California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 16, 2003

Student v. Fresno Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 2700-02, SN02-02700 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote

Fresno Unified must treat a fourth grader as eligible for special education as emotionally disturbed and hold an IEP meeting within 15 days.

Split decision: student prevailed on 2 of 3 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

Student's earlier hearing request (SN02-02473) was withdrawn on December 3, 2002, after a continuance was denied. The present request was filed the next day.

Summary

A fourth grader with ADHD filed for hearing after Fresno Unified twice found him ineligible for special education. He had a Section 504 plan, a classroom aide and many suspensions. Because the District had recommended expulsion, the case was heard on an expedited basis. The District argued that his behavior was learned and oppositional, a sign of social maladjustment rather than emotional disturbance.

The Hearing Officer found he did not meet the emotional disturbance criterion for inability to build relationships. His teacher, Rebecca Moler, and principal, Mike Jones, had seen him make friends, and he got along with his teacher. He did meet the criterion for inappropriate behavior or feelings under normal circumstances. The Hearing Officer credited his county mental health therapists, who had seen him weekly for a year and a half. District witnesses had not worked with him recently, and the District's outside expert had never met him. Social maladjustment does not bar eligibility when an emotional disturbance is also present, and the behavior does not need to be bizarre or withdrawn. His problems were marked and long-standing. They lowered his grades, cost him school time and required more than changes to regular education. Other health impairment was not decided. Because the District offered no IEP, it denied a FAPE. The Hearing Officer ordered an IEP meeting within 15 days, with his mental health providers invited, and an offer of services and placement.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled a district's argument that oppositional or socially maladjusted behavior rules out emotional disturbance eligibility. The Hearing Officer looked for an emotional basis under the federal definition. She gave more weight to providers who saw the student often and recently than to reviewers who had never met him.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1a. As of October 1, 2002, did Student meet eligibility criteria for special education as emotionally disturbed (ED)?

    Student met ED criteria for inappropriate behavior or feelings under normal circumstances, to a marked degree and over a long period of time. This adversely affected his education, and he needed more than changes to regular education. He did not meet the criterion for inability to build relationships. Social maladjustment does not bar eligibility when an emotional disturbance is also present.

  2. Not reachedEligibility

    Issue 1b. As of October 1, 2002, did Student meet eligibility criteria for special education as other health impaired (OHI)?

    Not decided because Student was found eligible as ED. The District must meet all of his disability-related needs through the IEP.

  3. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2. If Student was eligible for special education as of October 1, 2002, has Fresno Unified School District offered him a free appropriate public education (FAPE)?

    Student was eligible but had no IEP and had been offered no special education services, so the District did not offer a FAPE.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, the District must convene an IEP team to develop an IEP and offer Student a FAPE, including special education services and placement.
  • The District must invite Student's current mental health providers to take part in the IEP meeting.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Larry P. v. Riles; 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4)(ii); Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(i); 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(8); Cal. Educ. Code § 56026

People named in the decision

  • Mark Allen, interim SELPA director, Fresno Unified School District
  • Laura DeBenedetto, ALBA program teacher; witness for Student, Fresno Unified School District
  • Lisa (Alissa) Vasquez, school psychologist (2000 assessment), Fresno Unified School District
  • S. Goertzen, speech and language therapist, Fresno Unified School District
  • E. Johnson, special education teacher, Fresno Unified School District
  • E. Callahan, school nurse, Fresno Unified School District
  • V. Westburg, principal, Fresno Unified School District
  • David Hellwig, Ph.D., individual therapist; witness for Student, Children's Community Mental Health Services of Fresno County
  • Paul Phipps, marriage and family therapist, social skills group leader; witness for Student, Children's Community Mental Health Services of Fresno County
  • Stephen Fretz, LCSW, clinical supervisor, Children's Community Mental Health Services of Fresno County
  • Edgar Castillo, M.D., chief psychiatrist, Children's Community Mental Health Services of Fresno County
  • John Goodfellow, registered occupational therapist in private practice; OT assessor for District
  • Howard J. Glidden, Ph.D., developmental neuropsychologist in private practice; assessor for District
  • Sharon Walker, third-grade teacher, Fresno Unified School District
  • Rebecca Moler, fourth-grade teacher, Lincoln Elementary School, Fresno Unified School District
  • Mike Jones, principal, Lincoln Elementary School, Fresno Unified School District
  • Gerald Christensen, school psychologist, Fresno Unified School District
  • Richard Morriss, Ph.D., school psychologist; outside expert witness for District, Monterey Peninsula school district; Village Press Publications
  • Eulalio Castellanos, Student's prior counsel in SN02-02473
  • Janet Sconiers, advocate for Student in prior case SN02-02473
  • Children's Community Mental Health Services of Fresno County, mental health agency providing therapy

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Fresno, California, on December 19 and 20, 2002.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Dale Mentink of Protection and Advocacy, Inc. Also present on behalf of STUDENT was his mother. Respondent Fresno Unified School District was represented by attorney Christopher Fernandes from the law firm of Lozano Smith. Also present on behalf of the District was Mark Allen, interim SELPA director.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

(1) As of October 1, 2002, did Petitioner STUDENT meet eligibility criteria for special education as (a) emotionally disturbed (ED) and/or (b) other health impaired (OHI)?

(2) If STUDENT was eligible for special education as of October 1, 2002, has Respondent Fresno Unified School District offered him a free appropriate public education (FAPE)?

BACKGROUND FACTS

Petitioner STUDENT will turn ten years old in March of 2003. He is in the fourth grade and attends Lincoln Elementary School in the Fresno Unified School District. STUDENT has a history of behavioral difficulties resulting in multiple suspensions from school. He has been diagnosed with attention deficit/hyperactivity (ADHD) and oppositional defiant disorders (ODD). STUDENT has never been determined eligible for special education. However, he currently has a Section 504 Accommodation Plan to address behavioral difficulties. The District provides a classroom aide to monitor STUDENT’s behavior. STUDENT receives weekly individual and group therapy from Children’s Community Mental Health Services of Fresno County.(Footnote 1)

During the 1998-1999 school year, STUDENT attended kindergarten at Kirk Elementary School in the District on an interdistrict transfer from the West Fresno School District. In the fall of 1999, STUDENT began the first grade at Lincoln Elementary School. Following many behavioral incidents, STUDENT was placed for the second semester of his first grade year in the District’s Alternative Learning and Behavior Adjustment (ALBA) program. STUDENT’s teacher in the ALBA program was Laura DeBenedetto.

STUDENT returned to the ALBA program for the second grade. The ALBA program relocated to Konkel School for the 2000-2001 school year. STUDENT continued to have behavioral problems while in the ALBA program. A behavioral plan dated September 30, 2000, describes STUDENT’s behavior as follows: “STUDENT runs from class, refuses to follow directions of staff, yells profanities and demands one on one supervision when he is throwing a tantrum.” The plan called for STUDENT’s receiving points and tickets with which he could purchase rewards for good behavior. A quiet place was made available for him to regain control over his behavior.

In October 2000, MOTHER requested that the District assess STUDENT for special education. A multidisciplinary team consisting of school psychologist Lisa Vasquez, speech and language therapist S. Goertzen, special education teacher E. Johnson, regular classroom teacher Ms. DeBenedetto, nurse E. Callahan, and principal V. Westburg undertook the assessment of STUDENT in December 2000. The following assessments were administered to STUDENT: Test of Auditory-Perceptual Skills-Revised (TAPS-R), Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration (VMI), Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales, Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT), Test of Visual Perceptual Skills-Revised (TVPS-R), Connors’ Teacher Rating Scale-Revised, and Behavior Assessment Scale for Children (BASC).(Footnote 2) The assessment also included observations of STUDENT at school and a review of his educational records. The assessors concluded that STUDENT had average ability and was functioning within the expected range as measured by academic, speech and language assessments. The report of the assessment, dated December 11, 2000, indicates that the assessment team concluded that STUDENT did not meet special education eligibility criteria because of a specific learning disability, emotional disturbance, or other health impairment.

The IEP team met on December 11, 2000, to discuss the assessment. The team reached consensus that STUDENT was not eligible for special education and agreed to develop 504 and positive intervention plans to address STUDENT’s ADHD and behavioral problems. A 504 plan was put in place following the meeting. Although STUDENT’s teacher and social worker identified concerns regarding STUDENT’s emotional status, the team also agreed to consider returning STUDENT to a comprehensive elementary school. Ms. DeBenedetto reported alarming conversations with STUDENT regarding his fascination with dead people and his deriving pleasure from his pit bulls hurting someone. She also reported that STUDENT told her he would laugh if someone he loves died. The social worker noted that STUDENT may require placement in a mental health facility. STUDENT was suspended for at least 10 days during the 2000-2001 school year for causing injury to another person, engaging in an obscene act, using profanity, and being defiant.

During 2001, MOTHER again expressed concern to the District regarding the difficulty she was having managing STUDENT’s behavior. The District referred her to an agency for students who are suicidal or who have severe emotional problems, which then referred her to Community Mental Health Services. In August 2001, STUDENT began receiving services from Mental Health. David Hellwig, Ph.D., provides weekly individual therapy in sessions of approximately one hour each. Paul Phipps, marriage and family therapist (MFT), leads a weekly small social skills group in which STUDENT participates.

STUDENT returned to Lincoln Elementary School for the third grade in the fall of 2001. A behavioral plan was revised several times during the school year with the goal of improving STUDENT’s inappropriate school behavior, which included his being out of his seat, roaming around the classroom, engaging in angry outbursts, being aggressive, and using profanity. During the school year, STUDENT continued to be suspended many times for behaviors similar to those resulting in suspension during the prior school year. MOTHER also testified to being asked to pick up STUDENT from school before the end of the school day on multiple occasions. STUDENT’s report card for the third grade reflects below-expected achievement. STUDENT received grades of D, D-, D+, and C in reading, D, D, B-, and D- in mathematics, B-, D-, D-, and F in social science, and F, D-, C+, and D in science.

In July 2002, the District agreed to conduct a second assessment to determine whether STUDENT met special education eligibility.(Footnote 3) As part of the assessment, on August 10 and 12, 2002, John Goodfellow, a registered occupational therapist (OTR) in private practice, conducted an occupational therapy (OT) assessment of STUDENT at the request of the District. Mr. Goodfellow’s assessment consisted of clinical observations and administration of standardized tests. The assessment revealed that STUDENT had strengths in visual processing, body awareness, gross-motor skills, and manual dexterity. Areas of concern included auditory distractibility, tactile processing, self-regulation, and motor control and accuracy. Mr. Goodfellow also noted that STUDENT seeks movement, especially while seated, and requires extra time to complete tasks, especially tasks involving writing. Mr. Goodfellow recommended accommodations at school for STUDENT related to timed tests and homework. He also suggested that STUDENT be exposed to the computer and typing skills and that his teacher should be aware of his auditory distractibility and cue him as needed to return to task. Mr. Goodfellow recommended that STUDENT receive OT services at school consisting of at least 18 consultations or direct visits in 30-minute sessions to evaluate the ergonomics of STUDENT’s desk and the benefits of a disc-o-sit at the desk, to consult with STUDENT and his teacher regarding strategies to regulate behavior, and to work on writing skills and copying from the board.

In September 2002, Howard J. Glidden, Ph.D., a developmental neuropsychologist in private practice, assessed STUDENT on behalf of the District. Dr. Glidden administered the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-III (WISC-III), WIAT, Knox’s Cube Test, Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration (Fourth Revision), Tests of Apraxia, Motor-Free Visual Perception Test-Revised, Auditory Discrimination Test, Test of Auditory Analysis Skills, Sentence Memory Test, Cancellation of Rapidly Recurring Figures Test, Burks’ Behavior Rating Scale, and Conners’ Behavioral Rating Scale. Dr. Glidden also reviewed educational records, obtained information from STUDENT’s prior teacher, Sharon Walker, and interviewed MOTHER. Dr. Glidden diagnosed STUDENT with ADHD and stated that ODD should be ruled out. Dr. Glidden’s report includes many suggestions for dealing with STUDENT’s behavior resulting from his ADHD but does not offer any opinion regarding STUDENT’s eligibility for special education.

STUDENT entered the fourth grade in the fall of 2002. His teacher is Rebecca Moler. STUDENT has continued to have behavioral problems at school for which he has been suspended. During the first two weeks of October, STUDENT was suspended for four separate incidents for a total of nine and one-half days. On October 1, 2002, STUDENT engaged in a pushing incident on the playground with another student. He was suspended for one day. On October 3, 2002, STUDENT threatened another student, used profanity, and was defiant towards his teacher, resulting in a one-half day suspension. On October 7, 2002, STUDENT was suspended for three days for refusing to leave the class when asked, walking off campus, and using profanity with the principal. When STUDENT returned to school on October 11, 2002, from his suspension, he threatened two female students in his class, left class without permission, and used profane language. As a result, STUDENT was suspended for five days and expulsion has been recommended.

On October 17, 2002, District psychologist Gerald Christensen reviewed STUDENT’s educational records and recent assessments. Mr. Christensen completed a report analyzing whether the information led to STUDENT’s being eligible for special education because of a specific learning disability (SLD), emotional disturbance (ED), or other health impairment (OHI).(Footnote 4) Mr. Christensen concluded that STUDENT did not qualify for special education and offered his opinion that STUDENT meets DSM IV criteria for the diagnosis of conduct and oppositional defiant disorders.

The IEP team met on October 17, 2002, to discuss the results of the assessments and to determine STUDENT’s eligibility for special education. District members of the IEP team concluded that STUDENT did not meet special education criteria of SLD, ED, or OHI. A 504 manifestation determination meeting followed the IEP meeting. The District members of the 504 team concluded that STUDENT’s recent behavior for which he was suspended was not a direct manifestation of his identified disability, ADHD, and was not a result of inappropriate accommodations or modifications. STUDENT’s Section 504 Accommodation Plan dated October 17, 2002, was drafted to address certain inappropriate behaviors including inattention, impulsivity, fighting, and use of profanity. Concerns regarding STUDENT’s failing to turn in homework were also noted. The 504 Plan lists 17 accommodations and includes a behavioral plan with the goal of STUDENT’s remaining calm and maintaining his behavior within acceptable limits when he is frustrated or angry. Neither the IEP nor 504 documents are signed by MOTHER.

On November 8, 2002, a due process hearing was requested on behalf of STUDENT by his prior counsel, Eulalio Castellanos (SN02-02473). When the hearing convened on November 25, 2002, Mr. Castellanos withdrew as legal counsel. The hearing was continued to December 3, 2002. STUDENT’s mother and advocate Janet Sconiers appeared on behalf of STUDENT when the hearing reconvened on December 3, 2002. The hearing officer who convened the hearing on that date denied their request to further continue the hearing. Petitioner’s case SN02-02473 was then withdrawn. On the following day, December 4, 2002, the Hearing Office received Petitioner’s second request for a due process hearing (SN02-02700). The matter proceeded to hearing on December 19 and 20, 2002.(Footnote 5) STUDENT’s grades for the first quarter of the 2002-2003 school year were C in mathematics, C- in spelling, D in written language and science, D- in reading, and F in social studies. STUDENT received N (Needs improvement) in four of seven areas related to work habits and all Ns related to social skills.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: As of October 1, 2002, has Petitioner STUDENT met eligibility criteria for special education as (a) emotionally disturbed (ED) and/or (b) health impaired (OHI)?

Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and state special education law, a student with a disability meets eligibility criteria for special education services by satisfying the following: (1) a student must have a disability as defined by federal law, (2) because of the disability, the student must require instruction, services, or both which cannot be met by modification of the regular school program. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A) Cal. Educ. Code § 56026. Petitioner alleges he meets special education eligibility as emotionally disturbed and other health impaired, both of which are included in the federal definition of a disability.

(a) Does STUDENT meet eligibility criteria for special education as emotionally disturbed?

Petitioner alleges that the District should have determined that he met special education eligibility as emotionally disturbed (ED) pursuant to the second and third criteria set forth in Title 5, California Code of Regulations section 3030(i). The second criterion states that a student qualifies as ED when he/she exhibits an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers over a long period of time and to a marked degree, which adversely affect his educational performance. A student qualifies as ED under the third criterion when he/she exhibits inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances in several situations over a long period of time and to a marked degree, which adversely affect his educational performance. The District contends that STUDENT does not meet special education eligibility criteria as ED. The specific contentions of the parties related to each of the criteria are set forth below.

(1) Does STUDENT exhibit an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers?

Petitioner asserts that his relationships with peers and teachers are both troubled and short-lived. The District asserts that STUDENT is able to make friends and has good relationships with both his current teacher and principal.

STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, and his mental health therapists, Dr. Hellwig and Mr. Phipps, testified that STUDENT meets the above criterion. MOTHER testified that STUDENT’s involvement with other children in the neighborhood is short-lived because their interactions quickly become contentious. As an example, MOTHER related that when she put a basketball standard in front of her house, the neighborhood children initially came to play basketball with STUDENT. However, after a short period of time, the children did not want to play with STUDENT because he was not able to get along with them. MOTHER testified that no one calls or visits STUDENT. She further testified that STUDENT has difficulty getting along with cousins and with peers at church.

Dr. Hellwig testified that STUDENT does not have friends. Dr. Hellwig reached this conclusion because of conversations with STUDENT during therapy, discussions with MOTHER, feedback from Mr. Phipps, and information contained in Dr. Glidden’s assessment of STUDENT. Dr. Hellwig testified that although STUDENT claims to have a set of friends, he does not talk about any of the friends during therapy. Dr. Hellwig pointed to the following comments by one of STUDENT’s teachers, which are contained in Dr. Hellwig’s report: “In the classroom, various behavior problems include: Excessive aggressiveness to peers and defiance. Serious behavior problems include . . . not making friends.” Dr. Glidden also commented that “peer relationships are viewed as short-lived and conflictual in nature.” Petitioner’s Exhibit 8, pages 3 and 4.

Mr. Phipps testified that STUDENT was referred to his group therapy to learn to deal with peers and adults in an appropriate manner. He stated that STUDENT participates in the group but that his participation is facilitated by adults.

STUDENT’s current teacher, Rebecca Moler, and Lincoln principal, Mike Jones, testified that STUDENT has formed friendships at school. Ms. Moler testified that she has observed STUDENT playing with four particular students at school. Mr. Jones described an emerging friendship with a boy in his class who shares STUDENT’s interest in sports. According to Mr. Jones, when STUDENT returned to school the boys had an initial verbal exchange, then spent some time with Mr. Jones in his office, and now have been observed playing soccer and sitting together at lunch. Both Ms. Moler and Mr. Jones testified regarding a former Lincoln student’s recent visit to Lincoln for the express purpose of visiting STUDENT. Both observed their relationship to be one of friends.

Gerald Christensen, school psychologist, reviewed recent assessments of STUDENT and compiled a report analyzing STUDENT’s eligibility for special education. Mr. Christensen testified that STUDENT is able to interact appropriately with peers and teachers when he chooses to do so.

Alissa Vasquez, District school psychologist, assessed STUDENT when he was in the third grade. Ms. Vasquez testified that STUDENT was then able to make friends. In support of her conclusion, Ms. Vasquez testified that MOTHER’s responses on the socialization subdomains of the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales placed STUDENT’s social skills in the adequate range. His standard score was 100.(Footnote 6) (Petitioner’s Exhibit 6.)

District witnesses do not dispute that at times STUDENT has difficulty getting along with peers and behaves defiantly toward adults in authority. However, the Hearing Officer finds that the testimony of the District’s witnesses, in particular, Ms. Moler and Ms. Jones, establishes that STUDENT has friendships at school. Both Ms. Moler and Ms. Jones have observed STUDENT at school during the current school year, whereas neither Dr. Hellwig nor Mr. Phipps has. Dr. Hellwig and Mr. Phipps also have not spoken with anyone from STUDENT’s school regarding whether he has friends at school. Dr. Hellwig’s expressed belief that STUDENT does not have friends was contradicted by some of his own testimony. In particular, Dr. Hellwig stated that STUDENT has told him that he has friends and that he likes his teacher. Moreover, the fact that STUDENT does not talk about them during therapy does not undermine his assertion to Dr. Hellwig. Additionally, Ms. Moler and STUDENT concur that they have a good relationship despite STUDENT’s having some behavioral difficulties in class. Dr. Hellwig and Mr. Phipps work with STUDENT in a clinical setting, which perhaps should not be categorized as a “normal relationship.” However, both Dr. Hellwig and Mr. Phipps testified that they have established appropriate therapeutic relationships with STUDENT.

As to comments in Dr. Glidden’s assessment regarding STUDENT’s difficulty making friends, it should be noted that Dr. Glidden’s assessment was completed at the beginning of the school year, whereas Ms. Moler and Mr. Jones testified regarding their observations of STUDENT at school during the three months following Dr. Glidden’s assessment. The testimony of Laura DeBenedetto, one of STUDENT’s teachers in the ALBA program during the 2000-2001 school year who was called to testify on behalf of STUDENT, also is not persuasive as to STUDENT’s present ability to build relationships. Ms. DeBenedetto could not recall STUDENT’s having friends in her class. However, the fact that STUDENT may not have had friends in her class during the 2000-2001 school year is not determinative of his ability to establish friendships two school years later. Additionally, Ms. DeBenedetto testified that STUDENT worked most of the day individually with his aide so she had limited opportunities to view STUDENT’s interactions with other students.

In summary, for STUDENT to meet the above criterion, he must have an inability to build or maintain relationships with peers and teachers. This is a high standard to meet as it requires STUDENT’s difficulties with relationships to be both with peers and teachers. While the facts present a close call, because the evidence establishes that STUDENT has a satisfactory relationship with Ms. Moler and has been observed to build relationships with several peers during the current school year, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT does not meet ED eligibility under this criterion.

(2) Does STUDENT exhibit inappropriate types of feelings or behavior under normal circumstances?

Petitioner asserts that he exhibits inappropriate types of feelings and behavior under normal circumstances. MOTHER and STUDENT’s Mental Health therapists testified that STUDENT exhibits inappropriate types of behavior and feelings under normal circumstances. Their testimony was supported by Ms. DeBenedetto.

As to inappropriate feelings under normal circumstances, several of Petitioner’s witnesses testified that STUDENT has an abnormal interest in death. MOTHER testified that STUDENT has recently been accessing websites of dead people. Although he primarily has shown interest in Aliyah and Tupac Shakur, entertainers who met untimely deaths, MOTHER testified that it is their morgue photographs that are of interest to STUDENT. MOTHER stated that STUDENT has downloaded these photos to hang on his bedroom walls. MOTHER testified that STUDENT once told her to hit a dog in the road rather swerve the car to avoid the dog. Dr. Hellwig testified that STUDENT has told him he wishes someone would kill him or that he wishes he were dead.

Through her testimony, Ms. DeBenedetto confirmed her concerns regarding STUDENT, which she had memorialized in a letter dated September 29, 2000. Ms. DeBenedetto listed multiple behaviors that she believed were dangerous to STUDENT or other students. Ms. DeBenedetto also observed a pattern of defiant and disrespectful behavior. However, Ms. DeBenedetto stated that what disturbed her most were things that STUDENT told her. Ms. DeBenedetto stated “once he laughed as he told me that he wanted to draw a picture of him putting nails in dead people. He visibly enjoyed telling me about his pet pit bulls and how they hurt people. He said he would laugh if someone he loves dies.” In Ms. DeBenedetto’s opinion, STUDENT’s emotional responses were alarmingly inappropriate. Ms. DeBenedetto stated that none of the recent assessors obtained information from her regarding STUDENT.

STUDENT’s therapists testified that STUDENT also exhibits inappropriate types of behavior under normal circumstances. Dr. Hellwig and Mr. Phipps testified that STUDENT is oversensitive to being evaluated or criticized by others, whether the criticism is real or perceived. Mr. Phipps testified that seemingly “out of the blue,” STUDENT will have an outburst that is out of proportion to anything that has occurred. For example, Mr. Phipps testified that during a group session, STUDENT had an angry outburst in response to a seemingly benign discussion related to what the participants had done over the prior weekend.

Dr. Hellwig and Mr. Phipps opined that STUDENT’s behavior emanates from an underlying and profound sense of shame. They testified that STUDENT believes his “core” is a failure and that he is unacceptable. Dr. Hellwig also stated that STUDENT “labels himself as bad.” As an example, Dr. Hellwig related that STUDENT believed the reason for his father’s failure to come to his football practice after saying that he would was that there is something wrong with him. Another example of STUDENT’s belief that he is unacceptable occurred in response to his mother’s speaking with a new neighbor regarding STUDENT’s taking medication for attentional problems. STUDENT had an outburst and stated that he “just wished someone would kill him.” Dr. Hellwig testified that when STUDENT’s sense of shame is triggered, he acts out to protect himself. Dr. Hellwig testified that STUDENT is more vulnerable in a group, for example, at school, because he is dealing with multiple people.

The opinions of Dr. Hellwig and Mr. Phipps are memorialized in a letter to the District dated October 30, 2002. The letter is also signed by Stephen Fretz, LCSW, clinical supervisor, and Edgar Castillo, M.D., chief psychiatrist of Children’s Community Mental Health. The letter reads in pertinent part that “it is also our impression that he does have underlying emotional issues, which seem to interfere at school, resulting in multiple suspensions. We do believe that these issues fall under . . . ‘inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances. . . .’” Petitioner’s Exhibit 1, page 1.

The District asserts that STUDENT’s behavior at school, including aggression, defiance, and use of profanity, are learned behaviors that are supported by an environment embracing and rewarding such behavior. The District also asserts that STUDENT is socially maladjusted, which excludes him from special education eligibility. All of the District’s witnesses testified that STUDENT does not meet special education criteria as ED. Mr. Jones and Ms. Moler testified that STUDENT can go through periods when he does not lose his temper. They described STUDENT as “very pleasant” at times when he is not being disciplined or questioned about his behavior. In support of the District’s position that STUDENT’s behavior is learned, Ms. Moler testified that on one occasion MOTHER came to school and cursed at her in front of STUDENT and other students.

Mr. Christensen, who reviewed Dr. Glidden’s assessment and analyzed STUDENT’s eligibility for special education, testified that STUDENT exhibits socially maladjusted behavior and is not ED. Mr. Christiansen testified that there are several aspects of STUDENT’s behavior that distinguish him from a student who is ED. First, there is a consistent trigger for STUDENT’s behavior. STUDENT wants to maintain control and, if he cannot, he acts out. Second, Mr. Christensen testified that most students identified as ED are likely to engage in excessive crying or withdrawal behavior. Finally, Mr. Christensen testified that STUDENT’s defiant and aggressive behavior and use of profanity are learned in an environment where those behaviors are “shared and rewarded.”

Ms. Vasquez, who assessed STUDENT in 2000, also testified that STUDENT’s behaviors are related to social maladjustment and oppositional defiant behavior. Ms. Vasquez reviewed Dr. Glidden’s assessment conducted in 2002 and testified that his findings are consistent with her conclusions. She testified that aggressive, destructive, and disrespectful behavior are learned and should be treated with parent training and implementation of a behavioral management system. Ms. Vasquez testified that she concluded STUDENT’s behaviors are learned because STUDENT externalizes rather than internalizes his emotions.The District called Richard Morriss, Ph.D., as an outside expert witness. Dr. Morriss has been employed as a school psychologist for 38 years by the Monterrey Peninsula School District. Dr. Morriss reviewed assessments undertaken by Dr. Glidden, Mr. Christiansen, and Ms. Vasquez. Dr. Morriss concluded that STUDENT does not met ED criteria. Dr. Glidden testified that to meet the criterion related to inappropriate behavior, the student must exhibit bizarre, hallucinatory, delusional, or paranoid behavior, have crying or laughing jags, or experience severe mood swings. Dr. Morriss testified that STUDENT does not exhibit any of these behaviors. He also concluded that STUDENT’s behavior is not evidence of an emotional disturbance because it is consistently triggered by the same antecedents. Dr. Morriss testified that the diagnosis of ODD has clearly been established by STUDENT’s learned maladaptive behavior. Dr. Morriss testified that ODD “is excluded from special education criteria.” Dr. Morriss further testified that the District has an obligation to not place ODD students in special education. Dr. Morriss testified that shame is a normal emotion and does not rise to the level of an emotional disturbance.

The District’s witnesses were uniform in their opinion that STUDENT is not ED. However, their testimony and results of assessments support finding that STUDENT does meet ED criteria. As to STUDENT’s disproportionate sensitivity and outbursts, STUDENT’s teacher, Ms. Moler, related several recent incidents that support the testimony of STUDENT’s therapists regarding STUDENT’s overreaction to normal activities. Ms. Moler testified that STUDENT had an outburst when he saw her speaking with Mr. Jones and mistakenly assumed that they were talking about him. STUDENT also has become upset after mistakenly assuming that conversations between Ms. Moler and another student were regarding STUDENT. Ms. Moler testified that STUDENT’s last suspension began when he learned that two female students in his group had caused the group to lose several points. The classroom groups were engaged in a competition with the group earning the most points winning the competition. Ms. Moler stated that she tried to reassure STUDENT that the group already had earned sufficient points to win and that the loss of points would not result in any change to the outcome. Rather than listen to Ms. Moler, STUDENT called the students names, left, the class and the campus, and was described by Mr. Jones as being “out-of-control.” Mr. Jones testified that STUDENT is “impossible to talk to while in one of his moods.”

Dr. Glidden performed the most recent comprehensive assessment of STUDENT. He did not testify. The DSM IV diagnosis Dr. Glidden gave to STUDENT is limited to ADHD. However, some of Dr. Glidden’s findings corroborate the testimony of Dr. Hellwig and Mr. Phipps regarding STUDENT’s core sense of shame. As reported by Dr. Glidden, the results of the Burks’ Behavior Rating Scale using STUDENT’s mother and Ms. Walker, as informants, revealed similar areas of concern. They both identified significant elevations on subtests reflecting excessive sense of persecution, poor sense of identity, and poor ego strength.(Footnote 7) Petitioner’s Exhibit 8, page 13; Petitioner’s Exhibit 18.

STUDENT’s teacher in the third grade, Sharon Walker, ranked STUDENT’s over sensitivity to criticism as a “serious problem.” Petitioner’s Exhibit 19, page 4. She also described him as “likeable until he loses control. . . .” Petitioner’s Exhibit 19, page 5. STUDENT’s social worker from the ALBA program wrote the following:

STUDENT appears to have severe emotional and behavioral problems coping with his low self-esteem. . . . Considering all the variable multiple behavior problems, this student may not be suitable for any school at this time and may require additional structure in a clinical mental health setting.

Petitioner’s Exhibit 9, page 5.

Finally, Ms. Vasquez wrote in her report of December 2000 that “[STUDENT’s] high scores in the area of Emotional lability indicated STUDENT is prone more to emotional response than are normal such as crying or anger.” Petitioner’s Exhibit 6, page 7.

As to the District’s assertion that STUDENT’s inappropriate behavior is learned rather than the result of emotional problems, the District’s witnesses had very little, if any, information regarding STUDENT’s family life and none had visited his home. The only testimony in support of this assertion was that STUDENT’s mother had used inappropriate language at school on one occasion when she was upset. MOTHER testified that none of her other children, including STUDENT’s twin, experience the same behavioral problems STUDENT does.

The District’s assertion that STUDENT’s behavior must either be bizarre (or withdrawn) to meet the ED criteria also fails. First, neither federal nor State special education law imposes this requirement. Second, there was credible testimony regarding STUDENT’s unusual interest, feelings, and conversations related to death and dying. STUDENT is in the fourth grade, and no one refuted testimony that STUDENT’s serious interest in death and his expressed desire that someone kill him constitute aberrant behavior and feelings for a fourth-grade student.

In summary, the testimony of STUDENT’s mental health therapists that STUDENT exhibits inappropriate feelings and behavior under normal circumstances was persuasive and is supported by the testimony and written documentation discussed above. Petitioner’s witnesses also testified persuasively that STUDENT has an underlying emotional basis for both his inappropriate feelings and behavior. The Hearing Officer finds persuasive the testimony of Dr. Hellwig and Mr. Phipps. Both have provided STUDENT’s therapy consistently for the last year and one-half. They have gleaned information from weekly sessions with STUDENT over that entire period of time. Both formerly were employed by the District in a program for students with emotional disturbances and are familiar with students meeting ED criteria.

On the other hand, Ms. Vasquez assessed STUDENT two years ago and last saw him in the spring of 2001. Thus, while her assessment provides information as to STUDENT’s status at that time, Dr. Hellwig and Mr. Phipps have more contemporary information regarding STUDENT’s emotional status. Mr. Christiansen reviewed recent assessments but has not worked with STUDENT this school year. Mr. Christiansen has not assessed STUDENT. Dr. Morriss has extensive experience as a school psychologist. However, the Hearing Officer does not find Dr. Morriss’s testimony persuasive. Dr. Morriss has never met STUDENT. Additionally, Dr. Morriss relied heavily on his expressed bias that children with ODD rarely, if ever, are eligible for special education, apparently irrespective of any other qualifying diagnosis. His testimony was based less on information regarding STUDENT, special education definitions, or research-supported studies than on his self-published editorial articles. See Respondent’s Exhibit 12.(Footnote 8)

Regarding the District’s assertion that STUDENT is precluded from special education eligibility for special education as ED because he has an ODD or is socially maladjusted, the federal definition of ED does not exclude a student who is socially maladjusted as eligible for special education if the student is determined also to have an emotional disturbance. 34 C.F.R. § 300.7 (c)(4)(ii). Thus, STUDENT is not excluded from meeting ED criteria.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT meets ED criteria because of inappropriate feelings and behavior under normal circumstances. To be eligible for special education, STUDENT must also exhibit the ED characteristics to a marked degree and for a long period of time, his education must be negatively affected, and he must require instruction or services that cannot be met with modification to the regular education program.

Has STUDENT exhibited ED characteristics to a marked degree and for a long period of time?

MOTHER and Dr. Hellwig testified regarding the extent of STUDENT’s emotional difficulties. Dr. Hellwig stated that STUDENT’s difficulties affect his interpersonal relationships at home and with his extended family. Dr. Hellwig testified that he suggested MOTHER arrange for STUDENT to spend time in activities with his cousins. These get-togethers proved to be difficult as STUDENT could not get along with the others. MOTHER testified that STUDENT’s emotional and behavioral problems have affected the home. The family split up and STUDENT constantly is in turmoil with his siblings. MOTHER testified that STUDENT’s behavior affects him in the community. She testified that STUDENT’s participation in various community activities including PAL football as “short-lived” because of STUDENT’s outbursts and inability to control himself or get along with peers and leaders. MOTHER testified that she has been told by her church that she must be with STUDENT at all times or he cannot attend. Additionally, as discussed above, STUDENT has exhibited difficulties at school that have resulted in his being placed in a special program, ALBA, and in his being suspended multiple times. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT exhibits ED characteristics to a marked degree.

Special education law does not specify the period of time that constitutes a “long period.” Mr. Christiansen testified that a long period is at least two years.(Footnote 9) STUDENT’s problematic behavior and feelings have been evident at home and at school for several years. MOTHER testified that STUDENT has exhibited the behavioral problems described above since at least 2000. Ms. DeBenedetto’s concerns were expressed in 2000, as well. Finally, STUDENT’s therapists identified him as eligible for Mental Health services because of his emotional difficulties and behavioral problems in August 2001. Therefore, the evidence establishes that STUDENT has exhibited inappropriate feelings and behavior for a long period of time.

Have STUDENT’s ED characteristics adversely affected his education?

Petitioner asserts that his ED characteristics have resulted in multiple exclusions from school, thereby, adversely affecting his education. The District asserts that STUDENT has received average scores on measures of academic achievement demonstrating that he is benefitting from his education. Dr. Morriss testified that STUDENT is making appropriate achievement despite not being productive in class and does not demonstrate any skills deficits. Ms. Moler testified that STUDENT is a little behind in writing and has some difficulty putting words on paper. He passed level-four reading and is functioning at the mid-third-grade level in mathematics.

At one point, STUDENT was excluded from the general education class at the comprehensive elementary school and placed in ALBA. STUDENT’s recent behavior at school, as well as his behavior the prior school year, has resulted in multiple suspensions. See e.g. Petitioner’s Exhibits 23 and 24. STUDENT’s mother has also been asked to pick him up from school before the end of the school day. Thus, STUDENT has been excluded from school because of his ED characteristics. He presumably is missing valuable instruction in subject areas while he has been suspended. There is no dispute that STUDENT is of average intelligence. Yet his grades, which were discussed in the background facts above, are very poor and he is failing or in danger of failing multiple subjects this current school year. His grades last year also consisted of many Ds and Fs. Petitioner’s Exhibit 13. Additionally, STUDENT is missing out on opportunities to develop social skills when he is not in school. It is well documented that STUDENT’s social skills are deficient. The Hearing Officer finds that the above evidence establishes that STUDENT’s ED characteristics adversely affect his education.

A finding that STUDENT meets ED criteria is insufficient to designate him eligible for special education. STUDENT must also require instruction, services, or both, which cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program.

Does STUDENT require instruction or services that cannot be met with modification to the regular education program?

Petitioner asserts that he requires instruction and services that cannot be met with modification to the regular education program. The District asserts that STUDENT’s 504 Plan sufficiently address his needs.

For the past two years, the District has attempted to address STUDENT’s needs with a 504 Plan. The District has also implemented multiple behavior plans that have not been successful, as evidenced by STUDENT’s ongoing difficulties at school. Notwithstanding implementation of the 504 Plan and multiple behavioral plans, the evidence establishes that STUDENT has poor grades and has been excluded from school multiple times. It should be noted that STUDENT’s 504 Plan significantly reduces the amount of homework STUDENT is required to do, so his grades are not a result of the failure to complete homework assignments. According to Ms. Moler, she has lessened or reduced his homework to almost nothing.

Additionally, no one persuasively disputed Dr. Hellwig’s testimony that STUDENT requires a structured class with a small student-to-teacher ratio. Dr. Hellwig stressed the importance of, first, undertaking a comprehensive behavioral assessment of STUDENT, second, developing a comprehensive behavioral plan based on the assessment, and finally, increasing interagency collaboration. Dr. Hellwig also testified persuasively that it is important for Mental Health, the District, and STUDENT’s mother to collaborate to address STUDENT’s needs consistently across home, school, therapy, and community environments. STUDENT also requires someone to assist him at school to assess what externally triggers his actions and to process with STUDENT after an incident to help him understand internal antecedents. The Hearing Officer finds Dr. Hellwig’s recommendations are necessary for STUDENT to access his instruction and that his recommendations constitute more than mere modifications to the regular education program.

To summarize, STUDENT meets eligibility criteria for ED because he has exhibited unusual feelings or behaviors under normal circumstances to a marked degree and for a long period of time. Additionally, STUDENT’s education has been adversely affected and he requires special education.

(b) Does STUDENT meet eligibility criteria for special education as other health impaired (OHI)?

Petitioner contends that he meets special education eligibility under the category of other health impaired (OHI) because he has a attention deficit hyperactive disorder (ADHD) that results in limited alertness. Because it has been determined above that STUDENT is eligible for special education as ED, it is unnecessary to determine whether he also meets eligibility criteria as OHI. The District is responsible for developing an IEP and providing instruction and services designed to meet all of STUDENT’s needs arising from his disability. See e.g. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56345 and 56363.

ISSUE NO. 2: If STUDENT was eligible for special education as of October 1, 2002, has Respondent Fresno Unified School District offered him a free appropriate public education (FAPE)?

Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 14018. In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that to receive a FAPE, the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be designed to meet the unique needs of the student and reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit.

It has been determined above that STUDENT is eligible for special education as ED and that because of his ED, he requires special education instruction and services. STUDENT does not have an IEP and the District has not offered special education services to him. Thus, the District has not offered STUDENT a FAPE. The District must convene an IEP meeting to develop an appropriate IEP and to determine STUDENT’s necessary special education program, placement, and services.

ORDER

Within 15 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall (a) convene an IEP team to develop an individualized educational program (IEP) for STUDENT and (b) offer STUDENT a FAPE, including special education services and placement. The District shall invite STUDENT’s current mental health providers to participate in the IEP meeting.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: Petitioner prevailed on the issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

DATED: January 16, 2003 ________________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. The services STUDENT receives from Mental Health are not provided pursuant to the interagency agreement between the California Departments of Education and Mental Health. 2. The District employed alternative means to evaluate STUDENT’s cognitive functioning because the District does not administer intelligence tests to its African-American students pursuant to the decision in Larry P. v. Riles (N.D.Cal. 1979) 459 F. Supp. 926 aff’d in part, rev’d in part, (9th Cir. 1986) 793 F.Supp. 969, and by State policy. 3. MOTHER waived timelines for completion of the assessment.

4. Mr. Christensen’s report is entitled “Psycho-Educational-Report Addendum.” 5. The hearing was designated as “expedited” because the District has proposed to expel STUDENT and it was determined that the District is deemed to have a basis of knowledge that STUDENT was a child with a disability under 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(8). Therefore, he is entitled to the procedural protections of the IDEA. 6. Socialization subdomains measured by the Vineland include interpersonal relationships, play and leisure time, and coping skills. 7. The similarly identified concerns related to poor academics, poor attention, poor impulse control, poor anger control, excessive resistance, excessive withdrawal, and poor social conformity. 8. Dr. Morriss testified that he is the sole employee of Village Press Publications. His resume identifies many articles published by Village Press. The article contained in Respondent’s Exhibit 12 provides no factual basis or research study in support of conclusions he makes in the article such as “ [if an ODD student is placed in a special education class], the parent and child are now protected under the guidelines of state and federal Special Education law. Discipline often becomes a central issue, especially for the student with ODD who lives with a hostile parent who made him that way. The ODD student who becomes dangerous to himself and others can figuratively, and in some cases literally be given permission ‘to load their gun’ under the cover of Special Education.’” 9. There is no basis in the law for requiring a student with emotional problems to wait for such a long period of time to establish special education eligibility. To so require would likely result in irreparable harm to the student.