California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 23, 2002
Student v. San Dieguito Union High School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 2506-02 · Hearing Officer Sherianne Laba
San Dieguito Union High must add a transition plan and repay half of Balboa tuition from October 2002; other claims denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The decision notes that an earlier case, SN02-00636, covering the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years, was resolved through mediation. No remand, vacatur, or correction is noted.
Summary
The San Dieguito Union High School District filed for due process to show that its July 2002 IEP offered a 15-year-old student a FAPE for 2002-2003. The student is eligible under emotional disturbance and has school-related anxiety. His parents had placed him at Balboa Secondary School, a nonpublic school, and cross-filed for reimbursement and continued placement there. The District offered Torrey Pines High School, with a Learning Center special day class for one-third of the day plus counseling. The Hearing Officer found that the Balboa director's participation by phone met the IEP team requirement. She also found that the needs, goals, benchmarks, placement, counseling, and accommodations were appropriate. However, the student needed a written plan to transition from a nonpublic school to an unfamiliar public campus, and the IEP had none. Balboa met his needs, so reimbursement was available. The parents paid the deposit and September tuition before the District made its offer, so those costs were denied. The parents also did not share their concerns or their intent to stay at Balboa for seven weeks despite District requests, so the Hearing Officer cut reimbursement by 50%. She ordered the District to hold an IEP meeting within 25 days to write a transition plan, to invite and pay the student's psychologist, and to repay half of tuition from October 1, 2002 to that meeting. She denied prospective placement at Balboa. She also refused to exclude a witness's testimony or to sanction Student's counsel for giving that witness part of a transcript.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO treated a missing transition plan from a nonpublic school to public school under Education Code section 56345(b)(4) as a curable defect. It also shows how the Hearing Officer denied reimbursement for costs paid before the IEP offer. Separately, she cut the award because the parents did not share their concerns during the IEP process.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue I.A. Did the District commit a procedural violation by failing to have a teacher from Balboa present at the IEP meeting?
The Balboa director's telephone participation satisfied any requirement that a special education provider of the student attend; no procedural violation.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue I.B. Did the District misidentify Student's unique needs, offer appropriate goals and objectives with baselines and measurable benchmarks?
Needs were undisputed and correctly identified; the seven goals addressed all needs, were based on the private psychologist's report, and had measurable benchmarks; law did not require numerical baselines.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue I.C. Is the District's offer of placement inappropriate because it is on a campus that is too large, does not provide for adequate counseling, and does not have appropriate accommodations?
The Torrey Pines Learning Center plus general education placement, counseling exceeding the treating psychologist's recommendation, and listed accommodations including homework modification were appropriate.
- Student prevailedTransition
Issue I.D. Does Student require a transition plan?
Given his school-related anxiety and a move to an unfamiliar campus, Student needed a written transition plan; the Learning Center's unwritten 'built in' plan did not suffice, but the defect could be cured at an IEP meeting.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue II.A. Is Student entitled to reimbursement for the cost of his placement at Balboa from the start of the 2002-2003 school year until the date of this Decision?
Balboa was appropriate, but the deposit and September tuition paid before the IEP offer were denied, and October-onward tuition was cut 50% because the parents did not take part in the IEP process in good faith.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue II.B. Should Student be placed at Balboa for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year?
Prospective placement at Balboa was denied because the District substantially offered FAPE and the only defect could be fixed right away.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 25 calendar days of the order, the District must convene an IEP meeting to develop an appropriate transition plan for Student's immediate transition to a public high school campus.
- The District must invite Dr. Perlman to the IEP meeting and, if he attends, pay him his standard hourly rate for attending and participating.
- Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days of the decision, the District must reimburse the parents for 50% of the cost of Balboa attendance from October 1, 2002 through the date of the ordered IEP meeting. The deposit ($1,102.50) and September 2002 tuition ($1,102.50) are denied.
Key authorities
Board of Education v. Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23; Amanda J. v. Clark County School District; Adams v. State of Oregon; School Committee of Town of Burlington v. Department of Education; Florence County School District Four v. Carter; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education; Union School District v. Smith; People v. Valdez; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District
People named in the decision
- Torrie Norton, director of pupil personnel services, San Dieguito Union High School District
- Mary Ellen Nest, coordinator of special education (District witness), San Dieguito Union High School District
- Rienzi Haytasingh, school psychologist (District witness), San Dieguito Union High School District
- Mitchel Perlman, Ph.D., clinical psychologist; student's treating clinician and independent evaluator; expert witness for Student, Private
- Stephen Parker, Ph.D., director and founder of nonpublic school; witness for Student, Balboa Secondary School
- Patricia Cromer, Student's former attorney at July 2002 IEP meeting
- Balboa Secondary School, certified nonpublic school (parental placement)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Sherianne Laba, Hearing Officer, California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Encinitas, California, on November 19, 20, and 21, and December 3, 2002.
The San Dieguito Union High School District (hereinafter referred to as District) was represented by attorney Jonathan Read. Also present on the District’s behalf was Torrie Norton, director of pupil personnel services. STUDENT (hereinafter referred to as STUDENT or Student) was represented by attorney Eric Freedus. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf were his parents FATHER and MOTHER.
The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Mary Ellen Nest, coordinator of special education; and Rienzi Haytasingh, school psychologist. The Student called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: FATHER, Mitchel Perlman, Ph.D., clinical psychologist; and Stephen Parker, Ph.D., director and founder of Balboa Secondary School (Balboa).
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
I. Has the District offered STUDENT a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2002-2003 school year? (Footnote 1)
II If the District has not offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, is he entitled to reimbursement for, and prospective placement at, Balboa Secondary School (Balboa), a certified non-public school?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
Motion to Exclude Testimony of Stephen Parker, Ph.D.(Footnote 2)
The hearing in this matter commenced on November 19, 2002. On November 21, 2002, the Student called Dr. Perlman, the Student’s treating psychiatrist. Dr. Perlman provided extensive testimony, lasting the entire day, on the Student’s history, current needs, current progress, and his opinion regarding the goals and objectives and placement offered by the District. At the end of Dr. Perlman’s testimony the Hearing Officer, as she did with all witnesses, admonished the witness not to discuss his testimony with any other witness who had yet to testify in this matter.
On the fourth day of hearing (December 3, 2002) the Student called Dr. Parker, director of Balboa, the Student’s current educational placement. During Dr. Parker’s testimony, it came to the attention of the Hearing Officer and the District, through an admission made by Dr. Parker, that in preparation for the hearing, he had been provided a verbatim transcript Dr. Perlman’s testimony. However, this verbatim transcript was not a transcript of the official record of the hearing. Mr. Freedus had been recording the hearing for his own records and over the Thanksgiving break had Dr. Pearlman’s testimony transcribed and provided a portion of that testimony (approximately twenty pages) to Dr. Parker.
Upon learning that the admonishment given to Dr. Perlman had been violated and that Dr. Parker’s testimony was potentially colored by the actions of Mr. Freedus, the District moved to exclude Dr. Parker’s testimony in its entirety. While Mr. Freedus acknowledged circumventing the Hearing Officer’s order, he argued that no actual violation of the Hearing Officer’s admonishment had occurred because Dr. Perlman did not discuss his testimony with Dr. Parker. The Student further argued that regardless of any perceived violation of the Hearing Officer’s admonishment, the information provided was unrelated to Dr. Parker’s testimony and therefore did not affect his testimony.
The Hearing Officer and the District were provided a copy of twenty pages of verbatim transcript that were faxed to Dr. Parker. The Hearing Officer questioned Dr. Parker about the extent of his review of the document. Dr. Parker testified that the document he received was much shorter than that provided to the Hearing Officer and the District. Dr. Parker reviewed the twenty page document and confirmed that he did receive a portion of that document. Dr. Parker initialed each page that he recalled reading. (HO Ex. 1). Dr. Parker testified reliably that he had received and reviewed only eight of the twenty pages. (Test. of Parker) Upon further review of the eight pages that Dr. Parker actually reviewed, the pages at issue related to the goals and objectives that the District had drafted for STUDENT. Dr. Parker did not testify about the adequacy of the goals and objectives; therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Parker’s testimony remains fundamentally untainted and that no possible prejudice occurred.
One of the purposes for exclusion of witnesses in a closed due process hearing can be compared in theory and practice to the exclusion of witnesses at trial. The purpose of excluding witnesses is to ensure that the testimony of each witness is based upon his own recollection or knowledge and not affected by any testimony the witness has heard or read. If an order of exclusion is made at hearing, and that order is knowingly disobeyed, the Hearing Officer has the power to refuse to admit the testimony of the witness affected. (emphasis added) People v. Valdez, (1986) 177 Cal. App. 3d 680, 687. In this case, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded that Mr. Freedus’ actions, while unprofessional and inappropriate, were in knowing disobedience to the Hearing Officer’s admonishment. Mr. Freedus believed he was simply providing Dr. Parker with information on the goals and objectives that the District had proposed. (Dec. of Freedus). This position is supported by the fact that at the hearing Mr. Freedus did not question Dr. Parker about the goals and objectives. Therfore, Dr. Parker’s testimony will not be excluded.
Another appropriate remedy for actions which violate a hearing officer’s order or instructions is the imposition of sanctions against the violating attorney. Under State law, a hearing officer presiding over a special education due process hearing may order a party, the party’s attorney, or other authorized representative, or both, to pay reasonable expenses, including attorney’s fees, incurred by another party as a result of bad faith actions or tactics that are frivolous or intended solely to cause unnecessary delay (emphasis added) as defined in California Code of Civil Procedure Section 128.5. Cal. Code. Regs. tit. 5, § 3088; Cal. Gov’t Code § 11455.30(a), or the presiding hearing officer may initiate contempt sanctions with the court. In this case, while Mr. Freedus’ actions had the purpose of circumventing the Hearing Officer’s instructions, as discussed above, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded that Mr. Freedus’ actions were frivolous, done in bad faith, done in an effort to delay the hearing, or warrant contempt sanctions. Consequently, in this instance, no sanctions will be imposed. However, Mr. Freedus should take care that no such incident occur again as another presiding hearing officer might not be so tolerant.
In conclusion, the District’s motion to excluded the testimony of Dr. Parker, either partially or in its entirety, is denied. Furthermore, sanctions in this particular instance will not be imposed.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a fifteen-year-old student who lives within the jurisdictional boundaries of the San Dieguito Union High School District. STUDENT was identified as eligible for special education services, under the category of emotional disturbance (ED), during the 2001-2002 school year.
During the 2001-2002 school year STUDENT attended Carmel Valley Middle School. From the start of the 2001-2002 school year until January 2002, STUDENT’s difficulties escalated, his behavior at home deteriorated, his school attendance decreased, and he had several suicide attempts. In January 2002, STUDENT’s parents obtained an independent psychological evaluation from Dr. Perlman who diagnosed STUDENT with a major depressive disorder and extreme anxiety related to school. Dr. Perlman suggested that due to STUDENT’s school anxiety his parents should consider placement in a non-public school. STUDENT’s parents followed Dr. Perlman’s advice, and after investigating several school sites, enrolled STUDENT at Balboa in April 2002. STUDENT remained at Balboa until the end of the 2001-2002 school year.
Currently, STUDENT is attending Balboa school. His behaviors at home continue to fluctuate and he continues to have violent outbursts aimed at his brother, and the family dog. While he has not had any actual suicide attempts, STUDENT continues to make statements about not being around anymore, which would suggest that he still experiences suicidal ideations. Despite the continued fluctuations in behaviors, STUDENT’s behaviors have improved enough to discontinue his individual counseling sessions and move to family oriented counseling services. Lastly, academically STUDENT is still achieving in the above average to superior range.
STUDENT’s parents initially filed for a due process hearing to determine whether the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years. That case (SN02-00636) was resolved through mediation. Pursuant to that mediation agreement an individualized education plan (IEP) meeting was held in July to determine STUDENT’s placement for the 2002-2003 school year. At the July 2002 IEP meeting, the District offered STUDENT placement on a District high school campus, with support of a learning center. STUDENT’s parents disagreed with the placement offered by the District and re-enrolled him at Balboa. In October 2002 the District filed for due process to establish that the program it offered STUDENT for the 2002-2003 school year was appropriate. STUDENT cross-filed to obtain reimbursement for, and prospective placement at, Balboa for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year. The cases were consolidated and proceeded to hearing.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
I. Has the District offered STUDENT a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2002-2003 school year?
Student contends that the District failed both procedurally and substantively to offer him a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year. Student asserts that the District committed procedural violations by failing to have a teacher from Balboa present at the IEP meeting. Student asserts that the District substantively failed to offer him a FAPE by misidentifying his needs; failing to provide properly written goals and objectives; and failing to offer an appropriate placement, counseling services, accommodations, and a transition plan to meet his needs. As a result of these violations, the Student seeks reimbursement for the cost of securing his placement at Balboa including his placement there from September 2002 until the date of this Decision. Additionally, the Student seeks an order requiring the District to fund his placement at Balboa for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year.
The District contends that it did not commit a procedural violation because the IEP meeting had all the required members present. The District also contends that it offered STUDENT FAPE in all aspects for the 2002-2003 school year. Therefore, the District asserts that STUDENT is not entitled to reimbursement for, nor prospective placement at, Balboa.
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) students with disabilities have the right to FAPE. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Calif. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge, that meet the standard of the state education agency, and that conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court determined that to receive a FAPE, the student’s program must be designed to meet the unique needs of the student and be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit.
The Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural protections afforded by the IDEA, which are designed to ensure effective parental participation in the IEP process and careful consideration of a student’s educational needs. However, not every procedural flaw constitutes a denial of a FAPE. Procedural flaws must result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s participation in the IEP process to constitute a denial of a FAPE. Rowley, 458 U.S., at 206-207; See also W.G. v. B.D. of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F. 2d 1479, 1483-1484; Amanda J v. Clark County Sch. Dist. (9th Cir. 2001) 267 F. 3d 877.
In summary, to determine whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE, the Hearing Officer must analyze (a) whether the District complied with the procedural requirements of the IDEA and (b) whether the IEP and resulting placement were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and provide him with some educational benefit.(Footnote 3) The Hearing Officer first looks to the allegation related to procedural violations.
PROCEDURAL APPROPRIATENESS(Footnote 4)
Did the District fail to have a teacher from Balboa present at the IEP meeting?
The Student asserts that a teacher from Balboa should have been present at the July IEP meeting. The District asserts that all required members of the IEP team were present at the IEP meeting. State and federal law require that the IEP team include at least one special education teacher of the pupil, or if appropriate, at least one special education provider of the pupil. (emphasis added) 20 U.S.C. 1414(d)(1)(B); Calif. Educ. Code. §56341.
Present at the July IEP meeting were both a District special education teacher and Stephen Parker, Ph.D., the director at Balboa, who participated via telephone. (D1; Test. of Parker and Nest ). Dr. Parker regularly participates, on behalf of his staff, in IEP meetings. (Test. of Parker and Nest). Additionally, Dr Parker had personal knowledge of STUDENT, his needs, and his present levels of performance. (Test. of Parker).
Whether or not the law required the District was required to have a teacher from Balboa present is of no consequence since Dr. Parker’s presence at the IEP meeting via telephone satisfied any requirement that a special education provider be present at the IEP meeting and therefore, there was no procedural violation. Having concluded that the District did not commit a procedural violation, as alleged by the Student, the Hearing Officer now turns to the substantive appropriateness of the IEP.
SUBSTANTIVE APPROPRIATENESS
To determine whether the District’s offer of placement constitutes a FAPE, the Hearing Officer must first identify STUDENT’s unique needs. STUDENT argues that the District did not have sufficient information available to properly identify his needs and consequently misidentified his needs.
Unique Needs
To determine STUDENT’s unique needs, it is first necessary to identify what STUDENT’s present levels of performance were at the time the July IEP was developed. Adams v. State of Oregon (9th Cir. 1999) 195 F. 3d 1141. At the time the July IEP was developed, STUDENT had been attending private school for three months, and had not attended a public school for six months. (Test. of FATHER and Nest). Because STUDENT had not attended a District school for six months, the present levels of performance identified on the IEP were based on information extracted from Dr. Perlman’s report dated January/February 2002; a county mental health (CMH) report dated June 21, 2002; and information obtained from Dr. Parker and STUDENT’s parents. (D1; D4; D5; Test. of Nest, FATHER, and Parker). No evidence was presented to indicate that the District should have conducted further assessments or that the information available to the District was inaccurate in any way.
Multiple witnesses testified regarding STUDENT’s unique needs. All witnesses agreed that STUDENT did not have specific academic needs because STUDENT’s academic abilities were in the above average to superior range. Instead, STUDENT’s unique needs are almost entirely in the social-emotional area. Ms. Nest, Mr. Haytasignh, and Dr. Perlman testified that STUDENT had unique needs in the areas of task completion, organization, social-emotional, interpersonal social relationships, and problem solving. Each of these needs was identified in the IEP. (D1) Moreover, despite the arguments raised by Mr. Freedus, that the IEP did not correctly identify STUDENT’s needs, Mr. FATHER testified that he agreed with the present levels of performance and the areas of need identified in the IEP. Mr. FATHER only added that STUDENT is very aware of how he is perceived by others, does not want to be considered different than the other students, and wants to fit in with other students.
The Hearing Officer finds that based upon Mr. FATHER’s testimony there is no actual dispute about STUDENT’s unique needs. The needs identified by Mr. FATHER are all included in the IEP; therefore, the IEP appropriately identified STUDENT’s needs. The undisputed areas of need included in the IEP are: a challenging academic curriculum; assistance in addressing his low tolerance for frustration, his limited ability to manage interpersonal relationships, his chronic mood disturbance, depression, anxiety, and suicidal ideation; task completion; and learning to accept help from others. The Hearing Officer now turns to whether the goals and objectives address those unique needs and are designed to provide some educational benefit.
Goals and Objectives
Pursuant to Rowley and the IDEA, goals and objectives must be designed to meet a student’s unique needs and to confer educational benefit. California Education Code section 56345 further provides that the IEP must include measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives related to the student’s needs, and must enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. The Student argues that the goals and objectives offered were deficient because: they did not address each of his areas of need; there are no identified ‘baselines’; and the benchmarks are unmeasurable. Each of these assertions will be addressed below.
Are all areas of need addressed?
The July IEP contains seven goals and objectives. (D1) The goals address increasing self-esteem and self worth, increasing interaction with peers, decreasing feelings of distress, improving organizational skills, improving note taking skills, learning problem solving skills, and increasing ability to seek out assistance. The goals and objectives contained in the IEP were based on the recommendations made by Dr. Perlman in his report and adapted to the IEP by the IEP team. (Test. of Perlman, Parker, Nest, and Haytasingh). There is no dispute that STUDENT’s academic ability is above average to superior and all evaluators agreed that he did not have academic needs. (Test. of Nest, Haytasignh, FATHER, and Perlman).
STUDENT’s undisputed needs identified in the IEP are assistance in addressing his low tolerance for frustration, his limited ability to manage interpersonal relationships, his chronic mood disturbance, depression, anxiety, and suicidal ideation; task completion; and learning to accept help from others. The first and third goals, (increasing self esteem and self worth and decreasing feelings of distress and anxiety) relate to STUDENT’s low tolerance for frustration, depression, and anxiety. (D1; D5; Test. of Perlman and Nest). The second goal, (increasing interactions with peers) relates to STUDENT’s need to learn to manage interpersonal relationships and to accept help from others (D1; D5; Test. of Perlman and Nest). Goals four through seven, (using class notebooks to record assignments, taking notes, verbalize problem solving strategies, and seeking assistance from authority figures) relate to STUDENT’s need to improve note taking skills, learn problem solving skills, increase organizational skills, and increase his ability to seek out assistance. (D1; D5; Test. of Perlman and Nest).
Because each of the identified goals directly relates to the undisputed needs identified in the IEP and no persuasive evidence was presented to indicate that STUDENT has other needs which are not addressed by the goals, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives offered address all of STUDENT’s unique needs. Having determined that the goals address all areas of need, the Hearing Officer turns to whether the goals have an identified ‘baseline’.
Does each goal and objective have an identified ‘baseline’?
The Student argues that the goals and objectives are inappropriate because they do not have measurable baselines. However, the IDEA and state law do not specify that each goal must have a measurable baseline. The IDEA and State law require that an IEP contain a statement of measureable annual goals, include benchmarks or short term objectives. (20 U.S.C. 1414; 34 C.F.R. 300.347; Calif. Educ. Code 56345) The purpose of goals and objectives with benchmarks is to provide the student’s parents, teachers, and school administrators with a reference point upon which to later measure a student’s progress. (34 C.F.R. 300.347; Appendix A, Rederal Register, 12471) In this case, each of the seven goals written in the July 24, 2002 IEP is based upon a specific deficit or area of need which is intended to serve as the starting point for measuring STUDENT’s progress. (Test. of Nest and Haytasingh).
STUDENT’s case is unique in that unlike cases that involve deficits in specific academic areas, STUDENT’s needs are generally psychological in nature and not academic. With academic needs, districts can administer standardized tests to identify the student’s exact level of achievement and attach a numerical value to the level of achievement. In this case, no standardized test can be administered that would provide a numerical value to serve as a starting point for measuring STUDENT’s psychological functioning level. Instead, the District appropriately relied upon Dr. Perlman’s report in determining the goals and objectives (D1; Test. of Perlman). As stated earlier, there is no dispute that the needs identified in Dr. Perlman’s report are accurate. Since the goals and objectives are formulated from those needs, the Hearing Officer finds that goals and objectives are appropriately written to address STUDENT’s needs. The Hearing Officer now turns to the Student’s final contention related to goals and objectives, that is, are the benchmarks measurable?
Are the benchmarks measurable?
The purpose of benchmarks is to allow the IEP team to develop and implement a student’s IEP and to judge a student’s progress at regular intervals. Generally, benchmarks are used to establish the expected performance level that would lead to completion of the annual goal. (34 C.F.R. 300.347; Appendix A, Federal Register, 12471). As discussed above, STUDENT’s case is unique because his goals are not measurable by standardized testing. Therefore, the benchmarks written must be specific enough for STUDENT’s parents, teachers, and the District to determine, at regular intervals, whether STUDENT is making progress toward his goals.
Each of the seven goals written for STUDENT contains three benchmarks. (D1) Each of the benchmarks contains three components. (D1) First the benchmarks identify what is to be measured, and are generally written as “STUDENT will demonstrate the ability to do the above mentioned goal.” (D1) Second, each benchmark provides a specific required number of successful attempts at the mentioned goal. The benchmarks increase in difficulty at regular intervals, ultimately reaching the goals as written. (D1) Last, each goal identifies the school personnel responsible for completing the measurements for the benchmark. (D1; Test. of Nest and Haytasingh).
As stated above, the purpose of benchmarks is to provide a method for measuring progress. The evidence supports the finding that the benchmarks as written satisfy this purpose and no persuasive evidence was presented to indicate that the benchmarks as written could not provide information on STUDENT’s progress. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the benchmarks are appropriately written. Having addressed each of the Student’s allegations and having found that goals and objectives were appropriately drafted to address STUDENT’s unique needs, the Hearing Officer turns to whether the goals and objectives were designed to confer some educational benefit.
As discussed above, STUDENT does not have specific academic deficits. To the contrary, all witnesses testified that STUDENT’s academic abilities are in the above average to superior range and he is focused on attending college at Stanford University. Rather the brunt of STUDENT’s needs are a result of his severe emotional needs, described as school phobia, which affect his education. (Test. of Perlman). Dr. Perlman described STUDENT as a student who puts so much pressure on himself to achieve that he creates extreme levels of anxiety within himself. This anxiety does not manifest itself at school, but rather in the home environment in the form of tantrums, school avoidance, and suicidal ideation. (Test. of Perlman, Parker, and FATHER). Therefore, in addition to meeting his unique needs, in order to receive educational benefit, STUDENT requires goals and objectives to decrease his feelings of anxiety, increase his coping mechanisms, reduce his suicidal ideation, decrease his school phobia, increase his ability to complete tasks, and increase his organizational skills. (D1: Test. of Perlman).
The seven goals drafted for STUDENT specifically address these areas of need. The evidence supports the finding that the goals are designed to decrease STUDENT’s school phobia by increasing his success in the school environment. Accomplishing these goals will allow him to be successful in a school setting and therefore meet STUDENT’s unique needs and are calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives are designed to confer educational benefit to STUDENT. In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives address each of STUDENT’s unique needs, are appropriately written, and are designed to confer educational benefit and satisfy the requirements of Rowley, the IDEA, and comparable State law. Therefore, the Hearing Officer turns to the appropriateness of the District offer of placement and services.
Placement and Services
To be appropriate under the IDEA, a district’s proposed program must have been reasonably calculated to meet the unique needs of the student and provide him with some educational benefit. Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 200. While this requires a school district to provide a disabled child with meaningful access to education, it does not mean that the school district is required to guarantee totally successful results. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District (2d Cir. 1998) 142 F. 3d 119, 133. De minimus benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Id. At 130; M.C. v. Central Regional School District (3d Cir. 1996) 81 F. 3d 389, 393. However, a child’s academic program must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. Mrs. B v. Milford Board of Education (2d Cor. 1997) 103 F. 3d 1114, 1121; Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16 (3d Cir. 1988) 853 F. 2d 171, 185.
The Student argues that the District’s offer of placement and services does not address his unique needs and will not provide him with some educational benefit because the placement offered is on a campus that is too large, does not provide adequate counseling services or accommodations, and lacks a transition plan. Each of these contentions will be discussed separately.
Is the campus offered too large?
The Student did not argue and no evidence was presented to indicate that he requires a small group setting to learn. Instead, the Student argues that because of his previous failures on a campus of one-thousand students, to place him on a campus with upwards of three thousand students is inappropriate.
The District has offered STUDENT placement at Torrey Pines High School (Torrey Pines). (D1). The offered placement at Torrey Pines is the Learning Center program thirty-three percent of the day and in regular education for the remainder of the school day. (D1). Ms Nest described the Learning Center as a special day class (SDC) program designed for above average students who need additional assistance coping with school. The enrollment cap in the learning center, which is staffed by one special education teacher and an aide, is twelve students, but typically there are no more than four students in the classroom at one time. (Test. of Nest). Students enrolled in the Learning Center attend regular education courses for the majority of the school day and come to the Learning Center either for direct instruction in a particular subject or for the student requires a ‘safe haven’. (Test. of Nest).
Mr. FATHER testified that STUDENT requires a program that will provide him with a nurturing environment in a general education setting. STUDENT also requires that his placement provide him with a comfort level that will minimize his feelings of anxiety and increase his trust in the administrators of the program. (Test. of FATHER). According to Dr. Parker and Dr. Perlman, to be successful in his educational setting, STUDENT requires a learning environment that will support his emotional needs. This means that the program STUDENT is enrolled in must have a significant level of supervision and be a program that is not too rigid but is flexible enough to address his ever changing level of anxiety and frustration. Additionally, the personnel who work with STUDENT must be aware of his difficulties and, because STUDENT does not ask for assistance or outwardly demonstrate his frustration, be able to intervene when necessary. (Test. of Perlman and Parker). Finally, according to Dr. Perlman and Mr. Haytasingh, students such as STUDENT, with school phobia, cannot be isolated from the general learning environment. In order for STUDENT to overcome his phobia it is necessary to integrate him into a general learning environment; however this must be done cautiously so as to avoid regression, acting out, and self-injurious behaviors.
Mr. Haytasingh, testified that the District’s Learning Center program will provide STUDENT with a learning environment that not only provides him with academic challenges but also addresses his comfort and trust issues. The teachers and case managers assigned to the learning center do not have a large caseload which allows for more one-to-one contact and intervention with the students. (Test. of Haytasingh). Because of this increased level of contact, STUDENT’s teachers and case manager will be better able to develop an understanding of him, identify his stressors, and assist him with coping with his school related phobia and anxiety. (Test. of Haytasingh).
The District’s offer of placement provides that the Learning Center would be available to STUDENT for a minimum of two periods per day, with additional time as needed. (Test. of Nest). According to Ms. Nest, in STUDENT’s case, the Learning Center would not be specifically utilized for small group instruction, although this remains available as needed, but would provide STUDENT with group counseling, assistance with homework, and an outlet when he becomes frustrated or anxious. (D1; Test. of Nest). Additionally, the special education teacher or the classroom aide from the Learning Center would be available to accompany STUDENT to his general education classes to further assist him. (Test. of Nest).
Both Dr. Perlman and Dr. Parker have testified extensively about STUDENT’s need to have a controlled learning environment that will address his emotional needs. To address those needs the Learning Center program has been offered to STUDENT. The evidence establishes that the Learning Center will provide STUDENT with the support necessary to integrate into the regular school setting while addressing his emotional needs, with the ultimate goal of full integration into the regular education setting. The evidence also supports the finding that the campus and learning center placement in conjunction with placement in regular education courses offered by the District will provide STUDENT with some educational benefit because the Learning Center environment will address his unique needs and provide for implementation of his goals and objectives. Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement offered by the District is not on a campus that is too large and furthermore that it is appropriate and will provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.
The District’s offer of placement also includes DIS services. STUDENT’s second contention regarding the appropriateness of the counseling service and accommodations offered falls under the pervue of DIS services and is addressed next.
Does the IEP offer appropriate counseling services and accommodations?
Counseling Services
The District has offered STUDENT two thirty-minute individual counseling sessions per week and two forty-five minute group counseling sessions per week. Additionally, as part of the IEP CMH will provide one fifty-minute individual counseling session and one fifty-minute group counseling session per week. (D1).
According to Dr. Perlman, STUDENT requires counseling (psychotherapy) at least twice weekly to address his suicidal ideation, anxiety, and phobia. (D5). Yet, at the time the IEP was written, Dr. Perlman was only providing STUDENT with individual counseling one time per week Additionally, at the time of the hearing Dr. Perlman was no longer providing individual services and instead was providing STUDENT only with family counseling. Dr. Perlman testified that counseling continues to be crucial for STUDENT to deal with his anxiety and to learn to cope with the school environment.
It is undisputed that STUDENT requires counseling services to benefit from his education. Here, the District has offered STUDENT substantially more counseling services than Dr. Perlman, his treating psychologist, recommended. While the evidence supports the need for counseling to monitor his suicidal ideation, anxiety, and phobia, no evidence has been presented to indicate that STUDENT requires more counseling than the District has offered. Nor has evidence been presented to indicate that STUDENT requires private services or services other than those that can be provided by the District and CMH. Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of counseling services is appropriate as it will meet his unique needs and provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.
Accommodations and Modifications
STUDENT also argues that the IEP does not offer appropriate adjustments or modifications to meet his needs. Specifically, STUDENT argues that while the IEP indicates that his homework assignments will be adjusted or modified, it does not indicate how the assignments will be accommodated. STUDENT has not indicated any other form of accommodation or modification that he requires.
The IEP document indicates that STUDENT will have multiple accommodations and modifications made to his program, including; verbal and written prompts; outlines for the information being presented; notebooks for each classroom or subject; immediate intervention when becoming anxious; and flexibility of homework including expectations, amount and time. (D1). The adjustments or modifications will be made through coordination between STUDENT’s learning center instructors and his regular education instructors. (Test. of Nest). Furthermore, the learning center is designed to provide feedback to STUDENT’s parents on his progress. (Test. of Nest). These adjustments or modifications directly correlate to the needs identified for STUDENT. Furthermore, these accommodations are quite similar to those currently being implemented for STUDENT at Balboa. (Test. of Parker). At Balboa, STUDENT is excused from doing homework assignments and receives immediate intervention from Dr. Parker when he becomes anxious or tries to avoid school. (Test. of Parker). Additionally, STUDENT’s assertion that the homework accommodation does not indicate how the assignments will be modified is inaccurate. The IEP specifically states that STUDENT’s homework will be modified in expectation, amount and time. This clearly identifies that method for accommodating his homework.
The evidence supports the finding that the adjustments or modifications that have been offered, and specifically the homework modifications, are appropriate and will allow meet his unique needs and allow STUDENT to receive some educational benefit. The Hearing Officer turns to STUDENT’s last contention, related to the inclusion of a transition plan in the IEP.
Does STUDENT require a transition plan to provide for reintegration onto a public high school campus?
STUDENT contends that his IEP should have included a transition plan to facilitate his transition from Balboa to Torrey Pines. The District argues that STUDENT did not require a formal transition plan because he would have moved directly to Torrey Pines following summer break. However, just because a student is on summer break does not automatically mean that the student will not require a transition plan when school resumes. In making the determination whether a student requires a transition plan, the District must look to the student’s unique needs and the program offered to determine whether the students requires a transition plan to address those unique needs and to receive some educational benefit.
California Education Code section 56345(b)(4) provides that when appropriate, the IEP shall include a provision for the transition into a regular class program if the pupil is to be transferred from a special class or center, or nonpublic, nonsectarian school into a regular class in a public school for any part of the schoolday. In particular, such a transition plan shall include: a description of activities provided to integrate the pupil into the regular education program; the nature of each activity; the time spent on the activity each day or week; and a description of the activities provided to support the transition of pupils from the special education program into the regular education program. Calif. Educ. Code §56345(b)(4)(A) and (B).
The IEP for the 2002-2003 school year was developed during the summer break when STUDENT was enrolled in neither Torrey Pines nor Balboa. However, this does not automatically mean that STUDENT does not require a transition plan. During the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT attended school at Carmel Valley Middle School (S3). By January 2002, STUDENT had attempted suicide several times and was refusing to attend school. STUDENT remained out of school until April 2002. Dr. Perlman testified that STUDENT’s school phobia hindered his education to such a degree that he could no longer function on a public school campus. Hence, in April 2002 his parents placed him at Balboa.
According to Dr. Perlman, direct placement into any school without a transition plan, whether after summer break of not, would cause STUDENT to ‘shut down’. Such a situation would lead to regression in his progress and possibly further depression or suicidal ideation. STUDENT’s unique needs require that he have an educational program that will assist in controlling his depression and suicidal ideation. The IEP for the 2002-2003 school year recommends placement at a school (Torrey Pines) that STUDENT has never attended. The program offered by the District did not include any written transition plan. While Ms. Nest testified that the Learning Center has a ‘built in’ transition plan, this plan is not identified in the IEP.
Ms. Nest testified that the Learning Center has a built in transition plan. However, this plan has not been presented in writing and is not included in the IEP document. Without a written transition plan, those working with STUDENT will have not have the information necessary to determine whether this transition to Torrey Pines is succeeding or if adjustments to the program or services needs to be made.
Dr. Perlman’s credible testimony supports the finding that without a transition plan, STUDENT’s needs will not be met and he would not receive educational benefit. Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does require a transition plan and that the District has failed to provide such a plan. However, this is not a fatal error; the District’s lack of a transition plan in the IEP can be remedied by immediately holding an IEP meeting to create such a plan.
Summary
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of placement made at the July 24, 2002 IEP was substantively and procedurally appropriate, with the exception that the District must create a transition plan for STUDENT. Because of the lack of a transition plan, the IEP could not have been appropriately implemented at the start of the 2002-2003 school year; therefore, the Hearing Officer turns to whether this error permits reimbursement for the cost of STUDENT’s placement at Balboa and whether or not STUDENT should be placed at Balboa for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year.
II. If the District has not offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year is he entitled to reimbursement for, and prospective placement at Balboa, a certified non-public school?
The Student requests reimbursement for the cost of securing his placement at Balboa, his placement at Balboa from September 2002 until the date of this Decision, and prospective placement at Balboa for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year. Having determined that the District procedurally offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year and that the only substantive violation, failure to include a written transition plan, can be immediately remedied by adjusting the Student’s IEP, the Student’s request for prospective placement at Balboa is denied. However, because the IEP as offered by the District could not have been fully implemented at the start of the school year, the Hearing Officer will address the Student’s request for reimbursement.
Federal law provides that a local educational agency is not required to pay for the cost of education, including special education and related services, of a child with a disability at a private school or facility if that agency made a free appropriate public education available to the child and the parents elected to place the child in such private school or facility. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(i). The Code of Federal Regulation separates the rights and duties of local agencies and parents in situations where the parents have enrolled their child in a private school without a public agency placement or referral. 34 C.F.R. § 300.403; §§ 300.450-300.487. Section 300.403(a) makes clear that a local educational agency (LEA) is not required to pay for the cost of special education and related services, if the LEA offered FAPE and the parents elected to place a child in a private school. This regulation reiterates the statutory requirement stated in 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(i).
Because of the District’s failure to provide STUDENT with a written transition plan, reimbursement for his placement at Balboa may be appropriate. However, to make that determination the Hearing Officer must determine whether the program at Balboa was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and to provide educational benefit. Town of Burlington v. Dept. Of Education of Massachusetts, (1985) 471 U.S. 359, 369. However, the program that STUDENT’s parents provided need not be the “perfect” placement, or meet every requirement of FAPE to be appropriate. Alamo Heights Indep. Sch. Dist. v. Texas Board of Education, (5th Cir. 1986) 790 F. 2d 1153, 1161; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter (1993) 510 U.S. 7, 14.
In this case, STUDENT’s unique needs generally required that he have a program that would address his school phobia and monitor his depression and suicidal ideation The program at Balboa is on a small campus that provides for direct and individual instruction in courses required for the California State standards and college entrance. (Test. of Parker). Additionally, the program provided monitoring of STUDENT’s emotional status and progress with immediate intervention as needed. (Test. of Perlman and Parker). During his placement at Balboa, while his behavior at home continued to fluctuate, STUDENT has not had any attendance problems nor suicidal ideation. STUDENT is completing his assignments and has moved from individual therapy to family counseling. No persuasive evidence was presented to indicate that the Balboa program was inappropriate for STUDENT. Since the District failed to provide STUDENT with a written transition plan and Balboa did address his unique needs and provided him with some educational benefit, the Hearing Officer finds that reimbursement for his placement at Balboa is appropriate.
However, in the case, equitable considerations exist to reduce the amount of reimbursement STUDENT’s parents may receive for his enrollment at Balboa. Equitable considerations may be considered in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting relief. Burlington, 471 U.S. 359, 369; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496. Equitable considerations, including the conduct of the parties, may be relevant in fashioning appropriate relief. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 374; W.G., 96 F.2d 1486; Student W.,31 F.3d 1496.
Reimbursement for Deposit and First Month’s Tuition
In order to secure his placement at Balboa for the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT’s parents paid a non-refundable deposit in the amount of $1,102.50. This payment was made on July 15, 2002. (S2; Test of FATHER). Additionally, on that date, STUDENT’s parents paid another $1,102.50 for his tuition for the month of September 2002. Yet, the IEP for the 2002-2003 school year was not developed until the meeting held on July 24. 2002. (D1). At the time the District made its offer of placement of the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT’s parents had already enrolled him at Balboa. As noted above, the IDEA only provides for reimbursement in situations where a child is privately placed because a district has not offered a student a FAPE. In this case, STUDENT’s parents paid for his placement at Balboa before any offer of placement was made.(Footnote 5) Therefore, STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the deposit nor the first month’s tuition.
Reimbursement for Placement from October Until the Date of this Decision
The conduct of STUDENT’s parents during the IEP process also leads the Hearing Officer to further reduce the reimbursement award in this matter. The IEP meeting for the 2002-2003 school year was held on July 24, 2002. At that meeting, STUDENT’s parents refused to sign the IEP. They refused to sign to indicate their attendance and refused to identify the areas that they either agreed or disagreed with. (Test of Nest and FATHER). Instead, at the IEP meeting, STUDENT’s then attorney, Patricia Cromer, informed the District that the parents would be putting their concerns in writing after they had had an opportunity to discuss the offer of placement. (D1; Test. of Nest).
When STUDENT’s parents did not follow through with their promise to provide a written statement of the areas of agreement and disagreement, the District proceeded to follow-up. On August 6, 2002, the District sent a letter to Ms. Cromer requesting information on which components of the IEP STUDENT’s parents would and would not consent to. (D10). On August 13, 2002, Ms. Cromer faxed a reply indicating that she would respond “when the family returns my call.” (D9). No further response was received from Ms. Cromer or STUDENT’s parents. The 2002-2003 school year started on September 3, 2002. On September 6, 2002, when STUDENT was not enrolled, the District sent a another letter to Ms. Cromer requesting consent to the IEP. (D8). No response was received from Ms. Cromer. Then, on September 12, 2002, six days after the start of the school year, STUDENT’s new attorney, Mr. Freedus, sent a letter to the District indicating that he was now representing STUDENT and that his parents intended to keep STUDENT at Balboa rather than place him at a District site.(Footnote 6) (D7). No information was contained in this letter, as was promised, to indicate the areas where STUDENT’s parents either agreed or disagreed with the District’s offer of placement.
Under the IDEA and State law the IEP meeting is the key progress that Congress established to specifically allow parental participation in the educational planning process. One of the underlying purposes for including parents in the IEP process is to allow parents to express their concerns, negotiate for their child and debate any disagreements about the placement offered. Also inherent in this approach is the assumption that parents and districts will participate in the process in good faith. That is, that parents and districts will openly share their view and opinions and will not hide facts or information from one another. While their attendance at the IEP meeting indicates, at a minimum, a willingness to consider public school placement, STUDENT’s parents were not forthcoming in their intentions to keep STUDENT at Balboa. (Footnote 7) Not only did they not disclose the fact that they had already enrolled him at Balboa, despite their promise to do so, they also refused to discuss the offer of placement or disclose their concerns or dissatisfaction with the offer of placement.
If STUDENT’s parents had notified the District of their concerns at anytime prior to the start of the school year, then the District’s failure to include a written transition plan may have been rectified and enrollment at Balboa would not have been necessary.(Footnote 8) However, despite the District’s efforts to ascertain what portions of the IEP STUDENT’s parents contested, notification of their intent to reject the District placement and place STUDENT at Balboa was not provided to the District until September 12, 2002, a full seven weeks after the IEP meeting. Upon receiving that information, the District acted diligently in filing for a due process hearing to ascertain whether it had offered a FAPE.
All of these factors, the failure of STUDENT’s parents to participate in the IEP process in good faith, their failure to disclose their intent to enroll STUDENT at Balboa, and their failure to respond to the District’s numerous requests for information, when weighed together, support the finding that the conduct of STUDENT’s parents delayed the implementation of an appropriate program for STUDENT. Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds that the actions of STUDENT’s parents caused a delay in the production and implementation of an appropriate educational program for STUDENT and reduces the reimbursement award to STUDENT’s parents by fifty-percent.
Summary
The Hearing Officer finds that because the District has substantially offered STUDENT a FAPE, the failure to include a written transition plan being a violation that is easily rectified, he is not entitled to placement at Balboa for the reminder of the 2002-2003 school year. With regard to reimbursement for the cost of the deposit and tuition for the month of September, STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement because these payments were made prior to the District’s offer of placement. Lastly, because STUDENT’s parents did not participate in the IEP process in good faith, their actions delayed the implementation of an appropriate educational program for STUDENT and therefore, they are only entitled to fifty-percent of the cost of his placement at Balboa from October 1, 2002 through the date of the IEP meeting to be held to create a written transition plan for STUDENT, pursuant to this Decision.
ORDER
1. Within twenty-five (25) calendar days of the date of this order, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to develop an appropriate transition plan to facilitate STUDENT’s immediate transition to a public high school campus.
2. The District shall invite Dr. Perlman to attend the IEP meeting to assist with the development of the transition plan. If he chooses to attend, the District shall compensate Dr. Perlman, at his standard hourly rate, for his attendance and participation.
3. Within thirty (30) calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents for fifty-percent of the cost of his attendance at Balboa from October 1, 2002 through the date of the IEP meeting ordered by this decision.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
I Has the District offered STUDENT a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2002-2003 school year?
A. Did the District commit a procedural violation by failing to have a teacher from Balboa present at the IEP meeting?
The District prevailed.
B. Did the District misidentify STUDENT’s unique needs, offer appropriate goals and objectives with baselines and measurable benchmarks?
The District prevailed.
C. Is the District’s offer of placement inappropriate because it is on a campus that is too large, does not provide for adequate counseling, and does not have appropriate accommodations?
The District prevailed.
D. Does STUDENT require a transition plan?
The Student prevailed.
II If the District has not offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, is Balboa Secondary School, a certified non-public school, an appropriate placement?
A. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for the cost of his placement at Balboa from the start of the 2002-2003 school year until the date of this Decision?
The Student prevailed to the extent that reimbursement was awarded for fifty percent of the costs of tuition from October 2002 through the date of the IEP meeting held to develop a transition plan. The District prevailed to the extent that reimbursement for the nonrefundable deposit and the month of September 2002 were denied.
B. Should STUDENT be placed at Balboa for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year?
The District prevailed.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (California Education Code § 56505(i).)
Dated: December 23, 2002 _____________________________ Sherianne Laba, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. At the start of the hearing, the Student raised the issue that the extended school year(ESY) should be included. However, the Student did not pursue the issue at hearing. 2.In its brief on the motion the District also argued that the testimony of all of the Student’s witnesses should be excluded because, “it is likely that he [Mr. Freedus] provided the Student’s second witness, Dr. Perlman, with the transcript of the Student’s first witness, the Student’s father. Therefore, his conduct caused the whole proceeding to be tainted by calling into doubt the veracity and reliability of all of the Student’s witnesses’ testimony.” Other than the issues surrounding Dr. Parker’s testimony, there is no indication that the veracity of any of the Student’s other witnesses’ should be questioned. 3. The IDEA includes other standards such as least restrictive environment and comporting with the IEP which do not apply in this case and will not be addressed in this decision. 4. Throughout his closing brief, the Student argued repeatedly that the IEP lacked specificity, rendering it invalid pursuant to Union School District v. B. Smith 15 F. 3d 1519 (9th Cir. 1994). Union sets forth particular procedural requirements that a school district must follow in providing a formal written offer of placement. In this case, the only procedural issue raised by the Student at hearing was whether or not the District was required to have a teacher from Balboa present at the IEP meeting, which does not fall under the requirements set forth in Union. The Hearing Officer repeatedly informed both parties that if an issue was not raised at the hearing it would not be addressed in this decision. The Student did not raise Union issues, which primarily focus on providing an offer of placement in writing, at the hearing: therefore, this decision will evaluate the adequacy of the District’s offer of placement under Rowley, the IDEA, and State law, rather than the procedural requirements of Union. 5. In its closing brief, the District argued that STUDENT is not entitled to any special education services because he is a parentally placed private school child. While this position may have potential for argument on appeal, it was not raised at the hearing, and consequently is not addressed in this decision. Nonetheless, the evidence indicates that STUDENT’s parents participation in the IEP process and Mr. FATHER’s testimony indicates that they at least intended to consider any placement offered by the District which may be sufficient to qualify STUDENT as a public school student. 6. In its closing brief the District argued that reimbursement should be denied because STUDENT’s parents did not provide the required ten day notice of their intent to place him in private school. However, the notice regulations contained in the IDEA and comparable state law apply to students leaving public schools rather than coming to public schools. However, if the notice requirements did apply in this situation, the results with regard to the remedies awarded would have been the same. 7. Mr. FATHER and Dr. Perlman testified that it is their intention that STUDENT attend Torrey Pines, full time, by the start of the 2003-2004 school year. 8. At the hearing, STUDENT’s parents argued that the IEP was defective because it did not include a transition plan and that the District knew that STUDENT required such a plan
