California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 1, 2001
Student v. Yucaipa-Calimesa Joint Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 244-01 · Hearing Officer Glenna Eubank deCamara
Yucaipa-Calimesa Joint Unified denied FAPE by neglecting social skills; must assess for autism, but reimbursement claims fail.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A 13-year-old sixth-grader at Yucaipa-Calimesa Joint Unified's Park View Middle School filed for due process, with her mother representing her. She was eligible for special education as speech and language impaired, in the area of pragmatic (social) language. Her mother argued that the district ignored gaps in reading and math, did not provide the pull-out resource specialist program (RSP) services in her IEP, gave too little speech help, and failed to keep her safe. The mother moved her to a private school from December 2000 to April 2001.
The Hearing Officer found that the district had properly assessed and met her academic needs. She worked at grade level without modifications, met all of her IEP goals, and ranked near the top of her grade in math. The IEP's RSP offer was unclear and was not carried out, but this did not harm her academically. The safety claim failed because no staff member saw or heard of any incident. However, the district did not adequately address her social skills and pragmatic language needs, especially outside the classroom, even though she scored in the first percentile on a test of social understanding. That denied her a FAPE for 2000-2001. The Hearing Officer denied reimbursement for the Lindamood-Bell and Sylvan evaluations and for private school tuition. The district was ordered to assess social skills, social language, and autism, then hold an IEP meeting and add a formal social skills plan.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled a student who was doing well academically but had social and pragmatic language deficits that went unaddressed. Academic success did not end the inquiry. It also shows that private evaluations obtained before any district assessment, or in areas the district had assessed properly, were not reimbursed.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1a. Did the District deny a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year by failing to identify and address Student's academic needs in reading/language arts and math?
The District correctly assessed Student's cognitive ability and achievement; she met all IEP goals and worked at grade level without modifications, so her academic needs were met and she received educational benefit.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1b. Did the District identify and address Student's unique needs in social skills and pragmatic language, and did its program provide educational benefit in that area?
Despite a first-percentile score on a test of social understanding and observed social deficits, the District offered only monthly speech consultation and did not address social skills in unstructured settings; an autism evaluation was warranted. This denied a FAPE for 2000-2001.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1c. Did the District deny a FAPE by failing to maintain a safe school environment, requiring Student's removal from Park View?
Insufficient evidence: no staff witnessed or received reports of harassment, Student was the only source, and her reports more likely reflected her difficulty with social language.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEImplementation
Issue 1d. Did the District's program conform to Student's IEP, which called for 50 to 150 minutes of daily 'Pull-out/Small group/RSP' services?
The RSP offer was unclear and not specific, and the RSP services were not implemented, but Student was not harmed because she still benefited academically.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 2. Are the Petitioner's parents entitled to reimbursement for independent evaluations conducted by Lindamood-Bell Learning Processing Center and Sylvan Learning Center?
Denied: the evaluations were not obtained because parents disagreed with a District assessment (Lindamood preceded it; Sylvan was not shared until hearing), and they tested academic areas where the District's assessment was appropriate.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 3. Are the Petitioner's parents entitled to reimbursement of tuition costs resulting from Student's enrollment in private school for a portion of the 2000-2001 school year?
Denied: the parent herself testified that Calvary was inappropriate and gave no educational benefit, and no immediate safety threat excused the duty to choose a placement meeting Student's needs.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to assess. Within ten business days of the decision, District shall give parents an assessment plan for a comprehensive social skills and social language assessment, including observations by an appropriate specialist of Student's peer interactions 'in both structured environments' (likely meant structured and unstructured), and an evaluation for autism and/or autistic characteristics.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. After parents consent, assessments shall be completed and an IEP meeting convened within the time prescribed by law, unless extended by agreement.
- Order to provide or change services. At the IEP meeting, the team shall draft a formal social skills plan addressing any deficits the assessments reveal in social and pragmatic language skills and include it in the IEP.
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Seattle School Dist. v. B.S.; Union School Dist. v. Smith; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Alamo Heights Independent School Dist. v. State Board of Education
People named in the decision
- Gail Lindbergh, program manager, District representative (non-attorney), East Valley SELPA
- Lynn Pletcher, director of student services, Yucaipa-Calimesa Joint Unified School District
- Brett Smith, school psychologist (listed as counselor); conducted triennial psychoeducational reevaluation, Yucaipa-Calimesa Joint Unified School District
- Diane Smith, speech and language specialist; consultant and assessor, Yucaipa-Calimesa Joint Unified School District
- Tasha Bennett, sixth-grade general education teacher, Park View Middle School
- Rose Roy, resource specialist (RSP teacher), Park View Middle School
- David Caminiti, resource specialist (summer RSP teacher, elementary), Yucaipa-Calimesa Joint Unified School District
- Nancy Hilbrands, speech pathologist, Yucaipa-Calimesa Joint Unified School District
- Janet Curtis, counselor, Park View Middle School
- Melissa Proffitt, principal, Yucaipa-Calimesa Joint Unified School District
- Lindamood-Bell Learning Processing Center, private provider; independent academic evaluation
- Sylvan Learning Center, private provider; independent academic evaluation
- Calvary Chapel, private school (unilateral placement)
- Cherry Brethren, private parochial school (prior placement, K-5)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Glenna Eubank deCamera, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Yucaipa, California, on April 24, 25, and May 7 and 8, 2001.
Petitioner MOTHER (hereinafter Petitioner or MOTHER) was represented by her mother, MOTHER.
Yucaipa-Calimesa Joint Unified School District (hereinafter Yucaipa or District) was represented by Gail Lindbergh, program manager, East Valley Special Education Local Plan Area (SELPA). Also present on the District’s behalf was Lynn Pletcher, director of student services for Yucaipa.
The Petitioner called her mother, MOTHER, and also testified on her own behalf.
The Respondent called the following witnesses to testify: Brett Smith, counselor; Diane Smith, speech and language specialist; Tasha Bennett, teacher; Rose Roy, resource specialist; David Caminiti, resource specialist; Nancy Hilbrands, speech pathologist; Lynn Pletcher, director of student services; Janet Curtis, counselor; and Melissa Proffitt, principal.
Oral and documentary evidence was received during the hearing, and written closing arguments were submitted thereafter. The record was then closed and the issues were submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
The Petitioner did not submit an issue statement of specifically identify evidence she intended to introduce at the hearing. Within the requisite five days before the hearing, she had sent three documents to the Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office) and the Respondent, without specifying their purpose. At the hearing, the Petitioner stated that she wanted to submit these documents as evidence. The District acknowledged that it had previously received the three documents and that it did not object to their admission. The District did object to the late admission of an independent evaluator’s report, which the Petitioner first produced at the hearing. The Hearing Officer inquired as to whether the District was seeking a continuance of the hearing to require the five-day notice of the other party’s evidence. The District responded that it was ready to proceed with the hearing as scheduled. The Hearing Officer therefore admitted the independent assessment, and allowed the District to augment its evidence and witness list as necessary to respond to the new evaluation.
Although a witness list had not been submitted, the Petitioner’s mother indicated that only she and her daughter intended to testify. The Hearing Officer found that the District could reasonably have anticipated testimony from MOTHER and that therefore it could not claim surprise. The Hearing Officer also accepted a prior letter sent by the Petitioner’s mother to the Hearing Office and the Respondent, which specified her daughter’s desire to testify at the hearing, as the witness designation required by statue. The Petitioner’s mother then testified under oath in a narrative format, submitted to cross-examination, and conducted the direct examination of her daughter.
ISSUES
1. Did the District deny the Petitioner a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2000-2001 school year?
2. Are the Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for independent evaluations conducted by Lindamood-Bell Learning Processing Center (herinafter Lindamood) and Sylvan Learning Center (herinafter Sylvan)?
3. Are the Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement of tuition costs resulting from STUDENT’s enrollment in private school for a portion of the 2000-2001 school year?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The Petitioner maintains that the District did not identify her academic deficits or provide specific recommendations to address them. The Petitioner also argues that her designated disabling condition is a speech and language disorder, yet the District offered once-a-month consultation between the speech pathologist and her teacher to address her delay. Additionally, she did not receive pull-out services from services from the resource specialist program (RSP) as specified in her IEP, and the District did not attempt to remediate her academic delays in language arts and math. As a result, she contends that the District provided inadequate services to meet her special education needs and thereby denied her a FAPE. Finally, the Petitioner claims that she was forced to withdraw from public school and enroll in a private school because the District did not ensure a safe school environment for her. Consequently, she maintains that she is entitled to reimbursement for independent evaluations obtained from Lindamood and Sylvan.
The District disputed the Petitioners’s position, claiming that it assessed the Petitioner in all areas of suspected disability and drafted goals and objectives to respond to her identified areas of need. Yucaipa also contends that it provided the RSP and speech and language services necessary to meet STUDENT’s needs, as well as maintained a safe school environment. As a result, the Petitioner received a FAPE, and she is not entitled to reimbursement for independent assessments or private school tuition.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a thirteen-year-old sixth-grade student whose parents voluntarily enrolled her in Cherry Brethren, a private parochial school, for her kindergarten through fifth-grade school years. Throughout elementary school, STUDENT has qualified for special education in the category of speech and language impaired. Several years ago, a diagnosis of high functioning autism was suggested for STUDENT; however, no follow-u medical valuations were conducted.
Cherry Brethren operates on a traditional school year from September to June. Yucaipa utilizes a multi-track, year-round school schedule. Each year when Cherry Brethren’s school year ended, STUDENT would attend a Yucaipa elementary school during the summer months. She would then return to her private school each September. During the months that STUDENT attended public school, she was designated as a special education student and received speech and pull-out RSP services pursuant to an independent educational plan (IEP) drafted by the District. Prior to the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT left her general education classroom to receive REP instruction from the RSP teacher in the resource classroom. During the 2000-2001 school year, she was provided RSP aide assistance, when needed, within her regular education class. Cherry Brethren did not provide special education services to STUDENT.
STUDENT’s attendance at Cherry Brethren was terminated for disciplinary reasons at the end of the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT’s fifth-grade year. Consequently, she transferred to Yucaipa’s Park View Middle School (hereinafter Park View) for sixth grade at the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year. An IEP meeting was convened on May 2, 2000, to determine STUDENT’s sixth-grade placement and services. The IEP team agreed to place STUDENT in a general education classroom with RSP support. Her IEP stated that she was to be provided 50 to 150 minutes of daily “small-group/pull-out” resource assistance, four to five times per week. The Petitioner’s mother, MOTHER, chose her daughter’s scheduling track and general education teacher(Footnote 1). MOTHER remains very satisfied with her daughter’s regular education sixth-grade teacher.
According to MOTHER, within a month of beginning the 2000-20001 school year at Park View, STUDENT was being harassed at school and at the bus stop. The District maintains that it was unaware of any problems between STUDENT and other students, and MOTHER agrees that STUDENT is the sole source of her information. By December 2000, MOTHER believed that the harassment described by STUDENT created an emotionally unsafe environment for her daughter. She simultaneously notified Park View that she was removing STUDENT from school, and enrolled her in Calvary Chapel, another private school. Calvary Chapel did not provide any special education services, modifications, or accommodations for STUDENT. STUDENT found the curriculum far too difficult and she could not keep up with the other students. PARENTS returned STUDENT to Park View on April 1, 2001, to complete the remainder of her sixth grade year.
While STUDENT was still attending Calvary Chapel, MOTHER filed for this due process hearing contending that the District did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE. She seeks reimbursement for independent assessments, as well as repayment of the tuition costs for Calvary Chapel.
FINDINGS OF FACTS AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE ONE
Did the District deny STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2000-2001 school year?
“Special education” is defined as “specially designed instruction at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability...” 2 U.S.C. § 1401 (25). Under both federal and state law, students with disabilities have the right to a free and appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8), “free and appropriate public education” means special education and related services that meet the standards of a State educational agency and conform with the students individualized education program.
In determining whether a district has offered a free, appropriate public education, the focus is on the adequacy of the district’s proposed placement. The criteria are not whether the parents desire another program, or if that program would result in a greater educational benefit to the child. Gregory K. V. Longview School District, 811 F.2nd 1307 (9th cir. 1987) In the case of Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. Vs. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175, (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the Individuals with Disabilities Act (IDEA). The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or that the services maximize each child’s potential. The Court held that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.” An appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the individual child. Seattle School District v. B.S., 24 IDELR 68 (9th Cir. 1996); Union School District v. Smith, 15 F. 3d 1519 (9th Cir. 1994); Rowley, supra.
As part of an appropriate education, the child is also entitled to related services. The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective and supportive services which may be required to assist a child with a disability benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401 (22). California Education Code § 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” Included in the list of related services are speech and language, orientation and mobility, physical and occupational therapy, counseling, health and nursing services, social worker services, adapted physical education and psychological services. Additional services may include behavioral intervention services and case management.
Thus, a district has complied with its statutory obligations to offer an appropriate education pursuant to the IDEA, and the interpreting case law, when its offer of placement and services (1) is designed to meet the student’s unique needs; (2) provides the student with some educational benefit and (3) conforms to the student’s individual education program(Footnote 2). Rowley, supra; 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq. The Hearing Officer will discuss these issues when determining the appropriateness of the District’s offer of placement and services.
1. Did the District identify STUDENT’s unique needs and design an individual program to meet them?
A determination of the student’s particular special education requirements is a prerequisite to evaluating whether the District’s program appropriately responded to the child’s needs. In this case, the District determined that STUDENT qualified for special education as speech impaired, specifically in the area of pragmatic language. It did not find a specific learning disability in any area. MOTHER agrees that her daughter has serious delays in social communication. However, contrary to the District’s position, she believes that STUDENT has learning deficits in the areas of language arts and math.
The IEP implemented by the District to address STUDENT’s special education needs during the 2000-2001 school year provided for consultation between a speech pathologist and the general education teacher one-to-four times month for 15 to 30 minutes, and pull-out/small-group RSP for 50 to 150 minutes per day four to five times each week. At the Petitioner’s option, she could also attend the homework center and the lunchtime math lab, both of which are available to all students. The following accommodations and supports were also specified in STUDENT’s IEP: “ consultation from special education staff for academic an/or interfering mannerisms; assistance with taking tests and class assignments; assistance in modifying assignments; assistance with organizational issues necessary for success in general education, and in-class assistance from special ed staff.”
The Hearing Officer first considers the Petitioner’s assertion that the District failed to identify and respond to STUDENT’s academic needs. MOTHER expressed “serious concerns” about STUDENT’s academic skills. She disagrees with the District’s assertion that STUDENT’s academic performance falls within the average range in all areas. MOTHER claims that STUDENT has significant “gaps” in her reading and math abilities, which necessitate continuation of the RSP pull-out services she received from the District in prior years. She believes that STUDENT needs pull-out RSP services with systematic goals to remediate “gaps” in her reading and math skills. MOTHER also contends that her daughter requires remediation therapy form a nonpublic agency such as Lindamood or Sylvan Learning Center. She testified that the independent evaluations performed by Sylvan and Lindamood establish that STUDENT has areas of weakness within the broad categories of reading and math, which the District failed to address.
The District maintains that STUDENT’s disability is a mild deficiency in the area of pragmatic speech. Its testing has not revealed a specific learning disability resulting from a severe discrepancy between her ability and achievement levels. The District argues that STUDENT’s classroom achievement and standardized test scores support its conclusions regarding her academic abilities, and establish that her cognitive ability and performance levels are within the average range.
Brett Smith is the District school psychologist who administered STUDENT’s triennial reevaluation in March 2001. Mr. Smith found STUDENT ‘s cognitive abilities to be within the normal range as evidenced by a full-scale Intelligence Quotient (IQ) of 91 on the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Third Edition (WISC-III). Her verbal abilities were within the low-normal range, and her nonverbal abilities were within the average range. The totality of STUDENT’s subtest scores were within normal on the Woodcock-Johnson Test of Cognitive Ability (WJ-R). She displayed strengths in those subtests measuring visual processing, and comparative weaknesses in the subtests that measured auditory processing. STUDENT’s test scores revealed an aptitude for mathematical reasoning and numerical operations. These test scores, combined with STUDENT’s classroom performance and her teacher’s evaluation, cause Mr. Smith to conclude that STUDENT possessed the skills necessary to be academically successful in a regular education class. He recommended that frequent questions be inserted into class discussions that required STUDENT to integrate information; that visual aids and hands-on activities be utilized; that careful self-proofreading be encouraged; and that STUDENT be provided with opportunities to participate in activities about which she in knowledgeable.
Tasha Bennett, STUDENT’s sixth-grade teacher, testified that STUDENT performs within the top portion of her class academically, and within the upper third of all sixth-graders in the school. She is one of the highest ranked sixth-grade students in all aspects of math. Ms. Bennett stated that STUDENT has already met each of her IEP goals for the current school year. She fully participates in the general education core curriculum without any accommodations or modifications. Ms. Bennett explained that if STUDENT were to need additional help, an aide is available for two hours each day to provide support to the RSP students in her class. STUDENT is one of the students whom the aide has been instructed to “keep an eye on.”
Rose Roy has been STUDENT’s RSP teacher throughout the current school year. In the area of academics, Ms. Roy corroborated Ms. Bennet’s statement that STUDENT successfully accomplishes unmodified general education sixth-grade work, and she has fulfilled all of her IEP goals. Earlier in the year, STUDENT participated in the “homework center” to ensure the completion of her assignments. She no longer attends this program and her homework is always completed and returned. Ms. Roy explained that an RSP aide is assigned to STUDENT’s classroom two hours each day to assist the RSP students. In-class aide assistance and “in-class RSP pull-aside” help are available to STUDENT during this time, if necessary.
All of the District witnesses testified that STUDENT successfully worked at grade level in the regular education curriculum without modifications or accommodations. Her teacher noted that her overall academic performance was above average and that her math skills were higher than two-thirds of the sixth-graders in the entire school. A psychoeducational assessment conducted on March 30, 2001, determined STUDENT’s cognitive ability and achievement levels. Behavioral tests were also administered. STUDENT’s full-scale intelligence quotient (IQ) was 91, within the average range. Her performance scores were significantly higher than those predicted for a student with her general cognitive ability. On the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WAIT), STUDENT’s scores were Reading 101, Mathematics 114, Language 94, and Writing 101. STUDENT’s auditory and visual processing scores were both within the normal range on the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Cognitive Ability-Revised (WJ-R). However, her visual processing ability was stronger than her auditory processing skills ( 109 and 89, respectively). No significantly high scores were present on the Conners’ Teacher Rating Scale-Revised (CTRS-R). On the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test, STUDENT’s standard score was within the moderately high range at 122, age equivalency 17.7 years, percentile rank 93%. She received three “B” and three “C” grades on her fall 2000-2001 report card.
The Hearing Officer agrees that the District appropriately determined STUDENT’s cognitive ability and her performance levels and correctly concluded that her academic needs could be met in a general education classroom. STUDENT’s fulfillment of each of her IEP goals, her test scores, and her classroom performance, establish that she is succeeding in the general education program without modification of the core curriculum. There is no persuasive evidence that she has areas of significant weakness in reading and math that require remediation.
Although STUDENT successfully works at grade level, her future teachers should be aware that her mental control and visual processing capabilities are in the low-average range and they should monitor her retention of newly presented information. The school psychologist found that STUDENT evidenced a weakness in her ability to sustain attention, concentrate, and exert mental control. Mr. Smith explained that mental control is the ability to focus and retain information in the short -term memory, while performing a task or manipulating the information. During the speech and language assessment, Diane Smith also found that STUDENT’s lowest test scores were in the area of short-term memory. Ms. Smith testified that STUDENT had low-average scores on the two tests of her “working memory.” She could not easily hold information in her head while working on another task. According to Mr. Smith, STUDENT’s short-term memory weakness is assisted by the use of visual aids and hands-on activities, encouraging her to self-correct her work, and addressing questions to her that compel her to integrate information. STUDENT’s teacher, Ms. Bennett, successfully employed these strategies through the use of a multi-sensory teaching method.
Although the District properly identified and addressed STUDENT’s academic needs, it did not respond with similar appropriateness to indicators that her ability to interact with her environment was compromised. Speech and language specialist, Diane Smith, provided consultation services to STUDENT’s sixth-grade teacher. She also assessed STUDENT. Ms. Smith said that initially, STUDENT’s speech production was impaired. She spoke in a “breathless” manner, as if “her diaphragm were spasming.” However, STUDENT no longer has problems with speech articulation or production. Her remediation in that area was successful and “no one meeting STUDENT now would ever know she had prior speech problems.” Ms. Smith identified STUDENT’s current speech deficit as a pragmatic language delay, which she defined as a “weakness in the social aspect of life.” She further stated that “STUDENT’s problem involves interaction with others.” During Ms. Smith’s classroom observations at the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT did not interact with her classmates. Ms. Smith testified that STUDENT has made progress in this area over the course of the school year. Presently, she is initiating some communication within the classroom and working better within a group. It was Ms. Smith’s opinion that STUDENT’s speech services should be delivered within the classroom to teach her practical social skills. She testified that STUDENT would not benefit from individual speech therapy because that would isolate her, rather than encourage her involvement with other people.
Ms. Roy, STUDENT’s RSP teacher, testified that the “staff wanted her to learn social skills.” She said that the school staff focused primarily on improving STUDENT’s social skills within the classroom. According to Ms. Roy, at the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT mumbled, was uncommunicative, and made little eye contact. Both STUDENT’s teacher and the classroom aide were specifically instructed in techniques to use in the classroom to help her in these areas. Ms. Roy further testified that she invited STUDENT to join her and some other students in her RSP classroom during the lunch break. She keeps her room open during lunch time for students who may feel uncomfortable on the playground. Ms Roy extended this offer in response to MOTHER’s contention that STUDENT was isolated and alone during the lunch break.
According to Ms. Bennett, STUDENT’s classroom interaction with her peers has improved over the course of the school year with the implementation of the strategies suggested by the consulting speech therapist. Assisted by the recommendations from the speech and language specialist, Ms. Bennett and the classroom aide reminded STUDENT to make eye contact, speak so others could hear her, encouraged her involvement in group projects, and attempted to redirect her attention to assigned tasks. Ms. Bennett did not observe STUDENT during lunch time, so she had no information regarding STUDENTs social skills in an unstructured environment. She has, however, observed STUDENT leave the classroom for lunch in the company of other students.
Due to concerns about STUDENT’s ability to “fit in” at school, Janet Curtis, a District counselor, provided her with two counseling sessions during the first month of the 2000-2001 school year. Ms. Curtis testified that it was apparent that STUDENT was uncomfortable meeting with her in her office, so she did not continue the individual therapy sessions. Instead, she attempted to “keep an eye” on STUDENT by observing her around the campus, initiating periodic informal conversations, and conveying to STUDENT that she was available if STUDENT wanted to talk. Ms. Curtis testified that STUDENT’s affect and eye contact were appropriate when she spoke with her. She also described casual conversations she initiated with students outside STUDENT’s classroom, with STUDENT included in the group. Based upon her observations and interaction with STUDENT, Ms. Curtis concluded that she was making substantial progress in the area of social skills.
As part of the District’s March 2001 assessment, Mr. Smith administered the Comprehension subtlest of the Weshler Intelligence Scale for Children-Third Edition (WSC-III). On the Comprehension subtest of the WISC-III, STUDENT scored in the first percentile on the comprehension subtest. School psychologist, Brett Smith, reported that this subtest provides a measure of verbal reasoning. It requires the student “to provide oral solutions to everyday problems and to explain the underlying reasons for certain social rules or concepts.” In particular, the Comprehension subtest measures the understanding of social situations and social judgement as well as knowledge of conventional standards of social behavior.
Ninety-nine percent of the normal population scored higher than STUDENT on the WISC-III Comprehension subtest. STUDENT’s social responses at school were suggestive of a decreased awareness of social norms and supported the findings on the WISC-III. Her behaviors included mumbling, avoiding eye contact, unawareness of others, fixation on objects, decreased didactic and spontaneous speech, and misinterpreting social language. STUDENT’s behavioral history, combined with her score on that portion of the WISC-III that measures social awareness, establishes that the District knew, or reasonably should have known, that STUDENT had substantial unique needs in the areas of social skills and pragmatic language. The school staff provided some assistance to STUDENT with developing better in-class relationships with her peers, they did not help her translate those skills to the unstructured environment of the lunch area or playground, (See discussion below). The Hearing Officer, therefore, determines that STUDENT had unique needs in the areas of pragmatic language and social skills that the District did not adequately address. Assessments are necessary to determine the extent and type of services she requires to respond to her decreased ability to interact with others.
The Hearing Officer lastly responds to the Petitioner’s contention that it was necessary to remove STUDENT from Park View for safety reasons. Mrs. MOTHER testified that the primary reason that she removed her daughter from the District and enrolled her in a private school was that STUDENT was not emotionally safe on the District’s campus. She stated that STUDENT told her that she was teased, ridiculed, and ostracized by the other students.
Mrs. MOTHER recounted episodes of STUDENT returning home from school, crying and saying that other students were calling her names, teasing, humiliating, and making fun of her because she “was different.” Mrs. MOTHER stated that as a result of STUDENT’s decreased social and verbal skills, she was unable to respond with appropriate words, so she would physically strike those children who verbally assaulted her. She does not claim that STUDENT was ever physically harmed at school. Mrs. MOTHER believes that STUDENT’s behaviors and poor social and communicative skills caused further negative reactions and alienation from her peers. She testified that she had a difficult personal relationship with the school principal, so she was unable to address the problem with her. She did, however, raise concerns about her daughter’s emotional well-being on the school campus at an IEP meeting. At that meeting, she also requested that the school organize sensitivity training that addressed students with differences/disabilities for the students and staff of the entire school.
The District’s witnesses consistently testified that STUDENT is a well-behaved, quiet student who has never posed a discipline problem. The middle school staff were unaware of any incidents in which STUDENT had been teased or harassed by another student, nor had they received a single complaint form any student who claimed to have been struck by STUDENT.Mrs. MOTHER agreed that no one else had seen or reported any of the events related by her daughter, and that STUDENT was the exclusive source of information about the harassment.
The Hearing Officer finds that insufficient evidence was presented to conclude that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE by failing to maintain a safe environment, as alleged by Mrs. MOTHER. All of the District witnesses testified that they were unaware of any events that may have caused STUDENT to feel unsafe on campus. None of them had witnessed, or received any reports, of negative interactions between STUDENT and other students. Mrs. MOTHER acknowledged that the only evidence of the District’s alleged failure to respond to STUDENT’s need for a safe learning environment was the event described to her by STUDENT. STUDENT never reported physical altercations. All of the episodes related by Mrs. MOTHER involved incidents in which STUDENT’s feelings had been hurt by the words or actions of another student. Rather than indicating a lack of safety, it is more likely that STUDENT’s reports reflected her difficulty with social language.
2. Did the District’s program provide STUDENT with some educational benefit?
A. Academic Benefit
Mrs. MOTHER claims that the District did not respond to STUDENT’s complete needs in math and language arts. She testified that there are some areas within each of these disciplines in which STUDENT is not as accomplished. The duty imposed upon the District is to confer “some educational benefit,” not maximize her potential. Rowley (supra). The Hearing Officer has already determined that the District identified and addressed STUDENT’s academic needs and now considers whether it fulfilled its obligation to provide academic benefit.
Although by itself not determinative of the educational benefit STUDENT received during the 2000-2001 school year, the Hearing Officer notes the STUDENT has mad consistent academic progress while enrolled in the District’s programs. David Camimiti was STUDENT’s RSP teacher each year while she attended the summer months at the public elementary school. As part of his personal file, he plotted a graph of STUDENT’s progress in math, spelling and reading form the second through the fifth grades. Each year’s scores were obtained by administering the same achievement test (Kaufman), which allowed meaningful comparisons between scores. With the exception of one spelling score in the third grade, STUDENT consistently scored within the average range in each of the three areas tested. From the third grade on, she scored significantly above grade level in math.
The testimony of the District witnesses established that STUDENT continued to benefit academically during the 2000-2001 school year. She completed all of the general education sixth-grade curriculum with scores higher that 50% of her grade-peers. STUDENT’s classroom and RSP teachers testified that she met all of her IEP goals. Her classroom performance, report cards, and psychoeducational assessment further establish her progress. The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that STUDENT benefitted from the academic component of the District’s program.
B. Social and Language Benefits
Mrs. MOTHER describes STUDENT as focused inward, unaware of others, and without friends. STUDENT testified that she did not have any friends “because she was different that everyone else.” She said that the “other kids ditched her, “ and “teased her,” particularly at lunchtime and at the bus stop. STUDENT relayed an incident that is indicative of her problems with the nuances of social language. She told of being teased by other students because the zipper on her jeans was open. She said that they kept telling her that her “fly was open.” She did not understand what they meant, and thought that they were referring to the insect. STUDENT stated that one of the students then told her, “Your zipper is down - are you retarded?”
Ms. Smith conducted a series of classroom observations from July through September of the 2000-2001 school year. She reported that STUDENT frequently did not make eye contact; was preoccupied with objects rather than the assigned task; talked to herself; spoke in a flat, slow speech; was unaware of the actions of her peers during group activities; and spoke softly without recognizing that no one was responding to her. STUDENT was often off-task, would not interact with the other students when assigned group or partner activi6ties, and often became fixated on an object while ignoring her teacher’s instructions. Ms. Smith testified that when the school year began, STUDENT was “in her own world” and “didn’t understand things going on around her.” It was her opinion that STUDENT’s classroom participation had improved and that she was socializing some in class. Ms. Smith also stated that she had never observed STUDENT in an unstructured environment, so she had “no idea” of her social skills on the playground or lunch area.
Ms. Ray stated that STUDENT initially mumbled and was uncommunicative with the other students. With the intervention of her teacher and the RSP aide, STUDENT had improved her eye contact with others, especially with her teacher. She also made good progress relating to her classroom peers. In response to MOTHER’s concerns that STUDENT was isolated at lunchtime, Ms. Ray invited STUDENT to join her and some of her other students in the RSP room for lunch. STUDENT sometimes participated in the RSP lunch. Ms. Ray was unaware of STUDENT’s social behaviors when out of the classroom.
Ms. Curtis testified that she would sometimes seek out and initiate conversations with STUDENT as part of her effort to monitor STUDENT’s well-being. She engaged in brief one-on-one and group conversations with STUDENT. Ms. Curtis provided her opinion that STUDENT made eye contact and displayed socially appropriate behaviors. However, when questioned about STUDENT’s specific participation in these conversations, she acknowledged that she was the instigator and the primary participant. Ms. Curtis recalled STUDENT answering direct questions during contacts between the two of them, but she could not remember STUDENT ever contributing to a group conversation. She had never overheard any conversations between STUDENT and other students. She also had no information regarding STUDENT’s interactions with her peers in unstructured situations.
The District identified STUDENT’s disability as one involving pragmatic language. Its witnesses testified that her primary need was to improve her social skills. STUDENT’s score was the lowest possible on the WISC-III subtest that identified problems grasping social situations. Ms. Smith’s observation notes describe STUDENT engaging in unusual social behaviors. Although the District identified STUDENT’s primary area of disability as decreased social skills and language, it did not adequately address her social deficits. The testimony causes the Hearing Officer to conclude that the District failed to respond to multiple indicators of STUDENT’s difficulties with social communication and interactions. The Hearing Officer further finds that there is adequate evidence to warrant an autism evaluation as a suspected area of disability. Consequently, STUDENT did not receive educational benefit from the District’s program in this area.
3. Did the District’s program conform to STUDENT’s individual education program?
STUDENT’s IEP dated May 2, 2000, called for 50 to 150 minutes of “Pull-out/Small group/RSP” four to five times per week. On August 8, 2000, an addendum was added to the IEP that stated that the amount of time the RSP teacher/RSP aide spent in STUDENT’s classroom would increase from nine to fourteen hours a week. The RSP staff was also to assist STUDENT with organization and provide one-to-one repetition of the teacher’s instructions. The addendum did not change the individual RSP services specified in the underlying IEP. STUDENT’s IEP also provided for consultation between the speech pathologist and the general education teacher for 15 to 30 minutes, one-to-four times each month.
All parties agree that STUDENT was not pulled out of the general education class for RSP instruction. MOTHER testified to her understanding that the IEP of May 2, 2000, specified a continuation of the same pull-out assistance in the RSP classroom that STUDENT had received in the past. The Petitioner contends that she was denied a FAPE because she did not receive the type or amount of RSP support identified in her IEP.
The RSP teacher explained that, when necessary, STUDENT was given in-class assistance and in-class individual or small group “pull-aside help from an RSP aide. The District maintains that when REP services are described in an IEP as “Pull-out/Small group/RSP, “It does not mean that the student will be removed from the general education classroom for small-group services in an RSP class. Instead, it means that the student may receive some combination of pull-out or small-group RSP services, depending upon the teacher’s determination of the student’s needs at a particular time. Additionally, “pull-out” services can actually be “pull-back” of “pull-aside” within the classroom, either individually or in a “small-group.” The amount of RSP provided to STUDENT could range from 50 to 150 minutes daily depending upon her needs and the class schedule.
The description of RSP services contained in STUDENT’s IEP is unclear and subject to misinterpretation. Furthermore, even if the District’s version of the RSP services were accepted, no one suggested that STUDENT received even the minimum 50 hours of daily RSP as set forth in her IEP. The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not comply with its duty to make a specific offer of RSP services to STUDENT(Footnote 3), nor did it implement the RSP services contained in her IEP.
However, it has already been determined that the District’s program provided STUDENT with academic benefit. This benefit was conveyed without conformance to the level of RSP service specified in her IEP. Thus, the failure to adhere to the RSP portion of the IEP did not prejudice STUDENT, Conversely, the monthly speech and language consultation, as called for in the IEP, was provided, but it was insufficient to appropriately respond to her disability. This leads the Hearing Officer to the conclusion that STUDENT’s IEP did not adequately address her needs. It provided for unnecessary RSP intervention, and it failed to provide adequate assistance with social skills and communication.
In conclusion, the evidence establishes that the District failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year. The academic component of the program provided by the District addressed STUDENT needs, and provided educational benefit. However, the District did not offer a program that met STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of social interaction and communication.
ISSUE TWO
Are the Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for independent evaluations conducted by Lindamood-Bell Learning Processing Center and Sylvan Learning Center?
California Education Code § 56329 (b) provides,
A parent has the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil from qualified specialists...if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency. However, the public education agency may initiate a due process hearing...to show that its assessment is appropriate. If the final decision resulting from the due process hearing is that the assessment is appropriate, the parent still has the right for an independent educational assessment, but not at public expense.
In this case, the parents believed that the District did not identify their daughter’s learning disabilities or recommend appropriate interventions. They sought diagnostic evaluations form Lindamood and Sylvan to substantiate their belief that STUDENT has learning disabilities in the areas of language arts and math. MOTHER contends that the evaluations she obtained form Sylvan Learning Center and Lindamood reveal “gas” in STUDENT’s knowledge of language and mathematics that require systematic, planned special education remediation.
The District counters that the parents did not express disagreement with the District’s assessment, and specifically stated that they would obtain the Lindamood evaluation and seek reimbursement only if the sessions resulted in “considerable” academic growth. Lindamood therapy was never initiated, so results are not available. The District points out that the Lindamood assessment was conducted in August 2000, but a written report was not requested by the parents until January 2001, and the report was not submitted to the District until April 2001. Thus, the independent evaluation from Lindamood was obtained before the District even conducted its assessment. The Sylvan report was not even presented to the District until the first day of the hearing, and it tests in the same areas as the Lindamood assessment.
To be entitled to reimbursement for an independent evaluation, the parents must first disagree with a district’s assessment. In this case, the parents obtained an independent assessment before the District conducted its own. Therefore, it was not sought as a result of a disagreement with the District’s assessment. In addition, the parents stated that they intended to implement the Lindamood therapy and request reimbursement only if it provided substantial benefit to STUDENT. They were not obtaining the evaluation because they disputed a District assessment, but because it was a prerequisite to initiating Lindamood sessions. The Sylvan diagnostic examination merely reevaluated the same areas addressed by Lindamood, and the parents never apprised the District of its existence.
Another precondition to reimbursement is that the District’s assessment be deemed inadequate. The district’s assessment appropriately evaluated STUDENT in the academic areas. Its defect was that it did not fully investigate her social and communication needs. Both Lindamood and Sylvan tested STUDENT’s academic abilities, where the District’s assessment was appropriate. Neither of the independent assessments evaluated STUDENT’s social or language skills. The Petitioner therefore did not establish that se obtained independent evaluations because she disagreed with an inadequate District assessment. The request for reimbursement of the Lindamood Bell and Sylvan evaluations is denied.
ISSUE THREE
Are the Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement of tuition costs resulting from STUDENT enrollment in a private school for a portion of the 2000-2001 school year?
The parents of disabled children can be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for expenses they incur for private services they obtain to meet their child’s special education needs. Such reimbursement is an appropriate remedy where the school district has failed to provide their child with a free, appropriate education and the private services are found to be reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 358, (1985), See also Florence County School District Four, et. al. V. Carter, 510 U.S. 7 (1993).
The Hearing Officer has determined that STUDENT was denied a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year. However, reimbursement of nonpublic school tuition for Calvary Christian School (Calvary) is not an appropriate remedy in this case. When considering the appropriateness of the private services provided for their child for reimbursement purposes, parents are not held to the same standard as that of school districts knowledgeable in education, nor must they obtain the best possible private service to be entitled to reimbursement. Their choice must, however, be designed to meet their child’s unique needs and to provide some educational benefit. Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education, 790 F. 2d 1153 (5th Cir. 1986); Florence County School District Four v. Carter, (supra).
Ms. MOTHER clearly expressed her opinion that Calvary was an inappropriate placement for STUDENT and that she was lost in that environment. Mrs. MOTHER was adamant that Calvary was too difficult academically, the curriculum was not modified, and there were no special education services available. In her opinion, STUDENT received no educational benefit while attending Calvary. Mrs. MOTHER determined that STUDENT was unsafe on the District campus as a result of teasing and ridicule from other students, and believed she had to transfer STUDENT immediately to another school. She testified that she enrolled STUDENT in Calvary because it was the only private school she located that had an immediate opening for STUDENT in the middle of a school year. The Hearing Officer has previously determined that the petitioner did not establish an immediate threat to her safety. Consequently, the parental obligation to place STUDENT in a school that met her unique needs and provided educational benefit was not excused by an allegation of immediate danger, and the Petitioner’s parents are not entitled to tuition reimbursement.
CONCLUSION
STUDENT was denied a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year because the District did not identify and address her social and language deficits. She is entitled to complete social skills and pragmatic language evaluations and the provision of services individually designed to meet her unique needs in these areas. Her parents are not entitled to reimbursement for tuition costs of Calvary, or the independent evaluations from Lindamood or Sylvan.
ORDER
1. Within ten business days of the date of this decision, the District shall provide the parents with an assessment plan for a comprehensive social skills and social language assessment. The assessment must include personal observations by the appropriate specialist of STUDENT’s peer interactions in both structured environments. The assessment shall also include an evaluation in the area of autism and/or autistic characteristics.
2. Following the parents’ execution of the consent to assess, the assessments shall be completed and an IEP meeting convened within the time prescribed by law, unless extended by agreement of the parties.
3. At the IEP meeting, the IEP team shall draft a formal social skills plan to specifically address any deficits revealed in the assessments of STUDENT’s social and pragmatic language skills and include it in her IEP.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code, § 56507 (d), this decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement: The Petitioner prevailed on the issue of denial of a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year. The District prevailed on the issue of reimbursement for the costs of tuition and independent assessments.
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety(90) days of receipt of this decision. ( Education Code, § 56505 (i).)
Dated: _________________ __________________________________ GLENNA EUBANK deCAMARA, Hearing Officer, Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law
1. Although sixth-grade students attend a middle school campus, they continue to have only one teacher, as in elementary school, rather than rotating classes with a different teacher for each subject.
2. Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412 (a)(5)(A); Education Code § 56031. However, LRE is not an issue in this case. 3. A legally sufficient offer is a written, specific offer of an available program. Union School District v. B. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519 (9th Cir. 1994) discusses the obligation of districts to make a “formal written offer” of placement to the parents. The Ninth Circuit Court explained that “this formal requirement has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe it should be enforced rigorously.” The court then described the “important purpose” of a “formal written offer” as follows: (1) to create a clear factual record for later review; (2) to assist the parents in presenting complaints about the placement; (3) to allow the parents to decide whether to accept or reject the placement offered; and (4) to allow the school district to present relevant evidence to the Hearing Officer regarding the appropriateness of the placement offered.
