California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 28, 2004

Student v. Jurupa Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 2637-03 · Hearing Officer Vincent L. Pastorino

Jurupa Unified student with ADHD and a 504 plan found not eligible for special education; expulsion proceedings may continue.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. The decision distinguishes a prior SEHO decision dated December 6, 2000, involving the same student, which rescinded an earlier expulsion.

Summary

The parents of a 16-year-old eleventh grader at Jurupa Valley High School filed for due process after Jurupa Unified recommended expelling him for sexual misconduct with another student on campus in October 2003. The student had ADHD and a Section 504 accommodation plan, but the district had never found him eligible for special education. A 2000 SEHO decision had overturned an earlier expulsion because the district had reason to know he might have a disability. After the 2003 incident, the district assessed him and found him ineligible in December 2003. The family argued he qualified under other health impairment because of his ADHD and long discipline history. The Hearing Officer disagreed. Testing by school psychologist Ramon Barreras showed no sign that ADHD was hurting the student's performance. His eleventh-grade teachers described good behavior and mostly A's and B's before the suspension. Medication, the 504 plan, and his wish to play baseball appeared to explain the improvement. Letters from the student's private psychiatric providers did not persuade the Hearing Officer, and the doctor never testified. The Hearing Officer also found the incident was planned, not impulsive. Because the student was not eligible when the incident occurred, IDEA discipline protections did not apply, and the expulsion proceedings could go forward. Without eligibility, the Hearing Officer had no authority to order a functional analysis assessment. All relief was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO separated an ADHD diagnosis from special education eligibility. This student's needs were being met through medication and a Section 504 plan, so he did not need special education. As a result, IDEA discipline protections and a state "Hughes bill" functional analysis assessment were not available to him.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1. Does Student currently meet the eligibility criteria for special education under the category of "other health impairment"?

    Testing and eleventh-grade teacher reports showed ADHD was managed by medication and the 504 plan and did not adversely affect performance enough to require special education.

  2. District prevailedDiscipline

    Issue 2. Shall the District be ordered to dismiss the expulsion proceedings arising from an incident on or about October 14, 2003, on the grounds that Student should have been receiving special education services and the conduct was a manifestation of his disability?

    Student was not eligible for special education when the misconduct occurred, so IDEA discipline protections did not apply; the conduct was also found planned rather than impulsive, and dismissal of the expulsion was not ordered.

  3. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 3. Is the District required to offer Student a functional analysis assessment (FAA) and use the FAA to formulate a positive behavior intervention plan?

    Because Student is not eligible for special education, the Hearing Office had no authority to order a Hughes bill functional analysis assessment.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • All of Petitioner's requests for relief were denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(9); Cal. Educ. Code § 56339; Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(f); 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(8); 34 C.F.R. §§ 300.523, 300.524, 300.527; Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3052; Prior SEHO decision dated December 6, 2000 (same student)

People named in the decision

  • Andrew E. Carey, physical sciences teacher, Jurupa Unified School District
  • Ramon Barreras, school psychologist/behavior specialist, Jurupa Unified School District
  • Constance Lubak, English teacher, Jurupa Unified School District
  • Vicky Lynn Castillo, history teacher, Jurupa Unified School District
  • Vera Mahoney, high school assistant principal, Jurupa Valley High School
  • Stephen Eimers, director of administrative services and designee for discipline, Jurupa Unified School District
  • Ron Shecklen, principal, Jurupa Valley High School
  • Jenelle Benson, biology teacher, Jurupa Unified School District
  • Diana Pine, computer graphics teacher, Jurupa Unified School District
  • Debbie Buckhout, English teacher, Jurupa Unified School District
  • Pat Thompson, history teacher, Jurupa Unified School District
  • Teresa Foltz, math teacher, Jurupa Unified School District
  • Ric Slagle, math teacher/baseball coach, Jurupa Unified School District
  • Vincent John Tieri, special education teacher, Jurupa Unified School District
  • Amy Foody, program specialist; chaired December 10, 2003 IEP meeting, Jurupa Unified School District
  • Robin Thompson, speech and language pathologist, Jurupa Unified School District
  • Ms. Harrison, staff member whose office was designated in 504 plan, Jurupa Unified School District
  • T. Phillip Laney, M.F.T., private therapist (letters submitted for Student), DOGON Psychiatric Medical Group
  • Samuel E. Dey, Jr., M.D., private psychiatrist (letter submitted for Student; did not testify), DOGON Psychiatric Medical Group
  • DOGON Psychiatric Medical Group, private mental health provider
  • Gil Navarro, education advocate for Student, California Parents Association

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, on January 6, 7, and 8, 2004, in Riverside, California.

Petitioner STUDENT, (Petitioner, STUDENT, or STUDENT) was represented by education advocate Gil Navarro from California Parents Association. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf were his father, FATHER, and his mother, MOTHER. Respondent Jurupa Unified School District (Respondent or District) was represented by attorneys Jack Clarke, Dina Harris, and Khristina Lupariello from the office of Best Best & Krieger LLP. Also present on the District’s behalf was Stephen Eimers, District director of administrative services and designee for discipline.

The Petitioner called the following witnesses: Andrew E. Carey, District physical sciences teacher; Ramon Barreras, District school psychologist/behavior specialist; Constance Lubak, District English teacher; Vicky Lynn Castillo, District history teacher; Vera Mahoney, District high school assistant principal; FATHER; MOTHER; and STUDENT. The District called the following witnesses: Jenelle Benson, District biology teacher; Diana Pine, District computer graphics teacher; Debbie Buckhout, District English teacher; Pat Thompson, District history teacher; Teresa Foltz, District math teacher; Ric Slagle, District math teacher/baseball coach; Vincent John Tieri, District special education teacher; Amy Foody, District program specialist; and Robin Thompson, District speech and language pathologist.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Closing briefs were received on January 16, 2003, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

Issue 1: Does STUDENT currently meet the eligibility criteria for special education under the category of “other health impairment”?

Issue 2: Shall the District be ordered to dismiss the expulsion proceedings against STUDENT, arising from an incident that occurred on or about October 14, 2003, on the grounds that STUDENT should have been receiving special education services and the applicable conduct was a manifestation of his disability?

Issue 3: Is the District required to offer STUDENT a functional analysis assessment (FAA) and use the FAA to formulate a positive behavior intervention plan?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT, born on [date redacted], is a 16-year-old student currently in the eleventh grade. He has continuously been a resident of the District from his kindergarten school year through present. The District has never found STUDENT to be eligible for special education or related services, and he has never received such services.

On July 3, 2000, at the end of the seventh grade, STUDENT was expelled from school for making threatening remarks to a teacher. While STUDENT was under expulsion for the 2000-2001 school year, his father filed a request for a special education due process hearing. The issue presented at hearing on November 9 and 14, 2000, was whether the District was required to rescind STUDENT’s expulsion because, prior to the expulsion, the District had a basis of knowledge that STUDENT was a child with a disability but had never assessed him or found him eligible for special education. Citing STUDENT’s history of frequent and disruptive behaviors in conjunction with declining and failing grades, a recent diagnosis of ADHD, a reasonable probability that the behaviors were symptoms of ADHD, and certain academic issues suggestive of a specific learning disability, the hearing officer in that matter concluded that the District had a basis of knowledge STUDENT was a child with a disability prior to the behavior that led to his expulsion in the seventh grade. The hearing officer therefore concluded that STUDENT had been “expelled in error.” In the written decision dated December 6, 2000, the hearing officer ordered that the expulsion be rescinded and the District immediately return STUDENT to his original placement at middle school.

Meanwhile, on November 21 and 27, 2000, the District conducted psychoeducational and speech and language evaluations, respectively, as part of its assessment process in determining whether STUDENT was eligible for special education. The District school psychologist concluded that her evaluation of STUDENT did not indicate eligibility under the criteria for emotional disturbance or specific learning disability. The District speech and language specialist concluded that her evaluation did not indicate eligibility under the criteria for speech and language deficits.

The District convened an individualized education program (IEP) team meeting on December 11, 2000, to discuss whether STUDENT should be found eligible for special education. The team considered the psychoeducational and speech and language evaluations, STUDENT’s possible diagnosis of ADHD, and the criteria for eligibility under the category of “other health impaired” (OHI). The District members of the IEP team determined that if STUDENT did have ADHD, its severity was not sufficiently significant to qualify STUDENT under the criteria for OHI. After considering all of the above, the District members of the IEP team concluded that STUDENT was not eligible for special education. STUDENT’s father dissented to that conclusion, but he did not file for a new due process hearing.

On April 18, 2002, the District and STUDENT’s parents agreed that because of STUDENT’s ADHD, STUDENT was entitled to a “Section 504 Student Accommodation Plan.” (Footnote 1) The accommodations specified in the written plan included preferential seating near the front of the classroom or near the teacher, “a pass to Ms. Harrison’s office” whenever a substitute teacher conducted the class, weekly progress reports to be completed by STUDENT’s teachers and shown by STUDENT to his father, and after-school tutoring as needed. The “504 coordinator” notified STUDENT’s teachers that if STUDENT’s behavior was “exceptionally poor or disruptive,” they were to inquire if he had taken his ADHD medication. STUDENT’s 504 plan was updated on December 4, 2002, and again on February 13, 2003. The plans were all similar, and the latter version included provision for services from the “Youth Service Center Counselor.” The February 13, 2003 version stated that “STUDENT’s attention deficit disorder interferes with his ability to concentrate and focus. It may also impair his ability to make good choices if he has not taken his medication.”

On October 13 and 14, 2003, a female student “orally copulated” STUDENT in an outdoor and relatively secluded area on the campus of Jurupa Valley High School (JVHS) while STUDENT was in route from his biology class to his sixth-period baseball class. Those acts resulted in a “preliminary notice of suspension” being issued by District principal Ron Shecklen and assistant vice principal Vera Mahoney on October 22. The notice stated that STUDENT would be suspended from school for five days, commencing October 22, and expulsion was being recommended. The District held a meeting with STUDENT’s parents on October 27, and the suspension was extended pending a “discipline hearing” before a District administrative panel, to be held on December 12. On November 3, STUDENT enrolled in the District’s independent study program.

On November 4, 2003, STUDENT’s father notified the District that he was requesting the District to perform a special education assessment of STUDENT. The listed areas of concern were speech and language, academics, motor skills, ADHD, and emotional status.

On November 17, 2003, Ms. Mahoney completed a District administrative summary that references the October 2003 sexual misconduct incidents and summarizes STUDENT’s behavior history from seventh grade through the current portion of his eleventh-grade school year. According to Ms. Mahoney’s summary, “while in seventh grade STUDENT received D’s for his grades and was seen forty (40) times in the office for discipline problems.” In eighth grade, according to the summary, STUDENT was seen in the office for truancy, class disturbances, defiance, offensive language, and pulling a girl into the boy’s restroom. He was suspended for a total of seven days. He was then recommended for expulsion after “being defiant, disruptive, socking another student two times, and pushing an instructional aide in a confrontational way.” In March 2001, the recommendation for expulsion was withdrawn and the District recommended that STUDENT attend an alternative placement at the Learning Center for the remainder of the school year. In ninth grade at Jurupa Valley High School, STUDENT “was seen in the office twenty-four times for counseling and discipline referrals.” He was also suspended fifteen days for “pulling a girl’s pants down during P.E. class, using profane language to a teacher and fighting.” In tenth grade he “was seen by his guidance counselor for discipline problems at least thirty times. He was suspended a total of seventeen days for the 2002-2003 school year for defiance, taking items from a teacher’s desk without permission, tagging the boy’s restroom and posting an inappropriate picture of a student on a hallway wall.” Ms. Mahoney’s summary further states that during the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT “has received referrals for a class truancy and tardies to class. He was suspended and recommended for expulsion on October 22, 2003.” After citing STUDENT’s behavior history and the most recent incidents, Ms. Mahoney concluded her November 17, 2003 report by requesting STUDENT’s expulsion from the District for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year for violation of Cal. Educ. Code § 48900(i), e.g. committing an obscene act or engaging in habitual profanity or vulgarity, and § 48900(k), e.g. disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defying the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties.

Pursuant to FATHER’s November 4, 2003 request, the District completed a speech and language assessment of STUDENT on December 1, 2003. The examiner, Robin Thompson, concluded that “STUDENT’s integrated language performance fell well within normal limits.” District school psychologist/behavior specialist Ramon Barreras completed a psychoeducational evaluation on December 5. Mr. Barreras’ report states that according to the Weschler Intelligence Scale for Children–IV (WISC-IV), “STUDENT’s general cognitive ability is within the average range of intellectual functioning.” On the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement–III (WJ-III), STUDENT’s percentile rank in various academic areas ranged from twenty-four to fifty-eight. Other tests, according to the report, showed age-appropriate skills in auditory processing and memory ability, with average to superior skills in long- and short-term memory. Visual processing and visual motor integration were normal. To assess STUDENT’s social/emotional and behavior status, Mr. Barerras asked STUDENT, FATHER, STUDENT’s computer graphic design teacher (Ms. Pine), and STUDENT’s algebra teacher (Ms. Foltz), to complete the Behavior Assessment for Children (BASC) rating scales. Mr. Barreras also administered the Reynolds Adolescent Depression Scale–2nd Edition (RADS-2), and he reviewed STUDENT’s school records, including behavior history and reports from eleventh-grade teachers. Mr. Barreras concluded that “STUDENT is not exhibiting any significant behavioral or emotional difficulties that are impacting his academic performance or his ability to make appropriate decisions.”

Following completion of the special education assessment, the District held an IEP meeting on December 10, 2003. The meeting notes state that although STUDENT had a “history of disruptive, defiant, and disrespectful behavior,” his eleventh-grade teachers had reported good conduct. The notes also state that STUDENT would be changing his ADHD medication from Ritalin to Sestera and, according to his counselor, STUDENT has behavior difficulty but “does well when he is medicated.” The team discussed plans for ensuring that STUDENT took his medications. The District members of the IEP team concluded that STUDENT was not eligible for special education and that he was appropriately placed at the time of the alleged misconduct in October 2003. STUDENT’s father and STUDENT’s advocate disagreed with that conclusion. They asserted to the IEP team that STUDENT’s numerous discipline referrals over the past years were a result of STUDENT’s ADHD and, consequently, he should be found eligible under the criteria for “other health impaired” (OHI). The advocate requested a “Hughes bill” behavior assessment. The District stated that because STUDENT was not eligible for special education, a Hughes bill assessment was unavailable. However, the District offered a “non Hughes” behavior assessment, to be coordinated by the 504 team.

On December 11, 2003, the District determined that “the Discipline Process will go forward.” The present request for due process hearing was filed on December 15. On December 17, STUDENT’s father signed his consent to the “functional assessment of behavior (non-Hughes bill)” offered by the District. Meanwhile, the District has not allowed STUDENT to return to JVHS. He remains on an independent study program through the Learning Center.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue 1: Does STUDENT currently meet the eligibility criteria for special education under the category of “other health impairment”?

Children with disabilities have the right to a “free appropriate public education.” 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d), Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. (Footnote 3) The term “free appropriate public education” (FAPE) means “special education” and “related services” that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, meet the State educational standards, and conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). State law further defines the term “special education” as meaning specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of individuals with exceptional needs whose educational needs cannot be met with modification of the regular instruction program, and “related services” that may be needed to assist these individuals to benefit from specially designed instruction. Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. In accordance with the student’s unique needs and present levels of performance, the student’s IEP must provide for the student to be involved and progress in the general curriculum and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d), 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a).

For purposes of a child’s special education eligibility under federal law, 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A)(ii) defines “child with a disability” as meaning a child with at least one of the several conditions listed in § 1401, including the condition of “other health impairment,” who, by reason thereof, needs special education and related services. The term “other health impairment” (OHI) is defined in federal regulations as a condition whereby the student has “limited strength, vitality, or alertness, including a heightened alertness to environmental stimuli, that results in limited alertness with respect to the educational environment, that– (i) Is due to chronic or acute health problems such as ... attention deficit disorder or attention deficit hyperactivity disorder [ADHD] ... and (ii) Adversely affects a child’s educational performance.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(9).

For purposes of a child’s special education eligibility under State law, an “individual with exceptional needs” is defined as a student who is identified by an IEP team as “a child with a disability,” as that latter phrase is defined by federal statute in 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A)(ii), and who requires special education because of the degree of his or her “impairment.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56026, Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030. One of the “impairments” listed in the State regulations concerning eligibility, is “limited strength, vitality, or alertness due to chronic or acute health problems.” Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(f).

Although the above-referenced Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(f) does not specifically mention ADHD, the “impairment” described in § 3030(f) is analogous to the federal definition of OHI stated in 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(9). Moreover, by statute, State law expressly recognizes that ADHD can lead to eligibility for special education. Cal. Educ. Code § 56339. Under State law, a pupil whose educational performance is adversely affected by a suspected or diagnosed condition of ADHD and who demonstrates a need for special education and related services by meeting the eligibility criteria specified for OHI, emotional disturbance, or specific learning disabilities, is entitled to special education and related services. (Footnote 4) Cal. Educ. Code § 56339(a). (Footnote 5) If a pupil with ADHD is not found to be eligible for special education and related services pursuant to section 56339(a), “the pupil’s instructional program shall be provided in the regular education program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56339(b).

In the present case, STUDENT asserts that because of his ADHD, he is currently eligible for special education under the criteria for OHI specified in 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(9) and/or Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(f). (Footnote 6) STUDENT asserts that position primarily on the basis of his medical diagnosis of ADHD and longstanding history of behavior problems and poor grades. The District asserts that STUDENT’s performance in September and October of the 2003-2004 (eleventh-grade) school year confirms that from the beginning of the current school year through present, the degree and effect of STUDENT’s ADHD has not been such that STUDENT requires special education or related services. Instead, according to the District, STUDENT’s educational needs were and could be met through modification of the regular instruction program.

To determine whether, because of his ADHD, STUDENT currently meets the OHI eligibility criteria for special education, it will first be necessary to review the nature of ADHD and how it may be manifested in the classroom environment. The Hearing Officer will then review the December 2003 assessment, STUDENT’s academic and behavioral performance at JVHS, and testimony concerning the District’s determination of noneligibility at the December 10, 2003 IEP meeting. Thereafter, the Hearing Officer will determine whether STUDENT meets the OHI eligibility criteria for special education.

I . The nature of ADHD.

District employees testified concerning the nature of ADHD and how ADHD may be manifested in the school environment. District special education teacher Vincent Tieri testified that he has been a special education teacher for 24 years. According to Mr. Tieri, manifestations of ADHD within the classroom environment may include a “high motor idle” with tapping of fingers and feet, but with other students the manifestations may be subtle. A student may show no indications of hyperactivity and may appear, at least outwardly, to be attentive; however, the teachers may have to frequently repeat themselves. In other situations, the primary manifestation may be impulsive behaviors, including oral outbursts or physical aggression.

District program specialist Amy Foody’s testimony regarding the manifestations of ADHD was similar to Mr. Tieri’s description. Ms. Foody, with 17 years of experience in special education, further testified that manifestations of ADHD may include a student’s difficulty starting or completing assignments; impulsively “yelling out” in class and not waiting for his or her turn; being excessively active during unstructured times; misunderstanding or reacting angrily to negative comments; and difficulty understanding, due to an egocentric and immature viewpoint, his or her role in an incident.

At the hearing, STUDENT produced three recent letters from DOGON Psychiatric Medical Group (DOGON). STUDENT has been treating at DOGON since November 18, 2003. Two of the letters were written by T. Phillip Laney, M.F.T. The letters by Mr. Laney state that he had been counseling STUDENT and STUDENT’s father “to address STUDENT’s campus issue,” that STUDENT has a diagnosis of “314.01 Attention Deficit Disorder, predominately Hyper-Impulsive,” and that “in learning behavior STUDENT has a tendency to act out with limited foresight on consequences of his behavior.” The third letter, dated December 28, 2003, and written by Samuel E. Dey, Jr., M.D., states that STUDENT’s “diagnosis is severe ADHD, one of the symptoms of which is impulsivity, which is the cause of many of the behavioral problems he has been having lately. It is my recommendation that STUDENT be placed in special education.”

II. The December 2003 assessment.

Psychoeducational evaluation. District school psychologist and behavior specialist Ramon Barreras testified concerning his December 2003 psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT and his opinions concerning STUDENT’s noneligibility for special education. He testified that during the evaluation process he reviewed STUDENT’s extensive behavior history, but he also wanted to evaluate, through testing, how STUDENT’s performance may be affected by ADHD. He further stated that to determine eligibility, one must examine whether ADHD was affecting STUDENT’s performance, and, if so, whether modification of the regular instruction program was meeting STUDENT’s educational needs, thereby resulting in no need for special education.

Mr. Barerras testified that he found no negative impact from ADHD on STUDENT’s academic performance. He stated that during his two years as a school psychologist, he had performed eligibility evaluations on about 7-10 students who meet OHI criteria because of ADHD. He stated that with all of those students, he could see their difficulty in attending to his testing sessions. Those difficulties involved the students’ being fidgety and in motion, being easily distracted, and requiring frequent redirection and prompting during testing. Mr. Barerras testified that in the two, two-and-one-half hour testing sessions (performed over a span of two days) he conducted on STUDENT, he observed none of the above behaviors. He testified that STUDENT required no breaks during the testing. By comparison, the other students with ADHD usually required breaks every ten or fifteen minutes, and some of them had to be tested at home.

Mr. Barreras testified that in using the WISC–IV to evaluate STUDENT’s cognitive processing and functioning, he specifically wanted to measure STUDENT’s working memory and processing speed because the testing of those two areas on the WISC–IV requires “a lot of attention” by the student. STUDENT’s scaled scores related to processing speed, manipulation of information, and coding were in the average range and well-above what Mr. Barerras expects for students with ADHD. Medium memory scan, at 117, was in the high average range, and Mr. Barreras testified that he would have expected a score of 85 or below in a comparable student with ADHD.

Mr. Barerras stated that in addition to testing students in a “filtered” environment, he also considers their performance in the classroom setting as reported by teachers. Thus, he reviewed academic and behavior-related information provided by STUDENT’s teachers. STUDENT’s eleventh-grade teachers reported that STUDENT had good academic performance. Regarding behavior, Mr. Barerras testified that the BASC data obtained from STUDENT’s teachers was not indicative of STUDENT’s being adversely affected by ADHD in the school environment, although the BASC data obtained from STUDENT’s parents concerning the home environment was somewhat consistent with ADHD. Mr. Barreras testified that STUDENT’s extensive behavior and discipline history could just as well be found with students who do not have ADHD, and he does not connect the behavior and discipline history to STUDENT’s ADHD. He testified, for example, that the tardies and the one truancy in the 2003-2004 school year were not specific forms of behavior indicative of ADHD, but instead were common to the general student population. He also testified that the October 2003 acts of sexual misconduct were not, in his opinion, a manifestation of STUDENT’s ADHD. He stated that the circumstances of the incident, such as the timing, the location, and the willingness of the participant, showed that the actions were planned and were not impulsive behaviors.

Mr. Barerras’s report contains several recommendations to help with STUDENT’s attention in the classroom, but, according to Mr. Barerras, those recommendations are equivalent to strategies teachers commonly use for the general student population. The recommendations included reviewing and sharing STUDENT’s 504 plan with STUDENT’s teachers; using visual aids in conjunction with orally-presented activities; having structured, routine, and predictable classroom activities; maintaining close proximity and eye contact and continually asking for responses when giving instructions; checking for understanding by having STUDENT repeat directions back to the teachers; using alerting cues and giving one direction at a time; and breaking down large tasks into smaller tasks to avoid frustration or anxiety.

Regarding special education eligibility, Mr. Barreras concluded that STUDENT’s ADHD was in the low to mild range, that STUDENT was capable of making good decisions about his behavior, that the 504 plan was appropriate to STUDENT’s level of ADHD, that STUDENT’s ADHD was and could continue to be sufficiently managed by medications and the 504 plan, that the specific recommendations made in the report were good recommendations for all students, and, therefore, that the degree of STUDENT’s ADHD did not make STUDENT eligible for special education. Speech and language evaluation. District speech and language pathologist Robin Thompson testified regarding her December 2003 assessment of STUDENT. She stated that she is quite familiar with assessing students who have ADHD and STUDENT did not present as a student with ADHD. She stated that STUDENT was patient during testing and demonstrated good ability to perform all tasks. She stated that on the comprehensive test of phonological processing, an area usually found to be especially difficult for students with ADHD, STUDENT scored a 73. For students with ADHD, she would have expected single digit scores on that same test.

III. STUDENT’s performance at JVHS.

Ms. Mahoney’s November 17, 2003 District administrative summary, referenced above in Background Facts, recounts STUDENT’s behavior history commencing with seventh grade. However, because the present issue is limited to whether STUDENT currently meets eligibility criteria for special education, the Hearing Officer considers the history of STUDENT’s performance in high school, and particularly in the eleventh grade, to be more pertinent.

Testimony by STUDENT’s tenth-grade teachers. Andrew Carey, physical sciences teacher at JVHS, testified that he has seen students with ADHD make poor choices and impulsive decisions. As STUDENT’s physical sciences teacher for approximately the first month of STUDENT’s tenth-grade 2002-2003 school year at JVHS, the only such incident he observed with STUDENT was when STUDENT took exception to a comment made by a student seated in front of STUDENT in the class, and STUDENT “slugged” the student solidly in the back with his fist. Otherwise, according to Mr. Carey, STUDENT’s responses in the classroom were appropriate and he was engaged in the classroom activities.

Constance Lubak was STUDENT’s English teacher in tenth-grade during the fall quarter of 2002. She testified that STUDENT made poor choices in her classroom. She characterized his behavior as manipulative. Her general impression was that STUDENT often would intentionally cause trouble in the classroom, as though he was hoping that his behavior would result in his being sent out of the classroom.

Vicky Lynn Castillo was STUDENT’s world history teacher in tenth grade. She testified that STUDENT failed her class the first semester, but after she spoke to STUDENT’s father about having STUDENT turn in homework assignments, STUDENT’s effort improved and he received a passing grade for the second semester. Her general impressions about STUDENT were that he was a bright student who excelled at oral participation, improved his work when urged to do so by his father, had behavior issues but not necessarily impulsive behaviors, and had good behavior when he was on his medications.

Testimony by STUDENT’s eleventh-grade teachers. STUDENT’s eleventh-grade teachers testified concerning STUDENT’s performance from the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year in early September through commencement of STUDENT’s suspension in mid-October. Computer graphics teacher Diana Pine testified that she has a teaching credential for business technology and also for special education. She has two years of prior experience teaching special education classes in addition to currently being JVHS’s computer graphics teacher. She described STUDENT as being “model” student and a “great” student whothoroughly enjoyed the class, was focused on his work, learned skills that went beyond what was required for classroom projects, and was proud of his work. Ms. Pine testified that although her class was not as structured as, for example, an English class, she saw no indications of STUDENT’s having ADHD.

History teacher Pat Thompson testified that in his U.S history class, STUDENT was a good student with no behavior problems that would distinguish him from other students. He considered STUDENT to be a respectful student.

Math teacher Teresa Foltz testified that STUDENT was a good student who completed his assignments and had excellent conduct. When Ms. Foltz received the 504 plan, STUDENT’s desk was in the back of the class. Pursuant to the 504 plan recommendations, she offered STUDENT a seat near the front of the class. However, at STUDENT’s request, she allowed him to remain at the back of the class so long as there were no problems with his behavior. No problems ensued, and STUDENT remained at the back of the class until his subsequent suspension for the October 2003 sexual misconduct.

English teacher Debbie Buckhout testified that she received notice of STUDENT’s 504 plan in approximately the third week of September and began implementing it. As did Ms. Foltz, Ms. Buckhout also allowed STUDENT to remain seated at the back of the class so long as there were no problems, and there were no problems. She described STUDENT as an able, capable student. He was never disrespectful to her, and she recalls never having to ask him to be attentive. She considered his demeanor to be normal among high school students she has encountered in her 21 years of teaching. She stated that STUDENT had some early, minor problems with tardies, but those problems resolved after she spoke to STUDENT’s mother. Biology teacher Janelle Benson testified that at the beginning of September, STUDENT had problems with his effort and was failing the class. She discussed the matter with STUDENT’s mother. MOTHER told Ms. Benson that taking things away from STUDENT improves his behavior and MOTHER intended to take away STUDENT’s car. At about that time, Ms. Benson also received and began implementing STUDENT’s 504 plan. Shortly thereafter, STUDENT’s effort and scores improved at a rate indicating, in Ms. Benson’s opinion, that STUDENT would eventually conclude the course with a passing grade. She testified that she saw nothing distinct about STUDENT’s behavior to suggest ADHD, although she did notice that during the first few days of the class STUDENT talked excessively with the female students in the back of the classroom. The excessive talking ceased when Ms. Benson moved STUDENT to the front of the classroom.

Ms. Benson also testified that both STUDENT and the student with whom STUDENT engaged in the sexual misconduct were in her sixth-period biology class. On one occasion when STUDENT was seated in the front of the class and the female student was seated in the back of the class, STUDENT asked Ms. Benson for “bathroom passes” both for himself and the female student so they would be able to leave the classroom together. (Footnote 7)

Math teacher and baseball coach Ric Slagle testified that during tenth grade he spoke to STUDENT about being on the baseball team and told STUDENT that a 2.0 or higher grade point average (GPA) was required for a student’s being eligible to play on the team. STUDENT replied that he would try to improve his grades and did improve his grades in the spring of 2003. Consequently, Mr. Slagle allowed STUDENT to participate in JHVS’s baseball class during the fall of 2003. He noticed no problems with STUDENT’s behavior and attention. He confirmed that baseball appeared important to STUDENT, and that STUDENT probably had appropriate skill to eventually play at the varsity level.

Grades. STUDENT’s JVHS transcripts show that through the completion of summer school in 2003, STUDENT’s overall GPA was 1.7407 and STUDENT had earned a total of 115 credits toward graduation. According to District witnesses, that number of credits put STUDENT on pace to graduate at the completion of his fourth year in high school. The transcripts show gradual improvement in STUDENT’s grades. Through the two ninth-grade semesters, STUDENT’s semester grades in academic classes were one “B,” one “C,” three “D’s,” and five “F’s.” (Footnote 8) In tenth-grade summer school classes, STUDENT received a “B” in English in July 2002, and he received an “A” in English in August 2002. STUDENT’s semester grades for the two tenth-grade semesters during the regular school year were one “B,” six “C’s,” two “D’s,” and one “F.” (Footnote 9) In the second semester of tenth grade, as compared to the first semester, STUDENT raised his English grade from “D” to “C” and his algebra grade from “C” to “B.” None of his grades dropped from the first to the second semester. After having received a first-semester “F” in world history and then a second-semester “D” in world history during the tenth grade, STUDENT earned a “C” in world history during eleventh-grade summer school.

In the eleventh-grade regular school year, STUDENT only attended school from the beginning of September through approximately October 21, 2003. Although the first semester was still in progress when STUDENT was suspended, each of STUDENT’s teachers completed reports showing STUDENT’s grades as of October 21. STUDENT had earned an “A-” in computer graphic design from Ms. Pine, an “A-” in U.S. history from Mr. Thompson, a “B+” in algebra from Ms. Foltz, and a “B-/C+” in English from Ms. Buckhout. According to Ms. Benson, STUDENT’s scores in biology were at “F” level, but STUDENT had recently improved his scores from 50 percent to 57 percent and she believed that STUDENT was on track to improve to a passing grade. STUDENT had earned an “A” in advanced baseball from Mr. Slagle. (Footnote 10)

Testimony by STUDENT and his parents. STUDENT’s father, FATHER, testified that STUDENT began taking medications for ADHD in approximately December of 2000. The medications initially were helpful, but the dosages had to be increased. More recently, he believed that the medications had been less effective and STUDENT’s behavior was worsening at home and was not improving at school during the fall of 2003. The school, as it had in years past, was still calling him multiple times per week to discuss STUDENT’s behavior, and it was FATHER’s impression that STUDENT was still being frequently sent to the office for disruptive behaviors.

STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, testified that after STUDENT began taking his ADHD medications and participating in his 504 plan over the past couple of years, his behavior had improved and his grades had improved significantly. She had no opinion regarding what percentages of that improvement may be apportionable to the 504 plan, the medications, or other factors.

STUDENT testified that he tends to act before he thinks of the consequences, then he realizes the consequences are bad when he gets caught. He testified that he enjoys baseball and, after being told by the JVHS baseball coach that he needed to improve his grades to qualify for the team, he did make an effort to improve his grades during the spring of 2003. STUDENT testified that when he started eleventh grade in September 2003, he was often late to his first- and sixth-period classes because he preferred to continue talking to his friends. He stated that he performed poorly in biology class because the work was hard and he preferred to “slack off.” He stated that he tends to perform better in classes where he likes the teacher. He also stated that when he acts immaturely in class, such as by talking excessively, and a call is placed to his home, he stops the behaviors. Except for his excessive talking and some tardies, STUDENT believes that his behavior and performance had generally been good in eleventh grade.

IV. The District’s position at the December 10, 2003 IEP meeting.

Mr. Tieri attended the December 10, 2003 IEP meeting at which the District determined that STUDENT was not eligible for special education. Mr. Tieri testifed that the IEP team discussed STUDENT’s behavior history from prior years, but the District members of the team were impressed that information from the eleventh grade showed good performance, that teacher observations and reports from eleventh grade were favorable and matched STUDENT’s eleventh-grade academic performance, and that STUDENT was “on track” for graduation. According to Mr. Tieri, the District members of the team believed that STUDENT’s behavioral problems were, at least in part, caused by ADHD, but the District also believed that the 504 plan and the medications were sufficiently addressing STUDENT’s ADHD and, therefore, special education was not required.

Ms. Mahoney testified that she and the other District members of the IEP team believed that the 504 plan was meeting STUDENT’s ADHD needs and STUDENT did not require special education, as demonstrated by STUDENT’s academic improvement in the eleventh grade, his being “on track” to graduate,” his improved behavior in eleventh grade, and the fact that none of STUDENT’s eleventh-grade teachers thought that STUDENT’s behavior was interfering with academic progress.

Ms. Foody testified that she chaired the December 10, 2003 IEP meeting. She testified that the team did not dispute whether STUDENT had ADHD. Instead, the District members of the team determined that STUDENT’s educational progress was not adversely affected by ADHD to the degree necessary for special education eligibility.

V. Discussion and findings.

According to Mr. Barreras, his December 2003 psychoeducational evaluation showed no indication that ADHD was adversely affecting STUDENT’s educational performance to the degree that special education was required. The Hearing Officer found Mr. Barreras’ testimony to be credible. Mr. Barreras formulated his opinions from a variety of reasonable sources of information. He reviewed STUDENT’s school records. He relied upon standardized testing using, among other instruments, the WISC–IV. In assessing behavior, Mr. Barerras also utilized what he considered to be reliable BASC data obtained from STUDENT, FATHER, Ms. Foltz, and Ms. Pine. He credibly explained how certain scores on the WISC–IV, such as scores related to processing speed, manipulation of information, and medium memory, contraindicated that ADHD was affecting STUDENT’s performance. Testimony by the speech and language pathologist, Ms. Thompson, similarly showed that STUDENT did not present during testing as a student with ADHD.

Testimony by STUDENT’s eleventh-grade teachers showed that STUDENT’s behavior was not adversely affecting his performance to the degree that special education would be necessary. STUDENT’s eleventh-grade teachers were actually complimentary regarding STUDENT’s behavior. Their testimony was corroborated by STUDENT’s school records. The records showed that although STUDENT had several tardies at the beginning of the school year and was excessively talkative during the first weeks in his biology class, those problems had been resolved. The records also confirmed that up to the time of STUDENT’s suspension on October 22, 2003, STUDENT was making good academic progress, with “A’s” and “B’s” in every class except biology.

The quality of STUDENT’s academic performance and classroom behavior in eleventh grade stands in stark contrast to his prior history. The reasons for STUDENT’s improvement were not definitively demonstrated. Evidence suggested a combination of factors, such as ADHD medications, the 504 plan, STUDENT’s desire to improve performance so he could be eligible for baseball and also avoid various disciplinary measures by his parents, and STUDENT’s apparent aptitude and enthusiasm for selected subjects, including computer graphic design.

Whatever the reasons for STUDENT’s improved performance may be, STUDENT’s performance in eleventh grade, up to the time of the sexual misconduct incidents in October 2003, confirms that the degree of STUDENT’s ADHD is not such that STUDENT currently needs special education. Furthermore, the sexual misconduct incidents do nothing to change that determination. The evidence regarding when the events occurred, where they occurred, the willing participation of the female student, and the relationship between STUDENT and the other student, as demonstrated in Ms. Benson’s class, showed that the two incidents involving oral copulation were deliberate and well-planned, as opposed to being impulsive, reactive, or egocentric behaviors arising from ADHD. (Footnote 11) Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT currently does not meet the eligibility criteria for special education under the category of “other health impairment.”

Issue 2: Shall the District be ordered to dismiss the expulsion proceedings against STUDENT, arising from an incident that occurred on or about October 14, 2003, on the grounds that STUDENT should have been receiving special education services and the applicable conduct was a manifestation of his disability?

Under federal and State law, children who have been found eligible for special education are accorded certain protections in disciplinary matters. Federal law also extends those protections to children who have not yet been deemed eligible for special education if the local educational agency (or district) is deemed to have knowledge that the child is a child with a disability. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(8), 34 C.F.R. § 300.527. Among the protections accorded to children found eligible for special education, and also to children for whom the district is deemed to have a basis of knowledge that the child is a child with a disability, is the right to a manifestation determination review. (Footnote 12) 34 C.F.R. § 300.523. However, if “the behavior of the child with a disability was not a manifestation of the child’s disability, the relevant disciplinary procedures applicable to children without disabilities may be applied to the child in the same manner in which they would be applied to children without disabilities, except as provided in Sec. 300.121(d).” (Footnote 13) 34 C.F.R. § 300.524(a).

In the present case, STUDENT asserts that because he was not in an appropriate special education placement and program when the sexual misconduct occurred, and because the sexual misconduct was a manifestation of his disability, the expulsion proceedings must be dismissed. The District asserts that a student who is not eligible for special education is not entitled to the protections of the IDEA and, therefore, “the expulsion should stand.”

The Hearing Officer has already determined that STUDENT is not currently eligible for special education. The finding of noneligibility was made chiefly on the basis of STUDENT’s performance from the commencement of the eleventh-grade school year through the date of the sexual misconduct. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds also finds that STUDENT was not eligible special education when the sexual misconduct occurred. Thus, the protections sought by STUDENT under the IDEA and corresponding State law are not pertinent to the current expulsion proceedings, and the Hearing Officer will not order dismissal of the expulsion proceedings. (Footnote 14)

Issue 3: Is the District required to offer STUDENT a functional analysis assessment (FAA) and use the FAA to formulate a positive behavior intervention plan?

Federal and State law specify that behavior plans, formulated on the basis of assessment information, are to be included in a pupil’s IEP when necessary for meeting the pupil’s behavior-related needs arising from his or her disability. (Footnote 15) State regulations set forth, for use in certain situations, the mandatory and relatively detailed elements of a “behavioral intervention plan” (BIP) formulated from a particular type of assessment known as a “functional analysis assessment” (FAA), also commonly referred to as a “Hughes bill” assessment. BIPs, as defined by State law, are developed when the individual exhibits a serious behavior problem that significantly interferes with the implementation of the goals and objectives of the individual’s IEP. (Footnote 16)

STUDENT asserts that the District is required to offer him a functional analysis assessment (FAA) and that the FAA should be used in the formulation of a behavioral intervention plan (BIP). The District asserts that because STUDENT is not eligible for special education, an FAA cannot be ordered. As demonstrated by the above-cited law, the District’s position on this issue is correct. STUDENT is not eligible for special education. Consequently, the Hearing Office has no authority to order the District to provide STUDENT with an FAA.

ORDERS

1. All of the Petitioner’s requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided.

Issue 1: Does STUDENT currently meet the eligibility criteria for special education under the category of “other health impairment”? The District prevailed on this issue.

Issue 2: Shall the District be ordered to dismiss the expulsion proceedings against STUDENT, arising from an incident that occurred on or about October 14, 2003, on the grounds that STUDENT should have been receiving special education services and the applicable conduct was a manifestation of his disability? The District prevailed on this issue.

Issue 3: Is the District required to offer STUDENT a functional analysis assessment (FAA) and use the FAA to formulate a positive behavior intervention plan? The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Dated: January 28, 2004 ____________________________________ Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. The term “504 plan” arises from Section 504 of the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973. See 29 U.S.C. § 794 and 34 C.F.R. § 104.1. In certain situations, a child with learning difficulties may be ineligible for special education because the learning difficulties fit within none of the special education eligibility categories or because the degree of the learning difficulties is insufficient to qualify the child for special education. However, such a child may be eligible for accommodations at school under Section 504. Eligibility for Section 504 accommodations arises from a child’s having a physical or mental condition which substantially limits a major life activity.

2. Ms. Mahoney testified that although her administrative summary recommends expulsion on multiple grounds, the sexual misconduct occurring in October 2003 was, and currently remains, the main reason for the recommendation.

3. Federal special education law uses the term “child with a disability.” The corresponding provisions of State law use the term “individuals with exceptional needs.”

4. These conditions are further described in 34 C.F.R. § 300.7; Cal. Educ. Code § 56337; and Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(f), (i), and (j).

5. Section 56339(a) does not indicate why, in situations wherein a child has already been deemed eligible for special education under the criteria for OHI, emotional disturbance, or specific learning disability, one would inquire whether ADHD bears upon the child’s eligibility. Section 56339(a) may be intended to mean that ADHD can be one of the underlying conditions that supports eligibility under the criteria for OHI, emotional disturbance, and specific learning disability.

6. STUDENT does not assert eligibility under the criteria for emotional disturbance or specific learning disabilities.

7. Ms. Benson testified that she refused the request.

8. In ninth grade, STUDENT also received a “B” each semester in physical education (P.E.), and he received a “P” for ten units of Spanish 1.

9. In tenth grade, STUDENT also received semester grades of “B” and “A” in basketball. The “A” was received in the second semester.

10. The November 3, 2003 “withdrawal” grades listed on STUDENT’s JVHS transcript show lower grades that the interim grades given earlier by STUDENT’s teachers on October 21. The decrease was due to assignments and tests that STUDENT did not complete after his being suspended.

11. The above-referenced letters from DOGON did not persuade the Hearing Officer that STUDENT should be found eligible for special education. FATHER testified that a copy of STUDENT’s evidence binder had been given to Dr. Dey. However, there was no evidence that Mr. Laney or Dr. Dey actually considered or have even minimal knowledge of the law regarding special education eligibility, that they considered the significance of STUDENT’s 504 plan, or that they considered how STUDENT’s academic performance and behavior at school in eleventh grade compare to his academic performance and behavior in prior school years. Neither Dr. Dey nor Mr. Laney testified at the hearing. Diligent efforts by both parties to serve Dr. Dey with a subpoena requiring his testimony were futile. He reportedly evaded the process servers and refused to testify even after his staff had been informed that his testimony could be received telephonically.

12. The purpose of a manifestation determination review is to determine whether or not “(i) In relationship to the behavior subject to the disciplinary action, the child’s IEP and placement were appropriate and the special education services, supplementary aids and services, and behavior strategies were provided consistent with the child’s IEP and placement; (ii) The child’s disability did not impair the ability of the child to understand the impact and consequences of the behavior subject to disciplinary action; and (iii) The child’s disability did not impair the ability of the child to control the behavior subject to disciplinary action.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.523(c)(2). See also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k), Cal. Educ. Code § 48915.5.

13. The provisions of “Sec. 300.121(d)” apply only to children who are eligible for special education. STUDENT is not eligible for special education.

14. The situation in the present case is distinguishable from the December 6, 2000 hearing decision. The hearing officer in the prior case was not asked to rule on eligibility, and the hearing decision contained no findings with regard to whether or not STUDENT was eligible for special education. In the present case, the Hearing Officer has determined that STUDENT was not eligible for special education during the time period at issue.

15. Federal law makes general references to “positive behavioral interventions,” “functional behavioral assessment,” and “behavioral intervention plan[s].” See 20 U.S.C. §§ 1414(d)(3)(B)(i) and 1415(k)(1)(B).

16.The specific and required elements of a behavior intervention plan (BIP), as referenced under State law, are distinct from the general references to behavior intervention plans in federal law. BIPs are described in Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(d), (e), (f), and (aa). The elements and application of FAA’s are described in Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3052.