California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 24, 2004
Student v. Anaheim Union High School District
SEHO Case No. SN 2580-03 · Hearing Officer Judith E. Ganz
Anaheim Union High must fund rental car for family outings during residential-placement visits; longer visits and procedural claims denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None stated. The decision mentions an earlier California Department of Education compliance finding (January 21, 2003), an August 2002 mediated agreement, and an earlier due process request that the mother withdrew in April 2003.
Summary
A mother represented her ninth-grade son herself in a due process case against Anaheim Union High School District. The student was eligible for special education under emotional disturbance and specific learning disability. The District had placed him at an out-of-state residential treatment center, first Daystar in Texas and then Devereux Cleo Wallace (DCW) in Colorado Springs. His IEP included District-funded family visits for in-person family therapy. The parties had long disagreed about what a "therapeutic visit" covered and which travel costs the District had to pay.
The Hearing Officer relied on testimony from DCW staff members Jennifer Williams and Andrew Braun. She found that the whole visit, including family outings, served the student's therapy and IEP goals, not just the formal counseling session. Even so, she held that three days and two nights per visit was enough and denied the mother's request for an extra day and night. Because outings are part of the related service, the District must pay for reasonable ground transportation for them. That means a compact rental car with unlimited mileage plus fuel, or a taxi or car service within 20 miles of DCW if a rental is not possible. The mother's same-day trip escorting her son to DCW did not count as one of the six yearly visits. The Hearing Officer rejected the claims about predetermination and the District attorney's presence. The IEP team, including DCW staff, must meet within 20 business days to amend the IEP.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO treated parent visits to an out-of-state residential placement as a related service. The Hearing Officer found that family outings outside formal therapy sessions could serve therapeutic goals, so travel for them had to be free to the parent. The length of each visit still had to be tied to the student's needs.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Is the District required to extend Student's visits with his family for one additional day and night in order for him to benefit from his education?
The whole family visit, including outings, is therapeutic and part of the related service, but a three-day, two-night visit is appropriate; the extra day and night was denied.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. While Student's mother is visiting Student at the RTC, should the costs of ground transportation be at the District's expense?
Because family outings are part of the related service, the District must fund reasonable ground transportation for them: a compact rental car with unlimited mileage and fuel, or a taxi or car service within 20 miles of the facility.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. When Student's mother escorted Student to the new RTC for initial placement, should that be counted as one of the six therapeutic family visits allowed each year?
The same-day escort trip had no family therapy and was not a therapeutic visit, so it does not count toward the six visits; the number of visits depends on the student's needs, not on the parent's conduct.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 4A. Did the District seriously infringe upon the mother's ability to participate in the IEP process by predetermining the duration of visits by the director of student services, who lacks the credentials or knowledge to make this decision?
The school psychologist, not the director, drafted the transportation agreement; drafting documents in advance is allowed, and consulting the director on cost was prudent.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 4B. Did the District seriously infringe upon the mother's ability to participate in the IEP process by including the District's attorney at the IEP meetings?
The signature pages showed that the District's attorney attended none of the IEP meetings where the transportation agreement was discussed.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 20 business days of the decision, the IEP team, including Devereux Cleo Wallace representatives by telephone, must reconvene and amend the IEP as ordered.
- Order to provide or change services. The IEP must define a parent therapeutic visit as a three-day, two-night visit for face-to-face family therapy that may also include excursions with the student. Activities are chosen in consultation with facility staff but may be decided by the student and family. Off-campus visits are at the facility staff's discretion.
- Order to provide or change services. For the entire duration of each visit, the District must reserve and pay for a compact rental car with unlimited mileage for no more than three days, including fuel. If there is a legal impediment to the mother renting a car, the District must pay for a taxi or other car service for family outings within a 20-mile radius of the facility, unless the parties agree otherwise in writing. This is in addition to the ground transportation the District already agreed to fund.
- Order to provide or change services. The student and family are entitled to six therapeutic visits for the November 2003–November 2004 IEP year. The mother's escort trip to the new facility does not count as one of them. The District must implement the amended IEP.
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist. No. 23; Ash v. Lake Oswego School District; Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16; Roland M. v. Concord School Committee
People named in the decision
- Frances Correia, school psychologist, Anaheim Union High School District
- Dr. Michael Shelton, director of special youth services, Anaheim Union High School District
- Andrew Braun, executive director, residential treatment center, Devereux Cleo Wallace
- Jennifer Williams, intake director and supervisor of clinical therapists, residential treatment center, Devereux Cleo Wallace
- Devereux Cleo Wallace (spelled "Devereaux" in decision), out-of-state residential treatment center, Colorado Springs, Colorado
- Daystar, out-of-state residential treatment center (prior placement), Shiloh, Texas
- Ball Junior High School, District school (prior special day class placement), Anaheim Union High School District
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Judith E. Ganz, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Anaheim, California, on February 5-6, 2004. Closing oral arguments were heard by telephone conference on February 9, 2004.
Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by his mother and educational advocate, MOTHER. After each testified, Petitioner’s brother and sister were also present on Petitioner’s behalf on the first day of hearing. Respondent Anaheim Union High School District (Respondent or District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Vivian E. Billups. Also present on behalf of the District was Dr. Michael Shelton, the District’s director of special youth services.
MOTHER questioned the witnesses called on behalf of the District and called the following witnesses: SISTER, STUDENT’s sister; BROTHER, STUDENT’s brother; and herself. STUDENT testified on his own behalf by telephone.
The District questioned the witnesses called on behalf of Student. In addition, the District called the following District employees: Frances Correia, school psychologist; and Dr. Shelton. The District also called two witnesses who testified by telephone from the out-of-State residential treatment center (RTC) where STUDENT is placed: Andrew Braun, executive director; and Jennifer Williams, intake director and supervisor of clinical therapists.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following the parties’ closing arguments, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES (Footnote 1)
Issue No. 1: Is the District required to extend STUDENT’s visits with his family for one additional day and night in order for him to benefit from his education?;
Issue No. 2: While STUDENT’s mother is visiting STUDENT at the RTC, should the costs of ground transportation be at the District’s expense?;
Issue No. 3: When STUDENT’s mother escorted STUDENT to the new RTC for initial placement, should that be counted as one of the six therapeutic family visits allowed each year?;
Issue No. 4: Did the District seriously infringe upon the ability of STUDENT’s mother to participate in the IEP process by: (A) predetermining the duration of visits by the director of student services who lacks the credentials or knowledge to make this decision; and (B) including the District’s attorney at the IEP meetings?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
At hearing, the District’s attorney objected to consideration of Issue No. 2, maintaining that the District did not have adequate notice of the issue. In his request for due process hearing received by the Hearing Office on December 9, 2003, Petitioner included this concern. A prehearing conference had been conducted by telephone by this Hearing Officer where issues for hearing were discussed. A different attorney from the same law firm represented the District. Although the matter set forth in Issue No. 2 was identified as an issue for hearing during the conference, the prehearing conference order inadvertently omitted to list it. At the start of the due process hearing, the Hearing Officer asked both parties if there was any further clarification of the issues. Petitioner reminded the Hearing Officer that Issue No. 2 remained a matter for consideration at this hearing. The Hearing Officer found that the District was fairly apprised of the issue for hearing.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT, who turns fifteen in April, is currently in the ninth grade attending an out-of-State residential treatment facility (RTC) in Colorado Springs, Colorado. STUDENT’s mother, brother and sister reside within the boundaries of the Anaheim Union High School District. STUDENT has been eligible for special education and related services due to an emotional disturbance (ED) and as a student with a specific learning disability (SLD) for many years. (Footnote 2)
STUDENT moved within the boundaries of the District in September 2001. MOTHER brought STUDENT’s previous IEPs to the District and STUDENT was initially placed in a special day class at Ball Junior High School. Although the District advised MOTHER that it could control STUDENT in that environment, MOTHER disagreed with the placement. MOTHER testified that she was called to the school on a daily basis to pick up STUDENT because of his poor behavior. She told the District that STUDENT’s emotional needs were not being met and requested a mental health assessment (AB3632).
In April 2002, the District placed STUDENT at Daystar, a residential treatment facility in Shiloh, Texas. According to the testimony, STUDENT required the restrictive environment of a residential treatment facility to meet his severe social-emotional, behavioral, and academic needs. As part of his program, STUDENT received individual, group, and family counseling services. In addition, the IEP team agreed that some of the family counseling sessions needed to be in-person and that the District would fund these parental visits. The IEP team was unable to agree on the number of parental visits each year or the amount of related costs the District was obligated to fund.
In August 2002, with the assistance of a mediator, the parties reached an agreement concerning parental visitation. The District agreed to fund no more than six parent/student visits for the IEP year (April 17, 2002 through April 17, 2003). The initial placement visit in April 2002 was not counted as one of the six visits. In addition, the District agreed to pay for round-trip airfare as well as round-trip ground transportation from MOTHER’s home to the airport. The visits were to last for three days and two nights. The District also agreed to pay for two nights at a hotel in an amount not to exceed $130.00 and for the reasonable cost of a compact rental car, including gas, for no more than three days per visit. If a car rental was not possible, the District agreed to provide cab vouchers for travel from the airport to either Daystar or the hotel and between Daystar and the hotel. An additional four round-trip cab vouchers were provided “to be used for therapeutic purposes at Parent’s discretion.” A meal allowance was provided as well as a telephone card in the amount of $10.00 each month. (Student Exh. 1.)
On these visits, MOTHER was sometimes accompanied by STUDENT’s sister and brother. MOTHER and STUDENT’s siblings testified that to be on time for the flight schedules arranged by the District, the family had to depart for the airport in the early morning hours. The trip to Texas took several hours and by the time the family arrived for the first day of the visit around four or five o’clock in the afternoon, all were very tired. Typically, on the first day of the visit, the family met with STUDENT’s counselor for two to three hours. On some occasions, MOTHER also met with the counselor alone. On most of the visits, STUDENT was permitted to leave the facility and spend the rest of the visit off-grounds with his family. On the second day of the visit, STUDENT and his mother and siblings discussed what he wanted to do. According to STUDENT’s sister, SISTER, they would sometimes go shopping, go out to eat, or stay at the motel and watch movies or play with Play-Station-2. On the third day, STUDENT would help the family pack and return to the RTC. SISTER and MOTHER testified that there was little time to spend with STUDENT on the last day.
Beginning in September 2002, misunderstandings between MOTHER and the District arose concerning reimbursement for the related costs associated with these parental visits. (District Exh. 7; Student Exh. 4.) On October 17, 2002, MOTHER addressed her concerns to the California Department of Education (CDE). (Student Exh. 2.) On November 18, 2002, the CDE agreed to investigate the matter. (Student Exh. 5.) While the investigation was pending, the parties continued to disagree over ground transportation during the parental visits in Texas and whether costs incurred were reasonable. Because of the remote location, taxicab vouchers became impractical. Dr. Michael Shelton, the District’s director of special youth services, testified that the District arranged for ground transportation to be provided by a limousine service instead. However, there was no financial agreement between the limousine service and the District that limited the amount of time or travel. (Testimony of Shelton, MOTHER; District Exh. 21.) On one occasion in early February 2003, MOTHER took STUDENT to the beach, asked the limousine driver to wait, and incurred a bill of over $1000.00 for the three-day visit. (District Exh. 21.) On one occasion, STUDENT was not permitted to leave the RTC and accompany his family on outings, but MOTHER used the limousine for her own side-trip. Although Dr. Shelton testified that he believed these trips went beyond what had been contemplated by the mediated agreement, the District made these payments.
There were additional disagreements over the meaning and purpose of the parental visits. While the parties agreed that one purpose of the visit was for an in-person family counseling session, there continued to be confusion over whether the outings that occurred during the remainder of the time were for “therapeutic purposes” and whether they should be funded by the District at all. On January 21, 2003, the CDE found that the District was not in compliance regarding its provision of transportation vouchers. By way of corrective action, the CDE ordered the District to convene an IEP meeting “to clarify the four round-trips and four single trips that the District [would] provide for the student’s parent prior to the Complainant’s next visit to Texas.” (Footnote 3) In addition, the CDE ordered the IEP team to clarify “therapeutic purposes.”
The IEP team met in accordance with the CDE directive on February 21, 2003. (District Exh. 17.) The District members of the IEP team proposed a definition of “therapeutic purposes” as “the time the parent spends visiting with the student at the residential treatment facility and/or, when the student is allowed an off-site pass, time spent with the student and parent spend together (sic) at the parent’s hotel or other local destinations (15-45 minutes from Daystar) such as the mall, restaurant, or amusement park.” Clarification of the meaning of round-trip and single trips were suggested and a limit of $320.00 and 8 hours for ground transportation for each visit was imposed. Four round-trips were offered between the airport, hotel and treatment center. MOTHER disagreed with this plan.
The IEP team reconvened on April 17, 2003 to review STUDENT’s progress and to update the mediated transportation agreement that expired on April 17, 2003. Daystar staff and STUDENT participated in the meeting by telephone. According to the meeting notes, STUDENT’s progress was minimal due to his non-compliance, behavioral issues, work refusal, and minimal work. STUDENT’s aggression and therapeutic holds had diminished to one time per week. The IEP team agreed to continue goals and objectives that had been developed in November 2002. After this discussion, the Daystar staff ended their participation in the meeting. The rest of the IEP team discussed the details of the transportation agreement. Attached to the IEP was an interim transportation agreement dated from April 17, 2003 through November 5, 2003, the date of STUDENT’s next annual review. MOTHER agreed to the IEP, including the transportation arrangement, and withdrew her previous request for a due process hearing. For the seven month period, the District agreed to fund three visits, each to last for three days and two nights. The agreement provided that the District would fund round-trip airfare. Ground transportation would be funded by the District in an amount not to exceed $500.00 for each visit. Reimbursement was provided for food and lodging. One of the visits could include STUDENT’s siblings with reimbursement for the associated increase in costs. Home visits were also funded by the District. Finally, the District agreed to provide STUDENT with a $50.00 phone card for communication between STUDENT, his mother and siblings. (District Exh. 22.)
On June 18, 2003, the IEP team held another meeting. MOTHER told the IEP team that STUDENT had been injured by the Daystar staff. According to the IEP notes, the administration at Daystar investigated the complaints and determined that they were unfounded. The Daystar staff reported to the IEP team that the staff member in question would no longer be permitted to work directly with STUDENT. The IEP team recommended that STUDENT remain at Daystar and MOTHER, upon learning of the separation of the staff member from her son, agreed not to unilaterally remove him from the program. (Student Exh. 10.)
At the request of MOTHER, an emergency IEP meeting was convened on October 2, 2003. MOTHER expressed her concerns that STUDENT was not safe at Daystar and that the Daystar staff continued to “put their hands” on STUDENT. (Student Exh. 11.) Because STUDENT was scheduled for a home visit a few days after the meeting, MOTHER asked the IEP team for alternatives to returning him to Daystar. The District agreed to search for a new placement. On the next day, STUDENT flew home for a contemplated four-day visit (October 3, 2003 through October 6, 2003). (Testimony of MOTHER; District Exh. 26.) MOTHER testified that when STUDENT arrived home he had bruises and she did not return STUDENT to Daystar, although it was against medical advice. The IEP team met again on October 15, 2003 and reported that STUDENT had been accepted at two new residential treatment programs. The IEP team and MOTHER agreed that STUDENT should be placed at the Devereaux Cleo Wallace (DCW) residential treatment facility in Colorado Springs, Colorado. The IEP team agreed to continue to provide transportation “as usual,” citing the “prior agreement.” (Footnote 4) The meeting notes indicated that MOTHER would accompany STUDENT to DCW, but that this trip would be considered a visit for the next IEP year. The IEP team postponed STUDENT’s November 5, 2003 annual review to permit the staff at DCW to develop goals and objectives. MOTHER objected to counting her escort of STUDENT to DCW as one of the six visits. (District Exh. 25.)
The IEP team met on November 24, 2003 for the thirty day and annual reviews. Two members of the DCW staff participated in some of the IEP discussion. The IEP team noted that STUDENT continued to need residential placement to meet his academic, behavioral, and emotional concerns. Counseling was offered in the amount of individual sessions once each week, group counseling once each week, and family counseling once each week by telephone. Accommodations for testing included additional time and permission to ask questions. Goals and objectives were provided in reading, mathematics, writing and speaking, compliance with directions and remaining on task. An individualized transition plan (ITP) was included that provided for STUDENT to engage in social settings in the community and to develop life skills. A behavior support plan that targeted physical aggression, not following directions, peer provocation, and verbal disruption was also attached. The IEP noted that STUDENT was taking prescribed psychiatric medications that included Depakote, Trileptal, Geodon, Lexapro and Benadryl as needed. MOTHER agreed with all these components of STUDENT’s educational program. (District Exh. 28.)
A new “transportation agreement” was offered that included the frequency and duration of therapeutic visits and financial arrangements for the related costs of each visit, but MOTHER did not agree to its terms. (District Exh. 28; Student Exh. 12.) On December 4, 2003, the District informed MOTHER that it would not modify the transportation offer. (District Exh. 30.) As a result, on December 9, 2003, MOTHER requested this due process hearing.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue No. 1: Is the District required to extend STUDENT’s visits with his family for one additional day and night in order for him to benefit from his education?
Under both the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE) that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs and prepares them for employment and independent living. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a student at no charge to his or her parent or guardian, meet the standards of the State educational agency, include appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education, and are provided in conformity with the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). Additionally, education includes learning to be successful outside the classroom and incorporates much more than merely traditional academics. Ash v. Lake Oswego School District, 980 F.2d 585, 587 (9th Cir. 1992).
The term “related services,” referred to as designated instruction and services (DIS) in California, means transportation and such developmental, corrective, and other supportive services as may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education, including counseling and guidance. Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(b)(1)(5)(9); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). The list of related services is not exhaustive and may include other developmental, corrective, or supportive services if they are required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3001(z). Special education and related services must be tailored to meet the unique needs of the child with a disability. Polk v. Central Susquehana Intermediate Unit 16, 853 F.2d 171, 173 (3rd Cir. 1988); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(3). The determination of the appropriate counseling services and transportation to implement those services will depend on STUDENT’s unique needs. See, 34 C.F.R. § 300.24.
There is no dispute that STUDENT needs family visits at DCW in order to benefit from his education. The parties disagree over the duration of these visits. The controversy over the duration of visits arises from the long-held difference of opinion what is meant by a therapeutic visit. The Hearing Officer will turn first to the parties’ contentions, will then define a therapeutic visit, and lastly determine the appropriate duration for each visit.
Petitioner contended that: the entire visit, not just the face-to-face family counseling session was necessary to meet STUDENT’s therapeutic needs. Because travel time consumes a significant part of the first and last day of the visit, the family needs an additional day and night to spend adequate time with STUDENT and to meet with STUDENT’s teachers, psychiatrist, and other members of the staff who are only available on weekdays. STUDENT needs longer visits because he has made several suicide gestures in recent months. The District maintained that: the duration of family visits as set out in the November 24, 2003 IEP is appropriate. The District was willing to fund the therapeutic part of the parental visit accomplished during the family counseling session. However, the District was not willing to fund the remainder of the visit, which may include family outings, because it was merely “supplemental” to, but did not serve the therapeutic purpose of the visit. The duration of the visits is appropriate because travel to and from Colorado takes significantly less time than travel to Texas.
Preliminarily, the Hearing Officer notes that the determination of the appropriate duration of a related service such as parental visits must be based upon STUDENT’s unique needs. See, 34 C.F.R. § 300.300. The Hearing Officer finds that the testimony of MOTHER that the DCW staff was excused from participating in that portion of the IEP meeting where the frequency and duration of parental visits was discussed was undisputed. Frances Correia, the District’s school psychologist, and the only District witness who was present at the IEP meeting, conceded that the “details” of the “transportation agreement” were discussed after the DCW staff was excused from the meeting, and only that she could not recall whether DCW staff had any input into the “transportation” discussion. Accordingly, it appears from the available evidence that while the DCW staff provided input to the IEP team regarding STUDENT’s academic and behavioral needs as they related to his goals and objectives, behavior support plan, and need for counseling services, the District failed to include the DCW staff in the determination regarding the frequency and duration of visits. Because the DCW staff had first-hand knowledge of STUDENT and his needs, the District thus erred in the manner in which it came to its conclusion about the duration of visits. However, the evidence at hearing established that the District fulfilled its obligation by offering six parental visits and was correct in its ultimate determination that STUDENT would receive educational benefit from a family visit of three days, and two nights duration. (Footnote 5)
STUDENT’s unique needs with regard to family visits arose from his emotional disturbance and documented behavioral and social-emotional problems. There was no dispute that in order for STUDENT to benefit from his special education at the residential treatment facility, he needed to participate in face-to-face family therapy. However, as noted in the recitation of background facts, the parties have long disagreed over the educational benefit of the remainder of the visit. Frances Correia, the District’s school psychologist testified that in her opinion, the therapeutic visit entails the face-to-face family counseling session that occurs on the first day of the visit. While conceding that the remainder of the visit which was used for family excursions had some value, Ms. Correia opined that the rest of the visit was merely “supplemental” and did not serve a “therapeutic purpose.” According to Ms. Correia, because the family counseling session took place on the first day, the duration of each visit offered by the District was more than generous.
The credible testimony of the staff at DCW established that the entire visit, including events that took place outside the formal therapy session, would provide educational benefit for STUDENT. Jennifer Williams, who is the intake director and direct supervisor of clinicians at DCW and familiar with STUDENT’s mental health services and records, testified that the purpose of the rest of the visit is for the family to work on and practice the issues that were identified during the family counseling session. (Footnote 6) Thus for example, if communication problems were discussed with the counselor, then the family could practice talking about their feelings in a more natural setting outside the facility. In addition, in preparation for the ultimate goal to return home, the family can engage in day-to-day activities such as eating together and practicing hygiene. These experiences can take place on and off the facility’s grounds. Ms. Williams added that to gain the most benefit from family visits, it was preferable to include a weekday so that the parent could meet with the student’s psychiatrist, teachers, and other staff.
Andrew Braun, the executive director of DCW corroborated Ms. Williams’ testimony and explained that the therapeutic visit can be considered more broadly than Ms. Correia’s narrow view. Mr. Braun testified that the time spent between family and child outside of the traditional therapy session may increase the child’s emotional and psychological connection to his family. With regard to determining the duration of family visits, Mr. Braun explained that the question had to be clinically determined and was dependent upon the emotional needs and psychological state of the child at the time of the visit. The child’s clinician would have to decide whether it would be helpful and therapeutic to allow for less supervised activities such as might occur during the family visit.
The Hearing Officer finds from the credible and persuasive testimony of Ms. Williams and Mr. Braun that the entire visit, not just the family counseling session, serves a therapeutic purpose, is designed to meet STUDENT’s behavioral and social-emotional needs and provide him with educational benefit. Ms. Williams, unlike Ms. Correia, had first-hand knowledge of STUDENT’s needs and experience with families visiting their children from out-of-State. In addition, the conclusion that the entire visit enables STUDENT to benefit from his education finds further support in the goals and objectives of STUDENT’s IEP, particularly those geared to preparing him for independent living. Having experiences with his family on outings in the community is consistent with the goal in his IEP to “engage appropriately in a social setting” and to develop life skills that include “day-to-day techniques to make it possible to benefit in an (sic) community atmosphere.” (District Exh. 28.) These outings will help the DCW staff implement STUDENT’s IEP. Finally, the Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT is placed in a restrictive setting far from his family. Providing STUDENT the opportunity to work on therapy issues with his family in more natural settings that approximates a home environment, is consistent with least restrictive environment principles. As STUDENT’s sister SISTER so eloquently testified, the visits with her brother let him know that he has a family waiting for him.
Turning to the duration of the visits, Ms. Williams concluded that the therapeutic purposes of the visit as discussed above could be readily accomplished in a three day visit. In her opinion, a longer visit might disturb the treatment regimen and routine. While unable to provide a magic formula, Mr. Braun testified that typically visits lasted from two to four days, and might be dependent on the distance the family had to travel.
Addressing the concerns of Petitioner, the Hearing Officer finds that while travel to the RTC in Texas consumed a good part of the first and last day of the three day visit, the evidence established that travel to and from Colorado Springs would not curtail time spent with STUDENT to the same extent. Petitioner also asserted that STUDENT needed longer visits because STUDENT has made several suicide gestures since his arrival at DCW. The Hearing Officer is quite concerned about this conduct. (Student Exhs. 21, 22, 25, 27, 29.) STUDENT testified that he needs more visits with his mom to “ help [him] succeeding,” and that he cuts on himself because he “can’t see [his] mom.” However, Ms. Williams testified that in her clinical opinion and knowledge of STUDENT, there was nocorrelation between a visit lasting an additional day and the lessening of STUDENT’s depression. Further, the Hearing Officer observes that MOTHER dropped off STUDENT at DCW in October 2003, and as of the date of the hearing, had not yet gone to visit him. (Footnote 7) While the evidence clearly established that STUDENT missed his mother, Petitioner did not effectively link STUDENT’s needs to a visit of longer duration.
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that the entire visit, not merely the family counseling session, serves a therapeutic purpose and is designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and provide him with educational benefit. The duration of the visit, namely three days and two nights, is appropriate to meet STUDENT’s needs for in-person family counseling and for opportunities to be with his family in more natural settings. In addition, a longer visit might upset rather than enhance his treatment regimen. MOTHER is encouraged to include a weekday in her travel plans so that she can meet with members of STUDENT’s treatment team. This would be especially important at the present time because STUDENT’s clinician has left on medical leave and a new clinician has been assigned to STUDENT’s case. The IEP shall be amended to reflect the changed definition of “therapeutic visit.”
Issue No. 2: While STUDENT’s mother is visiting STUDENT at the RTC, should the costs of ground transportation be at the District’s expense?
This issue was further clarified during the due process hearing. The District has agreed to pay for round-trip ground transportation from the airport to the hotel and/or residential treatment site. The only matter at issue is whether the District should also fund the ground transportation costs associated with family outings.
As discussed above, the Hearing Officer has found that the entirety of the visit, includingfamily outings with STUDENT, is an integral part of the related services that are designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. Accordingly, since both federal and State special education law require that all related services shall be at no cost to the parent, the Hearing Officer finds that the District shall fund the reasonable costs associated with this additional ground transportation.
As set forth in the background facts, the parties have long been unable to resolve what are reasonable transportation costs. The Hearing Officer will provide some guidelines in an effort to avoid further legal proceedings to resolve this limited issue. Because the District has already agreed to fund MOTHER’s travel to and from the local airport and back and forth between the facility and the hotel, it seems practical and reasonable in order to accommodate those needs and the off-campus visits for the District to reserve and pay for a compact rental car with unlimited mileage for three days, including fuel costs. This arrangement obviates the need for cumbersome compilation of receipts for each type of ground transportation trip, and addresses the further concerns of MOTHER that she might be stranded and the District’s complaints of travel beyond that contemplated by the IEP team. However, in the event that there is a legal impediment to MOTHER’s ability to rent a car, the Hearing Officer finds that in addition to the transporation costs already agreed to, the District shall pay for the costs of a taxi or other car service for family outings for the entire duration of each visit.
Mr. Braun testified that DCW is approximately twelve miles from the airport and that within two miles from DCW there are leisure activities and other suitable sources of entertainment for the family to enjoy. In addition, the facility itself is on a one hundred acre campus with additional activities. Ms. Williams testified that while the ultimate decision of what to do and where to go during the visit is left to the family, the treatment team typically recommends a schedule of activities that are consistent with the student’s needs at the time of the visit and which provides predictability to the student. Traveling a long distance for outings is unnecessary to accomplish the therapeutic purpose of the visit as defined above. Staying within a reasonable proximity to the facility has the added benefit of allowing for emergency intervention if needed. As noted above, the Hearing Officer found that providing a rental car with unlimited mileage obviates the need to impose mileage restrictions on travel. However, in the event there is a legal impediment to MOTHER’s ability to rent a car and a taxi or car service is used instead, the Hearing Officer finds that, except with a written agreement between the District and Petitioner otherwise, the family may go on outings within a twenty-mile radius of DCW at District expense. (Footnote 8) The IEP shall be amended to reflect these changes.
Issue No. 3: When STUDENT’s mother escorted STUDENT to the new RTC for initial placement, should that be counted as one of the six therapeutic family visits allowed each year?
Unlike any of the previous agreements concerning the number of parental visits, this offer counted MOTHER’s escort of her son to DCW as one of the six therapeutic visits permitted for the 2003-2004 school year. Ms. Correia testified that in her opinion escorting STUDENT to DCW amounted to a “therapeutic visit.” The District also maintained that because MOTHER unilaterally removed STUDENT from the Texas RTC against medical advice and sought a new placement, the District should not have to fund this additional trip. The Hearing Officer finds that neither of these contentions has merit.
First, there was no dispute that STUDENT was unable to safely travel to Colorado Springs without an escort and that MOTHER could accompany her son at District expense. The undisputed evidence established that when MOTHER brought STUDENT to DCW, she was there for only a few hours, returning to Anaheim on the same evening. During that short time, she met various members of the DCW staff, reviewed STUDENT’s program, and briefly met alone with a counselor. Ms. Correia testified that in her opinion this event amounted to a therapeutic visit because MOTHER’s experience at DCW that day was “very much like a [therapy] session.” However, in justifying the District’s refusal to fund the costs of ground transportation for outings, Ms. Correia plainly testified that parental visits must include face-to-face family counseling sessions in a structured therapy setting in order to qualify as a “therapeutic visit.” There was no dispute that when MOTHER took STUDENT to DCW, no family counseling took place. Based upon this patent inconsistency, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Correia’s opinion was not credible. Ms. Jennifer Williams, called by the District as the only available witness at DCW to describe STUDENT’s needs, persuasively testified that in her opinion dropping off STUDENT at DCW was not a “therapeutic visit.” Finally, the Hearing Officer finds that insofar as the removal of STUDENT from the Texas RTC may have been a unilateral decision by MOTHER, the number of parental visits is not gauged by MOTHER’s conduct, but rather determined by STUDENT’s educational and social-emotional and behavioral needs described above.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s mother’s escort to DCW is not to be counted as one of the six therapeutic visits.
Issue 4: Did the District seriously infringe upon the ability of STUDENT’s mother to participate in the individualized education program (IEP) process by: (A) predetermining the duration of visits by the director of student services who lacks the credentials or knowledge to make this decision; and (B) including the District’s attorney at the IEP meetings?
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175, 205 (1982), the Supreme Court recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. States are required to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each child with a disability receives the FAPE to which he or she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the child’s educational placement. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). Not every procedural flaw constitutes a denial of FAPE, but procedural violations that result in loss of educational opportunity to the child or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process may constitute a denial of FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see also, Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).
Petitioner asserted that the draft transportation agreement at issue in this matter was predetermined and that the IEP team did not consider her opinions. Petitioner argued that the agreement was pretyped by Dr. Shelton, who lacked the credentials to determine the duration of parental visits. According to the credible testimony of Ms. Correia, it was she, not Dr. Shelton, who developed the proposed transportation agreement and who presented it to the IEP team for discussion and approval. There is nothing in federal or State special education law that precludes the drafting of documents in advance. Moreover, insofar as the question of parental visits imposed financial burdens on the District, the Hearing Officer finds that it was prudent for Ms. Correia to discuss the reasonableness of the offer with Dr. Shelton, as the director of student services.
The Hearing Officer finds there is no evidence to support MOTHER’s additional contention that she was unable to effectively participate in the IEP process due to the presence of the District’s attorney. A review of the signature pages of the IEP team meetings where the disputed transportation agreement was discussed (April 17, 2003 through and including November 24, 2003) reveals that the District’s attorney did not attend any of them. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds no merit to either of Petitioner’s procedural violation claims.
ORDER
1. Within twenty business days from the date of this Decision, the IEP team, including representatives from Devereaux Cleo Wallace by telephone, shall reconvene the IEP and amend the IEP as follows:
(A) The definition of “Parent therapeutic visit” to the residential facility shall be amended to read: The definition of the parent therapeutic visit to the residential facility is defined as a three-day two-night visit for the purpose of the parent to participate in face-to-face family therapy and may also include excursions with STUDENT. The choice of activities shall be in consultation with the residential treatment facility staff, but may be determined by STUDENT and his family.
The therapeutic visits may be off-campus, in the discretion of the residential treatment facility staff. The District shall pay for and reserve a compact rental car with unlimited mileage for no more than three days, including the costs of fuel, for the entire duration of each therapeutic visit. In the event there is a legal impediment to MOTHER’s ability to rent a car, the District shall pay for the costs of a taxi or other car service for family outings, in addition to the costs of ground transportation it has already agreed to fund. If a taxi or other car service is used, STUDENT and his family may travel within a twenty-mile radius of DCW, unless the parties agree in writing otherwise;
(B) STUDENT and his family shall be entitled to six therapeutic visits, as defined in (A) for this IEP year (November 2003-November 2004).
2. The District shall implement the amended IEP as set forth in Order No. 1.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code section 56507(d) , the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
Issue No. 1: Is the District required to extend STUDENT’s visits with his family for one additional day and night in order for him to benefit from his education?
The District prevailed on this issue to the extent the duration of each visit is appropriate. Petitioner prevailed to the extent the definition of therapeutic visit is extended to include the entire duration of the visit.
Issue No. 2: While STUDENT’s mother is visiting STUDENT at the RTC, should the costs of ground transportation be at the District’s expense?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 3: When STUDENT’s mother escorted STUDENT to the new RTC for initial placement, should that be counted as one of the six therapeutic family visits allowed each year?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 4: Did the District seriously infringe upon the ability of STUDENT’s mother to participate in the IEP process by: (A) predetermining the duration of visits by the director of student services who lacks the credentials or knowledge to make this decision; and (B) including the District’s attorney at the IEP meetings?
The District prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Dated: February 24, 2004 _________________________________ Judith E. Ganz, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The issues have been reworded and reorganized for purposes of analysis.
2. STUDENT’s eligibility for special education and related services was not an issue at this hearing and there was no testimony on the precise date that STUDENT first became eligible. MOTHER testified that STUDENT, as early as seven years old, made suicide attempts or gestures. When MOTHER first moved to the District in September 2001, she testified that she arrived with IEPs from her previous district of residence. According to the documents provided, STUDENT was first placed by the District in an RTC in Shiloh, Texas beginning in April 2002, apparently as a result of a mental health evaluation (AB3632). (Testimony of MOTHER; Student Exh. 1.)
3. MOTHER testified that she has requested reconsideration of the findings based upon the CDE’s incorrect statement that the mediated agreement provided for an additional four “single” instead of four additional round-trip cab vouchers. To date, MOTHER has not received any notification from the CDE on this matter.
4. School psychologist Frances Correia testified that this referred to the August 2002 mediated agreement.
5. The “transportation agreement” that was attached to the IEP included the frequency and duration of parental visits together with the travel and financial arrangements necessary to implement the visits. The Hearing Officer observes that the merging of the travel details with the provisions regarding therapeutic visits served to cloud, not clarify, the matter. To avoid further disputes, it might be more efficient and practical to discuss the frequency and duration of parental visits with input from the DCW staff as it relates to STUDENT’s needs, separate and apart from the transportation schedules and funding limits.
6. Jennifer Williams was called upon to testify at the last moment because the clinician who provided direct mental health services to STUDENT was on an emergency medical leave, having very recently been diagnosed with a serious medical problem. (Respondent’s List of Potential Witnesses and Declaration of Andrew Braun.) Ms. Williams has a master’s degree in behavior analysis and therapy. She has ten years experience working with children with behavioral difficulties. Ms. Williams had first-hand knowledge of STUDENT in that she admitted him to the facility, discussed STUDENT in monthly treatment plan review meetings with his clinician, and had personal interaction with STUDENT on the unit.
7. MOTHER testified that she thought when she filed for due process “everything stopped.”
8. These guidelines are limited to the present placement and STUDENT’s needs as they have been described at the present time.
