California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 3, 2004
Student v. Colton Joint Union High School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 2661-02, SN-2661-02 · Hearing Officer Tracy L. Tibbals
Colton Joint Union High School District must hold an IEP meeting for a 19-year-old found eligible under OHI and SLD; assessment reimbursements denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted. Five of the Student's seven issues were settled on the first day of hearing; the written settlement is not part of the record.
Summary
Both sides filed due process requests, and the cases were consolidated. The student was 19 and attended an independent study program at Washington Alternative High School. Colton Joint Union High School District had exited him from special education in 1998 and served him under a Section 504 plan for attention deficit disorder. On the first day of hearing, the parties settled five of the student's issues. Three issues remained: whether he was eligible for special education, and whether the district had to pay for two private psychoeducational assessments.
The Hearing Officer found him eligible under other health impairment (OHI) because of his long-diagnosed attention deficit disorder. Even with 504 accommodations, he failed most classes at Colton High School. At the alternative school, he passed only by taking one or two classes a term. At that pace, he would not earn his diploma before aging out at 22. The Hearing Officer also found him eligible for specific learning disability (SLD). Relying on Dr. Robert Patterson's 2004 assessment, the Hearing Officer compared his IQ to individual fluency subtest scores, not just cluster averages, and found severe discrepancies.
The Hearing Officer denied reimbursement for Dr. Steven Berk's 2000 assessment. The claim was time-barred. The assessment was also done for a private summer program, not because of disagreement with a district assessment, and the student's aunt had paid for it. Reimbursement for the Patterson assessment was denied because school psychologist Michael Gagnon's 2002 assessment was appropriate. The district must convene an IEP meeting.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO found a student with attention deficit disorder eligible even though he was passing classes with 504 accommodations, because his very slow progress toward a diploma showed he needed special education. It also shows that a parent can win on eligibility and still not get paid back for a private assessment if the district's own assessment was appropriate.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedEligibility
Issue 1. Is Student currently eligible for special education services under the category of other health impaired (OHI) and/or specific learning disability (SLD)?
Student is eligible under OHI because his long-standing attention deficit disorder adversely affects his educational performance, and 504 accommodations have not let him make reasonable progress toward a diploma. He also qualifies under SLD because individual fluency subtest scores show severe discrepancies in basic reading, math calculation and written expression, caused by a processing disorder.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 2. Is Student's parent entitled to reimbursement from the District for the Steven Berk psychoeducational assessment dated June 2000?
The claim is barred by the three-year statute of limitations because the mother knew of the 1998 district assessment in 1998. Reimbursement also fails because the assessment was obtained for a private summer program rather than out of disagreement with the district's assessment, and the aunt, not the parent, paid for it.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 3. Is Student's parent entitled to reimbursement from the District for the Robert Patterson psychoeducational assessment dated May 2004?
The District's 2002 psychoeducational assessment was appropriate. It was given by an experienced, credentialed school psychologist who used proper instruments and followed the test instructions. A different eligibility conclusion alone does not make it inappropriate, so no reimbursement is owed.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. The IEP team shall convene 'within no less than ten calendar days' of the date of the Decision to develop an IEP for the Student (likely intended: within ten calendar days).
Key authorities
20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A); 20 U.S.C. § 1401(26); Cal. Educ. Code § 56026; Cal. Educ. Code § 56337; Cal. Educ. Code § 56339(a); Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(f) and (j); 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56320, 56322, 56324; Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(j)
People named in the decision
- Dr. Ron Lackey, educational consultant representing Student, Student
- Gail Lindberg, District advocate; program manager, East Valley Special Education Local Plan Area
- Dr. Diane D'Agostino, pupil personnel services director, Colton Joint Union High School District
- Michael Gagnon, school psychologist; conducted 2002 psychoeducational assessment, Colton Joint Union High School District
- Patty Metheny, school psychologist; conducted 1998 triennial psychoeducational assessment, Colton Joint Union High School District
- Gail Darby, special education secretary, Colton Joint Union High School District
- Dr. Robert Patterson, independent psychologist; 2004 psychoeducational assessment; witness for Student, Private
- Dr. Steven A. Berk, private psychologist; June 2000 psychoeducational evaluation, Private (Massachusetts)
- Dr. Sarah Roddy, physician; 2003 neurological diagnosis, Loma Linda University pediatric neurological clinic
- Pine Ridge School, nonpublic school; summer remedial program, Williston, Vermont
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Tracy L. Tibbals, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, on July 15, 16, 20 and 21, 2004, in Bloomington, California.
The Petitioner/Cross-Respondent STUDENT (STUDENT or Student) was present. Also present on his behalf were educational consultant Dr. Ron Lackey and MOTHER, his mother. Respondent/Cross-Petitioner Colton Joint Union High School District (District) was represented at the hearing by advocate Gail Lindberg, program manager for the East Valley Special Education Local Plan Area. Also present for the hearing on behalf of the District was pupil personnel services director Dr. Diane D’Agostino.
The Student called as witnesses himself, his mother, and psychologist Dr. Robert Patterson. The District called Dr. D’Agostino, school psychologists Michael Gagnon and Patty Metheny, and special education secretary Gail Darby.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The parties presented their closing arguments in written briefs. After the receipt of the briefs, the matter was submitted for decision.
PREHEARING PROCEEDINGS
The parties identified a total of eight issues for determination at hearing pursuant to California Education Code section 56505(e)(6). Seven of these issues were listed by the Student and one by the District. On the first day of hearing, outside the presence of the Hearing Officer and before opening statements or the presentation of evidence, the parties met and conferred in settlement discussions. Later the same day, the parties informed the Hearing Officer that they had resolved five of the Student’s issues. The terms of this settlement were reduced to writing, which is not part of the record. The hearing then proceeded on the three remaining issues identified below, the first identified by the District and the remaining two by the Student.
ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING (Footnote 1)
1. Is Student currently eligible for special education services under the category of other health impaired (OHI) and/or specific learning disability (SLD)?
2. Is Student’s parent entitled to reimbursement from the District for the Steven Berk psychoeducational assessment dated June 2000?
3. Is Student’s parent entitled to reimbursement from the District for the Robert Patterson psychoeducational assessment dated May 2004?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a nineteen-year-old young man who resides in the District with his mother to whom, by power of attorney, he has assigned the right to make his educational decisions. He is not currently receiving any special education instruction or services from the District. The individualized education program (IEP) team determined in 1998 that he was no longer eligible after his triennial assessment. However, STUDENT does have accommodations including additional time for tests and assistance as part of a section 504 plan (Footnote 2) to address his diagnosed attention problems.
STUDENT had originally qualified for special education services in 1991 at the kindergarten level in Massachusetts through the sixth grade (1996-1997 school year). His individualized education programs (IEP’s) in two Massachusetts public school systems provided speech and language services, counseling, and placement in resource specialist (RSP) classrooms. STUDENT entered the District in September 1997 as a special education student based on his Massachusetts records and was placed in an (RSP) classroom in grade seven at Terrace Hills Middle School. The transferred records from Massachusetts note as of 1992 STUDENT had a diagnosis of attention deficit/hyperactive disorder (ADHD) and “below age level speech and language skills.”
STUDENT’s social adjustment in the District after his transfer from Massachusetts in the fall of 1997 proved difficult. He described his schooling in the District as a “horrible experience.” He said that before moving to Colton there was “no problem” getting help with his schoolwork. He contrasted the District program with the Massachusetts programs in which he stated teachers and staff had in place a “rewards system” and “things to boost self esteem” in the resource classes. He did not make many friends after entering the District. He reported that he was the subject of repeated teasing and bullying starting in his first semester in the District at the middle school level. STUDENT was also involved in a few altercations that resulted in two of his front teeth being broken. This required extensive dental work that at one point involved his having to wear what STUDENT called “grotesque temporary caps.” He reported continuing social discomfort after moving up to Colton High School for the ninth grade. He said that his high school experience “was never fun.” STUDENT related a string of incidents involving teasing, bullying, and physical assault.
The 1998 triennial assessment, which led to the determination that STUDENT was not eligible for special education, included a psychoeducational assessment by school psychologist Patty Metheny. (Footnote 3) Ms. Metheny found STUDENT’s cognitive and achievement skill levels to be within the average range. She noted in her report that at that time in middle school STUDENT was receiving passing grades, although he had “Ds” in science and an elective, and had “good attendance.” She also found that he had poorly developed skills in scanning and rapid eye-hand coordination and noted that “STUDENT’s performance may reflect his need to take his time to be accurate because he cannot rely on his visual memory rather than a deficit in concentration and attention.” In contrast, she found that he had exceptionally well-developed abilities to concentrate and work with auditorily presented material in the immediate present. Ms. Metheny summarized after her testing and observations that STUDENT “demonstrated well developed auditory short-term memory abilities, but poorly developed attention and concentration skills required in replicating a code when timed.” She also noted that STUDENT did not make friends easily, “which may contribute to social emotional problems interfering with his school performance.” Despite STUDENT’s previous participation in special education in Massachusetts due to a communication deficit, Ms. Metheny concluded that he no longer demonstrated such a condition. She further determined that there was no discrepancy between his cognitive abilities and academic achievement. Such a discrepancy is required to find that STUDENT had a specific learning disability that would qualify him for special education services. She suggested consideration of a section 504 plan to assist with task completion, personal responsibility skills, and age-appropriate social skills.
On November 10, 1998, STUDENT and his mother attended a section 504 meeting following the IEP meeting that resulted in a team decision to end his special education eligibility. A section 504 plan was prepared that provided STUDENT with more time to complete tests, assistance with organizational skills, small group or individual test administration, and help with editing written assignments. The plan document indicated that STUDENT had a “Diagnosis of ADD (attention deficit disorder), former communication handicap.”
STUDENT continued in the general education program in the District with this 504 plan for the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years, although he remained enrolled in an RSP English class.
During the summer of 2000 on the recommendation of STUDENT’s aunt in Massachusetts, STUDENT’s mother unilaterally placed him in a remedial program for learning disabled students at Pine Ridge School, a nonpublic school (NPS), near his aunt’s summer home in Williston, Vermont. Pine Ridge School described the six-week program as an “intensive” one in which “youngsters live, learn, and have fun together in a program which has nearly a 1:1 student to staff ratio.” The school employed a “highly structured approach to language learning” and stressed the Orton-Gillingham method (Footnote 4)“wherever appropriate.”
Pine Ridge School had required testing before enrollment in its program. Again on the recommendation of his aunt, STUDENT went to psychologist Dr. Steven A. Berk in Weston, Massachusetts, for an assessment that was paid for by STUDENT’s aunt. Dr. Berk tested STUDENT over two days in late June 2000. Dr. Berk’s overall test findings in the “Report of Psychoeducational Evaluation” were that STUDENT “struggles with very significant attentional deficits and learning disabilities.” Dr. Berk concluded that STUDENT’s learning disability involved auditory processing that, in turn, impacted decoding and comprehension in reading and written language. This assessor further stated that STUDENT’s needs extended beyond modification of the general education program, as his reading and writing deficits were extensive and required remediation. STUDENT’s attentional deficits, according to Dr. Berk, “are superimposed upon the learning disabilities,” suggesting the need for a small, self-contained classroom with learning specialists available for direct and consultative services. Among Dr. Berk’s recommendations were intensive remedial reading to address decoding and comprehension deficits and intensive remediation of written language deficits. Dr. Berk also recommended ongoing counseling because of STUDENT’s low self-esteem and depressive mood that “are impacting his attitude towards learning and contributing to apparent behavioral difficulties in the school setting.” Dr. Berk further advocated a review of STUDENT’s medication, observing that STUDENT’s response to the then-current type and dosage “appears to be less than optimal.” STUDENT’s mother is seeking reimbursement for the expense of the Berk assessment in this proceeding.
Although he was still not determined to be eligible for special education, the District kept him in an RSP English class through the tenth grade during the 2000-2001 school year at Colton High School. In June 2002 after three years at Colton High School, the District granted STUDENT’s mother’s request to enroll him in the District’s independent study program at Washington Alternative High School.
Prior to transferring to Washington, STUDENT had accumulated a .833 grade point average in his last semester at Colton High School, with an attendance record laced with tardies and truants. His only grade above a “D” during this semester was in ROTC. A similar pattern appeared on his record for the first term of the 2001-2002 school year, during which he earned a grade point average of .667 with ROTC repeating as the only class with a STUDENT above a “D.” Although he had below a 2.00 grade point average for all but one semester at Colton High School, STUDENT did receive passing grades in each of two single-class summer sessions that were scheduled one after the other in 2001. At Washington, his grades have been consistently in the “A” or “B” range up until the last semester of the 2003-2004 school year when he earned a “C” in biology. He had taken only one class a term and previously had taken a maximum of two classes a semester while at Washington. STUDENT’s mother testified that she tutored him at home up to sixty hours per week before he was at Washington and 30 hours after he entered the alternative program. She stated that the tutoring was very difficult and that she wanted to know “why he was grindingly slow.”
In June 2002, approximately two years after the Berk assessment, STUDENT’s mother requested a District review assessment to see if he again should be designated as a special education student. District school psychologist Michael Gagnon conducted the psychoeducational assessment over three days in late June and early July 2002. (Footnote 5) Mr. Gagnon concluded that as of July 2002, STUDENT did not meet the eligibility criteria for special education as he did not exhibit a specific learning disability or emotional disturbance. However, Mr. Gagnon found that STUDENT was entitled to section 504 accommodations because of “a perceived impairment in attention.” Although he found that STUDENT had adequately developed effective academic skills for his age, Mr. Gagnon noted that STUDENT “fails classes in high school.” Mr. Gagnon observed that “STUDENT may sacrifice speed for accuracy” because of his reading speed and pace on certain tasks. Although he noted that STUDENT had “unusually slow response time” that was “clinically relevant,” Mr. Gagnon concluded that all of STUDENT’s academic skills were intact with no basic deficits in psychological processes. Among Mr. Gagnon’s suggestions were accommodations in the regular classroom with extra time for assignments and projects, peer assistance for note taking, strategies and techniques to increase STUDENT’s rate, efficiency, and productivity, and timed tasks and work sessions. Counseling was recommended to address school failure and social-emotional issues.
The Student filed his request for due process hearing with the Hearing Office on November 26, 2002. The sole issue raised at that time was whether STUDENT should be eligible for special education services. The proposed resolution sought services and an independent assessment. The District filed its request for due process hearing on January 14, 2003, after a mediation session in the Student’s case. The relief sought by the District was a determination that its assessment was appropriate. The District’s request indicated that the basis for the filing was that the parent disagreed with the District’s assessment and wanted an independent assessment. It appears from the file that the assessment in question was that performed by District psychologist Gagnon in the summer of 2002 that found STUDENT ineligible for special education. The two cases were consolidated on the District’s motion on January 31, 2003.
In January 2003, approximately one month before STUDENT’s eighteenth birthday, he was further diagnosed as having a neurologically based “auditory processing and visual motor learning disability and attention-deficit disorder (ADD).” by Dr. Sarah Roddy at the Loma Linda University pediatric neurological clinic. (Footnote 6) His doctor noted in 2003 that the medication would help with his inability to focus and ADD but not his learning disability.
In April 2004, STUDENT’s mother arranged for an additional assessment by independent psychologist Dr. Robert Patterson. STUDENT’s scores and rankings in this assessment generally followed those reported from previous testing. His cognitive functioning was in the high average range. He was in the average to superior ranges in most skills. In the areas of math fluency, academic fluency, and speed for visual and auditory processing, his scores were low. Contrary to the findings of the two District assessors, however, Dr. Patterson concluded that STUDENT met the criteria for special education contained in Title 5, California Code of Regulations, sections 3030 (f) for other health impaired (OHI), and 3030 (j) for specific learning disability (SLD). With respect to his slow processing speed, Dr. Patterson found that STUDENT was a pupil with limited vitality, strength, or alertness due to a long-term condition, which affects his ability to stay focused and to function academically. Dr. Patterson also found that STUDENT had a specific learning disability because of his difficulty with reading, writing, and math calculation speed, that resulted in a severe discrepancy between his ability and performance. He concluded that STUDENT was “slow as molasses,” a characterization with which both STUDENT and his mother agreed. Dr. Patterson recommended compensatory remedial strategies as “how best to deal with STUDENT’s handicap” by placement either in a learning center or in a community college remedial program and counseling for help with his low self-concept.
After the filing of the Student’s case in November 2002, the parties proceeded through mediation sessions in an attempt to resolve their differences. After taking the matter off calendar a number of times, resetting the hearing dates, and continuances, the matter went forward on July 15, 2004.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The Student contends that the District did not appropriately assess him and that he qualifies for special education as OHI and SLD. The District contends that its assessments were appropriate and that Student does not qualify for special education as he receives section 504 accommodations that sufficiently facilitate his achievement. The Student further contends that, because the District’s 1998 and 2002 assessments are inappropriate, his parent is entitled to reimbursement for the IEEs completed by Dr. Berk and Dr. Patterson.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue Number 1: Is the Student currently eligible for special education services under the categories of OHI and/or SLD?
Relying on the psychoeducational report of Dr. Robert Patterson, the Student contends that he is eligible for special education under either one or both of the categories OHI and SLD. The District contends that its assessments in 1998 and 2002 correctly found that STUDENT was not eligible for special education and that his needs can be met in the general education program with accommodations contained in a section 504 plan.
A student’s eligibility for special education is established if the following criteria are met: (1) the student has a disability as defined in federal law, and (2) because of the disability, the student must require instruction, services, or both which cannot be met by modification of the regular school program. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A); California Education Code § 56026(a) and (b). OHI and SLD are among the disabilities included in the federal definition contained in section 1401(3)(A). First, the analysis will focus on OHI.
OHI
Title 5, California Code of Regulations section 3030 (f) sets forth the requirements of OHI eligibility:
A pupil has limited strength, vitality or alertness, due to chronic or acute health problems...which adversely affects a pupil’s educational performance...such physical disabilities shall not be temporary in nature...
OHI eligibility can be established with a diagnosis of ADHD or ADD if the disorder adversely affects the pupil’s educational performance and the pupil otherwise meets the eligibility requirements for OHI:
A pupil whose educational performance is adversely affected by a suspected or diagnosed attention deficit disorder or attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and demonstrates a need for special education and related services by meeting eligibility criteria specified in subdivision (f) or (i) of Section 3030 of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations or Section 56337 and subdivision (j) of Section 3030 of the California Code of Regulations for the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1400 and following) categories of “other health impairments,” “serious emotional disturbance,” or “specific learning disabilities,” is entitled to special education and related services.
California Education Code § 56339(a).
Therefore, a pupil diagnosed with ADHD or ADD qualifies for special education if the pupil (1) meets the criteria for OHI as defined in section 3030(f) or the criteria for SLD as defined in section 3030(j), and (2) because of the disability, the student must require instruction, services, or both which cannot be met by modification of the regular school program.
ADD and OHI eligibility
STUDENT first had a diagnosis of ADHD in 1992 (District Exhibit 9, page 57). In 1995 while still residing in Massachusetts, a neurologist observed that STUDENT’s “symptoms are consistent with a combination of learning disability and ADHD (District Exhibit 9, page 64).” In California in 2000, his pediatrician observed “symptoms of inattentiveness, hyperactivity, and impulsiveness (District Exhibit 13).” In January 2003, STUDENT was evaluated at the Loma Linda University Pediatric Neurological Clinic. The written summary of this examination included entries that STUDENT had auditory processing and visual motor learning disability with a neurological basis and ADD (Student Exhibit 13, page 185). Although there have been interruptions over the years in medication, he is still prescribed psychostimulants to allow him to increase his concentration and decrease restlessness which demonstrates STUDENT’s continuing attentional difficulties (District Exhibit 13; Student Exhibit 13, page 185). Furthermore, the long history of medical diagnoses and treatments show that STUDENT has a permanent, not temporary, condition with ADD.
The evidence of STUDENT’s classroom performance, the observations of his teachers, and his limited academic achievement demonstrates that this condition has limited his strength, vitality, and alertness to the extent that his educational performance has suffered an adverse impact. His teachers report that he has been “slow to start” assignments, has had “trouble understanding instructions,” and has at times completely lost track of the classroom activities by retreating into video games or creating artwork. He demonstrably cannot maintain the pace of the regular classroom routine or workload. This is particularly evident in the comparison of his success in the self-paced, alternative school environment with a very light class load to his program in the comprehensive high school setting. The Hearing Officer, therefore, finds that §STUDENT satisfies the first requirement for special education eligibility, as listed above, of a disability defined in federal law by meeting the criteria for OHI set forth in section 3030(f) of the regulations.
Requirement for instruction which cannot be met by modification of regular program
As discussed above, for a student who seeks special education services it must be shown that the student requires these services to receive a free, appropriate public education and cannot have his or her needs met in the general education program with modifications or accommodations. California Education Code § 56026(b); Title 5, California Code of Regulations § 3030. The District has provided STUDENT with accommodations in a 504 plan that have included additional time to do his work. Even with these accommodations, his Colton High School teachers noted his inattention, need for redirection, and requirement of one-on-one assistance (Student Exhibit 4, page 82; District Exhibit 2, pages 9, 10; District Exhibit 4, page 22). He also substantially failed in the comprehensive high school regular educational setting. At first glance, STUDENT is now functioning well in the general education program at Washington Alternative High School. His high school grades, however, did not reach a “C” level until he transferred to the self-paced alternative school environment with only one or two classes a term. For the last two years, he has received not only passing grades but also several above-average STUDENTs with the accommodations in place. STUDENT was not successful with a full course load in the regular high school program. He has been successful with accommodations in place with a minimum schedule of only one or two classes. The pace of STUDENT’s progress toward a high school diploma is unacceptable. The accommodations have not effectively ameliorated the demonstrated discrepancies to allow him to progress toward graduation.
As of June 2004, STUDENT had accrued 174.50 credits toward the 210.00 that he needs to earn his diploma. This is a shortfall of 35.5 credits. During the eighteen-month period between December 2003 and June 2004, he earned 12.0 credits toward graduation. If he can successfully continue at this pace, he will not complete his high school requirements until December 2008. He will turn twenty two years of age in February 2007. (Footnote 7) Therefore, even with the accommodations in the general education program, STUDENT will not be able to make reasonable progress. A fundamental purpose for providing special education is to meet the pupil’s needs and afford the pupil the opportunity to receive an educational benefit including meeting annual goals to advance at a reasonable pace in school through the individualized education program (IEP) process. 20 U.S.C. § 1414 (d)(1)(A)(iii)(I).
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs special education to receive an educational benefit and that he qualifies for special education services in the category of OHI to meet his needs in order to make reasonable progress.
Normally, if a pupil is found to qualify for special education on one basis, qualification under alternate categories need not be considered as the District is charged with meeting all of the pupil’s needs. 34 C.F.R. § 300.300 (a) (3) (ii). However, as substantial evidence is in the record on SLD and as a guide to the parties, the analysis will now turn to whether STUDENT qualifies for special education under the category of SLD.
SLD
SLD is defined in federal law as a “disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or using language, spoken or written, which disorder may manifest itself in imperfect ability to listen, think, speak, write, spell, or do mathematical calculations.” 20 U.S.C. § 1401(26). State law sets forth three criteria that must be met for this eligibility category:
(a) A severe discrepancy exists between the intellectual ability and achievements in one or more of the following academic areas:
(1) Oral expression.
(2) Listening comprehension.
(3) Written expression.
(4) Basic reading skills.
(5) Reading comprehension.
(6) Mathematics calculation.
(7) Mathematics reasoning.
(b) The discrepancy is due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes and is not the result of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantages.
(c) The discrepancy cannot be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program.
California Education Code section 56337.
A severe discrepancy is established through a formula using standardized test scores, by alternative means when standardized tests are considered invalid, or through a determination by the IEP team that such a discrepancy exists. Title 5, California Code of Regulations §§ 3030(j) (4) (A),(B), and (C). There is nothing in the record indicating that STUDENT’s standardized tests were invalid to assess his ability and achievement. The IEP team did not make an independent determination that such a discrepancy existed. Accordingly, his scores on the intellectual ability or IQ tests can be compared with his scores on his academic achievement tests using the following formula:
When standardized tests are considered to be valid for a specific pupil, a severe discrepancy is demonstrated by: first, computing into common standard scores, using a mean of 100 and standard deviation of 15, the achievement test score and the ability test score to be compared; second, computing the difference between these common standard scores; and third, comparing this computed difference to the standard criterion which is the product of 1.5 multiplied by the standard deviation of the distribution of computed differences of students taking these achievement and ability tests. A computed difference which equals or exceeds this standard criterion, adjusted by one standard error of measurement, the adjustment not to exceed 4 common standard score points, indicates a severe discrepancy when such discrepancy is corroborated by other assessment data which may include other tests, scales, instruments, observations and work samples, as appropriate.
Title 5, California Code of Regulations § 3030(j)(A).
The calculation following this formula customarily interprets the requisite difference for a finding of a severe discrepancy between the full scale ability score and the achievement standard scores to be at least 22.5 points, or 1.5 multiplied by 15, adjusted by one standard of measurement. Therefore, the computed difference must be at least 22.5 points, adjusted by the standard error of measurement not to exceed 4 common standard score points, or a range of 18.5 to 26.5 points. Section 3030(j)(4) of the regulations further requires the IEP team to “take into account all the relevant material which is available on the pupil. No single score or product of scores shall be used as the sole criterion...” (Footnote 8)
Therefore, to qualify for special education as having a specific learning disability, STUDENT must meet the three requirements that (1) a severe discrepancy exists between ability and achievement in one or more of the areas specified in the statute, (2) the severe discrepancy is due to a basic psychological processing disorder, and (3) the severe discrepancy cannot be ameliorated within the regular education program.
Severe Discrepancy
STUDENT’s cognitive level as shown in the record back to his years in Massachusetts has consistently tested in the average to high average range. (Student Exhibit 16, page 6, historical summary). The District’s 1998 assessment included administration of the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children, Third Edition (WISC-III) which reported STUDENT’s full scale IQ at 95, his verbal IQ at 97, and his performance IQ at 94 (District Exhibit 6). The Berk assessment completed in June 2000 as a prerequisite for STUDENT’s attendance in the Pine Ridge School summer program showed, after administration of the WISC-III, a full scale score of 109, and verbal score of 98, and a performance score of 121 (District Exhibit 8). The District’s 2002 assessment included scores on the Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale, Third Edition (WAIS-III), of a full scale IQ at 110, verbal IQ at 103, and performance IQ at 117. The Patterson assessment in 2004, using the Woodcock-Johnson Psycho-Educational Test Battery-Third Revision (WJ-III), indicated a full scale IQ of 105 within a range of 102-107 (Student Exhibit 16).
His academic performance scores also have been, for the most part, historically consistent in the average to low average range (Student Exhibit 16, pages 6,7, historical summary). The District’s 1998 assessment, using the Woodcock-Johnson Achievement Test-Revised (WJ-R), reported average skill levels in reading and mathematics and “low average academic skills” in written language. All of STUDENT’s reported standard scores on the District’s 1998 administration of the WJ-R were well within 22.5 points of his full-scale IQ at that time of 95 (District Exhibit 6, pages 3,4).
Dr. Berk’s administration of the Peabody Individual Achievement Test (PIAT) in 2000 reported rankings in reading comprehension at the 17th percentile and spelling at the 3rd percentile, but did not report comparable standard scores. Dr. Berk concluded that STUDENT’s “learning is compromised by the combined influence of severe attentional deficits and conjoint learning disabilities involving auditory language processing.” (District Exhibit 9)
The District’s 2002 assessment using the PIAT, revised, reported reading comprehension at the 27th percentile, and written language and total reading both at the 32nd percentile with standard scores reported within 22.5 points of STUDENT’s full-scale IQ as measured at the time of 110. This same District assessment indicated a spelling ranking of the 18th percentile with a score of 86 on the WIAT-II, and an oral reading quotient at the 34th percentile level, a passage score at the 25th percentile, and reading rate at the 5th percentile on the Gray Oral Reading Test, Third Edition (GORT-III) (District Exhibit 5).
In comparison, the Patterson 2004 achievement scores on the WJ-III included broad reading at the 12th percentile with a standard score of 83. The subtests in this category included letter-word identification at the 41st percentile with a score of 96, reading fluency at the 2nd percentile with a score of 70, and a passage comprehension at the 60th percentile with a score of 104. His overall result in the broad math cluster was a ranking at the 40th percentile with a standard score of 96, but with subtest results of calculations at the 59th percentile with a score of 104, math fluency at the 2nd percentile, with a score of 68, and an applied math ranking at the 62nd percentile with a score of 104. In broad written language STUDENT ranked at the 6th percentile with a standard score of 77. The subtests in this cluster placed STUDENT at the 19th percentile in spelling, with a standard score of 87, writing fluency at the 2nd percentile with a score of 70, and a writing sample at the 44th percentile with a score of 98. STUDENT’s academic fluency ranked at the 1st percentile with a standard score of 64. STUDENT’s 2004 scores on the WJ-III processes also showed sharp contrasts between and within the clusters. For example, his auditory processing, conceptualization, short-term memory, and working memory scores were all in excess of 100. STUDENT’s executive processing included concept formation ranking at the 94th percentile with a standard score of 123, planning at the 99th percentile with a score of 130+, but with pair cancellation below the 1st percentile with a score of 62. His processing speed was at the 3rd percentile with a score of 72 in both subtests. (Student Exhibit 16).
District assessor Michael Gagnon commented on Dr. Patterson’s report during his testimony at the hearing. Psychologist Gagnon acknowledged that in his 2002 testing, STUDENT received below average scores in timed tests in mathematics, reading, and writing as was similarly reflected in the Patterson report two years later. He viewed STUDENT’s slow pace that resulted in the lowest scores as a choice to emphasize accuracy at the expense of speed and the task is to “understand how STUDENT learns.” Mr. Gagnon did not find a severe discrepancy as the timed tests in each of these areas were averaged with other scores in these categories as part of the testing cluster that yielded composite achievement scores within 22.5 points of STUDENT’s cognitive level. Mr. Gagnon concluded that the clusters were “more valid” than looking at the component scores that were broken out in the Patterson results. Although Dr. Patterson’s conclusions of a severe discrepancy between STUDENT’s cognitive ability and achievement were based on individual scores that were part of a cluster, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that to do otherwise would effectively hide STUDENT’s disabilities in recognized categories for special education.
Mr. Gagnon noted that STUDENT described himself as “a poor reader”and that STUDENT had previously commented that doing well on school tests was not helpful to him after “all that my mother has done for me.” Although STUDENT did not finish or attempt portions of some of the standardized tests and assessments in evidence, there is no indication thathe systematically tried or was successful at trying to skew any of the test results in the record. Mr. Gagnon, who has substantial experience with special needs students, concluded that STUDENT “thinks fine.” STUDENT, he observed, could recall what was said in a statement read to him unlike other children with auditory processing problems with whom he had worked. From this perspective, Mr. Gagnon concluded that STUDENT’s slow pace in the testing process was a result of being “more thoughtful” or wanting to be accurate rather than a processing or neurological disability. The record, however, of STUDENT’s behavior and test results show a similar pattern back to the earliest grades.
A review of the Patterson assessment presents a severe discrepancy in a number of categories. Comparing STUDENT’s scaled IQ score of 105 with the achievement scores demonstrates discrepancies that are 22.5 or more points lower in categories including reading, math, writing, and academic fluency. The Patterson assessment also shows a number of average to above average skills side by side with STUDENT poorer skills. STUDENT scores high in the broad reading cluster in letter-word ID and passage comprehension but receives a score 35 points lower than his cognitive ability low in reading fluency. He scores well into the average range in the broad math cluster but is 37 points below his cognitive level in math fluency. His broad written language cluster score is 77 reflecting a discrepancy of 27.5 from his full-scale IQ of 105. Being able to read fluently is a basic reading skill. Math fluency is also a significant part of mathematics calculation. Moreover, viewing Dr. Patterson’s findings in light of section 3030 (j)(4) of the applicable regulations, the findings are consistent with “other relevant material which is available,” such as the medical evidence extending from STUDENT’s early elementary grades to 1993 that he has learning disabilities, prior testing including Dr. Berk’s report and the District’s 1998 and 2002 assessments, and his academic performance before he enrolled in the alternative high school program. The Patterson results also do not rely on a “single score or product of scores,” as several of STUDENT’s test results support Dr. Patterson’s finding. Furthermore, Dr. Patterson’s results are afforded more weight and are more appropriate to an assessment of current eligibility for special education because they are recent. The District’s latest assessment is over two years old. Although the District correctly points out that STUDENT does have average to strong skills in most portions of each of the academic clusters, the Hearing Officer finds that he has severe discrepancies in the qualifying categories listed in California Education Code section 56337(a) of basic reading skills, mathematics calculation, and written expression.
Basic psychological processing disorder
Qualification for special education under the category of specific learning disability requires that:
A pupil has a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or in using language, spoken or written, which may manifest itself in an impaired ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell, or do mathematical calculations...
Title 5 California Code of Regulations § 3030(j).
A recurrent theme in all of the assessments and teacher observations in evidence is that STUDENT is slow in processing information. He has consistently up to last year been diagnosed with ADD which is recognized as a category for eligibility under California Education Code section 56339(a) if he also meets the criteria in section 3030(j) of the regulations. (Footnote 9) The evidence demonstrates that STUDENT meets theses criteria with his slowness in reading, writing, and mathematics. Although District psychologist Michael Gagnon correctly indicated that slow “speed” is not a qualifying condition under the California Education Code for special education, the Hearing Officer views speed as a symptom of that processing disability in the use of written and spoken language, which has manifested itself in STUDENT’s impaired ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell, and do effective mathematical calculations. Additionally, the evidence of the severely discrepant individual scores within the academic clusters also supports a finding of a processing disability that has impacted his academic performance. STUDENT’s medical history and classroom performance are consistent with these scores. With respect to the statutory limitations on considering disorders in basic psychological processes contained in California Education Code section 56337(b), there is also no evidence that any discrepancy in the record is the result of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantages.
The Hearing Officer finds that the evidence persuasively establishes that STUDENT has a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or using language that manifests itself in an impaired ability to read, write, or do mathematical calculations.
Discrepancy cannot be ameliorated within the regular education program
As discussed in detail with respect to OHI, above, modification of the regular program through a 504 plan has been insufficient to allow STUDENT to make reasonable progress in high school. Mr. Gagnon said that Dr. Patterson’s findings did not indicate how STUDENT’s academic skills were adversely affected by his disability. Mr. Gagnon stated that there was no “showing of academic discrepancies” and that the low scores were not of a major concern as STUDENT was performing at his ability level without an adverse effect on his academic performance, although this assessor reported that STUDENT “failed six classes during the 2001-2002 school year...Four other courses he took were D or D- grades.” The record, however, shows a lack of academic success in the comprehensive high school program until June 2002, and minimal progress in the alternative high school setting afterwards. For the reasons considered in connection with OHI, above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs special education to receive an educational benefit and further finds that he qualifies for special education services in the category of SLD.
Issue Number 2: Is the Student’s parent entitled to reimbursement from the District for Dr. Steven Berk’s psychoeducational assessment dated June 2000?
A student’s parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation (IEE) performed by a qualified expert at district expense if the following requirements are met:
1. The parents disagree with an evaluation obtained by the district;
2. The district is unable to show at a due process hearing that its evaluation was appropriate.
34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b)
The Student is seeking in this proceeding reimbursement for the June 2000 assessment performed by Dr. Steven Berk in Norwood, Massachusetts. In further support of the reimbursement claim, the Student contends that his mother disagreed with District psychologist Patty Metheny’s 1998 psychoeducational assessment.
The threshold issue raised during the hearing was that the Student must first make a showing why the Hearing Officer can consider reimbursement for a June 2000 independent assessment that follows a disagreement with a 1998 school district assessment. There is a three-year statute of limitations applicable in due process cases under California Education Code section 56505 (j). (Footnote 10) The Student’s request for this due process hearing was filed on November 26, 2002. The Petitioner’s mother, however, testified that she did not consent to the District’s 1998 assessment and that it was not until review of STUDENT’s educational records in 2002 that she discovered a copy of the 1998 consent form purportedly with a forgery of her signature. As MOTHER’s testimony raised a contention that an unauthorized, and therefore potentially inappropriate, District assessment was not known to her until within the statute of limitations, the Hearing Officer allowed the Student to adduce evidence concerning the 1998 District assessment and reimbursement for the June 2000 assessment.
MOTHER testified that she disagreed with the 1998 assessment, but did not raise such a disagreement in 1998. However, she indicated that she was aware of Ms. Patty Metheny’s assessment in 1998 and participated in the November 1998 IEP team discussion of the results but raised no objections to the conduct or the appropriateness of the assessment. The November 2002 due process hearing request did not raise an issue concerning the 1998 assessment. The claim of inappropriateness based on a purportedly forged approval to the assessment plan was not raised until the hearing although MOTHER testified that she discovered the document in 2002. Whether or not MOTHER consented to the 1998 assessment, the record indicates that she concurred with the rest of the IEP team members in November 1998 and accepted Ms. Metheny’s finding of ineligibility for special education although MOTHER did question some of the specific results at the IEP meeting. Therefore, MOTHER was aware of the assessment in 1998, which precludes further consideration of this issue on statue of limitations grounds.
Even if the issue were not barred by the statue of limitations, the Berk assessment was approximately two years after the challenged District’s assessment. MOTHER also freely stated during her testimony that the 2000 Berk assessment was on her sister’s referral and was a prerequisite for STUDENT’s unilateral placement at the Pine Ridge school summer residential remedial program that her sister suggested near her sister’s summer home rather than because of a disagreement with the District’s 1998 assessment. Additionally, her sister, and not MOTHER, paid Dr. Berk for his assessment. MOTHER made no demand on behalf of the Student that the District pay for the 2000 independent assessment until after filing for a due process hearing more than two years later.
In summary, the evidence does not show a link between the 1998 District assessment and the 2000 Berk assessment. Additionally, the Berk assessment is relatively remote in time to the 1998 assessment. In her testimony, MOTHER clearly indicated that the Berk assessment was solely for the impending summer program at Pine Ridge and not conducted to address STUDENT’s special education eligibility, placement, or services in the District or as a “second opinion” to the 1998 assessment. Moreover, the Student’s parent cannot be “reimbursed” that for which she did not pay. For these reasons in addition to the statue of limitations bar, the Hearing Officer finds that the Student’s parent is not entitled to reimbursement for the Berk assessment under California Education Code section 56329 (b). In light of these findings, the Hearing Officer need not reach the issue of the appropriateness of the 1998 assessment or the claim of a forged consent to assess.
Issue Number 3: Is the Student’s parent entitled to reimbursement from the District for Dr. Robert Patterson’s psychoeducational assessment dated May 2004?
As with the Berk assessment, the record does not show a link between the Patterson assessment and a District prior assessment. The Patterson assessment was also relatively remote in time conducted approximately two years after the District’s 2002 assessment and approximately one and one half years after the Student’s due process request was filed. MOTHER testified that she arranged for the Patterson assessment on a mediator’s suggestion as there was no current data on STUDENT. This statement underscores that the Patterson assessment was not because of a disagreement with Mr. Gagnon’s 2002 assessment, but appears to have been performed for purposes of supporting the Student’s position at hearing. Nevertheless, the original 2002 due process request proposed an IEE as resolution for the issue of STUDENT’s special education eligibility. MOTHER also testified that the due process request was her “objection” in writing to the 2002 assessment. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer will consider the issue of the parent’s entitlement to reimbursement for the Patterson assessment.
The initial inquiry is to determine if District psychologist Michael Gagnon’s 2002 assessment was appropriate. An assessment must conform with California Education Code sections 56320 and 56322 to be deemed appropriate. Additionally, psychological assessments must be conducted by a credentialed school psychologist under California Education Code section 56324. Subsections (a) through (d) of section 56320, require that testing and assessment materials and procedures be selected and administered in a manner not to be racially, culturally or sexually discriminatory; provided and administered in the student’s primary language or other mode of communication; be validated for the purposes for which they are used; administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; tailored to assess specific areas of need; and selected and administered to ensure that, when administered to a pupil with impaired speaking skills, the test produces results that accurately reflect the student’s aptitude, achievement level, or any other factors the test purports to measure and not the student’s impaired speaking skills. The assessor also must be knowledgeable of the student’s disability. California Education Code § 56320 (g).
The uncontroverted evidence is that Mr. Gagnon was a California credentialed school psychologist in 2002. He had served in that capacity for at least seven years at the time of the assessment. He also held pupil personnel and teaching credentials. He had four years of classroom experience, mostly in special education. He also holds a national certification as a school psychologist and is licensed in California as a educational psychologist permitting him to practice outside the school system. Both STUDENT and Mr. Gagnon testified that the testing proceeded in a communicative and relatively relaxed manner. Mr. Gagnon credibly testified that he used recognized test instruments suited to STUDENT’s assessment needs and followed the test makers’ instruction manual in the administration of each instrument. Both STUDENT and his mother made unsubstantiated criticisms of Mr. Gagnon’s methodology. STUDENT stated that the District assessors in 2002 (Footnote 11) “always repeated” the questions and “talked slow like I was below their intelligence.” MOTHER stated that Mr. Gagnon did not consider the medical doctors’ letters in the file and improperly recalculated some of Dr. Berk’s results in the 2000 assessment. There is persuasive evidence, however, that Mr. Gagnon chose suitable test materials, followed proper test procedures, and heeded the test makers’ instructions. The fact that he believed a miscalculation appeared in the Berk report and that he referred to the medical opinions in the file only show that Mr. Gagnon did review and consider these items. The results Mr. Gagnon obtained were substantially consistent with prior assessments and Dr. Patterson’s subsequent 2004 assessment. The substantial agreement in findings among the Metheny, Berk, Gagnon, and Patterson reports is noteworthy. All four assessors recognized STUDENT’s social, emotional, and self esteem issues. Three assessors expressly recommended counseling. The different conclusion in the Gagnon report, alone, does not render the assessment “inappropriate” under the standards in the California Education Code. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s 2002 psychoeducational assessment was performed by an experienced, trained, and credentialed school psychologist who was knowledgeable about the Student’s disabilities, administered the proper test instruments in accordance with the test makers’ instructions, and substantially accurately measured the Student’s aptitude and achievement levels thereby rendering this assessment appropriate as a matter of law. Therefore, no further issues need be reached and there is no basis for the Hearing Officer to award reimbursement for Dr. Patterson’s report in light of this finding.
ORDER
(1) The IEP team shall convene within no less than ten calendar days of the date of this Decision to develop an IEP for the Student.
(2) All other requests for relief of the parties are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
(1) The Student prevailed.
(2) The District prevailed.
(3) The District prevailed.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
DATED: September 3, 2004 _______________________ Tracy L. Tibbals, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The wording of the issues here differs somewhat from the statements of issues filed by the parties before the hearing and stated on the record before the presentation of evidence. Changes in the language and in the order were made for clarity and to facilitate analysis in this Decision.
2. Section 504 of the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973, 29 U.S.C. sections 794, et seq., is designed to afford accommodations to pupils who have a physical or mental impairment which substantially limits a major life activity that may not qualify as a recognized category for special education services under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 U.S.C. sections 1400, et seq.
3. STUDENT’s mother asserted at the due process hearing that her signature assenting to Ms. Metheny’s October 1998 assessment plan was a forgery. She contends that she discovered the forgery in 2002 while reviewing STUDENT’s school records. She also alleges that she did not sign the assessment plan when it was presented to her in 1998, because a copy of parental rights was not on the reverse of the form as it stated above the place for her signature. She did raise questions about the assessment results at the November 2002 IEP meeting, but did not object to the fact that the assessment occurred. She assented to the termination of special education services along with the other IEP team members. MOTHER had not asserted the forgery issue or the lack of the consent to the 1998 assessment prior to the hearing in July 2004.
4. The Orton-Gillingham method is a remedial reading program that is highly structured and emphasizes a multi-sensory approach.
5. MOTHER acknowledged that she did sign the assessment plan consenting to Mr. Gagnon’s 2002 assessment.
6. His doctors have prescribed medication for ADHD and ADD from 1992 to the present with the exception of a four-year break. STUDENT took Ritalin daily until he was in the seventh grade. He began taking Concerta, a long-acting form of Ritalin, in 2002.
7. A student is “aged out” of special education at twenty-two years of age. California Education Code § 56026. As STUDENT’s birthday is in January, this code section permits him to continue in special education through the end of the fiscal year and, if applicable, the extended school year after his twenty-second birthday.
8. An article in California School Psychologist challenges this method. Helm and Johnson, Updated Tables Needed to Determine a Severe Discrepancy Under California Title 5 Regulations, 8 Cal. Sch. Psychologist 19 (1998). This article argues that the formula must factor in the correlation between the specific ability and achievement tests used by calculation of a correlation coefficient rather than only finding the difference in scores. There is no evidence in this record to support the approach in this article for STUDENT’s scores. As federal law does not specify a numerical difference to find a severe discrepancy, the cited method set forth in the California regulations will be applied in this case.
9. ADD is discussed in greater length, below, with respect to OHI.
10 The Legislature amended this section in 1991 to read: “Any request for a due process hearing...shall be filed within three years from the date the party initiating the request knew or had reason to know of the facts underlying the basis for the request.”
11. The District also arranged for an occupational therapy assessment in 2002 at the request of STUDENT’s mother.
