California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 27, 2003
Student v. Simi Valley Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 262-02 · Hearing Officer Joy Redmon
Simi Valley Unified must reimburse up to 20 hours of private speech therapy; most other speech claims denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted. Moorpark Unified was dismissed as a party on the first day of hearing; Hearing Officer Laba had denied its earlier motion to dismiss on May 20, 2002.
Summary
The parents of a 13-year-old boy filed for due process against Simi Valley Unified School District over his speech and language services from April 2001 through the 2002-2003 school year. The boy was eligible for special education as cognitively delayed. He has Fragile X syndrome and apraxia and was largely nonverbal. The parents wanted therapy focused on spoken speech. The district favored a mix of picture exchange cards (PECS), an electronic communication device, and speech work. Moorpark Unified was dismissed on the first day of hearing.
The Hearing Officer found the student needed a multimodal approach in which speech was one part, not the main focus. From April through early October 2001, his IEP goals covered only PECS, with no speech or device goals. That denied FAPE. The October 2001 IEP added those goals and was appropriate. In January 2002 the district offered an extra hour of weekly therapy, but the parents declined it. The district did not file for a hearing to override that refusal, as Education Code section 56346 required. So the student was denied FAPE from January 14, 2002 through extended school year. The 2002-2003 IEP was appropriate. The district must reimburse up to 20 hours (one hour per week) of private therapy from Drs. Brandt and Fosnot for April 1 to October 3, 2001, excluding August. The Hearing Officer denied reimbursement for 2002 because the parents had refused the offered time. Compensatory education was also denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled a parent's partial refusal of offered services. The district still had a duty to seek a hearing to override the refusal. Even so, the Hearing Officer denied reimbursement for that period on equitable grounds. Reimbursement for the earlier period was limited to the gap in services, not all private therapy.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue 1. Did the District provide STUDENT a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year from April 2001 forward regarding speech and language services?
The May 2000 IEP and the unconsented June 2001 offer had only PECS-based goals, with no vocalization or augmentative device goals. This denied FAPE from April 2001 through October 3, 2001. Claims that the IEP was not implemented were rejected.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. Did the District provide STUDENT a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year regarding speech and language services?
The October 2001 IEP provided FAPE. From January 14, 2002 through ESY, the student received only 45 of the 105 weekly minutes he needed. The parents had refused the added time, but the District did not seek a hearing to override the refusal under Ed. Code 56346(b), so FAPE was denied for that period.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. Has the District provided STUDENT a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year regarding speech and language services?
The October 2002 IEP's goals, including a less rigorous vocalization goal, and its 80 minutes per week of speech therapy were appropriate and were implemented.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for privately paid speech and language services provided by Dr. Fosnot and Dr. Brandt from April 2001 through the present exclusive of the payments already made by the District?
The parents receive reimbursement of one hour per week, up to 20 hours, for April 1 to October 3, 2001, excluding August. Reimbursement for 2002 was denied on equitable grounds because the parents refused the District's offer of added therapy.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 5. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, is he entitled to five speech and language sessions per week with Grace Brandt through the extended school year as compensatory education?
Compensatory education was denied. The student lost no educational opportunity because he received private therapy during both denial periods.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 20 days of the decision, the parents must give the District proof of payment for private speech therapy from Dr. Brandt and Dr. Fosnot for April 1, 2001 through October 3, 2001, excluding August. Within 20 days after receiving that proof, the District must reimburse one hour per week, not to exceed 20 hours total. No dollar amount was stated.
Key authorities
Rowley; School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Alamo Heights Independent School Dist. v. State Board of Education; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist.; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(b)
People named in the decision
- Elissa Henkin, educational advocate (witness for Student), Student
- Susan Fosnot, private speech-language pathologist (witness for Student), Private practice
- Grace Brandt, private speech-language pathologist (witness for Student), Private practice
- Sharon Bass Sicanoff, program specialist, Simi Valley Unified School District
- Mari Notrica, special education (SDC) teacher, Garden Grove Elementary, Simi Valley Unified School District
- Mary Schillinger, assistant director of student support services, Simi Valley Unified School District
- Donna Fong-Taylor, school speech therapist, Sycamore Elementary, Simi Valley Unified School District
- Judy Montgomery, speech pathologist and professor; expert witness for District, Private practice
- Dennis Carter, director of student support services, Simi Valley Unified School District
- Karen Moos, speech and language therapist; assistive technology assessor, Simi Valley Unified School District
- Monica Mallue, speech and language therapist, Simi Valley Unified School District
- Rick Ibbotson, custodian (witness for District), Simi Valley Unified School District
- Richard Jenkins, director of special education, Moorpark Unified School District
- Laba, SEHO Hearing Officer (earlier ruling on motion to dismiss), Special Education Hearing Office
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Joy Redmon, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific. The matter proceeded to hearing in Simi Valley, California, on March 25-28, and April 3-4, 2003.
Petitioner, STUDENT, was represented by attorney George Crook. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf were his parents, PARENTS, and educational advocate Elissa Henkin. Respondent Simi Valley Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Andrew Arczynski and Dennis Carter, director of student support services, was present on the District’s behalf. At the outset of the hearing, Moorpark Unified School District (Moorpark) was also a Respondent. Moorpark was represented by attorney Jeff Marderosian. Richard Jenkins, director of special education, was also present on Moorpark’s behalf. As discussed below, Moorpark was dismissed as a Respondent on the first day of hearing.
The Petitioner called the following witnesses: Elissa Henkin, educational advocate; Susan Fosnot, speech pathologist; FATHER, STUDENT’s father; Grace Brandt, speech pathologist; and MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother.
The District called the following witnesses: Sharon Bass Sicanoff, program specialist; Mari Notrica, special education teacher; Mary Schillinger, assistant director of student support services, Donna Fong-Taylor, speech therapist; Judy Montgomery; speech pathologist and professor; Dennis Carter, director of student support services; Karen Moos, speech and language therapist; Rick Ibbotson, custodian; and Monica Mallue, speech and language therapist.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The parties submitted written closing briefs. Thereafter, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
Issue 1 Did the District provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2000-2001 school year from April 2001 forward regarding speech and language services?
Issue 2 Did the District provide STUDENT a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year regarding speech and language services?
Issue 3 Has the District provided STUDENT a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year regarding speech and language services?
Issue 4 Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for speech and language services provided by Dr. Fosnot and Dr. Brandt from April 2001 through the present exclusive of the payments already made by the District?
Issue 5 If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, is he entitled to five speech and language sessions per week with Grace Brandt through the extended school year as compensatory education?
PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Petitioner initially named Simi Valley Unified School District as the sole respondent in this matter. In April of 2002, Petitioner added Moorpark Unified School District (Moorpark) as an additional respondent, alleging that Moorpark may be responsible for some compensatory education services because STUDENT was a resident of Moorpark during a portion of the three years preceding his filing for due process. Shortly thereafter, Moorpark filed a motion to be dismissed as a party. Moorpark argued that while STUDENT resided within the Moorpark District until approximately January of 2001, STUDENT was being served by Simi Valley pursuant to an inter-district transfer. Simi Valley opposed Moorpark’s motion to be dismissed, asserting that it relied upon assessments and IEPs conducted and created by Moorpark in servicing STUDENT. Petitioner did not respond to Moorpark’s motion. On May 20, 2002, Hearing Officer Laba denied Moorpark’s motion to be dismissed, at that time, because a factual issue remained regarding Moorpark’s responsibility to provide services to STUDENT while he was a resident of its district.
In March 2003, shortly before the hearing in this matter commenced, Petitioner requested that Moorpark be dismissed as a party. Simi Valley objected to the dismissal. All parties were ordered to appear on the first day of the hearing. Petitioner renewed his request to dismiss Moorpark, asserting that STUDENT moved from the Moorpark District into the Simi Valley District in approximately January of 2001. Petitioner clarified that he intended to limit his issues to the time period of April 2001 forward. Moorpark made an oral motion to be dismissed, asserting that irrespective of the previous interdistrict transfer, any and all obligation it had to STUDENT terminated when STUDENT’s family moved into the Simi Valley District in January of 2001. Simi Valley objected to Moorpark’s dismissal, arguing that it did not develop a new IEP for STUDENT but relied upon his previous IEP, created by Moorpark, when STUDENT moved to Simi Valley. Therefore, any defect in the IEP should be attributed to Moorpark and not Simi Valley.
This Hearing Officer was not persuaded by Simi Valley’s argument. Simi Valley acknowledged that STUDENT became a resident of its district in approximately January of 2001. The Hearing Officer determined that after that time, Simi Valley was responsible for creating and providing a program that conformed to the requirements of the IDEA. In light of the fact that Petitioner limited his issues to the time period after STUDENT became a resident of the Simi Valley District, and that Moorpark did not provide any services or participate in any IEP meetings for STUDENT during the time period at issue in the case, this Hearing Officer dismissed Moorpark as a party to the due process hearing. After that time, Mr. Marderosian and Mr. Jenkins left and the hearing proceeded with the remaining two parties.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Petitioner contends that the District has denied him a FAPE since April of 2001 with respect to his speech and language services. Specifically, he alleges that the District has failed to provide him a program that meets his unique need to vocalize. Additionally, Petitioner asserts that his parents required training on the use of the picture exchange communication system (PECS) and his augmentative communication device for use at home. Petitioner also asserts that the District failed to implement each of his IEPs since June of 2001 by failing to provide a one-to-one aide during speech and language sessions, failing to provide some of his speech therapy sessions, failing to implement his speech and language goals and objectives, failing to chart his progress, and failing to inform his parents of STUDENT’s progress at required intervals. STUDENT assets that he is entitled to compensatory education and reimbursement for privately paid speech and language therapy sessions because of the District’s denial of FAPE.
The District acknowledges that STUDENT has complex communication issues. It asserts that because of his speech and language delays, STUDENT’s unique need is to develop a functional and reliable way to communicate rather than to vocalize specifically. To meet this need, the District argues that STUDENT requires a multimodal approach that includes a nonverbal communication system like PECS, an augmentative communication device, and assistance with vocalization. The District asserts that it has continuously provided a program that meets STUDENT’s needs. The District also asserts that it has provided training to both PARENTS on the use of STUDENT’s augmentative communication device and that it is willing to provide additional training if requested. Further, the District asserts that it has implemented all components of STUDENT’s IEPs, but that STUDENT’s IEPs do not provide for a one-to-one aide during speech. Finally, the District asserts that it has provided STUDENT a FAPE; therefore, he is not entitled to his requested remedies.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
STUDENT is a thirteen-year-old boy who has received special education services throughout his educational career under the category of cognitively delayed. STUDENT has Fragile X Syndrome and apraxia, which have resulted in, among other things, a significant expressive and receptive language delay.(Footnote 1) Although STUDENT had been attending school in the District since February of 1998 pursuant to an interdistrict transfer agreement, he became a resident in approximately January of 2001.
During the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT attended Sycamore Elementary School. He was enrolled in a special day class (SDC) and received speech and language services, occupational therapy, and adapted physical education. At that point, STUDENT was nonverbal and primarily communicated using gestures and pointing. Speech therapist Donna Fong-Taylor provided three fifteen-minute speech and language therapy sessions to STUDENT per week and one consultation session to his SDC teacher. At that time, Ms. Fong-Taylor’s therapy sessions focused on the development of a functional communication system. Specifically, STUDENT learned to use the Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS)(Footnote 2) and an electronic augmentative communication device called a Tech Talker. According to Ms. Fong-Taylor, STUDENT preferred using PECS to express his wants and he required prompting to use the Tech Talker.
In addition to speech and language therapy provided in the school, STUDENT attended one thirty-minute therapy session per week by private speech pathologist Grace Brandt. Dr. Brandt had provided therapy to STUDENT since approximately 1998. During the 2000-2001 school year, Dr. Brandt worked with STUDENT on developing expressive verbal and nonverbal language and the use of his augmentative communication device.
STUDENT’s IEP meeting was held on June 13, 2001. Ms. Fong-Taylor recommended eliminating individual pull-out speech and language therapy and instead suggested providing in-class and consultation services. The PARENTs objected to consultation services and requested that he continue with individual therapy. Despite Ms. Fong-Taylor’s recommendation, the IEP team offered STUDENT three fifteen minute individual speech therapy sessions per week. The team agreed to eliminate consultation services. Speech therapist Karen Moos presented a report regarding an assistive technology assessment she had conducted of STUDENT. According to Ms. Moos, STUDENT had little motivation to use his Tech Talker and she recommended it be replaced with an Alpha Talker. The PARENTs requested that STUDENT be given a Dynamic Display device instead.(Footnote 3) The team agreed that Ms. Moos would conduct an additional assessment in the fall to determine if such a device was appropriate for STUDENT. At the end of the IEP meeting, the PARENTs did not sign the IEP. Instead, they requested additional time to review the IEP and to wait until the additional assessment was completed. Accordingly, STUDENT’s previous IEP remained in effect.
In July of 2001, STUDENT began working with private speech pathologist Dr. Susan Fosnot in addition to Dr. Brandt. According to MOTHER, Dr. Fosnot had significant experience working with children with apraxia. MOTHER explained that her primary concern was that STUDENT learn to speak and she believed that Dr. Fosnot could help STUDENT to speak. Dr. Fosnot conducted an assessment of STUDENT in July. She administered the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-III. On a single word test of understanding, STUDENT was in the first percentile rank for receptive language with an age equivalent of four years ten months. Regarding expressive language, Dr. Fosnot noted four vocalizations during spontaneous expression of fifty utterances. The four identified verbal expressions were “ma” (screams in protest), “mU” (represents moon), “gU ba” (good bye), and “a” (to signal his desire to leave.) Dr. Fosnot developed clinical goals and objectives and began seeing STUDENT for one one-hour session per week.
On October 3, 2001, another IEP meeting was held to determine STUDENT’s program for the 2001-2002 school year. The PARENTs presented Dr. Fosnot’s report and requested that the District agree to pay for five one-hour sessions with Dr. Fosnot per week for STUDENT through the extended school year. Ms. Fong-Taylor reviewed Dr. Fosnot’s report. Ms. Fong-Taylor disagreed with Dr. Fosnot’s recommended methodology for working with STUDENT because Ms. Fong-Taylor believed STUDENT showed no signs of being ready to vocalize. However, despite her disagreement with the report, Ms. Fong-Taylor suggested to the IEP team that Dr. Fosnot be given an opportunity to work with STUDENT to see if it would help him to vocalize. The IEP team drafted additional expressive language goals and objectives for STUDENT and agreed to pay for two two-hour sessions per week for twelve weeks with Dr. Fosnot. The IEP notes indicate that the team would meet again after twelve weeks. The notes further indicate that the team would review a report of progress to be provided by Dr. Fosnot. The PARENTs consented to the IEP. Dr. Fosnot was not given a copy of the IEP.
In December of 2001, Ms. Fong-Taylor and Sharon Bass Sicanoff, program specialist, observed one of Dr. Fosnot’s therapy sessions with STUDENT. It appeared to Ms. Fong-Taylor that a one-hour session was longer than STUDENT could tolerate. She expressed her concern to Dr. Fosnot. Dr. Fosnot agreed that a one-half hour session was more appropriate for STUDENT at that time. Thereafter, his sessions were reduced to two one-half-hour sessions per week.
The follow-up IEP meeting was scheduled for Friday, January 11, 2002. In preparation for that meeting, Ms. Fong-Taylor wrote a letter to Dr. Fosnot. Ms. Fong-Taylor requested a report from Dr. Fosnot, including a list of new sounds that STUDENT had acquired and an indication of the progress STUDENT had made toward achieving the clinical goals drafted by Dr. Fosnot. Dr. Fosnot did not receive the letter until January 7, 2002, four days prior to the IEP meeting. Dr. Fosnot explained that she requires at least two weeks’ notice to prepare a report and that she was never informed that a report was required in the previous IEP. Instead, Dr. Fosnot handwrote notes of STUDENT’s progress directly on Ms. Fong-Taylor’s letter and indicated that the PARENTs would bring samples of STUDENT’s work to the IEP meeting. According to her notes, STUDENT was able to vocalize the sounds /p/, /d/, /h/, /b/, and /m/. Dr. Fosnot was not invited by either the District or the PARENTs to attend the IEP meeting at which her services were to be discussed.
The IEP meeting was held on January 11, 2002. At the meeting, the PARENTs requested that STUDENT be transferred from Sycamore to an SDC at Garden Grove, that the District continue to fund Dr. Fosnot’s therapy sessions, and that STUDENT receive a Dynamic Display device. The IEP team members determined that the SDC at Garden Grove, taught by Mari Notrica, was an appropriate placement for STUDENT and agreed to transfer him by the end of January. Regarding the request that the District continue to fund Dr. Fosnot’s therapy sessions, Ms. Fong-Taylor and Ms. Moos explained that they believed the school could create and implement goals and objectives similar to Dr. Fosnot’s. The District drafted additional vocalization and oral-motor goals for STUDENT. To implement the new goals and objectives, the District offered two thirty-minute individual therapy sessions per week in addition to the three fifteen-minute sessions STUDENT was already receiving. The District members of the IEP team declined the PARENT’s request to continue funding Dr. Fosnot’s therapy services. In addition to the above, the District also recommended the use of a Dynamic Display device called a Dynamo. The PARENTs disagreed with the determination to suspend payment of Dr. Fosnot’s therapy sessions. However, they agreed to allow the District to implement the new IEP as written except for the proposed additional speech therapy time, deciding to continue with Dr. Fosnot’s private therapy at their own expense.
STUDENT transferred to Ms. Notrica’s SDC at Garden Grove. Speech therapists Karen Moos and Monica Mallue began providing STUDENT’s speech and language therapy. Ms. Moos and Ms. Mallue met with Ms. Fong-Taylor to discuss STUDENT’s speech and language needs. Ms. Moos focused on augmentative communication with STUDENT and Ms. Mallue focused on PECS and vocalization.
Shortly thereafter, the PARENTs filed a request for a due process hearing. However, the matter was taken off calendar. On October 25, 2002, another IEP meeting was held. The IEP team reviewed STUDENT’s progress toward meeting his goals and objectives from the previous year. The team drafted new goals and objectives. The District offered one twenty - and one thirty - minute individual pull-out therapy session per week, and one thirty minute in-class, small-group speech therapy session per week. The PARENTs again requested that the District agree to fund Dr. Fosnot’s private therapy. The District declined the request. The PARENTs authorized implementation of the IEP during the dispute resolution process. Ultimately, the parties were unable to resolve their dispute regarding the provision of speech and language services and went forward to hearing.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue 1 Did the District provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2000-2001 school year from April 2001 forward regarding speech and language services?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE) that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the students at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the students’ individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401 (8).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities.
In summary, under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley, the educational program must be designed to meet the student’s unique needs, to provide the student with some educational benefit, and the program must conform with the students’ IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176.(Footnote 4)
In this case regarding the denial of FAPE, Petitioner alleges that the speech and language services provided did not meet his unique needs, that the IEPs were not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit in acquiring a language system, and that portions of his IEP were not implemented.
Unique Needs 2000-2001 (April 2001 forward)
The parties in this case generally agree on STUDENT’s needs.(Footnote 5) It is undisputed that during the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT was a nonverbal child who relied primarily upon gestures, PECS, and an augmentative communication device (AC) to communicate. The parties also agree that STUDENT’s primary need was to develop a functional communication system. To develop a communication system, the parties agree that STUDENT required a multimodal approach, which Dr. Fosnot referred to as “total communication” or the integration of multiple types of expressive language, including PECS, AC, and expressive vocalization. The dispute at the heart of this case is whether or not vocalization should have been the primary focus of the total communication approach provided to STUDENT for him to develop a functional communication system.
Dr. Fosnot, STUDENT’s private therapist, testified that as a child with apraxia, vocalization should have been the primary focus of STUDENT’s therapy because the ability to orally communicate is an essential human function. Dr. Fosnot is a clinical speech pathologist who has been in private practice since 1974. Dr. Fosnot’s opinion was based upon the therapy she provided to STUDENT in a clinical setting. Dr. Fosnot testified that she never observed STUDENT at school, either in class or during individual speech therapy. Further, Dr. Fosnot’s curriculum vita reveals that her professional experience is limited to a clinic or college setting rather than an elementary school setting. The Hearing Officer finds Dr. Fosnot a credible witness but gives her testimony less weight because of her lack of experience within the school environment generally and because she never observed STUDENT outside of her clinic.
The District argued that STUDENT required an integrated approach with an emphasis on the modes of communication that were more reliable for STUDENT, like PECS and augmentative communication. STUDENT’s school speech therapists, Ms. Fong-Taylor, Ms. Moos, and Ms. Mallue, testified that for STUDENT to function in school and society, he needed a reliable and functional way to communicate his wants and needs and that vocalization, while important, should not have been the primary focus of therapy because his vocalization ability was not and may never be reliable. Dr. Montgomery, a private speech pathologist who reviewed STUDENT’s school and private records, echoed the sentiments of STUDENT’s school therapists and disagreed with Dr. Fosnot’s opinion regrading the primary focus of STUDENT’s therapy being vocalization. Dr. Montgomery testified that while STUDENT had a need to vocalize, emphasis should have been placed on the development of a communication system, with the primary focus being the modes of communication that provided STUDENT the most success in expressive language. Dr. Montgomery has been a licensed speech pathologist since 1974. In addition to private practice, Dr. Montgomery’s professional experience has included working as a classroom teacher, a school speech therapist, an elementary school principal, and the director of special education for the Fountain Valley School District. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Fong-Taylor, Ms. Moos, Ms. Mallue, and Dr. Montgomery credible witnesses. Further, the Hearing Officer finds that the totality of the evidence establishes that STUDENT required an integrated approach to the development of a communication system with vocalization as a component but not the primary focus.
Additionally, the testimony of STUDENT’s private therapist, Dr. Brandt, supports the opinions of Dr. Montgomery, Ms. Fong-Taylor, Ms. Moos, and Ms. Mallue over that of Dr. Fosnot. Dr. Brandt had been providing weekly vocalization therapy to STUDENT for four years prior to April of 2001. Despite hundreds of hours of therapy, Dr. Brandt testified that in April of 2001, STUDENT was making progress with oral motor control and limited vocalization, but he was not able to spontaneously produce any understandable words. According to Dr. Montgomery, STUDENT’s limited progress after extensive therapy establishes that vocalization was not a reliable form of expressive communication for STUDENT and, therefore, should not have been the primary focus of his therapy.
In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s primary need was to develop a communication system. Additionally, the Hearing Officer finds that to develop a communication system STUDENT needed a multimodal, total communication approach that included augmentative communication, nonverbal communication (PECS), and vocalization. Moreover, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s unique needs did not require the primary focus of his therapy to be placed on vocalization. Indeed such an emphasis may have been harmful to STUDENT’s progress in developing a communication system.
After having identified STUDENT’s unique needs, the Hearing Officer must determine if the program offered by the District was designed to meet those needs. In April of 2001, the time period at issue in this case, STUDENT’s operative IEP was that of May 24, 2000.
In the area of communication the IEP included four goals each with individual benchmarks. Ms. Fong-Taylor testified that she drafted the goals and presented them at the IEP meeting. The goals were as follows: STUDENT will answer “What do you see?” and “What do you have?” using a picture communication system, adding color and size descriptors if applicable; STUDENT will increase receptive language by identifying object/picture that corresponds to verbal and symbolic sentence; and STUDENT will increase expressive language by describing or answering questions regarding object/picture using picture symbols. Each of these goals incorporates PECS.
Ms. Fong-Taylor explained that at this point in STUDENT’s language acquisition it was appropriate to expand his PECS vocabulary. Ms. Fong-Taylor also testified that during the 2000-2001 school year she did not focus on vocalization with STUDENT. When questioned, Ms. Fong-Taylor reported that she confined her therapy sessions to STUDENT’s goals and objectives. Since there was no vocalization goal, it was not specifically worked on during therapy. Further, regarding the use of his Tech Talker, STUDENT’s present levels of performance mention that STUDENT used the Tech Talker when prompted. However, there is no reference to the Tech Talker in his goals and objectives. The Hearing Officer found above that STUDENT’s need to develop a communication system required a multimodal approach that included the use of vocalization and augmentative communication. However, the program provided by the District relied solely on PECS and failed to address vocalization and augmentative communication. An IEP must include goals and objectives addressing a student’s unique needs. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(ii) and (iii)(I) and (II), 34 C.F.R. § 300.347 (a)(2)(ii) and (a)(3)(i) and (ii) and California Education Code § 56345(a)(2)(B).) This requirement is not purely procedural. Ms. Fong-Taylor confirmed that she limited her therapy to what was specifically contained in STUDENT’s goals and objectives. Even if Ms. Fong-Taylor provided vocalization therapy to STUDENT on an ad hoc basis during the year, without identifying STUDENT’s then present level of performance and drafting goals addressing all of his needs, it would have been impossible to determine if STUDENT actually made any progress. The Hearing Officer finds that the IEP operative in April of 2001 was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs regarding vocalization and augmentative communication.
An IEP meeting for STUDENT was held on June 13, 2001. STUDENT’s parents did not consent to this IEP during the 2000-2001 school year; therefore, the May 2000 IEP remained in effect throughout the 2000-2001 school year including the ESY. The proposed goals and objectives in the IEP failed to include any reference to vocalization. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that IEP offered in June of 2001 but not implemented until revised in October of 2001 (as discussed below) was also not designed to meet STUDENT’s significant need to develop a functional and reliable communication system.
Educational Benefit
To establish that the District provided STUDENT a FAPE, it must prove that the program was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. As determined above, STUDENT’s IEP was not designed to meet his unique need regarding vocalization and augmentative communication. Ms. Fong-Taylor testified that she did not work on vocalization because STUDENT’s IEP did not contain any vocalization goals. The Hearing Officer finds that this omission was a significant defect in the IEP because STUDENT required a multimodal approach utilizing many types of communication instead of only one, in this case PECS. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s IEP was not designed to provide him with educational benefit in the key area of communication during the 2000-2001 school year from April 2001 forward.
Comport with IEP
In addition to the above elements, the District must also establish that the program it implemented comported with the IEP. STUDENT asserts that the District failed to implement his IEP by failing to provide a one-to-one aide during speech and language sessions, failing to provide some of his speech therapy sessions, failing to implement his speech and language goals and objectives, failing to chart his progress, and failing to inform the PARENTs of STUDENT’s progress at required intervals.
STUDENT argues that the District failed to provide a one-to-one aide during speech and language. The IEP indicates that STUDENT was to receive six hours of aide time per day during the 2000-2001 school year. According to the testimony of Ms. Fong-Taylor, the school day was from 8:15 a.m. until 2:35 p.m., six hours and twenty minutes. There is no indication in the IEP that six hours was to include speech therapy sessions. At the time the IEP was drafted, STUDENT was receiving three fifteen-minute speech therapy session per week. It is unclear on the face of the IEP whether or not STUDENT was to receive a one-to-one aide during speech therapy. Ms. Fong-Taylor testified that a one-to-one aide was not required during her therapy sessions because she was provided one-to-one therapy to STUDENT. On occasion, an aide would bring STUDENT to therapy; however, the aide was not required for her to provide STUDENT’s therapy services. Further, Ms. Fong-Taylor explained that she consulted with STUDENT’s classroom teacher and aides so that they could integrate his speech goals into the classroom curriculum. The Hearing Officer relies upon Ms. Fong-Taylor’s testimony and finds that the IEP did not require a one-to-one aide for STUDENT during speech therapy. Additionally, the Hearing Officer notes that no persuasive evidence was presented to the contrary. Therefore, the District did not fail to implement his IEP regarding an aide during speech therapy.
STUDENT asserted at the outset of the hearing that the District failed to provide some of STUDENT’s speech and language therapy sessions, that it failed to implement his goals and objectives, and that his therapist failed to chart his progress as required in the IEP. Other than these assertions, Petitioner presented no evidence of these failures. Ms. Fong-Taylor testified that the only sessions STUDENT may have missed were when he was absent. Additionally, she testified that she implemented his goals and objectives during the sessions. Ms. Fong-Taylor’s testimony was supported by the documentation she kept of her sessions identified as charting. The charting, reviewed at hearing by Ms. Fong-Taylor, also established that she did chart STUDENT’s progress as required in the IEP. Ms. Fong-Taylor’s charting established that she provided the required speech sessions, that she implemented STUDENT’s goals and objectives, and that she charted his progress. In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided a program that comported with his IEP regarding the provision of services, the implementation of goals and objectives, and charting of STUDENT’s progress.
STUDENT’s remaining contention regarding the program’s comportment with his IEP is that his parents were not informed of his progress at required intervals. Consistent with Education Code section 56345(a)(10) the IEP indicates that STUDENT’s parents will receive notice of progress three time a year, the same as typical peers receive conferences and report cards. Both PARENTS testified that STUDENT received report cards. MOTHER testified that she annually attended STUDENT’s parent-teacher conferences. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District implemented STUDENT’s IEP regarding informing his parents of his progress at required intervals.
In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District implemented a program that conformed to STUDENT’s IEP.
In summary, from April 2001 through the end of the extended school year, the District failed to provide a program to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in vocalization and augmentative communication. This error was significant because STUDENT required a multimodal approach and the District limited its therapy exclusively to PECS. The Hearing Officer also found above that the IEP was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was denied a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year from April 2001 forward because of the District’s failure to adequately address STUDENT’s significant area of need, communication.
Issue 2 Did the District provide STUDENT a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year regarding speech and language services?
Two IEPs were developed during the 2001-2002 school year, one on October 3, 2001 and the other on January 11, 2002. Both IEPs changed STUDENT’s program, therefore, the Hearing Officer will analyze the provision of FAPE separately under each IEP.
Unique Needs 2001-2002 - October through December
There is no dispute that STUDENT’s unique needs remained the same during the 2001-2002 school year as identified above. Therefore, the Hearing Officer must determine whether or not the program offered by the District at the October 3, 2001 IEP meeting was designed to meet those unique needs.(Footnote 6) It is important to note that during July of 2001, STUDENT began seeing private speech pathologist Dr. Fosnot. Dr. Fosnot conducted a speech and language evaluation of STUDENT and drafted proposed clinical goals and objectives for her use with STUDENT during therapy. The PARENTs brought Dr. Fosnot’s assessment and recommendations with them to the October 3, 2001 IEP meeting. After a discussion regarding Dr. Fosnot’s information, the October 3, 2001 IEP was finalized. It incorporated the proposed goals and objectives from the June 2001 IEP and included new goals and objectives in vocalization and augmentative communication as recommended by Dr. Fosnot. Additionally, the IEP provided for twenty-four one-hour speech therapy sessions to be provided by Dr. Fosnot to STUDENT at the District’s expense over a twelve-week period. The PARENTs signed the IEP.
The IEP proposed four communication goals and objectives. Ms. Fong-Taylor testified that she drafted the goals and objectives. They were as follows: STUDENT will point to appropriate place on chart, picture book, or augmentative communication device to follow along with class during calendar; STUDENT will describe or answer questions regarding selected curriculum unit using picture symbols or augmentative communication device during language arts; STUDENT will identify vocabulary for selected classroom units and place them in categories by name; and STUDENT will imitate “bus” and “bye” at appropriate times. Ms. Fong-Taylor testified that the team chose “bus” and “bye” as the starting point for vocalization because at that time STUDENT was able to make the following sounds /b/, /m/, /o/, /u/, (ah) (ooh). Therefore, according to Ms. Fong-Taylor, “bus” and “bye” were appropriate words. Additionally, the IEP indicates that the goals and objectives were to be implemented during one-to-one therapy sessions and generalized throughout the school day by STUDENT’s SDC teacher and classroom aides.
Ms. Fong-Taylor testified that the goals and objectives drafted for STUDENT were designed to meet his unique communication needs because they included PECS, vocalization, and augmentative communication. Dr. Fosnot testified that the goals and objectives were appropriate, but that they did not place the primary focus on vocalization. As determined above, the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT’s need for vocalization did not outweigh his need to develop a functional communication system. The Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives drafted by the District were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique communication needs because they adequately addressed the development of skills using different modes of expressive communication, including vocalization.
To implement these goals and objectives, the District offered STUDENT three fifteen-minute speech and language sessions per week. Dr. Fosnot testified that three fifteen-minute sessions were not enough to meet STUDENT’s needs as a child with apraxia. According to Dr. Fosnot, a child with apraxia requires a minimum of five one-hour sessions per week of one-to-one therapy that works on vocalization and oral-motor skills. Dr. Fosnot’s recommendation was for apraxic children generally and not STUDENT specifically. Further, the Hearing Officer notes that Dr. Fosnot’s treatment of STUDENT was inconsistent with her testimony. Dr. Fosnot testified that initially her therapy sessions with STUDENT were in one-hour increments; however, she determined after several sessions that this was too long for STUDENT to tolerate. Accordingly, Dr. Fosnot reduced STUDENT’s time to two thirty- minute sessions per week rather than two one-hour sessions. At that time, however, the District was willing to pay for two hours of Dr. Fosnot’s therapy per week. Therefore, when Dr. Fosnot reduced the session time to one-half hour increments, she could have increased the number of session to four times per week, closer to the amount of therapy she testified STUDENT required. However, Dr. Fosnot did not increase the number of sessions she provided STUDENT each week, despite the fact that the District was willing to pay for a full two hours per week. Considering that Dr. Fosnot’s actual provision of services, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not require five hours per week of one-to-one speech and language therapy to meet his needs.
As to the provision of forty-five minutes per week of therapy offered by the District, Ms. Fong-Taylor testified that STUDENT exhibited significant attention issues at school that impacted the amount of therapy he could tolerate. Dr. Fosnot’s assessment report of STUDENT reveals that while she was treating STUDENT, he was taking Cylert, Clonidine, and Paxil to assist with his attention issues. Ms. Fong-Taylor testified that three fifteen-minute sessions provided her an opportunity to implement STUDENT’s goals and objectives without overly taxing his ability to attend. FATHER also testified that at that time STUDENT was only able to attend to an activity at home for short periods of time before he “faded” and lost interest. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Fong-Taylor’s assessment of STUDENT’s ability to attend for short increments of time, confirmed by FATHER’s testimony, persuasive. Furthermore, Ms. Fong-Taylor testified that forty-five minutes per week was a sufficient amount of time to implement the goals and objectives drafted for STUDENT. Additionally, according to Ms. Fong-Taylor, STUDENT’s goals and objectives were also implemented by his SDC teacher and classroom aides. Ms. Fong-Taylor testified that she provided consultation services to the teacher and aides who then integrated what she was working on with STUDENT into the classroom to help him generalize what he was taught. In light of the information available to the District at that time, and the testimony of Ms. Fong-Taylor regarding STUDENT’s ability to attend and the fact that his SDC teacher and aides continued to work on his goals and objectives throughout the school day, the Hearing Officer finds that forty-five minutes per week of direct speech and language therapy in addition to consultation with STUDENT’s SDC teacher was a sufficient amount of time to implement STUDENT’s speech and language goals.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the program offered by the District from October through December of 2001 was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique communication needs.(Footnote 7)
Educational Benefit
Speech pathologist Dr. Montgomery testified regarding the educational benefit STUDENT received from the District’s program. According to Dr. Montgomery, the IEP was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to STUDENT. It was comprehensive and provided an opportunity for STUDENT to utilize several methods while developing a functional communication system. Ms. Fong-Taylor echoed the sentiments of Dr. Montgomery and testified that STUDENT actually did derive educational benefit as evidenced by his progress in all areas of communication. She testified that STUDENT became more proficient with his augmentative communication device and PECS. She revealed that he continued to produce sounds but had yet to spontaneously say “bus” or “bye.”
Petitioner argues that any educational benefit STUDENT received was as a result of the work he did with Dr. Fosnot and his other private speech therapist, Grace Brandt, not as a result of the District’s implemented program. However, Dr. Brandt, Petitioner’s own witness, testified that progress is a package and it is “impossible to untangle the threads of what moves a child ahead.”
Dr. Brandt is correct. It is impossible to apportion STUDENT’s progress to a particular service provider or methodology. The Hearing Officer finds that while STUDENT may have received additional benefit from Dr. Fosnot and Dr. Brandt, STUDENT’s IEP was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit because it provided the multimodal approach STUDENT required to meet his needs, including vocalization.
Comport with IEP
Petitioner makes the same assertions regarding the District’s failure to implement his IEP as in the year before. STUDENT asserts that the District failed to implement his IEP by failing to provide a one-to-one aide during speech and language sessions, failing to provide some of his speech therapy sessions, failing to implement his speech and language goals and objectives, failing to chart his progress, and failing to inform the PARENTs of STUDENT’s progress at required intervals. Considering the same arguments and evidence discussed above, the Hearing Officer finds that the program implemented by the District comported with STUDENT’s IEP.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program from October through December was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, and comported with his IEP. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided STUDENT a FAPE from October through December of 2001.
Unique needs January through the end of the 2001-2002 school year
STUDENT’s unique need to develop a functional and reliable communication system remained the same during this time period. Therefore, the Hearing Officer must determine whether or not the program provided by the District was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs.
An IEP meeting was held on January 11, 2002. Since the previous IEP meeting in October, STUDENT had worked with Dr. Fosnot for twelve weeks, funded by the District. Additionally, speech therapist Karen Moos had conducted an assistive technology assessment of STUDENT to determine if a Dynamic Display device was appropriate for him.(Footnote 8)
During the meeting, the PARENTs requested that STUDENT transfer from an SDC at Sycamore Elementary School to an SDC at Garden Grove Elementary School. They also requested that the District continue to fund Dr. Fosnot’s private therapy sessions. Finally, they requested that STUDENT be given a Dynamic Display device because STUDENT had become bored with the static Tech Talker and was no longer interested in using it.
The IEP team agreed that the SDC at Garden Grove, taught by Mari Notrica, was an appropriate placement for STUDENT. Further, during the meeting Ms. Moos reported her findings regarding the augmentative communication assessment. She recommended the use of a Dynamic Display device called a Dynamo. According to Ms. Moos, the Dynamo is more sophisticated than the Tech Talker and would “grow with STUDENT” as he became more proficient with this augmentative communication device. The IEP team agreed with the PARENTs and Ms. Moos and offered STUDENT the Dynamo. Additionally, Ms. Moos agreed to provide parent training to the PARENTs on the use of the Dynamo for home. Thereafter, the PARENTs did attend a training session with Ms. Moos.
Regarding the PARENT’s additional request, the District members of the IEP team determined that the District could provide STUDENT a program that constituted a FAPE without continuing to fund Dr. Fosnot’s therapy. Petitioner argued that STUDENT benefitted from Dr. Fosnot’s therapy and that the District should have continued to fund her services. The question for the Hearing Officer to determine is whether or not the program offered by the District was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs, not the appropriateness of Dr. Fosnot’s services to STUDENT.
The IEP goals and objectives implemented pursuant to the October 2001 IEP remained in effect; however, the team drafted additional communication goals for STUDENT. Ms. Fong-Taylor and Ms. Bass-Sicanoff observed one of Dr. Fosnot’s therapy sessions and read a brief handwritten report prepared by Dr. Fosnot. Ms. Bass-Sicanoff testified that both she and Ms. Fong-Taylor believed that they could incorporate portions of Dr. Fosnot’s therapy methodology into the District’s program. To that end, Ms. Fong-Taylor drafted three additional goals. They are as follows: STUDENT will use a voice output communication system to make requests with minimal adult cues; STUDENT will imitate bilabial words, (CV, VC, CVC) upon request saying entire word within five seconds; and STUDENT will imitate tongue and lip movements to produce vowel and consonant sounds following oral motor exercises. Ms. Fong-Taylor testified that these additional goals and objectives were drafted to further assist STUDENT in developing stronger oral-motor control to foster vocalization. The Hearing Officer finds that the additional goals and objectives incorporated into the October 2001 IEP were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
Because STUDENT was to transfer to Garden Grove, Ms. Fong-Taylor would no longer be providing speech and language therapy to STUDENT. Ms. Moos and Monica Mallue were STUDENT’s new speech therapists at Garden Grove. Ms. Moos testified that because of the additional goals and objectives, she believed that STUDENT’s speech and language therapy time should be increased. Additionally, STUDENT was provided a Dynamo augmentative device. According to Ms. Moos, the Dynamo was more sophisticated than STUDENT’s previous device and he required additional speech therapy time to learn how to access and use the Dynamo. At that time, STUDENT was receiving three fifteen-minute therapy sessions per week. The District offered to provide STUDENT with two additional individual thirty-minute speech therapy sessions per week for a total of one hour and forty-five minutes per week.
The PARENTs did not agree with the decision to suspend funding Dr. Fosnot’s services. They informed the IEP team that they elected to continue with Dr. Fosnot privately. The PARENTs consented to the implementation of the new IEP but rejected the District’s offer to increase STUDENT’s speech therapy by an additional hour per week. Petitioner asserts that the amount of speech and language therapy provided by the District was not sufficient to meet STUDENT’s needs as evidenced by District speech therapist Ms. Moos’s testimony that STUDENT required more time. The District argues that it actually offered more time and the parents refused, and that, therefore, they should be precluded from arguing that the amount of services was insufficient to meet STUDENT’s needs.
The District’s argument is unpersuasive. The District is correct in that it was precluded from implementing the additional one-hour of therapy per week without the PARENT’s consent. However, when a parent refuses consent for all or part of a program, as in this case, California law requires local education agencies to take steps to ensure that the child receives a FAPE. Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(b). If the local education agency determines that the portions of the program to which the parents did not consent are necessary to provide the child with a FAPE, it is required to initiate the due process hearing procedure to override the parents’ refusal of consent. Id.
In this case, both of STUDENT’s school speech therapists, Ms. Moos and Ms. Mallue, testified persuasively that STUDENT needed additional time to learn to use his Dynamo and for his revised goals and objectives to be fully implemented. The Hearing Officer, therefore, finds that the program implemented by the District did not meet STUDENT’s needs because the speech therapists had insufficient time to implement STUDENT’s goals and objectives and provide appropriate instruction on the use of his Dynamo.
Educational Benefit
STUDENT argues that the program provided by the District was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit because it failed to provide the amount of therapy necessary to meet STUDENT’s needs. As determined above, the District’s offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. However, STUDENT’s parents refused consent to increase the amount of time the District could provide speech therapy to STUDENT. The Hearing Officer determined above that STUDENT required the additional services to implement the goals and objectives. The IEP, as accepted by the parents, was not designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit because he required one hour and forty-five minutes per week of speech and language and he only received forty-five minutes per week.
Comport with IEP
STUDENT again asserts that the District failed to implement his IEP by failing to provide a one-to-one aide during speech and language sessions, failing to provide some of his speech therapy sessions, failing to implement his speech and language goals and objectives, failing to chart his progress, and failing to inform the PARENTs of STUDENT’s progress at required intervals.
The District argues that STUDENT’s January IEP does not provide for a one-to-one aide. A review of the IEP reveals that the IEP does not mention aide services at all. However, even if STUDENT still required the assistance of a one-to-one aide during the school day, the Hearing Officer finds that he did not require an aide during speech and language because he received speech therapy individually from the therapists, Ms. Moos and Ms. Mallue. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not fail to implement a program that comported to STUDENT’s IEP regarding an aide during speech and language.
Petitioner failed to present any evidence regarding the other allegations listed above. Ms. Mallue provided copies of the charts she kept during her therapy sessions with STUDENT. The charts reveal that STUDENT received the consented to amount of speech therapy, and that she implemented his goals and objectives. Ms. Moos testified that she primarily implemented STUDENT’s augmentative communication goals and objectives because she was responsible for teaching him to use his Dynamo. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Mallue and Ms. Moos collectively provided STUDENT’s speech therapy, implemented his goals and objectives, and charted his progress as required in his IEP.
Again, the PARENTs testified that they received STUDENT’s report cards and MOTHER attended STUDENT’s parent-teacher conferences during the 2001-2002 school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District complied with the IEP’s requirement regarding notifying the parents of STUDENT’s progress.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the October 2001 IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, to provide educational benefit, and the program implemented by the District comported with his IEP. In January, the District offered an appropriate program, but STUDENT’s parents prevented its complete implementation by refusing to accept additional speech therapy time. The District had an obligation to request a due process hearing to override the lack of parental consent, but it did not. The program implemented by the District was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs because he required one hour and forty-five minutes per week of speech therapy. The IEP, as implemented, was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. Finally, the Hearing Officer determined that the program implemented by the District comported with STUDENT’s IEP. In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided STUDENT a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year from October 2001 through January 13, 2002. The Hearing Officer further finds that the District did not provide STUDENT a FAPE from January 14, 2002, through the end of the school year to the extent that it did not provide STUDENT an appropriate amount of speech therapy to meet his needs. STUDENT required one hour and forty-five minutes per week and was provided only forty-five minutes per week.
Issue 3 Has the District provided STUDENT a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year regarding speech and language services?
Unique Needs 2002-2003
It is undisputed that STUDENT’s speech and language need is to develop a functional communication system utilizing a multimodal or total communication approach that includes nonverbal communication, augmentative communication, gesturing, PECS, and vocalization. Therefore, the Hearing Officer must determine whether or not the program offered by the District is designed to meet STUDENT’s communication need.
An IEP meeting was held on October 25, 2002. Ms. Mallue and Ms. Moos testified that they jointly drafted three goals and objectives for STUDENT in speech and language. The goals are as follows: In one year, STUDENT will navigate through his augmentative communication device paired with verbal approximations with minimal assistance; In one year, STUDENT will answer who, what, and where questions about a story or experience using his augmentative communication device in the classroom setting; and STUDENT will imitate on request bilabial consonant-vowel and vowel- consonant words given auditory cues. Ms. Mallue and Ms. Moos both testified persuasively that these goals were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
Petitioner makes two arguments regarding the appropriateness of the goals and objectives. First, Petitioner argues that the District “threw in the towel” regarding vocalization because it was only after the PARENTs’s insistence that the proposed goals were modified to include “paired with verbal approximations.” Second, Petitioner asserts that the vocalization goal regarding bilabial consonant vowel and vowel consonant words is less rigorous than the previous IEP.
Ms. Mallue testified that initially the first proposed goal did not include the phrase “paired with verbal approximations.” She explained that the goals were merely drafts until adopted by the IEP team. After a discussion during the meeting, the team, including the PARENTs, agreed to include “paired with verbal approximations” in the goal. According to Ms. Mallue, this is the appropriate use of the IEP process and does not constitute the District’s lack of commitment to vocalization. The Hearing Officer finds that the goal as adopted by the IEP team was appropriate to meet STUDENT’s need.
Ms. Mallue and Ms. Moos both acknowledged that the third goal, specifically addressing vocalization, was less rigorous than the one in the previous IEP that expected STUDENT to vocalize consonant-vowel, vowel-consonant, and consonant-vowel-consonant words upon request within five seconds. Ms. Mallue explained that STUDENT made only minimal progress toward the previous goal and that the expectation of “within five seconds” was beyond his ability at that time. Further, Ms. Moos explained that when the IEP team drafted the previous year’s goal, it was in light of Dr. Fosnot’s reported progress. Ms. Moos explained that STUDENT had not yet generalized that progress out of the clinical setting into the school setting. Even Dr. Fosnot acknowledged that several of the words STUDENT was able to say in therapy took individual phoneme prompts that exceeded five seconds. In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the current year’s vocalization goal is designed to meet STUDENT’s current needs even though it is less rigorous than his previous goal.
To implement his goals and objectives, the current IEP provides for one twenty-minute and two thirty-minute speech and language sessions per week. Ms. Mallue and Ms. Moos both testified that this is an appropriate amount of time to implement STUDENT’s goals and objectives. Ms. Moos explained that the amount of individual therapy offered to STUDENT was reduced from his previous IEP because STUDENT became more proficient with his Dynamo and required less individual instruction. The Hearing Officer finds that one hour and twenty-minutes is an appropriate amount of speech therapy to meet STUDENT’s current needs.
Educational Benefit
STUDENT argues that the program provided by the District was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit because it failed to provide the amount of therapy necessary to meet STUDENT’s needs. As determined above, the District’s offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Ms. Notrica testified that she continues to see STUDENT progress in her class because he is better able to communicate his desires using PECS and his Dynamo.(Footnote 9) According to Ms. Notricta, he has not spontaneously spoken any audible words other than “moo”; however, his vocalization of individual sounds has improved.
The Hearing Officer finds that the program provided by the District was designed to meet STUDENT’s communication needs. As in previous years, it is impossible to apportion the amount of progress STUDENT has received between his school and private services. However, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit and that STUDENT continues to make progress in acquiring a functional communication system using multiple-modes of expressive language, including vocalization.
Comport with IEP
Petitioner again makes the same assertions regarding the District’s purported failure to implement his IEP. No evidence was presented by Petitioner establishing that the District failed to implement any portion of the IEP. Ms. Mallue and Ms. Moos both testified that they are currently providing STUDENT’s required speech therapy, that they are implementing his goals and objectives, and that Ms. Mallue is charting STUDENT’s progress. Ms. Notrica testified that she has provided the PARENTs with report cards and has met with MOTHER during a parent-teacher conference. MOTHER confirmed Ms. Notrica’s testimony. In light of all the evidence presented regarding the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has implemented a program in conformity with STUDENT’s IEP.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s IEP was designed to meet his unique communication needs and that is was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, and that the District’s program was implemented in conformity with STUDENT’s IEP. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has offered and provided STUDENT a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year.
Issue 4 Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for privately paid speech and language services provided by Dr. Fosnot and Dr. Brandt from April 2001 through the present exclusive of the payments already made by the District?
Under the IDEA, decision makers have the authority to award “appropriate” relief for violations of FAPE. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i). Appropriate relief may, under certain circumstances, include reimbursement for expenditures made on privately obtained educational services. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Dep. of Educ. Of Mass., 471 U.S. 359, 369 (1985). For example, parents may be entitled to be reimbursed for private expenditures if it is determined that the school district failed to offer a FAPE and the private placement provided benefit. Parents need not procure a fully appropriate placement for services to be entitled to reimbursement. Alamo Heights Independent School Dist. v. State Board of Ed., 79 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). Reimbursement may be awarded even if the private service provider does not meet state certification requirements. Florence County School Dist. 4 v. Carter, 114 S.Ct. 361, 365-366 (1993).
Equitable considerations, including the conduct of the parties, may be relevant in fashioning appropriate relief. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 374; W.G. v Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist., 96 F.2d 1479, 1486 (9th Cir. 1992); Student W. v Puyallup School Dist., 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994).
The Hearing Officer determined above that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE from April of 2001 through October 3, 2001 by failing to provide a vocalization and an augmentative communication component to the multimodal approach to meet his unique need to develop a functional communication system. Additionally, the Hearing Officer determined that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE from January 14, 2002 through the end of the ESY by only providing forty-five minutes per week of speech and language therapy instead of one hour and forty-five minutes that he required. The Hearing Officer will analyze the time periods separately.
April 2001- October 3, 2001
During this time period, STUDENT was seeing private speech therapist Dr. Brandt. From July forward, STUDENT was seeing Dr. Fosnot. Both Dr. Brandt and Dr. Fosnot testified that they provided vocalization therapy to STUDENT. Dr. Brandt testified that she also worked with STUDENT on his augmentative communication device. The Hearing Officer finds that the services of Dr. Brandt and Dr. Fosnot were virtually identical to the services that STUDENT required and was not provided by the District. Accordingly, the PARENTs are entitled to reimbursement for some of the services they privately obtained on STUDENT’s behalf. The next question for the Hearing Officer to resolve is the appropriate amount of reimbursement.
At that time, STUDENT was receiving forty-five minutes of speech therapy per week by the District. Ultimately, when the District drafted an appropriate IEP that included vocalization and augmentative communication goals, the District determined that STUDENT required an additional hour per week of speech and language therapy to meet his needs. The Hearing Officer determined above that the increase was appropriate. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that during the time STUDENT was denied a FAPE he should have received one hour and forty-five minutes of speech therapy rather than forty-five minutes per week. Therefore, STUDENT is entitled to reimbursement of one hour per week of private speech and language services from April of 2001 through October 3, 2001 with the exception of August.(Footnote 10)
Dr. Brandt and Dr. Fosnot provided more than one hour per week of therapy to STUDENT during the time period at issue. However, in light of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is entitled to reimbursement for one hour of private speech therapy per week for a total of twenty weeks. The District is ordered to reimburse PARENTS, upon proof of payment, for the private speech and language therapy sessions they privately paid for from April 2001 through October 3, 2001 (except August) not to exceed twenty hours.
January 14, 2002 through the ESY
The Hearing Officer found that STUDENT required one hour and forty-five minutes per week of speech and language therapy to meet his needs during this time. The District offered the appropriate time but the parents refused to accept the increase. In awarding reimbursement, the Hearing Officer may consider the actions of both parties. In this case, the Hearing Officer determines that the District stood ready, willing, and able to provide a program that met STUDENT’s speech and language needs and that the parents’ refusal to consent to the additional time prevented the District from implementing its program. PARENTS did not provide any explanation as to why they consented to additional goals and objectives but refused the time necessary to implement them.
Petitioner’s attorney argued in his closing brief that the parents were merely too polite to testify that they had lost all confidence in the District’s ability to meet their son’s vocalization needs. This argument is unavailing. If they had lost confidence, it defies logic that they would have agreed to additional goals and objectives to be implemented by the very therapists in whom they had purportedly lost confidence. The Hearing Officer determines it was for another reason.
MOTHER testified that she takes STUDENT to see Dr. Fosnot two times per week in the mornings. According to MOTHER and STUDENT’s teacher, Ms. Notrica, on those days, STUDENT does not arrive at school until between 10:30 and 11:00 a.m. MOTHER mentioned that she was concerned about the amount of time these private therapy session took away from STUDENT’s school day. In light of this testimony, the Hearing Officer concludes that at least one reason for rejecting the additional time was MOTHER’s concern that STUDENT would miss even more class time than he already was with the private therapy sessions. Further, the Hearing Officer determines that it was the PARENTs’ personal decision to pull STUDENT out of school and take him to a private service provider when the District had offered an appropriate program that would have allowed him to spend more time in the classroom.
The Hearing Officer determined that the District had an obligation to request a due process hearing to override the parents’ lack of consent. However, after considering all of the evidence, including the District’s appropriate offer and the PARENTs’ conduct in refusing to accept, the Hearing Officer declines to award reimbursement for the services the PARENTs privately obtained when the District was willing and able to provide those services.
For all other times at issue in this case, the Hearing Officer has determined that the District provided STUDENT a FAPE. Therefore, his request for reimbursement of privately paid services except for the twenty hours discussed above, is denied.
Issue 5 If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, is he entitled to five speech and language sessions per week with Grace Brandt through the extended school year as compensatory education?
Compensatory education is a form of equitable relief that may be awarded to help overcome lost educational opportunity. See: Parents of Petitioner W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). A hearing officer has broad authority to craft an appropriate equitable remedy. (See School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S.Ct. 1996 (1985)) Compensatory education does not require day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity lost or time missed. Its purpose is to “ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of IDEA.” Id. at 1497. However, equitable considerations are appropriate when fashioning compensatory remedies. An application of equitable principles requires that the actions of the parties themselves must be considered when evaluating the circumstances surrounding the child’s lost education opportunity and in creating an adequate remedy. Id. Thus, when considering a request for compensatory education, it is first necessary to determine whether an LEA failed to provide a FAPE. If that issue is answered affirmatively, the subsequent question is not what precise services were missed but, rather, what compensatory services are necessary to provide an appropriate education under the law.
In this case, the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT was denied a FAPE from April through October 3, 2001. However, the PARENTs privately obtained speech and language therapy from two service providers. Therefore, STUDENT did not suffer a loss of educational opportunity because he privately received the therapy that the District was obligated to provide. Furthermore, the PARENTs requested and received reimbursement for the private services. Additionally, the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT was denied a FAPE from January 14, 2002, through the ESY regarding the amount of time provided for his speech and language therapy. However, STUDENT actually received private speech therapy during that time. Therefore, he did not lose any educational benefit. The Hearing Officer is not awarding reimbursement for those services; however, that does not entitle STUDENT to compensatory services. As discussed above, STUDENT’s parents obtained private speech therapy despite the District’s appropriate offer. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is not entitled to compensatory education.
Petitioner’s request for compensatory education is denied.
ORDER
1. Within twenty (20) days of the date of this Decision the PARENTs are ordered to provide proof of payment to the District for the private therapy services they procured from Dr. Brandt and Dr. Fosnot on behalf of STUDENT from April 1, 2001 through October 3, 2001, with the exception of August.
2. Within twenty (20) days of receipt of the PARENT’s proof of payment, the District shall reimburse the PARENTs for one hour per week, not to exceed twenty hours total, for the privately procured services of Dr. Brandt and Dr. Fosnot from April 1, 2001 through October 3, 2001, with the exception of August.
3. All of Petitioner’s other claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
Issue 1 Did the District provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2000-2001 school year from April 2001 forward regarding speech and language services? STUDENT substantially prevailed on this issue.
Issue 2 Did the District provide STUDENT a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year regarding speech and language services? The District substantially prevailed on this issue, except to the extent that STUDENT was entitled to one additional hour of speech therapy per week that he did not receive from January 14, 2002 through the ESY.
Issue 3 Has the District provided STUDENT a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year regarding speech and language services? The District prevailed on this issue.
Issue 4 Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for privately paid speech and language services provided by Dr. Fosnot and Dr. Brandt from April 2001 through the present exclusive of the payments already made by the District? The District substantially prevailed on this issue except to the extent that twenty hours of reimbursement was awarded.
Issue 5 If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, is he entitled to five speech and language sessions per week with Grace Brandt through the extended school year as compensatory education? The District prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
DATED: May 27, 2003 ____________________________________ Joy Redmon, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. Fragile X Syndrome is caused by a mutated gene on the X chromosome. Affected individuals typically have developmental delays, variable levels of mental retardation, and may exhibit behavioral and emotional problems. (Thomas CL ed. Taber’s Cyclopedia Medical Dictionary. 18th ed. F.A. Davis Company. Philadelphia; 1997.) Apraxia was defined during the hearing by Dr. Fosnot and Dr. Montgomery generally as a motor-planning problem caused by a neuromuscular condition that impedes a person’s ability to produce individual speech sounds. 2. PECS is a “low-tech” augmentative communication system that utilizes cards with picture drawings on them. A student is able to expressively communicate by pointing to a particular card or exchanging a card to receive the tangible object depicted on the card. 3. A Dynamic Display Device is a “high-tech” augmentative communication device that records and then later plays that sound upon request. A person is able to touch a picture and the word is spoken. It can be customized to suit the individual person’s needs. 4. There are other criteria that must be met to provide a FAPE. For example, the student’s IEP must provide, among other things, for the student to be involved and progress in the general curriculum and to participate in extracurricular and other non-academic activities. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d). However, no other elements of FAPE are at issue in this matter. 5. STUDENT had multiple needs including academic, physical, and social emotional. However, the issue in this case is limited to speech and language. Therefore, this Decision will focus on only on STUDENT’s program in the context of speech and language. 6. The Hearing Officer determined above that the program offered by the District on June 13, 2001, was not an offer of FAPE because it failed to include any reference to vocalization. Additionally, the PARENTs did not accept that offer until it was modified on October 3. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer’s previous finding of a denial of FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year also applies to September of 2001. 7. The finding regarding the appropriateness of the IEP is made irrespective of the additional therapy hours with Dr. Fosnot funded by the District. 8. In his closing brief, Petitioner argued that the assistive technology assessment was untimely because it was scheduled to be conducted in the fall of 2001 and was not completed until January. However, Petitioner did not raise this as an issue at the outset of the hearing. Further, Petitioner did not request any remedy that would have compensated him for this alleged failure. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer declines to analyze whether or not the assistive technology assessment was timely. 9. For a period of time during the current school year, STUDENT used a more sophisticated AC device called a Dynomite. His Dynamo was lost and the company loaned the District the Dynomite until a new Dynamo could be delivered. STUDENT received his new Dynamo in February. 10. August is exempted because STUDENT’s program included only the extended school year and not fifty-two weeks per year. The District witnesses testified that the extended school year runs through July and the regular school year commences in September. Therefore, he would not have received any speech and language services from the District in August.
