California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 30, 2004

Student v. Vacaville Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 2519-03 · Hearing Officer Vincent L. Pastorino

Vacaville Unified must provide 36 hours of compensatory OT and partly reimburse a laptop and vision therapy; auditory-processing claims denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 5 of 16 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The decision notes prior history only. In the earlier case SN03-01423, Hearing Officer Ohler issued an October 24, 2003 order dismissing all issues for 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 under the April 25, 2002 settlement agreement. The family then withdrew that case before the 2003-2004 issues were heard. The decision reports no appeal, remand or correction.

Summary

A 17-year-old eleventh grader at Will C. Wood High School filed for due process against Vacaville Unified School District over the 2003-2004 school year. He was eligible for special education under other health impairment based on ADHD and took college-preparatory and advanced placement classes. The family argued the District's offer failed to meet his needs in ten areas and that the District broke IEP procedures.

Hearing Officer Vincent L. Pastorino found the student had real visual-processing, visual-perceptual and fine-motor deficits. These showed up as slow, often hard-to-read handwriting. The District cut occupational therapy (OT) consultation from 90 to 30 minutes a month without enough support, and it offered no home and school computer access with word-processing software. That denied FAPE in this area, and through it in written language, math and organization. The Hearing Officer rejected the auditory-processing claims. He found that the family's experts relied on test scores without looking at how the student actually performed in class. The District won on German, social-emotional needs, transition planning and resource specialist services. The test-retake claim was moot. Holding IEP meetings without the parents did not deny FAPE.

The District was ordered to provide one hour of OT weekly for 36 weeks as compensatory education, followed by reassessment. It must also reimburse $567, half the laptop's cost, plus vision therapy from August 29 to December 24, 2003. Other requests, including reimbursement for private assessments and tutoring, were denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO weighed private clinical test results against a student's actual classroom performance. Experts whose findings matched what teachers saw were credited, and those who ignored grades and teacher reports were not. Reimbursement was also limited when parents bought services or assessments before the district made its offer.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1A. Did the District deny FAPE for 2003-2004 by failing to offer a program designed to meet the student's unique needs in visual processing, fine-motor, occupational therapy (OT), and assistive technology (AT)?

    Cutting OT consult to 30 minutes a month and offering no home and school computer access with word-processing software denied FAPE; vision therapy and an AT reassessment were not required; the District also failed to offer a needed perceptual skills assessment.

  2. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1B. Did the District deny FAPE by failing to offer a program designed to meet the student's unique needs in auditory processing?

    The student tested with auditory-processing deficits, but his school performance showed any related needs were minor; the offered accommodations were adequate, and the private experts' remediation recommendations were given little weight because they ignored his school performance.

  3. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1C. Did the District deny FAPE by failing to offer a program designed to meet the student's unique needs in written language?

    Because written-language deficits flowed from visual-processing and fine-motor deficits, the inadequate OT/AT offer also denied FAPE in written language; the requested auditory-based remediation was not required.

  4. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1D. Did the District deny FAPE by failing to offer a program designed to meet the student's unique needs in math?

    Visual-processing and handwriting deficits affected math, so the deficient OT offer denied FAPE in math; benefit came largely from the father's nightly tutoring, not the District's program.

  5. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1E. Did the District deny FAPE by failing to offer a program designed to meet the student's unique needs in German?

    The student had advanced to German III and had no unique needs in German; the teacher already allowed test retakes, so that accommodation claim was moot.

  6. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1F. Did the District deny FAPE by failing to offer a program designed to meet the student's unique needs in social/emotional functioning?

    Teachers saw no emotional problems at school requiring intervention, and the parent twice declined the District's offered social/adaptive assessment.

  7. District prevailedTransition

    Issue 1G. Did the District deny FAPE by failing to offer appropriate transition planning for post-secondary education?

    The transition plan lacked the detail the family wanted but met former Education Code section 56345.1(c) and was based on the student's input and interests.

  8. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue 1H. Did the District deny FAPE by failing to offer a program designed to meet the student's unique needs in organization?

    The organization goal was appropriate, but because organizational deficits stemmed partly from visual-processing deficits, the inadequate OT offer denied FAPE in organization.

  9. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1I. Did the District deny FAPE by failing to offer appropriate resource specialist program (RSP) services?

    The RSP period gave the student homework time, teacher help, oral testing and organization monitoring; it was designed to meet his RSP needs.

  10. Not reachedIEP content

    Issue 1J. Did the District deny FAPE by failing to offer appropriate accommodations, specifically test retakes?

    Test retakes were appropriate, but teachers kept allowing them and the school year was over, so the Hearing Officer found the issue moot.

  11. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure

    Issue 2(1). Did the District commit a procedural violation by conducting the June 2003 IEP meeting without the parents present?

    The District erred at least in part by meeting after the parent asked to postpone, but no offer was made at that meeting and a new offer was planned, so there was no lost educational opportunity or serious harm to participation.

  12. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 2(2). Did the District commit a procedural violation by conducting the August 28, 2003 IEP meeting without the parents present?

    Facing a CDE compliance deadline, the District tried but failed to get the parents to attend, and it promptly offered another meeting; no violation and no denial of FAPE.

  13. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 2(3). Did the District illegally conduct the December 8, 2003 IEP meeting by denying meaningful parent participation, ignoring independent assessments, and refusing to consider academic goals?

    The meeting transcript showed the mother participated extensively and the team considered the private assessments; separate academic-subject goals were not required.

  14. District prevailedTransition

    Issue 2(4). Did the District violate the IDEA by creating the transition plan without input from the student or his parents?

    The plan drew on the student's COIN 3 self-assessment and interviews, and the family discussed it at the December meeting; no procedural denial of FAPE.

  15. Not reachedIEP procedure

    Issue 2(5). Did the District deny FAPE by failing to have a procedurally valid IEP in place for the 2003-2004 school year?

    Because the August 2003 IEP was already found to deny FAPE on substantive grounds, the Hearing Officer made no further findings on this claim.

  16. Issue 3. Is the student entitled to reimbursement, compensatory education, and other remedies arising from the denial of FAPE for 2003-2004?

    The Hearing Officer awarded 36 weeks of compensatory OT, half the laptop cost, and vision therapy costs after the August 2003 offer; reimbursement for private assessments and tutoring and the auditory-related services was denied.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Unless the parties agree otherwise, within 15 business days of the decision (and as often as necessary afterward), the District must convene an IEP meeting to amend the IEP to add the compensatory OT, write goals and objectives, and decide how to split services between clinic, school-based services and/or consult.
  • Compensatory education. One hour of OT per week for 36 weeks, starting no later than the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year, to address the deficits in Beverly Bruce's August 2003 report. Ms. Bruce and Sutter Roseville Medical Center are not required to be the provider.
  • Order to assess. OT reassessment after 36 weeks; the IEP team may request earlier reassessments. The reassessment recommendations are not binding on the IEP team.
  • Reimbursement. $567.00 to the parents (50% of the $1,134 laptop computer and software cost), due within 30 calendar days.
  • Reimbursement. The costs of vision therapy and evaluation at EYEcenter from August 29 to December 24, 2003, computed by the District from the billing itemization in Pet. Ex. 1499-1502 and paid within 30 calendar days.

Total: 36 hours of compensatory services; $567 ordered

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist.; School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Education; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Gregory K.; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Shapiro v. Paradise Valley USD; Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ.; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. State of Missouri

People named in the decision

  • Lynda Donahue, special education director, Vacaville Unified School District
  • Judith W. Paton, audiologist, expert witness for Student, private
  • Linda Wuertle-Sullivan, private English tutor (also a Travis Unified School District teacher), private
  • Deborah Ross-Swain, Ed.D., C.C.C., private speech-language pathologist, expert witness for Student, private
  • Jennifer Hollibaugh, private speech-language pathologist and educational therapist, expert witness for Student, private
  • Beverly Bruce, private occupational therapist and certified sensory-integration therapist, Sutter Roseville Medical Center
  • Leanne Liddicoat, O.D., optometrist, vision therapy provider, EYEcenter Optometrics
  • Mary Lou Mendum, Ph.D., private chemistry tutor, private
  • Greg Goodsell, AP U.S. history teacher, Vacaville Unified School District
  • Rebecca Baclig, chemistry and biology teacher, Vacaville Unified School District
  • Stephen F. Wright, resource specialist program (RSP) teacher, Vacaville Unified School District
  • Kent B. Hart, M.D., student's psychiatrist, private
  • Elizabeth Fisher, English/German teacher, Vacaville Unified School District
  • Todd Blanset, English/American literature teacher, Vacaville Unified School District
  • Lawrence Puddy, math teacher, Vacaville Unified School District
  • Carolyn Patton (formerly Carolyn Fitzgerald), school psychologist, Vacaville Unified School District
  • Mary Ann Paulazzo, contract occupational therapist, OT provider under contract with the District
  • Lisa Nagle, academic counselor, Vacaville Unified School District
  • Richard Pinnell (also spelled Pinell), school psychologist, 2001 psychoeducational assessor, Vacaville Unified School District
  • David Grisham, O.D., optometrist, vision examination at District request, District contract
  • Grayson Hunley, assistive technology specialist, SELPA
  • Kara Cannon, occupational therapist, Progressus Therapy, Inc.
  • Gordon Ulrey, Ph.D., private psychologist (U.C. Davis), 2001 independent evaluation, private
  • Progressus Therapy, Inc., OT provider (nonpublic agency), District contract
  • Occupational Therapy Consultants, OT provider during 2002-2003, District contract
  • Lindamood-Bell (Berkeley), private learning program (summer 2002 placement under settlement), private
  • Ohler, SEHO Hearing Officer in prior case SN03-01423, Special Education Hearing Office

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, on February 17, 20, 24, and May 20, 21, 25, 26, and 27, 2004, in Vacaville, California.

Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT), was initially represented by attorney Bob Varma. Mr. Varma withdrew from this matter on the third day of hearing. (Footnote 1) Attorney Marcy J.K. Tiffany represented STUDENT on all subsequent hearing dates. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf, throughout the entire hearing, was STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER. Respondent Vacaville Unified School District (Respondent or District) was represented by attorney Jan E. Tomsky. Also present on the District’s behalf was Lynda Donahue, District special education director.

The Petitioner called the following witnesses: MOTHER; Ms. Donahue; Judith W. Paton, audiologist; Linda Wuertle-Sullivan, English tutor and Travis Unified School District teacher; Deborah Ross-Swain, Ed.D., C.C.C., speech and language pathologist; Jennifer Hollibaugh, speech and language pathologist; Beverly Bruce, occupational therapist; Leanne Liddicoat, O.D., EYEcenter Optometrics; STUDENT, Petitioner; Mary Lou Mendum, Ph.D., tutor; Greg Goodsell, District history teacher; Rebecca Baclig, District chemistry and biology teacher; FATHER, STUDENT’s father; Stephen F. Wright, District resource specialist program (RSP) teacher; and Kent B. Hart, M.D., psychiatrist.

The Respondent called the following witnesses: Elizabeth Fisher, District English/German teacher; Todd Blanset, District English/American literature teacher; Lawrence Puddy, District math teacher; Carolyn Patton (formerly Carolyn Fitzgerald), District school psychologist; Mary Ann Paulazzo, occupational therapist; and Lisa Nagle, District academic counselor.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Closing briefs were received by the Hearing Officer on July 1, 2004, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

Issue 1: Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year by failing to offer a program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the following areas:

(A) visual processing, fine-motor, occupational therapy (OT), and assistive technology (AT), (B) auditory processing, (C) written language, (D) math, (E) German, (F) social/emotional functioning, (G) transition planning for post-secondary education, (H) organization, (I) resource specialist program (RSP) services, and (J) accommodations? (Footnote 2)

Issue 2: Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year by violating various procedural requirements of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and related law?

Issue 3: Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement, compensatory education, and other remedies arising from the denial of FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT, born [date redacted], is a seventeen-year-old student eligible for special education services as a child with an “other health impairment” (OHI) arising from a diagnosis of “attention deficit hyperactivity disorder” (ADHD). He attends regular education classes at Will C. Wood High School (WCW), a District school, and has just completed his eleventh-grade (2003-2004) school year. STUDENT is on track to graduate with a regular high school diploma at the conclusion of the 2004-2005 school year, and he is striving for admission to a four-year college. The District first assessed STUDENT for special education eligibility and services in December 1994 while he was in the second grade at Cooper Elementary School, a District school. On the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children 3rd Edition (WISC-III), administered to STUDENT in December 1994, STUDENT’s scores included Verbal IQ = 118, Performance IQ = 110, and Full Scale IQ = 115, consistent with overall intellectual ability in the High Average (84th percentile) range. Further testing by the District in December 1994 showed that STUDENT had a significant discrepancy between his intellectual ability and his academic achievement in the areas of reading skills and math-application skills. Testing also indicated weakness in fine-motor processing.

Following the December 1994 assessment, the District provided resource program (RSP) services to STUDENT until exiting him from RSP services, pursuant to parent request, in April 1995. The District placed STUDENT on designated instruction and services (DIS) “monitor status,” meaning that instead of STUDENT’s receiving RSP services, his parents arranged for private tutoring services and his progress was monitored by the District. STUDENT subsequently transferred to a private Christian school for third grade and attended private school through the sixth grade. He enrolled in a District middle school for his seventh-grade school year (1999-200) and continued in a District middle school for his eighth-grade school year (2000-2001).

In March 2001, STUDENT’s mother referred him for special education assessment. At that time, the District had not been providing special education services to STUDENT, and he was reportedly receiving grades in the “C” range. The District’s assessment included a psychoeducational evaluation by Richard Pinnell, District school psychologist, performed in March and April 2001. STUDENT’s March 2001 WISC-III scores included Verbal IQ = 114 (82nd percentile), Performance IQ = 89 23rd (percentile), and Full Scale IQ = 102 (approximately 55th percentile). Thus, STUDENT’s Performance IQ on the WISC-III, had dropped 21 points in comparison to the testing in 1994. Mr. Pinell’s report states that STUDENT’s below-average scores on two Performance subtests suggested difficulties with visual-perceptual skills involving part-to-whole synthesis and visual-processing speed.

Mr. Pinell interpreted STUDENT’s scores on other testing as showing low-average visual-perceptual skills and low-average to average fine-motor skills. Mr. Pinell concluded that STUDENT’s scores “do not reflect a visual-motor integration processing deficit,” but he found that STUDENT exhibited “significant weaknesses” in short-term visual memory, in distinguishing essential from non-essential visual detail, and in completion of missing visual detail. He found that STUDENT also exhibited “relative weakness” in short-term memory for visual-sequencing matter, and that “STUDENT’s visual-perceptual skills are potentially an area of processing deficit.”

With regard to auditory processing, Mr. Pinell concluded that although on certain subtests STUDENT demonstrated an auditory weakness in the area of short-term auditory memory for rote or noncontextual verbal matter, the overall test results did not suggest an auditory-perceptual processing disorder. Mr. Pinell theorized that the weak scores on those subtests could be due to difficulties in STUDENT’s “ability to concentrate and perform activities requiring mental focus.”

Finally, Mr. Pinell found no significant discrepancy between STUDENT’s academic achievement and intellectual ability, meaning that STUDENT did not qualify for special education services under the category of specific learning disability. However, after considering the ADHD diagnosis by STUDENT’s psychiatrist, Dr. Hart, Mr. Pinell concluded that STUDENT likely was eligible for special education under OHI criteria.

The District found STUDENT to be eligible for special education in the spring of 2001. However, as STUDENT started his ninth-grade school year in the fall of 2001 at WCW, the parties had reached only partial agreement on an IEP. The notes from the October 18, 2001 IEP meeting show that on the basis of STUDENT’s ADHD diagnosis, the District members of the IEP team considered STUDENT to be eligibile under the criteria for OHI, and they concluded that STUDENT’s disability was affecting his progress in the general education curriculum because “STUDENT has difficulty taking notes, staying organized and remembering requirements and learning skills.” The District offered RSP consult for 50 minutes each week and RSP services for one period each school day. MOTHER signed her consent to the RSP consult and the goals and objectives. She refused to consent to the RSP services, and she objected to the eligibility category. She stated that STUDENT should instead be found eligible under the criteria for “specific learning disability” (SLD) arising from STUDENT’s visual-processing deficits.

In the fall of 2001, MOTHER informed the District that she believed STUDENT had been experiencing extreme stress at school due to lack of supports, but she remained reluctant to authorize RSP services. Her reluctance arose from STUDENT’s having received RSP services in the second grade, and MOTHER’s belief that STUDENT’s receipt of those RSP services had led to suicidal ideation by STUDENT. Thus, the District agreed to gather information for the purpose of determining whether STUDENT’s involvement in RSP or other special education services would be likely to cause a recurrence of such adverse effects upon STUDENT. This resulted in the January 10, 2002 report by District school psychologist Carolyn Fitzgerald. The stated purpose of the report was to cover “transition behavior” and “social/emotional needs.”

On the basis of information she gathered from STUDENT, his teachers, and other sources, Ms. Fitzgerald concluded that STUDENT was “functioning well” at school within the general education environment. She stated that STUDENT was “not averse” to receiving RSP services, but was reluctant to change his course schedule. Ms. Fitzgerald concluded that providing RSP services would not have “an extreme detrimental effect on STUDENT’s emotional health.” With regard to transition, Ms. Fitzgerald wrote that the IEP team “should develop a transition plan with STUDENT’s goals toward post secondary education in mind.” Ms. Fitzgerald’s report also states that STUDENT’s parents were requesting further assessment in assistive technology (AT), vision therapy, and occupational therapy (OT). The report states that the District would refer STUDENT to the SELPA for evaluation by an AT specialist and would contract with third parties to perform the vision therapy and OT evaluations.

Through the first semester of ninth grade, STUDENT completed his schedule of college-preparatory classes with a 2.67 grade point average (GPA).

The District and the SELPA conducted a combined AT/OT assessment from January to March 2002. The SELPA assessor concluded that STUDENT had deficits in his writing and copying skills, and it submitted a list of recommended services and accommodations to address those deficits. Pursuant to Distrist request, David Grisham, O.D., performed a vision examination on February 6, 2002. Dr. Grisham noted some uncorrected nearsightedness, but found that no “PSA” was needed. (Footnote 3) Thus, by inference, the District concluded that no vision therapy was needed.

After completion of the above evaluations, the parties remained unable to agree upon an IEP. MOTHER filed a request a for due process hearing in March 2002. The parties resolved the matter by a settlement agreement dated April 25, 2002. The agreement purported to resolve all issues through the 2002-2003 extended school year. It included provisions for STUDENT’s placement at the Berkeley Lindamood-Bell program for the summer of 2002 and a follow-up two-week session during the 2002-2003 school year. It also provided that the District would cooperate with the parent in identifying possible tutors, and that the District’s offer for the 2002-2003 school year would include, at a minimum, direct RSP services for one period each day, five days each week, RSP consultation for 50 minutes each week, and OT consultation for 60 minutes each month. The agreement specified that in the event of a dispute by the parties regarding STUDENT’s program, placement, and services for the 2003-2004 school year, the RSP and OT services/consultation in the settlement agreement would constitute STUDENT’s last agreed-upon and implemented placement, unless the parties agreed otherwise. (Footnote 4)

In the spring of 2002, Progressus Therapy, Inc. (Progressus) provided OT consultation to STUDENT. An undated progress note from Progressus covering the period from March to August 2002 states that STUDENT was progressing in visual-memory and sequential-memory tasks and in typing. The report described visual figure-ground and visual closure as still being “areas of difficulty.” STUDENT completed the 2002 spring semester with a 2.33 GPA for courses taken during that semester.

For the 2002-2003 school year, the parties agreed that STUDENT would receive one period of RSP services daily, 50 minutes of RSP consultation each week, and 90 minutes of OT consultation each month. In the spring of 2003, MOTHER withdrew her consent to OT because she was dissatisfied with the services as provided at that time by Occupational Therapy Consultants.

STUDENT received private after-school tutoring services from Linda Wuertle-Sullivan, currently a teacher at Travis Unified School District, for approximately one hour each week from January to June 2003. The tutoring was at parent expense. The focus of the tutoring was to address STUDENT’s writing skills, especially essay writing.

STUDENT earned a 2.83 GPA for the 2002-2003 fall semester and a 2.50 GPA for the 2002-2003 spring semester.

The District convened an annual-review IEP team meeting on June 6, 2003. The team discussed STUDENT’s present levels of performance, reviewed goals and objectives from May 10, 2001, and reviewed STUDENT’s transition plan from June 4, 2002. The notes state that STUDENT had passed all course work toward graduation; had passed the California High School Exit Exam (CHSEE); had, by using the COIN3 program, researched entrance requirements to 4-year-colleges selected by STUDENT; had “completed selected community based activities from the COIN3 program; had completed the self-assessment/career component of the COIN3 program; and had meet the last-agreed-upon May 10, 2001 goals and objectives. The geometry teacher made a presentation regarding self-directed vs. traditional teacher-directed approaches toward the curriculum for Algebra 2. The geometry teacher stated that STUDENT was currently working at a “B-” to “C+” level as of June 3, 2003. The notes express the team’s acknowledgment that it would have to meet again to “develop current goals/objectives and to determine further special education needs/placement.” Meanwhile, the District members of the team recommended continuing placement in RSP.

Due to disagreement with the District regarding scheduling and who would act as a third-party facilitator at the IEP meeting, neither of STUDENT’s parents had attended the June 6, 2003 IEP meeting. STUDENT’s parents filed a due process hearing request on or about June 25, 2003, case number SN03-01423. The District submitted a copy of the June 6, 2003 meeting notes to MOTHER on July 8, 2003. The accompanying cover letter by District special education director Lynda Donahue states that “since it has been a year since your son’s last assessment and you have expressed disagreement with the prior assessments, it is our intent to reassess your son in all areas of suspected disability.” The attached assessment plan specified proposed assessments in the areas of academic achievement by a special education teacher, social/adaptive behavior by a psychologist, motor development by a psychologist and/or occupational therapist, intellectual development or psychological processing by a psychologist, and “other tests/procedures” by a psychologist.

On July 11, 2003, the California Department of Education (CDE) ruled on a compliance complaint filed by MOTHER. The CDE found that the District had failed to tape record STUDENT’s classes, as required in his May 15, 2001 IEP. The CDE ordered the District to conduct an IEP meeting within 45 days to, among other matters, determine whether STUDENT had lost educational benefit by that violation over a two-month period ending May 13, 2003.

Meanwhile, STUDENT’s parents obtained several private assessments. Leanne Liddicoat, O.D., conducted a private evaluation of STUDENT at the EYEcenter on June 16, 2003. She concluded that STUDENT had profound deficits in visual-processing and visual-perceptual skills. She recommended at least four months of vision therapy. (Footnote 5) Judith Paton, an audiologist, evaluated STUDENT on July, 12, 2003. Her report contained an extensive list of auditory processing deficits applicable to STUDENT. She also recommended various interventions, including auditory integration training (AIT), Fast ForWord computer-based training, the Lindamood Bell LiPS program, referral to a developmental optometrist, speech and language therapy, services by an educational therapist, and several classroom accommodation strategies.

Also as part of the private assessment process, Jennifer Hollibaugh, speech and language therapist and educational therapist, evaluated STUDENT in May and August 2003. She concluded that STUDENT had deficits in visual processing, written language, handwriting, math, auditory processing, attention, executive functioning, and working memory. She recommended various interventions and accommodations, including placement in a class of no more than 8-10 students. Next in the private assessment process, Beverly Bruce, an occupational therapist, evaluated STUDENT on August 22, 2003. Ms. Bruce determined that STUDENT had deficits and/or concerns in the areas of visual-motor control, fine-motor skills, balance, bilateral coordination, postural/ocular mechanisms, visual perception, bilateral integration, sensory processing/regulation, and behavioral organization. She recommended 36 weekly sessions of OT.

At an August 20, 2003 mediation conference concerning STUDENT’s then-pending due process hearing request, the District informed the FAMILY of its intention to hold an IEP meeting either on August 27 or 28. The next day, the District emailed notice that an IEP meeting would be held on August 28. The FAMILY informed the District that they would be unavailable, but, given the deadline imposed by the CDE compliance order, the District chose to convene the IEP meeting in the FAMILY’s absence.

At the August 28, 2003 IEP meeting, the District set forth a proposed IEP for the 2003-2004 school year. The District offered a 50-minute RSP period daily, 50 minutes of RSP consult each week, 30 minutes of OT consult each week, and a transition plan for STUDENT’s post-secondary education. The District also offered general education accommodations, wrote a new goal related to organization, and attached some prior goals and objectives dated March 2002 related to handwriting, keyboarding, and the discrimination of visual properties of objects, pictures, letters, and shapes. The District again offered the July 2003 assessment plan to STUDENT’s parents for their consent. The August 28, 2003 proposed IEP and the assessment plan were mailed to the FAMILY on August 29, with a cover letter from Ms. Donahue asking for their consent and offering to convene a new meeting to review the proposed IEP and assessment. No consent was provided.

STUDENT commenced his eleventh-grade school year on or about September 4, 2003. His class schedule was German III, chemistry, English (college-preparatory), Alegbra 2, advanced placement (AP) U.S. history, and RSP/study skills. On September 5, MOTHER emailed questions to the RSP teacher concerning the amount of homework involved with the class, textbook options for children with disabilities, and the RSP teacher’s expertise and credentialing in chemistry, algebra, German, and English. (Footnote 6) On September 16, 2003, by request of STUDENT and/or his parents, STUDENT dropped the RSP/study skills class and replaced it with a physical education class. (Footnote 7)

As of September 19, 2003, the District’s understood STUDENT’s status as being that because of the withdrawal of parental consent, STUDENT would receive neither direct RSP services nor OT consultation services. The District would continue to provide RSP consultation for 50 minutes each week. The District considered the accommodations from the June 4, 2002 IEP to be the last-agreed upon accommodations for purposes of stay put. (Footnote 8) Due to the parents’ withdrawal of consent to OT consult, the District also would not be implementing the OT-related goals and objectives, and due to the parents’ withdrawal of consent to direct RSP services, an RSP goal was not being implemented. (Footnote 9)

In October 2003, the FAMILY retained the services of Mary Lou Mendum, Ph.D., a research biochemist at U.C. Davis, to tutor STUDENT in chemistry. She testified that she met with STUDENT throughout the school year in 90-minute sessions, two days each week.

The October 27, 2003 letter from the FAMILY’s attorney at that time, Bob Varma, characterizes the August 28, 2003 proposed IEP as “unilaterally developed.” The letter sets forth the parents’ request for a new IEP meeting “so that the family may participate in the development of a placement for STUDENT for the the 2003-2004 school year.” After a series of failed attempts to schedule an IEP meeting for a mutually agreeable date, the District eventually convened an IEP meeting on December 8, 2003, with both parties present. Meanwhile, on December 3, 2003, STUDENT’s representatives filed the current request for a due process hearing.

At the conclusion of the December 8, 2003 IEP meeting, the District’s offer for the 2003-2004 school year was similar to the August 28, 2003 offer. The proposed services related to RSP and OT were unchanged. The District updated the transition plan by listing the classes STUDENT would take in the eleventh and twelfth grades. General education accommodations remained the same, except for the addition of an accommodation that weekly home-school communication would occur through sending progress reports by email. Goals and objectives were fundamentally unchanged. The District amended its proposed assessment plan, adding a language-speech communication assessment by a speech and a language therapist and hearing/vision assessment by a school nurse.

STUDENT’s parents did not consent to the December 8, 2003 proposed IEP. In her December 11, 2003 letters to the District, MOTHER leveled approximately 43 detailed objections at the District regarding the District’s procedural approach to the meeting and the substantive terms of the District’s offer. Those objections reflected an overall belief by MOTHER that the District had knowingly scheduled insufficient time for the meeting, had refused to consider information provided by STUDENT’s parents, and had firmly predetermined its offer prior to commencement of the December 8 meeting. She also requested the immediate scheduling of a continuation of the December 8 meeting.

The District resumed the process of scheduling another IEP meeting for a mutually agreeable date. Meanwhile, MOTHER informed the District that STUDENT was now in an emotional crisis resulting from the District’s continuing to ignore STUDENT’s identified needs, its continuing to include the same individuals on the IEP team “who were responsible for burying the prior reports from his psychiatrist intended for his IEP team,” its refusing to schedule “an IDEA compliant meeting at a mutually convenient time, with reasonable notice, since November 2002,” and its continuing to deny STUDENT and his parents the opportunity to participate in the development of his IEP.

The current due process matter convened for hearing on February 17, 2004. Mr. Varma withdrew as the Petitioner’s counsel on February 24, 2004, and the hearing was continued for the purpose of allowing the Petitioner a reasonable amount of time to seek new counsel.

The next IEP meeting convened on March 18 and resumed on March 23, 2004. STUDENT’s psychiatrist, Dr. Hart, attended on March 23. The IEP meeting notes show discussion of STUDENT’s emotional state. The notes mention STUDENT’s “alter ego” and an at-home episode involving STUDENT’s damaging a couch with a knife after expressing frustration over a chemistry assignment. MOTHER expressed her concerns regarding STUDENT’s placement and services and her belief that they were inappropriate and harmful. MOTHER declined the District’s offer to refer STUDENT for an assessment by the County mental health agency. The parties discussed the District’s previously-offered assessment. MOTHER indicated that she would consent to certain portions of the plan if a Fairfield Unified School District (Fairfield USD) school psychologist performed the assessment.

According to correspondence from the District, Fairfield USD determined that it had no one available to assess STUDENT prior to the end of the 2003-2004 school year. On May 15, 2004, MOTHER signed her consent to the District’s March 18, 2004 proposed assessment plan. The plan provided for assessments in academic achievement by an RSP teacher, social/adaptive behavior by a psychologist, motor development by a psychologist and/or occupational therapist, language-speech communication development by a speech and language therapist, and intellectual development or psychological processing by a psychologist. The plan also provided for a “hearing vision and health update.”

District grade reports show that although STUDENT earned a “D” in German III for the 2003-2004 fall semester, his GPA for the fall semester was 2.67. STUDENT’s cumulative high school GPA through the end of the 2003-2004 fall semester, weighted for advanced placement classes, was 2.60. His non-weighted cumulative GPA was 2.5667, and his class rank was 257th out of 437 students. The due process hearing reconvened on May 20, 2004. The spring semester had not been completed when the evidentiary record closed.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue 1: Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year by failing to offer a program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of (A) visual processing and fine-motor/OT/AT, (B) auditory processing, (C) written language, (D) math, (E) German, (F) social/emotional functioning, (G) transition planning for post-secondary education, (H) organization, (I) RSP services, and (J) accommodations?

Individuals with exceptional needs have the right to a “free appropriate public education.” 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” (FAPE) means “special education” and “related services” available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards and conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). State law further defines the term “special education” as meaning specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of individuals with exceptional needs whose educational needs cannot be met with modification of the regular instruction program, and “related services” that may be needed to assist these individuals to benefit from specially designed instruction. Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.

Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and the decision of the Supreme Court in Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S.176 (1982), an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to meet the student’s unique needs and provide the student with some educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208.

STUDENT asserts that the District substantively denied him a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year by its failure to offer a program designed to meet his unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit. (Footnote 10) Although Issue 1 has been categorized into subparts (A) through (J), most of the contentions arise from the parties’ disagreement concerning the existence, nature, and degree of STUDENT’s deficits in visual processing, fine-motor and OT-related skills, and auditory processing. As the parties are unable to reach agreement concerning STUDENT’s areas of deficit, they have reached no agreement concerning STUDENT’s unique educational needs arising from those deficits. Thus, in proceeding through each subpart of Issue 1, the Hearing Officer will first review evidence and make findings concerning STUDENT’s pertinent areas of deficit and his unique educational needs arising from those deficits. The Hearing Officer will then determine whether the District’s offer was designed meet those needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit.

(A) Visual processing and fine-motor/OT/AT. (Footnote 11)

STUDENT asserts that the District failed to offer a program for the 2003-2004 school year designed to meet his unique needs related to visual-processing and fine-motor/OT/AT-related skills. He asserts that an appropriate program would have provided vision therapy for remediation of his visual-processing deficits, as recommended by Dr. Liddicoat; one hour of OT each week for 36 weeks, as recommended by Ms. Bruce; and the provision of a laptop computer, plus software and a methodology for improving STUDENT’s typing skills. As part of the requested remedy for the denial of FAPE, STUDENT’s parents seek reimbursement for the June 16, 2003 evaluation by Dr. Liddicoat and for the vision therapy provided at EYEcenter from June 18 through the reevaluation on December 24, 2003. STUDENT also seeks an order for OT services to be implemented as recommended by Ms. Bruce, and his parents seek reimbursement for Ms. Bruce’s August 22, 2003 OT assessment. STUDENT’s parents also seek reimbursement for a laptop computer for STUDENT. The District asserts that STUDENT’s visual-processing and fine-motor/OT/AT-related needs were appropriately addressed by the District’s offer of OT consultation and various accommodations.

(1) STUDENT’s visual processing and fine-motor/OT/AT-related needs.

Evidence pertinent to STUDENT’s visual processing and fine-motor/OT/AT-related needs comes from clinical assessment data, expert opinion, and STUDENT’s performance in school.

Assessment data and expert opinion. District assessment information was obtained from March 2001 through August 2002. According the March/April 2001 psychoeducational assessment and report by District school psychologist Richard Pinell, STUDENT has deficits in his visual-perceptual skills and he has visual-processing deficits in the areas of visual memory and distinguishing essential from nonessential details. (Footnote 12) According to the February 2002 vision assessment and report by Dr. Grisham, STUDENT has no problems with eye tracking and no need for a perceptual skills assessment. (Footnote 13) According to the January/March 2002 AT assessment and report by Grayson Hunley, STUDENT has poor writing and copying skills, resulting in an AT recommendation for verbally recording assignments posted on the board, training in typing, use of a word processor, handwriting development through OT, and the teaching of writing strategies that emphasize planning, organization, editing, and revising. (Footnote 14) According to the August 2002 OT progress report by Kara Cannon, as of March 2002, STUDENT had deficits in visual memory, visual sequential-memory, visual figure-ground, and visual closure. After receiving OT services from March to August 2002, STUDENT had progressed significantly in visual-memory and sequential-memory tasks, but visual figure-ground and visual-closure activities were still areas of deficit. He was making progress in typing. (Footnote 15)

Private assessment information was obtained by STUDENT’s parents from May through August 2003. According to Jennifer Hollibaugh, speech and language therapist and educational therapist, STUDENT has deficits in visual-motor integration and motor coordination. On the VMI he was average in visual perception, but on the Malcomesius he reportedly showed difficulty with long-term visual memory, visual discrimination, visual perception, and “integrating visual perception in association with a kinesthetic-motor (written) response.” Ms. Hollibaugh testified that her observations of STUDENT’s board-copying two or three letters per glance, inconsistent letter formation, and slow writing speed indicated motor-memory visual-processing deficits. (Footnote 16)According to the June 2003 sensory-motor examination and report by EYEcenter optometrist Leanne Liddicoat, O.D., STUDENT demonstrated eye-tracking deficits, mild convergence insufficiency and mild accommodative insufficiency causing image blurring or movement. He also demonstrated “profound” deficits in visual-processing/visual-perceptual skills, specifically with regard to visual discrimination, visual sequential-memory, visual figure-ground, and visual closure. (Footnote 17) According to the August 2003 OT evaluation and report by Beverly Bruce, STUDENT demonstrated deficits in visual-motor control, fine-motor skills, balance and bilateral coordination and integration, visual perception, sensory processing/regulation, and behavioral organization. (Footnote 18)

STUDENT was reevaluated at the EYEcenter in December 2003, after having received vision therapy there for several months. The December 24, 2003 progress report states that following the receipt of vision therapy, STUDENT’s eye movements and tracking, focus ability, and fusion were “good,” but STUDENT was still having difficulties in visual-motor memory, visual sequential-memory, and visual figure-ground. (Footnote 19)

STUDENT’s performance in school. With regard to STUDENT’s performance in school, testimony from STUDENT’s teachers and his private tutors indicates that STUDENT’s verbal (oral) skills are good. (Footnote 20) STUDENT’s private tutor in tenth-grade English from January to June 2003, Linda Wuertle-Sullivan, testified that the focus of her teaching was on STUDENT’s writing skills, especially essays and short stories in preparation for the CHSEE. STUDENT had difficulty with handwriting, mechanics, and sentence structure. In her opinion, STUDENT was bright and articulate. She considered him to be “verbally brilliant – off the chart,” but the gap between his verbal and writing skills was “vast.” He particularly impressed her with his knowledge of and ability to orally discuss the 1956 Hungarian revolution. STUDENT’s private tutor in chemistry during the 2003-2004 school year, Mary Lou Mendum, testified that STUDENT is “very smart verbally” and appears to be able to concentrate better than most students, but his performance on verbal quizzes is not consistent with his lower performance on written tests taken in class.

STUDENT’s eleventh-grade advanced placement U.S. History teacher, Greg Goodsell, testified that he uses audio and visual materials in class, and about 50 percent of class time is lecture. He stated that STUDENT’s participation in group discussions is usually “on point,” and he rates STUDENT’s “contribution” to the class as a “3” out of “5.” STUDENT’s grades are in the “B” range. STUDENT participates and does his work in class in a normal manner, and he is held to the same standards as his classmates. Mr. Goodsell described STUDENT’s handwriting as “readable but awkward,” and he described the content of STUDENT’s writing as “average” in comparison to classmates’ writing. Participation was STUDENT’s greatest area of strength, and testing was the greatest area of weakness.

Rebecca Baclig, STUDENT’s eleventh-grade chemistry teacher, attended several of STUDENT’s IEP meetings. She testified that STUDENT is a bright, well-read student who appears motivated and had worked hard in chemistry, especially on his projects. His current grade was a “C,” and his performance in chemistry was affected by his relatively poor math skills, especially at Algebra 1 level. STUDENT had been tutored by her after class. She stated that STUDENT’s grade would actually be a “D” except for the fact that she allows STUDENT to have test retakes. STUDENT tells her that when he sees a math problem, the variables visually appear to “switch places on him.” His writing lacks detail and specificity. She testified that STUDENT absolutely performs better when tested orally. Ms. Baclig agrees with the opinion, reportedly expressed to her by STUDENT’s tutor, that STUDENT knows “a lot more” than what his test scores indicate.

Todd Blanset, STUDENT’s eleventh-grade English literature teacher, testified that STUDENT was earning a “C+.” Except for one project that was not turned in, he would be close to an “A.” He testified that STUDENT was a good speaker and he had noticed no problems with STUDENT’s ability to listen. His writing often lacked specificity.

STUDENT testified that he is taking a high-level academic program because, by taking difficult classes, he hopes to obtain the skills he needs to be successful in life. He stated that he has the dream of going to college at a military academy but he lacks the necessary grades. In math, he is “staying afloat” by having his father tutor him almost two hours nightly, and that keeps him “one step behind.” STUDENT stated that he does not recall basic recurring concepts in math, such as decimals, rounding, and canceling. He gets mainly “C’s” and some “D’s” in algebra. STUDENT is not satisfied with his writing ability. His handwriting is poor and often illegible to him. His handwriting causes problems in math when he misreads numbers, and in notetaking if he miswrites a word, especially in chemistry and German. With regard to the content of his writing, STUDENT states that he develops good ideas in his mind, but he writes slowly and has to think of each word individually as he writes it. By the time he has written a few words, he has lost his overall idea. Consequently, it is difficult for him to organize his thoughts when he writes. STUDENT stated that he has difficulty with grammar and does not know how to use semicolons or other “dots” on paper. Although details are “in his head,” he writes only simple sentences, and he agrees that his writing lacks detail. STUDENT states that his organizational skills for homework tasks are poor. He considers his reading skills to be good. STUDENT’s opinions of his own performance were consistent with his spring 2003 scores on the California Standards Test - Grade 10, wherein he was proficient in language arts, advanced in history/social science, and below-basic in math.

STUDENT completed his ninth-grade fall semester with a 2.67 GPA, and he earned a 2.67 GPA for the spring semester (2001-2002). He earned a 2.83 GPA for the tenth-grade fall semester and a 2.50 GPA for the tenth-grade spring semester (2002-2003). He passed the California High School Exit Exam (CHSEE) in the spring of 2003 with no accommodations or modifications. On the California Standards Test - Grade 10, also taken in the spring of 2003, STUDENT scored in the “proficient” range in English-Language Arts. He scored “below basic” in Mathematics: Geometry. He scored in the “advanced” range in History Social Science: World History. He scored in the “basic” range in Science: Biology. (Footnote 21) On the National Comparison: CAT/6 Survey Edition - Grade 10, STUDENT’s subtest percentile-rank scores were 70 in Reading, 71 in Language, 32 in math, and 83 in Science.

For the fall semester of the school year at issue (2003-2004), STUDENT received a “D” in German III, and his GPA for the fall semester was 2.67. STUDENT’s cumulative high school GPA through the end of the 2003-2004 fall semester, weighted for advanced placement classes, was 2.60. His non-weighted cumulative GPA was 2.5667, and his class rank was 257th out of 437 students.

Discussion and findings. District assessment information and the private assessment information are consistent in showing that STUDENT has continuing or recurring deficits in visual-processing and visual-perceptual skills, specifically with respect to visual memory, visual sequential-memory, visual discrimination, visual figure-ground, and visual closure. The information is also consistent in showing that STUDENT has deficits in his writing and copying skills, planning and organization, and fine-motor skills. (Footnote 22) The evidence confirmed that STUDENT manifests all of the above deficits in performing school-related matters such as handwriting speed, handwriting legibility, and in the organization of his writing. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that STUDENT needed services and/or accommodations to address all of the above-described deficits.

Ms. Hollibaugh, a speech and language therapist, testified that STUDENT demonstrates deficits in visual-motor integration. Her opinion on the subject of visual-motor integration, to the extent it is offered by a speech and language pathologist, is not persuasive. However, Ms. Bruce, an occupational therapist, also found deficits in “visual-motor control.” Mr. Pinell, although concluding that certain findings did not “reflect a visual-motor integration processing deficit,” still found that STUDENT’s visual-motor integration skills were only at the 18th percentile in March 2001, more than two years prior to the assessments by Ms. Bruce and Ms. Hollibaugh. The opinions of Ms. Bruce and Ms. Hollibaugh are consistent with STUDENT’s demonstrated problems with slow handwriting and inconsistent letter formation. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT has deficits in visual-motor integration and requires services or accommodations to address those deficits.

Finally, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded as to the accuracy of Dr. Grisham’s February 2002 findings that STUDENT demonstrated no eye-tracking problems and no need for a PSA. The report from Mr. Pinell, the District school psychologist, states that STUDENT demonstrated deficits in visual perceptual skills. By Mr. Pinell’s testing, STUDENT scored at the 5th percentile on the overall Visual-Perceptual Quotient of the TVPS-UL, and STUDENT’s weakness in short-term visual memory, short-term memory for visual sequencing, distinguishing essential from nonessential visual detail, and visual completion of missing visual detail were all stated by Mr. Pinell to be components of visual-perceptual skills. For that reason, a perceptual-skills assessment, or PSA, should have been performed, but was not. Dr. Grisham’s statement that a PSA was not indicated calls into question his other findings regarding normal eye tracking. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer is persuaded by Dr. Liddicoat’s finding that STUDENT had deficits with eye tracking and also blurring of vision, and the Hearing Officer further finds that services and or accommodations were needed to address those deficits.

In summary, for the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT needed services and/or accommodations to address deficits in visual-processing and visual-perceptual skills, specifically with respect to visual memory, visual sequential-memory, visual discrimination, visual figure-ground, visual closure, and eye tracking, in addition to deficits in visual-motor integration and fine-motor skills, all of which manifested in deficits in STUDENT’s handwriting speed, handwriting legibility, copying skills, organization of writing, and task planning. STUDENT also needed a perceptual-skills assessment.

(2) The District’s offer.

STUDENT asserts that the District’s offer for the 2003-2004 school year was a denial of FAPE because it did not include a perceptual skills assessment or other appropriate vision assessment, vision therapy for remediation of his vision-processing deficits, weekly OT services as recommended by Ms. Bruce, a laptop computer with supporting software for word processing, and an appropriate plan for developing his typing skills and his mechanical and substantive writing skills. STUDENT also asserts that an AT assessment should have been performed to, among other reasons, “help identify the most effective way to improve STUDENT’s typing skills and to teach him how to use his laptop and software effectively, particularly in the classroom environment.”

To determine whether the District has offered STUDENT a FAPE, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of the District’s proposed program. Thus, in the present case, the inquiry begins with the District’s program. If the District’s program was designed to meet the Petitioner’s unique needs, as identified above by the Hearing Officer, and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, then it does not matter whether the services requested by STUDENT would have resulted in a better program. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314; 20 U.S.C. §§ 1401(8), 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.

The District’s proposed IEP for the 2003-2004 school year, dated August 28, 2003, states that STUDENT is eligible under the criteria for OHI and that “STUDENT has difficulty taking notes, completing and turning in assignments independently, staying organized, and following directions.” The District offered a 50-minute RSP period daily, 50 minutes of RSP consult to STUDENT’s general education teachers each week, 30 minutes of OT consult to STUDENT’s general and special education teachers (RSP teacher) each month, and a transition plan for STUDENT’s post-secondary education. General education accommodations included STUDENT’s receiving copies of available teacher notes upon STUDENT’s request, instruction presented with visual and oral prompts/cues as needed, STUDENT’s being allowed to give verbal (oral) responses on tests and quizzes to promote detailed responses within the RSP classroom at STUDENT’s request, and allowing extra time at STUDENT’s request to complete quizzes and tests on the same day. The District redated its July 2003 assessment plan to August 28, 2003, and again offered it to STUDENT’s parents for their consent.

The August 2003 IEP includes several goals and objectives. An “academic” goal states that according to STUDENT’s teachers, STUDENT’s organizational skills were low-average to average and he was turning in 90-100 percent of his assignments when given RSP support and additional time for those assignments. The annual goal was for STUDENT to “independently utilize organization and memory aides to ensure completion of and turning in 90% of assignments on time.” STUDENT’s “case manager” (RSP teacher) was responsible for monitoring the goal and its short-term objectives. This particular goal is dated August 28, 2003.

The August 2003 IEP contains two additional goals with objectives, both dated March 13, 2002, and both involving occupational therapy. The first goal, for “fine motor/written communication” states that “STUDENT is currently using his wrist for writing movements, instead of using finger movements . . . STUDENT is currently using a 2-finger method with elbows extended away from his body.” The annual goal was to “increase finger isolation skills for greater success with written work, both handwriting and keyboarding.” Progress was to be monitored by an occupational therapist. The second goal dated March 13, 2002, is for “visual perceptual skills.” The goal states that STUDENT was having difficulty with “closure” and “over/underextension” of lines on shapes, numbers, and letters, and he was having difficulty with classroom tasks requiring visual-perceptual skills. The annual goal was to “increase the use of visual perception skills and strategies for greater success with academics and written work.” This goal involved STUDENT’s working with an occupational therapist to identify visual-perceptual strategies, using a trial-and-error process, that would assist STUDENT in the classroom and with homework. Notations on the March 13, 2002 goals and objectives state that the January 2003 short-term benchmark for the fine-motor goal had been met in January 2003 and the March 2003 short-term benchmark for the visual-perceptual skills goal had been met by March 2003.

The notes from the August 2003 IEP meeting state that on the basis of STUDENT’s OT goals having been met, the District members of the team reached a consensus that direct OT services would no longer be necessary, and that 30 minutes of OT consultation per month, with STUDENT’s teachers, would meet his needs. The notes state that the prior goals would remain attached to the new IEP for monitoring purposes.

The August 28, 2003 IEP was updated at the December 8, 2003 IEP meeting. Changes included a provision that STUDENT’s progress, as monitored by the case manager and general education teachers, would be reported weekly by email to STUDENT’s parents. The transition plan was amended, and the proposed assessment plan was amended by adding language-speech communication assessment by a speech and language therapist and hearing/vision assessment by a school nurse. Goals and objectives were neither changed nor updated.

Returning now to the question of whether the District’s offer was designed to meet STUDENT’ unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, the text of the August 28, 2003 proposed IEP references STUDENT’s difficulties taking notes, completing and turning in assignments independently, staying organized, and following directions. By that language, the IEP generally acknowledges the manifestations of STUDENT’s visual-processing, visual-perceptual, fine-motor, and visual motor-integration deficits. A new goal involving the use of “organization and memory aides” was written to address STUDENT’s homework-organization skills and assignment-organization skills. To further address the manifestations of STUDENT’s above-stated deficits, the proposed IEP offered the accommodations for making teacher’s notes available on request; presenting instruction with visual and oral prompts/cues, as needed; allowing STUDENT to give verbal (oral) responses on tests and quizzes, thereby enabling STUDENT to give more detailed responses; and allowing extra time, not to exceed the school day, for STUDENT to complete tests and quizzes. The above-stated accommodations were intended to address the effects of STUDENT’s deficits in handwriting speed, handwriting legibility, and copying skills by enabling STUDENT to succeed in his classes in spite of his deficits. All of the above would be supported by 50 minutes of RSP period daily, 50 minutes of RSP consult to STUDENT’s general education teachers each week, and 30 minutes of OT consult to STUDENT’s general and special education teachers (RSP teacher) each month.

Except for the reduction of OT, the District’s offer for the 2003-2004 school year is similar to the services STUDENT was receiving for the prior school year. For the 2002-2003 school year, the parties had agreed that STUDENT would receive one period of RSP services daily and 50 minutes of RSP consultation each week. The parties had also agreed that the District would offer 90 minutes of OT consultation each month during the 2002-2003 school year. Thus, for the 2003-2004 school year the District reduced the OT consult offer from 90 minutes each month to 30 minutes each month.

A review of the evidence shows that the proposed reduction of OT was not warranted by the information available to the District at the August and December 2003 IEP meetings. First, the record shows that STUDENT had received OT from Kara Cannon at Progresses from approximately March to August 2002. Ms. Cannon’s August 2002 progress report states that using activities from the Visual-Perception Developmental Remedial Activities – Upper Level (Gardner, 1993), the therapy had targeted visual memory, visual sequential-memory, visual figure-ground, and visual closure. The August 2002 report states that STUDENT made progress, but visual figure-ground and visual closure remained areas of difficulty. The notes from the August 2003 IEP meeting state that the District’s decision to decrease OT was made on the basis of STUDENT’s having met his OT goals and objectives from March 2002. Review of the OT goals and objectives pages attached to the August 2003 IEP shows that by January/March 2003, STUDENT’s typing skills had progressed to a level where he would keep his elbows at his sides and use only wrist and finger movement when depressing keys. Also by January/March 2003, STUDENT had reportedly demonstrated visual closure in tasks such as forming shapes, numbers, and letters eighty percent of the time as measured by performance on random samples “pulled by the English teacher.” Given the multiple manifestations of STUDENT’s various visual-processing, visual-perceptual, and OT-related deficits, the Hearing Officer regards those achievements as falling significantly short of demonstrating that STUDENT needed only 30 minutes of consult each month to meet his needs.

Additional information available to the IEP team in August and December 2003 similarly failed to support a reduction in OT services to only 30 minutes each month. Occupational therapist Mary Ann Paulazzo testified that her office had contracted with the District to provide OT services to STUDENT during the 2002-2003 school year. She assigned a therapist at her office to provide the services. Although Ms. Paulazzo had not actually been STUDENT’s primary therapist, she did attend the August 2003 IEP meeting. She testified that on the basis of her review of STUDENT’s handwriting samples, she considered STUDENT’s handwriting to be “good.” She also testified that STUDENT’s teachers at the IEP meeting described STUDENT’s handwriting as functional and legible, and they stated that STUDENT had been able to write a five-paragraph essay during one class period. (Footnote 23) Thus, on the basis of that information and STUDENT’s having met his above-discussed goals and objectives, she believed that STUDENT no longer required OT services other than 30 minutes of monthly consult to his teachers.

In spite of the above, Ms. Paulazzo’s testimony failed to support the District’s position on reducing the OT services or that STUDENT had progressed to such a level that his needs could be met by 30 minutes of OT each month. Ms. Paulazzo acknowledged that she had never seen STUDENT type. She also acknowledged that at least one of the relied-upon goals was too subjective to be measurable. Moreover, her opinion regarding STUDENT’s handwriting is not shared by this Hearing Officer. Petitioner’s Exhibit 1077-1078 is a five-paragraph essay reportedly written by STUDENT. (Footnote 24) It may or may not be the same essay referenced by Ms. Paulazzo as having been discussed at the IEP meeting. In either event, most of the 41-line essay is legible, but much of it is not. The essay is not written in cursive. Ms. Paulazzo testified that STUDENT’s handwriting, as displayed in the documentary evidence, is “good.” To the Hearing Officer, Ms. Paulazzo’s favorable description of STUDENT’s handwriting is not credible for the handwriting that the Hearing Officer sees on the same exhibits. The description by Mr. Goodsell, STUDENT’s history teacher, that STUDENT’s handwriting is “awkward,” better matches what is on the exhibits, although “readable” only partially applies. Moreover, even if STUDENT did write the essay in Exhibit 1077-1078 in one class period, the short length of the essay does not indicate that STUDENT can take notes at a functional speed. Also, poor as the handwriting in the five-paragraph essay appears, that handwriting is noticeably superior to STUDENT’s handwriting samples in other exhibits (Pet. Ex. 1079, 1080). The awkward and somewhat laborious appearance of the handwriting samples is consistent with Ms. Hollibaugh’s testimony that, during her assessment in May and August 2003, STUDENT required 92 seconds to write the alphabet in cursive, while the norm is 30 seconds.

In summary, at the August 2003 IEP meeting, the information available to the District did not merit a reduction in OT services to only 30 minutes of consult each month. (Footnote 25) Instead, information such as the poor quality of STUDENT’s handwriting indicated that the above-referenced deficits identified in earlier assessments remained largely unresolved. Later, at the December 2003 IEP meeting, the District had available the reports from Ms. Bruce and Dr. Liddicoat. By that time, rather than suggesting a reduction in OT services, the information available to the District confirms that STUDENT still had significant OT-related needs arising from his visual-processing, visual-perceptual, and OT-related deficits, specifically manifested by poor and often illegible handwriting, slow handwriting, poor typing skills, and poor copying skills, all contraindicating a reduction in services to 30 minutes of OT consult each month.

With regard to the assertion that vision therapy, supervised by or through an optometrist, and OT were both required for meeting STUDENT’s needs during the 2003-2004 school year, the evidence showed that OT and vision therapy have a significant degree of overlap respective to STUDENT’s needs. Ms. Hollibaugh and Ms. Bruce testified that STUDENT’s visual-processing and visual-perceptual deficits could be addressed either by an occupational therapist or by a developmental optometrist. Information from Progresses shows that multiple methods of therapy are available, and that such therapy would be appropriate in addition to implementation of the various accommodations listed in STUDENT’s IEPs.

By December 2003, STUDENT had completed his course of private vision therapy provided through Dr. Liddicoat at the EYEcenter. The EYEcenter progress report shows that STUDENT had improved in several areas, and some of those areas likely overlapped with the deficits Ms. Bruce had identified in her August 2003 OT assessment. Depending on STUDENT’s new levels of performance at that time, the IEP team could then have considered the option of using vision therapy supervised by an optometrist in combination with OT. In either event, the evidence presented at hearing, particularly the above-referenced evidence regarding overlap of vision therapy and OT, showed that so long as STUDENT had appropriate OT services to address his deficits in visual-processing, visual-perceptual, and OT-related skills, then vision therapy supervised by an optometrist was not required to meet STUDENT’s needs arising from those same deficits. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that vision therapy, although appropriate as an alternative to certain OT services, was not required to meet STUDENT’s needs during the 2003-3004 school year.

With regard to AT assessment and services, STUDENT asserts that an AT assessment should have been performed to, among other reasons, “help identify the most effective way to improve STUDENT’s typing skills and to teach him how to use his laptop and software effectively.” Evidence from both parties was consistent in showing that STUDENT needed to develop word-processing skills to address his poor writing skills arising from deficits in visual-processing, visual-perceptual, and fine-motor/OT-related skills. The SELPA performed an AT assessment in March 2002, and STUDENT’s IEPs consistently addressed typing skills. Given the daily opportunities for STUDENT’s typing skills to be monitored at school, the Hearing Officer finds that an AT reassessment was not required for the 2003-2004 school year.

However, typing skills were of no use to STUDENT if he did not have regular access to a computer and appropriate software for use on certain classroom assignments and homework assignments, especially in English and advanced placement U.S. history. Occasional access to a computer at school would not have been sufficient to meet STUDENT’s needs. Because of legibility and speed deficiencies in STUDENT’s handwriting, STUDENT needed computer availability and word-processing capability, at home, to complete his assignments in a timely manner. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that, to meet STUDENT’s unique needs arising from deficits in his visual-processing, visual-perceptual, and fine-motor/OT/AT-related skills, the District was required to offer STUDENT regular access to a computer at home and at school with appropriate word-processing software. If the District did not provide a portable or laptop computer, STUDENT would have needed software that enabled him to use the school and home computers interchangeably on his assignments.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that by offering only 30 minutes of OT consult each month and by failing to offer STUDENT school- and home-computer access with appropriate word-processing software, the District’s offer for the 2003-2004 school year was neither designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs arising from deficits in visual-processing, visual-perceptual, and fine-motor/OT/AT-related skills, nor reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit. To that extent, STUDENT was denied a FAPE. The District also failed to offer a perceptual skills assessment, and the consequences of that failure will be addressed in Issue 3.

(B) Auditory processing.

The parties’ dispute concerning auditory processing comprises a major portion of this due process matter and will require examination at length. STUDENT asserts that he has profound auditory-processing deficits that, according to his experts, render him essentially non-functional in many areas. As will be further explained below, the District’s position on STUDENT’s auditory processing is evasive. The District’s position appears to be that if STUDENT has auditory processing deficits, those deficits are minor. Given the wide disparity in the parties’ positions on this matter, it will be necessary to examine this issue by first reviewing the reports and/or testimony of the pertinent experts.

District assessment. District assessment regarding auditory processing comes only from one source, Mr. Pinell’s March/April 2001 psychoeducational evaluation. When tested by Mr. Pinell, STUDENT ranked in the 34th percentile on the TAPS-U. Mr. Pinell wrote that STUDENT demonstrated an auditory weakness in the area of short-term auditory memory for rote or non-contextual verbal matter, but that the overall results of the TAPS-U do not suggest an auditory-perceptualprocessing disorder. Mr. Pinell theorized that the weakness could be due to difficulties in STUDENT’s “ability to concentrate and perform activities requiring mental focus.”

Gordon Ulrey, Ph.D. After indicating her disagreement with the District’s assessment and program, MOTHER had STUDENT evaluated by Gordon Ulrey, Ph.D., in July 2001. Dr. Ulrey is an associate clinical professor of psychology at U.C. Davis. He was not called as a witness at the hearing. In his comprehensive report, Dr. Ulrey concluded that STUDENT showed a “pattern of significant difference between verbal and non-verbal abilities related to visual spatial processing.” STUDENT “showed a pattern of auditory processing skills in the average range.” Dr. Ulrey stated “there is a consistent pattern of both processing speed and visual spatial thinking, representing underlying deficits . . . consistent with the schools finding on the tests of visual perceptual skills, which indicated impairments on visual closure, visual figure ground, visual sequential memory and overall perceptual quotient of 76, equivalent to the 5th percentile.” On the Children’s Memory Scale, difficulty was shown (3rd percentile) with attention and concentration and greater than expected difficulty with recognition memory. According to Dr. Ulrey, those results showed impairment in STUDENT’s “ability to sustain attention and concentration, as well as having greater difficulty with visual compared to auditory learning.” In a letter to MOTHER dated April 15, 2003, Dr. Ulrey summarized STUDENT’s scores on the “WJ III Tests of Cognitive Abilities,” administered in July 2001. The letter states Dr. Ulrey’s impression that, when compared to other students’ performance at STUDENT’s age level, STUDENT’s “performance is average in comprehension, knowledge, auditory processing, and processing speed; and low in visual-spatial thinking and fluid reasoning.”

Judith Paton, audiologist. Ms. Paton performed private audiologic testing of STUDENT on July 12, 2003. Ms. Paton begins her report by stating that “today’s testing is being done to examine the auditory nervous system contributors to the auditory deficits found on psychoeducational and language tests.” Thus, on its face, the report indicates an assumption by Ms. Paton that STUDENT had auditory processing deficits, and it indicates that Ms. Paton’s objective was to determine the cause of those deficits. The first page of the report lists background information about STUDENT reported to Ms. Paton from various sources, including “the recent report from Jennifer Hollibaugh, M.A.” (Footnote 26) After referring generally to having performed her own audiologic testing on STUDENT and stating some diagnosis codes, she concludes that STUDENT has a central auditory processing disorder (CAPD) and makes a rather expansive legal assertion that under “educational” and “civil rights” law, including “PL 94.142 . . . Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 . . . and the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 . . . this disability warrants specialized support and modifications at school to help STUDENT work up to true intellectual ability.” (Foontote 27) The remaining five pages of the report consist primarily of rote language concerning auditory processing, how certain aspects of CAPD may adversely affect a student’s performance, and available treatment/therapy options. Embedded within the above are some occasional references to STUDENT. (Footnote 28)

Ms. Paton’s report contains, at best, an ambiguous portrayal of STUDENT’s individual needs as pertinent to the IDEA and related law. For example, the Appendix to Ms. Paton’s report lists STUDENT’s audiologic test data. For some areas, the quantitative data was in the “abnormal range.” Unfortunately, how those results relate to STUDENT’s actual performance levels in classroom tasks and academic tasks is largely left to conjecture by the report. Page 1 of the report states that “audiologic results are consistent with a central auditory processing disorder (CAPD), as suggested by abnormal findings on tests considered sensitive to both brain stem and cerebral level auditory system dysfunction.” The report then states a diagnosis of central hearing impairment, abnormal auditory perception, and hyperacusis, with corresponding codes, and then makes the statement that “STUDENT’s hearing impairment interferes with important basic life activities, including not only education but also the development of employment skills and social skills, and cultivation of healthy leisure interests skills.” (Footnote 29) The next few pages of Ms. Paton’s report list and discuss “the most likely effects of this type of hearing impairment, and examples of measures which can help.” Thus, after stating that STUDENT’s hearing impairment interferes with important basic life activities, Ms. Paton’s report proceeds to identify only “the most likely effects” of STUDENT’s hearing impairment, as opposed to offering information on the actual affects manifested by STUDENT academically and in the classroom environment.

The nonspecificity in Ms. Paton’s report is a consequence of how she conducted her evaluation. Ms. Paton testified that she did not observe STUDENT in class or at school, did not consult with school personnel, and did not review school documents to learn about STUDENT’s educational performance. She stated that the cost of such observations would have been prohibitive, and that, in any event, her function was to determine what STUDENT can hear– not to tell a teacher what to do. (Footnote 30) To the Hearing Officer, the above factors significantly limit the usefulness of Ms. Paton’s report and her opinions. However, given the Petitioner’s extensive reliance on Ms. Paton’s findings and opinions, the remaining content of the report will be reviewed in detail.

The extensive list of “the most likely effects” of STUDENT’s CAPD begins with the category: “Difficulty receiving intelligible spoken input.” Under that category, according to the report, STUDENT may demonstrate “poor suppression of unwanted background sound at brain stem level (see test findings in Appendix).” Whether STUDENT actually does demonstrate that problem, otherwise known as “hyperacusis,” is not definitively stated in the report, but, in the event that he does, the report lists interventions that may be useful, such as auditory integration training (AID).

Next, the report states that STUDENT may have “Distortion of speech phonemes due to slow auditory processing speed at brain stem and cerebral level.” This finding was objectively indicated by Random Gap Detection Test (RGDT) scores in the borderline range at 2000 Hz and in the abnormal range at 4000 Hz. The report states that this condition, especially in combination with hyperacusis, degrades the “basic auditory signal,” resulting in some words being mistaken for others or rendered nonsensical. According to the report, such “misperceptions must be detected and corrected higher up on an intellectual basis from the context, a tiring extra step which normal-hearing students need not take.” Corrections may not be possible “when the vocabulary is new and the student has no experience from which to guess.” The report states that the condition is likely to cause difficulty attending to and understanding lectures, especially if attention must also be allocated to notetaking, and that the oral teaching of foreign languages could especially be met with difficulty.

The report next discusses “Imperception of melody and prosody as clues to meaning.” According to the report, this condition can impair the listener’s ability to discern the meaning of spoken language through the speaker’s tone of voice. The report states that this condition is indicated by STUDENT’s performance on the “singing portion of the PPS test, melodic errors on Sound Patterns, and left ear score on the DPS.” A review of the Appendix shows that STUDENT’s PPS (Pitch Pattern Sequencing) test data was “just outside the normal range” in perception of short tonal patterns, and it “showed far poorer ability to transfer that information via the corpus callosum to the dominant language centers of the opposite temporal lobe for verbal reporting.” STUDENT’s Sound Patterns test scores were measured as being at grade-equivalent 11.3, “showing adequate perception of various melodic, phonemic, and rhythmic-durational features of language, but “errors that did occur tended to be on melodic elements, consistent with the abnormal signing score on the PPS.” The left ear data on the DPS (Duration Pattern Sequencing) test showed “borderline ability distinguishing moderately slow timing differences, as is important for accurate perception of speech.”

The next general category of “most likely effects” of STUDENT’s CAPD, as listed in Ms. Paton’s report, is “Failures of accessing and automaticity.” The category begins with a discussion of “Problems with short term auditory and rote memory.” Although the discussion is extensive, Ms. Paton refers to none of her own specific test data to determine whether STUDENT has such memory difficulties. Instead, she states that prior testing has shown poor memory, but the testing is not identified.

The next subject in Ms. Paton’s report is “Slow or inaccurate linking of auditory and visual information,” as indicated by “poor scores on Filtered Speech testing.” The report states that when STUDENT is reading, he may formulate “a near-match instead of an exact one, STUDENT may mis-read or misspell and have to go back and correct when the error becomes clear from context or proofreading,” thus placing greater demands on STUDENT’s memory systems and lengthening study time because of the frequent need to re-read and correct.

Also with regard to the linking of auditory and visual information, Ms. Paton states that “people in this CAPD group don’t need to be taught the sounds and letters themselves, nor the principles of phonics . . . Rather, they need help in making quick and accurate linkages between, for example, the word they have in mind (temporal lobe) and the letters (occipital lobe) they need for writing and spelling the word.” She concludes: “This poor auditory-visual integration is thus one contributor to STUDENT’s slow writing and homework speed and his simplistic writing. It correlates with anatomically (connecting brain pathways) with the below-average scores on visual-motor integration found by other examiners.”

The report next moves to discussion of how STUDENT’s “Inefficient integration of language perceptions from the two hemispheres” contributes to STUDENT’s simplistic writing and short sentences when speaking. The report states that “in moving from the side of the brain with the creative ideas and mental images, something is lost in the process, so that not all of the ideas are described in words. This leaves the unfamiliar reader (or listener) the job of filling in the gaps.” Ms. Paton comes to this conclusion on the basis of STUDENT’s Staggard Spondaic Word (SSW) test and Pitch Pattern Sequencing (PPS) verbal response scores, both in the abnormal range.

Finally, under the category “Basic auditory-language inefficiencies,” Ms. Paton states that STUDENT has “problems with language functions like intuition of the basic rules of language, word finding, accessing word meanings, and/or perceiving grammatical clues to meaning.” This conclusion is reached by Ms. Paton on the basis of STUDENT’s performance on the Dichotic Competing Sentences test, measured in the “normal” range on the left and “borderline” range on the right.

Regarding STUDENT’s educational needs arising from the above-propounded deficits, Ms. Paton testified that STUDENT has “the double whammy.” According to Ms. Paton, STUDENT’s ability to succeed in a 4-year college would be problematic, as STUDENT lacks the requisite level of good listening skills and the ability to express himself within limited time. She stated that STUDENT is “beyond tutoring,” meaning that his learning will not improve through repetition. Instead, a different pathway to the brain must be utilized. She stated that to improve STUDENT’s condition, one needs to start below the level where people have been working. In Ms. Paton’s words, one needs to go down and “get the source of the basic glitches in STUDENT’s wiring fixed.” For this purpose, she recommends interventions mentioned in her report, including auditory integration training (AIT) to “help stimulate, synchronize, or otherwise train the non-cognitive part of the auditory system to better function”; Fast ForWord computer-based training or AIT “to improve auditory processing speed and phonemic/melodic awareness”; “work with an educational specialist on the various types of cognitive memory strategies, until the most efficient system is discovered and becomes automatic”; “formal systems for bringing in the motor or tactile system, like the Orton-Gillingham/Slingerland method or the Lindamood-Bell LiPS program . . . known to improve speed and accuracy of sound-symbol association”; checking for “and remediating any visual-perceptual problems (including slow visual processing speed) with educational therapist,” using programs such as Perceptual Enrichment Training (PEP); utilization of a “developmental optometrist” to “find and treat any brain stem visual barriers to reading such as poor tracking, focusing, or eye training”; working with an “educational specialist on ways of better integrating the two hemispheres, as by training in visualization NLP (Neuro-linguistic Programming), Edu-Kinesthetics (e.g. Brain Gym), and physical activities which require frequent crossing of the midline (e.g. occupational therapy)”; speech and language therapy by a pathologist “skilled with the more subtle and abstract types of language accessing; and numerous classroom accommodation strategies.

Jennifer Hollibaugh, speech and language pathologist. Jennifer Hollibaugh is a speech and language pathologist, and she also provides services as an educational therapist. (Footnote 31) She conducted an extensive evaluation in May and August 2003. She made numerous conclusions and recommendations on the basis of her test data, including her conclusion that STUDENT has an “Auditory/Language Processing Defict.” She stated those conclusions and recommendations in a lengthy, undated report entitled “Language-Learning Assessment.” The matter of correlating those conclusions and recommendations to STUDENT’s actual educational performance and unique needs arising from auditory-processing deficits is a matter that will be addressed by the Hearing Officer, as the report itself is chiefly devoid of such correlation. The Hearing Officer will begin, however, by summarizing Ms. Hollibaugh’s report. Much of the summary will include information pertinent to STUDENT’s visual-processing and OT-related deficits, but that information is included for the purpose of presenting Ms. Hollibaugh’s conclusions concerning auditory-processing in context.

Ms. Hollibaugh’s report contains a review of prior evaluations dating to 1994. Ms. Hollibaugh also administered her own testing and data collection, including the Goldman-Fristoe Woodcock Test of Auditory Discrimination (GFWT), Fullerton Language Test for Adolescents (Fullerton-LTA), Test of Visual Perception (VMI), Wide Range Assessment of Memory and Learning (WRAML), Key Math - Revised, the Mathematics Interview - Dr. Mel Levine - Student Questionnaire, Pediatric Examination of Educational Readiness at Middle Childhood (Peeramaid 2), Malcomesius Specific Language Disability Test (Malcomesius), Dysgraphia Assessment, Written Language Assessment (WLA), The Writing Interview - Dr. Mel Levine - Student Questionnaire, Nonverbal Learning Disorders - Parent Checklist (NVLD), Aggregate Neurobehavioral Student Health & Educational Review - Parent Questionnaire (ANSER), and ANSER - Student Questionnaire.

On the GFW, STUDENT scored in the 7th percentile on the subtest “Auditory Discrimination in Quiet, and he scored in the 1st percentile on the subtest “Auditory Discrimination in Noise.” On the Fullerton-LTA STUDENT scored at least 1.5 standard deviations (SD) below the midpoint on 6 of 8 subtests. His worst score, -3.5 SD, was on the Oral Commands subtest, relevant to skills involving visual perception, verbal retention, attention, and auditory processing of multi-step directions. On Oral Commands, he particularly tended to miss the middle information in verbal commands and the size/shape or visual-perceptual information. He was measured a -2 SD on the Syllabication subtest, requiring skills in attending, memory, auditory discrimination, and discrimination of prosody. On the VMI he was below the .02 percentile in the Visual-Motor Integration and the Motor Coordination subtests, and he was at the 32nd percentile in the Visual Perception subtest. On the WRAML, a test of the student’s “ability to actively learn and memorize a variety of information,” STUDENT’s age-equivalent scores ranged from 5.3 in Visual Learning to at or just below 17.0 in Number/Letter and Verbal Learning. On the Key Math -Revised, STUDENT’s percentile rank subtest scores ranged from the 5th percentile in Mental Computation, Measurement, and Interpreting Data, to the 84th percentile in Addition.

On the PEER-2, STUDENT’s performance indicated poor pencil control and “notably slow” written output; “extreme difficulty” in “phonological manipulation,” reportedly indicating deficits in phonological awareness, active working memory, and short-term memory; “specific difficulty” with “word finding and retrieval memory”; and other difficulties on tasks involving “yes/no/maybe,” verbal instructions, sentence formulation, sentence ambiguity, missing information, paragraph summarization and comprehension, memory functions, time orientation, digit span, and alphabetic rearrangement. Those latter difficulties reportedly showed deficits in the ability to draw inferences, short-term memory, temporal-sequential organization and sequential memory, active working memory, and auditory processing.

On the Malcomesius, STUDENT’s performance reportedly showed specific difficulty with long-term visual memory, visual discrimination, visual perception, and “integrating visual perception in association with a kinesthetic-motor (written) response.”

On the Dysgraphia Assessment, including examination of STUDENT’s writing of several sequential letters and shapes, STUDENT repeatedly “looked up” after copying 2 or 3 letters from the board, indicative of “weak motor memory” and impaired visual processing skills. He also showed inconsistent letter formations and decreased writing speed. On the WLA, a “norm-referenced test which focuses solely on the direct evaluation of a student’s writing” in “modes of expressive, instructive, and creative writing. STUDENT was measured at or below the 1st percentile in general writing ability, productivity, word complexity, and readability. His “written language quotient” was at -3 SD.

In summary, Ms. Hollibaugh concluded that STUDENT fit the “diagnostic criteria” for, in her words, Components of a Non-Verbal Learning Disability (NLD) - to include Visual Processing Deficits, Writing Language Deficit, Dysgraphia, Math Skill Deficits, Auditory/Language Processing deficit - with slow rise time for listening and small chunk size capacity, Attentional Deficits, and Executive Function Deficits, to include difficulty with word recall on demand, active working memory and thought flexibility, difficulty with integration and synthesis of information. (Footnote 32)

Ms. Hollibaugh expressed her firm opinion, both in her report and in her testimony, that STUDENT has a significant auditory-processing disorder, and that STUDENT’s slow and methodical work was a product of STUDENT’s trying to compensate for that and other deficits, especially those deficits related to memory, visual-perceptual skills, and graphomotor (handwriting) skills. She testified that STUDENT needed 92 seconds to write the alphabet in cursive, with the norm being 30 seconds. Thus, understanding and taking notes during oral lectures would be particularly difficult for STUDENT because he has “breakdowns” both in processing and writing. “Holding facts in his mind” is difficult due to problems with short-term memory, so STUDENT especially has difficulty manipulating facts during his thought processes.

On cross-examination, the District’s attorney suggested to Ms. Hollibaugh that the level of STUDENT’s grades and overall academic achievement at school, including success in advanced-placement and college-preparatory classes, was inconsistent with the widespread nature and rather severe level of deficits identified by Ms. Hollibaugh. In response, Ms. Hollibaugh noted that STUDENT has a strong interest in history, that he has development compensatory strategies for working around his deficits. She testified that she does not know specifically how STUDENT is using compensatory strategies to achieve his grades, but she does know that he definitely “tests” with deficits.

To address STUDENT’s visual-processing deficits, Ms. Hollibaugh recommended “structured and specialized instruction for Written Language Skills and Math Skills in a program which actively trains visualization skills – such as Lindamood Bell. She also testified that STUDENT’s visual-processing deficits should also addressed by OT or a developmental ophthalmologist. To address STUDENT’s auditory processing deficits, she recommended intervention by a speech and language pathologist, and she also recommended “Fast-Forward for Adoclescents/Adults” and or Tomatis therapy, a form of sound therapy. She also recommended various accommodations and modifications, including the provision of lecture notes; use of graphs, charts, or maps that contain writing comments or have “easily understood” captions and legends; use of columns on “math papers”; instruction in keyboarding and word-processing software; and use of a laptop computer with a word processing program. Regarding placement, she recommended a “highly structuted environment” with small class size (8-10 students), personal space in the classroom for regrouping or relaxing, positive support, use of interesting material for STUDENT to learn, teaching of compensatory strategies, vocational counseling to prepare for transition, and a staff knowledgeable and experienced in teaching children with “NLD.”

Deborah Ross-Swain, Ed.D. Dr. Ross-Swain, a speech and language pathologist with a doctoral degree in education, conducted an auditory-processing evaluation of STUDENT in March 2004. Her April 1, 2004 report begins with a review of STUDENT’s history and assessment by prior evaluators. Dr. Ross-Swain administered the following standardized assessments: the Lindamood Auditory Conceptualization Test (LACT), the Wide Range Achievement Test (WRAT), the Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills-Upper Level (TAPS-U), the Ross Information Processing Assessment (RIPA-2), and the Test of Language Competence–Expanded Edition (TLC-Level 2). The report then states her conclusion that, on the basis of her testing, STUDENT “experiences moderate to significant difficulty with skills of auditory processing,” including “1) auditory discrimination 2) immediate auditory memory 3) auditory sequential memory 4) auditory latency 5) auditory conceptualization 6) auditory cohesion 7) interpretation and following directions (mild) 8) working overtime to listen 9) auditory overload and fatigue.” The report then reviews STUDENT’s performance on each test.

On the LACT, STUDENT’s “total converted score of 85” reportedly was equivalent to fourth-grade level and age 9.10 years. He ranked in the 2nd percentile on the TAPS-U in comparison to 18-year-old individuals. On the WRAT, his 42nd percentile encoding (spelling) and 84th percentile decoding (reading) scores were respectively equivalent to ninth-grade and post-high-school levels.

On the RIPA-2, Dr. Ross-Swain stated that STUDENT’s scores indicated “moderate to marked impairment” of STUDENT’s “immediate, recent and remote memory, temporal and spatial orientation, semantic and linguistic organization, problem solving and abstract reasoning, and auditory processing of temporal, spatial, and comparative information.” The impairment was described by Dr. Ross-Swain as being to such a degree that “STUDENT’s skills may not be functional for his processing needs at this time.” Later in the report, however, Dr. Ross-Swain recharacterized STUDENT’s temporal and spatial orientation skills as “mildly impaired.” She also recharacterized his semantic and linguistic organization skills as “mildly to moderately weak,” and she recharacterized STUDENT’s problem-solving and abstract-reasoning skills as “mildly impaired.” At the conclusion of her discussion of the RIPA-2 data, Dr. Ross-Swain yet again appears to change her opinion as to the degree of impairment indicated on the RIPA-2 by stating that “the results of this battery indicate that STUDENT experiences difficulty with specific skills that were assessed. These skills fall far below age level norms and expectations, and may not be considered to be functional for his personal and educational needs.”

On the TLC-Level 2, administered to assess “metalinguistic competence in semantics, syntax and/or pragmatics,” STUDENT’s subtest scores were in the 9th percentile for Ambiguous Sentences, 37th percentile for Listening Comprehension/Making Inferences, 1st percentile for Oral Expression, and 9th percentile for Figurative Language.

Dr. Ross-Swain concluded that “the difficulty that STUDENT experiences with oral expression and academic performance are [r]elated to the weaknesses that he experiences with auditory processing skills.” She recommended an intensive therapy program, especially one that will address STUDENT’s weaknesses with auditory discrimination and immediate auditory memory, and reduce processing delays and auditory fatigue. She recommended Auditory Development Intervention (ADI), individual auditory and language processing therapy provided by a speech and language pathologist, and various classroom and home strategies.

Dr. Ross-Swain testified that she considered the findings in her report to be consistent with the findings in Jennifer Hollibaugh’s report.

Discussion and findings. On the basis of the report and testimony by audiologist Judith Paton, STUDENT asserts that he has a central auditory processing disorder (CAPD) in addition to hyperacusis. More specifically, STUDENT asserts that his receipt of intelligible spoken input is impaired by poor suppression of unwanted background noise at the brainstem level, by distortion of speech phonemes due to slow auditory processing speed, and by poor phonemic/melodic awareness. Those conditions allegedly cause STUDENT to be distracted when attempting to perform “exacting work like math or writing,” reduce STUDENT’s ability to keep pace with lectures, and reduce STUDENT’s ability to discern meaning in accordance with the speaker’s tone of voice.

Also on the basis of Ms. Paton’s report and testimony, STUDENT asserts that he has deficits in short-term auditory and rote memory, “slow or inaccurate linking of auditory and visual information,” and “inefficient integration of language perceptions from the two brain hemispheres.” Those conditions allegedly interfere with STUDENT’s ability to learn by drill or repetition, decrease his writing speed and spelling skills, cause a simplistic writing style, and interfere with language pragmatics.

STUDENT further asserts that the report and testimony by Ms. Hollibaugh corroborate the opinions of Ms. Paton, and, in addition, establish that he has deficits in the overall use of language, including morphology, oral commands, convergent production, divergent production, syllabication, and the use and understanding of idioms, and that he has an “Auditory/Language Processing Deficit – with slow rise time for listening, and small chunk size capacity.”

Finally, on the basis of Dr. Ross-Swain’s report and testimony, STUDENT asserts that he “has weaknesses in the following areas: auditory discrimination, immediate auditory memory, auditory sequential memory, auditory latency, auditory conceptualization, auditory cohesion, interpretation and following directions, working overtime to listen, auditory overload, and auditory fatigue.”

The District, in its closing brief, states “there is also no dispute that STUDENT demonstrates certain weaknesses in relation to his auditory processing.” However, the District is not definitive as to what it believes those “certain weaknesses” may be. None of STUDENT’s proposed IEPs for the period at issue specifically mention auditory processing as an area of deficit or need. The District refers to the portion in Mr. Pinell’s March 2001 psychoeducational report that states STUDENT has “demonstrated an auditory weakness in the area of short-term auditory memory for rote or non-contextual verbal matter,” but the District then points out that, according to Mr. Pinell, “the overall results of the TAPS-U did not suggest an auditory-perceptual processing disorder” and the purported “identified weakness” in auditory processing could be due to the effects of STUDENT’s ADHD.

On the basis of their collection and interpretation of STUDENT’s test data, the experts who testified on STUDENT’s behalf all agreed that STUDENT has a significant auditory-processing disorder. Meanwhile, however, STUDENT tested in the average-range (overall) performance in auditory-perceptual skills, as measured on the TAPS-U by Mr. Pinell in 2001, and Dr. Ulrey’s independent opinions concerning auditory processing were consistent with Mr. Pinell’s opinion. Although neither Mr. Pinell nor Dr. Ulrey testified, District school psychologist Carolyn Patton (Fitzgerald) testified that STUDENT’s scores on the 2001 assessment performed by Mr. Pinell indicate that STUDENT does not have an auditory processing disorder. She noted that STUDENT’s Verbal IQ score of 114 on the WISC-III indicated no auditory-processing deficit, while the lower Performance IQ score of 89 was, according to Ms. Patton (Fitzgerald) consistent with relatively lower skills in visual-processing and reasoning.

On the basis of the above, one could conclude that, in the words of Ms. Hollibaugh, STUDENT “tests” with deficits in auditory processing. However, irrespective of how accurate or inaccurate the test data obtained by STUDENT’s experts may be, the determination of STUDENT’s educational needs requires something other than accumulating test data, correlating that data to generic literature, and presuming that the all of the literature-data correlations apply to STUDENT. Instead, the primary factor in determining STUDENT’s unique needs, for purposes of FAPE, is STUDENT’s performance in the education environment. In this respect, the opinions of Ms. Paton, Ms. Hollibaugh, and Dr. Ross-Swain share a conspicuous weakness, as explained below.

Ms. Paton’s “Central Auditory Processing Evaluation” is replete with generic information concerning auditory processing and how auditory-processing disorders adversely affect school performance. However, except for a brief comment at the beginning of the report to the effect that STUDENT’s grades are “very poor,” Ms. Paton’s report contains little or no mention of STUDENT’s performance in school or what she understands “very poor” to mean in terms of actual grades.

Similarly, Dr. Ross-Swain’s 13-page “Auditory Processing Evaluation” purports to describe, also at some length, how STUDENT’s auditory-processing deficits are adversely affecting STUDENT’s ability to learn. The report mentions the ninth-grade “STAR” testing, but the report contains no meaningful references to the type or level of classes that STUDENT has taken in high school or his performance in those classes. The report contains some references to STUDENT’s asserted difficulties with certain academic tasks. (Footnote 33) However, there is no clear indication that Dr. Ross-Swain even inquired about the type and level of STUDENT’s classes, about his grades, or about the services STUDENT had received in the past year. The report contains no discussion of whether the test data obtained during the evaluation was consistent with STUDENT’s performance in school. Meanwhile, the record shows that STUDENT has had some measure of success in college-preparatory and advanced-placement classes, yet in Dr. Ross-Swain’s report STUDENT’s skills were repeatedly described as “not functional” with respect to STUDENT’s “learning and communication needs,” his “processing needs,” and his “personal and educational needs.” Dr. Ross-Swain’s failure to address those seeming contradictions, either in her report or in her testimony, limits the usefulness of her report and the opinions contained therein.

Finally, Ms. Hollibaugh’s 17-page “Language - Learning Assessment” contains a detailed summary of STUDENT’s assessment data from 1994-1995 and from 2001-2003. The report lists STUDENT’s grades for the 2002-2003 school year, mentions his ninth-grade “STAR 9 Testing,” and contains a passing reference to STUDENT’s “poor grades in math due to lack of motivation to complete assignments” in April 2001. Otherwise, there is no direct reference to STUDENT’s performance in school, including his strengths and weaknesses in school-related tasks. There is no discernible attempt by Ms. Hollibaugh to compare or reconcile STUDENT’s assessment data with his school performance, and no opinion was forthcoming regarding whether STUDENT’s performance in school was consistent with the other assessment data. Ms. Hollibaugh’s above-referenced testimony concerning STUDENT’s use of unidentified compensatory strategies to obtain his grades in college preparatory and advanced placement classes, was understood by the Hearing Officer as an acknowledgment that STUDENT’s academic performance is, in fact, higher than would be expected from the privately-obtained clinical assessment data. Particularly troubling was Ms. Hollibaugh’s recommendation for placing STUDENT into what would essentially be a nonpublic school to obtain a more structured environment in a class of 8-10 students– a drastic recommendation by an expert who indicated only minimal knowledge about STUDENT’s performance in school or his engagement in school activities, such running for class office and participating in German club and Boys State.

In summary, while making extensive recommendations for addressing STUDENT’s auditory-processing deficits, STUDENT’s experts considered almost none of the available information about STUDENT’s actual performance in school. Instead, those experts appear to have purposefully avoided consideration of information that might be inconsistent with the clinical test data. Consequently, Ms. Paton, Dr. Ross-Swain, and Ms. Hollibaugh have described STUDENT’s performance on clinical tests, but they have not identified STUDENT’s unique educational needs. Thus, their recommendations may or may not be useful for improving STUDENT’s performance on clinical tests, but their recommendations are not necessarily transferable to the task of formulating an educational program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit. With regard to STUDENT’s performance in school, the opinions of Ms. Paton, Dr. Ross-Swain, and Ms. Hollibaugh portray a student with a wide array of profound auditory-processing deficits, such that, in Dr. Ross-Swain’s terminology, STUDENT’s auditory processing skills “may not be considered to be functional for his personal and educational needs.” That portrayal is contradicted by other evidence concerning STUDENT’s performance in school.

STUDENT’s performance in school, as described by testimony from teachers, tutors, and STUDENT himself, was reviewed above in subpart (A) of Issue 1. To restate and summarize: STUDENT’s chemistry tutor, Dr. Mendum, described STUDENT as “very smart verbally” and able to concentrate better than most students. His performance on oral testing was a better measure of his knowledge than written testing. STUDENT’s private tutor in tenth-grade English, Ms. Wuertle-Sullivan, described STUDENT’s difficulty with handwriting, mechanics, and sentence structure, but she also described him as bright, articulate, and “verbally brilliant – off the chart,” with a “vast” gap between his verbal and writing skills. STUDENT’s eleventh-grade advanced placement U.S. History teacher, Mr. Goodsell, testified that STUDENT’s participation in group discussions is usually “on point,” and he rates STUDENT’s “contribution” to the class as a “3” out of “5.” STUDENT’s grades are in the “B” range. STUDENT participates and does his work in class in a normal manner, and he is held to the same standards as his classmates. Participation was STUDENT’s greatest area of strength, and testing was the greatest area of weakness.

Ms. Baclig, STUDENT’s eleventh-grade chemistry teacher, described STUDENT as a bright, well-read student who appears motivated and had worked hard in chemistry, especially on his projects. His problems in chemistry were chiefly related to poor math skills, especially at the Algebra 1 level. STUDENT has told her that when he sees a math problem, the variables visually appear to “switch places on him.” She also testified that STUDENT absolutely performs better when tested orally. Ms. Baclig and STUDENT’s tutor (Dr. Mendum) reportedly agree that STUDENT knows “a lot more” than what his test scores indicate. Todd Blanset, STUDENT’s eleventh-grade English literature teacher, testified that STUDENT was earning a “C+.” Except for one project that was not turned in, he would be close to an “A.” He testified that STUDENT was a good speaker and he had noticed no problems with STUDENT’s ability to listen, although his writing often lacked specificity.

STUDENT testified that he does not recall basic recurring concepts in math, such as decimals, rounding, and canceling. His handwriting is poor and often illegible to him. His handwriting causes problems in math when he misreads numbers, and in notetaking if he miswrites a word, especially in chemistry and German. STUDENT states that he develops good ideas in his mind, but he writes slowly and has to think of each word individually as he writes it. By the time he has written a few words, he has lost his overall idea. Consequently, it is difficult for him to organize his thoughts when he writes. Although details are “in his head,” he writes only simple sentences, and he agrees that his writing lacks detail. He considers his reading skills to be good. STUDENT’s opinions of his own performance were consistent with his spring 2003 scores on the California Standards Test - Grade 10, wherein he was proficient in language arts, advanced in history/social science, and below-basic in math.

One can now examine the opinions of STUDENT’s experts within the context of evidence concerning STUDENT’s performance in school. (Footnote 34)

First, Ms. Paton theorizes that, in the educational environment, STUDENT may demonstrate “poor suppression of unwanted background sound at brain stem level.” However, the evidence concerning STUDENT’s actual performance in the classroom did not indicate that STUDENT has difficulties with listening to or understanding oral information. In fact, the contrary was demonstrated by evidence concerning STUDENT’s verbal skills, his oral participation in classroom discussion, and his ability to perform at a higher level when tested orally.

Ms. Paton further theorizes that STUDENT may have “Distortion of speech phonemes due to slow auditory processing speed at brain stem and cerebral level,” resulting in some words being mistaken for others or rendered nonsensical and causing difficulty with the oral teaching of foreign languages. Again, the evidence concerning STUDENT’s classroom performance was inconsistent with those assertions. There was no evidence to credibly suggest that STUDENT has difficulty discerning the words that are spoken to him. Moreover, although STUDENT is having difficulties in German III, he must have demonstrated a considerable measure of success to even reach German III. Similarly, STUDENT’s classroom performance does not indicate that “imperception of melody and prosody as clues to meaning” is impairing his ability to discern the meaning of spoken language through the speaker’s tone of voice. Also, STUDENT testified that in being accepted to the Boys State program, considered to be an honors-level achievement, he probably had the lowest GPA of the candidates but was “saved” by his interview. Thus, his ability to listen and speak in an interview format was demonstrated to an area of strength relative to typical peers. Finally, with regard to reading problems indicated by STUDENT’s “poor scores on Filtered Speech testing,” the evidence confirms that STUDENT has no deficits in reading and, in fact, is a good reader.

Ms. Paton further suggests that STUDENT’s poor auditory-visual integration “is thus one contributor to STUDENT’s slow writing and homework speed and his simplistic writing,” that STUDENT’s “Inefficient integration of language perceptions from the two hemispheres” contributes to STUDENT’s simplistic writing and short sentences when speaking. This seems a far-reaching conclusion for an audiologist to draw solely from STUDENT’s Staggard Spondaic Word (SSW) test and Pitch Pattern Sequencing (PPS) verbal response scores, especially when persons listening to STUDENT speak do not report having to “fill in gaps” when STUDENT speaks. Meanwhile, STUDENT’s established vision-processing, visual-perceptual, fine-motor, and OT-related deficits, as described by evidence discussed above, are sufficient by themselves to account for STUDENT’s slow and simplistic writing.

Finally, Ms. Paton states that STUDENT has “problems with language functions like intuition of the basic rules of language, word finding, accessing word meanings, and/or perceiving grammatical clues to meaning.” STUDENT demonstrates some of those characteristics in his academic performance. However, Ms. Paton attempts to connect those problems to an auditory processing disorder on the basis of STUDENT’s performance on the Dichotic Competing Sentences test. STUDENT’s performance on that test was measured by Ms. Paton in the “normal” range on the left and “borderline” range on the right. Thus, his test performance does not match her conclusion.

With regard to Jennifer Hollibaugh, her assessment covered visual skills, OT-related skills, and auditory processing. Her wide-ranging opinions and recommendations, including what would amount to the removal of STUDENT from public school, were made without consideration of how STUDENT actually performs in school. Consequently, the Hearing Officer gives minimal weight to those opinions and recommendations. Similarly, Dr. Ross-Swain’s opinions and recommendations were formulated with no apparent regard for STUDENT’s actual performance in school. Thus, Dr. Ross-Swain’s report includes statements such as: “the difficulty that STUDENT experiences with oral expression and academic performance are [r]elated to the weaknesses that he experiences with auditory processing skills.” She also makes repeated references to STUDENT’s skills being “not functional” in many areas. Meanwhile, the evidence showed that STUDENT does not manifest difficulties with oral expression in the classroom setting, and he has obtained some measure of academic success in his college-preparatory program. Thus, STUDENT’s academic achievement and his overall verbal skills absolutely contradict those statements made by Dr. Ross-Swain.

Having considered all of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that although STUDENT, as tested by his experts, tests as having deficits in auditory processing, STUDENT’s educational performance confirms that his unique educational needs arising from those asserted deficits must be comparatively minor. To whatever extent he may have unique needs arising from an auditory-processing disorder, there is no credible indication that he requires the auditory-processing remediation services recommended by his experts. Accordingly, for the 2003-2004 school year, the Hearing Officer finds that the program offered by the District, including accommodations for visual and oral prompts and cues to be used in the classroom, receiving copies of teachers’ notes, and being allowed extra time on tests, was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs related to auditory processing and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit.

(C) Written language.

It is undisputed that STUDENT has deficits in written language. His writing, is slow, simplistic, and lacking in accurate grammar. These deficits adversely affect STUDENT’s note-taking ability, his ability to express his knowledge on written tests, and the quality and content of his writing. On the basis of recommendations by Ms. Hollibaugh and Dr. Ross-Swain, STUDENT asserts that to address those deficits, the District should have offered programs such as the Lindamood-Bell Visualizing and Verbalizing program, sessions with a speech pathologist to “help strengthen and develop accommodations for expressive language and auditory/language processing skills,” and services by an educational therapist to “teach him strategies for overcoming his deficits and to provide him with academic remediation in the areas where he is weakest.” STUDENT has also asserted that goals and objectives should have been included for those services.

The District asserts that its offer for RSP services, OT consult, and accommodations including visual and oral prompts and cues to be used in the classroom, receiving copies of teachers’ notes, and being allowed extra time on tests, was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs related to written language.

As found above, STUDENT’s educational performance is not so affected by auditory processing deficits as to require remediation services such as those suggested by STUDENT’s experts. However, as found above, the District’s offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs arising from deficits in visual-processing, visual-perceptual, and fine-motor/OT/AT-related skills. STUDENT’s deficits in those areas have had a direct, negative effect on STUDENT’s performance in written language. To the extent that appropriate OT/AT services were not offered, the District failed to offer a program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in written language and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit. To that degree, STUDENT has been denied a FAPE. (Footnote 35)

(D) Math.

STUDENT asserts that his auditory processing deficits have adversely affected his performance in math. Consequently, he asserts that the District denied him a FAPE by failing to offer “remediation of his auditory processing deficit accompanied by intensive remediation from an educational therapist.” So far as can be gleaned from the evidence and testimony presented at hearing, the District basically asserts that STUDENT has passed his math courses through Algebra 2, and thus he needed no services to directly address his math skills.

STUDENT’s assertion that his auditory-processing deficits have adversely affected his performance in math is rejected. The Hearing Officer has already determined that no such auditory-processing deficits exist at that level. The more applicable question is whether STUDENT has unique educational needs in math and, if so, in what nature and to what extent?

Information concerning STUDENT’s math skills is mixed. In the spring of 2003, STUDENT scored below-basic in math on the California Standards Test - Grade 10. On the National Comparison: CAT/6 Survey Edition - Grade 10, STUDENT’s subtest percentile-rank score was 32 in math. In the ninth grade, STUDENT earned a “B” and “B-” in Algebra 1 for the 2001-2002 fall and spring semesters, respectively. In the tenth grade he earned a “C” and “C+” in Geometry for the 2002-2003 fall and spring semesters, respectively. In the 2003-2004 school year, he was at “C” level in Algebra 2. The evidence showed that STUDENT’s grades in math were bolstered in major part through extensive tutoring by STUDENT’s father, approximately 90 minutes daily, resulting in sufficiently-high homework scores to counter poor test scores.

Dr. Ulrey’s July 2001 report indicates that STUDENT’s difficulties in math may be a product of STUDENT’s visual-processing deficits, or some other developmental factor, or a combination of factors. There is insufficient information to know the exact cause or causes. However, what the evidence does demonstrate is that STUDENT’s deficits in visual-processing, visual-perceptual skills, and fine-motor control have had adverse affects on his performance in math and thus give rise to unique needs. This is demonstrated by STUDENT’s statements regarding his inability to read his handwriting accurately when doing math problems, his slow writing speed and its interference with STUDENT’s retaining thoughts to put on paper, and the matter of “variables” visually appearing to move on the page.

The District has done nothing specific, in terms of an IEP, to address STUDENT’s difficulties in math. Indirectly, the District has offered RSP services and OT services. An appropriate OT offer would have been designed to improve STUDENT’s visual-processing/visual-perceptual skills and, in turn, improve his handwriting legibility, handwriting speed, and ultimately his performance in math. Thus, to the extent the District’s offer of OT services has already been found deficient, the District failed to offer a program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in math. Considering that STUDENT’s educational benefit in math has been largely due to the intervention of STUDENT’s father, the Hearing Officer also finds that the District’s program was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit in math. To that extent, STUDENT was denied a FAPE.

(E) German.

STUDENT asserts that the District failed to implement a goal addressing STUDENT’s performance in German, proposed by the District in June 2002 and consented to by MOTHER in September 2002, and that the District failed to update the goal for the 2003-2004 school year. STUDENT also asserts that the District should have offered accommodations allowing STUDENT to retake tests, as that was the only way STUDENT was able to obtain a passing grade.

STUDENT’s German teacher for tenth and eleventh grade, Elizabeth Fisher, testified that she does allow STUDENT to retake tests. (Footnote 36) Thus, whether STUDENT’s IEP should have specified an accommodation for retaking German tests is a moot point. Moreover, the Hearing Officer is not concerned with whether the June 2002 goal was implemented during the 2002-2003 school year. That school year is not at issue. With regard to whether the District should have continued to implement the June 2002 goal under a “stay put” situation or provided updated German goals for the 2003-2004 school year, there was no showing that STUDENT required intervention in German during the 2003-2004 school year. To the contrary, Ms. Fisher testified that, in comparison to other languages, German is particularly difficult to learn. STUDENT was one of only 6 students, among her class of 20 students during the 2003-2004 school year, who had advanced to German III. Thus, on the basis of STUDENT’s performance, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT had no unique needs in German for the 2003-2004 school year and there was no denial of FAPE related to German. (Footnote 37)

(F) Social/emotional functioning.

STUDENT asserts that the District failed to provide services to address his social/emotional functioning. The Petitioner’s explanation of this allegation is somewhat long and convoluted, dating to a January 10, 2002 report by District school psychologist Carolyn Fitzgerald (Patton) that states STUDENT appeared to be functioning well, socially and emotionally, and “his teachers have not noted any signs of extreme depression, anxiety, or aggression.” Documentary evidence shows that in February and March 2002, two of STUDENT’s teachers had in fact noted concerns about STUDENT’s emotional state in class, and at least one of those teachers had reported her concerns to Ms. Fitzgerald. Ms. Fitzgerald did not supplement her January 10, 2002 report to reflect the new information. MOTHER described a chain of events wherein the District continued to erroneously rely on Ms. Fitzgerald’s January 2002 report, and STUDENT’s emotional state continued to decline due to the stress of purportedly not having appropriate services. All of this was allegedly aggravated by the failure of the District to offer appropriate supports for the 2003-2004 school year, and STUDENT’s having to work an oppressive number of hours each day to complete his school work. STUDENT’s psychiatrist, Kent Hart, M.D., testified that he noticed increased emotional problems with STUDENT during the 2003-2004 school year, especially after the parties had failed to reach an accord at the December 2003 IEP meeting, attended by STUDENT.

Irrespective of what STUDENT’s emotional state was during the 2003-2004 school year, the evidence showed that STUDENT was not manifesting emotional problems at school to the degree that intervention was required. His teachers were specifically questioned about STUDENT’s emotional state, and their testimony was consistent in showing no significant mood changes in STUDENT after the December 2003 IEP meeting. Moreover, in August 2003 the District offered to do an assessment of STUDENT’s social/adaptive behavior. The offer was declined by MOTHER. At the December 2003 IEP meeting, MOTHER expressed concerns about STUDENT’s emotional status. The District again offered to perform an assessment of STUDENT’s social/adaptive behavior, and the offer again was declined by MOTHER. Having considered those factors, the Hearing Officer finds no failure by the District to meet needs arising from STUDENT’s social/emotional status.

(G) Transition planning for post-secondary education.

Beginning at age 16 or younger, a pupil shall have a statement of needed transition services included in the IEP. Transition services means a coordinated set of services that does the following:

(1) “Is designed within an outcome-oriented process, that promotes movement from school to postschool activities, including postsecondary education, vocational training, integrated employment, including supported employment, continuing and adult education, adult services, independent living, or adult communication.

(2) Is based upon the pupil’s individual needs, taking into account the pupil’s preferences and interests.

(3) Includes instruction, related services, community experiences, the development of employment and other postschool adult living objectives, and, when appropriate, acquisition of daily living skills and functional vocational evaluation.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.1(c). See also 34 C.F.R. § 300.29.

STUDENT asserts that the transition plan offered by the District was flawed because it (A) was developed without his input, (B) failed to discuss whether STUDENT has a career goal that requires attendance at a four-year college, (C) failed to describe a “coordinated set of activities” or an “outcome oriented process” to promote STUDENT’s movement from high school to achieving his goals,” (D) failed to mention instruction, related services, community experiences, or anything else that might help STUDENT achieve his goals, (E) failed to take into account STUDENT’s preferences and interests, (F) failed to help STUDENT understand the requirements for being admitted to a four-year college, (G) failed to help him explore alternatives to a four-year college, (H) failed to address obtaining a driver’s license, balancing a checkbook, or writing a resume to allow STUDENT to live independently, (I) failed to address whether STUDENT is adequately prepared to attend college, (J) failed to provide a meaningful transition plan to remediate his academic deficits in math and written language, (K) failed to provide guidance as to which colleges may be willing to take his “learning disabilities” into consideration when making admission decisions, (L) failed to address whether he should seek to attend a community college before seeking transfer to a four-year college, and (M) failed to help him deal with the emotional impact of realizing that he may not gain admission to a four-year college.

The transition plan offered for the 2003-2004 school year listed STUDENT’s high school exit exam scores and a tabulation of his credit needed and earned toward graduation. Transition services included, for “instruction,” that STUDENT would continue college-preparatory courses; for “community experience,” that STUDENT would explore club/class activity at the WCW; and for “employment and adult living,” that STUDENT would complete the “Workability I Program (Intro to Work)” and opportunities would be offered if allowed by STUDENT’s schedule. The plan included a list of STUDENT’s desires for post school outcomes and his applicable present levels of performance. Those outcomes covered independent living, attending a four-year college, STUDENT’s participation in as many campus activities as his schedule would allow, and STUDENT’s desire to enter a military service academy. The plan mentions that it was developed, at least in part, on the basis of STUDENT’s COIN 3 self-assessment, a “career exploration component,” and informal interviews during the 2002-2003 school year. The specific classes for STUDENT’s recommended course of study throughout high school were listed.

Comparison of the transition plan to the list of objections shows that: (A) The plan was, in fact, developed with STUDENT’s input from informal interviews and the COIN 3. (B) The plan mentions STUDENT’s desire to attend a four-year college, but does not discuss whether his career goal would require attendance at a four-year college. However, § 56345.1(c) does not specifically state that STUDENT must have identified a career goal by his eleventh-grade school year. (C) The plan lists coordinated activities to promote STUDENT’s post-high-school goal of attending college, including taking college-preparatory courses, exploring club/class activities, completing the Workability I program, and considering employment if his schedule allows. (D) The plan mentions instruction, i.e. the specific college preparatory courses. It mentions participation in community experiences, as allowed by STUDENT’s schedule, that would help STUDENT achieve his goal of attending college. The plan does not list special education services or specific services, but those are listed in the IEP and the transition plan is part of the IEP. (E) The plan takes into account STUDENT’s chief preference and interest to attend a four-year college. (F) The plan does help STUDENT understand the requirements for entering a four-year college by listing his projected schedule of classed.

(G) The plan does not specify or explore alternatives to a four-year college, but there is no statutory requirement that a list of such alternatives must be included. (H) the plan does not discuss STUDENT’s getting a driver’s license or balancing a checkbook, ect., but there is no indication that those were areas of unique need. There are no special concerns regarding STUDENT’s ability to live independently as an adult. (I) To the extent that it lists the classes taken and the classes he should take, the plan does address whether STUDENT is prepared to attend college. (J) The statute does not require that a transition plan also contain a plan to remediate deficits. (K) There is no requirement that the plan include a list of colleges that may be willing to accommodate STUDENT’s “learning disabilities.” There has been no finding that STUDENT has a “specific learning disability” within the meaning of special education law, and no such finding has been requested. However, useful implementation of the plan would suggest that STUDENT should receive some guidance in identifying colleges that may be appropriate to his skill level and his needs. (L) Again, useful implementation of the plan would include assisting STUDENT in identifying appropriate types of colleges. (M) There was no showing that STUDENT has such social/emotional needs and, in any event, MOTHER repeatedly declined consent for a social/emotional assessment.

In summary, the transition plan falls short of the level of detail demanded by the Petitioner, but it complies with the requirements of § 56345.1(c). The Hearing Officer finds that the transition plan was appropriate, and that transition planning has been designed to meet STUDENT’s needs in that area.

(H) Organization.

There is no dispute that STUDENT needs services to address deficits in organization. This is verified in the IEP statement that STUDENT’s disability affects his ability to stay organized, and by the inclusion of an annual goal with short-term objectives directed at organization and completion of homework assignments using “organization and memory aides,” to be implemented by STUDENT’s RSP teacher. To that extent, the District’s program was appropriate. However, the evidence also showed that STUDENT’s organizational deficits are due, at least in part, to his visual-processing deficits. Thus, to the extent the District failed to offer appropriate OT services, the District’s offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs nor reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit in the area of organization.

(I) RSP services.

STUDENT asserts that the RSP class and services were inappropriate because the class was nothing more than a “study hall” where STUDENT was basically given a desk and expected to primarily work by himself. On September 16, 2003, STUDENT chose to drop the RSP class and enroll in a physical education class. The District asserts that the RSP class was designed to provide STUDENT with a “sort of ‘time out’ during his day” to allow him to “relax and recoup,” and that the teacher would also provide direct instruction in organizational skills and provide monitoring and implementation of STUDENT’s goal for organization and assignment completion.

STUDENT’s August 2003 proposed IEP states that the RSP teacher would consult with STUDENT’s regular education teachers and STUDENT would also receive RSP services, in the resource room, for 50 minutes daily. The IEP states that the RSP would help to implement the transition plan, implement the accommodation for STUDENT’s completion of tests orally in the resource room, and implement the organization goal.

Stephen Wright, STUDENT’s RSP teacher for the 2002-2003 school year, testified that he was focused on assisting other RSP students with Algebra 1 during the RSP class, so STUDENT primarily worked independently. He testified that it was not made clear to him what study skills he was supposed to address with STUDENT. He monitored STUDENT’s notebook on a daily basis and submitted progress reports on Fridays. On a daily basis, he would ask STUDENT about assignments and ask STUDENT if he needed help. Mr. Wright testified that he did provide some academic help, but he generally needed to ask STUDENT’s teachers about matters such as geometry. It was Mr. Wright’s understanding that the RSP class for the 2003-2004 school year would have been similar for STUDENT, although a different teacher had been assigned to STUDENT and a new goal had been written for organization.

The evidence showed that the RSP class served as a place where STUDENT could work independently, and STUDENT most definitely needed significant amounts of time to do homework. The RSP teacher was available if STUDENT had questions, and there was nothing to prevent STUDENT from asking questions. The RSP teacher may not have been particularly skilled in certain subjects STUDENT was taking, but the RSP teacher would seek input from STUDENT’s regular education teachers. The class provided a place for STUDENT to complete tests orally, if requested. The RSP teacher monitored and addressed STUDENT’s organization. The task of directly addressing STUDENT’s visual-processing and OT-related deficits was a matter for the OT specialist, not the RSP teacher. No other RSP-related needs were demonstrated by the evidence. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the RSP program was designed to meet STUDENT’s need for RSP services.

(J) Accommodations.

STUDENT asserts that the accommodations offered in the August 2003 IEP were not designed to meet his unique needs with respect to test retakes. More specifically he asserts that the District had agreed in September 2002 to allow the accommodation of test retakes on exams that were not passed with a score of 75 percent or better. That accommodation, however, does not appear in the August 2003 IEP. STUDENT asserts that without the provision for test retakes, he would likely be failing his math, chemistry, or German classes.

The Hearing Officer agrees that test retakes were appropriate for the purpose of addressing STUDENT’s difficulties with written testing in comparison to oral testing. In that respect, test retakes could actually provide a more accurate indication of what STUDENT had learned. In any event, the evidence, as indicated by STUDENT’s above-stated assertions and elsewhere, showed that STUDENT’s teachers have continued to allow test retakes. (Footnote 38) Thus, with the 2003-2004 school year having been completed, the matter of test retakes is a moot point.

Summary

With regard to the Petitioner’s substantive FAPE allegations, the Hearing Officer has found that by offering only 30 minutes of OT consult each month and by failing to offer STUDENT school and home computer access with appropriate word-processing software, the District failed to offer a program for the 2003-2004 school year that was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs arising from deficits in visual-processing, visual-perceptual, and fine-motor/OT/AT-related skills and failed to offer a program reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit. To that extent, STUDENT was denied a FAPE. The Hearing Officer has also found that to the extent such OT services and corresponding goals and objectives were not offered, the District failed to offer a program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in written language, math, and organization. To that additional extent, STUDENT was a denied a FAPE. The District also failed to offer a perceptual skills assessment, and the consequences of that failure will be addressed in Issue 3. In all other respects, the District offered a program for the 2003-2004 school year that was designed to meet STUDENTs’ unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit.

* * * * * * * * * * * *

Issue 2: Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year by violating various procedural requirements of the Individual’s with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and related law?

In addition to recognizing the importance of the substantive requirements of the IDEA, the Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 201. Federal special education law requires states to establish certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which the student is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE. Procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484.

In the present case, STUDENT asserts several procedural violations. STUDENT asserts that the District (1) illegally conducted the June 3, 2003 IEP meeting by not having STUDENT’s parents present, (2) illegally conducted the August 28, 2003 IEP meeting by not having STUDENT’s parents present, (3) illegally conducted the December 8, 2003 IEP meeting by allowing no meaningful participation by STUDENT’s parents, by ignoring the independent assessments provided by STUDENT’s parents, and by refusing “to consider academic goals and objectives for reasons of policy, without consideration of STUDENT’s unique needs,” (4) violated the IDEA by creating STUDENT’s transition plan without input from either STUDENT or his parents, and (5) denied STUDENT a FAPE by failing to have an IEP in place for him during the 2003-2004 school year. The District denies all of the above allegations.

The June 3, 2003 IEP meeting. During the scheduling of the June 3, 2003 IEP meeting, a dispute arose concerning the selection of a facilitator to participate in the meeting. The FAMILY objected to the District’s choice of a facilitator and, on the day before the meeting, they notified the District that they would attend the IEP meeting with no facilitator, or with a different facilitator, but not with the facilitator proposed by the District. MOTHER then requested that the meeting be postponed so she could obtain legal representation. The District did not postpone the meeting. Instead, the District held the meeting in the parents’ absence. The Petitioner asserts that the District’s insistence upon using a facilitator that the parents had objected to, and also the convening of the meeting without the parents present, was a procedural violation of the IDEA and related law.

Section 56341.1(g) of the California Education Code expresses the intent of the legislature that IEP meetings be nonadversarial and convened solely for the purpose of making educational decisions for the good of the student. Section 56341.5(a) provides that IEP meetings shall be scheduled at a mutually agreed-upon time and place. The law does not require that both parents be present. Section 56341.5(a) states that a district shall take reasonable steps to ensure that one of the parents is either present or otherwise afforded an opportunity to participate. Section 56341.5(g) provides that an IEP meeting may be conducted without a parent present if the District is unable to convince the parent to attend.

The Petitioner asserts that the use of a facilitator to whom the parents had objected would result in an adversarial meeting, thereby violating § 56341.1(g). The Hearing Officer is not convinced that the Petitioner’s argument is correct. Whether a meeting becomes adversarial would depend on what actually occurs at the meeting. Furthermore, the meeting notes show that the proposed facilitator did not attend the meeting, indicating that the District honored the parents’ request regarding the facilitator. Thus, it is speculation to say that the meeting would have been adversarial. However, the District did elect to conduct the meeting in the parents’ absence. During the due process hearing, the District implied that it had misunderstood MOTHER’s correspondence as meaning that she refused to attend, although the written correspondence actually states that “we find it necessary to postpone the meeting.” Thus, the weight of the evidence shows that the District erred, at least in part, in conducting the meeting. Consequently, the question to be addressed is whether the procedural flaw resulted in the loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT or seriously infringed on his parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process, thereby resulting in the denial of a FAPE.

In addressing this question, the Hearing Officer observes that the June 3, 2003 IEP meeting did not result in the formulation of an offer for the 2003-2004 school year. The meeting notes state that continued placement in RSP was recommended, but the notes further state that “the team will need to meet again to develop current goals and objectives and to determine further special education needs/placement.” Furthermore, the District’s July 8, 2003 letter to MOTHER enclosed a proposed assessment plan for MOTHER’s consent, and the letter stated that it intended to use the assessment information to provide an updated offer of FAPE. Therefore, with a specific offer for the 2003-2004 school year having not yet been made at the June 3, 2003 IEP meeting, with 3 months remaining before the start of the 2003-2004 school year, and with the District having expressly stated that it wanted to make an updated offer of FAPE, the Hearing Officer finds that irrespective of whether or not the District properly convened the June 3, 2003 IEP meeting, the parents’ absence from that meeting did not result in such loss of educational opportunity or so seriously infringe on the right of the parent to participate in the IEP process as to result in the denial of a FAPE. (Footnote 39)The August 28, 2003 IEP meeting. On July 11, 2003, the CDE issued a compliance report ordering the District to conduct an IEP meeting within 45 days. After a brief discussion between the parties wherein the District proposed August 27 and August 28 as potential meeting dates, by notice dated August 21 the District informed MOTHER that an IEP meeting had been set for August 28. MOTHER rejected the August 28 date. The stated reasons for the rejection, as best can be determined from conflicting evidence, were that (a) FATHER had to work and would be unavailable to attend the meeting and that (b) MOTHER was required to attend to family matters arising from her mother having had open-heart surgery on August 20. The District’s attorney, by letter dated August 22, 2003, informed STUDENT’s parents that, in light of the CDE directive, the District had determined that the meeting would proceed on August 28. The District made subsequent attempts to convince either of STUDENT’s parents to attend, but those attempts did not succeed. The meeting proceeded on August 28, without attendance by STUDENT’s parents.

The District asserts that it was caught between “a now-familiar rock and hard place.” The District could either convene the meeting with no parent present, or postpone the meeting and miss the CDE deadline. Either way, the District expected MOTHER to claim a violation of her procedural rights. The District asserts that it elected to convene the IEP meeting because it felt that option would be in STUDENT’s best interests. (Footnote 40)

Section 56341.5 of the California Education Code does not specify the conditions under which a parent is deemed to have been given an appropriate opportunity to attend an IEP meeting. Section 56341.5(g) mentions that a District must keep certain records of an attempt to convince the parent to attend, but the section does not state that the failure to keep those records necessarily precludes a District from convening an IEP meeting in the parents’ absence. In the present case, the record contains several letters between the attorneys for the parties as they argued their respective positions concerning and leading up to the August 28, 2003 meeting date. The content of those letters expressly shows a continuing attempt by the District to convince at least one of STUDENT’s parents to attend the IEP meeting. On the basis of those communications and the matters reflected by the content of the letters, the Hearing Officer finds that the District in fact attempted to but was unable to convince either of STUDENT’s parents to attend. Given the importance of formulating an IEP before the beginning of the school year, and considering the directive from the CDE that resulted from a complaint filed by the parents, the Hearing Officer finds that the District acted within the bounds of section 56341 by convening the IEP meeting without the parents present. Additionally, the Hearing Officer notes that the parents did not demonstrate sufficient excuse to miss the meeting. For example, there was no showing as to why STUDENT’s father had to attend work in lieu of an IEP meeting for his son. There was no showing why the unfortunate situation with MOTHER’s mother actually would preclude MOTHER from attending a meeting that would occur 8 days after the surgery. (Footnote 41)

The December 8, 2003 IEP meeting. STUDENT asserts that the District illegally conducted the December 8, 2003 IEP meeting by (a) allowing no meaningful participation by STUDENT’s parents, (b) ignoring the independent assessments, and (c) refusing to consider formulation of academic goals and objectives because STUDENT was taking classes exceeding the minimal requirements for graduation.

With regard to assertion (a), the Hearing Officer has reviewed the portions of the December 8, 2003 IEP meeting that were recorded and transcribed by MOTHER. A review of that 46-page transcript shows that MOTHER engaged in meaningful participation at the meeting. MOTHER’s comments comprise a weighty percentage of the transcript. She certainly spoke more than any of the other participants. MOTHER asserts that because the District ended the meeting at approximately 12:15 p.m., she did not have sufficient time to discuss STUDENT’s program. Meanwhile, District special education director Lynda Donahue testified that the meeting was scheduled to commence at 9:00 a.m., but it actually started at approximately 10:00 a.m. because MOTHER’s attorney had arrived about one hour late. Considering all of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District allowed meaningful participation by MOTHER at the December 8, 2003 IEP meeting.

With regard to assertion (b), a review of the transcript confirms that the District allowed MOTHER to summarize her independent assessments during the IEP meeting. Unfortunately, MOTHER used the majority of that time recounting, in detail, assessments from prior years, but she also recounted, for the IEP team’s consideration, the private assessments obtained in the summer of 2003. While the District may have been unimpressed by the independent assessments, that is not the standard. Section 56329(c) requires that districts “consider” independent assessments, but districts are not required to agree with such assessments. Having reviewed the transcript of the IEP meeting as stated above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District considered the independent assessments and thereby satisfied the requirements of § 56329(c).

Regarding assertion (c), STUDENT needed goals and objectives to address his deficits in visual-processing and OT-related skills. He was not receiving services, nor was there a showing that he needed services, directly related to his academic subjects. For example, he was not receiving “math” services or “German” services. Thus, although goals and objectives were required for addressing deficits that impacted STUDENT’s math, such as vision-processing deficits, no goals and objectives were required specifically for his academic classes. (Footnote 42)

The transition plan. STUDENT asserts that he was denied a meaningful opportunity to participate in the formulation of his transition plan. The Hearing Officer addressed the formulation and content of the transition plan in Issue 1(G). The evidence showed that the plan was developed, at least in part, on the basis of STUDENT’s COIN 3 self-assessment, a “career exploration component,” and informal interviews during the 2002-2003 school year. MOTHER and STUDENT also had an opportunity to discuss the plan at the December 8, 2003 IEP meeting, and MOTHER had communication with Ms. Nagle, the academic counselor, during the 2003-2004 school year, concerning STUDENT’s college options. There was no procedural denial of FAPE concerning the transition plan.

Having an IEP in place for the 2003-2004 school year. Finally, STUDENT asserts that because the August 28, 2003 IEP meeting was held without participation by his parents, there was no procedurally valid IEP in place at the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year. The Hearing Officer has already found that the August 28, 2003 IEP substantively denied STUDENT a FAPE. Further findings regarding the August 28, 2003 IEP would not affect the outcome of this Decision.

Summary

In summary, the Hearing Officer has found no denial of FAPE arising from procedural violations.

* * * * * * * * * * * *

Issue 3: Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement, compensatory education, and other remedies arising from the denial of FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year?

The Hearing Officer has found that by offering only 30 minutes of OT consult each month and by failing to offer STUDENT school- and home-computer access with appropriate word-processing software, the District’s offer for the 2003-2004 school year was neither designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs arising from deficits in visual-processing, visual-perceptual, and fine-motor/OT/AT-related skills, nor reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit. The Hearing Officer has also found that because such OT services and corresponding goals and objectives were not offered, the District failed to offer a program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in written language, math, and organization. To that additional extent, STUDENT was denied a FAPE. The Petitioner’s itemized request for relief is set forth on pages 54 through 56 of his closing brief. The requested relief covers reimbursement for private assessments, reimbursement for private services, compensatory education, and in some instances, orders concerning new assessments and prospective placement and services.

When a school District denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is appropriate in light of the purposes of the IDEA. In addition, equitable considerations may be weighed in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting such relief. School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 358, 369 (1985). Among the factors to consider is the conduct of the parties. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist. 960 F.2d 1479, 1486 (9th Cir. 1992).

Parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement of the services they have procured for their children when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement or services and the services provided by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370. The Burlington rule is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parent are found to be the exact proper placement or services under the IDEA. Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). Although courts have recognized that the parent’s placement does not have to meet a standard as high as the school districts must meet, the parent’s placement must still meet other requirements of the IDEA, such as providing a placement that addresses the student’s needs and provides the student educational benefit. Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13 (1993).

Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. See Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District, 916 F.2d 865 (3d. Cir. 1990); Miener v. State of Missouri, 800 F.2d 749 (8th Cir. 1986). There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for hour compensation for missed services. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994).

Section 56329(b) of the California Education Code provides that a parent has a right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil from a qualified specialist, if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency, in accordance with section 300.502 of Title 43 of the Code of Federal Regulations. However, if the district’s assessment, through a due process hearing, is determined to be appropriate, the parent is not entitled to have the independent assessment be at public expense.

In the present case, the Hearing Officer’s findings regarding auditory processing have eliminated the asserted grounds for much of the requested relief. Also, some of the requested relief, if granted, could be characterized as including elements of a prospective placement for the 2004-2005 school year. The 2004-2005 school year is not at issue in this case; therefore, there will be no findings or orders regarding elements of FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year. However, some of those latter requests may also be characterized as compensatory education for the denial of FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year and, to that extent, could be presently be ordered for implementation in the 2004-2005 school year. The Hearing Officer will now address the specific items in STUDENT’s request for relief.

STUDENT requests Tomatis therapy, to be followed by an assessment for FastForward. Both of those requests relate to auditory processing, and they are denied. STUDENT also requests two hours of educational therapy each day for the duration of the 2004-2005 school year, to be provided by an educational therapist. STUDENT has based that request primarily on the opinions of Ms. Hollibaugh and Dr. Ross-Swain, including the suggestion of some hybrid-type private placement with an educational therapist in lieu of attending a nonpublic school with a class size of 8-10 students. Under such a program, STUDENT would receive “unit credit for the two hours of educational therapy he will be receiving each day.” The opinions of Ms. Hollibaugh and Dr. Ross-Swain were found to have minimal correlation to STUDENT’s actual performance in school, and there was no credible basis for ordering such a restrictive placement. Consequently, that request is denied.

STUDENT requests speech and language therapy to address auditory processing deficits. That request is denied. STUDENT has no such needs for speech and language services. STUDENT’s request for Interactive Metronome therapy, also related to auditory processing, is denied.

STUDENT requests college counseling to be provided by a consultant selected by STUDENT’s parents. That request is denied. College issues are being addressed by the District’s transition plan.

STUDENT requests payment for the cost of attending the Summer Concordia German High School Program during the summer of 2004. That request is denied. STUDENT has no educational needs directly related to deficits in German.

STUDENT requests “DIS counseling” and reimbursement for private psychological counseling with Dr. Hart during the 2003-2004 school year. Those requests are denied. Although STUDENT has emotional issues, the evidence demonstrated no educational needs related to social/emotional issues. In consideration of the fact that social/emotional assessment is pending, the IEP team may reconsider the matter of DIS counseling for the 2004-2005 school year.

STUDENT requests reimbursement for the cost of Ms. Paton’s July 12, 2003 assessment and Dr. Ross-Swain’s April 2004 assessment. Both of those private assessments covered auditory processing. As the basis for reimbursement, STUDENT asserts that the March/April 2001 District psychoeducational assessment performed by Mr. Pinell was inappropriate because the District, relying on Mr. Pinell’s conclusions, found that STUDENT had minimal or no needs related to auditory processing. (Footnote 43) The evidence presented at hearing confirms that Mr. Pinell assessed STUDENT’s auditory processing, and Mr. Pinell’s conclusions on that subject were consistent with STUDENT’s educational performance leading up to and during the 2003-2004 school year. Mr. Pinell’s conclusions regarding auditory processing were also consistent with the findings of Dr. Ulrey, the U.C. Davis psychologist retained at MOTHER’s request to evaluate STUDENT in July 2001 because she disagreed with Mr. Pinell’s assessment. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that in formulating and offering a program for the 2003-2004 school year, the District had appropriately assessed STUDENT in the area of auditory processing. Furthermore, the assessment by Dr. Ross-Swain essentially duplicated the assessment by Ms. Paton. The request for reimbursement of the cost of the private assessments performed by Dr. Ross-Swain and Ms. Paton is denied.

STUDENT requests reimbursement for the sensory-integration/visual-perceptual skills assessment performed by Dr. Liddicoat. MOTHER obtained Dr. Liddicoat’s assessment because neither the February 2002 vision assessment by Dr. Grisham nor any other District assessment formally included a perceptual skills assessment. The Hearing Officer has previously found that a perceptual skills assessment was required. However, MOTHER obtained the assessment by Dr. Liddicoat on June 16, 2003. Dr. Liddicoat’s vision assessment was obtained during the period covered by the April 2002 settlement agreement. At that point, the District still had two and one-half months to assess STUDENT and have the IEP team formulate and submit a program offer before the start of the 2003-2004 school year. Moreover, in a letter to MOTHER dated June 12, 2003, the Solano County Counsel’s Office informed MOTHER of the District’s intent to submit an assessment plan for the 2003-2004 school year. (Footnote 44) Thus, although the Hearing Officer has previously found that STUDENT needed a perceptual skills assessment, MOTHER obtained the independent assessment by Dr. Liddicoat even before the District was required to offer such an assessment in preparation for the 2003-2004 school year, and even after being given notice that the District was preparing an assessment plan. Under these circumstances, the request for reimbursement is without legal basis and is denied.

STUDENT requests reimbursement for the “Language-Learning Assessment” performed by Ms. Hollibaugh on May 12, 20, and 21, and August 13, 2003. As recounted above, Ms. Hollibaugh’s assessment purported to cover areas of suspected disability. However, as with the assessments listed above, Ms. Hollibaugh’s assessment was commenced during the period covered by the April 2002 settlement agreement and several months before the start of the 2003-2004 school year. Under those circumstances, the request for reimbursement is denied.

STUDENT requests reimbursement for the August 22, 2003 OT evaluation by Ms. Bruce. This assessment was obtained after the period covered by the April 2002 settlement agreement, but there is no basis for awarding reimbursement. Even if MOTHER obtained the OT evaluation because she disagreed with the District’s prior assessment, such prior assessment would have been covered by the terms of the settlement agreement. Meanwhile, with respect to the District’s obligation to prepare for the 2003-2004 school year, the District had submitted a proposed assessment plan to MOTHER on July 8, 2003. The proposed plan specified OT assessment. Thus, the District was attempting to obtain current OT assessment information to enable the IEP team to formulate a program for the 2003-2004 school year. Accordingly, the request is denied.

STUDENT requests reimbursement for the cost of his laptop computer. The documentary evidence shows that the computer was purchased on August 21, 2003 (Pet. Ex. 1505). This was a full week before the District made its deficient offer for OT/AT services at the August 28, 2003 IEP meeting. (Footnote 45) Consequently, the laptop computer was not purchased in response to a denial of FAPE arising during the period at issue in this case. However, the laptop computer served, at least in part, to mitigate the effects of the District’s failure to meet STUDENT’s OT/AT-related needs. STUDENT testified that because of its bulkiness and because of theft concerns, he seldom brought the computer to school, but he used it at home. On the basis of the above, STUDENT’s parents shall be awarded reimbursement for fifty percent of the cost of the computer and software. Documentary evidence shows that the total cost was $1,134. The District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents for one-half of that amount, or $567.00.

STUDENT requests reimbursement for the cost of the private chemistry tutoring provided by Dr. Mendum during the 2003-2004 school year. The evidence showed that STUDENT’s difficulties in chemistry were likely due in significant part to his difficulties in math, and both were adversely affected by his visual-processing deficits. By attempting to reduce STUDENT’s OT from 90 minutes each month to 30 minutes of consult each month, the District did not offer a program for the 2003-2004 school year that was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs in vision processing. However, under “stay put,” STUDENT would still have received either 60 minutes or 90 minutes of OT each month, depending on whether the April 2002 settlement agreement or the parties’ agreement for the 2002-2003 school year applied as stay put. Unfortunately, in April 2003, MOTHER withdrew her consent to OT, expressing her dissatisfaction with the provider. Rather than arranging with the District to obtain a different therapist, MOTHER chose to have STUDENT be without OT services throughout the 2003-2004 school year. Having thus considered the above circumstances, including the conduct of the parties, the Hearing Officer denies the request for reimbursement. See W.G., supra.

STUDENT requests reimbursement for the vision therapy provided by the EYEcenter from August to December 2003. The Hearing Officer has found that the District’s offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs related to vision-processing and visual-perceptual skills. However, STUDENT was assessed by Dr. Liddicoat on June 16, 2003, and commenced vision therapy on July 8, 2003. (Pet. Ex. 1499.) Thus, MOTHER had committed STUDENT to a vision therapy program before the District made a program offer for the FAPE period at issue in this case. Therefore, the request for reimbursement is granted only for the cost of the therapy and reevaluation obtained from August 29 to December 24, 2003. The District shall compute and reimburse that amount in accordance with the billing itemization in Pet. Ex. 1499-1502.

STUDENT requests an order for OT therapy for one hour per week for 36 weeks, as recommended in the OT assessment by Ms. Bruce, followed by an assessment to determine what, if any, additional therapy is needed, and then automatic granting of the additional therapy. The first 36 weeks computes to slightly more than 120 minutes of OT each month for approximately the duration of STUDENT’s senior year in high school. The 2004-2005 school year is not at issue in this case. Accordingly, no findings or orders will be made concerning the components of FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year. However, the Hearing Officer does have jurisdiction in this case to make orders for future compensatory education arising from the denial of FAPE that occurred in the 2003-2004 school year.

Regarding the above request for OT, the Hearing Officer notes that Ms. Bruce was a credible and informative witness. She stated that her examination was a medically-based assessment, not a school-based assessment, and she stated that she did not inquire whether STUDENT needed school-based services. In spite of the limited scope of her assessment, it is the best available assessment concerning STUDENT’s OT-related needs, and her pertinent findings are consistent with STUDENT’s actual performance in school. Furthermore, the amount of OT services recommended by Ms. Bruce is similar to what the parties had last agreed would be an appropriate amount for the 2002-2003 school year. In addition, STUDENT still has OT-related deficits adversely affecting his educational performance, and time to address those deficits is short– STUDENT will start his senior year in one month. The Hearing Officer is reluctant to trust that the parties will be able to reach agreement on an OT compensatory education remedy if the matter is referred to the IEP team. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer will order that unless the parties agree otherwise, as compensatory education for the denial of FAPE in the area of OT for the 2003-2004 school year, the District shall provide one hour of OT each week for 36 weeks, as recommended by Ms. Bruce, to address the deficits identified in Ms. Bruce’s report. The order will not require Ms. Bruce or Sutter Roseville Medical Center to be the service provider. The request for reassessment after 36 weeks is also granted, but the reassessment recommendations shall not be binding on the IEP team. (Footnote 46)

STUDENT’s IEP team will have to reach agreement on goals and objectives to accompany the above-referenced OT, and shall also have to decide how to apportion the services between clinic and school-based services and/or consult. The team must take into consideration the degree to which each area of deficit and/or concern listed in Ms. Bruce’s report is adversely affecting STUDENT’s educational performance. The IEP team is reminded that Ms. Bruce’s August 2003 report predates the December 2003 completion of STUDENT’s vision therapy at the EYEcenter. Due to the overlap of STUDENT’s fine-motor/OT/vision-processing/visual perceptual needs, and the fact that the EYEcenter reported progress from the vision therapy, the team will have to decide which of STUDENT’s remaining deficits in those areas must be addressed to meet his educational needs. STUDENT requests “an assessment by Lindamood-Bell to determine the number of hours of remediation STUDENT requires with respect to a Visualizing and Verbalizing program and provision of the hours recommended in the assessment.” That request is denied. As described in the Petitioner’s closing brief, the Lindamood-Bell services were requested in the context of auditory processing. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer will not issue an order directing Lindamood-Bell to supercede the duties of STUDENT’s IEP team.

STUDENT requests an AT assessment to identify the computer software to be used by STUDENT. However, STUDENT’s program for the 2004-2005 school year is not at issue. An AT assessment was already performed in March 2002. Whether STUDENT requires a new AT assessment for purposes of addressing his OT/AT-related needs for the 2004-2005 school year is a matter for his IEP team to decide. Accordingly, the request for an AT assessment is denied.

Lastly, STUDENT requests an order directing the District to hold an IEP meeting prior to the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year to address various listed matters pertinent to the 2004-2005 school year. Again, the 2004-2005 school year is not at issue in this case. Thus, the request is denied.

ORDER

1. Unless the parties agree otherwise, within 15 business days from the date of this Decision, and as often as is necessary thereafter, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting to accomplish the following:

(A) Amend STUDENT’s IEP to provide for one hour of OT each week for 36 weeks, commencing no later than the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year, to address the deficits identified in Ms. Bruce’s report (Pet.Ex. 1525). The IEP team shall develop goals and objectives to accompany the OT, taking into consideration the degree to which each area of deficit identified in the report is adversely affecting educational performance. The IEP team shall also decide how to apportion the services between clinic and school-based services and/or consult. Reassessment shall be done after 36 weeks, although the IEP team shall not be precluded from requesting earlier reassessments in addition to the 36-week reassessment.

2. Within 30 calendar days from the date of this Decision, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents in the amount of $567.00 for the laptop computer.

3. Within 30 calendar days from the date of this Decision, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the costs of the vision therapy and evaluation services received by STUDENT at EYEcenter from August 29 to December 24, 2003. The District shall compute and reimburse that amount in accordance with the billing itemization in Pet. Ex. 1499-1502.

4. All of the Petitioner’s remaining requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

The hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. Cal. Educ. Code § 56507(d),

Issue 1: Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year by failing to offer a program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the following areas:

(A) Visual processing, fine-motor, occupational therapy (OT), and assistive technology (AT). STUDENT prevailed on this issue.

(B) Auditory processing. The District prevailed on this issue.

(C) Written language. STUDENT prevailed on this issue.

(D) Math. STUDENT prevailed on this issue.

(E) German. The District prevailed on this issue.

(F) Social/emotional functioning. The District prevailed on this issue.

(G) Transition planning for post-secondary education. The District prevailed on this issue.

(H) Organization. STUDENT prevailed on this issue.

(I) Resource specialist program (RSP) services. The District prevailed on this issue.

(J) Accommodations. This issue was determined to be moot.

Issue 2: Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year by violating various procedural requirements of the Individual’s with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and related law? The District prevailed on this issue.

Issue 3: Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement, compensatory education, and other remedies arising from the denial of FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year? STUDENT prevailed on this issue to the extent that OT-related services were awarded as compensatory education, reimbursement for fifty percent of the cost of STUDENT’s laptop computer and software was awarded, and reimbursement for a portion of STUDENT’s vision therapy was awarded. The District prevailed on the remaining requests.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Dated: July 30, 2004 _________________________________ Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. Mr. Varma’s motion to withdraw was heard by telephone conference on February 24, 2004, by a hearing officer other than the undersigned Hearing Officer. The District did not participate in that conference.

2. These are the issues as presented for hearing by the Petitioner. Whether or not the Petitioner actually has needs in some of the above-stated areas is also in dispute. 3. The term “PSA” refers to “perceptual skills assessment.”

4. At least one purpose of this latter provision was to identify “stay put” in the event of a due process filing for the 2003-2004 school year.

5. At the request of STUDENT’s parents, Dr. Liddicoat’s office provided STUDENT with approximately 4 months of private vision therapy, ending in December 2003.

6. As of September 8, 2003, there had been no reply.

7. Case number SN03-01423 convened for hearing on September 10, 2003. The District moved to dismiss issues that it alleged were covered by the April 25, 2002 settlement agreement. After an evidentiary hearing concerning the agreement, Hearing Officer Ohler issued an October 24 order granting the District’s motion to dismiss all issues pertaining to the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years. The Hearing Office rescheduled the remaining portion of case number SN03-01423, pertaining to the 2003-2004 school year, for hearing to commence on October 28, 2003. However, STUDENT’s representatives withdrew that case prior to commencement of the hearing. The present request for a due process hearing solely on issues concerning the 2003-2004 school year was filed on December 3, 2003.

8. The version of the June 4, 2002 IEP in the District’s evidence packet (Dist. Ex. 57) contains several references to the IEP team’s agreement on various matters, but there is no signature on the document to indicate parent agreement or consent.

9. The District’s understanding of these matters is set forth in an October 10, 2003 letter from its attorney, Jan Tomsky, to STUDENT’s attorney, Bob Varma. As mentioned above, parent consent for OT consultation had been withdrawn in approximately April 2003.

10. Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and mandates that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be satisfactorily achieved. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. Additionally, the student’s IEP must provide for the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum in accordance with the student’s unique needs and present levels of performance and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a). Neither requirements are directly at issue in the present case.

11. STUDENT’s statement of issues presented for hearing, as well as the parties’ closing briefs, list visual processing, fine-motor, OT, and AT as separate issues. Because of the overlapping nature of the evidence and findings pertinent to these areas, for purposes of analysis the Hearing Officer has combined them into one subissue

12. According to the March/April 2001 assessment by District school psychologist Richard Pinell, STUDENT’s WISC-III scores included Verbal IQ = 114 (82nd percentile), Performance IQ = 89 23rd (percentile), and Full Scale IQ = 102 (approximately 55th percentile). Mr. Pinell’s report states that “a significant discrepancy exists between STUDENT’s Verbal and Performance IQs in favor of the Verbal IQ. Thus, STUDENT’s verbal abilities represent best how he solves problems. STUDENT’s below average performance on two Performance subtests suggests difficulties with visual-perceptual skills involving part-to-whole synthesis and visual-processing speed.”

Mr. Pinell’s report states that on the VMI, STUDENT demonstrated Low Average visual-perceptual skills (21st percentile) and Low Average to Average fine-motor skills (32nd percentile), considered by Mr. Pinell to be “commensurate with the results from the performance portion of the WISC-III and do not reflect a visual-motor integration processing deficit.” The report states that on the TVPS-UL, STUDENT exhibited “significant weaknesses” in short-term visual memory, distinguishing essential from non-essential visual detail, and visual completing of missing visual detail. He exhibited “relative weakness” in short-term memory for visual-sequencing matter. According to Mr. Pinell, the TVPS-UL results suggested that “STUDENT’s visual-perceptual skills are potentially an area of processing deficit.”

In his report, Mr. Pinell eventually concluded that the “the processing assessments suggest STUDENT exhibits difficulties with his visual-perceptual skills,” and he further concluded that “STUDENT appears to demonstrate visual-processing deficit in the areas of visual memory and distinguishing essential from nonessential details.”

13. David Grisham, O.D., examined STUDENT in February 2002 at the District’s request. His report states that the examination was requested to assess complaints of “tired eyes and burning for reading . . . poor copying skills . . . poor math” and to determine whether a “PSA” was needed. Dr. Grisham’s impressions included reduced visual acuity in the left eye due to uncorrected nearsightedness (20/40), normal eye muscle balance, good tracking and reading eye movements, and “tired eye” due to refractive imbalance. Glasses or contacts were suggested for school use. Dr. Grisham also suggested a typing course and tutoring for specific subjects that STUDENT may be struggling with. His report states that no “PSA” was needed.

14. Grayson Hunley, AT specialist for the SELPA, conducted an AT assessment from January to March 2002, for the particular purpose of addressing STUDENT’s writing and copying skills. Recommendations included consideration of use of a tape or digital recorder to verbally record assignments posted on the board, followed by transcription by hand or with a word processor; enrollment in a typing class or use of a typing software program; use of test-to-speech feedback for assignments produced by a word processor; handwriting development through OT; use of pencil grips; increased word-processor usage; use of peer editing/collaboration; and “process writing strategies with an emphasis on planning, organization, editing, and revising.”

15. Kara Cannon, an occupational therapist at Progressus Therapy, Inc., submitted a progress note summarizing STUDENT’s progress in OT from March 2002 to August 2002. The report states that individual activities from the Visual-Perception Developmental Remedial Activities – Upper Level (Gardner, 1993) had targeted STUDENT’s needs in the areas of visual memory, visual sequential-memory, visual figure-ground, and visual closure. “Good progress” was reported in visual-memory and sequential-memory tasks, including STUDENT’s studying a single design or a series of shapes and then four similar designs/series and recalling the correct one. Progress had been made in visual figure-ground and visual-closure activities, but those remained “areas of difficulty.”

Ms. Cannon’s August 2002 progress report further states that to address handwriting difficulties caused by decreased finger-isolation skills, and to assist with typing ability, STUDENT had been provided with “theraputty home-exercises” and Gripmaster. He had also been using the Typing Tutor 7 program as an introduction to typing and had progressed from 14 words per minute to 17.5 words per minute in random typing samples. He was able to keep his hands in correct placement on the keyboard.

16. Jennifer Hollibaugh, a private educational therapist and speech and language pathologist, administered the VMI to STUDENT at some time between May and August 2003. He scored below the .02 percentile in the Visual-Motor Integration and the Motor Coordination subtests, and he was at the 32nd percentile in the Visual Perception subtest. On the WRAML, a test of the student’s “ability to actively learn and memorize a variety of information,” STUDENT’s age-equivalent score was 5.3 in the Visual Learning subtest. On the Malcomesius Specific Language Disability Test, STUDENT’s performance reportedly showed specific difficulty with long-term visual memory, visual discrimination, visual perception, and “integrating visual perception in association with a kinesthetic-motor (written) response.” On the Dysgraphia Assessment, including examination of STUDENT’s writing of several sequential letters and shapes, STUDENT repeatedly “looked up” after copying two or three letters from the board, indicative of “weak motor memory” and impaired visual processing skills. He also showed inconsistent letter formations and decreased writing speed.

17. Leanne Liddicoat, O.D, at EYEcenter Optometrics, conducted a two-hour “sensory-motor examination” of STUDENT by parent request on June 16, 2003. STUDENT’s “entering concerns” included losing his place when copying, handwriting clarity, visual processing, and distance blur. Dr. Liddicoat concluded that STUDENT is myopic in both eyes and glasses or contacts should be worn full-time. He had a reduced ability to track his eyes accurately which, according to Dr. Liddicoat, could cause symptoms including reduced reading speed, losing one’s place while reading, difficulty copying from a board to paper or from a book to paper, and eye discomfort or fatigue while performing any near point task. He had mild convergence insufficiency and mild accommodative insufficiency, conditions that could cause blurring or doubling of an image on a page or the appearance that words are moving on a page. From his results on the Getman Motor Visual test (STUDENT scored at fifth-grade level), the Beery Visual-Motor Integration test (STUDENT scored at 11.8 years level), and the Gardner Test of Visual-Perceptual Skills (Gardner), Dr. Liddicoat concluded that STUDENT had profound areas of deficit in visual-processing/visual-perceptual skills. On the Gardner, STUDENT scored at the 0.1 percentile in visual discrimination, visual sequential-memory, visual figure-ground, and visual closure. He scored in the 5th percentile for visual memory and 9th percentile for visual form constancy.

On the basis of her examination findings, Dr. Liddicoat recommended at least four months of vision therapy. STUDENT commenced vision therapy at the EYEcenter on June 18, 2003.

According to EYEcenter literature provided by Dr. Liddicoat, visual processing refers to the ability of the brain to extract meaning from visual images. Figure-ground discrimination refers to the ability to distinguish a target object from the background. Visual memory refers to the ability to remember a form, letter, or word over a period of time. Visual closure refers to the fact that when one looks at an object, shape, or work, there is insufficient time to follow every detail of the shape. However, the brain should be able to “fill-in” those pieces that one’s eyes do not actually follow. Such deficits, according to the literature, can cause difficulty with attention, reading, comprehension of written material, and copying.

18. Beverly Bruce evaluated STUDENT on August 22, 2003, in her capacity as an occupational therapist and certified sensory-integration therapist at Sutter Roseville Medical Center. Her report states that STUDENT presented with subjective concerns regarding “labored” handwriting with poor legibility. Objectively, Ms. Bruce noted low muscle tone. On the Motor Free Visual Perception Test – Third Edition (MVPT-3), STUDENT scored in the 5th percentile. As a measure of fine-motor skills, STUDENT ranked at the age equivalent of 10 years and 3 months, the 6th percentile, on the VMI. On gross motor development skills, STUDENT demonstrated difficulty with “sequencing and initiation, and “impaired body scheme.” He appeared hypersensitive to visual and auditory sensory input, and hyposensitive to vestibular input. Regarding “organization of behaviors,” he showed difficulty with organization, task completion, attention, and following directions, corroborated by his percentile rank of less than 1 percent on the Goodenough-Harris Draw a Person test. Ms. Bruce’s impression was that STUDENT had deficits in visual-motor control, fine-motor skills, balance, and bilateral coordination. She also noted concerns regarding postural/ocular mechanisms, visual perception, bilateral integration, sensory processing/regulation, and behavioral organization.

Ms. Bruce recommended one hour of OT each week for 36 weeks. She testified that her recommendation was the maximum allowable under STUDENT’s applicable health insurance, but in either case she would want to reevaluate STUDENT in six months to see if interventions were effective. She stated that interventions would be helpful but would not necessarily remediate STUDENT’s deficits. She stated that remediation would be more likely to occur in a younger person, while the nervous system is “plastic.” She stated that she knows of no services STUDENT has received at Sutter Roseville Medical Center.

Ms. Bruce further testified that although she did not assess STUDENT’s typing ability, she would consider typing to be problematic because of STUDENT’s deficits in visual-perceptual and fine-motor skills. She also noted that her examination was a medically-based assessment. It was not a school-based assessment, and she did not inquire whether STUDENT needed school-based services.

19. Dr. Liddicoat testified that she did not have enough information to state whether STUDENT’s vision problems affected his learning. She was not familiar with his academic performance.

20. Most of the teachers who testified were STUDENT’s teachers during the 2003-2004 school year, and their impressions were largely formed after the District had made its offer for the 2003-2004 school year. However, the Hearing Officer considers their testimony to be indicative of how STUDENT likely performed during the months leading up to the formulation of the District’s offer. The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT’s performance after the District made its formal offer is also relevant because of the District’s continuing obligation to offer a FAPE throughout the 2003-2004 school year and, if necessary, revise the offer.

21. The State target is for all students to reach at least the proficient range. STUDENT’s scaled score of 347 in Science: Biology was 3 points below the proficient range of 350-393. His score of 273 in Mathematics: Geometry was well below the basic range of 300-349 and proficient range of 350-417.

22. The description of therapy being provided by Ms. Cannon addressed fine-motor skills in relation to handwriting and typing.

23. At the December 8, 2003 IEP meeting, STUDENT explained that he was able to complete the essay during class only because the English teacher had given him the assignment the night before, and he had prepared for it that evening with his tutor.

24. Nothing in the notes from the IEP meeting references the discussion of a five-page handwritten essay.

25. MOTHER’s withdrawal of STUDENT from OT in April 2003 was probably too close to the end of the school year to provide reliable information regarding how STUDENT would progress over an entire school year with what would have amounted to a two-thirds decrease in monthly OT. The OT services STUDENT received during the 2002-2003 school year have been referred to by both parties as “consult” and as “services.” The extent to which the services were “direct” services to STUDENT is unknown.

26. The manner by which Ms. Paton was able to refer to Ms. Hollibaugh’s report is unclear. Ms. Paton testified that she had viewed a draft of Ms. Hollibaugh’s report. Ms. Paton’s undated report refers to testing performed by Ms. Paton on July 12, 2003. Ms. Hollibaugh’s undated report refers to testing performed by Ms. Hollibaugh in May and August 2003.

27. The specific basis for the asserted legal standard of “help[ing] STUDENT work up to true intellectual ability” is not revealed by Ms. Paton.

28. Ms. Paton testified that the last five pages of her report were written generically but that all of the information was applicable to STUDENT.

29. Hyperacusis, in general, refers to sounds being perceived as too loud.

30. The data attached to Ms. Paton’s report includes some questionnaires completed by STUDENT’s mother concerning her observations of STUDENT.

31. Ms. Hollibaugh testified that there currently are no standardized training or licensing requirements for an educational therapist.

32. Ms. Hollibaugh’s report does not indicate the source of the “diagnostic criteria.”

33. Dr. Ross-Swain’s report does include some general references to STUDENT’s strengths and weaknesses, although the source is not indicated. The report states that STUDENT “is experiencing difficulty with following directions from the teacher, spelling, getting homework completed without a great deal of help, copying words from the board, learning math facts, learning and remembering vocabulary for classes, putting things in order, and remembering things people say. He often has to be re-taught the subject matter. His parents report that he works very hard to do well in school, but frequently still has difficulties.”

34. The reports by Ms. Bruce and Dr. Liddicoat also have a lack of references to STUDENT’s performance in school, yet the Hearing Officer has treated those reports favorably in comparison to the reports of Ms. Paton, Dr. Ross-Swain, and Ms. Hollibaugh. The favorable treatment results from the fact that evidence showing STUDENT’s school-based performance is consistent with the deficits found on clinical testing by Ms. Bruce and Dr. Liddicoat.

35. With regard to STUDENT’s request for speech and language services, the evidence does not show that STUDENT has needs in speech and language. In either event, the District has offered a language-speech communication assessment by a speech and language therapist, and MOTHER has signed her consent to that assessment. The outcome of this Decision is not intended to be interpreted by the parties as eliminating the appropriateness of conducting a speech and language assessment.

36. She indicated that STUDENT would likely be in the “C” range in either event.

37. The matter of whether STUDENT needed an accommodation for test-retakes in German III will again arise in subpart (J) of Issue 1.

38. See Pet. Ex. 1521.

39. The Petitioner cites Shapiro v. Paradise Valley USD, 317 F.3d 1072 (9th Cir. 2003). The facts and findings in Shaprio are distinguishable from the present case. In Shapiro, the Court found that the district committed procedural errors by holding a particular IEP meeting without the parents present and without either the student’s special education teacher or her speech and language pathologist present. The Court noted that procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE, but that procedural inadequacies that result in the loss of educational opportunity, or seriously infringe the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process, clearly result in the denial of a FAPE. After considering several facts and circumstances in the case, including the nature of the procedural flaws, the Court found that the district’s “failure to include the persons most knowledgeable about Dorie’s educational levels and needs – namely a representative from CID and Dorie’s parents – at the June 8 [1994] IEP meeting and its concomitant creation of a defective IEP resulted in lost educational opportunity for Dorie.” The Court did not elaborate on precisely how educational opportunity had opportunity for Dorie.” The Court did not elaborate on precisely how educational opportunity had been lost, but the facts in Dorie suggest that the procedurally-flawed IEP led directly to the parents’ enrolling Dorie in a private school at their own expense, thereby giving rise to a claim for reimbursement.

The present case is distinguishable from Shapiro. In the present case, the facts show that at the June 3, 2003 IEP meeting, the District did not formulate an IEP. Furthermore, the evidence showed that the actions of the District on June 3, 2003, were not the cause of MOTHER’s obtaining private assessments and services during the summer of 2003. Her disagreement with District assessments predated the June 3, 2003 IEP meeting by years. Her intention to obtain several private assessments had most recently been stated to the District in letters dated May 20 and 28, 2003. Thus, the facts showed that the convening of the IEP meeting did not result in loss of educational opportunity or seriously infringe the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process.

40. The District’s reasoning is not persuasive. Given the long history of animosity between the parties, the District should have anticipated that MOTHER would not agree to a IEP formulated in her absence. Moreover, postponing the meeting may have resulted in violation of the CDE order, but convening an IEP meeting without parent participation may also have fallen short of compliance with the CDE order.

41. Although the District may not have known this information at the time, there was no showing as to why, according to Ms. Bruce’s records, STUDENT was able to attend OT evaluation sessions, accompanied by MOTHER, on August 22, August 25, and September 8, 2003, yet neither of his parents was able to attend the August 28, 2003 IEP meeting.

Moreover, even if a procedural flaw had occurred (and the Hearing Officer has found that it did not) the evidence demonstrated that the District’s decision to convene the IEP meeting neither resulted in loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT nor seriously infringed on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process. Specifically, the evidence shows that promptly upon completion of the August 28, 2003 IEP meeting, the District drafted a letter and mailed it to STUDENT’s attorney on August 29, along with copies of the proposed IEP, an assessment plan, and signature pages for consent. The letter states that “if you would like us to schedule a meeting to review this IEP and assessment plan with you, we would be glad to do so. Please give me some dates that you would be sure you would be able to attend.” In spite of being given an opportunity to immediately select a date for a new IEP meeting, even potentially before the start of school in the first week of September, STUDENT’s parents waited two full months before formally requesting an IEP meeting. STUDENT’s attorney, Mr. Varma, eventually made the request by letter dated October 27, 2003. Finally, unlike the Shapiro case, the evidence indicated no action by STUDENT’s parents in reliance on the August 28, 2003 offer that would be pertinent to a remedy sought in this case. Thus, the District’s action did not result in loss of educational opportunity or seriously infringe on the rights of the parent to participate in the IEP process.

42. The requirements for goals and objectives in an IEP are set forth by statute. See Cal. Educ. Code section 56345(a)(2).

43. Although the District’s actions in assessing STUDENT’s auditory-processing skills predate the April 2002 settlement agreement, the settlement agreement did not eliminate the District’s obligation to have appropriately assessed STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year. Accordingly, this particular request for Although the District’s actions in assessing STUDENT’s auditory-processing skills predate the April 2002 settlement agreement, the settlement agreement did not eliminate the District’s obligation to have appropriately assessed STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year. Accordingly, this particular request for reimbursement and certain similar requests are not rendered moot by the settlement agreement.

44. The District submitted a proposed assessment plan for MOTHER’s consideration on July 8, 2003.

45. No program was formulated at the June 3, 2003 IEP meeting.

46. As in the analysis of the chemistry-tutoring reimbursement issue, the Hearing Officer has considered MOTHER’s conduct of revoking consent for OT services. However, in this compensatory education matter, the Hearing Officer will not penalize STUDENT for MOTHER’s having revoked consent to OT.