California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 18, 2002

Student v. Rim of the World Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 2413-01, SN-2413-01 · Hearing Officer Mark D. Brylski

Rim of the World Unified must assess, pay for a private DIR assessment and early mileage, and make up missed speech therapy.

Split decision: student prevailed on 7 of 12 issues (5 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. The decision applied a three-year limitations period from the November 5, 2001 filing. It did not address Section 504 or Section 1983 claims because they were outside the Hearing Office's jurisdiction. It treated a 2002-2003 program issue as premature.

Summary

Parents of a seven-year-old boy with autism and a secondary speech-language disability filed for due process against Rim of the World Unified School District. He attended a county special day class at Kimberly Elementary in Redlands plus an in-home discrete trial training program. The Hearing Officer reviewed claims from November 5, 1998 forward. The District's speech assessments never documented his oral motor skills, so they were inadequate for every year. Its only occupational therapy assessment was from 1998, so it should have reassessed sensory motor needs in 2000-2001 and 2001-2002. It agreed in mediation to assess auditory processing but never did. The vision assessment by developmental optometrist Dr. William Bescoby was appropriate. The District must complete oral motor, sensory motor and auditory processing assessments within 30 days, but not through independent evaluations at public expense. The District accepted and used Kelli Wilms' private DIR (Greenspan) assessment, so it must pay for it. Its September 2001 DIR offer, supervised by SELPA staff with outside consultants, provided FAPE, so the parents were not repaid for Wilms' ongoing services. Speech sessions missed because the county therapist was ill denied FAPE through October 2001. The Hearing Officer awarded one hour of make-up services for each missed hour, to be delivered within one year. Mileage was repaid only for November 1998 through summer 1999, when a long bus ride was unsafe for a nonverbal preschooler. A claim for higher tutor pay was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled a district that agreed to assess, did not do so, and then accepted and used a parent's private assessment. The district had to pay for it. The decision also shows that a therapist's illness did not excuse missed IEP speech services, and that whether bus transportation was appropriate depended on the child's age and ability to communicate.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailed in partAssessment

    Issue 1A. Did the District appropriately assess Student's needs in the areas of oral motor and sensory motor during the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs?

    Oral motor assessments were inadequate in every year because no oral peripheral exam, formal articulation testing or documented present levels; sensory motor assessment was appropriate for 1998-2000 but the District failed to reassess in 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 when conditions warranted and the three-year deadline passed.

  2. Student prevailedAssessment

    Issue 1B. Did the District appropriately assess Student's needs in the area of auditory processing during the 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs?

    The District agreed in a September 2000 mediation agreement to assess central auditory processing but never completed one; auditory processing remained a suspected area of disability needing assessment by an audiologist.

  3. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 1C. Did the District appropriately assess Student's needs in the area of vision during the 2001-2002 school year and ESY?

    The developmental optometrist's November 2001 vision assessment was valid and appropriate; the parent's and teacher's lay opinions did not outweigh his professional judgment.

  4. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 1D. Did the District appropriately assess Student's needs in the area of social skills development during the 2001-2002 school year and ESY?

    The District did not fail to assess because it was not required to assess during summer 2001 and it accepted the parents' private DIR assessment and then offered a DIR program; the prevailing-party section states neither party prevailed.

  5. Issue 2. Are Student's parents entitled to independent assessments in the areas of oral and sensory motor, auditory processing and vision therapy?

    Student needs oral motor, sensory motor and auditory processing assessments, which the District must conduct (contracting with an audiologist if needed, or accepting the private oral motor assessment), but not by independent assessors at public expense; no vision IEE because the District's assessment was appropriate.

  6. Issue 3. Are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessment of Ms. Wilms?

    Because the District agreed an assessment was needed, did not conduct one, and then accepted and used the private DIR assessment without objection or filing for due process, it must reimburse the parents for it.

  7. Not reachedIEP content

    Issue 4A. Did the District fail to provide or offer Student a FAPE by failing to develop IEPs appropriate to address his unique needs during the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, 2000-2001, and 2001-2002 school years and ESYs?

    Whether inadequate oral motor, sensory motor and auditory processing assessments led to inappropriate IEPs was premature pending new assessments; the District's September 13, 2001 DIR offer, supervised by SELPA staff with Pasadena consultation, was found to offer FAPE for social skills.

  8. Student prevailed in partImplementation

    Issue 4B. Did the District fail to provide or offer Student a FAPE by failing to provide speech and language services as provided for in his IEPs during the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years and ESYs?

    Speech-language hours missed because of the county therapist's illness denied FAPE from the 2000-2001 school year until October 2001; after that the parents chose a private provider instead of the District's services, so there was no failure.

  9. Issue 5A. Are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for the DIR and/or speech-language services provided by Ms. Wilms during the 2001-2002 school year and ESY?

    No reimbursement because the District's DIR offer provided FAPE and the parents rejected the District's speech-language services.

  10. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5B. Are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for the mileage costs for transporting Student to and from his school program during the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs?

    A bus ride of over an hour each way was inappropriate for a nonverbal preschooler in 1998-1999, so mileage is reimbursed from November 5, 1998 through 1999 ESY; no adequate proof for 1999-2000, and bus offers were appropriate from ESY 2000 onward.

  11. Issue 5C. Are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for the actual cost of staffing his home program during the 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs?

    The parent signed agreements accepting $10 per hour for tutors and showed no adequate tutors were unavailable at that rate, so the extra $2 per hour paid voluntarily is not reimbursable.

  12. Student prevailed in partImplementation

    Issue 6. If the District denied Student a FAPE during any or all of the above-mentioned school years and ESYs, is he entitled to compensatory education services?

    Student receives one hour of speech-language services for each hour the District was in arrears through October 2001, to be made up within one year; the request for 6 hours weekly of private Playworks speech and DIR services was denied.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, convene an IEP meeting to implement the compensatory speech-language award; the team should consider Ms. Segal's recommendation of 4-5 hours per week for six months when setting total weekly hours.
  • Compensatory education. One hour of speech-language services for each hour the District was in arrears (with credit for make-up sessions) up to the date in October 2001 when Ms. Wilms began services. The parent's September 22, 2001 letter listed 39 hours still owed. Hours must be made up within one calendar year of the decision.
  • Order to assess. Within 30 calendar days, conduct an oral motor assessment by a speech-language pathologist, a sensory motor assessment by an occupational therapist, and an auditory processing assessment by an audiologist (contracting with an audiologist if needed). The District may accept Ms. Segal's private oral motor assessment instead of conducting its own. Parents must make the student reasonably available.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. After receiving the assessments, convene an IEP meeting to develop goals and objectives as appropriate. The team may consider remedies for oral motor, sensory motor and auditory processing once results are in.
  • Reimbursement. Within 30 days of receiving proof, reimburse the parents for the cost of Ms. Wilms' July 3, 2001 assessment (amount not stated).
  • Reimbursement. Within 30 days of receiving proof, reimburse mileage between the home and Simpson Elementary School in Rialto from November 5, 1998 through 1999 ESY, for days the student attended and the parents drove him, at the rate the District pays its employees (amount not stated).

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District

People named in the decision

  • Kelli Wilms, private speech-language pathologist and DIR provider; director of Playworks Center for Development and Learning, Playworks (formerly Pediatric Developmental Associates)
  • Gwennyth Palafox, supervisor of in-home discrete trial program, nonpublic agency, Working With Autism
  • Peggy McFee, county principal for East Valley special education operations, San Bernardino County
  • Laurie Wellner, SELPA program specialist overseeing proposed DIR program, East Valley SELPA
  • Gayle Wray, occupational therapist, East Valley SELPA
  • Gail Lindberg, SELPA program manager; District's representative at hearing, East Valley SELPA
  • Cheryl Humphries, percipient witness for Student
  • Richard Fredericks, special day class teacher, San Bernardino County (Kimberly Elementary)
  • Sandra Isaak, speech-language pathologist (LSH specialist), San Bernardino County
  • Anita Ruesterholtz, SELPA administrator, East Valley SELPA
  • Becky Trebizo, fiscal analyst, East Valley SELPA
  • Dr. William Bescoby, developmental optometrist who conducted vision assessment
  • Holly Fernandes, instructional assistant / 1:1 aide, San Bernardino County
  • Kathy Baker, 1:1 aide (prior to January 2002)
  • Itrice Sanders, transportation scheduler, San Bernardino County
  • Cheryl Sjostrom, former principal, San Bernardino County Superintendent of Schools
  • Terry McLaughlin, assistant superintendent for student services, San Bernardino County Superintendent of Schools
  • Herbert R. Fischer, Ph.D., county superintendent of schools, San Bernardino County Superintendent of Schools
  • David Brown, director of special services, Rim of the World Unified School District
  • Judy Segal, private speech-language pathologist; rebuttal expert witness for Student
  • Susan McGann, speech-language assessor (January 1998 assessment)
  • LaVonne Rorer, speech-language pathologist assessor, Early Childhood Assessment Team and Services (ECATS)
  • Ms. Racine, teacher
  • Ms. Apolinar, occupational therapist, private June 1999 evaluation, Redlands Community Hospital
  • Diane Cullinane, DIR consultant, Pasadena Child Development Associates
  • Sara Trimball, supervisor who conducted staff training, Creative Home programs
  • Children's Center of Riverside, proposed District developmental assessor (assessment not conducted)
  • Advocate Schools, nonpublic agency proposed to replace in-home program
  • Inland Regional Center, regional center co-funding in-home program

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mark D. Brylski, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Colton, California, on April 30, May 1, June 3, 4, and 5, 2002.

Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented by attorney Kathleen M. Loyer. PARENTS, father and mother of Petitioner, also appeared on his behalf. The Rim of the World Unified School District (District) was represented by Gail Lindberg, program manager for East Valley SELPA (SELPA). Also present on behalf of the District were David Brown, director of special services of the District, and Peggy McFee, San Bernardino County principal for East Valley special education operations.

Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Kelli Wilms, director/speech-language pathologist for Playworks Center for Development and Learning (Playworks); Gwennyth Palafox, a Working With Autism (WWA) supervisor; Peggy McFee, San Bernardino County principal for special education operations; PARENT, mother of STUDENT; Laurie Wellner, program specialist for the SELPA; Gayle Wray, occupational therapist for the SELPA; Gail Lindberg, program manager for the SELPA; and Cheryl Humphries, a percipient witness.

Respondent called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Richard Frederick, special day class (SDC) teacher for San Berndardino County; Sandra Isaak, speech-language pathologist for San Bernardino County; Anita Ruesterholtz, administrator of the East Valley SELPA; Becky Trebizo, fiscal analyst for the SELPA; Dr. William Bescoby, developmental optometrist; Holly Fernandes, instructional assistant for San Bernardino County; Itrice Sanders, transportation scheduler with San Bernardino County; Cheryl Sjostrom, former principal of the San Berndardino County superintendent of schools; Terry McLaughlin, assistant superintendent for student services for the San Bernardino County superintendent of schools; and Herbert R. Fischer, Ph.D., Superintendent for San Bernardino County of Schools.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments, the case was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

1. Did the District appropriately assess STUDENT’s needs in the areas of:

A. oral motor and sensory motor during the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years, and extended school years (ESYs)?

B. auditory processing during the 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs?

C. vision during the 2001-2002 school year and ESY?

D. social skills development during the 2001-2002 school year and ESY?

2. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to independent assessments in the areas of oral and sensory motor, auditory processing and vision therapy?

3. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessment of Ms. Wilms?

4. Did the District fail to provide or offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE), by

A. failing to develop IEPs appropriate to address his unique needs during the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, 2000-2001, and 2001-2002 school years, and ESYs?

B. failing to provide speech and language services as provided for in his IEPs during the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years, and ESYs?

5. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for

A. the DIR and/or speech-language services provided by Ms. Wilms during the 2001-2002 school year and ESY?

B. the mileage costs for transporting STUDENT to and from his school program during the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs?

C. the actual cost of staffing the in-home program during the 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs?

6. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during any or all of the above-mentioned school years and ESYs, is he entitled to compensatory education services?

FACTUAL BACKGROUND

Petitioner STUDENT is a boy of seven years and five months with a diagnosis of autism. STUDENT resides with his parents in Lake Arrowhead, California. During the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT attended Kimberly Elementary school’s SDC school program in Redlands as a kindergarten student for two hours per day. The class was taught by Mr. Richard Fredericks and STUDENT was assisted by a one-to-one aide. The school is within the SELPA boundaries but is outside of STUDENT’s Rim of the World home school district. At the time of the hearing, STUDENT also attended an “in-home” discrete-trial training (DTT) program for approximately twenty-six hours per week that includes the use of privately contracted aides. (Test. of PARENT) The program, jointly funded by the Inland Regional Center (IRC) and East Valley SELPA (SELPA), is supervised by Ms. Gwennyth Palafox of Working With Autism (WWA), a nonpublic agency. The parents have also privately employed the services of Ms. Kelli Wilms, a speech-language therapist and director of Playworks. She is providing consulting services and speech-language services to STUDENT employing the DIR (Developmental, Individual-Difference, Relationship-Based) model developed by Dr. Stanley Greenspan. Ms. Wilms is also providing speech-language therapy services to STUDENT.

In an Early Start intake evaluation conducted by San Bernardino County in October 1997, STUDENT was found, at age two and one-half, to qualify for special education services due to at least a 50% delay in language development. (Pet. Exhs. 13-15) STUDENT was enrolled in an Early Start program in the Mission Education Center until reaching age three in February 1998. STUDENT had begun receiving center-based services in Redlands. The center was described as “developmental -- focusing on individual needs” and “very much like a pre-school.” (Test. of Ms. Sjostrom) In a December 1997 psychological evaluation conducted by IRC, STUDENT was diagnosed with pervasive developmental disorder (PDD), NOS, but was not found to qualify for regional center services as a student with autism or mental retardation. (Pet. Exhs. 30-33)

On January 27, 1998, San Bernardino County issued a multi disciplinary assessment report. STUDENT, at age thirty-five months, demonstrated significant weaknesses in the development of language skills as well as a “stiffness” and delays in the development of his social skills. (Pet. Exhs. 36-44) According to a teacher’s report, STUDENT remained isolated in his play and played “momentarily with a limited selection of toys.” The teacher reported using “play-based instruction,” DTT, and the Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS) methodologies.

On February 18, 1998, Ms. Gayle Wray, the SELPA’s occupational therapist, assessed STUDENT. Ms. Wray found that STUDENT displayed hyporesponsive behaviors with proprioceptive processing and sensory defensive behaviors. Ms. Wray recommended a sensory diet throughout the day and use of a weighted vest and brushing program to organize sensory input. (Pet. Exhs. 17-19)

On February 24, 1998 (just before STUDENT turned three), the IEP team met to discuss STUDENT’s transition from the Early Start program to the District. The IEP team recommended a program that emphasized discrete trial, PECS, TEACCH and play-based methodologies. The team also agreed to goals and objectives as follows: increasing independent toileting skills and hygiene skills to wash hands; improving attending skills; imitating gross motor movements and actions with objects; improving receptive language; communicating wants and needs using PECS; increasing expressive language in speech; working independently; and increasing socialization skills. (Pet. Exhs. 51-57) At an IEP meeting held on April 6, 1998, STUDENT was placed in the SELPA-operated SDC (for children with autism) at Simpson Elementary School in Rialto. (Pet. Exhs. 66-67) From age three to four and one-half, STUDENT attended Simpson six hours per day, five days per week, as a preschool student (he was age 3 to 4 ½) from April 1998 to June 1999.

(1998-1999 school year and ESY)

On December 14, 1998, LaVonne Rorer, a speech and language pathologist with the Early Childhood Assessment Team and Services (ECATS), reported in a speech-language assessment that STUDENT demonstrated “atypical patterns of speech and language development” and that STUDENT’s teacher had reported that he “understands well, but uses very little expressive language.” (Pet. Exhs. 69-72)

At an IEP meeting held on February 22, 1999, the IEP team agreed to STUDENT’s continued SDC placement at Simpson from February 1999 through June 1999. At a follow-up IEP meeting held on June 11, 1999, the speech therapist reported that STUDENT was making progress in that “he imitates and is showing success in word approximations.” The PARENTS requested a 40-hour-per-week DTT program through WWA “in three settings” (family office, grandmother’s home, and family’s home). Ms. Sjostrom testified that the June 11 meeting was held because the SELPA class [at Simpson] was closing, and that in addition to a DTT program, County staff would provide STUDENT with collaborative services. The IEP team recommended individual tutor services 30 hours per week and services from a teacher 8 to 10 hours per week collaborating with all staff and family. The team also recommended that speech services be provided three times per week in 30-minute sessions and that direct service and collaboration be provided by an OT. The DTT program was to begin the first week of July 1999. (Pet. Exhs. 85-87)

After a re-evaluation by the Inland Regional Center, STUDENT was diagnosed with autism at age four. (Test. of PARENT) In a privately obtained June 23, 1999 OT evaluation from the Redlands Community Hospital, STUDENT was diagnosed with “sensory integration processing dysfunction.” The assessment recommended that he receive a structured, therapeutic environment with sensory and developmental facility to meet his needs. (Pet. Exhs. 91-92)

In July 1999, STUDENT, at age four years four months, began receiving “intensive discrete trial therapy (DTT),” including 30 hours per week of individual tutor services under the supervision of Working With Autism (WWA), a certified nonpublic agency. STUDENT also began receiving collaborative services from a teacher. (Test. of Ms. Sjostrom)

(1999-2000 school year and ESY)

STUDENT continued in the fall of 1999 with the DTT in-home program supervised by WWA; however, he no longer attended Simpson. Instead, STUDENT received “collaborative” County staff services 8 to 10 hours per week at his parents’ office, and at a nearby home and “sometimes in the mountains [Lake Arrowhead].” (Test. of Ms. Sjostrom) In an IEP meeting held on January 5, 2000, the IEP team recommended that OT consultation be provided one time per week in thirty-minute sessions and that current services continue, including speech and language three times per week in thirty-minute sessions. (Pet. Exhs. 93-94)

On March 9, 2000, the IEP team met for STUDENT’s annual review. IEP notes indicate that STUDENT had shown “tremendous progress, meeting most of the previously written IEP goals and objectives” and that the team “feels the current program is operating smoothly, meeting STUDENT’s needs.” New goals and objectives were written in the areas of speech and language (articulation), spontaneous language (PECS), oral motor, auditory discrimination, communication, expressive skills, fine motor, play skills, receptive skills/ understanding, and self-help. The team recommended continuation of speech services, OT consultation, team meetings 3 to 4 hours per month, and up to 6 hours per month of WWA program supervision for the DTT program of 30 to 40 hours per week. (Pet. Exhs. 95-114) In an IEP meeting held on March 27, 2000, the team agreed that STUDENT also attend an ECATS center-based class three days per week in ninety-minute sessions at Mission Education Center. (Pet. Exhs. 115-116)

A WWA “behavioral progress report” dated April 25, 2000, indicates that at that time, STUDENT was receiving 40 hours of DTT per week, 6 hours of supervision per month, OT one and one-half hours per week, and speech therapy 4 hours per week. (Pet. Exhs. 117-121) At a June 26, 2000 IEP meeting, PARENT requested that STUDENT attend the summer ESY school session “3-5 days a week, 1 to 2 hours per day, depending on tolerance of school setting.” (Pet. Exh. 125) Thus, STUDENT first began attending the SDC class at Kimberly Elementary School in Redlands during the ESY 2000 (June 26, 2000, to July 25, 2000). (Test. of Mr. Fredericks)

(2000-2001 school year and ESY)

STUDENT continued in the fall 2000 with the DTT in-home program supervised by WWA. STUDENT also continued to attend the SDC at Kimberly taught by Mr. Fredericks. On September 11, 2000, in a “Final [mediation] Agreement” entered into between the parties, the District agreed to conduct a “full” psycho-educational assessment, including an assessment in central auditory processing. (Pet. Exh. 129) On October 4, 2000, PARENT signed a September 14 assessment plan that included an oral peripheral exam. (Pet. Exh. 132)

In a November 29, 2000 triennial assessment conducted by San Bernardino County, STUDENT at age five years and nine months, was found (as a student with autism) to be achieving at the “pre-kindergarten” level and functioning within the “mild handicapped range of cognitive ability”; within the two year, six month age range for language/communications skills; and within the four year, six month age range for fine and perceptual motor skills. (Pet. Exhs. 142-148)

As part of the triennial assessment, LSH specialist Sandra Isaak assessed STUDENT in October and November 2000. (Pet. Exhs. 133-135) Ms. Isaak found that, in articulation, STUDENT had “frequent vowel errors and a few consonant errors” not appropriate for his age, and that his articulation errors increased as the length of the utterance or word increased. Ms. Isaak concluded that STUDENT had made progress in therapy during the past year, but still had significant expressive and receptive language delays. Ms. Isaak also found that STUDENT had a “limited repertoire of phonemes” that he pronounced correctly, and that he was difficult to understand.

The IEP team met on December 6, 2000 for an “annual and triennial review” and agreed that STUDENT was eligible for special education as a student with autism (primary) and with a speech/language disability (secondary) (Pet. Exhs. 155-163) At an IEP meeting held on December 13, 2000, STUDENT’s parents requested continuing OT services until the sensory integration (SI)center opened in January 2001, and requested OT services at SI two times per week. STUDENT’s parents also requested reimbursement for transportation from home to school (Kimberly) and back home and speech therapy to five hours per week. The team agreed to provide speech three hours per week (two hours at home and two thirty-minute sessions per week in the classroom). The parents also requested compensatory time for speech sessions that had been missed. At the December 20, 2000 IEP meeting, STUDENT’s parents disagreed with the District team members’ recommendation that STUDENT attend class four hours per day, three days per week, and rejected the District’s offer of bus transportation from the Rim of the World to Kimberly or from San Bernardino to Kimberly. The PARENTS also rejected the District’s offer of a school program in Lake Arrowhead. STUDENT continued to attend Kimberly one and one-half hours per day, three days per week.

During the spring of 2001, the SELPA proposed changing, by June 15, 2001, the Regional Autism Program (RAP) under which STUDENT had been receiving in-home services, and replacing it with Advocate Schools, a nonpublic agency. Several parents within the SELPA whose children had been receiving in-home services under RAP, including the PARENTS, objected to the proposed change. The parents, including the PARENTS, also objected to a proposed change of in-home speech-language therapy services provided by Sandra Isaak, who was chronically ill and was missing speech therapy sessions. During a May 11, 2001 meeting held with San Bernardino County Superintendent Herbert Fischer and with school and SELPA officials, the parents aired their concerns and their desire that Ms. Isaak continue to provide speech services to their children. A few weeks after the meeting, the SELPA informed the parents that the RAP in-home program would not be replaced by Advocate schools. Additionally, Ms. Isaak’s request to change from her itinerant position to a classroom position because of health reasons was denied, and she was again scheduled to continue to provide speech services to the students, including STUDENT. (Test. of Ms. Ruesterholtz, PARENT, Ms. Lindberg and Ms. Isaak)

At an IEP meeting held on May 31, 2001, STUDENT’s parents noted that while he had made good progress in all academic areas, he was lacking in social skills, and requested that his needs in this area be assessed by Ms. Wilms through the “Greenspan methodology.” The PARENTS also requested that Ms. Wilms use the “Greenspan approach” beginning in August 2001. The team requested that an IEP meeting be held in July 2001 to discuss the Greenspan program for STUDENT and agreed to an assessment to determine STUDENT’s needs, but District team members would not agree to Ms. Wilms. The SELPA representative indicated that others could provide the Greenspan training and could do the assessment, which “will be shared with the parent by June 1, 2001.” (Test. of PARENT and Ms. Lindberg and Pet. Exhs. 171-173)

Ms. Lindberg did not follow up with the PARENTS on the following day (June 1) concerning the SELPA’s assessment for various reasons, and the PARENTS, after making several unsuccessful attempts to elicit a response from the SELPA had Ms. Wilms conduct a “DIR” assessment on July 3, 2001. (Test. of Ms. Lindberg, Ms. Wilms, and PARENT) Ms. Wilms’ July 3 report indicates that STUDENT’s parents “are requesting that we assume responsibility for their existing 40-hour/week program [the WWA-supervised DTT program] in which we would provide program development, supervision, and consultation based on Dr. Stanley Greenspan’s Developmental, Individual-Difference, Relationship-Based (DIR) model. They are aware that our approach is significantly different than that of [WWA], but believe that it would be beneficial in encouraging relatedness and communication.” (Pet. Exhs. 175-183)

In a letter to PARENT dated July 12, 2001, Ms. Lindberg confirmed a telephone conversation held on July 11, in which PARENT had “expressed a preference for having Kelli Wilms rather than Children’s Center conduct an evaluation of...STUDENT” (Pet. Exhs. 185-186) The letter further notes that the “SELPA had selected the Children’s Center [of Riverside] to conduct the assessment” and acknowledged PARENT’s formal request to have Ms. Wilms conduct an assessment and provide a DIR program for STUDENT. However, PARENT would not agree to an assessment by the Children’s Center, and the Children’s Center did not conduct an assessment of STUDENT. (Test. of Ms. Lindberg and Ms. Ruesterholtz)

(2001-2002 school year and ESY)

At an IEP meeting held on August 31, 2001, STUDENT’s parents provided a copy of Ms. Wilms’ report to the IEP team. STUDENT’s parents requested a 40-hour DIR program under the Greenspan model and that Ms. Wilms provide STUDENT with three hours per week of speech and language services and six hours per week of supervision of his in-home program. According to the IEP notes, Mr. Fredericks agreed with the assessment and that “social and emotional” was STUDENT’s main area of weakness. The meeting was reconvened to September 13 so that the school and SELPA team members could discuss Ms. Wilms’ recommendations. Meanwhile, STUDENT would continue to receive speech services three hours per week, and all services provided for in the May 31, 2001 IEP would remain in effect. (Pet. Exhs. 190-193)

The IEP team reconvened on September 13, 2001. At this meeting, PARENT requested that the home-based model be changed to a “floor-time model.” In response, the SELPA, County and District offered a DIR program plan that included consultation, assistance and training from Pasadena Child Development Associates (Pasadena) and that services were to be provided in the home and at school. According to the IEP notes, PARENT indicated that she was willing to accept the proposed plan only if Diane Cullinane (of Pasadena) supervised the program six hours per week. Instead, Ms. Cullinane was scheduled to come every four weeks. The IEP team did not reach agreement on either Ms. Wilms’ plan or the District’s plan. PARENT also mentioned STUDENT’s sensitivity to noise and requested an auditory processing assessment. (Pet. Exhs. 193-196)

STUDENT continued to attend Mr. Frederick’s SDC class at Kimberly in the fall 2001 and during the 2001-2002 school year, and increased his class attendance from one and one-half to two hours per day, although the District recommended that STUDENT attend class three hours per day. (Test. of Mr. Fredericks)

In a September 22, 2001 compliance complaint letter to the California Department of Education (CDE), the PARENTS reported that STUDENT had not received fifty-two hours of speech services during the period of August 14, 2001, to September 24, 2001. (Pet. Exh. 454)

In October 2001, STUDENT began receiving DIR services, including speech-language therapy, from Ms. Wilms at her office in Redlands. Although several visits have been made to the PARENTS’ office (none to the PARENTS’ home), almost all of Ms. Wilms’ services (including speech-language therapy services) are performed at Ms. Wilms’s Redlands office. (Test. of PARENT)

According to District staff members, STUDENT experienced an increase in behavioral problems. The District attributed the increase to changes in STUDENT’s home-based program and to the presence in the classroom of STUDENT’s one-to-one aide, Ms. Kathy Baker. Ms. Baker was using DIR, and not DTT, techniques. (Test. of Mr. Fredericks, Ms. Wray, Ms. Fernandes, PARENT and Ms. Wilms) PARENT stated that STUDENT’s increase in behaviors started in the summer 2001 and were not the result of the changes in STUDENT’s home-based programming. The District staff members also testified that when STUDENT’s one-to-one aide, Ms. Baker, was replaced by Holly Fernandes in January 2002, home since STUDENT was age three (1999) (Test. of Mr. Fredericks and Ms. Fernandes)

A December 7, 2001 IEP meeting was held to discuss the corrective action required by the CDE. PARENT, Mr. Fredericks, and Ms. McFee attended the meeting. The IEP comments indicate that the results of the “social skills assessment” had already been reviewed at the August 31, 2001 IEP meeting. Regarding the amount of hours (47) of makeup speech therapy due STUDENT, the IEP notes indicate that PARENT was asked what time STUDENT could be scheduled to attend speech therapy with Sandra Isaak. PARENT had responded that since STUDENT’s speech services “had not been provided for the last seven months” and she had “repeatedly attempted to contact the county principal and SELPA to implement speech,” she had hired an outside LSH (Ms. Wilms) to provide speech services. She also stated that she sought reimbursement for the speech services provided by Ms. Wilms for the past three months. The notes also indicate that PARENT stated that she did not want speech services from Ms. Isaak and that as of December 7, 2001, STUDENT has not received 69 hours of speech from the school district. PARENT testified that she would not sign the IEP because Dave Brown and Gail Lindberg were not in attendance. (Dist. Exhs. 5-7 and Test. of PARENT)

The IEP team met again on March 8, 2002, for an annual review. Mr. Fredericks reported progress on STUDENT’s annual goals and objectives, and Ms. Palafox of the WWA reported progress. Progress for speech therapy was not reported “because the county therapist has not been seeing STUDENT [and] because mom had contracted with a private vendor who was not in attendance.” The IEP team agreed on goals and objectives. The District recommended that STUDENT attend school within his home district. The District renewed its offer of a DIR model (either discrete trial, DIR, or a combination of the two) with supervision, training and coaching through the SELPA and consultation through Pasadena. The District members of the team agreed that STUDENT would continue to attend Kimberly for “up to 3 hours” daily for the period March 8, 2002, to July 30, 2002, but PARENT only agreed to 2 hours [per day]. (Pet. Exhs. 393-401)

ISSUE NO. 1: Did the District appropriately assess STUDENT’s needs in the areas of:

A. oral motor and sensory motor during the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and extended school years (ESYs)?

B. auditory processing during the 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs?

C. vision during the 2001-2002 school year and ESY?

D. social skills development during the 2001-2002social skills development during the 2001-2002 school year and ESY

Special education law provides that a student must be tested in all areas related to the suspected disability, including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, hearing motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional status. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f).) The purpose of the assessment is not only to determine an eligibility category for the student, but also to help determine a student’s unique educational needs. The assessment tools and strategies used must provide relevant information that will directly aid in the determination of the educational needs of the child. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(3)(D).

Under federal and State special education law, school districts are required to reassess students every three years, or more frequently, if conditions warrant a reassessment, or if the pupil’s parent or teacher requests a reassessment and a new individualized education program to be developed. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(2)(A); Calif. Educ. Code § 56381(a). The IEP team and other qualified professionals, as appropriate, must review existing assessment data (including information and evaluations provided by the student’s parents), current classroom-based assessments and observations, and teacher and related services providers’ observations. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(c)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(b)(1). After that review and input from student’s parents, the IEP team and other qualified professionals, as deemed appropriate, must then identify what additional data, if any, are needed to determine the following: (1) whether the student continues to have a disability under special education law; (2) the student’s present levels of performance and educational needs; (3) whether the student continues to need special education and related services; and (4) whether any additions or modifications to the special education and related services are needed to enable the student to meet the measurable annual goals set out in the IEP and to participate, as appropriate, in the general curriculum. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(c)(1)(B); Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(b)(2).

If the IEP team and other qualified professionals, as appropriate, determine that no additional data are needed to determine whether the student continues to be a child with a disability, the LEA must notify the student’s parents of (1) the determination and the reasons for it and (2) the parents’ right to request an assessment to determine whether the student continues to be a student eligible for special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(c)(4)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(b)(4). The LEA is then not required to conduct such an assessment unless requested to by the student’s parents. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(c)(4)(B); Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(b)(2). If the LEA conducts further testing as part of a reassessment, the reassessment must follow the procedures set for initial assessments. 34 C.F.R. § 300.536(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(a).

The Petitioner contends that the District failed to assess him appropriately in the areas of oral motor and sensory motor during the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, 2000-2001, and 2001-2002 school years and ESYs. The Petitioner also contends that the District failed to assess him appropriately in the area of vision therapy during the 2001-2002 school year, and that the District failed to provide an assessment by an audiologist in the area of auditory processing for the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years, notwithstanding an agreement to do so. Finally, Petitioner contends that the District failed to provide a developmental assessment to determine STUDENT’s social-emotional developmental needs in order to determine the appropriateness of providing him with DIR services, as requested in the May 31, 2001 IEP. Petitioner contends that the District’s failure to assess him appropriately in all areas of suspected disability resulted in the development of inadequate IEPs, thereby resulting in a denial of a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) for STUDENT for the school years specified above.

The District contends that it assessed STUDENT appropriately in all areas of suspected disability and that it also offered an additional developmental assessment by the Children’s Center of Riverside that was declined by STUDENT’s parents (discussed below).

A. Oral Motor and Sensory Motor

To determine whether the District failed to assess appropriately a suspected area of disability for STUDENT in oral motor and sensory motor, it is important to determine if STUDENT showed signs of having needs in those areas and whether the District appropriately assessed those areas of need in accordance with the above-cited statutory provisions.

Oral Motor

Ms. Gayle Wray, an occupational therapist who conducted an occupational therapy (OT) assessment of STUDENT in February 1998, indicated in her report that STUDENT had oral motor issues at that time because he was exploring non-food objects and was licking and tasting things. Ms. Wray testified that she recommended a “brushing program” and the “Wilbarger” protocol to address oral motor issues because the protocol included a specific oral motor protocol. Ms. Wray stated that an occupational therapist becomes involved in oral motor issues only if a child has difficulty eating that results in choking (thereby raising safety concerns at school). Otherwise, an OT at school does not conduct oral motor intervention, “because as an educational OT, we are identifying areas of need that are identified by the IEP team...necessary for the child’s education.” (emphasis added) A speech and language assessment report by Ms. LaVonne Rorer dated December 14, 1998, also noted that STUDENT did not “overstuff his mouth, choke, or gag” while eating.

The Hearing Officer notes that no credible evidence was introduced to show that STUDENT continued to explore non-food items or that he demonstrated difficulty feeding or choking that raised safety concerns at school and that impacted his education. However, the District did not provide authority for its contention that an occupational therapist only becomes involved in oral motor issues when there are safety concerns. Nevertheless, it is undisputed that STUDENT had oral motor intelligibility issues warranting assessment and intervention by a speech-language pathologist. Therefore, it is unnecessary for the Hearing Officer to decide whether STUDENT needed further assessment by an occupational therapist in the area of oral motor.

The District relied on the speech-language assessments of Ms. Susan McGann, dated January 27, 1998, and Ms. LaVonne Rorer, dated December 14, 1998, to establish that STUDENT was appropriately assessed during the 1998-1999 school year and ESY. However, neither Ms. McGann nor Ms. Rorer was called to testify at the hearing. Ms. McGann administered the Sequenced Inventory of Communication Development (SICD) test instrument, but Ms. Rorer conducted no standardized testing of STUDENT. Furthermore, neither Ms. McGann nor Ms. Rorer made any IEP recommendations for speech-language services.

Ms. Judy Segal, a speech-language pathologist who assessed STUDENT on May 10, 2002, at a break during the course of the due process hearing, testified as a rebuttal witness on behalf of Petitioner. Ms. Segal testified that the District speech and language assessments conducted by Ms. Susan McGann on January 27, 1998, and by Ms. LaVonne Rorer on December 14, 1998, were inappropriate because neither assessor conducted an oral peripheral examination and a formal articulation test. Ms. Segal also stated that the 1998 reports did not provide adequate documentation concerning STUDENT’s capability for speech sound production and oral movements and that his present levels of performance (following the 1998 assessments) were “basically unknown.”

The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Segal’s opinion regarding the inadequacy of the District’s assessments for the 1998-1999 school year and ESY in the area of oral motor persuasive for the following reasons: Ms. McGann’s and Ms. Rorer’s assessment reports (Ms. McGann and Ms. Rorer did not testify at the hearing) did not provide sufficient data for the IEP team to determine STUDENT’s present levels of performance so that appropriate oral motor goals and objectives could be formulated. Ms. McGann’s report referred to several misarticulations but failed to describe them. Ms. Rorer was aware that oral motor was an area of need for STUDENT by acknowledging that STUDENT “was unable to imitate various oral motor movements during the evaluation.” Ms. Rorer also reported that STUDENT did not consistently produce vocalizations during play and did not vocalize in response to another’s comments, noting that “it is unclear whether his unintelligible utterances are random or if there is an environmental referent associated with his vocalizations.” And yet Ms. Rorer did not make any recommendations regarding improving STUDENT’s oral motor skills or articulation. Moreover, it is undisputed that oral motor goals and objectives were not developed following Ms. Rorer’s December 1998 assessment.

Ms. Sandra Isaak, STUDENT’s speech-language therapist during the 1999-2000, 2000-2001 school years and ESYs, testified that oral motor goals were not established earlier, before she started working with STUDENT, because (oral motor) “wasn’t a priority” and that “developmentally, toilet training or sitting in a chair are priorities before you start doing oral motor.” It is undisputed that STUDENT was virtually nonverbal during the 1998-1999 school year and ESY and therefore it is unclear how much information standardized testing could have uncovered at a time when STUDENT was nonverbal for use by the IEP team. But it is also undisputed that oral motor development is vital for adequate speech sound production. Ms. Isaak acknowledged that in her experience, oral motor is a “direct link to articulation disorders” and that “if a child can’t move his tongue or his lips, then, how can you expect him to say those speech sounds correctly?”

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that without adequate data and without at least attempting to perform standardized testing and an oral peripheral exam, the IEP team during the 1998-1999 school year and ESY was unable to determine STUDENT’s oral motor needs and whether oral motor was a priority for STUDENT at that time. The credible evidence establishes that the District’s assessments in the area of oral motor were inappropriate for the 1998-1999 school year and ESY.

The District also failed to establish the adequacy of Ms. Sandra Isaak’s informal LSH assessment in the area of oral motor, conducted in October and November 2000 as part of STUDENT’s triennial assessment. In an assessment report dated January 8, 2001, Ms. Isaak found that “although STUDENT has made significant progress during therapy in the past year, he still has significant expressive and receptive language delays [and] has a limited repertoire of phonemes which he can pronounce correctly, making it difficult to understand his utterances.” Ms. Isaak also found that STUDENT has “oral sensory motor deficits which impeded his ability to correctly articulate phonemes in his utterances.” Ms. Isaak concluded her report by observing that “even with the above difficulties,” STUDENT remains an “active participant in the communication process” and responds during interactions “to the best of his ability and actively initiates communication with familiar people in his environment.” (Pet. Exhs. 133-135). Ms. Isaak testified that her assessment was adequate and appropriate and that she was considered to be an autism specialist within the county.

Ms. Segal testified that Ms. Isaak’s report did not contain data concerning oral motor findings and contained an “informal,” not formal, articulation inventory that Ms. Segal found inappropriate. Regarding Ms. Isaak’s informal inventory, Ms. Segal stated that it is difficult to completely ascertain STUDENT’s articulation needs from the report because columns were left blank, and that it was therefore hard to know whether the blank columns referred to a sound that he had omitted. It was also difficult to tell how Ms. Isaak elicited those phonemes and what the phonetic contexts were. Ms. Segal stated that the document should at least note if the child was able to produce those phonemes. In Ms. Segal’s opinion, the assessments conducted by the District were inappropriate as to his articulation and oral motor skills. From the standardized testing administered to STUDENT and an oral peripheral examination, Ms. Segal found STUDENT to have a severe communication disorder affecting receptive and expressive language and a severe articulation disorder secondary to an apraxia of speech, exacerbated by a fast rate of speech and decreased volume. Ms. Segal testified that, in her opinion, Ms. Isaak’s assessment was inappropriate to assess all aspects of STUDENT’s communication skills and that no comprehensive oral peripheral examinations and no formal articulation tests were ever administered by the District, “in spite of parental concerns and numerous notations in school records” commenting on the difficulty school staff had understanding what STUDENT was saying.

The District contended that Ms. Isaak’s assessment was adequate because Ms. Isaak worked with STUDENT on several IEP oral motor goals and objectives, and cited the following IEP goals and objectives: goal 2 and 4 within the March 2000 IEP relating to articulation and to the actual movement of the articulators, respectively; goal number 1 within the December 2000 IEP relating to oral motor movement of the articulators; and goal number 1 within the January 19, 2001 IEP, involving the correct imitation of an isolated labial (lip) or lingual (tongue) exercise. Ms. Isaak stated that the goals were written in the context of movement goals to increase intelligibility and that the assessors used gum massage and different oral stimulatory items within his mouth. It is undisputed that Ms. Isaak worked with STUDENT on these oral motor goals. (Test. of Ms. Isaak and Ms. Wray) Ms. Isaak also stated that she conducted an oral peripheral examination. However, the results were not documented in a written report.

With regard to the 1999-2000, 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs, the District failed to establish the appropriateness of the speech-language assessment conducted by Ms. Isaak in the area of oral motor for the following reason: Ms. Isaak did not document by written report her oral motor findings with sufficient specificity to establish present levels of performance. The fact that oral motor goals were established during the above-cited school years and ESYs does not mean that the District appropriately assessed STUDENT and appropriately documented his present levels of performance to ensure that appropriate oral motor goals were developed by the IEP team. Nor did Ms. Isaak conduct any formal assessments of STUDENT after her informal assessment in October and November 2000, even though it is undisputed that STUDENT continued to have significant difficulties with intelligibility. (Test. of Ms. Isaak, PARENT, Mr. Fredericks, Ms. Segal, and Ms. Fernandes) The District also failed to show why standardized test instruments were not used at a point when STUDENT was becoming verbal. Because the oral motor mechanism relates to intelligibility, it was important for the District to assess, and to document in writing, STUDENT’s present levels of performance in this area to establish appropriate goals and objectives for STUDENT. Notwithstanding the ongoing consultative efforts of Ms. Isaak and Ms. Wray in this area, the District failed to show that it assessed him appropriately. Accordingly, the weight of the credible evidence establishes that the District failed to assess STUDENT’s oral motor needs appropriately (to determine his present levels of performance and his oral motor educational needs) by a speech-language pathologist during the 1999-2000, 2000-2001, and 2001-2002 school years and ESYs. Calif. Educ. Code § 56831(b)(2).

Sensory Motor

As indicated above, Ms. Gayle Wray, an occupational therapist with the East Valley SELPA, conducted an OT assessment of STUDENT on February 18, 1998, when STUDENT was just under three years of age. Ms. Wray noted in her report that STUDENT displayed the following problems: hypo-responsive behaviors, proprioceptive processing, sensory defensive behaviors, difficulty attending to academic tasks, and difficulty interacting appropriately with peers. Ms. Wray described “proprioceptive” as “the sense that we receive through our joints and tendons” that “tells us where we are” and “where our body is relative to where we are in space.” She noted that STUDENT was having a lot of “hypo responses” and that he was seeking “a lot of” proprioceptive input by running, jumping, climbing on chairs and that such activities indicated sensory defensive behaviors. To address these areas of need, Ms. Wray recommended a sensory diet throughout the day to address STUDENT’s need for proprioceptive input, including the use of a weighted vest during instruction time; a brushing program to organize sensory input and decrease defensive behaviors; and a classroom program to address appropriate intervention strategies throughout the day to increase his attending to academic tasks and to encourage him to increase his social interactions through cooperative play activities with peers. (Pet. Exhs. 17-19 and Test. of Ms. Wray)

On the basis of her 1998 assessment, Ms. Wray testified that goal number 3 in the February 22, 1998 IEP was designed to improve STUDENT’s attending skills, so that STUDENT, by using sensory integration, could attend better and sit for longer periods of time, and that a determination on STUDENT’s progress in this area was made through consultation. STUDENT’s baseline rate at the time was that he sat for 30 to 90 seconds - longer with manipulative skills. (Test. of Ms. Sjostrom)

The Hearing Officer finds that the assessment by Ms. Wray was appropriate for the 1998-1999 school year and ESY. It is undisputed that STUDENT had sensory motor needs. Ms. Wray had already conducted an assessment in February 1998 and did identify sensory motor as an area of need. Further, Ms. Wray made specific recommendations toward meeting those needs. The Hearing Officer found the testimony of Ms. Wray to be credible and detailed regarding her discussion of ongoing consultative work with Ms. Isaak and with other members of STUDENT’s team regarding sensory motor issues. Petitioner did not challenge the qualifications, training or experience of Ms. Wray. Nor did the Petitioner provide an independent occupational therapist as a witness to rebut the findings and assessment of Ms. Wray. With regard to the 1999-2000 school year and ESY, it is undisputed that STUDENT continued to have sensory motor needs. Petitioner submitted the findings of a report by the Redlands Community Hospital dated June 23, 1999, to the IEP team, and the findings (including a diagnosis of “sensory processing dysfunction”) were shared with the IEP team. Because the IEP team had adequate information from Ms. Wray’s February 1998 assessment and from the June 1999 Redlands report, the District was under no obligation to reassess STUDENT during the 1999-2000 school year and ESY. Accordingly, the weight of the credible evidence establishes that the District appropriately assessed STUDENT’s sensory motor needs during the 1998-1999, 1999-2000 school years and ESYs.

However, the Hearing Officer also finds that the District failed to reassess STUDENT during the 2000-2001 and ESY, and that conditions warranted reassessment. Calif. Educ. Code § 56381(a). It is undisputed that the only OT assessment conducted by the District was performed in February 1998 when STUDENT was age three and had not yet received a diagnosis of autism (spring 1999). The only other OT findings available to the IEP team resulted from the June 1999 Redlands report. Because one year and a half had passed since the June 1999 Redlands sensory motor report, the District should have re-assessed STUDENT in occupational therapy during the triennial assessment conducted in November and December 2000. A reassessment would have furnished the IEP team with up-to-date data on STUDENT’s sensory motor needs to determine his present levels of performance. Moreover, with regard to the 2001-2002 school year and ESY, more than three years had passed since the District’s OT assessment of February 1998. A reassessment must be conducted at least once every three years (triennial). Calif. Educ. Code § 56391(a). It is undisputed that STUDENT, between the ages of four and six (during the 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs), was undergoing significant developmental and behavioral changes that reflected maturation and emerging autistic characteristics. Moreover, STUDENT was engaged in intensive discrete trials (begun in the summer 1999), and the District was just beginning to understand the nature and extent of STUDENT’s developmental and behavioral issues.

Although Ms. Wray testified that at no time did STUDENT’s parents ever express an interest in a “sensory motor assessment” (beyond the OT assessment conducted in February 1998) and that she never received any indication that STUDENT’s parents were unhappy with his OT services, the District was nevertheless obligated to reassess STUDENT’s sensory motor needs as conditions warranted, and after three years, and regardless of whether it had received a request from STUDENT’s parents. The District cannot be expected to reasonably rely on the assessment findings of February 1998 and June 1999 to determine sensory motor needs and appropriate sensory motor services for STUDENT during the 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs. Although it is undisputed that STUDENT currently receives direct OT services within a building purchased and equipped for the purpose of providing sensory integration (a sensory integration center), and that STUDENT is currently receiving OT services there two times per week in fifty- minute sessions (with an additional one-half hour for an OT consultation to his in-home program team), the District must still provide an occupational therapy assessment of STUDENT in the area of sensory motor to ensure that the services being provided are appropriate for him at this time.

The weight of the credible evidence establishes that sensory motor continues to be an area of need known to the District, and that conditions warranted (including developmental and behavioral changes relating to maturation to ongoing intensive discrete trials therapy begun in the summer 1999) reassessment of STUDENT’s sensory motor needs by an occupational therapist, and that the District failed to assess STUDENT’s sensory motor needs appropriately during the 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs.

B. Auditory Processing

2000-2001 School Year and ESY

It is undisputed that the District did not conduct an assessment in the area of auditory processing during the 2000-2001 school year and ESY. (Test. of Ms. PARENTS and Ms. Lindberg) It is also undisputed that the District agreed to conduct an assessment in the area of auditory processing in September 2000. Further, in an assessment plan dated September 14, 2000 and signed by PARENT on October 14, 2000, the District was to conduct a TELD-3 LIPS assessment. (Pet. Exh. 132) Ms. Isaak testified that this assessment instrument was not used and that the Lindamood Auditory Conceptualization Test (LACT) was attempted but not completed. Ms. Isaak indicated in her assessment report that “STUDENT was unable to complete assessment due to lack of understanding of basic concepts (i.e., first/last).” (Pet. Exh. 133)

According to Ms. Isaak’s “notes regarding behaviors” dated November 29, 2000, the LSH specialist made the following observations of STUDENT’s “behaviors before intervention”: “covering ears when sudden, unexpected, and/or loud noise in environment” and “covering ears and grinding teeth when tutor/teacher would present verbal directions.” (Pet. Exh. 137) Ms. Isaak then noted that following intervention, STUDENT demonstrated an “ability to tolerate greater variability of auditory input without grinding teeth and/or covering ears.” PARENT testified that Ms. Isaak and Ms. Racine, STUDENT’s teacher, concurred regarding STUDENT’s sensitivity to hearing. Ms. Racine had reported that STUDENT began to cover his ears in the late fall of 1999/early winter of 2000 until his auditory integration training (AIT) in February 2000 and then did not cover his ears until late summer of 2000, a “major topic of discussion at most of his team meetings.” (Pet. Exh. 138) PARENT testified that Ms. Isaak’s notes and Ms. Racine’s report were made to develop a baseline and also chart STUDENT’s sensitivity to different noises. PARENT stated that at that time and at different periods of his life, he was covering his ears quite a bit because “whatever slight noises that he’s hearing are just painful to him.” PARENT further stated that Ms. Isaak had told her that she could not perform the auditory processing evaluation because she was not trained in that area and that it would need to be done by an audiologist.

According to the notes of an IEP team meeting held on December 20, 2000, and the testimony of Ms. Lindberg, Ms. Isaak “was not able to assess [in the area of] auditory processing.” (Pet. Exh. 168) The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the IEP team had determined auditory processing to be a suspected area of disability for STUDENT warranting assessment at that time. The Hearing Officer finds that the District also did not assess STUDENT in the area of auditory processing during the 2001-2002 school year and ESY.

2001-2002 School Year and ESY

It is undisputed that at the time of the due process hearing, the District had not yet conducted an assessment of STUDENT in the area of auditory processing. (Test. of PARENT and Ms. Lindberg) Because the District had not yet conducted an assessment in the area of auditory processing, the Hearing Officer finds that auditory processing continues to be a suspected area of disability for STUDENT warranting assessment by an audiologist.

C. Vision

2001-2002 School Year and ESY

Petitioner contends that the vision assessment conducted by developmental optometrist William A. Bescoby on November 15, 2001, was inappropriate. Petitioner’s mother testified that she accompanied STUDENT to the assessment and that STUDENT’s tantrumming during the assessment was not taken into account by Dr. Bescoby, thereby rendering the assessment results invalid. STUDENT’s SDC class teacher, Mr. Richard Fredericks, testified that he also reviewed a copy of Dr. Bescoby’s report (given to him by STUDENT’s mother) and concluded that the recommendations were not useful for the classroom.

Dr. Bescoby credibly testified to his qualifications and experience as a board-certified licensed developmental optometrist with over twenty years of experience, including significant experience testing autistic children. Dr. Bescoby testified that because STUDENT was quite upset to be in a doctor’s office, it took a little while to gain his confidence. Because it was not possible for Dr. Bescoby to get STUDENT to respond directly to the eye chart on the wall, Dr. Bescoby testified that he used test objects to form a professional judgment to find STUDENT’s acuity to be 20/30, within the normal range, and based this opinion on having examined hundreds of students and STUDENT’s ability to respond to objects. Dr. Bescoby also determined, by the use of a retina scope, that STUDENT is farsighted, a condition Dr. Bescoby stated is quite normal for students in elementary school. Dr. Bescoby concluded that STUDENT did not need corrective lenses to see clearly. Dr. Bescoby also found STUDENT’s eye alignment to be normal. (Pet. Exhs. 381-383)

Dr. Bescoby felt that after the initial adjustment to the testing, STUDENT was doing a good job of trying to do the best that he could do on the testing and that the test results were “reasonably valid.” Moreover, Dr. Bescoby did not recommend vision therapy because, in his opinion, it would not be developmentally appropriate for STUDENT at this time because STUDENT’s overall gross motor and overall fine motor skills needed to be in place first before it would be appropriate to begin a vision therapy program. Dr. Bescoby stated that he would recommend re-testing STUDENT one year from the November 2001 test.

The Hearing Officer notes that Petitioner relied on the observations of Petitioner’s mother formed during the vision assessment and the opinion of STUDENT’s teacher regarding the usefulness of Dr. Bescoby’s recommendations to challenge the validity of Dr. Bescoby’s test results and recommendations. Petitioner did not call a witness knowledgeable in vision testing to challenge the findings of Dr. Bescoby. Neither PARENT nor Mr. Fredericks purported to have any training or experience in vision testing or therapy. Nor did Petitioner’s mother state that STUDENT’s vision had changed since November 2001 to warrant reassessment. Mr. Frederick testified that STUDENT’s vision is an area that he never felt was a great area of concern in the classroom and that his vision appears adequate for the activities they do in the classroom.

The Hearing Officer gives greater weight to the professional judgment and experience of Dr. Bescoby, and less weight to the lay opinions of PARENT and Mr. Fredericks. Mr. Fredericks was not even present for the vision assessment. Accordingly, the weight of the credible evidence establishes that Dr. Bescoby conducted a valid and appropriate vision assessment of STUDENT.

D. Social skills development

2001-2002 School Year and ESY

Petitioner contends that social-emotional development had become a primary area of need for STUDENT during the 2001-2002 school year and ESY, and that STUDENT needed an assessment to determine if he would benefit from the DIR methodology. Petitioner also contends that the District did not assess STUDENT in this area even though the District had agreed at the May 31, 2001 IEP meeting to conduct a developmental assessment.

The District contends that it offered to conduct a developmental assessment initially through the Advocate School, but Petitioner’s parents would not agree to one by Advocate School. The District contends that it next offered to conduct a developmental assessment through the Children’s Center, but that communication attempts between the PARENTS and the Children’s Center broke down and that PARENT would not agree to an assessment by the Center.At an IEP meeting held on May 31, 2001, STUDENT’s parents requested an assessment by speech-language pathologist Kelli Wilms to determine if the Greenspan DIR model was appropriate for STUDENT to address STUDENT’s need for development of social skills. The District would not agree to Petitioner’s request that Kelli Wilms conduct the assessment. PARENT testified that the assessment was needed to get a baseline of where STUDENT was developmentally and that “it wasn’t to see if he needed it -- the team had already agreed that he needed it.” Instead, the SELPA representative agreed to conduct a “global” assessment and to inform the PARENTS of the identity of the assessor (Test. of Ms. Lindberg and PARENT) PARENT stated that she told Ms. Lindberg on June 11 that “we had already done his triennial just five (5) months prior to that in which we assessed him completely in all areas -- and I didn’t understand why [the SELPA representative] was now asking for a global assessment when we just completed one.” Ms. Lindberg did not inform the PARENTS of the District’s proposed assessor (Children’s Center of Riverside) until July 12, 2002. (Test. of PARENT and Ms. Lindberg and Pet. Exhs. 185-186) Ms. Lindberg testified that the assessment contemplated wasn’t necessarily to decide about the DIR, that it wasn’t a ‘DIR test,’ but just more of a “developmental assessment kind of thing.” The parties therefore never came to an agreement during the summer of 2001 as to the precise nature of the assessment needed, or who would conduct the assessment.

It is undisputed that social-emotional development is a primary area of need for STUDENT. (Test. of PARENT, Mr. Fredericks, Ms. Lindberg, Ms. Wilms, and Ms. Palafox) Ms. Palafox, a supervisor with Working with Autism (WWA), testified that discrete trials does not address that component of development “per se” and that WWA is not trained to work with emotional development. It is also undisputed that STUDENT had discrete trials training through the WWA for two years as of the date of the requested DIR assessment and that STUDENT needed, according to Ms. Palafox, a different methodology (DIR) to assist in developing STUDENT’s social skills to enhance peer relationships. The District also acknowledged that the DTT model was not appropriately addressing STUDENT’s needs in the area of social-emotional development.

The Hearing Officer finds that the parties agreed that STUDENT needed an assessment to determine STUDENT’s needs in the area of social-emotional development. Petitioner wanted a DIR assessment conducted by Ms. Wilms, and the District wanted a developmental assessment conducted by the Children’s Center.

However, because the District was not required by special education law to conduct a developmental assessment during the summer 2001, ESY (as decided under Issue No. 3, infra., regarding reimbursement of the cost of Ms. Wilms’ assessment), and Petitioner had already conducted an independent assessment on July 3, 2001, the evidence establishes that the District did not fail to assess in an area of need by not conducting its own developmental assessment during the 2001-2002 school year and ESY for the following reason: the District accepted Ms. Wilms’ assessment at the August 31, 2001 IEP meeting and decided not to conduct its own developmental assessment by the Children’s Center or by any other agency. It is undisputed that the District reviewed Ms. Wilms’ assessment and then offered a District DIR model for STUDENT at the September 13, 2001 IEP meeting. (Test. of PARENT and Ms. Lindberg)

The credible evidence establishes that the District did not fail to assess STUDENT in an area of suspected disability/need - development of social skills to interact with peers - because the District was under no obligation to assess STUDENT during the summer 2001, and because the District accepted Ms. Wilms’ assessment report at the August 31, 2001 IEP meeting and then offered a District DIR program for STUDENT at the September 13, 2001 IEP meeting.

ISSUE NO. 2: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to independent assessments in the areas of oral motor and sensory motor, auditory processing, and vision therapy?

A parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation (IEE) performed by a qualified specialist at public expense if (1) the parent disagrees with an evaluation obtained by the educational agency and (2) the educational agency is unable to show at a due process hearing that its evaluation was appropriate. 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b). An IEE means an evaluation conducted by a qualified examiner who is not employed by the public agency responsible for the education of the child in question. 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(a)(3)(i). The phrase “at public expense” means that the public agency either pays for the full cost of the evaluation or ensures that the evaluation is otherwise provided at no cost to the parent. 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(a)(3)(ii). If the parent obtains an IEE at private expense, the results of the assessment shall be considered by the public education agency and may be presented at the due process hearing. 34 C.F.R. Section 300.502(b)

The Hearing Officer has already found that the District failed to provide an adequate assessment of STUDENT’s oral motor needs by a speech-language pathologist during the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs. Ms. Judy Segal, testified that she conducted an independent oral motor assessment of STUDENT on May 10, 2001. However, Petitioner did not seek reimbursement for the oral motor assessment conducted by Ms. Segal. Although Ms. Segal’s assessment report was not admitted into evidence, the report should be presented to the IEP team for its consideration in accordance with the Order of this Decision. If the District IEP team members decide not to accept Ms. Segal’s assessment results, the District is directed to conduct an oral motor assessment.

The Hearing Officer has determined that the District failed to reassess STUDENT’s sensory motor needs, when conditions warranted reassessment, during the 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs. However, Petitioner did not obtain a private occupational therapy assessment in sensory motor. Petitioner did not argue that the District cannot perform an adequate sensory motor assessment. Accordingly, Petitioner’s request for an independent sensory motor assessment is denied. The District is directed to conduct a sensory motor assessment by an occupational therapist in accordance with the Order of the Decisions herein, and therefore, Petitioner’s parents are not entitled to an independent sensory motor assessment at public expense.

The Hearing Officer has found that the District agreed to, but did not conduct, an assessment in the area of auditory processing. Petitioner did not call as a witness an individual who conducts testing for auditory processing, nor did Petitioner indicate that he has obtained an independent assessment in the area of auditory processing. The notes for the IEP meeting held on December 20, 2000, indicate the following: “Team requests an assessment by an LSH or audiologist to determine [the] benefit of AIT training.” (emphasis added) According to the testimony of Ms. Lindberg, central auditory processing assessments are conducted by speech-language pathologists and by audiologists (the auditory portion). Neither party called an audiologist as a witness at the hearing. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer directs that the District conduct an assessment for auditory processing by an audiologist, to be presented at the IEP meeting held in accordance with the Order of this Decision. However, Petitioner did not argue that the District cannot make the appropriate arrangements for an audiologist to conduct an auditory processing assessment. Therefore, if necessary, the District is directed to contract with an audiologist to conduct an independent assessment of auditory processing.

Because the Hearing Officer has found that the vision assessment of Dr. Bescoby was appropriate, the Petitioner is not entitled to an independent vision assessment at public expense.

ISSUE NO. 3: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessment of Ms. Wilms?

California Education Code Section 56329(b) provides that a parent has a right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment if the parent disagrees with the assessment obtained by the educational agency. As indicated above, under federal and State special education law, school districts are required to reassess students every three years, or more frequently, if conditions warrant a reassessment, or if the pupil’s parent or teacher requests a reassessment and a new individualized education program to be developed. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(2)(A); Calif. Educ. Code § 56831(a)

The District acknowledges that it attempted but did not obtain an assessment in the developmental (social-emotional) area for STUDENT. The District contends that PARENT declined an assessment by the Children’s Center of Riverside (offered by letter on July 12, 2001) and wanted Ms. Wilms to conduct the assessment in order to access services by Ms. Wilms. PARENT also questioned the qualifications of the Children’s Center to conduct a DIR assessment. As indicated above, PARENT testified that Ms. Lindberg told her on June 11 that she wanted a “global” assessment, but PARENT didn’t see the need for one because his triennial was conducted just five months prior in which he was assessed him “completely in all areas.” (emphasis added)

Education Code Section 56321(a) provides that “whenever an assessment for the development or revision of the [IEP] is to be conducted, the parent of the pupil shall be given, in writing, a proposed assessment plan within 15 days of the referral for assessment not counting days between the pupil’s regular school sessions or terms or days of school vacation in excess of five school days from the date of receipt of the referral. However, in any event, the assessment plan shall be developed within 10 days after the commencement of the subsequent regular school year or the pupil’s regular school term as determined by each district’s school calendar for each pupil for whom a referral has been made 10 days or less prior to the end of the school year.

Petitioner is entitled to a free appropriate public education and should not be required to fund an assessment accepted by the District, particularly when the District did not conduct its own assessment of STUDENT’s needs in the area of social skills development. Moreover, the District adopted a “DIR” model after reviewing Ms. Wilms’ assessment. This finding is limited to the unique facts of this case and effectuates the broad purposes of Section 56329(b) – that a District reassess a student when conditions warrant it, and that parents be reimbursed when a District decides not to conduct a reassessment that the parties have agreed is needed, and then accepts and uses the independent assessment provided by the parents. The District had an opportunity at the IEP meetings held on August 31, 2001, September 13, 2001, and December 7, 2001, to voice its disagreement with Ms. Wilms’ assessment but did not do so. Nor did the District prepare its own assessment plan and/or file for due process to validate its own proposed assessment plan. Accordingly, Petitioner’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for Ms. Wilms’ assessment.

ISSUE NO. 4: Did the District fail to provide or offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE), by

A. Failing to develop IEPs appropriate to address his unique needs during the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, 2000-2001, and 2001-2002 school years, and ESYs?

B. Failing to provide speech and language services as provided in his IEPs during the 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs?

In accordance with the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(D); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A “free appropriate public education” is one which provides special education and related services to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meets the State educational standards and conforms to the child’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).

To determine whether the District provided or offered STUDENT a FAPE, the proper focus is on the adequacy of the District’s placement. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If the District’s proposed program reflects STUDENT’s needs, provides some benefit, and comports with his IEP, the District has offered or provided a FAPE, even if the parent or guardian prefers another program, and even if the preferred program would have resulted in a greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314. While the school district is required under Rowley to provide a child with a disability with a meaningful access to education, it does not require the district to guarantee success. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998). The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require the school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. The Court stated that districts are only required to provide a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Rowley at 207-08. However, a de minimis benefit or only trivial advancement is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some benefit.” Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d at 130 (2d Cir.)

A. failing to develop IEPs appropriate to address his unique needs during the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs?

Petitioner contends that because the District failed to assess STUDENT appropriately in all areas of suspected/known disability, the District was unable to formulate appropriate IEP goals and objectives to meet his needs, thereby resulting in a denial of a FAPE. The Hearing Officer first addresses this contention for those areas of need (oral motor, sensory motor and auditory processing) the District did not conduct appropriate assessments. The Hearing Officer will then address the social skills assessment thereafter.

Oral Motor and Sensory Motor

As indicated above, the Hearing Officer has found that the District failed to assess STUDENT appropriately for his oral motor needs during the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs. The Hearing Officer also found that the District failed to assess STUDENT appropriately for his sensory motor needs during the 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs.

Although credible evidence at the hearing establishes that the District did formulate IEP goals and objectives for STUDENT in the area of oral motor during the 2000-2001 school year and that Ms. Wray (occupational therapist) and Ms. Isaak (speech-language therapist) provided STUDENT with oral motor services, it is uncertain whether an appropriate oral motor assessment or assessments would have resulted in additional, more appropriate oral motor goals and objectives better tailored to meet STUDENT’s oral motor needs during any of the above-cited school years and ESYs. Credible evidence at hearing also establishes that the District did provide services relating to sensory motor, and that STUDENT was receiving sensory integration twice per week beginning in January 2001. It is also uncertain whether a reassessment of STUDENT’s sensory motor needs during the 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs would have resulted in additional, more appropriate sensory motor goals and objectives. Accordingly, a remedy by the Hearing Officer at this time is premature for oral motor and sensory motor. The IEP team may consider fashioning appropriate remedies, if any are required, once the assessment results are received following the assessments conducted in accordance with paragraph two of the Order of this Decision.

Auditory Processing

The Hearing Officer found that the District failed to conduct an auditory processing assessment of STUDENT during the 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs. Because an auditory processing assessment was not completed, and no evidence was cited to show that auditory processing goals and objectives were formulated for STUDENT, it is premature for the Hearing Officer to determine whether STUDENT has needs in this area. The IEP team may again consider fashioning appropriate remedies, if any are required, once the assessment results are received following the assessment by an audiologist in accordance with paragraph two of the Order of this Decision.

Social Skills Development

STUDENT’s parents contend that his social-emotional needs (for the development of social skills) were not met by the District’s offer of DIR services made at the September 13, 2001 IEP meeting. Specifically, Petitioner contends that the District lack of trained staff to operate the DIR model and the lack of a sufficient number of hours for supervision by Dr. Cullinane of Pasadena Child Developmental Associates (Pasadena) rendered the District’s offer inadequate. The District contends that its September 13 offer of DIR services was adequate and designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

(1) Designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs

To determine whether the District’s offer of DIR services made at the September 13, 2001 IEP meeting was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, it is necessary to determine STUDENT’s needs in the area of social-emotional development at that time. It is undisputed that STUDENT needed development of his social skills in order to relate to peers appropriately. It is also undisputed that the parties agreed that the DIR model is appropriate to meet STUDENT’s need for developing his social skills. Moreover, Petitioner acknowledges in his brief that Petitioner’s parents accepted the District’s DIR offer made at the September 13 IEP meeting, but only if the offer included direct supervision by Dr. Cullinane of the Pasadena. The parties also acknowledged that although STUDENT progressed in his in-home program and in discrete trials, the DTT model did not appropriately address STUDENT’s needs for the development of his social skills.

Ms. Lindberg testified that the District’s DIR offer for STUDENT is home and school-based, and gives STUDENT opportunities to interact with his peers, in contrast to the clinical DIR model employed by Ms. Wilms, which allows for little or no opportunity for interaction with peers. Ms. Lindberg stated that Pasadena was hired to act primarily as a resource as consultants to the program and that Pasadena would serve as a “back-up” for Ms. Laurie Wellner, the SELPA’s program specialist responsible for overseeing implementation of the DIR program. Ms. Lindberg further stated that Pasadena agreed to come for ten days as an initial start-up program, one time per month, and for team meetings and training and whatever else was needed for the program. Ms. Lindberg stated that Pasadena was available to respond to calls from Ms. Wellner for assistance and training – “whatever it was she needed.”

Ms. Wellner testified that she has received training in all the specific modalities, including PECS, DTT, DIR, TEACCH, behavior, as well as inclusion issues, and that she had received twelve hours of training in DIR in Pasadena (four days of seminar training) as well as sixteen hours total for three other dates, two of which she worked with students. Ms. Wellner stated that she also received training with the Greenspan DIR model in November 2001 for three days and in March 2002 for three days. Ms. Wellner stated that the Greenspan training focused on how to implement the DIR model in the clinical setting and in the school setting. Ms. Wellner described the training as including direct clinical work with students in their setting, work with the occupational therapist, work with behavioral issues, and consultation with the family. Ms. Wellner described Greenspan’s basic floor-time premise as a series of milestones of socio-emotional growth for a particular child that are measured in months or years for typically developing children, and that DIR looks at where a child is developmentally in the areas of cognitive, emotional and social growth. Ms. Wellner stated that the model also considers the interrelatedness of motor skills, sensory impact, and family dynamics within the range of the student’s strengths or deficits. Ms. Wellner stated that she also has experience with floor-time guidelines and milestones beginning in 1991, when she taught general education and “from that time forward.”

Ms. Wellner stated that individuals from Pasadena had come out on three occasions to assist her and that she had three days of parent training and additional training totaling five days. Ms. Wellner further stated that she had supervised two formal DIR programs for two children within the SELPA who had DIR services in their IEPs, and had worked with five other students implementing the DIR or floor-time with them.

The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Wellner had the necessary qualifications, background, training, and experience to supervise implementation of the District’s DIR program proposed for STUDENT during the 2001-2002 school year and ESY, and that her extensive qualifications in teaching and in administration were adequate to ensure that the DIR model would be implemented appropriately. Petitioner provided no credible evidence to show that for the program to be successful, Dr. Cullinane of Pasadena needed to provide six hours of supervisory services each month. The Hearing Officer gives greater weight to the background, education, and teaching experience of Ms. Wellner, and less weight to the testimony of Ms. Wilms, who is an experienced speech-language therapist but has no teaching experience and did not observe STUDENT in the classroom before making her recommendations of “six hours of consultation” each month and implementation of a 40-hour DIR model program.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s DIR program supervised by Ms. Wellner was tailored to meet STUDENT’s need for the development of his social skills. The District’s offer provided for its implementation in school as well as at home, thereby increasing the opportunity for STUDENT to develop his social skills and to improve his interaction with peers in those two environments. The program included a minimum of nine hours of training for STUDENT’s parents, thirty to sixty minutes per week of supervision by Ms. Wellner, two days of intensive training for tutors, aides and implementers, and follow-up training, consultation, and oversight every six weeks or more often as needed. (Dist. Exh.197) The Hearing Officer finds that the amount of time allocated by the District for appropriate implementation of the DIR methodology (through training and intervention by Ms. Wellner) was adequate. The District is not required to design the “best program,” or to provide “the best education possible,” but to design and provide an appropriate program or service. Moreover, school districts are given some deference in deciding on the use of appropriate methodologies and strategies, and in what combination, to meet a student’s unique needs and provide an appropriate program. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the District’s offer was tailored to meet STUDENT’s need to develop his social skills both at home and in school.

(2) Reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit?

Petitioner did not contend that the District’s offer was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. It is undisputed that STUDENT achieved educational progress through the DTT program during the 2000-2001 school year and ESY. (Test. of PARENT and Ms. Palafox) The District’s offer for the 2001-2002 school year and ESY included a continuation of STUDENT’s school program at Kimberly and a continuation of one-to-one aide services in the classroom, together with thirty to forty hours of in-home tutor services, in addition to DIR services designed to develop STUDENT’s social skills. The District’s DIR offer represented the use of an additional methodology to address STUDENT’s needs in this area and included an appropriate amount of training for staff members and his parents. Both parties contend that the DIR model provides some educational benefit in the area of STUDENT’s social skills development. Moreover, Petitioner did not argue that the District’s offer would adversely affect STUDENT’s academic development. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit by developing his social skills and his interaction with peers.

(3) Failed to comport with STUDENT’s IEP

Because the District’s offer of DIR services was not implemented, it is unnecessary to address this issue.

The weight of the credible evidence establishes that the District’s offer on September 13, 2001, of DIR services was reasonably designed to meet STUDENT’s needs for the development of his social skills and was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit in the development of his social skills. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer was a FAPE for STUDENT during the 2001-2002 school year and ESY.

B. failing to provide speech and language services as described in STUDENT’s IEPs during the 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs?

It is undisputed that the District failed to provide speech and language services, as of November 2001, in the amount of 52 hours, covering the period August 2000 through September 2001. (Test. of PARENT, Ms. Isaak, and Pet. Exh. 454) According to a September 22, 2001 letter by PARENT to the District, of the fifty-two hours missed since August 14, 2000, the District had made up thirteen hours, with 39 “to be made up.” (Pet. Exh. 456) It is also undisputed that the primary reason for the missed services was the chronic and developing illness of Ms. Isaak. Additionally, it is undisputed that it was difficult to schedule missed services, in light of STUDENT’s full schedule. Nevertheless, it is also undisputed that the District is obligated to make up the missed services. The Hearing Officer finds that the number of hours missed during the 2000-2001 school year and ESY (52) is significant, because speech-language therapy addressed a critical area of need for STUDENT. The lack of consistency in serving STUDENT in a critical area of need resulted in the District’s failure to comport with STUDENT’s IEPs during the 2000-2001 school year and ESY.

With regard to the 2001-2002 school year, it is undisputed that STUDENT’s parents in October 2001 decided not to have Ms. Isaak continue giving STUDENT speech therapy. After conducting a single co-therapy treatment session with Ms. Wray on October 26, 2001, Ms. Isaak was asked by the PARENTS to discontinue the co-treatment sessions and not to provide any further speech-language services to STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds that this decision was made because the PARENTS had decided to adopt an integrative DIR model approach and to have speech-language therapist Kelli Wilms provide speech-language therapy to STUDENT within that model. Kelli Wilms testified that she started implementing her services in October 2001 and that the services included speech-language therapy and that she could not separate her DIR consultative services from the speech-language services that she was providing to STUDENT. Because Petitioner’s parents decided to use Ms. Wilms to provide speech-language therapy to STUDENT from October 2001 through ESY 2002, (and not to use the services of Ms. Isaak), the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not fail to comport with STUDENT’s IEPs regarding the provision of speech-language services beginning in October 2001 and through the 2002 school year and ESY. Petitioner’s closing brief argues that Respondent owes a minimum of 163 hours in compensatory speech-language services as of April 30, 2002. However that figure includes not only the speech-language therapy services owed by the District prior to October 2001, but also the speech-language therapy services provided by Ms. Wilms beginning in October 2001. The Hearing Officer has already decided that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE in the area of DIR services for the 2001-2002 school year and ESY. The Hearing Officer has also found that the District offered, but STUDENT’s parents rejected, speech-language services for the 2001-2002 school year and ESY. Accordingly, Petitioner is not entitled to compensatory speech-language services provided by Ms. Wilms beginning in October 2001 and continuing through the 2001-2002 school year and ESY.

Accordingly, the District’s failure to provide speech-language therapy services during the 2000-2001 school year and ESY, and into the 2001-2002 school until Ms. Wilms first began providing speech-language services in October 2001 resulted in a failure to comport with STUDENT’s IEPs. This failure resulted in a denial of FAPE with regard to the provision of speech-language therapy services to the extent that STUDENT did not receive speech-language services up to the point that Ms. Wilms began to provide speech-language services.

ISSUE NO. 5: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for

A. the DIR and/or speech-language therapy services provided by Ms. Wilms during the 2001-2002 school year and ESY?

B. the mileage costs for transporting STUDENT to and from his school program during the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs?

C. the actual cost of staffing his home program during the 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs?

A. Reimbursement for DIR and/or speech-language services provided by Ms. Wilms

Because the Hearing Officer determined that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE in the area of his social-emotional developmental needs for the 2001-2002 school year and ESY, Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for the DIR services provided by Ms. Wilms during the 2001-2002 school year and ESY.

B. Reimbursement for mileage costs for transporting STUDENT to and from school program

Petitioner’s parents contend that the District’s offer of bus transportation for STUDENT between their home in Lake Arrowhead and his school program(s) during the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, 2000-2001, and 2001-2002 school years and ESYs was not appropriate, because the bus ride of over one hour each way was not appropriate for STUDENT, a preschool child with autism. Petitioner seeks reimbursement for privately transporting STUDENT by car at the District’s mileage rate. The District contends that its offer of bus transportation from Petitioner’s home in Lake Arrowhead to his school program(s) was appropriate. The District further contends in its closing brief that the District should not be held liable for funding transportation simply because STUDENT’s parents chose to have STUDENT attend schooloutside of his home district and chose to transport him there themselves. The District further argues that while it offered STUDENT an appropriate placement at Kimberly, it also offered him an appropriate placement within his home district.

C.C.R. Section 300.24 provides that related services, include transportation and such developmental, corrective, and other supportive services as are required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education.

During the 1998-1999 school year, STUDENT attended Simpson Elementary School in Rialto, California. Ms. Itrice Sanders, the county transportation scheduler, stated that a bus ride from Lake Arrowhead to Simpson in Rialto is at least one hour and fifteen minutes each way. Ms. Sanders also testified to concerns that a preschool child with autism ride on a bus for longer than one hour each way, given the unfamiliar sounds associated with a school bus and its unstructured environment. It is undisputed that during the 1998-1999 school year and ESY, STUDENT, at ages three and four, attended Simpson in Rialto when he was “virtually non-verbal.” (Test. of PARENT, Ms. Palafox and Ms. Isaak). Given STUDENT’s very young age and his non-verbal status during the 1998-1999 school year and ESY, the District’s offer of bus transportation from Lake Arrowhead to Simpson in Rialto did not appropriately address potential safety concerns for STUDENT that could arise over the course of a lengthy bus ride.

During the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT no longer attended Simpson, and did not begin attending Kimberly in Redlands until the ESY 2000. Instead, in accordance with the June 11, 1999 IEP, STUDENT received “collaborative” County staff services at his parent’s office, and at a nearby home, and sometimes “in the mountains.” (Test. of Ms. Sjostrom) According to the March 27, 2000 IEP and the testimony of Ms. Sjostrom, STUDENT was placed in a center-based classroom three days per week at the Mission Education Center in Redlands, to begin on March 28, 2000. According to the June 9, 2000 IEP, that service ended in June 2000. However, Petitioner provided no direct evidence for mileage reimbursement for privately transporting STUDENT to the center-based classroom during this period. On an exhibit referred to as “mileage summary,” Petitioner did not provide any mileage data from “home to school” during the spring of 2000. (Pet. Exh. 408) A mileage estimate of 37 miles from home to school is noted on the upper right corner of the summary, but mileage data provided under the heading “home to school” for the months of June, July, August, September, October, November and December 1999 are variable, ranging from 10 miles to 22 miles. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the Petitioner did not establish an adequate basis for awarding reimbursement of mileage costs between STUDENT’s home and his school program during the 1999-2000 school year.

Regarding the 2000 ESY and 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs, when STUDENT attended Kimberly in Redlands, PARENT testified that by car, it takes fifty minutes to travel from Lake Arrowhead to the Kimberly school each way, and that a bus ride (with anticipated stops for other students) would take longer than one hour each way. However, STUDENT was now older (ages five, six, and seven, respectively) and he was no longer non-verbal. STUDENT had learned to communicate his needs more effectively after beginning an intensive discrete trial training program with WWA during the summer of 1999. The March 2000 IEP referred to the tremendous progress STUDENT had made on goals and objectives. Therefore, safety concerns about a long bus ride had substantially lessened. Accordingly, the District’s offer of bus transportation for the 2000 ESY, 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs was adequate and appropriate.

The weight of the credible evidence establishes that the District’s offer of bus transportation (taking at least one hour each way) during the 1998-1999 school year and ESY was not appropriate for STUDENT, an autistic preschool child who was essentially non-verbal at the time. However, Petitioner did not establish an adequate basis for awarding reimbursement from home to school for the 1999-2000 school year.

The weight of the credible evidence also establishes that the District’s offer of bus transportation during the 2000 ESY, 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs was appropriate, because STUDENT had become older and had learned to communicate his needs.

For the period November 5, 1998, through 1999 ESY, Petitioner’s parents are to be reimbursed at the appropriate mileage rate for the distance between STUDENT’s home in Lake Arrowhead and the Simpson Elementary School in Rialto on those school days that STUDENT attended school and was transported by his parents between those two locations.

C. Reimbursement for the actual cost of staffing STUDENT’s home program

Petitioner’s parents contend that the District inappropriately reimbursed them at the rate of $10.00 per hour paid for three privately obtained tutors to whom they paid $12.00 per hour. The tutors worked with STUDENT in his discrete trial in-home program during the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years. The District contends that Petitioner’s parents agreed to be reimbursed at $10.00 per hour and that the rate was appropriate.

It is undisputed that STUDENT’s mother signed two “Agreement for Reimbursement of Costs” forms for the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years, respectively, and that by signing the forms, PARENT accepted reimbursement at the rate of $10.00 per hour for tutors she hired for the in-home discrete trial program. (Dist. Exhs. 202-205) Ms. Trebizo, fiscal analyst for the SELPA, testified that all parents were reimbursed at the $10.00 per hour rate for privately obtained tutors. It is also undisputed that PARENT voluntarily decided to pay three tutors at $12.00 per hour for a specified period of time, but then decided not to continue to pay in-home tutors at the higher hourly rate. (Test. of PARENT) Although PARENT testified that she felt that she needed to pay the three tutors at the higher rate because they had asked her to be paid $12.00 per hour, Petitioner provided no evidence to show that adequate tutors could not be found at the $10.00 per hour rate. Moreover, PARENT stated that she no longer pays tutors more than $10.00 per hour. Accordingly, the weight of the credible evidence establishes that the $10.00 per hour reimbursement rate for private tutors was adequate to provide STUDENT with tutors appropriate for his in-home program.

ISSUE NO. 6: If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during any or all of the above-mentioned school years and ESYs, is he entitled to compensatory education services?

Compensatory education is an equitable remedy to compensate a student for lost educational opportunity when the District has failed to provide the student with appropriate special education services. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i)(2)(B)(iii); 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(1); The Ninth Circuit has held that compensatory education does not require that the student be compensated by providing a day for day replacement for each educational day lost. Compensatory education is not a contractual remedy but an equitable remedy, part of the Court’s resources in crafting appropriate relief....designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1496, 1497.

Petitioner seeks compensatory education services in the form of private speech-language and DIR services to be provided by Playworks for a combined minimum of 6 hours per week as well as reimbursement for those services previously privately funded.

The Hearing Officer has found that the District’s program failed to comport with STUDENT’s IEPs during the 2000-2001 school year and ESY to the extent that it did not provide him with speech-language services from the 2000-2001 school year to October 2001, when Ms. Wilms began providing him with speech-language therapy services. Petitioner is therefore entitled to an award of compensatory education.

The Hearing Officer takes into consideration that speech-language development is an area of critical need for STUDENT and that although the District attempted at various times to provide substitute services to “make up” the sessions missed by Ms. Isaak due to her chronic illness, and did use the services of a substitute speech-language therapist, the results of those efforts led to an inconsistent delivery of speech-language therapy services for STUDENT. It is undisputed that the District attempted to work with STUDENT’s parents to have Ms. Isaak continue to provide services to STUDENT, and it is undisputed that Ms. Isaak’s services were skillfully delivered to STUDENT. However, the staffing problems relating to Ms. Issak’s illness do not exempt the District from its obligation to provide timely speech-language services to STUDENT.

The Hearing Officer notes that according to PARENT’s September 22, 2001 letter to the District, the District needed to make up 39 hours of therapy services as of that date. Additionally, STUDENT may have missed additional hours of speech-language services between September 22 and the point at which Ms. Wilms began providing speech-language services in October 2001. Taking into account the circumstances as outlined above, the Hearing Officer determines that STUDENT needs to make up the loss of speech-language therapy services, and therefore awards Petitioner one hour of speech-language services for each hour that the District was still in arrears (with appropriate credit given for make-up sessions), up to the date when Ms. Wilms started providing speech-language therapy services to STUDENT in October 2001. According to Ms. Segal’s testimony, STUDENT could benefit from four to five hours of speech-language therapy services per week for a six-month period. Ms. Segal also recommended that STUDENT be reassessed after six months to determine his speech-language therapy needs. Accordingly, when the IEP team first convenes to implement the award of compensatory education in speech-language services, Ms. Segal’s opinion should be considered when determining the total number of hours per week (agreed-upon IEP speech-language services in addition to compensatory services) STUDENT will receive. The compensatory hours are to be made up by the District within one calendar year of the date of this Decision.

ORDER

1. Within fifteen (15) calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting for implementation of the compensatory education award in accordance with the determination under Issue No. 6.

2 A. Within thirty (30) calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall conduct an oral motor assessment by a speech-language pathologist, a sensory motor assessment by an occupational therapist, and an auditory processing assessment by an audiologist. If the Petitioner provides a copy of Ms. Segal’s oral motor assessment for consideration by the IEP team, the District members may then decide whether to accept Ms. Segal’s assessment in lieu of conducting its own oral motor assessment.

2 B. STUDENT’s parents shall make STUDENT reasonably available for the assessments identified in paragraph 2A of this Order.

2 C. Upon receipt of the District assessments (and/or acceptance of Ms. Segal’s assessment), the District shall convene an IEP meeting to develop goals and objectives for STUDENT, if appropriate, in light of the assessment(s) results.

3. Within thirty (30) days’ receipt of proof, the District is directed to reimburse the STUDENT’s parents for the cost of Ms. Wilms’ assessment in accordance with the Hearing Officer’s determination of Issue No. 3, and to reimburse the STUDENT’s parents for mileage between their home in Lake Arrowhead and the school program during the period November 5, 1998 through 1999 ESY, at the mileage rate the District reimburses its employees, in accordance with the Hearing Officer’s determination of Issue No. 5.

4. All other claims for relief made by Petitioner are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

In accordance with California Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

1. Did the District appropriately assess STUDENT’s needs in the areas of:

A. oral motor and sensory motor during the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years, and extended school years (ESYs)?

B. auditory processing during the 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs?

C. vision during the 2001-2002 school year and ESY?

D. social skills development during the 2001-2002 school year and ESY? **The Petitioner substantially prevailed on Issues 1A and 1B. The Respondent prevailed on Issues 1C. Neither party prevailed on Issue 1D.

2. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to independent assessments in the area of oral and sensory motor, auditory processing, and vision therapy? **The Petitioner prevailed on the oral motor and sensory motor assessment issue to the extent that STUDENT requires assessments in those areas. Petitioner also prevailed on the auditory processing assessment issue. Petitioner did not prevail on the requirement that the oral motor, sensory motor, and auditory processing assessments be conducted by independent assessors. The Respondent prevailed on the vision therapy assessment issue.

3. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessment of Ms. Wilms? **The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

4. Did the District fail to provide or offer STUDENT a FAPE by

A. failing to develop IEPs appropriate to address his unique needs during the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, 2000-2001, and 2001-2002 school years and ESYs?

B. failing to provide speech and language services as provided for in his IEPs during the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years and ESYs? **Neither party prevailed on Issue A because the issue is premature. Petitioner substantially prevailed on Issue B for the 2000-2001 school year and ESY and the 2001-2002 school year, up to October 2001.

5. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for

A. the DIR and/or speech-language therapy services provided by Ms. Wilms during the 2001-2002 school year and ESY? **The Respondent prevailed on this issue.

B. the mileage costs for transporting STUDENT to and from his school program during the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs? **The Petitioner prevailed on the Issue for the 1998-1999 school year beginning on November 5, 1998 through the 1999 ESY. The Respondent prevailed on the 1999-2000, 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs.

C. the actual costs of staffing STUDENT’s in-home program during the 2000-2001, 2001-2002 school years and ESYs? **The Respondent prevailed on this issue.

6. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during any or all of the above-mentioned school years and ESYs, is he entitled to compensatory education? **The Petitioner prevailed to the extent that the District failed to provide speech- language services during the 2000-2001 school year and ESY until October 2001.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal.Educ.Code § 56505(i).

Date: September 18, 2002 __________________________________________ Mark D. Brylski, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. Playworks was formerly known as Pediatric Developmental Associates.

2. The issues reflect discussions with the parties on the first day of hearing, and as supplemented by Petitioner’s “expanded” statement of issues and proposed resolutions dated May 20, 2002. The parties consented to the revised statement of issues. The issues are reworded and rearranged by the Hearing Officer to facilitate discussion and analysis. Issues raised by Petitioner relating to alleged violations of Sections “504" and “1983,” are not addressed because they are not within the jurisdiction of the Hearing Office. California Education Code § 56501(a).

3. Petitioner referred to the assessment within his issue statement as a “developmental assessment for purposes of determining DIR services as they recommended in their May [31] 2001 IEP.” DIR, an acronym meaning “Developmental, Individual-Difference, Relationship-Based” is a model or methodology developed by Dr. Stanley Greenspan. The District contended that the assessment it agreed to conduct at the May 31 IEP meeting was to determine STUDENT’s needs in a “global” or developmental way. During the IEP meeting, Petitioner’s mother referred to the assessment as one that addressed STUDENT’s need for “social skills.” The Hearing Officer therefore uses the expression “social skills development” as the area of need for STUDENT necessitating an assessment, without assuming that a particular methodology is intended.

4. Petitioner’s stated issue number five, “Would it be detrimental to Petitioner to sever his speech-language and DIR programs [with Ms. Wilms]?” is not addressed in this Decision, because it is premature. Neither party sought a determination on the appropriateness of STUDENT’s program and services for the 2002-2003 school year and ESY. The last IEP meeting held for STUDENT on March 8, 2002, only resulted in an agreement for services extending from March 8, 2002, to July 30, 2002.

5. The “in-home” program was generally provided at STUDENT’s parents’ office in the city of San Bernardino. STUDENT’s parents are marriage and family therapists.

6. Petitioner’s request for due process was filed on November 5, 2001. California Education Code Section 56505(j) provides that the request for due process must be filed “within three years from the date the party initiating the request knew or had reason to know of the facts underlying the basis for the request.” Accordingly, this Decision only addresses issues raised by Petitioner for the period beginning on November 5, 1998, through the 2001-2002 school year and ESY, and through the date the record closed.

7. STUDENT continued to receive DTT services from WWA from July 1999 through the hearing in June 2002.

8. The letter does not indicate that, apparently, Ms. Wilms had already conducted her DIR assessment on July 3, 2001.

9. The SELPA’s DIR program is described at Pet. Exh. 197.

10. The CDE issued a compliance report on November 2, 2001, finding that the District and county of office of education/county superintendent of schools (CSS) were “out of compliance” for failure to implement the December 20, 2000 and May 31, 2000 IEPs in the amount of 47 hours of LSH services, including compensatory LSH services, and that the District and CSS had not conducted an assessment in accordance with the May 31, 2001 IEP. (Pet. Exhs. 457-467)

11. During the discussion of issues held on the first hearing day, Petitioner acknowledged that he did not dispute whether the assessments used by the District were racially, culturally or sexually discriminatory, or whether the materials were provided in the student’s primary language, or dispute whether the instruments were validated for the purpose for which they were used or were administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions. Rather, Petitioner contends that the District failed to conduct appropriate assessments in all areas of suspected/known disability. California Education Code Section 56320.

12. During her assessment, Ms. Segal administered an oral peripheral examination, the Kaufman Speech Praxis Test, and the Goldman-Fristoe Test of Articulation. Ms. Segal stated that she found STUDENT to have significant oral motor issues and apraxia of speech, including multiple articulation errors that are inconsistent in nature (“a hallmark of...apraxia of speech.”) Ms. Segal also found that STUDENT spoke at a very rapid rate at times that further exacerbated his unintelligibility and that his volume was variable and often inaudible so that she had to ask him to repeat himself.

13. Ms. Wray testified that she has been an occupational therapist for five years and stated that she has had additional training in the Beckman Oral Motor protocol for oral motor intervention. Ms. Wray also stated that she is certified in the Sensory Integration and Praxis Test (SIP), based upon her extensive training in sensory integration and with the use and administration of the SIP.

14. Neither party called the occupational therapist, Ms. Apolinar, who wrote the report, to testify at the hearing.

15. Within a final mediation agreement dated September 11, 2000, the District agreed to conduct an assessment in “central auditory processing.” (Pet. Exh. 129) The agreement was entered into evidence by Petitioner without objection by the District.

16. PARENT testified that the SELPA referred STUDENT to Dr. Bescoby for a vision assessment because STUDENT “squints quite a bit, looks peripherally either way” and “does some eye fluttering.”

17. As discussed below, by accepting the assessment and by in effect making the assessment its own, the District became financially responsible for paying for it. This finding is consistent with Petitioner’s entitlement to a free appropriate public education.

18. Ms. Segal was not identified by Petitioner as a rebuttal witness until the late afternoon of the hearing on June 3, 2002. Petitioner withdrew his request to enter Ms. Segal’s written assessment report into evidence.

19. Although neither party argued the applicability of Section 56321(a) to the facts in this case, even if the District was not obligated to conduct an assessment of STUDENT during the summer 2001 in accordance with Section 56321(a), once the District agreed to conduct an assessment and then decided not to pursue one after accepting Ms. Wilms’ assessment at the August 31, 2001 IEP meeting, the District became obligated to pay for the assessment.

20. The District also noted its acceptance of Ms. Wilms’ assessment at the December 7, 2001 IEP meeting as its response to the CDE compliance finding that the District had failed to conduct an assessment in accordance with the May 31, 2001 IEP.

21. Petitioner contends that to the extent that the District failed to assess in all areas of suspected disability, the District likewise failed to develop IEP goals and objectives appropriate to address his unique needs the specific areas of alleged need (oral and sensory motor, auditory processing, vision, and social-emotional development).

22. Ms. Wilms testified that DIR is a developmental approach to intervention (as opposed to a behavioral approach (DTT). Ms. Wilms stated that the model focuses on where STUDENT “derailed” to fill in the gaps in the areas of socio-emotional development and communication skills and integrates communication, problem solving, and social interaction. Ms. Wilms also stated that the DIR model addressed STUDENT’s rote-like play skills and communication skills (“most of his words were just rote labels...he wasn’t using them to communicate on a social basis”) that were “prop-dependent” and “severely constricted in terms of intentions.” Ms. Wilms stated that she works with STUDENT about 4 ½ hours per week and does not separate DIR consultative services from the speech-language therapy services she provides to him.

23. It is also undisputed that the District proposed to increase the number of hours STUDENT attended Kimberly in order to increase his opportunity for developing social skills by imitating his peers. (Test. of Mr. Frederick)

24. Ms. Wellner stated that she has a master’s degree in special education and a master’s degree in educational administration, California teaching credentials in single subject and learning handicapped and has “just applied” for an educational administration credential. Ms. Wellner has also taught first and fourth grades as a general education teacher in California. Ms. Wellner stated that she has been working with autistic children since 1994, beginning as a special education SDC teacher in Fontana. Ms. Wellner has also provided numerous training sessions in autism in the areas of PECS, TEACCH, structured teaching training, behavioral training specific to student’s with autism, and then DIR training, both floor-time and DIR-based, on a particular student for a particular staff. Ms. Wellner stated that she had given, at the time of her testimony on June 3,2002, at least twenty training sessions in autism, and has been in contact with “quite a few” other individuals, other than Dr. Cullinane of Pasadena concerning DIR, and has attended training programs for staff members conducted by Sara Trimball, a supervisor at Creative Home programs.

25. Ms. Wilms testified that she had not yet completed the private, Greenspan certification process and that the State of California does not issue either a public certification or a credential in the Greenspan methodology.

26. The amount referred to includes the speech-language therapy services provided by Ms. Wilms beginning in October 2001, in addition to the make-up services owed by the District prior to October 2001.

27. The Hearing Officer does not address the District’s contention that STUDENT was also offered an appropriate placement within his home school District (Rim of the World). The District did not provide evidence to establish the offer’s appropriateness. Moreover, the District was obligated to provide appropriate transportation services to STUDENT while he attended the school program in Rialto.

28. The Hearing Officer notes that although Petitioner offered no direct testimony concerning the length of time for a bus ride between STUDENT’s home and the Kimberly school in Redlands, it is reasonable to assume that the ride would have taken one hour each way.

29. It is undisputed that STUDENT’s parents and other parents communicated their concern during the meeting held on May 11, 2002, at the superintendent’s office that Ms. Isaak continue to serve as the speech-language therapist for their children and that a decision was subsequently made to continue Ms. Isaak’s itinerant status, notwithstanding her chronic illness. It is unclear, however, whether STUDENT’s parents ever stated that they would accept no one other than Ms. Isaak to act as STUDENT’s speech-language therapist.