California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 21, 2004

Student v. Magnolia Elementary School District

SEHO Case No. SN 2399-02 · Hearing Officer Hee C. Kim

Magnolia Elementary must fund Lindamood-Bell summer instruction and an audiology IEE after offering an overly restrictive special day class.

Split decision: student prevailed on 4 of 14 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. The decision mentions an October 16, 2003 IEP that was outside the scope of the hearing.

Summary

The parents of an eight-year-old third grader eligible under "autistic-like behaviors" sued Magnolia Elementary School District over her program from October 1999 to October 2003. She was fully included in general education at Lord Baden Powell Elementary with an aide, resource support, and speech therapy. Hearing Officer Hee C. Kim reviewed each school year and summer separately and found FAPE was offered through April 7, 2003. The goals were measurable, the summer school offers were adequate, and the District's occupational therapy assessment was appropriate. The District should have assessed auditory processing after October 2001. That failure caused no lost educational opportunity, partly because the private audiologist's findings did not account for the student's cognitive and language delays. In April 2003, the District proposed a nonsevere special day class at Schweitzer Elementary. Its multisensory reading instruction was appropriate. However, a full-day class did not give the student the peer modeling she needed. A July revision allowed only 65 minutes a day in general education, and the District offered no basis for that number. FAPE was therefore denied from April 8 to October 15, 2003, though the 2003 summer reading offer was appropriate. The District must repay the parents for the private audiology evaluation but not a psychoeducational IEE, because the parents had refused the District's cognitive testing. It must also propose an auditory processing assessment and fund at least twelve weeks of clinic-based Lindamood-Bell instruction in summer 2004. Section 504 and Section 1983 claims were outside the Hearing Office's jurisdiction.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO treated a move from full inclusion to a special day class. The district had to justify how much time it offered in general education, and an unexplained 65 minutes failed the LRE requirement. It also shows that refusing consent to a district assessment can defeat a later request for reimbursement of an IEE.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 1A. Did the District deny FAPE from October 29, 1999 to the end of the 1999-2000 regular school year, where the May 27 and December 16, 1999 IEP goals allegedly lacked baselines and were not objectively measurable?

    No law requires a baseline for each goal; present levels gave adequate baselines, and the goals were measurable.

  2. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 1B. Did the District deny FAPE for the 2000 ESY by failing to identify a specific ESY placement and services?

    The District offered ESY in the preschool SDC summer program, a continuation of the existing placement, and the parent declined; the offer was adequate.

  3. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 1C. Did the District deny FAPE for the 2000-2001 regular school year by failing to conduct an auditory or audiological evaluation by December 2000, using inappropriate December 1999 goals, and omitting auditory processing goals from the December 2000 IEP?

    The District had no obligation to evaluate auditory processing before January 2001. The student met many goals, and auditory processing goals were not required.

  4. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 1D. Did the District deny FAPE for the 2001 ESY?

    The student attended general education summer school with her aide as agreed, and the challenges to the governing IEP failed.

  5. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEAssessment

    Issue 1E. Did the District deny FAPE for the 2001-2002 regular school year by failing to assess auditory processing and failing to develop appropriate and necessary goals and objectives?

    The District should have assessed auditory processing after October 2001. That failure caused no lost educational opportunity, the private audiologist's diagnosis was unreliable, and the goals were appropriate.

  6. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 1F. Did the District deny FAPE for the 2002 ESY by failing to include a recommendation for specific ESY services?

    The February and April 2002 addenda and the principal's June 30 letter gave sufficient written notice of summer school with aide and speech services.

  7. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEAssessment

    Issue 1G(1). From the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year to April 8, 2003, did the District deny FAPE by failing to assess in all areas of suspected disability (auditory processing, OT, phonemic awareness), failing to review the IEEs at an IEP meeting, failing to have qualified persons interpret the IEEs, and failing to develop appropriate goals?

    The failure to assess auditory processing again caused no lost opportunity. The OT evaluation was timely and appropriate, and no phonemic awareness evaluation was needed. The IEEs were adequately considered without an IEP meeting, and the goals were appropriate.

  8. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1G(2). Did the District's April 8, 2003 offer of a nonsevere SDC placement at Schweitzer deny FAPE from April 8, 2003 to the end of the 2002-2003 school year?

    The SDC offered appropriate multisensory reading instruction and reading goals. A full-day SDC, however, did not provide the peer modeling the student needed, so the placement was not in the LRE.

  9. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 1H. Did the District deny FAPE for the 2003 ESY by failing to identify a specific ESY placement and services?

    The April 2003 offer of the five-week Los Alamitos summer reading program was a sufficiently specific written offer, and the program was undisputedly appropriate.

  10. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1I. Did the District's offer, as modified by the July 9, 2003 letter to provide 65 minutes per day in general education, deny FAPE from the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year to October 15, 2003?

    The District offered no evidence showing how it set the 65 minutes or why the student could not be educated with nondisabled peers for longer, so it failed to establish an appropriate placement.

  11. Issue 2a. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for the independent audiological evaluation by audiologist Carol Atkins in July 2002?

    The District never assessed auditory processing despite notice and the parents' written request, so reimbursement is ordered. The District must also propose its own auditory processing assessment.

  12. Issue 2b. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for the psychoeducational evaluation by psychologist Robert Patterson, Psy.D., in August 2002?

    The parents refused consent for the District's proposed cognitive assessment, so there was no public evaluation to disagree with and no IEE at public expense.

  13. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for any denials of FAPE by the District from October 29, 1999 to October 15, 2003?

    Compensatory Lindamood-Bell instruction was awarded only for the April 8 to October 15, 2003 denial of FAPE.

  14. District prevailedThreshold and jurisdiction

    Issue 4. Did the District's actions result in a denial of STUDENT's rights under 42 U.S.C. Section 1983 and Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act?

    The Hearing Office lacks jurisdiction over Section 1983 and Section 504 claims and made no findings on them.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to assess. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, the District must present the parents an assessment plan for an evaluation of whether the student has auditory processing deficits that negatively affect her ability to benefit from her education. After the parents consent, the District must conduct the evaluation in compliance with federal and State law.
  • Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days of receiving proof of payment, the District must reimburse the parents for the July 2, 2002 audiometric evaluation by Carol Atkins. The decision states no amount.
  • Compensatory education. Unless the parties agree otherwise, the District must fund at least twelve weeks of clinic-based Lindamood-Bell instruction during summer 2004, including related transportation. It must also fund a Lindamood-Bell evaluation if the clinic deems one necessary before services begin.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist.; Capistrano Unified Sch. Dist. v. Wartenberg; Honig v. Doe; Polk v. Central Susquehanna; Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm.; Hoeft v. Tucson Unified Sch. Dist.; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist.; Burlington

People named in the decision

  • Annette Cleveland, director of special education, Magnolia Elementary School District
  • Cindy Hoffman, SELPA program specialist; reading evaluator, Greater Anaheim SELPA
  • Carol Atkins, private clinical audiologist; IEE assessor and witness for Student
  • Robert Patterson, Psy.D., private clinical and educational psychologist; IEE assessor and witness for Student
  • Jerry Lindquist, Ph.D., private occupational therapist and clinical psychologist; expert witness for Student
  • Deborah Zimmerman, special day class teacher, Schweitzer Elementary School
  • Cherie Bauer, SELPA program specialist, Greater Anaheim SELPA
  • John Reid, special education coordinator, Magnolia Elementary School District
  • Trudy Cunningham, principal, Lord Baden Powell Elementary School
  • Lori Choi, second-grade general education teacher, Lord Baden Powell Elementary School
  • Patricia Polcyn, OT and PT coordinator; school-based OT evaluator, Greater Anaheim SELPA
  • Maria Abramson, private clinical and educational audiologist; expert witness for District
  • Karen Stark, preschool special day class teacher, Dr. Jonas Salk Elementary School
  • Greta Tan, speech-language pathologist, Magnolia Elementary School District
  • Mary Olander, audiologist who conducted the District's audiological evaluations, Centralia School District
  • Joan Falconer, school psychologist, Magnolia Elementary School District
  • Shana Di Dodo, speech-language pathologist, Magnolia Elementary School District
  • Glenda McHale, SELPA autism specialist, Greater Anaheim SELPA
  • Tripti Ramani, private speech-language pathologist, Kaiser Permanente
  • Donna Brown, resource specialist, Lord Baden Powell Elementary School
  • Perry Lubens, M.D., private pediatric neurologist
  • Regina Fournier, private school staff member, Discovery Christian School
  • Anne Honeybourne, private school teacher, Discovery Christian School
  • Assistive Technology Exchange Center (ATEC), assistive technology evaluator
  • Vikki Rice, advocate for Student
  • Rodney Ford, advocate for Student
  • John Andersen, SEHO Hearing Officer who clarified the issues before hearing

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Hee C. Kim, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Anaheim, California, on October 21, 22, and 23 and November 12, 13, and 17, 2003. This matter also was heard briefly by telephone on November 19, 2003.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Tania Whiteleather from the Law Offices of Tania L. Whiteleather. Also present on Petitioner’s behalf during various times were her parents, PARENTS, and advocates Vikki Rice and Rodney Ford. Respondent Magnolia Elementary School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Sharon Watt from the offices of Filarsky & Watt, LLP. Also present on the District’s behalf was its director of special education, Annette Cleveland.

Petitioner called the following witnesses: MOTHER; Cindy Hoffman, a program specialist for the Greater Anaheim Special Education Local Plan Area (SELPA); Carol Atkins, a clinical audiologist in private practice; Robert Patterson, Psy.D., a clinical and educational psychologist in private practice; and Jerry Lindquist, Ph.D., an occupational therapist and clinical psychologist in private practice.

The District called the following witnesses: Ms. Cleveland; Deborah Zimmerman, a special day class (SDC) teacher at Schweitzer Elementary School; Cherie Bauer, a SELPA program specialist; John Reid, a special education coordinator for the District; Trudy Cunningham, the principal of Lord Baden Powell Elementary School (BPES); Lori Choi, a second-grade teacher at BPES; Patricia Polcyn, the occupational therapy and physical therapy coordinator for the SELPA; and Maria Abramson, a clinical and educational audiologist in private practice.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. After the receipt of written closing arguments, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING

1. Did the District commit procedural and substantive violations of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) that have resulted in denials of a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to STUDENT from October 29, 1999 to October 15, 2003 during the 1999-2000, 2000-2001, 2001-2002, 2002-2003, and 2003-2004 school years, including extended school years (ESYs)?

2. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the independent educational evaluations they procured from audiologist Carol Atkins and psychologist Robert Patterson, Psy.D., in 2002?

3. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for any denials of FAPE by the District from October 29, 1999 to October 15, 2003?

4. Did the District’s actions result in a denial of STUDENT’s rights arising under Section 1983 of Title 42 of the United States Code and under Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is an eight-year-old third-grade student who resides within the boundaries of the District. MOTHER referred STUDENT to the District for a special education evaluation in October 1998, shortly before STUDENT’s third birthday, because her language was delayed. At the time, STUDENT was attending preschool at the Children’s Learning Center, a private preschool.

The District convened STUDENT’s initial individualized education program (IEP) meeting on December 9, 1998, after she turned three years old. Based on the results of the multidisciplinary evaluation that had been performed by a District school psychologist and SELPA program specialist, the IEP team (IEPT) agreed that STUDENT qualified for special education and related services under the category of autistic-like behaviors. (Footnote 1) The IEPT developed ten goals and objectives to address her preacademic, communication, prevocational, social, language expression, self-help, and community-based skills. Following the December 1998 IEP, STUDENT attended a preschool special day class (SDC) program for severely handicapped (SH) students at Dr. Jonas Salk Elementary School (Salk). Five months later, on May 27, 1999, an addendum IEP meeting was held. At the meeting, SDC teacher Karen Stark reported that STUDENT had met the majority of her IEP goals but still had difficulty with toilet training. District speech-language pathologist (SLP) Greta Tan reported that STUDENT had age-appropriate phonemes. The IEPT developed four new goals and objectives in the areas of fine motor, self help, and preacademics.

For the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT continued to attend the SH-SDC at Salk. In December 1999, Ms. Tan completed a speech-language evaluation of STUDENT at the parents’ request. Ms. Tan found that STUDENT exhibited significantly delayed expressive and receptive language and articulation skills for her chronological age, but that the delays were commensurate with her cognitive level. Ms. Tan reported that STUDENT’s weakest areas were expressive communication and pragmatics, but that her difficulties in these areas were considered secondary to autistic-like behavior difficulties. That same month, on December 16, 1999, the District convened a meeting to conduct an annual IEP review. The IEPT agreed to continue STUDENT’s SDC placement and to add to her program fifteen minutes of speech therapy per week. Because MOTHER indicated that she wanted STUDENT to remain in the classroom, the IEPT agreed that Mrs. Tan would provide speech therapy in the classroom to address STUDENT’s speech goals, as well as provide speech consultation. The IEPT also agreed to eight goals and objectives in the areas of preacademics, academics, communication skills, psychomotor/fine motor skills, and pragmatic language; MOTHER declined proposed goals designed to address community-based instruction.

Near the end of the 1999-2000 school year, in May 2000, MOTHER requested a change of placement to a less restrictive placement. On June 5, 2000, the IEPT met again to discuss STUDENT’s transition from preschool to kindergarten. The IEPT agreed to change STUDENT’s placement to a general education placement at her home school, Lord Baden Powell Elementary School (Baden Powell), with support. Specifically, the IEPT determined that STUDENT would attend a general education kindergarten class at Baden Powell and receive thirty minutes per week of consultation services by the resource specialist (RS), two thirty-minute speech therapy sessions per week in the speech room, and the support of a “special circumstance assistant” (i.e., one-on-one aide) until her annual review in December 2000, at which time the continued necessity of the assistant would be reviewed. Finally, the IEP document indicates that the District offered extended school year (ESY) services but that the parent declined.

STUDENT did not, however, begin attending Baden Powell on September 11, 2000, as had been anticipated by the IEPT. MOTHER testified that STUDENT did not begin attending Baden Powell on September 11, the first day of school, because the parents had not yet decided whether to send STUDENT to the public school or to a private school. On September 21, 2000, an addendum IEP meeting was held to discuss the parents’ additional concerns. At the meeting, the IEPT agreed that STUDENT would begin attending the afternoon kindergarten program at Baden Powell on September 25, 2000, so that she could continue to attend Discovery Christian School (Discovery), a private school, in the mornings. On November 7, 2000, another addendum IEP meeting was convened. The IEPT noted that STUDENT had missed several speech therapy sessions when she began attending Baden Powell because no speech therapist had been available. The IEPT agreed to provide ten thirty-minute makeup speech therapy sessions. (Footnote 2)

On December 6, 2000, the IEPT met for the annual review. District staff noted that STUDENT had met the majority of her IEP goals and even exceeded some. The IEPT agreed to continue her placement in the general education program with the same level of RS, SLP, and aide support. The team also agreed to refer STUDENT to the school nurse for a hearing screening and, if warranted, to Centralia School District (Centralia) for a full audiological evaluation. The team developed seven new goals in the areas of written language, math, pre-reading, phonology, morphological and syntactical language, and pragmatic language. Finally, the team agreed that STUDENT would attend the general education summer school program during the summer of 2001.

A month later, on January 18, 2001, Centralia audiologist Mary Olander performed an audiological evaluation of STUDENT at the District’s request. Ms. Olander noted that MOTHER had reported concerns about STUDENT’s hearing and that her speech was unclear. Ms. Olander reported that STUDENT’s hearing appeared essentially to be within normal limits, but that it was possible that STUDENT had a history of fluctuating hearing loss because of frequent episodes of middle ear effusion. Ms. Olander noted that fluctuating hearing loss often has a negative impact on speech and language development. Ms. Olander recommended medical management by an ear, nose, and throat (ENT) specialist and an audiological reevaluation following medical management. Four months later, Ms. Olander reevaluated STUDENT. Ms. Olander’s May 2001 report states that STUDENT had mild conductive hearing loss in both ears and that this hearing loss could impact STUDENT’s ability to detect soft speech sounds (phonemes), especially when there was background noise. She noted that STUDENT’s hearing had fluctuated since her last audiologic evaluation. Ms. Olander again recommended medical management by an ENT specialist and an audiologic reevaluation following medical management.

According to MOTHER, STUDENT attended both three-week general education summer school sessions during the summer of 2001. MOTHER testified that STUDENT continued to receive the support of her one-on-one aide while she attended summer school but she did not receive any speech therapy.

For the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT’s first-grade year, STUDENT continued to be fully included in the general education program at Baden Powell with the support of an aide, the resource specialist program (RSP), and speech therapy. Near the beginning of the school year, the District conducted a triennial evaluation of STUDENT, which included evaluations by a school psychologist, RS, SLP, school nurse, her classroom teacher, and an adapted physical education (APE) specialist. (Footnote 3) School psychologist Joan Falconer measured STUDENT’s cognitive ability using the Kaufman Assessment Battery for Children (KABC) and reported that STUDENT’s ability fell in the borderline deficit range. STUDENT’s achievement was measured using the Wide Range Achievement Test – Third Edition (WRAT-3) with the following results: reading standard score (SS) of 98 (kindergarten level); spelling SS of 101 (kindergarten level); and arithmetic SS of 72 (preschool level). SLP Shana Di Dodo reported that STUDENT exhibited multiple articulation errors characterized by consistent sound substitutions and the persisting phonological process of cluster reductions, which impaired her overall speech intelligibility. She reported STUDENT’s strengths to be in the areas of receptive and expressive vocabulary (semantics) but that she presented with difficulties in syntax both receptively and expressively when compared to similar chronologically aged children. Ms. Di Dodo noted that STUDENT had displayed tremendous growth in pragmatics. She described STUDENT as a social, conversational child who participated with peers and adults, initiated conversations, maintained topics and eye contact, and requested clarification and help when necessary. Ms. Di Dodo recommended that STUDENT continue receiving two thirty-minute speech therapy sessions per week with an emphasis on improving speech intelligibility.

On October 25, 2001, the IEPT met for the triennial review. The team noted that STUDENT had met her annual IEP goals and was an “emerging” reader with on-target first-grade math skills. Although the parents requested an increase in aide support from four to six hours per day, the team agreed to continued placement in a general education first-grade classroom at Baden-Powell with thirty minutes per week of RS consultation, two thirty-minute speech therapy sessions per week, and four hours of aide support per day. Additionally, the District recommended that STUDENT attend general education summer school. The team agreed to five goals in the areas of math, language arts, reading, and phonology. Soon after this IEP meeting, STUDENT’s parents began to remove STUDENT from school two hours prior to the end of the full school day so she could attend Discovery. (Footnote 4)

The IEPT met again a week later on November 1 to discuss the parents’ request for a six-hour aide. MOTHER told the team that STUDENT had an aide for the entire school day during the prior school year and should continue to have a full-time aide to maintain continuity and growth in the areas of academic, emotional, and social skills. MOTHER also stated that STUDENT’s speech intelligibility and rate made it impossible for her to express her difficulties and frustration. The District denied the parents’ request for a six-hour aide, indicating that the goal was for STUDENT to continue her level of independence and to grow academically and socially without becoming dependent on an individual staff member. The District recommended that STUDENT continue receiving four hours of aide support per day along with twenty-five minutes per day of support from the RSP instructional assistant. The District also proposed that the SELPA autism specialist observe STUDENT, collect data, and meet with the IEPT in four weeks to review the level of support required. At the conclusion of the meeting, MOTHER signed in agreement with the goals and objectives from the IEP of October 25, 2001, but not in agreement with the placement and services recommended for STUDENT. In a letter to the superintendent dated the same day and in a November 2 letter, MOTHER refused permission to have the SELPA autism specialist observe STUDENT and collect data.

On or about November 22, 2001, the District filed a request with the Hearing Office for mediation (MO01-00175). The parties met in mediation on December 6, 2001, and reached a final agreement. The parties agreed that the District would conduct an assessment to determine STUDENT’s need for a one-on-one assistant through SELPA autism specialist personnel and that, during the assessment period when data was to be gathered, the District would increase the level of RSP aide support in order to provide STUDENT with aide support for the entire school day. The parents also agreed that STUDENT would attend the full school day during the assessment period. Following six weeks of removing STUDENT from school two hours early every day, STUDENT’s parents stopped removing her from school early to attend Discovery at or about this time.

Also on December 6, Centralia audiologist Mary Olander completed a second audiological reevaluation of STUDENT on the District’s behalf. Ms. Olander reported that testing showed normal hearing sensitivity in both ears but that STUDENT’s hearing had fluctuated at least once in the past, as noted in her May 2001 report. Ms. Olander recommended audiologic reevaluations every six to twelve months, or as needed, to monitor STUDENT’s middle ear status.

Through a consultation report dated February 1, 2002, SELPA autism specialist Glenda McHale reported her findings. She had reviewed STUDENT’s records, observed STUDENT in the school setting, interviewed District staff, and reviewed data collected over a four-week period. Ms. McHale reported that the general education classroom offered STUDENT high levels of scaffolding to support her in her success and progress, including a predictable routine and structured schedule, as well as high levels of predictability. Ms. McHale found that STUDENT clearly benefited from peer modeling and that she relied on observations for cues regarding expectations for her own behavior, performance, and learning. According to Ms. McHale, STUDENT evidenced parallel participation with her peers in choral activities and familiar routines. With regard to social skills, Ms. McHale reported that although STUDENT evidenced high levels of social interest, she evidenced limited interactive socializations. According to Ms. McHale, STUDENT’s socializations were based largely in proximity, the observation of others, and parallel activities. Ms. McHale noted staff had indicated that, while social delays remained, socialization had been an area of significant improvement for STUDENT. As for her pragmatic skills, Ms. McHale reported that although STUDENT had met her kindergarten speech and language objectives in pragmatics, those skills appeared not to have consistently generalized outside of a structured therapy setting.

Ms. McHale offered a multitude of recommendations, including the following: (1) that staff continue to participate in general training regarding the characteristics of autism, behavioral intervention strategies, communication, and social skills facilitation; (2) that service providers meet regularly as a team to collaborate and coordinate specific strategies and support for STUDENT that can be implemented consistently across all service providers in all settings; (3) that the District provide up to one hour per month of SELPA autism personnel consultation; (4) that the instructional assistant (IA) staff receive training in process-oriented instructional strategies, prompting hierarchies, and reinforcement strategies that support learning while building independence for the learner; (5) that goals and objectives be developed in the areas of pragmatics related to communication and deficits in socialization related to interaction skills, the implementation of which all staff should be instructed on and the implementation of which should be across all settings to ensure the generalization of skills; (6) that an IA be available during the first half of the school day to assist STUDENT in the area of academic instruction and practice because of STUDENT’s below grade level and approaching grade level performance marks on progress report cards; (7) that the IA provide support to STUDENT at recess and lunch times by organizing interactive play, redirecting STUDENT to respond to the initiations of peers, and facilitating STUDENT in the implementation of appropriate attention-gaining strategies and initiation strategies; and (8) that the classroom teacher facilitate the foregoing communication and socialization strategies in the classroom, particularly during workshop, centers, art, and other afternoon activities. With regard to the question of whether STUDENT required additional assistance in the afternoon, Ms. McHale concluded that STUDENT did not appear to require that additional level of support at the time. Ms. McHale noted that the current afternoon staff (the RSP aide) provided minimal and highly distant support through visual monitoring, with primary instruction and support provided by the classroom teacher. Ms. McHale noted that all recommendations about support should be revisited when the team planned for STUDENT’s needs in the second grade.

On February 19, 2002, an IEP addendum meeting was convened. Ms. McHale shared her evaluation findings and recommendations. The District proposed three new goals and objectives to address pragmatics, communication, and socialization skills. The District offered to add to STUDENT’s program a thirty-minute language group one time per week, which would take place in the classroom, to facilitate implementation of the new goals under the guidance of the SLP. The District also offered to increase RSP consultation services in the classroom from thirty minutes per week to fifteen minutes per day. The District denied the parents’ request for six hours of aide support per day but offered to continue providing four hours per day of aide assistance to support STUDENT’s learning during academics and facilitation of socialization. Further, the District offered to hold one-hour monthly planning meetings consisting of the staff, the aide, and the parents, as well as one hour per month of services by the SELPA autism specialist to provide training and consultation for STUDENT’s program. Finally, the District noted that STUDENT was eligible to attend the general education summer school program and offered to provide ongoing speech therapy to her if she attended summer school. The parents indicated that they would take the IEP home to review and requested the following: (1) independent educational evaluations (IEEs) by a psychologist and in the areas of cognition and speech, (2) an increase to RSP services to thirty minutes per day, (3) involvement in the school reading program, (4) an increase in speech therapy, (5) additional goals, (6) an assistive technology assessment, and (7) an increase in aide support to six hours per day with the then-assigned aide.

By letter dated February 27, 2002, the parents informed the District that they were in agreement with the increase in speech and RSP services. The parents also requested a change in the classroom teacher and the following IEEs: a central auditory processing (CAP) evaluation, complete psychological educational evaluation (including ability testing), and a complete speech and language evaluation. Shortly thereafter, on March 5, the District sent the parents a proposed assessment plan to assess STUDENT in the areas of cognition, speech, and assistive technology. MOTHER signed the assessment plan but crossed out the sections regarding cognition and speech. (Footnote 5)

By letter dated March 13, 2002, the District’s director of special education, Annette Cleveland, sent the parents a letter stating that the District was denying their requests for a change in the classroom teacher, an increase in the number of aide hours, a CAP evaluation, and enrollment in the school reading program. Ms. Cleveland also reiterated the District’s placement offer for STUDENT.

On April 25, 2002, Ms. Olander conducted a third audiological reevaluation of STUDENT on the District’s behalf. Ms. Olander reported findings consistent with normal hearing sensitivity in both ears and recommended another reevaluation in a year.

The next day, on April 26, another IEP addendum meeting was held to review the IEP recommendations from February 27 and STUDENT’s progress in the first grade program. The team also discussed the parents’ ongoing concerns and requests. District staff indicated that STUDENT was making progress in her placement, but MOTHER expressed doubts that STUDENT possessed the skills attributed to her by staff. By the conclusion of the meeting, the parents indicated their agreement with the following District-recommended changes from the February 27 meeting: (1) one hour monthly team planning meetings, (2) one hour per month of autism support from the SELPA for training and consultation, (3) a thirty-minute per week language group in the classroom, (4) general education summer school with ongoing speech therapy, and (5) the additional goals and objectives. The parents did not agree to increase RSP consultation services in the classroom to fifteen minutes per day, and they continued to disagree with the provision of aide support for only four hours per day. Additionally, the parents requested compensatory speech services for the previous summer.

In May and June 2002, MOTHER brought STUDENT to Kaiser Permanente (Kaiser) for a speech and language evaluation. Kaiser SLP Tripti Ramani noted that MOTHER reported that STUDENT was having difficulty in all academic areas and was interested in having her speech and language skills reevaluated. Ms. Ramani found that STUDENT appeared to exhibit severe impairments in receptive and expressive language skills and articulation skills, to have very little difficulty repeating auditory information in a rote manner but maximum difficulty organizing or manipulating auditory information, and to have difficulty sequencing sounds for multisyllabic words and phrases. Ms. Ramani reported that STUDENT would benefit from regular therapy sessions focused on improving her speech and language skills and that the therapy should involve home and parent involvement to aid with the carryover of skills to new environments. Ms. Ramani found that in the classroom STUDENT might benefit from strategies to ensure that she processes and retains information presented auditorily, such as presenting information visually, checking periodically for understanding of key vocabulary and oral directions, and providing multiple repetitions of information and then asking her to repeat directions after presentation.

By letter dated June 30, 2002, Trudy Cunningham, the principal of Baden Powell, informed the parents that she would ensure STUDENT’s placement in both sessions of regular education summer school program at Baden Powell based on their request. Ms. Cunningham confirmed that STUDENT would be supported by a one-on-one aide during both summer school sessions. STUDENT attended both general education summer school sessions, with aide support and speech therapy services, during the summer of 2002.

On July 2, 2002, the parents brought STUDENT to private audiologist Carol Atkins for a special diagnostic audiometric evaluation to assess her auditory processing (AP) skills. Ms. Atkins found that STUDENT presented with significant speech and language processing issues. After Ms. Atkins cautioned that interpretation of STUDENT’s AP skills had to be viewed with caution because of her delays in articulation and receptive and expressive language, Ms. Atkins noted that STUDENT’s receptive auditory skills were weak for listening in the presence of noise (i.e., competing speech, fan noises, and when riding in a car). Ms. Atkins reported that STUDENT’s performance during the evaluation suggested that she has difficulty decoding information and processing it accurately, especially in the presence of competing information, and that lengthy information would compound her processing difficulties. Additionally, Ms. Atkins noted that the parents indicated that STUDENT’s activities of daily living were satisfactory but that she has reported sensitivity to sounds and retreats under a table if on sensory overload; that she prefers cotton clothing and will wear her shoes backwards; and that she is a selective eater, preferring food from Taco Bell, rice, tuna, and mashed potatoes. Ms. Atkins stated that further investigation of STUDENT’s sensory integration (SI) skills might be very helpful in developing increased integration of sensory input and decrease shut-down behaviors. Finally, Ms. Atkins reported that intervention to address STUDENT’s auditory, language, and behavioral needs was critical and that the District and parents needed to find “a nurturing, structured, quiet environment” for STUDENT to begin learning academics and social skills. Ms. Atkins diagnosed STUDENT with a CAP deficit, as part of her autism spectrum syndrome, in the following specific areas: decoding auditory information, auditory association deficit, and integration of auditory information. Ms. Atkins recommended that STUDENT continue to receive intensive speech therapy, that an occupational therapy (OT) assessment be conducted to rule out an SI disorder, that she increase her AP skills using a sound therapy methodology such as Samonas Sound Therapy, and that she be reevaluated by an audiologist in one year to monitor auditory maturation.

That same month, the parents contacted private psychologist Robert Patterson, Psy.D., for a psychoeducational evaluation. Dr. Patterson observed STUDENT in the school setting at Baden Powell on July 22, while she was attending summer school, and administered formal assessment measures on August 15. Dr. Patterson diagnosed STUDENT with an autistic disorder and a developmental coordination disorder (fine motor). He reported that STUDENT performed cognitively in the mid-borderline range verbally, with a relative strength in terms of quantitative thinking and a relative weakness in verbal abstract thinking. He noted that on nonverbal items STUDENT performed in the low average range. With regard to academics, Dr. Patterson stated that STUDENT was performing on the cusp between low average and average functioning in reading and written expression, but on the cusp between borderline and low average functioning in math, and that she was reading below the pre-primer level. Dr. Patterson reported that STUDENT’s visual motor integration skills were average but that she had a very slow processing speed and a significantly impacted understanding of spatial relationships. Additionally, Dr. Patterson reported that all language functioning was significantly impacted, as were conceptualization skills, and that STUDENT had difficulty rapidly shifting her mental set. Further, he noted that STUDENT had significantly delayed working memory and long-term retrieval skills and that her adaptive functioning skills were on the cusp between low average and average functioning levels. Dr. Patterson recommended that STUDENT be evaluated by an OT because she appeared to have difficulty integrating different components of her body into fully integrated movements and had auditory defensiveness that was impacting her ability to focus in the classroom. He also stated that she required very specific social skills training involving the specific teaching of nonverbal communication and skill training for verbal communication, including conversation initiation, verbal turn-taking, and topic maintenance. Additionally, Dr. Patterson recommended ongoing speech therapy focusing on expressive and pragmatic language and that the school staff consult with an independent audiologist regarding how best to develop STUDENT’s listening skills and AP deficits. Finally, Dr. Patterson found that STUDENT would benefit from a multisensory method of teaching reading and written language such as Project Read, Slingerland, Orton-Gillingham, or the ADD Program from Lindamood-Bell (LMB).

For the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT continued attending Baden Powell, this time in a general education second-grade classroom. Shortly after the beginning of the school year, on September 17, an IEP addendum meeting was held. The IEPT discussed whether STUDENT should be retained in the first grade and agreed that she should not be retained.

On October 4 and 7, 2002, Ms. Di Dodo conducted a speech and language evaluation to gather updated information regarding STUDENT’s present levels of functioning in anticipation of her annual IEP review. Ms. Di Dodo concluded that STUDENT demonstrated growth in her speech and language skills. Specifically, Ms. Di Dodo reported that STUDENT’s overall speech intelligibility had increased and the number of sound errors had decreased; that her receptive vocabulary had shown a growth of ten months; and that expressively she had demonstrated the use of grammatical structures in her oral language. Additionally, at or about the same time, RS Donna Brown and classroom teacher Lori Choi administered the Weschler Individual Achievement Test – Second Edition (WIAT-II), WRAT-3, Reading High Frequency Words, and the San Diego Quick Nonsense Word Test to evaluate STUDENT’s academic functioning.

On October 24, 2002, the IEPT met for the annual review. MOTHER stated at the meeting that she was concerned that STUDENT’s skills had regressed and that her needs had not been addressed. Ms. Cunningham raised an issue with regard to absences and tardiness, noting that STUDENT had missed twenty-nine days of school and been tardy ninety-seven times during the prior school year. The IEPT then discussed STUDENT’s progress at school and the results of recent updated testing. MOTHER requested an OT assessment with a focus on SI. District staff replied that a referral for an OT assessment would be made after the IEP was completed and the team agreed that a referral was warranted. The District then presented sixteen proposed goals and objectives to address the areas of expressive language, pragmatics, articulation, phonemic awareness, decoding and word recognition, comprehension and analysis, sentence structure, spelling, math, socialization, and independence. The District also proposed the following: placement in a general education program for 1,770 minutes per week; sixty minutes per day of pullout RSP; three thirty-minute pullout speech therapy sessions per week (one session to be on a one-on-one basis and two sessions to be on a 1:2 adult-to-student ratio); one thirty-minute speech therapy session in the classroom per week; and collaboration with staff by the RS and SLP on as needed basis. The October 24 meeting was continued, however, because the parents had to leave. Before leaving, the parents orally agreed with the proposed amount of speech services, although they indicated that all pullout speech sessions should be on a one-on-one basis. The parents did not, however, provide written consent for implementation of any of the District’s proposed changes.

By letter dated two days later, October 26, the parents accused the District of denying STUDENT an appropriate education for years and continuing to deny her educational services that would allow her to make educational progress. The parents stated that STUDENT had failed to make appropriate educational progress in school and failed to make progress on her goals and objectives. Additionally, the parents indicated they had obtained IEEs that indicated STUDENT required intensive speech and language services, an OT assessment, social services training, and a program to address her reading and writing skills, such as LMB, Project Read, Slingerland, or Orton-Gillingham. The parents asserted that the District had taken no steps to address STUDENT’s unique needs in OT, social skills, expressive and receptive language, and reading and writing (i.e., language processing), and that she had made no real progress in those areas. Finally, the parents declared that the District should provide STUDENT with intensive speech and language services, an OT assessment, a social skills training class, and a multisensory program to address her language processing needs to allow her to make progress in reading and writing. Shortly thereafter, on October 28, the parents filed with the Hearing Office a request for the instant due process hearing.

The IEPT reconvened on November 5, 2002. Ms. Brown presented two more proposed goals to address socialization and independence. Additionally, Ms. Cleveland presented a proposed assessment plan for an OT assessment, which MOTHER signed. Finally, the District reiterated the proposals made at the October 24 meeting and proposed the following additional services: support from a one-on-one aide four hours per day; a one-hour monthly team planning meeting; ten hours per month of autism support from SELPA staff to provide direct training and coaching of staff for the facilitation of social interactions, independence, and curriculum modification, using a cross section of times and places to get an overview of STUDENT’s typical day; and the general education summer school program with ongoing speech services. The parents orally indicated agreement with the offer of continued aide support, although they still believed that STUDENT required six hours of aide support per day. The parents also orally indicated agreement with continuation of the monthly meetings and the offer of autism support, although they believed that more than ten hours per month of autism support was necessary. The parents were silent as to the remainder of the District’s proposed placement and did not provide written consent for implementation of any of the District’s proposed changes.

On November 26, 2002, Patricia Polcyn, the OT and physical therapy coordinator for the SELPA, conducted a school-based OT evaluation of STUDENT on the District’s behalf. Ms. Polcyn conducted a file review, school observations, staff interviews, and an observation in the OT clinic and completed the Short Sensory Profile (SSP) and School Functional Assessment (SFA). She found that the SSP indicated that STUDENT was processing sensory information sufficiently for learning in the educational environment, and that the SFA results indicated that STUDENT was functioning well in her educational placement at Baden Powell. Ms. Polcyn noted that STUDENT moved her body with ease and coordination and that her fine motor skills had developed nicely. Ms. Polcyn stated that although STUDENT could be distracted by sounds in the classroom, she was refocused easily by her teacher or assistant. Additionally, Ms. Polcyn stated that her observation of STUDENT’s play skills indicated that she was able to use her time productively and to use play as a means for learning, although it had been reported that she needs encouragement to play interactively with peers. Ms. Polcyn concluded that STUDENT did not require OT intervention to benefit from the educational environment and that the District had provided an assistant to address STUDENT’s areas of academic need when appropriate. Ms. Polcyn presented her evaluation findings at an IEP addendum meeting on January 6, 2003. At the meeting, the District determined that STUDENT did not require direct OT services.

On March 10, 2003, the parents finally provided written consent for implementation of the placement and services recommended by the District at the IEP meetings held on October 24 and November 5, 2002.

On March 14, 18, and 20, 2003, SELPA program specialist Cindy Hoffman conducted a comprehensive reading evaluation of STUDENT at the District’s request. Using a variety of standardized, criterion-referenced, and informal measures, Ms. Hoffman found that STUDENT’s reading skills were scattered between the pre-kindergarten and kindergarten levels. Ms. Hoffman reported that, when STUDENT was presented with a short story without picture clues to guide her, STUDENT scanned the passage and read the words she recognized but that, when she was presented with kindergarten level stories with picture clues and patterns to aid her, she read the material willingly and with expression. Additionally, Ms. Hoffman noted that STUDENT’s rate of reading was slow and labored. Ms. Hoffman concluded that STUDENT required a multisensory reading program to provide the specific skills that she required to remediate her deficits in reading, such as Reading Mastery Fast Cycle, Project Read, LMB Lips Program, and Touch Phonics.

An IEP addendum meeting was convened on April 8, 2003, to review the results of Ms. Hoffman’s reading evaluation. At the meeting, the team discussed a myriad of placement options for STUDENT. The District then proposed changing STUDENT’s placement to the nonsevere (NS) SDC at Schweitzer Elementary School (Schweitzer) taught by Deborah Zimmerman, with four hours per day of aide support to facilitate the transition. The District also offered STUDENT placement in the five-week summer reading program provided by the Los Alamitos School District (Los Alamitos). Additionally, the District recommended that the team continue with the related services then in place and all the goals and objectives previously developed, and proposed four additional goals to address reading/phonemic awareness and reading comprehension. While MOTHER agreed that the Baden Powell placement was not appropriate for STUDENT and that she required a more intense program, MOTHER did not agree to placement in the SDC at Schweitzer. MOTHER requested that STUDENT be placed in the SH-SDC regional program at Holder Elementary School (Holder) located in the Savanna School District.

By letter dated July 9, 2003, Ms. Cleveland denied the parents’ requests for placement at Holder and for the thrice weekly pullout speech therapy to be provided on a one-on-one basis. Ms. Cleveland explained that the District believed that the Schweitzer placement was appropriate for STUDENT, and that the provision of three individual speech therapy sessions would not be appropriate because STUDENT benefits from peer language modeling. Ms. Cleveland reiterated the District’s April 8 offer as follows: placement in the NS-SDC at Schweitzer for 1,445 minutes per week (300 minutes per day on Mondays, Tuesdays, Wednesdays, and Fridays and 245 minutes per day on Thursdays) with (1) sixty-five minutes per day in the general education program; (2) four hours per day of one-on-one aide support; (3) a one-hour team planning meeting one time per month; (4) ten hours per month of autism support from the SELPA for training and consultation; (5) two thirty-minute pullout speech therapy sessions per week on a 1:2 adult-to-student ratio and one thirty-minute pullout speech therapy session per week on a one-on-one basis; (6) one thirty-minute language group collaboration session in class per week; (7) coordination and collaboration of services by the SDC teacher as needed; (8) special modifications and accommodations including adapted materials, number lines, a calculator, access to the classroom computer, word puzzle cards, math manipulatives, a word wall, software for school-based computers, highlighted text, and ongoing staff training in autism.

The parents never agreed to placement in the Los Alamitos summer reading program for the 2003 ESY. Because the parents also never consented to the Schweitzer placement, when the 2003-2004 school year began, STUDENT continued in her general education placement at Baden Powell, which was her last agreed-upon and implemented placement. (Footnote 6)

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Did the District commit procedural and substantive violations of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) that have resulted in denials of a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to STUDENT from October 29, 1999 to October 15, 2003 during the 1999-2000, 2000-2001, 2001-2002, 2002-2003, and 2003-2004 school years, including extended school years (ESYs)?

Pursuant to the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, all children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE) that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs and prepares them for employment and independent living. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a child at no charge to his or her parent or guardian, meet the standards of the State educational agency, include appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education, and are provided in conformity with the child’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). (Footnote 7) Special education law also requires that a child with a disability be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A).

Such special education and related services must be tailored to meet the unique needs of the child with a disability by means of an IEP. Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16, 853 F.2d 171, 173. The IEP, which is the “centerpiece of the [IDEA’s] education delivery system for disabled children,” consists of a detailed written statement that must be developed, reviewed, and revised for each child with a disability. Honig v. Doe (1988) 484 U.S. 305, 108 S.Ct. 592, 598; 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343, 56345. The IEP must include a statement of the goals and objectives, special education and related services, and program modifications or supports for school personnel that are to be provided to meet the child’s needs resulting from his or her disability to enable the child to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum and be educated and participate with nondisabled children to the maximum extent possible. Id.; see also 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56031, 56345.

In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S. Ct. 3034, the United States Supreme Court determined that a child’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the child with some educational benefit to satisfy the IDEA, but that the school district is not required to provide the child with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court held that a school district is required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child. Id. at 201. Consequently, an appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the child. Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996); Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1524 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied 513 U.S. 965 (1994). De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist., 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2nd Cir. 1997).

The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. 458 U.S. at 205. States are required to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each child with a disability receives the FAPE to which he or she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the child’s educational placement. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). Not every procedural flaw constitutes a denial of FAPE, but procedural violations that result in loss of educational opportunity to the child or seriously infringe on the parent=s opportunity to participate in the IEP process may constitute a denial of FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).

Accordingly, the analysis of whether a child has been provided a FAPE in the LRE generally requires a two-part inquiry. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-207. First, the Hearing Officer must determine whether the District complied with the procedures set forth in the IDEA. Id.; Capistrano Unified Sch. Dist. v. Wartenberg, 59 F.3d 884, 891 (9th Cir. 1995). Second, the Hearing Officer must determine whether the IEP developed through the IDEA’s procedures is reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit upon Jackson. Id.

Petitioner contended that the District committed a number of procedural and substantive violations of the IDEA that denied her a FAPE from October 1999 to October 2003. Among other things, Petitioner argued that the District failed to assess her in all areas related to her suspected disability, failed to develop appropriate goals and objectives, failed to consider adequately the findings and recommendations of the independent educational evaluations procured by her parents during the summer of 2002, and failed to offer her specific ESY placements. In response, the District contended that its assessments and recommended placements were appropriate under the IDEA and provided STUDENT educational benefit. The District also argued that its most recently recommended placement, the nonsevere special day class (NS-SDC) at Schweitzer Elementary School (Schweitzer) with Deborah Zimmerman and other enumerated services, constitutes a FAPE for STUDENT in the LRE.

Given the numerous school years at issue, this Decision will examine Petitioner’s FAPE challenges one school year at a time. (Footnote 8)

A. October 29, 1999 to the End of the 1999-2000 Regular School Year

The only argument Petitioner specifically advanced with regard to the 1999-2000 regular school year involved the goals and objectives contained in her IEPs dated May 27 and December 16, 1999. Petitioner contended that many of the goals and objectives lacked baselines and were not objectively measurable. The IEP for each child with a disability must include a statement of the child’s present levels of educational performance and a statement of measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives. 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56534(a). Measurable annual goals are “critical to the strategic planning process used to develop and implement the IEP for each child with a disability” and enable the child’s teachers, parents, and others involved in developing and implementing the child’s IEP to measure during the year if the child is making progress toward meeting the annual goal. 34 C.F.R., App. A to Part 300, Q.1.

Petitioner argued that the District failed to provide sufficient baselines for the goal for identifying and naming body parts in the May 27 IEP and for all eight goals in the December 16 IEP. The Hearing Officer disagrees. First, there is no specific requirement in either federal or State law that the IEP identify a specific baseline for each goal included in the IEP. While an IEP is required to include a statement of the child’s present levels of educational performance, it is nowhere stated that the present levels of performance must align exactly with every goal and objective. In any case, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided adequate information about STUDENT’s present levels of performance in her annual IEPs dated December 1998 and December 1999 to inform a reader as to the baselines for the goals at issue. For example, STUDENT’s December 1998 annual IEP indicated that she had an expressive vocabulary of fewer than fifteen words, none of which were body parts, meaning that she could not identify and name any body parts at that time. Additionally, the baseline for the District’s December 1999 goal that STUDENT be able to name the shapes square, circle, rectangle, and triangle is contained in the present levels of performance section of that IEP, which states that STUDENT was able to name only the shape circle with eighty percent accuracy. The Hearing Officer also does not find persuasive Petitioner’s argument that four of the goals and objectives in the May 27 IEP, and four of the goals in the December 16 IEP were not objectively measurable. Each of the eight goals at issue provided a specific description of the target skill, the level of accuracy expected for achievement of the goal, and the method by which progress would be measured. For example, the May 1999 goal for identifying body parts required that STUDENT identify three body parts by touching herself and naming the parts upon an adult’s request with eighty percent accuracy by October 1999 and that she identify five body parts by the same method with ninety percent accuracy by December 1999. The goal also indicated that progress would be measured by way of teacher observations and data sheets. This goal, like the others at issue, met the IDEA’s requirement that the annual goals be “measurable.”

The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the goals and objectives at issue were appropriate under the IDEA and that the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 1999-2000 regular school year.

B. 2000 ESY

Petitioner contended that the District denied her a FAPE for the 2000 ESY by failing to identify a specific ESY placement and services for her. ESY services extend educational programming beyond the normal school year to prevent serious regression over the summer months in order to provide the child with a FAPE. Hoeft v. Tucson Unified Sch. Dist., 967 F.3d 1298, 1301 (9th Cir. 1992); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(b). California law provides that a school district is required to provide ESY programming to a child with a disability when she has unique needs that require special education and related services in excess of the regular academic year. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043. Section 3043 of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations defines such children in the following manner:

Such individuals shall have handicaps which are likely to continue indefinitely or for a prolonged period, and interruption of the pupil=s educational programming may cause regression, when coupled with limited recoupment capacity, rendering it impossible or unlikely that the pupil will attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that would otherwise be expected in view of his or her handicapping condition.

There was no dispute that STUDENT qualified for ESY services during the summer of 2000. The District determined that she was eligible for ESY services during her annual IEP meeting held on December 16, 1999 because, according to the written IEP, she required the services “to assist in maintaining [her] rate of learning.” The later IEP of June 5, 2000 indicates that the District offered ESY services but the parent declined the offer. Annette Cleveland testified that the District’s ESY offer was for the preschool SDC summer school program at Salk Elementary School, which would have been a continuation or extension of the same program STUDENT had attended during the prior regular school year. The District’s offer for the 2000 ESY did not constitute a change of placement from the program that had been offered and provided during the regular school year, and therefore did not require a notice of proposed change of placement. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District made an adequate offer for STUDENT for the 2000 ESY and did not deny her a FAPE.

C. 2000-2001 Regular School Year

With regard to the 2000-2001 regular school year, Petitioner argued that the District denied her a FAPE because (1) it should have performed an auditory or audiological evaluation for auditory processing deficits by December 2000, (2) the December 16, 1999 IEP goals and objectives were inappropriate, and (3) the December 6, 2000 IEP should have included goals to address auditory processing. (Footnote 9)

First, with regard to the need for an auditory processing evaluation, Petitioner argued that the District had more than sufficient information to warrant an auditory or audiological evaluation by December 2000. Petitioner alleged that STUDENT’s educational history was replete with problems suggestive of auditory processing issues, including difficulty following directions and appearing to become distracted. When a school district conducts an initial evaluation for special education or a reevaluation of a child with a disability, the school district is required to assess the child in all areas related to the suspected disability. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(2) and (b)(3)(iii)(C); 34 C.F.R. § 300.532(g); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56320(f), 56381(a). Areas related to a suspected disability may include health and development, vision (including low vision), hearing, motor abilities, language function, general intelligence, academic performance, communicative status, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional status. 34 C.F.R. § 300.532(g); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320.

The Hearing Officer is not persuaded that the weight of the evidence establishes that the District should have conducted an audiological evaluation any earlier than January 2001, which is when the first of four audiological evaluations was conducted by Centralia School District (Centralia) on the District’s behalf. Initially, the Hearing Officer notes that the District performed a hearing screening, which yielded normal results, as part of STUDENT’s initial evaluation for special education when she was three years old. Additionally, STUDENT’s difficulties in matters such as following directions and maintaining attention to task had been evaluated earlier and attributed to her autism and language processing delays. Further, the District’s initial audiological evaluation on January 18, 2001, the appropriateness of which was not disputed by either party or by either of the audiologists who testified, found STUDENT’s hearing to be essentially within normal limits for at least one ear and her word recognition ability to be excellent for soft conversational speech. A fluctuation in STUDENT’s hearing was not found until Centralia conducted a second audiological evaluation four months later in May 2001. This second evaluation found a mild conductive hearing loss in both ears which, according to the report of Centralia audiologist Mary Olander, could have impacted STUDENT’s ability to detect soft speech sounds or phonemes, especially in the presence of background noise. Given the foregoing information, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded that the District had an obligation to conduct further audiological evaluations during the course of the 2000-2001 regular school year, or even that the failure to identify auditory processing deficits during the 2000-2001 regular school year resulted in a loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT. The testimony of District witnesses, as supported by the written IEP goal progress reports entered into evidence, demonstrated that STUDENT was able to meet many of her IEP goals and objectives during the course of the 2000-2001 regular school year in spite of her placement in the general education program.

Second, Petitioner’s challenges to the appropriateness of the goals and objectives contained in the IEP dated December 16, 1999 were, as discussed previously, not meritorious. Finally, the Hearing Officer also finds unpersuasive Petitioner’s third contention regarding the goals and objectives contained in the IEP dated December 6, 2000. Petitioner argued that had the District conducted an audiological evaluation, it would have discovered auditory processing deficits which then should have been addressed by her IEP goals and objectives in December 2000. In light of the above finding that the District did not improperly fail to evaluate STUDENT for auditory processing deficits, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was not required to include goals to address auditory processing in STUDENT’s December 2000 annual IEP.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer determines that the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2000-2001 regular school year.

D. 2001 ESY

At the IEP meeting held on December 6, 2000, STUDENT’s IEP team agreed that she would attend the general education summer school program during the summer of 2001. According to MOTHER’s testimony, STUDENT attended the general education summer school program during the summer of 2001, as agreed, and received the services of her one-on-one aide while attending school. Unlike the other ESYs at issue, Petitioner did not contend that the District failed to identify or recommend a specific ESY placement or services for the 2001 ESY. In light of the fact that all other challenges to the IEP in effect during the 2001 ESY (i.e., the December 6, 2000 IEP) were found unpersuasive, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided STUDENT a FAPE during the 2001 ESY.

E. 2001-2002 Regular School Year

Petitioner contended that the District denied her a FAPE for the 2001-2002 regular school year because it failed to assess her in the area of auditory processing, and thereby failed to identify and address her needs in auditory processing, and failed to develop appropriate and necessary goals and objectives for her. With regard to Petitioner’s contentions regarding auditory processing, the evidence established that the District should have conducted an audiological evaluation to investigate the possibility of auditory processing deficits after October 2001. In May 2001, Ms. Olander had reported finding mild conductive hearing loss in both ears that could impact STUDENT’s ability to detect soft speech sounds (phonemes), especially when there was background noise. While the District’s triennial reevaluation of STUDENT in October 2001 included school psychologist Joan Falconer’s administration of the Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills (TAPS), a test which apparently included a subtest entitled “auditory processing,” there was no evidence presented that this single subtest on a single measure was sufficient to determine if STUDENT had auditory processing deficits that were affecting adversely her ability to benefit from her educational programming. Moreover, Ms. Falconer stated in her psychoeducational evaluation report that STUDENT did not answer correctly any of the questions on the auditory processing subtest, and that STUDENT’s auditory perception skills ranged from the borderline deficit to low average range. Finally, by letter dated February 27, 2002, STUDENT’s parents requested an independent educational evaluation (IEE) for auditory processing. (Footnote 10)

However, notwithstanding the District’s obligation to conduct an auditory processing assessment, there is no evidence that the District’s failure to conduct such an assessment denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 2001-2002 regular school year. (Footnote 11) As noted earlier, not every procedural flaw constitutes a denial of FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484. Only procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the child or seriously infringe on the parent=s opportunity to participate in the IEP process may constitute a denial of FAPE. Id. Here, there is no evidence that either occurred.

Petitioner alleged that she has an auditory processing disorder that adversely impact her learning and that the District’s failure to assess her in the area of auditory processing during the 2001-2002 regular school year resulted in the District’s inability to recognize that she had such a disorder and to address auditory processing in her IEP. The Hearing Officer disagrees. First, there is no evidence that STUDENT has an auditory processing disorder. The only witness who assessed STUDENT in the area of auditory processing was audiologist Carol Atkins, who assessed STUDENT on July 2, 2002. Ms. Atkins diagnosed STUDENT as having an auditory processing deficit “as part of her Autism Spectrum Syndrome.” The Hearing Officer finds credible, however, the testimony of audiologist Maria Abramson that Ms. Atkins’ findings are critically flawed. According to Ms. Abramson, a licensed clinical and educational audiologist in private practice, Ms. Atkins’s evaluation does not establish that STUDENT has an auditory processing disorder because Ms. Atkins failed to take into consideration STUDENT’s mid-borderline to low average cognitive ability or her significant language processing delays. In fact, Ms. Atkins testified that she had assumed that STUDENT had average cognitive skills because of her diagnosis as a high functioning autistic student, and admitted that it is critical when interpreting test findings to take into consideration a child’s handicapping conditions, including autism or developmental delay. Ms. Abramson persuasively testified that reliable literature in the field of audiology states that certain other childhood disorders, such as autism, may compound the accurate diagnosis of an auditory processing disorder. According to Ms. Abramson, it is important to know a child’s cognitive ability before testing to avoid using tests that are above the child’s cognitive level and obtaining scores tainted by the child’s developmental delays. Ms. Abramson also testified that it is important to know the extent of a child’s language processing skills to ensure that the child understands the tests. The Hearing Officer finds credible Ms. Abramson’s testimony that Ms. Atkins was unable to arrive at a differential diagnosis because the measures she used were not able to separate out auditory issues from other confounding childhood disorders, such as cognitive delays and a speech and language disorder. In other words, it was not possible for Ms. Atkins to determine with any degree of accuracy whether the results she obtained were due to an auditory processing disorder rather than delays attributable to STUDENT’s autism, below average cognitive ability, or language processing delays.

Second, the failure to implement any of Ms. Atkins’s recommendations for addressing STUDENT’s purported auditory processing disorder did not lead to a denial of educational opportunity. Ms. Atkins made three pertinent recommendations in her report: (1) continue with speech and language services, (2) conduct an occupational therapy assessment to rule out a sensory integration disorder, and (3) increase auditory processing skills using a sound therapy methodology. The District offered to continue providing STUDENT two thirty-minute speech therapy sessions per week for the 2001-2002 regular school year and, on February 19, 2002, offered to add a thirty-minute per week language group. Additionally, as will be discussed more fully later, the District’s occupational therapy assessment in November 2002 determined that STUDENT did not have a sensory integration disorder. Further, according to Ms. Abramson’s undisputed testimony, sound therapies such as the one recommended by Ms. Atkins, Samonas Sound Therapy, have not been proven to be effective in addressing auditory processing delays.

Finally, STUDENT’s IEPs for the 2001-2002 regular school year nevertheless addressed auditory processing difficulties in a number of ways. According to Ms. Atkins, goals addressing word recognition, as contained in STUDENT’s IEPs dated December 6, 2000 and October 25, 2001, improve listening skills. Also, her IEPs included regular program modifications such as modeled instructions, repeated directions, and visual cues. Further, the IEPs called for four hours of aide support per day to provide instructional assistance to address, among other things, difficulties in following directions and maintaining attention to task.

Petitioner’s final contention is that the District denied her a FAPE by failing to provide her appropriate and necessary goals and objectives, Petitioner argued that specific goals in her IEPs dated October 25, 2001 and February 19, 2002 lacked adequate baselines or were not objectively measurable. Petitioner also alleged that the District should have included IEP goals to address auditory memory, speech rate, and auditory processing. The Hearing Officer is not persuaded that any deficits in the District’s proposed goals and objectives denied STUDENT a FAPE. Contrary to Petitioner’s assertion, the goal in the October 25 IEP for her to increase her sight word vocabulary was objectively measurable. The goal indicated the number of sight words from the Sitton, Fry word list that STUDENT was expected to identify and the expected degree of accuracy. Additionally, her pragmatics goals in the February 19 IEP had sufficient baselines contained within the IEP and were objectively measurable because they specified the particular skills expected out of a set number of trials. Lastly, program specialist Cherie Bauer, who has bachelor’s and master’s degrees in speech pathology and a restricted speech credential, testified that the October IEP contained articulation goals that addressed both auditory memory and speech rate.

In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 regular school year.

F. 2002 ESY

During the 2002 ESY, STUDENT attended both three-week general education summer school sessions at Baden Powell with aide support and received ongoing speech and language therapy. Petitioner argued that the District denied her a FAPE for the 2002 ESY because it failed to include in either the October 2001 or February 2002 IEP a recommendation for specific ESY services. The evidence does not support Petitioner’s argument. Both the February 19 and April 26, 2002 IEP addendums contain a recommendation for general education summer school with ongoing speech services. Further, by letter dated June 30, 2002, principal Trudy Cunningham confirmed with the parents that STUDENT would have a place in both general education summer school sessions and that she would be provided the assistance of her special needs assistant during both sessions. Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided the parents sufficient written notification of its offer of services for the 2002 ESY and did not deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002 ESY.

G. 2002-2003 Regular School Year (1) beginning of the 2002-2003 regular school year to April 8, 2003 (Footnote 12)

With regard to the 2002-2003 regular school year, Petitioner contended that the District denied her a FAPE by (1) failing to assess her in all areas of suspected disability, (2) failing to address or review at an IEP meeting the findings and recommendations of the audiological and psychoeducational IEEs obtained by her parents in July and August 2002, (3) failing to have qualified persons present at an IEP meeting to interpret and explain the educational implications of the IEEs’ findings and recommendations, and (4) failing to develop appropriate and necessary IEP goals and objectives for her. Each argument will be addressed in turn.

First, Petitioner argued that the District should have assessed her in the areas of auditory processing, occupational therapy (OT), and phonemic awareness and that its failure to assess in these areas resulted in an inability to identify and address her needs in these areas. As with the prior school year, the Hearing Officer finds that there was sufficient information available to the District to put it on notice that STUDENT should have been evaluated in the area of auditory processing. Additionally, the evidence discloses that the District received a copy of Ms. Atkins’ report in November 2002, which put it on notice that an independent assessor had determined that STUDENT had an auditory processing disorder. However, as with the 2001-2002 regular school year and for the same reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to conduct an auditory processing assessment did not result in lost educational opportunity for STUDENT. Briefly, there is no persuasive evidence that STUDENT had an auditory processing disorder that adversely affected her ability to learn or that any failure to implement any of Ms. Atkins’ recommendations for addressing the purported auditory processing disorder denied STUDENT educational opportunity. Additionally, STUDENT’s IEPs for the 2002-2003 regular school year addressed auditory processing concerns in other ways, including through the support of an instructional assistant, regular program modifications such as repeated directions and visual cues, and goals to address word recognition and phonemic awareness.

Petitioner’s argument that the District should have conducted an OT evaluation rests on the fact that both Ms. Atkins and Dr. Patterson recommended an OT evaluation to determine if STUDENT had sensory integration deficits. SELPA OT and physical therapy coordinator Patricia Polcyn conducted an OT evaluation on the District’s behalf on November 26, 2002, but Petitioner contended that Ms. Polcyn’s OT evaluation was untimely and inappropriate. Given the lack of persuasive evidence that the District received a copy of the IEEs prior to November 2002, the Hearing Officer does not agree that the OT evaluation was untimely. Additionally, Ms. Polcyn’s testimony established that she conducted an appropriate school-based OT evaluation, and determined that STUDENT was processing sensory information sufficiently for learning in the educational environment and did not require OT intervention to benefit from her educational programming. Ms. Polcyn testified that she is a fully qualified and licensed occupational therapist experienced in evaluating students’ sensory integration needs. Also, the evidence disclosed that Ms. Polcyn conducted an appropriate evaluation of STUDENT’s school-based OT needs using appropriate measures. While Petitioner offered the testimony of private occupational therapist Jerry Lindquist, Ph.D., to dispute the appropriateness of Ms. Polcyn’s evaluation, Dr. Lindquist’s testimony did not establish that Ms. Polcyn’s evaluation was inappropriate or that STUDENT had sensory integration deficits that impacted her ability to benefit from her instruction. Dr. Lindquist confirmed that the measures used by Ms. Polcyn, the Short Sensory Profile (SSP) and the School Functional Assessment (SFA), are assessment measures typically used by occupational therapists for school-based OT evaluations. Although Dr. Lindquist criticized Ms. Polcyn’s use of the SSP rather than the Sensory Profile, his testimony revealed that he had limited familiarity with the SSP. Further, the Hearing Officer was not persuaded that the use of the SSP and SFA, instead of the Sensory Integration & Praxis Test (SIPT), was inappropriate in light of STUDENT’s delays. Ms. Polcyn testified that she is certificated in the administration and interpretation of the SIPT, but that she chose to use the SSP and SFA so she could obtain findings about STUDENT’s ability to function in a school setting, rather than in a one-on-one testing situation. Ms. Polcyn also persuasively testified that the SIPT is not appropriate for children like STUDENT who do not process language very well.

Lastly, Petitioner alleged that the District should have conducted an evaluation in phonemic awareness because of the IEE recommendations for specific Lindamood-Bell (LMB) services, which addresses phonemic awareness. Petitioner stated that she had no dispute with the appropriateness of the reading evaluation eventually performed on the District’s behalf by SELPA program specialist Cindy Hoffman in March 2003, but that the evaluation should have been performed earlier. Initially, the Hearing Officer notes that Ms. Atkins did not recommend the provision of LMB services and that psychologist Robert Patterson, Psy.D., recommended the A.D.D. program from LMB as only one of a number of possible “multisensory method[s] of teaching reading and written language” to STUDENT. Furthermore, neither evaluator recommended that the District conduct an evaluation in phonemic awareness in their written reports or testified that such an evaluation had been necessary. In fact, Dr. Patterson testified that at the time of his testing STUDENT’s achievement was commensurate with her cognitive ability and that his results showed that phonemic awareness was a strength for her. In short, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded that the District failed to assess STUDENT in any area of suspected disability for the 2002-2003 regular school year.

With regard to Petitioner’s second and third claims, that the District denied her a FAPE by failing to address or review at an IEP meeting the findings and recommendations of the IEEs or to have persons present to interpret the IEEs’ findings, the Hearing Officer notes that if parents obtain an IEE at private expense, the results of the evaluation must be “considered” by the school district “in any decision made with respect to the provision of FAPE to the child.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(c)(1); see also Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(c). However, contrary to Petitioner’s assertion, a careful reading of the federal and State laws reveals no provision that requires a school district to “consider” or review an IEE at an IEP meeting. (Footnote 13) The District’s special education director, Annette Cleveland, testified that the IEEs by Ms. Atkins and Dr. Patterson were reviewed and considered by District members of STUDENT’s IEPT and other District staff, including school psychologist Joan Faulkner, the speech and language pathologist (SLP), the resource specialist, and program specialist Cherie Bauer. Ms. Cleveland testified that District staff felt that the IEEs’ findings were commensurate with those previously obtained through District evaluations. The Hearing Officer finds that the District adequately “considered” the IEEs as required by federal and State law. In fact, District IEPT members later referenced Dr. Patterson’s findings regarding STUDENT’s cognitive functioning when evaluating her performance on the reading assessment at the IEP meeting held on April 8, 2003.

Moreover, the Hearing Officer does not agree with Petitioner that the District denied her a FAPE by improperly failing to identify and address the specific educational needs and the recommendations contained in the IEEs. As noted earlier, Ms. Atkins’ evaluation did not establish that STUDENT has an auditory processing disorder and, in any event, the District’s failure to implement any of her recommendations did not deny STUDENT a FAPE. Additionally, Dr. Patterson’s report included only the following four recommendations: (a) that she should be seen by an occupational therapist because she appeared to be having sensory integration and processing issues; (b) that she be provided very specific social skills training involving specific teaching of nonverbal communication and verbal communication; (c) that she receive ongoing speech and language therapy focusing on expressive and pragmatic language therapy; and (d) that she would benefit from a multisensory method of teaching reading and writing such as Project Read, Slingerland, Orton-Gillingham, or the A.D.D. Program from LMB. (Footnote 14) As mentioned previously, Ms. Polcyn conducted an OT evaluation in November 2002 and determined that STUDENT had no sensory integration or processing issues in the school environment that required OT intervention. Dr. Patterson’s second and third recommendations to develop socialization and communication skills had been addressed already by the District in February 2002, following SELPA program specialist Glenda McHale’s evaluation. At that time, the District offered to add to STUDENT’s program goals to address pragmatic language, communication, and socialization skills; a thirty-minute language group under the guidance of the SLP one time per week to facilitate implementation of the foregoing goals; one hour per month of services by the SELPA autism specialist to provide training and ongoing consultation to school staff; one-hour planning meetings per month to monitor progress and ensure consistency in her program; and continued aide support to facilitate socialization opportunities, among other things. At the annual IEP review on October 24, 2002, the District offered to continue with the foregoing social skills training and to add one more weekly thirty-minute pullout speech therapy session (for a total of three thirty-minute pullout speech sessions per week), as well as proposed new goals in the areas of pragmatics, expressive language/communication, and socialization. Lastly, Dr. Patterson’s fourth recommendation was only a suggestion that STUDENT would benefit from a multisensory teaching method for reading and written language. Dr. Patterson’s report noted, however, that during his evaluation STUDENT had performed “on the cusp between low average and average functioning” in reading and written expression, commensurate with her cognitive ability. (Footnote 15) Consequently, given the information available at the time, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was not obligated to provide STUDENT a multisensory teaching method to address reading and written expression.

Finally, Petitioner’s fourth contention, that the District denied her a FAPE by failing to develop appropriate and necessary goals and objectives, also was not supported by the evidence. Petitioner argued that the District’s proposed goals were inappropriate because they failed to address auditory processing, sensory integration, and phonemic awareness; the pragmatics goals in the February 2002 IEP lacked baselines and were not objectively measurable; and the majority of the goals in the October 2002 IEP lacked baselines. Initially, as noted earlier, there is no evidence that STUDENT had educational needs in the areas of auditory processing and sensory integration that the District was required to address in her IEP during the 2002-2003 regular school year. As for phonemic awareness, Dr. Patterson’s report indicated that STUDENT had phonemic awareness skills commensurate with her ability. (Footnote 16) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds Petitioner’s claim that the District’s goals failed to address all her areas of need to be without merit. Next, the pragmatics goals in the February 2002 IEP previously have been determined to contain sufficient baselines and to be objectively measurable. As for Petitioner’s final challenge to the October 2002 IEP goals, the Hearing Officer notes that almost all of the goals contained information about STUDENT’s then-present level of performance in the area being addressed by the goal and that the present levels of performance page contained additional information about the areas being addressed. The IDEA requires nothing more.

In short, the Hearing Officer finds unpersuasive Petitioner’s contention that the District denied her a FAPE from the beginning of the 2002-2003 regular school year to at least April 8, 2003 (2) April 8, 2003 to the end of the 2002-2003 regular school year

On April 8, 2003, the District held an IEP addendum meeting to review the reading evaluation completed by SELPA program specialist Cindy Hoffman on March 25, 2003. (Footnote 17) Ms. Hoffman found that STUDENT’s reading skills were scattered between the pre-kindergarten and first-grade levels (STUDENT was in the second semester of her second-grade year at the time) and that her rate of reading was slow and labored. Ms. Hoffman stated in her report that STUDENT required a multisensory reading program to provide the specific skills she required to remediate her deficits in reading, such as Reading Mastery Fast Cycle, Project Read, the LMB Lips Program, or Touch Phonics. At the April 8 IEP meeting, the District proposed to change STUDENT’s placement to the nonsevere special day class (NS-SDC) at Schweitzer Elementary School (Schweitzer) taught by Deborah Zimmerman, with four hours per day of aide support to facilitate the transition. The District also offered to continue with the related services then in place (i.e., one thirty-minute language group per week, three thirty-minute speech therapy sessions per week, and one sixty-minute team planning meeting per month) and the goals and objectives developed at the annual review in October 2002, as well as proposed four additional goals to address reading, phonemic awareness, and reading comprehension. Lastly, the District proposed to increase the amount of monthly autism support for training and consultation purposes to ten hours per month.

Petitioner argued that the District’s April 8 proposal did not offer her a FAPE because (1) the District failed to take into consideration the findings and recommendations of the IEEs, as well as those of District and SELPA evaluators, and (2) it failed to include goals to address reading. Specifically, Petitioner contended that the District’s proposal was inappropriate because it failed to include an offer for LMB instruction, or one of the other multisensory methods identified by Dr. Patterson and Ms. Hoffman. Petitioner also contended that the proposal was inappropriate because it failed to provide for integration in the general education program for modeling opportunities or, in other words, that the proposed placement was not in the least restrictive environment (LRE). Petitioner argued that she requires placement for roughly half a school day in the general education program and half the day in an intensive program that provides a multisensory approach to teaching reading and writing.

There is no dispute that STUDENT presently requires a multisensory approach to teaching reading and written language to remediate her delays in those areas. The testimony of NS-SDC teacher Deborah Zimmerman established that the proposed placement in her classroom would have provided STUDENT with a multisensory approach to learning reading and written expression, consistent with the recommendations of Dr. Patterson and Ms. Hoffman. Ms. Zimmerman has been a special education teacher for thirty-three years and, prior to that, was an SLP. She has a bachelor’s degree in hearing and speech sciences, a master’s degree in speech pathology, a clear teaching credential that allows her to teach severely handicapped children, and a life credential in restricted special education for grades kindergarten through twelve, which indicates that she’s a speech and language specialist. Ms. Zimmerman testified that both she and her classroom aide are trained in Reading Mastery Fast Cycle, which was recommended by Ms. Hoffman, as well as a variety of other instructional methodologies including LMB. Ms. Hoffman testified that Ms. Zimmerman has attended many of her reading workshops and that she has observed Ms. Zimmerman’s classroom over many years. Ms. Hoffman testified that the particular combination of methodologies Ms. Zimmerman uses in her classroom would have perfectly addressed STUDENT’s needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed placement was designed to address STUDENT’s need for a multisensory approach to reading and written expression, consistent with the recommendations of the evaluators.

The District’s proposed placement was not, however, designed to address STUDENT’s need for modeling opportunities. SELPA program specialist and autism consultant Glenda McHale determined in her February 2002 report that STUDENT “clearly benefits from peer modeling and relies on observation for cues regarding expectations for her own behavior, performance, and learning.” This observation was echoed by District witnesses who have worked with STUDENT in the school setting, including Ms. Cleveland. Ms. Cleveland testified that STUDENT benefits from modeling to develop her skills in socialization, pragmatics, language, and other areas. Ms. Cleveland also testified that one of the reasons STUDENT was placed initially in the general education program was to provide her with modeling opportunities and that she was able to make progress in the general education setting. Both parties agree that STUDENT’s present needs require a more restrictive setting because she requires more intensive academic instruction to close the growing gap between her achievement and that of her same-age peers. However, she also requires some mainstreaming opportunities for purposes of modeling. The Hearing Officer agrees with Petitioner that a full-day placement in the NS-SDC—which consisted of only children with disabilities with similar needs in language, socialization, and communication—did not offer appropriate modeling opportunities for STUDENT.

Finally, the Hearing Officer does not find persuasive Petitioner’s contention that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE because it failed to include reading goals in the April 2003 IEP. The April 2003 IEP included four additional proposed goals to address reading, reading comprehension, and phonemic awareness.

In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to establish that the placement it proposed for the period April 8, 2003 to the conclusion of the 2002-2003 regular school year constituted a FAPE for STUDENT. The District’s proposed placement failed to provide sufficient integration in the general education program. In all other respects, however, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer constituted a FAPE for STUDENT.

H. 2003 ESY

Petitioner contended that the District denied her a FAPE for the 2003 ESY because it failed to identify a specific ESY placement and services for her in the October 24, 2002 annual IEP. Contrary to Petitioner’s assertion, the October 2002 IEP did include a specific ESY offer, placement in the general education summer school program with ongoing speech therapy services. More importantly, however, the April 8, 2003 IEP addendum contained a revised and even more specific ESY offer: placement in the five-week summer reading program provided within the Los Alamitos School District (Los Alamitos). Both Ms. Cleveland and Ms. Hoffman testified that the Los Alamitos summer reading program provides three LMB programs—Lips, Visualizing & Verbalizing, and Seeing Stars. STUDENT’s parents did not consent to the Los Alamitos summer program, and STUDENT did not receive services from the District during the 2003 ESY.

There is no dispute that the Los Alamitos summer reading program would have been appropriate for STUDENT for the 2003 ESY. In fact, MOTHER testified that if she had understood that the Los Alamitos program being offered used LMB strategies, she would have consented to implementation of the program for the 2003 ESY. Petitioner argues in her closing brief that the April 8 offer was insufficient because it failed to specify that the proposed Los Alamitos program consisted of LMB methodologies. The Hearing Officer is not persuaded by this argument. It is evident that there was some confusion at the April 8 IEP meeting on the parents’ part about the specific Los Alamitos program being offered. The IEP document makes clear, however, that the District’s offer is the five-week Los Alamitos summer reading program and describes the recent visit that MOTHER and Ms. Cleveland had made to the Los Alamitos clinic “that utilizes Lindamood-Bell program.” The Hearing Officer finds that the District properly discharged its duty to make a sufficiently detailed written offer of placement for STUDENT for the 2003 ESY. (Footnote 18)

Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003 ESY.

I. Beginning of the 2003-2004 Regular School Year to October 15, 2003

At the beginning of the 2003-2004 regular school year, the District offered the same placement as that proposed on April 8, 2003, except insofar as the offer was modified through a letter from Ms. Cleveland dated July 9, 2003. The only modification was that the District offered to provide STUDENT sixty-five minutes per day in the general education program, with the remainder of the day to be spent in the NS-SDC. Because the District’s offer remained essentially the same as that made on April 8, 2003, the Hearing Officer will not revisit the same challenges advanced by Petitioner except with respect to the modification proposed in July 2003.

The District presented no persuasive evidence that STUDENT required placement in the NS-SDC for the entire school day except for sixty-five minutes. In fact, there was no evidence as to how the sixty-five minutes was determined or what factors determined that sixty-five minutes of participation in the general education program was appropriate for STUDENT. As mentioned previously, the IDEA requires that a child with a disability be educated in the LRE. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A). In other words, to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities are to be educated with children who are not disabled and special classes, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular educational environment, is to occur only when the nature or severity of the child’s disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. Id. Because there was no indication that STUDENT cannot be educated with her nondisabled peers for more than sixty-five minutes per day, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to establish the appropriateness of the placement it proposed for STUDENT for the beginning of the 2003-2004 regular school year to October 15, 2003.

* * * *

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE from October 29, 1999 to April 7, 2003 and for the 2003 ESY. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE from April 8, 2003 to the conclusion of the 2002-2003 regular school year and from the beginning of the 2003-2004 regular school year to October 15, 2003.

ISSUE NO. 2: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the independent educational evaluations they procured from audiologist Carol Atkins and psychologist Robert Patterson, Psy.D., in 2002?

Petitioner argues that her parents are entitled to reimbursement for the two independent educational evaluations (IEEs) they obtained from audiologist Carol Atkins and psychologist Robert Patterson, Psy.D., in July and August 2002, respectively. A parent may obtain an IEE performed by a qualified specialist at public expense if the parent disagrees with an evaluation obtained by the educational agency, and the educational agency is unable to show at a due process hearing that its evaluation was appropriate. 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b). If the decision in a due process hearing is that the school district’s evaluation was appropriate, parents still have the right to an IEE but not at public expense. 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b)(3); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b). Ms. Atkins’ testimony established that she was qualified to perform an audiometric evaluation of STUDENT in July 2002. For example, she testified that she is a licensed certified clinical audiologist experienced in assessing students to determine the existence of auditory issues. Additionally, the Hearing Officer determined above that the District should have conducted an audiology evaluation to determine the existence of auditory processing deficits by at least November 2001. Further, the parents requested in writing an auditory processing evaluation by letter dated February 27, 2002, which indicated their disagreement with the fact that the District had not conducted such an evaluation. As program specialist Cherie Bauer confirmed during her testimony, the District has never conducted an audiological evaluation to address auditory processing issues for STUDENT. Therefore, because the District was unable to prove at hearing that its evaluations were appropriate or that it otherwise was not required to perform an auditory processing assessment, the parents are entitled to reimbursement for expenses related to their procurement of the evaluation from Ms. Atkins in July 2002.

However, the Hearing Officer notes that she was not persuaded that Ms. Atkins was able to obtain valid findings with regard to whether STUDENT has auditory processing issues that are negatively impacting her ability to benefit from her instructional programming. At a minimum, Ms. Atkins’ evaluation raised questions that the District should have investigated further to ensure that STUDENT’s needs are addressed properly in her educational program. Because the District has not yet investigated further, the Hearing Officer finds that the District must present the parents with a proposed assessment plan so that it may conduct an evaluation to determine whether STUDENT has auditory processing deficits that negatively impact her learning.

With regard to the psychoeducational evaluation conducted by Dr. Patterson in August 2002, the Hearing Officer notes that the parents requested a complete psychological educational evaluation, including ability testing, through their letter dated February 27, 2002. Shortly thereafter, on March 5, the District forwarded to the parents a proposed assessment plan to assess STUDENT in the area of cognition, among others. The parents did not provide consent for the District to perform a cognitive evaluation of STUDENT. The comments to the federal regulations provide useful guidance in such a situation: “The right of a parent to obtain an IEE is triggered if the parent disagrees with a public initiated evaluation. Therefore, if a parent refuses to consent to a proposed public evaluation in the first place, then an IEE at public expense would not be available since there would be no public evaluation with which the parent can disagree.” 34 C.F.R. Part 300, Attachment 1, § 300.502. In this case, the parents refused permission for the District to conduct even the cognitive portion of a psychoeducational evaluation. Consequently, the parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the psychoeducational evaluation performed by Dr. Patterson in August 2002.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the parents are entitled to reimbursement for the audiometric evaluation performed by Ms. Atkins on July 2, 2002, but not for the psychoeducational evaluation performed by Dr. Patterson in August 2002. Within thirty calendar days of receipt of proof of payment, the District shall reimburse the parents for the audiometric evaluation conducted by Ms. Akins on July 2, 2002. The Hearing Officer also finds that the District is obligated to conduct an evaluation to determine if STUDENT has auditory processing deficits that negatively impact her ability to benefit from her education. Within fifteen calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall present to the parents a proposed assessment plan for that purpose and, after receiving the parents’ consent, shall conduct an auditory processing evaluation in compliance with federal and State laws.

ISSUE NO. 3: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for any denials of FAPE by the District from October 29, 1999 to October 15, 2003?

Based on the principle set forth in Burlington, supra, that a child with a disability is entitled to “appropriate” relief when a school district fails to provide a FAPE, federal courts have held that compensatory education is a form of equitable relief which may be granted for the denial of appropriate special education services to help overcome lost educational opportunity. See, e.g., Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist., 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). Compensatory education does not, however, necessarily involve an obligation to provide day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity or time missed. Id. at 1497. The purpose of compensatory education is to “ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of IDEA.” Id.

The Hearing Officer determined above that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE only for the following discrete time periods: April 8, 2003 to the end of the 2002-2003 regular school year; and the beginning of the 2003-2004 regular school year to October 15, 2003. Petitioner requested the provision of LMB services to compensate for past denials of FAPE, among other things. Both Dr. Patterson and Ms. Hoffman recommended LMB services to address STUDENT’s deficits in reading and written language. Given the District’s failure to show that it offered STUDENT a FAPE for the foregoing time periods and the undisputed evidence that an LMB program would address STUDENT’s significant needs in reading and written language, the Hearing Officer determines it is appropriate to award some LMB services to redress the District’s denial of FAPE. Unless the parties agree otherwise, during the summer of 2004, the District shall fund at least twelve weeks of clinic-based LMB instruction, including related transportation. The District also shall fund an LMB evaluation, if such is deemed necessary by the LMB clinic prior to the provision of services.

ISSUE NO. 4: Did the District’s actions result in a denial of STUDENT’s rights arising under Section 1983 of Title 42 of the United States Code and under Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act?

The Hearing Office has jurisdiction over claims involving children with disabilities under the IDEA and State special education law in situations where (1) there is a proposal to initiate or change the identification, assessment, or educational placement of the child or the provision of a FAPE to the child; (2) where there is a refusal to initiate or change the identification, assessment, or educational placement of the child or the provision of a FAPE to the child; and (3) where the parent refuses to consent to an assessment of the child. Cal. Educ. Code § 56501(a). The Hearing Office’s jurisdiction to hear these disputes arises from a grant of power from the California State Department of Education pursuant to California Education Code Section 56504.5. The Hearing Office does not, however, have jurisdiction over claims arising under other federal statutes, such as the Civil Rights Act or the Rehabilitation Act. The Hearing Office has consistently held so in a long line of cases. See, e.g., STUDENT v. Hacienda-La Puente Unified Sch. Dist. (SN1105-97) 27 IDELR 885 (December 9, 1997).

Consequently, because the Hearing Office lacks jurisdiction over claims arising under either Section 1983 of Title 42 of the United States Code or Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act, the Hearing Officer declines to make any findings as to whether the District’s actions resulted in a denial of STUDENT’s rights under these Acts.

ORDER

1. Within fifteen calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall present to the parents an assessment plan that proposes an evaluation to determine if STUDENT has auditory processing deficits that negatively impact her ability to benefit from her education. After receipt of the parents’ consent, the District shall conduct an auditory processing evaluation in compliance with federal and State laws.

2. Within thirty calendar days of receipt of proof of payment, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the audiometric evaluation conducted by Ms. Akins on July 2, 2002.

3. Unless the parties agree otherwise, during the summer of 2004, the District shall provide compensatory education to STUDENT by funding at least twelve weeks of clinic-based LMB instruction for her, including related transportation. The District also shall fund an LMB evaluation, if such is deemed necessary by the LMB clinic prior to the provision of services.

4. Petitioner’s remaining requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute:

1. Did the District commit procedural and substantive violations of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) that have resulted in denials of a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to STUDENT from October 29, 1999 to October 15, 2003 during the 1999-2000, 2000-2001, 2001-2002, 2002-2003, and 2003-2004 school years, including extended school years (ESYs)? The District prevailed on this issue with respect to the period October 29, 1999 to April 7, 2003 and for the 2003 ESY. Petitioner prevailed on this issue with respect to the period April 8, 2003 to the conclusion of the 2002-2003 regular school year, and from the beginning of the 2003-2004 regular school year to October 15, 2003.

2. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the independent educational evaluations they procured from audiologist Carol Atkins and psychologist Robert Patterson, Psy.D., in 2002? Petitioner prevailed on this issue with regard to Ms. Atkins’ evaluation, and the District prevailed on this issue with regard to Dr. Patterson’s evaluation.

3. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for any denials of FAPE by the District from October 29, 1999 to October 15, 2003? The District substantially prevailed on this issue because Petitioner was found entitled to compensatory education only to redress the denial of FAPE for the period April 8, 2003 to the conclusion of the 2002-2003 regular school year, and from the beginning of the 2003-2004 regular school year to October 15, 2003.

4. Did the District’s actions result in a denial of STUDENT’s rights arising under Section 1983 of Title 42 of the United States Code and under Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act? The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Date: January 21, 2004 Hee C. Kim, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

A month later, Perry Lubens, M.D., a private pediatric neurologist, diagnosed STUDENT with high functioning autism (HFA) spectrum disorder.

2 There is no dispute that the District provided all necessary makeup speech therapy sessions that school year.

3 The school psychologist later provided an addendum to her multidisciplinary evaluation report on January 28, 2002, to report assessment results that had not been available by October 2001.

4 According to a letter dated December 3, 2001 from a Discovery staff member, Regina Fournier, STUDENT had been enrolled in the Expressways to Learning program (Expressways) at Discovery for three years. Ms. Fournier described Expressways as a computer program designed to remediate or accelerate a student in math or reading. According to a letter from Anne Honeybourne, a teacher at Discovery, STUDENT’s two hours per day at Discovery included a kindergarten class from 12:30 to 1:30 p.m., where she participated in social studies, science, and music lessons and Bible study.

5 The assistive technology evaluation was completed on July 25, 2002, by the Assistive Technology Exchange Center (ATEC). ATEC did not recommend the use of any assistive technology devices, but noted that STUDENT had attended well to tasks presented using the computer and had appeared motivated to use the computer throughout the evaluation session. ATEC suggested that STUDENT might benefit from the use of a computer with appropriate educational software to support the school curriculum.

6 STUDENT’s IEPT met again on October 16, 2003. However, the IEP developed on that date was not entered into evidence and no claims arising after October 15, 2003, are at issue in these proceedings.

7 “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, provided at no cost to parents, that meets the unique needs of the child. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. “Related service” means transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(z).

8 As Petitioner was informed at the commencement of the hearing in this matter, in due consideration of both parties’ due process rights, this Decision will address only those specific allegations raised by Petitioner prior to the taking of evidence. Petitioner clarified her specific allegations with Hearing Officer John Andersen during an in-depth discussion of the issues on September 2, 2003. At no point thereafter did Petitioner move to modify or amend her list of specific allegations.

9Audiologist Carol Atkins testified that the phrase “auditory processing” refers to how people process sound, and that what used to be known as a “central auditory processing disorder” has recently become known simply as an “auditory processing disorder.” She described the difference between the terms “auditory processing disorder” and “central auditory processing disorder” as an anatomical one that, for purposes of this Decision, is unnecessary. This Decision will use the term “auditory processing” exclusively for ease of reference.

10 The District refused the parents’ request for an auditory processing assessment through a letter from Ms. Cleveland dated March 13, 2002, but there is no evidence that the District conducted an adequate review of existing evaluation data before refusing the parents’ request. When parents request a reevaluation of a child with a disability, unless the request is for a reevaluation to determine if the child continues to be a child with a disability, the school district may refuse the parents’ request but only after the IEP team (IEPT) and other qualified professionals, as appropriate, review the child’s existing evaluation data and input from the parents. 34 C.F.R. § 300.533; Cal. Educ. Code § 56381. Although the review of existing data does not require a meeting (34 C.F.R. § 300.533(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(g)), it does require the inclusion of the child’s parents, who are members of the IEPT, in the review of existing data and the consideration of the parents’ input into whether the requested evaluation is necessary to determine, among other things, the child’s educational needs. 34 C.F.R. § 300.533(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(a). The District presented no evidence that the parents were included in the group reviewing existing data or that their input was sought in making the determination of whether an auditory processing evaluation was necessary.

11 Ms. Olander conducted a fourth audiological evaluation of STUDENT on the District’s behalf on April 25, 2002. Ms. Olander reported that STUDENT’s scores on the pure tone test and tympanometry were consistent with normal hearing sensitivity in both ears. Audiologist Carol Atkins testified that because Ms. Olander did not test STUDENT below fifteen DDHL, the testing constituted a screening only. There was no dispute that Ms. Olander’s evaluation did not determine whether STUDENT had an auditory processing disorder

12 At the beginning of the 2002-2003 regular school year, the District’s offer for STUDENT was for continued placement in the general education program at her home school, Baden Powell, with ongoing special education support including RSP services, speech and language therapy, and aide support. At an IEP addendum meeting on April 8, 2003, the District proposed to change STUDENT’s placement to the nonsevere special day class at Schweitzer Elementary School with special education support. Because the two placements require different analyses with regard to their appropriateness for STUDENT, they will be analyzed separately to avoid confusion

13 An exception may exist when the IEPT is required to revise the IEP in conjunction with a review of existing evaluation data as part of an initial evaluation or reevaluation. See 34 C.F.R. §§ 300.343(c)(2)(iii), 300.533(a)(1). However, there is no dispute that the IEEs were not presented as part of an initial evaluation or of a reevaluation required by Part B of the IDEA.

14 While Petitioner argued in her closing brief that one of Dr. Patterson’s recommendations addressed the role an instructional assistant (IA) should play in STUDENT’s educational program, the Hearing Officer notes that Dr. Patterson’s written report did not address the IA’s role and that his IA recommendations were first provided to the District during the course of his testimony at hearing.

15 While Dr. Patterson testified that STUDENT’s parents attributed STUDENT’s academic progress to instruction she had received at Discovery Christian School (Discovery), Dr. Patterson was unaware of how little instruction STUDENT had received from Discovery by August 2002. In fact, apart from a six-week period in December 2001 when STUDENT’s parents removed her from school two hours early to attend Discovery in the afternoons, the evidence established that STUDENT had received the majority of her instruction in the public school setting since at least the end of her kindergarten year.

16 On page 27 of his report, Dr. Patterson stated the following with respect to STUDENT’s phonemic awareness:

Phonemic awareness is based upon the Sound Blending and Incomplete Words Subtests [of the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement – Third Edition] and a considerable body of research has documented that there is a relationship between poor phonological awareness and delayed literacy development, which does not appear to be the case with STUDENT. STUDENT is performing in overall phonemic awareness with a standard score of 86, at the 18th percentile, getting 74 percent of the 90 percent an average student would get correct. Overall strategies that are being used with her at the present time appear to be assisting in the development of the ability to auditorially process language sounds or phonemes.

17. Petitioner specifically stated that she was not challenging the appropriateness of this assessment or that it adequately assessed her phonemic awareness skills.

18. To support her position, Petitioner also cited in her closing brief the testimony of District special education coordinator, John Reid, who transcribed the discussion at the IEP meeting, that he was not aware from the discussion at the IEP meeting that the proposed Los Alamitos summer reading program utilized LMB strategies. Unlike MOTHER, however, Mr. Reid had not just recently visited the Los Alamitos program and was not aware that the Los Alamitos clinic used LMB strategies.