California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 9, 1998

Mt. Diablo Unified School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 251-98 · Hearing Officer JoAnn Irwin-Eshelman

Mt. Diablo Unified need not reimburse parent for 1996 independent assessment; its 1995 triennial evaluation was appropriate.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The decision notes a related earlier due process case (SN 136-97) in which other issues were resolved by a mediation agreement on May 20, 1997. The assessment reimbursement issue was not resolved in that agreement.

Summary

Mt. Diablo Unified School District filed for a due process hearing to avoid paying for an independent assessment. A parent had obtained the assessment in 1996 from the Children's Health Council. The student was 19 and had received special education since preschool. She was in a modified full inclusion program at Northgate High School. The parent represented her daughter at the hearing.

The District completed a triennial evaluation in early 1995. Its school psychologist, special day class teacher and speech-language pathologist all assessed the student. The parent never disagreed with that evaluation, and she said so at hearing. In 1996, concerned about her daughter's high school program, she asked Karen Grites of the Children's Health Council to observe and test the student. Ms. Grites did not testify.

Hearing Officer JoAnn Irwin-Eshelman found the 1995 triennial met every Education Code section 56320 requirement. She also found that conditions in 1996 did not warrant a new assessment. The parent pointed to a moderate drop in reading scores. The Hearing Officer found that the District's comparison, using the same test both years, was more credible. Some decline is common when a student moves to high school. There was no evidence of changes in behavior, grades or disability. The teacher's January 1996 testing showed no need for more evaluation. The parent used the assessment to push for program changes. That was a valid use, but it did not make the District pay. Reimbursement was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled reimbursement for an independent assessment when the parent did not dispute the district's last assessment. A drop in test scores, without other evidence of changed conditions, was not enough to require a reassessment. Getting an outside assessment to press for program changes did not, alone, require the district to pay for it.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue 1. Must the District reimburse Respondent for an independent assessment obtained by the parents in 1996 from the Children's Health Council?

    Reimbursement for the 1996 Children's Health Council assessment was denied because the District's 1995 triennial assessment was appropriate and no reassessment was warranted in 1996.

  2. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 1A. Was the District's 1995 triennial evaluation of STUDENT appropriate?

    The parent conceded the point, and the evidence showed the 1995 triennial met every requirement of Education Code section 56320(a)-(g).

  3. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 1B. Did conditions warrant an additional reassessment of STUDENT by the District in 1996?

    A moderate drop in reading scores during the move to high school, with no other evidence of changed circumstances, did not show that conditions warranted a reassessment under section 56381.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • The District's 1995 triennial evaluation was found appropriate, and the request for reimbursement of the October 1996 Children's Health Council independent assessment was denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Cal. Ed. Code § 56329(b); Cal. Ed. Code § 56320; Cal. Ed. Code § 56381; Cal. Ed. Code § 56507(d)

People named in the decision

  • Joan Alber, program administrator for special education, Mt. Diablo Unified School District
  • Brigitte Fisher, school psychologist (1995 triennial assessor), Mt. Diablo Unified School District
  • Rosemary Hindes, special day class teacher (academic assessor, 1995 triennial), Foothill Middle School, Mt. Diablo Unified School District
  • Michelle Clark, speech-language pathologist, Mt. Diablo Unified School District
  • Elizabeth Castro, special day class teacher (January 1996 standardized testing), Northgate High School, Mt. Diablo Unified School District
  • Dr. Edward Becking, private psychologist, Private
  • Karen Grites, independent assessor (observation and achievement testing), Children's Health Council
  • Children's Health Council, private assessment provider, Private

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

Case No: SN 251-98 This matter was heard before JoAnn Irwin-Eshelman, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Concord, California, on April 28, 1998. Petitioner Mt. Diablo Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Laurie Reynolds of Miller Brown & Dannis, Attorneys at Law. Joan Alber, program administrator for special education, was also present on behalf of the District. Respondent was represented by her mother, PARENT. Janice Wright, a friend of the STUDENT's family, was also present. Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open for the submission of written closing arguments. The arguments were received, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision. ISSUE Must the District reimburse Respondent for an independent assessment obtained by the parents in 1996 from the Children's Health Council? BACKGROUND FACTS STUDENT is a 19-year-old young woman diagnosed with Down syndrome who has been receiving special education services since preschool. She has just completed her third year in a modified full inclusion placement at her neighborhood school, Northgate High School. In January and February 1995, when STUDENT was in the eighth grade at Foothill Middle School, the District completed a triennial evaluation. School psychologist Brigitte Fisher assessed STUDENT using the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Third Edition (WISC-III), the Bender Visual-Motor Gestalt test, the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales, the Draw-A-Person test, Kinetic Family drawings, classroom observations by STUDENT's special day class teacher, an interview with STUDENT, and information from PARENT. Rosemary Hindes, STUDENT's special day class teacher at that time, assessed STUDENT's academic skills using the Wide Range Achievement Test-Revised (WRAT-R), the Woodcock-Johnson Psychoeducational Battery (W-J), and the Brigance reading comprehension test. A health assessment and gross motor re-evaluation were also completed. In a written report dated January 31, 1995, Ms. Fisher reviewed the testing results and noted that "STUDENT has made very good progress in all areas. She has mastered basic academic skills, especially in reading and written language, but experiences greater difficulty in tasks which require higher level cognitive skills, such as abstract reasoning, analysis and synthesis, and the ability to draw inferences." (Dist. Exh. 1.) The speech and language pathologist, Michelle Clark, also evaluated STUDENT for the triennial. Ms. Clark noted that STUDENT has a mild conductive hearing loss and bilateral deterioration of the tympanic membrane. (Dist. Exh. 1.) Ms. Clark summarized her results stating that "STUDENT...is making nice progress in speech and language skills. Strengths are in grammar, social language, and vocabulary. Areas to continue working on include: clarity of speech, problem-solving, listening, and increased interaction with familiar peers." (Dist. Exh. 1.) At PARENT's request, in late February 1995, STUDENT received additional psychological evaluation and intelligence testing from a private psychologist, Dr. Edward Becking. Dr. Becking made a number of specific recommendations regarding STUDENT's academic program, and concluded with the recommendation that "STUDENT be placed in a special day class for those times when she is not main- streamed in order for her to have a secure basis and a teacher who will be able to monitor and coordinate her educational needs." (Resp. Exh. A.) The results of the triennial evaluation were reviewed by the Individualized Education Program (IEP) team at meetings held on March 2, 1995, and April 25, 1995. The parents did not indicate any disagreement with the evaluations performed or results obtained in the triennial. (Testimony of Rosemary Hindes, PARENT.) In the fall of 1995, STUDENT entered ninth grade at Northgate High School. At that time, PARENT began to have concerns about STUDENT's high school program because STUDENT was placed in a special day class with students who were learning handicapped (LH) and seriously emotionally disturbed (SED). In January 1996, STUDENT's special day class teacher, Elizabeth Castro, administered two standardized tests--the W-J and the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT)--to update STUDENT's present levels of performance for the annual IEP review. Ms. Castro concluded that math, listening and reading comprehension were all areas needing continued attention. She also commented that "STUDENT is an excellent sight word reader and speller. She does an outstanding job with oral expression." (Resp. Exh. B-3.) In March 1996, STUDENT's annual IEP team meeting was held and the results of Ms. Castro's testing were reviewed. PARENT was still concerned about her daughter's program and, later that spring, requested that Karen Grites of the Children's Health Council (CHC) observe STUDENT in her ninth grade classes. (Resp. Exh. B-22.1.) Ms. Grites did the observation in June 1996, and observed STUDENT again in her tenth grade classes in October 1996. Ms. Grites also administered the Woodcock-McGrew-Werder Mini-Battery of Achievement (Woodcock-McGrew) tests. In a report dated October 16, 1996, Ms. Grites summarized the results of the observations and testing, and made several IEP program recommendations. The CHC report and recommendations were considered by the District at a November 1996 IEP team meeting. In early 1997, PARENTS filed for due process hearing in a related case (SN 136-97) due to their continuing concerns about STUDENT's program. The issue of reimbursement for the CHC assessment was included in that case, but was not resolved with the other issues in a mediation agreement on May 20, 1997. (Resp. Exh. D-4.) After this date, PARENT continued to pursue the request for reimbursement for the CHC assessment from the District. On January 8, 1998, the District denied the request, and subsequently filed for due process hearing on February 20, 1998. CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES The District contends that Respondent has conceded all facts necessary for a decision in favor of the District because Respondent does not disagree with the District's 1995 triennial assessment and Respondent chose not to ask the District for an additional assessment in 1996 before the CHC assessment was completed. The District claims that the purpose of Respondent's independent assessment--to evaluate STUDENT's program--is also reason to deny reimbursement. The District contends that its 1995 triennial assessment was appropriate and requests that the Hearing Officer deny reimbursement for the CHC independent assessment. Respondent admits that she has never questioned the validity of the District's 1995 triennial assessment or the 1996 standardized testing by Ms. Castro. Respondent requests reimbursement for the CHC independent assessment because she states that there were no other current assessments available in October 1996. Respondent also claims that the CHC assessment helped document certain program needs which the District would not have otherwise incorporated in her June 1997 IEP. FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW Must the District reimburse Respondent for an independent assessment obtained by the parents in 1996 from the Children's Health Council? Under Education Code Section 56329(b), a parent is entitled to a free and appropriate special education assessment of his or her child. If the parent disagrees with an assessment performed by the school district, the parent may obtain an independent educational assessment of the child and seek reimbursement. However, the school district may initiate due process hearing procedures to show that its assessment was appropriate. If the district's assessment is determined to be appropriate, then the parent will not be reimbursed, but the independent assessment results must still be considered by the IEP team. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56329(b).) A. Was the District's 1995 triennial evaluation of STUDENT appropriate? School districts must reassess special education students every three years following procedures outlined in Education Code Section 56320. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56381.) Those procedures spell out several requirements which must be met to ensure that an assessment is complete and appropriate. Testing and assessment materials must be nondiscriminatory, appropriately validated, administered by trained personnel and provided in the pupil's primary language. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56320(a)-(b).) Tests and assessment materials must assess specific areas of educational need, accurately reflect the student's aptitude, achievement or other factors, assess all areas of suspected disability, not rely on a single procedure to determine the student's educational program, and be conducted by persons knowledgeable about the student's disability. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56320(c)-(g).) Here, there is no dispute between the parties that the 1995 triennial evaluation of STUDENT was complete, valid and appropriate. PARENT has conceded this point in both her testimony and closing argument. (Resp. Closing Argument, pg. 1.) Further, the evidence presented by the District established that STUDENT's 1995 triennial evaluation satisfied all requirements set forth in Education Code Section 56320(a)-(g) as described above. The testing and assessment materials were nondiscriminatory, administered in STUDENT's primary language, validated for the specific purpose for which they were used, and were administered by trained, knowledgeable personnel in accordance with testing instructions. (Testimony of Ms. Hindes, Michelle Clark, Brigitte Fisher.) STUDENT was assessed in all areas of suspected disability, test results were determined to be accurate, and several procedures were used to determine her educational needs. (Testimony of Ms. Hindes, Ms. Clark, and Ms. Fisher.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's triennial evaluation of STUDENT performed in January and February 1995 was complete and appropriate. B. Did conditions warrant an additional reassessment of STUDENT by the District in 1996? Under Education Code Section 56381, a reassessment must be conducted more frequently than every three years,"...if conditions warrant, or if the pupil's parent or teacher requests a new assessment and a new individualized education program to be developed."(footnote 1) (Emphasis added.) Respondent's theory for reimbursement of the independent CHC assessment appears to rely on the underlined provision in Section 56381 noted above. She claims that her academic performance was "declining" and her program needs warranted an additional assessment by the District late in the 1995-96 school year or early in the 1996-97 year when the CHC evaluation was completed. (Resp. Closing Argument, pg. 1.) The "declining" academic performance to which Respondent refers is documented only by a moderate decline in STUDENT's scores in reading from the time of the 1995 triennial until October 1996 when the CHC assessment was completed. STUDENT's reading scores from the three tests performed during this period are as follows. (See Resp. Exh. A-4, A-11, B-2, B-3, C-10, C-12.) STUDENT'S READING SCORES: 1995-1996 January 1995--triennial evaluation by the District Test given Percentile Grade level Standard Score WRAT-R 16th 8 beginning 85 W-J 30th 6.4 92 January 1996--standardized testing by STUDENT's teacher, Ms. Castro WIAT 21st ---- 88 W-J 18th 6.1 ---- October 1996--standardized testing by CHC, Ms. Grites Test given Percentile Grade level Standard Score Woodcock-McGrew (age-based) 7th ---- 78 Woodcock-McGrew (grade-based) 12th 5.4 82 In a memo written by Ms. Grites to an attorney in the fall of 1996, there is brief mention of the change in STUDENT's reading scores. (Resp. Exh. C-12.1.) Ms. Grites states: "Of note, STUDENT's measured academic achievement in reading (1/95) ranked between the 16th and 30th percentile.... Currently STUDENT's reading skills rank only at the 7th percentile." (Resp. Exh. C-12.3.) This statement was accurate but reported only one of STUDENT's two reading scores obtained on the Woodcock-McGrew test. The score which Ms. Grites reported was the lower of STUDENT's two scores noted above. (Resp. Exh. C-10, C-12.) No mention was made of the grade-based score which placed STUDENT in the 12th percentile. Because Ms. Grites did not testify, her rationale for this approach and further information on the testing was not provided. The formal report which Ms. Grites prepared made no mention of a decline in STUDENT's academic performance in reading or in any other area. In summarizing her "impressions" of STUDENT's performance on the reading portion of the Woodcock-McGrew, Ms. Grites noted that STUDENT's "letter word identification skills were exceptionally strong and she even read several words above grade level....Her reading comprehension skills were slightly less well developed, however scores indicate her functioning to be well above that which her cognitive test scores predict." (Resp. Exh. C-8.) STUDENT's overall performance on the academic achievement measures of the Woodcock-McGrew was described by Ms. Grites as "generally at well above expected level." (Resp. Exh. C-8.) Although Respondent has documented a decline in STUDENT's reading skills, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded from this limited evidentiary showing that this condition alone warranted an additional assessment by the District. The District's scores showing the decline in STUDENT's reading skills are more credible because the same test (the W-J) was administered and compared in 1995 and 1996. Ms. Grites used a different test to evaluate STUDENT, and some disparity between the Woodcock-McGrew and the W-J scores could be expected. In addition, it is not unusual for a child to experience some decline in academic performance during a transition to high school and change in program. No other evidence was presented to show that significant changes had occurred for STUDENT which would trigger the need for an additional reassessment. Respondent offered no evidence of changes in STUDENT's behavior, disabling condition, grades, or social situation, for example. Instead, PARENT clearly stated her position, through both testimony and argument, that the CHC independent assessment was a tool she chose to use to persuade the District to make IEP program changes. While this may be a valid use for such an assessment, it does not also mean that the District must foot the bill, as there is no compelling proof that conditions warranted an additional reassessment of STUDENT by the District. Moreover, in January 1996, STUDENT's special education teacher, Ms. Castro, tested STUDENT using the W-J and the WIAT. (Resp. Exh. B-1-4.) This testing was done in preparation for the annual IEP team meeting and provided the participants with updated information on STUDENT's progress in her high school placement. Nothing in that standardized testing indicated that more extensive evaluation was necessary at that time, and Ms. Castro made no recommendation for further evaluation. (Resp. Exh. B-3.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Respondent has failed to establish that conditions in 1996 warranted an additional reassessment of STUDENT's educational needs by the District. Because the District's 1995 triennial evaluation was appropriate, and no reassessment was warranted at the time of the CHC independent assessment, Respondent's request for reimbursement for the CHC independent assessment is denied. ORDER 1. The District's 1995 triennial evaluation of STUDENT was an appropriate assessment of her educational needs under Education Code Section 56320. 2. Respondent's request for reimbursement for the Children's Health Council independent assessment by Karen Grites, completed in October 1996, is denied. PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE Pursuant to Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: Must the District reimburse Respondent for an independent assessment obtained by the parents in 1996 from the Children's Health Council? The District prevailed on this issue, and on each subpart of this issue. RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56505(i).) DATED: July 9, 1998 _________________________________________ JoAnn Irwin-Eshelman, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. No evidence was presented to indicate that STUDENT's parent or teacher had actually requested a new assessment and IEP. In fact, PARENT testified that she wanted an objective assessment and, for this reason, selected an assessor from outside the District.