California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 21, 2003
Student v. Burlingame School District et al.
SEHO Case No. SN 2579-02 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote
Burlingame School District and San Mateo County Office of Education owe make-up therapy; Parkside class offer upheld.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
Stay-put orders were issued on December 3, 2002, and February 21, 2003. The decision does not report any later history.
Summary
The parents of a 12-year-old girl with severe multiple disabilities, including cerebral palsy, a visual impairment and a seizure disorder, filed against the Burlingame School District and the San Mateo County Office of Education. They challenged her education from November 1999 through 2002-2003 and opposed the offered county special day class (SDC) at Parkside Middle School. The Hearing Officer found that she benefited in Holly Parry's county class in 1999-2000 and 2000-2001, given the severity of her needs. However, the agencies did not deliver all occupational therapy (OT) and physical therapy (PT) in her IEPs. They could not shift that duty to California Children's Services, and the 2000-2001 gaps denied a FAPE. In fall 2001, missing equipment, unsafe supervision and bus transfers, and missed services caused regression in Brenda Galicia's class. Services at Lincoln Elementary in 2002 were also inconsistent, so 2001-2002 was a denial of FAPE. For 2002-2003, the Parkside class was an appropriate offer. Letters sent before school began named the class, which cured a vague written offer. But the agencies failed to provide aide, OT and speech-language services the parents had agreed to, and teacher hours owed under stay put. The Hearing Officer ordered an IEP meeting within 15 days to plan her move to Parkside. The meeting must also schedule compensatory OT, PT and speech-language therapy, starting by June 9, 2003, and finished within one year.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO held school agencies responsible for IEP therapy that California Children's Services failed to deliver. It also shows how SEHO treated a vague written placement offer as cured by later letters naming the class. And it found that repeated missed services and equipment can add up to a denial of FAPE.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Did Respondents provide Petitioner a FAPE from November 18, 1999, through the end of the 1999-2000 school year including the ESY?
The teacher and aide were qualified, the class was safe enough, and she made progress, so the agencies largely prevailed. However, they were responsible for 34 OT sessions that California Children's Services did not provide. The Hearing Officer said the OT shortfall did not deny FAPE, but the prevailing-party section excepted OT.
- Student prevailed in partImplementation
Issue 2. Did Respondents provide Petitioner a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year including the ESY?
Staff training, safety, goal implementation and educational benefit were adequate. However, OT was missed from August to October 16, 2000, and about 74 PT sessions were missed. The agencies remained responsible despite California Children's Services' role, and these gaps denied a FAPE as to OT and PT.
- Student prevailedImplementation
Issue 3. Did Respondents provide Petitioner a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year including the ESY?
In Ms. Galicia's class, missing equipment, unsafe supervision and bus transfers, and missed OT and PT caused regression. At Lincoln, OT, PT and speech-language services were not delivered consistently, and she made no meaningful progress. FAPE was denied for 2001-2002.
- Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE
Issue 4. Did Respondents offer Petitioner a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year including the ESY?
The IEP team was properly composed, and the vague offer of a 'County SDC/SMH' was cured by letters naming the Parkside class. The Parkside SDC was an appropriate offer. However, the agencies failed to provide consented-to aide, OT and speech-language/AAC services, and the stay-put teacher hours for 41 school days.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 5. If Respondents did not offer Petitioner a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, should they be required to create a placement on an elementary school campus that includes (a) a full-time teacher; (b) a full-time, trained aide; (c) a classroom with four similar or higher functioning peers; and (d) at least monthly collaboration between the teacher, aide, and all service providers?
Not addressed because the 2002-2003 offer was found to be a FAPE; the prevailing-party section states Respondents prevailed.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 6. If Respondents denied Petitioner a FAPE, is she entitled to compensatory educational services?
She is entitled to compensatory OT, PT and speech-language therapy for services not already made up, delivered within one year. A request for an outside monitor was denied with all other relief.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, convene an IEP meeting to (a) develop a plan to transition the student to the Parkside SDC/SMH and (b) set a schedule so that all compensatory services are delivered within one year of the decision.
- Compensatory education. Compensatory OT, PT and speech-language therapy (LAS) for services not provided and not already made up. Services begin no later than June 9, 2003, and run over ESY 2003 and the 2003-2004 school year including ESY. The decision notes she can benefit from three sessions weekly of OT, PT and LAS. No total hours were ordered.
- Placement ordered. As soon as practicable after the transition plan is implemented, transition the student to the SDC/SMH class at Parkside Middle School.
Key authorities
Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist.; W.G. v. Target Range; Amanda J. v. Clark County; Ms. B. v. Milford Bd. of Educ.; Burlington; Student W. v. Puyallup; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. Missouri; Gov. Code § 7570 et seq.; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(12)(B)(ii); Ed. Code § 56346(a); 5 CCR § 3042(a)
People named in the decision
- Janice Robbins, Director of special education and categorical programs, Burlingame School District
- Caitie O'Shea, Educational services manager, San Mateo County Office of Education
- Joan Thomas, Senior administrator for special education, San Mateo County Office of Education
- Prancess Tucker-Jones, Assistant education services manager for secondary services, San Mateo County Office of Education
- Jeffie Gellerman, Advocate for Student
- Ardath McDermott, Current occupational therapist
- Maureen Murphy, Physical therapist (Nov. 2001-Nov. 2002), Community Gate Path
- Kathy Ash, Teacher at Lincoln (Jan.-Aug. 2002)
- Melisa Kaye, Private occupational therapist (Apr.-Nov. 2002)
- Tracy Berliner, Assistive technology/AAC specialist, Center for Accessible Technology
- Lauren Haggerty, Private physical therapist (since Nov. 2002)
- Anne LePage, Educational services manager, San Mateo County Office of Education
- Carol Barraco, Program manager, San Mateo County Office of Education
- Marty Jo Matetick, Special day class teacher, Parkside Middle School (offered placement), San Mateo County Office of Education
- Denise Sequeira, One-to-one aide, San Mateo County Office of Education
- Holly Parry, Special day class teacher, Audubon Elementary (Dec. 1999-2001), San Mateo County Office of Education
- Mitzi Soo, BTSA advisor; former special day class teacher (1997-1999), San Mateo County Office of Education
- Katheryn Burke, BTSA advisor, San Mateo County Office of Education
- Ruth Johns, Former one-to-one aide (1996-1999), San Mateo County Office of Education
- Katie Krabbenschmidt, Language and speech/augmentative communication specialist, San Mateo County Office of Education
- Ilene Goldman, Teacher of the visually impaired/orientation and mobility specialist, San Mateo County Office of Education
- Marcella Murray, Speech and language pathologist, San Mateo County Office of Education
- JoAnne V. Becker, Registered nurse, San Mateo County Office of Education
- Brenda Galicia, Special day class teacher, Audubon Elementary (fall 2001), San Mateo County Office of Education
- Robin Joe, Special day class teacher, Nesbit Elementary (fall 1999), San Mateo County Office of Education
- Barbara Nelson, Former special day class teacher (1996-1997), San Mateo County Office of Education
- Laurie Field, Substitute teacher during Ms. Parry's maternity leave
- Vicky Palmer, BTSA advisor to Ms. Parry
- Christina Gleason, One-to-one aide in Ms. Galicia's class
- Ms. Tobar, Former one-to-one aide
- Stacey Leong, Occupational therapist at Lincoln (through Feb. 2002)
- Donna Wright, Teacher hired by District in Feb. 2003, Burlingame School District
- Jennifer McClean, Occupational therapist available to Parkside class, California Children's Services
- Nicky Alsberry, Physical therapist available to Parkside class, California Children's Services
- Robert Ridgeway, Vision specialist, San Mateo County Office of Education
- Therapy Link, Private OT provider (Oct. 2000-June 2001)
- Step-By-Step, Private conductive education program in which parents enrolled student in Aug. 2002
- Bridge School, Nonpublic school that declined to accept student
- California Diagnostic Center of Northern California, Field-based assessment (Jan. 2000)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Burlingame and Redwood City, California, on February 25-28, March 4-7 and 19-21, 2003.(Footnote 1)
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Roberta S. Savage from the law firm of Varma & Clancy. STUDENT’s mother, was present during the course of the hearing. STUDENT’s father, was present on the afternoon of March 7, 2003. On February 25 and March 6, 2003, advocate Jeffie Gellerman also was present on behalf of Petitioner. Respondents Burlingame School District and San Mateo County Office of Education were represented at the hearing by attorney John D. Nibbelin, deputy county counsel, from the Office of San Mateo County Counsel. Present on behalf of Respondent Burlingame School District was Janice Robbins, District director of special education and categorical programs. Caitie O’Shea, educational services manager, was present on most days on behalf of the Respondent San Mateo County Office of Education (COE). On several days, Joan Thomas, senior administrator for special education, or Prancess Tucker-Jones, assistant education services manager for secondary services, was present in Ms. O’Shea’s absence.
The following witnesses testified at the hearing: MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother; FATHER, STUDENT’s father; Jeffie Gellerman, advocate; Ardath McDermott, STUDENT’s current occupational therapist; Maureen Murphy, physical therapist with Community Gate Path, STUDENT’s physical therapist from November 2001 to November 2002; Kathy Ash, STUDENT’s teacher from January to August 2002; Melisa Kaye, occupational therapist in private practice, STUDENT’s therapist from April to November 2002; Tracy Berliner, educational specialist with the Center for Accessible Technology, STUDENT’s augmentative assistive technology specialist from April 2002 to the present; and Lauren Haggerty, physical therapist in private practice, STUDENT’s physical therapist since November 2002. The following witnesses are employees of the Burlingame School District: Janice Robbins, director of special education and categorical programs; The following witnesses are employees of the San Mateo County Office of Education: Caitie O’Shea, educational services manager; Anne LePage, educational services manager; Carol Barraco, program manager; Marty Jo Matetick, special day class teacher, Parkside Middle School; Denise Sequeira, STUDENT’s one-to-one aide; Holly Parry, STUDENT’s special day class teacher from December 1999 through the end of the 2000-2001 school year; Mitzi Soo, Beginning Teacher Support and Assessment (BTSA) advisor, STUDENT’s teacher during the 1997-1998 and 1998-1999 school years; Katheryn Burke, BTSA advisor; Ruth Johns, STUDENT’s aide during the 1997-1998 and 1998-1999 school years; Katie Krabbenschmidt, language and speech/augmentative communication specialist; Ilene Goldman, teacher of the visually impaired/orientation and mobility specialist; Marcella Murray, speech and language pathologist; and JoAnne V. Becker, registered nurse.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES(Footnote 2)
(1) Did Respondents provide Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from November 18, 1999, through the end of the 1999-2000 school year including the extended school year (ESY)?(Footnote 3)
(2) Did Respondents provide Petitioner a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year including the ESY?
(3) Did Respondents provide Petitioner a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year including the ESY?
(4) Did Respondents offer Petitioner a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year including the ESY?
(5) If Respondents did not offer Petitioner a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, should they be required to create a placement that includes the following: (a) a full-time teacher;
(b) a full-time, trained aide;
(c) a classroom with four similar or higher functioning peers; and (d) at least monthly collaboration between the teacher, aide, and all service providers?
(6) If Respondents denied Petitioner a FAPE for all years at issue, is she entitled to compensatory educational services?
BACKGROUND FACTS
Petitioner STUDENT is a twelve-year-old student who resides with her family within the jurisdictional boundaries of the Burlingame School District. STUDENT is eligible for special education because of severe multiple disabilities, including cerebral palsy and significant delays in all areas of development.(Footnote 4) STUDENT also has a cortical visual impairment and a seizure disorder. Since January 2002, STUDENT has participated in an individualized program at Lincoln Elementary School within the Burlingame School District. She receives all of her services at Lincoln, including two hours daily of instruction from a teacher, a full-time one-to-one aide, language and speech (LAS) therapy, occupational therapy (OT), physical therapy (PT), services for the visually impaired (VI), assistive technology (AT) services, and augmentative alternative communication (AAC) services. STUDENT is not placed in a class and has no peers in her program. STUDENT is entitled to receive educational services 46 weeks each year.(Footnote 5) STUDENT had attended special day classes (SDCs) operated by the San Mateo County Office of Education (County or COE) and received multiple services from the County from 1993 until her parents removed her in November 2001 from Brenda Galicia’s class at Audubon Elementary School. Audubon is located in Foster City.
During the 1996-1997 school year, STUDENT attended a County SDC taught by Barbara Nelson. Ruth Johns served as STUDENT’s one-to-one aide. During the 1997-1998 and 1998-1999 school years, STUDENT was in a County SDC taught by Mitzi Soo, with Ms. Johns continuing as STUDENT’s aide. The PARENTS were pleased with STUDENT’s progress while she was in Ms. Nelson’s and Ms. Soo’s classes. With Ms. Johns in close proximity, STUDENT independently took steps to cross the classroom, operated two cause and effect Big Mac switches to communicate, and used a cup and spoon during snack.
In the fall of 1999, STUDENT entered a County SDC for orthopedically disabled students taught by Robin Joe. The class was located at Nesbit Elementary School in Belmont. STUDENT’s parents had multiple concerns about the placement related to transportation and the number of different aides assigned to STUDENT.(Footnote 6) On November 30, 1999, at the parents’ request, STUDENT was transferred to Holly Parry’s SDC at Audubon Elementary School in Foster City. STUDENT continued in Ms. Parry’s class for the remainder of the school year and for the entire 2000-2001 school year. STUDENT entered Ms. Galicia’s SDC at Audubon in the fall of 2001. Because of concerns that included STUDENT’s safety, STUDENT’s parents removed her from Ms. Galicia’s class and requested that the District provide her with a placement and services.
Because STUDENT’s parents did not want STUDENT to return to a County program, the District developed and implemented a program at Lincoln until such time that an appropriate class could be identified. With the support of Respondents, STUDENT’s parents applied for STUDENT to attend the Bridge School, which is a certified nonpublic school serving students with orthopedic and communication disabilities requiring assistive technology and augmentative communication systems. The Bridge School did not accept STUDENT. She remained at Lincoln through the ESY with Kathy Ash as her teacher and Denise Sequeira as her aide. In August 2002, STUDENT’s parents enrolled her in Step-By-Step, a private conductive education program for students with cerebral palsy.
For the 2002-2003 school year, Respondents offered to place STUDENT in a newly formed County SDC at Parkside Middle School in the San Bruno Park School District. The class is taught by Mary Jo Matetick. STUDENT’s parents consented to all of the services offered by Respondents. However, they have not consented to STUDENT’s placement in the SDC. In the fall of 2002, STUDENT continued to receive the services called for by her IEP at Lincoln.(Footnote 7) However, she did not have a teacher until the District hired Donna Wright in February 2003. Ms. Sequeira has continued as STUDENT’s aide, except from August through November 2002.
STUDENT’s parents requested a due process hearing in November 2002 regarding STUDENT’s placement for the 2002-2003 school year. STUDENT’s parents request that Respondents create a class for STUDENT at her local elementary school that includes, among other things, a maximum of four peers whose functional skills are near or above STUDENT’s present level of functioning. STUDENT’s parents assert that an appropriate class should focus on communication with students using communication devices. They also assert that STUDENT’s program should be coordinated and monitored by an outside individual hired by the District. For reasons set forth with more specificity below, Petitioner additionally contends that she is entitled to compensatory education because Respondents have failed to provide her with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) and all of the services to which she has been entitled during the current school year as well as the prior three school years.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Did Respondents provide Petitioner STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from November 18, 1999, through the end of the 1999-2000 school year including the extended school year (ESY)?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP).(Footnote 8) 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that to receive a FAPE, the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be designed to meet the unique needs of the student and reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the school district is not required to provide the child with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court held that a school district is required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201. Consequently, an appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education must be provided for the student. Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996); Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1994, 1524 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied 513 U.S. 965 (1994). However, de minimis benefit or only trivial advancement is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist., 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2nd Cir. 1997).
The Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural protections afforded by the IDEA, which are designed to ensure effective parental participation in the IEP process and careful consideration of a student’s educational needs. One of the rights afforded to parents is the right to be provided a formal written offer of placement by the school district. Union v. Smith, 157 F.3d. 1519 (9th Cir. 1994); cert.denied 115 S. Ct. 428 (1994). The Court in Union noted that one of the reasons for a formal written offer is to provide parents the opportunity to decide whether the offer of placement is appropriate and whether or not to accept the offer.
Not every procedural flaw constitutes a denial of a FAPE. Procedural flaws must result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s participation in the IEP process to constitute a denial of a FAPE. Rowley, 458 U.S., at 206-207; See also W.G. v. B.D. of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F. 2d 1479, 1483-1484; Amanda J. v. Clark County School District (9th Cir. 2001) 267 F.3d 877.
In summary, to determine whether the District offered the student a FAPE, the Hearing Officer must analyze (a) whether the District complied with the procedural requirements of the IDEA and (b) whether the IEP and resulting placement were designed to meet the student's unique needs, reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, and conform with the IEP according to the standards set forth in the IDEA and Rowley.
STUDENT was in Holly Parry’s SDC at Audubon Elementary School during the 1999-2000 school year and received multiple services including language and speech therapy (LAS), occupational therapy (OT), physical therapy (PT), and services for the visually impaired (VI). Petitioner’s parents consented to the IEP. However, Petitioner now contends that Respondents failed both procedurally and substantively to provide her with a FAPE while in Ms. Parry’s class during the 1999-2000 school year.
Petitioner states in her Closing Brief that she “does not contest that her IEP was designed to meet her unique educational needs.” (Petitioner’s Closing Brief, page 9.) However, she raises procedural deficiencies that appear to the Hearing Officer to relate to whether the placement was designed to meet her unique and individual needs and are addressed below in the section related to unique needs. Petitioner also asserts that her skills regressed and that she failed to benefit educationally during the 1999-2000 school year. Finally, Petitioner asserts that Respondents failed to provide her a program and services that conformed to her IEP in that they did not implement and/or adequately monitor goals and objectives, provide her with required equipment, or provide OT at the frequency called for by the IEP.
Respondents contend that they provided Petitioner with a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year. Respondents assert that Petitioner’s parents and service providers participated in developing her IEP, which was designed to meet her needs and provide her with educational benefit. Respondents assert that, in fact, Petitioner made progress during the 1999-2000 school year. As to whether Respondents provided Petitioner with a program and services that conformed to her IEP, Respondents assert that Petitioner required medically necessary OT services rather than educationally related OT. Thus, California Children’s Services (CCS), rather than Respondents, was responsible for providing the medically necessary OT.
Was Respondents’ offer designed to meet Petitioner’s unique and individual needs?
Prior to determining whether Respondents offered Petitioner a FAPE from November 18, 1999, to the end of the 1999-2000 school year, it is necessary to identify Petitioner’s unique and individual needs as they existed in the fall of 1999. There is no dispute that STUDENT is significantly delayed in all areas of development, has a seizure disorder, and is visually impaired. Much of the testimony from STUDENT’s teachers, parent, and multiple service providers familiar with STUDENT before or during the 1999-2000 school year focused on STUDENT’s motor and communication deficits and the needs arising from those deficits.(Footnote 9)
As to gross motor deficits, the undisputed testimony establishes that STUDENT had poor balance, strength, flexibility, and endurance skills. She was learning to take steps independently but required support from adults at all times while walking. To address motor deficits, witnesses testified that STUDENT needed to receive instruction and engage in exercises, which also required that appropriate equipment, including a large therapy ball, tricycle, trampoline, adapted chair and bench, and mats, be available in her classroom. STUDENT also required assistance with fine-motor skills. Sensory, vestibular, and tactile activities were recommended to help her be ready to attend to outside stimuli, to develop strength in her hands and fingers, and to relax her muscles. (See Petitioner’s Exhibits pages 102 and 176.) STUDENT’s communication skills were extremely limited and, according to Ms. Krabbenschmidt’s assessment report in April 2000, if left alone, STUDENT would “just sit and not initiate interactions to get needs met.” (See Petitioner’s Exhibits page 181.) Ms. Krabbenschmidt stated that STUDENT needed to learn to call out to get attention and to indicate when she wanted a drink or something to eat. MOTHER also testified that the most important communication skill STUDENT needed to develop was a means to express her wants and needs. To this end, the witnesses concluded that STUDENT needed to learn to use assistive technology and augmentative alternative communication, including manipulation of switches to express “yes” and “no” and to make other choices, and intellikeys and a touch screen computer to activate activities.
The testimony establishes that STUDENT also required adaptations to her school environment to ensure her safety because of seizures, visual impairment, and poor motor skills. STUDENT’s seizures occurred without warning and she potentially could injure herself. Following the seizure, STUDENT needed a period to rest and regain her strength. The recovery period varied by the length and intensity of the seizure. STUDENT required an environment that had sufficient space to maintain her equipment and that was not overly crowded or that contained obstacles that could interfere with her mobility.
STUDENT’s self-help skills were minimal. She was able to hold a spoon and bring it to her mouth. She also could bring a carton of milk to her mouth. STUDENT was not able dress or undress. She was diapered and had no independent toileting skills. Thus, STUDENT required a program that would include activities designed to help her develop self-help skills, particularly in the areas of self-feeding and toileting.
Many witnesses described STUDENT as lacking motivation. They stated that she needed a sensory program to increase her level of awareness. The teachers and Ms. Johns testified that STUDENT required repetition, consistency, encouragement and follow-up by staff to keep her mind and body involved. Because of the intensity of STUDENT’s deficits described above, all of the witnesses testified that STUDENT required extensive assistance to participate in tasks and concluded that she requires one-to-one assistance at all times. However, MOTHER and Ms. Johns emphasized the importance of balancing STUDENT’s need for support from adults so that she would be safe but would not become overly dependent on the adults.
In January 2000, a field-based assessment was undertaken by the California Diagnostic Center of Northern California. The report of the assessment expresses what is the general consensus of the witnesses regarding the appropriate focus of STUDENT’s program, which is on development of functional communication and skills that will allow her to be as independent as she possibly can. The IEP team and the above assessment concluded that STUDENT required close communication between the numerous professionals and the parents involved in STUDENT’s education.
Only the specific allegations raised by Petitioner as to whether the placement was designed to meet her unique and individual needs are discussed below. Specifically, Petitioner asserts that Respondents failed to (a) appropriately train her teacher and aide, (b) provide appropriate transportation, (c) maintain a safe environment, (d) assess and address her needs for assistive technology and augmentative communication services, and (e) implement recommendations from the Diagnostic Center.
(a) Were Petitioner’s teacher and aide properly qualified and trained to meet her needs?
Turning first to the qualifications and training of Holly Parry, Petitioner’s teacher beginning in December 1999, Petitioner asserts that Ms. Parry was not properly qualified or trained. Petitioner asserts that Ms. Parry either did not hold any teaching credential or held an emergency credential during the period she was Petitioner’s teacher, which adversely affected Ms. Parry’s ability to meet Petitioner’s needs as a student with multiple disabilities.
Respondents assert that Ms. Parry met State credentialing standards, had experience implementing goals and objectives similar to the goals and objectives contained in Petitioner’s IEP, and received support from a Beginning Teacher Training and Assessment (BTSA) advisor and other sources, including Petitioner’s prior teachers and service providers.
In support of her position, Petitioner submitted a printout from the website for the California Commission on Teacher Credentialing. (Petitioner’s Exhibits page 715.) The printout states that Ms. Parry presently holds an Emergency Education Specialist Instruction Permit authorizing her to provide instruction and related services to individuals with primary disability designations that include moderate/severe mental retardation and multiple disabilities in grades 1 through 12. The printout also states that the permit is Ms. Parry’s third and will expire on May 1, 2003. Finally, it is noted that permits may be reissued to Ms. Parry for a maximum of two additional one-year periods, provided Ms. Parry completes at least six semester units of approved course work in a Commission-accredited professional preparation program. Petitioner alleges that information contained in the website document establishes that because Ms. Parry’s current credential was issued in the month of May, she could not have had her first emergency teaching credential until May 2000, six months after STUDENT entered her program.
Ms. Parry testified that she entered the graduate credential program at San Francisco State University (SFSU) in 1998 and will complete the program in June 2003. Ms. Parry testified that in 1999, she held an emergency special education credential authorizing her to teach students with moderate to severe disabilities. Ms. O’Shea supported Ms. Parry’s testimony as to Ms. Parry’s holding a credential authorizing her to teach the SDC at the time in which Petitioner was placed in her class.
The Hearing Officer concludes that the printout from the Commission on Teacher Credentialing is not definitive as to Ms. Parry’s credential in December 1999. For example, she may have been authorized in December 1999 to teach the SDC under a substitute teacher, intern, or pre-intern credential. There also was no testimony regarding the status of credential requirements in December 1999 and whether they may be different from the requirements set forth in the recent printout. Other than the one hearsay document submitted by Petitioner, she has provided no persuasive evidence as to Ms. Parry’s lack of an appropriate credential from December 1999 to May 1999.
As to Ms. Parry’s training, MOTHER testified that Ms. Parry lacked sufficient training to understand how to meet STUDENT’s needs, such as properly supporting STUDENT walking, knowing where to place her hands when moving STUDENT, or using appropriate techniques to help STUDENT while riding her tricycle.
Ms. Parry testified that she had four years’ experience as an instructional assistant and substitute teacher in special education classes and, in those positions, had become familiar with and implemented goals and objectives for students with disabilities similar to Petitioner’s disabilities. Additionally, Ms. Parry specifically familiarized herself with STUDENT and her educational needs. She had previously observed STUDENT in Miss Soo’s class and consulted with Ms. Soo and STUDENT’s service providers several times following STUDENT’s placement in her class. Additionally, Ms. Parry received support as a new teacher from Vicky Palmer, an advisor for the Beginning Teacher Support and Assessment (BTSA) program, in the form of consultation and in-service training. Ms. Parry’s testimony was supported by the testimony of Ms. Soo and Ms. O’Shea. The Hearing Officer concludes that their testimony establishes that Ms. Parry was sufficiently trained to implement Petitioner’s goals and objectives and to meet her needs.
As to the aide’s training, MOTHER testified that, in her opinion, Ms. Parry as a first-year teacher lacked sufficient knowledge to properly train STUDENT’s one-to-one aide. Although Ms. Parry trained, the evidence establishes that the aide also received training from at least some of STUDENT’s service providers including VI and PT providers. MOTHER was not in Ms. Parry’s class on a daily basis. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that Ms. Parry was in a better position to possess knowledge of the aide’s training than MOTHER.
In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that Ms. Parry and the aide were sufficiently qualified and trained to address STUDENT’s unique and individual needs. (b) Did Respondents provide Petitioner appropriate transportation services?
Petitioner asserts that problems with her transportation resulted in her frequently arriving up to one hour late to school. Respondents assert that transportation problems were adequately addressed during the period Petitioner was in Ms. Parry’s class.
MOTHER testified that STUDENT frequently missed the first hour of school during the 1999-2000 school year. However, on cross-examination, MOTHER acknowledged that transportation problems primarily occurred while Petitioner was attending Ms. Joe’s class at Nesbit. Ms. Gellerman, who has advocated on STUDENT’s behalf for several years, recalled that transportation problems had not been resolved when STUDENT moved to Ms. Parry’s class but did not provide any further details regarding the nature of the transportation problems. Ms. Parry testified that she was aware that transportation had been a problem in the past so she tracked the time of STUDENT’s arrival at school. She was unable to recall any particular problems with STUDENT’s arriving late and testified that STUDENT was on time to school almost every day.
None of Petitioner’s witnesses provided persuasive testimony regarding the amount of class that STUDENT missed because she allegedly arrived late to Ms. Parry’s class or the impact of the late arrivals on STUDENT’s education. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Parry, who was the teacher of the class, testified persuasively as to STUDENT’s timely arrival to class. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that any transportation problems that may have persisted after STUDENT’s transfer to Ms. Parry’s class did not rise to the level of denying STUDENT a FAPE.
(c) Did Respondents fail to meet Petitioner’s need for a safe environment?
Petitioner asserts that Ms. Parry’s class did not provide her with a safe environment. In support of her contention, MOTHER testified that STUDENT received scrapes, bruises, and scratches at school, which she did not receive at home. The District’s position is that Ms. Parry’s class did offer Petitioner a sufficiently safe environment and the number of small injuries she may have received were not unusual, given her age and disabilities.
There is no evidence of serious injuries to STUDENT or a pattern of action or inaction by staff that resulted in injury to STUDENT during the 1999-2000 school year. The Hearing Officer finds that the minor scrapes, bruises, or scratches STUDENT may have received while at school do not support a finding that the Respondents failed to meet STUDENT’s need for a safe environment.
(d) Did Respondents assess and address her needs for assistive technology and augmentative communication services?
Petitioner asserts that she required assistive technology (AT) and augmentative communication (AAC) services to facilitate communication. Petitioner further asserts that Respondents failed to undertake an assessment of her augmentative communication needs until April 2000, which was approximately five months after her parents had requested the assessment. The District offered no explanation for this delay. The evidence substantiates that the results of the AT assessment were first discussed at an IEP meeting in April 2000. An IEP meeting must be convened 50 days, not counting vacation, from the date of receipt of the parent’s written consent for an assessment, unless the parent agrees in writing to an extension. Cal. Educ. Code § 56344. However, absent information regarding when an assessment plan was developed and signed by the parents giving consent for the assessment, it is impossible to determine whether the assessment was undertaken within the required timelines.
(e) Did Respondents fail to implement recommendations from the Diagnostic Center’s assessment report?
Petitioner asserts that the Respondents failed to consider the results of the Diagnostic Center’s assessment report until May 2000 although it was completed in January 2000. Petitioner further asserts that even after the IEP team reviewed the assessment report, the teacher failed to implement suggestions from the report. Respondents offered no explanation as to the delay of the IEP team in reviewing the assessment report, which was completed on January 26, 2000. (Petitioner’s Exhibits pages 488-495.) However, Petitioner provided no legal authority requiring the IEP team to adopt or the teacher to implement the recommendations from the Diagnostic Center’s assessment. Therefore, Petitioner’s assertion that an alleged delay and/or failure to implement the Diagnostic Center’s recommendations resulted in a denial of FAPE fails.
Was Respondents’ offer reasonably calculated to provide Petitioner with educational benefit?
To be appropriate under the IDEA, Respondents’ proposed placement must have been reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. Rowley 458 U.S. at 200. While requiring Respondents to provide STUDENT with meaningful access to education, Rowley does not require the responsible educational agency to guarantee totally successful results. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998).
Petitioner contends that she failed to gain meaningful benefit from her education during the 1999-2000 school year. Petitioner asserts that each review by the IEP team indicated that she was not making progress toward meeting goals and objectives and, in fact, was regressing in the area of self-help. MOTHER testified that from her observation of STUDENT at home and at school, she believes that STUDENT did not make progress. Additionally, MOTHER testified that the goals and objectives were not designed to teach STUDENT new skills but were a review of skills she had developed while in Ms. Soo’s class. For example, MOTHER testified that despite STUDENT’s using two switches at snack time, pedaling the tricycle, using the restroom, self-feeding, and walking independently during the prior school year, her goals and objectives for the 1999-2000 school year addressed similar skills.
Respondents assert that they provided Petitioner with a placement that was reasonably calculated to provide her with benefit and from which she did benefit. Specifically, Respondents assert that the multiple services provided to Petitioner addressed her communication, self-help, vision, mobility, gross- and fine-motor, socialization, and pre-academic needs. Respondents further assert that Petitioner made progress in the areas of gross-motor, self-help, fine-motor, toileting, and visual functioning.
Ms. Parry testified that Petitioner’s Exhibits pages 92-93 accurately describe Petitioner’s skills when she entered her class in December 1999. As to gross-motor skills, STUDENT was walking around the playground taking 50-60 steps independently while closely monitored. In the class, she could walk across the room independently with shadowing but would not always put her hands in front of her when encountering furniture. She was working on transitioning from a chair to a standing position and from standing to sitting. STUDENT’s fine-motor skills allowed her to sometimes pick up small objects. She could use a big red switch to activate the computer and to request something to eat or drink. Regarding self-help skills, STUDENT was using an adapted spoon and bowl with a lip and would bring the spoon to her mouth. She needed assistance scooping. She wore diapers but would use the toilet if caught in time. She would assist taking off and sometimes putting on her jacket and harness.
STUDENT was using Big Mac switches with photos velcroed to the top to request something to eat or drink. She inconsistently clapped if she wanted more of something or signed “finished” when she wanted to stop an activity.
Ms. Parry testified that STUDENT made progress while in her class during the 1999-2000 school year in regard to walking independently, scooping food, and toileting. Ms. Parry testified that STUDENT had increased the number of steps she was taking and the amount of time she was able to stand. She also was beginning to lift her leg to ascend the stairs. Ms. Parry’s testimony that STUDENT made progress is supported by comparing STUDENT’s performance levels and progress on goals and objectives as recorded on her IEP in September 1999 with similar information in subsequent IEPs. (See Petitioner’s Exhibits pages 123-124, 144- 149 and 174 - 175.) In determining STUDENT’s then present levels of performance at her annual IEP meeting in April 2000, the IEP team determined that STUDENT was walking 80 to 100 steps on the playground and in the multipurpose room. This was an increase in the number of steps she was able to take since entering Ms. Parry’s class. In December 1999, STUDENT would not put her hands in front of her as she walked, whereas in April 2000, she would grab onto sturdy objects she encountered while walking. She also had progressed on an objective requiring her to stand up from a chair and follow the direction of “give me your hand.” In September, STUDENT was able to complete the task one out of five times and, in March, three out of five times. STUDENT also partially met two other objectives related to standing and riding her tricycle. The IEP also indicated that STUDENT had improved her familiarity with stairs and was lifting her legs more frequently to step up the stairs. STUDENT also partially met two of three fine-motor objectives and three of three self-help objectives. The testimony of Ms. Soo and Ms. Parry, as well as Petitioner’s Exhibits page 124, establishes that STUDENT was feeding herself more independently during the 1999-2000 school than she had the prior school year. STUDENT also achieved a toileting objective of voiding in the toilet when given two of three opportunities daily.
STUDENT’s April 2000 IEP reflects partial achievement in one out of six communication objectives. Ms. Krabbenschmidt, who had assessed STUDENT in 1997 and again in April 2000, provided additional information regarding STUDENT’s communication skills. According to Ms. Krabbenschmidt, STUDENT demonstrated similar skills on both assessments. Ms. Krabbenschmidt described STUDENT’s communication as typical of a three- to six-month old child in both 1997 and 2000. Ms. Krabbenschmidt stated that at the time of her reassessment, STUDENT was using only one Big Mac switch, whereas in 1997, she was using two. Ms. Krabbenschmidt stated that she did not know why STUDENT was using only one Big Mac in 2000. Thus, it is unclear whether STUDENT’s skills had decreased using the Big Mac or whether she was not given an opportunity to manipulate two switches at the time of the assessment. Ms. Parry offered an explanation as to why STUDENT was not showing progress in communication skills. Ms. Parry testified that the VI specialist was using photos on the switches and other communication devices. In Ms. Parry’s opinion, using pictures was not appropriate because of STUDENT’s visual impairment.
A student’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. Ms. B. v. Milford Bd. of Educ., 103 F.2d 1114, 1121 (2nd Cir. 1997). The Hearing Officer concludes that taking into consideration the intensity of STUDENT’s needs and her multiple significant disabilities, the evidence establishes that STUDENT’s program was reasonably calculated to provide her with educational benefit and that she benefitted from her education during the relevant portions of the 1999-2000 school year. While communication skills changed little, if any, STUDENT did show growth in motor and self-help skills, which were important steps toward STUDENT’s achieving independence to the extent possible.
Did Respondents provide Petitioner with a program and services that conformed to her IEP?
(a) Did Respondents provide Petitioner with the equipment necessary to implement her IEP?
STUDENT’s IEP called for her to have specialized equipment including a computer with a touch screen window program and intellikeys, cause and effect switches and toys, a walker, a specialized chair, an adjustable bench, and a tricycle. Petitioner asserts that not all of the equipment she required was available to her at school. Respondents assert that any equipment that may have been unavailable was unavailable for only a short period of time.
In support of Petitioner’s assertion, MOTHER testified that the computer was not working during some of her observations. Ms. Parry did not disagree that the class computer sometimes was not working. However, she testified that the extent of the computer’s unavailability was limited to a one- to two-week period. There is no persuasive evidence that the computer was unavailable to STUDENT for extended periods of time.
Ms. Soo testified that STUDENT’s tricycle was unavailable at the beginning of the school year. Her testimony is supported by the IEP, which states that as of December 1999, the tricycle was “on order.” (Petitioner’s Exhibits page 120.) Thus, it appears that the tricycle was not available to STUDENT for at least one month during the period at issue. Therefore, it is concluded that both the computer and the tricycle were not available to STUDENT for brief periods of time. There was no persuasive evidence that any other equipment required by Petitioner’s IEP was unavailable. As discussed below, in light of testimony that STUDENT could use other equipment to practice similar skills, it is concluded that Respondents sufficiently provided STUDENT with the equipment necessary to implement her IEP.
(b) Did Respondents implement Petitioner’s goals and objectives?
Petitioner asserts that not all of her IEP goals and objectives were implemented. For example, Petitioner asserts that she was unable to work on a goal related to riding a tricycle because Respondents failed to have a tricycle available for her. Petitioner also asserts that while the computer was unavailable for one- to two-week periods, she was unable to work on goals and objectives that required a working computer.
Respondents assert that if any equipment was unavailable, it was for a brief period of time and that during any period equipment was unavailable, STUDENT’s goals and objectives were addressed by other means.
STUDENT’s IEP includes a goal and objective related to riding a tricycle and other goals call for STUDENT to use a computer. It has been concluded above that for short periods of time, neither the tricycle nor computer were available to STUDENT. However, Ms. Parry testified persuasively that even when the computer or tricycle were unavailable, she still was able to implement communication, self-help, and motor goals and objectives. For example, Ms. Parry testified that she used a communication device during every morning circle time and used a cause and effect switch during feedings. She also used two switches during small-group activities. She incorporated a goal related to sitting during circle time. Ms. Parry testified that she generally took STUDENT to the toilet three times daily. There was no persuasive evidence to rebut Ms. Parry’s testimony that she implemented Petitioner’s goals and objectives. Ms. Parry was present in the class daily, whereas Petitioner’s witnesses were not. Moreover, a review of goals and objectives related to each of these activities shows that they were implemented during the overall course of the school year and that STUDENT demonstrated progress on each goal and objective. (See Petitioner’s Exhibits pages 212-214.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that overall, Ms. Parry implemented STUDENT’s goals and objectives.
(c) Did Respondents provide Petitioner with the OT called for by her IEP?
A review of pertinent IEPs establishes that STUDENT was entitled to twice weekly OT, which was to be provided by CCS. (Petitioner’s Exhibits pages 88 and 150.) Petitioner asserts that from December 20, 1999 through August 22, 2000, CCS provided her with only one hour weekly of OT, although the IEP called for two hours weekly. Petitioner asserts that Respondents were responsible for ensuring that she received the one-hour session of OT that CCS failed to provide. MOTHER testified that STUDENT received OT at the clinic setting but did not receive OT at the school site, resulting in a loss of 34 hours of OT to which she was entitled pursuant to her IEP. MOTHER further testified that part of the impact on STUDENT was that neither the aide nor teacher was shown how to feed STUDENT, implement the brushing program, or work on fine-motor goals and objectives.
Respondents assert that Petitioner required “medically necessary” OT, which was the responsibility of CCS to provide rather than the Respondents. In the alternative, Respondents agree that if they were responsible for providing the OT that CCS failed to provide, they would make up the sessions.
California has an interagency agreement allocating responsibility for mental health services to the Department of Mental Health, and medically necessary OT and PT to California Children’s Services (CCS). (See Chapter 26.5 Government Code § 7570 et. seq.) However, the interagency agreement does not relieve Respondents of responsibility for providing such services when determined necessary for the student and, as here, the agency has failed to provide the services. Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(a). The IDEA further provides that “if a public agency other than an educational agency fails to provide or pay for the special education and related services. . ., the local educational agency ...shall provide or pay for such services to the child. Such local educational agency or State agency may then claim reimbursement for the services from the public agency that failed to provide or pay for such services. . . .” 20 U.S.C. §1412(a)(12)(B)(ii). Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that Respondents were responsible for providing STUDENT with 34 sessions of OT that were called for by her IEP but not provided by CCS. However, it was concluded above that Petitioner showed progress in both fine- and gross-motor skills and benefitted from her education. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the failure to receive all of the OT to which Petitioner was entitled did not result in the denial of a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year.
ISSUE NO. 2: Did Respondents provide Petitioner a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year including the ESY?
During the 2000-2001 school year, Petitioner remained in Ms. Parry’s class at Audubon and received the same services as she received the prior school year. STUDENT’s needs remained substantially the same as the prior school year.
Petitioner raises several areas of concern regarding the substantive appropriateness of her placement for the 2000-2001 school year, including the training of her teacher and aide, the lack of a safe school environment, and the failure to provide OT and PT as called for by her IEP. Petitioner also asserts that she did not receive meaningful benefit from her education. Respondents contend that they provided STUDENT with a FAPE.
The discussion below is limited to the specific deficiencies Petitioner raised at the hearing that she contends led to the denial of FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year.
Was Respondents’ offer designed to meet Petitioner’s unique and individual needs?
(a) Were Petitioner’s teacher and aide properly qualified and trained?
Petitioner asserts that the same deficiencies related to Ms. Parry’s and the aide’s qualifications and training continued, leading to Ms. Parry’s failing to meet Petitioner’s needs. It was concluded in Issue No. 1 that Ms. Parry and the aide were adequately qualified and trained to meet Petitioner’s needs.
Petitioner additionally asserts that Laurie Field, who substituted for Ms. Parry while she was on maternity leave for three months, also did not hold an appropriate teaching credential. MOTHER testified that she contacted the California Teaching Commission and learned from the Commission that Ms. Field then held a substitute teaching credential which limited her to substituting for 20 cumulative days in one class.(Footnote 10) However, the school superintendent may approve an extension of 20 school days and, in extraordinary circumstances, may grant additional days. Cal. Educ. Code § 56061. Therefore, the fact that Ms. Field remained in Ms. Parry’s class longer than authorized by her substitute credential, does not automatically result in a finding that Respondents violated the education code or that Ms. Field was unable to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs. Several of Respondents’ witnesses testified that STUDENT received multiple services from service providers who were available to provide Ms. Field with guidance as to implementing STUDENT’s program. STUDENT also had a full-time one-to-one aide that was familiar with her needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes there is insufficient evidence to support Petitioner’s claim that the lack of qualifications and/or training of STUDENT’s aides or teachers resulted in their failing to address her unique and individual needs.
(b) Did Respondents ensure Petitioner’s safety at school?
Petitioner asserts that the Respondents failed to meet her need for a safe environment. Petitioner asserts that she would not have been seriously injured on several occasions if she was properly supervised. The District asserts that the injuries STUDENT sustained did not result in the denial of a FAPE.
MOTHER testified that during the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT sustained a broken finger and a broken tailbone. The broken finger occurred during Ms. Field’s tenure in the class. STUDENT’s one-to-one aide was not present when she was injured. However, STUDENT was being assisted by another aide. The broken tailbone occurred during the extended school year. Ms. Parry had returned to the class by that time. The evidence establishes that STUDENT fell on her bottom while in the bathroom with her one-to-one aide. According to the aide, STUDENT suffered a seizure without warning prior to falling. The aide was unaware that STUDENT had sustained a serious injury. The school did not report her injury that day. However, MOTHER took STUDENT to the doctor because of her obvious discomfort as reported by the bus driver and observed by her parents at home. The next day while MOTHER was speaking with Ms. Parry, the aide related to Ms. Parry what had happened.
It has been concluded that one of STUDENT’s needs is for a safe environment. The nature and severity of STUDENT’s disabilities, including a seizure disorder, require that she be carefully supervised at all times. For this reason, she has a one-to-one aide. The Respondents have provided her with this service. Additionally, the witnesses testified that on an average, STUDENT suffers from at least two seizures daily. MOTHER disputes that the seizures are “drop” or gran mal seizures. However, it is undisputed that the seizures generally occur without warning and may cause STUDENT to drop her head or fall. The seriousness of STUDENT’s injuries cannot be taken lightly. However, it is noted that STUDENT’s serious injuries occurred while different teachers and aides were present and under different circumstances. One injury was early in the school year while the other occurred during the ESY. The Hearing Officer concludes that the injuries do not constitute a pattern of poor supervision or an unsafe environment. In consideration of the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the Respondents took adequate steps to ensure STUDENT’s safety at school.
Was Respondents’ offer reasonably calculated to provide Petitioner with educational benefit?
Petitioner asserts that she did not make meaningful progress toward meeting her goals and objectives related to communication, motor, and self-help skills.
Respondents assert that their offer was reasonably calculated to provide Petitioner with benefit and, in fact, she derived educational benefit during the 2000-2001 school year. Specifically, Respondents assert that the multiple services provided to Petitioner addressed her communication, self-help, vision, mobility, gross- and fine-motor, socialization, and pre-academic needs. Respondents further assert that Petitioner made progress in the areas of gross-motor, self-help, fine-motor, toileting, and visual functioning.
MOTHER testified that STUDENT regained some of the skills she had demonstrated earlier while in Ms. Soo’s class, which were not evident the prior school year. For example, MOTHER stated that STUDENT showed improved walking and self-feeding skills. However, in MOTHER’s opinion, because STUDENT did not acquire skills beyond those skills she possessed in 1999, STUDENT did not make meaningful progress.
The testimony of Ilene Goldman, VI specialist, supported MOTHER’s testimony in part. Ms. Goldman had met STUDENT while in Ms. Nelson’s class. (STUDENT was in Ms. Nelson’s class through the 1996-1997 school year.) Ms. Goldman testified that STUDENT was more receptive to being in school while in Ms. Goldman’s class and less agitated than she observed her to be during the 2000-2001 school year. Marcella Murray, STUDENT’s speech and language therapist, testified that STUDENT did not demonstrate improved receptive language skills and made only minimal progress with expressive language skills. (See also Petitioner’s Exhibits page 202-203, wherein the lack of any progress toward expressive communication goals and objectives is recorded.) STUDENT showed only slight growth on two of six self-help objectives. Although MOTHER asserted STUDENT was not able to use two Big Mac switches, Ms. Murray, who worked with STUDENT as her speech and language therapist, testified that STUDENT had access to at least four Big Macs and was able to use two with facilitation.
On the other hand, the testimony of STUDENT’s teacher, Ms. Parry, and the IEP reflect STUDENT’s growth in other areas. Ms. Parry testified that STUDENT made progress toward meeting gross-motor and self-help goals and objectives. For example, as of March 2001, STUDENT was taking 115 steps with prompts while in June 2000, she was taking 90-100 steps. STUDENT also increased by one the number of stairs she would initiate stepping up and also increased the number of steps she was taking in other situations, such as walking around a table. As to self-help skills, Ms. Parry testified that STUDENT increased the number of times she correctly placed her drink container on the table from two to three out of five times with “light assistance.” Ms. Parry testified that STUDENT’s balance and posture improved. A review of STUDENT’s progress from April 2000 to March 2001 as recorded on her IEP shows that STUDENT was able to remain seated on top of a cube chair with a wedge from five to twenty-five minutes. As to fine-motor tasks, STUDENT improved her ability to pick up small objects. STUDENT also improved her ability to use a touch screen window on the computer.
In summary, while STUDENT made minimal progress on communication goals and objectives, she continued to make steady progress toward meeting gross-motor goals and objectives and demonstrated progress in fine-motor skill tasks. Progress also was made toward meeting some self-help goals and objectives. Therefore, the evidence establishes that STUDENT’s progress toward achieving goals and objectives during the 2000-2001 school year was mixed. However, goals and objectives are one measure of progress. Here, the testimony of Ms. Parry, STUDENT’s teacher, weighs more than the testimony of other witnesses toward finding that STUDENT benefitted from her education. STUDENT had been in Ms. Parry’s class for over one year, giving Ms. Parry ample opportunity to observe her progress or lack thereof on a daily basis. Ms. Parry’s testimony augmented the information recorded on the IEP as to STUDENT’s improved motor skills. It is undisputed that motor skills are an important component of her education. Additionally, in determining whether STUDENT benefitted from her education, the intensity of STUDENT’s needs and her multiple disabilities must be considered. Taking all of these factors into consideration, the Hearing Officer concludes that Ms. Parry’s testimony and the documented improvement in several areas substantiates that STUDENT benefitted from her program, placement and services during the 2000-2001 school year.
Did Respondents provide Petitioner with a program and services that conformed to her IEP?
(a) Did Respondents implement Petitioner’s goals and objectives?
Petitioner asserts that there is no evidence that Ms. Parry implemented goals and objectives for the IEP. The Respondents assert otherwise. In support of Respondent’s assertion, Ms. Parry described the schedule matrix she developed, illustrating times during the school day when STUDENT’s goals and objectives were implemented. The testimony of several of the professionals providing STUDENT’s services corroborated Ms. Parry’s testimony. For example, Ms. Goldman testified that she observed Ms. Parry working with STUDENT using touch windows, intellikeys, switches, and lightbrite books. Ms. Murray testified that STUDENT used Big Mac switches. These observations substantiate that Ms. Parry implemented goals and objectives from several areas including communication. Ms. Robbins also observed Ms. Parry’s class on several occasions and expressed no concerns as to Ms. Parry’s implementing STUDENT’s goals and objectives. The Hearing Officer concludes that their testimony establishes that goals and objectives were implemented in Ms. Parry’s class.
(b) Did Respondents provide Petitioner with the OT called for by her IEP?
Petitioner’s IEP during this period called for two hours weekly of OT. There is no dispute that Petitioner did not receive OT from August 30, 2000, to October 16, 2000, because Respondents failed to have anyone available to provide the services. Respondents hired a private provider, Therapy Link, which provided Petitioner with two sessions weekly of OT from October 16, 2000, to the end of the 2000-2001 school year. Therefore, Petitioner did not receive OT consistent with her IEP during September through October 16, 2000.
(c) Did Respondents provide Petitioner with the PT called for by her IEP?
Petitioner’s IEP indicates that she was to receive two sessions weekly of PT. There was no IEP convened to change the frequency of services. (Petitioner’s Exhibits page 223.) However, from September through December 12, 2000, CCS provided Petitioner with one hour weekly of PT, from December 13, 2000 to April 2, 2001, CCS provided two hours monthly of PT rather than weekly, and from April 3, to the remainder of the school year, including the ESY, CCS did not provide any PT.
Respondents do not dispute the level of PT to which Petitioner was entitled pursuant to her IEPs. However, Respondents assert that Petitioner was entitled to “medically necessary” PT for which CCS was responsible rather than the District or COE.
There is no persuasive evidence that Petitioner received PT at the level called for by her IEP. As determined above related to OT, the Respondents remain responsible for providing Petitioner with the services called for by her IEP. Thus, The Hearing Officer concludes that Respondents failed to ensure that Petitioner received the PT to which she was entitled for a total of approximately 74 sessions.(Footnote 1)
Summary
In summary, it has been concluded that Respondents failed to provide multiple OT and PT sessions in conformance with her IEP, thereby resulting in the denial of FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year as to OT and PT.
ISSUE NO. 3: Did Respondents provide Petitioner a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year including the ESY?
September to December 2001
Petitioner participated in two substantially different placements during the 2001-2002 school year. From September to December, Petitioner was placed in Brenda Galicia’s SDC at Audubon. She continued to be entitled to the same services as prior school years as her needs remained substantially the same as described above in Issue No. 1.
Petitioner raises multiple areas of concern regarding the substantive appropriateness of her initial placement for the 2001-2002 school year. Petitioner challenges Ms. Galicia’s qualifications and training, the aide’s training, and the lack of a safe educational environment. Petitioner also asserts that Ms. Galicia failed to implement Petitioner’s goals and objectives and Respondents failed to provide all services called for by her IEP, which resulted in Petitioner’s failing to benefit from her education. The discussion below is limited to the specific areas of concern raised by Petitioner.
Was Respondents’ offer designed to meet Petitioner’s unique and individual needs?
(a) Were Petitioner’s teacher and aide properly qualified and trained?
Petitioner asserts that Ms. Galicia, her teacher from September 2001 until her parents removed her from school in December 2001, was not properly qualified or trained to meet STUDENT’s needs as a student with severe multiple disabilities. Respondents assert that Ms. Galicia met State credentialing requirements and received support from a BTSA advisor.
Katheryn Burke, BTSA advisor, testified that Ms. Galicia was appropriately accredited in another country and was either on a waiver or an emergency credential at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year, which required her to take six units annually toward achieving a clear credential. Ms. Burke testified that she met multiple times with Ms. Galicia to discuss strategies for working with STUDENT to address self-help skills and toileting, and regarding the use of assistive technology devices. Ms. Burke stated she also assisted Ms. Galicia develop a schedule matrix indicating when STUDENT’s goals and objectives would be addressed in the class schedule. Ms. Burke testified that Ms. Galicia received additional support from STUDENT’s former teachers, Ms. Soo and Ms. Parry, who each came to Ms. Galicia’s class to consult with her on at least one occasion.
As to the aide’s training Ms. Burke testified that STUDENT’s aide, Christina Gleason, was included in the training provided to Ms. Galicia. Ms. Robbins testified that STUDENT’s former aide, Ms. Tobar, supported Ms. Gleason. The testimony of Ms. Burke and Ms. Robbins was not disputed as to the training provided to STUDENT’s aide. Although there was a great deal of discussion at the hearing regarding which of two plans was implemented, there is no dispute that the COE and the District developed a training plan and Ms. Galicia and STUDENT’s aide participated in the training. The Hearing Officer concludes that the evidence as discussed above supports the finding that Ms. Galicia and Ms. Gleason were sufficiently qualified and trained to implement STUDENT’s IEP.
(b) Did Respondents ensure Petitioner’s safety at school?
Petitioner asserts that while she was in Ms. Galicia’s class, Respondents failed to ensure her safety at school and, as a result, she suffered head and other injuries that could have been prevented with appropriate supervision. The District did not specifically respond to these assertions.
MOTHER testified that STUDENT was injured multiple times in the three months she was in Ms. Galicia’s class. MOTHER described several incidents. On one occasion, STUDENT fell off the peanut ball and hit her head on the wheelchair that was too close in proximity to where she was using the ball. She received a gouge in her head. STUDENT hit her head on a table on another occasion and was injured when transferring from one bus to another. MOTHER testified that during one of her visits to the classroom, STUDENT was left alone on a couch. STUDENT fell off of the couch. MOTHER expressed great concern that STUDENT was left alone. MOTHER also testified regarding an incident on October 29, 2001. MOTHER found STUDENT sitting on the floor of the school bathroom while two aides were assisting another two children. MOTHER found this particularly troubling since STUDENT was supposed to have a one-to-one aide. (See Petitioner’s Exhibits pages 672 - 677.)
Respondents’ witnesses countered MOTHER’s testimony by stating generally that they provided training to STUDENT’s staff. However, Ms. Robbins’ testimony regarding the incidents establishes that she shared some of MOTHER’s concern for STUDENT’s safety.
The fact that the incidents described by MOTHER, who observed some directly, occurred in a relatively short period of time appears to have resulted because of a lack of diligence on the part of the staff. The staff were not sufficiently aware of the potential harm to STUDENT should she have a seizure. MOTHER’s testimony suggests that staff also were not aware of the potential risk of injury by placing STUDENT in close proximity to equipment. It is noted that neither Ms. Galicia nor the classroom aide testified. Thus, their perspective of the incidents was not heard. There was no explanation given for STUDENT’s being left on a bathroom floor.
Petitioner additionally asserts that Respondents’ failure to provide appropriate transportation services placed her in risk of injury. MOTHER testified that, without her knowledge, Petitioner was required daily to change buses while traveling between home and school, which resulted in STUDENT’s being injured. MOTHER testified that she properly fastened STUDENT into her harness on the bus when she left home in the morning. However, when STUDENT changed buses, she then was not properly fastened into her harness. Ms. Robbins testified regarding the bus situation and appeared concerned about the bus transfer as well. Ms. Robbins stated that she investigated the bus situation and determined that STUDENT was changing buses on the way to school. Following Ms. Robbins’ discovering the bus changes, the marks on STUDENT were attributed to the lack of proper training regarding fastening STUDENT’s harness. There is no dispute that on at least one other occasion, STUDENT was injured as she was getting onto the bus.
There is no evidence that the Respondents resolved the bus situation. STUDENT continued to arrive home from school with marks on her neck from the improperly placed harness. Additionally, during bus transfers, STUDENT suffered other injuries. The above testimony of Ms. Robbins and MOTHER, leads the Hearing Officer to the conclusion that Respondents failed to meet Petitioner’s need for a safe environment while traveling between home and school and while attending Ms. Galicia’s class.
Was Respondents’ offer reasonably calculated to provide Petitioner with educational benefit?
Petitioner asserts that she did not make meaningful progress during the first part of the 2001-2002 school year because Ms. Galicia did not implement IEP goals and objectives and because she was working on skills that she had previously mastered by 1999. Respondents assert that they provided Petitioner with a placement that was reasonably calculated to provide her with benefit and from which she did benefit. Specifically, Respondents assert that the multiple services provided to Petitioner addressed her areas of need and that by the end of the school year, she had made substantial progress in areas including self-help, balancing, fine-motor skills, and walking.
MOTHER testified that STUDENT did not make meaningful progress in Ms. Galicia’s class. It was her opinion that STUDENT was working on skills that she previously was able to perform. Ruth Johns, STUDENT’s aide for approximately four years while she was in Ms. Nelson’s and Ms. Soo’s classes, was asked to help train STUDENT’s teacher and aide in March 2002, after transferring to Lincoln. Ms. Johns expressed the opinion that STUDENT had “fallen way back” and was working on skills she previously had been able to perform (Footnote 12) As to motor skills, Ms. Johns testified that when she last worked with STUDENT, she was able to independently walk 50 to 60 steps and pedal her tricycle independently. As to communication skills, Ms. Johns stated that STUDENT was able to activate two switches and shake her head to indicate “yes” or “no.”
Ms. Krabbenschmidt, who is employed by the COE, testified that STUDENT’s communication skills in December 2001continued to fall within the three- to six-month range. While STUDENT had not demonstrated improved communication skills the prior school year, Ms. Krabbenschmidt’s current assessment showed that STUDENT regressed in specific skill areas. For example, in 2001, STUDENT required full facilitation to use the Big Mac switch in 2001 that she had during prior assessments. STUDENT previously had been using two switches and was observed to use only one in 2001. Significantly, Ms. Krabbenschmidt observed that in 2001, STUDENT was not initiating communication whereas in 1997 STUDENT would reach out to touch her aide and call out to a familiar person on the other side of the room and, in 2000, STUDENT would spontaneously reach out. (See Petitioner’s Exhibits pp. 180-181 and 315-317.)
There is no dispute that Respondents offered a variety of services to address Petitioner’s multiple needs. As was concluded in the first issue, STUDENT requires a consistent program to retain skills and to gain new skills. However, as discussed more fully below, STUDENT’s program was not consistently implemented in Ms. Galicia’s class. For one, STUDENT did not have equipment necessary to work on her goals and objectives for substantially all of the time she was in Ms. Galicia’s class. She also did not receive all of the services called for by her IEP. Moreover, Ms. Krabbenschmidt and Ms. Johns offered persuasive testimony as to STUDENT’s regressing while in Ms. Galicia’s class. Both Ms. Krabbenschmidt and Ms. Johns have worked directly with STUDENT and have known her since she was in preschool and, thus were able to credibly compare STUDENT’s skills in March 2002 to the skills she previously possessed. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT failed to make meaningful benefit in Ms. Galicia’s class.
Did Respondents provide Petitioner with a program and services that conformed to her IEP?
(a) Did Respondents provide the equipment required to implement Petitioner’s IEP?
Petitioner asserts that not all of the equipment required to implement Petitioner’s IEP was available in Ms. Galicia’s classroom. Respondents assert that any initial problems arranging for Petitioner’s equipment to be placed in Ms. Galicia’s classroom were taken care of during the fall of 2001. There is no dispute that STUDENT continued to require the same equipment described in earlier issues.
MOTHER testified that at the IEP meeting on December 19, 2001, Ms. Galicia stated that she still did not have all of STUDENT’s equipment. MOTHER also testified that when she observed Ms. Galicia’s class in October, there were no batteries for the cause and affect toys and STUDENT’s special toilet seat was not attached. STUDENT’s helmet did not fit so she needed a new one. A piece of STUDENT’s bench was missing and the slant board was put away in a cabinet. MOTHER stated that she and Ms. Robbins scurried around to locate equipment and make it useable for STUDENT.
Ms. Robbins acknowledged that there was a problem at the beginning of the school year with the availability of STUDENT’s equipment. The classroom was being recarpeted and it took some time before all of the equipment was retrieved from storage, opened, and utilized. Ms. Robbins recalled that it took several weeks for the equipment to arrive in Ms. Galicia’s class. Ms. Robbins was aware that, as of November 6, 2002, or later, there still were no switches or light boxes available for STUDENT’s use. Ms. Robbins stated that “as they found equipment” it was put into use. Ms. Robbins also stated that some equipment had still not been set up prior to STUDENT’s parents removing her from the class in December 2001. Ms. Murray also testified that from her visits, she was aware that the sole computer in Ms. Galicia’s class was not working.
It was concluded in Issue No. 1 that STUDENT utilizes a great deal of equipment, which is required to implement her IEP goals and objectives. The testimony discussed above establishes that equipment necessary to implement STUDENT’s IEP was not available from September to December 2001. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that Respondents failed to provide STUDENT equipment in conformity with the requirements of her IEP.
(b) Did Respondents implement Petitioner’s goals and objectives?
Petitioner asserts that Ms. Galicia did not implement her IEP goals and objectives. Respondents disagree with the assertion.
MOTHER testified that at the IEP meeting on December 19, 2001, Ms. Galicia stated that she still did not have all of STUDENT’s equipment and, for this reason, was not working on all of STUDENT’s goals and objectives. MOTHER testified that without STUDENT’s toilet seat installed, Ms. Galicia could not have been able to implement toileting goals appropriately. At that time, STUDENT was to be placed on the toilet at several specific times during the school day to pattern her use of the toilet. MOTHER testified that during her classroom observations, Ms. Galicia also was not implementing goals and objectives related to the use of the tricycle because STUDENT’s helmet was too tight and she required a new one. Additionally, MOTHER testified that a special chair necessary to implement goals and objectives related to sitting/standing goals and objectives was not used.
Ms. Robbins did not recall Ms. Galicia’s statement at the IEP meeting and testified that she had observed goals and objectives being implemented that involved STUDENT’s using a ball and walking. However, Ms. Robbins also acknowledged working with MOTHER to attempt to locate STUDENT’s equipment. She also concurred with MOTHER that much of STUDENT’s equipment was unavailable. Ms. Krabbenschmidt and Ms. Murray acknowledged that the computer was unavailable sometimes during the fall of 2001 because it was not working. Ms. Burke testified that during her visits to Ms. Galicia’s class, she observed self-help, walking, and cause and effect goals and objectives being implemented. She also saw STUDENT working on making choices. Ms. Galicia did not testify.
The Hearing Officer finds that the testimony of MOTHER and Ms. Robbins establishes that equipment essential to implement STUDENT’s goals and objectives was unavailable for three months which resulted in the failure to implement all of STUDENT’s goals and objectives. A review in December 2001 of STUDENT’s goals and objectives confirms that a goal related to STUDENT’s using the computer was not addressed. (See Petitioner’s Exhibits page 332.) STUDENT is a student with multiple, intense needs, including the need for a consistent and repetitive program so that she will retain skills and develop new skills. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the Respondents’ failure to ensure that equipment was available until three months into the school year resulted in their failing to provide a program that conformed to STUDENT’s IEP.
(c) Did Respondents provide OT consistent with Petitioner’s IEP?
Petitioner asserts that at all times during the 2001-2002 school year, her IEP called for two hours of OT. The record shows that during September of 2001, STUDENT received one hour per week of OT and one hour of make up services for services she did not receive the prior school year. Thus, STUDENT did not then receive both make-up OT and the two hours of OT called for by her IEP in the fall of 2001. (d) Did Respondents provide PT consistent with Petitioner’s IEP?
There is no dispute that Petitioner did not receive PT through November 26, 2001, and received one hour rather than two beginning on November 26, 2001. In November 2001, the District contracted with Maureen Murphy to provide PT. Ms. Murphy’s schedule allowed her to provide STUDENT with only one session weekly. Therefore, there is no dispute as to the number of hours that PT was provided to Petitioner. There also is no dispute that the number of hours did not conform with the hours called for by Petitioner’s IEP.
Respondents continue to assert that CCS, rather than Respondents was responsible for providing PT. As previously determined in issues above, Respondents remained responsible for providing services called for by Petitioner’s IEP. For this reason, the Hearing Officer concludes that Respondents did not provide Petitioner with services that conformed to her IEP.
Summary
Respondents failed to provide Petitioner with a program that was designed to meet her unique needs as they related to safety both in the classroom and while being transported to and from school. The evidence above established that Respondents failed to provide the equipment necessary for STUDENT to progress on self-help skills related to toileting, to progress on gross-motor skills addressed by using the tricycle and specialized chairs, and to progress on communication or small-motor skills addressed by use of cause and effect switches and programs on the computer. The failure of Respondents to implement goals and objectives and to provide services and equipment as discussed above, resulted in STUDENT’s failing to receive meaningful benefit. While Respondents argued that either STUDENT’s seizure disorder interfered with her making progress or, alternatively, she has reached a plateau, the testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Soo, and Ms. Johns establishes that STUDENT was able to retain skills and improve skills when provided a consistent program. Their testimony, as well as the testimony of Ms. Krabbenschmidt, also establishes that STUDENT previously was better able to independently feed herself, use switches for communication, and walk independently than she was while in Ms. Galicia’s class. Although STUDENT was able to maintain some skills during prior school years despite missing some OT and PT services, the cumulative effect of missing equipment and services resulted in STUDENT’s regressing. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Respondents failed to provide Petitioner with a FAPE for the first three months of the 2001-2002 school year.
January to August 2002
The IEP team crafted a program and services for Petitioner after her parents removed her from the COE placement. Beginning in January 2002, the District provided a teacher, aide, and services to Petitioner at Lincoln Elementary School. Petitioner was not placed in a classroom with other students. While generally pleased with the program and services, Petitioner asserts that she failed to make meaningful benefit from her education. Petitioner also asserts that because she had multiple service providers during the course of the year, there were periods of time when changes from one provider to another resulted in the Respondents’ failure to provide all of the services to which Petitioner was entitled pursuant to her IEP.
Respondents assert that Petitioner made educational progress during the school year and benefitted from her placement. The District acknowledges that it had to deal with a number of challenges related to service providers when Petitioner moved from the COE’s SDC to Lincoln. The areas discussed below are limited to those raised by Petitioner regarding Respondents’ failure to provide her with a FAPE.
Was Respondents’ offer reasonably calculated to provide Petitioner with educational benefit?
Petitioner asserts that she did not make meaningful progress while placed at Lincoln during the regular school year. Petitioner asserts that the progress that she did make simply returned her to the level at which she had been functioning some four years earlier while in Mitzi Soo’s SDC.
Respondents assert that they provided Petitioner with a placement that was reasonably calculated to provide her with benefit and from which she did benefit. Specifically, Respondents assert that the multiple services provided to Petitioner addressed her areas of need and that by the end of the school year, she had made substantial progress in areas including self-help, balancing, fine-motor skills, and walking.
As to progress, Ms. Ash testified that STUDENT responded well to a one-step direction of “head up.” Ms. Ash also testified that during the time she worked with STUDENT, her self-feeding skills improved as did her use of switches.
Despite Respondents’ assertions that STUDENT made meaningful growth, many of STUDENT’s service providers testified that STUDENT did not progress while at Lincoln. Melissa Kaye, registered occupational therapist, provided STUDENT’s OT from April to November 2002. Ms. Kay concluded that STUDENT did not make meaningful progress from April to June 2002. Ms. Sequeira, STUDENT’s aide, testified that by the end of the summer, STUDENT was walking 20 to 25 steps independently. There is no persuasive evidence that STUDENT has maintained or shown growth in fine- or gross-motor skills development, particularly given that earlier testimony established that STUDENT was walking more than 100 steps during prior school years. Ms. Goldman, who has known STUDENT since preschool, also stated that STUDENT had regressed. Ms. Murray, LAS therapist, testified that she continued to work on the same goals and objectives through April 2002 and recommended in June 2002, that the goals and objectives be revised. Here again, as discussed more fully below, STUDENT did not receive services consistently throughout the school year. The Hearing Officer concludes that Respondent has failed to establish through their own witnesses that STUDENT made meaningful progress in motor or communication skill areas.
Did Respondents provide Petitioner with a program and services that conformed to her IEP?
(a) Did Respondents provide OT consistent with the requirements of Petitioner’s IEP?
Petitioner asserts that while placed at Lincoln, her IEP continued to call for two hours weekly of OT. Petitioner asserts, however, that through February 28, 2002, she received one hour weekly of OT. The District asserts that it provided two hours weekly of OT through February 28, 2003. Ms. Robbins testified that she calculated the number of hours of OT that had been provided by Ms. Leong from information available to the District, including invoices, and found that Stacey Leong provided two hours weekly of OT through February 28, 2002. The schedules of services provided to Petitioner at Lincoln, showing that Stacey Leong provided OT twice weekly, support Ms. Robbins’ testimony. (Petitioner’s Exhibits pages 682 -685.) Stacey Leong did not testify and none of Petitioner’s witnesses had direct knowledge of the dates Stacey Leong provided OT. Therefore, the Hearing Officer relies on the testimony of Ms. Robbins and the schedules available for review and concludes that through February 2003, Petitioner received OT consistent with the requirements of her IEP.
Petitioner additionally asserts that from February 28 to April 20, she received no OT, that from April 20 through July 22, she received one hour weekly of OT, and that from July 23 to the end of the ESY program, she did not receive any OT. Respondents concur with Petitioner’s assertions as to the above periods. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that, except as to the period from her placement at Lincoln to February 28, 2002, Respondents failed to provide OT in conformity with her IEP.
(b) Did Respondents provide PT consistent with the requirements of Petitioner’s IEP?
Petitioner asserts that Respondents provided one hour of PT through April 28, 2002, rather than the two hours called for by her IEP. Respondents concur that Petitioner did not receive twenty hours of PT as called for by her IEP As to the rest of the school year, Respondents provided an appropriate level of PT. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Respondents failed to provide PT consistent with her IEP.
(c) Did Respondents provide language and speech (LAS) therapy and augmentative alternative communication (AAC) services consistent with the requirements of Petitioner’s IEP?
Petitioner was entitled to LAS one hour weekly, except during spring break, the week between the regular school year, two weeks before the start of the regular school year, and winter break. Petitioner asserts that she did not receive any LAS/AAC therapy from April 25, 2002, through May 28, 2003, and after August 1, 2002, until a new therapist was recently hired. Respondents do not dispute that they failed to provide Petitioner LAS or AAC services during these periods. Therefore, the Respondents failed to provide LAS therapy that conformed with STUDENT’s IEP.
(d) Did Respondents provide assistive technology (AT) services consistent with the requirements of Petitioner’s IEP?
Petitioner asserts that from January 28, 2002, to June 14, 2002, she received a total of 35.5 hours of AT services, whereas her IEP called for her to receive 60 hours. Thus, she did not receive 24.5 hours of assistive technology to which she was entitled. Respondents assert that according to invoices received from the service provider, Tracy Berliner provided AT services at the level called for by Petitioner’s IEP. Ms. Berliner testified that she provided direct services as well as consultative services for a total amount that was consistent with STUDENT’s IEP. There is no persuasive evidence to the contrary.
Summary
In summary, the evidence establishes that STUDENT failed to receive OT, PT, and LAS consistent with the services called for by her IEP, which was developed and agreed to by Petitioner’s parents and Respondents’ members of the IEP team. It has also been concluded that STUDENT failed to demonstrate progress in both motor and communication skills, which the testimony of her prior aides and teachers establishes that she is capable of making when provided with a consistent program. These determinations result in the Hearing Officer’s concluding that Respondents failed to offer and provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year.
ISSUE NO. 4: Did Respondents offer Petitioner a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year including the ESY?
The dispute related to the 2002-2003 school year centers around Respondents’ offer to place Petitioner in a COE special day class for students with severe multiple disabilities (SDC/SMH). The SDC/SMH is located at Parkside Intermediate School, which is within the San Bruno Park Unified School District. Petitioner alleges both procedural and substantive deficiencies related to Respondents’ offer.(Footnote 13) Respondents contend that its offer was both procedurally and substantively proper.
Did Respondents commit procedural errors that resulted in the denial of a FAPE to Petitioner?
Petitioner asserts that Respondents committed the following procedural violations related to the offer of placement for Petitioner for the 2002-2003 school year: (a) the composition of the IEP team at the meeting at which the County SDC/SMH was offered was not appropriate, and (b) the offer of placement made by Respondents’ members of the IEP team was vague and was not made in writing. Petitioner asserts that by not having a full discussion of placement options, her parents were prevented from being able to meaningfully participate in the IEP process.
(a) Did an inappropriately composed IEP team result in the denial of a FAPE?
Education Code section 56341(b) sets forth the required members of an IEP team. Those persons include (1) a representative other than the student’s teacher designated by the administration who is knowledgeable of program options appropriate for the students and who is qualified to provide or supervise the provision of special education (the representative may be an administrator, program or other specialist); (2) the pupil’s present teacher (there are other provisions if the student does not have a current teacher); and (3) one or both of the parents. Subdivision (c) provides that when appropriate, the IEP team shall include the student and other individuals possessing expert knowledge.
In attendance at the IEP meeting on June 5, 2002, were MOTHER; Ms. Gellerman, the advocate; Ms. Robbins; Mr. Nibbelin; Ms. LePage, COE integrated services manager; Ms. Ash, STUDENT’s teacher; Ms. Goldman, STUDENT’s VI provider; and Ms. Kaye, STUDENT’s occupational therapist. At the reconvened IEP meeting on June 13, 2002, additional persons were present, including Ms. Berliner, AT specialist, and Ms. Murphy, PT specialist. Thus, Petitioner’s assertions regarding an improperly convened IEP team fail.
(b) Did Respondents fail to put their offer of placement in writing, thereby resulting in the denial of a FAPE to Petitioner?
Petitioner asserts that Respondents failed to put their offer of placement to STUDENT in writing. Respondents assert that although the IEP developed in June did not identify the specific location of the County SDC proposed for Petitioner’s placement, during the summer the District shared information regarding the classroom location with Petitioner’s parents and MOTHER visited the class prior to the beginning of the school year and at least one other time.
Respondents are required to make a formal written offer of placement in accordance with Union School District v. Smith (9th Cir. 1994) 15 F.3d 1519, 1526, Cert. Denied 115 S.Ct. 428; 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3). In Union, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals stated “this formal requirement [of a written offer of placement] has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe it should be enforced rigorously.” The Court went on to discuss the reasons for imposing the requirement, in pertinent part to alert the parents of the need to consider seriously whether the proposed placement is appropriate under the IDEA and to help the parents determine whether to oppose or accept the placement with supplemental services.
MOTHER testified that prior to the IEP meeting in June 2002, the District had asked her to observe an SDC at Westborough. At the IEP meeting, Respondents offered to place STUDENT in a County SDC, without identifying the specific class. Sometime during the summer, MOTHER learned that the class that had been at Westborough had moved to Parkside. This information was convened in a letter to the PARENTS by Mr. Nibellin. No students were present the first time MOTHER went to observe the class. She returned for a brief second observation in September and again in March, during the course of the hearing. The IEP dated June 5, 2002, identifies the placement offered to STUDENT as a San Mateo County Office of Education SDC/SMH. MOTHER has written next to her signature that she agrees to the placement and services “with exception to County Classroom for ‘02 -‘03.” (Petitioner’s Exhibits pages 357-361.) Ms. Robbins testified that at the time of the IEP meeting, no one was certain where the class would be located for the 2002-2003 school year. While the June 5, 2002, offer of placement is in writing and acknowledged by MOTHER, the offer of “a County SDC/SMH” is not sufficiently specific to satisfy California’s definition of “placement.” Specific educational placement is “that unique combination of facilities, personnel, location or equipment necessary to provide instructional services to an individual with exception needs.” 5 CCR § 3042(a). It also is not sufficiently specific to allow the parents to make an informed decision regarding whether or not to accept the offer. However, the evidence establishes that the parents were informed both orally and in writing that Respondents were offering to place Petitioner in the County SDC/SMH located at Parkside. (See Respondent’s Exhibit 35, which is a letter to the PARENTS dated July 12, 2002, and states the “District has been informed that the class it is offering will be located at the campus of the Parkside Intermediate School, in the San Bruno Park Elementary School District during the 2002-2003 academic year.” See also Respondent’s Exhibit 37, a second letter to the PARENTS dated August 16, 2002, reiterating the Respondents’ offer of placement at the County’s SDC at Parkside and further describing the class, its teacher, and students.) Additionally, MOTHER visited Ms. Matetick’s class on at least two occasions. Therefore, given the specificity in letters to the PARENTS prior to the beginning of the school year detailing the placement offered by Respondents, the Hearing Officer finds that the requirements of Union were satisfied.
Did Respondents offer Petitioner a substantively appropriate placement?
Is the placement designed to meet Petitioner’s unique and individual needs?
Turning first to STUDENT’s needs, the testimony of STUDENT’s current service providers, as well as Ms. Ash, Ms. Sequeira, and MOTHER, establishes that STUDENT continues to have deficits in all areas of development. Overall, STUDENT needs to develop independence to the extent possible. She requires exercises and equipment to develop motor skills, and instruction and opportunities to develop self-help skills, including self-feeding and toileting. STUDENT needs to develop a functional communication system that includes the use of AT and AAC devices. STUDENT needs to increase her level of awareness.
STUDENT’s teacher, aide, parent, and service providers made recommendations regarding the components of an appropriate placement for STUDENT. They recommended generally that STUDENT participate in a class with an experienced teacher and a low student-to-teacher ratio. Additionally, the witnesses agree that STUDENT requires peers whose goals and objectives are similar to STUDENT’s goals and objectives. As to the appropriate number of students in the class, Ms. Ash and MOTHER recommended that there be four to five students in the class. Ms. Gellerman recommended no more than seven students, and Ms. Ash stated that eight students in the class would be too many because STUDENT requires a lot of attention. Other witnesses were unable to specify an appropriate number of students. Rather than determining a specific number of students with whom STUDENT should be placed, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires a low student-to-teacher ratio and that additional factors should be considered in determining an appropriate number of students. Those factors include the nature and severity of the other students’ disabilities and the class size.
As to the classroom, the witnesses concurred that the class and playground must offer STUDENT a safe environment and have sufficient space for her equipment, as well as areas for walking and riding her tricycle.(Footnote 14) Finally, the witnesses testified that the service providers need to communicate and coordinate. Melissa Kay, who provided STUDENT’s OT until November 2002, succinctly stated that STUDENT’s program “works best if the team works on the same goals but with each specialist working on a specific point.” She stated that involving the parents is important also. The Hearing Officer adopts the recommendations above of STUDENT’s teacher, parent, aide, and service providers, on which they generally concur, and finds that the above constitute the necessary components of an appropriate placement for STUDENT.
MOTHER additionally asserted that for safety reasons STUDENT should be placed on an elementary school campus rather than a middle school. While a safe environment is essential for STUDENT, there was no persuasive evidence that an elementary school is inherently safer for STUDENT than a middle school. MOTHER asserted that STUDENT requires a class similar to classes at the Bridge School in which all students are using AT and AAC systems and the development of communication is the focus of the curriculum. There is no dispute that STUDENT’s developing communication skills is important. However, the evidence has shown that STUDENT has multiple needs that must to be addressed. Additionally, none of STUDENT’s providers of language and communication services testified that the focus of STUDENT’s class should be on AT/AAC.
The above components that have been determined essential to an appropriate placement for STUDENT will next be compared to the information regarding the SDC/SMH to determine whether the class is designed to meet STUDENT’s needs.
MOTHER testified that Ms. Matetick’s class is not appropriate for STUDENT. First, MOTHER expressed her concerns regarding the County’s ability to address STUDENT’s needs, given ongoing problems with STUDENT’s prior placements in County SDCs. MOTHER expressed the opinion that Ms. Matetick’s classroom is too small and there is insufficient room in the class for all of Petitioner’s equipment. MOTHER additionally found Ms. Matetick’s class inappropriate because she did not observe any children in the class using communication devices. MOTHER also expressed concerns about the safety of the sidewalk at Parkside. She testified that there is a ledge on the sidewalk that drops onto asphalt. During a recent visit, MOTHER observed the class to be “pristine,” leading her to question whether the students were actually using equipment and engaged in activities in the classroom. MOTHER additionally raised concerns regarding the presence of a dog in the classroom and asserted that the dog may be in STUDENT’s way, thereby causing an unsafe environment for STUDENT. MOTHER additionally asserted that STUDENT may have an allergic reaction to the dog.
Much of the information regarding the proposed classroom was provided by Marty Jo Matetick, the teacher of the SDC/SMH. Ms. Matetick’s testimony establishes that Parkside Intermediate School serves general education students in the seventh and eighth grades and special education students in the sixth through eighth grades. The SDC/SMH is a new class that was formed in the fall of 2002 and is the only class in the County for students with severe multiple disabilities.
Ms. Matetick testified that she has been employed by the COE for 11 years. She has a master’s degree in education and holds a California teaching credential authorizing her to teach students with physical disabilities and other health impairments from birth through 22 years old. Ms. Matetick has been certified and taught special education students in two other states. She presently is enrolled in a graduate-level program to teach students with visual impairments. Ms. Matetick has previously worked with students using voice output equipment and has supervised students’ one-to-one aides. No one disputed Ms. Matetick’s qualifications. The evidence establishes that Ms. Matetick is an experienced teacher and appropriately credentialed to teach the SDC/SMH and she also is well-qualified to be Petitioner’s teacher. Ms. Matetick has taught students with a wide range of disabilities, including students with physical and developmental disabilities. Additionally, Ms. Matetick is currently enrolled in a graduate level program related to teaching students with visual impairments. The Hearing Officer concludes that Ms. Matetick meets the requirement that STUDENT be placed in a class with an experienced teacher. Given Ms. Matetick’s experience, she should be able to coordinate STUDENT’s service providers so that they are working toward achieving common goals for STUDENT.
Turning to STUDENT’s need for a class with a low student-to-teacher ratio, Ms. Matetick testified that she is assisted by two aides. There also are four one-to-one aides assigned to specific students in the class. The class is composed of eight students who previously attended other schools within San Mateo County. Given that there are seven adults in the class and eight students, the student-to-teacher ratio is nearly one-to-one. STUDENT has her own one-to-one aide and, if she were placed in the class, she would not disrupt the student-to-teacher ratio. The maximum number of students that may be placed in the class is 12. Thus, even if an additional four students were assigned to the class, the student-to-teacher ratio would remain low and would satisfy the requirement that STUDENT be placed in a class with a low student-to-teacher ratio.
As to STUDENT’s need for an appropriate peer group, Ms. Matetick’s testimony establishes that the students in the class range in age from 12 years to 14 years. Approximately one half of the students have developmental disabilities. One third of the students also have cerebral palsy. Six or seven of the students use a wheelchair over one-half of the day. None of the students walk independently. All of the students receive OT and PT. Two of the students have some oral language. One uses sentences. The other student who communicates orally uses words. However, the only words he uses consistently are “yes” and “no.” Some of the students use communication books with either symbols or pictures. All of the students use voice output devices, which range from a single action switch to one with multiple phrases. Many of the students have additional equipment they use during the school day. A comparison of STUDENT’s disabilities and areas of need to the disabilities and general areas of need to the students in Ms. Matetick’s class reveals many similarities. For example, both have motor and communication deficits and both have AT and AAC systems. Additionally, the students receive services that are similar to the services provided to STUDENT. Ms. Krabbenschmidt, the augmentative communication specialist, testified that STUDENT’s AAC program can be set up and implemented in Ms. Matetick’s class in the same way that she already has set up a program for another student. Other students already receive services similar to the services STUDENT receives. The evidence establishes that service providers regularly are available to the class including Jennifer McClean, an occupational therapist from CCS, Nicky Alsberry, a physical therapist from CCS, and Robert Ridgeway, a COE vision specialist. Additionally, Ms. Matetick and Ms. Burke testified that STUDENT’s goals and objectives are similar to some of the goals and objectives of students in Ms. Matetick’s class. Larger equipment is stored in a specified area of the classroom. Petitioner provided no persuasive evidence to the contrary. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that Ms. Matetick’s class would provide STUDENT with an appropriate peer group.
Turning to the class environment, Ms. Matetick testified that safety is a top priority in her class. Ms. Matetick testified that the class has a trained facility dog, a golden retriever, who roams about the room. The dog is available to assist the students by picking up things dropped on the floor, among other tasks. In response to MOTHER’s concern that the dog may present an unsafe obstacle in the environment, Ms. Matetick testified that with her current class, the dog’s primary role is to be social and, therefore, could be restricted to a specific area of the classroom. MOTHER also asserted that the dog may cause STUDENT to have an allergic response. There is insufficient evidence to reach a conclusion as to whether the dog would need to be removed or restricted because of STUDENT’s allergies. This issue should be explored by the parties prior to placing STUDENT in the class. Except as to other vague allegations by MOTHER that a middle school campus is unsafe, there is no reason to believe that Ms. Matetick’s class would provide an unsafe environment for STUDENT.
As to STUDENT’s need for a classroom that is sufficiently large enough to accommodate the equipment she requires to implement her IEP and allow adequate space for her to walk and ride a tricycle, Ms. Matetick testified that the class is housed in a typical classroom, which is sufficiently large enough to accommodate the needs of the eight students in the class. She acknowledged that some rearranging would have to occur in the classroom to accommodate STUDENT. Ms. Robbins and Ms. O’Shea also testified regarding the physical attributes of Parkside. Both stated that there are flat surfaces inside and outside for STUDENT to walk on and there are flat surfaces outside where STUDENT may ride her tricycle. Ms. Burke also has visited Ms. Matetick’s class three times and testified that STUDENT’s equipment would fit in the classroom and her trampoline could be placed in the multipurpose room. Ms. O’Shea testified similarly.
Neither STUDENT’s current teacher, aide, nor service providers have observed Ms. Matetick’s class. Thus, many of the people with knowledge regarding STUDENT and her needs were unable to offer any opinion as to the appropriateness of the SDC/SMH for STUDENT. However, other of Respondents’ witnesses have observed Ms. Matetick’s class and also have direct knowledge of STUDENT and her educational needs. JoAnne Becker, R.M., COE school nurse, Ms. Krabbenschmidt, Ms. Robbins, and Ms. O’Shea testified on behalf of Respondents that the SDC at Parkside offers STUDENT an appropriate placement. Ms. Becker described the staff at Parkside as “dedicated” and expressed the opinion that they would be able to provide STUDENT with a safe environment. Ms. Becker has known STUDENT since preschool. Ms. Robbins has observed Ms. Matetick’s class and also has had opportunities to both observe STUDENT and work directly with her. On occasion, Ms. Robbins has filled in as a substitute teacher or aide for STUDENT.
The Hearing Officer finds persuasive the consistent testimony of the Respondents’ witnesses who have had multiple opportunities to observed Ms. Matetick’s class and the Parkside campus, and who also are familiar with STUDENT and her needs. In considering the above testimony, the Hearing Officer concludes that Ms. Matetick’s SDC/SMH is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs and will provide her with a safe environment that is able to accommodate her need to have equipment available, and will provide opportunities for STUDENT to develop motor and functional communication skills.
Did Respondents offer Petitioner a placement reasonably calculated to provide her with educational benefit?
Respondents have offered a placement and multiple services that will provide STUDENT opportunities to participate in activities addressing her most significant deficits in motor and communication areas. In a class with a few other students with similar needs and with her own individual aide, STUDENT will receive the individual attention she requires to grow. She will also be in a safe environment with an experienced teacher. The placement and services as discussed above are designed to increase STUDENT’s ability to communicate and ambulate, thereby allowing her to become as independent as possible. The Hearing Officer finds that the placement is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.
Have Respondents provided a program and services that conform to Petitioner’s IEP?
There is no dispute as Respondents are ready and able to implement the offered placement. However, there remains a dispute as to the level of the agreed-to services that Respondents have provided to Petitioner during the current school year.
(a) Have Respondents provided Petitioner with a “specialist teacher” as provided for in her IEP?
STUDENT’s IEP calls for services from a “specialist teacher.” Petitioner asserts that she was entitled to 32.5 hours of instruction from a specialist teacher but that she did not receive any services from a teacher from September to February 2, 2003. Petitioner additionally asserts that since February 3, 2003, she has received 10 hours weekly of instruction from a teacher rather than the 32.5 hours to which she is entitled. Respondent asserts that it offered Petitioner an appropriate placement and, therefore, she was not entitled to any separate instructional hours from a teacher.
STUDENT’s parents elected to not place her in the Respondents’ proposed County class and filed for due process on November 18, 2002. However, pursuant to stay put orders dated December 3, 2002, and February 21, 2003, it has been concluded that STUDENT was entitled to two instructional hours daily from a teacher during the pendency of due process. Respondents failed to provide a teacher from the date of filing of the request for due process until February 3, 2003, for a total of 41 school days at two hours daily.
(b) Have Respondents provided Petitioner with a one-to-one aide as provided for in her IEP?
Petitioner asserts that she did not receive any aide services from September 4, 2002, to November 15, 2002. Petitioner asserts that from November 15, 2002 to December 16, 2002, Petitioner received eight hours weekly of aide services whereas she was entitled to 32.5 hours weekly. Respondent asserts that it offered an appropriate placement and that no aide time is owed to Petitioner.
MOTHER testified that on June 13, 2002, she gave written consent to implementation of the services set forth in the IEP dated June 5, 2002, with the sole exception noted to STUDENT’s placement in the County classroom. (See also Petitioner’s Exhibits pages 357-421.) The IEP provides for STUDENT to receive the services of a full-time one-to-one instructional assistant for five days each week. Pursuant to Education Code section 56346(a), those components of the program to which the parent has consented shall be implemented. Therefore, Respondents were responsible for providing STUDENT the services of a fulltime aide from the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year.
(c) Have Respondents provided AT services consistent with the requirements of Petitioner’s IEP?
Petitioner asserts that Ms. Berliner has provided Petitioner with two hours of AT services whereas Petitioner’s IEP calls for three to four hours of AT services. Respondents assert that Ms. Berliner has provided at least three hours of AT during this period. The testimony of Ms. Berliner and Ms. Robbins confirms that Ms. Berliner provided AT direct services and consultation consistent with the requirements set forth in STUDENT’s IEP.
(d) Have Respondents provided LAS/AAC services consistent with the requirements of Petitioner’s IEP?
Petitioner asserts that she has not been provided with LAS/AAC services since July 27, 2002. Respondents do not dispute that Petitioner did not receive LAS/AAC services and that she was entitled to one hour weekly of LAS/AAC. However, Respondents assert that a LAS therapist has been identified and that she is presently provided these services at the rate of two hours weekly (one hour of services pursuant to the IEP dated June 5, 2002, and one hour make-up sessions).
(e) Have Respondents provided OT consistent with the requirements of Petitioner’s IEP?
Petitioner asserts that from September 2002 to November 26, 2002, she received one hour weekly of OT. However, Petitioner asserts she was entitled to two hours weekly of OT and, therefore was not provided 13 hours of OT. Respondents do not dispute that they failed to provide Petitioner with 13 hours of OT.
Summary
As to the offer of placement, it has been concluded that it is designed to meet Petitioner’s unique and individual needs and is reasonably calculated to provide her with educational benefit, and conforms with her IEP. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that Respondents offered an appropriate education to Petitioner for the 2002-2003 school year. However, as to the program that has been provided since the beginning of the school year, Respondents failed to provide services that conformed with Petitioner’s IEP as to LAS, aide services, and OT. Respondents also failed to provide teacher services consistent with STUDENT’s right to stay put. Given that STUDENT has been participating in an individualized program at Lincoln, she will require time to transition back into a classroom with other students. Ms. Robbins testified that the District would “support” such a transition plan, although a transition plan is not specifically set forth in STUDENT’s IEP. The Hearing Officer concludes that a plan to transition STUDENT from Lincoln to Ms. Matetick’s class is warranted.
ISSUE NO. 5: If Respondents did not offer Petitioner a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, should they be required to create a placement on an elementary school campus that includes the following: (a) a full-time teacher;
(b) a full-time, trained aide;
(c) a classroom with four similar or higher functioning peers; and (d) at least monthly collaboration between the teacher, aide, and all service providers.
It has been concluded in Issue No. 4 that Respondents offered Petitioner a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year. Therefore, it is unnecessary to address this issue.
ISSUE NO. 6: If Respondents denied Petitioner a FAPE, is she entitled to compensatory educational services?
Parents may be entitled to relief when a school district has failed to provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE). School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 358; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496. Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See, e.g. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.)
Petitioner seeks that the Respondents provide her with the services they failed to provide over the past three years. Petitioner also requests that, in light of the complexity of her program and services and the multiple missed services in the past, Respondents identify a person who would be specifically responsible to monitor the implementation of Petitioner’s program. Respondents assert that STUDENT has benefitted from her education and that she is not entitled to a compensatory remedy.
Throughout the period in question, Respondents have failed to consistently provide OT, PT, and LAS services. (See discussion above.) During some years, STUDENT made progress according to the legal standard set forth in Rowley. However, despite making progress, STUDENT possesses minimal communication and motor skills. In the area of communication, STUDENT has learned to implement the most rudimentary system of communication. She has switches to activate to respond to yes or no questions. To ambulate, she requires a one-to-one adult aide at her side. Even with the aide in close proximity, the maximum number of steps STUDENT takes is slightly over 100.
It has been concluded above that STUDENT benefits from consistency and repetition. Not only is she more alert, she more fully participates. Her current physical therapist testified that STUDENT has shown that she can benefit from an increased level of services. STUDENT now receives three sessions weekly of PT to make up for lost services, and the therapist providing the program stated that STUDENT is doing well. The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT is entitled to compensatory OT, PT, and LAS to the extent Respondents have not previously provided make-up session to compensate for services not previously provided. The services shall be implemented over the course of the extended school year 2003 and the 2003-2004 school year, including the extended school year. STUDENT has shown that she can benefit from three services weekly of OT, PT, and LAS.
ORDER
(1) Within 15 calendar days of the date of this Decision, Respondents shall convene an IEP meeting for the purpose of (a) developing a plan to transition STUDENT to the Parkside SDC/SMH, and (b) determining a schedule for implementing compensatory services so that STUDENT receives all services within one year of the date of this Decision.
(2) The Respondents shall begin providing compensatory services no later than June 9, 2003.
(3) As soon as practicable following implementation of the transition plan, Respondents shall begin transitioning STUDENT to the SDC/SMH class at Parkside Middle School.
(4) All of Petitioner’s other claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
(1) Did Respondents provide Petitioner STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from November 18, 1999, through the end of the 1999-2000 school year including the extended school year (ESY)?(Footnote 15)
Respondents prevailed on this issue except as to the provision of all of the OT services called for by Petitioner’s IEP.
(2) Did Respondents provide Petitioner a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year including the ESY?
Respondents prevailed on this issue except as to the provision of all of the OT and PT services called for by Petitioner’s IEP.
(3) Did Respondents provide Petitioner a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year including the ESY?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
(4) Did Respondents offer Petitioner a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year including the ESY?
Respondents prevailed as to the prospective placement; Petitioner prevailed as to the first three months of the school year and as to the provision of all of the OT, LAS, and aide services called for by the IEP and teacher services required pursuant to stay put.
(5) If Respondents did not offer Petitioner a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, should they be required to create a placement that includes the following: (a) a full-time teacher;
(b) a full-time, trained aide;
(c) a classroom with four similar or higher functioning peers; and (d) at least monthly collaboration between the teacher, aide, and all service providers.
Respondents prevailed on this issue.
(6) If Respondents denied Petitioner a FAPE, is she entitled to compensatory educational services?
Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Dated: May 21, 2003 ________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Officer
1. On February 25, 2003, the parties engaged in settlement discussions, procedural matters were discussed, and issues were clarified. The first witness was called on February 26, 2003. 2. On the first day of hearing, the Hearing Officer denied as premature Respondents’ request to add issues related to whether the nature and/or frequency of some of Petitioner’s services should be changed from direct to consultation, because Respondents had neither proposed such changes at an individualized educational program (IEP) meeting nor requested a hearing to raise the issues. 3. Petitioner alleged there were deficiencies in her education for the entire 1999-2000 school year. However, the issues addressed by this decision are limited to the period falling within the three-year statute of limitations. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(j). The Hearing Office received Petitioner’s request for hearing on November 18, 2002. 4. STUDENT’s communication skills fall between the three- to six-month level and her motor skills fall between six months to one year. 5. STUDENT does not receive services during winter or spring breaks, the week following the regular school year, or the two weeks prior to the start of school in the fall. 6. The PARENTS estimated that STUDENT had up to 12 different aides during the first one and one-half month of school. As to transportation, STUDENT frequently arrived at school one hour or more after school had begun. 7. The District apparently mistakenly believed that STUDENT continued to attend Step-By-Step and did not have her services in place when school began in the fall of 2002. 8. The 1997 reauthorization of the IDEA additionally provides that an appropriate education for a student with a disability shall include access to the general education curriculum as appropriate and instruction and related services designed to prepare the student for employment and independent living. These components of an appropriate education are not at issue in this hearing. 9. Those witnesses include MOTHER, Mitzi Soo, STUDENT’s teacher during the 1997-1998 and 1998-1999 school years; Holly Parry, STUDENT’s teacher from December 1999 through the end of the 2000-2001 school year; and Ruth Johns, STUDENT’s one-to-one aide beginning with the 1996-1997 school year through May 1999. Additional witnesses who have provided services to STUDENT at various times since preschool also testified including Ilene Goldman, VI specialist; Katie Krabbenschmidt, AAC specialist; and Joanne Becker, R.N. 10. Ms. Field does not presently hold a teaching credential in California. 11. The Hearing Officer’s calculation of the number of missed sessions varies slightly from Petitioner’s calculations. The Hearing Officer has taken into consideration MOTHER’s testimony that STUDENT was not entitled to services for six weeks during the year. 12. Ms. Johns was asked to help train Ms. Ash and Ms. Sequeira and, during the course of her training, spent several days in the classroom with STUDENT. 13. Petitioner’s parents have consented to the services offered by Respondents at the IEP meeting in June 2002. Therefore, the appropriateness of the services that were offered will not be addressed by this Decision. However, Petitioner asserts that Respondents have failed to provide some of the services called for by the IEP. Petitioner’s assertions are addressed in the section related to whether the placement conforms with the IEP. 14. The equipment STUDENT currently uses includes mats, a tricycle, peanut ball, large therapy ball, special chair, trampoline, computer, switches, and musical toys. 15. Petitioner alleged there were deficiencies in her education for the entire 1999-2000 school year. However, the issues addressed by this Decision are limited to the period falling within the three-year statute of limitations. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(j). The Hearing Office received Petitioner’s request for hearing on November 18, 2002.
