California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 30, 2004
Student v. Glendale Unified School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 2587-04, SN-2587-04 · Hearing Officer Judith E. Ganz
Glendale Unified must phase out in-home DTT gradually, train staff, and make up missed APE and speech sessions.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None stated.
Summary
Both the student and Glendale Unified School District filed for hearing, and the cases were consolidated. The student is a 10-year-old fifth grader eligible for special education under autism and mental retardation (now called intellectual disability). Her 2004-2005 IEP placed her in a special day class at R.D. White Elementary with a 1:1 aide. It also ended the 15 weekly hours of in-home discrete trial training (DTT) that the District had funded under a January 2004 settlement. The Hearing Officer upheld the District's assistive technology, adapted physical education (APE), and psychoeducational assessments. She found the District met its occupational therapy assessment duty because the parents did not make the student available to its qualified assessor. She denied reimbursement for private evaluations by Dr. Christine Davidson and Sharyn Kerr. A late health assessment was a procedural violation that did not deny FAPE. However, the IEP denied FAPE. It lacked a toy play goal, a home-school collaboration system, and services during year-round off-track breaks. It also cut in-home DTT abruptly, even though the new teacher and aide lacked DTT training. The District also delayed APE, speech, and AT services after the parents consented through their attorney's August 31, 2004 letter. The Hearing Officer ordered up to 15 hours a week of in-home DTT during a transition plan and staff DTT training. She also ordered IEP amendments, seven APE and seven speech make-up sessions, and immediate AT devices and training.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled a district's plan to end home-based intensive behavioral services. The Hearing Officer judged the plan by what the district knew when it made the offer. Because new classroom staff were untrained, she required a gradual transition with staff training. The decision also accepted parent consent given through an attorney's letter.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue I-A. Was the District's 2004 triennial assessment appropriate: were the assistive technology and adapted physical education assessments rushed and inappropriate for lacking a parent interview?
No law requires an assessment of a particular length or individual parent interviews; the AT and APE assessments were not rushed and were appropriate.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue I-B. Was the psychoeducational assessment appropriate (Developmental Profile-II norms, Vineland administration, ratio IQ calculation)?
The tests were not discriminatory and were properly administered, and the assessment rightly focused on developmental skills rather than the IQ score, so it was appropriate.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue I-C. Did the District fail to conduct the occupational therapy assessment to which parents consented?
The District met its obligation because it offered a qualified assessor of its choosing, and the parents did not make the student available.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEAssessment
Issue II-A. Did the District deny FAPE by failing to timely conduct assessments (Dr. Glover's behavioral assessment and the health assessment)?
Dr. Glover's assessment was timely under the settlement agreement's timeline waiver; the health assessment was late but caused no lost educational opportunity.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue II-B. Did the District fail to make a clear and coherent program offer?
Differing goal start and end dates and an offer built over three meetings did not make the offer unclear; there was no Union violation.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue II-C. Did the District fail to ensure the presence of all required personnel when the program offer was made?
Each assessor presented results at one of the three meetings, so absences at the final July 15, 2004 meeting did not violate Education Code section 56341(b).
- Student prevailed in partIEP content
Issue II-D. Did the District fail to provide goals and objectives designed to meet the student's unique preacademic/academic, socialization, self-help, and behavioral needs?
The IEP needed a toy play goal; the preacademic, self-help/feeding, and behavioral goals and the behavior support plan were adequate.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue II-E. Did the District fail to continue District-funded in-home discrete trial training (DTT) services?
Ending the 15 weekly hours abruptly denied FAPE because the new teacher and aide lacked DTT training; the services had to continue during a transition plan, not indefinitely.
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue II-F. Did the District fail to develop a system of collaboration between the in-home and school programs?
Leaving out any home-school collaboration system did not meet the student's need to generalize skills across settings.
- Student prevailed in partIEP content
Issue II-G. Did the District fail to provide designated instruction and services and in-home DTT during the off-track periods?
The District failed to show the student would not regress, so the IEP needed two weeks of DIS in each off-track period; the claim for three weeks was denied.
- Student prevailed in partImplementation
Issue II-H. Did the District fail to timely implement consented-to components of the IEP?
Consent was effective August 31, 2004 through counsel's letter; APE, AT devices and training, and speech services were not timely provided, though the SDC placement and aide were.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue III. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for independent educational evaluations they obtained?
The District's assessments were appropriate and Dr. Glover's assessment was timely, so the private evaluations by Ms. Kerr and Dr. Davidson were not reimbursed.
- Student prevailed in partImplementation
Issue IV. If the District denied FAPE during 2004-2005, is the student entitled to compensatory educational services from September 1, 2004 through the date of the Decision?
The Hearing Officer awarded 7 APE sessions, 7 speech sessions, and immediate AT devices and training; additional DTT was denied except under the transition plan.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to provide or change services. Within 20 calendar days, the District must arrange for Pacific Child and Family Associates (or, if it cannot, another certified nonpublic agency or qualified District staff) to provide District-funded in-home DTT, not to exceed 15 hours per week, only until the transition plan is completed.
- Staff training. Within 20 calendar days, the District must develop and implement a training program for the student's teacher and 1:1 aide: 10 hours of didactic DTT training, completed by February 25, 2005, plus regular supervision and feedback resuming March 28, 2005 and continuing through no later than April 29, 2005, with input from the in-home behavioral supervisor.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 20 school days, the IEP team must meet and amend the IEP to add a toy play goal and objective, the training program, a home-school collaboration system (including one visit by the teacher and aide to the home program and a regular communication schedule), and a statement that all DIS will be provided during the remaining 2004-2005 off-track periods.
- Order to provide or change services. The IEP must include a transition plan, completed by April 29, 2005, that gradually reduces District-funded in-home DTT from no more than 15 hours per week while increasing school attendance to 20 hours per week or more. The in-home DTT behavioral supervisor must be on the team, and the team must decide whether DTT is needed during the off-track period.
- Compensatory education. Seven additional adapted physical education sessions and seven additional speech and language sessions, completed by June 29, 2005.
- Order to provide or change services. The District must immediately provide the computer/AT devices named in the IEP and arrange staff training on them, to be completed by 'February 25, 2004' as written (likely intended February 25, 2005).
Key authorities
Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Target Range; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Andress v. Cleveland Indep. Sch. Dist.; Adams v. State of Oregon; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Burlington; Clyde K. v. Puyallup; Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Hoeft v. Tucson Unified School Dist.; Miller v. Fairchild Indus.
People named in the decision
- Timothy R. Walker, Director of special education, Glendale Unified School District
- Michele Yamarone, Case carrier, Glendale Unified School District
- Claudette Machado, Special day class teacher, Glendale Unified School District, R.D. White Elementary
- Lyubov Bouniatian, 1:1 aide, Glendale Unified School District
- Dr. Todd Fine, Coordinator / assistant director of special education, Glendale Unified School District
- Georgia Katelanis, School psychologist (psychoeducational assessor), Glendale Unified School District
- Kimberly Carlson, Speech-language pathologist, Glendale Unified School District
- Dr. Dorie A. Glover, Behaviorist in private practice; behavioral assessor and District witness, Private practice
- Dr. Christine (Chris) Davidson, Licensed educational psychologist; independent evaluator and expert witness for Student, Private practice
- Sharyn Kerr, Clinical director; independent behavioral evaluator and witness for Student, Autism Comprehensive Educational Services (ACES)
- Sally Torrens, In-home DTT supervisor; witness for Student, In-home DTT program
- Dr. B.J. Freeman, Assessor who diagnosed autism, UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute
- Pacific Child and Family Associates (PCFA), Nonpublic agency providing in-home DTT, Nonpublic agency
- Glendale Adventist, Nonpublic agency chosen by District to conduct OT assessment, Nonpublic agency
- Pasadena Child Development Associates, Private OT provider requested by parent, Private provider
- Frank Lanterman Regional Center, Regional center funding in-home DTT, Regional center
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Judith E. Ganz, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Glendale, California, on November 17, 18, 30, and December 1, 2, and 3, 2004.
Petitioner and Cross-Respondent Glendale Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Sherianne Laba. Also present on behalf of the District, except for several hours on November 30, 2004, was Timothy R. Walker, director of special education for the District. Respondent and Cross/Petitioner STUDENT (Student or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Michael Jewell. Also present on behalf of STUDENT was her mother, MOTHER. STUDENT’s father, FATHER, was also present on the first day of hearing on STUDENT’s behalf.
The District called the following District employees as witnesses: Timothy R. Walker, director of special education; Michele Yamarone, STUDENT’s case carrier; Claudette Machado, STUDENT’s special day class teacher; Lyubov Bouniatian, STUDENT’s one-to-one aide; Dr. Todd Fine, coordinator of special education; Georgia Katelanis, school psychologist; and Kimberly Carlson, speech and language pathologist. The District also called Dr. Dorie A. Glover, behaviorist in private practice.
Student called the following witnesses: MOTHER, her mother; Dr. Christine Davidson, licensed educational psychologist; Dr. Sharyn Kerr, clinical director of Autism Comprehensive Educational Services (ACES); and Sally Torrens, her in-home discrete trial training supervisor.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of the parties’ closing written arguments, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
Issue No. I: Was the District’s 2004 triennial assessment of STUDENT appropriate?
Issue No. II: Has the District denied STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) procedurally and substantively for the 2004-2005 regular school year and extended school year by failing to:
A. timely conduct assessments;
B. make a clear and coherent program offer;
C. ensure the presence of all required personnel when the program offer was made;
D. provide goals and objectives designed to meet STUDENT’s unique preacademic/academic, socialization, self-help, and behavioral needs;
E. continue District-funded in-home discrete trial training (DTT) services; F. develop a system of collaboration between STUDENT’s in-home and school programs;
G. provide designated instruction and services and in-home DTT during the off-track periods; and
H. timely implement consented-to components of the IEP?
Issue No. III: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for independent educational evaluations they obtained?
Issue No. IV: If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 2004-2005 school year, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory educational services from September 1, 2004, through the date of this Decision? (Footnote 1)
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The District asserted the following: STUDENT’s 2004 triennial assessment complied with legal requirements. The District remained ready, willing, and able to conduct the occupational therapy assessment but STUDENT’s parents did not make her available. The behavioral assessment conducted by Dr. Dorie Glover was appropriate. Student’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent educational evaluations they obtained. The 2004-2005 individualized education program is both procedurally and substantively an offer of a free appropriate public education and accordingly, Student is not entitled to any compensatory educational services.
Student contended the following: both the assistive technology and adapted physical education assessments were rushed and failed to include a parent interview, the psychoeducational assessment was inappropriate, and an occupational therapy assessment which had been consented to by Student’s mother was not performed. The 2004-2005 individualized education program is procedurally defective because the District failed to conduct timely assessments, failed to make a clear, coherent offer of placement, and failed to ensure the presence of all required personnel when the placement offer was made. Substantively, the educational program offered by the District fails to provide goals and objectives and services designed to meet STUDENT’s academic, social/emotional, self-help, and behavioral needs. The program is defective because it fails to continue District-funded discrete trial training services, to develop a system of collaboration between STUDENT’s home and school programs, and to offer designated instruction and services during the off-track intercession periods. Finally, the District failed to implement consented-to components of the individualized education program and STUDENT is entitled to compensatory educational services.
PROCEDURAL MATTER
District’s Motion to Dismiss Issues.
This consolidated matter convened for hearing on November 17, 2004, at which time the parties’ statements of issues were reviewed and the issues for hearing were further clarified. Following the clarification of issues, the parties engaged in settlement discussions outside the presence of the Hearing Officer. Opening statements and testimony was taken on November 18, 2004, and the matter was continued for good cause until November 30, 2004. On November 29, 2004, the Hearing Office received from the District a written motion to dismiss or strike several of Student’s issues that had been identified for hearing. A clerk of the Hearing Office called Student’s counsel and verified that the motion had been received. Student’s counsel was provided with the opportunity to orally respond to the District’s motion on November 30, 2004.
In its written motion, the District maintained that the parties entered into a settlement agreement on January 31, 2004, that precluded the Student from raising most of the issues Student had identified for hearing. The District maintained that the settlement agreement resolved all the Student’s issues regarding the appropriateness of the District’s assessments that had been conducted in May and June 2004 as well as the provision of a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year. The District also argued that any matters regarding the provision of services before September 1, 2004, namely DTT services or entitlement to compensatory educational services, should also be dismissed. (Footnote 2) During oral argument, the District modified its position and stated that the issues that remained for hearing included whether Student required in-home DTT services to receive educational benefit and whether Dr. Glover’s assessment was appropriate.
Student agreed that pursuant to the parties’ settlement agreement, the effective date for her issues regarding the implementation of the 2004-2005 IEP and an analysis of Student’s entitlement to compensatory educational services is September 1, 2004. However, Student opposed the motion to dismiss. Student asserted that the District had waived its right to seek dismissal of issues at this stage of the proceedings, and that Student’s issues concerning the appropriateness of the District’s assessments and whether the 2004-2005 IEP offered Student a FAPE are not barred by the settlement agreement. (Footnote 3)
The law governing settlement agreements in California is clear. An agreement to settle a legal dispute is a contract and its enforceability is governed by familiar principles of contract law. (Miller v. Fairchild Indus., 797 F.2d 727, 733 (9th Cir. 1986); Village of Kaktovik v. Watt, 233 U.S. App. D.C. 39, 689 F.2d 222, 230 (D.C. Cir. 1982).) By entering into a settlement agreement, each party agrees to “extinguish those legal rights it sought to enforce through litigation in exchange for those rights secured by the contract.” (Village of Kaktovik, 689 F.2d at 230.) A release generally extends to all matters within the parties’ contemplation at the time it is executed. (Chadwick v. Northwest Airlines, Inc., 654 P.2d 1215, 1217 (Wash. App. 1982).) Furthermore, where the language of a contract is clear and not absurd, it will be followed. (Cal. Civil Code § 1638; Apra v. Aureguy, 55 Cal.2d 827, 830 (1961).) Finally, there is a strong public policy interest in enforcing valid settlement agreements. (McDermott Inc. v. AmClyde, 511 U.S. 202, 114 S.Ct. 1461, 1468 (1994); D.R. v. East Brunswick Bd. of Educ., 109 F.3d 896 (3d Cir. 1997).)
After considering the parties’ arguments and reviewing the settlement agreement (District Exh. 3), the Hearing Officer first found that the District had not waived its right to seek dismissal of Student’s issues. The Hearing Officer found that in this particular case the legal effect of the settlement agreement could have been raised at any time by the District as an affirmative defense to the issues identified for hearing, even as late as its closing argument. Further, Student did not assert any harm from the timing of the District’s motion.
Turning to the legal effect of the settlement agreement, the District relied upon the following provision of the settlement agreement in support of its position that Student’s issues for hearing had been resolved:
[para.]w. This agreement resolves any and all issues, known and unknown, within the jurisdiction of the California Special Education Hearing Office, between Student, Parents, and District through and including August 31, 2004. (District Exh. 3.)
A review of the settlement agreement revealed that it was only intended to dispose of issues related to STUDENT’s educational program from February 1, 2004, through August 31, 2004. (District Exh. 3, paras. b, c, d, e, f, g, h, i, and n.) Accordingly, the Hearing Officer found that the settlement agreement reached in January 2004 did not foreclose Student from raising claims regarding procedural defects or loss of educational benefit in an educational program for the 2004-2005 school year which had not yet been developed or implemented by the time of the settlement agreement. (District Exh. 3, para. n.) Regarding the assessment issues, the Hearing Officer found that the settlement agreement only set forth those assessments the parties agreed would be performed. (District Exh. 3, paras. j and k.) The Hearing Officer found that the general agreement to assess did not resolve whether assessments not yet conducted by the time of the settlement agreement comported with legal requirements. Moreover, the District did not effectively explain why, in its opinion, the appropriateness of Dr. Glover’s assessment was still at issue whereas the appropriateness of the assessments performed by District personnel was not. Accordingly, the District’s motion to dismiss or strike Student’s issues was denied.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a ten-year-old fifth-grader. STUDENT was initially found eligible for special education and related services under the category of other health impaired as she suffers from several medical problems including a seizure disorder, hypogenesis of the corpus collosum, scoliosis, a vision impairment (including strabismus, nystagmus, and fluttering eyes), precocious puberty, and gastroesocophageal reflux. In 2001, the District determined that STUDENT is mentally retarded. In 2003, STUDENT underwent further testing at the University of California at Los Angeles (UCLA) and was diagnosed as a child with autism spectrum disorder. In May 2004, the District changed STUDENT’s eligibility category to autism and mental retardation. STUDENT lives with her parents and typically developing twin brother within the boundaries of the District.
When STUDENT was an infant she exhibited feeding and swallowing problems and at one year of age suffered a grand mal seizure. Her developmental milestones were characterized by global delays in motor, speech, social interaction, and cognitive skills. STUDENT first learned to walk when she was six years old and did not speak in short phrases until she was seven.
STUDENT was referred to the Frank Lanterman Regional Center (Regional Center) when she was eighteen months old. The Regional Center provided speech and language therapy (SAL), physical therapy (PT), occupational therapy (OT), floor time therapy, and music therapy until she was three years old. In January 1998, at the age of three, STUDENT was assessed by the District and found eligible for special education and related services under the category of other health impaired. From February 1998 through December 2002, the District funded for STUDENT one-to-one instruction from a nonpublic agency for ten hours each week and individual therapies in PT, OT, and SAL. At her triennial evaluation conducted by the District in April 2001, the District’s school psychologist found STUDENT to be functioning at a one and one-half-year-old to two-year-old level in most areas (academic, socialization, daily living, and communication) and concluded STUDENT is moderately mentally retarded.
STUDENT has exhibited continuous behavior problems including irrational fears, inattention, lack of self-help skills, an inability to develop social relationships, and inappropriate interaction with men or strangers. In December 2002, the Regional Center referred STUDENT to Pacific Child and Family Associates (PCFA), a nonpublic agency, to evaluate STUDENT’s behaviors. PCFA performed a functional behavioral analysis and identified target problem behaviors as not responding to requests, tantrumming, inappropriate eating behavior (stuffing mouth with food, biting utensils), aggression (pulling hair, biting people or objects), and inappropriate oral activity (mouthing and licking objects). PCFA recommended intensive intervention through the use of one-to-one discrete trial training in the home setting. (District Exh. 36.)
In January 2003, STUDENT was placed in a special day class at R.D. White Elementary School (R.D. White), a District public school. At first she attended school once a week for up to four hours with one-to-one support. (Footnote 4) Toward the end of the 2002-2003 regular school year, STUDENT’s attendance increased to three days a week for four hours each day. The individualized education program (IEP) team met on May 22, 2003, and June 3, 2003, to develop STUDENT’s educational program for the 2003-2004 regular school year and extended school year. STUDENT continued to be identified as eligible for special education and related services under the category of other health impaired. Educational goals were identified in the areas of academics, speech and language, psychomotor/perceptual, personal/social/adaptive, and prevocational skills and attention to task. (Footnote 5)
The placement recommendation included a special day class for four hours each school day with an assigned aide providing one-to-one support. Designated instruction and services (DIS) were included in the areas of speech and language therapy (individual fifty-minute sessions three times each week in a clinic), occupational therapy (one fifty-minute session each week in the school setting), and physical therapy (individual fifty-minute sessions twice a week in a clinic, once a week at home, and once a week at school). The team agreed to provide an educational program during the July 2003 intercession and to provide two weeks of DIS during the four week “off-track” periods in November 2003 and March 2004. (Footnote 6) A behavior specialist from PCFA reported her recent observation of STUDENT’s behavior to the IEP team. Behaviors that impeded STUDENT’s learning were listed as inattention to task, distractability, tantrumming, avoidance, inappropriate touching, taking of objects, placing of hands in her mouth, and biting objects. A behavior support plan (BSP) was attached to the 2003-2004 IEP. The psychologist agreed to review the BSP with all other members of STUDENT’s team, and the District members of the IEP team agreed the BSP should be implemented by all teaching staff.
STUDENT’s parents disagreed with the placement offer and did not sign the IEP. According to the IEP meeting notes, they believed STUDENT should continue to receive clinic OT services in addition to the one session at school and requested an additional OT assessment. A proposed assessment plan to conduct an occupational therapy assessment dated June 3, 2003, was provided to STUDENT’s parents. (District Exh. 1.) STUDENT’s parents also believed that STUDENT should receive in-home DTT at District expense. They did not agree that an assessor suggested by District members of the IEP team should conduct a DTT assessment. (Student Exh. 43.) Although it is not clear from the record, it appears that STUDENT had begun receiving in-home DTT from PCFA at the end of May 2003 funded by the Regional Center. (District Exh. 37.) (Footnote 7) MOTHER testified that she later removed STUDENT from R.D. White and that the District provided home schooling to STUDENT beginning in June 2003. (Footnote 8) On June 24, 2003, and July 10, 2003, STUDENT was assessed at the UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute. STUDENT was diagnosed with an autism disorder and Dr. B.J. Freeman recommended that STUDENT be provided an intensive intervention program both at home and in school. (Student Exh. 39.) On November 5, 2003, MOTHER consented to the District’s proposed OT assessment.
Shortly thereafter, both parties to this matter requested a due process hearing regarding the provision of DTT and additional assessments. (Glendale Unified School District vs. STUDENT, Consolidated Case No. SN03-02226/SN03-02273.) The matter was scheduled for hearing at the end of January 2004. After several days of negotiation outside the presence of the presiding hearing officer, the parties reached a settlement agreement. The agreement set forth the agreed-upon educational program for STUDENT for the period from February 2004 through August 31, 2004. The parties agreed that STUDENT would attend a special day class at R.D. White ten hours each week with the support of a one-to-one assistant who would receive twenty hours of DTT training. The District agreed to fund fifteen hours each week of in-home DTT services when school was in session in addition to the twelve hours funded by the Regional Center. The parties agreed that STUDENT would receive DIS services while school was in session and during two of the four week off-track periods in March and August 2004. The parties further agreed that the goals and objectives set forth in the May and June 2003 IEP described above would be implemented during this time frame.
The parties also agreed that STUDENT would be assessed in the areas of adapted physical education (APE), occupational therapy, and assistive technology (AT) and that Dr. Dorie Glover would conduct a behavioral assessment. The parties agreed that an IEP meeting would be convened to discuss the assessment results and to develop an educational program for the 2004-2005 school year which would not be implemented until September 1, 2004. (District Exh. 3.)
The District provided STUDENT’s parents with a proposed assessment plan on February 20, 2004. In a letter to the District dated March 9, 2004, MOTHER reported the results of the UCLA assessment and returned the assessment plan signed and modified to include additional assessments she wanted performed. (District Exh. 5; Student Exhs. 13, 23.) On March 22, 2004, the District responded that it could not start the assessments until there was an agreed-upon assessment plan. (District Exh. 5.) On March 24, 2004, MOTHER wrote to the principal at R.D. White, refusing consent to the proposed assessment plan. (Student Exh. 25.)
STUDENT returned to school on March 25, 2004. (Testimony of MOTHER.) One week later, the District wrote to MOTHER and informed her that Glendale Adventist, a nonpublic agency, was available to conduct the OT assessment referenced in the settlement agreement. (District Exh. 6.) On April 19, 2004, another letter from MOTHER informed the District that the assessment plan failed to address STUDENT’s many areas of disability. MOTHER requested authorization for the Pasadena Child Development Associates to conduct the OT assessment and asked that the AT and APE assessments, both of which she had earlier consented to, be performed. (Student Exh. 26.)
On April 30, 2004, MOTHER requested an IEP meeting. (District Exh. 6.) An IEP meeting was held on May 20, 2004. The IEP team identified STUDENT as eligible for special education and related services as a child with autism and mental retardation. APE and AT assessment reports dated May 20, 2004, were reviewed. The team agreed to try APE for six months despite reservations expressed by the APE assessor that STUDENT’s base skills were too delayed. The AT specialist recommended the use of certain computer equipment and staff training. Progress reports were presented by the in-home behaviorist, physical therapist, and clinic speech therapist. Goals and objectives dated May 20, 2004, were presented in the areas of APE and AT. At that meeting, the District presented MOTHER with another assessment plan proposing to assess STUDENT in the following areas: academic/preacademic achievement, social and emotional development, motor ability, language and speech communication, general ability, health and developmental, career/prevocational skills, adaptive behavior/self-help skills, and physical therapy. The IEP meeting was continued to allow for completion of the assessment process. (District Exh. 15.) MOTHER signed her consent to the proposed assessments on May 25, 2004. (District Exh. 7.)
During the month of June 2004, several assessments were performed including a psychoeducational assessment (District Exh. 11), a special education assessment (District Exh. 12), and a speech and language assessment (District Exh. 13). On June 23, 2004, Dr. Glover performed her behavioral assessment and recommended that the District-funded in-home DTT services be discontinued. (District Exh. 14.) The IEP team met again on June 30, 2004. The recent assessment results were reviewed. The in-home behaviorist reported on STUDENT’s progress and the District’s classroom aide reviewed some of STUDENT’s self-help skills. Goals and objectives in the areas of speech and language, adaptive/social, and psychomotor skills were drafted.
On July 15, 2004, the IEP team completed the IEP. Additional OT goals were presented. For the 2004-2005 regular school year and extended school year, District members of the IEP team recommended placement in the special day class at R.D. White, with increasing attendance over a four week period until STUDENT reached five days a week for four hours each day. A full-time one-to-one aide was also assigned. DIS services were offered in SAL, OT, PT, and APE. AT equipment and staff training was also included. Also attached to the IEP was a behavior support plan. District members of the IEP team recommended elimination of the fifteen hours of District-funded in-home DTT services. According to the IEP meeting notes, a health assessment would be completed by August 9, 2004, and would be reviewed at a subsequent meeting. STUDENT’s parents did not consent to the IEP and disagreed with the recommendation to eliminate District-funded in-home DTT services.
On August 4, 2004, a new teacher, Claudette Machado, was assigned to STUDENT’s special day class. STUDENT continued to attend school on Mondays, Thursdays, and Fridays for a total of ten hours each week. In addition to spending some time in the classroom with her teacher and aide, STUDENT also received OT, PT, and SAL. On August 18, 2004, MOTHER’s attorney wrote to the District’s attorney that STUDENT’s parents were having independent behavioral evaluations performed and were seeking permission for the assessors to observe STUDENT’s program. (Student Exh. 33.) On August 11, 2004, STUDENT was privately assessed by Dr. Chris Davidson and on August 28, 2004, she was assessed by private assessor Sharyn Kerr of Autism Comprehensive Educational Services. (Student Exhs. 21, 22.) Both Dr. Davidson and Ms. Kerr concluded that STUDENT was learning well at home and responding well to DTT therapy. Ms. Kerr and Dr. Davidson both recommended that STUDENT continue her DTT therapy and that there be increased collaboration between home and school providers.
On August 31, 2004, the attorney for Student wrote a letter to the District’s attorney indicating that certain components of the IEP were consented to. (Student Exh. 34.) The District sent a return letter to Student’s counsel denying funding for independent evaluations, indicating that Glendale Adventist remained ready to perform the OT assessment, and stating its belief that STUDENT did not require unilateral placement in a DTT program to obtain educational benefit. Finally, the letter advised that STUDENT’s parents had to sign the IEP form in order for it to be implemented. (Student Exh. 35.)
On September 21, 2004, MOTHER sent a letter by facsimile to the principal of R.D. White indicating that STUDENT would begin attending school on Wednesdays for a total of thirteen hours each week. (Footnote 9) Reference was made to the August 31, 2004 attorney letter, and consent was given to make up missed SAL and APE sessions. (Student Exh. 36.)
The IEP team met on October 4, 2004. The August 5, 2004 health assessment report was reviewed and the need for services during the upcoming off-track period in November was discussed. Those District members of the IEP team in attendance at the meeting thought that STUDENT did not require designated instruction and services during the off-track periods but according to the meeting notes, the team had yet to ask the occupational therapist for input. MOTHER told the team that STUDENT was entitled to receive designated instruction and services during the off-track period pursuant to the stay put provision. It appears from the testimony that STUDENT received two weeks of designated instruction and services during the October-November 2004 off-track period. (Footnote 10) MOTHER signed her consent on the IEP form for STUDENT to attend the special day class at R.D. White fifteen hours each week and to receive the SAL, OT, PT, APE, and AT described in the July 15, 2004 IEP. Beginning on October 4, 2004, Ms. Carlson provided speech and language services to STUDENT three times each week.
On October 18, 2004, Student filed her request for a due process hearing alleging that the assessments that had recently been performed were inappropriate and that the educational placement described in the IEPs dated May 20, 2004, June 30, 2004, and July 15, 2004, denied her a free appropriate public education (FAPE). Student sought reimbursement for private assessments her parents had obtained and compensatory educational services. On October 20, 2004, the District filed its own request for a due process hearing seeking a determination that the assessments performed by its personnel and Dr. Glover were appropriate and that its proposed placement offered STUDENT a FAPE. On November 10, 2004, the Hearing Office granted the Student’s unopposed motion to consolidate the two matters and scheduled the consolidated case for hearing.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue No. I: Was the District’s 2004 triennial assessment of STUDENT appropriate?
Both State and federal special education law provide that a reassessment of a child with a disability shall be conducted at least every three years as part of the school district’s continuing obligation to make a free appropriate public education available to the student. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56381; 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(2)(A); 34 C.F.R §. 300.536(b).) Reassessments shall be conducted in conformity with the procedures specified in California Education Code sections 56320 and 56321(b). The purpose of reassessment is not only to determine whether the student remains eligible for special education and related services but to also determine the educational needs of the student. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(3)(D); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56320(e), 56321(a).) In addition, a student must be assessed in all suspected areas of disability and need. (See 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(2), (b)(3)(C); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f).) In determining the areas to reassess, the IEP team may review existing available data and determine what, if any, additional information or testing is needed. (34 C.F.R. § 300.533(a)(1), (2).)
Special education law requires that if a school district conducts further tests as part of a reassessment, it must follow the procedures governing initial assessments. (Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56320, 56381(a).) Testing and assessment materials and procedures must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; must be provided and administered in the pupil’s native language; must be administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; and must be validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(a)(b).) Assessment materials must assess specific areas of educational need and not merely provide a single general intelligence quotient. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(c).) Further, no single procedure shall be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for a child. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(e).)
The assessments shall be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the suspected disability. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(g).) Psychological assessments shall be conducted by a credentialed school psychologist who is trained and prepared to assess cultural and ethnic factors appropriate to the pupil being assessed. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56324(a).) Health assessments shall be conducted by a credentialed school nurse or physician who is trained and prepared to assess cultural and ethnic factors for the pupil being assessed. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56324(b).) Additionally, assessments must be conducted by persons competent to perform the assessments, as determined by the school district, county office, or special education local plan area. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56322.)
Regarding the appropriateness of the District’s assessments, Student maintains that: (A) both the AT and APE assessments were rushed and failed to include a parent interview; (B) the psychoeducational assessment was inappropriate; and (C) an OT assessment which had been consented to by her parents has never been performed. (Footnote 11) The District asserts that the assessments it conducted were appropriate. The District concedes that the OT assessment has not been performed but argues that although it has been willing to perform the assessment, STUDENT’s parents have not made her available.
The evidence established at the due process hearing that the parties entered into a settlement agreement on January 31, 2004, wherein the District agreed to conduct reassessments in the areas of APE, OT, and AT and the parties agreed that Dr. Dorie Glover would conduct a behavioral assessment. (District Exh. 3.) Parental consent was provided for all of the assessments at issue. (District Exhs. 1, 7; Student Exh. 26.) (Footnote 12) Except for the occupational therapy assessment that has not been performed, there is no dispute that the triennial evaluation assessed STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability. Regarding Dr. Dorie Glover’s assessment, the District seeks a determination that her assessment was appropriate. However, Student’s quarrel with Dr. Glover’s assessment is that it was untimely and that her conclusion that District-funded in-home DTT services should be eliminated was incorrect. Accordingly, there is no dispute that Dr. Glover’s assessment was appropriate. The questions raised by Student concerning Dr. Glover’s assessment will be addressed below in Issue No. II, namely with regard to whether the District denied STUDENT a FAPE. The Hearing Officer will address the appropriateness of the assessments in the context of the parties’ contentions.
A. The assistive technology and adapted physical education assessments.
Student asserts that both the APE and AT assessments were rushed, failed to include a parent interview, and therefore were inappropriate. The District argues that the AT and APE assessments were appropriate.
The first of three IEP meetings held to determine STUDENT’s educational program for the 2004-2005 school year took place on May 20, 2004. Both the AT and APE assessments were conducted on the same day as the IEP meeting. MOTHER testified that she first learned that STUDENT’s APE assessment was being conducted when she received a telephone call from the District in the late morning of May 20, 2004, asking if she could pick up STUDENT a little later than usual that day at 12:30 p.m. She further testified that she left school that day with STUDENT at 12:05 p.m. In addition, according to MOTHER, she was never informed that an AT assessment had taken place. Finally, she testified that neither assessor interviewed her as part of their assessments.
There is nothing in either federal or State special education law which requires that an assessment be of any particular length in order to comport with the legal requirements set forth above and therefore Student’s argument to the contrary is misplaced. According to the AT assessment report, the AT assessor interviewed STUDENT’s teacher, observed her in the classroom, and was guided by a formal assessment guide. (District Exh. 10.) The APE assessment report indicated that STUDENT was assessed using tools that measured gross motor developmental delays, fitness level, and gross motor development. (District Exh. 8.) Neither assessor reported that there was insufficient time to complete their assessments. In fact, the APE report expressly states that the test results obtained were valid and that STUDENT tried her best. (District Exh. 8.)
Further, Student presents no legal authority for the proposition that parent interviews by each individual assessor must be conducted in order for the assessment to be appropriate. The law contemplates and encourages parental input as part of the IEP process to determine whether further assessments may be required and whether any independent evaluations they procured will provide useful information to the IEP team. (See 34 C.F.R. § 300.533.) In this case, the evidence of the January 2004 settlement agreement, as well as the correspondence between the parties described above, established that STUDENT’s parents were active participants in the reassessment process. Moreover, MOTHER was in attendance at the May 20, 2004 IEP meeting where both the AT and APE assessors presented their results. There is no indication in the IEP meeting notes, nor did MOTHER testify, that she disagreed with the AT and APE findings. In fact, even though the APE assessor expressed some reservations concerning the provision of APE to STUDENT in light of her significant delays, the IEP team agreed to try APE for six months and made APE part of STUDENT’s program. Finally, it is important to note that STUDENT’s parents have consented to both AT and APE services as described in the July 15, 2004 IEP.
The Hearing Officer finds that the AT and APE assessments were not “rushed,” STUDENT’s parents were active participants in the assessment process, and accordingly, that the AT and APE assessments were appropriate.
B. The psychoeducational assessment.
Student maintains that the psychoeducational assessment was flawed because she is of Armenian descent and the assessor administered the Developmental Profile-II to her even though it has been criticized for its limited normative sample, the assessor failed to administer the Vineland Adaptive Scale-Classroom Edition in conformance with test instructions, and the assessor relied on an obsolete method to calculate her intelligence quotient (IQ). The District asserts that the Developmental Profile is considered valid for children of all ethnic backgrounds, that the assessor correctly relied on additional sources of information when STUDENT’s teacher was unable to complete all portions of the Vineland survey, and that the assessor’s focus was on determining STUDENT’s developmental level and not her IQ.
District school psychologist Georgia Katelanis conducted the psychoeducational assessment over the course of six days in June 2004. (District Exh. 11.) Ms. Katelanis has been a school psychologist for fourteen years. She has a bachelor’s degree in psychology and master’s degrees in education and educational psychology. She has a pupil personnel services credential and a clear multiple subject teaching credential. Ms. Katelanis has experience and training working with children diagnosed with autism and currently consults with teachers and parents concerning learning and behavior issues. Last year, of the nearly one hundred assessments she conducted, approximately thirteen of them involved children with autism and mental retardation. Ms. Katelanis first assessed STUDENT three years earlier in 2001 and sees STUDENT regularly during the school year. Accordingly, Ms. Katelanis was qualified to perform the assessment.
Turning first to the Student’s criticism of the Developmental Profile-II, Ms. Katelanis testified that the Developmental Profile requires both a direct assessment and interview. The test was normed on a group of Caucausian, African-American, and “other” (Hispanic and Asian) children. Ms. Katelanis acknowledged that the “other” children were not sufficiently represented in the sample but testified that the test provides useful information across all cultures because it assesses developmental skills. Ms. Katelanis used the same instrument in 2001 and, comparing results, found that STUDENT had made a few modest gains.
Dr. Chris Davidson testified on behalf of Student. Dr. Davidson has a bachelor’s degree, a master’s in counseling, and a doctorate in education administration. She is a licensed educational psychologist and a credentialed school psychologist. She has assessed approximately five hundred children diagnosed with autism, has extensive school experience, and is currently in private practice. Dr. Davidson testified that the Developmental Profile-II has been criticized because it was not normed on a wide population, used few African-American children with the majority of the sample living in Indiana, and has not been renormed based upon the more current census. (Footnote 13) In reaching her opinion, Dr. Davidson relied upon professional literature authored by “Burros.” However, neither the citation nor the literature was provided to the District or the Hearing Officer. Given the absence of the text and the failure to provide the District the opportunity to effectively cross-examine Dr. Davidson regarding its contents, the Hearing Officer is unable to assign these criticisms of the test any evidentiary value. Moreover, although STUDENT is of Armenian heritage, she has always been identified as “white.” Accordingly, in light of Ms. Katelanis’s persuasive testimony that the test is a useful measure across all cultures because it assesses developmental skills, the Hearing Officer finds that the District established that the test is not racially or culturally discriminatory and has been validated for the specific purpose for which it was used. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(a)(b).)
Ms. Katelanis also administered the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales-Classroom Edition. Ms. Katelanis testified that the same survey had been completed in the previous evaluation and therefore the current results provided a useful comparison. STUDENT’s classroom teacher was interviewed to help determine STUDENT’s adaptive functioning in the areas of communication, daily living skills, and socialization. Ms. Katelanis testified that when STUDENT’s classroom teacher was unable to answer all the survey questions, she questioned other staff who worked with STUDENT to fill in the gaps. Ms. Katelanis testified that the Vineland manual permits asking several teachers to complete the questionnaire. Notably, Dr. Davidson did not testify inconsistently, but only stated that the test manual provides that if additional teachers are queried, a separate inventory must be completed and that any such deviation should be noted in the report.
Although the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Katelanis’s approach should have been mentioned in her report, the Hearing Officer does not find this omission invalidated the results. The Hearing Officer finds that the Vineland was administered in conformance with test instructions. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(b)(3).) Turning next to Ms. Katelanis’s calculation of STUDENT’s IQ, Ms. Katelanis testified that she attempted to administer the Kaufman Assessment Battery, a standardized test, and selected this instrument because some of the subtests are nonverbal and the manual permits the examiner to demonstrate and to repeat instructions. Ms. Katelanis testified, however, that even with these modifications, STUDENT was unable to understand the test instructions. Ms. Katelanis explained that in order to determine STUDENT’s level of cognitive functioning, she used a variety of other techniques including interviews of STUDENT’s teacher, mother, in-home DTT therapist, and speech therapist; observations of STUDENT at home, in OT, and in SAL; and informal play assessments to determine what skills STUDENT could perform. At hearing, Ms. Katelanis testified that she calculated STUDENT’s IQ by dividing several of STUDENT’s mental age scores by her chronological age and multiplying the result by one hundred. By this means, Ms. Katelanis determined STUDENT’s IQ to be twenty-six, a rate she testified fell in the severely mentally retarded range.
Ms. Katelanis testified, however, that her main focus was not on actual scores, but rather on what STUDENT was able to do developmentally. Based upon her observations of STUDENT, Ms. Katelanis testified that STUDENT could use foresight to solve problems, imitate, use memory when she was familiar with something, and sort by shapes. Ms. Katelanis also noted that STUDENT exhibited difficulties in fine motor work, communication, understanding language, and understanding symbolic representations (sorting by color or representational qualities). Based upon these observations, Ms. Katelanis’s report concluded that STUDENT’s cognitive skills fell between the one and one-half to two and one-half year old range.
Dr. Chris Davidson testified on behalf of Student and was critical of Ms. Katelanis’s IQ calculation, noting that this ratio method is considered obsolete. (Footnote 14) Dr. Davidson explained that this method does not take account of standard errors of measurement and, that as the child gets older the difference between the child’s mental age and chronological age is greater and the IQ score is concomitantly reduced.
The Hearing Officer has found above that the test instruments used by Ms. Katelanis comported with legal requirements and that she was qualified to perform the psychoeducational assessment. The Hearing Officer observes that neither federal nor State special education law requires that a particular method be used to calculate a pupil’s IQ score. Thus, even if Ms. Katelanis’s calculation was questionable, it is not prohibited by federal or State special education law. Moreover, there is no dispute that STUDENT is eligible for special education services, whether the identified category is autistic-like behaviors or mental retardation. Additionally, when making her program recommendations, Ms. Katelanis relied more heavily on observations of the skills STUDENT demonstrated than on the IQ measure. This is consistent with State special education law which requires that assessment materials assess specific areas of educational need and not merely provide a single general intelligence quotient. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(c).) Further, no single procedure may be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for a child. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(e).) Indeed, Dr. Davidson’s opinion was in accord that the important thing to determine is where a child is developmentally and at what level the child is able to function. Notably, Dr. Davidson did not formally assess STUDENT’s cognitive functioning and was unable to provide the Hearing Officer with an alternative measure.
Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that both Ms. Katelanis and Dr. Davidson testified consistently that the focus of the assessment was on the developmental skills STUDENT demonstrated and less on her classification. The Hearing Officer further finds that Ms. Katelanis’s psychoeducational assessment comported with legal requirements and served the purpose of an appropriate assessment, namely to provide useful information and observations of both STUDENT’s cognitive and adaptive functioning sufficient for the IEP team to identify STUDENT’s academic needs.
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that the psychoeducational assessment was appropriate. The Developmental Profile-II was not racially or culturally discriminatory and has been validated for the specific purpose for which it was used, the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales was administered in accordance with test instructions, and the cognitive assessment appropriately focused on STUDENT’s developmental skills rather than her IQ score.
C. Occupational therapy assessment.
The District concedes that in spite of STUDENT’s parents’ consent to conduct an OT assessment, an OT assessment has yet to be performed. However, the District asserts that while it has been ready, able, and willing to conduct the OT assessment, STUDENT’s parents have not made her available. At hearing, MOTHER testified that she did not agree with the assessor selected by the District to conduct the OT assessment because STUDENT had a bad experience at that agency when she was four or five years old and other parents have told her about unspecified complaints. MOTHER conceded that she is unaware whether the same therapist who worked with STUDENT over five years ago still works at the agency or who would conduct the OT assessment.
The Hearing Officer finds that MOTHER’s reference to remote events or unspecified rumors does not warrant a departure from the current standard that affords a school district the right to choose among qualified assessors. (See, e.g., Andress v. Cleveland Indep. Sch. Dist., 64 F.3d 176, 178-179 (5th Cir. 1995), cert. denied, 117 S.Ct. 58 (1996); Vander Malle v. Ambach, 673 F.2d 49, 53 (2d Cir. 1984).) Moreover, In Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1315 (9th Cir. 1987), the Ninth Circuit stated “if the parents want [their child] to receive special education under the Act, they are obligated to permit such testing.” In Andress v. Cleveland Independent School District, 64 F.3d at 178, the Fifth Circuit concluded that “a parent who desires for her child to receive special education must allow the school district to evaluate the child...there is no exception to this rule.” (See also Vander Malle v. Ambach, 673 F.2d at 53.) There is no dispute in this case that the OT assessor selected by the District, Glendale Adventist, is qualified to assess STUDENT. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has discharged its obligation to conduct an OT assessment in this case, and that one would have been performed had the parents not refused to present STUDENT to be assessed by the qualified assessor of the District’s choosing.
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s AT, APE, and psychoeducational assessments were appropriate and that the District met its obligations regarding the OT assessment.
Issue No. II: Has the District denied STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) procedurally and substantively for the 2004-2005 regular school year and extended school year by failing to: (A) timely conduct assessments; (B) make a clear and coherent program offer; (C) ensure the presence of all required personnel when the program offer was made; (D) provide goals and objectives designed to meet STUDENT’s unique preacademic/academic, socialization, self-help, and behavioral needs; (E) continue District-funded in-home discrete trial training (DTT) services; (F) develop a system of collaboration between STUDENT’s in-home and school programs; (G) provide designated instruction and services and in-home DTT during the off-track periods; and (H) timely implement consented-to components of the IEP?
Under both federal and State special education law, all students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.) The term “free appropriate public education” (FAPE) means special education and related services that are available to students at no charge to their parents or guardians, that meet State educational standards, and that conform with the students’ individualized education programs (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).) An IEP is a written statement that must be developed, reviewed, and revised for each child with a disability. (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343, 56345.) The IEP must include, among other things, a statement of the special education and related services to be provided to meet the student’s needs that result from his or her disability to enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.) An IEP is an educational package that must target all of a student’s unique educational needs, whether academic or nonacademic. (Lenn v. Portland Sch. Comm., 998 F.2d 1083, 1089 (1st Cir. 1993).) The term “unique educational needs” is to be broadly construed and includes the student’s academic, social, emotional, communicative, physical, and vocational needs. (Seattle Sch. Dist. No 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996).)
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that for a student to receive a FAPE, the student’s IEP must be designed to meet the unique needs of the student and be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or with instruction or services that maximize the students’ abilities. Id., 458 U.S. at 198-200. De minimus benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some benefit.” (Walczak v. Florida Union School District, 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2d Cir. 1998).) A child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. (Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997).)
A stated purpose of the IDEA is “to ensure that all children with disabilities have available to them a free appropriate public education that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs and prepare them for employment and independent living.” (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d).) Additionally, education is the ability to be successful outside the classroom and incorporates much more than merely traditional academics. (Ash v. Lake Oswego School District, 980 F.2d 585, 587 (9th Cir. 1992).)
Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a student from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in regular education classes cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.) The IDEA requires that children with disabilities be mainstreamed to the maximum extent appropriate. (See 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56364.)
The term “related services,” referred to as designated instruction and services (DIS) in California, means transportation and such developmental, corrective, and other supportive services as may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education, including counseling and guidance. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(b)(1)(5)(9); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22).) The list of related services is not exhaustive and may include other developmental, corrective, or supportive services if they are required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. (34 C.F.R. § 300.14; Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(z).) Special education and related services must be tailored to meet the unique needs of the child with a disability. (Polk v. Central Susquehana Intermediate Unit 16, 853 F.2d 171, 173 (3d Cir. 1988); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(3); 34 C.F.R. § 300.24.)
The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 205.) States are required to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which s/he is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. (W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992).) Procedural flaws dot not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process may constitute a FAPE denial. (W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).)
Accordingly, the analysis of whether a child has been provided a FAPE is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to consider both whether procedural steps were followed and whether the proposed program is substantively appropriate. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-207.) The District has the burden of proof at the administrative hearing that it complied with the IDEA. (Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist. No 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994).)
Student raises a number of procedural and substantive allegations that she contends denied her a FAPE. The Hearing Officer turns first to Student’s alleged procedural violations. Student asserts that the District failed to: (A) timely conduct assessments; (B) make a clear and coherent program offer; and (C) ensure the presence of all necessary personnel when the program offer was made.
PROCEDURAL APPROPRIATENESS.
A. Timely conduct assessments.
State special education law establishes timelines for assessment and for the convening of an IEP meeting to discuss the assessment results and to develop an educational program. When a student is referred for special education, the local educational agency (LEA) must conduct an appropriate assessment. The LEA is given a maximum of fifteen days from the referral to provide an assessment plan to the parent. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(a).) The parent is allowed at least fifteen days to consider and give consent to the assessment. Upon receipt of parental consent, the LEA has a maximum of fifty days from that date to conduct a full assessment and to develop an IEP that makes a FAPE available to the student. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56344; see also Cal. Educ. Code § 56043.) Additionally, as noted above, a child with a disability must be reassessed at least once every three years. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56381; 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(2)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.536(b).)
Student asserts that the District entered into a contract with Dr. Dorie Glover too late for the triennial review due in May 2004, and that the health assessment and IEP meeting to discuss the health assessment did not comport with statutory timelines. The District maintains that Dr. Glover’s assessment was timely and comported with the terms of the parties’ January 31, 2004 settlement agreement. It concedes that the health assessment was delayed but argues that the error did not amount to a denial of a FAPE.
1. Dr. Dorie Glover’s assessment. Turning first to the timeliness of Dr. Glover’s assessment, the Hearing Officer must examine the terms of the January 31, 2004 settlement agreement. The District agreed to contract with Dr. Glover to conduct an assessment regarding STUDENT’s need for discrete trial training as part of her educational program. Under the terms of the agreement, the fifty-day statutory timeline would not commence until fifteen days after the District entered into a contract with Dr. Glover, providing the District with a total of sixty-five days in which to have the assessment completed and reviewed by the IEP team. (District Exh. 3, para. j.) The District entered into a contract with Dr. Glover on May 25, 2004, and her assessment was conducted on June 23, 2004. (District Exhs. 29, 14.) The IEP team met to discuss the results of Dr. Glover’s assessment on June 30, 2004. Therefore, only thirty-six days elapsed between the time the District entered into a contract with Dr. Glover and the IEP team’s review of the assessment. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Glover’s assessment was timely pursuant to the express terms of the settlement agreement and Student’s waiver of the statutory timelines.
Further, although in the ordinary course of things STUDENT’s triennial review should have occurred in May 2004, the settlement agreement modified the dates for review of STUDENT’s educational program. Under the terms of the agreement, the parties settled all issues with regard to STUDENT’s education for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year and up to September 1, 2004. Additionally, the new IEP for the 2004-2005 school year based upon the more current assessments would not be implemented until September 1, 2004. (District Exh. 3, para. n.) The results of Dr. Glover’s assessment were discussed and an offer of placement was made well in advance of the September 1, 2004 start date. Moreover, STUDENT’s parents were active participants in the IEP meetings when Dr. Glover’s report and recommendations were discussed. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that even if Dr. Glover’s assessment was completed after the time for STUDENT’s triennial review, under the circumstances of this case, the timing of Dr. Glover’s assessment did not infringe on STUDENT’s parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process and that there was no loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT with regard to the only school year at issue, the 2004-2005 school year.
2. Health assessment. Student maintains that the District’s health assessment violated the statutory timelines set forth above. Student argues further that she was harmed by the delay because the health assessment alerted her to the need to conduct further testing. The District concedes that the health assessment was delayed but maintains that the IEP team had sufficient information concerning STUDENT’s health from MOTHER to make its program offer. According to the District, after the health assessment was discussed by the IEP team, no changes were made to STUDENT’s educational program.
It is undisputed that by not completing the health assessment until August 5, 2004, and by not having the IEP team review the health assessment until October 4, 2004, the District conducted and reviewed the health assessment beyond the statutory timelines. However, the Hearing Officer does not conclude that this procedural violation amounted to a denial of FAPE. STUDENT’s medical history has been well known to the District for many years. As noted above in the recitation of background facts, STUDENT had been identified as eligible for special education and related services under the category of other health impaired as a result of these problems. In addition, much of the health assessment report contained information regarding STUDENT’s physical difficulties that had already been made known to the IEP team by the occupational therapist, the adapted physical education instructor, the special education teacher, and the school psychologist, and was noted on the 2004-2005 IEP. (See Student Exh. 8, p.2.) Addressing the parents’ concern about STUDENT’s visual needs, the health report noted that STUDENT’s vision was functional but that STUDENT did not use her central vision. Notably, the health assessor reported that previous recommendations made in December 2002 to assist STUDENT to use her central vision were being utilized in the classroom. (District Exh. 16.) Although the health assessment triggered STUDENT’s parents’ request for an additional assessment, the Hearing Officer finds that the late health assessment did not require modifications to STUDENT’s educational program and thus STUDENT did not lose educational opportunity as a result. (Footnote 15)
Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Glover’s assessment was timely pursuant to the express waiver of statutory timelines in the parties’ January 31, 2004 settlement agreement. In addition, the report was presented to the IEP team in advance of the July 15, 2004 IEP meeting when the program offer was made. The Hearing Officer further finds that although the District conducted and reviewed the health assessment beyond the statutory timelines, the procedural violation did not amount to a denial of a FAPE.
B. Clear, coherent written offer.
A school district is required to give written prior notice to the parents of a student with disabilities whenever it proposes to initiate or change, or refuses to initiate or change, the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the student, or the provision of a free appropriate public education to the student. (20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3).) Such notice provides the parent with information that can help them to make informed decisions about their child’s education. The notice is also important in that it helps to ensure that there is a clear record of what placement, services, and assistance were offered to the student and when they were offered. (See Union School Dist. v. B. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994).) Among the procedural violations that may amount to a denial of FAPE is the failure of the school district to make a clear, coherent offer of placement in compliance with the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and Union.
Student argues that the District failed to make a clear, coherent offer of placement because the goals and objectives have inconsistent start and end dates and there was no offer of placement and services at two of the three IEP meetings. The District maintains that the law does not require that a program offer be completed in one sitting and that the IEP is otherwise procedurally correct.
The IEP must include a statement of the specific special educational instruction and related services and supplementary aids and services to be provided to the pupil, as well as “[t]he projected date for the beginning of [these] services and modifications...” (Cal. Educ. Code § 56345 (3)(6).) In this case, as written, Student is correct that the IEP listed goals and objectives with different start and end dates. Thus, for example, the speech and language, adaptive behavior, social skills, and prevocational goals run from June 30, 2004, to June 30, 2005, OT goals run from July 2004 to July 2005, and APE goals run from May 2004 to May 2005. However, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP comported with the legal requirement that the IEP state the projected start date for services and that the different projected start dates did not result in a vague offer of placement as contemplated under Union. According to the IEP, STUDENT’s next review is scheduled for May 2005. Thus, even the earliest of the start dates fairly apprises STUDENT’s parents of her educational program for the 2004-2005 school year.
Turning to the number of IEP meetings held, the evidence establishes that the IEP team met three times to discuss the many assessment results and to develop an educational program for STUDENT for the 2004-2005 school year. However, neither federal nor State special education law require that the IEP meet only once to develop an educational program offer. Student has presented no legal authority in support of this contention. Moreover, as found above, the District complied with the terms of the parties’ January 31, 2004 settlement agreement and held the IEP meetings, including the one on July 15, 2004, in sufficient time for STUDENT’s parents to make an informed decision concerning the District’s offer of placement for the 2004-2005 school year. In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that there were no Union violations. The written offer was sufficiently clear to alert STUDENT’s parents to consider seriously whether the proposed placement was appropriate under the IDEA.
C. Presence of all required personnel when the program offer was made.
California Education Code section 56341(b) identifies the necessary members of the IEP team as including (1) one or both parents, (2) a special education teacher of the pupil, (3) a regular education teacher of the pupil if the pupil is or may be participating in the general education program, (4) a representative of the responsible local educational agency, and (5) an individual who conducted an assessment of the student and is familiar with the assessment results or recommendations. Additionally, section 56341(b)(6) indicates that, at the discretion of the parent or the LEA, the team may include “other individuals who have knowledge or special expertise regarding the pupil, including related services personnel, as appropriate.”
In this case, Student asserts that these provisions were violated because necessary personnel were not present at the final meeting in July 15, 2004, when the full offer of placement was made. The evidence demonstrated that at the first IEP meeting held on May 20, 2004, the APE, AT, PT, and clinical speech and language assessors and in-home behaviorist presented their testing results and reports and provided input to the IEP team, who discussed their recommendations. APE goals and objectives were developed. Present at the first meeting were Dr. Fine (assistant director of special education), a general education teacher, STUDENT’s special education teacher, STUDENT’s in-home behaviorist, a speech pathologist, R.D. White’s principal, the clinical director of the NPA providing in-home DTT services, the adapted physical education assessor, the assistive technology assessor, and STUDENT’s mother. At the second meeting held on June 30, 2004, Dr. Glover reviewed her assessment, the special education teacher reviewed her report, the in-home behavioral supervisor presented an updated report, STUDENT’s one-to-one aide noted her observations of STUDENT’s progress and needs, and the school psychologist reviewed her report. Present at the second meeting were Dr. Fine, the general education teacher, the school psychologist, a speech and language pathologist, STUDENT’s special education teacher, an occupational therapy student, STUDENT’s one-to-one aide, Dr. Glover, STUDENT’s attorney, and STUDENT’s mother. At the last meeting held on July 15, 2004, the goals and objectives were discussed and a placement was recommended. Additionally, the behavior support plan was developed and the transition plan to increase STUDENT’s school attendance was developed. Present at that meeting were Dr. Fine, the school psychologist, the speech and language pathologist, a special education teacher, the school principal, the Student’s and District’s attorneys, and the mother.
California Education Code section 56341(b) does not require every individual who has worked with a student to attend every IEP meeting. In this case, as set out above, each assessor attended at least one of the three IEP meetings and presented his or her report and recommendations. (See Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b)(5); 34 C.F.R. § 300.344 (a)(6).) The meeting notes establish that the results and recommendations were discussed by the IEP team. A representative from STUDENT’s home program also provided input. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s parents and other members of the IEP team were fairly apprised of the assessors’ test results and recommendations over the course of the three meetings convened to develop a program for the 2004-2005 school year. Accordingly, the absence of some of the assessors and service providers at the last of the three IEP meetings did not violate section 56341(b), and the District therefore did not fail to have appropriate members present at the IEP team meetings.
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to conduct a health assessment within the statutory timelines but that STUDENT did not lose educational opportunity as a result. The Hearing Officer further finds that Dr. Glover’s assessment was timely, the District’s program offer was clear and coherent, and the District did not fail to have appropriate members present at the IEP team meetings. Thus, no procedural violations occurred that denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year.
SUBSTANTIVE APPROPRIATENESS.
To determine whether the District substantively offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of the District’s proposed program. (Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.) If the District’s offer is designed to address STUDENT’s unique educational needs, is reasonably calculated to provide her some educational benefit, and comports with her IEP, the District has offered a FAPE.
Student raises a number of substantive allegations that she contends denied her a FAPE. In particular, she alleges that the District failed to: (D) provide goals and objectives designed to meet her unique preacademic/academic, socialization, self-help, and behavioral needs; (E) continue District-funded in-home discrete trial training services; (F) develop a system of collaboration between her in-home and school programs; (G) provide designated instruction and services and in-home DTT during the off-track periods; and (H) timely implement consented-to components of the 2004-2005 IEP. In order to determine whether the program offer described in the 2004-2005 IEP substantively offered a FAPE to Student within the context of her contentions, the Hearing Officer will turn first to a discussion of Student’s unique needs. The Hearing Officer will then examine whether the District’s program is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide her with educational benefit. Finally, the Hearing Officer will address whether the District implemented consented-to components of the program offer.
STUDENT’s unique needs.
The parties generally agree that STUDENT has deficits in cognitive functioning, speech and language development, fine and gross motor skills, socialization skills, and behavior. The parties also agree that STUDENT’s academic deficits manifest in the need for a special day class with a low student-teacher ratio. There is no dispute that STUDENT has difficulty attending to task, following teacher’s instructions, attending to activities of daily living including eating and toileting independently, and that she therefore requires the assistance of a full-time dedicated one-to-one aide. The parties also agree that STUDENT’s communication and language deficits include understanding only simple one word instructions, poor articulation, and spontaneous speech that consists of mostly two to three word phrases, and that she requires speech and language therapy to address these deficits. There is also general agreement that STUDENT’s health needs and gross motor deficits, which include an unsteady gait, poor posture, limited strength and flexibility, and imbalance, require that she receive adapted physical education and physical therapy. In addition, there is no dispute that STUDENT’s communication and language deficits require that she be provided with assistive technology devices to help make her needs and wants known. The parties agree that STUDENT’s behaviors interfere with her ability to access the general education curriculum and that she needs behavioral approaches to learning, such as discrete trial training, as well as a behavioral support plan.
The parties dispute whether STUDENT needs additional goals and objectives and services to meet her unique preacademic/academic, socialization, self-help, and behavioral needs. Student asserts that she requires additional preacademic/academic goals to address each of her deficits, a toy play goal to develop socialization skills, and a feeding goal. Although there is general agreement that Student requires trained personnel to work one-to-one with her using a behavioral strategy such as discrete trial training in both the home and school environment, Student argues that she continues to require fifteen hours of District-funded in-home DTT services over and above the twelve hours of DTT services provided by the Regional Center. In addition, Student maintains that she needs a more specific behavioral support plan and collaboration between the home and school programs.
The District argues that the IEP appropriately prioritizes STUDENT’s academic needs in drafting goals and objectives. The District believes that given STUDENT’s cognitive functioning, the academic goals in the IEP meet her needs and that the benchmarks are measurable. The District asserts that a feeding goal is worked on in the home program and is not an area of concern in the educational setting. Finally, the District maintains that the fifteen hours of District-funded in-home DTT services that was provided pursuant to the parties’ January 2004 settlement agreement is no longer necessary to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. The District also contends that the behavioral support plan is designed to meet STUDENT’s behavioral needs.
In determining whether the 2004-2005 IEP offers STUDENT a FAPE within the context of the parties’ contentions, the Hearing Officer turns first to a more detailed discussion of STUDENT’s academic, socialization, self-help, and behavioral needs.
1. Preacademic/academic needs. The parties generally agree that STUDENT demonstrates low cognitive functioning and that her academic performance is significantly delayed and inconsistent. STUDENT has difficulty generalizing from one environment to the next. (Testimony of Glover, Torrens.) Ms. Katelanis testified that STUDENT uses trial and error and foresight when placing wood inset pieces in an unfamiliar form board. She can imitate one-step simple actions such as placing blocks if the blocks are arranged one at a time. STUDENT demonstrates object constancy and can retrieve a hidden object if she watches, but is unable to reach around a barrier to get it.
STUDENT’s classroom teacher, in-home behaviorist supervisor, and school psychologist all found that STUDENT does not demonstrate one-to-one correspondence and is unable to count out more than two objects without prompting. STUDENT is able to state her first name and the names of her mother, father, and brother when asked. STUDENT can point to main body parts and name and match shapes, but cannot identify colors. STUDENT can imitate a horizontal or vertical line, cut a piece of paper in two, trace with assistance, and look at what she is coloring. There is no dispute that STUDENT’s deficits manifest in the need for an educational program that stresses readiness skills in the areas of reading, mathematics, and basic writing, and that she needs to learn to generalize skills across home and school environments. The parties generally agree that STUDENT also needs educational supports including a one-to-one aide and special day class teacher each trained in discrete trial training techniques.
2. Socialization needs. The parties agree that STUDENT manifests significant social skills deficits. STUDENT is just beginning to parallel play, that is, to play alongside other children. By teacher, aide, and school psychologist report, STUDENT enjoys being around her school peers. Dr. Glover observed that STUDENT has only a limited understanding of taking turns. STUDENT does not initiate play or know how to play with a simple toy without adult assistance either at home or school. According to both Ms. Katelanis and Dr. Glover, STUDENT is unable to occupy herself when other classmates engage in free play. MOTHER reported that STUDENT is also unable to occupy herself at home and has only limited play skills. (Student Exh. 21.) STUDENT requires an educational program that emphasizes socialization skills for her to function in a least restrictive environment in the future. (Testimony of Glover.)
3. Self-help needs. Although the parties agree that STUDENT has made some progress in this area, by all reports STUDENT continues to need assistance while toileting, washing and drying her hands, and eating. STUDENT has a history of gagging and vomiting when presented with foods she does not like or when the food is not cut into small pieces. STUDENT requires the assistance of a one-to-one aide to help her with these tasks.
4. Behavioral needs. The parties generally agree that STUDENT has significant behavioral needs that interfere with her ability to access the general education curriculum. STUDENT engages in self-stimulatory behaviors that include rubbing her fingers across her teeth, mouthing objects, biting her shirt and eating utensils, hand flapping, hand gazing, excessively repeating greetings, and grabbing peers. She also tantrums and has a difficult time attending to a task or instructions without repeated prompts. When seeking to avoid a task, STUDENT will frequently ask to go to the bathroom. MOTHER noted that STUDENT’s behaviors make family outings difficult. (Student Exh. 21.) To address STUDENT’s behavioral problems, STUDENT needs a program that includes a behavioral support plan and intensive one-to-one intervention using an effective behavioral strategy such as discrete trial training.
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s deficits manifest in unique needs in the areas of preacademic/academic development, self-help, socialization, and behavioral skills. These needs require an educational program that addresses basic academic readiness skills, socialization skills including initiating play with peers and occupying herself, and self-help skills including toileting and eating with less assistance. In addition, STUDENT requires trained personnel to utilize one-to-one discrete trial training strategies in the home setting, as well as within the context of the group classroom setting, to meet her unique needs.
The program offer.
The District’s offer is described in the May 20, 2004, June 30, 2004, and July 15, 2004 IEPs. STUDENT was offered placement in the same special day class that she previously attended for grades one through three, but with a new teacher. The IEP provides that STUDENT will attend school five days a week for four hours each day. STUDENT is the oldest of ten students in the class. The teacher has the assistance of three classroom aides and the same one-to-one aide who worked with STUDENT during the 2003-2004 school year was reassigned to assist her. Goals and objectives are offered in the areas of speech and language (to improve receptive language, to follow a verbal direction, to improve pragmatic and expressive language by greeting a peer, to produce two to four word sentences), self-help skills (to fasten and unfasten pants when using the bathroom, to take a jacket on and off), behavior (to express frustration by asking for an alternative activity instead of tantrumming, to attend to task on table top activities with minimal assistance), socialization (to take turns, to keep hands to herself during unstructured times), preacademic development (to imitate horizontal and vertical lines, to make a circular scribble), prevocational skills (to walk in a line), fine motor skills (to hold a pencil using a tripod grasp, to use a scissor to snip), and gross motor skills (to throw and catch a ball). Assistive technology devices provided for STUDENT include a computer, adapted keyboard, and developmentally appropriate software. In addition, the assistive technology services include staff training.
Also included are the following designated instruction and services: speech and language therapy in three small group thirty-minute sessions each week in school and two sixty-minute sessions each week in a clinic, adapted physical education once each week for forty minutes, physical therapy in four fifty-minute sessions each week once in school and three times in a clinic, and occupational therapy in one individual fifty-minute session each week in school. Extended school year services are offered to prevent regression. Modifications include repetition, consistency, one-step directions, reinforcers, easy access seating, and assistance during eating. A behavior support plan is also attached to STUDENT’s IEP.
Student’s parents have consented to the following components of the educational program and therefore these parts of the educational program are not in dispute: attendance in the special day class for fifteen of the twenty hours offered, the assistance of a one-to-one aide, three sessions each week of speech and language therapy in school, adapted physical education once each week, and the provision of assistive technology devices. (Footnote 16) The Hearing Officer will next examine, within the context of Student’s substantive contentions set out above as Issue II (D) through (H) whether the program offer is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs is reasonably calculated to provide her with educational benefit, and whether the consented-to portions of the IEP have been implemented.
D. Provide goals and objectives designed to meet STUDENT’s unique preacademic/academic, socialization, self-help, and behavioral needs.
Federal and State special education law require generally that the IEP developed for a child with special needs contain the present levels of the child’s educational performance and measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, related to the child’s needs. The purpose of goals and measurable objectives is to permit the IEP team to determine whether the pupil is making progress in an area of need. (See 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a)(2)(i)(ii); 34 C.F.R. Part 300, Appendix A, Q.1; Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.) These statutes generally provide that a child’s broad area of need should be addressed in an IEP. However, there is no specific requirement that the educational program address each and every deficit within an area of need. Indeed, in developing the “individualized” program, the team may consider the particular child’s cognitive skill level, whether the goal is attainable for that child in the allotted time, and the child’s schedule and health needs.
Academic goals. Turning first to the question of whether there should be additional preacademic goals, Student contends that although the assessments and progress reports revealed that she does not understand the mathematical concept of one-to-one correspondence and is unable to identify colors or recognize letters, no goals were written in these areas. According to Student’s counsel, Student requires goals and objectives in these areas to benefit from her educational program. The District concedes that these are areas of deficit but argues that STUDENT’s current functioning is too low to include goals to address these deficits.
The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the testimony of the witnesses from both sides that goals addressing these deficits are beyond STUDENT’s current skill level at this time, that it would not be reasonable to expect that she would demonstrate progress in these areas, and that these areas would be too frustrating for her. The Hearing Officer observes it is undisputed that STUDENT’s frustration often leads to behaviors that interfere with her ability to access the curriculum. Ms. Katelanis testified that a task needs to be close to STUDENT’s developmental level in order for her to learn. Thus, for example, Ms. Machado, STUDENT’s special day class teacher, testified that STUDENT presently is not able to count more than two objects. Ms. Katelanis persuasively testified that one-to-one correspondence is conceptually more difficult than counting and that STUDENT must first learn to count. (Footnote 17) Sally Torrens, the behavioral supervisor for STUDENT’s in-home discrete trial training program, testified consistently that goals to identify a number of objects (one-to-one correspondence), had been dropped from the home program precisely because STUDENT became too frustrated when the task was presented to her. Similarly, Ms. Katelanis explained that STUDENT is conceptually unable to distinguish differences, including identifying colors and letters. Ms. Torrens testified that these activities have also been dropped from STUDENT’s in-home program.
Dr. Glover testified persuasively that because STUDENT has been taught almost exclusively in isolated one-to-one settings and because she is now ten years old, it is important to emphasize functional language, self-help, and daily living skills over academic skills at this time. According to Dr. Glover, emphasizing these domains will allow STUDENT to function in a less restrictive environment in the future. Thus, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that it was reasonable to prioritize STUDENT’s academic needs in a manner that promotes her independence. In addition, based upon her performance, it would be unrealistic to expect that she could progress toward achieving these additional academic goals within the allotted time. As set forth above, STUDENT’s IEP addresses her broad area of need in academic readiness. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the preacademic goals set forth in the 2004-2005 IEP are designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and are reasonably calculated to provide her with educational benefit. (Footnote 18)
Social skills goals. The Hearing Officer turns to STUDENT’s need for a toy play goal to address her socialization needs. As set forth above, according to the undisputed testimony of Dr. Glover, the development of social skills is a very important component of STUDENT’s educational program at this time. Both Ms. Sharyn Kerr, an experienced behavioral therapist who has extensive experience with children with autism, and Dr. Davidson testified consistently with District witnesses that pretend or toy play is an important precursor to socializing with peers. Currently, however, STUDENT is unable to play with toys without adult assistance and is only just beginning to play alongside other children. As Dr. Glover further noted, much of STUDENT’s educational experience has been in isolated one-to-one settings and she has not learned either to occupy herself or play with peers. In group settings, such as in the community or in school, there are natural lulls or unstructured times. At present, if STUDENT is not directed to an activity, Dr. Glover observed that STUDENT’s self-stimulatory behaviors increase. The Hearing Officer finds that this area of need is not below STUDENT’s developmental level. In addition, toy play is not adequately addressed in the IEP within the other social skills goals that address taking turns and keeping her hands to herself. Based upon the persuasive testimony from witnesses for both sides, the Hearing Officer finds that a toy play goal should be part of STUDENT’s educational program to meet her socialization needs and toprovide her with educational benefit. Moreover, based upon Dr. Glover’s observation, independent toy play may have the additional benefit of reducing STUDENT’s self-stimulatory behaviors and thus improve her ability to access the curriculum.
Self-help goals. Turning to the need for a feeding goal, the District maintained that a feeding goal is not related to the educational setting and therefore does not need to be addressed by STUDENT’s IEP. Nevertheless, self-help needs such as toileting and dressing are appropriately addressed in STUDENT’s IEP. The Hearing Officer observes that to provide a student with a FAPE, an IEP must prepare a student for independent living. An educational program that addresses eating without gagging, vomiting, or biting on utensils provides a means by which STUDENT can work toward independence and thus is educationally necessary. However, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP effectively addresses this need. The IEP expressly lists “assistance with eating” as a modification to STUDENT’s program. Moreover, the evidence established that STUDENT’s aide was provided training by a feeding therapist who had been working with STUDENT in her home program. STUDENT’s aide testified that she helped STUDENT to eat and that while STUDENT has vomited a few times, she no longer does so on a weekly basis. Ms. Machado, STUDENT’s current teacher, testified that at school, STUDENT has made progress in eating independently and using utensils. The Hearing Officer observes that the behavior support plan addresses STUDENT’s inappropriate biting of objects, which necessarily includes biting on eating utensils. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not require a more specific feeding goal to meet her self-help needs or provide her with educational benefit.
Behavioral goals. As set out above, the parties generally agree that STUDENT has significant behavioral problems that interfere with her ability to access the curriculum. Student argues that the IEP lacks goals and objectives to meet all her behavioral needs and that the behavioral support plan was developed without sufficient personnel, fails to target each of her behavioral needs, and lacks specificity. The District maintains that STUDENT’s behavioral needs are sufficiently addressed by the behavior support plan attached to the 2004-2005 IEP.
The Hearing Officer finds that Student’s contentions regarding the behavior support plan do not have merit. First, each of STUDENT’s behavioral problems are either identified as goals in the 2004-2005 IEP or in the behavioral support plan. Goals in STUDENT’s IEP include keeping her hands to herself (to address aggression), expressing frustration or choosing an alternative activity (to address frustration), and greeting peers without repetition of greetings (to address perseverative greetings). The behavior support plan addresses tantrumming and asking to go to the bathroom to avoid an activity. (Student Exh. 8.)
Next, as stated above, there is no legal requirement that every provider be present when the educational program is offered. In this case, the record revealed that STUDENT’s former teacher provided her input and records to Ms. Katelanis who assisted the IEP team in developing the behavior support plan. Ms. Katelanis also relied on the input from Ms. Carlson, STUDENT’s speech pathologist, who is knowledgeable about STUDENT’s behaviors and who had observed STUDENT first-hand in the special day class and during individual speech and language sessions.
Moreover, there is no requirement that a behavioral support plan comply with the legal requirements of a more formal behavioral intervention plan, including data collection methods, identification of antecedents, behaviors, and consequences, and a listing of reinforcers. (Compare with Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56520-56524 (the “Hughes Bill”); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3052.) When “an individual exhibits a serious behavior problem that significantly interferes with the implementation of the goals and objectives of the individual’s IEP,” a “behavioral intervention plan” must be written and become part of the IEP. (Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(f).) (Footnote 19) In this case, there was no allegation or any showing that STUDENT required the more formal behavior intervention plan. Accordingly, the concerns of Student that the plan lacked specificity are not well taken. The Hearing Officer finds that the behavior support plan complied with legal requirements.
Further, Student also contends that the mastery level of many of the short-term objectives in her IEP are below eighty percent and are therefore too low. Short-term objectives or benchmarks are included in a student’s IEP for the IEP team to measure the pupil’s progress. (34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a)(2).) Neither federal nor State special education law require that in order to measure progress the student must achieve an objective at a particular percentage level. Rather, the IEP is an “individualized” program and the measure of progress must be based upon the skill level a particular student can attain. Other than referencing the general standard another school district may have adopted, Student has not presented the Hearing Officer with any legal authority to support her position. Student challenged the mastery levels in several goals including the goals to improve expressive language, to reduce tantrums, and to imitate lines and shapes. Each of the disputed goals reports STUDENT’s present level of performance and sets the measure of progress in the short-term benchmarks with either increasing levels of mastery or increasingly difficult tasks. The Hearing Officer finds that there is sufficient information to measure progress and to determine whether STUDENT is deriving educational benefit from her program.
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that with the exception of the toy play goal, the goals and objectives set forth in STUDENT’s 2004-2005 IEP are sufficient to measure STUDENT’s progress and are designed to meet her unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide her with educational benefit.
E. Continue District-funded in-home discrete trial training services.
The parties generally agree that the application of discrete trial training techniques is an effective strategy to address STUDENT’s academic, communication, and behavioral needs both at home and in school. At present, STUDENT receives twelve hours of in-home DTT therapy through the Regional Center. A key dispute among the parties is whether the additional fifteen hours of in-home DTT services that had been funded by the District for six months pursuant to the January 31, 2004 settlement agreement should be discontinued. Student asserts that she continues to need the additional in-home therapy to address her behavioral needs and provide her with educational benefit. In addition, Student asserts she continues to need the in-home therapy because her teacher and aide are not sufficiently trained to apply this strategy in the classroom and because she is making progress in the intensive in-home program. At a minimum, according to Student, rather than eliminating the District-funded in-home DTT services altogether, she needs a transition plan. The District maintains that STUDENT has not met many of her goals in the home program and that her other needs, including her need to generalize across environments and to develop social skills, require that she increase her attendance in the school environment. The District argues further that the total number of hours Student requests for her educational program would be overly burdensome and would not meet her needs.
According to Dr. Glover, Ms. Torrens, and Ms. Kerr, DTT is a teaching method that may be used regardless of the content area and which breaks a task into simple steps, provides a response, includes prompting as needed, and gives reinforcement. Dr. Glover explained that the purpose of intensive one-to-one highly structured intervention such as DTT is to reduce maladaptive behaviors that cause a child to be unable to function in a less restrictive environment, such as a school setting. Based upon her first-hand observations of STUDENT at home and in school, Dr. Glover concluded that STUDENT has learned to attend to a stimulus, make a response, appreciate reinforcement when she is correct, and comply with simple directions. Dr. Glover opined that STUDENT has accomplished these “learning to learn” building blocks and should move as quickly as possible to the more naturalistic school setting. According to Dr. Glover, STUDENT has been taught in one-to-one isolated settings for much of her educational life. As a result, STUDENT is prompt dependent, overly structured, and adult oriented. Exclusive one-to-one training does not permit STUDENT the opportunity to practice self-control, to observe and interact with peers and role models, to occupy herself during unstructured times, to engage in routine social interactions, and to generalize her skills in the more social school environment. Although Dr. Glover recognized that STUDENT continues to need one-to-one teaching, she also needs group-based activities. STUDENT would learn to focus in an environment with distractions and the presence of other children would diffuse the availability of adult attention, thereby promoting her independence. Dr. Davidson, Ms. Kerr, and Ms. Torrens agreed that STUDENT needs placement in a school setting where school staff is trained in the application of DTT strategies and is able to provide her an adequate amount of one-to-one teaching. They also believed, however, that STUDENT continues to need the additional fifteen hours of District-funded in-home DTT services over and above the twelve hours provided by the Regional Center.
Sally Torrens, the behavioral therapist supervising STUDENT’s in-home DTT program, testified consistently that as of June 2004, STUDENT was able to sit and attend, respond to requests, take in feedback, and understand cause and effect. However, Ms. Torrens disagreed that STUDENT was ready to move to the classroom setting, finding STUDENT to be only at the very beginning stages of DTT learning. Ms. Torrens based her opinion on a text authored by Dr. Ron Leaf that a move to the classroom should not be made until a student has reached the “middle stage” of discrete trial training. However, the Hearing Officer declines to assign evidentiary value to a text that was not provided to the District because the District then lacked the opportunity to cross-examine Ms. Torrens on the book’s content. Importantly, the Hearing Officer has no way to know the context of Dr. Leaf’s conclusions and no way to judge whether, like Dr. Glover, Dr. Leaf’s theoretical construct takes account of STUDENT’s specific age and social needs.
Sharyn Kerr, the clinical director of Autism Comprehensive Educational Services, also testified on behalf of Student. Based upon her observations of STUDENT’s home program, Ms. Kerr reported that, with the exception of verbal self-stimulatory behavior, other targeted behaviors either were reduced or remained stable. (Student Exh. 21.) Ms. Kerr was of the opinion that STUDENT would benefit from a continuation of the use of DTT in a one-to-one setting. However, Ms. Kerr acknowledged that although STUDENT benefitted from her home program, STUDENT was also able to function in the classroom.
Finally, the Hearing Officer accords Dr. Davidson’s opinion that STUDENT should continue to receive District-funded in-home DTT services little weight. Dr. Davidson based her opinion that in-home DTT services should not be “abandoned” in large measure on the report from UCLA which concluded in 2003 that STUDENT required intensive behavioral intervention. The Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Davidson’s opinion ignores the fact that STUDENT continues to receive in-home DTT services from the Regional Center. Moreover, as Dr. Glover convincingly testified, the UCLA recommendations were made at a time before STUDENT had received any DTT services at all. The Hearing Officer observes that there was no testimony from the UCLA assessors and thus the Hearing Officer has no way to determine whether the same recommendation would be made at this time.
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds Dr. Glover’s opinion that STUDENT is ready to move to the classroom setting more convincing than Student’s witnesses. First, Dr. Glover took account of all of STUDENT’s needs, including her age, her need to develop social skills, social language, and communication, and her need to learn to play with and model her behaviors after her peers. Second, although there was some disagreement concerning the number of hours STUDENT should attend school, Ms. Kerr agreed that STUDENT benefitted from the school setting. Finally, the Hearing Officer assigned the opinions of Ms. Torrens and Dr. Davidson in this regard little weight for the reasons set forth above. Thus, if these were the only factors to consider, the Hearing Officer would find that STUDENT no longer requires the fifteen hours of District-funded in-home DTT services in order to be provided a FAPE. STUDENT would attend the school program where trained personnel would work with STUDENT on a one-to-one basis applying the discrete trial training strategies that have proven to be a successful intervention for her. Importantly, STUDENT would derive educational benefit from the school program that was designed to meet her social skills, language and communication, and behavioral needs, and that satisfies the IDEA’s goal to promote independence. Moreover, placement in the school program in lieu of the District-funded in-home program is consistent with least restrictive environment principles.
However, the Hearing Officer finds that a significant assumption underlying Dr. Glover’s opinion changed after Dr. Glover wrote her report but before the IEP team developed STUDENT’s educational program. Dr. Glover’s recommendation to discontinue District-funded in-home DTT services was based in substantial part on her June 2004 observation of STUDENT’s teacher and aide who “demonstrated a good understanding of DTT principles and utilized these principles in a natural environment.” (District Exh. 14.) Unfortunately, however, sometime before July 2004, STUDENT’s classroom teacher terminated her employment with the District. This change in personnel was especially important in light of Dr. Glover’s report which found the special day class placement “inappropriate for STUDENT [in the long run] because of the wide discrepancy between her level of functioning and those of her classmates.” (District Exh. 14.) Indeed, Dr. Glover’s recommendation to place STUDENT back in this classroom in spite of her concerns was based upon STUDENT’s demonstrated familiarity with the particular class routines, classmates, and teacher. The IEP team met in July 2004 and adopted Dr. Glover’s recommendation to eliminate the District-funded in-home DTT services even though it did not yet know either the identity of STUDENT’s new teacher or the experience with DTT the teacher would have. However, an IEP must take into account what was fairly known to the team and what was objectively reasonable at the time the educational program was developed. (See Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141 (9th Cir. 1999).) The District should have known at the time of the July 2004 IEP meeting that it was unable to assess the effect of this dramatic reduction by more than half of the in-home DTT services on STUDENT’s ability to derive educational benefit from her educational program.
By all accounts, both STUDENT’s current teacher and one-to-one aide are well meaning and work hard with STUDENT. However, Ms. Machado, STUDENT’s current teacher, is currently attending school to obtain her teaching credential and has only an internship teaching credential. She testified that she has been exposed to discrete trial training principles but has not had training or supervision by a behaviorist who applied DTT. Ms. Machado also testified that she is more familiar with pivotal response training techniques, but Dr. Glover explained at hearing that pivotal response training is more content specific and is best used in conjunction with DTT principles. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Machado’s limited knowledge of general DTT principles with no opportunity for supervision or feedback is insufficient training and experience to meet STUDENT’s educational needs and provide her with educational benefit.
In addition to relying on the training and experience of STUDENT’s teacher, Dr. Glover’s opinion was also based on the assumption that STUDENT’s aide would be able to provide one-to-one teaching applying DTT strategies. STUDENT’s aide testified that she only received ten hours of training by someone named Natalie but was unable to describe the training sessions. She has not been observed or supervised applying DTT strategies. According to observations by Dr. Glover, Dr. Davidson, and Ms. Torrens, STUDENT’s aide possesses some basic skills but is too intrusive and in need of training to reduce or scale back prompts. As Dr. Glover explained in her assessment report, skills to be taught must be broken down into smaller parts and each smaller part, or sub-skill, should be taught one at a time. In addition, the effective use of a hierarchy of prompts ensures that a student experiences success and is a key principle of DTT strategy. (Footnote 20) (District Exh. 14.) Ms. Kerr observed that STUDENT’s aide did not instruct STUDENT using small steps. The Hearing Officer finds, therefore, that because STUDENT’s one-to-one aide is unable to demonstrate key components of DTT strategy and has had no opportunity for supervision or feedback, she lacks sufficient training and experience to meet STUDENT’s educational needs and provide her with educational benefit.
The Hearing Officer has found above that there is no dispute that application of discrete trial training principles both at home and in school is an effective learning strategy for STUDENT and plays a critical role in her ability to access the curriculum. Further, there is general agreement that in order to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and to provide her with some educational benefit, school staff must be trained and experienced in one-to-one teaching using DTT strategies. Since Dr. Glover wrote her report in June 2004, she has not had the opportunity to observe STUDENT’s current teacher. As found above, however, both STUDENT’s teacher and her one-to-one aide lack the necessary training and experience at this time to provide what all agree is a crucial learning strategy. Moreover, Dr. Glover’s recommendation to discontinue District-funded in-home DTT services was also dependent in part upon STUDENT’s familiarity with her trained and experienced teacher, an individual who is no longer employed with the District. At hearing, Dr. Glover conceded that if STUDENT’s current teacher has less training and experience applying DTT principles than the teacher she observed during her June 2004 assessment, it might be necessary to continue District-funded in-home DTT intervention but that “[i]t wouldn’t be horrible if the home program was abruptly stopped.” However, based upon the totality of the circumstances just described, the Hearing Officer finds more convincing Dr. Glover’s candid acknowledgment that a period of transition during which time STUDENT’s teacher and aide receive additional training would meet STUDENT’s needs and benefit STUDENT. During the time the District-funded in-home program is continued, STUDENT could gradually increase the hours she attends school. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that before the District-funded in-home DTT program can be eliminated, a transition plan must be developed that includes a provision for providing additional DTT training, supervision, and feedback to STUDENT’s teacher and one-to-one aide during the period of transition.
The evidence established at hearing that both Ms. Machado and STUDENT’s aide have received limited training in DTT principles and application of these strategies to children with autism and mental retardation. Accordingly, within twenty calendar days from the date of this Decision, the District shall develop and implement a training program which includes ten hours of didactic training in DTT principles and application of these strategies to children with autism and mental retardation and a regular schedule of supervision and feedback for STUDENT’s teacher and aide. The District shall receive input from STUDENT’s in-home behavioral supervisor and any additional resources identified by the District as appropriate for this training purpose. The didactic component of the training program shall be completed no later than February 25, 2005, the last school day before the March 2005 off-track period. Supervision and feedback can begin during the didactic training period and shall resume when school is in session starting on March 28, 2005, and continuing to no later than April 29, 2005, in time to provide progress reports to the IEP team which is scheduled to conduct STUDENT’s annual review in May 2005.
Additionally, the IEP team shall reconvene to develop a transition plan to coincide with the training program just described and the provisions of the plan shall be completed no later than April 29, 2005. The Hearing Officer finds this to be a reasonable period of transition in light of STUDENT’s age, her need to be among peers, Ms. Machado’s testimony that additional hours in school will allow her to work with STUDENT more consistently, the goal of the IDEA to promote independence, and the requirement that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment. For the purposes of developing the transition plan, the IEP team shall include STUDENT’s in-home DTT behavioral supervisor. The transition plan shall take account of STUDENT’s need for social interaction and, where practicable, consider Dr. Glover’s recommendation to include her parents, brother, and neighborhood children. The transition plan shall provide for a gradual decrease of the District-funded in-home DTT program starting at no more than fifteen hours each week, or fewer as may be determined at the discretion of the IEP team, while STUDENT’s teacher and aide receive the didactic training, supervision, and feedback just described. The transition plan shall provide for a gradual increase in STUDENT’s school attendance until she reaches twenty hours each week, or more as may be determined by the IEP team, that takes account of STUDENT’s scheduling and health needs.
The District shall fund the additional hours of in-home DTT services in an amount not to exceed fifteen hours each week, as agreed-upon by the IEP team, for the period of the transition. Additionally, the District shall arrange for Pacific Child Family Associates (PCFA), the certified nonpublic agency which previously provided these services for the District and is the current provider of the in-home services provided by the Regional Center, to provide STUDENT with DTT pursuant to the terms of the transition plan described above. Such an arrangement shall enable STUDENT to continue with familiar therapists and allow for a coordination of services. In the event that PCFA is unable or unwilling to perform this service, the IEP team shall identify and arrange for another certified nonpublic agency or qualified District personnel to provide the additional in-home DTT services.
The IEP team shall determine whether District-funded in-home DTT services will be required during the February 28, 2005 through March 25, 2005 off-track period to prevent regression, taking into account the Hearing Officer’s findings below concerning the provision of services during the off-track periods.
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that, under the circumstances of this particular case, the District should have but failed to continue providing STUDENT fifteen hours each week of District-funded in-home DTT services until her new classroom teacher and one-to-one aide were sufficiently trained, and should have but failed to develop an appropriate transition plan for the cessation of the District-funded in-home DTT program.
F. Develop a system of collaboration between STUDENT’s in-home and school programs.
As found above, there is no dispute that STUDENT’s performance is inconsistent and that she needs to learn to generalize across environments. Witnesses from both sides testified as to the importance of cooperation among all the home therapists and school staff, including the related service providers, to identify successful interventions across environments and to develop consistency within STUDENT’s program. (See, e.g., Student Exh. 19.) In her assessment report, Dr. Glover recommended a “program coordinator” with expertise in autism to work across home and school environments to ensure consistency and communication. (District Exh. 14.) Ms. Kerr testified convincingly that communication of successful interventions among staff provides for a more effective and efficient program. Thus, based upon the undisputed evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the complete omission of a system of collaboration between home and school programs in STUDENT’s 2004-2005 IEP does not meet her needs and is not reasonably calculated to provide her benefit. The inclusion of a system of collaboration in STUDENT’s program takes on heightened significance as STUDENT transitions to increasing hours of attendance at school and fewer hours of in-home services. Dr. Glover testified that in order to integrate the home and school curriculum, in-home staff could come to school and STUDENT’s one-to-one aide could visit the home program. MOTHER testified that she has invited STUDENT’s teacher and aide into her home. Accordingly, the IEP team shall identify the members of STUDENT’s collaboration team, arrange for one visit by STUDENT’s teacher and aide to observe the home program, and establish a regular meeting schedule or other convenient system of communication between in-home providers and school staff.
G. Provide designated instruction and services and in-home DTT during the off-track periods.
Extended school year services (ESY) are educational services that extend instruction beyond the normal school year to prevent serious regression over the summer months. (Hoeft v. Tucson Unified School District, 967 F.3d 1298, 1301 (9th Cir. 1992).) In California, a school district is required to provide a special education student ESY programming when the student requires special education and related services in excess of the regular academic year or when the IEP team has determined the need for ESY programming. (Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043.) Students entitled to receive ESY services are defined as:
Such individuals ... have handicaps which are likely to continue indefinitely or for a prolonged period, and interruption of the pupil’s educational programming may cause regression, when coupled with limited recoupment capacity, rendering it impossible or unlikely that the pupil will attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that would otherwise be expected in view of his or her handicapping condition. (Id.)
As set out above, STUDENT’s school is on a year round schedule. During the 2004-2005 school year, the extended school year is considered by the District to be July 2005. This extended school year period is included in STUDENT’s 2004-2005 IEP “to prevent regression.” (Student Exh. 8.) According to the school calendar, STUDENT’s assigned elementary school is not in session during additional “off-track” periods, including the period from October 25, 2004, through November 23, 2004, with three additional days for the Thanksgiving holiday, and the period from February 28, 2005, through March 25, 2005. MOTHER testified that STUDENT received two weeks of designated instruction and services during the November 2004 off-track period. Student maintains that the District should have provided three instead of two weeks of designated instruction and services during the October to November off-track period, and should have offered two weeks of designated instruction and services during the February through March 2005 off-track period in the 2004-2005 school year. Student also argues that she requires District-funded in-home DTT services during the off-track periods. The District maintains that STUDENT does not require any services during the “off-track” period.
The District failed to establish at the due process hearing that STUDENT would not regress during the off-track period. Ms. Machado, STUDENT’s current SDC teacher, acknowledged that she is unable to provide an opinion because she has not seen STUDENT after a prolonged absence. There was no testimony from any District witness that STUDENT would not regress or had shown the ability to recoup lost skills after an extended break. In fact, to the contrary, Dr. Glover reported that STUDENT needs “mass repetitions” to learn skills and testified along with Ms. Katelanis that STUDENT is unable to generalize skills. The Hearing Officer further observes that STUDENT was provided with designated instruction and services during the November 2003 and March 2004 off-track periods as described in the May 2003 IEP. (Student Exh. 43.) In addition, the 2004-2005 IEP provides for services during the July 2005 extended school year. The District did not effectively explain why the District members of the IEP team believed STUDENT would regress during July 2005 but not during the remaining off-track period for the 2004-2005 school year, namely in February-March 2005 (a break of four weeks). Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that to propose a program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide her educational benefit, the District should have included a provision for two weeks of designated instruction and services to be provided during the off-track periods. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to include a provision for services during off-track periods in the IEP.
The Hearing Officer notes that, according to MOTHER’s testimony, the District actually provided STUDENT two weeks of services during the off track period in November 2004. Nevertheless, Student argues that because the November off-track period was three days longer than the typical off-track break, she should have received three weeks of services instead of the two which were provided. The Hearing Officer observes that STUDENT has consistently been provided with no more than two weeks of services during the off-track periods in the past. The November 2004 off-track period was three days longer because it included three days for the Thanksgiving holiday when no services could have been provided. Thus, while the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was entitled to two week of services during the off-track periods during the 2004-2005 school year, the Hearing Officer finds Student’s additional contention that she required three weeks unavailing.
Turning to the question of whether STUDENT also requires District-funded in-home DTT services during the off-track periods so that she will not regress, the Hearing Officer has already found above that the District should have developed an appropriate plan to transition STUDENT from its home DTT program and should have continued to offer STUDENT the fifteen-hour per week DTT home program until its staff was sufficiently trained. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that for the same reasons, STUDENT requires designated instruction and services during the off-track periods, STUDENT was entitled to receive two weeks of fifteen hours each of District-funded in-home DTT services during the November 2004 off-track period to prevent regression. However, according to Student, the Regional Center already funded the additional hours of DTT during the November 2004 off-track period and thus, Student is not entitled to a remedy. Whether STUDENT will continue to require all or some of the DTT services during the February-March 2005 off-track period will be dependent upon the transition plan developed by the IEP team as described above. The Hearing Officer will leave to the discretion of the IEP team the determination of whether STUDENT will require all or part of these District-funded DTT services during the February-March 2005 off-track period, as it gradually reduces these services in keeping with the discussion set out above.
G. Timely implement consented-to components of the IEP.
The parties agree that STUDENT’s parents consented to components of the 2004-2005 IEP. However, the parties disagree about when the consent was provided. Student asserted her parents consented on August 31, 2004, in a letter written by their attorney. On the other hand, the District maintains that it received consent when MOTHER signed the IEP addendum on October 4, 2004.
State special education law provides that a special education program cannot be implemented until the student’s parent consents in writing to all or part of the IEP. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(a).) Section 56346(a) further provides that “if the parent does not consent to all components of the [IEP], then those components of the program to which the parent has consented shall be implemented so as not to delay providing instruction and services to the pupil.” The question in this particular case is whether Student’s attorney can authorize consent to components of the IEP on Student’s parents’ behalf.
On August 31, 2004, Student’s counsel addressed a letter to the District’s attorney consenting to components of the IEP and a copy was provided to Student’s parents. (Student Exh. 34.) It was not until two weeks later that Mr. Walker wrote to Student’s counsel informing him that Student’s parents had to sign the IEP if they wanted to consent to the IEP. (Student Exh. 35.) On September 21, 2004, MOTHER faxed a letter to the principal of STUDENT’s school confirming her consent and referencing the August 31, 2004 attorney letter. (Student Exh. 36.) On October 4, 2004, at the IEP meeting convened to discuss the health and development assessment, MOTHER signed the IEP addendum indicating her consent to the same components of the IEP. (District Exh. 17.)
Mr. Walker testified that the District does not accept a “random” attorney letter in lieu of signed parental consent because it cannot be certain that the attorney has the authority to represent the wishes of the parent. While the District’s argument may be theoretically tenable, here the record does not support its position. Rather, from the following facts the record establishes that the District had a clear indication that there had been some form of consent and that it should have, but failed to, timely investigate further. First, along with MOTHER, both Student’s counsel and the District’s counsel attended the July 15, 2004 IEP meeting that is the subject of this dispute. Second, on September 17, 2004, Mr. Walker wrote to Student’s counsel addressing his letter to Student’s parents in care of their attorney. From this record, the Hearing Officer finds that the District knew Student was represented by counsel and who the attorney was. Further, the Hearing Officer observes that when parties are represented, communications are typically directed through attorneys rather than between the parties themselves. Even if the District was uncertain as to Student’s counsel’s authority to consent on the parents’ behalf, it should have timely directed an inquiry to STUDENT’s parents to verify their wishes. Moreover, on September 21, 2004, MOTHER faxed a letter to the school principal consenting to the same components of STUDENT’s IEP as noted in her attorney’s letter. Further, contrary to the District’s position, there is nothing in either federal or State special education law that requires written parental consent to be on the IEP document. Finally, under the facts of this particular case, the District did not effectively explain why it waited nearly two weeks to respond to the attorney letter to verify or confirm that Student’s parents consented to the components of the IEP set forth in the attorney letter. The Hearing Officer observes that the intent of California Education Code section 56346(a) is to implement consented-to provisions of the IEP without delay, for the benefit of the student.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that under the particular facts and circumstances of this case, Student’s parents consented to the following components of the 2004-2005 IEP on August 31, 2004: attendance in the special day class for fifteen hours each week, a one-to-one aide for the entirety of the school day, three thirty-minute small group-sessions of speech and language services each week, adapted physical education once a week in a forty-minute small-group session, and the provision of assistive technology devices and staff training. The Hearing Officer notes the District has provided STUDENT placement in the special day class at R.D. White with the support of a one-to-one aide for the entirety of the school day since September 1, 2004, the start date of the 2004-2005 IEP. However, there is no dispute that the APE services have not yet been implemented, that the AT devices have yet to be provided to STUDENT, that the staff has not been provided training on the use of the AT devices, and that the District waited until October 4, 2004, to implement the speech and language therapy sessions. The consequences of these errors will be addressed below in Issue No. IV.
* * * *
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that there were no procedural violations that denied STUDENT a FAPE. However, the Hearing Officer finds that the 2004-2005 IEP improperly fails to provide: (1) a toy play goal; (2) teacher and aide training, feedback, and supervision in DTT principles; (3) a system of collaboration among STUDENT’s in-home and school service providers; (4) a transition plan to gradually reduce District-funded in-home DTT services instead of abruptly eliminating them; and (5) two weeks of designated instruction and services during the off-track periods. Additionally, the District failed to implement certain consented-to components of the 2004-2005 IEP in a timely manner. As a result, taking into consideration all the violations, the Hearing Officer finds that the program offered and provided by the District for the 2004-2005 school year is not designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs, is not reasonably calculated to provide her with benefit, and did not comport with the consented-to components of the IEP in the respects described above. Because of the totality and significance of the violations, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has not offered or provided STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year.
Issue No. III: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for independent educational evaluations they obtained?
A parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation (IEE) performed by a qualified specialist at public expense if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the educational agency, and the educational agency is unable to show at a due process hearing that its assessment was appropriate. (34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b).)
Student’s parents seek reimbursement for the evaluations conducted by Sharyn Kerr and Dr. Chris Davidson. (Student Exhs. 21 and 22.) However, there is no legal authority for Student’s position that her parents are entitled to reimbursement for these IEEs as a result of the timing of the District’s contract with Dr. Glover. As found above, the District did not delay in obtaining Dr. Glover’s assessment. Under the circumstances of this case, pursuant to the parties’ January 31, 2004 settlement agreement, Student waived the applicable statutory timelines. Moreover, Dr. Glover’s assessment thereafter comported with the agreed-upon timelines and her report was presented to the IEP team well in advance of the July 15, 2004 IEP meeting where the educational program offer for the 2004-2005 school year was made. Further, the Hearing Officer found above that the District’s assessments were appropriate. Accordingly, STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the IEEs they obtained.
Issue No. IV: If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 2004-2005 school year, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory educational services from September 1, 2004, through the date of this Decision?
The Hearing Officer found above that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year and failed to implement the consented-to components of STUDENT’s 2004-2005 IEP beginning on September 1, 2004, which included speech and language services, adapted physical education, and assistive technology devices and staff training. Student seeks compensatory educational services to make up for seven speech and language therapy sessions and seven adapted physical education sessions she missed as a result of the District’s failure to timely implement the consented-to components of the 2004-2005 IEP. Student also seeks immediate implementation of the assistive technology devices and the agreed-upon staff training. Finally, Student seeks compensatory educational services to make up for the fifteen hours each week of District-funded in-home DTT services to which she claims she was entitled from September 1, 2004, through October 23, 2004, and from November 28, 2004, through the date of this Decision. The District believes STUDENT is not entitled to any remedies because her parents did not bring her to school for enough hours in which to provide the additional services.
When a school district denies a special education student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. In addition, equitable considerations may be weighed in granting relief and courts have broad discretion in fashioning a remedy which helps a student overcome lost educational opportunity. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 358 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994).) There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the petitioner is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” (Puyallup, 31 F.3d at 1497.)
The Hearing Officer observes that in granting equitable relief, parents’ behavior may be taken into account. In this case, from September 1, 2004, to the close of the evidentiary record in this case on December 4, 2004, the parents brought STUDENT to school for only approximately ten to thirteen hours each week. In addition, from September 1, 2004, through September 21, 2004, STUDENT did not attend school on Wednesdays. Starting on September 22, 2004, STUDENT comes to school on Wednesday mornings but she ends her day shortly before APE is offered at R.D. White. However, the evidence also established that in addition to attending school, STUDENT’s schedule includes clinic-based designated instruction and services. (Footnote 21) These additional services are provided by the District and the provision of these further services competes with the District’s own schedule for APE. Thus, except for the limited time from September 1, 2004, through September 21, 2004, when STUDENT did not attend school on Wednesdays at all, the District’s purported inability to provide services to STUDENT was because of its own scheduling conflicts and the Hearing Officer therefore finds that the District remained obligated to implement the agreed-to services.
APE services. As found above, there is no dispute that the District has yet to provide any APE services to STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds that providing no services at all amounts to a loss of educational opportunity. However, the District established that it remained willing and able to provide STUDENT with APE services on Wednesday afternoons starting at 12:15 p.m. As found above, STUDENT’s parents voluntarily elected not to bring STUDENT to school at all on Wednesdays until September 22, 2004. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is not entitled to a remedy for the missed APE sessions from September 1, 2004, through September 21, 2004. However, from September 22, 2004, to the date of this Decision, the District should have provided the agreed-to APE services to STUDENT. As found above, STUDENT left school at 12:15 p.m. on Wednesdays when the District provided APE only because she was scheduled to attend District-provided OT services at a nonpublic agency at 2:00 o’clock that same afternoon. The District provided no evidence that it made any effort to reconcile the scheduling conflict or that it asked MOTHER to change the time of the OT session. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was entitled to APE services from September 22, 2004, through the date of this Decision, and that, due to the District’s failure to provide the required APE services, STUDENT is entitled to the seven compensatory APE sessions requested. These seven additional APE sessions shall be completed by the end of the 2004-2005 regular school year, which is June 29, 2005.
SAL services. The Hearing Officer observes that beginning the week of October 4, 2004, Ms. Carlson, the speech and language pathologist, has been meeting with STUDENT three times each week as provided for in the 2004-2005 IEP. However, the parties agree that if the starting date was September 1, 2004, STUDENT missed seven speech and language therapy sessions either because the agreed-to sessions were not provided or because of the failure of Ms. Carlson to make up sessions she missed during her vacation at the end of September. Ms. Carlson testified that STUDENT has exhibited spontaneous speech and language in the classroom and in speech therapy. However, in light of STUDENT’s undisputed significant language and communication delays, the Hearing Officer finds that she lost educational opportunity by the District’s failure to provide seven SAL sessions. As found above, the fact that STUDENT attended school for fewer hours than provided for in the IEP did not foreclose the District from providing the agreed-to services. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is entitled to compensatory education in the amount of seven additional speech and language sessions. These additional SAL sessions shall be completed before the end of the 2004-2005 regular school year on June 29, 2005.
AT devices and staff training. As found above, there was no dispute that the District has yet to provide the AT devices and staff training to use these devices. The District shall immediately provide STUDENT with the AT devices agreed to in the IEP and implement staff training on the use of the ordered software.
DTT services. Student contends that she is entitled prospectively to District-funded in-home DTT services for the failure of the District to continue these services as part of her educational program. However, the Hearing Officer has found above that STUDENT was entitled to a continuation of the District-funded in-home DTT services only as part of a transition plan. Thus, because the District will add these services to STUDENT’s program as part of the transition plan ordered in this Decision, the Hearing Officer finds that any further remedy is unnecessary.
In sum, STUDENT is entitled to seven additional APE sessions, seven additional SAL sessions, and the immediate implementation of the AT services and staff training as compensatory educational services. STUDENT is not entitled, however, to any additional District-funded in-home DTT services except as may be provided for in the transition plan discussed above.
ORDERS
1. In preparation for the transition plan set out below, within twenty calendar days from the date of this Decision, the District shall arrange for Pacific Child Family Associates (PCFA), the certified nonpublic agency that currently provides in-home DTT services to STUDENT, to provide additional in-home DTT services. In the event PCFA is unwilling or unable to perform this service, the IEP team shall identify and arrange for another certified nonpublic agency or qualified District personnel to provide in-home DTT services. Unless the parties agree in writing otherwise, the District-funded in-home DTT services shall be provided in an amount not to exceed fifteen hours each week and only until the transition plan set out below is completed.
2. Within twenty calendar days from the date of this Decision, the District shall develop and implement a training program which includes ten hours of didactic training in DTT principles and application of these strategies to children with autism and mental retardation and a regular schedule of supervision and feedback for STUDENT’s teacher and one-to-one aide. The District shall receive input from STUDENT’s in-home behavioral supervisor and any additional resources identified by the District for this training purpose. The didactic component of the training program shall be completed no later than February 25, 2005, the last school day before the March 2005 off-track period. Supervision and feedback can begin during the didactic training period and shall resume when school is in session starting on March 28, 2005, and continuing to no later than April 29, 2005, in time to provide progress reports to the IEP team which is scheduled to conduct STUDENT’s annual review in May 2005.
3. Within twenty school days from the date of this Decision, the IEP team shall meet and amend STUDENT’s IEP to:
(A) include a goal and objective in the area of toy play;
(B) include the training program and schedule of supervision and feedback for STUDENT’s teacher and one-to-one aide as set forth in Order 2 above;
(C) include a transition plan that provides for a gradual decrease of the District-funded in-home DTT program starting at no more than fifteen hours each week, or fewer as may be determined appropriate at the discretion of the IEP team, while STUDENT’s teacher and aide receive didactic training, supervision, and feedback in DTT. The transition plan shall provide for a gradual increase in STUDENT’s school attendance until she reaches twenty hours each week, or more as may be determined appropriate by the IEP team, that takes account of STUDENT’s scheduling and health needs. The District shall fund the additional hours of in-home DTT services in an amount not to exceed fifteen hours each week, as agreed upon by the IEP team, for the period of the transition. The IEP team shall determine whether District-funded in-home DTT services will be required during the off-track period to prevent regression. For the purposes of developing the transition plan, the IEP team shall include STUDENT’s in-home DTT behavioral supervisor. The transition plan shall coincide with the training program set out in Order 2 and shall be completed no later than April 29, 2005;
(D) include a system of collaboration between the home and school programs. The IEP team shall identify the members of STUDENT’s collaboration team, arrange for one visit by STUDENT’s teacher and aide to observe the home program, and establish a regular meeting schedule or other convenient system of communication;
(E) include a statement that all designated instruction and services shall be provided during the remaining off-track periods in the 2004-2005 school year calendar;
(F) provide as compensatory education seven additional adapted physical education sessions and seven additional speech and language sessions to be completed by June 29, 2005, the last day of the 2004-2005 regular school year; and (G) immediately provide STUDENT with the computer devices named in the IEP and arrange for staff training on the use of these devices to be completed no later than February 25, 2004.
3. Student’s remaining requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
Issue No. I: Was the District’s 2004 triennial assessment of STUDENT appropriate?
The District prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. II: Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) procedurally and substantively for the 2004-2005 regular school year and extended school year by failing to: (A) timely conduct assessments; (B) make a clear and coherent program offer; (C) ensure the presence of all required personnel when the program offer was made; (D) provide goals and objectives designed to meet STUDENT’s unique preacademic/academic, socialization, self-help, and behavioral needs; (E) continue District-funded in-home discrete trial training services; (F) develop a system of collaboration between STUDENT’s in-home and school programs; (G) provide designated instruction and services and in-home DTT during the off-track periods; and (H) timely implement consented-to components of the IEP?
Student prevailed in part and the District prevailed in part. Student prevailed on subpart (D) to the extent the IEP failed to contain a toy play goal; (E) to the extent the District will continue to fund in-home DTT services as part of a transition plan; (F); (G) to the extent the District will provide designated instruction and services during the off-track periods and may have to fund in-home DTT services during the transition plan in accordance with this Decision; and (H) to the extent that APE, AT devices and training, and speech and language therapy were not timely provided. The District prevailed on subparts (A), (B), (C), and (D) to the extent the preacademic/academic, self-help, and behavioral goals (including the behavioral support plan) addressed STUDENT’s needs.
Issue No. III: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for independent educational evaluations they obtained?
The District prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. IV: If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 2004-2005 school year, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory educational services from September 1, 2004, through the date of this Decision?
Student prevailed to the extent she is entitled to seven adapted physical education sessions, seven additional speech and language therapy sessions, and to the immediate provision of the assistive technology devices and staff training. Student’s remaining claims for relief were denied.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety days of receipt of this Decision. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).)
Dated: December 30, 2004 _______________________________ Judith E. Ganz, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. In her closing argument, Student alleged for the first time that: (1) the District either failed to timely initiate a due process hearing or reimburse her parents for independent educational evaluations they obtained; and (2) one of the goals in the July 15, 2004 individualized education program failed to specify how progress would be evaluated. These issues were not raised during hearing and therefore were not addressed by both parties in the presentation of issues and evidence. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer declines to address these additional matters because of the lack of notice to the District that these matters were at issue.
2. In particular, the District moved to dismiss the following issues: (1) did the District appropriately conduct psychoeducational, speech and language, assistive technology, adapted physical education, occupational therapy, and health assessments in May and June 2004; (2) was the independent behavior assessment conducted by Dr. Dorie Glover in June 2004 an appropriate assessment; (3) did the District offer the Student a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year at the IEP meetings held on May 20, 2004, June 30, 2004, and July 15, 2004; (4) did the District offer an appropriate behavior support plan to the Student at the July 15, 2004 IEP team meeting; (5) has the District appropriately implemented the IEP developed for the 2004-2005 school year and is Student entitled to compensatory education for missed services before September 1, 2004; and (6) are the parents entitled to reimbursement for the independent behavior assessment obtained from ACES and an independent psychoeducational assessment obtained from Dr. Chris Davidson?
3. Unless otherwise indicated by the context, the Hearing Officer will refer to the IEPs developed in May, June, and July 2004, all of which addressed STUDENT’s program for the 2004-2005 school year, collectively as the 2004-2005 IEP.
4. According to MOTHER, a one-to-one aide from a nonpublic agency was provided at the parents’ expense to work with STUDENT in the classroom for two weeks. Apparently on February 13, 2003, the parties entered into a settlement agreement to settle a then-pending due process hearing. MOTHER testified that the District agreed to provide one-to-one support. When the aide was assigned, STUDENT returned to school in March 2003 and remained in school until the end of June 2003. Although the specific agreement was not made part of the record in this matter, the settlement was referenced in a Memorandum Order Re: Settlement and Dismissal dated February 26, 2004, which had been issued by the Hearing Office in another case between the parties. (See Glendale Unified School District vs. STUDENT, Case No. SN03-02226/SN03-02273.)
5. Goals and objectives were developed to: follow commands, answer “who,” “what,” and “where” questions, initiate a three word phrase, use a pincer grasp, pull pants up during dressing or after toileting, cease unsolicited hugs and grabbing of peers, take turns, ambulate independently up and down inclines, ascend ten stairs using a railing and alternating her feet, position herself on a chair and get on and off, ambulate while holding weights, improve dressing skills, throw a ball overhead with directionality, walk in a line, count out three objects, say “I want” rather than grab, keep hands to herself, parallel play, greet teacher and peers, sort two shapes, fill in stencils, wash and dry her hands, and look at the speaker when verbally prompted.
6. R.D. White Elementary School is on a year-round“track” schedule (track D). School was not in session during July 2003. For the 2003-2004 school year, school was not in session from October 27, 2003, through November 26, 2003 (plus two days for the Thanksgiving holiday), March 1, 2004, through March 24, 2004, and for the month of July 2004. (Student Exh. 44.) For the 2004-2005 school year, school is not in session from October 25, 2004, through November 23, 2004 (plus three additional days for “student free day” and Thanksgiving), and February 28, 2005, through March 25, 2005. (Student Exh. 45.)
7. MOTHER testified that STUDENT first started to receive in-home DTT services in February 2004.
8. As will be set forth below, STUDENT returned to school on March 25, 2004.
9. On Tuesdays, STUDENT received District-funded PT services at a nonpublic agency, District-funded SAL at a nonpublic agency, and in-home DTT services in the afternoon provided by the Regional Center. (Testimony of MOTHER.)
10. As will be discussed below, the dispute among the parties is whether STUDENT should have received three weeks instead of two weeks of DIS during this particular off-track period. During this off-track period, the Regional Center provided an additional fifteen hours of in-home DTT services each week, over and above the twelve hours each week of services that it ordinarily provided.
11. At the start of the hearing, Student also identified as an issue for hearing that the District’s speech and language assessment was inappropriate. However, in her closing brief, based upon testimony at the hearing from the speech and language pathologist regarding the manufacturer’s test instructions, Student withdrew that issue. (Student’s Closing Brief, p. 10, fn.2.)
12. As set out above in the background facts, the District provided a proposed assessment plan to STUDENT’s parents on February 20, 2004. (District Exh. 5.) In the several months that followed, correspondence between STUDENT’s parents and the Districts indicated that the parties were unable to reach complete agreement on the scope of the proposed assessments. (See Student Exhs. 13, 23, 25, 26; District Exhs. 5, 6.) However, it is undisputed that all of the assessments were performed with parental consent.
13. Dr. Davidson testified that children get smarter and tests have to be renormed to keep up with their changing performance.
14. As will be set forth below, the Hearing Officer finds that the psychoeducational assessment comported with legal requirements. However, the Hearing Officer observes that there was no testimony to contradict Dr. Davidson’s opinion that Ms. Katelanis’s measure of STUDENT’s intelligence quotient was obsolete. The Hearing Officer is concerned that an “obsolete” measure was used to classify STUDENT as “severely” mentally retarded. The Hearing Officer notes that all other cognitive assessments of STUDENT consistently found her to fall in the moderate range, including the relatively recent assessment performed in June and July 2003 at the UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute. (Student Exh. 39.)
15. STUDENT’s parents have since requested and the District has agreed to perform a functional vision assessment. Neither party provided a copy of the proposed assessment plan that included parental consent. (District Exh. 18.)
16. As will be discussed more fully below in Issue II (G), the parties disagree about when STUDENT’s parents consented to these components of the 2004-2005 program offer.
17. For the first time in her closing brief, Student requested an additional counting goal. This contention was not identified as an issue by either party for hearing. Consequently, the Hearing Officer will not address this contention in this Decision.
18. Ms. Machado testified on cross-examination that theoretically she might consider adding goals to address one-to-one correspondence and identification of primary colors to STUDENT’s program. However, the Hearing Officer observes that because STUDENT attends school fewer hours than set forth in her IEP and spends so many additional hours attending her designated instructional services, Ms. Machado testified that she does not have enough time to work with STUDENT consistently as it is. MOTHER described STUDENT’s typical day as including services in clinic settings, in home, and in school. MOTHER testified that STUDENT is “very tired” and that she requires a daily nap when she returns home from school. As stated above, neither federal nor State special education law require that IEP goals address each and every deficit within an identified area of need.
19. Behavioral intervention plans “shall be based upon a functional analysis assessment....” (Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3052(a)(3).) The “functional analysis assessment procedure” must contain a “ (A) systematic observation of the occurrence of the targeted behavior for an accurate definition and description of the frequency, duration, and intensity; (B) systematic observation of the immediate antecedent events associated with each instance of the display of the targeted inappropriate behavior; (C) systematic observation and analysis of the consequences following the display of the behavior to determine the function the behavior serves for the individual, i.e., to identify the specific environmental or physiological outcomes produced by the behavior [the communicative intent of the behavior is identified in terms of what the individual is either requesting or protesting through the display of behavior]; (D) ecological analysis of the settings in which the behavior occurs most frequently. The functional analysis assessment report shall describe the nature and severity of the targeted behavior(s) in objective and measurable terms; the rate of alternative behaviors, their antecedents and consequences; and recommendations for consideration by the IEP team which may include a proposed behavioral intervention plan. (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3052(b)(2)(A)(B)(C)(D).)
20. As Dr. Glover explained, the prompt hierarchy (from least to most intrusive) is used as follows: non-verbal prompt (pointing, eye movement), verbal prompt, modeling, and physical guidance (“hand over hand”). (District Exh. 14.)
21. According to MOTHER, STUDENT receives the following additional District designated instruction and services: clinic-based SAL on Monday mornings, PT and SAL at nonpublic agencies on Tuesday morning, PT at a nonpublic agency on Wednesday mornings, OT at a nonpublic agency on Wednesday afternoons from 2:00 to 3:00 p.m., and PT at a nonpublic agency on Thursday afternoons.
22. The proposed assessment plan was dated October 8, 2004. Neither party provided a copy that included parental consent.
