California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 15, 2003

Student v. Napa Valley Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 2375-02 · Hearing Officer Michael F. Geary

Napa Valley Unified must fund 280 Lindamood-Bell hours and reimburse tutoring after late child find and inadequate IEPs.

Split decision: student prevailed on 7 of 7 issues (5 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The decision includes a note that it was amended to add a new paragraph 4 to the Order (Lindamood-Bell compensatory reimbursement) and to renumber the later paragraphs. The date of the amendment is not stated.

Summary

A fourth-grade student at Brown's Valley Elementary School filed against Napa Valley Unified School District. He had been found ineligible for special education in 2000, then spent third grade at a charter school. In March 2002 he was found eligible under specific learning disability. He returned to the District in fall 2001 struggling academically and behaviorally. The Hearing Officer found the District should have referred him for assessment by October 16, 2001, about six weeks into the year. Instead, it waited until December and then added a 36-day delay for a student study team meeting. An IEP should have been in place by December 20, 2001. The District also failed to assess occupational therapy (OT), social-emotional functioning, and behavior until early 2003. Its pragmatic language assessment was adequate. The March 2002 IEP denied FAPE. It left him in large general education classes without enough help and gave no behavior, social-skills, or OT support. The March 2003 IEP offered FAPE except in two ways: it had no aide to support peer interaction, and its math goals were not measurable against present levels. The District must reimburse a private psychological evaluation and tutoring by Marilyn Reid and Haughton Learning Center. It must also pay for 280 hours of Lindamood-Bell instruction as compensatory education. It must assess OT, add aide time for social skills, and set compensatory OT at an IEP meeting. Reimbursement for two other private evaluations was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This case shows how SEHO set a child-find deadline once a teacher saw serious needs early in the year. It also shows the Hearing Officer treating an extra student study team meeting as an improper delay. Finally, it shows how a private reading program was funded as compensatory education even though it was not reimbursable as a substitute for the IEP offer.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailed in partChild find

    Issue 1. Did the District fail to fulfill its child-find obligation from the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year until Petitioner was identified as a child with disabilities on or about February 1, 2002?

    District should have referred the student for assessment by October 16, 2001 and had an IEP by December 20, 2001; the delayed December referral and 36-day student study team delay denied FAPE, but no violation at the very start of the school year.

  2. Student prevailed in partAssessment

    Issue 2. Did the District fail to assess the Petitioner in all areas related to his suspected disability?

    District failed to assess OT, social-emotional functioning, and behavior until the assessments done for the March 2003 IEP; its pragmatic language assessment was adequate and the Chapter 26.5 mental health assessment was appropriate.

  3. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. During the 2001-2002 school year, did the District fail to provide a FAPE to Petitioner?

    No services from December 20, 2001 to March 5, 2002, and the March 2002 IEP was not designed to meet needs for small-group instruction or aide support, remediation, behavior, social skills, and OT, so it denied FAPE; no speech-language need found.

  4. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 4. During the 2002-2003 school year, did the District fail to provide a FAPE to Petitioner?

    FAPE was denied until March 11, 2003 under the deficient March 2002 IEP; the March 2003 IEP offered FAPE except it lacked an aide to facilitate peer interaction and measurable math goals based on present levels.

  5. Issue 5. Are Petitioner's parents entitled to reimbursement from the District for the cost of the independent assessments conducted by Cathryn Ross, M.D., Daniel Peters, Ph.D., Marian Lane Diamond, Ph.D., and Lindamood-Bell?

    Dr. Peters' evaluation is reimbursed because the District had not assessed social-emotional needs; the Ross and Diamond evaluations were not based on disagreement with a District assessment; the Lindamood-Bell assessment depends on (and is paid as part of) the compensatory award.

  6. Issue 6. Are Petitioner's parents entitled to reimbursement from the District for the cost of remedial services provided by Marilyn Reid, Haughton Learning Center, and Lindamood-Bell?

    Tutoring by Marilyn Reid (December 20, 2001 until RSP began) and Haughton services are reimbursed; Lindamood-Bell is not reimbursed on a FAPE theory because the March 2003 IEP was largely appropriate.

  7. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 7. Is Petitioner entitled to an award of compensatory education and, if so, of what shall that award consist?

    Compensatory education awarded: 280 hours of Lindamood-Bell instruction, extra aide time for social-skills facilitation, and compensatory OT to be set by the IEP team after a new OT assessment.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Within 10 calendar days of receipt of proof, reimburse parents for the assessment by clinical psychologist Daniel Peters (order says conducted on or about June 17, 2002).
  • Reimbursement. Within 10 calendar days of receipt of proof, reimburse parents for tutoring by Marilyn Reid from December 20, 2001 to the day before RSP services began under the March 5, 2002 IEP, plus transportation at $.365 per mile.
  • Reimbursement. Within 10 calendar days of receipt of proof, reimburse parents for Haughton Learning Center services from December 20, 2001 to August 15, 2002, plus transportation at $.365 per mile.
  • Compensatory education. Within 10 calendar days of receipt of proof, reimburse parents for 280 hours of Lindamood-Bell services, the February 28, 2003 Lindamood-Bell assessment, and related transportation at $.365 per mile.
  • Order to assess. Before an IEP meeting within 30 calendar days of the start of the school year (order says '2003-3004', likely meaning 2003-2004), District must obtain an OT assessment by a qualified, licensed occupational therapist, with a written report advising on compensatory OT for the lack of OT from December 20, 2001 to February 18, 2003; report to go to parents and their attorney.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 30 calendar days after the start of the 2003-2004 school year, convene an IEP meeting to add measurable math goals and objectives based on stated present levels of performance, and to consider the OT report and agree on compensatory OT to be added to the IEP.
  • Compensatory education. Additional aide time sufficient for the aide to receive social skills training and consultation from the District's behavioral consultant and to spend two hours per week facilitating social interaction between the student and larger peer groups outside the general education classroom (duration not stated).

Total: 280 hours of compensatory services

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Seattle School Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Burlington; Florence County Sch. Dist. Four v. Carter; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Alamo Heights v. State Bd. of Educ.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.; M.C. v. Central Regional School Dist.; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. Missouri; Lachmann v. Illinois State Bd. of Educ.

People named in the decision

  • Sherrie Haycock, resource specialist, Napa Valley Unified School District
  • Kim Silacci, fifth-grade general education teacher, Brown's Valley Elementary School
  • Marilyn Reid, private tutor (District teacher), Private
  • Linda Barbour-Kambe, coordinator of special education, Napa Valley Unified School District
  • Lenore Hirsch, principal, Brown's Valley Elementary School
  • Elizabeth McCall Szporn, clinic director, private provider, Lindamood-Bell Learning Center, Corte Madera
  • Marian Lane Diamond, private psychologist (neuropsychological assessment), expert witness for Student, Private
  • Patricia Woichik, second-grade teacher, Brown's Valley Elementary School
  • Terry Shuster, behavior management specialist (behavior support plan), Napa Valley Unified School District
  • Sue Wortman, speech and language therapist/assessor, Napa Valley Unified School District
  • Laura Miller, director of special education, Napa Valley Unified School District
  • Tracey Weigand, behavior analyst, MSW (functional analysis assessment and BIP), District assessor
  • Gina Freeman, resource specialist, Napa Valley Unified School District
  • Donna Poninski, school psychologist, Napa Valley Unified School District
  • Linda Ibitz, Chapter 26.5 mental health assessor, Napa County Health and Human Services Agency
  • Alex Peters, fourth-grade general education teacher, Brown's Valley Elementary School
  • Mary Lucchese, school psychologist (2002 psychoeducational assessment), Napa Valley Unified School District
  • Jeanie Pennington, occupational therapy assessor, District assessor
  • Daniel Peters, private clinical psychologist (independent evaluation), Private
  • Cathryn Ross, developmental and behavioral pediatrician (private evaluation), Private
  • Gregory Matsumoto, private psychologist, Private
  • Del Domezio, private psychotherapist, Private
  • Haughton Learning Center, private tutoring provider, Private
  • Denise Tognolini, assistant to Student's counsel

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Napa, California, on May 8, 9, 13, 14, 15, and 16, 2003.

Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Margaret M. Broussard. Ms. Broussard was accompanied at times by her assistant Denise Tognolini. STUDENT’s parents, Mr. and Ms. PARENT, were also present.

Respondent Napa Valley Unified School District (Respondent or District) was represented at the hearing by the District’s general counsel, Sally Dutcher. The District was also represented at the hearing by Linda Barbour-Kambe, coordinator of special education, or Laura Miller, director of special education.

Petitioner called the following witnesses: Sherrie Haycock, a District resource specialist; Kim Silacci, STUDENT’s fifth-grade teacher; Marilyn Reid, a District teacher who provided private tutoring services to STUDENT; Linda Barbour-Kambe; Lenore Hirsch, principal of STUDENT’s school, Brown’s Valley Elementary School (BVES); Elizabeth McCall Szporn, clinic director of the Lindamood-Bell Learning Center (Lindamood-Bell) in Corte Madera, CA; Marian Lane Diamond, private psychologist; and Mr. and Ms. PARENT.

Respondent called the following witness: Patricia Woichik, STUDENT’s second-grade teacher; Terry Shuster, a District behavior management specialist; Sue Wortman, a District speech and language therapist; Laura Miller; Tracey Weigand, a behavior analyst; Gina Freeman, a District resource specialist; Donna Poninski, a District psychologist; Linda Ibitz, a Napa County Department of Mental Health assessor; and Sherrie Haycock. The oral and documentary evidence was presented at the hearing. Closing arguments of the parties were heard, and the record was closed, on May 20, 2003.

ISSUES .(footnote 1)

Issue No. 1: Did the District fail to fulfill its child-find obligation from the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year until Petitioner was identified as a child with disabilities on or about February 1, 2002?

Issue No. 2: Did the District fail to assess the Petitioner in all areas related to his suspected disability?

Issue No. 3: During the 2001-2002 school year, did the District fail to provide a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) to Petitioner?

Issue No. 4: During the 2002-2003 school year, did the District fail to provide a FAPE to Petitioner?

Issue No. 5: Are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement from the District for the cost of the independent assessments conducted by Cathryn Ross, M.D., Daniel Peters, Ph.D., Marian Lane Diamond, Ph.D., and Lindamood-Bell?

Issue No. 6: Are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement from the District for the cost of remedial services provided by Marilyn Reid, Haughton Learning Center, and Lindamood-Bell?

Issue No. 7: Is Petitioner entitled to an award of compensatory education and, if so, of what shall that award consist?

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

Prior to the admission of any evidence, the District made a motion to dismiss some of the Petitioner’s issues on the ground that he had failed to give the required ten days’ notice stating the specifics regarding his claims. The Petitioner opposed the motion, arguing that a statement of issues that was timely served adequately identified the issues.

The Hearing Officer denied the motion on the ground that the Petitioner had identified his issues with adequate specificity in a timely-served statement of issues.

BACKGROUND

STUDENT is ten years and eleven months old (DOB [date redacted]). He lives with his adoptive parents, Mr. and Ms. PARENT, and his younger brother BROTHER in Napa, California.

STUDENT came to live with the PARENT family as their foster child seven days after his birth. Both of STUDENT’s biological parents are said to have suffered from psychological problems. His mother was diagnosed with a personality disorder with prominent borderline schizotypal and paranoid features. His father was diagnosed with depression and a passive aggressive personality disorder. There were early reunification efforts, but those failed. The PARENTs had their own son, BROTHER, about a year after taking STUDENT in. STUDENT was approximately two and a half years old when the PARENTs adopted him.

STUDENT attended kindergarten in Ukiah, California during the 1997-1998 school year. His teacher thought that his language skills were lagging, but he seemed to do reasonably well otherwise.

STUDENT’s first grade year during 1998-1999 was at Brown’s Valley Elementary School (BVES) in the District, the school he still attends. His academic difficulties began to emerge during that year. He was in the Reading Recovery remedial program during some of that year, but was reported to be doing well. At the recommendation of his teacher he attended summer school to work on mastery of language arts and math skills that he would need to be successful in the second grade. It was later reported that STUDENT made no progress in summer school due in large part to behavior that interfered with his work. Before school started in the fall, Mr. and Ms. PARENT expressed their concern and asked that STUDENT be assessed and that an individualized education plan (IEP) meeting be convened.

The District convened a pupil study team (PST) meeting on September 7, 1999. The District declined to do a complete psychoeducational assessment. It was apparently the consensus, at least among the District team members, that STUDENT was simply unwilling to try new or difficult tasks.

Although STUDENT’s parents did not contest the PST’s decision not to assess STUDENT, they took him to be evaluated by psychologist Gregory Matsumoto on September 10, 1999. Dr. Matsumoto concluded that STUDENT was depressed and referred him to a physician for medication.

STUDENT’s difficulties at school continued in the second grade. STUDENT’s teacher, Ms. Woichik, spoke with Mr. and Ms. PARENT early in the year about STUDENT’s behavior. She was most concerned about what she viewed as STUDENT’s refusal to do the work. She changed his seat location and tried to redirect him. She used what she described as an assertive discipline system with graduated levels. All of these efforts met with little success. STUDENT’s parents were sufficiently concerned to again request a complete evaluation and an IEP on March 21, 2000.

STUDENT’s standardized testing and reporting (STAR) performance report dated April 2000 revealed that only two of his subtest scores were above the twenty-fifth percentile: vocabulary (36%) and reading comprehension (27%).

STUDENT underwent a psychoeducational assessment by the District in April and May 2000. Standardized testing indicated that STUDENT was of high-average intelligence with verbal, performance, and full-scale intelligence quotient (IQ) scores of 112, 110, and 112, respectively on the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-III (WISC-III). There was no severe discrepancy between any of his IQ scores and his achievement scores on the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT). .(footnote 2) A speech and language assessment was within normal limits.

On May 23, 2000, the IEP team, including Mr. and Ms. PARENT, agreed that STUDENT did not qualify for special education and related services under the category of specific learning disability (SLD). The minutes of the meeting state that STUDENT was performing at grade level in all areas and that there was no evidence of an SLD. There was no documented discussion of STUDENT’s performance on the SAT-9. Other eligibility categories were not seriously considered at that time.

STUDENT did not attend a District school for the third grade during the 2000-2001 school year. He attended the Napa Charter School (NCS), which uses Waldorf methodologies. .(footnote 3) It was during this school year that STUDENT’s parents told him that he was adopted. No one from the school testified at the hearing. However, the records indicate that, although STUDENT received two hours of tutoring per week during the school year, he did not perform well that year and that, if anything, his learning difficulties were getting worse. The STAR performance report April 2001 revealed no score in any subtest over the twelfth percentile. The PARENTs were not pleased with how STUDENT did at NCS. They planned to return him to BVES for the fourth grade in the fall of 2001.

STUDENT began working with Marilyn Reid as a tutor and with Del Domezio as a psychotherapist during the summer of 2001. Ms. Reid was aware of his SAT-9 scores but believed that his reading level was appropriate, with only some weakness in comprehension. She was mainly concerned about math and about the frustration and anger that STUDENT displayed. Ms. Reid specifically asked the principal at BVES, Ms. Hirsch, to place STUDENT in the fourth-grade, general education class taught by Alex Peters because she believed that he would be able to correct some of the difficulties that STUDENT was having. .(footnote 4) No one, including STUDENT’s parents, Ms. Reid and Mr. Domezio, suggested that STUDENT be considered or assessed for special education.

As requested, STUDENT was enrolled in Mr. Peters’ fourth grade class at BVES for the 2001-2002 school year. From the beginning of the school year, Mr. Peters recognized that STUDENT was having great difficulty. He was performing below grade level in math, spelling and writing. Reading fluency was about at grade level and reading comprehension was a little lower. Behavior was also a problem. Organization and neatness were, in Mr. Peters’ view, serious deficits, but STUDENT also had difficulties completing his work and participating in class and was often off task and not following instructions.

Ms. PARENT testified that she asked Ms. Hirsch to provide some help to STUDENT and that Ms. Hirsch said that the school could not provide help but suggested that the PARENTs could get help from a private organization, such as Haughton. STUDENT was assessed by Haughton on November 28, 2001, and began receiving academic assistance a short time later. STUDENT stopped tutoring with Ms. Reid about that same time.

Mr. Peters tried for months to address STUDENT’s needs through modifications of the regular instructional program. Finally, on December 10, 2001, he referred STUDENT to a student study team (SST). On the referral forms, Mr. Peters indicated that STUDENT was performing at or below second grade level for math, spelling and writing. He also reported that STUDENT was below grade level in oral language, fine and gross motor skills, following directions, adaptive behavior, peer relationships, and response to authority. The referral stated that all appropriate interventions had been tried without success. Mr. Peters attached a copy of the STAR performance report from April 2000. .(footnote 5)

Dr. Cathryn Ross, a specialist in developmental and behavioral pediatrics, evaluated STUDENT two days after the SST referral at the request of Ms. PARENT, who believed that the Haughton assessment did not address STUDENT’s possible needs in the areas of behavior, attention, and fatigue. .(footnote 6) Dr. Ross administered the Pediatric Examination of Educational Readiness at Middle Childhood 2 and concluded that STUDENT probably did not have a significant SLD. She believed that his academic difficulties were most likely the result of a combination of depression, anxiety, and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) – inattentive type. She also believed that STUDENT’s dysgraphia was caused by a developmental coordination disorder. Dr. Ross recommended ADHD medication, continued therapy to deal with his depression and anxiety, continued tutoring to help STUDENT to catch up academically, and adaptations and accommodations within the classroom, including the use of a tape recorder and word processor and allowing additional time for written assignments.

The SST met on January 15, 2002. Ms. Haycock had by then already administered the Jordan Left Right Reversal Test (JLRRT) and the written language subtest of the WIAT. On the JLRRT STUDENT was unable to identify ninety-seven percent of the letters that were written incorrectly. His writing sample was scored at the eighteenth percentile for his age. Ms. Haycock speculated that poor concentration due to ADHD and/or depression was the cause. The SST referred STUDENT for another full psychoeducational assessment.

The District’s psychological assessment conducted by Mary Lucchese on or about January 29, 2002, produced a composite IQ from the Stanford-Binet, 4th Edition (SB-4) of 96, sixteen points lower than when measured by the WISC-III less than two years earlier. .(footnote 7) The Test of Visual-Motor Integration (VMI) produced a score of 81. Ms. Lucchese concluded that STUDENT’s strengths were in the areas of verbal expression and comprehension and short-term memory. His weaknesses were in the areas of visual and sensory fine motor skill processing and quantitative reasoning. The projective Sentence Completion and Three Wishes tests were also administered. No particular conclusions were drawn from the results of these tests. Ms. Lucchese recommended accommodations, leaving it to the IEP team to determine an appropriate educational program.

Sherrie Haycock handled the educational component of the District’s assessment by administering the WIAT again. This time, STUDENT’s scores were consistently lower than they were in April 2000, with the subtest scores ranging from a low of 85 in spelling to a high of 109 in listening comprehension. These same scores were 96 and 128, respectively, in the prior year’s results. Ms. Haycock recommended that STUDENT receive resource specialist program (RSP) services to build skills in reading comprehension, math, and written language.

The speech and language component was administered by Sue Wortman, who administered the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test (PPVT), the Expressive Vocabulary Test (EVT), the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals (CELF), and the Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills (TAPS). .(footnote 8) She concluded that STUDENT had no speech and language needs. .(footnote 9)

At an IEP meeting on March 5, 2002, STUDENT was found eligible for special education under the category of SLD. .(footnote 10) The placement agreed upon by all team members, including the parent, was RSP services. STUDENT would receive remedial assistance in written language and math in Sherrie Haycock’s resource room for sixty to ninety minutes three to five times per week. No behavioral, mental health, or OT services were provided. .(footnote 11) Eighty percent of STUDENT’s school day was to be spent with his regular class. No extended school year (ESY) services were offered.

There was one goal each for language arts and math: to improve STUDENT’s skills. The language arts goal was broken down by short-term objectives addressing spelling, reading, and writing skills. The math goal was broken down to short-term objectives addressing basic math skills, including multi-digit multiplication and division and rounding whole numbers up to the seventh digit (millions), solving word problems and demonstration of general math competency through weekly or chapter tests.

According to Mr. Peters, STUDENT did show some improvement in the third trimester of his fourth-grade year, although he remained below grade-level. Math and written expression continued to be particularly difficult. STUDENT’s behavior had also improved. His third trimester report states that he was performing satisfactorily in all academic areas except math and that his behavior was improving, although still not satisfactory. STUDENT’s STAR performance report for the fourth grade showed significant gains. STUDENT remained below the fiftieth percentile in all subtests except vocabulary (64%) and math problem solving (60%), but only three of the scores were below the twenty-fifth percentile: math procedures (23%), language expression (22%), and spelling (9%). Most of the remaining scores were between the thirty-seventh and forty-seventh percentiles.

Clinical psychologist Daniel Peters, Ph.D., evaluated STUDENT in May and June 2002. He did not testify, but his report is in evidence. The report reveals that Mr. Domezio and the PARENTs referred STUDENT for assessment because they wanted a better understanding of STUDENT’s social-emotional functioning. Dr. Peters reviewed records and administered a series of projective tests. He concluded that STUDENT was significantly depressed and suffered from chronic anxiety. He believed that STUDENT had a delayed ability to connect with people, attention problem, and sensory-motor deficits. The doctor acknowledged the indication that STUDENT was not learning as he should but was not sure of the cause of this problem. He was not convinced that ADHD was the problem. He recommended that the depression first be addressed, since that could have accounted for some of the difficulties with attention. Dr. Peters was concerned that the medications STUDENT was taking were not be working. He recommended that this be reviewed and that the counseling with Mr. Domezio continue and that it include a family component. He also suggested occupational therapy (OT), perhaps with a sensory-motor integration component to help with pencil-to-paper tasks. Dr. Peters’ opinion was that it was too soon to conclude that the resource services were inadequate to address STUDENT’s needs at school. He suggested that if STUDENT did not show signs of rebounding in the fifth grade, a special day class (SDC) might be considered.

STUDENT continued his work at Haughton over the summer of 2002. He entered Ms. Silacci’s fifth-grade class at BVES in the fall. Almost immediately after school began, Ms. Silacci and other school staff became concerned about STUDENT’s behavior. He was writing all over his backpack, drawing pictures filled with violent images, talking to himself loudly in class, and giggling and laughing uncontrollably for no apparent reason. These disruptions were happening frequently, as often as six times during the day. He almost never did his work. None of Ms. Silacci’s efforts to deal with these maladaptive behaviors worked.

Eventually, Terry Shuster, a District behavior specialist, got involved at the request of Ms. Hirsch and Del Domezio to develop a behavior support plan (BSP) that was to be used by the teacher to more effectively address the behaviors. Mr. Shuster conducted an observation in late September and prepared a written BSP dated October 2, 2002. Among the recommended strategies were increased one-to-one time for STUDENT and teacher/staff, various accommodations to help him to understand directions and complete assignments, and time away from class when his disruptive behavior was not otherwise manageable. .(footnote 12) The plan specifically stated that it was “for teacher use only.” STUDENT’s parents were not involved in the development of the plan and were not even aware of the behavior plan until the next IEP meeting was convened on October 22, 2002.

The October 22, 2002 IEP meeting was called to consider a supplement to the existing IEP from the previous March to address the increasing negative behaviors and the lack of expected progress, among other things. For the first time, an attorney, Ms. Broussard, accompanied the PARENTs. The team agreed that a mental health referral pursuant to Chapter 26.5 of the California Government Code was appropriate. .(footnote 13) The parents consented to the referral and associated assessments. Additional matters were to be considered at a continued meeting one week later. This postponement was, at least in part, to accommodate the District’s desire to also have it’s own attorney present when Ms. Broussard presented her views.

The meeting reconvened on October 29, 2002. There was much discussion about the parents’ concerns, particularly regarding STUDENT’s interfering behaviors and poor academic progress, but also about his possible pragmatic language, fine motor, and sensory needs. It was agreed at this meeting that the District would conduct a functional analysis assessment (FAA) of STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors, a pragmatic language assessment, and an OT assessment before the team reconvened on January 14, 2003. Mr. and Mrs. PARENT requested that a shadow aide be assigned to work with STUDENT in the meantime.

As a result of the October 29, 2002 meeting, changes were made to the face of the March 5, 2002 IEP document. It was changed to indicate that STUDENT’s behavior was impeding his learning. A reference to the BSP and the referral for an FAA was added. The service plan was also changed to clarify that STUDENT’s resource time would consist of seven to eight forty-minute small group sessions per two weeks and three to four forty-five-minute small-group or individual sessions per week. There was no change made referencing the assignment of an aide. However, on November 26, 2002, Ms. PARENT authorized the implementation of part-time aide services. There are other references in the record to an aide being assigned by December, but neither party provided specific details regarding this service.

In a supplemental educational assessment in November and December 2002, Sherrie Haycock attempted to update STUDENT’s present levels of performance through classroom observation, teacher’s tests, diagnostic reading scales, a writing sample and other data. Ms. Haycock did not consider the results to be a particularly reliable measure of STUDENT’s skill levels in the various areas because his performance was, in her opinion, so erratic due to his fluctuating emotional state.

STUDENT underwent an OT assessment by Jeanie Pennington. .(footnote 14) She administered the Bruininks-Oseretsky Test of Motor Proficiency and conducted a clinical evaluation and concluded that STUDENT had difficulties with cutting and using writing tools due to poor posture, upper extremity stability, and coordination. She predicted difficulty changing long-established patterns but recommended a trial of OT interventions during weekly sessions of thirty to forty-five minutes and one to two hours of consultation monthly. Classroom accommodations, including an angled writing surface and a seat cushion to improve posture, were suggested. She also recommended that keyboarding be considered as an alternative to writing.

Sue Wortman did an assessment of STUDENT’s pragmatic language skills in December 2002. STUDENT achieved a pragmatic language quotient of 109, which was at the seventy-third percentile. Ms. Wortman found no evidence of a pragmatic language deficit.

The FAA was done in December 2002 and January 2003 by Tracey Weigand, MSW. Ms. Weigand reviewed documents and observed STUDENT at school, collecting data for analysis. It was her understanding that the severely disruptive behaviors had improved since implementation of Mr. Shuster’s behavior plan. However, STUDENT’s behaviors continued to interfere with his learning. Ms Weigand observed that STUDENT attended and remained on task seventy-five percent of the time in Ms. Haycock’s resource room but only twenty-five percent of the time in the general education classroom. Ms Weigand also observed that STUDENT engaged in behaviors, such as talking to himself, that tended to alienate many of his peers and discouraged social interaction. Although STUDENT was seen interacting with a small group of three or four friends, Ms. Weigand believed that he preferred isolation. It seemed to reduce some of his social anxiety. On the basis of the FAA, Ms. Weigand developed a behavioral intervention plan (BIP). The BIP focused on STUDENT’s attention to task and work completion in his general education class and on reducing behaviors that were believed to interfere with peer socialization.

On the basis of their own research and inquiries, Petitioner’s parents began to suspect that STUDENT might be autistic. In pursuit of that suspicion, they brought STUDENT to Marian Lane Diamond, Ph.D. Dr. Diamond conducted a neuropsychological assessment of STUDENT between November 27, 2002 and January 8, 2003. She reviewed STUDENT’s medical and educational records and administered a number of standardized tests, including the WISC-III, the WIAT-II, the Gray Oral Reading Test (GORT), and various neuropsychological tests. Dr. Diamond testified that in her opinion STUDENT is a high-functioning child with a pervasive developmental disorder (PDD), not otherwise specified (NOS).

It is Dr. Diamond’s opinion that although STUDENT is bright, he should be in a small class that is staffed by people who are trained to work with children with PDD. She also recommends that STUDENT have a full-time aide knowledgeable about PDD. In her opinion, because STUDENT lacks the basic skills in reading, written expression, and math calculation as well as adequate social and pragmatic language skills, he needs an intensive program that focuses on the development of social skills, communication and academic remediation. Dr. Diamond specifically recommends the Lindamood-Bell programs. She also believes that STUDENT should receive continued individual psychotherapy, the use of a clear and detailed daily schedule, and keyboard practice.

Linda Ibitz, a licensed mental health counselor for the Health and Human Services Agency for the County of Napa conducted the Chapter 26.5 mental health assessment of STUDENT. The date of the actual assessment is not known, but her report was dated January 14, 2003. She also testified at the hearing. Ms. Ibitz reviewed the earlier assessment reports of Drs. Matsumoto, Peters and Ross, and Ms. Lucchese, as well as the prior IEPs. She interviewed Ms. PARENT and spoke with Mr. Domezio. She also interviewed STUDENT and observed him at school.

It was Ms. Ibitz’s impression that STUDENT was intelligent, but there are many factors interfering with his learning. Those included a mood disorder, anxiety, and low self esteem. STUDENT stated that he did not feel loved by his family. His social awkwardness and odd behaviors tended to alienate his peers. Ms. Ibitz believed that as the demands of social interaction and relationships became more complex, STUDENT’s difficulties in this area became more problematic. Poor coping skills aggravated the situation, sometimes causing STUDENT to react with anger and, at times, aggression, leading to arguments with family or peers, temper tantrums, defiance, artwork with violent content, or other conduct problems. Ms. Ibitz was of the opinion that a general education placement continued to be appropriate. However, she predicted that a more restrictive placement in an SDC for emotionally disturbed students might be required when STUDENT entered adolescence. She recommended that he receive case management and continue individual and family-based counseling services and medication as appropriate. She stated that the services of a cognitive therapist would be appropriate.

Ms. Haycock again attempted to update STUDENT’s present level of performance on February 7, 2003. She believed that STUDENT had made less than expected progress in math. He was able to read 5.5 grade-level passages fluently and with eighty percent comprehension. He was less successful reading 6.5 grade-level passages due to the unfamiliarity of some of the words. He also would not take the time to decode words that he did not recognize. STUDENT continued to have difficulties with spelling and written expression. In spite of his limited progress, Ms. Haycock had seen a change in STUDENT’s performance at school since he returned from the winter break. It seemed to her that he was more willing to persevere when asked to do a difficult academic task. .(footnote 15)

The IEP team met again on February 18, 2003. .(footnote 16) The reports of the assessments since the last IEP were presented. It was agreed that there would be further discussion of Dr. Diamond’s findings and recommendations at a continued meeting on February 25, 2003. The team was to prepare draft goals and objectives and present them to the parents and their attorney for review. An addendum to the March 2002 IEP was prepared. It offered to add mental health and OT services as recommended by the assessors. STUDENT’s parents did not agree to the addendum.

The IEP team last met prior to the hearing on March 11, 2003 to further discuss addenda to the February 2003 plan. STUDENT’s eligibility was still based on an SLD resulting from deficits in visual processing and sensory-motor skills that caused weaknesses in reading comprehension, written expression and math. The District recommended placement in the general education classroom for English, social studies, science, music, and physical education (PE). It also offered RSP in language arts and math for two to two and one-half hours four to five days per week, behavioral consultation services three to four hours per month, individual OT for thirty to forty-five minutes weekly, OT consultation for one to two hours per month, a one-to-one instructional aide for two and one-half to three hours per day, and Chapter 26.5 mental health services consisting of individual therapy one hour per week and case management services two to four hours per month. The decision on STUDENT’s entitlement to ESY was deferred to a later meeting.

Behavior goals were developed based on the recommendations of Tracey Weigand. General mental health goals that overlapped somewhat with the behavior goals were also developed. The team expected the counselor, Del Domezio, to develop more specific mental health goals, but he was not at the meeting, possibly because his services had been terminated by the PARENTs. There were four OT goals addressing body mechanics, keyboard use, and self-regulation. There were three language arts goals that addressed reading and written expression, and four math goals. Dr. Diamond suggested that there be a goal to develop better decoding skills. Ms. Haycock agreed to test STUDENT for a baseline, but no goal was developed at the meeting. Ms. Broussard requested goals to address the basic math skills, such as multiplication facts, that appeared to be missing from STUDENT’s repertoire. Mr. and Ms. PARENT wanted STUDENT to attend Lindamood-Bell.

STUDENT’s parents did not agree to the offered IEP at the meeting, but they eventually agreed that STUDENT could attend the RSP for math and receive the mental health services. However, his participation in the RSP has been limited due to his attendance at Lindamood-Bell.

On March 21, 2003, the PARENT’s attorney gave formal notice that STUDENT would be attending Lindamood-Bell, and they would be seeking reimbursement from the District for the cost of that service. On that same day, Ms. Broussard requested that the hearing in this matter be placed back on the calendar from which it had been removed months earlier by agreement of the parties. STUDENT started Lindamood-Bell services on April 7, 2003. At the time of the hearing, STUDENT attended the Lindamood-Bell program in the mornings, returning to school around 11:30 a.m. He was then able to participate in one hour and fifteen minutes of RSP, lunch and general education for the remainder of the day. He is expected to participate in a more intense Lindamood-Bell summer program and complete his four-hundred-hour scheduled remediation by the beginning of sixth grade.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue No. 1: Did the District fail to fulfill its child-find obligation from the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year until Petitioner was identified as a child with disabilities on or about February 1, 2002?

The Petitioner alleges that the District knew or should have known that he was a child with suspected disabilities and in need of assessment for special education before the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year. He contends that the District should immediately have identified STUDENT as a child with a suspected specific learning disability (SLD), emotional disability (ED), and/or pervasive developmental disorder (PDD). This suspicion should have led to a prompt assessment in these areas at the start of the 2001-2002 school year. .(footnote 17) The District asserts that it had assessed STUDENT for special education just more than a year before he entered the fourth grade and that the IEP team, including STUDENT’s parents, agreed that he did not qualify for special education at that time. The District argues that, based upon information that it had at the start of the 2001-2002 school year, it was not compelled to again assess Petitioner until Mr. Peters initiated the referral process on December 10, 2001.

The federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), as amended in 1997, and State law impose upon each school district the duty actively and systematically to identify, locate, and assess all children with disabilities who require special education and related services. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(3) (formerly 20 U.S.C. § 1412(2)(C)); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56300, 56301. Under State law, the school district must establish written policies and procedures for a continuous child-find system. Cal. Educ. Code § 56301. Identification procedures shall include systematic methods of referrals of students by teachers, parents, agencies, professional persons, and members of the public, and those procedures must be coordinated with school site referral procedures for students with needs that cannot be met with modification of the regular instructional program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56302. A referral for assessment means any written request for assessment made by a parent, teacher, or other service provider. Cal. Educ. Code § 56029. All referrals for special education and related services shall initiate the assessment process and shall be documented. Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3021(a). Referrals by school staff must state the reason for the referral and contain documentation of the resources of the regular education program that have been considered. However, such documentation must not delay the assessment process. Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3021(b). The obligation set forth in this statutory and regulatory scheme is often referred to as the “child-find” obligation. .(footnote 18) The District did identify STUDENT as a child with a suspected SLD in the spring of 2000. On the basis of the assessment data available at the time, the IEP team, including Mr. and Ms. PARENT, agreed that STUDENT was ineligible for special education under the category SLD. The Petitioner has not since sought to contest the issue of STUDENT’s eligibility for special education before the 2001-2002 school year. In the context of the issues presented for determination here, the Hearing Officer is primarily concerned with whether or not the District was aware of facts warranting another look at the eligibility issue.

Ms. Reid, an experienced teacher, informed Ms. Hirsch that STUDENT had made little progress at NCS and that she was working with him primarily on third-grade-level math skills that he had not learned the previous school year. Ms. Reid specifically requested that STUDENT be placed in Mr. Peters’ class and explained her reasons, including her belief that Mr. Peters could give STUDENT appropriate structure with high expectations and the academic and emotional care and attention that STUDENT needed. Ms. Reid did not suggest that STUDENT be considered for special education. She testified that she did not think it was appropriate to talk to the District about special education at that time. Both Ms. Reid and Mr. Domezio expressed their belief that Mr. Peters could help STUDENT succeed. Neither did STUDENT’s parents request another assessment of their son.

The information that was available to the District concerning STUDENT’s eligibility for special education at the start of the 2001-2002 school year did not compel it to assess him again at that time. He had been found ineligible near the end of his last year of attendance at BVES and had been attending a Waldorf-method school during the intervening year. .(footnote 19) Neither Ms. Reid nor Mr. Domezio, both of whom had more current knowledge regarding STUDENT than the District had, suggested that special education should be considered immediately. Although Mr. Peter’s was concerned about STUDENT’s academic performance and behavior early in the year, he did not refer STUDENT for special education before he tried modifications and accommodations in his classroom that might have allowed STUDENT to progress in the general curriculum. Mr. Peters’ efforts to first attempt to address STUDENT’s needs with general education resources were consistent with the law. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56026(b), 56302, and 56303. However, the District eventually had reason to suspect a disability for which assessment was warranted. The question is how long that discovery should have taken.

Ms. Reid wrote to the principal, Lenore Hirsch, in August 2001. Ms. PARENT spoke with Mr. Peters about her son’s problems at the beginning of the school year. There was no evidence to show when the District first received information from NCS regarding STUDENT’s dismal third-grade year, but it certainly should have had that information within six weeks after school began. Mr. Peters testified that he recognized very early that STUDENT might need more than the general education resources could offer him. Within eight weeks, Mr. Peters was concerned that STUDENT lacked the basic skills that he needed to progress in the fourth-grade curriculum. The efforts of Mr. Domezio and Ms. Reid notwithstanding, Mr. Peters realized early in the school year that STUDENT had not yet mastered third-grade math concepts and was simply not learning what Mr. Peters was trying to teach him. In addition to his poor academic skills, his disorganization and weak fine motor skills were also apparent to Mr. Peters.

It should not have taken until December 10, 2001, over three months after school started, for STUDENT to be formally referred for assessment. There was no explanation offered for the delay. The Hearing Officer finds that the District had adequate information regarding STUDENT’s difficulties, by the time it should have received the his student records from NCS six weeks after the school year began, or by October 16, 2001. The District should have referred STUDENT for a special education assessment by that time.

Even when the referral finally took place in December, there was another delay of thirty-six days for the SST meeting. The District did not show why that meeting was necessary. It was the District’s obligation to provide appropriate procedures for the fulfillment of its child-find obligation. Those procedures must include systematic methods of utilizing referrals of students from parents, teachers, and others. Cal. Educ. Code § 56302. Although it might be appropriate for a school district to schedule a meeting, such as an SST, to provide the parents an opportunity to participate in the process of identification and assessment, as provided in Cal. Educ. Code section 56304, the law does not require that additional step and in practice prohibits it if it serves only to delay a referral. Under the circumstances presented here, a referral by October 16, 2001 should have immediately initiated the assessment process. Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3021. The SST referral completed by Mr. Peters contained the information required by Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3021(b). If the District believed an SST meeting was required, it was incumbent on it to convene that meeting within the fifteen days allowed for delivery of an assessment plan to the parents. Cal. Educ. Code § 56321. Had that been done in this case, the assessment plan would have been timely presented and promptly signed. The ultimate result of these delays was that STUDENT’s fourth-grade year was almost over by the time he received any of the required services.

The District was informed just before the school year began that STUDENT was in need of academic tutoring and psychotherapy. It should have had in its possession all of STUDENT’s records from NCS within six weeks. Within the first six to eight weeks of school, STUDENT’s teacher recognized serious academic and behavioral needs. This information should have caused the District to identify STUDENT as a child with a suspected disability that was potentially impeding his learning within six weeks of the start of the 2001-2002 school year, or by October 16, 2001. That suspicion of a disability should have resulted in an immediate referral for assessment. Cal. Educ. Code § 56302. Pursuant to the District’s procedures, the assessment plan should have been delivered to the parents at an SST meeting on or before October 31, 2001. The plan would have been signed at that meeting, and the IEP would have been developed on or before December 20, 2001. Instead, the IEP was not developed until March 5, 2002, seventy-five days later. STUDENT was more than halfway through his fourth-grade year before services were provided. The law does not tolerate such delay. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to conduct appropriate child-find for STUDENT, thereby denying him a FAPE. Issue No. 2: Did the District fail to assess the Petitioner in all areas related to his suspected disability?

Petitioner alleges that the District failed to assess him in all areas related to his suspected disability. He alleges that he should have been assessed in the areas of pragmatic language, OT, and social-emotional functioning. .(footnote 20) Petitioner also alleges that it was or should have been clear to the District that STUDENT required more than consideration of his disruptive behavior in the planning process. He contends that an FAA and BIP were required. The District denies these allegations and asserts that it fulfilled its responsibility to assess the Petitioner.

The law requires that a student be assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability. If appropriate, assessment must include language function, motor abilities, and social, emotional, and communicative status. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f). The purpose of the assessment is to gather all relevant information that will assist the IEP team to identify the student as a child with a disability and to provide the team with the information it will need to develop an appropriate individualized education plan. 20 U.S.C. § 1414 (b)(2)(A). Another of the factors that must be considered by the IEP team when developing the plan for the student is whether the student engages in behaviors that impede his or her learning or the learning of others. If there are such behaviors, the team must, when appropriate, consider appropriate strategies, including positive behavioral interventions, strategies and supports to address the behavior. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.1(b)(1).

If the IEP team determines that the instructional or behavioral approaches specified in the student’s IEP have been ineffective, an FAA is required. Cal. Code of Regs., tit. 5, § 3052(b). The FAA must be conducted by or under the direction of a person who has documented training in positive behavior intervention. Id. If the student exhibits a serious behavior problem that significantly interferes with the implementation of the goals and objectives of his or her IEP, a behavior intervention plan (BIP) is developed and becomes part of the IEP. Cal. Code of Regs., tit. 5, § 3001(f). A “serious behavior problem” refers to behaviors that are self-injurious, assaultive, or cause serious property damage and other severe behavior problems that are pervasive and maladaptive. Cal. Code of Regs., tit. 5, § 3001(aa). The BIP is based upon the FAA. Cal. Code of Regs., tit. 5, § 3052(a). It is to include specific information about the targeted behaviors, goals and objectives specific to the BIP, and other information. Cal. Code of Regs., tit. 5, § 3001(f). Once the BIP is developed, a copy of the BIP is to be given not only to the parents, but also to all persons responsible for its implementation in the student’s educational and noneducational environments so it can be effectively implemented in a consistent manner across those environments. Id.

Pragmatic Language

It does not appear from the record that anyone had a particular concern or suspicion at the time that STUDENT had needs in the area of pragmatic language. It was not listed as a concern of any of STUDENT’s teachers or parents at the time. .(footnote 21) No one requested that a test of pragmatic language be done. Sue Wortman conducted the speech and language assessment for the District in January 2002. The assessment did not include a standardized test of pragmatic language. However, it did include an observation of how STUDENT conversed with the assessor. Ms. Wortman concluded from that observation that STUDENT conversed easily with good pragmatic language skills.

At the Petitioner’s request, Ms. Wortman conducted another assessment in January 2003. This one was specifically for pragmatic language and included the standardized Test of Pragmatic Language. The results were consistent with the earlier assessment. The Petitioner contends that the assessment is still inadequate because it has not been adequately focused on STUDENT’s pragmatic language skills in social settings. The Petitioner offered no opinion from a speech and language therapist. He offered Dr. Diamond’s recommendation as evidence of the need for a more thorough assessment. The Hearing Officer found the Petitioner’s evidence on this question unpersuasive. The evidence establishes that the District adequately assessed STUDENT in the area of pragmatic language.

Occupational Therapy

Ms. PARENT testified credibly that STUDENT has had problems with fine motor skills and “pencil-to-paper” tasks at least since first grade. His first grade teacher agreed that this was an area of need at that time. His second-grade teacher agreed that STUDENT had a hard time with written language. The evidence that STUDENT’s problems with writing continued was basically unopposed. Mr. Peters’ SST referral even stated that fine motor was an area of need for STUDENT who in fourth grade could still not color within the lines and had difficulty with cutting, pasting, coloring, and writing activities. Mr. Peters goes on to describe STUDENT’s writing as messy, with letters colliding and no space between words. When Ms. Lucchese tested STUDENT’s visual-motor skills in 2001, she also found that visual and sensory fine-motor skill processing was an area of need for him. This evidence establishes that the District had reason to suspect that STUDENT had a disability that caused him to have OT needs. .(footnote 22)

The District did not conduct an OT assessment during the 2001-2002 school year. It did not offer any evidence to show why an OT assessment was not done or to establish that one was not necessary. An OT assessment was done in December or January 2003 to prepare for the March 2003 IEP meeting. The Petitioner agrees that the assessment was appropriate.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to conduct a required OT assessment in preparation for the IEP meeting in March 2002 and that the failure continued until January 2003. Social-emotional Functioning

There was abundant information known to the District that suggested that STUDENT might have had a disability that affected his social-emotional functioning at the time of Mr. Peters’ referral. Maladaptive behaviors began to interfere with his learning in 1999 and continued thereafter. There had been a long-standing diagnosis of depression for which STUDENT had taking medication for over two years. There had long been violent content to his drawings. STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors did not respond to Ms. Woicik’s discipline or to any of the interventions tried by Mr. Peters. He was not learning in spite of the extra assistance he was getting from Ms. Reid and Haughton and the District was unable to explain the reason except lack of motivation.

It may have been significant that STUDENT’s parents had told him that he was adopted during the previous year. STUDENT’s reaction to this information may have contributed to his problems with anger, frustration, and self-esteem that Ms. Reid had told Ms. Hirsch about before the school year began. The District was aware that STUDENT had been in therapy with Del Domezio since the summer of 2001, but even that was not helping him with his school work. Mr. Peters informed the SST team that STUDENT could not think in an orderly and logical manner and was subtly anxious. Sherrie Haycock’s told the SST that ADD and/or depression may have been responsible for many of STUDENT’s problems.

The District should have suspected a social-emotional component to STUDENT’s difficulties with education. The assessment should have included an evaluation of his social-emotional functioning. The social-emotional component appears to have consisted of only two projective tests: the Sentence Completion Test and the Three Wishes Test. These projective tests might be useful as screening tests to provide some general information, but in this case, where there was information that suggested the strong possibility of social-emotional needs, they were not enough. Judging from Ms. Lucchese’s report of her assessment, these tests were not sufficient to allow her to draw any useful conclusions or make any specific recommendation. .(footnote 23) Her discussion of the test results strongly suggests that she had little if any appreciation of the potential role of social-emotional factors in STUDENT’s learning difficulties. The evidence overwhelmingly establishes that the District did not appropriately assess STUDENT’s needs in the area of social emotional functioning prior to STUDENT’s referral for a Chapter 26.5 assessment almost a year after Mr. Peter’s SST referral.

The IEP team agreed to a Chapter 26.5 referral on October 22, 2002. The assessment was completed in mid-January, 2003. The Petitioner contends that neither the District’s assessments nor the Chapter 26.5 assessment by Ms. Ibitz constitutes an appropriate evaluation of STUDENT’s social-emotional functioning. Although Petitioner did not clearly argue the point, the basis of the disagreement appears to be Dr. Diamond’s diagnosis that STUDENT has a PDD-NOS. The District defends the Chapter 26.5 assessment as an appropriate inquiry into STUDENT’s social-emotional needs. Ms. Ibitz is an experienced mental health case manager for Napa County. She conducts approximately forty mental health assessments under Chapter 26.5 annually. In STUDENT’s case, the assessment included a review of the prior reports of Drs. Matsumoto, Peters, and Ross, as well as the District’s psychoeducational assessments and STUDENT’s IEP documents. She interviewed STUDENT and his mother, spoke with Del Domezio, and observed STUDENT at school. She also administered the Achenbach Teacher Report Form and the Child Behavior Checklist. On the basis of information gathered, Ms. Ibitz concluded that STUDENT had some kind of mood disorder, with anxiety and low self-esteem complicating the picture. She also believed that STUDENT’s family relationships, or at least how he viewed those relationships, was a contributing factor. Ms. Ibitz testified that she was particularly impressed with the assessment and report by Dr. Peters, who wrote of the same kind of rigidness that she herself observed. The Hearing Officer found Ms. Ibitz to be an objective and credible witness. He conclusions were consistent with the evaluations of other experts, with the exception of Dr. Diamond. This evidence established that the District’s Chapter 26.5 assessment was appropriate.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT’s social-emotional functioning until the Chapter 26.5 assessment was conducted by Ms. Ibitz and that the Chapter 26.5 assessment was appropriate.

Behavior

The evidence showed that STUDENT had a consistent history of behavior that interfered with his learning and the learning of his classmates. It started in first grade and was so pervasive when STUDENT was in summer school in 1999 that he made no progress toward achieving the academic skills that he had not learned during the regular school year. In second grade he would wander around the classroom when he was supposed to be working. At times he would play with toys or otherwise occupy himself rather than do his work.

This avoidance behavior was not unlike the testing behavior STUDENT displayed. Both Ms. Woicik and Dr. Matsumoto may have believed or at least suspected that STUDENT’s conduct was entirely volitional. However, intentional disruptive behavior is no less in need of effective intervention. Nothing in the law suggests that the obligation of an LEA to address behavior that interferes with education depends on whether or not it is intentional. The maladaptive behaviors, particularly avoidance, continued in Mr. Peters’ class.

No behavioral assessment was done by the District to prepare for the March 2002 IEP meeting. The IEP created at that meeting states that STUDENT’s behavior was not impeding his or his classmates’ learning. Ms. Barbour-Kambe, who filled out much of the IEP document, did not recall checking the “No” box in that section, but it is clear that it was checked at the time. That information was not correct. STUDENT’s behaviors did interfere with his learning. Those maladaptive behaviors should have been addressed by appropriate behavioral intervention. It was not until the following October that the District enlisted the aid of Terry Shuster, who conducted an observation and prepared a BSP. Although this plan appeared to some to have a positive effect, it was finally determined that an FAA was necessary. Ms. Weigand conducted that assessment in late February 2003. The Petitioner agrees that the FAA was appropriate. The Hearing Officer finds that until that FAA was completed, the District had failed to conduct an appropriate and required behavior assessment.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to appropriately assess the Petitioner in the areas of OT, social-emotional functioning, and behavior until those assessments were conducted in preparation for the March 2003 IEP.

Issue No. 3: During the 2001-2002 school year, did the District fail to provide a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) to Petitioner?

The Petitioner alleges that the IEP developed in March 2002 failed to provide him with a FAPE. He claims that during the 2001-2002 school year his unique needs required; (1) one-on-one or small-group instruction or, alternatively, a full-time aide to assist with instruction while in a large group; (2) significant academic remediation in math and language arts; (3) behavioral services to address his maladaptive behaviors; (4) a one-to-one aide to facilitate social interaction between STUDENT and his peers; (5) OT services; and (6) speech and language services. He also contends that he, like all special education students, required goals and objectives that were measurable, contained present levels of performance, and addressed all of his unique needs, including those in the areas of academics, social-emotional functioning, and behavior. The District contends that an appropriate IEP was timely developed at the March 2002 meeting and thereafter implemented, providing a FAPE to the Petitioner.

A FAPE is special education and related services that are available to a student at no charge to his or her parent or guardian, meet the standards of the State educational agency, and are provided in conformity with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). It includes special education and related services that are designed to meet the child’s unique needs that cannot be met with modification of the regular instructional program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. In addition, an IEP must enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum and provide the opportunity to be educated and participate with nondisabled students to the maximum extent possible. .(footnote 24) 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.

An appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the student. Seattle School District No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996); Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1994, 1524 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied 513 U.S. 965 (1994). Moreover, the focus of the inquiry should not be on whether the student may obtain greater benefit in the placement that is preferred by the parents but, rather, whether the school district’s proposed placement is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the student. Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S. Ct. 3034; Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).

In summary, to be substantively appropriate, an IEP must (1) be designed to meet the student’s unique needs; (2) be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit; and (3) conform to the student’s IEP. In4 addition, the IEP must enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum and provide the student with the opportunity to be educated and participate with nondisabled students to the maximum extent possible. .(footnote 25)

There were two clearly identifiable segments during the 2001-2002 school year: (A) from the start of school to the March 5, 2002 IEP; and (B) from the March 5, 2002 IEP to the end of the school year. The Hearing Officer will deal with these segments separately.

A. Start of School to March 5, 2002 IEP

The Hearing Officer has already determined that the District failed to fulfill its child-find obligation to Petitioner by failing to timely identify and assess him. STUDENT should have been properly assessed and all appropriate services should have been provided beginning on December 20, 2001. STUDENT had no IEP and received none of the required services from December 20, 2001 to March 5, 2002, the date of the first IEP. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide a FAPE during this time.

B. March 5, 2002 IEP to the End of the 2001-2002 School Year

The Hearing Officer now examines the March 5, 2002 IEP to determine whether or not it provided a FAPE to STUDENT.

Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs

The evidence established that STUDENT, when placed in a general education class of twenty or more students, became easily frustrated, angry and possibly disruptive or shut down completely as soon as he found the work too challenging. The Hearing Officer does not believe that STUDENT is incapable of doing the work. STUDENT is intelligent. Rather, the Hearing Officer believes that STUDENT needs attention. It is undisputed that he is more attentive and less disruptive and avoidant in one-to-one and small-group instructional settings than he is in large-group instructional settings. Ms. Woicik observed that STUDENT would do the work as long as someone was sitting next to him. Mr. Peters told the SST that STUDENT’s classroom performance would at times depend on who was sitting with him. Tracy Weigand has observed that STUDENT is attentive to task seventy-five percent of the time when in small group or individual instruction in Ms. Haycock’s RSP room, but he is attentive to task only twenty-five percent in the general education classroom. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needed a small-group instructional setting or, alternatively, an instructional aide while in a large group instructional setting, like Mr. Peters’ general education class. The evidence clearly showed that STUDENT needed significant academic remediation in the areas of math and language arts. He functioned well below grade level in these areas. Mr. Peters confirmed that STUDENT had not mastered the foundation skills in earlier grades and that he would need those skills to be successful in school.

There is little dispute or question that maladaptive behavior impeded STUDENT’s learning. It had been a significant impediment at least since the summer of 1999. According to all of the evidence, it remained so when he returned to BVES in the fourth grade. STUDENT needed behavioral strategies to effectively address this need.

It was clear from the record that STUDENT wanted to have more friends, but his behaviors and social awkwardness tended to alienate his peers. The evidence showed that he was anxious about how he was viewed and accepted by other children and tended to isolate himself, limiting his interactions to a small group of boys in his class. His probable depression, immaturity, odd behaviors, and social awkwardness combined to make it difficult for STUDENT to bond with more of his classmates and to feel comfortable in larger groups. His alienation would add to his depression and cause frustration and anger that would further interfere with his social relationships. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needed a trained aide to encourage and otherwise facilitate mutual, positive interaction between STUDENT and his peers, particularly groups of peers that included children who were not part of his small social circle.

STUDENT also needs OT services. The Hearing Officer does not have the benefit of an OT assessment at about the time that the 2002 IEP was developed. However, he does have the benefit of the January 2003 report of Jeanie Pennington that describes STUDENT’s OT needs and notes that, “Due to [STUDENT’s] age, it may be difficult to change patterns that have been established for so many years.” On the basis of this report by the District’s own OT assessor, the Hearing Officer determines that STUDENT needed some level of OT services to be included in his March 2002 IEP.

There was no significant evidence to suggest that STUDENT required speech and language services to address what Petitioner alleges was a need in the area of pragmatic social language skills. Other than a tendency to make little eye contact, at least with some persons, there was no evidence of a deficit in this area. The District tested STUDENT’s pragmatic language skills and found them to be adequate. Although Dr. Diamond was dissatisfied with the District’s assessment technique, the Hearing Officer found that concern to be of little evidentiary value. The Petitioner offered no evidence from a qualified speech and language professional to contradict the testimony of Sue Wortman.

In summary, STUDENT’s needs that should have been addressed in the March 2002 IEP included his needs for: (1) individual and small-group instructional setting or, in the alternative, an instructional aide during large-group instruction; (2) significant remediation in the areas of math and language arts; (3) behavioral strategies to effectively address his maladaptive behaviors; (4) an aide to increase social skills and opportunities and STUDENT’s tolerance for social interaction with a group of peers beyond his small circle of friends; and (5) an appropriate level of OT services. .(footnote 26)

Pursuant to the March 2002 IEP, eighty percent of STUDENT’s time was to be spent in the general education large-group environment without an aide. STUDENT’s need for individual or small group instruction or the assistance of an aide was not met.

There is a substantial overlap between STUDENT’s need for academic remediation and his need for small-group or individual instruction. RSP services were provided, at least in part, for remediation in the areas of math and language arts. STUDENT was to be provided with sixty to ninety minutes of RSP services three to five times weekly. .(footnote 27) The evidence demonstrated that STUDENT needed more, particularly since he remained in a large-group instructional setting for most of the day.

Having not assessed STUDENT for behavioral, social-emotional, or OT needs, the District had little information that would have enabled it to offer an appropriate services to meet STUDENT’s needs in theses areas. As it was, the District offered no services to meet these needs. .(footnote 28)

The evidence established that the March 5, 2002 IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

Reasonably Calculated to Provide Some Educational Benefit

Although, according to Mr. Peters, STUDENT made some academic gains between March 5, 2002 and the end of the school year, those gains were small. De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2d Cir. 1998); M.C. v. Central Regional School District, 81 F.3d 389, 393 (3d Cir. 1996). STUDENT remained below grade level at year’s end. STUDENT’s need for individual or small-group instruction was being met for only a small part of his school day. His needs for remediation and social skills development were only being partially met, and his behavioral and OT needs were not being met at all. The evidence showed that the March 5, 2002 IEP was not reasonably calculated to provide meaningful educational benefit to STUDENT.

On the basis of the determination that the March 2002 IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs or reasonably calculated to provide an educational benefit, the Hearing Officer finds that it did not provide a FAPE to STUDENT. It is unnecessary to examine the other elements of the FAPE analysis.

Issue No. 4: During the 2002-2003 school year, did the District fail to provide a FAPE to Petitioner?

The Petitioner’s allegations regarding the 2002-2003 school year are similar to those regarding the prior year. However, he claims that STUDENT’s social-emotional needs became apparent during this year and that those required both assessment and services. The Petitioner contends that the defective March 5, 2002 IEP remained in effect during most of the 2002-2003 school year and that the subsequent March 11, 2003 IEP was similarly deficient, except the Petitioner does not contest the offer of OT services. He also alleges that there were procedural violations during the 2002-2003 school year that resulted in a denial of a FAPE. More specifically, he contends that the behavioral assessment and interventions by Terry Shuster were without parental consent and that the District failed to have Mr. Shuster at the IEP meeting when his BSP was presented for review. .(footnote 29) The District contends that it provided a FAPE to STUDENT and that procedural violations, if any, did not cause harm to STUDENT or his parents.

As with the prior year, the 2002-2003 school year can be divided into two segments for this analysis: (A) the beginning of the year to the March 11, 2003 IEP; and (B) the March 11, 2003 IEP to the end of the school year. There were several IEP meetings during the year. Some of these resulted in modifications to STUDENT’s program, or recommendation/offers of such modifications. The Hearing Officer will discuss the effect of changed circumstances on the appropriateness of the March 2002 IEP as long as that one remained in effect.

A. The Beginning of the Year to the March 11, 2003 IEP

There was no evidence to suggest that STUDENT’s areas of need had changed over the summer, except that his maladaptive behaviors were worse when he returned to school following the summer break. No other changed circumstance of significance was evident when the school year began.

The District attempted to address STUDENT’s increasing maladaptive behaviors by developing and implementing a behavior support plan (BSP). An addendum IEP meeting was convened on October 22, 2002 to discuss STUDENT’s behavior. A mental health referral was agreed upon. The meeting was short, and there was no change in STUDENT’s placement or services. At an October 29, 2002 IEP meeting, it was agreed that additional assessments (OT, pragmatic language, and FAA) would be done. Changes were made to the face of the March 2002 IEP, but these were for clarification of the existing services and not a change in placement or services. All of the petitioner’s procedural claims involve these matters. Because the defective March 5, 2002 IEP remained in effect, it is not necessary to address these procedural claims. The District continued to deny a FAPE to STUDENT.

At an IEP meeting on February 18, 2003, the District prepared an addendum to the March 5, 2002 IEP offering mental health and OT services as recommended by the assessors. It was not signed. Neither party presented testimony to explain why it was not signed. Both parties offered a copy of the addendum into evidence. There being no suggestion or argument to the contrary, the Hearing Officer finds that the addendum was offered to and refused by the Petitioner. Mental health services are not an issue and the record discloses that the PARENTs have agreed to those. If they had agreed to the delivery of the OT services, the nature and amount of which they do not dispute, those needs would have been met. However, the denial of a FAPE in other respects continued with the continued implementation of the March 2002 IEP.

B. The March 11, 2003 IEP to the End of the School Year

A new IEP was developed and offered at the March 11, 2003 IEP meeting. That IEP provides that STUDENT will spend approximately two to two and one-half hours daily, or forty-nine percent of his school day, receiving individual or small-group RSP services. It places STUDENT in the general education, large-group instructional environment for approximately two and one-half to three hours daily, but provides a one-to-one aide for that same period of time. Remediation and instruction in math and language arts are the focus of the RSP services. Behavioral consultation services three to four hours monthly and direct and consultative OT and mental health services are also provided.

Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs

All of STUDENT’s instructional time provided in the IEP is either in the RSP individual or small-group environment or a regular classroom with the assistance of a one-on-one aide. This is what the Petitioner wanted. The proposed IEP is designed to meet STUDENT’s need for individual or small-group instruction.

The IEP provides two to two and one-half hours daily of instruction and remediation in math and language arts. This is significantly more than that provided by the previous IEP and is approximately the same period of time used by Lindamood-Bell to provide instructional services to STUDENT. No expert suggested that he be provided with more RSP services. The IEP is reasonably designed to meet STUDENT’s need for remediation.

Behavioral support services as recommended by Ms. Weigand are provided in the IEP. The Hearing Officer found Ms. Weigand to be a competent behavioral expert and credible witness. The Petitioner offered no convincing evidence to contradict Ms. Weigand’s opinions and recommendations. .(footnote 30) The evidence adequately established the appropriateness of the offered behavioral services to meet STUDENT’s need for behavioral support.

The March 2003 IEP provides just enough time to assist STUDENT while he is in the large-group instructional environment. Although a behavior goal is to increase social interaction and cooperation with peers during class activities, there is no provision of an aide or aide time to assist STUDENT specifically with his social isolation both during class activities and, perhaps more importantly, during free time, such as during lunch and recess. STUDENT’s need for this assistance is not met by the IEP.

The Hearing Officer finds that the March 11, 2003 IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs except his need for trained aide to encourage and otherwise facilitate mutual, positive interaction between him and his peers, particularly groups of peers that included children who were not part of his small social circle.

Reasonably Calculated to Provide Some Educational Benefit

The IEP contains goals that are reasonably calculated to provide an educational benefit while meeting STUDENT’s needs. One of these goals focuses on decreasing STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors that interfere with his attention to instruction and tasks. Another focuses on decreasing one of STUDENT’s behaviors that, in addition to interfering with his learning, also tends to alienate his peers, self-talk. That same goal provides for staff support to facilitate STUDENT’s participation in cooperative or free-time activity with his peers, with the later goal of such participation independently. There are mental health goals that are reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit by meeting STUDENT’s need to increase attention to task, assignment completion, and self-esteem and to decrease depression, anxiety, and avoidance behaviors. The OT services are calculated to provide educational benefit, as are the services of the aide and the RSP.

The Petitioner’s principal contention is that the goals and objectives were inadequate because they did not address all areas of need, did not contain present levels of performance, and were not measurable. However, counsel provided little evidence or argument on those claimed deficiencies. .(footnote 31)

At an IEP meeting, Ms. Broussard inquired regarding goals for learning basic math facts and operations. In her closing argument she proposed that there should be goals for visual memory, organization, and attention, among others. Dr. Diamond suggested at an IEP meeting that there should be a goal for decoding.(footnote 32). The law does not require a specific goal for every deficit. It would be counter productive to micromanage teachers and staff with overly detailed goals and objectives for every area where there is a deficit. (See, e.g., Rowley, supra, at 208; Lachmann v. Illinois State Board of Education, 852 F.2d 290, 297 (7th Cir. 1988) cert. denied, 488 U.S. 925 (1988)). Generally, goals should address areas of need and provide a reasonable basis upon which to judge progress.

The IEP contains thirteen annual goals: two behavior goals, each with three or four intermediate objectives; three general mental health goals; four OT goals, each with two or three intermediate objectives; three language arts goals, each with two intermediate objectives; and four math goals, each with two to three intermediate objectives. .(footnote 33) These goals addressed all of STUDENT’s areas of need and their general scope was adequate to provide an educational benefit to STUDENT.

It did not appear from the evidence or the argument that the Petitioner disputed the behavioral, mental health, or OT goals that are contained in the IEP. He does dispute the academic goals and objectives on the grounds that they are not measurable because they do not contain present levels of performance.

The language arts goals refer to supplementary evaluations dated February 18, 2003 for STUDENT’s present levels of performance. The report of this evaluation is in evidence. It contains present levels of performance for reading, spelling and written language. In reading, STUDENT was able to read Diagnostic Reading Scales at grade levels 4.5 and 5.5 with fluency and eighty percent comprehension and the 6.5 grade level passage fluently but with fourteen errors and twenty percent comprehension. Present levels of performance for spelling and written language are also found in that supplementary evaluation. .(footnote 39) Although the District should have included present levels of performance on the IEP without having to reference another document that may or may not be attached, the Hearing Officer finds that the ommission in this case was harmless. STUDENT’s present levels of performance, insofar as those were reasonably determinable by assessment, were known to all parties.

The IEP refers to a supplementary evaluation dated January 18, 2003 for present levels of performance in math. The Hearing Officer believes that this date was a typographical error because the February 18, 2003 supplementary evaluation referred to also contains present levels of performance in math and would have been the most recent source of that information at the time of the March 11, 2003 IEP meeting. That evaluation contains present levels of performance, to the extent ascertainable, based upon Ms. Haycock’s individual assessment of STUDENT’s ability to: (1) multiply multi-digit numbers by a two digit number; (2) round seven digit numbers at the fourth through seventh digits; (3) addition and subtraction of fractions with like denominators; and (4) word problems involving addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division. .(footnote 35) The evaluation also contains the results of the recent District math assessment with percentages achieved in problem solving, computation, number sense, algebra, and math reasoning.

However, the math goals in the IEP are couched in different terms and focus on different skills or combinations of skills than those referred to in the supplemental evaluation. Although Ms. Haycock may be able to measure STUDENT’s progress in math using those goals, the Hearing Officer is not convinced that STUDENT’s parents or anyone else could. Whether or not STUDENT is making progress in math, an area in which he has consistently demonstrated substantial weakness, is not something that should be left to faith in a teacher’s judgement. It should be apparent by objective measurement based in part upon the present levels of performance set forth in the IEP. The math goals and objectives in the IEP do not allow that measurement to be done. .(footnote 36)

The Hearing Officer finds that the March 2003 IEP is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to STUDENT except insofar as the math goals and objectives do not contain adequate present levels of performance that would allow for an objective measurement of progress.

Conform To the IEP

Conformity of STUDENT’s program to his IEP is not an issue.

The March 11, 2003 IEP appropriately meets STUDENT’s many needs in the areas of individual attention, remediation, behavior, and OT and also provides an educational benefit in many respects. It is deficient only to the extent it fails to address STUDENT’s need for an aide to facilitate social interaction and does not contain objectively measurable math goals based on current levels of performance. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the March 11, 2003 IEP offered a FAPE to STUDENT except to the extent that it does not meet his need for an aide to facilitate social interaction and does not contain objectively measurable math goals based on current levels of performance.

Issue No. 5: Are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement from the District for the cost of the independent assessments conducted by Catheryn Ross, M.D., Daniel Peters, Ph.D., Marian Lane Diamond, Ph.D., and Lindamood-Bell?

The Petitioner claims that his parents are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the assessments because the District’s assessments were inappropriate. The District defends its assessments.

As stated above, the law requires that a child with a suspected disability be assessed by the school district in all areas related to the suspected disability. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f). The purpose of this requirement is clear. The evaluation must be “sufficiently comprehensive to identify all of the child’s special education and related services needs.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.532(h). The IEP team must be able to rely on the information from an initial assessment to determine eligibility and to develop an appropriate educational program. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b).

A parent has the right to obtain an independent assessment at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment done by the school district. The school district must pay for the independent assessment unless there is a determination through due process that its assessment was appropriate. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b).

STUDENT was assessed by the District for the purpose of determining eligibility in April and May 2000. At the meeting in May 2000 it was determined that STUDENT was not eligible for special education. No independent assessment was requested or conducted in association with that determination. It was not until STUDENT returned to a District school for the fourth grade that Dr. Cathryn Ross conducted the first independent assessment at issue. The assessment was conducted on December 12, 2001, after the special education referral process was started but before the District’s assessments were conducted. Ms. PARENT first testified that she took STUDENT to Dr. Ross because the assessment by Haughton did not address behavior, attention, and fatigue. She contradicted that testimony the following day when she said that she took STUDENT to Dr. Ross because she had not been informed by the District regarding the result of its ADD screening more than two years earlier. The Petitioner did not adequately explain this discrepancy. The Petitioner did not request reimbursement for the assessment by Haughton, and there was no evidence to suggest it was done because of a disagreement with any District assessment.

The Hearing Officer finds that the assessment by Dr. Ross was not related to a disagreement by the parents with any assessment by the District. The statutory conditions for reimbursement were not met. Reimbursement for that expense is not due.

Clinical psychologist Daniel Peters evaluated STUDENT at the request of the parents and Del Domezio on May 31 and June 5, 2002. By that time, the District’s assessment had been completed and STUDENT had been found eligible for special education under the category SLD. However, the District had not conducted an appropriate assessment of STUDENT for social-emotional deficits and no mental health services were being provided. The PARENTs reasonably sought such an assessment by Dr. Peters. They are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of that assessment.

On October 22, 2002, the IEP team, including STUDENT’s parents, agreed to a mental health referral pursuant to Chapter 26.5 of the California Government Code. On October 29, 2002, the PARENTs agreed to pragmatic language, behavior, OT, and academic achievement evaluations that were to be completed by the next agreed-upon IEP meeting date of January 14, 2003. Before those assessments were completed, the PARENTs took STUDENT for an assessment by Dr. Diamond because they had begun to suspect that STUDENT’s disability placed him somewhere on the autism spectrum. At no time before Dr. Diamond’s assessment did STUDENT’s parents ask the District to assess STUDENT specifically for PDD or autism. Ms. PARENT testified that she did not trust the District’s assessment process. Mr. PARENT said that he did not believe that the mental health assessment would look at the possibility of autism or PDD and he was concerned about delay.

The Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Diamond’s assessment was not done because of a disagreement with any District assessment. .(footnote 37) The statutory conditions for reimbursement have not been met. Reimbursement for the assessment by Dr. Diamond is not due.

The Petitioner also requests reimbursement for the assessment conducted by Lindamood-Bell. Such assessments are used by Lindamood-Bell to provide baselines for the determination of the type and amount of services to be provided to the customer and to judge progress resulting for those services. The clinic director of Lindamood-Bell, Elizabeth Szporn, testified that the tests are a required part of the process. Neither of STUDENT’s parents testified that the Lindamood-Bell assessment was done because of a disagreement with any of the District’s assessments. Although the parties have a substantial dispute regarding whether or not the District should pay for the services of Lindamood-Bell, reimbursement for the cost of this assessment will under these circumstances depend on an award of reimbursement for the Lindamood-Bell services.

Issue No. 6: Are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement from the District for the cost of educational services provided by Marilyn Reid, Haughton Learning Center, and Lindamood-Bell?

The Petitioner seeks reimbursement for his parents for the cost of educational services provided by Marilyn Reid, Haughton Learning Center, and Lindamood-Bell. He alleges that these services were reasonable and necessary to address the educational needs that the District failed to address when it breached its child-find obligation and then failed to provide a FAPE to him.

Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under the IDEA and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Educ., 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496. The placement or services chosen by the parents is not required to be the “exact proper placement required under the Act.” Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). However, the placement and services selected by the parents must address the student’s needs and provide the student with educational benefit. Florence County Sch. Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13 (1993).

The Hearing Officer has found that the District should have identified STUDENT as a child with a suspected disability within six weeks of the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year, or by approximately October 16, 2001, and that an IEP should have been developed and services begun on or about December 20, 2001.

Marilyn Reid started to provide services to STUDENT in August 2001. She testified that she provided services until STUDENT started at Haughton and began to receive RSP services in late February or early March 2002. The services provided by Ms. Reid consisted of one-to-one tutoring in math and language arts, both areas of need for STUDENT that were not being adequately by the District. It was reasonable for STUDENT’s parents to use the services of Ms. Reid and to believe that they provide an educational benefit to their son. Mr. and Ms. PARENT are entitled to reimbursement for these expenses for services rendered on or after December 20, 2001 but no later than the day before the District started to provide RSP services to STUDENT. Related transportation expenses shall also be reimbursed.

Ms. PARENT testified that she took STUDENT to Haughton for educational assistance because Ms. Hirsch refused her request to give STUDENT additional help with his math. She said that it was Ms. Hirsch who recommended Haughton. No one from Haughton testified but the records show that Haughton delivered educational services in math and language arts. Mr. PARENT testified that the Haughton services were delivered from February 2002 to August 2002, with the summer program being more intensive. Mr. PARENT also testified that there was a period of time during which STUDENT was going to school and receiving services from Ms. Reid and Haughton. In light of the limited number of hours of service provided by Haughton, the Hearing Officer considers the timing of delivery of those hours to be inconsequential. .(footnote 38)

STUDENT needed additional instruction in math and language arts. Haughton provided that remediation. The Hearing Officer finds that services provided by Haughton were reasonably intended to meet STUDENT’s need for academic assistance and to provide an educational benefit. The PARENTs are entitled to reimbursement for the Haughton expenses, including related transportation expenses.

The clinic director of Lindamood-Bell testified that STUDENT was assessed by her organization on February 28, 2003. He began to receive services on April 7, 2003. The Hearing Office held that the IEP dated March 11, 2003 did not offer STUDENT a FAPE. However, the deficiencies in the March 11, 2003 IEP did not justify placement in the Lindamood-Bell program as an acceptable substitute for the District’s offered program. But for a disjunction between present levels of performance and goals for math, the District had offered STUDENT a program that would meet his then current academic needs in math and language arts and thereby provide the required educational benefit. The evidence suggests that the PARENTs wanted STUDENT to attend Lindamood-Bell for language arts and this has been the substantial focus of the efforts of Lindamood-Bell. The services of Lindamood-Bell were not necessary to provide STUDENT a FAPE after March 11, 2003. Under the circumstances, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the educational services provided by Lindamood-Bell on the theory that those were necessary to provide a FAPE to STUDENT. .(footnote 39)

Issue No. 7: Is Petitioner entitled to an award of compensatory education and, if so, of what shall that award consist?

Court decisions subsequent to Burlington, supra, have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749. Compensatory education is an equitable remedy. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for-hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the Petitioner is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Puyallup, supra, 31 F.3d at 497.

The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is entitled to an award of compensatory education due to the District’s failure to provide OT services from January 2, 2002 to February 18, 2003. However, the Hearing Officer lacks sufficient evidence upon which to base the calculation of an award. Ms. Pennington states in her report that it may not be possible to remediate except by teaching alternative skills, such as keyboarding. Additional information from a qualified occupational therapist, and possible other experts, is necessary. The Hearing Officer finds that it is the responsibility of the IEP team to obtain the necessary information and to craft an award that will fairly compensate STUDENT for the loss.

The Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT is entitled to an award of compensatory education due to the District’s failure to meet his need for an increase in social skills and opportunities from January 2, 2002 to March 12, 2003. The award shall consist of additional aide time sufficient to allow the aide to receive appropriate social skills training and consultation from the District’s behavior specialist and to spend two hours per week facilitating social interaction outside of the general education classroom setting between STUDENT and groups of peers larger than his usual small group of friends.

Finally, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is entitled to an award to compensate him for the hours of individual and small-group instruction and additional remediation that he was not provided from December 20, 2001 to the date of the March 2003 IEP. The services of Marilyn Reid and Haughton were appropriate, but considering the significant denial of required daily services over approximately thirteen school months, these alone were not nearly sufficient to meet the needs that the District should have been meeting. .(footnote 40)

Since April 7, 2003, STUDENT has been receiving remediation from Lindamood-Bell. Ms. Szporn reported that STUDENT had completed fifty-five hours of the “Visualizing & Verbalizing” and had made significant gains by the time of the hearing. She expected that he would ultimately require one hundred forty hours of that program. She also stated that she had recommended eighty to one hundred hours of the “Seeing Stars” program and eighty to one hundred hours of the “On Cloud Nine Math” program and that she expected that all recommended programs would be completed by the start of the 2003-2004 school year. The Hearing Officer was persuaded that the recommended Lindamood-Bell programs will fairly compensate STUDENT for the instruction and remediation that the District did not provide from December 20, 2001 to March 11, 2003. Therefore, in addition to the above award elements, the Hearing Officer finds that the cost of the two hundred eighty hour Lindamood-Bell is an appropriate element of the compensatory education award.(footnote 41)

ORDER

1. Within ten calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse the Petitioner’s parents for the cost of the assessment of the Petitioner conducted on or about June 17, 2002 by clinical psychologist Daniel Peters.

2. Within ten calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse Petitioner’s parents for the cost of educational services rendered to Petitioner by Marilyn Reid between December 20, 2001 and the day before the District started to provide RSP services to Petitioner pursuant to the March 5, 2002 IEP, and for transportation costs at the rate of $.365 per mile (the standard federal reimbursement rate for 2002).

3. Within ten calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse Petitioner’s parents for the cost of educational services rendered to Petitioner by Haughton Learning Center between December 20, 2001 and August 15, 2002, and for transportation costs at the rate of $.365 per mile.

4. Within ten calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse Petitioner’s parents for the cost of two hundred eighty hours of educational services rendered to Petitioner by Lindamood-Bell, for the cost of the assessment of Petitioner conducted by Lindamood-Bell on February 28, 2003, and for all related transportation costs at the rate of $.365 per mile. 5. In preparation for an IEP meeting within thirty calendar days of the start of the 2003-3004 school year, the District shall conduct an occupational therapy assessment of STUDENT by a qualified and licensed occupational therapist. In connection with that assessment, the District shall: (a) inform the assessor concerning the Hearing Officer’s determination regarding Petitioner’s OT needs and his entitlement to a compensatory award; (b) inform the assessor concerning the parties’ need for a written report from him or her to provide guidance on the question of compensatory education for OT services that would be likely to fairly compensate the Petitioner for the failure of the District to provide OT services from December 20, 2001, until they were offered on February 18, 2003; (c) provide the assessor with copies of all (d) complete the assessment before the IEP meeting to documents he or she may need to answer the question(s) posed; be held within thirty calendar days of the start of the 2003-3004 school year, as set forth below; (e) provide a copy of the assessor’s written report to the Petitioner’s attorney and parents.

6. Within thirty calendar days after the start of the 2003-2004 school year, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting to:

(a) provide for additional aide time sufficient to allow the aide to receive appropriate social skills training and consultation from the District’s behavioral consultant and to spend two hours per week facilitating social interaction between STUDENT and groups of peers larger than his usual small group of friends outside of the general education classroom setting; (b) include measurable math goals and objectives that are based on stated present levels of performance; (c) consider the report of the occupational therapist and reach an agreement regarding an award of compensatory OT. Those additional services shall be incorporated into the Petitioner’s IEP.

7. All of the Petitioner’s other claims to relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

Issue No. 1: Did the District fail to fulfill its child-find obligation from the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year until Petitioner was identified as a child with disabilities on or about February 1, 2002?

The Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue.

Issue No. 2: Did the District fail to assess the Petitioner in all areas related to his suspected disability?

The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

Issue No. 3: During the 2001-2002 school year, did the District fail to provide a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) to Petitioner?

The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

Issue No. 4: During the 2002-2003 school year, did the District fail to provide a FAPE to Petitioner?

The Petitioner prevailed on this issue as it related to the school year until March 11, 2003.

Issue No. 5: Are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement from the District for the cost of the independent assessments conducted by Cathryn Ross, M.D., Daniel Peters, Ph.D., Marian Lane Diamond, Ph.D., and Lindamood-Bell?

The Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the extent that reimbursement was awarded for the assessment by Dr. Peters.

Issue No. 6: Are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement from the District for the cost of remedial services provided by Marilyn Reid, Haughton Learning Center, and Lindamood-Bell?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the extent that reimbursement was awarded for the services rendered by Marilyn Reid and Haughton Learning Center.

Issue No. 7: Is Petitioner entitled to an award of compensatory education and, if so, of what shall that award consist?

The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Dated: July 15, 2003 ________________________________ Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

* The Decision has been amended to add a new paragraph 4 to the Order and to renumber the susequent paragraphs of the Order accordingley.

1. The Hearing Officer has organized the issues for the purposes of adjudication. 2. Two of STUDENT’s scores, 128 in listening comprehension and 116 in basic reading, were higher than his full-scale IQ score. His lowest score was 96 in spelling. The others were between 100 and 109. 3. The school, often referred to in the record as the “Waldorf School,” was not a District-chartered school. The documentary evidence indicates the school is chartered by the Twin Ridges Elementary School District, which is part of the Placer Nevada Special Education Local Plan Area (SELPA). 4. Mr. Domezio made a similar request.

5. There was no evidence to suggest that Mr. Peters was aware of the SAT-9 scores from 2001. 6. There was no evidence when Ms. PARENT made the arrangements for this evaluation.

7. Dr. Matsumoto had used the Kaufman Brief Intelligence Scale to measure STUDENT’s vocabulary (verbal), matrix (performance) and composite IQs at 126, 93, and 110, respectively. 8. The report refers to the Clinical Evaluation of Language Functioning, but this is believed to be an error. The edition of the tests administered is not given. 9. There was also an assessment for adaptive physical education (APE). The assessor concluded that STUDENT did not qualify for APE, and that finding has not been disputed by the Petitioner. 10. There are no recorded minutes of the meeting, and the bases for the eligibility finding is not clear, but there does not appear to have been any severe discrepancy between ability and achievement test scores. 11. The IEP indicated that behavior did not impede learning.

12. Time away from class could be with the resource teacher or an “errand to nowhere,” the purpose of which was to allow STUDENT to be away from the class without feeling that he was being punished. 13. All references to Chapter 26.5 are to California Government Code Chapter 26.5.

14. The date of the assessment is unclear. Ms. Pennington did not testify. Her report is dated December 22, 2002 and February 9, 2003.

15. Several of the witnesses noted that there was one particular boy in STUDENT’s class with whom he had a great deal of conflict and that when this boy left the school, STUDENT’s behavior improved, at least for a time. 16. The meeting was originally scheduled for January 14, 2003, but was postponed to this later date by agreement.

17. The Petitioner frequently referred to the information the District had at the time of the assessment in the spring of 2000. However, the Petitioner did not put that assessment in issue. 18. It is also referred to as the “search and serve” obligation.

19. The parties seem to agree that the NCS did not follow the methodologies and curriculum of the typical public school. According to Ms. Reid, the Waldorf method emphasizes freedom and personal decision making practices that probably caused “academic harm” to STUDENT.

20. In her closing argument, Ms. Broussard for the first time asked the Hearing Officer to determine that the District had failed to assess STUDENT for autism or autistic-like behaviors. This issue was raised late in the proceeding and, in any event, the evidence offered in support of this claim was unconvincing. 21. It appears to have become a focus of attention since the PARENTs began to believe that STUDENT has a PDD. 22. Although the District did not have the benefit of Dr. Ross’s and Dr. Peters’ reports until later, their opinions regarding STUDENT’s OT needs lend further credibility to the Petitioner’s position.

23. Ms. Lucchese did not testify at the hearing.

24. These two elements are not at issue here.

25. The procedural elements of FAPE will be discussed in the Hearing Officer’s analysis of the issues for the 2002-2003 school year.

26. The Petitioner did not request a finding that the March 2002 IEP should have included mental health services and no expert specifically testified that STUDENT needed them during the 2001-2001 school year. Regardless of the evidence suggesting that STUDENT may have had significant emotional issues since before the 2001-2002 school year, it would be inappropriate for the Hearing Officer to make a finding on a matter that was not presented for determination. 27. The amount of time actually spent was not shown.

28. lthough there was evidence to suggest that STUDENT may have a tendency to regress during long breaks, extended school year (ESY) services were also not offered, but the Petitioner did not raise this issue until closing arguments.

29. Petitioner raised numerous other alleged procedural violations for the first time in closing argument. Those included: (1) that eligibility, goals, and services were determined by District personnel before IEP meetings were convened; (2) that there was inadequate participation of regular education teachers in IEP meetings; and that the IEP team failed to consider the report of Dr. Peters. Because the District was given inadequate notice of these issues, the Hearing Officer does not address them here.

30. petitioner did offer into evidence an unsigned letter on plain paper without any identifying letterhead that purported to criticize Ms. Weigand’s report. The Hearing officer gave it no weight. 31. The Hearing Officer gleans that the Petitioner believes the goals should be in some fashion based on a diagnosis of PDD-NOS. The Hearing Officer was not persuaded that this diagnosis was correct. 32. Ms. Reid was of the opinion that decoding was not a problem.

33. The mental health goals are based on the assessment by Ms. Ibitz, but the IEP states that STUDENT’s therapist will provide more specific goals. The PARENTs terminated the services of Mr. Domezio and at the time of the hearing were in the process of finding a “cognitive therapist” to work with STUDENT. 34. The supplementary evaluation of STUDENT’s writing skills was not based on the “Step Up to Writing” program that the District proposed to use with STUDENT, but that is a matter easily dealt with by an initial assessment when that program is started and does not render the goal unmeasurable.

35. STUDENT’s patience with tests and his test-taking skills make it difficult to know what STUDENT really can do. 36. It would seem that the use of four math problems would allow the achievement of an eighty percent or better accuracy rate, that required by the goals for mastery, only with the achievement of one hundred percent accuracy. Otherwise, it appears that progress could be calculated if a present level of performance was given for each goal and objective.

37. STUDENT’s eligibility category is not an issue identified by the Petitioner.

38 The Haughton reassessment summary dated August 12, 2002 states that STUDENT had received only fifty-five hours of instruction to that date at its facility.

39. This finding does not prevent the Hearing Officer from awarding the cost of the Lindamood-Bell services as an element of compensatory education for necessary services that were not provided to STUDENT by the District during the time that it denied him a FAPE. 40. The Hearing Officer estimates the hours of service provided by Ms. Reid and Haughton combined at approximately eighty hours. 41. The testimony indicated that the cost of the hours is not dependent on the program being used. The Hearing Officer does not dictate how those hours may be used to assist STUDENT.