California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 16, 2005

Student v. Fresno County Department of Children and Family Services

SEHO Case No. SN 262A-05, SN05-00262A · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote

Fresno County Department of Children and Family Services must provide compensatory social skills training; reimbursement claims denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 13 of 27 issues (2 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The original case was consolidated with Clovis Unified School District, then bifurcated by agreement; the Student–District matter (SN05-00262B/SN05-00390) was taken off calendar.

Summary

The parents of a 14-year-old eighth grader eligible for special education under autistic-like behaviors filed against the Fresno County Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS). Under California's interagency mental health law, DCFS provided his school-based therapy. The case began consolidated with Clovis Unified School District. The parents and the district moved toward settlement, and the DCFS claims were heard separately.

The Hearing Officer found DCFS's 2002 assessment substantially appropriate. DCFS gave no assessment plan, but the mother knew what the assessment would cover and took part in it, so FAPE was not denied. DCFS had no duty to reassess in 2002-2003. For the 2003 assessment, DCFS did not show that its assessor, listed as an unlicensed clinician, was qualified. In 2002 and 2003, DCFS did not share its assessment reports before IEP meetings, which kept the parents from taking full part. Across three school years, DCFS treatment plans lacked clear present levels, measurable goals, and service frequency, and did not address anxiety or social skills deficits. DCFS also stopped services in February 2003 without an IEP meeting. The Hearing Officer denied reimbursement for independent assessments and private tutoring. As compensatory education, DCFS must provide weekly social skills training, starting with one peer and moving to a peer group, through the 2005-2006 regular school year. Requests for ABA, speech therapy, and other remedies were denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO held a county mental health agency to IEP content and procedural duties under the interagency rules, such as sharing assessment reports and writing measurable treatment goals. It also shows the Hearing Officer treating social skills training as a mental health service the county could be ordered to provide as compensatory education.

Issues and holdings

  1. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEAssessment

    Issue 1. Did DCFS conduct an appropriate assessment of Student on February 4, 2002, and prepare an appropriate report of the assessment on February 11, 2002?

    DCFS gave no assessment plan, but the mother knew the assessment's parts and took part, so FAPE was not denied; the assessor was qualified, all suspected areas were assessed, and the report substantially complied. DCFS substantially prevailed.

  2. District prevailedResponsible agency

    Issue 2a. Did DCFS fail to offer and provide appropriate mental health services in 2001-2002, including ESY, by failing to document why its services were inappropriate?

    The referral did not show an autism diagnosis, and psychotherapy suited the stated concerns, so DCFS had no duty to reject the referral as inappropriate.

  3. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 2b. Did DCFS fail to make a copy of Student's mental health assessment available to his parents at least two days prior to the IEP meeting (2001-2002)?

    DCFS did not discuss or provide its assessment report before the February 2002 IEP meeting, which prevented the parents from participating effectively.

  4. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure

    Issue 2c. (Listed as a duplicate of 2b in the decision.) The body addresses DCFS's failure to contact the District within one working day of receipt of the referral to schedule an IEP meeting.

    DCFS violated the one-working-day contact rule, but the District held the IEP meeting and services were added, so there was no infringement or lost educational opportunity.

  5. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 2d. Did DCFS fail to provide a written assessment report to IEP team members (2001-2002)?

    DCFS did not show that it gave its report to the IEP team on time; its only transmittal letter was dated November 2003.

  6. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 2e. Did DCFS fail to attend IEP meetings (2001-2002)?

    There was no evidence that the District or the parents invited DCFS to IEP meetings, so its failure to attend was not a violation.

  7. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue 2f. Did DCFS fail to develop an IEP that included present levels, measurable goals and objectives, and the initiation, duration and frequency of services, reasonably calculated to provide benefit (2001-2002)?

    The provisional treatment plan and the April 2002 Plan of Care had vague present levels and goals, no frequency of services, and nothing on anxiety or social skills, so they were not designed to give educational benefit. Psychotherapy rather than ABA was an appropriate type of service for that period.

  8. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 3. Did DCFS conduct an appropriate assessment of Student for the 2002-2003 school year?

    No one requested a reassessment, and conditions did not warrant one because Student was making progress, so DCFS had no duty to reassess.

  9. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue 4a. Did DCFS fail to develop an IEP for 2002-2003, including ESY, with present levels, measurable goals and objectives, and the initiation, duration and frequency of services, reasonably calculated to provide benefit?

    The October 2002 Plan of Care had the same defects: generalized present levels, no anxiety or social skills goals, and no frequency for its therapies.

  10. Student prevailedImplementation

    Issue 4b. Did DCFS fail to notify parents, the District, and IEP team members of the discontinuation of services (2002-2003)?

    DCFS stopped services in February 2003 and issued a May 2003 discharge notice that apparently neither the parents nor the District received, so it failed to provide services consistent with the IEP.

  11. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 4c. Did DCFS fail to convene an IEP meeting to discuss the change to mental health services (2002-2003)?

    No IEP meeting was held to discontinue services; DCFS was not relieved of its obligation simply because the parents removed Student from the District.

  12. Student prevailed in partAssessment

    Issue 5. Did DCFS conduct an appropriate assessment of Student on October 17, 2003, and prepare an appropriate report of the assessment on October 31, 2003?

    DCFS did not show that its assessor, identified as an unlicensed clinician, was qualified. The missing assessment plan did not deny FAPE, all suspected areas were assessed, the observation setting was adequate, and the report met legal requirements.

  13. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 6a. Did DCFS fail, for 2003-2004, to contact the District within one working day of receipt of the referral to schedule an IEP meeting?

    DCFS offered no evidence that it complied; together with its other procedural failures, this seriously infringed on parent participation.

  14. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 6b. Did DCFS fail to make a copy of the mental health assessment available to the parents at least two days prior to the IEP meeting (2003-2004)?

    Without the report, the parents could not disagree with its recommendations or ask the assessor to attend, which seriously infringed on their participation.

  15. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 6c. Did DCFS fail to provide a written assessment report to IEP team members (2003-2004)?

    DCFS offered no evidence that it gave its report to the IEP team; this was part of the cumulative procedural violations that denied FAPE.

  16. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 6d. Did DCFS fail to attend IEP meetings (2003-2004)?

    The Hearing Officer found that DCFS offered no evidence of meeting any of the listed procedural requirements and concluded it failed to follow procedural requirements.

  17. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue 6e. Did DCFS fail to develop an IEP for 2003-2004 with present levels, measurable goals and objectives, and the initiation, duration and frequency of services, reasonably calculated to provide benefit?

    The provisional plan addressed only anxiety, and the December 2003 Plan of Care addressed only outbursts. Neither addressed social skills, and the December plan gave no frequency or duration for therapies.

  18. Issue 7. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for independent assessments by the M.I.N.D. Institute (May 22, 2003) and Howard Glidden, Ph.D. (January 12, 2004)?

    The 2002 DCFS assessment was appropriate and the M.I.N.D. assessment came more than a year later without a timely disagreement; Dr. Glidden's assessment came from an occupational therapist's referral, not from disagreement with DCFS's assessment.

  19. Issue 8. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for tutoring by the Cullinan Education Center from September 2002 to June 2003?

    No one testified about the tutoring, and there was no evidence linking it to DCFS's failure to provide mental health services.

  20. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 9a. Is Student entitled to ABA services from Teaching Autistic Children, 20-40 hours per week for one year or longer?

    Denied; the social skills training ordered was found to satisfy the compensatory request.

  21. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 9b. Is Student entitled to a social skills curriculum, including "Navigating the Social World," as part of the school curriculum?

    Denied; no testimony was offered about the program or whether it was appropriate for Student.

  22. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 9c. Is Student entitled to a social skills play group with typically developing age-appropriate peers supervised by an individual experienced in autistic spectrum disorders?

    Granted in modified form: DCFS must provide weekly social skills training with age-appropriate peers who have appropriate social skills, starting with one peer, through the 2005-2006 regular school year. Session length is at DCFS's discretion.

  23. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 9d. Is Student entitled to $1,000 toward parent training?

    Denied as covered by the social skills training ordered.

  24. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 9e. Is Student entitled to speech and language services from the Center for Communication Skills three times weekly in 50-minute sessions?

    Denied.

  25. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 9f. Is Student entitled to the FastForward program as recommended by the Center for Communication Skills?

    Denied.

  26. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 9g. Is Student entitled to training in autistic spectrum disorders four times per year for mental health professionals who assess or serve autistic students?

    Denied.

  27. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 9h. Is Student entitled to a functional analysis assessment by a behaviorist experienced in autistic spectrum disorders?

    Denied.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Compensatory education. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, DCFS must begin social skills training. It must first introduce Student to the training with one age-appropriate peer who has appropriate social skills; the DCFS therapist decides how long this step takes, but it must be finished within two months.
  • Compensatory education. DCFS must provide weekly social skills therapy with an age-appropriate peer group whose members have appropriate social skills. This runs for the rest of the 2004-2005 school year, including extended school year, and for the entire regular 2005-2006 school year. DCFS sets the length of each session.
  • All other requested relief was denied, including reimbursement for the independent assessments and Cullinan tutoring, ABA, a specific social skills curriculum, parent training funds, speech-language services, FastForward, staff training, and a functional analysis assessment.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist.; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Adams v. Oregon; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Burlington; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Alamo Heights Independent School Dist. v. State Board of Education; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. Missouri; Cal. Gov. Code §§ 7570-7576; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 2, §§ 60020, 60045, 60050

People named in the decision

  • Howard Glidden, Ph.D., developmental neuropsychologist in private practice; independent assessor and expert witness for Student
  • Michelle Wenell, certified associate behavioral analyst; expert witness for Student, Advance Kids (certified nonpublic agency), executive director
  • Aaron Stabel, board-certified behavior analyst; independent behavior assessor, Advance Kids
  • Susan Clare, Ph.D., former school psychologist; witness for Student, Clovis Unified School District
  • Chris Weatherby (also spelled Weatherly; formerly Norton), marriage and family therapist; DCFS therapist 2002-2003; witness for DCFS, Fresno County DCFS
  • Fletcher Davis, licensed clinical social worker; DCFS therapist at IIP; witness for DCFS, Fresno County DCFS
  • Laurie Haberman, division manager, Fresno County DCFS
  • Jeanie Cox, clinical supervisor, Fresno County DCFS
  • Margaret Hart, clinical supervisor, Fresno County DCFS
  • Sharon Bryer, LCSW, senior licensed mental health clinician; conducted 2002 mental health assessment, Fresno County DCFS
  • Marian Wood, unlicensed mental health clinician; conducted October 2003 assessment, Fresno County DCFS
  • Deborah Riverhawk Helmns, LCSW; co-signer of October 2003 assessment report, Fresno County DCFS
  • Isabelo Artacho, neurologist; prescribing physician
  • Richard E. Reither, private marriage and family therapist
  • Linda Reither, private speech-language therapist
  • Ms. Folmer, RSP teacher, Dry Creek Elementary School
  • Emily Devere, occupational therapist; referred Student to Dr. Glidden
  • M.I.N.D. Institute, University of California, Davis, independent assessor
  • Diagnostic Center Central California, state diagnostic center; assessed Student in 2002
  • Cullinan Education Center, private tutoring provider
  • Teaching Autistic Children, proposed private ABA provider
  • Center for Communication Skills, proposed private speech-language provider

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter convened before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific=s McGeorge School of Law, in Clovis, California, on March 9 and 10, and in Fresno, California, on March 11, 2005. (Footnote 1)

STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorneys Mandy Leigh of EduLegal and Jay J. Jambeck of the Schinner Law Group. Also present on behalf of STUDENT were his parents. Respondent Fresno County Department of Children and Family Services (Respondent or DCFS) was represented by attorney Zachary Redmond, deputy county counsel, Office of the Fresno County Counsel. Also present on behalf of DCFS were Laurie Haberman, division manager; Jeanie Cox, clinical supervisor; and Margaret Hart, clinical supervisor.

Petitioner called the following witnesses: Dr. Howard Glidden, developmental neuropsychologist in private practice; Michelle Wenell, certified associate behavioral analyst and executive director of Advance Kids, a certified nonpublic agency (NPA); mother; father; and Susan Clare, Ph.D., former school psychologist with Clovis Unified School District. DCFS called mental health clinicians Chris Weatherby, marriage family therapist (MFT), and Fletcher Davis, licensed clinical social worker (LCSW).

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open for the receipt of written closing briefs. After receipt of the closing briefs, the record was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

This case began as a consolidated matter involving STUDENT, DCFS, and the Clovis Unified School District. On the first day of hearing, STUDENT and the District indicated their intent to settle issues regarding STUDENT=s education. However, STUDENT and DCFS were unable to reach agreement on issues regarding the appropriateness of mental health services and indicated their intent to proceed to hearing. The case then was bifurcated by agreement of the parties. The matter regarding STUDENT and DCFS, SN05-00262A, proceeded to hearing on the issues identified below. The consolidated case involving the Student and the District, SN05-00262B/SN05-00390, was taken off calendar.

ISSUES

1. Did the Fresno County Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS) conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT on February 4, 2002, and prepare an appropriate report of the assessment on February 11, 2002?

2. Did DCFS fail to offer and provide STUDENT appropriate mental health services during the 2001-2002 school year, including the extended school year (ESY), by failing to a. document why its services were inappropriate;

b. make a copy of STUDENT=s mental health assessment available to his parents at least two days prior to the IEP meeting;

c. make a copy of STUDENT=s mental health assessment available to his parents at least two days prior to the IEP meeting;

d. provide a written assessment report to IEP team members;

e. attend IEP meetings; and f. develop an IEP that included present levels of performance, measurable goals and objectives, and the initiation, duration and frequency of services, and that was reasonably calculated to provide him with benefit?

3. Did DCFS conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT for the 2002-2003 school year?

4. Did DCFS fail to offer and provide STUDENT appropriate mental health services for the 2002-2003 school year, including the ESY, by failing to a. develop an IEP that included present levels of performance, measurable goals and objectives, and the initiation, duration and frequency of services, and that was reasonably calculated to provide him with benefit;

b. notify parents, the District, and IEP team members of the discontinuation of services; and c. convene an IEP meeting to discuss the change to mental health services?

5. Did DCFS conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT on October 17, 2003, and prepare an appropriate report of the assessment on October 31, 2003?

6. Did DCFS fail to offer and provide STUDENT with appropriate mental health services for the 2003-2004 school year, including the ESY, by failing to a. contact the District within one working day of receipt of STUDENT=s referral to schedule an IEP meeting;

b. make a copy of STUDENT=s mental health assessment available to his parents at least two days prior to the IEP meeting;

c. provide a written assessment report to IEP team members;

d. attend IEP meetings; and e. develop an IEP that included present levels of performance, measurable goals and objectives, and the initiation, duration and frequency of services, and that was reasonably calculated to provide him with benefit?

7. If DCFS failed to conduct appropriate assessments and prepare appropriate reports of assessments, are STUDENT=s parents entitled to reimbursement for independent assessments conducted by the M.I.N.D. Institute on May 22, 2003, and by Howard Glidden, Ph.D., on January 12, 2004?

8. If DCFS failed to offer and/or provide STUDENT with appropriate mental health services, are his parents entitled to reimbursement for tutoring provided to STUDENT by the Cullinan Education Center from September 2002 to June 2003?

9. If DCFS failed to offer and/or provide STUDENT with appropriate mental health services, is he entitled to the following prospective compensatory remedies:

a. Applied behavior analysis (ABA) services provided by Teaching Autistic Children in the amount of 20-40 hours per week for one year or longer;

b. Provision of a social skills curriculum, including ANavigating the Social World@ as part of the school curriculum;

c. Provision of a social skills play group with typically developing age-appropriate peers supervised by an individual with experience in autistic spectrum disorders;

d. One thousand dollars toward parent training;

e. Speech and language services to be provided by the Center for Communication Skills three times per week in 50-minute sessions;

f. The FastForward program as recommended by the Center for Communication Skills;

g. Training in autistic spectrum disorders four times per year for mental health professionals who assess and/or provide services to autistic students by an individual who has experience in autistic spectrum disorder diagnosis or who has experience creating IEPs with appropriate services for children with autistic spectrum disorders; and h. Completion of a functional analysis assessment by a behaviorist with experience in autistic spectrum disorders?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a fourteen-year-old student in the eighth grade. He is eligible for special education under the criteria of autistic-like behaviors and exhibits deficits in social skills and pragmatic language. STUDENT resists following rules and exhibits angry outbursts at school. His cognitive skills generally fall in the average range. STUDENT has had varying diagnoses including Asperger=s Syndrome, Tourette=s Disorder, obsessive compulsive disorder (ODD), attention deficit hyperactive disorder (ADHD), depression, anxiety, and autism. At the time of the hearing, STUDENT was attending Alta Sierra Intermediate School, where he was placed in the resource specialist program (RSP) for core academic classes and receiving RSP support for science, and taking general education art and physical education classes. STUDENT also was receiving speech and language therapy for 30 minutes weekly to address poor pragmatic skills and participating in social skills training to improve interactions with peers. STUDENT has a behavior intervention plan (BIP) to address behavioral difficulties which include verbal outbursts, attacks on peers and adults, and use of profanity.

STUDENT exhibited odd behaviors at home at an early age and experienced behavioral difficulties and poor social skills at school beginning in kindergarten. Dr. Isabelo Artacho, neurologist, initially evaluated STUDENT because of head and leg tics, and prescribed various medications to address anxiety and attentional difficulties. (Footnote 2) STUDENT has been eligible for special education because of autistic-like behaviors since the second grade. During STUDENT=s early elementary school years, STUDENT=s parents intermittently provided individual therapy for STUDENT with Richard E. Reither, MFT. In a report dated September 2, 1999, when STUDENT was in the third grade, Mr. Reither stated that STUDENT portrayed many symptoms of Asperger=s Syndrome. The family also met with Mr. Reither. The parents found Mr. Reither=s guidance helpful to their understanding of STUDENT and their gaining skills to successfully manage his behavior at home. The parents also provided STUDENT with private speech and language therapy from Linda Reither during elementary school.

During the school year 2001-2002, STUDENT attended the fifth grade at Dry Creek Elementary School and was placed in Ms. Folmer=s RSP class for core academics. On January 10, 2002, STUDENT=s parents consented to the IEP team=s referral of STUDENT to DCFS for an assessment. The referral was due to STUDENT=s experiencing Asignificant social/emotional difficulties beyond Asperger=s symptomology.@ The behaviors included outbursts, anger, tantrums, low frustration tolerance, out-of-control laughter, and inability to relate appropriately to adults and peers. (Student=s Exhibit 000038) Sharon Bryer undertook the assessment on behalf of DCFS. At the time of her assessment, STUDENT=s parents reported that he was taking Paxil and Metidate. Ms. Bryer=s report of the assessment, dated February 11, 2002, recommended outpatient mental health therapy to reduce angry outbursts. At an IEP meeting on February 26, 2002, the team agreed to add mental health services to STUDENT=s IEP. No one from DCFS attended the IEP meeting. The IEP called for therapy one hour each week. Because Ms. Bryer retired, Chris Weatherby (Footnote 3) provided STUDENT=s outpatient therapy from February 2002 through the summer.

Also in February 2002, the District began its triennial evaluation of STUDENT. The psychoeducational report noted that STUDENT was exhibiting difficulty with both adult and peer interactions. STUDENT also was observed to exhibit poor eye contact and poor voice modulation, engage in attention seeking behavior, and misinterpret verbal, nonverbal, and body language of others. Following a referral from the District, a team from the Diagnostic Center Central California observed STUDENT at school on April 2, 2002, and assessed him at the Center the following day. The focus of the assessment was to develop an understanding of STUDENT=s behavioral and academic needs. The Diagnostic Center made multiple recommendations including that STUDENT would benefit from the kinds of educational and communicative interventions for children with autism and Asperger=s. In April 2002, the IEP team developed goals and objectives in the areas of reading, written language, and mathematics. Other goals related to increasing STUDENT=s vocabulary, following class rules, decreasing frustration, and improving problem-solving skills, social language, social interactions. DCFS=s initial Plan of Care, which is dated April 22, 2002, identified decreasing STUDENT=s temper outbursts as the primary goal of mental health services.

During STUDENT=s sixth-grade year, he participated in the Elementary Intervention Program (EIP), which was located at Clovis Elementary School. The EIP was a special day class (SDC) serving emotionally disturbed (ED) students in grades 1 through 6 from throughout the District. The EIP class had a structured point and level system that allowed students to earn privileges for good behavior. DCFS provided mental health services in the EIP, including recreational, individual, and family therapies. Ms. Weatherly continued to provide STUDENT=s therapy while he attended the EIP. An updated DCFS Plan of Care, dated October 30, 2002, noted STUDENT=s low tolerance for frustration was leading to temper outbursts. STUDENT=s Plan called for continued individual therapy, collateral therapy to support the parents, and recreation therapy to improve STUDENT=s social skills.

In February 2003, STUDENT=s parents removed him from the EIP and enrolled him in a home school program through the Sierra Charter School, which is chartered by the Sanger School District. On May 22, 2003, DCFS discharged STUDENT, apparently believing that the parents no longer wanted services from DCFS because they were taking STUDENT to the M.I.N.D. Institute of the University of California, Davis. (Footnote 4) Following a visit in June 2003, the M.I.N.D. Institute assessors diagnosed STUDENT as having Asperger=s disorder, depression, and an unspecified learning disorder. Recommendations included having STUDENT participate in a social skills group.

STUDENT returned to the District in the fall of 2003, and was placed in the Intermediate Intervention Program (IIP) at Alta Sierra Intermediate School for the seventh grade. The IIP is an SDC that serves students in grades 7 and 8 who are emotionally disturbed. The IIP includes a structured level system that allows students to earn points for appropriate behavior. STUDENT=s IEP goals and objectives addressed areas of reading, mathematics, and pragmatic language. STUDENT continued to receive speech and language therapy and psychological services to address deficits in pragmatic language and social skills. DCFS undertook a reassessment of STUDENT on October 17, 2003. At the time of DCFS=s assessment, STUDENT was taking Paxil, Clonidine, and Risperidal, which had been prescribed by Dr. Artacho. The goal of DCFS=s Plan of Care, dated October 30, 2003, was to reduce STUDENT=s symptoms of anxiety, which included inattention, difficulty sitting still and inability to focus or concentrate. On November 14, 2003, STUDENT=s parents gave consent for him to resume outpatient services from DCFS. Fletcher Davis provided STUDENT=s therapy at the IIP.

In January 2004, STUDENT=s parents engaged Dr. Glidden to independently assess STUDENT. Dr. Glidden reviewed STUDENT=s educational and medical records, and administered multiple tests to STUDENT that focused on assessing STUDENT=s cognitive, perceptual, sensory, and behavioral skills. Dr. Glidden gave STUDENT the diagnosis of autism. Dr. Glidden=s recommendations included that STUDENT receive multisensory/multimodal instruction, continue with speech and language therapy, be placed in a structured classroom with a low student-to-teacher ratio, receive social skills training, participate in structured social activities, and that his educational program incorporate the Treatment and Education of Autistic and related Communication-handicapped Children (TEAACH) program. Dr. Glidden also recommended development of a contingency behavior program for STUDENT.

On April 2, 2004, STUDENT=s parents withdrew their consent to DCFS services because of their concern that the therapy from DCFS was not appropriately addressing STUDENT=s needs as a child with autism. STUDENT=s parents also obtained an independent assessment of STUDENT=s behavior from Advance Kids. The assessment, which was undertaken by Aaron Stabel, board-certified behavioral analyst (BCBA), consisted of a file review, observation of STUDENT at school and at home, and parent interviews. Mr. Stabel=s recommendations included academic testing, updating the functional analysis assessment (FAA) and behavior support plan (BSP), social skills training, monitoring the effectiveness of the BSP, and training for staff on intervention strategies and data collection. Mr. Stabel also recommended implementing Dr. Glidden=s recommendations and consulting with a board-certified behavior analyst to develop and implement appropriate behavioral techniques.

The parents initially filed for a hearing naming the District and DCFS, and raised issues of the appropriateness of past and present programs, mental health services, and placements provided to STUDENT. The District cross-filed on issues of whether it could assess STUDENT and make a new referral to DCFS over the lack of consent from the parents, and the appropriateness of its prior assessments and offer of placement. As previously stated, the cases were consolidated, then bifurcated, and the issues remaining in the present case are limited to the appropriateness of services provided by DCFS.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE 1: Did the Fresno County Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS) conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT on February 4, 2002, and prepare an appropriate report of the assessment on February 11, 2002?

STUDENT contends that DCFS failed to properly assess him because (1) DCFS did not provide his parents with an assessment plan within 15 days of receipt of the referral from the District, (2) the assessment was not conducted by a qualified individual, (3) DCFS did not assess him in all areas of suspected disability, and (4) DCFS did not observe him in his classroom. STUDENT also contends that the report of the assessment is deficient because it does not include (1) observations in STUDENT=s school setting, (2) a discussion of the relationship of STUDENT=s behavior to his academic and social functioning, (3) any educationally relevant health and development, and medical findings, (4) a determination of the effects of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage, and (5) a recommendation of whether STUDENT requires special education and related services.

Assessment Plan

STUDENT asserts that DCFS did not provide his parents with an assessment plan. DCFS did not provide evidence of an assessment plan.

On January 10, 2002, the District referred STUDENT to DCFS for an assessment to determine whether he was eligible for mental health services. (Student=s Exhibit 000038-39) Upon receipt of the referral, DCFS was required to follow certain procedures. (Footnote 5) Within five days of receipt of the referral, DCFS was required to review the recommendation and determine if a mental health assessment was necessary. If DCFS determined a mental health assessment was necessary, it was required to notify the District, develop a mental health assessment plan, and provide the plan and a consent form to the parent within 15 days of receipt of the referral. Cal. Code. Regs. tit. 2, ' 60045(a) and (b). See also Education Code section 56321(a), which similarly provides that whenever an assessment is proposed, the parent must be given a proposed assessment plan within 15 days of the referral for assessment. In this case, DCFS concluded that an assessment of STUDENT was necessary and, therefore, was required to provide his parents with an assessment plan.

There is no evidence that DCFS prepared an assessment plan and presented it to STUDENT=s parents for their consideration. However, the evidence establishes that MOTHER was informed of the components of the proposed mental health assessment, albeit by the District rather than DCFS. The District=s consent for mental health referral form included the following statement:

I understand that the referral consists of a review of school records and an observation of the student. If further assessment by the Mental Health staff is needed, a new assessment plan will be developed for my approval.

(Student=s Exhibit 000038)

Below this statement, MOTHER signed her name on January 10, 2002, giving her consent to the referral to DCFS and to the exchange of information between DCFS and the District. Additionally, MOTHER was present and participated in the assessment, completed a form providing medical and family histories, and, as reflected on the assessment form, was given opportunities to provide input regarding STUDENT=s presenting problems, developmental history, medical problems, medications, conditions affecting STUDENT=s physical and mental health, and psychiatric history of STUDENT and his family. (DCFS Exhibits 9 and 10)

As to the required contents of an assessment plan, section 60045(b) provides that the assessment plan must include, but is not limited to, a review of the student=s school records and observation of the pupil in the educational setting, when appropriate. Section 56321(b)(3) of the Education Code requires that the assessment plan include an explanation of the types of assessments to be conducted. A review of the consent for assessment reveals that the proposed assessment would consist of a review of school records and an observation, which the hearing officer determines identifies the components of the assessment and sufficiently satisfies the requirements of section 60045(b).

In summary, STUDENT=s parent knew the proposed elements of the DCFS assessment and participated in the assessment. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that although DCFS did not provide the parents with an assessment plan and failed to conform to special education procedural requirements, the evidence establishes that this omission did not seriously infringe on the parents= participation in the IEP process or result in a denial of FAPE to STUDENT. (Footnote 6)

Assessor

On February 4, 2002, Sharon Bryer, LCSW and senior licensed mental health clinician for DCFS, assessed STUDENT on behalf of DCFS. (DCFS Ex. 10) STUDENT does not dispute that Ms. Bryer is a properly licensed clinical social worker. However, STUDENT asserts that Ms. Bryer was not qualified to assess STUDENT because diagnosing autism spectrum disorders was Aoutside the scope of her practice.@ DCFS asserts that Ms. Bryer was qualified to assess STUDENT and that STUDENT=s argument fails because STUDENT did not have the diagnosis of autism at the time of the assessment.

As to the requirements Ms. Bryer must have satisfied to undertake a mental health assessment of STUDENT, Government Code section 7572(c) requires that mental health assessments be conducted by qualified mental health professionals as specified by the regulations. The applicable provision of the regulations, section 60020(j) of the California Code of Regulations, title 2, defines Aqualified mental health professional@ as licensed practitioners of the healing arts: a psychiatrist; psychologist; clinical social worker; marriage, family and child counselor; registered nurse, mental health rehabilitation specialist, and others who have been waivered under Section 5751.2 of the Welfare and Institutions Code. Such individuals may provide mental health services, consistent with their scope of practice.

Ms. Bryer has retired from DCFS and did not testify at the hearing. However, Ms. Weatherby testified that Ms. Bryer was a licensed clinical social worker, which is reflected on Ms. Bryer=s assessment report. Under the above regulation, Ms. Bryer=s license qualified her as a licensed practitioner to undertake a mental health assessment. The Hearing Officer finds unavailing STUDENT=s assertions that assessing STUDENT was Aoutside the scope of her practice.@ First, although it is unclear from the evidence what Ms. Bryer=s experience was with children with autism, there is no specific requirement that she have a certain amount of experience in that area to be qualified to conduct a mental health assessment. Second, at the time of the assessment, STUDENT had been given multiple diagnosis, none of which then established that he was a child with autism.

Assessment

STUDENT contends that the assessment by DCFS was deficient because it did not assess him in all areas of suspected disability and did not include an observation of him in the school setting. DCFS contends that its assessment was appropriate.

Regarding the required contents of a mental health assessment, California Code of Regulations, title 2, section 60020(g) states that a Amental health assessment@ is a service designed to provide formal, documented evaluation or analysis of the nature of the pupil=s emotional or behavioral disorder. It is conducted in accordance with California Code of Regulations, Title 9, Section 543(b), and Sections 56320 through 56329 of the Education Code. . . .

Education Code sections 56320 provides, in pertinent part:

(a) Testing and assessment materials and procedures used for the purposes of assessment and placement of individuals with exceptional needs are selected and administered so as not to be racially culturally, or sexually discriminatory. (b) Tests and other assessment materials meet all the following requirements: (1) Are provided and administered in the pupil=s primary language or other mode of communication . . . (2) Have been validated for the specific purpose for which they are used.

(3) Are administered by trained personnel in conformance with the instructions provided by the producer of the tests and other assessment materials, except that individually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning shall be administered by a credentialed school psychologist . . . (e) No single procedure is used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for an individual with exceptional needs. (f) The pupil is assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, including low vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional status. A developmental history is obtained, when appropriate. . . .

Because STUDENT=s allegations regarding the inappropriateness of the DCFS=s evaluations are limited to whether he was assessed in all areas of suspected disability and whether the assessment inappropriately failed to include an observation of him in the school setting, it is unnecessary to address other requirements of Education Code section 56320 through 56329. (Footnote 7)

Turning first to whether the DCFS assessed STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability, the District=s referral for assessment identifies concerns related to STUDENT=s having outbursts of anger, tantruming, out-of-control laughter, low frustration tolerance, and difficulty relating appropriately to adults and peers. (Student=s Ex. 39) A form completed by MOTHER indicates similar concerns. She checked the following problem areas: overly active, can=t sit still, easily distracted, poor concentration, does not think before acting, does not do as asked, argues with adults, back talks, temper outbursts, easily angered, no friends, teases or is teased, trouble with kids, difficulty with school work, irritability, stays to self and headaches/stomach aches. (DCFS Ex. 9)

Ms. Bryer=s assessment of STUDENT on February 4, 2004, consisted of a review of STUDENT=s school records and interviews of STUDENT and his mother. From these sources, Ms. Bryer gathered information regarding STUDENT=s presenting problems, developmental history, medical problems, medications, and special education resources, conditions affecting STUDENT=s physical and mental health, and a psychiatric history of STUDENT and his family. From her observations and interactions of STUDENT, Ms. Bryer obtained information regarding STUDENT=s then-current mental status. Information regarding STUDENT=s education was gleaned from the parent, STUDENT, his school records, and also from Ms. Folmer, STUDENT=s teacher. (DCFS Ex. 10)

By comparing the areas of concern and the areas covered by the assessment, the Hearing Officer concludes that all areas of suspected disability were assessed. Contrary to STUDENT=s assertions, there was no specific concern related to or request for an assessment of autism.

STUDENT asserts that Education Code section 56327(c) required that the DCFS assessment include an observation of him at school. DCFS asserts that its assessment satisfied legal requirements.

Education Code section 56327(c) provides that the written assessment report must include Arelevant behavior noted during the observation of the pupil in an appropriate setting.@ It is undisputed that the initial DCFS assessment did not include an observation of STUDENT at school. However, the assessment included Ms. Bryer=s observations of STUDENT during testing and also included information regarding STUDENT=s behavior at school from STUDENT=s teacher. Ms. Bryer also reviewed STUDENT=s educational records, which provided her with additional information regarding STUDENT=s behavior at school. It is noted that a summary of this information is included in Ms. Bryer=s report of the assessment. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the assessment sufficiently satisfied Education Code section 56327(c) requiring an observation occur in an Aappropriate@ setting.

Assessment Report

STUDENT contends that the assessment report prepared by Ms. Bryer is deficient because it does not include the items enumerated above. DCFS contends that the assessment report satisfied legal requirements.

Section 60045(g) of California Code of Regulations, title 2, requires the assessor to provide a written assessment report to the IEP team pursuant to Education Code section 56327. Education Code section 56327 requires in pertinent part that the report include the following:

(a) Whether the pupil may need special education and related services. (b) The basis for making the determination.

(c) The relevant behavior noted during the observations of the pupil in an appropriate setting. (d) The relationship of that behavior to the pupil=s academic and social functioning. (e) The educationally relevant health and development, and medical findings, if any. . . . (g) A determination concerning the effects of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage, where appropriate. . . .

The report of Ms. Bryer=s assessment is dated April 2, 2002. The report includes information and/or findings under the following headings: identifying information, a description of the problem, relevant history, other factors to consider as appropriate, recommendations, provisional treatment plan, and date of initiation of services. (DCFS Ex. 3) Comparing Ms. Bryer=s report with the requirements of an appropriate assessment report establishes that the report meets subsection (a) of 56327 because it includes a recommendation for servicesBthat STUDENT participate in outpatient services. Subsections (b) and (d) are satisfied by the comment indicating that STUDENT=s educational performance is adversely affected by other factors than a disabling condition. Although the report describes STUDENT=s behavior, there is no indication whether the information was derived from observations. Therefore, it is difficult to determine whether subsection (c) has been satisfied by the report. However, the report does describe STUDENT=s behavior and indicates that STUDENT Averbally abuses peers, bangs his head on the desk, pounds on his desk with his fist, and refuses to follow staff directives.@ The report does describe relevant medical history and indicates that environmental, cultural, and economic disadvantage were considered. In summary, although the assessment report is brief, the evidence as discussed above establishes that the report substantially satisfies the requirements of an appropriate assessment report.

ISSUE 2: Did DCFS fail to offer and provide STUDENT appropriate mental health services during the 2001-2002 school year, including the extended school year (ESY)?

Under both the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, students with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. ' 1400; Cal. Educ. Code ' 56000. The term Afree appropriate public education@ means special education and related services that are available to a student free of charge, that meet the standards of the State educational agency, and that are provided in conformity with the student=s IEP. 20 U.S.C. ' 1402(8). ASpecial education@ is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. ' 1401(a)(16). The term Arelated services@ includes transportation and other services that may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. (Footnote 8) 20 U.S.C. ' 1401(17); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, ' 3001(z).

A claim that there has been a denial of a FAPE can present both procedural and substantive questions. Among the IDEA=s procedural mandates is that the process for the development of the IEP allow the parents to meaningfully participate in it. Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 206-207, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982). Not every procedural flaw is critical, but one that results in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringes on the parents= opportunity to participate in the IEP process may constitute a denial of a FAPE. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483-1484 (9th Cir. 1992).

Substantively, the determination of a FAPE is based on the appropriateness of the educational program offered or provided to the student with a disability. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). In Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court stated that the student need not be provided with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child=s abilities. Id. at 198-200. Rather, the Court held that the student must be provided a Abasic floor of opportunity@ consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to meet the student=s needs, reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, and that comport with the student=s IEP. Id. at 201. (Footnote 9)

California Government Code Chapter 26.5 describes interagency responsibilities for providing services, including mental health services, to students with disabilities. Pursuant to 26.5, Aensuring maximum utilization of all state and federal resources available to provide a child with a disability . . . with a free appropriate public education, the provision of related services . . . and designated instruction and services . . . shall be the joint responsibility of the Superintendent of Public Instruction and the Secretary of Health and Welfare.@ Cal. Gov=t Code ' 7570. The State Department of Mental Health, or any community mental health service, Ashall be responsible for the provision of mental health services, as defined in regulations by the State Department of Mental Health, developed in consultation with the State Department of Education, when required in the pupil=s individualized educational program.@ Cal. Gov=t Code ' 7576(a). The regulations applicable to the State Department of Mental Health and its designated local agencies provide that Aspecial education instruction, designated instruction and services, related services, and residential placements are to be provided at no cost to the parent.@ Cal. Code Regs., tit. 2, ' 60200(b). When mental health services are necessary for a student with a disability to benefit from special education, the student=s IEP must specify the Ainitiation, duration and frequency of the mental health services.@ Cal. Code Regs., tit. 2, ' 60050(a)(4).

Alleged Procedural Violations

STUDENT contends that DCFS=s failure to adhere to procedural requirements resulted in a denial of a free appropriate public education (FAPE). Specifically, STUDENT asserts that DCFS failed (1) to document why its services were inappropriate, (2) to contact the District within one working day of receipt of his referral to schedule an IEP meeting, (3) to make a copy of the mental health assessment available to his parents at least two days prior to the IEP meeting, (4) to provide a written assessment report to IEP team members, and (5) to attend IEP meetings.

STUDENT asserts that because DCFS is precluded from providing services to children with a diagnosis of autism and, at the time of the referral, STUDENT was eligible for special education as autistic-like, DCFS could not provide STUDENT with appropriate services. Therefore, in STUDENT=s opinion, DCFS failed to follow procedural requirements because it did not document why its services were inappropriate pursuant to the section 60045(a)(1) of the California Code of Regulations, title 2. DCFS asserts that STUDENT did not have a diagnosis of autism at the time of the referral and that an educational eligibility of autistic-like did not make STUDENT=s referral inappropriate. DCFS also asserts that STUDENT is difficult to diagnose and that assessors have been unable to agree upon the proper diagnosis.

Section 60045(a)(1) states that within five working days of receipt of a referral, DCFS must review the referral to determine if an assessment is necessary. If DCFS determines that the referral is Ainappropriate,@ it must document the reasons and notify the District and parents within one working day. There is no dispute that DCFS did not provide the District and STUDENT=s parents with a notice that the referral was inappropriate. However, the Hearing Officer concludes that DCFS was not required to determine that the District=s referral of STUDENT was inappropriate and, therefore, was not required to provide notice to the District and STUDENT=s parents.

First, even assuming that DCFS does not serve children with autism, there was nothing in the District=s referral that would have required DCFS to reject the referral as Ainappropriate.@ The referral does not indicate that STUDENT had a diagnosis of autism. (Footnote 10) Rather, it states, Ain addition to his medical diagnosis of Tourette=s, OCD and ADHD, as well as symptoms of Asperger=s, STUDENT exhibits significant social/emotional difficulties beyond the Asperger symptomatology. STUDENT exhibits outbursts of anger with tantruming, out-of-control laughter, and low frustration tolerance. He picks upon the weaknesses of peers and makes cruel remarks to them. STUDENT is unable to relate appropriately to adults as well as peers.@ Further, the referral indicates that part of the reason for the referral was that the District intended to refer STUDENT to its EIP for emotionally disturbed children and mental health services were a mandated component of the program. (Student=s Ex. 39)

Moreover, DCFS is charged with providing psychotherapy as defined in section 2903 of the Business and Professions Code. Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, ' 60020(i). Section 2903 of the Business and Professions Code defines Apsychotherapy@ as the Ause of psychological methods in a professional relationship to assist a person or persons to acquire greater human effectiveness or to modify feelings, conditions, attitudes and behavior which are emotionally, intellectually, or socially ineffectual or maladjustive.@ There is no evidence that at the time of the referral, psychotherapy would have been inappropriate to address STUDENT=s social and emotional concerns delineated in the referral.

Finally, the testimony of Ms. Weatherby, who provided STUDENT=s therapy following the assessment, was persuasive as to STUDENT=s needs at the time of his referral to DCFS. Ms. Weatherby is an MFT and is very familiar with STUDENT because she provided his therapy for the year following the referral to DCFS. Ms. Weatherby testified that she did not see STUDENT as a child with autism because of his ability to communicate and be insightful. Ms. Weatherby testified that she believed STUDENT exhibited characteristics of Asperger=s, signs of ODD, anxiety, angry outbursts, frustration, aggression, and defiance. For all of the above reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that DCFS did not inappropriately accept STUDENT=s referral.

STUDENT=s next contention is related to the scheduling of an IEP meeting following DCFS=s receipt of the referral. California Code of Regulations, title 2 section 60045(d) provides that upon receipt of the parent=s written consent for a mental health assessment, mental health is required to contact the school district within one working day to establish the date of the IEP meeting. In turn, the district is responsible for scheduling the IEP meeting within 50 days from the receipt of the parent=s consent for the mental health assessment. See also Cal. Educ. Code ' 56344(a).

DCFS=s witnesses did not dispute STUDENT=s contention that DCFS failed to contact the District within one working day of receipt of the referral to schedule an IEP meeting. There also is no documentary evidence that DCFS ever contacted the District to schedule an IEP meeting and, therefore, did not follow procedural requirements. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that DCFS failed to satisfy the requirements of section 60045(d). However, because the District scheduled an IEP meeting, which MOTHER attended, and there was agreement to provide STUDENT with mental health services, the Hearing Officer concludes that there was no persuasive evidence that the failure of DCFS related to scheduling an IEP meeting infringed on the parents= participation in the IEP or resulted in a loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT.

Regarding STUDENT=s assertion that DCFS failed to timely provide his parents and the IEP members with a copy of the assessment report, the law requires that whenever a mental health assessment has been conducted, the recommendation of the assessor Ashall be reviewed and discussed with the parent and with appropriate members of the individualized education program team prior to the meeting of the individualized education program team. . . .@ Cal. Gov=t Code ' 7572(d)(1). Section 60045(f) further provides that the mental health assessor shall make a copy of the assessment report available to the parent at least two days prior to the IEP team meeting and subsection (g) requires the assessor to provide a written assessment report to the IEP team.

Ms. Bryer completed the mental health assessment report on February 11, 2002. The IEP team convened on February 26, 2005, to add mental health services to STUDENT=s IEP. (Student=s Ex. 000086) MOTHER testified that she neither received a copy of the assessment report nor discussed the results of the assessment with anyone from DCFS prior to the IEP meeting. MOTHER testified that Ms. Bryer did not explain to her what type of services DCFS would provide to STUDENT. MOTHER also testified that no one from DCFS attended the IEP meeting. None of the witnesses testifying on behalf of DCFS contradicted MOTHER=s testimony. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that DCFS did not satisfy its obligation to discuss the recommendations and provide a copy of the assessment report to STUDENT=s parents in advance of the IEP meeting.

The testimony did not clearly establish whether DCFS discussed the recommendations of the assessor with IEP members or provided a copy of the written assessment to the IEP team. However, because the District convened an IEP meeting following the assessment for the distinct purpose of adding mental health services to STUDENT=s IEP, there had to have been some communication between DCFS and the District regarding STUDENT=s eligibility for services. As to whether the IEP team members had a copy of the report prior to meeting, DCFS asserts that a copy of the report was provided. In support of its contention, DCFS provided a copy of a letter to the District with the assessment report attached. (DCFS Ex. 3) However, the letter to the District is dated November 10, 2003, well after the IEP meeting initiating mental health services for STUDENT. MOTHER testified that she did not recall any discussion at the IEP meeting of the mental health assessment. DCFS did not offer persuasive evidence to the contrary. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that DCFS failed to establish that it timely provided a copy of its assessment report to the IEP team.

It is next necessary to determine whether DCFS=s failure to follow procedural requirements resulted in the denial of FAPE to STUDENT. MOTHER testified that although she did not have the assessment report and Ms. Bryer had not explained to her the type of services mental health would provide, she consented to STUDENT=s receiving mental health services because the family no longer could afford private therapy and she was willing to accept any services available to help STUDENT. DCFS asserts that because STUDENT=s mother participated in the development of STUDENT=s mental health treatment plan, there was no denial of FAPE. However, the evidence establishes that the IEP Addendum dated February 26, 2002, does not include any goals and objectives related to mental health services. The only goal--to eliminate angry outbursts--is included in a provisional treatment plan contained in the DCFS assessment report, which was not provided to the parent in advance of the IEP meeting. Additionally, DCFS=s Plan of Care was not developed until April 22, 2002. Finally, had STUDENT=s parents received a copy of the assessment report prior to the IEP meeting, they would have been able to determine whether they disagreed with the recommendations. Had they disagreed, they could have invited DCFS to attend the IEP meeting. When a parent disagrees with the recommendation for mental health services, mental health is required to notify the parent in writing and may require the person who conducted the assessment to attend the IEP meeting to discuss the recommendation. The person who conducted the assessment shall attend the individualized education program team meeting Aif requested.@ Cal. Gov=t Code ' 7572(d)(1). However, without the assessment report from DCFS, the parents were unable to make an informed decision whether they agreed with the recommendations. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that because DCFS did not discuss its assessment and recommendations with STUDENT=s parents in advance of the IEP meeting or provide a copy of the assessment report to the parents, they were unable to effectively participate in the IEP meeting at which mental health services were added to STUDENT=s program.

As to STUDENT=s final contention that DCFS was required to attend IEP meetings but did not, special education law provides that whenever a related service is considered for inclusion in the student=s IEP, the local educational agency Ashall invite the responsible public agency representative to meet with the individualized education program team to determine the need for the service and participate in developing the individualized education program. . . .@ (Emphasis added.) Cal. Gov=t Code ' 7572(e). There is no evidence that DCFS attended any of STUDENT=s IEP meetings during the 2001-2002 school year. However, STUDENT=s contention fails because there also is no evidence that the District invited DCFS or that DCFS failed to attend an IEP meeting in response to a request from STUDENT=s parents during the relevant time period.

Alleged Substantive Deficiencies

STUDENT asserts that the services offered by DCFS were not designed to address his identified social, emotional, and behavioral needs. STUDENT also asserts that talk therapy was an inappropriate technique to employ with him because of his autism and language deficits. DCFS contends that it offered appropriate services that were developed by DCFS in consultation with STUDENT=s mother. When determining whether the offer of services was appropriate, the review must focus on the adequacy of the proposed program at the time it was drafted. Adams v. Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999)

It is first necessary to determine what STUDENT=s unique mental health needs were at the time the services were offered. STUDENT=s triennial evaluation, which was undertaken in January, February, and March of 2002, summarizes areas of concern consistent with the testimony of STUDENT=s parents, Ms. Bryer, and the DCFS assessment. To summarize, STUDENT exhibited extreme difficulties with attention to task, social interaction with peers and adults, uncooperative behavior, low frustration tolerance, and poor anger control. He also exhibited anxiety. (See Student=s Ex. 120 - 128; DCFS Ex. 10) Ms. Weatherby testified that STUDENT told her he wanted to learn how to reduce his frustration in class, learn how to improve his coping skills and how to Ado things differently.@ Because of these multiple areas of concern, the consensus is that STUDENT required specialized services that would teach him the skills and strategies to increase attention, improve social skills, replace inappropriate behavior, increase frustration tolerance, reduce anxiety, and control anger. (Footnote 11)

At the core of the dispute is the nature of the services STUDENT required to address the above deficits. STUDENT contends that he required individual behavioral-based therapy and social skills training with an age-appropriate group, as well as parent training to ensure his behavioral treatment was applied consistently. DCFS contends that STUDENT=s needs could be addressed by psychotherapy services. There appears to be consensus that STUDENT required social skills training. Dr. Glidden and Ms. Wenell testified persuasively that social skills training was necessary to address STUDENT=s poor social skills. Documentary evidence from both the District and DCFS support the necessity of social skills training. Moreover, DCFS did not provide persuasive testimony to the contrary. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needed social skills training. Additionally, there was no dispute that collateral parent services were necessary to ensure that the parents had the skills to support STUDENT=s program and to ensure consistency across environments.

As to the nature of mental health services, Dr. Glidden testified that STUDENT required behavioral intervention therapy. In his opinion, Atalk therapy@ would not have been appropriate for STUDENT. Dr. Glidden testified that talk therapy involves using metaphors and discussion with the client to help the client to see things in a different way. Dr. Glidden acknowledged that STUDENT would not have suffered harm per se from receiving talk therapy. However, in his opinion, talk therapy would interfere with STUDENT=s Atrajectory of improvement.@ In other words, providing inappropriate therapy would interfere with STUDENT=s receiving appropriate therapy. Ms. Wenell also recommended that STUDENT receive behavior therapy based on ABA principles and strategies. In Ms. Wenell=s opinion, talk therapy would not have been appropriate for STUDENT because of his difficulty with social cues and because language problems are at the core of his diagnosis.

Dr. Glidden and Ms. Wenell hold impressive credentials and are experienced assessing or providing ABA services for children with autism. However, neither Dr. Glidden nor Ms. Wenell had met or assessed STUDENT in 2002 and, therefore, their opinions regarding the type of therapy STUDENT required were based on information gleaned well after 2002 and not information available at the time period under discussion. Additionally, Ms. Wenell has never met STUDENT. On the other hand, in testifying that psychotherapy available from DCFS would have addressed STUDENT=s mental health needs, Ms. Weatherby relied on her knowledge of STUDENT at the time services were offered. Additionally, all of the witnesses acknowledge that STUDENT had a complex set of disabilities and, in fact, was not diagnosed with autism until January 2004, some two years after the period under consideration. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds Ms. Weatherby=s testimony persuasive on this issue and concludes that STUDENT did not require ABA therapy in February 2002 and that psychological therapy as described by mental health regulations would have met his needs.

Next, turning to the adequacy of the mental health portion of the IEP, STUDENT contends that DCFS failed to develop an IEP that included present levels of performance, measurable goals and objectives, and the initiation, duration and frequency of services, and that was designed to address his needs.

The IEP must include the specific special education instruction and related services to be provided to the student. Cal. Educ. Code ' 56345(a)(3). Whenever a mental health service is necessary for a student to benefit from special education, the mental health portion of the student=s IEP must include the following: a description of the present levels of social and emotional performance; goals and objectives of the mental health services with objective criteria and evaluation procedures; a description of the type, initiation, duration, and frequency of mental health services to be provided; and signed parental consent for treatment that is in addition to the signed IEP. Cal. Code Regs., tit. 2, ' 60050(a)(1-5).

STUDENT first asserts that the mental health portion of the February 2002 IEP is deficient because it lacks a description of the present levels of social and emotional performance. Initially, it must be noted that references to mental health services in IEPs drafted by the District are limited to a statement that STUDENT will receive mental health services for one hour each week. Therefore, it is necessary to examine documents provided by DCFS to assess the adequacy of its services offered to STUDENT. A provisional treatment plan is incorporated in the assessment report from DCFS dated February 11, 2002. The report generally describes STUDENT=s demonstrating symptoms of anxiety, and states that STUDENT engages in Atemper outbursts in which he verbally abuses peers, bangs his head on the desk, pounds on his desk with his fist, and refuses to follow staff directives.@ However, the report lacks specific information regarding the nature, frequency, or duration of any of the behaviors. (DCFS Ex. 3) Although not specifically stated as Apresent levels of performance,@ the provisional treatment plan identifies Athe problem@ as Ainappropriate expression of anger@ and has a short-term goal of reducing verbal outbursts of anger as manifested by head-banging, verbal abuse of peers, desk-thumping, and refusal to follow directives Afrom three times a week@ to once a week. (Emphasis added) Thus, the plan identifies STUDENT=s present level of performance related to his expression of anger. However, given the multiple ways in which STUDENT expressed his anger, the reader is unable to discern which behavior is occurring and at what frequency. Additionally, Ms. Weatherby acknowledged that the provisional treatment plan does not address anxiety, which was identified as the primary diagnosis identified in the DCFS assessment. The plan also does not address STUDENT=s social difficulties. In light of the above, the Hearing Office finds the above inadequately describes STUDENT=s then present levels of social and emotional performance.

STUDENT next challenges the adequacy of the goals and objectives. No one disputed Ms. Wenell=s testimony that it was (and is) extremely important for STUDENT to have structured and measurable goals so that STUDENT and everyone else knows when he is successful. This opinion is consistent with recommendations resulting from the District=s behavioral assessments of STUDENT. The provisional treatment plan includes a long term goal to eliminate angry outbursts, the short-term goal described above, and an objective to reduce angry outbursts. After reviewing the plan Dr. Glidden described the goals and objectives as Avague and immeasurable@ and expressed the opinion that only the person preparing the plan would be able to implement it. The Hearing Officer concurs and finds the goals and objective do not sufficiently identify objective criteria and evaluation procedures to determine whether they are being achieved. As discussed above, although the goal is to reduce the behavior from three to one time a week, it is impossible to determine which of STUDENT=s behaviors would be addressed. Moreover, there are no goals to address anxiety and deficits in social skills.

STUDENT asserts that the plan does not include a description of the type, initiation, duration, and frequency of mental health services to be provided. A review of the plan indicates that it merely provides for outpatient mental health treatment. Even when read in conjunction with the addendum to STUDENT=s IEP dated February 26, 2002, which states that mental health services would be provided for one hour weekly, the provisional plan does not sufficiently satisfy the requirements of California Code of Regulations, title 2, section 60050. (Footnote 12)

To summarize, the provisional treatment plan of care failed to satisfy requirements of special education and mental health requirements and was not designed to address STUDENT=s needs.

The provisional plan was supplanted on April 22, 2002, by DCFS=s initial Plan of Care. Ms. Weatherby testified that she drafted the plan with input from MOTHER regarding the outcome she would like to see from therapy. The plan states that STUDENT has daily temper outbursts manifested by talking back, being argumentative, flopping on the floor, and refusing to follow adult direction. The stated goal is to decrease temper outbursts from daily to two times a week. The interventions are identified as individual therapy utilizing play therapy and collateral therapy to develop and support parents. The stated duration of therapy is six months. (DCFS Ex. 8) The initial Plan is sufficient to the extent that it identifies the specific interventions that would be employed and the nature of the services that would be provided. However, it remains vague as to which of STUDENT=s expressions of temper would be addressed and what evaluation procedures would be used to determine whether the goal were being achieved. Moreover, the plan is limited to addressing outbursts and does not address anxiety or social skills deficits. Therefore, DCFS failed to propose a plan in April 2002 designed to address STUDENT=s needs.

Petitioner next contends that the services offered by DCFS were not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. As set forth above, the student must be provided a Abasic floor of opportunity@ consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to meet the student=s needs, reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, and that comport with the student=s IEP. Rowley at 201. Because of the deficiencies in the provisional plan for STUDENT=s services and the failure of the initial Plan of Care to identify certain required components, the Hearing Officer concludes that DCFS failed to offer a program designed to provide Petitioner with educational benefit. In part, this conclusion is reached because of the failure of DCFS to address STUDENT=s significant social deficits and the need for social skills training.

ISSUE 3: Did DCFS conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT for the 2002-2003 school year?

DCFS did not assess STUDENT during the 2002-2003 school year. However, STUDENT contends that DCFS should have reevaluated him or referred him to a specialist in autistic spectrum disorders because he continued to exhibit behavioral problems at school. STUDENT asserts that the assessment should have been procured from someone other than DCFS because DCFS did not have a specialist in autism. DCFS contends that it had no obligation to assess STUDENT during the 2002-2003 school year and asserts that STUDENT was making progress.

STUDENT cited no specific law requiring mental health to reassess a student to whom it is providing services. Pursuant to Education Code section 56381, a reassessment of a student must be conducted at least every three years or more frequently, if conditions warrant a reassessment or the student=s parent or teacher requests a reassessment and a new IEP to be developed.

As to whether conditions warranted a reassessment of STUDENT, MOTHER testified that STUDENT=s behavior at school had not improved during the prior school year and continued to deteriorate during the 2002-2003 school year. She stated that STUDENT also continued to exhibit difficulty with social skills. MOTHER testified that she expressed her concerns to Ms. Weatherby. Ms. Weatherby provided STUDENT=s mental health therapy from February 2002 through 2003. Ms. Weatherby testified that during the 2002-2003 school year, she was on the school campus weekly and communicated with STUDENT=s teacher and recreational therapist regularly regarding STUDENT. Ms. Weatherby testified that STUDENT made progress during the course of her treating him and benefitted from the entire mental health program offered in conjunction with the District=s EIP. As an example of STUDENT=s progress, Ms. Weatherby described STUDENT=s beginning to talk about things that were bothering him rather than acting out. She stated that he had an arrangement with his teacher that he could draw rather than simply reacting when something bothered him. Ms. Weatherby also recalled that the recreational therapist concurred that STUDENT was making progress. (Footnote 13) Additionally, Ms. Weatherby did not recall STUDENT=s parents expressing dissatisfaction with the services he was receiving.

The Hearing Officer concludes that DCFS was under no obligation to conduct an assessment of STUDENT during the 2002-2003 school year. First, there is no evidence that MOTHER, Ms. Weatherby, or anyone else requested a reassessment of STUDENT or the development of a new IEP. Second, there is no persuasive evidence that conditions warranted a reassessment of STUDENT. Although STUDENT continued to have behavioral and social problems during the year, the Hearing Officer finds Ms. Weatherby=s testimony persuasive that STUDENT was making progress. Ms. Weatherby regularly observed STUDENT and communicated with the staff working with him in the educational environment. Finally, there was no persuasive evidence that there were any significant changes to the nature of STUDENT=s behavior, social, or emotional functioning that would warrant a mental health reevaluation.

ISSUE 4: Did DCFS fail to offer and provide STUDENT appropriate mental health services for the 2002-2003 school year, including the ESY?

STUDENT contends that DCFS failed to develop an IEP that included present levels of performance, measurable goals and objectives, and the initiation, duration, and frequency of services, and that was reasonably calculated to provide him with benefit. DCFS contends that it complied with legal requirements and that its portion of the IEP was appropriate.

In the fall of 2002, STUDENT entered the EIP within the District. DCFS continued to provide services to STUDENT in the EIP. On October 30, 2002, DCFS updated its Plan of Care with input from STUDENT and his mother. (DCFS Ex. 7) STUDENT=s mother identified STUDENT=s academic and behavior success as the desired outcome. Although STUDENT participated in the Plan of Care, he stated that he had no opinion regarding the desired outcome. The Plan of Care indicates that STUDENT continued to exhibit a low tolerance for frustration that led to temper outbursts. The Plan called for STUDENT to decrease temper outbursts from three to four times per week to one time per week. To address this need, DCFS offered individual therapy to Afacilitate appropriate expression of thoughts and feelings,@ collateral session to support parents, and recreation therapy to improve social skills. The Plan is signed by STUDENT and his mother.

There is no persuasive evidence that STUDENT=s needs had changed as of the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year. STUDENT continued to require specialized services to teach him the skills and strategies to increase attention, improve social skills, replace inappropriate behavior, increase frustration tolerance, reduce anxiety, and control anger.

Similar to the initial Plan of Care, the revised Plan of Care dated October 20, 2002, fails to provide present levels of performance regarding the frequency of each of STUDENT=s inappropriate behaviors. Instead, it provides a generalized statement that outbursts were occurring three to four times weekly. There also is no information regarding STUDENT=s then-present social skills or anxiety levels, which continued to be problematic for STUDENT. There also are no goals and objectives related to decreasing anxiety or improving social skills. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that DCFS=s updated Plan of Care fails to address STUDENT=s mental health needs.

Contrary to STUDENT=s assertion, the Plan of Care identifies the duration of therapy as six months and indicates that STUDENT is entitled to individual, collateral, and recreation therapy. However, the Plan fails to indicate the frequency of each of the therapies.

Because the DCFS Plan of Care suffered from the same deficiencies as the prior Plan of Care, the Hearing Officer finds the DCFS failed to offer services designed to meet STUDENT=s needs and, therefore, did not satisfy the requirements of Education Code section ' 56345 and California Code of Regulations, title 2, ' 60050.

Additionally, the evidence establishes that DCFS inappropriately discontinued STUDENT=s services in February 2003. Ms. Weatherby provided STUDENT=s services until his parents removed him from the District in February 2003, when MOTHER decided to home-school STUDENT. Thereafter, DCFS did not provide STUDENT with services. However, the discharge document from DCFS is dated May 22, 2003. MOTHER testified that she never terminated STUDENT=s services from DCFS. She also stated that she did not receive the discharge document from DCFS. According to Ms. Weatherby, MOTHER informed her that she was attempting to get services from the M.I.N.D. Institute. Apparently there was some discussion about Ms. Weatherby=s continuing to provide services but MOTHER indicated that it was difficult to transport STUDENT to the school he previously attended and where the DCFS services were provided. The conversation ended on Ms. Weatherby=s assurance that she would attempt to see if her schedule would accommodate seeing STUDENT at a different location. There was no further communication from Ms. Weatherby until the notice of discharge on May 22, 2003. At hearing, she testified that she did not prepare a discharge document earlier because she thought the parents might change their mind about wanting mental health services. However, the evidence establishes that no services were provided to STUDENT by DCFS from February to May.

Government Code section 60050(b) provides that when mental health services are completed or terminated by mutual agreement, mental health is required to notify the parent and the district, which must schedule the IEP meeting to discuss and document the proposed change if it is acceptable to the IEP team. The evidence also establishes that there was no IEP meeting to discontinue mental health services. In fact, a subsequent IEP dated August 28, 2003, which was prepared in anticipation of STUDENT=s return to the District in the fall of 2003, states that STUDENT is Acurrently a client of mental health.@ (Student=s Ex. 184) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that there is no persuasive evidence that DCFS was relieved of its obligation to provide mental health services to STUDENT simply because the parents removed STUDENT from the District and DCFS unilaterally prepared a discharge notice that apparently was not received by either the parents or the District. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that DCFS failed to provide mental health services that comported to STUDENT=s IEP.

In summary, DCFS failed to offer a legally sufficient Plan of Care for the 2002-2003 school year and failed to provide services to STUDENT that comported with his IEP from February 2003 to the end of the school year.

ISSUE 5: Did DCFS conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT on October 17, 2003, and prepare an appropriate report of the assessment on October 31, 2003?

STUDENT=s arguments regarding the inappropriateness of the assessment plan and assessment by DCFS on October 17, 2003, mirror his arguments made regarding the appropriateness of the DCFS assessment conducted in 2002. STUDENT asserts that DCFS did not provide his parents with an assessment plan, did not have a qualified assessor conduct the assessment, did not assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability, and did not observe him in his classroom. DCFS maintains that it properly assessed STUDENT.

Assessment Plan

STUDENT returned to the District in the fall of 2003, and entered the IIP. On September 25, 2003, the District again referred STUDENT for mental health services because the IIP, like the EIP, required that the students participate in mental health programs provided by DCFS. (Student=s Ex. 210) There is no evidence that DCFS prepared an assessment plan prior to its assessment. However, like the prior referral, the District=s September 2003 referral indicates that DCFS would conduct an assessment that included a review of school records and an observation of STUDENT. MOTHER signed her consent to the assessment. (Student Ex. 00210) Thus, MOTHER was aware of the components of the proposed mental health assessment. Additionally, MOTHER was present and participated in the assessment. MOTHER completed a form that identified her concerns regarding STUDENT and provided medical and school histories. (DCFS Ex. 6) The assessment form reflects MOTHER=s participation in the assessment process. For example, there are various notes on the report indicating MOTHER=s input, including her report that STUDENT had recently gained weight. (DCFS Ex. 5)

First, because the referral explained that the assessment would include a review of STUDENT=s school records and an observation of STUDENT, the Hearing Officer determines that the requirements of section 56321(b)(3) of the Education Code were sufficiently satisfied. Second, the Hearing Officer finds that MOTHER was informed of the components of the proposed mental health assessment, albeit by the District rather than DCFS. She also participated in the assessment process. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that although DCFS did not provide the parents with an assessment plan, this omission did not seriously infringe on the parents= participation in the IEP process or result in a denial of FAPE to STUDENT.

Assessor

In response to the referral from the District, DCFS conducted an assessment of STUDENT to determine whether he qualified for mental health services. The assessment was undertaken by Marian Wood on October 17, 2003. (DCFS Ex. 5) It is noted initially that Ms. Wood appears to be an Aunlicensed mental health clinician.@ (See DCFS Ex. 4) There was no testimony on behalf of DCFS regarding Ms. Wood=s qualifications. Ms. Wood=s designation as an Aunlicensed mental health clinician@ would not satisfy the requirements of a Aqualified mental health professional@ pursuant to section 60020(j) of the California Code of Regulations, title 2. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds DCFS failed to establish that Ms. Wood was qualified to assess STUDENT. However, it is unclear whether or not Ms. Wood conducted the assessment under the supervision of a qualified assessor. The Hearing Officer notes that the assessment report is also signed by Deborah Riverhawk Helmns, LCSW. As a licensed clinical social worker, Ms. Helmns would have been qualified to undertake the assessment.

Assessment

STUDENT contends that the assessment by DCFS on October 17. 2003, was deficient because DCFS failed to assess him in all areas of suspected disability and did not include an observation of him at school. MOTHER identified the following problem areas: overly active, can=t sit still, easily distracted, poor concentration, does not think before acting, reckless, does not do as asked, argues with adults, back talks, temper outbursts, easily angered, no friends, is teased, trouble with kids, difficulty with school work, irritability, low self-esteem, stays to self, and overly tired. (Footnote 14) (DCFS Ex. 6) The assessment notes concerns related to STUDENT=s lack of social skills and poor ability relating to others. (DCFS Ex. 5)

A review of the assessment indicates that the assessment consisted of a review of STUDENT=s school records and interviews of STUDENT and his mother. From these sources, the assessment notes that she gathered information regarding STUDENT=s presenting problems, medical, developmental, and psychiatric histories, and conditions affecting STUDENT=s functioning. From her observations and interactions with STUDENT, Ms. Wood obtained information regarding STUDENT=s mental status at the time of the assessment. By comparing the areas of concern and the areas covered by the assessment, the Hearing Officer concludes that all areas of suspected disability were assessed. Again, contrary to STUDENT=s assertions, there was no specific concern raised related to autism. There also was no request for an autism assessment

As to whether the assessment included an observation of STUDENT in an Aappropriate setting,@ it is undisputed that the assessor did not observe STUDENT at school. However, the assessment included Ms. Wood=s observations of STUDENT during testing. The Hearing Officer finds this to be an appropriate setting and sufficiently satisfies Education Code section 56327(c).

Assessment Report

An assessment report was prepared as a result of the assessment on October 17, 2003. (See DCFS Ex. 4) The report of Ms. Wood=s assessment is dated October 31, 2003. The report includes information and/or findings under the following headings: identifying information, description of problem, relevant history, other factors to consider as appropriate, recommendations, a provisional treatment plan, and initiation of services. Comparing Ms. Wood=s report to the requirements of an appropriate assessment report establishes that the report satisfies subsection (a) because it includes a recommendation for servicesBoutpatient mental health services. Subsections (b) and (d) are satisfied by the comments in the sections describing the problem and Aother factors to consider.@ The report describes STUDENT=s behavior during the assessment and, thus, subsection (c) is satisfied. The report also describes relevant medical history and indicates that environmental, cultural, and economic disadvantage were considered. While the assessment report is brief, it contains all of the components required by Education Code 56327. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds the report sufficiently satisfies legal requirements.

ISSUE 6: Did DCFS fail to offer and provide STUDENT with appropriate mental health services for the 2003-2004 school year, including the ESY?

Alleged Procedural Violations

STUDENT contends that DCFS=s failure to follow procedural requirements resulted in the denial of FAPE. Specifically, STUDENT asserts that DCFS failed (1) to contact the District within one working day of receipt of STUDENT=s referral to schedule an IEP meeting, (2) to make a copy of STUDENT=s mental health assessment report available to his parents at least two days prior to the IEP meeting, (3) to provide a written assessment report to IEP team members, and (4) to attend IEP meetings.

DCFS provided no testimony that it adhered to any of the above requirements. There also was no testimony from anyone else in support of DCFS that it contacted the District to set an IEP, timely made a copy of the assessment report available to the parents, and provided a written assessment report to IEP team members. Therefore, for the same reasons discussed above in Issues no. 2, the Hearing Officer concludes that DCFS failed to adhere to procedural requirements. It is necessary to determine whether these procedural deficiencies seriously infringed on the parents= participation in the IEP process or resulted in loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT. As in the previous school year, the failure of DCFS to provide the parents with a report of the assessment essentially prevented them from disagreeing with the recommendations from the assessment and asking that the assessor attend the IEP meeting to discuss the recommendations. Additionally, as discussed below, there was no evidence of a Plan of Care developed by DCFS and agreed to by the parents until December 31, 2003. When considered together, the Hearing finds that the failures of DCFS to follow procedural requirements seriously infringed on the parents= participation in the IEP process.

Alleged Substantive Deficiencies

STUDENT contends that DCFS failed to develop an IEP that included present levels of performance, measurable goals and objectives, and the initiation, duration, and frequency of services. STUDENT also asserts that the services offered by DCFS were not designed to meet his needs and were not reasonably calculated to provide him with benefit. DCFS contends that it offered STUDENT appropriate mental health services

To determine whether the offer of mental health services was appropriate, it is first necessary to determine STUDENT=s unique mental health needs at the time services were offered. The testimony of MOTHER, Dr. Glidden, Ms. Wenell, and Mr. Davis, as well as the most recent mental health assessment, establish that STUDENT continued to exhibit difficulty with attention, social interactions, anxiety, and angry outbursts. A report from the M.I.N.D. Institute concurred, noting in particular STUDENT=s difficulty with social situations and learning to make and keep friends. (Student=s Ex. G) Because of the continuing concerns in the above areas, STUDENT required specialized services to teach him the skills and strategies to improve social skills, reduce anxiety, and control anger.

An amendment to STUDENT=s IEP dated November 14, 2003, reinitiated STUDENT=s receipt of services from DCFS. (Student=s Ex. 000231) The only notation on the IEP document regarding mental health services simply indicates that STUDENT would receive outpatient services for 45 minutes weekly. The sole goals and objectives for STUDENT=s mental health services from November 14, 2003, to December 31, 2003, are contained in the assessment report from DCFS under a provisional treatment plan. There is no evidence that the provisional plan of care was approved by STUDENT=s parents. The Ainitial@ Plan of Care was signed and agreed to by STUDENT=s parents is dated December 31, 2003. Even if the provisional plan could be considered as DCFS=s offer of services for STUDENT, and could be implemented absent parental consent, the Hearing Officer finds the provisional plan inadequate. The provisional plan identifies anxiety as the sole Aproblem@ to be addressed by mental health therapy and offers only goals to reduce symptoms of anxiety. There are no proposed goals related to social skills, although the mental health assessment report identifies Asocial impairment@ as a Aproblem@ and the evidence above established social skills deficits as a significant concern for STUDENT. There also are no goals and objectives to address STUDENT=s angry outbursts. Therefore, because of these important omissions, the Hearing Officer concludes that the provisional plan of care was not designed to meet STUDENT=s needs.

The Plan of Care agreed to on December 31, 2003, is also deficient. (Student=s Exhibit 000240) The Plan includes one goal to reduce incidences of outbursts of anger and verbal aggressiveness. The Plan does not include goals to address STUDENT=s anxiety or social skills and, therefore, is not designed to meet STUDENT=s needs. Additionally, the Plan of Care calls for family, collateral, and individual therapy but does not indicate the duration and frequency of any of these therapies.

In summary, given the finding above that the failure of DCFS to follow procedural requirements infringed on the parents= participation in the IEP process, and the finding here that both the provisional plan of care and the initial Plan of Care were not designed to meet STUDENT=s needs, the Hearing Officer concludes that DCFS failed to offer STUDENT appropriate services for the 2003-2004 school year.

ISSUE 7: If DCFS failed to conduct appropriate assessments and prepare appropriate reports of assessments, are STUDENT=s parents entitled to reimbursement for independent assessments conducted by the M.I.N.D. Institute on May 22, 2003, and by Howard Glidden, Ph.D., on January 12, 2004?

STUDENT contends that his parents are entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent assessments they procured. DCFS contends that its assessments were appropriate and that, therefore, DCFS is not required to reimburse STUDENT=s parents for the costs of the independent assessments.

A parent may obtain reimbursement for an independent educational evaluation (IEP) performed by a qualified specialist if the parent disagrees with an evaluation obtained by the educational agency, and the educational agency is unable to show at a due process hearing that its evaluation was appropriate. 34 C.F.R. ' 300.502(b); Cal. Educ. Code ' 56329(b) and (c).

The first assessment for which STUDENT=s parents seek reimbursement was obtained from the M.I.N.D. Institute on May 22, 2003. DCFS=s assessment preceding the independent assessment was completed on February 4, 2002, more than one year prior to the independent assessment. It was concluded above that the DCFS February 2002 assessment was appropriate and that DCFS was not required to reassess STUDENT during the 2002-2003 school year. Moreover, there was no evidence that the parents disagreed with DCFS=s assessment at or near the time it was completed. Because DCFS=s assessment was appropriate and because the independent assessment occurred significantly after the DCFS assessment, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT=s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the assessment by the M.I.N.D. Institute.

The request by STUDENT=s parents for the costs of Dr. Glidden=s assessment completed in January 2004 is also denied. The evidence establishes that STUDENT was referred to Dr. Glidden by Emily Devere, occupational therapist, for an assessment of his cognitive and neurodevelopmental functioning, and not because the parents disagreed with the assessment by DCFS. (Student=s Ex. A)

ISSUE 8: If DCFS failed to offer and/or provide STUDENT with appropriate mental health services, are his parents entitled to reimbursement for tutoring provided to STUDENT by the Cullinan Education Center from September 2002 to June 2003?

STUDENT asserts that because DCFS failed to offer and provide him with appropriate mental health services, his parents are entitled to reimbursement for tutoring services they obtained for him from the Cullinan Education Center. DCFS maintains that at all times it provided appropriate services for STUDENT and that, even if he were entitled to remedies, the services procured by the parents for STUDENT from Cullinan were not in response to the alleged failure by DCFS to provide mental health therapy.

Special education law provides that when a school district denies a student FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is Aappropriate@ in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. Of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. '1415(i) (1997); Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496. Thus, the parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement or services and the services provided by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. The services need not be an exact match but must address the student=s needs. Burlington, supra, 471 U.S. at p. 370. The rule in Burlington is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parents are found to be the exact proper placement or services required under the Act. Alamo Heights Independent school District v. state Board of Education, 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986).

No one testified regarding the Cullinan tutoring services and there was no persuasive evidence that the tutoring services the PARENTS obtained from Cullinan were related to an alleged failure on the part of DCFS to provide appropriate mental health services. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer declines to reimburse STUDENT=s parents for the costs of tutoring from Cullinan.

ISSUE 9: If DCFS failed to offer and/or provide STUDENT with appropriate mental health services, is he entitled to prospective remedies?

STUDENT asserts that he is entitled to multiple prospective compensatory remedies for DCFS=s failure to offer and provide him with appropriate mental health services. Specifically, he requests the following:

a. Applied behavior analysis (ABA) services provided by Teaching Autistic Children in the amount of 20-40 hours per week for one year or longer;

b. Provision of a social skills curriculum, including ANavigating the Social World@ as part of the school curriculum;

c. Provision of a social skills play group with typically developing age-appropriate peers supervised by an individual with experience in autistic spectrum disorders; d. One thousand dollars toward parent training;

e. Speech and language services to be provided by the Center for Communication Skills three times per week in 50-minute sessions;

f. The FastForward program as recommended by the Center for Communication Skills;

g. Training in autistic spectrum disorders four times per year for mental health professionals who assess and/or provide services to autistic students by an individual who has experience in autistic spectrum disorder diagnosis or who has experience creating IEPs with appropriate services for children with autistic spectrum disorders; and h. Completion of a functional analysis assessment by a behaviorist with experience in autistic spectrum disorders.

DCFS contends that STUDENT is not entitled to a compensatory remedy. DCFS contends that the compensatory education remedies requested by STUDENT are specialized behavioral services that DCFS is not obligated to provide. DCFS asserts that it is only required to provide mental health services as defined by section 60020(i) of the California Code of Regulations, title 5.

As set forth above, when a student has been denied a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is Aappropriate@ in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. Of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369 (1985) Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have extended relief in the form of compensatory education. See, e.g., Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749. It has been determined that DCFS has failed to meet STUDENT=s mental health needs from February 2002 through the 2003-2004 school year. In particular, DCFS has failed to offer a mental health Plan of Care designed to address STUDENT=s significant social skills deficits. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer determines that STUDENT is entitled to a compensatory remedy.

It is next necessary to determine what constitutes an appropriate compensatory remedy. Initially, the Hearing Officer notes that recommendations by the experts who testified were strikingly similar with respect to the services that STUDENT requires. Dr. Glidden testified that STUDENT requires social skills training with an age-appropriate group in a setting where the social interactions are going to occur. Dr. Glidden testified that the peers in the group should have appropriate behavior so that STUDENT can model their behavior to the extent he is able. Dr. Glidden stated that individuals with autistic disorders find it difficult to generalize information learned in one location to a new or different location, hence the recommendation for STUDENT that the social skills training occur in the environment in which the social skills will be used. Dr. Glidden additionally recommended that because of STUDENT=s social isolation at school, STUDENT be included in a Abuddy system@ whereby STUDENT gradually would be introduced to other students. (See also Student=s Exhibit A, p. 22) Ms. Wenell concurred with Dr. Glidden=s recommendation that STUDENT receive social skills training. Ms. Wenell also expressed some concern that initially STUDENT may feel uncomfortable receiving social skills training in a general education environment. She suggested that STUDENT=s initial training be one-to-one. (See also Student=s Exhibit J) The assessors of the M.I.N.D. Institute included similar recommendations. Their report states, ASTUDENT would benefit from participation in a social skills group where he may learn needed skills to appropriately navigate frequently encountered social situations and learn to make and keep friends.@ (Student=s Exhibit G)

The Hearing Officer rejects the argument by DCFS that it is not required to provide social skills training and concludes that social skills training falls within the scope of services DCFS may offer. (See Cal. Code Regs., tit. 2, ' 60020(i), referencing the Business and Professions Code to define mental health services.) Section 2903 of the Business and Professions Code describes Apsychotherapy@ as the use of psychological methods in a professional relationship to assist a person acquire Agreater human effectiveness or to modify feelings, conditions, attitudes and behavior which are emotionally, intellectually, or socially ineffectual or maladjustive.@

The Hearing Officer adopts the recommendations of the experts that STUDENT requires social skills training and concludes that social skills training is an appropriate compensatory remedy for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer concludes that DCFS shall arrange for STUDENT to participate weekly in a social skills play group with age-appropriate peers who exhibit appropriate social skills. DCFS shall determine the appropriate amount of time for each session. The Hearing Officer concurs with the recommendations of Dr. Glidden and Ms. Wenell that STUDENT should gradually be introduced to the group. To accomplish this, mental health shall initiate the social skills training with one age-appropriate peer who exhibits appropriate social skills. The amount of time needed for this initial step is at the discretion of the DCFS therapist but should be accomplished within no more than two months. Given the multiple years that DCFS has failed to offer STUDENT appropriate services, the Hearing Officer finds that DCFS shall provide the social skills therapy for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year, including the extended school year, and for the entire regular 2005-2006 school year. STUDENT=s request for a specific social skills curriculum is denied. STUDENT presented no testimony regarding the programBANavigating the Social World@Bor the appropriateness of the program for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer concludes that the social skills training ordered satisfies STUDENT=s request for compensatory services and, therefore, rejects STUDENT=s other requests.

ORDER

1. Within 15 calendar days of the date of this decision, DCFS shall begin providing social skills training for STUDENT that is consistent with this decision. Specifically, DCFS shall proceed as follows:

a. To introduce STUDENT to social skills training, DCFS shall initiate social skills training with one age-appropriate peer exhibiting appropriate social skills. The amount of time needed for this initial step is at the discretion of the DCFS therapist but must be accomplished within no more than two months.

b. DCFS shall provide STUDENT the social skills therapy with an age-appropriate peer group who exhibit appropriate social skills for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year, including the extended school year, and for the entire regular 2005-2006 school year. DCFS shall determine the appropriate amount of time for each session.

2. STUDENT=s other requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

Issue 1: Did the Fresno County Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS) conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT on February 4, 2002, and prepare an appropriate report of the assessment on February 11, 2002? DCFS substantially prevailed on this issue.

Issue 2: Did DCFS fail to offer and provide STUDENT appropriate mental health services during the 2001-2002 school year, including the extended school year (ESY)? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.

Issue 3: Did DCFS conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT for the 2002-2003 school year? DCFS prevailed on this issue.

Issue 4: Did DCFS fail to offer and provide STUDENT appropriate mental health services for the 2002-2003 school year, including the ESY? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.

Issue 5: Did DCFS conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT on October 17, 2003, and prepare an appropriate report of the assessment on October 31, 2003? STUDENT prevailed on this issue to the extent that DCFS failed to establish that its assessor was qualified.

Issue 6: Did DCFS fail to offer and provide STUDENT with appropriate mental health services for the 2003-2004 school year, including the ESY? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.

Issue 7: If DCFS failed to conduct appropriate assessments and prepare appropriate reports of assessments, are STUDENT=s parents entitled to reimbursement for independent assessments conducted by the M.I.N.D. Institute on May 22, 2003, and by Howard Glidden, Ph.D., on January 12, 2004? DCFS prevailed on this issue.

Issue 8: If DCFS failed to offer and/or provide STUDENT with appropriate mental health services, are his parents entitled to reimbursement for tutoring provided to STUDENT by the Cullinan Education Center from September 2002 to June 2003? DCFS prevailed on this issue.

Issue 9: If DCFS failed to offer and/or provide STUDENT with appropriate mental health services, is he entitled to prospective compensatory remedies? STUDENT prevailed to the extent that he is entitled to compensatory social skills training.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code ' 56505(i).

DATED: April 16, 2005 ________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. On March 9, 2005, the parties engaged in settlement discussions and no evidence was taken on that date.

2. Dr. Artacho has continued to prescribe various medications for STUDENT.

3. Ms. Weatherly recently married and changed her last name from Norton to Weatherly.

4. The M.I.N.D. Institute, Medical Investigation of Neurodevelopmental Disorders, assesses and serves persons with neurodevelopmental disorders, including autism.

5. It is not entirely clear when DCFS received the referral from the District. However, the dates of the assessment and ensuing IEP meeting are not in dispute. What is in dispute is whether DCFS provided the parents with an assessment plan.

6. As discussed more fully below in Issue 2, federal and State special education law affords parents certain procedural rights, including the right to meaningfully participate in the IEP process. Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 206-207, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982). The failure to follow procedural requirements that seriously infringed on the parents= opportunity to participate in the IEP process or resulted in STUDENT=s loss of educational opportunity may constitute a denial of a FAPE. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483-1484 (9th Cir. 1992).

7. That is, with the exception of Education Code 56327, regarding the requirements of an assessment plan, which is discussed below.

8. California also uses the term Adesignated instruction and services@ or ADIS.@ Cal. Educ. Code ' 56363(a).

9. Federal and State law also require that students with disabilities be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S. C. ' 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code ' 56301. LRE is not at issue in this case.

10. Although STUDENT exhibits some autistic-like behaviors, the first diagnosis of autism was by made by Dr. Glidden in January 2004.

11. In areas not specifically addressed by mental health services, there is no dispute that STUDENT has pragmatic language deficits for which he requires speech and language therapy, and some academic deficits for which he requires specialized instruction in a special education environment. These needs are not addressed in this Decision.

12. Although not specifically raised as a procedural violation, the Hearing Officer notes that the failure to make a formal, written offer of placement constitutes a violation of IDEA=s procedural requirements and may result in the denial of FAPE. Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994); 20 U.S.C. ' 1415(b)(3).

13. STUDENT entered the EIP where he participated in recreation therapy in addition to individual therapy with Ms. Weatherby.

14. One additional area marked by MOTHER relates to school. However, the entire comment cannot be read.