California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 5, 2004

Student v. Placentia-Yorba Linda Unified School District (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 2498-03 · Hearing Officer Jessica Katz

Placentia-Yorba Linda Unified may place autistic second grader in special day class, though it misapplied his behavior plan.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 6 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

Before this decision, the District sought a temporary restraining order in federal District Court on November 26, 2003. The court denied the TRO but ordered the District to implement the November 18, 2003 IEP offer, conduct a new FAA, and consider using Rick Clemons and placement at Golden Elementary. Earlier due process was settled at mediation on June 5, 2003.

Summary

Placentia-Yorba Linda Unified School District filed for due process to have its special day class (SDC) offer upheld. The parents, representing themselves, cross-filed. The eight-year-old student is eligible with autism and mild mental retardation. He had always been fully included in general education with a one-on-one aide from the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD). His task-avoidance behaviors escalated in second grade at Sierra Vista. On November 14, 2003, two staff members were injured during a classroom removal. The District then offered an autism SDC at Tynes Elementary.

The Hearing Officer found that CARD's behavior intervention plan (BIP) was properly developed under the Title 5 rules. However, staff did not carry it out as written. They used basket holds at least 25 times, often to force the student to finish tasks with hand-over-hand guidance, not only in emergencies. The school nurse also did not monitor the holds as required. This denied FAPE. There was no denial of FAPE on occupational therapy, because the parents had agreed to provide transportation. There was also none on a computer program that was not in the IEP. Short notice of the emergency IEP meeting did not prevent the parents from taking part. Applying the Holland factors, the Hearing Officer held that the Tynes SDC was FAPE in the LRE. The District was ordered to implement that IEP and to complete a new behavior assessment and BIP within 20 calendar days. No compensatory remedy was ordered.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO judged a behavior plan's design separately from how staff carried it out. Using restraint to force a student to finish work broke the plan and Title 5's emergency intervention limits. Even so, the Hearing Officer used the Holland factors to approve a more restrictive SDC placement.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 1a (development). Did the District fail to provide FAPE from September through November 14, 2003, by improperly developing the behavior intervention plan (BIP)?

    CARD's functional analysis assessment and BIP met Title 5, section 3052. The BIP considered the medical information then known, included adequate de-escalation guidance and reflected parent input. Delay in finalizing it was by agreement.

  2. Student prevailedImplementation

    Issue 1a (implementation). Did the District fail to provide FAPE from September through November 14, 2003, by improperly implementing the BIP?

    Staff used basket holds and modified holds at least 25 times, often to force task completion, contrary to the BIP, CARD's training and the Title 5 emergency intervention limits. Nurse monitoring was not done. This denied FAPE, but no remedy was ordered for it.

  3. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1b. Did the District fail to provide FAPE by failing to provide occupational therapy (OT)?

    The parents agreed in the settlement to transport the student to their chosen out-of-area OT provider. Once the parents said they could not, the District promptly held an IEP addendum meeting, where the parents agreed to consult-based OT and a sensory diet. OT was made available.

  4. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1c. Did the District fail to provide FAPE by failing to provide the student with computer services (Writing with Symbols program)?

    The program was not in the IEP, and no evidence showed it was needed for FAPE. The District bought it and trained staff under a verbal agreement, and it should be provided when the student returns.

  5. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 2 (procedural). Did the parents have appropriate notice and an opportunity for meaningful participation in the November 18 and 25, 2003 IEP meetings?

    Notice of the emergency IEP meeting came only the day before. Even so, Father attended, proposed an alternative placement, visited both schools, and took part in the reconvened meeting, so meaningful participation was not impaired.

  6. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2 (substantive/LRE). Was the District's placement offer at the November 18 and 25, 2003 IEP meetings a FAPE in the least restrictive environment for the 2003-2004 school year?

    Relying on the Diagnostic Center assessment and the Holland factors, the Hearing Officer held that the Tynes autism SDC, with mainstreaming and reverse mainstreaming, met the student's needs and was the LRE. Academic benefit, limited social benefit in general education and severe disruption favored the SDC.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order that district's offer may be implemented. The District shall implement the November 18 and 25, 2003 IEP in the SDC at Tynes Elementary School.
  • Order to assess. The District shall complete the functional analysis assessment (FAA) and develop a new BIP within 20 calendar days of the Decision, taking the decision's findings into account in the new setting.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Holland; Adams v. State of Oregon; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; W.G. v. Target Range School Dist.; Honig v. Doe; Alamo Heights Independent School Dist. v. Texas Board of Education; Roland M. v. Concord School Committee; Fuhrman v. East Hanover Bd. of Educ.

People named in the decision

  • Dr. Sebastian Bosch, director of research and development; conducted FAA and wrote BIP; District witness, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
  • Eric Maier, senior managing clinical supervisor and student's case manager; District witness, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
  • Trisha Brady, coordinator of special education, Placentia-Yorba Linda Unified School District
  • Joan Akers, director of special education, Placentia-Yorba Linda Unified School District
  • Valerie Johnson, school psychologist; Diagnostic Center assessor, California Diagnostic Center
  • Suzanne Flatley, speech and language specialist, Placentia-Yorba Linda Unified School District
  • Gwen Redira, behavior specialist / full inclusion specialist; CPI trainer, Placentia-Yorba Linda Unified School District
  • Debra Foye, school nurse (registered nurse), Placentia-Yorba Linda Unified School District
  • Katie Wheeler, special day class teacher at Tynes Elementary, Placentia-Yorba Linda Unified School District
  • Janell Betts, second grade general education teacher at Sierra Vista, Placentia-Yorba Linda Unified School District
  • Patricia Dilliard, resource specialist, Placentia-Yorba Linda Unified School District
  • Brieanna Peterson, one-on-one instructional aide (CARD-trained), Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
  • Heather Bradshaw, one-on-one instructional aide
  • Patricia Schwartz, retired program specialist; District witness
  • Julie Garcia, resource specialist program aide, Placentia-Yorba Linda Unified School District
  • Ivor Weiner, assistant professor of special education; expert witness for Student, California State University Northridge
  • Dr. Barbara Phillips, assistant professor of special education; expert witness for Student, California State University Fullerton
  • Lisa Venzke, in-home instructional aide; witness for Student
  • Rick Clemons, director of inclusive education and community partnership; full inclusion specialist conducting new FAA; witness for Student, Rick Clemons Agency
  • Cynthia Wineinger, private speech and language pathologist; witness for Student
  • Irvine Therapy, private occupational therapy provider
  • Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), nonpublic agency providing in-home and school aide and behavior services

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Jessica Katz, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Yorba Linda, California, on January 20-23, 27-30, 2004.

Petitioner/Cross-Respondent Placentia-Yorba Linda Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Karen Keating. The District’s coordinator of special education, Trisha Brady, was present on behalf of the District. Joan Akers, the District’s director of special education, was also present on behalf of the District on the first day of hearing.

Respondent/Cross-Petitioner Student (Student) was represented at hearing by his parents.

The District called the following witnesses: Dr. Sebastian Bosch, director of research and development at Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD); Trisha Brady; Valerie Johnson, school psychologist at the California Diagnostic Center; Suzanne Flatley, speech and language specialist; Gwen Redira, behavior specialist; Debra Foye, registered nurse; Katie Wheeler, special day class (SDC) teacher at Tynes; Janell Betts, second grade teacher at Sierra Vista; Patricia Dilliard, resource specialist; Brieanna Peterson, instructional aide; Patricia Schwartz, retired program specialist; Heather Bradshaw, instructional aide; and Eric Maier, senior managing clinical supervisor at CARD.

The Student called the following witnesses: Ivor Weiner, assistant professor of special education at California State University Northridge; Deanna Monzon, parent of a student in Student’s class; Dr. Barbara Phillips, assistant professor of special education at California State University Fullerton; Lisa Venzke, in-home instructional aide; Mother; Father; Rick Clemons, director of inclusive education and community partnership; and Cynthia Wineinger, private speech and language pathologist.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was closed upon receipt of final written arguments and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

1. Did the District fail to provide Student with a Free Appropriate Public Education (FAPE) from September through November 14, 2003, by (a) improperly developing and implementing a behavior intervention plan (BIP); (b) failing to provide occupational therapy (OT); and (c) failing to provide Student with computer services?

2. Was the District’s placement offer at the November 18 and 25, 2003 IEP meetings a FAPE in the least restrictive environment (LRE) for the 2003-2004 school year?

CONTENTIONS

The Student contends that he was not provided a FAPE in the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year because his BIP was not properly developed and implemented. The Student asserts that emergency interventions were utilized at inappropriate times and that if he had not been restrained as frequently his behaviors would not have escalated to the point of needing an SDC. Student also contends that the District failed to provide OT and computer services as set forth in his March 6, 2003 IEP and the June 5, 2003 settlement agreement. The Student contends that the SDC that was offered at the November 18 and 25, 2003 IEP meetings is not the LRE and that he should be enrolled in a general education classroom with appropriate supports and services.

The District contends that it provided Student a FAPE September through November 14, 2003. The District asserts that it properly developed the BIP with the assistance of the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), Student’s home and school service provider since age three. The District contends that the BIP was properly implemented in accordance with the CARD training. The District also asserts that it provided OT and computer services as set forth in the March 6, 2003 IEP and settlement agreement dated June 5, 2003. The District also contends that at the November 18 and 25, 2003 IEP meetings, its placement offer of a special day class (SDC) at Tynes Elementary School (Tynes) is a FAPE. The District contends that it met all the procedural requirements and that the placement at Tynes is in the LRE.

BACKGROUND FACTS

Student is an eight-year-old boy who is eligible for special education as a child with mild mental retardation and autism. Student’s autism falls on the moderate to severe end of the autistic spectrum. He is currently enrolled in the District. Student attended a general education second grade classroom with a one-on-one aide until November 14, 2003, but presently is not attending school due to the current disagreement regarding his placement. Student lives with his parents, sister, and two brothers. (Footnote 1)

Student has been eligible for special education since age three and at all times, has been fully included in general education classrooms with a one-on-one aide from CARD. Over the past two years, Student’s maladaptive behaviors (hitting, screaming kicking, and yelling) in the classroom have increased in intensity and frequency requiring the development of a behavior intervention plan (BIP). Because the District contracted with CARD to provide services both in home and school, the parties agreed to have CARD conduct a functional analysis assessment (FAA) in the spring of 2002. However, the parents did not agree with the initial BIP that was created and Student’s maladaptive behaviors in the classroom worsened.

In January 2003, the parties agreed to conduct another FAA and revise the BIP. Dr. Sebastian Bosch, from CARD, conducted an FAA and created a BIP in accordance with the District’s guidelines. The District and the parents had a series of IEP meetings in March and April 2003 to discuss Student’s BIP and his IEP. The BIP required that when Student had disruptive behaviors in the classroom, he would be removed from the setting so as not to interfere with the education of the general education students. All members of the IEP team were concerned about the proposal to remove Student from the classroom because his main behavior targeted by the BIP was escaping tasks, and removal from the classroom would likely enforce, rather than minimize, the targeted behavior. There was no agreement to the BIP and the parents filed for due process on behalf of Student.

On June 4, 2003, Eric Maier, the Student’s case manager from CARD conducted a training by CARD of the implementation of the BIP. The next day, the parties participated in mediation. The parties agreed to settle the dispute and dismiss the due process proceeding. The agreement memorialized the March 6, 2003 IEP. The parties also agreed that Student would remain in a general education classroom with a one-on-one aide from CARD; OT services would be provided, at the parents’ request, by Irvine Therapy with transportation to be provided by Father with reimbursement from the District; and the BIP was to be implemented as written by Dr. Bosch with an agreement to do a basket hold rather that a four point restraint if Student became a danger to himself or others. There was also a discussion of utilizing a computer program to help Student with his communication skills but neither the IEP nor the settlement agreement reflects the use of the specific computer program. (Footnote 2)

During the summer, Student continued to have Brieanna Peterson as his one-on-one aide in a general education non-comprehensive summer school/camp style program. (Footnote 3) Student did not have any serious maladaptive behaviors requiring his removal from the setting; however, the summer program was social, not academic.

Prior to the start of Student’s second grade year (2003-2004 school year), a CARD clinic team meeting was held at the family home on August 28, 2003. Student began second grade on September 2, 2003, in Janell Betts’ general education classroom. The parties agreed to have a second training on the implementation of the BIP after a few days of school because Heather Bradshaw was added as an additional aide and it would be important for her to observe in the classroom and understand Student’s behaviors. On September 9, 2003, Eric Maier and Dr. Bosch from CARD conducted a training for everyone involved in Student’s program: Janelle Betts; Heather Bradshaw and Brieanna Peterson, one-on-one aides; Gwen Redira, inclusion specialist; principal of Sierra Vista; Patricia Dilliard, resource specialist (RSP); Julie Garcia, RSP aide, an aide from Tynes; and Father. The parties were taught how to implement the behavior plan and given several examples of reinforcers. The participants had the opportunity to directly observe the plan being implemented because Student had a behavioral outburst in his classroom and had to be removed. Dr. Bosch and Mr. Maier assisted in the removal and brought Student into the multi-purpose room where the training was taking place. Dr. Bosch and Mr. Maier had to struggle with Student to get him into a desk and keep him from slipping to the floor. With one person holding him into his chair, the other person put his hand over Student’s hand to do hand-over-hand manipulation of the task from which Student had previously attempted to escape. (Footnote 4)

Following the training, the BIP was fully implemented in the classroom. For the first few weeks, Student’s behaviors began to lessen and the parties were encouraged that the BIP might actually work. The school staff met every Wednesday to discuss Student’s progress and behaviors and to exchange ideas to work with him effectively. Additionally, Ms. Betts, Ms. Bradshaw, and Ms. Peterson sat down and developed his curriculum for the semester so that the aides would always have alternative work for Student to do if the lesson plans for the general education students was too challenging for Student. Ms. Betts also taught the two aides how to modify the general education curriculum to Student’s level and to implement the use of a white board to make the letters bigger and the sentences shorter.

At the end of September 2003, a back to school night was held, and the parents of the general education students in Student’s class seemed pleased about Student’s placement. However, Student’s behavioral outburst started to become more intense and more frequent. The parties had agreed in the settlement agreement to meet by October 15, 2003, to reassess and finalize the BIP. On October 14, 2003, a meeting was held with Father, Eric Maier, Gwen Redira, Janell Betts, Heather Bradshaw, Brie Peterson, and Patricia Dilliard. The parties agreed that Student’s behaviors were increasing and that it was becoming more difficult to remove him from the classroom. The team discussed that although the special and emergency procedures contained within the BIP were being implemented more frequently than expected, there was a downward trend of serious behavior incidents based on the data that had been charted since the beginning of the school year. The team also noted concerns due to a recent medication change. The parties discussed some of the problem areas on the BIP. Mr. Maier agreed to observe Student in the classroom setting and then to have a follow up meeting to discuss his observation.

After the October 14, 2003 meeting, Student’s outbursts in the classroom became more frequent and more intense. Student began to react to the removals from the classroom. He would resist hand-over-hand manipulations to complete tasks by flopping to the floor, head-butting his aide, and flailing his arms. Most attempts at hand-over-hand eventually turned into holding his left arm across his body in a modified basket hold while he was sitting in the chair and then forcibly holding his right arm and hand to make him do the work. If he flopped on the floor, Student was also placed in a modified basket hold and forced to continue to do his work. The basket hold was described as an emergency restraint where two people sat behind Student on the floor. Student was placed in a sitting position with his legs crossed and held down and his arms placed across his chest with his hands held by his side. This restraint was to be utilized only if he was a danger to himself or others. Student was placed in a basket hold at least twenty-five times between September 2, 2003 through November 14, 2003, and almost every time was following a hand-over-hand manipulation. It appeared that Student began to gain sensory benefit from being held because he seemed to calm down when held and also enjoyed being read to while being held. Additionally, he successfully escaped the task.

Mr. Maier observed Student on November 10, 2003, but did not see any of the targeted behaviors that the team had discussed at the meeting on October 14, 2003. However, Mr. Maier gave some suggestions on a new token economy system to address Student’s escalating behaviors. Before the suggestions could be implemented, Student had a serious behavior incident on November 14, 2003, where he unintentionally sprained Ms. Bradshaw’s wrist and broke Ms. Dilliard’s nose while struggling during a classroom removal.

Student was subsequently suspended from school and the District held an emergency IEP meeting on November 18, 2003. The District recommended a change in placement to an SDC class at Tynes Elementary School. During the IEP meeting, Father requested an alternative to Tynes that was not as restrictive, such as Golden Elementary School, a school within the District with an SDC for learning disabled students. The District agreed to take Father to both Golden and Tynes and to reconvene the IEP meeting on November 25, 2003. Father observed both classrooms and was opposed to placing Student at Tynes and requested placement at Golden. The District continued to recommend Tynes because it felt it was the appropriate placement for Student.

Because the parents opposed the District’s proposed placement, the District filed for a temporary restraining order (TRO) on November 26, 2003, to keep Student from returning to Sierra Vista. The District Court did not order the TRO but ordered the District to implement the November 18, 2003 IEP offer, ordered the parties to conduct a new FFA, and ordered the District to consider using Rick Clemons. (Footnote 5) Further, the Court ordered that the District consider placing Student at Golden. The District then filed for due process contending that its offer is appropriate. The parents cross-filed contending that the offer was not in the least restrictive environment and that the BIP was inappropriate. The parents have chosen to keep Student home pending the resolution of this hearing. Rick Clemons agency is currently conducting an FAA, but its completion has been delayed because Student is not in school.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

1. Did the District fail to provide Student with a Free Appropriate Public Education (FAPE) from September through November 14, 2003, by (a) improperly developing and implementing a behavior intervention plan (BIP); (b) failing to provide occupational therapy (OT); and (c) failing to provide Student with computer services?

Under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.) Federal and State law mandates that all children with disabilities have available to them a FAPE that includes special education and related services to meet their unique needs. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000 et seq.) The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a child at no charge to his or her parent or guardian, meets the standards of the State educational agency, include appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education, and are provided in conformity with the child’s individualized education program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401 (8)). Special education law also requires that a child with a disability be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). (20 U.S.C. § 1412 (a)(5)(A)). The IEP, which is the “centerpiece of the [IDEA’s] educational delivery system for disabled children,” consists of a detailed written statement that must be developed, reviewed and revised for each child with a disability. (Honig v. Doe 484 U.S. 305 (1988), 108 S.Ct. 592, 598; 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343, 56345). The IEP must include a statement of the goals and objectives, special education and related services, and program modifications or supports for the school personnel that are to be provided to meet the child’s needs resulting from his or her disability, to enable the child to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum, and be educated and participate with nondisabled children to the maximum extent possible. (Id., see also 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56031, 56345).

The standard for determining whether the program provided Student a FAPE involves the following factors: whether the placement and services were designed to address Student’s unique needs, were reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit, and conformed to his IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, 458 U.S. 176.)

The Student contends that the District failed to provide a FAPE because it did not properly develop and implement the BIP. The Student also contends that the District failed to provide him with OT services and computer services.

The District contends that it properly conducted the FAA in accordance with the Hughes Bill requirements set forth in Title 5, California Code of Regulations section 3052 and developed the BIP accordingly. The District further contends that it implemented the BIP as it was written. The District also contends that any lack of OT services was due to the parents not transporting Student to OT. The District also contends that it trained teachers on the computer program and was ready to implement it in the classroom when Student was suspended. However, it is also the District’s position that the computer program was a suggested program and was not specifically part of his IEP.

The Student’s assertions regarding a denial of FAPE are limited specifically to the development and implementation of the BIP and the provision of OT and computer services. There are no other issues in contention regarding Student’s placement and services following the mediation on June 5, 2003, which memorialized the March 6, 2003 IEP until November 14, 2003, when Student was suspended from school.

a. Was the behavior intervention plan properly developed and implemented?

Before it can be determined if the BIP was appropriate, it is necessary to first understand Student’s behavioral needs at the time the BIP was developed. It is undisputed that many of Student’s behaviors were a result of task avoidance. If a task was new or challenging (such as math), Student would attempt to avoid the task by high-pitched screams, yelling, flailing on the floor, hitting and head-butting. Student needed constant reinforcers to help keep him on track so that he knew what he was working towards. He needed frequent breaks and sensory stimulation (such as back and head rubs) to help him stay on task. He needed his academic work modified to his level of functioning. He also needed staff trained on the implementation of the BIP. Finally, Student needed a setting where he could be removed in order to implement the special circumstances and emergency intervention components of the BIP outside the presence of the general education students.

(1) Was the BIP designed and developed to meet Student’s unique needs?

If any child is found to have a behavior problem that interferes with his/her learning or the learning of others, the IEP team is required to consider, if appropriate, strategies, including positive behavior interventions, strategies and supports to address that behavior. (20 U.S.C.§ 1414(d)(3)(B)(i); 34 C.F.R. § 300.346(a)(2)(i); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.1(b)(1)). A behavior plan is a written document that is developed when an individual exhibits serious behaviors problems that significantly interfere with the implementation of the goals and objectives of the individuals IEP. (Title 5 C.C.R. § 3001(f)). The plan shall be developed based on the completion on an FAA and it shall become part of the student’s IEP. (Title 5 C.C.R. § 3052(c)). The FAA should be systematic observations of the occurrences of targeted behaviors, observation of the immediate antecedents of events associated with each behavior, observation and analysis of the consequences following the behavior and a determination of the function that the behavior serves, an ecological analysis of the settings that the behavior occurs, a review of records for medical and health factors that may influence the behaviors, and a review of the history of the behaviors including effectiveness of previous behavior interventions. (Title 5 C.C.R. § 3052 (1)). The interventions should be based on the FAA and include: altering the identified antecedent event to prevent the occurrence of the behavior by providing choice; changing the setting; offering a variety and meaningful curriculum; removing environmental pollutants such as notice; establish a predictable routine; teach the individual alternative behaviors that produce the same consequences such as teaching the individual to make requests, teach socially acceptable behaviors, and have alternative communication modes; teaching the individual adaptive behaviors such as choice making, self-management, relaxation techniques, and general skill development which ameliorate negative conditions that promote inappropriate behaviors; and manipulating the consequences for the display of targeted behaviors that more effectively reduce desired outcomes. (Title 5 C.C.R. § 3052(d)).

In January 2002, Dr. Bosch completed his first FAA and BIP for Student. The parties did not agree with the findings and no BIP was implemented. In January 2003, the parties agreed that it was necessary for Student to have a BIP and agreed to have Dr. Bosch, director of research and development at CARD, conduct a second FAA and create a new BIP. Dr. Bosch testified that the purpose of a functional analysis assessment (FAA) is to look at the cause or source of a behavior and then create an intervention to address the behaviors. He explained that the purpose of the BIP was to look at the targeted behaviors and address the antecedents and consequences of those behaviors. Dr. Bosch explained that Student’s targeted behaviors were hitting, slapping, and yelling. The function of those behaviors was escape or task avoidance. Dr. Bosch made his recommendations based on two days of observation in the classroom, participation in a number of meetings, and review of CARD, school and medical records. Dr. Bosch testified that he developed the BIP in accordance with the District’s template.

The BIP specified Student’s targeted behaviors as hitting, spitting and yelling. The antecedents to these behaviors were identified and the consequences and interventions were set forth to respond to the targeted behaviors. If the interventions described did not enable Student to demonstrate a desired alternative behavior, a secondary plan entitled “decreasing maladaptive targeted behaviors” was developed. There were four preliminary steps: (1) response priming at home to help Student with new and novel concepts; (2) frequent daily reinforcer assessments; (3) choice between modified task – between and within activities; and (4) modified task presentation. If Student responded appropriately to the preliminary interventions, then the aide was to assess reinforcers with him for two minutes and then modify the task. However, if the desired result did not occur from the preliminary interventions and he continued to exhibit targeted behavior, then the staff was to implement the special behavior intervention and if that was not successful, then emergency behavior interventions were to be utilized.

Special behavior interventions directed staff to (1) block any further attempts at hitting/slapping; (2) rapidly remove Student from the classroom using trained staff; (3) avoid talking to Student while being removed from the classroom; (4) place in an unlocked secluded area where Student would pose no danger to himself or others; (5) continue working on the academic tasks; (6) stand behind Student to provide prompts; (7) allow Student to earn his way back to the classroom by (a) completing all work that evoked the targeted behavior(s), or (b) completing all work given in the unlocked secluded area, and (c) exhibiting no target behavior; (7) no reinforcement while in that environment; and (8) record the frequency of the target behavior. If the special behavior interventions were not effective, the emergency interventions were to be implemented.

The emergency interventions were to be utilized only if Student became a threat to himself or others. If the staff was unable to block and/or stop Student from hitting or slapping, two trained personnel were to employ a basket hold. Whenever Student was restrained, a registered nurse was to check on his welfare every fifteen minutes, and all emergencies should have been documented. In addition to the behavior modifications and interventions, the BIP required staff training and a meeting by October 15, 2003, to evaluate the progress and appropriateness of the BIP.

The Student contends that the BIP was not developed appropriately because (1) the District did not consider ecological factors such as Student’s medical condition and the setting where Student would be placed; (2) there were no de-escalation procedures written into the BIP; (3) the BIP was not finalized October 15, 2003; and (4) Dr. Bosch never interviewed the parents when creating the BIP.

The District contends that it followed the appropriate steps in the development of the BIP.

1. Ecological and placement factors

The parents raise concerns that the District did not include Student’s medical information in the BIP; however, evidence at hearing showed that the parents failed to inform the District of Student’s medication concerns at the time of the development of the IEP and only informed the District around October 14, 2003, when the nurse called the parents to gain information about anti-seizure medications that Student was taking. On November 25, 2003, Mother dropped off a letter from a doctor regarding medical concerns, but this was the first time the parents informed the District of Student’s medications. Student was also diagnosed with ulcerative colitis during the spring of 2003. The Parent’s informed the school of his condition and the District was fully aware of his needs. Mother was concerned that the basket hold may affect Student’s condition; however, the parents specifically requested to have the basket hold rather than a four-point hold knowing of Student’s condition at the time of the request. The Hearing Officer finds that the District took into consideration all the information on Student’s medical conditions that it had at the time of the development of the BIP.

The Student asserts that CARD and the District did not understand the rationale behind full inclusion. (Footnote 6) The Student asserts that he should not have been removed from the general education setting because removal exacerbated his maladaptive behaviors. It also allowed him to physically escape from the task that he was attempting to avoid in the first place. The parents also suggested that Student should not have been removed from the classroom during a behavioral outburst because Student reacted to the removal by more intense kicking and hitting. The parents assert that the BIP should have required that the staff ignore Student when he was screaming or flailing in the classroom. However, Ms. Betts, Student’s teacher, testified that Student was flailing near desks and disrupting the learning of others, plus it appeared that he was actually seeking out the attention of the other students in order to escape the task. Based on the evidence presented, there is no persuasive basis for the Student’s argument.

The District developed a program specifically for Student’s placement in a general education classroom. The parties agreed that it would not be feasible to ignore Student’s behaviors because it would be too disruptive to the other students in the classroom and potentially dangerous. Dr. Bosch testified that he developed the BIP to modify Student’s behaviors by the least intrusive type of manipulations such as positive reinforcement and support. Dr. Bosch explained that to implement the plan in a general education setting required removal from the environment, but his behavior was an escape behavior and the removal may actually enforce the specific behavior. The Hearing Officer finds Dr. Bosch’s testimony persuasive as he conducted two thorough FAA involving Student and he has worked, taught and written in the field of autism since 1996. Further, Ms. Betts persuasively testified that Student’s behavioral outbursts interfered with the learning of the other student in her class thereby necessitating his removal from the classroom and not ignoring the screaming. The Hearing Officer finds that ignoring the behaviors was not an alternative for the BIP because he was placed in a general education setting.

2. De-escalation procedures

The parents argue that there were no de-escalation procedures written into the BIP. A review of the BIP reveals that it does not specifically provide for de-escalation procedures; however, throughout the plan, guidance is given to reinforce Student and bring him back to the task or demand that was presented. Further, throughout the day, the aides modify the reinforcers as Student’s desires change. As set forth above, a plan was developed to help Student with new concepts, including priming at home and reevaluating his reinforcers on a daily basis (if not more often). Every morning, Student was to be presented with a reinforcer menu (a menu of items such as maps of Disneyland, preferred activities, and candy) to choose what he wanted to work for that day. Those reinforcers were to be utilized whenever a task or demand was placed on him, both to keep him on track and to de-escalate him once he got off track. The Hearing Officer finds that the BIP set forth ample guidelines for his teachers and aides to bring him back to the task and de-escalate the behaviors.

3. BIP finalization by October 15, 2003

The parents raised concerns about the BIP not being finalized by October 15, 2003, in accordance with the settlement agreement. The parties convened an IEP meeting on October 14, 2003, to discuss the BIP. There was consensus that the BIP was problematic and the parties agreed to have Dr. Maier conduct a blind observation of Student so that Student would not be aware of his presence, to develop new reinforcers, and to reconvene the discussion on November 25, 2003. On November 4, 2003, Ms. Redira conducted an additional training on the crisis prevention intervention (CPI) to train the staff on how to properly remove Student from the classroom. Following the training, she sent Mr. Maier an email to discuss the problems with the BIP. Mr. Maier and Ms. Redira went to the Parent’s home on November 6, 2003 to work on additional reinforcers and to discuss problems with the BIP with the family. Mr. Maier then observed Student on November 10, 2003. The meeting on November 25, 2003, was held but it was an IEP meeting to make an offer of a new placement because of the behavioral incident on November 14, 2003. The Hearing Officer finds that the parties did meet in accordance with the settlement agreement but were unable to finalize the BIP by October 15, 2003 because Student was continuing to exhibit maladaptive behaviors rather than reduce or replace the occurrences of such behavior. Any delay to finalization was by subsequent agreement of the parties.

4. Parental input into the BIP

The parents also argue that the District failed to interview them during the creation of the FAA. The law does not specifically require that the parents be interviewed during the FAA process. In this case, the parents had ample opportunities to voice their concerns regarding the BIP during the six IEP meetings that were held between March and June 2003 and also had opportunities to work with Mr. Maier in their own home. Mr. Maier had worked with the family for approximately five years and had monthly meetings in the home and assisted Dr. Bosch in the development of the BIP. No evidence was presented that the parents were unable to give their input in the creation of the BIP or that Dr. Bosch did not consider the information gleaned from the parents. The Hearing Officer finds that the parents were participants in the development of the BIP.

Summary

In reviewing the BIP and the evidence presented, it appears that the District and CARD properly developed the BIP in accordance with the California Code of Regulations section 3052. The Hearing Officer must look at the appropriateness of the BIP at the time it was created. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal has endorsed the “snapshot” rule, which holds that the actions of a school cannot “be judged exclusively in hindsight…an IEP must take into account what was, and what was not, objectively reasonable when the snapshot was taken, that is, at the time the IEP was drafted.” (Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (1999), citing Fuhrman v. East Hanover Bd. of Educ., 993 F.2d 1031, 1041 (3rd Cir. 1993)).

However the ”snapshot” rule does not eliminate a school district’s obligation to revise a student’s educational program if it becomes apparent over a course of the school year that he student is not receiving educational benefit. Dr. Bosch conducted the FAA, observed Student in his educational setting, and included the essential elements in the BIP. Dr. Bosch conducted a systematic observation of the occurrences of Student’s targeted behaviors, observed the immediate antecedents of events associated with each of his behaviors, observed and analyzed the consequences following the behavior to determine the function that the behavior serves, conducted an ecological analysis of the settings that the behaviors occurred, reviewed the records for medical and health factors that may have influenced the behaviors, and reviewed the history of the behaviors including effectiveness of previous behavior interventions. Further, because CARD worked with Student for a total of six years both in home and school, Dr. Bosch was able to develop the BIP in accordance with Mr. Maier who had been Student’s case supervisor the entire time and fully understood Student’s behavioral needs. The Hearing Officer finds that the BIP was properly developed and included specific action to replace targeted maladaptive behaviors and was designed to meet Student’s unique needs. Furthermore, the BIP was appropriately developed in accordance with Title 5, California Code of Regulation section 3052.

(2) Was the BIP reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

The Hearing Officer has already determined that the BIP was designed to meet Student’s unique needs. The BIP was specifically designed to target the maladaptive behaviors (hitting, screaming, and kicking to avoid tasks) that were interfering with his ability to remain in the general education setting. Student’s inappropriate behaviors needed to be modified in order for him to remain in a general education setting and still receive educational benefit. The Hearing Officer finds that the BIP was reasonably calculated at the time it was created to provide Student the tools he needed to remain in a general educational setting.

(3) Did the District’s implementation conform to the BIP?

The Student contends that the District failed to properly implement the BIP because the special behavior interventions employed by the District far exceeded the steps set forth in the written BIP. Further, the Student asserts that he was subjected to physical restraint or placed in a basket hold in order to gain his compliance with task completion and that the hand-over-hand manipulation often was the cause of the behavioral emergencies requiring a basket hold.

The District contends that it implemented the behavior interventions in accordance with the provisions of the BIP and the training on the implementation of the BIP. As to implementation, Ms. Bradshaw explained that she and Ms. Peterson used several reinforcers to keep Student on task including, verbal praise, schedule boards, a clear end to each task, and reinforcer menus so that Student knew what he was working towards. Additionally, they had alternative curriculum to use and were taught how to modify the curriculum so that Student could work within his abilities. There was also a training conducted by Mr. Maier and Dr. Bosch on September 9, 2003, on the implementation of the BIP. Ms. Redira, Ms. Dilliard, Ms. Bradshaw, Ms. Peterson, Father, Suzanne Flatley, and aide from Tynes SDC, and Ms. Betts attended the training. Student’s school team also met weekly to discuss Student’s program. Ms. Redira, the District full inclusion specialist and a certified trainer in Crisis Prevention Intervention (CPI), conducted a full day training session for the staff working with Student on how to properly escort Student with the carry-hold from the classroom to alternative settings. The CPI training also included training on de-escalation techniques.

Ms. Bradshaw and Ms. Peterson testified if Student were approached while flailing, he would kick more. They explained that at the beginning of the school year they could often predict when Student would have a behavior and attempt to modify the situation to avoid the behavior before it occurred. However, as the year progressed, Student’s behaviors became more extreme. It began to take more than two staff to escort Student due to his weight and his flailing. The aides explained that it was usually a struggle to get him out of the room. Ms. Bradshaw testified that she utilized the emergency interventions (basket hold) when Student grew aggressive with the aides or they were unable to maintain him in his chair. She explained that it often calmed him down to motor him through an activity while he was being held on the floor, though it took two to three people to hold him down. However, her testimony established that sometimes Student could be held down for as much as forty-five minutes at a time. By November, Student was being removed from the classroom almost on a daily basis. Student’s aide, either Ms. Bradshaw or Ms. Peterson, had to call Ms. Dilliard (and sometimes a third person) for backup to help remove Student to a different setting when he presented targeted behaviors as called for by the BIP.

Despite the trainings and the BIP, the evidence establishes that Student continued to struggle while being escorted, and his significant weight gain added to the difficulty of removing Student. When Student was removed to the MPR or RSP, the aides brought class work and attempted to place Student at a desk to get him to continue working on the task that he was avoiding prior to his maladaptive behavior. If Student refused to work, he would head butt, flail his arms and legs, and attempt to fall to the floor. If the aides were able to keep Student in his chair, one person would hold his left arm to his chest while the other motored him through the task by hand-over-hand manipulations with his right hand. If Student continued to struggle or fall to the floor, the aides would place him in a modified basket hold and continue to attempt to motor him through the task. A modified basket hold was described as one aide sitting behind him with her arm around him, hold one arm to his chest while she or another person attempted to hand-over-hand manipulation to get him to complete the task.

Ms. Dilliard testified that one time she implemented the basket hold and read to Student to get him to continue the task at hand. During that situation, Student had asked to use the bathroom. The staff felt that Student was using the bathroom as an escape and motored him through the activity. However, Student wet himself in the process.

Mr. Maier explained that the basket hold was only to be used in an emergency situation when Student was a danger to himself or others and it was not to be used to gain compliance. Further, when Student was in a basket hold, no work was to be done until he calmed down. The basket hold was not meant to be soothing or calming and should last no more than eight minutes at a time (this is based on one minute per year of child’s age – Student is eight years old). Mr. Maier explained that Student should have been released from the basket hold and attempted to be redirected to complete the task with social praise and reinforcement, if he still continued to be a threat to himself or others, then he should have been placed back in the basket hold. Further, Mr. Maier explained that he did not teach the school staff to utilize a modified basket hold. Mr. Maier testified that if the staff was holding Student down on the floor and motoring him through the activity, it is not how he trained the staff on the BIP. Further, the BIP was written to have two people do a basket hold not three people.

Further, Debra Foye, the school nurse, testified that she was not aware of the BIP and the requirement that a nurse should observe Student’s welfare every fifteen minutes when he is placed in a basket hold. Ms. Foye testified that she only observed Student on a few occasions following October 14, 2003, and did not monitor Student prior to that date.

The evidence established that Student was placed in some type of hold at least twenty-five times between September and November 14, 2003. Testimony indicated that many of these holds were a direct result of Student being removed from a situation and the behaviors increased in intensity as he was forced to continue motoring through the activities.

The Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not implement the behavior plan appropriately. The staff testified that their manipulations often caused the behavior to escalate to a point of needing to place him in a basket hold or modified basket hold. The staff did not follow the guidelines set forth above. The holds were not used in unpredictable situations with spontaneous behavior; rather, the holds were used following a removal that Student contested. The plan was not implemented according to the training provided by CARD because there was to be no work done while Student was in a basket hold. The basket hold was not supposed to be calming or used to gain compliance; rather, it was an emergency intervention to be used if Student was a danger to himself or others. Further, emergency interventions may only be used to control unpredictable, spontaneous behavior which poses clear and present danger of serious physical hard to an individual or others which cannot be immediately prevented by a response less restrictive than temporary application of a technique used to contain behavior. (Title 5 C.C.R. § 3052 (i)). Although the BIP was designed to meet his unique needs and was intended to provide educational benefit, the staff did not implement the plan as written. Further, because Student’s behaviors had gotten so extreme that he was removed so often from the educational setting rather than being in an environment where removal is not necessary, he has been unable to access his education in the general education setting.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District properly designed and developed the BIP; however, the District failed to implement the behavior interventions in accordance with the BIP. Despite the District’s positive intentions, Student’s behaviors were exacerbated by the physical restraints and holds that the District utilized. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide Student a FAPE in regards to his behavior intervention plan.

The parents argue that had the District developed and implemented an appropriate BIP, Student would have been able to remain in a general education setting with supports and accommodations and request that Student remain in general education as a remedy for the District’s failure to provide Student with a FAPE. The District argues that Student needs to be placed in an SDC in accordance with the offer of placement made at the November 14 and 18, 2003 IEP meetings. The Hearing Officer understands the student's requested remedy, which under some circumstances may be appropriate. However, in light of the determination regarding the District's proposed placement, the Hearing Officer declines to order implementation of the prior BIP in the general education environment.

b. Did the District provide Student with OT services?

The Student contends that the District failed to provide the OT services that were set forth in the settlement agreement on June 5, 2003. The Student contends that when the District was informed that the parents were unable to transport Student to Irvine Therapy, the District should have provided transportation. The parents are only seeking acknowledgement of the District’s failure to provide transportation and are not seeking compensatory education for Student.

The District asserts that the parents requested that Irvine Therapy provide and had agreed to transport Student because Irvine Therapy is outside of the area which the District transports its students. The District contends that Father informed it during the summer that he was unable to transport and Father requested an alternate service provider within the area the District provides transportation. The District asserts that because Father requested new service providers, an IEP needed to be convened. The District further asserts that an IEP team meeting was convened, alternative arrangements were made regarding OT services, and that it has complied with those agreements.

On June 5, 2003, the parties agreed to settle their disputes and adopt the March 6, 2003 IEP. On the IEP document, the parties added that Irvine Therapy would provide OT for one sixty-minute session per week and the parents would provide transportation. The District immediately contacted Irvine Therapy to secure an outside contract and Father to inform him that he was to schedule an appointment. Father testified that he did not schedule an appointment because he unable to transport Student to OT over the summer due to personal health problems. (Footnote 7) On August 29, 2003, Ms. Redira contacted Father, via email, to follow up on Student’s OT services. Father replied on September 3, 2003, indicating that he had not been able to transport Student to OT and requested an alternative OT and the scheduling of an additional IEP meeting to discuss changes regarding OT. On September 3, 2003, Ms. Redira replied to Father and suggested September 9, 2003 for an IEP to discuss changes to the OT services, and Father agreed. On September 9, 2003, the District held an IEP meeting, addendum to the March 6, 2003 IEP meeting. The parents accepted the District’s offer of OT services on a consult basis and a sensory diet in the classroom.

The parents willingly and knowingly agreed to transport Student as part of the settlement agreement. The parents did not raise any issues regarding the invalidity of the agreement or to set aside the settlement. Father also testified that Student’s behavior was the main issue and he agreed to the provision of consultation-based services for OT to allow the focus of Student’s program to be his behavior. Further, when the District was informed that the Parents were unable to provide transportation per the agreement, an IEP addendum meeting was immediately scheduled and alternative OT services were agreed upon. The parents rely on Alamo Heights Independent School District v. Texas Board of Education, 790 F.2d 1153 (5th Cir. 1986), arguing that transportation is not limited by geographical boundaries if the services are necessary for special education. However, this case is distinguishable from Alamo Heights because although OT is necessary for Student to receive a FAPE, Student’s parents requested a service provider that is approximately fifteen miles from the District’s boundary, and through mediation, agreed to provide the transportation. Once the District was informed that the parents were unable to provide transportation as they had agreed to, an addendum to the IEP was made, alternate services were offered and agreed to, and subsequently provided to Student.

Based on all the information presented, the Hearing Officer finds that OT is a necessary component of FAPE; however, Student’s lack of transportation to OT did not result in a denial of FAPE. The parties specifically agreed to utilize an outside agency, with the provision that the parents agreed to provide transportation and would be reimbursed for their mileage. The District was not aware that the parents were not unable to transport Student. Even if the District had been aware, it would not have been able to convene an IEP meeting to amend the provision of OT services prior to when it did. Moreover, the Parents are seeking no services or compensatory education for Student or arguing that the District failed to reimburse them for transportation. The Hearing Officer finds that the District made OT services available to Student.

c. Did the District provide Student with the Writing with Symbols Program?

The Student contends that the Writing with Symbols computer program was necessary to support his communication needs and was a component of his March 6, 2003 IEP that was memorialized in the settlement agreement on June 5, 2003. The District contends that assistive technology was never specifically listed as part of his IEP. However, the District acknowledges that there was a verbal agreement to provide the service. Furthermore, the District contends that it trained staff on Writing with Symbols and was ready to implement the program, at approximately the time of the November 14, 2003 incident.

No evidence was presented that Student needs the Writing with Symbols computer program in order to receive a FAPE. Furthermore, nowhere does the March 6, 2003 IEP or the many addendums state that Student must have this specific program. The District did, however, purchase and train the staff on the program and is ready to implement the program upon Student’s return. The Hearing Officer finds that the District initiated the computer program in conformity with the verbal agreement; therefore, since it has already purchased and trained the staff, Student should receive the service upon his return to the District.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that although Student’s BIP was designed to met his unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit, the District failed to properly implement the BIP and subsequently denied him a free appropriate public education from the June 5, 2003 settlement through November 14, 2003. The Hearing Officer further finds that the District made OT services available to Student and initiated the computer program that was requested by the parents.

2. Was the District’s placement offer at the November 18 and 25, 2003 a FAPE in the LRE for the 2003-2004 school year?

As described above, the standard for determining whether the placement offered Student a FAPE involves the following factors: whether the placement and services are designed to address Student’s unique needs, are reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit, and conform to his IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, 458 U.S. 176.)

In Rowley, the Supreme Court decided the appropriate level of instruction and services that must be provided to students with disabilities in order to satisfy the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education instruction or services, or that those services maximize a student’s potential. The Court stated that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.” (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200.) As long as a school district provides an appropriate education, methodology is left up to the school’s discretion. (Rowley at 208.) In determining whether the school district has offered a FAPE, the focus is on the adequacy of the district’s proposed program. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307(9th Cir. 1987)). If the district has offered a FAPE, the district is not required to place the student in the program preferred by the parents, even if the preferred program is likely to result in greater educational benefit. (Id.)

The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. (458 U.S. at 205). States are required to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each child with a disability receives the FAPE to which he or she is entitled and that the parents are involved in the formulation of the child’s educational placement. (W.G. v. Bd. Of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992)). Not every procedural flaw constitutes a denial of FAPE, but procedural violations that result in loss of educational opportunity to the child or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process may constitute a denial of FAPE. (W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990)).

Accordingly, the analysis of whether a student has been provided a FAPE requiring the Hearing Officer to decide whether the proposed placement is substantively appropriate and whether procedural steps have been followed. (Rowley, at 206-207).

Moreover, special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a student from the general education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in general education classes cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.)

Procedurally, the Student contends that the parents were not given adequate notice of the IEP meeting on November 18, 2003. Substantively, the Student contends that he was not offered a FAPE at the November 18 and 25, 2003 IEP meetings because the program is not designed to meet his unique needs because he requires general education peers and a general education setting. The Student additionally contends that the behavior intervention plan is inappropriate because it has not been modified from the program that was inappropriate in the general education classroom and it utilizes emergency interventions for compliance. Finally, the Student asserts that the program at Tynes Elementary School is not in the least restrictive environment.

The District asserts that Student was offered a FAPE at the November 18 and 25, 2003 IEP meetings, that the SDC class is an appropriate offer for Student and that it is designed to meet his unique needs in the least restrictive environment. The District contends that it is currently working with Rick Clemon’s Agency to develop a new FAA and BIP and until those are completed, it is inappropriate to assess the current BIP. Further, the District asserts that the parents had adequate notice and ability to participate in the IEP meetings on November 18 and 25, 2003, and in fact participated.

Procedural Safeguards--

Did the parents have appropriate notice and an opportunity for meaningful participation in the IEP process?

The Student contends that the parents were unable to fully participate in the IEP process because they were informed on November 17, 2003, of the November 18, 2003 IEP meeting. Further, the parents contend that they did not have adequate notice that the District would be recommending a more restrictive placement at the meeting on November 18, 2003. The District asserts that due to the incident on November 14, 2003, causing injury to two staff members, the District needed to convene an emergency IEP meeting and informed the parents in adequate time that the meeting would take place. Further, the District asserts that because a change in placement was recommended, the IEP meeting was reconvened on November 25, 2003, to give the parents an opportunity to observe both the placement offered by the District and an alternative placement that the parents requested. Further, the District argues that Father attended both IEP meetings and was given ample opportunity to discuss the proposed placement and to participate in the IEP meetings.

The law imposes on school districts an obligation to ensure that parents of a child with a disability are members of any group that makes decisions about the educational placement of their child (34 C.F.R. § 300.501(c)(1)), but allows school district personnel to engage in preparatory activities to develop a proposal that will be discussed at a later IEP meeting. (34 C.F.R. § 300.501(b)(2)). Under California Education Code section 56340, a school district is required to convene and conduct meetings for the purpose of developing, reviewing, and revising IEPs of each individual with exceptional needs. Under California Education Code section 56341.5 (b), parents or guardians shall be notified of the individualized education program meeting early enough to attend. There is no authority, however, that permits a school district to develop, review, or revise a child’s IEP without the benefit of an IEP team meeting. The evidence demonstrates that the District acted within these guidelines when it made its proposal for Student’s educational placement for the 2003-2004 school year.

On Friday, November 14, 2003, Student was removed from his classroom due to a behavioral outburst. Heather Bradshaw called for assistance to remove him, as per procedure, and with the assistance of Patricia Dillard and one other staff member, Student was escorted out of the classroom. During the escort, Student continued to struggle and in Ms. Bradshaw’s attempt to continue to assist Student, her wrist was sprained. Ms. Bradshaw removed her hold of Student’s arm and in the process, his leg went up in the air and he accidentally kicked Ms. Dilliard and broke her nose. Student’s parents were immediately contacted and he was suspended. The following Tuesday, the District convened an emergency IEP meeting and recommended a change in placement because Student’s behaviors had continued to escalate and he had become too big to escort out of the room as required by the BIP.

It is undisputed that an unfortunate incident occurred on November 14, 2003, and that it was necessary to convene an emergency IEP meeting. Although there was little notice, Father was able to be present and participate in the IEP team meeting. Even if the parents’ argument was correct, to be a denial of FAPE, the lack of timely notice must seriously infringe on the parents’ participation in the IEP process. Father attended the meeting, made an alternative placement suggestion, was able to visit the placement sites, and participated in a subsequent IEP meeting at a later date, November 25, 2003, to allow the parents to observe the sites and make an informed decision on the proposed placement offer. Further, the parties had previously scheduled an IEP meeting on November 25, 2003 to discuss the BIP. Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the parents had ample opportunity and ability to participate in the IEP process. The fact that the parents were not informed of the meeting until the day before and the day of does not indicate that the parents were not provided an opportunity for meaningful participation in the IEP process. The IEP meeting was continued to a later date to give the parents an opportunity to observe the schools. Father observed Tynes, the District’s choice, and Golden, the parents’ alternative option. The District continued to recommend Tynes and the parents objected to the SDC placement and than filed for due process. The Hearing Officer finds that the parents were afforded every opportunity for meaningful participation in the IEP meeting as required by California Education Code section 56341.5(a) and 34 C.F.R. section 300.501(b)(2).

Substantive Requirements-- a. Was the placement offer at the November 18 and 25, 2003 IEP meetings designed to meet Student’s unique needs and provide him with educational benefit?

The only area in dispute is the placement offer in the SDC class at Tynes. There is no dispute regarding the following elements of the offer at the November 18 and 25, 2003 IEP meeting: goals and objectives, in-home therapy, the support of a one-to-one aide, and occupational therapy and speech and language therapy needs.

Before it can be determined whether the District’s offered placement is designed to meet Student’s unique needs, it is necessary to first determine what his unique needs were at the time of the offer. Both documentary evidence and testimony of all of the witnesses established that Student is low-functioning, autistic child with mild mental retardation. Both parties agree that the Diagnostic Center Assessment conducted the week of October 27, 2003 sets forth Student’s placement needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will utilize this assessment to set forth Student’s needs in addition to uncontradicted evidence. According to the assessment, Student needs consistent use of a reinforcer menu (two to five items that Student chooses to work towards); visual supports such as a word or picture schedule; errorless learning - only ten percent of work should be new or instructional to promote successful learning; activities presented in containers and designed so that visual closure is obvious; “first-then” principle; rapid pace and tight schedule; early warning signals for problem behaviors and interventions with a break or reduction in difficult tasks. It was also undisputed that Student needs interaction with typical peers, a setting where he does not need to be removed when is having a behavior, a break area, and a sensory area.

The Student also argues that he needs a general education setting, a teacher or aide who previously has fully included a special education student, and a positive full inclusion program. The District contends that Student needs a special day class with teachers who are fully trained to deal with an autistic child and a behavior plan that does not necessitate his removal from class.

The District’s offer consists of placement in Katie Wheeler’s SDC class at Tynes Elementary School, a comprehensive campus within the District. Ms. Wheeler testified about the classroom environment. She explained that Tynes is a highly structured language based program designed for first through third grade students within the District who are mostly on the moderate to severe end of the autistic spectrum. In addition to Ms. Wheeler, there are three aides to work with seven children. There is small group, large group and individualized instruction. Children have an individualized curriculum based on their goals and objectives and cognitive abilities. The students are given grade-level curriculum or higher if the student can perform at a higher level. Throughout the day, there are numerous opportunities for social and communication skills work. Each day, general education children come into the classroom for thirty-minute sessions. The SDC students are also mainstreamed at recess, lunch, field trips, and assemblies. The SDC students are given peer buddies during mainstreaming times.

The classroom is set up with eight desks, similar to a general education setting, one-to-one workspaces, and a couple of large tables. There is a designated play area, a snack area, a break area with a beanbag, and a sensory area. There is opportunity for additional mainstreaming on the general education campus.

Ms. Wheeler has set up various reinforcers in her classroom. She first develops the individual curriculum with a general education teacher and the IEP teams. She then develops a reinforcer menu, utilizes the “first then” teaching method (first complete five questions, then receive reinforcement), does rapid pace teaching and has a positive behavior support system such as a token board. She will follow a work schedule with each student and teaches him or her to use break cards. Ms. Wheeler testified that all of the elements set forth in the Diagnostic Center Assessment could be implemented in her classroom.

The Student’s parents were not opposed to Ms. Wheeler as Student’s teacher or the benefits that the SDC could offer; however, the Parents argue that the benefits of Student interacting with typical peers outweigh the benefits of the SDC. Dr. Barbara Phillips, a professor of special education at California State University, Fullerton testified that studies have shown that a child is much more accepted by typical peer when a child is pulled out of general education rather than being in an SDC class and mainstreamed for part of the day in general education. Professor Ivor Weiner, an assistant professor of special education at California State University, Northridge, testified that he is not overly concerned with Student’s academics; rather, he needs a social curriculum because he is lacking in those skills. Rick Clemons, a full inclusion specialist, testified that full inclusion works when there is a collaborative partnership with the teacher, aide, behaviorist, parent, and administration. He explained that although Student has severe behavior problems, if he had had a staff that was trained in how to properly include Student, he would receive the full benefit of being with typical peers.

Ms. Betts testified regarding Student’s interaction in her general education classroom. Ms. Betts explained that Student followed along with the basic classroom schedule, but all the work was modified to accommodate Student’s academic levels. Student had classroom tasks that included, taking the attendance and lunch count to the office in the morning. She also did some teaching to the other students regarding children with special needs to help the children understand Student. Student was not making educational progress in her classroom. She implemented errorless learning (teaching information that Student has already learned) because Student would get frustrated and have behavioral outbursts when challenged academically. Ms. Betts felt that Student needed a teacher who was fully trained in special education and who could devote more of his or her time to working with Student. She explained that she had twenty students to be concerned with and if Student was disrupting the learning of the other nineteen students, he needed to be removed.

Ms. Betts explained that when Student was first placed in her classroom, the other students and Student were showing the benefits of his full inclusion because they all wanted to help Student and sit with him at lunch. However, as the semester progressed, the social benefits diminished and the other students would scatter away when Student began flailing and they no longer wanted to play with him. In her opinion, Student stopped gaining the social benefits of full inclusion.

Valerie Johnson of the California Diagnostic Center testified that Student’s frustration level due to his autism and cognitive abilities are impacting his communication and socialization. His behavior is likely a direct result. Ms. Johnson explained that until Student’s behaviors are under control, he would not be available for learning. Ms. Johnson testified that Student’s needs cannot be met in his present setting because his behavioral issues are so intense. He needs to learn more appropriate ways to work out his frustrations and he is frustrated academically because he cannot keep up with the academics in second grade.

The Hearing Officer notes that the parents strongly believe in the concept of full inclusion because they believe Student needs to be in an environment where he can learn from his typical peers. However, no evidence was presented that Student gained any social benefit from being full included in the past. To the contrary, he alienated himself because he had so many behavioral outbursts. His behavioral outbursts appeared to be a direct result of task avoidance when he was challenged. During his summer program, Student had no academic tasks placed upon him and he did not have any severe behavioral challenges. Student is not cognitively at the same level as his peers. The academic assignments are too challenging and he reacts to that challenge through protests of screaming, kicking, and hitting. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by Ms. Johnson’s testimony because all parties agreed that the Diagnostic Center Assessment was very thorough and accurate. The Student’s witnesses, though learned, had never assessed Student nor had they observed him in an academic setting. Student needs to be in a setting that can meet his cognitive and social needs. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s placement offer of an SDC at Tynes is designed to meet his unique needs and will provide him educational benefit because he will be in a setting where he does not have to be removed due to his behavioral outbursts.

Behavior Plan

The Student contends that the behavior intervention plan that the District offered is not designed to meet his needs because it restrains him in order to ensure his compliance with a task and has not been modified for an SDC placement. The District contends that the behavior intervention plan is appropriate and will be revised in accordance with the findings of the FAA that is in the process of being completed by Rick Clemons agency. However, the parties understand that the FAA cannot be completed until Student is attending a school setting and because the parents have chosen to keep Student out of school pending this decision, the FAA and behavior intervention plan are put on hold.

In this case, the District contracted with CARD to complete an FAA and develop a BIP. As previously found, the BIP was appropriate in a general education setting; however, the District failed to properly implement the BIP. The recommendation is for Student to be placed in an SDC where he would not have to be removed from the classroom setting for maladaptive behaviors and the current BIP does not address this aspect. However, the parties are currently undergoing a new FAA with a different outside organization. There is no further order that the Hearing Officer can make aside from ordering a new FAA and new BIP based on the new placement which is already agreed to and will be undertaken upon Student’s return to school in the District. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will order that the District complete the new FAA and implement a new BIP in accordance with the findings of this Decision.

Furthermore, the Hearing Officer is persuaded by the District’s witnesses and Ms. Johnson’s testimony and report that even if Student’s BIP had been appropriately implemented in the general education classroom, he currently needs a more restrictive environment because he needs the benefits of the SDC class such as: no removal for behavioral outbursts, a break and sensory area, and teachers and staff who have specific training to work with autistic children.

Is the placement in the Least Restrictive Environment?

The Student objects to placement at Tynes because it is a special day class (SDC) with no opportunities for participation in a general education program or for mainstreaming. Student asserts that all the classroom accommodations can be properly implemented in a general education classroom setting if the BIP is appropriate and the school staff believes in full inclusion. Student asserts that he requires role models who are general education students and that the general education students benefit from having him in the classroom. The District contends that Tynes is the most appropriate placement for Student because his behaviors are so extreme that they are getting in the way of his being able to access his education. The District asserts that Student is not cognitively functioning at grade level and he is being removed from the classroom setting so often that it is disrupting Student’s education and the education of the other children. The District asserts that Student will be able to be in a placement where he does not have to be removed due to maladaptive behaviors and he will be able to continue to access his education. Furthermore, the District contends that Student will have both mainstreaming and reverse mainstreaming opportunities throughout the day.

Special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a student from the general education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in general education classes cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.) In determining whether disabled children should be placed in a general classroom with supplemental aids and services, the courts have created a four-part test that requires consideration of the following facts: (1) the academic benefits available to the disabled student in a general education classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared with the academic benefits of a special education classroom; (2) the non-academic benefits of interaction with children who are not disabled; (3) the effect of the disabled student’s presence on the teacher and other children in the classroom; and (4) the cost of mainstreaming the disabled student in a general education classroom. (Sacramento Unified School District v. Holland 14 F.3d 1398 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 114 S.Ct. 2679 (1994)).

(1) The academic benefits available to the disabled student in a general education classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared with the academic benefits of a special education classroom.

When Student was in school, he had an aide with him full-time and she removed him from class whenever he began to have a behavioral problem. Student also worked one-on-one out of the class with his speech and language pathologist, the resource specialist, and his one-on-one aide for approximately two and a half hours a day; consequently, he was out of class more than in class. When he was in class, he was working on a modified curriculum. He occasionally joined in during floor time and during small group rotations when the small group worked with his teacher. During all times, the teacher and aide either modified his work, or he was given completely different work that was at his level. The teacher implemented errorless learning because Student had difficulty with new tasks and new academic challenges.

Student has not had a significant amount of education in a classroom setting since September 2003 when his behaviors began to get out of control. Student was unable to access his education while placed in a general education curriculum due to his behaviors. The Hearing Officer finds that the academic benefits available to Student in the SDC classroom far outweigh the academic benefits from the general education classroom. Student needs to be in an SDC rather than the general education setting because his behaviors have so impacted his ability to access the general education curriculum. Further, the Hearing Officer finds that the structure and behavioral support that Student will receive in the SDC will enable him to obtain academic progress.

(2) The non-academic benefits of interaction with children who are not disabled.

The program at Tynes is a self-contained SDC for children who are on the moderate to severe end of the autistic spectrum. There is ample opportunity to interact with non-disabled peers through reverse mainstreaming and mainstreaming at lunch and recess. Student has always been in a general education classroom, but in the last year his behaviors have been so extreme that he has been removed from the classroom for the majority of the day. The parents argue that Student did well eating lunch with non-disabled peers, interacting well on the playground, lining up when the bell rang and that he was well-behaved during silent reading. The parties all agree that Student enjoys interacting with other children. However, there was no testimony that Student needs to be with non-disabled peers in order to develop his social skills. In fact, the aides and school staff testified that Student is motivated by the adults and did not have much interaction with the other children while in his classroom. Furthermore, most of the parents’ arguments as to why Student should be in a general education classroom are based on the social benefits he receives at recess and lunch. Placement in the SDC will not preclude him from mainstreaming during the recess and lunch periods.

Furthermore, the aides and school staff testified that some of the children became afraid of Student and did not want to sit next to him in class anymore. Student’s behaviors began to interfere with his ability to make friends and truly be part of the classroom environment.

The Hearing Officer finds that Student would receive greater benefit in developing peer relationships in the SDC classroom than the general education setting where his behaviors impeded his ability to interact with his peers. Further, Student will continue to have the ability to interact with non-disabled peers during the times that have been most beneficial to him in the past.

(3) The effect of the disabled student’s presence on the teacher and other children in the classroom.

Student has severe behavior problems. During his second-grade year, he screamed, kicked, hit, threw pencils, fell to the floor flailing, refused to comply with his work by avoiding being held and was removed from the classroom on a daily basis. During his removal on November 14, 2003, he struggled so much that one of the staff sprained her wrist and his foot came in contact with Ms. Dilliard’s nose, causing her nose to break. While Student was placed in the general education setting, he was extremely disruptive to the students, teachers, school staff, and the entire student population on the Sierra Vista. At the beginning of the school year, the students in Student’s class were all volunteering to eat lunch with Student and wanted to sit next to him and help him with the work. However, as his behaviors became more frequent and more aggressive, the children started backing away from him. He was constantly removed from the classroom by two or even three adults and taken to the multi-purpose room on campus. He physically hit his aides and ended up accidentally injuring two staff members. The children no longer volunteered to sit next to him. The other students in his class began to cover the ears to avoid high-pitched screams; Ms. Brady testified that the some the other student’s grades went down as the semester progressed. The parents of the other children asked the teacher to not have their sons or daughters placed next to Student for fear of getting hurt, and finally, after the incident on November 14, 2003, the parents all called each other and began a campaign to the school board to have Student removed from the classroom. When the parents disagreed with the IEPs on November 18 and 25, the District went to the court to request a temporary restraining order so that Student would not be permitted to return to the school pending the due process hearing.

In this case, Student was not successful in general education. He was disruptive to his classmates, his school, and most importantly to himself. He needs a program where the teachers are specially trained to deal with low functioning autistic students and the resulting behaviors. Ms. Wheeler and the paraeducators assigned to her classroom have special training to work specifically on assisting Student in accessing his education despite his behavioral challenges. Ms. Wheeler has previously worked with Student as an aide and understands his needs. The Hearing Officer finds that the effect of Student’s presence on the general education students and teacher to be severely disruptive and unsuitable.

(4) The cost of mainstreaming the disabled student in a general education classroom.

This is not a factor that was raised in this Decision.

Based on the above analysis of the Holland factors, the Hearing Officer finds that the offered placement at Tynes provides Student a FAPE in the least restrictive environment for the 2003-2004 regular school year. Because the parties are currently in the process of undergoing a new FAA and BIP, the Hearing Officer orders that the District take the above findings into consideration when implementing the BIP in the new setting.

ORDERS

1. The District shall implement the November 18 and 25, 2003 IEP in the SDC at Tynes Elementary School.

2. The District shall complete the FAA and develop a new BIP within 20 calendar days of this Decision.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507 (d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with the statute:

1. Did the District fail to provide Student with a Free Appropriate Public Education (FAPE) from September through November 14, 2003?

Was the behavior intervention plan properly developed and implemented?

The District prevailed on the development of the BIP. The Student prevailed on the implementation of the BIP.

Did the District provide occupational therapy?

The District prevailed on this issue.

Did the District provide computer services?

The District prevailed on this issue.

2. Was the District’s placement offer at the November 18 and 25, 2003 IEP meetings a FAPE in the least restrictive environment (LRE) for the 2003-2004 school year?

The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. California Education Code § 56505 (i).

Date: March 5, 2004 ______________________________________Jessica Katz, Hearing OfficerCalifornia Special Education Hearing Office

1. Two of Student’s siblings have been diagnosed with high-functioning autism.

2 Although settlement agreements are generally intended to be confidential, the parties introduced the settlement agreement into evidence and waived the confidentiality.

3 Ms. Peterson has worked with Student since November 2002 and was trained by CARD to provide both in home and school services.

4 Hand-over-hand manipulation was described as physically guiding Student’s hand to assist him to complete the task such as holding the pencil in Student’s hand and making him write.

5 Rick Clemons Agency is an organization that the parents requested the District utilize to conduct the FAA and create a BIP because the agency specializes in full inclusion.

6 The parents strongly believe in the concept of full inclusion. They have attended a number of conferences and believe that placement in a general education classroom is the most beneficial to Student. Further, the parents have two other children who are high-functioning autistic and who have been successfully fully included in general education.

7 Father underwent cancer treatment during the spring and summer of 2003.