California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 7, 2002
Student v. San Diego Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 2386-01 · Hearing Officer Maxine R. Benmour
San Diego Unified denied FAPE in reading for three years and must give a Down syndrome student one year of compensatory independent study.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted. Footnote 2 says Petitioner withdrew an issue about direct case-manager services under a California Department of Education order, and the parties resolved a speech and language issue on January 8, 2002.
Summary
The parent of an 18-year-old twelfth grader filed against San Diego Unified School District. The student has Down syndrome and was eligible for special education under the category then called mental retardation. He attended a full inclusion program at Madison High School, read at about a first-grade level, and planned to pursue supported employment after graduating in June 2002. His mother argued that the District should have provided a comprehensive, phonics-based reading program from 1999-2000 through 2001-2002, instead of the sight-word program it adopted in May 2000. She asked for an intensive program at the Whittier Learning Center that would continue past age 21.
The Hearing Officer found that the District denied FAPE in all three years, but for a different reason than the phonics dispute. Neither program taught the student to read what he would need for work and independent living, such as job applications, bus schedules, prescriptions, and food labels. His IEPs and transition plans had no reading goals tied to those needs. The request for Whittier was denied because no evidence showed that Whittier could meet these needs or that services past age 21 were required. Instead, the Hearing Officer ordered one year of compensatory independent study after graduation, through June 2003, focused on reading for jobs and daily living. The District had to hold an IEP meeting within 15 days, start the program within 30 days, and consider locations other than Madison.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO tied reading instruction for an older student with significant cognitive disabilities to the transition plan. The Hearing Officer found a denial of FAPE because reading goals did not match the student's goals for work and independent living. The remedy was a year of post-graduation instruction in place of the private program the parent requested.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Did the District fail to provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education for the 1999-2000, 2000-2001, and 2001-2002 school years by failing to provide him with a comprehensive, phonics-based reading program?
Denial of FAPE in all three years: neither the phonics nor the sight-word program, and no IEP/ITP goal, addressed the student's reading needs for supported employment and independent living after graduation.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. If the District failed to provide FAPE for those school years, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education in the form of an intense reading program at the Whittier Learning Center that extends beyond the age of twenty-one?
Whittier placement and services past age 21 denied for lack of evidence; one year of compensatory independent study in employment and independent-living reading ordered instead.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. District to convene an IEP meeting within 15 calendar days of the decision to develop an independent study program teaching reading related to supported employment and independent living, considering the student's abilities, goals, and transition plan requirements.
- Compensatory education. One year of compensatory independent study beyond June 2002 graduation, to begin within 30 days of the decision and continue through June 2003, teaching reading related to job descriptions, job applications, other job-related information, and independent living. The IEP team must consider locations other than Madison High School, including places where the student can study with chronological peers or students with similar reading needs.
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; School Committee of Town of Burlington v. Department of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.; M.C. v. Central Regional School Dist.; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education; Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. State of Missouri
People named in the decision
- Debra Zapp, full inclusion itinerant teacher (taught phonics-based reading program), San Diego Unified School District
- Dayle Taresh, full inclusion itinerant teacher; assessor (Woodcock-Johnson, Fry, San Diego Quick Assessment), San Diego Unified School District
- Marcia Holdaway, full inclusion aide, San Diego Unified School District
- Gregory Lyon, special education instructional assistant (also spelled Lyons in decision), San Diego Unified School District
- Robert Morris, program manager, San Diego Unified School District
- Pamela Garcia, third-grade teacher who conducted a reading assessment at parent's request; witness for Student, Chula Vista Elementary School District
- Whittier Learning Center, private reading program requested by parent, private provider
- Maleia Christian, volunteer advocate for Student
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Maxine R. Benmour, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in San Diego, California, on December 11 and 12, 2001.
Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Thomas S. Nelson and volunteer advocate Maleia Christian. Also present on Petitioner’s behalf was his mother, MOTHER.(Footnote 1) Respondent San Diego Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Ricardo J. Soto, District assistant general counsel.
Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: MOTHER, Petitioner’s mother; Debra Zapp, District full inclusion itinerant teacher; Pamela Garcia, Chula Vista Elementary School District teacher; Marcia Holdaway, District full inclusion aide; and Gregory Lyon, District special education instructional assistant.
The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Dayle Taresh, District full inclusion itinerant teacher, and Robert Morris, District program manager.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the parties to submit written closing arguments. Upon receipt of the briefs on January 7, 2002, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUES(Footnote 2)
1. Did the District fail to provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education for the 1999-2000, 2000-2001, and 2001-2002 school years by failing to provide him with a comprehensive, phonics-based reading program?
2. If the District failed to provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education for the 1999-2000, 2000-2001, and 2000-2001 school years, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education in the form of an intense reading program at the Whittier Learning Center that extends beyond the age of twenty-one?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is an eighteen-year-old student with Down Syndrome who has been eligible for special education under the category of mental retardation since kindergarten. STUDENT exhibits mild to moderate cognitive delays and significant delays in adaptive behavior. He is currently in the twelfth grade in a full inclusion program at the District’s Madison High School (Madison) and plans to graduate in June 2002.
When STUDENT was in the first grade, he began reading instruction in a phonics-based program at the District’s Juarez Elementary School. From second grade through fourth grade, the District placed STUDENT in an intensive reading mastery classroom at Birney Elementary School. As a result of this intensive reading program, by the time STUDENT was in the fourth grade, he had learned vowel and consonant sounds, phonetic spelling, and how to write a simple sentence with prompting. Standardized achievement testing in the area of reading at the time found him to score at the first-grade level in letter-word identification, passage comprehension, and broad reading.
When STUDENT began the fifth grade, the District changed his classroom, and he no longer received the intensive reading program he had received during the prior three years. Instead, he participated in the regular education fifth-grade curriculum, including the regular education fifth-grade reading curriculum. When STUDENT began the sixth grade, the District again changed his program to one in which he would learn social functional skills rather than academic skills. As a result, in sixth grade, STUDENT participated in the regular education reading curriculum supplemented only by a reading laboratory. The District continued this program throughout seventh and eighth grades when STUDENT was attending Pacific Beach Middle School. In addition, STUDENT’s individualized education program (IEP) team did not develop any goals or objectives related to reading skills during fifth through eighth grades.
During the 1998-1999 school year, when STUDENT began the ninth grade at Madison, the District placed him in a full inclusion program with an adapted curriculum and an itinerant full inclusion teacher. Debra Zapp, STUDENT’s itinerant full inclusion teacher, began reading instruction with STUDENT in a comprehensive, phonics-based reading program.
On May 27, 1999, at the end of STUDENT’s ninth-grade year, the District convened an IEP meeting and noted that STUDENT was reading at a set 1, level 4 reading level, in a primary reading series implemented by Ms. Zapp.(Footnote 3) The team agreed to continue Ms. Zapp’s phonics-based reading program and established a goal for the following year for STUDENT of completing set 3, level 3, of this primary reading series.
In December 1999, when STUDENT was in the tenth grade, Ms. Zapp left Madison, and the District replaced her with Dayle Taresh, another full inclusion itinerant teacher. In January, March, and May 2000, after Ms. Taresh had begun to work with STUDENT, she administered the Fry Oral Reading Test to him and found him able to read a simple, first-grade level paragraph at a slow pace with zero to two errors, and to read a more advanced paragraph at the same pace with five to six errors. She also administered the San Diego Quick Assessment during this time and found that STUDENT continued to read at the primer and first grade levels.
Ms. Taresh continued the reading program begun by Ms. Zapp until May 2000, when the District convened an IEP meeting to discuss STUDENT’s program for the following school year. At that meeting, Ms. Taresh described STUDENT’s current levels of performance in reading as having “made some growth, however his instructional level of reading consistently tests at the primer level.” She further noted that STUDENT read in context at a first-grade level. In light of her assessments and STUDENT’s age, Ms. Taresh recommended that STUDENT transition from his phonics-based reading program to a sight-word reading program in which he would learn to recognize and read signs and other information in the community. The IEP team established an annual goal of reading and understanding the meaning of seventeen community survival signs with ninety percent accuracy. District personnel and STUDENT’s mother agreed to the new reading goal.
On December 4, 2000, when STUDENT was in the eleventh grade, the District again convened an IEP meeting. At this meeting, STUDENT’s mother expressed disagreement with the sight-word reading program begun by Ms. Taresh in May 2000, and requested that the District instead provide STUDENT with a comprehensive, phonics-based reading program similar to the one previously provided by Ms. Zapp. MOTHER also requested that the District place STUDENT at the Whittier Learning Center (Whittier) because she believed that he needed an intensive reading program to compensate for the time since May 2000 that he had not been in the phonics-based program. The District members of the team advised her that they would have to assess STUDENT to determine if he required an intensive reading program such as the one at Whittier.
In December 2000, following the IEP meeting, Ms. Taresh administered the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement (Woodcock-Johnson) and the San Diego City Schools Current Performance Profile-Functional Academics Information (San Diego) to STUDENT. In the areas of letter-word identification, passage comprehension, and broad reading on the Woodcock-Johnson, STUDENT scored at the first-grade level. On the San Diego, Ms. Taresh found that STUDENT was able to read his name and the names of familiar people, to read approximately forty-four functional words, to read sixty common sight words, and to recall main characters and some events when short passages were read to him.
On June 1, 2001, following these assessments, the District again convened an IEP meeting. Based on her assessments, Ms. Taresh recommended that STUDENT continue instruction in sight-word reading rather than reverting to the phonics program that he had previously received. Ms. Taresh advised the IEP team that she believed that STUDENT was not learning to read in the phonics-based program. The District thus informed MOTHER that it would not place STUDENT at Whittier.
In November 2001, STUDENT’s mother filed a request for due process hearing with the Special Education Hearing Office. She disagrees with the sight-word reading program offered by the District and believes that STUDENT should have been receiving a phonics-based reading program for the 1999-2000, 2000-2001, and 2001-2002 school years.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Did the District fail to provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education for the 1999-2000, 2000-2001, and 2001-2002 school years by failing to provide him with a comprehensive, phonics-based reading program?
Under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge, that meet the standard of the state education agency, and that conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).
The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective and supportive services as may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). California Education Code § 56252 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” Included in the list of related services are speech and language, orientation and mobility, physical and occupational therapy, counseling, health and nursing services, social worker services, adapted physical education, and psychological services.
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, the Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services which must be provided a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of IDEA. The court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available education or services or that the services maximize each child’s potential. The court stated that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to meet the student’s unique needs and confer educational benefit. Id. at 200-201.
To determine whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of the District’s proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist. (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307, 1314. If the District’s proposed program would have addressed the Petitioner’s unique needs, provided him some educational benefit, and comported with his IEP, then the District offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would likely result in greater educational benefit. Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., supra, 811 F.2d at 1314.
When taken together, the IDEA and the Supreme Court’s Rowley decision require that an appropriate program: (1) be designed to meet the unique needs of the student, (2) be reasonably calculated to provide the student with educational benefit, and (3) conform to the student’s IEP. Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 200.
In addition, an appropriate program for a student who is fourteen years of age or older must include transition services to promote the student’s movement from school to activities after graduation. Such activities may include postsecondary education, vocational training, integrated employment, adult education, adult services, independent living, or community participation, depending upon the unique needs of the particular student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(30); Calif. Educ. Code § 56345.1(c). These services must also include instructional strategies that will prepare pupils with severe disabilities to make a successful transition to supported employment and living in the community. Calif. Educ. Code § 56462(c)(1).
Petitioner contends that the District failed to provide him with a FAPE during the 1999-2000, 2000-2001, and 2001-2002 school years by its failure to provide him with a reading program that was based upon phonics instruction. The District contends that STUDENT did not require a phonics-based program and that it appropriately provided him with a sight-word reading program geared to his community needs after graduation.
1999-2000 School Year
Was the District’s Offer Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?
As stated above, the Hearing Officer must first determine if the District’s reading program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs during the 1999-2000 school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer must first determine STUDENT’s unique needs during that year.
It is undisputed that STUDENT functioned at the first-grade level in reading during the 1999-2000 school year as demonstrated on all standardized tests administered to him since the second grade. A review of the evidence reveals that the District first administered the Woodcock-Johnson to STUDENT in June 1992, when he was in the second grade. STUDENT scored at the kindergarten and first-grade level on this test. The District again administered the Woodcock-Johnson to STUDENT in February 1995, when he was in the fifth grade. STUDENT again scored at the first-grade level in reading. In May 1998, when STUDENT was in the eighth grade, he again scored at the first-grade level in reading on the Wide Range Achievement Test.
The evidence thus reveals that during the 1999-2000 school year STUDENT read at a first-grade level. In addition, a review of STUDENT’s IEP of May 27, 1999 reveals that the IEP team agreed to one annual reading goal of increasing STUDENT’s reading skills so that he would be able to read at a higher level in his phonics reading program during the 1999-2000 school year. A review of this IEP also reveals that the team agreed in an Individualized Transition Plan (ITP) that STUDENT would pursue supported employment after graduation from high school in June 2002. At that time, STUDENT was working in the school cafeteria and was engaged in cleaning, stocking, and food preparation activities. Therefore, given STUDENT’s reading ability and his ITP goals during the 1999-2000 school year, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT had unique reading needs that year in the area of transition services, particularly in the area of preparation for supported employment and independent living after graduation. Pursuant to his IEP/ITP and federal and State law, STUDENT needed to learn to live an independent life after graduation.
District inclusion specialist Debra Zapp testified that she began to work with STUDENT in the fall of 1998, when he was in the ninth grade. At that time, she noted that STUDENT had not received specialized reading instruction for the past four years. Therefore, she instituted a phonics-based reading program that utilized a series of primary reading books that focused on reading comprehension. Ms. Zapp testified that STUDENT did well when she worked with him, made progress within the series of phonics-based books, and successfully worked on his IEP reading goal during the time that she taught him.
District aide Marcia Holdaway also testified that she began to work with STUDENT in March 2000. Ms. Holdaway helped STUDENT read from phonics-based books in which he was able to “sound out short and easy words,” and helped him read words with which he had difficulty. Ms. Holdaway testified that the phonics-based program she used also included words found in the community, and that STUDENT was a “whiz” with these words. According to Ms. Holdaway, STUDENT made progress during the time she worked with him because he learned both the recognition of words by sight as well as simple phonics. She also described STUDENT as greatly enjoying reading. In addition, when the District changed STUDENT’s program to a reading program that did not include phonics instruction in May 2000, Ms. Holdaway made flash cards for STUDENT to read but also helped him “sound out” words with which he was not familiar. If he was unable to “sound out” the word, she put the word into a sentence for STUDENT to read. After STUDENT mastered a list of words read in this manner, she provided him with a new list. According to Ms. Holdaway, STUDENT was able to learn a list of words from rote learning, but did not necessarily learn the meaning of the words unless he read them in context.
In addition to the foregoing witnesses, District inclusion specialist Dayle Taresh testified that she began to work with STUDENT in December 1999 after Ms. Zapp left Madison. Ms. Taresh further testified that she observed STUDENT in his reading program at that time and determined that he was unable to master the sounds in previous books that he had allegedly learned to read. She also observed that STUDENT did not seem to utilize sounds when he read, and that, rather than helping him with phonics, his aides merely gave him a word when did not know it.
After her observation of STUDENT during the spring semester of the 1999-2000 school year, Ms. Taresh decided to assess STUDENT with the use of the Instant Word List and the San Diego Quick Assessment. From these assessments, she determined that STUDENT read at or near the first-grade level. As a result of her observations of him, Ms. Taresh also believed that STUDENT’s success in using phonics had been “very small.” She disagreed that STUDENT was able to read the level of primer book that Ms. Zapp believed that he was able to read.
Ms. Taresh also testified that she believed that STUDENT read from sight rather than from phonics at the end of the 1999-2000 school year. She believed that STUDENT needed a sight-word reading program primarily because, after working with him for three or four months, she did not see him using phonics skills. In addition, she believed, based in part upon his age, that he needed to learn to read at a sufficient level so that he would be able to fill out job applications, read safety precautions, and survive independently in the community after he graduated.
On the basis of the foregoing evidence, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that, in both the phonics and sight-word reading programs, the District failed to address STUDENT’s unique reading needs in the area of transition services, particularly in the area of preparation for supported employment and independent living after graduation. Furthermore, the evidence reveals that the District used a program that was a combination of phonics and sight-word reading when it changed STUDENT’s reading program in May 2000. According to Ms. Holdaway, she used both flash cards and a “sounding out” method to teach reading to STUDENT and did not use only a sight-word program.
In addition, as indicated previously, Ms. Zapp, STUDENT’s inclusion teacher during the 1999-2000 school year, knew that STUDENT read at no higher than a first-grade level as demonstrated by standardized testing done in prior years. In addition, Ms. Zapp testified that she participated in the IEP meeting on May 27, 1999, and thus knew that STUDENT’s ITP goal was to obtain supported employment after graduation. However, her testimony reveals that, in her reading program, Ms. Zapp taught STUDENT to read only primer-level books. She did not teach him to read information that would be useful in his goal of supported employment and independent living after graduation. No one testified that the ability to read primer and first-grade books is a skill that is useful in employment.
Moreover, Ms. Taresh, who began to work with STUDENT in the middle of the 1999-2000 school year, testified that she had reviewed the reading program instituted by Ms. Zapp, and had also reviewed STUDENT’s IEP goals for that year. Therefore, Ms. Taresh also knew that STUDENT intended to pursue supported employment after graduation. However, she also did not teach STUDENT to read the information related to supported employment and independent living. She testified that STUDENT needed to learn to read in order to complete job applications. However, according to the evidence, she and STUDENT’s aides did not teach him to read job applications, but taught him only words that she thought would be useful in the community.
Despite the knowledge of both inclusion teachers who worked with STUDENT during the 1999-2000 school year that STUDENT intended to pursue supported employment after graduation, and despite IEP/ITP goals related to supported employment during that school year, the IEP team failed to address his reading needs in the area of supported employment and independent living. As indicated previously, Ms. Zapp’s goal was to teach STUDENT to read books in a primary series, and Ms. Taresh’s goal was to teach STUDENT a list of words that he would be able to use after graduation. Ms. Taresh testified that STUDENT needed to learn to read job applications and safety warnings. However, the evidence does not reveal that anyone at the District taught STUDENT to read job applications or safety warnings. They merely taught him to read primer and first-grade books and a list of words that he would recognize in the community.
However, in addition to the job applications and safety warnings that the District proposed to teach STUDENT, he needs to be able to read in a variety of settings in order to live independently. For example, in order to live independently, one needs to read words and sentences that are found in items such as job applications, job descriptions, medical prescriptions, telephone directories, bus schedules, maps, movie and television schedules, store prices, and food labels. There was no evidence that anyone at the District taught STUDENT the reading skills that he needed to learn to read these items or other items related to his ITP goals of post-graduation supported employment and independent living.
In addition, despite STUDENT’s unique reading needs in the area of supported employment and independent living after graduation, the IEP team failed to identify any goals in STUDENT’s IEP or ITP during the 1999-2000 school year related the need to read any of the items listed above. In May 1999, the District knew that STUDENT read at a first-grade level and that he planned to pursue supported employment after graduation. Despite this knowledge, it failed to identify any goals or objectives related to learning to read items that would help him secure employment. It also failed to identify any goals or objectives related to independent living. All that STUDENT had learned to read were primary books and a list of words. In light of STUDENT’s unique reading needs during the 1999-2000 school year, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to appropriately identify STUDENT’s needs, failed to identify goals and objectives related to those needs, and failed to address those needs in its phonics program, its sight-word programs, or a combination of the two programs. On the basis of STUDENT’s record as a first-grade reader, and the purpose of federal and State law relating to transition services for students with severe disabilities, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide STUDENT with an instructional approach in reading that addressed his employment-related and independent living reading needs during the 1999-2000 school year.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s reading program for STUDENT during the 1999-2000 school year was not designed to meet his unique reading needs in the area of transition services, particularly in the area of preparation for supported employment and independent living after graduation.
Was the District’s Offer Reasonably Calculated to Provide STUDENT With Educational Benefit?
Secondly, the Hearing Officer must determine if the District’s reading program during the 1999-2000 school year was designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. To be appropriate under the IDEA, the District’s proposed program must have been reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 200. While this requires a school district to provide a disabled child with meaningful access to education, it does not mean that the school district is required to guarantee totally successful results. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District (2d Cir. 1998) 142 F.3d 119, 133. De minimus benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Id. at 130; M.C. v. Central Regional School District (3d Cir. 1996) 81 F.3d 389, 393. However, a child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education (2d Cir. 1997) 103 F.3d 1114, 1121; Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16 (3d Cir. 1988) 853 F.2d 171, 185.
As indicated previously, because of STUDENT’s limitations, he read at a first-grade level while in the tenth grade. In addition, as discussed above, during the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT had unique reading needs in the area of transition services, particularly in the area of preparation for supported employment and independent living after graduation. As discussed above, the evidence indicates that the District failed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs during that year because it failed to address his need to learn to read in preparation for supported employment and independent living after graduation. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that none of the District’s reading programs in the 1999-2000 school year provided educational benefit in the area of reading for supported employment and independent living. The Hearing Officer thus finds that the District’s reading program during the 1999-2000 school year failed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.
Did the District’s Offer Conform to STUDENT’s IEP?
In light of the District’s failure to develop appropriate goals and objectives for STUDENT in his IEP for the 1999-2000 school year, the IEP for that year was substantively defective. Therefore, the issue of whether or not the District’s offer conformed to his IEP is not relevant to a determination of FAPE for the year.
On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s reading program for STUDENT for the 1999-2000 school year was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and was not reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. The Hearing Officer thus finds that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year.
2000-2001 School Year
Was the District’s Offer Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?
It is undisputed that STUDENT continued to function at the first-grade level in reading during the 2000-2001 school year as demonstrated on additional standardized tests administered to him during that year. In December 2000, District inclusion specialist Ms. Taresh administered the Woodcock-Johnson to STUDENT to determine his level of reading ability(Footnote 4). STUDENT again scored at the first-grade level in reading aptitude.
In addition, a review of STUDENT’s IEP/ITP dated May 25, 2000, reveals that the IEP team again agreed to one annual reading goal of reading and understanding seventeen “community survival” signs. At the time, the IEP/ITP team indicated that STUDENT was able to read the following signs: “no swimming,” “no cigarettes,” “stop,” and “exit.” This IEP also indicated that STUDENT continued to work in the school cafeteria, and that his education included “a growing focus on the development of post school and employment skills.” The team also recommended that STUDENT develop “job search skills.” Therefore, STUDENT’s reading ability and his IEP/ITP goals during the 2000-2001 school year established that STUDENT continued to have unique reading needs that year in the area of transition services, particularly in the area of preparation for supported employment and independent living after graduation.
In addition, District aide Gregory Lyons testified that he began working with STUDENT in December 2000, and that he and Ms. Holdaway shared the responsibility of working with STUDENT during the 2000-2001 school year. Mr. Lyons testified that he assisted STUDENT in reading, that STUDENT was able to read “fifty to sixty percent” of the words in books he read that year, and that STUDENT “sounded out” some of the words that he did not know. In addition, Ms. Holdaway testified that, during the 2000-2001 school year, she made flash cards to teach STUDENT lists of words. Her strategy in working with STUDENT was to determine if he knew the word, and, if he did not, to help him to “sound out” the word and, if he was unable to do that, she would put the word into a sentence for him to read. She testified that in this manner STUDENT was able to use many words in context. In addition, Ms. Taresh testified that STUDENT made good progress in reading while working with Ms. Holdaway during the 2000-2001 school year.
Similarly to the 1999-2000 school year, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that, in the reading program taught to STUDENT during the 2000-2001 school year, the District failed to address his unique reading needs in the area of transition services, particularly in the area of preparation for supported employment and independent living after graduation. In addition, although Ms. Taresh testified that she changed STUDENT’s reading program from a phonics-based program to a sight-word program, the evidence reveals that STUDENT’s aides continued to use the “sounding out” skills of a phonics program and the flash cards of a sight-word program. The testimony of both Mr. Lyons and Ms. Holdaway indicates that the District never completely abandoned the phonics program during the 2000-2001 school year. However, whichever program the District used, the evidence reveals that the District taught STUDENT a list of words but failed to teach him the reading skills necessary for supported employment and independent living. As indicated above, these skills include the ability to read words and sentences that are found in items such as job applications, job descriptions, medical prescriptions, telephone directories, bus schedules, maps, movie and television schedules, store prices, and food labels.
In addition, in spite of STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of supported employment after graduation, the IEP/ITP team again failed to identify any goals in STUDENT’s IEP/ITP during the 2000-2001 school year related the need to read words and sentences related to obtaining employment and independent living. In May 2000, the District knew that STUDENT read at a first-grade level and that he planned to pursue supported employment after graduation. Despite this knowledge, it again failed to identify any goals or objectives related to learning to read items that would help him secure employment or live independently. The only items that STUDENT learned to read that year were a list of words that were not necessarily related to employment or independent living. The Hearing Officer thus finds that the District failed to appropriately identify STUDENT’s reading needs, failed to identify goals and objectives related to those needs, and failed to address those needs in its reading program. In light of STUDENT’s record as a first-grade reader, and the purpose of federal and State law relating to transition services for students with severe disabilities, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide STUDENT with an instructional approach in reading that addressed his employment-related and independent living reading needs during the 2000-2001 school year.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s reading program for STUDENT during the 2000-2001 school year was not designed to meet his unique reading needs in the area of transition services, particularly in the areas of preparation for supported employment and independent living after graduation.
Was the District’s Offer Reasonably Calculated to Provide STUDENT With Educational Benefit?
As indicated above, because of STUDENT’s limitations, he read at a first-grade level during the 2000-2001 school year while in the eleventh grade. In addition, as discussed above, STUDENT had unique reading needs in the area of transition services, particularly in the areas of preparation for supported employment and independent living after graduation. As discussed above, the evidence indicates that the District failed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs during that year because it failed to address his need to learn to read in preparation for supported employment and independent living after graduation. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s reading program did not provide educational benefit in the area of reading for supported employment and independent living. The Hearing Officer thus finds that the District’s reading program during the 2000-2001 school year failed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.
Did the District’s Offer Conform to STUDENT’s IEP?
In light of the District’s failure to develop appropriate goals and objectives for STUDENT in his IEP for the 2000-2001 school year, the IEP for that year was substantively defective. Therefore, the issue of whether or not the District’s offer conformed to his IEP is not relevant to a determination of FAPE for the year.
On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s reading program for STUDENT for the 2000-2001 school year was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. The Hearing Officer thus finds that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year.
2001-2002 School Year
Was the District’s Offer Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?
It is undisputed that STUDENT continued to function at the first-grade level in reading in June 2001, when he was preparing to enter the twelfth grade, as demonstrated on additional assessments administered to him during that year.
In June 2001, the District members of the IEP team proposed a reading goal for STUDENT that would increase his reading vocabulary by forty words. Petitioner’s mother disagreed with this goal, as she believed that STUDENT already knew many of the proposed vocabulary words. Therefore, she asked Pamela Garcia, a third-grade bilingual teacher in the Chula Vista Elementary School District and friend of STUDENT’s family for nine years, to assess STUDENT’s reading abilities.
In October 20001, as a result of MOTHER’s request, Ms. Garcia, who has taught reading as part of her third-grade curriculum for fifteen years, assessed STUDENT’s reading abilities. In this regard, Ms. Garcia administered the Fry Oral Reading Test to STUDENT, asked STUDENT to read a list of vocabulary words developed by his mother, and listened as STUDENT read books to her. She testified that she tested STUDENT in the ability to read a list of words, and that he was able to read these words and use them in context. Ms. Garcia described STUDENT as someone who can read first-grade books for pleasure. During the hearing in this matter, Petitioner presented a videotape of Ms. Garcia’s assessment of STUDENT. Ms. Garcia described STUDENT’s performance in the videotape as knowing “most consonant sounds,” being able to identify 98 of the 100 most common words in the English language, and as an “independent reader” with an end-of-first-grade reading ability.
In contrast to Ms. Garcia’s opinion, Ms. Taresh testified that, when she observed STUDENT reading in the videotape, she saw him try a different word when he made an error rather than using a phonics-based strategy. Ms. Taresh also testified that she was very pleased to see that STUDENT recalled the words that he had learned during the prior year. Ms. Taresh saw STUDENT’s abilities in the videotape as evidence of the success of the sight-word program that she had implemented in the spring of 2000.
In addition, a review of STUDENT’s IEP/ITP dated June 1, 2001, for the 2001-2002 school year, indicates that the District proposed one reading goal of increasing sight-word vocabulary by forty words. STUDENT’s mother disagreed with this goal because she believed that STUDENT could already read many of the words on the District’s proposed list. Further, STUDENT’s IEP/ITP indicated that he continued to work in the school cafeteria, and that his duties included, “signing in, obtaining needed materials, counting or weighing items, and bagging items.” The IEP/ITP team recommended that STUDENT “continue to develop his job seeking and employment skills as he prepares for graduation,” and that his education include “a growing emphasis on development of employment and independent living.”
On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer is persuaded by the uncontradicted testimony of Ms. Garcia that STUDENT had learned to read a list of words and had learned to read at a first-grade level by the time that he was in the twelfth grade. However, the Hearing Officer finds that the reading program that the District proposed to teach STUDENT during the 2001-2002 school year failed to address his unique reading needs in the area of transition services, particularly in the areas of preparation for supported employment and independent living after graduation. As indicated by the evidence, the District proposed to teach STUDENT a list of words but failed to propose to teach him the reading skills needed for supported employment and independent living, including words and sentences found in items such as job applications, job descriptions, medical prescriptions, telephone directories, bus schedules, maps, movie and television schedules, store prices, and food labels.
In addition, in spite of STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of supported employment and independent living after graduation, the IEP team again failed to identify any goals in STUDENT’s IEP/ITP during the 2001-2002 school year related to the need to read items related to obtaining employment and independent living. In June 2001, the District knew that STUDENT read at a first-grade level, and that he planned to pursue supported employment after graduation. Despite having this knowledge, the District members of the IEP team failed to identify any goals or objectives related to learning to read items that would help STUDENT secure employment and to live independently. The only items that the District proposed to teach STUDENT to read that year were a list of words that were not shown to be related to employment or independent living. On the basis of STUDENT’s unique reading needs during the 2001-2002 school year, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to appropriately identify STUDENT’s needs, failed to identify goals and objectives related to those needs, and failed to address those needs in its proposed reading program. In light of STUDENT’s record as a first-grade reader, and the purpose of federal and State law relating to transition services for students with severe disabilities, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide STUDENT with an instructional approach in reading that addressed his employment-related and independent living reading needs during the 2001-2002 school year.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s reading program for STUDENT during the 2001-2002 school year was not designed to meet his unique reading needs in the area of transition services, in particular in the area of preparation for supported employment and independent living after graduation.
Was the District’s Offer Reasonably Calculated to Provide STUDENT With Educational Benefit?
As indicated above, the limitations imposed by STUDENT’s disability demonstrated that he continued to read at a first-grade level while in the twelfth grade. In addition, as discussed above, STUDENT had unique reading needs in the area of transition services, particularly in the areas of preparation for supported employment and independent living after graduation in June 2002. As discussed above, the evidence indicates that the District failed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in its proposed reading program for the 2001-2002 school year because it failed to address STUDENT’s need to learn to read in preparation for supported employment and independent living after graduation. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s proposed reading program for the 2001-2002 school year did not provide educational benefit in the area of reading for supported employment and independent living. The Hearing Officer thus finds that the District’s proposed reading program for the 2001-2002 school year failed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.
Did the District’s Offer Conform to STUDENT’s IEP?
In light of the District’s failure to develop appropriate goals and objectives for STUDENT in his IEP for the 2000-2001 school year, the IEP for that year was substantively defective. Therefore, the issue of whether or not the District’s offer conformed to his IEP is not relevant to a determination of FAPE for the year.
On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s reading program for STUDENT for the 2000-2001 school year was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique reading needs, and was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. The Hearing Officer thus finds that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year.
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s reading program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and was not reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit, and thus did not offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 1999-2000, 2000-2001, and 2001-2002 school years.
ISSUE NO. 2: If the District failed to provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education for the 1999-2000, 2000-2001, and 2001-2002 school years, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education in the form of an intense reading program at the Whittier Learning Center that extends beyond the age of twenty-one?
When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, supra, 471 U.S. at 369. Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have also extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3rd Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749. Compensatory education is an equitable remedy, and there is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for-hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the Student is appropriately educated with the meaning of the IDEA.” Student W. v. Puyallup School District, supra, 31 F.3d at 1497. In crafting appropriate relief, a hearing officer has broad latitude. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k); School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education of Massachusetts, supra, 471 U.S. 359.
Although the Hearing Officer found that the District failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1999-2000, 2000-2001, and 2001-2002 school years, Petitioner did not provide persuasive evidence that he requires compensatory education in the form of an intense reading program at the Whittier Learning Center that extends beyond the age of twenty-one. Petitioner presented no evidence from anyone at the Whittier Learning Center that its facility had a program that could address STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of reading related to supported employment and independent living. In addition, Petitioner presented no evidence that STUDENT requires compensatory education beyond the age of twenty-one.
However, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is entitled to some type of compensatory education for the District’s failure to provide him with an appropriate reading program for the past three years. The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT needs an additional one year of independent study beyond graduation in June 2002. During that year of independent study, the District shall instruct STUDENT in reading related to job descriptions, job applications, other job-related information, and independent living.
ORDER
1. a. The District shall convene an IEP team meeting within fifteen (15) calendar days of the date of this decision to develop an independent study program for STUDENT. This independent study program shall instruct STUDENT in reading related to supported employment and independent living. In developing an appropriate program for STUDENT, the IEP team shall keep in mind STUDENT’s current abilities and limitations, STUDENT’s goals and objectives related to supported employment and independent living, and the requirements of federal and State law regarding individual transition plans.
b. The District shall begin STUDENT’s independent study program within thirty (30) days of the date of this decision and shall continue the independent study program through June 2003.
c. In developing an independent study program for STUDENT, the IEP team shall consider STUDENT’s comfort level in continuing to attend school at Madison after graduation. Therefore, the IEP team shall consider locations for STUDENT’s independent study after June 2002 other than Madison. Such locations may include facilities where STUDENT can study with his chronological peers or with other students with similar reading needs.
2. All of Petitioner’s remaining claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
1. Did the District fail to provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education for the 1999-2000, 2000-2001, and 2001-2002 school years by failing to provide him with a comprehensive, phonics-based reading program? Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
2. If the District failed to provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education for the 1999-2000, 2000-2001, and 2000-2001 school years, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education in the form of an intense reading program at the Whittier Learning Center that extends beyond the age of twenty-one? Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the limited extent that the Hearing Officer ordered one year of compensatory education.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: February 7, 2002 ____________________________________ Maxine R. Benmour, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. Petitioner’s father, FATHER, was also present during a portion of the first day of hearing. 2. For purposes of clarification and organization, the Hearing Officer has reorganized Petitioner’s statement of the issues. On the first day of hearing, Petitioner withdrew an issue related to receipt of direct services from a case manager pursuant to an order of the California Department of Education. In addition, on January 8, 2002, the parties jointly notified the Hearing Officer that they had resolved an issue relating to the provision of speech and language services. 3. The IEP document actually states that STUDENT’s reading level was at set 2, level 4, but Ms. Zapp testified that this was an error and should have read set 1, level 4.
