California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 11, 2003
Student v. Redlands Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 2692-02 · Hearing Officer Tracy L. Tibbals
Redlands Unified violated child find and must fund evaluations, Frostig School tuition and living expenses for a senior with seizures
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of an 18-year-old senior filed against Redlands Unified School District. Her grades had fallen from honor roll to mostly D's and F's in high school. Her parents repeatedly asked her counselor for help and raised testing, but the District did not assess her until they made a written request in February 2002. School psychologist Ronald Sewell gave a brief test battery, found average intelligence, and blamed emotional factors. The IEP team found her not eligible. Private evaluators then found something else. Psychiatrist Dr. Robert duBois Lynch diagnosed frequent brief seizures that affect comprehension. Psychologist Dr. Donald Hoaglund found a severe gap between her ability and her achievement. Her parents placed her at the Frostig School, a nonpublic school in Pasadena.
Hearing Officer Tracy L. Tibbals found that the District violated child find. The steep grade drop, low test scores, known childhood meningitis and the parents' requests should have raised a suspicion of disability. The District's assessment was also inadequate. It relied on one IQ test, did not test written expression, and ignored motor, comprehension and health concerns. The Hearing Officer found her eligible as other health impaired and as having a specific learning disability. The District must reimburse both private evaluations ($5,373), Frostig tuition from October 2002, and monthly living expenses near the school. It must also fund Frostig through the end of 2002-2003. Claims for Sylvan tutoring, travel and meals were denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled child find when a student's grades collapsed without explanation and her parents raised testing only out loud. The Hearing Officer held that the trigger for assessment is a suspected disability, not an obvious one. The district had to assess in all suspected areas, including health, and choose tests that the student's processing deficits would not skew.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedChild find
Issue 1. Did the District fulfill its responsibilities to identify Petitioner as a child with a disability?
The sharp drop from honor-roll grades, continued failure despite heavy homework time, known meningitis history and parent inquiries by May 2001 should have led the District to suspect a disability; it had to at least tell the parents how to request assessment in writing and should have recommended assessment.
- Student prevailedAssessment
Issue 2. Did the District conduct appropriate assessments and assess the Petitioner in all areas of suspected disability?
The District assessment relied on one IQ measure (KBIT) skewed by processing deficits, did not test written expression, and failed to follow up on low comprehension, motor and visual-integration scores, possible emotional disturbance, and possible medical causes, including a health assessment.
- Student prevailedEligibility
Issue 3. Was the Petitioner eligible for special education and related services as an individual with special needs as other health impaired or having a specific learning disability while enrolled in the District?
The uncontroverted diagnosis of frequent seizures limiting alertness supports other health impaired eligibility. Dr. Hoaglund's analysis shows a severe ability-achievement discrepancy for specific learning disability, and her needs could not be met through regular-program modifications.
- Student prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 4. Is the Petitioner entitled to reimbursement of the cost for private assessments by Dr. Robert duBois Lynch and Dr. Donald D. Hoaglund?
Parents disagreed with the District assessment and the District did not show its assessment was appropriate, so both private evaluations are reimbursable.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 5. Is the Petitioner entitled to reimbursement of the cost for tutoring services at the Sylvan Learning Center in Redlands, California, and costs, including tuition, lodging, travel, and meals, for attending the Frostig School, a nonpublic school (NPS), in Pasadena, California?
The District denied FAPE. Frostig tuition and $1,310 (ordered as $1,305) per month in living expenses from February 1, 2003 are reimbursed. Sylvan assessment and tutoring, travel, and meals are denied because Sylvan predated any District assessment and gave no benefit, and the record lacked proof of the added travel and meal costs.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 6. Is the Petitioner entitled to a private placement at the Frostig School at the District's expense?
Frostig met the student's unique needs and gave educational benefit. With about two months left before graduation, she should stay there, with the District funding tuition and living expenses through the end of 2002-2003.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 20 calendar days of the Decision, convene an IEP meeting to find the student eligible for special education in line with the Decision and develop a complete IEP placing her at the Frostig School.
- IEE at public expense. Reimburse parents for the private assessments: $1,138.00 (Dr. Robert duBois Lynch) and $4,235.00 (Dr. Donald Hoaglund).
- Reimbursement. Reimburse parents for Frostig School tuition and related services from October 1, 2002 through the date of the Decision, as shown on Student Exhibit 53 and verified and updated with Frostig. Amount not stated.
- Reimbursement. Reimburse parents for living expenses of $1,305 per month (the body of the Decision says $1,310) from February 1, 2003, prorated through the date of the Decision.
- Placement ordered. The student is to be placed at the Frostig School for the rest of the 2002-2003 school year.
- Prospective funding of private placement. The District pays Frostig tuition directly from the date of the Decision through the end of the school year, and pays parents living expenses of $1,305 per month, prorated, through the end of the current Frostig term.
Total: $5,373 ordered
Key authorities
School Committee of Town of Burlington v. Department of Education; Florence County School District Four v. Carter; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Cal. Educ. Code § 56320; Cal. Educ. Code § 56337; Title 5 CCR § 3030; 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b); 34 C.F.R. § 300.532
People named in the decision
- Gail Lindberg, District advocate; program manager, East Valley Special Education Local Plan Area
- Cheryl Sjostrom, special services director, Redlands Unified School District
- Betty G. Hill, high school counselor, Redlands East Valley High School, Redlands Unified School District
- Sandy Russell-Nichley, counselor, Redlands Unified School District
- Ronald Sewell, school psychologist (District assessor), Redlands Unified School District
- Linda Carter, resource teacher (classroom observation), Redlands Unified School District
- David Belk, U.S. history teacher, Redlands Unified School District
- Sandy A. Crumrine, independent study instructor, Redlands Unified School District
- John Salvador, world history teacher, Redlands Unified School District
- James Bigelow, mathematics teacher, Redlands Unified School District
- Carolyn Sitter, independent study counselor, Redlands Unified School District
- Dr. Robert duBois Lynch, private psychiatrist (neuropsychiatric evaluation); expert witness for Student
- Dr. Donald D. Hoaglund, private clinical and forensic psychologist (neurocognitive evaluation); expert witness for Student
- Dr. Eric Fox, private neurologist (EEG)
- Dr. Klein, physician referenced for EEG (Student Exhibit 39)
- Tobey Shaw, principal, witness for Student, Frostig School (nonpublic school)
- Frostig School, certified nonpublic school, Pasadena
- Sylvan Learning Center, private tutoring provider, Redlands
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Tracy L. Tibbals, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Redlands, California, on February 20, 21, 25, and 26, 2003, and in Pasadena, California, on the afternoon of February 26, 2003.
Petitioner STUDENT (STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented at the hearing by attorney Benjamin Y. Kim. Also present on the Petitioner’s behalf were her parents, FATHER and MOTHER. The Redlands Unified School District (District or Respondent) was represented at the hearing by advocate Gail Lindberg, program manager for the East Valley Special Education Local Plan Area. Also present on behalf of the District was Cheryl Sjostrom, special services director.
Petitioner called as witnesses herself, her parents, District counselor Betty G. Hill, psychiatrist Dr. Robert duBois Lynch, psychologist Donald D. Hoaglund, District psychologist Ronald Sewell, and Frostig School principal Tobey Shaw. The District called District U.S. history teacher David Belk, independent study instructor Sandy A. Crumrine, world history teacher John Salvador, mathematics teacher James Bigelow, counselor Sandy Russell-Nichley, and independent study counselor Carolyn Sitter.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the receipt of written closing briefs. After receipt of the briefs, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING(Footnote 1)
1. Did the District fulfill its responsibilities to identify Petitioner as a child with a disability?
2. Did the District conduct appropriate assessments and assess the Petitioner in all areas of suspected disability?
3. Was the Petitioner eligible for special education and related services as an individual with special needs as other health impaired or having a specific learning disability while enrolled in the District?
4. Is the Petitioner entitled to reimbursement of the cost for private assessments by Dr. Robert duBois Lynch and Dr. Donald D. Hoaglund?
5. Is the Petitioner entitled to reimbursement of the cost for tutoring services at the Sylvan Learning Center in Redlands, California, and costs, including tuition, lodging, travel, and meals, for attending the Frostig School, a nonpublic school (NPS), in Pasadena, California?
6. Is the Petitioner entitled to a private placement at the Frostig School at the District’s expense?
BACKGROUND FACTS
Petitioner is an eighteen-year-old high school senior residing within the boundaries of the District. She received a medical diagnosis in June 2002 that included in part that she experiences complex partial seizures causing a major learning disability of poor comprehension in reading and listening. The diagnosing physician concluded that during approximately one third of her waking hours she has seizures lasting three to forty seconds. These episodes pass without any obvious indication to an untrained observer. She has never been determined eligible for special education. She is now attending classes at the Frostig School after a unilateral placement by her parents.
At age two she was hospitalized in the intensive care unit because of spinal meningitis and lapsed into a coma that lasted four days. This is now the suspected cause of her medical diagnosis. At the time of her meningitis affliction, her father recalls her doctor informing him of the life threatening nature of the illness and its potential for causing brain damage. No apparent health consequences followed STUDENT throughout her childhood. STUDENT was an active youngster, participating in various sports including soccer, softball, and cross-country track. In the fall of her freshman year in high school, however, she fainted while running in a cross-country meet. She had had no similar health problems previously. Her family at the time did not connect this event to her meningitis some twelve or more years before.
STUDENT enrolled in the District in January 2001 in the middle of her tenth grade year. Until this time she had attended the Rialto Unified School District. Her grades in school were good to excellent until her freshman high school year at Rialto. At that point her grades slipped precipitously from honor roll status with A’s and B’s to predominately D’s and F’s. STUDENT was distraught over this sudden decline, and she and her parents could not make sense of or stop this steep slide in her grades. Her parents even relocated the family from Rialto to Redlands, hoping that the change in school districts would improve her academic performance.
STUDENT began classes at the Respondent’s Redlands East Valley High School in January 2001. STUDENT’s father met with STUDENT’s counselor, Ms. Betty Hill, to review the curriculum and to bring her STUDENT’s Rialto transcripts. As the term progressed, STUDENT did not do better academically than she had at Rialto. In light of STUDENT’s continuing grade problems, FATHER communicated regularly with counselor Hill seeking help to improve STUDENT’s performance. Based on reports from STUDENT’s teachers, Ms. Hill told FATHER about two months into her first term in the District that STUDENT was not studying enough and was not turning in her homework.
STUDENT and her parents were distressed that her academic performance was not improving as they had hoped. In spite of the fact that she would study for several hours at home every night, STUDENT’s teachers continued to report that the poor grades were a result of not completing homework and failure to master the material.
FATHER testified that he asked Ms. Hill on more than one occasion to have STUDENT tested as a means to find out why she was failing in most of her core classes and to help STUDENT achieve a decent level of grades so that she could graduate and go on to college. FATHER stated that he informed Ms. Hill about STUDENT’s medical history and, at one point, told the counselor that it could have caused learning disabilities. FATHER recalled that Ms. Hill’s response was that STUDENT did not need testing but needed to study more and work harder. Ms. Hill did not recall the verbal requests for testing.
In an effort to improve STUDENT’s grades, her parents placed her in the Sylvan Learning Center (Sylvan), a private tutoring service, for three days a week starting in May 2001. MOTHER testified that one of the reasons the family went to Sylvan was for testing, as the District would not assess STUDENT.
STUDENT’s parents report that Sylvan tested STUDENT and found that her reading was far below grade level and that she had difficulties with reading comprehension. She stayed with the Sylvan program for about nine months with no appreciable progress in reading comprehension or school grades. FATHER and MOTHER understood from Sylvan that this organization’s testing did not assess for learning disabilities, but they understood from Sylvan that in STUDENT’s case “there could be something there.”
At the end of her first semester in the District, STUDENT received only one passing grade in her core academic classes. In a May 2001 meeting between counselor Hill and STUDENT’s parents, Ms. Hill repeated that STUDENT’s problems were lack of attentiveness and not working hard enough. Ms. Hill strongly recommended continuation high school at the District’s Orangewood School as STUDENT’s “only option” to make up the failed classes in time for graduation with her class. FATHER initially refused this option.
STUDENT’s grades continued predominately in the “D” and “F” range as STUDENT went through her eleventh-grade year. In the face of this lack of improvement, in the spring of 2002 FATHER finally assented to placement in the continuation high school over STUDENT’s strong objection.
Near the end of February 2002, at the request of her parents, STUDENT was assigned to a new counselor, Ms. Sandy Russell-Nichley. As STUDENT was at risk of not graduating with her class, her new counselor placed her in an independent study program. STUDENT was successful in this self-paced program and made up several credits.
No District employee had advised the parents of the procedure to initiate assessment. In February 2002, STUDENT’s mother learned from a co-worker about a web site that offered information about how to obtain district assessments for public school students. From visiting this web site, the PARENTS learned that under the law the District must assess STUDENT for suspected learning disabilities if a written request were made.
In late February 2002, STUDENT’s parents made written requests for STUDENT’s assessment. FATHER described the written requests to be without distinction from his verbal request for testing in February 2001 and on several occasions thereafter. The written requests, one to the high school vice principal and one to the District psychologist, mentioned the bout with meningitis, the coma, and the “possibility that she may have some sort of learning disability.”
The District responded timely to the written request. District psychologist Ronald Sewell interviewed MOTHER and obtained a parents’ questionnaire from the PARENTS that disclosed the meningitis and coma at age two but with no further details. The parents’ questionnaire did not list the fainting spell STUDENT experienced in her freshman year in Rialto, but MOTHER indicated that she told Mr. Sewell about this episode during the parent interview.
Mr. Sewell drafted an assessment plan that did not call for any medical screening beyond vision and hearing checkups. FATHER and MOTHER approved the plan as proposed. Mr. Sewell then conducted a two-hour testing session with STUDENT. After he obtained the results of the testing, he prepared his April 29, 2002 evaluation report. In this report he did not recommend initiation of special education and support services. He found STUDENT to be in the average range for intelligence with “no evidence of a serious and ongoing specific learning disability which is impacting overall learning and achievement.” He concluded that her academic performance was the result of what he observed to be “emotional factors.”
Resource teacher Linda Carter conducted a classroom observation of STUDENT as part of the assessment. Her written report described STUDENT as daydreaming during class with short attention and that she was “off task easily.” With respect to following directions, Ms. Carter stated that STUDENT observes others first and needs repetition. Her motor skills were termed “limited.” Teacher observations both for this assessment and in general consistently viewed STUDENT as courteous and well behaved but unable to keep up with the classroom work.
The IEP team met on April 29, 2002, for approximately one and one-half hours and considered Mr. Sewell’s evaluation and the classroom observations. Ms. Carter, the classroom observer, did not attend the meeting. The team determined that STUDENT was not eligible for special education but recommended that her parents privately fund counseling to “assist STUDENT with stress management.”
Dissatisfied with the IEP team’s findings, FATHER and MOTHER sought a second opinion.
On May 30, 2002, STUDENT went to Dr. Eric Fox, a neurologist, who administered an electroencephalogram (EEG). His report interpreting the EEG found it to be “abnormal” and described “epileptiform spike-wave complexes” and “abnormalities . . . consistent with structural damage, probably involving the right hemisphere and lowered seizure threshhold.”
On June 20, 2002, she went the Dr. Robert duBois Lynch, a psychiatrist who specializes in neuropsychiatric evaluations. Dr. Lynch conducted an eight-hour examination of STUDENT and concluded that she had “seizures,” a “major learning disability of poor comprehension in reading and listening,” “obsessive compulsive disorder, moderate,” and “anxiety disorder, moderate.” He found that most of her stress is from the reactions of others to her disorders.
Dr. Lynch testified that she suffered seizures from four to forty seconds in duration about one third of her waking hours. During his clinical examination Dr. Lynch noted theses seizure events occurred with her eyes open. She would simply “blank out.” He observed that it would be rare for an untrained person to detect this constant seizure activity. He said that the family would likely assume this behavior was part of her personality and think that she was simply “not paying attention.” In the school setting, he said that during her blank spells STUDENT can hear the teacher but not the content of what is being said.
Dr. Lynch connected this constant spate of seizures to STUDENT’s academic difficulties. He found that she is “a potentially gifted learning disabled person with dysphasia with difficulty in encoding, slow rise time, and difficulty in retrieving learned information.” Dr. Lynch stated that STUDENT will require extra time in learning. According to Dr. Lynch, her penmanship, spelling, and written expression are impacted by dyspraxia which suggests that written expression may never fully represent her intelligence. Discussing STUDENT’s sudden change in grades’ performance after the eighth grade, he said that his “best guess” is that the onset of puberty increased the seizure activity.
Clinical and forensic psychologist Dr. Donald D. Hoaglund prepared a follow-up “neurocognitive and psychological evaluation.” After twelve hours of testing and evaluation over several office visits from July 31 through August 16, 2002, Dr. Hoaglund concluded that STUDENT had specific processing disorders that required more time for her to complete tasks. Dr. Hoaglund assessed STUDENT’s intelligence to approach the gifted range. He found STUDENT to be a learning disabled student with cognitive deficits that explained the discrepancy between academic achievement and ability.
After obtaining the reports from Dr. Lynch and Dr. Hoaglund, the PARENTS informed the District of the EEG findings and the private assessments by telephone and by letter from Petitioner’s attorney. The District did not take any action in response to these communications.
At the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT’s parents withdrew her from the District and enrolled her in the Frostig School, a certified nonpublic school (NPS) in Pasadena that specializes in teaching students with learning disabilities. She plans on graduating from the Frostig School in the spring of 2003.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The Petitioner contends that the District did not identify STUDENT as an individual with a potential disability and did not evaluate her in all areas of suspected disability. The Petitioner maintains that she is eligible for special education and services.
The District counters that it did not have sufficient information from STUDENT’s parents or indication from her classroom performance to suspect that STUDENT had a learning disability or a medical problem. Such a disability, the District maintains, would be revealed only through an assessment beyond that which the District psychologist can perform.
The Petitioner contends she is entitled to reimbursement for the assessments of Dr. Lynch and Dr. Hoaglund, the services she received at the Sylvan Learning Center, and the total costs for attending the Frostig School in Pasadena.
She also maintains that she is entitled to placement in and prospective District funding of her tuition and living expenses for the Frostig School.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue Number 1: Did the District fulfill its responsibilities to identify Petitioner as a child with a disability?
The District under the law must “systematically seek out” all persons living within the District’s boundaries who are less than 22 years of age and have exceptional needs. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10); Cal. Educ. Code § 56300. To fulfill this “child find” duty, “[E]ach district, special education local plan area, or county office shall provide for the identification and assessment of an individual’s exceptional needs, and the planning of an instructional program to meet the assessed needs .” Cal. Educ. Code § 56302.
Before considering the District’s assessment of STUDENT, the first question is did the District fulfill its “child find” duty? The Petitioner contends that the District breached this duty in the face of STUDENT’s sudden grade decline, knowledge of her childhood meningitis, and constant pleas for help from her parents. The District contends that Petitioner’s condition was not apparent to her teachers and that even Petitioner’s parents did not suspect that she was experiencing seizures.
It is uncontroverted that the PARENTS frequently contacted STUDENT’s guidance counselor, Ms. Betty Hill, seeking help and exploring all possible solutions to STUDENT’s problem of continuing bad grades. Both parents stated that they asked for help and raised the issue of assessment more than once in 2001. MOTHER stated that she did not hear from Ms. Hill between registration in January 2001 and late May 2001, even though MOTHER understood that Ms. Hill would keep her informed of STUDENT’s performance. MOTHER said that Ms. Hill called the home at 9:30 p.m. for the first time in May 2001 to tell the PARENTS that STUDENT was not on track for graduation.
MOTHER described the meeting following this telephone call on or about May 28, 2001, with Ms. Hill with STUDENT present. MOTHER characterized the session as “heated.” She stated that she asked about testing and raised the issue of a possible learning disability and potential linkage to STUDENT’s childhood meningitis. MOTHER testified that this was the meeting at which Ms. Hill said testing was not called for and only recommended the transfer to Orangewood.
Ms. Hill testified that she learned of STUDENT’s meningitis from her parents in January 2001, when STUDENT first registered in the District. She understood that it was not “full-blown” in that there were no complications such as deafness, physiological disabilities, or seizures. She also referred to FATHER’s “active communication” about STUDENT and characterized his communications as “consistent themes” dealing with concern over STUDENT’s academic failures, why she was not successful in the District, and requests for help. Ms. Hill recalled FATHER’s initial theory that STUDENT’s grades were a result of her discomfort in her prior school because of escalating violence. Ms. Hill, however, never reconsidered this “theory” when STUDENT’s grades did not improve after the first progress report in the new school setting, without the influence of violence. The counselor also stated that neither FATHER nor MOTHER ever asked for an assessment. She said that she was aware of the tutoring at Sylvan and understood from FATHER that Sylvan would do an assessment. She said that she never received a Sylvan assessment.(Footnote 2) Ms. Hill did not look past the teacher reports of “daydreaming” and “not completing assignments” as the explanations.
Although Ms. Hill did not recall the parents asking for testing, the Hearing Officer finds that the record supports that FATHER and MOTHER inquired about assessment no later than May 2001 during the session with Ms. Hill when she recommended the continuation high school program for STUDENT. In addition, from January 2001 until the written assessment request in February 2002, the District had indications that should have raised a suspicion that STUDENT could have a disability. These include the sudden “free fall” in her grades from elementary to high school evident in her cumulative file, the fact that a “free fall” persisted after STUDENT’s transfer to the District, and the fact that notwithstanding her parents’ reports of the time that she spent on homework, her teachers observed that she did not complete her assignments. The District was also aware that STUDENT had a history of meningitis. This, combined with STUDENT’s unexplained serious and recent failures in school, should have led the District to suspect a disability.
The Hearing Officer concludes that when the parents inquired about assessment, the District had a duty under its child find obligations at least to advise the FAMILY about the proper procedures to put the assessment request into writing. Title 5, CCR § 3021(a). In addition, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District had sufficient information to suspect a disability and was obligated to recommend an assessment even without a specific parental request.
The record establishes that the District did not fulfill its child find responsibilities.
Issue Number 2: Did the District conduct appropriate assessments and assess the Petitioner in all areas of suspected disability?
A student must be assessed in all areas of suspected disability before any action is taken. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320. This assessment process commences through a written referral by a parent, teacher, school personnel, or other appropriate agency or person. Cal. Educ. Code § 56302, 56321(a); Title 5 CCR § 3021.
As the discussion below details, STUDENT has at least two recognizable disabilities qualifying her for special education eligibility. The District assessment did not find either one of these disabilities. The record shows that the District did not follow up with further assessment in the areas of poor motor skills, visual integration, low comprehension and reading skills, and potential emotional disturbance. In April 2002, STUDENT was first assessed by Mr. Sewell.(Footnote 3) He performed an assessment and prepared a written “Psycho-educational Report” (Student Exhibit 30). He spent a total of one and one-half to two hours with STUDENT, three to four hours to compile and to score the results, and approximately one day to prepare his report. In conducting his assessment, he reviewed STUDENT’s school records, standardized tests, and third-party written information in the parents’ questionnaire, teacher evaluations, and one “Observation of Relevant Behavior.” Mr. Sewell also interviewed STUDENT’s mother. He had a questionnaire from STUDENT’s parents that noted the meningitis, the coma, and the possibility of a learning disability. (Footnote 4) As the sole measure of STUDENT’s intelligence, Mr. Sewell administered the Kaufman Brief Intelligence Test (KBIT). To measure achievement, he administered the Wide-Range Achievement Test--III (WRAT–III), and the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement–III (WJ-III). He evaluated her perception through the Beery Development Test of Visual-Motor Integration (BDVM) and the Beery Development Test of Visual Perception (BDVP). He also administered the Detroit Test of Learning Aptitude–III and the Learning Efficiency Test II. His assessment also include the parent-completed Behavior Assessment System For Children and the Behavior Rating Profile-II Student Form.
Relying on his KBIT results, Mr. Sewell found her composite IQ to be 104 “at the 61st %ile and is solidly average.” He also found her achievement to be average. Her percentile scores on the WRAT–III ranged from a high of 70 for spelling to 32 to 24 for reading and arithmetic respectively. The WJ-II percentile rankings were in the 31-36 range for language skills and at 48 for applied math problems. STUDENT scored at the fourth percentile in visual motor integration on the BDVM. Mr. Sewell found the last score to be “borderline.” Her visual perception ranked at the 32nd percentile on the BDVP.
Independent assessor Dr. Donald Hoagland spent twelve hours in approximately two-hour increments from July 31 through August 16, 2002. He indicated that he spread out the testing to address STUDENT’s need for relatively short sessions to overcome her fatigue that would set in after about two hours. He reviewed background records, including Dr. Lynch’s report, and administered a battery of standard measuring instruments. These included the Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale-Third Addition (WAIS-III), the Comprehensive Test of Non-Verbal Intelligence (CTONI), and the Woodcock-Johnson Psycho-Educational Battery-Third Edition sub tests for achievement and cognitive ability. He also administered the Informal Reading Inventory (IRI) to assess reading comprehension.
He also administered some twelve additional tests under the category “ Neurocognitive Testing,” and two tests under the category “Psychological Testing.” He compiled the results and his conclusions in a 42-page report (Student Exhibit 41). Dr. Hoaglund testified that STUDENT is “of above average to superior ability.” He relied on the CTONI to determine ability. He observed that this test instrument does not rely on language processing to reach a result as do other regularly administered tests of intelligence. He found that “cognitive processing deficits interfered with her effective use of her intelligence.”
Dr. Hoaglund testified that although the KBIT utilized by the District is a recognized testing instrument, its accuracy is more dependent on the processing skills of the test subject than are alternate means of testing. In light of STUDENT’s demonstrable deficits including inability to copy accurately, motor skills weaknesses, and expression limitations reflected in the District’s own assessment, other testing protocols that circumvent these limitations are necessary to achieve a more reliable measure of her abilities. The District should have used other assessment instruments. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320 (d).
Dr. Hoaglund testified to his use of the CTONI to measure STUDENT’s ability. This test is not timed and does not have a memory component. Mr. Sewell challenged the use of the CTONI by Dr. Hoaglund as a test primarily designed for non-English-speaking students. Dr. Hoaglund, however, convincingly explained that the CTONI is not limited to non-English speakers and its use of pictorial and geometric media circumvents deficits such as STUDENT’s to yield an accurate result. The findings of Dr. Lynch (Student Exhibit 40) and Dr. Hoaglund (Student Exhibit 41) establish that an intelligence measurement tool whose results would not be skewed by comprehension or expression disabilities would have yielded a much higher result.
On the basis of the finding that STUDENT possessed average intelligence, the District report found no severe discrepancy between assessed ability and achievement. The District report further found no evidence of a specific learning disability and concluded that the results “do not appear to meet the State of California criteria for the initiation of special education and support services.” Mr. Sewell used only one measure, the KBIT, to determine STUDENT’s I.Q. The Hearing Officer finds that this is insufficient as no effort was made to obtain test results “that accurately reflect the pupil’s aptitude, achievement level, or any other factors the test purports to measure and not the pupil’s impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills unless those skills are the factors the test purports to measure.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(d).
Mr. Sewell’s saw the primary source of STUDENT’s “school related failure” to be “emotional factors.” He referred to a “ran away episode” of less than one-day when STUDENT lived in Rialto. He recommended that STUDENT’s parents explore counseling “at their own expense. . .as an option to ameliorate STUDENT’s present academic frustrations.” Mr. Sewell apparently suspected an emotional basis for STUDENT’s poor performance even before he began the assessment. He testified that it was common for high school youths to have such problems during adolescence. He listed drugs, alcohol, family problems, and “boy-girl” issues as commonly arising when youngsters enter high school. He observed that “grades drop all the time.” MOTHER testified that during her pre-assessment interview with Mr. Sewell, he constantly inquired about such factors as marital discord, family frictions, peer problems, sibling problems, and similar issues. Mr. Sewell found none of these factors to be present. He does, however, zero in on a one-day run away episode, apparently to show that this was indicative of an emotional problem in the home. The record gives no further details of what Mr. Sewell knew about this event. Dr. Lynch’s report, however, describes the event as a one-time occurrence arising out of STUDENT’s understandable upset at the sudden death of a peer in an automobile accident.
There is no immediate indication that STUDENT had any social or family problems that would be emotionally upsetting. Her teachers report without exception that STUDENT is pleasant and well-behaved. The parents’ questionnaire supplied to Mr. Sewell before his assessment described a stable home life. This questionnaire, however, also disclosed that STUDENT had been exposed to alcoholism, drug use, death of close friends and family, and mental problems.
Mr. Sewell’s “emotional upset” theory is plausible to explain extreme contrast between a student’s pre-high school and high school grades. It was appropriate to probe further to see if STUDENT had an emotional problem of such a magnitude that could cause such a major decline in grade performance. The District had the indications to do more to testing rather than to recommend that the parents pay for nonspecific therapy. Emotional disturbance, a recognized ground for special education eligibility, should have been considered as a suspected disability in the face of a serious decline in grades.
This serious decline in grades was the biggest clue. The District report recites from a record review that STUDENT earned above-average grades through the eighth grade and that she enjoyed “honor roll” status. From the ninth grade onward, her grades predominately were near failing or failing. On the parent questionnaire, STUDENT’s parents reported that the Sylvan testing showed that she was two and one-half years behind in comprehension and that she needed a smaller class size because she was easily distracted. Moreover, the District knew that she spent substantial time on her homework. The record indicates that she tended to sit at or near the front of the classroom. Nevertheless, teachers universally observed in written reports that STUDENT “daydreams” or cannot follow directions. Tutoring did not improve STUDENT’s performance. Problems remained with basic comprehension and reading skills. STUDENT, whose athletic activities were disclosed to the District, inconsistently had noticeable motor skills problems observed in the District assessment. The information provided by the parents disclosed STUDENT’s meningitis and a sibling and grandmother with seizures.
Even STUDENT’s achievement scores on the tests that were part of the District assessment showed woefully low levels in comprehension and reading skills. Additionally, STUDENT took the standardized SAT-9 tests on April 23, 2001 (District Exhibit 8). These scores were also in her file and revealed that in the second semester of her tenth grade year her reading comprehension was at the sixth percentile or a 4.8 grade level. Her language, language mechanics, and language expression all fell in the fourth to eighth percentiles or in the early fourth grade range. The evidence shows that the District curriculum pointed to further testing. District counselor Russell-Nichley stated that Mr. Sewell’s assessment did not measure written expression, an area where STUDENT had shown great difficulty. This difficulty was yet another manifestation of her disabilities. Ms. Russell-Nichley indicated that the District’s curriculum emphasizes written expression for at least one third of student assignments. It follows that a District assessment should test for this important skill area, particularly when this was one of the areas causing STUDENT difficulty and a major component of the District’s curriculum. The District report also includes observations that STUDENT had “fine motor paper/pencil prehension inefficiencies” or “foibles.” This was attributed to her below average visual-motor integration. The report also contained Ms. Carter’s written classroom observations that STUDENT had “limited” motor skills, short attention, and was frequently daydreaming.
Mr. Sewell acknowledged during his testimony that STUDENT’s grades were consistent for a student with a learning disability. “Attention problems” observed by all of STUDENT’s teachers, Mr. Sewell stated, also could be construed as pointing to an “at risk” status. He also said that “peaks and valleys,” in test scores, may further be an indiction of the presence of a learning disability. It appears that Mr. Sewell was so certain that typical adolescent emotional problems were at the root of STUDENT’s performance before he commenced his testing that he failed to give due consideration to the poor scores in basic comprehension, perception and expression that betokened something else was there. These test scores, coupled with the clues of failing grades, poor motor skills, daydreaming, family health history and difficulty following directions, should have raised a suspicion of disability with further testing to follow either by the District or through outside referrals.
The parties dispute whether the District should have recognized STUDENT’s history of meningitis as a possible cause of her present school difficulties. As noted above, the District did have knowledge of STUDENT’s medical history. Although Ms. Hill testified that she believed this medical history was a past event with no current repercussions, the Hearing Officer finds ample evidence that the parents did repeatedly raise the history of meningitis as a current concern. The question is whether the District was required to conduct medical assessments to explore further this link to STUDENT’s current educational problem.
Mr. Sewell indicated that a medical assessment would be recommended only if a medical problem was “obvious.” He also believed that the parents were not expecting a medical evaluation. As FATHER and MOTHER approved the assessment plan (District Exhibit 6) without change, this assertion appears to be correct. In addition, Dr. Lynch, however, observed that STUDENT’s seizure activity would escape notice by untrained eyes. Indeed, two doctors had treated STUDENT for her fainting spell and a dislocated shoulder, yet nothing in the record shows that either doctor noted seizure activity. Therefore, as apparently even treating medical doctors did not recognize STUDENT’s symptoms, it is not surprising that STUDENT’s parents and District personnel did not notice the seizures. The teachers who testified did note that STUDENT often did not pay attention. However, no teacher, not even one who himself was under medication to control grande mal seizures, suspected STUDENT was experiencing seizures in class.
The Hearing Officer finds, however, that the standard for assessing to identify disabilities is not that they are “obvious,” but that they are merely “suspected.” In addition, it is the District, not the parents, that had the responsibility of developing an appropriate assessment plan. The Hearing Officer finds that even if a potential link to STUDENT’s meningitis at age two and the family seizure history was sufficiently obscure to excuse the District from making the medical connection, her parents’ frequently expressed concerns, and her precipitous drop from honor roll status and low test scores should have led to further testing, including a medical assessment.(Footnote 5) The District was obligated to assess in all areas of suspected disability including health and was obligated to conduct an assessment that is “sufficiently comprehensive to identify all of the child’s special education and related services needs, whether or not commonly linked to the disability category in which the child has been classified.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.532(g) and (h).
The Hearing Officer finds that the District assessment was inadequate and did not assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability. The record shows a failure to follow up with suitable testing after low achievement scores in comprehension, motor skills, and visual integration and in light of STUDENT’s low grades, classroom inattentiveness, parent information, and possible medical causes. The evidence shows that there were other test instruments available, such as the CTONI, that were indicated as a means to reach an accurate result in view of the apparent comprehension and processing difficulties.
Issue Number 3: Was the Petitioner eligible for special education and related services as an individual with special needs in the areas of other health impaired and specific learning disability?
A student’s eligibility for special education is established if the following criteria are met: (1) the student has a disability as defined in federal law, and (2) because of the disability, the student must require instruction, services, or both which cannot be met by modification of the regular school program. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56026(a) and (b).
The federal definition of a disability constituting eligibility for special education includes mental retardation, hearing, speech, language, visual, orthopedic, and health impairments, autism, traumatic brain injury, and specific learning disabilities.
Eligibility for special education as other health impaired (OHI) arises if the student has “limited strength, vitality or alertness, due to chronic or acute health problems, including but not limited to a heart condition, cancer, leukemia, rheumatic fever, chronic kidney disease, cystic fibrosis, severe asthma, epilepsy, lead poisoning, diabetes, tuberculosis and other communicable infectious diseases, and hematological disorders such as sickle cell anemia and hemophilia which adversely affect a pupil’s educational performance.” Title 5 CCR § 3030(f).
The federal standard for OHI is met if the student has “limited strength, vitality or alertness, including a heightened alertness to environmental stimuli, that results in limited alertness with respect to the educational environment . . .” 34 CFR § 300.7(c)(9).
The three requirements to meet special education eligibility for specific learning disability are set out in California Education Code, Section 56337:
(a) A severe discrepancy exists between the intellectual ability and achievement in one or more of the following academic areas: (1) Oral expression;
(2) Listening comprehension;
(3) Written expression;
(4) Basic Reading Skills;
(5) Reading comprehension;
(6) Mathematics calculation;
(7) Mathematics reasoning.
(b) The discrepancy is due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes and is not the result of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantages.
(c) The discrepancy cannot be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program.
A severe discrepancy can be established through a formula using standardized tests, by alternative means when standardized tests are deemed invalid, or through an IEP team determination that such a discrepancy exists. Title 5 CCR § 3030(j)(4).
The practice is to interpret the required difference for a determination of a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement standard scores to be at least 22.5 points, 1.5 multiplied by the standard deviation of 15, plus or minus 4 points, which is one standard error of measurement. This computed difference constitutes a severe discrepancy when “such discrepancy is corroborated by other assessment data which may include other tests, scales, instruments and work samples, as appropriate. Title 5 CCR § 3030(j)(4)(A)
The evidence supports a finding that STUDENT is eligible for special education and services as other health impaired and specific learning disability.
On June 20, 2002, STUDENT saw Dr. Robert duBois Lynch, who specializes in neuropsychiatric assessment. He reviewed Dr. Klein’s EEG (Student Exhibit 39) that showed abnormalities and structural damage. Dr. Lynch administered numerous evaluation protocols over an eight-hour period. He prepared a fourteen-page report (Student Exhibit 40) that made several diagnoses. These included “complex partial seizures,” “Reading disorder, mainly for comprehension,” “Disorder of written expression,” and “Dysphasia for encoding & retrieving information.” Dr. Lynch also diagnosed “Obsessive compulsive disorder, moderate,” and “Anxiety disorder, moderate.” He concluded that STUDENT has a “major learning disability . . . of poor comprehension in reading and listening and this should be considered to be related to interruptions from blank spells as described.”
Dr. Lynch testified that STUDENT’s chronic health condition affected her educational progress. He said that her processing deficit and constant visual refocusing required accommodations for her to comprehend. Dr. Lynch indicated that STUDENT’s brain damage is in the right hemisphere, which is the repository of language. This, he explained, is the reason for her difficulty in comprehension and expression.
Applying the legal standard for SLD, Dr. Hoaglund found a discrepancy sufficient to qualify STUDENT for special education. His report contains a detailed analysis to show a severe discrepancy in all of the core areas. Dr. Hoaglund also found STUDENT eligible for special education as OHI because of her seizure disorder, which he concluded caused her attention deficiency and left her chronically mentally, if not physically, fatigued. He recommended intensive instruction in a nonpublic school specializing in disabled students. He also suggested psychotherapy to help her deal with anxiety and to “develop strategies for coping with her cognitive and learning deficits.”
Both independent assessments are thorough, well-documented, and convincing in describing STUDENT’s disabilities and providing the basis for special education eligibility in the areas of other health impaired and specific learning disability.
Dr. Lynch’s medical diagnosis is uncontroverted in the record. This diagnosis establishes that STUDENT has a health impairment with chronic seizures one third of her waking hours that limits her strength, vitality, and alertness to the extent that it adversely impacts her educational performance. This squarely meets the required elements of a chronic health problem set forth in 34 CFR section 300.7(c)(f) and Title 5 CCR section 3030(f). The Hearing Officer therefore finds that STUDENT is eligible for special education services on the grounds of other health impaired.
Dr. Hoaglund found a severe discrepancy qualifying STUDENT for special education and services under the category specific learning disability, whereas the District did not. Both Dr. Lynch and Dr. Hoaglund found that STUDENT possesses innate abilities in the superior to gifted range, while Mr. Sewell found that she had average intelligence. The District assessment overlooked the extremely low scores in comprehension and visual integration that suggest a discrepancy even for one of average intelligence, or at least a basis for further testing.
Dr. Lynch’s diagnoses established that STUDENT has superior abilities but is plagued with comprehension problems caused by her continuous seizures. Dr. Hoaglund used test devices that measured her ability and minimized the effects of disability. The Hearing Officer finds that the analysis and conclusions in the reports from these two assessors place STUDENT in the correct ability range.
The District has argued that STUDENT is not entitled to special education and services under Cal. Educ. Code section 56026(b) and Title 5, CCR section 3030, contending that she can be provided services through modifications to or accommodations in the regular school program. STUDENT was able to make up failed classes in relatively rapid fashion in a District independent studies program. This contention, however, is unavailing.
STUDENT’s academic shortfall was so extreme that she clearly did not make progress in the general curriculum in the District (District Exhibit 10). Her successes with make-up work in independent studies merely underscored her need for additional, if not unlimited, time to complete assignments. The Frostig School program meets STUDENT’s fundamental processing disorder needs that require services that are beyond what can be provided in the general education classroom. The use of assistive technology such as books on tape and computers at the Frostig School has proven to be a means for STUDENT to work through her disabilities. Specialized software, colored backgrounds on the computer screen, small class size, and individualized attention have met STUDENT’s needs to overcome her comprehension disabilities.
Based on her abilities, the achievement scores obtained by the District and Dr. Hoaglund, the Hearing Officer adopts Dr. Hoaglund’s analysis in his report (Student Exhibit 41, pages 41,42) and finds that there is a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement. Under the standards set forth in Cal. Educ. Code section 56337 and Title 5, CCR section 3030(j), STUDENT also qualifies for special education services in the category of specific learning disability.
Issue Number 4: Is the Petitioner entitled to reimbursement of the cost for private assessments?
Petitioner’s parents may obtain an independent educational evaluation (IEE) performed by a qualified expert at the District’s expense if the following requirements are met:
1. The parents disagree with an evaluation obtained by the District;
2. The District is unable to show at a due process hearing that its evaluation was appropriate.
34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b)
STUDENT’s parents disagreed with the District’s evaluation. They proceeded to take STUDENT to a neurologist for an EEG, to Dr. Lynch for a medical diagnosis, and then to Dr. Hoaglund for a neuropsychological assessment. The District failed to demonstrate that its assessment was appropriate. Both of these IEEs identified disabling conditions that were not uncovered in the District assessment.
The Hearing Officer therefore finds that STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for the expense of Dr. Lynch’s assessment and Dr. Hoaglund’s assessment.
Issue Number 5: Is the Petitioner entitled to reimbursement of the cost for tutoring services at the Sylvan Learning Center in Redlands, California, and costs, including tuition, lodging, travel, and meals, for attending the Frostig School, a nonpublic school (NPS), in Pasadena, California?
Because STUDENT is eligible for special education and services, the District is obligated to provide a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) to STUDENT to meet her unique needs under the provisions of the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law. 20 U.S.C. §1400(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. This free appropriate education includes special education and related services that meet the standards of the State educational agency, including appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education provided in conformity with the student’s IEP under 20 U.S.C. section 1401(8). As STUDENT was not identified as a child with special needs and her disabilities were not addressed, the Hearing Officer finds that the District denied a FAPE to STUDENT.
A denial of FAPE by an educational agency entitles the student to “appropriate” relief in light of the purposes IDEA. School Comm. Of the Town of Burlington v.Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 374; 105 S.Ct. 1996 (1985); 20 U.S.C. § 1415. The Burlington principle provides for equitable relief for the denial of appropriate special education services to help overcome lost educational opportunity. This standard does not require, however, day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for time or opportunity lost. Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist., 31 F.2d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994).
Sylvan Expenses
STUDENT’s parents paid for tutoring services at Sylvan for about a nine-month period starting in May 2001. Her grades during this time period, however, did not show any improvement. The evidence indicates that after she was in the Sylvan program, her standardized test scores did improve slightly compared to the previous year (District Exhibit 8).(Footnote 6) There is no clear indication in the record, however, that this minimal improvement to a level still far below her grade level was the result of Sylvan tutoring services. Both FATHER and MOTHER stated that STUDENT did not receive any appreciable benefit from Sylvan.
The invoice from Sylvan for services (Student Exhibit 48)(Footnote 7) reflects an “Assessment Fee” on May 14, 2001. This invoice, along with the testimony of FATHER and MOTHER, indicates that STUDENT was tested by Sylvan at or about this date. MOTHER testified that Sylvan told her that the test results suggested that STUDENT may have a learning disability but that Sylvan did not address disabilities. In fairness to the PARENTS, they were trying all avenues to help STUDENT succeed in school. Nevertheless, they continued with the Sylvan program for three-quarters of a year without progress.
The Sylvan assessment preceded the District assessment by almost one year. The statutory requirement cannot be met for IEE reimbursements, as there was no disagreement with a District assessment. This Sylvan program also did not address STUDENT’s needs. Therefore, these services did not help overcome lost educational opportunity as required for relief under Burlington, supra.
The Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement of the Sylvan expenses for assessment or services.
Frostig School Expenses
STUDENT’s parents unilaterally placed her in the Frostig School in October 2002 after the District did not respond to the definitive findings of Dr. Fox’s EEG and the reports of Dr. Lynch and Dr. Hoaglund. There is no evidence of a reconvened IEP meeting, recommendations for further District assessment, or any communication at all from the District to the PARENTS after the PARENTS told the District of the medical and clinical findings.
The Frostig School is a certified NPS in Pasadena, California, specializing in children with learning disabilities. Frostig School principal Tobey Shaw testified to the program and STUDENT’s progress in it. STUDENT also testified that she wants to complete her high school at Frostig. With the help of assistive technology and accommodations in the program, such as individualized computer programs, scanning pens to place written text on the computer screen in a format that enhances her comprehension, multi-sensory approaches to the material, time accommodations, and individual attention in small classes, STUDENT is making good grades. The record indicates that STUDENT has adjusted to the Frostig School and is doing well. She will graduate this spring. The Hearing Officer finds that the Frostig program has met STUDENT’s needs to work around her seizure condition and her comprehension disabilities and is providing an educational benefit to STUDENT. Her parents are therefore entitled to reimbursement of tuition to the date of this Decision.
The evidence indicates that STUDENT has moved from her relative’s home in Monrovia to an apartment in Pasadena to be near the Frostig School. MOTHER testified that as of the hearing STUDENT had moved and the apartment rents for $1310.00 per month. There is also evidence that this apartment is reasonably necessary for STUDENT to attend a school that is well beyond a reasonable commuting distance from her family home. It is reasonable to rent a unit with sufficient room to allow MOTHER to stay with her disabled daughter and look after STUDENT’s transportation and other non-educational needs. As an equitable adjustment, the Hearing Officer awards as reimbursement for all living expenses while STUDENT was attending the Frostig School the sum of $1310.00 per month commencing February 1, 2003, through the date of this Decision.
STUDENT’s parents are further seeking reimbursement of transportation for travel to and from Pasadena weekly and daily trips of six miles each round trip to the Frostig School. The record does not indicate exactly when the family has made the Redlands to Pasadena trip other than the indication of “every weekend.” As to the daily travel, there is no evidence what the distance is from the family home in Redlands to Redlands East Valley High School or Orangewood High School to establish a benchmark for what the family would have spent in transportation without the Pasadena placement. The Burlington principle allows an equitable adjustment to compensate for lost educational opportunity. This principle requires the Hearing Officer to consider the additional cost of an appropriate placement. However, without sufficient evidence in the record to make this determination, no reimbursement is awarded for travel.
The parents also seek reimbursement of food expenses for eating out, as MOTHER stated that they did not cook at the relative’s home in Monrovia where STUDENT was staying immediately after enrolling at the Frostig School (Student Exhibit 51). As there is no evidence to compare what STUDENT’s food expenses would be at home or how often she ate out in Redlands, there is insufficient evidence to award reimbursement in this category.
Issue Number 6: Is the Petitioner entitled to a private placement at the Frostig School at the District’s expense?
Unilateral placement made by the parents need not meet the exact requirements of the IDEA, such as conformity to the student’s IEP, when the private program meets the student’s needs and provides an educational benefit. Florence County Sch. Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 113; 114 S.C. 361 (1993). In this instance, there is no IEP to consider. As discussed above, the Frostig program has met STUDENT’s unique needs and has provided her an educational benefit.
The District has the obligation to provide a free and appropriate public education to STUDENT. The District may have had resources all along to provide an appropriate placement and services to STUDENT. As there are scarcely two months left in this school year and STUDENT is nearing the end of her high school experience, she should remain at the Frostig School. Moving her at this point would only disrupt her progress and jeopardize her graduation.
The Hearing Officer finds that the Frostig School is the proper placement for STUDENT for the balance of the 2002-2003 school year. The District shall make arrangements with the Frostig School to pay for STUDENT’s tuition from the date of this Decision until the end of this school year. The District shall pay to STUDENT’s parents on a monthly basis STUDENT’s living expenses at the rate of $1310.00 per month pro rated from the date of this Decision through the end of the Frostig School current term.
ORDER
(1) Within twenty calendar days of date of this Decision, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting for the purposes of finding STUDENT eligible for special education in accordance with this Decision and developing a complete IEP for STUDENT placing her at the Frostig School.
(2) The District shall reimburse to Petitioner’s parents the cost of the assessments performed by Dr. Robert duBois Lynch and Dr. Donald Hoaglund as set forth in the invoices in Student Exhibits 47 and 41, or $1,138.00 and $4,235.00, respectively.
(3) The District shall reimburse to the Petitioner’s parents the amounts shown on Frostig School statement as set forth in Student Exhibit 53 for tuition and related services for STUDENT for the time period from October 1, 2002 through the date of this Decision. The District shall contact the Frostig School for verification and updating of the tuition expenses through the date of this Decision. The District shall further reimburse to the Petitioner’s parents the sum of $1305 per month for all living expenses commencing February 1, 2003, prorated through the date of this Decision.
(4) For the balance of the 2002-2003 school year the Petitioner shall be placed in the Frostig School. The District shall pay directly to the Frostig School STUDENT’s tuition from the date of this Decision through the end of this school year. On a monthly basis the District shall further pay to Petitioner’s parents the Petitioner’s living expenses from the date of this Decision prorated through the end of the current Frostig School term at the same rate of $1305 per month as they were reimbursed as set forth in paragraph (3), above.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code §56507(d), the hearing Decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
(1) Did the District fulfill its responsibilities to identify Petitioner as a child with a disability? - The Petitioner prevailed on the first issue.
(2) Did the District conduct appropriate assessments and assess the Petitioner in all areas of suspected disability? - The Petitioner prevailed on the second issue.
(3) Was the Petitioner eligible for special education and related services as an individual with special needs as other health impaired or having a specific learning disability while enrolled in the District? - The Petitioner prevailed on the third issue.
(4) Is the Petitioner entitled to reimbursement of the cost for private assessments by Dr. Robert duBois Lynch and Dr. Donald D. Hoaglund? - The Petitioner prevailed on the fourth issue.
(5) Is the Petitioner entitled to reimbursement of the cost for tutoring services at the Sylvan Learning Center in Redlands, California, and costs, including tuition, lodging, travel, and meals, for attending the Frostig School, a nonpublic school (NPS), in Pasadena, California? - The District prevailed in part and the Petitioner prevailed in part. The Petitioner, however, substantially prevailed on the fifth issue.
(6) Is the Petitioner entitled to a private placement at the Frostig School at the District’s expense? - The Petitioner prevailed on the sixth issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
DATED: April 11, 2003 ___________________________ Tracy L. Tibbals, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The wording of the issues here differs somewhat from the statements of issues filed by the parties before the hearing and described in their closing briefs. Changes in the language and in the order the issues were presented were made for clarity and to facilitate analysis in this Decision. No changes in substance have been made. 2. MOTHER stated that she at first tried to get STUDENT credit for the work done at Sylvan. She indicates that the District said that Sylvan was not recognized by the District. On that basis, MOTHER said that she thought the Sylvan tests results would not be accepted by the District. 3. The evidence shows that District psychologist Ronald Sewell is experienced and qualified to perform assessments for special education screening. He is fully credentialed and has served as a school psychologist for many years. He is close to earning his doctorate degree from the University of California, Riverside. 4. MOTHER testified that she mentioned the fainting episode to Mr. Sewell and that STUDENT’s older brother and grandmother had a history of seizures. 5. A medical assessment is particularly important where, as here, STUDENT’s lack of attention was attributed by the school personnel to daydreaming and not paying attention when in fact she was having seizures. Identifying the fact that she is having seizures is critical to appropriate programming and intervention for this student. 6. Her SAT-9 score for reading comprehension in May 2002 compared to that of the prior year increased from the sixth percentile to the twelfth percentile, or up slightly more than one year in grade equivalent from 4.8 to 6.1. 7. Student Exhibit 48 also appears to include Sylvan charges not attributable to services provided to STUDENT. Entries also show services to BROTHER, STUDENT’s older brother.
