California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 24, 2002
Student v. Temecula Valley Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 2415-01 · Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard
Temecula Valley Unified denied FAPE for three-plus years; must fund IEEs, rescind diploma, and provide three years of compensatory services.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted in the decision. Footnote 2 says the issues were revised during the hearing and Petitioner's separate due process request about the Hein IEE was withdrawn after that issue was added to this case.
Summary
A 19-year-old student challenged her program at Temecula Valley Unified School District from February 1998 through her senior year in 2000-2001. In 1997 the district made her eligible under "limited cognitive functioning." Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard found the 1997 assessment relied on the Matrix Analogies Test and Woodcock-Johnson cognitive subtests. These are intelligence tests barred for African-American students under Larry P. v. Riles. The label in effect treated her as having an intellectual disability and lowered expectations and services. The district's assessments also missed her speech-language, adaptive, social-emotional, memory, and health needs, including frequent sleeping in class. The district must reimburse $2,000 for independent evaluations by psychologist Dr. Robert Patterson and speech-language pathologist Joanne Hein.
The Hearing Officer found a denial of FAPE in every year at issue. Goals could not be measured, no speech therapy was offered, transition planning was thin, and ESY was either not offered (1998) or not described (1999). In May 2000, district staff held an IEP meeting without the parents and never told them about a Lindamood-Bell offer. Issuing a diploma during the hearing, without prior written notice, violated stay put. The district must rescind the diploma, fund an auditory processing evaluation, and provide three years of compensatory services. These are the Bridge workability program, three hours of weekly speech therapy, intensive Lindamood-Bell reading instruction, and self-advocacy training.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied Larry P. v. Riles to tests that are not on the state's banned list but act as IQ measures. It also shows how a cognitive eligibility label can shape services. It treated a mid-hearing diploma as a stay put violation, and it ordered compensatory services to start right away rather than after age 22.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 1. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the independent educational evaluations by clinical and educational psychologist Dr. Robert Patterson and/or by speech and language pathologist Joanne Hein?
The district's 1997 and 2000 triennials and its February 2001 speech assessment were not appropriate. They relied on intelligence and vocabulary tests barred for African-American students under Larry P. v. Riles, and they did not assess speech-language, adaptive, social-emotional, memory, or health (in-class sleeping) needs. The district must reimburse both IEEs, $2,000 total.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2a. Did the District deny a FAPE by failing to offer an appropriate program, including speech and language services, for the 1997-1998 school and ESY year, beginning February 7, 1998?
The ninth-grade RSP program denied FAPE. It had no writing or targeted math goals, the reading goal could not be measured, and it offered no speech-language services. Because a discriminatory test understated her potential, it was not reasonably calculated to provide benefit. No ESY was offered for 1998, and the district gave no reason.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2b. Did the District deny a FAPE by failing to offer an appropriate program, including speech and language services, for the 1998-1999 school and ESY year?
The tenth-grade program denied FAPE. The move to SDC came late, the reading goal could not be measured, transition plans covered only grades, community service, and a driver's license, and no speech services were offered. The 1999 ESY was not described in the IEP, and the district offered no evidence about it.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2c. Did the District deny a FAPE by failing to offer an appropriate program, including speech and language services, for the 1999-2000 school and ESY year?
The January 1999 IEP and the April 2000 offer did not meet the student's needs in reading comprehension, functional math, social skills, transition, or speech-language. For the 2000 ESY, the district held a May 2000 IEP meeting without the parents after they had canceled it and never told them it was offering Lindamood-Bell instruction. These procedural violations denied FAPE.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2d. Did the District deny a FAPE by failing to offer an appropriate program, including speech and language services, for the 2000-2001 school year?
From fall 2000 to April 3, 2001, the offers did not address the student's needs. Her progress in math did not cure that, because offers are judged when made. The April 4, 2001 IEP offered only vague speech consultation with no goals and was not implemented, because the district did not realize the parents had consented. Issuing a regular diploma during the hearing, without prior written notice, violated stay put and denied FAPE.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. If the District denied a FAPE during any of the above years, is Petitioner entitled to compensatory education and other remedies available under State and federal law?
The student was awarded three years of compensatory services starting immediately: the Bridge workability program, speech-language therapy, Lindamood-Bell reading instruction, and self-advocacy training. The Hearing Officer declined the request to start services after age 22 as speculative.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Within 10 business days of the decision, the district must rescind the student's high school diploma and issue a certificate of completion.
- Reimbursement. Within 10 business days, the district must reimburse $2,000 for the independent evaluations by Dr. Robert Patterson and Joanne Hein ($1,000 each).
- Order to assess. Within 10 business days, if it has not already done so, the district must prepare an assessment plan for an audiologist to evaluate the student for central auditory processing disorder and arrange a prompt evaluation. The IEP team must meet within 10 days of receiving the results to modify the IEP as needed.
- Compensatory education. Transition services: regular attendance at the district's Bridge/Workability program until age 22, with transition goals updated each year. The IEP team decides whether participation ends December 31, 2004 or continues through the end of the 2004-2005 school year (Ed. Code § 56026(c)(4)(C)).
- Compensatory education. Speech-language: 3 hours per week of intensive services from a licensed speech-language pathologist, using Ms. Hein's goals and objectives as the baseline. In the first year, at least 2 hours per week must be one-on-one; the remaining hour may be small group. After that, the therapist sets the mix. Services last three years, including summers, with two weeks allowed for vacations and holidays.
- Compensatory education. Reading comprehension: intensive Lindamood-Bell instruction (Visualizing and Verbalizing and Seeing Stars), at least 4 hours a day, 5 days a week, for at least 6 weeks in ESY 2002. The IEP team then decides whether to continue Lindamood-Bell or use another multisensory, structured program such as Project Read. Reading compensatory services last three years, including summers, and all summer programs must match this intensity. The IEP team sets the school-year amount.
- Compensatory education. Self-advocacy: participation in a self-advocacy program like the one Dr. Patterson described, covering relationships with same-age peers, access to community services, and employment. The IEP team sets the timing.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. No later than six months before the student's 22nd birthday, the IEP team must meet to review her present levels and her completion of the compensatory services, and to decide whether she needs more services to transition into supported employment and independent living.
Total: $2,000 ordered
Key authorities
Board of Educ. v. Rowley; Larry P. v. Riles; Crawford v. Honig; W.G. v. Target Range School Dist.; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Adams v. Oregon; School Comm. of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ.; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. Missouri; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.; Mrs. B. v. Milford Bd. of Educ.; Hoeft v. Tucson Unified School Dist.; Student v. Novato Unified School District (SEHO 1995); Student v. Ravenswood Elementary School District (SEHO 1998)
People named in the decision
- Eric (Rick) Hollins, school psychologist, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Cory Page, SDC teacher and case carrier (emergency credential in physical education), Temecula Valley High School
- Robert Alban, RSP teacher and case carrier, Temecula Valley High School
- Peggy Dixon, SDC teacher, case carrier; Bridge program teacher, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Linda Niotis, SDC teacher and department chair, Temecula Valley High School
- Pamela (Pam) Metzger, district language, speech and hearing specialist, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Dr. Robert Patterson, clinical and educational psychologist; independent evaluator and expert witness for Student
- Joanne Hein, private speech-language pathologist; independent evaluator and witness for Student
- Dr. Clifford Corman, M.D., psychiatrist; private evaluator and witness for Student
- Dr. John Hannaman, former district speech therapist, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Diane Castro, regular education teacher, Temecula Valley High School
- Vicki Alban, SDC teacher, Temecula Valley High School
- Tamara Kinney, school counselor, Temecula Valley High School
- Yvonne Beaman, assistant principal, Temecula Valley High School
- Troy Knudsvig, program specialist, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Roxanne Hunter, school nurse, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Deborah Miller, director of special education, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- DeAnne Johnson, school psychologist, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Lisa Marie Dorn, school psychologist, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Donna Ramirez, workability coordinator, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Mr. Mart, general education teacher, Temecula Valley High School
- Pam Ford, general education teacher, Temecula Valley High School
- Ms. Teahan, general education teacher, Temecula Valley High School
- Michael Arroyo, ESY teacher, Temecula Valley High School
- Mr. Cariss, RSP teacher, Temecula Valley High School
- Mr. Crownover, TPP Careers teacher, Temecula Valley High School
- Lindamood-Bell, private reading/language instruction provider (ordered compensatory provider)
- Kaiser Permanente, private provider; 1993 psychoeducational evaluation
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Temecula, California, on March 1 and 2, April 24 and 25, May 24 and 25, June 7 and 8, July 19, 20, 26, and 27, and November 11 and 14, 2001.
Petitioner STUDENT (hereafter, Petitioner or STUDENT) was present at the hearing on March 1, 2001. She was represented by attorneys Shelli Lewis, Jonathan Barron, and Don Gonzalez.(Footnote 1) Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was her mother, Student’s Mother, and, on some days, her father, Student’s Father. Respondent Temecula Valley Unified School District (hereafter, Respondent or District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Nancy Stephens. Also present on the District’s behalf on most hearing days was special education director Deborah Miller.
Petitioner called the following witnesses: District school psychologist Eric Hollins, teachers Cory Page, Robert Alban, Peggy Dixon and Linda Niotis, speech pathologist Pamela Metzger, STUDENT’s Mother, private clinical psychologist Dr. Patterson, private speech pathologist Joanne Hein, and Dr. Corman, MD. The District called the following witnesses: former District speech therapist Dr. John Hannaman, teachers Diane Castro and Vicki Alban, school counselor Tamara Kinney, Temecula Valley High School (TVHS) assistant principal Yvonne Beaman, program specialist Troy Knudsvig, school nurse Roxanne Hunter, speech pathologist Pamela Metzger, special education director Deborah Miller, and school psychologists Eric Hollins, DeAnne Johnson and Lisa Marie Dorn.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. At the conclusion of the hearing, the record remained open to allow the parties to submit written closing arguments. Thereafter, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for a decision.
ISSUES(Footnote 2)
1. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs associated with the independent educational evaluations (IEEs) conducted by clinical and educational psychologist Dr. Robert Patterson and/or by speech and language pathologist Joanne Hein?
2. Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) by failing to offer her an appropriate program, including speech and language services, for the following school years and/or extended school years (ESY):
a. the 1997-1998 school and ESY year, beginning on February 7, 1998,(Footnote 3) b. the 1998-1999 school and ESY year, c. the 1999-2000 school and ESY year, and/or d. the 2000-2001 school year?(Footnote 4)
3. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during any of the above years, is she entitled to compensatory education and other remedies available under State and federal law?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Petitioner contends that the District denied her a FAPE essentially throughout her high school career at Temecula Valley High School (TVHS), extending from February 7, 1998, during the second half of her ninth grade year, through her senior year in the 2000-2001 school year. Specifically, Petitioner contends that the District failed to identify her unique needs and failed to design goals and objectives to address her unique needs. Petitioner contends that she did not meet any of the goals and objectives drafted for her during these years and did not make progress in the areas of reading comprehension, written language, math, social-emotional needs, and self-help. Petitioner asserts that the District failed to offer her speech therapy and extended school year services, offered inadequate extended school year programs, failed to offer appropriate transition services, improperly modified her grades and failed to specify in the individualized education program (IEP) that her grades were to be modified.
Petitioner asserts that the District conducted assessments using intelligence test instruments banned for use with African-American students pursuant to the decision in Larry P. v. Riles, 495 F. Supp. 926, and subsequent interpretation by the California Department of Education (CDE). Although Petitioner does not directly challenge her eligibility classification for special education and related services, she asserts that the District’s determination that she was a student with “limited cognitive functioning” was, in effect, a determination that she was mentally retarded. This in turn led to reduced expectations of and services to her, with the result that she received no educational benefit.
Procedurally, Petitioner asserts that the District conducted IEP meetings without the parents, failed to make complete offers of placement, and failed to maintain STUDENT’s school records documenting her progress in the form of progress records, notes and work samples. Finally, Petitioner contends that the District inappropriately issued her a regular high school diploma during the pendency of the due process hearing and contrary to the parties’ agreement that she would receive a certificate of completion. Petitioner seeks compensatory education of day-for-day services for the three years that FAPE was allegedly denied her and asks that these compensatory services, including speech and language therapy, begin only after she has turned twenty-two. She also requests reimbursement for the costs of independent educational evaluations by Dr. Patterson and Ms. Hein.
Respondent contends that it provided STUDENT with a FAPE for each of the academic years at issue and that the IEP team appropriately offered STUDENT speech and language services at the IEP meeting of April 4, 2001.(Footnote 5) Respondent asserts that STUDENT’s eligibility classification as a student with “limited cognitive functioning” did not affect the level or type of services it provided to her and that these educational services were sufficiently beneficial to enable her to meet all District requirements for graduation in June 2001. Respondent further contends that it continues to provide STUDENT with special education, including speech therapy services in a consultative/collaborative format, in its Bridge workability program, which is designed for special education students between eighteen and twenty-two years of age who demonstrate a need for additional instruction in functional living skills and training in employment through supervised work experience. In Respondent’s view, if it is determined that a FAPE was denied, Petitioner is not entitled to day-for-day compensatory education or any other remedies beyond the 2004-2005 school year, when STUDENT will reach age twenty-two. Respondent further asserts that reimbursement for independent educational evaluations by Dr. Patterson and Ms. Hein should be denied because its psychoeducational and speech and language assessments of STUDENT were appropriate. Finally, Respondent asserts that it issued STUDENT’s diploma without an intent to end her education and that it is willing to rescind her diploma if ordered to do so by the Hearing Officer.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
STUDENT is currently nineteen years old and is a student of African-American descent. When she was in the fourth grade, her family moved to Temecula from San Diego, where both of STUDENT’s Parents worked as police officers. From January 1994 through February 1997, STUDENT was found eligible by the District for special education and related services as an individual with a speech or language disorder and she received speech and language services. In February 1997, following STUDENT’s triennial assessment, the IEP team changed her eligibility classification. STUDENT was released from speech and language and determined to be eligible as an individual with “limited cognitive functioning.” The IEP team determined that STUDENT had “general deficits in cognitive functioning, adaptive behaviors, and academic functioning.” Throughout high school, STUDENT was categorized as a student of limited cognitive functioning. She received resource specialist program (RSP) services in the ninth grade and half of the tenth grade. In January 1999, STUDENT’s placement was changed from RSP to special day class (SDC). At the time the due process hearing began, STUDENT was completing her senior year and, in the District’s view, on track to graduate with a regular high school diploma in June of 2001. At an IEP meeting in April 2001, however, the IEP team had agreed that STUDENT would participate in graduation ceremonies but would receive a “certificate of completion” rather than a diploma, which would allow her to continue to receive services. The IEP team offered STUDENT placement during the 2001 extended school year in its Bridge workability program for 18-to-22-year-olds, that focuses on practical life skills. In June 2001, during the course of the due process hearing, the District issued STUDENT a high school diploma. At the conclusion of the hearing, STUDENT was continuing to participate in the Bridge program at the District.
February 1997 Triennial Evaluation and IEP
When STUDENT began attending ninth grade at Temecula Valley High School (TVHS) in the fall of 1997, her February 27, 1997 triennial review IEP was still in effect. During the triennial assessment conducted for this IEP, school psychologist Deanne Johnson administered various standardized test instruments to STUDENT, including the Matrix Analogies Test (MAT) and the Woodcock Johnson Psycho-Educational Test Battery-Revised Test of Cognition, subtests of verbal reasoning and verbal conceptual development. STUDENT demonstrated below average abilities in abstract problem solving and nonverbal reasoning and received a standard score of 69 on the MAT. She had difficulty generalizing concepts and strategies and seemed to make random guesses rather than to problem-solve. A test of adaptive behavior revealed that STUDENT could not read an analog clock and had difficulty counting change. STUDENT’s scores on the Wide Range Assessment of Memory and Learning (WRAML) were consistently in the below average range, with one in the deficient range. STUDENT demonstrated a short auditory memory for simple to more complex information. On memory tasks of visual information, she did not recall designs for reproduction after a few moments. From this test, Ms. Johnson concluded that STUDENT had general processing difficulties, in both visual and auditory areas.
At the time of this triennial assessment, STUDENT was eligible for special education as a student with a speech or language impairment. Speech and language therapist Dr. John Hannaman administered the Expressive One Word Picture Vocabulary Test (EOWPVT) and the Receptive One Word Picture Vocabulary Test (ROWPVT) to STUDENT. Her standard scores on these tests were 80 and 82 respectively, in the borderline range. Dr. Hannaman noted that STUDENT did not want pull-out services. He determined that STUDENT’s test scores were commensurate with her ability level and recommended that she be released from speech and language therapy. The assessment team then recommended that STUDENT be made eligible for special education “due to limited cognitive abilities with commensurate deficits in academic and adaptive behavior skills.” The assessment report indicated that “although STUDENT appears to fall within a more ‘borderline’ than an extremely low range, the IEP Team members all expressed concern about STUDENT’s applied academic and adaptive skills which cannot be remediated in the regular education program alone.”
At the February 27, 1997 triennial review, the IEP team changed STUDENT’s special education eligibility from speech or language impairment to “limited cognitive functioning” with “general deficits in cognitive functioning, adaptive behaviors, and academic functioning.” STUDENT was placed in the RSP program for thirteen percent of her school day. The IEP team determined that STUDENT’s special education areas of needs were in language arts and support math. It determined that modifications would be required in all regular classes to help STUDENT apply skills, and noted that she benefits from repetition of information and key concepts. No related services were offered.
Several areas of weakness were identified in STUDENT’s present levels of performance on the triennial IEP. STUDENT had a relative weakness in reading comprehension, and low reasoning and inferential skills. Spelling in context was a relative strength for STUDENT, but she was weak in grammar. In math, while STUDENT demonstrated a strength in calculation, she had poor math reasoning. STUDENT had a deficit in visual memory. STUDENT’s social-emotional functioning was described as “good attitude, friendly, good work habits, resistant only when conceptual thinking/reasoning is involved.” No health concerns were noted. In career/vocational, the IEP team noted that STUDENT “needs early job training. Learning keyboard skills.” In the area of self-help, a difficulty using money and reading a clock was noted. The IEP team drafted two annual goals for STUDENT to accomplish by the middle of ninth grade in February 1998. STUDENT was to “improve reading skills” by passing reading comprehension questions and vocabulary tests at the fourth grade level, and “to improve math skills” by receiving grades of C or better in regular math class, and by attending math lab at least twice a week and learning money changing skills. March 2, 1998 Annual Review
RSP teacher Robert Alban was STUDENT’s case carrier for the second half of the ninth grade at TVHS. On March 2, 1998, toward the end of her freshman year, Mr. Alban convened STUDENT’s annual review IEP team meeting. STUDENT and both of her parents were present at the IEP meeting and her eligibility as a student with limited cognitive functioning was confirmed. The IEP team determined that STUDENT’s special education areas of need were in English, math, health and physical science, and increased her participation in the RSP program from thirteen to forty-seven percent. No related services were offered. An ESY program was not offered. STUDENT would receive assistance as needed from instructional assistants in regular education classes and she would be given extra time on tests that she would be allowed to take in the resource room.
The IEP team determined that STUDENT’s present level of performance in reading was at approximately the fourth-grade level, with a relative weakness in comprehension. Her written language skills were also at fourth-grade level and she had difficulty with sentence structures, mechanics, and spelling. In math, STUDENT had a weakness in calculations (fractions) and reasoning. STUDENT had deficits in visual memory, a weak vocabulary, and age appropriate social-emotional functioning. A recent health problem with STUDENT’s “knees and headaches” was noted.
STUDENT had not met her math goal and had only partially met her reading goal from the February 1997 IEP. Two new annual goals, to be accomplished by March 1999, were written: STUDENT was “to write an organized paragraph,” and “to comprehend textbooks,” in her RSP health, physical science, world history and English classes. The IEP team also prepared an Individualized Transition Plan (ITP) that set forth three goals: STUDENT was to complete four hours of community service, turn in at least 90% of all assignments, and enroll in a driver’s education program, and pass the driver’s examination. STUDENT’s Father consented to the IEP.
January 1999 IEP: Transfer to SDC
STUDENT entered the tenth grade in the fall of 1998 and continued in the RSP program pursuant to the March 1998 IEP. During this school year, case carrier Mr. Alban recommended that STUDENT’s placement be changed to the special day class (SDC) program because STUDENT’s teachers advised him she was having difficulty passing regular education classes and needed additional time and modifications. Mr. Alban also believed that STUDENT was losing ground with his modified RSP curriculum, because it was small-group work and she required one-on-one assistance. Mr. Alban spoke to STUDENT’s parents two to three times to let them know that she was struggling and that her needs were not being met in RSP. He recalled that the parents were initially reluctant to change her placement but eventually advised him that they believed SDC would be in STUDENT’s best interest.
On December 16, 1998, Mr. Alban prepared a notification to the parents of an IEP meeting scheduled for January 5, 1999 at their request to discuss a possible change of placement to the SDC program as a result of STUDENT’s failure in drivers’ education and RSP English. STUDENT’s Father indicated that he would attend the scheduled meeting. At the hearing, Mrs. PARENT testified that both she and STUDENT’s Father were unable to attend the January 5 IEP meeting because, as part of their job duties, they were both under subpoena to testify in superior court. She also testified that she had left a message with the District to this effect and had requested to reschedule the IEP meeting. STUDENT’s Mother testified that the change in placement was not at the parents’ request.
On January 5, 1999, the District conducted the IEP team meeting without the presence of either of STUDENT’s parents. District members of the IEP team were Mr. Alban, SDC teacher Peggy Dixon, general education teacher Mr. Mart, school psychologist Ms. Johnson, and TVHS assistant principal Ms. Beaman. STUDENT was also present. Mr. Alban had no recollection of follow-up contact with the parents about attending the January 5, 1999 IEP meeting, but noted that the IEP documented a telephone contact on January 4, 1999. After confirming her eligibility, the IEP team noted that STUDENT’s current grades, as well as her teachers’ observations, indicated she needed assistance from the special education program for more than fifty percent of her day. STUDENT had failed both Fastrack, and world history. STUDENT was placed in the SDC program for sixty percent of her day in core classes (math, English, reading and U.S. history), with regular education classes in PE, activities and electives. Extended school year was offered. No related services were offered.
The IEP team determined that STUDENT’s present level of performance in reading was below grade level with relative weakness in comprehension and difficulty reading general education textbooks. Mr. Alban testified that he had not formally assessed STUDENT but believed she was reading somewhere between the fourth and fifth grade level, with comparable level writing skills. The IEP indicated that STUDENT had difficulty with basic math facts, had a weak vocabulary, was friendly, cooperative, and respectful, and had age appropriate social-emotional functioning. Under health, the team noted that STUDENT had problems with her knees. In daily living skills, STUDENT was described as able to help with cooking and house cleaning. Her work maturity skills stated that she was “usually on time to class.” Her career/job interest were undecided, with a possible interest in becoming a kindergarten teacher. The IEP team indicated that STUDENT learned best with multi-modal instruction and that her disability made it difficult to comprehend concepts and materials in general education.
The IEP team determined that STUDENT had not met her March 1998 written language goal and had only partially met her reading comprehension goal. Three new goals were drafted: STUDENT was to “improve her math skills utilizing fractions (calculation and word problems),” to “write a three-paragraph essay with proper format, punctuation and spelling,” and to “read six novels and answer comprehension questions with eighty percent accuracy.” Because STUDENT tended not to read at home, two of the six novels were to be read outside of school. The IEP team also developed an ITP for then sixteen-year-old STUDENT with goals to pass all classes with grades of C or better, to complete five hours of community services, and to obtain a driver’s license for employment and post-school living. The transition plan indicated that STUDENT had no unique needs in the areas of daily living skills and that a functional vocational evaluation was “not applicable.”
The IEP team determined that differential high school proficiency standards were to be applied to STUDENT and that proficiency tests were waived. The IEP team also indicated that STUDENT required alternative assessments rather than state and district assessments because “excessive modifications invalidate the tests - standardized tests [W-J Revised] will be given instead.” The team determined that STUDENT was to receive instructional assistance as needed and that her tests were to be given in the SDC room, with reader and extended time as needed. The IEP was sent home with STUDENT for parental review. That same day, STUDENT’s Father signed his consent to IEP.
Following the January 5, 1999 IEP, Peggy Dixon became STUDENT’s new case carrier at TVHS. After STUDENT’s change in placement to SDC, her grade point average increased from a 1.40 in the first trimester of the tenth grade to grade point averages of 3.60 in her second and third trimester of the tenth grade.
IEP Meeting of September 7, 1999
STUDENT entered her eleventh grade in the fall of 1999 and continued in the SDC program pursuant to the January 1999 IEP. In late August 1999, Cory Page became STUDENT’s case carrier and one of her SDC teachers at TVHS. Mr. Page testified that he had an emergency teaching credential in physical education.
On September 7, 1999, an IEP team meeting was held in response to the parents’ request to discuss their concerns about STUDENT’s schedule. The parents believed STUDENT was not being challenged in the SDC program and were considering a change in placement back to RSP. STUDENT’s Mother testified that STUDENT was baking cookies and walking track at school. The IEP meeting was attended by both parents, STUDENT, Ms. Beaman, department chair Linda Niotis, school psychologist Rick Hollins, case carrier Cory Page, and general education teacher Pam Ford. The IEP Team Summary indicates that Ms. Niotis discussed the SDC program, her concerns about STUDENT and her opinion that STUDENT was appropriately placed in the SDC. The parents decided to leave STUDENT in the SDC program. The IEP summary indicated that the “parents were unable to attend last IEP but were informed that any future IEPs will be held at a time when parents can attend.”
In October and December 1999, and January 2000, Mr. Page reported that STUDENT was making progress on her goals. STUDENT received grade point averages of 2.40 in her first trimester and 3.20 in her second trimester.
February 2000 Triennial Assessment
STUDENT’s triennial review was due in February 2000, in the middle of her junior year. District’s proposed assessment plan for STUDENT’s triennial involved a “review of existing information.” On January 30, 2000, STUDENT’s Mother signed the assessment plan and requested an assessment of STUDENT’s cognitive development and learning ability. The District did not propose cognitive testing of STUDENT.
STUDENT’s triennial assessment was conducted by school psychologist Lisa Dorn, SDC teacher Cory Page, and school nurse Roxanne Hunter. In a report dated February 7, 2000, STUDENT was noted to have processing deficits in overall cognitive abilities and to have generally good health, with the exception of knee problems. STUDENT was described as very friendly and cooperative, with behaviors associated with much younger children. For example, during the evaluation, STUDENT spontaneously got out of her chair and attempted to rub the examiner’s shoulders. She also hummed and giggled while completing tasks. STUDENT reported that she enjoyed her SDC classes and that she planned to graduate and get a job with her mother’s help. STUDENT was very active and wiggled in her seat throughout the evaluation. In the assessment report, Ms. Dorn found STUDENT to have “deficits in attention and concentration skills.” At the hearing, Ms. Dorn testified that STUDENT did not present with an attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). She recalled that STUDENT’s behavior seemed developmentally appropriate relative to someone with her cognitive functioning.
In assessing STUDENT for the 2000 triennial, Ms. Dorn reviewed the District’s prior testing, including the Matrix Analogies Test (MAT) administered by Ms. Johnson for the February 1997 triennial, and met with STUDENT for approximately ninety minutes. Ms. Dorn noted that previous assessments had concluded that STUDENT had processing disorders in the area of cognitive abilities. For her 2000 triennial review, STUDENT was administered the Wide Range Assessment of Memory and Learning (WRAML), a general measure of an individual’s memory and processing skills. STUDENT received a memory screening index standard score of 66 with a percentile rank of 1. The assessment indicated that “a standard score of 66 lies in the limited cognitive functioning range and suggests significant deficits in memory and learning abilities. However, an analysis of individual subtest scores suggest relative strengths in the area of visual processing with severe deficits in auditory memory and processing.” Ms. Dorn testified that STUDENT’s teachers should use this information to ensure that their lessons had a visual component. STUDENT’s test results on the Beery Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration (VMI) suggested that she had “significant deficits” in the area of visual-motor integration skills. Ms. Dorn testified that this score meant STUDENT would need longer time to complete her written assignments or for taking notes in class. In math, these deficits might interfere with her perception of shapes and spatial relations in geometry.(Footnote 6)
According to Mr. Page, STUDENT’s strengths were in being on-task, in completing work, and in basic math skills. STUDENT’s academic weaknesses were in “reading comprehension, sentence structure, spelling, and the mechanics of written language.” Mr. Page also assessed STUDENT’s academic achievement for the triennial by administering the Woodcock-Johnson Psycho-Educational Battery-Revised Tests of Achievement (WJ-R TA) and the Test of Written Language-Third (TOWL-III) to her. (Footnote 7)
STUDENT’s social and emotional development was assessed via input from Mr. Page. He indicated that STUDENT appeared to have “limited peer interactions” in class, that her self-esteem “seems to be OK,” and that her attitude in class was appropriate. He noted that STUDENT sometimes displayed immature behaviors. Regarding STUDENT’s career-vocational needs, the assessment noted that STUDENT reported she plans on graduating from high school and that she “will get a job with the assistance of her mother.” STUDENT reported that she enjoyed younger children and might like to be a kindergarten teacher. In summary, the triennial assessment reported that, according to Mr. Page, STUDENT was appropriately placed in SDC program. April 4, 2000 Triennial Review
On April 4, 2000, the IEP team convened for STUDENT’s triennial IEP review. This meeting was attended by Mr. and STUDENT’s Mother, STUDENT, case carrier Cory Page, school psychologist Mr. Hollins, general education teacher Ms. Teahan and TVHS assistant principal Ms. Beaman. STUDENT’s eligibility was confirmed as limited cognitive functioning. The IEP indicated that STUDENT would remain in the SDC program seventy-three percent of her time. STUDENT was determined to be eligible for ESY. No related services were offered.
STUDENT’s present levels of performance were described on the IEP as follows. Her broad reading from the WJ-R was at a 5.6 grade equivalent (SS=81), with a 3.6 grade equivalent in passage comprehension (SS=69). The team noted that STUDENT’s comprehension skills were somewhat limited and that she had “difficulty recognizing setting, details, sequence of events, and plots in her reading.” Her broad mathematics were at a 4.7 grade equivalent (SS=69), with a higher score of 77 in calculation. The team noted that STUDENT possessed good organizational and task-responsibility skills that have helped her to succeed in math. Although STUDENT was able to calculate whole numbers efficiently, she had difficulty with decimals and unlike fractions. In written expression, STUDENT received a standard score of 87 on the TOWL-III. She was noted to have some difficulty with organizing her thoughts, in recognizing syllables and in knowing where to hyphenate words. The IEP team indicated that STUDENT communicated well with adults and peers, sometimes appeared shy but was able to express her thoughts and feelings when necessary. The only health issue noted was “some problem with her knees.”(Footnote 8) STUDENT’s social-emotional development was described as within normal limits. No problems were noted with STUDENT’s daily living skills and she was described as “capable of caring for his [sic] own needs and assisting around the house.” The team noted that STUDENT was interested in becoming a day care worker or teacher. The team noted that STUDENT’s learning preference was to write out instructions and read them back to herself. Parent priorities for STUDENT were to enhance her long term education; i.e, “to be able to function independently upon graduation, social skills to be enhanced, more relationship with her peers. Form concrete ideas for a career.”
The IEP team determined that STUDENT had partially met her math and reading goals and her objectives from the January 1999 IEP, but had not met her written language skill goal to write a three-paragraph essay with proper format, punctuation and spelling. Three new goals were drafted to be met by April 2001: STUDENT was to “be able to add/subtract fractions with unlike denominators,” to “read a 50-100 word passage at the sixth-grade level and answer five written comprehension questions,” and to “write two to three related sentences given a picture or verbal prompts, using correct syntax, punctuation and capitalization.” The IEP team also drafted an individual transition plan for seventeen-year-old STUDENT. Her goals were similar to the previous transition plan but added a goal to fill out job applications, rental agreements by taking two trimesters of TPP careers and child development classes. No activities or goals were listed for daily living skills or functional vocational evaluation.
The IEP team indicated that differential high school proficiency standards would be used for STUDENT. Specifically, “completion of IEP goals will constitute passage of proficiencies for graduation purposes.” The IEP team described STUDENT’s program modifications as “extended and modified assignments.” At this IEP meeting, the District explained to STUDENT the impending transfer of educational rights to her in October 2000, on her eighteenth birthday. At the conclusion of this IEP team meeting, both Mr. and STUDENT’s Mother consented to the IEP program.
Request for Due Process and IEP Addendum of May 25, 2000
On May 3, 2000, the Hearing Office received Petitioner’s first request for due process hearing against the District. Petitioner asserted that she had not received educational benefit, particularly in reading comprehension, because she had only progressed two grade levels between her fifth and eleventh grades (from third- to fifth-grade level) and had been denied individual tutoring. As a proposed resolution, Petitioner requested instruction at the Lindamood Bell center and for placement in a special program or school that would allow her to learn and prepare for life. By late May 2000, Petitioner had provided the District with a signed authorization for release of information to her attorney, Ms. Lewis.
On May 25, 2000, an IEP meeting was scheduled to address the parents’ concerns over STUDENT’s progress. On that date, however, STUDENT’s Mother wrote to Mr. Page to confirm her voice mail of May 23, 2000 canceling the May 25, 2000 IEP meeting and advising him that she would call to reschedule the meeting. The parents sent Mr. Page a separate letter by certified mail indicating that they dissented to the IEP of April 4, 2000, and disagreed with both the goals and objectives and the placement offered to STUDENT by the District. The parents revoked their previous consent to STUDENT’s IEP program, and indicated that they disagreed with the test scores reported, with STUDENT’s present levels of performance, and with the District’s assessment. The parents advised the District that they would seek an independent educational evaluation and would request reimbursement from the District for that evaluation.
On May 25, 2000, the District members of the IEP team conducted the IEP meeting without the parents or STUDENT. According to the IEP addendum, the District was aware that STUDENT’s Mother had canceled the meeting with Mr. Page; however, the District members of the IEP team “met anyway to discuss concern and offer Lindamood-Bell instruction as they previously requested on due process filing.” The IEP documents that the IEP team “agreed to Lindamood-Bell [LMB] instruction to address IEP reading goals/objectives. This instruction will be for the duration of the extended school year (24 days) with an informal reassessment at the end of this time to provide to IEP team in order to determine need for fall instruction using Lindamood methods.” School psychologist Deanne Johnson testified that she had consulted with the director of special education at that time who wanted to make the LMB offer for the ESY 2000. According to Ms. Johnson, Mr. Page as case carrier had the responsibility of notifying the parents about the IEP. In this case, the IEP was never signed by the parents so it was not put in effect.
At the hearing, STUDENT’s Mother testified that she had never been informed of this offer, that she learned it had been made only after she requested STUDENT’s school records for the hearing, that she would have accepted the offer, and that STUDENT never received any services from LMB. Independent Evaluation by Dr. Robert Patterson
On July 21, 2000, clinical and educational psychologist Dr. Patterson conducted an independent psycho-educational assessment of STUDENT at her parents’ request because they believed she had been misdiagnosed as essentially mentally retarded by school staff. An additional purpose of his evaluation was to determine if STUDENT was eligible for Regional Center services. At the time of this assessment, STUDENT was seventeen years ten months old. Dr. Patterson noted that she was obese and hypoactive, friendly and cooperative, but mildly anxious and distractible. Her memory appeared impaired, particularly for remote events. Dr. Patterson conducted extensive testing on STUDENT over a five-hour period, and did a historical review of educational testing administered to her by various school districts from 1993 through 2000.
From his testing of STUDENT to determine her eligibility for Regional Center services, Dr. Patterson determined that STUDENT was not mentally retarded, i.e., that she did not have significantly below average cognitive functioning coupled with adaptive and other processing difficulties.(Footnote9) STUDENT was in the borderline or low average range of functioning. As a consequence, STUDENT would not be eligible for Regional Center services. Dr. Patterson testified that, by using established criteria for determining the intelligence of an African-American student, he would assume STUDENT had an IQ between 70 and 90 and that she functioned between the borderline to the low average range, not in the mentally retarded range. In reaching this conclusion, Dr. Patterson noted that when the District administered to STUDENT various tests of achievement in 1997 and 2000, her scores were not in the retarded range, but in the borderline to low average range.(Footnote 10) As a consequence, the determination that she was of “limited cognitive functioning” conflicted with STUDENT’s historical testing record.
Dr. Patterson assessed STUDENT’s neuropsychological functioning as well as her functioning in the areas of academic achievement, language, memory, social and emotional needs, and adaptive behavior. From his assessment, Dr. Patterson concluded that STUDENT was a student with neurological impairments who had likely suffered anoxic damage during birth when she was delivered with her umbilical cord around her neck. Dr. Patterson testified that STUDENT’s neurological problems were manifested in her memory and attentional problems. To address these problems educationally, she required highly repetitive instruction presented in a multi-sensory teaching method, particularly in the areas of reading, writing and math concepts.
Dr. Patterson diagnosed STUDENT with a cognitive disorder NOS, a mathematics disorder, a developmental coordination disorder (fine motor disorder), and borderline intellectual functioning. Dr. Patterson summarized that both past and present assessment results indicate that STUDENT “is performing in the mid-low average range, which is often labeled as borderline cognitive functioning, particularly if adaptive behaviors are in this same general region. STUDENT has variable performance historically in terms of achievement skills and mathematics is seen as being exceedingly difficult for her....” The Personality Inventory for Children indicated that STUDENT has “achievement difficulties, cognitive and developmental issues as well as possible depression.”
Dr. Patterson recommended that STUDENT receive a full speech and language assessment, that she participate in “social skills training” to learn self-advocacy and social skill, that she be provided instruction in domestic skills and in time concepts, health and safety, and measurement. Dr. Patterson indicated that the District had “not provided any coherent indication for the slow, but steady decline in reading skills and in calculation skills from 1997 to the present time” and that this decline may be due to difficulties with organicity but may also be due to STUDENT’s instructional setting. In his opinion, STUDENT’s deficits in reading, reading comprehension, vocabulary, writing and practical math can be remediated. Although Dr. Patterson agreed that STUDENT’s cognitive abilities would impact her reading comprehension, he testified that STUDENT would be capable of developing her comprehension skills if presented with the correct teaching format. The primary focus should be on teaching STUDENT good decoding skills and visual-verbal strategies for decoding. To remediate STUDENT’s reading, any of the multisensory methods such as Lindamood “Seeing Stars” or Project Read would help if STUDENT was exposed to it consistently for a lengthy period of time. Dr. Patterson testified that a highly redundant teaching system is critical to STUDENT’s ability to store and retrieve information from her short and long term memory. In his opinion, STUDENT would benefit from a program of multisensory instruction in reading and written language to assist her in developing reading and written language skills, and from a program designed to work with concrete manipulatives in mathematics to increase her skills and her mathematic vocabulary.
February 2001 Update to February 2000 Triennial Assessment(Footnote 11)
In February 2001, STUDENT was assessed by TVHS school psychologist Eric Hollins, SDC teacher Linda Niotis, speech and language specialist Pam Metzger and school nurse Roxanne Hunter to provide assessment information to supplement the February 2000 triennial assessment and the assessment information provided by Dr. Robert Patterson.
The supplemental assessment covered several areas in which STUDENT had not been assessed in the 2000 triennial: adaptive functioning, speech and language functioning, daily living skills, socialization, and vocational needs. In the area of adaptive functioning, school psychologist Mr. Hollins noted that STUDENT’s triennial assessment of February 2000 did not include any assessment data that explored her development of adaptive skills at home and school. He noted that Dr. Patterson had conducted an adaptive functioning assessment of STUDENT by administering the Normative Adaptive Behavior Checklist (NABC), completed by the parent, and the Street Survival Skills Questionnaire (SSSQ), completed by STUDENT. On the NABC, STUDENT’s Mother rated STUDENT at the first percentile (SS=66), consistent with an 8.11 year old child. On the SSSQ, STUDENT placed herself at the ninth percentile (SS=80), within the low average range, with skills ranging from high average to the borderline. To supplement this information, Mr. Hollins assessed STUDENT’s adaptive functioning by interviewing STUDENT’s Mother with the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales: Interview Edition. The Vineland results indicated that STUDENT’s adaptive skills ranged from 7.5 year old age equivalent in expressive language functioning to 12.6 year old range in community living skills, with an overall score indicative of a moderate deficit. Ms. Niotis was asked to complete the Adaptive Behavior Evaluation Scale-Revised (ABES-R) based on her personal knowledge of STUDENT in class. STUDENT’s Father was also asked to complete the ABES-R. On the ABES-R, STUDENT’s Father rated STUDENT in the below-average range in all areas of adaptive functioning with a SS of 60, at the fourth percentile. By contrast, Ms. Niotis rated STUDENT in the low-average range in all areas with the exception of self-care which was average. The results of her completion of the ABES-R resulted in a standard score of 81 for STUDENT, at the 12th percentile.
District language, speech and hearing specialist Pam Metzger conducted a speech and language assessment of STUDENT for the supplemental assessment. From her assessment, Ms. Metzger concluded that STUDENT’s overall language scores ranged from low average in receptive vocabulary to the extremely low range in expressive language. In pragmatic language skills, STUDENT’s ability to use language in social situations was on the borderline of moderately low/extremely low range of functioning for a student her age. Ms. Metzger did not include any recommendation for speech therapy services in her report.
To determine STUDENT’s academic functioning, Ms. Niotis administered tests from the Brigance Diagnostic Inventory of Essential Skills, a measure of scholastic achievement.(Footnote 12) At eighteen years three months of age, STUDENT’s reading decoding skills were at the fifth-grade level. In oral reading, her decoding level increased to the seventh-grade level. In reading comprehension, STUDENT scored below the third-grade level, answering only two of the five third-grade level questions correctly. STUDENT was able to provide factual information about the passage but could not state its main idea or define its vocabulary. At the fourth-grade-level, she only answered one of the five correctly. In mathematics, STUDENT’s calculation skills were at the fourth grade level. She could add, subtract, multiply and divide whole numbers and fractions with like and unlike denominators. She can multiply and divide fractions and reduce improper fractions. On math comprehension, STUDENT was at the second-grade level, did not seem to know the operation necessary (e.g., she frequently did not look at the operation sign and would add all the problems) and was also inconsistent in her answers by missing easier ones and correctly performing more complicated tasks. She had no concept of percentage and frequently put decimal points in the wrong spot. In measurement, STUDENT had weaknesses in telling time except for on the half hour or hour and confused conversion of hours, minutes, and seconds. Ms. Niotis summarized that STUDENT performs rote learning tasks well (capitalization, math facts) “but where higher thinking skills are required, STUDENT either doesn’t understand what to do or simply doesn’t bother to figure it out.” Ms. Niotis noted that “when asked to go beyond the Knowledge level in Bloom’s taxonomy, STUDENT puts her head down, goes to sleep, or becomes defiant in an effort to avoid the task.”
STUDENT’s daily living skills were inventoried for the first time in this assessment. Mr. Hollins inventoried in the following areas of knowledge: money and change making, ability to state date, month and year, ability to tell time from an analog clock, self care, ability to care for living quarters and personal property, knowledge of food preparation, and use of telephone for general and emergency communication. Deficits were noted in making or receiving change, ability to tell time, and ability to follow multiple steps for food preparation. In addition, although STUDENT knew to call 911 in an emergency, STUDENT’s Mother believed STUDENT might not remember this in an emergency as she panicked easily.
STUDENT’s prevocational needs were assessed by having her complete the Vocational Preference Inventory and the Discovery Program Inventory to determine her vocational interests. The results of these assessments indicated that STUDENT wanted to work with and help others, be creative and use some organization and/or manual dexterity skills. STUDENT appeared to lack confidence in her skills and abilities and to seek areas where she was most comfortable. It was apparent that STUDENT was aware of her limitations and demonstrated no interest in areas requiring academic skills. STUDENT expressed most interest in child care or care of others but did not want total responsibility for the child. In the socialization domain, STUDENT reported that her best friend is nine years old, that other children in her neighborhood will not play with her, that she prefers younger children and that she has few friends her own age. She reported she spends most of her free time watching television, likes to sleep a lot and collected stickers. STUDENT was reported to be afraid to drive.
In summary, Mr. Hollins indicated that STUDENT demonstrated a range of abilities from fairly average skills to significantly delayed skills. While her receptive vocabulary skills were assessed to be in the average range, her expressive language skills “are significantly delayed relative to her age.” Areas of weakness were her visual sequential memory skills and auditory perceptual abilities. Mr. Hollins noted that STUDENT’s visual motor integration skills have consistently declined, that she was currently unable to complete math problems she had previous correctly completed. On the Woodcock Johnson-Revised, STUDENT’s her reading decoding (letter-word identification) skills increased from a 5.4 grade equivalent in February 1997 to a 7.6 grade equivalent in February 2000; however, her reading comprehension score rose only six months during that same time period.
Mr. Hollins reported that STUDENT demonstrated the ability to perform concrete, rote tasks with some efficiency (e.g., decoding words using phonics). STUDENT “struggles when the comprehension requirements go beyond recalling facts and details.” Inferential reasoning and using context clues to comprehend, interpret and expand on a writer’s words was difficult. STUDENT’s “cognitive weaknesses appear to be most pronounced when she engages in tasks that are not of a rote nature. Tasks which require STUDENT to engage higher order thinking skills such as to think critically, to reason, conceptualization, or the ability to analyze and synthesize information have historically been most challenging for STUDENT. Ultimately, most tasks which require these abilities will continue to be quite challenging...” Mr. Hollins also noted that STUDENT’s comprehension abilities were affected both by her cognitive skills and the fact that she does no outside reading to reinforce what she has learned at school. Mr. Hollins indicated that, while STUDENT was difficult to categorize for eligibility purposes, she needed special education services.
IEP of February 16, 2001
On February 16, 2001, the IEP team met to conduct STUDENT’s annual review and to review her February 2000 triennial evaluation in light of the February 2001 update conducted by Mr. Hollins. The IEP meeting was attended by eighteen year old STUDENT, her mother, her attorney Ms. Lewis, the District’s attorney Ms. Stephens, SDC teacher Ms. Niotas, program specialist Troy Knudsvig, Mr. Hollins, speech pathologist Pam Metzer, and assistant principal Yvonne Beaman. After reviewing STUDENT’s assessments, goals and present levels of performance, the team determined that drafted IEP goals and objectives would be faxed for parents to review and that the IEP team would reconvene in late March 2001. It was also determined that Mr. Knudsvig would escort the parents to visit placement options prior to the next meeting and that the special education workability coordinator would be invited to the next IEP meeting.
IEP of April 4, 2001
On April 4, 2001, the IEP team reconvened for approximately five hours to conclude STUDENT’s annual review and to review the District’s supplemental assessments. STUDENT, now almost eighteen and a half years old, was present with her parents and Ms. Lewis. District members of the IEP team were the new director of special education Deborah Miller, language and speech specialist Pam Metzger, school psychologist Eric Hollins, regular education teacher Diane Castro, TVHS assistant principal Yvonne Beaman, workability coordinator Donna Ramirez, and program specialist Troy Knudsvig. STUDENT’s eligibility as “limited cognitive functioning” was confirmed. The IEP team determined that STUDENT had not met her written language skills goal from her prior IEP, and had only partially met her annual goals in math and reading comprehension. STUDENT had made partial progress on her objectives.
According to Ms. Miller, the primary discussion at this IEP meeting concerned STUDENT continuing for at least a fifth year of high school in the 18-to 22-year-old workability program, with interagency participation. New goals and objectives were discussed during the meeting. The biggest challenge, according to Ms. Miller, was combining STUDENT’s functional skills with some ongoing academic areas of need. The IEP team agreed that Mr. Knudsvig would take the draft goals home, revise them to conform with the discussion at the meeting, and distribute them to the parties.
The finalized IEP document dated April 4, 2001, contained twelve specific annual goals. These goals addressed STUDENT’s needs to learn or improve her survival vocabulary, her functional reading comprehension skills, her written language skills, and her functional math skills. For example, these goals focused on STUDENT’s ability to function in everyday life by targeting her ability to use time management, to correlate meaning between conventional and analog clocks, to recognize different coin and bill combinations and make exact change, to access bus transportation by being able to read schedules, pay fares and take the bus, to calculate measurements and to know measurement equivalencies, to review her written work and edit it for accuracy. Similarly, the ITP offered to STUDENT in the April 4, 2001 IEP included five needed transition services with related goals and activities in the areas of improving functional life skills particularly in math, reading and social skills; becoming mobile throughout the community using public transportation; attaining job skills needed to become an independent adult, pursuing a career of choice and gaining personal achievement; learning to master basic daily living skills relating to being on her own; and participating in workability assessments as needed to measure growth and continued need areas.
The IEP team determined that STUDENT “needs her self-esteem and depression issues addressed.” As a result, the team completed an AB 2726 referral for mental health assessment for STUDENT, who was identified to be “at-risk for depression, is withdrawn.” The referral described STUDENT’s interactions with age peers as “very limited,” her social skills as “significantly below age level,” and her classroom participation as “at times very withdrawn, stays away from groups.” STUDENT “can become easily frustrated when she is faced with difficult tasks.”
The IEP team determined that modified proficiency standards were not to be used for STUDENT and that STUDENT was to follow the general standards. Although District members of the team believed that STUDENT had met general standards for graduation, the IEP team determined that “STUDENT will finish the 2000-01 school year at TVHS...and participate in the graduation ceremonies and other related senior activities. STUDENT will receive a certificate of completion for meeting the credit requirement for high school.”
At the conclusion of this IEP meeting, STUDENT was offered placement in the SDC program for sixty-seven percent of the day through the end of the 2000-2001 school year as well as for the 2001 extended school year through August 3, 2001. The parties dispute whether a fifth-year program was actually offered to STUDENT. The IEP team summary notes indicate that the team would “reconvene in August to address the 5th year placement.” The face sheet of the IEP indicates SDC from August 27, 2001 through April 4, 2002. No related services were identified on the IEP; however, the Team summary notes indicate that the “speech and language pathologist will consult with STUDENT’s teachers on pragmatic, social skills, and vocabulary as well as observe STUDENT’s pronunciation skills.”
Independent Speech and Language Evaluation by Ms. Hein
On April 6, 2001, speech and language pathologist Joanne Hein conducted an independent speech and language evaluation of STUDENT. The purpose of the evaluation was to assess and diagnose STUDENT’s language deficits, to determine whether a central auditory processing disorder could be affecting STUDENT’s performance, and to make educational and pre-vocational recommendations for her.
From her evaluation, Ms. Hein concluded that STUDENT had severe receptive and expressive language deficits secondary to impairments in her attention, selective attention/concentration, storage, retrieval, and higher-order processing of linguistic input. Ms. Hein concluded that “these deficits affect her ability to consistently process and formulate language at a level needed for independent, daily living needs and academic success.” She recommended that STUDENT be referred to an audiologist for further assessment of a central auditory processing disorder that may be affecting her ability to consistent access information. Ms. Hein also recommended that STUDENT receive the remainder of her high school education in an academic environment that can “program” language to her specific needs with appropriate professional support. Ms. Hein indicated that STUDENT’s prognosis “is favorable for functional receptive and expressive language gains, if [she]...can receive intensive speech-language training prior to completing her education and attempting to enter the workforce.” Regarding the estimated frequency and duration of treatment, Ms. Hein recommended that STUDENT receive three hours a week of speech-language treatment for two years, with direct weekly intervention of two and a half hours, and thirty minutes of weekly consultation among treating professionals. Ms. Hein also prepared functional goals in a treatment plan for STUDENT to be used in a school or clinical setting. These detailed goals focus on the development of both expressive and receptive language, retrieval and use of words using visualization and other strategies in curriculum and job-related information, correct articulation in conversational speech, and use of age-appropriate social language skills with specific pragmatic benchmarks. A goal was also developed to provide consultation services to STUDENT’s teachers, family, and treating professionals to support the transfer of new language strategies from structured therapy to academic, social and vocational settings.
Dr. Corman’s Evaluation
On April 18, 2001, STUDENT’s Mother had STUDENT assessed by psychiatrist Dr. Clifford Corman, M.D., to determine whether she met the criteria for attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) under the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual - Fourth Ed. (DSM-IV). Dr. Corman interviewed both STUDENT’s Mother and STUDENT, administered to STUDENT the Test of Variables of Attention (TOVA), a nonlanguage-based, computerized continuous performance test (CPT), and completed a DSM-IV checklist. The TOVA was administered to STUDENT four times over two day. From the initial TOVA test, Dr. Corman determined that STUDENT had severe attention problems. After her initial TOVA test, STUDENT was placed on different amounts of the stimulant medication adderol. Thereafter, her test performance on the TOVA improved. STUDENT’s performance also improved clinically, by being awake and able to listen and pay attention to a greater degree. Dr. Corman determined that STUDENT met the DSM-IV diagnostic criteria for attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder - inattentive type. Dr. Corman also indicated that STUDENT probably had narcolepsy and recommended that a sleep study be conducted to determine whether she had sleep apnea. In his opinion, neither of these conditions would affect his diagnosis of ADHD.(Footnote 13)
Issuance of Diploma
In June 2001, during the course of the due process hearing, the District issued a high school diploma to STUDENT. TVHS assistant principal Ms. Beaman testified that she was asked by the counseling department whether STUDENT should receive a diploma. Because Ms. Beaman believed there had not been a decision on the certificate of completion, she advised that a diploma should be issued. Director of special education Deborah Miller testified that she was not aware that a diploma had been issued to STUDENT until mid-July 2001. District records indicate that Petitioner’s consent to the IEP, with a limited exception relating to speech therapy, was received by the District on April 25, 2001. Ms. Miller testified that the District would rescind the diploma and issue STUDENT a certificate of completion instead if ordered to do so by the Hearing Officer and that the District had not stopped serving STUDENT as a result of the issuance of the diploma. STUDENT’s Current Program: Bridge Workability Program
STUDENT began attending the District’s Bridge workability program at a different campus during the extended school year 2001 and continued in that program for the 2001-2002 school year. According to Ms. Miller, there were ten students in the Bridge ESY program that was taught by two teachers. Beginning in the fall 2001-2002, the Bridge program was taught by SDC teacher Ms. Dixon and had five students in the class. District speech therapist Pam Metzger testified that, starting in the fall 2001-2002, she came to class twice a week for a minimum of thirty minutes each to work on pragmatic language skills. Ms. Metzger testified that she accompanies the students to their job sites once a week for a two-hour period, where she acts in the capacity of communication facilitator. The class component of speech therapy includes functional articulation, role playing, and work on group dynamics.
On the last day of the hearing, November 14, 2001, STUDENT’s Mother testified that STUDENT had recently been diagnosed with narcolepsy, a condition characterized by brief attacks of deep sleep.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
I. IS PETITIONER ENTITLED TO REIMBURSEMENT FOR THE INDEPENDENT EDUCATIONAL EVALUATIONS BY DR. PATTERSON AND/OR BY SPEECH AND LANGUAGE PATHOLOGIST JOANNE HEIN?
A parent has the right to obtain an independent educational assessment of the pupil from a qualified specialist, at public expense, if the parent disagrees with the assessment obtained by the District, unless the District shows at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b).
Petitioner requests reimbursement for her independent psycho-educational evaluation conducted in July 2000 by Dr. Patterson and for her independent speech and language evaluation conducted in April 2001 by Ms. Hein. At the hearing, STUDENT’s Mother testified that the cost of each of these evaluations was $1,000 and that she had paid for these evaluations. Accordingly, Petitioner requests reimbursement in the total amount of $2,000.00. The District contends that reimbursement is inappropriate for either Dr. Patterson’s or Ms. Hein’s evaluation because its evaluations were appropriate. Further, it asserts that Petitioner failed to give the District notice during the IEP meeting of April 4, 2001, that it disagreed with Ms. Metzger’s speech assessment. The District asserts that, at the time of the April 4, 2001 IEP meeting, Petitioner had already obtained the IEE.
California Education Code § 56320 governs the appropriateness of the District’s assessment and sets forth, in pertinent part, the following requirements. Testing and assessment materials and procedures must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; must be provided and administered in the pupil’s primary language or other mode of communication; must be administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; and must be validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(a)-(b). In addition, the pupil must be assessed in all areas of suspected disability, including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, including low vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, interests, and social and emotional status. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f). Assessment materials must assess specific areas of educational need and not merely provide a single general intelligence quotient. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(c). Further, no single procedure shall be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for a special education child. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(e).
Moreover, psychological assessments, including individually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning, must be administered by a credentialed school psychologist, and health assessments must be conducted by a credentialed school nurse or physician. These assessors must be trained and prepared to assess cultural and ethnic factors appropriate to the pupil being assessed. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56320(b)(3), 56324. In addition, assessments must be conducted by persons competent in performing the assessment, as determined by the school district, county office, or special education local plan area. Cal. Educ. Code § 56322. A written assessment report shall include “whether the pupil may need special education and related services.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56327 (a).
As discussed below, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s triennial assessments of STUDENT were not appropriate because the District used and substantially relied on racially discriminatory test instruments, and because it failed to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability, including speech and language, health and development, and social-emotional and adaptive functioning. Accordingly, reimbursement for the independent educational evaluations obtained by Petitioner from both Dr. Patterson and Ms. Hein is appropriate.
1. Racially Discriminatory Tests
School districts are statutorily prohibited by both the IDEA and California education law from assessing any student for special education using racially discriminatory tests. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(3), Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(a). Pursuant to these statutes, assessments that include such tests are not considered legally appropriate.
In Larry P. v. Riles (N.D. Cal. 1979) 459 F. Supp. 926, affd in part, revd. in part (9th Cir. 1986) 793 F. Supp. 969, the court determined that intelligence tests were racially biased against African Americans. The court found that, on the average, African American students scored approximately fifteen points below Caucasian students. The court also concluded that African American students were disproportionately represented in classes for educable mentally retarded (EMR) students. From its findings, the court issued a permanent injunction preventing public educational agencies for “utilizing, permitting the use of, or approving the use of any standardized intelligence tests...for the identification of black EMR children or their placement into EMR classes without securing prior approval by the court.” Larry P. at 989.
In 1986, the court expanded its 1979 injunction prohibiting the use of intelligence tests to include the use of intelligence tests in the assessment of African American students for eligibility as learning disabled and when referring the students for any special education assessment. The expansion of the injunction occurred following a stipulation by the parties. (See Larry P. v. Riles (1986) Order Modifying Judgment.) Thereafter, in 1992, the 1986 modification to the original Larry P. injunction was vacated on the ground that it violated the due process rights of a group of plaintiffs affected by the modification. Crawford v. Honig; Larry P. v. Riles (1992) Memorandum and Order. Under Crawford, the original Larry P. decision stands. The 1992 Crawford decision has been affirmed by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. Crawford v. Honig; Larry P. v. Riles (9th Cir. 1995) 37 F. 3d 485. The most recent decision states that the original injunction in Larry P. is reinstated. The Hearing Office has determined that, even though EMR classes no longer exist, the use or consideration of IQ tests prohibited by Larry P. by school districts concerning African American student continues to be inappropriate and is in effect. Because mental retardation continues to establish special education eligibility, “the danger of misidentifying a student as mentally retarded continues to exist today.” Student v. Ravenswood Elementary School District, et al., (March 26, 1998) “Memorandum of Order Denying in Part and Granting in Part Ravenswood’s Motion to Dismiss and Sequoia’s Motion to exclude Evidence.”
Petitioner introduced evidence through the independent evaluation and testimony of Dr. Patterson that the District administered racially discriminatory tests to STUDENT during its triennial assessment in February 1997. In reviewing STUDENT’s educational testing history, Dr. Patterson noted that the Matrix Analogies Test (MAT) administered to STUDENT by the District in its 1997 triennial assessment “is clearly intended to be an IQ test for nonverbal learners and is listed under Cognitive and IQ tests in most test catalogs....” Dr. Patterson concluded that “because the California Department of Education has indicated that Tests of Cognition or IQ Tests may not be administered to individuals of African-American descent, it would appear that the district made an error in administering this test to her.” STUDENT’s standard score of 69 on this test was on the cusp between mild retardation and borderline cognitive functioning. Dr. Patterson noted that, during this same assessment, the District administered another prohibited test to STUDENT: the Woodcock-Johnson Psycho-Educational Test Battery-Revised Test of Cognition, specifically, the subtests for verbal reasoning and verbal concept development. Dr. Patterson testified that these tests were also clearly listed as tests that may not be administered to African-American students in the California Association of School Psychologists (CASP) Best Practices Manual.
The District’s 2000 triennial assessment of STUDENT was predominantly based upon a review of her records that essentially incorporated her previous testing with racially discriminatory test instruments. Dr. Patterson also reviewed the District’s February 2000 triennial assessment, which confirmed STUDENT’s eligibility as an individual with limited cognitive functioning. According to Dr. Patterson, school psychologist Ms. Dorn’s conclusion from her review of STUDENT’s educational records that STUDENT’s intellectual ability was “estimated to be within the range of limited cognitive function” was “not consistent with the actual historical records.” In fact, a majority of STUDENT’s achievement test standard score results on the 1997 WJ-R Test of Achievement were in the 70 to 80 range. (See fnt. 10, supra). In addition, Dr. Patterson reported that STUDENT’s scores on the 2000 WRAML subtests administered to her by Ms. Dorn were extremely variable, with some scores in the average range (picture and design memory), and some in the retarded or significantly below average range (sentence memory, number-letter memory, and story memory). This pattern was again apparent in her 2000 WJ-R achievement testing by Mr. Page for the triennial. (Resp. Ex. 19). Dr. Patterson noted that STUDENT’s written language score on the Test of Written Language -3 (TOWL-3) was “clearly in the upper portion of the low average range, with a standard score of 87, at the 19th percentile which is not consistent with difficulty in learning.” The Hearing Officer finds that the consistent disparity in both the 1997 and 2000 triennial assessments between STUDENT’s higher achievement test results and her score on the MAT reinforces the great weight the District placed on STUDENT’s MAT’s result, which, in turn, led to the determination of her “limited cognitive functioning.”
The District introduced testimony from school psychologists Deanne Johnson and Rick Hollins that the MAT is not a prohibited IQ test. By contrast, school psychologist Ms. Dorn concurred with Dr. Patterson that the MAT is a prohibited intelligence test, even though it was not specifically listed as such. Although the MAT was not one of the specific tests listed as prohibited for use in the California Department of Education’s (CDE) 1997 memorandum entitled “Clarification on Banned Tests,” the CDE memorandum explicitly provided that the “Larry P. Settlement (1986) prohibits the use of IQ tests with Black pupils for special education purposes. IQ tests are construed to mean any test which purports to be or is understood to be a standardized test of intelligence....” See also, CDE’s 1989 “Larry P. Task Force Report: Policy and Alternative Assessment Guideline Recommendations.”
The Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Patterson’s testimony is entitled to great weight. As indicated in his Professional Vitae (Student Ex. 178), Dr. Patterson has extensive education and experience in special education and assessments and has taught psychological and educational assessment for special education. In addition to his experience, Dr. Patterson spent approximately five hours with STUDENT during his July 2000 assessment and conducted a comprehensive review of her educational background since kindergarten. The Hearing Officer finds Dr. Patterson’s testimony that the MAT is a standardized test of intelligence within the scope of Larry. P. to be extremely persuasive in light of his overall background and education, as well as his participation on the Larry P. task force. These tests, and in particular the MAT, formed the basis for the District’s determination that STUDENT was a student of limited cognitive functioning. STUDENT’s standard score of 69 on the MAT placed her into the under-70 IQ, or mentally retarded range. The weight of the evidence established that “limited cognitive functioning” was widely recognized as the “less-loaded” linguistic equivalent of mentally retarded. (Test. Dr. Patterson, Lisa Dorn, Rick Hollins).(Footnote 14) Thus, the use of this test exposed STUDENT to the type of detriment that Larry P. was designed to eliminate. Dr. Patterson’s determination that STUDENT was not mentally retarded was reinforced by the District assessment team’s own conclusion that she was in the borderline range and the fact that her achievement test results reached up into the low average range.(Footnote 15)
The Hearing Officer finds that the impact of the improper intellectual testing of STUDENT in her February 1997 triennial review was profound, and affected her throughout the three years during which this triennial was in place. The determination that STUDENT had limited cognitive functioning in effect set the stage for the level of expectation as well as the level of services that she received. This error was continued in the February 2000 triennial assessment. While Petitioner’s categorization as an individual with limited cognitive functioning is not at issue in this hearing, as discussed below, it adversely affected the educational services she received.
The evidence also supports a finding that the District’s speech and language assessments in both 1997 and in 2001 used racially discriminatory tests. Dr. Patterson testified that the District’s use of the Expressive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test (EOWPVT) during STUDENT’s 1997 speech evaluation by language and speech specialist Dr. Hannaman was explicitly prohibited. Dr. Hannaman acknowledged this during his testimony. As discussed below, the EOWPVT was the only test of STUDENT’s expressive language administered for this triennial and resulted in her release from speech and language. Dr. Hannaman also testified that the MAT cognitive testing information contained in the February 1997 triennial assessment was a possible basis for his conclusion that STUDENT’s language scores were commensurate with her ability. When STUDENT was next assessed for speech and language services in February 2001, District speech therapist Ms. Metzger assessed STUDENT with various instruments including the
Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test - Third Ed, Form IIIA (PPVT-III). Ms. Metzger testified that she was not aware of the Larry P. prohibition on the use of this test until after the assessment.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s 1997 and 2000 triennial assessments and the February 2001 speech and language assessment of STUDENT were not appropriate because they used and relied on racially discriminatory test instruments in violation of Larry P. v. Riles. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s assessments were not appropriate pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(3) and Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(a).
2. Failure to Assess in All Areas of Suspected Disability a. Speech and Language
The record establishes that STUDENT had received speech and language services since early elementary school. STUDENT was identified as a student with a speech or language impairment by the District for the three years prior to her 1997 triennial assessment. During the 1996-1997 school year, STUDENT’s speech and language therapist was Dr. John Hannaman. who provided her with small-group speech therapy that focused on language development, and on building vocabulary and expressive and receptive language. As previously discussed, in February 1997, Dr. Hannaman administered the EOWPVT and the ROWPVT to STUDENT, who received standard scores of 80 and 82 respectively in the borderline range. Dr. Hannaman recommended that STUDENT be released from speech and language therapy because her scores on these tests were commensurate with her ability level. This recommendation was adopted by the IEP team in February 1997. Thereafter, STUDENT was not offered any speech and language services until four years later, just two months before the end of her senior year in April 2001.
At the hearing, Dr. Hannaman testified that STUDENT would not have been disqualified from speech and language even if her scores were commensurate with her ability and that he had several other students with lower capacities who continued to receive services. In his opinion, STUDENT was embarrassed at being pulled out of class for services. If STUDENT had wanted to continue speech services, Dr. Hannaman testified that he would have recommended that she continue to receive them. If he had wanted to discharge STUDENT from speech eligibility, Dr. Hannaman testified that he would have conducted more extensive testing. The Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Hannaman’s testimony, coupled with STUDENT’s history, persuasively establishes that the District was aware of STUDENT’s ongoing need for speech and language services.
Nonetheless, during its February 2000 triennial review, none of the District’s assessment team members was a speech therapist. The District did not conduct any assessment of STUDENT in the area of speech and language function. While frequently mentioning STUDENT’s limited cognitive abilities, the triennial assessment report made no mention of her past identification as an individual with a speech or language impairment and did not discuss her current abilities in expressive or receptive language or in pragmatics. As discussed below, both District speech therapist Ms. Metzger and independent therapist Ms. Hein agreed that STUDENT has severe deficits in both her expressive and her receptive language and that she had been grossly underserved by the District in this area for years. From the totality of the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s 2000 triennial assessment was not appropriate because it failed to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability.
This failure was recognized by Dr. Patterson in his July 2000 independent evaluation. To assess her language functioning, Dr. Patterson administered the Expressive Vocabulary Test to STUDENT, who received a standard score of 82, at the 12th percentile. This score was in the low average range, similar to a child of eleven years six months of age. Dr. Patterson recommended that STUDENT be given a full speech and language evaluation, not a single test, and concluded that “it would appear that the reason that she is being removed from speech and language assistance is because the assumption has been made that she is of low cognitive function and would not benefit from such therapy, which in this case is a mistake.”
The first time the District fully assessed STUDENT’s speech and language functioning during her high school years was in February 2001, the last half of her senior year. District speech therapist Pam Metzger administered the following tests to STUDENT: the Comprehensive Assessment of Spoken Language, Form 2 (CASL), the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test - Third Ed, Form IIIA (PPVT-III) discussed above, the Expressive Vocabulary Test (EVT) and the Test of Pragmatic Language (TOPL). Ms. Metzger concluded that STUDENT’s overall language scores ranged from low average in receptive vocabulary (SS 95 on PPVT-III) to the extremely low range in expressive language (SS 66 on EVT) for a student her age.
Ms. Metzger found that STUDENT’s pragmatic ability to use language in social situations was on the borderline of the moderately low to extremely low range of functioning (TOPL SS=70, third percentile). Ms. Metzger testified that the TOPL was normed for a kindergarten through thirteen-year-old population, but that it was permissible to use it to test older students. If normed to her chronological age, STUDENT would have fallen below the first percentile in pragmatic language. STUDENT’s greatest areas of pragmatic difficulty were in requesting (ability to make requests), informing (ability to use statements of fact, clarification, description, opinion, and agreement), physical context (ability to appropriately describe a situation/place), abstractions (figurative or metaphorical language) and topic maintenance. In her report dated February 4, 2001, Ms. Metzger made no specific recommendation for services for STUDENT, but indicated that the information should be considered by the IEP team. On April 4, 2001, the IEP team offered STUDENT an unspecified amount of speech consultation. No direct services were offered.(Footnote 16)
On April 6, 2001, private speech-language pathologist Joanne Hein conducted a speech and language assessment of eighteen-year-old STUDENT over a period of five hours.(Footnote 17) Ms. Hein administered the following tests to STUDENT: the Comprehensive Receptive and Expressive Vocabulary Test (CREVT), the Expressive One Word Picture Vocabulary test (EOWPVT), the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals-3 (CELF-3), the Screening Test for Auditory Processing Disorders for Adolescents and Adults (SCAN-A), the Lindamood Auditory Conceptualization Test (LAC), the Gates-MacGinitie Reading Test (Speed and Accuracy), the Screening Test for Developmental Apraxia of Speech, the Test of Written Language-3 (TOWL-3) and the Pragmatic Skills Checklist.
On the CREVT, STUDENT a scored at the thirtieth percentile (SS=92, AE 14.6 years) in receptive vocabulary, but at the second percentile (SS=70, AE 8.3 years) in expressive vocabulary. Her expressive language score was in the severely impaired range. On the EOWPVT, normed on a population that extended to fifteen and eleven months of age, STUDENT scored at the sixteenth percentile or age equivalent of 12.7. Ms. Hein indicated that due to the normative population, this was an over-estimate of STUDENT’s current expressive language abilities. On the CELF-3, STUDENT scored at the first percentile in all receptive language subtests (concepts and directions, word classes, semantic relations) and in all expressive language subtests (formulated sentences, recalling sentences, sentence assembly). STUDENT received a standard score of 50, at the first percentile, in both receptive and expressive language. STUDENT could follow only forty-three percent of two-step commands and none of the three-step commands (concepts and directions).
Ms. Hein administered the SCAN-A to STUDENT to determine if there was an auditory processing disorder that was differentially affecting her language skills. All of STUDENT’s scores on this test were in the severely impaired range. Ms. Hein testified that these results indicated that STUDENT would have difficulty listening in class. From the SCAN-A, Ms. Hein recommended that STUDENT be referred for further assessment by an audiologist knowledgeable in auditory processing disorders and appropriate treatment “for Central Auditory Processing Disorder.” Ms. Hein also administered the LAC test to STUDENT to determine her ability to track sounds in syllables for reading and decoding success. STUDENT’s scores on the LAC were at the “level expected for minimal competencies with late-second grade reading/decoding material, and therefore are significantly impaired...This type of deficit is indicative of the need for intensive intervention with auditory memory and processing skills for success with reading decoding....” This grade level would prevent STUDENT from reading words that were unfamiliar to her. STUDENT’s score on the Gates-MacGinitie Reading Test for reading rate and basic understanding revealed that her accuracy score was below the 3.3 grade level.
Ms. Hein reported that STUDENT demonstrated focus, motivation, and good use of problem solving strategies in completing her tests for the evaluation. She appeared to have significant word retrieval problems that indicated she had good word knowledge that was not functionally available to her. STUDENT’s cognitive strengths were reinforced by her performance on the TOWL-3, which required her to write a story independently from a picture. STUDENT’s resultant standard “spontaneous writing score” was at the sixty-fifth percentile. Ms. Hein testified that STUDENT’s scores on the TOWL-3 indicated that she has many higher level thinking skills and higher level functioning than she tends to demonstrate. Ms. Hein also administered the Screening Test for Developmental Apraxia of Speech, because of STUDENT’s Mother’ concern about STUDENT’s mumbling. Her results on this test suggested that STUDENT’s difficulty with sequential processing had an impact on her speech output, particularly in pronouncing multi-syllabic words.
Finally, Ms. Hein had STUDENT’s Mother complete the Pragmatic Skills Checklist, to survey STUDENT’s social language skills. Ms. Hein reported that the rating given to STUDENT by her mother, a 43, indicated that she needed remediation for social language difficulties in the following areas: adjusting her conversation to her audience, taking conversational turns, appropriately entering a group, making appropriate statements, reading non-verbal cues in listeners, using and interpreting gestures appropriately, giving sequenced information, and making predictions. (Footnote 18)
Ms. Hein testified that, in her opinion, STUDENT had severe deficits in both her receptive and her expressive language, which were affected by a central auditory processing problem. In her opinion, STUDENT has had these disorders over the past three years and should have received speech and language therapy over the last three years. Ms. Hein testified that STUDENT has a potential for much higher functioning but that she needs an intensive program of daily individual speech therapy as well as small-group therapy with students with similar deficits. A Lindamood Bell program that would incorporate reading and language would be an excellent choice for remediating STUDENT’s deficits. Ms. Hein disagreed with the District’s position that STUDENT did not require direct speech and language therapy. Ms. Hein testified that STUDENT’s language development did not necessarily have to be provided entirely by a speech pathologist, but that she needed to work with experienced staff guided by someone who could interface with the entire teaching team.
After reviewing Ms. Hein’s report, Ms. Metzger testified that their results were fairly comparable and that she would have expected Ms. Hein’s result based upon her own assessment. Ms. Metzger testified that she agreed with Ms. Hein’s conclusion that STUDENT has severe expressive and receptive deficits. She disagreed, however, that this was “secondary to attention problems.” In Ms. Metzger’s opinion, STUDENT’s deficits do not result from ADHD or a central auditory processing disorder (CAPD). Ms. Metzger did not suspect a CAPD for STUDENT because STUDENT has cognitive problems and CAPD has been normed on a population of individuals with normal intelligence. Ms. Metzger testified that it would be appropriate to follow Ms. Hein’s recommendation for STUDENT to be assessed by an audiologist regarding CAPD but she believed that the results should be viewed cautiously, in light of the fact that it was designed for individuals with language difficulties and normal intelligence.
The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Metzger’s perception of STUDENT, with whom she had no prior contact at the time of her two-hour evaluation, was tainted by her knowledge that STUDENT was a student with “limited cognitive functioning.” Although the Hearing Officer found Ms. Metzger to be a very sincere and open-minded witness, it is difficult to determine what effect this information had on her evaluation of STUDENT. It is clear from her testimony, however, that she would not suspect a CAPD in an individual like STUDENT who did not have “normal intelligence.” As a consequence, the District’s identification of STUDENT as a student of limited cognitive functioning inappropriately affected her evaluation. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s February 2001 speech and language assessment was inappropriate because Ms. Metzger’s assessment was affected by the District’s use of racially discriminatory test instruments.
b. Adaptive, Social-Emotional and Memory Functioning
At the time of her 2000 triennial assessment, STUDENT was seventeen years old. The District’s assessment failed to address important areas of suspected disability for her. Specifically, the District’s assessment did not address her adaptive, social-emotional or memory functioning. These areas were particularly critical for STUDENT given her age and need for transition planning. Dr. Patterson’s independent educational evaluation provided significant new information regarding STUDENT’s adaptive skills, as well as her social-emotional and memory functioning. While the District eventually assessed STUDENT in these areas in February 2001, this was based on its own recognition of these omissions in the triennial review.
For example, as previously discussed, Dr. Patterson measured STUDENT’s adaptive functioning by having STUDENT’s Mother complete the Normative Adaptive Behavior Checklist (NABC). STUDENT’s Mother’ responses indicated that STUDENT was performing like a child of eight years, eleven months of age with low self-help, home living, and independent living skills. Her social skills, sensory motor skills, and language conceptualization skills were low. She was seen by her mother as having difficulty following through on a number of relatively straight-forward, simple home living skills. In addition, Dr. Patterson had STUDENT complete the Street Survival Skills Questionnaire (SSSQ) that required her to demonstrate her actual knowledge in the domains of basic concepts, functional signs, tools, domestics, health and safety, public services, time, money, and measurement. STUDENT’s overall functioning on the SSSQ was in the low average range. Dr. Patterson noted that this score did not appear to be consistent with the school staff’s perception of STUDENT as of limited cognitive functioning. This adaptive assessment provided specific information regarding areas of functional need for STUDENT that would be vital for planning transition services and other IEP goals.
Dr. Patterson assessed STUDENT’s social-emotional functioning by having STUDENT’s Mother complete the Personality Inventory for Children (PIC) that is scored in comparison to responses of parents of children with no known disorders. On the Clinical Scale of the PIC, STUDENT was seen as “having significant difficulties with adjustment, achievement, cognition, and developmental issues and fits a Profile Type 3, which are children that exhibit cognitive and academic deficits and may have poor behavioral adjustment, having problems that were first noticed in infancy that continued. These are children that have developmental delays and poor social skills and poor achievement in more than one academic area. They often have memory deficits and speech disturbances. This includes children that fit into a number of different types of difficulties, but often children with organic disorders with cerebral dysfunction as a result of organicity.” The PIC indicated that STUDENT may be experiencing depression. By contrast, the only input in the District’s 2000 assessment regarding STUDENT’s social-emotional functioning was Mr. Page’s assessment that STUDENT’s self-esteem “seems to be OK.”
Dr. Patterson’s assessment provided the first comprehensive examination of STUDENT’s memory function. The results of the Learning Efficiency Test-II (LET-II) indicated that STUDENT “has significant difficulties with memory depending on how that memory is assessed. For ordered material she does much better in terms of long term memory for auditorially presented material....She does less well for unordered material but her short term auditory memory is an area of relative strength. STUDENT’s long term memory visually is her relative strength in terms of visual memory and what she sees unordered she transfers a significant amount into long term memory. Her memory functioning is variable across time.” The educational significance of this finding was that STUDENT cannot retrieve information from memory unless it is taught in a highly redundantly fashion because she requires a high degree of repetition to put information permanently into memory.
c. Health: STUDENT’s Fatigue/ Sleep Issues
Finally, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability because it persistently ignored what the evidence demonstrated to be a significant issue relating to STUDENT’s habit of falling asleep in class. School psychologist Deanne Johnson testified that she did not observe any symptoms of ADHD in STUDENT during the February 1997 (eighth grade) triennial assessment that would have caused her to further assess STUDENT in this area. She also noted that there were no reported health concerns. District staff subsequently failed to refer information about STUDENT’s persistent in-class sleeping to the IEP team for consideration of the need for additional assessment. Mr. Alban, STUDENT’s RSP case carrier in the ninth and tenth grade, testified that he noticed a certain lethargy and lapses of attentiveness in STUDENT. STUDENT told him she was sleepy as a result of staying up too late and not getting enough sleep. This information was never noted on her IEP. According to Ms. Alban, one of STUDENT’s SDC teachers in the tenth and eleventh grades, STUDENT “would be out,” would snore and be difficult to wake, except in classes where there were hands-on activities. As described by Ms. Alban, STUDENT’s behavior relating to falling asleep in class was of a magnitude that should have been called to the attention of the IEP team for assessment.(Footnote 19) In addition, STUDENT’s progress reports and student/teacher contact records also reflect a pattern over the years of teachers making comments either about STUDENT sleeping in class or about her accomplishment by not sleeping in class.(Footnote 20) STUDENT’s Mother testified that she was concerned about STUDENT’s academics because she was told that STUDENT slept in class all day. As acknowledged by SDC teacher Ms. Niotis, this in-class sleeping behavior “absolutely affected” STUDENT’s ability to attend to her education. Nonetheless, throughout her assessments and IEPs, STUDENT was generally described as healthy. The only problem noted was with her knees. Although the February 2000 triennial indicated that STUDENT had “deficits in attention and concentration skills,” Ms. Dorn testified that, in her opinion, STUDENT was not ADHD but at a lower developmental level.(Footnote 21)As indicated in the evaluations of Dr. Patterson and Ms. Hein, as well as in the testimony of Dr. Corman, STUDENT had attentional, neurological and auditory processing problems that may have been implicated in her in-class sleeping. For example, Ms. Hein testified that a central auditory processing problem would have made listening in class difficult for STUDENT. An assessment to address the underlying cause of STUDENT’s inability to stay awake in class may have sparked a much-needed reexamination of her needs and abilities. The District’s failure to acknowledge the need for and to undertake such an assessment underscores the notion that this behavior did not seem unusual for a student of limited cognitive functioning. * * *
In summary, for the reasons outlined above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s assessments of STUDENT were not appropriate. The Hearing Officer further concludes that Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for the independent educational evaluations of both Dr. Patterson and Ms. Hein in the total amount of $2,000.00.
II. DID THE DISTRICT OFFER STUDENT A FREE APPROPRIATE PUBLIC EDUCATION (FAPE) FOR THE FOLLOWING SCHOOL AND/OR EXTENDED SCHOOL YEARS: 1997-1998 BEGINNING FEBRUARY 7, 1998; 1998-1999;
1999-2000; AND/OR 2000-2001?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C.§ 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no cost to the parents, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8) (1997). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401 (25) (1997). The term “related services” means transportation and such developmental, corrective, and other supportive services, including speech and language services, as may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education, including recreation and therapeutic recreation services. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). Designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56363 (b) (1987).
To determine whether the District provided STUDENT a free appropriate public education, the Hearing Officer must focus on the adequacy of the District’s offered and proposed programs. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S.C. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirement of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. Id. At 198 - 200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instructional and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student . Id. at 207-208. De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d at 130 (2d Cir. 1998). Rather, a child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2nd Cir. 1997).
In addition, an appropriate program for a student who is fourteen years of age or older must include transition services to promote the student’s movement from school to activities after graduation. Such activities may include postsecondary education, vocational training, integrated employment, adult education, adult services, independent living, or community participation, depending upon the unique needs of the particular student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(30); Calif. Educ. Code § 56345.1(c). These services must also include instructional strategies that will prepare pupils with severe disabilities to make successful transitions to supported employment and living in the community. Calif. Educ. Code § 56462(c)(1).
In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S.C. 3034 (1982), the Supreme Court recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 205. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992).
An analysis of whether STUDENT has been provided a FAPE is thus twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to decide both whether procedural steps have been followed and whether the proposed placement and program are substantively appropriate. In this latter regard, the District’s placement offer during each of the years at issue must have been designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, have been reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit, and have comported with the services actually offered in her IEPs. Because Petitioner did not contend that the services she received were not the same as the services offered to her in the IEPs, it is not necessary to address this component of the FAPE analysis.
1. The 1997-1998 School/Extended School Year, beginning February 7, 1998 (Ninth Grade)
The 1997-1998 school year was STUDENT’s freshman year at TVHS. As previously discussed, during her triennial assessment IEP of February 27, 1997, STUDENT’s eligibility was changed to limited cognitive ability. This triennial IEP remained in effect until her annual review of March 2, 1998, more than half way through her ninth grade year. Thus, for the approximate four-week period from February 7 through March 2, 1998, STUDENT was receiving educational services as outlined in her IEP dated February 27, 1997. Pursuant to that IEP, STUDENT was receiving resource specialist services (RSP) for thirteen percent of her day with no related services. Thereafter, the balance of her ninth grade school and extended school year was governed by her IEP dated March 2, 1998. Pursuant to that IEP, STUDENT was receiving RSP services forty-seven percent of her day with no related services. She was not offered an extended school year program.
A. Was the placement designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
STUDENT’s Unique Needs
The first step in deciding whether the District’s offered placement for the ninth grade from February 7, 1998, through the end of the extended school year 1997-1998 was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs is determining what those unique needs were. Many of STUDENT’s unique needs were outlined in her 1997 triennial assessment. STUDENT’s areas of weakness were in comprehension of reading at the third grade level or above (needs assistance with drawing inferences and conclusions from her reading at all levels), understanding math concepts (errors on all problems with addition of coin values, solving single-step story problems, knowledge of time and calendar concepts), and written language (developing complete sentences and a simple theme with correct organization). These needs were reiterated in STUDENT’s present levels of performance for the March 1998 annual review. STUDENT was “reading below grade level (4th) with relative weakness in comprehension,” and her writing was also at fourth grade level. She had difficulty “with sentence structures, mechanics, and spelling.” STUDENT had a “weak vocabulary.” In math, STUDENT had a “weakness in calculations (fractions) and reasoning.” There was no dispute among the parties that STUDENT had unique needs in these area.
The Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT had unique needs in expressive and receptive language, as well as pragmatic language skills. As previously discussed, the testimony of Ms. Hein and Ms. Metzger convincingly established that STUDENT had severe deficits in expressive and receptive language as well as in pragmatic language throughout her high school years, the remediation of which was necessary for her to benefit educationally from her instructional program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56363.
Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s placement from February 7, 1998 to the end of the ninth grade was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs for the following reasons.
First, the February 27, 1997 IEP governing STUDENT’s program from February 7, 1998 through March 2, 1998, failed to address STUDENT’s unique written language needs. Although STUDENT had demonstrated a weakness in written language in the areas of developing complete sentences and a simple theme with correct organization during the triennial review of February 1997, there were no goals drafted in the area of written language. (Test. of Ms. Dixon). The IEP also failed to target her specific area of need in mathematics. Although the triennial assessment identified specific areas of weakness for STUDENT in understanding math concepts (errors on all problems with addition of coin values, solving single step story problems, knowledge of time and calendar concepts), her annual math goal was simply “to improve math skills” with short-term objectives to receive grades of C or better in regular math class, and to attend math lab at least twice a week and learn money-changing skills. An individualized education program “shall show a direct relationship between the present levels of performance, the goals and objectives, and the specific educational services to be offered. Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3040(c). There was no such relationship here.
Second, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP of March 1998 was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs because the reading goal “to comprehend textbooks” was not measurable. Rather, the texts were to be modified to an unspecified grade level. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A), Educ. Code § 56345(2). This goal was not designed to meet STUDENT’s severe deficits in reading comprehension, but rather appeared to be designed to maintain her then-current level of reading. In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that the March 1998 IEP failed to include an annual goal in mathematics. Although STUDENT had not met her math goal from her previous IEP, that goal was not continued and her newly identified math weaknesses in “calculations (fractions) and reasoning” were not incorporated into a specific and measurable mathematics goal. Instead, math was simply eliminated from STUDENT’s goals.
Third, STUDENT was offered no speech and language services. Although STUDENT’s alleged embarrassment about being “pulled out” for small group speech services may have been a concern, the IEP failed to address her need for counseling services to address self-esteem issues arising out of this reaction to necessary services or her need for an alternative method of delivery of speech services. The weight of the evidence established that STUDENT’s severe deficits in receptive and expressive language were integrally related to her ability to improve her reading comprehension level. The District’s program failed to offer her direct speech and language services or a cohesive reading program designed to increase her ability levels.
B. Was the placement reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit?
Petitioner argued that throughout her high school career her grades were modified or inflated to allow her to pass and to ultimately achieve sufficient credits to graduate. She argues that despite the fact that she was promoted from grade to grade and earned credits toward graduation, she had received no educational benefit. Petitioner further argued that this lack of educational benefit was demonstrated by the fact that she never met any of her IEP goals and that her skill levels failed to progress. For example, in March of 1998 in the ninth grade, STUDENT had not met her math goal and only partially met her reading goal from the February 1997 IEP. Her present level of reading performance in March of 1998 was below the fourth grade level with lower comprehension. At the end of the ninth grade, however, STUDENT had passing grades, with her lowest grade a D minus in Introduction to Art.(Footnote 22)
The Hearing Officer finds that the issue of whether STUDENT’s grades were modified during high school is not the proper analysis for determining whether the placement was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. While passing grades are one factor to consider in determining educational benefit, the more relevant inquiry is whether STUDENT received educational benefit in her areas of unique need. The evidence demonstrates that STUDENT did not receive any services in the area of speech and language and that her severe expressive and receptive language deficits were inextricably related to her ability to read and comprehend materials. The District failed to establish that STUDENT received any services in her specific deficit areas in mathematics. Finally, educational progress must be gauged in relation to a student’s potential. (Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, supra). In this case, the use of racially discriminatory intelligence tests led to a conclusion that STUDENT’s potential was less than it actually was. The Hearing Officer finds that it impossible at this juncture to determine how much progress STUDENT may legitimately have achieved had she not been determined, in effect, to be mentally retarded. A placement that fails to provide necessary related services as a result of an erroneous assessment of a student’s potential is not reasonably calculated to provide more than de minimus educational benefit. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the ninth grade placement in the RSP at TVHS was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.
1998 Extended School Year
Petitioner contends that the District denied her a FAPE by failing to offer her an extended school year (ESY) program for ESY 1998.
Extended school year (ESY) programming is educational programming that extends instruction beyond the normal school year to prevent serious regression over the summer months. Hoeft v. Tucson Unified Sch. Dist., 967 F.3d 1298, 1301 (9th Cir. 1992); see also, 34 C.F.R.§ 300.309 (b). In California, a school district is required to provide a special education student with ESY programming when the student requires special education and related services in excess of the regular academic year or the IEP team has determined the need for ESY programming. Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 5, § 3043; compare with 34 C.F.R.§ 300.309 (a) 2. Section 3043 of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations defines such students in the following manner:
Such individuals shall have handicaps which are likely to continue indefinitely or for a prolonged period, and interruption of the pupil’s educational programming may cause regression, when coupled with limited recoupment capacity, rendering it impossible or unlikely that the pupil will attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that would otherwise be expected in view of his or her handicapping condition.
Where a child has been determined eligible for ESY services by his or her IEP team, the written IEP must include an ESY program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(b)(3); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(b)(1)(ii).
The District did not provide any evidence regarding STUDENT’s regression or recoupment rates or why she was not offered an ESY program for the 1998 ESY. The weight of the evidence established that STUDENT was a student whose deficits were likely to continue, who had made very slow progress in her primary area of need of reading comprehension, and whose performance was likely to suffer from an interruption over the summer. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE by failing to offer an ESY program for 1998. * * * * In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 1997-1998 school year beginning on February 7, 1999, or for the 1998 extended school year.
2. The 1998-1999 School and Extended School Year (Tenth Grade)
The 1998-1999 school year was STUDENT’s sophomore year at TVHS. In October 1998, STUDENT turned sixteen. At the time she began tenth grade, her March 2, 1998 annual review IEP was in effect. Pursuant to that IEP, STUDENT was receiving RSP services forty-seven percent of her day with no related services. STUDENT’s first trimester grade point average in November 1998 was 1.40. She failed RSP world history and driver’s education. In January 1999, the District members of the IEP team changed STUDENT’s placement from the RSP program to the special day class (SDC) program. The parents subsequently consented to this change in placement. Pursuant to that IEP, STUDENT was in the SDC program sixty percent of the time for four classes: math, English, reading and U.S. history, with regular education classes for PE and electives. No related services were offered. Extended school year was offered.
A. Was the placement designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
STUDENT’s Unique Needs
STUDENT’s academic areas of need remained essentially the same in her sophomore year, with specific needs in reading, reading comprehension, written expression and mathematics. As indicated in her present levels of performance from the March 2, 1998 IEP, STUDENT was reading “below grade level (4th) with relative weakness in comprehension,” and her writing was also at fourth grade level. She had difficulty “with sentence structures, mechanics, and spelling.” STUDENT had a “weak vocabulary.” In math, STUDENT had a “weakness in calculations (fractions) and reasoning.” As previously discussed, STUDENT continued to have unique needs in the area of expressive, receptive and pragmatic language.
STUDENT’s RSP case carrier, Mr. Alban, described STUDENT unique needs during the ninth and tenth grades as follows: She had a difficulty with concepts, with recalling facts and with comprehension of both oral and written materials. STUDENT had writing problems. In Mr. Alban’s opinion, STUDENT’s biggest need was for “a lot of one-on-one” help and personal attention. This was the reason he recommended placement in the SDC program. He was concerned STUDENT was not getting the help she needed in regular classes with the assistance of instructional aides. Mr. Alban testified that, at the time of the January 1999 IEP meeting, STUDENT’s unique needs were basically to have more explanation and time spent on reviewing materials (remediation and providing paraphrase). He testified that comprehension continued to be a primary need requiring one-on-one instruction. She needed work on reading, specifically in recall, comprehension, learning strategies (i.e., note taking, mind-mapping strategies for recall, mnemonic devices), and work on writing effective sentences, paragraphs, topic sentences, conclusions and organizational skills.
The Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT had unique needs in the area of transition services to prepare her for supported employment and independent living after graduation. As indicated in STUDENT’s 1997 triennial IEP, STUDENT required early job training. Given STUDENT’s deficits in basic reading, writing and math skills, she required a program that would train her in functional academic skills as well as in adaptive daily living skills.
Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?
The Hearing Officer finds that the placement offered to STUDENT was not designed to meet her unique needs for the following reasons.
First, during the period prior to the January 1999 IEP meeting, case carrier Mr. Alban was aware of STUDENT’s need for more one-to-one assistance. In fact, Mr. Alban testified that he was aware of that need shortly after STUDENT entered the ninth grade. Mr. Alban testified that he tried to talk STUDENT’s parent into placing her in the SDC program, but changed his position based upon their desire for her to remain in regular education. As a result, he did not recommend a change to the SDC program until almost a year later, in December 1998, when she was failing two classes. (Footnote 23) Second, the Hearing Officer has previously found that the March 1998 IEP failed to address STUDENT’s unique needs in reading comprehension and in mathematics by writing unmeasurable goals in reading/reading comprehension and by failing to write a math goal. The IEP also failed to address any of STUDENT’s acknowledged deficits in vocabulary. The Hearing Officer finds that the reading comprehension goal of the January 1999 IEP failed to establish any qualitative standard by which to measure her reading comprehension. Although one of the clear purposes of this goal was to encourage STUDENT to read outside of school, it failed to address her primary need to increase her ability to read and comprehend at a more advanced grade level. As with the March 1998 reading goal, the January 1999 goal was designed to maintain STUDENT’s reduced level of reading comprehension.
Third, the IEPs of March 1998 and January 1999 failed to address STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of transition services, particularly in the area of preparation for supported employment and independent living skills after graduation. Mr. Alban developed STUDENT’s goals and objectives in the January 1999 IEP. He testified that while he believed they were designed to meet her unique needs, he would probably add vocational goals. Mr. Alban testified that this is generally done in the ninth grade but “we don’t have many vocational offerings.” In his experience, at the freshman and sophomore level, transition goals are geared to meeting graduation requirements and obtaining a license, which was believed necessary for STUDENT to obtain a job.
A review of STUDENT’s transition plan contained in both the March 1998 and January 1999 IEP confirms that the only goals were to obtain passing grades, complete community service requirements for graduation and to obtain a drivers’ license. It is apparent that no serious consideration was given to preparing STUDENT for employment and independent living following high school. Although STUDENT’s need for early job training was recognized by the triennial assessment team in February 1997, two years later no concrete plans or services were being provided that would develop functional skills, including functional academic and speech/pragmatic skills, required for her to obtain supported employment. It is noteworthy that both the February 1997 and February 2000 triennial assessment indicate that STUDENT planned to get a job “with the help of her mother.”
Fourth, no services were offered to address STUDENT’s severe expressive and receptive language deficits or her pragmatic skills. As previously discussed, the provision of speech services was essential for STUDENT to progress in her other areas of unique need.
B. Was the placement reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit?
The weight of the evidence establishes that STUDENT did not receive educational benefit during the first half of the school year in the RSP program. She was failing several classes, had a grade point average of 1.40, had not met her March 1998 goal in written language, and had only partially met her reading comprehension goal.
It is clear that STUDENT received services more closely designed to provide benefit after her January 1999 change in placement to the SDC program. District SDC teachers Ms. Dixon and Ms. Alban testified that they used a variety of multi-sensory teaching methods in their classes with STUDENT, as well as instruction in how to use academic skills in functional contexts. STUDENT was exposed to reading newspapers, magazines and novels, some of which contained vocabulary that was reduced to a third- to fourth-grade reading level, with occasional pictures.
Dr. Patterson testified that the appropriateness of an SDC placement for STUDENT would depend upon its type. It would not be appropriate in his opinion to place her in a tradition SDC class. Rather, STUDENT required an SDC class with a transition program that included highly repetitive intensive remediation with realistic skills. The program needed to include vocational and life skills, reading, practical math and written language skills. STUDENT needed to be exposed to general information from practicing her skills. STUDENT required a structured reading and writing program that would incorporate her processing problems and be applicable to job applications, reading newspapers, and functioning in the community.
The Hearing Officer finds that, while some focus on functional skills was provided to STUDENT, the District’s SDC classes did not provide her with the intensity of focus in the areas outlined by Dr. Patterson. In addition, the weight of the evidence established that STUDENT required both intensive speech therapy and an intensive reading program to benefit from her education and to prepare her to transition into supported employment and independent living. These services were not offered and STUDENT continued to be under the cloud of limited cognitive functioning. There is no persuasive evidence that STUDENT had improved her functional skill levels during this year. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.
1999 Extended School Year
Although STUDENT was offered extended school year services at the IEP of January 5, 1999, the IEP document provided no description of what was to be encompassed in her ESY program. Where a student has been determined eligible for ESY services by his or her IEP team, the written IEP must include an ESY program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(b)(3); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(b)(1)(ii). At the hearing, the District offered no evidence regarding STUDENT’s ESY 1999 program. A review of STUDENT’s transcript from that period indicates only that she withdrew from world history and received no credits for the ESY.(Footnote 24)
The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not meet its burden of demonstrating that it offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 1999 ESY. * * * * In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1998-1999 school or extended school year.
3. The 1999-2000 School and Extended School Year (Eleventh Grade)
STUDENT began her junior year at TVHS in the fall of 1999. STUDENT’s placement in the SDC program for sixty percent of her day, pursuant to the IEP of January 1999, was confirmed at an IEP meeting in September 1999. In February 2000, STUDENT’s triennial review assessment was conducted. As discussed above, STUDENT’s triennial review did not assess her need for speech and language services. The triennial assessment did not assess her in the areas of social-emotional functioning, adaptive functioning or vocational needs. STUDENT’s triennial review IEP meeting was convened on April 4, 2000. Pursuant to that IEP, STUDENT’s SDC placement was increased to seventy-three percent. Extended school year was offered. No related services were offered. The IEP documented the parents’ priority for STUDENT to be able to function independently on graduation, with enhanced social skills and more relationships with her peers. While the parents initially consented to this IEP, they revoked their consent in May 2000. As a result, the January 1999 IEP remained in effect throughout this school year.
A. Was the placement designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
STUDENT’s Unique Needs
STUDENT’s unique needs during the 1999-2000 school year remained substantially the same. She had unique needs to improve her reading and reading comprehension skills, and to improve her math and written language skills. STUDENT had unique needs in the area of expressive and receptive language and pragmatic skills. She had unique needs for transition services, particularly in acquiring functional skills to enable her to enter the workforce and to live independently after high school.
Designed to Meet Her Unique Needs
Beginning in August 1999, Cory Page became STUDENT’s case carrier and one of her SDC teachers. As previously indicated, Mr. Page held an emergency teaching credential in physical education.(Footnote 25) STUDENT’s SDC teachers during the eleventh grade testified that they used multi-sensory teaching methods with STUDENT, began instructing her with the Jane Shaffer writing program, exposed her to regular education curriculum through modified texts, and provided her with some instruction in functional use of skills. (Testimony of Ms. Alban, Ms. Niotis).
However, the Hearing Officer finds that the 1999-2000 placement was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs for the following reasons.
First, the Hearing Officer has previously found that the January 1999 IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs because it failed to address her unique reading comprehension, transition and speech needs. This IEP was in effect throughout the 1999-2000 school year.
Second, the District’s April 4, 2000 offer, that was initially accepted then rejected by the parents, failed to address STUDENT’s unique need for the following reasons. As acknowledged by Mr. Hollins, the April 2000 IEP should have included goals in the areas of functional math skills, social skills relating to developing relationships with same age peers, and vocational skills. As previously discussed, STUDENT’s transition needs for postschool employment and independent living were not assessed at all in her triennial assessment. Rather, under “career-vocational,” the assessors noted, as they had in the 1997 triennial, that “STUDENT...is planning on graduating from high school and will get a job with the assistance of her mother.” While STUDENT took one TPP Careers class in the eleventh grade, there was no persuasive evidence that this class provided her with the intensity of services required in light of her unique needs.
Third, no services were offered to address STUDENT’s severe expressive and receptive language deficits or her pragmatic skills. As previously discussed, the provision of speech services was essential for STUDENT to progress in her other areas of unique need.
B. Was the placement reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit?
In April 2000, when the IEP team reviewed STUDENT’s progress on her annual goals from the January 1999 IEP, it determined that she had not met her written language goal and had only partially met her goals in math skills and reading comprehension. Because her reading comprehension goal did not target any grade level for reading comprehension, it is difficult to determine what was achieved by her partial completion of this goal. It was clear from standardized testing that STUDENT could decode at a higher level than she could comprehend. STUDENT’s reading abilities, as measured by the WJ-R in March of 2000 were at the 3.6 grade level in passage comprehension, the 7.6 grade level in letter-word identification, and the 5.6 grade level in broad reading.
The weight of the evidence established that STUDENT required both intensive speech and language therapy and an intensive reading program to benefit from her education and to help prepare her to transition into supported employment and independent living. There is no persuasive evidence that STUDENT had improved her functional skill levels during this year. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with more than de minimus educational benefit.
2000 Extended School Year
STUDENT was offered extended school year services in the April 2000 IEP. As previously discussed, on May 25, 2000, the District members of the IEP team convened an IEP meeting without either of the parents or STUDENT in attendance. The purpose of the meeting was to discuss the parents’ concerns that STUDENT had received no benefit in reading comprehension and was functioning at the fifth-grade level in the eleventh grade. At this IEP meeting, the District offered STUDENT Lindamood Bell [LMB] instruction for the 2000 extended school year with an informal reassessment at its conclusion to determine her need for LMB methods the following school year. The IEP document was not signed by the parents and was never implemented. STUDENT’s Mother testified that she had never received this IEP or had any knowledge of the offer. STUDENT never received LMB services.(Footnote 26)
The Hearing Officer finds that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 2000 ESY based upon two procedural violations. First, the District inappropriately convened an IEP meeting without either of STUDENT’s parents in attendance after confirming that the parent had canceled the meeting through Mr. Page, who was at the IEP meeting. Pursuant to Calif. Educ. Code §§ 56341(b) and 56341.5, the parents are mandatory participants at IEP meetings absent documented efforts by the district to ensure their attendance. In this case, the District made no pretense of efforts to ensure the parents’ attendance at the meeting. This action was particularly egregious in light of the District’s action in conducting the January 1999 IEP meeting without the parents’ presence and the District’s subsequent representation that their attendance would be ensured for all future IEP meetings. Second, the District failed to convey its offer of LMB services to STUDENT’s parents. District witnesses testified that the case carrier, Mr. Page, had the responsibility for delivering the March 25, 2000 IEP to the parents for their review. The Hearing Officer finds Mrs. STUDENT’s Parents’ testimony that she never received this offer to be credible and there was no testimony to contradict this. While procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, Id. at. 1484.
In this case, the Hearing Officer finds that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 2000 ESY both because her parents were denied the opportunity to participate in the IEP process and because she was denied an important educational opportunity.
* * * In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school and extended school year.
4. The 2000-2001 School and Extended School Year (Twelfth Grade)
STUDENT entered her senior year at TVHS in the fall of 2000 and continued in the SDC program. It is apparent from the record as a whole that the District became more responsive to STUDENT’s needs after her initial request for due process hearing was filed. As previously indicated, in August 2000 the parties agreed that STUDENT would be assessed in areas ignored in the February 2000 triennial assessment but addressed by Dr. Patterson. That assessment was completed in February 2001 and culminated in a new IEP dated April 4, 2001, that included a number of detailed goals and transition services for STUDENT that were specifically designed to address her functional academic skills and transition needs. An analysis of whether FAPE was provided during the 2000-2001 school year thus must be broken into two time frames, outlined below.
1. Fall 2000 through April 3, 2001
A. Was the placement designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
STUDENT’s unique needs
STUDENT’s basic unique needs remained substantially the same in the 2000-2001 school year. According to Dr. Patterson, STUDENT also had needs to develop her self-advocacy skills. Because of STUDENT’s auditory language processing problem, she did not read nonverbal cues. As a result, STUDENT was in need of a social-skills training program, like the one developed by Michelle Gardica Winter, to develop self-advocacy skills and to learn how to read nonverbal cues. Ms. Metzger testified that STUDENT’s pragmatic skills were extremely low and that she had a need in the area of self-advocacy. From the testimony of both Dr. Patterson and Ms. Metzger, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT had an additional unique need in the area of developing self-advocacy skills.
Designed to Meet her Unique Needs?
STUDENT’s teachers during her senior year also testified that they used multi-sensory teaching methods with STUDENT, and provided her with some instruction in functional use of skills. (Testimony of Mr. Page, Ms. Castro). Mr. Page remained STUDENT’s case carrier and taught her SDC English classes over two trimesters.
Although STUDENT’s parents consented to the April 4, 2000 IEP, they revoked their consent to that document in May 2000, after filing their initial request for due process hearing. As a consequence, the January 1999 IEP remained in effect throughout the year. The Hearing Officer finds that the 1999-2000 placement as offered in the January 1999 IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs for the same reasons outlined in the previous school year. In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that the April 4, 2000 placement offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs because it failed to included goals in the areas of functional math skills, social and self-advocacy skills, failed to address STUDENT’s unique transition needs, and failed to offer services to address STUDENT’s severe expressive and receptive language deficits or her pragmatic skills.
B. Was the placement reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit?
Although the District’s offered placement was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs during the 2000-2001 school year, the testimony of Dr. Patterson established that STUDENT demonstrated progress particularly in the area of mathematics when he retested her with the PIAT-R in April 2001. Dr. Patterson testified that STUDENT had a positive outlook on life, had lost a significant amount of weight, was less bothered by her knees, and had more insight into her learning and social problems than during his initial evaluation. In mathematics, STUDENT had improved from a 2.2 (SS=61) to a 6.3 grade equivalent (SS=82). STUDENT was still significantly delayed compared to her peers. However, Dr. Patterson testified that this increase in four grade levels demonstrated that STUDENT is clearly capable of learning with appropriate instruction. He attributed this increase to a recent District report that indicated STUDENT was working on basic skills such as making change and on math vocabulary. STUDENT’s general information and adaptive behavior also increased during this period.(Footnote 27)
It is well established that the District’s offer must be viewed at the time it was made to determine if it was designed to provide STUDENT with a meaningful benefit, rather in hindsight. Adams v. Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141( 9th Cir. 1999). In this case, for all of the reasons previously articulated, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s placement offers were not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and were not reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit at the time they were made. While STUDENT in fact made some progress, the reason for that progress is not clear. The evidence established that, during this year, STUDENT was experiencing several life changes. For example, she was losing weight and was receiving more attention regarding her education and future from her mother, who had retired from the police force. Nonetheless, although testing indicated that STUDENT received benefit in some areas, particularly in mathematics, she did not receive more than de minimus benefit in her critical areas of need in reading comprehension, speech, and transition services. The benefit STUDENT received will be a factor the Hearing Officer will consider in determining the appropriate amount of compensatory services.
2. April 4, 2001 Through the End of the 2000-2001 School Year
A. Procedural Appropriateness
Petitioner contends that the District denied her a FAPE by awarding her a high school diploma in June of 2001 during the pendency of the due process hearing and contrary to the agreement in the IEP of April 4, 2001, that she would receive a certificate of completion.
The obligation to make FAPE available to all children with disabilities does not apply to “students with disabilities who have graduated from high school with a regular high school diploma.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.122(a)(3). It is not necessary to conduct an evaluation of a student with a disability prior to graduation with a regular high school diploma. 34 C.F.R. § 300.534(c)(2). However, “graduation from high school with a regular diploma constitutes a change in placement, requiring written prior notice in accordance with § 300.503.” The uncontradicted evidence establishes that prior written notice was not provided to Petitioner before the diploma was awarded and that the diploma was awarded contrary to the agreement reached at the April 4, 2001 IEP meeting to issue STUDENT a letter of recommendation and not a diploma.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s action of awarding STUDENT a high school diploma during the pendency of this due process hearing violated the automatic stay put provisions of 20 U.S.C. § 1415 (j) and constituted a denial of FAPE. This violation clearly deprived STUDENT of substantial educational opportunity. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, Id. at. 1484. The Hearing Office has recognized that “the award of a diploma to a student with a disability has significant consequences. Whereas prior to graduation the student is entitled to receive a multitude of services from one central source (the school district), after graduation the student is responsible for identifying and establishing eligibility for appropriate services from a potentially vast array of adult agencies. Because graduation constitutes a change in placement, a school district seeking to award a diploma must notify the parent of the intent to award a diploma and confirm that the student has completed his IEP criteria for graduation.... And because the IDEA does not contemplate the provision of special education or related services beyond graduation, a fundamental prerequisite to awarding a valid diploma to a special education student is that adequate transition planning and services have been provided.” Student v. Novato Unified School District (April 1995) 22 IDELR 1056. In this case, the District’s failure to provide appropriate transition services to STUDENT was one of the reasons for the Hearing Officer’s finding that STUDENT was denied a FAPE. Thus, she faces a substantial loss of educational opportunity. As a consequence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the diploma issued to STUDENT must be rescinded and that the District must issue to her a certificate of completion as set forth in the Order below.
B. Substantive Appropriateness
As previously indicated, the April 4, 2001 IEP was the first IEP document during STUDENT’s high school career that contained detailed and measurable goals designed to address her unique needs. The primary deficiency of the April 4, 2001 IEP was its failure to recommend a specific and appropriate amount of speech and language services or to include any goals and objectives in the area of speech and language. The Hearing Officer finds, therefore, that the April 4, 2001 IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs because it failed to include an appropriate offer of speech and language services or to include measurable speech and language goals. The Hearing Officer finds that the level of services offered in the IEP was vague, provided no direct services and was not individualized to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.(Footnote 28)
In addition, STUDENT’s goals outlined in the April 4, 2001 IEP were not put into effect during the 2000-2001 school year. Although Petitioner and her parents signed the April 4, 2001 IEP document with a limited dissent and returned these forms to the District on April 24 and 25, 2001, testimony of District witnesses (Ms. Miller, Ms. Metzer) revealed that the special education office was unaware of its own receipt of Petitioner’s consent and had therefore not implemented the goals. Consequently, the District’s placement offer was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit because the uncontradicted evidence established that the IEP was not implemented during the school year due to the District’s erroneous belief that consent had not been provided by Petitioner. * * * In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s 2000-2001 placement did not offer STUDENT a FAPE. It was not designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs, it was not promptly implemented after the IEP of April 2001, and the District denied her a substantial loss of educational opportunity by issuing her a diploma during the pendency of the due process hearing in contravention of the automatic provisions of stay put and in violation of the parties’ April 2001 IEP. The placement failed to address her critical needs in the areas of reading comprehension, speech and language, and transition services. * * * * * * * * * *
A review of STUDENT’s progress from the ninth grade through the twelfth grade reveals that she never met any of the few goals established for her. Although progress toward achieving IEP goals is not a guarantee, the Hearing Officer has determined that STUDENT did not receive the type and level of services required to meet her unique needs and that her deficits were remediable had she received a program of sufficient depth and intensity. At the end of the twelfth grade, STUDENT was still unable to read an analog clock or to make change, deficits that were identified in her 1997 triennial assessment. Her level of reading comprehension was still below the fourth grade level and her expressive and pragmatic language skills were significantly delayed. Although the 1997 triennial indicated that STUDENT required early job training, specific efforts toward developing her functional academic and life skills were just beginning with the goals drafted for the April 2001 IEP, that were not implemented until after the conclusion of the 2000-2001 school year.
III. IF THE DISTRICT DENIED STUDENT A FAPE DURING ANY OF THE ABOVE YEARS, IS SHE ENTITLED TO COMPENSATORY EDUCATION AND OTHER REMEDIES AVAILABLE UNDER STATE AND FEDERAL LAW?
When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. Of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997). Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have also extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See, e.g. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3rd Cir. 1990) 916 F. 2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.) Compensatory education is an equitable remedy. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for-hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the Student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir.1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1497.
The Hearing Officer has determined that STUDENT was denied a FAPE from February 7, 1998 through the conclusion of the 2000-2001 school year. Petitioner argues that day-for-day compensatory education, while not required, is appropriate in this case. She further argues that the Hearing Officer should determine that any compensatory education awarded begin after her twenty-second birthday, when she will no longer be eligible for special education services. However, Petitioner has not presented any authority for her assertion that she is automatically entitled to special education services until the age of twenty-two.
STUDENT will turn age twenty-two on October 6, 2004, during the 2004-2005 school year. Pursuant to Education Code § 56026(c)(4)(C), as a student who turns twenty-two in October, she “shall be terminated from the [special education] program on December 31 of the current fiscal year [2004], unless the person would otherwise complete his or her individualized education program at the end of the current fiscal year.” Thus, it is possible that STUDENT could complete the full academic year of 2004-2005. This means that, theoretically, STUDENT could receive as many as three years of educational services from the date of this decision.
Respondent opposes an award of compensatory education to commence after STUDENT turns twenty-two, but its position on STUDENT’s continued eligibility is contradictory. It argues, on the one hand, that STUDENT is eligible through the 2004-2005 school year, and on the other, that she is entitled to additional services on a demonstration of need as determined by the IEP team. In fact, the services currently offered STUDENT in the IEP of April 2001 extend only through April 2002. Any additional services after that point are subject to redetermination at that time, in light of STUDENT’s needs and progress. The practical effect of the parties’ disagreement is as follows: Under Petitioner’s view, she is automatically entitled to special education services until the age of twenty-two and should receive an additional award of compensatory education of three years. This could result in a receipt of special education services through the 2007-2008 academic year. Under Respondent’s view, Petitioner is entitled to special education services for possibly less but for no more than the full 2004-2005 school year.
A review of the statutory definition of “child with a disability” establishes that a special education student who has not graduated is not automatically entitled to continuing services until age 21 or 22. As indicated in Education Code § 56026(c)(4), ongoing services are available to students between the ages of 19 and 21 years who are enrolled in or eligible for a program prior to his or her 19th birthday, “and have not yet completed his or her prescribed course of study or who have not met proficiency standards prescribed pursuant to Sections 51215 and 51216.” While the statute offers no definition of “prescribed course of study,” it is apparent that, in this context, it refers to the course of study outlined in the goals and objectives of the student’s IEP.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is entitled to three years of compensatory education services because her unique needs were not addressed during her high school years and were negatively affected by her characterization as an individual of limited cognitive functioning. The Hearing Officer further finds that these services are to commence within twenty days of the date of this decision. While it is possible to award compensatory education services to commence beyond the age of twenty-two for violations that occurred within the period of statutory eligibility, the Hearing Officer declines to make this order. Petitioner has produced no evidence regarding the type of educational services that STUDENT would require at age twenty-two. The speculative nature of such an award was recognized by Petitioner’s counsel at the outset of the hearing. She suggested that the IEP team be ordered to convene and determine STUDENT’s needs at that time. The Hearing Officer concludes, however, that STUDENT requires an immediate and intensive infusion of services in the areas of reading comprehension, speech and language, and transition services. As indicated by Ms. Hein, STUDENT’s future prognosis is good if she receives such services before she becomes an independent adult (i.e., graduates and/or attempts to enter the workforce). Given the multiple choices and decisions facing STUDENT as she enters young adulthood, there is no guarantee that she will be interested in and/or available to participate in intensive services over three years from now.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires the following compensatory services:
1. Transition services: The District presented substantial evidence regarding its Adult Bridge/Workability program in which STUDENT is currently enrolled. That program involves a combination of academic and functional life skills, with on-the-job experience facilitated by a job coach and interaction with the speech therapist both at the job site and in the classroom. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s Bridge Workability program appropriately addresses STUDENT’s unique transition needs. The District is to provide STUDENT with services through this program until she turns twenty-two. STUDENT’s transition goals shall be annually updated by the IEP team. Pursuant to California Education Code § 56026(c)(4)(C), the IEP team shall determine whether STUDENT’s participation in the program should conclude on December 31, 2004, or should extend through the completion of the 2004-2005 school year. Petitioner points out that the District’s Bridge services are only offered for three hours and twenty minutes per day, five days a week. These service shall be supplemented as outlined below.
2. Speech and Language: STUDENT is to receive three (3) hours a week of intensive speech and language services utilizing the goals and objectives outlined by Ms. Hein in her assessment report. These goals and objectives shall serve as the baseline for STUDENT’s speech and language services and may be amended by the IEP team as her expressive, receptive, and pragmatic language skills develop in the future. These services shall be provided to STUDENT by a licensed speech and language pathologist. During the first year of services, STUDENT shall be provided a minimum of two hours per week of one-on-one services by the speech therapist. At the conclusion of one year of services, the speech therapist may determine the appropriate proportion of time STUDENT is to receive in one-on-one and small-group services.(Footnote 29) Services shall continue for a period of three years, including summers, with reasonable time (two weeks) for vacations and holidays.
3. Reading Comprehension: STUDENT shall received intensive services from the Lindamood Bell program in reading comprehension and language, initially using a visualizing-verbalizing and Seeing Stars model. These services shall be provided for a minimum of four hours a day, five days a week, for a minimum of six weeks, in the ESY 2002. At the conclusion of the summer program, the IEP team shall meet and determine whether to continue providing LMB instruction or whether STUDENT requires a different type of cohesive reading program such as Project Read. The reading program provided must be multi-sensory, highly structured and redundant. STUDENT shall be provided compensatory services in reading comprehension for a period of three years, including summers, with reasonable time for vacations and holidays. All summer programs shall be of the intensity and duration described above. The IEP team shall determine the amount of reading comprehension services to be provided to STUDENT during the school year in light of the total services she must receive.
4. Self-Advocacy: STUDENT shall participate in a self-advocacy program such as described by Dr. Patterson to assist her in advocating for her own needs in relation to developing relationships with same age peers, accessing community services and employment needs. The IEP team shall determine the appropriate time for her participation in this program in light of her overall education schedule and needs.
ORDER
1. Within ten (10) business days of the date of this decision, the District shall rescind STUDENT’s high school diploma and issue to her a certificate of completion.
2. Within ten (10) business days from the date of this decision, the District shall reimburse Petitioner for the costs of the independent educational evaluations conducted by Dr. Patterson and Ms. Hein, for a total amount of $2,000.00.
3. Within ten (10) business days from the date of this decision, if it has not already done so, the District shall prepare an assessment plan for STUDENT to be evaluated by an audiologist for central auditory processing disorder and make necessary arrangements for a prompt evaluation. The IEP team shall meet within ten (10) days of receipt of the results of the evaluation to modify STUDENT’s IEP as necessary to implement treatment recommendations resulting from this evaluation.
4. The District shall provide STUDENT with the following compensatory education services:
a. Transition services: Regular attendance at the Bridge/Workability program until she turns twenty-two. STUDENT’s transition goals shall be annually updated by the IEP team. Pursuant to California Education Code § 56026(c)(4)(C), the IEP team shall determine whether Petitioner’s participation in the program should conclude on December 31, 2004, or should extend through the completion of the 2004-2005 school year.
b. Speech and Language: STUDENT is to receive three (3) hours a week of intensive speech and language services utilizing the goals and objectives outlined by Ms. Hein in her assessment report. These services shall be provided to STUDENT by a licensed speech and language pathologist. During the first year of services, STUDENT shall be provided a minimum of two (2) hours per week of one-on-one services by the speech therapist. The remaining hour may be in small-group services. At the conclusion of one year of services, the speech therapist may determine the appropriate proportion of time STUDENT is to receive one-on-one and small group services. Services shall continue for a period of three years, including summers, with reasonable time (two weeks) for vacations and holidays.
c. Reading Comprehension: STUDENT shall received intensive services from the Lindamood Bell program in reading comprehension and language, initially using a visualizing-verbalizing and Seeing Stars model. These services shall be provided for a minimum of four hours a day, five days a week, for a minimum of six weeks, in the ESY 2002. At the conclusion of the summer program, the IEP team shall meet and determine whether to continue providing LMB instruction or whether STUDENT requires a different type of cohesive reading program such as Project Read. The reading program provided must be multi-sensory, highly structured and redundant. STUDENT shall be provided compensatory services in reading comprehension for a period of three years, including summers, with reasonable time for vacations and holidays. All summer programs shall be of the intensity and duration described above. The IEP team shall determine the amount of reading comprehension services to be provided to STUDENT during the school year in light of the total services she must receive.
d. Self-Advocacy: STUDENT shall participate in a self-advocacy program such as described by Dr. Patterson to assist her in advocating for her own needs in relation to developing relationships with same age peers, accessing community services and employment needs. The IEP team shall determine the appropriate time for her participation in this program in light of her overall education schedule and needs.
5. No later than six months prior to STUDENT’s twenty-second birthday (April 6, 2004), the IEP team shall meet to evaluate her present levels of performance, her completion of the compensatory education services outlined in Order 4, and to determine her need for additional services to effectively transition into supported employment and independent living.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: The Student prevailed on all issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: April 24, 2002 _____________________________________ Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. Mr. Gonzalez appeared for Ms. Lewis on July 19, part of July 26, November 13, and 14, 2001. 2. The issues are different from those originally submitted to the Hearing Office. They have been revised and renumbered for clarification and to reflect discussions between the parties and the Hearing Officer on the first day of hearing and on subsequent days when the Hearing Officer permitted the addition of two issues that Petitioner noticed on April 24, 2001. On April 25, 2001, the District’s objection to adding an issue regarding STUDENT’s eligibility for special education as a student with a speech or language disorder was sustained. Following clarification by Petitioner, the issue (now incorporated into Issue 2) was amended to assert that speech and language related/DIS services were a component of the FAPE to which Petitioner believed she was entitled. The District did not dispute this. On May 24, 2001, the Hearing Officer overruled the District’s objection and allowed the addition of Petitioner’s issue regarding reimbursement for the Hein IEE, now incorporated into Issue 1, in the interests of judicial economy. As a result of this ruling, Petitioner withdrew her request for a separate due process hearing. 3. Petitioner’s request for due process hearing was received by the Hearing Office on February 7, 2001. Calif. Educ. Code § 56505 (j). 4. On the first day of hearing, Petitioner clarified that extended school year was contested for every year except 2000-2001. 5. Respondent also contends that STUDENT was not eligible for special education as a student with a speech or language impairment. As indicated in footnote 3, supra, however, the only issue for the hearing is whether STUDENT should have been provided related services of speech therapy, and not her eligibility on this basis. 6. This score was well below STUDENT’s two previous VMI standard score results of 87 in 1997, at the high end of below average range, and of 91 in 1994, in the low average range. 7. Mr. Page testified that he administered these tests under Ms. Niotis’ supervision, that she helped him score them, and that he took a course in assessment after he administered this test. 8. The IEP noted that STUDENT had complained about her knees hurting in aerobics. STUDENT’s Mother acknowledged that STUDENT had weak knees because of her weight. Ms. Teahan suggested a walking program for STUDENT on weekends and, at STUDENT’s Mother’s request, stated she would add this to STUDENT’s class fitness journal. 9. The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders- Fourth Edition (DSM-IV), describes mental retardation as significantly subaverage general intellectual functioning that is accompanied by significant limitations in adaptive functioning in at least two of the following skill areas: communication, self-care, home living, social/interpersonal skills, use of community resources, self-direction, functional academic skills, work, leisure, health, and safety. Significantly subaverage intellectual functioning is defined as an IQ of about 70 or below (approximately 2 standard deviations below the mean). Individuals with an IQ in the 71-84 range are within the borderline intellectual functioning range. DSM-IV at pp. 39-40. As noted by Dr. Patterson, Larry P. does not prohibit the use of IQ testing of American-American students in contexts other than special education. 10. For example, on the 1997 Woodcock-Johnson Psycho-Educational Test Battery-Revised, STUDENT received the following standard scores on subtests: letter word identification (SS=87), passage comprehension (SS=73), calculation (SS=91), applied problems (SS=76), dictation (SS=77), and writing sample (SS=83). On the Wide Range Achievement Test-Revised (WRAT-R), an older version of the current WRAT-3, STUDENT received a standard score of 83 on reading, 91 on spelling, and a 90 on arithmetic. On the Test of Written Language-2 (TOWL-2), an older version of the current TOWL-3, STUDENT received a standard score of 80. In the area of language, STUDENT received standard scores of 80 on both the Expressive One Word Picture Vocabulary Test (EOWPVT) and on the Receptive One Word Picture Vocabulary Test (ROWPVT). Both of these scores were in the low average range. In reading, STUDENT demonstrated a great difficulty in word attack with mid-word sounds and performed at the 2.2 grade level. Dr. Patterson reported that this demonstrated “a significant lack of understanding of phonetic principles.” 11. On August 1, 2000 at an informal conference, the parties agreed to additional assessments in the areas of academics (to determine STUDENT’s skill deficits in reading, math and written language), speech and language, social skills, vocational needs, and occupational therapy. Because Petitioner did not challenge OT services, it is not necessary to address this portion of the assessment. 12. Dr. Patterson testified that the Brigance is a valuable tool for developing curriculum. It is not a normed reference test, however, so there is no way to determine STUDENT’s standard score, where she is in relation to peers, or how her progress compares from test to test. 13. According to Dr. Corman, there is a twenty percent chance of false positive or false negative findings in CPT tests that is also true for any diagnostic tool. Although the District introduced evidence that discussed higher false positive or negative rates of several CPTs, Dr. Corman testified that the TOVA has been accepted in the field for diagnostic purposes and that it was only one of several tools he used to diagnose STUDENT. 14. Dr. Patterson testified that the term “limited cognitive function” as used by the District in its multiple determinations of STUDENT’s eligibility for special education on her IEPs extending from February 1997 to April 2001 met the definition of mentally retarded under Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(h). “A pupil has significantly below average general intellectual functioning existing concurrently with deficits in adaptive behavior and manifested during the developmental period, which adversely affect a pupil’s educational performance.” In his opinion, the IEP team could definitely have determined STUDENT to be eligible as a student with a specific learning disability pursuant to an alternative assessment under Cal. Code Regs., tit.5, § 3030(j), or under the more comprehensive category as a student with an “other health impairment,” based upon her significant deficits in functioning from medical conditions that impacted her ability to learn (Cal. Code Regs., tit.5, § 3030(f)). 15. This conclusion is consistent with STUDENT’s IQ testing during a 1993 psychoeducational evaluation by Kaiser Permanente, when she was ten years old in the fifth grade. STUDENT received a verbal IQ score of 70 and a performance IQ score of 85 on the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Revised (WISC-R). Because STUDENT exhibited a high degree of emotional unrest and problems with processing verbal information, the assessor determined that these scores did not appear to be a valid estimate of her innate intellectual potential. (Pet. Ex. 13). The WISC-R was later specifically prohibited for use for special education purposes with African-American students in Larry P. v. Riles, 495 F. Supp. 926 (1979), p. 931. 16. At the April 4, 2001 IEP meeting, STUDENT’s present level of performance in communication was described in part as follows: “student has average receptive language, moderately low expressive language, and moderately low pragmatic language. The area of pragmatic language seems to be the area of most concern.” At the due process hearing, Ms. Metzger testified that she believed STUDENT was eligible for speech and language services and that she had written a note to the speech therapist to meet with STUDENT’s teacher “at least once a month for consult/collab to discuss vocab development, pragmatic/social language, conventions of conversation, etc..” and that she should “try to go in and observe STUDENT in that classroom at least 2xmo particularly listening for speech error patterns as well as the above (15 minutes ea.time).” At the IEP meeting, however, the District did not offer STUDENT any specified amount of consultative speech services and did not mention collaboration services that would directly involve the student. 17. There is no merit to the District’s contention that STUDENT was assessed by Ms. Hein prior to the April 4, 2001 IEP meeting. STUDENT’s Mother testified that, after the IEP team denied STUDENT speech and language services at the April 4, 2001 IEP meeting, she took STUDENT for an independent speech and language evaluation by Joanne Hein. Ms. Hein testified that she assessed STUDENT over a five-hour period on April 6, 2001. 18. An example of STUDENT’s inappropriate pragmatic language skills (failure to differentiate audiences) was her statement to Ms. Hein that she “is a real suck-up for teachers.” STUDENT also reported that she likes to give teachers massages and do favors for them. Ms. Hein testified that STUDENT thinks she can manipulate teachers and that she showed both pride and lack of insight by this statement. 19. For example, Ms. Alban testified that STUDENT made diligent efforts to stay awake in class. STUDENT brought a squirt bottle to class and asked students around her to squirt her if she fell asleep. Ms. Alban tried other methods to keep STUDENT awake: she removed STUDENT from her more comfortable desk, where she could put her head down, to a computer table. When this did not stop STUDENT from falling asleep, Ms. Alban had STUDENT sit on a chair and gave her a clipboard to write on. Ms. Alban described one particularly memorable incident in which STUDENT decided to stand by a tall filing cabinet to stay awake. Even this did not help: STUDENT still fell asleep and Ms. Alban “heard her go down” and hit the cabinet. Nonetheless, Ms. Alban testified that she had no concern that STUDENT had a physical problem because her explanation about staying up late at night watching TV was reasonable. STUDENT described the movie she watched, and because it was listed in the TV guide, Ms. Alban believed her. SDC teacher Ms. Niotis testified that she told STUDENT’s parents about this behavior many times but did not tell them about STUDENT’s explanation of watching TV. STUDENT’s Mother testified that, once she learned this was STUDENT’s explanation for sleeping, she put her to bed early. 20. During the ninth grade, RSP teacher Mr. Cariss reported that STUDENT seemed tired lately/at times. He later reported that she“wants to sleep in class. Must be the teacher!!!” In April 2000, in SDC driver’s education, STUDENT was noted as “having trouble staying awake as we read chapter...”and, “falls asleep during tests and class discussions....” Later that month, Ms. Alban noted that STUDENT was “doing great-fell asleep in the middle of doing a math problem; says she is really tired.” In May 2000, it was noteworthy that “STUDENT does all her work and stays awake in class.” That same month, SDC teacher Ms. Niotis’ comment regarding STUDENT’s participation in SDC history was “if she’s not sleeping, she is talking.” On January 16, 2001, Mr. Crownover in TTP Careers class noted that “STUDENT is sick frequently in class–she sleeps–or else does not wish to participate in class activities. Many things we do are with partners or small groups.” 21. In describing Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), the DSM-IV at p. 82-83, states that “symptoms of inattention are common among children with low IQ who are placed in academic settings that are inappropriate to their intellectual ability. These behaviors must be distinguished from similar signs in children with Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder. In children with Mental Retardation, an additional diagnosis of Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder should be made only if the symptoms of inattention or hyperactivity are excessive for the child’s mental age...” 22. Various District witnesses testified that STUDENT’s grades were in effect modified by virtue of being in special education. (Test. Mr. Alban, Mr. Page, Ms. Dorn, Ms. Niotis). Mr. Alban testified that “technically” STUDENT’s grades were not modified but the classes were modified and this would eventually have an affect on her grades. Expectations for special education students were modified so that STUDENT’s grade of D- in Introduction to Art was actually a modified D-. Mr. Alban testified that the grades were definitely modified in RSP classes. Both Mr. Alban and Mr. Page testified that one of their responsibilities as case carrier was to talk to regular education teachers if a student was failing and to select classes in which a student would be successful. Regular teachers may have been asked to modify grades but it was up to the discretion of the individual teacher to decide whether to do so. Mr. Page testified that, in STUDENT’s senior year, he talked to her RSP math teacher about her failing grade. STUDENT received a B in the class. STUDENT’s Mother testified that she was advised by Mr. Page that STUDENT’s grades were based on her effort not her ability. This was consistent with the testimony of Ms. Niotis that the only reason for an SDC student to fail a class was for not completing the work, and that all work was graded in relation to the individual rather than against an objective standard. The evidence also established that the District had a policy to allow the name of a regular education class to be changed to an SDC class in order for a student to obtain a passing grade. This occurred several times with STUDENT. Finally, the evidence established that grades would be modified to ensure passing if a teacher did not notify parents that their child was at risk of failing. As a consequence, STUDENT received a C- in Ms. Castro’s Clothing class during her senior year instead of an F. 23. Mr. Alban conceded that it was understandable for the parents to oppose SDC placement if STUDENT was receiving regular education grades of A, B and C and the IEP did not indicate that the grades would be modified. He also believed that due to grade inflation in special education classes, it was difficult for a case carrier to explain a student’s problems to his/her parents because the grades did not paint a true picture of his/her progress. 24. During the extended school year 1999, STUDENT enrolled in SDC English A. A report card for the period June 29 through July 15, 1999, indicated that STUDENT ultimately withdrew from the class. On July 15, 1999, teacher Michael Arroyo completed a “TVHS Grade Change Form” for STUDENT to request that the course title of STUDENT’s SDC English A class be changed to SDC World History for ESY 1999. This change was approved by Ms. Beaman on August 4, 1999. STUDENT earned no credit for any class during this extended school year. 25. Calif. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3053 provides that special day classes “shall be taught by a full-time-equivalent teacher whose responsibility is the instruction, supervision, and coordination of the education program for those individuals enrolled in the special class. The special class shall be taught by a teacher who holds an appropriate special education credential authorized by the Commission on Teacher Credentialing and who possesses the necessary competencies to teach individuals assigned to the class....” The Hearing Officer finds that, due to his lack of training and experience in special education, Mr. Page’s testimony is entitled to little weight. 26. STUDENT was the traditional method of delivery of school papers and IEP documents to the parents. For example, she attended the January 5, 1999 IEP meeting that was convened in the parents’ absence and brought the completed document home for their review and signature. The District offered no evidence that the May 2000 IEP document was sent to the parents. 27. STUDENT’s total reading remained roughly the same on this retest, decreasing slightly from a 5.0 to a 4.9 grade equivalent (GE). While STUDENT’s reading recognition had increased from a 4.4 GE in July 2000 to a 5.3 GE in April 2001, her reading comprehension had declined from a 5.4 GE (SS=79) to a 4.0 GE (SS=71). STUDENT’s spelling decreased from 7.9 to 6.3 GE, her written expression decreased slightly from a standard score of 78 to 76, but this was not statistically significant in Dr. Patterson’s view. 28. When asked whether this level of services was appropriate for STUDENT, Ms. Metzger testified that she believes all students need it every day but that it is not logistically possible. She testified that this is what the District is currently offering all or a majority of its students. 29. The Hearing Officer notes Ms. Metzger’s opinion that STUDENT needs to be in a learning environment with same-age peers and have her vocabulary and language skills developed in a functional class context. In light of the years of remediation STUDENT requires, however, that assessment must be made by the therapist with whom she is working and will undoubtedly change over time.
