California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 14, 2004

Student v. Kern High School District (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 2385-04 · Hearing Officer Terrence B. Ohler

Kern High School District's full-time AIM behavior program offer was too restrictive; Hearing Officer orders new IEP and compensatory services.

Split decision: student prevailed on 4 of 16 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

Kern High School District and a student's parents filed hearing requests that were combined into one case. The student was 14 and in ninth grade. He was eligible for special education under "mental retardation," now called intellectual disability. He also had Prader-Willi syndrome and serious behavior and toileting needs. He moved from Bakersfield City School District and attended Golden Valley High School for 15 days. After several behavior incidents, the District offered a full-time placement in its Alternative Instructional Methods (AIM) program on the Vista West alternative school campus. The parents refused and kept him home.

The Hearing Officer found no procedural violations. Only one special education teacher had to attend the IEP meetings, no nurse was required, and the health assessment was not yet due. During the 30-day interim period, the District properly followed the prior district's IEP. It did not have to follow a June 2004 behavior support plan (BSP) that was never part of that IEP. The claims about health, toileting, physical therapy, and a calculator failed. But the academic, adapted physical education, and behavior goals were not individualized or measurable. The District adopted the BSP on paper but never made sure staff used it. AIM offered no mainstreaming and was not the least restrictive environment. The District was ordered to provide 4 hours of adapted physical education and 6 hours of one-to-one speech therapy, hold an IEP meeting by January 14, 2005, and give the BSP to all staff.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied least restrictive environment rules to a behavior-based placement. A district urging a fully separate program had to show it had considered behavior supports in a less restrictive setting. Behavior incidents alone were not enough. Adopting a behavior plan on paper without giving it to staff counted as a failure to implement.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1A1. Whether the District failed to ensure that all of Student's special education teachers attended the September 10 and 15, 2004 IEP meetings

    The law requires only one special education teacher of the child at the IEP meeting, and the case manager attended both meetings.

  2. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1A2. Whether the District failed to ensure that a nurse attended the September 10 and 15, 2004 IEP meetings

    A school nurse is not a required IEP team member, and no health assessment was being reviewed at those meetings.

  3. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 1A3. Whether the District failed to complete a health assessment before the September 10 and 15, 2004 IEP meetings

    The 50-day assessment timeline had not run for a student who entered the District on August 30, 2004, so there was no violation.

  4. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue 1B-interim (speech). Whether Student received the speech and language therapy required by the prior district's March 2, 2004 IEP during the interim period

    Student received three 30-minute sessions over three weeks of attendance; the session missed on September 10 was in effect made up later.

  5. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue 1B-interim (PT). Whether the District implemented the physical therapy required by the March 2, 2004 IEP before the September 10, 2004 IEP meeting

    Undisputed testimony showed the District implemented the prior IEP, including physical therapy, through September 10, 2004.

  6. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue 1B-interim (BSP). Whether the District was required to implement the City District's June 8, 2004 behavior support plan before the September 10, 2004 IEP meeting

    The BSP was not attached to or adopted into the prior IEP, so under Education Code section 56325 the District did not have to follow it, including its toileting steps, during the interim period.

  7. Student prevailed in partIEP content

    Issue 1B1a. Whether the goals and benchmarks in the September 15, 2004 IEP are too vague and not individualized to meet Student's unique needs

    Academic goals written for Golden Valley's academic program did not fit Student's need for functional academics, and the adapted PE and behavior goals were vague and not measurable; no self-help goal was shown to be needed.

  8. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1B1b. Whether the District's program addresses Student's behavioral needs

    AIM could appropriately address Student's behavior needs with a proper behavior plan; goal and implementation claims were decided separately.

  9. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1B1c. Whether the District failed to address Student's health needs (training in Prader-Willi syndrome, health monitoring plan, dietary plan, glasses, recliner, limits on sitting)

    The District acted reasonably on the information it had by obtaining consent for a health assessment, and the parents had not made Student available to complete it.

  10. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 1B1d. Whether the District's offer should have included a toileting plan

    The District adopted a two-hour bathroom schedule and the BSP's toileting steps, no toileting incidents occurred afterward, and further needs can be addressed after the health assessment.

  11. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1B1e. Whether Student requires 30 minutes per week of physical therapy rather than adapted physical education

    The District physical therapist's unopposed opinion supported adapted PE four times a week for 20 minutes, with PT consultation, as meeting Student's needs.

  12. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1B1f. Whether Student must be allowed a laptop, a calculator, and computer programs for home use

    The parties agreed Student could use a parent-provided laptop; there was no showing that a calculator or home software was needed for Student to benefit from his education.

  13. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue 1B2a. Whether the District provided the speech and language therapy required by Student's IEP after September 10, 2004

    Speech services matched the IEP through September 29, 2004; services missed after Student's removal were addressed under Issue 2.

  14. Student prevailedImplementation

    Issue 1B2b. Whether the District implemented the City District's June 8, 2004 BSP after adopting it on September 10, 2004

    The District conceded staff did not use the adopted BSP and did not show that teachers or the 1:1 aide received it or were told to follow it.

  15. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1B3. Whether the District's offered placement in the AIM program provides Student an education in the least restrictive environment

    The District did not prove that full-time AIM with no mainstreaming was the LRE and did not consider behavior supports in a less restrictive setting; behavior incidents alone did not justify it. Student's request for a specific Golden Valley class was not granted.

  16. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2. If the District failed to provide or offer a FAPE for the 2004-2005 regular school year, is Student entitled to compensatory education?

    The parents were justified in refusing AIM, so Student was awarded 12 adapted PE sessions and 12 one-to-one speech sessions for services missed after September 29, 2004.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Compensatory education. Twelve 20-minute sessions of adapted PE (4 hours), in addition to regular services, all to be delivered by June 15, 2005 on a schedule set by the IEP team.
  • Compensatory education. Twelve 30-minute one-to-one sessions of speech and language therapy (6 hours), in addition to regular services, all to be delivered by June 15, 2005.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. By January 14, 2005, convene an IEP meeting and develop a new IEP that: (A) offers an LRE placement consistent with the decision, which found Student needs a self-contained functional academic program taught by a special education teacher, with a low student-to-adult ratio, behavior supports, and mainstreaming opportunities; (B) replaces the Math 2A, Reading Comprehension 1, Reading 1, and Written and Oral Language goals with functional academic goals; (C) revises the Adaptive P.E. and BSP Behavioral goals; (D) states whether a 1:1 aide will be provided or how supervision will be ensured when food is present and during toileting; (E) states what measures will protect Student from his escape risk.
  • Order to provide or change services. The District must give all of Student's teachers, aides, and related service providers a copy of the City District's June 8, 2004 BSP and instruct them to follow it.

Total: 10 hours of compensatory services

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range; Gregory K. v. Longview; Sacramento City USD v. Rachel H.; Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Educ.; Seattle Sch. Dist. v. B.S.; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup; Burlington; Adams v. State of Oregon; Honig v. Doe; Walczak; Kevin G. v. Cranston; Barnett v. Fairfax County; Cal. Educ. Code § 56325

People named in the decision

  • Carissa Krizo, program specialist, Kern High School District, Golden Valley High School
  • Patricia Young, special education coordinator, Kern High School District
  • Misty Thomas, special education teacher and case manager, Kern High School District
  • Tami Richardson, special education teacher, Kern High School District
  • Richard Davis, special education teacher, Kern High School District
  • Sam Rufus, campus security officer, Kern High School District
  • Jeannie Jorgenson, special education teacher (testified about AIM program), Kern High School District
  • Gina Gordon-Lopez, school psychologist, Kern High School District
  • Sherilyn Sarff, speech-language pathologist, Kern High School District
  • Sean Lopez, 1:1 aide, Kern High School District
  • Chris Thompson, aide, Kern High School District
  • Officer Ruiz, campus security officer, Kern High School District
  • Bridget DeLouth, healthcare specialist, Kern High School District
  • Sissy Tran, drafter of behavior goals (did not testify), Kern High School District
  • Jack Lollar, physical therapist, Kern High School District
  • Brenda Pulskamp, school nurse, Kern High School District
  • Elliott Hardamon, special education teacher (former 8th grade teacher), witness for Student, Bakersfield City School District
  • Hilda Rios, aide, witness for Student, Bakersfield City School District
  • Shelly Meagher, signer of June 8, 2004 behavior support plan, Bakersfield City School District
  • Patty Beckwith, dietitian, University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA)
  • Micky Hennen, educational advocate for Student
  • Stacey Inman, attorney for District
  • Donalee Huffman, attorney for Student

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Terrence Ohler, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Bakersfield, California, on October 20, 21, 22, 26, 27, 28, and 29 and November 2, 3, and 4, 2004. This matter also was heard briefly by telephone on November 9, 2004.

Kern High School District (District) was represented by attorney Stacey Inman. Also present on the District’s behalf was Carissa Krizo, the District’s program specialist at Golden Valley High School, and at times, Patricia Young, the District’s special education coordinator. STUDENT was represented by attorney Donalee Huffman and educational advocate Micky Hennen. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf were, at times, his MOTHER, and his FATHER.

The District called the following witnesses: Misty Thomas, special education teacher for the District; Patricia Young, special education coordinator for the District; Tami Richardson, special education teacher for the District; Carissa Krizo, program specialist for the District at Golden Valley High School; Richard Davis, special education teacher for the District; Sam Rufus, campus security officer for the District; Jeannie Jorgenson, special education teacher for the District; Gina Gordon-Lopez, school psychologist for the District; and Sherilyn Sarff, speech and language pathologist for the District. Student called the following witnesses: FATHER; Hilda Rios, an aide for the Bakersfield City School District (City District); and Elliott Hardamon, a special education teacher for City District.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments, the matter was submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

A. Student’s Motion to Change Hearing Location and Subsequent Motion to Continue the Hearing

On November 1, 2004, after seven days of hearing had been completed, the Hearing Office received the Student’s written request to change the hearing location. No written opposition was received from the District. At the hearing on November 2, 2004, the Hearing Officer considered Student’s motion and heard oral arguments from both parties. Student contended that his parents had become very uncomfortable with the place of hearing on October 29, 2004. Student contended that his SISTER was not permitted to enter the hearing room until District personnel checked with other District personnel in the hearing room. Student also contended that on one occasion, the police officer re-entered the hearing room immediately after his AUNT came into the hearing room to observe. The District contended that no cause had been shown for moving the hearing location.

The Hearing Officer ruled that no good cause had been shown for changing the hearing location. The Hearing Officer found that the hearing location remained “reasonably convenient” to the parents and the pupil. (See Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(b).) The Hearing Officer was not persuaded that the incidents alleged above with respect to the sister and aunt warranted a change in hearing location. With respect to STUDENT’s sister, the Hearing Officer indicated that the District had not acted improperly in identifying the observer and ensuring she had the right to enter the hearing room. With respect to STUDENT’s aunt, the Hearing Officer indicated there was no showing that the police officer’s re-entry into the hearing room at the same time as the observer was anything more than a coincidence. Nevertheless, the Hearing Officer instructed the District’s counsel to inform District personnel that they should treat observers respectfully. He also ruled that a police officer should be present at all times during the hearing to avoid the appearance that the officer was only present at hearing when a perceived threat was present in the hearing room. (footnote 1)

After the motion to change the hearing location was denied, Student immediately made a motion to continue the hearing so that he could seek judicial review of the Hearing Officer’s ruling denying a change of hearing location. Without specifying a date, Student requested a continuance until such time as a court ruled on his request. The District opposed the request for a continuance, noting that this was a consolidated case to which the District had a right to quick resolution and that it was unaware of any authority permitting an interlocutory appeal of a denial of a motion to change the hearing location. The Hearing Officer denied Student’s motion for a continuance as no good cause had been demonstrated. Special education law mandates speedy resolution of due process disputes, and hearings may be continued only for good cause. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(f).) Generally, a written decision in a due process hearing must be rendered within forty-five days from the date the Hearing Office receives a request for hearing. (Id.) “Good cause” must be construed narrowly in light of the mandate for speedy resolution of disputes. The parties did not cite any authority either for an interlocutory challenge to a ruling that denies a change of hearing location or for a continuance of the hearing while such a challenge is adjudicated, and the Hearing Officer was unaware of any such authority. Thus, the Hearing Officer determined that Student had failed to demonstrate good cause for a continuance.

B. The Hearing Officer’s Taking of Additional Testimony After the Parties Had Rested

Late on November 4, 2004, the parties rested their respective cases. The parties agreed to conduct a telephone conference on November 5, 2004, so that the Hearing Officer could discuss closing briefs and other miscellaneous matters with the parties. During the telephone conference on November 5, 2004, the Hearing Officer set a deadline for closing briefs, clarified the nature of the parties’ contentions on some issues, and determined that additional evidence was needed on selected issues, such as what speech and language services the District had actually provided and what individualized education program (IEP) the District had been following for Student from August 30, 2004, through September 10, 2004. The District moved to reopen the case to present testimony on these issues, which was opposed by the Student. The Hearing Officer suggested that the parties might eliminate the need for additional testimony if they could reach a stipulation regarding these issues. The Hearing Officer scheduled another telephone conference for November 9, 2004, and instructed the District to have witnesses available to testify by phone in the event the parties had not reached a stipulation.

During the telephone conference on November 9, 2004, the parties indicated they had not reached a stipulation to resolve the issues, and Student objected to the taking of additional evidence, noting that both parties had rested. The District did not oppose the Hearing Officer’s request to take additional evidence, although it indicated that it believed the information being sought had already been elicited from its witnesses. The Hearing Officer overruled the Student’s objection, noting that the Hearing Officer believed the additional information might be important to him in writing a decision. After administering an oath to each witness, the Hearing Officer asked questions of Ms. Sarff and then of Ms. Young. Each party was given the opportunity to ask questions of each witness. After the testimony of Ms. Young, no more evidence was presented by either party.

ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING

1. Has the District provided and offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2004-2005 regular school year?

2. If the District has failed to provide or offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 regular school year, is he entitled to compensatory education?

CONTENTIONS

Student contends that the District has not provided and offered him a FAPE for the 2004-2005 regular school year because it committed numerous procedural and substantive violations. The parties stipulated that the time span at issue is from August 30, 2004, through June 9, 2005. As to Student’s procedural contentions, he asserts that each of his special education teachers should have attended the September 10 and 15, 2004 individualized education program (IEP) meetings. While Student concedes that Ms. Thomas was present at both meetings, he contends Mr. Davis and Ms. Richardson should have attended the meetings. Furthermore, Student contends that the District should have completed a health assessment prior to the September 10 and 15, 2004 IEP meetings. (footnote 2) In addition, Student contends that a District nurse should have attended the September 10 and 15, 2004 IEP meetings but did not. With respect to procedural contentions, the District responds that the law only requires that one special education teacher attend the IEP meetings, that the District was not required to complete a health assessment by the time of the September 10 and 15 IEP meetings, that FATHER executed a consent for a health assessment at the September 15, 2004 IEP meeting, that the parents have not cooperated with the District’s attempts to perform the health assessment, and that the District was not required to have a nurse present at the IEP meetings.

As to Student’s substantive contentions, he asserts that the District’s proposed placement in the Alternative Instructional Methods (AIM) program does not provide a FAPE for numerous reasons. First, Student contends AIM is too restrictive an environment. Student contends the AIM program is segregated from the general school population and does not provide opportunities for mainstreaming. Second, Student contends that the AIM placement is primarily intended to address and contain his behaviors, but not to address his other needs. Specifically, Student asserts that AIM’s bathroom facilities are insufficient because they do not contain a shower, that AIM is not set up to teach him functional living skills, and that AIM would not address his physical therapy needs. Third, Student contends AIM is unsafe and unhealthy. He asserts that the AIM program is located on the Vista West High School (Vista West) campus, which is an alternative school. He asserts that he would be vulnerable to the alternative education population of students at Vista West. He also asserts that while the campus is fenced, it does not have locked gates. Consequently, he contends he could easily escape and become injured on an adjacent highway. He further asserts the fumes from the adjacent highway and nearby oil refinery may be injurious to his health.

Additionally, Student contends that the District should have followed, but did not follow, a behavioral support plan developed by his prior school district, Bakersfield City School District (City District), which was signed by his parents on June 8, 2004 (City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP). Student contends that the District’s failure to follow the BSP exacerbated his behavioral incidents that occurred in September 2004, which are described more fully below. Student also contends that the goals and benchmarks presented by the District with respect to behavior are vague and that there are no present levels of performance stated to use as a baseline for measurement.

Student also contends that the District’s offer should have included a toileting plan. Student contends a plan should have been developed that instructs District personnel on how to spot cues that he needs to use the bathroom given his problems with bowel control, that addresses his tendency to eat or play with his feces, that instructs his aide not to leave him unattended in the bathroom, that addresses procedures for safely cleaning him and the surrounding environment after a toileting accident and identifies where safety supplies were kept, and that specifies that District personnel, not his parents, are responsible for cleaning toileting accidents at school. Although some of this information is contained in the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP, Student contends District personnel did not follow that information. (Footnote 3)

Student further contends that he has not received the physical therapy services and speech and language services to which he is entitled. Student also contends that the District’s offer fails to address his health needs. Specifically, Student contends that the District failed to provide aides and teachers properly trained in Prader-Willi syndrome (PWS). One of Student’s exhibits describes PWS as a complex genetic disorder that typically causes low muscle tone, short stature, incomplete sexual development, cognitive disabilities, problem behaviors, and a chronic feeling of hunger that can lead to excessive eating and life-threatening obesity. (Student’s Exhibit B-10. ) (Footnote 4) Furthermore, Student contends there should be a health plan related to the District’s monitoring of his oxygen tanks, glucose level, heart rate, and pulse rate. Student contends the District made him do the monitoring himself. He contends the plan should include the daily charting of levels and rates and that the plan should address how to use the monitoring equipment and other equipment such as his scooter and walker. He contends the plan should specify how District personnel will ensure he does not sit for more than one hour at a time. Student contends there should be a dietary plan offered so that he will not eat too much and so that his parents will be aware of what he ate during the day. Student contends he should have access to a recliner for napping and for relieving pressure on his legs. Student also contends there should be a plan to ensure he wears his glasses.

Finally, Student contends that the District’s offer does not meet his unique needs because the goals and benchmarks are too vague and were preprinted without being individualized for him. In addition, Student contends goals and benchmarks should be included to address functional living skills. (Footnote 5)

As a consequence of the District’s allegedly deficient offer, Student contends that he is entitled to remain at the school where he started the school year, Golden Valley High School (Golden Valley). However, Student contends he should be placed in a self-contained classroom at Golden Valley, which the District has described as a class for lower functioning autistic students. Student is also requesting compensatory education, but only for allegedly missed sessions of speech and language therapy and physical therapy. Student requests that the IEP be amended to include the requisite toileting and health related plans mentioned above, to clarify the meaning of goals and benchmarks, and to include functional living goals and benchmarks. In addition, Student requests that he be permitted to use a laptop computer, a calculator, and to bring home computer programs to be installed on his home computer. Finally, Student requests that his father be allowed to act as his aide until an aide is properly trained. (Footnote 6)

The District responds that it has provided and offered Student a FAPE for the 2004-2005 regular school year and that all of Student’s claims are without merit. The District contends that AIM will address STUDENT’s needs. With respect to STUDENT’s behavioral needs, the District contends that without knowing whether the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP had been approved by any prior IEP team, the District adopted the plan at its first IEP meeting for STUDENT during the September 10, 2004 IEP but that it had no need to follow the plan thereafter. The District contends that it was entitled to follow the City District’s last agreed upon IEP dated March 2, 2004, until it convened its own IEP meeting on September 10, 2004. With respect to STUDENT’s toileting needs, the District contends the City District did not have a toileting plan to follow and that STUDENT was placed on a two-hour toileting schedule pursuant to the District’s September 10, 2004 IEP. The District contends that when the on-going health assessment is completed, the IEP team will further address STUDENT’s toileting needs. As to STUDENT’s health needs, the District contends such needs will be addressed after the on-going health assessment has been completed. Nevertheless, the District notes that it has attempted to assist in addressing STUDENT’s dietary needs. As to goals and benchmarks, the District contends they are sufficient. The District requests an order that it has provided and offered a FAPE.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a fourteen-year-old student who is receiving special education because of mental retardation. STUDENT has also been diagnosed with Prader-Willi syndrome (PWS), described above. Additionally, he has bowing of his legs, which makes it difficult to walk and participate in physical activities. (Footnote 7) Due to his obesity and leg problems, STUDENT uses what the parties have referred to as an electric scooter to transport himself, which is his own personal property. (See Exhibit FFF.) While at Golden Valley, he also has used an electric wheelchair, which is the District’s property. (See Exhibit 40.) STUDENT has apparently been diagnosed with morbid obesity, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, asthma, sleep apnea, and thyroid disease, although no medical testimony was presented to describe these conditions or to elaborate on the nature of how these conditions affect STUDENT in the educational setting. (Footnote 8) (Exhibit 21.) He requires continuous oxygen to maintain adequate oxygen saturation.

By the conclusion of the due process hearing, STUDENT had attended the District’s schools for less than one month because his parents withdrew STUDENT from the District in late September 2004 pending a decision in this case. Prior to attending school in the District, STUDENT had attended eighth grade in the Bakersfield City School District (City District). STUDENT’s eighth grade class was self-contained and consisted of four students, including STUDENT. Mr. Hardamon, who was STUDENT’s eighth grade teacher, described the class as a pilot program for mentally retarded and emotionally disturbed students. For ninth grade, STUDENT changed school districts and began attending the District on August 30, 2004.

In May 2004, prior to STUDENT attending the District, STUDENT’s parents discussed his transfer to the District with Ms. Young, the District’s special education coordinator. On June 1, 2004, Ms. Young met FATHER at STUDENT’s junior high school. Although FATHER was upset that District personnel had not participated in the City District’s IEP meetings, Ms. Young apologized, expressed to FATHER that she hoped that the parents could have a fresh start in the District, and asked FATHER to write out a “wish list” of what he would like to see in the District’s program for STUDENT. She also met STUDENT briefly at a school function in a park later that day. By letter dated June 7, 2004, PARENTS stated their wish list in response to Ms. Young’s request. Among other things, the letter expresses the parents’ “wish to have an Intra-District transfer so STUDENT will be allowed to attend Golden Valley High, because we have trust in the Dean of Students, and STUDENT has met with Carissa Krizo on June 7, 2004 and he felt comfortable with her.” (Exhibit 25.) The letter also indicates that the parents would like STUDENT “to experience changing classes even if it may not be an all day routine.” Ms. Krizo, the program specialist at Golden Valley High School, met STUDENT, as well as FATHER, on June 7, 2004. Although FATHER expressed that he wanted to register STUDENT for Golden Valley right then, Ms. Krizo explained that he could not because it was not her decision whether STUDENT could attend Golden Valley.

Although Ms. Young recommended to the District on June 30, 2004, that South High School be STUDENT’s placement (see Exhibit 26), Ms. Young testified that the District did not offer South High School to STUDENT’s parents because FATHER had previously expressed that he wanted STUDENT to attend Golden Valley and because two principals in the District, who had some prior knowledge of FATHER, had informed her that FATHER was unlikely to change his mind once he made a decision. Ms. Young testified that the District also had considered recommending West High School but did not for the same reasons. Eventually, on August 20, 2004, Ms. Young, in consultation with other District personnel, decided to accommodate the parents’ request and approved the intra-District transfer for STUDENT to attend Golden Valley for the 2004-2005 school year. The parties agree that STUDENT began attending Golden Valley on August 30, 2004. According to Ms. Young, until the District convened its first IEP meeting for STUDENT on September 10, 2004, the District attempted to implement the City District’s IEP of March 2, 2004, at Golden Valley. STUDENT was assigned a one-to-one aide, Mr. Sean Lopez. Ms. Krizo developed STUDENT’s class schedule at Golden Valley, which included separate classrooms for math, choir, English, social studies, adapted physical education, and another social studies class. (Footnote 9) Choir and adapted physical education were classes where STUDENT was mainstreamed with the general education population.

On September 1, 2004, his third day at Golden Valley, STUDENT indicated he was not feeling well. Mr. Lopez accompanied him to the office to call his parents. While waiting for STUDENT’s parents, STUDENT began disassembling parts to his scooter and called Mr. Lopez profanities when directed to stop. When Mr. Lopez directed STUDENT to wait outside for his parents, STUDENT escaped off school grounds, driving his scooter down an adjacent street. When STUDENT returned to the campus a few minutes later, numerous District personnel met him. At one point, STUDENT indicated he did not have to talk to them, called them a profanity, drove off in his scooter despite requests to stop, and rammed into a gate. When the security officer, Officer Ruiz, took the key from the scooter, STUDENT cried and sat on the ground in the sun. When the District’s healthcare specialist, Ms. Bridget DeLouth (phonetic), tried to convince STUDENT to move into the shade, he called her profanities. When Officer Ruiz attempted to call STUDENT’s grandmother on STUDENT’s cell phone, STUDENT knocked the phone out of the officer’s hand. Eventually, STUDENT’s parents arrived at about 10:00 a.m. and brought him home for the day. (Exhibit 23; testimony of Ms. Krizo.)

The next day on September 2, 2004, STUDENT left the adapted physical education class without telling Mr. Lopez where he was going. When Mr. Lopez caught up to STUDENT, STUDENT indicated he had urinated on himself. (Exhibit 23.)

On September 9, 2004, STUDENT argued with Mr. Lopez in the bathroom regarding how long Golden Valley had been open. STUDENT indicated that Mr. Lopez made him sick, and STUDENT began wiping feces on his shirt, legs, arms, and penis. He indicated he would not get up to take a shower and threatened to wipe feces on Mr. Lopez. Eventually, FATHER arrived, cleaned STUDENT (with Ms. De Louth’s help), and took STUDENT home. (Exhibit 23; testimony of FATHER.)

On September 10, 2004, STUDENT’s IEP team at the District was set to meet for the first time. Several hours before the IEP meeting convened, one of STUDENT’s teachers, Ms. Richardson, noticed that STUDENT had run his electric wheelchair into a fence. When she asked him what was wrong, he indicated he did not want to go to class. Ms. Richardson attempted to start a conversation by asking if STUDENT wanted to talk to his father or Ms. Krizo. STUDENT stated that he wanted to call his father but that he did not have his cell phone. From a prior conversation with FATHER, Ms. Richardson knew that STUDENT should have his cell phone with him. Accordingly, Ms. Richardson searched his backpack, found the phone, and told him not to lie to her again. As she attempted to call FATHER with her back to STUDENT, he drove the wheelchair into her, wrapping his legs around hers for approximately one minute. Using profanity, he repeatedly asked her to give him the phone. When she turned around and faced STUDENT, he grabbed her left breast, squeezing and twisting it. After STUDENT released Ms. Richardson’s legs, she indicated that she would have him arrested if he ever did that again. STUDENT then reached for Ms. Richardson’s right breast, but she was able to avoid his grasp. STUDENT then remained with his aide, Mr. Lopez, while Ms. Richardson went to call FATHER and to tell Ms. Krizo what had happened.

STUDENT and Mr. Lopez then went to Ms. Krizo’s office where STUDENT waited outside. Ms. Richardson explained to Ms. Krizo what had just happened. Ms. Krizo then went out and asked STUDENT what was going on. STUDENT first said nothing and then reached out and grabbed Ms. Krizo’s left breast without saying anything. Ms. Krizo then went back to her office and called MOTHER. In addition, before STUDENT left school, he grabbed the breast of the school psychologist, Ms. Gina Gordon-Lopez, while she was trying to talk to him. Thereafter, STUDENT slid out of the electric wheelchair and onto the ground. MOTHER arrived and took STUDENT home at about 8:45 a.m., and he did not attend classes the rest of the day. (Exhibit 23; testimony of Ms. Richardson and Ms. Krizo.) Ultimately, as a consequence of the incidents that occurred on September 10, 2004, STUDENT was suspended for five school days: September 13, 14, 15, 16, and 17, 2004. (Exhibit 33-1; testimony of Ms. Young.)

Despite earlier events, the IEP team still convened on September 10, 2004, which was the IEP team’s first meeting and a three year review. (Exhibit 12-1.) Although Golden Valley is not mentioned by name, there is no dispute that it was offered as the placement and that the parents consented to the IEP. However, due primarily to incidents that occurred earlier that day, which were still being investigated when the September 10, 2004 IEP meeting occurred, the District’s willingness to provide Golden Valley as STUDENT’s placement was short-lived.

On September 15, 2004, the IEP team met to consider whether the behavioral episodes of September 10, 2004, were a manifestation of STUDENT’s disability and whether his placement was appropriate. The IEP team determined that STUDENT’s conduct was a manifestation of his disability. (Exhibit 13-3.) In addition, although the District’s offer in the September 15, 2004 IEP document remained the same as the September 10, 2004 IEP document in many other respects, the District changed its offer of placement from Golden Valley to the AIM program. In recommending AIM, the IEP document states that the IEP team “recommends an alternative program for a behavior based program” and that AIM focuses “primarily on behaviors and work[s] on transition back to the home school campus.” (Exhibit 13-17.) The AIM program is located on the Vista West campus, which is an alternative school. The parents did not consent to the AIM placement and did not consent to the IEP.

On September 23, 2004, Mr. Lopez and a second aide assigned to STUDENT, Mr. Chris Thompson, accompanied STUDENT to the restroom. When they tried to convince STUDENT to leave the electric wheelchair outside the restroom, STUDENT became irritated and tried to bump into the aides with his wheelchair. When Mr. Lopez placed his hand over the wheelchair’s controller, STUDENT tried to remove Mr. Lopez’s hand and swung at Mr. Lopez three times with a closed fist. STUDENT became enraged, threw himself on the floor, and cursed at the aides several times. (Exhibit 23.) Due to this incident, STUDENT was suspended for two school days: September 28 and 29, 2004. (Exhibit 33-2; testimony of Ms. Krizo.) STUDENT’s parents eventually removed him from school in late September 2004. In total, STUDENT attended Golden Valley, which is the only District school or program in which he has participated, for fifteen school days beginning August 30, 2004, and ending on September 27, 2004. (Footnote 10)

On September 24, 2004, the Hearing Office received the District’s request for a due process hearing. The District stated its sole issue for hearing as whether its placement offer of AIM in the September 15, 2004 IEP is appropriate. On September 27, 2004, the Hearing Office received the Student’s request for a due process hearing, which stated numerous issues including whether the District’s placement offer is appropriate. On October 5, 2004, the Hearing Office granted the Student’s motion to consolidate the cases and to continue this newly consolidated case to October 20, 2004, which is when the hearing on this case commenced.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Has the District provided and offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2004-2005 regular school year?

Under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.) The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a child at no charge to his or her parent or guardian, meet the standards of the State educational agency, include appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education, and are provided in conformity with the child’s individualized education program (IEP). (Footnote 11) (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).) Special education law also requires that a child with a disability be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A).)

Such special education and related services must be tailored to meet the unique needs of the child with a disability by means of an IEP. (Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16, 853 F.2d 171, 173 (3d Cir. 1988).) The IEP, which is the “centerpiece of the [IDEA’s] education delivery system for disabled children,” consists of a detailed written statement that must be developed, reviewed, and revised for each child with a disability. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343, 56345; Honig v. Doe, 484 U.S. 305 (1988).) The IEP must include a statement of the goals and objectives, special education and related services, and program modifications or supports for school personnel that are to be provided to meet the child’s needs resulting from his or her disability to enable the child to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum and be educated and participate with nondisabled children to the maximum extent appropriate. (20 U.S.C. §§ 1412(a)(5)(A), 1414(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56031, 56345.)

Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he or she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. (W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992).) The United States Supreme Court has recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. (See Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 205 (1982) (Rowley).) Not every procedural flaw constitutes a denial of FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process may result in the denial of FAPE. (W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).)

With respect to the substantive requirements of the IDEA, the United States Supreme Court in Rowley determined that a child’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the child with some educational benefit to satisfy the IDEA, but that the school district is not required to provide the child with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child’s abilities. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 198-200.) The Court held that a school district is required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child. (Id. at 201.) Consequently, an appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the child. (Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996).) De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. (Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist., 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2d Cir. 1998).)

To determine whether a school district substantively offered a FAPE, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of the District’s offer. (Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).) If the proposed program (1) addresses STUDENT’s unique needs, (2) is reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, (3) comports with his IEP, and (4) provides for education in the least restrictive environment (LRE), then the District has offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would likely result in greater educational benefit. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031; Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.)

The analysis of whether a child has been provided or offered a FAPE is generally twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to consider both whether procedural steps were followed and whether the proposed placement is substantively appropriate. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-207.) The Hearing Officer will address each of Student’s particular procedural contentions before discussing the substantive appropriateness of the District’s offer of placement.

A. PROCEDURAL SAFEGUARDS:

1. The District’s alleged failure to ensure that all of STUDENT’s special education teachers attended the September 10, 2004 and September 15, 2004 IEP meetings

The parties agree that only one of STUDENT’s special education teachers, Ms. Thomas, attended each of the IEP meetings. Ms. Thomas was also STUDENT’s special education case manager at Golden Valley. Neither of STUDENT’s other special education teachers, Mr. Davis and Ms. Richardson, attended. The law only requires that one special education teacher attend. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(B); 34 C.F.R. § 300.344; Cal. Educ. Code § 56341; see also 34 C.F.R., App. A to Part 300, Q. 23 [the requirements of 34 CFR section 300.344(a)(3) can be met by “a special education teacher of the child” attending the IEP meeting].) Student has not presented authority to the contrary, completely ignoring the issue in his closing brief. The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit a procedural violation by not having more than one special education teacher at the September 10, 2004 or the September 15, 2004 IEP meetings.

2. The District’s alleged failure to ensure that a nurse attended the September 10, 2004 and the September 15, 2004 IEP meetings

The parties agree that a nurse did not attend either of the IEP meetings. The law identifying what individuals are required to comprise an IEP team does not specify that a nurse must be included. (See 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(B); 34 C.F.R. § 300.344; Cal. Educ. Code § 56341; see also 34 C.F.R., App. A to Part 300, Q. 30 [indicating that 34 C.F.R. § 300.344 does not require related services personnel to be a part of the IEP team, although it may be appropriate for such personnel to attend].) In fact, in the comments to the federal regulations, the federal Office of Special Education Programs (OSEP) specifically rejected a suggestion that participation by a school nurse be mandatory. (Footnote 12) (64 Fed. Reg. 48 at 12585.) Student has not presented authority to support his contention, completely ignoring the issue in his closing brief. Additionally, while a nurse may be a necessary participant pursuant to California Education Code section 56341(b)(5) if the IEP team is required to review a health assessment during the IEP meeting and the nurse conducted the assessment or is otherwise required to interpret the assessment results for the student, neither was the case for STUDENT in September 2004. (See also 34 C.F.R. § 300.344(a)(6).) The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit a procedural violation by not having a nurse at the September 10, 2004 or the September 15, 2004 IEP meetings.

3. The District’s alleged failure to complete a health assessment prior to the September 10, 2004 and the September 15, 2004 IEP meetings

There is no dispute that the District had not completed a health assessment for STUDENT prior to either the September 10, 2004 or the September 15, 2004 IEP meetings. STUDENT was new to the District as of August 30, 2004. The law requires that an assessment be completed and an IEP be developed at an IEP meeting within fifty days from the date the school district receives written consent to assess. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56344(a).) Even if one assumes the District should have presented the parents with an assessment plan on STUDENT’s very first day of school and that the parents consented to the plan on that date, the District would have had fifty days from August 30, 2004, to complete its assessment (or October 19, 2004, in this example). Student has not presented authority for why the District was obligated to complete a health assessment prior to that date. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit a procedural violation by not having completed a health assessment by the September 10, 2004 or the September 15, 2004 IEP meetings.

*****

In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not violate the procedural safeguards of the IDEA or California special education law.

B. SUBSTANTIVE REQUIREMENTS:

The Hearing Officer notes that Student’s substantive contentions relate to two separate time periods, namely the time before and the time after the District’s IEP of September 15, 2004, which contains the District’s placement offer for the remainder of the 2004-2005 regular school year.

-- August 30, 2004, through September 14, 2004

The 2004-2005 school year was STUDENT’s first year with the District, and he began school at Golden Valley on August 30, 2004. With respect to the first time period, the parties agree that the District had the right to implement the prior school district’s IEP, which they also agree was City District’s March 2, 2004 IEP, to the extent possible within the District’s existing resources. Upon STUDENT’s transfer into the District, California Education Code section 56325 required the District to implement STUDENT’s existing IEP from his former school district, to the extent possible within existing resources, during an interim period not to exceed thirty days. The District was then required to convene an IEP meeting within the thirty-day period to review the interim placement and make a final recommendation. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56325(b).) In essence, California Education Code section 56325 grants a school district a thirty-day period to rely on the IEP of the prior district while it develops its own placement recommendation. In this case, the District’s IEP team met for the first time on September 10, 2004, which was only fourteen calendar days from the time STUDENT began attending the District schools and was well within the thirty-day time period provided by the law.

In this section of the analysis, the Hearing Officer also will include the time span from the September 10, 2004 IEP meeting to the September 15, 2004 IEP meeting where the District members of the IEP team recommended a different placement. STUDENT was suspended during this time frame for the behavioral episode of September 10, 2004, and there is no indication that Student ever challenged the validity of the suspension. (Footnote 13) Furthermore, Student does not contest the appropriateness of his initial placement at Golden Valley. (Footnote 14) Given these considerations, the Hearing Officer finds that there is no reason to analyze alleged deficiencies in the September 10, 2004 IEP document, except insofar as they were carried over into the September 15, 2004 IEP. This is particularly true given that the Hearing Officer also finds that analyzing this time frame would not change the outcome of this Decision even if he assumes the validity of Student’s contentions for this time frame.

With respect to the time span of August 30, 2004, through September 15, 2004, the parties disagree whether the District properly implemented the City District’s March 2, 2004 IEP. Specifically, the dispute relates to whether STUDENT received the proper amount of speech and language therapy, physical therapy, and the benefit of the City District BSP (which also touched upon toileting) during this approximately two week period of time.

1. Speech and language therapy

The parties dispute whether STUDENT received the amount of speech therapy time he was entitled to pursuant to the pertinent IEP documents. As mentioned above, the District was attempting to implement the City District’s March 2, 2004 IEP prior to September 10, 2004. (Testimony of Ms. Young; see Cal. Educ. Code § 56325.) The March 2, 2004 IEP states that STUDENT was to receive thirty minutes of speech services one time per week.

The District’s speech and language pathologist, Ms. Sherilyn Sarff, credibly testified that she provided thirty minutes of speech and language services to STUDENT on September 2, 24, and 27, 2004. From August 30, 2004, through September 10, 2004, there were two weeks of school, which means that STUDENT should have received two sessions of speech and language during that time span. Although she was scheduled to provide services on September 10, 2004, Ms. Sarff testified that services were not provided on that date because the IEP meeting was held during that time.

As mentioned above, the parties stipulated that STUDENT attended fifteen days of school, which is the equivalent of three weeks of school. In addition, the Hearing Officer notes that on three of the days, STUDENT went home early. Also, as mentioned above, STUDENT was suspended for the days of September 28 and 29, 2004. Given that STUDENT received three speech and language sessions and that he attended school for three weeks, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT received the speech and language services to which he was entitled not only through September 10, 2004, but also through September 29, 2004. Even though the services were not provided as scheduled during the week of September 6, 2004, the missed session was, in effect, provided at a later date.

2. Physical therapy

The City District’s March 2, 2004 IEP states that STUDENT was to receive thirty minutes of physical therapy services per week. (Exhibit 10-1 and 10-5.) For the time period before the September 10, 2004 IEP meeting, Ms. Young testified that the District implemented the City District’s March 2, 2004 IEP. There was no contrary evidence that the District did not provide physical therapy services during that period. Therefore, on the basis of the undisputed evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that the District implemented the City District’s IEP with respect to physical therapy through September 10, 2004.

3. City District’s behavioral support plan signed June 8, 2004 (City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP)

For the time period before the September 10, 2004 IEP meeting, the District contends it had no obligation to implement the City District’s BSP signed June 8, 2004 (City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP), since it was not attached to the March 2, 2004 IEP, which the parties agree was the City District’s last agreed upon IEP. The Student contends the District was still required to implement the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP, even though it was not attached to the March 2, 2004 IEP or otherwise referenced in it.

There is no dispute that the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP was not attached to the City District’s March 2, 2004 IEP, which was the IEP the District was attempting to implement pursuant to California Education Code section 56325, or that it was even in existence at the time of the City District’s March 2, 2004 IEP meeting. The City District’s March 2, 2004 IEP document contains no reference to the City District BSP signed June 8, 2004. Although it does contain a reference to a “behavior plan” which it indicates is dated February 3, 2003, and updated January 20, 2004, there is no further information stated about the purported plans. In addition, neither of the purported plans was actually attached to the IEP document. (See Exhibit 10 and Exhibit AAA.) Neither of the purported February 3, 2003 or January 20, 2004 behavior plans was offered into evidence. Nor is there evidence that the District had a copy of these plans at any time. With respect to the particular plan at issue, the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP indicates that it was signed by Ms. Shelly Meagher of the City District. However, no evidence was presented that STUDENT’s IEP team at the City District formally approved the document and adopted it as part of his IEP. Nor was there evidence that this particular plan had actually been implemented by the City District.

As noted, California Education Code section 56325 grants a school district a thirty-day period to rely on the IEP of the prior district while it develops its own program recommendation. Neither the City District’s March 2, 2004 IEP document nor the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP itself reflects that the BSP had been incorporated into the IEP or otherwise adopted by the City District’s IEP team. At the District’s very first IEP meeting on September 10, 2004, which was timely convened within thirty days, the BSP document was adopted by the District’s IEP team. Accordingly, given that the law permitted the District to rely upon the City District’s IEP and that it was not evident that the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP was part of that IEP, the Hearing Officer finds under the circumstances that the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to implement the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP before the September 10, 2004 IEP meeting. Additionally, the District did not deny a FAPE by failing to implement any other BSP, such as the February 3, 2003 BSP or January 20, 2004 update, because there is no indication that either document was provided to the District by the City District or by the parents. Finally, for the same reasons the Hearing Officer has found that the District was not generally required to implement the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP, he also finds that the District was not required to follow the specific recommendations contained in that BSP with respect to toileting.

Student’s brief refers to the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP as a behavioral intervention plan (BIP) and suggests there is no law requiring that a BIP be attached to the IEP document to be operative. However, there was no evidence presented to support the claim that the BSP is a BIP, and the title of the document itself – Behavior Support Plan (BSP) – belies that notion. Furthermore, even if the BSP could be characterized as a BIP, the Hearing Officer notes that Student’s characterization of the BSP as a BIP does not necessarily help his position. A BIP must be approved by an IEP team, and there is no evidence that the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP was approved by the City District’s IEP team. (See Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3052(c).) The IDEA regulations make clear that an IEP team must consider strategies and interventions to address a child’s behavior that impedes his or her learning and that if the IEP team determines that an intervention, accommodation, or other modification is necessary, such a statement must be included in the IEP. (34 C.F.R. §§ 300.346(a)(2)(i), 300.346(c).) This means that a BSP must be considered and adopted by the IEP team and that the BSP should be attached or at least referenced in the IEP document. There was no evidence that these steps were taken by the City District with respect to the June 8, 2004 BSP at issue.

*****

In light of the foregoing findings, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided STUDENT a FAPE from August 30, 2004, through September 14, 2004.

-- September 15, 2004, through the end of the 2004-2005 regular school year

The analysis of whether STUDENT has been provided a FAPE substantively involves considering whether the proposed program (1) addresses STUDENT’s unique needs and is reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit and (2) comports with his IEP. Furthermore, an additional requirement is that STUDENT’s program must be provided in the least restrictive environment (LRE). Each consideration will be addressed in turn.

1. Is the District’s program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit?

The Hearing Officer must initially determine if the District’s offer of September 15, 2004, is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and is reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit. Therefore, the Hearing Officer must first determine what STUDENT’s unique needs are. The parties agree that STUDENT is mentally retarded and that he is eligible for special education and related services as a result of his disabilities. The parties also agree that STUDENT’s needs are basic and extensive, covering the areas of academics, speech and language (articulation), motor skills, toileting, behavior, transition, and social skills and that STUDENT needs a structured environment as he has difficulty with change. The parties also agree that STUDENT has various health conditions, although they disagree over whether and how the District was obligated to address his health needs at the time of its September 15, 2004 offer. The Hearing Officer addresses below disputes over whether the District’s proposed program meets STUDENT’s unique needs and is reasonably calculated to provide him benefit.

a. Goals and benchmarks

The IEP for each child with a disability must include a statement of the child’s present levels of educational performance and a statement of measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives. (34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a).) Measurable annual goals are “critical to the strategic planning process used to develop and implement the IEP for each child with a disability” and enable the child’s teachers, parents, and others involved in developing and implementing the child’s IEP to measure during the year if the child is making progress toward meeting the annual goal. (34 C.F.R., App. A to Part 300, Q.1.)

Student contends that the District’s offer does not meet his unique needs because the goals and benchmarks are too vague. Student also contends that some are not individualized to meet his needs. The District contends that its goals and benchmarks are sufficient. (Footnote 15)

The evidence establishes that the September 10, 2004 IEP was developed to fit STUDENT into the Golden Valley campus, that the Golden Valley program is an “academic” program and not a “functional academic” program, that the academic goals and benchmarks were developed for an academic program as opposed to a functional academic program, and that STUDENT actually needs a functional academic program, not a pure academic program. (Testimony of Ms. Thomas, Ms. Young, and Ms. Krizo.) Ms. Young testified that the Golden Valley program has an academic curriculum, which she described as traditional math, reading, and writing for a diploma. In contrast, she testified that the functional curriculum teaches functional living skills such as making a bed, preparing a snack, learning self-help skills, learning to measure soap for laundry for math, and learning how to understand survival signs for reading. Ms. Krizo testified that she had concerns that Golden Valley would not be able to meet STUDENT’s needs because, among other reasons, it provides an academic program whereas there were no academic goals in STUDENT’s previous IEP. Ms. Thomas, STUDENT’s case manager at Golden Valley and the person responsible for communicating with the teachers regarding his goals and benchmarks, testified that when the September 10, 2004 IEP meeting was held, she did not feel the program the District developed was appropriate for STUDENT but that the IEP team recommended what it did because it was trying to work with the family and hoping there would not be a problem in the future. She testified that the AIM program, which was offered at the September 15, 2004 IEP meeting, would appropriately address STUDENT’s needs because, among other things, it was a functional academic program, which is what she believes he needs. However, there is no dispute that when the District offered the AIM program five days after September 10, 2004, the goals and benchmarks remained the same. No effort was made to convert the academic goals and benchmarks to functional academic goals and benchmarks. Simply changing the program placement does not correct the inappropriate goals and benchmarks that were written for the academic program.

Given STUDENT’s needs for a functional academic program and that the existing academic goals were not crafted for functional academics, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and benchmarks on the pages titled “Math 2A,” “Reading Comprehension 1,” “Reading 1,” and “Written and Oral Language 1” are not individualized to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. A fair summary of the District’s witnesses’ testimony is that the goals and benchmarks were drafted so that STUDENT could fit a program at Golden Valley that was not meant for a student with his needs. The Hearing Officer notes that the District made little attempt to establish by testimony that each of the goals and benchmarks are appropriate. (Footnote 16)

Related to the area of functional academics, the Hearing Officer notes that Student contended during clarification of the issues that self-help skills such as showering should have been addressed by goals and benchmarks. However, he did not present evidence on what skills he is lacking. In fact, documentary evidence suggests the District had no reason to know he needed goals and benchmarks in that area. The September 10, 2004 IEP document the parents accepted stated that “STUDENT’s parents report [he] can take care of himself (shower, dress, brush teeth, etc.).” (Exhibit 12-4.)

With respect to the adapted physical education (APE) goal and benchmarks, the Hearing Officer finds that they are vague and not measurable. The APE goal is that STUDENT “will have participated in various activities (i.e. general movements, balance, and stamina),” and the benchmark states he will “demonstrate satisfactory performance in “movement activities.” (Exhibit 13-8.) The corresponding criterion for measurement of the goal is that his success will be measured by earning a passing grade; the corresponding criteria for measurement of the benchmarks are that his success will be demonstrated by seventy percent participation in activities. The phrase “movement activities” is not defined. Nor are the terms “general movements, balance, and stamina” defined. There is no way to know what specific skills are being taught. Furthermore, the criteria of receiving a passing grade or of attaining seventy percent participation in activities does nothing to explain whether and to what extent particular skills (which are never defined) are in fact being developed and mastered. Yet, the law requires that goals and benchmarks be measurable. (34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a)(2); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(2).)

With respect to the behavior goal and benchmarks, the Hearing Officer finds they are also vague. Initially, the Hearing Officer notes that the District conceded that the reference to a “BSP” or “Behavioral Support Plan” at various places on the form was an error. (See Exhibit 13-7. ) (Footnote 17) Ms. Krizo testified that there is no correlation between the goal and benchmarks and any BSP and that the references to a BSP were a mistake. Next, it is not clear how the one stated behavior goal is related to many of the underlying benchmarks. For example, while the sole goal is that “STUDENT will improve social skill deficits,” some of the benchmarks state that student will “attend regularly,” “manage emotions of nervousness, fear,” and “transition without incident from one activity to another.”

Furthermore, while goals and benchmarks must be measurable, the District’s proposed behavior goal and benchmarks fail to contain measurable criteria for how the goal and many of the benchmarks are to be measured. For example, the document states that the goal of “STUDENT will improve social skill deficits” will be measured by the criteria of “as demonstrated by: … less than 1 a week behavioral incidents.” There is no description of what social skill deficits are of concern, let alone how such deficits are quantifiable as one a week behavior incidents. With respect to the benchmarks “attend regularly” and “manage emotions of nervousness, fear,” the document completely omits any reference under the corresponding “criteria” column as to how these benchmarks will be measured. As to the remaining benchmarks of “follow directions, accept limits & rules,” “respect others property and rights,” “accept responsibility for own actions,” “request, protest, negotiate, problem solve,” and “transition without incident from one activity to another,” it is not clear how the corresponding “criteria” for measurement of “less than [3, 2, or 1, depending on time period] a week behavior incidents” can measure progress in these areas. Success at “following directions,” for example, does not necessarily correlate to the lack of “behavioral incidents.” Additionally, given that the IEP document does not describe STUDENT’s present levels of performance in behavior, it is difficult to discern what specific needs are being addressed.

Because the behavior goal and benchmarks are vague and not measurable, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not establish that the behavior goal and benchmarks meet STUDENT’s needs. The Hearing Officer notes that none of the witnesses persuasively testified that the behavior goal and benchmarks are appropriate for STUDENT, although Ms. Krizo attempted to defend some of them on cross-examination. The person who drafted them, Ms. Sissy Tran, never testified.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s goals and benchmarks on the pages titled “Math 2A,” “Reading Comprehension 1,” “Reading 1,” “Written and Oral Language 1,” “Adaptive P.E.,” and “BSP Behavior Goals” are not individualized to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and are not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. The IEP team must revisit what goals and benchmarks are appropriate for STUDENT in these areas, particularly since the parties agree that a functional academic program is what STUDENT needs. (Footnote 18)

b. Behavioral needs

The parties agree that Student’s behavioral needs are significant. As stated in the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP, STUDENT may exhibit tantrums with physical aggression (e.g., hitting, throwing feces, spitting, kicking, and causing property damage), may refuse to do his school work, may drop to the ground and refuse to move, and may smear his feces. (Exhibit 31; see also Exhibit 13-24 through 13-30.) With respect to the AIM program, there is no dispute that it is a program that focuses “primarily on behaviors.” (Exhibit 13-17.) Ms. Jorgenson testified that the AIM program is designed for students with behavioral problems like STUDENT’s and that staff at AIM are trained in techniques to handle behavioral incidents. In addition, she testified that a social worker observes incoming students in their class setting during the first thirty days and then makes additional recommendations with respect to behaviors, if appropriate. The weight of the evidence is that the AIM program could appropriately address STUDENT’s behavioral needs, assuming a proper behavior plan is implemented. (Footnote 19)

Student’s contentions with respect to his behavioral needs break down into two categories: (1) vague behavioral goals and benchmarks and (2) failure to implement the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP. Behavior goals and benchmarks already have been discussed above. The Hearing Officer will discuss the alleged failure to implement the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP below in the section regarding whether the District’s program comported with STUDENT’s IEP.

c. Health needs

During the parties’ clarification of issues, Student identified a myriad of concerns regarding the District’s alleged failure to meet his health needs. For example, Student contends that the District failed to provide training in PWS to his aides and teachers, failed to include a health protocol or plan related to the District’s monitoring of his oxygen tanks, glucose level, heart rate, and pulse rate, failed to have a plan to ensure he would not sit for more than one hour at a time, failed to provide a dietary plan, failed to have a plan to ensure he wore his glasses, and failed to ensure access to a recliner for napping and for relieving pressure on his legs. Yet, Student’s closing brief does not specifically address what legal duties the District violated in these areas. (Footnote 20)

As explained below, the Hearing Officer finds that, to date, the District has properly addressed Student’s known health needs by offering to conduct a health assessment. Upon entering the District, the District attempted to follow the City District’s IEP, pursuant to California Education Code section 56325. Yet, the City District’s IEP does not clearly identify what health related duties the City District’s personnel were performing or what health plans or protocols they were following. (Footnote 21) Although one page of the City District’s March 2, 2004 IEP indicates there is a health services “protocol” in STUDENT’s school file (see Exhibit 10-4), nothing is attached to the IEP, and there is no evidence of what that protocol was. Student never identified at hearing any specific written protocols that were part of his program at City District and never identified which plans or doctors’ orders, if any, the District should have otherwise followed. Furthermore, as recently as the September 10, 2004 IEP, to which both parents consented, the District had reason to believe that STUDENT was capable of performing health functions such as checking his pulse oximeter and checking his blood glucose level. (Exhibit 12-4.) The September 10, 2004 IEP, to which the parents consented, contains no indication that the parents believed that specific plans or doctor’s orders needed to be followed or implemented by District personnel. Also, Ms. Krizo credibly testified that FATHER had orally indicated on prior occasions that STUDENT was able to check his own oxygen and glucose levels. With respect to a need for a dietary plan, Ms. Krizo credibly testified that the parents indicated that STUDENT could eat a normal lunch. She also testified that STUDENT’s dietician at the University of California at Los Angeles (UCLA), Ms. Patty Beckwith, had indicated that STUDENT did not have a dietary plan, although she did indicate that it was best to eliminate STUDENT’s dessert. Ms. Young testified that dietary guides concerning the District’s food menu were provided to the parents for review but that the parents never got back to the District personnel regarding their wishes for STUDENT’s diet.

During the September 15, 2004 IEP meeting, the District agreed to perform a health assessment. (Exhibit 13-26.) At the same meeting, FATHER signed his consent for the assessment. (Exhibit 22.) The form indicates that the assessment was a joint request by the school and parent and that the areas of “health, development, vision, and learning” will be assessed “to determine health/medical factors which may impact education or participation.” As of September 15, 2004, STUDENT had only been in the District for just over two weeks. Prior to that date, the District had not been idle in attempting to meet STUDENT’s health needs. For example, the District had ordered and received a motorized wheelchair for STUDENT’s use, which he used, and District personnel had received training on how to monitor and service his oxygen tanks. After the health assessment was signed on September 15, 2004, the District sent out records requests to STUDENT’s doctors at UCLA on October 7, 2004, but no records had yet been received by the District. (Testimony of Ms. Young.) In addition, a District nurse, Ms. Brenda Pulskamp, called MOTHER on October 15, 2004, to conduct a physical assessment of STUDENT, but MOTHER indicated that “things had changed” since the assessment plan was signed and that she would need to talk to her attorney. (Exhibit 44.) Ms. Pulskamp also left a follow-up message on October 20, 2004, with the parents. No evidence was received that the parents ever permitted the physical health assessment of STUDENT.

On the basis of the information presented at hearing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District acted diligently and reasonably in addressing STUDENT’s health needs based upon the information reasonably available to it. (Footnote 22) There is no indication that the District violated any law by not having health related plans in place by the time of its first IEP meeting on September 10, 2004, or by the September 15, 2004 IEP meeting. Generally, a school district has fifty days from the time it receives written consent to assess to complete its assessment and develop an IEP for a child. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56344.) Even if one assumes the earliest timeline by suggesting that the District should have sought written consent to assess on STUDENT’s first day of school and that such consent was obtained that same day (i.e., August 30, 2004), the District would have had fifty days, which is well beyond the date of the September 15, 2004 IEP, to complete a health assessment and to develop appropriate plans or protocols. Additionally, although there is a fifty day timeline, clearly the District must have access to STUDENT to complete its health assessment, and the weight of the evidence is that STUDENT’s parents have not made him reasonably available for assessments. (Footnote 23) After the District’s health assessment is completed, the IEP team may well decide that health plans, further training of staff, or other accommodations are necessary to address STUDENT’s health needs. However, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded that the District has denied STUDENT a FAPE to date based on a failure to address his health needs. (Footnote 24)

d. Toileting needs

STUDENT has serious toileting needs, which are undisputed. Not only does he have difficulty controlling his bladder and bowels, but he also has a tendency to play with or smear his feces if left unattended in the bathroom. (Footnote 25) The parties also do not dispute that he needs access to a shower in case of toileting accidents. (Footnote 26) Student contends the District should have developed a toileting plan to address his toileting needs. He contends a plan should have been developed that instructs District personnel on how to spot cues that he needs to use the bathroom given his problems with bowel control, that addresses his tendency to eat or play with his feces such as a “go and flush” strategy where the toilet is flushed immediately after bowel movements, that instructs his aide not to leave him unattended in the bathroom, that addresses procedures for safely cleaning him and the surrounding environment after a toileting accident and identifies where safety supplies are kept, and that specifies that District personnel, not his parents, are responsible for cleaning toileting accidents at school. The District contends some of STUDENT’s toileting needs were addressed in the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP while other needs, if any, would be addressed after the District’s health assessment is completed.

In the September 15, 2004 IEP, the District adopted both a two-hour bathroom schedule and the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP which contains some toileting procedures. Further, no evidence was presented of any toileting incidents from September 10, 2004, to the time STUDENT was removed from school on September 27, 2004. Therefore, even if the District should have done more as to toileting, there is no evidence of any prejudice to STUDENT with respect to toileting through the date he was removed from school.

Furthermore, there is no indication that the District violated any law by not having a toileting plan in place by the time of its first IEP meeting on September 10, 2004, or by the September 15, 2004 IEP meeting. As mentioned above, a school district generally has fifty days from the time it receives written consent to assess to complete its assessment and develop an IEP for a child. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56344.) Although consent to a health assessment has been provided, the District has not been able to complete it because the parents have not made STUDENT available, as discussed above. Any additional toileting concerns Student has with the District’s offer, that are not otherwise addressed by the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP, may be addressed after the completion of the District’s on-going health assessment. Given the information reasonably available to the District, the Hearing Officer finds that it has provided for and offered to address STUDENT’s toileting needs to date.

e. Physical therapy

The parties agree that STUDENT has physical fitness needs, including the need to build upper body strength. However, the parties have not elaborated upon what those needs are. Student’s contention is that he should receive thirty minutes of physical therapy per week, whereas the District contends his physical therapy needs can be adequately addressed by adapted physical education (APE).

Ms. Young testified that at the September 10, 2004 IEP meeting, Mr. Jack Lollar, a physical therapist for the District, discussed physical therapy services with the parents and indicated that he did not believe STUDENT needed physical therapy given that his needs were being met by APE. The IEP document reflects that the parents agreed to have Mr. Lollar consult with the APE teacher on an as needed basis and that no direct physical therapy services would be provided. (Exhibit 12-23.) The September 15, 2004 IEP reflects that the District offered APE four times per week for twenty minutes per session, that services would include stretching exercises and upper extremity exercises, and that the focus would be to build upper body strength. (Footnote 27) (Exhibit 13.) Given the unopposed opinion of Mr. Lollar that STUDENT’s needs in this area could be met sufficiently with APE without physical therapy, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique physical therapy needs and provide him educational benefit.

f. Laptop computer, calculator, and computer programs

Finally, Student requests that he be permitted to use a laptop computer and a calculator in class and that he have access to computer programs that he can use at home. With respect to a laptop, the parties agreed during the hearing that STUDENT will be permitted to use a laptop at school, which will be provided by the parents. With respect to the calculator and the use of computer programs at home, the Hearing Officer finds that to date the District has not failed to offer a FAPE by not specifically including these items in its offer. Based upon the information the District reasonably had available to it, the District did not have reason to suspect that STUDENT needs these items to benefit from his education. While Mr. Hardamon testified that the use of a calculator had been helpful to STUDENT while he was in his class, his testimony did not specifically indicate that STUDENT’s unique needs require the use of a calculator. In addition, there is no indication that the District is generally opposed to the use of calculator where appropriate. (Testimony of Mr. Davis.) Furthermore, no evidence was presented with respect to what specific computer programs, if any, are necessary for STUDENT to benefit from his education, and no specific programs were ever mentioned at the hearing. (Footnote 28)

*****

In summary, the Hearing Officer has determined that the District has failed to offer a program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit with respect to goals and benchmarks in the areas of functional academics, APE, and behavior. With respect to STUDENT’s health needs and toileting needs, the District has offered to address STUDENT’s needs to date. Furthermore, if the parents want the District to address STUDENT’s health needs in more detail, the parents must make STUDENT available so that the District can complete its on-going health assessment and propose additions to the IEP, if necessary. On the basis of the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer has also determined that the District’s offer of APE is sufficient to address STUDENT’s physical therapy needs. Finally, the District has not failed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs by not specifically providing for the use of a calculator in class or by not permitting access to computer programs for his use at home.

2. Did the District’s program comport with STUDENT’s IEP?

With respect to contentions that STUDENT did not receive what he is entitled to under his IEP, he asserts that he did not receive the full amount of speech and language therapy to which he was entitled. He also asserts that the District did not properly implement the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP, even though it was attached to the September 10, 2004 and September 15, 2004 IEPs. The Hearing Officer notes there is no issue here of whether the District properly carried out the AIM program offered in the September 15, 2004 IEP document because the parents did not consent to that IEP.

a. Speech and language therapy

As previously determined, the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT was provided the amount of speech and language therapy to which he was entitled through September 29, 2004. Because STUDENT was removed from school and has not been receiving speech therapy after that time, the Hearing Officer will consider below whether STUDENT is entitled to compensatory education for speech therapy services missed after September 29, 2004.

b. City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP

With respect to the period of time after the September 10, 2004 IEP meeting, the District attached the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP to both the District’s September 10, 2004 and September 15, 2004 IEPs. Between September 15, 2004, and STUDENT’s last day in school on September 27, 2004, STUDENT only attended school for six days. The District’s closing brief concedes that the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP “was not used by STUDENT’s educators at Golden Valley” because, purportedly, “they did not see him engage in any of the behavior that was addressed by the plan.” (District’s Brief, p.36, lines 7-8.)

The Hearing Officer notes that even after the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP was adopted by the District, the District did not establish that all of the teachers and aides who worked with STUDENT were given a copy of the plan and were instructed to implement the plan. Ms. Krizo, who was the person overseeing STUDENT’s special education at Golden Valley, testified that it was up to the teachers to come to the office to obtain copies of a student’s behavioral plan and that it was up to the teachers to give a copy of the behavioral plan to the aides who work with the student. She also testified that she did not know if STUDENT’s teachers and aide had read the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP or if it had been used by District personnel. She stated she also was not sure if a daily contact log was being sent home to the parents as required by the BSP, and the District did not otherwise establish that such a log was being sent to the parents. (See Exhibit 13-25.) She also stated she was “not sure” if she provided any directions to staff on how to handle STUDENT’s behavioral problems.

With respect to behavioral incidents occurring after September 10, 2004, documentary evidence was admitted describing an incident on September 23, 2004, which involved STUDENT swinging three times at his aide, Mr. Lopez, as described more fully above. (Exhibit 23-9 through 23-11.) Even though neither party presented any testimony regarding this event, no testimony was presented indicating that the District followed the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP in responding to this event, and the District’s brief concedes that STUDENT’s educators never used the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP. Despite the District’s contention that the BSP was not needed because STUDENT allegedly did not engage in behavior covered by the plan, the BSP specifically states that STUDENT can engage in oppositional behavior that may include physical aggression such as hitting. (Exhibit 13-21.) When such oppositional behavior occurs, the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP recommends allowing STUDENT to make appropriate choices of work activities. (Id.) The BSP also indicates that STUDENT’s “wish list” can be used as a reinforcer. The concept of giving STUDENT choices is also mentioned in the section of the BSP discussing work refusals. (Exhibit 13-22.) The District never established that Mr. Lopez, the person who worked with STUDENT most closely, read the BSP, was provided a copy of the BSP, or was instructed to follow the BSP. The Hearing Officer thus finds that the District failed to ensure that District personnel implemented the BSP after it was adopted on September 10, 2004. (Footnote 29)

*****

In summary, the issue of whether the District’s implementation of STUDENT’s program comported with STUDENT’s IEP is limited because STUDENT never enrolled in the AIM program and because STUDENT was removed from District’s schools on September 27, 2004. From September 15, 2004, until STUDENT’s parents removed him from Golden Valley, the Hearing Officer has determined that the District provided speech and language therapy that comported with STUDENT’s IEP. However, the District failed to comport with STUDENT’s IEP to the extent that it did not substantively implement the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP which the District adopted and attached to the September 15, 2004 IEP.

3. Does the District’s offered placement at AIM provide STUDENT an education in the LRE?

Student contends AIM is too restrictive an environment. He asserts that despite some behavioral episodes while at Golden Valley, he has not been given a fair opportunity to succeed on a mainstream campus, having attended Golden Valley for only fifteen days. Nevertheless, Student does not contend that his last implemented placement at Golden Valley, as reflected in the September 10, 2004 IEP, is appropriate. Instead, he contends his placement should remain at Golden Valley but should be modified so that he is placed in the District’s self-contained, low functioning, autism class.

In its brief, the District contends “no issue was raised regarding least restrictive environment. Therefore, the District will not address this issue.” (District’s Brief, p.40.) The Hearing Officer notes that the District’s assertion that LRE was not raised as an issue is surprising and simply incorrect. Student’s issue statement dated October 8, 2004, indicated that the District’s placement offer was at issue (see issue number three of Student’s issue statement), and Student’s attorney specifically stated during the clarification of the issues on the second day of hearing, October 21, 2004, that the AIM program was inappropriate because, among other reasons, it was not the least restrictive environment. (Footnote 30) As gathered from the District’s statements during the issues clarification discussion and in its opening statement, the Hearing Officer infers that the District’s position as to LRE is that STUDENT needs a more restrictive environment than his current placement at Golden Valley and that the AIM program, while more restrictive than Golden Valley, is necessary to properly address his behavioral needs at this time.

Often, the issue of LRE arises in the context of whether a student should be placed in the regular classroom with non-disabled peers (mainstreamed) or whether he should be placed in a more restrictive environment such as a self-contained special day class. In such instances, the court in Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H., 14 F.3d 1398, 1404 (9th Cir. 1994) (Rachel H.) lays out four factors for consideration. (Footnote 31) However, the factors are difficult to apply where a regular classroom placement is not one of the placement options being considered, which is the case here, and the parties made no specific attempt to address the factors through testimony.

Neither party contends that the last agreed upon and implemented placement at Golden Valley, which was not a self-contained classroom and required STUDENT to transition between each of his classes, is appropriate. The issue is whether STUDENT requires the restrictive placement of the AIM program at Vista West with no mainstreaming opportunities or whether a less restrictive placement is appropriate, such as the self-contained, special day autism class at Golden Valley with mainstreaming opportunities which the Student requests. While a regular classroom placement is not at issue in this case, the legal concept of LRE applies. When placement outside the regular classroom is necessary for the child to benefit educationally, the IEP team still must mainstream the child to the maximum extent appropriate. (See 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b).) As one court explains, IDEA and its regulations do not contemplate an all-or-nothing educational system in which handicapped children attend either regular or special education. Rather, the Act and its regulations require schools to offer a continuum of services. (Citations.) Thus, the school must take intermediate steps where appropriate, such as placing the child in regular education for some academic classes and in special education for others, mainstreaming the child for nonacademic classes only, or providing interaction with nonhandicapped children during lunch and recess. … If the school officials have provided the maximum appropriate exposure to non-handicapped students, they have fulfilled their obligation under the [IDEA].

Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Educ., 874 F.2d 1036, 1050 (5th Cir. 1989) [footnote omitted].

In analyzing the statutes regarding LRE, the Daniel R.R. court found, in effect, that Congress created such a strong preference in favor of educating children with disabilities with their non-disabled peers (mainstreaming) that the less restrictive environment rises to the level of a presumption in favor of mainstreaming. (Daniel R.R., 874 F.2d at 1045, 1052; see also Temecula Valley Unified School District v. Student, SN03-01996 (CA SEHO 2003).)

As to the restrictive nature of the AIM program, the IEP indicates that one hundred percent of STUDENT’s time would be spent in special education. (Exhibit 13-15.) There is no offer of any type of mainstreaming with the general education population. Additionally, Ms. Jorgenson testified that students in the AIM program do not interact with the other students on the Vista West campus. Ms. Jorgenson also testified that there is no reverse mainstreaming for students in the AIM program. The September 15, 2004 IEP indicates that the AIM program focuses “primarily on behaviors.” (Exhibit 13-17.) Ms. Jorgenson testified that staff at AIM are trained in Professional Assault Response Training (PART or Pro-Act), which involves techniques for, among other things, physically taking down to the floor a student who is experiencing an acute behavioral problem. With a population of thirty-eight students, Ms. Jorgenson testified that the AIM staff averages a physical “take down” of one student per week.

The District presented no evidence that STUDENT needs as restrictive a placement as the AIM program during one hundred percent of his school day to benefit from his education. Although the District presented evidence regarding whether AIM is appropriate to meet STUDENT’s needs, no testimony was elicited as to why full-time placement in AIM is the LRE for STUDENT. The District also presented no evidence that STUDENT cannot benefit from at least some mainstreaming opportunities. As the court states in Daniel R.R., aside from any educational benefits, “mainstreaming may have benefits in and of itself. For example, the language and behavior models available from nonhandicapped children may be essential or helpful to the handicapped child's development.” (Daniel R.R., 874 F.2d at 1047-1048.) While the District presented evidence that STUDENT was not doing well at Golden Valley in a placement that had him transitioning class to class, this does not establish that STUDENT could not benefit from a more structured setting, such as a self-contained classroom, with some mainstreaming opportunities.

Although the District has not explicitly so stated, the District’s sole rationale for eliminating all of STUDENT’s opportunities for mainstreaming appears to be that his behavior is so out of control that the restrictive setting of AIM is justified. Yet, the District has presented no authority for the proposition that incidents of bad behavior, standing alone, eliminate the need to consider what a child’s LRE is. To the contrary, the law still requires school districts to consider LRE for a child with behavioral issues. When a child’s behavior impedes his learning, the IEP team must determine whether supports, strategies, or interventions are necessary to address the behavior. (34 C.F.R., App. A to Part 300, Q. 39; 34 C.F.R. § 300.346(a)(2)(i); see also Cal. Educ. Code § 56523(b)(2).) These legal provisions “are designed to foster increased participation of children with disabilities in regular education environments or other less restrictive environments, not to serve as a basis for placing children with disabilities in more restrictive settings.” (34 C.F.R., App. A to Part 300, Q. 39; see also Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(d).) “If the child can appropriately function in the regular classroom with appropriate behavioral supports, strategies or interventions, placement in a more restrictive environment would be inconsistent with the least restrictive environment provisions of the IDEA.” (34 C.F.R., App. A to Part 300, Q. 39.)

There is no evidence that the District engaged in a careful or even minimal consideration of whether STUDENT’s behavioral needs could be adequately addressed with behavioral supports, strategies, or interventions in a less restrictive environment than AIM with no mainstreaming opportunities. To the contrary, the evidence is that the District never attempted to implement the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP in earnest either before or after it was adopted by the District on September 10, 2004, as discussed above. The District adopted the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP only in form, not in spirit and substance. In addition, the Hearing Officer notes that Ms. Krizo’s testimony was inconsistent with respect to whether the District was developing its own behavioral plan. She first indicated that the District decided on September 10, 2004, to develop its own BSP. Later, she testified the District planned to wait and see how the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP worked before preparing its own BSP. While one cannot redo time to know what impact a serious effort to implement the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP may have had, it is no stretch to say that implementation of a plan designed to address many of the very behaviors STUDENT exhibited at Golden Valley may have helped minimize them. It must be emphasized that there is no proof that the very person who worked with STUDENT the most, Mr. Lopez, ever read the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP, was ever given a copy of the BSP, or was ever instructed to follow the BSP. While the Hearing Officer does not take lightly the seriousness of the behavioral incidents STUDENT exhibited, he also believes they should be viewed in the context that STUDENT was not receiving the benefit of a behavioral plan designed to effectively deal with his behaviors.

Furthermore, Student presented evidence that he recently has been successful in an environment less restrictive than AIM. Student presented testimony from his former teacher, Mr. Hardamon, and a former aide, Ms. Rios, who worked with him during the 2003-2004 school year. Mr. Hardamon testified that STUDENT’s eighth grade class was comprised of four students in a self-contained classroom, which was located on a regular junior high school campus in the City District. Mr. Hardamon testified that STUDENT was mainstreamed during lunch, recess, assemblies, and physical education. He testified that STUDENT had learned to play bass and that general education kids played music with him during recess. Mr. Hardamon believes the general education students liked STUDENT. Ms. Rios, who worked in STUDENT’s class for approximately six months, testified that general education students came in and interacted with STUDENT for approximately five or ten minutes per week during which time they discussed music or videos, for example. Ms. Rios also indicated that special education students from other classes came to STUDENT’s classroom and interacted with him for approximately forty minutes, four days per week. Those students practiced social skills or math with STUDENT. Ms. Rios testified that she thought STUDENT interacted well with the other students and enjoyed the interaction.

With respect to STUDENT’s behavior, Mr. Hardamon testified that STUDENT never tried to strike him, although STUDENT had tried to strike his aide during that year. (Footnote 32) Mr. Hardamon indicated that STUDENT’s attempted swings were easy to avoid by taking a step back given that STUDENT had poor muscle tone. Mr. Hardamon testified that although STUDENT did present behavioral challenges, Mr. Hardamon developed a rapport with STUDENT and learned how to handle him by watching FATHER’s interactions with STUDENT. Neither Mr. Hardamon nor Ms. Rios indicated that STUDENT had touched them offensively. Mr. Hardamon testified that he thought STUDENT was quite successful in the City District’s program.

In addition to evidence of success in Mr. Hardamon’s program with the support of a behavioral plan, the Hearing Officer notes there was no evidence that STUDENT has harmed or attempted to harm other students or that he has caused substantial disruption to other students. The absence of this type of evidence also weighs in favor of providing at least some mainstreaming opportunities to STUDENT. (See Rachel H., 14 F.3d at 1404 (holding that the court should consider, among other factors, the effect the child has on the teacher or other children in the regular classroom).)

The law squarely places the burden of proving the appropriateness of a placement on the District. (Seattle School Dist., No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1498 (9th Cir. 1996).) As the party urging the more restrictive placement, the District’s burden includes proving that AIM is the LRE for STUDENT. (Daniel R.R., 874 F.2d 1036.) The Hearing Officer finds that the District has not demonstrated that the AIM program is the LRE for STUDENT. In short, the District proposed a highly segregated, restrictive, full-time placement in AIM without considering whether STUDENT’s behavioral needs could be sufficiently met in a less restrictive environment with behavioral supports, strategies, or interventions. The occurrence of behavioral episodes, standing alone, is not a sufficient rationale for ignoring the requirement of LRE.

Although the District’s current offer of the AIM program is too restrictive, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded that the District is required to offer another placement at Golden Valley where the parents would like him to attend. There is no requirement in the IDEA that the District offer an appropriate program at a particular school site. (See Kevin G. by Robert G. v. Cranston School Committee, 130 F.3d 481 (1st Cir. 1997); Barnett by Barnett v. Fairfax County School Bd., 927 F.2d 146, 152 (4th Cir. 1991).) Furthermore, although Student contends that the low functioning autism class at Golden Valley may be appropriate, Student presented very little evidence regarding that program, except for a question here and there on cross-examination of District witnesses. In addition, the Hearing Officer is not convinced that STUDENT would be a good fit given that autistic children, who generally require a great deal of stability and are adverse to change, may be particularly vulnerable to any behavioral problems STUDENT may exhibit.

Given the possibility that the District may re-offer the AIM program to STUDENT with some mainstreaming opportunities, the Hearing Officer makes the following additional observations. The evidence is that the AIM program is designed to meet STUDENT’s core needs in many respects, including, for example, behavioral needs, functional academic needs, and social needs (except for education in the LRE) in a structured setting with a low student-to-staff ratio. For example, Ms. Jorgenson testified that the AIM program is designed for students with behavioral problems like STUDENT’s. A social worker observes incoming students in their class setting during the first thirty days and then makes additional recommendations with respect to behaviors, if appropriate. Ms. Jorgenson’s unopposed testimony was that AIM offers a functional academic program and focuses on developing social skills, including community outings. She also testified that AIM currently has thirty-eight students, four teachers, and approximately a two-to-one student-to-staff ratio, that the students generally remain in one class throughout the day, and that the program is more managed and structured than what STUDENT experienced at Golden Valley. In addition, she testified that AIM could meet STUDENT’s adapted physical education needs.

Other than AIM not being STUDENT’s LRE, his central contentions against AIM are arguments that AIM’s facilities, which are located on the Vista West campus, are unhealthy, unsafe, or inadequate. With respect to Student’s contention that the AIM program’s location next to an oil refinery is hazardous to his health, there was no evidence that his needs required him to be some minimal distance from the refinery. In spite of pictures of the refinery and testimony regarding the Vista West campus’s distance from the refinery, no evidence was presented that the refinery presents any special health risks to STUDENT based on his unique needs. (Footnote 33)

With respect to safety concerns, Student contends that he could escape from the campus onto a busy street. Ms. Jorgenson’s unopposed testimony was that the Vista West campus is gated but that the gates are not locked. The Hearing Officer is unable to determine from the evidence presented whether the Vista West campus is sufficiently secure to meet STUDENT’s flight risk. Among some of the unknown factors bearing on this issue are how many gates there are on campus, how far the gates are from where the AIM program is located, and whether STUDENT would have a full-time aide at AIM who would strictly monitor his whereabouts. Regardless of where STUDENT attends school, the IEP team must consider what steps are necessary to protect STUDENT from the flight risk he presents.

Student also contends that he would be physically vulnerable to the general education population at Vista West whom he characterized as having violent tendencies. Although it is undisputed that Vista West is an alternative education campus, Ms. Jorgenson testified that there have not been any problems with the general education population of students at Vista West interfering with the students in the AIM program. There was no evidence presented refuting Ms. Jorgenson’s testimony or otherwise proving that the other students at Vista West present a particular danger to STUDENT. Accordingly, on the basis of the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that the general education population at Vista West does not present a special risk of physical harm to STUDENT based on his unique needs.

With respect to Student’s contention that there are no showers available for him to use in the event of a toileting accident, the District responds that it has purchased a shower unit that can be installed in either of the two bathrooms available for his use at Vista West where the AIM program is located. Ms. Young testified that the District has purchased this equipment. The Hearing Officer finds that the AIM program is not deficient simply because a shower has not yet been installed at Vista West. Given that the District would not know in advance of this Decision whether its offer of the AIM program will be upheld or whether the parents will ultimately accept such a placement and allow STUDENT to attend the AIM program, it would not be reasonable to expect the District to have installed a shower at a facility STUDENT may never attend. After the District receives assurances from the parents that they will accept a particular placement, then the shower, if necessary, should be immediately installed. (Footnote 34)

Given the foregoing discussion with respect to LRE, the Hearing Officer will order the IEP team to reconvene to discuss and develop an appropriate placement for STUDENT consistent with this Decision. Given STUDENT’s need for structure and difficulty with change, the parties are in general agreement that a self-contained classroom will better meet his needs than a placement where he is changing from class to class throughout the entire school day. The District should ensure that all of STUDENT’s teachers, aides, and related service providers are given a copy of the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP and that District personnel implement it. (Footnote 35) Whichever placement is chosen by the IEP team, there may very well be a period of time where STUDENT experiences behavioral difficulties as he adjusts to the new placement. From the beginning, it will be imperative that the staff who works with STUDENT understand what triggers his behaviors and how to respond to STUDENT, which, at least in part, is described in the BSP. The Hearing Officer also notes that the District should make clear in its new offer of placement whether it is offering the services of a one-to-one aide for STUDENT. (Footnote 36) At a minimum, the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP requires that STUDENT be accompanied at all times when he uses the bathroom. (Exhibit 13-28.) In addition, the nature of STUDENT’s eating disorder requires that STUDENT be closely monitored when food is present.

*****

In light of the foregoing findings, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to provide or offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 regular school year. The District failed in its obligation to provide and offer a FAPE to the extent that it did not provide appropriate goals and benchmarks in the areas of functional academics, APE, and behavior, that it did not implement the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP, and that it did not offer a placement in the LRE.

ISSUE NO. 2: If the District has failed to provide or offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 regular school year, is he entitled to compensatory education?

If a district fails to provide a FAPE, then a child is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of IDEA. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359, 369 (1985). Based on the principle set forth in Burlington, federal courts have held that compensatory education is a form of equitable relief which may be granted for the denial of appropriate special education services to help overcome lost educational opportunity. (See Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist., 31 F.3d 1489, 1496-1497 (9th Cir. 1994).) Nevertheless, there is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for-hour compensation for time missed. (Id. at 1497.)

Because the District did not offer a program that addressed STUDENT’s needs in the LRE, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s parents were justified in not consenting to the September 15, 2004 IEP and in refusing to allow his transfer into the AIM program. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer also finds that an award of compensatory education is appropriate.

Physical therapy and speech and language therapy are the only two areas in which the Student is asserting a right to compensatory education. The Hearing Officer has previously determined, based on the evidence presented, that the District appropriately offered adapted physical education (APE) in lieu of physical therapy. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer will address whether STUDENT is entitled to compensatory education in the areas of APE and speech and language therapy.

As mentioned, STUDENT did not attend school after September 27, 2004, and he was suspended on September 28 and 29, 2004. Therefore, the Hearing Officer considers whether STUDENT is entitled to compensatory education in the areas of APE and speech and language therapy after September 29, 2004. Although Petitioner has requested an hour-for-hour award of compensatory education, neither of the parties offered evidence or argument with respect to how much APE and speech and language therapy is required to bring STUDENT to a point similar to where he would be if such services had been rendered during the weeks he has been out of school. Determining a precise amount of compensatory educational services always involves a difficult appraisal of where the child might have been had he been appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA and what services are required to redress the failure to appropriately educate.

With respect to APE, the September 10, 2004 IEP, which is the last agreed upon IEP, requires the District to provide one period per school day of APE. Nevertheless, the Hearing Officer previously determined that the offer of four weekly sessions of twenty minutes per session, as stated in the September 15, 2004 IEP meets STUDENT’s needs, and he finds that this level of APE per week (i.e., one hour and twenty minutes) is an appropriate starting point for considering an award of compensatory education. In light of the totality of the circumstances in this case—taking into consideration the length of the deprivation and the nature of the deprivation—the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is entitled to compensatory services in the form of twelve APE sessions of twenty minutes each for a total of four hours of APE services.

With respect to speech and language services, the September 10, 2004 IEP requires the District to provide thirty minutes of services per week. Although it indicates that the services may be provided in a one-to-one or “small setting,” the more recent IEP of September 15, 2004, eliminates the “small setting” language. The clear implication from Ms. Sarff’s testimony is that she had been providing one-to-one instruction to STUDENT at each speech and language session. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the speech and language services should be provided to STUDENT on a one-to-one basis. As to the amount of services, the Hearing Officer awards STUDENT compensatory education of twelve thirty-minute sessions of speech and language therapy for a total of six hours of speech and language services.

The Hearing Officer will reserve to the IEP team the task of scheduling the compensatory education so that the APE services and speech and language services are completed by June 15, 2005.

ORDER

1. As compensatory education, the District shall provide STUDENT twelve twenty-minute sessions of APE and twelve thirty-minute sessions of speech and language therapy. Each of these sessions of APE and of speech and language therapy must be provided in addition to the APE and speech and language services STUDENT would ordinarily receive during the regular school week. At the IEP meeting discussed below, the IEP team shall develop a schedule for the delivery of the compensatory education so that STUDENT receives all compensatory education services by June 15, 2005.

2. By January 14, 2005, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting and develop a new IEP. During the IEP meeting, the IEP team shall:

A. discuss and describe in the IEP a placement offer that is the LRE for STUDENT in conformity with the findings made in this Decision, including the findings that STUDENT needs a self-contained placement that provides a functional academic program taught by a special education teacher with a low student-to-adult ratio, behavioral supports, and mainstreaming opportunities;

B. replace the goals and benchmarks of the September 15, 2004 IEP on the pages entitled “Math 2A,” “Reading Comprehension 1,” “Reading 1,” “Written and Oral Language” with goals and benchmarks designed to meet STUDENT’s functional academic needs;

C. discuss and revise the goals and benchmarks of the September 15, 2004 IEP on the pages entitled “Adaptive P.E.” and “BSP Behavioral Goals”;

D. discuss and state in the IEP whether or not STUDENT will be provided a one-to-one aide (if a full-time one-to-one aide is not offered by the District, the District shall otherwise specify in the IEP how adequate supervision of STUDENT will be ensured when food is present and during toileting); and

E. consider and state in the IEP what measures will be taken to protect STUDENT from the escape risk he presents.

3. The District shall ensure that all of STUDENT’s teachers, aides, and related service providers are given a copy of the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP and that these individuals are instructed to follow it.

4. All of Student’s other claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

1. Has the District provided and offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2004-2005 regular school year?

Student is the substantially prevailing party on this issue.

2. If the District has failed to provide or offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 regular school year, is he entitled to compensatory education?

Student prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety days of receipt of this Decision. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).)

Dated: December 14, 2004 ____________________________________ Terrence B. Ohler, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

After the Hearing Officer’s ruling, FATHER was permitted to address the Hearing Officer directly on the record. FATHER was not in attendance at hearing when the motion to change hearing location was argued. FATHER argued additional bases for why the hearing location should be changed, such as that he never wanted the current hearing location, which he argued was not a neutral setting because it was District property, and that the policy of no smoking on school grounds made the hearing site inconvenient for observers to the hearing. The Hearing Officer did not consider these additional bases for Student’s motion as no motion to reconsider the ruling was requested. In any event, the Hearing Officer notes that the additional bases advanced by FATHER would not have changed the Hearing Officer’s ruling. The additional bases were not relevant to the Hearing Officer’s determination that the hearing location remained “reasonably convenient” to the parents and STUDENT in accordance with Education Code section 56505(b).

2 Although Student sometimes used the term “nursing assessment” at hearing, the term “health assessment” will be used instead in this Decision as that term more accurately describes what was being requested. (See District’s Exhibit 22, which is the request for a health assessment and is to be performed by a school nurse.)

3 The City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP indicates, for example, that a bathroom schedule is utilized, that a “go and flush” strategy is used (meaning the toilet is flushed immediately after bowel movements), that he needs assistance cleaning himself, and that staff should accompany him at all times in the restroom. (District’s Exhibit 13-26.)

4 Student’s exhibits are lettered, and the District’s exhibits are numbered. Exhibit page numbers are referenced by a dash. For example, page 10 of Exhibit B is referenced as “Exhibit B-10.”

5 The Hearing Officer does not address issues that were not specifically raised at the hearing. For example, Student’s closing brief raises the issue of whether the District violated the Student’s rights by holding meetings where it considered placement without the parents being present. However, this issue was not specifically presented as one for hearing, and, accordingly, the District has not been given a fair opportunity to respond to the contention.

6 The issue of whether STUDENT needs a one-to-one aide to receive an appropriate education was not raised as an issue for hearing. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer will not address this requested remedy. Nevertheless, the Hearing Officer notes that he is unaware of any authority that would require a school district to allow a student’s father to act as the student’s aide.

7 During clarification of the issues, Student also contended he suffers from “Bilateral Bowin,” which he claims relates to one leg growing longer than the other. This term also appears in the District’s IEP documents of September 10 and 15, 2004. Nevertheless, no evidence was presented by either party as to what this condition is or its effect, if any, on his needs.

8 The Hearing Officer notes that Student elected not to call any of the numerous medical practitioners he initially stated were expected to testify.

9 The parties used the phrase “adaptive physical education” both in testimony and in the IEPs. However, the law uses the term “adapted,” not the term “adaptive.” (See, e.g., 34 C.F.R. § 300.26(b)(2)(ii); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(b)(5).) Accordingly, the Hearing Officer will use the term “adapted,” instead of “adaptive,” in this Decision.

10 The parties stipulated that STUDENT attended school on the following days: August 30 and 31, 2004; and September 1 (but went home at 10 a.m.), 2, 3, 7, 8, 9, 10 (but went home at 9 a.m.), 20, 21, 22 (but went home at 10:30 a.m.), 23, 24, and 27, 2004. 11 “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, provided at no cost to parents, that meets the unique needs of the child. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.) “Related services” means transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(z).)

12 OSEP also indicates that a school nurse’s participation is subject to the same standard as other providers of related services and that he or she could be a member of the IEP team at the discretion of the parents or public agency, provided that the nurse possesses the requisite knowledge and special expertise regarding the child. (64 Fed. Reg. 48 at 12585.)

13 The September 15, 2004 IEP document reflects that Student’s attorney, Ms. Huffman, acknowledged at the IEP meeting that the suspension was understandable. (Exhibit 13-18.)

14 Student’s counsel confirmed in a telephone conference on November 5, 2004, that Student is only contesting the appropriateness of the District’s proposed placement in the AIM program, not his former placement at Golden Valley. Nevertheless, as discussed further below, Student believes he should not return to his former placement at Golden Valley but instead should be placed in a self-contained classroom at Golden Valley.

15 The District’s brief contends that Student only elicited testimony about the behavioral goal. However, this is not true. For example, Student asked questions regarding goals and benchmarks of Mr. Richard Davis regarding math, of Ms. Misty Thomas regarding written and oral language, and of Ms. Krizo regarding adapted physical education.

16 In fact, Mr. Davis acknowledged that he thought the math goal and benchmarks were likely a grade level too high for STUDENT and he was uncertain whether functional math might be more appropriate for STUDENT.

17 Although much of the testimony regarding the behavioral goals and benchmarks focused on the September 10, 2004 IEP (see Exhibit 12-12), the Hearing Officer references Exhibit 13 which comprises the District’s most current offer and contains a virtually identical document at Exhibit 13-7.

18 Student made no specific contention that the only remaining goal and benchmarks in the September 15, 2004 IEP, which are related to speech and language, are deficient.

19 While FATHER made passing reference to students being physically taken down at AIM on a daily basis and to there being blood on the bottom of the classroom door during his testimony, these contentions were not put at issue through Student’s statement of issues or during the discussion of the issues for hearing, and they, therefore, will not be addressed in this Decision. In any event, these alleged facts were not sufficiently established at the hearing by FATHER’s testimony or otherwise.

20 In addition, Student elected not to present some of his evidence and testimony that, it appears, may have been relevant to these claims. For example, Student elected not to call any of his medical providers. He also acquiesced in the District’s objection to Exhibit C, which contains miscellaneous information regarding prescriptions and diet but which was not admitted into evidence. However, the Hearing Officer notes that while some of these sources of evidence may have offered information relevant to STUDENT’s health needs, the District’s actions can be judged only in light of what the District knew or should have known at the time it made its offer. (See Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999).)

21 The terms health “plans” and “protocols” were used interchangeably by Student’s counsel and are used interchangeably for purposes of this Decision.

22 The Hearing Officer notes that FATHER testified that he submitted a binder of articles regarding PWS to the District before the school year began. However, there is no evidence that the binder, which was not submitted into evidence, contained any information specific to STUDENT and his special education needs. 23 The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has determined that if parents want their child to receive special education and related services under the IDEA, the parents must allow the educational agency to assess their child. (Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1315; see also Andress v. Cleveland Independent Sch. Dist., 64 F.3d 176, 179 (5th Cir. 1995), cert. denied, 519 U.S. 812 (1996) (stating “there is no exception to the rule”).)

24 The Hearing Officer hopes that STUDENT’s parents, health professionals, and other representatives will be clear in identifying to the District precisely what health needs the District should address, and he suggests that Student’s health requests of District personnel be made in writing. This should help eliminate confusion over what health procedures STUDENT is able to perform as opposed to procedures District staff should perform. (See also Cal. Code of Regs. tit. 5, § 3051.12 (requiring a specific written statement from a physician and surgeon and from the parent for “specialized physical health care services” a student is required to have during the school day).)

25 He apparently has also been known to eat his feces, although no evidence of this fact was presented.

26 The sufficiency of the AIM program’s showering facilities will be addressed below in the section regarding whether AIM is STUDENT’s least restrictive environment.

27 The Hearing Officer notes that the amount of time offered in APE per week (one hour, twenty minutes) far exceeds the amount of time in physical therapy that Student asserts he should be provided per week (thirty minutes).

28 The Hearing Officer notes that Student stated during the hearing on October 21, 2004, that he was not raising issues with respect to whether the District failed to properly assess him. Additionally, there was no evidence that an assistive technology assessment was ever requested, and there was no contention that the District should have otherwise performed such an assessment.

29 The Hearing Officer finds it unnecessary to separately discuss Student’s issue regarding aides not properly supervising him. In addition to the fact that Student’s attorney indicated that the issue could be combined with the issue of the behavioral plan, the violation, if any, would not lead to a different remedy in this case, even if it is assumed to be true.

30 The Hearing Officer notes that LRE was also the central thrust to the objection to the AIM placement as stated by Student’s attorney at the September 15, 2004 IEP meeting and memorialized in the September 15, 2004 IEP. As paraphrased in that document, Student’s attorney stated, in part: “I disagree with the AIM program…. It is too restrictive and [STUDENT] has not [been] given the opportunity to be provided [an education] on the mainstream campus. … Not giving him an opportunity to an alternative structure in the mainstream campus before he is sent to a restrictive program is inefficient.” (Exhibit 13-18.) Questions were also presented to witnesses at hearing regarding mainstreaming opportunities at AIM without any relevance objection being stated by the District’s attorney. It is not credible that the District did not know that LRE was an issue in this hearing.

31 The factors include consideration of: (1) the academic benefits available to the child from placement in a regular classroom; (2) the nonacademic benefits available to the child from such a placement; (3) the effect the child has on the teacher and other children in the regular classroom; and (4) the costs of mainstreaming the child. Rachel H., 14 F.3d at 1404.

32 Mr. Hardamon testified that he never saw STUDENT actually strike his aide. There is a document indicating STUDENT struck his aide on at least one occasion, but the document was not admitted into evidence because a sufficient foundation for the document had not been established. (See Exhibit 52.)

33 During the clarification of the issues, Student’s attorney also contended that STUDENT could eat paint chips left around the drinking fountain at AIM. However, no evidence was presented about paint chips being around a drinking fountain. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer does not address this contention.

34 The Hearing Officer notes that the District should not expect STUDENT’s parents to clean STUDENT after toileting accidents at school, although the evidence is inconclusive whether this has been the case in the past.

35 Because Student acknowledges that the City District’s June 8, 2004 BSP is appropriate to address his behavioral needs, the Hearing Officer will not address whether additional behavioral supports, strategies, interventions, or goals and benchmarks are necessary to provide him a FAPE. Nothing in this Decision should be construed to prevent the District from eventually developing its own BSP or from offering additional methods to address STUDENT’s behavioral needs.

36 While Ms. Krizo testified that STUDENT would have the services of a one-to-one aide on a full-time basis while at Golden Valley, neither the September 10, 2004 nor the September 15, 2004 IEP indicates what aide support STUDENT would receive. Whether STUDENT needs the services of a one-to-one aide was not placed at issue in this hearing.