California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 10, 2004
Student v. Encinitas Union School District
SEHO Case No. SN 2645-03 · Hearing Officer Judith E. Ganz
Encinitas Union must fund aural habilitation, Lindamood-Bell reading, and a trained one-on-one aide for a deaf student with a cochlear implant
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of an eight-year-old second-grader filed for due process against Encinitas Union School District. Their daughter is deaf and uses a cochlear implant. She attended general education at Olivenhain Pioneer Elementary with speech therapy, consultation from a deaf and hard of hearing (DHH) itinerant teacher, and limited aide time. Before the hearing began, the Hearing Officer denied the district's motion to recuse her.
The district agreed the student needed aural habilitation, which is training to understand sounds heard through the implant. For first grade (2002-2003), however, the IEP had no aural habilitation goals and staff were not trained to provide it. The Hearing Officer found a denial of FAPE and ordered reimbursement of $4,507.04 for private sessions with audiologist Joan Hewett.
For 2003-2004, the IEP again lacked aural habilitation goals. It gave one hour of daily help from a minimally trained aide, even though the student struggled in every academic subject. It also lacked intensive, individualized reading instruction in phonological awareness and fluency. Its phonics goals had vague baselines, and there were no fluency goals. The district won on written expression goals and on parent participation.
The district must:
- reimburse $12,707, plus $69 per later session, for Lindamood-Bell;
- fund up to ten Lindamood-Bell sessions a week through extended school year (ESY);
- provide a trained one-on-one aide in all academic subjects through ESY;
- amend the IEP within 15 business days.
The request for a one-year aide was denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled a district's claim that aural habilitation was woven into a deaf student's school day. Without written goals, trained staff, and records, the Hearing Officer found the service was not really provided. It also shows how vague baselines in reading goals weighed against a district under the Rowley standard.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year by failing to provide services designed to meet her unique need for aural habilitation?
The IEP had no aural habilitation goals, and the speech therapist, aide, and teacher were not trained to provide or did not provide aural habilitation, so the program was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year, are her parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private aural habilitation services they obtained?
Weekly private aural habilitation from audiologist Joan Hewett met the student's needs and provided benefit; the district must reimburse $4,507.04 on invoice or proof of payment.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3A. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for 2003-2004 by failing to provide the services of a trained one-on-one language facilitator designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs for aural habilitation?
The IEP again lacked aural habilitation goals, and one hour of daily aide time from a minimally trained aide, with no data collection or coordination, could not meet needs that arose in all academic subjects.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3B. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for 2003-2004 by failing to provide an intensive individualized reading program designed to remediate STUDENT's deficits in the areas of phonological awareness and reading fluency?
The phonemic awareness goals had vague baselines and no measurable benchmarks, there were no fluency goals, and the general education reading program did not give the intensive small-group or one-on-one instruction the student needed.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 3C. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for 2003-2004 by failing to provide IEP goals and objectives designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs in written expression?
The written language goal had specific short-term objectives and a data-based baseline, and it was reasonably calculated to provide benefit.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 3D. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for 2003-2004 by failing to permit full parental participation in the IEP process?
The district considered the private assessments and the parents' requests, and the parents took an active part; written refusal letters after IEP discussions did not seriously limit their participation.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year, are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for services they procured and to other remedies?
The parents were awarded Lindamood-Bell reimbursement, continued Lindamood-Bell sessions through ESY, and a trained one-on-one aide through ESY; the request for a language facilitator for one year was denied.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days of receipt of an invoice or proof of payment, reimburse parents $4,507.04 for aural habilitation sessions with Joan Hewett from September 2002 through August 31, 2003.
- Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days of receipt of an invoice or proof of payment, reimburse parents $12,707.00 for Lindamood-Bell services from October 6, 2003 through January 30, 2004, plus $69.00 per session from January 31, 2004 to the date of the Decision.
- Compensatory education. Unless the parties agree otherwise in writing, the district must fund the Lindamood-Bell reading program at $69.00 per session, up to ten sessions per week, from the date of the Decision through the end of ESY.
- Order to provide or change services. Provide a trained one-on-one instructional aide in all academic subjects for the rest of the 2003-2004 regular school year, including ESY. The aide must monitor hearing equipment, preview and review lessons, practice vocabulary, redirect attention, clarify teacher instructions, write unknown words, and express what the student cannot hear. Consistent, coordinated record-keeping must be developed to measure progress.
- Staff training. The aide must be trained in aural habilitation and in teaching a child with a cochlear implant to listen. Training comes from the DHH itinerant teacher, speech therapist, and audiologist, or other formal training the IEP team designates.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 business days, the IEP team must meet and amend the IEP to add: aural habilitation goals; phonological awareness and reading fluency goals with accurate present levels and measurable benchmarks; and the one-on-one trained aide in all academic subjects through ESY.
Total: $17,214.04 ordered
Key authorities
Rowley; Burlington; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Target Range; Student W. v. Puyallup; Clyde K. v. Puyallup; Roland M. v. Concord School Committee; Gregory K.; Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Schweiker v. McClure
People named in the decision
- Robert Roice, educational consultant representing District, Encinitas Union School District
- Dr. Beverly K. Barrett, director of pupil personnel services, Encinitas Union School District
- Bonnie Tierney, licensed educational psychologist, expert witness for Student, private practice
- Janna Carlson, private speech-language pathologist, expert witness for Student, private practice
- Joan Hewett (also spelled Hewitt), private pediatric audiologist; provided private aural habilitation, private practice
- Astrid Fisher, deaf and hard of hearing itinerant teacher, Encinitas Union School District
- Shirley Randall, special day class teacher and case carrier, Encinitas Union School District
- Susan Jordan, school psychologist, Encinitas Union School District
- Denise Hall, instructional aide, Encinitas Union School District
- Kathleen Shockney, second-grade general education teacher, Encinitas Union School District
- Kathryn Gibb, speech-language pathologist, Encinitas Union School District
- Dana Thurm, first-grade general education teacher, Encinitas Union School District
- Karen Ryan, first-grade speech-language therapist, Encinitas Union School District
- Erin Hyer, private speech-language pathologist (assessor), private practice
- Dr. Doris Trauner, neurologist, private
- Dr. Carren Stitka, independent psychological evaluator, private
- Lynn Kirsch, independent speech-language evaluator, private
- Lindamood-Bell, private reading clinic, private provider
- Children's Choices for Hearing and Talking Center (CCHAT), certified nonpublic school for deaf and hard of hearing children, nonpublic school
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Judith E. Ganz, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Encinitas, California, on March 2, 3, and 4, 2004. The Hearing Officer took additional testimony by telephone on March 9, 2004.
Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Judith Cohen. Also present on behalf of STUDENT were her parents, MOTHER and BIRTH MOTHER, her birth mother. Respondent Encinitas Union School District (Respondent or District) was represented at the hearing by educational consultant Robert Roice. Also present on behalf of the District was Dr. Beverly K. Barrett, the District’s director of pupil personnel services.
Petitioner questioned the witnesses called on behalf of the District. In addition, Petitioner called the following witnesses: Bonnie Tierney, licensed educational psychologist in private practice; Janna Carlson, private speech and language pathologist; Joan Hewitt, private pediatric audiologist; BIRTH MOTHER; MOTHER ; and STUDENT.
The District questioned the witnesses called on behalf of Student. In addition, the District called the following District employees: Astrid Fisher, deaf and hard of hearing itinerant teacher; Shirley Randall, STUDENT’s special day class teacher and case carrier; Susan Jordan, school psychologist; Denise Hall, STUDENT’s instructional aide; Kathleen Shockney, STUDENT’s second grade regular education teacher; Kathryn Gibb, speech and language pathologist; and Dr. Barrett.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following the parties’ oral closing arguments, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision. ISSUES (Footnote 1)
Issue No. 1: Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2002-2003 school year by failing to provide services designed to meet her unique need for aural habilitation?
Issue No. 2: If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year, are her parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private aural habilitation services they obtained?
Issue No. 3: Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year by failing to:
(A) provide the services of a trained one-on-one language facilitator designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs for aural habilitation;
(B) provide an intensive individualized reading program designed to remediate STUDENT’s deficits in the areas of phonological awareness and reading fluency;
(C) provide IEP goals and objectives designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in written expression; and (D) permit full parental participation in the IEP process?
Issue No. 4: If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year, are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for services they procured and to other remedies? (Footnote 2)
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Petitioner alleges a number of procedural and substantive violations of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and corresponding State special education law. For the 2002-2003 school year, Petitioner asserts that the District failed to provide aural habilitation services designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs as a deaf child with a cochlear implant. As a result of this failure, Petitioner’s parents seek reimbursement for the cost of private aural habilitation services they procured. The District argues that aural habilitation services were provided to STUDENT as an integral part of her school day and that because STUDENT was provided with a FAPE, no remedy is required.
For the 2003-2004 school year, Petitioner asserts the following: the District’s program was substantively inappropriate because the District failed to provide a one-on-one trained language facilitator to meet STUDENT’s aural habilitation needs, failed to provide an intensive individualized reading program that emphasized phonological awareness and reading fluency, and failed to provide written expression goals and objectives in STUDENT’s individualized education program (IEP). Procedurally, the District failed to consider the recommendations of the private evaluators STUDENT’s parents had retained and chilled their participation in the IEP process. Petitioner requests a trained one-on-one language facilitator to assist STUDENT in all academic subjects for a period of one year from the date of this Decision. STUDENT’s parents request reimbursement for private Lindamood-Bell reading program services they procured, and an order permitting STUDENT to complete the Lindamood-Bell program at District expense.
The District asserts the following: the reading program as well as the one-on-one instructional aide assistance the District provided for one hour each day met STUDENT’s unique needs. The IEP appropriately addresses STUDENT’s written expression needs. STUDENT’s parents were active participants in the IEP process. The District maintains that it provided STUDENT with a FAPE, and that Petitioner is entitled to no remedies.
PROCEDURAL MATTER
Motion to Recuse the Hearing Officer.
At the start of the hearing, the Hearing Officer informed the parties that, from 1974 through 1977, she was a special education teacher at a nonpublic school owned and administered by Ms. Cohen, the attorney for Petitioner. The Hearing Officer further advised the parties that she had had no personal or professional contact with Ms. Cohen since that time and she harbored no bias or prejudice toward either side. Respondent’s counsel moved to recuse the Hearing Officer arguing that because there were many other hearing officers who had not worked with Ms. Cohen, the Hearing Officer should be replaced. Petitioner’s counsel opposed the motion.
Under federal and State law, parties to a special education due process hearing are entitled to a fair and impartial administrative hearing before a person knowledgeable in the laws governing special education and administrative hearings. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(f)(1); Cal. Educ. Code § 56501(b)(4). Specifically, federal law provides that a hearing may not be conducted by a person who: (1) is an employee of the State educational agency (SEA) or the LEA involved in the education or care of the child or (2) has a personal or professional interest that would conflict with his or her objectivity in the hearing. 34 C.F.R. § 300.508(a). California Education Code section 56501(b)(4) provides that parties to a due process hearing have the right to a fair and impartial hearing. Government Code section 11425.40(a) provides that a presiding hearing officer is subject to disqualification for bias, prejudice, or interest in the proceeding.
The analysis of a challenge to the impartiality of a hearing officer must start with the presumption that hearing officers are unbiased. Schweiker v. McClure, 456 U.S. 188, 195, 102 S.Ct. 1665 (1982); McIntyre v. Santa Barbara County Employees’ Retirement System, Bd. of Retirement, 91 Cal.App.4th 730, 735 (2001). This presumption may be rebutted by a showing of conflict of interest or some other specific reason for disqualification, but the burden rests on the party making the assertion. Schweiker, 456 U.S. at 195; McIntyre, 91 Cal.App.4th at 735. An asserting party must allege facts demonstrating that the challenged judicial or quasi-judicial officers are contaminated with bias or prejudice. Andrews v. Agricultural Labor Relations Board, 28 Cal.3d 781, 792 (1981). Bias and prejudice are never implied; they must be clearly established. Id.
Here, Respondent’s counsel failed to allege sufficient facts to demonstrate that the Hearing Officer was biased or prejudiced, maintaining only that another hearing officer was preferred. The fact of a prior relationship, with no personal or professional contact for nearly three decades, failed to establish that the Hearing Officer had any bias, prejudice, or interest which would affect her ability to be fair and impartial in this case. Accordingly, the motion to recuse the Hearing Officer was denied.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is an eight-year-old (date of birth: [date redacted]) second-grader who is eligible for special education and related services because she is deaf/hard of hearing. STUDENT lives within the boundaries of the District with her parents. BIRTH MOTHER is a principal of an elementary school in the San Diego Unified School District. MOTHER is a credentialed teacher but is not teaching at the present time. STUDENT attends her neighborhood school, Olivenhain Pioneer Elementary School (OPE), in the regular education program, where she also receives special education and related services.
STUDENT was diagnosed with profound bilateral sensorineural hearing loss when she was fourteen months old. At age one and one half, STUDENT attended an early childhood parent education program for children with hearing loss that emphasized an aural/oral approach to communication, where she also received speech therapy. Hearing aids provided little benefit. At age two, STUDENT received a cochlear implant, but her response to speech and sound was less than anticipated. (Footnote 3) Beginning in March 1998, STUDENT attended the Children’s Choices for Hearing and Talking Center (CCHAT), a certified nonpublic school for deaf and hard of hearing children, that emphasized an aural/oral approach to communication. STUDENT participated in the parent/infant program and then attended the program’s preschool funded by the District. When STUDENT was three-years-old, additional mapping of the implant was performed. (Footnote 4) At age five, STUDENT was diagnosed with Landau-Kleffner Syndrome, a seizure disorder characterized by childhood aphasia. By age six, the cochlear implant was considered functional. The District conducted its initial assessment of STUDENT in 2001. For kindergarten (2001-2002 school year), the District offered to place STUDENT in a special day class, but her parents chose instead to continue STUDENT at CCHAT at their own expense.
For the first grade (2002-2003 school year), STUDENT’s parents asked that she attend the regular education program at the same neighborhood school (OPE) her sister attended. The individualized education program (IEP) team met in June 2002 to develop goals and objectives for the upcoming school year. STUDENT’s parents provided private psychoeducational (March 2002) and speech and language (June 2002) evaluations they had obtained, along with recommendations for goals and objectives. The tests revealed that STUDENT had superior to above average intelligence, but she had deficits in expressive language, auditory processing, and auditory memory. In August 2002, the District refused to place STUDENT at OPE and offered to place her in a special day class program at Magnolia Elementary School, a school for deaf and hard of hearing children located some distance away in Carlsbad. (District Exh. 6.)
On August 19, 2002, the IEP team met again to revisit the question of placement and services. The team was told that STUDENT had been diagnosed with Landau-Kleffner Syndrome and that the neurologist, Dr. Doris Trauner, recommended intensive speech and language therapy. The IEP team agreed to place STUDENT in a regular education first-grade class at OPE for thirty days and to provide speech and language therapy. According to the IEP meeting notes, STUDENT’s parents agreed to train the District staff regarding the cochlear implant and to bring an FM hearing system to be used by teachers and other students. (Footnote 5) The District’s Deaf and Hard of Hearing (DHH) specialist would be consulted upon her return from vacation. The IEP team planned to reconvene in thirty days to determine if the regular education program was appropriate for STUDENT and to review the level of services.
The IEP team meeting scheduled for September 18, 2002, was postponed because of STUDENT’s parents’ request that the District’s DHH itinerant teacher, Astrid Fisher, observe STUDENT in class. The IEP team reconvened on September 26, 2002. In addition to Ms. Fisher’s September 23, 2003, observation, the team reviewed Dr. Trauner’s recommendation for intensive speech and language therapy, as well as a private speech and language assessment obtained by STUDENT’s parents. The private speech pathologist reported STUDENT demonstrated significant expressive language delays and difficulties with articulation and intelligibility, and recommended speech and language therapy. The IEP team agreed to continue to mainstream STUDENT in the regular education first-grade class for ninety-five percent of the school day. Agreement was not reached on the goals and objectives; the amount of speech and language services to be provided; the degree of support, training, coordination and collaboration between the DHH itinerant teacher and other teaching staff; the percentage of time STUDENT would spend outside the classroom; or what modifications were necessary to improve the classroom’s acoustics.
On November 22, 2002, the IEP team met again, continuing its thirty-day review from August 19, 2002. The level of speech and language services offered was increased. Ms. Fisher developed a support plan to assist in using the FM equipment, and goals and objectives were agreed upon. The private audiologist assisting STUDENT, Joan Hewett, told the IEP team that STUDENT needed aural habilitation. The team agreed to discuss the need for instructional aide assistance in the classroom, the provision of additional speech and language services, and the classroom’s acoustics, at the next meeting.
The “thirty-day review” was completed on March 3, 2003. According to the IEP meeting notes, STUDENT was working hard but was not yet at grade level because of limitations in vocabulary and expressive language. STUDENT’s parents asked for two additional hours of after-school speech and language therapy each week by a private practitioner funded by the District, but the District refused. The District had recently increased instructional aide assistance. The acoustics of STUDENT’s classroom had been altered. The IEP team agreed to continue the placement as set out in the June 17, 2002 IEP, as amended in August and November, and to advance STUDENT’s annual and triennial review to April 2003. (Footnote 6)
The IEP team met on June 17, 2003, to develop STUDENT’s educational program for the second grade (2003-2004 school year). The team examined STUDENT’s first-grade goals and objectives, and finding continued areas of need in comprehension, pragmatics, syntax, articulation, and phonemic awareness, adopted the same goals for the upcoming school year. According to the IEP meeting notes, BIRTH MOTHER and MOTHER expressed concern that STUDENT was delayed in reading, writing and spelling, and asked for a full time classroom aide as well as three hours of speech and language therapy, each week. STUDENT’s parents also asked the District to identify someone with expertise in Landau-Kleffner Syndrome to assist in developing goals and to advise on services. The meeting was adjourned because of lack of time and was rescheduled for the beginning of the upcoming school year.
According to STUDENT’s parents, they received no response to their requests for expert assistance and additional services during the summer of 2003, so they informed the District that they intended to have STUDENT evaluated by Erin Hyer, a speech pathologist, experienced with deaf and hard of hearing children and Landau-Kleffner Syndrome. On July 29, 2003, in response to a second letter of inquiry from STUDENT’s parents, the District refused STUDENT’s parents’ request to fund Ms. Hyer’s evaluation. STUDENT was evaluated by Ms. Hyer on July 25, 2003, and assessed at a Lindamood-Bell clinic on August 22, 2003.
The 2003-2004 school year began in mid-August. On August 14, 2003, BIRTH MOTHER and MOTHER requested an emergency IEP meeting to review the private Hyer and Lindamood-Bell assessments and to complete goals on STUDENT’s IEP. At the August 29, 2003 IEP team meeting, the District members of the IEP team explained how, in their opinion, the proposed goals and objectives reflected the identified areas of need and the recommended goals of the private assessors. STUDENT’s parents requested additional time to review the District’s proposed goals. Another meeting was scheduled to finalize the goals and objectives and to discuss support services. District members of the IEP team agreed to consider conducting the three-year evaluation early, as well as consider STUDENT’s parents’ additional requests for Lindamood-Bell and language facilitator services. By letter dated September 10, 2003, the District refused these requests.
In September 2003, the District developed an assessment plan. On September 15, 2003, STUDENT’s parents made written notations on the evaluation plan form naming additional assessments they wanted performed, and then signed the document. Another IEP meeting was scheduled for September 19, 2003 to develop the three-year assessment plan and complete the IEP started in June 2003. However, on September 16, 2003, STUDENT’s parents informed the District that they did not consider another IEP meeting useful at that time because of their disagreements with the District over goals and services.
On September 19, 2003, the District wrote that it would not accept the “altered” assessment plan. In a letter dated October 2, 2003, the District informed STUDENT’s parents that it might request a due process hearing. On October 6, 2003, STUDENT’s parents enrolled STUDENT in the private Lindamood-Bell clinic program. The IEP team met again on November 12, 2003. The District presented a new unaltered assessment plan which MOTHER approved. According to the meeting notes, the goals and objectives for occupational and speech and language therapies were agreed upon. Classroom teacher assessments were shared. The program offer for the 2003-2004 regular school year and ESY included consultation by the occupational therapist, DHH itinerant teacher, and audiologist; speech and language therapy; and the assistance of an instructional aide in the classroom for thirty minutes every day. STUDENT’s parents reiterated their request for ten sessions of Lindamood-Bell services each week, and for one hour of private speech and language therapy each week. They asked for additional time to review the proposed goals and objectives and agreed to provide all or partial consent by November 17, 2003.
On December 16, 2003, STUDENT’s parents requested this due process hearing.
The District’s psychologist, Susan Jordan, conducted a psycho-educational assessment on December 10, 2003. On January 14, 2004, the District asked for more time to complete its assessment of STUDENT. The District’s speech pathologist assessed STUDENT over several days in January and February 2004. On February 20, 2004, STUDENT’s parents received the District’s assessments. BIRTH MOTHER and MOTHER informed the District that they preferred the hearing process over another IEP meeting. Approximately two weeks before the start of the due process hearing, the District increased STUDENT’s speech and language sessions from two to four times each week and reassigned STUDENT’s instructional aide to a two-hour block in the morning during the language arts period, replacing the aide’s one-half hour in the morning and one-half hour in the afternoon. No new IEP was developed.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue No. 1: Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2002-2003 school year by failing to provide services designed to meet her unique need for aural habilitation?
Under both federal and State special education law, all students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” (FAPE) means special education and related services that are available to the students at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet State educational standards, and that conform with the students’ individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). An IEP is a written statement that must be developed, reviewed, and revised for each child with a disability. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343, 56345. The IEP must include, among other things, a statement of the special education and related services to be provided to meet the student’s needs that result from his or her disability to enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345. An IEP is an educational package that must target all of a student’s unique educational needs, whether academic or nonacademic. Lenn v. Portland Sch. Comm., 998 F.2d 1083, 1089 (1st Cir. 1993). The term “unique educational needs” is to be broadly construed and includes the student’s academic, social, emotional, communicative, physical, and vocational needs. Seattle Sch. Dist. No 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that for a student to receive a FAPE, the student’s IEP must be designed to meet the unique needs of the student and be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or the best instruction or services that maximize the students’ abilities. Id., at 198-200. De minimus benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some benefit.” Walczak v. Florida Union School District, 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2nd Cir. 1998). A child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2nd Cir. 1997).
Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a student from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in regular education classes cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A): 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. The IDEA presumes that children with disabilities should be mainstreamed to the maximum extent appropriate. See 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56364. The District has the burden of proof at the administrative hearing that it complied with the IDEA. Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist. No 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994).
The term “related services,” referred to as designated instruction and services (DIS) in California, means transportation and such developmental, corrective, and other supportive services as may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education, including counseling and guidance. Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(b)(1)(5)(9); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). The list of related services is not exhaustive and may include other developmental, corrective, or supportive services if they are required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 34 C.F.R. § 300.14; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3001(z). Special education and related services must be tailored to meet the unique needs of the child with a disability. Polk v. Central Susquehana Intermediate Unit 16, 853 F.2d 171, 173 (3rd Cir. 1988); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(3); 34 C.F.R. § 300.24.
For the 2002-2003 school year, Petitioner’s counsel alleges that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide aural habilitation services. The parties generally agree that because STUDENT was born deaf but then two years later received a cochlear implant, she has a unique need for aural habilitation services. Petitioner asserts that the District’s program lacked specific aural habilitation goals and therefore was not designed to meet her unique needs or reasonably calculated to provide her with educational benefit. The District argues that aural habilitation services were delivered as an “integral part” of her program throughout the school day.
The Hearing Officer will turn first to a discussion of STUDENT’s unique need for aural habilitation. (Footnote 7) The Hearing Officer will then examine whether the District’s program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique need for aural habilitation and reasonably calculated to provide her with educational benefit.
A. STUDENT’s unique need for aural habilitation.
A child like STUDENT, who is born profoundly deaf and then receives a cochlear implant, does not develop normal hearing. According to Janna Carlson, a private California licensed speech pathologist possessing advanced degrees and training regarding cochlear implants, the sound a person hears with a cochlear implant has been described as akin to “an out-of-tune radio station.” Ms. Carlson explained that individuals with a cochlear implant require aural habilitation training in order to understand what they are hearing. (Footnote 8)
Joan Hewett is a licensed pediatric audiologist, with a bachelor’s degree in psychology and a master’s degree in teaching the deaf, expecting to complete her doctorate in audiology in August 2004. She taught deaf children from pre-school through kindergarten and has been a DHH itinerant teacher. She has also directed a program for deaf and hard of hearing students for ten years, and since 1995, while in private practice, has had extensive experience working with children with cochlear implants. Ms. Hewett has known STUDENT for a considerable period of time, having first met STUDENT when she attended the parent-toddler program. Ms. Hewett privately assessed STUDENT in August 2002, provided individual sessions of aural habilitation services to STUDENT from September 2002 through August 2003, and recently met with STUDENT on February 26, 2004. Ms. Hewett and Ms. Carlson testified that aural habilitation teaches the brain to hear, to identify and attach meaning to a sound, and then to attach language to the sounds. In order to follow instructions or learn concepts from a classroom teacher, STUDENT has to learn to listen. She has to detect and discriminate the sounds, hear a word, understand the word, attach meaning to the word, and then hold the word or words in her memory. The acquisition of language in this manner improves STUDENT’s articulation and communication. Both Ms. Hewett and Ms. Carlson testified that STUDENT, as a child with a cochlear implant, needs aural habilitation, as described above.
The District agreed. Before the September 2002 IEP meeting, Astrid Fisher, the District’s DHH itinerant teacher, observed STUDENT in her first-grade class that had begun in mid-August 2002. Ms. Fisher then reported to the IEP team that STUDENT exhibited difficulty receiving, retaining, and applying information presented orally by her classroom teacher. Other information available to the IEP team when it developed STUDENT’s program for the 2002-2003 school year were private evaluations obtained by STUDENT’s parents that corroborated Ms. Fisher’s classroom observations. Both Dr. Carren Stitka, who conducted an independent psychological evaluation in March 2002, and Lynn Kirsch, who conducted an independent speech and language evaluation in June 2002, concluded that STUDENT evidenced significant difficulty remembering information that was presented orally. Dr. Stitka recommended that all staff working with STUDENT be specially trained in the needs of deaf children with cochlear implants and learn to be familiar with STUDENT’s aural/oral means of communication. Ms. Hewett told the IEP team in November 2002 that STUDENT needed aural habilitation services. In addition to these evaluations, Ms. Fisher acknowledged that “aural habilitation is an important requirement” for a child with a cochlear implant. From the undisputed testimony of the witnesses from both sides, the Hearing Officer finds that aural habilitation is a critical area of need in order for STUDENT to understand concepts taught in her regular education classroom as well as to improve her ability to communicate.
B. The program offer.
The program provided to STUDENT for the 2002-2003 school year was developed over the course of many months at several IEP meetings held on June 17, 2002, August 19, 2002, September 26, 2002, November 22, 2002, and finally completed on March 3, 2003. It was not until late September that the District first agreed to place STUDENT at OPE, her neighborhood school, with supportive services. When the IEP team agreed to mainstream STUDENT, Ms. Fisher joined the IEP team to assist in developing goals and objectives and to provide on-going consultation to staff.
According to the undisputed testimony of Ms. Hewett, in November 2002 Ms. Fisher and the District’s audiologist told the rest of the IEP team that aural habilitation services should be provided. However, according to Ms. Hewett, no specific aural habilitation goals were drafted because the District’s speech and language therapist, Karen Ryan, thought that the existing goals were sufficient to encompass STUDENT’s needs in this area. The IEP included goals and objectives in the areas of language comprehension, pragmatics, syntax, articulation, phonemic awareness, repetition of sequence of words, and recognition of symbols and sounds. The program also included speech and language services in the amount of one half-hour of small group, one half-hour of individualized speech and language therapy, and one half-hour of social skills each week. (Footnote 9) Ms. Fisher developed a “support plan” that addressed the testing and use of STUDENT’s hearing equipment. STUDENT was “pulled out” of her classroom and taken to the special education room for one-half hour each day during silent reading. (Footnote10) Sometime in the middle of her first-grade year, STUDENT was provided with one-half hour of instructional aide services in her classroom.
The Hearing Officer will now determine whether the program offered for the 2002-2003 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique need for aural habilitation and reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit.
C. Was the District’s program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique need for aural habilitation and provide her with some educational benefit?
1. Program designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. As stated above, the District agreed that STUDENT needed aural habilitation services. DHH itinerant teacher, Ms. Fisher, admitted that the IEP did not contain specific aural habilitation goals and objectives but testified that aural habilitation services had been provided to STUDENT as an integral part of her school day by her speech and language therapist, instructional aide, and classroom teacher. However, for the 2002-2003 school year, the “thirty-day” review of STUDENT’s program took nearly seven months from when it began in mid-August 2002. Over the course of the school year, the IEP was, at best, a work in progress. In fact, notes from as late as the March 3, 2003 IEP team meeting indicated only that the staff intended to “try to incorporate [aural habilitation] into [STUDENT’s] school program.” (District Exh. 11; emphasis added.)
Moreover, Ms. Ryan, STUDENT’s first-grade speech therapist who had recommended to the IEP team that no specific goals for aural habilitation were necessary, had no experience working with a child with cochlear implants. STUDENT received therapy from Ms. Ryan twice a week, for thirty minutes each session. Because Ms. Ryan did not testify, there was no first-hand evidence regarding whether or how she provided aural habilitation. STUDENT’s current speech therapist, Kathryn Gibb, reviewed Ms. Ryan’s notes and testified that Ms. Ryan taught listening skills using a computer program called Earobics. (Footnote 11) Ms. Ryan’s notes did not demonstrate, however, that the Earobics program was used on a regular basis, and instead those notes indicated that in a two and one-half month period, Earobics was used only six times. Moreover, Ms. Gibb conceded on cross-examination that Earobics is not a program designed for children with a cochlear implant. On the basis of the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the speech and language therapist did not appropriately address STUDENT’s need for aural habilitation.
Further, although the record is not completely clear, it appears that STUDENT was not provided with one-on-one instructional aide services until sometime in the middle of her first- grade year. (Student Exh. 5; Testimony of Randall.) Denise Hall, who worked as STUDENT’s instructional aide from the middle of the first grade, testified that she had no communication with STUDENT’s speech therapist during the 2002-2003 school year. (Footnote 12)In addition, according to Ms. Hall, DHH itinerant teacher Ms. Fisher’s training of Ms. Hall emphasized the use and testing of STUDENT’s hearing equipment. Ms. Fisher testified that she only provided an “in-service” to Ms. Hall for thirty minutes and formally observed Ms. Hall on three occasions. Thereafter, Ms. Fisher informally provided pointers to Ms. Hall. Testing of STUDENT’s hearing equipment was only a part of the services STUDENT required. As found above, STUDENT’s unique needs included learning to “listen” so she could attach meaning to the sounds she heard. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s training of Ms. Hall failed to adequately address the instructional components of aural habilitation services and concludes that Ms. Hall was not trained to provide aural habilitation services to STUDENT.
Further, Ms. Hall testified that beginning in the middle of the first-grade school year, she worked with STUDENT for only thirty minutes each day. (Footnote 13) Ms. Hall frequently sat with STUDENT during a class reading lesson and helped her identify the many words she missed, and also helped STUDENT with writing assignments. Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that while the assistance of an instructional aide was a significant and necessary part of STUDENT’s program, Ms. Hall’s assistance was not equivalent to aural habilitation services, described above. Finally, according to STUDENT’s first-grade teacher, Dana Thurm, although Ms. Fisher taught her how to use the hearing equipment, it was BIRTH MOTHER, not trained or credentialed District staff, who taught Ms. Thurm how to ask comprehension questions and check that STUDENT understood the lesson. Ms. Thurm did not testify that she provided aural habilitation to STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds that, like Ms. Hall, Ms. Thurm neither provided, nor was trained to provide, aural habilitation services to STUDENT.
In sum, the weight of the evidence established that the District neither provided specific aural habilitation goals nor included such services or adequate training for such services within its existing program. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s critical area of need for aural habilitation.
2. Reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. As found above, aural habilitation was a critical area of need for STUDENT in order to help her understand the concepts taught orally in the classroom, as well as to help her communicate. As Ms. Hewett explained, STUDENT did not bring the same vocabulary, language, and conceptual background to learning new concepts, as her hearing peers. Indeed, both federal and State special education laws require that deaf or hard-of-hearing students receive such services as will assist the student to utilize their mode of communication. In order to provide an “appropriate” education for a deaf or hard-of-hearing child in the least restrictive environment, the IEP team is required to consider “the related services and program options that provide the pupil with an equal opportunity for communication access.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(d); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.346(a)(2)(iv). Related services include “[a]udiology” and in relevant part “[p]rovision of habilitative activities, such as language habilitation, auditory training, speech reading, hearing evaluation, and speech conservation.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.24(b)(1)(iii). Because aural habilitation is a critical area of need that affected STUDENT’s performance in all academic areas as well as her ability to communicate, and because the District failed significantly to address that critical area of need, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.
Thus, to the extent the District’s program for the 2002-2003 school year was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs for aural habilitation and thereby was not reasonably calculated to provide her with educational benefit, STUDENT was denied a FAPE.
Issue No. 2: If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year, are her parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the private aural habilitation services they obtained?
As found above, the District failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year. STUDENT’s parents request reimbursement for the private aural habilitation services they obtained for STUDENT from Ms. Hewett in the period from September 2002 through August 31, 2003.
Parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they procured for their child as “appropriate relief” where, as here, the responsible school district denies the child a FAPE. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i). Equitable considerations are relevant in determining relief under the IDEA. Burlington, 472 U.S. at 374. The Burlington rule of reimbursement is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parent are found to be the exact proper placement or services required under the IDEA. Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (6th Cir. 1986). Although the parent’s placement does not have to meet a standard as high as school districts must meet under the IDEA, the parent’s placement must still meet the student’s needs and provide the student some educational benefit. Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13 (1993).
Turning to whether the private services met STUDENT’s need for aural habilitation and provided STUDENT with some educational benefit, Ms. Hewett testified that she provided individual aural habilitation services, one hour each week, to STUDENT from September 2002 through the end of August 2003. Ms. Hewett testified that hearing children learn vocabulary and language through hearing themselves babble and listening to others. During her sessions with STUDENT, Ms. Hewett’s goal was for STUDENT to learn to use listening as a learning modality as hearing children do. According to Ms. Hewett, STUDENT made great progress using listening to articulate, understanding the sounds she heard, and modeling her speech after what others said. Ms. Hewett observed emerging skills in the areas of using context to understand the meaning of a new word, asking for help, and listening to correct her own language. According to teacher reports in May 2003, although STUDENT continued to exhibit difficulties, it was noted that STUDENT demonstrated increased participation in class discussions. Ms. Hall testified that she observed improvement over the course of the school year, insofar as STUDENT more frequently asked for help from her classmates and modeled some of her actions after her peers. Because, as found above, the District completely failed to provide aural habilitation services, the Hearing Officer attributes these gains to the private services STUDENT received, and concludes that the services met STUDENT’s need for aural habilitation and STUDENT derived some educational benefit from them.
Accordingly, upon receipt of an invoice or proof of payment, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the aural habilitation services provided to STUDENT by Ms. Hewett from September 2002 through August 31, 2003, in the amount $ 4507.04. (Footnote 14)
Issue No. 3: Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year by failing to: (A) provide the services of a trained one-on-one language facilitator designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs for aural habilitation; (B) provide an intensive individualized reading program designed to remediate STUDENT’s deficits in the areas of phonological awareness and reading fluency; (C) provide IEP goals and objectives designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in written expression; and (D) permit full parental participation in the IEP process?
STUDENT has several areas of need, all arising from her hearing deficits and use of her cochlear implant. The parties agree that she needs services to address aural habilitation, and to address her deficits in phonological awareness, reading fluency, and written expression. However, the parties disagree whether the services offered by the District for the 2003-2004 regular school year and ESY were designed to meet these areas of need and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit. (Footnote 15) Before examining the District’s program and determining whether or not that program was appropriate, it will first be helpful to examine STUDENT’s unique needs in greater detail.
STUDENT’S UNIQUE NEEDS.
The parties generally agree that STUDENT has above average intelligence and the cognitive ability to progress in the general curriculum. By all accounts, STUDENT is a skillful athlete, well liked by her peers and teachers, and highly motivated to try her best. The District staff noted growth in socialization and adjustment to her new school during STUDENT’s first-grade year (2002-2003). The Hearing Officer turns first to a discussion of STUDENT’s unique needs within the context of Petitioner’s contentions. (Footnote 16)
Aural habilitation. As in the previous school year (2002-2003), it is undisputed that STUDENT’s hearing impairment and adjustment to “listening” with a cochlear implant affects both her ability to access the general curriculum as well as to communicate. STUDENT still has difficulty receiving information orally, and retaining and applying that information. Thus, the parties agree that STUDENT’s need for aural habilitation services persists. According to the DHH itinerant teacher, Ms. Fisher, STUDENT has a “way to go” in this area of need. (Footnote 17) The parties agree that STUDENT’s hearing equipment must be monitored to assure that the cochlear implant is functional and the FM system is used correctly.
The evidence established that STUDENT has difficulty comprehending curriculum concepts and vocabulary used in a lesson presented in the classroom. Both a “present levels of achievement” form dated at the end of STUDENT’s first-grade year in May 2003 and a June 2003 teacher progress report, indicated that STUDENT had weaknesses with story problems or “anything [involving] language” in the area of mathematics. STUDENT’s second-grade teacher Kathleen Shockney, testified that STUDENT continues to demonstrate difficulty with vocabulary. Although Ms. Fisher testified that STUDENT appeared to understand the concepts in the academic subject areas covered in the afternoon, the same June 2003 teacher progress report indicated that in history/social studies, STUDENT was only just approaching grade level. Ms. Hall testified that she kept a record of words that STUDENT failed to comprehend in these subject areas and had to send them home so that STUDENT’s parents could assist her. In addition, STUDENT needs help understanding teacher instructions. STUDENT’s first-grade teacher reported at the end of May 2003 that STUDENT often did not focus during oral instructions. Ms. Shockney testified that STUDENT continues to frequently ask for clarification and for instructions to be repeated.
As a result of these deficits, the parties generally agree that in order for STUDENT to access the curriculum, she needs a trained one-on-one aide in the classroom. According to Ms. Fisher and instructional aide Denise Hall, STUDENT needs an aide to preview and review lessons, practice curriculum vocabulary, and focus STUDENT’s attention on the teacher and teacher’s instructions. Both private speech pathologist Ms. Carlson and private audiologist Ms. Hewett generally agreed that STUDENT needs the assistance described by Ms. Fisher and Ms. Hall, adding that STUDENT needs help to write words STUDENT does not know and to express for her what she is unable to hear. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that in order to meet STUDENT’s deficits in the area of aural habilitation, STUDENT needs monitoring of her hearing equipment, as well as the assistance of a one-on-one trained aide in the classroom, to perform the above-described activities. (Footnote 18)
Phonological awareness and reading fluency. STUDENT’s first-grade teacher, Dana Thurm testified that at the end of first grade, STUDENT had no phonetic skills and relied only on a sight word attack approach to reading. In developing STUDENT’s program for the 2003-2004 school year, in addition to Ms. Thurm’s year-end progress report, the IEP team also had available to it two private evaluations obtained by STUDENT’s parents. Erin Hyer, a private speech and language pathologist who was also experienced with Landau-Kleffner Syndrome, assessed STUDENT in July 2003. Bonnie Tierney, a private licensed and credentialed educational psychologist and nation-wide trainer of teachers in literacy who possessed significant experience with language delayed students, reviewed Ms. Hyer’s report and testified that in July 2003, STUDENT was far below her age level in all areas of phonological awareness. The second private assessment was administered by the Lindamood-Bell clinic on August 22, 2003, when STUDENT was seven years, eight months old, and had completed the first grade. On the word attack subtest of the Woodcock-Reading Mastery Test -NU, STUDENT scored in the eleventh percentile, well below the average range (twenty-fifth through seventh-fifth percentile) and at the beginning first-grade level. STUDENT evidenced difficulty perceiving groups of sounds and corresponding letter symbols when or where a letter was added, substituted, omitted, or shifted in a syllable. According to the Lindamood-Bell assessor’s report, these weaknesses contributed to problems with word attack and word recognition. Thus, based on the above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs a program that emphasizes phonological awareness skills. (Footnote 19)
The evidence also established that STUDENT had unique needs in the area of reading fluency. Ms. Thurm indicated on her June 2003 progress report that STUDENT was only “approaching grade level standard” in the area of reading fluency. STUDENT’s second-grade teacher, Ms. Shockney, testified that STUDENT’s reading fluency rate of sixty-five words per minute was below grade level (seventy-eight to one-hundred-six words per minute) and identified reading fluency as an area of need. The private August 2003 Lindamood-Bell assessment results were consistent with these teacher reports. On the Gray Reading Oral Reading Test 4, STUDENT scored at the second percentile in accuracy, fluency, and comprehension, and in the second percentile in reading rate, all below the beginning first-grade level. Private speech pathologist Ms. Carlson testified that because STUDENT was unable to read with sufficient speed, her ability to comprehend what she read was adversely affected.
As STUDENT entered the second grade, there was some dispute about the reading level she had achieved. According to written progress reports prepared at the end of first-grade, STUDENT was able to read in the middle of the first-grade level independently, and at a somewhat higher reading level with prompts and support. However, STUDENT’s first grade-teacher, Ms. Thurm, acknowledged that on the last grading period in June 2003, she found it difficult to grade STUDENT on her reading assessments and had not counted certain errors because she was “rooting for” STUDENT. Ms. Thurm admitted that had she graded STUDENT accurately, STUDENT would have been ranked at the same level as when she started the first grade, that is at a pre-primer or beginning reader level. Ms. Thurm also testified that STUDENT read by sight and had no other word attack skills. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by Ms. Thurm’s candid assessment and finds that despite STUDENT’s above average cognitive ability, she was still a beginning reader at the end of first grade. The Hearing Officer concludes therefore that STUDENT needs intensive intervention in the areas of phonological awareness and reading fluency to address these delays.
From the first-hand observations of MOTHER and Ms. Fisher, the evidence also established that STUDENT demonstrates difficulty learning reading when the lesson is presented in a large group format and therefore she needs small group or individualized teacher instruction. MOTHER volunteered in STUDENT’s classroom during the first-grade year over three hours each week, and observed that during choral reading, STUDENT did not participate. MOTHER also noted that when the teacher asked questions about the story, STUDENT failed to respond. MOTHER’s testimony was corroborated by observations of DHH itinerant teacher, Ms. Fisher, who observed STUDENT during a reading lesson on October 6, 2003. Ms. Fisher noted that STUDENT’s attention was deteriorating, that she was not doing as much as before, and that she exhibited many comprehension problems. (Footnote 20)
The Hearing Officer concludes, on the basis of the above, that STUDENT needs an intensive and individualized reading program with an emphasis on phonological awareness and reading fluency, taught in a small-group or one-on-one format, to remediate her deficits in these areas. Private educational psychologist, Bonnie Tierney, testified persuasively that reading may serve as a valuable compensatory strategy to help STUDENT attach meaning to words and sounds, as well as to improve her articulation and to use correct word endings. Thus, development of phonological awareness skills and reading with fluency takes on heightened importance as STUDENT learns to “listen” with a cochlear implant.
Written expression. On the progress reports prepared at the end of the first grade in May and June 2003, it was reported that in written language, STUDENT has difficulty with sentence structure, verb tenses and verb endings and that she needs help with spelling. Private audiologist, Ms. Hewett, testified that these deficits arose from STUDENT’s hearing impairment. Thus, for example, STUDENT had particular problems using the past tense. Ms. Hewett explained that STUDENT omits “-ed” on the end of a word in a writing assignment because STUDENT may not be hearing the “t” sound at the end of “dropped” or “walked.” STUDENT’s aide, Ms. Hall, testified that STUDENT is a “great writer” and that although STUDENT needs her help, STUDENT only requires “minimal” assistance. However, Ms. Hall acknowledged that STUDENT needs help replacing missing words and adding word endings. Dr. Beverly Barrett, director of pupil personnel services for the District, observed STUDENT during a classroom writing session in February 2004, and testified that STUDENT could “self-correct” with the “help” of her aide. MOTHER and Ms. Tierney observed STUDENT during the same classroom writing session and testified that STUDENT needs assistance from her classroom aide to write in her journal. STUDENT’s second-grade teacher, Ms. Shockney, testified that STUDENT is becoming expressive in her writing, but still needs help with sentence structure, word order, and tense agreement. The Hearing Officer finds that the testimony of the witnesses from both sides was essentially consistent and, on the basis of the above, finds that STUDENT has unique needs in the area of written expression.
* * * * * * In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s hearing deficits and adjustment to hearing with her cochlear implant manifested in unique needs in the areas of aural habilitation, phonological awareness and reading fluency, and written expression. STUDENT needs a program that provides a trained one-on-one instructional aide, an intensive individualized reading program taught in a small-group or one-on-one format to remedy her deficits in phonological awareness and reading fluency, and assistance with written expression.
THE PROGRAM OFFER.
The District’s offer of placement was described in the June 17, 2003, August 29, 2003, and November 12, 2003 IEPs. (Footnote 21) The program included placement in the second-grade regular education class with designated instructional services as follows: fifteen ten-minute occupational therapist consultations, sixty thirty-minute DHH itinerant teacher consultations, thirty sixty-minute individual speech and language sessions, thirty sixty-minute group speech and language sessions, and two thirty-minute audiologist consultations, all to be provided from November 12, 2003, through June 6, 2004. The offer included the extended school year, and instructional aide services in the amount of one-half hour in the morning and one-half hour in the afternoon, everyday. Because STUDENT had not successfully met her first-grade goals, the same goals and objectives were carried over but modified to the extent that they were meant to incorporate the second-grade curriculum level.
STUDENT’s annual goals set forth in her 2003-2004 IEP were to: improve her understanding and usage of the language of classroom material; adopt or change her oral language to fit the situation by following rules of conversations with peers; improve her understanding and usage of the structure of language in the classroom; use corrected speech sounds; when shown four letters or numbers for five seconds, reproduce the identical sequence of letters; read fifty words using phonemic awareness and rhyming skills; select a word or words and compose a multi-word sentence using correct pronunciation, word tense and meaning; listen critically and respond appropriately to oral communication during thirty minutes of classroom time; follow procedures to use an FM system independently throughout the school day; and improve her ability to isolate tongue and jaw movements through oral-motor strengthening exercises.
The Hearing Officer will next examine, within the context of Petitioner’s contentions set out above as Issue 3 (A) through (D) whether the program offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide her with educational benefit.
A. Provide the services of a trained one-on-one language facilitator designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs for aural habilitation.
As stated above, the parties do not dispute that STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of aural habilitation persisted for the 2003-2004 school year. As also stated above, the parties agree that in order to meet this area of need, STUDENT requires the assistance of a one-on-one aide. Petitioner asserts that, as in the previous school year, the IEP lacked goals and objectives targeted to aural habilitation and that STUDENT required the services of a trained “language facilitator” during all academic instruction in order to meet her needs. The District argues that there is no difference between the language facilitator Petitioner requests and the instructional aide assistance the District provides. The District adds that STUDENT’s aural habilitation needs were met because two weeks before the start of the due process hearing, STUDENT’s aide time was increased, from one-half hour in the morning and one-half hour in the afternoon, to a two-hour block in the morning during the language arts period. It disagrees that STUDENT needs an aide for other academic subject areas. The Hearing Officer will address each of these contentions.
Goals and objectives. As in the previous school year, the IEP did not address aural habilitation. Annual goal number 10 in the 2003-2004 IEP to “listen critically” was targeted to classroom behaviors such as turn-taking, not speaking in a loud volume, not interrupting, and using words instead of gestures or sounds. Neither this goal nor any others specifically addressed aural habilitation, as described above. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP was deficient with respect to the provision of goals and objectives addressing aural habilitation.
Services of a “language facilitator.” The services of an instructional assistant constitute a supportive service that must be provided when necessary for a student with exceptional needs to benefit from his or her instructional program. See 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(a). Petitioner maintains that STUDENT needs the services of a “language facilitator” for all academic subjects. Petitioner also asserts that the language facilitator requires additional training, needs to monitor STUDENT’s progress and devise a record-keeping system, and should coordinate her efforts with other members of STUDENT’s team. The District argues that one-hour of instructional aide assistance every day provides sufficient support.
Petitioner’s counsel defined a “language facilitator” as a trained aide who facilitates communication within the educational environment by redirecting the student’s attention, previewing a new unit, focusing on vocabulary and language content, implementing teacher direction by pointing, locating or repeating strategy, previewing contents of and providing a narration of a movie, facilitating peer interaction, enhancing language acquisition, and providing a language model. (Footnote 22)
Addressing Petitioner’s first contention regarding STUDENT needing a language facilitator in all subjects, the parties generally agreed that STUDENT needed a trained one-on-one instructional aide to preview and review lessons, practice curriculum vocabulary, clarify teacher instructions, write words STUDENT did not know, and express for her what she was unable to hear. STUDENT’s instructional aide, Ms. Hall, testified that while she was in the classroom for one-half hour in the morning, she repeated teacher directions, helped STUDENT focus on written assignments, and reviewed vocabulary words. During the one-half hour that she removed STUDENT from the classroom in the afternoon, Ms. Hall previewed the lesson for the next day and identified vocabulary words STUDENT needed to practice.
However, as found above, STUDENT demonstrated weaknesses with concepts and vocabulary and understanding instructions in all academic areas of the curriculum. These subjects were presented over the course of the entire school day, including when Ms. Hall was not present. Neither Ms. Hall’s one hour with STUDENT as provided in the IEP, nor Ms. Hall’s recent reassignment to a two-hour block in the morning, allowed Ms. Hall to preview and review curriculum concepts and vocabulary or to clarify directions during all periods of academic instruction. Notably, Ms. Hall identified vocabulary words that proved difficult for STUDENT, but sent these words home for STUDENT to practice with her parents. While home assistance can reinforce ideas or concepts learned in school, parental assistance may not replace the District’s obligation to provide STUDENT with a FAPE. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that due to her limited availability, Ms. Hall was unable to perform the duties of a language facilitator designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of aural habilitation. Because a language facilitator was needed for all academic subjects, the instructional aide assistance provided by the District was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. Further, the Hearing Officer observes that far from isolating her from her peers as the District witnesses feared, a language facilitator provided during all of STUDENT’s academic subjects would help STUDENT communicate with her general education peers, consistent with least restrictive environment principles.
The Hearing Officer will next address Petitioner’s remaining contentions regarding the instructional aide, namely that the District’s instructional aide was not sufficiently trained, failed to maintain accurate records or coordinate her efforts with other members of the District staff. According to Petitioner, a language facilitator is trained in aural habilitation theory and the use of cochlear implants, monitors comprehension, and documents problems in written logs or reports. The language facilitator also acts as a liaison between the DHH itinerant teacher and classroom teacher, participates in developing academic goals, and oversees the daily maintenance of assistive devices.
The training provided to Ms. Hall was limited to a short “in-service” and intermittent “coaching” by Ms. Fisher. Further, Ms. Hall received no input or training from STUDENT’s speech and language therapist regarding STUDENT’s language acquisition. While not formally made part of the written placement at issue in this due process hearing (see Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994)), the Hearing Officer observes that two weeks before the due process hearing, Ms. Hall started to accompany STUDENT to her speech therapy sessions. Ms. Gibb testified that she has begun to teach Ms. Hall how to help STUDENT speak in complete sentences, use correct pronouns, and implement the goals and objectives in STUDENT’s IEP. While Ms. Hall’s observation of Ms. Gibb is a starting point, the Hearing Officer finds that the instructional aide requires more input and training from the speech therapist, audiologist and DHH itinerant teacher, to learn how a student like STUDENT with a cochlear implant uses language and “listens.” Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that, having received no training from STUDENT’s speech and language therapist, and only a short “in-service” from Ms. Fisher, the instructional aide was not adequately trained.
With regard to record-keeping and coordinating Ms. Hall’s efforts with other District staff, STUDENT’s case carrier, Shirley Randall, testified that the speech therapist did not review the aides’ “logs.” In any event, Ms. Hall testified that the only logs she kept were time records. Moreover, there was no evidence Ms. Hall collected data noting particular problems associatedwith STUDENT’s listening skills, and no evidence she ever communicated even her informal observations to Ms. Gibb, STUDENT’s second-grade speech therapist. In fact, Ms. Hall testified that during STUDENT’s first grade (2002-2003), she had no contact with STUDENT’s speech therapist at all. DHH itinerant teacher, Ms. Fisher, kept only random notes. Ms. Fisher testified that as of the time of the due process hearing in March 2004, although she has some sort of conversation “in passing” with STUDENT’s teacher, she had not spoken to STUDENT’s general education teacher, and had only met with Ms. Gibb three times since the start of the school year (mid-August 2003).
According to the persuasive testimony of private audiologist Ms. Hewett, if the aide, therapist, and teacher had each noted consistent problems with a particular sound, collaboration might have indicated a need for remapping of STUDENT’s cochlear implant or helped identify an area of academic need. For example, if one member of the team noted that STUDENT was not hearing the “k” sound and was unable to hear the difference between “car” and “tar,” the implant might have been remapped to enable STUDENT to hear the correct sound. In addition the team could have determined whether the problem was related to STUDENT’s failure to comprehend the meanings of “car” or “tar.” Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that record-keeping and coordination of services is necessary to meet STUDENT’s needs to monitor and correct the functioning of her hearing equipment, to help STUDENT adjust to her cochlear implant, and to identify areas of academic need. The Hearing Officer further finds that the instructional aide did not collect or maintain sufficient data either to monitor STUDENT’s progress or to provide a means to coordinate her efforts with STUDENT’s credentialed therapists and teachers.
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP did not include goals and objectives in the area of aural habilitation. Further, the District failed to assign a trained instructional aide for all academic subjects, failed to develop record keeping methods to objectively measure STUDENT’s progress, and failed to coordinate the instructional aide’s services with the members of STUDENT’s team. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that in the area of aural habilitation and need for a one-on-one instructional aide, the District’s program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and was not reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit. To that extent, STUDENT was denied a FAPE. The IEP shall be amended to include goals and objectives in the area of aural habilitation. Although the nomenclature is not determinative, in order to implement these goals, the District shall identify, arrange and provide the services of a trained one-on-one instructional aide to perform the duties of the “language facilitator” described above, and these services shall be provided in all academic subjects for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year, including the ESY. The instructional aide shall receive training from the speech therapist, audiologist, and the DHH itinerant teacher, or such other formal training which the IEP team may designate, in aural habilitation and teaching a child with a cochlear implant to “listen.” Consistent and coordinated record keeping methods shall be devised in order to objectively measure STUDENT’s progress. Once the IEP is properly amended to add aural habilitation goals, proper record-keeping will provide an accurate means to objectively measure STUDENT’s progress on the benchmarks and short-term objectives.
B. Provide an intensive individualized reading program designed to remediate STUDENT’s deficits in the areas of phonological awareness and reading fluency.
Petitioner alleges that the District’s program was deficient for failing to provide an intensive individualized reading program that emphasizes phonological awareness and reading fluency, such as the Lindamood-Bell program, where STUDENT’s parents privately enrolled STUDENT in October 2003. The District asserts its offer was appropriate because its second-grade reading curriculum targets phonics. In addition, according to the District, the IEP goals address phonological awareness, and STUDENT received the support of an instructional aide to practice word attack skills. The District also cited STUDENT’s progress in reading and maintained that her reading level at the end of first grade was consistent with her language delays.
The focus of inquiry in a FAPE analysis concerns the appropriateness of the District’s program and not whether the program preferred by STUDENT’s parents, such as Lindamood-Bell, would be a better program. See Gregory K. While parents may prefer a particular methodology for their child and believe it would confer more educational benefit on her than would the program offered by a school district, the law requires the district “to provide an appropriate placement, not the best possible placement. Moreover, when a district is providing an appropriate placement, the parents do not have the right to compel the district to provide a particular educational program or methodology.” See Roland M. v. Concord School Committee, 910 F.2d 983 (1st Cir. 1990).
Thus, the Hearing Officer turns to whether the District’s program was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs in the areas of phonological awareness and reading fluency. STUDENT’s second-grade teacher, Ms. Shockney, testified that she used the second-grade Houghton-Mifflin basal reading program which employed a phonics word attack approach. Although there was no dispute that STUDENT used only a sight word attack approach to reading and needed to develop phonetic word attack skills, Ms. Shockney testified that the District’s reading program only used a phonics library twice a week.
Examining the 2003-2004 IEP, the Hearing Officer observes that two goals in the IEP appear to address phonemic awareness skills. Nevertheless, the Hearing Officer finds persuasive Petitioner’s additional contention that these goals lacked data-supported baselines and objectively measurable benchmarks. The IEP for each child with a disability must include a statement of the child’s present levels of educational performance and a statement of measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives. 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56534(a). Measurable annual goals are “critical to the strategic planning process used to develop and implement the IEP for each child with a disability” and enable the child’s teachers, parents, and others involved in developing and implementing the child’s IEP to measure during the year if the child is making progress toward meeting the annual goal. 34 C.F.R. App. A to Part 300, Q.1.
Specifically, annual goal number six provides that “by annual review, STUDENT will improve in her ability to perceive letter sounds within words and perform at her curriculum level +80% in phonemic awareness skills with adults.” As private educational psychologist Ms. Tierney persuasively testified, there is no way to ascertain in goal six how many sounds are within STUDENT’s “curriculum level.” Moreover, as described above, the IEP must contain a statement of the student’s present levels of performance in order to define the areas of need and identify the starting point from which to gauge progress. Here, the baseline, or present level of performance, for goal six merely states: “phonemic awareness difficulty +60%.” Annual goal number eight provides that “by June 2004, STUDENT will read 100 word family words using phonemic awareness and rhyming skills to facilitate reading with 90% accuracy in 4/5 trials as measured by teacher record.” (District Exh. 15.) The baseline for goal eight states only that “STUDENT can’t rhyme words;” and “STUDENT can ‘sound out’ words but does not generalize rhyming words.” STUDENT’s District speech therapist Ms. Gibb was unable to effectively explain how these descriptions identified STUDENT’s present levels of performance. Thus, from these vague statements, it is unclear where STUDENT began. Moreover, as found above, STUDENT’s first-grade teacher did not provide the IEP team with an accurate assessment of STUDENT’s reading grade level as she started the second grade. Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that these IEP goals lacked specific or accurate present levels of performance and thus failed to provide a means by which to gauge STUDENT’s progress in phonological awareness. Further, the IEP was entirely lacking in goals and objectives to address reading fluency.
In addition, as found above, STUDENT needs intensive individualized instruction to address her deficits. Thus, the Hearing Officer next examines whether the program provided appropriate individualized and intensive attention. At the start of the school year, Ms. Shockney provided some individual assistance to STUDENT within a small group and occasionally one-on-one. However, there was no evidence that during those sessions Ms. Shockney worked with STUDENT to address her phonological awareness or reading fluency deficits, or that she did so on a consistent basis. The Hearing Officer finds especially troubling that at mid-year the Houghton-Mifflin curriculum eliminated small group work entirely but the IEP did not anticipate or plan for this change.
Finally, although STUDENT’s hearing deficits and the fact that she did not “hear” for the first two years of her life contributed to her delays, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded by the District’s argument that STUDENT made adequate progress consistent with her hearing loss. As found above, under the District’s reading program, STUDENT made little if any progress during her entire first-grade year. Special education law does not require waiting for the child to fall further behind before providing a reading program designed to meet her unique needs and provide her with some educational benefit.
Considering all of the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs for an intensive individualized program that addressed her phonological awareness and reading fluency deficits in a small group or one-on-one format. Because of the significance of reading to STUDENT as a compensatory strategy due to her hearing loss, in this respect, the program offer was not reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit.
C. Provide IEP goals and objectives designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in written expression.
As found above, STUDENT has unique needs in the area of written expression. Reviewing STUDENT’s 2003-2004 IEP, goal number four targets STUDENT’s ability to “improve in her understanding and usage of the structure of language in the classroom at her level of instruction +80% of the time.” While this annual goal appears to suffer from the same ambiguity as those discussed above, the short-term objectives provide specific targeted skills and the level of accuracy needed to reach the annual goal. (Footnote 23) In addition, the baseline reflects specific data and provides that “STUDENT omits the ‘is’ 40% of the time...” Thus, contrary to Petitioner’s contention, the Hearing Officer finds that this written expression goal was consistent with federal and State law requirements. Moreover, test results from the District’s December 2003 assessment showed that STUDENT constructed sentences well and that she achieved average scores on her writing samples. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the goal and objective was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of written expression and was reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit.
D. Permit full parental participation in the IEP process.
Petitioner contended that the District chilled parental participation in the IEP process by providing written refusals to each of their requests for assessment or for consideration of their experts’ recommendations. The District maintained that although District members of the IEP team sometimes disagreed with STUDENT’s parents, it considered the private assessors’ recommendations and STUDENT’s parents fully participated in the IEP process.
The right to a FAPE includes the important entitlement to certain procedural protections during the process of development an IEP for a child with a disability. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992); Rowley, 458 U.S. at 205. Not every procedural flaw constitutes a denial of FAPE, but procedural violations that result in loss of educational opportunity to the child or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process may constitute a denial of FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see also, Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990). The procedural rights that extend to parents include the right to participate in the development of the child’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. section 1415(b). California Education Code section 563419 (f) provides that parents of disabled children have the right to present information to the IEP team and the right to participate in meetings relating to eligibility for special education and related services, recommendations, and program planning. See also, 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(c); 34 C.F.R.§ 300.343(c)(2)(iii); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(c).
In developing STUDENT’s IEP for the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT’s parents provided two private assessment reports to the IEP team when it met in August 2003, which Petitioner claims the District failed to consider. However, the meeting notes demonstrate that consideration to the recommendations contained within each independent assessment was given by the District members of the IEP team. A list was prepared by District staff and presented at the IEP meeting outlining which of the proposed goals and objectives reflected the private evaluators’ recommendations. In addition, the IEP team agreed to add an oral-motor goal, as had been recommended. The meeting notes reflected the concerns of the parents, including their requests to implement the private evaluators’ additional recommendations for a Lindamood-Bell reading program and a one-on-one language facilitator. Shortly after the meeting, the District sent a letter to STUDENT’s parents refusing these requests. The letter explained that the District’s methodology for teaching reading was appropriate and that it did not believe STUDENT needed additional aide support. The District also sent similar “refusal letters” to STUDENT’s parents denying their requests for private assessments and other requests for services.
From this record, the Hearing Officer finds that the District gave due consideration to the requests of STUDENT’s parents as well as to the evaluations provided by them. Further, the evidence showed that STUDENT’s parents were active participants in the IEP process. The fact that the District disagreed whether STUDENT needed an additional assessment, or an aide, or a particular reading program, or that it expressed its formal disagreement in a letter drafted after the discussions of these matters by the IEP team, did not seriously infringe on STUDENT’s parents ability to participate in the IEP process. A procedural violation does not occur simply because school employees are not persuaded by a parent’s position and continue instead to offer the school’s preferred program.
* * * * * In sum, for the 2003-2004 school year, the District did not commit procedural violations that denied STUDENT a FAPE. Substantively, however, the program failed to provide aural habilitation services implemented by a trained one-on-one language facilitator, and failed to provide an intensive individualized reading program that addressed phonological awareness and reading fluency. To that extent, the program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs or reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit, and consequently, the District denied STUDENT a FAPE.
Issue No. 4: If the District failed to offer or provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year, are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for services they procured and other remedies?
The Hearing Officer has found above that the District failed to offer or provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year. STUDENT’s parents seek reimbursement of the cost of private services they obtained at a Lindamood-Bell clinic from October 6, 2003, through January 30, 2004, in the amount of $12,707.00, and additional hours from January 31, 2004, to the date of this Decision. Petitioner requests the services of a language facilitator for one year from the date of this Decision. In addition, as compensatory education, Petitioner also requests that STUDENT complete the Lindamood-Bell program until it is finished, at District expense.
Lindamood-Bell reading program. The Hearing Officer has determined that STUDENT has a unique need for an intensive individualized reading program that emphasizes phonological awareness and reading fluency and that the District failed to provide a program designed to meet these needs. As set out in Issue No. 2 above, in order to be entitled to reimbursement, although the parent’s placement does not have to meet a standard as high as school districts must meet under the IDEA, the parent’s placement must still meet the student’s needs and provide the student with some educational benefit.
STUDENT completed the first grade (2002-2003 school year) at the same beginning reading level as she started. In October 2003, STUDENT’s parents sought Lindamood-Bell services as a result of the District’s failure to offer a FAPE in this critical area of need. Turning to whether STUDENT received some educational benefit from the Lindamood-Bell program, test results in the areas targeted by the Lindamood-Bell program show that STUDENT benefitted from this program. Reviewing the Lindamood-Bell pre- and post-test results, Ms. Tierney testified that in the area of word attack skills, as measured by the Woodcock Reading Mastery Test, STUDENT made very significant gains from August 2003 until January 2004. STUDENT showed significant improvement in her ability to blend sounds and some growth in segmentation of words (take words apart, comprehend individual parts of words and know what the word is). STUDENT’s second-grade teacher, Ms. Shockney, testified that on recent reading assessments, STUDENT made progress, and at mid-year was testing at the end of first-grade level. The Hearing Officer is persuaded that the comparative gains as measured in January 2004 arose from the private services STUDENT’s parents obtained, and thus concludes that the Lindamood-Bell program provided STUDENT with some educational benefit. Accordingly, upon presentation of an invoice or proof of payment, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the Lindamood-Bell reading services they obtained for the sessions STUDENT attended from October 6, 2003, through January 30, 2004, in the amount of $12,707.00, and then in the amount of $69.00 per session, from January 31, 2004, to the date of this Decision.
Petitioner’s counsel also requests, as compensatory education, that the District fund additional sessions of the Lindamood-Bell program, starting from the date of this Decision until the program is completed. (Footnote 24) Based upon the principle enunciated in School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 358 (1985), that a child with a disability is entitled to “appropriate” relief when a school district fails to provide a FAPE, federal courts have held that compensatory education is a form of equitable relief which may be granted for the denial of appropriate special education to help overcome lost educational opportunity. See, for example, Student W. v. Puyallup., 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). The purpose of compensatory education is to “ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Id. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the petitioner is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA” Puyallup, 31 F.3d at 1497. In addition, courts have broad discretion to fashion a remedy which helps a student to overcome lost educational opportunity. Burlington; Puyallup.
The Hearing Officer has found above that the District’s program failed to provide an individualized intensive reading program that emphasized phonological awareness and reading fluency. There was no evidence presented that Lindamood-Bell is the only available program to meet STUDENT’s needs. Nevertheless, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has not offered or provided an alternative reading program through the end of the regular school year and the ESY. The Hearing Officer observes that STUDENT is already enrolled in the Lindamood-Bell program and is familiar with the both the program and its teachers. In addition, the school year is nearing an end with limited time to pursue the IEP process. Based upon the above findings that reading is an important compensatory strategy for STUDENT because of her hearing loss and that time is of the essence, the Hearing Officer finds that in order for STUDENT to be provided with a FAPE for the 2003-2004 regular school year and the ESY, she is entitled to some additional instruction from the Lindamood-Bell program. Accordingly, unless the parties agree in writing otherwise and taking into consideration STUDENT’s schedule, STUDENT may continue to attend up to ten sessions each week at the rate of $69.00 per session, from the date of this Decision through the end of the ESY, at District expense.
Language Facilitator. Petitioner’s counsel seeks the services of a language facilitator for one year from the date of this Decision. The Hearing Officer found above that to provide STUDENT with a FAPE, the District shall identify, arrange, and provide for a one-on-one trained instructional aide to perform the duties of a language facilitator as described in this Decision, in all academic subjects for the remainder of the 2003-2004 regular school year, including the ESY.
The Hearing Officer has made no findings regarding STUDENT’s needs for the 2004-2005 school year and the District has yet to make an offer for the upcoming school year. Because the 2004-2005 school year is not at issue, Petitioner’s request is considered by the Hearing Officer as a request for compensatory education. From all present indications, STUDENT will require the services of a language facilitator in order for her to receive a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year rendering these services redundant as a form of compensatory education. The Hearing Officer observes that the vocabulary and concepts in the third-grade curriculum will be more difficult than those with which STUDENT struggled during the current school year. In either event, the extent of the services that STUDENT will need is dependent upon monitoring of STUDENT’s progress in aural habilitation and academic subjects by the IEP team. Thus, the Hearing Officer declines to make specific orders for additional services and Petitioner’s further request for relief is denied.
ORDER
1. Within thirty calendar days of receipt of an invoice or proof of payment, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the aural habilitation sessions provided to STUDENT by Joan Hewett from September 2002 through August 31, 2003, in the amount of $4507.04.
2. Within thirty calendar days of receipt of an invoice or proof of payment, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the Lindamood-Bell program services STUDENT attended from October 6, 2003 through January 30, 2004, in the amount of $12,707.00, and then in the amount of $69.00 per session, from January 31, 2004, to the date of this Decision.
3. Unless the parties agree in writing otherwise, the District shall fund the Lindamood-Bell reading program, at the rate of $69.00 per session, for up to ten sessions each week from the date of this Decision, until the end of the ESY.
4. The District shall identify, arrange, and provide for the services of a one-on-one trained instructional aide during all academic subjects, for the remainder of the regular 2003-2004 school year, including the ESY. In addition to other duties as identified by the IEP team, the instructional aide shall perform the duties consistent with those outlined in this Decision, specifically to: monitor the functioning of STUDENT’s hearing equipment; preview and review curriculum concepts and lessons; practice curriculum vocabulary and language content; redirect STUDENT’s attention; clarify and implement teacher instructions; write words STUDENT does not know; and express for her what she is unable to hear. The instructional aide shall receive training in aural habilitation and teaching a child with a cochlear implant to “listen” either from the DHH itinerant teacher, speech therapist, and audiologist, or such other formal training which the IEP team may designate, so that she can carry out those duties just described and others as may be identified by the IEP team. Consistent and coordinated record-keeping methods shall be devised in order to objectively measure STUDENT’s progress on the benchmarks and short-term aural habilitation objectives that will be developed by the IEP team, as provided below in Order 5 (A).
5. Within 15 business days from the date of this decision, and thereafter as necessary, the IEP team shall meet and amend STUDENT’s IEP to:
(A) include goals and objectives in the area of aural habilitation to be implemented by the instructional aide, as defined in Order No. 4 above, in coordination with STUDENT’s classroom teacher, speech and language therapist, DHH itinerant teacher, case carrier, and consulting audiologist;
(B) include goals and objectives in the area of phonological awareness and reading fluency supported by accurate and specific present levels of performance and objectively measurable benchmarks that will be implemented, as applicable by STUDENT’s classroom teacher, speech and language therapist, DHH itinerant teacher, case carrier, instructional aide (as defined in Order 4 above), and consulting audiologist; and (C) include the services of a one-on-one trained instructional aide during all academic subjects, for the remainder of the regular 2003-2004 school year, including the ESY, as described in Order No. 4, above.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
Issue No. 1: Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2002-2003 school year by failing to provide services designed to meet her unique need for aural habilitation?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 2: If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year, are her parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private aural habilitation services they obtained?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 3: Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year by failing to: (A) provide the services of a trained one-on-one language facilitator designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs for aural habilitation; (B) provide an intensive individualized reading program designed to remediate STUDENT’s deficits in the areas of phonological awareness and reading fluency; (C) provide IEP goals and objectives designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in written expression; and (D) permit full parental participation in the IEP process?
Petitioner prevailed on subparts (A) and (B). The District prevailed on subparts (C) and (D).
Issue No. 4: If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year, are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for services they procured and to other remedies?
Petitioner prevailed to the extent that STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for private Lindamood-Bell services that they procured from October 6, 2003, through January 30, 2004, and then in the amount of $69.00 each session, from January 31, 2004, to the date of this Decision. Petitioner is also entitled to compensatory education in the form of Lindamood-Bell services through the end of the 2003-2004 ESY. Petitioner is entitled to the services of a trained one-on-one language facilitator for the remainder of the 2003-2004 regular school year, including the ESY. Petitioner’s remaining requests for relief were denied.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Dated: May 10, 2004 _________________________________ Judith E. Ganz, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The issues have been reworded and reorganized for purposes of analysis and are substantively unchanged from the issues presented by Petitioner.
2. In her closing argument, Petitioner alleged for the first time that the District failed to comply with the statutory timelines regarding assessments. This issue was not raised during hearing and was not addressed by both parties in the presentation of issues. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer declines to address this additional matter.
3. A cochlear implant is a device for treating severe deafness that consists of electrodes implanted by surgery. The electrode array stimulates the auditory nerve. (Testimony of BIRTH MOTHER; Janna Carlson, private speech pathologist.) Even with the assistance of a cochlear implant, STUDENT has a hearing impairment. STUDENT does not hear a broad range of frequencies. She remains eligible for special education as a child who is deaf/hard of hearing. (District Exh. 15.)
4. Mapping refers to the process of programming the cochlear implant so that it can receive sound and a frequency of pitches.
5. The FM system works with a receiver and a transmitter. A small receiver was attached to STUDENT’s cochlear implant. The speaker (teacher, aide, classmate) would wear a transmitter with an integrated microphone. The transmitter sends an FM signal to the receiver, which relays the sound to the hearing instrument.
6. No triennial review took place in April 2003.
7. The discussion of STUDENT’s unique needs is limited in this section to her need for aural habilitation because it is the single matter in issue for the 2002-2003 school year. A broader discussion of STUDENT’s unique needs will be presented below in Issue No. 3.
8. Ms. Carlson has both a bachelor’s and master’s degree in speech and hearing sciences. She interned at Children’s Hospital in Chicago and was a member of the cochlear implant team at Children’s Hospital in San Diego. She was a speech and language pathologist for deaf and hard of hearing children for the San Diego Unified School District. She has worked with fifteen children who were fitted with cochlear implants, many children with seizure disorders, and one with Landau-Kleffner Syndrome. She is currently in private practice evaluating and treating deaf and hard of hearing children and adults.
9. Although STUDENT’s parents agreed upon this level of services, the IEP meeting notes, over the course of all these IEP meetings, reflected STUDENT’s parents’ on-going request for additional speech and language services.
10. It was not clear from the documents or testimony provided whether STUDENT received instruction from the special education resource teacher or an instructional aide during these pull-out sessions. However, from the middle of the first-grade year on, the record did establish that STUDENT received one-half hour of pull-out and one-half hour of push-in services from an instructional aide.
11. Ms. Gibb testified that Earobics is a computer auditory processing program which emphasized rhyming, phonemic awareness and listening skills.
12. In fact, Ms. Hall had no contact with STUDENT’s speech therapists until two weeks before the start of this due process hearing.
13. A second instructional aide worked with STUDENT in the afternoon for one-half hour every day but did not testify.
14. Petitioner’s counsel, in her opening statement, indicated that the cost of Ms. Hewett’s aural habilitation services was $ 4507.04. However, no documentary proof was provided. Accordingly, in order to be reimbursed, Petitioner shall present either an invoice or proof of payment to the District.
15. The issues in this case do not concern whether the program comported with STUDENT’s IEP or prepared her for employment and independent living, and will not be addressed.
16. STUDENT also has expressive and receptive language deficits that require intensive speech and language therapy. STUDENT’s difficulty with articulation requires the services of an occupational therapist to meet her oral-motor needs. However, the Hearing Officer’s review of STUDENT’s unique needs will focus upon those needs which are relevant to the services that are in dispute.
17. STUDENT was assessed by the District’s school psychologist, Susan Jordan, in December 2003, after the November 2003 IEP addendum offer at issue. Ms. Jordan testified that even as of that date, STUDENT continued to have difficulty understanding what she heard.
18. With regard to the classroom aide, the parties disagree over the level of training and frequency of assistance. Petitioner’s counsel contends that STUDENT needs the assistance of a “language facilitator” for all academic subjects, while the District argues that an instructional aide during the language arts period is sufficient to meet STUDENT’s needs. This matter will be discussed in more detail below when the Hearing Officer analyzes whether the District’s program, which included a one-on-one instructional aide, was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide her with educational benefit.
19. “Phonological awareness” is the ability to auditorily track, segment, identify, sequence, and manipulate individual sounds, and is the foundation for decoding, reading accuracy, fluency and reading comprehension. (Student Exh. 109.) The parties also used the term “phonemic awareness” interchangeably to describe these same skills.
20. Ms. Fisher testified that up until two weeks before the due process hearing, without the additional support of an instructional aide during the reading lesson, STUDENT continued to exhibit “problems.”
21. Unless otherwise indicated by the context, the Hearing Officer will refer to the June, August, and November IEPs collectively as the 2003-2004 IEP.
22. The parties did not address what assistance STUDENT required if the class was shown a movie.
23. For example, the first benchmark for goal number four provides: “By 11-2003, STUDENT will use correct noun/verb agreement when given target sentences with a choice of 2 answers eg [sic] ‘The girls (is, are) going to school[‘] 4 of 5 times with an adult listener providing the sentences.”
24. Petitioner’s counsel estimated that, as of January 31, 2004, there were an additional one-hundred eighty hours remaining to complete the Lindamood-Bell program. Because STUDENT has been attending the Lindamood-Bell program from January 31, 2004, through the date of this Decision, the number of hours necessary to complete the program is somewhat less than counsel’s original estimate.
