California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 6, 2002

Student v. Berkeley Unified School District (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 2392-02 · Hearing Officer Joseph T. Macaluso

Berkeley Unified's preschool offer denied FAPE over deficient IEP goals, but the district need not fund conductive education.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 3 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

Corrected version: the decision notes spelling corrections (Student's name, Dr. Paula Gardner, Suzanne Cresswell, Gyorgyi Fellner, Gabor Fellner) and an amended date for receipt of closing briefs. Before the hearing resumed, the Hearing Officer ruled on November 26, 2001 that he could not place a student in a non-certified nonpublic school. Student then sought a temporary restraining order in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California. Judge Marilyn Hall Patel denied it on December 4, 2001 but noted that Student could present conductive education evidence at the hearing.

Summary

Berkeley Unified School District and the parents of a preschooler both filed for hearing, and the cases were consolidated. The child has cerebral palsy and is eligible for special education as orthopedically impaired. She attended Beginning Steps to Independence, a private conductive education program. The District offered a special day class at Hopkins Preschool focused on augmentative and alternative communication (AAC). The parents wanted conductive education to continue.

The Hearing Officer found that the September 13, 2001 IEP denied a free appropriate public education (FAPE). No teacher who knew the student attended the meeting, and the parents were not meaningfully involved. The IEP had missing or inaccurate present levels. It had no goals for sitting, standing, walking, grasping or self-help, and the goals it did have could not be measured. The offer also had no transition plan and no seating, barrier vest or motorized wheelchair evaluations. It gave little detail about therapy, the aide or the occupational therapy assistant, and it underweighted her motor needs. The Hearing Officer rejected the District's argument that it lacked data, because it never monitored the private placement it had funded.

The parents lost on conductive education. The child made progress, but Beginning Steps kept little data and no witness addressed normal maturation. Studies showed no advantage over a multidisciplinary approach. The District must hold an IEP meeting within 30 days and write measurable goals in all areas of need. The IEP team must provide intensive physical, occupational and speech therapy and should conduct the three equipment evaluations.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO treated missing present levels and unmeasurable goals as a substantive denial of FAPE rather than a technical error. It also shows that a district that funds a private placement is expected to monitor progress there. A family asking for a specific method had to show that only that method could provide educational benefit.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue 1. Did the District's offer of placement and services at the Hopkins Preschool for the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year provide Student with a FAPE?

    The offer denied FAPE. The IEP lacked accurate present levels and measurable goals, no teacher attended, and the parents were not meaningfully included. The offer also had no transition plan, no seating, barrier vest or wheelchair evaluations, and too little detail on therapy and aide services, and it underweighted motor needs.

  2. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2. If the District did not offer Student a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year, does the District have a legal obligation to provide her with conductive education to meet her unique and individual needs?

    Student made some progress in conductive education but did not prove it was the only program that could meet her needs. The program kept no regular data, no witness addressed maturation, and empirical studies showed no advantage over a multidisciplinary model.

  3. Not reachedIEP procedure

    Issue Procedural (unnumbered). Student's three alleged procedural violations

    Held moot because the District was found not to have offered a FAPE for 2001-2002.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 30 calendar days, District shall convene an IEP meeting to develop a program that continues to promote growth of gross and fine motor skills while giving reasonable weight to communication deficits and other needs. The IEP team shall write measurable goals and objectives in gross motor, fine motor, occupational (head/trunk control, seating), self-help, receptive and expressive language, AAC, academic, and social/emotional skills.
  • District should consider including and paying for participation of Dr. Ashton and Dr. Gardner (goal writing) and Gabor and Gyorgyi Fellner (as consultants) on the IEP team.
  • Order to provide or change services. IEP team shall provide intensive physical and occupational therapy (and should consider consulting with a conductor) and intensive individual speech and language therapy with augmentative and alternative communication devices on a weekly basis; should consider orthopedic adaptive equipment.
  • Order to assess. IEP team should conduct a posture and seating evaluation, a barrier vest evaluation, and a motorized wheelchair evaluation.
  • IEP team should consider providing parents with training to take part in Student's education at home and at school.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Seattle School Dist. v. B.S.; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Cedar Rapids Community School Dist. v. Garret F.; M.C. v. Voluntown Board of Educ.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.

People named in the decision

  • Lenore A. Silverman, District counsel, Schools Legal Counsel
  • Erika Martinez, assistant to District counsel, Schools Legal Counsel
  • Joann Biondi, director of special education, Berkeley Unified School District
  • Susan Deutsch, District occupational therapist, Berkeley Unified School District
  • Dr. Sarah Blackstone, augmentative and alternative communication specialist, District witness
  • Dr. Diane Ashton, special education professor, expert witness for District
  • Louise Fender, District speech and language specialist, Berkeley Unified School District
  • Margaret Lindenstein, District speech and language specialist, Berkeley Unified School District
  • Joni Miller, special day class teacher, Hopkins Preschool, Berkeley Unified School District
  • Elaine Westlake, physical therapist, District assessor
  • Sally Sweatfield, special education program supervisor, Berkeley Unified School District
  • Judith Baldwin, school psychologist, Berkeley Unified School District
  • Dr. Susan Effgen, special education professor and physical rehabilitation specialist, expert witness for District, University of Kentucky
  • Melody James, compliance investigator, District witness, California Department of Education
  • Dr. Paula Gardner, special education professor, expert witness for Student (also referred to once as Dr. Susan Gardner)
  • Suzanne Cresswell, private occupational and physical therapist, witness for Student
  • Naomi Shimizu, private physical therapist, witness for Student, Kaiser Hospital (through Regional Center)
  • Gabor Fellner, conductor and director of conductive education program, witness for Student, Beginning Steps to Independence
  • Gyorgyi Fellner, head conductor and Student's conductor, witness for Student, Beginning Steps to Independence
  • Beginning Steps to Independence, Inc., Conductive Education Center, private conductive education program (denied nonpublic school certification), Los Gatos, California
  • Sue Ann Krejcarek, early intervention occupational therapist, Alameda County CCS
  • Susan (Suzanne) McKnight, infant development specialist, Children's Hospital parent-infant program
  • Frances Graham-Jones, feeding, speech and oral-motor therapist
  • Anita Cotton, author of 1998 therapy report
  • Regional Center of the East Bay, early intervention provider
  • Hon. Marilyn Hall Patel, U.S. District Judge who denied Student's temporary restraining order, U.S. District Court, Northern District of California

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Joseph T. Macaluso, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Berkeley, California, on November 8, 2001, December 10, 11, 12, 18, and 19, 2001, January 29 and 30, 2002, February 4, 5, 6, 25, 26, and 27, 2002, March 25 and 26, 2002, and April 8, 2002. Appearing on behalf of Petitioner/Respondent Berkeley Unified School District (District) were attorney Lenore A. Silverman from Schools Legal Counsel, Erika Martinez, assistant to Ms. Silverman, and Joann Biondi, director of special education for the District. Appearing on behalf of Respondent/Petitioner STUDENT (Student) were attorneys Roberta Savage and Geralyn M. Clancy from Varma and Clancy, and FATHER and MOTHER, parents of Student. _______________________ *Please note the following spelling corrections: STUDENT, Dr. Paula Gardner, Suzanne Cresswell, Gyorgyi Fellner, and Gabor Fellner. In addition, the date of the receipt of closing briefs has been amended.

The following witnesses were called by the District to testify: Susan Deutsch, District occupational therapist; Dr. Sarah Blackstone, augmentative and alternative communication specialist; Dr. Diane Ashton, special education professor; Louise Fender, District speech and language specialist; Margaret Lindenstein, District speech and language specialist; Joni Miller, District special day class teacher; Elaine Westlake, physical therapist; Sally Sweatfield, District special education program supervisor; Judith Baldwin, District psychologist; Joann Biondi, District director of special education; Dr. Susan Effgen, special education professor and physical rehabilitation specialist; and Melody James, California Department of Education compliance investigator.

The following witnesses were called by Student to testify: MOTHER, Student’s mother; Dr. Paula Gardner, special education professor; Suzanne Cresswell, occupational and physical therapist; Naomi Shimizu, physical therapist; Gabor Fellner, conductor and conductive education specialist; Gyorgyi Fellner, conductor and conductive education specialist; and FATHER, Student’s father.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of closing briefs on May 17, 2002, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

PROCEDURE

On November 8, 2001, the first day of hearing, an issue arose regarding whether the Hearing Officer could, as a matter of law, prospectively place a student in a non-certified nonpublic school. The parties agreed to continue the hearing and brief the issue for the Hearing Officer.

On November 26, 2001, after reviewing briefs from both parties, the Hearing Officer held that he may not render a decision that results in the placement of an individual with exceptional needs in a nonpublic school or agency if the school or agency has not been certified.

Following issuance of the order, Student filed a complaint in the United Stated District Court, Northern District of California, seeking a temporary restraining order to enjoin the due process proceeding.

On December 4, 2001, the Honorable Marilyn Hall Patel heard argument regarding Student’s restraining order. The court denied Student’s request for a restraining order. However, the court noted that Student could present evidence regarding a conductive education program at the due process hearing.

ISSUES

1 1 Did the District’s offer of placement and services at the Hopkins Preschool for the 2001- -2002 school year and extended school year provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education (FAPE)?

2. If the District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year, does the District have a legal obligation to provide her with conductive education to meet her unique and individual needs?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The parties dispute whether the District’s offer of placement and services for the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year provides STUDENT with a FAPE. First, the parties disagree whether the District’s emphasis on STUDENT’S communication needs and the use of augmentative and alternative communication devices to meet her needs is appropriate. While the District contends that STUDENT requires immediate and intensive interventions to meet her communication needs, Petitioner argues that her program should be conductive education because it emphasizes the whole individual and not one part. Second, the parties dispute the appropriateness of the IEP goals and benchmarks drafted at the September 13, 2002 IEP team meeting. While the District contends that the goals and benchmarks are appropriately drafted to meet STUDENT’S needs, Petitioner asserts that they are defective because the present levels of performance, goals, and benchmarks are either missing or are inaccurately drafted. Third, the parties dispute whether the services that the District offered STUDENT are designed to meet her needs. While the District alleges that the type and amount of services offered meet STUDENT’S multiple needs, Petitioner contends that the services offered are either insufficient and/or vague regarding their content. Finally, Petitioner contends that only conductive education can meet her needs.

BACKGROUND INFORMATION

STUDENT was born on [date redacted]. She was subsequently diagnosed with cerebral palsy with spastic quadriplegia, which affects the use of her arms, legs, hands, feet, head and trunk. Furthermore, it affects her speech and language, academic development, and self-help skills. STUDENT resides with her parents within the jurisdictional boundaries of the Berkeley Unified School District. She was eligible for intensive early intervention services as a child with Orthopedic Impairments under Part B of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act. STUDENT currently attends Beginning Steps to Independence, Inc., Conductive Education Center in Los Gatos, California.

On November 29, 1996, twelve days after STUDENT was born, her treating physicians referred her to the Regional Center of the East Bay, Alameda County (Regional Center), for services because of complications at birth. On January 10, 1997, the Regional Center held an initial individualized family service plan meeting for STUDENT and her parents. The Regional Center referred STUDENT to Alameda County CCS for physical and occupational therapy. Ms. Naomi Shimizu provided the physical therapy and Ms. Sue Ann Krejcarek provided the occupational therapy.

In September 1997, STUDENT began to attend a parent-infant program at Children’s Hospital and at home. The program was taught by Ms. Susan McKnight, an infant development specialist. STUDENT took part in circle time, free play, and snack time. She also began to receive feeding, speech, and oral-motor therapy from Frances Graham-Jones. STUDENT continued to receive occupational, physical, and speech and language therapy for the remainder of 1997, 1998 and 1999.

In June 1999, STUDENT began to attend the Mommy and Me conductive education program at Beginning Steps to Independence (Beginning Steps). Conductive education is an educational methodology that treats the totality of the individual in a “holistic” manner and not its component parts. The framework of conductive education is based upon six fundamental elements: (1) the conductor; (2) the group; (3) motivation; (4) daily task series; (5) rhythmic intention; and (6) facilitation. Alameda County initially paid for this service as part of STUDENT’S early intervention program. The Mommy and Me program, which was taught by conductors, ran four days per week, three hours per day. When STUDENT entered Beginning Steps, she was two and one half years old and her developmental levels were as follows: her gross motor skills were from seven to eight months; her fine motor skills were from eight to nineteen months; her cognitive abilities were from twelve to twenty-seven months; her expressive and receptive language skills were from eleven to fifteen months; her self-help skills were from nine to sixteen months; and her social/emotional skills were from eighteen to thirty six months. With regard to her gross and fine motor needs, the conductors concentrated on STUDENT’S sitting, standing, walking, trunk and head control, and grasping. STUDENT used ankle and foot orthotics (AFOs), arm gators, ladder back chairs and a plynth table to improve her motor skills. With regard to her cognitive needs, the conductors worked on preschool concepts in areas such as letters, numbers, symbols, seasons, and weather. With regard to her speech and language needs, the conductors worked on singing, vocalizing letters, eye gazing, auditory scanning, and nodding. STUDENT’S receptive language skills were much stronger than her expressive language skills. Finally, with regard to her self-help needs, the conductors worked on STUDENT’S eating, drinking, dressing, and toilet training skills.

In November 1999, when STUDENT was three years old, she transitioned out of the Regional parent infant program and into the Berkeley Unified School District. The District evaluated STUDENT in the areas of her in her gross and fine motor skills, communication skills, academic and pre-academic skills, cognitive development, and social/adaptive behavior. The District’s assessment revealed delays in all areas of need similar to those which the Regional Center had found and treated in the past.

On October 15, 1999, STUDENT’S initial IEP meeting took place. The District identified STUDENT as a child with a disability in need of special education and related services under the qualifying criteria of Orthopedically Impaired. The IEP team members discussed the findings from their assessments and STUDENT’S present levels of performance in her gross and fine motor skills, communication, academic and pre-academic skills, cognitive development, and social/adaptive behavior. Thereafter, the IEP team wrote specific and detailed goals and objectives in all of these areas of need. The District offered a placement in Joni Miller’s class at the Hopkins preschool. In addition, the District offered STUDENT occupational and physical therapy and speech and language services. STUDENT’S parents visited the Hopkin’s placement prior to the IEP meeting and rejected it at the end of the IEP meeting because they felt that it could not met STUDENT’S unique and individual needs.

On January 14, 2000, the IEP team met again. As a result of prior negotiations, the District agreed to continue STUDENT’S placement at Beginning Steps. On April 26, 2000, an additional IEP meeting was held to finalize the agreement and fund the placement at Beginning Steps through the United Cerebral Palsy foundation. The District agreed to pay for STUDENT’S program through the United Cerebral Palsy foundation for two reasons: first, an official at Beginning Steps advised the District that Beginning Steps would be certified; and second, the District wanted to make a conciliatory gesture towards STUDENT’S parents.

From April 2000 to June 2001, STUDENT continued to attend the Mommy and Me program at Beginning Steps. While STUDENT evidenced some improvement in her gross and fine motor skills, cognitive development, and academic and pre-academic skills, her expressive language skills continued to be severely delayed. Her receptive language skills appeared to be age appropriate. In June 2001, STUDENT graduated from the Mommy and Me program and entered the full-time Busy Buddies program for preschool children at Beginning Steps. STUDENT attended Busy Buddies five days per week, six hours per day. From June 2001 to September 2001, STUDENT continued to show slow but steady improvement in all of her areas of need except expressive language.

On September 4, 2001, the California Department of Education, Special Education Division, conducted an offsite validation review and an onsite review at Beginning Steps. The evaluation included a review of the education program, individualized education programs (IEPs), master contracts, and individual service agreements. The team found Beginning Steps to be out of compliance with State standards in the above referenced areas. Thus, the State denied Beginning Steps nonpublic school certification.

In the summer and fall of 2001, the District evaluated STUDENT at home and at Beginning Steps in preparation for the 2001-2002 school year. The assessments were in the areas of physical and occupational therapy, speech and language, pre-academic skills, and social-emotional skills. On September 13, 2001, an IEP meeting was held for STUDENT. There was no general education teacher or special education teacher present as a member of the IEP team. While the IEP team did not consider whether the goals and benchmarks from the January 2000 IEP had been met, it did discuss the District’s evaluations. After discussing the evaluations, the IEP team wrote present levels of performance, goals and benchmarks for addressing STUDENT’S needs in physical therapy-posture/alignment, physical therapy-mobility/transitions, language arts, literacy skills, receptive and expressive language, augmentative and alternative communication (AAC) techniques and strategies, math readiness, play, and general knowledge. The IEP team did not write goals and objectives to address STUDENT’S needs in sitting, standing, walking, grasping, toileting, dressing, feeding and drinking. The District offered weekly occupational, physical and speech and language therapy, AAC services and a one-to-one aide. Finally, the District offered STUDENT a morning placement in Joni Miller’s special day class at the Hopkins preschool for the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year. STUDENT’S parents neither accepted nor rejected the offer of placement and services at Hopkins because they first wanted to view the placement. They assumed that the IEP meeting would be continued to discuss goals and objectives and placement after they had observed the Hopkins program.

The District and STUDENT’S parents scheduled a visit to Hopkins preschool on September 24, 2001. However, STUDENT’S parents canceled the visit because of a conflict that arose with STUDENT’S schedule at Beginning Steps. STUDENT’S parents expressed an intent to reschedule the visit.

On September 26, 2001, the District filed its request for a due process hearing in this matter. On October 24, 2001, STUDENT’S parents visited the Hopkins program. They concluded that it did not meet STUDENT’S needs.

On October 29, 2001, the District sent STUDENT’S parents a letter explaining the offer of placement and services at the September 13, 2001 IEP meeting. On October 31, 2001, STUDENT’S parents sent the District a parent addendum that outlined their concerns with the District’s offer of placement and services for the 2001-2002 school year and requested that the District continue STUDENT’S placement at Beginning Steps. On December 6, 2001, the District sent STUDENT’S parents a final placement offer. The District offered an additional hour and forty-five minute program in the afternoon for four days per week to address STUDENT’S language needs and the services of a certified occupational specialist. STUDENT’S parents rejected the offer. On November 2, 2001, STUDENT filed a request for a due process hearing. Thereafter, the two requests for hearing were consolidated and the parties proceeded to hearing.

LEGAL ANALYSIS

ISSUE 1: Did the District’s offer of placement and services at the Hopkins Preschool for the 2001-2002 school year and extended school provide STUDENT with a free and and appropriate public education?

Under both the federal Individual with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, disability is a natural part of the human experience and in no way diminishes the right of individuals to participate in or contribute to society. Improving educational results for children with disabilities is an essential element of our national policy of ensuring equality of opportunity, full participation, independent living, and economic self-sufficiency for individuals with disabilities. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(c)(1); 34 C.F.R. § 300.1. Thus, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet State educational standards, and that conform with the Student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Huson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that the Student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the students’ abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Rowley, 458 at 207-208. Thus, an appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the individual child. Seattle School District v. B.S. (9th Cir. 1996) 82 F.3d 1493; Union School District v. Smith (9th Cir. 1994) 15 F.3d 1519, cert. denied 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994). Furthermore, the focus of the inquiry is not on whether the student may obtain greater benefit in a placement that is preferred by one of the parties. Rather, a placement is adequate if it is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the student. Gregory K. v. Longview School District (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307. Finally, the student should advance appropriately toward attaining the annual goals, be involved and progress in the general curriculum and be educated and participate with other children with disabilities and nondisabled children. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(iii)(I)(II)(III).

In Summary, under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the STUDENT’S unique needs, provide the student with some educational benefit, and conform with the IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et. seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176.

1. STUDENT’S unique needs

To analyze the appropriateness of the educational placement offered by the District, a review of STUDENT’S unique needs as of September 2001 is required. In May, June and September 2001, Ms. Elaine Westlake, physical therapist, Ms. Judith Baldwin, District psychologist, and Ms. Susan Deutsch, District occupational therapist, assessed STUDENT in the areas of gross and fine motor skills, cognitive/academic skills, speech and language skills, behavior/social emotional skills and self-help skills. The District’s assessment team employed only a few standardized tests to assess STUDENT because of her limited communication and motor skills. Thus, the assessors relied primarily upon observation, non-standardized testing, and discussions with STUDENT’S conductors at Beginning Steps to Independence and with her parents.

To assess STUDENT’S gross and fine motor skills, Ms. Westlake had STUDENT perform exercises. With regard to STUDENT’S posture, Ms. Westlake observed that STUDENT sat with a curved spine, which was corrected with positioning. STUDENT also exhibited difficulty maintaining her head upright and tended to hyper-extend or flex her neck. Furthermore, STUDENT exhibited minimal range of motion in her knees, unequal motion in her straight leg raises, tightness in her hip adductors and hamstrings, and external rotation in her legs in all positions. Finally, STUDENT exhibited low muscle tone in her trunk and fluctuating muscle tone in her extremities. Because she had very low trunk control, she was unable to maintain a good head position for learning. Ms. Westlake, Ms. Deutsch, Dr. Ashton, Dr. Blackstone, and Ms. Miller all testified that trunk control was critical for STUDENT to access the curriculum in the classroom. Thus, Ms. Westlake and the aforementioned witnesses testified that STUDENT required a seating evaluation to assess the proper seat height, the use of a wedge to improve her sitting posture and a barrier vest to improve her head and trunk control.

With regard to her sitting skills, STUDENT was able to ring-sit on the floor and maintain this position using her arms for support. She was able to roll from supine to prone and transition to a quadruped position for 10 to 15 seconds. With regard to STUDENT’S mobility skills, STUDENT exhibited a strong pattern of movement that hindered her ability to bring her hands to midline or to reach for objects. STUDENT also crawled by advancing her arms and legs without external support. Finally, she could transition to a high kneel with minimal to moderate assistance and with trunk support could walk on her knees.

Ms. Westlake also assessed STUDENT’S need for orthopedic equipment. She noted that STUDENT could stand with moderate assistance while wearing ankle foot orthotics (AFOs). Her ability to stand also improved when she wore leg gaiters. At Beginning Steps to Independence (Beginning Steps), STUDENT performed standing activities for approximately 45 minutes and sat on a chair with foot support and a pommel between her legs. Furthermore, she held onto rings and sticks when performing various activities. With regard to her gait, STUDENT used a Pony walker and other supports. At Beginning Steps, Ms. Westlake observed that STUDENT performed a walking program to transition to various activities (snack, lunch, bathroom, classroom) using modified AFOs, leg gaiters, and a ladder-back chair. Ms. Westlake recommended that STUDENT use hip helpers both to keep her lower limbs aligned and improve standing and walking. Finally, Dr. Blackstone and Ms. Deutsch testified that STUDENT needs a motorized wheelchair in class in order for her to be mobile in and outside class. However, they pointed out that she requires an evaluation before she can actually use a motorized wheelchair.

To assess STUDENT’S fine motor functioning, Ms. Susan Deutsch observed STUDENT at home and at Beginning Steps. Ms. Deutsch noted that STUDENT, who is left-handed, had difficulty reaching, grasping, and maintaining a grasp on objects. For example, she held markers for a brief time using a pronated grasp. Ms. Deutsch and Ms. Miller testified that STUDENT could use orthopedic pencils, markers, toys, etc. to address her fine motor needs. STUDENT’S parents testified that modified, orthopedic utensils would be helpful since STUDENT enjoyed drawing and painting. Ms. Deutsch noted that STUDENT also had difficulty producing movements that required strength and coordination with her arms. Part of this problem was related to STUDENT’S poor trunk support and control when seated. The poor trunk control, in turn, affected her ability to keep her head up and to use her arms to access things, such as a computer with Intellikeys. Finally, during table top activities at Beginning Steps, visual and manipulative materials were presented to STUDENT in a horizontal plane. As a result, STUDENT was not able to see many of the learning materials presented because her head tended to rest on the table. Ms. Baldwin, Ms. Biondi, and Dr. Blackstone testified that when they observed STUDENT at Beginning Steps, her head was often down on the table.

To assess STUDENT’S cognitive/pre-academic abilities, Ms. Judith Baldwin employed visual scanning techniques by holding up two objects and asking STUDENT to demonstrate her knowledge of concepts. With regard to colors, STUDENT was able to correctly choose the colors blue, red and green but not the color yellow. With regard to preschool concepts, she demonstrated understanding of big, little, long, short, up and down. When asked to differentiate whether certain containers were full or not, STUDENT initially could not indicate which container was full and which was empty. After some trial teaching, she learned the concept very quickly. STUDENT also was asked to demonstrate her understanding of the concepts “full” and “empty.” After 10 minutes of trial teaching, she understood the concepts. Ms. Baldwin noted that STUDENT was attentive during the trial teaching and enjoyed learning and demonstrating her knowledge. During class at Beginning Steps, Ms. Baldwin observed that STUDENT had difficulty matching shapes on a horizontal board. Ms. Baldwin and Ms. Deutsch were not sure whether STUDENT did not understand the concepts or was not able to demonstrate her knowledge because of the motor and visual demands of the task. With regard to letters, STUDENT was able to discriminate between the letter “A” and other letters and was able to choose her name out of a field of three other names. She could not discriminate between the letters “B” and “D.” With regard to numbers, STUDENT was not able to indicate her age when given the choice of looking at 4 fingers or 5 fingers. During STUDENT’S home visit, Ms. Deutsch noted that STUDENT enjoyed the computer, stayed engaged for 45 minutes, and had an age appropriate attention span. Thus, STUDENT’S interest and speed at learning concepts and her good attention span led Dr. Baldwin to conclude that STUDENT had at least average cognitive skills.

To assess STUDENT’S speech and language functioning, Ms. Baldwin, Ms. Deutsch and Ms. Westlake observed STUDENT at home and at Beginning Steps and also interviewed STUDENT’S parents and her conductors. With regard to STUDENT’S receptive language skills, her parents reported that STUDENT understood much of what was said to her. She loved being read to and would listen attentively to stories and music. Ms. Baldwin, Dr. Blackstone, and Ms. Deutsch reported that STUDENT appeared to understand much of what was said to her as noted by her vocalizations, eye gaze, and head movements. STUDENT understood the names of most major body parts and followed requests to move her body parts as much as she physically could. Thus, Dr. Blackstone concluded that STUDENT’S receptive language skills are probably commensurate with her cognitive abilities. With regard to her expressive language skills, STUDENT’S parents reported that STUDENT communicated her needs through eye gaze, intonation of her vocalization, and body language such as turning towards and away from stimuli. For example, STUDENT could choose a favorite book by looking at it when it was paired with an unwanted book. Ms. Fellner testified that STUDENT could touch a page with her fist. Ms. Baldwin and Ms. Deutsch confirmed that STUDENT enjoyed being read to. Furthermore, STUDENT’S parents reported that STUDENT could say “ice cream” and an approximation of “no” and “yes.” Finally, Dr. Blackstone and Ms. Fellner testified that although STUDENT does not have a structured communication system, the staff at Beginning Steps and individuals who know her are able to read her needs.

To assess STUDENT’S augmentative and alternative communication (AAC) needs, Dr. Sarah Blackstone also observed STUDENT at home and at Beginning Steps and interviewed her parents. Dr. Blackstone discerned that STUDENT had a severe communication impairment secondary to dysarthria that was complicated by her lack of access to language symbols. When she assessed STUDENT, STUDENT seemed to understand spoken direction and conversational speech and recognized some less typical vocabulary. Dr. Blackstone noted that without expressive language, it was impossible to know what STUDENT’S specific strengths and weaknesses were. Thus, her main concern lay with STUDENT’S lack of expressive language and the large gap between what she understood and what she could communicate.

In addition to her severe dysarthria, STUDENT’S expressive communication skills were further compromised by her inability to use signs and gestures, to write or draw independently and by her lack of access to AAC techniques. Dr. Blackstone pointed out that although modeling and feedback are crucial components of normal language development and learning, STUDENT has no way to ask questions or modify concepts based on adult feedback. She testified that when adults do not know what a child understands or does not understand, they may misinterpret a child’s needs and abilities and waste valuable instruction time. Dr. Blackstone estimated thatSTUDENT’S speech-motor skills fell below a 6-month level. Nonetheless, she vocalized frequently and tried to say words when asked. While Dr. Blackstone’s prognosis for STUDENT’S developing functional speech was poor, her prognosis for STUDENT’S learning to use her voice effectively to express specific intents and perhaps even to operate assistive technology was excellent. Thus, Dr. Blackstone recommended that STUDENT be introduced to and provided with access to AAC strategies and techniques in all aspects of her education program. The AAC strategies and techniques, explained Dr. Blackstone, would help her to communicate her ideas, thoughts, opinions, needs and feelings to familiar as well as unfamiliar communication partners.

To assess STUDENT’S social/emotional skills, Ms. Baldwin and Ms. Deutsch evaluated STUDENT through parent and teacher reports and observation at Beginning Steps and home. STUDENT’S parents reported that she enjoys adult-facilitated symbolic play with toy cars and figures. However, STUDENT was unable to play independently because of her limited ability to manipulate toys. STUDENT’S parents reported that STUDENT has specific likes and dislikes and readily expresses her opinions about them. Ms. Fellner, STUDENT’S teacher at Beginning Steps, confirmed that STUDENT lets one know whether or not she likes an activity. With regard to social relationships, Ms. Fellner noted that STUDENT has a friend at school and they laugh together. Ms. Baldwin and Ms. Deutsch were unable to assess STUDENT’S play skills because they did not observe a play component at Beginning Steps. However, they did observe STUDENT laugh and smile when the examiners did “silly things” with her.

To assess STUDENT’S self-help needs, Ms. Baldwin and Ms. Deutsch evaluated STUDENT through parent and teacher reports and observation at Beginning Steps and home. With regard to eating, STUDENT ate solid foods and enjoyed a variety of tastes and textures. MOTHER reported that although STUDENT could bite, chew, and swallow food, one had to hold the food up to her mouth. Because she is not self-feeding, STUDENT needs someone to put finger foods in her hand. Furthermore, STUDENT is not able to hold a cup and drink without assistance. With regard to her dressing, STUDENT cannot dress and undress herself independently. Finally, with regard to her toileting, STUDENT is not toilet-trained.

In summary, the District’s assessments confirmed that STUDENT has substantial ongoing needs in her gross and fine motor skills, cognitive and pre-academic skills, speech and language skills, social/emotional, and self-help skills. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer shall now review the District’s proposed program and services and determine whether they are designed to meet STUDENT’S unique and individual needs.

2. Program designed to meet STUDENT’S needs a. Goals and short-term objectives

In determining whether the District’s proposed program and services are designed to meet STUDENT’S unique and individual needs, an analysis of the September 13, 2001 IEP is required. The IEP is a written statement of present levels of educational performance and measurable annual goals and benchmarks. These are developed to meet the STUDENT’S unique needs and to provide the special education, related services and supplementary aides that will assist the STUDENT in attaining these goals. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(ii)(iii); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a)(1)(2)(i); Cal. Ed. Code § 56345(a)(1)(B)(2).

In determining a child’s present levels of educational performance and developing goals and benchmarks, federal law provides that a primary consideration in the development of the child’s IEP should be how each child’s disability affects the child’s involvement and progress in the general curriculum. 34 C.F.R. Part 300, Appendix A, “Present Levels of Educational Performance.” The Code states that “ in assessing children with disabilities, school districts may use a variety of assessment techniques to determine the extent to which these children can be involved and progress in the general curriculum, such as criterion-referenced tests, standard achievement tests, diagnostic tests, other tests, or any combination of the above.” “The purpose of using these assessments is to determine the child’s present levels of educational performance and areas of need arising from the child’s disability so that approaches for ensuring the child’s involvement and progress in the general curriculum and any needed adaptations or modifications to that curriculum can be identified.”

In defining the importance of the goals and benchmarks in developing STUDENT’S program and services, 34 C.F.R., Part 300 Appendix A, under the heading “Measurable Annual Goals, Including Benchmarks Or Short-Term Objectives, states in pertinent part:

Measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, are critical to the strategic planning process used to develop and implement the IEP for each child with a disability. Once the IEP team has developed measurable annual goals for a child, the team (1) can develop strategies that will be most effective in realizing those goals and (2) must develop either measurable, intermediate steps (short-term objectives) or major milestones (benchmarks) that that will enable parents, students, and educators to monitor progress during the the year, and, if appropriate, to revise the IEP consistent with the student’s instructional needs.

As noted above, each annual goal must include either short-term objectives or benchmarks. The purpose of both is to enable a child’s teacher(s), parents, and others involved in developing and implementing the child’s IEP, to gauge, at intermediate times during the year, how well the child is progressing toward achievement of the annual goal. IEP teams may continue to develop short-term instructional objectives, that generally break the skills described in the annual goal down into discrete components. The revised statute also provide that, as an alternative, IEP teams may develop benchmarks, which can be thought of as describing the amount of progress the child is expected to make within specified segments of the year. Generally, benchmarks establish expected performance levels that allow for regular checks of progress that coincide with the reporting periods for informing parents of their child’s progress toward achieving the annual goals. An IEP team may use either short term objectives or benchmarks or a combination of the two depending on the nature of the annual goals and the needs of the child.

Thus, both federal and State law place a strong emphasis on determining present levels of performance and developing measurable goals and incremental benchmarks that will be the foundation for the child’s program and services.

In this case, the District’s September 13, 2001 IEP sets forth present levels of performance with accompanying goals and benchmarks to address STUDENT’S unique needs in physical therapy-posture/alignment, physical therapy-mobility/transitions, language arts, expressive language, improved switch access, math readiness, play, and general knowledge. The evidence at the hearing established that when drafting STUDENT’S present levels of performance and goals and benchmarks, the IEP team did not have, as required by both federal and State law, a general or special education teacher familiar with STUDENT to advise them about STUDENT’S needs. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(B)(iii); 34 C.F.R. § 300.344(a)(2)(3); Cal. Ed. Code § 56341(b)(2)(3). Furthermore, the Hearing Officer’s review of the IEP meeting tapes and the testimony of STUDENT’S parents established that the parents were not integrally included, as required by federal and State law, when discussing and drafting STUDENT’S present levels of performance. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(B)(i); 34 C.F.R. § 300.344(a)(1); Cal. Ed. Code § 56341(b)(1).

Because the IEP team did not have a teacher present at the IEP meeting who was familiar with Student’s needs and did not actively include STUDENT’S parents in drafting STUDENT’S goals and benchmarks, the IEP team did not develop present levels of performance or develop inaccurate present levels of performance. For example, the IEP team failed to draft present levels of performance for many of STUDENT’S substantial gross and fine motor needs. Specifically, there were no present levels of performance regarding STUDENT’S lying supine, crawling, rolling from supine-to-prone and from prone-to-supine, sitting, weight bearing, standing upright and standing in quadruped, walking, grasping, and transitioning between these various tasks. District witnesses testified that because STUDENT’S communication and accompanying AAC techniques were the main focus of the IEP, many of STUDENT’S gross and fine motor needs were not discussed. Ms. Deutsch testified that the absence of specific present levels of performance addressing STUDENT’S gross and fine motor needs reflected a philosophical difference between the District’s and STUDENT’S parents opinion regarding the direction that STUDENT’S educational program should take: while the District emphasized communication and AAC techniques for STUDENT, her parents emphasized STUDENT’S gross and fine motor needs.

With regard to the present levels of performance that the IEP team did discuss and include in the IEP, the information was often general, incomplete or inaccurate. In the language arts goal, for example, the present level of performance stated that STUDENT did not use graphic symbols or words. However, MOTHER and Ms. Fellner disputed this point. They testified that STUDENT recognized circles, squares, triangles and stars and could use simple words such as ‘no,’ ‘yes,’ ‘agua’ for water, ‘I’ for ice cream, etc. Ms. Blackstone, Ms. Baldwin, and Ms. Deutsch confirmed that STUDENT recognized her name and the names of some letters, could read some words, and understood some basic shapes and that letters made sounds. In the reading comprehension goal, the present level of performance stated that STUDENT had limited ability to respond to comprehension questions about books she was reading. However, MOTHER and Ms. Fellner testified that when asked questions about a book that was read to her, STUDENT could point to pictures and objects to answer questions and could shake her head to indicate if the story was changed or the question was somehow inaccurate. Dr. Blackstone and Ms. Baldwin confirmed that STUDENT could answer some very simple reading comprehension questions and also had a “remarkable” attention span. The present level of performance in the general knowledge goal stated that STUDENT was not able to demonstrate knowledge of preschool content such as animals, weather, seasons, and the calendar. Again, MOTHER and Ms. Fellner testified that STUDENT could point to pictures of different farm and zoo animals, could indicate when questions about the weather were wrong, and understood the change of seasons. While the District contended that there was no data to substantiate the recollection of Ms. Fellner and STUDENT’S parents, the fact that none of the witnesses disputed that STUDENT was bright and had near age level receptive language capabilities made it more likely than not that STUDENT had some basic understanding of these concepts. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the present level of performance that the IEP team did include in the IEP were often general, incomplete or inaccurate.

The result of the IEP team’s failure to develop present levels of performance in some areas of need and the formulation of inaccurate present levels of performance in other areas of need led to both an absence of goals in important areas of need and to the development of goals that were not measurable. First, the IEP team did not develop complete goals in the area of gross and fine motor needs. For example, there were no goals regarding STUDENT’S balance, sitting, standing, walking, and transitioning between these tasks. With regard to STUDENT’S fine motor needs, there were no goals addressing her ability to grasp and release objects. With regard to STUDENT’S self-help needs, there were no goals addressing toileting, feeding, drinking, and dressing.

At the same time, many of the goals the IEP team did draft were not measurable. For example, the physical therapy-postural/alignment goal stated that STUDENT needed “adaptive equipment to improve her posture/positioning to better access/participate in classroom activities.” However, the goal is not measurable because it does not state what STUDENT will do but what the providers will do for her. The physical therapy-mobility/transitions goal stated, for example, that STUDENT would “improve” her sit to stand activity at school as well as have assistance walking in the school and the classroom. However, the focus of this goal, like the previous one, was not on what STUDENT would learn to do for herself that would be measured but on what would be done to assist her. The language arts goal stated that STUDENT would “improve literacy skills-reading comprehension.” Dr. Susan Gardner testified that literacy skills is a very broad area which includes, among other things, identifying and creating letters, making sounds, writing sentences, reading, answering questions etc. While the focus of this goal is on STUDENT, Dr. Gardner explained that the goal is vague, over-broad, and has no measurable criteria. These three goals, like many other goals in the IEP, exemplified a problem with the IEP, that it contained no criteria for measuring progress.

The IEP team’s failure to develop measurable goals with accurate present levels of performance resulted in the absence of benchmarks to measure STUDENT’S progress toward the goal. Using the physical therapy-postural/alignment goal as an example again, it contained three short-term objectives. The first short-term objective stated that STUDENT would “wear hip helpers” to improve the alignment of her legs and to improve her ability to sit and stand in class. The second short-term objective stated that STUDENT would have her seating evaluated and modified at school to improve her positioning, transitioning, and access to desk top activities in class. The third short-term objective stated that STUDENT would be evaluated by January 2002 for a barrier vest to improve her trunk and hand control so that she could improve her ability to see her teacher in the classroom. These three short-term objectives, like the goal they build up to, are not focused on what STUDENT will do but on what the IEP team will do for her. Furthermore, the three short-term objectives have no measurable criteria, are goals unto themselves, and do not lead up to the annual goal. These benchmarks were exemplary of other benchmarks contained within additional goals in the IEP. Because the benchmarks have little to no measurable criteria, the IEP team will not be able to determine if STUDENT is progressing toward the annual goals.

In this case, the District contended that the goals and objectives in the September 13, 2001 IEP were comprehensive, measurable, data based, and observable. Dr. Diane Ashton initially testified that the goals and objectives were measurable and “very well” drafted. Later, while testifying on rebuttal, she stated that the goals and objectives at an initial IEP are written more generally and can be revised within 60 days at another IEP meeting. She reasoned that if the goals and objectives in the September 13, 2001 IEP had any deficiencies, they could be remedied in 60 days at a follow-up IEP meeting. Furthermore, Dr. Ashton testified that the goals and objectives in the September 13, 2001 IEP were a “good start” and that measurable and observable goals and objectives “in the real world,” don’t always happen “at first blush.” The Hearing Officer did not find the District’s explanations for the deficiencies in the September 2001 goals and objectives credible. First, the IEP team previously wrote very detailed and measurable goals and objectives in STUDENT’S January 2000 IEP. Second, the IEP team failed to review the January 2000 IEP goals and objectives and determine if STUDENT had met them or not. Finally, the January 2000 IEP goals and objectives could have served as a model for the goals and short-term objectives in the September 13, 2001 IEP meeting. The IEP team at the September 2001 IEP team had the framework to draft measurable goals and objectives for STUDENT yet failed to do so.

The District next contended that if the goals and short-term objectives in the September 13, 2001 IEP were inappropriate, it was because the IEP team did not have the requisite data to draft them. The District contended that it was not possible to design accurate present levels of performance and measurable goals and short-term benchmarks for three reasons: first, STUDENT had been out of the District for over a year; second, Beginning Steps did not keep regular data on STUDENT; and third, no one from Beginning Steps attended the September 13, 2001 IEP meeting. The Hearing Officer shall address each contention individually. With regard to the contention that STUDENT had been out of the District for over a year, California Education Code § 56043(h) provides that an IEP team shall meet at least annually to review a pupil’s progress, the IEP, including whether the annuals goals for the pupil are being achieved, the appropriateness of the placement, and to make any necessary revisions. Furthermore, a district is required to provide each service provider with a copy of the STUDENT’S IEP so that it is aware of what it is responsible for implementing. Cal. Ed. Code § 56347. Finally, a District has an obligation to monitor a child’s program at a private school if placed there by the public agency. 34 C.F.R. § 300.349(c). In this case, the District agreed with STUDENT’S parents in April 2000 to place STUDENT at Beginning Steps through the United Cerebral Palsy Foundation. Furthermore, the IEP team wrote a detailed IEP in January 2000 with goals and objectives while STUDENT attended Beginning Steps. Thus, the IEP team had an obligation to find out if Beginning Steps implemented and met STUDENT’S goals and short-term objectives. If Beginning Steps did not meet STUDENT’S goals and objectives, the IEP team had the obligation to call an IEP meeting and find out why not. Finally, STUDENT’S parents testified that they offered to obtain data from Beginning Steps for the District. However, they explained that the District advised them that it would collect the data on STUDENT’S progress and they need not do so. However, Ms. Sally Sweatfield and Ms. Joann Biondi testified that the District never requested that Beginning Steps document STUDENT’S progress and provide them with reports. While Beginning Steps should have regularly recorded objective, measurable data on STUDENT’S progress and did not do so, the District is equally culpable for not following up on her progress with Beginning Steps and scheduling an IEP meeting to address any deficiencies in Beginning Steps’ reporting procedures.

With regard to the argument that Beginning Steps did not attend the September 13, 2001 IEP meeting and thus prevented the IEP team from drafting appropriate goals and objectives, the evidence established that the IEP team had many resources available to it to determine STUDENT’S present levels of performance and draft appropriate goals and short-term objectives for STUDENT. However, as discussed above, the IEP team did not conduct the September 13, 2001 IEP meeting with a general or special education teacher who was familiar with STUDENT. Mr. Gabor Fellner, a head conductor at Beginning Steps who testified about STUDENT’S unique and individual needs, explained that he was not invited in a timely fashion to take part in the September 2001 IEP team meeting. Furthermore, Ms. Gyorgyi Fellner, STUDENT’S conductor at Beginning Steps, testified and demonstrated that she had personal knowledge about STUDENT’S present functioning. For example, she knew about STUDENT’S gross and fine motor skills, speech and language skills, her self-help skills, etc. While her personal knowledge may not have been as accurate as measurable, written data, it would have provided the IEP team with a starting point to draft STUDENT’S present levels of performance, initial goals, and benchmarks. Thereafter, the IEP team could have scheduled, as Dr. Ashton testified, another IEP meeting in 60 days to redraft the goals and benchmarks as required.

Second, Ms. Sweatfield testified that MOTHER advised her at the September 2001 IEP meeting that Mr. Fellner received notice of the IEP meeting too late to attend. However, Ms. Sweatfield did not follow-up with a phone call to determine if anyone from Beginning Steps could attend the IEP meeting either telephonically or at a second IEP meeting scheduled in the near future. If the IEP team had conducted the IEP with either Mr. Fellner or Ms. Fellner in person or telephonically, it could have obtained information regarding STUDENT’S present levels of performance in various domains and drafted measurable goals and benchmarks. Third, the IEP team elicited little information from STUDENT’S parents about STUDENT at the September IEP meeting. After listening to all 3 of the tapes from the September IEP meeting, the Hearing Officer learned that the IEP team rarely asked STUDENT’S parents for any personal information about STUDENT’S functioning in her areas of need. Ms. Judith Baldwin confirmed this point in her testimony. STUDENT’S parents’ testimony at the hearing established that they possessed sufficient personal knowledge about STUDENT’S present levels of performance in many of her areas of need that would have provided the IEP team with enough information to write measurable goals and benchmarks. Finally, Ms. Sweatfield testified that the District did not ask STUDENT’S parents to bring any information about STUDENT from Beginning Steps to the IEP meeting. Because the District did not conduct the September 13, 2001 IEP meeting with anyone from Beginning Steps and did not adequately include STUDENT’S parents in developing the goals and benchmarks, it cannot now use the lack of data as a sword in this action. The foregoing indicates that the District had enough resources available to it to determine STUDENT’S present levels of performance and write appropriate goals and benchmarks for STUDENT at the September 13, 2001 IEP meeting and it failed to do so.

When the September 13, 2001 IEP meeting adjourned, the IEP team still had an opportunity to schedule a second IEP meeting and write goals and benchmarks for STUDENT. STUDENT’S parents testified that it was their impression that an additional IEP meeting would be set to discuss matters further. The Hearing Officer listened to the IEP team meeting tapes and arrived at the same conclusion. In a parent addendum dated October 31, 2001, they noted that goals and objectives did not cover all areas of STUDENT’S special education needs. Furthermore, Ms. Deutsch and Ms. Westlake testified that additional goals and benchmarks “clearly” needed to be written at the IEP meeting. However, Ms. Deutsch testified that the IEP team felt it was important to complete the AAC component of the IEP program because Dr. Blackstone was present and the IEP team members had to collaborate with her. Instead of calling a second IEP meeting to write the additional goals and objectives in STUDENT’S areas of need, the District filed for hearing after STUDENT’S parents canceled an observation of the Hopkins program in October 2001 and before a new observation could be set. Furthermore, Ms. Sweatfield admitted that the IEP was to “really explain our program and concern that augmentative communication was a huge need.” Finally, and most telling, Ms. Sweatfield testified that the District would not complete STUDENT’S IEP until “the parents agreed to place STUDENT in Joni Miller’s class.” While the District, then, had sufficient time between the September 13, 2001 IEP meeting and the first day of hearing on November 8, 2001 to schedule a second IEP meeting and complete STUDENT’S goals and objectives, the evidence established that it never had the intent to do so.

In summary, the IEP team failed to develop accurate present levels of performance, and measurable goals and benchmarks in STUDENT’S areas of need. This omission went to the very foundation of STUDENT’S program and is far more than a mere technical violation of the law. Both STUDENT’S and the District’s witnesses emphasized the critical importance of having properly drafted goals and objectives for STUDENT. Doctor Effgen, Dr. Gardner, Dr. Ashton, Ms. Westlake and Ms. Miller testified that the goals and objectives both define and drive the program, services and supports. Furthermore, Dr. Gardner pointed out that the goals and objectives are the “blueprint” for the instruction and tell the teachers what they need to do during that day in order to support the child’s growth. Dr. Ashton testified that while all children may participate in the same activities during the school day, they participate in them differently pursuant to their individual needs. Ms. Miller testified that she would be concerned if an IEP were not complete because the IEP must have clearly written goals and benchmarks. Thus, the uniquely tailored goals and benchmarks, which serve as the “blueprint” to STUDENT’S program, were either non-existent or poorly drafted by the IEP team at the September 2001 IEP team meeting.

b. Special education and related services tailored to the unique needs of the child

Because the IDEA requires a district to provide handicapped children with a FAPE, the district must develop a special education and related services “tailored to the unique needs of the handicapped child.” Rowley, 458 U.S. at 181-182 (1982). The Hearing Officer shall now review whether the program offered by the District was tailored to meed STUDENT’S unique and individual needs.

i. Transition plan from Beginning Steps to Hopkins

While the District presented an array of teaching professionals and experts who testified about the “state-of-the-art” nature of the Hopkins program and how it would meet STUDENT’S unique and individual needs, the District’s program lacked many foundational components that would meet those needs. First, the District’s program lacked a transition plan from Beginning Steps to the Hopkins Preschool program. Dr. Ashton testified that when STUDENT transitions from a more restrictive environment, such as Beginning Steps, to a less restrictive environment, such as the Hopkins program, a transition plan is “absolutely necessary” to prepare her for the new educational program. Ms. Deutsch testified that the reason a transition plan is so important is that it helps to obviate the uncertainty when STUDENT transitions into a new school environment. In order to have a successful transition plan, Dr. Ashton explained that the District, parents, and service providers should all work together when formulating it. Furthermore, she pointed out that the transition plan should contain a very detailed guide about what will happen to the child in the initial 30 days, the following 30 days, and then the final 15 days in the new placement. While Ms. Baldwin admitted that STUDENT needs a transition plan, the Hearing Officer did not find credible her contention that STUDENT did not require a transition plan with any more detail than any other child. If STUDENT’S needs were similar to a typically developing peer, Ms. Baldwin’s statement might be believable. However, STUDENT suffers from severe cerebral palsy with multiple delays. A detailed transition plan would help STUDENT’S parents, special education teacher, service providers, and aides to provide her with a smooth transition from Beginning Steps to Hopkins while STUDENT acclimates herself to the new school environment, students, and teaching methodologies. Thus, a transition plan is an essential element to STUDENT’S program and the IEP team failed to tailor one for her.

ii. Sitting, barrier vest, and motorized wheel chair evaluations

While a transition plan is an important element for STUDENT’S move into a new school program, the evidence at the hearing established that STUDENT’S success in the classroom greatly depends upon her access to the classroom curriculum. Dr. Blackstone, Ms. Deutsch, Ms. Westlake, and Ms. Miller uniformly testified that STUDENT’S positioning and seating are critical for her to access the classroom curriculum and her success. However, the IEP team failed to evaluate STUDENT’S seating and positioning prior to the September 13, 2001 IEP team meeting. With regard to STUDENT’S seating, Ms. Deutsch testified that STUDENT needed to have her trunk and head control evaluated to determine how it affected her seating and access to the curriculum. She pointed out that if STUDENT does not use AFOs and leg and arm gaiters, which the IEP team did not discuss using, STUDENT will need a molded seat to avoid the necessity of being strapped into a seat or wheelchair. Ms. Westlake also suggested that STUDENT be evaluated for a barrier vest to improve her trunk and head control. If the seating and barrier vest evaluations are done, Ms. Deutsch explained, STUDENT will have control over her body and head, which will allow her to sit and look at things upright, use her hands to access low and high technology AAC devices, and take part in the curriculum. Without stable trunk and head control, Ms. Deutsch explained, STUDENT will be forced to use low technology AAC devices such as an E-tran or switches and will have reduced access to the class curriculum. Finally, Dr. Blackstone testified that without proper seating, STUDENT will continue to struggle with her head going down when she uses her hands or with her hands not being easily usable when her head is up. Ms. Deutsch concluded that STUDENT’S seating evaluation is a “basic assumption” to STUDENT’S whole District program and it was not done before putting a program together for her.

In addition to the seating and barrier vest evaluations, the District also proposed that STUDENT use a motorized chair at Hopkins in lieu of the full-time facilitation that she presently receives at Beginning Steps. However, before STUDENT could use a motorized wheel chair, Ms. Deutsch testified, STUDENT needs an evaluation first. She explained that STUDENT would have to be fitted for the motorized wheelchair and would have to learn how to access switches to use it. Furthermore, Ms. Deutsch and Ms. Westlake testified that because no other child in the Hopkins program has a motorized wheelchair, Ms. Miller’s class is a little small for a motorized wheelchair. Thus, the IEP team would have to work out the logistics of having a motorized wheelchair for STUDENT in the classroom. Since the District proposes a substantial reduction or a complete elimination of the facilitation that STUDENT presently receives at Beginning Steps, the motorized wheelchair evaluation, like the seating evaluation, is central to STUDENT’S access to the classroom curriculum. Without the evaluation, it is unknown how STUDENT and the motorized wheelchair fit into the District’s program. Thus, without the seating, barrier vest, and motorized wheelchair evaluations being conducted prior to the September 13, 2001 IEP meeting, Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’S program at Hopkins was not properly tailored to meet her critical access needs to the curriculum.

iii. Gross/fine motor needs vs. communication needs

The District’s proposed use of a motorized wheel chair for STUDENT also presents a fundamental shift in the prioritization of STUDENT’S needs. In this case, the parties did not dispute that STUDENT continues to suffer substantial delays in many areas, including her gross motor, fine motor, and communication skills. However, the parties disputed how the delays should be prioritized and treated. Petitioner, on the one hand, contended that her delays, especially her gross and fine motor delays, required manual facilitation from conductors and aides for five days, 30 hours per week. While the Fellners admitted that there were no studies to substantiate that a 30 hour school week comprised of manual facilitation provided any greater benefit than a reduced amount facilitation, they objected to the use of a wheelchair for educating STUDENT.

The District, on the other hand, contended that from June 1999 to the present, Beginning Steps has placed too great an emphasis on improving STUDENT’S gross and fine motor skills and not enough emphasis on her communication needs. While the evidence established that the conductive education program at Beginning Steps has attempted to address STUDENT’S communication needs, Dr. Blackstone testified that the AAC techniques and devices that should have been used at Beginning Steps to address STUDENT’S substantial communication deficits were never employed. Dr. Blackstone explained that because Beginning Steps did not use any AAC devices, the gap between STUDENT’S communication skills and her age increased while at Beginning Steps and it continues to increase to date. Furthermore, she noted that the window of opportunity for STUDENT to have a chance to speak becomes smaller and smaller as time goes by. To close the ever widening gap between her age and her communication needs, the District’s witnesses explained in great detail how the Hopkins program would employ low technology devices such as switches, an E-Tran, auditory and visual scanning, and alphabet/number boards and high technology devices such voice activated output devices, computers with scans, Intelli-keys, etc. In fact, the parties agreed that STUDENT needs these AAC devices to remedy her communication deficits. Finally, Dr. Blackstone explained that if STUDENT is to have a chance at communicating, she needs to immediately start an intensive communication program to keep the window of opportunity from closing shut on her and relegating her to a life without expressive communication.

The District’s witnesses contended, then, that addressing STUDENT’S communication needs had a higher priority than addressing her gross and fine motor needs. However, theDistrict presented no evidence that STUDENT would receive any greater benefit from concentrating on her communication and academic skills in a motorized wheelchair than from working on those skills with manual assistance. Dr. Blackstone and Dr. Effgen explained that it would take an inordinate amount of time, energy and cooperation on behalf of both STUDENT and the staff to facilitate her to sit, stand, and walk throughout the school day. This time, they argued, could be spent instead on her communication and other needs. However, the District provided few specifics about its program, as discussed in greater detail below, that would have given this contention greater credence. For example, there was no specific detail on who, what, when, where, and how STUDENT’S gross and fine motor skills would be worked on during class. Furthermore, the physical and occupational therapy services were a set number of hours without any supporting detail. Because STUDENT made some progress in her gross and fine motor skills at Beginning Steps, as will be discussed under issue two, it would not be unreasonable to expect that a percentage of her day would be devoted to improving her gross and fine motor skills outside of a motorized wheel chair and a percentage of her school day might be in a motorized wheelchair to concentrate on her communication skills. Both Ms. Westlake and Ms. Baldwin suggested such an approach for STUDENT at the September 2001 IEP meeting. The benefit of this approach is that no one set of STUDENT’S needs would be over or under emphasized and all her needs would hopefully be met. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s strong emphasis on communication, while well intentioned, failed to provide sufficient emphasis on STUDENT’S ongoing gross and fine motor needs.

iv. Instructional assistant and certified occupational therapist

The District’s strong emphasis on communication led it to ignore additional details about STUDENT’S gross and fine program. First, the program did not provide any detail on the instructional assistant and COTA that the District offered. With regard to the instructional assistant, the offer included the instructional assistant’s services along with 20 hours of training and 20 hours of training/consultation for the teacher. Ms. Deutsch testified that one did not know if the instructional assistant, who is still unknown, could learn the AAC technology that STUDENT will need. Furthermore, she noted that the specifics of the instructional assistant’s training were not discussed. Ms. Miller testified that the training was important because the instructional assistant would need to be able to work with STUDENT. The District’s offer also did not indicate the number of hours that STUDENT would have an instructional assistant during the school day. Finally, there was also no discussion at the September 2001 IEP meeting regarding what the instructional aide would do to meet STUDENT’S gross and fine motor and communication needs. With regard to the COTA, Ms. Deutsch testified that the COTA was not discussed at the September 2001 IEP meeting. The evidence at the hearing established that the same concerns regarding the instructional assistant applied to the COTA also. Thus, the District’s failure to delineate the specific roles that both the instructional aide and the COTA would play in STUDENT’S educational program further clouded the picture regarding how STUDENT’S motor and communication needs would be met.

v. Physical and occupational therapy

The uncertainty regarding the instructional aide and the COTA was also present in the physical therapy and occupational therapy services that the District offered STUDENT. With regard to the physical therapy services, the District offered STUDENT physical therapy three times per week for one hour. However, what the physical therapy would entail was unknown: it was not discussed at the IEP meeting, there were no specific gross and fine motor goals and benchmarks, and the physical therapist was unknown. With regard to the occupational therapy, the District offered STUDENT 2 and 1/4 hours of occupational therapy 3 times per week plus 4 to 8 hours per month of consultation for the instructional assistant. But just as the IEP failed to provide any specifics about the physical therapy, it also was vague about the occupational therapy. District witnesses also testified that the physical and occupational therapy would be integrated throughout the school day during circle time, art time, snack and lunch time, and recess. Again, the District provided no specific detail regarding how this integration would be accomplished. Finally, if STUDENT were to accept the District’s offer of services, STUDENT would face a reduction from 30 hours of direct facilitation per week to 5 and 1/4 hours of physical and occupational therapy per week. While Student’s witnesses admitted that there was no objective basis for 30 hours per week of manual facilitation for Student, the District also offered no explanation how it arrived at a 24 and 3/4 hour reduction of manual facilitation either. Thus, the physical and occupational therapy services lack the specificity and clarification regarding how the therapy would meet STUDENT’S gross and fine motor needs.

vi. Communication Skills

The parties agreed that while STUDENT possessed good receptive language skills, she had severely delayed expressive communication skills. They did not dispute that Dr. Blackstone and the Hopkins program had the tools to meet STUDENT’S communication needs. However, the lack of specifically drafted communication goals and benchmarks and the absence of scheduled evaluations to determine what AAC devices STUDENT might be able to use did not give this aspect of STUDENT’S program the specificity it needed to measure STUDENT’S needs and progress and to take full advantage of the communication tools that the Hopkins program has to offer.

vii. Self-help skills

With regard to STUDENT’S self-help skills, the District also did not offer a specific program regarding how it would meet STUDENT’S self-help needs. As discussed above, there were no goals and benchmarks to address STUDENT’S toileting, dressing, and feeding needs. Ms. Miller testified that she is very skilled at teaching toileting skills and that she and the instructional assistant work on self-help skills throughout the day. While the Hearing Officer does not doubt that Ms. Miller and her staff work on self-help skills, the District tailored no program specific to STUDENT’S unique self-help needs.

viii. Academic skills

The District offered STUDENT a structured morning program at Hopkins Preschool from 9:00 a.m. to 12:00 p.m., which included circle time, art time, recess time, free play, and snack and lunch time, and an afternoon program from 12:00 p.m. to 1:45 p.m. that concentrated on STUDENT’S communication skills. While the District’s witnesses testified that the school day would touch upon all of STUDENT’S academic needs, the parties greatly disputed whether the District’s program was tailored to meet those needs. For example, with regard to STUDENT’S understanding and comprehension of stories, Ms. Miller testified that STUDENT would read books on the level of “Brown Bear, Brown Bear.” STUDENT’S parents explained that the book was a simple reader for young children. They testified that STUDENT listened to much more complicated stories at home and could answer simple comprehension questions about the stories by pointing to pictures, objects, or protesting when the story was changed. With regard to the alphabet and numbers, STUDENT’S parents contended that she knew all of her alphabet, could rote count up to 20 and knew her numbers up to 30. The District alleged that Student’s academic development was less than what STUDENT’S parents portrayed it to be. Because there was no testimony regarding how the alphabet and numbers in the Hopkins program would be taught to STUDENT and the District witnesses pointed out that there was no State mandated pre-school curriculum on this subject, it was unclear how Student’s disputed academic needs would be met. The lack of specifically drafted goals and benchmarks made this question all the more compelling. Thus, the District’s academic program was not specifically tailored to meet Student’s academic needs.

ix. Social/emotional skills-reverse mainstreaming

The evidence at the hearing established the children in the Hopkins class had disabilities ranging from autism to cerebral palsy. Ms. Miller and Ms. Deutsch explained that the physical and communication skills of the students in the Hopkins class ranged from those who were confined to a wheelchair and were non-verbal to others who were mobile and verbal. Furthermore, the District brought in typically developing peers for recess, circle and art time. Ms. Deutsch and Ms. Miller explained that the District program had a good mix of children that would allow STUDENT to interact with both more verbal and mobile peers and also typically developing peers. Furthermore, the teacher, instructional assistant, and COTA would work on facilitating cooperative play and friendships between STUDENT and the other students. A concern that STUDENT’S parents expressed was that the cooperative play would not occur between STUDENT and the other children because STUDENT might be confined to a motorized wheelchair during the day. While the District asserted that the requisite interaction would occur between STUDENT and other students, questions regarding the motorized wheelchair and any hindrances it might present went unanswered. Thus, while the District’s program regarding STUDENT’S social/emotional skills was well tailored to STUDENT’S needs, a few details remained to be specifically addressed.

Summary

The program offered by the District had many generalized elements that could ultimately provide STUDENT with a FAPE. This fact was especially true with regard to the resources and experts it has to address and meet STUDENT’S communication needs. However, the program was not tailored to meet STUDENT’S unique and individual needs because it did not have proper goals and benchmarks, physical and occupational therapy services, a proper balance between STUDENT’S motor and communication needs, proper evaluations for sitting, provision for a barrier vest and the use of a motorized wheelchair, a transition plan, sufficient explanation regarding the training and role of the aides and COTA, academic and self-help skills, and social/emotional needs. The absence of the “blueprint” in this case, then, is like getting into a beautiful new car for a long trip without a map: whether one reaches his destination will be a matter of luck, not planning.

3. Program designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit

Because the IEP team did not draft appropriate goals and objectives, and tailor the program to STUDENT’S needs, the foundation was not in place for STUDENT to receive educational benefit.

4. Implementation of the IEP

This element was not at issue at the hearing.

5. Appropriate program designed to provide STUDENT with the least restrictive environment Because the District did not offer STUDENT an appropriate program tailored to meet her unique and individual needs, whether the Hopkins program is the least restrictive environment for STUDENT is not ripe for decision.

In summary, the oral and documentary evidence at the hearing established that the IEP team did not develop an IEP program and services that were designed to meet the individual needs of STUDENT. Instead, it generally described the component parts of the Hopkins Preschool program and offered her a generic program and services at the school. The components of STUDENT’S program were generic because the IEP team did not draft appropriate goals and benchmarks, a transition plan from Beginning Steps to Hopkins, a self-help program, did not conduct appropriate evaluations to determine how STUDENT would access the classroom curriculum, placed too great an emphasis on her communication needs and too little an emphasis on her gross and fine motor needs, did not provide any detail about the physical and occupational therapy, the instructional assistant and COTA, and offered an academic program without an accurate understanding of her academic skills. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of placement and services for the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE.

ISSUE 2: Does the District have a legal obligation to provide STUDENT with conductive education to meet her unique and individual needs?

Congress enacted the Individuals with Disabilities Act (IDEA) “to ensure that all children with disabilities have available to them a free appropriate public education that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs and prepare them for employment and independent living.” 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A); see also Cedar Rapids Cmty. Sch. Dist. v. Garrett F., 526 U.S. 66, 68, 143 L. Ed. 2d 154, 119 S. Ct. 992 (1999); Board of Educ. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 188-189, 73 L. Ed. 2d 690, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982). A free appropriate public education is defined as special education and related services that have been provided at public expense, without charge, and are in conformity with the individualized education program. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8); M. C. v. Voluntown Board of Educ., 226 F.3d 60, 62 (2d Cir. 2000). The education provided must be “reasonably calculated to enable the child to receive educational benefits,” though states are not required to maximize the potential of handicapped children. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207; see also M.C., 226 F.3d at 62. Thus, “an appropriate public education under IDEA is one that is likely to produce progress, not regression.” Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist., 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2d Cir. 1998).

In this case, Petitioner first contends that her “program must be a conductive education program.” Conductive education, according to STUDENT, is the only methodology which will meet her unique and individual needs and provide her with educational benefit. Petitioner’s closing brief, page 33 of 36, line 15. The District alleges, on the other hand, that the evidence does not support Petitioner’s contention. Thus, the Hearing Officer shall first review the conductive education methodology and thereafter the progress, if any, that STUDENT has made at Beginning Steps as an example of conductive education.

1. Conductive education methodology

The theory and practice of conductive education were explained by both Mr. Gabor Fellner, conductor and director of Beginning Steps to Independence (Beginning Steps), and Ms. Gyorgyi Fellner, head conductor at Beginning Steps. The Fellners testified that conductive education is an intensive early intervention program designed for children with neuromotor disorders, including cerebral palsy. Mr. Fellner explained that a fundamental tenent of conductive education is that cerebral palsy is not an orthopedic impairment but a learning disability. Because conductive education treats cerebral palsy as a learning disability, it does not treat the individual parts of the child but educates the whole person. Mr. Fellner described this approach as “holistic” and the methodology as “a way of life.”

In classifying cerebral palsy as a learning disability, the Fellners testified that conductive education takes a different approach to educating disabled children as compared with the traditional multi-disciplinary team model found in many schools today. While the latter model employs multiple specialized professionals on a collaborative basis to meet the child’s individual and unique needs, the Fellners testified that the knowledge and expertise of a single conductor is central to this conductive education model. The Fellners explained that the holistic approach of conductive education requires the conductor to employ daily intensive training and interventions in a structured educational framework to target the child’s individual needs. The framework of conductive education is based upon six fundamental elements: (1) the conductor; (2) the group; (3) motivation; (4) daily task series; (5) rhythmic intention; and (6) facilitation. The Hearing Officer shall review each element.

a. The conductor

The Fellners testified that the conductor is trained in the theory and methodology of conductive education at the Peto Institute in Hungary. The course of study is four years long and includes course work in education, science, physical and occupational therapy, language, and clinical training. Ms. Fellner pointed out that the clinical training provides the conductor with the opportunity to hone his skills in gross and fine motor movement, language, cognitive development, and self-help. Completion of the curriculum and clinical training leads to a four year degree and the title of conductor. Thereafter, the conductor has the knowledge, training and skills to develop and implement an educational program for disabled children using the theories and methods of conductive education.

b. The conductive education group and motivation

While the conductor develops and implements the disabled child’s program pursuant to the principles of conductive education, the group and motivation, according to the Fellners, are keys to the conductive education methodology. The Fellners testified that children in the conductive education group must have similar motor disabilities. The reason for the similar levels of motor disabilities is that the level playing field serves as a strong motivating factor for the students. Ms. Fellner testified that if the disabled child is in a group with other students who are more mobile, the disabled child will become frustrated because he/she can not participate in the same activities as the non-disabled child. The Fellners and STUDENT’S mother pointed out that the group of disabled children who have similar disabilities are motivated together, learn together, and ultimately achieve together. Thus, an educational environment comprised of similarly disabled children is critical in the conductive education methodology.

c. Daily task series

While the conductor, the group and motivation play key roles in the conductive education methodology, the daily task series, according to the Fellners, is another central element to the educational methodology. The Fellners testified that the daily task series is a set of activities which the conductor develops to address a child’s individual needs. The Fellners explained that the conductor identifies a specific problem area, creates a task for it, breaks the task down into incremental steps for the child, and then implements it. Thereafter, the child sequentially practices each step until all are successfully completed. Once the child successfully and consistently completes a task series, the child then moves on to a more advanced series of tasks. Finally, the Fellners testified that the daily task series, which include lying, standing, walking, sitting, academics, language, self-help etc., must be practiced five days per week, six hours per day. However, STUDENT’S witnesses admitted that other than the maxim “more is better,” there are no objective studies that concluded that a child needs to attend conductive education for 30 hours per week to receive educational benefit. Mr. Fellner and Ms. Cresswell testified that there is no proof that the amount of time STUDENT attends Beginning Steps is directly related to the amount of progress she made. Thus, the evidence does not establish a direct correlation between the amount of time STUDENT spends in conductive education and the amount of progress she makes.

d. Rhythmic intention

The next important element in conductive education is rhythmic intention. As the conductor implements the task series and the child practices each task, the conductor, according to the Fellners, employs a melodic voice to both guide the child through the task series and to teach the child to internalize each task. Mr. Fellner explained that the conductor will say “now I lift my arm up, 1,2,3,4,5" and the child sequentially proceeds through each step. This rhythm, according to the Fellners, is internalized in the child’s brain and helps the child to master each task series.

e. Facilitation

While the conductors develop and implement many of the task series for the disabled children, the Fellners explained that the severity of the children’s disabilities often require the conductors to use manual facilitation to help the children. The Fellners testified that the level of facilitation that a child requires may range from simple verbal cues to substantial manual support from two individuals with verbal direction. As the child becomes more proficient at performing a task, the level of facilitation decreases until the child can perform the task with minimal to no facilitation.

f. Literature and studies

To further evaluate conductive education, the Hearing Officer turns to the literature and studies on conductive education that the parties produced at the hearing. In support of the conductive education methodology, Petitioner produced numerous articles regarding conductive education, why it is superior to the multi-disciplinary model used by the District, and why the District should choose it to educate STUDENT. While the articles explained the benefits of conductive education, they included no empirical studies or data to establish that it is superior to the multi-disciplinary education model. The District, however, presented six empirical studies with data which established that children with cerebral palsy who were educated using a conductive education model achieved no better results than children who were educated using the multi-disciplinary team approach. Dr. Effgen, who reviewed the studies during her testimony, testified that education in an environment which included typically developing peers as well as children with cerebral palsy, achieved either similar or better results than the children who were educated together with similar disabilities, as they do in a conductive education environment. Mr. Fellner admitted that he knows of no studies that have found that conductive education is a superior methodology to the multi-disciplinary model. Furthermore, Ms. Fellner admitted that STUDENT could participate, learn, and be motivated in a non-conductive education environment. Finally, Ms. Suzanne Cresswell, STUDENT’S physical and occupational specialist, testified that she is aware of no empirical data that concluded that conductive education is more effective than a multi-disciplinary approach. She admitted that she could not say that STUDENT would not have made the same progress in the District’s program as compared to that at Beginning Steps.

While the parties made compelling arguments for their particular educational models, the Hearing Officer found the District’s position on educating STUDENT in a multi-disciplinary model more convincing. First, Dr. Effgen’s opinion was well supported by her qualifications. She testified that she possesses a Ph.D. in special education from Georgia State University, is the director of the doctoral rehabilitation program at the University of Kentucky, is a licensed physical therapist, has researched and studied conductive education in Hong Kong and the United States, and has worked with cerebral palsy students for thirty years since 1972. Second, the federal law supports the District’s position. Finally, the Hearing Officer reviewed the six empirical studies regarding both conductive education and the multi-disciplinary educational model and confirmed that the educational results in both educational models were either the same or better in the multi-disciplinary model.

In summary, the evidence at the hearing established that conductive education is a teaching methodology which employs daily intensive training and interventions in a structured educational framework to target the child’s individual and unique needs. It addresses a child’s needs in an educational framework that includes six fundamental elements: (1) the conductor; (2) the group; (3) motivation; (4) daily task series; (5) rhythmic intention; and (6) facilitation. Conductive education seeks to address a child’s needs not as individual parts but as a complete whole or “a way of life.” However, empirical studies have established that the educational results achieved by students in a conductive education environment have been no better than the educational results achieved by students in multi-disciplinary environment

2. STUDENT’S educational progress in conductive education Petitioner’s second contention in this case is that her program must be conductive education because she has made extraordinary progress in such a program at Beginning Steps that cannot be duplicated in a District program which includes physical, occupational and speech/language therapies. The District, however, alleges that the objective evidence regarding STUDENT’S progress in conductive education at Beginning Steps does not support Petitioner’s conclusion. In determining whether STUDENT’S placement must be conductive education, the Hearing Officer shall review STUDENT’S progress, determine whether the objective data substantiates that this progress could not be duplicated using physical, occupational, and speech/language therapies, and decide what role, if any, normal maturation plays in her progress. STUDENT’S needs fall in five broad categories: (1) gross and fine motor skills; (2) communication; (3) academic skills; (4) self-help skills; and (5) social/emotional skills. The Hearing Officer shall review the progress, if any, in each area of need.

a. Gross and fine motor needs

STUDENT’S gross and fine motor needs also fall into five broad categories: (1) lying; (2) sitting; (3) standing; (4) walking; and (5) grasping. The testimony, medical, therapy, and educational records established that since birth, STUDENT’S cerebral palsy has been characterized by decreased muscle tone throughout her body. The decreased muscle tone, which exists in both STUDENT’S upper and lower extremities, has manifested itself in the form of unusually weak or tight muscles, difficulty with balance, poor coordination, and abnormal reflexes. In STUDENT’S upper extremities, the symptomatology has included little to no control of the lumbar, thoracic, cervical spine and head, oral musculature, shoulders, arms, hands and fingers. With regard to her lower extremities, STUDENT’S symptomatology has included limited hip and knee control, an inability to stand flat footed, and very poor trunk control. The totality of these limitations in STUDENT’S upper and lower extremities has produced physical limitations in the five broad categories outlined above.

When STUDENT entered conductive education at Beginning Steps in June 1999, the aforementioned physical limitations played a significant role in her life. Ms. Fellner, STUDENT’S initial conductor, described STUDENT as “very floppy.” Because of STUDENT’S physical limitations, the Fellners and STUDENT’S parents testified that STUDENT could not independently sit, stand, or walk. Furthermore, they noted that STUDENT’S grasp and arm movement were limited and she had little control of her head. From June 1999 to the present, the Fellners and STUDENT’S parents testified that STUDENT has achieved slow but steady progress in the aforementioned areas of need. While the District argued that Beginning Steps failed to keep regularly, recorded data to establish that STUDENT made progress, the limited data that Beginning Steps did keep along with the testimony of the Fellners and STUDENT’S parents established that STUDENT made some progress in her gross and fine motor skills while attending Beginning Steps.

With regard to sitting, STUDENT improved from being able to sit on the floor for short periods (Suzanne McKnight report, dated May 3, 1999) to being able to hold onto a chair in front of her while sitting on a box (Beginning Steps report dated April 14, 2001). With regard to standing, STUDENT progressed from being able to bear “most of her weight in standing and steps” (McKnight May 3, 1999 report) to being able to stand upright between two chairs with orthopedic equipment on for more than a minute (Beginning Steps report dated February, 2001). Ms. Fellner and STUDENT’S parents also pointed out that STUDENT’S head control improved. The records and testimony indicated that prior to conductive education, STUDENT had great difficulty keeping her head up in a number of different positions. By 2002, Ms. Fellner testified that while STUDENT still exhibited delays in her head control, it improved to the point that she could keep it up longer depending on the level of her motivation. With regard to walking, STUDENT progressed from being able to walk with a Pony walker (Naomi Shimizu report dated March 10, 1999) to walking with help from behind and in front while wearing orthopedic boots and arm orthotics (Beginning Steps report dated May 1, 2001.) Ms. Fellner and STUDENT’S parents noted that STUDENT can presently walk with a chair without support in front. With regard to lying down, she progressed from requiring minimal assistance in rolling from supine to prone and back (Shimizu March 10, 1999 report) to no assistance (Ms. Fellners testimony). Finally, with regard to grasping, STUDENT progressed from using a “reflex grasp” (Anita Cotton September 23, 1998 report) to hold small objects to using two fingers or a pincer grasp more recently (Ms. Fellner testimony). Thus, the evidence established that STUDENT has shown some progress in her gross and fine motor skills while attending conductive education at Beginning Steps.

While STUDENT’S gross and fine motor skills improved at conductive education, the evidence did not clearly establish that the STUDENT’S progress could only be achieved in conductive education. The Fellners testified that when STUDENT began to attend Beginning Steps in June 1999, they had no standardized reporting procedures. Thus, they recorded no initial baseline data from which to later measure STUDENT’S progress regarding her needs. Thereafter, the conductors kept no daily, weekly, or monthly logs of STUDENT’S progress. Instead, they wrote bi-annual reports about STUDENT’S progress in her areas of need and goals. The areas of need that were reported upon did not contain detailed data of STUDENT’S progress. In 2001, Mr. Fellner testified that Beginning Steps began to keep weekly records. However, the weekly records, which were kept on a substantially less than weekly basis, only contained anecdotal observations and did not cover all areas of need. The reason that Beginning Steps did not regularly track STUDENT’S progress, according to the Fellners, is because conductive education relies primarily on observation and the conductor’s memory for recording data.

Because Beginning Steps did not regularly record data regarding STUDENT’S progress, the Hearing Officer could not determine whether the amount of time STUDENT spent in conductive education resulted in an amount of progress that was greater than what STUDENT might achieve in a District multi-disciplinary model using physical and occupational therapy. Finally, the lack of recorded data was also compounded by the absence of any medical reports or testimony from a medical doctor regarding the role that normal maturation played in STUDENT’S progress. STUDENT’S parents testified that STUDENT was regularly seen by a pediatrician, orthopedic surgeon, and a neurologist from birth. However, these medical doctors neither wrote medical reports nor testified regarding STUDENT’S diagnosis and prognosis during any particular time while she attended Beginning Steps, whether her progress was beyondher diagnosed condition during those time periods, and what amount of progress was attributable to her maturation and the methodologies that Beginning Steps used. While Ms. Suzanne Cresswell, a registered occupational and physical therapist, discussed STUDENT’S progress at Beginning Steps, she failed to answer and was not qualified to answer these three important medical questions. Without any answers to these three medical questions, the Hearing Officer was unable to measure and evaluate the rate, quantity, and quality of STUDENT’S progress while she attended Beginning Steps and whether the progress was any different from what STUDENT would have achieved in a traditional physical and occupational therapy.

The evidence established, then, that STUDENT has made progress in her gross and fine motor skills while attending Beginning Steps. However, without daily, weekly, and monthly recorded data and testimony from a physician clarifying critical medical issues in this case, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT failed to establish that the progress she made in her gross and fine motor needs in conductive education at Beginning Steps could only be duplicated in that educational environment.

b. Communication needs

Prior to attending conductive education, the therapy records and testimony from the witnesses established that STUDENT’S receptive communication was intact. As early as 1998, Ms. Suzanne McKnight reported that STUDENT’S receptive language skills were “far superior” to her expressive language skills. Ms. McKnight noted that STUDENT could follow simple commands, make choices between activities and toys and was beginning to identify objects and pictures on request. (McKnight July 13, 1998 report). By May 1999, Ms. McKnight reported that STUDENT could select familiar objects on request and could touch a picture of a familiar object. STUDENT’S parent also testified that STUDENT enjoyed listening to stories and could answer questions after a story was completed. After STUDENT began conductive education at Beginning Steps in June 1999, the conductors’ reports and testimony confirmed that STUDENT had excellent receptive language skills. Furthermore, Dr. Blackstone testified that after her assessment of STUDENT, her receptive communication appeared to be intact and age appropriate. Thus, Petitioner presented no objective evidence that any progress STUDENT may have made in this area of need was more likely the result of any particular methodology used in conductive education as opposed to a well established skill base in this area of need.

The evidence regarding STUDENT’S progress in her expressive communication while in conductive education at Beginning Steps was not as clear as the evidence regarding her progress in her receptive communication. Prior to attending Beginning Steps, the therapy records and STUDENT’S parents’ testimony established that STUDENT already had a sophisticated system of expressive communication in place. Records from the individual family service plan and Ms. McKnight in 1998 and 1999 reported that STUDENT could draw attention to herself with facial expressions, eye gaze, a variety of vocalizations, and turning her head for “no” and “yes.” Thus, STUDENT possessed alternative modes of expressive communication before attending conductive education.

After STUDENT began to attend conductive education, her expressive language continued to improve. During 1999 and 2000, reports from the Regional Center of the Easy Bay and Beginning Steps indicated that STUDENT responded with “yes” and “no” more frequently, tried to copy sounds and words, vocalized more around peers, finished up incomplete sentences by making a sound, and suddenly burst out with words. From 2001 through April 2002, the conductive education weekly reports and two annual reports noted an increase in STUDENT’S expressive language. STUDENT started to use “yes” and “no” more often though the supporting data was absent. When AAC devices were introduced after Dr. Blackstone’s visit, the November 2001 Beginning Steps reports noted a sudden flurry of activity. STUDENT used one-word sentences and also said ‘enjoy your meal,’ ‘I want,’ ‘agua,’ ‘meat,’ ‘I am done,’ ‘wipe,’ ‘numerals,’ ‘letters,’ and friends’ names. Finally, the reports stated that STUDENT used her voice more often when she wanted attention and to ask or answer questions.

The problems with the evidence regarding STUDENT’S gross and fine motor skills also was present with the progress she made in her communication skills. Beginning Steps did not keep regular daily, weekly, or monthly logs regarding her progress in her communication skills. Furthermore, Petitioner presented no evidence regarding what amount of her expressive communication progress was reasonably foreseeable regardless of the methodology used and what amount of the progress was specifically due to conductive education. Finally, Petitioner presented no evidence regarding what amount of her progress in expressive communication was the result of normal human maturation.

The evidence established, then, that STUDENT has made some progress in her receptive and expressive communication while attending conductive education. However, the lack of regularly recorded data and the absence of reports or testimony from either a medical doctor and/or speech and language specialist failed to establish that the progress STUDENT made in her communication needs could only be achieved in conductive education at Beginning Steps.

c. Academic skills

As a result of her delays in her communication, STUDENT has been unable to express and experts have been unable to measure the level of her academic skills. Nonetheless, STUDENT’S ability to eye gaze, point, and vocalize have provided some evidence of her academic skills. Before attending conductive education at Beginning Steps, early records in 1998 and 1999 from Ms. McKnight reported that STUDENT was a bright child. Ms. McKight related that STUDENT enjoyed songs and books “enormously” and became very upset if one changed or skipped a part of a story. Furthermore, STUDENT participated by turning the pages and patting the pictures. A number of witnesses also testified that STUDENT had a very good attention span. Finally, she knew several body parts, could hand a toy back and forth, and enjoyed imaginative play with dolls and tea parties.

After STUDENT began to attend conductive education in June 1999, the evidence established that she continued to make academic progress. With regard to numbers, the Fellners and her parents testified that she learned to count to 20 and understood numbers up to thirty. The District admitted that Petitioner recognized some of her numbers but contended that the amount was substantially less than 20. With regard to the alphabet, the Fellners and STUDENT’S parents testified that she learned all 26 letters. While the District admitted that STUDENT learned some of the alphabet, it contended that it was less than all 26 letters. With regard to shapes, she recognized a square, triangle, rectangle and star and learned how to stack rings. With regard to her colors, the Fellners and STUDENT’S parents testified that STUDENT knew most of her colors and could sort them. The District admitted that STUDENT learned some of her colors. With regard to common animals, the Fellners and STUDENT’S parents testified that she learned animal names and sounds. The District did not present any evidence in rebuttal of this point. With regard to the seasons and months, the Fellners and STUDENT’S parents contended that STUDENT had mastered these concepts. The District contended that she had not mastered any of these concepts. With regard to reading Petitioner’s witnesses testified that STUDENT had learned to sequence events in a story. Finally, the Fellners and STUDENT’S parents testified that she had learned to sort objects and was learning to add and subtract animals. The District offered no evidence in rebuttal on this specific point. The evidence established, then, that while the parties disputed the amount of academic progress that STUDENT had made in conductive education at Beginning Steps, they did agree that she made some progress in her academic skills.

While STUDENT made some academic progress in conductive education at Beginning Steps, her witnesses could not establish that this progress could only be duplicated in conductive education. Again, Beginning Steps failed to keep regularly recorded data about the rate, quantity, and quality of STUDENT’S progress in her academics. Because the parties all agreed that STUDENT is a very bright little girl, Petitioner presented no evidence that the results achieved in conductive education were anything more or less than one might expect. Finally, STUDENT presented no testimony from either a medical doctor or a psychologist to explain what amount of STUDENT’S academic was the result of normal human maturation and what amount of the progress could be attributed to the methodologies used at conductive education. Thus, STUDENT failed to establish that her academic progress could only be accomplished in conductive education.

d. Self-help skills

Because STUDENT experiences delays in her gross and fine motor skills and communication, she experienced delays with her dressing, hygiene, and eating. Prior to attending Beginning Steps, the records and testimony established that STUDENT could not dress herself, take care of her own hygienic needs, and could not feed herself. STUDENT’S parents also testified that because STUDENT had difficulty with different food textures, she experienced problems swallowing foods. However, the records indicated that STUDENT helped to dress herself by giving her hand and pushing her arm through a sleeve. STUDENT also enjoyed selecting her own clothes and had very clear preferences. With regard to eating, she drank from a controlled flow cup and a straw, and enjoyed a variety of foods including grilled cheese sandwiches and ice cream, and could hold and wave a spoon. STUDENT’S parents testified that there was no improvement in her personal hygiene prior to attending Beginning Steps.

After STUDENT began to attend conductive education at Beginning Steps, she continued to make gains in her self-help skills. With regard to her dressing needs, she learned to remove small articles of clothing with help, and lifted her hips to help pull off her pants. With regard to her feeding, both the reports and testimony established that STUDENT, with help, was learning to feed herself with finger foods, to drink from a cup without a lid, to scoop food independently with her spoon, and to grasp a paper towel. With regard to her toileting, she could indicate when her pants were soiled and was trying to use the restroom more often while holding onto a chair. However, she could not use the toilet independently.

While STUDENT made some gains in her self-help skills while she attended conductive education, the gains that she made were also plagued by the same concerns as noted in the other areas of need. There were no daily, weekly, or monthly records to establish the rate, quantity, and quality of STUDENT’S progress. There were not medical reports or testimony regarding whether the progress in her self-help skills was within her expected range of skills pursuant to the level of her disability or was above and beyond what one might expect. Finally, there were neither reports nor testimony from a medical professional regarding the role of maturation and the methodologies used in conductive education. Thus, STUDENT failed to establish that the progress she made in her self-help skills could only be made at conductive education.

e. Social/emotional skills

STUDENT’S final area of need is her social/emotional skills. The records and testimony established that despite STUDENT’S delays, she is a social and happy little girl. Prior to attending conductive education, the IFSP reports from 1998 and 1999 established that STUDENT was very social after she became comfortable with new people. STUDENT’S parents pointed out that STUDENT became easily upset if startled by a sudden noise and was more comfortable with adults. After STUDENT began to attend conductive education in 1999, Mr. Fellner testified that STUDENT initially had tantrums, shouted, and screamed. She did not want to take her turn, wanted things immediately, and was quite uncooperative at times. However, by the time she graduated into the Busy Buddies program in April 2001, Ms. Fellner testified that STUDENT had improved her social emotional skills. For example, she settled into Busy Buddies within two weeks. Furthermore, she made a friend with a little boy in her class. Finally, Mr. Fellner testified that STUDENT became frustrated only one to two times per week. Thus, the evidence established that STUDENT made progress in her social/emotional skills while attending conductive education.

While STUDENT made progress in her social/emotional skills, the same problems that existed in the other areas of need were present in this area of need also. First, Beginning Steps did not keep regular records to measure STUDENT’S progress. Second, there was no testimony from a psychologist regarding what amount of the improvement in STUDENT’S social/emotional skills was due to normal maturation or the methodology used in conductive education. However, the most critical evidence regarding STUDENT’S progress in this area of need was the testimony of the Fellners. Mr. Gabor Fellner admitted that STUDENT could participate in an inclusive setting to not only be motivated but to also learn social skills. Furthermore, both Ms. Fellner and STUDENT’S mother testified that STUDENT could play with typically developing peers. Finally, Ms. Fellner, who had been STUDENT’S conductor at Beginning Steps, testified STUDENT’S class at Beginning Steps had children who were mobile and served as models to motivate STUDENT who was not mobile. In fact, Ms. Fellner pointed out that in STUDENT’S class, there was a little boy who was very mobile and with whom STUDENT had become good friends. Ms. Fellner testified that STUDENT chose this little boy as a friend because he “was a go everywhere child and it amazed her. That was the greatest motivation for her.” The District’s witnesses testified that the program at Hopkins would provide STUDENT with similar children and similar motivation.

Thus, the evidence established that STUDENT has made progress in her social/emotional skills while attending conductive education. However, there were no regularly, recorded data, measurable goals nor testimony from a psychologist regarding the role of maturation in STUDENT’S gains. Furthermore, STUDENT admitted that her social/emotional gains could be made in a setting with typically developing peers. Thus, STUDENT did not establish that her social/emotional needs could only be met in conductive education.

Summary and conclusion

STUDENT is a young, disabled student who has multiple, complex gross and fine motor needs, receptive and expressive communication needs, self-help needs, academic needs and social needs. The parties disputed whether conductive education or the multi-disciplinary team methodology would best meet STUDENT’S unique and individual needs and provide her with a free and appropriate public education. STUDENT contended that her educational program must be conductive education. Conductive education is a unique educational model that purports to educate the whole student and not individual needs. This educational model employs the use of a conductor, a group of students with similar motor needs, motivation, daily task series, rhythmic intention and facilitation. While the evidence established that STUDENT made some progress while being educated with conductive education, it did not establish that the progress STUDENT made in conductive education could only be duplicated in that environment. Petitioner could not make the this critical link between her progress and the conductive education methodology because Beginning Steps did not keep regularly, recorded data. Furthermore, Petitioner’s witnesses presented no evidence on what role maturation played in STUDENT’S progress. Thus, while conductive education has some appropriate elements and has helped STUDENT to make progress in her unique and individual needs, STUDENT failed to prove that conductive education is the only educational program that can do so.

The parties’ dispute over the appropriate methodology to educate STUDENT resulted in a reluctance on behalf of both parties to recognize the positive elements in both the conductive and multi-disciplinary educational models. While both parties failed to establish that their individual educational models alone can systematically and simultaneously meet STUDENT’S multiple needs, the evidence established that both conductive education and the multi-disciplinary team model, in a creative fusion of techniques, could meet STUDENT’S unique needs. If the parties set aside the pre-existing beliefs regarding their own and their opponents’ educational methodologies and collaboratively and creatively employ elements from both educational models, the parties could tailor a unique and individual special education program and services for STUDENT that will ensure equality of opportunity, full participation, independent living and economic self-sufficiency for her.

Procedural violations

STUDENT alleged that the District committed three procedural violations. However, the Hearing Officer finds that these issues are moot because the District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year.

ORDER

Therefore, the Hearing Officer orders as follows:

1. IEP Meeting

Within 30 calendar days of this Order, the District shall convene an IEP meeting for STUDENT to develop a program that continues to promote the growth of her gross and fine motor skills while giving reasonable weight to her communication deficits and other needs.

2. IEP Team Members

As possible IEP team members, the District should consider including and paying for the participation of the following individuals:

(a) Dr. Ashton and Dr. Gardner for their knowledge and expertise in drafting measurable goals and objectives to meet STUDENT’S unique needs; and (b) Mr. Gabor and Ms. Gyorgyi Fellner as consultants because they have worked with STUDENT at Beginning Steps for almost the last three years and are knowledgeable about her present levels of performance in many of her areas of need and about alternative methodologies which may continue to develop and nurture her progress.

3. The IEP team shall create a program for STUDENT which includes, but is not limited to, the following:

Measurable goals and objectives (a) Gross motor skills: sitting, standing, and walking.

(b) Fine motor skills: grasping, holding objects and writing.

(c) Occupational skills: head control, trunk control, seating and positioning, (d) Self-help skills: toileting, dressing, eating and drinking.

(e) Receptive language skills: measurable task series to test STUDENT’S receptive language understanding.

(f) Expressive language skills: vocalization and communication with pictures, objects, and computer programs.

(g) AAC skills: Eye gazing, pointing, auditory and visual scanning, letter and number boards, E-trans, switches, computers, educational and voice activated computer programs.

(h) Academic skills: Numbers, letters, Meyer Johnson symbols, preschool reading comprehension, writing, and math readiness.

(i) Social/emotional skills: Cooperative play and socialization with typically developing peers while keeping STUDENT’S unique and individual needs in mind.

Physical/Occupational Therapy Services

The IEP team shall provide intensive physical and occupational therapy to address STUDENT’S gross and fine motor needs and should also consider consulting with a conductor.

Speech and Language Therapy Services

The IEP team shall providing STUDENT with intensive individual speech and language therapy with augmentative and alternative communication devices on a weekly basis.

Adaptive Equipment

The IEP should consider using orthopedic equipment for STUDENT during school such as ankle, foot, arm and leg orthotics, and perhaps equipment similar to that used at Beginning Steps. The IEP team should also conduct a posture and seating evaluation, a barrier vest evaluation, and a motorized wheelchair evaluation for STUDENT.

4. Finally, the IEP team should consider providing STUDENT’S parents with the training they will need to actively partake in STUDENT’S education at home and at school.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), this Decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

(1) Did the District’s offer of placement and services for the 2001-2002 school year and the extended school year, provide STUDENT with a FAPE?

STUDENT prevailed on this issue.

(2) If the District’s offer of placement and services for the 2001-2002 school year and the extended school year did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE, does STUDENT require a conductive education program to meet her unique and individual needs?

The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

Dated: September 6, 2002 _____________________________________ Joseph T. Macaluso, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. The issue here differs slightly from the issue noticed by Student at the hearing. A slight modification was made for the purposes of clarification.

2. When STUDENT began to attend Beginning Steps, she continued to receive physical therapy from Ms. Shimizu at Kaiser Hospital through the Regional Center. Ms. Shimizu provided ongoing physical therapy to STUDENT through June 2001. Thereafter, Ms. Shimizu provided STUDENT with periodic follow-up examinations because of the intensity of the program at Beginning Steps.

3. Conductors are teachers who are trained in the methodology of conductive education at the Peto Institute in Hungary.

4. Conductors are teachers who are trained in the methodology of conductive education at the Peto Institute in Hungary.

5. Ms. Susan Deutsch, District occupational therapist, testified that the District filed for a due process hearing before the IEP process was done.

6. The District did not quantify the amounts of time Student would use a wheelchair and would be manually facilitated in the classroom.

7. The studies were entitled the Bairstow study, the Coleman study, the Catanese study, the Reddihough study, the Bochner & Chapparo study, and the Sigafoos study.

8. A report did follow in September 1999 but it contained no specific data regarding STUDENT’S areas of need. Instead, it contained generalizations about her areas of need along with goals and objectives.