California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 25, 2003
Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 2662-02 · Hearing Officer Lawrence E. Mendel
Los Angeles Unified must reimburse private speech therapy, OT, and an independent assessment; May Center reimbursement denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
Parents of a 10-year-old eligible for special education based on traumatic brain injury and a specific learning disability filed against Los Angeles Unified School District. The case covered occupational therapy (OT) and speech-language therapy from November 27, 1999, the start of the three-year limitations period, plus a placement offer and reimbursement.
The Hearing Officer found the District failed to offer or provide appropriate OT and speech-language services in every school year. The District did not show its providers at the Julia Ann Singer School understood the student's disability. Its goals missed needs such as word finding and memory. Its later offers of group speech therapy and minimal or consultation-only OT were too little. The student's progress was credited to private therapists Sheila Moskowitz and Abby Yolles. The May 2001 IEP named no specific school, which violated the formal written offer rule of Union School District v. Smith. Even so, the parents did not show that their two-week placement at the May Center in Massachusetts was appropriate, so those costs and their search costs were denied.
The District must reimburse the private speech therapy, the private OT, and Dr. Nina Kogan's psychoeducational assessment, which it relied on after dropping its own assessment. Within 30 days, it must revise the IEP to add speech goals and 60 weekly minutes each of individual speech therapy and OT. Ongoing private services were denied because District therapists were qualified.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO placed the burden on a district to prove its therapists understood a student's unique disability. Progress made while a family was paying for private therapy was credited to that therapy. A district that drops its own assessment and relies on a parent's private evaluation was ordered to reimburse the parent for it.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1a1. For the 1999-2000 school year, including ESY: Did the District fail to offer and provide appropriate occupational therapy services?
The goals covered the student's needs, but 60 minutes a week was not enough. The District did not show its therapist understood the student's disability, and the student made no progress.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1a2. For the 1999-2000 school year, including ESY: Did the District fail to offer and provide appropriate speech/language services?
The July 1999 IEP had no goals for abstract reasoning, word finding, short-term memory, or oral motor needs. Progress was credited to the private therapy, not the District's services.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1b1. For the 2000-2001 school year, including ESY: Did the District fail to offer and provide appropriate occupational therapy services?
No new goals addressed a new visual-motor need. The District presented no evidence of any OT provided after July 2000; stopping the provider at the parent's request did not end its duty to provide OT.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1b2. For the 2000-2001 school year, including ESY: Did the District fail to offer and provide appropriate speech/language services?
The deficient July 1999 speech goals carried over, so the failure to offer appropriate speech/language services continued. A separate claim that no annual IEP was held was rejected because the delays were mutually agreed.
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1c1. For the 2001-2002 school year: Did the District fail to make an offer of an appropriate placement at the May 29, 2001 IEP team meeting?
The IEP named no specific nonpublic school. A June 2000 'funding' letter listing three schools was not a formal written offer under Union v. Smith, so no placement was offered.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1c2. Following placement at Westwood Charter School, did the District fail to offer and provide appropriate occupational therapy services?
The goals were adequate, but 30 minutes a week of direct OT plus 15 minutes of consultation was not enough. Progress was credited mainly to the private OT.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1c3. Following placement at Westwood Charter School, did the District fail to offer and provide appropriate speech/language services?
The needs and goals were properly identified, and the District therapist used appropriate strategies. However, the subtle nature of the student's deficits required individual rather than small-group therapy, so 60 minutes a week of group therapy was inappropriate.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1d1. For the 2002-2003 school year, including ESY: Did the District fail to offer and provide appropriate occupational therapy services?
The December 2002 goals were appropriate, but 60 minutes a month of consultation was inadequate. The student needed 60 minutes a week of individual OT.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1d2. For the 2002-2003 school year, including ESY: Did the District fail to offer and provide appropriate speech/language services?
The single goal did not address pragmatics, linguistic flexibility, or linguistic abstracts. Thirty minutes a week of group therapy was inadequate; 60 minutes a week of individual therapy was needed.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2a. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for private speech/language services provided by Sheila Moskowitz, November 1999 to the present?
The private speech therapy replaced services the District failed to provide and was appropriate. Providing more than 'some benefit' is no basis to reduce reimbursement.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2b. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for private occupational therapy provided by Abby Yolles, September 2000 to the present?
The private OT replaced services the District failed to provide, accurately addressed the student's needs, and produced continuous progress.
- Student prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 2c. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the independent educational assessment of Dr. Nina Kogan completed in September 2000?
The District had not unreasonably delayed its assessment. But it dropped the assessment once the parents hired Dr. Kogan and then relied on her report, so it must reimburse the cost.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2d. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the May Center placement (tuition, transportation, lodging) and the parents' placement search costs, including travel to the May Center and Morningside Academy in Seattle?
The District denied FAPE for 2001-2002, but the parents did not show the May Center was appropriate; the student was withdrawn after about two weeks. All related costs were denied.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. Does STUDENT require ongoing private speech/language services of two hours a week for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year, including ESY?
The District's therapist, Ms. Bader, is qualified, so private services are not required. The District must instead offer at least 60 minutes a week of individual speech therapy with new goals.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4. Does STUDENT require ongoing private occupational therapy services of one hour a week for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year, including ESY?
The District's therapist, Ms. Kelly, is qualified, so private services are not required. The District must instead offer at least 60 minutes a week of individual OT.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days of receiving proof of cost, reimburse the cost of private speech/language therapy by Sheila Moskowitz from November 27, 1999 through the date of the Decision. No amount stated.
- Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days of receiving proof of cost, reimburse the cost of private occupational therapy by Abby Yolles from September 2000 through the date of the Decision. No amount stated.
- IEE at public expense. Within 30 calendar days of receiving proof of cost, reimburse the cost of Dr. Nina Kogan's psychoeducational assessment (the order describes it as done 'in September and August of 2000'). No amount stated.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 30 calendar days of the Decision, convene an IEP meeting to revise the December 2, 2002 IEP. The team must draft new speech/language goals covering short-term memory and word finding, pragmatics, linguistic flexibility, linguistic abstracts, and higher order reasoning such as inferences and prediction.
- Order to provide or change services. Revise the December 2, 2002 IEP to provide 60 minutes a week of individual speech/language therapy for the new goals and 60 minutes a week of individual OT for the existing goals. The IEP team decides whether District staff or a nonpublic agency provides the services.
Key authorities
Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; School Committee of Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; 34 C.F.R. § 300.403; Educ. Code § 56329; Educ. Code § 56321; Educ. Code § 56365
People named in the decision
- Lori Waldinger, parent advocate and educational consultant (witness)
- Dr. Nancy Niparko, treating neurologist (witness)
- Abby Yolles, private occupational therapist (witness)
- Sheila Moskowitz, private speech-language pathologist (witness)
- Alana Ronen, speech/language specialist (witness)
- Sharon Snyder, speech-language assessor (1999), Los Angeles Unified School District
- Shellie Bader, speech-language pathologist at Westwood Charter School, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Stacey Kelly, occupational therapist (from September 2002), Los Angeles Unified School District
- Maria Lucas, occupational therapy assessor (1999), Los Angeles Unified School District
- Harriet Maglin, nonpublic school coordinator, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Barbara Killian, special education teacher, Westwood Charter School, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Fei Xiong (formerly Maynard), occupational therapist at Westwood Charter School, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Edie Bartnoff (also spelled Barnoff), vice principal, Julia Ann Singer School (nonpublic school)
- Susan Brown, former speech/language therapist at Julia Ann Singer School, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Marianne McKim, occupational therapist (December 1999-July 2000), Los Angeles Unified School District
- Dr. Nina Kogan, developmental and clinical psychologist; independent psychoeducational assessor
- Howard Gellerman, chair of the May 29, 2001 IEP meeting, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Harriet Oken, teacher, Westwood Charter School
- Victoria McKendall, administrator of due process, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Deborah Neal, due process specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Shari Robertson, due process specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Barbara Dixon, due process specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Susan Glickman, due process specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Julia Ann Singer School, nonpublic school (prior placement)
- May Center, private residential school in Massachusetts (unilateral placement)
- Frostig School, nonpublic school considered
- Village Glen, nonpublic school considered
- Dubnoff, nonpublic school listed in District funding letter
- Morningside Academy, private school in Seattle visited by the parents
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Lawrence E. Mendel, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Los Angeles, California, on April 22, 23, 24, 25, and May 1, 2, 5, and 8, 2003.
STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Thomas Beltran. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf at different times during the hearing were MOTHER, his mother, and FATHER, his father. Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District (Respondent or District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Christopher Fernandes. Also present on the District’s behalf at different times during the hearing were Victoria McKendall, District administrator of due process; Deborah Neal, due process specialist; Shari Robertson, due process specialist; Barbara Dixon, due process specialist; and Susan Glickman, due process specialist.
The following witnesses were called to testify at the hearing: Lori Waldinger, parent advocate and educational consultant; MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother; Dr. Nancy Niparko, neurologist; Abby Yolles, occupational therapist; Sheila Moskowitz, speech/language pathologist; Alana Ronen speech/language specialist; Sharon Snyder, speech language specialist; Shellie Bader, speech/language pathologist; Stacey Kelly, occupational therapist; Maria Lucas, occupational therapist; Harriet Maglin, nonpublic school coordinator; Barbara Killian, teacher; Fei Xiong, occupational therapist; and Edie Barnoff, vice principle of the Julia Ann Singer School.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Upon the receipt of closing arguments, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL HISTORY
This case was filed on November 27, 2002. Cal. Education Code section 56505(j) provides for a three-year statute of limitations for special education due process hearings. Therefore, the issues addressed in this case are limited to the time period November 27, 1999, to the present.
In his closing argument, counsel for the District argued that on the first day of the hearing the only issue identified by Petitioner in relation to the District’s offer and provision of speech/language and occupational therapy services was the qualifications of the District’s providers. Counsel argues that Petitioner’s disputes with the goals, objectives, and amount of services were never specifically raised and consideration of those issues should be barred. The Hearing Officer notes that this argument was only raised in the District’s closing argument. This narrowing of the issues was not discussed on the first day of hearing, nor was it raised at any point during the hearing. The Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner’s statement of the issues, both in writing and on the first day of hearing, did identify concerns with the goals and objectives and the amount of services offered by the District.
At the conclusion of the hearing, it was agreed that the record would be left open for the filing by Respondent of brief declarations from Susan Brown, a former District speech/language therapist, and Marianne McKim, a District occupational therapist. The affidavits were to relate only to the licensing, certification and experience of those two individuals. A declaration of Susan Brown was submitted on May 19, 2003. Respondent was not able to obtain a declaration from Ms. McKim, but counsel for Respondent filed his own declaration as to Ms. McKim’s licensing in the State of California. Both declarations were accepted by the Hearing Officer and admitted as Respondent’s exhibit numbers 41 (Ms. Brown’s declaration) and 42 (counsel’s declaration).
ISSUES(Footnote 1)
1. Did the District fail to offer STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) for the time period of November 27, 1999 through the present?
a. For the 1999-2000 school year, including the extended school year:
1. Did the District fail to offer and provide STUDENT with appropriate occupational therapy services? 2. Did the District fail to offer and provide STUDENT with appropriate speech/language services?
b. For the 2000-2001 school year, including the extended school year:
1. Did the District fail to offer and provide STUDENT with appropriate occupational therapy services? 2. Did the District fail to offer and provide STUDENT with appropriate speech/language services?
c. For the 2001-2002 school year, including the extended school year:
1. Did the District fail to make an offer of an appropriate placement at the May 29, 2001 IEP team meeting? 2. Following STUDENT’s placement at the Westwood Charter School, did the District fail to offer and provide STUDENT with appropriate occupational therapy services? 3. Following STUDENT’s placement at the Westwood Charter School, did the District fail to offer and provide STUDENT with appropriate speech/language services?
d. For the 2002-2003 school year, including the extended school year:
1. Did the District fail to offer and provide STUDENT with appropriate occupational therapy services? 2. Did the District fail to offer and provide STUDENT with appropriate speech/language services?
2. As a result of the District’s alleged failures for the time period of November 27, 1999, to the present, is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the following:
a. The cost of private speech/language services provided by Sheila Moskowitz for the time period November 1999 to the present? b. The cost of private occupational therapy services provided by Abby Yolles for the time period September 2000 to the present? c. The cost of the independent educational assessment of Dr. Nina Kogan completed in September 2000? d. The cost of STUDENT’s placement at the May Center, including tuition, transportation, lodging, and the cost of the PARENTS’ search for a new placement, including travel costs for visiting the May Center as well as the Morningside Academy in Seattle?
3. Does STUDENT require ongoing private speech/language services of two hours a week for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year, including the extended school year?
4. Does STUDENT require ongoing private occupational therapy services of one hour a week for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year, including the extended school year?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a ten-year-old student who just completed the fourth grade at the Westwood Charter School (Westwood) within the Los Angeles Unified School District. STUDENT has been eligible for special education and related services since he was three years old based on a traumatic brain injury (TBI) and a specific learning disability (SLD). An accident during a Cesarean Section birth resulted in trauma to the right side of STUDENT’s brain. STUDENT suffered a stroke shortly after birth, which caused more damage to his brain. As a result, STUDENT experienced seizures, paralysis to his left side, difficulty with perception, and memory impairment. STUDENT began receiving physical therapy (PT) soon after birth, and occupational therapy (OT) at about nine months of age. He began receiving speech/language (S/L) therapy at approximately eighteen months of age. STUDENT’s speech/language therapist was Sheila Moskowitz, who has continued to provide services to STUDENT through the present. STUDENT also received extensive treatment from neurologists and other medical professionals. Due to extensive early intervention, STUDENT’s seizures have resolved, and the effects of the paralysis are almost unnoticeable except when STUDENT is tired. Although STUDENT has made significant progress, he continues to have problems in the areas of S/L and OT.
In 1996, when STUDENT first started attending Hancock Park Elementary School within the District, he was ambulatory, but nonverbal. He was starting to learn sign language and had only limited use of his left arm. STUDENT began having some severe behavior problems and, in July 1997, STUDENT’s IEP team recommended changing his placement to the Julia Ann Singer School (JAS), a nonpublic school. The team also recommended S/L services, counseling and an OT assessment. When STUDENT began attending JAS, he was receiving S/L therapy from Susan Brown at the school for a total of sixty minutes a week and also continued to receive private S/L therapy after school from Ms. Moskowitz. STUDENT was not receiving any OT at this time.(Footnote 2)
Following his triennial evaluation, STUDENT’s IEP meeting was held in July 1999. The IEP team noted that STUDENT had made significant progress in the areas of communication and behavior. However, STUDENT continued to have difficulty staying on topic, maintaining attention, and controlling impulsive behavior. He also continued to have tantrums when he did not get his way, but these were decreasing.
Despite STUDENT’s progress in his communication skills, there was significant disagreement between the PARENTS and the District over STUDENT’s speech and language needs. The District’s assessment found that STUDENT could express his needs and wants using complete sentences with age appropriate semantics, morphology, and syntax. In addition, the District found that STUDENT displayed good pragmatic language skills and could ask and answer questions appropriately. STUDENT demonstrated no word finding problems. The District assessor did find that STUDENT had difficulty with abstract reasoning and some higher order thinking. Ms. Moskowitz, the private S/L therapist, believed that STUDENT had poor pragmatic skills with difficulty staying on topic, turn-taking in conversation, understanding idioms, and distractibility. Ms. Moskowitz also found that STUDENT had difficulty asking appropriate questions in conversation. She also believed STUDENT had significant difficulty with short-term memory and retrieval from memory resulting in word finding problems. Ms. Moskowitz agreed that STUDENT had difficulty with abstract reasoning.
Despite the PARENTS’ continued requests for OT services, school-based OT had not yet begun.(Footnote 3) The OT assessment found that STUDENT had weaknesses in the areas of fine motor skills, bilateral motor skills, and visual perception. He also demonstrated problems with staying on task, poor impulse control, and easy distractibility.
The IEP team recommended S/L therapy and OT for a total of sixty minutes a week each. There was to be additional OT services to make up for the delay in starting OT, but the amount was not specified. Goals and objectives were drafted in the areas of pre-math, pre-reading, oral language, S/L, behavior, fine motor, vocational education, and OT. MOTHER disagreed with the S/L assessment in its entirety. The IEP notes that MOTHER also had concerns about the OT services but was willing to agree to them in the interest of getting the OT started as soon as possible.
MOTHER testified that OT services did not begin right after the July 1999 IEP meeting. The May 2001 IEP indicated that OT was provided from December 1999 through July 2000 by Marianne McKim. MOTHER testified that she was very dissatisfied with Ms. McKim’s services. In addition, MOTHER was not satisfied with the S/L services that Susan Brown was providing. In July 2000, MOTHER requested that both the school-based OT and S/L services be discontinued because MOTHER did not feel that the providers were familiar with STUDENT’s disability or properly trained in serving a TBI student. The District agreed and stopped providing school-based OT and S/L services in July 2000.
By the end of the 1999-2000 school year, the PARENTS believed that STUDENT’s behavior had improved to the point that it was time to consider changing his placement from JAS to a school more focused on academics. This desire was further reinforced by safety issues that had arisen at JAS. Edie Bartnoff, the vice-principle at JAS, testified that it is not uncommon for JAS students to move to a less restrictive environment once their behavior is better controlled. Ms. Bartnoff testified that the JAS staff agreed with the PARENTS that STUDENT no longer needed the intensive behavioral support provided by JAS.
At the end of the 1999-2000 school year, the PARENTS began searching for a new placement. The PARENTS were assisted by Harriet Maglin, the District NPS coordinator, Ms. Bartnoff, and other resources that MOTHER had developed. MOTHER testified that the schools she contacted were requesting a current psychoeducational assessment on STUDENT. MOTHER stated that she had requested a psychoeducational assessment from JAS in April or May of 2000, but nothing was done.(Footnote 4) In July 2000, MOTHER again requested a new assessment and was told that it would take two months to complete and that the testing would be done by interns. The PARENTS believed that the JAS plan for testing was too slow and not appropriate, and contracted with Nina Kogan, a developmental and clinical psychologist, to perform an assessment of STUDENT. Dr. Kogan completed her testing in July and early August of 2000. After Dr. Kogan completed her assessment, the District discontinued its plans to assess STUDENT.
In her search for a new placement, MOTHER testified that she was looking for a school with a strong academic program and expertise in working with TBI children. She visited numerous schools including the Frostig School and Village Glen, both nonpublic schools. Initially, both the PARENTS and the District were hoping that STUDENT would be accepted at the Frostig School, but in August 2000 the PARENTS received notice that the Frostig School had not accepted STUDENT. As a result, STUDENT returned to JAS for the 2000-2001 school year pursuant to the July 1999 IEP. MOTHER continued her search for a new placement. Eventually she began to look outside the county, and then outside the state. Among other locations, MOTHER visited schools in Washington, Massachusetts and New York. The PARENTS received recommendations from several sources for the May Center, a school specializing in TBI children located near Boston. The PARENTS visited the May Center for two days in March 2001. In April or May 2001, MOTHER and STUDENT visited the May Center for three or four days while the May Center staff evaluated STUDENT. While the PARENTS were considering the May Center, and the May Center was considering STUDENT, the PARENTS and the District continued to look for a local placement.
In September 2000, MOTHER contacted Abby Yolles, a private OT, for an evaluation of STUDENT’s needs. By October 2000, Ms. Yolles had completed her assessment and started providing private OT services twice a week for a total of 120 minutes each week. During the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT also continued to receive private S/L services from Ms. Moskowitz.
Beginning in July 2000, the District made several attempts to schedule STUDENT’s annual IEP. There is some dispute as to why each attempted IEP team meeting did not occur. MOTHER recalls that the IEP meetings did not occur in part because the District wanted to identify STUDENT’s new placement before holding the meeting, and, in part, because of problems arranging for the entire IEP team to be present. District witnesses testified that the initial delay occurred because the PARENTS wanted to wait until Dr. Kogan’s testing had been completed. There was also testimony that later delays were caused by the PARENTS’ desire to have Ms. Moskowitz (and after September 2000, Ms. Yolles) present at the meeting.
An IEP team meeting was finally convened on May 29, 2001. At the meeting, Ms. Moskowitz and Ms. Yolles presented reports of STUDENT’s progress on his goals and his present levels of performance. Goals and objectives were drafted in the areas of counseling/social skills, OT, behavior, vocational education, math, reading, oral language, and expressive language. The PARENTS’ requested reimbursement for the evaluation by Dr. Kogan and the past services provided by Ms. Moskowitz and Ms. Yolles. The PARENTS also requested that STUDENT be placed in the residential program at the May Center in Massachusetts. The IEP indicates that the team recommended placement in a special day class at an NPS, but does not indicate what NPS. MOTHER testified that Howard Gellerman, who chaired the meeting for the District, stated that he did not have the authority to place STUDENT at the May Center, and referred the PARENTS back to the District NPS coordinator. Harriet Maglin, the NPS coordinator, stated that prior to the May IEP meeting she had recommended placement at Village Glen to MOTHER. MOTHER had rejected that placement because she felt that the population at Village Glen was primarily autistic students and therefore not appropriate for STUDENT. The IEP meeting ended without a specific offer of placement being made.
In August 2001, STUDENT was accepted into the residential program at the May Center, and the PARENTS took STUDENT to Massachusetts to enroll him in that program. After the initial orientation, MOTHER stayed in Boston to be near STUDENT and FATHER returned to California. After two weeks, MOTHER removed STUDENT from the residential program. MOTHER stated that she believed that the curriculum at the May Center was appropriate, but that the other students in STUDENT’s residence were functioning at a much lower level than STUDENT and posed a safety risk for him. Once STUDENT was exited from the residential program, the May Center informed MOTHER that STUDENT would have to transfer to the day treatment program, but that there were no openings in that program. MOTHER and STUDENT returned to California.
In September 2001, after her return from Massachusetts, MOTHER contacted Ms. Bartnoff and explained what had happened at the May Center. Shortly thereafter, MOTHER was referred to Harriet Oken at the Westwood Charter School. MOTHER had previously spoken with Ms. Oken (in early 2001), and Ms. Oken had told MOTHER that her class was not appropriate for STUDENT. In September, Ms. Oken still believed that her class was not suitable for STUDENT, but suggested that MOTHER talk to Barbara Killian, another teacher at Westwood. Ms. Killian met with MOTHER and with STUDENT, and both MOTHER and Ms. Killian decided that STUDENT was a good fit for Ms. Killian’s class. STUDENT began attending Ms. Killian’s class at Westwood in September 2001. Ms. Killian told MOTHER that she wanted to observe STUDENT for a few weeks to help determine his present levels of performance before holding an IEP meeting.
The first IEP team meeting for STUDENT at Westwood was held on November 7, 2001. Ms. Killian reported that STUDENT was functioning at the kindergarten to first-grade level in both math and reading. STUDENT was able to sit for thirty minutes to complete a task, and could attend to familiar tasks without constant adult support. Language was a relative strength for STUDENT. He could engage in age appropriate conversations with both adults and peers. Ms. Killian also observed that STUDENT had significant memory problems. Ms. Xiong, the OT at Westwood, and Ms. Bader, the S/L pathologist, completed assessments of STUDENT in preparation for this meeting. In S/L, STUDENT demonstrated below average expressive and receptive language skills. In particular, Ms. Bader noted problems with auditory memory and abstract ideas. STUDENT also had some problems with word finding. In her OT assessment, Ms. Xiong noted that STUDENT had low muscle tone and low muscle strength; however, his strength was adequate for carrying out classroom tasks. STUDENT demonstrated below average visual perceptual and visual motor skills as well as problems with sensory modulation as demonstrated by difficulty staying focused and being easily distracted. Goals were drafted in the areas of reading, math, language, vocational education, counseling, and OT. The team recommended forty-five minutes a week of OT services and sixty minutes a week of S/L services. MOTHER continued to want the District to reimburse her for the past services of Ms. Yolles and Ms. Moskowitz, the assessment by Dr. Kogan, and the cost of the placement at the May Center. MOTHER also wanted the District to continue to fund the ongoing services by Ms. Yolles and Ms. Moskowitz.
Over the next year, Ms. Killian, STUDENT’s teacher, testified that STUDENT made progress in all areas. The next IEP team meeting was on December 2, 2002. By that time, STUDENT had become an “emerging reader,” with over one hundred sight words. Ms. Killian did note that STUDENT’s performance deteriorated under stress. STUDENT’s math skills had also improved significantly. Although writing was still difficult for STUDENT, his skills in this area had also improved. He was beginning to write material on a specific topic with some punctuation. STUDENT’s oral language skills continued to be a relative strength. His word finding skills had improved, and he was working on higher order thinking such as similarities and differences. STUDENT’s ability to retell a story with appropriate sequencing had also improved. STUDENT continued to have some problems with turn-taking when he would get excited. STUDENT’s OT skills had shown significant gains. STUDENT’s skills in the areas of fine motor, visual motor, visual perceptual, bilateral coordination, sensory modulation, and sensory processing had all improved. Goals were drafted in the areas of language arts, math, reading, social/emotional, S/L, and OT. The team recommended thirty minutes a week of S/L services and sixty minutes a month of consultation OT services. The PARENTS did not agree with the S/L or OT services offered primarily because of the amount of services offered and concerns over the qualifications of the providers. The PARENTS also continued to request reimbursement for privately provided services, placement, and assessments.
After the December 2002 IEP meeting, the PARENTS continued to fund the private OT and S/L services from Ms. Yolles and Ms. Moskowitz. Through the commencement of the hearing, STUDENT has continued in his placement at Westwood. Because MOTHER did not agree to the services offered in the December 2002 IEP, STUDENT has continued to receive OT and S/L services at the level set forth in the November 2001 IEP.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
This case involves issues covering parts of four separate school years. Although the basic issues for each year are similar, the provision of S/L and OT services, there are some differences as to the Petitioner’s allegations as well as the District’s offers. Each school year will be examined separately below.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. Did the District fail to offer STUDENT with a FAPE for the time period of November 27, 1999, through the present?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE) that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs and prepare them for employment and independent living. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 (d). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401 (25) (1997). The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). Education Code section 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). The student’s IEP must provide, among other things, for the student to be involved and progress in the general curriculum and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s potential. Id. at 198-200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services, which are individually designed to provide some educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201.
In summary, under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley the proposed educational program must 1) be designed to meet the student’s unique needs, 2) provide for the student to be involved and progress in the general curriculum and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities, 3) be calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, and 4) must conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176. If these requirements are met, then the District has offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer a different program or services and even if the parents’ preferred program or services would result in greater educational benefit. (Rowley at 207-208; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist. (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307, 1314.)
Each of STUDENT’s IEPs during the time periods at issue called for extended school year (ESY) services; however, there were no specific allegations relating to the extended school year. It was undisputed that STUDENT was, and is, entitled to ESY services, but because the allegations for the ESY time are no different from the allegations for the regular school year, the ESY time will not be addressed separately.
a. The 1999-2000 school year, including the extended school year.
The only issue for this school year is the appropriateness of the District’s offer and provision of OT and S/L services. As set forth earlier in this decision, the statute of limitations limits the time period at issue in this school year to November 27, 1999, through the end of the extended school year.
1. Did the District fail to offer and provide STUDENT with appropriate occupational therapy services?
OT is a designated instruction or service (DIS) as those services are defined by the Education Code. The District must provide DIS when the instruction or services are necessary for the student to benefit from his education. Educ. Code § 56363. There is no dispute that STUDENT required OT services to benefit from his education. The Petitioner’s contention is that the OT services offered did not address all of STUDENT’s unique needs, and that the services were not provided by a person who was sufficiently familiar with STUDENT’s disability and unique needs to be able to provide appropriate services. Petitioner also contends that STUDENT did not benefit from the District’s OT services.
The first issue that must be addressed is the identification of STUDENT’s educational OT needs as of November 1999. The District assessed STUDENT in July 1999. Ms. Lucas, the District OT assessor, found that STUDENT had needs in the areas of fine motor skills, bilateral motor skills and visual perception. Ms. Lucas found that STUDENT had difficulties with organizing his behavior as evidenced by his distractibility, short attention span, and difficulty transitioning between tasks. Ms. Lucas also concluded that STUDENT had adequate muscle strength and tone to benefit from his education. Furthermore, Ms. Lucas found that STUDENT did not have sensory processing issues.
MOTHER testified STUDENT had displayed sensory processing problems in the past and that the OT services he had been receiving had utilized sensory integration techniques. MOTHER stated that STUDENT continued to have sensory processing issues in 1999, and still has them to this day. MOTHER’s testimony was supported by the testimony of Abby Yolles. Although Ms. Yolles did not see STUDENT until September 2000, she testified that he still had sensory processing and sensory integration issues when she evaluated him. Ms. Yolles stated that STUDENT’s sensory problems were affecting fine and gross motor abilities as well as his attention. Ms. Killian, STUDENT’s current teacher, also testified that STUDENT continues to display some sensory processing problems in her class. On the basis of the testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Yolles and Ms. Killian, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT had sensory processing problems in 1999.
There was also testimony that STUDENT had reduced muscle strength and tone. Although there is evidence to support this contention, the evidence also established that STUDENT’s muscle strength and muscle tone were adequate to allow him to benefit from his education.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s educational OT needs as of November 1999 were poor fine motor skills, poor bilateral coordination, impaired organization of behavior, impaired visual perception, and impaired sensory processing. The goals that were being addressed by the District’s OT provider in December 1999 were drafted at the July 26, 1999 IEP meeting.(Footnote 5) The July 1999 IEP contained goals to address STUDENT’s fine motor and bilateral coordination. There was also a goal to address visual processing, organization of behavior, and sensory processing. Although Ms. Lucas did not find that STUDENT had sensory processing needs she agreed to include a goal in this area because of the concerns MOTHER expressed at the IEP team meeting. Based upon the testimony of Ms. Lucas, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s goals were designed to meet all of STUDENT’s educational OT needs as of November 1999.
Petitioner also contends that the amount of OT services offered, sixty minutes a week, was not adequate to implement the goals drafted. Although Ms. Yolles was not working with STUDENT in November 1999, she testified that it would take at least two hours a week of OT services to address all of STUDENT’s OT needs identified in 1999. The District presented no testimony from Ms. McKim, the District OT. Ms. Lucas testified that she believed the amount of services offered by the District to be appropriate, but she had never actually worked with STUDENT, she had only performed the assessment. Because of her extensive history working with STUDENT, the Hearing Officer finds Ms. Yolles’s opinion persuasive and concludes that STUDENT needed two hours a week of OT to address his needs.
In addition, Petitioner argues that the OT provider was not sufficiently familiar with STUDENT’s disability and unique needs to be able to provide appropriate services. MOTHER testified that she observed and spoke with Ms. McKim, who provided STUDENT with OT from December 1999 through July 2000. MOTHER stated that Ms. McKim did not appear to have a good understanding of the nature of STUDENT’s disability and was at times confused about what side of the brain had been damaged and what side of the body had suffered paralysis. MOTHER’s concerns about Ms. McKim led MOTHER to ask the District to stop using Ms. McKim as STUDENT’s OT in July 2000. Dr. Niparko, STUDENT’s treating neurologist, testified that it is important that any therapist working with STUDENT understand the nature of his disability in order to develop appropriate treatment strategies and to have realistic expectations. Other than presenting proof that Ms. McKim was a licensed occupational therapist, the District failed to provide any evidence that Ms. McKim had any understanding of STUDENT’s disability or that she utilized appropriate strategies in implementing the goals and objectives. The District has the burden of proving that it complied with the IDEA. Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District, No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994). On the basis of the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has failed to establish that Ms. McKim was sufficiently familiar with STUDENT’s disability and unique needs to be able to provide appropriate services.
There also is no evidence that STUDENT made progress on his OT goals. When Ms. Yolles assessed STUDENT in September 2000, he presented with more OT needs than had been noted in the District’s assessment in the previous year. In September 2000, STUDENT had poor fine motor and bilateral coordination skills. He continued to have poor organization of behavior. His visual processing and sensory processing impairments were not improved, and he also demonstrated visual motor difficulties. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not make progress on his OT goals during the 1999-2000 school year.
Although the District did draft goals to address all of STUDENT’s educational OT needs for the 1999-2000 school year, the District failed to offer an adequate amount of services and failed to show that the therapist who provided OT was sufficiently familiar with STUDENT’s disability and unique needs to be able to provide appropriate services. Furthermore, STUDENT did not make progress on his OT goals. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide STUDENT with appropriate OT services during the 1999-2000 school year.
2. Did the District fail to offer and provide STUDENT with appropriate speech/language services?
Speech/language, like OT, is a designated instruction or service. There is no dispute that STUDENT required S/L services in order to benefit from his education. The Petitioner’s contention is that the S/L services offered did not address all STUDENT’s unique needs and that the services were not provided by a person who was sufficiently familiar with STUDENT’s disability and unique needs to be able to provide appropriate services.
To identify STUDENT’s educational S/L needs for the 1999-2000 school year, the District conducted an S/L evaluation in July 1999. Ms. Snyder, the District assessor, administered the Expressive One Word Picture Vocabulary Test, an oral peripheral test, the Fisher-Logemann Articulation Test, the Preschool Language Scale test, and obtained a spontaneous language sample. On the vocabulary test, STUDENT obtained a score of 91, in the average range. Ms. Snyder concluded that STUDENT had adequate structure and function of his oral mechanisms. STUDENT displayed some articulation problems but these were viewed to be age appropriate, and Ms. Snyder found that they did not impair STUDENT’s overall intelligibility. From the spontaneous language sample, Ms. Snyder concluded that STUDENT’s pronunciation, grammar, syntax, semantics, and pragmatics were all age appropriate. In expressive language, STUDENT demonstrated problems with abstract concepts and abstract reasoning, as well as some grammar errors in irregular plurals and superlative forms. Ms. Snyder concluded that STUDENT had needs in the areas of abstract reasoning, defining words and expressing quantity. Ms. Snyder also consulted with STUDENT’s teacher. Ms. Snyder testified that the teacher identified additional needs in the areas of turn-taking and problem solving. The July 1999 IEP also states that STUDENT had difficulties with topic maintenance, and tangential responses in targeted conversations.
Ms. Moskowitz, who had been providing STUDENT with private speech language therapy since he was eighteen months of age, testified that STUDENT had significant needs during the 1999-2000 school year not identified by the District’s assessment. Of primary concern to Ms. Moskowitz was the District’s failure to identify word finding or memory problems. Ms. Moskowitz stated that, in 1999, STUDENT continued to have significant short-term memory and word finding problems. Ms. Moskowitz believed that these problems were one of the root causes of STUDENT’s problems staying on topic and tangential responses. Ms. Moskowitz’s opinion was corroborated by the testimony of Ms. Bader (STUDENT’s S/L therapist at Westwood) and Ms. Killian (STUDENT’s teacher at Westwood), who both stated that STUDENT continued to have word finding and short-term memory problems in 2001 and 2002. Ms. Moskowitz also testified that STUDENT continued to have oral motor problems in 1999 that interfered with his ability to make certain sounds. Specifically, STUDENT was having difficulty moving his tongue properly to form all of the sounds necessary for speech. Ms. Moskowitz’s testimony in this area is supported by the testimony of Ms. Yolles, who also noted oral motor difficulties.
On the basis of the testimony of Ms. Moskowitz, Ms. Killian and Ms. Bader, the Hearing Officer finds that, during the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT had S/L needs in the areas of abstract reasoning, defining words and expressing quantities, grammar, topic maintenance in conversation, turn-taking, problem solving, word finding, short-term memory, and oral motor tongue movement. Although the District drafted goals to address turn taking, topic maintenance in conversation, and problem solving, no goals were drafted to address STUDENT’s needs in the areas of abstract reasoning, defining words, expressing quantities, word finding, short-term memory or oral motor functioning.
Although there was evidence that STUDENT did make progress in relation to his S/L needs during the 1999-2000 school year, the Hearing Officer finds that this progress can only be attributed to the private therapy provided by Ms. Moskowitz, not the District S/L services. The District presented no evidence of how familiar Ms. Brown was with STUDENT’s disability or his unique needs. Furthermore, the District presented no evidence on what strategies Ms. Brown utilized during the 1999-2000 school year. On the other hand, Ms. Moskowitz testified at length regarding her familiarity with STUDENT’s history and needs, as well as how she addressed those needs. On the basis of this evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to establish that it provided S/L services that met STUDENT’s unique needs or were designed to benefit STUDENT. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to offer or provide STUDENT with appropriate S/L services during the 1999-2000 school year.
b. The 2000-2001 school year, including the extended school year.
Petitioner has raised three issues for this school year: the District’s failure to hold an IEP, the adequacy of the offer and provision of OT services, and the adequacy of the offer and provision of S/L services.
When STUDENT entered school for the 2000-2001 school year, he was receiving services pursuant to the July 1999 IEP. No IEP was held during the 2000-2001 school year until May 2001. The primary purpose of the May 2001 IEP was to determine the placement and services for the 2001-2002 school year; therefore, that IEP will be analyzed later in this Decision as part of the 2001-2002 school year. The District has an obligation to hold an IEP meeting at least annually. Educ. Code § 56343. In this case, beginning in July 2000, the District made numerous attempts to hold an IEP meeting. Each attempted IEP meeting was rescheduled, sometimes at the parent’s request and sometimes at the District’s request. Although Petitioner has raised the District’s failure to hold an IEP as an issue in this hearing, the Hearing Officer finds that any delay in holding an IEP during the 2000-2001 school year was, at the time, mutually agreed to by both the parents and the District.
Because no new IEP meeting was held for the 2000-2001 school year, the offer and provision of S/L and OT services during that year will be analyzed based upon the services offered in the July 1999 IEP.
1. Did the District fail to offer and provide STUDENT with appropriate occupational therapy services?
On the basis of Ms. Yolles’s September 2000 evaluation of STUDENT, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT continued to have educational OT needs in the same areas as in the prior school year. In addition, STUDENT had an additional need in the area of visual motor integration. This new area of need was not addressed in the prior IEP. Because no new goals were drafted for this school year, the District failed to identify all of STUDENT’s unique needs or draft goals to address those needs.
It has already been determined that the District failed to provide appropriate OT services to STUDENT during the 1999-2000 school year. Furthermore, in July 2000 MOTHER requested that the District stop using Ms. McKim as STUDENT’s OT provider.(Footnote 6) The evidence establishes that Ms. McKim stopped providing OT in July 2000. Although the District was complying with MOTHER’s request, this did not absolve the District of its duty to provide appropriate OT services. The District presented no evidence as to what, if any, OT it provided during 2000-2001 school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to establish that it provided OT services that were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and calculated to provide him with any benefit. Because the District failed to identify all of STUDENT’s unique needs, and failed to offer services to meet those needs or provide STUDENT with any benefit, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to offer or provide STUDENT with appropriate OT services during the 2000-2001 school year.
2. Did the District fail to offer and provide STUDENT with appropriate speech/language services?
Ms. Moskowitz’s testimony established that STUDENT continued to have S/L needs in the same areas as in the prior school year. Although STUDENT had made progress, he still had needs in the areas of abstract reasoning, defining words and expressing quantities, grammar, topic maintenance in conversation, turn taking, problem solving, word finding, short-term memory, and oral motor tongue. However, the Hearing Officer has already determined that the District’s July 1999 IEP did not identify all of STUDENT’s S/L needs or contain goals that addressed all of those needs. As these were the same goals to be addressed during the 2000-2001 school year, the District’s failure to offer appropriate S/L services continued through the 2000-2001 school year. The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not identify all of STUDENT’s S/L needs, offer services to address those needs or provide STUDENT with benefit. Therefore, the District failed offer or provide STUDENT with appropriate S/L services during the 2000-2001 school year.
c. The 2001-2002 school year, including the extended school year.
For this school year Petitioner has raised three issues. First, that at the May 29, 2001 IEP team meeting, the District failed to make any offer of placement for the upcoming 2001-2002 school. Petitioner alleges that the District’s failure to make an offer of placement forced Petitioner to withdraw STUDENT from school and unilaterally place him at the May Center in Massachusetts in August 2001. The placement at the May Center only lasted a little over two weeks, after which STUDENT returned to the District (Petitioner’s request for reimbursement for the cost of this placement will be addressed later in this Decision). Following his return, STUDENT was placed at the Westwood Charter School. There is no dispute about the appropriateness of this placement. However, there continues to be a dispute as to the OT and S/L services that the District provided after STUDENT was placed at Westwood. Therefore, in addition to the District’s alleged failure to offer an appropriate placement at the May 2001 IEP meeting, Petitioner alleges that the OT and S/L services offered and provided by the District were not appropriate.
1. Did the District fail to make an offer of an appropriate placement at the May 29, 2001 IEP team meeting?
The purpose of the May 29, 2001 IEP team meeting was to determine STUDENT’s placement and services for the 2001-2002 school year. Prior to this meeting, both parties had agreed that JAS was no longer an appropriate placement for STUDENT. As a result, both the PARENTS and the District had spent many months searching for a new placement. The only school that both sides had agreed on, the Frostig School, had not accepted STUDENT. After visiting many schools both in California and in other states, the PARENTS had concluded that the only other placement that was both appropriate and would accept STUDENT was the May Center in Massachusetts. At the May 29, 2001 IEP team meeting, the PARENTS informed the District that they were requesting placement at the May Center. The IEP team reviewed STUDENT’s progress and present levels of performance, drafted goals and objectives, offered placement at an NPS with DIS counseling, S/L, and OT. However, no specific NPS was offered. MOTHER testified that the District personnel at the meeting referred her back to the District NPS coordinator to locate an appropriate placement. MOTHER’s June 18 and June 25, 2001 letters to the District state that Ms. Maglin, the NPS coordinator, had, at some time before the May IEP meeting, informed MOTHER that she believed the Village Glen School was an appropriate placement for STUDENT. MOTHER disagreed, feeling that the student population and the program at Village Glen would not meet STUDENT’s needs. However, Ms. Maglin did not attend the May IEP meeting, and there is no evidence that Village Glen was discussed or even mentioned at the IEP meeting. In fact, there is no indication that any specific placement, other than the May Center, was even discussed at the meeting.
The law explicitly requires the District to make a formal written offer of placement when it proposes, or refuses, to initiate or change the educational placement of a disabled child. Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 513 U.S. 965, 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994). The Court in Union stated, “We find that this formal requirement has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe it should be enforced rigorously. The requirement of a formal, written offer creates a clear record that will do much to eliminate troublesome factual disputes many years later about when placements were offered, what placements were offered, and what additional educational assistance was offered to supplement a placement, if any.” Id. Petitioner argues that the District failed to make an offer that met this standard. The District argues that, although a specific school was not offered at the May 2001 IEP meeting, a written offer of placement at Village Glen had already been made. The District points to a June 6, 2000 letter from Ms. Maglin to the PARENTS. This letter states that STUDENT had been approved for funding for placement at a nonpublic school and lists three schools, Frostig, Village Glen, and Dubnoff, as certified nonpublic schools that were able to provide an appropriate educational program. The letter instructs the PARENTS to call the listed schools to arrange for interviews. The letter closes by saying that, once the PARENTS had selected a nonpublic school, they should contact Ms. Maglin so that she could begin the necessary follow-up procedures.
The Hearing Officer finds that the combination of the June 6, 2000 letter and the May 29, 2001 IEP did not constitute a formal written offer of placement. The June 2000 letter, on its own, is not a clear offer of placement. In fact, Ms. Maglin referred to it as a “funding” letter. The Hearing Officer finds that this letter was merely a suggestion to the PARENTS that the listed schools should be considered. Furthermore, this letter was sent almost a year before the IEP meeting. It is unreasonable to expect that the PARENTS were to understand that the District had formally offered the listed schools as the placements for an IEP that was to be written a year later. The IEP, though specific about goals, objectives and DIS services, was silent as to the specific NPS being offered. No NPS is mentioned in the document, nor was any NPS discussed at the meeting. There was no formal notice to the PARENTS as to what, if any, NPS they were to consider as being offered by the District. The Hearing Officer finds that this case presents the exact situation that the rule enunciated in Union was intended to avoid, “…troublesome factual disputes many years later about when placements were offered, what placements were offered, and what additional educational assistance was offered to supplement a placement, if any.” Id. Because the District failed to offer any placement, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to offer of an appropriate placement at the May 29, 2001 IEP team meeting.
2. Following STUDENT’s placement at the Westwood Charter School, did the District fail to offer and provide STUDENT with appropriate occupational therapy services?
Petitioner contends that the District failed to identify all of his OT needs and failed to offer services adequate to meet those needs.
In September 2001, following STUDENT’s return from the May Center, the parties mutually agreed to place STUDENT at the Westwood Charter School. An IEP meeting was not held until November 7, 2001, to allow the Westwood staff an opportunity to work with and evaluate STUDENT. Fei Xiong (formerly Maynard) conducted the District’s OT assessment. Ms. Xiong’s assessment included formal testing, classroom and playground observation, teacher and parent interviews, and informal testing. Ms. Xiong concluded that STUDENT had a functional range of movement at all joints, slightly low muscle tone, and adequate strength for carrying out classroom tasks. STUDENT demonstrated adequate postural stability with the endurance necessary to sit at a desk for twenty minutes. On formal testing, STUDENT’s visual perceptual abilities were below average in the areas of form constancy and sequential memory. These impairments would impact STUDENT’s ability to form letters and designs. STUDENT’s fine motor skills were age appropriate. However, STUDENT’s visual motor skills were below average. Organization of behavior was also an area of weakness. STUDENT demonstrated sensitivity to various types of sensory input. STUDENT also had difficulty filtering auditory input. Ms. Xiong believed that these problems might have been involved in STUDENT’s difficulty maintaining his attention to task. Ms. Xiong found that STUDENT’s motor planning and social skills were areas of strength. Ms. Killian, STUDENT’s teacher at Westwood, testified that Ms. Xiong’s report was an accurate picture of STUDENT’s educational OT needs in November 2001.
Ms. Yolles, the private OT, agreed with Ms. Xiong’s evaluation, with the exception that she believed STUDENT continued to have needs in the areas of in-hand manipulation, motor planning, and self-help skills. Ms. Yolles also testified that STUDENT continued to need clinic-based services to address his reduced muscle strength and muscle tone.
The Hearing Officer accepts the testimony of Ms. Yolles that STUDENT continued to have some impairment in the areas of in-hand manipulation, motor planning, self-help, muscle strength, and muscle tone. However, the Hearing Officer puts great weight in the testimony of Ms. Killian, STUDENT’s teacher since September 2001. Ms. Killian stated that STUDENT’s abilities in these areas were adequate for him to benefit from his education. On the basis of Ms. Killian’s and Ms. Xiong’s testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that these were not areas of educational OT needs. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s educational OT needs were in the areas of visual perception, visual motor skills, organization of behavior, and sensory processing.
Two OT goals were drafted at the IEP meeting. The first goal was primarily classroom-based and addressed STUDENT’s ability to attend and complete classroom activities. This goal addressed STUDENT’s sensory processing and organization of behavior issues. The second goal was for the direct OT services and addressed STUDENT’s visual sequential memory, form constancy, visual motor skills, and memory. Although these goals in and of themselves were somewhat ambiguous, when they are read in conjunction with the present levels of performance and the OT summary in the IEP, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals did adequately address all of STUDENT’s educational OT needs.
The District offered and provided thirty minutes a week of direct OT and fifteen minutes a week of consultation with the classroom teacher. In addition to the services from the occupational therapist, STUDENT’s OT needs were worked on and reinforced in the classroom. Ms. Killian’s classroom provided a sensory rich environment that was designed to assist STUDENT with his sensory processing and organization of behavior needs. However, Ms. Yolles testified that thirty minutes a week of direct OT was inadequate to meet all of STUDENT’s needs. Ms. Yolles stated that STUDENT needed two hours a week of direct services. Because of Ms. Yolles’s extensive experience in working with STUDENT, the Hearing Officer gives her testimony significant weight. The Hearing Officer finds that thirty minutes a week of direct services, even when combined with the classroom environment, was not reasonably calculated to address all of STUDENT’s OT needs or provide him with benefit.
Despite the District’s deficient offer, it is undisputed that STUDENT did make significant progress on his OT goals during the 2001-2002 school year. In fact, STUDENT made so much progress that Ms. Yolles reduced her private OT from two hours a week to one hour a week in September 2002. However, the District failed to present any convincing evidence that STUDENT’s progress was attributable to the District’s services rather than the private services provided by Ms. Yolles. Because the District’s offer was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with benefit, and because the District did not establish that its services were responsible for STUDENT’s progress, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s progress during the 2001-2002 school year was primarily the result of the private services provided by Ms. Yolles. In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to offer or provide STUDENT with appropriate OT services during the 2001-2002 school year.
3. Following STUDENT’s placement at the Westwood Charter School, did the District fail to offer and provide STUDENT with appropriate speech/language services?
Petitioner contends that the District failed to identify all of STUDENT’s S/L needs, and failed to offer services adequate to meet his needs.
Shellie Bader assessed STUDENT’s S/L needs for the District in October 2001. Ms. Bader administered the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals - 3 (CELF-3) and the Expressive One Word Picture Vocabulary test. On the CELF-3 STUDENT scored below average in both expressive and receptive language. He demonstrated problems with sentence structure, concepts and directions, word classes, formulated sentences and recalling sentences. Ms. Bader concluded that STUDENT had needs in the areas of memory, word finding, higher order thinking, and abstract reasoning. STUDENT had difficulty in concepts such as similarities, associations, and opposites. He also had trouble when information was only presented auditorily, doing much better on tasks when visual cues were used. Ms. Bader also noted that STUDENT would talk “around” subjects rather than address them directly.
Ms. Moskowitz’s report and testimony indicate that she believed STUDENT had needs in the areas of short-term memory, word finding, organizing conversation, use of linguistic flexibility, and use of linguistic abstracts. In comparing the opinions of Ms. Bader and Ms. Moskowitz, the Hearing Officer finds that, while using different terminology, both identified the same areas of need. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT had S/L needs in the areas of short-term memory, word finding, using language to address topics in an appropriate fashion, and understanding and using abstracts and higher order concepts such as similarities and differences. The Hearing Officer finds that the District did identify all of STUDENT’s S/L needs for the 2001-2002 school year.
Three goals were drafted to address STUDENT’s S/L needs. The first was a classroom goal for STUDENT to remember and retell his vital information. The second goal called for STUDENT to use word retrieval strategies to describe similarities, differences, categories and idioms. The last goal called for STUDENT to use appropriate language to retell a story or event in a logical sequence. The Hearing Officer finds that these goals addressed all of STUDENT’s S/L needs. STUDENT’s short-term memory and word finding deficits were addressed in all three goals. STUDENT’s tendency to “talk around” topics was primarily addressed in the third goal but was also involved in the second goal. STUDENT’s deficits in using abstracts and higher order thinking was primarily addressed in the second goal but was also addressed in the third goal.
The District offered sixty minutes a week of small-group instruction to meet these goals. In addition, STUDENT’s placement was in a small, language-based class that provided extra S/L instruction and reinforced the pullout therapies. Ms. Moskowitz testified that STUDENT’s needs could not be met in sixty minutes of small-group therapy. Ms. Moskowitz also questioned whether the school-based therapist was using the appropriate strategies to address STUDENT’s needs. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Bader was using appropriate strategies. Ms. Bader reviewed the strategies discussed in Ms. Moskowitz’s report and stated that she agreed with almost all of them, and utilized the same or similar strategies when working with STUDENT. However, the Hearing Officer gives great weight to Ms. Moskowitz’s testimony that STUDENT continued to need individual S/L therapy to benefit from his education. Ms. Moskowitz testified that the unusual nature of STUDENT’s disability made it almost impossible to address his needs in a small group because it would not be possible to find a group of similarly impaired students to place him with. The Hearing Officer also notes that numerous assessors, including Ms. Bader, stated that when they first met STUDENT he appeared to have very good oral language skills, and only after more contact and testing did STUDENT’s deficits become apparent. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT continued to need individual rather than small group therapy because of the subtle, and often deceptive, nature of STUDENT’s S/L deficits. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of sixty minutes of group therapy was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs or reasonably calculated to provide him with any benefit.
It is undisputed that STUDENT continued to make progress on his S/L goals during the 2001-2002 school year. However, as with the OT services, STUDENT also continued to receive private S/L services in addition to the services provided by the District. During this year, Ms. Moskowitz was providing approximately ninety minutes a week of individual S/L therapy. Because the Hearing Officer has already found that STUDENT required individual therapy to benefit from the S/L services, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s progress in this area was primarily the result of Ms. Moskowitz’s services, not the District’s S/L group therapy.
Based upon the finding that STUDENT continued to need individual S/L services, and the finding that STUDENT’s progress was the result of the private services rather than the District’s services, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to offer or provide STUDENT with appropriate S/L services during the 2001-2002 school year.
In summary, for the 2001-2002 school year, the District failed to make an offer of an appropriate placement at the May 2001 IEP meeting. In addition, the District’s offer of thirty minutes a week of individual OT was not reasonably calculated to address all of STUDENT’s OT needs or provide him with benefit. Finally, the District’s offer of sixty minutes a week of group S/L therapy was also not designed to meet STUDENT’s S/L needs or reasonably calculated to provide him with any benefit.
d. The 2002-2003 school year, including the extended school year.
During the first part of the 2002-2003 school year, services continued to be provided under the November 2001 IEP. Therefore, the conclusions regarding the services offered in that IEP would continue to apply to the first months of the 2002-2003 school year. The annual IEP meeting for this school year was held on December 2, 2002. New goals and objectives were drafted and services offered. The PARENTS did not agree with the IEP, so services have continued to be provided pursuant to the November 2001 IEP. This Decision will analyze whether the S/L and OT services offered in the December 2, 2002 IEP were appropriate.
1. Did the District fail to offer and provide STUDENT with appropriate occupational therapy services?
Petitioner contends that the District failed to identify all of STUDENT’s OT needs and failed to offer services adequate to meet his needs.
The IEP team meeting for this school year was held on December 2, 2002. As stated earlier, it is undisputed that STUDENT had made significant progress on his OT goals during the previous school year. At the time of the IEP meeting, Stacey Kelly was the District OT providing services to STUDENT.(Footnote 7) She did informal assessments and consulted with the classroom teacher in assessing STUDENT’s needs. She concluded that STUDENT’s ability to sequence fine motor tasks had improved to within normal limits. She also found that STUDENT could attend to an adult-directed activity for twenty-five to thirty minutes with only one to two verbal cues. STUDENT’s sensory modulation and sensory processing skills had improved, as had his visual sequential memory and form constancy skills. In conclusion, Ms. Kelly found that STUDENT’s only remaining OT needs were in the areas of visual-motor integration and visual perception. Ms. Kelly believed that these remaining needs could be meet in the classroom with only consultation/collaboration support from the OT.
Ms. Yolles, who continued to provide private OT services, evaluated STUDENT in November 2002. Ms. Yolles found that STUDENT’s fine motor and in-hand manipulation skills were within normal limits. STUDENT’s visual-motor and visual spatial skills had also shown significant improvement, although STUDENT continued to have some difficulty with remembering letter formations. Ms. Yolles concluded that STUDENT’s visual-spatial, visual-perceptual, and visual-tracking skills, though improved, continued to be areas of need. Ms. Yolles also concluded that STUDENT’s sensory processing skills had improved substantially; however, she believed STUDENT needed to continue to improve his sensory modulation, sensory regulation skills.
In comparing the two evaluations, the Hearing Officer finds that, although some details differ, both Ms. Yolles and Ms. Kelly identified the same areas of need with the exception of sensory modulation. Ms. Yolles’s opinion is supported by the testimony of Ms. Killian, the classroom teacher, who stated that STUDENT continues to have some sensory modulation problems. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT continued to have needs in the areas of visual-spatial, visual-perceptual and visual-tracking skills. In addition, STUDENT needed continued support in relation to his sensory modulation and sensory regulations skills. Although Ms. Kelly did not agree that sensory modulation and regulation were areas of need, she did draft a goal in this area to address concerns raised at the IEP meeting. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did identify all of STUDENT’s OT needs.
Two OT goals were drafted. The first addressed STUDENT’s needs in the areas of visual-motor integration, form constancy and sequential memory. The second goal addressed STUDENT’s needs in the area of sensory processing. Ms. Yolles testified that the goals were not detailed enough and recommended six different goals. Although Ms. Yolles’s goals break STUDENT’s needs down into smaller segments, the Hearing Officer finds persuasive Ms. Kelly’s testimony that the District’s goals addressed the same areas of need.(Footnote 8) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did draft goals to address all of STUDENT’s OT needs. However, the Hearing Officer finds persuasive Ms. Yolles’s testimony that these goals could not be adequately addressed without continued individual services. Ms. Yolles, who has been working with STUDENT since October 2000, testified that STUDENT continues to need sixty minutes a week of direct OT services. After considering STUDENT’s OT needs, the past progress that STUDENT has made with direct OT services, and Ms. Yolles’s testimony that STUDENT continued to need individual OT services to meet his needs, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT continued to need sixty minutes a week of individual OT services to address his educational OT needs during the 2002-2003 school year. Because the District only offered sixty minutes a month of consultation/collaboration services, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs or reasonably calculated to provide him with benefit. Therefore, the District failed to offer STUDENT appropriate OT services for the 2002-2003 school year.
2. Did the District fail to offer and provide STUDENT with appropriate speech/language services?
Petitioner contends that the District failed to identify all of STUDENT’s S/L needs and failed to offer services adequate to meet his needs.
Ms. Bader, in her informal evaluation of STUDENT, noted improved use of word finding strategies and improved understanding and use of similarities, differences, word categories and word definitions. Ms. Bader also noted that STUDENT had improved in his ability to retell a story with the proper sequencing of events. Although all of these areas were improved, she also stated that she continued to work on them with STUDENT in therapy. In addition, STUDENT continued to demonstrate some difficulty with pragmatics, in particular turn-taking. STUDENT’s inability to answer inference, prediction and main idea questions was also an area of continued need. Ms. Moskowitz, again using different terminology, identified the same areas of need.
On the basis of the reports of Ms. Bader and Ms. Moskowitz, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT had ongoing S/L needs in the areas of short-term memory and word finding, pragmatics, linguistic flexibility (expressions with multiple meanings), use of linguistic abstracts (metaphors and idioms), and higher order reasoning such as inferences and prediction. Only one S/L goal was drafted. This goal called for STUDENT to tell the main idea of a story or event and answer how and why questions with critical elements of the story. Although this goal could address short-term memory, word finding and higher order reasoning skills, it did not directly address linguistic flexibility, linguistic abstracts or pragmatics. The Hearing Officer finds that, although the District did identify all of STUDENT’s S/L needs, it failed to draft goals and objectives to address all of his needs.
The December 2002 IEP only offered thirty minutes a week of group S/L services. The Hearing Officer finds that this level of services was inadequate to meet all of STUDENTs needs or provide STUDENT with benefit. For the same reasons as set forth for the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT continued to need individual S/L services to progress on his goals. Furthermore, thirty minutes a week was not enough time to provide STUDENT with benefit. Ms. Moskowitz recommended ninety minutes a week of individual services; however, the Hearing Officer finds that this amount of time does not take into account the amount of S/L support STUDENT receives from Ms. Killian in the course of the school day. Because of this additional level of support, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s S/L needs could have been addressed by sixty minutes a week of individual S/L therapy. The Hearing Officer concludes that sixty minutes of individual S/L therapy, combined with placement in Ms. Killian’s class, is necessary to address STUDENT’s S/L needs and provide STUDENT with benefit for the 2002-2003 school year.
In conclusion, the District failed to draft goals to meet all of STUDENT’s S/L needs, and failed to offer a level of services calculated to provide STUDENT with benefit. Therefore, the District failed to offer STUDENT appropriate S/L services for the 2002-2003 school year.
2. As a result of the District’s alleged failures for the time period of November 27, 1999 to the present, is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the following:
a. The cost of private speech/language services provided by Sheila Moskowitz for the time period November 1999 to the present.
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private services replaced services that the school district failed to provide and were appropriate under the IDEA. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359, 369-370; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(1997).) It has already been established that the District failed to offer or provide STUDENT with appropriate S/L services from November 1999 through the date of this Decision. The next question is whether the services the PARENTS provided through Ms. Moskowitz replaced services the District failed to provide and were appropriate.
Ms. Moskowitz provided S/L services to STUDENT, the very services the District failed to provide. In addition, the evidence established that the services Ms. Moskowitz provided were appropriate. The evidence and testing showed that STUDENT made steady progress on all of his S/L needs during the time period at issue. As to the strategies utilized, Ms. Bader testified that the strategies Ms. Moskowitz listed were all excellent strategies for STUDENT. The District’s only dispute with the services Ms. Moskowitz provided is that they may have exceeded what was educationally necessary. The Hearing Officers finds that Ms. Moskowitz’s services were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with benefit, and that STUDENT did benefit from those services. Even if STUDENT received more than some benefit, this does not provide a basis for reducing any reimbursement.
The Hearing Officer finds the services that the PARENTS obtained from Ms. Moskowitz were a replacement for the S/L services the District failed to provide and Ms. Moskowitz’s services met STUDENT’s needs and were appropriate. Therefore, the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the S/L services Ms. Moskowitz provided to STUDENT from November 1999 through the present.
b. The cost of private occupational therapy services provided by Abby Yolles for the time period September 2000 to the present.
It has already been established that the District failed to offer or provide STUDENT with appropriate OT services from September 2000 through the date of this Decision. The next question is whether the services the PARENTS provided through Ms. Yolles replaced services the District failed to provide and were appropriate.
Ms. Yolles provided OT services to STUDENT, the very services the District failed to provide. In addition, the evidence established that the services Ms. Yolles provided were appropriate. Ms. Yolles accurately identified STUDENT’s needs, and provided services to meet those needs. It is undisputed that STUDENT made continuous progress on his educational OT needs during the time period at issue.
The Hearing Officer finds the services that the PARENTS obtained from Ms. Yolles were a replacement for the appropriate OT services the District failed to provide and that those services met STUDENT’s needs and were appropriate. Therefore, the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the OT services Ms. Yolles provided to STUDENT from September 2000 through the present.
c. The cost of the independent educational evaluation of Dr. Nina Kogan completed in September 2000.
A parent has the right to an independent educational assessment at public expense if the parent disagrees with an evaluation obtained by the public agency. Educ. Code § 56329. In this case the PARENTS requested that the District perform a comprehensive psychoeducational evaluation. MOTHER believes she first requested an assessment in April or May of 2000, and then renewed the request in July of 2000. The purpose of the requested assessment was to provide additional information on STUDENT’s present levels of performance to assist in the search for a new placement. The PARENTS, dissatisfied with the District’s proposed timing and manner of conducting the evaluation, obtained a private assessment by Dr. Nina Kogan. The District argues that the PARENTS are not entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Kogan’s assessment because they did not disagree with a District assessment; instead, they obtained a private assessment before the District had completed its proposed assessment.
The Hearing Officer disagrees with the District’s reading of the statute. If the District’s interpretation is correct, a District could avoid ever reimbursing a parent for a privately obtained evaluation by indefinitely delaying its own assessment. However, the District must be given the opportunity to conduct its assessment. The law sets forth specific timelines within which a District must conduct an assessment requested by the parents. Whenever an assessment for the development or revision of the individualized education program is to be conducted, the parent of the pupil shall be given, in writing, a proposed assessment plan within 15 days of the referral for assessment not counting days between the pupil's regular school sessions or terms or days of school vacation in excess of five schooldays from the date of receipt of the referral. (emphasis added) Educ. Code § 56321. MOTHER stated that she first requested an assessment in April or May of 2000 and then renewed the request in July 2000. However, this timing is in conflict with the evidence. MOTHER stated she started looking for a new placement in June 2000. It was only after contacting schools that she learned that many of the placements being considered required a current psychoeducational evaluation. It was at this point that she requested a psychoeducational evaluation from the District. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the PARENTS did not request a psychoeducational evaluation until July 2000. This puts the request during the summer, when school was not in regular session. Therefore, the District was not obligated to develop a written assessment plan until fifteen days after regular school reconvened in the fall. This timing corresponds with MOTHER’s testimony that JAS staff told her that the assessment would not be completed for two months.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not unreasonably delay its proposed assessment of STUDENT. Because the District was not given the opportunity to conduct its own assessment, the PARENTS would not normally be entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the independent evaluation performed by Dr. Kogan. However, the facts in this case are somewhat unique. Although the District did not unreasonably delay its proposed assessment, it never completed that assessment. The evidence established that, once the PARENTS contracted with Dr. Kogan, the District discontinued its plans to assess STUDENT. Furthermore, the evidence also established that the District reviewed and relied on Dr. Kogan’s assessment at the May 2001 IEP meeting.
The IDEA states that a student with disabilities is entitled to a free and appropriate education. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d) (emphasis added). If the District were allowed to discontinue its own assessment and instead rely on the parents’ privately obtained assessment without reimbursing the parents for that assessment, then the student’s education would not be free. To interpret section 56329 to dictate this result would be contrary to the basic purposes of the IDEA. Because the District failed to complete a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT, and because the District then relied on the results of Dr. Kogan’s assessment, the Hearing Officer finds that the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of Dr. Kogan’s psychoeducational assessment.
d. The cost of STUDENT’s placement at the May Center, including tuition, transportation, lodging, and the cost of the PARENTS’ search for a new placement, including travel costs for visiting the May Center as well as the Morningside Academy in Seattle.
As with reimbursement for privately provided DIS, parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of a placement they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement was appropriate under the IDEA. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359, 369-370; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(1997).) Petitioner argues that section 1412 changed the traditional test for reimbursement. He argues that that when, as in this case, the District failed to make a timely offer of an appropriate placement, the parents may be reimbursed for their unilateral placement of the student without proving that the private placement was appropriate. The Hearing Officer disagrees. The Code of Federal Regulations specifically states that for the parents to be reimbursed for a private placement there must be a finding that the private placement was appropriate. 34 C.F.R. § 300.403. Petitioner argues that this regulation is invalid because it conflicts with the statute. Again, the Hearing Officer disagrees. Section 1412 states that a parent may be reimbursed for the cost of a private placement when the District failed to offer a FAPE. That statute does not require reimbursement. Section 300.403 simply clarifies under what circumstances reimbursement is appropriate. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the test for reimbursement is (1) whether the District failed to offer a FAPE, and (2) whether the parent’s private placement was appropriate under the IDEA.
It has already been established that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year including the extended school year. However, there was little evidence presented that the placement at the May Center was appropriate for STUDENT. The only evidence on this issue was the testimony of MOTHER that she believed that the proposed placement at the May Center was appropriate. No evidence was presented as to the results of the May Center’s evaluations, the general program at the May Center (other than statements that it was a program for TBI children), or the specific program being offered for STUDENT. Furthermore, the evidence established that the May Center placement was not appropriate. MOTHER removed STUDENT from the May Center after little more than two weeks. MOTHER stated that the student population in the residence posed a safety risk for STUDENT. Although MOTHER testified that the day class program at the May Center would have been appropriate, this placement was not available. Furthermore, as stated earlier, the only evidence in support of this contention was MOTHER’s general testimony. The Hearing Officer finds that the placement at the May Center was not an appropriate placement for STUDENT.
Because the PARENTS’ private placement at the May Center was not appropriate, the PARENTS are not entitled to reimbursement for the placement. Without an entitlement to reimbursement for the May Center placement, there is no basis in the law for reimbursement for any of the costs associated with that placement. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the PARENTS are not entitled to reimbursement for the cost of STUDENT’s placement at the May Center or the cost of the PARENTS’ search for a new placement, including travel costs for visiting the May Center as well as the Morningside Academy in Seattle.
3. Does STUDENT require ongoing private speech/language services of two hours a week for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year, including the extended school year?
Nonpublic services shall be utilized to provide DIS required by a student’s IEP when no appropriate public educational program is available. Educ. Code § 56365. Therefore, STUDENT would be entitled to ongoing private S/L services if the District were unable to provide appropriate services. It has been established that the amount of S/L services offered by the District was inadequate and that providing small-group instruction rather than individual therapy was inappropriate. However, the Hearing Officer finds that the District is able to provide appropriate services.
Ms. Bader, STUDENT’s current S/L therapist, testified that she has a bachelor’s degree in psychology and a master's in communication disorders. She also has a multi-subject teaching credential and has been working for the District for eight years. She has had experience in working with children with autism, brain injuries, developmental delays, and severe learning disabilities. She has also worked with students who have suffered strokes. She testified to her familiarity with STUDENT’s injury and his history. Ms. Bader reviewed the strategies being utilized by Ms. Moskowitz, was familiar with all of them, and stated that she had been utilizing most of those strategies in her work with STUDENT. On the basis of this information, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Bader is qualified to provide S/L services to STUDENT.
Although the District is able to provide appropriate services, it has not done so, nor is the current offer appropriate. To provide appropriate S/L services the District will need to convene a new IEP meeting, draft goals to address all of STUDENT’s S/L needs, and offer at least sixty minutes of individual S/L therapy. Whether these services will be provided by District staff or through a nonpublic agency will be left to the discretion of the IEP team.
4. Does STUDENT require ongoing private occupational therapy services of one hour a week for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year, including the extended school year?
As with the S/L services, it has already been established that the amount of OT services offered by the District was inadequate to meet STUDENT’s needs. However, the Hearing Officer finds that the District is able to provide appropriate services.
Ms. Kelly, STUDENT’s current OT, testified that she has a bachelor’s degree in psychology and a master's in occupational therapy. She is state-certified and licensed to provide occupational therapy. Prior to becoming an occupational therapist, she taught special education for the District for two years. She testified to familiarity with STUDENT’s injury and his history. Furthermore, she testified to an understanding of strategies appropriate to address STUDENT’s needs. On the basis of this information, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Kelly is qualified to provide OT services to STUDENT.
Similar to S/L services, the District is able to provide appropriate OT services but has not done so, nor is the current offer appropriate. To provide appropriate OT services, the District will need to convene a new IEP meeting and offer a minimum of sixty minutes a week of individual OT. Whether these services will be provided by District staff or through a nonpublic agency will be left to the discretion of the IEP team.
CONCLUSION
The District has failed to offer or provide STUDENT with appropriate S/L or OT services from November 27, 1999, through the date of this Decision. As a result of this failure, the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for the private S/L service they obtained from Sheila Moskowitz from November 1999 through the date of this Decision. The PARENTS are also entitled to reimbursement for the private OT services they obtained from Abby Yolles from September 2000 through the date of this Decision. However the PARENTS are not entitled to ongoing private S/L or OT services. To provide appropriate S/L and OT services, the District must convene an IEP meeting and amend the December 2002 IEP by drafting additional S/L goals and objectives to cover all of STUDENT’s needs in this area: short-term memory and word finding, pragmatics, linguistic flexibility (expressions with multiple meanings), and use of linguistic abstracts (metaphors and idioms), and higher order reasoning such as inferences and prediction. To meet these needs, the District must offer a minimum of sixty minutes a week of individual S/L therapy. Although the District’s current OT goals and objectives as contained in the December 2002 IEP are appropriate, the District must amend that IEP by offering a minimum of sixty minutes a week of individual OT in order to properly address all of STUDENT’s identified needs in that area.
In addition, the District failed to make a specific offer of placement at the May 2001 IEP meeting. However, because the PARENTS’ unilateral private placement at the May Center was not appropriate under the IDEA, the PARENTS’ are not entitled to reimbursement for the costs of this placement, or the costs associated with locating this placement.
Because the District failed to complete a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT and subsequently relied on Dr. Kogan’s assessment, the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the psychoeducational assessment performed by Dr. Nina Kogan.
ORDER
1. Within thirty calendar days of receipt of proof of the cost of STUDENT’s private speech/language therapy provided by Sheila Moskowitz from November 27, 1999 through the date of this Decision, the District shall reimburse Petitioner for the cost of these services.
2. Within thirty calendar days of receipt of proof of the cost of STUDENT’s private occupational therapy provided by Abby Yolles from September 2000 through the date of this Decision, the District shall reimburse Petitioner for the cost of these services.
3. Within thirty calendar days of receipt of proof of the cost of Dr. Kogan’s psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT in September and August of 2000, the District shall reimburse Petitioner for the cost of that assessment.
4. Within thirty calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting to revise the December 2, 2002 IEP. At this meeting the IEP team will draft new speech/language goals and objections to address all of STUDENT’s educational speech/language needs: short-term memory and word finding, pragmatics, linguistic flexibility (expressions with multiple meanings), linguistic abstracts (metaphors and idioms), and higher order reasoning such as inferences and prediction. The December 2, 2002 IEP shall also be revised to provide STUDENT with sixty minutes a week of individual speech/language therapy to address the new goals and objectives, and sixty minutes a week of individual occupational therapy to address the existing goals and objectives.
5. All of Petitioner’s other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
1. Did the District fail to offer STUDENT with a FAPE for the time period of November 27, 1999 through the present?
a. For the 1999-2000 school year, including the extended school year:
1. Did the District fail to offer and provide STUDENT with appropriate occupational therapy services? 2. Did the District fail to offer and provide STUDENT with appropriate speech/language services?
Petitioner prevailed on all issues for this school year.
b. For the 2000-2001 school year, including the extended school year:
1. Did the District fail to offer and provide STUDENT with appropriate occupational therapy services? 2. Did the District fail to offer and provide STUDENT with appropriate speech/language services?
Petitioner prevailed on all issues for this school year.
c. For the 2001-2002 school year, including the extended school year:
1. Did the District fail to make an offer of an appropriate placement at the May 29, 2001 IEP team meeting? 2. Following STUDENT’s placement at the Westwood Charter School, did the District fail to offer and provide STUDENT with appropriate occupational therapy services? 3. Following STUDENT’s placement at the Westwood Charter School, did the District fail to offer and provide STUDENT with appropriate speech/language services?
Petitioner prevailed on all issues for this school year.
d. For the 2002-2003 school year, including the extended school year:
1. Did the District fail to offer and provide STUDENT with appropriate occupational therapy services? 2. Did the District fail to offer and provide STUDENT with appropriate speech/language services?
Petitioner prevailed on all issues for this school year.
2. As a result of the District’s alleged failures for the time period of November 1999 to the present, is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the following:
a. The cost of private speech/language services provided by Sheila Moskowitz for the time period November 1999 to the present.
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
b. The cost of private occupational therapy services provided by Abby Yolles for the time period September 2000 to the present.
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
c. The cost of the independent educational evaluation of Dr. Nina Kogan completed in September 2000.
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
d. The cost of STUDENT’s placement at the May Center, including tuition, transportation, lodging, and the cost of the PARENTS’ search for a new placement, including travel costs for visiting the May Center as well as the Morningside Academy in Seattle.
Respondent prevailed on this issue.
3. Does STUDENT require ongoing private speech/language services of two hours a week for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year, including the extended school year?
Respondent prevailed on this issue.
4. Does STUDENT require ongoing private occupational therapy services of one hour a week for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year, including the extended school year?
Respondent prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: June 25, 2003 ____________________________________ Lawrence E. Mendel, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. For purposes of clarification and organization, the Hearing Officer has revised the parties’ statements of the issues. These revisions only affect the organization of the Decision and not the substantive analysis. 2. The PARENTS had had to stop the private OT they were providing due to logistical problems. 3. The District and the PARENTS were engaged in negotiations on the amount of time necessary to make up for the missed OT sessions. The amount and provision of these compensatory OT services was not raised as an issue for this hearing. 4. STUDENT’s triennial assessment in 1999 did not contain a psychoeducational assessment. 5. Although the time period covered in this case extends to November 1999, the evidence established that District OT services did not commence until December 1999. 6. It has already been found that Ms. McKim was not providing appropriate OT services. 7. Ms. Kelly had taken over for Ms. Xiong in September 2002.
8. Ms. Yolles did have a seventh goal, for STUDENT to learn keyboarding. Although this was something she was working on with STUDENT, there was no evidence that this skill was necessary for STUDENT to benefit from his education.
