California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 26, 2004

San Francisco Unified School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 2653-03 · Hearing Officer Judith E. Ganz

San Francisco Unified may not exit a sixth grader with a learning disability from special education, Hearing Officer rules.

Student prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The decision notes a related prior due process decision about the 2002-2003 program: STUDENT vs. San Francisco Unified School District, decided February 20, 2004 (citation omitted).

Summary

San Francisco Unified School District filed for due process asking a Hearing Officer to approve its decision to exit an 11-year-old sixth grader from special education. He had been eligible since 2001 with a specific learning disability. That finding rested on a severe gap between his average ability and his achievement and on weak auditory processing and auditory memory. In fall 2003, school psychologist DeAna Soto and program specialist Kay Cook reassessed him. Both said their own results were invalid because they believed he was not trying. The District relied instead on a 2002 independent evaluation by Dr. Tina Guterman, older achievement scores, and his current grades.

The Hearing Officer denied the District's request. She accepted that his cognitive ability was average, because IQ stays fairly constant. But achievement changes over time, so year-old scores could not show his current skills. Several of the new subtest scores showed a severe discrepancy. The assessor's own record form also said the testing was a fair sample of his abilities. No evidence showed that his earlier processing disorder had gone away. His general education math teacher, Rose Castro, gave him a C "to encourage him" even though he earned many Ds and Fs on quizzes. He also had not met his math goals. The District had not adequately looked into his social-emotional needs either. The student remains eligible for special education.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled a district's request to end eligibility when the district said its own new testing was invalid. The Hearing Officer would not rely on achievement scores that were a year old, because achievement changes over time. She also looked past a passing grade that did not match the student's actual work.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1. Has the District properly determined that STUDENT should be exited from special education and related services?

    The District called its own 2003 testing invalid and did not show through year-old achievement scores, current grades, or other evidence that the student no longer had a severe discrepancy or processing disorder, so the exit request was denied.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • The District's request to exit the student from special education is denied; the student remains eligible. (At hearing, the District agreed to keep him in the RSP program through the end of the school year.)

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Larry P. v. Riles, 793 F.2d 969 (9th Cir. 1986); Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(j); Cal. Educ. Code § 56337; Cal. Educ. Code § 56026; 20 U.S.C. § 1401(26); 34 C.F.R. § 300.541

People named in the decision

  • Pamela Mills, Ed.D., District administrator; supervised school psychologist; witness, San Francisco Unified School District
  • Ralph Scott, SELPA director, San Francisco Unified School District
  • Kay Cook, program specialist; achievement assessor, San Francisco Unified School District
  • DeAna C. Soto, school psychologist, San Francisco Unified School District
  • Aruna Subramanian, fifth grade inclusion and resource specialist teacher, San Francisco Unified School District
  • Rose Castro, sixth grade general education mathematics teacher, San Francisco Unified School District
  • Matthew Kulis, sixth grade resource specialist teacher, San Francisco Unified School District
  • Gerti Tyler, home tutor; witness for Student
  • Dr. Tina Guterman, independent clinical neuropsychologist; witness for Student
  • Brent Marquez-Valenti, fourth grade general education teacher; witness for Student, Jefferson Elementary School District
  • Ana Garcia, second and third grade general education teacher, Jefferson Elementary School District
  • Suzanne Mulcahy, school psychologist, Jefferson Elementary School District
  • Blaine Stoddard, certified Spanish interpreter, Interpreters Unlimited
  • Victor Fridman, certified Spanish interpreter, Interpreters Unlimited

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Judith E. Ganz, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in San Francisco, California, on February 10-13, 2004.

Petitioner San Francisco Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Lenore Silverman. Also present on behalf of the District was Pamela Mills, Ed.D., administrator for the District. Ralph Scott, SELPA director for the District, substituted for Dr. Mills on one morning. Respondent STUDENT (Student or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by his mother, MOTHER. STUDENT’s father, FATHER, also appeared on STUDENT’s behalf for parts of two days. Also present on February 10-12, 2004, to interpret for FATHER and MOTHER was certified Spanish interpreter Blaine Stoddard. Certified Spanish interpreter Victor Fridman interpreted for MOTHER on February 13, 2004. Both interpreters were from Interpreters Unlimited.

The District questioned the witnesses called on behalf of Student. In addition, the District called the following District employees: Kay Cook, program specialist; DeAna C. Soto, school psychologist; Aruna Subramanian, STUDENT’s fifth grade inclusion and resource specialist teacher; Rose Castro, STUDENT’s sixth grade general education mathematics teacher; Matthew Kulis, STUDENT’s sixth grade resource specialist teacher; and Dr. Pamela Mills.

MOTHER questioned the witnesses called on behalf of the District and called the following witnesses: Gerti Tyler, STUDENT’s home tutor; Dr. Tina Guterman, independent assessor; Brent Marquez-Valenti, STUDENT’s fourth grade general education teacher; and FATHER and MOTHER and STUDENT.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following the parties’ oral closing arguments, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUE PRESENTED FOR HEARING

Has the District properly determined that STUDENT should be exited from special education and related services?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT, who will turn twelve in March, attends the sixth grade at James Denman Middle School. He lives with his mother and sister within the boundaries of the District. Although STUDENT’s father and mother are separated, STUDENT has regular weekly contact with his father. STUDENT has been eligible for special education and related services since 2001 as a student with a specific learning disability (SLD).

STUDENT attended kindergarten through fourth grade in the Jefferson Elementary School District (Jefferson). During his kindergarten and first grade years, STUDENT missed a significant amount of school when he accompanied his family to El Salvador. (District Exh. 39.) In the second grade, STUDENT’s general education teacher, Ana Garcia, reported to the school study team that he had difficulties in reading, following directions and completing work. At the start of the third grade, Ms. Garcia referred STUDENT for a special education assessment, reporting that he continued to perform “very low” in reading and mathematics despite her providing alternative teaching methods and extra tutoring. (District Exhs. 38; 45.)

Following MOTHER’s consent, STUDENT was assessed by Suzanne Mulcahy, school psychologist for Jefferson, in January and February 2001. (District Exhs. 36; 45; Student Exh. 33.) Ms. Mulcahy administered the Weschler Intelligence Test for Children, Third Edition (WISC-III), and the Comprehensive Test of Nonverbal Intelligence (CTONI). STUDENT received a full scale intelligence quotient of 101 on the WISC-III and a nonverbal score of 115. The Weschler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT) and the Woodcock Reading Mastery tests were also administered. STUDENT scored in the low average range in reading (WIAT reading composite 82; Woodcock word attack, word identification, passage comprehension 85); in the average range in mathematics (mathematics composite 97, numerical operations 98, mathematics reasoning 96); with a scatter of scores in language (listening comprehension 83, oral expression 107); and in the low average range in writing (writing composite 80, written expression 77, spelling 88). Comparing his achievement scores with his cognitive abilities, the assessor found that STUDENT exhibited a severe discrepancy in the areas of reading comprehension, listening comprehension and written expression. The report also indicated that STUDENT’s overall auditory processing was average but that he demonstrated low average abilities in auditory perception and had serious difficulties with short-term auditory memory. Classroom observation revealed that STUDENT had difficulty obtaining information from presentation of a mathematics lesson on the board.

At an individualized education program (IEP) meeting held in early February 2001, the Jefferson IEP team found that STUDENT was unable to be successful in the general education program even when provided with accommodations and was eligible for special education and related services as a student with SLD. (Student Exh. 13.) The IEP provided for two goals and objectives, one to improve his handwriting and the second to target his reading comprehension. STUDENT was provided with two hundred fifty minutes of support in the resource specialist program (RSP).

In the fourth grade (2001-2002 school year), his general education mathematics teacher, Brent Valenti, reported to the Jefferson IEP team in February 2002, that STUDENT’s strengths were in the areas of fine motor skills (cursive writing and printing), organization, basic mathematical computation skills, and social skills. Mr. Valenti identified areas of need in adding and subtracting unlike fractions and copying final drafts without mistakes. Achievement tests in reading (Woodcock Reading Mastery) showed increases from the previous year in standard scores to the average range in the areas of word identification, word attack, word comprehension and passage comprehension. STUDENT’s mathematics scores in basic concepts, operations and applications showed similar improvement to standard scores in the average range. The February 2002 IEP provided for one goal and objective in the area of written expression (to proofread and edit his work) and STUDENT’s RSP support was reduced to two hundred minutes. (District Exh. 33.)

STUDENT started the fifth grade at Cesar Chavez Elementary School within the boundaries of the District. Upon receipt of the Jefferson 2002 IEP, the District IEP team convened in October 2002. STUDENT’s present levels of performance were assessed using the Peabody Individual Achievement Test-Revised (PIAT-R) (District Exh. 46.) STUDENT performed in the average range and within the fifth grade instructional level for all subtests, showing relative weaknesses in reading recognition and spelling, and strengths in writing and general information. Aruna Subramanian, the RSP teacher who administered the assessment, recommended that RSP services be reduced to forty-five minutes, three times each week. It was reported that STUDENT worked well with a group, had a positive attitude, possessed a “great” vocabulary, made an effort and liked the school. Areas of need were also identified in mathematical operations, spelling, writing, completing tasks in a timely manner, focusing, and proofreading. He interacted well with his peers and appeared confident. Goals and objectives were drafted in mathematics (multiplication, long division, solving equations) and writing and editing. MOTHER agreed to the goals and objectives, but believed STUDENT needed additional one-on-one assistance for sixty minutes each day. (District Exh. 28.)

MOTHER had STUDENT assessed by an independent clinical neuropsychologist, Dr. Tina Guterman, in November 2002. Dr. Guterman concluded that STUDENT, who had average cognitive functioning abilities, scored below his abilities and needed a higher level of educational support in the areas of reading, spelling and written expression. She also noted STUDENT’s difficulties with mathematical calculations. (District Exh. 44.) In February 2003, IEP meetings were convened but not completed due to disagreements over the level of special education support STUDENT needed. (District Exhs. 23, 24.) Ultimately, MOTHER challenged the appropriateness of the 2002-2003 school year program, and STUDENT was the subject of a recent due process hearing on that issue. See STUDENT vs. San Francisco Unified School District, citation omitted, decided February 20, 2004.

By way of summary, STUDENT continued to receive the same level of RSP support in mathematics and writing during the 2002-2003 school year that was provided under the February 2002 IEP (200 minutes each week). In the spring of 2003, STUDENT achieved a “basic” score in English-Language Arts and “below basic” in mathematics on statewide standardized tests. (District Exh. 51.) In June 2003, it was reported that STUDENT was reading at the instructional level for his grade. (District Exh. 42.) STUDENT met one of his writing goals (to check and circle incorrect words) and made some progress on two others (use of a dictionary; to read his writing out loud and correct his grammar). STUDENT had not met any of his mathematics objectives, but made some progress by the end of the regular school year. (District Exh. 25.) His fifth grade teacher reported that while he was a strong reader, STUDENT needed to improve his grammar and spelling. STUDENT continued to find mathematics difficult, and commented to his teacher that he was unable to learn the concepts. STUDENT needed to improve working independently and completing classwork in a timely manner. (District Exh. 52.)

When STUDENT started the sixth grade (2003-2004 school year) in middle school, he continued to participate in the RSP program, which was offered as a study skills class of sixteen students five days a week for fifty minutes each day. STUDENT also attended an after-school tutorial program available to all students. In September 2003, MOTHER consented to additional assessments. (Student Exh. 28.) School psychologist DeAna Soto performed a psychoeducational assessment and Kay Cook assessed STUDENT’s achievement in September and October 2003. Both Ms. Cook and Ms. Soto cautioned that their test results were invalid because it appeared STUDENT was unfocused and purposely answered questions incorrectly. Ms. Soto concluded that STUDENT was no longer eligible for special education and related services. (District Exh. 39.) On November 3, 2003, the IEP team, referring to STUDENT’s school performance and taking account of previous cognitive and academic assessments, recommended that STUDENT be exited from special education. MOTHER disagreed with the District’s conclusion and the District filed for this due process hearing. At hearing, the District agreed to maintain STUDENT in the RSP program until the end of the school year.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue: Has the District properly determined that STUDENT should be exited from special education and related services?

Under federal and State special education law, an individual with exceptional needs is one who meets the definition of a child with a disability and as a result of the impairment, requires instruction, services, or both which cannot be provided with modification of the regular education program. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A)(i); Cal. Educ. Code § 56026(a), (b). The disabilities identified in the IDEA are mental retardation; hearing, speech or language, visual, orthopedic, and other health impairments; emotional disturbance; autism; traumatic brain injury; and specific learning disabilities. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A)(i); see Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(a)-(j).

A specific learning disorder is defined as a “disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or in using language, spoken or written, which disorder may manifest itself in imperfect ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell, or do mathematical calculations.” 20 U.S.C. § 1401(26)(A). Basic psychological processes include “attention, visual processing, auditory processing, sensory-motor skills, cognitive abilities including association, conceptualization and expression.” Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(j)(1). For a child to qualify for special education as having an SLD: (1) he must exhibit a severe discrepancy between intellectual ability and achievement in the areas of oral expression, listening comprehension, written expression, basic reading skills, reading comprehension, mathematics calculation, or mathematics reasoning (34 C.F.R. § 300.541(a)(2); Cal. Educ. Code § 56337(a)); (2) the severe discrepancy must be due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes and must not be primarily the result of an environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage (34 C.F.R. § 300.541(b)(3),(4); Cal. Educ. Code § 56337(b)); (3) the discrepancy cannot be ameliorated through “other regular or categorical services” offered within the regular education program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56337(c); see 34 C.F.R. § 300.543(a)(6). The determination of whether a severe discrepancy exists is to be made by the IEP team, taking into account all available relevant information. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(j)(4). No “single score or product of scores, test or procedure shall be used as the sole criterion” in determining a child’s eligibility for special education. Id.

A severe discrepancy can be established through a formula using standardized tests, by alternative means when standardized tests are considered to be invalid, or by a finding of the IEP team that a severe discrepancy exists. Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(j)(4)(A), (B), (C).

The District contends that as of November 2003, STUDENT no longer was eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability. The District believed that its current psychoeducational assessment results were invalid. It argued, however, that scores on previous testing evidenced neither a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement nor a processing disorder, and that he was currently performing within instructional standards. According to the District, STUDENT is able to progress in the general education program with tutoring assistance available to all general education students. Student argues that he performed poorly in mathematics, reading comprehension, and written expression and continued to need special education support.

Turning first to the measure of STUDENT’s cognitive functioning, the District believed that its recent psychoeducational assessment conducted in September and October 2003 was invalid. Ms. Soto credibly testified that in her opinion, the cognitive functioning assessment was invalid because STUDENT was unresponsive, unfocused, oppositional, and tired. Ms. Soto did not believe that STUDENT put forth his best effort. The District asserted nevertheless, that STUDENT’s current cognitive functioning could be ascertained by previous test scores. On the District’s assessment of his cognitive functioning, STUDENT achieved a full scale standard score of 65. This score fell far below the average range for children of his age. This result was well below the relatively consistent intelligence quotient (IQ) scores within the average range that STUDENT had received on the independent evaluation performed by Dr. Tina Guterman in November 2002 (WISC-III standard score 99) and on Jefferson’s psychoeducational assessment conducted in January 2001 (WISC-III, full scale IQ of 101; CTONI, full scale IQ 115). (District Exhs. 39, 44, 45.) Dr. Mills, who supervised Ms. Soto and discussed the test results, persuasively testified that tests of cognitive functioning usually remain relatively constant, absent some kind of brain trauma, which was not present here. Consequently, Dr. Mills concluded that the District’s recent assessment of STUDENT’s cognitive testing was invalid and chose instead to rely on Dr. Guterman’s IQ tests results. Because cognitive functioning remains relatively constant and there being no dispute concerning the validity of Dr. Guterman’s assessment, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s cognitive functioning is in the average range. (Footnote 1)

Believing its recent achievement tests were also invalid, the District asserted that it could rely instead on a combination of older achievement test scores and STUDENT’s current academic performance to demonstrate that STUDENT was no longer in need of special education support. A severe discrepancy, or lack thereof, may be demonstrated by alternative means when the standardized test scores are invalid. See Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(j)(4)(B). In October 2003, Kay Cook administered the Woodcock-Johnson III tests of achievement for the District. (District Exh. 39.) Like Ms. Soto, Ms. Cook testified that she had questions whether STUDENT put forth his best effort and whether the achievement test scores were accurate. While the broad standard scores did not meet the severe discrepancy criteria, on several of the subtests, STUDENT received scores that resulted in a severe discrepancy between his cognitive functioning (full scale IQ scores 99-115) and achievement. Thus, for example, STUDENT received a standard score of 76 in passage comprehension, 79 in applied mathematical problems, and 71 in writing samples. (Footnote 2) Dr. Mills acknowledged that these subtest results raised “red flags” and may have been areas of concern. To determine whether the achievement test scores were reliable in light of Ms. Cook’s questions about STUDENT’s effort, Dr. Mills compared Ms. Cook’s results with Dr. Guterman’s achievement tests and the October 2002 PIAT. According to Dr. Mills, on the previous achievement tests, STUDENT did not perform consistently low in these same academic areas. Thus, for example, on the written expression test on the WIAT administered by Dr. Guterman, STUDENT achieved a standard score of 85. Dr. Mills concluded that the former tests were more reflective of STUDENT’s achievement than the current scores. According to Dr. Mills, because the valid testing performed by Dr. Guterman did not evidence a severe discrepancy as defined under State special education law, STUDENT is not eligible for special education. (Footnote 3)

The Hearing Officer does not find Dr. Mills’ explanation persuasive. The Hearing Officer is concerned about explaining the current subtest scores away or finding a lack of discrepancy between ability and achievement by comparison to year-old achievement test scores. Unlike cognitive functioning, achievement is variable. Reliance on achievement test scores administered over a year earlier in November 2002 to invalidate the more contemporaneous achievement test results was not supported by reference to any accepted research in the field. Moreover, on STUDENT’s test record protocol, Ms. Cook checked the box marked “no” to the question “do you have any reason to believe this testing session may not represent a fair sampling of the subject’s abilities?” (District Exh. 64.) Ms. Cook did not effectively explain this discrepancy. Ms. Cook’s handwritten notations on the test protocols indicated that STUDENT had difficulties in the academic areas identified as needing remediation. Thus, for example, Ms. Cook wrote that for math calculations STUDENT used his fingers and did not know his multiplication tables. (District Exh. 64.) Accordingly, in light of Ms. Cook’s testimony that she would like to conduct further testing to know if these results were a fair sample, the Hearing Officer finds that the current achievement test results raised more questions than it answered concerning STUDENT’s eligibility for special education.

The Hearing Officer next determines whether STUDENT has a disorder in one of the basic psychological processes. In the February 2001 testing performed at Jefferson, STUDENT exhibited serious difficulties in short-term auditory memory and low average abilities in overall auditory perception. As a result of processing disorders in auditory processing and auditory memory, STUDENT was identified as a student with an SLD. (District Exh. 34.) Teacher reports in the fifth grade identified focusing on the lesson while in a large group and dealing with distractions, as areas of need for STUDENT. (District Exh. 28.) The District attempted to show, however, that this previously identified processing disorder ceased to exist. Believing its own assessment was invalid, the District again looked to Dr. Guterman’s results, claiming that because she did not report a processing disorder, there was no evidence he had one. However, Dr. Guterman’s evaluation did not address one way or the other whether STUDENT had a psychological processing disorder, although she reported that he had difficulty recalling discrete information, and trouble organizing and translating verbal information into calculations when asked to solve arithmetic problems. (District Exh. 44.) Ms. Soto’s assessment results indicated that STUDENT exhibited auditory processing weaknesses and difficulties with auditory memory, but she testified that these weaknesses did not amount to a processing disorder. The Hearing Officer observes that these areas of “weakness” are the same as those identified as processing disorders at Jefferson. However, in light of the assertion that its testing was invalid, the Hearing Officer is unable to draw any conclusion one way or the other from these recent results. The Hearing Officer finds that there was previous evidence of a processing disorder and no testimony that a processing disorder could be cured or otherwise disappear. Dr. Guterman’s evaluation failed to examine the issue, and the District’s testing, at best, left the record obscure.

Seeking further justification for exiting STUDENT from special education, the District presented evidence of STUDENT’s current academic performance in both the RSP and general education mathematics class. Under his existing IEP, STUDENT attends a study skills class of sixteen students for fifty minutes five days each week. Matthew Kulis, STUDENT’s credentialed RSP teacher, testified that STUDENT was performing well in his class in the areas addressed in his IEP, namely written expression and mathematics. STUDENT asked questions when he needed help and was responsive to assistance, but also demonstrated an ability to work independently. According to Mr. Kulis, STUDENT was working within sixth grade instructional standards and no longer required special education. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s performance in his RSP class may be an indication that he is ready to move from special education. However, the Hearing Officer finds that there is insufficient other evidence of STUDENT’s performance in the general education program to warrant the conclusion that he is no longer eligible.

Mr. Kulis and Dr. Mills testified that in reaching their conclusion that STUDENT could progress in the general education program without special education assistance they relied, in part, on the C grade STUDENT received from his general education mathematics teacher, Rose Castro. The Hearing Officer finds, however, that Ms. Castro’s testimony concerning STUDENT’s progress in general education mathematics was not convincing. Ms. Castro did not recall seeing STUDENT’s IEP and testified that she did not see the need to be informed of his IEP mathematics goal. Ms. Castro testified that she learned whether her thirty students understood the classwork by asking them to raise their hands if they did not understand the lesson. Ms. Castro added that she then would tell her students to try harder. Ms. Castro was unable to testify how often STUDENT asked for help in this manner, but recalled she frequently made notations on his work to come to her for help, but that STUDENT did not do so. Reviewing her grade book, Ms. Castro acknowledged that STUDENT earned only Ds and Fs on many quizzes and work assignments. When asked to account for his C grade on this record, Ms. Castro explained that she gave the grade to encourage him and make him “happier.” Furthermore, in contrast to her testimony that STUDENT was achieving in her class, Ms. Castro reported to Ms. Soto that “STUDENT is at risk for demonstrating academic difficulties, particularly in understanding or completing school-work.” (District Exh. 39.) The Hearing Officer further observes that STUDENT scored “below basic” on standardized tests in mathematics administered at the end of the 2002-2003 school year. Moreover, as to his progress on his IEP mathematics goals, STUDENT had made some progress but had not met any of the three objectives by the end of the 2002-2003 regular school year. (District Exh. 25.) More recently, in November 2003, at the time of the IEP team decision to exit STUDENT from special education, Mr. Kulis reported that STUDENT had still not met his mathematics goal. (Footnote 4) (District Exh. 26.) Notably, because of parental disagreement, the operative mathematics objectives were those that had been developed at the October 2002 IEP, when STUDENT was just starting the fifth grade.

As discussed above, the District offered as an explanation for STUDENT’s poor performance on its recent assessments that he was oppositional and refused to put forth his best effort. Both Ms. Soto and Ms. Cook testified that, in their opinion, STUDENT was “faking bad,” that is, was purposely answering questions incorrectly. Mr. Kulis also testified that STUDENT erased correct answers on an assignment, and in his view, purposely replaced them with wrong answers. However, in contrast to the purported lack of motivation to do well, STUDENT was voluntarily taking advantage of the District’s tutoring program. The Hearing Officer observes that STUDENT’s school records reveal other behavioral problems and anxiety about school performance. After his family’s return from El Salvador, when STUDENT entered the first grade, he expressed suicidal ideation. In the fourth grade, STUDENT had conflicts with peers on the playground and was rude to teachers. He reportedly was embarrassed about having to leave his general education class to go to the RSP pull-out class. Mental health referrals were made but MOTHER declined to consent.

According to the District’s theory, STUDENT purposely answered questions incorrectly bowing to parental pressure to remain “disabled” and his fear over leaving special education. The Hearing Officer notes, however, that STUDENT’s oppositional behavior the previous year was attributed to his participation in, rather than concern about leaving, special education. STUDENT’s parents and STUDENT himself testified that STUDENT cannot do the work. Ms. Soto testified that the testing she performed to determine STUDENT’s behavioral needs was, like her other testing, invalid. On a true-false test, STUDENT circled both “true and false” and on a survey of his feelings, answered either he “didn’t know,” or that it was none of the examiner’s business to most of the questions. (District Exh. 65.) While the truth may lie somewhere between the District’s and Student’s polar views, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to adequately investigate STUDENT’s emotional resistance or other social-emotional needs. Although the District expressed concerns about STUDENT’s behavior, its sole attempt to discover STUDENT’s needs resulted only in another invalid test.

In sum, the Hearing Officer does not find the District’s alternative formulation convincing. In theory, while cognitive functioning may remain the same, the Hearing Officer finds that it is not possible to draw the similar inference that achievement tests administered over a year earlier are an accurate measure of STUDENT’s current academic functioning. Using older achievement tests to justify exiting a student from special education makes little sense. Eligibility under the SLD category is determined by STUDENT’s current academic functioning, the measure of which was invalid under the District’s own theory. Moreover, as described above, the District did not effectively establish that STUDENT’s current school performance evidences his ability to perform without special education support. Notably, in the other recent due process proceeding, the District took the position that its program that included RSP support provided STUDENT with a free appropriate public education. The District presented no persuasive evidence in this matter that STUDENT’s current academic performance warranted a change to his program. Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not properly determine that STUDENT can be exited from special education and related services at this time in his education.

ORDER

The District’s request to exit STUDENT from special education is denied.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code section 56507(d) , the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

Student prevailed on the only issue heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Dated: February 26, 2004 Judith E. Ganz, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Officer

1. Although the District maintains a policy not to use IQ tests, it agreed to rely on Dr. Guterman’s WISC-III IQ test results for its eligibility determination. The Hearing Officer observes that traditional IQ tests have come under increasing criticism in recent years because of cultural bias and other factors tending to diminish their reliability and that they have undergone a number of successful legal challenges (see, for example, Larry P. v. Riles, 793 F.2d 969, 975-76 (9th Cir. 1986)). However, there is no legal impediment to the District’s consideration of this score here.

2. When standardized tests are considered valid for a student, a severe discrepancy can be demonstrated by computing the difference between a student’s ability and achievement test standard scores. The required difference for a severe discrepancy can be demonstrated by computing the difference between a student’s ability and achievement test standard scores. The required difference for a severe discrepancy has commonly been interpreted to be at least 22.5 points, adjusted by one standard error of measurement not to exceed four common standard score points, or between 18.5 to 26.5 points. A severe discrepancy exists when the computed difference in scores “is corroborated by other assessment data which may include other tests, scales, instruments, observations and work samples, as appropriate.” Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(j)(4)(A).

3. Using a different formula from State special education law, that is correlation charts developed by Weschler to compare the WISC-III to the WIAT, Dr. Guterman concluded that statistically significant discrepancies existed between STUDENT’s ability and spelling (16 points below his IQ), word reading skills (13 points below his IQ), and reading comprehension (13 points below his IQ). Dr. Guterman also reported that STUDENT’s errors in mathematical operations, especially division were “striking” given his intellectual capabilities. (District Exh. 44.) In February 2001, the previous testing revealed a severe discrepancy between STUDENT’s ability and achievement in the areas of reading comprehension, listening comprehension and written expression. (District Exh. 45.)

4. Mr. Kulis also noted that although STUDENT was improving in his written expression goal, he “still needed support.” (District Exh. 26.)