California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 24, 2005

Student v. Davis Joint Unified School District et al.

SEHO Case No. SN 2531-04 · Hearing Officer Lawrence E. Mendel

Davis Joint Unified must provide four hours of compensatory occupational therapy; parents' claims for a 40-hour home ABA program denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 2 of 5 issues (2 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parents of a four-year-old preschooler filed for due process against Davis Joint Unified School District and the Yolo County Office of Education. The child was eligible for special education based on autistic-like behaviors. In 2003-2004 he spent nine hours a week in a county autism clinic using one-to-one applied behavior analysis (ABA) and six hours a week in a district preschool special day class (SDC). He also received speech and occupational therapy (OT). In April 2004 the parents removed him from the SDC. They then rejected the June 2004 offer for extended school year (ESY) and 2004-2005. Instead, they placed him in a 40-hour-a-week home ABA program from Therapeutic Pathways, paid for partly by Alta Regional Center. They asked for a full-time home program, compensatory services, and reimbursement.

The Hearing Officer found no procedural violations. The IEP team considered other options, including the parents' request, and the parents took full part in meetings. The goals were appropriate, as were the clinic's teaching methods, data collection, supervision, and staff training, and the child made strong progress. The speech goals lacked benchmarks, but this caused no harm. Speech and OT stopped in April 2004 because the mother effectively withdrew consent. The 2004-2005 offer added a general education State preschool with an aide and was found appropriate, so no reimbursement was owed. The only violation was a four-week delay in starting individual OT in fall 2003. The district must hold an IEP meeting within 20 days and provide four hours of compensatory OT within three months.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied the Rowley "some educational benefit" standard to a combined clinic-and-SDC autism program, rather than the full-time home ABA the parents preferred. It also shows how a parent's silence after removing a child from class was treated as withdrawing consent for services. The OT delay was remedied hour-for-hour.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Did the District and County offer and provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education for the 2003-2004 regular school year?

    FAPE was offered and provided except that the District failed to start individual OT services from September 27 to October 28, 2003. The team considered a continuum of options and the parents participated meaningfully. Missing benchmarks on the speech goals caused no harm. The clinic ABA program was appropriate. The mother effectively withdrew consent when speech and OT stopped in April 2004.

  2. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2. Did the District and County offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2004 extended school year and the 2004-2005 school year?

    The offer of an SDC, County clinic, and State preschool with a shadow aide, plus speech and OT, was designed to meet the student's needs. It was reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit and was in the LRE. The goals were reasonable and the speech pathologist was qualified.

  3. Issue 3. If the District and County did not offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2004-2005 school year, what is his appropriate placement for the remainder of the school year?

    Not addressed because the 2004-2005 offer was found to provide FAPE. The prevailing-party section lists the District and County as prevailing.

  4. Student prevailed in partImplementation

    Issue 4. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the District's failure to provide him with occupational therapy and speech/language therapy?

    Four hours of compensatory individual OT were awarded hour-for-hour for the four-week delay in fall 2003. No compensatory services were owed for April to June 2004 because the mother had withdrawn consent.

  5. Issue 5. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the privately funded services which Therapeutic Pathways provided from July 2004 through the present?

    No reimbursement for the home ABA program because the District and County offered FAPE for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Unless the parents agree otherwise in writing, the District must convene an IEP meeting within 20 calendar days of the decision to set the duration and frequency of compensatory OT.
  • Compensatory education. 4 hours of compensatory individual occupational therapy, to be completed within three months of the decision date.

Total: 4 hours of compensatory services

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range School Dist.; Adams v. State of Oregon; Seattle School Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; School Committee of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ.; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Alamo Heights ISD v. State Board of Education; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.; Roland M. v. Concord School Committee; Lester H. v. Gilhool

People named in the decision

  • Gay Bourguignon, interim coordinator of special education, Davis Joint Unified School District
  • James (Jim) Coulter, assistant superintendent, Yolo County Office of Education
  • Devon Cavagnaro, clinic supervisor, witness for Student, Therapeutic Pathways
  • Jill Young, site director, witness for Student, Therapeutic Pathways
  • Brigitte Elder, training coordinator and home program clinical supervisor, expert witness for Student, Therapeutic Pathways
  • Jackie Radin, director, witness for Student, Davis Parent Nursery School
  • Laurel Clumpner, principal of adult schools; former District coordinator of special education, Davis Joint Unified School District
  • Ann Christison, behavior specialist, County autism clinic, Yolo County Office of Education
  • Ruth Yamashita, speech-language pathologist, Davis Joint Unified School District
  • Matt Chesnut, behavior analyst (former County behavior analyst and supervisor), Yolo County Office of Education
  • Deedra Seibert, special education preschool SDC teacher, Davis Joint Unified School District
  • Kelli Parnall (formerly Howie), occupational therapist, Davis Joint Unified School District
  • Carolyn Ecker, occupational therapist (initial OT assessment)
  • Therapeutic Pathways, nonpublic agency providing home ABA program
  • Alta Regional Center, regional center funding home ABA program
  • Davis Parent Nursery School, preschool attended by student (operated by District adult education), Davis Joint Unified School District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Lawrence E. Mendel, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Davis, California, on January 4, 5, 6, 10, 11, and 18, 2005.

STUDENT (STUDENT or Student) was represented at the hearing by attorney Roberta Savage. Also present on the Student’s behalf were his mother MOTHER and his father, FATHER. The Davis Joint Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Jan Tomsky. Also present on the District’s behalf was Gay Bourguignon, interim coordinator of special education. The Yolo County Office of Education (County) was represented at different times at the hearing by attorneys Edmundo Aguilar and Sherianne Laba. Also present on County’s behalf was James Coulter, assistant superintendent.

The following witnesses were called by the Student to testify at the hearing: Devon Cavagnaro, Therapeutic Pathways (TP) clinic supervisor; MOTHER, mother; Jill Young, TP site director; Brigitte Elder, TP training coordinator; and Jackie Radin, director of Davis Parent Nursery School. The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Laurel Clumpner, principle of adult schools; Ann Christison, behavior specialist; Ruth Yamashita, speech/language pathologist; Matt Chesnut, behavior analyst; Deedra Seibert, special education preschool teacher; Jim Coulter, assistant superintendent for the County; and Kelli Parnall, occupational therapist. The County did not call any witnesses to testify at the hearing.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following the receipt of written closing arguments, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUES

1. Did the District and County offer and provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education for the 2003-2004 regular school year? 2. Did the District and County offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2004 extended school year and the 2004-2005 school year?

3. If the District and County did not offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2004-2005 school year, what is his appropriate placement for the remainder of the school year?

4. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the District’s failure to provide him with occupational therapy and speech/language therapy?

5. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the privately funded services which Therapeutic Pathways provided from July 2004 through the present?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a four year old pre-school student who resides with his parents and two brothers in Davis, California. In June 2003, he was referred by his parents for assessment to determine his eligibility for special education. At the time of his referral, his twin brother was also being evaluated for special education eligibility. In July 2003, STUDENT was assessed by the Davis Joint Unified School District and Yolo County Office of Education in the areas of academics, social/emotional functioning, psychomotor functioning, speech/language development, and intellectual ability. The psychoeducational evaluation was completed in August 2003, and concluded that STUDENT had significant delays in receptive and expressive language skills, socialization and readiness to learn skills, pre-academic skills, and self help skills. The report concluded that STUDENT was eligible for special education on the basis of autistic like behaviors. It also recommended completion of occupational therapy (OT) and speech/language (S/L) assessments.

STUDENT’s first individualized education plan (IEP) team meeting was held on August 11, 2003. While finding that STUDENT had needs in the same areas identified in the psychoeducational assessment, the team noted that STUDENT had relative strengths in the areas of matching, social interaction with adults. The team also agreed that STUDENT had emerging language skills, visual-motor integration skills. It was also noted that, although STUDENT displayed some inappropriate behaviors, those behaviors had recently become much less frequent. After a discussion of the assessment results it was agreed by both the parents and District and County staff that the assessors had identified all of STUDENT’s areas of need. Placement was recommended in the County autism clinic program for nine hours a week and in the District preschool special day class (SDC) for six hours a week. The County clinic provided individual applied behavioral analysis (ABA)-based services. The IEP also included eight hours a month of behavior consultation services to the classroom teacher and staff by County staff, use of the picture exchange communication system (PECS) to aide in language development, quarterly review meetings between District/County staff and the parents, and extended school year (ESY) services. The team drafted and agreed on seventeen goals and objectives, and agreed to the completion of OT and S/L assessments. The team also discussed that STUDENT was in the process of evaluation by the Alta Regional Center (Alta) for eligibility for a home program to address functional skills. It was estimated that Alta would be providing fifteen hours a week of home ABA services. The PARENTS agreed to the District/County offer, and in August 2003, STUDENT began attending Deedra Seibert’s preschool SDC and the County Clinic program under the direction of behavioral specialist Ann Christison.

On August 13, 2003, occupational therapist Carolyn Ecker completed an OT assessment. Ms. Ecker found that STUDENT had emerging and maturing skills in the areas of motor planning, grasp during play, and bilateral skills. However, she found that STUDENT’s skills were developmentally delayed with particular needs in the areas of sensory processing, gravitational insecurity, attention to task, peer interaction, motor planning, balance, and fine motor. She recommended sixty minutes a week of OT services.

On September 24, 2003, speech pathologist Ruth Yamashita administered the Preschool Language Scale-3 to STUDENT. Results placed STUDENT in the first percentile in auditory comprehension and the third percentile in expressive communication. Ms. Yamashita recommended thirty minutes a week of individual and thirty minutes a week of group speech language therapy. She also recommended sixty minutes a month of consultation services.

On September 26, 2003, an addendum IEP meeting was held to add S/L services to STUDENT’s program. The team incorporated Ms. Yamashita’s recommendation for a total of sixty minutes a week of individual and group therapy. Ms Yamashita drafted goals to address receptive and expressive language and pragmatics. The PARENTS agreed to the IEP.

In October 2003, STUDENT began receiving a fifteen hour a week home ABA program provided by Therapeutic Pathways, a certified nonpublic agency), and funded by Alta. (Footnote 1)

On November 19, 2003, Respondents convened STUDENT’s first quarterly review meeting. The notes from this meeting indicate that STUDENT was using a token system to address behavior, and had met both short-term objectives on his behavior goal. STUDENT had also met one or more short term objectives in the areas of play skills, fine motor skills, receptive language, visual performance, imitation skills, math readiness, reading readiness, receptive language, functional communication (PECS), and social skills. Furthermore, STUDENT had met six of his long-term goals.

On December 17, 2003, an IEP addendum meeting was held to add OT services. On the basis of Ms. Ecker’s report, and on the recommendation of occupational therapist Kelli Howie, the IEP team offered STUDENT sixty minutes a week of direct OT services and sixty minutes a month of OT consultation. (Footnote 2) Ms. Howie drafted goals to address sensory processing and fine motor skills. The IEP also notes that STUDENT had already begun receiving weekly OT services with the parents consent. The PARENT’S agreed to the IEP.

MOTHER testified that around January or February 2004 she began to be concerned about STUDENT’s SDC placement. MOTHER stated that, on the basis of her observations, STUDENT was more advanced than the other students in the class and that STUDENT lacked appropriate peer interaction opportunities. MOTHER discussed her concerns with Brigitte Elder, STUDENT’s home- program clinical supervisor from TP. Ms. Elder agreed to observe STUDENT’s SDC, which she did on February 17, 2004. Ms. Elder reported to MOTHER that she did not feel the SDC was appropriate for STUDENT because she believed STUDENT was more advanced than the other students, that STUDENT did not have any appropriate language models in the class, and that STUDENT had little opportunity for peer play and peer interaction. In March 2004, the PARENT’S decided to remove STUDENT from the District SDC. By letter dated April 12, 2004, MOTHER informed the District that, as of April 13, 2004, STUDENT would no longer be attending the SDC preschool class. (Footnote 3) Following STUDENT’s removal from the SDC, he no longer received S/L or OT services. (Footnote 4)

On April 19, 2004, an IEP team meeting was held to discuss the PARENT’S decision to remove STUDENT and his twin brother from the SDC. The meeting was not concluded on the 19th and continued on April 26 and May 14. The majority of the first two days of the meeting was devoted to STUDENT’s brother, but the May 14 meeting dealt primarily with STUDENT. At the meetings, STUDENT’s goals and objectives were reviewed, and the PARENT’S presented their reasons for removing STUDENT from the SDC. The PARENT’S stated that they did not feel the SDC was properly addressing STUDENT’s need to work on social skills. The PARENT’S also expressed general dissatisfaction regarding both the SDC and the County clinic program because they felt there was inadequate communication between themselves and the District and County staff. TP staff also attended the IEP meetings and presented their recommendation that STUDENT be placed in an intensive, one-to-one, forty hour a week ABA program. The PARENT’S stated that this was also their desire. At the meeting on May 14, 2004, the District stated that they were continuing to offer the placement and services as set forth in the August 11, 2003 IEP and amended in September and December 2003. ESY services were also discussed and recommended by the District and County. The ESY placement discussed consisted of attendance in the SDC extended school year program for five weeks, the County clinic program from June 21 to July 30, and OT and S/L as set forth in the IEP. The need to assess STUDENT in preparation for his annual IEP, to be held in June, was also addressed. On May 14, MOTHER signed a plan to assess STUDENT in the areas of pre-academics, social emotional functioning, adaptive behavior, occupational therapy, speech/language development, intellectual ability, and behavior.

On June 1, 2004, STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting was held. The meeting was completed on June 15, 2004. At these meetings, STUDENT’s goals and objectives and the results of the recent assessments were reviewed, and the District’s offer for ESY and the 2004-2005 school year were discussed. District and County staff reported that STUDENT had made significant progress in all of his areas of need over the prior school year and was working on generalizing many of his new skills across different settings. In the clinic, STUDENT was also working on “bridging concepts.” Ms. Christison explained that “bridging concepts” incorporates multiple concepts that STUDENT had mastered in a discrete trial setting into a functional activity. The District’s and County’s offer for ESY was similar to what had been recommended at the May 14 meeting: the SDC extended school year program with ninety minutes a week of S/L and thirty minutes a week of OT services, and four hours a week of shadow aide support in the SDC by a para-educator from the Count clinic. The offer also included six hours a week of clinic time. It was explained that the purpose of the shadow aide was to get STUDENT used to the presence of an aide in preparation for placement in a general education pre-school class in the fall. The offer for the 2004-2005 school year consisted of placement in the SDC pre-school class for two and a half hours a day, two days a week, the State pre-school two hours a day for two days a week with the support of a shadow aide, the County clinic for six hours a week, individual S/L therapy two times a week for thirty minutes each session, group S/L therapy once a week for thirty minutes, and OT once a week for thirty minutes. The PARENT’S did not consent to the IEP.

By letter dated June 20, 2004, the PARENT’S informed the District that they were removing STUDENT from all services and that STUDENT would not attend the ESY program. The PARENT’S stated that they intended to place STUDENT in the program recommended by TP at the May 14 meeting. On October 13, 2004, the PARENT’S filed the due process hearing request that is the subject of this hearing.

Since July 2004, the PARENT’S have been partially funding a forty hours a week home ABA program provided by TP. Alta continues to pay for one-half of the hours, and the PARENT’S pay for the other half. In addition, since August 2004, STUDENT has been enrolled at the Davis Parent Nursery School three days a week. (Footnote 5)

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Student contends that he was denied a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2003-2004 regular school year on the basis of both procedural and substantive violations of the IDEA. Procedurally, Student argues that he was denied a FAPE by the District and County for two reasons: (1) they failed to offer him a continuum of services; and (2) they did not allow the parents meaningful participation in the IEP process. Substantively, Student alleges that the goals and objectives did not address all of his areas of need, were underestimates of his ability, and lacked benchmarks. In addition, Student contends that the goals should have been revised during the year to reflect his progress. Regarding the placement and services offered, Student contends that the services were not intensive enough, lacked adequate supervision, lacked parent participation, and did not provide him with opportunities for appropriate peer interaction. Student also argues that the OT services were not commenced in a timely manner. Furthermore Student contends that the treatment team meetings offered did not occur, data collection was improperly done in the County clinic, the promised collaboration with the home program did not occur, the clinic aides and S/L pathologist were not properly trained, and OT and S/L services were discontinued without parent consent. Student contends that he should have been provided with a forty hour a week in-home ABA program similar to that provided to him by TP.

Student’s contentions are similar regarding the District’s and County’s offer for the 2004 ESY. Student alleges that the District and County continued to commit the same procedural violations as occurred during the 2003-2004 regular school year. Student also contends that the placement offered was not intensive enough and should have consisted of a forty hour a week in-home ABA program rather than the combination of SDC and County clinic program offered.

Regarding the 2004-2005 school year, Student contends that the District’s and County’s procedural violations continued. Student also argues that the goals and objectives were not appropriate because they failed to address all of his areas of need and continued to underestimate his abilities. The offer of placement in the State preschool was not appropriate because it did not offer STUDENT opportunities for appropriate peer interaction, and because STUDENT would be exposed to multiple languages during parts of the instruction, which could be confusing for him. Student also contends that the reduction in clinic hours would not have met his needs. Student’s only contention regarding the offer of OT and S/L services was that the proposed speech/language therapist, Ruth Yamashita, was not qualified to provide S/L services to a child such as him. Student contends that he required a combination of a general education preschool placement and home ABA program that would total forty hours a week.

Regarding placement for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year, Student contends that he requires a combination of one-to-one in-home ABA services, such as that which is being provided by TP, and placement in the preschool class at the Davis Parent Nursery School. Student also alleges that he is entitled to compensatory education for missed S/L and OT services, and that his parents are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the in-home ABA program which TP has provided since July 2004 to the present.

The District and County contend that they offered and provided STUDENT with a FAPE during all times at issue and that STUDENT is not entitled to any of the relief requested.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

1. Did the District and County offer and provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education for the 2003-2004 regular school year?

Under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a child at no charge to his or her parent or guardian, meet the standards of the State educational agency, include appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education, and are provided in conformity with an individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). Special education law also requires that a child with a disability be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A). Such special education and related services must be tailored to meet the unique needs of the child with a disability by means of an IEP. Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16, 853 F.2d 171, 173 (3d Cir. 1988).

In Board of Educ. of Hendrick Hudson Central School Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that a child’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the child with some educational benefit to satisfy the IDEA, but that the school district is not required to provide the child with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court held that a school district is required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child. Id. at 201. Consequently, an appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the child. Seattle School Dist., No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996). De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist., 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2d Cir. 1998).

The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. 458 U.S. at 205. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he or she is entitled, and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process may result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1483; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).

In summary, under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley, the proposed educational program must (1) be designed to meet the student’s unique needs, (2) provide for the student to be involved and progress in the general curriculum, (3) be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, (4) conform with the student’s IEP, and (5) provide placement in the least restrictive environment. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, 458 U.S. 176. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer must consider whether the necessary procedural requirements were adhered to. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-207.

In this case, Student is contending that the District and County denied him a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year as the result of both procedural and substantive violations of the IDEA. Student’s contentions regarding procedural violations will be examined first.

Procedural Violations

Student contends that he was denied a FAPE by the District and County for two reasons: (1) they failed to offer him a continuum of services; and (2) they did not allow the parents meaningful participation in the IEP process.

Did the District and County Fail to Offer a Continuum of Services?

California and federal law require that LEAs have available “a full continuum of program options” to meet the unique needs of the child, including instruction conducted in the classroom, in the home, in hospitals and institutions, and in other settings. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. Student contends that the District and County did not consider any option other than the program they offered, including the parent’s request for a forty hour a week in-home ABA program.

At STUDENT’s initial IEP meeting held on August 11, 2003, MOTHER , Ms. Seibert, Ms. Clumpner, and the audio tape of the IEP meeting established that the District and County staff reviewed the results of STUDENT’s assessments as well as the information provided by the PARENTS. The IEP team discussed STUDENT’s unique needs and why the District and County were recommending a program that included discrete trial training in a clinic setting and an SDC preschool class for STUDENT. Various combinations of these services were also considered, including starting with only direct instruction in a clinic setting and adding the SDC later, or combining both programs at the start of the school year. STUDENT’s possible needs for designated instruction and services (DIS) and ESY were discussed. Other placement and service options that were considered were a general education placement, assistive technology and adaptive physical education. It was also discussed that STUDENT was in the process of being evaluated by Alta for provision of a home program. The PARENT’S did not raise the issue of a forty-hour a week in-home program for STUDENT until after they had removed both STUDENT and his brother from the SDC in March 2004.

At the IEP meetings held in April and May to address the PARENT’S reasons for removing STUDENT and his brother from the SDC, the parents’ desire for a forty hour a week in-home program was discussed. The IEP document as well as testimony from Ms. Seibert, Ms. Christison and Ms. Clumpner established that District and County staff explained their reasons for continuing to recommend a placement that included a combination of clinic and SDC time. At that time, other placement options were again discussed, including DIS services, non-public school placement, services from non-public agencies.

On the basis of the foregoing evidence, including testimony by MOTHER , TP staff, and District and County staff, the IEP notes, and the tape of the August 11, 2003 IEP meeting, the Hearing Officer finds that the District and County did consider a wide variety of program options, including the parents’ request for a forty hour a week in-home program. Furthermore, State and federal law only require that the educational agency have “available” a full continuum of options. There is no requirement that a student’s IEP actually discuss each and every placement option available for students with exceptional needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District and County did not commit any procedural violation on this basis.

Were the PARENT’S Denied Meaningful Participation in the IEP Process?

Student contends that his parents were denied meaningful participation in the IEP process because the District and County did not consider their input, did not allow them to participate in the development of his program, and did not provide them with sufficient information about his performance in the District’s and County’s programs. School districts must ensure that the parent of each individual with exceptional needs is a member of any group that makes decisions on the educational placement of the individual with exceptional needs. Cal. Educ. Code § 56342.5. In addition, the parents or a child with a disability must be regularly informed of the child’s progress, at least as often as parents are informed of a nondisabled child’s progress. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345. Furthermore, STUDENT’s IEPs called for quarterly team meetings to review progress.

The District and County witnesses credibly testified that, at STUDENT’s initial IEP meeting held on August 11, 2003, the assessments were reviewed in detail, STUDENT’s strengths and weakness were discussed, and proposed goals and objectives were reviewed one-by-one. At all stages the PARENT’S actively participated in the discussions, asked questions, and provided information. No decision in the drafting of the IEP was made without first obtaining input from the PARENTS. Following the discussion of the goals and objectives, an additional goal was added at MOTHER ’s request. The witnesses’ testimony regarding this IEP meeting is corroborated by the audio tape of the meeting. The evidence also established that, during the year, MOTHER met and spoke with both District and County staff on a daily basis, and was provided with ongoing information about what STUDENT was working on. Furthermore, the PARENT’S were given training in STUDENT’s sensory diet exercises for use at home, and were offered the opportunity to participate in various general trainings during the school year. (Footnote 6)

STUDENT’s first quarterly team meeting was held in November, 2003, at which time his progress on all of his goals and objectives was reviewed. STUDENT’s second quarterly team meeting was scheduled to March, but was delayed when the PARENT’S removed STUDENT from the SDC. However, STUDENT’s progress was reviewed in detail at the series of IEP meetings held in April and May 2004. STUDENT’s IEP team met again at the end of the year at his annual IEP team meeting and again reviewed his progress on his goals and objectives and the results of updated assessments.

At the series of IEP meetings held in April and May 2004, the PARENT’S were given the opportunity to present their concerns about his program. In addition to input from the PARENTS, Brigitte Elder and Jill Young from TP, who were attending the meetings on STUDENT’s behalf, participated in the discussion regarding STUDENT’s program. During the course of the meetings, the PARENT’S presented a written statement of their concerns, which was responded to in writing by the District and County prior to the final meeting on May 14. The evidence established that, at the meetings, the District and County responded to the PARENT’S concerns regarding the SDC placement, and the program in general, and explained the reasons for continuing to recommend the clinic/SDC placement.

The evidence as a whole establishes the parents were active members of the IEP team. They were, at all times, presented with updated information regarding STUDENT’s program, and afforded the opportunity to present and discuss each of their concerns. Furthermore, STUDENT’s progress on his goals and objectives was reviewed in detail at three different times during the year as required by his IEP. On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District and County did consider the PARENT’S input, and allowed them to participate in the development of STUDENT’s program. The Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT’s parents were regularly informed of his progress, and that the quarterly progress meetings called for in STUDENT’s IEP were all held. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District and County did not commit a procedural violation on this basis.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District and County did not deny STUDENT a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year on the basis of any procedural violations of the IDEA.

Substantive Violations

Was the District’s and County’s offer designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?

The first step is to determine what STUDENT’s unique needs were at the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year. There is no dispute that the District’s and County’s assessments performed in July, August, and September 2003 accurately identified all of STUDENT’s strengths and deficits. Those assessments established that STUDENT had deficits in areas of pre-academics, social skills, peer interaction/peer play, behavior, readiness to learn skills, expressive/receptive language, pragmatics, self-help skills, sensory processing, balance, and fine/gross motor skills. However, while finding deficits in all of the areas listed, the assessments also established that STUDENT had relative strengths in the areas of matching, imitation, receptive instructions, labeling, social awareness with adults, attention to task, and motor planning. In order to address those deficits, the District and County assessors determined that STUDENT needed individual instruction using ABA techniques such as discrete trial training to learn basic skills and address behavioral needs, small group instruction in a structured setting in order to address pre-academic skills, social skills, peer interaction/peer play, and to reinforce and generalize those skills learned in the individual instruction. It was also determined that STUDENT would need S/L and OT services.

It is undisputed that STUDENT required S/L, and OT services. It is also undisputed that he required individual ABA-based instruction to learn basic skills in all of his areas of deficit. However, Student contends that he required a full-time, individual, ABA-based home program rather than a combination of individual and small group instruction. This contention will be addressed later in this Decision.

The next question is whether the District’s and County’s offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The offer as set forth in the IEPs of August 11, September 26, December 17, 2003, consisted of nine hours a week of one-to-one ABA services in the County autism clinic, six hours a week in the District’s preschool SDC, eight hours a month of supervision/behavior consultation to District and County staff by Ms. Christison, and DIS in S/L and OT. Student contends that this program was not designed to meet his unique needs because the goals and objectives were not appropriate, the program was not intensive enough, the SDC lacked opportunities for peer interaction, the County’s clinic program was not an appropriate ABA program, the OT services were not added in a timely manner, and the S/L pathologist was not properly qualified. Each of Student’s contentions will be examined separately.

1. Appropriate Goals and Objectives

An IEP must include measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, to meet the needs of students with disabilities. 20 U.S.C. § 1414 (d)(1)(A)(ii); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(2).

At the August 11, 2003 IEP meeting, the team developed seventeen goals for implementation in the clinic and SDC in the areas of behavior, self help, play skills, fine motor, receptive language, visual performance, imitation skills, matching skills, expressive language, math readiness, reading readiness, functional communication, and social/play skills. S/L goals were added in September 2003, and OT goals were added in December 2003. Student contends that these goals were inappropriate for several reasons: (1) several of the goals called for the use of PECS which was not an appropriate methodology for him; (2) the goals were underestimates of his ability; (3) the goals did not adequately address his needs in the areas of play skills, social skills, and behavior; (4) the S/L goals lacked any benchmarks; (5) the goals should have been revised during the school year because of the progress he had made; and (6) additional goals were to be added for implementation in the classroom, but that no such goals were ever written. There was no dispute regarding the appropriateness of the OT goals.

a. Appropriateness of PECS

Regarding the use of PECS, Ms. Christison, STUDENT’s behavior specialist, testified that in the course of her initial assessment of STUDENT she observed that he was making vocalizations but was not using verbal language in a functional manner. She found that STUDENT primarily used signs and body movements in order to get his needs met. Ms. Christison also probed the use of PECS with STUDENT during her assessment. On the basis of her observations, she concluded that the use of PECS would be appropriate to help STUDENT develop a functional communication system. Dr. Elder, STUDENT’s program supervisor at TP, stated that, in her opinion, the use of PECS could actually discourage a child such as STUDENT from utilizing verbal language. However, Ms. Christison explained that PECS was not used to discourage verbal communication, but to give STUDENT the opportunity to communicate his needs and wants more fully. In addition, she stated that PECS could aide STUDENT in learning sentence structure. Ms. Christison also noted that the first time Dr. Elder saw STUDENT was in October 2003 by which time he had already been in the District’s and County’s program for some time, and was already beginning to use vocalizations in a functional manner.

The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Christison’s testimony credible. Ms. Christison has a bachelor’s degree in psychology and certificate in applied behavior analysis from Sacramento State University, and is qualified to sit for the Board Certified Associate Behavior Analyst exam. She has also received additional training related to treating children with autism, including trainings in neurodevelopmental disorders, ABA, professional assault response training, and PECS. She also has experience working for a nonpublic agency as a tutor and lead tutor providing in-home ABA programs to autistic children. It is also undisputed that the results of her initial assessment of STUDENT provided an accurate reflection of STUDENT’s strengths and weaknesses. On the basis of Ms. Christison’s testimony, and a review of the evidence as a whole, the Hearing Officer finds that the use of PECS was appropriate for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT used PECS only in the clinic. STUDENT worked on verbal communication in the classroom and during S/L therapy. While Dr. Elder testified that the use of PECS would impede STUDENT’s development of verbal language, no convincing evidence was presented to support her opinion. Dr. Elder did note a few incidents documented in STUDENT’s clinic data binder that could be interpreted as evidence that STUDENT actually refrained from using verbal language in order to use his PECS book, but the Hearing Officer finds this evidence unconvincing. The testimony of Ms. Seibert, Ms. Christison, and Ms. Yamashita regarding STUDENT’s improving verbal communication skills during the 2003-2004 school year all confirm that the use of PECS with STUDENT did not significantly interfere with his development of verbal language. Therefore, having found that the use of PECS was appropriate, the Hearing Officer finds that the PECS goals and objectives were appropriate for STUDENT.

b. Goals and Objectives Underestimated STUDENT’s Abilities

Dr. Elder testified that the non-PECS goals drafted in August 2003, though addressing appropriate skills for STUDENT, were inappropriate because they were all underestimates of what STUDENT could accomplish within one year. However, the Hearing Officer notes that, as stated above, Dr. Elder did not assess STUDENT until October 2003, after he had been in the District and County program for almost two months. The District’s and County’s offer must be judged based upon the information available to the District and County at the time that the offer was made. Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999). Ms. Christison, who drafted those goals, stated that she based them on the District’s and County’s assessment performed in July and early August 2003, which included input from the parents as well as an observation of STUDENT at home. As previously stated, the members of STUDENT’s IEP team, including MOTHER , all agreed that the District’s and County’s assessments had been very complete and that the results were a very accurate representation of STUDENT’s strengths and weaknesses. The Hearing Officer also notes that STUDENT had not previously been in any program, so there was no past history of performance to rely. Ms. Christison persuasively testified that, on the basis of the District’s and County’s assessment of STUDENT as well as her experience in working with autistic children, she believed the goals were reasonable estimates of what STUDENT could accomplish in one year. Furthermore, the goals were reviewed and discussed in detail at the August IEP team meeting, and were agreed upon by the entire team.

On the basis of the evidence reviewed above, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives included in STUDENT’s August 2003 IEP were reasonable estimates of what STUDENT could accomplish in one year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that those goals did not underestimate STUDENT’s abilities.

c. Goals and Objectives Failed to Address All Areas of Need

Student contends that the August 2003 goals and objectives, as well as the S/L goals and objectives added in September 2003, failed to address his deficits in the areas of play skills, social skills, and behavior. Ms. Christison credibly testified that two of the goals she wrote were specifically to target play skills and another goal was written to address STUDENT’s imitation skills. Furthermore, an additional goal was added at the August 2003 IEP meeting to address social/play skills. Ms. Yamashita, STUDENT’s S/L pathologist also drafted two pragmatic language goals. One of the pragmatic language goals addressed STUDENT’s basic conversation skills, which Ms. Yamashita testified was, in part, worked on during peer play in the SDC. Therefore, regarding social skills, the IEP team drafted a social skills goal, and Ms. Yamashita, as stated earlier, drafted two pragmatic language goals. Dr. Elder testified that, in her opinion, the District’s and County’s goals did not adequately address STUDENT’s need to learn play skills and social skills. She stated that examples of specific skills that could have been addressed were imitative play, pretend play, playing games, engaging in conversation, attending to peers, and learning by observing.

After reviewing the District’s and County’s goals and objectives, the Hearing Officer finds that, contrary to Dr. Elder’s assertions, there were goals to address imitation skills, playing games (assembling puzzles and turn taking), and basic conversation skills. Furthermore, the goals draft by the IEP team allowed the team to develop an effective program for STUDENT. As will be discussed in more detail later, STUDENT made significant progress toward all of his goals during the 2003-2004 regular school year. While there were no goals directly addressing pretend play, attending to peers, or learning by observing, the Hearing Officer finds that there is no requirement that a district draft goals to address each and every discrete skill a student may need improvement in. As stated above, the educational agency is required to develop annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, to meet the needs of students with disabilities. Id. The law requires that those goals meet the child’s needs that result from his disability and enable the child to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. Id. One of the primary purposes of the goals is to allow the IEP team to develop strategies that would be effective in allowing the student to reach his goals. 34 C.F.R. Part 300, Appendix A, Question 1. On the basis of the foregoing analysis, the Hearing Officer finds that the District and County did draft goals and objectives that met STUDENT educational needs in relation to play skills and social skills, and that the goals allowed STUDENT to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum.

Regarding behavior, Student contends that the District and County failed to address his inappropriate behaviors, including tantrums, head butting, and hand flapping. STUDENT’s initial assessment indicates that he was exhibiting some tantrums, hitting/kicking, head butting, and hand flapping. However, the assessment also states that MOTHER reported that the frequency of those behaviors had been declining. The data provided by MOTHER indicated that tantrums were only occurring .2 times a day, that hand flapping was occurring once a day, and the hitting/kicking was occurring 4.7 times a day. On the basis of the data collected during the assessment, the assessors concluded that the purpose of the head butting and hitting/kicking was communication, and the purpose of the hand flapping was intrinsic reinforcement. Because the primary function of the hitting and kicking was communication, the IEP team recommended a combination of a token system to reinforce appropriate behaviors, the use of PECS to improve STUDENT’s functional communication, and S/L services and ABA-based services to improve STUDENT’s expressive and receptive language skills. A behavior goal which incorporated the use of a token system and several receptive/expressive language goals were developed. In order to address hand flapping, OT services were offered which included a goal to address sensory processing. OT exercises, including sensory diet exercises, were also incorporated into the SDC routine. Student contends that these goals were inadequate to address his needs in the area of behavior. Student argues that more goals or a behavior plan should have been developed.

An educational agency is required to develop appropriate strategies and supports when a child’s behavior impedes his learning. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.1 However, a more formal behavior intervention plan need only be developed when a student’s IEP team finds that the behavioral approaches specified in the student’s IEP have proven to be ineffective. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5 § 3052. The Hearing Officer finds that there was no evidence that STUDENT required a formal behavior intervention plan. STUDENT’s IEP contained various strategies for controlling his inappropriate behaviors. Furthermore, Ms. Seibert, Ms. Yamashita, and Ms. Christison all testified that, as the year progressed and STUDENT’s functional communication skills improved, his inappropriate behaviors declined. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the strategies and supports which were included in STUDENT’s IEP were effective in controlling his behavior. On the basis of the foregoing analysis, the Hearing Officer finds that the District and County drafted appropriate goals and included sufficient services and supports to address STUDENT’s inappropriate behaviors.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District and County did draft goals and objectives to address all of STUDENT’s needs, including social skills, play skills, and behavior. Therefore, the goals and objectives were not inappropriate on that basis.

d. The S/L Goals lacked benchmarks

As set forth above, IEP goals must have included benchmarks or short-term objectives. The District and County concede that the S/L goals added to STUDENT’s IEP lacked benchmarks or short-term objectives. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that, to the extent the S/L goals lacked benchmarks or short-term objectives, STUDENT’s goals and objectives were not appropriate. The District argues that, despite this deficiency in the drafting of the S/L goals, STUDENT did not suffer any harm because he made progress on his goals, and that progress was reported to the parents. As noted previously, the purpose of benchmarks is to enable a child’s parents and teachers to gauge, at intermediate times during the year, how well the child is progressing toward the achievement of the annual goal. 34 C.F.R. Part 300, Appendix A, Question 1.

Ms. Yamashita testified that, in her initial assessment of STUDENT, he had severe deficits in both receptive and expressive language. STUDENT also had needs in the area of pragmatics. She drafted ten goals to address his needs in those areas. Ms. Yamashita reported on STUDENT’s progress on his goals at the series of IEP meetings in April and May 2004 and at STUDENT’s annual IEP in June 2004. By May 14, 2004, STUDENT had met five of his ten goals and had made substantial progress on the other five. On May 20, 2004, Ms. Yamashita administered the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-3 and the Expressive Vocabulary Test. On these tests, STUDENT scored in the average range for both receptive and expressive vocabulary. Ms. Yamashita also observed and worked with STUDENT throughout the year in the SDC setting. Over the course of the year, she observed that STUDENT showed improvement in all speech and language areas, including asking and answering questions, following directions, articulation, vocabulary, conversation skills, and peer interaction. Ms. Yamashita’s testimony was corroborated by the testimony of Ms. Seibert, the SDC teacher. Ms. Seibert stated that, over the year, STUDENT displayed increased vocalizations, improved greetings, increased vocabulary, and the beginnings of social skills.

The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Yamashita and Ms. Seibert credible. On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not suffer any harm from the District’s failure to draft benchmarks or short-term objectives for the S/L goals. Despite the lack of benchmarks or short-term objectives, STUDENT did make substantial progress of all of his S/L goals, meeting five of the ten. In addition, by May 2004 STUDENT’s expressive and receptive vocabulary and improved to the extent that he scored in the normal range on standardized testing. Furthermore, Ms. Yamashita was able to report on STUDENT’s progress as two different IEP meetings. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to include benchmarks for his S/L goals.

e. Revision of Goals and Objectives

Student contends that the District and County were required to revise his goals and objectives during the school year because of the progress he had demonstrated by November 2003, and May 2004. The evidence established that STUDENT had met six of the seventeen goals drafted in August by November 2003. He had met two goals in the areas of receptive language, two goals in the area of reading readiness, and one goal in each of the areas of expressive language and functional communication. By May, 2004, he had met one more goal in each of the areas of math readiness, visual performance, and play skills. By May, he had also met S/L goals in the areas of identifying categories, responding to requests, understanding the use of objects, phonemes, and producing final consonants. Although the evidence established that STUDENT made significant progress on his goals and objectives as early as November 2003, he offers no authority in support of his contention that this progress obligated the District and County to revise his goals prior to his annual IEP. As found earlier, STUDENT’s goals and objectives were appropriate at the time they were drafted. A school district is required to revise a student’s goals and objectives whenever the student demonstrates a lack of anticipated progress but does not have such an obligation when a child exhibits progress prior to a scheduled review. See Cal. Educ. Code § 56343(b). Furthermore, even though STUDENT met many of his annual goals, he had other appropriate goals, which he continued to work on. In addition, after he had mastered a specific skill in the clinic setting, Ms. Christison testified that the clinic staff continued to work on generalizing that skill to functional settings, and on combining mastered skills through “bridging concepts.” Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District and County had no duty to revise STUDENT’s August 2003 goals and objectives, or his September S/L goals during the 2003-2004 regular school year.

f. Failure to Add Classroom Goals

Student contends that the District agreed to draft goals for implementation in the SDC but that no classroom goals were ever written. MOTHER testified that, at the initial IEP for STUDENT’s twin brother, the District had stated that it would later add goals for implementation in the SDC. MOTHER testified that she assumed that the same would be done for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer notes that the placements offered for STUDENT and his brother were similar, both involved placement in the County autism clinic and Ms. Seibert’s SDC. However, it is uncontested that development of additional classroom goals was never discussed or even mentioned at STUDENT’s IEP. STUDENT’s goals were discussed at the August 2003 IEP meeting in detail. After reviewing the audio tape of that IEP meeting, the Hearing Officer finds that it was clear that the only additional goals anticipated were to be in the areas of S/L and OT. Furthermore, the IEP document, by each goal, states that the goals were to be implemented in the SDC as well as in the County clinic. On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s IEP included goals for implementation in the SDC.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s IEP included appropriate annual goals and objectives that met all of his unique educational needs. The Hearing Officer also finds that, although the S/L goals lacked benchmarks or short-term objectives, STUDENT did not suffer any harm as a result of that failure. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District and County did not deny STUDENT a FAPE on this basis.

2. Intensity of the Placement Offered

Student contends that, in August 2003, he required a full-time, individual, home ABA program rather than the combination of clinic and SDC offered by the District and County. Dr. Elder testified that, on the basis of her assessment of STUDENT in October 2003, he was not yet ready to benefit from a classroom setting. Dr. Elder explained that it is her general practice in working with autistic children such as STUDENT to start them in an intensive one-to-one ABA program to teach basic skills and then move into small group instruction. However, Dr. Elder also stated that her assessment in October 2003 was not a full assessment and only focused on STUDENT’s functional skills. Further, Dr. Elder’s opinion regarding STUDENT’s skills in August 2003 are not supported by the results of the District’s and County’s assessment. As set forth earlier in this Decision, it is undisputed that STUDENT had emerging skills in many areas, including imitation, receptive instructions, social awareness of adults, attention to task. It was noted during STUDENT’s August 2003 IEP meeting that he had a surprising number of skills for a child who had not previously been in any program. The County’s assessment, which was agreed to be a very accurate assessment of STUDENT’s abilities, recommended a combination of direct, individual ABA-based instruction, and small group instruction to develop social skills and reinforce and expand on pre-academic skills. Ms. Seibert testified that her SDC is a very small, structured setting with a high teacher-to-student ratio. The SDC had only four to nine students during the 2003-2004 regular school year, and the staff included Ms. Seibert and two para-educators. In addition, Ms. Yamashita was in the classroom assisting with instruction on a daily basis. STUDENT’s August 2003 IEP team, which included Ms. Christison, Mr. Chesnut, and Ms. Seibert, all of whom had extensive experience in working with autistic children, concluded that STUDENT’s level of skill development indicated that he was ready to benefit from placement in an SDC. They credibly testified that small group instruction in an SDC setting allowed STUDENT to develop his social skills, play skills, and to aide in generalizing the skills he learned in the clinic setting into a more functional setting.

The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Seibert, Mr. Chesnut, and Ms. Yamashita persuasive. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT required small group instruction in order to learn social skills, peer interaction skills, and peer play skills. Dr. Elder’s opinion regarding starting STUDENT exclusivey in an intensive one-to-one ABA program was based upon her typical practice in providing programs for autistic children, not upon STUDENT’s unique needs or his level of skill development. The Hearing Officer also notes that development of social skills and play skills were primary areas of concern for MOTHER in August 2003. The IEP team recommended small group instruction to address these skills. On review of Dr. Elder’s description of the home program provided to STUDENT by TP during the 2003-2004 regular school year, the Hearing Officer finds that, had STUDENT been placed exclusively in a one-to-one home ABA program, he would have had little opportunity for any peer interactions. Furthermore, on the basis of the testimony of Ms. Seibert, Mr. Chesnut, and Ms. Christison, the Hearing Office finds that STUDENT’s emerging skills, in particular his skills in the areas of imitation, receptive instructions, social awareness, and attention to task, established that placement in an SDC was appropriate to meet his needs in the areas of social skills and play skills and to reinforce and expand on the skills STUDENT was taught in the clinic setting.

3. Opportunities for Peer Interaction in the SDC

Student contends that the offer of placement in the SDC was not designed to meet his unique needs because it did not offer him any opportunities to learn social skills or appropriate peer interaction skills. MOTHER testified that when she observed STUDENT in the SDC she never observed any facilitated peer interaction or “teaching” of social skills. MOTHER discussed her concerns with Dr. Elder, though not with Ms. Seibert or District or County staff. Dr. Elder observed STUDENT’s SDC on one day in February 2004, and reported to MOTHER that STUDENT was more advanced than the other students and appeared bored. Dr. Elder told MOTHER that she did not observe any facilitated peer interactions or peer play. She described the SDC in relation to STUDENT as “very sad.”

As set forth above, Ms. Seibert testified that, during the 2003-2004 regular school year, her SDC had between four and nine children enrolled. Staff consisted of herself and two para-educators. In addition Ms. Yamashita and Ms. Parnall (formerly Ms. Howie), the OT, were both in the class assisting with instruction at various times. In contrast to the testimony of MOTHER and Dr. Elder, Ms. Seibert stated STUDENT was not the most advanced student in her classroom. She also testified that social skills and peer play/peer interaction were regularly addressed in her class. By example, either she or one of the aides would frequently facilitate peer interactions in the context of games and outside play. In addition social greetings and asking questions were often targeted. Play was facilitated every day in some capacity. Ms. Yamashita was also present in the classroom almost every day. She stated that she regularly worked with STUDENT on his expressive, receptive and pragmatic language goals in the classroom setting. She also stated that she consulted with Ms. Seibert and assisted the classroom staff throughout the year on any issues or activities that were speech/language related.

After considering the evidence as a whole, the Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Seibert and Ms. Yamashita credible and persuasive. Their testimony was consistent, and is further corroborated by the fact that STUDENT made progress in both his social skills and peer play skills during the time he was enrolled in the SDC. Furthermore, MOTHER only observed the class for a brief time at the beginning of each class and Dr. Elder only observed the class on one day. On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer of placement in the SDC provided STUDENT with opportunities to learn and practice social skills, play skills, and peer interactions skills. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of placement in the SDC was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

4. Appropriateness of the Clinic ABA Program

Student contends that the County clinic program was not designed to meet his unique needs because it utilized and different teaching methodology than was used in the home program, the program did not utilize appropriate data collection or record keeping, lack of adequate supervision, and the clinic staff was not properly qualified or trained.

a. Teaching Methodology

Dr. Elder testified that, on the basis of her observation of the County’s clinic program and her review of the clinic data binder, the County clinic was utilizing a different technique in providing discrete trial training. She stated that the clinic was using a method that allowed STUDENT to provide an incorrect response before providing a prompt. She explained that, in the home program, TP used a method known as “errorless learning,” which provides immediate prompts to prevent STUDENT having the opportunity to give an incorrect response. She stated that, in her opinion, the use of the different techniques in the different settings had the potential to be confusing and frustrating for STUDENT.

Mr. Chesnut, a former behavior analyst for the County and Ms. Christison’s supervisor during the 2003-2004 school year, testified that a child such as STUDENT can benefit from DTT delivered in different manners and different environments. Mr. Chesnut testified that his experience included a master’s degree in special education, and experience as both a classroom teacher, behavior analyst, and as the executive director of Applied Behavior Consultants, a nonpublic agency that provides home programs and other services to autistic children. He explained that, in his experience, the manner of delivery of DTT depended on the child’s individual needs and skill levels. He went on to state that learning certain skills might require a variety of techniques. He also stated that the ultimate goal of DTT is for the student to be able to generalize the skills into different environments. Ms. Christison also testified regarding the importance of generalization, and stated that variety is necessary for generalization. She testified that it was her practice to vary the teaching techniques the clinic used with STUDENT as part of a trouble shooting process when STUDENT had trouble learning a particular skill. The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Mr. Chesnut and Ms. Christison credible.

The Hearing Officer finds that evidence does not support Dr. Elder’s belief that use of different techniques in the home program and at the County clinic was confusing and frustrating for STUDENT. Although Dr. Elder had a different opinion than the County staff regarding the benefit of the use of different techniques in the two settings, the evidence established that STUDENT made substantial progress on his goals and objectives in both the home and clinic environment during the 2003-2004 school year. As set forth earlier, STUDENT had met nine of his seventeen clinic/SDC goals by May 2004 and made significant progress on the remaining goals. In addition, Dr. Elder’s data showed that STUDENT met over sixty-four percent of his home goals during the same time period. On the basis of the testimony set forth above, and the evidence as a whole, the Hearing Officer finds that the use of different teaching techniques was beneficial to STUDENT and aided in his generalization of skills to different environments. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the use of different teaching techniques in the clinic and home settings was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

b. Lack of Proper Data Collection and Record Keeping

Dr. Elder and Dr. Jill Young, the TP site director, both reviewed the data binder from STUDENT’s County clinic program and testified that the believed that data had not been collected properly and that variations in the numbers of trial and numbers of prompts was not appropriate for an ABA based DTT program. Dr. Young characterized that data collection as “glaringly inappropriate and sloppy.” Dr. Elder and Dr. Young both stated that an ABA based program must be driven by data collected and that appropriate decisions could not be made unless the data collection was done properly. They also testified that, because of the way the data was recorded, they could not look at it and tell what skills STUDENT had mastered or when.

Ms. Christison testified that she regularly reviewed the data from the DTT sessions at the County clinic and consulted with the para-educators who administered the trials. Ms. Christison also worked with STUDENT one-to-one at times. She did admit that there were a few errors in calculating the percentages on some trials, but she tried to check those figures when she reviewed the binder. However, she stated that she was able to review the data and, with consultations with the staff, determine STUDENT’s progress on each skill being worked on and determine the appropriate next step in his program. As noted earlier, Ms. Christison also stated that she would vary the number of trials depending on the skills being worked on, and as a means of troubleshooting problem areas. She stated that the clinic staff collected data on any skill they worked on. Mr. Chesnut also testified that it was his practice to review each student’s data binder and recalled nothing inappropriate in STUDENT’s binder.

Dr. Elder and Dr. Young testified at length regarding the difference between the way that the County clinic kept data and the way TP kept data. However, there was no evidence that the differences in forms used, variations in the numbers of trials, or isolated errors had any impact on the effectiveness of the County’s clinic program. Ms. Christison testified credibly that she was able to accurately monitor STUDENT’s progress through use of the data, staff consultation, and personal observation. In fact, as stated earlier in this Decision, STUDENT did make progress on all of his goals and objectives. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT’s IEP did not require the measuring of progress by data collection. STUDENT’s progress was to be measured by observation by staff and teacher. On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the County’s method of data collection did not render STUDENT’s clinic program inappropriate.

c. Inadequate Supervision

Student contends that the eight hours a month of supervision offered by the County was not adequate. Student argues that he needed thirty hours a month of supervision combined with an additional ten hours a month of program development similar to what was provided by TP in relation to his home program. Dr. Elder testified that she believed that the forty hours a month of supervision and program development provided in TP’s program was necessary to provid STUDENT with an appropriate program.

Ms. Christison credibly testified that, within the eight hours a month of supervision, she provided one and one-half hours a week of staff meetings, held with the child present, one hour a month of classroom observation, and one hour a month of consultation with other providers such as Ms. Yamashita and Ms. Parnall. Ms. Christison also met with her supervisor, Mr. Chesnut, on a weekly basis and attended progress meetings, IEP meetings, and one Alta meeting regarding STUDENT’s program. She stated that, in her opinion, the eight hours a month of supervision was adequate for STUDENT’s clinic program. Although Dr. Elder testified that TP provided a far greater amount of supervision hours each month, there was no evidence that the additional hours were necessary to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

The Hearing Officer finds that the forty hours a month provided by TP was not necessary to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, but was simply the standard amount of time offered by TP to its home program clients. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer finds that, on the basis of Ms. Christison’s testimony, the eight hours a month of supervision provided by the County was adequate to meet STUDENT’s needs.

d. Staff Qualifications and Training

Student contends that the County clinic staff was not properly qualified or trained to provide an ABA program to him. However, Ms. Christison testified that she has a bachelor’s degree in psychology and certificate in applied behavior analysis from Sacramento State University. Her resume also listed numerous professional trainings related to treating children with autism, including trainings in neurodevelopmental disorders, ABA, professional assault response training, and PECS. Prior to being employed by the County she worked for Applied Behavior Consultants for over two years as a behavior consultant, tutor, and lead tutor providing in-home ABA programs to autistic children.

Mr. Chesnut testified that his experience included a master’s degrees in special education, and experience as both a classroom teacher, behavior analyst, and as the executive director of Applied Behavior Consultants, a nonpublic agency that provides home programs and other services to autistic children.

Ms. Christison also testified that clinic para-educators received four hours of general training in ABA techniques and DTT. Both of STUDENT’s primary para-educators had one to two years of experience working with autistic children at the County clinic and had received additional in-service trainings in ABA techniques, including PECS. STUDENT also had one long-term substitute aide whom Ms. Christison personally trained in the weekly team meetings and with additional hands-on training. Ms. Christison stated that she spent additional time with the substitute beyond what was required in STUDENT’s IEP.

Student, while contending gernally that the clinic staff was not properly qualified, presented no testimony or documentary evidence regarding what specific qualifications the clinic staff was lacking. On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the clinic staff was properly qualified and trained to provide STUDENT’s ABA program. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the County clinic program was not deficient on this basis.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the County’s clinic program utilized appropriate teaching methodologies, had appropriate data collection and record keeping, provided an appropriate amount of supervision, and the staff was properly qualified and trained. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the County clinic program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

5. Delay in Providing OT Services

Student contends that the OT services were not commenced in a timely manner. Specifically, the OT assessment was completed on August 13, 2003, but OT services were not added to STUDENT’s IEP until December 17, 2003, four months later. MOTHER testified that she was told that the delay was due to difficulty in hiring an OT to provide services to STUDENT.

Ms. Parnall, STUDENT’s OT during the 2003-2004 school year, and Ms. Seibert testified that, although addition of OT services to STUDENT’s IEP was delayed until December, STUDENT’s OT needs were being addressed. Ms. Seibert testified that she consulted with a District OT in setting up OT related activities, including sensory diet exercises, in her SDC as part of the regular routine for the entire class. In addition, Ms. Parnall testified that she actually began providing STUDENT with individual OT services, with MOTHER ’s consent, on October 28, 2003, on the basis of the August 2003 OT assessment and goals and objectives proposed that assessment. Ms. Parnall’s testimony is corroborated by STUDENT’s December 2003 IEP, which indicates that individual OT services were already being provided at the time of the IEP meeting with the permission of STUDENT’s parents.

MOTHER consented to completion of an OT assessment on June 6, 2003, just prior to the conclusion of the 2002-2003 regular school year. The 2003-2004 school year began on August 27, 2003. On the basis of the timeline set forth in California Education Code section, 56043, the District had until September 27, 2003, to convene an IEP meeting to review the OT assessment and add services if necessary. Although the assessment was completed in a timely manner, individual OT services were not actually begun until October 28, 2003, a delay of four weeks. On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s IEP was not designed to meet his unique needs to the extent that OT services were not started until October 28, and not formally added to his IEP until December 17, 2003. Even though STUDENT was receiving OT related services as a regular part of his SDC, it is undisputed that he required individual OT services to meet his unique needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2003-2004 regular school year to the extent that he did receive individual OT services until October 28, 2003, a delay of one month.

4. Qualifications of the S/L Pathologist

Student contends that Ms. Yamashita was not qualified to provide his S/L services. Ms. Yamashita testified that she has a bachelor’s and master’s degree in speech pathology. She is also a State licensed speech pathologist. She stated that she has been employed as a speech/language pathologist since 1989 and has been working with the District for three years. Since 2001, Ms. Yamashita has attended over twenty professional trainings, most related to providing services to children with autism. In her career she has assessed and provided services to over one hundred and fifty children, approximately twenty of whom have been autistic. Ms. Yamashita also testified to knowledge of different techniques for providing S/L services to autistic children. The only evidence that Ms. Yamashita was not properly qualified to provide services to STUDENT was her failure to include benchmarks or short-term objectives in her original goals for STUDENT. Although this was not an appropriate method for drafting goals and objectives, it has already been found that STUDENT did not suffer any harm as a result of this defect.

After considering Ms. Yamashita’s education and considerable experience as a speech pathologist, as well as her specific training and experience in working with autistic children, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Yamashita was properly qualified and trained to provide S/L services to STUDENT. Therefore, the District’s offer of S/L services was not deficient on this basis.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that Respondents’ program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs except to the extent that the District failed to provide STUDENT with individual OT services for the time period from September 27 to October 28, 2003, a period of four weeks.

Was the District’s and County’s Offer Reasonably Calculated to Provide STUDENT With Some Educational Benefit?

To be appropriate under the IDEA, the District’s and County’s offer must have been reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 200. As discussed above, the offer consisted of nine hours a week of one-to-one ABA services in the County autism clinic, six hours a week in the District’s preschool SDC, eight hours a month of supervision/consultation, and DIS in S/L and OT services. Goals and objectives were developed in the areas of behavior, self help, play skills, fine motor, receptive language, visual performance, imitation skills, matching skills, expressive language, math readiness, reading readiness, functional communication, and social/play skills, pragmatics, and occupational therapy. The Hearing Officer has previously found that the District and County identified all of STUDENT’s unique needs, drafted appropriate goals and objectives, and offered placement and services that were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

On the basis of the evidence discussed above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s and County’s offer was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement and services offered did provide him with educational benefit. Ms. Christison, Ms. Seibert, Ms. Yamashita, and Ms. Parnall all persuasively testified that STUDENT made progress during the 2003-2004 regular school year on all of his goals and objectives. By May 2004, STUDENT had met over half of his annual goals and had made significant progress on the remaining. Ms. Seibert and Ms. Yamashita testified that, in the classroom setting, they had observed improvement in the areas of behavior, vocalizations, vocabulary academics, attention, social skills, and play skills. Ms. Christison testified that STUDENT had acquired a large number of basic skills through the clinic program, and by the end of the year was working on generalizing those skills into functional settings and combining the skills through a process the clinic referred to as “bridging concepts.” Ms. Parnall testified that STUDENT also made progress on all of his OT goals. She stated that he demonstrated improved tolerance to sensory input, improved balance, and improved fine motor skills. The Hearing Officer finds these witnesses credible because of the extensive work with STUDENT, and their collaboration with each other during the school year. On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s and County’s offer for the 2003-2004 regular school year was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.

Did the District’s and County’s Program Conform to his IEP?

To be appropriate under the IDEA, the program provided by the District and County during the 2003-2004 regular school year must have conformed with what was offered in STUDENT’s IEP. Student contends that the program provided did not conform with his IEP for three reasons: (1) the consultation between District and County staff members did not occur as frequently as offered; (2) the promised collaboration with the home program did not occur; and (3) OT and S/L services were discontinued without parent consent in April 2004.

1. Lack of Consultation Between District and County Staff

Student contends that the behavior consultation services to be provided by the clinic staff did not occur. Student bases this contention on a lack of notes documenting each team meeting and staff consultation.

STUDENT’s IEPs offered eight hours a month of behavior consultation plus one hour a month of consultation from both the S/L pathologist and OT. Ms. Christison was to provide the eights hours of behavior consultation through regular meetings with clinic and District staff. As stated earlier, Ms. Christison testified to holding weekly team meetings with the para-educators that lasted an average of one and one-half hours, weekly meetings with Mr. Chesnut, monthly one-hour observations of and consultation with Ms. Seibert in the SDC, and monthly one-hour collaboration meetings with District and County staff. Ms. Christison testified that all of these meetings and consultations occurred throughout the year. Ms. Seibert testified that Ms. Christison observed her class at least once a month, and that both Ms. Yamashita and Ms. Parnall were in her class every week, and consulted specifically about STUDENT on a weekly basis. Ms. Seibert also stated that she spent additional time communicating with and collaborating with the clinic aides regarding STUDENT’s goals and activities. Ms. Yamashita testified that she worked with Ms. Seibert on a daily basis. She stated that she also consulted with Ms. Christison and Ms. Parnall approximately once a week. Ms. Parnall further corroborated the testimony of Ms. Christison, Ms. Seibert, and Ms. Yamashita. Because of these witnesses extensive contact with STUDENT, and the consistency of their testimony regarding the ongoing collaboration, the Hearing Officer finds their testimony credible. The Hearing Officer does not find that the lack of contemporaneous notes documenting each collaboration detracts from the credibility of the witnesses. On the basis of the foregoing, and after totaling the hours of consultation and collaboration testified to by the District and County witnessed, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT received at least ten hours a month of behavior consultation and other collaborative services as offered in his IEPs.

2. Collaboration with the Home Program

Student contends that the District and County failed to provide the promised collaboration with his home program providers. The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT’s IEP contained no specific offer regarding collaboration with the home program, nor was this issue specifically discussed at STUDENT’s IEP meeting. However, the evidenced established that there was adequate communication between the TP staff and District and County staff. Ms. Christison testified that she attended STUDENT’s IPP meeting (the Regional Center equivalent of an IEP meeting) where a home program was offered. In addition, in November 2003, Ms. Christison met with Dr. Elder and discussed strategies during Dr. Elder’s observation of STUDENT’s clinic program. Dr. Elder also attended STUDENT’s quarterly review meeting held in November 2003, and attended the series of IEP meetings held in April and May, and STUDENT’s annual IEP meetings in June. In addition, Dr. Elder observed STUDENT’s SDC in February. Ms. Christison also stated that she had been provided with a copy of TP goals for STUDENT’s home program. These facts are undisputed.

On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that, although there was no formal requirement in STUDENT’s IEP for any collaboration with his home program providers, there was ongoing collaboration and communication between the District and County staff and the TP staff providing STUDENT’s home program. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District and County did not deny STUDENT a FAPE on this basis.

3. Discontinuation of OT and S/L services

It is undisputed that STUDENT’s OT and S/L services were discontinued in April 2004. Student contends that this was done without the consent of his parents. The District contends that MOTHER withdrew her consent for those services.

Ms. Seibert testified that, in March 2004, MOTHER informed her that she was removing STUDENT from Ms. Seibert’s SDC. At that time, Ms. Seibert asked MOTHER whether she wished to continue with the OT and S/L services. Ms. Seibert testified that MOTHER stated that the S/L services would be dealt with by TP in the home program, but that she was not sure about the OT services. Ms. Seibert encouraged MOTHER to contact Ms. Yamashita and Ms. Parnall directly if she wished services to continue. It is undisputed that MOTHER never contacted either therapist, nor did she contact anyone else at the District, about continuing S/L and OT services. The Hearing Officer notes that both the individual S/L and OT services were provided during the time STUDENT was in the SDC. The group S/L session were actually conducted in the SDC. Therefore, once STUDENT was removed from the SDC, he was no longer attending school during the times that S/L and OT had previously been provided. In addition, Ms. Yamashita and Ms. Parnall both testified that Ms. Seibert told her that STUDENT would not be continuing with either S/L or OT services because the home program would be providing them. Similarly, Ms. Clumpner, the District coordinator of special education during the 2003-2004 school year, testified that Ms. Seibert informed her that MOTHER did not want STUDENT to continue in either S/L or OT. On April 12, 2004, MOTHER informed the District in writing that, effective April 14, 2004, she was removing STUDENT from Ms. Seibert’s SDC. The letter made no mention of either S/L or OT services. Both services were discontinued at the time STUDENT was removed from the SDC.

A series of three IEP meetings were held on April 19, April 24 and May 14, 2004, to discuss the PARENT’S reasons for removing STUDENT and his brother from Ms. Siebert’s SDC. STUDENT’s annual IEP was held on June 1 and June 15, 2004. The evidence established that, at no time during any of these five IEP meetings, did the PARENT’S ever object to the fact that S/L and OT services were no longer being provided. Furthermore, as part of the April, May IEP meetings, the PARENT’S drafted and submitted a three page “Parent Addendum to IEP” dated April 24, 2004. Though listing the parents’ concerns in detail, at no point does this document refer to the discontinuation of S/L and OT services.

After reviewing the testimony and the evidence as a whole, the Hearing Officer finds that MOTHER essentially withdrew her consent for both the OT and S/L services at the time she removed STUDENT from the SDC. MOTHER was asked specifically about continuing those services by Ms. Seibert, and was instructed to contact either Ms. Yamashita or Ms. Parnall if she wished services to continue and chose not to. In addition, at the five IEP meetings that followed, the PARENT’S had ample opportunity to object to the discontinuation of S/L and OT or to ask for the services to be resumed and again chose not to. Finally, MOTHER took the time to draft a three-page statement of her concerns, and did not list the stopping of the S/L or OT services among them. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE on this basis.

Was the offer of placement in the least restrictive environment?

This was not raised as an issue for the 2003-2004 regular school year.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District and County offered and provided STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2003-2004 regular school year except to the extent that the District failed to provide individual OT services to STUDENT during the time period from September 27 to October 28, 2003.

2. Did the District and County offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education for the 2004 extended school year and the 2004-2005 school year?

At the IEP meetings convened on June 1 and 15, 2004, STUDENT’s IEP team discussed STUDENT’s program for the 2004 ESY and for the 2004-2005 school year. Assessments were reviewed, goals and objectives drafted, and the District and County presented their offers of placement and services. STUDENT contends that the District and County failed to offer him a FAPE for either the 2004 ESY or 2004-2005 school year on the basis of both procedural and substantive violations of the IDEA

Procedural Violations

Student contends that the District’s and County’s offer for 2004 ESY and 2004-2005 school year was not appropriate because the District and County continued to fail to offer him a continuum of services, and continued to deny his parents the opportunity for meaningful participation in the IEP process.

Did the District and County Fail to Offer a Continuum of Services?

Student contends that the District and County did not consider any option other than the program they offered. A review of the June 2004 IEP document and the testimony of the witnesses in general established that, at IEP meeting, the District and County staff reviewed the results of STUDENT’s assessments as well as progress reports from the 2003-2004 school year. The IEP team discussed STUDENT’s unique needs. It was also discussed that STUDENT would be ready for a general education placement in the fall of 2004, and that steps needed to be taken during the summer to begin that transition. The transition was to continue in the fall with a combined placement that included the County clinic, Ms. Seibert’s SDC, and placement in the State preschool with clinic aide support. The IEP documents establish that options considered included a general education placement, DIS services, a full-time clinic or home program, and an SDC placement. MOTHER testified that she did not raise any concerns regarding the ESY offer or the placement in the SDC or County clinic. She did raise concerns regarding the State preschool and her desire that STUDENT have access to typically developing peers. Testimony and the IEP notes establish that her concerns were discussed by the IEP team.

On the basis of the foregoing evidence, including testimony by MOTHER , District and County staff, and the IEP notes, the Hearing Officer finds that the District and County did consider a wide variety program options at the June 1 and June 15, 2004 IEP meetings. Furthermore, as noted earlier in this Decision, the Respondents were not required to actually offer the full continuum of placement options to STUDENT, only to have a full continuum of options available. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District and County did not commit any procedural violation on this basis.

Were the PARENT’S Denied Meaningful Participation in the IEP Process?

Student contends that the District and County continued to deny his parents meaningful participation in the IEP process because the District and County did not consider their input. The District and County witnesses testified that, at STUDENT’s annual IEP meetings in June 2004, the assessments were reviewed in detail, STUDENT’s strengths and weakness were discussed, the parents’ concerns were discussed, and proposed goals and objectives were reviewed. As with the IEP meetings in April and May, Dr. Young and Dr. Elder were present at the June IEP meetings at the PARENT’S request. Ms. Clumpner testified that, for the 2004-2005 school year a monthly parent consultation meeting was added to STUDENT’s program to address MOTHER’s previously expressed concerns regarding her communication with District and County staff. In addition, Ms. Yamashita testified that she recommended an increase in STUDENT’s S/L services for the 2004-2005 school year, in part, because MOTHER had requested an increase in STUDENT’s S/L services. MOTHER stated that she did not raise any concerns because she did not feel that the District or County were willing to consider her concerns.

The evidence as a whole establishes the parents were active members of the IEP team. They were presented with updated information regarding STUDENT’s program, and afforded the opportunity to present and discuss each of their concerns. The District and County members of the IEP team addressed each of the parents’ concerns at the June IEP meetings, and made changes to initial recommendations on the basis of the parents’ concerns. On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District and County did consider the PARENT’S input and allow them to participate in the development of the program. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District and County did not commit a procedural violation on this basis.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District and County did not deny STUDENT a FAPE during the 2004 ESY or 2004-2005 school year on the basis of any procedural violations of the IDEA.

Substantive Violations

Was the District’s and County’s Offer Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?

The first step is to determine what STUDENT’s unique needs were in June 2004. In preparation for STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting, the District and County reassessed STUDENT in the areas of pre-academics, intellectual ability, social/emotion functioning, behavior, fine/gross motor ability, and speech/language development. The results of these assessments indicated that STUDENT had made progress in all areas during the 2003-2004 regular school year, but that he still had significant deficits in many areas.

Ms. Christison’s assessment noted that STUDENT had made progress in the areas of functional communication, expressive and receptive language, pre-academics, fine skills, sensory processing, and fine motor skills. She stated that STUDENT was using vocalizations on a consistent basis to get his needs met. He had also mastered many identification skills in the clinic setting, including identification of objects by function, shape, and color. He had also progressed in number and letter identification, identification of body parts, and identification of community helpers. By June he was working on generalizing these skills into functional environments, and combining the skills through bridging concepts. STUDENT had also made progress in the areas of prepositions and social questions. Regarding pre-academics, STUDENT was working on matching and sorting by category, in generalizing non-verbal imitation skills into functional environments. Regarding play skills, STUDENT was working on twenty-five piece puzzles, and independent play with various objects. STUDENT had also demonstrated the ability to engage in functional turn taking. STUDENT was also able to cut out objects on paper. Ms. Christison’s report noted that the clinic was working on combining skills involving labeling, identification, counting, imitation, social questions, turn taking, and receptive instructions.

Ms. Parnall reported that STUDENT was better able to tolerate sensory diet activities including joint compression and brushing. She also stated that STUDENT had made significant progress in his fine motor skills, some having reached an age appropriate level. She noted continued delays in the areas of gross motor skills, and fine/gross motor coordination.

Ms. Yamashita found that STUDENT had achieved expressive and receptive vocabulary scores within the normal range. However, she concluded that STUDENT still had deficits in the areas of syntax, semantics, and pragmatics.

The behavior assessment found that STUDENT was able to take turns, respond appropriately to instructions, and greet adults. He was observed to engage in parallel play and displayed some skills in the areas of interactive play and symbolic play. STUDENT was also able to transition between activities and environments, and responded well to prompting. It was concluded that STUDENT continued to have deficits in the areas of social skills and self-help skills.

Following a review of the assessments, and obtaining input from STUDENT’s parents, the IEP team found that STUDENT continued to have deficits in the areas of functional communication, social skills, expressive and receptive language skills, pragmatics, play skills, pre-academics, sensory processing, and fine and gross motor skills.

As a result of these deficits, the IEP team concluded that STUDENT needed individual instruction using ABA techniques to teach basic skills, small group instruction to work on social skills, play skills, and generalization of skills into a functional environment, and placement in a general education pre-school class to allow STUDENT access to typically developing peers in a structured setting. Dr. Elder testified that TP had also identified skill deficits in these same areas through their work with STUDENT in the home program. She also stated that she agreed that STUDENT needed a combination of individual ABA-based instruction and small group instruction that included access to typically developing peers.

Following a review of the evidence as a whole, including the District’s and County’s assessments, and the testimony of Ms. Christison, Ms. Seibert, Ms. Parnall, Ms. Yamashita, MOTHER , and Dr. Elder, the Hearing Officer finds that the District and County accurately identified STUDENT’s areas of deficit, as a result of which STUDENT needed a combination of individual and small group instruction and placement in a general education pre-school classroom to allow STUDENT access to typically developing peers.

The next question is whether the District’s and County’s offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. For the 2004 ESY, the program consisted of placement in the District’s summer SDC with four hours a week of shadow aide support provided by the County Clinic. ESY also included nine hours a week of the County clinic program and ongoing S/L and OT services. Beginning in the fall of 2004, STUDENT would transition into five hours a day in the Ms. Seibert’s SDC, four hours a week in the State preschool with shadow aide support, six hours a week in the County clinic program, and ongoing S/L and OT services. In addition, the District and County offered seven hours a month of behavior consultation by the County clinic staff and one forty-five minute meeting each month between STUDENT’s parents and District and County staff. During the 2004-2005 school year, Alta has continued to fund approximately fifteen hours a week of an in-home ABA program provided by TP. Since July 2004, the PARENT’S have funded an additional fifteen to twenty hours of in-home ABA services provided by TP. Student contends that the District’s and County’s offers were not designed to meet his unique needs for four reasons: (1) the goals and objectives were not appropriate; (2) the programs were not intensive enough; (3) the State preschool placement was not appropriate; (4) and the proposed S/L therapist was not properly trained or qualified. Other than the contention regarding the S/L therapist’s qualifications, there was no dispute regarding the offer of OT and S/L services.

1. Appropriate Goals and Objectives

The IEP team drafted seventeen goals and objectives in the areas of expressive language, receptive language, pragmatic language, functional communication, gross motor skills, sensory processing, sound/symbol association, interactive play, pre-math skills, social skills, and self-help. Student contends that these goals were not appropriate because they underestimated what he could accomplish in one year, and they failed to adequately address his deficits in the areas of communication, social skills, play skills, and behavior.

a. Goals and Objectives Were Underestimates

Dr. Elder testified that, in preparation for the due process hearing, she compared the District’s and County’s goals and objectives to those she had drafted for STUDENT in his home program. She stated that she found that she had consistently estimated that STUDENT would achieve similar goals months ahead of the target dates in the District’s and County’s goals. She stated that, on the basis of this review, and the progress she had seen in STUDENT over the summer and fall of 2004, she concluded that the District’s and County’s goals were underestimates of what STUDENT could accomplish in one year. Ms. Christison, Ms. Seibert, Ms. Parnall, and Ms. Yamashita all persuasively testified that, on the basis of their experience in working with STUDENT and the assessments performed in May 2004, they believed that the District’s and County’s goals did not underestimate STUDENT’s abilities.

As set forth earlier, the District’s and County’s offer must be judged based upon the information available to the District and County at the time that the offer was made. See Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999). The Hearing Officer notes that Dr. Elder compared the District and County goals and objectives with the goals she had drafted approximately five months after STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting. During that time, STUDENT had been in a thirty to forty-hour a week home ABA program provided by TP. Considering STUDENT’s progress during the 2003-2004 regular school year, it is to be expected that he would have continued to make significant progress in all areas. The Hearing Officer cannot judge the District’s and County’s estimates of STUDENT’s abilities in hindsight. After considering the evidence available to the District and County in June 2004, the Hearing Officer finds that the District and County goals and objectives were reasonable estimates of what STUDENT could accomplish in one year. The District and County staff who drafted the goals and objectives had extensive experience in working with STUDENT during the past school year, and had completed additional assessments of him. On the basis of their experience and updated assessments, the District and County staff had accurately identified STUDENT’s strengths and weaknesses and his present levels of functioning. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was not denied a FAPE on this basis.

b. Goals and Objectives Failed to Address All Areas of Need Dr. Elder testified at length regarding the appropriateness of the District and County goals and objectives. She stated that, in general, the goals failed to adequately address STUDENT’s deficits in the areas of social skills and play skills. She noted that the TP goals were more detailed and extensive in the areas of social questions, pragmatics, sequencing skills, play skills and social skills. She noted that the District and County did not have any goal to address implied meanings. In conclusion, she stated that the TP goals were more involved and comprehensive than the District and County goals.

Upon a review of the goals and objectives proposed by the District and County, the Hearing Officer finds that they did contain measurable goals and objectives in the areas of expressive and receptive language, social skills, pragmatic language skills, functional communication skills, peer play, and behavior. In fact, STUDENT had multiple goals in each of these areas. As stated regarding the 2003-2004 regular school year goals and objectives, there is no requirement that a district draft goals to address each and every discrete skill a student may need improvement in. The educational agency is only required to develop annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, to meet the child’s needs that result from his disability and enable the child to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. On the basis of the foregoing analysis, the Hearing Officer finds that the District and County did propose goals and objectives that meet STUDENT’s needs that resulted from his disability, including his deficits in the areas of communication, social skills, play skills, and behavior. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was not denied a FAPE on this basis.

2. Intensity of the Placement Offered

Student agrees that his program for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year needed to include placement in a general education classroom; however, as with the 2003-2004 regular school year, Student contends that the remainder of his program should have consisted of an intensive ABA in-home program similar to what had been provided by TP. Student argues that the combination of the County clinic and District SDC would not meet his educational needs for the same reasons as had been raised for the 2003-2004 regular school year.

The Hearing Officer notes that, during the 2003-2004 regular school year, STUDENT made substantial progress in all areas with the combination of SDC, County clinic, and home program. Furthermore, STUDENT made more progress on his home program goals during the time period in which he was in all three placements, having met 64% of his home program goals, when compared to his progress after he had been removed from the SDC in April, only having met 36.9% of his home program goals between April and July 2004. Furthermore, the assessments performed in May 2004 found that STUDENT had mastered a wide variety of skills, and was working on generalizing those skills into different environments. As testified to by Ms. Seibert and Ms. Christison, one of the primary purposes of the SDC placement was to provide STUDENT a controlled environment in which he could learn to generalize the basic skills he had learned in the clinic setting. Ms. Seibert’s SDC during the 2004-2005 regular school year closely resembled her class during the previous year, having a low student-teacher ratio and a great deal of structure. In addition, MOTHER testified that her concerns for the 2004-2005 school year continued to focus on STUDENT’s social skills and peer play skills. The Hearing Officer notes that both the clinic and home program settings involve one-to-one instruction with few opportunities for peer interactions. In contrast, Ms. Seibert testified that her SDC provided STUDENT with a highly structured, controlled environment with numerous opportunities to work on his social skills and peer play skills under the close supervision of herself and her staff. On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT continued to require an SDC placement as part of his program for the 2004-2005 regular school year to provide him with greater opportunities for generalization of his skills in a controlled environment, and to further develop his social skills and peer play skills. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was not denied a FAPE on this basis.

3. State Preschool Placement

Student, while agreeing that he required placement in a general education preschool class as part of his program for the 2004-2005 school year, contends that the offer of placement at the State preschool was not appropriate. Specifically, Student contends that the use of other languages in the classroom would be inappropriate for a student with emerging language skills such as himself. Student also contended that the State preschool setting would not provide him with access to typically developing peers.

Dr. Elder stated that she had had the opportunity to visit the State preschool classroom in April 2004, and she observed that, during circle time, songs were sung in several languages other than English, including Chinese and Spanish. Dr. Elder also observed that one student was spoken to in Spanish by one of the classroom aides. In addition, a portion of the calendar activity involved languages other than English. Dr. Elder testified that, in her opinion, exposure to other languages in the preschool classroom could be confusing of a child such as STUDENT with only beginning language skills, and could delay STUDENT’s acquisition of English. She stated that her opinion was based upon her general experience working with autistic children.

Ms. Clumpner had also observed the State preschool on four or five different days during the 2003-2004 school year to evaluate it as a possible placement for District special education students. She stated that she did observe the use of different languages during circle time and during the calendar activity, but that, in her experience, exposure to different languages was a common part of a typical preschool setting. She stated that all actual instruction was performed in English. Ms. Clumpner testified that, in addition to a bachelor’s degree in psychology, a master’s degree in child development, and a current California credential in pupil services, and five years of experience as coordinator of special education for the District, she also has experience as a bilingual speech pathologist. She stated that she had reviewed research on the benefits of bilingual learning in a child’s cognitive development and that she was not aware of any researched the supported Dr. Elder’s opinion that exposure to other languages at the State preschool would be detrimental to STUDENT. Mr. Chesnut concurred with Ms. Clumpner, stating that, on the basis of his experience in working with autistic children, and his review of research and articles related to educating autistic children, he did not believe that exposure to different languages would be harmful to a child such as STUDENT.

Because Ms. Clumpner’s experience as a psychologist, coordinator of special education, and as a bilingual speech pathologist, and Mr. Chesnut’s credible testimony, the Hearing Officer finds their opinions persuasive. The Hearing Officer notes that Dr. Elder, while experienced in working with autistic children, is not a speech pathologist. In addition, the Hearing Officer notes that other languages were only used in a limited portion of the State preschool class, and that all actual instruction was done in English. On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the State preschool classroom was appropriate for STUDENT despite the use of several languages during circle time and during the calendar activity.

Student also contends that the State preschool would not have provided him with access to typically developing peers. However, the evidence did not support Student’s contention. Ms. Clumpner testified that the State preschool classroom is a typical preschool classroom with primarily typically developing students with an eight-to-one student to teacher ratio. She stated that only one of the current students was a special education student. Ms. Clumpner also testified that, in her observation of that class, the class routine was typical of a preschool class, involving free play, circle time, various activity stations, music, story time, snack time, and outside play. Student presented no evidence to the contrary. In addition, Ms. Siebert, who was also familiar with the State preschool classroom (the State preschool is on the same campus as Ms. Seibert’s SDC), testified that she believed it would have been an appropriate general education placement for STUDENT for the 2004-2005 school year. On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that placement at the State preschool would have provided STUDENT with appropriate access to typically developing peers. Therefore, STUDENT was not denied a FAPE on this basis.

4. Qualifications of the S/L Therapist

Student contends that Ms. Yamashita lacked the proper qualifications and training to provide his S/L therapy during the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year. The Hearing Officer has already found that Ms. Yamashita was properly qualified to provide STUDENT’s S/L services during the 2003-2004 regular school year. There was no evidence that STUDENT’s speech and language needs had changed such that Ms. Yamashita would no longer have been qualified to provide him this services. Therefore, on the basis of the Hearing Officer’s previous finding regarding Ms. Yamashita’s qualifications, the Hearing Officer finds that she continued to be qualified to provide STUDENT with S/L services during the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that District’s and County’s offer for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

Was the District’s and County’s Offer Reasonably Calculated to Provide STUDENT With Some Educational Benefit?

As discussed above, the Hearing Officer has found that the District and County identified all of STUDENT’s unique needs, drafted appropriate goals and objectives, and offered placement and services that were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The Hearing Officer has also found that, in a similar placement during the 2003-2004 regular school year, STUDENT made substantial progress on all of his goals and objectives. All of the District and County witnesses testified that they believed that STUDENT would have continued to make progress had he remained in the District’s and County’s program during the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year. There was no persuasive evidence to the contrary. Student’s sole argument on this issue was that he would have made more progress had he been in a full time home program during that period of time. However, as set forth previously in this Decision, a school district is not required services that maximize the child’s abilities. See Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 at 198-200. On the basis of the foregoing evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s and County’s offer for the 2004 ESY and 2004-2005 school year was also reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.

Did the District’s and County’s Program Conform to STUDENT’s IEP?

STUDENT was removed from all District and County placement and services in June 2004. Therefore, there is no issue for this time period regarding conforming to the IEP.

Was the offer of placement in the least restrictive environment?

As set forth above, a student’s placement must also be in the least restrictive environment. This means that the student must have been educated and allowed to participate in school activities with nondisabled students to the maximum extent appropriate. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A). Student’s only contention regarding the least restrictive environment was that the State preschool was not a general education placement and would not have provided access to typically developing peers. This contention has already been addressed in this Decision and it has already been found that placement in the State preschool classroom was an offer of placement in a general education classroom with appropriate access to typically developing peers. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s and County’s offer was in the least restrictive environment.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District and County offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year.

3. If the District and County did not offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2004-2005 school year, what is his appropriate placement for the remainder of the school year?

The Hearing Officer has already found that the District and County did offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year. Therefore, there is no need to address this issue.

4. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the District’s failure to provide him with occupational therapy and speech/language therapy?

When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(ii). Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. See, e.g., Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District, 916 F.2d 865 (3d. Cir. 1990); Miener v. State of Missouri, 800 F.2d 749 (8th Cir. 1986). Compensatory education is not a contractual remedy, but an equitable remedy, part of the Hearing Officer’s resources in crafting "appropriate relief." Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA. Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1497 (9th Cir. 1994).

Student contends that he is entitled to compensatory OT and S/L services because the District failed to provide him with those services during April, May and June, 2004. The Hearing Officer has found that the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide him with OT and S/L services during those months because MOTHER had withdrawn her consent for those services. Therefore, STUDENT is not entitled to compensatory education for those time periods. However, the Hearing Officer also found that the District did deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide STUDENT with individual OT services between September 27 and October 28, 2003. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is entitled to compensatory OT services for that failure. Although there is no entitlement to hour-for-hour compensation, because of STUDENT’s continuing deficits in the area of fine and gross motor skills, the Hearing Officer finds that hour-for-hour compensation is appropriate. The Hearing Officer found that the District failed to provide him with individual OT for four weeks during 2003. STUDENT should have been receiving sixty minutes a week of individual OT during that time.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is entitled to four hours of compensatory individual OT services. The provision of those compensatory services shall be concluded within three months of the date of this Decision.

5. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the privately funded services which Therapeutic Pathways provided from July 2004 through the present?

Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under the IDEA and replaced services that the school district failed to provide. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). However, parents are not required to have procured an exact proper placement under the IDEA in order to be entitled to reimbursement. Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education, 79 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. l986). The parents may receive reimbursement so long as their placement met the student’s unique needs and provided the student with educational benefit. Id.

In this case, the Hearing Officer has found that the District and County did not deny STUDENT a FAPE during the 2004 ESY, or the 2004-2005 school year. Therefore, his parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the privately funded services, which Therapeutic Pathways provided from July 2004 to the present.

ORDER

1. Unless the parents agree in writing otherwise, within twenty calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to determine the duration and frequency of compensatory occupational therapy services to be provided to STUDENT. The IEP team shall provide STUDENT with four hours of compensatory occupational therapy services. The compensatory occupational therapy services shall be completed within three months of the date of this Decision.

2. All of Petitioner’s remaining claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

1. Did the District and County offer and provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education for the 2003-2004 school year?

The District and County prevailed on this issue except to the extent that the District failed to provide STUDENT with individual OT services for a period of four weeks during 2003.

2. Did the District and County offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2004 extended school year and the 2004-2005 school year?

The District and County prevailed on this issue.

3. If the District and County did not offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education for the 2004-2005 school year, what is his appropriate placement for the remainder of the school year?

The District and County prevailed on this issue.

4. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the District’s failure to provide him with occupational therapy and speech/language therapy?

Student prevailed on this issue to the extent that he is entitled to compensatory education for the District’s failure to provide individual OT services for a period of four weeks in 2003. All other requests for compensatory education were denied.

5. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the privately funded services which Therapeutic Pathways provided from July 2004 through the present?

The District and County prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Dated: March 24, 2005 ____________________________________ Lawrence E. Mendel, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

MOTHER testified that the home program actually started with a reduced number of hours but built up quickly to the full fifteen hours a week.

2 The IEP, on its face, states that STUDENT was offered thirty minutes a week, but it was undisputed that he was actually offered and provided with sixty minutes a week.

3 The PARENT’S also removed STUDENT’s brother from the SDC preschool class.

4 There is a dispute regarding why S/L and OT services were discontinued, which will be dealt with in the analysis portion of this Decision.

5 The Davis Parent Nursery School is operated by the District’s adult education department.

6 The PARENT’S chose not to attend any of the general classes offered by the District.