California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 23, 2003
Student v. Pasadena Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 2461-02 · Hearing Officer Judith E. Ganz
Pasadena Unified denied FAPE to student with autism by not reassessing him and not implementing his behavior plan; assessments and compensatory services ordered.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted. The decision takes official notice of an earlier settlement in Case No. SN1067-99.
Summary
The mother of a 14-year-old eighth grader with autism filed for due process against Pasadena Unified School District and represented him at hearing. In spring 2002, she and Regional Center workers reported that he showed far higher academic skills at home than at school. At her urging, the IEP team moved him from a special day class into four general education classes at Wilson Middle School. A triennial reassessment never happened because she refused or withdrew consent. After an aggressive incident in October 2002, she kept him home.
Hearing Officer Judith E. Ganz found the District denied a FAPE from March 26 to October 16, 2002. The District admitted it did not know what the student could do. Even so, it deferred to the parent and never asked for a hearing to assess without consent. It also failed to carry out the behavior intervention plan in general education classes, where teachers never received the plan or training. The 2002-2003 offer, including extended school year, also denied a FAPE. It rested on unknown needs and was not a clear written offer. The request for an independent behavior assessment by a nonpublic agency was denied because the mother never disagreed with the District's assessment.
The Hearing Officer ordered a comprehensive assessment, an updated behavior assessment after the student's return, a transition plan, interim home teaching, and teacher training on the behavior plan. She also awarded up to 92.5 hours of compensatory speech therapy, social skills instruction, and tutoring.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO treated a district that relied on a parent's reports and waited for her permission instead of assessing a student whose needs were unclear. The district could have sought a hearing to assess without consent. It also shows that a behavior plan must be carried out in general education classes as well as special education settings.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedAssessment
Issue 1a. Did the District fail to provide a FAPE from March 2002 through October 16, 2002 by failing to reassess the student to identify his needs and present levels of performance so the IEP team could develop an IEP reflecting his then-current needs and abilities?
The District deferred to the parent and never sought a hearing to assess without consent despite an overdue triennial and widely conflicting reports of ability, so it never identified the student's needs; the IEP was substantively inappropriate and denied a FAPE from March 26 to October 16, 2002.
- Student prevailedImplementation
Issue 1b. Did the District fail to provide a FAPE from March 2002 through October 16, 2002 by failing to implement the behavioral intervention plan (BIP)?
General education teachers never received the BIP or training, the behavior case manager did not consult with them, and behaviors were not tracked across settings; this failure to implement denied a FAPE.
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 2. Did the District offer the student a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, including the extended school year?
Without knowing the student's needs, the District could not make an appropriate offer; the November and December 2002 IEPs were a work in progress with no clear placement, which denied the parent meaningful participation and denied a FAPE.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 3. Did the District fail to implement the behavior intervention plan, and if so, is the parent entitled to have a functional analysis assessment performed by a nonpublic agency at District expense?
No independent FAA at public expense because the parent never disagreed with the District's FAA and showed no link between the implementation failure and the FAA's adequacy; the District was still ordered to conduct the updated FAA it had promised.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4. Is the student entitled to compensatory educational services for the District's alleged past failures to provide him a FAPE from March 2002 to the present?
Because FAPE was denied for about a full school year, the student was awarded up to 35 small-group and 60 individual 30-minute speech sessions, 15 hours of social skills instruction, and 30 hours of one-to-one tutoring.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, convene an IEP meeting to develop a home-to-school transition plan, provide home teaching, and decide whether speech-language services can begin along with the student's return to school (frequency set by the IEP team).
- Order to provide or change services. Provide home teaching by a credentialed teacher under the 'February 29, 2003 IEP' until the transition plan is completed and the student returns to school. The order says February 29, 2003, a date that does not exist; it likely means the February 19, 2003 IEP.
- Order to assess. Conduct a comprehensive psychoeducational assessment within 35 calendar days (excluding school vacation over five school days). It must cover behavioral/emotional, communication and socialization, and academic needs, use assessors experienced with autism, and use a credentialed school psychologist such as Dr. Levy. Assessors may begin in the home. The parent must make the student reasonably available. The report goes to the parent within 5 business days of completion.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days after the assessments are completed, convene an IEP meeting to offer a placement based on the results, write new goals, decide how much the student participates in general education, and set up the compensatory tutoring and speech sessions.
- Order to assess. Within 15 business days after the student returns to school, a qualified assessor must begin an updated functional analysis assessment (FAA). It must be completed within 35 calendar days of the return (excluding school vacation over five school days) and include a draft BIP. The report goes to the parent within 5 business days.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days after the FAA and draft BIP are completed, convene an IEP meeting with the FAA preparer and a general education teacher (if the student is in general education) to adopt a BIP, review placement and goals, and set the social skills compensatory instruction.
- Staff training. The IEP team must set a schedule for the behavior intervention case manager to immediately train all of the student's teachers on carrying out the BIP and on collecting evaluative data (5 C.C.R. § 3001(f)).
- Compensatory education. Up to 35 thirty-minute small-group speech-language sessions (17.5 hours), 60 thirty-minute individual speech-language sessions (30 hours), 15 hours of social skills instruction, and 30 hours of one-to-one academic tutoring by a credentialed teacher, all to be completed within three years unless the parties agree otherwise in writing. The IEP team, including the parent, may reduce the hours if conditions warrant.
Total: 92.5 hours of compensatory services
Key authorities
Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Target Range School Dist.; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Burlington; Seattle School Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Larry P. v. Riles
People named in the decision
- Judy Halpern-O'Neal, program specialist and administrator; District representative at hearing, Pasadena Unified School District
- William Crosson, Regional Center service coordinator, Frank D. Lanterman Regional Center
- Joseph Hardy, communication aide and sign language specialist (in-home), Frank D. Lanterman Regional Center
- Pamela A. Mallon, teacher specialist/program specialist; prepared FAA and BIP; behavior intervention case manager, Pasadena Unified School District
- Cecilia Lopez, in-home behavioral consultant, nonpublic agency, Nonpublic agency under contract with Regional Center
- Rochelle Coombs, SH/SDC special education teacher, Wilson Middle School, Pasadena Unified School District
- Joseph Givens, speech and language teacher, Pasadena Unified School District
- Cynthia Cottier, augmentative communication assessor (independent contractor), Contractor to Pasadena Unified School District
- Darienne Gilmer, occupational therapist, Pasadena Unified School District
- Judith Barhhydt, director of special education, Pasadena Unified School District
- Dr. Beth Levy, school psychologist; District witness, Pasadena Unified School District
- Dr. Bernhardt, case coordinator listed on April 2002 triennial assessment plan, Pasadena Unified School District
- B.J. Freeman, autism expert consulted by Dr. Levy (referenced only), UCLA
- UCLA autism evaluation clinic, private psychoeducational evaluator (September 2002), UCLA
- Tobinworld, nonpublic school (prior placement, 1999-2000), Nonpublic school
- Diagnostic Center, conducted April 1999 assessment, California Diagnostic Center
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Judith E. Ganz, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Pasadena, California, on March 18-21, and 25-27, 2003.(Footnote 1)
Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented by his mother, MOTHER. Also present on behalf of Petitioner were his friends, FAMILY FRIENDS. Also present on several mornings were STUDENT and STUDENT’S COUSIN, a Regional Center worker and STUDENT’s cousin. Respondent Pasadena Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Cyndi Dalton of the law offices of Lozano Smith. Also present on behalf of the District was Judy Halpern-O’Neal, program specialist and administrator for the District.
The Petitioner called the following witnesses: William Crosson, service coordinator for the Frank D. Lanterman Regional Center; Joseph Hardy, communication aide and sign language specialist providing services at home through the Regional Center; Pamela A. Mallon, teacher specialist with the District’s special education department; Cecilia Lopez, behavioral consultant for a nonpublic agency; Rochelle Coombs, STUDENT’s teacher for his severely handicapped/special day class; Joseph Givens, District speech and language teacher; Cynthia Cottier, independent contractor for the District in the area of augmentative communication; Darienne Gilmer, District occupational therapist; Judith Barhhydt, director of special education for the District, Judy Halpern-O’Neal, program specialist for the District; STUDENT, and MOTHER.
The District put on its case by questioning the witnesses called by the Petitioner and also calling Dr. Beth Levy, school psychologist.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. After hearing the parties’ closing arguments, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
I. Petitioner’s motion to recuse Hearing Officer.
On March 21, 2003, MOTHER requested a new hearing officer. She asserted that the presiding Hearing Officer was biased. In particular, Petitioner maintained that the Hearing Officer did not take into account the alleged failure of the District to implement past settlement agreements, that the Hearing Officer requested that Petitioner describe a prospective witness’ areas of testimony before calling the witness, and that the Hearing Officer did not understand that the testimony of STUDENT’s SH/SDC classroom teacher was perjured. Finally, Petitioner complained that the purpose of the District’s settlement discussions on March 13 and 14 was to delay the proceedings so that Petitioner’s witness, Ms. Cottier, would be unavailable.
The Hearing Officer was unaware of the settlement agreements referenced by Petitioner, but found that the jurisdiction of the Hearing Officer did not include enforcement of settlement agreements. With regard to the Hearing Officer’s request that Petitioner describe prospective witnesses’ areas of testimony in advance of their testimony, the Hearing Officer made this request after Petitioner spent most of a full hearing day (from 9:30 a.m. to 6 p.m.) posing questions to STUDENT’s classroom teacher. The Hearing Officer’s request was a reasonable measure designed to assist MOTHER in focusing her questions and to enable the Hearing Officer to hear testimony relevant to the issues as framed by Petitioner. The Hearing Officer kept in mind that MOTHER is not an attorney and provided significant leeway.
On the day following the testimony of the classroom teacher, Ms. Coombs, the Hearing Officer received a letter from Ms. Coombs complaining of MOTHER’s conduct in the parking lot after the hearing. Without a time consuming investigation and/or mini-trial as to the truth of Ms. Coombs’ assertion, the Hearing Officer reminded both parties to treat all witnesses with respect both inside and outside the hearing room. The Hearing Officer observed that the tone of MOTHER’ examination of Ms. Coombs the previous day had warranted a reminder to ask questions respectfully. The Hearing Officer made no credibility assessment of the witness’ testimony based upon these events. Finally, Ms. Cottier was available to testify and was called by Petitioner as a witness. In sum, the Hearing Officer found there was an insufficient basis to support Petitioner’s allegations, and the motion to recuse the Hearing Officer was denied.
II. Petitioner’s request to impose sanctions and find the District’s attorney in contempt.
On March 17, 2003, the Hearing Officer received a request from Petitioner to impose sanctions and to hold the District’s attorney in contempt. Petitioner alleged that the District acted in bad faith by presenting Petitioner with a settlement agreement on March 14, 2003 that did not reflect the matters actually agreed upon. The District provided the Hearing Officer a written response on March 20, 2003 and asserted that it negotiated with MOTHER in good faith.(Footnote 2) Petitioner failed to present a sufficient basis to find that the District undertook bad faith actions or tactics that were frivolous or solely intended to cause unnecessary delay as defined in section 128.5 of the Cal. Code of Civil Procedure. See, Cal. Government Code §§ 11455.10-11455.30; C.C.R., tit. 5, § 3088. The request to impose sanctions or find the District’s attorney in contempt was denied.
III. Petitioner’s second “motion to impose sanctions, objection to the introduction of hearsay evidence not supported by documents regarding state of mind of ‘All IEP Team Members,’ request for judicial notice of attached laws and references, and request to strike reference to Petitioner communicating by ‘Facilitated Communication.’”
On March 25, 2003, the presiding Hearing Officer received the above-entitled motion. On March 27, 2003, the District provided a written response. Petitioner requested that the Hearing Officer “control” the responses of witnesses that were hearsay, that is “not evident and contradictory to the Documentary Evidence.” Petitioner reiterated his request to find the District’s attorney in contempt and to impose sanctions. Attached to Petitioner’s motion were annotated provisions of the California Evidence Code, (Cal. Evidence Code §§ 412, 1230, 702, 410), an “untitled” document setting forth two individuals’ (unrelated to this case) statements about teaching, a two page document relating methods of functional behavioral assessment, and 14 pages of what appeared to be daily check lists and some school work. The District responded that the basis for Petitioner’s complaints was his disagreement with the testimony, that hearsay is admissible, and that the record was replete with references to facilitated communication.
The Hearing Officer found that Petitioner was advised at the start of the hearing that the technical rules of evidence did not apply. If Petitioner disagreed with a witness’ testimony, the appropriate procedure was to present contrary documents or witnesses with a different opinion. It was not within the discretion of the Hearing Officer to prohibit a witness from using the term “facilitated communication” and the request to strike those references was unwarranted. Finally, Petitioner provided no new facts or law that merited reconsideration of his previous request to impose sanctions. Accordingly, Petitioner’s motion was denied in its entirety.
ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING(Footnote 3)
1. Did the District fail to provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from March 2002 through October 16, 2002 by:
a. failing to reassess STUDENT to identify his needs and present levels of performance to enable the individualized education program (IEP) team to develop an IEP that accurately reflected his then current needs and abilities; and b. failing to implement the behavioral intervention plan(BIP).(Footnote 4)
2. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, including the extended school year?
3. Did the District fail to implement the behavior intervention plan, and if so, is Petitioner’s mother entitled to have a functional analysis assessment performed by a nonpublic agency at the District’s expense?
4. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory educational services for the District’s alleged past failures to provide him a FAPE from March 2002 to the present?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Petitioner maintained that the District failed to provide a FAPE for STUDENT from March 2002 through October 16, 2002. Petitioner asserted that STUDENT was denied a FAPE because the District failed to accurately determine STUDENT’s present levels of performance and consequently failed to develop appropriate academic goals and objectives. Petitioner agreed with the IEP team’s determination that STUDENT should be placed in four general education classes. However, according to Petitioner, STUDENT demonstrated high level skills at IEP meetings and to Regional Center workers who worked with STUDENT at home, and the IEP goals and objectives failed to reflect these abilities. Petitioner also alleged that STUDENT was denied a FAPE because the District failed to implement the BIP. According to Petitioner, it was the lack of an adequate BIP that led STUDENT to exhibit dangerous behaviors at the start of the 2002-2003 school year and that forced Petitioner’s mother to remove him from the school setting. Petitioner seeks a new FAA conducted by a nonpublic agency that is more familiar and experienced in assessing the complex behaviors of children diagnosed with autism than are the District’s assessors. Petitioner also requests compensatory educational services.
The District maintained that it did not deny STUDENT a FAPE from March 2002 to October 16, 2002 because, although it was uncertain about STUDENT’s levels of performance, its decision to place STUDENT in four general education classes was in keeping with STUDENT’s mother’s requests. In the alternative, the District asserted that it was unable to accurately determine STUDENT’s needs and abilities because STUDENT’s mother refused to consent to its reassessment plan. The District maintained that its BIP was appropriately implemented. According to the District, Petitioner did not disagree with its FAA and accordingly he is not entitled to an independent behavioral assessment at the District’s expense.
Petitioner also asserted that the District’s offer of placement for the 2002-2003 school year did not specify whether STUDENT would be provided the functional life skills curriculum in the SH/SDC or offered classes in the general education curriculum. The District contended that its offer for the 2002-2003 school year, contained within several IEPs, was clear. The District asserted that the modifications of its offer, contained within a February 2003 IEP that provided for home teaching, was an interim offer necessitated by MOTHER’s having removed STUDENT from school. In the alternative, the District acknowledged that presently it was unable to make an offer without reassessments and although it offered an updated reassessment plan, Petitioner withdrew her consent.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a fourteen-year-old student who has received special education services since 1992 when he was three and one-half-years old as a child diagnosed with autism. STUDENT is currently enrolled at Wilson Middle School in the eighth grade, although he has not attended school since October 17, 2002. In addition to special education and related services provided by the District, STUDENT receives assistance from the Frank D. Lanterman Regional Center, including the services of a home behaviorist and a communication therapist, as well as respite care for STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER. STUDENT lives with his mother and brother within the boundaries of the District.
To appreciate the facts that led to this due process hearing, it is useful to understand the relationship of the parties. Before STUDENT transferred to Wilson Middle School, in June 2000, the District and MOTHER reached a settlement agreement where the parties agreed to hold monthly IEP meetings.(Footnote 5) According to the testimony, the intent and purpose of these meetings was for the District staff to report STUDENT’s progress as well as to effectuate improved collaboration and communication among the District staff and the Regional Center personnel. STUDENT’s teacher, Ms. Coombs, explained that in advance of these monthly meetings, she and MOTHER would confer about suitable goals and objectives for STUDENT. Based upon MOTHER’s input, Ms. Coombs drafted goals and objectives for consideration by the IEP team. (See, for example, Respondent Exhs. 78, 79.)
The record demonstrated that when the IEP team developed goals and objectives, sometimes disputes arose whether STUDENT’s present levels of performance were accurately identified. On these occasions, MOTHER would either have STUDENT demonstrate a skill to the IEP team or report through Regional Center personnel what STUDENT was capable of achieving. Although the District staff acknowledged that they were sometimes perplexed by STUDENT’s presentation, the IEP team frequently acquiesced to MOTHER’s demands and modified STUDENT’s IEP goals and objectives.
Disagreements over what STUDENT could achieve became more striking in March 2002 when STUDENT reportedly exhibited significantly more advanced accomplishments at home than he demonstrated at school. In reliance on MOTHER’s reports and acceding to her urging, in April 2002, the IEP team placed STUDENT in four general education classes. The District staff thought that STUDENT’s behaviors might improve and hoped that he would participate in the general education curriculum, but acknowledged that it remained unclear whether STUDENT would benefit academically from these classes. At the same time MOTHER approved of these classes, she complained that the goals and objectives omitted academic goals; MOTHER believed that STUDENT was capable of a higher level of academic achievement. Between April 2002 and the date of this due process hearing, two formal triennial evaluation plans were devised by the District to identify STUDENT’s needs and abilities but these were never conducted because MOTHER either refused or withdrew her consent. Despite its lack of conviction that its educational program was appropriate, the District never sought to implement either assessment plan. Although MOTHER had the UCLA autism evaluation clinic conduct a psycho-educational assessment of STUDENT in September 2002, MOTHER failed to bring the written report to the IEP team. It was against this backdrop that the parties’ attempts at settlement of the issues presented here failed and brought them to this due process hearing.
By way of background, STUDENT is a non-verbal child who communicates primarily through the use of pointing and gestures, the minimal use of sign language, occasionally with the use of assistive devices, and more recently by writing. In addition to these communication difficulties, STUDENT’s disability affects all areas of academic achievement as well as his ability to socialize. STUDENT also exhibits maladaptive behaviors, including some self-stimulatory behaviors and physical aggression that interferes with his ability to learn.
Between the ages of nine and eleven, STUDENT attended a special day class in a nonpublic school within the boundaries of the District (Tobinworld, 1999-2000 school year, including the ESY) and a special day class in a District public school (Sierra Madre Elementary School (2000-2001 school year, including the ESY) where he received special education and related services. In July 1999, the IEP team agreed that STUDENT’s curriculum should emphasize the acquisition of functional skills. (Respondent Exh. 7.)
STUDENT was transferred to Wilson Middle School at the start of the regular 2001-2002 school year where he was placed in a special day class for the severely handicapped (SH/SDC). There he received a functional life skills curriculum designed to prepare a student for life in the community and that emphasized number recognition, telling time and identifying money amounts, use of the computer, teaching of pre-vocational tasks (collating, hole punching), recognition of safety/survival words (such as “poison”), and participation in small group games to improve socialization skills with peers. An IEP dated October 8, 2001 provided that STUDENT also receive designated services in the areas of occupational therapy (OT), individual and small group speech therapy and adaptive physical education. STUDENT had a one-to-one aide who interpreted STUDENT’s use of sign language. The agreed-upon goals and objectives included finger individuation (to address STUDENT’s difficulties isolating his thumb and other digits and to assist with the motor planning needed for signing), fine motor therapy (to assist STUDENT to use adequate pressure to write), receptive and expressive language development, functional math skills, pre-vocational skills, development of quantitative concepts, recreational and leisure activities to increase social interaction, and functional reading skills. A multi-modality approach was used to increase STUDENT’s ability to communicate that included the use of an assistive device.(Footnote 6) STUDENT attended an eighth grade general education mathematics class “to observe, listen, work on his own.”
At the end of March 2002, when STUDENT was still in the seventh grade, the IEP team reported a “breakthrough”; that is, STUDENT understood that he could communicate and respond through writing. According to Ms. Cottier, who was retained by the District to conduct augmentative communication evaluations of STUDENT on several occasions, STUDENT communicated by writing with assistance in single words, phrases and sentences. STUDENT’s SH/SDC teacher, Ms. Coombs, noted in her March 2002 progress report that STUDENT was able to write many things with support, “from his name to complete sentences,” that he could solve simple, pre-kindergarten level deductive reasoning problems and that he demonstrated higher level skills than he had at the February 2002 IEP meeting. Ms. Coombs informed the team that she had presented materials to STUDENT at a sixth grade level, but that she had not yet identified his level of performance and recommended testing.
At this March IEP meeting, MOTHER demonstrated how STUDENT completed complex logical puzzles and tasks, and MOTHER reported that STUDENT exhibited “savant-like” skills at home. MOTHER added that STUDENT could read and comprehend anything, could perform mathematics functions such as addition, subtraction, division, could grasp algebra, calculus and geometry, was able to operate a computer, and understood history, maps, geography, and any kind of physics. (Petitioner Exh. 12.) His home behaviorist reported that STUDENT answered graduate record examination questions.
A member of the IEP team wrote on the March 26, 2002, consensus or individual statement form that “no one is aware of the extent of STUDENT’s capabilities which are dramatically above the level of activities presented in the past and what are available in his current classroom.” Testing of STUDENT’s higher level skills by the school psychologist was discussed and other academic opportunities were explored. (Respondent Exh. 88.) On March 27, 2002, MOTHER communicated with the District and requested a meeting with the school psychologist and “some sort of interim plan pending assessment” and reported that STUDENT no longer wanted to go to school because there was nothing for him to learn there. (Petitioner Exh. 12.)(Footnote 7) On March 29, 2002, the District responded to MOTHER’ written request for additional assessments by noting that STUDENT’s triennial evaluation was due in June 2002 and agreed that psychological and educational testing should be conducted as soon as possible. (Respondent Exh. 90.)
MOTHER removed STUDENT from school for thirteen days. (Petitioner Exh. 12.) While STUDENT was out of school, a communication reassessment was conducted by Ms. Cottier on April 7, 2002 in his home. Ms. Cottier reported that STUDENT was more social than on previous assessments and that he responded better. Ms. Cottier observed that STUDENT was able to write with minimal support to the back of his hand, arm or elbow. Ms. Cottier opined that STUDENT’s writing was not “facilitated” by another adult; that is, the responses were STUDENT’s and not those of the person providing touch to STUDENT’s hand, arm, or elbow as he formed the letters. Included in her recommendations, was the suggestion that STUDENT try more interesting academic subjects. (Respondent’s Exh. 92.)
Upon STUDENT’s return after spring break on April 22, 2002, a new class schedule was implemented that provided regular physical education and classes in the general education curriculum, including art, geometry, world history. STUDENT spent two periods in his SH/SDC class for tutorial where he also received OT and speech and language therapy. (Respondent’s Exh. 91.) Ms. Coombs testified that there were several goals and objectives in STUDENT’s functional life skills curriculum that were still unmet, but that the program was provided based upon MOTHER’ request for more mainstreaming opportunities for STUDENT. According to a progress report prepared after several days, STUDENT liked his classes.
On April 30, 2002 a triennial assessment plan was prepared but was not consented to. (Petitioner Exh. 12). According to the plan, Dr. Bernhardt was listed as the case coordinator, and testing was to be performed in the areas of academics, social/emotional/adaptive behavior, intellectual functioning, motor/perceptual development, communication (if needed) and health. On May 21, 2002, MOTHER complained that Dr. Bernhardt was not part of the IEP team and asked that the team develop the assessment plan instead. At a meeting of the IEP team on May 29, 2002, MOTHER advised the team that she would “notify the school staff when STUDENT was motivated to participate in testing, including academic skills.” (Petitioner Exh. 12.)
In May 2002, two additional goals targeted to the general education classes were added to STUDENT’s IEP. The goals were in the areas of expressive writing (write class schedule, copy three key concepts from the regular education classes) and behavior (open book to the appropriate page, arrive on time and remain in class until dismissed). Ms. Coombs showed the general education teachers STUDENT’s IEP, but the teachers were not provided with copies of his IEPs. At the May 29, 2002 IEP team meeting, it was reported that STUDENT had made progress; he was waiting his turn, behaving on the school bus, demonstrating more independence, was shaking people’s hands and making eye contact. Another IEP team meeting was held on June 18, 2002 where it was agreed that STUDENT would attend a general education class and the previous goals and objectives would remain through the extended school year summer program. (Respondent Exh. 102.) According to the District, the June 18, 2002 was the last signed document regarding STUDENT’s educational needs. (Respondent Exh. 110.)(Footnote 8)
Adding to STUDENT’s academic difficulties were STUDENT’s maladpative behaviors that interfered with his ability to learn. As early as 1992, STUDENT refused to comply with requests and threw tantrums when asked to perform new or different tasks or when there was a change in routine. (Respondent Exh. 79.) In 1999, while STUDENT was at Tobinworld, he exhibited similar behaviors with increased frequency. When he became physically aggressive, the IEP team determined intervention was required and behavioral goals were added to his IEP. (Respondent Exh. 11.) At Sierra Madre Elementary School, in October 2000, a functional assessment of behavior was performed and a positive behavior support plan (PBSP) was developed by Ms. Mallon, the District’s program specialist. At that time, STUDENT’s behaviors included grabbing others and removing his shoes outside of the classroom. The team agreed to keep a daily log of STUDENT’s behaviors. Strategies to reduce the maladaptive behaviors included the use of “social stories” (stories that identified normative behaviors in certain situations), the squeezing of a soft ball that provided sensory input, and the use of crisis intervention techniques as a last resort in case STUDENT grabbed others in a manner that could result in serious harm or injury. (Respondent Exh. 45.) The PBSP followed STUDENT to Wilson Middle School and was part of his October 2001 IEP.
In November 2001, at the end of a school day, STUDENT refused to get ready for the bus, screamed, cried, kicked, ran to another classroom area, pushed furniture, became increasingly aggressive toward school staff and was eased into a prone position on the floor until he calmed. (Petitioner Exh. 7; Respondent Exh. 73.) This episode was similar to, but more severe than the behaviors STUDENT had historically displayed that had included frequent bouts of screaming, tantrums, spitting, kicking and scratching, and refusing tasks. Based upon this episode, the IEP team determined that the PBSP was ineffective. (Respondent Exh. 73). MOTHER approved a behavioral assessment. (Respondent Exhs. 70, 71). On February 13, 2002, Ms. Mallon completed an FAA and report. (Petitioner Exh. 7.) The report concluded that STUDENT’s grabbing behaviors were a way for him to avoid new requests or demands made of him. Observations of STUDENT at school revealed that he became increasingly noncompliant in order to avoid completion of tasks. The IEP team agreed that a BIP was necessary and adopted Ms. Mallon’s BIP, dated March 6, 2002. (Respondent Exh. 83.) The target behaviors were listed as noncompliance (with physical aggression) and noncompliance (refusing a task).
The BIP provided that replacement behaviors would be taught by the teaching staff using discrete trial training strategies. According to the BIP, the staff would use praise and limited time on preferred tasks as positive consequences for not grabbing and performing a requested task. If STUDENT did not comply, then no time would be allotted for preferred tasks and privileges and/or tokens would be lost. The staff would use crisis prevention intervention strategies to lower STUDENT’s anxiety before he became more physically aggressive. Both targeted behaviors of refusing a task and grabbing would be tracked on a daily basis. Antecedent behaviors were identified as STUDENT’s making noises or tapping, getting out of his seat, leaving an assigned area, and unscheduled requests for sensory integration, restroom, food and drink. STUDENT’s general education class teachers were not provided with a copy of STUDENT’s BIP.
The next IEP team meeting was held on September 10, 2002 at the start of the 2002-2003 school year. STUDENT continued to attend classes in the general education curriculum. No changes were recommended for the instructional objectives except that additional goals in OT were added to teach STUDENT to use a keyboard. That morning, STUDENT had been evaluated at the UCLA autism evaluation clinic. MOTHER reported to the team that STUDENT resisted the assessment.(Footnote 9) The team agreed that the STUDENT’s functional analysis would be updated. (Respondent Exh. 109.) In October 2002, STUDENT was physically aggressive toward his general education art teacher in a manner that frightened her.
After this episode, the District proposed an interim behavior plan. If STUDENT demonstrated out-of-seat behavior or out-of-context laughing, or invaded personal space, his one-to-one aide would remove him from his general education class and return him to his SH/SDC class. MOTHER kept STUDENT home from school starting on October 17, 2002. (Petitioner Exh. 12.) Shortly thereafter, on October 28, 2002, MOTHER filed a request for a due process hearing. MOTHER indicated that she kept STUDENT home to avoid the risk of continued escalation and because she disagreed with the District’s “punitive” approach of removing STUDENT from general education classes if he exhibited maladaptive behaviors.
In November and December 2002, as well as in February 2003, the IEP team met in an attempt to offer a program for the 2002-2003 school year. STUDENT did not return to school. After several unsuccessful formal and informal attempts at settlement, the due process hearing convened on March 18, 2002.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Did the District fail to provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from March 2002 through October 16, 2002 by (a) failing to reassess STUDENT to identify his needs and present levels of performance to enable the individualized education program (IEP) team to develop an IEP that accurately reflected his then current needs and abilities; and (b) failing to implement the behavioral intervention plan(BIP)?
Under both the State special education law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), all students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE) that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs and prepares them for employment and independent living. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A); Cal. Education Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the students at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the students’ individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that to receive a FAPE, the student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit to satisfy the IDEA, but that the school district is not required to provide the student with the best education available or instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. Id., at 198-200. The Court held that a school district is required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id., at 201. Consequently, an appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the student. Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996); Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1994, 1524 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied 513 U.S. 969 (1994). Moreover, the focus of the inquiry is not on whether the student may obtain greater benefit in the placement that is preferred by the parents, but rather, whether the school district’s proposed placement is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the student. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).
Under the IDEA and Rowley, the analysis whether a student has been provided with a FAPE requires the Hearing Officer to consider whether an educational program was designed to meet the student’s unique educational needs and prepare the student for employment and independent living, was reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit and comported with his IEP. The school district has the burden of proving at the administrative hearing that it complied with the IDEA. Clyde v. Puyallup Sch. Dist. No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994).
What were STUDENT’s unique needs?
There was no dispute that STUDENT’s autism affected his academic performance as well as his ability to manage his behaviors and to communicate. Beginning in March 2002, however, there were widely divergent views about what STUDENT was capable of achieving academically.
Petitioner contended that STUDENT’s IEP, developed in April 2002, was inappropriate because it failed to reflect what she perceived as STUDENT’s needs and strengths. On the other hand, although the District acknowledged that it did not know what STUDENT was capable of achieving and suggested that it was highly skeptical that STUDENT’s needs and strengths measured up to MOTHER’s appraisal, it placed STUDENT in four general education classes. MOTHER agreed with the IEP team’s decision to place STUDENT in four general education classes but at the same time she maintained that STUDENT should have been provided with instructional goals commensurate with his high achievement level.
By raising the purported failure of the District to develop a suitable educational program and criticizing the District for not depending upon her reports of STUDENT’s levels of performance and academic needs, Petitioner placed the District’s failure to identify or assess STUDENT’s needs squarely at issue. At the heart of the dispute in this case is whether the District understood STUDENT’s needs and developed an IEP that reflected those needs.
STUDENT’s academic needs.
Perhaps the greatest debate in this matter centered around how STUDENT’s autism affected his academic needs. There was a marked disparity between the opinion of the District’s staff, on the one hand, and those of MOTHER and the Regional Center personnel on the other, regarding STUDENT’s academic needs and strengths.
The District’s staff testified that STUDENT was prompt-dependent and, like other autistic children, rarely initiated a task. Ms. Coombs testified that she found it difficult to know what STUDENT knew. According to Ms. Coombs, STUDENT could solve some pre-kindergarten to first grade logic problems and, while STUDENT could recognize a few words, she was not certain whether STUDENT could read or was simply looking at the pictures. Ms. Coombs testified that she was unconvinced by STUDENT’s performances at the IEP meetings and that she believed these demonstrations were a “one shot deal.”
In contrast, those working with STUDENT at home provided anecdotal reports of STUDENT’s “savant-like” behaviors, as well as his ability to solve high-level logic problems and to complete graduate record examination questions. Ms. Lopez, STUDENT’s home behaviorist, testified that on one occasion, STUDENT chose a Scrabble game. Ms. Lopez provided STUDENT with the game instructions that he appeared to read. After a few minutes, as the game rules provided, STUDENT selected seven tiles, knew how to choose who went first, and was able to form words, although he took a very long time to do so.(Footnote 10) MOTHER reported that STUDENT was capable of physics and high level mathematics. According to MOTHER, “I have never assumed STUDENT does NOT understand or know how to do anything he is not doing anymore but think of the problem as one of EXPRESSION...” (Respondent Exh. 102; 7/9/02 fax from MOTHER to District staff; emphasis in original.)
Believing that STUDENT could master an academic curriculum, MOTHER requested that STUDENT be provided general education classes with instructional goals suited to the ability level he had displayed at home. In April 2002, in response to MOTHER’s having withdrawn STUDENT from school for several days and upon her report that STUDENT was “bored” at school, the IEP team agreed to add four general education classes to STUDENT’s schedule with two periods for tutorial in his SH/SDC class. Ms. Halpern-O’Neal and Ms. Mallon testified, however, that although the IEP team had acquiesced to MOTHER’s demands and placed STUDENT in four general education classes, they actually believed that STUDENT could obtain greater educational benefit from the functional life skills curriculum.
As the Hearing Officer has already observed, despite the District’s acknowledgment that it was perplexed by the differences in STUDENT’s performance, not only did it make the program change as just described, it also acquiesced to MOTHER and took no steps to assess STUDENT. (Footnote 11) While input from a student’s parent is part of a comprehensive assessment, it should not be the sole determinant whether or to what extent additional assessments are required. See, 20 U.S.C. §1414(c); Cal. Education Code § 56381(b). Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that in order to determine the appropriate educational program designed to meet STUDENT’s needs, the District should have taken steps to implement its assessment plan and to override MOTHER’s lack of consent for several reasons. First, the triennial evaluation was due and the need for its implementation was especially pressing, in part because the previous evaluation conducted in April 1999 had been the subject of some dispute among the IEP team. STUDENT was assessed in April 1999 by the Diagnostic Center. There was some disagreement with the results, including the IEP team’s indication that the results underestimated STUDENT’s pre-academic skill level. What had perplexed the IEP team in 1999 was only more confounding in April 2002. See, Cal. Education Code § 56381 (a).(Footnote 12) Second, as already discussed, there were widely competing reports of STUDENT’s cognitive abilities. Next, the District conceded at the same time that it was skeptical of STUDENT’s achievements described by MOTHER and the Regional Center personnel, it remained uncertain what STUDENT could achieve. Finally, the IDEA and State special education law contemplate that a local educational agency will seek a due process hearing in order to implement its assessment plan and override a parent’s lack of consent. See, Cal. Education Code § 56501(a)(3). The Hearing Officer finds that there was more than enough justification for the District to do so here.
Absent such an assessment, or other expert evaluation, the Hearing Officer finds that this record lacks dependable measures from which to draw conclusions about STUDENT’s present levels of performance and educational needs and utterly lacks any basis by which to reconcile the widely competing views of STUDENT’s needs and strengths. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer shall order the District to have a comprehensive assessment conducted by qualified assessors to assist the IEP team to determine STUDENT’s educational needs. The evaluation shall be sufficiently comprehensive to identify all of STUDENT’s special education and related services needs. At a minimum, the testing shall fully assess STUDENT in his known areas of need, that address his behavioral and emotional needs, including addressing his anxiety and lack of motivation; his communicative and socialization needs, including his ability to write, type or use a keyboard; and his academic needs that include identification of his present levels of performance and his ability to be involved in or progress in the general education curriculum. Attention shall be paid to STUDENT’s resistant behaviors and efforts will be made and strategies developed, if necessary, to use a variety of assessment tools at the discretion of the assessors. Test instruments shall be selected to assess the relative contribution of cognitive and behavioral factors to STUDENT’s need for services. 34 C.F.R. § 300.532(i).(Footnote 13)
The District shall select assessors who have experience with children diagnosed with autism and with difficult to assess children. A credentialed school psychologist, such as Dr. Levy, shall conduct the psychological assessment. Observations and data shall be gathered from Regional Center personnel, STUDENT’s teachers, and other adults who know STUDENT and shall include information about STUDENT’s daily living skills and functioning at home and in the community. The assessment shall also include input from MOTHER. The assessments shall in all respects conform with the IDEA and State special education law. See, Cal. Education Code § 56320; § 56322; § 56324; 34 C.F.R. § 300.532; § 300.533; § 300.536.
In addition, an assessment report shall be prepared in accordance with the requirements set forth in California Education Code section 56327 and STUDENT’s parent shall be provided a copy in a reasonable time before the next scheduled IEP as will be set forth in the Order.
STUDENT’s behavioral needs.
Similarly, although there was no dispute that STUDENT had unique behavioral needs that interfered with his ability to learn, the IEP team agreed in September 2002, that it did not fairly comprehend the complexity of STUDENT’s behaviors and agreed to conduct an updated FAA. The record established that STUDENT had developed sophisticated behavioral mechanisms that stymied the District staff and the Regional Center personnel. The complexity of STUDENT’s presentation was noted in the UCLA autism clinic evaluation. The report stated “it is not uncommon for STUDENT’s presentation to puzzle providers unfamiliar with the range of expression for Autistic Disorder.” (Petitioner Exh. 11.) The report explained children diagnosed with autism experience delays in social abilities so that the school setting, which involved more social demands, might lead to more disorganized behaviors and distress. Indeed, STUDENT testified at the due process hearing, by writing with the pressure of a pencil applied to the back of his hand by MOTHER, that when he felt anxious, he sometimes laughed when he felt sad and said “yes” when he meant “no.”
Adding further to the ambiguity surrounding STUDENT’s behavioral needs, was MOTHER’s assertion that some of the discrepancy about what STUDENT could achieve academically was a function of STUDENT’s behaviors. According to MOTHER it was STUDENT’s refusal, rather than his inability, that kept him from performing the work. (Respondent Exh. 106; 10/7/02 fax correspondence from MOTHER. MOTHER wrote “what is so frustrating is he definitely can do all the work, but [he] has developed such complex avoidance behaviors from years of doing almost nothing, that unless we can manage this behavior ‘education’ will be impossible.”) In like manner, the District was uncertain whether STUDENT failed to perform assignments in the general education classes because he was not interested or because he was incapable of doing so. According to Ms. Coombs’ progress report in May 2002, “it seems as if [STUDENT’s] reluctance/resistance is directly related to the imposed higher expectations at school.”
The Hearing Officer finds convincing the testimony of all the District staff and Regional Center personnel that STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors continue to interfere with his ability to learn, but that because these behaviors have worsened and become more sophisticated and complex, STUDENT’s behavioral needs remain unclear. The Hearing Officer finds that, as with the other disputes concerning STUDENT’s needs, it is not possible to identify STUDENT’s unique behavioral needs without a new behavioral assessment. Accordingly, as discussed in Issue No. 3 below, the Hearing Officer will order that the promised updated FAA shall be performed in order to identify STUDENT’s unique behavioral needs.
STUDENT’s communication needs.
STUDENT had unique needs in the area of communication. STUDENT was non-verbal and, up until the time period at issue during this hearing, had primarily communicated using gestures, some sign language, and the occasional use of assistive devices. The record demonstrated that in March 2002, however, the IEP team agreed that STUDENT had a “breakthrough.” According to Ms. Cottier and MOTHER, STUDENT recognized his own ability to participate and respond and he understood that he could communicate through writing. MOTHER testified that STUDENT could write independently and that if he did not do so in school, it was because STUDENT refused to perform. Even though STUDENT’s teacher and occupational therapist, who worked with STUDENT on writing, never observed STUDENT write on his own, the record demonstrated that the District staff offered no challenge to the conclusion that STUDENT had experienced a “breakthrough” at the time. Members of the IEP team testified, however, that they questioned whether STUDENT was writing on his own, or needed pressure applied to the back of his hand, arm or elbow, or whether STUDENT’s writing was unintentionally “facilitated” by the adult guiding his hand.(Footnote 14) In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that, while STUDENT demonstrated improvement in this area, STUDENT’s communication needs and strengths were not clearly perceived.
Was the placement designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit?
There was little direct evidence or testimony whether STUDENT made progress while this IEP was implemented from April 2002 through October 2002. Ms. Coombs testified that generally, STUDENT did not really “do anything” in these classes. STUDENT, on the other hand, testified that he liked his geometry class, but did not care for either his history or art teacher, because his history teacher made him write, and because his art teacher did not like his art work. In May 2002, the District reported that STUDENT did not respond in his general education classes in writing or by signing. The evidence demonstrated that a goal that required STUDENT to write three key concepts from each of the general education classes was not met.
Nevertheless, the Hearing Officer is unable to determine whether the placement was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs or calculated to provide him with educational benefit because, as just discussed above, STUDENT’s needs have yet to be identified.
Did the placement comport with STUDENT’s IEP?
As just discussed the Hearing Officer has found that the IEP was not substantively appropriate because it was not based upon an assessment of STUDENT’s unique needs. Consequently, whether the placement comported with STUDENT’s IEP is not material to this Decision. Nevertheless, Petitioner has raised the additional allegation that the District failed to implement the BIP as part of the IEP. The Hearing Officer will address this question because the implementation of the BIP was an essential component of STUDENT’s educational program, no matter what the setting. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the IEP team’s determination that the key to STUDENT’s participation was the management of his behavior.(Footnote 15)
The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to implement the BIP across all school environments as required. See, C.C.R, tit. 5 § 3001(d); § 3052(a)(6). Despite STUDENT’s undisputed need for consistency, and even though STUDENT spent a significant part of his school day in his four general education classes, the evidence established that STUDENT’s general education teachers were not provided with STUDENT’s BIP. In fact, Ms. Halpern-O’Neal testified that it was not the District’s practice to provide the BIP to the general education teachers. Ms. Mallon testified that she left the implementation of STUDENT’s BIP to his SH/SDC teacher. Notably, however, Ms. Coombs never showed STUDENT’s general education teachers the BIP. Ms. Mallon, as the behavior intervention case manager (BICM), was obligated to consult with staff members and parents in order to effectively implement the plan, which she failed to do. See, C.C.R., tit. 5, § 3001(f). The Hearing Officer finds that the failure of the BICM to consult with the general education staff or to review the contents of the BIP with them, or ensure that Ms. Coombs provided the general education staff with the proper information, failed to comport with STUDENT’s IEP.
The BIP was drafted and adopted by the IEP team before STUDENT was placed in his general education classes and was written under the assumption that the District staff implementing the BIP were trained in discrete trial training as well as crisis intervention strategies. There was no evidence that the general education teachers were provided with any such training and it was not surprising that the October 2002 episode occurred in that setting. Moreover, the evidence showed that if STUDENT engaged in targeted behaviors, he was removed from his general education classroom and returned to the SH/SDC classroom. There was no evidence that other than this punitive approach, the general education teachers either knew about, knew how to, or attempted to teach replacement behaviors.
The Hearing Officer finds that the BIP was a critical component of STUDENT’s IEP and that the strategies set out in the BIP were not systematically implemented across all school environments. The Hearing Officer further finds that STUDENT’s behaviors were not adequately tracked, nor were the BIP’s strategies evaluated. Consequently, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s failure to implement the BIP denied STUDENT a FAPE.
* * * * In sum, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE from March 26, 2002 to October 16, 2002. The District failed to identify STUDENT’s unique needs because it abdicated its responsibilities and obligations to STUDENT to accurately assess his needs and strengths. In addition to the IEP being substantively inappropriate, the District failed to provide STUDENT with a program that comported with his IEP because it failed to implement his BIP. Absent a comprehensive assessment, including the promised FAA, the District was unable to assess STUDENT’s needs and strengths and was unable to design a program that was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer will order that the District shall conduct a comprehensive assessment that shall include a new FAA.
ISSUE NO. 2: Has the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, including the extended school year?
The problems just described that pervaded the 2001-2002 school year, namely the failure to identify STUDENT’s unique needs, plagued the District’s ability to offer a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, including the ESY. The evidence clearly demonstrated a student whose abilities had stymied all who worked with him, and there was no way to know what STUDENT was capable of, why he resisted performing and what measures could be attempted so that his behaviors did not impede him from taking advantage of his educational program. Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds that the failures outlined in Issue No. 1 made it virtually impossible for the District to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, and that it failed to do so. Indeed, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has all but conceded in its most recent placement offer contained within the IEP of February 2003, that without implementation of an assessment plan that it devised on February 19, 2003, it is unable to offer an appropriate placement. (See, Respondent Exh. 113; IEP dated February 19, 2003.) The Hearing Officer does not find convincing the position taken by the District at hearing, that this request for reassessment in order to offer STUDENT a placement was necessitated only because STUDENT was kept at home since October 2002. As discussed in Issue No. 1 above, the Hearing Officer has found that the District failed to identify STUDENT’s unique needs from March 2002 to the present.
The District contended that its offer of placement was contained within two IEPs dated November 27, 2002 and December 10, 2002. (Petitioner Exh. 15.) The Hearing Officer finds that these IEPs were a work in progress. The IEPs included instruction in the SH/SDC class and the provision of designated instructional services in OT, speech (small group and individual) and a one-to-one signing aide. Although some of the proposed goals and objectives were directed towards general education classes, missing was a clear statement whether STUDENT would return to his SH/SDC classroom or participate in the general education curriculum. In addition, the IEP provided that whether the promised updated FAA would be conducted was deferred to mediation. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that whether a BIP would be implemented into STUDENT’s educational program remained indefinite. At the December meeting, the IEP team agreed that OT services would be discontinued, leaving uncertain who would teach STUDENT to type or use a keyboard. (Respondent Exh. 109.) Finally, the IEP included the equivocal statement that the “team agrees that STUDENT should return to Wilson but we are not sure of what supports to put in place to support his transition back,” and “the next step is determining the setting and the steps over returning.” Not only was a transition plan never devised, the Hearing Officer finds these statements reflected the uncertainty of the IEP team. Because the District staff was unable to settle on an appropriate placement, it did not meet its obligation to demonstrate to MOTHER that the District had carefully thought through and selected a placement that, in its professional judgment, would meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure amounted to a denial of FAPE. Among the procedural violations that constitute a denial of FAPE is the failure a school district to make a formal, written offer of placement in compliance with the IDEA’s procedural requirements. Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994). To result in the denial of FAPE, a procedural violation must seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process or result in the loss of educational opportunity. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992). Here, MOTHER was denied meaningful participation in the IEP process because the District failed to produce a written, specific offer of placement that MOTHER could seriously consider for the 2002-2003 school year.
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to identify STUDENT’s unique needs as discussed in Issue No. 1 prevented it from making a placement offer based upon his unique needs. Alternatively, the District failed to make a clear, coherent offer, and for both these reasons failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, including the ESY.
ISSUE NO. 3: If the District failed to implement an appropriate behavioral intervention plan, is STUDENT entitled to have a functional analysis assessment performed by a nonpublic agency at the District’s expense?
California Education Code section 56329(b) provides that a parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation from a qualified specialist at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment conducted by the educational agency. However, if the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent evaluation. Id; see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b). Petitioner seeks to obtain an FAA conducted by an independent agency asserting that the BIP was inappropriately implemented.
The Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner is not entitled to obtain an independent FAA at the District’s expense for two reasons. First, Petitioner did not disagree with the FAA that was conducted by the District. By failing to contest the adequacy of the FAA, the statute’s threshold requirement that Petitioner assert a disagreement with the District’s assessment was not satisfied. Second, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner failed to establish a nexus between the District’s failure to implement the BIP and the adequacy of the District’s FAA. Accordingly, Petitioner’s request for an independent FAA at the District’s expense is denied.
However, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP team in September 2002, agreed that an updated FAA should be performed. Indeed, the District started to collect additional data and only stopped because STUDENT was removed from school, not because there was a determination that an FAA was unnecessary. Because of the District’s promise, as well as the undisputed evidence that STUDENT continued to exhibit serious and maladaptive behaviors that interfered with his ability to learn, the Hearing Officer will order that the District shall conduct an FAA as part of the comprehensive assessment discussed in Issue No. 1.
In reaching this conclusion, the Hearing Officer disagrees with Petitioner’s unsupported assertion that an FAA should precede other testing in order for the assessor to determine how to take account of STUDENT’s performance anxiety and resistance to test-taking. The Hearing Officer finds convincing Dr. Levy’s opinion that an FAA could be part of a comprehensive psycho-educational assessment with collaboration of the professional assessors. Dr. Levy’s credentials as a school psychologist and experience with autistic children, albeit younger than STUDENT, support giving her opinion significant weight. Although Dr. Levy was not an expert in behavioral analysis, she had extensive training and experience in assessments and assessing difficult to examine children.(Footnote 16) The Hearing Officer is persuaded by Dr. Levy’s testimony that well-trained professional assessors would develop appropriate strategies and select assessment tools to take account of STUDENT’s anxiety and resistance.
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that the District shall conduct a new FAA as part of the comprehensive assessment the Hearing Officer found necessary in Issue No. 1.(Footnote 17) The Hearing Officer is mindful that STUDENT has not been in school since October 2002 and is aware of the evidence and documents that reflect STUDENT’s distress and anxiety when routines are changed. In addition, according to MOTHER, STUDENT has recently been identified as suffering from anxiety disorder. Consequently, the IEP team will be ordered to develop a transition plan to smooth STUDENT’s return to school before it conducts the new FAA.
ISSUE NO. 4 Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory educational services for the District’s alleged past failures to provide him a FAPE?
When a school district denies a special education student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. In addition, equitable considerations may be weighed in granting relief and courts have broad discretion to fashion a remedy which helps a student to overcome lost educational opportunity. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 358 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the petitioner is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA” Puyallup, 31 F.3d at 1497.
Petitioner maintains that STUDENT is entitled to speech and language therapy, social skills instruction after school and at home, and academic tutoring to make up for “whatever instruction he missed” in mathematics, basic reading and writing, as a result of the failure of the District to provide him a FAPE.(Footnote 18)
The Hearing Officer concluded above that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE from March 26, 2002 to the present. The specific failures of the District resulted in a loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT, because among other things the District failed to identify his unique needs and failed to implement consistent strategies to address the behaviors that interfered with STUDENT’s ability to participate in the school setting. In other words, the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for a period corresponding to approximately one full school year and STUDENT is entitled to compensatory education to redress this failure.
Determining a precise amount of compensatory educational services always involves a difficult appraisal of where the child might have been had he been appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA and what services are required to redress the failure to appropriately educate him. There should be a nexus between the compensatory education award and the specific loss of opportunity suffered by the child. In this case, the precise harm that such a deprivation of educational programming caused to STUDENT is especially difficult to measure, where as here, STUDENT’s capabilities have yet to be assessed.
However, given the totality of the circumstances in this case, and taking account of the length of the deprivation and loss of educational opportunity, the Hearing Officer finds that the following services are reasonably calculated to enable STUDENT to progress in his known areas of need:
Speech and language therapy sessions.
STUDENT received thirty minutes of small group speech therapy once a week and thirty minutes of individual speech therapy twice a week as a designated instructional service as part of his educational program. Theoretically, for the one year that STUDENT was denied a FAPE, he was deprived of approximately 50 thirty-minute small group sessions and 100 individual sessions. Taking account of the totality of the circumstances, such as STUDENT’s undisputed need for speech and language services and the likely event that he will be provided with such services upon his return to school, as well as the fact that he received speech and language therapy sessions from April 2002 through October 2002, and mindful that there is no obligation to award one hour for every hour missed, the Hearing Officer finds that a maximum of 35 thirty-minute speech and language therapy small group sessions and a maximum of 60 thirty-minute individual sessions is reasonably calculated to enable STUDENT to progress if the designated service had been provided.
Social skills instruction.
Although Petitioner indicated that he sought social skills instruction, his request for these services was unaccompanied by any further description. However, the Hearing Officer is convinced that this student has deficits in the area of socialization. The Regional Center staff testified that STUDENT is afraid of strangers he meets in the community, and Ms. Coombs testified that STUDENT resists playing games with small groups of peers in his SH/SDC class. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT should receive a maximum of fifteen hours of social skills instruction to address these deficits. After the comprehensive assessment, including the FAA, reveals STUDENT’s needs, the IEP team shall determine what instruction best addresses these deficits.
Academic tutoring.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT should receive up to a maximum of thirty hours of one-to-one academic instruction by a credentialed teacher to address STUDENT’s academic deficits. The IEP team shall determine whether this instruction will be in academics from the general education curriculum in STUDENT’s areas of interest, or will be in the functional life skills curriculum. This determination shall be made after the assessment reveals STUDENT’s needs.
The District shall complete all the compensatory educational services no later than three years from the date of this Decision, unless the parties agree in writing otherwise. The District shall implement the compensatory education services in a manner that ensures they have minimal impact on STUDENT’s school day and ability to participate in the education program. If conditions warrant, at the discretion of the IEP team, including MOTHER, the numbers of hours of these compensatory educational services may be reduced.
ORDER
1. Within 15 calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting in order a. To develop a transition plan to assist STUDENT in his transition from home to school;
b. To provide home teaching by a credentialed teacher in accordance with the February 29, 2003 IEP until the transition plan is completed and STUDENT is returned to school;
c. To determine if the speech and language services can begin in coordination with STUDENT’s transition back to school. The IEP team will determine the frequency of this instruction.
2. The District shall conduct a comprehensive psycho-educational assessment in conformance with this Decision and in compliance with the IDEA and State special education law. This comprehensive psycho-educational assessment shall be completed within 35 calendar days (excluding days of school vacation in excess of five schooldays) from the date of this Decision. The assessor(s) shall determine the location of the assessment(s), and, in the discretion of the assessor(s), the assessment(s) may begin in STUDENT’s home.
3. STUDENT’s mother shall make him reasonably available for the assessments outlined in Order 2.
4. The District shall provide a copy the written assessment report(s) to STUDENT’s mother within five business days from the completion of the assessment report(s).
5. Within 15 calendar days from the date the assessments were completed, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting to:
a. offer an appropriate educational placement in accordance with the assessment results and the identification of STUDENT’s present levels of performance, needs and strengths; develop new goals and objectives; and determine the extent to which STUDENT shall participate in the general education curriculum;
b. determine the specific areas of academic deficits to be addressed by the one-to-one academic tutoring awarded as compensatory education, as well as the frequency and duration of that instruction; and, c. determine how to incorporate the academic tutoring and the additional hours of individual and small-group speech and language therapy into STUDENT’s existing educational program.
6. Within 15 business days from the date STUDENT returns to school, the District shall have a qualified assessor in accordance with the requirements of the Cal. Code of Regulations begin to conduct an updated FAA. The updated FAA shall be completed no later than 35 calendar days (excluding days of school vacation in excess of five schooldays) after STUDENT has returned to school. The FAA shall include a draft BIP.
7. The District shall provide a copy of the updated FAA report and draft BIP to STUDENT’s mother within five business days from the date the report is completed.
8. Within 15 calendar days from the completion of the FAA report and draft BIP, the District shall convene an IEP meeting that shall be certain to include, in addition to the team members, a general education teacher (if STUDENT participates in the general education curriculum in accordance with Order No. 3) and the preparer of the FAA report. The IEP team shall:
a. address the findings and results of the FAA and determine the appropriate BIP;
b. address STUDENT’s placement needs in light of the new information gathered from the FAA;
c. determine if any additional program changes need to be made or goals and objectives need to be modified as a result of the findings of the FAA;
d. devise a schedule for the BICM to immediately provide the requisite input and training to all STUDENT’s teachers how to appropriately implement the BIP and how to collect and maintain evaluative data in accordance with C.C.R., tit. 5, § 3001(f); and, e. determine the specific areas of social skills instruction to be addressed, as awarded as compensatory education, as well as the frequency, duration, and location of that instruction.
9. To redress its failure to provide STUDENT with a FAPE from March 2002 to the present, the District shall provide as compensatory educational services a maximum of: (1) thirty-five thirty-minute speech and language therapy small group sessions; (2) sixty thirty-minute individual speech and language therapy sessions; (3) fifteen hours of social skills instruction; and (4) thirty hours of one-to-one academic tutoring, to be completed no later than three years from the date of this Decision, unless the parties agree in writing otherwise. The District shall implement these compensatory educational services in a manner that ensures they have minimal impact on STUDENT’s school day and ability to participate in the education program. The IEP team, including MOTHER, may in its discretion reduce the number of hours of compensatory education if conditions so warrant.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to Cal. Education Code section 56507(d) , the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
1. Did the District fail to provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from March 2002 through October 16, 2002?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
2. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, including the extended school year?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
3. Did the District fail to implement the behavior intervention plan, and if so, is Petitioner’s mother entitled to have a functional analysis assessment performed by a nonpublic agency at the District’s expense?
The District prevailed on this issue to the extent that Petitioner is not entitled to an independent behavioral assessment at the District’s expense. However, the District shall have a qualified assessor conduct an updated FAA as part of the comprehensive assessment set out in the Order.
4. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory educational services for the District’s alleged past failures to provide him a FAPE from March 2002 to the present?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal. Education Code section 56505(i).
DATED: April 23, 2003 _________________________________ Judith E. Ganz, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. On March 4, 2003, outside the presence of a different presiding hearing officer, the parties engaged in settlement discussions. On that date, at the request of the parties, the matter was continued until March 13, 2003. On March 13 and 14, outside the presence of the Hearing Officer and before any evidence was taken or documents received, the parties attempted to reach a settlement agreement, but they were unsuccessful. No testimony was taken or evidence received until March 18, 2003. 2. Attached to the District’s response was an interim settlement agreement that was the subject of the negotiations on March 13 and 14, 2003. The Hearing Officer did not read the attachment, other than its title, and removed the pages from the District’s response and returned them to the District’s attorney. 3. The issues listed here were modified for the purposes of clarification and appropriate analysis. 4. During a prehearing conference and at the start of the due process hearing, Petitioner asserted two additional violations that he claimed denied him a FAPE. Although Petitioner contended that the District failed to provide an appropriate one-to-one aide and that the District failed to develop a transition plan to help STUDENT adjust to placement in the general education classes in April 2002, there was no testimony or evidence presented in support of these allegations. Consequently, this Decision will not address these matters. 5. The Hearing Officer took official notice of the Memorandum of Settlement Agreement and Dismissal in Case No. SN1067-99 at Petitioner’s request. 6. STUDENT tried various devices that assisted him to communicate, from the Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS) that used picture icons that STUDENT could point to, to devices where he would point to a picture icon that produced a computer generated voice response. 7. In a letter sent to the District, Petitioner referenced a request she had made three weeks earlier for formal assessments. (Petitioner Exh. 12 (letter dated 3/27/02).) The record showed that in February 2002, MOTHER asked that speech and language assessments be performed. (Respondent Exh. 80.) 8. No progress reports or other records from the extended school year program were made available, since according to the District witnesses, these documents had been packed in boxes when the school rooms were painted and apparently lost. 9. The UCLA autism evaluation clinic prepared a report that, according to District witnesses, was not shown to District staff until it was made part of the documents accepted during the course of this due process hearing. (Petitioner Exh. 11.) STUDENT was referred to UCLA for testing by the Regional Center. Standardized tests were administered, but it was noted that STUDENT was very resistant to testing and compliance was “extremely erratic.” The UCLA clinic attempted to administer the Stanford-Binet-Fourth Edition and the assessor obtained some age equivalency scores in the areas of verbal reasoning (comprehension: 2 years, 7 months; absurdities: 2 years, 9 months), abstract visual reasoning (pattern analysis: 3 years, 4 months; copying: 2 years, 3 months) and short-term memory (bead memory: 3 years, 2 months). Other subtests were attempted, but no scores were reported. The Hearing Officer observes that the administration of standardized intelligence tests to an African-American student by a local education agency has been banned. See, California Department of Education, Larry P.[Larry P. v. Riles, 37 F.3d 485 (9th Cir. 1995)] Legal Advisory, 10/11/94. The Hearing Officer did not consider these test results for purposes of this Decision. 10. None of the Regional Center staff were experienced or trained to conduct formal assessments. Ms. Lopez is a behavioral consultant with a nonpublic agency that contracted with the Regional Center to provide in-home behavior management services for STUDENT. Ms. Lopez had two bachelors degrees, one in education and the other in English and foreign studies. Ms. Lopez was trained by the nonpublic agency how to develop and implement an in-home behavioral program. Ms. Lopez was unaware whether STUDENT’s behaviors interfered with his ability to learn. Mr. Hardy taught STUDENT sign language and assisted STUDENT in the community. Mr. Hardy had extensive training in special education and working with deaf students and testified that he, and the rest of the Regional Center personnel, were “all looking for answers” to explain STUDENT’s behaviors, anxiety and abilities. 11. The Hearing Officer observes that the District frequently acquiesced to STUDENT’s mother’s demands in making educational decisions. In this instance, when MOTHER told the IEP team she would let them know when STUDENT was ready to be tested, the District wholly abdicated its responsibility to STUDENT by waiting for her permission. The IDEA and State special education law contemplate that the District staff with educational expertise will carry out its obligation to STUDENT. The Hearing Officer further observes, that the IDEA and State special education law contemplate that if a parent obtains an independent evaluation, the report may be provided to the IEP team so that the team can both make informed decisions about the student’s educational program and determine whether additional evaluations are necessary. Here, the District staff testified that it would have been helpful to review the September 2002 UCLA autism evaluation clinic report that was never provided by Petitioner to the IEP team. 12. A document provided by Respondent indicated that District calculated that the current triennial evaluation was due in June 2002. However, since the previous triennial review was completed in April 1999, the Hearing Officer finds that this triennial evaluation was due in April 2002. In either case, now that it is April 2003, the triennial evaluation is long overdue. 13. The Hearing Officer observes that MOTHER initially signed the District’s reassessment plan dated February 19, 2003, but later withdrew her consent. The assessment plan included the names of Regional Center personnel upon MOTHER’s request. MOTHER testified that she withdrew her consent to the plan when she learned that those individuals were unable to participate in the evaluation, under the terms of their contracts with the Regional Center. 14. According to Ms. Cottier, there is a great deal of controversy surrounding the notion of “facilitated communication.” There are those who suspect that a “facilitator” who touches the hand of a student provides more than sensory stimulation to write, and in fact, unintentionally may guide the student’s hand to the make the correct letters. Put simply, under that theory, the student is not forming the letters at all. On the other hand, there are those who believe that some autistic children are “locked up” and have a lot to say when they finally comprehend that typing or writing the letters is a means to communicate with others. In Ms. Cottier’s opinion, STUDENT’s writing was not “facilitated” because she observed that he was able to form letters with the assistance of different adults applying slight pressure to the back of his hand. The Hearing Officer observed during the due process hearing, that STUDENT responded in writing with pressure applied by MOTHER with a pencil to the back of his hand. STUDENT did not write an answer to a question posed by the District’s attorney when no pressure was applied. 15. “[I]n the case of a child whose behavior impedes his or her learning or that of others, [the IEP team shall] consider, when appropriate, strategies, including positive behavior interventions, strategies, and supports to address that behavior.” 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(3)(B)(i); 34 C.F.R. § 300.3469a)(2)(i). If, in considering the behavior needs of the child, the IEP team determines that a child needs a particular device or service (including an intervention, accommodation, or other program modification) in order for the child to receive FAPE, the IEP team must include a statement to that effect in the child’s IEP. 34 C.F.R. § 300.346(c). When a child with exceptional needs exhibits serious behavior problems that significantly interferes with the implementation of his IEP goals and objectives and instructional/behavioral approaches specified in the IEP have proven ineffective, the school district must conduct a functional analysis assessment (FAA) and develop a behavioral intervention plan (BIP) for the child. C.C.R., tit.5, § 3001(f);§ 3052(b). 16. Dr. Levy has two masters degrees, one in clinical psychology and the other in psychological assessments. She possesses a doctorate in clinical psychology, and is frequently called upon to assess children who are difficult to test. She had post-doctoral experience working with children diagnosed with autism and often consults with B.J. Freeman, a recognized autism expert at UCLA. In addition to her private practice, Dr. Levy has been employed by the District to perform psycho-educational assessments for four years. 17. At the due process hearing, the District asserted that an FAA was unnecessary at this time because STUDENT is not in school and there was no way to know whether STUDENT’s behaviors would recur. The Hearing Officer observes that waiting until STUDENT exhibited maladaptive behaviors before addressing his behavioral needs would be contrary to the intent of the IDEA and State special education law which is that intervention should occur before a child fails or engages in dangerous behaviors. 18. Although Petitioner had been receiving APE and OT at one time, Petitioner did not seek compensatory educational services to make up for these services. The Hearing Officer observes that when STUDENT was placed in the general education classes in April 2002, he was also placed in regular physical education, where he apparently made progress. With regard to OT, the Hearing Officer observes that in December 2002, the IEP team determined that STUDENT no longer required OT services.
