California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 23, 2003

Student v. Cotati-Rohnert Park Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 2449-02 · Hearing Officer Paul E. Lacy

Cotati-Rohnert Park Unified denied FAPE to a tenth grader with a learning disability; Hearing Officer orders a new program, compensatory services, and partial assessment reimbursement.

Split decision: student prevailed on 3 of 3 issues (2 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. The Hearing Officer retained jurisdiction for 90 days for supplemental proceedings on the IEP-team-developed program. On December 3, 2002, Hearing Officer Tibbals had earlier excluded 2001-2002 school year issues. The decision references a prior due process case settled in December 2001.

Summary

The parents of a 15-year-old tenth grader with a specific learning disability challenged Cotati-Rohnert Park Unified School District's 2002-2003 offer. The May 2002 IEP placed her at Rancho Cotati High School in three special day classes and one resource specialist math class. It also offered two 55-minute speech and language sessions a week, pulled from her academic classes. She had severe auditory processing, memory, and language deficits and worked at about a third- to fourth-grade level.

Hearing Officer Paul E. Lacy found a denial of a free appropriate public education (FAPE). Her classes did not use the intensive language-based curriculum, interactive multisensory methods, or "chunking" and feedback strategies she needed. District speech-language specialist Donna Neptune described those strategies. The student was repeating a math class she had nearly failed. Her speech therapy was cut from 230 to 110 minutes a week, had no written goals, and ignored her expressive language deficits. Because of the pull-outs, she also missed special day class time her IEP required.

The Hearing Officer rejected Pathways School, a residential nonpublic school that serves students with behavior problems. There was too little evidence to decide on New Horizons School. Instead, the IEP team must meet within 10 days. Within 20 days, the District must offer a program meeting listed requirements, including at least 230 weekly minutes of speech therapy and compensatory services. The District must reimburse an independent visual perceptual assessment but not a psychoeducational assessment.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied Rowley. A program nearly identical to earlier ones that produced little progress was found not reasonably calculated to provide benefit. When no proposed placement fit, the Hearing Officer had the IEP team build a program with specific required components. Reimbursement for an assessment depended on whether a suspected area of disability had been left unassessed.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Did the District offer STUDENT a Free and Appropriate Public Education (FAPE) for the 2002-2003 school year?

    The special day class and RSP program lacked the intensive language-based, multisensory, 'chunking' instruction the student needed. The 110 weekly minutes of speech therapy were too little and did not address expressive language. The program was not reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, and pull-outs meant it did not conform to the IEP, so FAPE was denied.

  2. Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2. If the District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, is placement at either Pathways or New Horizons School an appropriate remedy for STUDENT?

    Pathways, a residential nonpublic school serving students with behavioral and emotional disorders, was not appropriate. The record did not show whether New Horizons was appropriate. Instead, the IEP team was ordered to design a program with specified components and compensatory services.

  3. Issue 3. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of educational assessments they obtained for STUDENT in the fall of 2002?

    The parents get reimbursement for Dr. Hoenig's visual perceptual assessment because the District's own speech-language assessors recommended it and the District never did it. They get no reimbursement for Dr. Nunno's psychoeducational assessment because there was no showing that they disagreed with the 2000 assessment or asked for a new one.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 10 calendar days of the order, the IEP team shall convene to design the student's program.
  • Order to provide or change services. Within 20 days, the District shall offer a program addressing all of the student's needs, including the eight items listed under Issue 2: (1) a small, structured special day class in a public school or State-certified nonpublic school, with an intensive language-based curriculum, 'chunking' and feedback strategies, reading-based practice, and interactive multisensory techniques in all subjects, with preference for a Sonoma County placement and consideration of the student's wishes; (2) a math curriculum using the same strategies; (3) weekly conferences among all primary providers for six weeks, then as needed through the case manager; (4) four speech and language sessions weekly totaling at least 230 minutes, no session over 60 minutes, at least 170 minutes one-to-one, with written goals covering expressive language, provided in addition to academic classes; (5) study skills instruction; (6) all transition requirements; (7) an IEP team determination of whether counseling is needed; (8) compensatory services.
  • Compensatory education. The IEP team must include compensatory education for the time the student was denied FAPE, from the start of school in September 2002 until the order is implemented (excluding absences). Services may extend beyond the 2002-2003 school year and ESY. No amount was specified.
  • Reimbursement. The parents are entitled to reimbursement for Dr. M. Pia Hoenig's fall 2002 visual perceptual assessment. No amount was stated.
  • The Hearing Officer retains jurisdiction for 90 days to address matters related to the education plan the IEP team is ordered to develop.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489; Todd v. Andrews (11th Cir. 1991) 933 F.2d 1576; Moubry v. Independent School District No. 696, 951 F.Supp. 867; 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i)(2)(B)(iii); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f); Cal. Educ. Code § 56507(d)

People named in the decision

  • John Laughlin, school psychologist; party representative, Cotati-Rohnert Park Unified School District
  • Ron Whitman, director of special education; party representative, Cotati-Rohnert Park Unified School District
  • M. Pia Hoenig, O.D., M.A., independent visual perceptual skills evaluator retained by parents, Private
  • Vincent Nunno, Ph.D., clinical and educational psychologist; independent psychoeducational assessor retained by parents, Private
  • Grace Rogers, Ph.D., school psychologist (2000 psychoeducational assessment), Petaluma City School District
  • Nancy Schwartz, speech and language pathologist retained by District (May 2002 assessment), Contracted by District
  • Elaine Stevick, speech and language pathologist retained by District; supervised May 2002 assessment, Contracted by District
  • Ms. Campbell, director of New Horizons School; provided speech and language services in spring 2002, New Horizons School (nonpublic school, Santa Rosa)
  • Donna Neptune, speech and language specialist providing student's services, Cotati-Rohnert Park Unified School District
  • Arline Thomas, special day class English teacher and case manager, Rancho Cotati High School
  • Nancy Nelson, classroom aide, Rancho Cotati High School
  • Cheryl Patnaik, special day class world history teacher, Rancho Cotati High School
  • Mr. Quinn, special day class science teacher, Rancho Cotati High School
  • Maria Del Carmen Baron, RSP math (pre-algebra) teacher, Rancho Cotati High School
  • Carolyn Jones, speech and language specialist; attended May 2002 IEP meeting and drafted language goals, Cotati-Rohnert Park Unified School District
  • Louise Robertson, director of admissions, Pathways School (residential nonpublic school, Pennsylvania)
  • Hearing Officer Tibbals, SEHO Hearing Officer who excluded 2001-2002 issues on December 3, 2002, Special Education Hearing Office
  • Lindamood Bell, private speech and language provider (summer 2001), Private provider

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Paul E. Lacy, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, on December 10, 11, 12, 13, 17, 18, and 19, 2002, in Rohnert Park, California.

STUDENT (hereinafter “STUDENT” or “Petitioner ”) was represented by attorneys Jane F. Reid and Stanley M. Zeigler. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf were her parents. The Cotati-Rohnert Park Unfied School District (hereinafter “District ” or “Respondent”) was represented by attorney Margaret M. Merchat. Cotati-Rohnert Park’s school psychologist, John Laughlin, was present on behalf of the District on December 12, 2002, and Ron Whitman, the District’s director of special education, was present on behalf of the District thereafter.(Footnote 1)

The Hearing Officer received oral and documentary evidence during the course of the proceedings. On January 13, 2003, the Hearing Officer received closing briefs from the parties and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

1. Did the District offer STUDENT a Free and Appropriate Public Education (FAPE) for the 2002-2003 school year?

2. If the District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, is placement at either Pathways or New Horizons School an appropriate remedy for STUDENT?

3. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of educational assessments they obtained for STUDENT in the fall of 2002?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT, born on [date redacted], was fifteen years and eleven months at the time the hearing convened. STUDENT currently lives with her parents in Rohnert Park, Sonoma County, California. She is presently eligible for special education as a child with a specific learning disability. As of the time the hearing closed, STUDENT was in the tenth grade and receiving special education services at Rancho Cotati High School in the Cotati-Rohnert Park Unified School District.

STUDENT was originally found eligible for special education with a speech and language disorder when she was in the first grade. At that time, she lived in Petaluma and attended school in the Petaluma City Elementary School District (Petaluma). She initially was placed in a resource specialist program (RSP). In the second grade, Petaluma placed her in a special day class, where she remained throughout her elementary school years.(Footnote 2) By the third grade, STUDENT was identified with a specific learning disability. Prior to the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT’s family moved into the Cotati-Rohnert Unified School District, and STUDENT enrolled in the District’s Creekside Middle School for the eighth grade. Petaluma is part of the same SELPA as Cotati-Rohnert Park, and STUDENT received services at Cotati-Rohnert Park under the Petaluma IEP, which had been developed by Petaluma in August 2000. That IEP called for STUDENT to be placed in a special day class and receive speech and language services.

In May 2001, the District held an IEP team meeting for STUDENT. The IEP team placed STUDENT in a special day class for the 2001-2002 school year and continued speech and language services. From July through September 2001, STUDENT was enrolled at Lindamood Bell (LMB), where she received 205 hours of speech and language services over the course of the next 10 weeks.

At an IEP meeting in September 2001, Petitioner requested additional services from LMB, but the District disagreed. The Petitioner filed for a due process hearing at that time, and the case was settled in December 2001. The District agreed to provide STUDENT with two hours a week of speech and language services for the balance of the 2001-2002 school year at New Horizons School, a nonpublic school (NPS) in Santa Rosa for learning disabled students.

In May 2002, the IEP team met and the District offered STUDENT the program that is at issue in this case, which included three periods of special day classes, one period of RSP, and two periods of speech and language. The Petitioner’s parents disagreed with the District’s offer and filed for due process on November 6, 2002. Pending the outcome of the due process hearing, STUDENT went forward with the program offered by the District.

In the fall of 2002, Petitioner obtained two independent educational assessments from Dr. Pia Hoenig and Dr. Vincent Nunno.

POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES

The Petitioner contends that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year. Specifically, Petitioner asserts that the special day classes offered by the District do not employ a curriculum and learning strategies that meet STUDENT’s unique needs and allow her to benefit from her educational program. Additionally, Petitioner alleges that the 110 minutes of speech and language services offered by the District are not sufficient in time and scope to meet STUDENT’s needs. By way of a remedy, the Petitioner seeks placement at Pathways School in Pennsylvania, a California State-certified NPS, or New Horizons school, a State-certified NPS in Santa Rosa, California.

Petitioner also claims that the District failed to properly assess her and thus her parents are entitled to reimbursement for two independent assessments they obtained in the fall of 2002.

Respondent argues that the placement and services it offered STUDENT meet her needs and allow her to benefit from her educational program. Additionally, Respondent maintains that Pathways is not an appropriate placement for STUDENT.

Respondent also contends that Petitioner is barred from seeking reimbursement for the independent assessments obtained in the fall of 2002 because the previous assessments were conducted prior to the 2002-2003 school year and, as a result of a prior settlement agreement, previous school years are not at issue in the case.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue Number 1: Did the District offer STUDENT a Free and Appropriate Public Education (FAPE) for the 2002-2003 school year?

Under both the federal Individual with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, disability is understood as a natural part of the human experience that in no way diminishes the right of individuals to participate in or contribute to society. Improving educational results for children with disabilities is an essential element of our national policy of ensuring equality of opportunity, full participation, independent living, and economic self-sufficiency for individuals with disabilities.(Footnote 3) (20 U.S.C. § 1400 (c)(1); 34 C.F.R. § 300.1.) Students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.) The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet State educational standards, and that conform with the Student’s individualized educational program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18).) “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, provided at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).) Additionally, In Board of Education of the Hendrick Huson Central School District, et. al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit.

In summary, under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley an appropriate educational program must (1) be designed to meet the student’s unique needs, (2) provide the student with some educational benefit, and (3) conform with the student’s IEP. (20 U.S.C. §1400 et. seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176.)

Thus, the Hearing Officer must first ascertain STUDENT’s unique needs and then determine whether the program offered by the District was designed to meet those needs and provide her with some educational benefit as well as determine whether it comported with her IEP.

1. Unique Needs (a) STUDENT’s Unique Needs

As noted above, STUDENT is eligible for special education as a child with a specific learning disability. STUDENT’s unique needs arise from her particular learning disorders and language deficits. There were no significant disagreements between the parties regarding the nature and extent of her deficits.

More specifically, the May 2002 IEP notes that STUDENT has deficits in processing speed, immediate memory recall, and auditory processing. These deficits were consistent with those found by Grace Rogers, Ph.D., the school psychologist for the Petaluma School Districts who administered a psychoeducational assessment to STUDENT in 2000. Subsequent to the May 2002 IEP, Dr. Vincent Nunno, Ph.D., a clinical and educational psychologist retained by STUDENT’s parents to conduct an independent assessment of STUDENT, determined that STUDENT has a severe auditory processing disorder, severe visual-motor integration impairments, severe memory deficits in both the auditory and visual domains, attention deficits, and dysgraphia. His assessments also placed STUDENT in the low average range for cognitive ability, with her full scale WISC-III score at 79. No one disputed Dr. Nunno’s findings regarding STUDENT’s processing deficits or cognitive ability, which were not inconsistent with assessments undertaken in 2000 and 1998 by other school districts where STUDENT had previously attended. Additionally, Dr. M. Pia Hoenig, O.D., M.A., who was retained by STUDENT’s parents to conduct an independent perceptual skills evaluation in the fall of 2002, determined that STUDENT had deficits in the areas of visual sequential memory, visual closure (the ability to perceive and visualize images), and visual spatial planning.(Footnote 4)

As for speech and language, STUDENT was assessed in May 2002 by Nancy Schwartz under the direction of Elaine Stevick, both speech and language pathologists retained by the District. As part of that assessment, STUDENT was administered the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals–3 (CELF-3), the Expressive One word Picture Vocabulary Test, the Phonological Awareness Test, and the Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills–Revised (TAPS). Several tests or sub-tests indicated that STUDENT had significant deficits in several facets of language. On the CELF-3 receptive language sub-tests, STUDENT scored in the 9th percentile on word classes and in the 5th percentile on semantic relationships. On the CELF-3 expressive language sub-tests, STUDENT scored in the 5th percentile on both sentence recall and sentence assembly. The Phonological Awareness Test indicated that STUDENT had difficulty with most phonological awareness skills. On the TAPS, STUDENT scored in the 1st percentile on the Auditory Number Memory sub-test (Forward) and in 5th percentile on Auditory Number Memory (Backward). In her report, Ms. Schwartz concluded that STUDENT has a “moderately severe auditory processing deficit, including poor phonological awareness skills, auditory memory skills, and resulting poor decoding and encoding skills.”

In summary, STUDENT’s learning disorders and language deficits are multi-faceted and severe. There is virtually no dispute that historically STUDENT’s disorders and deficits have hindered her ability to learn and progress in her educational program. At the time of the hearing, STUDENT was nearly sixteen years old and in the tenth grade. However, the IEP team reported in May 2002 that STUDENT academically functioned at a third to fourth grade level in most, if not all, academic subjects. As a result of her varied and extensive deficits, STUDENT has unique needs that require a highly structured and individualized educational program.

As discussed in more detail in subsection (c) below, the evidence established that STUDENT needs to be placed in a small, structured class that employs an intensive language-based curriculum designed to address STUDENT’s language impairments, which include both receptive and expressive language deficits. Expert witnesses, including Ms. Campbell, the director of New Horizon School where STUDENT received speech and language services in the spring of 2002, explained that because of her extensive processing deficits that cut across both auditory and visual domains, and because she is so many grade levels behind in all academic areas, STUDENT needs an intensive language-based curriculum with an emphasis on vocabulary and language. Additionally, virtually all of the experts emphasized that STUDENT needs an interactive multi-sensory approach to learning. Moreover, STUDENT’s needs require that her educational program include the interactive “chunking” and feedback strategies explained by Ms. Donna Neptune, the District’s speech and language specialist who presently provides STUDENT with speech and language services. She explained that STUDENT’s deficits, particularly her memory deficits, require that she have information provided to her in small “chunks,” and that persons presenting STUDENT with information engage her in a dialogue that includes clarifying questions and feedback. Furthermore, Ms. Neptune emphasized that STUDENT needs to constantly practice the skills that she learns in her speech and language sessions, and that her practice must include an extensive reading program. STUDENT’s needs require that such a curriculum, strategies, and techniques must be applied in all of her courses of study, including math.

(b) The Educational Program Offered by the District

Next, the Hearing Officer must review the program offered by the District and determine whether it was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs. The parties agreed that the educational program offered by the District was contained in the May 2002 IEP document.

The IEP proposes goals and objectives for STUDENT in the areas of reading, written language, and math.(Footnote 5) STUDENT’s reading goals call for her to read aloud fluently and accurately narrative and expository text with appropriate pacing, intonation, and expression at the third grade level; to know and use complex word families when reading and to decode two syllable words at the high-third and low-fourth-grade levels; and to read and demonstrate her understanding of texts at the fourth-grade level. STUDENT’s written language goals call for her to create a simple paragraph with a topic sentence and simple supporting facts and detail. Her written language goals also call for her to improve her spelling ability. STUDENT’s math goal calls for her to achieve 70% or greater on pre-algebraic math skills. Quarterly objectives were set forth for each specified goal.

To implement the goals and objectives for the 2002-2003 school year, which includes an extended school year (ESY), the District offered to place STUDENT at Rancho Cotati High School. The proposed placement called for STUDENT to be placed in a special day class for three periods each day, and an RSP math class for one period each day. The special day class, taught by Ms. Arline Thomas, included one period–55 minutes–of English, which included reading and writing, one period of world history each day with Ms. Cheryl Patnaik, and one period of science with Mr. Quinn. The one period of RSP math was a pre-algebra course with Ms. Maria Del Carmen Baron. The IEP also called for STUDENT to receive two periods of speech and language services each week from Ms. Neptune, a speech and language specialist. Each speech and language session was scheduled for 55 minutes, with one being a one-to-one session and the other included one other student. STUDENT’s speech and language services were not in addition to her academic classes; rather, she was to be pulled out of other regularly scheduled classes to receive the service. The IEP also included two elective courses, one in dance and the other choir.

(c) Did the Placement Offered by the District Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?

As noted above, STUDENT was offered and placed in three periods of special day class for English, science, and history and in one period of RSP math.(Footnote 6) Each class met once each day for 55 minutes. Ms. Thomas is both STUDENT’s special day class English teacher and her special education case manager. STUDENT’s English class covers reading and written language, and the material Ms. Thomas presents ranges from the second to fourth grade level, with some beginning fifth grade material. Ms. Thomas noted that she is responsible for implementing STUDENT’s reading and written language goals and objectives. Ms. Thomas testified that she has 13 students in her special day class and that she is assisted by one full-time aide, Ms. Nancy Nelson.(Footnote 7) Ms. Thomas described the content of her English special day class. She said that she usually begins each class by posting a “daily sentence” on an overhead. The sentences that Ms. Thomas places on the overhead needs correcting–notably, punctuation and capitalization-and the students, including STUDENT, are required to make the corrections to the sentence. Next, a cue for a journal entry is placed on the board that includes a topic, and the students are then required to write in their individual journals for five minutes. Following this assignment, Ms. Thomas reads to her students approximately 10-12 minutes per day from a “teenage type novel” and then asks them questions about the material, characters, setting, theme, and plot. The students are also required to take notes on the book. At the end of the book, each student in the class does a report on the book. Twice a week, the students engage in reading comprehension skill building according to the goals in their individual IEPs. Additionally, the students are also required to participate in the “Start-to-Finish” reading program. That program has the students reading a grade-level story on a computer screen while they listen audibly. The words on the screen are highlighted as they are read, and afterward the students are required to answer questions relating to comprehension and word meaning. Twice each week, Ms. Thomas presents a grammar lesson that includes nouns, verbs, punctuation, how to form possessives, and other related topics. She added that she always encourages students to read and go to the library. Ms, Thomas said that the students, including STUDENT, read silently for approximately 45 minutes per week. Ms. Thomas related that she also presents a phonics lesson to the class for 10-15 minutes once a week and occasionally twice a week.

Ms. Thomas also described her strategies for instructing STUDENT and her other special day class English students. She described how she presents direct lessons in front of all 13 children in her class, and then goes around the room and answers any questions they may have. She said that she also uses the ‘white board’ as a visual tool. For example, when she is teaching essay writing skills, Ms. Thomas puts information on the board, the class brainstorms ideas, Ms. Thomas frames the essay on the board, writes introductory sentences on the board, and then the students write. Afterward, she reviews the students’ written work and helps them edit it. She described how the class develops the essay sentence by sentence and paragraph by paragraph. As for spelling, the students are given a list of spelling words to study. They also incorporate the words in a sentence. She gives her class a spelling test each week. As for the phonemic awareness lessons, Ms. Thomas uses a particular curriculum that includes a work book. In that program, Ms. Thomas orally presents words and the students put the words into sentences in their work books. Other times, Ms. Thomas orally presents an initial sound and then reads four words. The students are required to match the words with the sounds. Ms. Thomas asserted that she utilizes multi-sensory teaching techniques in her class. She articulated that she verbalizes information (auditory), she utilizes visual techniques by putting information on the ‘white board’ or overhead projector, and that auditory and visual modes are combined in the “Start-to-Finish” program, where the students see words on a computer while they listen to them on an auditory recording. Ms. Thomas affirmed that she does not utilize any brand named teaching techniques or strategies such as Lindamood Bell or Slingerland.

The strategies that Ms. Thomas utilizes in her special day class to address the needs of her students generally, do not meet STUDENT’s unique needs for successful learning. Ms. Neptune, the District’s speech and language specialist who presently provides STUDENT with speech and language services, testified that as a result of STUDENT’s memory disorders, a multi-step interactive learning process must be applied in addition to multisensory learning. Specifically, Ms. Neptune described a process by which STUDENT’s teachers–or parents or peers, depending on the setting–must present information in small blocks or “chunks.” She called this technique “chunking.” Next, the teacher must ask STUDENT specific questions regarding the information and then ask STUDENT to repeat back her understanding of what she has been told. Ms. Neptune stated that STUDENT’s teachers could not simply ask her if she understands or wait for her to ask for help, because STUDENT generally will not realize that she doesn’t understand. Therefore, if STUDENT is asked a yes or no question, she will indicate that she understands the information when in fact she does not. Additionally, she will generally not initiate questions regarding what she is told because she often will not realize that she didn’t grasp the information. These strategies, which Ms. Neptune considered critical for STUDENT to learn, are not part of Ms. Thomas’s special day class.

Moreover, Ms. Neptune discussed the importance of STUDENT putting the skills that she develops in her speech and language sessions into “practice, practice, practice.”(Footnote 8) Specifically, Ms. Neptune advised that to practice the skills that she teaches STUDENT in the ‘LIPS’ program, STUDENT should read silently for “at least” two hours each day, one hour at home and one hour in her school class. Additionally, she said that to ensure that STUDENT is correctly learning her language skills, STUDENT’s teacher should keep a running record of her reading. Ms. Neptune explained that STUDENT’s teacher must ask STUDENT questions regarding what she has read, answer STUDENT’s questions regarding the words that she does not understand, and keep a record of the words that STUDENT learns from her reading. However, the practice program emphasized by Ms. Neptune, including two hours of daily reading–with one hour of reading in school–and the analysis and record of STUDENT’s progress in developing language, is not included in STUDENT’s educational program.

Additionally, Ms. Campbell, Ms. Stevick, Dr. Hoenig, and Dr. Nunno stated that to accommodate STUDENT’s language deficits, STUDENT needs a language-based curriculum in addition to speech and language services. Ms. Campbell explained that a language-based curriculum involves presenting information and lessons with emphasis on vocabulary and language and how they relate to the subject taught. She added that generally students connect vocabulary and language to various subjects by inference, but, as a result of her deficits, STUDENT does not. Consequently, STUDENT’ ability to learn a subject is impaired. Moreover, virtually all of the witnesses in the case testified that STUDENT needs to receive instruction in a multisensory approach, i.e., auditory, visual, tactile, and kinesthetic. Ms. Campbell and Ms. Stevick further expounded that multi-sensory learning is an interactive process between the teacher and student, and it utilizes multiple sensory modalities at a given point in time. Although Ms. Thomas uses basic oral and visual techniques that may address the needs of her class generally, she does not utilize the intensive language-based multi-sensory strategies described by Ms. Campbell, Ms. Stevick, Dr. Hoenig, and Dr. Nunno. These interactive multi-sensory strategies involve an intensive interplay of various senses. These specialized techniques are specially developed for special education students and are an integral part of some of the brand-name programs such as Orton-Gillingham and Lindamood Bell.(Footnote 9) In contrast, the simplistic strategies employed in Ms. Thomas’s special day class are virtually no different from those typically utilized in a regular education program at any given elementary school. Again, although Ms. Thomas’s methods may be appropriate for her class generally, they do not address STUDENT’s needs for an intensive language-based curriculum that makes use of integrated and interactive multi-sensory techniques. As discussed above, STUDENT’s deficits are so varied and so severe, that they require intensive individualized learning strategies such as “chunking,” an intensive language-based curriculum, and a specialized interactive multisensory approach to learning.

Ms. Cheryl Patnaik, STUDENT’s special day class history teacher, described her teaching strategies for her class and STUDENT. Ms. Patnaik related that she typically requires her class to read a chapter in their history text book and then asks the students questions regarding what they have read. She added that the class discusses the information they read and that she often adds additional information to the discussion. Ms. Patnaik explained that when she introduces a new topic to the class she lectures the class on the subject. Additionally, she recounted how she has had guest speakers present information on relevant topics. Ms. Patnaik said that she also assigns projects and activities that involve the students role playing and making hyrogriphics out of clay. She elaborated that she gives her students a pretest the day before the actual test. Students are allowed to use their notes, test, and talk with their peers while taking the pretest, but not during the actual test the following day. The tests literally duplicate the pretests.

Ms. Patnaik observed STUDENT to have difficulty with her writing and organizing her thoughts. Ms. Patnaik made it a point to utilize visual cues for STUDENT, and she helped STUDENT remember information by employing visualization techniques. Ms. Patnaik, however, does not utilize the learning techniques that Ms. Neptune considered critical for STUDENT to learn. Indeed, Ms. Patnaik testified that STUDENT rarely asks for help, and when she asks STUDENT how she is doing, STUDENT usually responds “ok.” Moreover, Ms. Patnaik does not employ the intensive language-based curriculum that makes use of the integrated and interactive multi-sensory techniques that STUDENT requires to learn. Similarly, Ms. Maria Del Carmen Baron, STUDENT’s RSP math teacher, did not indicate that she uses the strategies described by Ms. Neptune or the intensive language-based curriculum and interactive multi sensory techniques that STUDENT needs.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of three periods of special day class and one period of RSP class at Rancho Cotati High School does not meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

(d) Speech and Language Services

The Petitioner alleged that the 110 minutes of speech and language services offered by the District was not sufficient to meet her needs, and that the services offered did not address her expressive language deficits. As discussed above, STUDENT’s speech and language deficits are severe and include both expressive and receptive language. Her scores on the standardized language assessments that were administered by the District’s independent assessor, Ms. Schwartz, in May of 2002 show little if any meaningful progress from the scores she received on the language assessment administered by Petaluma in August 2000.(Footnote 10) During the second half of the 2001-2002 school year–January 2002 through June 2002–STUDENT was provided two hours of speech and language services at New Horizons in addition to the two 55-minute pull-out sessions provided by the District. Yet by all accounts, STUDENT’s progress remained slow. Other than Ms. Neptune’s broad conclusory opinion that two 55-minute speech and language sessions was adequate for STUDENT, the District failed to explain how a reduction in speech and language services from 230 minutes a week to 110 minutes each week would address STUDENT’s severe language deficits.(Footnote 11)

Additionally, Ms. Carolyn Jones, the District’s speech and language specialist who attended STUDENT’s May 2002 IEP meeting and drafted the goals and objectives that were subsequently misplaced, testified that she orally communicated the content of the missing goals and objectives to Ms. Neptune and that Ms. Neptune was working with STUDENT on these goals. Ms. Jones testified that the goals and objectives she drafted and told to Ms. Neptune were two receptive language goals that addressed auditory memory and phonemic awareness. Ms. Jones said that she did not draft or convey any expressive language goals. Ms. Neptune confirmed that her understanding of STUDENT’s language needs is that they are receptive and not expressive. Yet, as set forth above, Ms. Stevick’s May 2002 language assessment revealed significant deficits in expressive language. The District did not present any evidence that any goals and objectives were developed to address these needs.

Moreover, Ms. Carolyn Jones, the speech and language specialist who testified on behalf of the District, stated that STUDENT had met most of her language goals and objectives for 2001-2002. But standardized tests do not reflect such gains. Furthermore, the skills that Ms. Neptune testified that she was presently working with STUDENT on were also primary goals and objectives in STUDENT’s 2001-2002 IEP. Ms. Campbell credibly testified that STUDENT was beginning to make progress during the few months that she provided STUDENT with 120 minutes of services a week at New Horizons in the spring of 2002 on top of the 110 minutes that the District was furnishing. The District, however, did not provide any evidence that STUDENT would continue to make any progress if her services were reduced by 120 minutes.

Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that two 55-minute sessions of speech and language services do not meet STUDENT’s significant language need and that the District’s program does not address her identified expressive language needs.

2. Reasonably Calculated to Provide Some Educational Benefit

Ms. Thomas testified that the English special day class is similar to the program STUDENT attended with her last year during the 2001-2002 school year. Ms. Thomas also stated that although STUDENT had progressed from a third to a fourth grade level in reading, she had made only slight progress at best in the area of written language. The only new component to her special day class this year is the “Start-to-Finish” program, which is designed for reading. The District did not explain how STUDENT would progress in her writing skills this year when she did not do so last year–and she had not done so as of the time of the hearing. Perhaps more troubling is STUDENT’s RSP math class. Ms. Baron testified that STUDENT is repeating the same math class that she virtually failed last year, and she expects STUDENT to have to repeat the same class next year. Repeating the same math course for three or more years, however, is not progress. Moreover, the overall program proposed by the District for 2002-2003–a combination of District special day classes and RSP–is nearly identical to the programs that were provided to STUDENT in 2000-2001 and 2001-2002, and during those years STUDENT made virtually no progress in writing or math and very little progress in reading. The District did not provide any persuasive evidence to indicate that STUDENT would make meaningful progress under the program they offered this school year. Additionally, as discussed above, the evidence indicated that in the 2001-2002 school year STUDENT had made little or no progress in speech and language until her services were increased from 110 to 230 minutes with the addition of the New Horizons program. And the evidence does not support a finding that STUDENT will benefit from the 110 minutes offered by the District for the 2002-2003 school year.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s English and math classes as well as her speech and language services are not reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit.

3. Conformity with the IEP

STUDENT’s IEP calls for her to be placed in three special day classes five days each week for a total of 165 minutes per day. Five of those class sessions are for English, which directly addresses two of STUDENT’s most severe academic deficits–writing and reading. Yet, Ms. Thomas and Ms. Patnaik testified that STUDENT is pulled out of classes respective English and history classes once each week to receive her speech and language services. Thus, STUDENT is not receiving 110 hours of special day class services as called for under the IEP.

4. Conclusion(Footnote 13)

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the educational program offered by the District to STUDENT for the 2002-2003 school year is not designed to meet her unique needs, it is not reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit, and, at least in part, it is not in conformity with her IEP. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has not offered or provided STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year.(Footnote 14)

Issue Number 2. If the District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, is placement at either Pathways or New Horizons School an appropriate remedy for STUDENT?

The Petitioner asserts that if the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not provide her with a FAPE, the Hearing Officer should order STUDENT to be placed at Pathways, a California State-certified residential NPS. However, Louise Robertson, Pathway’s director of admissions, testified that her school would have to undertake additional assessments of STUDENT to determine whether Pathways was an appropriate placement to meet STUDENT’s needs. In light of the following, the Hearing Officer finds that Pathways is not an appropriate placement for STUDENT.

Ms. Robertson testified that Pathways serves students who have learning disabilities accompanied by emotional and behavioral disorders. Specifically, Ms. Robertson described typical Pathway students as children who have impulse control problems, exhibit inappropriate emotional responses, engage in temper tantrums, cannot sustain regular and consistent attention in an educational setting, are often hyperactive or restless, and sometimes display “physical” behavior problems. The evidence at hearing made clear that STUDENT does not exhibit any of these types of behavior or emotional problems. Indeed, all of the witnesses agreed that STUDENT is friendly, cordial, cooperative, and well-behaved. Thus, it is more likely that STUDENT would be intimidated, frightened, or at least distracted by peers who engage in the type of behavior described by M. Robertson. Moreover, Ms. Robertson explained that her school is structured to serve the needs of children with such behaviors. Thus, it is also likely that Pathways would not accept STUDENT and valuable time would be lost in going through Pathway’s assessment process. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer will not order STUDENT placed at or assessed by Pathways.

Petitioner further contends that if STUDENT is not placed at Pathways she should be placed at New Horizons. Ms. Campbell, the director of New Horizons, testified that she did not believe that STUDENT would receive an appropriate education at her school, although New Horizons might be able to do an “acceptable job” with sufficient support services. Petitioner, however, did not present any evidence at the hearing regarding the New Horizons program and how it is appropriate to serve STUDENT’s needs. Thus, the Hearing Officer does not have any information with which to analyze whether New Horizons is an appropriate placement for STUDENT.(Footnote 15)

Therefore, in the absence of a specific, appropriate remedy, the Hearing Officer finds that it will be necessary for the IEP team to convene and design a program for the 2002-2003 school year, including the ESY, to meet STUDENT’s needs as they were established at the hearing.

Additionally, as discussed above, the Hearing Officer has determined that the District did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, which is the year that is at issue in this case. However, half of the 2002-2003 school year is over and STUDENT has been denied a FAPE for those months. Courts have consistently held that the authority to award compensatory education is derived from 20 U.S.C. Section 1415(i)(2)(B)(iii), which authorizes a court to grant such “relief as it determines is appropriate.” “The purpose of compensatory education is to replace lost educational services.” (Moubry v. Independent School District Number 696, 951 F.Supp. 867 (8th Cir. 1996).) Compensatory education may be an appropriate equitable remedy when the responsible educational authority has failed to provide a disabled child with an appropriate education as required by the IDEA. (Todd v. Andrews, 933 F.2d 1576 (11th Cir. 1991).) Moreover, “compensatory education is not a contractual remedy, but an equitable remedy, part of the Court's resources in crafting appropriate relief...Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” (Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F3d 1489 (9th Cir. 1994).)

Therefore, the IEP team must not only design a prospective program to meet STUDENT’s needs for the balance of the 2002-2003 school year, including the ESY, but it must also include additional services to adequately compensate her for the period of time during the 2002-2003 school year that she was denied a FAPE.(Footnote 16) As established at the hearing, STUDENT’s needs include the following:

1. Placement in a special education program at a public school or State-certified NPS. The placement must include a small, structured special day class that employs an intensive language-based curriculum designed to address STUDENT’s language deficits. The placement must also utilize the interactive “chunking” and feedback strategies explained by Ms. Neptune, as well as provide for the reading-based practice activities that she described in her testimony. The placement must also use interactive multi-sensory learning techniques that are designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. Such a curriculum, strategies, and techniques must be applied in all of STUDENT’s courses of study, including math. Although the IEP team is not limited by geography in selecting an appropriate placement for STUDENT, preference should be given to a primary placement in Sonoma County to maximize STUDENT’s benefit from transitional services and any vocational programs implemented by the team. Additionally, in determining whether STUDENT should be placed in a District program or an NPS, the IEP team shall take STUDENT’s personal desires, social needs, and aspirations into consideration. To that end, the IEP team, including the District members and STUDENT’s parents, shall make every effort to include STUDENT at the IEP team meetings.

2. A math curriculum that includes the language and learning strategies that are required for STUDENT’s English and other academic classes and one that is designed to allow STUDENT to progress in her math skills.

3. All primary service providers–teachers and therapists–must confer with each other weekly for six weeks to ensure complete integration and coordination of her educational program and services. Thereafter, STUDENT’s case manager shall meet with other service providers as necessary to ensure that STUDENT’s program is working and to make adjustments as necessary.

4. Four sessions of speech and language services each week totaling at least 230 minutes, but not to exceed 60 minutes in any single session. The therapy sessions should be one-to-one for at least 170 minutes, and an additional student may be included in STUDENT’s sessions for as much as 60 minutes. Written goals and objectives must be provided for the speech and language services. The speech and language goals and objectives and services must address all of STUDENT’s varied and severe language deficits, including expressive language. The speech and language therapy session must be in addition to STUDENT’s academic program.

5. STUDENT’s program must address her need for developing study skills as discussed by Ms. Campbell and Dr. Hoenig.

6. The IEP team must address all transition requirements under special education law.(Footnote 17)

7. In her closing brief, the Petitioner asserted that the Hearing Officer should order counseling services for STUDENT. The Petitioner did not present sufficient evidence at hearing to require such an order; however, in light of the testimony from Dr. Nunno and Ms. Campbell, the IEP team must determine whether such services are needed.

8. The IEP team must account for the time during the 2002-2003 school year that STUDENT did not receive a FAPE. To that end, STUDENT’s program must include compensatory education services to make up for that time. The IEP team should be mindful of the fact that STUDENT will have limits on the amount of time that she can reasonably be expected to receive and benefit from academic services and, thus, the team may need to consider accounting for the lost time by extending compensatory services beyond the 2002-2003 school year and ESY.

Petitioner also presented evidence that STUDENT needs the assistance of assistive technology to benefit from her educational program. During the framing of the issues, the parties did not identify the need for an assistive technology assessment as an issue for hearing. However, if the Petitioner requests such an assessment, the IEP team must determine whether such an assessment should be done. (Cal. Ed. Code § 56320(f).)

Issue Number 3: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of educational assessments they obtained for STUDENT in the fall of 2002?

Petitioner obtained two educational assessments for which they seek reimbursement: a visual perceptual assessment by Dr. Hoenig, and a psychoeducational assessment provided by Dr. Nunno. The District contends that the issue of assessments is barred because the 2001-2002 school year is not at issue in this case.

State special education law states that a parent has the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by a public agency and the agency’s assessment is determined to be inappropriate. (See Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b).)

In this case, the District retained Ms. Stevick and Ms. Schwartz to conduct a speech and language assessment. Ms. Stevick and Ms. Schwartz determined that their assessment indicated that STUDENT needed a visual perceptual assessment and recommended that the District obtain such an assessment. Such an assessment was not conducted in the 1998 or 2000 assessments, and the District did not present any evidence at the hearing to dispute the fact that such an assessment was required.(Footnote 18) Special education law requires that a student be tested in all areas related to the suspected disability. (Cal. Ed. Code § 56320(f).) However, the District did not prepare an assessment plan or take any other steps toward conducting the assessment. Thereafter, in the fall of 2002, STUDENT’s parents obtained a visual perceptual assessment from Dr. Hoenig, that clearly identified specific deficits that had not been articulated before this point.

Although issues from the 2001-2002 school year were excluded from the case by Hearing Officer Tibbals on December 3, 2002, Dr. Hoenig administered her independent assessment in the fall of 2002, which is not excluded from the case. The fact that the District failed to provide STUDENT with a visual perceptual assessment during the 2001-2002 school year, a school year not at issue in the case, does not bar a remedy for an act occurring in the 2002-2003 school year, i.e., Dr. Nunno’s assessment. Moreover, the District’s duty to conduct a visual perceptual assessment continued into the 2002-2003 school year, and the District did not provide any evidence that it took any steps to conduct such an assessment.

Therefore, STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Hoenig’s visual perceptual assessment conducted in the fall of 2002.

As for the independent psychoeducational assessment conducted by Dr. Nunno in September 2002, a previous psychoeducational assessment was conducted by Grace Rogers of the Petaluma City School District in August 2000. The Petitioner did not present any information that she disagreed with that assessment or that she subsequently requested a new assessment from Cotati-Rohnert Park.(Footnote 19) Moreover, unlike with Dr. Hoenig’s assessment, there is no evidence that another expert in the course of an assessment identified an area of suspected disability and recommended an assessment. Thus, because there is no evidence that Petitioner disagreed with the prior assessment and there is no evidence that an additional assessment was requested or recommended, Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement.

ORDER

1. Within 10 calendar days of the date of this order, STUDENT’s IEP team shall convene to design STUDENT’s program.

2. Within 20 days of the date of this order, the District shall offer STUDENT an educational program that addresses all of STUDENT’s needs, including, but not necessarily limited to the items one through eight specifically set forth in issue number two above.

3. The Hearing Officer retains jurisdiction for 90 days from the date of this Decision to address matters related to the education plan the IEP team is ordered to develop for STUDENT. If neither party petitions for supplemental proceedings within this period, jurisdiction shall terminate.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statue:

1. Did the District offer STUDENT a Free and Appropriate Public Education (FAPE) for the 2002-2003 school year? Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

2. If the District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, is placement at either Pathways or New Horizons School an appropriate remedy for STUDENT? Respondent prevailed on this issue to the extent that the Hearing Officer determined that Pathways School is not an appropriate placement for STUDENT. Petitioner prevailed on the balance of this issue inasmuch as she received a substantial remedy.

3. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of educational assessments they obtained for STUDENT in the fall of 2002? Petitioner prevailed on this issue as it relates to Dr. Hoenig’s assessment. Respondent prevailed on this issue as it relates to Dr. Nunno’s assessment.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties in this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).)

Date: January 23, 2003 ___________________________________ Paul E. Lacy, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. On December 10, 2002, the District requested a continuance because it contended that it did not have personnel available to attend the hearing as a party representative. Prior to December 12, 2002, Mr. Whitman was serving as a party representative in another special education due process hearing that was occurring at the same time as the present hearing. The District noted that it had other persons qualified to represent it in due process hearings but informed the Hearing Officer that those persons were assigned to other tasks. Petitioner informed the Hearing Officer that they had scheduled several expert witnesses for the days to come, and those witnesses could not be rescheduled for several weeks. The Hearing Officer denied the motion to continue, ruling that the motion was untimely and that the District had not established good cause for the delay. The District had persons authorized to represent them in due process hearings legally available, however, it chose to assign them to other tasks instead of represent it at the hearing. Additionally, based on the availability of witnesses, the Hearing Officer determined that a continuance would cause an unacceptable delay of three to four weeks. 2. The evidence indicated that STUDENT also received services from the Piner-Olivet Union School District, which apparently operated a charter school that STUDENT attended. The evidence also indicated that STUDENT attended approximately nine schools in eleven years, but it is unclear exactly which schools she attended and whether the nine schools included the two schools she has attended at Cotati-Rohnert Park. 3. Given the role of educating children with disabilities in achieving these policies, the development of language must be given heightened attention inasmuch as it underlies and serves as the foundation not only for education in general, but also for each of Congress’s specified policy objectives. 4. Significant deficits in visual motor integration were also noted in her 1998 psychoeducational evaluation. 5. The evidence indicates that goals and objectives for language were also drafted and then revised at the May 2002 IEP team meeting. However, the written drafts for the language goals and objectives, which STUDENT’s parents did not agree to, were apparently lost. According to Ms. Jones and Ms. Neptune, no new written goals and objectives for language were prepared. 6. There was no information presented at the hearing as to how three separate special day classes for three separate subjects differed from an RSP class.

7. Ms. Thomas noted that there is another aide in her classroom, but that aide is specifically assigned to assist one student in her class and she does not assist Ms. Thomas generally, nor STUDENT particularly. 8. The content of STUDENT’s speech and language program is discussed below. 9. Although most of the language experts disagreed as to which of the name brand language programs was most suited for STUDENT–most of them said that the programs were similar to each other–virtually all of these witnesses agreed that STUDENT needed to utilize the essential components of one or more of the programs whether they were packaged under one label or whether they were individually mixed and matched. 10. Ms. Carolyn Jones, the speech and language specialist who testified on behalf of the District, stated that STUDENT had met most of her language goals and objectives for 2001-2002. However, as noted, standardized tests do not reflect such gains. (Moreover, the skills that Ms. Neptune testified that she was presently working with STUDENT on were also primary goals and objectives in STUDENT’s 2001-2002 IEP.) Finally, even if STUDENT had met her goals for last year–and the Hearing Officer is not persuaded that she did–STUDENT received 230 minutes of speech and language services between January and June 2002. The District did not provide any evidence that STUDENT would continue to make any progress if her services were reduced by 120 minutes. 11. The Hearing Officer did not give much credence to Ms. Neptune’s conclusion that 110 minutes of speech and language services were adequate to address STUDENT’s extensive needs because she did not explain how 110 minutes would suffice when STUDENT virtually hadn’t progressed at all until the two hours of services–for a total of 230 minutes–were added in the spring of 2002. In contrast, Ms. Neptune was credible and persuasive when she articulated with great specificity the techniques, strategies and repetitive practice that STUDENT required to learn. 12. The very reason that special education law absolutely requires that goals and objectives must be in writing is that it is nearly impossible to evaluate a student’s needs and measure her progress without knowing exactly what the goals and objectives are. Although documents may get misplaced from time-to-time, the District’s witnesses had no explanation as to why new documents were not drafted. 13. Although both parties discussed and argued issues relating to STUDENT’s ESY in the summer of 2002, the 2001-2002 school year, which includes ESY services in 2002, was not identified as an issue in this case. 14. Petitioner also asserted that the District did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE because the goals and objectives drafted at the May 2002 IEP meeting were inappropriate. As discussed above, the Hearing Officer has already noted that the District failed to redraft the speech and language goals and objectives that were misplaced after the May 2002 IEP. However, in light of the fact that the Hearing Officer has found that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, it is unnecessary to separately analyze the goals and objectives to determine if they constitute an independent basis for finding a denial of FAPE. Because nearly eight months has passed since the goals and objectives were developed for the 2002-2003 school year, and in light of the Hearing Officer’s order set forth below to reconvene an IEP meeting, the IEP team will need to completely review and update STUDENT’s goals and objectives. The Hearing Officer reminds the IEP team to determine all of STUDENT’s deficits and educational needs, determine her present levels of performance in each applicable area, and draft appropriate goals and objectives with adequate specificity to address each of STUDENT’s needs. 15. Although the Hearing Officer does not have adequate information regarding the specific components of the program at New Horizons to determine whether it meets STUDENT’s needs, the Hearing Officer is not excluding New Horizons as an appropriate program for STUDENT. Based on the evidence presented at hearing, the IEP team should consider New Horizons as a possible placement for STUDENT or as a supplemental service provider. 16. That time begins from the start of school in September 2002 and continues until the order in this Decision is implemented. The time does not include absences. Again, due to the absence of a specific, appropriate remedy, the Hearing Officer finds that it will be necessary for the IEP team to convene and design both a prospective program and appropriate compensatory services. 17. Although Petitioner raised the issue of a transition plan at the hearing in the context of the FAPE issue, such a plan is not required before STUDENT’s sixteenth birthday. STUDENT will turn sixteen years old during the present school year, and the IEP team must address the transition plan issue at that point. 18. The District argues in its closing brief that the IEP team did not dwell on Ms. Stevick’s recommendation, nor did the team recommend that the assessment be done. Whether an assessment is in fact required is not dependent on whether the team recommended it. The question is whether the evidence supports the fact that the assessment addressed a suspected area of disability. In fact, Dr. Hoenig’s assessment specifically identified a number of disabilities. 19. In her closing brief, Petitioner argued that the 2000 assessment did not constitute a triennial assessment and that a triennial assessment was due in January 2001. However, whether the 2000 assessment served as a triennial assessment or whether the IEP team made a conscious decision in January 2001 that further assessments were not needed was not made an issue at the hearing. Although the Petitioner references documents in evidence to support her position, the parties did not have an opportunity to litigate the issue. Thus, the Hearing Officer will not consider failure to conduct a triennial assessment as a basis for awarding reimbursement.