California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 1, 2005
Student v. Davis Joint Unified School District et al.
SEHO Case No. SN 2530-04 · Hearing Officer Maxine R. Benmour
Davis Joint Unified must provide 18 hours of makeup speech and OT; Hearing Officer upholds the preschool autism program and denies home-program reimbursement.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted.
Summary
The parents of a four-year-old boy eligible for special education because of autistic-like behaviors filed against Davis Joint Unified School District and the Yolo County Office of Education (YCOE). From 2003 to 2004, the boy attended a preschool special day class and YCOE's autism clinic, which provided one-on-one applied behavior analysis (ABA). He also received speech and occupational therapy (OT). The parents removed him from the special day class in April 2004 and from all school services in June 2004. They then paid for part of a 40-hour-per-week in-home program from Therapeutic Pathways and sought reimbursement.
Hearing Officer Maxine R. Benmour found that the two-week 2003 ESY clinic program and the 2003-2004 program offered a FAPE. She rejected claims about a continuum of options, parent input, goals, the ABA methods, data collection, staff training, collaboration, and parent training. The September 2003 speech goals lacked short-term objectives, but the boy made satisfactory progress, so this did not deny FAPE. However, the District denied FAPE when it stopped speech and OT from April 13 to June 20, 2004. The parents had withdrawn him only from the class, not from those services. Because he lost skills, the Hearing Officer ordered 540 minutes each of speech and OT, to be completed within six months. The June 2004 offer of a special day class, clinic, and related services was a FAPE, so reimbursement for the home program was denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO treated a partial withdrawal from services. Taking a child out of a class did not end the district's duty to provide other IEP services until the parents clearly withdrew consent to them. It also shows SEHO weighing school staff who worked with the child daily over a private home-program supervisor.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Did the District and YCOE offer and provide Student a FAPE for the 2003 extended school year (ESY)?
The July 2003 goals addressed every area of need, and the two-week autism clinic program offered a reasonable 'jump start' for a child new to schooling; FAPE offered.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 2a. Procedural: whether the District and YCOE failed to offer a continuum of services, including an in-home program, for 2003-2004
The team discussed the parents' proposed 30-40 hour home program and other options before the parents agreed to the offer; no violation.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 2b. Procedural: whether the District and YCOE failed to consider parents' input at the April 19 and 26, 2004 IEP meetings
Both parents and their home-program providers attended, submitted written concerns, and received responses; no violation.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 2c. Whether the September 2003 speech and language goals lacked present levels of performance
The September 26, 2003 IEP included present levels describing strengths and weaknesses.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP content
Issue 2d. Whether the September 2003 speech and language goals lacked short-term objectives or benchmarks
The District conceded the goals lacked short-term objectives and the IEP was deficient, but Student made satisfactory progress, so there was no harm and no FAPE denial.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 2e. Whether the District and YCOE failed to revise the July 2003 goals once some were met, and to revise speech and language goals for lack of progress
Ed. Code 56343(b) requires review when progress is lacking, not when goals are met early; Student progressed on speech goals, so no revision was required.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2f. Whether YCOE failed to provide an appropriate ABA program (teaching methodology, repetition, data collection, staff qualifications)
The difference in methods from the home program was not shown to confuse Student, repetition matched his learning rate, data errors did not make the program inappropriate, and staff were qualified.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2g. Whether the District and YCOE failed to collaborate with the home program and hold weekly staff meetings
Collaboration and staff meetings in fact occurred throughout the year, and no evidence showed Student needed more.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 2h. Whether the IEPs improperly lacked a parent training component
The District and YCOE offered several parent trainings, and the parents attended two; no showing that more were needed.
- Student prevailedImplementation
Issue 2i. Whether the program comported with the September 26 and December 17, 2003 IEPs given that speech and language and OT services stopped April 13 to June 20, 2004
The parents withdrew Student only from the special day class in April and did not withdraw speech and OT until June 20, 2004, so stopping those services denied FAPE.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 3. Did the District and YCOE offer Student a FAPE in June 2004 for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year?
The combined special day class, autism clinic, speech, OT and consultation offer met Student's needs and was reasonably calculated to provide benefit; school staff testimony outweighed the home-program supervisor's view that a 40-hour home program was needed.
- Student prevailedImplementation
Issue 4. Is Student entitled to compensatory education for the District's failure to provide speech and language and OT services from April 13, 2004, to June 20, 2004?
Hour-for-hour compensation was appropriate because Student lost speech and fine motor skills; 540 minutes each of speech and OT ordered.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 5. Are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for Therapeutic Pathways services from July 2004 through the present?
Because the June 2004 offer was a FAPE, no reimbursement for the in-home program is owed.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Compensatory education. 540 minutes of speech and language services and 540 minutes of occupational therapy services (nine weeks at 60 minutes per week each), to be completed within six months of the decision.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. District to convene an IEP meeting within ten calendar days to set the duration and frequency of the compensatory speech and OT services.
- Order that district's offer may be implemented. Within five calendar days, District and YCOE to place Student in the preschool special day class and YCOE autism clinic and begin the June 2 and 15, 2004 IEP program, if the parents make him available within five calendar days.
Total: 18 hours of compensatory services
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Adams v. State of Oregon; Ojai Unified School District v. Jackson; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education; Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District
People named in the decision
- Jim Coulter, assistant superintendent, Yolo County Office of Education
- Marsha Ludwig, director of student services, Davis Joint Unified School District
- Jill Young, Ph.D., site director, private nonpublic agency (witness for Student), Therapeutic Pathways
- Coleen Sparkman, director, private nonpublic agency (witness for Student), Therapeutic Pathways
- Brigitte Elder, Ph.D., clinical supervisor of in-home program (witness for Student), Therapeutic Pathways
- Ruth Yamashita, speech-language pathologist, Davis Joint Unified School District
- Kelli Howie Parnall, occupational therapist, Davis Joint Unified School District
- Deedra Seibert, special day class preschool teacher, Davis Joint Unified School District (Pioneer Elementary School)
- Ann Christison, behavior specialist, autism clinic, Yolo County Office of Education
- Laurel Clumpner, adult school principal; coordinator of special education in 2003-2004, Davis Joint Unified School District
- Matthew Chesnut, program director of Parent Infant Program; behavior analyst for the autism clinic, Yolo County Office of Education
- Carolyn Ecker, occupational therapist (August 2003 OT assessment), Davis Joint Unified School District
- Jennifer Galas, school psychologist, Davis Joint Unified School District
- Martha Coppinger, director of special education, Davis Joint Unified School District
- Therapeutic Pathways, nonpublic agency providing in-home discrete trial training
- Alta California Regional Center, regional center funding the in-home program
- Applied Behavior Consultants, private ABA agency (behavior specialist's former employer)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Maxine R. Benmour, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Davis, California, on November 18-19, November 30, December 1-3, and December 8, 2004.
Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Roberta S. Savage. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was his mother, MOTHER. STUDENT’s father, FATHER, also attended a portion of the hearing. Respondent Davis Joint Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Jan E. Tomsky of the law firm Lozano Smith. Also present on the District’s behalf was Marsha Ludwig, director of student services. Respondent Yolo County Office of Education (YCOE) was represented at the hearing by attorney Edmundo R. Aguilar of the law firm Atkinson, Andelson, Loya, Ruud & Romo. Also present on YCOE’s behalf was Jim Coulter, assistant superintendent.
STUDENT called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Jim Coulter, YCOE assistant superintendent; Marsha Ludwig, District director of student services; MOTHER, his mother; Jill Young, Ph.D., site director of Therapeutic Pathways; Coleen Sparkman, director of Therapeutic Pathways; and Brigitte Elder, Ph.D., clinical supervisor of Therapeutic Pathways.
The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Ruth Yamashita, District speech and language pathologist; Kelli Howie Parnall, District occupational therapist; Deedra Seibert, District special day class preschool teacher; Ann Christison, YCOE behavior specialist; Laurel Clumpner, District adult school principal; and Matthew Chesnut, program director of Parent Infant Program.
YCOE did not call any witnesses to testify.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the parties to submit written closing arguments. Upon receipt of the briefs from STUDENT and the District, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision. (Footnote 1)
ISSUES (Footnote 2)
1. Did the District and YCOE offer and provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003 extended school year (ESY)?
2. Did the District and YCOE offer and provide STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year?
3. Did the District and YCOE offer STUDENT a FAPE in June 2004 for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year?
4. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the District’s failure to provide him with speech and language and occupational therapy services from April 13, 2004, to June 20, 2004? (Footnote 3)
5. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement from the District and YCOE for costs incurred in providing services to STUDENT from Therapeutic Pathways from July 2004 through the present?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a four-year-old boy who resides with his parents, his identical twin, and his older sibling within the jurisdictional boundaries of the District. He has been eligible for special education and related services since the age of three on the basis of autistic-like behaviors, including speech and language and socialization deficits. STUDENT currently receives an in-home, forty-hour-per-week discrete trial training (DTT) program from Therapeutic Pathways, a state-certified nonpublic agency (NPA), with twenty hours per week funded by Alta California Regional Center (ACRC) and the remaining twenty hours funded by his parents. He currently receives no services from the District or YCOE. When STUDENT was approximately two years of age, his parents became concerned because he exhibited severe speech and language delays, fixated on certain objects, did not interact with other people, and seemed to be in “his own world.” As a result, in February 2003, shortly before STUDENT’s third birthday, his pediatrician referred him to a behavioral pediatrician who diagnosed him with autism.
Thereafter, in May 2003, when STUDENT turned three years of age, his parents contacted YCOE to inquire about preschool special education services for him. Consequently, in June 2003, District and YCOE personnel completed a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT, assessing him in the areas of cognitive development, communication, and behavior. These assessors concluded that STUDENT met the requirements of eligibility for special education and related services on the basis of autistic-like behaviors because of his deficits in all of the areas assessed. They also recommended placement in a preschool SDC classroom, one-on-one applied behavior analysis (ABA) instruction in the YCOE autism clinic, and speech and language therapy. They further recommended an additional assessment by an occupational therapist.
On July 9 and July 15, 2003, the District convened an initial individualized education program (IEP) meeting to discuss the assessment results and placement and services for STUDENT for the 2003 ESY and the upcoming 2003-2004 school year. The team agreed that STUDENT was eligible for special education and related services due to his autistic-like behaviors and agreed to place him in the YCOE autism clinic beginning on July 21, 2003, for the two weeks remaining in the 2003 ESY. In addition, the team agreed to place STUDENT in an SDC preschool classroom for six hours per week and in the YCOE autism clinic for twelve hours per week for the 2003-2004 school year beginning in August 2003. The team also agreed to goals and objectives for STUDENT in the areas of receptive language, functional communication, socialization, imitation, visual performance, play skills, fine motor, self-help, and tantrum behavior. The team agreed to further assess STUDENT in the areas of speech and language, occupational therapy (OT), and preacademic skills following the meeting. Although the parents indicated to the District and YCOE that they preferred an intensive home program for STUDENT, they consented to the District’s and YCOE’s proposed program for the 2003 ESY and the following school year. They also advised the District and YCOE that they had contacted Alta California Regional Center (ACRC), which had agreed to assess STUDENT in August. After the meetings, STUDENT attended the YCOE autism clinic for the remaining two weeks of the 2003 ESY.
On August 12, 2003, District occupational therapist Carolyn Ecker conducted an OT assessment of STUDENT. Ms. Ecker concluded that STUDENT’s OT areas of concern included sensory processing, motor planning, attention to task, and fine/gross motor coordination. She recommended that STUDENT receive sixty minutes per week of OT services at school. On August 26, 2003, ACRC evaluated STUDENT, found him eligible for services, and agreed to fund a ten-hour-per- week in-home DTT program. In August 2003, pursuant to the IEP of July 2003, STUDENT began to attend Deedra Seibert’s preschool SDC class for six hours per week and the YCOE autism clinic for twelve hours per week, both located at the District’s Pioneer Elementary School.
On September 24, 2003, District speech and language pathologist Ruth Yamashita administered the preschool language scales assessment to STUDENT and found him to have severe deficits in the areas of auditory comprehension, expressive communication, and total language. She described STUDENT as an excellent candidate for speech and language services.
On September 26, 2003, the District convened an IEP meeting to discuss Ms. Yamashita’s speech and language assessment. (Footnote 4) At this meeting, the team, including STUDENT’s mother, agreed to add to STUDENT’s IEP two thirty-minute speech and language sessions per week, one sixty-minute speech and language consultation per month, and eight hours of clinic behavior consultation per month. The team also added nine speech and language goals to STUDENT’s IEP. Following this meeting, STUDENT began speech and language therapy with Ms. Yamashita.
On October 20, 2003, STUDENT began a ten-hour-per-week, home-based, one-on-one DTT program with Therapeutic Pathways that was funded by ACRC. In addition, in late October 2003, although not required by his IEP, District occupational therapist Kelli Howie Parnall began to work with STUDENT for sixty minutes per week. STUDENT’s parents did not dispute STUDENT’s receipt of OT services when they later became aware that the District had been providing this service.
On December 17, 2003, the District again convened an IEP meeting to discuss Ms. Ecker’s August 2003 OT assessment of STUDENT and the OT services being provided by Ms. Parnall. At that meeting, the IEP team, including STUDENT’s parents, agreed to add to STUDENT’s IEP sixty minutes per week of OT and sixty minutes per month of OT consultation. The team also agreed to add two OT goals and objectives to STUDENT’s IEP.
In January 2004, ACRC increased STUDENT’s home-based DTT program from ten hours to fifteen hours per week. Thereafter, in March 2004, ACRC added an additional five hours to STUDENT’s home-based program, at his parents’ request, for a total of twenty hours per week. STUDENT continued in the District, YCOE, and home-based programs until April 2004.
In March 2004, MOTHER advised STUDENT’s preschool teacher, Ms. Seibert, that she and her husband were removing STUDENT from her classroom because they believed that he was not progressing in the SDC classroom and that STUDENT’s home program with Therapeutic Pathways was a better use of his time. On April 12, 2004, MOTHER sent the District a letter formally notifying it that the parents were withdrawing STUDENT from the District’s SDC classroom effective April 13, 2004. Thereafter, STUDENT did not attend the District’s preschool classroom, and the District no longer provided him with speech and language or OT services. However, STUDENT continued to attend the YCOE autism clinic for twelve hours per week.
On April 19 and April 26, 2004, as a result of the parents’ letter, the District convened an IEP meeting to discuss the PARENTS’ decision to remove him from school and to review STUDENT’s goals and objectives. At these meetings, the parents discussed their dissatisfaction with the District’s and YCOE’s program. Their concerns centered on their belief that there was a lack of communication between them and the District and YCOE and their discontent regarding STUDENT’s progress on his goals and objectives and speech and language therapy.
On May 14, 2004, the District again convened an IEP meeting to discuss assessments of STUDENT in preparation for his annual IEP in June 2004. At this meeting, STUDENT’s parents consented to assessments in the areas of preacademic, social/emotional, adaptive behavior, speech and language, intellectual ability, and behaviors. In addition, the District proposed additional goals and objectives in the areas of sensory processing and receptive language. Although the parents agreed to the assessment plan, they did not consent to the IEP.
On May 26, 2004, Ms. Parnall conducted an OT assessment of STUDENT pursuant to the parents’ signed assessment plan. Ms. Parnall concluded that STUDENT continued to exhibit deficits in the areas of sensory processing, self-help, and visual/fine/gross motor skills and recommended continued direct OT services and OT consultation. In addition, on June 2, 2004, District school psychologist Jennifer Galas conducted a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT in the areas of gross and fine motor skills, social-emotional status, preacademic skills, communication skills, and adaptive behavior skills. Ms. Galas found that STUDENT continued to exhibit weaknesses in all of the areas assessed.
On June 2 and June 15, 2004, the District convened an annual IEP meeting to discuss the recent assessments and placement and services for STUDENT for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year. At this meeting, the District and YCOE proposed a preschool SDC classroom, speech and language services, YCOE autism clinic services, behavioral consultation services, OT services, OT consultation, and monthly consultation between the parents and District and YCOE staff for both the ESY and the following school year. STUDENT’s parents did not consent to this IEP.
On June 20, 2004, STUDENT’s parents sent a letter to the District advising it that they had made “a unilateral decision to remove STUDENT from the YCOE Autism Clinic and opt to not continue with the SDC Preschool, Speech, and Occupational Therapy services.” The letter also stated that STUDENT would not be attending the 2004 ESY. In their letter, the parents further stated that they intended to provide STUDENT with a home-based program from Therapeutic Pathways and to seek reimbursement from the District for the costs of this program.
On October 13, 2004, FATHER and MOTHER filed a request for due process hearing with the Hearing Office. They seek a determination that the District and YCOE failed to provide or offer STUDENT a FAPE from the 2003 ESY through the present, compensatory education for the District’s failure to provide STUDENT with speech and language and OT services from April to June 2004, and reimbursement from the District for costs incurred in providing STUDENT with a home-based program with Therapeutic Pathways since July 2004.
CONTENTIONS
STUDENT contends that the District’s and YCOE’s proposed placement and services for the 2003 ESY denied him a FAPE because they developed inappropriate goals and objectives and offered him only a two-week program rather than the longer program that he required to address his needs. STUDENT also contends that the District and YCOE did not offer or provide him with a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year because of two procedural violations: (1) they failed to offer him a continuum of services and (2) they failed to consider his parents’ input at IEP meetings. In addition, he raises five concerns with regard to the substantive nature of the offer. He contends that the District and YCOE: (1) failed to revise his July 2003 goals and objectives, (2) failed to develop appropriate speech and language goals and objectives, (3) failed to provide him with an appropriate ABA program, (4) failed to collaborate with his home program and to conduct weekly staff meetings; and (5) failed to include a parent training component in his IEPs.
STUDENT further contends that the District and YCOE failed to offer him a FAPE for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year because they offered the same inappropriate placement and program from the prior school year. He further contends that since July 2004, he has required a forty-hour-per-week, in-home, one-on-one ABA program. Finally, STUDENT contends that he is entitled to compensatory education and that his parents are entitled to reimbursement for costs incurred in providing him with services.
The District and YCOE contend that they offered and provided STUDENT with a FAPE for all time periods in question, they committed no procedural violations, and STUDENT and his parents are not entitled to compensatory education or reimbursement.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Did the District and YCOE offer and provide STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003 ESY?
Under both the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a student free of charge, that meet the standards of the State educational agency, and that are provided in conformity with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25). The term “related services” includes transportation and other services that may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(17); Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 5, § 3001(2).
A claim that there has been a denial of a FAPE can present both procedural and substantive questions. Among the IDEA’s procedural mandates is the requirement that the process for the development of the IEP allow the parents to meaningfully participate in it. Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 206-207 (1982). Not every procedural flaw is critical, but one that results in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringes on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process may constitute a denial of FAPE. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483-1484 (9th Cir. 1992).
Substantively, the determination of a FAPE is based on the appropriateness of the educational program offered or provided by the local education agency (LEA) to the disabled student. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court stated that the LEA is not required to provide a student with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. Rather, the Court held that an LEA is required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to meet the student’s needs, reasonably calculated to provide him or her with some educational benefit, and that comport with the student’s IEP. Id. at 201. While this requires an LEA to provide a disabled child with meaningful access to education, it does not require the LEA to guarantee successful results. Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist., 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2nd Cir. 1997).
Federal and State law also require that LEAs educate disabled children in the least restrictive environment (LRE), with removal from the regular educational environment occurring only when the nature and severity of the children’s disabilities is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56301.
When taken together, the IDEA and the Supreme Court’s Rowley decision thus require that an appropriate placement: (1) be designed to meet the unique needs of the student, (2) be reasonably calculated to provide the student with educational benefit, and (3) conform to the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 188.
STUDENT contends that the District’s offer of two weeks of one-on-one ABA services in the YCOE autism clinic in July 2003 did not offer or provide him with a FAPE for the 2003 ESY because he required a longer time period of services. He further contends that the goals and objectives developed in July 2003 were inappropriate to address his needs.
What Were STUDENT’s Unique Needs in July 2003?
To determine whether the placement the District and YCOE offered STUDENT in July 2003 provided him with a FAPE, it is first necessary to identify his unique needs at that time.
The parties generally do not dispute the nature of STUDENT’s unique needs in July 2003. As indicated in the District’s and YCOE’s psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT in June 2003, STUDENT exhibited deficits in the areas of expressive and receptive language, adult/peer interaction skills, and the development of cognitive/preacademic abilities. MOTHER testified that her primary concerns in July 2003 were STUDENT’s lack of speech and language and his lack of social interaction with others.
In the area of receptive language skills, the District and YCOE assessors found that STUDENT did not consistently attend to the speech of others, did not respond to his name, did not understand the relationships between objects or abstract concepts, did not respond to the speech of others, did not answer questions, did not follow lengthy directions, and did not understand novel and complex sentences. In addition, the assessors noted that STUDENT did not respond to simple commands, such as “sit down,” “come here,” or “stand up.”
In the area of functional communication skills, the assessment report found that STUDENT did not seek attention when he requested items, did not comment on objects, did not greet others, did not answer or acknowledge the speech of others, did not engage in conversation with others, and rarely interacted with others. According to the assessment report, STUDENT had some limited expressive language, but he lacked action labels, expressions of cessation, expressions of rejection, expressions of possession, and location words.
In the area of socialization skills, the assessment report states that MOTHER reported that STUDENT did not interact with his brother in a reciprocal fashion and was reluctant to maintain eye contact with his parents. In the area of imitation skills, the assessors found STUDENT to have little success. In the area of visual performance skills, the assessors found STUDENT to have deficits in color matching, an inability to identify shapes and objects, and an unwillingness to comply with instructions. In the area of play skills, the report notes that STUDENT preferred to play alone, paid little attention to toys, and did not respond to a “peek-a-boo” game.
In the area of tantrum behavior, the report found that tantrum behavior was observed to occur an average of 1.33 times in a two-hour period. STUDENT’s tantrums included crying or screaming, stiffening his body, pushing others, and stomping, and they occurred during demand situations, transitions, and when a preferred item was removed.
In addition to the assessment report, the IEP document indicates that in July 2003 MOTHER reported that STUDENT did not initiate requests in the self-help area of using the bathroom and did not independently wash his hands.
The parties agreed that STUDENT required one-on-one ABA and small-group instruction with similar peers for the 2003 ESY and the 2003-2004 school year as the proper way to address his above-identified deficits. In the area of language and communication, he required specialized one-on-one ABA and small-group instruction to address his expressive, receptive, and communication deficits. One-on-one ABA and small group instruction in language and communication would also address his behavioral deficits of having tantrums by teaching him to communicate his wants and needs. In the area of socialization and play skills, he required specialized small-group instruction to address his difficulties with peer and adult interaction. In the areas of imitation, visual performance, and preacademic skills, he required specialized one-on-one ABA instruction to learn these individual skills, such as matching colors and shapes, and small-group instruction to learn to generalize these skills to a larger environment. In the area self-help skills, he required both one-on-one ABA and small-group instruction to learn the skills required to use the bathroom appropriately.
Therefore, on the basis of the undisputed evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that in July 2003, STUDENT had deficits in the areas of in language and communication, socialization, imitation, visual performance, play, tantrum behavior, and self-help skills. The Hearing Officer further concludes that STUDENT’s unique needs in these areas required one-on-one ABA and small-group instruction with similar peers to address his deficits. .
Was the Proposed Placement in the YCOE Autism Clinic During the 2003 ESY Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?
Although the parties agreed that STUDENT had deficits that required specialized one-on-one ABA instruction and small-group instruction for the 2003 ESY and the 2003-2004 school year, they agreed to provide him with only one-on-one ABA instruction for the remainder of the 2003 ESY. As indicated above, at the time of STUDENT’s IEP meeting in July 2003, only two weeks of the ESY program remained. The District and YCOE offered STUDENT one-on-one ABA instruction for the 2003 ESY for the final two weeks of the summer program. STUDENT disputes the length of the program offered and provided during the 2003 ESY and contends that the District and YCOE should have provided him with a longer program.
It must next be determined if this proposed placement for the remaining two weeks of the 2003 ESY was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas identified above. Although STUDENT’s parents agreed to the placement at the time and do not dispute the level of services offered, they have two areas of dispute with the program for the 2003 ESY: (1) the goals and objectives developed by the IEP team were not appropriate to address his identified areas of need, and (2) the program inappropriately ended after only two weeks.
1. Goals and Objectives
An IEP must include measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, to meet a student’s needs that result from the student’s disability to enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum and to meet the student’s other educational needs that result from the student’s disability. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(2).
A review of the evidence reveals that in July 2003, STUDENT’s IEP team developed fourteen goals and objectives for him in the areas of receptive language, functional communication, socialization skills, imitation skills, visual performance, play skills, fine motor skills, self-help skills, and a decrease of tantrums. YCOE behavior specialist Ms. Christison testified that she drafted these goals and objectives for STUDENT on the basis of the District’s and YCOE’s assessment in June 2003 in which she had assessed STUDENT in the areas of communication, social interaction, and preacademic skills. She further testified that she believed the goals and objectives to be appropriate to address his deficits in the areas of expressive and receptive language, adult/peer social interaction skills, and the development of cognitive/preacademic abilities.
As discussed above, the District and YCOE assessment in June 2003 found that in the area of receptive language skills, STUDENT had difficulties with attending and responding to others, understanding speech-related relationships, and following directions. In the area of functional communication skills, STUDENT did not respond or interact with other people and had limited expressive language. In the area of socialization skills, STUDENT did not interact with others or maintain eye contact. STUDENT also had limited abilities in the area of imitation and play skills. In the area of visual performance skills, STUDENT to have deficits with colors, shapes, and objects. Finally, in the area of self-help skills, STUDENT had difficulty with use of the bathroom.
In addition to these areas of needs, Ms. Christison testified that she drafted goals and objectives in the area of fine motor skills, even though STUDENT had not yet been assessed by an occupational therapist. She believed that these would be beneficial for him since he exhibited no awareness of his hands during her assessment.
As indicated by STUDENT’s undisputed assessment, he had deficits in the areas of communication, socialization, imitation, play skills, visual performance, and self-help in July 2003. Moreover, according to the persuasive testimony of Ms. Christison, which is supported by the documentary evidence, the District and YCOE developed goals and objectives for STUDENT in the areas of receptive language, functional communication, socialization skills, imitation skills, visual performance, play skills, fine motor skills, self-help skills, and a decrease of tantrums to address each of his identified areas of deficit. Petitioner did not dispute that the District developed goals and objectives in these areas and did not explain his specific concern. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District and YCOE developed appropriate goals and objectives for STUDENT that addressed all of his areas of need as identified in the assessment conducted in June 2003.
2. Length of Program
STUDENT contends that the YCOE clinic program of two weeks at the end of the 2003 ESY was insufficient for STUDENT as he required a longer period of time in the clinic before beginning school in the fall of 2003. Marsha Ludwig, District director of student services, testified that she attended the IEP meetings for STUDENT in July 2003. She also testified that the District and YCOE team members believed that it would be appropriate for STUDENT to have an early “jump start” for the remaining two weeks of the 2003 ESY to begin to learn task-compliance skills prior to the regular school program that would begin in the fall. She testified that the District and YCOE believed it appropriate for STUDENT to begin the program “in increments” because he had not yet been in any program and thus the District and YCOE needed to see how much of a program he could tolerate. Additionally, YCOE behavior specialist Ann Christison testified that a break prior to the new school year would not be harmful to STUDENT as he had just begun to tolerate the program.
Dr. Brigitte Elder, clinical supervisor at Therapeutic Pathways, testified that STUDENT became a client of her agency in October 2003 and that she has worked with him since that time. In contrast to the District and YCOE witnesses, she testified that she does not believe it to be appropriate to work with STUDENT for two weeks followed by a three-week break because that level of inconsistency would be detrimental to his progress. She further testified that she does not recommend more than a one-week break for children in her program.
The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT does not dispute the number of hours or the type of service provided by the YCOE clinic during the 2003 ESY but disagrees solely with the length of the program. The Hearing Officer gives more weight in this regard to the testimony of Ms. Ludwig, who is familiar with the special education program in the District, and Ms. Christison, who worked directly with STUDENT during the 2003 ESY, than to that of Dr. Elder, who did not begin to work with STUDENT until three months after the end of ESY. Although Dr. Elder testified regarding her general knowledge of children with autism, Ms. Christison testified regarding her direct knowledge of STUDENT during the time period in question. Both Ms. Ludwig and Ms. Christison testified that the YCOE two-week program, the time remaining in ESY at the time of the IEP meeting, was designed to give STUDENT a “jump start” because he had not yet learned to tolerate any type of program. In fact, according to their credible testimony, this “jump start” was designed to and did benefit STUDENT by gradually teaching him to tolerate an educational program. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District and YCOE offer for the 2003 ESY was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs in the area of one-on-one ABA instruction.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that in July 2003 the District and YCOE developed goals and objectives that were appropriate for STUDENT and designed to address his unique needs and offered and provided STUDENT with an appropriate two-week program in the YCOE autism clinic. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District and YCOE did not deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003 ESY.
Was the Placement in the YCOE Autism Clinic Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit to STUDENT?
The Hearing Officer must next determine if the District’s and YCOE’s offer and placement of STUDENT in the YCOE autism clinic for the 2003 ESY was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. (Footnote 5) As discussed above, the Hearing Officer found that goals and objectives developed by the IEP team in July 2003 were designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs as determined by the District’s and YCOE’s assessment in July 2003. In addition, the Hearing Officer found above that the District’s and YCOE’s two-week program during the 2003 ESY was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The Hearing Officer also finds that the offer was calculated to provide benefit to STUDENT. Ms. Christison testified that the District and YCOE believed that the clinic would allow him to learn to tolerate an educational program and that he in fact did so. Moreover, STUDENT presented no evidence that the two-week program did not provide him with educational benefit.
Therefore, on the basis of the above evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s and YCOE’s placement of STUDENT in the YCOE autism clinic for the 2003 ESY was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to STUDENT.
Did the Placement in the YCOE Autism Clinic Conform to STUDENT’s IEP?
There is no dispute that the District and YCOE provided the placement and implementation of goals and objectives specified in the IEP of July 9 and 15, 2003.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s and YCOE’s offer and placement of the YCOE autism clinic for the 2003 ESY was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit, and conformed to STUDENT’s IEP. In addition, there is no issue regarding least restrictive environment in this matter. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District and YCOE offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003 ESY.
ISSUE NO. 2: Did the District and YCOE offer and provide STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year?
As discussed above, children with disabilities are entitled to a FAPE that provides them with a basic floor of opportunity. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000; Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 207-208. As further discussed in Rowley, children are entitled to both procedural and substantive protections in special education law. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-207. However, only those procedural flaws that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range, supra, 960 F.2d at 1483.
Accordingly, the analysis of whether a child has been provided a FAPE is generally twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to consider both whether procedural steps were followed and whether the proposed placement was substantively appropriate. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-207.
Procedural Violations
STUDENT contends that the District and YCOE committed two procedural violations during the 2003-2004 school year. He contends that: 1) they failed to offer him a continuum of services, and 2) they failed to consider his parents’ input at IEP meetings in April 2004.
1. Continuum of Services
California and federal law require that LEAs have available “a full continuum of program options” to meet the unique needs of the child, including instruction conducted in the classroom, in the home, in hospitals and institutions, and in other settings. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. STUDENT contends that the District and YCOE failed to consider an in-home program for him as part of a continuum of options.
With regard to placement options, the July 2003 IEP document indicates that the parties, including the parents, considered resource support in a general education classroom as well as a nonpublic school before deciding that STUDENT needed “small group and individual instruction” in an SDC classroom and the YCOE autism clinic to best serve his needs.
MOTHER testified that she informed the IEP team at the meetings in July 2003 of research that showed that an intense program was the most appropriate program for young children with autism. When she mentioned the possibility of a thirty- to forty-hour-per-week home program, YCOE assistant superintendent Jim Coulter told her that such a program was unnecessary for STUDENT. He described YCOE’s collaboration with ACRC in which ACRC provides a home-based ABA program, while the District and YCOE provide an educationally based ABA and classroom program. Mr. Coulter advised MOTHER that under the District’s and YCOE’s proposed program, STUDENT would receive a thirty-three-hour-per-week program, including the fifteen hours that would likely be funded by ACRC. MOTHER testified that the parents consented to the District’s and YCOE’s offer on the “reassurance” from Mr. Coulter that the District and YCOE program was modeled after intense home programs.
On the basis of the foregoing evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District and YCOE did not fail to consider a continuum of options for STUDENT, including an in-home program. In fact, it is undisputed that the parents raised the issue of a forty-hour-per-week in-home program at the meetings, the parties discussed this option, YCOE explained its opposition to such a program, and the parents ultimately agreed to the proposed District and YCOE program. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District and YCOE did not commit any procedural violations on this basis.
2. Parental Input at IEP Meetings
Cal. Educ. Code section 56342.5 provides that districts shall ensure that “the parent of each individual with exceptional needs is a member of any group that makes decisions on the educational placement of the individual with exceptional needs.” STUDENT contends that the District and YCOE failed to consider the input of his parents in developing his program at IEP meetings held on April 19 and 26, 2004, following his parents’ decision to remove him from the preschool program.
A review of the evidence reveals that in March 2004, MOTHER informed Ms. Seibert of the parents’ intention to remove STUDENT from the SDC classroom and that the parents subsequently wrote a letter to the District informing it that the parents were removing STUDENT from the classroom effective April 13, 2004. Thereafter, the District convened an IEP meeting on April 19 and 26, 2004. It is undisputed that both of STUDENT’s parents attended both IEP meetings, that Dr. Elder and Dr. Jill Young from Therapeutic Pathways also attended both meetings on STUDENT’s behalf, and that the parents submitted a written list of concerns to explain their dissatisfaction with the District’s program.
A review of the IEP document from the meeting on April 19, 2004, reveals that one of the purposes of the meeting was to “understand parents’ reasons for making a unilateral change in STUDENT’s IEP placement, and to respond to this decision.” The document further states that the parents expressed their concerns at the meeting regarding the amount of communication between the parents and STUDENT’s service providers. In addition, on April 24, 2004, two days prior to the second meeting, the parents submitted a three-page written document to the District in which they itemized a “list of concerns” regarding STUDENT’s program. The IEP document from the meeting on April 26, 2004, states that District and YCOE staff responded to the parents’ concerns and explained their belief that STUDENT had benefited and would continue to benefit in their program.
The evidence in this matter reveals that the parents were members of the IEP team and active participants in all program and placement discussions regarding STUDENT in April 2004. Contrary to STUDENT’s assertions, the District and YCOE were well aware of his parents’ concerns regarding his placement and program in April 2004, were aware of the parents’ concerns regarding the level of communication among the parties, and discussed the parents’ concerns at the meetings in April. Moreover, he has presented no information that the District or YCOE prevented his parents from presenting their concerns or other information at the meetings.
In sum, the Hearing Officer is persuaded by the above evidence that the District and YCOE did not fail to consider STUDENT’s parents’ input during the IEP meetings in April 2004. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District and YCOE did not commit a procedural violation on this basis.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District and YCOE did not commit procedural violations that denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year.
Substantive FAPE
As discussed above, children with disabilities are also entitled to a substantive FAPE that provides them with a basic floor of opportunity. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000; Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208.
What Were STUDENT’s Unique Needs During the 2003-2004 School Year?
To determine whether the placement the District and YCOE offered STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year provided him with a FAPE, it is first necessary to identify his unique needs at that time. As discussed above, the parties met in July 2003 to discuss STUDENT’s needs and a program and placement for him for both the 2003 ESY and the 2003-2004 school year. The parties agreed that STUDENT required one-on-one ABA and small-group instruction with similar peers for the 2003 ESY and the 2003-2004 school year as the proper way to address his above-identified deficits. In the area of language and communication, he required specialized one-on-one ABA and small-group instruction to address his expressive, receptive, and communication deficits. One-on-one ABA and small group instruction in language and communication would also address his behavioral deficits of having tantrums by teaching him to communicate his wants and needs. In the area of socialization and play skills, he required specialized small-group instruction to address his difficulties with peer and adult interaction. In the areas of imitation, visual performance, and preacademic skills, he required specialized one-on-one ABA instruction to learn these individual skills, such as matching colors and shapes, and small-group instruction to learn to generalize these skills to a larger environment. In the area self-help skills, he required both one-on-one ABA and small-group instruction to learn the skills required to use the bathroom appropriately.
Therefore, on the basis of the undisputed evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that in July 2003, STUDENT had deficits in the areas of in language and communication, socialization, imitation, visual performance, play, tantrum behavior, and self-help skills. The Hearing Officer further concludes that STUDENT’s unique needs in these areas required one-on-one ABA and small-group instruction with similar peers to address his deficits. As there is no evidence that STUDENT’s needs changed from July 2003 to August 2003, when the 2003-2004 school year began, the Hearing Officer concludes that these were STUDENT’s unique needs for the 2003-2004 school year. (Footnote 6)
Was the District’s and YCOE’s Proposed Program for the 2003-2004 School Year Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?
It must next be determined if the District’s and YCOE’s proposed program and placement for STUDENT during the 2003-2004 school year were substantively designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas identified above. The District’s and YCOE’s offer for the 2003-2004 school year included placement in a preschool SDC classroom, one-on-one ABA instruction in the YCOE autism clinic, and related services of speech and language, OT, and consultation. STUDENT contends that the District and YCOE program and placement were not substantively designed to meet his unique needs because they: (1) failed to develop speech and language goals and objectives that included present levels of performance and short-term objectives; (2) failed to revise his goals and objectives during the school year; (3) failed to provide him with an appropriate ABA program; (4) failed to collaborate with his home program and to conduct weekly staff meetings; and (5) failed to include a parent training component in his IEPs.
1. Appropriate Goals and Objectives
An IEP must include present levels of performance that include how a preschool child’s disability affects his or her participation in appropriate activities. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(1)(B). In addition, as discussed above, an IEP must include measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, to meet the needs of students with disabilities. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(2). Moreover, in order to benefit educationally, a student must make satisfactory progress towards his or her IEP goals and objectives. Ojai Unified School District v. Jackson, 4 F.3d 1467, 1475 (9th Cir. 1993).
a. Present Levels of Performance
STUDENT contends that the speech and language goals developed by the District in September 2003 were defective because they did not include present levels of performance.
A review of the evidence reveals that on September 24, 2003, District speech and language pathologist Ruth Yamashita administered the preschool language scales assessment to STUDENT and found him to score in the first percentile in the areas of auditory comprehension, expressive communication, and total language. Ms. Yamashita described STUDENT at that time as being nonverbal, not understanding stimulus response, and having no attention skills. On September 26, 2003, the District convened an IEP meeting to discuss Ms. Yamashita’s assessment and to propose speech and language services and goals for STUDENT. At the meeting in September 2003, the IEP team agreed to nine speech and language goals in the areas identified by Ms. Yamashita as STUDENT’s areas of deficit, including visual tracking, receptive language, matching objects, requesting objects, naming body parts, labeling items, imitating nonverbal/oral-motor movement, imitating vowels and early developing consonants, and being exposed to labels for emotions.
With regard to STUDENT’s contention that his goals did not include present levels of performance, the evidence reveals that Ms. Yamashita’s description of STUDENT’s present levels of performance is contained in the section of the IEP entitled “Present Level of Performance,” and includes his emerging strengths in the areas of imitating sounds, making eye contact with peers and adults, and developing language. Her description of his present levels of performance also includes his weaknesses in the areas of visual tracking, taking in environmental information, attending, matching objects, making and responding to simple requests, naming body parts, responding to simple requests, understanding and expressing simple words, imitating nonverbal movements, imitating sounds, and identifying basic emotions. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that STUDENT’s IEP of September 26, 2003, appropriately contained his present levels of performance.
b. Short-Term Objectives or Benchmarks
The purpose of benchmarks or short-term objectives is to enable a child’s parents and teachers to gauge, at intermediate times during the year, how well the child is progressing toward the achievement of the annual goal. 34 C.F.R. Part 30, Appendix A. In addition, an IEP team shall meet whenever a child demonstrates a lack of anticipated progress. Cal. Educ. Code § 56343(b). STUDENT contends that the speech and language goals developed in September 2003 were defective because they did not include short-term objectives or benchmarks.
As discussed above, the IEP team agreed to nine speech and language goals in the areas of visual tracking, receptive language, matching objects, requesting objects, naming body parts, labeling items, imitating nonverbal/oral-motor movement, imitating vowels and early developing consonants, and being exposed to labels for emotions. The District concedes that Ms. Yamashita failed to include short-term objectives in the nine long-term goals that she proposed for STUDENT in September 2003. However, the District argues that STUDENT did not suffer any harm as a result because he had made progress on his long-term goals by the time that his parents removed him from school in April 2004. Thus, to the extent that there were no short-term objectives, the IEP was deficient.
Ms. Yamashita testified regarding STUDENT’s progress on his speech and language goals as well as reported his progress at IEP meetings in April and June 2004. She testified that STUDENT met three of his goals by the end of the year, those in visual tracking, requesting objects, and being exposed to labels for emotions. She further testified that he made partial progress on five of his remaining goals: he met 50 percent of his receptive one-step direction goal; he was able to match objects by putting socks in shoes, using a cup and plate at snack table, and putting his plate in the garbage although at a lower level than the proposed 70 percent; he met 50 percent of the goal of labeling items; he met 75 percent of the nonverbal imitation goal; and he met 20 percent of the verbal imitation goal. According to Ms. Yamashita, the only goal in which STUDENT had made very little progress by April 2004 was in the area of naming body parts. However, she reported at the IEP meeting in June that he had begun to learn this goal, as he was able to touch his eyes, ears, and mouth following an instruction to do so. In addition, Ms. Yamashita testified credibly that STUDENT’s progress in classroom behavior was due in part to the increased communication skills that he had learned in speech and language therapy.
Ms. Yamashita testified that STUDENT “definitely” benefited from his work in speech and language therapy. She saw gains of paying attention, tolerating physical prompts, articulating sounds, developing eye contact, and developing a few words by the time that she stopped working with him. She also testified that he tolerated being around other children, played with toys appropriately, followed routines, followed some one-step directions, and transitioned better as a result of her work with him. She also testified that she believed that STUDENT would continue to progress in speech and language therapy.
Several other witnesses corroborated STUDENT’s progress on his speech and language goals during the 2003-2004 school year. In her annual review dated June 1, 2004, Ms. Christison reported that STUDENT had begun to work on vocal imitation in the clinic in consultation with Ms. Yamashita. Ms. Christison stated that she and Ms. Yamashita introduced six sounds to STUDENT, and he quickly acquired the ability to produce four of them. Ms. Seibert also testified that she and Ms. Yamashita consulted on strategies during the 2003-2004 school year. Ms. Seibert testified that she saw progress in STUDENT’s verbal skills throughout the school year and anticipated that he would become more verbal as she and Ms. Yamashita continued to work with him. Dr. Elder also described STUDENT when she first met him as having no receptive or expressive language and testified that by June 2004, he had made some progress in verbal imitation and had learned ten receptive labels, a skill that she described as a challenge for him.
On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that although the District failed to develop short-term objectives for STUDENT, STUDENT did not suffer harm as a result of this failure. As the purpose of short-term objectives, or benchmarks, is to gauge a child’s progress at intervals throughout the year so as to revise his or her IEP if the child is not progressing toward a goal, in this case, there was sufficient evidence that although there were no short-term objectives, STUDENT made satisfactory progress overall. He met three of his long-term goals and made satisfactory progress towards all of his six remaining goals. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to include short-term objectives in his speech and language goals.
2. Revision of Goals and Objectives a. Goals and Objectives From IEP of July 2003
STUDENT contends that the District and YCOE had an obligation to revise his July 2003 goals and objectives during the 2003-2004 school year because he met three of his goals and objectives by November 2003, and met another one by March 2004. As discussed above, the IEP team developed fourteen goals and objectives for STUDENT in July 2003 in the areas of receptive language, functional communication, socialization, imitation, visual performance, play skills, fine motor, self-help, and tantrum behavior. As further discussed above, the Hearing Officer found that the goals and objectives developed in July 2003 were appropriate for STUDENT based upon his deficits as found in assessments conducted at the time. See Adams v. State of Oregon, supra, 195 F.3d at 1149.
Both STUDENT’s mother and Ms. Christison testified that at the time of STUDENT’s quarterly review meeting on November 19, 2003, he had met one goal and objective in the area of imitation and two goals and objectives in the area of visual performance skills. In the area of imitation, he was able to imitate ten different one-step actions in random rotation. In the area of visual performance, he was able to match novel two-dimensional to two-dimensional and three-dimensional to three-dimensional objects and to match eight shapes and colors. They further testified by March 26, 2004, STUDENT had met one additional goal and objective in the area of receptive language. In this area, he was able to identify ten objects, six colors, and six shapes.
However, the Hearing Officer finds unpersuasive STUDENT’s argument that the District and YCOE had an obligation to revise the goals and objectives set forth in the IEP of July 9 and 15, 2003, because he had met four of them by November 2003 and March 2004. As discussed above, these goals and objectives were appropriate for the 2003-2004 school year at the time that they were developed. Adams v. State of Oregon, supra, 195 F.3d at 1149. Moreover, a district has an obligation to revise goals and objectives whenever a child demonstrates a lack of anticipated progress but does not have such an obligation when a child exhibits progress prior to a scheduled review. Cal. Educ. Code § 56343(b). Although MOTHER testified that the parents were aware that STUDENT had met these goals and objectives during the school year, she also stated that they did not raise any concerns that some goals and objectives were no longer appropriate for STUDENT with District or YCOE staff at anytime prior to the IEP meetings held in April 2004 -- after they had removed STUDENT from the SDC classroom. Therefore, on the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District had no obligation to revise STUDENT’s July 2003 goals and objectives during the 2003-2004 school year.
b. Speech and Language Goals
STUDENT also contends the District improperly failed to revise his speech and language goals during the 2003-2004 school year when he failed to make progress on them.
As discussed above, in September 2003, the District proposed nine speech and language goals in the areas of visual tracking, receptive language, matching objects, requesting objects, naming body parts, labeling items, imitating nonverbal/oral-motor movement, imitating vowels and early developing consonants, and being exposed to labels for emotions. As the Hearing Officer found above, STUDENT began the 2003-2004 school year with virtually no expressive or receptive language skills and made satisfactory progress on all of his speech and language goals during the 2003-2004 school year. STUDENT completely met three of his nine goals, made gains from twenty to seventy-five percent on five of the others, and had begun to work on one other one by June 2004.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District and YCOE did not improperly fail to revise STUDENT’s July 2003 goals and objectives or his speech and language goals during the 2003-2004 school year, because, in fact, he made progress on his speech and language goals. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District and YCOE did not deny STUDENT a FAPE on this basis.
3. Appropriateness of ABA Program
STUDENT contends that the YCOE’s ABA program was not appropriate for him because YCOE used a different teaching methodology than that used by his home program, a factor that he contends was confusing for him. STUDENT further contends that the YCOE program did not provide him with the amount of repetition that he required to learn the skills being taught and did not use appropriate data collection techniques to record his progress or lack of progress. STUDENT also contends that YCOE clinic staff was not appropriately qualified, supervised, or trained to instruct him in ABA techniques because they had insufficient knowledge of ABA instruction.
a. Teaching Methodology
With regard to STUDENT’s instructional program, Dr. Elder, the clinical supervisor of Therapeutic Pathways, testified that YCOE uses an instructional technique that allows STUDENT to provide two incorrect responses before being prompted with a correct response, while Therapeutic Pathways uses an “errorless learning” technique that provides more immediate prompting so that STUDENT is less likely to respond incorrectly. She testified that these different approaches could be confusing for STUDENT because he is a “sensitive learner” and needs more time and consistency to learn skills. She also testified that it is difficult for children with autism to generalize across programs, requiring the use of a single program for all instruction.
Mr. Chesnut, the behavior analyst of STUDENT’s YCOE clinic program during the 2003-2004 school year, testified that there are different DTT instructional strategies that different practitioners use with different children, depending upon the child and the practitioner. He testified that sometimes practitioners even mix strategies with the same child. According to Mr. Chesnut, the use of different strategies is not confusing to a child, and, in fact, it may be appropriate to use different strategies if a child has difficulty with a particular lesson.
In addition to disputing Dr. Elder’s characterization of the instructional program provided at YCOE, Ms. Christison also testified that there are different ways to deliver instruction, response, and reinforcers in a DTT program. According to Ms. Christison, because of the critical importance of learning to generalize the skills learned in a DTT program, a child needs to learn in a variety of formats. She further testified that the use of different formats is not confusing for children and was not confusing for STUDENT, as he responded well to the format used in the clinic.
Although STUDENT contends that the difference in instructional methodology between his home and YCOE program was confusing for him, he presented no evidence that it was, in fact, confusing. Both Mr. Chesnut and Ms. Christison, who were directly involved in STUDENT’s clinic program throughout the entire school year, testified credibly that not only was the use of different programs not confusing for STUDENT, it was actually appropriate and effective to use different approaches to teach STUDENT to generalize across a variety of settings. Although Dr. Elder believes that different approaches are not appropriate for children with autism because of their difficulty with generalization, she presented no information that STUDENT was not able to learn to generalize as a result of different approaches at the clinic and at home. On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded that YCOE’s use of a different teaching methodology in the clinic from that used in his home program rendered the program inappropriate for STUDENT.
b. Amount of Repetition
With regard to the amount of repetition in his DTT program, Dr. Elder testified that in STUDENT’s home DTT program, his aides conduct hundreds of trials per hour with him. She further testified that the two to three trials per item recorded in STUDENT’s clinic data binder were not sufficient because he needed more repetition of the same item and frequent review of what he had already learned. Coleen Sparkman, director of Therapeutic Pathways, and Dr. Jill Young, site director of Therapeutic Pathways, also testified that they believe that STUDENT did not have a sufficient amount of trials to learn a skill in the YCOE program.
Mr. Chesnut testified that there is not a standard number of trials for DTT instruction. What is important is to attempt a significant number of trials in a day. In his opinion, the number of trials depends upon what skill is being taught. In some instances, two or three trials of one skill is sufficient if the student is learning quickly. Ms. Christison testified that there was no need for repetition when STUDENT was one hundred percent correct in his responses at the beginning of a lesson. She testified that she instructed STUDENT’s aides to proceed to the next step in many areas because of his high acquisition rate. Therefore, according to Ms. Christison, STUDENT did not require a specific number of trials during a specific period of time.
On the basis of the above evidence, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that the clinic provided STUDENT with an appropriate amount of repetition to learn the skills being taught. As Ms. Christison credibly testified, the clinic staff geared the number of repetitions that STUDENT performed to his skill level and did not needlessly repeat skills that he had already learned.
c. Data Collection
With regard to data collection, Dr. Elder testified that STUDENT’s YCOE program was inappropriate because the aides did not collect data properly. According to her review of his clinic data binder, she could not determine the amount of STUDENT’s progress and also noted that some percentage calculations appeared to be incorrect. Ms. Christison testified that data for STUDENT were not recorded everyday because she sometimes spoke directly with STUDENT’s aide rather than having the aide record the information for a particular skill. She also testified that if his data binder reflected no data in a particular area, that indicated that a lesson was not taught that day. She also testified that she advised the aides that in areas in which STUDENT was very successful, they were permitted to record only estimated percentages rather than trial-by-trial data. Mr. Chesnut testified that he reviewed STUDENT’s data book, and acknowledged that there were some errors in the reporting and calculation of STUDENT’s discrete trials. He stated, however, that there are almost always errors in data collection.
The Hearing Officer is not persuaded that YCOE’s data collection rendered STUDENT’s program inappropriate. STUDENT presented no support for his contention that data collection at the clinic needed to be done exactly as it was done in the home program or that it was the sole determining factor of STUDENT’s progress on his goals and objectives. As the IEP team agreed in July 2003, progress made on his goals and objectives would be measured by observations of teacher and staff as well as review of data and not solely by data collection.
d. Staff Qualifications
STUDENT contends that the YCOE staff was not properly qualified, trained, or supervised in ABA techniques as they did not instruct appropriately in ABA methods. Ms. Christison, the YCOE clinic behavior specialist for the past three years, testified that she was responsible for implementing STUDENT’s ABA program during the 2003-2004 school year. She testified that she received a certificate from California State University, Sacramento in ABA techniques as part of her B.A. degree in psychology. She further testified that she is a board-certified associate behavior analyst, has taken sixteen units in ABA courses, and has been trained as an implementer of PECS. She stated that prior to working for YCOE, she worked as a tutor and lead tutor at Applied Behavior Consultants (ABC), providing in-home programs to children with autism. Since 1999, she has worked with approximately twenty to twenty-five children with autism at both ABC and YCOE, ninety percent of them of preschool age. In her current position with YCOE, she conducts assessments, consults in the early intervention autism program, consults with teachers regarding behavior services, implements behavior support plans in classrooms, and provides training and feedback to YCOE instructional aides.
Ms. Christison testified that she supervises the YCOE clinic instructional aides and that they receive three ongoing trainings per year in PECS, ABA in the classroom, and generalization of skills. She further testified that the two aides assigned to STUDENT during the 2003-2004 school year were very experienced in one-on-one instruction, having worked in ABA programs for children with autism, one for six years and one for three years. With regard to the substitute aide that instructed STUDENT for the last six weeks of the 2003-2004 school year, Ms. Christison testified that substitutes receive one child-specific training outside of the clinic, learn in a hands-on approach, and regularly attend team meetings. Moreover, Ms. Christison testified that she spent more time with the substitute aide than was indicated on STUDENT’s IEP. STUDENT presented no evidence to dispute this testimony.
On the basis of the foregoing evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the YCOE clinic staff was properly qualified, supervised, and trained in ABA techniques during the 2003-2004 school year. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District and YCOE did not deny STUDENT a FAPE on this basis.
In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes in light of the foregoing findings that YCOE did not fail to provide STUDENT with an appropriate ABA program during the 2003-2004 school year. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District and YCOE did not deny STUDENT a FAPE on this basis.
4. Collaboration With the Home Program and Weekly Staff Meetings
STUDENT contends that during the 2003-2004 school year, the District and YCOE staff did not conduct monthly consultations with his home program staff and did not convene weekly staff meetings and that STUDENT required these meetings to adequately address his unique needs.
Although STUDENT contends that the District and YCOE improperly failed to conduct monthly consultations with his home program and failed to convene weekly staff meetings regarding STUDENT, he did not present evidence to support his contention that he required such meetings to progress during the school year. Moreover, it is undisputed that collaboration between the home and school program, as well as staff meetings, actually occurred throughout the school year. According to the evidence, Ms. Christison, STUDENT’s YCOE clinic behavior specialist, and Dr. Elder, STUDENT’s in-home clinic supervisor, met on seven different occasions regarding STUDENT during the 2003-2004 school year -- at an ACRC meeting in October 2003, at a District/YCOE quarterly meeting in November 2003, during Dr. Elder’s observation of STUDENT at the YCOE clinic in November 2003, at an ACRC meeting in January 2004, at an ACRC meeting in April 2004, and at two IEP meetings in April 2004. With regard to staff meetings, Ms. Christison testified that her eight-hour per month consultation for STUDENT included weekly meetings, monthly classroom observations, twice weekly collaborations with his classroom teacher, and discussions with his speech and language and occupational therapists. STUDENT presented no evidence to dispute this testimony.
On the basis of the foregoing evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District and YCOE did not improperly fail to conduct monthly consultations and weekly staff meetings regarding STUDENT during the 2003-2004 school year. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District and YCOE did deny STUDENT a FAPE on this basis.
5. Parent Training Component
STUDENT contends that the District and YCOE improperly failed to offer training to his parent, a service that he contends that he required to progress on his goals and objectives. However, the evidence reveals that the District and YCOE actually offered training to STUDENT’s parents. MOTHER testified that in the fall of 2003, FATHER attended a PECS workshop for parents. She also testified that she attended a training regarding sensory diet by the District’s occupational therapist but was unable to attend two general speech and language trainings that Ms. Yamashita offered to parents.
On the basis of the evidence that the District and YCOE offered the parents several trainings throughout the 2003-2004 school year and the parents attended two of the trainings, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District and YCOE did not deny STUDENT a FAPE on this basis. STUDENT presented no evidence that his parents required additional trainings for him to receive a FAPE.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s and YCOE’s July 2003 goals and objectives, speech and language goals, ABA program, collaboration between home and school program, and parent training were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs for the 2003-2004 school year.
Was the District’s and YCOE’s Proposed Program for the 2003-2004 School Year Reasonably Calculated to Provide STUDENT with Educational Benefit?
The Hearing Officer must next determine if the District’s and YCOE’s offer and placement of STUDENT in a preschool SDC and YCOE autism clinic with speech and language, OT, and consultation services during the 2003-2004 school year was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. As discussed previously, the Hearing Officer concluded that the goals and objectives developed for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year in the areas of receptive language, functional communication, socialization, imitation, visual performance, play skills, fine motor, self-help, tantrum behavior, and speech and language were appropriate for him and designed to address his unique needs. The Hearing Officer also concluded that the District’s and YCOE’s speech and language goals, ABA program, collaboration between home and school program, and parent training were designed to address his unique needs in these areas.
The Hearing Officer finds that these same elements were calculated to provide benefit. Moreover, a review of the evidence reveals that the District’s and YCOE’s proposed program did, in fact, provide him with such benefit. Ms. Seibert, Ms. Yamashita, Ms. Christison, and Ms. Parnall, District and YCOE staff who worked directly with STUDENT during the 2003-2004 school year, all testified credibly that STUDENT benefited educationally and socially and progressed on his goals and objectives by placement in the SDC classroom and the autism clinic with the related services of speech and language and OT. They all testified that by the end of the school year, STUDENT was better able to attend to school and clinic activities, was able to request items that he needed or wanted, was better able to tolerate proximity to peers, and had learned colors, numbers, and shapes. The Hearing Officer finds these witnesses credible because of their knowledge of STUDENT in the school environment. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s and YCOE’s proposed placement in an SDC classroom and the YCOE autism clinic with related services of speech and language, OT, and consultation services was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to STUDENT.
Did the District’s and YCOE’s Proposed Program for the 2003-2004 School Year Comport With STUDENT’s IEP?
STUDENT contends that the District’s program during the 2003-2004 school year failed to comport with his IEPs of September 26, 2003, and December 17, 2003. STUDENT contends that the District failed to provide him with speech and language and OT services from April 13, 2004, to June 20, 2004, pursuant to these IEPs. The District acknowledges that it did not provide STUDENT with speech and language and OT services during this time, but it contends that it had no obligation to do so because his parents withdrew their consent to such services. (Footnote 7)
A review of the IEP dated September 26, 2003, reveals that the team agreed that STUDENT would receive two thirty-minute-per-week speech and language sessions from September 2003 until June 2004. In addition, the IEP dated December 17, 2003, indicates that the parties agreed to add OT services to STUDENT’s IEP in the amount of sixty minutes per week from December 2003 until June 2004.
A further review of the evidence reveals that in the middle of March 2004, MOTHER orally advised Ms. Seibert that STUDENT’s parents had decided to remove him from the preschool SDC classroom because ACRC was paying for a home program and STUDENT was not using all of his hours and because the parents believed that the SDC was not appropriate for him. Thereafter, on April 12, 2004, MOTHER sent a letter to Laurel Clumpner, District coordinator of special education during the 2003-2004 school year, advising her that the parents were providing the District with “written notification that effective April 13, 2004, STUDENT will no longer be attending the SDC Preschool at Pioneer Elementary because this placement is not appropriate for him.”
MOTHER testified that the parents withdrew their consent to the SDC but not to speech and language and OT services in April 2004. A review of the transcript of the meeting held on April 19, 2004, indicates that Marsha Ludwig, District director of student services, asked MOTHER if she wanted STUDENT to continue with speech and language and OT services, and MOTHER responded that she was “not at that place yet.” In addition, Ms. Clumpner testified that she asked the parents at the IEP meeting on April 26, 2004, if they wanted to discontinue speech and language and OT services and that they advised her that they were still not sure.
Thereafter, on June 20, 2004, the parents sent a letter to Martha Coppinger, District director of special education, informing her that “we are making a unilateral decision to remove STUDENT from the YCOE Autism Clinic and opt to not continue with the SDC Preschool, Speech, and Occupational Therapy services.”
The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the evidence that STUDENT’s parents did not decide to withdraw him from speech and language and OT services until June 20, 2004. Although Ms. Clumpner and Ms. Seibert testified that they believed that the parents had withdrawn their consent to these services on April 13, 2004, when they withdrew STUDENT from the SDC, the evidence indicates otherwise. At both meetings in April, the parents indicated that they had not yet decided whether to continue with speech and language and OT services. There is no evidence that they decided to withdraw him from these services until the letter dated June 20, 2004. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District program failed to comport with STUDENT’s IEPs of September 26, 2003, and December 17, 2003, by failing to provide him with speech and language and OT services from April 13, 2004, to June 20, 2004. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year to this extent.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year to the extent that it failed to provide him with speech and language and OT services from April 13, 2004, to June 20, 2004. With respect to STUDENT’s remaining contentions, the Hearing Officer finds that the District and YCOE offered and provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year.
ISSUE NO. 3: Did the District and YCOE offer STUDENT a FAPE in June 2004 for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year?
A review of the evidence reveals that on June 2 and 15, 2004, the District convened an annual IEP meeting to discuss STUDENT’s program and placement for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year. At those meetings, the District and YCOE offered STUDENT placement in a preschool SDC classroom for six and one-half hours per week and the YCOE autism clinic for twelve hours per week with related services of ninety minutes per week of speech and language services, thirty minutes per week of OT services, seven hours per month of behavioral consultation, and forty-five minutes per month of consultation with parents and staff for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year. In addition, the District and YCOE proposed nineteen goals and objectives for STUDENT in the areas of receptive language, articulation, functional communication, expressive language, visual performance, imitation, motor planning and coordination, sensory processing, interactive play, preacademic skills, attention, and self-help. STUDENT’s parents refused to consent to the proposed IEP and contend that the offer was not designed to meet his needs and was not calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. They contend that he requires a forty-hour- per-week, one-on-one, in-home DTT program to meet his needs.
What Were STUDENT’s Unique Needs in June 2004?
As discussed above, to determine whether the placement the District and YCOE proposed for STUDENT in June 2004 offered him a FAPE, it is first necessary to identify his unique needs at that time.
In May 2004, District school psychologist Jennifer Galas conducted a psychological evaluation of STUDENT. On the basis of a parent interview, observations of STUDENT, the Behavior Assessment for Children Structured Developmental History, Behavior Assessment System for Children, and the Developmental Profile II, she concluded that STUDENT had deficits in the areas of motor skills, social skills, preacademic skills, communication skills, and self-help skills. In May 2004, Ms. Parnall also conducted an OT assessment of STUDENT. She described STUDENT as having difficulty with motor planning, initiating purposeful activities, jumping, and fine/gross motor coordination. In addition, Ms. Parnall testified that STUDENT had difficulty with the self-help skill of toilet training because he had a hard time tolerating the auditory input involved in toilet use.
On May 25, 2004, Ms. Seibert, STUDENT’s SDC teacher, conducted an observation of STUDENT in an SDC classroom. In her written report, she noted deficits in the areas of making eye contact, remaining quiet at the end of an activity, throwing balls, transitioning to the snack table, and eating appropriately. Furthermore, she testified that at the time that STUDENT left her classroom in April 2004, he was not yet interacting with other children, needed prompting to complete table activities, and needed prompting to stay seated during circle time.
On June 1, 2004, Ms. Christison prepared an annual review of STUDENT in the autism clinic. According to her report, STUDENT continued to exhibit deficits in the areas of functional communication, expressive/receptive repertoire, preacademic skills, and art/play skills. Ms. Christison concluded that STUDENT needed to continue working on verbal imitation, receptive language, and imitation of object labeling. She also testified that STUDENT had not yet developed sufficient skills in the areas of number concepts, letter and number identification, turn-taking, pretend play, readiness for kindergarten, phonic sounds, and reading readiness.
On June 2, 2004, Ms. Yamashita, STUDENT’s speech and language therapist, prepared a written report regarding STUDENT’s strengths and weaknesses. Although she was unable to administer formal testing to STUDENT due to his noncompliance, she reported that his language functioning in April 2004 included the ability to express some sounds, to pay attention for longer periods of time, and to sometimes follow one-step directions. However, STUDENT continued to have deficits in the areas of matching objects, labeling objects, verbal imitation, identifying body parts, and using prepositions. As part of her assessment, she observed STUDENT in a novel preschool setting and found that he had difficulties with peer interactions, remaining seated during circle time, and attending to tasks. She recommended continued speech and language therapy of ninety minutes per week to facilitate receptive and expressive language, verbal output, and social/pragmatic skills.
STUDENT’s parents generally agreed with the District and YCOE regarding his areas of deficit in June 2004. They agreed that in the area of language and communication, he required specialized one-on-one ABA and small-group instruction to address his expressive, receptive, and communication deficits. One-on-one ABA and small group instruction in language and communication would also address his behavioral deficits of having tantrums by teaching him to communicate his wants and needs. In the area of socialization and play skills, he required specialized small-group instruction to address his difficulties with peer and adult interaction. In the areas of imitation, visual performance, and preacademic skills, he required specialized one-on-one ABA instruction to learn these individual skills, such as matching colors and shapes, and small-group instruction to learn to generalize these skills to a larger environment. In the area self-help skills, he required both one-on-one ABA and small-group instruction to learn the skills required to use the bathroom appropriately. On the basis of the foregoing evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT had deficits in June 2004 in the areas of communication, socialization, play skills, imitation, visual performance, preacademic skills, and self-help skills.
In addition, STUDENT’s parents agreed with the District and YCOE that STUDENT required one-on-one ABA instruction to address these deficits although they believed that he required this instruction in a forty-hour-per-week home-based ABA program and that he was not yet ready for a preschool SDC classroom. With regard to the type of instruction needed to address these deficits, however, the Hearing Officer is persuaded by the credible testimony of the District and YCOE witnesses who worked with STUDENT during the 2003-2004 school year in the clinic and SDC setting and saw his progress in attention, communication, socialization, and generalization as a result of his placement. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that as a result of his deficits, STUDENT continued to require one-on-one ABA and small group instruction with similar peers to address his deficits and that these were his unique needs in June 2004.
Was the District’s and YCOE’s Proposed Program for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 School Year Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?
As discussed above, it must next be determined if the District’s and YCOE’s proposed placement for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas identified above.
Ms. Seibert testified that the District’s proposed SDC preschool classroom for STUDENT included free play, fine motor activities, sensory activities, gross motor activities, games, circle time for songs and reading books, oral motor activities, snack time, table time activities, and imitation activities. She further testified that the classroom had one teacher, two classroom aides, and one-on-one aides for individual students as required by their IEPs. Ms. Seibert also testified that the teacher would consult with STUDENT’s occupational therapist, speech and language therapist, and autism clinic behavior specialist regarding strategies to use in the classroom to work on his goals and objectives and to teach him to generalize the skills learned in the clinic.
Ms. Clumpner described the proposed preschool classroom as being appropriate to meet STUDENT’s needs because the staff work as a team, the team immediately address difficulties, there is planned peer interaction, goals and objectives are embedded throughout the day, social development and learning to play are interwoven throughout the day, language activities are planned, and the class has an OT component. She described the District’s and YCOE’s offer as including all of the components that STUDENT needed to prepare for kindergarten and to develop language, social skills, peer relationships, and the ability to play.
Ms. Yamashita testified that she proposed an increase in speech and language from sixty minutes per week to ninety minutes per week because STUDENT had developed the ability to participate in more direct therapy as a result of his better attention skills when compared with earlier in the school year. She further testified that she and the classroom teacher would work together on STUDENT’s speech and language goals and objectives in addition to his individual therapy sessions. She also testified that the SDC classroom is appropriate for STUDENT because there are children in the class with superior language skills who would provide him with appropriate role models.
Ms. Parnall testified that she would work with STUDENT on fine motor, messy play, and gross motor activities. She would also work with classroom staff to show them how to help STUDENT with motor activities in the classroom and with clinic staff to help him become calm, organize his nervous system, and decrease his sensory defensiveness. Ms. Parnall testified that she proposed a decrease in OT services from sixty minutes per week to thirty minutes per week because STUDENT’s progress during the prior school year indicated that he no longer required as much direct service.
Finally, Ms. Christison testified that the instructional aides would instruct STUDENT in task analysis in the autism clinic by conducting one-on-one DTT sessions that address his goals and objectives. In addition, she testified that she would participate in weekly team meetings, observe STUDENT’s classroom monthly, and collaborate with his classroom teacher and service providers.
In summary, Ms. Christison, Ms. Seibert, and Ms. Yamashita all testified that the District’s and YCOE’s combination program of a preschool SDC classroom and the YCOE clinic, with related services of speech and language and OT, was the most appropriate way to provide instruction to STUDENT. Ms. Christison testified that she did not believe that a home program was appropriate for STUDENT because he needed to learn to generalize the skills learned in his one-on-one instruction and would best do so in a preschool classroom where he could participate in his small-group and interact with other children. Dr. Elder disagreed with Ms. Christison’s opinion and stated that, although STUDENT needed to learn to generalize, he first needed to learn preschool readiness skills, such as learning to interact with peers and learning attention skills, prior to attending school. They further testified that they had seen evidence of STUDENT’s ability to attend better in class, to better communicate his needs and wants in class, and to begin to interact with other children in class as a result of beginning to generalize from the clinic to the classroom as the 2003-2004 school year progressed.
Dr. Elder also testified that she believed that the SDC classroom proposed for STUDENT was inappropriate on the basis of an observation of his classroom that she conducted in February 2004. She testified that during unstructured free play, STUDENT was not engaged appropriately, engaged in repetitive behaviors, and fixated on a train in the classroom. She also observed that STUDENT did not follow group instruction and required physical prompts for most activities. She was particularly concerned about an incident in which STUDENT cried for several minutes when the class could not go outside because it had begun to rain. She testified that this incident indicated to her that the SDC classroom was not appropriate for STUDENT because he was not learning to manage transitions.
The Hearing Officer is persuaded that the District’s and YCOE’s offer of placement and services for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of motor planning and coordination, sensory processing, socialization, preacademic skills, communication skills, expressive/receptive language, self-help skills, imitation skills, play skills, and attention. Ms. Parnall testified credibly that she would address STUDENT’s motor and sensory processing needs. Ms. Yamashita testified credibly that she would address STUDENT’s communication, expressive/receptive language, and attention needs. Ms. Christison testified credibly that she would address STUDENT’s preacademic, communication, and play skills in the autism clinic. Finally, Ms. Seibert, as corroborated by Ms. Clumpner, testified credibly that she would address all of STUDENT’s areas of need and goals and objectives in her language-based classroom.
Although Dr. Elder observed Ms. Seibert’s classroom and believed it to be inappropriate for STUDENT, the Hearing Officer accords more weight to the testimony of Ms. Seibert, Ms. Christison, Ms. Yamashita, and Ms. Parnall, all of whom worked closely with STUDENT on a regular basis throughout the 2003-2004 school year. Each of these individuals is very familiar with STUDENT’s unique needs in the classroom and clinic, is familiar with his IEP goals and objectives, and is familiar with the program and services provided to STUDENT by the District and YCOE. On the other hand, Dr. Elder, who observed only one two-and-one-half-hour preschool class, does not have the same familiarity with STUDENT’s school program. She testified that she has never taught in a preschool, is not a credentialed teacher, and has worked with children with autism only outside of the school setting. In addition, she testified that she did not believe it appropriate to speak to Ms. Seibert about the difficulties she had observed with STUDENT because that would have been an “insult” to the teacher. Therefore, as Dr. Elder has no direct experience in a school setting and did not speak to the teacher to learn any additional information about the classroom that she observed, the Hearing Officer gives less weight to her opinion than to that of all of STUDENT’s school providers.
Therefore, on the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s and YCOE’s proposed offer in June 2004 was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year.
Was the District’s and YCOE’s Proposed Placement for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 School Year Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit to STUDENT?
As discussed above, the Hearing Officer must next determine if the District’s and YCOE’s proposed placement for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to STUDENT. As discussed previously, the Hearing Officer concluded that the District’s and YCOE’s offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs in the areas of motor planning and coordination, sensory processing, socialization, preacademic skills, communication skills, expressive/receptive language, self-help skills, imitation skills, play skills, and attention. The IEP team also drafted goals and objectives in the areas of receptive language, articulation, functional communication, expressive language, visual performance, imitation, motor planning and coordination, sensory processing, interactive play, preacademic skills, attention, and self-help that would address STUDENT’s areas of identified need.
All of the District and YCOE witnesses who have worked directly with STUDENT testified that he benefited from his placement in a preschool SDC and the YCOE autism clinic with related services of speech and language therapy and OT during the 2003-2004 school year and that he would continue to benefit from this placement and services.
Ms. Seibert, Ms. Christison, and Ms. Yamashita all testified that when STUDENT began the 2003-2004 school year, he was nonverbal, had no play skills, dropped objects, moved away from people, had no eye contact, had a short attention span, could not transition, had tantrums, screamed, and engaged in self-stimulatory behavior. They all testified that by the end of the school year, he had made a great deal of progress in these areas and would continue to make gains as he continued in the District and YCOE program. Adams v. State of Oregon, supra, 195 F.3d at 1149.
Ms. Seibert testified that STUDENT’s classroom progress included the ability to transition, to follow a schedule, to no longer have tantrums, to sit in circle time for ten minutes, to make eye contact, to play appropriately, to begin to engage with other children, to be aware of other people, to perform classroom activities, to request some desired items, to make some verbal sounds, and to be more attentive. Ms. Yamashita also testified that STUDENT progressed during the 2003-2004 school year in his speech and language therapy and in the classroom. She testified that he was able to pay attention and focus, tolerate physical prompts, articulate sounds, and speak a few words by the end of the school year. She described his biggest improvements as cognition, attention, behavior, and following class routines. In her opinion, he progressed and would continue to progress.
Ms. Christison also testified that STUDENT had made a great deal of progress during the 2003-2004 school year. She testified that he had a lot more sounds, his social skills and attention increased significantly, he understood other people’s impact on him, he had made significant progress in preacademic skills, he followed routines and transitions, and his peer imitation was better. Finally, Ms. Parnall testified that STUDENT made progress in OT in that he had begun to make eye contact, touched messy activities, and spontaneously engaged in activities. She also testified that he was participating more in class activities, had more interest in fine motor activities, had learned to scribble, worked with clay, played on the obstacle course, had decreased sensory defensiveness, transitioned better, and played more appropriately.
STUDENT disputes the District and YCOE testimony regarding his progress during the school year primarily on the basis of the observation of Dr. Elder in February 2004. However, similar to the above finding, the Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Seibert, Ms. Christison, and Ms. Yamashita more credible regarding STUDENT’s progress because of their knowledge of STUDENT and his needs in the classroom and clinic setting rather than Dr. Elder’s opinion that is based upon her knowledge of STUDENT mainly in the home setting.
On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s and YCOE’s proposed placement for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to STUDENT.
Did the District’s and YCOE’s Proposed Program for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 School Year Comport With STUDENT’s IEP?
There is no dispute that the District and YCOE are willing to provide the placement and services, and implement the goals and objectives specified in the IEP of June 2004.
In sum, the Hearing Officer concludes that in June 2004 the District and YCOE offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year. (Footnote 8)
ISSUE NO. 4: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the District’s failure to provide him with speech and language and occupational therapy services from April 1, 2004, to June 20, 2004?
Compensatory education is an equitable remedy which may be available when a school district has failed to provide a student with appropriate special education services. Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir.1994). The Ninth Circuit has held that compensatory education does not involve an obligation to provide day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity lost or time missed. The purpose of compensatory education is “to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of IDEA.” Id. at 1497. In crafting appropriate relief, a hearing officer has broad latitude. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k); School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education of Education of Massachusetts, 471 U.S. 359 (1985).
Because of the Hearing Officer’s findings that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide him with speech and language and OT services from April 13, 2004, to June 20, 2004, the Hearing Officer finds that an award of compensatory education is justified. STUDENT contends that he is entitled to the exact number of hours of services that he missed during this time. While there is no automatic entitlement to hour-for-hour compensation, in this case the Hearing Officer finds that this level of compensatory education is appropriate in light of the fact that STUDENT received no speech and language and no OT services that he required to benefit from his education for more than two months. This is particularly true in light of the credible evidence that STUDENT lost some speech and language and OT skills as a result of missing these sessions. Ms. Christison testified that STUDENT had lost some of his ability to communicate between the time that he stopped his speech and language sessions and her annual review in June 2004. Ms. Parnall testified that STUDENT’s fine motor skills had decreased when she assessed him in May as compared with activities that he could perform earlier in the year due to his not receiving OT services on a weekly basis.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is entitled to compensatory education of nine weeks each of speech and language and OT services of sixty minutes weekly, or a total of 540 minutes each of speech and language and OT services. The compensatory speech and language and OT services shall be completed within six months of the date of this Decision.
ISSUE NO. 5: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement from the District and YCOE for costs incurred in providing services to STUDENT from Therapeutic Pathways from July 2004 through the present?
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under the IDEA and replaced services that the school district failed to provide. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir.1994). However, parents are not required to have procured an exact proper placement under the IDEA in order to be entitled to reimbursement. Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education, 79 F.2d 1153, 1161(5th Cir. l986). The parents may receive reimbursement so long as their placement met the student’s unique needs and provided the student with educational benefit. Id.
In light of the Hearing Officer’s finding that the District and YCOE offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year, his parents are not entitled to reimbursement for costs incurred in providing services from Therapeutic Pathways from July 2004 through the present.
ORDER
1. Within five calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District and YCOE shall place STUDENT in the District’s preschool special day class and the YCOE autism clinic and shall immediately begin providing him with the program in his IEP dated June 2 and June 15, 2004.
2. If STUDENT’s parents want STUDENT to receive services from the District and YCOE, they shall make him available for placement in the District’s preschool special day class and YCOE’s autism clinic within five calendar days of the date of this Decision.
3. Within ten calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to determine the duration and frequency of compensatory speech and language and occupational therapy services to be provided to STUDENT. The IEP team shall provide STUDENT with 540 minutes each of speech and language and occupational therapy services. The compensatory speech and language and occupational therapy services shall be completed within six months of the date of this Decision.
4. All of Petitioner’s remaining claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
1. Did the District and YCOE offer and provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003 extended school year (ESY)?
The District and YCOE prevailed on this issue.
2. Did the District and YCOE offer and provide STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year?
The District and YCOE substantially prevailed on this issue. Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the limited extent that the Hearing Officer found that the District failed to provide him with speech and language and occupational therapy services from April 13, 2004, to June 20, 2004.
3. Did the District and YCOE offer STUDENT a FAPE at his annual IEP meeting in June 2004 for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year?
The District and YCOE prevailed on this issue.
4. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the District’s failure to provide him with speech and language and occupational therapy services from April 13, 2004, to June 20, 2004? Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
5. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement from the District and YCOE for costs incurred in providing services to STUDENT from Therapeutic Pathways from July 2004 through the present?
The District and YCOE prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Dated: February 1, 2005 ___________________________________ Maxine R. Benmour, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
YCOE did not submit a closing brief.
2Although the issues were discussed at the beginning of the hearing, the issues listed here differ slightly in wording and organization from the issues as stated by Petitioner. These differences were made for purposes of clarification and analysis only and include no substantive changes. 3 STUDENT framed this issue as having a beginning date of April 1, 2004. However, according to the evidence, his parents submitted a letter to the District informing them that they were withdrawing STUDENT from his classroom effective April 13, 2004. STUDENT presented no evidence to dispute the date contained in this letter and does not contend that the District stopped providing him with speech and language and OT services prior to that time. Therefore, the Hearing Officer has modified the date to April 13, 2004, to conform to the evidence.
4 The IEP team did not discuss the August OT assessment at the September meeting. In addition, although the team had agreed in July to conduct a further preacademic assessment of STUDENT prior to the IEP meeting in September, no such assessment was conducted during the 2003-2004 school year.
5 The District’s and YCOE’s offer for the 2003 ESY must generally be judged based upon information available to the District and YCOE at the time that the offer was made in July 2003. However, information regarding STUDENT’s functioning during the 2003 ESY may be relevant to corroborate whether the offer was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir.1999).
6 As discussed above, the District’s and YCOE’s offer must generally be judged based upon information available to the District and YCOE at the time that the offer was made in July 2003 for the 2003-2004 school year. Adams v. State of Oregon, supra, 19/5 F.3d at 1149.
7 A student is not required to participate in all or part of a special education program unless the parent consents in writing to all or part of the program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(a).
8 STUDENT contends that he is entitled to a different speech and language therapist than Ms. Yamashita for the 2004-2005 school year because of his contention that Ms. Yamashita caused him to fail to meet his speech and language goals and objectives for the 2003-2004 school year. However, in light of the Hearing Officer’s finding that STUDENT made satisfactory progress on his speech and language goals and objectives for that year, there is no longer a basis for this contention. STUDENT also contends that since Ms. Parnall testified that she does not have a contract with the District for the 2004-2005 school year, he is entitled to a “qualified occupational therapist who provides consistent services for at least one calendar year.” However, he has provided no support for his request that the Hearing Officer order the District to contract with an occupational therapist for at least one calendar year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer declines to make such a finding.
