California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 9, 2004
Student v. Capistrano Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 2569-03 · Hearing Officer Christian M. Knox
Capistrano Unified offered a three-year-old with autism a FAPE; Hearing Officer denies IEE reimbursement and all other relief.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted. An earlier December 17, 2003 stay-put order required 48 hours per month of IBI with 6 hours per month of supervision but did not require that Coyne & Associates provide them.
Summary
The parents of a three-year-old boy with autism filed for due process against Capistrano Unified School District. He was moving from regional center services, which included 12 hours a week of in-home individual behavior intervention (IBI). In November 2003 the District offered a structured autism preschool class at Oak Grove Elementary. The offer included 10 hours a week of IBI, split between home and school, plus speech, occupational therapy and parent training. The parents argued that the District made procedural errors, assessed him inadequately, wrote goals that were too low, and offered too few services. They sought reimbursement for four independent evaluations and private speech therapy, plus compensatory services.
Hearing Officer Christian M. Knox ruled for the District on every issue. The IEP team considered the Coyne & Associates report because its author presented it at the meeting. No IEP meeting is required to consider independent evaluations, and District staff reviewed each one. Limiting the independent psychologist to 20-minute classroom visits still gave her an equivalent chance to observe. The father took meaningful part in the meeting. The District's occupational therapy, speech-language and psychoeducational assessments were found comprehensive and valid. The goals were measurable and suited the student's trouble generalizing skills. The language-based autism preschool and related services were reasonably calculated to give him some educational benefit under Rowley. The parents' requests for reimbursement and compensatory education were denied.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO handled independent evaluations. It held that districts must consider them but need not hold an IEP meeting to do so. A limit on how long observations last can still give an evaluator an equivalent opportunity to observe. And a parent's prompt due process filing excused the district's failure to fund the evaluations or file its own hearing request.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1A. Did the District commit a procedural violation by failing to consider the Coyne & Associates report at the November 18, 2003 IEP meeting?
The report was considered: its author presented it orally at the meeting and District team members reviewed it there.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 1B. Did the District commit a procedural violation by failing to initiate a due process hearing or pay for the independent educational evaluations secured by the parents?
Student filed for due process 12 days after giving notice of the IEEs and raised IEE reimbursement, so the District's failure to fund or file caused no prejudice and did not deny FAPE.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 1C. Did the District commit a procedural violation by failing to convene an IEP meeting to consider the independent assessments by Laurie Cohen, Abby Rozenberg, and ACES, Inc.?
The law requires the District to consider IEEs, not to hold an IEP meeting about them. District providers reviewed each IEE and would not have changed their recommendations.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 1D. Did the District fail to timely and appropriately allow Dr. Davidson and Mr. Ochoa to observe the proposed placements?
The 20-minute observation limit still gave Dr. Davidson an equivalent opportunity under Ed. Code 56329(b). Mr. Ochoa was not an independent evaluator, so he had no right to observe.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1E. Was the father denied an opportunity to meaningfully participate in the November 2003 IEP meeting because placement, services and goals were predetermined?
The father attended a two-hour meeting with counsel, his input was sought repeatedly, and no predetermination was shown.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 2. Did the District appropriately assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability for the November 18, 2003 IEP?
The occupational therapy, speech-language and psychoeducational assessments were comprehensive, used valid tools, were done by qualified staff and met Ed. Code 56320. Using an older Sensory Profile version did not make the OT assessment invalid.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. Did the District substantively deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 regular school year?
Present levels and goals were appropriate and measurable. The structured autism preschool, 10 hours a week of IBI split between home and school, the supervision, and the OT and speech services were reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 4a. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for the independent educational evaluations by Abby M. Rozenberg, Laurie Cohen, ACES, Inc., and Dr. Christine Davidson?
The District's assessments were appropriate, so no IEE reimbursement was owed.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4b. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for speech and language services provided at his parents' expense?
No FAPE denial, so no reimbursement for private speech therapy or related transportation.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4c. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education consisting of additional speech and language, occupational therapy, and behavioral therapy services?
No FAPE denial and the assessments were appropriate, so no compensatory education was awarded.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- All of Petitioner's claims for relief were denied. Separately, a post-hearing motion to compel stay put was denied as moot, and a motion to exclude the District's consulting attorney was denied.
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist.; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; T.S. v. Bd. of Educ. Town of Ridgefield; G.D. v. Westmoreland School District; Evans v. District No. 17; Burlington; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education; Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm.
People named in the decision
- Diane Lappi, Executive director of special education, Capistrano Unified School District
- Robert White, Director of SELPA support, Capistrano Unified School District
- Kim Gaither, District legal specialist, Capistrano Unified School District
- J. Anthony Smith, Consulting attorney for District, Capistrano Unified School District
- G. Robert Roice, Educational consultant representing District, Capistrano Unified School District
- Abby M. Rozenberg, Private speech-language pathologist; independent evaluator and expert witness for Student
- Laurie Cohen, Private occupational therapist; independent evaluator and expert witness for Student
- Sharyn Kerr, Supervisor, certified nonpublic agency; independent evaluator and witness for Student, ACES, Inc.
- Dr. Christine Davidson, Private psychologist; independent evaluator and expert witness for Student
- Brett Ellison, School psychologist, Capistrano Unified School District
- Dr. Paul Alan Dores, Autism educational consultant; expert witness for District, Capistrano Unified School District
- Cheryl Botzong Shapland, Occupational therapist, Capistrano Unified School District
- Beryl Ann Adams, Autism specialist and IBI supervisor, Capistrano Unified School District
- Susan Brown, Speech-language pathologist, Capistrano Unified School District
- Oswaldo (Ozzie) Ochoa, IBI program supervisor, certified nonpublic agency, Coyne & Associates Education Corp.
- Jennifer Fant (formerly Greenfield), Special education program specialist, Capistrano Unified School District
- Regina Gutierrez, Structured autism preschool special day class teacher, Oak Grove Elementary, Capistrano Unified School District
- April Waldron, Structured autism class teacher, Palisades Elementary, Capistrano Unified School District
- Timothy Adams, Attorney for Student at November 2003 IEP meeting
- Kathy Johnson, Private speech-language therapist retained by parents
- Coyne & Associates Education Corp., Certified nonpublic agency providing IBI
- ACES, Inc., Certified nonpublic agency; independent behavior evaluation
- Regional Center of Orange County, Regional center providing Early Start services
- Interagency Assessment Center, Developmental evaluator for regional center
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Christian M. Knox, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in San Juan Capistrano, California, on June 15-18 and 22, 2004.
Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Michael Jewell of Roberts, Adams & Jewell. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was his father, FATHER. Respondent Capistrano Unified School District (District) was represented by educational consultant G. Robert Roice. Also present on behalf of the District was Diane Lappi, executive director of special education for the District. When Ms. Lappi was unavailable, present on behalf of the District was Robert White, director of SELPA support, or Kim Gaither, District legal specialist. Also present on behalf of the District was consulting attorney J. Anthony Smith.
Petitioner called the following witnesses: FATHER, STUDENT’s father; Abby Rozenberg, speech and language pathologist; Laurie Cohen, occupational therapist; Sharyn Kerr, supervisor of ACES, Inc., a certified nonpublic agency; and Dr. Christine Davidson, private psychologist.
The District called the following witnesses: Brett Ellison, school psychologist; Dr. Paul Alan Dores, educational consultant; Cheryl Botzong Shapland, occupational therapist; Beryl Ann Adams, autism specialist and individual behavior intervention (IBI) supervisor; Susan Brown, speech pathologist; Ozzie Ochoa, IBI supervisor for Coyne & Associates, a certified nonpublic agency; Jennifer Fant, special education program specialist; and Regina Gutierrez, structured autism preschool teacher.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of written closing arguments. Upon receipt of the written briefs on July 19, 2004, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
Stipulations.
During the hearing the parties entered into the following factual stipulations:
1. STUDENT is currently receiving twelve hours per week of individual behavior intervention (IBI) at home and six hours per month of IBI supervision. 2. STUDENT is making progress in his home-based IBI program.
3. The placement offer for STUDENT of November 18, 2003, was at Oak Grove Elementary School. 4. Mr. Roice received the independent educational evaluations from Ms. Rozenberg, ACES, Inc., and Ms. Cohen on or about February 18, 2004. 5. An IEP meeting was not convened to consider the aforementioned reports. 6. If Ms. Kerr was recalled to testify, she would testify that she reviewed Petitioner’s Exhibit 44 prior to testifying on June 16, 2004. 7. The Infant/Toddler Sensory Profile was available to assessors prior to the District’s assessment of STUDENT.
Motion to Exclude J. Anthony Smith from the hearing.
On the first day of the hearing, Petitioner made a motion to exclude J. Anthony Smith based upon the District’s failure to provide written notice to Petitioner of its intent to have an attorney present at the hearing. Alternatively, Petitioner asserted that Mr. Smith was an observer and as such could not discuss the hearing with Mr. Roice or any other District personnel. The motion was opposed by the District. The District argued that it provided Petitioner with constructive notice that Mr. Smith would be present as a consultant because Mr. Smith was present when this matter first convened on May 25, 2004. (Footnote 1)
California Education Code section 56507 provides that notice of a party’s intention to be represented by an attorney at a due process hearing must be given ten days prior to the hearing. If notice is not given, good cause exists for a continuance. California Education Code section 56505(e)(1) provides that any party to a hearing has a right to be accompanied and advised by counsel and by individuals with special knowledge or training relating to the problems of individuals with exceptional needs. See also 34 C.F.R. § 300.509(a)(1).
The Hearing Officer denied the motion to exclude and or to prohibit Mr. Smith from discussing the hearing with Mr. Roice or any other district personnel. Mr. Smith was present at the hearing on May 18, 2004, and Petitioner was made aware that he was going to be a consultant on this case. (Footnote 2) Petitioner’s assertion that he was prejudiced because “he knew what a Bob Roice case looks like” and therefore would have prepared differently if Mr. Smith was going to be present was unpersuasive. The purpose for requiring a party to serve a notice of intent to obtain an attorney is to provide the opposing party the opportunity to obtain legal counsel of its own. In this case, Petitioner has been represented by competent counsel since the inception of this case. In addition, any party has the right to be accompanied and advised by counsel and no notice is necessary unless the party intends to be represented by an attorney at the hearing. The Petitioner failed to show any prejudice would result from allowing Mr. Smith to remain in the proceedings and, therefore, the motion was denied. (Footnote 3)
Motion to Compel Performance of Stay Put
On July 22, 2004, the Hearing Office received a Motion to Compel Performance of Stay Put Order or, Alternatively, Motion for Stay Put Order from the Petitioner. The Hearing Office received a response from the District on July 28, 2004, a reply from Petitioner on July 29, 2004, a further response from the District on July 30, 2004, and an additional reply from Petitioner on August 2, 2004. Under federal and State special education law, unless the educational agency and the parent agree otherwise, a special education student must remain in his or her present educational placement pending completion of due process hearing procedures. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(j); Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(d). Since the due process hearing has now been completed, the issue of stay put is moot and, therefore, the motion is denied.
ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING (Footnote 4)
1. Did the District commit procedural violations when developing the November 18, 2003 individualized education program (IEP) that resulted in a denial of a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for STUDENT?
2. Did the District appropriately assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability in preparation for the November 18, 2003 IEP?
3. Did the District substantively deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 regular school year? 4. Is STUDENT entitled to the following remedies:
a. Reimbursement for the independent educational evaluations completed by Abby M. Rozenberg, Laurie Cohen, ACES, Inc., and Dr. Christine Davidson; b. Reimbursement for speech and language services provided to STUDENT at his parents’ expense; and c. Compensatory education consisting of additional speech and language services, occupational therapy services, and behavioral therapy services?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
STUDENT contends that the District failed to procedurally comply with the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law when developing the November 18, 2003 individualized education program (IEP) in numerous respects. Specifically, STUDENT contends that the individualized education program team (IEPT) failed to consider the independent evaluation of Coyne & Associates at the IEP meeting on November 18, 2003. STUDENT also contends that the District committed a procedural violation by failing to initiate a due process hearing or pay for the independent educational evaluations (IEEs) secured for STUDENT by his parents upon receiving notice that STUDENT intended to secure IEEs. STUDENT further contends that the District failed to convene an IEP meeting to consider the independent assessments by Laurie Cohen, Abby Rozenberg, and ACES, Inc. STUDENT contends that the District failed to timely and appropriately allow Dr. Christine Davidson and Mr. Oswald Ochoa to conduct appropriate observations of the proposed placements for STUDENT resulting in a denial of educational benefit for STUDENT and/or a denial of STUDENT’s parents right to participate in the development of STUDENT’s educational program. STUDENT also contends that his father was denied an opportunity to participate in the IEP meeting because the decisions concerning placement, services, and goals and objectives had already been decided and that his input was not welcomed.
STUDENT further contends the District failed to assess him in all areas of suspected disability prior to the November 18, 2003 IEP and, therefore, he was denied a FAPE. STUDENT also asserts he was denied a FAPE because the District failed to: (1) develop measurable goals in all areas of his unique needs as recommended by Coyne & Associates, (2) develop measurable goals in all areas of need as identified by the District in their assessments (specifically, in the areas of speech and language, occupational therapy, social skills, cognitive skills, fine motor skills, and gross motor skills), (3) identify appropriate baselines in all areas of need in the IEP, and (4) set goals which were not too low or that had not already been achieved by STUDENT.
In light of the procedural and/or substantive violations asserted above, STUDENT contends that he is entitled to reimbursement for the independent educational evaluations completed by Abby M. Rozenberg, Laurie Cohen, ACES, Inc., and Dr. Christine Davidson and reimbursement for speech and language services. In addition, he seeks compensatory education.
The District contends that the IEPT considered all evaluations at the November 18, 2003 IEP and, therefore, the District was fully aware of STUDENT’s needs when developing the goals and objectives set forth in the November 18, 2003 IEP. The District contends that a FAPE was offered to STUDENT and that no procedural violations occurred. Therefore, STUDENT is not entitled to any of the remedies he is seeking.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a three-year-old child who became eligible for special education and related services as a child with autism on his third birthday, December 8, 2003. He resides within the boundaries of the District with his parents and older sibling. STUDENT is not currently enrolled in a preschool program; however, he is receiving IBI, speech and language therapy, and occupational therapy from the District. STUDENT’s parents are providing him with additional speech and language therapy through a private pathologist.
In May 2003, six months before STUDENT turned three years old, STUDENT’s parents became concerned about his inattentiveness and lack of progress in the area of language development. STUDENT’s parents took him to an audiologist for an assessment. The hearing assessment was inconclusive. He was then referred to the Regional Center of Orange County (RCOC). The RCOC referred STUDENT for a complete developmental evaluation.
On July 28, 2003, STUDENT was assessed by the Interagency Assessment Center on behalf of the RCOC. The testing revealed that STUDENT presented with deficits in receptive communication, expressive communication, and social skills. The RCOC referred STUDENT for services through Coyne & Associates Education Corp. (Coyne & Associates). On August 25, 2003, STUDENT began receiving twelve hours of in-home one-to-one IBI services per week from Coyne & Associates pursuant to an individualized family service plan (IFSP). The program provided to STUDENT also included parent training and six hours per month of IBI supervision. The IFSP did not provide for speech and language services or occupational therapy.
On September 19, 2003, STUDENT’s parents, the RCOC representatives, and representatives from the District met to develop a transition plan for the transfer of services from the RCOC to the District prior to STUDENT’s third birthday. During the meeting, the parents voiced their concerns about STUDENT’s speech and language development. STUDENT was referred for a special education assessment by the District.
In anticipation of STUDENT’s third birthday and the transfer of services to the District, Coyne & Associates prepared a report setting forth STUDENT’s levels of functioning as of November 2003, together with program goals and objectives and recommendations for future goals and objectives. Coyne & Associates administered the Brigance Diagnostic Inventory of Early Development and the Assessment of Basic Language and Learning Skills in its evaluation of STUDENT. The Coyne & Associates’ report concluded that STUDENT had significant delays in the areas of speech and language, fine motor, cognitive, and social/emotional development.
On October 17, 2003, Susan Brown, the District’s speech pathologist, completed her assessment of STUDENT. In addition to observations of STUDENT, Ms. Brown’s assessment included administration of the Preschool Language Scale-Fourth Edition (PLS-4), the Receptive-Expressive Emergent Language Scale-Second Edition (REEL-2), and the Mac Arthur Communicative Development Inventory: Words and Gestures (Mac Arthur). As a result of her evaluation, Ms. Brown concluded that STUDENT had deficits in the areas of receptive language, expressive language, pragmatics, and speech. Ms. Brown was unable to complete an oral motor screening due to STUDENT’s reluctance to imitate her oral motor movements.
Brett Ellison, the District’s school psychologist, also completed his evaluation of STUDENT on October 17, 2003. To evaluate STUDENT, Mr. Ellison completed observations of STUDENT and administered the Scales of Independent Behavior-Revised (full-scale) (SIB-R), the Mullen Scales of Early Learning (Mullen), the Psychoeducational Profile-Revised (PEP-R), the Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration (VMI), and the Childhood Autism Rating Scale (CARS). As a result of his evaluation, Mr. Ellison confirmed the diagnosis of autism within the mild to moderate range and noted specific deficits in the areas of cognitive verbal, cognitive performance, perception, and imitation. Mr. Ellison also noted that STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language skills were severely delayed.
On October 31, 2003, Cheryl B. Shapland, the District’s occupational therapist, concluded her evaluation of STUDENT. To complete her assessment, Ms. Shapland observed STUDENT and administered the Peabody Developmental Motor Scales-Second Edition (PDMS-II), Observable Sensory Motor Behavior, and the Sensory Profile. Ms. Shapland identified areas of weakness for STUDENT, including: difficulty with transitions; sensory seeking; inattention/distractability; visual output (avoids eye contact); failure to draw horizontal/vertical lines on request; and possession of a strong desire to get his way.
On November 18, 2003, the District convened an IEP meeting to discuss STUDENT’s placement and programming for the 2003-2004 school year. Those in attendance were: FATHER, STUDENT’s father; Timothy Adams, attorney for STUDENT; Brett Ellison; Susan Brown; Cheryl Shapland; Regina Guitierez, District structured autism preschool teacher; Jennifer Fant, program specialist; Oswaldo Ochoa, program supervisor with Coyne & Associates; an RCOC representative; and a regular education teacher. (Footnote 5) The IEP meeting was audiotaped.
The team discussed the assessments, present levels of performance, goals and objectives, and placement. The District proposed the following placement and services: a structured autism preschool class with Ms. Gutierrez at Oak Grove, an elementary school operated by the District, four hours per day, five days per week; six one-hour sessions per year of IBI parent training and skills generalization; occupational therapy one time per week for thirty minutes in a small group; speech and language services two times per week in one thirty-minute individual session and one thirty-minute small-group session, with an additional fifteen-minute session per week of speech and language consultation with school staff; ten hours per week of IBI with five hours per week provided at home and five hours per week at school; and two hours of IBI supervision per month. The program also provided reverse mainstreaming for fifty percent of the school day. (Footnote 6) FATHER did not agree to the IEP at the IEP meeting and indicated that he would review the documents and provide a response at a later time.
On November 29, 2003, STUDENT’s parents, through their legal counsel, submitted written objections to the District’s offer. STUDENT’s parents informed the District that they would be seeking independent educational evaluations in the areas of speech and language, psycho-education, occupational therapy, and behavior at public expense. STUDENT’s parents did not agree with the level and frequency of the occupational therapy and speech and language therapy offered. However, they agreed that the District’s offer of occupational therapy and speech and language services should be provided to STUDENT while the matter was being resolved.
On December 8, 2003, STUDENT filed for a due process hearing alleging a denial of FAPE, both procedurally and substantively, for the 2003-2004 school year. On the same date, the Hearing Office also received STUDENT’s motion for stay-put pursuant to the individual family service plan dated July 29, 2003, which included forty-eight hours per month of individual IBI and six hours per month of IBI supervision through Coyne & Associates. On December 17, 2003, the Hearing Office denied the motion and found that although the District was required to provide STUDENT with forty-eight hours per month of individual IBI with six hours per month of IBI supervision, the District was not required to utilize Coyne & Associates to provide these services.
Pursuant to the parents’ consent to implement portions of the IEP, on December 9, 2003, STUDENT began receiving OT services from Ms. Shapland one time per week in a thirty-minute session and speech and language services from Ms. Brown two times per week in thirty-minute sessions. STUDENT continued to receive twelve hours per week of IBI and the transition of IBI from Coyne & Associates to the District took place in December 2003 and January 2004.
On December 9, 2003, STUDENT was evaluated by Abby M. Rozenberg, speech and language pathologist, at his parents’ request. In addition to observing STUDENT, Ms. Rozenberg administered the Communicative Functions and Means Checklist, Westby Symbolic Play Scale, Sequenced Inventory of Communication Development-Revised (SICD-R), and portions of the Kaufman Speech Praxis Test for Children (KSPTC). Ms. Rozenberg concluded that STUDENT presented with deficits in receptive and expressive language. Ms. Rozenberg suspected a weakness in STUDENT’s auditory processing relative to his visual strengths. STUDENT also had difficulty with play, pragmatics, and interaction/attention skills. At the conclusion of her report, Ms. Rozenberg made several recommendations for STUDENT.
STUDENT was evaluated by Laurie Cohen, occupational therapist, on December 6, 10, and 12, 2003, again at his parents’ request. Ms. Cohen observed STUDENT and administered the protocol worksheet and profile guidelines for occupational therapy and physical therapy in California public schools, the School Functional Analysis Battery, the Post-Rotary Nystagmus Test for Vestibular Dysfunction and Processing Disorders, and a Functional and Task Analysis for Performance Comparison. Ms. Cohen concluded that STUDENT had substantial difficulties in the areas of physical and cognitive/behavior tasks, including difficulties in postural control, bilateral motor coordination, motor planning, perceptual motor concepts/skills, writing, sensory processing, behavior control, and peer interaction/cooperative play.
At his parents’ request, Sharyn Kerr, M.A., supervisor of ACES, Inc., performed an evaluation of STUDENT on December 20, 2003, to determine his current developmental functioning across various domains and to make educational recommendations. Ms. Kerr administered the PEP-R and conducted an observation of STUDENT. Ms. Kerr concluded that STUDENT’s greatest area of weakness was expressive language. STUDENT demonstrated emerging skills in the areas of imitation and receptive language.
Finally, again at his parents’ request, Dr. Christine Davidson evaluated STUDENT on December 29, 2003, and conducted observations of the proposed placement at Oak Grove and a similar classroom at Palisades Elementary School on January 16, April 1, and May 5, 2004. In addition to observing STUDENT, Dr. Davidson administered the Bayley Scales of Infant Development-Second Edition (Bayley), the Sensory Profile, the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales (Vineland), the Burks’ Behavior Rating Scales (Burks’), and the CARS. Dr. Davidson concluded that STUDENT was severely delayed in receptive and expressive language. Dr. Davidson made several recommendations including placement in a language-based preschool program, speech and language services, occupational therapy, parent training, mainstreaming, and in-home IBI services.
On or about February 18, 2004, the District received copies of the reports prepared by Ms. Kerr, Ms. Rozenberg, and Ms. Cohen. Dr. Davidson’s report was not received by the District until approximately May 18, 2004.
In April 2004, STUDENT’s parents retained Kathy Johnson to provide private speech and language therapy for STUDENT. STUDENT attends therapy with Ms. Johnson two times per week in thirty-minute individual sessions.
In June 2004, an IEP meeting was held to consider services for the 2004 extended school year. STUDENT’s parents did not attend the IEP meeting. STUDENT has continued to receive from the District twelve hours of IBI services per week with six hours of IBI supervision per month; thirty minutes of occupational therapy per week; and two thirty-minute sessions of speech and language services throughout the pendency of this action.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue No. 1: Did the District commit procedural violations when developing the November 18, 2003 individualized education program (IEP) that resulted in a denial of a free appropriate public education for STUDENT?
Under both the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term free appropriate public education means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State’s educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(8).
The right to a FAPE also includes the important entitlement to certain procedural protections during the process of developing an individualized education program for a disabled child. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992); Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 205 (1982). Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1483. In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, the Supreme Court recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA as part of the provision of FAPE. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 205.
The procedural rights that extend to parents under the IDEA include the right to participate in the development of the child’s IEP and the opportunity for mediation and a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process may result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).
Petitioner alleges that the District committed five procedural violations that resulted in the denial of a FAPE. Each of those allegations will be addressed in turn below.
A. Failing to consider the Coyne & Associates’ report at the November 18, 2003 IEP.
California Education Code section 56341.1(a)(2) provides that when developing a child’s IEP, the IEPT shall consider the results of the initial assessment or most recent assessment of the pupil. See also 34 C.F.R. § 300.346(a)(ii). If an independent assessment for the provision of related services or designated instruction and services is submitted to the IEPT, review of that assessment is to be conducted by qualified personnel. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 7572(d)(2). The assessment is to be considered by the public agency with respect to the provision of a FAPE to the child. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(c); 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(c)(1).
Petitioner contends that the November 2003 Coyne & Associates’ report was not considered by the IEPT. The evidence produced at the hearing does not support this contention. It is uncontroverted that the Coyne & Associates’ report was not provided to the District until the IEPT meeting on November 18, 2003. Therefore, the District did not have an opportunity to have the report reviewed prior to the IEPT meeting as contemplated by section 7572 of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations. Further, special education program specialist, Jennifer Fant, reviewed the report during the IEPT meeting, as did speech pathologist Susan Brown and occupational therapist Cheryl Shapland. More importantly, Mr. Ochoa, the author of the report, was present during the IEP meeting. Mr. Ochoa testified that he gave an oral report at the IEP meeting outlining the contents of the written report. This is confirmed in the minutes of the IEP meeting (Respondent’s Ex. 7).
The Hearing Officer finds that the Coyne & Associates’ report was properly considered at the November 18, 2003 IEP meeting. Mr. Ochoa was present at the IEP meeting and orally presented a summary of his written report. Moreover, the District members of the IEPT reviewed the report during the meeting. Each member of the IEPT testified that they at least skimmed the report at the IEP meeting.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that through Mr. Ochoa’s presentation, the IEPT properly reviewed and considered the Coyne & Associates’ report. Therefore, a procedural violation based on the review and consideration of the Coyne & Associates’ report did not occur.
B. Failing to initiate a due process hearing or pay for the independent educational evaluations secured for STUDENT.
A parent has the right to obtain an independent assessment at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment performed by the school district. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b); 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b)(1). The school district must pay for the independent assessment unless there is a determination through a due process hearing that its assessment was appropriate. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56329(b), 56506(c); 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b)(2). The Code of Federal Regulations expands the obligation of the District by requiring that upon receipt of a request for an IEE at public expense, the District initiate a due process hearing without unnecessary delay to show that its evaluation is appropriate, or provide funding for the IEE at public expense if the parents request an IEE at public expense. 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b)(2).
STUDENT was assessed by the District in October 2003. In a letter to the District dated November 26, 2003, STUDENT’s parents, through their attorney, informed the District that they intended to pursue independent educational evaluations at public expense for STUDENT. The Hearing Office received Petitioner’s request for due process hearing on December 8, 2003. STUDENT’s independent evaluations, to be conducted by Ms. Cohen, Ms. Rozenberg, ACES, Inc., and Dr. Davidson, were commenced on December 9, 2003. The IEE reports, with the exception of Dr. Davidson’s, were not received by the District until approximately February 18, 2004. Dr. Davidson’s report was not received until May 18, 2004.
The law requires that the District pay for an IEE unless there is a determination, through a due process hearing, that the District’s assessment was appropriate. The issue of whether the District’s assessment was appropriate was brought promptly to the attention of the Hearing Office. Just twelve days after the notice to the District of STUDENT’s intent to obtain IEEs, the Hearing Office received STUDENT’s request for a due process hearing that identified reimbursement for the IEEs as an issue. Therefore, although the District did not request a due process hearing in this matter, STUDENT requested a due process hearing soon after the District received notice of STUDENT’s intent to pursue IEEs. Thus, no prejudice to STUDENT occurred. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to either pay for the IEEs or initiate a due process hearing did not result in a denial of FAPE.
C. Failing to convene an IEP meeting to consider the independent assessments by Laurie Cohen, Abby Rozenberg, and ACES, Inc.
California Education Code section 56329(c) provides that if a parent or guardian obtains an independent educational assessment at private expense, the results of the assessment shall be considered by the public education agency with respect to the provision of a FAPE to the child and may be presented as evidence at a due process hearing. See also 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(c)(1). Using plain meaning, “considered” would require that the IEE be reflected on and thought about with a degree of care or caution. T.S. v. Bd. of Educ. Town of Ridgefield, 10 F.3d 87, 89 (2d Cir. 1993). Not every member of the IEPT is required to have reviewed the IEE for it to have been properly considered. T.S., 10 F.3d at 90. A substantive discussion of the IEE is not required. G.D. v. Westmoreland School District, 930 F.2d 942, 947 (1st Cir. 1991). Review of the IEE by the district’s director of special education may be sufficient for the IEE to be deemed properly considered. Evans v. District No. 17, 841 F.2d 824, 830 (8th Cir. 1988). There is no requirement that a meeting be conducted to review an IEE.
It is undisputed that the District was provided with the IEEs of Rozenberg, Cohen, and ACES, Inc. on or about February 18, 2004, approximately three months after the November IEP meeting. It is also undisputed that an IEP was not convened for the sole purpose of discussing the results of the IEEs. (Footnote 7) However, neither federal nor State law requires that an IEP meeting be convened to consider IEEs. The requirement is that the IEEs be considered by the District.
It is undisputed that each of the IEEs obtained by Petitioner was reviewed and considered by the District. Ms. Shapland, the District’s occupational therapist, reviewed the occupational therapy report prepared by Ms. Cohen for Petitioner. Ms. Shapland testified in depth concerning Ms. Cohen’s report and indicated that she would not have changed her recommendations basedon anything contained in Ms. Cohen’s report. Likewise, Ms. Brown, the District’s speech pathologist, reviewed the speech and language assessment authored by Ms. Rozenberg. Ms. Brown also indicated that she would not have changed her recommendation or any of the goals and objectives set forth in the November 18, 2003 IEP based upon any information contained in Ms. Rozenberg’s report. Ms. Kerr’s report was reviewed by Beryl Adams, the District’s autism specialist and the IBI supervisor assigned to STUDENT, in February or March 2004. Dr. Davidson’s report was reviewed by Ms. Gutierrez, the District’s special education teacher for the Oak Grove structured autism preschool class, and by Dr. Dores, autism consultant for the District.
The Hearing Officer finds that members of the IEPT considered the IEEs subsequent to the November 2003 IEP. Although an IEP meeting was not convened for the express purpose of addressing the IEEs, the undisputed testimony of the District’s service providers reveals that the IEEs were considered and that the District would not have changed its recommendations for placement and services for STUDENT based upon the information and the recommendations contained in the IEEs. Further, The District had completed its review of each of the IEEs prior to the IEP meeting in June 2004. Had the parents requested, the IEEs could have been discussed at that time. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that a procedural violation did not occur.
D. Failing to timely and appropriately allow Dr. Davidson and Mr. Ochoa to conduct appropriate observations of the proposed placements for STUDENT.
California Education Code section 56329(b) provides that if a public agency observed a student when conducting its evaluation, an independent educational assessor shall have an equivalent opportunity to observe the student in his current educational placement and setting and to observe a proposed educational placement and setting.
In conducting her psychoeducational evaluation, Dr. Davidson observed the proposed placement of Regina Gutierrez’s structured autism class at Oak Grove on February 11 and April 1, 2004. Dr. Davidson also was permitted by the District to visit the structured autism class at Palisades taught by April Waldron on April 1 and May 5, 2004, even though this was not the placement the District had proposed. Each visit was limited to approximately twenty minutes per District policy. (Footnote 8) It is undisputed that the District has a policy of limiting observations by non-staff persons to twenty minutes per visit and that visits must be arranged ahead of time.
Petitioner contends that the District did not provide Dr. Davidson with an equivalent opportunity to observe the proposed placement at Oak Grove because the District limited her observations to twenty minutes and her appointments for observations had to be made approximately three weeks in advance. Dr. Davidson testified that she was frustrated with the observations because she was unable to observe teacher instruction and being provided with information on mainstreaming opportunities. Dr. Davidson also testified that the twenty-minute limitation prevented her from being able to adequately review the educational program.
To determine whether Dr. Davidson was provided with an equivalent opportunity to conduct an observation, the Hearing Officer must consider what observations were made by Mr. Ellison of STUDENT in conducting the District’s psychoeducational evaluation. Mr. Ellison testified that he observed STUDENT in his home IBI program on one occasion for approximately one hour.
The Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Davidson was provided with an equivalent opportunity to observe the proposed placement at Oak Grove. Dr. Davidson testified that she observed the placement on two occasions for a total of forty minutes. In addition, the District did not limit the number of observations Dr. Davidson could make, just the duration of the observations. Legitimate reasons can exist for limiting the time for classroom observations. There can be considerable concerns with the effect that outside observers have on the education and behaviors of young children, particularly those with autism. The Hearing Officer notes that Dr. Davidson observed the District’s proposed program on two occasions and could have requested additional observations.
In addition, California Code of Education section 56329(b) only provides for an equivalent opportunity for observations, it does not require that the evaluator be given the opportunity to speak with the teachers. The District provided Dr. Davidson an opportunity to observe the proposed educational placement on two occasions. The District was not required to make its teachers available for an interview. (Footnote 9) There is no evidence that Dr. Davidson would have been denied a request to observe a third time. Therefore, the District did not commit a procedural violation by limiting the duration of Dr. Davidson’s observations.
The Hearing Officer also finds that the District did not commit a procedural violation by not allowing Mr. Ochoa to accompany FATHER on an observation of Ms. Gutierrez’s classroom or by not allowing Mr. Ochoa to observe the placement outside the presence of FATHER. Mr. Ochoa asked the principal of Oak Grove if he could observe Ms. Gutierrez’s class subsequent to the November 2003 IEP meeting. The District denied his request.
There are extensive procedures involved in evaluating a student, including the use of appropriate assessment tools, the qualifications of the personnel administering the tests, and the nature of observations that are to be conducted. 34 C.F.R. §§ 300.532, 300.533; Cal. Educ. Code § 56320. In this case, the only report prepared by Mr. Ochoa was the termination report in November 2003. After that report was submitted to the IEP team, Mr. Ochoa did not perform any further assessments of STUDENT. Mr. Ochoa testified that his role as IBI supervisor for Coyne & Associates was to develop a program for STUDENT, establish a rapport with STUDENT’s parents, to provide them with support, serve as liaison between STUDENT’s parents and the tutors, and provide support and supervision for STUDENT’s IBI program. The law does not provide for observations to be made by persons other than independent evaluators and parents. Mr. Ochoa’s involvement with STUDENT was insufficient to constitute an independent evaluation and, therefore, the provisions of California Education Code section 56329(b) were not triggered. Consequently, the District did not commit a procedural violation by not allowing Mr. Ochoa an opportunity to observe Ms. Gutierrez’s classroom.
E. Denying FATHER an opportunity to meaningfully participate in the November 2003 IEP meeting.
Petitioner’s contention that FATHER was denied an opportunity to meaningfully participate in the November 2003 IEP meeting is without merit. Petitioner contends that decisions concerning STUDENT’s placement, services, and goals and objectives were predetermined and that FATHER felt as though it was not a process where he could provide any input. However, FATHER testified that the IEP meeting was approximately two hours in length and that he was represented by counsel throughout the IEP meeting. Ms. Fant testified that FATHER was given ample opportunity to ask questions and provide input during the process. The notes from the IEP meeting reveal that FATHER’s input was sought from the IEPT on at least eight separate occasions during the meeting. (Respondent’s Ex. 7.) Ms. Fant also testified that counsel for FATHER interrupted the assessors on numerous occasions demanding that recommendations be provided at that time. The evidence showed that the intended process for the IEP meeting was for the results of all evaluations to be presented. Then the IEPT considered the goals and objectives to be implemented for STUDENT. After the goals and objectives were agreed upon, the IEPT discussed the placement and services necessary to meet the goals and objectives. The notes from the IEP meeting reveal that FATHER ultimately concurred with the rest of the IEPT regarding setting goals that would not frustrate STUDENT and to develop new goals when STUDENT had mastered those previously set. (Respondent’s Ex. 7.) FATHER was given the opportunity to meaningfully participate in the IEP process by being able to ask questions and provide information and suggestions and through the presence of his counsel. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that a procedural violation did not occur.
*********
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit any procedural violations which resulted in the loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT or seriously infringed on his parents’ ability to participate in the IEP process.
Issue No. 2: Did the District appropriately assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability for the November 18, 2003 IEP?
The law requires that a child with a suspected disability be assessed by the school district in all areas related to the suspected disability, including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general intelligence, communicative status, self-help, and social and emotional status. 34 C.F.R. §§ 300.320(a), 300.531; Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f). Occupational therapy and physical therapy are also areas of service that require prior assessment. Cal. Gov’t Code § 7572. The evaluation must be sufficiently comprehensive to identify all of the child’s special education and related services needs. 34 C.F.R. § 300.532(h). The IEP team must be able to rely on the information from an initial assessment to determine eligibility and to develop an appropriate educational program. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b).
The assessments themselves must meet certain statutory requirements set forth in California Education Code section 56320. See also 34 C.F.R. § 300.532. Among those are requirements that assessment materials (1) have been validated for the specific purpose for which they are used, (2) are properly administered by trained personnel, and (3) include those tailored to assess specific areas of educational need. No single procedure is to be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program. The assessments must be competently performed. 34 C.F.R. § 300.532; Cal. Educ. Code § 56322. A credentialed school psychologist must conduct the psychological assessment of a student. Cal. Educ. Code § 56324.
The District conducted assessments in three areas: occupational therapy, speech and language, and psychoeducation. The Hearing Officer will address each evaluation individually.
Occupational Therapy Assessment
Cheryl Shapland completed the occupational therapy assessment for the District. Ms. Shapland has been an occupational therapist for the District for three years. She has a bachelor’s degree in physical education with a minor in adaptive physical education, a teaching credential in physical education, and a master’s degree in occupational therapy. Ms. Shapland has been an occupational therapist for four years. She received training in working with children diagnosed with autism spectrum disorders including Orange County Department of Education classes and Alert, and she is certified in sensory integration. Ms. Shapland is a registered and licensed occupational therapist.
Ms. Shapland conducted her evaluation of STUDENT on October 17 and 31, 2003. Ms. Shapland spent a total of two and a half hours with STUDENT. On October 17, 2003, Ms. Shapland observed STUDENT in his home while he participated in several testing activities directed by the school psychologist and the speech pathologist for the District. On October 31, 2003, Ms. Shapland observed STUDENT at the OT clinic at Crown Valley. Over two days of observation, Ms. Shapland completed the PDMS-II, Observable Sensory Motor Behavior, and the Sensory Profile. Ms. Shapland also gathered information through a home observation, parent interview, and age- appropriate fine motor skill observation in her assessment of STUDENT. Ms. Shapland testified that STUDENT was able to focus and attend for the assessment. However, STUDENT’s ability to focus and attend was greater at the clinic than in his home.
The District’s OT assessment was comprehensive and the IEPT appropriately relied upon the report. Ms. Shapland spent two and a half hours with STUDENT and conducted observations not only in STUDENT’s home, but in a clinical setting as well. Ms. Shapland obtained information for her assessment from a variety of sources including the PDMS-II, parent questionnaire, and personal observation.
Petitioner asserts that STUDENT required assessment in motor planning, vestibular processing, specific muscle strength, reflex integration, task analysis, and social responses with other children. This contention is without merit. Neither the parents’ concerns nor the Coyne & Associates’ report indicated that these areas were cause for concern or that deficits in these areas were suspected. Ms. Shapland’s report reveals that she completed an assessment of STUDENT’s visual, auditory, tactile, proprioceptive, and vestibular systems. The Hearing Officer finds that the areas assessed by Ms. Shapland were sufficient to determine STUDENT’s present levels of performance from an OT perspective and whether he needed special education and OT related services. Although Ms. Shapland could not assess STUDENT in social responses with other children because he was not in a classroom setting, there was insufficient evidence produced for the Hearing Officer to find that such an assessment was required.
Petitioner also asserts that the Sensory Profile administered by Ms. Shapland was not validated for the specific purpose for which it was used. Ms. Cohen testified that the Sensory Profile administered by Ms. Shapland was for school-age children and not the proper tool to be used in assessing STUDENT. Ms. Cohen testified that the Sensory Profile for Infants and Toddlers should have been administered. Ms. Cohen’s testimony criticizing Ms. Shapland’s administration of the Sensory Profile was not persuasive.
The evidence produced at the hearing revealed that the District administered the Sensory Profile to STUDENT in October 2003, and that this test was normed for children thirty-six months through fourteen years of age. Ms. Shapland testified that this was the only version of the Sensory Profile the District had purchased by the time she evaluated STUDENT. The evidence also demonstrated that in or about 2002, new Sensory Profile tests were published. The new versions provided for four separate tests: birth through six months, seven months through thirty-six months, school-age children (ages five through ten), and adolescents and adults (ages fourteen and older).
Ms. Shapland asserts that her administration of the older version of the Sensory Profile (ages thirty-six months through fourteen years) was not invalidated because STUDENT was administered the test at thirty-four months and, from an OT perspective, this age difference was considered negligible. (Footnote 10) Ms. Shapland’s assertion is supported by Petitioner’s Exhibit 50 which identifies the normed ages for each testing section. In each and every section, children aged thirty-four months and thirty-six months are included in the same normed category. In addition, the Sensory Profile is a parent questionnaire and not a child-driven instrument. Thus, the assessment did not require STUDENT to complete any tasks.
The Hearing Officer finds that the administration of an older version of the Sensory Profile to STUDENT did not invalidate Ms. Shapland’s findings. The purpose of the Sensory Profile was to determine how sensory systems might impact classroom performance. Ms. Shapland did not rely solely on the Sensory Profile, but compared those responses to her own observations of STUDENT in the home and in a clinical setting. Specifically, Ms. Shapland testified that STUDENT was able to complete visual tasks without showing any signs of distress. STUDENT did not appear to be bothered by sounds. Although FATHER reported that STUDENT did not like to stand in line close to other people and that he did not notice or was not bothered by his hands and face being messy, Ms. Shapland concluded that this was consistent with STUDENT not responding to tactile stimuli. Ms. Shapland completed light-touch and deep-touch exercises with STUDENT and he did not appear distressed with either activity. Ms. Shapland concluded that STUDENT did not have any tactile defensiveness and, if anything, STUDENT wanted more tactile stimuli in his environment. According to Ms. Shapland, STUDENT’s vestibular system was also within normal limits. For example, STUDENT enjoyed climbing and did not demonstrate any rocking behaviors. Ms. Shapland concluded that her observations of STUDENT supported the findings of the Sensory Profile.
In addition, the Hearing Officer notes that Dr. Davidson completed an Infant/Toddler Sensory Profile for STUDENT on December 29, 2003. Dr. Davidson concluded that STUDENT was sensory avoiding. Although Dr. Davidson reached the opposite conclusion of Ms. Shapland, Ms. Shapland’s administration of an older version of the Sensory Profile is not invalid. The Hearing Officer would note that Dr. Davidson is a psychologist and that analysis of sensory systems is within the purview of an occupational therapist like Ms. Shapland. Ms. Shapland testified that the purpose of the Sensory Profile is not to give a definitive answer as to whether a child is sensory avoiding or sensory seeking; the purpose is to look at how the sensory systems might affect his performance in the classroom. Using clinical reasoning and STUDENT’s responses to sensory stimuli, Ms. Shapland was able to learn how STUDENT may function in the classroom setting. Ms. Shapland concluded that the finding of sensory seeking on the Sensory Profile was appropriate based upon her observations of STUDENT in the home and in the clinic.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s OT assessment was sufficiently comprehensive to identify all of STUDENT’s suspected areas of deficit and the assessment tools used were validated for the specific purpose for which they were used. STUDENT was assessed in the areas of fine motor, visual motor, and sensory motor abilities. Ms. Shapland did not solely rely on one testing tool. She administered a test, conducted observations, and reviewed parent questionnaires. Ms. Shapland is a licensed and registered occupational therapist and was qualified to administer the different test instruments. Therefore, the IEPT was able to rely on the information from an initial assessment to determine eligibility and to develop an appropriate educational program. Ms. Shapland testified that the results of evaluation were valid. The Hearing Officer finds that the assessment was competently performed and met the statutory requirements set forth in California Education Code section 56320.
Speech and Language Assessment
Susan Brown completed a speech and language assessment for the District. Ms. Brown is a speech and language pathologist for the District. Ms. Brown obtained her bachelor’s degree in speech and hearing from the University of California, Santa Barbara and her master’s degree from California State University, Fullerton in 1983. Ms. Brown has her California license and a certificate of clinical competence from the American Speech and Hearing Association. Ms. Brown has also attended training in the area of autism including training in the Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS), TEACCH, and Links to Language. Ms. Brown is currently assigned to one of the District’s preschool assessment teams, which assesses children two years and ten months to five years of age. Ms. Brown has served in this capacity for eight years.
Ms. Brown administered three tests in conducting her evaluation of STUDENT -- the PLS-4, the REEL-2, and the Mac Arthur. Ms. Brown observed STUDENT for approximately three hours, including an observation at his home. The PLS-4 is one of the most commonly used assessment tools for assessing children of STUDENT’s age, according to Ms. Brown. The REEL-2 is in a parent-interview format and collects information concerning how the child functions in different situations. The Mac Arthur provides information concerning basic vocabulary development, understanding, and expressive use. Based upon the assessments, Ms. Brown concluded that STUDENT’s receptive language was in the eleven- to thirteen-month age range. STUDENT’s expressive language skills were in the sixteen- to seventeen-month level. An oral facial examination was unable to be completed because of STUDENT’s reluctance to imitate Ms. Brown.
Abby Rozenberg, a speech pathologist retained by the parents, reviewed the District’s evaluation of STUDENT and had several concerns. Ms. Rozenberg testified that the District’s evaluation of STUDENT was incomplete due to the discrepancy between STUDENT’s auditory functioning and his expressive language. She testified that these scores were more than one standard deviation apart and this was clinically significant. Ms. Rozenberg contends that there was an underlying reason for the deviation and further investigation in the form of additional assessments was needed to discover the nature of the disorder.
Ms. Rozenberg also asserted that a better assessment tool for autistic children should have been used with STUDENT. Ms. Rozenberg contends that it is most important to do an extensive behavior examination when assessing a child’s communicative abilities. Ms. Rozenberg was also critical of the report for several other reasons, including alleged inconsistencies between the receptive and expressive language findings, Ms. Brown’s failure to identify STUDENT’s twenty-four words spoken, and Ms. Brown’s failure to list the vowels used by STUDENT. Ms. Rozenberg asserted that STUDENT appeared to use traditionally later developing sounds and not earlier developing sounds. He was missing “t,” “k,” and “z.” In addition, Ms. Rozenberg did not know if the sounds STUDENT produced were elicited or used independently.
Ms. Rozenberg also testified that further testing in oral motor was necessary to complete an assessment. Voice and fluency should have been addressed to ensure that STUDENT did not have a voice disorder and to ensure that his vocal chords were intact. Additionally, according to Ms. Rozenberg, the testing revealed what STUDENT could not do and did not give STUDENT credit for what he could do. STUDENT’s expressive and receptive language was emerging. Concerning pragmatics, Ms. Rozenberg would have liked to have seen more description concerning language in play, play with puppets, eye gaze, turn taking, and interacting with objects.
The Hearing Officer finds the District’s position persuasive. Ms. Rozenberg’s contention that the discrepancy between STUDENT’s auditory functioning and his expressive language required additional testing is unpersuasive. Ms. Rozenberg’s position is not supported by the evidence. All evaluators agree that STUDENT has deficits in expressive language. STUDENT’s language deficits have been evaluated by numerous assessors including Coyne & Associates, Ms. Brown, and Ms. Rozenberg. STUDENT has been diagnosed with autism and consequently has receptive and expressive language deficits. Ms. Rozenberg was unable to identify any additional needs which would lead the Hearing Officer to find that further testing was necessary.
The Hearing Officer also finds Ms. Rozenberg’s criticism of the assessment tools used by Ms. Brown is without merit. Ms. Rozenberg testified that in her opinion more appropriate tools could have been used to conduct an evaluation of a child with autism. However, Ms. Rozenberg did not testify that the assessment tools used by Ms. Brown were not valid or were inappropriate. Ms. Brown credibly testified that the assessment she conducted was valid and appropriate.
Ms. Brown also testified that she could not have administered a standardized articulation test due to STUDENT’s level of functioning at the time the evaluation was completed. A standardized articulation test would have required STUDENT to look at a picture and state the word. STUDENT would not have been able to complete this task. In addition, STUDENT needed more language before articulation could have been thoroughly evaluated. Ms. Brown’s explanation is logical given STUDENT’s skill level at the time the tests were administered. Ms. Brown attempted to do an oral motor screening; however, STUDENT was reluctant to imitate her productions. STUDENT’s oral motor functioning would have been continually monitored while he was participating in speech and language services to ensure that this was not an area of concern. Ms. Rozenberg did complete an oral motor functioning evaluation and concluded that STUDENT did not have any deficits in this area. According to Ms. Brown, the manual for the PLS-4 indicates that there are specific sections of the test which identify areas of concern when working with children diagnosed with autism. In addition, Ms. Brown considered the results of the PEP-R when reaching her conclusions. Ms. Brown was unfamiliar with the assessment tools used by Ms. Rozenberg in her assessment. However, Ms. Brown testified that Ms. Rozenberg’s conclusions were similar to her own. A review of the conclusions in each report confirm this assertion.
Additionally, Ms. Brown explained that the inconsistencies in the receptive language section of her report were not based upon the testing she administered but on the inconsistent answers given by the parents. STUDENT’s ability to use vocalizations and gestures to request objects is not the same as using words to request objects. There are no inconsistencies in the pragmatic sections. In one instance STUDENT is trying to initiate a game, but he is not attempting to get someone’s attention to look at an object or attend to something he wants.
Finally, Ms. Brown has been delivering speech and language services to STUDENT on a weekly basis since December 2003. Ms. Brown reports that STUDENT is making very nice progress and he has met the majority, if not all, of the benchmarks in the areas of expressive language, receptive language, and social skills. Ms. Brown has not seen anything in her work with STUDENT that would cause her to conclude that her assessment was not valid.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s speech and language assessment was sufficiently comprehensive to identify all of STUDENT’s suspected areas of deficit. Ms. Brown properly administered the assessment tools. The assessment tools were valid and evaluated STUDENT in the areas of expressive language, receptive language, and pragmatics, STUDENT’s primary areas of deficit. In addition, Ms. Brown did not rely solely on one instrument but used tests, observations, and parent questionnaires to reach her conclusion. In addition, Ms. Brown also reviewed the test results of other evaluators. Ms. Brown testified that her results were valid. There is no persuasive evidence to the contrary. The IEPT was able to rely on the information from an initial assessment to determine eligibility and to develop an appropriate educational program. Therefore, the assessment was competently performed and met the statutory requirements set forth in California Education Code section 56320.
Psychoeducational Assessment
Brett Ellison, the District’s school psychologist, completed a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT. Mr. Ellison has been a school psychologist for eleven years and has worked for the District for nine years. Mr. Ellison obtained his bachelor of science degree in social science, his master’s degree in counseling and psychology from California State University, Fullerton, and his school psychology credential from Chapman University. Mr. Ellison’s primary responsibility with the District is to evaluate preschool students. Mr. Ellison performs approximately sixty-five to one hundred evaluations per year. A speech pathologist and an occupational therapist are involved in the assessments.
Mr. Ellison used five assessment tools and conducted observations of STUDENT in completing his evaluation. Mr. Ellison used the SIB-R, an interview rating form completed by STUDENT’s parents, to determine STUDENT’s functioning and behavior. Mr. Ellison also administered the PEP-R which is used to identify uneven learning patterns in children with autism or related disorders. Mr. Ellison also administered the VMI. The VMI measures visual- motor integration. STUDENT’s raw score was two with an age equivalent of two years, nine months. The Hearing Officer finds that based upon his experience and education, Mr. Ellison was more than qualified to conduct these assessments. The Hearing Officer also finds that the assessment was comprehensive.
Mr. Ellison also received information from STUDENT’s parents to complete the CARS. STUDENT scored a thirty-six, which falls within the mildly to moderately autistic range. Mr. Ellison attempted to administer the Mullen; however, STUDENT had difficulty cooperating with him during the structured tasks. Mr. Ellison testified that he did not administer an intelligence test because an intelligence score is, or can be, misleading at this tender age.
Dr. Davidson was critical of the District’s assessment for two basic reasons. First, Dr. Davidson contends that the findings on the SIB-R concerning the maladaptive behavior should have been explained in more detail to develop goals and objectives. Second, Dr. Davidson contends a reasonably experienced school psychologist would have tried to administer the Mullen on more than one occasion.
The Hearing Office finds the District’s position persuasive. Mr. Ellison did attempt to administer the Mullen; however, the Mullen requires a lot of picture pointing and some of the directions can be confusing. STUDENT had difficulty pointing to pictures upon request. This information is consistent with the characterization of STUDENT from other witnesses, including Ms. Shapland and Ms. Brown. Contrary to the assertion of Dr. Davidson, given Mr. Ellison’s explanation of the Mullen, STUDENT’s difficulty with completing the test was not limited to a lack of rapport, but on STUDENT’s uncontroverted difficulties with expressive and receptive language. While Dr. Davidson administered additional assessments, Mr. Ellison testified that his evaluation was thorough and appropriate. There were no substantive differences in the results obtained by Mr. Ellison and Dr. Davidson. The tests administered by the District provided the IEPT with sufficient information to prepare goals and objectives for STUDENT.
Petitioner also challenged the use of the SIB-R based on a treatise by Jerome Satler, Assessment of Behavior of Children, 4th Edition. Mr. Satler criticized the SIB-R because of the complicated use of the scoring scale and because the norm sample does not match federal census schedules. This contention is not persuasive. Petitioner’s expert, Dr. Davidson, did not testify that the SIB-R was an inappropriate tool to use in STUDENT’s assessment. Mr. Ellison testified credibly that Mr. Satler has a critique of every test instrument and that he did not give weight to Mr. Satler’s criticism because the criticism did not make sense. Mr. Ellison was able to obtain scores from the SIB-R.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s psychoeducational assessment was sufficiently comprehensive to identify all of STUDENT’s suspected areas of deficit. The IEPT was able to rely on the information from an initial assessment to determine eligibility and to develop an appropriate educational program. Mr. Ellison was qualified to administer the assessment tools to STUDENT. The assessment tools selected by Mr. Ellison were tailored for STUDENT’s specific areas of need, including uneven learning patterns in children with autism and visual-motor integration. In addition, Mr. Ellison did not rely on one test instrument. Mr. Ellison administered test instruments, conducted observations, and reviewed the evaluations completed by other assessors. Mr. Ellison testified that his results were valid. There is no persuasive evidence to the contrary. Therefore, the assessment was competently performed and met the statutory requirements set forth in California Education Code section 56320.
*******************
The Hearing Officer also finds to be without merit Petitioner’s contention that the reports were incomplete because they did not contain recommendations for which placement and services STUDENT should receive. California Education Code section 56327 identifies all information which must be contained in a written assessment report and recommendations from the evaluators are not required to be a part of the report. Each of the evaluators were present at the IEP meeting to give an oral recommendation for placement and services. The amount of services offered depended on the placement. For example, Ms. Brown testified that if STUDENT had not been offered placement in a language-based, structured autism preschool classroom, her recommendation for the amount of speech and language services would have been different. Therefore, it was not inappropriate for the evaluators to meet and consider all reports, comments, and suggestions from all members of the IEPT, including FATHER, prior to making their recommendations.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District assessed STUDENT in all areas related to the suspected disability, including motor abilities, language function, communicative status, self-help, and social and emotional status. The evaluations were sufficiently comprehensive to identify all of STUDENT’s special education and related services needs. The IEPT was able to rely on the information from the assessments to determine eligibility and to develop an appropriate educational program, and the assessments met the statutory requirements set forth in California Education Code section 56320.
Issue No. 3: Did the District substantively deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 regular school year?
As stated above, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education in the form of special education and related services that conform to the student’s individualized education program. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16). The term “related services” includes transportation and other services that may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(17). California Education Code section 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”
To determine whether the District substantively provided STUDENT a free appropriate public education, one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s proposed programs. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. While this requires a school district to provide a disabled child with meaningful access to education, it does not mean that the school district is required to guarantee successful results. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998). The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak, 142 F.3d at 130. Rather, a child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997).
To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program must have been designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs, have been reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, and comported with his IEP. (Footnote 11)
A. Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Educational Needs and Reasonably Calculated to Provide Some Benefit
To determine whether the District’s program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique education needs, it is first necessary to identify those needs as they existed in November 2003. The parties generally do not dispute what STUDENT’s deficits were during the 2003-2004 regular school year. As set forth above, STUDENT exhibited difficulty in expressive and receptive language, pragmatics, socialization, and fine motor skills and he had difficulty with distractability and inattention.
FATHER described STUDENT as a fairly bright child who exhibited difficulty with his speech. STUDENT could articulate a few words, but his speech was mostly jabbering. In November 2003, some words of requesting were just emerging in STUDENT. Approximately twenty percent of the time, FATHER was able to obtain a verbal response or request from STUDENT. FATHER testified that most of the time STUDENT would take your hand and lead you to what he wanted. FATHER also described STUDENT as an intriguing child with a lot of capabilities, some of which were being expressed then, but with many abilities that had not yet emerged. STUDENT was described as having difficulty attending. Sometimes he could sit when he was asked and sometimes he could not. Dinner was generally a more difficult time to get him to settle down and attend. However, STUDENT was capable of sitting and going through a book with an adult. In November, it was fairly difficult for STUDENT to make eye contact when requested and verbal cues would have to be given once or twice.
In light of STUDENT’s needs identified above, the District offered STUDENT placement in Regina Gutierrez’s structured autism preschool program at Oak Grove five days per week, four hours per day. In addition, STUDENT was offered the following DIS: five hours per week of IBI in the home and five hours per week of IBI in the school setting; two hours per month of IBI supervision; one thirty-minute occupational therapy small-group session per week; one thirty-minute individual speech and language therapy session per week; one thirty-minute speech and language therapy small-group session per week; and six one-hour IBI parent training and skill generalization sessions per year. The IEP contained four cognitive/pre-academic goals, two fine motor goals, five social skills goals, one pre-vocational goal, three self-help goals, six receptive language goals, and four expressive language goals. Although there is no dispute concerning the type of placement and STUDENT needed, the parties do not agree on the goals and objectives, the exact placement, the amount and location of IBI services, and the amount of occupational therapy and speech and language therapy STUDENT required to receive a FAPE. Petitioner contends that the District’s offer was not a FAPE and that he should have been placed in the structured autism preschool program in Ms. Waldron’s class at Palisades. In addition, STUDENT should have received twelve hours of IBI per week in the home; six hours per month of IBI supervision; IBI parent training; three hours per week of individual speech and language therapy; and two hours per week of individual occupational therapy. The strongest area of contention was the goals and objectives developed by the District.
Petitioner contends that the District failed to identify appropriate baselines in all areas of need in the IEP. Further, Petitioner contends that the District (1) failed to develop measurable goals in all areas of his unique needs as recommended by Coyne & Associates, (2) failed to develop measurable goals in all areas of need as identified by the District in its assessments, specifically in the area of speech and language, occupational therapy, social skills, cognitive skills, fine motor skills, and gross motor skills, and (3) failed to set sufficiently challenging goals because some had already been achieved.
Present levels of performance. California Education Code section 56345 provides that for a preschool-age child, the written IEP shall list the present levels of the child’s educational performance, including, as appropriate, how the disability affects the child’s participation in appropriate activities.
Present levels of performance on the November 18, 2003 IEP are listed in the categories of cognitive/pre-academics, fine motor skills, social skills, pre-vocational skills, self-help skills, receptive language, and expressive language. Comparison of the language in the IEP to other documents indicates that the present levels of performance were derived from the multidisciplinary report, including the speech and language assessment, and the occupational therapy assessment.
The Hearing Officer finds that the present levels of performance, as written in the November 18, 2003 IEP, accurately conveyed STUDENT’s deficits. STUDENT’s most severe deficits were in the areas of receptive and expressive language. Present levels of performance should be used as a basis for establishing goals and objectives, and are also relevant in determining an appropriate placement. The present levels of performance indicated in the IEP are consistent with the assessments completed by the District and are also consistent with the Coyne & Associates’ report and the IEEs obtained by Petitioner. It is clear from the testimony in this matter that the District members of the IEPT gave due consideration to all of STUDENT’s needs and the severity of STUDENT’s deficits before writing the goals and objectives and making recommendations for placement and services for STUDENT.
Goals and objectives. California Education Code section 56345 provides that the IEP shall include measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, related to meeting the pupil’s needs resulting from the pupil’s disability and enabling the pupil to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. See also 34 C.F.R. § 300.347 (a)(2). The purpose of short-term objectives or benchmarks is to provide a mechanism for a child’s teacher and parents to monitor the child’s progress -- or lack thereof -- in special education over the course of the year. See 34 C.F.R., Appendix A to Part 300.
Petitioner presented extensive testimony in criticism of the proposed goals and objectives. Specifically, through the testimony of Dr. Davidson, Ms. Rozenberg, and Ms. Cohen, Petitioner contends that the goals and objectives were too low or had already been mastered, that additional goals were needed, and that some of the goals were not measurable. The District contends that it provided appropriate goals and objectives and that they were measurable. The Hearing Officer finds the District’s position persuasive. Ms. Gutierrez testified that she understood each goal and objective and identified, in detail, when in the classroom schedule each of STUDENT’s goals would have been addressed. Ms. Gutierrez also testified that if a goal were mastered she would move to the next task level. The Hearing Officer will address the disputed goals in turn.
Dr. Davidson testified that STUDENT’s counting goal, which provided that by November 2004 STUDENT would count orally to five using pegs or beads as the teacher pointed to each item on four out of five occasions, was too low because when she tested him in December 2003, STUDENT could count to three. Dr. Davidson contends that the short-term objective of the counting goal, which required STUDENT to count to three, had already been met. Dr. Davidson believed a more appropriate goal would have been for STUDENT to count to at least ten. FATHER also testified that in November 2003, STUDENT could count to three by vocalizing the numbers. According to FATHER, he informed the IEPT of this at the IEP meeting and expressed his concern that some of the goals were too low. The data delivery logs (Petitioner’s Ex. 44) indicate that on January 20, 2004, STUDENT was not able to count to five; a score of ten percent in STUDENT’s ability to count to five is noted. The data delivery logs also indicate that STUDENT could not count to two without prompting. On February 10, 2004, a score of thirty percent is noted. Page eight of the notes from the IEP meeting (Respondent’s Ex. 7) indicates that the IEPT informed FATHER that the IEP process allows for modification and revision of the goals at any time should new areas need to be addressed or if the student exceeds the anticipated rate of progress. The District was concerned about pushing STUDENT too hard and causing him to become frustrated, yet they wanted STUDENT to progress as quickly as possible. At the IEP meeting, FATHER agreed with the District’s position. Based upon the information provided to the IEPT at the IEP meeting and STUDENT’s then-present levels of performance, the Hearing Officer finds that this was an appropriate goal in November 2003.
Dr. Davidson also criticized the goal on page twelve of the IEP, which provided that by November 2004, STUDENT would identify five basic colors on four out of five occasions as determined by teacher observation, selected records, or tests. Dr. Davidson testified that STUDENT could easily match five colors and that the appropriate goal for STUDENT was for ten colors to be matched. FATHER testified that in November 2003, STUDENT could match two or three colors. The Hearing Office finds the testimony of FATHER persuasive as it is confirmed by the daily data sheets provided by the IBI tutor. On December 18, 2003, STUDENT’s matching of five colors was accurate thirty percent of the time. On December 19, 2003, he was scored at twenty percent. As of January 6, 2004, STUDENT was matching colors with only sixty percent accuracy. (Footnote 12) In addition, Mr. Ellison testified that generalization is a concern for children with autism. The goals and objectives were developed with this in mind. In addition, Mr. Ochoa, STUDENT’s IBI supervisor from Coyne & Associates, testified that when he was delivering IBI services to STUDENT, he observed that STUDENT had difficulty generalizing tasks from the bedroom where tutoring occurred to another room in the house. Ms. Adams, STUDENT’s current IBI supervisor, and Ms. Gutierrez testified that they would each be working with STUDENT on this goal. Therefore, this goal was appropriate in November 2003.
Dr. Davidson also criticized STUDENT’s goal that by November 2004, STUDENT would sit and attend to a five-minute story on four out of five occasions and participate in circle-time activities on four out of five occasions as determined by teacher observation, selected records or tests. The Coyne & Associates’ report indicated that an appropriate circle-time goal for STUDENT would have been to sit for ten to fifteen minutes in a group. Mr. Ellison testified that based upon his assessment of STUDENT, he believed the District’s goal in this area was appropriate because STUDENT was having difficulty attending during his observation. The data sheets support this conclusion (Petitioner’s Ex. 44). On December 18, 2003, STUDENT was able to sit for a three- minute story but required six prompts, leaving him with a score of forty percent. On February 6, 2004, STUDENT was able to attend to a one-minute story with one prompt. As of March 31, 2004, STUDENT was still working on mastering a five-minute story. On at least one occasion on either March 30 or March 31, he was able to listen to a five-minute story without prompts. However, the next time the task was attempted, STUDENT required three prompts. Beryl Adams, the District’s autism specialist and STUDENT’s IBI supervisor, testified that mastery occurs when STUDENT is able to complete the requested task for more than one adult and over a period of time. Ms. Adams testified that at the time she became STUDENT’s IBI supervisor in December 2003, STUDENT had not mastered any of the goals set forth in the November 18, 2003 IEP. Based upon the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the five-minute story and circle-time goal was appropriate for STUDENT in November 2003.
The November 2003 IEP contained a goal which provided that by November 2004, STUDENT would play beside or around other children and watch other children intently on four out of five occasions as measured by teacher observation or records. Dr. Davidson and Ms. Rozenberg contend that the District’s goal concerning parallel play was inappropriate. Based upon STUDENT’s present levels of performance and the recommendations contained in the Coyne & Associates’ report, Dr. Davidson testified that a more appropriate goal for STUDENT would have been a goal in the area of reciprocal play which also would have involved turn taking. The Coyne & Associates’ report indicates that STUDENT was becoming more interested in other children and recommended a reciprocal play goal with turn taking with a peer and minimal prompts. While working with Coyne & Associates, STUDENT was able to engage in simply play games when initiated by an adult and was able to play appropriately with a thematic toy. Mr. Ochoa testified that he told the District’s assessors that although they were not able to obtain cooperation from STUDENT when he was being assessed, STUDENT had mastered his play goal with Coyne & Associates. Ms. Rozenberg testified that play goals are important because they are an extension of language and symbolic knowledge. This is a core deficit of children with autism in that they lack intraspective talking and the symbolic use of language.
The District contends that a parallel play goal was more appropriate because STUDENT had not had a set of peers to play with due to a lack of a preschool setting. As previously stated, the District was very concerned about STUDENT’s ability to generalize skills into the classroom setting. The evidence presented showed that STUDENT had difficulty transferring tasks between rooms in his home or between his room and outside. No evidence was produced that would show STUDENT was able to achieve this goal in a classroom setting. In addition, the data sheets show that STUDENT had achieved parallel play with one hundred percent accuracy on only a few occasions by the end of the 2003-2004 regular school year. However, STUDENT has not been able to parallel play with one hundred percent accuracy over any significant period of time. Therefore, the parallel play goal was appropriate in November 2003.
Dr. Davidson and Ms. Rozenberg also contend that the goal providing that by November 2004, STUDENT would follow one-step directions within the context of a familiar classroom routine in eight out of ten trials as measured by staff observation, records, and/or selected tests was inappropriate. The Coyne & Associates’ report indicates that STUDENT had mastered the goal of following five receptive instructions without visual cues and recommended that a goal be set for STUDENT that would require him to follow ten two-step instructions both at the table and require crossing the room a distance of seven to ten feet. The District’s goal specifically requires that the goal be completed in a classroom setting. In addition, the data sheets indicate that STUDENT was not able to follow three receptive instructions when the District began delivering IBI services to STUDENT in December 2003. Therefore, the District’s goal was appropriate in November 2003.
Ms. Rozenberg also criticized the goals and objectives set by the District. Specifically, Ms. Rozenberg concluded that STUDENT’s social skills goal of following directives from the teacher had already been mastered by STUDENT. The Coyne & Associates’ report indicates that STUDENT had mastered following five receptive instructions without visual cues. However, both Mr. Ellison and Ms. Brown indicated that STUDENT was noncompliant during their assessments. The data sheets also support the inclusion of this goal. For example, on January 5, 2004, two IBI tutors took STUDENT outside of his home and he was noncompliant with instructions of the tutors. Given the difficulty STUDENT had with generalization of location and with adults, this was an appropriate goal for STUDENT as he transitioned into a classroom setting.
Ms. Rozenberg further criticized the District’s goal for STUDENT that by November 2004, he would identify pictures of common objects upon request in eight out of ten trials as measured by observation, anecdotal notes, and/or selected tests. The Coyne & Associates’ report indicated that STUDENT had mastered spoon, cup, banana, and chips. Ms. Rozenberg contends that based upon the mastery of these items that the goal of eight of ten was too low. The data sheets reveal that as of May 10, 2004, STUDENT still had not mastered this goal. Although he did identify common objects with one hundred percent accuracy on four occasions between April 1 and May 10, 2004, there were also occasions when he could not identify any items or identified objects with thirty percent accuracy after being able to achieve one hundred percent accuracy. This data further supports the District’s position concerning STUDENT’s difficulty with generalization. Therefore, the goal was appropriate in November 2003.
Ms. Rozenberg also criticized the District’s goals and objectives for failing to provide goals in other areas. Ms. Rozenberg concluded that the District should have set goals for oral motor imitation, verbal motor imitation, “manding” for attention, intraverbal relations, greeting, and making eye contact. Development of goals and objectives in these areas was also recommended by Coyne & Associates. The District contends that the goals recommended by Coyne & Associates and Ms. Rozenberg were incorporated into many of the District’s other goals, including, primarily, the circle-time goal. Regarding articulation goals, Ms. Brown, the District’s speech and language pathologist, testified that prior to implementation of any articulation goal, it was important for STUDENT to obtain more words.
The Hearing Officer finds the District’s position persuasive. Ms. Adams testified that greetings, including “hi” and “goodbye,” are embedded in circle-time activities. Circle time includes different activities that include singing songs, greeting, story time, and calendar activities. The preschool teacher determines which goals to work on in the classroom and IBI breaks down the goals into elements. By stating the goals and objectives in general terms, the teacher and service providers have flexibility in implementing the goals. Progress meetings are then held to clarify and track a child’s progress. Ms. Brown also testified that the goals and objectives proposed by Coyne & Associates were incorporated into the District’s goals and objectives. In addition, Mr. Ochoa was present at the IEP meeting when these goals and objectives were presented. All of the District representatives present at the IEP meeting consistently testified that their impression from the meeting was that Mr. Ochoa was in agreement with the goals and objectives presented. (Footnote 13) Therefore, in general, there was no persuasive evidence that additional goals in the areas proposed by Ms. Rozenberg were necessary for STUDENT.
Ms. Cohen also criticized the District’s goals and objectives. Ms. Cohen believed that the Coyne & Associates’ goals in the areas of gross motor, including walking backwards and on a balance beam, fine motor skills and fine motor imitation should have been incorporated into the District’s goals. The Hearing Officer does not find Petitioner’s position persuasive. STUDENT had not been identified as having deficits in the area of gross motor skills by any witness, including his father. Ms. Shapland testified that STUDENT had good motor planning and could go through obstacle courses. The District did include goals in the area of fine motor, including drawing horizontal and vertical lines, a circle, and a cross and using scissors to cut an eight- inch line. Although STUDENT was able to cut a line during the District’s assessment, this activity did not rise to the level of accomplishing the goal identified by the District. Further, STUDENT only mastered his cutting goal a couple of months ago. He has still not mastered his drawing goal. STUDENT is now able to consistently draw a circle; however, he is not able draw a diagonal line or cross. Ms. Shapland is not ready to change STUDENT’s goal at this time. For these reasons, as well as concerns with generalization, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s goals were appropriate in November 2003.
Ms. Cohen also proposed four goals in the following areas: postural control; bilateral motor coordination and motor planning; perceptual concepts, motor planning, and writing; and sensory processing, behavioral control, and peer interaction/cooperative play. The Hearing Officer finds that goals in these areas would not have been appropriate for STUDENT. STUDENT did not have any difficulty with postural control, bilateral motor coordination, motor planning, or perceptual concepts. As stated previously, Ms. Shapland has been providing OT services to STUDENT since December 2003. She has not seen any indication that STUDENT has difficulties in these areas. Further, these areas have not been identified as areas of difficulty for STUDENT by any other assessor or service provider. Ms. Shapland testified that STUDENT would have been provided a sensory diet that would have been incorporated into the classroom setting to address any sensory needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that goals and objectives in these areas were not needed.
Petitioner also criticizes the cognitive/pre-academic goal which provides that by November 2004, STUDENT would match objects by size and color on four out of five occasions as determined by teacher observation, selected records, or tests. Petitioner contends that the goal was set too low because he could already accomplish this task. Although the Coyne & Associates’ report indicated that STUDENT could match two-dimensional stimuli, the District’s goal provided for increased dimensions. Mr. Ellison testified that for mastery of STUDENT’s matching goal, he would need to have matched three-dimensional stimuli. For example, STUDENT would have been required to match a big, yellow circle. This is clearly a more advanced skill than that identified by Coyne & Associates. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the matching goal was appropriate in November 2003.
Petitioner also asserts that the goal which stated that by November 2004, he would recognize action pictures by pointing upon request with eighty percent accuracy as measured by staff observation, records, and/or selected tests was vague and unmeasurable. The Hearing Officer finds this argument is without merit. First, the goal is clearly measurable in that it required eighty percent accuracy for mastery. Second, Ms. Gutierrez testified that she understood the goal, would have been able to implement the goal, and identified when in STUDENT’s program she would have worked on the goal. The Hearing Officer finds that the goal was appropriate in November 2003.
Petitioner further asserts that the social skills goal and objective which provided that by November 2004, he would visually request (PECS) or verbally request a desired item on four out of five occasions as measured by teacher observation or records was inappropriate because he was a verbal child and he had not previously used PECS. Ms. Rozenberg testified that PECS was not appropriate for STUDENT because he had oral communication skills and could imitate oral communication. However, Petitioner’s behavior expert, Ms. Kerr, testified that in her opinion PECS was important because of STUDENT’s lack of language. The use of visuals would relieve STUDENT’s frustration. In Ms. Kerr’s opinion, the use of PECS would not result in delay of expressive language. Ms. Kerr testified that the use of multiple communication systems would not have interfered with STUDENT learning verbal skills and that the use of PECS would have been helpful for STUDENT. Mr. Ellison testified that based upon his interaction with STUDENT and his observations, PECS would have been an effective tool to use with STUDENT. Ms. Shapland testified that during her observation of STUDENT, he exhibited difficulty transitioning between tasks and occasionally tantrummed. Ms. Shapland testified that the use of PECS would be helpful in transitions and in transitioning. Ms. Brown testified that PECS was added to the goal because STUDENT was not consistently getting his needs met with verbalization. (Footnote 14) Ms. Gutierrez testified that PECS does not distract from the acquisition of language. She further testified that if a child is verbal, she would use PECS in addition to seeking a verbal response from a child.
The Hearing Officer finds that the addition of PECS in a social skills goal was not inappropriate. The District did not propose the use of PECS in any expressive or receptive language goal. The Hearing Officer is persuaded that the use of PECS for STUDENT would have assisted him in transitioning and in avoiding tantrums. Further, one of Petitioner’s own experts testified that the use of PECS with him would have been helpful. Finally, the goal did not require the use of PECS; PECS was clearly only an option.
Finally, Petitioner contends that the goals and objectives prepared by Coyne & Associates were not incorporated into his IEP. Ms. Adams, the District’s autism specialist and STUDENT’s IBI supervisor, testified that she carefully reviewed the Coyne & Associates’ report to ensure that the District was in fact addressing all of STUDENT’s needs. Ms. Adams testified that after reviewing the IEP and the Coyne & Associates’ report, she concluded that all of the Coyne & Associates’ recommended goals and objectives were incorporated into the IEP with the exception of a goal which would have required STUDENT to wait for a desired activity or object. Ms. Adams testified that the waiting goal was not appropriate for STUDENT at that time because STUDENT was to move to a classroom setting. According to Ms. Adams, in a classroom setting the waiting goal would not be appropriate in the beginning; the compliance goal is paramount. Once the compliance goal was achieved, then it would have been appropriate to move on to a waiting goal.
The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Adams persuasive. Ms. Adams testified that she is familiar with the District’s structured autism programs and is aware of the training and experience of the teachers and aides. Ms. Adams’ review of the goals of objectives of Coyne & Associates and the District was thorough and her explanation of the practical application of goals and objectives was compelling. Ms. Adams indicated that the goals and objectives needed to be written in such a way that IBI tutors and instructors could increase or change the stimuli to ensure true mastery of a task and educational growth. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that all of the Coyne & Associates’ goals were incorporated into the IEP goals and objectives with the exception of the waiting goal, which was not appropriate in November 2003.
****************
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s goals and objectives were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. STUDENT had difficulty generalizing skills between adults and locations within his own home. His transfer to a classroom setting, which would have added peers, was likely to, at least initially, lead to further difficulty with generalization based upon STUDENT’s past behavior. In addition, the District informed FATHER that they were willing to change and modify goals as they were met by STUDENT. The Hearing Officer also finds that the goals and objectives were measurable. Each goal provided the number of successful trials necessary to master the benchmark. The language of the goals and objectives provided the tutors and teachers sufficient information to measure STUDENT’s progress, while at the same time allowing flexibility to increase STUDENT’s skill level when appropriate. Given that STUDENT has only mastered three of the twenty-five goals--his cutting goal, matching and sorting goal, and listening to a story for five minutes--as of April 2004, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s goals and objectives were appropriate in November 2003.
Placement and services. The Hearing Officer must next determine if the District’s proposed placement was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of socialization, receptive and expressive language, fine motor skills, and self-help and pre-academic skills. Petitioner does not dispute that a structured autism preschool was an appropriate placement for him or that his goals and objectives could have been implemented in that setting. Rather, Petitioner asserts that Ms. Gutierrez was not qualified and that her class was not as structured as Ms. Waldron’s, another teacher in the District. After a careful review of the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence does not support Petitioner’s contention that the placement offered by the District for the 2003-2004 regular school year was not designed to address his unique educational needs. STUDENT’s unique educational needs are undisputed. However, Petitioner disputes that placement in Ms. Gutierrez’s class was appropriate. Petitioner also contends that IBI services in the amount of twelve hours per week, OT services in the amount of two hours per week, and speech and language services in the amount of three hours per week should have been provided, together with eight hours of IBI supervision and parent training. Petitioner also contends that the IBI services should be delivered in-home.
Oak Grove Structured Autism Preschool Special Day Class. The evidence produced at the hearing showed that the placement offer of Oak Grove was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Ms. Gutierrez’s Oak Grove classroom was observed by Mr. Ellison, Ms. Brown, and Dr. Paul Dores. All of these witnesses agree that this was an appropriate placement for STUDENT. The program was provided five days per week for four hours per day. The purpose of the structured autism preschool class was to provide a low child-to-teacher ratio to allow more opportunities for one-to-one adult instruction to work on specific goals in areas of need. At the time of the IEP, Ms. Gutierrez had five students enrolled in her classroom and she had two adult aides. The class was very structured and focused on STUDENT’s main deficits in that it was language based. Ms. Gutierrez testified that a language-based program is more attuned to language in the classroom than other preschool programs. The children are given prompts to provide some sort of communication through language instead of the instructor anticipating what a child is requesting. Language is addressed throughout the daily program.
Ms. Gutierrez testified that she employed many different methods in her teaching, including discrete trial training (DTT), TEACCH, Links to Language, Handwriting Without Tears, and Floor Time. These methods are among those Dr. Davidson suggested be implemented in working with STUDENT. Ms. Gutierrez’s preschool program included, among other things, schedules, circle time, and centers. In the centers, there were two to three children at a time. At the centers IBI methods were employed in many areas including math, counting, adding, and sorting colors. General language was also used during the center activities. Ms. Gutierrez’s program also had an OT component and reverse mainstreaming that would have met the requirements set forth in STUDENT’s IEP.
Dr. Dores, an autism expert, has provided ongoing consultation for the development of autism classrooms in the District. (Footnote 15) He has helped define what a structured autism class should provide, has observed the District’s program, has made recommendations, and has conducted trainings. Dr. Dores indicated that an autism class should have a small number of children with enhanced levels of staffing. In addition, the staff should have specialized training in behavior and structural technologies. The advantage of a structured autism class is greater access to consultation and supervision in areas that can be particularly troublesome. Dr. Dores has observed Ms. Gutierrez’s classroom and, in his opinion, Ms. Gutierrez’s classroom was of high quality and complied with all the components of a structured autism class.
Petitioner’s disagreement with the placement is not the structured autism preschool, but Ms. Gutierrez’s classroom. All of the witnesses agreed that STUDENT should have been placed in a language-based structured autism class. It is undisputed that Ms. Gutierrez’s class is a language- based structured autism preschool class. Dr. Davidson’s disagreement with the placement in Ms. Gutierrez’s classroom is based upon her observation that Ms. Gutierrez’s classroom did not appear as structured as Ms. Waldron’s class at Palisades and that Ms. Gutierrez did not have goals and objectives posted on her classroom wall. Dr. Davidson believed that this was an indication of the organization and structure of the classroom. Dr. Davidson also placed emphasis on there not being any girls in Ms. Gutierrez’s class. The Hearing Officer finds Petitioner’s argument unpersuasive. Dr. Davidson testified that she only observed Ms. Gutierrez’s classroom for twenty minutes on two occasions. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Gutierrez’s classroom was highly structured and the lack of goals and objectives posted on the classroom wall does not lead to a denial of a FAPE. There was no evidence that a teacher’s choice of where to maintain goals and objectives for students in the classroom impacts the education being provided to the student. In addition, Dr. Davidson admitted that the lack of girls in the classroom would not have impacted STUDENT’s education.
Petitioner also argues that placement in Ms. Gutierrez’s classroom was not appropriate because Ms. Gutierrez is an inexperienced teacher. The Hearing Officer does not find this argument persuasive. For a teacher to be qualified to teach a special education class, the teacher must hold a special education credential and possess the necessary competencies to teach individuals assigned to the class. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3053(c).
The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Gutierrez was qualified to teach a structured autism preschool class. Ms. Gutierrez graduated from San Diego State with a bachelor’s degree in child and family development in 2002. She obtained her special education credential from California State University at Fullerton in August 2003, and is currently working on her master’s degree in early childhood special education. Ms. Gutierrez completed her student teaching in an autism-specific classroom in Yorba Linda/Placentia School District. This was Ms. Gutierrez’s first year teaching a structured autism preschool class. Dr. Dores testified that Ms. Gutierrez was a “great” teacher. There is no evidence to the contrary. Further, the evidence shows that Ms. Gutierrez successfully taught five autistic children this year. One child is transitioning into a regular education classroom, one is moving onto a less restrictive special day class, and one is transitioning into a blended program. Therefore, although this was Ms. Gutierrez’ first teaching assignment, there is no evidence that she lacked the education or experience to have provided STUDENT with a FAPE.
Based upon the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement in Ms. Gutierrez’s structured autism preschool special day class was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs. The Hearing Officer also finds that the proposed placement was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.
IBI services and supervision. As previously stated, “related services” must be provided when required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(17). California Education Code section 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”
The District offered to provide STUDENT with ten hours per week of IBI services, five in the home and five at school. The District also offered two hours per month of IBI supervision and six one-hour parent training sessions per year. Petitioner contends that IBI services for STUDENT should have continued in the amount of twelve hours per week in-home and six hours per month of supervision. This contention is based upon the progress that STUDENT has made in his current program, as well as Petitioner’s assertion that there is a preference for the educational program for children under three is to focus on the whole family.
The Hearing Officer finds that the IBI services proposed by the District were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. California Education Code section 56441.4 provides that for children between the ages of three and five years old, appropriate settings for special education services include any of the following: (a) the regular public or private nonsectarian preschool program; (b) the child development center or family day care home; (c) the child's regular environment that may include the home; (d) a special site where preschool programs for both children with disabilities and children who are not disabled are located close to each other and have an opportunity to share resources and programming; (e) a special education preschool program with children who are not disabled attending and participating for all or part of the program; or (f) a public school setting which provides an age-appropriate environment, materials, and services, as defined by the superintendent. The weight of the evidence shows that STUDENT was ready to participate in a special education preschool program by November 2003. The Hearing Officer was persuaded by the testimony of the District’s witnesses, particularly Ms. Adams and Dr. Dores. In weighing the testimony of the Petitioner’s witnesses and the District’s witnesses, the Hearing Officer considered several factors, including the expertise of the witnesses.
Dr. Dores testified that he is a strong believer in early intervention in the area of autism, specifically behavior-based early intervention. Dr. Dores testified that home is an appropriate place to start, but research indicates that a home program should be the primary place for services only when it is not feasible for the child to participate in a school-based program or the school is incapable of providing the services for the child. There are characteristics present when a child is ready to move from home to other settings, including whether there is an appropriate and effective receiving party; whether the child is beginning to have the ability to respond in anything other than a one-to-one environment; and the social needs of the child. Dr. Dores advocates for a child to be moved into a classroom setting as quickly as possible in terms of acclimating to structure, noise, and other factors. One of the goals of IBI is to prepare children to attend a school-based program. It is important to make sure skills that are being taught are skills that can be used in the ultimate environment where teaching will take place. In addition, a school setting has typically developing peers, as well as peers with non-typical skill development. A school setting provides greater social development because of the resources of large groups and small groups.
According to Ms. Adams and Mr. Ochoa, STUDENT was capable of participating in a preschool program in November 2003. The evidence also supports a finding that the District was capable of providing appropriate IBI services for STUDENT. Ms. Adams is the District’s autism specialist and an IBI supervisor. Ms. Adams has a bachelor’s degree in comparative psychology and a master’s degree in administration. In 1983 Ms. Adams obtained her school psychology masters degree, and in 1991 Ms. Adams became a behavior specialist within a school psychology setting. Ms. Adams has had extensive specific autism training. Ms. Adams was also a trainer in TEACCH and PECS in the State of Vermont. Ms. Adams is responsible for assessing children and overseeing, developing, and refining programs to meet children’s needs.
STUDENT was placed on Ms. Adams’ caseload on December 9, 2003, as part of the transition of IBI services from Coyne & Associates to the District. Ms. Adams first met with STUDENT in January 2004. Ms. Adams further testified that at the time she began working with STUDENT, she would have liked to have moved STUDENT to a school program. She has observed STUDENT and reviewed his progress and believes he was ready to move to a school situation. Ms. Adams does not believe it would have been appropriate to provide IBI strictly in the in-home setting because children with autism tend to become very dependent upon adults. It is important for children to move into a school setting as young as possible to develop social skills. Ms. Adams also testified that she is familiar with the model of splitting IBI services between home and school. Ms. Adams testified that this model is used with children who have language limitations. STUDENT does not have language limitations that would limit his work at school. She is also concerned that if a child is taught in isolation too long, they will over learn that situation and have greater difficulty transitioning to other environments and generalizing their skills. Further, Ms. Adams testified that the five hours of IBI services in the classroom has exponentially more impact than the one-to-one provided outside the classroom.
Although Petitioner opposes the proposed IBI services by the District, the Petitioner did not provide any persuasive evidence that would lead the Hearing Officer to conclude that the IBI offer was inappropriate. Ms. Kerr testified that the natural learning setting is the home and that STUDENT has demonstrated the ability to learn at home. Ms. Kerr also indicated that STUDENT has a role model available at home, his typically developing brother. She was also concerned with STUDENT’s ability to generalize and believed that the IBI should continue at twelve hours per month in-home based on STUDENT’s progress. Ms. Kerr did not testify that the District’s offer would not have met STUDENT’s needs, only that the twelve hours would have been better. However, when this testimony is weighed against that of Dr. Dores and Ms. Adams, it is not persuasive. The testimony of Dr. Dores and Ms. Adams is supported by their expertise and experience and is logical and convincing. In addition, pursuant to Rowley, the District is not required to offer the best possible placement and services, only those that would have allowed STUDENT to benefit in his educational program.
Additionally, the Hearing Officer finds that two hours per month of IBI supervision was sufficient to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs. Although Ms. Kerr testified that six hours per month of IBI supervision would have been sufficient if STUDENT had been provided with IBI services in the home, she also testified that if STUDENT had received ten hours of IBI services per week, two hours of supervision would be appropriate. Ms. Kerr further testified that STUDENT’s case was fairly straight forward and that STUDENT did not have a lot of behavior problems. With regard to parent training, all of the witnesses agreed that parent training was necessary for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the testimony of the District members of the IEPT who all of whom agree that the services offered in the IEP, including parent training, would have met STUDENT’s needs. Mr. Ellison has had numerous years of experience working with children in an educational setting and was in a better position to determine the amount of parent training necessary to provide STUDENT with educational benefit than Dr. Davidson. Mr. Ellison has evaluated preschool students and worked as a school psychologist in an elementary school for eight years. Dr. Davidson, however, does not have any experience with preschool children in an educational setting. (Petitioner’s Ex. 49.) The Hearing Officer finds that the offered IBI supervision and parent training was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of five hours of IBI at home, five hours of IBI at school, and two hours per month supervision plus six hours of parent training per year was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs. The Hearing Officer also finds that the IBI offer was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.
Occupational therapy. The District offered STUDENT one thirty-minute session of occupational therapy in a small group per week. In addition, Ms. Gutierrez testified that an occupational therapist came into her classroom for forty-five minutes each week to work with the children on fine motor skills and toileting skills. Ms. Shapland testified that she would also have prepared a sensory diet to be integrated into the classroom once STUDENT transitioned to the structured autism preschool class.
Petitioner relies on the testimony of Ms. Cohen to support his position that two hours of individual OT services per week was necessary for him to receive benefit from his educational program. The Hearing Officer is not persuaded by the testimony of Ms. Cohen. Ms. Cohen’s report was specious in that Ms. Cohen failed to administer any assessment tools which were standardized for STUDENT’s age or were appropriate to evaluate STUDENT in the school setting. Ms. Shapland credibly testified that many of the tasks Ms. Cohen asserted STUDENT could not accomplish were not age appropriate. Ms. Cohen’s conclusions were not corroborated by other reports, including that of Coyne & Associates. Ms. Cohen’s administration of the Sensory Profile was also suspect because in May 2004, she instructed STUDENT’s parents to recall their responses to questions in the previous Sensory Profile administered by Ms. Shapland in November 2003. Ms. Cohen then took those responses and inserted them into the 2002 Sensory Profile to obtain a result. Ms. Shapland testified that the questions in the previous Sensory Profile and the 2002 Sensory Profile were not the same.
Further, Petitioner’s position is not supported by the evidence. As set forth above, STUDENT did not appear to have any deficits in gross motor. STUDENT’s fine motor deficits would have been addressed in his small-group OT sessions and the classroom setting. Ms. Shapland testified that OT was needed to address STUDENT’s sensory-based needs and to assist STUDENT in generalizing his skills into the classroom. Ms. Shapland has worked with STUDENT and will continue to provide him with OT services pursuant to the IEP. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by Ms. Shapland’s testimony that the OT services provided in the IEP would have allowed STUDENT to benefit from his educational program.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of occupational therapy was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs. The Hearing Office also finds that the offer for occupational therapy was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.
Speech and language therapy. Petitioner contends that he required three hours of individual speech and language therapy per week to benefit from his education program based upon his level of deficits. The District contends that because the structured autism preschool is a language-based program, the District’s offer of one thirty-minute session per week of individual speech therapy and one thirty-minute session per week of small-group speech and language therapy was sufficient to allow STUDENT to benefit from his educational program.
Ms. Rozenberg testified that STUDENT needed three hours of speech and language therapy per week. Ms. Rozenberg contends that each session should have been one hour in length because STUDENT’s attention could be maintained for that duration of time. In addition, Ms. Rozenberg contends that this level of service was necessary because STUDENT had severe deficits, but his language was emerging. Further, STUDENT had normal cognition and was at a prime age for language development. Ms. Rozenberg also asserts that individual therapy was necessary because STUDENT did not have the skills to generalize his language and had to demonstrate generalization prior to peers being introduced into a therapeutic setting. Ms. Rozenberg did admit that STUDENT has demonstrated some social skills in a group setting.
The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the testimony of Ms. Brown. Ms. Brown testified that she made the District’s recommendation for speech and language therapy because STUDENT was to be placed in a structured autism preschool program which was language based. In reaching her conclusion, Ms. Brown not only observed Ms. Gutierrez’s classroom, but she also spoke with STUDENT’s IBI tutors. Ms. Brown agreed that if STUDENT were not placed in a language-based structured autism preschool, then he would need additional speech and language services. Ms. Brown recommended small-group speech and language services because a small group would have given STUDENT the opportunity to learn new language skills and use them in appropriate situations. The small group provides opportunities for labeling, requesting, and identifying items. The small-group setting allows the child to see communication as important. In a small group, a child is able to learn social interaction, take turns, and communicate. In individual therapy, Ms. Brown works on tasks such as showing pictures to point to, “give me,” and play activities. She usually starts with a song and ends with a goodbye song, using STUDENT’s name.
In addition, Ms. Brown does not believe that three hours per week would have been appropriate for STUDENT because of his tender age. Ms. Brown has not previously provided one- hour speech and language therapy sessions for three-year-old children. Ms. Brown testified that she did not feel this was appropriate, given their attention span at such a young age. In fact, STUDENT was described by Mr. Ellison and Ms. Brown as having difficulty attending during evaluations. Ms. Brown testified that if a child is in a structured autism language-based program, she would not recommend more speech and language therapy sessions beyond those offered to STUDENT in November 2003. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the speech and language therapy services offered would have met STUDENT’s unique educational needs. The Hearing Office also finds that the offer for speech and language services was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.
******************
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT had unique needs in the areas of expressive and receptive language, cognitive/pre-academics, fine motor skills, social skills, pre-vocational skills, and self-help skills. The present levels of performance and goals and objectives drafted by the District adequately addressed each need. Further, the District’s offer for placement and services was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The Hearing Officer also finds that the proposed placement and services were reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.
B. Comports with his IEP
There is no dispute that the District was and remains ready, willing, and able to provide the placement, services, and implementation of the goals and objectives specified in the IEP of November 18, 2003. In fact, the District has provided speech and language services, occupational therapy, and IBI consistent with the IEP.
*******************
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 regular school year. The District’s offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs, was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit, and would have comported with STUDENT’s November 18, 2003 IEP.
Issue No. 4: Is STUDENT entitled to the following remedies?
A. Reimbursement for the independent educational evaluations completed by Abby M. Rozenberg, Laurie Cohen, ACES, Inc., and Dr. Christine Davidson.
A parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation (IEE) performed by a qualified specialist at public expense if (1) the parent disagrees with an evaluation obtained by the educational agency and (2) the educational agency is unable to show at a due process hearing that its evaluation was appropriate. 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b).
The Hearing Officer found that the District’s evaluations were appropriate. Therefore, Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for the IEEs completed by Ms. Rozenberg, Ms. Cohen, ACES, Inc., or Dr. Davidson.
B. Reimbursement for speech and language services provided to STUDENT at his parents’ expense. Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under the IDEA. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994).
The District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE. Therefore, STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for speech and language services or the transportation costs associated therewith.
C. Compensatory education consisting of additional speech and language services, occupational therapy services, and behavioral therapy services.
The Petitioner contends that he is entitled to compensatory education services in the amounts recommended in the IEEs since November 2003.
Courts have consistently held that the authority to award compensatory education is derived from 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i)(2)(B)(iii), which authorizes a court to grant such “relief as it determines is appropriate.” “The purpose of compensatory education is to replace lost educational services.” Moubry v. Independent School District Number 696, 951 F.Supp. 867 (D.Minn. 1996). Compensatory education may be an appropriate equitable remedy when the responsible educational authority has failed to provide a disabled child with an appropriate education as required by the IDEA. Todd v. Andrews, 933 F.2d 1576 (11th Cir. 1991).
With regard to Petitioner’s request for compensatory education services, it was found above that the District appropriately assessed STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE. Therefore, STUDENT is not entitled to compensatory education services.
ORDER
All of the Petitioner’s claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with the statute:
The District prevailed on all issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Date: August 9, 2004 _________________________________________ Christian M. Knox, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The hearing was scheduled to commence on May 18, 2004. However, on that date, before any testimony was presented, the parties requested the matter be continued due to the late report of Dr. Davidson. The Hearing Officer granted the request for a continuance and the matter reconvened on June 14, 2004.
2. The District indicated that Mr. Smith would not be questioning any witnesses, making objections, or participating in oral or closing statements.
3. In an abundance of caution, the Hearing Officer offered to briefly continue this matter to allow Petitioner additional time to prepare. Petitioner did not want to continue the hearing.
4. On the first day of hearing Petitioner withdrew all issues concerning the 2004 extended school year.
5. At the time of the IEP meeting Ms. Fant was not married and her name was Jennifer Greenfield. The signature of the RCOC representative and the regular education teacher are illegible on the IEP and there was no testimony concerning the identity of these individuals.
6. A reverse mainstreaming program is one in which general education students are brought into a special education setting to interact with special education students for a portion of the day.
7. An IEP meeting was held in June 2004 for the purpose of determining the appropriate placement and services for STUDENT for the 2004 extended school year. The parents did not attend that IEP meeting.
8. It is interesting to note that Dr. Davidson’s report is silent concerning the Oak Grove placement despite visiting the classroom on two occasions.
9. Notwithstanding, Ms. Gutierrez testified that reverse mainstreaming was occurring in her classroom at the time Dr. Davidson made her observations. A typically developing peer attends Ms. Gutierrez’s class three days a week for the entire day.
10. Ms. Shapland was unaware that the Sensory Profile for Infant/Toddlers was published prior to her evaluation of STUDENT.
11. Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a student from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in regular education classes cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. In this case, LRE was not raised as an issue and, therefore, it will not be addressed.
12. As of March 16, 2004, STUDENT was able to count to five by repeating after the tutor. STUDENT is currently working on counting in the method identified in the November 18, 2003 goals and objectives.
13. Mr. Ochoa testified that he remembered asking the IEPT to change some of the goals and objectives and informing the IEPT that they did not see eye to eye on the assessment of STUDENT. However, Ms. Fant listened to the audio tape of the IEP prior to testifying and stated that Mr. Ochoa did not voice any concerns or objections to the assessments or the goals and objectives. FATHER listened to the audio tape four times prior to testifying and did not disagree with Ms. Fant’s testimony concerning Mr. Ochoa.
14. Ms. Brown is not currently using PECS with STUDENT. However, Ms. Brown testified that STUDENT has been introduced to PECS in IBI and Ms. Shapland testified that she uses PECS in OT.
15. Dr. Dores received his bachelor of arts degree from the University of California at Los Angeles (UCLA) in psychology in 1975. He obtained his master’s degree in psychology from the State University of New York at Stony Brook in 1977 and his doctorate in 1984. Dr. Dores became licensed to practice psychology in New York in 1985 and in California in 1990. Dr. Dores was trained by Dr. Lovaas and worked on the original autism program at UCLA supervised by Edward Karr. Dr. Dores worked at the Suffolk Child Development Center and was the first clinic director of the New England Center for Children. Dr. Dores has worked with populations from infancy to adulthood in homes, schools, residential programs, and institutions since 1972. Autism has been one of his primary areas of focus since age seventeen. Dr. Dores was involved in the original use of the autism project during which the systematic application of DTT was first demonstrated empirically. Dr. Dores has trained staff, helped to create home-based and school-based programs, and has taught courses in autism and the application of behavioral programs.
