003 school year and acknowledged the parents’ request for placement at Orangeview Junior High School after the parents visited Hope School, Orangeview, and the District’s Lexington Junior High School. Although this IEP indicated that STUDENT was offered no mainstreaming, it nevertheless did offer regular program participation in assemblies, field trips, school activities, and community-based instruction. STUDENT’s parents consented to the April 2002 IEP.
The next IEP meeting was held on July 9, 2002. The notes to the July IEP state that the High School District deferred to PARENTS and offered the severely handicapped special day class at Orangeview Junior High School. The District also offered speech and language for thirty minutes twice a week, mobility services once a month, and modified physical education. The IEP was agreed to by the parents and implemented by the District. Subsequent IEP meetings in September and October resulted in modifications to the IEP at the request of the parents. The September IEP changed the modified physical education offer to adapted physical education. At the October 2002 IEP meeting, the mobility training was increased to forty minutes per week. In November 2002, the parents rescinded their consent to the July 2002 IEP (Petitioner Exhibit 95). (Footnote 9) Three IEP meetings were held after the parents withdrew their consent during the balance of the 2002-2003 school year in December 2002, January 2003 (the annual IEP meeting), and April 2003. During these meetings, the team continued to discuss STUDENT’s levels of performance, assessments, and disputed areas such as DTT and ABA assessment, mainstreaming, and oral speech therapy.
Because the High School District made its original offer in July 2002, with modifications in September and October 2002, and then made another offer at the annual IEP meeting in January 2003, the Hearing Officer will address the issue of FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year within two time periods: July 2002 to the annual IEP on January 2003, and January 2003 through the end of the extended school year. Petitioner contends that the High School District denied him a FAPE on both procedural and substantive grounds during these time periods.
The 2002-2003 school year from July 9, 2002, to January 7, 2003
Procedural considerations
Participation of teachers in July 2002 IEP meeting
Petitioner contends that there was neither a general education teacher nor a special education teacher present at the July 9, 2002 IEP meeting, which seriously infringed upon PARENTS’s ability to participate in the IEP process. The District argues that lack of a general education teacher at this IEP meeting did not cause Petitioner any educational harm. The District also argues that the parents waived the right to have any teachers present. The purpose of this meeting, as described in the IEP (High School District Exhibit 2), was to discuss school placement at the parents’ request. District program specialist Marilyn Bakarich, who was the administrator designee at this IEP meeting, testified that no teachers were on duty on that date. The notes of this mid-summer meeting also record that “parents waived their right to not [sic] have a teacher present.” The evidence shows that this IEP includes an express waiver of a known right to have a general education and special education teacher present as provided in Cal. Educ. Code section 56341. Whether this waiver is effective to overcome the violation of law not to have the teachers present need not be reached. There is no evidence that the parents were deprived of involvement in the IEP process or that there was any loss to STUDENT of educational opportunities. To the contrary, this IEP team accepted the placement at Orangeview Junior High School that the parents requested over the District’s original recommendation for Hope School. Although there was no general education or special education teacher present, the Hearing Officer finds no denial of FAPE resulted because of the absence of a general education teacher and a special education teacher.
Parental consent
Petitioner further contends that the High School District improperly terminated DTT services and provided occupational services without parental consent.
DTT services
Petitioner contends that DTT services were terminated without parental permission, whereas the District argues that by mutual consent the DTT services were never provided by the High School District. The District contends that Petitioner’s parents signed and initialed the July 9, 2002 IEP (High School District Exhibit 2) that approved an offer of DIS that did not include DTT services to Petitioner. The July 2002 IEP notes specifically state that DTT will not be continued in the High School District. The District further argues that there was no dissent expressed by or on behalf of the parents at this IEP meeting or at two subsequent meetings on September 26, 2002, and October 21, 2002, with translators present (Petitioner Exhibits 42, 43). Therefore the District properly did not provide DTT as a service at the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year.
Although PARENTS consented to the provisions of the July 2002 IEP, they revoked their consent on November 19, 2002 (Petitioner Exhibit 95), after these two additional IEP meetings had been held. A review of this revocation letter shows a blanket revocation although DTT is the only service that is expressly mentioned. The letter, written by an advocate on behalf of PARENTS, invoked misunderstanding of the “content and ramifications” of the July 2002 IEP because of asserted language difficulties, even though an interpreter had been present to translate the oral proceedings and written documents at each of these IEP meetings. (Footnote 10) The record is clear that in November 2002, PARENTS had made their wishes known that they wanted DTT in STUDENT’s program, just as he had had in the Elementary District. DTT was not part of STUDENT’s offered program with parental approval under the terms of the July 2002 IEP through the date of the revocation of consent on November 19, 2002. The Hearing Officer, however, need not reach the consent issue, in light of his finding, below, that DTT is inappropriateness for DTT in STUDENT’s program for the 2002-2003 school year.
Occupational therapy
Petitioner argues that providing him with occupational therapy consultation was improper as it was without parental consent. The District responds that Petitioner had not received any direct occupational therapy services since before his enrollment in the Elementary District. The High School District continued providing occupational therapy consultation with the special day class teacher for services in the classroom just as he had received while in the Elementary District.
The October 21, 2002 IEP (Petitioner Exhibit 43) provided for occupational therapy consultation services “as needed,” but Petitioner’s parents did not consent to this IEP. (Footnote 11) This is the IEP meeting that included discussion of the occupational therapy assessment. It was at this time, the parents contend, that they first learned STUDENT was receiving consultative occupational therapy services after he moved to the High School District. A review of the record shows that Petitioner continually received consultative occupational therapy services and no direct services from the time he entered the Elementary District. Moreover, Petitioner’s parents have been very involved on the IEP team with respect to occupational therapy and have been instrumental in forming STUDENT’s program in adapted physical education, mobility training, and feeding issues. The March 2002 IEP, which the parents had approved, included goals in occupational therapy although the role of an occupational therapist as a consultant or otherwise was not stated except for the parent-requested “recommendations to ensure that STUDENT eats safely.”
The District appears to argue that no consent is required as the occupational services were not direct. Cal. Educ. Code section 56346 (a), however, expressly requires written consent to “all or part” of the IEP. Consultative services for implementation in the classroom were part of STUDENT’s program and required parental consent as did every other aspect whether “direct” or not. Although Petitioner’s parents do not specifically state that occupational therapy consultative services were a basis for their withholding of consent to the October 2002 IEP, PARENTS did not consent to any part of the District’s consultative occupational therapy program before, on, or after that date. The record shows that STUDENT made progress in occupational therapy and related goals. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that, although the parents did not provide consent for the consultative occupational therapy services implemented by the District, there was no resulting harm.
Parental request
Petitioner also argues that the High School District did not respond timely to his parents’ request for an IEP meeting. Petitioner’s parents made an October 30, 2002 request (Petitioner Exhibit 93) to convene an IEP meeting on November 18, 2002, which is within the thirty days required by Cal. Educ. Code section 56343.5 for the District to set the meeting. (Footnote 12) The next IEP meeting, according to the evidence, was on December 19, 2002 (Petitioner Exhibit 45), beyond the thirty-day time requirement. The District states that it made efforts to schedule the meeting in accordance with the availability of all the participants. The parents’ request gave no alternatives to the date of November 18. The record shows continuing District efforts to schedule this meeting (Petitioner Exhibits 93, 94, 95). The District did, however, violate its duty to set the meeting within the thirty-day statutory requirement. There is no evidence, however, that this delay interfered with parental participation in the process or deprived Petitioner of educational opportunity, particularly in light of the evidence, that the delay was for the purpose of obtaining parental participation with all of the necessary team members present.
Substantive considerations
The same pattern of analysis follows with the High School District’s offer and implementation of Petitioner’s program as with the Elementary District. To determine if the High School District provided a FAPE, the standards of Rowley, supra, and the IDEA are applied to determine whether the District’s program was designed to meet Petitioner’s unique needs, calculated to provide to him some educational benefit, comports with his IEP, and provides the least restrictive environment.
Did the High School District program address Petitioner’s unique needs from July 9, 2002, to January 7, 2003?
STUDENT’s unique needs
As of the summer of 2002, STUDENT’s needs remained the same as they were while he attended the Elementary District. Because of his developmental delays, he required a small classroom setting with individual or small-group instruction. He continued to require instruction and services that addressed his skills in social interaction, coordination and mobility, and both oral communication and nonverbal communication.
The July 9, 2002 IEP
The July 9, 2002 IEP (Petitioner Exhibit 39) is on a High School District form and is designated “new” and for “incoming 7th grader.” It indicates that STUDENT’s handicapping conditions are visual impairment, mental retardation, orthopedic impairment, and speech disorder. The offered instructional setting is in a special day class for the severely handicapped at Orangeview Junior High School. The services listed were speech and language twice a week, mobility training once a month, and modified physical education. The IEP team did not develop new goals and objectives for the July IEP. The July 9, 2002 IEP refers to the March 4, 2002 IEP as the last IEP with objectives. The July 2002 IEP also approves a “late start” for STUDENT as requested by his parents, allowing him to come to school after his morning medications. The team agreed to conduct an assistive technology screening, as the evidence suggests that STUDENT had limited success with the audio output device that he had in the Elementary District. The IEP team also agreed to an occupational therapy assessment in light of his history of balance and coordination problems. The appropriateness of the services offered in the July 2002 IEP will be discussed below.
The October 21, 2002 IEP
The IEP team met again on October 12, 2002, to review the assistive technology screening and the occupational therapy assessment approved at the July 2002 meeting. Petitioner argues that the communication goals developed at the October 21, 2002 IEP meeting (Petitioner Exhibit 43) (Footnote 13) are “vague and immeasurable” because they lacked in some cases who would measure the progress and what percentage of accuracy was sought. A review of these goals, however, shows that the underlying objectives indicate the teacher, parents, aide, STUDENT, or speech and language pathologist as the persons responsible. Although there are blanks in two of the objectives for the communication goal in the October 2002 IEP on the lines labeled “as measured by,” the speech and language pathologist is listed as the person measuring the performance for the third objective that specifically relates to sign language and provides for eighty percent accuracy. It would have been desirable to indicate that a particular person was responsible for measuring each of the other two objectives. These objectives call for STUDENT to use a computer and software with a mouse to support his math skills and use of a larger keyboard for letter and number recognition. It is apparent from this set of objectives that the teacher and aide, who are listed among the responsible persons for this goal, would do the measuring of the first two objectives. Moreover, these two objectives are qualitative rather than quantitative and can be simply assessed as either met or not. The Hearing Officer finds that the missing entries in these instances are de minimis and do not interfere with the goals and objectives otherwise addressing STUDENT’s needs in this area. Conspicuously absent, however, is any oral communication goal. The Hearing Officer has found that oral communication is one of Petitioner’s needs; therefore, the IEP should have included goals and objectives to meet that need.
Placement
Although Petitioner requested and approved the placement offered in the July 2002 IEP, he alleged at hearing that the placement was inappropriate. Petitioner now contends that his placement in the special day class for the severely handicapped at Orangeview Junior High School for the 2002-2003 school year did not meet his unique needs because the teacher lacked skills in teaching children with autism and both the teacher and classroom aide lacked mastery of sign language; there was not appropriate supervision; and there was no one-to-one aide. The District asserts that the placement was appropriate in all of the disputed areas. STUDENT was in Mr. Ken Seefeldt’s special day class for the entire school day. He participated in adapted physical education. His only regular education program participation was during lunch, recess, passing periods, assemblies, field trips, and school activities.
Whether his teacher should have been trained in teaching children with autism, the District contends that STUDENT is not autistic and his “autistic-like” symptoms are not educationally significant. The District’s program is to be designed to address his needs. There is no showing that autism training was required to assist the classroom teacher and staff in addressing STUDENT’s needs. (Footnote 14)
Petitioner also asserts that the teacher and aides lacked mastery of sign language. When STUDENT entered the High School District in June 2002, gestures, sign language and PECS were his primary means of communication. As of the September 26, 2002 IEP (Petitioner Exhibit 42), special day class teacher Seefeldt’s goal was to learn five signs. Speech therapist Karin Daignault taught sign language to STUDENT and maintained a log (Petitioner Exhibit 162) for back and forth communication with his parents about the language program to keep the parents up with the signs their son was learning, provide for reinforcement at home of the skills learned in the classroom, and to answer questions. Ms. Daignault’s testimony, corroborated by this log book, demonstrates that Ms. Daignault was successfully able to teach sign language and to communicate with STUDENT. There is no showing in the evidence that the teacher and staff needed to “master” these methods so long as they are able to teach and communicate with STUDENT.
Petitioner also asserts that the placement was not appropriate because he lacked proper supervision. MOTHER testified that she once observed STUDENT unattended after an adapted physical education class. This episode appears from the evidence to be an exception to the rule. Moreover, the incident occurred outside of the special day class. Program specialist Marilyn Bakarich testified that she never saw STUDENT on campus unaccompanied by an adult. Although the High School District declined to provide a one-to-one aide, instructional aides were available when needed for help with specific tasks including lunch time. The District witnesses convincingly observed that STUDENT had supervision constantly, whether he was in class or moving about the campus.
Petitioner again asserts that a one-to-one aide should have been offered and provided. The parents raised this issue specifically at the September 2002 IEP meeting. STUDENT had a continuing need for supervision to meet reasonable safety and academic concerns. As discussed above with regard to the supervision aspect of his placement, STUDENT received that supervision. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s needs for supervision and assistance were met without the need for a one-to-one aide for the period from July 9, 2002 through January 7, 2003.
The Hearing Officer finds that the special day class at Orangeview Junior High School was designed to meet Petitioner’s needs from July 9, 2002 through January 7, 2003.
Services
Petitioner also challenged the nature and frequency of services offered by the High School District in the 2002-2003 school year in the areas of speech and language, assistive technology, occupational therapy, and DTT.
Speech and language
Petitioner states that the High School District reduced the already inadequate level of speech and language services provided by the Elementary District even further during the 2002-2003 school year and should have offered oral communication therapy. The March 4, 2002 IEP (Petitioner’s Exhibit 35) was the last IEP in the Elementary District that included an offer. The total time allocated to speech and language in this IEP was ninety minutes. The IEPs at the High School District level, starting with the July 9, 2002 IEP (Petitioner Exhibit 39) offered a total of sixty minutes administered for thirty minutes twice a week. The IEP notes also indicate that “Parents have requested individual speech therapy” for the two sessions. Petitioner’s speech and language consultant, Judy Segal, stated that STUDENT should have received far more intense therapy than the sixty minutes per week that was offered. District speech therapist, Karin Daignault, persuasively testified, based on her regular observations of STUDENT working with him in the classroom setting for one and one-half school years, that the sixty minutes of speech and language addressed STUDENT’s needs consistent with his cognitive abilities and capacity to attend.
Petitioner additionally argues that sign language instruction was deficient. Ms. Segal stated that Ms. Daignault should have mastered sign language before working with STUDENT. The evidence indicates that his own skill level did not require this. STUDENT’s knowledge extended to some seventy signs, but his expressive use was far less, with an inability to express more than one or two signs at a time. As discussed above with respect to placement, Ms. Daignault persuasively testified that she was able to communicate with STUDENT and teach him new signs. She was able to address STUDENT’s needs in this nonverbal communication skill. Ms. Segal also stated that PARENTS should have been offered sign language training from the District. The record also shows that the District kept the parents informed on STUDENT’s progress with signing. There is no provision in the IDEA or State law, however, requiring the District to provide services to the parents unless these services are necessary to allow the pupil to benefit from his or her program. There is no evidence that in this case the parents were not able to keep up with their son as he progressed in learning sign language with the information provided by the District.
The Hearing Officer finds that the speech and language services offered from July 9, 2002, to January 7, 2003 were designed to meet Petitioner’s needs for communication.
Assistive technology
Petitioner asserts that the offer of assistive technology was not designed to meet his needs in the 2002-2003 school year. The High School District maintained that it offered and provided STUDENT appropriate tools with PECS, a computer and software, and an audio box with a one-message output that met his needs. District specialist Kathy Lewis did perform an assistive technology screening on September 24, 2002 (High School District Exhibit 14). She recommended continued “picture communication symbols” training, a single switch audio box, a computer with large keyboard, and further sign language training. Petitioner’s augmentative communication consultant, Cynthia Cottier, testified that the one-message device was too simple for STUDENT, who rarely initiates communication. The Elementary District had furnished him a four-message unit. In the October 2002 IEP the High School District provided a single output device, apparently simpler than the one he had before, after Ms. Lewis observed in her screening report that he was not able to use more complicated devices and understand their communicative intent. Ms. Lewis, who is a teacher of the severely handicapped (SH) at the District’s Hope School and has been a mentor teacher as well as serving on the District’s assistive technology task force, persuasively testified that during her screening STUDENT could not connect meanings with the various messages available on the multiple output devices. She said that she wanted STUDENT to start with the basics, as she had recommended with his computer skills. Ms. Lewis indicated that Ms. Cottier reached similar conclusions to hers, but thought the multiple output device recommended by Ms. Cottier could be “overwhelming” for STUDENT. Ms. Lewis convincingly stated that STUDENT needed a grounding in learning the cause and effect of the communication device before he advanced to multiple outputs. The IEP team included Ms. Lewis’s assistive technology recommendations in furtherance of addressing STUDENT’s needs. The Hearing Officer finds that the inclusion of Ms. Lewis’s recommendations in the offer is appropriate under Cal. Educ. Code section 56341.1(b)(5) to meet his needs.
Occupational Therapy
Petitioner’s occupational therapy consultant Laurie Cohen stated that because of STUDENT’s limited academic progress, STUDENT should have been offered direct occupational therapy during the 2002-2003 school year in areas such as peer interaction, sensory processing, and fine and gross motor skills. The High School District occupational therapy assessment by Ms. du Preez concluded consultative services, only, were appropriate to meet STUDENT’s needs in this area (High School District Exhibit 6). Ms. du Preez testified that STUDENT needed the repetition that came from incorporating occupational therapy exercises daily in the classroom curriculum. She indicated that she provided drills and equipment to special day class teacher Ken Seefeldt that he used in the classroom, such as fine motor exercises and a sorting rack with colors and shapes to match with pictures. Ms. du Preez recommended a name stamp be made for STUDENT as he had been unable for years to write his name. In contrast, Ms. Cohen suggested a direct therapy program in such areas as holding a pencil or handwriting that went beyond his motor skills level. It is noted that the Cohen report does not address STUDENT’s cognitive level as a factor contributing to the level of his motor skills. Ms. Cohen acknowledged that cognitive ability can impact occupational therapy skills. On the basis of Ms. du Preez’s report and persuasive testimony, the Hearing Officer concludes that the High School District’s occupational therapy program for the 2002-2003 school year from July through January was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the classroom program through consultation and the related mobility and adapted physical education programs.
Discrete Trial Therapy
Petitioner also contends that he should have been offered DTT for the 2002-2003 school year. The High School District never offered DTT to STUDENT. The IEP team in December 2002 directly dealt with the parents’ request for DTT and discussed the subject “at length” without offering the service (Petitioner Exhibit 45). Petitioner’s experts have not shown how DTT, a methodology that can deal with a large number of subject areas and is particularly suited for younger children diagnosed on the autism spectrum, would meet any of STUDENT’s unique needs during the 2002-2003 school year. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the weight of the evidence establishes that DTT was not an appropriate service to offer for the 2002-2003 school year.
Was the High School District program calculated to provide Petitioner an educational benefit from July 9, 2002, to January 7, 2003?
Petitioner maintains that the occupational therapy and language programs were not reasonably calculated to provide to Petitioner an educational benefit.
Occupational therapy
Petitioner contends that he could have progressed better toward his educational goals had he received direct occupational therapy. Petitioner, however, showed consistent progress toward his occupational therapy goals through consultation between the teacher and the occupational therapist and through his adapted physical education class as reflected in the IEP for September 26, 2002 (Petitioner Exhibit 42). The adapted physical education teacher reported to the September 2002 IEP team on STUDENT’s progress toward his goals. There is no evidence showing that his educational goals would have become any more attainable had he received direct occupational therapy. To the contrary, the credible testimony of the GASELPA occupational therapist, Ms. Karen du Preez, indicates that at his age, STUDENT would not receive benefit from direct services beyond the direct therapy which he received while he attended the Rowland Unified School District. The Hearing Officer finds that the High School District’s occupational therapy program was calculated to provide a benefit to Petitioner and did provide a benefit from July 9, 2002 to January 7, 2003.
Speech and language
Petitioner argues that the High School District language program was not calculated to provide a benefit because the teacher and aides were not fluent in sign language. The evidence, including the testimony of speech therapists Ms. Daignault and Ms. Wohlgemuth and the speech and language log in Petitioner’s Exhibit 162, however, demonstrates that STUDENT was generally progressing toward his communication goals. The log lists the new signs introduced in class and documents that STUDENT is using them.
The Hearing Officer finds that the High School District offered to Petitioner with respect tothe occupational therapy and sign language, a program that was reasonably calculated to provide Petitioner an educational benefit from July 9, 2002, to January 7, 2003.
Did the High School District’s program comport with Petitioner’s IEPs and provide him with the least restrictive environment from July 9, 2002, to January 7, 2003?
There is no dispute that, from July 9, 2003, to January 7, 2003, the High School District implemented the July 2002 IEP as modified by the September and October 2002 IEPs. Petitioner contends, however, that the High School District did not implement the March 4, 2002 IEP, purportedly the last agreed-upon IEP as of the November 19, 2002 revocation of consent, by failing to mainstream STUDENT during the 2002-2003 school year. The March 2002 IEP (Petitioner Exhibit 35), developed while STUDENT was a pupil in the Elementary District, offered seventy-five minutes of mainstreaming with normally developing peers during lunch, recess, assemblies, and story time. While in the Elementary District, STUDENT went to a third grade classroom to participate in the story time portion of the school day. The April 19, 2002 IEP (High School District Exhibit 1) completed on a GASELPA form and consented to by the parents, however, notes that after his transfer to the High School District, STUDENT’s “regular program participation” would be assemblies, field trips, school activities, and community-base instruction. There is no mention of “story time.” The April 2002 IEP deals with STUDENT’s placement after his upcoming transfer to the High School District. The description of “regular program participation” is the only program-related item dealt with in the April 2002 IEP other than discussing potential placements. Significantly, there was no reference to “story time” in the July 2002 IEP. The High School District, moreover, had no story time opportunities in its program as discussed at the December 19, 2002 IEP meeting (Petitioner Exhibit 45). Having no story time is consistent with the agreed-upon IEP of April 2002, the consent to which was not revoked. The High School District consistently offered one hundred percent of STUDENT’s academic time to be in special education but with program participation in lunch, recess, passing periods, assemblies, field trips, and school activities. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did have mainstreaming opportunities with typically developing peers that comported with his IEP from July 9, 2002, to January 7, 2003.
The Hearing Officer finds that the High School District substantially offered and provided a FAPE to Petitioner for the period from July 9, 2002, through January 7, 2003.
January 7, 2003 through the end of the extended school year
The analysis will now turn to Petitioner’s additional specific allegations of a denial of FAPE by the High School District during the balance of the 2002-2003 school year and extended school year starting with the annual IEP on January 7, 2003.
Procedural considerations
January 7, 2003 IEP meeting
Petitioner contends that the High School District committed additional procedural violations during the 2002-2003 school year through a number of missteps at the January 7, 2003 IEP meeting; by failing to respond to parental requests on separate occasions for an IEP meeting, assessments, educational records, the occupational therapist’s resume, and classroom observation; and by failing to state a clear offer in the January 7, 2003 IEP.
Scheduling to allow parental attendance
The first issue raised is that the District did not schedule this session to allow the parents to attend. According to Cal. Educ. Code section 56341.5 (c), the IEP meeting is to be “scheduled at a mutually agreed upon time and place.” The signature page and meeting notes (Petitioner Exhibit 47), however, document the attendance and participation of both PARENTS. As the parents attended this meeting, the scheduling of this IEP meeting did not infringe on the parents’ participation in the IEP process, and there is no evidence that Petitioner was denied an educational opportunity.
Absence of general education teacher
Petitioner also asserts that there was no general education teacher at the January 2003 IEP meeting. This was STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting as well as a continuation of the December 19, 2002 IEP meeting. Cal. Educ. Code section 56341(b)(2) requires the participation of a general education teacher on the IEP team “if the pupil is, or may be, participating in the regular education environment.” The notes indicate that the IEP team discussed extensively his present levels of performance and goals and objectives. STUDENT’s special day class teacher, Mr. Seefeldt, his adapted physical education teacher, service providers, a school psychologist, and District administrators participated. This IEP also notes that “A copy of parent’s rights in Vietnamese was presented. Parents waived explanation of those rights.” The notes further report that MOTHER raised the issue of mainstreaming, which resulted in the following entry: “Should the team need input today from a general ed teacher, she will be called in. STUDENT is not currently in any regular education classes.” There is no evidence of a legally effective waiver by STUDENT’s parents of the requirement for a regular education teacher to be present. Although STUDENT was not currently in any general education classes, his mother raised the issue of including him in that environment as he had been in the general education classes for part of the day in the Elementary District. She also testified that she requested that a regular education teacher be called. Although the District argues that a general education teacher was present at the December 2002 IEP meeting, the issue of mainstreaming arose during the January 2003 session. As mainstreaming was a continuing concern for Petitioner’s parents, the Hearing Officer finds that the absence of a general education teacher at the January 2003 IEP meeting was a procedural violation that seriously infringed on parental participation in the IEP process with respect to mainstreaming.
Clear offer of DIS
The next contention is that the January 7, 2003 IEP did not specify whether the speech and language services were to be given individually or in a group. Although the High School District argues that the parents already knew about the program through home-to-school communication, observations of lessons, and presence at IEP meetings, such specificity is required in the IEP to facilitate full parental participation and to ensure that there is no lost educational opportunity for Petitioner. Therefore, the speech and language offer is deficient in specifying whether the services were to be given individually or in a group.
Petitioner also alleges that the January 2003 IEP has an inadequate explanation of the assistive technology offered. On page two in the blank following the heading “Specialized equipment, materials, services, including assistive technology screening referral” is the entry “computer software, communication boards, switch (list will be provided to parents).” On page twenty two of this IEP, the notes state, “In regard to assistive technology equipment, a list of what has been ordered will be provided to parents.” Cal. Educ. Code section 56345(a)(3) requires the IEP to include “The specific special educational instruction and related services and supplementary aids and services to be provided to the pupil.” The IEP states that PARENTS were to receive a list of all the assistive technology equipment that had been ordered. The statute, however, asks for the description in the IEP to be “specific.” References to “software” and “switch” are general and would not inform the parents or a non-IEP team member provider what aids were to be used or implemented. The Hearing Officer finds a procedural violation in that the assistive technology description in the January 7, 2003 IEP lacked sufficient specificity and therefore infringed on the parents’ ability to participate in this aspect of their son’s program in the IEP process and potentially resulted in the loss of educational opportunity for Petitioner.
Parental requests
Petitioner contends that the High School District failed to respond appropriately to his parents’ requests for convening an IEP meeting, his educational records, the resume of an occupational therapist, and classroom observation.
Educational records
Petitioner also alleges the High School District improperly withheld his educational records more than five days after his parents requested them in violation of Cal. Educ. Code section 56504. On May 9, 2003, PARENTS requested a copy of a report describing injuries STUDENT sustained at school in January 2003 (Petitioner Exhibit 115). On May 13, 2003, Petitioner’s counsel requested logs for speech and language, adapted physical education, and orientation and mobility services (Petitioner Exhibit 116). Counsel followed up on both requests on May 21, 2003 (Petitioner Exhibit 120). The District contends that Petitioner has not shown a refusal to grant access to educational records or that any delay “resulted in a denial of FAPE.” The District sent to Petitioner’s counsel what were indicated as duplicate documents in early June 2003 by overnight delivery (High School District Exhibit 39) explaining that the incident report had been sent to Petitioner’s counsel by facsimile on May 23, 3003, and that the balance of the records consisting of “communication logs” were already provided to MOTHER under a standing arrangement. Further correspondence between Petitioner’s counsel and the District’s counsel followed in late June 2003 (High School District Exhibits 40, 41). Petitioner’s counsel questioned in this correspondence whether the documents furnished were complete. The District’s counsel responded that they were. It is not clear from this evidence whether PARENTS had all or part of the requested documents before the written requests were sent, although all of them should have been made available within five days under Cal. Educ. Code section 56504. As the evidence indicates that PARENTS continued to be active in STUDENT’s education and there is no link demonstrated between access to these documents and STUDENT’s program, there is no showing that parental participation in the IEP process or educational opportunity for Petitioner suffered from delay in the parents receiving all of the documents requested.
Occupational therapist’s resume
Petitioner also contends that the High School District did not respond to his parents’ request for the resume of Karen du Preez, who performed an occupational therapy assessment (High School District Exhibit 6). Petitioner’s parents assert that they had serious concerns regarding the qualifications of the person who had assessed their son’s occupational therapy needs. The District responds that it never received notice that the parents did not receive the resume. Moreover, the District argues that Petitioner has failed to establish that his parents have a right to the resume. The December 2002 IEP notes indicate that the parents were concerned about Ms. du Preez’s background in sensory integration. The January 2003 IEP notes state that a letter from GASELPA director Candy Miller (Petitioner Exhibit 13) was shared at the meeting describing Ms. du Preez’s qualifications, including those with respect to “sensory processing dysfunction, as well as sensory-integrative, developmental, and neuro-developmental disorders.” The IEP notes also indicate that the District would furnish PARENTS with Ms. du Preez’s resume. Ms. du Preez testified that she provided a copy of her resume to the District, but PARENTS stated that they never received it. Although PARENTS should have received the copy of the resume after the District offered to provide it, there is no specific legal entitlement for parents to receive a District assessor’s resume. Moreover, the Hearing Officer finds that this apparent oversight did not interfere with parental participation in the IEP process or result in loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT, as the information regarding her qualifications were provided at the January 2003 IEP meeting.
Classroom observation
Petitioner also contends that the High School District wrongfully limited his mother’s observations of his program in the classroom during the 2002-2003 extended school year. The District did restrict MOTHER to two fifteen-minute observations toward the end of the extended school year and prohibited interruption of the classroom instruction (Petitioner Exhibit122). The evidence shows that this District limitation on classroom visits came only after issues arose during the abbreviated extended school year program concerning the frequency and manner of MOTHER’s visits. There is no evidence of any other restrictions on STUDENT’s parents to observe his extended school year program. PARENTS had previous communications with the District concerning procedures for classroom observations. The notes for the October 21, 2002 IEP (Petitioner Exhibit 43) contain the entry, “PARENTS agreed to make an appointment for classroom visits and check in at the office for a visitor’s pass.” The December 19, 2002 IEP (Petitioner Exhibit 45) records teacher Seefeldt’s request that MOTHER not interrupt him while in the classroom with questions during lessons. He suggested answering her questions during pre-arranged conference times. District assistant principal Nancy Malotte wrote PARENTS on December 20, 2002 (Petitioner Exhibit 97), to clarify District policy that required all visitors to check in at the main office, receive a visitor’s badge, and coordinate with the classroom teacher in advance to prevent interference with lesson plans. PARENTS responded cordially in a letter (Petitioner Exhibit 98) indicating that they would follow the policies and requested them in writing. Ms. Malotte referred them to the “Parent-Student Handbook” that is provided when each student registers in the District and offered to provide another copy if needed (Petitioner Exhibit 100). The District’s limitations on MOTHER’s classroom visits, both in general and for the 2002-2003 extended school year, were specific and met legitimate interests of classroom management, student safety, and student privacy. They did not deny PARENTS an opportunity to observe. The Hearing Officer finds that there is no showing of unreasonable limitation on classroom observation that intruded on parental participation in the IEP process or resulted in lack of educational opportunity for STUDENT.
Substantive considerations
For the 2002-2003 school year and extended school year on and after January 7, 2003, Petitioner alleges that the High School District did not develop appropriate goals and objectives in communication, did not provide an appropriate placement, failed to provide a one-to-one aide, failed to offer and provide appropriate types and levels of services in the areas of speech and language, assistive technology, occupational therapy, and DTT, and failed to implement the mainstreaming provisions of the Elementary District’s March 4, 2002 IEP. The Hearing Officer has already made a finding that the High School District offered and provided a FAPE from July 9, 2002, through January 7, 2003. The following discussion concerns the balance of the 2002-2003 school year.
Did the High School District program address Petitioner’s unique needs from January 7, 2003, through the extended school year?
STUDENT’s unique needs
Petitioner’s needs did not change from the summer of 2002. Both Petitioner’s parents and the High School District agreed that he continued to require a small, supervised classroom with individual or small-group instruction to address his severe deficits. Communication continued to be a major area of need. The parties agreed that he required instruction in nonverbal modes such as sign language, PECS, and audio output devices to address his severe deficits in communication.
The parties, however, disagreed whether he also required speech and language therapy to address his oral language skills. The January 7, 2003 IEP meeting notes (Petitioner Exhibit 47) show that the District was advocating nonverbal communication rather than speech production. The notes also state that MOTHER expressed the desire for STUDENT to continue to work on speech production. As of the April 10, 2003 IEP meeting (Petitioner Exhibit 50), the District presented its speech and language assessment that concluded STUDENT’s oral motor skills were inadequate for the production of functional, intelligible speech. This IEP also includes a notation that STUDENT’s parents wanted “more improvement in speech skills.”
Both Petitioner’s speech and language witness Ms. Judy Segal and Dr. Ira Lott were of the opinion that STUDENT could produce oral language on some level. Ms. Segal was able to elicit syllables from STUDENT in a clinical setting, although she stated that STUDENT will never be fluent in oral communication. She said that with proper therapy the goal realistically could be as much as a two-year-old age equivalent level. The High School District speech and language therapists Karin Daignault and Kathleen Wohlgemuth determined in March 2003 that STUDENT had “plateaued” in oral language (High School Exhibit 25). They consider him to be “nonverbal” but note that he does have a small vocabulary. They reported, in their assessment, that STUDENT has been observed in the classroom recognizably singing “The Barney Song,” although primarily with vowels, limited consonants, and word unintelligibility. The District assessors’ view is that STUDENT’s past progress in oral language is “minimal.” They conclude that his prognosis for future progress is “very poor.” This view, however, supports Petitioner’s opinion that some progress is possible.
STUDENT’s cognitive ability is approximately twenty-four months. This does not portend that language fluency in any mode will ever be reached. According to his IEPs and MOTHER’s testimony, he did not enjoy much more progress with audio output devices or picture systems than with oral language. The evidence reveals advancement in sign language. For example, while the March 2002 IEP (Petitioner Exhibit 35) states that he can use “some basic signs,” the December 19, 2002 IEP reports that he can use and understand thirty-six signs at school (Petitioner Exhibit 45). This skill is of limited advantage, however, unless he is an environment with people who can sign. Moreover, the evidence indicates that even with sign language STUDENT could not usually link more than two signs for expressive communication. His mother testified that he did not use PECS very often and that he could not sign a sentence. The record thus reflects slow progress for STUDENT in all areas of communication. With his extremely limited success with communication in any form, he requires oral speech therapy as well as the other therapies to meet his needs in this profound area of deficit.
The IDEA requires that STUDENT’s program to the greatest extent feasible prepare him for supported employment, independent living, and community participation (20 U.S.C. § 1400 (c) (1); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.1). The Hearing Officer finds that oral communication was one of STUDENT’s unique needs during the 2002-2003 school year to prepare him for supported employment, independent living, and community participation to the greatest extent feasible.
The January 2003 offer for instruction and services
The High School District offered in January 2003 (Petitioner Exhibit 39) to keep STUDENT in the special day class for severely handicapped students on the comprehensive campus of Orangeview Junior High School. The District also offered to continue as services speech and language twice a week for thirty minutes, and mobility training forty minutes a week, and adapted physical education. The offer included regular education participation at lunch, recess, passing periods, assemblies, field trips, and school activities.
Communication and occupational therapy goals and objectives
Petitioner contends that the communication and occupational therapy goals did not meet STUDENT’s needs. Petitioner’s speech and language consultant, Judy Segal, stated that the January 7, 2003 IEP communication goal did not meet STUDENT’s needs as it was “non-communicative” as it focused on “labeling.” This goal, “STUDENT will express information by increasing his use of signs, pictures, gestures,” is directed toward STUDENT’s undisputed severely delayed level in communication. The objectives progress to “answer question,” and “respond with the correct sign.” These goals address STUDENT’s communication with the exception of speech.
Petitioner’s occupational therapist consultant stated that the goals in this area did not address STUDENT’s fine motor deficits. She further indicated that there should have been goals for letter formation, motor planning, fine motor, transitioning, and initiation. The goals and objectives in the January 2003 IEP, however, directly address such topics as balance, calisthenics, and coordination-related activities such as ball bouncing. A specific goal for letter formation for STUDENT is not appropriate until he is able to master his pre-literacy goals to including letter and number recognition. The Hearing Officer finds that the occupational goals in the January 2003 IEP addressed STUDENT’s needs.
Placement
Petitioner contends that his requested placement at Orangeview Junior High School for the entire 2002-2003 school year was not appropriately implemented. As discussed for the time period from July 9, 2002, to January 7, 2003, this placement met STUDENT’s needs. For the spring 2003, Petitioner asserts that he was “segregated from the rest of the class” and kept at the computer by himself. He also asserts continuing lack of appropriate supervision.
Occupational therapy consultant, Laurie Cohen, testified that during her May 2003 classroom observation, STUDENT was alone in the rear of the classroom working on the computer with his back to the rest of the class. His classmates were involved in a Bingo game that STUDENT joined at Ms. Cohen’s suggestion. Ms. Cohen reported that STUDENT’s classmates were very supportive of his participation. She testified that STUDENT “beamed” when he won a game and received the congratulations of his fellow students. This anecdote refers only to a single incident. The District witnesses, including program specialist Marilyn Bakarich, speech therapist Karin Daignault, and occupational therapist Karen du Preez, testified persuasively that STUDENT was regularly included in classroom activities to the extent that his cognitive abilities would allow. Ms. Bakarich also indicated that STUDENT spent three out of seven periods in the school day using his computer and software in part because of his differing functional level form his classmates. More weight is given to the testimony of the District witnesses. They were regularly in the classroom, whereas Ms. Cohen’s testimony was based on a single visit.
MOTHER described an incident in which STUDENT fell and sustained an injury in the restroom on January 28, 2003. The incident report (Petitioner Exhibit 164) indicates that STUDENT suffered a bruise on his face that was treated with ice, and subsequently he was sent home. During this restroom visit, his supervision was another disabled student. The Hearing Officer finds, as with the period from July 9, 2002, to January 7, 2003, that the evidence shows that this incident was an exception to the constant supervision described by the District witnesses.
The Hearing Offer finds that this placement, including all of the reasons mentioned in regard to the period from July 9, 2002 to January 7, 2003, was appropriate for the balance of the 2002-2003 school year.
Services
From January 2003 through the end of the extended school year, Petitioner also challenged the nature and frequency of services offered by the High School District in the 2002-2003 school year in the areas of speech and language, assistive technology, occupational therapy, and DTT.
Speech and language
Petitioner also contends for the period from January 2003 through the end of the extended school year that the High School District offered an inadequate level of speech and language services and should have offered oral communication therapy. The District counters that the program outlined in the January 7, 2003 IEP (Petitioner Exhibit 47) that continued to offer the same level of speech and language services as appeared in the agreed-to July 2002 IEP, was at a level of services that was appropriate to STUDENT’s goals, and correctly emphasized expressive communication using signs, pictures, and gestures rather than oral language. The January 2003 IEP was STUDENT’s annual IEP and the first IEP at the High School District to include a complete set of proposed goals and objectives. The District’s speech and language services offered from January 2003 through the extended school year were designed to meet Petitioner’s needs for basic communication in all areas except oral language.
Assistive technology
The High School District’s assistive technology offer contained in the October 2002 IEP continued for the rest of the 2002-2003 school year. The program outlined by District specialist Kathy Lewis was analyzed, above, for the July 2002 to January 2003 time frame. This program continued through the end of the year. Accordingly, for the same reasons set out in the discussions of the prior time periods, the Hearing Officer finds that the assistive technology incorporated in the January 2003 IEP offer was appropriate to meet Petitioner’s needs.
Occupational Therapy
STUDENT’s January 2003 IEP included adapted physical education and mobility goals that directly addressed many of the specific areas raised by Petitioner’s occupational therapist consultant Laurie Cohen, including balance, ball bouncing, and calisthenics. The evidence indicates that STUDENT’s needs in this area were met. The Hearing Officer concludes that the High School District’s occupational therapy program for the 2002-2003 school year as outlined in the January 2003 IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the related mobility and adapted physical education programs.
Discrete Trial Therapy
As concluded, above, from July 2002 to January 2003, DTT was not an appropriate part of Petitioner’s program. The parties did continue to discuss this issue at the January 2003 IEP meeting. Special day class teacher Ken Seefeldt reported to the January 2003 IEP team on his conversations with the Elementary District that indicated DTT was not effective for STUDENT. Moreover, the skills that DTT at the elementary level targeted, such as gross motor, are covered in specific goals and objectives for adapted physical education and mobility in the 2002-2003 school year as proposed in the January 7, 2003 annual IEP (Petitioner Exhibit 47). The Hearing Officer therefore finds that from January 7, 2003, through the extended school year, DTT remained an inappropriate service for Petitioner.
The Hearing Officer finds the January 2003 offer for placement and services at Orangeview Junior High School were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs with the exception of his need for oral communication therapy.
Was the High School District’s program calculated to provide Petitioner an educational benefit from January 7, 2003 through the extended school year?
Petitioner continues to maintain that the occupational therapy and language programs were not reasonably calculated to provide to Petitioner an educational benefit for the period on and after January 7, 2003, through the extended school year
Occupational therapy
Petitioner continued to show progress toward his occupational therapy goals through consultation between the teacher and the occupational therapist and through his adapted physical education class according to the January 7, 2003 IEP (Petitioner Exhibit 47). The January 2003 team reviewed present levels of performance in gross and fine motor activities and received a report from the adapted physical education teacher that STUDENT had shown “a lot of “growth.” There remains no evidence from January 2003 through the extended school year that his educational goals would have become any more attainable had he received direct occupational therapy. The District’s occupational therapy program was addressing his needs and was allowing STUDENT to make progress toward his goals. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the District’s occupational therapy program was calculated to provide a benefit to Petitioner and did provide a benefit from January 7, 2003, through the extended school year.
Speech and language
The record supports the same finding for the second half of the school year as for the period from July 9, 2002, through January 7, 2003. The High School District offer continued to include services that addressed his nonverbal communication needs. Moreover, Petitioner continued to progress in sign language irrespective of the fact that the teacher and aides were not fluent in sign language. The log book (Petitioner Exhibit 162) continues to chronicle STUDENT’s advancement.
The Hearing Officer finds, with the exception of oral language, that the High School District offered to Petitioner with respect to the occupational therapy and sign language, a program that was reasonably calculated to provide Petitioner an educational benefit.
Did the High School District’s program comport with Petitioner’s IEPs and provide him with the least restrictive environment from January 7, 2003 through the extended school year?
The evidence reveals no dispute that the High School District implemented the January 7, 2003 IEP. The Petitioner contends for the balance of the school year, following the revocation of consent to the July 2002 IEP, that the High School District did not implement the mainstreaming provisions of the March 4, 2002 IEP with respect to story time. As discussed in regard to the period from July 2002 to January 2003, the agreed-to April 19, 2002 IEP (High School District Exhibit 1) includes “regular program participation” but has no reference to “story time.” The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did have mainstreaming opportunities with typically developing peers that comported with his IEP for the period from January 7, 2003, through the extended school year.
The Hearing Officer further finds that the High School District substantially offered and provided a FAPE to Petitioner for the period from January 7, 2003, through the extended school year with the exception of oral language, the lack of specificity in its assistive technology offer, and the lack of a general education teacher at the January 2003 IEP meeting.
ISSUE NO. VII: Did the High School District during the 2003-2004 school year fail to assess Petitioner in all areas of suspected disability?
For the 2003-2004 school year Petitioner again asserts the he should have been assessed in autism, applied behavior analysis, and vision as suspected areas of disability
A. Autism and applied behavioral analysis
Autism
For the 2003-2004 school year, Petitioner reasserts his arguments from previous years that the District should have conducted an autism assessment because STUDENT displayed behaviors that Petitioner alleges should have raised suspicions of autism. He points to additional High School District data such as the September 27, 2002 occupational therapy report (Petitioner Exhibit 66) that refers to his lack of interaction with other students and his “problematic” social skills, and the March 2003 speech and language report (Petitioner Exhibit 75) that notes tactile defensive behaviors, repetitive video watching, and not playing with other children. There is also testimony from various educators who worked with STUDENT, including occupational therapist Karen du Preez, reporting that STUDENT “flicks his hands.” Petitioner characterizes these as “self-stimulating behaviors,” a recognized symptom of autism. District speech therapist Daignault noted noncompliance and gritting of teeth (Petitioner Exhibit 158).
The High School District responds that autism was not a “suspected area of disability” during the 2003-2004 school year. Furthermore, the District argues that Petitioner’s minimal “autistic-like behaviors” have not adversely affected his educational performance.
As of the 2003-2004 school year, Petitioner had obtained two independent educational evaluations in the area of autism. Neuropsychologist Dr. Christine Majors assessed STUDENT in May and July 2003 and issued her report in October of that year (Petitioner Exhibit 73). She found that he was autistic. She dismissed STUDENT’s low cognitive ability or other diagnoses as explanations for these behaviors. Dr. Majors administered standardized tests to STUDENT and determined his full IQ to be 37, in the severely delayed range. Ms. Jessica Postil, of Autism Spectrum Consultants, also assessed STUDENT in July 2003 (Petitioner Exhibit 84 ). She, too, concluded that STUDENT had autism. She observed motor difficulties and repetition of an “e” sound, along with limited eye contact, nonsensical play when toys were available, and defiance when asked to perform language tasks. The High School District also had received a follow-up diagnosis dated March 3, 2003, from UCI’s Dr. Ira Lott (High School District Exhibit 22), who said that STUDENT had “congenital encephalopathy with developmental delay and autistic features. The autism is secondary to the underlying neurological disorder that has included elements of hydrocephalus requiring a shunt.” Dr. Lott continues to state, “It is not unusual for children with congenital developmental delay to have atypical features on the autism spectrum. STUDENT needs to work primarily with a teacher who is experienced in children with developmental delay and who can work behaviorally with some of the autistic features.”
The District administered the GARS, which indicated a “very low” probability results for autism, as part of its multidisciplinary assessment dated after Dr. Lott’s letter on March 21, 2003 (High School District 26). The District had placed STUDENT in a special day class for severely handicapped children and was working with STUDENT “behaviorally” with his conduct, which at times, as discussed above, could be “autistic like.” The District also received the reports of Petitioner’s other assessors, Ms. Cohen and Ms. Cottier. They reported behaviors that are contraindications for autism. For example, Ms. Cohen indicated that STUDENT “initiates contact” with his peers and that he “is able to transition from one activity to the next but it takes him a longer time than his peers to regulate his behavior (Petitioner Exhibit 82).” She also said that he did not need any breaks during her assessment and that he wanted to interact with his peers. STUDENT’s “finger flicking” arose during Ms. Cohen’s observations. She stated, “Inappropriate behaviors such as pulling or walking away, refusing to work, occasionally flicking his fingers, and muttering to himself escalate when he is required to follow directions from unknown persons, when he is in new places, and when he is prompted to partake in unfamiliar activities.” Ms. Cottier reported during her assessment that “STUDENT was social, cooperative and an active participant” and “STUDENT was social and entered into activities easily and it was clear that STUDENT possessed an intent to communicate and interact (Petitioner Exhibit 83).” Ms. Cottier also noted that STUDENT maintained good eye contact and participated in a ninety-minute session with “continual attending.” Additionally, Petitioner’s autism consultant, Jessica Postil, testified that she was not aware of STUDENT’s history of cerebral palsy and pervasive development delays, which could have contributed to both the motor difficulties and sound repetition she observed during her assessment session. Speech and language assessor Judy Segal also attested to STUDENT’s good eye contact. Dr. Majors acknowledged on cross-examination that the observed “autistic-like” behaviors could also be consistent with global development delays or, in the case of incidents of poor eye contact, could possibly arise from cultural factors.
The Hearing Officer finds that in the 2003-2004 school year, the additional assessment and observation information provided by Petitioner, particularly after the District’s multidisciplinary report, did not provide the District a reason to conduct further assessments for autism.
Applied behavioral analysis
Petitioner realleges that the High School District should have performed an ABA assessment during the 2003-2004 school year, as it was “on notice” that this was an area of need for him. The District responds that ABA “is not an area of suspected disability,” but a methodology not appropriate for STUDENT. As discussed in reference to the 2002-2003 school year, the Hearing Officer finds that there was no suspected disability or conditions warranting an ABA assessment for the 2003-2004 school year.
B. Vision
Petitioner reasserts the need for a vision assessment for the 2003-2004 school year based on Dr. Ballinger’s report (Petitioner Exhibit 86) and contends that the High School District should have reassessed his needs. The District argues that there was no indication of a vision problem. The District witnesses, including vision specialist Jane Vogel, observed that STUDENT has no obstacles to accessing his curriculum because of a vision disability. The District refers to the testimony of its vision specialist, Ms. Vogel, that any vision limitations Petitioner may have are attributable to permanent muscle problems related to cerebral palsy or the inability to process due to his cognitive ability. Although STUDENT very well may have diagnosable vision defects, there is no showing of their relevance to STUDENT’s current academic program, as there is no evidence showing that he cannot access his education because of eyesight deficiencies. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the High School District had no duty to assess for vision during the 2003-2004 school year.
ISSUE NO. VIII: Did the High School District fail to offer and provide Petitioner a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2003-2004 school year, and extended school year?
As Petitioner began the 2003-2004 school year, the evidence indicates that the High School District continued to offer and implement the January 2003 IEP. There were only two IEP meetings during the 2003-2004 school year up to the date of the due process hearing. On November 24, 2003, the IEP team received an occupational therapy report and discussed occupational therapy services and future occupational therapy assessment (Petitioner Exhibit 51). On January 4, 2004, the team met for STUDENT’s annual IEP and reviewed proposed goals and objectives. Both of these IEP meetings were after Petitioner’s due process request. STUDENT’s parents did not attend either meeting. The January 2004 IEP offered placement at Hope School, the same level of speech and language, adapted physical education, and consultative services for assistive technology and occupational therapy.
Procedural considerations
Petitioner contends that the High School District committed procedural violations during the 2003-2004 school year by failing to obtain parental consent for occupational therapy services, refusing to conduct an occupational therapy assessment after referral, and failing to make a clear offer of DIS in the January 7, 2004 IEP.
Occupational therapy
Petitioner continues to take issue with the occupational therapy consultation that continued into the 2003-2004 school year without parental approval of the IEP. In the 2003-2004 school year, the parents had not consented to the services in any High School District IEP. As in the 2002-2003 school year, the Hearing Officer finds that the occupational therapy provided in the classroom continued without parental consent.
Petitioner also contends that the High School District failed to develop an assessment plan after “an occupational therapy referral.” The GASELPA occupational therapist, Ms. du Preez, prepared a report in November 2003 (Petitioner Exhibit 51). This report concludes with the statement that at the January 2004 annual IEP meeting “a request for an assessment plan will be done to determine STUDENT’s eligibility for continued occupational therapy intervention.” Petitioner characterizes Ms. du Preez’s letter as a referral for assessment by a service provider under Cal. Educ. Code section 56029. (Footnote 15)
The District argues that although an occupational therapy assessment would be part of the triennial assessment, as discussed at the November 24, 2003 IEP meeting (Petitioner Exhibit 51), there is no evidence that a referral for occupational therapy assessment was made or addressed at the January 2004 IEP meeting.
Ms. du Preez’s letter, the purported “referral,” reads prospectively: “a request...will be done.” Although Ms. du Preez was present at the January 7, 2004 IEP meeting, FATHER or MOTHER was not. The issue of an occupational therapy reassessment does not appear in the meeting notes (High School District Exhibit 57). There is no evidence that Ms. du Preez made a referral for assessment at any other time. The Hearing Officer, however, construes the raising of this issue by Petitioner in this due process proceeding to be a referral by the parents for an occupational therapy reassessment. Therefore, the District should prepare an appropriate assessment plan.
Offer of DIS
Petitioner contends that the District’s offers for speech and language and assistive technology in the January 7, 2004 IEP (Petitioner’s Exhibit 52) are not clear.
Speech and Language
Once again, Petitioner raises the question whether the speech and language services would be offered in a group or individual setting. The January 7, 2004 IEP (High School District Exhibit 57) offers “speech and language therapy” twice a week for thirty minutes a session. For the reasons discussed for the prior years, the Hearing Officer finds that the failure to specify what therapies are contemplated or whether they will be provided individually or in a group deprived the parents of meaningful participation in the IEP process and affected Petitioner’s educational opportunity in this area.
Assistive Technology
Petitioner points to an inconsistency regarding the audio box description. Whereas the January 2004 IEP reference is to single output device, the District’s assistive technology assessortestified that the device she was describing at the meeting had eight or twelve voice outputs. Moreover, the IEP notes (Petitioner Exhibit 52) state that the District offered to purchase a device comparable to that recommended by Petitioner’s assistive technology consultant Cynthia Cottier on a trial basis. The Hearing Officer finds that there is an internal ambiguity in the January 2004 IEP. There is no showing in the record, however, that this ambiguity led to an infringement of parental participation in the IEP process or loss of educational opportunity to Petitioner. The parents did not attend this meeting, and the District has offered to follow the recommendation of Petitioner’s own witness. Because this IEP does include the District’s offer to accept Ms. Cottier’s recommendation on a test basis, the District should pursue this course of action.
Substantive considerations
Petitioner contends for the 2003-2004 school year that the High School District failed to develop appropriate goals and objectives, failed to offer and provide an appropriate placement, and failed to offer and provide appropriate types and levels of services.
Was the 2003-2004 program designed to meet Petitioner’s unique needs?
STUDENT’s unique needs
There was no change in STUDENT’s needs at the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year. He continued to require a small instructional environment with significant modification of the curriculum.
The 2003-2004 offer for instruction and services
The High School District offered to Petitioner a special day class for severely handicapped students on the special education campus of Hope School. The services offered for 2003-2004 were at the same level as 2002-2003 for speech and language, mobility training, and adapted physical education. The January 2004 IEP offer also included assistive technology and occupational therapy consultative services for thirty minutes each per month.
Goals and objectives
Petitioner contends that the occupational therapy and speech and language goals in the January 2004 IEP were inadequate to meet his needs. The goals remained substantially similar to the goals in the earlier years. Following the analysis for the 2002-2003 school year, the Hearing Officer finds that, with the exception of provisions for oral language, the goals in the January 7, 2004 IEP were designed to meet Petitioner’s needs.
Placement
For the first half of the 2003-2004 school year, the High School District offered the same placement as it did for the prior year, in the severely handicapped special day class at Orangeview Junior High School. Petitioner raises the same issues concerning the Orangeview placement of poor supervision, lack of inclusion in group activities, no teacher knowledgeable in the areas of autism, and no teacher or staff fluent in sign language. For the reasons set forth in the placement discussion for the 2002-2003 school year, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement at Orangeview designed to meet Petitioner’s needs with the exception of the absence of oral language from the program.
The January 2004 offer, however, proposes to place STUDENT at Hope School “at this time.” Petitioner argues that the proposed placement at Hope School is inappropriate as it does not offer the “total communication environment” that Buena Park, the nonpublic school that Petitioner seeks to attend at public expense, was described to have. Additionally, Petitioner alleges that the staff at Hope School are not extensively trained in working with children with autism. The High School District defends the offer for Hope School as a means for Petitioner to expand his nonverbal communication skills, particularly in sign language, on a campus dedicated to special needs students. The District argues that STUDENT has made progress on the comprehensive campus in a special day class, but that his “functional communication needs” can be better met on this special education campus where fellow students and not only staff will be able to reciprocate with sign language, pictorial symbols, and voice output devices.
The January 2004 IEP recognizes STUDENT’s needs for small instructional environment with significant modifications of the curriculum. He has demonstrated needs to develop both verbal and nonverbal communication skills to the extent his cognitive abilities will allow. Hope School has approximately twenty students who use sign language in a class setting separate from the rest of the school which has a total enrollment of about 262 pupils. District psychologist Donna Erickson indicated that very few students actually communicate with sign language, and the students predominately do not use PECS or voice output devices with each other. It appears from the evidence that wherever STUDENT goes to school, he will be “different” from his classmates. Even in his Orangeview special day class, he does not participate in all activities because of his cognitive limitations compared to the other students. Hope School exclusively services special education pupils. The advantage of sign language usage at Hope School appears to the Hearing Officer to be illusory. The signing students at Hope are in their own special group and are presumably either deaf or hard of hearing and most likely far advanced compared to STUDENT both cognitively and in the use of sign language. STUDENT can hear and has needs demanding attention to the basics both in academics and communication including oral language, sign language, and other nonverbal means of communication. With the addition of specific speech production goals, the program at Orangeview can be designed to meet all of STUDENT’s current needs. The record indicates that STUDENT is well accepted at Orangeview and is achieving. The District and the GASELPA have demonstrated that they have the capabilities to implement sign language training to STUDENT as well as work on the other areas of communication. Although Hope School appears from the testimony from its teachers and administrators to be a good facility, the District has not shown that this placement is appropriate for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds that a preponderance of the evidence weighs in favor of finding this placement inappropriate for Petitioner to meet his needs.
Types and levels of services
Petitioner alleged substantially the same deficiencies in the High School’s services for the 2003-2004 school year in the areas of occupational therapy, DTT and ABA, assistive technology, vision therapy, and speech and language, as in prior years. The services that the High School District provided also remained substantially the same from the 2002-2003 school year. The assistive technology section of the January 7, 2004 IEP (High School District Exhibit 57) offered to accept Ms. Cottier’s recommendation for an audio output device on a trial basis. The Hearing Officer makes the same analysis for 2003-2004 as for 2002-2003, and finds that, with the exception of oral language, the services were designed to meet Petitioner’s needs during the 2003-2004 school year.
One-to-one aide
The record shows no reason to alter the analysis for the earlier school years with respect to the question of a one-to-one aide during the current school year. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s needs do not require a full-time shadow aide for the 2003-2004 school year.
Was the 2003-2004 program calculated to provide Petitioner an educational benefit?
Petitioner contends that the occupational therapy consultation program and the speech and language services identified in the January 7, 2004 IEP (Petitioner Exhibit 52) were not reasonably calculated to provide some benefit. The High School District argues that Petitioner benefitted from the programs in both of these areas. The District points to progress in both areas in the one-year interval between the annual IEP meetings from January 2003 to January 2004.
The evidence does show that STUDENT made progress on his coordination goals. He also showed progress in his nonverbal communication goals in the use of sign language and PECS. The occupational therapy goals and related motor skills goals were specifically calculated to increase his balance and ability to move through his environment. The communication goals were calculated to provide STUDENT advancement toward functional communication. The Hearing Officer finds that, with the exception of oral language, the High School District’s 2003-2004 occupational therapy and language program was reasonably calculated to provide an educational benefit to Petitioner.
Did the 2003-2004 program comport with Petitioner’s IEP’s and place him the least restrictive environment?
For the 2003-2004 school year Petitioner raises no contentions as to the program comporting with his IEPs or whether the program affords him the least restrictive environment for the Orangeview placement.
With respect to the proposed placement at Hope School in the January 2004 IEP, there is no comportment issue, as there has been no implementation of the offer. Petitioner does contend, however, that the offer would deprive STUDENT of interaction with typically developing peers. Petitioner expressed concern that, as he is particularly susceptible to imitation, the paucity of appropriate peer models at Hope School presents a disadvantage. The District witnesses indicated that a significant percentage of students at Hope School have behavioral problems and seven students have formal behavioral intervention plans (BIPs). The legal standard for placement is to offer a FAPE and “promote maximum interaction” between youth with disabilities and those without and to meet the “educational and service needs” of special education students in the least restrictive environment. Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. The Hope School program features “reverse mainstreaming” with typically developing peers participating in the program. The record, however, does not demonstrate that Hope School would provide to STUDENT the “maximum interaction” with typically developing peers. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that proposed placement at Hope School does not afford STUDENT the least restrictive environment.
The Hearing Officer finds that the High School District did not offer a FAPE to Petitioner for the 2003-2004 school year.
ISSUE NO. IX: Is autism Petitioner’s appropriate qualifying eligibility?
Petitioner contends that he should have autism as his qualifying category for special education instruction and services. Both the Elementary and the High School District maintain that his “autistic-like behaviors,” to the extent that there are any, are manifestations of his developmental delays and cognitive ability level or are not educationally significant.
Under State law, “autistic-like behaviors” may entitle a student to special education if the results of an assessment demonstrate the degree of the student’s impairment requires a special education program. This classification is determined by exhibiting any combination of seven behaviors listed in the California Administrative Code, 5 C.C.R. section 3030(g):
1. An inability to use oral language for appropriate communication. 2. A history of extreme withdrawal or relating to people inappropriately and continued impairment in social interaction from infancy through early childhood. 3. An obsession to maintain sameness.
4. Extreme preoccupation with objects or inappropriate us of objects or both. 5. Extreme resistance to controls.
6. Displays peculiar motoric mannerisms and motility patterns. 7. Self-stimulating, ritualistic behavior.
Under federal law, 34 C.F.R.§ 300.7 (c)(1)(i),“autism” is defined as “a developmental disability significantly affecting verbal and nonverbal communication and social interaction, generally evident before age three, that adversely affects a child’s educational performance. Other characteristics often associated with autism are engagement in repetitive activities and stereotyped movements, resistance to environmental change or change in daily routines, and unusual responses to sensory experiences.”
The record includes the opinions of Ms. Jessica Postil and Dr. Christine Majors that STUDENT does display autistic-like behaviors. Dr. Lott diagnosed STUDENT with “secondary autism” that resulted from his pervasive developmental delays. The teachers and staff of both Districts, however, viewed any of STUDENT’s “autistic tendencies” to be a consequence of his delays. Even Petitioner’s own assessors, such as Ms. Cottier in her assistive technology assessment, Ms. Cohen in her occupational therapy assessment, and Dr. Ballinger in her vision assessment, described STUDENT as attending for extensive periods of time, capable of eye contact, and generally compliant. High School District speech and language therapists Karin Daignault and Kathleen Wohlgemuth reported in their assessment (High School District Exhibit 25) classroom observations of STUDENT’s appropriate peer interactions, including sharing a teddy bear during play and empathizing by hugging a sad classmate. The Hearing Officer finds convincing the opinions of these assessors as well as the testimony of the teachers and staff who had experience with autistic students and who saw STUDENT on multiple occasions as opposed to clinical observations.
Under the criteria set forth in federal and State law, clearly STUDENT meets the criterion of an inability to use oral language for communication that has affected his social interaction. The evidence, however, amply supports that his cognitive ability, developmental delays, and cerebral palsy are the cause of this communication disability. The remaining criteria are either not observed regularly in STUDENT’s behavior or they are also a function of his cognitive ability, development delays, or cerebral palsy. For the preceding three school years, there was insufficient evidence to establish autism as a suspected disability either for the Elementary District or the High School District. The High School District also completed the GARS in March 2003 (High School District Exhibit 26) resulting in a finding of a low probability for autism.
There is no dispute that STUDENT qualifies under Cal. Educ. Code section 56026 (a) and (b) for special education instruction and services which cannot otherwise be provided with modification of the regular school program. He meets the disability requirements for significantly below average intellect, 5 C.C.R. § 3030 (h), and speech and/or language impaired, 5 C.C.R. § 3030 (c). Irrespective of the qualifying category, the High School District must meet STUDENT’s unique needs. 34 C.F.R. § 300.300 (a) (3) (ii)
The Hearing Officer finds by the weight of the evidence that Petitioner does not qualify for special education eligibility because of autism or autistic-like behaviors.
ISSUE NO. X: Are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for independent educational evaluations (IEEs)?
Petitioner is seeking reimbursement for the assessments performed by Dr. Majors, Ms. Postil, Dr. Ballinger, Ms. Cohen, Ms. Segal, and Ms. Cottier. Petitioner’s parents may obtain an independent educational evaluation (IEE) performed by a qualified expert at the District’s expense if the following requirements are met:
a. The parents disagree with an evaluation obtained by the District;
b. The District is unable to show at a due process hearing that its evaluation was appropriate.
34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b), (c)
The six IEEs for which Petitioner seeks reimbursement for his parents each follow a disagreement with the corresponding High School District assessment (Petitioner exhibits 105, 108, 109, 123). The Hearing Officer has found, however, in the case of each of the District assessments, that they were appropriate under Cal. Educ. Code sections 56320, 56322, and, where required, section 56322. Consequently, the Hearing Officer will not reimbursements for IEEs.
ISSUE NO. XI: Is Petitioner entitled to compensatory education prospectively for two years in the areas of discrete trial training, speech and language therapy and occupational therapy because of the denial of a free, appropriate public education for the 2000-2001, 2001-2002, 2002-2003, and 2003-2004 school years and extended school years?
A denial of FAPE by an educational agency entitles the student to “appropriate” relief in light of the purposes of IDEA. School Comm. Of the Town of Burlington v.Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 374; 105 S.C. 1996 (1985); 20 U.S.C. § 1415. The Burlington principle extends to compensatory education as a form of relief to students who have been denied a FAPE. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District, 916 F.2d 865 (3d. Cir. 1990). Compensatory education is an equitable remedy to replace lost educational services. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for-hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the Student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d. 1489, 1496-1497 (9th Cir. 1994).
Petitioner is seeking two years of compensatory education from the Elementary District in the form of occupational therapy, speech and language therapy, and DTT services because of the claimed failure to provide appropriate types and levels of these services. The Elementary District contests any claim by Petitioner for compensatory education. The District argues that Petitioner has failed to establish how the requested remedies relate to the purported deficiencies in the Elementary District’s program.
From the High School District, Petitioner is requesting placement at the NPS Buena Park School for two years as compensatory education based on the alleged failure of the District to provide an appropriate placement, speech and language, occupational therapy, assistive technology, vision therapy, and DTT. The High School District counters that Petitioner is not entitled to any compensatory education as he enjoyed an appropriate program and made progress commensurate with his cognitive ability and expected rate of growth.
As to the 2000-2001 and the 2001-2002 school years while Petitioner was enrolled in the Elementary District, the Hearing Officer found a procedural violation of FAPE in the form of the offer for speech and language services that was unclear whether the services were to be provided in a group or individual setting. For the 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 school years, after Petitioner transferred to the High School District, the Hearing Officer found a procedural and a substantive violation of FAPE as to the form of the offer for speech and language services and to the oral speech portion of Petitioner’s speech and language program. Additionally, the Hearing Officer found that the High School District committed procedural violations by proceeding without parental consent, failing to make a clear offer for assistive technology, and failing to have a general education teacher present at an IEP team meeting to discuss mainstreaming. Consequently, compensatory education is appropriate.
The Hearing Officer is adopting Ms. Segal’s recommendation as to individual speech production therapy daily for a six-month trial with regular monitoring and a reevaluation at six-month intervals. As the evidence shows that Petitioner has attending problems and a low frustration threshold with speech-related exercises, the initial therapy shall be in fifteen minute sessions subject to adjustment, shorter or longer, after sixty calendar days. This therapy is not to supplant Petitioner’s program for speech and language skills which shall incorporate oral language. The High School District shall locate an appropriate provider, who may be one of its own employees, an employee of a school district or a SELPA, or a private provider. The services shall commence no later than forty-five days after the date of this Decision. The Elementary District shall bear fifteen percent of the cost of the therapy for its duration and the High School District the balance. The compensatory therapy shall not exceed two years from the date of the first session.
ISSUE NO. XII: Is Petitioner entitled to placement at the Buena Park Speech and Language Development Center, a nonpublic school, for two years at public expense as compensatory education?
Petitioner seeks placement at the High School District’s expense at the Buena Park School, a nonpublic school (NPS), as compensatory education for denial of FAPE for the last two years. The High School District argues that it has offered an appropriate placement at Hope School and that Petitioner has failed to introduce any credible evidence that Buena Park School is appropriate to meet his needs.
The equitable principle of Burlington also provides hearing officers with the authority to award prospective placement or services in an NPS at public expense. Under this principle, a remedy may be fashioned to include NPS placement if the public school district did not provide a FAPE.
Relying primarily on the uncorroborated testimony of Dr. Majors, Petitioner contends that Buena Park School is an appropriate placement because of the favorable teacher/student ratio to address STUDENT’s attention deficits, the staff’s extensive training in autism, augmentative communication systems and assistive technology, and an environment of “total communication.” Dr. Majors also described the Buena Park School’s “upper-level program” in which STUDENT would work on the same type of academic skills as at Orangeview with a staff experienced with children having vision and hearing disabilities, and an occupational therapist. The evidence indicates, however, that none of these benefits of Buena Park School as argued by Petitioner are significantly absent in STUDENT’s current placement at Orangeview Junior High School. The Orangeview special day class has a similar teacher/student ratio. STUDENT receives redirection and prompts if he wanders from the task at hand. Occupational therapy and assistive technology are available at Orangeview to meet STUDENT’s needs. The High School District and GASELPA have the staff trained in dealing with all of STUDENT’s disabilities and needs. As STUDENT has hearing and vision correction that allows him to access his curriculum, there is no need for a staff trained in these areas of disability although the evidence indicates that the High School District and GASELPA have these resources at the ready.
The Hearing Officer has found that the High School District has offered Petitioner a FAPE with some exceptions. These exceptions are addressed in this decision. As the evidence demonstrates that the District and GASELPA have the resources to provide a FAPE to Petitioner, the Hearing Officer will not award this NPS placement as compensatory education. The Hearing Officer finds that the award above of oral speech and language therapy sufficiently remedies the denials of FAPE.
ORDER
(1) Within fifteen calendar days of the date of this Decision, the IEP team shall convene inviting the Elementary District and GASELPA to participate, to do the following:
(A) Draft an appropriate goal and objectives for oral expression and then formulate services that will address Petitioner’s needs in this area for immediate implementation in his school program, (B) Draft an appropriate program for compensatory oral language services as follows:
1. Compensatory services shall be provided in a six-month, Monday through Friday regimen of therapy, school holidays excepted, for fifteen minutes a session,
2. The therapy shall continue through the extended school year,
3. At the end of the six-month period, the IEP team shall meet with the provider to discuss Petitioner’s progress and determine whether to modify the nature of the services or shorten or lengthen the sessions, and shall determine if continuation or termination of the therapy is appropriate,
4. Within fifteen calendar days of the IEP meeting convened pursuant to paragraph (1), above, the High School District shall implement the compensatory services,
5. The compensatory services are to continue for a period not to exceed the end of the 2004-2005 extended school year,
6. The expense of this therapy shall be borne fifteen percent by the Elementary District and eighty-five percent by the High School District.
(C) Within fifteen calendar days of the IEP meeting convened pursuant to paragraph (1), above, the High School District shall draft an assessment plan limited to the area of oral expression if the team determines further assessment is necessary.
(2) Within fifteen calendar days of the date of this Decision, the High School District shall implement the assistive technology provisions of the January 7, 2004 IEP as to the purchase and provision to Petitioner of a Tech/Speak or comparable voice output device for a sixty calendar day trial after Petitioner receives this device. The IEP team shall evaluate the device and its effectiveness at the conclusion of the trial period and determine whether to continue providing this device or alterative audio output devices as appropriate.
(3) Within fifteen calendar days of the date of this Decision, the High School District shall prepare an assessment plan for an occupational therapy reassessment for presentation to Petitioner’s parents.
(4) All other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
(I) The Elementary District prevailed.
(II) Both Petitioner and the Elementary District prevailed in part. The Elementary District substantially prevailed on this issue.
(III) The Elementary District prevailed.
(IV) Both Petitioner and the Elementary District prevailed in part. The Elementary District substantially prevailed on this issue.
(V) The High School District prevailed.
(VI) Both Petitioner and the High School District prevailed in part. The High School District substantially prevailed on this issue.
(VII) The High School District prevailed.
(VIII) Both Petitioner and the High School District prevailed in part. The Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue.
(IX) The High School District prevailed.
(X) The High School District prevailed.
(XI) All parties prevailed in part. The Elementary District and the High School District substantially prevailed.
(XII) The High School District prevailed.
ADDENDUM TO PREVAILING PARTY STATUS
If the award of attorneys fees becomes an issue, the Hearing Officer makes the following comments. Both the request for the due process hearing and the statement of issues exchanged pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code section 56505(e)(6) listed thirty-six issues for adjudication. After the telephonic prehearing conference, the number of issues with inherent subparts was reduced to seventeen. A substantial amount of time was spent at the beginning of this seven-day hearing clarifying what issues would be heard. The final number was thirteen with multiple subparts. Some of these issues raised by Petitioner and joined by the Respondents were of little consequence to the delivery of a free, appropriate public education to Petitioner or to his requested remedies. Although the Hearing Officer expects Petitioner in a due process proceeding to raise all issues bearing on the student’s education, the Hearing Officer strongly recommends that Petitioner’s counsel in the future narrow the case at hearing to those issues of true disagreement and substance.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
DATED: May 28, 2004 _______________________ Tracy L. Tibbals, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The wording of the issues here differs somewhat from the statements of issues filed by the parties before the hearing and stated on the record before the presentation of evidence. Changes in the language and in the order were made for clarity and to facilitate analysis in this Decision. No changes in substance have been made.
2. DTT is a teaching technique used with children that breaks down behaviors into discrete steps paired with reinforcement and enforcement consequences and rewards with an aim toward generalizing the behaviors across other environments.
3. “ABA” includes analyses and approaches to increase the functioning of disabled students in a number of areas through behavioral “redirection.” DTT is one of the methodologies included under ABA.
4. Section 56320 (f) mandates assessments in all areas related to the suspected disability including, if appropriate, health and development, vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, intelligence, academic performance, communicative status, self-help, orientation and mobility, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional status.
5. The issue of an alleged missing health assessment that was also listed in the January 10, 2001 assessment plan was raised for the first time in Petitioner’s posthearing brief. Consequently, this issue will not be reached in this Decision.
6. Special education law also requires that the student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) placing the student to the maximum extent appropriate with normally developing peers (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550; Cal. Educ. Code § 56031). Neither specific placement or LRE is in dispute the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years and will therefore not be addressed for these years.
7. This issue of apraxia will be discussed in more detail under the services provided for the 2002-2003 school year.
8. As discussed with respect to the Elementary District offer of services, the term “assistive services” was understood by the parents and the rest of the IEP team to mean DTT.
9. Parents have the right to revoke their consent to the IEP “at anytime.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.500 (b) (1) (iii) (A) The High School District, however, continued after November 2002 to offer and implement the July 2002 IEP as modified by the two following IEPs until the annual IEP meeting in January 2003.
10. The District’s position is that basing the revocation on language was “disingenuous” because of the active involvement of translators (High School District Exhibit 10).
11. The parents also contend that STUDENT should have received direct occupational therapy services as discussed below.
12. The parents’ revocation of their consent to the July 2002 IEP on November 19, 2002, is one day after their proposed IEP meeting date
13. Although goals and objectives were prepared at the time of the October 2002 IEP meeting, they were not discussed according to the meeting notes.
14 The Hearing Officer makes a finding, below, that Petitioner does not qualify for special education under the category of autism.
15. This definitional code section states “‘Referral for assessment’ means any written request for assessment to identify an individual with exceptional needs made by any of the following: (a) A parent or guardian of the individual (b) A teacher or other service provider of the individual...”
