California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 2, 2005
Student v. Fullerton School District
SEHO Case No. SN 2579-04 · Hearing Officer Deborah M. Cooke
Fullerton School District violated child find from April 2003, but the student was not shown eligible and got no relief.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The student filed against Fullerton School District over his fifth- through seventh-grade years (2001-2004). He was an English learner who had changed schools many times and was never found eligible for special education. He argued he should have qualified with a specific learning disability (SLD) or as other health impaired (OHI) because of attention problems.
For 2001-2002, the Hearing Officer found the District met its child find duty. The mother's verbal remarks to school staff were not a referral. After she signed a referral in April 2002, the District gave her an assessment plan that same day. It held the IEP meeting 48 days after she consented. School psychologist Sue Khalili interpreted the IQ testing properly and confirmed it with a nonverbal IQ test. No speech-language assessment or further attention testing was needed. The scores showed no severe gap between ability and achievement. The mother took a real part in the IEP meeting, and a pre-typed draft was not predetermination.
By April 2003, however, poor grades, low test scores, and ongoing attention and work-completion problems put the District on notice. It never referred him for assessment, which violated child find through 2003-2004. Without new testing, though, the student was not shown to be eligible. The Hearing Officer denied reimbursement for two 2004 private evaluations ($1,200 and $425) and compensatory education. No relief was ordered.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO could find a child find violation yet order no remedy, because the student never proved he was eligible during the disputed years. It also shows that vague, uncorroborated verbal remarks were not treated as a referral, and that a later guardian lacked standing to seek reimbursement for that period.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedChild find
Issue 1A. During 2001-2002, did the District deny FAPE by failing to meet its child find obligations to timely assess Petitioner and convene IEP meetings?
Mother's verbal comments were not a referral; the District gave an assessment plan the same day as the April 25, 2002 written referral and held the IEP meeting 48 days after consent.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 1B. During 2001-2002, did the District deny FAPE by failing to properly and completely assess Petitioner in all areas of suspected disability?
WISC-III was properly interpreted and corroborated by the nonverbal CTONI; speech-language assessment and further attention testing were not warranted.
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 1C. During 2001-2002, did the District deny FAPE by failing to identify Petitioner as eligible under specific learning disability and other health impaired?
No severe ability-achievement discrepancy, difficulties could not be separated from limited English and school changes, and no evidence supported OHI.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1D. During 2001-2002, did the District deny FAPE by failing to allow the parent meaningful participation in the IEP process?
A pre-typed draft IEP was not predetermination; mother actively participated, and notice given at the IEP meeting was sufficient.
- Student prevailed in partChild find
Issue 2A. During 2002-2003, did the District deny FAPE by failing to meet its child find obligations to make a special education referral upon the parent's request?
No parent request was proven, but poor grades, low scores, and attention and work-completion concerns put the District on notice by April 2003; failure to refer violated child find from April 2003 on.
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 2B. During 2002-2003, did the District deny FAPE by failing to identify Petitioner as eligible under specific learning disability and other health impaired?
No standard scores showed a severe discrepancy and no persuasive evidence of an ADD/ADHD diagnosis; eligibility could not be found.
- Student prevailedChild find
Issue 3A. During 2003-2004, did the District deny FAPE by failing to meet its child find obligations to make a special education referral (or assess) upon the parent's request?
No parent request was corroborated, but the District's continued failure to refer the student during 2003-2004 was a continuing child find violation.
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 3B. During 2003-2004, did the District deny FAPE by failing to identify Petitioner as eligible under specific learning disability and other health impaired?
Without new cognitive testing or standard scores, no severe discrepancy was shown, and there was insufficient evidence for OHI.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 4A. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the 2004 assessment completed by Kate Mack in the amount of $1,200?
Denied because the District's 2002 assessment was appropriate, the current guardian lacked standing for the period at issue, and the evaluation was too remote in time.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 4B. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the 2004 assessment completed by the Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center in the amount of $425?
Denied for the same reasons as the Mack evaluation.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 5. Is Petitioner entitled to compensatory education consisting of Lindamood-Bell educational therapy, transportation, tutorial services, and a summer writing course?
Because the student was not found eligible in any year at issue, he was not entitled to compensatory education.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- All of Petitioner's claims for relief were denied.
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist. No. 23; School Committee of Town of Burlington v. Department of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Todd v. Andrews; Cal. Educ. Code § 56337; 5 C.C.R. § 3030(j); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b)
People named in the decision
- Lourene Happoldt, director of student support services, Fullerton School District
- Susan Barnett, educational advocate for Student
- Elizabeth Ellison, fifth-grade teacher, Raymond Elementary School, Fullerton School District
- Sorour (Sue) Khalili, school psychologist, Fullerton School District
- Donnau Maria Cooper, school counselor, Ladera Vista Junior High School, Fullerton School District
- Jackie Morrissey, clinic director, private provider, Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center, Newport Beach
- Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center, private evaluator/provider (independent partial diagnostic evaluation), Newport Beach, California
- Rebecca Von Duering, school psychologist, Capistrano Unified School District
- Kathleen Stuhr Mack, private clinical psychologist; expert witness for Student, Private practice
- Yvette Edwards, sixth-grade teacher, Rolling Hills School, Fullerton School District
- Jamie Locke, seventh-grade transitional English teacher, Fullerton School District
- Andrew Grauer, seventh-grade transitional social studies teacher, Fullerton School District
- Christel Maiwald, resource specialist, Fullerton School District
- Toni Hanson, speech and language pathologist, Fullerton School District
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Fullerton, California, on December 1, 2, 3, 7, and 8, 2004.
STUDENT (hereafter STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented at the hearing by attorney William Marquis. Also present on behalf of Petitioner was his guardian, GUARDIAN; Susan Barnett, educational advocate; and on various days of the hearing, his mother, MOTHER. Fullerton School District (hereafter Fullerton or District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Cynthia Yount of the Parker & Covert law firm. Also present on behalf of the District was Lourene Happoldt, director of student support services for the District.
The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: MOTHER; Elizabeth Ellison, STUDENT’s fifth-grade teacher; Sorour (Sue) Khalili, school psychologist for the District; Donnau Maria Cooper, counselor at LaDera Vista Junior High School in the District; GUARDIAN; Jackie Morrissey, clinic director at the Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center in Newport Beach, California; Rebecca Von Duering, school psychologist for the Capistrano Unified School District; Kathleen Stuhr Mack, private clinical psychologist; and Yvette Edwards, STUDENT’s sixth-grade teacher.
The following witnesses were called by the District: Jamie Locke, STUDENT’s seventh-grade transitional English teacher; Andrew Grauer, STUDENT’s seventh-grade transitional social studies teacher; and Christel Maiwald, resource specialist for the District.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of the parties’ written closing arguments, which were timely postmarked. Following receipt of the parties’ closing arguments, the matter was submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
On November 23, 2004, upon the request of the District, the Hearing Office added Capistrano Unified School District (Capistrano) as a party to this matter; however, Capistrano was not notified of its addition to this matter until November 30, 2004, one day prior to the start of the hearing. Thus, on November 30, 2004, Capistrano submitted a motion to continue the December 1, 2004 hearing date, or in the alternative, to dismiss Capistrano as a party from this action, alleging that the issues presented by Petitioner did not cover a period of time that Petitioner was a resident of Capistrano. The district of residence is generally responsible for providing a special education student with educational services. (Cal. Educ. Code § 48200.) Accordingly, on the first day of hearing, the Hearing Officer addressed Capistrano’s motion and gave each party an opportunity to respond to the question of STUDENT’s residency during the period of time at issue in this matter. Neither party opposed dismissing Capistrano as a party to the action. Since no party had raised any issue against Capistrano and Petitioner was not a resident of Capistrano during the school years in question, the Hearing Officer dismissed Capistrano as a party to this action. Additionally, the Hearing Officer denied Capistrano’s motion to continue the hearing since it was moot. The hearing then proceeded as scheduled.
Next, the Fullerton School District raised questions as to whether GUARDIAN, STUDENT’s current guardian, had legal standing to bring the current action, since there was no court-ordered appointment of GUARDIAN as STUDENT’s legal guardian. Rather, there had only been an assignment of STUDENT’s educational rights to GUARDIAN by STUDENT’s mother.
The Hearing Officer received sworn testimony from MOTHER, STUDENT’s biological mother, regarding the execution of various legal documents authorizing the permanent guardianship of STUDENT to GUARDIAN and the period of time that such guardianship covered. The evidence established that MOTHER was the legal guardian and the holder of STUDENT’s educational rights during the time period in dispute (2001-2002 through 2003-2004 school years). Therefore, this Hearing Officer concluded that MOTHER had standing to exercise STUDENT’s educational rights in these proceedings. Petitioner also requested that GUARDIAN remain listed on the due process hearing request, since she is the current holder of STUDENT’s educational rights and his current legal guardian. This Hearing Officer ruled that GUARDIAN would remain on the Hearing Office’s contact sheet for this matter and would be entitled to receive all information pertaining to this proceeding.
ISSUES
1. During the 2001-2002 school year, did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) by failing to:
A. meet its “child find” obligations to timely assess Petitioner and convene IEP meetings; B. properly and completely assess Petitioner in all areas of suspected disability; C. identify Petitioner as eligible for special education services under the categories of specific learning disability (SLD) and other health impaired (OHI); and D. allow his parent meaningful participation in the IEP process?
2. During the 2002-2003 school year, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to:
A. meet its “child find” obligations to make a special education referral upon the parent’s request; and B. identify Petitioner as eligible for special education services under the categories of specific learning disability and other health impaired?
3. During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to:
A. meet its “child find” obligations to make a special education referral upon the parent’s request; and B. identify Petitioner as eligible for special education services under the categories of specific learning disability and other health impaired?
4. Is Petitioner entitled to the following remedies:
A. reimbursement for the 2004 assessment completed by Kate Mack in the amount of $1,200.00; and B. reimbursement for the 2004 assessment completed by the Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center in the amount of $425.00?
5. Is Petitioner entitled to compensatory education consisting of educational therapy services provided by Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes (LMB) Center, including transportation to and from the LMB Center, educational tutorial services, and a summer writing course?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Petitioner contends that the District violated its mandate under the “child find” statute by failing to timely assess him and convene IEP meetings. Additionally, Petitioner argues that the District failed to properly and completely assess him during the 2001-2002 school year. According to Petitioner, the testing performed by the District was insufficient in that it did not provide a full picture of his deficits and did not assess him in all areas of suspected disability.
Petitioner alleges that when the District did convene the IEP meeting in June 2002, the District improperly failed to find him eligible for special education and related services under the categories of specific learning disability and other health impaired and failed to offer him special education and related services necessary to meet his unique needs. Petitioner also contends that his parent was not allowed meaningful participation in the IEP process.
The District argues that it met its child-find obligations by timely assessing STUDENT and convening an IEP meeting. Regarding assessment, the District contends that it properly assessed Petitioner in all areas of suspected disability. According to the District, the testing it conducted in 2002 corroborates previous testing conducted by the Capistrano Unified School District and supports the conclusions and decisions reached by the IEP team regarding STUDENT’s eligibility and need for services. Moreover, the District argues that the parent never expressed disagreement with its testing and the District never refused any parent request for assessment.
With respect to eligibility, the District contends that Petitioner was not eligible for special education services as a student with a specific learning disability because at no time did there exist a severe discrepancy between STUDENT’s ability and achievement. Moreover, the IEP team could not rule out STUDENT’s limited English proficiency, his unstable home environment, and the numerous school changes as the causes of his difficulties in school. The District also argued that STUDENT’s low grades were primarily the result of his failure to complete homework assignments. According to the District, although STUDENT had some difficulty focusing his attention, he also was not eligible for special education and related services under the category of other health impaired. The District argues that Petitioner’s needs were addressed through the regular education program by the District’s provision of school-based resource specialist program services, his placement in English language development courses, and other interventions.
Lastly, the District argues that the District did not commit any procedural violations regarding the provision of written notice to the parent and did not preclude the parent from participating in the development of the student’s educational program.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a fourteen-year eight-month-old student who currently resides with his guardians, GUARDIANS, in Aliso Viejo, California, and attends school in the Capistrano Unified School District (Capistrano). During the prior three school years (2001-2002 through 2003-2004), STUDENT resided with his natural mother, MOTHER, within the boundaries of the Fullerton School District (District). At the time of the hearing and during the time that he resided in the District, STUDENT was not eligible to receive special education services.
On or about December 1998, STUDENT, along with one of his siblings, was placed as a foster child in the home of GUARDIAN (who was not married at that time). In January 1999, GUARDIAN enrolled STUDENT in Capistrano, where he was placed in a third-grade classroom at Foxborough School and received instruction in English only. According to GUARDIAN, after one week of attending school at Foxborough, STUDENT’s teacher contacted her to ask if she was aware that STUDENT could not read or write. GUARDIAN knew that STUDENT could not read because his sibling had told her that STUDENT had previously received instruction only in Spanish and had never learned to read. According to the home language survey completed by MOTHER at Fullerton, STUDENT learned both Spanish and English when he first began to talk. He used both languages frequently at home, and was spoken equally to in both Spanish and English. The adults in his home often spoke both languages. Up to three years of age, STUDENT’s mother spoke only Spanish to him and he responded to her in English. STUDENT was retained in the third grade, which he repeated during the 1999-2000 school year.
In January 2000, STUDENT was referred by Capistrano’s student study team (SST) for a psychoeducational assessment due to academic concerns regarding his reading, written language, mathematics, social studies, and science concepts. As part of his psychoeducational evaluation, a speech and language evaluation was also conducted by Capistrano’s speech pathologist. On February 2, 2000, an IEP team determined that STUDENT did not qualify for special education services as a student with a specific learning disability. Although he did not qualify for special education, the IEP team developed an elementary intervention plan for STUDENT to address concerns about his progress in the areas of reading and written expression. He was referred to the Capistrano’s after-school tutoring program; however, he never attended the program.
In June 2000, STUDENT returned to live with his natural mother. During the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT was in the fourth grade and attended Francis Scott Key Elementary School in the Anaheim City School District. Comments by STUDENT’s fourth-grade teacher on his report card indicated that during the school year, STUDENT showed an incredible amount of improvement, but needed to work on completing class and homework assignments. STUDENT was assigned to the fifth grade for the 2001-2002 school year.
As evidenced by a report card signed by STUDENT’s fifth-grade teacher on September 26, 2001, STUDENT started the 2001-2002 school year at Francis Scott Key Elementary School. Then, on or about October 16, 2001, STUDENT’s mother enrolled him in the Fullerton School District, where he was placed in Elizabeth Ellison’s regular education fifth-grade class at Raymond Elementary School (Raymond). Based on STUDENT’s November 2001 results on the California English Language Development Test (CELDT) indicating he was an English Language Learner (ELL), STUDENT was placed in the sheltered English immersion program at Raymond, which is a class designed for students who are in the process of acquiring the English language. The sheltered English immersion program provides instruction, textbooks, and instructional materials in English. The program also provides some primary language support to assist students with concept clarification.
According to MOTHER, when she enrolled STUDENT at Raymond, she informed the school that STUDENT needed either an IEP or an SST and that testing and studies had been conducted at his other schools. STUDENT’s fifth-grade teacher at Raymond, Elizabeth Ellison, testified that on or about December 2001, she met with MOTHER, who indicated that she believed STUDENT needed special education or “resource” services. Ms. Ellison informed MOTHER that she was not aware of that need and that she would check STUDENT’s cumulative file once STUDENT’s previous school had forwarded it to Raymond. On a developmental health history form completed on February 26, 2002, MOTHER indicated that STUDENT had previously received special classes or services due to reading problems. According to District school psychologist Sue Khalili and resource specialist Christel Maiwald, an attempt was then made to schedule a school intervention team (SIT) meeting with MOTHER in February and March 2002; however, each time a meeting was scheduled, MOTHER cancelled the meetings.
A SIT meeting was ultimately held at Raymond on April 25, 2002, at which time it was decided that STUDENT would be assessed by the school psychologist, the resource specialist, and the nurse “in order to exclude a learning disability.” Additionally, the SIT decided to provide STUDENT school-based services until the assessment had been completed. Starting immediately after the April 25, 2002 SIT meeting, Ms. Maiwald provided STUDENT instruction and assistance in language arts for thirty minutes each day, four times each week on a “pull-out,” small-group basis. STUDENT also received in-class assistance with math from the instructional assistant four times each week for thirty minutes, and he received English language development instruction for thirty minutes each day.
Once the District completed its assessments, an IEP meeting was held on June 13, 2002. The IEP team concluded that STUDENT did not demonstrate a significant discrepancy between his intellectual ability and measured achievement and therefore determined that special education services were not warranted at that time. The IEP team believed that STUDENT’s needs could be met in the regular education program and offered to provide him school-based resource intervention. By the end of the fifth grade, STUDENT’s teacher noted that he had many areas of need, that school was a struggle for him, and that he needed to do his homework in order to practice the skills being taught each day.
During the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT was in the sixth grade and attended Rolling Hills School in the District. According to STUDENT’s sixth-grade teacher, Yvette Edwards, STUDENT started the school year one or two weeks late. At the beginning of the school year, Ms. Edwards noticed that STUDENT was unable to stay on task, and was easily distracted, very energetic, and always moving around. Because of this behavior, coupled with his below grade level performance on language arts (writing), reading, and math assessments conducted at the beginning of the year, STUDENT was referred to an SIT meeting during the first trimester.
On or about January 16, 2003, an SIT meeting was convened and the test results from the prior year’s assessment done at Raymond and STUDENT’s school history were discussed. The SIT noted that STUDENT had attention deficits and that distractibility was a significant problem at that time in the classroom. The SIT recommended that the parent contact STUDENT’s physician for a medical evaluation for attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and that the school support him in areas requested by the physician. The SIT also developed an action plan to provide STUDENT school-based resource services in reading and writing. A follow-up SIT meeting to review the medical results and evaluation was to occur in March 2003; however, there is no evidence that such a meeting ever occurred.
According to Ms. Edwards, STUDENT received the school-based resource services in reading and writing during the 2002-2003 school year. The services were provided on a “pull-out” basis in a small group for one hour almost every day. STUDENT continued to receive those services until approximately April 2003, when STUDENT’s behavior became too disruptive to the group and he was being continually sent back to class. Ms. Edwards also recommended STUDENT for after-school interventions; however, she did not recall whether his mother gave permission for those services to be provided.
During the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT attended Ladera Vista Junior High School as a seventh-grader. He was placed in transitional English, study skills, and social studies classes. Transitional classes are designed for English language learners, students whose parents have indicated that English is not the student’s primary language, and those who have scored at a certain level on the CELDT test. Transitional classes are designed to provide students with more vocabulary development and focused work on spelling, reading, and comprehension. The instruction is provided in small groups using specialized instructional materials.
According to STUDENT’s seventh-grade social studies teacher, Andrew Grauer, STUDENT had limited participation in class and failed to complete the assignments at the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year. However, Mr. Grauer reported that after October 2003, STUDENT’s behavior significantly improved after he seated STUDENT in front of the classroom closer to his desk where he could more thoroughly monitor his progress. As a result of this modification, STUDENT’s class participation increased and he began to complete more class work.
Notwithstanding STUDENT’s improved behavior, by March 2004, STUDENT’s counselor, Donnau Cooper, forwarded to STUDENT’s parents a letter indicating that STUDENT was performing significantly below grade level in language arts, writing, reading, and math and recommending that STUDENT attend the District’s extended year intervention summer school from July 19, 2004, to August 6, 2004. By the fourth quarter of the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT had a 1.429 grade-point average and had received a grade of F in English, science, and pre-Algebra, a D- in social studies, and a C- in study skills. There was no evidence as to whether STUDENT actually attended summer school in 2004 as recommended by his school counselor.
On or about June 28, 2004, STUDENT returned to live with GUARDIANS, who were appointed by STUDENT’s mother to be his guardians. On July 8, 2004, GUARDIAN obtained an independent partial diagnostic evaluation of STUDENT from the Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center in Newport Beach, California. On September 7 and 16, 2004, at the request of GUARDIAN, Kathleen Stuhr Mack, a private clinical psychologist, conducted an independent brief diagnostic psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT.
At the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year, STUDENT began attending Don Juan Avila Middle School in the Capistrano Unified School District (Capistrano). He is currently placed in a regular education eighth-grade classroom. According to GUARDIAN, STUDENT expresses frustration at not being able to do his homework and it is difficult for him to organize his thoughts and understand his assignments. During this year’s open house at his school, all of STUDENT’s teachers expressed concern that STUDENT was unable to keep up with the class work.
On or about October 2004, STUDENT was referred for a psycho-educational evaluation by the student study team at Capistrano at GUARDIAN’s request that he be tested for special education services. In October and November 2004, Capistrano school psychologist Rebecca von Duering conducted various testing and her findings indicated that STUDENT appeared to be functioning within the average level of cognitive ability and had a processing disorder in the area of attention, specifically related to memory (both auditory and visual). In the area of behavior, Ms. von Duering reported that there were consistent clinically significant findings in the area of attention problems noted in both the home and school environment. STUDENT appeared to be functioning within the average to below-average range of academic ability and, overall, his scores in reading and written expression did not appear to be commensurate with his measured ability level. Ms. von Duering found that there appeared to be a severe discrepancy between STUDENT’s ability level and his academic performance and, therefore, concluded that STUDENT appeared to be a student with a specific learning disability who required special education services. At the time of this hearing, Capistrano’s IEP team had not met to discuss Ms. von Duering’s test results.
On October 20, 2004, the Hearing Office received Petitioner’s request for a due process hearing, alleging that his legal rights under the IDEA had been violated and requesting an award of compensatory education and reimbursement for independent educational evaluations. The matter then proceeded to hearing.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. During the 2001-2002 school year, did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) by failing to:
A. meet its “child find” obligations of timely assessing Petitioner and convening IEP meetings;
B. properly and completely assess Petitioner in all areas of suspected disability; C. identify Petitioner as eligible for special education services under the categories of specific learning disability and other health impaired; and D. allow his parent meaningful participation in the IEP process?
A. Child Find Obligations
Petitioner argues that the District failed to meet its “child find” obligations by failing to timely develop an assessment plan and assess him upon his enrollment in the District in October 2001. Petitioner contends that the District waited until April 25, 2002, to convene a student intervention team (SIT) meeting and draft an assessment plan. The District contends that it satisfied its child find obligations pertaining to STUDENT by timely initiating and conducting an appropriate comprehensive assessment of STUDENT during the 2001-2002 school year.
The federal Individuals with Disabilities in Education Act (IDEA), as amended in 1997, and State law impose upon each school district the duty to actively and systematically identify and assess all children with disabilities who require special education and related services. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(3); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56300, 56301.) Identification procedures must include referrals of students by teachers, parents, agencies, professional persons, and members of the public. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56302.) Once a student is identified and assessed, a district is then required to develop a student’s individualized education program (IEP) in accordance with statutory timelines. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56344.) The obligation set forth in this statutory scheme is often referred to as the “child-find” obligation. (Footnote 1)
On April 25, 2002, the assessment process for STUDENT was initiated during an SIT meeting, which MOTHER attended. Thus, to address Petitioner’s claim regarding the District’s obligation to proceed expeditiously in assessing STUDENT in the fall of 2001, the Hearing Officer must determine whether the District had an obligation to assess him, and if so, at what point during the 2001-2002 school year that obligation arose. All referrals for special education and related services shall be documented and shall initiate the assessment process. (5 C.C.R. § 3021.) Therefore, to initiate the assessment process, a referral must be in writing. However, when a verbal referral is made, staff of the school district, SELPA, or county office are to offer assistance to the individual in putting the request in writing, and are to assist the individual if the assistance offer is accepted. (Id.)
There is no evidence that any of STUDENT’s teachers at Raymond or other District staff referred STUDENT for a special education assessment prior to April 25, 2002. Although MOTHER testified that in October 2001, she told “a lady” in the Raymond school office that STUDENT needed an IEP or an SST (student study team), there is no persuasive evidence that MOTHER made a verbal referral for a special education assessment of STUDENT. MOTHER testified that the lady with whom she spoke in the school office told her that the document she must be referring to was an IEP and that the District “had thirty days to respond.” However, MOTHER did not provide any definitive information about her exchange with the school office personnel. Additionally, in December 2001, during a parent teacher conference with STUDENT’s fifth-grade teacher, Elizabeth Ellison, MOTHER told Ms. Ellison that STUDENT previously received resource specialist services. (Testimony of E. Ellison.) According to Ms. Ellison, after speaking to MOTHER she assumed that STUDENT had an IEP. She communicated this information to District resource specialist Christel Maiwald, who then requested STUDENT’s cumulative file from STUDENT’s prior school district. However, when the District received STUDENT’s cumulative file in February 2002, it indicated that STUDENT was never found eligible for special education. (Testimonies of S. Khalili, E. Ellison, and C. Maiwald.)
The Hearing Officer is not persuaded that MOTHER made a verbal referral for special education services in October or December 2001. Therefore, the District was not required to assist her in completing a written referral at either time or developing an assessment plan.
After receiving STUDENT’s cumulative file from the previous school district and determining that STUDENT had not previously received special education services, the evidence showed that the District quickly attempted to schedule an SIT meeting with MOTHER. The District utilizes the SIT as part of its referral process.
According to school psychologist Sue Khalili and Ms. Ellison, because of their concerns as well as in response to MOTHER’ request to meet and discuss STUDENT’s progress, the District staff attempted on many occasions to contact MOTHER in February and March 2002 to schedule an SIT meeting; however, each time, MOTHER would cancel the meeting, providing numerous excuses as to why she was unable to attend. Petitioner did not refute the facts presented regarding the District’s attempts to schedule an SIT meeting.
The SIT meeting was ultimately conducted on April 25, 2002, at which time a written referral for special education was signed by MOTHER to begin the assessment process. (Dist.’s Exh. 7.) Whenever an assessment for the development of an IEP is to be conducted, the child’s parent shall be given, in writing, a proposed assessment plan within fifteen days of the assessment referral (not counting days between regular sessions or school vacations lasting longer than five days), unless the parent agrees, in writing, to an extension. (Cal. Educ. Code. § 56321(a).) In this case, an assessment plan was created and MOTHER also signed it on April 25, 2002, the same day that the referral was submitted, clearly within fifteen days. (Dist.’s Exh. 8; testimonies of MOTHER and E. Ellison.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided a timely assessment plan to MOTHER on April 25, 2002, the same day of the referral at the SIT meeting and the same day the parent signed the assessment plan.
An assessment must be completed and an IEP developed within 50 days (not counting certain days when regular school is not in session) from the date of receipt of the parent’s written consent for assessment, unless the parent agrees in writing to an extension. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56344.) In this case, STUDENT’s first IEP meeting following his initial assessment was held on June 13, 2002, 48 days after the District received MOTHER’ consent to assess STUDENT. (Dist.’s Exh. 22.) The Hearing Officer concludes that the District timely convened the initial IEP meeting after MOTHER’ signing of the assessment plan. In light of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District met its child find obligations during the 2001-2002 school year.
B. Assessment
After the assessment plan was developed and signed by the parent, the District conducted its multidisciplinary assessment of STUDENT in May and June 2002. Petitioner contends that the District failed to properly conduct intelligence testing and failed to assess him in all areas of suspected disability, specifically in the areas of speech and language and attention. The District contends that the test scores obtained in the course of its assessments were interpreted in accordance with best practices, and that it appropriately assessed STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability.
To be appropriate, the District’s assessment must have met the statutory requirements set forth in Cal. Educ. Code § 56320 et. seq., which provides, in pertinent part:
(a) Testing and assessment materials and procedures used for the purposes of assessment and placement of individuals with exceptional needs are selected and administered so as not to be racially culturally, or sexually discriminatory. (b) Tests and other assessment materials meet all the following requirements: (1) Are provided and administered in the pupil’s primary language or other mode of communication . . . (2) Have been validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. (3) Are administered by trained personnel in conformance with the instructions provided by the producer of the tests and other assessment materials, except that individually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning shall be administered by a credentialed school psychologist (c) Tests and other assessment materials include those tailored to assess specific areas of educational need and not merely those which are designed to provide a single general intelligence quotient. (d) Tests are selected and administered to best ensure that when a test administered to a pupil with impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills produces test results that accurately reflect the pupil’s aptitude, achievement level, or any other factors the test purports to measure and not the pupil’s impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills unless those skills are the factors the test purports to measure. (e) No single procedure is used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for an individual with exceptional needs. (f) The pupil is assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, including low vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional status. A developmental history is obtained, when appropriate. . . .
Petitioner’s allegations regarding the inappropriateness of the District’s assessment are set forth above. As there were no other challenges to the assessment, it is unnecessary to address the remaining requirements of an appropriate assessment. Therefore, the discussion below is limited to Petitioner’s three allegations raised at the hearing and set forth above. Cognitive Testing
Petitioner contends that the District failed to properly administer, score, and interpret test data in determining the discrepancy calculation for the specific learning disability (SLD) eligibility. According to Petitioner, the school psychologist’s averaging of the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children – Third Edition (WISC-III) subtest scores to arrive at an intelligence quotient (IQ) score invalidated the use of WISC-III because such averaging created an untrue picture of his intelligence. Petitioner argues that the District failed to conduct further intelligence testing to find the cause of the scattered WISC-III subtest scores and that the WISC-III was not an appropriate test to use with him because it is biased against children with language difficulties.
The District contends that its school psychologist properly administered the WISC-III and that the test results were interpretable using best practices. The District also contends that it nevertheless also administered a nonverbal IQ test, the Comprehensive Test of Nonverbal Intelligence (CTONI). The District argues that the cognitive tests and achievement test scores demonstrated no significant discrepancy between STUDENT’s cognitive ability and academic achievement and that Petitioner presented no credible evidence to support his argument that the cognitive test scores were interpreted incorrectly.
Private psychologist Kathleen Stuhr Mack, who assessed STUDENT in 2004, testified that given the scatter among STUDENT’s WISC-III verbal subtest scores and the fact that the WISC-III is very language-loaded, his verbal IQ score is not a good average score because it obscures important strengths and weaknesses and, therefore, may lead to a low estimate of STUDENT’s IQ absent further analysis. On this basis, Ms. Mack did not believe that STUDENT’s 2002 WISC-III full-scale IQ score was valid. However, the Hearing Officer notes that Ms. Mack provided no foundation for her opinion about the validity of STUDENT’s IQ scores. Ms. Mack stated that she would have conducted more cognitive testing in 2002 and would have given STUDENT a less language-laden IQ measure, such as the Leiter-R test, and also would have followed up by assessing his attention and his speech and language. (Footnote 2)
Ms. Khalili conducted cognitive testing of STUDENT in 2002 using the WISC-III, which measures how a student processes verbal and nonverbal information, and the CTONI, a nonverbal test. Ms. Khalili testified that she was trained during her graduate studies to use Alan Kaufman’s seven-step strategy to interpret WISC-III test results. Kaufman’s strategy is based on best practices and is explained in his book, Intelligence Testing with the WISC-III. (Footnote 3) (Testimony of S. Khalili.) According to Ms. Khalili, although there was some scatter among STUDENT’s verbal subtest scores on the WISC-III, all of his WISC-III test scores were still interpretable because there was no significant difference between the average of STUDENT’s subtest scores and any individual subtest score. (Footnote 4) (Dist.’s Exhs. 13 and 14.) Ms. Khalili explained that according to Kaufman’s seven-step method, if there is a difference of seven points or more between any of the examinee’s verbal subtest scores, the examiner cannot interpret the examinee’s test scores. (Footnote 5) Similarly, if there is at least an eight-point difference between any of the examinee’s performance subtest scores on the WISC-III, the IQ cannot be determined.
The evidence indicated that there was no significant difference between STUDENT’s WISC-III individual subtest scaled scores. STUDENT’s WISC-III verbal subtest scores ranged from 4 to 10 and his performance subtest scores ranged from 5 to 10. In addition, there was no significant difference between the average of STUDENT’s verbal (6.5) and performance (8.3) subtest scaled scores and any individual verbal or performance subtest scaled scores. Accordingly, Ms. Khalili testified that although there was some scatter among STUDENT’s verbal and performance WISC-III subtest scores, indicating that he had both weaknesses and strengths in different skill areas, all of his scores on the WISC-III were interpretable based on Kaufman’s seven-step interpretation model. STUDENT’s WISC-III test results indicated a verbal scale IQ of 82, a performance IQ of 87, and a full-scale IQ score of 83.
Ms. Khalili acknowledged that the WISC-III may discriminate against children who have language processing difficulties and that, therefore, even though STUDENT’s WISC-III results were interpretable according to Kaufman’s seven-step interpretation method, Ms. Khalili also administered a second intelligence test, the CTONI, a nonverbal IQ measure. She stated that STUDENT’s nonverbal IQ score on the CTONI was 86, which was consistent with STUDENT’s WISC-III test results. (Dist.’s Exh. 19.) Ms. Khalili testified that she would not have given the WISC-III to STUDENT if English was not his dominant language. (Footnote 6)
After reviewing the District’s test results during her testimony, Ms. Mack acknowledged that there was minimal scatter in the CTONI scores and that she had no concern about the accuracy of the CTONI test results. Ms. Mack still believed, however, that the District’s test results seemed to be a low estimate of STUDENT’s skills.
The Hearing Officer is hesitant to rely on Ms. Mack’s interpretation of the District’s 2002 cognitive testing. On the one hand, she states that her own evaluation was brief and not a “normal comprehensive evaluation” and that additional testing was, and still is, warranted in order to obtain a true picture of STUDENT’s abilities. On the other hand, she seems to believe that she obtained sufficient information from her testing to draw the conclusion that STUDENT’s IQ is “at least in the average range.” Ms. Mack did not testify as to how rendering an opinion as to STUDENT’s intelligence level based on limited information was possible in her case, but allegedly not possible in the District’s case. Because Ms. Mack rendered an opinion on STUDENT’s intelligence level after a less than full evaluation and a recommendation for additional testing, the Hearing Officer finds Ms. Mack’s opinion unpersuasive. Moreover, Ms. Mack’s evaluation was conducted in September 2004, more than two years after the District conducted its assessment.
The Hearing Officer is persuaded that the District conducted an appropriate assessment of STUDENT’s cognitive intelligence in 2002. There is no convincing evidence that the District failed to properly administer, score, or interpret test data in determining STUDENT’s cognitive ability. There also is no convincing evidence that the District failed to administer appropriate cognitive measures or that it needed to conduct further testing to determine his cognitive ability. Furthermore, the evidence persuasively demonstrates that the District assessor, Sue Kahlili, was competent in her respective field and was qualified to test STUDENT in the areas of his suspected disability.
Speech and Language Assessment
Petitioner argues that the District failed to assess him in all areas of suspected disability. Specifically, Petitioner contends that the District failed to refer him for a speech and language assessment even though the need for it was indicated. According to Petitioner, the District’s failure to conduct such an evaluation rendered the IEP team’s special education eligibility decision incomplete and invalid as to his unique educational needs. The District asserts that STUDENT did not require a speech and language assessment because at no time did he demonstrate a speech and language impairment. Moreover, prior testing and teacher reports did not indicate that speech and language was a suspected area of disability for STUDENT and, therefore, additional testing in that area was not warranted in 2002.
Ms. Mack conducted a limited psychological evaluation of STUDENT in September 2004 and concluded that she would have recommended a speech and language evaluation of STUDENT after seeing the scatter of subtest scores on the verbal portion of Ms. Khalili’s 2002 administration of the WISC-III. (Pet.’s Exh. AA-3.) According to Ms. Mack, after she saw STUDENT’s scaled scores of 4 on the WISC-III vocabulary subtest and 7 on the similarities subtest, she wondered about STUDENT’s functional language skills for learning and his receptive and expressive language skills. However, Ms. Mack also testified that she had no impression from STUDENT’s everyday speech that his vocabulary was depressed.
Ms. Khalili testified that although the scatter of STUDENT’s verbal subtest scores on the WISC-III indicated he had weaknesses and strengths in different areas, the scattered scores were not unusual for an individual who spoke English as a second language. Additionally, there was no significant difference between STUDENT’s verbal and performance IQ scores on the WISC-III. Ms. Khalili also noted that STUDENT did not score at or below the seventh percentile for his chronological age or developmental level on any of the standardized tests in morphology, syntax, semantics, or pragmatics that were conducted in 2000 to qualify him for speech and language services at that time. (5 C.C.R. § 3030(c)(4); Dist.’s Exh. 3.) Moreover, she stated that one would not expect STUDENT to score lower on the speech and language test in 2002 after having had two years of instruction in English. (Footnote 7)
Ms. Khalili and Ms. Maiwald were both present and participated at the April 25, 2002 SIT meeting during which the SIT reviewed STUDENT’s 2000 speech and language assessment from Capistrano, his language scores on the SAT-9 test, and teacher reports during that meeting and determined that STUDENT’s language skills had improved. Additionally, the SIT noted that Capistrano had previously concluded that STUDENT did not have a speech and language impairment that qualified him for speech and language services. (Dist.’s Exh. 3.) The District’s speech and language pathologist, Toni Hanson, who has more than twenty-six years of experience and has assessed thousands of students, also attended the SIT meeting and opined that STUDENT’s speech and language was not the cause of his struggles in class. (Testimonies of S. Khalili and C. Maiwald.) According to Ms. Khalili, after the SIT’s review of all available data, no member of that team, including the parent or the District’s speech and language pathologist, requested or recommended a speech and language assessment.
Ms. Mack’s testimony regarding STUDENT’s need for a speech and language assessment was not supported by the evidence and also is not persuasive given the fact that her assessment and review of STUDENT’s needs were limited and performed in 2004, long after the District’s evaluation. In addition, Ms. Mack did not conduct an observation of STUDENT in class or consult with any of STUDENT’s teachers or the District school psychologist who had assessed him. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer puts little weight on Ms. Mack’s testimony and finds that a speech and language assessment of STUDENT was not warranted during the 2001-2002 school year.
The Hearing Officer was persuaded by Ms. Khalili’s credible testimony that as of April 2002, STUDENT had made more than adequate progress in language and that STUDENT’s academic issues were more likely attributed to his being an English-language learner than to speech and language problems. The Hearing Officer also finds significant the fact that STUDENT did not qualify for speech and language services when he was tested by Capistrano in 2000, when he had just begun receiving school instruction in English. Additionally, there was no evidence that speech and language was an area of suspected disability at the time of the 2002 SIT meeting, nor did any member of the SIT request or recommend a speech and language assessment.
Testing of Attentional Issues
With respect to his contention that the District failed to assess him in all areas of suspected disability, Petitioner also argues that the District did not further assess his attentional difficulties to determine his eligibility under the category of other health impaired. Petitioner argues that the District’s school psychologist did not give his mother the Burks’ Behavior Rating Scale or an AD/HD questionnaire to complete. According to Petitioner, had Ms. Khalili completed a comprehensive evaluation, he would have been found eligible under OHI.
The District contends that no further testing of STUDENT’s attentional issues was warranted during the 2001-2002 school year. STUDENT’s teacher testified that his behaviors were within the expected range of his same-age peers, correctable, and situational. Moreover, the school psychologist determined, based on her observations, assessment, and her experience, that STUDENT did not exhibit symptoms associated with ADD or ADHD. The District argues that STUDENT’s attention problems were attributable to his lack of sleep, not eating well, and other adjustment issues resulting from a history of school changes and an unstable home environment.
Ms. Mack opined that given the scatter of STUDENT’s verbal subtest scores on the WISC-III and the results of the Burks’ Behavior Rating Scale, she would have examined his attention more closely and conducted additional testing to determine the types of interventions STUDENT would need. Ms. Mack also testified that she would have referred STUDENT to a child psychologist or pediatrician. The Hearing Officer notes that the District’s assessment did include the type of recommendations suggested by Ms. Mack above, including a referral to individual and family counseling. (Dist.’s Exh. 23, pg. 10.)
The Hearing Officer finds credible the testimony of Ms. Khalili, an experienced school psychologist, that the District’s assessment included a sufficient review of STUDENT’s attention. Ms. Khalili testified that during the April 25, 2002 SIT meeting, no one raised ADD or ADHD as a potential area of disability for STUDENT. Nevertheless, the issue of STUDENT’s attention was considered in the District’s assessment. In examining STUDENT’s attention, the District had STUDENT’s fifth-grade teacher, Elizabeth Ellison, complete the Burks’ Behavior Rating Scale on May 24, 2002. (Pet.’s Exh. AA, pgs. 19-21.) Ms. Ellison was the only individual who reported that STUDENT had poor attention and impulse control, and that he experienced withdrawal. However, Ms. Ellison testified that STUDENT nevertheless had good behavior in class and that he could be redirected when he was not on task or engaging in inappropriate behavior. Additionally, Ms. Khalili spoke with Christel Maiwald, the resource specialist who provided STUDENT school-based services in language arts on a pull-out basis four times each week for thirty minutes from April 26, 2002, through June 2002. Ms. Maiwald testified that while in her class, STUDENT demonstrated good, cooperative behavior, and was not disruptive.
Ms. Khalili also conducted a classroom observation of STUDENT. Ms. Khalili testified that in her classroom observation of STUDENT, she examined STUDENT’s class performance, which included looking at his attention, how he interacted with others, and how he processed information in the classroom. Ms. Khalili testified that she saw some distraction in her observation, but that with teacher prompts, STUDENT was able to get back on task. She also stated that she did not see STUDENT exhibit any impulsive behavior and that his ability to follow directions was appropriate when compared to other students. Moreover, Ms. Khalili stated that as part of her evaluation, she reviewed Capistrano’s 2000 evaluation, and the results of Capistrano’s administration of the SNAP IV Teacher and Parent Rating Scale, which was completed by STUDENT’s teacher. (Dist.’s Exh. 2.) Capistrano had found that its testing did not indicate that STUDENT had significant difficulties with inattention, hyperactivity, or impulsivity.
According to Ms. Khalili, since her classroom observation did not indicate attention problems, and Capistrano’s previous evaluation gave no indication that STUDENT had ADD, she did not pursue additional testing in that area because it was not necessary. Ms. Khalili believed that STUDENT’s lack of sleep and the chaos going on in his home were the reasons for his attention difficulties. Additionally, there was no indication that STUDENT had had attentional problems for at least a six-month period or in more than one setting.
As part of the District’s assessment, information about STUDENT’s behavior was also obtained from STUDENT’s mother. When MOTHER completed the behavioral characteristics section on the District’s development health history form on February 26, 2002, she indicated that STUDENT was happy, aggressive, sensitive, short-tempered, shy, and proud, but she did not mark the section to indicate that STUDENT was impulsive. Nor did she use the space provided on the form to write in any other characteristics that STUDENT may have been exhibiting at home, such as his having poor attention. (Dist.’s Exh. 6.)
Petitioner also argues that the District’s assessment was flawed because the parent was not given the opportunity to complete the Burks’ Behavior Rating Scale. However, Petitioner presents no legal authority for the proposition that the parent must complete the Burks’ Behavior Rating Scale in order for the assessment to be appropriate. The law contemplates and encourages parental input as part of the IEP process to determine whether further assessments may be required and whether any independent evaluations they procured will provide useful information to the IEP team. (See 34 C.F.R. § 300.533.) In the present matter, mother’s completion of the developmental history form in February 2002, and her participation and input at both the SIT meeting in April 2002 and the IEP meeting in June 2002, established that STUDENT’s parent had sufficient opportunity to provide the District any necessary information about STUDENT’s attention and impulse control in the home environment.
The Hearing Officer is not persuaded that attention and impulsivity issues affected STUDENT’s studies such that the District should have conducted further assessment of STUDENT in these areas during the 2001-2002 school year. On the basis of all of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the information available to the District at the time of its assessment did not warrant additional evaluation. The District’s assessment sufficiently examined STUDENT’s attention and impulsivity to determine the relationship of his behavior to his academic and social functioning. The Hearing Officer finds that since there was no evidence that STUDENT had been diagnosed with ADD or ADHD and no evidence of any history of attentional issues across more than one setting or for a prolonged period of time, there was no need for the District to conduct additional testing or observations of STUDENT’s attention beyond what was performed as part of the District’s multidisciplinary assessment.
C. Eligibility Under SLD and OHI
Petitioner contends that during the 2001-2002 school year, the District should have found him eligible to receive special education services under the categories of specific learning disability (SLD) and other health impaired (OHI). The District contends that Petitioner’s educational difficulties were attributed to circumstances other than his being eligible for special education services. Additionally, the District contends that Petitioner provided no credible, verifiable evidence that he has, at any time, been eligible for special education services under any category. The Hearing Officer will address STUDENT’s eligibility under each disability category separately below.
Specific Learning Disability
Petitioner argues that he qualified for special education under the category of specific learning disability and that the assessment conducted by the District as a basis for its eligibility determination was flawed and invalid. According to Petitioner, the manner in which the District interpreted his WISC-III test scores, and the District’s failure to do additional testing after reviewing the WISC-III scores, invalidated the use of the WISC-III as part of the discrepancy analysis. Moreover, Petitioner contends that the District failed to consider other evidence of a severe discrepancy as set forth in 5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(4)(C), such as his percentile scores from testing conducted by the District. Petitioner argues that the District only considered one criteria-the discrepancy analysis using only the standardized test scores.
The District argues that its assessment results did not indicate a significant discrepancy between STUDENT’s ability and achievement or otherwise support a finding of an SLD. The District contends that the assessment test scores were interpreted in accordance with best practices. Additionally, the District contends that the IEP team’s determination of STUDENT’s ineligibility was based upon numerous criteria, including a review of available pupil records (including Capistrano’s 2000 evaluation), standardized cognitive and academic assessment data, information from STUDENT’s teacher, parent-provided information, including a health and development history, and STUDENT’s input. Lastly, the District argues that STUDENT’s difficulties at school were attributable to circumstances other than his being eligible for special education services. Despite his ability to learn and do grade-level activities, STUDENT had limited proficiency in English, he had a great number of living and school changes, and he failed to complete his homework, causing him to receive poor grades. According to the District, STUDENT’s academic problems were adequately addressed through the regular education program, including his placement in the English language learner program and his receipt of school-based resource services. The IDEA defines “specific learning disability” as a “disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or using language, spoken or written, which disorder may manifest itself in imperfect ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell, or do mathematical calculations.” (20 U.S.C. § 1401(26).) California Education Code section 56337 states that the following three requirements must be met in order to satisfy eligibility criteria for a specific learning disability:
(a) A severe discrepancy exists between the intellectual ability and achievement in one or more of the following academic areas: (1) Oral expression;
(2) Listening comprehension;
(3) Written expression;
(4) Basic reading skills;
(5) Reading comprehension;
(6) Mathematics calculation;
(7) Mathematics reasoning.
(b) The discrepancy is due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes and is not the result of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantages.
(c) The discrepancy cannot be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program.
With regard to the first criterion, a severe discrepancy can be established by the following: [F]irst, converting into common standard scores, using a mean of 100 and standard deviation of 15, the achievement test score and the ability test score to be compared; second, computing the difference between these common standard scores; and third, comparing this computed difference to the standard criterion which is the product of 1.5 multiplied by the standard deviation of the distribution of computed differences of students taking these achievement and ability tests.
(5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(4)(A).)
From the calculation of this formula, a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement is found when the difference in standard scores is at least 22.5 points (1.5 multiplied by the standard deviation of 15), adjusted by 4 points, which is one standard error of measurement. (Footnote 8) This computed difference constitutes a severe discrepancy when “such discrepancy is corroborated by other assessment data which may include other tests, scales, instruments and work samples, as appropriate.” (Id.)
As discussed earlier in this Decision, the evidence does not support Petitioner’s claim that the District’s cognitive testing was flawed and invalid. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer is not convinced that the manner in which the District interpreted his WISC-III test scores invalidated the use of the WISC-III as part of the discrepancy analysis. Petitioner’s claim that the District should have conducted additional cognitive testing is also not persuasive because the District administered an additional cognitive measure, the CTONI, which results the Hearing Officer found above to be valid and consistent with the WISC-III findings.
According to Ms. Khalili’s cognitive testing, at the time of the June 2002 IEP meeting, STUDENT’s intellectual functioning based on the WISC-III and the CTONI measured within the low average range, with no significant difference between verbal and nonverbal abilities. (Dist.’s Exh. 23, pg. 6.) Ms. Khalili testified that in determining whether a discrepancy existed based on standardized test scores, the IEP team used STUDENT’s CTONI nonverbal IQ score of 86 and his WISC-III performance IQ score of 87.
The scores obtained from achievement tests administered by District resource specialist Christel Maiwald in June 2002 reflect no discrepancy between STUDENT’s ability and achievement in any of the academic categories set forth in Education Code Section 56337. (See Dist.’s Exhs. 23 and 24.) (Footnote 9) STUDENT’s relevant standard achievement test scores ranged from 70 to 84. STUDENT’s standard score in reading on the WRAT 3 was the lowest relevant score that he received. However, a score of 70 does not indicate a severe discrepancy because the difference between the ability score of 87 and the achievement score of 70 is not at least 22.5 points, even when the difference is adjusted by four common standard score points.
Having found that STUDENT does not exhibit a severe discrepancy based on valid standardized assessments, the Hearing Officer next examines Petitioner’s contention that the IEP team should have considered evidence other than his standardized test scores in determining the existence of a severe discrepancy between his ability and achievement. Specifically, Petitioner argues that the District only considered his standardized test scores in its discrepancy analysis. Petitioner contends that his percentile scores on the District’s administration of the WRAT 3 and WJ-R show a clear discrepancy between his ability and achievement, and that the IEP team had an obligation under the spirit and intent of the statute to investigate and qualify him under 5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(4)(C). (Footnote 10)
The evidence also does not support Petitioner’s contention that the District considered only one criterion in determining whether a discrepancy existed. Ms. Khalili testified persuasively that the IEP team’s determination of STUDENT’s ineligibility was based on the comprehensive assessment data, including the parent-provided information, such as the development history form, information regarding STUDENT’s involvement in the general curriculum provided by his regular education teacher, input from the resource teacher, developmental health history, observations of the student, previous assessments conducted by Capistrano, his cumulative file, and standardized test results.
As to additional information available to the IEP team at the June 2002 IEP meeting, STUDENT’s teacher, Elizabeth Ellison, reported that he was working well below grade level in the areas of math and language arts. In addition, as the school year progressed, STUDENT became more inconsistent in completing his homework. Notwithstanding his poor grades and homework difficulties, however, STUDENT’s teachers indicated that when he put forth the effort and completed his homework, he could follow instructions and complete his work with the support of the school-based resource program, through which STUDENT received daily assistance in language arts and math, and with the small-group assistance he received in the after-school intervention program. (Pet.’s Exh. U-3; testimonies of E. Ellison and C. Maiwald.)
Additionally, Ms. Ellison believed that STUDENT’s significant number of absences from school early in the school year, his coming to school unbathed and unprepared without materials, his numerous school changes, and the definite lack of support at home from his mother contributed a great deal to his academic difficulties and, ultimately, to his declining grades. (Footnote 11)
According to both Ms. Ellison and Christel Maiwald, who provided STUDENT’s school-based resource services, a student’s frequent change in schools negatively affects his/her school performance because he/she is constantly having to adjust to new school procedures, there is no continuation in instruction, and there typically is a delay in working out the details of a new student’s educational program. (Footnote 12)
Both Ms. Khalili and Ms. Maiwald testified that the IEP team determined that it could not rule out the strong indication that STUDENT’s academic problems resulted from his lack of consistent instruction, given the numerous school changes, and his second language issues, given the fact that he did not receive English-only instruction until the third grade. (Footnote 13) According to Ms. Khalili, English language learners do not have the same learning curve as students whose primary language is English. Therefore, the rate of progress of English language learners cannot necessarily be compared to students whose primary language is English and who have received consistent English-only instruction. Nevertheless, although STUDENT did not have English-only instruction until the third grade and had many moves in and out of foster care and different schools, Ms. Khalili opined that STUDENT’s scores on standardized testing done in Capistrano in 2000 and in the District in 2002 were fixed, which meant he made consistent progress without significant regression. (See Dist.’s Exhs. 2 and 24.)
In conclusion, the intellectual and cognitive testing in 2002 established that STUDENT had the ability to learn, and his teachers indicated that he could do the work when he put forth the effort, turned in his homework, and was provided various school-based supports through the regular education program. In reviewing the information noted above, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence here does not demonstrate that a severe discrepancy existed as a result of a basic psychological disorder. (5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(4)(C).) Moreover, the IEP team would have been unable to determine that if a discrepancy existed by standardized scores or other measures, it would not be primarily the result of limited school experience or poor school attendance. (5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(5).)
Other Health Impaired
Petitioner contends that at all times since entering the District, he has met eligibility criteria for special education as OHI because of an attention deficit disorder (ADD). Petitioner argues that sufficient evidence existed during the 2001-2002 school year that attention and impulsivity issues affected his studies such that the District should have assessed him for those issues. According to Petitioner, despite these indications, the IEP team failed to consider qualifying him for special education services under OHI.
The District contends that OHI was not an area of suspected disability during the time Petitioner was enrolled in the District. According to the District, STUDENT’s behaviors were within the expected range of his same-aged peers, correctable, and situational. Additionally, the District argues that STUDENT’s attentional problems were attributable to a lack of sleep, not eating well, and other adjustment issues resulting from his history of school changes and unstable home environment.
To meet federal eligibility criteria for special education as OHI, the student must have “limited strength, vitality or alertness, including a heightened alertness to environmental stimuli, that results in limited alertness with respect to the educational environment,” because of chronic or acute health problems, such as attention deficit disorder or attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, which adversely affects a child’s educational performance. (34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(8).) Under state law, OHI eligibility for special education is set forth at Title 5, California Code of Regulations section 3030(f) as follows:
A pupil has limited strength, vitality or alertness, due to chronic or acute health problems, including but not limited to a heart condition, cancer leukemia, rheumatic fever, chronic kidney disease, cystic fibrosis, severe asthma, epilepsy, lead poisoning, diabetes, tuberculosis and other communicable infections diseases, and hematological disorders such as sickle cell anemia and hemophilia which adversely affects a pupil’s educational performance… such physical disabilities shall not be temporary in nature
OHI eligibility for special education can be established with a diagnosis of ADD if the disorder adversely affects the pupil’s educational performance, the pupil otherwise meets the eligibility requirements for OHI, and because of the disability, the student requires instruction, services, or both, which cannot be met by modification of the regular school program. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56339(a).)
The Hearing Officer already determined that the District did not have to conduct additional testing or observation of STUDENT’s attention beyond what was conducted as part of its 2002 multidisciplinary assessment. Although OHI eligibility for special education can be established with a diagnosis of ADD, Petitioner did not present any persuasive evidence of how he met the eligibility criteria under OHI during the 2001-2002 school year. Petitioner claims that he was medically diagnosed with either ADD or ADHD and briefly took medication for the condition during the 2002-2003 school year. (Testimony of MOTHER.) However, there was no persuasive evidence that he was diagnosed with ADD or ADHD during the 2001-2002 school year. Moreover, Capistrano found through its testing in 2000 that STUDENT had no significant difficulties with inattention, hyperactivity, or impulsivity. (Dist.’s Exh. 2.) Additionally, on the developmental health history form completed by MOTHER in February 2002, she did not indicate that STUDENT was impulsive or that he had poor attention at home. (Dist.’s Exh. 6.)
The Hearing Officer already found above that the District’s assessment sufficiently examined STUDENT’s attention to determine the relationship of his behavior to his academic and social functioning. Moreover, Petitioner presented no convincing evidence of his meeting the eligibility criteria under OHI during the 2001-2002 school year. The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that STUDENT did not meet special education eligibility under the OHI category.
D. Meaningful Participation in IEP Process
Petitioner contends that the District violated his procedural rights that allow his mother to have meaningful participation in the IEP process by failing to provide his mother prior written notice of its decision to deny him eligibility for special education and the District’s basis for that determination. Petitioner also contends that the District failed to conduct the June 2002 IEP meeting in accordance with the law. In this regard, Petitioner argues that the District had already made the decision that he was not eligible for special education services before the IEP team met. Consequently, his mother never had an opportunity to fully discuss his educational status and participate in the decision regarding his receipt of special education. According to Petitioner, the decision of the IEP team was predetermined and the IEP document was pre-typed before the IEP meeting.
The District argues that when the June 13, 2002 IEP team determined that STUDENT was not eligible for special education, there was no change to his educational placement proposed, and therefore, no need to provide the parent with prior written notice of the IEP team’s determination. (34 C.F.R. § 300.503.) Moreover, the District argues that it may give the parent notice at the same time that it requests parental consent, such as at an IEP meeting. (34 C.F.R. § 300.503(a)(2).) Additionally, the District contends that Petitioner presented no credible evidence that any “pre-typed” IEP documentation presented at Petitioner’s IEP team meeting was anything other than a draft, or that the parent, her representative, or any member of the IEP team were precluded from requesting revisions to the draft IEP or presenting suggested documentation themselves.
Parents of children with disabilities are provided procedural protections under the IDEA and federal regulations implementing the IDEA. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; 34 C.F.R. § 300 et seq.) Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the appropriate public education to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. (W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992).) The Supreme Court noted in Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 205-206, 102 S.Ct. 3034, that “Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation” at every step “as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP.” Procedural flaws, however, do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE. (W.G., supra, 960 F.2d at 1484.) Procedural violations which result in a “loss of educational opportunity” or which “seriously infringe the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process clearly result in the denial of a FAPE.” (Id.)
Federal law also requires districts to provide parents with prior written notice a reasonable time before the district proposes or refuses to change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of a student or the provision of a FAPE to a student. (34 C.F.R. § 300.503(a)(1)(i-ii).) However, if the action proposed by the District also requires parental consent, the District may give the parent notice at the same time it requests parent consent. (34 C.F.R. § 300.503(a)(2).) There was no proposal at the June 13, 2002 IEP meeting to change STUDENT’s placement. Rather, the IEP team determined that STUDENT was not eligible for special education services and recommended continuing his placement in the regular education program. (Dist.’s Exh. 22, pg. 9.) Such action could constitute a district’s refusal to change STUDENT’s identification as a regular education student or his placement in the regular education program. However, since the District’s action also required the parent’s consent, the District was not required to provide the parent notice of his ineligibility before the IEP team meeting. Additionally, the IEP team’s rationale for its determination of ineligibility was noted on the IEP document, explaining that STUDENT did not demonstrate a significant discrepancy between his ability and achievement level, and therefore, did not meet title 5 eligibility criteria at that time. (Id.)
The evidence establishes that the determination of STUDENT’s ineligibility was made at a properly noticed and constituted IEP meeting at which his parent was provided procedural safeguards, an opportunity to discuss the issue, and an opportunity to request and obtain a due process hearing. MOTHER attended the IEP meeting and signed the IEP acknowledging her receipt and understanding of her parental rights, her participation in the development of the IEP, and her agreement with the determinations made by the entire IEP team on that date. (Dist.’s Exh. 22.) On page 9 of the IEP document, the initials “AR” appear, indicating the parent’s acknowledgement of her receipt of the parent rights, her agreement with the placement and services, and her receipt of the documentation of eligibility and a copy of the multidisciplinary report. MOTHER testified that although she signed the IEP document, the initials “AR” on the document were not her own.
Ms. Ellison and Ms. Khalili both attended the June 13, 2002 IEP meeting and testified that they witnessed MOTHER both sign and initial the IEP document. Although MOTHER denied the initials as her own, the great weight of the evidence does not support her testimony in this regard. Not only did two credible witnesses testify that they witnessed her signing and initialing the document, but there was no other copy of the IEP document produced that differed in any way from the IEP document offered into evidence by both parties. (See Pet.’s Exh. BB and Dist.’s Exh. 22.)
The evidence also does not support Petitioner’s contention that the eligibility determination was made prior to the IEP meeting without the parent’s participation. Although Ms. Khalili testified that she and Ms. Maiwald discussed their testing results before the June 13, 2002 IEP meeting, findings made by the assessors based on testing results do not constitute the decisions of the IEP team. The IEP documentation was pre-typed before the IEP meeting, as is customarily done in the District; however, the computer was left open at the IEP meeting to make changes to the IEP document. Ms. Maiwald and Ms. Khalili testified that no one in attendance at the IEP meeting asked to make any changes to the draft IEP that were refused by the IEP team. MOTHER did not refute this testimony. In fact, some handwritten changes and additions were made to the IEP document at the meeting. (See Dist.’s Exh. 22, pgs. 1, 2, and 9) Additionally, Ms. Khalili testified that the summary report reviewed at the IEP meeting was considered a draft until it was reviewed at the IEP meeting and all team members were given an opportunity to suggest revisions or provide additional information. (See summary statement at Dist.’s Exh. 23, pg. 1.)
Although there is no indication in the IEP meeting notes that MOTHER disagreed with the District assessors’ findings, MOTHER testified that she disagreed with the District’s testing and their conclusion that STUDENT did not qualify for special education. Her disagreement was partly based on previous testing conducted at other school districts, which she believed indicated that STUDENT had dyslexia and had a learning disability. (Dist.’s Exh. 22) According to MOTHER, the IEP team participants told her that she had to sign the IEP document and, consequently, she felt as though she was frustrating the other IEP team members so she did not pursue the issue any further. The Hearing Officer is reluctant to give great weight to MOTHER’ testimony in this regard. For one, her testimony has proven to be inconsistent. For instance, although MOTHER testified on direct examination that previous testing had shown that STUDENT had a learning disability and was dyslexic, on cross-examination, she changed her testimony to state that there was no testing indicating that he had dyslexia or a learning disability.
In addition, Ms. Khalili, Ms. Maiwald, and Ms. Ellison all stated that MOTHER appeared to understand the discussions of the IEP team and agreed with the conclusions reached by the IEP team. According to Ms. Maiwald and Ms. Khalili, MOTHER did not express any confusion regarding the assessments conducted by the District and she seemed to be knowledgeable as to what was transpiring during the IEP meeting. Ms. Maiwald also testified that MOTHER was an active participant in the IEP meeting who asked many questions and consented to a continuation of the school-based resource services offered to STUDENT.
The Hearing Officer finds no persuasive evidence that the determination regarding STUDENT’s eligibility was unilaterally made without the parent’s participation or consent. Additionally, the Hearing Officer was not persuaded by Petitioner’s contention that his parent was precluded from participating in the development of his educational program. MOTHER was present at the June 13, 2002 IEP meeting at which the District’s assessment reports were reviewed and discussed by all IEP team members. Additionally, the evidence indicates that MOTHER had a meaningful opportunity to ask questions and express her opinions regarding the District assessment results and also to participate in the decision regarding STUDENT’s eligibility for special education. All of the IEP team members agreed that STUDENT had educational difficulties and that he required academic assistance. The IEP team considered the criteria for STUDENT’s qualification for special education services under SLD, but because STUDENT did not qualify, the IEP team, including MOTHER, agreed to provide STUDENT with school-based resource services to address his problem areas. The evidence convincingly demonstrates that MOTHER had “a large measure of participation” in the formulation of STUDENT’s educational program. (Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 205; see also W.G., supra, 960 F.2d 1483.)
2. During the 2002-2003 school year, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to:
A. meet its “child find” obligations to make a special education referral upon the parent’s request; and B. identify Petitioner as eligible for special education services under the categories of specific learning disability and other health impaired?
A. Child Find
Petitioner contends that the District failed to meet its child find obligations during the 2002-2003 school year by not making a special education referral after his mother requested an assessment for special education upon enrolling him at Rolling Hills Elementary School (Rolling Hills) in the District. Additionally, Petitioner argues that even though his teacher, Yvette Edwards, had noticed that he had attention problems and an SIT meeting was held on January 16, 2003, there is no evidence that the District followed up with the SIT’s action plan or referred him for an assessment for special education services as OHI. Petitioner also contends that the District failed to implement the school-based resource services (previously provided during the fifth grade at Raymond) during the first trimester of his sixth-grade year.
The District contends that it did not improperly fail to assess Petitioner during the 2002-2003 school year or in any way fail to respond to a referral for assessment. According to the District, Petitioner failed to provide any credible or reliable evidence to support his allegation that the District failed to respond to his parent’s request to assess, or that his parent even made a request for a special education assessment.
MOTHER testified that when she enrolled STUDENT at Rolling Hills, she told a lady at the school that she was told she needed to inform the school about STUDENT’s “SST.” According to MOTHER, the lady with whom she spoke at Rolling Hills told her that someone would get back to her. MOTHER did not recall with whom she spoke when she initially enrolled STUDENT at Rolling Hills or whether she made any further requests for special education for STUDENT while he attended school there. MOTHER also testified that she spoke with STUDENT’s sixth-grade teacher, Ms. Edwards, about STUDENT’s attention. According to MOTHER, Ms. Edwards suggested that she have STUDENT tested for ADD or ADHD, given his behaviors in class. There is no documentary evidence that a special education assessment was ever requested during the 2002-2003 school year, verbally or in writing.
Ms. Edwards testified that she did not recall contacting the parent to inform her that she thought STUDENT had ADD or ADHD issues, but she did recall that at the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year, she believed STUDENT might have attention issues because of his inability to attend and stay on task, and because he was easily distracted, very energetic, and always moving around. Ms. Edwards attributed STUDENT’s academic weaknesses partially to his inability to attend and stay focused, and also to his erratic home life. Ms. Edwards testified that STUDENT was often disruptive, talking, and roughhousing with the other boys in her class, although she did not consider his behaviors to be atypical compared with other kids the same age. However, because of STUDENT’s behaviors and his below grade level performance on the reading and math assessments conducted by the school at the beginning of the school year, STUDENT was referred to an SIT by school staff within the first trimester of the school year.
An SIT meeting was held on January 16, 2003. Both Ms. Edwards and MOTHER were among the attendees at this meeting. (Dist.’s Exh. 29.) The SIT noted that math and reading were areas of concern for STUDENT and that he did not produce any work in class and did not complete his homework. The test results from the prior year’s assessment conducted at Raymond were discussed by the SIT, as well as STUDENT’s previous school history. Attention deficits were noted and, at that time, distractibility was a significant problem in the classroom for STUDENT. (Id.) The SIT recommended that the parent contact her physician for a medical evaluation of STUDENT for ADHD and stated that the school would provide STUDENT “support where requested by [the] physician.” (Id. at pg. 2.) Additionally, the SIT developed an action plan that included providing STUDENT school-based resource services in reading and writing through a pull-out, small-group program almost everyday for one hour. (Testimony of Y. Edwards.) A follow-up SIT meeting to review the results of the medical evaluation was scheduled for March 2003, and the SIT coordinator and the team itself were responsible for assisting with the follow-up. (Dist.’s Exh. 29.) There was no evidence, however, that the SIT ever reconvened to follow up and determine whether STUDENT had received a medical evaluation for ADD or ADHD.
MOTHER testified that she took STUDENT for a medical evaluation and that he was diagnosed with either ADD or ADHD and placed on medications, which STUDENT took for only a few weeks. (Footnote 14) According to MOTHER, she told Ms. Edwards that she had taken STUDENT to his doctor and thanked her because STUDENT had obtained medication for his ADD or ADHD. Ms. Edwards, however, testified to the contrary, stating that she never received any information that STUDENT had been diagnosed with ADD or ADHD. Ms. Edwards also testified that she did not recall STUDENT ever discussing with her the fact that he had been seen by a medical doctor for ADD or ADHD, and believed she would have remembered such a conversation.
To assist STUDENT with his difficulty in completing his work and staying on task, Ms. Edwards tried simplifying STUDENT’s work and giving him fewer math problems, as well as standing by him or seating him close to her so that she could redirect him. (Testimony of Y. Edwards.) Additionally, school-based resource services were provided to STUDENT; however, those services lasted only until the end of April 2003. STUDENT was precluded from continuing to attend his resource class because he became too disruptive to the group, kept the other students from receiving their lesson, and was continually sent back to his regular class because of his behavior. Ms. Edwards also testified that she recommended that STUDENT attend the after-school intervention program, but she was unaware whether STUDENT actually attended. In spite of Ms. Edwards’ provision of various classroom interventions and the provision of school-based resource services, STUDENT continued to have difficulty staying on task and completing class work.
There was no evidence that the modifications and accommodations employed by Ms. Edwards at the beginning of the school year to monitor STUDENT’s completion of work and his behavior were successful during the remainder of the school year. Moreover, STUDENT was precluded from attending the school-based resource services that were implemented after the first trimester. By the end of the first trimester of the school year, STUDENT had achieved only partial mastery of the standards taught in reading, writing, spelling, and mathematics, and he was at risk of retention. (Pet.’s Exh. DD.) By the end of the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT’s grades had not improved. Moreover, STUDENT’s teacher had reported that he needed to improve his ability to stay on task, use his time effectively, and work independently. (Id.)
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s poor grades and below-grade-level performance on reading and math assessments, coupled with the ongoing concerns regarding his behavior and work completion expressed by his teachers, placed the District on notice by the end of April 2003 that a special education referral was warranted. Having failed to make such a referral, the District failed to meet its child find obligations from April 2003 to the end of the 2002-2003 school year. The potential loss of educational opportunity or prejudice to Petitioner because of the District’s failure to make a special education referral will be addressed below.
B. Eligibility Under SLD and OHI
Specific Learning Disability
Petitioner contends that the District failed to find him eligible under SLD, despite test scores and grades that showed he received no benefit from the limited school-based resource services provided to him for language arts and reading. Regression was evident on standardized assessments. Furthermore, Petitioner argues that there was no analysis of the school-based services to determine whether they were effective and to see if he should be considered for special education at the end of sixth grade.
The District argues that it properly found that STUDENT was not eligible for special education under SLD and that Petitioner failed to present evidence in support of his qualification for special education services during the 2002-2003 school year.
No new cognitive testing was performed during the 2002-2003 school year, and the only evidence of achievement testing was STUDENT’s scores on the California Standards and California Achievement Tests, Sixth Edition taken in the spring of 2003. (Pet.’s Exhs. LL-8 and 9.) The testing results indicated that STUDENT was performing “far below basic” California standards in English-language arts and “below basic” in mathematics. However, since there were no standard scores provided for either test, the Hearing Officer cannot make a determination as to whether a severe discrepancy existed between STUDENT’s intellectual ability and achievement based on the formula using standardized test scores. Although STUDENT’s sixth-grade report card indicated that by the second trimester he was struggling with his academics, making minimal effort to improve his school work, and failing to turn in his homework, there was no evidence of standardized test scores demonstrating a severe discrepancy between his ability and achievement, which is the legal standard required by law. Therefore, during the 2002-2003 school year, there was insufficient evidence to find that STUDENT was eligible as a student with a specific learning disability.
Other Health Impaired
Petitioner contends that despite having been diagnosed by a doctor as having ADHD, the District failed to qualify him for special education services under the category of OHI.
The District argues that Petitioner failed to provide any reliable or credible evidence that he has ever been diagnosed with ADD or ADHD or that he was prescribed any medication for any such diagnosis. The District also contends that the reliable witness testimony of STUDENT’s teacher, Yvette Edwards, indicates that although attention issues were of concern, STUDENT’s behaviors were not atypical of sixth-grade boys.
The Hearing Officer already found above that there was persuasive evidence that the District had an obligation to make a special education referral by the end of April 2003 due to STUDENT’s reported attention issues in the classroom and academic difficulties. However, because no new assessment was conducted and there exists no persuasive evidence that STUDENT was diagnosed with ADD or ADHD, the Hearing Office cannot reach a conclusion as to whether STUDENT was eligible as OHI during the 2002-2003 school year.
3. During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to:
A. meet its “child find” obligations to conduct an assessment of Petitioner upon the parent’s request; and B. identify Petitioner as eligible for special education services under the categories of specific learning disability and other health impaired?
A. Child Find
Petitioner argues that his parent verbally requested that he be assessed at La Dera Vista Junior High School (La Dera Vista), but he was never tested. Petitioner also argues that even though his teacher, Mr. Grauer, testified that he noticed an attentional deficit in STUDENT’s inability to complete assignments, Mr. Grauer did not refer him for possible assessment of that issue.
According to the District, Petitioner failed to provide reliable or credible evidence that the parent ever made any verbal or written request for a special education assessment of STUDENT while he was enrolled at La Dera Vista. The District contends that it did not improperly fail to assess the Student during the 2003-2004 school year or in any way fail to respond to a referral for assessment.
MOTHER testified that she told “a lady” at La Dera Vista that STUDENT needed an IEP. MOTHER also stated that she told STUDENT’s counselor, Donnau Cooper, throughout the school year that STUDENT needed to be tested. According to MOTHER, Ms. Cooper provided her a packet of information, which she completed and returned to the school; however, STUDENT was never tested during the 2003-2004 school year. MOTHER could not provide any details as to whom she spoke with at La Dera Vista or the specific nature of that conversation. She also could not indicate whether the papers that Ms. Cooper allegedly provided to her were papers for a special education referral.
Ms. Cooper testified that she did not recall MOTHER asking her about a special education assessment for STUDENT. However, Ms. Cooper did recall meeting with MOTHER about another of her children, and according to Ms. Cooper, during those meetings, MOTHER did not make any requests regarding STUDENT. Ms. Cooper testified that if a parent asks her for a special education assessment, her practice is to have the parent complete a student intervention referral form and a parent and student questionnaire. Once the parent turns in those forms, she then sets up an SIT meeting that includes the student’s teacher, a school psychologist, and administrator, who will discuss and review recommendations for the student. According to Ms. Cooper, once the SIT meeting is held, information generated by the team is placed in the student’s cumulative file. Neither party provided any documentary evidence indicating that a special education referral had been made during the 2003-2004 school year and no other witnesses testified that MOTHER had talked to them about assessing STUDENT.
The Hearing Officer finds there was no convincing evidence that STUDENT’s parent made a referral for special education, either verbally or in writing, during the 2003-2004 school year to which the District failed to respond. Although MOTHER testified that she spoke with a lady at the school and that she asked STUDENT’s counselor about assessing him, the evidence does not corroborate her testimony. MOTHER also had difficulty remembering specifically with whom she spoke and time frames during which she may have had certain conversations. Understandably, it is difficult to remember the specifics of conversations presumably held more than one year ago; however, the Hearing Officer is hesitant to rely upon a witness’s unspecific and uncertain statements that have no corroborating proof.
The Hearing Officer next determines whether the District otherwise had an obligation to refer STUDENT for a special education assessment during the 2003-2004 school year. The evidence indicated that many of the behaviors and academic difficulties that STUDENT experienced during the 2002-2003 school year continued into the 2003-2004 school year. STUDENT’s seventh-grade teacher, Andrew Grauer, testified that STUDENT was unorganized, lacked the ability to focus or maintain his attention, and had difficulty completing his class work and homework. According to Mr. Grauer, STUDENT’s behaviors worsened towards the end of the school year, and by the fourth quarter, STUDENT’s grades in academic subjects were predominantly below average. STUDENT received an F in English, science, and pre-algebra concepts, a D- in social studies, and a C- in study skills. (Pet.’s Exh. HH.)
The Hearing Officer concluded above that as of April 2003, there was sufficient information available to the District to put it on notice that a special education referral was warranted. The District took no action during the 2002-2003 school year, and its failure to refer STUDENT for a special education assessment during the 2003-2004 school year constituted a continuing child find violation. The potential loss of educational opportunity or prejudice to STUDENT because of the District’s failure to make a special education referral will be addressed below.
B. Eligibility Under SLD and OHI
Specific Learning Disability
Petitioner argues that he had a language-based learning disability, as evidenced by his inability to write down answers on paper even when he knew the answers. Petitioner claims that he made no meaningful progress in the seventh grade and received no educational benefit.
The District argues that it properly found that STUDENT was not eligible for special education under SLD. The District contends that Petitioner failed to present evidence in support of his qualification for special education services during the 2003-2004 school year.
Again, there was no new cognitive testing during the 2003-2004 school year and the achievement test scores were not in the form of common standard scores, using a mean of 100 and a standard deviation of 15. Therefore, the achievement test scores that were obtained during the 2003-2004 school year could not be compared to his previous cognitive test scores to determine whether a severe discrepancy existed.
In addition, although his scores were significantly below grade level, STUDENT showed marked improvement on his achievement testing conducted during the 2003-2004 school year. STUDENT’s percentile rank on the California Achievement Test 6 indicated a substantial increase from his spring 2003 testing. His reading percentile rank went from a 12 in 2003, to a 24 in the spring of 2004; his language percentile rank went from a 1 in 2003, to a 30 in 2004; his math rank went from a 2 in 2003, to a 30 in 2004; and his spelling percentile rank went from a 1 in 2003, to a 29 in 2004. (Pet.’s Exh. LL-13.)
STUDENT’s scaled scores on the California Standards Tests indicated an increase in language arts, with a score of 293 in the spring of 2004, up from 229 in 2003. His math scaled score, however, dipped to 229, compared to his score of 288 in the spring of 2003. Additionally, STUDENT scored significantly below grade level on the District’s math assessment conducted in the spring of 2004. (Pet.’s Exhs. FF and LL-13.) Notwithstanding the test scores that were submitted into evidence, however, the Hearing Officer cannot conclude that a severe discrepancy existed between STUDENT’s intellectual ability and achievement based on the formula using standardized test scores. Since there was no evidence of standardized test scores demonstrating a severe discrepancy between his ability and achievement, which is the legal standard required by law, the Hearing Officer finds that during the 2002-2003 school year, there is insufficient evidence to conclude that STUDENT had a specific learning disability.
Other Health Impaired
Although Petitioner argued that he was qualified for special education as OHI during the 2003-2004 school year, he did not present sufficient evidence that he met the criteria for eligibility under OHI. Rather, Petitioner’s argument focuses on the allegation that his teacher, Andrew Grauer, noticed an attention deficit in his ability to complete assignments, and therefore should have referred him for a special education assessment.
Having failed to present sufficient evidence that he had limited strength, vitality or alertness, due to chronic or acute health problems, the Hearing Officer cannot conclude that STUDENT should have been found eligible for special education services as OHI. (34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(8); 5 C.C.R. § 3030(f).)
4. Is Petitioner entitled to the following remedies:
A. reimbursement for the 2004 assessment completed by Kate Mack in the amount of $1,200.00; and B. reimbursement for the 2004 assessment completed by the Lindamood Bell Learning Processes Center in the amount of $425.00?
California Education Code Section 56329(b) provides that a parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation from a qualified specialist at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment conducted by the educational agency. However, if the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent evaluation. (Id.)
As to the specific concerns raised by Petitioner, the Hearing Officer found above that the District’s 2002 multidisciplinary assessment was appropriate and complied with the law. Specifically, the Hearing Officer found that the District properly administered, scored, and interpreted appropriate cognitive measures, that a speech and language assessment was not warranted, that the District sufficiently examined STUDENT’s attention and impulsivity, and that the District’s assessors were competent in their respective fields and qualified to test STUDENT in his suspected areas of disability. However, the Hearing Officer also found that as of April 2003, the District had an obligation to refer STUDENT for a special education assessment and failed to do so. Notwithstanding that failure, Petitioner’s request for reimbursement is barred because reimbursement is being sought by Petitioner’s current guardian, GUARDIAN, who does not have standing to bring claims for the time period at issue in this hearing.
When the Hearing Officer ruled at hearing that MOTHER had standing to exercise STUDENT’s educational rights in these proceedings, the Hearing Officer was not aware that STUDENT’s current guardian, GUARDIAN, and not his parent, was the one requesting reimbursement for the independent evaluations. The Hearing Officer later learned through testimony provided at hearing that GUARDIAN obtained the LMB and Mack assessments. However, as indicated above, GUARDIAN does not have standing to bring a claim for reimbursement because she did not hold STUDENT’s educational rights during the time period at issue in this matter.
Additionally, the independent evaluations occurred over two years after the District’s June 2002 assessment–a period of time that the Hearing Officer finds too detached from and unrelated to the District assessment conducted in 2002. By the time GUARDIAN obtained the private evaluations during the summer and fall of 2004, STUDENT had already left the District and was no longer living with his natural mother, MOTHER. He had returned to live with GUARDIAN again as of June 2004. (Testimony of GUARDIAN.)
Since the Hearing Officer determined above that the District’s 2002 assessment was appropriate and since GUARDIAN is not eligible to bring this claim, the law does not support reimbursement for these assessments.
5. Is Petitioner entitled to compensatory education consisting of educational therapy services provided by Lindamood Bell Learning Processes (LMB) Center, including transportation to and from the LMB Center, educational tutorial services, and a summer writing course?
Compensatory education may be an appropriate equitable remedy when the responsible educational authority has failed to provide a disabled child with an appropriate education as required by the IDEA. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 358; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496; Todd v. Andrews, 933 F.2d 1576 (11 Cir. 1991).) Because it was found above that STUDENT was not eligible for special education during any of the school years at issue, he was not entitled to special education and related services during that time. Accordingly, STUDENT also is not entitled to compensatory education services.
ORDER
All of Petitioner’s claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement.
1. During the 2001-2002 school year, did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) by failing to:
A. meet its “child find” obligations to timely assess Petitioner and convene IEP meetings; B. properly and completely assess Petitioner in all areas of suspected disability; C. identify Petitioner as eligible for special education services under the categories of specific learning disability and other health impaired; and D. allow the parent meaningful participation in the IEP process?
Respondent prevailed on this issue.
2. During the 2002-2003 school year, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to:
A. meet its “child find” obligations to make a special education referral upon the parent’s request; and B. identify Petitioner as eligible for special education services under the categories of specific learning disability and other health impaired?
Petitioner prevailed on sub-issue (A) and Respondent prevailed on sub-issue B.
3. During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to:
A. meet its “child find” obligations to make a special education referral upon the parent’s request; and B. identify Petitioner as eligible for special education services under the categories of specific learning disability and other health impaired?
Petitioner prevailed on sub-issue (A) and Respondent prevailed on sub-issue B.
4. Is Petitioner entitled to the following remedies:
A. reimbursement for the 2004 assessment completed by Kate Mack in the amount of $1,200.00; and B. reimbursement for the 2004 assessment completed by the Lindamood Bell Learning Processes Center in the amount of $425.00?
Respondent prevailed on this issue.
5. Is Petitioner entitled to compensatory education consisting of educational therapy services provided by Lindamood Bell Learning Processes (LMB) Center, including transportation to and from the LMB Center, educational tutorial services, and a summer writing course?
Respondent prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. (California Education Code § 56505(i).)
Dated: February 2, 2005 __________________________________ Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
It is also referred to as the “search and serve” obligation.
2 Ms. Mack is a psychologist licensed by the State of California. She has a master’s degree in clinical psychology and a Ph.D. in clinical psychology, both from the Fielding Institute in Santa Barbara, California. (Pet.’s Exh. NN.) Ms. Mack testified that she has maintained a private practice since 1999 and that two-thirds of her practice involves psychoeducational assessment of individuals between ages 5 and 22. One-third of her practice involves parent coaching and individual psychotherapy.
3 According to Ms. Khalili, the National Association of School Psychologists also recommends using Kaufman’s seven-step model for interpreting the WISC-III.
4 Ms. Khalili testified that she received a Bachelor of Arts degree from California State University, Fullerton, master’s degrees in both counseling psychology and educational psychology, and has been a school psychologist with the District since 1998. Ms. Khalili has two pupil personnel services credentials – one in school counseling and the other in school psychology. She also is a licensed marriage, family, and child therapist. (Dist.’s Exh. 28.)
5 For instance, on the WISC-III verbal scale, STUDENT received a vocabulary subtest scaled score of 4 and an information subtest scaled score of 10 – a difference of only six points, which is not considered to be statistically significant. (Testimony of S. Khalili; Dist.’s Exh. 23, pg. 5.)
6 The Hearing Officer notes that neither party disputed any of the language dominancy testing results, which indicated English was STUDENT’s dominant language. (See Dist.’s Exh. 10.)
7 STUDENT was instructed in Spanish only during kindergarten and first grade, had some bilingual instruction during second grade, and first began English-only instruction in the third grade. Moreover, MOTHER had reported that Spanish was the home language. (Dist.’s Exh. 6.)
8 An article in the California School Psychologist called into question this practice. “Helm and Johnson, Updated Tables Needed to Determine a Severe Discrepancy Under California’s Title 5 Regulations,” 8 Cal. Sch. Psychologist 19 (1998). According to this article, the formula to determine a severe discrepancy must take into account the correlation between the specific ability and achievement tests used (by computing the correlation coefficient, r) rather than merely calculating simple differences between scores. The authors set forth tables showing standard criterion values for specific cognitive and achievement tests, based upon the correlation between the tests, and give the standard error of measurement to be applied. However, there is no known corroboration of the data, and the utility of the data provided is seriously limited. For example, no information is provided for the WJ-R Broad Written Language score in comparison with a WISC-III IQ score, or for the Stanford-Binet. At the hearing, no evidence was presented which applied the method presented in the above article for the specific tests administered to STUDENT. Moreover, the federal statute and regulation do not require a specific numerical difference between ability and achievement scores to establish a severe discrepancy. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(26); 34 C.F.R. § 300.541.) Therefore, the methods set forth in California Code of Regulations, Title 5, Section 3030(j), including use of the 22.5 point discrepancy, will be applied here.
9 Ms. Maiwald administered three different achievement tests to STUDENT in June 2002: the Wide Range Achievement Test 3 (WRAT 3), the San Diego Quick Assessment, and Woodcock-Johnson Psycho-educational Battery-Revised (WJ-R). STUDENT performed below age and grade level expectations in all areas of the school curriculum. (See Dist.’s Exh. 24.) The San Diego Quick Assessment does not provide standardized test scores, but indicates a student’s independent, instructional, and frustration levels of learning.
10 On the WRAT 3, STUDENT’s reading skills were at the second percentile and his arithmetic skills at the seventh percentile. On the WJ-R, STUDENT’s percentile scores in any of the academic categories set forth in Education Code Section 56337 ranged from the fourth to the nineteenth percentile. (Dist.’s Exh. 24.)
11 STUDENT had 16 absences during the first trimester of his fifth-grade year, and according to Ms. Ellison, those absences were not due to his late enrollment in school. The absences occurred after he started attending Raymond. (Pet.’s Exh. U-3.)
12 According to the documentary evidence and testimony from MOTHER, STUDENT had attended at least six different schools by the time he entered fifth grade at Raymond in the District. (See Pet.’s Exhs. E, J, K, and R.)
13 The summary statement made in the District’s multidisciplinary assessment indicated that the test results may have been impeded by environmental factors and many changes in schools and living environments. (Dist.’s Exh. 23, pg. 1.)
14 According to MOTHER, STUDENT refused to continue taking the medication because it had the effect of making him cry by the end of the school day and his friends would tease him for crying.
