California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 7, 1996
Student v. Petaluma Joint Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 255-96 · Hearing Officer Leonard Garfinkel
Petaluma Joint Unified must find eighth grader eligible as learning disabled and reimburse evaluation, therapy and tutoring costs.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The hearing began April 16, 1996 before Hearing Officer Mark Paxson. It was taken off calendar under an interim agreement for the District to assess and hold an IEP meeting. The Petitioner asked on June 6, 1996 to put it back on calendar, and Hearing Officer Garfinkel heard and decided it.
Summary
A 14-year-old who had just finished eighth grade at Petaluma Junior High School, represented by his father, challenged Petaluma Joint Unified School District's refusal to find him eligible for special education. The student had very high verbal ability but had struggled in math and writing since fifth grade. In December 1995, the District refused the father's request for an assessment. It blamed the student's grades on low motivation and a family loss. After the hearing began, the District agreed to assess. Then, at a June 1996 IEP meeting, it found him ineligible, partly to keep him in the "least restrictive environment."
The Hearing Officer found him eligible under the specific learning disability category. He had severe gaps between ability and achievement in written expression and math calculation. A visual-motor processing disorder caused these gaps, and changes in the regular program had not fixed them. The Hearing Officer held that the District should not have refused the assessment. Its later assessment was also inappropriate: no one observed the student in class or talked to his teachers, and it ignored a private evaluation done six weeks earlier with the same achievement test. The District had to reimburse the One-to-One Learning Center evaluation but not two other private evaluations. It also had to reimburse private psychotherapy for school-related depression and summer 1996 tutoring at New Horizons, a nonpublic school. Because no one presented evidence on placement, the Hearing Officer ordered an IEP meeting within 15 days.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied California's severe-discrepancy test to a high-ability student by comparing subtest IQ scores to achievement scores. It also held that a district cannot deny eligibility in order to keep a student in the least restrictive environment, and that a learning disability assessment requires classroom observation.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedEligibility
Issue 1. Is STUDENT eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability?
The student met all three parts of Education Code §56337: severe ability-achievement discrepancies in written expression and math calculation, caused by a visual-motor processing disorder and not primarily by attendance or environmental factors, that could not be corrected in the regular program. Denying eligibility to keep him in the least restrictive environment was a misapplication of LRE.
- Student prevailed in partIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 2. Must the District reimburse Petitioner for the cost of independent educational evaluations (IEEs) conducted by Dr. Laura Doty, One-to-One Learning Center, and Dr. Carol Lidz?
The District wrongly refused the December 1995 assessment request. Its May 1996 assessment was inappropriate because it had no classroom observation or teacher input, ignored the One-to-One IEE, and repeated a test given six weeks earlier. Only the One-to-One evaluation was reimbursed; the Doty and Lidz evaluations were not.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. Must the District reimburse Petitioner for the cost of psychotherapy provided by Dr. Werner Berg since February, 1996?
Because the District wrongly denied needed special education, the student became depressed about school failure. Reimbursing Dr. Berg's psychotherapy was appropriate relief.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4. Must the District reimburse Petitioner for the cost of tutoring provided by New Horizons during the summer of 1996?
The student needed remediation because the District failed to find him eligible. Reimbursing summer 1996 tutoring at New Horizons, a certified nonpublic school, was appropriate relief.
- Not reachedPlacement and LRE
Issue 5. If it is determined that STUDENT is eligible for special education, what is the appropriate placement for the 1996-97 school year?
Neither party presented evidence on placement. The matter was sent back to the IEP team to meet within 15 days, and neither party prevailed.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- IEE at public expense. Within 15 days of the decision, the District must reimburse the parent, subject to proof, for the cost of the One-to-One Learning Center assessment.
- Reimbursement. Within 15 days of the decision, the District must reimburse the parent, subject to proof, for Dr. Werner Berg's psychotherapy since February 1996.
- Reimbursement. Within 15 days of the decision, the District must reimburse the parent, subject to proof, for remedial tutoring by New Horizons during summer 1996.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 days of the decision, the District must convene an IEP meeting to develop an appropriate IEP and identify an appropriate placement for 1996-97.
- Declaratory order that the student is eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability.
Key authorities
Burlington School Committee v. Department of Education; Capistrano Unified School District v. Wartenburg; Holland v. District of Columbia; Students of California School for the Blind v. Honig; Letter to Ulissi (OSEP 1992); Letter to Lillie (OSEP 1995); Letter from Schrag (OSEP 1992); Letter to Williams (OSEP 1993); Education Code §56337; 5 CCR §3030(j)
People named in the decision
- Gerald Klor, director of special education, Petaluma Joint Unified School District
- Dr. Gerald Lapinski, school principal, Petaluma Joint Unified School District
- Barbara Larson, eighth grade school counselor, Petaluma Junior High School
- Dr. Barbara Badham, school psychologist, Petaluma Joint Unified School District
- Corlyn Porteous, school psychologist (District assessor), Petaluma Joint Unified School District
- Colleen Maloney, resource specialist (District assessor), Petaluma Joint Unified School District
- Endora Hsia, SELPA program specialist, County SELPA
- Dr. Werner Berg, private psychologist/psychotherapist, Private practice
- Dr. Laura Doty, private psychologist (independent evaluator), Private practice, Santa Rosa
- Dr. Carol Lidz, psychologist (independent evaluator), Touro College school psychology program
- Diane Wall, director, tutoring and testing center (independent evaluator), One-to-One Learning Center
- Deanne Larson, tutoring specialist; administered achievement testing, One-to-One Learning Center
- Claudia Leithe, tutoring specialist; scored achievement testing, One-to-One Learning Center
- One-to-One Learning Center, private tutoring and testing center (IEE provider), Santa Rosa
- New Horizons, certified nonpublic school providing summer tutoring, Nonpublic school
- Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer who presided at the April 16, 1996 hearing session, California Special Education Hearing Office
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Leonard Garfinkel, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Petaluma, California, on June 23 and 24, 1996.(FOOTNOTE 1) Additional testimony was taken, by agreement of the parties, via telephone conference on July 11 and 12, 1996.
Petitioner STUDENT attended the hearing and was represented by his father, PARENT. Respondent Petaluma Joint Unified School District (the District) was represented by attorney Joseph Kinkade. Also present on behalf of the District was Gerald Klor, director of special education.
Petitioner called the following witnesses: PARENT; Mr. Klor;
Dr. Werner Berg, psychologist; Dr. Gerald Lapinski, school principal; Barbara Larson, school counselor; Corlyn Porteous, school psychologist; Dr. Barbara Badham, school psychologist;
Colleen Maloney, resource specialist; and Diane Wall, Deanne Larson, and Claudia Leithe, tutoring specialists, One-to-One Learning Center. The District questioned all of the witnesses called by Petitioner but called no additional witnesses.
Oral, documentary, and tape-recorded evidence was received.
The record was left open until July 26, 1996 for the receipt of closing briefs. At that time the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUES
1. Is STUDENT eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability?
2. Must the District reimburse Petitioner for the cost of independent educational evaluations (IEEs) conducted by Dr. Laura Doty, One-to-One Learning Center, and Dr. Carol Lidz?
3. Must the District reimburse Petitioner for the cost of psychotherapy provided by Dr. Werner Berg since February, 1996?
4. Must the District reimburse Petitioner for the cost of tutoring provided by New Horizons during the summer of 1996?
5. If it is determined that STUDENT is eligible for special education, what is the appropriate placement for the 1996-97 school year?
SUMMARY OF RELEVANT EVIDENCE
A. Introduction
STUDENT is fourteen years old and lives in Petaluma, within the District, with his father PARENT. STUDENT recently completed the eighth grade at Petaluma Junior High School. He is a bright student who has performed poorly in school. He has never been found eligible for special education. This case concerns PARENT's contention that the District should have found STUDENT eligible for special education by reason of a specific learning disability during the 1995-96 school year.
B. Chronological Summary
In elementary school, STUDENT did well (A's and B's) until fifth grade. In fifth grade (1992-93) at Piner Elementary in the Piner-Olivet Union School District in Santa Rosa, he did less well, receiving a B in Language Arts, C's in Science and Social Studies, and a D in Math.
In the fall of 1993, when STUDENT was in sixth grade at Piner Elementary, school personnel referred him to the student study team (SST). The SST meeting notes for November 18, 1993 indicate that areas of concern included math, handwriting, completion of work, and inability to stay focused on tasks. STUDENT's grades by academic quarter for sixth grade (1993-94) were: Language Arts: C, C+, B, B; Math: F, D-, C-, D; Science: A, B, C; and Social Studies: B, B, C, C. STUDENT's teacher wrote at year-end that, at times, STUDENT did not complete assignments.
In early summer 1994 STUDENT's mother was diagnosed with cancer. In September STUDENT enrolled in the Santa Rosa City Schools District and was assigned to the seventh grade at Comstock Junior High School. On September 22, STUDENT's mother died.
STUDENT's final fall 1994 semester grades were as follows:
English B-; Math F; P.E. C; Health D; History/Geography C-;
Exploratory B-. In March, 1995, one of STUDENT's teachers completed a "student intervention request form." The teacher wrote: "STUDENT is a very bright boy, but seems in a daze most of the time. Mother died earlier this year." For the remainder of the second semester of seventh grade (spring 1995), STUDENT was placed on a shortened schedule. He attended math and English and two smaller classes known as "opportunity" classes. His spring semester grades were as follows (third and fourth quarter grades are followed by a final spring semester grade): Opportunity 1: C, F, D; Opportunity 2: C, F, D; English: C-, F, D-; Math: F, F, F.
In early May 1995, PARENT withdrew STUDENT from school and took him on a three-month cross-country trip. STUDENT's percentile scores on the September, 1995 California Test of Basic Skills (CTBS) were as follows: Vocabulary 93%, Comprehension 75%, Spelling 45%, Language Mechanics 59%, Language Expression 47%, Math Computation 12%.
In the fall of 1995, STUDENT moved to Petaluma, enrolled in the District and was assigned to Petaluma Junior High School (PJHS). Soon after school began, PJHS personnel referred him to the "Student Study Team" (SST) for "writing difficulties especially around spelling and writing organization." The SST did not include any of STUDENT's teachers, nor did it include anyone who had ever observed STUDENT in the classroom. The SST met on November 1 and summarized its discussion of STUDENT that day as follows:
STUDENT's mom passed away during 7th grade. He was placed on a minimum schedule. Barbara Larson [8th grade counselor] met with his dad before school started. There seems to be an issue with spelling and cursive writing.
The SST did not recommend any modifications to the regular instructional program at that time.
The SST met again on November 10 and summarized its discussion of STUDENT that day as follows -- again referring to events of the previous year:
STUDENT's mother passed away. He enrolled after school started. STUDENT had frequent absences last year.
Again, no modifications to STUDENT's regular instructional program were recommended.
On December 10, PARENT wrote to Barbara Larson, the eighth grade counselor, and formally requested a special education assessment. On December 14, Dr. Barbara Badham, school psychologist and SST member, wrote to PARENT, indicating that the District would not perform the requested assessment. She wrote:
STUDENT's teachers over the years have unanimously lauded him as a capable student, although there has been mild concern that he does not apply himself to the best of his ability. STUDENT received generally average grades up through the sixth grade. In the seventh grade his performance declined, following his mother's death. This is despite his having demonstrated average or better attainment on standardized testing scores . . .
Taken as a whole, the Learning Team's review did not find STUDENT to be a likely special education candidate.
STUDENT has had no difficulty progressing from grade to grade. He passed all proficiency testing in March, 1993, on his first attempt. His health and developmental histories appear normal, and none of his teachers has ever referred STUDENT for special education support. Two of the factors underlying the decline in his performance in school are specifically excluded under law as reasons to consider a student for learning-handicapped status.
These include a lack of motivation and effort as indicated by his failure to complete assignments and a history of being able to function within the instructional range of his grade placement.(FOOTNOTE 2)
We are therefore not recommending an evaluation at this time. The Learning Team believes that STUDENT can be successful within the regular education mainstream, despite some weakness in his cursive skills.
Dr. Badham suggested the following possible modifications to STUDENT's regular education program:
1. Selection of classes and teachers offering a maximum of structure, supervision and consistent consequences;
2. Use of weekly progress reports to ensure feedback about performance and expectations;
3. Use of a signed contract for work completion;
4. Provision of assignments that are either shorter or broken into smaller steps;
5. Reduction in the amount of writing required;
6. Use of a spell checker;
7. Preferential seating as needed to reduce distractions;
8. Extension of time frames for testing or completion of assignments;
9. Participation in school-based counseling and before-school tutoring on a regular basis.
Dr. Badham also wrote that, "if you feel further support is needed, you might want to pursue private counseling or tutoring at your own expense." Dr. Badham did not advise PARENT that he had the right to request a special education due process hearing to challenge the District's refusal to conduct an assessment.
On January 10, 1996, PARENT wrote to the superintendent of schools for Sonoma County, requesting a due process hearing. The superintendent referred the request to Gerald Klor, the District's director of special education. Mr. Klor advised PARENT as to how to properly request a state level due process hearing, and indicated that the District might have a county SELPA program specialist independently review the District's decision not to conduct an assessment of STUDENT.
Although he spent about four hours each night doing homework, STUDENT's grades for the fall semester ending January 24, 1996 were as follows (first and second quarter grades are followed by the final fall semester grade for each subject):
Science: B C- C Phys Ed. D- F F History C- D D English F F F French C C C Algebra C+ D C-
During the fall semester, STUDENT was absent eleven times in science, nine times in physical education, and seven times in each of his other classes.
At the direction of the school counselor, Ms. Larson, STUDENT's schedule for the second semester of eighth grade (spring 1996) was re-arranged. He was assigned to all new teachers for academic classes, with the exception of French.
On February 15, 1996, Endora Hsia, SELPA program specialist, prepared a report indicating that she had reviewed the District's file and agreed with Dr. Badham's decision not to conduct an assessment of STUDENT. Ms. Hsia did not observe STUDENT in class, nor did she interview any of his teachers. She wrote:
STUDENT's sudden and dramatic deterioration in his school work was coincident with his mother's death while he was in grade 7. This would suggest to me that counseling or therapy would be more beneficial for STUDENT than pursuing remedies within special education. It seems highly probable that STUDENT's educational difficulties and lack of motivation are a reflection and artifact of more basic needs surrounding possible unresolved issues of bereavement and loss. I would strongly urge the school to facilitate getting STUDENT into counseling services to overcome this traumatic loss of a parent.
On February 19 and 26, PARENT took STUDENT to Dr. Laura Doty, a private psychologist in Santa Rosa, for an independent evaluation. Dr. Doty gave STUDENT an intelligence/ability test, the Wechsler Intelligence Scales for Children-III (WISC-III), and several "projective" tests typically used to assess emotional functioning. She did not give STUDENT any achievement tests.
Dr. Doty's written report did not disclose STUDENT's WISC-III scores, but rather simply described a verbal IQ in the Superior range, Performance IQ in the Average range, and Full Scale IQ in the Above Average range.(FOOTNOTE 3) She noted that there was a significant difference between STUDENT's Verbal and Performance IQs, and concluded: "His Full Scale score, then, is somewhat artificially depressed by this difference, and is likely not to be an accurate reflection of STUDENT's abilities, which I would estimate to be in the Superior range." She concluded that the scores suggested a "mild learning disability in the area of visual processing." She noted that projective tests indicated STUDENT became depressed when he made mistakes, and was still grieving over the loss of his mother.
Dr. Doty recommended: (1) individual psychotherapy and (2) a change to a school "that appreciates students with independent spirits, preferably with a small size, to provide a social milieu that is comfortable for him."
On February 26, the District's special education director, Mr. Klor, sent PARENT a copy of Ms. Hsia's report, and indicated PARENT could call him if he would like a referral to a counselor in the Petaluma area. At about that time, PARENT began taking STUDENT to psychologist Dr. Werner Berg for private therapy. Dr. Berg testified at the hearing that he found STUDENT to be depressed. STUDENT's symptoms included low energy level, anxiety about the future, and lack of joy in things that 13-year-olds typically enjoy. He felt hopeless about his past school performance and believed that he would continue to fail there. The fear and concerns regarding school caused some stomach upset and sleeplessness. Dr. Berg found that bereavement issues also contributed to STUDENT's depression. On March 8, STUDENT received his grades for the first six weeks of the spring semester:
Physical Education: F, Science: P, English: F, History: C, French: D; Algebra: F.
On March 14, Dr. Badham wrote to PARENT that she was approving some modifications that had been suggested to her by Dr. Doty: extra time for tests, alternatives to "Scantron" answer sheets, and permission to use a computer to complete written homework assignments. On March 20, the Hearing Office received PARENT's request for a due process hearing.
On March 21, the SST met. The SST meeting notes indicated:
"visual processing difficulties . . . concentration a big problem." The following modifications were suggested: (1) French:
independent study, (2) Math: less examples (STUDENT to do every other problem or every fourth problem), (3) English: larger assignment sheets, expand explanation of assignments, laptop computer, (4) History: "modification when needed", laptop computer, (5) Physical education: encouragement. The SST meeting notes also noted the following general modifications were considered: more time on tests if needed, and use of a pass-fail grading policy. After-school tutoring in English was recommended. Shortly thereafter, STUDENT began to attend such sessions.
On March 26 PARENT took STUDENT to the One-to-One Learning Center in Santa Rosa for an independent evaluation. One-to-One is a tutoring and testing center staffed by persons experienced in both teaching and testing.(FOOTNOTE 4) STUDENT was given several achievement tests, including the Reading and Math portions of the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement -- Revised (WJ-R).(FOOTNOTE 5) Standard scores on the WJ-R given March 26 were as follows:
Reading Tests Letter-Word Identification 113 Passage Comprehension 100 Word Attack 100 Reading Vocabulary 119
Math Tests Calculation 70 Applied Problems 198 Quantitative Concepts 97
One-to-One director Diane Wall wrote in her assessment report:
STUDENT appears to have most achievement skills within the normal age and grade norms for his age; except for his Math Calculation and Quantitative Math processes.
Yet, there appear to be extenuating inconsistencies within his Visual and Auditory responses in short-term memory responses which are not allowing him the ability or facility to transfer immediate information that is a necessary part of completing conceptual learning.
STUDENT shared with the evaluator that at times he is confused by what was discussed within the classroom setting and he has difficulty in transferring and storing that new information appropriately. STUDENT shows and exhibits difficulties with auditory and visual sequential short term memory processes involving four or above units in processing. As a result STUDENT shows some discrepancies within his academic skills and math performances. These discrepancies and inconsistencies in visual and auditory processing of short term memory information could be affecting STUDENT's abilities to follow directions, transfer immediate information, sort complex information and build new complex concepts being presented within the classroom setting.
STUDENT needs to learn to apply specific skill strategies and techniques to assist him in comprehending and sorting complex written materials, improving math calculation, and developing skills to help sort, identify and integrate new information in order to learn new complex concepts.
On April 16, the due process hearing commenced. After PARENT had testified for a period of time, Hearing Officer Paxson indicated that he believed it would be necessary for the District to conduct a comprehensive assessment of STUDENT before the issue of eligibility could be appropriately heard and decided.(FOOTNOTE 6) Hearing Officer Paxson inquired if the parties would so agree. The parties then agreed that the District would prepare a proposed assessment plan and, upon receiving PARENT's written consent, conduct the assessment.(FOOTNOTE 7) The parties further agreed that, upon completion of the assessment, the District would convene an IEP meeting to consider the results. The parties agreed to take the hearing off calendar pending the result of the IEP meeting.
In early May, STUDENT was evaluated by District resource specialist Colleen Maloney and school psychologist Corlyn Porteous. More specifically, Ms. Maloney gave STUDENT the Reading, Math and Written Language portions of the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement, Revised (WJ-R). Ms. Maloney was not aware that STUDENT had taken the Reading and Math portions of the same test six weeks earlier at One-to-One Learning Center. The District's special education director, Mr. Klor, testified at the hearing that he intentionally did not advise Ms. Maloney and Ms. Porteous of the testing performed by One-to One because (1) he wanted to give the District assessors a fresh start and (2) he did not find the One-to-One assessment valuable. When he came home after taking the WJ-R with Ms. Maloney, STUDENT told his father, "I've already taken that test."
STUDENT's scores on the WJ-R given May 8 were as follows:
Reading Tests Letter-Word Identification 130 Passage Comprehension 125 Broad Reading 131
Math Tests Calculation 87 Applied Problems 97 Broad Math 91
Written Language Tests Dictation 97 Writing Samples 123 Broad Written Language 105
Thus, on three subtests which he had taken six weeks earlier, STUDENT's scores increased by the following amounts: letter-word identification, +17; passage comprehension, +25; and calculation, +17.
Also in early May, Corlyn Porteous, District school psychologist, gave STUDENT an intelligence/ability test, the Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scale: Fourth Edition. STUDENT's standard scores were as follows: Verbal Reasoning: 145, Abstract/Visual Reasoning: 110, Quantitative Reasoning: 115, Short-Term Memory: 99, Composite: 121. Ms. Porteous testified that where, as here, there are such large differences between IQ scores in different sub-areas, the composite IQ is less valuable. In such a situation, she testified, one should compare the IQ scores in different sub-areas to achievement scores in order to determine severe discrepancies.
Comparing her IQ scores to the Woodcock-Johnson scores obtained by Ms. Maloney, Ms. Porteous found a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in math. She noted a "relative weakness" in visual-motor integration and visual memory "which may be impacting [STUDENT's] written language skill in class and math skill on standardized tests", but testified she did not believe it constituted a visual processing disorder. Ms. Porteous noted that STUDENT was now passing all of his classes with the exception of algebra, in which he was receiving an F, and English, in which he was receiving an Incomplete. She wrote in her assessment report:
When asked about his reported difficulties in school, STUDENT stated that he has a hard time with "some really small stuff." (i.e. telling right from left, concentrating, writing neatly, reversing letters, etc.)
STUDENT also feels it is sometimes difficult to remember assignments for his English class and that his assignments take too long to complete.
Ms. Porteous testified that she did not know the reason for STUDENT's poor school performance, but that grief over the loss of his mother, STUDENT's own high expectations for himself, and absences from school, could be contributing factors. Ms. Porteous did not observe STUDENT in class, nor did she interview any of his teachers. Nevertheless, she believes that he has the ability to succeed in regular education, with modifications. She recommended: (1) use of a tape recorder for dictation, (2) reading STUDENT's own written work to him for proofing, (3) use of the computer, (4) use of graph paper to organize math problems, (5) and checking math work for accuracy.
On May 10, the SST team noted that STUDENT continued to perform very poorly in English, despite frequent tutoring from his teacher. That spring, STUDENT failed an entrance exam for students hoping to enroll in ninth grade algebra the following fall.
On May 20, 1996, during a weekend when PARENT and STUDENT were in New York to attend STUDENT's brother's college graduation, PARENT had STUDENT evaluated by psychologist Dr. Carol Lidz, director of the school psychology program at Touro College. Dr. Lidz' written report did not report any test scores, but rather discussed some of the learning difficulties he was exhibiting. (FOOTNOTE 8) She noted that "areas that need to be addressed in helping STUDENT develop a more positive learning and school experience include his concentration/memory, visual-motor integration, and general organizational strategies and planning." She recommended that he receive more individual attention and perhaps be instructed in smaller classes such as resource classes. With respect to math, she specifically recommended direct instruction on a tutorial basis.
On June 4, 1996, an IEP meeting was held to discuss the results of the assessments. The District determined that STUDENT was not eligible for special education by reason of a specific learning disability. A written summary of the meeting noted that STUDENT was having "difficulty with the 8th grade curriculum . . . difficulty with math and written work", but that Ms. Porteous and Ms. Maloney "would like STUDENT to be in the least restrictive environment" and that STUDENT's test results did not meet Title 5, California Code of Regulations, requirements.
At the IEP meeting, Ms. Maloney stated that the fact that STUDENT had taken the WJ-R six weeks before she gave it to him would "totally skew [STUDENT's] performance" on the latter administration of the test. At the hearing, Ms. Maloney testified that there could be a positive effect involved in taking the test six weeks later, although she would not necessarily expect increased scores unless STUDENT had been told the correct answers. She did not express an opinion as to the reason for the increased scores, but suggested that it was possible that he felt more comfortable during her testing than he had during the first testing.
DISCUSSION
A. Is STUDENT eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability?
Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), children with disabilities are entitled to a free, appropriate education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. §1400(c); see also California Education Code §56000. The term "children with disabilities"
includes children with one or more specified disabilities, including specific learning disabilities, who, by reason thereof, "need" special education and related services. 20 U.S.C.
§1401(a)(1)(A); see also California Education Code §56026(a-b).(footnote 9)
Under federal law, the term "children with specific learning disabilities" means:
those children who have a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or in using language, spoken or written, which disorder may manifest itself in imperfect ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell, or do mathematical calculations. Such disorders include such conditions as perceptual disabilities, brain injury, minimal brain dysfunction, dyslexia, and developmental aphasia. Such term does not include children who have learning problems which are primarily the result of visual, hearing, or motor disabilities, of mental retardation, of emotional disturbance (footnote 10), or of environmental, cultural or economic disadvantage.
20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(15) (emphasis added); see also 34 C.F.R.
§300.7(a)(10).
The federal regulations interpreting the IDEA provide more specific criteria for determining whether a child has a specific learning disability:
(a) A team may determine that a child has a specific learning disability if (1) The child does not achieve commensurate with his or her age and ability levels in one or more of the areas listed in paragraph (a)(2) of this section, when provided with learning experiences appropriate for the child's age and ability levels; and (2) The team finds that the child has a severe discrepancy between achievement and intellectual ability in one or more of the following areas (i) oral expression; (ii) listening comprehension; (iii) written expression; (iv) basic reading skill; (v) reading comprehension; (vi) mathematics calculation; or (vii)
mathematics reasoning;
34 C.F.R. §300.541. The federal regulations do not further define the term "severe discrepancy." They do note, however, that in determining whether a child is eligible for special education by reason of a specific learning disability, it must be considered whether any severe discrepancy is "correctable without special education and related services." 34 C.F.R. §300.543(b)(6); see also Education Code 56026.
Federal law establishes the minimum standard for defining the covered disabilities. Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 736 F.2d 773, 784-85, aff'd sub. nom. Burlington School Committee v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985). Federal law also notes that a FAPE must meet not only federal but also state standards. 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(18); see also Students of California School for the Blind v. Honig, 736 F.2d 538, 545 (9th Cir. 1985), vacated on other grounds, 471 U.S. 148 (1984).
California has adopted the federal standards for determining whether a student is eligible for special education services.
Education Code §56000; 56026. Under state law, in order for a student to be eligible for special education by reason of a specific learning disability, the three requirements of Education Code §56337 -- as further defined by the regulations contained at Title 5, California Code of Regulations (CCR) Section 3030 -- must be met. According to §56337, a student is eligible for special education by reason of having a specific learning disability if all of the following exist:
(a) A severe discrepancy exists between the intellectual ability and achievements in one or more of the following academic areas: (1) oral expression, (2) listening comprehension, (3) written expression, (4) basic reading skills, (5) reading comprehension, (6) mathematics calculation, or (7) mathematics reasoning.
(b) The discrepancy is due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes and is not the result of environmental, cultural or economic disadvantages.
(c) The discrepancy cannot be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program.
The California Code of Regulations provides further guidance as to the proper interpretation of Education Code §56337. With respect to Education Code Section 56337(a), a "severe discrepancy" is defined, in terms of standardized test scores, as a difference of greater than 1.5 standard deviations, adjusted by one standard error of measurement, between ability and achievement scores (using a mean of 100 and a standard deviation of 15). Title 5 CCR Section 3030(j)(4)(A). In other words, in order to be severely discrepant, ability and achievement scores must be at least 22.5 points apart. The discrepancy must not be primarily the result of limited school experience or poor school attendance. Title 5 CCR Section 3030(j)(5).
"Achievement" as used in Education Code §56337(a) includes the pupil's level of competence in materials and subject matter explicitly taught in school and is measured by standardized achievement tests. Title 5 CCR Section 3030(J)(3).
With respect to Education Code Section 56337(b), the basic psychological processes are defined as attention, visual processing, sensory motor skills, and cognitive abilities including association, conceptualization, and expression. Title 5 CCR Section 3030(j)(1).
1. Severe discrepancy between ability and achievement
The evidence established that STUDENT presently has a severe discrepancy of at least 22.5 points between IQ and standardized achievement test scores in a number of areas, as explained below. The evidence showed that because of the wide variation among STUDENT's sub-IQ scores obtained by the District's Ms. Porteous in May, 1996, for comparison purposes one must use the sub-IQ scores rather than the composite IQ. The sub-IQ scores were: Verbal: 145; Abstract/Visual: 110; Quantitative: 115; and Short-Term Memory: 99. Comparing these IQ scores to the Woodcock-Johnson achievement scores obtained by the District's Ms. Maloney in May, 1996, one finds the following severe discrepancies: (1) a 48 point discrepancy between verbal IQ (145) and achievement in dictation (97); (2) a 40 point discrepancy between verbal IQ (145) and achievement in broad written language (105); and (3) a 28 point discrepancy between quantitative IQ (115) and achievement in calculation (87).
In addition, the evidence showed that, six weeks before he took the Woodcock-Johnson with Ms. Maloney, STUDENT took portions of the same test at One-to-One. STUDENT's scores rose significantly on three subtests that he had taken previously.
There was some evidence that the increases may have been attributable to a "practice effect", and no persuasive alternative explanation for the increases was given. Thus, the validity of certain of the scores obtained by Ms. Maloney is drawn into question. Assuming that the achievement scores previously obtained by One-to-One have more validity, and therefore comparing those scores to STUDENT's IQ scores, the previously-noted discrepancy between quantitative IQ (115) and achievement in calculation (70) increases to 45 points.
Again, using the One-to-One scores, four further severe discrepancies surface, in addition to the three noted above: (4) a 32 point discrepancy between verbal IQ (145) and achievement in letter-word identification (113); (5) a 45 point discrepancy between verbal IQ (145) and passage comprehension (100); (6) a 45 point discrepancy between verbal IQ (145) and achievement in word attack (100); and (7) a 26 point discrepancy between verbal IQ (145) and achievement in reading vocabulary (119).
The U.S. Department of Education's Office of Special Education Programs (OSEP) has issued policy letters stating that a child such as STUDENT with a high IQ may be eligible for special education because of a specific learning disability if he otherwise meets the requirements. More specifically, OSEP has stated:
Each child who is evaluated for a suspected learning disability must be measured against his or her own expected performance, and not against some arbitrary general standard.
Letter to Ulissi, 18 IDELR 683 (OSEP 1992); see also Letter to Lillie, 23 IDELR 714 (OSEP 1995). In this case, the evidence established that STUDENT has a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in at least two of the specified categories:
written expression and mathematical calculation. Education Code §56337(a)(3),(6).
The evidence did not establish that such discrepancies are "primarily" the result of limited school experience or poor school attendance. Title 5 CCR Section 3030(j))5). While there was evidence of poor attendance in seventh grade -- the year STUDENT's mother died -- absences were not so significant during eighth grade (an average of eight per class during the fall semester). None of STUDENT's teachers testified, and thus no one with personal knowledge of STUDENT's classroom performance in English, math, or any other subject testified that they believed absences were the primary cause of his severe discrepancies. In any event, the evidence showed that STUDENT has exhibited the same school difficulties since fifth grade, regardless of attendance pattern.
The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT meets the criteria of Education Code §56337(a).
2. Discrepancy due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes and not the result of environmental, cultural or economic disadvantages
The evidence showed that STUDENT's severe discrepancies between ability and achievement are attributable to a disorder in one of the basic psychological processes, including, at a minimum, visual-motor processing. Education Code §56337(b); Title 5 CCR Section 3030(j)(1). This disorder manifested itself in an impaired ability to produce written work and do mathematical calculations. Title 5 CCR Section 3030(j).
There was no evidence that the discrepancy between ability and achievement in written expression and mathematical calculations was "the result" of environmental, cultural or economic disadvantages. Education Code §56337(b). Even assuming that the death of STUDENT's mother nearly two years ago constitutes the type of disadvantage contemplated by the code section, STUDENT demonstrated the same impaired ability to produce written work and do mathematical calculations prior to his mother's death. While grief has certainly been a contributing factor to STUDENT's depression and school difficulties, the evidence does not support a conclusion that it was the primary factor causing his severe discrepancies. (Footnote 11)
The Hearing Officer concludes that the criteria of Education Code §56337(b) are met.
3. Discrepancy cannot be corrected within the regular instructional program (i.e., the student needs special education)
The evidence showed that despite attempts at modification of the regular instructional program, STUDENT continued to perform poorly. Despite tutoring from his English teacher, modifications in math, and performing four hours of homework each night, STUDENT -- a student with superior verbal ability and solid mathematical ability -- continued to fail in these two subjects in eighth grade. Moreover, STUDENT had experienced similar school difficulties since fifth grade, and his case had been a topic of discussion by student study teams since sixth grade. STUDENT received D's in math in fifth and sixth grades, an F in math and a D in English in seventh grade, D's and F's in math and an F in English in eighth grade. (Footnote 12) Also in eighth grade, he failed the entrance exam for prospective ninth grade algebra students for 1996-97.
The evidence clearly demonstrated that STUDENT needs special education. (Footnote 13) As noted above, none of STUDENT's teachers testified. Thus, no one with personal knowledge of STUDENT's classroom performance in English, math or any other subject testified that his needs can be met in regular education. The Hearing Officer finds that the criteria of Education Code §56337(c) are met.
In conclusion, because the criteria of Education Code §56337 (a), (b), and (c) are met, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is eligible for special education by reason of a specific learning disability.
B. Must the District reimburse Petitioner for the cost of independent assessments performed by Dr. Laura Doty, One-to-One Learning Center, and Dr. Carol Lidz?
A parent may be reimbursed for an independent educational evaluation (IEE) when it is determined at a due process hearing that a District assessment was inappropriate and that a corresponding IEE was appropriate. 34 C.F.R. §300.503; Education Code §56329. In this case, PARENT requested that the District assess STUDENT in December, 1995, but the District refused. That refusal was inappropriate. The evidence established that, at a minimum, the District at that time should have had a reasonable suspicion that STUDENT had a specific learning disability and was in need of special education and related services. (Footntoe 14) He was an eighth grader of high ability who was failing English, getting D's in history and math, and whose overall gradepoint average was 1.4 on a 4.0 scale, despite the fact that "student study teams" had been addressing his case since sixth grade.
Thus, upon receipt of PARENT's December 10 request for assessment, the District was required to: prepare a proposed assessment plan for the parents' written consent within 15 days, Education Code §56321(a); conduct an appropriate assessment, Section 56320; prepare a written assessment report, Section 56327; notify PARENT of his right to receive a copy of the written report and obtain an IEE, Section 56329; and conduct an IEP meeting to review the results of the assessment, determine eligibility, and, assuming STUDENT was found eligible, prepare an IEP, all within 50 days of receipt of the parent's written consent for assessment, Sections 56342 and 56344. Thus, the process should have been completed by approximately late February.
Not only did the District inappropriately refuse to assess STUDENT, once the District assessors, Ms. Porteous and Ms. Maloney, did conduct an assessment in May, the assessment was inappropriate. First, the assessment failed to comply with specific requirements that apply when evaluating a child suspected of having a specific learning disability. The District assessment team did not interview any of STUDENT's teachers, did not observe STUDENT in class, and thus did not provide a written statement of relevant behavior noted during the observation of the child and the relationship of that behavior to the child's academic functioning. 34 C.F.R.§§300.540(a)(1);.542(a);.543(a)(3-4); Education Code §56341(e).
Further, the District's assessment failed to consider the One-to-One Learning Center IEE obtained by PARENT, as required by the federal regulations. See 34 C.F.R. §300.503; see also Title 5 CCR Section 3030 (when determining whether a student has a specific learning disability, school district must consider "all relevant material.") This was particularly significant because One-to-One had given STUDENT the WJ-R six weeks before Ms. Maloney did, thus calling into question her results. Finally, the District assessors concluded, incorrectly, that STUDENT was ineligible for special education, based, at least in part, on a misapplication of the concept of "least restrictive environment."
Having concluded that the District assessment was inappropriate, it is necessary to examine the appropriateness of the assessments obtained by Petitioner. The reports of Dr. Doty and Dr. Lidz, who did not testify at the hearing, had limitations. For example, neither provided any test scores. On the other hand, the report by the One-to-One personnel, who testified, provided (1) relevant information about STUDENT to PARENT at a time when the District had refused to conduct an assessment, (2) WJ-R achievement scores that were particularly helpful to the Hearing Officer in determining severe discrepancies, and (3) written conclusions that confirmed what other evidence in the case demonstrated -- that STUDENT has a visual processing disorder.
The law does not specifically indicate that a parent may be reimbursed for more than one IEE that addresses the same area of suspected disability. The Hearing Officer finds that, under the circumstances, Petitioner is entitled to be reimbursed for the One-to-One assessment but not those performed by Dr. Doty and Dr. Lidz.
3. Must the District reimburse Petitioner for the cost of psychotherapy provided by Dr. Werner Berg since February, 1996?
A hearing officer may award "appropriate" relief for violations of FAPE. 20 U.S.C. §1415(e)(2). Appropriate relief may include reimbursement. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359, 369 (1985). In this case, the District incorrectly denied needed special education and related services to STUDENT. As a result, STUDENT experienced depression regarding school failure. Subsequently, STUDENT obtained private psychotherapy from Dr. Werner Berg to address this issue. The Hearing Officer finds that appropriate relief in this case includes reimbursement for psychotherapy provided by Dr. Berg.
4. Must the District reimburse Petitioner for the cost of tutoring provided by New Horizons during the summer of 1996?
As a result of the District's failure to find him eligible for special education and related services, STUDENT requires remediation. During the summer of 1996 PARENT obtained tutoring for STUDENT from New Horizons, a certified nonpublic school that serves students with learning disabilities. The Hearing Officer finds that appropriate relief in this case includes reimbursement for tutoring provided by New Horizons during the summer of 1996.
5. If it is determined that STUDENT is eligible for special education, what is the appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year?
Neither party presented evidence on this issue. Therefore, the matter is referred back to the IEP team. Within fifteen (15) days of the date of this Decision, the IEP team shall meet to develop an appropriate IEP for STUDENT and identify an appropriate placement for the 1996-97 school year.
ORDER
1. STUDENT is eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability.
2. Within fifteen (15) days of the date of this Decision, the District shall reimburse PARENT, subject to proof, for the cost of One-to-One's assessment, Dr. Berg's psychotherapy since February 1996, and remedial tutoring provided by New Horizons during the summer of 1996.
3. Within fifteen (15) days of the date of this Decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting for the purpose of developing an appropriate IEP for STUDENT and identifying an appropriate placement for the 1996-97 school year.
All of Petitioner's remaining requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code §56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
Issue #1: Is STUDENT eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue #2: Must the District reimburse Petitioner for the cost of independent assessments conducted by One-to-One Learning Center, Carol Lidz, and Laura Doty?
Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue to the extent that Petitioner was awarded reimbursement for the assessment conducted by One-to-One Learning Center.
Issue #3: Must the District reimburse Petitioner for the cost of psychotherapy provided by Dr. Werner Berg since February, 1996?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue #4: Must the District reimburse Petitioner for the cost of tutoring provided by New Horizons during the summer of 1996?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue #5: If it is determined that STUDENT is eligible for special education, what is the appropriate placement for the 1996-97 school year?
Neither party prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code §56505(i).
Dated: August 7, 1996 _________________________ Leonard Garfinkel Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES
1. Hearing commenced before Hearing Officer Mark Paxson on April 16, 1996. Shortly after the hearing began, the parties reached an interim agreement and the hearing was taken off calendar at their mutual request. On June 6, Petitioner requested that the matter be placed back on the hearing calendar. 2. Evidence at the hearing showed that, in determining whether a student has a specific learning disability, one criteria the District uses is whether the student demonstrates achievement "below the instructional range of the regular classroom 3. Dr. Doty did not testify at the hearing. PARENT testified that, initially, he did not want the actual IQ scores obtained by Dr. Doty released to the District because he thought they were low and did not reflect STUDENT's true ability. At the hearing, PARENT supplied the scores at the Hearing Officer's request. They were as follows: Verbal: 121, Performance: 100, and Full Scale: 117. 4. Director Diane Wall is a credentialed speech therapist and special education teacher and tutors Deanne Larson and Claudia Leithe are credentialed regular education teachers. 5. The test was given by One-to-One's Deanne Larson, who obtained raw scores. During the pendency of the hearing process, at the Hearing Officer's request, One-to-One's Claudia Leithe converted Ms. Larson's raw scores to the standard scores listed herein.
6. See, e.g., Holland v. District of Columbia, 71 F.3d 417, 419 (D.C. Cir. 1995). In Holland, a parent requested that the District conduct an assessment to determine eligibility for special education after the student was psychiatrically hospitalized. The District failed to do so, and the parent requested a due process hearing. At the hearing, the hearing officer ordered the District to conduct the assessment and then convene an IEP meeting to determine eligibility, and, if appropriate, to determine placement and special education services for the student.
7. The District agreed, at PARENT's request, that District school psychologist Dr. Badham and county SELPA school psychologist Ms. Hsia, who had both previously determined that STUDENT did not have a "suspected" learning disability, would not participate in the assessment. 8. The District agreed, at PARENT's request, that District school psychologist Dr. Badham and county SELPA school psychologist Ms. Hsia, who had both previously determined that STUDENT did not have a "suspected" learning disability, would not participate in the assessment. 9. California uses the term "individuals with exceptional needs", who are "children with disabilities" as defined in IDEA whose impairment "requires instruction, services or both which cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program." Education Code §56026(a-b).
10. The "emotional disturbance" described in section 1401(a)(15) is "non-serious." Capistrano Unified School District v. Wartenburg, 59 F.3d 884, 892-894 (9th Cir. 1995). Serious emotional disturbance, or SED, on the other hand, is a separate eligibility category. 34 C.F.R. 300.7(a)(9); Title 5, California Code of Regulations, Section 3030(j).
11. For these same reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's learning problems are not primarily the result of "[non-serious] emotional disturbance." See 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(15); Capistrano Unified School District v. Wartenburg, 59 F.3d 884, 892-894 (9th Cir. 1995).
12. These are average grades for the year.
13. At both the IEP meeting and the hearing District witnesses stated that a primary reason for denying eligibility for special education was the desire to educate STUDENT in the "least restrictive environment" (LRE). This is a misapplication of the LRE concept. LRE is a term that applies only to disabled students who have been found eligible for special education. Once a student is found eligible, the District must develop an IEP that is designed to provide the student with a free, appropriate education (FAPE). One of the elements of a FAPE is that the student be educated in the least restrictive appropriate environment.
School districts must ensure that a continuum of alternative placements are available to meet the educational needs of special education students, such as regular classes, resource specialist assistance, special day classes, special schools, home instruction, residential treatment centers, and instruction in hospitals. See, e.g., 34 C.F.R. §§300.17(a)(1)(i); 300.551(a-b). IDEA further states: . . . to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities [who have been found eligible for special education] should be educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment [shall] occur only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. §1412(5)(B); see also Education Code §56001(g); 56031; 56364.
However, nothing in federal or state law states that a student with a specific learning disability may be found ineligible for special education because being served by an IEP is "more restrictive" than not being served by one. A finding that a student is eligible for special education by reason of a specific learning disability simply means that the student's severe discrepancy between ability and achievement cannot be corrected with services available within the regular instructional program and that, therefore, the student needs, to some extent, special education and related services. 14.Under federal and state law, school districts have an obligation to "identify, locate and evaluate" those students in the district who are in need of special education services. 34 C.F.R. §300.128; 300.220; Education Code §56300 et seq. The term "evaluate" refers to the procedures used to determine (1) whether a child has a disability and (2) the nature and extent of the special education and related services the child needs. 34 C.F.R. §300.500(b). Before any action is taken with respect to the initial placement of a child with a disability in a program providing special education and related services, the child must be assessed in "all areas related to the suspected disability." 34 C.F.R. §300.532(f); see also Education Code §56320(f).
Federal law does not use the term "referral for assessment." According to the U.S. Department of Education's Office of Special Education Programs (OSEP), interpreting federal law, a school district only has the duty to assess, upon parent request, if it suspects that a child has a disability and is in need of special education and related services. Letter to Williams, 20 IDELR 1210 (OSEP 1993); Letter to Anonymous, 21 IDELR 998 (OSEP 1992). However, according to OSEP, if the District suspects a disability, it cannot refuse or delay an assessment on the grounds that modifications to the regular education program are being attempted. Letter from Schrag, 19
IDELR 498 (OSEP 1992).
California law notes that the parent has the right to initiate a referral for special education services. Education Code §56506(b). In California, the term "referral for assessment" means any written request for assessment to identify an individual with exceptional needs made by a parent, teacher, or other service provider. Education Code §56029. The Education Code states that a pupil shall be "referred" for special education instruction and services only after the resources of the regular education program have been considered, and, where appropriate, utilized. Education Code §56303. On the other hand, Title 5, California Code of Regulations Section 3021(a) states that "all referrals for special education and related services shall initiate the assessment process." (Emphasis added.) Title 5 CCR Section 3021(b) states that all school staff referrals must include documentation of the resources of the regular education program that have been considered, modified, and when appropriate, the results of intervention. However, Section 3021(b) further notes that this documentation shall not delay the time limits for completing the assessment plan or assessment.
