California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · October 30, 2002
Student v. Cotati-Rohnert Park Unified School District et al.
SEHO Case No. SN 2553-02 · Hearing Officer Van T. Vu
Cotati-Rohnert Park Unified and Sonoma County Office of Education prevail; nonpublic school offer upheld as least restrictive environment.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a 13-year-old eighth grader filed for due process against Cotati-Rohnert Park Unified School District and the Sonoma County Office of Education. The decision describes the student as autistic, with significant cognitive delays. He was nonverbal and used emerging sign language. He attended a county special day class at Windsor Middle School with a one-to-one behavioral aide. After about a month of increasing aggression, he was suspended for ten days. The parents then kept him home. At a November 20, 2002 IEP meeting the parents chose not to attend, the District offered the Spectrum Center, a nonpublic school.
The Hearing Officer found that the Windsor program met the student's needs and followed his IEP. This covered the curriculum, a female aide, staff with working sign language skills, occupational therapy, peer integration, adapted physical education, and the behavior plans. The Hearing Officer noted that the placement itself became unsuitable late in October, but ordered no remedy because the agencies acted promptly. The November offer met the written-offer requirement, even though related services appeared only in the earlier March IEP. Any notice defect caused no harm. Under the Rachel H. factors, Spectrum was the least restrictive environment because the student's behaviors could not be controlled in a public class. No IEP meeting was needed before a suspension of ten days or less. Reimbursement for private sign language tutoring was denied. The parents were ordered to make the student available at Spectrum if they want a publicly funded education.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO used the Rachel H. factors to approve a more restrictive nonpublic school when a student's aggression escalated despite an aide and a behavior plan. It also shows that a placement-only IEP addendum could rely on an earlier IEP for services, and that suspensions of ten days or less did not require an IEP meeting first.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedCurriculum
Issue I.A.1. Whether the Windsor program from September 23 to November 20, 2002 was designed to meet Student's needs, given his claim that he required a curriculum designed for autistic children
The Hearing Officer found the principal's testimony more persuasive than the Student's expert. The Windsor curriculum was individualized and used autism-appropriate strategies, so it met Student's needs.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue I.A.2. Whether Student required a male aide rather than a female aide
Student could toilet independently and had no incontinence problems at Windsor. An aide of either gender could carry out the positive behavior strategies, so the female aide met his needs.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue I.A.3. Whether Student required a teacher proficient (fluent) in American Sign Language
Staff needed functional signing skills above Student's level, not fluency. The teacher had functional skills and the aide was proficient in ASL.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue I.A.4. Whether Student was provided occupational therapy that addressed his sensory integration needs
Undisputed occupational therapist testimony showed that the services followed the IEP and addressed sensory integration.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue I.A.5. Whether Student was provided appropriate opportunities to integrate with his typical peers
Student had general education PE, weekly library visits and community outings, plus reverse mainstreaming three times a week. This was integration to the extent appropriate.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue I.A.6. Whether Student required direct adapted physical education services from a qualified APE specialist
The four hours per year of APE consultation, plus the specialist's work with the class, were appropriate. The expert's call for daily services was not based on any APE assessment.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue I.A.7. Whether the program lacked a site-specific behavior intervention plan from September 23 through October 22, 2002
A site-specific plan could not practically be developed until Student had attended Windsor and the functional analysis assessment was done. Using Dr. Schrader's comprehensive plan in the meantime was appropriate.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue I.A.8. Whether the behavior intervention plan presented October 22, 2002 was sufficiently comprehensive (three hours of observation; no toileting plan; vocalizations, scissors cutting, mouthing objects not addressed)
Three hours of observation was typical and sufficient, and the plan addressed vocalizations. The other behaviors were absent or did not significantly affect Student's education, so they did not need to be in the plan.
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue I.B. Whether the program conformed with Student's IEP, specifically whether one 45-minute weekly speech and language session was not provided
The speech-language pathologist delivered the full 90 minutes a week in shorter sessions suited to Student's attention span.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue II.A.1. Whether Respondents failed to make a formal written offer of placement (Union) at the November 20, 2002 IEP because the addendum did not restate related services
An offer may be made through several documents. The November addendum changed only placement, and the related services were in the March 2002 IEP, so the Union requirement was met.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue II.A.2. Whether Respondents failed to provide prior written notice of their intent to change placement to a nonpublic school before the November 20 IEP meeting
The parents knew weeks in advance that a change of placement would be discussed and had toured Spectrum. Any timing violation was purely technical and caused no prejudice.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue II.B.1. Whether the offer was inappropriate for failing to include a male aide proficient in ASL for 360 minutes per day
A female aide could meet Student's needs. Aide services were needed only for the 300-minute school day.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue II.B.2. Whether the offer was inappropriate for failing to include two 30-minute speech and language sessions per day from a therapist fluent in ASL
Two 45-minute sessions a week from a therapist with functional ASL skills were appropriate, based on the treating pathologist's testimony.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue II.B.3. Whether the offer failed to include 10-15 minutes per day of OT exercises for sensory integration
Uncontested testimony showed that Spectrum provides at least 15 minutes a day of sensory integration exercises.
- District prevailedCurriculum
Issue II.B.4. Whether the Spectrum offer lacked a curriculum designed for autistic children
Spectrum's curriculum used methods commonly used with autistic children and was driven by the IEP.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue II.B.5. Whether the offer failed to include necessary adaptive physical education services
Spectrum has an on-site APE specialist, and students take part in APE activities every day.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue II.B.6. Whether the nonpublic school placement at Spectrum was too restrictive compared with a public special day class with a 1:6 ratio
Applying the Rachel H. factors, the Hearing Officer held Spectrum was the least restrictive environment. Student's escalating aggression could not be controlled in a public special day class and affected staff and students.
- District prevailedDiscipline
Issue III. Does the law require Respondents to convene an IEP meeting and change Student's behavior intervention plan before suspending him for up to ten days?
IEP review and behavior plan modification are required only for removals of more than ten school days, so the ten-day suspension was appropriate.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue IV. Is Student entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private sign language tutoring?
Reimbursement was denied. Student was properly suspended, the parents waived stay put, the District was trying to hold an IEP meeting from November 12 to 20, and a FAPE was offered on November 20.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order that district's offer may be implemented. The District's November 20, 2002 offer of placement at the Spectrum Center was appropriate and in the least restrictive environment. The parents must make Student available for the Spectrum placement if they want him to have a publicly funded education.
- All of Student's requests for relief were denied, including compensatory education and reimbursement for private sign language tutoring.
Key authorities
Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Target Range School Dist.; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H.; Daniel R. v. State Board of Education; Roland M. v. Concord School Committee; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education; Student v. San Jose Unified School District (SN99-01033)
People named in the decision
- Ron Whitman, special education director, Cotati-Rohnert Park Unified School District
- Kathryn Hill, principal, Windsor Middle School county program, Sonoma County Office of Education
- Gary Moe, assistant superintendent for special education programs, Sonoma County Office of Education
- Marc Pieper, behavior analyst; conducted functional analysis assessment and behavior plan, ANOVA (nonpublic agency)
- Andrew Bailey, executive director, ANOVA (nonpublic agency)
- Lainie Williams, 1:1 behavioral aide, ANOVA (nonpublic agency)
- Cathy Loftin Donovan, special day class teacher, Sonoma County Office of Education, Windsor Middle School
- Karen Pihl, speech and language pathologist
- Dr. Julie Griffith, pediatric neurologist; expert witness for Student
- Sarah Field, private occupational therapist; conducted OT assessment, Redwood Pediatrics (director)
- Christina Olstad, assistant director, Spectrum Center (nonpublic school)
- Alex Ruth, teacher of proposed class, Spectrum Center (nonpublic school)
- Kirsty Asher, speech and language pathologist (proposed provider), Spectrum Center (nonpublic school)
- Susan Langer, school psychologist; psychological evaluation, Cotati-Rohnert Park Unified School District
- Dr. Carl Schrader, conducted functional analysis assessment and behavior plan (May 2002)
- Karen Demars, speech pathologist; speech and language assessment
- Elaine Stevick, speech pathologist; speech and language assessment
- Laurie Fusfield, deaf and hard of hearing teacher; sign language assessment
- Deanna Downing, private sign language tutor
- Lattice School, nonpublic school (prior placement)
- A Better Chance School (ABC), nonpublic school (prior placement)
- George Schumer, certified real-time reporter (closed captioning)
- Cynthia Pacini, certified real-time reporter (closed captioning)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter convened for hearing before Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, on December 5, 6, and 10-13, 2002 in Rohnert Park, California.
Petitioner STUDENT (STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented during the hearing by his aunt and advocate, Susan Foley. STUDENT’s parents, MOTHER and FATHER, were also present on his behalf.
Respondent Cotati-Rohnert Park Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Jane Tomsky from the law firm of Lozano Smith and special education director Ron Whitman. Attorney Sarah Tigerman was also present on behalf of the District at times during the hearing. Respondent Sonoma County Office of Education (SCOE) was represented by attorneys Marko Fong and Nancy Klein and SCOE principal Kathryn Hill.
The hearing was open to the public at the request of Petitioner. George Schumer and Cynthia Pacini, certified real-time reporters, provided closed-captioning services for FATHER.
Petitioner called as witnesses: MOTHER, his mother; Ron Whitman; District special education director; Kathryn Hill; SCOE principal; Marc Pieper, behavior analyst; Cathy Loftin Donovan, special day class teacher; Karen Pihl, speech and language pathologist; and Dr. Julie Griffith, pediatric neurologist.
The District called as witnesses: Andrew Bailey, executive director of ANOVA, Lainie Williams, one-to-one behavioral assistant; Sarah Field, director of Redwood Pediatrics; Christina Olstad, assistant director at the Spectrum Center; and Susan Langer, school psychologist.
Respondent SCOE called as witnesses Gary Moe, assistant superintendant for special education programs, and Kathryn Hill.
The Hearing Office received the parties’ closing briefs on December 23, 2002. The record was then closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES(Footnote 1)
I. Did the Respondents deny Petitioner a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from September 23, 2002, through the date of the IEP meeting on November 20, 2002, by failing to provide him with a program that was designed to meet his needs and that comported with his IEP?
II. Was Respondents’ November 20, 2002 offer of the Spectrum Center procedurally and substantively appropriate?
III. Does the law require Respondents to convene an IEP meeting and to change Petitioner’s behavior intervention plan prior to suspending him for up to ten days?
IV. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for costs of private sign language tutoring services procured for Petitioner?
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Petitioner STUDENT is a thirteen-year-old autistic eighth-grader who is eligible for special education and related services as a student with significant cognitive delays. STUDENT is tall for his age and weighs approximately 280 pounds. He is nonverbal with emerging language skills facilitated by sign language. Additionally, STUDENT has a history of exhibiting behaviors such as aggression, property destruction, inappropriate urination, noncompliance, and tantrumming. Overall, his needs are in the area of academics, social behavior, language and communication, and gross and fine motor abilities. STUDENT lives at home with his parents and has not attended public school since October 25, 2002. STUDENT is currently being home-schooled by his parents.
STUDENT was primarily home-schooled until the age of eight, when he and his parents moved to Rohnert Park, California. After enrolling in the District, STUDENT was placed in a full inclusion classroom during the spring of 1998. During the fall of the 1998-1999 school year, STUDENT’s placement was changed to a SCOE special day class for the severely handicapped to better meet his needs. During the spring of 2000, STUDENT’s placement was changed again to Lattice School, a nonpublic school, to address, in part, his increasing behavioral issues. After STUDENT had been at Lattice for two months, the PARENTS had concerns about the placement and requested the District to change STUDENT’s placement again. For the remainder of the 2000-2001 school year and through the end of the 2001-2002 school and extended school year, STUDENT attended another nonpublic school called A Better Chance School (ABC).
During STUDENT’s final year at ABC, disagreements arose between the District and the PARENTS regarding STUDENT’s education. Consequently, the PARENTS requested a due process hearing to resolve their differences on March 11, 2002. In the meantime, on February 27 and March 25, 2002, STUDENT’s IEP team convened to revise his educational program. The PARENTS refused consent to any portions of the IEP. Then, in April 2002, the PARENTS and the District entered into a final mediation agreement settling all educational issues through the end of the 2002 extended school year. In the mediation agreement, the PARENTS agreed to allow the District to conduct assessments of STUDENT and the District agreed, among other things, to “pursue options that may exist for STUDENT within the county and/or SELPA.” On the same day that the parties resolved their dispute through mediation, the PARENTS provided the District consent to implement the March 25 IEP.
During May 2002, the District’s school psychologist, Susan Langer, conducted her psychological evaluation of STUDENT. Additionally, the District obtained a speech and language assessment of STUDENT from speech pathologists Karen Demars and Elaine Stevick and a functional analysis assessment (FAA) from Dr. Carl Schrader. According to Dr. Scharder’s report, the purpose of the FAA was to determine “the parameters of a new program for STUDENT… [that] will be developed and implemented in his new district or county placement in September.” (Dist. Exh. 48.) Thus, the purpose of Dr. Schrader’s assessment was to develop a plan for addressing STUDENT’s behaviors during his transition from ABC to his new county placement in the fall of 2002. On May 31, 2002, STUDENT’s IEP team convened to review and discuss the assessments. Additionally, sometime during the summer of 2002, the PARENTS hired Deanna Downing to provide STUDENT with sign language tutoring at his home.
STUDENT’s IEP team convened again on August 13, 2002, this time to plan for STUDENT’s transition from ABC into an SCOE special day class. At the meeting, the team considered possible placements for STUDENT at Sonoma High School and at Windsor Middle School. Although the District specifically offered Petitioner a placement at Sonoma High School, it considered Windsor Middle School also appropriate and agreed to allow the PARENTS to choose between the two placements. Also during the meeting, the PARENTS consented to the District’s request that it be allowed to conduct an assessment by a deaf and hard of hearing specialist to determine the level of STUDENT’s signing abilities and another functional analysis assessment, this time to develop a behavior intervention plan specific to STUDENT’s new placement. On September 11, 2002, the PARENTS requested that the District also conduct an occupational therapy assessment of STUDENT. Following classroom visitations to the two placements offered by the District, the PARENTS chose a placement for STUDENT at Windsor Middle School. STUDENT completed his transition from ABC and began his full-time attendance at Windsor on September 23, 2002.
While at Windsor, STUDENT attended Ms. Cathy Loftin Donovan’s special day class. Ms. Donovan’s class consisted of a total of twelve students, and Ms. Donovan was assisted by four aides. One of the four aides, Lainie Williams, was assigned specifically to work with STUDENT throughout his school day. Ms. Williams is employed by a nonpublic agency called ANOVA, which provides behavioral support services. During the time Ms. Williams worked with STUDENT, she was supervised by behavior analyst Marc Pieper, who was also responsible for conducting the FAA of STUDENT and developing the site-specific behavior intervention plan. Both Ms. Williams and Mr. Pieper assisted STUDENT in his educational environment by applying the behavioral recommendations from Dr. Schrader’s FAA report. STUDENT also received speech and language services, occupational therapy services, and adaptive physical education consultation services.
During the month following STUDENT’s transition to Ms. Donovan’s class, STUDENT was involved in approximately 16 incidents of increasingly frequent and intensive aggressive behaviors towards his peers and aide. The behaviors included shoving, punching, kicking, grabbing, and pouring water on others. According to Ms. Williams, STUDENT appeared to target much of his aggression on a blind autistic student in his class. In the meantime, the District’s FAA of STUDENT conducted by Marc Peiper during September and October was completed by October 14, 2002. (Dist. Exh. 27.) Additionally, the District’s sign language assessment conducted by Deaf and Hard of Hearing teacher Laurie Fusfield and occupational therapy assessment conducted by private occupational therapist Sarah Field were completed on October 16, 2002. On October 22, 2002, another IEP meeting was convened to review STUDENT’s progress, to discuss the assessment reports, to discuss Ms. Fusfield’s proposed goals and objectives in the area of speech and language, and to discuss Mr. Pieper’s proposal for a behavior intervention plan for STUDENT at Windsor. At that meeting, the PARENTS consented to Ms. Fusfield’s goals and objectives and Mr. Pieper’s BIP.
The very next day, while at school, STUDENT pushed Ms. Williams against the classroom door and proceeded to kick her on her legs. To stop STUDENT from kicking her, Ms. Williams redirected STUDENT in a stern voice to sit down, and signed the same command in American Sign Language. STUDENT eventually complied with Ms. Williams’ request and stopped kicking her. On October 24, the next day, while walking back to class from physical education class with Ms. Williams, STUDENT again shoved Ms. Williams against the classroom door, punched her in the arm, and then spit on her. When Ms. Williams and another SCOE staff person opened the door to the classroom, STUDENT entered the class, grabbed a mug located near him, and threw it against a table with such force that the mug shattered and damaged the table. Although STUDENT was allowed to return to school the next day, SCOE assistant superintendent Gary Moe suspended STUDENT for five days on October 25, 2002. Mr. Moe eventually extended the suspension to ten days. In letters to the District and the PARENTS, Mr. Moe indicated his request for an IEP meeting to be convened to discuss the appropriateness of the Windsor placement for STUDENT and the possibility of changing his educational placement.
The IEP meeting requested by Mr. Moe was first scheduled for November 7, 2002. Although the PARENTS indicated that they would attend the meeting, the District cancelled the meeting because it had not found an appropriate alternative placement to offer to Petitioner. Pending the IEP meeting, the PARENTS visited various educational placements considered by the District and SCOE for STUDENT. The IEP meeting was later rescheduled to November 13, 2002, after MOTHER’s visit to the Spectrum Center, but the PARENTS requested that it be rescheduled to allow FATHER to attend. On November 15, 2002, the PARENTS requested a special education due process hearing to resolve issues pertaining to STUDENT’s education since his transition to Windsor Middle School.(Footnote 2) Although the IEP meeting was rescheduled as the PARENTS requested to November 20, 2002, they declined to attend the meeting and instead decided to proceed to the due process hearing to resolve the parties’ differences over STUDENT’s education. (Dist. Exh. 2.) After learning that SCOE considered seeking an injunction preventing STUDENT from returning to Windsor due to his aggressive behaviors, the PARENTS notified the District and SCOE that they did not intend to pursue stay put at Windsor pending the due process hearing. Instead of returning STUDENT to Windsor, the PARENTS kept STUDENT at home to be home-schooled.
The November 20 IEP meeting was eventually held without the PARENTS’ participation. At the IEP meeting, the District offered STUDENT a placement at the Spectrum Center, a certified nonpublic school, in San Pablo. As of the date of the hearing, the PARENTS had refused consent for the change of placement.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
I. Did the Respondents deny Petitioner a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from September 23, 2002, through the date of the IEP meeting on November 20, 2002, by failing to provide him with a program that was designed to meet his needs and that comported with his IEP?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Education Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student, including instruction conducted in the classroom, in the home, in hospitals and institutions, and in other settings. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16). In California, special education is described as providing a full continuum of program options, including instruction in school and other nonschool settings, to meet the educational and service needs of the disabled child in the least restrictive environment. Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. Furthermore, an IEP is a written statement that must be developed, reviewed, and revised for each student with a disability. The IEP must include a statement of the goals and objectives, of the special education and related services, and of the program modifications or supports for school personnel that are to be provided to enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum, and to be educated and participate with disabled and nondisabled peers in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347; Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343 and 56345.
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that the student=s individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student=s abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Rowley, 458 at 207-208.
Additionally, special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A) specifically provides:
To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.
The requirement that disabled children be educated to the maximum extent appropriate with nondisabled children is often referred to as “mainstreaming,” or education in the “least restrictive environment” (LRE). The law demonstrates a “strong preference for ‘mainstreaming’ which rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption.” Daniel R. v. State Board of Education, 874 F.2d 1036, 1044-45 (5th Cir. 1989).
To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the Resondents’ offered or proposed program must have met the following four requirements in order to have constituted an FAPE: (1) been designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, (2) been reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, (3) conformed with him IEP. Additionally, federal and State law require the proposed program to have been provided in the least restrictive environment.
In this case, Petitioner started attending school full time at Windsor on September 23, 2002. Following some behavioral incidents of aggression against his aide, Lainie Williams, Petitioner was suspended from school on October 25, 2002. Petitioner’s suspension ended on November 11, 2002; however his parents did not return him to school or pursue stay put. Petitioner’s IEP team eventually convened on November 20, 2002, without his parents in attendance. At that meeting, the District members of the IEP team recommended that Petitioner’s placement be changed from Windsor to Spectrum, an NPS.
Regarding the time period from September 23, 2002 through November 20, 2002, Petitioner disputes that the Respondents’ program at Windsor was designed to meet his unique needs and comported with his IEP. Petitioner did not specifically challenge that the program was reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit or that the placement was in the least restrictive environment.
A. Designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs
In determining whether the District’s program was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs, it is first necessary to determine what those needs are. The parties have generally no dispute regarding the nature and scope of Petitioner’s deficits and educational needs. Petitioner is a cognitively impaired student with significant deficits in the areas of cognition, social/behavior and language and communication. STUDENT is tall for his age and he weighs approximately 280 pounds.
According to Susan Langer’s May 2002 psychological report, STUDENT is functioning overall at approximately the thirty-month level, with skills scattered between the 19- to-40 month level. STUDENT’s relative strengths are in the areas of fine motor skills and eye-hand integration, while his relative weaknesses are in the areas of cognitive development and cognitive verbal skills. STUDENT has difficulty with visual motor/visual perception tasks, an example of which is his inability to write any letters or numbers from a model or memory. Additionally, STUDENT has a poor attention span. By most accounts, STUDENT cannot tolerate more than twenty minutes of academic work at a time. Ms. Field, an occupational therapist who assessed STUDENT in October 2002, testified that STUDENT seeks sensory input and that the provision of sensory motor activities in his program has proven successful in keeping STUDENT alert and attentive in class. Because of STUDENT’s cognitive impairments and poor attention span, STUDENT requires a highly structured placement with a low student-to-adult ratio. Additionally, he requires sensory integration activities integrated into his school day and a one-to-one aide to assist him with his academics and to keep him on task.
Also in her psychological report, Ms. Langer noted that STUDENT’s behaviors that are of concern are his “lack of seeking help, not initiating social interactions, playing alone, and poor attention span.” Ms. Langer also reported that some behaviors observed at school include “pinching, kicking, slapping, and targeting other students.” Similarly, Dr. Schrader noted in his May 2002 report that STUDENT’s behavioral excesses include aggression, property destruction, taking food from others, self-injury, inappropriate urination and defecation, and noncompliance and tantrumming. Marc Pieper, a behaviorist who conducted a functional analysis assessment of STUDENT in September and October 2002, also found STUDENT to have many of the behaviors Ms. Langer and Dr. Schrader noted. To address STUDENT’s behaviors, he requires a behavior intervention plan to be implemented by his aide throughout the school day and the consultation services of a behavior analyst. To address his difficulties socializing with peers, STUDENT requires peer models with typical behaviors with whom he can model.
Both Dr. Schrader and Mr. Pieper hypothesized that some of STUDENT’s behavioral difficulties may be related to his language and communication deficits. STUDENT is nonverbal and has recently begun using sign language as his preferred primary mode of communication. (Dist. Exh. 24.) STUDENT has functional receptive language abilities and he appears to understand what is requested or expressed to him in the classroom environment. Expressively, STUDENT is able to use several appropriate signs and is able to imitate signs that are shown to him. Due to STUDENT’s limited language abilities, STUDENT requires exposure to language (both oral and ASL) throughout his school day that focuses on building vocabulary and basic word concepts. He also requires direct speech and language services and language instruction in the classroom to enable him to express his wants and needs, primarily through the use of sign language.
In summary, STUDENT is a nonverbal student who is significantly cognitively impaired. STUDENT functions at approximately the thirty-month level and has a limited attention span. STUDENT exhibits many problem behaviors such as noncompliance and aggression. Additionally, STUDENT has difficulty initiating interactions with peers. As a result of his deficits, STUDENT requires a small, structured class where he can be exposed to language throughout the school day. STUDENT also requires a behavior intervention plan and peer models of typical social interactions. STUDENT’s attention deficits and behavior problems also require that he have individualized attention, particularly a one-to-one aide.
To address STUDENT’s needs, STUDENT’s March 2002 IEP team developed twelve annual goals in the areas of academics, language and communication, motor skills, vocational and safety skills, self-help skills, and recreation and leisure skills. In October 2002, STUDENT’s IEP team added four additional goals and objectives in the area of speech and language following the completion of Ms. Fusfield’s assessment. The appropriateness of the goals and objectives are not at issue in this case.
STUDENT’s March IEP, as amended by subsequent addenda, also called for the provision of related services in the form of a one-to-one behavior aide, four hours per month of behavior aide supervision, two 45-minute sessions per week of direct speech and language therapy, one 45-minute session of direct occupational therapy, and four hours per year of adaptive physical education consultation services. Additionally, for the period from September 23, 2002, through November 20, 2002, STUDENT’s IEP placed him in a special day class at Windsor Middle School. As implemented, STUDENT attended class taught by Ms. Kathy Loftin Donovan. Additionally, Lainie Williams was assigned as his behavioral aide and Marc Pieper was the behavior consultant who supervised Ms. Williams. Ms. Williams worked with STUDENT throughout the school day, implemented his behavior intervention plan, and instructed and interpreted in ASL for STUDENT. Karen Pihl served as STUDENT’s speech and language therapist and Sarah Field served as his occupational therapist.
Petitioner contends that the Respondents’ provided program and services were not designed to meet his needs because he required (1) a curriculum designed for autistic children, (2) a male aide rather than a female aide, (3) a teacher proficient in American Sign Language, (4) opportunities to integrate with his typical peers, (5) occupational therapy that addressed his sensory integration needs, (6) direct adapted physical education services, (7) a site specific behavior intervention plan from September 23, 2002, through October 22, 2002, and (8) a comprehensive BIP from October 22, 2002, through November 20, 2002. Each of Petitioner’s contentions will be addressed in turn below.
1) A curriculum designed for autistic children
Petitioner contends that STUDENT requires a curriculum designed specifically for children with autism. In support of his position, Petitioner offered the testimony of Dr. Griffith, who recommended that STUDENT’s curriculum be developed by an autism specialist. According to Dr. Griffith, “curriculum” refers to the substantive “content” STUDENT is to receive in school (e.g., reading, math, social skills, etc…). Dr. Griffith testified that it is important for STUDENT’s curriculum to be developed by an educational specialist who has experience working with many autistic students and making recommendations regarding educational curriculum, and who can provide ongoing supervision of the educational program. Despite Dr. Griffith’s recommendations, she provided no specifics regarding which of STUDENT’s needs would be met with this specialized curriculum or how STUDENT’s needs were not being met with the curriculum in place at Windsor. Additionally, Dr. Griffith has not taught in the classroom environment and does not have any training or expertise in the development of curricula for autistic children.
The only significant evidence presented at hearing regarding the appropriateness of the curriculum at Windsor came from the testimony of Ms. Hill, the principal of Windsor School, whose training and work experience for the past 20 years has involved educating children with autism. Ms. Hill holds a bachelor’s degree in psychology, a master’s degree in education, and multiple credentials to teach disabled students and to administer educational programs. Ms. Hill has attended trainings related to the field of autism, including training on the development of IEP goals and stardards-based education. Moreover, she has held many employment positions related to the education of autistic children in both the private and public sector.
Ms. Hill testified that she is familiar with the curriculum in Ms. Donovan’s class, she supervises that class as principal of the school, and has visited the class on at least six occasions since the fall of 2002, when STUDENT entered the class. She testified that STUDENT’s program is individualized according to STUDENT’s needs and utilizes many strategies and instructional methods appropriate for autistic children. For example, as mentioned above, STUDENT has difficulty with sustaining attention. Ms. Hill testified that STUDENT’s curriculum allows for frequent breaks between academic activities, and includes picture schedules, positive reinforcement, choices of activities, and sensory integration activities. Additionally, STUDENT’s academic activities are provided in a manner that clearly indicates to him the beginning, middle, and end of the task. From her training and experience in the area of autism and her first-hand knowledge and observation of the curriculum provided in Ms. Donovan’s class, Ms. Hill testified that the curriculum was appropriate for STUDENT. In light of Ms. Hill’s specific and extensive expertise regarding the development and supervision of educational programs for autistic children, the Hearing Officer finds Ms. Hill’s testimony more persuasive than that of Dr. Griffith. Accordingly, the evidence establishes that STUDENT’s curriculum was designed to meet his needs relating to his attention problems.
2) A male aide rather than a female aide
It is undisputed that STUDENT requires a one-to-one aide to assist him with his academics, to manage his behaviors, and to keep him on task. Petitioner argues that STUDENT requires a male aide to accompany him into the restroom. Petitioner’s expert witness, Dr. Griffith, testified generally that STUDENT should be provided with a male aide to assist him with bathrooming. However, no significant evidence was presented that STUDENT had any needs regarding the adaptive skill of bathrooming while at Windsor or that any behavioral issues related to bathrooming could not have been appropriately addressed by his female aide, Ms. Willams.
Although STUDENT experienced incontinence problems while attending school his prior placement at ABC, it is undisputed that no such problems existed while STUDENT attended Windsor. The uncontested evidence established that STUDENT can independently toilet himself and that his incontinence problem of urinating on himself was eliminated at Windsor when he was placed on a toileting schedule, as Dr. Schrader recommended in his report. Although STUDENT did have one incident when he urinated on himself while seated at his desk at Windsor, there is no dispute that the incident was related to his behaviors rather than his incontinence. None of STUDENT’s functional analysis assessments indicated that STUDENT requires a male aide to address such behaviors. In fact, Mr. Pieper’s undisputed testimony establishes that STUDENT’s negative behaviors were addressed through positive behavior intervention strategies, an aide of either gender can appropriately implement those strategies, and that Ms. Williams in fact implemented those strategies. Additionally, STUDENT’s teacher, Ms. Donovan, testified that Ms. Williams appropriately worked with during the school day. From the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the provision of a female aide was designed to meet STUDENT’s need for individualized attention to address his academics, behavior, and attention problems.
3) A teacher proficient in American Sign Language (ASL)
The parties do not dispute that STUDENT requires a language-rich environment where he is exposed to both oral and sign language throughout the school day. Petitioner’s expert witness Dr. Griffith testified that she recommends that STUDENT have a teacher “fluent” in ASL.(Footnote 3) Dr. Griffith reasoned that STUDENT’s teacher must be fluent in ASL to be able to independently assess whether STUDENT is learning in his educational environment. Dr. Griffith provided no reason related to STUDENT’s actual educational needs why it is necessary for his teacher to be fluent in ASL. On the contrary, STUDENT’s speech and language pathologist, Karen Pihl, testified that STUDENT’s teacher does not need to be fluent in ASL. According to Ms. Pihl, persons working with STUDENT must have “functional” signing skills that are more proficient than STUDENT’s skills to be able to adequately assist him in developing his sign language skills.(Footnote 4) There is no dispute that STUDENT’s teacher, Ms. Donovan, had functional ASL skills, or that STUDENT’s aide, Ms. Williams, was proficient in sign language and had more proficient skills than STUDENT. In light of this fact, Ms. Pihl testified that STUDENT was receiving his academic lessons when Ms. Williams was there to interpret Ms. Donovan’s instructions for him.
The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Pihl more persuasive than that of Dr. Griffith. Unlike Ms. Pihl, Dr. Griffith is not a speech and language pathologist and she does not have any direct knowledge of the nature and extent of his language needs. Rather, Dr. Griffith testified that her recommendations were based in large part on a review of STUDENT’s assessments and not on any assessments in this area that she completed herself. Regarding Dr. Griffith’s concern that STUDENT’s teacher be able to assess his learning, Ms. Williams was present with STUDENT throughout the day and was able to provide her with information regarding STUDENT’s progress. Additionally, as is discussed below, Ms. Pihl provided STUDENT with speech and language therapy weekly and is also competent to judge STUDENT’s language development.
In summary, the evidence establishes that STUDENT does not require a teacher fluent in ASL to address his needs. Specifically, the evidence establishes that Ms. Donovan had the functional signing skills necessary to assist STUDENT, and that STUDENT’s need for exposure to sign language in the classroom was met with the services of Ms. Williams, who is proficient in ASL.
4) Occupational therapy that addressed his sensory integration needs
Petitioner contends next that STUDENT was not provided with any occupational therapy services to specifically address his sensory integration needs. This allegation is simply not supported by the evidence. The undisputed testimony of Sarah Field, STUDENT’s occupational therapist, establishes that she provided him services pursuant to his IEP, and that part of those services addressed his sensory integration issues. According to Ms. Field, sensory integration problems are difficulties processing sensory input that is related to the person’s problems with modulating that sensory input. Ms. Field developed the occupational therapy goals in STUDENT’s March 2002 IEP, which included a goal pertaining to his sensory issues. (Dist. Exh. 61 at page 15.) Ms. Field testified that both her work and Ms. Williams’ work with STUDENT addressed his sensory issues. For example, STUDENT was given a menu of sensory activities that he could choose from. Both she and Ms. Williams provided him that menu of choices and assisted him with whatever choice he picked. In light of the undisputed evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the STUDENT’s occupational therapy was designed to meet his needs.
5) Opportunities to integrate with his typical peers
Petitioner contends that he was not provided appropriate opportunities to integrate with his regular education peers. However, he provided no argument or evidence regarding what type or level integration would have been appropriate or why the integration actually provided by Respondents failed to meet his needs. Rather, Ms. Donovan testified that STUDENT was provided many meaningful opportunities to integrate with his nondisabled peers. She stated that STUDENT was integrated with his peers during physical education class. Additionally, STUDENT had the opportunities to integrate with is typical peers when his class went to the library each week or when his class went on its community outings each week. Moreover, typical students were reverse-mainstreamed into STUDENT’s class three times per week for 30-minutes at a time. Based on this uncontroverted evidence that STUDENT was in fact integrated with his nondisabled peers to the extent appropriate, the Hearing Officer finds that this portion of STUDENT’s program was designed to meet his needs.
6) Adapted physical education services
Petitioner argues that STUDENT requires adaptive physical education services provided by a qualified APE specialist and that his program was deficient because his program did not provide for such services. The evidence supports the contrary conclusion. Pursuant to STUDENT’s March IEP, STUDENT attended regular education physical education class and he was to receive four hours of APE consultation services per year. The undisputed testimony of Ms. Hill established that during the month that STUDENT attended school at Windsor, STUDENT’s APE specialist consulted with his educators and service providers to modify his physical education program. Ms. Hill also testified that the APE therapist was present in STUDENT’s classroom and often provided direct APE services to STUDENT’s entire class. Furthermore, Ms. Williams and Ms. Donovan testified that STUDENT was able to participate appropriately during physical education class with the level of APE services that he received.
Although Dr. Griffith testified that she recommended daily “adapted physical therapy,” she acknowledged that her recommendation was based on her belief that he requires such services and not based on any APE assessments that she reviewed or conducted. In fact, Dr. Griffith recommended that an APE assessment be completed to determine the nature and extent of his APE needs, if any. Moreover, there is no indication that Dr. Griffith has any background or expertise in the provision of, or assessment regarding, APE services. In light of the evidence that the APE services provided by Respondents were appropriate for STUDENT, it is concluded that his program was designed to address his APE needs.
7) A site specific behavior intervention plan from September 23, 2002, through October 22, 2002
Petitioner argues next that the Respondents’ program was not designed to meet his needs because it lacked a site-specific behavior intervention plan from September 23 through October 22, 2002, to address his behavioral difficulties. Although it is undisputed that no site-specific behavior intervention plan was in place between September 23, 2002, and October 22, 2002, the Hearing Officer concludes that it was not practicable for one to be developed during this time frame. Additionally, the Hearing Officer finds that an appropriate behavior plan was otherwise in place to address Petitioner’s behavioral needs.
As noted above, STUDENT began attending Windsor School full time on September 23, 2002. It is undisputed that prior to STUDENT’s transition to Windsor, a functional analysis assessment (FAA) of STUDENT’s behavior was conducted by Dr. Carl Schrader. By all accounts, Dr. Schrader’s FAA was intended to provide parameters to address STUDENT’s behaviors at his county placement, which later was determined to be Windsor. Moreover, STUDENT’s IEP team agreed in August 2002 that another FAA was to be conducted upon STUDENT’s transition for the purpose of developing a behavior plan for STUDENT specific to his Windsor placement. According to the undisputed testimony of Christina Olstad, the assistant director at the Spectrum Center and someone who has extensive experience developing and implementing BIPs, behavior intervention plans typically take about thirty days to develop. Because STUDENT’s behavior at Windsor had to be analyzed before a site-specific BIP could be developed, no site-specific behavior plan could have been developed for STUDENT until after he had entered Windsor and enough time had passed for the FAA to be completed. Considering that the assessment was arranged prior to STUDENT’s entering Windsor and was conducted soon after he began school there, the Respondents acted promptly and appropriately to address STUDENT’s behavioral needs. Furthermore, because it is undisputed that Dr. Schrader’s FAA and BIP were comprehensive and appropriate, the Hearing Officer finds that the temporary implementation of that BIP was appropriate for transitional purposes pending the development of a site-specific plan.(Footnote 5)
8) A comprehensive BIP from October 22, 2002, through November 20, 2002
Petitioner argues that the BIP developed by Marc Pieper and presented to the IEP team on October 22, 2002, was not designed to meet his needs because it was not adequately comprehensive. Specifically, Petitioner contends that Mr. Pieper spent only three hours doing observations of him in the classroom and that three hours is insufficient time to collect information upon which to base an appropriate plan. Additionally, Petitioner asserts that the BIP did not provide for a toileting plan and failed to address his vocalizations, obsessive compulsive behaviors like cutting with scissors, and his behavior of putting foreign objects in his mouth.
Although Petitioner claims that three hours of observation time is insufficient, he does not state or provide evidence as to how much time is appropriate or how the lack of observation time affected the BIP that was developed. Rather, the undisputed testimony of behaviorists Marc Pieper and Andrew Bailey establishes that the average time spent conducting observations for FAAs is typically three hours and that three hours was sufficient time to observe STUDENT to develop his BIP. In fact, Dr. Schrader indicated in his report that he also spent three hours observing STUDENT in conducting his FAA.
The evidence also establishes that Mr. Pieper’s BIP did not need to include a toileting plan and failed to address his vocalizations, obsessive compulsive behaviors like cutting with scissors, and his behavior of putting foreign objects in his mouth. Contrary to Petitioner’s contention, STUDENT’s vocalizations were in fact addressed in Mr. Pieper’s BIP. On page five of his report, Mr. Pieper lists “growling, or making louder tonal responses” as possible precursor behaviors to noncompliance or aggression. Throughout his BIP, Mr. Pieper discussed strategies to address STUDENT’s noncompliance and aggression.
Third, although Petitioner claims that Mr. Pieper’s plan did not address his toileting issues, his behavior of cutting paper with scissors, and his behavior of putting foreign objects in his mouth, there is no evidence that any of these behaviors significantly affected his education. As noted above, STUDENT did not have any toileting problems due to incontinence. To the extent that his urination was related to his noncompliance or attention seeking behaviors, those behaviors were addressed in the BIP. Additionally, as Dr. Griffith acknowledged, cutting paper with scissors is an activity that STUDENT prefers and can be appropriately used to calm him when he is agitated. There is no significant evidence that STUDENT inappropriately perseverated on the activity of cutting paper with scissors. Rather, Ms. Williams and Ms. Field testified that STUDENT could be successfully redirected from this activity. Moreover, STUDENT’s educators and service providers testified that he was not observed putting inappropriate objects in his mouth. Because these behaviors were either absent from the educational environment or occurred so sporadically that they did not significantly impact his education, there was no need to develop behavior strategies to address them in the BIP.
In summary, the evidence establishes that three hours was sufficient time to observe STUDENT as part of the FAA. Additionally, Marc Pieper’s BIP adequately addressed STUDENT’s vocalizations and no additional strategies were needed to address his behaviors related to toileting, cutting with scissors, or putting inappropriate objects in his mouth.
B. Conformed with STUDENT’s IEP
As noted above, Petitioner’s February 2002 IEP called for two forty-five-minute sessions per week of individual speech and language therapy, for a total of 90 minutes of services per week. Petitioner contends that the program provided by the District failed to comport with his IEP because Respondents failed to provide him with one 45-minute session per week of speech and language therapy. The evidence does not support Petitioner’s position.
Karen Pihl, the speech and language pathologist responsible for providing STUDENT with his language services, testified that she provided STUDENT with all of the services required by his IEP. Specifically, she testified that she was present in STUDENT’s class for four to five hours on Mondays every week that STUDENT attended school at Windsor.(Footnote 6) According to Ms. Pihl, STUDENT could not tolerate more than 25 minutes of direct speech and language therapy at one time due to his attention problems. Thus, she provided the full 90 minutes of speech and language services to which he was entitled in shorter sessions and at various settings within his class during the four to five hours that she was present in the class. During her time with STUDENT, Ms. Pihl worked towards developing rapport and worked on communication activities relating to verbal communication, phonemic awareness, and facilitating oral speech. Given Ms. Pihl’s undisputed testimony that she provided STUDENT with his required 90 minutes of speech and language services per week, the evidence establishes that STUDENT’s program and services comported with his IEP.
****
In conclusion, with regard to the portions of his education that were challenged for the timeframe of September 23 through November 20, 2002, it was found above that the Respondents provided STUDENT with services that were designed to meet his needs and that comported with his March 2002 IEP. However, the evidence shows that STUDENT’s behaviors were not in control while he was at Windsor, and those behaviors led to his suspension and the Respondents’ recommendation to change his placement. Although it was determined above that the portions of STUDENT’s program that Petitioner challenged were appropriate to address certain specific needs, the evidence indicates that STUDENT’s classroom placement was not appropriate for him. At hearing, Mr. Pieper testified that STUDENT’s placement in the special day class at Windsor was not appropriate for him due to the multitude of variables in the environment that are triggers for STUDENT’s aggression and noncompliance and that cannot be controlled. According to Mr. Pieper, no behavior plan could adequately address STUDENT’s behavior in that classroom placement. Similarly, Ms. Williams testified that she implemented Dr. Schrader’s plan (e.g., she helped him prepare for transitions, gave him sensory breaks between academic activities, and redirected him and taught him replacement behaviors), STUDENT still responded with aggression toward her and other students.
To address the inappropriate placement, the Respondents appropriately convened an IEP meeting on November 20, 2002, to discuss a change to a more restrictive setting. Because STUDENT was only at Windsor for a short period of time (i.e., five weeks), because the placement there became inappropriate towards the end of his attendance at Windsor, and because the Respondents acted promptly and appropriately at address the inappropriate aspects of STUDENT’s program, no compensatory education or other remedy is warranted regarding this time period.(Footnote 7)
II. Was Respondents’ November 20, 2002 offer procedurally and substantively appropriate?
As noted above, both State law and the IDEA guarantee students with disabilities the right to a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment. 20 U.S.C. ' 1400; Education Code ' 56000. The right to a FAPE also includes the important entitlement to certain procedural protections during the process of developing an individualized education program for a disabled child. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992); Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 205 (1982). In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, the Supreme Court recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA as part of the provision of FAPE. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 205 (1982). Procedural flaws, however, do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE. Only procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).
Accordingly, the analysis of whether a student has been provided a free appropriate public education (FAPE) is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to decide both whether procedural steps have been followed and whether the proposed placement and program are substantively appropriate. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206208.
As noted above, Petitioner’s IEP team convened on November 20, 2002, after Petitioner’s suspension to discuss the appropriateness of his placement at Windsor. At that meeting, without the parents in attendance, the educational members of the team recommended that Petitioner’s placement be changed to Spectrum. Other than the change of placement, all other aspects of Petitioner’s program were to remain the same as indicated on his March 2002 IEP. Petitioner challenges the District’s offer of placement on both procedural and substantive grounds.
A. Procedural Appropriateness
Petitioner contends that the Respondents violated his procedural rights by (1) failing to meet the Union requirement, as discussed more fully below, of a formal written offer of placement and, (2) failing to provide him with prior written notice of their intent to change his placement from an SDC to a nonpublic school.
1. Formal written offer of placement
Among the procedural violations that may constitute a denial of FAPE is the failure of a school district to make a formal, written offer of placement in compliance with the IDEA=s procedural requirements. Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert denied, 513 U.S. 965, 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994); see also 20 U.S.C. ' 1415(b)(3) (1997). In Union, the Ninth Circuit stated, AWe find that this formal requirement has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe it should be enforced rigorously.@ Union, 15 F.3d at 1526. The Court went on to discuss the reasons for imposing the requirement: (1) to alert the parents of the need to consider seriously whether the school district=s proposed placement is appropriate under the IDEA; (2) to help the parents determine whether to oppose or accept the placement with supplemental services; and (3) so that the school district is more prepared to introduce sufficient relevant evidence of the appropriateness of the placement at a due process hearing. Id. The Court was unequivocal in stating that “this formal requirement has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe it should be enforced rigorously.” Id.
Petitioner asserts that Respondents failed to make a formal written offer of placement at the November 20, 2002 IEP meeting because the IEP does not set forth the specific related services Petitioner is to be provided. Although Petitioner acknowledges that the November 2002 IEP states that it is an addendum to an IEP concluded on March 25, 2002, that lists his specific related services, Petitioner argues that the failure to restate the specific services in the November IEP is a violation of the requirements of Union.(Footnote 8)
Petitioner misunderstands the law and argues form over substance. While the IDEA and Union require local educational agencies to make a formal written offer of placement, the law does not require that the offer be contained in only one document. In determining whether a Union offer had been made, the Hearing Office has consistently considered offers contained in a collection of documents. (See Student v. San Jose Unified School District, et al., SN99-01033.) The face of the November 20, 2002 IEP clearly indicates that it is an addendum to a previous IEP. According to the IEP, the purpose of the IEP meeting was solely to discuss the change of placement to Spectrum Center. Additionally, prior to the meeting, Petitioner’s representatives visited the Spectrum Center and they understood that Spectrum would be offered as a placement for STUDENT. Moreover, the parties do not dispute that the related services Respondents offered Petitioner were those contained in the March 25 IEP. Therefore, Petitioner was well aware of the Respondents’ offer of placement and the specific related services that were to be provided to STUDENT. Because the November IEP is clear that its purpose is to change only one portion of the previously accepted educational program and the portions that Petitioner contends are missing from the November IEP are contained in the March IEP, there is no need to go through the technical exercise of restating the portions of the educational program that were not the subject of the IEP meeting. In light of the March and November 2002 IEPs, the Hearing Officer finds that Respondents satisfied the requirement of a formal written offer of placement.
2. Prior written notice Special education law requires that districts provide parents written notice of a proposal or refusal to initiate or change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child or the provision of FAPE. 20 U.S.C. §1415(b) and 34 C.F.R. § 300.503. Petitioner argues that the Respondents were required by law to provide him the notice before the November 20 IEP of the intent to change his placement to the Spectrum Center, and that they failed to do so. Thus, Petitioner disputes only the timing of the notice and does not dispute the appropriateness of the notice that was provided. Regardless of when the written notice was provided to Petitioner, the evidence establishes that Petitioner understood weeks before the November 20, 2002 IEP meeting that the purpose of the meeting was to discuss his possible change of placement to address his behavioral issues. (Test. of MOTHER; Dist. Exhs. 2-7, 11, 14-15 and 17.) Prior to the November 20 IEP meeting, Petitioner’s parents toured various placements Respondents had considered for him, including the Spectrum Center that was later offered to Petitioner. Furthermore, Petitioner was sufficiently familiar with his rights to have filed a compliance complaint with the State in the past and two due process hearing requests, including the present case. From the above, the evidence establishes that Petitioner had adequate notice of the Respondents’ proposal to change his placement prior to the November 20 IEP meeting. Therefore, any violation of the “prior written notice” requirement Petitioner asserts would have been purely technical in nature and did not result in any prejudice to him.
B. Substantive Appropriateness
For the time period from November 20, 2002 forward, Petitioner’s needs were essentially the same as discussed at length above. In short, STUDENT is a nonverbal student who is significantly cognitively impaired. STUDENT functions at approximately the thirty-month level and has a limited attention span. STUDENT exhibits many problem behaviors such as noncompliance and aggression. Additionally, STUDENT has difficulty initiating interactions with peers. As a result of his deficits, STUDENT requires a small, structured, language-rich classroom environment. Additionally, STUDENT requires individualized attention, behavioral intervention, and peer models for social interaction.
The only difference in this time period was the level of STUDENT’s behavioral needs. From the undisputed testimony of Petitioner’s educators and service providers, his aggressive behaviors became more frequent and more intensive during the month he attended Windsor. As noted in a behavioral log kept by Ms. Williams and other staff at Windsor, STUDENT exhibited approximately sixteen acts of aggression against his peers and his aide. The acts of aggression included grabbing, pushing, hitting, punching, spitting, and attempting to pour water on other students’ heads. Ms. Williams testified that STUDENT appeared to target some of his aggression at a blind autistic student in his class. Ms. Williams appeared also to be a target of STUDENT’s aggression. Thus, STUDENT also requires an environment with less stimulation and where his behaviors can be controlled.
Ultimately, his aggression against Ms. Williams on October 23 and 24 led to his suspension and the District’s recommended change of placement to Spectrum Center. The Spectrum Center is a certified nonpublic school located in San Pablo, California that serves special education students. According to Christina Olstad, the assistant director at Spectrum, approximately 75% of the students at Spectrum are autistic. The classroom recommended for STUDENT by the District is taught by Alex Ruth. Mr. Ruth teaches a class of ten autistic students with the assistance of four instructional aides. Mr. Ruth is currently being taught sign language by a Spectrum speech and language therapist. Mr. Ruth’s class schedule includes time for direct instruction and small group instruction, physical education, social skills activities, personal hygiene activities, the provision of related services, and community-based instruction. Additionally, Mr. Ruth uses picture schedules in his class to assist the students to transition between activities.
Other than the change of placement to Spectrum, all other aspects of STUDENT’s March IEP were to remain the same. As noted above, STUDENT’s March IEP, as amended by subsequent addenda, called for the provision of related services in the form of a one-to-one behavior aide, four hours per month of behavior aide supervision, two 45-minute sessions per week of direct speech and language therapy, one 45-minute session of direct occupational therapy, and four hours per year of adaptive physical education consultation services. The aide that would work with STUDENT on an individual basis has functional sign language skills and currently works with a student who uses sign language. Ms. Olstad testified that the aide can sign approximately 100 signs. Additionally, Ms. Olstad testified that STUDENT’s speech and language therapy would likely be provided by Kirsty Asher, a speech and language pathologist who has functional sign language skills. The occupational therapist at Spectrum has extensive training in sensory integration issues and would be the one implmenting STUDENT’s occupational therapy goals and objectives. Moreover, Spectrum has an on-site adaptive physical education specialist who provides APE services everyday to the students and would be available to provide STUDENT services and make modifications in his physical education program.
Petitioner also asserts that Respondents offer was substantively inappropriate because it failed to include (1) the services of a male aide proficient in ASL for 360 minutes per day, (2) speech and language services for two thirty-minute sessions per day by a therapist fluent in ASL, (3) 10-15 minutes per day of occupational therapy exercises to address his sensory integration problems, (4) a curriculum designed for autistic children, and (5) adaptive physical education services. Additionally, Petitioner asserts that the Respondents’ offer of a nonpublic school placement is too restrictive, and that a placement in a public special day class with a student to teacher ratio of six-to-one is the least restrictive environment for him.
1. Services of male aide for 360 minutes per day
Petitioner argues that Respondents’ November 2002 offered program is not designed to meet his needs because it does not include the services of male aide for 360 minutes per day. As was concluded above, STUDENT’s behavioral needs can be appropriately addressed with the services of a female aide. Moreover, although Petitioner asserts he requires aide services for 360 minutes per day, the District’s offered program at Spectrum was to last 300 minutes per day. Because the purpose of STUDENT’s aide is to assist him during his school day, there is no justification for providing him aide services beyond the school day. Accordingly, the offer of a female aide for STUDENT’s entire school day at Spectrum was designed to meet his needs.
2. Speech and language services for two thirty-minute sessions per day from a therapist fluent in ASL
As noted above, STUDENT needs exposure to both oral and sign language throughout his school day. Due to his limited language abilities, STUDENT requires instruction on building vocabulary and the use of language to express his wants and needs. Because sign language is emerging as STUDENT’s primary mode of communication, his language instruction must include the instruction of sign language. Petitioner contends that he requires direct speech and language services twice daily from a speech and language therapist fluent in ASL. Dr. Griffith testified that STUDENT requires two sessions per day of speech and language services to assist STUDENT to build his vocabulary, sentence structure, and verbal language. Although there is no disagreement that STUDENT requires exposure to language throughout his school day, Ms. Pihl, STUDENT’s speech and language pathologist, disagrees that STUDENT requires the level of speech and language services recommended by Dr. Griffith. Rather, she testified that two 45-minute sessions of direct speech and language services per week were appropriate to meet Petitioner’s needs.
For the same reasons stated above regarding Ms. Pihl’s expertise in speech and language as compared to Dr. Griffith’s and her direct knowledge of STUDENT’s language needs, the Hearing Officer finds Ms. Pihl’s testimony regarding STUDENT’s speech and language needs more persuasive. With regard to Petitioner’s contention that STUDENT requires a speech and language pathologist “fluent” in ASL, it was also determined above that STUDENT’s service providers only need to have functional ASL skills that are more advanced than STUDENT’s. According to Ms. Pihl, it is important for STUDENT’s speech and language pathologist to be able to sign words conveying wants and needs. Ms. Pihl testified that the therapist must know enough sign language to implement STUDENT’s language program. Because the Respondents’ offered program included speech and language services of appropriate frequency and duration to be provided by a therapist proficient in ASL, this portion of Respondents’ offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s language and communication needs.
3. 10-15 minutes per day of OT exercises to address his sensory integration problems
Petitioner contends next that the Respondents’ offered program was not designed to meet his sensory integration needs because it did not include ten to fifteen minutes per day of sensory integration exercises. The evidence established that the program includes a minimum of fifteen minutes per day of sensory integration exercises. Respondents do not dispute that STUDENT requires the frequency and duration of sensory integration exercises incorporated into his school day as Petitioner requests. According to Christina Olstad, the assistant director of the Spectrum Center, the educational placement and program offered to STUDENT at Spectrum would include a minimum of fifteen minutes of sensory integration exercises per day. She also described that Spectrum has an “explorer zone room” that includes a rock climbing wall and a variety of seeing, touching, and smelling activities for the students to experience. Ms. Olstad’s testimony was not disputed by Petitioner. In light of Ms. Olstad’s uncontested testimony, the Hearing Officer concludes that the Respondents’ offer included the appropriate amount of sensory integration exercises to meet STUDENT’s needs.
4. A curriculum designed for autistic children
Petitioner also asserts that the Spectrum placement offer was inappropriate because it lacked a curriculum designed for autistic children. Again, Petitioner provided no support for his contention and the evidence establishes otherwise. The undisputed testimony of Ms. Olstad establishes that the curriculum offered to STUDENT is based on methodologies and instructional strategies commonly utilized for autistic children. For example, Ms. Olstad testified that the class curriculum offered to STUDENT includes picture schedules, predictable and consistent routines, sensory integration exercises, community-based instruction, and lots of positive reinforcement. Additionally, Ms. Olstad testified that a student’s IEP would drive the curriculum and that the physical education curriculum is developed by the APE specialist and the language portions of the curriculum are developed by the speech and language pathologist. From Ms. Olstad’s undisputed testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that the Respondents did offer a program with a curriculum designed to meet STUDENT’s needs as an autistic student.
5. Adaptive physical education services
Petitioner also contends that the Respondents’ offer failed to include necessary APE services. Petitioner does not indicate how much APE services is necessary other than that the services should be provided every day. The evidence establishes that the APE services at Spectrum are appropriate for Petitioner. Respondents do not dispute that STUDENT requires some APE services as part of his program. Ms. Olstad testified that the Spectrum Center has an on-site adaptive physical education specialist that provides APE services to all of the students at Spectrum. Moreover, she testified that the students at Spectrum participate in APE activities every day. Ms. Olstad’s testimony was not disputed. Even if STUDENT required APE services each day as Petitioner asserted, those services would be provided to him at Spectrum as Ms. Olstad testified. In light of the evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the Respondents’ offer included appropriate APE services to address his needs.
6. Least restrictive environment
Finally, Petitioner contends that the placement offer at Spectrum is not the least restrictive environment for him. Although he agrees that the Windsor placement is no longer appropriate, he requests a different special day class within the county that has a teacher-to-student ratio of one-to-six. In determining whether a placement is the least restrictive environment, the courts have indicated four factors to be considered. Those factors include: (1) the educational benefits available to the child in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared to the educational benefits of a special education classroom; (2) the non-academic benefits to the handicapped child of interaction with nonhandicapped children; (3) the effect of the presence of the handicapped child on the teacher and other children in the regular classroom; and (4) the costs of supplementary aids and services necessary to mainstream the handicapped child in a regular classroom setting. Sacramento City Unif. School Dist. v. Rachel H., (9th Cir. 1994) 14 F.3d 1398.
The balancing of the four factors weigh in favor finding that Spectrum is the least restrictive environment for STUDENT. First, the education benefits of attending Spectrum is that Spectrum is better able to control STUDENT’s behaviors and to teach him strategies to manage his behaviors. As was noted above, STUDENT’s behaviors, particularly his aggression, increased when he attended the public special day class. There is no dispute that STUDENT’s behaviors are the difficulties most immediately affecting his ability to access his education. These behaviors increased despite STUDENT’s being provided a one-to-one behavioral aide, a behavioral consultant, a behavior plan, and a multitude of supports within his environment to address his language and sensory integration deficits. STUDENT’s behavioral consultant, Marc Pieper, testified that STUDENT’s behaviors cannot be appropriately controlled at a public school due to the multitude of variables that exist in the environment. According to Mr. Pieper, a behavior intervention plan cannot be developed to cover all of the possible environmental situations at the public school that may trigger STUDENT’s aggressive behaviors.
In comparison, Spectrum offers a more controlled educational environment with fewer students and more physical locations (such as empty classrooms) where students can go to deescalate from their behavior. Additionally, STUDENT would be provided increased support for his behavioral needs at Spectrum, support that is not available at a public school campus. Ms. Olstad testified that the class offered to STUDENT has an adult-to-student ratio of approximately one-to-two. In addition to the adults in the class, a number of other Spectrum staff with extensive education and experience in autism and behavior management (e.g., the educational coordinator, senior clinician, clinical director) are available to assist in addressing the behaviors of students in the class. Ms. Olstad testified that Spectrum applies positive behavior intervention strategies to address negative behaviors and the students’ programs are constantly monitored to ensure that their behavior intervention plans are implemented appropriately. Thus, Spectrum offers STUDENT better educational benefits than a public special day class.
Second, although the non-academic benefit of STUDENT is attending a public special day class is that he would be on a campus with typical peers with whom he can socialize, there is indication that STUDENT’s behaviors affected his ability to integrate with his regular education peers. According to Ms. Williams, STUDENT was removed from his regular education physical education class on occasion due to his loud vocalizations. According to Mr. Pieper, those vocalizations are possible precursors to STUDENT’s noncompliant or aggressive behaviors. Because Spectrum serves only special education students, he would not have the same opportunity to be on a campus with his regular education peers. However, Ms. Olstad testified that many students at Spectrum do not have behavioral challenges and they could serve as behavior models for STUDENT. Moreover, the curriculum at Spectrum includes community-based instruction that allows the students to be taken into the community to learn adaptive living skills. Hence, while STUDENT would have more opportunities to integrate with nondisabled peers at a public school campus, his behaviors interfere with his ability to appropriately access those opportunities.
Third, STUDENT’s presence in the special day class at Windsor had negative effects on his aide and the other students. Ms. Williams testified that while she initially enjoyed working with STUDENT and made best efforts to support his success, she feared for her safety after he shoved, kicked, punched, and spit on her on October 23 and 24. Her concern for her safety eventually led to her decision not to work as STUDENT’s aide anymore. Ms. Williams also testified that because of STUDENT’s height and large size, she was concerned about the ability to control his aggression towards other students. According to Ms. Williams, the students in STUDENT’s class were initially very accepting of STUDENT. However, as his aggressive behaviors increased, the students became increasingly cautious around him and concerned for their own safety. Similarly, the SCOE assistant superintendent for special education programs testified that he was also concerned about the safety of his staff and the other students. During an observation he did of STUDENT the day STUDENT was suspended, Mr. Moe observed students seated at a table immediately move away from the table when STUDENT sat down. Moreover, Ms. Donovan, STUDENT’s teacher, testified that she spoke with Ms. Williams daily about how to address STUDENT’s behaviors. Because STUDENT’s behaviors intensified despite their efforts, Ms. Donovan testified that she has concerns about the safety of her staff and her ability to stop STUDENT’s aggression towards others should he return to her special day class. From the above, the evidence established that STUDENT’s presence in the special day class caused the staff and students in the class to fear for their safety.
With regard to the fourth factor, no evidence was provided regarding the costs of any of STUDENT’s services. Because the Respondents continued to offer STUDENT at Spectrum the same related services provided under his March 2002 IEP, the costs of these services are not anticipated to be significantly different. In any event, the parties did not dispute this cost factor.
In balancing the factors above, the Hearing Officer finds that Spectrum is better able to address STUDENT’s behaviors and the placement at Spectrum would likely avoid the negative impact of his presence in the SDC class on the teachers and students described above. Although Petitioner would clearly have more opportunities to integrate and socialize with his regular education peers in an SDC class at an integrated public school, his behavioral issues appear to affect the success of that integration. In light of Petitioner’s increased behavioral problems and the immediate need to control his behaviors for him to access his education, the Hearing Officer concludes that the Spectrum Center is currently the least restrictive environment for STUDENT where his unique needs can be addressed.
****
In conclusion, it was determined above that the Respondents did not commit any procedural violations that denied Petitioner a FAPE. The Respondents’ November 20, 2002 offer met the Union requirement, and Petitioner had adequate notice of the Respondents’ proposed change of placement. Additionally, with regard to the portions of the offer that Petitioner disputed, it was found above that Respondents’ offer was designed to meet Petitioner’s needs and was provided in the least restrictive environment. There was no significant allegation that STUDENT would not have benefitted from the program offered at Spectrum or that the program would not have comported with his November 20 IEP. Therefore, the November 20 offer was an offer of FAPE.
III. Does the law require Respondents to convene an IEP meeting and to change Petitioner’s behavior intervention plan prior to suspending him for up to ten days?
Petitioner asserts that the law requires Respondents to inquire as to whether portions of his program required to be changed before suspending him. Petitioner cites the California Code of Regulations at Section 3052, which governs positive behavioral interventions, as support for his position. Petitioner also asserts that, because Respondents failed to convene an IEP meeting to change his BIP, Respondents inappropriately suspended him. The Respondents contend that the law does not require the District to convene an IEP meeting for any suspensions of up to ten cumulative days and that the suspension was appropriate.
Both federal and State law provide procedures and standards for imposing discipline on a disabled student. Generally, a district has broad powers to discipline a special education student in much the same way as a student not eligible for special education. 34 C.F.R. § 300.520. The procedural protections for students with disabilities arise only when there is a disciplinary change of placement, which the regulations define as a suspension lasting more than 10 days. 34 C.F.R. § 300.519.
While the federal and State special education law pertaining to the discipline of a disabled child require districts contemplating a suspension of more than ten school days to convene an IEP meeting prior to the disciplinary action to determine, among other things, that the student’s placement was appropriate at the time of the behavioral incident, the law is void of any such requirement pertaining to disciplinary actions of ten days or less.(footnote 9) Specifically, the requirement in Section 300.520(b)(1)(ii) of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations that the IEP team review and/or modify the student’s existing behavior intervention plan is triggered only after the student has been suspended for more than ten school days in a school year. Moreover, according to the comments to the federal regulations, interpreting the law relating to discipline to allow a window of ten days when a child may be removed from his or her placement without educational services or special procedural protections gives school officials “reasonable flexibility for dealing with minor infractions of school rules by children with disabilities, yet ensures that…[they] are not cut off from educational services and that their behavior is appropriately addressed.” Because Petitioner was not suspended for more than ten school days during the school year, and because the law does not require the Respondents to convene an IEP meeting to review and or modify his BIP prior to such a suspension, the Hearing Officer finds that the Respondents appropriately suspended Petitioner.
IV. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for costs of private sign language tutoring services procured for Petitioner?
Petitioner requests reimbursement of his private sign language tutoring provided by Deanna Downing from November 11, 2002, through the date of the decision. Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under IDEA and are reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985). It was found above that Respondents’ placement, although not inappropriate on the grounds asserted by Petitioner, became inappropriate towards the last weeks in October that Petitioner attended school there. From October 25 through November 11, 2002, Petitioner was appropriately suspended by Respondents. Following November 11, 2002, Petitioner’s parents waived stay put and therefore, were not entitled to any educational services during that time. Moreover, it was found above that the Respondents offered Petitioner a FAPE at the November 20, 2002 IEP meeting.
Therefore, the only time period that Petitioner may be entitled to reimbursement is from November 12 through November 20, 2002. During this time, the Respondents attempted to schedule an IEP meeting with the PARENTS, but one of those meetings (which was scheduled for November 13, 2002) was cancelled by the PARENTS. Because Respondents were attempting to correct the deficiency in its program during this time and because Petitioner waived his right to services he would otherwise have been entitled to under stay put, the Hearing Officer concludes that no reimbursement is warranted in this case. Therefore, Petitioner’s request for reimbursement is denied.
ORDER
1. The District’s November 20, 2002 offer of Spectrum was appropriate and in the least restrictive environment. The PARENTS shall make STUDENT available for his placement at Spectrum if they wish him to have a publicly funded education.
2. All of Petitioner’s requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: Respondents prevailed on all of the issues decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
DATED: October 30, 2002 ____________________________________ Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The issues here were renumbered for the purpose of proper analysis. 2. Petitioner’s original request for hearing was sent to the Hearing Office by fax on November 11, 2002. However, the request did not include all of the necessary information to open a case for Petitioner. The information was later provided to the Hearing Office on November 15, 2002. 3. Dr. Griffith made no recommendation regarding the required ASL proficiency of STUDENT’s teacher in her February 2002 report. (Student Exh. M.). Thus, the only evidence from Dr. Griffith regarding her recommendations for STUDENT’s teacher was her testimony at hearing. 4. The Hearing Officer notes, as stated above, that STUDENT is nonverbal but is not deaf or hard of hearing. Rather, STUDENT appears to prefer sign language as his primary mode of communication. 5. The Hearing Officer is also satisfied that Dr. Schrader’s recommendations were actually implemented by Respondents. Ms. Williams and Mr. Pieper, the persons responsible for implementing the plan at Windsor, both testified that Dr. Schrader’s plan was implemented and gave specific examples of how the plan was implemented. This evidence is also supported by the testimony of Ms. Donovan and other witnesses who observed STUDENT in his program. Although Petitioner appeared to contend that one or more of the recommendations were not implemented, the evidence did not support Petitioner’s contention. Regardless, Dr. Schrader wrote in his report that his recommendations were to be “used as a guide rather than as a rigid program plan.” (Dist. Exh. 48 at pg. 5 of report.) Thus, according to Dr. Schrader, total implementation of his plan was not necessary for the plan to be appropriate. 6. As noted above, STUDENT was suspended on October 25, 2002, for ten school days. Following the end of his suspension on November 11, 2002, STUDENT’s parents chose not to return him to school at Windsor and not to pursue STUDENT’s stay put placement or services there. (See Dist. Exh. 10.) Therefore, STUDENT was not available for, and the Respondents were not required to provide, speech and language services pursuant to his IEP from November 11, 2002, through the end of the hearing. 7. As noted above, STUDENT started school full-time at Windsor on September 23, 2002. He was suspended for ten days on October 25, 2002, and his suspension ended during the second week of November. Following the end of the suspension, STUDENT’s parents waived their right to stay put. 8. The March 25, 2002 IEP was begun on February 27, 2002, and concluded on March 25. (Pet. Exhs. A and B.) 9. Federal law provides that, if disciplinary action is contemplated involving a change of placement for more than 10 days, no “later than 10 school days after the date on which the decision to take that action is made, a review shall be conducted of the relationship between the child’s disability and the behavior subject to the disciplinary action.” 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(4)(A)(ii) (1997). If, in conducting the review, the team determines that the behavior which is the subject of the discipline was not a manifestation of his/her disability, the disabled student may be disciplined in the same way as a nondisabled student. Moreover, if the review results in a determination that the student’s IEP was deficient, the IEP team “must take immediate steps to remedy those deficiencies.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.523(f).
