California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 27, 2005
Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 255-05 · Hearing Officer Tracy L. Tibbals
Los Angeles Unified's assessments and middle school special day class offer upheld; requests for nonpublic school and compensatory education denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The decision refers to a prior due process case between the parties (SN04-02090), which was settled by an October 5, 2004 agreement. The Hearing Officer ruled that compliance with that agreement, including the agreed FBA, was outside the scope of this case (post-hearing order dated April 1, 2005).
Summary
A 13-year-old sixth grader eligible for special education under specific learning disability, who also has ADHD, filed for due process against Los Angeles Unified School District. He challenged the November 23, 2004 IEP. That IEP placed him in special day classes (SDC) for all academic subjects at Northridge Middle School, which made up about 87 percent of his school day. The student asked for a nonpublic school placement and compensatory education.
On assessments, the Hearing Officer found that the occupational therapy, speech and language, central auditory processing, and assistive technology assessments were all appropriate. Each was done by a qualified assessor. The assessors did not ask the parents for input directly, but the Hearing Officer held that this did not change the results or limit parent participation. The auditory processing screener properly put off further testing for one year after consulting an educational audiologist. The assistive technology assessor found the student could already access the curriculum, so equipment trials were not needed.
On FAPE, the Hearing Officer found that the small classes, aides, and accommodations met the student's reading, attention, and auditory processing needs. Teachers and Dr. Jose Gonzalez, a District administrator and educational psychologist, testified persuasively that the student was making progress. The SDC was the least restrictive environment, and no nonpublic school was needed. All relief was denied. Issues on IEE reimbursement and parent participation were withdrawn.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO judged assessments by the assessor's qualifications and the areas of suspected need, not by whether standardized tests or equipment trials were used. It also shows that assessors' failure to ask parents for input directly was not treated as a denial of FAPE when parent information was already available from other sources.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 1. Did the District fail to conduct appropriate assessments or follow through on assessments of Petitioner in the areas of occupational therapy, speech and language, central auditory processing, and assistive technology?
All four assessments were done by qualified assessors, were appropriate, and left out no area of suspected disability or needed test instrument. The assessors did not ask the parents for input directly, but this did not affect the results or deny FAPE.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. Did the District fail to offer Petitioner a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year as there was an inadequate level of services and supports and a placement that was not in the least restrictive environment appropriate to his needs?
The November 23, 2004 IEP offered special day classes with accommodations. The offer met the student's unique needs, was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, and was the least restrictive environment. No nonpublic school or counseling was required.
- Dismissed / withdrawnIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue Footnote 1(a). Reimbursement for independent educational evaluations (IEEs)
Petitioner withdrew this issue before the hearing ended.
- Dismissed / withdrawnIEP procedure
Issue Footnote 1(b). Whether the District allowed Petitioner's parent to participate meaningfully in the IEP process
Petitioner withdrew this issue before the hearing ended.
- Not reachedIEP procedure
Issue Footnote 1(c). Adequacy of the District's written offer (raised first in Petitioner's closing brief)
The Hearing Officer did not address this issue because it was not raised at the hearing and the District had no chance to respond.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Petitioner's requests for relief, including compensatory education and a nonpublic school placement, were denied.
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23; Adams v. Oregon
People named in the decision
- Lois Goorwitz, supervising psychologist, The Help Group
- Linda Steel (also called Norma Steel), private therapist; marriage and family therapist intern; witness for Student, The Help Group
- Gloria Wright, special education advocate and retired school psychologist; witness for Student (February 2005 KTEA assessment)
- Sally Blitz-Weisz, speech and language pathologist; central auditory processing screener, Los Angeles Unified School District
- James Astle, assistive technology assessor, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Niraj Jaju, contracted occupational therapist assessor, contractor to Los Angeles Unified School District
- Sofia Carias, contracted speech and language pathologist assessor, contractor to Los Angeles Unified School District
- Mario Martinez, special day class teacher (language arts and social studies), Northridge Middle School, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Sam Tgovanis, special day class teacher (math and science) and case carrier, Northridge Middle School, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Deborah Smith, behavior specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Julie Truckenmiller, educational/school psychologist, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Jose Gonzalez, special education administrator; educational psychologist, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Sandy Keaton, educational audiologist consulted on auditory processing screening, Not stated
- Cynthia Shimizu, District representative present at hearing, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Pamela Daves, attorney with Petitioner's counsel's firm (observed one day)
- Cristina Diaz, certified Spanish interpreter
- Roxanna Lopez, certified Spanish interpreter
- Maria Capurro, certified Spanish interpreter
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Tracy L. Tibbals, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, on March 1-4, 2005, in Los Angeles, California, and March 24 and 25, 2005, in Northridge, California.
Petitioner STUDENT (STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented at the hearing by attorney Heather Zakson and, for a portion of the hearing, by attorney Jean Murrell Adams. Attorney Pamela Daves, who is with the law firm representing Petitioner, observed for a day of the hearing. Also present on Petitioner’s behalf was his mother, MOTHER. Petitioner’s father, FATHER, was present for the first day of the hearing. Lois Goorwitz, supervising psychologist from The Help Group attended during the testimony of her intern, Linda Steel. Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Diane Willis. Also present representing the District was Cynthia Shimizu.
Petitioner called as witnesses, his mother; Gloria Wright, special education advocate and retired school psychologist; and Norma Steel, marriage and family therapist intern. The District called as witnesses, Sally Blitz-Weisz, speech and language pathologist; James Astle, assistive technology assessor; Niraj Jaju, occupational therapist; Sofia Carias, speech and language pathologist; Mario Martinez and Sam Tgovanis, special day class teachers; Deborah Smith, behavior specialist; Julie Truckenmiller, educational psychologist; and Jose Gonzalez, District special education administrator.
Certified interpreters Cristina Diaz, Roxanna Lopez, and Maria Capurro alternatively provided simultaneous translation of the proceedings into the Spanish language for MOTHER.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The parties argued their respective positions in written briefs. After receipt of the briefs, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUE PRESENTED FOR HEARING (Footnote 1)
1. Did the District fail to conduct appropriate assessments or follow through on assessments of Petitioner in the areas of occupational therapy, speech and language, central auditory processing, and assistive technology?
2. Did the District fail to offer Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2004-2005 school year as there was an inadequate level of services and supports and a placement that was not in the least restrictive environment (LRE) appropriate to his needs?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
On the first day of the hearing, Petitioner raised as one of his issues that the District failed to conduct a functional behavioral analysis (FBA) and develop a behavioral support plan (BSP). The District objected to consideration of this issue in this proceeding because this issue was included in the terms in the October 2004 settlement agreement (Petitioner Exhibit 20) that concluded a prior due process proceeding between the parties, case SN04-02090. This agreement, in part, provided for an FBA to be conducted by the District. The Hearing Officer ruled that Petitioner may raise the issue of the appropriateness of an FBA or a BSP as evidence of Petitioner’s needs after October 5, 2004; however, the Hearing Officer specified that the hearing issues would not include any claims that the District should be complying with the October 5, 2004 settlement agreement, because compliance with the terms of a settlement agreements is not generally within the jurisdiction of the Hearing Office. (Footnote 2) The Hearing Officer issued a post-hearing order clarifying that this issue will not be under consideration.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a thirteen-year-old sixth-grade student who resides with his parents within the boundaries of the District. He qualifies for special education under the category of specific learning disability (SLD) and has a diagnosis of attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). He currently attends the District’s Northridge Middle School where he attends two special day classes (SDC), one for math and science, and the other for language arts and social studies.
STUDENT was retained in the second grade for the 2000-2001 school year after failing to pass grade-level standards that were necessary for advancement to the third grade. He had attended three intervention programs during the 1999-2000 school year in an effort to improve his performance but continued to show little growth in his academic subjects. (Footnote 3) MOTHER requested a special education assessment because she “wanted to see why” he was not doing well in school. In response to this request, the District drafted an assessment plan, and STUDENT was assessed pursuant to this plan. The initial individualized education program (IEP) team met on September 28, 2000, to review the assessment results. His math scores were above average, but his reading and spelling scores were below average. The team concluded that STUDENT had deficiencies in the areas of attention and auditory processing that caused severe discrepancies between his cognitive ability and his academic achievement. The team found him eligible for special education and services as SLD. Goals and objectives in the areas of language arts and vocational education were adopted. The District offered a general education placement with resource specialist (RSP) services. Accommodations included a teacher-to-student ratio of one-to-ten for services, individual assistance, and a computer program. MOTHER approved this IEP.
STUDENT’s IEP team met for an annual review on November 6, 2001, when he was in the third grade. His present levels of performance showed progress from the last IEP. He remained approximately one grade level behind in language arts, but still was above average in math. The team adopted classroom supports, accommodations, and instructional modifications. The supports aimed at his deportment and attention issues with a behavior chart to remind STUDENT to stay on task. Tasks were limited to fifteen-minute intervals and in a quiet, isolated environment. Accommodations included lower-level materials, peer tutoring, small group instruction, individual assistance “when able to be provided,” word books, and charts. He was to receive modifications such as extended time, clarification of directions, and chapter tests with assistance and direction from the RSP teacher or special education assistant. The District offered to continue STUDENT in the RSP program with updated goals in language arts and vocational education. MOTHER gave her consent to this IEP.
The next annual review IEP meeting was on November 15, 2002. As a fourth grader, STUDENT was at the high third/beginning fourth-grade level in language arts. Math continued to be an area of strength for STUDENT with scores at the high fifth grade level. His reading was slow and he continued to have some problems with letter reversals or transpositions in written language. STUDENT reportedly was still easily distracted. He also needed directions restated and required organizational assistance from his teachers and classroom aides. The IEP noted that STUDENT “with modifications works well in the regular classroom program with collaborative and pullout resource support,” but that classroom behavior and inability to stay on task were still challenges for him. The team also learned that STUDENT and his family were in private family counseling at that time. The District continued to offer a general education placement with RSP supports and interventions. MOTHER approved the November 2002 IEP.
STUDENT’s three-year review IEP meeting convened on September 25, 2003. MOTHER informed the team that her son now had a medical diagnosis of ADHD and had been prescribed medication. At that time STUDENT had not yet started taking the drug because the family needed to arrange for funds to purchase the prescription. The IEP notes reflect that STUDENT continued to have attention, auditory processing, and focusing difficulties in the classroom. STUDENT’s cognitive assessments showed him to be functioning within the average range. His achievement scores in the language arts, however, were in the second-grade to high third-grade level. In math, he scored in the high fifth-grade range. The District’s assessor remarked that STUDENT’s scores were affected by his inability to concentrate. MOTHER consented to the continuation of the District’s offer of RSP services provided to STUDENT in the general education program.
STUDENT’s next annual review IEP was May 28, 2004. As a fifth-grade student, STUDENT scored overall at the third-grade level in written language and the high second-grade level to the third-grade level in reading. In math, an area of strength for STUDENT in the past, he scored in the seventh-grade level in calculation, but overall averaged in the fourth-grade range. The level of reading required for word problems, according to the assessor, constituted STUDENT’s biggest challenge in math. MOTHER and therapist Linda Steel asked the IEP team to consider a more restrictive environment for STUDENT. The District offered STUDENT an SDC program after he advanced to middle school. FATHER and MOTHER approved the IEP but stated several “concerns and thoughts” including that “the school has failed our son” because he had not mastered basic reading skills and has not been “able to keep up with the academic demands over the past five years.”
STUDENT moved to Middle School for the sixth grade at the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year. Petitioner filed his first due process request in August 2004. After a mediation agreement between the parties in October 2004 settled this earlier due process proceeding, the IEP team met on November 23, 2004. The team received the results of assessments agreed to as part of the mediation settlement. At issue in this case are the assessments the IEP team received in occupational therapy, central auditory processing, speech and language, and assistive technology. None of the assessors recommended direct services in their respective areas, and the District offered none. The IEP team noted that STUDENT’s academic performance was “well below grade level” in math and language arts but that he was making progress and continued to improve. The District did offer to keep him in the middle school SDC program with accommodations. Although she was present for this IEP meeting, MOTHER did not consent to the provisions of this IEP.
Petitioner filed the current due process request on February 1, 2005, disagreeing specifically with the November 23, 2004 IEP and alleging inadequate assessments and learning supports. This matter went to hearing on March 1, 2005.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Petitioner contends that the District failed to perform appropriate assessments in occupational therapy, speech and language, central auditory processing, and assistive technology. Petitioner argues that the District did not assess in all areas of suspected disability and that the assessments did not use appropriate test instruments necessary to assess all of his needs. Petitioner further contends that the assessors did not seek parental input as part of their assessments. The District argues that its assessments were appropriate in all areas.
Petitioner further contends that the District failed to provide him a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year since October 5, 2004, as the placement offered is not in the appropriate least restrictive environment and appropriate services and accommodations have not been offered. The District argues that the SDC program at Northridge Middle School has provided a FAPE in the least restrictive environment.
Petitioner is seeking a nonpublic school (NPS) placement and compensatory education as remedies in this proceeding.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue No. 1: Did the District fail to conduct appropriate assessments or follow through on assessments of Petitioner in the areas of occupational therapy, speech and language, central auditory processing, and assistive technology?
Although the District did provide assessments in the areas of occupational therapy, speech and language, central auditory processing, and assistive technology, Petitioner contends that these assessments were not appropriate and did not assess in all areas of his suspected disabilities. The District argues that each of these assessments was appropriate.
Reassessment of a special education student must occur at least every three years, or more frequently “If conditions warrant a reassessment,” and must follow the procedures set forth for an initial assessment to determine eligibility. Cal. Educ Code § 56381. The initial assessment procedures include that a student must be assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability by “qualified persons.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56320. The procedures require an effort to obtain test results “that accurately reflect the pupil’s aptitude, achievement level, or any other factors the test purports to measure and not the pupil’s impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills unless those skills are the factors the test purports to measure.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(d). The reassessment process requires review of existing assessments, input from the pupil’s parents to determine whether the student still qualifies for special education, present levels of performance and educational needs, whether the student continues to need special education and related services, and whether additions or modifications to the student’s program are needed to meet the annual goals in the IEP “and to participate, as appropriate, in the general curriculum.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(b). The District is obligated to “administer tests and other assessment materials as may be needed to produce the data identified by the individualized education program team.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(c). An IEP team, or “qualified professionals, as appropriate,” may determine that no additional data is needed to determine continued eligibility for special education provided that the District so notifies the parents of the determination, and the reasons therefor. Cal. Educ. Code §56381(d).
Petitioner asserts that, in each of the four assessments at issue, none of the assessors directly sought input from Petitioner’s parents. Each of the four assessors testified that no direct parental input was solicited as part of the respective assessment. Although the statute recites this initial step, substantial parental input available to the assessors appears in the record through the IEPs and prior assessments. Moreover, after MOTHER’s extensive testimony, there does not appear to be any additional information relevant to STUDENT’s classroom performance necessary to determine STUDENT’s qualification for special education, present levels of performance, or educational needs that the assessors did not already have from other, more detailed sources. Even though the law lists this step in the assessment process, there is no requirement in the law that an assessor must submit a questionnaire of a standardized measure to the parents as part of the assessment process. The Hearing Officer finds that results of each of the four assessments were not compromised by this omission. Applying the test to determine if a procedural violation of the law constitutes a denial of FAPE, the Hearing Officer further finds that there was no prevention of meaningful parental participation or deprivation to STUDENT of educational opportunity. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 , 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992).
Occupational therapy
The District contracted with California-licensed occupational therapist Niraj Jaju to assess STUDENT. For over six years, Mr. Jaju has performed assessments of children including those of middle school age. The Hearing Officer finds Mr. Jaju to be a credible witness with extensive experience in occupational therapy and gives his testimony great weight. Mr. Jaju reviewed some samples of STUDENT’s work and observed him in his classroom. Mr. Jaju noted that STUDENT was still printing but that his written work was legible and showed appropriate “line regard” with respect to placing letters within the preprinted lines on his paper. Although he observed that STUDENT was easily distracted, Mr. Jaju stated that STUDENT was able to “self correct” and was alert in the classroom even with noise distractions. Mr. Jaju also said that STUDENT was “well coordinated” and appeared to have normal fine motor skills. Had Mr. Jaju seen any sensory seeking, sensory avoidance, or any other occupational therapy needs, he stated that he would have followed up with further assessment. Mr. Jaju described in his report (Petitioner Exhibit 7) how he used the “ecological model of student performance” as a guide, which he stated is “best practice” according to the published Guidelines for Occupational Therapy and Physical Therapy in California Public Schools. He did not conduct any standardized assessments of STUDENT and did not communicate with his parents. Mr. Jaju concluded that STUDENT did not require any occupational therapy services.
Petitioner contends that his visual-motor skills and “atypical” classroom behavior should have been areas for further occupational therapy assessment. Petitioner points to the District’s September 2003 assessment that refers to STUDENT’s lack of “visual-motor integration” issues and the District’s November 2004 assessment that refers to “poor visual planning” and “poor motor execution (Petitioner Exhibit 11).” In her November 2004 assessment, District psychologist Julie Truckenmiller stated that STUDENT required “close structure when asked to complete visual-motor written tasks” and indicated that the District occupational therapy assessment would provide “additional evaluation information” for the IEP team (Petitioner Exhibit 2). Mr. Jaju did provide that “additional evaluation information,” however, but did not see any indication that further assessment for a suspected disability appeared in his review of STUDENT’s work, observation of his functioning in the classroom setting, and interviews with teachers. There is no indication in the evidence that the “visual-motor” issues noted by the District assessors were indicators of issues that occupational therapy would necessarily treat as opposed to another manifestation of his diagnosed disabilities that the SDC, with its small class size and individualized attention, already addressed. This is also true of classroom “atypical behavior” that Petitioner appears to argue was not observed by Mr. Jaju. Petitioner suggests that Mr. Jaju may have been there on one of STUDENT’s “good days,” and that this “shed no light on STUDENT’s inability to regulate his behavior.” Mr. Jaju, however, noted that STUDENT was prone to inattentiveness but was able to “self correct.” Moreover, Mr. Jaju, who has substantial experience and training in the occupational therapy field, persuasively testified that he reviewed the IEPs and went over samples of STUDENT’s work with his teachers and saw no indications of a need for occupational therapy. There was no convincing evidence to the contrary. The Hearing Officer concludes that Mr. Jaju did a complete review of STUDENT’s occupational therapy needs and had no reason to conduct any follow up assessments.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s occupational therapy assessment was conducted by a qualified person, was appropriate, and there is no evidence in the record indicating that STUDENT has suspected disabilities in this area that have not been assessed or that appropriate test instruments were not used.
Speech and language
The District contracted with California-licensed speech and language pathologist Sofia Carias to assess STUDENT. Ms. Carias holds a master’s degree in speech and language and has assessed some fifteen students who qualified as SLD. The Hearing Officer finds that she was a credible witness and affords her testimony great weight. She administered the Comprehensive Assessment of Spoken Language (CASL) standardized test to STUDENT and recorded her observations. (Petitioner Exhibit 5). Ms. Carias found that STUDENT was articulate and had normal language skills for an adolescent male, although he required encouragement to proceed during part of the assessment until he “warmed up” and needed less redirecting. She reported STUDENT’s score on the CASL was not more than one and one-half standard deviations below the mean and, accordingly, did not qualify STUDENT for speech and language services. Ms. Carias found him to be within “functional limits” for his age with respect to voice fluency, articulation, and oral mechanics. She concluded that STUDENT did not require speech and language services. She saw no difficulties with STUDENT’s higher language functioning or “mental linguistics.” She did comment, however, on his inattentiveness. Ms. Carias stated that STUDENT could have scored even higher on the tests that she administered had he been more attentive. To the extent she noted that STUDENT had trouble with eye contact or attentiveness, she characterized these traits as also typical of young men in his age group. Ms. Carias said that STUDENT displayed patterns similar to other SLD students with whom she has worked who had the need for questions to be repeated or a longer than normal response time.
Petitioner contends that Ms. Carias did not assess STUDENT’s needs in written language and relied only on the CASL to recommend that he receive no services in speech and language. The speech and language assessment was conducted at the same time STUDENT was assessed by others in all academic areas including written language. Moreover, Ms. Carias stated that she employed the Fifty Utterance Language Sample as well as the CASL and her clinical observations of his use of language in her presence to determine that STUDENT did not require speech and language services. The record includes no convincing evidence to the contrary. The Hearing Officer concludes that Ms. Carias, who persuasively testified to her experience in diagnosing and treating communication disorders, did a complete review of STUDENT’s use of spoken language and that the District adequately assessed his use of written language through other means, including the academic assessments performed during the same time period by Mr. Sam Tgovanis, STUDENT’s math and science teacher and case carrier.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s speech and language assessment was conducted by a qualified person, was appropriate, and there is no indication in the record that STUDENT has suspected disabilities in this area that were not assessed or that appropriate test instruments were not used.
Central auditory processing
District speech and language pathologist Sally Blitz-Weisz performed a central auditory processing screening in October 2004. With more than twenty years of experience in her field, Ms. Blitz-Weisz is a California-licensed speech language pathologist and holds a master’s degree in speech and language. She has worked with SLD and ADHD students and has conducted more than 250 central processing disorder assessments of children. The Hearing Officer finds her testimony credible and gives it great weight. Ms. Blitz-Weisz’s report (Student Exhibit 4) notes that STUDENT passed a District audiometric screening in August 2003, and that the triennial psychoeducational assessment reported that STUDENT’s visual perceptual skills and visual-motor integration were good, but that his auditory sequencing and discrimination were weaknesses. Ms. Blitz-Weisz stated that STUDENT was cooperative and appeared to work to the best of his ability during the screening. She administered the Screening Test for Auditory Processing Disorders in Adolescents (SCAN-A). Although STUDENT scored in the normal range for identifying words in a compromised acoustical environment and with background babble, his overall results were in the “questionable range.” He had difficulty with successive monosyllabic words, sentences separated by a significant, brief interval and competing words. Ms. Blitz-Weisz indicted that low scores on the competing words subtest can be due to delayed auditory maturation or damage to the central auditory pathways. Ms. Blitz-Weisz employed other measures, including the Comprehensive Test of Phonological Processes (CTOPP) to test STUDENT’s awareness of and access to the sound structure of his oral language, the Lindamood Auditory Conceptualization Test (LAC) to check auditory perception and conceptualization of speech sounds, and the Fast ForWord Demonstration to test auditory discrimination, attention and memory.
Considering the test results and record review, Ms. Bliz-Weisz concluded that STUDENT was in the questionable range in comparison to his peers, with some skills in the normal range but showed greater difficulty with sound segmenting and recalling numbers beyond four digits in length. After consulting with education audiologist Dr. Sandy Keaton, Ms. Blitz-Weisz recommended readministering the SCAN-A in one year after STUDENT has been in the SDC setting with its various accommodations. Ms. Blitz-Weisz further recommended encouraging STUDENT’s teachers to use visual cues and preteach new and familiar vocabulary in context. In the meantime, current recommendations included maintaining the accommodations in prior IEPs of shortened tasks, extended time for developing concepts, small group instruction, repeated directions, and additional accommodation of flexible seating, if needed.
Petitioner contends that, based on her testimony, Ms. Blitz-Weisz is only a screener for auditory processing deficits and an audiologist is needed for a diagnosis. Petitioner argues that the IEP team should have referred STUDENT to the next level of assessment. Ms. Blitz-Weisz, however, did consult with an educational audiologist and shared the test results to see if further assessment was necessary at that time. It was after this consultation that Ms. Blitz-Weisz recommended that the SCAN-A be readministered in one year. The District’s assessor, therefore, verified that no further assessment at that time is indicated, and that one year in the SDC class should pass before taking another look at STUDENT. The Hearing Officer concludes that Ms. Blitz-Weisz conducted a complete auditory processing screening and that, after consultation with an education audiologist, properly deferred further screening until STUDENT has spent one year in his new, more restrictive classroom environment.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s central auditory processing screening was conducted by an qualified person, is appropriate and that there is no evidence in the record indicating that STUDENT has any suspected disabilities in this area that have not been assessed or the appropriate test instruments were not used.
Assistive technology
Assistive technology is an aid to increase, maintain, or improve a student’s functional capabilities as described in 34 C.F.R. section 300.5. Assistive technology is an area that the IEP team must consider in developing a pupil’s program under Cal. Educ. Code section 56341.1(b)(5).
District assistive technology assessor James Astle, who was assigned to assess STUDENT’s assistive technology needs, reviewed records, interviewed teachers and others who worked daily with STUDENT, and observed him in the classroom to assess his “functional access needs.” Mr. Astle stated that he was looking to see if STUDENT could access the curriculum. Mr. Astle’s conclusion was that STUDENT did have functional access (Petitioner Exhibit 6). This finding, according to Mr. Astle, precluded any further consideration of assistive technology for STUDENT. Mr. Astle distinguished between “accommodations,” such as the use of keyboards or books on tape, and assistive technology. He described accommodations as a means to enhance performance, which is not a goal of assistive technology. Mr. Astle gave examples of books on tape for a blind student or a wheel chair to give a nonambulatory student means to get into a classroom as examples of assistive technology to provide functional access to the curriculum. He said that assistive technology is appropriate if it is necessary for a student to perform a task as opposed to accommodations that are employed “as needed.” Mr. Astle commented that, based on his own experience, it is not unusual to find ADHD or SLD students have no need for assistive technology for functional access to the curriculum.
Petitioner contends that Mr. Astle should have run “equipment trials” with STUDENT. He also argues that the IEP notes state that books on tape may help him. Petitioner further contends that Mr. Astle had a “bias” that assistive technology was not commonly a need for students who have a diagnosis of SLD or ADHD.
Mr. Astle’s experience in education extends over twenty years including a master’s degree in special education, and an assistive technology certification. The Hearing Officer finds him to be a credible witness and gives his testimony great weight. Mr. Astle persuasively testified that STUDENT has no need for assistive technology to achieve functional access to his classroom or curriculum. Equipment trials would be appropriate only in the event that a need for functional access were determined. As to discussion at the IEP meeting about books on tape, Mr. Astle described how this may be an appropriate aid or accommodation, but that it is not a necessity for functional access. There also is no showing in the evidence that Mr. Astle’s results were predetermined by STUDENT’s disabilities. His reference to the tendency of SLD/ADHD students to have functional access appears to have arisen after he made the determination in STUDENT’s individual case based on his observations and discussions with STUDENT’s teachers.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s assistive technology assessment was conducted by a qualified person, is appropriate, and there is no evidence in the record indicating that STUDENT has any suspected needs in this area that have not been assessed or that appropriate test instruments were not used.
The Hearing Officer finds that the assessors in all four of the assessments at issue were qualified in their respective fields, performed appropriate assessments, and did not omit any area of suspected disability or appropriate test instruments.
Issue No. 2: Did the District fail to offer Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2004-2005 school year as there was an inadequate level of services and supports and a placement that was not in the least restrictive environment (LRE) appropriate to his needs?
Petitioner contends that the District did not offer him a FAPE in the November 25, 2004 IEP. He alleges that the offered placement and level of services were inappropriate for him. The District responds that it did offer a program that provides STUDENT a FAPE.
The District is required to provide a FAPE to STUDENT to meet his unique needs under the provisions of the IDEA and State law. See 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A FAPE includes special education and related services that are provided at public expense, under public supervision and direction, and without cost to the parents that meet the standards of the State educational agency, including appropriate education provided in conformity with the student’s IEP as described in 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).
“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, provided at no cost to parents, that meets the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. “Related services” include transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a student to benefit from special education as defined in the IDEA at 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). State law provides for similar services as part of designated instruction and services (DIS) under California Education Code section 56363(a) and Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations, section 3001(z).
The United States Supreme Court in the leading decision of Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 198-208 (1982), set the standard by which the District’s instruction and services are measured. The Rowley decision, at 198-201, however, held that the IDEA does not require a district to provide to the student the best education available or to provide instruction that maximized his abilities. Rather, a special education student is entitled to have access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to meet his unique needs and to provide educational benefit as a “basic floor of opportunity.”
Special education law also requires that the student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE), placing the student to the maximum extent appropriate with typically developing peers. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550, Cal. Educ. Code § 56001(g).
Rowley and the federal and State statutes, discussed above, require the following analysis for substantive FAPE issues: 1. Is the District’s program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs? 2. Is the program reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT some educational benefit? 3. Does the program as implemented conform to his IEP? 4. Additionally, does the program provide a FAPE in the least restrictive environment?
To determine if the District offered Petitioner a FAPE, the Hearing Officer will first identify STUDENT’s unique needs.
Petitioner’s unique needs
There is no dispute that STUDENT has ADHD with deficiencies in auditory processing, planning, organization, and sequencing, and that he qualifies for special education because of an SLD. The parties concur that STUDENT has areas of need in reading, writing, and applied math. His greatest delays are in reading. He has specific problems with phonological awareness, which affect his decoding skills and comprehension of what he reads. These deficiencies in reading impact all academic areas because of his difficulties with written material. STUDENT has problems paying attention in class and staying on task. He requires intensive academic instruction in a small class to keep him focused and visual cues and prompts to enhance his auditory discrimination. The District’s offer
In the November 23, 2004 IEP, the District offered STUDENT placement in the sixth grade at Northridge Middle School with all of his academic subjects taught in an SDC setting. The offer includes accommodations of proximity seating, monitoring as needed, extended time, teacher prompting, a small group setting, and graphic organizers. The offer further provides for STUDENT to be with typically developing peers in the school’s general education population for thirteen percent of his total school time each week.
Next, the Hearing Officer will determine if the District’s offer meets STUDENT’s needs.
Designed to meet unique needs
Petitioner contends that the November 2004 offer does not address his needs in several respects including instructional supports for processing deficits; intervention services for reading, auditory processing, and social/emotional issues; elective classes; and small group instruction.
The SDC placement provides to STUDENT small-group instruction, specialized instruction in the academic core areas, and accommodations to meet his needs to focus on his assigned tasks in class. STUDENT’s language arts and social studies teacher, Mario Martinez, described the daily literature for success program that is used in his class and employs a course of study know as Language!. Petitioner has argued that the IEP did not discuss the name of any specific program. The choice of methodology, however, is within the District’s discretion as long as the provisions of the IDEA are being followed. Rowley, supra, at 208-209. The program used in the SDC, as described by Mr. Martinez, targets grade-level writing, language mechanics skills, and reading. The reading portion emphasizes phonics skills and fluency with corresponding writing assignments. Each student maintains a workbook and the teacher follows up with visual aids and the use of a graphic organizer white board to keep track of assignments. The teacher is assisted with one full-time aide to provide individualized assistance to the fifteen students in the class.
The students use grade-level books, which are the same as those used in the general education classes for both reading and social studies. Mr. Martinez said that the current social studies unit is ancient civilization for which he has two assistants in the classroom to help the students. He stated that he follows the same “pacing plan” for lessons as is used in general education. His SDC, however, has the smaller size than the general education classroom and accommodations for the students along with individualized instruction as needed. Also, “hands-on” involvement from the teacher and “roving” aides is available to address STUDENT’s tendency toward inattentiveness and planning and organizational needs. With respect to STUDENT’s auditory processing deficits, Mr. Martinez said that he and the aides read or repeat directions to STUDENT, use visual materials, and large print. Mr. Martinez said that he works to motivate his students with high expectations. STUDENT communicates well, is a “joyful student” who is popular with his classmates, and is “always smiling,” according to Mr. Martinez. Although occasionally he said that he needed to tell STUDENT to “tone down” in the classroom, Mr. Martinez described STUDENT’s behavior as generally “not inappropriate.” Mr. Martinez agrees with the accuracy of the present levels of performance indicated for STUDENT as of November 2004 in the IEP, and believes that STUDENT appears motivated and has appropriate goals.
STUDENT’s other SDC teacher, Mr. Sam Tgovanis, described a similar classroom routine for science and math. There are eleven students in the class with one full-time aide. The assignments are always posted to assist in organizing the student and providing visual reinforcement. Lessons are gone over one-to-one with the students, if necessary, and the aide is constantly moving around the classroom to keep students on task. Mr. Tgovanis said that he and his aide know what each student is doing. STUDENT is on Mr. Tgovanis’s case load. As a carry over from Mr. Martinez’s program, Mr. Tgovnis incorporates reading and writing skills in both science and math. Mr. Tgovanis administered the most recent academic assessments and then drafted the November 2004 goals for STUDENT. As a student in his classroom, Mr. Tgovanis describes STUDENT as “outgoing,” “friendly,” “popular,” and “happy” with a sense of humor.
The evidence does not support the need for any additional interventions with STUDENT’s transfer from the self-contained general education classroom in elementary school to the SDC format in middle school. Speech and language pathologist Sofia Carias stated that she is familiar with the SDC program and that STUDENT’s speech and language needs can be addressed in the SDC environment. There is no indication that as of November 2004, STUDENT needed counseling to address social/emotional issues in the classroom. His private therapist, Ms. Linda Steel testified that he improved with respect to acting out and self esteem issues after several months of therapy. She remarked, however, the STUDENT was “not a good candidate” for therapy as he is not prone to discuss emotional issues. She also has not seen STUDENT since he started middle school. Petitioner has certainly expressed a legitimate concern that his academic performance has the potential to undermine his self esteem and place him at risk of dropping out. His teachers, however, universally report him to be “happy,” “popular,” “social,” and “outgoing.” The November 2004 IEP (Petitioner Exhibit 1) does include social and emotional needs and his prior IEPs included vocational goals aimed at classroom behavior. The testimony of both Mr. Martinez and Mr. Tgovanis, however, indicated that class size and frequent teacher or aide redirection are meeting STUDENT’s needs in this area. District psychologist Julie Truckenmiller’s assessments of STUDENT’s emotional and behavioral condition revealed no significant problems. The record does not indicate that counseling intervention is necessary at this time to allow STUDENT to function in his classroom environment and access his curriculum.
Petitioner further decries the lack of elective subjects to motivate and challenge STUDENT. STUDENT shared with his mother and Ms. Steel how much he enjoyed a fifth-grade robotics class. MOTHER stated that one of the reasons she wants an NPS placement for STUDENT is for music and art classes. The District, however, is charged with meeting STUDENT’s unique needs. The SDC classes are intensive and focused to meet his needs and take up eighty-seven percent of the school day. There is no evidence what unmet needs would be addressed by electives that are not otherwise addressed by the District’s offer.
The SDC program at Northridge Middle School with the small class sizes and the offered accommodations with additional time allowances, visual aides, and proximity seating address STUDENT’s needs for intensive, individualized study in his academic areas and provide a means to deal with his attention and auditory processing deficits. Mr. Martinez described how his reading program emphasizes language mechanics, phonics skills, and fluency. Both of his teachers stated that reading is incorporated throughout STUDENT’s academic program. The Hearing Officer finds that the November 23, 2004 offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
Reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit
Petitioner contends that he has not benefitted from the program offered in the November 2004 IEP and that he has regressed in academic achievement. He challenges the goals and objectives as not offering him “the opportunity to progress.” The Hearing Officer, however, notes that the legal standard to be applied is whether the offer was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit on the date it was made in November 2004. The District’s offer must be viewed in the context of conditions at that time and not in hindsight or including speculative or potential future facts. Adams v. Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999).
STUDENT’s IEP team was consistently made up of members who knew and understood his needs well. Many members had assessed him or worked with him regularly. The IEP was drafted and addressed his unique needs. The team, including STUDENT’s parents, agreed to a more restrictive placement in the sixth grade than in the elementary school to put him in an environment to address better his needs resulting from his ADHD. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the November 2004 offer was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.
As noted above, the standard is whether or not the IEP offer was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit at the time it was drafted. However, Petitioner alleges that subsequent testing in February 2005, reveals that he did not make educational progress. The Hearing Officer notes that the evidence does not support this contention. Petitioner points to the February 2005 assessment conducted by retired District school psychologist and special education advocate Gloria Wright (Petitioner Exhibit 22). Ms. Wright administered the standardized Kaufmann Test of Educational Achievement (KTEA), the same test that Mr. Tgovnis administered in November 2004 before the offer was made. Petitioner argues that Ms. Wright’s scores show no progress in reading decoding since September 2000, and a severe drop in mathematics, one of his preferred subjects. Although his report card for the current school year predominates with “A’s” and “B’s”, Petitioner characterizes this as a demonstration of his effort and not his academic progress.
District special education administration Dr. Jose Gonzalez, however, testified that STUDENT’s standard scores on the normed tests predating the offer actually establish that he was making progress at the same rate as his peers because his standard scores since second grade remained in the same range or “confidence interval.” Dr. Gonzales said that standard scores are a better measure of a student’s performance than age or grade equivalents. He described the standard score based on age norms as more accurate compared to age and grade equivalents, which require calculation by interpolations or estimations. After reviewing STUDENT’s math application scores on his standardized tests, Dr. Gonzalez commented that this area is one of particular difficulty for STUDENT as it involves sequential planning and conceptualization–both areas of deficit for STUDENT. The math applications test for second graders, as described by Dr. Gonzalez, requires far less planning, sequencing, or conceptualization than the math applications test for the fifth or sixth grades. Dr. Gonzalez also saw impulsivity as another reason for STUDENT’s low math application scores particularly in light of his strong calculation skills. Dr. Gonzalez suggested that reading math applications problems to STUDENT would yield a better assessment, although this procedure is not necessarily permitted on standardized tests. As STUDENT repeated the second grade, Dr. Gonzalez gave the opinion that grade-based norms, not grade equivalents, would give more accurate results than the age-based norms. Age-based norms compared STUDENT to a group of students who usually have had one more year in the curriculum. Dr. Gonzalez also noted that on the criterion-based state-mandated tests, STUDENT generally met the adopted California grade-level academic standards. Dr. Gonzalez earned a doctorate degree in educational psychology and has served as a school psychologist for the District. He is a California-credentialed school psychologist and is licensed to practice as an educational psychologist. He has been in private practice and previously served as the director of neuropsychological assessments at Los Angeles Children’s Hospital. He also has substantial experience with the test instruments used with STUDENT, including interning with Dr. Nadine Kaufmann, co-author of the KTEA, and has regularly interpreted scores for other students. Dr. Gonzalez persuasively testified that STUDENT has not regressed, but has made progress.
According to his teachers, STUDENT has made progress in all areas with respect to the adopted goals in the District program as offered in the November 23, 2004 IEP. Mr. Tgovanis, as STUDENT’s case carrier, chose goals to provide for a grade level of improvement during the coming year over his present levels of performance as of November 2004. The IEP recites that previous “vocational goals,” aimed at classroom behavior were not adopted as the SDC placement and the accommodations to deal with his lack of attentiveness and deficit in auditory processing covered these areas. Although STUDENT was behind in all academic areas as of November 2004, Mr. Martinez and Mr. Tgovanis, who work with him daily, report that STUDENT is progressing toward his goals in their classrooms.
Petitioner quotes Mr. Tgovanis’s testimony that STUDENT will not reach his next benchmarks toward his goals. Although this is an accurate excerpt from Mr. Tgovanis’s testimony, he observed that this slow down in progress was a recent development because STUDENT was not trying as hard as he had been earlier in the year. Mr. Tgovanis testified, however, that STUDENT was making some progress and had increased his skill levels since September. Mr. Tgovanis also commented that STUDENT “speeds through homework” in class, which is consistent with Dr. Gonzalez’s interpretation from the test data that STUDENT impulsively rushes through his assignments. STUDENT’s school work in evidence (Petitioner Exhibit F) suggests this “speeding” is an explanation of incomplete or inaccurate work as much as any of his deficits. Irrespective of STUDENT’s apparent “slow down” in his math and science class, Mr. Tgovanis stated that STUDENT is capable of learning. In math calculation, Mr. Tgovanis said that STUDENT was so capable in this area that in classroom competitive academic games, STUDENT impresses the other members of the class and “knocks their socks off.” Mr. Martinez, STUDENT’s language arts and social studies teacher, also predicted that STUDENT will leave the SDC placement and move into general education within two or three years as he is progressing toward grade-level standards in his class.
The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Dr. Gonzalez and STUDENT’s teachers persuasive that the November 23, 2004 offer to Petitioner was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT an educational benefit at the time that it was drafted. The Hearing Officer further finds that STUDENT has made academic progress.
Conforms to the IEP The record shows that the District has been implementing STUDENT’s program as offered in the November 23, 2004 IEP. As Petitioner has not contested this issue, this element will not be discussed.
Least restrictive environment
Petitioner contends that the placement offer in the November 2004 IEP is not the least restrictive environment. Petitioner argues that he requires a more restrictive placement at an NPS to meet his needs.
The law of mainstreaming special education students directs the District, to the greatest extent appropriate, to place them in a general education setting. The element of the least restrictive environment (LRE), as mandated by the IDEA in 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A), requires “To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.”
State law directs special education programs to ensure that “Individuals with exceptional needs are offered special assistance programs that promote maximum interaction with the general school population in a manner which is appropriate to the needs of both.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56001(g).
STUDENT’s November 23, 2004 IEP offers a program that is eighty -seven percent in special education (Petitioner Exhibit 1), with the balance of his time in a general education setting, which the District asserts is the least restrictive environment for STUDENT.
The evidence of his history of acting out, need for repeated directions, individualized instruction, and requirement for constant prompting to stay on task indicates that STUDENT needs an SDC placement for the majority of his day. The evidence, however, suggests that STUDENT receives non-academic benefits from the balance of his school day with the general education students. His teachers report that he is popular with his peers and is outgoing. There is no showing in the record that STUDENT’s needs to advance in reading, writing, and applied math require a more restrictive environment or would be more appropriately placed in a setting with reduced or no contact with general education students. The record shows that STUDENT relates well to his peers and that he is popular. Moreover, he has progressed in the SDC setting. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer is the least restrictive environment for STUDENT as of November 2004.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer in the November 23, 2004 IEP was appropriate and in the least restrictive environment and offered a FAPE to Petitioner. Accordingly, Petitioner’s requests for compensatory education and NPS placement are denied.
ORDER
Petitioner’s requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON THE ISSUES HEARD
Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute:
The District prevailed on the issue heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
DATED: May 27, 2005 _______________________ Tracy L. Tibbals, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. Before the conclusion of the hearing, Petitioner withdrew issues concerning reimbursement for independent educational evaluations (IEEs) and whether the District allowed Petitioner’s parent to participate meaningfully in the individualized education program (IEP) process. Additionally, Petitioner’s closing brief raised an issue of the adequacy of the District’s written offer to Petitioner. As this issue was not raised during the hearing and the District has not had an opportunity to respond, the Hearing Officer will not address this issue in the Decision.
2. On the last day of the hearing, District behavior specialist Deborah Smith testified that she is in the process of preparing an FBA for Petitioner following the terms of the October 5, 2004 settlement agreement and that the FBA may lead to the development of a BSP. That this issue would not be included in this Decision was further addressed in the order dated April 1, 2005.
3. The District has implemented intervention classes at the second-grade and eighth-grade levels as part of a program to eliminate social promotion.
