California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 6, 2004

Student v. Burlingame Elementary School District et al.

SEHO Case No. SN 2353-03, SN-2353-03 · Hearing Officer Suzanne B. Brown

Burlingame Elementary and San Mateo County Office of Education owe 25 compensatory hours for LRE failures; Mexico residential reimbursement denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 6 of 19 issues (3 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. The decision mentions an earlier case, SN01-00278, which was dismissed for lack of activity on March 1, 2002. The Hearing Officer denied the District's motion to bar pre-March 2002 issues on that basis.

Summary

A parent filed against Burlingame Elementary School District and the San Mateo County Office of Education for a 14-year-old eighth grader eligible as emotionally disturbed. In February 2002, after repeated suspensions, the IEP team moved him from his neighborhood middle school to a county special day class (SDC) at Alta Loma Middle School. The Hearing Officer found that the district made that move without first trying positive behavioral interventions in general education, such as a functional analysis assessment or a behavior support plan. As a result, the SDC was not his least restrictive environment from February 2002 to March 2003. Both agencies also denied FAPE by holding his annual IEP meeting about three and one-half months late and by never providing the 15% mainstreaming his IEP required. His behavior worsened in spring 2003, so the SDC was the least restrictive setting from March to November 2003. After his behavior improved, the full-time SDC offer for the rest of 2003-2004 again was not. His claims about speech services, teacher credentials, testing, notice, consent, and a mental health referral failed. Reimbursement for the parent's unilateral placement at Casa-By-The-Sea in Mexico was denied. That placement was more restrictive, did not remedy the violations, and was made without advance notice. The agencies must hold an IEP meeting to consider a Children's Health Council evaluation, add 25 hours of compensatory education, and use behavioral interventions to gradually add mainstreaming.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied the Holland test when a district moved a student with disruptive behavior to an SDC without first trying positive behavioral supports. It also treats mainstreaming written into a signed IEP as binding. Finally, it shows that reimbursement for a more restrictive private placement was denied where the violations involved too little mainstreaming.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1. Did the District deny FAPE in the LRE by placing Petitioner in a COE SDC in February 2002 without first attempting to accommodate him in his general education placement at his home school?

    Applying Holland, the District moved the student to a full-time SDC without first trying an FAA, behavior support plan or other positive behavioral interventions, so it failed to accommodate him in the LRE.

  2. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 2a. Failing to hold an IEP meeting for approximately sixteen months, from February 2002 to June 2003.

    The annual IEP meeting was about three and one-half months late; this seriously infringed on parent participation and denied FAPE, though it caused no lost educational opportunity.

  3. Student prevailedImplementation

    Issue 2b. Failing to provide mainstreaming in conformity with the IEP dated February 21, 2002.

    The IEP called for 15% mainstreaming, but the student received none and the parent never consented in writing to remove it; this was a substantive denial of FAPE.

  4. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue 2c. Failing to provide speech-language services to address Petitioner's speech-language deficits identified in the IEP dated February 21, 2002.

    The COE speech-language specialist provided the services beginning in February 2002; no denial of FAPE.

  5. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2d. Failing to provide a properly credentialed teacher in the COE SDC.

    The SDC teacher's learning handicapped credential, together with her experience and coursework, authorized her under 5 C.C.R. § 80047.2 to teach an SDC for students with emotional disturbance.

  6. Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2e. Failing to address Petitioner's behavioral and speech-language needs in the COE SDC placement and failing to place Petitioner in a class with an appropriate peer group in the LRE.

    The SDC met the student's behavior and speech needs and had an appropriate peer group, but it was not the LRE from February 2002 to March 2003. It was the LRE from March to June 2003.

  7. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 2f. Failing to properly assess Petitioner, specifically concerning the Woodcock-Johnson testing administered in May 2003.

    There was no evidence the testing was inaccurate; three high subtest scores out of nearly thirty were explained and fit with earlier testing.

  8. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 3a. Failing to provide prior written notice of the refusal of the parent's request to change Petitioner's placement.

    Crediting staff testimony, the Hearing Officer found the parent never clearly asked for a change of placement on June 30 or July 15, 2003, so no notice was required.

  9. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 3b. Refusing to allow the parent to retract her consent to the June 30, 2003 IEP.

    The parent did not clearly convey that she was withdrawing consent; staff reasonably understood her to want changes to the IEP document. No procedural violation.

  10. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 3c. Failing to convene an IEP meeting in July 2003 despite the parent's request for an IEP meeting.

    Education Code § 56343.5's 30-day timeline excludes July and August, so no meeting was required in July or August 2003.

  11. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 3d. Failing to provide the parent with a copy of the June 30, 2003 IEP document.

    The parent initialed that she received a copy at the June 30, 2003 meeting, and staff credibly testified that she did; no violation.

  12. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 3e. Failing to include Petitioner's speech-language pathologist at the June 2003 IEP meetings.

    The speech-language pathologist presented at the June 4 meeting; her attendance at the June 30 continuation was not required under Education Code § 56341(b).

  13. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue 3f. Failing to refer Petitioner for Chapter 26.5 mental health services in conformity with the June 30, 2003 IEP.

    The school psychologist made the referral within days. The parent did not promptly return the county forms. No violation.

  14. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 4a. For August to November 2003, failing to allow parental participation in the IEP process.

    The parent participated extensively in the October and November 2003 IEP meetings. Offering a placement other than the one she preferred was not a procedural violation.

  15. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 4b. For August to November 2003, continuing to offer to place him in the COE SDC, which failed to address his unique needs and was not in the LRE.

    Because the student's out-of-control behavior had escalated, the SDC offer met his needs and was the LRE for this period.

  16. Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE

    Issue 5. Did Respondents fail to offer a FAPE beginning in November 2003 and for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year by continuing to offer placement in the COE SDC, which fails to address his unique needs and is not the LRE?

    The SDC was otherwise appropriate. But his disruptive behaviors had subsided and no behavioral interventions had been tried to expand mainstreaming, so the SDC was not his LRE.

  17. Issue 6a. Should Respondents reimburse Petitioner for placement at Casa By The Sea and related expenses including transportation?

    Reimbursement was denied. The residential placement was more restrictive, did not replace the missing mainstreaming or fix the late IEP, and the parent gave no advance notice.

  18. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 6b. Should the Hearing Officer order a comprehensive special education assessment in all areas to determine an appropriate placement?

    No assessment was ordered. There was no evidence of inaccurate assessment, and the triennial was already scheduled for March 2004.

  19. Student prevailed in partIEP procedure

    Issue 6c. Should the Hearing Officer order an IEP team meeting to consider the results of the Children's Health Council (CHC) assessment and determine a new, appropriate placement?

    The Hearing Officer ordered an IEP meeting to consider the CHC report, plus 25 hours of compensatory education and a gradual increase in mainstreaming. A new placement was not ordered.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 7 days of the decision, Respondents must schedule an IEP team meeting and send written notice to all participants. The meeting must convene within 20 days of the decision, and the team must consider the Children's Health Council evaluation report.
  • Compensatory education. At that IEP meeting, the team must add 25 hours of compensatory education designed to address the student's behavioral needs, maximize his mainstreaming opportunities, and assist his transition to high school. The hours may include consultation by a behavior analyst or school psychologist. They should be delivered while he remains a District student, including ESY; if not finished by the end of the school year, they may be completed in 2004-2005.
  • Order to provide or change services. The IEP team must use behavioral interventions to gradually add another mainstreaming opportunity, such as another class period in addition to lunch, during the current school year. This is to be developed together with the compensatory behavioral services. Respondents may keep the student in the COE SDC at Alta Loma.

Total: 25 hours of compensatory services

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Holland; Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education; W.G. v. Target Range School Dist.; Burlington School Committee v. Dept. of Education; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Todd v. Andrews; Moubry v. Independent School Dist. No. 696

People named in the decision

  • Janice Robbins, District director of special education and pupil services, Burlingame Elementary School District
  • Princess Tucker-Jones, COE educational services manager, San Mateo County Office of Education
  • Lori Solgaard, special day class teacher, San Mateo County Office of Education (Alta Loma Middle School)
  • Robin L. Kim, school psychologist, San Mateo County Office of Education
  • Carol Martin, speech and language specialist, San Mateo County Office of Education
  • Kenneth Slaugh, licensed social worker; witness for Student, Casa-By-The-Sea (apparent)
  • Michael Chism, witness for Student regarding residential program, Casa-By-The-Sea (apparent)
  • Children's Health Council (CHC), independent evaluator (District-funded 2001 evaluation), private clinic
  • Casa-By-The-Sea, private residential school (unilateral placement), Ensenada, Mexico
  • Susan Foley, advocate for Student

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter convened for hearing in Burlingame, California, on December 2, 3, 4 and 5, 2003, before Hearing Officer Suzanne B. Brown, California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law. Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented by advocate Susan Foley. Present on Petitioner’s behalf was his mother, MOTHER. Respondent Burlingame Elementary School District (District) was represented by attorney Diane Finkelstein of the law firm of Shupe & Finkelstein. Present on behalf of the District was Janice Robbins, District director of special education. Respondent San Mateo County Office of Education (COE) was represented by attorney Paul Okada, deputy county counsel for San Mateo County. Present on COE’s behalf was Princess Tucker-Jones, COE educational services manager.

Petitioner called the following witnesses: MOTHER, Petitioner’s mother; Kenneth Slaugh, licensed social worker; Lori Solgaard, COE special education teacher; Michael Chism; Robin L. Kim, COE school psychologist; and Janice Robbins, District director of special education and pupil services.

The COE called the following witnesses: Carol Martin, speech and language specialist; and Princess Tucker-Jones, COE educational services manager.

The District examined all of the above witnesses but did not call any additional witnesses.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Thereafter the parties submitted written closing briefs, which were received no later than January 9, 2004. On January 6, 2004, the Hearing Office received from the Respondents a “Joint Request for Administrative Notice.” The Hearing Office received Petitioner’s opposition to Respondents’ request on January 20, 2004, and on that date the matter was closed and submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

At the hearing, the District moved to dismiss any issues arising prior to March 1, 2002, in light of a dismissal order issued by the Hearing Office on that date. The order concerned a prior case, SN01-00278, regarding this student and filed by Petitioner’s mother solely against the District. Case SN01-00278 did not proceed to hearing and, according to the Dismissal Order, was dismissed by the Hearing Office due to lack of activity. (Dist. Exh. 3.) That order did not state whether the dismissal was with prejudice.

After hearing arguments from both the District and Petitioner concerning the District’s dismissal motion, the Hearing Officer denied the motion on the grounds that the March 1, 2002 order did not bar Petitioner from raising issues arising prior to March 1, 2002. The Dismissal Order in SN01-00278 was solely due to lack of activity and did not dismiss issues with prejudice. The Hearing Officer invited the parties to submit any additional evidence indicating dismissal with prejudice, such as an executed settlement agreement in SN01-00278, but none of the parties submitted any such document or argued that such a document exists.

Additionally, on January 6, 2004, the Hearing Office received from Respondents a “Joint Request for Administrative Notice.” In this request, Respondents asked the Hearing Office to take “administrative notice” of court documents filed in a custody dispute between STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, and STUDENT’s father, FATHER. The documents Respondents presented were a sworn declaration from STUDENT’s maternal grandparents and an Order After Hearing ordering MOTHER to return STUDENT to the San Francisco Bay Area on or before November 10, 2003. Respondents argued that these documents are relevant to impeach MOTHER’s credibility regarding sworn testimony she gave at the hearing regarding whether the family court had ordered her to return STUDENT to California from Mexico.

On January 20, 2004, the Hearing Office received Petitioner’s opposition to Respondents’ request. Petitioner argued that Respondents’ delay in making this request was prejudicial and warranted denial of the request. Petitioner further argued that the documents for which Respondents seek administrative notice are irrelevant to the issues in this case. Additionally, Petitioner argued that the sworn declaration of STUDENT’s grandparents should not be considered because there was no opportunity to cross-examine the grandparents. In the alternative, Petitioner requested that, should Respondents’ request be granted, that additional documents concerning the custody dispute also be considered.

Official notice may be taken, either before or after submission of the case for decision, of “any fact which may be judicially noticed by the courts of this State.” (Cal. Government Code § 11515.) Parties present at the hearing shall be informed of the matters to be noticed, and those matters shall be noted in the record, referred to therein, or appended thereto. Any such party shall be given a reasonable opportunity on request to refute the officially noticed matters by evidence or by written or oral presentation of authority, the matter of such refutation to be determined by the agency. (Ibid.) Regarding facts which may be judicially noticed by the courts, California Evidence Code section 452(d) provides that judicial notice may be taken of records of any court of this state.

In the present case, MOTHER testified regarding family court custody matters regarding STUDENT. In her testimony, she offered several assertions, including that STUDENT’s return from Mexico was not pursuant to a family court order. In response, Respondents request that the Hearing Officer take judicial notice of the court documents filed in San Mateo County Family Court regarding STUDENT’s stay in Mexico, including the Family Court’s order to return STUDENT to the San Francisco Bay Area no later than November 5, 2003.

The Hearing Officer finds that these documents have some relevance to MOTHER’s credibility. Prior to MOTHER’s testimony, Respondents could not have reasonably known that the family court documents would be relevant to this special education due process proceeding. In light of these circumstances, the Hearing Officer will take official notice of all of the family court documents submitted by Petitioner and Respondents in the post-hearing motion. Such notice constitutes only notice that the documents exist and were filed in a State court; the Hearing Officer’s official notice does not assume the truth of the facts asserted within the documents.

ISSUES (Footnote 1)

1. Did the District deny Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE) by placing Petitioner in a COE special day class (SDC) in February 2002 without first attempting to accommodate him in his general education placement at his home school?

2. For the period from February 2002 through June 2003, did the District and COE (collectively, Respondents) deny Petitioner a FAPE as follows:

(a) failing to hold an individualized education program (IEP) meeting for approximately sixteen months, for the period from February 2002 to June 2003;

(b) failing to provide mainstreaming in conformity with the IEP dated February 21, 2002;

(c) failing to provide speech-language services to address Petitioner’s speech-language deficits identified in the IEP dated February 21, 2002;

(d) failing to provide a properly credentialed teacher in the COE SDC;

(e) failing to address Petitioner’s behavioral and speech-language needs in the COE SDC placement and failing to place Petitioner in a class with an appropriate peer group in the LRE; and (f) failing to properly assess Petitioner, specifically concerning the Woodcock-Johnson testing administered in May 2003?

3. Did Respondents deny Petitioner a FAPE in June and July 2003, as follows:

(a) failing to provide prior written notice of the refusal of the parent’s request to change Petitioner’s placement;

(b) refusing to allow the parent to retract her consent to the June 30, 2003 IEP;

(c) failing to convene an IEP meeting in July 2003 despite the parent’s request for an IEP meeting;

(d) failing to provide the parent with a copy of the June 30, 2003 IEP document;

(e) failing to include Petitioner’s speech-language pathologist at the June 2003 IEP meetings; and (f) failing to refer Petitioner for Chapter 26.5 mental health services in conformity with the June 30, 2003 IEP?

4. Did Respondents deny Petitioner a FAPE for the period from August to November 2003, as follows:

(a) failing to allow parental participation in the IEP process; and (b) continuing to offer to place him in the COE SDC, which failed to address his unique needs and was not in the LRE?

5. Did Respondents fail to offer Petitioner a FAPE beginning in November 2003 and continuing for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year by continuing to offer placement in the COE SDC which fails to address his unique needs and is not the LRE?

6. If Respondents denied Petitioner a FAPE, should the Hearing Officer order the following relief:

(a) reimbursement to Petitioner by Respondents for placement at Casa By The Sea and related expenses including transportation;

(b) a comprehensive special education assessment in all areas to determine an appropriate placement; and (c) an IEP team meeting to consider the results of the Children’s Health Council (CHC) assessment and determine a new, appropriate placement?

BACKGROUND FACTS (Footnote 2)

STUDENT is a fourteen-year-old boy who lives with his mother, MOTHER, and her fiancee within the boundaries of the Burlingame Elementary School District. He has occasional contact with his biological father, FATHER, who has been divorced from STUDENT’s mother since STUDENT was preschool-age. STUDENT is currently in the eighth grade and attends a special day class (SDC) operated by COE at Alta Loma Middle School (Alta Loma), which is located in South San Francisco, California and is outside of the Respondent District. He is currently identified as eligible for special education under the category of emotionally disturbed (ED).

STUDENT attended kindergarten and elementary grades at the District’s McKinley and Washington elementary schools. He was initially determined eligible for special education in kindergarten due to a specific learning disability (SLD), and later also due to a speech-language impairment (SLI). He also received a medical diagnosis of attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) at age six.

STUDENT repeated his kindergarten year and subsequently attended a special day class (SDC) for first and second grades. For third, fourth and fifth grades, he returned to a regular education classroom setting and received special education services including speech-language therapy and resource specialist program (RSP) services, although he remained eligible solely due to SLI and not SLD. (Dist. Exh. 24.)

STUDENT manifested some behavioral problems during elementary school and was often asked to leave sports and other after-school activities, such as the Boy Scouts, due to his aggressive behaviors with other students. (Testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Robbins.) In October 2000, when STUDENT was in fifth grade, a District school psychologist conducted a behavioral assessment and reported that STUDENT had significant difficulties with oppositional behavior, cognitive problems, inattention and hyperactivity. When the individualized education program (IEP) team convened in November 2000 to discuss the behavioral assessment, the team agreed to add behavior goals and objectives to STUDENT’s program. The IEP notes state that MOTHER reported that STUDENT would be having a neurological assessment and had been referred to a psychiatrist. (Footnote 3) (Id.) The IEP notes also indicate that STUDENT would be referred for a mental health assessment pursuant to Chapter 26.5 of the California Government Code. (Dist. Exh. 22.)

In February and March 2001, District staff conducted STUDENT’s triennial assessment. The school psychologist concluded that STUDENT did not qualify as a student with an SLD and the speech-language pathologist found that STUDENT did not qualify as a student with an SLI. When the IEP team convened, the District staff recommended that STUDENT was no longer eligible for special education. MOTHER did not agree to exit STUDENT from special education. In April 2001, MOTHER filed a request for due process hearing and STUDENT remained a special education student pursuant to stay put. (See Dist. Exh. 15.) Also in April 2001, the IEP team convened to discuss the results of STUDENT’s 26.5 mental health assessment. San Mateo County Mental Health had determined that STUDENT was eligible for mental health services. The IEP team agreed to add mental health services to STUDENT’s program for one hour per week for a six-week period, until STUDENT’s next scheduled IEP meeting on June 8, 2001. (Dist. Exh. 15.) Thereafter STUDENT’s mental health services were discontinued at MOTHER’s request. (Testimony of Janice Robbins.)

In summer 2001, the District agreed to fund an independent evaluation of STUDENT by the Children’s Health Council (CHC). The findings contained in CHC’s evaluation report included that STUDENT was a student with low average learning abilities, but that his academic achievement test scores met or exceeded his ability levels. On the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual-IV (DSM-IV) scale, the CHC report’s findings included an Axis I diagnosis of ADHD by history, a deferred diagnosis for Axis II, and a global assessment of functioning (GAF) of 70 due to mild to moderate difficulty in educational environment. (Pet. Exh. Q.)

In June 2001, STUDENT graduated from elementary school. In early September 2001, he began attending sixth grade at the District’s Burlingame Intermediate School (BIS). MOTHER reports that STUDENT had significant difficulty acclimating to the middle school, including frequently getting in fights and being teased. MOTHER reports that she frequently received phone calls from the school about STUDENT’s behavior and sometimes went to the school to help STUDENT access his locker. STUDENT was suspended for an incident in November 2001 and suspended again for another incident in December 2001.

In January 2002, STUDENT was suspended from school for threatening to shoot another student with a BB gun. MOTHER testified that, as a result of this incident, the police searched their home for guns but did not find any, and STUDENT was not arrested. Because the school suspension resulted in STUDENT’s cumulative suspension time reaching ten days, the District’s school psychologist conducted an assessment of STUDENT’s social/emotional functioning and reviewed the appropriateness of his then-current placement. (Dist. Exh. 6.) The school psychologist’s February 2002 report included a discussion of the CHC evaluation report. The school psychologist’s report concluded in part that STUDENT was eligible for special education as a student with emotional disturbance (ED).

On February 7, 2002, the IEP team convened to review the manifestation determination. The team agreed to change STUDENT’s eligibility category to ED, finding that STUDENT had: (1) an inability to learn which cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory or health factors; (2) an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers; and (3) inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations. The team agreed to change STUDENT’s placement to a COE SDC at Alta Loma, and agreed that STUDENT would also receive transportation provided by COE and extended school year (ESY). (Pet. Exh. B.) The IEP notes indicate that STUDENT’s mother had observed the COE SDC and agreed to the new placement. (Footnote 4)

Shortly after STUDENT began attending the COE SDC at Alta Loma, the IEP team convened again to add new goals and objectives. The IEP document, dated February 21, 2002, also added speech-language therapy for thirty minutes per week. (Footnote 5) The document also indicates that STUDENT would be mainstreamed for 15% of his school day. (Pet. Exh. C-2.)

For the rest of his sixth grade year, STUDENT remained in the SDC at Alta Loma. The SDC was comprised of seven boys, ages eleven to fourteen, all of whom were eligible for special education due to ED. (Testimony of Ms. Solgaard.) Alta Loma is a regular education middle school campus, but STUDENT was not mainstreamed for lunch or any other part of his school day. (Testimony of Ms. Solgaard, MOTHER.) In June and July 2002, STUDENT attended the SDC for the ESY.

STUDENT returned to the SDC for the 2002-2003 school year. He continued to receive speech-language therapy and continued to spend 100% of his time in a special education setting without mainstreaming. STUDENT’s behavior problems at home and in the community appeared to increase in or about spring 2003. Reportedly STUDENT’s behaviors during this time period included vandalism and theft, including stealing the emblems off cars in a parking lot. (See testimony of Ms. Solgaard, MOTHER.) MOTHER testified that STUDENT had purchased a realistic-looking toy gun for $60 at a local store and rode his bicycle with the toy gun visibly protruding from his waistband.

STUDENT’s annual IEP was due to convene in February 2003, but it was delayed and did not convene until June 4, 2003. At that IEP meeting, speech-language pathologist Carol Martin discussed her report on STUDENT’s progress and her recommendations for his speech-language goals. (Footnote 6) (Testimony of Carol Martin, Robin Kim, Ms. Solgaard.) Ms. Martin completed her presentation, signed the IEP document and left the meeting. Ms. Kim also signed the IEP on June 4, which is her practice to avoid the risk of forgetting to sign it later. (Testimony of Ms. Kim.) As the meeting continued into the late afternoon, the rest of the IEP team members agreed to reconvene the meeting at a later date. The IEP team subsequently reconvened on June 30, 2003. (Footnote 7) The team members discussed and agreed upon STUDENT’s goals and objectives, and agreed to continue STUDENT’s placement in the COE SDC. The team also agreed to refer STUDENT for a mental health assessment. MOTHER, Ms. Solgaard and STUDENT signed the IEP document. (Exh. COE-4, p. 4; Dist. Exh. 2, p. 4.; testimony of Ms. Kim, Ms. Solgaard.) The document indicated that STUDENT would be mainstreamed for recess and lunch, for a total of 7% of his school day. (Exh. COE-4, p. 2; Dist. Exh. 2, p. 2.)

In June and July 2003, STUDENT again attended ESY at the COE SDC taught by Ms. Solgaard. On July 8, 2003, STUDENT told Ms. Solgaard privately that he had been in a fight with his mother’s boyfriend and was afraid to go home. Ms. Solgaard telephoned Ms. Kim to discuss the situation, including the obligation to report any suspected child abuse to Child Protective Services. At the end of school that day, Ms. Kim arrived and joined STUDENT and Ms. Solgaard in discussing the situation; collectively they agreed that Ms. Kim would drive STUDENT home from school that day and wait with him until his mother arrived home. (Testimony of Ms. Solgaard, Ms. Kim.) Ms. Kim drove STUDENT home from school and waited until MOTHER arrived at the home. Ms. Kim, MOTHER and STUDENT then discussed the situation and agreed upon some solutions. (Testimony of Ms. Kim.)

On or about July 11, 2003, MOTHER telephoned Ms. Solgaard to discuss concerns about STUDENT. MOTHER explained that she believed she needed to intervene and do something about STUDENT’s behavior. MOTHER stated that she might want to include something different in the IEP. Ms. Solgaard told MOTHER that she would schedule an IEP meeting for July 15, 2003, which was during the final week of the ESY. (Footnote 8) Ms. Solgaard then spoke with Ms. Kim and informed her of the IEP meeting scheduled for July 15. On July 14, Ms. Kim learned that a representative from the District would not be available to attend the IEP meeting on July 15. (Testimony of Princess Tucker-Jones, Ms. Kim.)

When MOTHER arrived for the IEP meeting on July 15, Ms. Kim and Ms. Solgaard reported that no District representative was available to attend the meeting that day and explained that a District representative needed to attend the IEP meeting if the team was going to consider changing STUDENT’s placement. Ms. Solgaard and Ms. Kim said that they would need to reschedule the IEP meeting, but stated that they could have a parent conference with MOTHER that day instead. (Testimony of Ms. Solgaard, Ms. Kim.) MOTHER agreed to stay for a parent conference.

During the July 15 conference, MOTHER stated that she wanted to change the box on the IEP form regarding her consent from “yes” to “no.” Ms. Kim informed her that they could only change the IEP document during an IEP meeting. MOTHER also discussed that she was upset because STUDENT’s behavior at home was out of control. MOTHER stated that she was considering an out-of-state placement for STUDENT, but also stated that she had not made a final decision and that STUDENT might return to Ms. Solgaard’s SDC in the fall. (Testimony of Ms. Solgaard, Ms. Kim.) MOTHER indicated that she would investigate potential placements while STUDENT was on a three-week vacation at his aunt’s in Colorado during the summer break. Ms. Solgaard and Ms. Kim informed MOTHER that they believed that STUDENT was appropriately placed in the COE SDC and a change of placement was not warranted. Ms. Kim asked MOTHER if she intended to “seek fiscal responsibility from the District” for an out-of-state placement; MOTHER confirmed that she did. (Testimony of Ms. Kim.)

On or about the following day, July 16, MOTHER telephoned Ms. Kim and again stated that she wanted to change the box on the IEP document regarding parental consent from “yes” to “no.” (Testimony of Ms. Kim.) Ms. Kim again informed MOTHER that she could not change the content of an IEP document outside of an IEP meeting. Ms. Kim told MOTHER to contact Princess Tucker-Jones, educational services manager for COE, to schedule an IEP team meeting. (Id.)

In August 2003, MOTHER drove STUDENT from Burlingame to Ensenada, Mexico, where the residential school Casa-By-The-Sea is located. MOTHER had enrolled STUDENT initially for a three-month period at Casa-By-The-Sea, although she was uncertain whether he would remain there for a longer period up to twelve months. (Testimony of MOTHER; see also testimony of Michael Chism.) Casa-By-The-Sea is a residential school for boys; the school currently has just under 300 students. The students attend academic classes six days per week, with scheduled activities on Sundays; the entire program is designed to emphasize “character-building.” The school has a level-based behavior program, requiring each entering student to begin at Level 1 and earn privileges only by advancing to the higher levels. (Testimony of Mr. Chism.)

In late August, Ms. Solgaard received a telephone call from STUDENT’s father, who said that STUDENT had been kidnapped and asked if she knew where STUDENT was. Ms. Solgaard replied that she did not know where STUDENT was and stated that she did not know if he would be returning to her class when the new school year began. (Testimony of Ms. Solgaard.) The next day, Ms. Solgaard spoke on the telephone with MOTHER, who explained that STUDENT was at a residential placement outside of California for either three, six, ten or twelve months. Ms. Solgaard then telephoned STUDENT’s father to inform him that STUDENT was in a residential placement outside of California.

STUDENT remained at Casa-By-The-Sea for three months. During that period, he had two therapy sessions with a licensed social worker. MOTHER visited Casa-By-The-Sea in mid-September for STUDENT’s birthday. However, because “contact” visits were not permitted for students below Level 4, MOTHER did not spend time with STUDENT and instead only observed him from a distance through a window.

In late October 2003, STUDENT returned to northern California and the IEP team convened to discuss his placement. Both STUDENT’s mother and STUDENT’s father attended this meeting. The IEP notes acknowledge that a misunderstanding had occurred during the July parent conference regarding scheduling an IEP meeting. The notes indicated that STUDENT would return to the COE SDC at Alta Loma and that “the parent disputes the fall placement.” (Pet. Exh. D-2.) The IEP meeting ran out of time and was continued to November 3, 2003. STUDENT’s father again was in attendance at the reconvened IEP meeting. The notes of that meeting indicate that MOTHER sought reimbursement for STUDENT’s out-of-state placement and the District denied that request. The notes state that “the parent is in dispute regarding placement from August 10-October 27, 2003, and asked to revoke her consent for that period of time and continue the June, 2003 IEP in Nov. 2003.” (Pet. Exh. D-6.)

On November 4, 2003, STUDENT returned to the COE SDC at Alta Loma for his eighth-grade year and has continued to attend that placement. On November 7, 2003, the Hearing Office received a request for due process hearing from MOTHER on behalf of STUDENT. STUDENT’s triennial assessment is due in March 2004. (Testimony of Janice Robbins; Dist. Exh. 17.) At the end of this school year, STUDENT is scheduled to complete eighth grade and move on to high school, which is operated by a school district other than the Respondent District.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

1. Did the District deny Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE) by placing Petitioner in a special day class (SDC) in February 2002 without first attempting to accommodate him in his general education placement at his home school?

Petitioner contends that his placement into the COE SDC was a denial of FAPE because the SDC was not his LRE. Petitioner contends that he could have been accommodated in the general education setting by utilization of behavioral supports such as a functional analysis assessment (FAA) and behavioral intervention plan (BIP). The District contends that the SDC was Petitioner’s LRE. The District argues that, as of February 2002, Petitioner’s behaviors interfered with his receiptof the nonacademic benefits of the general education setting and had a significant negative effect on the teacher and other students in the general education setting.

Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); California Education Code § 56000.) “FAPE” consists of special education and related services that are available at no charge, meet state educational standards, and conform to the student’s individualized education program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).) “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parents, that is provided to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. ) “Related services” means transportation and other developmental, corrective and supportive services as may be required to assist the child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(a).)

The analysis of whether a student has been provided a free appropriate public education (FAPE) is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to decide whether the proposed placement was substantively appropriate and whether appropriate procedural steps were followed. (Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982).) Regarding whether the placement was substantively appropriate, one of the requirements is that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a student from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in regular education classes cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.) The requirement that disabled children be educated to the maximum extent appropriate with nondisabled children is often referred to as mainstreaming or education in the LRE. The law demonstrates “a strong preference for ‘mainstreaming’ which rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption.” (Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education (5th Cir.1989) 874 F.2d 1036, 1044-45.)

Moreover, a federal regulation requires that the child’s placement must be as close as possible to the child's home, and unless the child’s IEP requires some other arrangement, he must be educated in the school that he would attend if he were not disabled. (34 CFR § 300.552.) That federal regulation also states that in selecting the LRE, consideration is given to any potential harmful effect on the child or on the quality of services that he needs. (34 CFR § 300.552(d).)

In determining whether disabled children should be placed in a regular classroom with supplemental aids and services, the courts have created a four-part test: (1) the academic benefits available to the disabled student in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared with the academic benefits of a special education classroom; (2) the non-academic benefits of interaction with children who are not disabled; (3) the effect of the disabled student’s presence on the teacher and other children in the classroom; and (4) the cost of mainstreaming the disabled student in a regular classroom. (Sacramento City Unified School District v. Holland (9th Cir. 1994) 14 F.3d 1398, cert. denied, 114 S.Ct. 2679 (1994).)

(1) The academic benefits available to STUDENT in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared with the academic benefits of a special education classroom

STUDENT’s achievement test scores indicate that he was able to receive some academic benefit in elementary school when he was mainstreamed and received RSP and speech-language services. On both the Woodcock-Johnson Psychoeducational Battery-Revised and the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT) administered during his triennial evaluation in March 2001, STUDENT scored in the average range in all academic areas, with standard scores ranging from 95 to 109. (Dist. Exh. 17.) These scores are particularly indicative when contrasted with STUDENT’s verbal IQ score of 81, performance IQ score of 86 and full-scale IQ score of 82 on the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-III (WISC-III). Similarly, the CHC evaluation of August 2001 found that several of STUDENT’s achievement test scores exceeded his low average-range ability scores. (Pet. Exh. Q.) Thus, at least through his fifth grade year, STUDENT was receiving academic benefit in a regular education setting with RSP and speech-language services.

Regarding comparison with the benefits of a special education classroom, STUDENT’s triennial evaluation is not due until March 2004, so comparable academic test scores measuring his recent progress are not available. However, the academic benefits of the SDC may still be considered in light of STUDENT’s unique needs. Because of STUDENT’s problems with attention, behavior and impulse control, he required structure, organization and consistency in his academic setting. (Pet. Exh. Q; testimony of Ms. Solgaard.) Ms. Solgaard described how the SDC was highly structured and had clear, consistent behavioral expectations. Ms. Solgaard explained that STUDENT needed to be reminded to exercise good judgment; because of the setup and small teacher-to-student ratio in the SDC, STUDENT was able to receive the reminders and oversight he needs to adjust his behavior. Given STUDENT’s unique needs, the SDC environment offered academic benefit, as reflected by his subsequent good grades there from November 2002 to June 2003. (Dist. Exh. 17, p. 19.)

Thus, the evidence indicates that STUDENT would have been able to receive academic benefit in either a regular education setting with supports or in the SDC.

(2) The non-academic benefits of interaction with children who are not disabled

There was little evidence to support the District’s position that STUDENT was unable to benefit from interaction with nondisabled children. The evidence did establish that STUDENT has had problems interacting with other children, both disabled and nondisabled. For example, STUDENT’s mother testified about some of the difficulties STUDENT had in a mainstream setting, including that he was frequently teased, got into fights, and acted aggressively towards other children. Similarly, STUDENT got into fights on the bus to Alta Loma and provoked other children in the SDC.

However, STUDENT’s behavior problems do not appear to have prevented him from receiving benefit from interactions with typically developing peers. MOTHER testified that STUDENT gained benefit and improved self-esteem from his friendships with non-disabled students and from his participation in sports and other extracurricular activities. MOTHER stated that STUDENT had played the clarinet, played in after-school sports, socialized with his friends in the neighborhood and attended birthday parties. MOTHER asserted that STUDENT feels depressed and alienated now that he is in a special education setting and away from typically developing peers. MOTHER explained that, since he switched schools, STUDENT no longer participates in activities with his friends from the local neighborhood. She testified that she has observed a negative impact on STUDENT’s behavior since he left regular education, in that STUDENT now “acts out” more.

Thus, the evidence demonstrated that STUDENT received benefit from interaction with typically developing peers.

(3) The effect of the disabled student’s presence on the teacher and other children in the classroom

The evidence indicates that STUDENT’s presence was disruptive to the general education classroom. The SDC teacher testified that, until recently, STUDENT’s behavior demonstrated that he could not be in a mainstream environment without being disruptive. Ms. Solgaard reported that in 2002 and 2003, STUDENT manifested behavioral difficulties in class that included provoking other students and a lack of impulse control. Similarly, Ms. Robbins testified that STUDENT had significant behavior problems in regular education and had been suspended numerous times. The school psychologist’s report of February 2002 refers to a history of suspensions and behavioral problems including “significant difficulties interacting with peers, making inappropriate statements of a sexual nature, physical altercations, threatening violence to a classmate, and destruction of property and theft.” (Dist. Exh. 6.) MOTHER acknowledged that over the years STUDENT had been asked to leave approximately 90% of his extracurricular activities due to his aggressive behaviors with other students.

In the Holland case, the court stated that the law requires a school to consider and employ reasonable means to relieve the teacher of excessive burdens which may result from the presence of the disabled student. (Holland, supra., at 879.) In Holland, the student was not disruptive so the court discussed this burden only in the context of a student who may require too much of the teacher’s attention. However, a similar obligation exists when the student’s presence creates a burden due to the student’s disruptive behaviors. This obligation is consistent with the requirement that the IEP team consider positive behavior interventions, strategies and supports to address behaviors that impede the disabled child’s learning or that of others. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(3)(B)(1); 34 C.F.R. § 300.346(a)(2)(i); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.1(b)(1).)

Under California law, an eligible pupil’s IEP must provide those supports and services that allow the pupil to advance in his or her educational program in the LRE. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.) Among the supports and services potentially available to a student with behavioral problems are a functional analysis assessment (FAA) and behavior intervention plan (BIP). State law requires that an FAA “shall occur after the IEP team finds that instructional/behavioral approaches specified in the student’s IEP have been ineffective” when the student has a serious behavior problem. (Cal. Code Regs., Tit. 5, § 3052(b).) The regulations define serious behavior problems as “behaviors which are self-injurious, assaultive, or cause serious property damage and other severe behavior problems that are pervasive and maladaptive for which instructional/behavioral approaches specified in the student's IEP are found to be ineffective.” (Cal. Code Regs., Tit. 5, § 3001(aa); see also Cal. Code Regs., Tit. 5, § 3052(b).) An FAA forms the basis for a BIP, which the regulations define as “a written document which is developed when the individual exhibits a serious behavior problem that significantly interferes with the implementation of the goals and objectives of the individual’s IEP.” (Cal. Code Regs., Tit. 5, § 3001(f).)

In the present case, the District’s special education director, Janice Robbins, explained that STUDENT’s February 2002 IEP team determined that STUDENT’s behaviors could not be managed in a general education setting with RSP support. Ms. Robbins testified that the team did not seek to conduct an FAA to manage STUDENT’s behaviors because at that time his behaviors were not severe enough to warrant an FAA. (See also testimony of Ms. Solgaard.) Ms. Robbins indicated that a behavior support plan is another positive behavioral intervention, one that can be utilized for a student whose behaviors are not severe enough to warrant an FAA, but the IEP team did not appear to consider a behavior support plan before changing STUDENT’s placement to the COE SDC. (See Pet. Exh. B; see also Dist. Exh. 15.)

Considering the IEP team’s failure to utilize an FAA, a behavior support plan, or similar positive behavioral interventions prior to changing STUDENT’s placement, in February 2002 the District failed to employ the required reasonable means to analyze and address STUDENT’s disruptive behaviors. Therefore, while STUDENT’s presence in the general education classroom was disruptive to the teacher and the class, the extent of that effect cannot be fairly judged. It is unknown whether positive behavioral interventions would have effectively addressed STUDENT’s disruptive behaviors in February 2002. Accordingly, consideration of the effect of STUDENT’s disruptive behavior on the general education classroom is counterbalanced by the District’s failure to attempt positive behavioral interventions.

(4) The cost of mainstreaming the disabled student in a regular classroom

Cost was not raised as an issue in this case.

Thus, the evidence established that STUDENT received both academic and non-academic benefits from the regular education environment. While his disruptive behaviors had a negative effect on his teacher and other students in the general education environment, the lack of positive behavioral interventions weighs against that finding.

Given the above findings, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to attempt to accommodate STUDENT in his LRE, the general education classroom with special education supports, before changing his placement to a more restrictive, full-time special education setting outside of his neighborhood school. (Footnote 9)

2. For the period from February 2002 through June 2003, did the District and COE (collectively, Respondents or LEAs) deny Petitioner a FAPE as follows:

(a) failing to hold an individualized education program (IEP) meeting for approximately sixteen months, for the period from February 2002 to June 2003;

Petitioner contends that the delay in convening an IEP meeting during this time period was a procedural violation which significantly interfered with his parent’s right to participate in the IEP process, thus denying him a FAPE. The District concedes that the delay in convening the IEP meeting technically was a procedural violation, but argues that the violation was minor and did not in any way deny Petitioner a FAPE. The COE argues that the delay in convening the IEP meeting did not constitute a denial of FAPE, in part because the June 2003 IEP essentially continued the same placement and services from the previous IEP.

As discussed above, the analysis of whether a student has been provided a free appropriate public education (FAPE) is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to decide whether the proposed placement was substantively appropriate and whether appropriate procedural steps were followed. (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 206-207.) The Supreme Court noted in Rowley that “Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation” at every step “as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP.” (Rowley at 205-206.) Procedural violations which result in a “loss of educational opportunity” or which “seriously infringe the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process clearly result in the denial of a FAPE.” (W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1484.) Procedural violations which do not result in educational loss for the student or serious infringement upon parental participation in the IEP process are insufficient to support a finding that the student has been denied a FAPE. (Ibid.)

A child’s IEP team must meet to review the child’s IEP periodically and at least annually. (34 C.F.R. § 343(c)(1); Cal. Educ. Code § 56343; Cal. Code Regs., Tit. 5, § 3069.) The district, special education local plan area (SELPA) or county office shall maintain procedures for conducting reviews of all IEPs on at least an annual basis. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56380.)

In the present case, STUDENT’s IEP team convened on February 21, 2002, but did not meet again until June 4, 2003. During this period, STUDENT remained in the SDC at Alta Loma with speech-language services and ESY. When the IEP team reconvened for STUDENT’s annual IEP in June 2003, the team agreed to continue STUDENT’s placement at the SDC, although in July 2003 STUDENT’s mother indicated that she wanted to change her consent to that placement.

MOTHER testified that in approximately February 2003, she spoke to STUDENT’s SDC teacher and asked to schedule his annual IEP meeting. Ms. Solgaard agreed to schedule the meeting, but the meeting did not take place because the team members were busy, Ms. Solgaard was in an accident, and spring break intervened. (Testimony of MOTHER.) Ms. Kim testified that one reason for the delay of the IEP meeting was that Ms. Solgaard had been in an accident and had physical therapy appointments due to that accident. Ms. Solgaard explained that scheduling conflicts occurred in part because she tried to schedule the IEP meeting so that STUDENT’s father could be present. Ms. Solgaard stated that she spoke to MOTHER about the scheduling problems during a telephone call and MOTHER was understanding about the problem.

Thus, STUDENT’s IEP team did not meet for approximately fifteen and one-half months. Because State and federal law require an IEP team to convene at least annually, the three and one-half months delay in STUDENT’s IEP annual IEP meeting constituted a procedural violation.

The next question is whether this violation resulted in loss of educational opportunity or serious infringement on parental participation in the IEP process which denied STUDENT a FAPE. The delay does not appear to have caused a loss of educational opportunity; even once the IEP convened in June 2003, the team agreed to continue STUDENT’s placement in the SDC. (Footnote 10) Regarding parental participation in the IEP process, the testimony of MOTHER and Ms. Solgaard indicated that MOTHER was very concerned about STUDENT’s behaviors in spring 2003. When the IEP team finally convened in June 2003, MOTHER discussed her concerns at the IEP meeting. The failure to convene the meeting for three and one-half months delayed the parent’s ability to have the IEP team consider these concerns and how they might affect Petitioner’s educational program. The District argues that there was no serious infringement because STUDENT’s parents both had continuing communication with STUDENT’s teacher during the relevant time period. The Hearing Officer finds that while such communication diminishes the infringement on the parent’s right to participate in the IEP process, it does not rectify it. The IEP is the centerpiece of a special education student’s program; an IEP meeting is essential to monitoring the student’s progress and communication between parent and teacher does not replace that. (See Cal. Educ. Code § 56343.)

Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the three and one-half month delay constituted a serious infringement on the parent’s participation in the IEP process which denied STUDENT a FAPE.

(b) failing to provide mainstreaming in conformity with the IEP dated February 21, 2002;

Petitioner argues that the failure to implement the mainstreaming identified in the IEP constituted a nonconformity with the IEP which denied Petitioner a FAPE. Respondents generally argue that mainstreaming was not appropriate for STUDENT and that the mainstreaming provision on the IEP was only a goal, not part of his program. The COE indicates in its closing brief that the provision for mainstreaming was “the inadvertent marking of a box on the IEP.” To meet the legal standards for substantive appropriateness, an educational program must be designed to address the student’s unique needs, be reasonably calculated to provide the student with educational benefit, and be in conformity with the student’s IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley at 206-207.) Here Petitioner raises the issue of conformity with the IEP dated February 21, 2002, which was in place until a new IEP was signed on June 30, 2003.

The IEP dated February 21, 2002 stated that STUDENT would be mainstreamed in the non-academic areas of “lunch, breaks and assemblies,” for a total of 15% of his school day. (Pet. Exh. C-2.) However, STUDENT ate lunch in the SDC and was not mainstreamed for any part of his school day. STUDENT and the other SDC students attended school-wide assemblies as a group. (Testimony of Ms. Solgaard.)

Ms. Solgaard testified that STUDENT’s behaviors from February 2002 to June 2003 were such that he could not be mainstreamed. Ms. Solgaard reported that in 2002 and 2003, STUDENT manifested behavioral difficulties in class that included provoking other students and a lack of impulse control.

However, despite Ms. Solgaard’s conclusion that mainstreaming could not be implemented, STUDENT’s IEP continued to reflect mainstreaming for 15% of his school day. At the hearing, Ms. Solgaard explained that the mainstreaming component was part of the IEP because “that was the hope and the wish” for STUDENT.

California law provides that a special education program cannot be implemented until a parent of the student consents in writing to the IEP. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(a).) Thus, a change of placement cannot occur without a parent’s written consent. While changed circumstances may render an agreed-upon placement unavailable or inappropriate, a parent of the student must consent in writing to changing a placement already agreed upon in a signed IEP. (See Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(a).)

In the present case, STUDENT’s receipt of a full-time special education program was not in conformity with his then-current IEP, which provided for 15% mainstreaming. Nothing on the IEP document indicates that the mainstreaming was only a goal and would not be implemented. Neither of STUDENT’s parents gave written consent to remove the mainstreaming portion of his placement. There was no testimony or other evidence in support of support COE’s suggestion that the mainstreaming component on the IEP was included inadvertently.

Accordingly, the failure to mainstream STUDENT for 15% of his school day was a nonconformity with his IEP of February 21, 2002, and to this extent constituted a substantive denial of FAPE.

(c) failing to provide speech-language services to address Petitioner’s speech-language deficits identified in the IEP dated February 21, 2002;

At the beginning of the hearing, Petitioner argued that Respondents had failed to provide him with speech-language services from February 2002 through June 2003. During the hearing, COE speech-language specialist Carol Martin testified that she had provided speech-language services to STUDENT during this time period, pursuant to the IEP dated February 21, 2002. In his closing brief, Petitioner no longer appears to dispute that the services were provided. (Footnote 11) In any event, Ms. Martin’s testimony established that she provided STUDENT with speech-language services beginning in February 2002. The June 2003 IEP reflects that STUDENT had been receiving speech-language services since that time and indicates his progress on speech/language goals and objectives. (Exh. COE-4, p.9-12.) Accordingly, there was no denial of FAPE regarding failure to provide speech-language services during the relevant time period.

(d) failing to provide a properly credentialed teacher in the SDC;

Petitioner argues that the SDC teacher did not possess the proper teaching credential required to teach students with ED in an SDC. Respondents contend that Ms. Solgaard possesses the required credentialing.

Ms. Solgaard testified that she has the proper credentials to authorize her to teach an SDC for students with specific learning disabilities and mild to moderate emotional problems. Ms. Solgaard explained that her teaching credentials include a California special education credential for learning handicapped (LH) students. The CTC website confirms that Ms. Solgaard has a “professional clear specialist instruction credential in special education” and that her authorized subject under this credential is LH. (Footnote 12) (See Pet. Exh. R.) Ms. Solgaard explained that she has taken graduate-level coursework regarding teaching severely handicapped (SH) students, although she does not possess the SH credential. She further testified that she is currently in her twenty-fourth year of teaching and has extensive experience teaching special classes for students with ED and behavioral disorders.

A special day class shall be taught by a teacher who holds an appropriate special education credential authorized by the Commission on Teacher Credentialing (CTC) and who possesses the necessary competencies to teach individuals assigned to the class. (Cal. Code Regs., Tit. 5, § 3053(c).) California Code of Regulations, Title 5, section 80047.2 requires that to be authorized by the CTC to teach an SDC in which the primary disability is ED, a teacher must hold one of the following credentials:

(1) Education Specialist Instruction Credential: Mild/Moderate Disabilities;

(2) Education Specialist Instruction Credential: Moderate/Severe Disabilities;

(3) The Special Education Specialist Instruction Credential for the Severely Handicapped;

(4) The special education credentials, other than the credentials in (1), (2), and (3) above, listed in Sections 80047 and 80047.1, provided the following conditions have been met:

(A) The holder of the special education credential has taught full-time for at least one year prior to September 1, 1991 in a special day class in which the primary disability was serious emotional disturbance, and (B) Has received a favorable evaluation or recommendation to teach a special day class with the primary disability of serious emotional disturbance by the local employing agency.

Section 80047.2 further provides that “the holder of one of the special education credentials listed in Sections 80047 and 80047.1 who does not meet the requirements of (a) above shall be authorized to teach in a special day class in which the primary disability is serious emotional disturbance provided the following requirement is met: Completion of a Commission-approved program for children identified with serious emotional disturbance.” (Cal. Code Regs., Tit. 5, § 80047.2(b).) California Code of Regulations Title 5, section 80047 lists “special education specialist instruction credential for the learning handicapped” as one of that section’s credentials. Section 80047 also specifies that the holder of a learning handicapped (LH) special education credential is permitted to teach children with mild or moderate disabilities in an SDC in which the primary disability is specific learning disability or mental retardation.

Simply put, California regulations permit a teacher with an LH credential to teach a special class for ED students if the teacher has either specified experience or specified education in teaching ED students. In the present case, Ms. Solgaard’s testimony was sufficient to establish that she met one or both exceptions.

As the holder of an LH credential, which is one of the credentials listed under California Code of Regulations, Title 5, section 80047, Ms. Solgaard appears authorized to teach an SDC for ED students pursuant to either subsection (a)(4) or subsection (b) of Title 5, C.C.R. section 80047.2. Pursuant to section 80047.2(a)(4), Ms. Solgaard testified that she has taught students with emotional and behavioral disorders for over twenty-three years. Pursuant to section 80047.2(b), Ms. Solgaard testified that she has completed graduate-level SH coursework and that she has the requisite credentialing to teach an SDC for ED students. The Hearing Officer finds this information sufficient to establish that Ms. Solgaard is authorized to teach an SDC for ED students pursuant to Title 5, C.C.R. section 80047.2.

Accordingly, Respondents did not deny STUDENT a FAPE on this basis.

(e) failing to address Petitioner’s behavioral and speech-language needs in the COE SDC placement and failing to place Petitioner in a class with an appropriate peer group in the LRE;

As noted above, the IDEA and relevant case law require that a substantively appropriate educational program must be designed to address the student’s unique needs, be reasonably calculated to provide the student with educational benefit, be in conformity with the student’s IEP, and be in the LRE. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley at 206-207; 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Cal. Education Code § 56031.)

Determination of whether the COE SDC placement was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs begins with identifying those needs. STUDENT is currently eligible solely due to ED. His IQ scores are in the low average range and his achievement test scores are in the average range. His primary area of need concerns his behavior, although he also needs speech-language therapy as a related service. As discussed in Issue #1, STUDENT has problems with attention, behavior and impulse control. In light of these problems, STUDENT requires structure, organization, clear expectations and consequences, and consistency in his academic setting. (Testimony of Ms. Solgaard; see also Pet. Exh. Q.) To address STUDENT’s behavioral needs, the SDC is highly structured and has clear, consistent behavioral expectations and consequences. Ms. Solgaard described additional behavioral interventions she employed when STUDENT could not control his behavior, including seating him in a quiet area. (Footnote 13) Because of the setup and small teacher-to-student ratio in the SDC, STUDENT has been able to receive the reminders and oversight he needs to regulate his behavior.

Previously in Issue #1 this Decision determined that the SDC offered academic benefit for STUDENT. Regarding receipt of educational benefit in the area of behavior, the evidence indicated that STUDENT had improved his behavior and gained benefit in this area during the period of his SDC placement. Ms. Solgaard testified that the structure, small class size and behavioral supports in the COE SDC were sufficient to manage STUDENT’s behaviors. Ms. Solgaard testified thatSTUDENT’s behavior at school began improving after November 2002, once he adjusted to the expectations and requirements in the SDC. (See Pet. Exh.C; Exh. COE-4.) She indicated that STUDENT’s behavior has now improved so much that he is ready to be mainstreamed for lunch with non-disabled peers.

Regarding STUDENT’s speech-language needs, Ms. Martin explained that STUDENT has weaknesses in social and classroom pragmatics, such as not blurting out an answer in the classroom. Ms. Martin testified that STUDENT also has weaknesses in processing, which cause him to have difficulty answering questions after he has received the information he would need to answer them. His test results also indicate some weaknesses in language skills such as vocabulary. (Exh. COE-4.) Ms. Martin explained how initially she worked with STUDENT for twenty-minute sessions because of his short attention span and high distractibility, but that she gradually increased to thirty and then forty-minute sessions as he was able to pay attention for longer periods. In February and March 2003, Ms. Martin administered several tests in speech-language areas, which scores reflected STUDENT’s progress. (Testimony of Ms. Martin; Exh. COE-4, p. 7-9.) In a review of STUDENT’s progress in December 2003, Ms. Martin also reported progress on speech-language goals and objectives. (Exh. COE-5.) Overall, Ms. Martin’s testimony and supporting documentary evidence established that the speech-language services she provided were designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs.

Regarding providing STUDENT with an appropriate peer group, this Decision’s Issue #1 already determined that STUDENT’s placement into the COE SDC in February 2002 was not in the LRE because he potentially could have remained in the regular education environment. However, aside from the preference for mainstreaming, the COE SDC provided STUDENT with an appropriate peer group of classmates. Ms. Solgaard testified that the class is composed of seven boys from ages eleven to fourteen, although at some points there has been a fifteen-year-old student. Ms. Solgaard further testified that all of the students in her class have behavioral disorders or emotional disorders, and are generally of average intelligence. She explained that, during the 2002-2003 school year only, she had one student with an eligibility designation of specific learning disability (SLD) and another whose eligibility category was in question, but the other students were eligible due to ED. In light of the evidence about the student population in the COE SDC, the Hearing Officer finds that the class had an appropriate peer group for STUDENT.

Regarding whether the SDC placement was in the LRE, this Decision has already found that the District’s change of STUDENT’s placement in February 2002 failed to accommodate him in the LRE. As detailed in Issue #1, whether STUDENT could have been placed in a regular classroom with supplemental aids and services depended on whether he was able to receive academic and non-academic benefit in a general education setting and on the effect of STUDENT’s presence on the teacher and other children in the classroom. (Holland at 1404.) Cost of the placement is not at issue in this case.

Regarding the period following the change of placement, from February 2002 to June 2003, the Hearing Officer considers any changes over time which would alter the findings regarding LRE contained in Issue #1. Regarding academic benefit, STUDENT’s previous gains in regular education and the evidence of his academic progress in the SDC setting indicate that he remained able to receive academic benefits in either the a general education classroom or the SDC. Similarly, as discussed in Issue #1, STUDENT continued to be able to receive non-academic benefit in the regular education setting.

However, the evidence indicates that the effect of STUDENT’s presence on others in the classroom changed over the course of his attendance at the SDC. As discussed in Issue #1, while STUDENT’s behaviors in the general education setting were disruptive to others, the District failed to attempt behavioral interventions which may have moderated the effect of his behaviors. During the initial period after the change of placement in February 2002, there is no evidence of change in his behavior which would alter that finding; the lack of behavioral interventions indicates that the effect of STUDENT’s behavior on the general education classroom cannot be properly evaluated. However, Ms. Solgaard and MOTHER both testified that in spring 2003 STUDENT’s behaviors outside of school grew noticeably worse and included drinking alcohol, smoking, stealing and vandalism. MOTHER testified that STUDENT’s behaviors were out of control in spring and summer 2003 and that she was concerned that STUDENT presence at Alta Loma during this period was a danger to the other students. In contrast, Ms. Solgaard reported that STUDENT was well-behaved in class during spring and summer 2003, although she was likewise concerned about STUDENT’s behavior outside of school.

MOTHER’s testimony about STUDENT’s out-of-control behavior and need for a more restrictive placement in spring and summer 2003 established that STUDENT needed a more restrictive placement during that time period. (See also testimony of Ms. Solgaard.) Given Petitioner’s position that STUDENT needed a more restrictive placement beginning in approximately March 2003, STUDENT’s placement from March to June 2003 was in the LRE. In light of this evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the SDC placement, including speech-language services, was designed to address STUDENT’s behavioral and speech-language needs and offered an appropriate peer group. However, the placement was not in the LRE from February 2002 to March 2003; the SDC was STUDENT’s LRE only from March through June 2003.

(f) failing to properly assess Petitioner, specifically concerning the Woodcock-Johnson testing administered in May 2003?

Petitioner’s sole allegation regarding assessment concern the accuracy of a few sections of the Woodcock-Johnson-III Tests of Achievement; specifically, Petitioner disputes STUDENT’s grade-equivalent scores of 13.0 (86th percentile) on the Writing Samples subtest, 12.9 grade equivalent (73rd percentile) on the Word Attack subtest and 11.7 grade equivalent (77th percentile) on the Editing Skills subtest. Other than disagreeing with these scores, Petitioner has not identified any dispute with Respondents’ assessments of STUDENT. Petitioner has not identified any remedy that he seeks as a result of this testing, although in general he contends that his next triennial assessment should be in March 2004, three years from his last triennial evaluation in March 2001. Respondents contend that the Woodcock-Johnson testing was accurate; the District notes that STUDENT’s overall scores are consistent with his previous achievement test scores from his last triennial evaluation.

The Woodcock-Johnson achievement testing administered in May 2003 was not part of a triennial evaluation. There is no allegation that STUDENT received or was offered an inappropriate program or services based upon the results of this testing. While Petitioner argues that his next triennial assessment should be in March 2004, District special education director Janice Robbins confirmed in her testimony that STUDENT’s triennial evaluation is already scheduled for March 2004. (See also Dist. Exh. 17.)

In any event, Ms. Solgaard explained that STUDENT’s scores on the specific subtests such as Writing Samples and Word Attack may appear high because of the format of the tests. Ms. Solgaard confirmed that STUDENT’s writing ability is not at a college level, but explained that STUDENT was able to achieve high scores on those two particular subtests because those tests only require the student to write words and sentences, not whole paragraphs. Ms. Solgaard testified that STUDENT did very well on the Editing subtest and that his score of 77th percentile and 11.7 grade equivalent on that subtest was accurate.

In light of all circumstances, there is no evidence that the Woodcock-Johnson testing was inaccurate. While variation occurred depending on the particular test, STUDENT’s percentile scores on the May 2003 tests were not out of line with his percentile scores on previous achievement testing by the District in May 2001 and by CHC in August 2001. (Dist. Exh. 2, p. 16-18; Dist. Exh. 17, p. 8; Pet. Exh. Q, p. 23-27, 32.) STUDENT’s unusually high scores on three out of nearly thirty subtests administered in May 2003 did not indicate that Respondents failed to accurately assess him. (Footnote 14) 3. Did Respondents deny Petitioner a FAPE in June and July 2003, as follows:

(a) failing to provide prior written notice of the refusal of the parent’s request to change Petitioner’s placement

Petitioner contends that MOTHER requested a change of placement at the IEP meeting on June 30, 2003, and at the parent conference on July 15, 2003. Petitioner contends that Respondents failed to provide written notice of their refusal to change this placement, and that this failure constituted a procedural denial of FAPE. Respondents argue that MOTHER never requested a change of placement in June or July 2003.

Federal law requires Respondents to provide to the parent prior written notice of their refusal to change the educational placement of a child with a disability. (20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3).) The notice must include, among other things, an explanation for the refusal; other options considered and rejected and the reasons; and each test, record, or report used as a basis for the refusal. (20 U.S.C. § 1415(c).) Moreover, as noted previously in this Decision, procedural violations do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE. Instead, only procedural violations which result in a loss of educational opportunity or a serious infringement on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process constitute a procedural denial of FAPE. (Target Range, supra, 960 F.2d at 1484.)

The evidence demonstrates that MOTHER did not clearly request a change of placement at either the IEP meeting on June 30, 2003, or at the parent conference on July 15, 2003. Regarding the June 30 IEP meeting, MOTHER’s testimony that she requested a different placement was not credible in light of the persuasive testimony and documentary evidence to the contrary. MOTHER acknowledged in her testimony that she had signed her attendance on the IEP document and checked the “yes” box next to the sentence: “I agree with special education placement/services as specified on this IEP.” (Exh. COE-4, p. 4; Dist. Exh. 2, p. 4.) During cross-examination at the hearing, MOTHER could not explain why she had checked that box if she had not agreed with the placement. Moreover, the Hearing Officer found both Ms. Kim and Ms. Solgaard credible in their testimony that MOTHER and the other IEP team members all indicated their agreement to continue STUDENT’s placement at the COE SDC. Considering both the IEP document and the testimony of the COE employees, the Hearing Officer finds that MOTHER did not request a change of placement for STUDENT at the IEP meeting on June 30, 2003.

Regarding the July 15 parent conference, MOTHER claims that she told Ms. Kim and Ms. Solgaard at the July 15 meeting that she was sending STUDENT to a residential placement, Casa-By-The-Sea in Ensenada, Mexico. MOTHER further asserted that she had provided the two COE employees with information about Casa-By-The-Sea, which they photocopied for their records.

In contrast, Ms. Kim and Ms. Solgaard both credibly testified that MOTHER told them that she was concerned about STUDENT’s behavior and that she was considering other placements, but that she had not made a final decision and might send STUDENT back to the COE SDC when the new school year began. In the discussion of possible options, Ms. Solgaard and Ms. Kim both advised MOTHER that they thought that STUDENT was appropriately placed in the COE SDC. Ms. Kim acknowledged that MOTHER had stated during the July 15 meeting that she wanted to “change the box” on the IEP document, but Ms. Kim did not understand MOTHER’s request to be a request for a change of placement. Neither Ms. Kim or Ms. Solgaard recognized any documents about Casa-By-The-Sea and testified that they did not hear MOTHER mention Casa-By-The-Sea during the July 15 meeting. Ms. Kim acknowledged that MOTHER had shown her some documents about a potential residential placement, but explained that it was a placement in Utah.

In light of the testimony presented at the hearing, the Hearing Officer concludes that MOTHER did not clearly request a change of placement during the July 15 meeting. For several reasons, the Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Kim and Ms. Solgaard more credible on this point than the testimony of MOTHER. First, it is simply more likely and more believable that MOTHER does not accurately recall what she said on this point than that both Ms. Kim and Ms. Solgaard are mistaken or being dishonest. Ms. Solgaard testified that when STUDENT’s father telephoned her at the beginning of the school year to ask about STUDENT’s whereabouts, she told him that she did not know; when she learned from MOTHER that STUDENT was at a residential placement, she then telephoned STUDENT’s father to relay that information. This testimony is consistent with the accounts of Ms. Solgaard and Ms. Kim, but inconsistent with MOTHER’s claim that she requested a change of placement at the July 15 meeting and informed the COE employees about Casa-By-The-Sea.

Moreover, while MOTHER appeared to be honest, her recollection of what occurred during meetings was not reliable. For example, as discussed above, MOTHER claimed that she had requested a change of placement at the IEP meeting on June 30, but then could not explain why she had checked the box on the IEP indicating that she agreed with the COE SDC placement. In another example, MOTHER had initially asserted during the hearing that she had never met Carol Martin, STUDENT’s speech-language specialist, despite Ms. Martin’s signature on the June 2003 IEP document. This testimony proved unreliable when Ms. Martin, Ms. Kim and Ms. Solgaard all testified credibly that Ms. Martin and MOTHER had met and interacted when Ms. Martin gave a detailed presentation during the June 4 IEP meeting when MOTHER was present.

Considering all testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that MOTHER did not clearly request a change of placement at either the IEP meeting on June 30 or the parent conference on July 15, 2003. Hence, Respondents had no obligation to provide written notice of their refusal to change STUDENT’s placement, and no procedural violation occurred.

(b) refusing to allow the parent to retract her consent to the June 30, 2003 IEP;

Petitioner contends that MOTHER told COE employees that she wanted to withdraw her consent to the June 2003 IEP, but that she was not permitted to do so. Respondents argue that MOTHER never conveyed that she wanted to withdraw her consent to the IEP, and instead COE employees understood MOTHER’s statements to indicate only that she wanted to make changes to the language on the IEP document.

A student is not required to participate in a special education program until the parent consents in writing to the program. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(a).) If the parent does not consent to a program or withdraws consent, the student remains in his or her last agreed-upon educational placement until resolution of the dispute. (See 20 U.S.C. § 1415(j); California Education Code § 56500(d).)

During the parent conference on July 15, and subsequently during a telephone conversation, MOTHER stated that she wanted to change the box on the IEP form regarding her consent from “yes” to “no.” (Testimony of Ms. Kim; see also testimony of MOTHER.) On each occasion, Ms. Kim informed MOTHER that she could not change the content of an IEP document outside of an IEP meeting.

At the hearing, Ms. Kim credibly testified that she did not understand MOTHER’s statements as a request to change the placement identified in the IEP. Ms. Kim explained that she thought MOTHER wanted to make changes to the IEP document, which can only be accomplished during an IEP meeting. During questioning at the hearing, Ms. Kim acknowledged that a parent can also write out any disagreement with the IEP and submit that document to be attached to the IEP; Ms. Kim admitted that she had not thought of suggesting that option to MOTHER.

In light of all circumstances, MOTHER did not clearly convey her desire to withdraw her consent to the June 2003 IEP. The COE employees attempted to facilitate MOTHER’s participation in the IEP process but simply did not understand her statements to constitute a request to withdraw her consent to that IEP. Therefore, this event did not constitute a procedural violation or a procedural denial of FAPE.

(c) failing to convene an IEP meeting in July 2003 despite the parent’s request for an IEP meeting;

Petitioner contends that Respondents failed to convene an IEP meeting despite the parent’s request. Respondents contend that the IEP team is not required to convene during the months of July and August.

An IEP team meeting requested by a parent shall be held within thirty (30) days, not counting days in July and August, from the date of receipt of the parent’s written request. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56343.5) If a parent makes an oral request, the school district shall notify the parent of the need for a written request and the procedure for filing a written request. (Ibid.)

On or about July 11, 2003, MOTHER orally requested an IEP team meeting concerning STUDENT. While COE initially attempted to schedule the meeting in mid-July, District and COE employees were not available during the summer vacation and therefore the IEP team did not convene. The District and COE both operate on a traditional school year calendar; some District and COE employees were not available to attend the IEP meeting during the summer.

Considering the clear language of Education Code section 56343.5, the law did not require Respondents to convene an IEP team meeting in July or August 2003. Thus, no procedural violation occurred.

(d) failing to provide the parent with a copy of the June 30, 2003 IEP document;

Respondents contend that STUDENT’s mother was provided a copy of the IEP at the meeting on June 30, 2003. Petitioner contends that MOTHER did not receive a copy of the June 30, 2003 IEP document. Initially at the hearing, Petitioner initially asserted that MOTHER did not receive a copy of the June 2003 IEP until the exchange of evidence a week before the hearing. Subsequently Ms. Kim testified that, in approximately September 2003, MOTHER requested another copy of the IEP and Ms. Kim immediately sent her a copy. At the hearing, Ms. Kim verified a tape recording of a voicemail message she had received from MOTHER, in which MOTHER acknowledged receiving the copy of the IEP document in the mail. In Petitioner’s closing brief, Petitioner argued that MOTHER did not receive a copy of the June 2003 IEP until Ms. Kim mailed it in September 2003.

The LEA(s) shall give the parent or guardian a copy of the IEP at no cost to the parent or guardian. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(i).) In the present case, Ms. Solgaard and Ms. Kim both testified that MOTHER received a copy of the IEP document at the end of the meeting on June 30, 2003. On the signature page of the IEP document, MOTHER’s initials appear next to the statement “I have received a copy of the IEP.” (Exh. COE-4, p. 4; Dist. Exh. 2, p. 4.)

The only evidence in support of Petitioner’s position is MOTHER’s testimony that she did not receive a copy of the IEP at the meeting on June 30, 2003. As discussed previously in Issue #3(a), MOTHER’s reported recollections of what took place at meetings were often unreliable. Moreover, in this instance MOTHER’s version of events seems highly doubtful; the COE employees appeared to clearly understand the obligation to provide the parent with a copy of the IEP document, and MOTHER initialed on the IEP document that she had received a copy. Considering all evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that MOTHER received a copy of the June 2003 IEP document at the IEP meeting on June 30, 2003. Therefore, no procedural violation occurred. (e) failing to include Petitioner’s speech-language pathologist at the June 2003 IEP meetings;

Respondents contend that the speech-language pathologist, Carol Martin, attended the IEP meeting on June 4, 2003, during which time she provided detailed information about STUDENT’s progress in speech and language. Respondents do not dispute that Ms. Martin did not attend the continuation of the IEP meeting on June 30, but argue that her presence was not required and that she would have returned to the meeting if her presence was required or requested. California Education Code section 56341(b) identifies the necessary members of the IEP team. One category of potential IEP team member is “an individual who conducted an assessment of the student, or who is knowledgeable about the assessment procedures used to assess the student and is familiar with the assessment results or recommendations.” (Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b)(5).) The Education Code also provides that “at the discretion of the parent, guardian or the district, [SELPA], or county office, other individuals who have knowledge or special expertise regarding the pupil, including related service personnel, as appropriate.” (Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b)(6).)

Regarding the IEP meeting on June 4, 2003, as discussed previously in this Decision, the testimony of Ms. Martin, Ms. Kim and Ms. Solgaard clearly established that Ms. Martin had attended the IEP meeting and gave a fairly lengthy presentation during the meeting. Ms. Martin completed her presentation, signed the IEP document and left the meeting.

There is no dispute that Ms. Martin had completed her participation in the IEP meeting on June 4 and therefore did not attend the continued IEP meeting on June 30 meeting. Considering the factual circumstances, and pursuant to Education Code section 56341, there was no requirement that Ms. Martin attend the second IEP meeting. Ms. Martin had already participated regarding her area of knowledge, STUDENT’s speech-language services; there was no evidence to indicate that Ms. Martin’s participation was required under subsections 5 or 6 of section 56341(b). Testimony established that the IEP team members could have contacted Ms. Martin on June 30 if the team had questions for her or otherwise required her participation. (Testimony of Ms. Martin, Ms. Kim.) Thus, Ms. Martin’s failure to attend the IEP meeting on June 30, 2003 was not a procedural violation and did not constitute a procedural denial of FAPE.

(f) failing to refer Petitioner for Chapter 26.5 mental health services in conformity with the June 30, 2003 IEP?

Petitioner argues that STUDENT’s program failed to conform to his June 30, 2003 IEP because the mental health services “were not made available until November, 2003.” (Pet. Closing Brief, p. 27.) Respondents argue that the COE staff made the referral for STUDENT’s mental health assessment within a few days after the IEP meeting on June 30, 2003.

As discussed previously in this Decision, one element of LEAs’ obligation to provide a FAPE is the obligation to provide a program in conformity with the student’s IEP. (Rowley, supra at 206-207.) California law defines a mental health assessment as “a service designed to provide formal, documented evaluation or analysis of the nature of the pupil’s emotional or behavioral disorder.” (Cal. Code Regs., Tit. 2, § 60020(g).) An IEP team, LEA or parent may initiate a referral for a student’s assessment to the community mental health agency. (Cal. Gov’t Code § 7576(b); Cal. Code Regs., Tit. 2, § 60040(a).)

The June 30, 2003 IEP contains a provision for a referral for a mental health assessment. Ms. Kim testified that she contacted the county mental health agency and initiated the referral within a few days after the IEP meeting on June 30. MOTHER acknowledged in her testimony that she received the paperwork from the county mental health agency but did not immediately complete and return the forms. MOTHER testified that she has since returned the completed forms and has scheduled an appointment for STUDENT’s mental health assessment.

In light of these facts, there is no evidence whatsoever of any failure by Respondents to refer STUDENT for mental health services in conformity with the IEP. (Footnote 15) Accordingly, no procedural violation occurred and there was no denial of FAPE on this basis.

4. Did Respondents deny Petitioner a FAPE for the period from August to November 2003, as follows:

(a) failing to allow parental participation in the IEP process;

Petitioner argues that “Respondents’ refusal to accept MOTHER’s revocation of consent continued through November, 2003.” (Pet. Closing Brief, p. 27.) Petitioner argues that Respondents’ continued offer of the COE SDC at the October/November IEP meetings “constitute a denial of parental participation in the IEP process.” Respondents argue that MOTHER fully participated in the October/November IEP meetings.

The IDEA and State special education laws all emphasize that parents have the right to participate in decisions regarding their child’s educational placement. (See, e.g., Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56304, 56342.5; 20 U.S.C. § 1415.) For example, LEAs are obligated to take whatever action is necessary to ensure that the parent understands the proceedings at a meeting, including arranging for an interpreter for a parent with deafness or whose native language is other than English. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(h).) A procedural violation which seriously infringes on a parent’s right to participate in the IEP process constitutes a procedural denial of FAPE. (Target Range, supra at 1484.)

There is no persuasive evidence to support MOTHER’s allegation that Respondents denied her right to participate in the IEP process during this time period. The October/November 2003 IEP notes and the testimony of other IEP team members indicate that MOTHER participated extensively in that IEP meeting. The LEAs’ decision to offer a placement other than the parent’s preferred placement does not constitute a procedural violation. (Footnote 16) There was no procedural violation or procedural denial of FAPE due to failure to allow parental participation in the IEP process.

(b) continuing to offer to place him in the COE SDC, which failed to address his unique needs and was not in the LRE?

Petitioner again contends that the COE SDC was not designed to address STUDENT’s behavioral needs and was not in the LRE. Respondents again contend that the COE SDC placement was an appropriate offer of FAPE.

As discussed herein, the IDEA and relevant case law require that a substantively appropriate educational program must be designed to address the student’s unique needs, be reasonably calculated to provide the student with educational benefit, be in conformity with the student’s IEP, and be in the LRE. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley at 206-207; 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Cal. Education Code § 56031.)

This Decision has already determined that, for the period from February 2002 to June 2003, the COE SDC placement was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of behavior and speech-language and provided him with some educational benefit. The Decision found that the COE SDC placement was not in STUDENT’s LRE from February 2002 to March 2003, in large part because it was unknown whether behavioral interventions would have reduced STUDENT’s disruptive effect on his general education teacher and classmates. However, the Decision found that the COE SDC was in STUDENT’s LRE beginning in March 2003, because of STUDENT’s escalating behaviors outside of school and his mother’s position that he therefore needed a more restrictive placement.

Respondent’s offer for the period from August to November 2003 is contained in the June 2003 IEP. That IEP continued STUDENT’s placement in the COE SDC, and indicated that STUDENT would be mainstreamed for lunch and recess, for a total of 7% of his school day.

There is no dispute that STUDENT continued to have unique needs in the same general areas as he did in 2002-2003. Staff at Casa-By-The-Sea confirmed that, from August through October 2003, STUDENT still manifested behavioral problems including failure to control his behavior. (Testimony of Kenneth Slaugh, Mr. Chism.) Ms. Solgaard testified that STUDENT’s behavior in class had improved somewhat in spring 2003, although his behavior in his home and community grew far worse around the same time. Ms. Solgaard’s class remained essentially the same and continued to offer the same types of structure and behavioral supports. Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that, for the period from August to November 2003, the COE SDC offer continued to address STUDENT’s unique needs and was reasonably calculated to result in educational benefit.

Because the IEP was not implemented during this period, there is no dispute regarding conformity with the IEP. Regarding LRE, the Hearing Officer revisits the analysis for the period from February 2002 to March 2003, to consider if any factors have changed. While STUDENT could still have received the academic and nonacademic benefits of regular education from August to November 2003, there are greater problems with the effect of his presence on the teacher and other students in the general education setting. MOTHER testified that the reason she took STUDENT to Casa-By-The-Sea in August 2003 was that he had out-of-control behaviors, including stealing and vandalism. MOTHER testified that she was particularly concerned about STUDENT’s attendance at Alta Loma during ESY in June and July 2003, and worried that STUDENT might be a danger to others students at the school.

In light of this evidence, STUDENT’s behaviors would likely have been disruptive to the general education setting and could not have been placed in a setting less restrictive than the COE SDC. Thus, Respondents’ offer for August to November 2003 was in the LRE and did not denySTUDENT a FAPE.

5. Did Respondents fail to offer Petitioner a FAPE beginning in November 2003 and continuing for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year by continuing to offer placement in the COE SDC which fails to address his unique needs and is not the LRE?

In light of this Decision’s previous findings regarding the appropriateness of the COE SDC placement for STUDENT, the Hearing Officer will consider whether any changes warrant a different finding for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year. Other than some behavioral issues, none of the parties contended, or presented evidence showing, that STUDENT’s needs have changed since the prior school year. MOTHER indicated that STUDENT’s behaviors improved while he was at Casa-By-The-Sea and he no longer manifests the out-of-control behaviors he demonstrated during spring and summer 2003. Ms. Solgaard testified that “STUDENT picked up right where he left off” in her class and that, since June 2003, she has felt confident recommending that he be mainstreamed for his lunch.

Thus, because STUDENT’s needs generally remain the same, the Hearing Officer finds that the COE SDC continues to be designed to address his unique needs and allow him to receive educational benefit. There is no issue of conformity with the IEP because implementation of the IEP began only a few weeks before the hearing, when STUDENT returned to the SDC. Hence, the final consideration is whether the offer is in the LRE. To recap, for the period from February 2002 to March 2003, this Decision found that the placement was not in the LRE because STUDENT could have received academic and nonacademic benefits from mainstreaming and because the District had not attempted to implement behavioral supports to reduce the disruptive effect of STUDENT’s behaviors in the general education setting. However, regarding the period from March to November 2003, the evidence about STUDENT’s increased behaviors and his mother’s decision to place him in a more restrictive placement warranted a finding that the COE SDC was STUDENT’s LRE for that period.

Regarding STUDENT’s current behaviors, the evidence indicates that his significantly disruptive behaviors have subsided. His current teacher confirms that he is ready to be mainstreamed for lunch in conformity with his IEP. Given that behavioral interventions designed to allow STUDENT greater mainstreaming have not been attempted, the COE SDC is not STUDENT’s LRE. As discussed in Issue #1, it is unknown whether an FAA, BIP or other intervention could eliminate STUDENT’s disruptive behaviors and allow him to be mainstreamed without negative effect on the general education environment. Therefore, the COE SDC placement is not STUDENT’s LRE, although the placement is otherwise appropriate.

6. If Respondents denied Petitioner a FAPE, should the Hearing Officer order the following relief:

(a) reimbursement to Petitioner by Respondents for placement at Casa By The Sea and related expenses including transportation;

Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services were appropriate under the IDEA and replaced services that the school district failed to provide. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359, 369-370; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(1997).)

In the present case, this Decision has found one procedural violation due to a delay in convening STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting, and substantive denials concerning lack of mainstreaming and placement in the LRE. The specific findings of substantive denials of FAPE were that: (1) from February 2002 to March 2003, the District failed to attempt to accommodate STUDENT in the LRE; (2) from February 2002 to June 2003, Respondents failed to provide mainstreaming for 15% of STUDENT’s school day in conformity with his IEP; and (3) from November 2003 to June 2004, Respondents failed to offer a placement in the LRE.

As a remedy for denials of FAPE, Petitioner seeks reimbursement for a residential placement STUDENT attended from August to October 2003 at Casa-By-The-Sea in Ensenada, Mexico. Casa-By-The-Sea is a residential school for boys with a program is designed to emphasize “character-building.” The school has a level-based behavior program, requiring each entering student to begin at Level 1 and earn privileges only by advancing to the higher levels.

There is no question that Casa-By-The-Sea is a more restrictive placement than the COE SDC, which is located on a general education middle school campus. This Decision determined that STUDENT was denied a FAPE due to lack of mainstreaming in conformity with his IEP and failure to attempt to accommodate him in an educational environment less restrictive than the COE SDC. The Casa-By-The-Sea placement was a more restrictive placement and thus did not replace the mainstreaming that Respondents failed to provide. Indeed, Petitioner’s position is inherently contradictory in that he argues that Respondents denied him a FAPE by failing to mainstream him, but then seeks reimbursement for a more restrictive placement in a residential setting. Additionally, the residential placement did not remedy the denial of FAPE caused by Respondents’ delay in convening the IEP meeting originally scheduled for February 2003, that finally convened in June 2003.

In any event, reimbursement for Casa-By-The-Sea would be reduced or denied due to the parent’s failure to notify Respondents about the unilateral placement at least ten days in advance. Reimbursement paid to a parent of a child with a disability for costs of a private school may be reduced or denied if the parent fails to do one of the following:

(aa) at the most recent IEP meeting that the parents attended prior to removal of the child from the public school, the parents did not inform the IEP Team that they were rejecting the placement proposed by the public agency to provide a free appropriate public education to their child, including stating their concerns and their intent to enroll their child in a private school at public expense; or (bb)10 business days (including any holidays that occur on a business day) prior to the removal of the child from the public school, the parents did not give written notice to the public agency of the information described in (aa).”

(20 U.S.C. § 1412 (a)(10)(C)(iii); see Cal. Educ. Code § 56276.)

This Decision has already determined that MOTHER did not clearly convey to Respondents that she intended to place STUDENT in a residential placement. The testimony of Ms. Kim and Ms. Solgaard established that MOTHER stated during the July 15 parent conference that she was concerned about STUDENT’s behavior and that she was considering other placements, but that she had not made a final decision and might send STUDENT back to the COE SDC when the new school year began. COE staff first learned that STUDENT was at a residential placement when MOTHER informed Ms. Solgaard of the placement during a telephone conversation in late August 2003, after STUDENT was already at Casa-By-The-Sea. The District first learned of the residential placement when its special education director received in the mail a copy of STUDENT’s Casa-By-The-Sea invoice that MOTHER sent. (Testimony of Ms. Robbins.)

Because the residential placement did not replace any services that Respondents failed to provide and had no causal relationship with the denials of FAPE, and because MOTHER failed to provide the required advance notice of the unilateral placement, reimbursement for the unilateral placement is not an appropriate remedy. Because the reimbursement is denied, there is no need for the Hearing Officer to consider whether the parent’s unilateral placement was an appropriate placement for STUDENT.

(b) a comprehensive special education assessment in all areas to determine an appropriate placement;

There was no evidence to indicate that STUDENT has not been accurately assessed. Moreover, Respondents acknowledge that STUDENT’s triennial assessment will be conducted in March 2004, three years after his last triennial assessment in March 2001. (Testimony of Ms. Robbins.) In light of Respondents’ position that STUDENT’s triennial assessment will be conducted in March 2004, there is no need for the Hearing Officer to order this assessment as a remedy in the present matter.

(c) an IEP team meeting to consider the results of the Children’s Health Council (CHC) assessment and determine a new, appropriate placement?

The IEP team that convened on February 7, 2002, considered the CHC evaluation report. (Dist. Exh. 6; testimony of Ms. Robbins.) Immediately following that IEP meeting, most of the members of STUDENT’s IEP team changed due to STUDENT’s change in placement from BIS to the COE SDC at Alta Loma. The SDC teacher and other COE members of STUDENT’s new IEP team had not seen the CHC evaluation report and therefore were unable to consider it. (Testimony of Ms. Solgaard.) It is unknown why MOTHER did not present the CHC evaluation to the IEP team if she wanted the team members to consider the report. While the report is now two and one-half years old, it may nevertheless be useful to the current IEP team. Because the report addresses STUDENT’s needs within the context of a general education setting, the IEP team’s consideration of the report has some causal relationship to this Decision’s findings regarding denials of FAPE due to lack of mainstreaming and failure to attempt to accommodate STUDENT in his LRE.

Additionally, while Petitioner has not argued for STUDENT to return to a purely mainstream environment, and the evidence does not indicate that STUDENT’s behaviors can yet be managed within a full-time mainstream environment, the past denials of FAPE put STUDENT in need of additional preparation for his transition to high school. (See Dist. Exh. 29.) To remedy the denials, the Hearing Officer will consider an award of compensatory education. Compensatory education is an equitable remedy which may be available when the school district has denied the student a FAPE. (Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1497 (9th Cir. 1994).) In fashioning appropriate equitable relief the conduct of both parties should be reviewed, along with the nature of relief requested, to determine whether an award of compensatory education is appropriate. (Id.) Courts have explained that the purpose of compensatory relief is to replace lost educational services and ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA. (Student W. at 1497; Todd v. Andrews, 933 F.2d 1576 (11th Cir. 1991); Moubry v. Independent School District No. 696, 951 F.Supp. 867 (8th Cir. 1996).) There is, however, no obligation to compensate the child by providing a day of education for each educational day lost. (Student W. at 1497.)

As a remedy for the past denials of FAPE found in this Decision, Respondents shall provide STUDENT with a total of twenty-five hours of compensatory education designed to address his behavioral needs, maximize his mainstreaming opportunities, and assist his transition to high school. The twenty-five hours need not necessarily be provided in direct services; for example, the compensatory education may include consultation by a behavior analyst or school psychologist in designing appropriate behavioral interventions for STUDENT. Because STUDENT is about to graduate from the District, and because the compensatory education is designed in part to facilitate STUDENT’s transition to high school, the IEP team should plan for the compensatory education to be delivered during the remaining months that STUDENT is still a student of the District, including the 2003 ESY. (Footnote 17)

Because this Decision found that the COE SDC placement was appropriate for STUDENT this year other than its failure to place him in the LRE, and because a change of placement this late in the school year would be ill-advised, Respondents may maintain STUDENT’s placement in the COE SDC at Alta Loma. However, to address Respondents’ failure to offer placement in the LRE this year, the IEP team shall utilize behavioral interventions in order to gradually add another mainstreaming opportunity for STUDENT, such as another class period in addition to lunch. This increase in mainstreaming should be developed in conjunction with the behavioral services provided due to the award of compensatory education, such that any behavioral interventions developed due to the compensatory education award may also be utilized in increasing STUDENT’s mainstreaming during his current school year.

ORDER

1. Within seven days of the date of this Decision, Respondents shall schedule an IEP team meeting and shall send written notice of the meeting to all participants pursuant to 34 C.F.R. section 300.345 and California Education Code section 56341.5. The meeting shall be scheduled to convene within twenty (20) days of the date of this Decision. At the IEP meeting, the team shall:

(a) consider the Children’s Health Council (CHC) evaluation report;

(b) add to STUDENT’s IEP the twenty-five (25) hours of compensatory education awarded herein. The compensatory education shall be designed to address STUDENT’s behavioral needs, maximize his mainstreaming opportunities, and assist his transition to high school.

(c) utilize behavioral interventions in order to gradually add another mainstreaming opportunity for STUDENT, such as another class period in addition to lunch. This increase in mainstreaming should be developed in conjunction with the behavioral services provided due to the award of compensatory education, such that any behavioral interventions developed due to the compensatory education award may also be utilized in increasing STUDENT’s mainstreaming during his current school year.

2. All of Petitioner’s other requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: 1. Did the District deny Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE) in February 2002 by placing Petitioner in a COE special day class (SDC) without first attempting to accommodate him in his general education placement at his home school?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

2. For the period from February 2002 through June 2003, did the District and COE (collectively, Respondents) deny Petitioner a FAPE as follows:

(a) failing to hold an individualized education program (IEP) meeting for approximately sixteen months, for the period from February 2002 to June 2003;

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

(b) failing to provide mainstreaming in conformity with the IEP dated February 21, 2002;

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

(c) failing to provide speech-language services to address Petitioner’s speech-language deficits identified in the IEP dated February 21, 2002;

Respondents prevailed on this issue.

(d) failing to provide a properly credentialed teacher in the COE SDC;

Respondents prevailed on this issue.

(e) failing to address Petitioner’s behavioral and speech-language needs in the COE SDC placement and failing to place Petitioner in a class with an appropriate peer group in the LRE;

Respondents primarily prevailed on this issue, except that Petitioner prevailed on this issue regarding placement in the LRE for the period from February 2002 to March 2003.

(f) failing to properly assess Petitioner, specifically concerning the Woodcock-Johnson testing administered in May 2003?

Respondents prevailed on this issue.

3. Did Respondents deny Petitioner a FAPE in June and July 2003, as follows:

(a) failing to provide prior written notice of the refusal of the parent’s request to change Petitioner’s placement;

Respondents prevailed on this issue.

(b) refusing to allow the parent to retract her consent to the June 30, 2003 IEP;

Respondents prevailed on this issue.

(c) failing to convene an IEP meeting in July 2003 despite the parent’s request for an IEP meeting;

Respondents prevailed on this issue.

(d) failing to provide the parent with a copy of the June 30, 2003 IEP document;

Respondents prevailed on this issue.

(e) failing to include Petitioner’s speech-language pathologist at the June 2003 IEP meetings; and

Respondents prevailed on this issue.

(f) failing to refer Petitioner for Chapter 26.5 mental health services in conformity with the June 30, 2003 IEP?

Respondents prevailed on this issue.

4. Did Respondents deny Petitioner a FAPE for the period from August to November 2003, as follows:

(a) failing to allow parental participation in the IEP process; and

Respondents prevailed on this issue.

(b) continuing to offer to place him in the COE SDC, which failed to address his unique needs and was not in the LRE?

Respondents prevailed on this issue.

5. Did Respondents fail to offer Petitioner a FAPE beginning in November 2003 and continuing for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year by continuing to offer placement in the COE SDC which fails to address his unique needs and is not the LRE?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the extent that the placement is not in the LRE. Respondents otherwise prevailed on this issue.

6. If Respondents denied Petitioner a FAPE, should the Hearing Officer order the following relief:

(a) reimbursement to Petitioner by Respondents for placement at Casa By The Sea and related expenses including transportation;

Respondents prevailed on this issue.

(b) a comprehensive special education assessment in all areas to determine an appropriate placement; and

Respondents prevailed on this issue.

(c) an IEP team meeting to consider the results of the Children’s Health Council (CHC) assessment and determine a new, appropriate placement?

Petitioner prevailed in part on this issue, to the extent that the Decision ordered the IEP team to consider the results of the CHC assessment. Additionally, the Decision awarded Petitioner twenty-five hours of compensatory education and a gradual increase in Petitioner’s amount of mainstreaming for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: February 6, 2004 ___________________________________ Suzanne B. Brown Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. Some issues have been revised for purposes of clarity and organization, although the issues remain the same substantively. Additionally, Petitioner initially identified a hearing issue concerning provision of transportation as a designated instruction and service (DIS). However, on the final day of hearing, the parties confirmed that they had resolved this issue and requested that it be dismissed.

2. In this matter, in several areas the parent’s testimony about factual events differed from the testimony of LEA employees. This Decision’s “Background Facts” section describes the factual version which the Hearing Officer determined to be true, based upon the evidence presented. Where appropriate, recitations of facts are followed by a citation to the witnesses and/or evidentiary documents upon which the factual finding is based.

3. The IEP notes also reflect that MOTHER expressed concern about STUDENT’s then-current placement and stated that she believed a more intensive placement was required.

4. At the hearing, MOTHER testified that she felt she had no choice but to accept the new placement.

5. MOTHER’s copy of the IEP document does not list the speech-language services, although the District’s copy does. There was no evidence clearly explaining this discrepancy.

6. MOTHER initially testified that Carol Martin did not attend the IEP meeting, then later testified that STUDENT had recalled Ms. Martin’s attendance at the meeting. In any event, the testimony of Ms. Martin, Ms. Kim and Ms. Solgaard regarding Ms. Martin’s presentation at that IEP meeting clearly established that Ms. Martin had attended the IEP meeting and gave a fairly lengthy presentation during the meeting.

7. The individuals in attendance at the June 30 meeting were school psychologist Robin Kim, Ms. Solgaard, MOTHER and STUDENT. Ms. Martin had completed her presentation regarding STUDENT’s speech-language services at the June 8 meeting and therefore she did not attend the June 30 meeting. (Testimony of Ms. Martin.)

8. Both the District and Alta Loma operate on a traditional school year calendar.

9. In its closing brief, the District argues that it is improper for a parent to challenge the content of a previous IEP if the parent agreed to the content of the IEP at the time. The Hearing Officer is unaware of any binding authority in support of the District’s position. The District cites to 34 C.F.R. section 300.350 in support of its position, but that section does not address this point.

10. Petitioner does not allege that the failure to convene the IEP meeting caused a loss of educational opportunity. (See Petitioner’s Closing Brief, p. 14.)

11. Petitioner’s closing brief raises new issues regarding whether the speech-language services were appropriate and whether Petitioner’s mother consented to provision of the services. Because issues must be identified at least ten days prior to the hearing, issues raised for the first time in a closing brief will not be addressed.

12. This website appears to be the basis for the confusion regarding Ms. Solgaard’s credentialing. The webpage for Ms. Solgaard’s LH credential identifies that credential, but does not identify the relevant exception regarding ED students pursuant to Cal. Code Regs., Tit. 5, section 80047.2. (See Pet. Exh. R.)

13. Ms. Solgaard also repeatedly suggested that STUDENT would benefit from mental health services, but MOTHER said that she believed the SDC placement was enough for STUDENT and that mental health services were not necessary. (Testimony of Ms. Solgaard.)

14. Moreover, consistent with Petitioner’s request, Respondents are scheduled to conduct his triennial reassessment in March 2004.

15. In fact, the evidence established that at several points Respondents had previously sought to provide mental health services to STUDENT, but MOTHER refused the services. Specifically, she terminated STUDENT’s 26.5 mental health services in June 2001, after STUDENT had already been found eligible for those services. Additionally, once STUDENT began attending the SDC, Ms. Solgaard also suggested that STUDENT would benefit from mental health services; however, MOTHER said that she believed the SDC placement was enough for STUDENT and that mental health services were not necessary. (Testimony of Ms. Solgaard.)

16. To that extent, Ms. Tucker-Jones, Ms. Kim, and Ms. Solgaard testified that MOTHER seemed to convey agreement with the LEAs’ offer to put STUDENT back in the COE SDC, and merely disagreed with the COE SDC offer for the period STUDENT was in his residential placement. The IEP notes reflect that this was MOTHER’s position. (Dist. Exh. 29; Pet. Exh. D-6.)

17. However, if delivery of the twenty-five hours of compensatory services is not completed by the end of the current school year, Respondents’ obligation to deliver those hours of services remains. In that instance, Respondents may complete delivery of the compensatory services during the 2004-2005 school year.