California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 7, 2002
Student v. Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 233-01 · Hearing Officer Jessica Katz
Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified denied FAPE to a preschooler on the autism spectrum and violated stay put; must reimburse parents and fund compensatory services.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The decision notes a related District-filed case, SN02-01487, decided by Hearing Officer Trevor Skarda on September 20, 2002. It allowed the District to assess the student beginning November 1, 2002, for use at the annual IEP meeting expected around January 2003. Stay put orders in this case were issued February 26, July 25, and August 1, 2001.
Summary
Parents of a preschool boy filed for due process in February 2001. At his first IEP, after he left regional center early intervention, Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified offered a 16.5-hour-per-week special day class at its Sunrise preschool program. He had an autism-spectrum diagnosis (PDD-NOS), but the District found him eligible under speech and language. The Hearing Officer held that neither the December 2000 offer nor the same placement offered in January 2002 provided a FAPE. The class had too few typical peers for him to model. He also needed home-based ABA, a trained one-on-one shadow aide, individual speech and occupational therapy after school, and a six-month transition plan. The District's own expert agreed on the home program and the transition plan. The class was also not his least restrictive environment. The District argued that the Hearing Office could not enforce its own stay put orders, but the Hearing Officer rejected that argument. She found the District failed to provide the ordered aide, home ABA, speech therapy and OT, and provided music therapy and transportation only from September 30, 2001. The District must repay the parents for services from the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD) and for private OT and speech therapy. The parents reported spending about $37,600. The District must also hold an IEP meeting within 30 days. It must offer up to 93 hours a year, for three years, of compensatory social and communication services. Compensatory music therapy was denied.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO handled a preschooler's move from early intervention to a school district IEP. The Hearing Officer required a transition plan and home ABA, and held that a hearing officer could enforce stay put orders while a case was still pending. Reimbursement and compensatory services were ordered for the stay put violations.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE at the December 4, 2000 IEP meeting?
The Sunrise special day class offer was not a FAPE. It gave too little contact with typical peers and left out home ABA, a trained shadow aide, individual after-school speech and OT, and a six-month transition plan from the IFSP. It was also not the LRE.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE at the January 9, 2002 IEP meeting?
The written offer repeated stay put, but the District treated it as a renewed Sunrise placement. Because his needs had not changed, the offer failed for the same reasons as the December 2000 offer.
- Student prevailedStay put
Issue 3. Did the District comply with the stay put orders issued by the Hearing Office on February 26, 2001, July 25, 2001 and August 1, 2001?
SEHO can enforce stay put orders issued while a case is pending (Wyner distinguished). The District complied on the typical preschool. It violated the orders on the shadow aide, home ABA, speech, OT, and music therapy and transportation before September 30, 2001.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for the out of pocket money they spent in obtaining the services spelled out in the stay put orders?
The parents' CARD ABA program and their private OT and speech therapy were appropriate. The parents are entitled to their out-of-pocket costs for these services.
- Student prevailedStay put
Issue 5. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the services that the District failed to offer under stay put?
The student was awarded compensatory social and communication services in place of missed ABA, OT and speech, to be banked over three years outside school hours. Compensatory music therapy was denied because it was not shown to be necessary.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 20 calendar days of receiving proof from the parents, reimburse the parents' CARD expenses from August 1, 2001 through the date of the decision.
- Reimbursement. Within 20 calendar days of receiving proof, reimburse occupational therapy expenses at Pediatric Therapy Network from May 8, 2001 through the date of the decision.
- Reimbursement. Within 20 calendar days of receiving proof, reimburse speech and language therapy expenses with Mary Ann Gordon O'Brien. The parents' closing brief reported $31,770.50 for CARD, $4,400 for speech, and $1,467 for OT as of October 7, 2002.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 30 calendar days, convene an IEP meeting to develop and offer an appropriate IEP consistent with the decision, and to discuss and offer compensatory education.
- Order to provide or change services. The IEP must offer a typical language-based preschool with a trained shadow aide. It must include a transition program of in-home IBI/ABA for at least six months that gradually phases into the classroom. It must include some individual and some group OT and speech therapy, with the individual therapy outside regular classroom hours.
- Compensatory education. Up to 93 hours per year for three years of social and communication-based programming, individual or group, outside regular classroom hours. The services must be completed by November 1, 2005 unless the parents agree otherwise, and the District must offer free transportation to the sessions.
Total: 279 hours of compensatory services
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education; Florence County School District Four v. Carter; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Alamo Heights Independent School District v. Texas Board of Education; Wyner v. Manhattan Beach Unified School District; Porter v. Board of Trustees of Manhattan Beach Unified School District; Stacey G. v. Pasadena Independent School District; Zvi D. v. Ambach; Thomas v. Cincinnati Board of Education
People named in the decision
- Dr. Stephanny Fumi Noro Freeman, expert witness for Student; director, early childhood partial hospitalization program, UCLA
- Dr. B.J. Freeman, expert witness and assessor for Student; professor of medical psychology, UCLA
- Rosamel Casado, case supervisor, private ABA provider, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
- Gretchen Axton, music therapist, Music Wonders (apparently)
- Shirley Resich, coordinator of special education, Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
- Roni Goodman, program specialist, Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
- Dr. Mary Ann Clark, program specialist / coordinator; assessment team member, Southwest SELPA / Wiseburn School District
- Barbara McGinty, speech-language pathologist, assessor, District / Sunrise program
- Doreen Hata, special education teacher, Sunrise program
- Robert Farran, director, Southwest SELPA
- Laura Stanek, occupational therapist, Sunrise program
- Beth Raposa, school psychologist, District
- Robin Shipley, behavior consultant, District
- Helen Sowell, nonpublic school liaison, District
- Jeanette Barker, adaptive physical education specialist, District
- Lynn Busia, director of pupil services, Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
- Dr. Bryna Siegel, expert witness for District; director, pervasive developmental disorders clinic, UCSF
- Ms. Bedoya, IEP team member (in place of special education teacher), District
- Ms. Mulligan, regional center caseworker, Harbor Regional Center
- Emi Baca, private occupational therapist, Pediatric Therapy Network
- Ms. Hampton, DTT supervisor, California Psychcare (apparently)
- Ms. Carwin, general education preschool teacher, Community Baptist preschool
- Nancy Milburn, educational consultant at IEP meeting, Filarsky & Watt
- Ms. Feldman, interim director, District / SELPA
- Dr. Sadeghi, director, nonpublic agency, California Psychcare
- Mary Ann Gordon O'Brien, private speech-language therapist
- Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer in related case SN02-01487, Special Education Hearing Office
- California Psychcare, nonpublic agency, DTT/ABA provider and aide
- Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), nonpublic agency, ABA provider and aide
- Working with Autism, nonpublic agency, ABA provider
- Music Wonders, music therapy provider
- Pediatric Therapy Network, private occupational therapy provider
- Harbor Regional Center, regional center (IFSP services and funding)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Jessica Katz, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Palos Verdes Estates, California, on July 23-24, August 6-7, 13-14, and September 4-5, and 10-13, 2002.
Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney George Crook of the law firm Newman Aaronson Vanaman. Also present on the Petitioner’s behalf were his parents. STUDENT’s baby sister was also present during the entire hearing. Respondent Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Andrew V. Arczynski of the law firm Filarsky & Watt LLP. Also present on behalf of the District were Shirley Resich, coordinator of special education, and Roni Goodman, program specialist.
Petitioner called the following witnesses: Dr. Stephanny Fumi Noro Freeman, director of the early childhood partial hospitalization program at UCLA; Rosamel Casado, case supervisor, center for autism and relate disorders (CARD); Shirley Resich, coordinator of special education; Gretchen Axton, music therapist; the Father; Dr. B.J. Freeman, professor in the department of medical psychology at UCLA; the MOTHER; and George Crook. District called the following witnesses: Dr. Mary Ann Clark, Southwest SELPA/Wiseburn school district coordinator; Barbara McGinty, speech and language pathologist; Doreen Hata, special education teacher; Robert Farran, director of Southwest SELPA; Laura Stanek, occupational therapist; Beth Raposa, school psychologist; Robin Shipley, behavior consultant; Helen Sowell, nonpublic school liaison; Jeanette Barker, APE specialist; Lynn Busia, director of pupil services; and Dr. Bryna Siegel, adjunct professor in the department of psychiatry at UCSF and director of the pervasive developmental disorders clinic.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The parties submitted written closing arguments, the last of which was received by the Hearing Officer on October 9, 2002. Thereafter, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
On December 4, 2000, an initial IEP meeting was held for STUDENT at the District. The parents disagreed with the offer of placement and filed for due process and stay put on February 5, 2001. On February 26, 2001, a stay put was ordered by the Hearing Office. Prior to entering the District, STUDENT received services through his IFSP; the stay put ordered placement in conformity with STUDENT’s IFSP. On July 16, 2001, Petitioner requested clarification on the stay put in regards to the extended school year (ESY) and times and providers of speech and language (SP/L) and occupational therapy (OT) services. On July 25, 2001, the Hearing Office issued an order in regards to OT and SP/L, but requested further information on the issue of ESY. On August 1, 2001, the Hearing Office issued an order regarding the duration of stay put services. All issues pertaining to stay put will be addressed in their entirety under issue number three. The parties attempted to settle the dispute on several occasions between February 2001 and July 2002, but were unsuccessful. In the meantime, the annual IEP meeting was held and the IEP became at issue.
On June 26, 2002, the District filed a request for a due process hearing in order to assess STUDENT. Case number SN02-01487 was heard on August 15 and 16, 2002, and a decision was issued by Hearing Officer Trevor Skarda on September 20, 2002. The Hearing Officer found that the District is entitled to conduct educational assessments on STUDENT beginning November 1, 2002, pursuant to the parties’ already signed agreements.
ISSUES
1. Did the District offer STUDENT a Free Appropriate Public Education (FAPE) at the December 4, 2000 IEP meeting?
2. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE at the January 9, 2002 IEP meeting?
3. Did the District comply with the stay put orders issued by the Hearing Office on February 26, 2001, July 25, 2001, and August 1, 2001?
4. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for the out-of-pocket money they spent in obtaining the services spelled out in the stay put orders?
5. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the services that the District failed to offer under stay put?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Petitioner contends that the District did not offer a FAPE on December 4, 2000, at the initial IEP meeting. Petitioner believes that the District failed to find that he is a child with autism and, therefore, could not determine his unique needs. Further, Petitioner contends that he needed a transition plan from his IFSP to his IEP and that the District failed to offer the transition plan. Once Petitioner filed for due process, Petitioner’s position was that the District failed to comply with multiple stay put orders from the Hearing Office. Petitioner requests reimbursement for services that his parents obtained consistent with the stay put orders. Further, Petitioner believes that the offer made at the January 9, 2002 IEP meeting was not an offer of FAPE. Petitioner also asserts that he is entitled to compensatory education for lost educational opportunity.
District contends that it made an appropriate offer of FAPE to Petitioner at the IEP meeting on December 4, 2000. District further asserts that the Hearing Officer has no authority to rule on the issue of failure to comply with the stay put order and that even if the Hearing Officer finds that she has authority, the District complied with the stay put orders as best it could. The District asserts that the parents refused to accept the services offered and that the parents unilaterally chose all service providers. Therefore, District contends that the parents are not entitled to any reimbursement or compensatory education. Further, the District contends that it made an appropriate offer of FAPE to STUDENT at the January 2002 IEP meeting.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a four-and-a-half-year-old boy who has been diagnosed with autistic-like behaviors. He was born on [date redacted]. STUDENT lives with his parents, his little brother, age three and a half and also autistic, and his little sister, age eight months. When STUDENT was eighteen months old, he was referred to the Harbor Regional Center (HRC) for services, and an individualized family service plan (IFSP) was developed for STUDENT and his family. At age two and half, he had a preliminary diagnosis of autism. A new IFSP was developed for STUDENT and his family on June 6, 2000, which was then revised in September 2000.
Prior to STUDENT’s entering the District, STUDENT’s program consisted of 15 hours a week of typical preschool with a one-on-one aide 10 hours per week during preschool, 21.5 hours a week of discreet trial training (DTT) with California Psychcare (CP),(Footnote 1) 2 hours per week of speech and language service at the home, 2 hours per week of clinic-based occupational therapy, and one hour a week of music therapy. Prior to STUDENT’s enrollment in the District, the parents had STUDENT evaluated by several agencies. In November 2000, his parents brought him to Dr. BJ Freeman at UCLA for a thorough assessment. Dr. BJ Freeman diagnosed STUDENT on the autism spectrum. The parents also took STUDENT and his brother to the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD) in November 2000. CARD conducted its own assessment and placed STUDENT and his brother on the waiting list. In September 2000, through a referral from HRC, STUDENT and his family had its initial contact with the District and the assessment process began.
The District conducted a multidisciplinary comprehensive psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT during November 2000. The assessment team was composed of a school psychologist, Beth Raposa; a speech and language pathologist, Barbara McGinty; an occupational therapist, Laura Stanek; a behavior specialist, Robin Shipley; a special education teacher, Doreen Hata; a school nurse, and a program specialist, Dr. Mary Ann Clark. This team interviewed STUDENT, his parents, STUDENT’s teacher from Community Baptist preschool, and his services providers from California Psychcare. Some members of the team also observed STUDENT in his educational setting at Community Baptist preschool. The team also reviewed all of STUDENT’s prior assessments.
The assessment procedures consisted of transdiciplinary play assessment by which each of the team members observed STUDENT in a natural setting playing with a variety of toys and instruments. Each member of the team had a different specialty and analyzed him from that perspective. STUDENT also participated in several tests -- the Carolina Curriculum for preschoolers with special needs, the Peabody motor scales, the preschool language scale, the analysis of sensory behavior – revised, and the Gilliam Autism rating scale. The team looked at several areas to determine STUDENT’s current level of functioning: learning to learn skills; readiness to learn skills (behavioral compliance); pre-academic skills (attention and memory, general concepts, size and number concepts, reasoning); play skills; speech and language development; social and emotional development (responsibility, self-concept, interpersonal skills); daily living skills (eating, dressing, grooming, and toileting); fine motor skills (visual motor integration, biomechanical postural control--eye hand coordination, visual motor skills, hand use, manipulation, bilateral skills, and tool use); sensory registration and processing (vestibular system, proprioceptive system, and tactile system); motor planning (gross motor skills, balance, locomotor, stairs and climbing, object control, and learning style). During the assessment process, STUDENT was very cooperative and the team concluded that they conducted a thorough evaluation and assessment.
The results of the assessment revealed that STUDENT demonstrated pre-academic skills ranging from two years six months to three years emerging to four years six months. He had higher skills in the areas of number and letter recognition, identifying colors and shapes, and counting objects. His daily living skills ranged from two years six months to four years, and his social and emotional skills ranged from two years to three years. STUDENT’s receptive language skills were scattered between two years and three years. His receptive language skills were through two years six months. Overall, receptive and expressive language skills were in the low average range to moderately delayed. STUDENT’s fine motor development was considered average. His gross motor skills were scattered from below to within normal range compared to peers his own age. STUDENT’s main weaknesses were in the area of pragmatics (social language), play skills and self-care skills. STUDENT was found to have pervasive developmental disorder (PDD)/not otherwise specified (NOS), atypical autism with mild autistic-like behaviors.
On December 4, 2000, an initial IEP meeting was held at the District. All members of the assessment team (with the exception of Doreen Hata, who was replaced by Ms. Bedoya) were also members of the IEP team. Also present as members of the IEP team were Ms. Mulligan and a manager from HRC; Emi Baca, occupational therapist from pediatric therapy network; Ms. Hampton, a DTT supervisor; Ms. Carwin, STUDENT’s general education teacher; Nancy Milburn, an educational consultant from the law firm of Filarsky and Watt;(Footnote 2) and both Mr. and Mrs PARENT. STUDENT was found eligible for special education under the category of speech and language, rather than autism. A program was developed for him at the Sunrise preschool.
The Sunrise program had four special day class (SDC) language-based classrooms with the same number of students and teachers. Within the Sunrise program, there were several specialists that spent time in each of the four classrooms, a speech and language therapist, an occupational therapist, an adaptive physical education teacher, a nurse, and a program specialist. Each specialist worked with the children in small groups or one-on-one, depending on the children’s needs. Each SDC class had 9-12 full-time special education students between the ages of 3 and 5 years old, in addition to 2-4 part-time “typical” preschool students. The special education students had varying eligibility categories, such as autism, speech and language difficulties, Down syndrome, and developmental delays. Within the classroom, there were three to four aides, some full-time, some part-time, and one full-time special education teacher. The program offered to STUDENT consisted of a 16.5-hour-a-week SDC at the Sunrise program.
During the IEP meeting, Petitioner’s parents did not agree with the program offered. Additionally, the parents believed that STUDENT should be eligible as an autistic child because he was previously diagnosed by several doctors and assessment teams as autistic. Yet, despite the label of PDD/NOS, which is on the autistic spectrum, the District found STUDENT eligible only under the category of speech and language. The parents also wanted a transition plan from the previous service providers to the program offered by the District, but none was offered. The issue of developing a transition plan was raised at the IEP meeting by the parents; the District members of the IEP team did not believe that STUDENT needed a transition plan and testified that the only reason that they considered meeting for a subsequent IEP meeting was to develop a plan for the parents. The District members of the IEP team members believed that the program offered was the best and most appropriate program for STUDENT.
A subsequent IEP meeting was scheduled; however, the parents cancelled the IEP meeting because they filed for due process on February 5, 2001, and requested a stay put of STUDENT’s prior placement. On February 26, 2001, the Hearing Office issued an order granting stay put of STUDENT’s previous IFSP placement. Meanwhile, HRC continued to pay for services for STUDENT until the District began providing the stay put placement and services. On March 8, 2001, the District sent the family a letter stating proposed times of OT and SP/L stay put services. All proposed times conflicted with STUDENT’s typical preschool and DDT services. The parents telephoned the District employees several times to arrange for services. Due to the pending due process hearing, the District employees refused to talk to the parents on the telephone and requested that all communication be done through written correspondence. Several letters were sent to the parents regarding scheduling of services and the scheduling of the “stay put IEP” meeting, and the parties agreed to hold a meeting on May 8, 2001. (Footnote 3) In April 2001, Working with Autism (WWA) had contacted the family to begin intensive behavior intervention (IBI)/applied behavior analysis (ABA) services.(Footnote 4) WWA began working with STUDENT on or about May 1, 2001.
On May 8, 2001, a stay put IEP meeting was held. The District proposed placing STUDENT at Discovery World private preschool 15 hours a week, with a one-on-one aide 10 hours a week. Further, the District would provide the OT and SP/L services as spelled out in the stay put order. The District would utilize an NPA for both IBI/ABA services and music therapy. The parents did not immediately sign the stay put IEP because they wanted to first consult with their attorney. On or about May 9, 2001, WWA contacted the parents to inform them that the District had cancelled the contract with WWA to provide services to STUDENT because the parents had not signed the IEP. Immediately following the discussion with WWA, Father contacted the District to sign the “stay put IEP.” The District told the parents that a full IEP team needed to be present to sign the IEP, and offered either May 14 or 16, 2001, for the parents to sign the “stay put IEP.” On May 16, 2001, the parents signed the “stay put IEP,” but objected to the placement at Discovery World because they felt that it was too much like day care and would not meet STUDENT’s needs. However, the parents agreed on all other proposed services in the “stay put IEP.” The District informed the parents that if Discovery World was refused, the District would not provide a one-on-one aide. The parents signed the IEP and recontacted WWA; however, WWA no longer had space available for STUDENT.
Following the stay put IEP offer, HRC continued to pay for the typical preschool (Community Baptist) and the one-on-one aide (California Psychcare aide), and the District assumed responsibility for the majority of the services. On or about June 1, 2001, the District began contracting with California Psychcare to once again provide services for STUDENT. California Psychcare was told to provide services only through July 20, 2001, rather than year-round. On July 16, 2001, Petitioner filed a motion for clarification on the stay put in regards to year-round services and the times and providers of OT and SP/L services. The Hearing Office ordered that to accommodate STUDENT’s schedule, either the District or an NPA could provide OT and SP/L services. More information was requested by the Hearing Office to rule on the issue of year-round services. On August 1, 2001, after receiving more information, the Hearing Office issued a clarification to the stay put order, ordering services year-round, including August.
Meanwhile, the District did not offer an NPA provider for OT or SP/L. The District employees testified that because they had OT and SP/L specialists on staff, there was no need to contract out to an NPA. However, the District’s only offered times for OT and SP/L conflicted with STUDENT’s preschool and DTT services. The District made multiple attempts to find a time that would fit into STUDENT’s schedule, but never varied from the hours that STUDENT received other services. The parents therefore acquired service providers at their own expense.
Contrary to the stay put order of August 1, 2001, the District failed to provide IBI/ABA services in August 2001.(Footnote 5) Further, CP stopped providing an aide during school hours because HRC paid less per hour to the aides than to the in-home service providers. In June 2001, CARD began providing in-home services to STUDENT’s brother. In July 2001, HRC contracted with CARD to provide STUDENT’s one-on-one aide because CP had cancelled its contract with HRC. In July 2001, CARD informed the parents that STUDENT’s name had come up on the waiting list for in-home services. When STUDENT’s services with CP ended, the parents began utilizing CARD for ABA services on or about August 1, 2001.
In early September 2001, CP attempted to contact the parents to resume services but the family was on vacation. When the family returned, MOTHER informed the school that STUDENT would be staying with CARD. On September 30, 2001, the District agreed to provide music therapy and transportation to STUDENT in accordance with his “stay put IEP.” There was no further contact with the family until arrangements needed to be made for the annual IEP meeting that was held on January 9, 2002.
The parents requested that the annual IEP meeting be held the same day as his brother’s transition IEP meeting on January 9, 2002. The parents initially informed the District that they would have all of STUDENT’s service providers present at the IEP meeting and had assumed that the District would also provide information about STUDENT. When the parents were informed that the District had intended that the IEP meeting be for information gathering only, the parents, through advice of counsel, refused to have the providers present, even though all providers were on the school site for his brother’s IEP meeting.
On January 9, 2002, the District offered STUDENT placement in the Sunrise SDC, the same placement as offered in the previous IEP, with no other services. However, Sunrise was moving campuses and would no longer have mainstreaming and reverse mainstreaming opportunities for STUDENT. The parents rejected the offer and requested that the District pay for CARD services pending the outcome of the due process hearing.(Footnote 6) The District testified that CARD was not a good service provider because one of the districts in the SELPA had difficulty obtaining administrative records, and therefore, refused to pay for CARD.
Between January and the commencement of the hearing, many unsuccessful attempts at settlement occurred. Due to a lack of agreement between the parties, this matter commenced for hearing on July 23, 2002.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. Did the District offer STUDENT a Free Appropriate Public Education (FAPE) at the December 4, 2000 IEP meeting?
Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); California Education Code §56000.) Federal and State law mandates that all children with disabilities have available to them a FAPE that includes special education and related services to meet their unique needs. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; California Education Code § 56000 et seq.)
The analysis of whether a student has been provided a FAPE is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to decide whether the proposed program is substantively appropriate and whether procedural steps have been followed. (Board of Hendrick Hudson School District v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 206-207.) The standard for determining whether the proposed program offers STUDENT a FAPE involves the following factors: whether the placement and services are designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs; are reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to him; and conform to his IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, 458 U.S. 176.)
In Rowley, the Supreme Court decided the appropriate level of instruction and services that must be provided to students with disabilities in order to satisfy the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education instruction or services, or that those services maximize a student’s potential. The Court stated that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.” (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200.) In determining whether the school district has offered a FAPE, the focus is on the adequacy of the district’s proposed program. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District, (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307.) If the district has offered a FAPE, the district is not required to place the student in the program preferred by the parents, even if the preferred program is likely to result in greater educational benefit. (Id.)
Moreover, special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a student from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in regular education classes cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Education Code § 56031.)
The Petitioner contends that he was not offered a FAPE in the December 4, 2000 IEP meeting, because the program was not designed to meet his unique needs and it was not in the least restrictive environment. Further, Petitioner contends that no transition plan was offered from the IFSP to the IEP, and that due to the major change in placement, STUDENT needed a transition plan.
The District asserts that STUDENT was offered a FAPE at the December 4, 2000 IEP meeting, that the SDC class was an appropriate offer for STUDENT, and that it was designed to meet his unique needs in the least restrictive environment. Further, the District contends that STUDENT did not need a transition plan.
What are STUDENT’s unique needs?
Before is can be determined whether the District’s offered placement and program is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, it is necessary to first determine what his unique needs were at the time of the offer. It is undisputed that STUDENT has pervasive developmental disorder (PDD)/not otherwise specified (NOS), which is on the autistic spectrum. Generally, STUDENT is very verbal.
STUDENT’s levels of performance at the time of the December 4, 2000 IEP meeting showed that STUDENT had a readiness to learn in that his imitation skills were emerging, his ability to pay attention was good, though he performed better during preferred activities, and he was cooperative in following age-appropriate directions in a school environment, with emerging skills at home. STUDENT was tested on his pre-academic skills and was generally found in the two year six month range for attention and memory, general concepts (alphabet, colors, and numbers), size and number concepts (big/little), and reasoning (cause and effect, and why questions). STUDENT’s play skills were limited. He only had very basic pretend skills, did not initiate play with peers, and was just beginning parallel play. He needed help in the areas of play skills, pre-vocational skills, self-help skills, speech and language, and occupational therapy.
STUDENT’s main delays were in the areas of speech and language, communication and social and play skills. Although, academically, STUDENT was functioning at his age level, he needed additional processing time with verbal information. Because of STUDENT’s difficulty with imitation, he needed a setting with typical peers in order to enhance those skills. STUDENT needed ample opportunity for modeling behaviors and speech of typical peers. STUDENT acquired skills with minimal exposure and was a “fast learner.” STUDENT needed individualized teaching that focused on expressive semantics and pragmatics. STUDENT needed both verbal and physical prompting, from either a teacher or an aide, to initiate play, and participate in group activities with peers.
In regards to occupational therapy, STUDENT had difficulty with object control (demonstrating significantly below average range compared with peer performance), and had emerging skills in balance and locomotor. He needed additional supports from both individual and group therapy to overcome his deficits.
Each of the party’s contentions will be discussed below to determine if the services and placement offered by the District were designed to meet his unique needs and were reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. Because the Petitioner was never made available for the District’s offered placement and program, it is unnecessary to determine if the actual placement and program was properly implemented and comported with his IEP.
Was the December 4, 2000 IEP offer designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and was it reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?
Petitioner contends that the District could not have met his unique needs because the District labeled STUDENT under the category of speech and language rather than autism (Footnote 7) . However, it is clear that the Petitioner does not dispute the assessment or the goals and objectives formulated from that assessment but disputes that the placement and services were not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. STUDENT believed that his program was generally inappropriate because he needed at least twenty-five to thirty hours a week of structured programming to keep him actively engaged and actively learning. STUDENT contends that he needed an environment where he could interact on a consistent basis with typically developing peers in order to model appropriate communication and behaviors. The Petitioner contends that he needed one-on-one behavior intervention outside of the regular classroom so that he could work on his play and communication skills in a natural environment and then practice the skills within the classroom with the assistance of a shadow aide(Footnote 8) . Petitioner asserts that he needed individual speech and language therapy after school hours because this was his greatest area of deficit. STUDENT also believes that due to his object control difficulties, he needed individual occupational therapy after school hours. STUDENT also asserted that he needed a transition plan from his IFSP to his IEP.
The District asserts that it offered STUDENT an appropriate program that was both designed to meet his unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. On December 4, 2000, the District offered STUDENT a placement in Sunrise special day class (SDC) for five days a week, three hours and twenty minutes a day. The class was described as a fully included classroom with typical peers.(Footnote 9) His program consisted of individual/small group speech and language therapy, two times a week for thirty minutes; adaptive P.E. in a small group in either the classroom or clinic, two times per month for thirty minutes, to be monitored; occupational therapy in a small group in the classroom, two times per month for thirty minutes, to be monitored.
Typical peers
Petitioner contends that the offered placement at the Sunrise SDC class did not meet his unique needs because he was not given enough opportunity to be with typical peers. Petitioner contends that he needed a program rich in social curriculum in order to maximize the opportunities for modeling, but that the District’s program at Sunrise did not give STUDENT an opportunity to model appropriate peer behaviors and interactions.
The District argues that its program would provide a language-based curriculum with highly trained teachers and professionals that has ample opportunity to interact in a fully included program typical peers. The District believed that the 2-4 typical peers that attended the SDC class for two to three days a week would give STUDENT sufficient opportunity to be with typical peers. Further, the SDC class had both mainstreaming and reverse mainstreaming opportunities with Discovery World and Town and Country preschools for 1-2 hours a week.
The Hearing Officer finds that the SDC class did not offer STUDENT an opportunity to model typical peers on a regular basis. STUDENT had emerging imitation skills and had difficulty with both verbal and nonverbal communication. If STUDENT had begun modeling incorrect social behaviors or communication, this would have been detrimental to his needs. STUDENT was moving into the observational learning stage. He needed a program that would teach him appropriate communication skills with typical peers; however, the majority of the students in the SDC were disabled. To only have 2-4 typical peers to model, STUDENT would likely begin modeling inappropriate speech and behaviors. Although the staff within the SDC class testified that STUDENT would have ample opportunity for modeling his disabled peers and occasional typical peers, the Hearing Officer is not convinced that this was appropriate modeling for STUDENT.
The District also argued that STUDENT would have ample opportunity for both mainstreaming and reverse mainstreaming. However, Ms. Hata, the special education teacher, testified that there were only one to two hours a week for mainstreaming and reverse mainstreaming opportunities. Further, Ms. Hata explained that STUDENT may not have always been included in the mainstreaming opportunities because only three to four children per classroom could attend Discovery World and/or Town and Country each week. The Hearing Officer does not believe that this mainstreaming and reverse mainstreaming would have been adequate to meet STUDENT’s need to be with typical peers. In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s program was not designed to meet his need to be with typical peers, nor was it reasonably calculated to provide him the educational benefit that he could have acquired from being with typical peers.
Individualized behavior intervention
Petitioner contends that in order to address his needs in the areas of communication and social and play skills, he needed IBI/ABA in-home services because he needed individualized instruction to work on his semantics and pragmatics. Further, Petitioner argued that he needed a one-on-one shadow aide who was familiar with the home program to help implement the IBI/ABA services within the school setting. Additionally, STUDENT contends that he needed to be actively engaged for 25 to 30 hours a week, which included both school-based and home-based programs.
The District argued that STUDENT did not need individualized instruction because the program that was offered included IBI/ABA services within the classroom environment. Further, the District asserted that STUDENT only needed a comprehensive school-based program with no additional services outside of the classroom or an additional aide within the classroom.
The December 4, 2000 IEP did not offer STUDENT IBI/ABA in-home services. However, the District clearly agreed that STUDENT needed individualized instruction in both pragmatics and semantics, but disagreed with the location and the intensity. According to Dr. BJ Freeman, the purpose behind a communication-based intensive in-home program was to teach skills in the home that could be reinforced in the school/social environment. Dr. BJ Freeman explained that a one-on-one behavior intervention program should take place in the natural environment (the home) and teach the child skills that he could use elsewhere. Further, Dr. Freeman testified that a child on the autistic spectrum, including PDD/NOS, needs a structured program that includes both a preschool and an IBI/ABA type program in the home that will keep him or her engaged for 25-30 hours a week to maximize his learning potential. The District’s expert witness, Dr. Bryna Siegel, also testified that higher functioning children respond more robustly to intervention and that a high functioning autistic child such as STUDENT would respond best to both a model preschool and a home-based intensive behavior intervention program. The Hearing Officer agrees with both Doctors BJ Freeman and Bryna Siegel that STUDENT needed a home-based IBI/ABA type of program in December 2000.
STUDENT also needed consistency between his IBI/ABA home-based program and his preschool environment. STUDENT argued that he needed a one-on-one aide trained in behavior intervention. The District agreed that STUDENT needed prompting both verbally and physically from either a teacher or an aide, but argued that an aide would be more intrusive. The District witnesses testified that STUDENT would become so dependent on the aide that he would become a passive responder. Further, the District argued that STUDENT would be stigmatized by his peers because of the adult supervision. The District believed that it would be more beneficial for STUDENT to have a special education teacher and several specially trained aides to assist in prompting rather that just an aide without the special education teacher. However, Ms. Shipley, the behaviorist from the District, testified that if an aide were properly trained, a child would not become dependent. Ms. Shipley explained that the goal for the shadow aide is to become unnecessary to the child. The shadow aide gradually pulls away from the child and eventually becomes unknown to the child. Based on Ms. Shipley’s explanation, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded that an aide would be more intrusive than an SDC. The Hearing Officer finds that a one-on-one shadow aide that is specially trained in appropriate behavior intervention and that is familiar with STUDENT’s home-based intervention would be the logical one-on-one aide.
In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s program was not designed to meet his needs in the areas of communication and play and social skills, nor was it reasonably calculated to provide him the educational benefit that he could have acquired from being in an IBI/ABA home-based program and having a trained IBI/ABA shadow aide within the classroom environment.
Speech and language
Petitioner contends that the District could not meet his speech and language needs at the Sunrise program. Petitioner asserts that he needed individual speech and language services outside the regular school day. Dr. BJ Freeman explained that STUDENT had a major deficit in speech and language and believed that only two 30-minute small-group sessions was not appropriate for STUDENT. She explained that STUDENT needed both small-group speech and language and individual speech and language after school hours. Because STUDENT needed to have ample opportunity for social interaction with his peers, his work on speech and language development should not have interfered with his preschool program. Petitioner does not contend that the services offered within the program were inappropriate, just that he needed additional services.
The District contends that the Sunrise program is a language-based program that focuses on speech and language throughout the day. The Sunrise program has four different classrooms that are similarly situated. The speech and language pathologist is a member of the team and works in each of the four classrooms during the daily activities and programming. Speech and language was integrated into the centers with three to four children, one of whom was a nondisabled child who helped with modeling appropriate language. There were high levels of adult prompts throughout the day mixed with lessons in each activity e.g. using the restroom. Each program and lesson plan was structured, and there was modified language used for each child within the classroom to conform to each child’s IEP. The District believed that because of the language-based curriculum, as well as the group speech and language sessions, STUDENT did not need an additional two hours a week of speech and language therapy.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needed a program that would encourage his communication skills. He lacked the ability to initiate play with peers and needed a program that could teach him how to walk up to another little child and ask to play. The District testified that the Sunrise program continually encouraged communication between children and adults to work on speech and language components of each child’s IEP. The Hearing Officer believes that although STUDENT needed a language-based program, like Sunrise, STUDENT also needed additional individual supports outside of the classroom environment. STUDENT’s biggest area of deficit was speech and language, and the Hearing Officer does not believe that the Sunrise program adequately addressed this component of STUDENT’s education. The Hearing Officer concludes that the Sunrise program did not meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of speech and language because he needed additional support beyond the classroom day, nor was the program reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit.
Occupational therapy
Petitioner contends that the District failed to offer an appropriate amount of OT in the December 4, 2000 IEP beyond the classroom day. STUDENT was receiving two hours a week of individual clinic-based OT through his IFSP, and the IEP offered only two occupational therapy session per month for thirty minutes of monitoring within the classroom. According to the IEP of December 4, 2000, STUDENT’s occupational therapist explained that STUDENT needed OT to expand his play repertoire and that he needed to work on his gross motor skills. (P-Exh.3)
The District contends that the Sunrise program offered STUDENT an appropriate amount of OT because the occupational therapist was involved in the program on a daily basis. The occupational therapist testified that STUDENT did not have any significant delays in his fine and gross motor skills that would warrant additional individual OT. However, the occupational therapist explained that STUDENT was to be monitored for his OT needs and if necessary, the Sunrise program would offer a pull-out for OT. Laura Stanek, the occupational therapist from the Sunrise program, explained that once a week, the children in the classroom attend the OT clinic. Additionally, Ms. Stanek leads a sensory motor group in the classroom, one time a week for thirty minutes. Ms. Stanek also designs at least one lesson plan a week to work on fine motor skills. Ms. Stanek also regularly works in the classroom in the different centers working with the children on their fine and gross motor skills.(Footnote 10)
The evidence, both documentary and testimonial, established that STUDENT was progressing in his gross motor skills but still needed assistance in object control and did not have any significant delays in fine motor skills. Further, the program at Sunrise could teach STUDENT skills in his areas of deficits. There is no evidence that STUDENT needed the individual attention from Ms. Stanek on fine motor skills. However, STUDENT was significantly below the average range of children his age on his object control and needed more individualized work than the IEP offered. Ms. Stanek did not indicate how the weekly classroom visit to the OT clinic would be individualized to address STUDENT’s gross motor deficits. The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT needed an occupational therapy program that was integrated into the classroom environment, such as the Sunrise program. However, STUDENT also needed individual occupational therapy outside of the school hours to work on his object control. Because the District failed to offer individual occupational therapy program that would meet STUDENT’s needs outside of the school, the Hearing Officer concludes that the offered OT was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs or provide him educational benefit.
Transition services
The parents requested a transition plan at the December 4, 2000 IEP meeting because STUDENT had been receiving over forty hours of intensive services a week, and the District only offered approximately 16.5 hours per week of an SDC. Petitioner asserted that as a three-year-old, he needed consistency and stability in his program. He argued that transitioning from a typical preschool program in the morning and IBI/ABA services in the afternoon plus six hours a week of SP/L, OT and music therapy, to a 16.5-hour-a-week SDC program with no afternoon or in-home services would have been too much of a change for him. Dr. BJ Freeman explained that without an appropriate transition plan that addressed consistency and planned structured activities, STUDENT would likely have regressed.
The District argued that no transition plan was needed for STUDENT; rather, his parents may have needed a transition from the IFSP to the IEP. However, both the special education teacher, Ms. Hata, and the District’s expert witness, Dr. Bryna Siegel, testified that STUDENT needed a transition plan by which he could continue his after-school program for some time while attending the Sunrise program in the morning. Dr. Siegel testified that a transition plan is “most important” for a child and that it should be done in a continuum. The child should first start an integration component for at least six months and then the program should be reevaluated. Dr. Siegel also believed that the transition plan should be written into the IEP because whenever there is a home-based program provided through an IFSP, there is bound to be a change of providers (either to another home-based program or to a school-based program), and both the parents and the child need to have time to prepare for the changes. Therefore, based on the testimony of the District’s witnesses, the Hearing Officer is convinced that STUDENT needed a transition plan for at least six months. According to Dr. Siegel, the District should have written a six-month transition plan so that STUDENT could gradually transition from his intensive home-based program into the school based program. The transition plan should have addressed the issue of fading out the IBI/ABA in-home program in addition to the IBI/ABA aide within the classroom. The Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offer was insufficient because it failed to offer a transition plan to STUDENT and was therefore not designed to meet his unique needs nor was it reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the December 4, 2000 IEP offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs nor did it offer STUDENT educational benefit. The District offered an SDC class that did not enable STUDENT to have frequent communication and contact with typical peers. The program also failed to include IBI/ABA in home services and a one-on-one shadow aide within the school setting. The program did not offer individual speech and language and occupational therapy services outside of the school setting. Finally the IEP failed to include a transition plan for STUDENT from his IFSP to his IEP.
Was the placement offered in the December 4, 2000 IEP in the least restrictive environment?
The law requires that STUDENT be educated to the maximum extent possible with his nondisabled peers. Removal from the general education environment must only occur when the nature and severity of a child’s disability is such that education in the general education classroom cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A).) STUDENT’s placement was to be in a special day class (SDC) at Sunrise school. The SDC is a program for preschoolers with special needs. There are approximately fifteen children in the classroom at any given time. Present on a daily basis were about nine to twelve children with disabilities. Each day, approximately two to four “typical” nondisabled preschoolers attended the program to offer mainstreaming opportunities for the disabled children. The typical peers would attend the program either two or three days a week. The SDC has one special education teacher, one to four full-time aides, a part-time OT, a part-time SP/L specialist, a part-time adaptive P.E. teacher.(Footnote 11)
As previously explained, the Sunrise program did not offer STUDENT enough opportunities to be with nondisabled peers. No evidence was presented that STUDENT’s disability was so severe that it warranted a special day class. Much evidence was presented that a one-on-one aide is actually more restrictive than an SDC class because the child becomes dependent on the aide; however, the Hearing Officer was not persuaded by that testimony. To the contrary, at the time of the offer, STUDENT worked with a one-on-one aide in the classroom who was also a member of his DTT program. His aide was able to incorporate the DTT program into the social setting by prompting STUDENT both verbally and physically. There was no evidence presented that STUDENT became dependent on his aide or that he did not interact with the rest of the students because of the aide’s involvement. Additionally, Robin Shipley, the school behaviorist, testified that an aide could be beneficial if appropriately trained to help the child access the learning environment. On the basis of STUDENT’s unique needs as described above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the SDC was not the least restrictive environment for STUDENT.
2. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE at the January 9, 2002 IEP meeting?
On January 9, 2002, the District convened an annual IEP for STUDENT. The District’s written offer was to maintain the services as identified under stay put. However, all of the District witnesses testified that the offer on January 9, 2002 IEP was for STUDENT to attend the Sunrise program. Additionally, the District’s closing brief stated that the District reiterated what it had previously offered in December 2000. Further, based on the testimony of the parents, it was also their impression that the District’s offer was the Sunrise classroom. Additionally, in the body of the IEP, the District states that “the team reinforces their idea and belief that the language based curriculum is best for STUDENT in conjunction with the collaboration of additional educational therapists and providers.” Therefore, despite the written offer (a reiteration of the stay put order), the Hearing Officer will analyze the offer as an offer to place STUDENT at Sunrise.
Because the Hearing Officer already found that the District’s offer of December 4, 2000, was not a FAPE, and no new evidence was presented that STUDENT’s needs had changed, the Hearing Officer concludes that the January 9, 2002 IEP did not offer STUDENT a FAPE.
3. Did the District comply with the stay put orders issued by the Hearing Office on February 26, 2001, July 25, 2001 and August 1, 2001?
Petitioner asserts that the District failed to comply with the three stay put orders issued by the Hearing Office. Petitioner contends that the District did not provide IBI/ABA in-home services, speech and language, and occupational therapy.
The District asserts that every effort was made to accommodate the family and that the family chose to make unilateral placements for STUDENT with CARD and refused OT and SP/L therapy. Further, the District contends that the Hearing Officer does not have authority to rule on the issue of compliance with stay put.
Under State and federal law, a special education student is entitled to remain in his or her present educational placement pending the completion of a due process procedure unless the parents and the public educational agency agree otherwise. (Cal. Ed. Code § 56505(d); 20 U.S.C. § 1415; Stacey G. v. Pasadena Independent School District (5th Cir. 1983); Zvi D. v. Gordon Ambach, 694 F.2d 904 (2nd Cir. 1982).) For purposes of stay put, the current educational placement is typically the placement contained in the student’s last agreed upon Individualized Education Program (IEP) which has been implemented prior to the dispute arising. (Thomas v. Cincinnati Bd. Of Educ.,918 F.2d 218 (6th Cir. 1990).) The purpose of stay put is to maintain the status quo pending resolution of the due process matter. (Stacey G. v. Pasadena Independent School District, 695 F.2d 949, 953 (5th Cir. 1983); Zvi D. v. Gordon Ambach, 694 F.2d 904 (2nd Cir. 1982).) Stay put applies automatically upon the filing of a due process hearing request.
District contends, citing Wyner v. Manhattan Beach Unified School District (9th Cir. 2000) 223 F.3d 1026, that the Hearing Officer lacks authority to rule on the issue of violations of stay put. The court in Wyner held that SEHO does not have authority to enforce an order from a prior due process hearing, i.e., after relinquishing jurisdiction over the parties by rendering a final decision. Wyner is distinguishable since the stay put order in this case was issued during the pendency of the hearing and prior to rendering a final decision. The Hearing Office still had jurisdiction over the parties and the issues. The District’s reliance on Wyner is misplaced.
A Hearing Officer may issue many orders during the course of a hearing to ensure procedural due process (e.g. evidentiary orders, orders for independent assessments, orders regarding dates of hearing) all of which are clearly enforceable by a Hearing Officer (e.g. see Cal. Code of Regs.§ 3088). The statute states that “during the pendency of any proceeding…the child shall remain in the then-current educational placement…” 20 U.S.C. § 1415(j). Hearing Officers are routinely called upon to issue stay put orders at the commencement of a hearing. To hold that the Hearing Officer could not then enforce that order when the District fails to comply would deny the student an important component of the procedural due process guaranteed by § 1415.
Additionally, the District cites Porter v. Manhattan Beach Unified School District (CD Cal. 2000) 123 F. Supp. 2d 1187 as authority that Petitioner’s avenue for relief was with the compliance office of the California Department of Education. However, this case was overturned on October 8, 2002, by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. Porter v. Board of Trustees of Manhattan Beach Unified School District et al., D.C. No. CV-00-08402 held that the parents were not required to exhaust California’s complaint resolution procedure in order to enforce compliance of a SEHO decision that had not been appealed.
The Hearing Officer concludes that when stay put disputes arise during the pendency of a due process hearing and prior to the rendering of a final decision, the Hearing Officer has jurisdiction not just to make stay put orders but also to determine whether the orders have been violated and to order remedies for such violations. As will be discussed later, in this case the violations of the orders also resulted in a denial of FAPE. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will address the stay put violations.
STUDENT filed for due process on February 5, 2001. Therefore, his stay put placement began on February 5, 2001, despite the fact that the order was issued on February 26, 2001. The District was ordered to provide STUDENT placement and services “in conformity” with the educational services that he had received through his IFSP during the pendency of the due process proceedings, unless the parties agreed otherwise. That placement included: (1) 18 hours per month of typical preschool; (2) 10 hours per week of a one-on-one shadow aide in the typical preschool by a qualified aide; (3) 21.5 hours per week of direct individual intensive early autism treatment in the home by a qualified behavior therapist with six hours per month of supervision;(Footnote 12) (4) 2 hours per week of speech therapy; (5) 2 hours per week of occupational therapy; (6) 2 hours per week of music therapy by a qualified music therapist; and (7) one way transportation, three days per week.
On May 8, 2001, the District held a stay put IEP meeting to provide service in accordance with the stay put order issued on February 26, 2002. All services were to begin on March 8, 2001. The program offer was (1) 18 half days per month at a typical preschool provided by either the LEA or a nonpublic school (NPS); (2) 10 hours per week of an intensive behavior intervention (IBI)/ applied behavior analysis (ABA) aide to be provided by the LEA at the vendored preschool to be provided by the District; (3) 21.5 hours per week of IBI/ABA direct services in the home to be provided by either the LEA or an NPA; (4) 6 hours per month of IBI/ABA supervision; (5) 2 hours per week of individual speech and language therapy in the Sunrise room to be provided by either the LEA or an NPA; (6) 2 hours per week of individual occupational therapy at the Sunrise clinic to be provided by either the LEA or an NPA; (7) 2 hours per week of individual music therapy to be provided by either the LEA or Music Wonders; and (8) transportation, one-way, three days per week to the vendored preschool.
On July 16, 2001, the Petitioner requested clarification of the stay put order because he was not receiving his speech and language services and was concerned about his services ending on July 20, 2001, rather than continuing year-round. On July 25, 2001, the Hearing Office issued an order clarifying the stay put order. That order required that: (1) speech therapy shall be provided in the home, twice a week for one hour each session; (2) the District shall provide occupational therapy at a District site by a District employee or through an NPA; (3) in providing both the in home speech therapy, and the occupational therapy, the District must make a good faith effort to schedule these services so that they do not conflict with Petitioner’s pre-school program; (4) Petitioner’s parents shall also make good faith efforts to accommodate the District’s scheduling efforts; and (5) both parties shall submit documents; supported by sworn affidavits, setting forth the frequency and duration of the services provided to Petitioner during the summer of 2000.
After documents and sworn affidavits were received, the Hearing Office ordered on August 1, 2001, that all services set forth in the stay put orders dated July 25, 2001, and February 26, 2001, were to be provided continuously throughout the summer. Further, the District was ordered to not stop providing those services while school was not in session.
Petitioner contested the entirety of the stay put placement offer because it was not in compliance with the Hearing Office’s orders. The Hearing Officer will address each component of the stay put order.
(1) 18 hours per month of typical preschool
On May 8, 2001, the District’s first preschool offer was Discovery World, but Town and Country was also discussed as a possible placement. MOTHER had previously visited Discovery World, as had Ms. Mulligan, the caseworker from HRC, and both felt that it could not adequately meet STUDENT’s needs. Their impression of the program was that it was not structured and that it was more like day care than a typical preschool. STUDENT’s parents also visited Town and Country and felt that it was appropriate. According to the District, there was no room at Town and Country. No other typical preschool was offered to the parents.(Footnote 13)
Because the parents rejected the District’s offer, HRC agreed to continue funding Community Baptist preschool until September 2002, when STUDENT started at Town and Country preschool. Just because the parents did not like the offered program does not indicate that the District failed to offer a program in compliance with the stay put order of February 26, 2001. No evidence was presented that Discovery World was a “day care” program and not a “typical” preschool. Although the District did not offer any program other than Discovery World, the Hearing Officer finds that the District complied with the stay put order to offer a typical preschool. In addition, even assuming that Discovery World was not a “typical” preschool, STUDENT was not prejudiced because HRC continued to pay for STUDENT’s preschool program at Community Baptist preschool.
(2) 10 hours per week of an intensive behavior intervention (IBI)/ applied behavior analysis (ABA) aide to be provided by the LEA at the vendored preschool to be provided by the District.
Under the IFSP, HRC contracted with California Psychcare (CP) to provide the IBI shadow aide to STUDENT at his typical preschool. On May 8, 2001, the District offered STUDENT an aide at Discovery World. However, the parents rejected the placement at Discovery World, and the District did not offer an aide at Community Baptist preschool because the aide was contingent on the acceptance of the Discovery World preschool. (Testimony of Father) The IBI/ABA is necessary for STUDENT to function in a typical preschool. He needs support and prompting (both verbal and physical) from a shadow aide who has specialized training in IBI/ABA. The stay put order did not state that the aide is contingent on the acceptance of a preschool program offered by the District. The stay put order specifically described the requirement of an aide as a separate and distinct requirement.
Following the May 8, 2001 stay put IEP meeting, the parents informed HRC that the District would not provide an aide at the preschool, so HRC agreed to continue funding the aide at Community Baptist. HRC funded the CP aide through July 2001, when CP cancelled its contract with HRC. HRC then contracted with CARD to provide a one-on-one aide. HRC has continuously funded CARD to the present.
No evidence was presented that the District ever offered a one-on-one aide following the May 8, 2001 stay put IEP meeting. The Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to comply with the stay put order, but determines that STUDENT was not prejudiced because HRC continued to fund a one-on-one aide.
(3) 21.5 hours per week of IBI/ABA direct services in the home to be provided by either the LEA or an NPA, and 6 hours per month of IBI/ABA supervision(Footnote 14)
Under the February 26, 2001 stay put order, the District was to provide 21.5 hours a week in-home IBI/ABA services. The District did not contract with WWA until sometime in mid-April and then abruptly cut off the services when the parents requested to take the stay put IEP home in order to consult with their attorney. Thereafter, the District representative claimed that services could not be provided without a signed IEP, yet the District had already begun providing services prior to the stay put IEP meeting. In a letter dated March 8, 2001, the District made it clear that it was prepared to immediately begin providing OT and SP/L during the offered times. Further, the District contracted with WWA sometime in April, prior to the May 8, 2001 IEP meeting, and service began on or about May 1, 2001.
Despite the District’s contention that the parents only wanted IBI/ABA services from CARD, STUDENT’s parents readily accepted WWA. However, because WWA no longer had space available, the District contracted with CP, and the parents accepted CP, for IBI/ABA services.(Footnote 15) The parents also made requests that were rejected by the District of many different IBI/ABA providers such as Lovass, Autism Partnership, and Working with Autism. The Hearing Officer can only conclude that the issue was not the parent’s stubbornness, but the District’s failure to offer any provider other than CP.
The District authorized services with CP only through the 2000-2001 school year which did not include times when school was not in session (August). Therefore, the parents did not want a lapse in STUDENT’s IBI/ABA services and began utilizing CARD. Within four months, STUDENT was on his third IBA/ABA provider which defeated the purpose behind stay put–to maintain the status quo during the resolution of the due process hearing.
STUDENT began receiving service from CARD both in home and at school on August 1, 2001. When the District recontacted the parents in early September 2001, the parents declined the CP services and continued with CARD. Although the District asserts that CARD became a unilateral placement and that the District is not responsible for repayment of services, the Hearing Officer concludes otherwise. The District failed to provide services in accordance with the August 1, 2001 stay put order. The District witnesses each testified that they were on vacation in August so they did not know of the order until September. However, Ms. Feldman, the interim director (after Dr. Mary Ann Clark left the District on June 30, 2001) worked during the month of August, and the fact that the majority of the District employees were on vacation is no defense to a failure to follow the stay put order. Ms. Busia also testified that the stay put order was “misplaced” during the August holiday; however, the District was represented by attorneys who also received the stay put order. Further, the purpose behind stay put is consistency, and the District failed to provide consistency. Since CARD was also providing the one-on-one aide in the classroom, CARD was clearly the obvious choice of an IBI/ABA provider.
The Hearing Officer again notes that the District did not begin providing service to STUDENT until May 2001. However, HRC provided the IBI/ABA services to STUDENT up until May 2001, when the District contracted with WWA and STUDENT was therefore not prejudiced. The Hearing Officer finds that the District only provided services for approximately ten days in May and for the months of June and July 2001, and otherwise, failed to comply with the stay put orders. The Hearing Officer notes that although the District did offer CP in September 2001, the District had already failed to comply with the stay put order and that using CP again, would have required another change and interruption of the consistency in programming that STUDENT needed. In summary, the District failed to comply with the stay put orders issued by the Hearing Office.
(4) 2 hours per week of individual speech and language therapy to be provided by either the LEA or an NPA in the home; and (5) 2 hours per week of individual occupational therapy to be provided by either the LEA or an NPA(Footnote 16)
The District was ordered to provide SP/L and OT services through the stay put order of February 26, 2001. On May 16, 2001, the parents agreed to have the District provide the OT and SP/L service to STUDENT and informed HRC that it was no longer responsible for providing STUDENT SP/L and OT services. Despite the parents’ acceptance of services from the District, the District failed to offer services at times that STUDENT would be available, so on July 1, 2001, Petitioner filed a request for clarification of the stay put order. On July 25, 2001, the Hearing Office issued a stay put clarification order stating that the SP/L was to be in home and OT was to be clinic-based and provided by either the LEA or an NPA. Further, the District was to make a good faith effort to schedule these services so that they did not conflict with STUDENT’s preschool program, and the parents were also ordered to make good a faith effort to accommodate the District’s scheduling efforts. Despite the orders, the District never actually provided SP/L or OT services to STUDENT.
STUDENT had been receiving OT and SP/L services through his IFSP either before 9:00 a.m. or after 4:00 p.m. because he went to school from 9:00 a.m. to 12:00 p.m. and had DTT services from 1:00 p.m. to 4-4:30 p.m. daily. When the District first contacted the parents on March 8, 2001, via letter, with possible times of OT and SP/L services, the initial times offered were during STUDENT’s typical preschool or DTT hours. The District stated that it made several attempts to accommodate STUDENT’s schedule but continued to offer services only between 9:00 a.m. and 3:00 p.m. Although the District made several attempts at finding times when the District employees could provide services to STUDENT, at no time did the District ever offer STUDENT service before 9:00 a.m. or after 3:00 p.m. Nor did the District ever consider using an NPA in order to comply with the stay put order and offer services outside of the regular school hours. Both the OT and SP/L specialists from the District testified that an NPA was not necessary because they could meet STUDENT’s needs; however, the District failed to recognize that STUDENT needed services at times other than those offered. The District argued that the parents were inflexible and refused to move STUDENT’s IBI/ABA services in order for STUDENT to either go to the clinic-based OT or have the in-home SP/L services. However, the District failed to take into consideration the scheduling conflicts within the family’s household. MOTHER had carefully orchestrated STUDENT and his brother’s special education services so that CARD would provide both boys with services at the same time. Although the Parents did not provide both SP/L and OT consistently (due to financial considerations), STUDENT went to his OT before school and had his SP/L therapy following his IBI/ABA services at home. Yet, at no time was the District willing to offer STUDENT services at anytime prior to 9:00 a.m. or after 3:00 p.m. The parents continued to utilize the OT and SP/L providers that had previously been serving STUDENT through his IFSP. Because of the prohibitive cost, the parents could not afford consistent OT and SP/L services.
The Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to comply with the stay put orders of February 26, 2001, and July 25, 2001. No persuasive evidence was submitted to explain why the District refused to provide STUDENT OT and SP/L services during times that would work with STUDENT’s busy schedule. The District repeatedly asserted that MOTHER was inflexible; however, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to consider an NPA or consider STUDENT or his family’s schedule. The District refused to offer an NPA in accordance with the stay put order, and refused to offer services outside of the regular school hours. Further, unlike the situation above in which HRC continued to pay for the IBI/ABA aide, the parents were forced to incur all expenses associated with SP/L and OT.
(6) 2 hours per week of individual music therapy to be provided by either the LEA or Music Wonders
STUDENT began receiving music therapy in accordance with his IFSP in approximately September 2000 through HRC. On May 8, 2001, the District agreed to continue music therapy with Music Wonders. However, the District did not begin paying for Music Wonders until September 30, 2001. The Hearing Officer understands that the District has continuously paid for Music Wonders throughout the resolution of the due process hearing with the exception of time that school was not in session. Despite the District’s lack of compliance until September 30, 2001, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was not prejudiced because HRC continued to provide services until the District took over the contract. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District only complied with the stay put order from September 30, 2001, and prior to that, the District was out of compliance.
(7) Transportation, one way, three days per week to vendored preschool
On May 8, 2001, the District agreed to provide transportation three days per week to the vendored preschool. The District only began providing this service on September 30, 2001, through the resolution of this matter. No evidence was submitted that the District ever offered transportation prior to September 30, 2001. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District only complied with the stay put order from September 30, 2001, and that prior to that, the District was out of compliance.
4. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for the out of pocket money they spent in obtaining the services spelled out in the stay put orders?
Petitioner requested reimbursement for out-of-pocket expenses and compensatory services for violations of the stay put orders. The Hearing Officer has found that there were violations of the stay put orders in that the District failed to provide the one-on-one aide, the IBI/ABA in-home services, and the SP/L and OT services. The Hearing Officer also found each of these services to be essential components of FAPE that the District failed to offer in the December 2000 and January 2002 IEPs. Therefore, reimbursement and compensatory education can be awarded on two separate grounds (for violations of stay put and failure to offer FAPE in 2000 and 2002), each of which supports the remedy.(Footnote 17)
Because the District failed to provide a FAPE to STUDENT from December 4, 2000, until the present, the parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the cost of services that they provided under the stay put order if it is determined that STUDENT’s placement is appropriate under IDEA. In addition, equitable considerations may be considered in granting relief. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359; Student W. v. Puyullup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496.) To be appropriate, the services provided by a parent must be designed to meet the student’s unique needs and to provide the student with educational benefit. (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200.) However, parents are not required to provide the “perfect” placement for their children when the school district failed to provide a FAPE. (Alamo Heights Independent School District v. Texas Board of Education (5th Cir. 1986) 790 F.2d 1153, 1161.) For purposes of reimbursement, the placement provided by the parent also need not meet every requirement to be appropriate. For example, the placement need not be state-certified as a nonpublic school. (Florence County School District Four v. Carter (1993) 510 U.S. 7, 14.)
Petitioner contends that he is entitled to reimbursement for the cost of CARD, speech and language and occupational therapy that the Parents independently obtained for STUDENT. Further, Petitioner asserts that CARD was an appropriate IBI/ABA provider that conferred STUDENT educational benefit. Petitioner also contends that both the OT and SP/L providers were appropriate and were designed to meet his unique needs and provide him with educational benefit.
The District asserts that STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for services because the District offered the services but the parents refused to accept the District’s offer. However, the Hearing Officer found that the only offer refused by the parents was Discovery World.
Although it is unusual for a Hearing Officer to rule on reimbursement for failure to comply with stay put, the Hearing Officer has actually determined that the stay put was the appropriate program for STUDENT. Because the District failed to comply with the stay put order, the Hearing Officer must determine if the services obtained by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. Extensive evidence was presented on CARD, the program that the parents obtained for STUDENT. Ms. Rosamel Casado, STUDENT’s case supervisor explained the program and each of the goals and objectives for STUDENT. She explained that STUDENT made much progress. Further, the behaviorist and speech and language pathologist from the District both testified that the goals and objectives were appropriate with the exception of a few extraneous goals. In regards to the OT and SP/L services, there was no dispute about the appropriateness of the services that the speech and language pathologist and the occupational therapist provided to STUDENT.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer agrees that the Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement and finds that the Parents are entitled to all out-of-pocket costs that were spent to provide STUDENT educational services. According to the closing brief as of October 7, 2002, the Parents have spent $31,770.50 for CARD, $4,400 for speech and language therapy, and $1,467 for occupational therapy.
5. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the services that the District failed to offer under stay put?
Compensatory education is an equitable remedy to compensate a student for lost educational opportunity when the District has failed to provide the student with appropriate special education services. (20 U.S.C. § 1415(i)(2)(B)(iii); 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(1).) The Ninth Circuit has held that compensatory education does not require that the student be compensated by providing a day for day replacement for each educational day lost. “Compensatory education is not a contractual remedy but an equitable remedy, part of the Court’s resources in crafting appropriate relief...designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” (Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1496, 1497.)
Petitioner asserts that he should be compensated for the missed hours of SP/L (84 one-hour sessions of one-on-one home therapy), OT (104 one-hour sessions of clinic-based OT), IBI/ABA services (93 hours of individual therapy, plus 6 hours of supervision), and music therapy (12 sessions between July 20 and September 3, 2001 and 12 sessions between July 20 and September 3, 2002). Petitioner believes that these hours should be banked over the next three years and that the focus should be on social and communication issues with peers.
The District asserts that STUDENT is not entitled to any compensatory education because all programs and services were offered to STUDENT and his parents unilaterally rejected those services. Again, the Hearing Officer previously found that the only offer refused by the parents was Discovery World.
When asked of Dr. Freeman how she would suggest the loss of OT, SP/L, and ABA/IBI be made up to STUDENT, she suggested that the make-up services should not overtax STUDENT. Dr. Freeman testified that the hours should be “banked” for STUDENT to use down the road because STUDENT is young and will need work on his language and social development during his primary grades. Dr. Freeman explained that there are creative ways to use the compensatory services, such as programs for STUDENT when he is in third and fourth grade to help him realize that he is an autistic child. Dr. Freeman also suggested that the services need to be focused on STUDENT’s social skills, such as gym classes or play groups, and that these groups need to be outside of the regular school hours. Dr. Freeman also explained that the programs need to be focused on the quality of the services rather than the quantity. No witness on behalf of the District testified on how compensatory education should be delivered because the District adamantly believed that it provided appropriate services for STUDENT.
The Petitioner contends that he needed music therapy as part of his program. However no evidence was presented that music therapy was necessary to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. MOTHER explained that STUDENT had auditory sensitivities and that the OT could not address those sensitivities. MOTHER contacted the American Music Association and found out that music therapy may be helpful to STUDENT. Music therapy was then made part of STUDENT’s IFSP. According to the music therapist, Gretchen Axton, the therapy helped STUDENT with pretend play, sharing and communication. She worked with STUDENT on drums to help him tolerate different levels of noise. However, Dr. BJ Freeman testified that she did not believe music therapy was necessary for STUDENT’s development and compared music therapy to a music lesson.
Although the District offered music therapy, it did not believe that STUDENT needed individual music therapy. There was no indication from the comprehensive assessments that STUDENT had auditory sensitivity that required individual music therapy. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer does not find that STUDENT should receive compensatory education for the missed hours of music therapy.
Therefore, based on the suggestions from the Petitioner’s expert, the Hearing Officer concludes that the Petitioner is entitled to compensatory education for IBI/ABA services, OT, and SP/L. The Hearing Officer agrees with Dr. BJ Freeman on the distribution of the services. The District shall provide STUDENT with no more than 280 hours of services over the next three years specifically in the areas of social and communication skills and allocated towards play and social groups. Dr. Freeman suggested that STUDENT may have difficulty in third or fourth grade and that these hours could help, but if he is doing well, then the service may not be necessary. The compensatory education must be separate from the offer of FAPE, and occur outside of the regular school hours and STUDENT is not to be overtaxed with services.
ORDERS
1. Within twenty calendar days of receipt of proof from the parents, the Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District shall reimburse the parents for expenses related to CARD from August 1, 2001 through the date of this Decision.
2. Within twenty calendar days of receipt of proof from the parents, the Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District shall reimburse the parents for expenses related to occupational therapy at Pediatric Therapy Network from May 8, 2001, through the date of this Decision.
3. Within twenty calendar days of receipt of proof from the parents, the Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District shall reimburse the parents for expenses related to speech and language therapy with Mary Ann Gordon O’Brien.
4. Within thirty calendar days, the Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District shall convene an individualized education program (IEP) meeting to develop and offer STUDENT an appropriate IEP consistent with this Decision.(Footnote 18) In addition to developing the IEP, the District shall discuss and offer compensatory education services. The District’s offer of an IEP and compensatory education shall be in compliance with the following:
a. The IEP shall offer a program for STUDENT that includes a typical language-based preschool with the assistance of a trained shadow aide.
b. The District shall provide STUDENT with a transition program of IBI/ABA in-home services for at least six months. The transition program shall be designed, per Dr. Siegel’s suggestion, so that the in home IBI/ABA services gradually decline, and the IBI/ABA services are transitioned into the regular classroom environment.
c. The District shall provide STUDENT with some individual and some group-based occupational therapy and speech and language therapy. The group-based therapy may be implemented in the classroom. The individual therapy must be offered outside of regular classroom hours.
d. The District shall develop and offer STUDENT a program a maximum of 93 hours a year for the next three years of social and communication-based programming, either individual or group-based, outside of regular classroom hours. This programming shall be provided in a manner that does not cause STUDENT to lose any time from school and shall be completed no later than November 1, 2005, unless the parents agree otherwise. The District shall also offer to provide, at no cost to the parents, any necessary transportation to and from the sessions.
5. The Petitioner’s remaining claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507 (d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with the statute:
1. Did the District offer STUDENT a Free Appropriate Public Education (FAPE) at the December 4, 2000 IEP meeting?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
2. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE at the January 9, 2002 IEP meeting?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
3. Did the District comply with the stay put orders issued by the Hearing Office on February 26, 2001, July 25, 2001 and August 1, 2001?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
4. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for the out of pocket money they spent in obtaining the services spelled out in the stay put orders?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
5. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the services that the District failed to offer under stay put?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Education Code § 56505 (i).
Date: November 7, 2002 ______________________________________Jessica Katz, Hearing OfficerCalifornia Special Education Hearing Office
1. Although the IFSP specified 21.5 hours a week, California Psychcare only provided 18-19 hours a week of DTT services.
2. Ms. Milburn did not disclose her employer at the time of the IEP meeting.
3. Stay put IEP” was described as a meeting to develop a program for Student that was in conformity with the stay put orders. 4. IBI/ABA services are frequently synonymous with DTT, and for the purposes of this Decision, the acronyms will be used interchangeably unless otherwise stated. 5. The District contract for the 2000-2001 school year with California Pyschcare ended on July 20, 2001 because it did not include school holidays or breaks. 6. The parents testified that both CARD and CP charge $50 per hour for in-home services. 7. Although Student was found eligible under the category of speech and language, several District witnesses testified that Student was on the autistic spectrum, but that his greatest area of need was in speech and language.
8. A “shadow aide” also known of as a “one-on-one” aide was described by both Robin Shipley, the District’s behaviorist and Rosamel Casado, STUDENT’s case manager from CARD, as a someone who is specially trained to implement IBI/ABA services within the classroom environment through appropriate verbal and physical prompts.
9. Although the Sunrise SDC was described as full included, a fully included classroom is generally a classroom with more typical peers then special education students. Further, Dr. Stephanny Freeman testified that she evaluated thirteen schools within four districts, and stated that although she liked the Sunrise program, she did not believe that it was a fully included program, rather a special education program with some typical peers.
10. Sunrise preschool is a center-based preschool where each lesson plan is taught in a different center, e.g. a kitchen center, a dress-up center, a library area. 11. Sunrise program consists of four classrooms. The program had full-time OT’s, SP/L pathologists and APE teachers whose time was divided between the four classrooms. 12. The IBI/ABA aide should be trained in the same techniques as the IBI/ABA home-based program utilizes. 13. Sunrise SDC was again offered as a placement; however, this was not a typical preschool in conformity with the stay put order. 14. The Hearing Officer will address both services and the 6 hours of supervision as one issue and refer to both as “services.” 15. The District did not want to contract with CP because at the May 8, 2001 stay put IEP meeting, Mary Ann Clark said that she did not have good experiences with CP and did not want to utilize CP as a service provider for STUDENT. Further she stated, “that Dr. Sadeghi, the director of CP, tends to promote increasing hours even if it is not best for the child and her feeling was that he (Dr. Sadeghi) was inappropriate” 16. The Hearing Officer will address both OT and SP/L together because they were similarly discussed by the parties.
17. It should be noted that in this case, had the District properly implemented the stay put orders, the failure to offer these as FAPE in the two separate IEPs at issue would have alleviated the need for reimbursement and compensatory remedies. 18. Pursuant to Case number SN02-01487, the parties shall begin the assessments on or after November 1, 2002. However, these assessments are to be utilized for the annual IEP meeting that should occur around January 2003.
