California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 19, 2004
Student v. Capistrano Unified School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 2379-03 · Hearing Officer My T. Huynh
Capistrano Unified's plan to move a student with a brain injury into its young adult program upheld; District may implement it.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a 17-year-old with a traumatic brain injury (TBI) filed for due process against Capistrano Unified School District, and the District filed a cross-complaint. The student attended the Tustin Center, a private program, and his parents had agreed he could move to the District's Young Adult Transition Program (YATP). The parties settled other issues during the hearing. The only remaining dispute was whether the transition plan in the May 25, 2004 IEP was appropriate. The parents wanted a six-month plan in which District staff would work with him at the Tustin Center for four months before he moved. The District's plan had three phases: staff would shadow him at the Tustin Center for one to two weeks, he would make two visits and then phase into the YATP over three weeks, and his current one-to-one aide would fade out over five months. The team would meet weekly.
The Hearing Officer found that current behavior data showed his physical aggression had dropped sharply. The parents' expert received less weight because he had not assessed the student since 2001. The student builds trust faster when a familiar aide is present, so keeping the aide throughout met his behavioral needs. District psychologists persuasively testified that a long stay at the old site would confuse him. A sensory diet and a quiet classroom met his sensory needs. The District prevailed and could implement the plan. The parents had to make the student available within 15 calendar days.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO judged a transition plan between placements under Rowley. The Hearing Officer gave more weight to current behavior data and recent observations than to an expert's older assessment. Keeping a trusted aide with the student, holding weekly team check-ins, and providing sensory supports were treated as enough to address the parents' safety concerns.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1. Did the District fail to develop an appropriate plan in the May 25, 2004 IEP to transition Student from the Tustin Center to the Young Adults Transition Program?
The District's three-phase transition plan, with the student's current aide present throughout, weekly team meetings, behavior plans, a sensory diet and an adaptable quiet classroom, was designed to meet his behavioral and sensory needs and was reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order that district's offer may be implemented. District may begin implementing the transition plan from the Tustin Center to the YATP proposed in the May 25, 2004 IEP; parents shall make Student available for the transition within 15 calendar days of the decision. All of Student's requests for relief denied.
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District; Ms. B. v. Milford Board of Education
People named in the decision
- Thomas Willis, Ph.D., psychologist, expert witness for Student, Associate director for Applied Behavior Analysis
- Corey Roberts, former educational aide, witness for Student
- Charles Hwang, adapted physical education specialist, witness for Student
- Juda Carter, director, witness for Student, Tustin Center
- Noel Deleon, student's current one-to-one aide, Tustin Center
- Mary Ann Kelly, school nurse, District witness, Capistrano Unified School District
- Gary Strickland, director of career preparation, District witness, Capistrano Unified School District
- Melanie Lavering, YATP teacher, District witness, Capistrano Unified School District
- Roz Ballante, behavioral program specialist, District witness, Capistrano Unified School District
- Heather King, Ph.D., school psychologist, District witness, Capistrano Unified School District
- Claudia Ginsberg-Brown, manager of special services and supervising occupational therapist, District witness, Capistrano Unified School District
- Diane Lynn Wertheimer-Gale, occupational therapist, District witness
- Diane Lappi, executive director, District representative and witness, Capistrano Unified School District
- Kim Gaither, legal specialist, District representative, Capistrano Unified School District
- Paul Alan Dores, Ph.D., psychologist, District expert witness
- David Lachuga, Ph.D., psychologist, District witness
- Tustin Center, private educational program (current placement)
- May Center, out-of-state educational facility (prior placement, Massachusetts)
- Bancroft Neurohealth, private provider that supported and later closed the prior private center
- Diagnostic Center, state diagnostic evaluator (1997 evaluation)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before My T. Huynh, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in San Juan Capistrano, California, on June 1-4, 9 and 10, 2004.
Petitioner and Cross-Respondent (Student) was represented by attorney Katherine Loyer. Also present on the Student’s behalf were his parents, Mother and Father, and in attendance for portions of the hearing was Student’s sister. Respondent and Cross-Petitioner Capistrano Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Caroline Zuk. Also present on the District’s behalf were executive director Diane Lappi and legal specialist Kim Gaither.
The Student called the following witnesses: Mother; psychologist Thomas Willis, Ph.D.; educational aide Corey Roberts; adapted physical education specialist Charles Hwang; and Tustin Center director Juda Carter.
The District called as its witnesses: school nurse Mary Ann Kelly; director of career preparation Gary Strickland; teacher Melanie Lavering; program specialist Roz Ballante; school psychologist Heather King; manager of special services Claudia Ginsberg-Brown; occupational therapist Diane Lynn Wertheimer-Gale; executive director Diane Lappi; psychologist Paul Alan Dores, Ph.D.; and psychologist David Lachuga, Ph.D.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was closed upon the completion of closing arguments on June 10, 2004, and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUE (Footnote 1)
Did the District fail to develop an appropriate plan in the May 25, 2004 individualized education program (IEP) to transition Student from the Tustin Center to the Young Adults Transition Program?
BACKGROUND FACTS
Student is a seventeen-year-old boy who resides within the boundaries of the District with his parents. He is eligible for special education and related services as a student with a traumatic brain injury (TBI). At the age of three and a half, he was diagnosed with a brain tumor located between his brain stem and fourth ventricle. Shortly thereafter, he underwent two surgeries to remove the tumor. To date, he has experienced no reoccurrence of the cancer.
The complications from the surgeries caused considerable problems to Student’s brain. Within ten days of his second surgery, Student developed meningitis and suffered a grand mal seizure. Approximately one month later, he also contracted foot and mouth virus and suffered additional seizures. As a result of his illnesses, Student required hospitalization.
Also following his surgeries, Student became impulsive, hyperactive, and inattentive. In addition, he became hypersensitive to environmental stimuli and exhibited defensiveness from his senses of touch, smell and hearing. Further, he began manifesting complex partial seizures. (Footnote 2) As a behavioral response to sensing an upcoming seizure, he would pat his stomach and state that he was becoming “sick.” (Footnote 3) The injuries related to his brain surgeries also cause delays in his cognitive development and verbal expression. Although Student has improved in the above deficit areas, these concerns continue today.
Unbeknownst to Student’s parents, the surgeries also partially severed two cranial nerves impacting his face. The partially severed nerves caused total paralysis to the right side of his face. However, the nerves continued to emanate debilitating pain sensations. (Footnote 4) Due to Student’s delayed verbal communication skills, he was unable to express himself in a meaningful way to alert adults of his pain. The severed nerves were not discovered until Student underwent further surgery on his right eye in September 2000. Prior to that discovery, Student’s pain caused him to clutch and tear at his right eye. His pain was so intense that by May 2001, he had inflicted sufficient injury to himself resulting in blindness in the right eye. He also pulled out several of his teeth.
Student entered the District in March 1990 and attended pre-school. Initially, the District placed him in a speech and language special day class (SDC) program. Upon entering school, Student began exhibiting behavioral and social skills problems including rigidity, and perseveration regarding his seizures. (Footnote 5) Because his seizures are so commonplace, Student perseverates about his seizures by perpetually discussing his discomfort stemming from them. He also began demonstrating rigidity and resistance to changes in his surroundings and scheduling of activities. Student was susceptible to acting out in unfavorable surroundings or activities, often without warning. If this rigidity was not properly addressed, Student’s behaviors would escalate from mere resistance to full-blown aggression towards himself or others requiring physical restraint. Student attended four different schools within the District from 1990 through 1998. Throughout his attendance at the District’s schools, he demonstrated the above behavioral problems. His difficulties caused him to be sporadically returned home by the District to receive educational programming. (Footnote 6)
It was not until the Diagnostic Center’s evaluation of Student in June 1997 that his disability was concretely identified. (Pet. Ex. 81) The Diagnostic Center diagnosed Student with an organic brain disorder stemming from injuries associated with his brain tumor and surgeries. Then, Student’s eligibility for special education and related services was reclassified to a student with TBI. The report also recommended twenty-four hour care with supervision adequate to provide safety for Student. Although Student’s family was initially reluctant to place him in twenty-four hour care, his continuing aggressive behaviors and growing size, convinced his family to place him at an educational placement outside the District. (Footnote 7) In May 1998, Student’s parents enrolled him at the May Center, an educational facility specializing in children with severe behavioral deficits, located in Massachusetts.
Student attended the May Center until May 2001. During his attendance, he made considerable strides in his behavior and social skills. The May Center staff worked to identify antecedent triggers to his maladaptive behaviors and introduced a program of positive behavior management. Nonetheless, Student was often susceptible to rigidity and aggressive behaviors requiring physical restraint. During one restraint, Student caused serious injury to his left eye. (Footnote 8)
In March 2001, Mother informed the District that Student would be returning to California for emergency eye surgery. In May 2001, Student’s parents founded, with support from Bancroft Neurohealth, the Student Center, an educational facility specializing in working with children with TBI. (Footnote 9) In preparation for his return to California, his parents consulted with psychologist Thomas Willis, Ph.D., to facilitate Student’s transition from the May Center to the Student Center.
Dr. Willis supervised Student’s transition from the May Center to the Student Center by coordinating staff from both facilities. Dr. Willis carefully studied the strategies and techniques employed by May Center staff and instructed the Student Center staff in their use. Further, three May Center staff members came to California to assist with the transition. The May Center personnel worked with Student at his new placement over the course of three weeks before returning to Massachusetts. Although the transition to the Student Center was not ideal because Dr. Willis would have preferred having May Center staff stay beyond three weeks to assist Student, Dr. Willis nonetheless considered it a success. (Pet. Ex. 214)
In January 2003, Student’s IEP team met to discuss the District’s recommendation that Student attend the District’s Young Adult Transition Program (YATP). (Dist. Ex. 35) The YATP combines classes and community outings to assist students with severe disabilities, ages sixteen through twenty-two, learn independent living and vocational skills. (Dist. Ex. 96) Student’s parents dissented to the recommendation for the YATP and instead requested that the District fund his placement at the Student Center.
Student attended the Student Center until Bancroft Neurohealth closed it in August 2003. However, Student’s parents founded and opened the Tustin Center in September 2003 on the same location as occupied previously by the Student Center. With the exception of the change of ownership, the Tustin Center functions similarly to the Student Center. Student has been attending the Tustin Center since September 2003. During his attendance at both the Student and Tustin Centers, Student has shown considerable improvement in his behavior and social skills. In addition to receiving instruction from the Center, he also receives related services in the areas of speech and language, physical therapy and occupational therapy. In the past year, the frequency and intensity of his behaviors including, physical aggressions have been reduced considerably. Further, he has also developed greater tolerances to changes in his environment including the structure and scheduling of activities. These improvements have been credited to the Tustin Center’s staff’s training and experience working with Student.
During the 2003-2004 school year, there have been over seven IEP team meetings discussing recommendations for Student’s educational placement. Although Student’s parents continued to have concerns about the appropriateness of the YATP for Student, after several meetings, they were willing to allow his transfer to the YATP. During the March 8, 2004 IEP meeting, the District made its draft recommendation for a transition plan from the Tustin Center to the YATP. (Dist. Ex. 88) Student’s parents disagreed with the plan citing the lack of completion of pending assessments and input from Tustin Center’s staff in the initial draft transition plan. Further, Student’s parents had grave concerns about Student’s ability to safely undergo a transition on the District’s recommended timetable. Accordingly, his parents proposed an alternative plan calling for the transition to take place over the course of six months. (Pet. Ex. 1056)
The parents’ plan emphasizes the building of rapport between Student, YATP staff and related service providers at the Tustin Center for the first four months prior to physically moving Student to the YATP. In response, the District offered a revised final transition plan at the May 25, 2004 IEP meeting that integrated some aspects of Student’s parents’ plan. (Dist. Ex. 148) Nonetheless, the Student disagrees with the District’s proposed plan to transition him to the YATP, which is the subject of this hearing.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
District’s Contentions
The District generally contends that the revised transition plan proposed in the May 25, 2004 IEP is appropriate to meet Student’s behavioral and sensory needs. The District asserts that its plan contains the necessary structure and personnel to provide for Student’s successful transition from the Tustin Center to the YATP and to allow Student to receive educational benefit. To that end, the plan includes positive behavioral programming via two behavior plans, a sensory diet, and an adaptable classroom environment. Moreover, the YATP staff is comprised of highly trained and experienced administrators and teachers who have deliberated exhaustively about Student and are capable of implementing an appropriate transition program for him. The District further asserts that the transition plan also builds in sufficient time for both Student and the YATP staff and related service providers to build relationships allowing them to work well together.
Student’s Contentions
Student contends that the District’s revised transition plan is not appropriate given Student’s severe behavioral and sensory issues. Student further asserts that the District’s plan is fatally flawed in several respects. First, the period of time for the transition is insufficient to build adequate relationships between the YATP staff and Student for a safe transition. Specifically, if Student is not given enough time to familiarize himself with the YATP staff and feel secure around them, his behaviors could escalate into physical aggressions causing serious harm or injury to others or him. Further, the specified amount of time given to YATP staff and related service providers is inadequate for them to learn the numerous “rules” necessary to work with Student. Without sufficient time to learn Student’s “rules,” his behaviors could escalate into physical aggressions. Student also asserts that Student’s hypersensitivity to changes in his surroundings will not adequately addressed by the YATP facility. Specifically, the physical structure does not offer a conducive learning environment due to its level of sensory stimuli.
Student proposes an alternative transition plan which “front loads” the majority of the transition process at the Tustin Center rather than the YATP. The Student’s proposal requires that the YATP staff and related service providers work with Student at the Tustin Center for four months prior to physically transporting Student to the YATP. Overall, the Student’s plan calls for a complete transition of Student to the YATP full-day program by the end of six months.
FINDINGS OF FACTS AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Did the District fail to develop an appropriate plan in the May 25, 2004 individualized education program (IEP) to transition Student from the Tustin Center to the Young Adults Transition Program?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Education Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student including instruction conducted in the classroom, in the home, in hospitals and institutions, and in other settings. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16). The term “related services,” which is also referred to in California as “designated instruction and services” (DIS), includes developmental, corrective, and supportive services that may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363.
An IEP is a written statement that must be developed, reviewed, and revised for each student with a disability. The IEP must include a statement of the goals and objectives, the special education and related services, and of the program modifications or supports for school personnel that are to be provided to enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum, and to be educated and participate with disabled and nondisabled peers in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347; Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343 and 56345.
To determine whether the District provided Student a free appropriate public education, one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s offered and proposed programs. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Rowley Court concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 207-208. De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d at 130 (2d Cir. 1998). A child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. Ms. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997). Furthermore, the amended IDEA specifies additional requirements for the provision of a FAPE that is not in dispute in the present case, such as the obligation to enable the child to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. (See, e.g., 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a).)
To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program must have met the following substantive requirements in order to constitute an appropriate educational program: (1) been designed to meet Student’s unique needs, (2) been reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, and (3) comported with his IEP. (Footnote 10)
Here, the sole issue in dispute is whether the District’s plan proposed at the May 25, 2004 IEP meeting to transition Student from the Tustin Center to the YATP is appropriate under the standards of the IDEA and Rowley. In order to determine if the District offered an appropriate transition plan, the Hearing Officer must first determine Student’s unique needs.
Student’s Unique Needs
Because of Student’s traumatic brain injury, he suffers from deficits in several areas. The parties generally agree that Student has needs in the areas of behavior, sensory processing, independent living and vocational skills, communication and social skills, functional academics, orientation and mobility, and cognitive and executive functioning. However, with respect to the appropriateness of the May 25, 2004 transition plan, only behavior and sensory processing are applicable because they directly impact his ability to transition to the YATP. The parties concur that the other areas of need would be addressed once Student has been fully transitioned and acclimated to the YATP.
Behavior
The parties generally agree that Student has behavioral needs associated with his TBI. Paramount to his behavioral deficits is Student’s rigidity to change and his need for reassurances with predictability of activities and his surroundings. Mother testified that Student’s agitation ranges from simple verbal resistance against non-favored activities to full-blown physical aggression requiring the use of physical restraint for his safety and the safety of others. School psychologist Heather King agreed and added that familiarity and security dominate Student’s ability to maintain interpersonal working relationships with adults. The lack of security creates anxiety within Student causing him to exhibit his maladaptive behaviors. Similarly, both Mother and Gary Strickland, District director of career preparation, also stated that Student requires structure and familiarity with his surroundings and activities. Further, psychologist Thomas Willis, Ph.D., testified that Student must feel a sense of security with persons working with him. Specifically, Student requires others to be both aware of his seizure issues and know how to assist him should a seizure occur. Because of his rigidity, Student struggles with changes in his environment. In addition, he also has difficulties with abrupt scheduling changes. This rigidity is closely associated with his sensory processing needs, to be discussed below.
Although both parties agree about the type of behavioral problems Student exhibits, they disagree as to the frequency and level of this deficit. Specifically, the parties differ in their viewpoints as to the propensity in which Student’s behaviors are aggressive and require physical restraint. The parties also disagree as to Student’s level of need to build rapport to establish working relationships with others.
Propensity for Aggression Requiring Physical Restraint
The Student asserts that the District does not fully comprehend the nature and extent of Student’s behavioral needs as they relate to his susceptibility to engage in aggressive behaviors. Specifically, the Student contends that the District’s proposed transition plan would lead to greater frequency and severity of Student’s physical aggressions that may cause harm to Student and others. Mother stated that Student has made great improvements with his behaviors since attending the May Center through the present. Student has not had a full-blown aggressive outburst requiring physical restraint since October 2003. (Testimony of Charles Hwang) However, Mother notes that near full-blown outbursts occur on nearly a weekly basis. She credits the work and experience of the Tustin Center staff in preventing such events.
Nonetheless, Mother also testified that Student’s past aggressiveness and need for restraint reflect his potential to endanger others and himself. In November 2001 and January 2002, Corey Roberts was involved in situations requiring physical restraint of Student following behavioral outbursts. (Footnote 11) Mr. Hwang also added that in October 2003, Student had another violent physical outburst where four large male staff members were required to restrain Student. Both witnesses and Mother agree that Student is extraordinarily strong for his size. In light of Student’s potential for serious harm, Dr. Willis reiterated his view that Student requires an extended transition period to minimize the potential of such violent outbursts.
In contrast, the District claims that the Student’s characterization of Student’s potential to endanger him and others is inaccurate. During the past school year, Mr. Strickland observed and interacted with Student over twelve hours both in the classroom and during a class field trip. Specifically, Mr. Strickland testified that in his observations of Student and review of his records, Student has made significant strides in his behavior and has not exhibited more than one incident of full-blown aggression during the 2003-2004 school year. In essence, the Student’s fears of his engaging in violent outbursts are not an accurate reflection of his current state. As discussed above, Mr. Hwang testified that Student has only had one incident of aggression requiring physical restraint by Tustin Center staff since October 2003. In addition, data collection of Student’s daily behaviors by Tustin Center staff over the past year does not indicate maladaptive behaviors rising to the level of aggression necessitating physical restraint.
In fact, the rate in which physical aggression occurred between September 2003 and February 13, 2004, was only 0.5% of his intervals of time at the Tustin Center. (Pet. Ex. 525) Roz Ballante, District behavioral program specialist, testified that she reviewed the daily data collection reports and determined that Student’s physically assaultive behaviors have diminished significantly. (Footnote 12) Further, she stated that he is not the same child that returned to California from the May Center three years ago. Moreover, the District points out that Dr. Willis’s concerns about Student’s propensity for violent behavior are not based on the current data. Dr. Willis admitted that he had not prepared an assessment of Student since 2001 and his conclusions were not based on current data. Over the last school year, Dr. Willis had only spent about two hours observing Student. Given Dr. Willis’s admission, the Hearing Officer finds his testimony less credible than the testimonies of Mr. Strickland and Ms. Ballante who offered opinions regarding Student’s current behaviors based on recent data.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District has persuasively shown through recent observations made by Mr. Strickland and the uncontested data collected from the Tustin Center that Student’s propensity for physically assaultive behaviors has diminished. It is uncontested that the Tustin Center’s data collection of Student’s daily behaviors during 2003-2004 school year is accurate. These records note a very small rate of incidence for physically assaultive behavior by Student. Given Dr. Willis’s admission that his opinions are not based on current information, the Hearing Officer determines that his depiction of Student’s behavior do not reflect his present unique needs. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that although Student still has the potential for physically assaultive behavior, his current needs reflect that these behaviors have significantly diminished.
Building Rapport and a Working Relationship
The parties also disagree as the level of rapport that is necessary for Student to build a working relationship with service providers. Each of the Student’s witnesses testified that Student requires time to build rapport and develop relationships with others to successfully implement any educational program. According to Dr. Willis, a working relationship reflects a level of rapport between a person and Student where Student is secure in being alone with that person. (Footnote 13) Dr. Willis’s opinion was equally applicable to related service providers. Dr. Willis expressed concerns that even four months may not be sufficient to build adequate rapport because the transition should occur at a pace comfortable for Student and not for the convenience of others. Instead, he concluded that any transition for Student to a new educational environment must be gradual.
The Student’s other witnesses were also in accord with Dr. Willis’s view. Mother supported Dr. Willis’s testimony with her own observations. She added that Student requires six to eight months to get to know people and become adequately comfortable to work with them. Both Student’s adaptive physical education teacher Charles Hwang and former aide Corey Roberts also agreed that building a relationship adequate for working with Student requires a significant period of time. Although they could not designate a specific duration, both concurred that a period of three weeks prior to the transition to the YATP would be insufficient.
Dr. Willis further testified that the alternative transition plan proposed by Student’s parents reflects Student’s behavioral needs. He explained that District staff must dedicate more time to learn protocols and methods of interaction with Student. Part of this learning process requires District personnel to observe Student. Given Student’s numerous “rules” which must be learned to avoid causing behavioral escalations, time must be allocated to learn these “rules.” (Footnote 14)
Dr. Willis testified that Student must be transitioned gradually to allow him to become aware that a transition is going to take place and give him sufficient time to prepare. In his opinion, Student must build a level of tolerance for any change. In support of his opinions, Dr. Willis referred to the extensive report with behavior intervention and data collection protocols, which he developed in September 2001. (Footnote 15) (Pet. Ex. 214) In Dr. Willis’s report, he documented Student’s behavioral difficulties in conjunction with Student’s ability to transition from the May Center to the Student Center in 2001. Dr. Willis explained, by way of example, that Student’s prior transition from the May Center to the Student Center involved setting a countdown for the days until his move. In that prior transition, Dr. Willis spent four months building a relationship with Student. He also carefully noted the May Center’s intervention strategies and videotaped them as a teaching tool for Student Center staff. Dr. Willis concluded that a high level of attention to moving Student slowly along any transition is necessary for everyone’s safety.
The Student’s witnesses also discounted Student’s friendly and gregarious personality around newly introduced individuals as not indicative of his behavioral deficits. Mother explained that Student could meet and interact with new people with little difficulty. However, she testified that this improvement with initial friendliness does not translate into the ability for Student to successfully work with others. Mother further stated that Student is friendly and gregarious with new people but direct service providers are subject to resistance when asking Student to perform work. She added that establishing a working relationship with Student requires a long period of time. For instance, Tustin Center director Juda Carter testified that she required nine months of contact with Student to develop a working relationship with him. (Footnote 16) Ms. Carter agreed with Mother that a casual, social relationship with Student is different from the relationship that is necessary to allow for educational instruction. She further testified that a casual relationship with Student is insufficient to engage him and successfully permit educational work.
The District does not dispute that building rapport with Student is necessary to create working relationships. However, the District disagrees with the Student’s arguments regarding the amount of time necessary to establish a working relationship and building rapport with Student. Specifically, the District argues that building rapport to allow an appropriate transition can be met by utilizing someone currently working with Student. This contention is supported by Dr. Willis’s admission that Student is able to transition to new environments with the assistance of his aide. Dr. Willis testified that Student is more readily able to make adjustments when accompanied by persons with whom Student has a strong relationship. Such an individual understands Student’s behaviors and potential for escalation. In turn, this person can facilitate better understanding between Student and new service providers. The individual could also ease the introduction of new service providers to Student and help build rapport more quickly than without such a presence. Ultimately, a person with a strong relationship with Student would be able to shorten the time necessary to build rapport and establish a working relationship with new service providers.
The Hearing Officer finds that establishing a working relationship by building rapport between Student and service providers is an area of need. The Hearing Officer also finds that this is a prerequisite to implementing any type of educational program with Student. Although the parties may disagree as to the amount of time that may be necessary to build adequate rapport between Student and service providers, there is no dispute that Student is readily able to build rapport with the assistance of a person with a strong relationship with Student. Correspondingly, the Hearing Officer finds that this area of need may be addressed more readily with someone with whom Student is familiar or he has an established relationship. The Hearing Officer finds that Student’s needs for establishing working relationships are manageable where someone with a strong relationship with Student facilitates the building of rapport between Student and service providers.
Sensory Processing
The parties also generally agree that Student has deficits in the area of sensory processing. As discussed above, Student has difficulties with changes in the physical aspects of his surrounding. Mother and Dr. Willis each testified that Student is hypersensitive to changes in the levels of light and noise. Further, Mother stated that he is also defensive to certain materials he may touch or smell. Dr. King also testified that she observed Student being susceptible to over-stimulation, which causes him to perseverate. Further, he has needs relating to his vestibular processing. (Footnote 17) Student is very conscious of his problems with balance, and fears that awkward movement may set off seizures. The deficits in vestibular processing coupled with his fears cause Student to perseverate regarding seizures and exhibit maladaptive behaviors.
The Hearing Officer finds that to address Student’s sensory processing deficits, he requires an environment that reduces stimuli to his senses that cause Student to escalate behaviorally. In that regard, Student’s educational setting must also allow him relief from overwhelming activity or stimuli. Further, Student would also require a program that identifies items, which could cause him to become anxious or agitated.
Designed to Meet Student’s Needs
The District’s Transition Plan Offer
The District’s May 25, 2004 IEP revised transition plan calls for Student’s transition from the Tustin Center to the YATP in three parts over a five-month period. (Dist. Ex. 148) The testimony of YATP teacher Melanie Lavering and a review of the written plan establish that throughout the process, Student’s current one-to-one aide from the Tustin Center will accompany him. Further, weekly meetings will take place between Student’s parents, and staff from the YATP, District and Tustin Center to discuss the progress of the transition and to make necessary modifications.
The first phase of the plan involves activities prior to Student’s move to the YATP. Ms. Lavering testified that initially, a YATP teacher and two instructional assistants would attend class at the Tustin Center for one week. “They will shadow Student, attending all aspects of his current program.” (Dist. Ex. 148) The YATP teacher will meet with the Tustin Center teacher to review all aspects of his program. Correspondingly, the instructional assistants will confer with Student’s Tustin Center aide to learn techniques that have been effective in the past. (Footnote 18) In addition, District staff responsible for delivering related services will also shadow Student during corresponding service sessions at the Tustin Center. District related services staff would observe and participate in these sessions over a two-week period. In addition, all District staff working with Student will spend a full day at the Tustin Center observing Student during specific times corresponding to their specialization and in other school settings. These observations will be staggered and occur over a two-week period.
Ms. Lavering stated that prior to Student’s physical move to the YATP, Student would make two visits to the new placement. First, Student, his parents, and current aide would attend an informal weekend open house at YATP after Student has met District staff at the Tustin Center. A second visit would take a week later during the regular school day. Student, accompanied by his aide, would be encouraged to participate in preferred activities with his aide during this second visit.
Ms. Lavering explained that the second phase calls for a three-week period of Student’s transitioning into fulltime participation at the YATP class. Over the course of the three weeks, Student’s time spent at the YATP would grow incrementally from initially “checking in” and participating in limited structured activities to near fulltime attendance in the YATP class. Each day during this phase, Student, with his aide, would spend more time at the YATP instead of the Tustin Center.
The final phase calls for a five-month period of the YATP staff and District service providers ultimately assuming all responsibilities for Student’s educational program. The central focus of this period is to gradually diminish the role of Student’s current aide and increase the duties of the YATP staff. Initially, Student’s aide would be directly involved in all activities with Student at the YATP. By the end of the period, his aide would only be on-site to provide support, if needed, whereas the YATP staff would be responsible for Student’s entire program.
In addition to the transition plan, Student’s May 25, 2004 IEP also includes two behavior plans to assist with his transition and educational program at the YATP. Student has both a positive behavior management plan (PBMP) and a behavior intervention plan (BIP) derived from a functional analysis assessment. (Dist. Ex. 86 and 91) These plans include guidelines for working with Student’s behavioral needs and data collection for further evaluation and study in developing interventions and strategies.
The Hearing Officer now turns to determining whether the above plan to transition Student from the Tustin Center to the YATP is designed to meet his needs. As discussed above, the District must establish that its proposed plan was developed to address Student’s unique needs in the areas of behavior and sensory processing.
Behavior
As discussed above, the Hearing Officer determined that Student has behavioral needs that require the building of rapport to establish working relationships with new service providers. The witnesses generally testified that Student must feel secure to engage in his education. Student contends that the District’s plan does not meet this need because it does not provide for a gradual transition. Dr. Willis testified that the District’s proposal does not provide sufficient time for Student to familiarize himself with the YATP staff before physically moving Student to the YATP facility, a new environment. Dr. Willis stated that one week would be insufficient to build enough rapport to establish a working relationship between Student and the YATP staff. Mother added that Student must know that the person working with him understands his fear of seizures and his “rules.”
The District contends that Student’s behavioral needs can be met by having Student’s current aide, Noel Deleon, accompany Student during this process to allow others to build rapport and ultimately working relationships after five months. The District also asserts that Mr. Deleon could facilitate Student’s building rapport with his service providers. In support of the its proposition that Student’s current aide could facilitate the transition process, the District points to Student’s ability to work with occupational therapist Diane Wertheimer-Gale. Ms. Wertheimer-Gale testified that Student was accepting of her as a service provider three weeks after their initial meeting. During the first two weeks, she worked alongside his then occupational therapist. On the third week, she worked with Student with his aide. Following the third week, she was able to work with him alone and, thereafter their working relationship has been smooth. Ms. Wertheimer-Gale’s experience also supports the District’s position that no precise amount of time can be identified to exactly the amount of time necessary to establish a relationship and build rapport with Student. The parties also agree that Student feels secure with Mr. Deleon. Moreover, Ms. Wertheimer-Gale testified credibly that she was able to build rapport and establish an effective working relationship with Student within three weeks through the assistance of his current aide.
The Hearing Officer finds that Student is able to build rapport with the assistance of his current aide Mr. Deleon. The undisputed testimony is that Student is able to transition with the assistance of a person with a strong relationship with Student. (Testimony of Dr. Willis) This ability to transition when facilitated by an aide was exemplified by Ms. Wertheimer-Gale’s experience of working with Student. The Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Willis’s admission and Ms. Wertheimer-Gale’s experience establishes the propriety of having Student’s current aide facilitate his transition process through all phases of the District’s proposed plan. Mr. Deleon would provide the security necessary for Student to be comfortable adjusting to new people. Further, he could also facilitate the interactions with new service providers allowing Student and them to build rapport and establish working relationships readily. The Hearing Officer also finds that because Mr. Deleon can assist new service providers to learn Student’s “rules” while they build rapport with Student, Mr. Deleon’s presence significantly curtails the probability of Student exhibiting problem behaviors including physical aggressions.
Although not dispositive due to its remoteness in time, Student’s transition from the May Center to the Student Center in May 2001 is also instructive and lends support to the adequacy of the District’s plan. During that transition, May Center staff that had been working with him for approximately three years was able to successfully assist Student in his transition in only three weeks. This is at a time where Student’s aggressive behaviors were more frequent and involved a cross-country move. Prior to the move, Student had never visited the Student Center nor met any staff other than Dr. Willis, yet he was able to make a “superb” transition. (Testimony of Dr. Willis)
Further, the witnesses also agree and establish that Student is friendly and gregarious to new people. (Testimony of Mother and Mr. Strickland) Although his initial affable disposition is not sufficient for a working relationship, it nonetheless reflects Student’s ability to meet new people to begin establishing rapport. As a fail-safe measure, the District’s plan also includes weekly meeting involving Tustin Center, YATP and related services personnel to discuss the transition’s progress and make changes where necessary. (Dist. Ex. 148) The meetings ensure that the transition takes place on a pace amenable to Student. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed plan with its weekly meetings and focusing on Student’s inherent friendliness coupled with the presence of Student’s aide throughout the transition does, in fact, meet his behavioral needs in facilitating the building of rapport and working relationships with new service providers.
Transition to the YATP over three weeks
In addition, Student also contends that the proposed transition plan is inappropriate because it moves Student to the YATP setting prematurely. Dr. Willis testified that the transition of YATP staff must take place before moving Student into the new environment. He assisted in the development of the Student’s parents’ proposed transition plan, which calls for the YATP staff to work with Student for four months at the Tustin Center prior to moving him to the YATP physical site. Dr. Willis stated that given the amount of changes in Student’s educational program with new personnel, the additional change of location would adversely affect him by adding too many changes at once and over-stimulating him. According to Dr. Willis, the new set of changes could act as “settling events” which would affect Student’s reaction to everyday antecedents. Dr. Willis testified that under the District’s plan, Student might not be able to tolerate the same antecedents depending on the day. He stated that one event that may be tolerable to Student on one day might not be tolerable the next day given all the changes in his daily routine.
In response, the District offered the testimony of several witnesses, most notably Dr. Heather King. (Footnote 19) In her approximately fifty hours of studying Student’s records, observing Student and preparing for IEP meetings, Dr. King testified that four months of the YATP staff at the Tustin Center is unnecessary and potentially detrimental to Student. She stated that the parents’ plan would not amount to a true transition. In her opinion, Student needs to be transitioned to his new environment as soon as possible rather than extending his presence at the current location. In Dr. King’s opinion, the practical result of the Student’s proposed four-month time frame for the YATP staff would cause Student confusion between the two settings and the people associated with those settings.
Dr. Paul Alan Dores reiterated Dr. King’s opinion and concerns over the proposed time to be spent at the Tustin Center. (Footnote 20) Dr. Dores testified that the suggested time by Student’s parents is too long making the transition difficult for Student to understand that the new environment is a unique setting. Dr. Dores dismissed Student’s parents’ plan as unhelpful because skills acquired in an old environment would not necessarily be applicable or transferable to the new environment. Dr. Dores noted that in the past, Student has had multiple transitions with new settings, teachers, and aides in both Massachusetts and California. In each situation, the transitions focused on the new setting and were manageable. Moreover, he asserted that the parents’ suggested timeframe is not supported by any data. Here, the Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Drs. King and Dores persuasive. Notably, Dr. King in forming her opinion, observed Student at the Tustin Center on three separate occasions for several hours at a time. Both psychologists based their testimony on the most recent data regarding Student, the Hearing Officer finds their opinions convincing compared to Dr. Willis’s opinion, which did not take into account recent information about Student.
In addition, Mother and Dr. Willis both admitted that Student is better able to adjust to new environments than in the past. As discussed above, the Hearing Officer has found that Student is better able to undergo changes with the assistance of his current aide. Dr. Willis also noted that Student could traverse environmental changes with help from someone possessing a strong relationship with Student. The Hearing Officer finds that Mr. Deleon would also be present to assist in making this adjustment. Given the credible opinions of Drs. Dores and King coupled with the Student’s witnesses’ admission that Student is able to adjust to new environments, the Hearing Officer determines that Student does not require an extended period of time at the Tustin Center to effectuate a proper transition. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s behavioral needs would be met by the District’s proposed fulltime transition to the YATP site over the course of three weeks.
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that District’s proposed transition plan is designed to meet Student’s behavioral needs. The program addresses his security issues by including his current aide as a necessary element to allow Student to build rapport and working relationships with new people. The program also properly focuses on moving Student to his new placement, the YATP, as quickly as possible, to encourage acclimation to the new environment. The Hearing Officer also notes that the District’s proposed plan includes a fail-safe measure of weekly meetings between all interested parties to review the transition’s progress and discuss modifications to address concerns during the process. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed transition plan is designed to meet his behavior needs.
Sensory Processing
The Student also claims that the District’s proposed transition plan is inappropriate because the physical environment of the YATP does not meet Student’s sensory processing needs. Dr. Willis testified that he visited the YATP in October 2003. He visited the three classrooms on the site and determined that two of the classrooms were too noisy for Student. Specifically, he noted that the two classrooms allowed outside traffic noise to “stream” inside. Further, he described the environment as “unusual” because of the configuration of the room as it accommodates the program’s other students. Specifically, he expressed concerns that the room’s configuration is geared towards promoting activity among the other students and would serve to over-stimulate Student’s senses. Given the other students’ activities and the noise from the outside, Dr. Willis concluded that these distractions could overwhelm Student’s senses and cause escalation in his maladaptive behaviors.
In response, the District points to services it included in the May 25, 2004 IEP. First, the District developed a sensory diet designed specifically to address Student’s sensory needs. (Footnote 21) District occupational therapist Claudia Ginsberg-Brown testified that Student’s sensory diet contains protocols to assist Student perform at an optimum level. (Footnote 22) It specifically targets items, which may cause Student to become agitated or anxious. Ms. Ginsberg-Brown stated that the sensory diet would be used in conjunction with Student’s two behavioral plans to control his behaviors and create a “comfort zone” where information Student receives would not be overwhelming. Moreover, the protocols do not require application by an occupational therapist; rather any trained staff member may implement the protocols. Ms. Ginsberg-Brown added that the sensory diet was developed with the assistance of Student’s current teacher, aide and occupational therapist at the Tustin Center.
Further, the District provided evidence that the YATP’s physical site is adaptable to address situations where Student’s senses may be overwhelmed. Gary Strickland, director of career preparation, testified that the YAPT site consists of four portable classrooms that are connected. Two of the main classrooms are vividly ornate and the majority of students perform their activities within these rooms. However, one of the classrooms is sparsely decorated and frequently remains empty. This location is not as subject to street noise and serves as a quiet room that would be available to assist Student with sensory issues.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s transition plan does meet Student’s sensory processing deficits. Ms. Ginsberg-Brown testified without contradiction that the sensory diet is an effective tool in addressing Student’s sensory processing needs and controlling behaviors. In addition, Mr. Strickland also testified without contradiction that the YATP’s physical site could be adapted to provide Student relief from overwhelming sensory stimuli and to resolve concerns expressed by Dr. Willis. Because the District has shown that it provides a sound sensory diet and an adaptable physical environment at the YATP, the Hearing Officer finds that the May 25, 2004 IEP’s transition plan is proper to meet his sensory processing needs.
**** In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed transition plan from the May 25, 2004 IEP is designed to meet Student’s unique needs. The District has produced persuasive evidence that Student’s behavioral needs will be addressed by the proposed plan. Likewise, the District has also provided convincing evidence that Student’s sensory processing deficits will be addressed at the YATP site.
Calculated to Provide Some Educational Benefit
As discussed above, the Hearing Officer determines that the District proposed transition plan is designed to meet Student’s behavior and sensory processing needs. Because of the structure and services included in the plan, Student’s needs in these areas are likely to be addressed. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed transition plan is also calculated to provide some educational benefit to Student.
Conforms to the IEP
The Student did not raise the issue of whether the District conformed to elements of the proposed transition plan. Correspondingly, the Hearing Officer refrains from analyzing this element of the Rowley test.
ORDER
1. The District may begin implementing the plan to transition Student from the Tustin Center to the YATP proposed in the May 25, 2004 IEP and Student’s parents shall make Student available for the transition within 15 calendar days of the issuance of this Decision.
2. All of the Student’s requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute.
The District prevailed on the sole issue in this matter.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505 (i).
Date: August 19, 2004 My T. Huynh, Hearing OfficerCalifornia Special Education Hearing Office
During the course of the hearing, the parties stipulated to resolving other issues raised by the Petitioner and dismissed them from the action. This Decision reflects the sole issue remaining in dispute.
2 A partial complex seizure is a seizure associated with loss of consciousness but not involving the entire body. (Testimony of school nurse Mary Ann Kelly)
3 In 1999, a vagel nerve stimulator (VNS) was surgically implanted into Student chest. The VNS is a device that decreases the number, frequency, duration and severity of seizures by producing an electronic pulse.
4 Mother stated that Student was suffering from undiagnosed nerve pain caused by the severing of the trigeminal nerve. The trigeminal nerve is located in the cranial cavity.
5 Perseveration is the uncontrollable repetition of a particular response, such as a word, phrase, or gesture, despite the absence or cessation of the stimulus.
6 Mother testified that on two occasions, Student returned home without any educational programming immediately in place. Instead, he received home teaching and a one-to-one aide some time later.
7 By 1998, Student was becoming a large boy and difficult for Mother to physically manage. Today, Student is nearly six feet tall and weighs approximately 180 pounds.
8 As a result of Student’s injuries to both his eyes and limited vision, Student is now legally blind.
9 The Student Center is named after the Student.
10 Federal and State law also require that districts educate disabled children in the least restrictive environment, with removal from the regular education environment occurring only when the nature and severity of the children’s disabilities is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56301. Student does not contend that his educational placements have not been in the least restrictive environment as required by law.
11 Mr. Roberts recalled suffering a sprained wrist, torn neck muscles, concussion, scratches and bite marks from Student’s attacks. He also recalls that two additional people were required to separate Student from himself. At the time, Student was only 140 pounds and today he weighs over 180 pounds.
12 Ms. Ballante holds a master’s degree in education and five teaching credentials. Further, she holds a credential as a behavior intervention case manager (BICM)
16 Dr. Willis holds a Ph.D. in psychology from UCLA. He has worked in the area of behavioral psychology for over thirty years and is currently the associate director for Applied Behavior Analysis. He has held that title since 1981. (Pet. Ex. 21)
17 Occupational therapist Claudia Ginsberg-Brown testified that vestibular processing encompasses proprioception, which is a sense that allows the brain to process information regarding the body’s relationship to space. It also controls the body’s sense of balance.
18 Focus will be placed on the following: learning current verbal cues and scripted language, reviewing current behavior management techniques, reviewing medical data, observing and learning data collection methods, reviewing academic instructional techniques and reviewing the format of any existing community based/vocational instruction.
19 Dr. King holds a Ph.D. in psychology and credentials in both teaching and psychology. She has been working in the field of psychology since 1989.
20 Dr. Dores holds a Ph.D. in psychology and is a licensed psychologist. His primary area of expertise is behavior disorders, developmental disabilities, and TBI. He has been working with TBI patients since 1988.
21 The sensory diet was developed and originally offered at Student’s March 8, 2004 IEP meeting. It is incorporated by reference into the May 25, 2004 IEP addendum.
22 Ms. Ginsberg-Brown holds a master’s degree in occupational therapy and has served as the District’s manager of special services and supervising occupational therapist for the past four years.
