California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 2, 2005
Student v. Davis Joint Unified School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 246-05 · Hearing Officer Michael F. Geary
Hearing Officer upholds Davis Joint Unified's assessment, finds student not eligible under emotional disturbance, and denies all relief.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The decision references a prior SEHO decision between the same parties (Case No. SN04-02072/04-02200, September 30, 2004). No remand, court order, vacatur, or correction is noted.
Summary
Davis Joint Unified School District filed for due process to defend its psychoeducational assessment of a 17-year-old who had never been found eligible for special education. His parents had placed him at Island View, a residential treatment center in Utah. They filed their own case, which was consolidated with the District's. They argued he qualified under emotional disturbance. A prior SEHO decision had required the District to decide his eligibility by November 4, 2004. District psychologist A'Delle Dugan-Laws assessed him at Island View, and the IEP team found him not eligible. Before the hearing, the Hearing Officer denied the District's motion to bar issues under collateral estoppel. Claims against the Yolo County mental health department settled and were dismissed.
The Hearing Officer found the District's assessment appropriate. The assessor reviewed existing records and gathered input from his teachers, parents, and therapist. She used valid tools, including the Behavior Assessment System for Children, and did not rely on a single test. Because the assessment was appropriate, the parents could not be reimbursed for Dr. William Merz's independent assessment. The Hearing Officer gave little weight to Dr. Merz's opinions. He found the student did not show any of the three claimed emotional disturbance traits over a long period and to a marked degree that harmed his schoolwork. The student's grades stayed strong. Because the student was not eligible, the Hearing Officer did not decide the IEP procedure, residential reimbursement, or IEP-meeting claims. All relief was denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled a claim of emotional disturbance for a high-achieving student. It examined whether each claimed trait lasted a long time and to a marked degree, and whether it hurt educational performance. A medical diagnosis of depression was not treated as the same thing as meeting the special education criteria.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 1. Are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the independent assessment conducted by Dr. William Merz from December 2004 through February 2005? (District filed to defend its assessment; Student argued it failed to consider existing data, used unvalidated instruments, misadministered the BASC, relied on a single procedure, and did not assess in all areas.)
The District's assessment was appropriate: it considered data from many sources, used valid tools, gave the BASC as instructed, did not rely on a single procedure, and assessed all areas. The parents were not entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessment.
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 2. Has Student been eligible for special education under the category of emotional disturbance from November 4, 2004, to the present?
Student did not show a pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression, inappropriate behavior or feelings, or an inability to build relationships over a long period and to a marked degree that adversely affected his educational performance. He was not eligible.
- Not reachedIEP procedure
Issue 3. Did the District deny Student or his parents required procedural safeguards at the November 4, 2004 IEP meeting? (Student alleged that only District members discussed eligibility in private and that the parents' views were not fairly considered.)
Because Student was not eligible, the Hearing Officer found it unnecessary to address the claimed procedural violations at the IEP meeting.
- Not reachedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4. Are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs incurred since November 4, 2004, for his unilateral educational placement at Island View, a residential treatment center in Utah, including reasonable travel costs for Student and his parents?
Because Student was not eligible, the Hearing Officer did not reach the reimbursement claim. Responsibility for the unilateral placement rests with the parents.
- Not reachedEligibility
Issue 5. Should the District be ordered to convene an IEP meeting, find Student eligible, and develop an IEP for him?
Because Student was not eligible, the Hearing Officer found it unnecessary to address the request for an IEP meeting and IEP.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- All of Student's claims to relief were denied.
Key authorities
Levy v. Cohen (1977) 19 Cal.3d 165; J.F. and N.F. v. School District of Philadelphia (E.D. Pa. 2000) 32 IDELR 93; University of Tenn. v. Elliott (1986) 478 U.S. 788; United States v. Utah Constr. & Mining Co. (1966) 384 U.S. 394; Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist. (9th Cir. 1994); Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S. (9th Cir. 1996); Norton v. Orinda Union Sch. Dist. (9th Cir. 1999); School Committee of Town of Burlington v. Department of Educ. (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994); Student v. Vacaville Unified School District, SN03-01423 (SEHO 2003); Student v. Davis Joint Unified School District, SN04-02072/04-02200 (SEHO 2004)
People named in the decision
- A'Delle Dugan-Laws, school psychologist; District assessor, Davis Joint Unified School District
- Marsha Ludwig, director of student services; District administrator at the November 2004 IEP meeting, Davis Joint Unified School District
- Gay Bourguignon, interim coordinator of special education, Davis Joint Unified School District
- Dale Erdman, psychotherapist at residential treatment center; witness for Student, Island View Residential Treatment Center
- Dr. William Merz, psychologist; independent assessor and expert witness for Student
- Dr. Jeremy A. Chiles, psychologist who assessed Student in Utah
- Dr. Keather Kehoe, child psychiatrist (private)
- Dr. Nancy Mercer, psychologist who gave Rorschach test (private)
- Dr. Laura Nasatir, treating physician, outpatient program, Sutter Center for Psychiatry
- Dr. J. Huffine, psychologist at wilderness program, Sage Walk
- Dr. Judi Vallero, primary care physician
- Greg Guss, counselor (private)
- Dr. Jackson, staff psychiatrist, Island View Residential Treatment Center
- Island View Residential Treatment Center, residential treatment center in Utah (parents' unilateral placement)
- Sage Walk, wilderness program in Oregon (private provider)
- Sutter Center for Psychiatry, psychiatric facility (private provider)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Davis, California, on March 8, 9, and 10, 2005.
Petitioner/Cross-Respondent Davis Joint Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Jan Tomsky. The District’s director of student services, Marsha Ludwig, was also present during most of the hearing. The District’s interim coordinator of special education, Gay Bourguignon, was present on the afternoon of March 9, 2005.
Respondent/Cross-Petitioner STUDENT (Student or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Margaret Broussard. STUDENT’s father, FATHER, was also present.
The District called the following witnesses: A’Delle Dugan-Laws, the District psychologist who assessed STUDENT on October 27, 2004, and Marsha Ludwig, who attended the November 2004 individualized education program (IEP) meeting as the District’s administrator.
Student called the following witnesses: STUDENT’s father, FATHER; Dale Erdman, a psychotherapist who has been providing services to STUDENT during his stay at the Island View residential treatment program in Utah; and Dr. William Merz, a psychologist, who conducted an independent assessment of STUDENT over a two month period from December 2004 to February 2005.
Oral and documentary evidence was presented at the hearing. The parties’ closing arguments were heard, and the record was closed on March 10, 2005.
ISSUES
Issue No. 1: Are Student’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the independent assessment conducted by Dr. William Merz from December 2004 through February 2005?
Issue No. 2: Has Student been eligible for special education under the category of emotional disturbance from November 4, 2004, to the present?
Issue No. 3: Did the District deny Student or his parents required procedural safeguards at the November 4, 2004 IEP meeting?
Issue No. 4: Are Student’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs incurred since November 4, 2004, for his unilateral educational placement at Island View, a residential treatment center in Utah, including reasonable travel costs for Student and his parents?
Issue No. 5: Should the District be ordered to convene an IEP meeting, find Student eligible, and develop an IEP for him?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
Dismissal Of Yolo County Department Of Alcohol, Drug, and Mental Health
The District filed its action on November 15, 2004, against Student only. Student filed his action on January 31, 2005, against the District and the Yolo County Department of Alcohol, Drug, and Mental Health (MH). On the first day of the hearing, before any evidence was admitted, the parties discussed settlement off the record and outside the presence of the Hearing Officer. The parties later reported to the Hearing Officer that an agreement had been reached to settle Student’s issues against MH. Student requested that the Hearing Officer dismiss MH. The District did not oppose the request. The Hearing Officer dismissed MH and the matter proceeded between the remaining two parties.
District’s Motion to Bar Issues/Evidence
Before the introduction of any evidence, the District made a motion to collaterally estop Student from litigating questions of fact or law that were determined in a prior due process proceeding that resulted in a decision by the Hearing Office on September 30, 2004 (Case No. SN04-02072/04-02200). The District also argued that Student should not be allowed to present evidence that had been presented in the prior hearing, particularly because the hearing officer in the prior case found the evidence to be insufficient to support finding that the District had a “search and serve” obligation to Student before June 4, 2004, or that Student was eligible for special education prior to November 4, 2004. The District asserted that the Hearing Officer should not admit or consider medical and related records that had been considered by the hearing officer in the prior hearing because those had already been found to be inadequate to support a finding that Student was eligible, but should base his determinations in the instant matter only upon the subsequent assessments conducted by Ms. Dugan-Laws and Dr. Merz.
Student contended that none of the issues presented for this hearing have been previously decided in due process in that the hearing officer in the prior case found that the eligibility issue for the 2004-2005 school year and the related remedy issue for that school year were not ripe because the District had not had the opportunity to conduct its assessment. Student argued that the District’s assessment has now been completed and the District has denied eligibility. It is that determination, and the process that led to that determination, that Student challenges.
The doctrine of collateral estoppel precludes parties from relitigating an issue that has been finally determined in prior litigation. Application of the doctrine requires that the issue presented for adjudication be the same one that was decided in the prior action, that there be a final judgment on the merits in the prior action, and that the party against whom the plea is asserted was a party to the prior action. Levy v. Cohen, (1977) 19 Cal. 3d 165, 171.
In J.F. and N.F., etc. v. School District of Philadelphia, etc. ( D.C. PA 2000) 32 IDELR 93, the court states its analysis of the need for such application to special education due process hearings, in part, as follows:
The Supreme Court has explained that giving preclusive effect to the findings of an administrative agency serves the underlying purposes of issue preclusion which include "both the parties, interest in avoiding the cost and vexation of repetitive litigation and the public's interest in conserving judicial resources." University of Tenn. v. Elliott, (1986) 478 U.S. 788, 798. The Court has also held that "[w]hen an administrative agency is acting in a judicial capacity and resolves disputed issues of fact properly before it which the parties have had an adequate opportunity to litigate, the courts have not hesitated to apply res judicata to enforce repose." United States v. Utah Constr. & Mining Co., (1966) 384 U.S. 394, 422.
The Hearing Office has long applied the doctrine of collateral estoppel to its own decisions. The doctrine serves the legitimate purpose of curtailing multiple actions between the same parties on the same issue and thus avoiding unnecessary effort by and expense to the parties and to the tribunals to which the issues are presented. Once litigated and finally determined between the parties, an issue should be laid to rest.
At the due process hearing in Case No. SN04-02072/04-02200, the hearing officer was asked by Student to adjudicate his claims that the District had failed in its child-find obligation, that he was eligible for special education on the basis of an emotional disturbance, that the District failed to provide Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2003-2004 and the 2004-2005 school years, and that Student and his parents were thus entitled to remedies. In the decision issued on September 30, 2004, the hearing officer found, inter alia, that the District’s child-find obligation did not arise until June 2004, and that the District was not required to convene the initial IEP meeting until November 4, 2004. She denied all relief relating to the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year (ESY) because the District had no obligation to provide Student a FAPE at that time, and she held that the issues relating to the 2004-2005 school year were not ripe because the District had not yet had the opportunity to complete its assessment and convene the initial IEP meeting.
The Hearing Officer found that none of the five issues identified for adjudication in this matter had been finally determined in the prior hearing and that, therefore, Student was not collaterally estopped from litigating those issues in the instant hearing. Furthermore, because the District failed to identify any specific finding of fact or conclusion of law in the prior case that Student was seeking to litigate again in the instant hearing, there was no basis for an order limiting the issues. There was also no basis for an order limiting evidence. Therefore, the Hearing Officer denied the District’s motion.
Burden of Producing Evidence
The District argued that Student should be required to first produce his evidence because his issue regarding eligibility was the “larger” issue in dispute and because he sought to change the status quo. Student contended that the District should proceed first on its assessment issue, followed by Student’s presentation of his case on the remaining issues.
The Hearing Officer has the authority to exercise reasonable control over the mode and order of presenting witnesses and evidence. There is no special education law assigning the burden of producing evidence. The Hearing Office generally has assigned that burden to the party seeking to change the status quo. (Student v. Vacaville Unified School District, SN03-01423 (CSEHO, Oct. 2003.)) However, in such cases the issue is usually the appropriateness of an implemented educational program, and the party to whom the burden is assigned is the one seeking to change that program. This kind of analysis is less helpful in a case where the issues are the appropriateness of a school district’s assessment and its determination regarding eligibility.
The District filed its due process hearing request first on November 15, 2004, two and one-half months before Student filed his due process hearing request. The District’s case would have gone to hearing but for the parties’ stipulation taking the matter off the hearing calendar and, much later, Student’s unopposed motion to consolidate the cases. The District has the burden of proving that it complied with special education law. (Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist., No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994); Seattle Sch. Dist., No. 1 v. B.S., et al., 82 F.3d 1493, 1498 (9th Cir. 1996); Alan Norton v. Orinda Union Sch. Dist., 29 IDELR 1069 (9th Cir. 1999).) Student clearly and specifically identified his contentions regarding the alleged deficiencies of the District’s assessment. Thus, the District knew precisely which elements of the assessment were contested and was in a better position to bear the burden of producing evidence because it had the easiest access to witnesses and other evidence relevant to the assessment issues. Considering all of the circumstances, the Hearing Officer determined that the District’s assessment issue would proceed first and that the District would bear the burden of going forward on that issue.
Student agreed that he would bear the burden of producing evidence on the remaining issues. Therefore, the Hearing Officer ordered that the District first produce witnesses on its assessment issue. Student would then produce his witnesses both on the assessment issue and on the other issues.
BACKGROUND
STUDENT is seventeen years old. For most of his life, he has lived in Davis, California, with his parents, MOTHER and FATHER. During some of that time, his older half-brother also lived with him. STUDENT has never been found eligible for special education. Until July 2004, STUDENT attended public schools in Davis and demonstrated superior academic ability and achievement. In late July 2004, STUDENT’s parents unilaterally sent him to Sage Walk, a wilderness camp for troubled teens in Oregon, due to concerns about drug abuse and other problematic behaviors. From there, STUDENT was unilaterally placed by his parents at Island View Residential Treatment Center in Utah, where he remains to date.
According to the histories contained in the various medical and psychological reports in evidence, STUDENT’s parents believe that he has been depressed since he started attending school, apparently at age five or sooner. There is a reference to a single consultation with a psychologist because of a concern about gender identity issues when he was a young child. FATHER testified that he took STUDENT to a mental health professional again when he was six years old. The record shows that STUDENT has been intermittently under the care of mental health professionals primarily since spring of 2003 when the family attended therapy for some period of time. It is not clear what prompted this family therapy. It may have been to help STUDENT deal with his feeling following the suicide of a close friend. It may also have related to family conflict. For many years, STUDENT’s mother has traveled extensively for her job and is said to be away from home sixty percent of the time. STUDENT also has had significant conflict with his father. (Footnote 1) The family therapy was interrupted when STUDENT traveled during the summer with the People-to-People Program, in which youth who are perceived to be leaders in their community are escorted through several European countries. STUDENT did not return to family therapy when he finished his travels and began attending Davis High School.
STUDENT’s behaviors worsened during the spring semester of 2004. He was depressed and there was increasing conflict between him and his parents. In February, he cut himself on his arms, though not with the intent to kill himself. His parents attempted to initiate a “5150” at a psychiatric facility but STUDENT ran away. (Footnote 2) He was cleared the next day as not being a danger to himself or others, so no hospitalization occurred. By mid-March 2004, STUDENT consulted with his primary care physician complaining of depression involving family issues and admitting to abuse of marijuana weekly, and hallucinogenic mushrooms, Ecstasy, and methamphetamines less frequently. A counselor that STUDENT was also seeing at the time suggested an evaluation by a prescribing psychiatrist.
On March 31, 2004, STUDENT began seeing child psychiatrist Keather Kehoe. At that time STUDENT reported to Dr. Kehoe that he had been using marijuana “most days” since April 2003 and had “tried mushrooms before.” He denied other drug use and stated to her that he was then using drugs only rarely because of drug testing at his new job at a grocery store. STUDENT continued to see Dr. Kehoe for several months.
In April 2004, Dr. Nancy Mercer administered a Rorschach Inkblot Test (RIT) to STUDENT. During an interview with Dr. Mercer, STUDENT denied recent drug use, but she noted that his pupils were dilated at the time her examination.
According to reports by STUDENT and his parents to several mental health practitioners, STUDENT began using drugs no later than mid-2003. By February 2004, he was sexually active, mostly or entirely with males. (Footnote 3) There were significant conflicts with his father over independence and trust issues. STUDENT was using drugs, sneaking out of the house at night, and may have been sexually promiscuous or trading sex for drugs. His parents were understandably concerned.
During all of this time STUDENT was doing well in school. He had always done superior academic work with mostly “A” and “B” grades. By this time he was in a mixed placement, attending gifted and talented (GATE) English, an advanced placement (AP) Spanish Literature, and a lab science course at the Davis High School Campus while taking health, algebra 2, and a modern world civilization classes through independent studies. However, beginning in April 2004, STUDENT’s attendance dropped off.
FATHER took STUDENT to the emergency room on June 3, 2004, with a report of a suspected overdose of alcohol, methamphetamines, and sleeping pills. Hospital records do not confirm an actual overdose, but a record of that date from Yolo County Suicide Prevention indicates that STUDENT’s parents reported that he was self-destructive. The clinician determined that STUDENT was not a danger to himself or others but his parents insisted on a hospitalization to contain him and were referred to the Sutter Center for Psychiatry (Sutter) for a possible voluntary admission. On June 7, 2004, STUDENT agreed to enter an outpatient program at Sutter. On June 8, 2004, Dr. Laura Nasatir informed the District that STUDENT was not then able to resume regular school with the demands of year-end finals. According to a history contained in a later report, STUDENT took some of his mother’s sleeping pills with rum on June 10, 2004. This was never characterized as an attempted suicide. However, on June 11, 2004, STUDENT was admitted to Sutter.
The evidence does not show the length of STUDENT’s hospitalization at Sutter. Neither party offered the records of this hospitalization. He was apparently discharged by the end of June because, according to the documents, on July 1, 2004, STUDENT’s mother reported by email to an educational therapist that STUDENT was still seeking drugs and alcohol and was “huffing” (inhaling gases to become intoxicated). She also wrote that there had been a violent argument between STUDENT and his father and that STUDENT had run away.
STUDENT stayed away, apparently living with a friend in Sacramento, California, for approximately four weeks. In mid-July, he stopped using drugs. (Footnote 4)
In late July, STUDENT and his friend traveled to southern California. When he returned to Sacramento on or about July 28, 2004, an “escort” service hired by his parents took him to Sage Walk, a wilderness camp for troubled teens in central Oregon. The day before STUDENT’s discharge from Sage Walk, psychologist J. Huffine, Ph.D., diagnosed STUDENT with depression and substance abuse and stated that STUDENT would require lots of work to maintain his sobriety and avoid an unhealthy lifestyle.
On September 1, 2004, STUDENT was escorted directly from Sage Walk to Island View, where he remains to date. STUDENT’s Island View admission note dated September 2, 2004, states that he acknowledged daily methamphetamine use and varied marijuana use for the past year, as well as experimentation with cocaine, heroine, and “a lot of other medications.” On September 10, 2004, STUDENT reported to Utah psychologist Jeremy Chiles that his drug use was limited to marijuana prior to April 2004 and that he began to use hard drugs then when he was keeping company with a drug dealer who would supply STUDENT with various drugs for free.
On August 16, 2004, STUDENT filed a request for due process. He contended at that time, as he does now, that he was eligible for special education due to an emotional disturbance (ED). The Hearing Office issued a decision in that matter on September 30, 2004. That decision determined, among other things, that the District’s child-find obligation to STUDENT did not arise until June 4, 2004, when it learned of STUDENT’s outpatient hospitalization and, therefore, the District was not required to provide special education or related services to STUDENT during the 2003-2004 school year. The hearing officer who heard the previous case determined that the District was required to determine STUDENT’s eligibility for special education for the upcoming 2004-2005 school year and extended school year and, if appropriate, to develop an individualized education program (IEP) for him by November 4, 2004.
The District psychologist, A’Delle Dugan-Laws, traveled to Island View to assess STUDENT on October 27, 2004. Ms. Dugan-Laws concluded that STUDENT was not eligible for special education under the category ED. The District convened an IEP meeting on November 4, 2004, and, over his parents’ objection, determined that STUDENT was not eligible for special education. STUDENT’s parents indicated that they would seek an independent assessment at public expense. On November 15, 2004, the District filed its request for due process seeking to defend its assessment. On January 31, 2005, Student filed his request for due process.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue No. 1: Are Student’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the independent assessment conducted by Dr. William Merz in December 2004 through February 2005?
Student claims that his parents are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the assessment conducted by Dr. William Merz in December 2004 through February 2005. He alleges that the assessment by A’Delle Dugan-Laws was inappropriate and that she reached the wrong conclusion regarding STUDENT’s eligibility for special education. The District contends that its assessment was proper.
A parent has the right to obtain an independent assessment at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment done by the school district. The school district must pay for the independent assessment unless there is a determination through due process that its assessment was appropriate. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(a) and(b).)
An assessment by a school district must meet the statutory requirements set forth in California Education Code sections 56320 et seq. Student identified specific requirements that he contends were not met. He contends that the assessment by Ms. Dugan-Laws was inappropriate because (1) The District did not adequately consider existing data about STUDENT; (2) The assessment instruments had not been validated for the specific purpose for which they were used; (3) The Behavior Assessment Scale for Children (BASC) was not administered in conformance with instructions; (4) A single procedure was used as the sole criterion for determining whether STUDENT was eligible on the basis of an emotional disturbance; and (5) STUDENT was not assessed in all areas related to his suspected disability.
The Hearing Officer will examine each of these contentions.
Existing Data Not Considered
In essence, Student contends that the District failed to review and take into consideration all of the available information relating to STUDENT’s potential emotional disturbance.
The Hearing Officer is not aware of, nor did the parties point out, any specific legal requirement regarding the type or amount of existing data that must be taken into consideration as part of an initial assessment. Federal and State law states that the IEP team shall, “if appropriate,” review existing evaluation data, including evaluations and information provided by the parents, current classroom-based assessments and observations, and observations by teachers and related service providers. (34 C.F.R. § 300.533(a)(1); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(h).) Generally, the District was required to document and carefully consider information from a variety of sources, including test data and parent and teacher input. (34 C.F.R. § 300.535(a).)
According to the testimony and report of Ms. Dugan-Laws, she reviewed STUDENT’s cumulative file and his attendance record, and met with his parents on June 10 to discuss a plan to return STUDENT to school in the fall with an accommodation plan pursuant to section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (29 U.S.C. § 794). Ms. Dugan-Laws was aware that STUDENT had recently entered an outpatient program at Sutter and of Dr. Nasatir’s diagnosis of depression and substance abuse.
In the course of her assessment of STUDENT, Ms. Dugan-Laws also reviewed the report of Jeremy A. Chiles, the psychologist who assessed STUDENT in Utah on September 10, 2004. Dr. Chiles’ report contained a detailed history of STUDENT’s development, difficulties, and treatment. Dr. Chiles conducted a thorough psychoeducational evaluation that included review of STUDENT’s mental health records, an interview and mental status examination of STUDENT, interviews of STUDENT’s parents, and the administration of the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory, Adolescent Edition (MMPI-A), the Millon Adolescent Clinical Inventory (MACI), the Rorschach Inkblot Test (RIT), the Sentence Completion Test (SCT), the Substance Abuse Subtle Screening Inventory for Adolescents, the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children, Fourth Edition (WISC-IV), and the Woodcock-Johnson Test of Achievement, Third Edition (WJ-III). Having reviewed Dr. Chiles’ report, Ms. Dugan-Laws was also aware of STUDENT’s diagnosis of depression, sexual identity problem, oppositional defiant disorder, parent-child relationship problems, and substance abuse.
Ms. Dugan-Laws traveled to Island View to assess STUDENT on October 27, 2004. She first met with STUDENT’s therapist, Dale Erdman. That brief meeting was followed by a two and one-half hour long assessment session with STUDENT. Ms. Dugan-Laws then rejoined Mr. Erdman for lunch and a further discussion of STUDENT’s situation, including his difficulties with sexual identity, drug abuse, and family conflict. Ms. Dugan-Laws testified that Mr. Erdman told her, among other things, that STUDENT “hid” himself from others and was just beginning to talk about his issues and feelings. Ms. Dugan-Laws spent another two to two and one-half hours assessing STUDENT in the afternoon.
Student was critical of the District’s assessment on the ground that Ms. Dugan-Laws did not gather and consider all of the potentially pertinent information. STUDENT’s consultant, Dr. Merz, stated in his report that Ms. Dugan Laws missed “important data,” including records from Drs. Kehoe, Mercer, and Huffine, and Island View. However, the evidence showed that Ms. Dugan-Laws reviewed Dr. Chiles’ report, which contained his summary of STUDENT’s mental health history, and that she discussed STUDENT’s diagnosis and treatment at Island View with Mr. Erdman. Dr. Merz failed to explain in either his report or his testimony how or why a review of these other records was necessary to assess STUDENT and make a recommendation regarding his eligibility for special education. The Hearing Officer has reviewed the records of these providers that were offered into evidence. The only “new” information contained in those records related to STUDENT’s purported sexual experiences with multiple older male partners and his claims that he was raped. (Footnote 5) Even assuming there is some truth to these claims, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded that knowledge of them was required for an appropriate assessment.
Ms. Dugan-Laws’ report and testimony showed that, in addition to the information obtained from STUDENT’s parents, his educational records, and the report of Dr. Chiles, she also obtained information from Dale Erdman, the Island View therapist who had spent almost two months with STUDENT in individual and group therapy, and from four of STUDENT’s teachers at Island View. (Footnote 6) The Hearing Officer found her testimony persuasive.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District did fulfill its obligation to adequately document and consider information about STUDENT from a variety of sources, including his teachers, parents, and other assessors.
Assessment Instruments Not Validated
Student contends that his eligibility for special education due to an emotional disturbance is based on three of the five characteristics set forth in federal and State law. (Footnote 7) He claims that he has a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression, that he exhibits inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances in several situations, and that he is unable to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers. (34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4)(i)(B-D); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(i)(2-4).) Student concedes that the District used instruments that were validated for evaluating depression. However, he claims that the District did not use assessment instruments that were validated for assessing the other two characteristics.
There is no legal requirement that the LEA use standardized or validated instruments to determine whether a pupil exhibits one or more of the characteristics of ED. Rather, the LEA is required to document and carefully consider information from a variety of sources, including test data and parent and teacher input. (34 C.F.R. § 300.535(a).) However, if the LEA chooses to use standardized tests, federal law requires that those be validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. (20 U.S.C.§ 1414(b)(3)(B)(i); 34 C.F.R. § 300.532(c)(1).) The Comments to the 1999 regulations explain that the validation requirement is limited to standardized tests, then goes on to state “The selection of appropriate assessment instruments and methodologies is . . . left to State and local discretion.” (64 Fed Reg. 12633 (March 12, 1999).)
State law arguably goes a bit further by requiring that “tests and other assessment materials” be validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320((b)(2).) However, the term “validated” is not defined in either the federal or State special education statutes or regulations. However, in this context, an assessment instrument is generally considered valid if it actually measures what it purports or intends to measure. (Assessment, Eighth Edition, Salvia, J., & Ysseldyke, J. E. (2001).) Furthermore, federal law requires the use of “technically sound instruments” and tools and strategies that provide relevant information that will assist in the determination of the educational needs of the pupil. (34 C.F.R. § 300.532(i) and (j).) Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that at least non-standardized instruments can be validated by proof that they are generally considered to be technically sound and to provide reliable measures of what they purport to measure.
Ms. Dugan-Laws testified that, in addition to the information contained from the various sources identified above and her observation of STUDENT during the assessment process, she used the Behavior Assessment System for Children (BASC), a normed and validated instrument that is consistently and reliably used by psychologists to assess a number of social and emotional areas. (Footnote 8) Ms. Dugan-Laws’ assessment report shows that the areas evaluated by the BASC included some related to STUDENT’s ability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers (attitude toward teachers, social and leadership skills, interpersonal relationships, and withdrawal), and some related to inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances in several situations (atypicality, or unusual perceptions, thoughts or behaviors, and aggression). Ms. Dugan Laws testified that the District’s administration of the BASC included surveys that were completed by STUDENT, both his parents, and four of his teachers at Island View. She stated that she also used the Sentence Completion Test, which is not standardized or normed but can provide useful information regarding the subject’s self-image.
Student did not offer any evidence to support his view that the District’s assessment, including the BASC, was ineffective to assess for the two traits in question: his ability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers and his tendency to exhibit inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances in several situations. His own consultant, Dr. Merz, was not critical of the District’s assessment on this ground and Dr. Merz did not describe any effort by him to specifically assess for the two characteristics at issue. Dr. Merz’s testimony showed that he relied principally if not exclusively on historical information from STUDENT. In addition to reviewing relevant information and using valid instruments to assess for related traits, Ms. Dugan-Laws also obtained information from STUDENT, as well as from four of his teachers and his therapist at Island View.
On the basis of the persuasive and essentially unopposed testimony of Ms. Dugan-Laws, the Hearing Officer finds that the District used appropriate and valid assessment methods and materials to determine whether STUDENT was unable to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers or exhibited inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances in several situations.
BASC Not Administered In Conformance With Instructions
Student challenges the District’s administration of the BASC on the ground that the teachers who completed the surveys had known STUDENT for less than two months.
Tests and other assessment materials must be administered in conformance with instructions provided by the producer of the tests or other assessment materials. (34 C.F.R. § 300.532(c)(1)(ii); Cal. Educ Code § 56320(b)(3).)
Ms. Dugan-Laws testified that the BASC manual recommends the use of the teacher rating scales (TRS) with teachers who have adequate “familiarity” with the pupil and that use by a teacher who has had almost daily contact with the pupil for at least one month is in conformance with instructions.
Student’s evidence did not contradict Ms. Dugan-Laws’ testimony. Although Dr. Merz said that it was common practice not to give the TRS to teachers who have only know the pupil for one month and that he prefers its use by teachers who have know the pupil for about a semester, he did not contradict Ms. Dugan-Laws testimony that her use of the TRS was in conformance with the producer’s instructions. Dr. Merz administered only the self-report of the BASC during his assessment. When asked why he did not use the parent and teacher surveys, he testified that he considered the District’s administration of the BASC to the teachers and the parents to have been appropriate so chose to administer the self-report only “to address discrepancies.” He also testified that he did not expect that the teachers would have responded differently even though they would have had several additional months of familiarity with STUDENT.
Ms. Dugan-Laws has a master’s degree in special education with an advanced specialization in the area of serious emotional disturbance and a pupil personnel services credential in school psychology and counseling. She has been trained in the use of various assessment tools, including the BASC, and has twelve years experience as a school psychologist during which time she has conducted five hundred to eight hundred assessments, including approximately two hundred focused on social and emotional areas. She testified convincingly to her familiarity with the BASC and its instructions for use. Her unopposed testimony established that her reliance on the TRS from STUDENT’s teachers at Island View was in conformance with the BASC instructions.
The Hearing Officer finds that the BASC was administered in conformance with instructions.
Single Procedure Used As The Sole Criterion
Federal and State law provides that a single procedure shall not be used as the sole criterion for determining eligibility. (34 C.F.R. § 300.532(f); Cal. Educ Code § 56320(e).)
Student contends that the District improperly relied on the BASC and the RADS-II as the sole criterion for finding STUDENT ineligible for special education. He argued that the District thereby relied on a single procedure – the “standardized inventory tests” – as the sole criterion for its determination that STUDENT was not eligible for special education.
Student’s argument in this regard was strained and unpersuasive. The evidence discussed above established that the District’s assessor did not base her determination on any single procedure. Educational and prior assessment records were reviewed. Information was obtained from a variety of sources. Standardized and non-standardized measures were used. All of this information was used to determine STUDENT’s eligibility for special education.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not rely on a single procedure as the sole criterion for determining eligibility.
Assessed In All Areas
Student contends that the District failed to assess him for the two ED characteristics referred to above: inappropriate types of behavior or feelings exhibited under normal circumstances in several situations, and an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers. (Footnote 9)
The law requires that a child with a suspected disability be assessed by the school district in all areas related to the suspected disability. (34 C.F.R. § 300.532(h); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f).) The evaluation must be “sufficiently comprehensive to identify all of the child’s special education and related services needs.” (34 C.F.R. § 300.532(h).) The IEP team must be able to rely on the information from an initial assessment to determine eligibility and to develop an appropriate educational program, if one is required. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b).
The Hearing Officer has already found that the District used appropriate and valid assessment tools and strategies to assess STUDENT. Student disagrees with the District’s conclusions, but he offered no evidence to support his argument that he was not assessed in the areas of suspected disability. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did properly assess Student to determine whether he had an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers, or exhibited inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances in several situations.
In summary, the District carefully documented and considered information about STUDENT from a variety of sources, including his teachers, parents, and other assessors. It used appropriate and valid assessment methods and materials to determine whether STUDENT was unable to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers or exhibited inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances in several situations. The District properly administered the BASC in conformance with the producer’s instructions and did not rely on a single procedure as the sole criterion for determining eligibility. Finally, it properly assessed Student to determine whether he had an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers, or exhibited inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances in several situations.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s assessment was appropriate and that Student’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the independent assessment conducted by Dr. William Merz in December 2004 through February 2005.Issue No. 2: Has Student been eligible for special education under the category of ED from November 4, 2004, to the present?
Federal and State laws set forth the criteria for determining whether a pupil qualifies for special education services on the basis of an emotional disturbance. (Footnote 10) The law provides that a pupil is eligible for special education if, because of an emotional disturbance, the pupil exhibits one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree, which adversely affect educational performance:
(1) An inability to learn which cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors. (2) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers. (3) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations. (4) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.
(5) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.
(34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5 §3030(i).)
Student contends that he has been eligible for special education due to an emotional disturbance that is evidenced by his general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression, his inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations, and his inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers. The District denies that Student has been eligible as evidenced by any of these traits during the time in question.
A General Pervasive Mood Of Unhappiness Or Depression
On the basis of her assessment of STUDENT on October 27, 2004, Ms. Dugan-Laws concluded that STUDENT did not have a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. According to her testimony, she based her conclusion principally upon her observations of STUDENT during the assessment and the results of the BASC survey completed by STUDENT and his teachers at Island View and STUDENT’s responses on the Reynolds Adolescent Depression Scale, Second Edition (RADS-II), all of which indicated depression scales within the average range. Ms. Dugan-Laws testified that, although it is important to gather information about the pupil from various sources, best practice requires that she give more weight to standardized measures, such as the BASC with its own reliability scales, than to interviews because the latter are too subjective and subject to interpretation.
Student challenged Ms. Dugan-Laws’ failure to take the parents’ BASC responses into consideration. Both of those rated STUDENT as clinically significant on the depression scale. Ms. Dugan-Laws’ testimony indicated that she questioned the reliability of the Parents’ BASC responses due to what she characterized as an unusual level of agreement between them, and that she ultimately gave greater weight to the responses of STUDENT and his teachers as more indicative of how he was doing. The Hearing Officer found Ms. Dugan-Laws’ testimony persuasive in this respect.
STUDENT also challenged Ms. Dugan-Laws’ reliance on his responses to the BASC and RADS-II in light of the opinion of Dr. Chiles that STUDENT “fakes good” by misrepresenting his behavioral and emotional difficulties. Inasmuch as the parties agree that STUDENT is bright, articulate, adept at duplicity and manipulation, and inclined to employ dramatic effect to create a desired impression, the Hearing Officer agrees that the District’s assessor would have been ill advised to base any conclusion solely on his report. However, Ms. Dugan-Laws testified that the BASC, at least, includes reliability scales to minimize the subject’s ability to manipulate the results and these indicated that STUDENT’s responses were valid and reliable. In addition, she did not rely solely on STUDENT’s self-reports. She also considered information from a variety of other sources, including Dr. Chiles’ report, other assessment data, Mr. Erdman, and several of STUDENT’s teachers. The Hearing Officer found Ms. Dugan-Laws’ reliance on STUDENT’s responses to be appropriate.
Dr. Merz is critical of Ms. Dugan-Laws’ opinion that STUDENT did not have a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression when she assessed him. He states in his report and his testimony at hearing that this finding is inconsistent with the findings of ten other mental health practitioners. The Hearing Officer does not know who these ten practitioners are. Dr. Merz had the same records that the Hearing officer had. The Hearing Officer is aware of seven who have stated that STUDENT was depressed. The Hearing Officer will examine these opinions to determine if, in fact, they are inconsistent with Ms. Dugan-Laws’ opinion.
STUDENT’s primary care physician, Judi Vallero, M.D., did not testify at the hearing. Her records that were admitted show a diagnosis on March 12, 2004, of depression. The bases for that diagnosis are not in evidence. It appears to have been based substantially if not entirely on the STUDENT’s statement that he had been intermittently depressed four to five times per week for the last two years due primarily to conflict with his parents about his independence. STUDENT denied problems with sleeping, eating, or energy, symptoms of depression according to the testimony of Dr. Merz. Dr. Vallero noted in her chart that STUDENT was positive for anhedonia (a pervasive lack of pleasure or enjoyment), another symptom of depression, but she does not note the basis for this finding or reconcile it with STUDENT’s report to her that he was fine with his friends. STUDENT admitted to Dr. Vallero that he abused drugs, including marijuana, Ecstasy, hallucinogenic mushrooms, and methamphetamines, but there is nothing to suggest that she explored the causal connection between the drugs and STUDENT’s mood. STUDENT was concerned about an anticipated drug test for employment. Dr. Vallero gave STUDENT advice about how long it would take to clear marijuana from his system and ordered a drug screen for marijuana, which was negative.
The Hearing Officer does not equate the diagnosis by Dr. Vallero to an opinion that STUDENT had general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression under the special education criteria. STUDENT said he was unhappy about his parents’ refusal to trust him to live his social life without restrictions. That does not constitute a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. Drug abuse also does not establish that the abuser has a general and pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.
Psychiatrist Keather Kehoe, M.D., also did not testify at the hearing but some of her records are in evidence. She first saw STUDENT on March 31, 2004, to evaluate his need for psychoactive medications. STUDENT told her that his depression started with a romantic rejection in January 2003 and was exacerbated by the suicide of his friend in April 2003. STUDENT did not tell Dr. Kehoe that his depression was constant or pervasive. In fact, this time he denied anhedonia but said, again, that he enjoyed time with his friends. Dr. Kehoe diagnosed depression but the bases for her opinion are not clear. Dr. Kehoe’s records do not show that STUDENT was suffering from a general and pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.
The records of Dr. Kehoe also indicate that STUDENT’s behavioral problems escalated in May and that on June 4, 2004, counselor Greg Guss reported to her that STUDENT was “unraveling,” as evidenced by missed appointments, increased drug use and truancy, defiance at home (sneaking out), and the theft of $600 from his parents. The described behavior is not consistent with any of the DSM-IV criteria for depression referred to by Dr. Merz in his report.
Nancy Mercer, Ph.D., administered the RIT to STUDENT on April 12, 2004. Her records indicate that she interpreted the results as positive for depression. Dr. Mercer did not testify. This Hearing Officer does not equate this test interpretation with the opinion that STUDENT had a general and pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression and finds no basis upon which Dr. Merz could do so.
On June 7, 2004, STUDENT entered the Sutter outpatient program, and later was admitted, with a working diagnosis by Dr. Nasatir of depression and multiple drug abuse. Dr. Nasatir did not testify and the bases of Dr. Nasatir’s diagnosis cannot be determined from the records. Furthermore, the reason for the hospitalization is unclear. There is nothing to indicate that STUDENT was thought by any medical professional to be a danger to himself or others. This suggests that the hospitalization was voluntary. The records suggest that the hospitalization was at the insistence of STUDENT’s parents, who wanted to “contain him” to prevent him from engaging in problematic behaviors.
Dr. Huffine, at Sage Walk, did not testify at the hearing. His report dated August 30, 2004, the day before STUDENT’s move to Island View, also contains a diagnosis of depression. The bases for that diagnosis are not clear, though there is a reference to STUDENT’s statement that he had been depressed for some time and had used drugs and alcohol to self-medicate. Dr. Huffine’s opinion was that STUDENT would need lots of work “to maintain his sobriety and avoid an unhealthy lifestyle to which he is attracted.”
Dr. Chiles conducted his evaluation of STUDENT in Utah on September 10, 2004. His was the only assessment prior to the November 4, 2004 IEP meeting to include standardized testing. (Footnote 11) Dr. Chiles confirmed the diagnosis of depression, identity problem, oppositional defiant disorder, parent-child relationship problem, and drug abuse. It cannot be determined from Dr. Chiles’ report whether at the time of the assessment STUDENT had general and pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression, or which of the several diagnoses, in Dr. Chiles’ opinion, required placement at Island View.
Finally, there have been the ongoing evaluations of STUDENT by the staff at Island View. According to the testimony of STUDENT’s therapist, Dale Erdman, the supervising psychiatrist has consistently diagnosed depression, among other problems, including substance abuse, parent-child relationship problems, and post-traumatic stress disorder. The staff psychiatrist, Dr. Jackson, did not testify at the hearing, but his initial assessment report notes that STUDENT was pleasant and cooperative with a mildly depressed mood. Dr. Jackson’s diagnoses were depression, mild at present, substance dependence, and parent-child relational problems. Although subsequent progress reports do not describe the depression as mild, there was no evidence to show that Dr. Jackson ever reevaluated STUDENT or why Dr. Jackson’s opinion might have changed. Mr. Erdman, who has spent more time with STUDENT than any of the other mental health practitioners, testified that, STUDENT was and remains “very depressed.” However, Mr. Erdman also testified that STUDENT has not had a general and pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression because of his ability to act as if everything was OK, even to the extent that he could perform well and school and convince his teachers that nothing was wrong.
Ms. Dugan-Laws’ conclusion that STUDENT does not have general and pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression is not in conflict with the opinions of the other practitioners, with the exception of Dr. Merz. First, Drs. Vallero, Kehoe, Mercer and Nasatir were seeing STUDENT when he was, by all accounts, at his lowest point, using hard drugs and in constant conflict with his father. Second, none of the diagnoses of depression are explained – or in some instance explainable – on the basis of a general and pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. Most appear to be based solely on STUDENT’s report that he was depressed or on diagnoses by others. (Footnote 12) Finally, Dr. Jackson observed only a mildly depressed mood on admission to Island View and Mr. Erdman states that STUDENT is able to avoid a depressed mood.
Dr. Merz stated in his report and his testimony that at all times pertinent STUDENT has had a general and pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. For the reasons discussed below, the Hearing Officer gives little weight to the opinions of Dr. Merz because he finds his opinions lacking in foundation and credibility.
Dr. Merz repeatedly refers to the inconsistency between Ms. Dugan-Laws’ findings and the findings of all other assessors, but his characterization of the findings of those other assessors is often unsupported. First, none of those prior assessors were seeking to determine STUDENT’s eligibility for special education. Most examined STUDENT at a time when he was at a low point in term of his behavior (drug abuse and possible promiscuity). None specifically stated that STUDENT has a general and pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. Dr. Merz focuses almost entirely on the general diagnoses of depression but does not objectively view and/or characterize the supporting data. In several instances, he mischaracterizes data to support his conclusions. He reports that Dr. Vallero took a history on March 12, 2004, that was positive for sleep, eating, and energy problems, when her findings were just the opposite. He reported that STUDENT was placed on a 5150 when, in fact, no 5150 ever occurred according to the evidence. Similarly, without any factual support, he reported that STUDENT was twice hospitalized because his behavior was so out of control that he had become a danger to himself. The record does not support a finding that any mental health practitioner ever found that STUDENT was a danger to himself or others. At best, the record supports a finding that STUDENT was hospitalized once, and even then, probably because his parents believed that he needed to be protected from his own reckless adventures in drugs and sex.
In addition, Dr. Merz demonstrates repeatedly throughout his report and testimony that he readily will draw conclusions in Student’s favor with little or no factual or legal support. For example, it was not enough for the doctor to support Student’s argument that he exhibited three of the five statutory traits of ED. Although the clear focus of Dr. Merz’s evaluation was depression, his report and testimony goes further. In support of his opinion that Student demonstrated an inability to learn that intellectual, sensory, or health factors could not explain, Dr. Merz ignored STUDENT’s superior academic performance and relied upon STUDENT’s truancy (“If he is not at school, he cannot learn.”), an “incomplete” grade in a course, and STUDENT’s report that he had difficulty focusing and doing his work.
Additionally, Dr. Merz refused to provide test data, including the scores on which he relied, in part, to reach his conclusions. Although he testified that he did not provide this information due to ethical considerations and the requirements of the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996, the Hearing Officer is aware of no prohibition of disclosure of the information in the context of a due process hearing. The Hearing Officer also found the doctor’s refusal to disclose the data inconsistent with his criticism of the District’s assessment on the ground that it lacked sufficient data for crosschecking.
Dr. Merz administered two formal assessments to STUDENT: the Sixteen Personality Factor Inventory, Fifth Edition (16PF) and the BASC, self-report only. He describes the 16PF as an “old standby” that is normed and validated, but he did not state what it was validated to assess. At one point in his testimony, Dr. Merz stated that he did not know whether depression was one of the included scales on the 16PF, but he later conceded that it was not. He testified that he inferred that STUDENT was depressed from other results on the 16PF. However, his description of the results of this test indicates that the data was more indicative of STUDENT having anxiety than depression.
Dr. Merz testified that his administration of the BASC self-report produced results more consistent with depression than did the 16PF, but, as indicated above, there was no adequate explanation of why he chose to administer the BASC to STUDENT only. Dr. Merz agreed that the BASC is a total system and that the instructions recommend that the assessor get information from parents, teachers, and the pupil. If, as suggested above, Dr. Merz believed that he could rely on the scales administered to STUDENT’s parents and teachers by Ms. Dugan-Laws, he made no attempt to discuss the teachers’ responses.
Even if STUDENT did have a general and pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression at some point or points in time, such as after the suicide of his friend or near the end of the 2003-2004 school year, the evidence shows that this mood did not persist over a long period of time and to a marked degree, adversely affecting his educational performance.
Dr. Merz testified, apparently based upon one report, that STUDENT has been depressed since the third grade. STUDENT had also variously traced his depression to sometime between mid 2002 (according to his report to Dr. Vallero) and the suicide of his friend in April 2003 (according to his report to several practitioners). Although this may qualify as a long period of time under the regulations, the evidence shows that STUDENT continued to do well academically during all of this time. Although there was an interruption of his school attendance following the death of his friend, it has already been determined in the prior hearing that STUDENT successfully completed all of his course work for that year. (Footnote 13) (Student v Davis Joint Unified School District, SN04-02072/04-02200 (SEHO 2004).)
STUDENT also did well in school during the first semester of his tenth grade year and during most of the second semester of that year. It was only in the latter part of the tenth grade, as STUDENT’s drug abuse and conflicts with his parents escalated, that he began to skip more school and schoolwork. After a brief hospitalization and time away from family conflict, STUDENT stopped using drugs on his own in mid-July, two weeks before his parents had him escorted to Sage Walk. He eventually completed most of his missed work and has maintained a superior grade point average, which included advanced classes. According to the undisputed evidence, STUDENT also has continued to do well academically at Island View. The evidence shows that STUDENT’s behavior had only a negligible adverse affect on his educational performance and only for a short period of time during the last month or two of the 2003-2004 school year.
Student’s position is that he is doing well academically at Island View only because that residential treatment center offers him the structure and support that he requires. Mr. Erdman’s testimony offers some support for this position. He is of the opinion that STUDENT may engage in “risky behaviors,” including drug use, if he returns to his home. However, he also testified that STUDENT could still be academically successful while engaging in risky behaviors because of his superior ability. In any event, the fact that Student benefits from the parents’ preferred placement and the possibility that he will abuse drugs or engage in other potentially risky behaviors if he returns home are not sufficient to require the District to pay for the placement. If STUDENT is not eligible for special education, responsibility for the unilateral placement rests with his parents.
In summary, the evidence shows that STUDENT has had some difficult times over the last few years. There have been issues relating to his sexual orientation, but STUDENT has stated to several mental health professionals that he is comfortable with that. There have been issues relating to the frequent absence of his mother from the family home and the significant conflicts, including physical altercations, between STUDENT and his father. There was the suicide of a friend and STUDENT’s habitual drug abuse involving a variety of prescription and street drugs, including regular methamphetamine use. Throughout most of these experiences, STUDENT performed well in school and enjoyed his time with friends. This changed in the latter part of the 2003-2004 school year. STUDENT was seventeen years old and desperately wanted to be free of his parents’ control. He talked to his doctor about emancipation and an early graduation from Davis High School. There are repeated references in the evidence to increased defiance by STUDENT, who would sneak out of his home and party with his friends all night. According to STUDENT, there was increased drug abuse and sexual promiscuity. As STUDENT’s defiance and risky behaviors increased, his parents became increasingly concerned and just as desperate to control their son. It is no coincidence that STUDENT’s poor school attendance and performance were increasing at the same time. The culmination was the forced hospitalization in June, followed almost immediately by a physical altercation between STUDENT and his father, and STUDENT leaving home to stay with his friend in Sacramento. Two weeks before STUDENT was escorted to Sage Walk, and without further urging by his parents or any therapist, he made his own decision to change his life. He stopped using drugs and from all reports STUDENT has done well since then at Sage Walk and Island View.
STUDENT has clearly been unhappy at times. However, the weight of the evidence establishes that he had returned to a high functioning level by the time Ms. Dugan-Laws conducted her assessment just before the November 4, 2004 IEP meeting. The Hearing Officer was persuaded that Ms. Dugan-Laws’ assessment of STUDENT for a general and pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression was appropriate and that her conclusion was valid and supported by other evidence, including the testimony of Mr. Erdman. This is not to say that Mr. Erdman and others are not correct in their belief that STUDENT still has issues relating to manipulation, dishonesty, avoidant behaviors, and family conflict, among other things, and that these may improve with appropriate treatment. It is simply not the responsibility of the District to provide that treatment.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has not had a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression over a long period of time and to a marked degree that has adversely affected his educational performance during the time at issue.
Inappropriate Types Of Behavior Or Feelings
Student also contends that his eligibility for special education under the category ED is evidenced by his inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations. The District contends that Student has not exhibited this characteristic.
The Hearing Officer has already found that Ms. Dugan-Laws properly assessed for this characteristic. She concluded that STUDENT did not exhibit it. Mr. Erdman also testified that STUDENT does not exhibit inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations. Only Dr. Merz supported this claim for Student. In his report Dr. Merz opines that STUDENT has demonstrated this trait by meeting the following DSM-IV criteria for depressive disorder: (1) markedly diminished interest or pleasure in all, or almost all, activities most of the day, nearly every day (as indicated by either subjective account or observation made by others), (2) insomnia or hypersomnia nearly every day, (3) psychomotor agitation or retardation nearly every day (observable by others, not merely subjective feelings of restlessness or being slowed down), and (4) diminished ability to think or concentrate, or indecisiveness, nearly every day (either by subjective account or as observed by others). In his testimony, Dr. Merz stated that STUDENT evidenced this characteristic only by his dysphoric mood, when his emotions were inconsistent with the context or circumstances, such as when he would go to a rave party but not be happy to be there.
The Hearing Officer found Dr. Merz’s opinion regarding this trait to be without evidentiary support. First, the Hearing Officer was not persuaded by the doctor’s conclusory statement that the four DSM-IV criteria for depression equate to the trait of inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations. Second, the weight of the evidence shows that STUDENT did not meet those criteria. For the most part, STUDENT has always indicated that he continued to take pleasure in the company of friends. The evidence does not show that STUDENT had insomnia, hypersomnia, psychomotor agitation or retardation, a diminished ability to think or concentrate, or indecisiveness, nearly every day during the time at issue. Dale Erdman, who has spent the greatest amount of time providing psychotherapy to STUDENT since September 2004, did not testify that STUDENT satisfied any of the four criteria that Dr. Merz ties to this trait. On the contrary, Mr. Erdman testified that STUDENT does not exhibit inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances in several situations.
The Hearing Officer found the testimony of Ms. Dugan-Laws and Mr. Erdman to be persuasive. Ms. Dugan-Laws’ opinion was based on an appropriate assessment. Mr. Erdman’s opinion was based on substantial and current personal knowledge gained over six months of individual and group therapy and other observations of STUDENT at Island View.
As discussed above, even if there was evidence that STUDENT has exhibited inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances in several situations, nothing has occurred over a long period of time and to a marked degree that has adversely affected his educational performance during the time at issue.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Student has not exhibited inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances in several situations over a long period of time and to a marked degree that has adversely affected his educational performance during the time at issue.
Inability To Build Or Maintain Satisfactory Interpersonal Relationships
Student also contends that his eligibility for special education under the category ED is evidenced by his inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers.
Dr. Merz’s report states that “interview data” support this contention. He refers to STUDENT’s purported withdrawal after the suicide of his friend and characterizes STUDENT’s later relationships as “not satisfactory” because the relationships were in some way tied to drugs or sex. His testimony was to the same effect. Dr. Merz described STUDENT’s relationships as cordial, but lacking in reciprocity because STUDENT only “played the role” of a friend, pretending through outward appearances to be a friend but failing to honestly and openly reveal and contribute himself to the relationship. In essence, with the exception of the friend who committed suicide, Dr. Merz believes that STUDENT’s refusal or inability to reciprocate caused him to be unable to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers.
The Hearing Officer does not believe that the law requires the kind of qualitative analysis employed by Dr. Merz. Furthermore, Dr. Merz ignores the many references in the evidence to STUDENT’s friendships. He was in a group of close friends that included the one who committed suicide. According to FATHER, STUDENT had a good interpersonal relationship with the teacher who provided educational services to him at home after the suicide of his friend. STUDENT told Dr. Kehoe on March 31, 2004, that he had a group of several close friends, male and female, and that he enjoyed spending time with them. STUDENT lived and traveled with his friend from Sacramento in July 2004. During at least two of those weeks, STUDENT was not using drugs. Dr. Huffine states in his report that STUDENT makes friends easily. Dr. Chiles’s report stated that STUDENT had the adaptive capacity to establish close, intimate, and mutually supportive relationships. Finally, Mr. Erdman acknowledges that STUDENT had friends before he entered Sage Walk and that he has made friends at Island View.
As with the other two ED characteristics discussed above, even if there was evidence that STUDENT at some point had an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers, the evidence establishes that it was not for a long period of time and to a marked degree adversely affecting his educational performance during the time at issue.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has not had an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers for a long period of time and to a marked degree adversely affecting his educational performance during the time at issue.
In summary, the Hearing Officer has found that, during the time at issue, Student has not had any of the three characteristics of ED upon which he bases his eligibility claim.
The Hearing officer finds that Student has not been eligible for special education under the category of ED from November 4, 2004 to the present.
Issue No. 3: Did the District deny Student a free appropriate public education at the November 4, 2004 IEP meeting?
Student contends that the District denied him a FAPE at the November 4, 2004 IEP meeting in several respects. He claims that there was a procedural denial of a FAPE in that all required IEP team members did not participate in the discussion of eligibility at the meeting. Student alleges that only the District members of the IEP team discussed eligibility while in a private meeting and that the parents and the representatives of Island View who were participating by telephone, including the Student’s general education teacher, were not allowed to participate in that discussion. In addition, Student alleges that the District did not fairly considering the views of his parents. The District contends that it properly conducted the November 4, 2004 IEP meeting.
The law requires that an IEP team include one or both of the pupil’s parents, at least one general education teacher if the pupil is or may be participating in the general education environment, and at least one special education teacher or provider. (34 C.F.R. § 300.344(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b).) However, because the Hearing Officer has determined that Student has not been eligible for special education during any of the time at issue, it is not necessary to address his claim that he was denied procedural protections at the IEP meeting on November 4, 2004.
Issue No. 4: Are Student’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs incurred since November 4, 2004, for his unilateral educational placement at Island View, a residential treatment center in Utah, including reasonable travel costs for Student and his parents?
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under the IDEA and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Educ., 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994).)
Because the Hearing Officer has determined that Student has not been eligible for special education during any of the time at issue, it is not necessary to address his claim that has parents are entitled to reimbursement for the costs of his educational placement at Island View Residential Treatment Center in Utah, including reasonable travel costs for Student and his parents.
Issue No. 5: Should the District be ordered to convene an IEP meeting, find Student eligible, and develop an IEP for him?
Because the Hearing Officer has determined that Student has not been eligible for special education during any of the time at issue, it is not necessary to address his request that the District be ordered to convene an IEP meeting, find Student eligible, and develop an IEP for him.
ORDER
All of Student’s claims to relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
The District prevailed on all issues.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Date: June 2, 2005 _________________________________ Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1 STUDENT’s mother did not appear at the hearing, but the evidence indicates that most of the serious family conflict was between STUDENT and his father
2. Section 5150 of the California Welfare & Institutions Code refers to 72-hour involuntary commitments when a person is believed by the legal authorities to be a danger to himself or others. Such commitments are frequently referred to simply by reference to the section number
3 Many of the psychotherapists who have examined or treated STUDENT have also expressed concern about his risky and potentially damaging sexual behavior with older males. However, the actual extent of this behavior is also unclear due to STUDENT’s inconsistent description of his involvement with older men. STUDENT has reportedly announced that he is bisexual on occasion and that he is gay on other occasions. He has told some that he had sexual experiences with three women and ten men, but has also reported that all of his sexual experiences have been with older men, as many as thirty-one, and that some of these men (five or ten of them, depending on to whom STUDENT was reporting) forcibly raped him. Medical records show that on February 5, 2004, STUDENT’s father requested an AIDS test for STUDENT due to STUDENT’s report to him of unprotected sex “last year” with a partner who may have had human immunodeficiency virus (HIV).
4 Dr. Jeremy Chiles, Ph.D., reports that STUDENT stopped using drugs two weeks before his parents had him escorted to Sage Walk and that a drug test confirmed that STUDENT was clean on admission to Sage Walk. This report is consistent with STUDENT’s report to Dr. Merz and is not disputed.
5 It is not clear why STUDENT omitted such important information from his report to Dr. Chiles. However, the parties agree that STUDENT is an unreliable source, is dishonest and manipulative, has inconsistently reported events, and admits to evaluators that he loves attention and secretly enjoys real-life drama and tragedy.
6 The information from STUDENT’s teachers and some of the information from his parents was provided in responses to a standardized survey that was one of the assessment tools.
7 Although Dr. Merz in his testimony and Student in his closing argument referred to the remaining two characteristics, these were not placed at issue for hearing and will not be adjudicated.
8 Dr. Merz used the BASC self-report in his assessment of STUDENT.
9 As stated previously, although there were references in Student’s evidence and argument to other issues, including the eligibility category of specific learning disability, only the three statutory characteristics of ED identified above were placed at issue by Student.
10 The State law uses the term “serious emotional disturbance.” (Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5 §3030(i).) Federal law avoids the pejorative connotation of the term “serious” by using the term “emotional disturbance.” (34 C.F.R. § 300.7(a).) The federal preference is followed here.
11 There was no evidence suggesting that the RIT administered by Dr. Mercer is properly considered a standardized instrument.
12 As noted by Dr. Merz in his report, a finding of a pervasive depressed mood is only one of the findings that support a diagnosis of depressive disorder under the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders - Fourth Edition (DSM-IV).
13 The doctrine of collateral estoppel applies regardless of the absence of grades on STUDENT’s transcript for the second semester of grade nine.
