California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 13, 2002
Student v. Desert Sands Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 2709-01 · Hearing Officer Deborah M. Cooke
Desert Sands Unified must keep student in Wilson Middle School special day class with added supports; most other claims denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
Parents filed for a 12-year-old sixth grader against Desert Sands Unified School District. He had Down syndrome and was eligible under the category then called mental retardation. He attended a special day class (SDC) at Wilson Middle School with a one-to-one paraeducator and took two general education electives. The parents said the district had not followed his November 2000 IEP. They also challenged parts of the November 2001 IEP. At hearing, the district argued that a county-run class would serve him better.
The Hearing Officer found that the district substantially provided adaptive physical education. Two sessions were missed, one while the teacher waited for a doctor's note about safety. Inclusion specialist consultation was provided as required. The district did fail to follow the IEP when the speech therapist cut speech from twice to once a week without an IEP meeting, even though the mother had informally agreed. No compensatory services were awarded because the student still benefited. The IEP did not need to promise a substitute aide.
The Hearing Officer would not rule on the county class, because the district never offered it in writing. She found the Wilson SDC appropriate with changes. She upheld weekly 40-minute speech and found band was not required. She ordered the district to keep the SDC placement, have the inclusion specialist consult staff right away, and train the aide in corrective reading. The IEP must also list weekly speech and two general education electives that address social skills.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled a service cut agreed to informally with a parent. Changing services outside an IEP meeting was a failure to implement the IEP. Still, no compensatory education was ordered because the student kept benefiting. It also shows that a district could not get a ruling on a placement it never offered in writing.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue 1a. Did the District's educational program fail to conform to the last agreed-upon and implemented IEP dated November 29, 2000, with regard to the provision of adaptive physical education (APE) services during the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years?
The IEP was substantially implemented; one APE session was reasonably withheld pending a doctor's clarification and one was missed for the instructor's absence, and the May 2000 APE goals remained in effect for a year, so new goals were not required in November 2000.
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue 1b. Did the District's educational program fail to conform to the November 29, 2000 IEP with regard to the provision of inclusion specialist services during the 2001-2002 school year?
The IEP required consultation with class staff, not classroom presence; credible testimony showed the inclusion specialist consulted at least twice a month for 30 minutes.
- Student prevailedImplementation
Issue 1c. Did the District's educational program fail to conform to the November 29, 2000 IEP with regard to the provision of speech services during the 2001-2002 school year?
Reducing speech from twice to once weekly from September 2001 by oral agreement with the mother, without an IEP meeting, meant speech services failed to conform to the IEP.
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue 2. If the District's educational program failed to conform to the last agreed-upon and implemented IEP, is Student entitled to compensatory education in the areas of APE, inclusion specialist services, and speech?
No compensatory education: the two missed APE sessions were de minimis, inclusion services were provided, and the student still benefited from once-weekly speech with home practice tapes.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 3. Did the District satisfy special education law by excluding from the IEP document a written statement that a substitute shall be provided for the one-to-one paraeducator when the paraeducator is absent?
The law does not require such language absent a showing of specific need; the district must implement the IEP, and the evidence did not show the student had been left without a substitute aide.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 4a. Pursuant to the IEP dated November 27, 2001, did the District deny a FAPE by placing Student in a special day class at Wilson Middle School?
The parents' preferred Wilson SDC was appropriate with added inclusion specialist consultation and aide training; the Hearing Officer declined to rule on the county TMH class because it was never formally offered in writing.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4b. Pursuant to the IEP dated November 27, 2001, did the District deny a FAPE by changing Student's speech and language services?
One 40-minute weekly session using oral motor programming and auditory bombardment, with home practice, met the student's speech needs and provided educational benefit.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4c. Pursuant to the IEP dated November 27, 2001, did the District deny a FAPE by deleting elective band class from the IEP document?
No evidence showed a need that only band could meet, so band was not required, but the IEP must provide two general education electives addressing social skills, peer interaction and group work.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Placement ordered. District shall maintain the student's placement in Ms. Wilcox's SDC at Wilson Middle School for the 2001-2002 school year.
- Order to provide or change services. The assigned inclusion specialist shall immediately consult with the student's service providers about modifications and ideas to include him more successfully in nonacademic activities.
- Staff training. District shall give the student's one-to-one paraeducator appropriate training in the corrective reading technique used in the SDC.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. District shall hold an IEP meeting and modify the IEP to provide (a) speech and language services once a week for 40 minutes as proposed in the November 27, 2001 IEP and (b) enrollment in two general education electives that address social skills, peer interaction skills and working with groups.
Key authorities
Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education; S.V. v. Sherwood School Dist.
People named in the decision
- Larry Lehnhof, Regional Center case worker (present for Student), Regional Center
- Carolyn Rounsaville, director of special education, Desert Sands Unified School District
- Maureen Boren, program specialist, Desert Sands Unified School District
- Judi Wilcox, special day class teacher, Wilson Middle School, Desert Sands Unified School District
- Terry Sheehan, current one-to-one paraeducator, Desert Sands Unified School District
- Renee Rogers, former one-to-one paraeducator, Desert Sands Unified School District
- Regina Quintero, classroom instructional aide, Madison Elementary School
- Pamela Reinholtz, regular education teacher, Desert Sands Unified School District
- Rea Bowling, special day class teacher, Woodrow Wilson Middle School
- Nancy Bucher, speech therapist, Desert Sands Unified School District
- Lawrence McCoy, music director (band teacher), Woodrow Wilson Middle School
- Barbara Johnson, adaptive physical education specialist (2000-2001 APE instructor), Desert Sands Unified School District
- Mary Abarrate, school psychologist, Desert Sands Unified School District
- John (Jack) O'Connell, school psychologist, Desert Sands Unified School District
- James Wyllie, adaptive physical education specialist (current APE provider), Desert Sands Unified School District
- Tyra Seymour, coordinating principal, Riverside County Office of Education
- Elka Kelly, program specialist, Desert Sands Unified School District
- Sandy Gilbert, program specialist, Desert Sands Unified School District
- Anne LaLonde-Berg, inclusion specialist, Desert Sands Unified School District
- Dr. Gutierrez-Go, student's private pediatrician, Private provider
- Maria Gless, attorney for District, Best, Best & Krieger, LLP
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in La Quinta, California, on January 8, 9, 29, 30, and 31, 2002.
Petitioner STUDENT (hereafter, Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by his mother, MOTHER. Also present on behalf of the Petitioner was his father, FATHER, and Larry Lehnhof, STUDENT’s Regional Center case worker. Respondent Desert Sands Unified School District (hereafter, Respondent or District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Maria Gless of the law offices of Best, Best & Krieger, LLP. Also present on behalf of the Respondent were Carolyn Rounsaville, director of special education for the District, and Maureen Boren, program specialist for the District.
The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: Judi Wilcox, STUDENT’s current special day class teacher; Terry Sheehan, STUDENT’s current one-to-one paraeducator; Renee Rogers, STUDENT’s former one-to-one paraeducator; Regina Quintero, classroom instructional aide at Madison Elementary School; Pamela Reinholtz, regular education teacher; Rea Bowling, special day class teacher at Woodrow Wilson Middle School; and MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother.
The following witnesses were called by Respondent: Nancy Bucher, speech therapist for the District; Lawrence McCoy, music director at Woodrow Wilson Middle School (Wilson); Barbara Johnson, adaptive physical education (APE) specialist for the District; Mary Abarrate, psychologist for the District; John (a.k.a. “Jack”) O’Connell, school psychologist for the District; James Wyllie, APE specialist for the District; Tyra Seymour, coordinating principal for the
Riverside County Office of Education; Elka Kelly, program specialist for the District; Sandy Gilbert, program specialist for the District; and Anne LaLonde-Berg, inclusion specialist for the District.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of written closing arguments. Closing arguments were received from both parties and the record was closed on February 14, 2002.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
On the first day of hearing, Petitioner added an issue regarding the appropriateness of the District’s recommendation that he receive speech and language services one time each week. Additionally, the District requested a determination by the Hearing Officer as to whether STUDENT’s current placement in the District’s special day class at Wilson Middle School is appropriate.(Footnote 1) The District’s counsel pointed out at the hearing that the IEP dated November 27, 2001, provided for STUDENT’s continued placement in the special day class at Wilson as the parents were requesting. However, the District stated at hearing that it now believed that STUDENT’s needs dictated placement in a more restrictive program to enable him to learn more. Specifically, the District argued at hearing that STUDENT should be placed in a county-run, trainable mentally handicapped (TMH) special day class.
The Hearing Officer will not make a determination as to the appropriateness of the county-run TMH program because it is not an issue ripe for adjudication and was not properly raised by Respondent. The IEP dated November 27, 2001, which the parents did not sign, states that STUDENT would remain in the special day class program at Wilson Middle School. Although the IEP indicates that the District considered and recommended that STUDENT be referred for placement in a county program, the final offered program did not include the same. (See Resp.’s Exh. 4, pgs. 1 & 5.) Rather, the District agreed, in writing, that STUDENT would stay in the special day class program at Wilson because the parents refused to have him referred to the county-run program. (Id. at pg. 5.)
Although the District presented evidence at hearing in support of its contention that a county-run, trainable mentally handicapped program would be “more appropriate” for STUDENT, the District has not made a formal, specific, written offer to place STUDENT in any particular county-run program and has not properly brought this issue before the Hearing Officer. Therefore, it is not necessary for the Hearing Officer to make a determination of the appropriateness of placing STUDENT in that program. (Union School District v. B. Smith (9th Cir. 1994) 15 F.3d 1519, 1526.)
In an abundance of caution, however, the Hearing Officer will consider the appropriateness of STUDENT’s current placement in Judi Wilcox’s special day class at Wilson Middle School, because that is the placement the District formally offered in writing on the IEP dated November 27, 2001, and both parties agreed that the Hearing Officer should decide the issue of its appropriateness.
ISSUES
1. Did the District’s educational program fail to conform to STUDENT’s last agreed-upon and implemented IEP dated November 29, 2000, with regard to (a) the provision of adaptive physical education (APE) services during the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years, (b) the provision of inclusion specialist services during the 2001-2002 school year, and (c) the provision of speech services during the 2001-2002 school year?
2. If the District’s educational program failed to conform to STUDENT’s last agreed-upon and implemented IEP, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education in the areas of APE, inclusion specialist services, and speech?
3. Did the District satisfy special education law by excluding from STUDENT’s IEP document a written statement that a substitute shall be provided for his one-to-one paraeducator when the paraeducator is absent?
4. Pursuant to the IEP dated November 27, 2001, did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education by (a) placing him in a special day class at Wilson Middle School, (b) changing his speech and language services, and (c) deleting elective band class from his IEP document?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a twelve-year-old student with a diagnosis of Down syndrome with moderate to severe mental retardation. He is a resident of the Desert Sands Unified School District and attends the sixth grade at Wilson Middle School in the District pursuant to an intradistrict transfer. STUDENT qualifies for special education services under the category of mental retardation and is currently placed in a special day class with designated instruction and services in the areas of speech and language, adaptive physical education, inclusion specialist support, one-to-one paraeducator support, transportation, and extended school year services.
STUDENT’s last agreed-upon and implemented individualized education program (IEP) was dated and signed by his parents on November 29, 2000. At the time the November 2000 IEP was developed, STUDENT attended Madison Elementary School. However, for the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT transferred to Wilson Middle School, and since September 2001, he has been attending Judi Wilcox’s special day class (SDC). Ms. Wilcox’s noncategorical SDC consists primarily of students who have specific learning disabilities, including processing disabilities, hearing and visual impairments, and autism. There are nineteen students in her class. STUDENT is currently mainstreamed for two elective classes and for modified physical education, lunch, recess, passing periods, and school day activities. According to STUDENT’s mother, STUDENT has always been placed in a special day class and mainstreamed for a portion of his day in regular education.
At an IEP team meeting held on November 27, 2001, most of the District members of the IEP team recommended that STUDENT be referred for consideration of placement in a county-run special day class program located on a District school campus. They believed he would “receive a more beneficial educational program based on his needs and abilities.” (Resp.’s Exh. 4.) During the November 2001 IEP meeting, STUDENT’s parents refused the county referral and the IEP team ultimately agreed that STUDENT would continue to attend the self-contained special day class program at Wilson Middle School, with designated instruction and services in speech and language, APE (pending doctor’s approval), paraeducator support, curb-to-curb transportation, and extended school year services.(Footnote 2) Notwithstanding STUDENT’s continued placement in the SDC at Wilson, STUDENT’s parents refused to sign the November 2001 IEP for reasons that will be discussed below, and subsequently filed a request with the Hearing Office for a due process hearing.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
As stated above, the last agreed upon and implemented IEP was dated November 29, 2000. At hearing Petitioner contended that the District failed to properly implement the November 29, 2000 IEP. Specifically, Petitioner alleged that the District failed to develop new APE goals at the November 2000 IEP team meeting, failed to provide two of his required APE sessions during the 2001-2002 school year, failed to provide inclusion specialist services two times a month since September 2001, and failed to provide his speech services two times per week since September 2001.
With regard to the offer made in the unsigned November 27, 2001 IEP, Petitioner alleges that his current placement in Ms. Wilcox’s SDC is the appropriate placement for him because he is making progress in that class and it is the least restrictive placement in which he has benefitted. Petitioner also contends that his unique needs necessitate speech services two times a week. And finally, Petitioner argues that his desire to learn music and his need to interact with typically developing peers necessitates his enrollment in the elective band class.(Footnote 3)
The District contends that STUDENT’s May 22, 2000 APE goals were written for one year, and therefore, those goals could have been continued for the next school year. Regarding the provision of services, the District contends that APE services were reasonably denied on two occasions during the 2001-2002 school year due to the instructor’s concern regarding STUDENT’s susceptibility to injury and sudden death. The District also argued that the inclusion specialist services were provided to STUDENT in accordance with his November 2000 IEP. And lastly, the District did not deny that speech services were not provided two times per week since September 2001, but claimed that the speech therapist’s recommendation to reduce the services proved beneficial to STUDENT.
Regarding the November 2001 IEP, the District contends that STUDENT’s current placement in Ms. Wilcox’s SDC does not allow him to make any educational growth, nor can he with the amount of modifications that are needed for him to remain in that environment. (Resp.’s closing brief, pg. 13.) Regarding speech, the District contends that the services recommended by its speech therapist were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and would provide him with educational benefit. Regarding the band class, the District argues that even with adaptations and modifications, STUDENT is not able to follow the requirements of the band class and is not receiving any educational benefit.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. Did the District’s educational program fail to conform to STUDENT’s last agreed upon and implemented IEP dated November 29, 2000, with regard to:
(a) the provision of adaptive physical education (APE) services during the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years, (b) the provision of inclusion specialist services during the 2001-2002 school year, and b) the provision of speech services during the 2001-2002 school year?
The analysis of whether STUDENT has been provided a free appropriate public education (FAPE) includes, among other things, a determination by the Hearing Officer as to whether STUDENT’s educational program conformed to the IEP. (Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034.) Petitioner argues that certain services identified in his IEP dated November 29, 2000, were not provided to him during the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years. The Hearing Officer analyzes each issue below.
APE services
Petitioner alleges that during the 2001-2002 school year, the District failed to provide APE services as specified in his November 29, 2000 IEP. Specifically, Petitioner contends that the APE specialist did not provide him APE services on two occasions until his parents provided a note from his doctor regarding his ability to participate in physical activity. Petitioner also alleges that during the November 2000 IEP team meeting, the District failed to draft new APE goals for the 2000-2001 school year. The District argues that although APE services were not provided on two occasions during the 2001-2002 school year due to concerns raised by STUDENT’s doctor as to the appropriateness of his participating in physical education, STUDENT suffered no harm as a result. Additionally, the District contends that there was no procedural violation regarding the APE goals because the IEP team on May 22, 2000, wrote APE goals which covered one full year. (Resp.’s closing brief, pg. 7.)
James Wyllie is STUDENT’s current APE service provider. Mr. Wyllie testified that during the November 2001 IEP team meeting, MOTHER informed him that STUDENT’s doctor had written a note stating that STUDENT was not to participate in physical education. Additionally, Mr. Wyllie testified that he had previously read literature about the instability of the spine of those with Down syndrome. After discussing the issue of physical education at the November 2001 IEP meeting, Mr. Wyllie believed that it was necessary to cease APE services until he received a follow- up note from STUDENT’s doctor stating whether it would be appropriate for STUDENT to participate in APE. Sandy Gilbert, program specialist for the District, also was present at the November 2001 IEP team meeting and supported Mr. Wyllie’s testimony on this matter. Ms. Gilbert believed that Mr. Wyllie’s request for an additional note from STUDENT’s doctor was a reasonable request given the previous note written by his doctor stating that STUDENT should not participate in physical education.
According to Mr. Wyllie, STUDENT received APE services until November 2001. Mr. Wyllie then stopped providing APE services until MOTHER provided a December 3, 2001 note from STUDENT’s doctor, which clarified the doctor’s recommendation that STUDENT continue to be engaged in APE, but be restricted from regular physical education. (Testimony of J. Wyllie; Resp.’s Exh. 17.) Mr. Wyllie testified that STUDENT missed one APE session because of Mr. Wyllie’s absence, and a second session because the doctor’s note had not yet been provided confirming the appropriateness of APE services.
MOTHER testified that after the November 27, 2001 IEP meeting, Mr. Wyllie visited STUDENT’s pediatrician, Dr. Gutierrez-Go, at which time the doctor informed Mr. Wyllie that STUDENT could not engage in contact sports. MOTHER also testified that the December 3, 2001 letter written by Dr. Gutierrez-Go indicated that STUDENT’s cervical spine x-rays were normal and that there was no concern about STUDENT’s falling. (Resp.’s Exh. 17.)
The evidence indicates that prior to Mr. Wyllie’s receipt of Dr. Gutierrez-Go’s December 3, 2001 letter clarifying her recommendation for STUDENT’s participation in APE, Mr. Wyllie was understandably cautious regarding the type of physical activity that was safe for STUDENT.(Footnote 4) Mr. Wyllie testified that his concern for STUDENT’s safety stemmed from his understanding that individuals with Down syndrome are susceptible to experiencing sudden death. (Resp.’s Exh. 17.) The Hearing Officer finds that Mr. Wyllie’s determination that he first needed additional information before proceeding with APE services was reasonable and warranted, considering the information made available to him at the November 2001 IEP team meeting. The evidence therefore indicates that the November 2000 IEP was substantially implemented, notwithstanding the reasonable failure to provide one session of APE until receipt of the doctor’s note and a second session due to Mr. Wyllie’s absence.
Regarding Petitioner’s contention that new APE goals should have been drafted at the November 2000 IEP meeting, STUDENT’s APE instructor during the 2000-2001 school year, Barbara Johnson, testified that although APE goals generally are written for one year, new goals are usually drafted at IEP meetings. As of the November 2000 IEP team meeting, APE goals had last been written for STUDENT on May 22, 2000. (Resp.’s Exh. 1.) According to Ms. Johnson, new APE goals should have been drafted at the November 2000 IEP meeting because STUDENT was at a point of transition. Ms. Johnson also testified, however, that during the 2000-2001 school year, she worked on the APE goals identified in the May 22, 2000 IEP and that STUDENT only partially met his arrhythmic goal and did not meet his endurance goal. Ms. Johnson stated that her expectations for STUDENT’s progress were too high and that STUDENT was lower functioning than she had anticipated. Therefore, STUDENT did not need new goals.
The District argues that goals from the May 22, 2000 IEP addendum were written for one year. Therefore, current goals were in place until the end of the 2000-2001 school year. The May 22, 2000 IEP addendum includes two APE goals designed to address STUDENT’s motor skills and endurance. Mr. Wyllie, STUDENT’ s current APE instructor, testified that STUDENT has been working on his goals by doing activities such as dribbling, catching, tossing, and more recently, hitting golf balls. According to Mr. Wyllie, APE includes a wide variety of activities, and STUDENT’s current APE activities include motor patterns that will assist STUDENT in developing his motor skills. Mr. Wyllie also testified that he did not work on the endurance goal set forth in the May 22, 2000 IEP, which included running, because he believed that it was best if STUDENT did not run and jump because of the potential danger of his falling or running into other students. The Hearing Officer notes that the District was willing to add to the November 27, 2001 IEP a new APE goal designed to develop STUDENT’s object control skills in the area of toss and catch. However, the parents refused to sign that IEP document.
The Hearing Officer finds that although new APE goals were not developed at the November 29, 2000 IEP team meeting, the evidence demonstrated that STUDENT continued receiving appropriate APE services that allowed him to work on gross motor skills, which was an area of need for him. Additionally, there was no evidence that STUDENT should have been working on areas other than those already being addressed with his former and present APE service providers. Moreover, the APE goals from May 22, 2000 IEP were in effect for one year. And although the District added an APE goal during the IEP team meeting in November 2001, the parents refused to approve any portion of that IEP. Therefore, the May 2000 APE goals remained in effect for one full year, and unless otherwise requested by the parents, the District was not required to develop any additional goals until the next annual review during the IEP team meeting in November 2001.
Inclusion specialist services
Petitioner alleges that since the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year, the inclusion specialist (IS) has been to STUDENT’s classroom on only one occasion. STUDENT’s last agreed-upon and implemented IEP dated November 29, 2000, requires that the inclusion specialist consult with the class staff two times a month for thirty minutes each consult. (Pet.’s Exh. A.) Anne LaLonde-Berg is STUDENT’s current IS. Ms. LaLonde-Berg testified that during the 2001-2002 school year, she has consulted with STUDENT’s class staff, including his teacher and his aide, at least two times each month since September 2001. The place and manner in which the IS services were provided varied. However, Ms. LaLonde-Berg and STUDENT’s paraeducator, Mr. Sheehan, both confirmed that Ms. LaLonde-Berg had provided consultation at least, if not more than, two times each month for thirty minutes each consult. Terry Sheehan, STUDENT’s paraeducator, testified that Ms. LaLonde-Berg has been in the classroom observing STUDENT and bringing work for him to do at least two times a month since September 2001. According to Mr. Sheehan, Ms. LaLonde-Berg consults with him by giving him pointers on how to improve his support of STUDENT.
According to Ms. LaLonde-Berg, she consulted with the class staff after STUDENT had left school for the day, outside of the classroom, in and about the school campus, and at the Eisenhower campus, where STUDENT serves as a library aide. Ms. LaLonde-Berg further testified that she also uses email to communicate and consult with the staff about issues that might arise. She also maintains an anecdotal log regarding IS services rendered. Ms. LaLonde-Berg maintains that she consulted with the class staff approximately one hour a month, which is in addition to time spent preparing materials for STUDENT’s use.
STUDENT’s SDC teacher, Judi Wilcox, testified that Ms. LaLonde-Berg has been in her classroom three or four times since September 2001. Ms. Wilcox testified that Ms. LaLonde-Berg gave her some suggestions on how to get started with STUDENT and then Ms. Wilcox worked with MOTHER to determine what MOTHER wanted STUDENT to accomplish. Ms. Wilcox also testified that she did not know if the Ms. LaLonde-Berg had met with all of STUDENT’s other teachers, but she did know that the Ms. LaLonde-Berg had visited STUDENT’s band classroom.
Although Ms. Wilcox only recalled Ms. LaLonde-Berg being in her classroom on three or four occasions and the paraeducator recalled her being there at least two times a month since September 2001, the real issue is not how many times the IS was physically in the classroom, but whether she provided the appropriate number of hours of consultative IS services each month. The November 29, 2000 IEP does not require the IS to be physically present in the classroom. Rather, that IEP requires that the IS “consult with class staff.” In light of the credible testimony of Ms. LaLonde-Berg and Mr. Sheehan, who works with STUDENT on a daily basis as his paraeducator, the Hearing Officer finds that IS services were provided in accordance with the current IEP, dated November 29, 2000.
Speech services
Petitioner contends that since September 2001, he has received speech and language services only one time a week, rather than the two times each week as prescribed by his November 29, 2000 IEP. According to MOTHER, she and STUDENT’s speech therapist, Nancy Bucher, discussed STUDENT’s progress during this current school year. Mrs. Bucher testified that at the beginning of the school year, she suggested that she reduce her provision of speech services to STUDENT to once a week and also provide him with a tape recorder so that he could listen to what he was saying and practice his speech at home. She stated that STUDENT had not been making much progress during this current school year. Although STUDENT works and tries hard, speech has been difficult for him because of his dyspraxis. MOTHER acknowledged that she had agreed to decrease STUDENT’s speech services to one time per week on a trial basis and that Ms. Bucher provided her with tapes she could use with STUDENT to practice his speech at home. Although MOTHER informally agreed to the trial reduction in speech services, MOTHER did not want to change the IEP. (Testimony of Nancy Bucher.) Thus, although the November 2000 IEP was not changed as to speech services, MOTHER and Ms. Bucher came to an oral agreement about the temporary change in the amount of services. MOTHER also testified that she has been using the speech tapes with STUDENT at home, and although she was having difficulty with the speed of the tapes, MOTHER felt that the tapes had been helpful to STUDENT since they continue at home what the speech therapist is working on with STUDENT at school.
The proper process for amending an IEP is to hold an IEP team meeting to first discuss any recommended changes. (Educ. Code § 56343(b) and (c)). This allows each member of the IEP team, particularly the service providers, to be apprised of the services the student should be receiving and to ensure compliance with the provisions of the IEP document. Having recommended a change in the amount of speech services that STUDENT required, Ms. Bucher should have requested an IEP team meeting to discuss the appropriateness of such a change. A discussion among the IEP team members regarding the recommendation that speech services be reduced did not occur until the November 27, 2001 IEP team meeting, at which time MOTHER indicated her disagreement with the reduction in STUDENT’s speech services. Notwithstanding MOTHER’s previous oral agreement with Ms. Bucher to the trial reduction of services, the proper steps were not taken to formally change the IEP document. As a result, the District’s speech and language services failed to conform to STUDENT’s IEP from September 2001.
2. If the District’s educational program failed to conform to STUDENT’s last agreed-upon and implemented IEP, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education in the areas of inclusion specialist services, APE and speech?
In light of the Hearing Officer’s decision above that inclusion specialist services were provided in conformance with the November 29, 2000 IEP document, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT is not entitled to compensatory education in that area. With regard to APE and speech services, however, given the Hearing Officer’s determination above, the Hearing Officer considers whether compensatory education is warranted.
Compensatory education is an equitable remedy that may be available when the school district has failed to provide the student with appropriate, special education services. (Student W. v. Puyallup School District, (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496; see also S.V. v. Sherwood School District 75 F.Supp.2d 1153, 1157 (D. Oregon, 1999).) Compensatory education does not require day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity lost or time missed. Its purpose is to “ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of IDEA.” (Puyallup School District, supra, 31 F.3d at 1497.)
APE services
Given the Hearing Officer’s conclusion above that STUDENT has continued to receive appropriate APE services, notwithstanding the two missed sessions, the Hearing Officer finds that compensatory education in the area of APE is not warranted. Mr. Wyllie testified that although STUDENT missed two APE sessions, he continued working towards his goals. According to Mr. Wyllie, because STUDENT has significant motor delays because of the Down syndrome, any additional sessions would not be of benefit to him. Petitioner presented no evidence that his needs were not met or that he failed to receive educational benefit as a result of the two missed sessions. Therefore, no opportunity was lost due to the de minimis denial of services and no remedy is warranted. Speech services
MOTHER testified that STUDENT has recently benefitted from using at home the speech tapes provided by Ms. Bucher. Moreover, Ms. Bucher testified that STUDENT’s needs require that he work on his speech outside the speech room because direct, one-to-one, speech services two times each week were not producing any greater results. Additionally, Ms. Bucher’s progress report dated November 29, 2001, indicates that no progress had been observed with regard to STUDENT’s speech intelligibility, but that STUDENT was making progress toward the goal of producing sounds, in that he could imitate sounds in words with a teacher model. (Pet.’s Exh. C.) From the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT received some benefit from the modified speech services in that he was able to make some progress with his intelligibility. STUDENT’s paraeducator, Mr. Sheehan, testified that he was under the impression that STUDENT’s speech had decreased because of the speech teacher’s failure to provide him with speech services two times each week. However, Mr. Sheehan did not provide a basis for this opinion or provide any specific examples of the alleged decrease. Therefore, the Hearing Officer gives his testimony little weight in this regard.
The Hearing Officer concludes that there was no convincing evidence that decreasing the speech services to one time per week, albeit outside the IEP process, in any way failed to meet STUDENT’s needs or failed to provide him with educational benefit. Thus, compensatory education is not necessary because STUDENT was appropriately educated in speech during the 2001-2002 school year, and there was no opportunity lost.
3. Did the District satisfy special education law by excluding from STUDENT’s IEP document a written statement that a substitute shall be provided for his one-to-one paraeducator when the paraeducator is absent?
Petitioner argues that his IEP document should include a written statement that the District will provide a substitute for STUDENT’s one-to-one paraeducator should the paraeducator be absent. Petitioner expressed a concern that the District would not provide a substitute for his one-to-one paraeducator if necessary. The District contends that there is no dispute that STUDENT requires one-to-one paraeducator support; however, it does not agree that it is required to put language into the IEP document regarding substitute personnel. The District also indicated that it is its policy to provide a substitute for absent personnel.
Education Code section 56345 and Section 300.347 of volume 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations (C.F.R.) identify all of the required provisions of the IEP document. The IEP document must include the specific special education instruction and related services and supplementary aids and services that will be provided to the student and a statement of the program modifications or supports for school personnel that will be provided for the student. (Educ. Code § 56345(a)(3); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(3).) The District’s version of the IEP dated November 27, 2001, states that STUDENT would be provided with additional paraeducator support, six hours per day, from November 27, 2001, to November 27, 2002. (Resp.’s Exh. 4.)(Footnote 5) The parents contended that there was no substitute for the paraeducator on the day that the paraeducator testified at the hearing. However, there was no evidence that STUDENT had been left without a substitute for his paraeducator. In fact, Terry Sheehan, STUDENT’s current paraeducator, testified that whenever he is absent he calls and informs his employer and someone from the school fills in for him.
The District is required by law to provide STUDENT with special education and related services in accordance with his IEP. Therefore, absent a showing that additional language is necessary to address a specific need of STUDENT’s, there is no reason to add language that a substitute be provided for the paraeducator.
4. Pursuant to the IEP dated November 27, 2001, did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education by (a) placing him in a special day class at Wilson Middle School, (b) changing his speech and language services, and (c) deleting elective band class from his IEP document?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Education Code § 56000.) The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).)
“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).) The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22).) California Education Code section 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA (now IDEA ‘97). The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. (Id. at 200.) According to Rowley, the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available, or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. (Id. at 198-200.) The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Id. at 201.)
To determine whether the District provided STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE), one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s program. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).) If the District’s program reflected STUDENT’s needs, provided some benefit, and comported with his IEP, the District provided a FAPE, even if the parents preferred another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would have resulted in greater educational benefit. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.) Special education law also requires that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment, which, in this case, means ensuring that STUDENT’s education is provided in a manner that promotes his maximum interaction with children or youth who are not disabled, and which is appropriate to the needs of both. (20 U.S.C. §§ 1412(a)(5)(A), 1414(d)(1)(A)(iii)(III); Educ. Code § 56031.)
To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program must have met the following three requirements in order to have constituted a substantively appropriate educational program: (1) been designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, (2) been reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, (3) comported with his IEP, and (4) been provided in the least restrictive environment.
Petitioner contends that his current placement in Ms. Wilcox’s SDC is the appropriate placement for him because he is making progress in that class and it is the least restrictive placement in which he has benefitted. Petitioner also contends that his unique needs necessitate speech services two times a week, rather than one time each week, as the District is proposing. Finally, Petitioner argues that he should not be excluded from the elective band class simply because he learns differently and requires modification to the band class curriculum.
The District contends that STUDENT’s current placement in Ms. Wilcox’s SDC does not allow him to make any educational growth, nor can he with the amount of modifications that are needed for him to remain in that environment. (Resp.’s closing brief, pg. 13.) Additionally, regarding speech, the District contends that the recommended one-time-a-week, forty-minute speech session is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and will provide him with educational benefit. Regarding the band class, the District argues that even with adaptations and modifications, STUDENT is not able to follow the requirements of the band class and is not receiving any educational benefit.
To determine the appropriateness of (1) STUDENT’s current placement in Ms. Wilcox’s special day class, (2) the District’s proposed amount of speech and language services, and (3) STUDENT’s enrollment in the elective band class, the Hearing Officer must first identify STUDENT’s needs.
As of November 27, 2001, STUDENT was reading at the 1.6 grade level. According to Mary Abbarrate, a District psychologist, individuals at the mild to severe level of mental retardation can expect to achieve up to a second-grade level in reading with a great deal of repetition through the twelfth grade. MOTHER testified that STUDENT could read the entire book called “Green Eggs and Ham.” Additionally, in May 2001, STUDENT received an award for having read 52 books (each with approximately 20 pages) at the first-grade level over a period of one month.
Both of the District psychologists who assessed STUDENT concluded that given his ability level, it is more beneficial for STUDENT to learn practical, functional, survival words that would be useful for everyday life situations. (Testimonies of N. Abbarrate and J. O’Connell.) They also concurred that to become independent in school and in the community environment, STUDENT should work on functional life skills goals rather than reading and curriculum goals. However, Ms. Abarrate believed it was important that STUDENT continue to work toward attaining a second- grade reading level. Terry Sheehan, STUDENT’s current one-to-one paraeducator, testified that although it takes STUDENT some time, he can comprehend sentences at the second-grade-reader level. Additionally, Anne LaLonde-Berg, STUDENT’s current inclusion specialist, testified that STUDENT’s reading skills are very strong and further development in that area should be encouraged.
In the area of communication, Ms. Bucher testified that STUDENT has difficulty modeling speech, since it requires different tongue positions. She stated that, currently, STUDENT’s overall speech is at the fourth-year level and he is difficult to understand. Although he can speak in complete sentences, he speaks very rapidly in conversation. According to Ms. Bucher, STUDENT can answer “yes” and “no” questions if they are repeated; however, he cannot always answer more difficult questions. Ms. Bucher believes that STUDENT has difficulty with the content of questions. Ms. Wilcox testified that STUDENT’s speech was not very clear and that STUDENT has a tendency to use one- and two-word sentences.
Ms. Wilcox testified that STUDENT needs to be included in the games and activities during lunch and needs assistance from the inclusion specialist to facilitate his inclusion. Having observed STUDENT this school year in his SDC, in his elective classes, during lunch, and generally around campus while he was transitioning between classes, Ms. LaLonde-Berg, STUDENT’s current inclusion specialist, opined that STUDENT needed to work more on his expressive and receptive communication skills and developing peer interaction skills. According to Ms. LaLonde-Berg, to avoid teasing by other students at school, STUDENT should work on basic communication level skills so that he understands what other typical sixth-grade students do in the community, on the school campus, in the cafeteria, and in the student store.
In sum, the parties generally do not dispute that STUDENT’s moderate mental retardation, developmental delays in the areas of speech and related communication/social skills, and his poor gross motor skills necessitate his receiving special education services, including related services in the areas of speech, APE, the assistance of a paraeducator, and the support of an inclusion specialist. The parties agree that STUDENT should be mainstreamed for opportunities to interact in a group socially and develop appropriate peer interaction skills. The parties also agree that since STUDENT’s reading skills are very strong given his ability level, further development in that area should be encouraged. There is no dispute that STUDENT needs to learn functional living skills. However, the parties disagree slightly as to the degree that his placement should address these skills. The District contends that STUDENT should be placed in an environment where he can focus more on functional living skills than academics. MOTHER testified, however, that STUDENT already demonstrates a number of living skills and contends that his current placement provides him with sufficient assistance in this area. According to MOTHER, STUDENT can already shower and dress and feed himself. He can answer the telephone and give basic information to the caller. STUDENT can operate the VCR and change the channels on the Direct Television program. He can also unlock the car door, turn on the dishwasher, take out the trash, and feed his pet guinea pig. MOTHER also reported that STUDENT helps her shop for groceries by weighing the fruits and vegetables and bagging the groceries. (See also Pet.’s Exh. I.) Although the parties disagree as to the extent that STUDENT needs to learn functional living skills, the Hearing Officer finds that he does require some living skills training in his program in order to meet his needs.
The Hearing Officer now turns her attention to the IEP dated November 27, 2001, to determine whether the goals and objectives therein address STUDENT’s unique needs. The IEP dated November 27, 2001, includes goals to improve STUDENT’s writing and reading, his intelligibility of speech, and his gross motor skills. The IEP also includes clearly defined goals and objectives dealing with time concepts, simple addition and subtraction using a calculator, survival and calendar words, and the use of money. The November 2001 IEP provides for STUDENT’s placement in Ms. Wilcox’s SDC at Wilson, speech and language services once a week for 40 minutes, two general education elective courses, APE two times each week for 35 minutes to work on his gross motor skills, and a one-on-one paraeducator. (Resp.’s Exh. 4.) Additionally, as discussed earlier, after commencement of the hearing in this matter, the parties added inclusion specialist support to the IEP.
There was no dispute that the goals in the November 27 2001 IEP were appropriately designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs. Additionally, the parties do not dispute that STUDENT requires individual instruction throughout the day to implement his goals and objectives and that he requires many repetitions of a task to gain acquisition of a particular skill. The dispute between the parties centers on the specific placement, the amount of speech and language services STUDENT requires, and whether or not he requires beginning band class. The Hearing Officer addresses each of these disputed areas below.
(a) Placing STUDENT in a special day class at Wilson Middle School
Petitioner contends that his current educational placement in Ms. Wilcox’s SDC with opportunities to participate in the regular education program is an appropriate placement because it meets his needs and provides him with educational benefit. The District argues that the current special day class placement does not provide STUDENT with a FAPE because that class does not provide an environment where STUDENT can work on functional living skills. (Resp.’s closing brief.) According to the District, STUDENT is making no educational growth because of the amount of modifications that are needed for him to remain in that environment.
According to District witnesses, Ms. Wilcox’s SDC does not appropriately address STUDENT’s academic needs in that the program is too far above his ability level, too difficult to modify, and does not address his social needs because STUDENT does not interact with nondisabled peers or his classroom peers. (Testimonies of Sandy Gilbert,(Footnote 6) Elka Kelly,(Footnote 7) and Anne LaLonde-Berg.(Footnote 8)) Several District witnesses also asserted that STUDENT needs to be in a program that proceeds at his pace and which focuses on functional life skills. (Testimonies of N. Abarrate, J. O’Connell, T. Seymour, S. Gilbert, A. LaLonde-Berg.) However, some of these witnesses were unaware of STUDENT’s current needs and others had never observed STUDENT in his current placement.
According to the testimonies of Ms. Wilcox and Mr. Sheehan, STUDENT works mostly independently from the other students in the SDC with a one-to-one paraeducator.(Footnote 9) Ms. Wilcox testified that STUDENT would be unable to do any of the work in her SDC without his paraeducator helping him and getting him started on assignments. She also testified, however, that no teacher could give STUDENT the time necessary to give him the attention he requires. Thus, if placed in any other program, STUDENT would also require the assistance of a one-to-one paraeducator. During his work sessions, STUDENT works on skills outlined in his IEP such as time concepts, addition and subtraction, survival and calendar words, reading signs, and counting money. He is also integrated with other students to work on daily living skills or social skills. STUDENT’s work is modified for language arts and math. To participate in the daily oral language activity, STUDENT orally identifies punctuation, capitalization, and grammar errors in a sentence, and Mr. Sheehan highlights the errors. STUDENT then traces over the highlighting so that he can make the corrections and work on his handwriting. In math, STUDENT’s modifications include enlargement of the times table charts and the use of manipulatives. Mr. Sheehan assists STUDENT with reading comprehension and math. Mr. Sheehan testified that if he were better trained in the corrective reading program that is used in STUDENT’s SDC, he could better assist STUDENT in that area. Ms. Wilcox also testified that she can address STUDENT’s scholastic needs in her class, although she could use additional assistance from the inclusion specialist (IS) with modifying his work.(Footnote 10)
According to Ms. Wilcox, the living skills that she teaches in her classroom are important for STUDENT to learn because eventually he will be trained to go to work, catch a bus, know the days of the week, and perform other similar living skills, and the sooner he is introduced and taught those skills, the better he will be able to function. In terms of social interaction, according to Mr. Sheehan, STUDENT interacts with other students at lunch and during passing periods, and plays with other students in his APE class. However, he has never seen STUDENT engage in play with nondisabled students.
STUDENT’s current placement in the District SDC program with other children with abilities different from his does not necessarily make his current program inappropriate. Many children are frequently placed in settings with lesser-disabled peers for the purpose of obtaining social benefit from the other students in the class. As will be discussed in greater depth below, STUDENT’s placement in Ms. Wilcox’s class allows him opportunities to be integrated with other nondisabled and lesser-disabled students that he would not receive otherwise. These integration opportunities could be further structured to enable him to work on his social goals relating to interactive play and staying within a group. In fact, Ms. Wilcox testified that she needed some assistance from the inclusion specialist in the form of suggestions of how she can better include STUDENT in games and activities during lunch. Ms. Wilcox also stated that
STUDENT’s current aide could use training in the corrective reading program in which STUDENT participates. However, STUDENT can do the class work if it is modified and if instructions are spoken to him. (Testimony of Judi Wilcox.)
The Hearing Officer finds that with certain modifications, which the Hearing Officer will discuss further below, STUDENT’s educational program and services can be provided in Ms. Wilcox’s classroom and that therefore, the SDC meets his unique educational needs.
To be appropriate under the IDEA, the District’s program must also be reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. (Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 200.) While this requires a school district to provide a disabled child with meaningful access to education, it does not mean that the school district is required to guarantee totally successful results. (Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998).) De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. (Id. at 130.) A child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. (Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997).)
Petitioner asserts that he has benefitted from being around nondisabled peers in the District’s SDC because there he has access to language and behavior models, is able to improve his social skills and self-esteem, and has opportunities to form friendships and participate in academic and nonacademic activities. (Pet.’s closing brief.) Ms. Wilcox testified that STUDENT has made progress socially. He started the year confused -- having to move from class to class -- and was sometimes late; however, he has been able to get settled into the middle school’s changing of classes and made the transition to the new program.
Academically, although STUDENT is unable to keep up with the other students in the class and made little progress this school year in math and reading, according to Ms. Wilcox, the real issue is whether he is meeting his goals, and not whether he is keeping up with other students. STUDENT received an “A” in language arts, which reflects his participation on his IEP goals and doing what he was told to do. STUDENT also has advanced past his previous goals in his knowledge of sight words from 70 to 102 sight words. According to Mr. Sheehan, STUDENT can now write out sounds and has improved in his ability to phonetically recite words and write. Mr. Sheehan also reported that STUDENT can comprehend sentences at the second-grade-reader level. MOTHER testified that STUDENT can read the entire book called “Green Eggs and Ham,” and in May 2001, he received an award for having read 52 books (each approximately 20 pages) at the first-grade level over a period of one month.
The District asserts that STUDENT’s placement in Ms. Wilcox’s class is not reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit for two reasons. First, the District alleges that STUDENT is not benefitting from the modified program because he is not working on the curriculum that other students follow in Ms. Wilcox’s class. Second, the District alleges that
STUDENT requires a program focused on functional living skills that is absent from Ms. Wilcox’s program. The Hearing Officer finds these arguments unpersuasive.
The District’s first argument ignores that much of the instruction within Ms. Wilcox’s classroom is being done in large and mid-sized groups with either Ms. Wilcox or her classroom aide leading instruction. Although the skills of some of the other students in the class exceed those of STUDENT’s and STUDENT may not benefit as much as these children do from the lecture and large- and mid-sized group instruction, STUDENT’s program does not require that he be able to follow the exact same curriculum as the other children. Thus, while STUDENT is placed in Ms. Wilcox’s class, a large part of his school day is dictated by the tasks outlined in his goals and objectives, tasks that are repeated many times throughout his school day and reinforced by his paraeducator. STUDENT has his own curriculum which is focused on his goals and objectives, and he is integrated with the other students to the extent that his abilities allow. And as indicated above, STUDENT has made progress on his goals and objectives. Therefore, the modified instruction provided by Ms. Wilcox and her classroom aide, along with the one-to-one assistance of his paraeducator, is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.
With regard to the District’s second argument that STUDENT requires a setting where he can work on functional living skills, Ms. Wilcox testified that her class program includes living skills, and Mr. Sheehan indicated that he works on those living skills, such as reading signs and making change, with STUDENT. Additionally, as indicated above, MOTHER testified that STUDENT already has acquired a number of essential living skills.
The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the evidence establishes that the special day class program in which STUDENT is currently enrolled is reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit.
There was no dispute whether the educational program outlined in the November 27, 2001 IEP would conform to the IEP. Issues raised regarding the content of the IEP have already been addressed above by the Hearing Officer.
Lastly, this case does not directly raise an issue of the least restrictive environment because there is no question of STUDENT’s being placed in a more or less restrictive placement. Nevertheless, the law recognizes that students may have a need to be associated with typically developing peers for a number of reasons. Therefore, the least restrictive environment in the context of this case raises the issue of whether Ms. Wilcox’s SDC meets STUDENT’s needs to interact with lesser-disabled and nondisabled peers. Ms. Wilcox’s SDC is primarily composed of students who have learning disabilities, thus allowing STUDENT to interact with lesser-disabled students. STUDENT also has the opportunity to interact with nondisabled students during his two regular education elective classes, during passing periods, and at lunch. Although Ms. Wilcox indicated that she needed additional assistance from the inclusion specialist to find ways to include STUDENT in games and activities during lunch and class instruction, the evidence established that, with appropriate modifications, STUDENT’s placement in Ms. Wilcox’s SDC meets his needs to have meaningful access to lesser-disabled and nondisabled children or youth, as required under the law regarding the least restrictive environment. (Educ. Code § 56031.)
In summary, the District has provided STUDENT an educational placement in which his goals and objectives are implemented, and in which he receives the individual attention that he requires. STUDENT’s primary teacher, the SDC classroom aide, his one-to-one paraeducator, and regular education teachers all have access to training and consultation by an inclusion specialist who can assist them with modifications to the SDC curriculum and the mainstreamed classes. The Hearing Officer finds, however, that given Ms. Wilcox’s testimony that she needs assistance with modifications and ideas on how to more successfully include STUDENT in nonacademic activities, the inclusion specialist should immediately consult with STUDENT’s service providers regarding these necessary modifications to his program. Additionally, given that corrective reading is a part of the SDC program in which STUDENT participates and a program from which he can benefit, the Hearing Officer finds it necessary that his one-to-one paraeducator be further trained in assisting STUDENT with this program so that STUDENT can access the corrective reading portion of the class to the fullest extent possible.
With the modifications noted above, the evidence establishes that STUDENT’s current placement in Ms. Wilcox’s SDC is designed to meet his unique needs, reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, conforms with the IEP, and provides meaningful access to lesser-disabled and nondisabled children or youth in a variety of contexts.
(b) Changing STUDENT’s speech and language services
As discussed earlier, during the November 27, 2001 IEP team meeting, speech and language therapist Nancy Bucher recommended to the IEP team that STUDENT’s speech services be decreased to one forty-minute session each week. Ms. Bucher testified that she began working with STUDENT during the summer of 2001. At the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year, Ms. Bucher discussed with MOTHER some of the concerns she had regarding STUDENT’s minimal progress on his speech goals, and suggested to MOTHER that she meet with STUDENT once a week and provide him with a tape recorder to practice his speech at home. Ms. Bucher testified that the forty-minute, one-to-one speech session that she provides STUDENT once a week is intense enough to carry over through the week. Additionally, Ms. Bucher believed that since it is difficult for STUDENT to model speech due to the tongue positions, he needs to be able to listen to what he is saying and practice by using a set of headphones and listening to the speech tapes outside the speech room. Therefore, Ms. Bucher recommended changing the technique being used in speech to a technique using oral motor programming and auditory bombardment.(Footnote 11)
Petitioner did not provide any evidence in support of his contention that he requires speech services two times a week. MOTHER admitted that, initially, she agreed to the reduction in speech services to one time each week. However, after it was revealed at the November 2001 IEP team meeting that STUDENT was not progressing, she requested that speech services resume on a two-time-a-week basis. Additional services, however, do not always make a program appropriate. In this case, the evidence established that STUDENT’s needs did not necessitate speech sessions two times per week. Rather, his speech needs necessitated a reduction in the number of speech sessions and the use of a different approach that included STUDENT practicing his speech at home by listening to a speech tape, using headphones and a tape recorder.
The Hearing Officer found Ms. Bucher’s testimony regarding STUDENT’s speech needs to be credible. Ms. Bucher has a bachelor’s degree in speech from California State University, Chico and a master’s degree in speech pathology and audiology from the University of Oregon. She is licensed in the State of California to provide private speech therapy and has a California certificate entitling her to work in public schools. She also has national certification through the American Speech and Hearing Association. In short, Ms. Bucher was well-qualified to speak to STUDENT’s educational needs.
Ms. Bucher testified credibly about STUDENT’s potential success with one-on-one intense speech sessions one time a week, which included his paraeducator taking notes, working on the lessons at home, and a modification of the speech techniques used during his sessions and at home. New techniques and structure were offered to ensure that STUDENT could successfully work on his speech goals both during the speech session and outside the speech room.
The Hearing Officer therefore concludes one forty-minute session each week and the use of oral motor programming and auditory bombardment techniques has met STUDENT’s unique speech needs and provided him with educational benefit.
(c) Deleting elective band class from STUDENT’s IEP document?
Petitioner contends that the District is attempting to exclude him from participating in the elective band class because he has a disability and learns differently within the regular classroom. Petitioner argues that the fact that he learns differently does not justify his exclusion from the elective band class. (Pet.’s closing brief.) The District, on the other hand, argues that there is no evidence that STUDENT is benefitting from the band class or that he specifically needs the band class to receive educational benefit. According to the District, there are other elective classes that may provide STUDENT with a better fit and allow him to feel successful in that environment. (Resp.’s closing brief.)
In considering whether the regular education elective band class is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, the Hearing Officer considered STUDENT’s current educational needs and the testimony of the band class instructor, STUDENT’s paraeducator, and those who have observed STUDENT in the band class. The Hearing Officer found no evidence that identified STUDENT as having any specific musical need that could only be addressed in the beginning band class. Although there was evidence that STUDENT enjoyed the band class and that the ability to hear music and touch and play the instruments could be beneficial to him, the evidence did not establish that STUDENT specifically required enrollment in the band class to meet any of his educational needs.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District is not obligated to include the elective band class in STUDENT’s IEP. However, the evidence did establish that STUDENT needs to work on developing social skills and peer interaction skills, and that he needed more practice working with groups. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District IEP team must build into STUDENT’s program opportunities for him to associate with other typically developing peers. Although there is no specific need for STUDENT to be enrolled in the beginning band class and therefore, no authority for the Hearing Officer to award the band class per se, STUDENT does require at least two elective classes (the amount previously recommended in his November 2001 IEP) that will address his needs in the areas of social skills, peer interaction skills, and working with groups.
*** In conclusion, the District’s overall program as contained in the IEP dated November 27, 2001, did not deny STUDENT a FAPE, except to the extent that it should have provided for immediate consultation by the inclusion specialist with STUDENT’s service providers regarding modifications and ideas on how to more successfully include STUDENT in nonacademic activities, and for STUDENT’s one-to-one paraeducator to be further trained in assisting STUDENT with the corrective reading program so that STUDENT can access the corrective reading portion of the class to the fullest extent possible.
Additionally, although the District is not required to place STUDENT in the beginning band class in order to provide him with a FAPE, the District IEP team must write into the IEP document that STUDENT is entitled to participate in two general education elective classes that are directed toward addressing his needs in the areas of social skills, peer interaction skills, and working with groups. Such a program would be designed to meet his unique educational needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit.
ORDER
1. The District shall maintain STUDENT’s placement in Ms. Wilcox’s SDC at Wilson Middle School for the 2001-2002 school year.
2. The inclusion specialist assigned to STUDENT shall immediately consult with STUDENT’s service providers regarding modifications and ideas on how to more successfully include STUDENT in nonacademic activities.
3. The District shall provide STUDENT’s one-to-one paraeducator with appropriate training in the corrective reading technique so as to assist STUDENT with that portion of his current program.
4. The District shall conduct an IEP meeting and modify STUDENT’s IEP to reflect the following:
a. the provision of speech and language services one time each week for forty minutes as proposed by the District on the IEP dated November 27, 2001.
b. STUDENT’s enrollment in two elective general education classes that address his needs in the areas of social skills, peer interaction skills, and working with groups.
5. All of Petitioner’s remaining claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement.
1. Did the District’s educational program fail to conform to STUDENT’s last agreed-upon and implemented IEP dated November 29, 2000, with regard to (a) the provision of adaptive physical education (APE) services during the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years, (b) the provision of inclusion specialist services during the 2001-2002 school year, and (c) the provision of speech services during the 2001-2002 school year?
The District prevailed on this issue with regard to subissues (a) and (b). Petitioner prevailed on this issue with regard to subissue (c).
2. If the District’s educational program failed to conform to STUDENT’s last agreed upon and implemented IEP, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education in the areas of APE, inclusion specialist services, and speech?
The District prevailed on this issue.
3. Did the District satisfy special education law by excluding from STUDENT’s IEP document a written statement that a substitute shall be provided for his one-to-one paraeducator when the paraeducator is absent?
The District prevailed on this issue.
4. Pursuant to the IEP dated November 27, 2001, did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education by (a) placing him in a special day class at Wilson Middle School, (b) changing his speech and language services, and (c) deleting elective band class from his IEP document?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue with regard to subissue (a). The District prevailed on this issue with regard to subissues (b) and (c).
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (California Education Code § 56505(i).)
Dated: March 13, 2002 __________________________________ Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. Normally, the Respondent does not raise issues, absent a cross-filing. However, in this case, the parties agreed to the addition of issues with respect to speech and the appropriateness of STUDENT’s placement in the District’s special day class at Wilson. The hearing process is designed to resolve issues in a comprehensive and expedient manner. Therefore, the Hearing Officer’s consideration of these two new issues raised by Petitioner and Respondent is appropriate in the interest of judicial economy. 2. The parents argued that the copy of the November 2001 IEP document provided to them at the IEP team meeting did not include additional paraeducator support or inclusion specialist support. (See Pet.’s Exh. B, pg. 1.) However, the District presented as part of its exhibit packet its version of the same IEP, which included paraeducator support. (See Resp.’s Exh. 4, pg. 1.) The parties discussed these discrepancies in the IEP documents off the record and outside the presence of the Hearing Officer. On January 9, 2002, at the hearing, the parties indicated they had reached an agreement that STUDENT’s IEP for the current school year would include one-to-one paraeducator support six hours per day and inclusion specialist support two times a month. Therefore, these issues were resolved by the parties. 3. Petitioner originally raised two other issues, one regarding a notation on the IEP document that STUDENT be excluded from SAT 9 testing, and the other regarding continuation of STUDENT’s work as a library aide. However, during the hearing, the parties indicated to the Hearing Officer that they had resolved the issue regarding the SAT 9 testing, and neither party addressed the continuation of STUDENT’s work as a library aide. Therefore, these issues need not be addressed by the Hearing Officer. 4. Mr. Wyllie testified that he received a bachelor of science degree in physical education. He is also a credentialed APE specialist. Mr. Wyllie also testified that he has previously worked with students with down syndrome and mental retardation. 5. As discussed earlier, although the parties had different versions of the November 27, 2001 IEP document, the parties agreed at hearing that the District would provide the related services of a paraeducator and an inclusion specialist. 6. Ms. Gilbert testified that she has a bachelor’s degree in English and Spanish from the University of Illinois and two master’s degrees - one in education administration form California State University, Northridge, and the other in special education from California Lutheran College. Ms. Gilbert also has a doctoral degree in institutional management from Pepperdine University. (See also Resp.’s Exh. 22.) She is currently a program specialist in special education for the District. 7. Ms. Kelly testified that she has a bachelor’s degree in music from California State University, San Bernardino and a master’s degree in special education from the same university. Currently, she is employed by the District as a program specialist, a position she has been in for the last six years. Although Ms. Kelly had observed STUDENT during the 1999-2000 school year, she had not observed him during the 2000-2001 or 2001-2002 school years. Ms. Kelly testified that she did not know the current level of STUDENT’s skills. (See also Resp.’s Exh. 21.) 8. Ms. LaLonde-Berg testified that she has a bachelors of science degree in human biology and behavior and a master’s degree in education administration from California State University, San Bernardino. She has been an inclusion specialist with the District since September. Ms. LaLonde-Berg also testified that she has taught in county programs for approximately sixteen years, both in northern California and in Riverside county. (See also Resp.’s Exh. 19. 9. While the District questions the appropriateness of STUDENT’s current placement in Ms. Wilcox’s class where his curriculum is mostly different from those of the other students in the class, the Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT’s program in Ms. Wilcox’s class is not unlike the generally described program in the county trainable mentally handicapped special day class, which the District asserts is “more appropriate” for him. 10. Ms. Wilcox testified that she received a bachelor of arts degree in liberal studies iwth an emphasis in psychology and special education from California State University, San Bernardino (CSUSB) in 1997. She is currently working on a master’s degree in special education CSUSB. Ms. Wilcox also has a special education credential for mild to moderate disabilities and has worked in the education field since 1985. (See also Resp.’s Exh. 20.) 11. Oral motor programming involves training the tongue and lips to be used in a certain manner. Auditory bombardment involves bombarding the auditory system with the sound one is trying to imitate. You bombard the system by repeating the sound - usually using a tape recorder with headphones to repeat different words. (Testimony of Nancy Bucher.)
