California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 18, 2002
Student v. Oxnard Union High School District
SEHO Case No. SN 2403-01 · Hearing Officer Trevor Skarda
Oxnard Union High School District wrongly found a depressed student ineligible and must reimburse her residential placement costs after December 2000.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The student's mother filed for due process against Oxnard Union High School District. The student had a long history of depression. In fall 2000, her 11th-grade year, she was hospitalized three times, earned no credits at Camarillo High School, and was then placed by her mother at Cross Creek Manor, a residential program in Utah. A District school psychologist, Judy Greycloud, assessed her there. At a December 5, 2000 IEP meeting, the team found her not eligible as emotionally disturbed.
Hearing Officer Trevor Skarda disagreed. He found that she showed a pervasive mood of depression to a marked degree and over a long period. Applying a "significant impact" standard, he found that her depression adversely affected her educational performance because she could not attend school and earned no credits. She also needed services beyond a modified regular program. The District therefore denied her a FAPE from December 5, 2000.
The District won the other claims. A failing grade and absences in ninth grade did not trigger child find. The District's assessment was appropriate, so the parent's private assessment by Dr. Marilyn Evenson was not reimbursed. Cross Creek and its Browning Academy met her academic and emotional needs. The District must reimburse placement costs after December 5, 2000, and the October 2000 transport, but not earlier costs or parent seminars. Compensatory education was denied. An IEP team must develop a FAPE program within 30 days.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO handled emotional disturbance eligibility for a student whose grades had improved before a crisis. It looked at the student's condition when the team met, not at earlier periods of remission. Lost attendance and credits counted as an adverse effect on educational performance, and reimbursement began only from the date FAPE was denied.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedEligibility
Issue 1. Was Student eligible for special education from December 5, 2000, to the present because of an emotional disturbance?
Student showed a pervasive mood of depression to a marked degree and over a long period. It significantly harmed her educational performance in 11th grade, when she earned no credits at her school. She needed services beyond a modified regular program, so the IEP team was wrong to find her ineligible on December 5, 2000.
- District prevailedChild find
Issue 2. During the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years, did the District meet its obligation to seek and serve Student, i.e., to identify her alleged disability and to provide a program to address her needs?
One failing grade and frequent absences in ninth grade did not put the District on notice of a disability. The mother's uncorroborated testimony about talking to a counselor was given no weight, so there was no child find violation.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 3. Is Mother entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the assessment conducted by Marilyn M. Evenson, Ph.D., in October 2001?
The school psychologist's November 2000 assessment was appropriate even though she did not interview the father. In any event, the private assessment was not shown to have been obtained because the parent disagreed with the District's assessment.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4. Is Mother entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the costs of the Cross Creek Manor placement from October 2000 through the date of this decision, including expenses incurred for tuition, travel, parent training services, and related costs?
Cross Creek met Student's academic and emotional needs, so the parent gets reimbursement for costs after December 5, 2000, plus the October 2000 transport. Costs before December 5, 2000, and parent-education seminar costs are denied.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 5. Is Student entitled to compensatory education services?
Compensatory education was denied because the parent's private placement appropriately met Student's needs during the period when FAPE was denied.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days after receiving proof, the District must reimburse the mother for (1) the cost of transporting Student to Cross Creek in October 2000 and (2) all costs related to the Cross Creek placement incurred after December 5, 2000, up to the date of the decision. This includes tuition, therapy by Brent Hall, incidentals, uniforms, and parent transportation and lodging for visits. It excludes Dr. Seely's assessment and parent-education costs. No dollar amount was stated.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 30 calendar days of the decision, the IEP team must develop a program, consistent with the decision, that is designed to provide Student a FAPE.
Key authorities
School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ.; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ.; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist.; Student v. Hemet Unified School District, SN 550-91; Berkeley Unified School District (1987) EHLR 509:197; 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(i); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b)
People named in the decision
- Peggy Nadin, director of special education, Oxnard Union High School District
- Judy Greycloud, school psychologist (District assessor), Oxnard Union High School District
- Marilyn M. Evenson, Ph.D., private psychologist; independent assessor and witness for Student, Private
- Kenneth L. Seely, Ph.D., licensed clinical psychologist; private assessor (February 2001), Private
- Tracy S. Bennett, Ph.D., clinical psychologist; private assessor (1999), Private
- Mark Heller, Ph.D., psychologist; private evaluator (1994-1995), Private
- Kenneth Locke, resource specialist; assessor (1997), Pleasant Valley School District
- Patricia Myers (also spelled Meyer), therapist; witness for Student, Vista del Mar Hospital
- Brent Hall, licensed clinical social worker; therapist, Cross Creek Manor
- Dr. Howard Glick, attending psychiatrist, Vista del Mar Hospital
- Dr. Daniel Flynn, private psychiatrist, Private
- Dr. Barry C. Barmann, private psychotherapist, Private
- Dr. Mary Moebius, physician, Private
- Dr. Laila Malad, prescribing physician, Private
- Dr. Herbert Goldin, physician, Private
- Cross Creek Manor / Browning Academy, private residential treatment placement and school (Utah), Private
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Oxnard, California, on November 28, December 6 and 7, 2001.
STUDENT (STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Rene Thomas Folse. Also present on behalf of STUDENT was her mother, MOTHER. The Oxnard Union High School District (District) was represented by attorney John E. Hayashida. Also present on behalf of the District was Peggy Nadin, the District’s director of special education.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The parties provided written closing arguments, the last of which was received by the Hearing Officer on January 10, 2001. Thereafter, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES(Footnote 1)
1. Was STUDENT eligible for special education from December 5, 2000, to the present because of an emotional disturbance?
2. During the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years, did the Oxnard Union High School District (District) meet its obligation to seek and serve STUDENT, i.e., to identify her alleged disability and to provide a program to address her needs?
3. Is MOTHER entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the assessment conducted by Marilyn M. Evenson, Ph.D., in October 2001?
4. Is MOTHER entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the costs of the Cross Creek Manor placement from October 2000 through the date of this decision, including expenses incurred for tuition, travel, parent training services, and related costs?
5. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education services?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
STUDENT contends that the District members of the IEP team were incorrect when they determined on December 5, 2000, that she was not eligible for special education under the category of emotionally disturbed (ED). STUDENT argues that she should have been found eligible as ED because, in pertinent part, she exhibited “a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression” to a marked degree, over a long period of time, and that this condition adversely affected her educational performance. STUDENT also contends that the District failed in its child find obligations during the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years. MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother seeks reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT’s private placement at Cross Creek Manor from October 2000 to the present. STUDENT also contends that she is entitled to reimbursement for a private assessment procured by the family in October 2001 because Judy Greycloud’s assessment of November 2000 was not appropriate. Finally, STUDENT also requests compensatory education.
The District contends that STUDENT was not eligible for special education as of December 2000. In that regard, the District contends that STUDENT’s grades had improved during the ninth and tenth grades (1998-1999,1999-2000), she had a boyfriend, she was a member of the basketball team, and she held a job (until she was sexually assaulted by a coworker). The District acknowledges that STUDENT was hospitalized for emotional problems in December 1998 and again in the beginning of her eleventh grade school year (2000-2001). Nonetheless, the District argues, she did not meet the ED criteria because she did not suffer from “a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression” to a marked degree and over a long period of time. Regardless, contends the District, her condition did not aversely affect her educational performance.
With regard to the Petitioner’s request for reimbursement for Marilyn Evenson’s assessment, the District argues that Judy Greycloud’s assessment was appropriate and therefore Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement. Regarding Petitioner’s request for reimbursement for the costs associated with her stay at Cross Creek Manor, the District contends that Ms. PARENT is not entitled to reimbursement because (1) STUDENT was not eligible for special education, and (2) Ms. PARENT failed to provide sufficient evidence regarding the appropriateness of her placement.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT has never been found eligible for special education services. Her parent has resided within the boundaries of the District at all relevant times. STUDENT attended school in the Oxnard Union High School District during her ninth and tenth grade school years (1998-1999, 1999-2000). STUDENT was also enrolled in the District during the first part of the eleventh grade (2000-2001), although she missed a significant amount of school during that school year because of three consecutive hospitalizations following a sexual assault by a co-worker in the summer of 2000. Immediately after the last of the three hospitalizations (at the end of October 2000), STUDENT’s mother sent STUDENT directly to Cross Creek Manor in Utah via an escort service. STUDENT has attended Cross Creek Manor since that time. After STUDENT was placed at Cross Creek Manor, the District assessed her and found her to be ineligible for special education.
STUDENT was adopted by MOTHER and FATHER in August of 1984. Her biological mother, BIOLOGICAL MOTHER, was chronically mentally ill. She suffered from paranoid schizophrenia, bipolar disorder and obsessive-compulsive disorder. BIOLOGICAL MOTHER died from injuries sustained when she fell off of a cliff not long after STUDENT was born. Testimony of MOTHER.
In the first grade STUDENT allegedly tried to change another student’s diaper; it was interpreted by STUDENT’s school that she had inappropriately touched the other student in a sexual manner. For the remainder of the school year, STUDENT was required to go to the bathroom accompanied by an adult.(Footnote 2) Testimony of MOTHER.
In the second grade (1991-1992 school year), while attending the Santa Rosa School in the Pleasant Valley School District, STUDENT and other students were told a graphic story (“the Bloody Mary incident”) by a young male student. STUDENT and the other students who were traumatized by the story were sent home for the day. The other children returned the following day to school. STUDENT did not immediately return and reportedly suffered from hallucinations and other symptoms, such as difficulty sleeping, because of the boy’s story. Her physician, Dr. Mary Moebius, referred STUDENT to Dr. Barry C. Barmann for six individual psychotherapy sessions. After three sessions with Dr. Barmann, who used techniques similar to those used to deprogram cult members, STUDENT experienced a “complete recovery.” According to Ms. MOTHER, STUDENT was doing well in school and she was “at the top of her class” after Dr. Barmann’s therapy. Testimony of MOTHER and Petitioner’s Exh. J, pp. 1-9.
In the fifth grade (the 1994-1995 school year), STUDENT was evaluated by Mark Heller, Ph.D, because of “concerns about school difficulties and suspected attention disorder.” Petitioner’s Exh. A 1-45. Dr. Heller performed multiple assessments and prepared a report of his findings. He found, in pertinent part, that STUDENT had low-average to average intelligence and attention-deficit/hyperactive disorder, inattentive type. He noted that there “are some mild to moderate emotional and behavioral problems” that he recommended be “monitored closely.” Dr. Heller also found that “other diagnoses to consider in future re-evaluations” should include dysthymia, oppositional defiant disorder, generalized anxiety and bipolar disorder.
In February 1996, the second semester of STUDENT’s sixth grade school year, STUDENT was first prescribed Zoloft for depression by Dr. Laila Malad. Petitioner’s Exh. F, p. 5. STUDENT has been prescribed Zoloft in varying quantities to control her depression since that time.
During the seventh grade (1996-1997), STUDENT attended a private catholic school, La Reina High School. In November 1996, her parents were legally separated (although they lived together until April 1997). Also in November 1996, STUDENT was treated by Dr. Herbert Goldin for “shingles.” Petitioner’s Exh. J, p. 11. STUDENT’s mother testified that STUDENT developed shingles because she was stressed about midterm examinations.
In April 1997, STUDENT was assessed by the Pleasant Valley School District, at the suggestion of the staff at La Reina. Kenneth Locke, a resource specialist with Pleasant Valley School District, conducted an assessment and prepared a report. The only assessment tools used by Mr. Locke were the Woodcock Johnson (WJ) assessment in the areas of reading and broad written language and the Wide Range Achievement Test (WRAT) in the area of mathematics. Mr. Locke concluded that because STUDENT scored generally in the average to low-average range on the achievement tests, “STUDENT’s academic skills are sufficient to handle the curriculum in a regular public school system.” Petitioner’s Exh. F, p. 1.
STUDENT was placed on academic probation during the seventh grade at La Reina. In June 1997, after receiving two grades of D, one B and three C’s (a second semester GPA of 1.83), STUDENT was not allowed to return to La Reina High School. Petitioner’s Exh. G, p. 1.
In September 1997, STUDENT returned to public school in the Pleasant Valley School District, where she attended the eighth grade at Los Altos Intermediate School. Also in September of 1997, STUDENT was involved in a serious incident involving two boys. It is unclear what actually occurred. STUDENT initially stated to her mother that she was threatened by the boys. She subsequently stated to an assessor that she was raped by one of the boys. Petitioner’s Exh. A, p. 50, Petitioner’s Exh. B, p. 1.
In December 1997, STUDENT was physically abused by her adoptive father. MOTHER witnessed the incident and called the police. After STUDENT returned home late from the mall one evening, her father assaulted her (i.e., hit and kicked her multiple times and picked her up by her ponytail). She missed ten days of school as a result of severe bruising and pain. Mr. PARENT was asked to leave the house for one week after the incident, and he later returned without consequence, according to Ms. PARENT. STUDENT also told mental health professionals that her father had threatened her and had called her names such as “bitch” and “selfish brat.” Petitioner’s Exh. A, p. 50.
STUDENT began attending Camarillo High School within the Respondent District beginning in the ninth grade (1998-1999 school year). On December 1, 1998, STUDENT was hospitalized at Anacapa Hospital for severe depression and post traumatic stress disorder after she had been physically abused by her father.(Footnote 3) The hospital report indicates that upon admission STUDENT exhibited “depressed mood, flat affect, isolation, withdrawal, poor attention and concentration, lack of motivation, decreased energy, guardedness, poor self-esteem, suspiciousness, psychomotor retardation, disheveled appearance, anxiety and sadness.” While at Anacapa, STUDENT was prescribed Mellaril and her Zoloft dosage was increased. A drug screen was negative.(Footnote 4) Against medical advice, she was discharged on December 6, 1998 after five days. Upon discharge, STUDENT was diagnosed with “major depression, severe, without psychotic features” and post traumatic stress disorder. STUDENT’s mother removed her against medical advice because STUDENT had allegedly been hit by another patient with a brush. Petitioner’s Exh. B, pp. 1-6 and Testimony of PARENT.
STUDENT received poor grades for the first semester of the ninth grade, and no credit in one course (reading).(Footnote 5) In addition to a grade of F in reading, STUDENT received D’s in health education, P.E. and math, and C’s in English and Spanish. She also was absent numerous days during the semester. Her second semester grades showed some improvement: she received C’s in math, Spanish and agriculture, B’s in geography and English, and one D in P.E. Her absences decreased slightly during the second semester. District’s Exh. 1.
STUDENT’s mother had her assessed by clinical psychologist Tracy S. Bennett, Ph.D., beginning in May of 1999. Dr. Bennett assessed STUDENT on May 25 and 31, and June 7 and 10, 1999. She prepared a report of her findings in which she states that the reason for the assessment was as follows:
STUDENT is a 15-year-old Caucasian female referred by Dr. Daniel Flynn, psychiatrist, for a psycho diagnostic assessment to clarify psychological issues that may be interfering with her academic and social functioning. Reported difficulties include increasing defiance and oppositionality across contexts, lying, truancy, drinking alcohol, smoking marijuana (resulting in a recent school suspension), and peer rejection. Problems of conduct have escalated since 9/97 following an incident where she was threatened and held at knife point by a male peer and later physically assaulted by her adoptive father . . .
Petitioner’s Exh. A, p. 46.
Dr. Bennett developed STUDENT’s background history, conducted a clinical interview with Ms. PARENT and STUDENT, reviewed records and administered multiple psychological and attention assessment. She concluded, in pertinent part, as follows:
STUDENT demonstrates behaviors characteristic of a comorbid presentation of reactive attachment disorder, conduct disorder, and mild depressive symptomatology with escalations after trauma incidences involving her father and a male peer. Ms. PARENT’s persistent research in understanding STUDENT is consistent with this conclusion.
More specifically, STUDENT has demonstrated markedly disturbed and developmentally inappropriate social relatedness in most contexts since infancy, despite her adoptive mother’s consistent attempts to provide a warm and stable environment. . . . STUDENT’s adoptive father was also rarely present in her life, with the exception of two physical abuse incidents which likely contributed to her confusion and distrust of others . . . Social deficits have been consistently impairing in peer relationships, resulting in peer rejection and isolation. As she gains insight into her differentness in combination with the critical nature of peer attachment in adolescence, STUDENT appears to have become increasingly depressive and desperate in her attempts at making friends and has become increasingly provocative in her expression of anger. She also has become more opportunistic, deceptive, and manipulative with others which only puts her at greater risk for victimization and fails in providing her with peer affection that she craves. Poor social skills have contributed to social isolation both with family members and peers, resulting in an impoverished emotional support system and a tendency to vacillate between externalized and internalized anger and disappointment. Considering her recent impulsivity and desperation to seek affection, STUDENT appears to be at high risk for victimization by others and in seeking escape through dangerous means such as substance abuse, self-harm, and escalating risk.
Petitioner’s Exh. A, at p. 52. [Emphasis in original].
Dr. Bennett diagnosed STUDENT with reactive attachment disorder of infancy, disinhibited type, conduct disorder, and depressive disorder NOS. She recommended continued medication management with Dr. Flynn, individual psychotherapy “with an integrated parent-training component . . . with a supportive and educational focus on social skills” and diagnosed STUDENT with “impulsive, oppositional, and depressive symptoms; and with a strong consideration for substance-abuse proneness.” Dr. Bennett also recommended that Ms. PARENT participate in a community-based parenting group for support and education, and a neurological consultation to rule out a seizure disorder. Petitioner’s Exh. A, at p. 52.
STUDENT continued at Camarillo during the tenth grade (the 1999-2000 school year). At the beginning of the year, STUDENT got pregnant. She had a surgical abortion in October 1999 at Planned Parenthood in Ventura.(Footnote 6) Testimony of MOTHER. She was also arrested for shoplifting in approximately January of 2000, for which she was placed on probation and drug tested. Testimony of MOTHER, District’s Exh. 2, and Petitioner’s Exh. D, p. 9.
STUDENT had a boyfriend who also attended Camarillo High School. At some point during the tenth grade, STUDENT allegedly became upset at her boyfriend and attempted to enlist the services of some “Hispanic” students to beat him up. The boyfriend told the police but did not press charges. Testimony of MOTHER.
Ms. PARENT testified that STUDENT began making obsessive phone calls during the tenth grade and that she continued this behavior into the eleventh grade. According to Ms. PARENT, STUDENT would make multiple phone calls to other students, her ex-boyfriend and his relatives, to the point that other parents called Ms. PARENT and asked her to stop STUDENT from harassing their children. Ms. PARENT indicated that she was forced to disconnect all of the phones in her house to stop STUDENT from making multiple unwanted phone calls. At one point, STUDENT borrowed a friend’s calling card and used it excessively; the young girl’s father brought the bill to Ms. PARENT. Testimony of MOTHER.
STUDENT’s grades for the first semester of tenth grade improved slightly, as did her attendance. She received an A in Advanced Girls Basketball, B’s in Biology Lab and World Civilization, C’s in Floriculture and English and a D in math. The second semester of tenth grade was STUDENT’s best academically. She received A’s in international cuisine, P.E., biology lab and world civilization and B’s in math and English. STUDENT also had the fewest absences during this semester. District’s Exh. 1.
STUDENT obtained a job at a local restaurant in approximately January 2000, where she worked for about six months. In July 2000, STUDENT was involved in an incident at work. A coworker allegedly locked her in a storeroom and sexually assaulted her. STUDENT did not return to her job at the restaurant. Following the incident, STUDENT experienced a significant weight loss, which resulted in a hospitalization at Vista del Mar Hospital in September of 2000.(Footnote 7)
On September 7, 2000, STUDENT was admitted to Vista del Mar Hospital. Her therapist at Vista del Mar attributed the hospitalization to the sexual molestation. Testimony of Patricia Myers. A report was prepared by the physician who treated STUDENT, Dr. Howard Glick, who wrote, in pertinent part as follows:
This is the first psychiatric admission for this young woman who was admitted after a 15-20 lb. weight loss over the past month, not eating, and not taking care of herself. She was taken to a local emergency room where electrolytes were drawn and found to be normal but she had lost a great deal of weight. She also left home after an argument with her mother to visit her friend, was becoming increasingly disobedient in that area. Mother contacted the crisis team who placed her on a 5150 as being dangerous to herself.
Petitioner’s Exh. C, at p. 1.
Dr. Glick’s admission history states that STUDENT’s diagnosis upon admission was “Major Depressive Disorder Recurrent, Moderate, Rule Out Anorexia Nervosa.” STUDENT was discharged on September 15, 2000, with a fair prognosis, with aftercare which was to include both psychiatric and outpatient counseling services. Petitioner’s Exh. C, at p. 2. At the time of her discharge, STUDENT’s diagnosis remained the same, “Major Depressive Disorder, Recurrent, Rule Out Anorexia Nervosa.” Id. at p. 7.
On September 17, 2000, STUDENT was re-admitted to Vista del Mar; this was essentially a continuation of her previous admission. Her admitting diagnosis remained the same, major depressive disorder, recurrent, moderate to severe. The staff at Vista del Mar suspected that STUDENT’s return was related to another young man whom she had met on her previous stay. They felt that she was malingering. The admission history states in that regard as follows:
Subsequent [to the previous discharge on September 15, 2000] she did fairly well [on] Saturday. However, on Sunday she became increasingly depressed with feelings of hopelessness but without suicidal ideation, because, “I’m a bad person for having done all those things.” The staff here are somewhat suspicious that her return has something to do with a gentleman that she met while here on the unit before, although she denies that.
Petitioner’s Exh. C, p. 8. [Emphasis added].
During STUDENT’s second stay at Vista del Mar, Dr. Glick was again STUDENT’s attending psychiatrist. His discharge summary notes that Ms. PARENT agreed to give STUDENT “one last chance” at home and that she had arranged for outpatient follow-up with STUDENT’s private psychiatrist, as well as counseling. The summary additionally states that STUDENT and her mother had agreed that if she was unable to function at home, she would return to the hospital and from there she would be sent to a “residential placement.” Petitioner’s Exh. C, p. 11.
STUDENT was discharged from Vista del Mar on September 28, 2000, after a stay of 13 days. At the time of her discharge from Vista del Mar, STUDENT’s diagnosis remained the same, Major Depressive Disorder, Recurrent, Moderate to Severe. Petitioner’s Exh. C, p. 12.
On October 11, 2000, not long after her discharge from Vista del Mar, STUDENT was hospitalized at Anacapa Hospital. The hospitalization was the result of her expressed suicidal ideation to her counselor(Footnote 8). She had run away from home and had taken the car late at night to go to a boyfriend’s residence. It was felt that she was at risk, and for that reason she was hospitalized at Anacapa. STUDENT’s admission diagnosis was Major Depression, Moderate in Severity, and the admission evaluation notes that STUDENT’s “insight and judgement” and her “impulse control” were poor.
Approximately 8 days into her stay, STUDENT was placed on “one to one observation” because she presented a high AWOL risk. She remained at Anacapa until October 28, 2000, when she was discharged to a transport service and transported to Cross Creek Manor in Utah. Petitioner’s Exh. B, p. 21. The discharge summary states that STUDENT exhibited the following symptoms during her 17-day stay:
The patient exhibited the following symptoms and behaviors during the course of treatment: depressed mood, suicidal ideation, rapid speech, anger, impaired insight and judgement, labile mood, poor hygiene, mood swings, tearfulness, anxiety, agitation, isolation, withdrawal, anergia, anhedonia, irritability, poor impulse control, poor response to re-direction. The patient’s attendance and participation in program groups and activities was fair.
Petitioner’s Exh. B, p. 25.
The discharge summary also states that “STUDENT responded well to the combination of the structured program, psychotherapy, and psychopharmacology, and showed improvement by the time of discharge.” It further states as follows:
The patient was discharged in improving condition with a good prognosis with ongoing continued aftercare and medication compliance. The patient was oriented to time, place and person. Attention span and memory were intact. There were no speech or motor abnormalities noted. Mood remained depressed and irritable with angry affect. Thought processes were linear. She denied auditory and visual hallucinations, paranoid ideation, and other psychotic symptoms. She denied suicidal and homicidal ideation. Other mental status parameters were within normal limits.
Petitioner’s Exh. B, p. 26.
Because of the three hospitalizations during September and October, STUDENT essentially did not attend Camarillo High School during the eleventh grade. She received no credit in any of her classes at Camarillo High School. However, she did receive credit for two hospital courses she attended during her 17-day stay at Anacapa, U.S. History and an elective. She received an A in U.S. History and a B in the elective. District’s Exh. 1.
On November 14 and 15, 2000, STUDENT was assessed by Judy Greycloud in Utah. Ms. Greycloud is a school psychologist employed by the District. She used a number of evaluation instruments, including the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children – III (WISC III); Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT); Bender Visual Motor Gestalt (Bender); Beck Depression Inventory; Devereux Scale of Mental Disorders (DSMD); Draw-A-Person: Screening Procedure for Emotional Disturbance (DAP:SPED); Personality Inventory for Youth (PIY); Revised Children’s Manifest Anxiety Scale (RCMAS); and a sentence completion test. She also collected teacher reports, interviewed STUDENT, her mother, her therapist at Cross Creek, and her therapist who treated her between her last two hospitalizations in the fall of 2000. She also reviewed STUDENT’s voluminous assessments and hospital records. Petitioner’s Exh. F, p. 4.
Ms. Greycloud concluded in her assessment report that STUDENT’s learning ability was in the low average to average range, her adaptive skills were within normal limits, and her academic skills were within expected performance levels. She concluded that STUDENT did not meet the eligibility criterion as an emotionally disturbed student. In particular, Ms Greycloud noted that STUDENT did not meet the criteria, “a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression” to a marked degree, and over a long period of time. She explained that while “STUDENT has a history of depression dating back several years, for which she takes medication,” STUDENT has nonetheless “managed to make satisfactory progress in school despite this condition.” Petitioner’s Exh. F, p.13.
On December 5, 2000, the District held an IEP team meeting for the purpose of determining whether STUDENT was eligible for special education services under the category of emotionally disturbed. No regular education teacher was present at the meeting. The team determined that STUDENT was not eligible. STUDENT’s mother did not consent to the IEP. Petitioner’s Exh. F.
STUDENT received no educational services at Cross Creek for the first several weeks of her stay. Testimony of MOTHER and Greycloud.
In February 2001, Kenneth L. Seely, Ph.D., a licensed clinical psychologist, assessed STUDENT in Utah. The reason for the referral was as follows:
STUDENT was referred to Cross Creek Manor by her mother, MOTHER. Specific concerns at the time of admission were her oppositional behaviors, sexual activity and acting out. A psychological evaluation was specifically requested to assess her current level of psychological and intellectual functioning and to address any treatment and/or placement recommendations.
Petitioner’s Exh. D, p. 1.
Dr. Seely administered the Rorschach Inkblot Test and the Minnesota Multi phasic Personality Inventory-Adolescents (MMPI-A). He also conducted a mental status examination, a clinical interview, and reviewed past reports. Dr. Seely found, in pertinent part, as follows:
It is noted that although this testing did not address her cognitive functioning, her previous testing indicated she is currently functioning in the “below average” range of intelligence. Her achievement testing showed in most areas average ability, with an area of below average ability in her mathematics skills. She did not appear to have any cognitive deficits that would preclude problems in maintaining average levels of performance, but the significance of her depression, adjustment and conduct disordered presentation is such that it is likely to cause significant difficulties during times of stress. She reported that during 8th and 9th grades her academic performance was significantly lower and she had more problems in maintaining her grades. She reported A grades for part of 10th grade, which suggests that she is capable of attaining average levels of performance, but during times of distress she appears to be less capable of maintaining this performance. Her current level of distress is likely to contribute to difficulties in her concentration, energy, and her attitude toward academic achievement.
Petitioner’s Exh. D, p. 7. [Emphasis added].
Dr. Seely diagnosed STUDENT with “Major Depressive Disorder, Recurrent, Severe, (possibly with Interepisode Recovery); Conduct Disorder, Mild; Adjustment Disorder with Disturbance of Conduct; and, Cannabis Dependence.” He recommended continued residential placement, with emphasis on addressing STUDENT’s conduct disorder, drug addiction, and depression. Petitioner’s Exh. D, p. 8.
In October 2001, STUDENT’s mother obtained an assessment from Dr. Marilyn Evenson. Dr. Evenson flew to Utah and assessed STUDENT at Cross Creek Manor. Dr. Evenson did not draft a report of her assessment. Dr. Evenson’s assessment was limited to STUDENT’s psychological functioning.
The Hearing in this matter convened on November 28, 2001, and ended on December 7, 2001. As of the last day of hearing, STUDENT was still attending Cross Creek Manor.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Was STUDENT eligible for special education from December 5, 2000, to the present because of an emotional disturbance?
The primary issue in this matter is whether STUDENT should have been found eligible for special education as emotionally disturbed at the IEP team meeting held on December 5, 2000. Petitioner’s Exh. E.
To qualify for special education under the category of ED,(Footnote 9) a student must . . . exhibit one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree, which adversely affect educational performance:
(1) An inability to learn which cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors; (2) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers; (3) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations; (4) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression; or (5) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.
34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4)(i) (1996); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(i). The term ED does not, however, apply to students who are socially maladjusted, unless it is determined that they have a serious emotional disturbance. 34 C.F.R. §300.7(c)(4)(ii) (1996); see Cal. Educ. Code § 56441.11(c)(C). The primary disputed characteristic was whether STUDENT exhibited “a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression” to a marked degree and for a long period of time.
Did STUDENT exhibit a “general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression,” to a marked degree and over a long period of time?
Judy Greycloud’s assessment, which she conducted shortly before the District members of the IEP team found STUDENT ineligible for special education, states as follows:
STUDENT has a history of depression dating back several years, for which she takes medication. She has managed to make satisfactory progress in school despite this condition. She does not appear to meet this [criterion].
District’s Exh. 4.
Ms. Greycloud testified that her assessment revealed that STUDENT exhibited this characteristic “over a long period of time” and that “at times over the past few years [ninth and tenth grades], it was marked.” The District, nonetheless, argues that STUDENT’s depression was not “marked” in degree and exhibited over a long period of time. The District points out that Dr. Heller’s assessment in 1995 found that STUDENT had “mild to moderate emotional and behavioral problems” and Dr. Bennett’s assessment in the summer of 1999 found that STUDENT displayed “mild depressive symptomatology.”(Footnote 10) The significance of this, argues the District, is that both Dr. Bennett and Dr. Heller’s assessments were conducted during times when STUDENT was not suffering from the effects of one of the many significant traumas in her life (rape, physical abuse by her father, abortion and another sexual assault). The District also argues that STUDENT did well (this is not seriously disputed) in school during the second semester of her tenth grade year, the semester that preceded the three successive hospitalizations during the summer/fall of 2000.
The District’s focus is misplaced. The question is whether STUDENT, as of December 2000, had exhibited the qualifying characteristic over a long period of time and to a marked degree, not whether she experienced a period or periods of remission during her educational career.
Focusing on December 2000, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s depression had been exhibited both to a marked degree and over a long period of time. The evidence established that following the sexual assault, STUDENT was hospitalized three times over a period of two months (the beginning of September through the end of October of 2000). The unanimity of all of the healthcare providers during this period is persuasive on several points: STUDENT was severely depressed. STUDENT had suicidal ideation. STUDENT exhibited extremely risky behaviors because of her depression. Because of STUDENT’s severe depression, suicidal ideation and other symptoms, she did not attend school at Camarillo High School for most of the period beginning in August to the end of October, when she was transferred to Cross Creek Manor. After she was transferred to Cross Creek Manor, she was still unable to attend classes for the next several weeks because her serious depression-related symptoms continued. She was also accompanied by a staff person everywhere she went for the first several weeks because it was discovered that she had made plans to run away. The Hearing Officer additionally notes that Dr. Seely’s assessment, in February 2001, about eight months after the sexual assault, determined that STUDENT still required residential placement and counseling and that she still suffered from major depression. Because STUDENT exhibited serious depressive symptoms over a period of several months, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT met the characteristic “to a marked degree and over a long period of time.”
Did STUDENT’s condition adversely affect her educational performance?
To summarize, the Hearing Officer has determined above that STUDENT exhibited a “general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression,” to a marked degree and over a long period of time. The primary question, indeed, the crux of the dispute between the parties, is whether this qualifying characteristic had an “adverse affect” on STUDENT’s “educational performance.” To resolve this question, it is necessary to know what degree of adverse affect is legally required for ED eligibility.
No witness called provided persuasive testimony about the appropriate legal interpretation. There is no federal statutory or regulatory interpretation of “adverse affect.” In 1989, the Office of Special Education Programs (OSEP) was asked to provide guidance on what the term “adversely affects educational performance” means in the context of identifying ED students. In its administrative interpretation, OSEP indicated that this term is subject to a variety of interpretations by the states. “In reference to SED(Footnote 11) children and youth, States typically include within the parameters of educational performance those elements which are of specific educational concern to the school, which are reflected in the school’s curriculum and which generally receive some type of formal rating. While some States do provide additional procedures and guidance related to [this term] . . . [its] application to a particular child continues to be based largely on the unique facts, and circumstances of the particular case.”
While some states have enacted specific regulations defining “adverse affect on educational performance,” California has not done so. In California, it has been noted that “there is no qualifying language to indicate that any more than some adverse effect is needed to satisfy this criterion . . . . However, there is reason to believe that the adverse effect required by the regulation must have a significant impact on the student’s educational standing.” Student v. Hemet Unified School District and Riverside County Mental Health Department, SN 550-91 [interpreting identical federal language].
The Hearing Officer concludes that a “significant impact” on a student’s educational standing must be present to demonstrate “adverse affect.” That impact must be determined in light of the unique facts of each case.
In examining whether STUDENT’s depression adversely affected her educational performance, the District (and the District members of the December 2000 IEP team), focused on STUDENT’s progression during the ninth and tenth grades. As developed above, STUDENT did progressively better after her first semester of her ninth grade year at Camarillo. STUDENT did very well during the second semester of the tenth grade. She received the best grades of her educational history during this period. She also participated in a team sport (basketball) during this period. Finally, she successfully obtained and held a job at a local restaurant for about six months while succeeding academically in school.
However, the focus of both the December 2000 IEP team and the District at the instant Hearing is misplaced. The focus should have been the eleventh grade, when STUDENT’s depressive symptoms became so severe following the sexual assault that she was hospitalized three times over a period spanning two months. The Hearing Officer is aware of one California administrative decision which concluded that “it is certain that a pupil cannot receive educational benefit if he cannot attend classes.” Berkeley Unified School District (1987) EHLR 509:197. The Hearing Officer in that case determined that, although the student had demonstrated that he could perform well academically, his condition had nonetheless adversely affected his educational performance because the student had run away from home and stopped attending school altogether due to an emotional disturbance. As a result, his grades had deteriorated from A’s and B’s to receiving no credits due to nonattendance. At the time of the hearing, the student should have been advancing to the twelfth grade, but had received only a portion of his tenth grade credits.
A review of STUDENT’s educational performance during eleventh grade reveals that STUDENT’s depression, indeed, had a significant impact on her education during the eleventh grade: she received no credits from Camarillo High School because she was unable to attend school. In fact, the only credits she received during this period were for two courses that she took during her 17-day stay at Anacapa, a structured, protected hospital environment where she was held against her will and where she received counseling and other mental health services on almost a daily basis.(Footnote 12)
Did STUDENT require instruction, services, or both which could not have been provided with modification of the regular school program?
In summary, STUDENT exhibited a pervasive mood of depression to a marked degree and over a long period of time, and this condition adversely affected her educational performance. The next question is whether STUDENT required instruction, services, or both, which could not have been provided with modification of the regular school program.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did require instruction and services beyond modification of the regular school program. During September and October 2000, she tried to attend the regular education program at Camarillo, but failed. During part of this time, she was receiving some counseling services from Ventura County. Testimony of MOTHER. Her academic success at Anacapa, despite her severe depression, shows that STUDENT required a controlled, structured environment in order to make academic progress. The evidence further established that her need for a controlled, structured environment continued long after STUDENT was placed at Cross Creek Manor. Dr. Seely’s report in February 2001 found, in pertinent part, as follows:
STUDENT is currently receiving treatment in the form of a long-term residential treatment center, and this is recommended to continue. She is receiving a regimented behavioral program, which will help with seeing that her choice of adjusting socially through conduct-disordered behaviors does not help with life. She will also benefit from the artificial social environment that is provided in her placement, and she can challenge her beliefs about others and social interactions, and if placed back into her previous environment, she would have a high likelihood of returning to old behaviors of her peers and social contacts. Her depression is significant enough to include suicidal ideation, and past problems with suicidal ideation were reported. She can be monitored in her current environment for this and her means of self-harm reduced.
Petitioner’s Exh. D, p. 7.
In sum, the Hearing Officer has found that (1) STUDENT exhibited the qualifying characteristic of a “pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression, (2) she exhibited this characteristic over a long period of time and to a marked degree, (3) her pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression had an adverse affect on her educational performance, and (4) she required instruction and services which could not have been provided with modification of the regular school program. She was therefore eligible for special education as a child with an emotional disturbance as of December 5, 2000, determination by the District IEP team members that she was not eligible at that time was incorrect(Footnote 13).
ISSUE NO. 2: During the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years, did the District meet its obligation to seek and serve STUDENT, i.e., to identify her alleged disability and to provide a program to address her needs?
The IDEA and State law impose an affirmative duty on school districts to ensure that all disabled children who are in need of special education and related services are “identified, located, and evaluated.” 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(3); Cal. Educ. Code § 56300 (Deering Supp. 1999). This duty is not dependent on any request by the parent for special education testing or referral for services. The duty arises with the district’s knowledge of facts tending to establish a suspected disability and the need for IDEA special education services. Under State law, a child may be referred for special education only after the resources of the regular education program have been considered and, where appropriate, utilized. Cal. Educ. Code § 56303 (Deering 1987).
The Petitioner provided little evidence at hearing regarding any failure on the part of the District to seek out and serve STUDENT prior to the District’s assessment and IEP meeting in the fall of 2000. The Petitioner generally argued at the hearing that STUDENT’s failing grade and numerous absences during the ninth grade should have alerted the District that STUDENT was a child with an emotional disturbance. Additionally, Ms. PARENT testified that she spoke to a counselor about STUDENT’s problems at some point before STUDENT’s final decompensation in July 2000.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s F grade during her ninth grade year and her frequent absences should not have alerted the District that she may have been a child with a disability. Many students receive failing grades and are frequently absent; in fact, failing grades and frequent absences are often closely correlated. The question is whether there was some unique fact that was known to the District that should have prompted a further inquiry culminating in an assessment and, eventually, special education services. The Petitioner presented no such distinguishing fact.
With regard to Ms. PARENT’s statement regarding a conversation with a counselor, the Hearing Officer finds Ms. PARENT’s recollection of events to be generally unreliable. After contradicting (and correcting) herself during cross-examination, Ms. PARENT revealed that her memory was unreliable because she has taken the drug “Phen Phen” at some point in the past. Given that her statement was not corroborated by any evidence, the Hearing Officer affords her testimony no weight on this critical point.
In sum, the District did not fail in its child find obligation to STUDENT during her ninth and tenth grade years at Camarillo.
ISSUE NO. 3: Is MOTHER entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the assessment conducted by Marilyn M. Evenson, Ph.D., in October 2001?
Petitioner seeks reimbursement for an evaluation that was obtained from Marilyn M. Evenson, Ph.D. Pursuant to State and federal law, a parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation from a qualified specialist if the parent disagrees with the assessment conducted by the local educational agency. If the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment was appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent evaluation. Cal. Educ. Code §56329(b). Thus, the first question is whether Judy Greycloud’s assessment was appropriate.
Petitioner argues that Judy Greycloud’s assessment of November 2000 was inappropriate and therefore Ms. PARENT should be reimbursed for the costs of a private assessment she obtained from Marilyn M. Evenson. The thrust of Petitioner’s arguments in that regard are that, while the assessment tools, behavioral scales, interviews, and documents reviewed during her comprehensive assessment were appropriate, her assessment does not state with sufficient detail every behavior or mishap that befell STUDENT since the first grade. Petitioner also argues that because STUDENT failed to interview Mr. PARENT, her assessment was inadequate. Petitioner’s arguments are not persuasive.(Footnote 14)
The sole omission in Ms. Greycloud’s assessment, that her failure to interview STUDENT’s adoptive father, does not render her assessment inappropriate.(Footnote 15) Ms. Greycloud conducted a thorough interview of MOTHER, the only parent that STUDENT lived with during her entire stay at Camarillo High School. Moreover, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Greycloud’s assessment report contained sufficient detail regarding STUDENT’s relevant educational history, including significant behavioral events and educationally related problems. As such, both her assessment and the resultant report were appropriate.
Assuming arguendo that Ms. Greycloud’s assessment was inappropriate, Ms. PARENT is still not entitled to reimbursement for the assessment conducted by Dr. Evenson. Petitioner presented no persuasive evidence that Dr. Evenson’s assessment was procured because Ms. PARENT disagreed with the District’s assessment. Because Ms. PARENT did not procure the private assessment because she disagreed with the District’s assessment, she is not entitled to reimbursement.
ISSUE NO. 4: Is MOTHER entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the costs of the Cross Creek Manor placement from October 2000 through the date of this decision, including expenses incurred for tuition, travel, parent training services, and related costs?
When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997). Thus, parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement or services and the services provided by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370. However, the Burlington rule is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parent are found to be the exact proper placement or services required under the Act. Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). The Alamo court stated the following about the rationale behind the Court’s decision in Burlington:
The rationale behind Burlington’s holding is that parents who elect to risk shouldering the costs of what they perceive to be a more appropriate placement, and whose judgment is wholly or in part vindicated by the district court, should receive more than an “empty victory.” [Footnote omitted.] As stated by the Court, if “appropriate relief” in the form of reasonable reimbursement is not allowed, “the child’s right to a free appropriate public education, the parent’s right to participate fully in developing a proper IEP, and all of the procedural safeguards would be less than complete.” [Footnote omitted.]
Id.
In Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13, 114 S.Ct. 361 (1993), the Supreme Court specifically exempted parents from having to meet certain requirements of the IDEA in their unilateral placements. For example, parents are not required to conform their unilateral placement to the content of the student’s IEP or provide a placement that is certified by the state. Id. at 13-14. Although the Court has recognized that the parents’ placement does not have to meet a standard as high as a school district’s must meet, the parents’ placement must still meet other requirements of the IDEA, such as providing a placement that addresses the student’s needs and provides the student educational benefit. Id.
As developed above, the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE beginning in December 2000 when if failed to find STUDENT eligible for special education as emotionally disturbed. Accordingly, Ms. PARENT may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the private educational services she obtained after December 5, 2000, if they were appropriate.(Footnote 16)
The remaining question is whether the services that Ms. PARENT procured after December 5, 2000, were appropriate for STUDENT. Petitioner seeks reimbursement for (1) the costs associated with STUDENT’s placement at Cross Creek Manor (including tuition, room and board, academic services, counseling/therapy services, incidentals and parent transportation and lodging), and (2) the costs associated with parent education. Each will be discussed below.
(1) The Costs Associated with STUDENT’s Placement at Cross Creek Manor
The District argues generally that Ms. PARENT is not entitled to reimbursement because there was insufficient evidence that Cross Creek was appropriate for STUDENT.(Footnote 17) No witness from Cross Creek testified at the Hearing. Nonetheless, as discussed below, there was sufficient evidence that STUDENT’s residential placement at Cross Creek appropriately met her academic and her emotional/behavioral needs.
With regard to the academic appropriateness of Cross Creek, Ms. PARENT testified that there was not “much” of an academic component for the first couple of weeks and that the initial focus was on STUDENT’s urgent emotional/behavioral needs. When Ms. Greycloud assessed STUDENT in mid-November (at that point, STUDENT had been there for about two weeks), STUDENT was not yet attending classes so she did not have the opportunity to observe STUDENT receiving instruction at Cross Creek/Browning Academy. She did, however, look at some of the materials, which she felt were appropriate, and she observed some of the classes. Ms. Greycloud explained that the students whom she observed were essentially on independent study; they were placed in classes of 10-12 students, and the teacher would walk around and answer questions posited the teacher by the students. She felt that this was inappropriate for STUDENT because this teaching model assumes a student is self-motivated and disciplined, and those characteristics were not generally associated with STUDENT. Testimony of Greycloud.
STUDENT started attending classes before the December 5, 2000 IEP meeting, and by that time, her teachers reported that she was making progress. Ms. Greycloud obtained teacher rating scales and other information from most of STUDENT’s teachers at Cross Creek during her assessment. STUDENT’s U.S. History teacher indicated that STUDENT was average in behavior, class work, participation, cooperation, and social relationships with “excellent attendance and quality of work.” The same teacher noted that STUDENT worked slowly and sought perfection. STUDENT’s math teacher did not have much to report except that she was “slow in the pretest.” STUDENT’s English teacher reported that STUDENT was receiving a “B”; he also noted that her attendance, homework and cooperation were above-average. Finally, STUDENT’s Business teacher generally rated STUDENT to be average, and noted that she required reassurance.
STUDENT’s academic progress continued through July 2001. Petitioner submitted into evidence a transcript, dated July 2001, that tracks her progress after a little over one semester in the Browning Academy. STUDENT received excellent grades and received substantial credits in all reported courses – by July, STUDENT had attained “B” grades in the following classes: introduction to business (.5 credits), U.S. History (.5 credits(Footnote 18)) Math 87 (.5 credits), and Study Skills (.5 credits). She had also received “A” grades in the following classes: Physical Education (1.0 credits), Skills Development (.5 credits), and Fine Arts (.5 credits). She was also enrolled in Eleventh Grade English (1.0 credits), but had not yet completed the course. Petitioner’s Exh. D, pp. 10-11.
STUDENT continued to make academic progress through the end of September 2001. STUDENT’s “educational plan,” dated October 1, 2001, indicates that STUDENT was winding up her eleventh-grade-required courses by that time. She was completing the second semester of 11 English,(Footnote 19) the second semester of U.S. History, and she was completing the graduation requirements in the area of mathematics. She was also taking several twelfth grade classes by that time, including physical education, physical science and American government. Id. at 11.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s Cross Creek/Browning Academy placement appropriately addressed her academic needs. STUDENT’s teachers reported that STUDENT was performing adequately in their classes, both behaviorally and academically. By July 2001, STUDENT had earned grades of A and B in all reported subjects. By the beginning of October 2001, she had completed most of her eleventh grade requirements and was working towards completing the eleventh grade/second-semester requirements in English and U.S. History and graduation requirements in the area of mathematics( Footnote 20). By that time, STUDENT was also taking three twelfth-grade courses. Considering all of the above, STUDENT’s program at Cross Creek/Browning Academy met her educational needs.
The Hearing Officer similarly finds that Cross Creek Manor appropriately addressed STUDENT’s most important and urgent needs, her emotional/behavioral needs, including her needs for residential treatment and substantial individual and group therapy. First, the evidence established that STUDENT required a residential placement, and Cross Creek (a residential placement) met this need. Patricia Meyer, who was STUDENT’s therapist at Vista Del Mar in September/October 2000, testified that STUDENT required residential treatment because of her serious depression, suicidal ideation, and risky behaviors. STUDENT’s risky behaviors continued after she was placed at Cross Creek; STUDENT was placed on “staff buddy,” which means she had to be accompanied by a staff member everywhere she went, because she had tried to run away. STUDENT’s need for a residential placement continued in February 2001. Dr. Seely, who assessed STUDENT in February 2001, recommended that STUDENT continue her placement at a “long-term residential treatment center.” Dr. Evenson, who assessed STUDENT in October 2001, concurred with Dr. Seely’s recommendation that long-term residential treatment was still necessary for STUDENT. Testimony of Evenson. There was no persuasive evidence that STUDENT’s need for residential treatment changed during her stay at Cross Creek.
Second, it is not seriously disputed that STUDENT required extensive therapy because of her serious, ongoing major depression, suicidal ideation and risky behaviors, and that this need has been appropriately met by Cross Creek. Dr. Seely recommended continuing group and individual therapy to address STUDENT’s emotional/behavioral needs in February 2001. Dr. Evenson testified that this need continued in October 2001. There was documentary evidence presented that STUDENT has consistently received such therapy during her stay at Cross Creek, including both individual and group therapy, from a licensed clinical social worker named Brent Hall. District’s Exh. 4 and Petitioner’s Exh. H, pp. 15-20. Because STUDENT’s placement at Cross Creek met her most urgent and extensive emotional/behavioral need for a structured, residential placement and provided her with substantial group and individual therapy, it appropriately met those needs.(Footnote 21)
In sum, because STUDENT’s Cross Creek/Browning placement met STUDENT’s emotional/behavioral needs, as well as her academic needs, it was appropriate. Ms. PARENT is therefore entitled to reimbursement for the services provided by Cross Creek/Browning Academy after December 5, 2000 through the date of this decision, as well as for the cost of transporting STUDENT to Cross Creek in October 2000(Footnote 22).
(2) The Costs associated with Parent Education
Petitioner also seeks reimbursement for “parent education.” These services, which were provided in the form of seminars in Arizona and San Diego, were allegedly recommended by the staff at Cross Creek. The Petitioner failed to provide any persuasive (or nonhearsay) evidence that the parent seminars were either an appropriate or a necessary part of STUDENT’s Cross Creek placement, or were otherwise necessary to provide STUDENT with a FAPE. As such, Ms. PARENT is not entitled to reimbursement for the costs associated with the two parent seminars.
In sum, Ms. PARENT is entitled to reimbursement for the following services: (1) the cost of transporting STUDENT to Cross Creek in October 2000 and (2) all costs related to her placement at Cross Creek incurred after December 5, 2000 up to the date of this decision, including tuition, the costs of therapy provided by Brent Hall, incidentals, uniforms, and parent transportation and lodging during parental visits to Cross Creek, up to the date of this decision.
ISSUE NO. 5: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education services?
When a school district denies a special education student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 374, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997). Based on the principle set forth in Burlington, federal courts have held that compensatory education is a form of equitable relief that may be granted for the denial of appropriate special education services to help overcome lost educational opportunity. See, e.g., Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist., 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994).
It has been found above that STUDENT was denied a FAPE from December 2000 up to the date of this decision. It also has been found above that the program provided by STUDENT’s mother beginning in the fall of 2000 was appropriate. Because her Cross Creek private placement appropriately addressed STUDENT’s needs, STUDENT is not entitled to compensatory education.
ORDER
1. Within 30 calendar days after receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse MOTHER for the following: (1) the cost of transporting STUDENT to Cross Creek in October 2000 and, (2) all costs related to her placement at Cross Creek incurred after December 5, 2000, up to the date of this decision, including tuition, costs of therapy provided by Brent Hall, incidentals, uniforms, and parent transportation and lodging during parental visits to Cross Creek. The District is not required to reimburse Ms. PARENT for the cost of Dr. Seely’s assessments or parent education costs.
2. Within 30 calendar days of the date of this decision, the IEP team shall, in conformity with this decision, develop a program that is designed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE and that otherwise conforms with the law.
3. All other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
1. Was STUDENT eligible for special education from December 5, 2000, to the present because of an emotional disturbance? -The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
2. During the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years, did the Oxnard Union High School District (District) meet its obligation to seek and serve STUDENT, i.e., to identify her alleged disability and to provide a program to address her needs? -The District prevailed on this issue.
3. Is MOTHER entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the assessment conducted by Marilyn M. Evenson, Ph.D., in October 2001? -The District prevailed on this issue.
4. Is MOTHER entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the costs of the Cross Creek Manor placement from October 2000 through the date of this decision, including expenses incurred for parent training services, travel and related costs? -The Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue. Petitioner prevailed on this issue for all costs incurred after December 5, 2000, up to the date of this decision, plus the costs of transporting STUDENT to Cross Creek in October 2000. The District prevailed on the remainder of costs sought by the Petitioner.
5. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education services?
-The District prevailed on this issue..
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
DATED: March 18, 2002 _____________________________________ Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The issues have been framed to reflect the discussions with the parties and for proper analysis. 2. There is no school record or any other document that reflects that this actually occurred. 3 STUDENT reported to Dr. Bennett in May and June 1999 that her father had physically abused her in November 1998. He choked her and slapped her with the back of his hand, according to STUDENT. Petitioner’s Exh. A, at p. 50. 4. STUDENT began abusing drugs, including marijuana and alcohol, during the ninth grade. Apparently her marijuana abuse began at some point after her first hospitalization, because she tested negative for all drugs at this time. 5.STUDENT was five credits behind at the time she left the District and was placed at Cross Creek Manor in Utah by her mother. Those five credits, which have not yet been made up, were lost because she received an F in Reading during the first semester of ninth grade at Camarillo High School in the District. 6.Ms. PARENT testified that she did not find out about the pregnancy or the abortion until approximately October 2000, when STUDENT’s former boyfriend and his parent visited Ms. PARENT because STUDENT was harassing the young man. During the conversation, it was related to Ms. PARENT that STUDENT had been pregnant and that she had undergone an abortion the previous fall. 7. STUDENT found another job at a coffee house after she quit her restaurant job. She worked at the coffee house for a couple of weeks, according to Ms. PARENT. 8. Ms. PARENT testified that STUDENT wrote what was deemed to be a suicide note. 9. This category was formerly known as “seriously emotionally disturbed.” See 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A)(i) (1997). 10. Dr. Bennett’s assessment, as developed above, diagnosed STUDENT with depressive disorder NOS (not otherwise specified). Dr. Bennett noted that STUDENT’s otherwise mild symptoms escalated after the “Bloody Mary Incident” and after she was physically abused by her father. Petitioner’s Exh. A, p. 52. 11. ED is the same as SED; this category was formerly known as “seriously emotionally disturbed.” See 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A)(i) (1997). 12. The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT’s condition likely contributed to her failing grade inreading during the first semester of her ninth grade year. STUDENT was hospitalized for several days during this period after being abused by her adoptive father. The five credits she did not receive because of the F have not yet been made up. 13. Petitioner also objected to the composition of the December 5, 2000 IEP team, stating that, because no regular education teacher was present, the meeting was procedurally inappropriate. It is not necessary to determine if this alleged procedural violation resulted in a denial of FAPE because it has already been determined that the decision of December 5, 2000 IEP team, i.e., that STUDENT was not eligible, was incorrect. Because STUDENT was not found eligible, and was offered no special education services, she was necessarily denied a FAPE. 14. Petitioner’s attorney argues that Judy Greycloud’s assessment report lacked sufficient detail, while Dr. Evenson never managed to successfully reduce her assessment to writing. 15. It is unclear whether Dr. Evenson interviewed Mr. PARENT, either. 16. Ms. PARENT is not entitled to reimbursement for services STUDENT received prior to December 5, 2000 (other than the cost of transporting STUDENT), because there was no denial of FAPE prior to that date and no other basis for reimbursement. It was not alleged, for example, that the assessment and IEP were untimely. Ms. PARENT is entitled to reimbursement for the cost of transporting STUDENT (this cost was incurred before December 5, 2000), because this cost would have been incurred by Ms. PARENT whether STUDENT was placed at Cross Creek before or after December 5, 2000. 17. The District made additional arguments, including that Ms. PARENT never informed the District that she was going to place STUDENT in Cross Creek before she actually placed her there in October 2000 and that “county mental health” was never consulted regarding the need for a residential placement or if one was available in California. The first argument is inapplicable in light of the determination that Ms. PARENT is not entitled to reimbursement for the Cross Creek placement for services incurred before December 5, 2000 -- as of that date, the District had been on notice for some time that STUDENT was in Cross Creek. The argument that county metal health was never consulted is also unavailing; it was the District’s responsibility to consult with county mental health, not the parent’s. 18. Each half credit is the equivalent to one semester worth of work, according to the Browning Academy transcript and the Educational Plan. Petitioner’s Exh. D, pp. 10-11. 19. While it is not known what grade she received for the first semester of 11 English (eleventh grade English), by October 1, 2001, STUDENT had completed the first semester of 11 English and was working on the second semester. Thus, she had made progress since July 2001 when she had not received credits for the first semester of 11 English. Petitioner’s Exh. D, pp. 10-11. 20. In light of the fact that she received no credit for all of her work at Camarillo during the period from August 2000 through the end of October 2000 (essentially one-half of a semester), the fact that STUDENT had not, as of October 1, 2001, completed her eleventh grade/second semester required courses, is not surprising. 21. STUDENT had made enough emotional/behavioral progress by the fall of 2001 that she was allowed to visit home. Testimony of MOTHER. 22. Ms. PARENT is not entitled to reimbursement for the cost of Dr. Seely’s assessment (which was not at issue in the hearing).
