California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 8, 2003

Student v. San Leandro Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 271-03 · Hearing Officer Deborah M. Cooke

San Leandro Unified must add one-to-one tutorial help and supervised glucose testing; parent's private school request denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 2 of 7 issues (2 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. The decision mentions a parent compliance complaint filed with the California Department of Education on February 5, 2003, with no response in evidence.

Summary

A ninth grader at San Leandro High School, eligible for special education with a specific learning disability, filed for due process through a parent advocate. He also has diabetes, which caused frequent absences and missed work. He challenged his 2002-2003 program and asked for placement at Straunella Academy, a small private school.

Hearing Officer Deborah M. Cooke found that the mother took part in drafting IEP goals. Preparing draft goals ahead of time did not shut her out. The District failed to send the weekly progress reports the December 2002 IEP required. The Hearing Officer called this a procedural violation that did not deny a free appropriate public education (FAPE) and noted the District had offered a fix. No goals tied to specific mainstream classes were needed.

The student did not need one-to-one help in every class. He did need one-to-one instruction in his resource tutorial, including staff who gather and explain his missed work. The District's home instruction offer was appropriate: one hour per day missed after three straight sick days, plus summer sessions. Three hours a day was not required. The nursing offer was largely appropriate and no on-site nurse was needed. However, trained staff must always supervise his blood glucose testing.

The District's resource program, with these additions, was the least restrictive appropriate placement. The District was ordered to implement its IEP and offer with these amendments.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO handled a student with a learning disability whose health-related absences caused missed work. The Hearing Officer rejected a private school placement. Instead, she ordered targeted one-to-one tutorial support, coordination of make-up work and supervised glucose testing. She also held that a missed progress-report requirement was a procedural violation without denial of FAPE.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1. Did the District fail to allow the parent to participate in drafting the goals and objectives for the October 2002 and December 2002 IEP meetings and for the February 24, 2003 offer letter?

    Drafting proposed goals before the meetings did not block parent participation; the mother attended, voiced her concerns, the concerns were added to the IEPs, she signed agreeing to the December goals, and the District offered to reconvene the IEP team after its February letter.

  2. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEImplementation

    Issue 2. Did the District fail to provide the parent with weekly progress reports pursuant to the December 16, 2002 IEP?

    The District did not send the weekly progress reports the IEP required. This was a procedural violation, but it caused no shown harm and did not seriously infringe on parent participation, and the District offered a fix.

  3. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 3.i. Did the District fail to offer and/or provide a program, including the placement, which meets STUDENT's needs for the 2002-2003 school year with respect to goals and objectives for mainstream classes?

    IEP goals address the student's needs, not specific class content. The reading, writing and math goals and the accommodations were carried out in his general education classes, so no class-specific goals were needed.

  4. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3.ii. Did the District fail to offer and/or provide a program, including the placement, which meets STUDENT's needs for the 2002-2003 school year with respect to one-to-one instructional support for all classes?

    The student did not need one-to-one help in all classes. He did need one-to-one instruction in his resource tutorial, plus staff to gather and explain missed make-up work, which the District's offer did not cover.

  5. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3.iii. Did the District fail to offer and/or provide a program, including the placement, which meets STUDENT's needs for the 2002-2003 school year with respect to home instruction?

    The District's offer was appropriate: one hour of one-to-one home instruction per day missed after three straight sick days, plus summer one-to-one sessions, along with tutorial and progress reports. No evidence supported three hours a day from the first absence. The case manager must coordinate home instruction and send work home.

  6. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3.iv. Did the District fail to offer and/or provide a program, including the placement, which meets STUDENT's needs for the 2002-2003 school year with respect to nursing support services?

    No on-site nurse was needed, and the offer of a registered or licensed vocational nurse within one hour to give injections was appropriate. However, trained staff must always be present when the student tests his blood glucose, and the offer's protocol and ketone wording must be clarified.

  7. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 3 (placement). Did the District fail to offer and/or provide a program, including the placement, which meets STUDENT's needs for the 2002-2003 school year (placement at Straunella Academy versus District resource program)?

    With the ordered additions, the District's resource math, English and tutorial placement, plus home instruction, met the student's needs in the least restrictive environment. The parent's requested private school with six students was not required.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to provide or change services. District shall implement the December 16, 2002 IEP and its February 24, 2003 offer letter, with the amendments ordered.
  • Order to provide or change services. IEP must specify one-to-one instruction by District staff during the resource tutorial class to organize the student's work, explain missed assignments and answer content questions. A District staff person must obtain and compile make-up assignments for all classes, determine what the student needs to pass, and help him complete the make-up work in tutorial.
  • Order to provide or change services. The student's case manager is responsible for coordinating home instruction and sending his work home, in consultation with the mother, who will judge whether he is medically able to take part in home instruction.
  • Order to provide or change services. Designated trained school staff must always be present in the special education staff room to monitor the student's blood glucose testing and recording, and to help with appropriate procedures for low or high readings.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23; Bend-Lapine School District v. D.W.

People named in the decision

  • Deidre Lasher, director of special services, San Leandro Unified School District
  • Katherine Piccus, behavior specialist; District representative at hearing, San Leandro Unified School District
  • Cleo Simon, parent advocate for Student
  • David Phillips-Kerley, physical education teacher, Bancroft Middle School
  • Susan Blevins, school nurse (RN), San Leandro Unified School District
  • Margaret Kato, school nurse, San Leandro Unified School District
  • Bruce Clement, math teacher, San Leandro High School
  • Daniel Weber, general education English/creative writing teacher, San Leandro High School
  • Edward Poshkus, resource math teacher, San Leandro High School
  • Julie Nicholas, science and AVID teacher, San Leandro High School
  • Lynn Isola, resource English and tutorial teacher, San Leandro High School
  • Jennifer Riester, resource specialist teacher, San Leandro High School
  • Diana Godet, counselor, San Leandro High School
  • Robert Williams, vice principal, Bancroft Middle School
  • Diane Emberlin, assistant director and chief financial officer, Straunella Academy (private school)
  • Anita Schriver, resource specialist teacher; former case manager, Bancroft Middle School
  • Suruchi Bhatia, attending physician; Student's physician, Children's Hospital, Oakland
  • Gretchen Romani, resource specialist; Student's case manager, San Leandro High School
  • Donna VanValer, program specialist, San Leandro Unified School District
  • Aulani Cler, food services director, San Leandro Unified School District
  • Mamatha Moorthy, school psychologist (triennial assessment), San Leandro Unified School District
  • Ms. Richardson, resource math teacher, San Leandro High School
  • Alameda Behavioral Health Care Services, county mental health agency (referral for counseling assessment)

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in San Diego, California, on March 6, 7, 11, 12, and 13, 2003.

STUDENT (hereafter, Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by parent advocate Cleo Simon. Also present on behalf of Petitioner was his mother, MOTHER. San Leandro Unified School District (hereafter, Respondent or District) was represented at the hearing by behavior specialist Katherine Piccus. Also present on behalf of the District was Deidre Lasher, director of special services.

The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: STUDENT; David Phillips-Kerley, physical education teacher at Bancroft Middle School (Bancroft); Susan Blevins, District school nurse; Margaret Kato, District school nurse; Bruce Clement, math teacher at San Leandro High School (SLHS); Daniel Weber, English teacher at SLHS; Edward Poshkus, resource math teacher at SLHS; Julie Nicholas, science and AVID teacher at SLHS; Lynn Isola, resource English and tutorial teacher at SLHS; Jennifer Riester, resource specialist teacher at SLHS; Diana Godet, counselor at SLHS; Robert Williams, vice principal at Bancroft; Diane Emberlin, assistant director and chief financial officer at Straunella Academy; Anita Schriver, resource specialist teacher at Bancroft; Suruchi Bhatia, attending physician at Children’s Hospital in Oakland, CA; Gretchen Romani, resource specialist and STUDENT’s case manager at SLHS; Deidre Lasher; and MOTHER.

The following witnesses were called by Respondent to testify: Donna VanValer, program specialist for the District; Aulani Cler, food services director for the District; and Mamatha Moorthy, school psychologist for the District.

ISSUES(Footnote 1)

1. Did the District fail to allow the parent to participate in drafting the goals and objectives for the October 2002 and December 2002 IEP meetings and for the February 24, 2003 offer letter?

2. Did the District fail to provide the parent with weekly progress reports pursuant to the December 16, 2002 IEP?

3. Did the District fail to offer and/or provide a program, including the placement, which meets STUDENT’s needs for the 2002-2003 school year with respect to:

i. goals and objectives for mainstream classes;

ii. one-to-one instructional support for all classes;

iii. home instruction; and iv. nursing support services?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner makes a number of procedural and substantive allegations that he believes amounted to a denial of a FAPE. Procedurally, Petitioner contends that his parent was not allowed to provide her input on the development of goals and objectives in the October 10, 2002 and December 16, 2002 IEPs and in the District’s offer letter dated February 24, 2003. Petitioner also contends that the District failed to conform his program to his December 2002 IEP by not providing his parent with weekly progress reports.

Substantively, Petitioner alleges that he required specific goals and objectives for his mainstream classes, specifically, his science and creative writing classes, and that he requires one-to-one instructional support most of the time in all of his classes. Additionally, Petitioner contends that his educational and health needs require the District to provide him three hours of home instruction for each day that he is absent (starting from the first day that he is sick) so that he can make up the work he missed at school. To accommodate his health needs, Petitioner contends that he requires nursing services as a related service in his IEP in order to benefit from his education and increase his school attendance. Lastly, Petitioner alleges that the District does not have a placement to meet his needs and, therefore, he should be placed in a nonpublic school, namely Straunella Academy. As a result of the District’s alleged failure to meet his educational needs, Petitioner contends that he did not make meaningful academic progress during the 2002-2003 school year.

The District contends that it has provided and can continue to provide STUDENT a FAPE that addresses his needs, both educationally and medically. According to the District, the services and modifications included in the formal written offer dated February 24, 2003, presented to Petitioner’s mother, together with the December 16, 2002 IEP, address STUDENT’s unique needs and are reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to STUDENT. The District argues that goals were crafted to address STUDENT’s needs and the District offered to continue his enrollment in resource English and math classes, with small-group tutorial ninety minutes daily and the availability of home instruction both during the school year and during the summer, if needed. Additionally, the District contends that staff-supervised weekly progress reports would assist in addressing the impact of absences and missed assignments. And finally, in order to assist STUDENT in the regulation of his diabetic condition, the District contends that it offered extensive direct health care and trained supervision of his health needs. The District contends that it has provided for his medical needs by following orders specified by STUDENT’s doctor on his individual school healthcare plan (ISHP).

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a fourteen-year-old student who is a resident of the San Leandro Unified School District. He currently attends ninth grade at San Leandro High School (SLHS) and is placed in the resource specialist program for English and math and previously received support in all his classes through the resource tutorial program. STUDENT became eligible for special education and related services as a student with a specific learning disability when he was in the sixth grade, on the basis of a discrepancy between intellectual ability and his level of academic achievement in the areas of mathematics calculation and written expression. Additionally, weak auditory processing and visual processing, as well as weak attention skills and visual motor impairment were also noted in the first psychoeducational study.

STUDENT also has type 1 diabetes and hyperthyroidism and, according to his individualized school healthcare plan (ISHP), his condition requires that he test his blood glucose levels daily before meals while at school and treat his condition depending on the testing results. At school, STUDENT tests his blood glucose level himself in the special education office where his testing supplies and snacks are kept and keeps a record of his testing results. He is not escorted to the special education room and, according to STUDENT, whomever is in the special education office will assist him if necessary. STUDENT often experiences both high and low blood glucose level fluctuations. STUDENT’s diabetes can also cause him to feel fatigued, and if his blood glucose level is extremely low, he may become aggressive and combative and may require a snack or juice. STUDENT also needs to test his blood glucose levels if he is not feeling well. When his blood glucose level is high, STUDENT becomes dehydrated and has to use the bathroom often in order to flush out the ketones in his system. To treat his high blood glucose level at school, STUDENT will drink some water and stay in the special education office for a while. In some cases, when his blood glucose level is high, he may require an insulin injection. According to STUDENT, his condition also affects his concentration at school. Additionally, certain foods can alter his blood glucose levels to his detriment and, therefore, STUDENT’s diet is restricted according to his condition. At home, STUDENT injects insulin into himself in the morning, at dinner, and before he goes to sleep at night. He has done this since he was six years old.

Prior to his current ninth-grade school year, STUDENT attended Bancroft Middle School (Bancroft) in the District. When STUDENT started seventh grade, he was placed in the resource specialist program for English and math and made remarkable improvement in his attitude and his academics. Because of this improvement, during his eighth-grade year at Bancroft the amount of time STUDENT spent in special education was reduced. STUDENT was placed in mainstream classes and only received support in those classes from the resource specialist program (RSP) staff who went into his classes and provided assistance to him. By the end of his eighth-grade year, STUDENT was passing all of his classes, except for physical education and science. (Pet.’s Exh. K-11b.) According to Anita Schriver, resource specialist and STUDENT’s case manager during junior high school, the IEP team believed that STUDENT had made enough progress and had solid enough skills to warrant less special education upon his entrance into high school. Therefore, for the first part of his ninth-grade year at SLHS, the IEP team placed STUDENT in regular education classes and provided him RSP tutorial assistance to help him complete homework assignments and to help him with difficult classes.

An IEP meeting was held on October 10, 2002, which STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, attended. During that meeting, the IEP team discussed STUDENT’s difficulty in his regular education math class where he was receiving an “F” grade and decided to move him into a resource math class where later he improved his grade to a “B-.” Additionally, pursuant to MOTHER’s request, STUDENT’s resource tutorial class was switched from the morning time slot to the afternoon time slot because MOTHER believed that STUDENT should have tutorial assistance after he had already been to his core classes for the day. Although MOTHER agreed to STUDENT’s class schedule changes, she did not sign the October 2002 IEP document because she did not feel satisfied with what the District offered and wanted STUDENT to be tested again to determine his present levels of performance. Ms. Romani informed MOTHER that testing STUDENT’s academic performance at that time would be premature because he had just been tested in May 2002. Accordingly, further testing was delayed until December 2002.

In December 2002, school psychologist Mamatha Moorthy conducted a triennial assessment of STUDENT’s special education needs and services. Additionally, on December 10 and 11, 2002, Gretchen Romani, STUDENT’s current RSP case manager, gave STUDENT the Woodcock-Johnson psychoeducational battery-revised test to determine his academic performance levels. On December 16, 2002, another IEP team meeting was held to discuss STUDENT’s lack of success in general education English and to address changing that class due to the increased student to teacher ratio for the forthcoming term.

During the December 16, 2002 IEP meeting, MOTHER presented her concerns in writing, which were attached to the IEP document. Essentially, MOTHER had concerns about the size of STUDENT’s classes and suggested that STUDENT be placed in classes with a smaller student to teacher ratio so that he could have more individual attention. Additionally, MOTHER expressed that STUDENT’s doctor thought it would be beneficial to monitor STUDENT’s blood glucose levels from school, which would require before and after lunch testing of his blood glucose levels and the administration of insulin when needed. MOTHER also indicated that STUDENT required school health care services provided by a qualified school nurse or other qualified person. (Dist.’s Exh. 15, pg. 40.) MOTHER signed the December 2002 IEP, but agreed only to the eligibility designation and the goals and objectives. She did not agree to implement the program placement and services.

Although STUDENT wanted to remain in a regular education English class, ultimately, in January 2003, MOTHER wrote the District and requested that STUDENT be placed in the resource specialist program for both math and English. His class schedule was adjusted accordingly. Additionally, STUDENT’s resource math class was changed this term to a different teacher who uses a more one-on-one personal approach than his previous resource math teacher.

STUDENT has missed a considerable amount of school during the 2002-2003 school year due to his health and is currently behind in all of his classes. Since the beginning of the school year, STUDENT has been absent for one full week because he and his family went on a cruise and has missed school on other numerous occasions due to illness. (Dist.’s Exh. 79.) Since January 27, 2003, however, there has been a marked increase in the number of his absences and according to MOTHER, the absences were due to STUDENT feeling sick and stressed from what Petitioner believes is harassment by the District, which has caused STUDENT not to want to attend school. Additionally, STUDENT was recently diagnosed with irritable bowel disease.

On February 11, 2003, the Hearing Office received Petitioner’s request for a due process hearing. Because the parties had not come to an agreement during the December 2002 IEP meeting about STUDENT’s program, the District prepared and hand-delivered to the parent a written offer of placement and services based upon its investigation into STUDENT’s progress and discussion with his teachers and the District participants in the December 16, 2002 IEP meeting. In that letter dated February 24, 2003, the District also suggested that they reconvene an IEP team meeting with the parent so that the parties could discuss the District’s offer and further address MOTHER’s questions or concerns about the offer. MOTHER did not respond to Ms. Lasher’s letter.

The parties were unable to resolve their disputes, and this case went to hearing on March 6, 2003, over the above-listed issues.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. ' 1400; Cal. Educ. Code ' 56000.) The term Afree appropriate public education@ means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State’s educational standards, and that conform to the student=s individualized educational program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. ' 1401(a)(18).)

ASpecial education@ is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. (20 U.S.C. ' 1401(25).) The term Arelated services@ includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. ' 1401(22).) California Education Code section 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California=s term for related services, shall be provided Awhen the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.@

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA (now IDEA >97). The Court determined that a student=s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. (Id. at 200.) According to Rowley, the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available, or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student=s abilities. (Id. at 198-200.) The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a Abasic floor of opportunity@ that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Id. at 201.)

To determine whether the District provided STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE), one must focus on the adequacy of the District=s program. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).) If the District=s program reflected STUDENT=s needs, provided some benefit, and comported with his IEP, the District provided a FAPE, even if the parent preferred another program and even if the parent=s preferred program would have resulted in greater educational benefit. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.) Special education law also requires that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment, which, in this case, means ensuring that STUDENT=s education is provided in a manner that promotes his maximum interaction with children or youth who are not disabled, and which is appropriate to the needs of both. (20 U.S.C. '' 1412(a)(5)(A) and 1414(d)(1)(A)(iii)(III); Educ. Code ' 56031.)

To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District=s program must have met the following four requirements in order to have constituted a substantively appropriate educational program: (1) been designed to meet STUDENT=s unique needs, (2) been reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, (3) comported with his IEP, and (4) been provided in the least restrictive environment.

The analysis of whether a student has been provided a free appropriate public education (FAPE) is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to decide whether procedural steps have been followed and whether the proposed program and placement are substantively appropriate. (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 206-207.)

Procedural Appropriateness

Petitioner contends that the District committed procedural violations that resulted in his parent not being able to participate in the IEP process and the District’s program not comporting with his IEP.

Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE. However, procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent=s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of FAPE. (W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1484.)

Petitioner asserts two procedural violations, each of which will be addressed separately below. 1. Did the District fail to allow the parent to participate in drafting the goals and objectives for the October 2002 and December 2002 IEP meetings and for the February 24, 2003 offer letter?

Petitioner contends that his parent was not given the opportunity to participate in drafting the goals and objectives included in the October and December 2002 IEPs and in the February 24, 2003 offer letter. Specifically, Petitioner alleges that the District drafted the goals and objectives before it came to the October and December 2002 IEP team meetings and then merely presented these to the parent. The Petitioner makes the same allegation with respect to the February 24, 2003 offer letter, stating that the offer letter was drafted by the District and then merely presented to the parent.

The District argues that at both the October and December 2002 IEP meetings, the parent was presented, not with final goals and objectives, but with a draft of proposed goals and objectives which had been prepared by the District based on a review of the records as well as on discussions with the parent. The District contends that at the October 2002 IEP meeting, the parent expressed her concerns about STUDENT’s difficulties and the parties agreed to conduct an assessment. Furthermore, at the December 2002 IEP meeting, the parties discussed the goals and objectives, revised them accordingly, and the mother signed the December 2002 IEP document indicating her agreement with the goals and objectives and STUDENT’s eligibility. As for the February 24, 2003 offer letter, the District contends that it proposed the continuation of goals that had already been approved by MOTHER in the December 16, 2002 IEP. Moreover, when it presented the offer, it proposed to convene an IEP meeting to discuss the offer and address any concerns or suggestions that the parent may have had.

October 10, 2002 and December 16, 2002 IEP meetings

Both State and federal special education law require a district to take steps to ensure that one or both of the parents of a child with a disability are present at each IEP meeting or are afforded the opportunity to participate. (34 C.F.R. §300.345; Ca. Educ. Code §56341.5.) In addition, when developing a student’s IEP, the IEP team must consider the strengths of the child and the concerns of the parents for enhancing the education of their child. (34 C.F.R. §300.346; Ca. Educ. Code §56341.1(1).)

It was uncontroverted that the IEP meetings were properly noticed and that the parent was present at both the October and December 2002 IEP meetings. Although MOTHER did not sign the October 2002 IEP, the evidence shows that during the four-hour meeting, she did express her concerns about STUDENT. (Pet.’s Exh. A-13.) MOTHER testified that she fully explained all the issues she believed STUDENT had, including his excessive talking, his frequent trips to the bathroom and to get drinks of water, his lack of focus and attention, and his failure to complete his work and homework. No agreement was reached. MOTHER wanted further testing, and the meeting was continued.

When the IEP team met again in December 2002, the goals and objectives were slightly revised to reflect more specifically STUDENT’s needs pursuant to the recent assessment results. The District was also prepared to revise the goals again after discussing them with MOTHER. Ms. Romani, STUDENT’s case manager, testified that she brought blank IEP pages to the IEP meeting and that MOTHER’s concerns were discussed again and noted on the IEP document in the comments section and the parent concerns section. (See Pet.’s Exh. B-5, B-7, & B-11.) MOTHER also wrote out her concerns on a piece of paper that was attached to the December 2002 IEP as an addendum. (Dist.’s Exh. 15, pg. 40) However, MOTHER testified that she wanted her goals for STUDENT to be set forth in the goals section of the IEP, not as an addendum.

A review of MOTHER’s concerns indicates that although she described them as goals, her concerns were really the areas in which she believed STUDENT had special needs. For example, MOTHER was concerned about STUDENT’s organizational skills, work pace, attention, reading, math, and spelling. She believed he needed individualized instruction and smaller classes. She was also concerned about specific teaching methods. (Dist.’s Exh. 15, pg. 40.) Because the parent’s concerns were really related to the class environment and the teaching methods that would be used, the IEP team addressed the concerns in the accommodations and modification sections of the IEPs. (Dist.’s Exh. 15, pg. 38 & Exh. 21, pg. 64.) MOTHER testified that she and the other IEP team members did discuss the proposed goals. She also acknowledged that she may not have completely understood how the goals and objectives section of the IEP was to be completed, but believed that specific teaching methods should have been described in that section. She also expressed her disappointment with what she believed was the repetition of STUDENT’s goals without substantial change from one IEP to the next.

The Hearing Officer finds that the evidence did not support the allegation that the IEP goals and objectives were written without parent participation. Proposed goals and objectives were drafted prior to the scheduled IEP meetings, blank IEP pages were brought to the meetings, and the parent was then given the opportunity at the IEP meetings to participate in writing the final version. (Testimonies of G. Romani, D. Lasher, and D. Godet.) The District’s preparation of proposed goals and objectives before the IEP meeting did not infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process, but rather streamlined the IEP process. The final goals included in the December 16, 2002 IEP addressed STUDENT’s difficulties in reading, writing, math calculation, behavior, and study skills, and MOTHER signed that IEP indicating her agreement with the goals and objectives. The parent was given an opportunity to ask questions and participate in formulating the IEPs. The parent’s “goals,” which were really concerns that she had with how STUDENT would be taught and the type of class setting he needed, were considered during the IEP meeting and adequately reflected in various sections of both the October and December 2002 IEPs and also incorporated into an addendum to the IEP dated December 16, 2002, which the mother signed. Accordingly, the evidence demonstrates that STUDENT’s parent was involved in both the October and December 2002 IEP processes and therefore, there was no procedural error in this regard.

With respect to Ms. MOTHERS’ contentions that the goals lacked specificity as to methods of implementation, the Hearing Officer notes that there is no requirement that goals include methodology. In addition, methodology is typically left to the discretion of the District. (See e.g., Bend-Lapine School District v. DW, 28 IDELR 734 (9th Cir. 1998.) The Hearing Officer finds that the IEP properly included adaptations and modifications that would be provided to the student to meet his unique needs and that the goals and objectives were properly written. The Hearing Officer also finds the allegation that the goals were repeated from one IEP to the next to be unsupported by the evidence. According to the documentary evidence, the goals were changed from the October 2002 IEP to the December 2002 IEP to reflect, with more specificity, STUDENT’s needs pursuant to assessment results. (See Pet.’s Exhs. C-8, C-9, B-8, B-8A.)

February 24, 2003 offer letter

Because a full agreement was not reached at the December 16, 2002 IEP meeting, the District made a separate offer to the parent. Deidre Lasher testified that she personally delivered to STUDENT’s mother the District’s offer letter dated February 24, 2003. According to Ms. Lasher, she investigated STUDENT’s history and reviewed his past IEPs in developing an offer. Ms. Lasher testified that MOTHER had previously agreed to the goals and objectives from the December 16, 2002 IEP, those same goals were included in the February 2003 offer, but were further modified in order to reflect measurability.(Footnote 2) (Dist.’s Exh. 1, pg. 1.)

MOTHER rejected the District’s offer and did not respond to the District’s February 24, 2003 letter requesting that they convene an IEP meeting because she believed the offer was not what STUDENT needed. MOTHER also stated, however, that she realized that the District is required to convene an IEP team meeting.

Federal law requires that a district provide the parent with prior written notice a reasonable time before the district proposes to change the educational placement of a child or the provision of FAPE to a child. (34 C.F.R. §300.503.) Because the District’s February 24, 2003 offer letter included a proposal to change STUDENT’s program, the District was required to provide the parent with reasonable prior notice, and it did. Moreover, the District offered to reconvene an IEP team meeting with MOTHER present so that both parties could discuss the District’s offer contained in the letter and its appropriateness for STUDENT, and further address MOTHER’s questions and concerns about its offer. (Dist.’s Exh. 1, pg. 4.)

Based on the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the February 24, 2003 offer was the summation of the issues that the parties had previously discussed at both the October and December 2002 IEP meetings. In addition, the District provided the parent with an opportunity to participate in drafting goals and objectives when it offered in the February 24, 2003 letter to reconvene an IEP team meeting with the parent present to discuss its offer and further address the parent’s concerns.

2. Did the District fail to provide the parent with weekly progress reports pursuant to the December 16, 2002 IEP?

Petitioner alleges that the District’s program did not comport with his IEP because it failed to provide his parent with the weekly progress reports pursuant to the December 16, 2002 IEP.

The evidence showed that the District was required to provide STUDENT’s parent with weekly progress reports and the testimony demonstrated that the District failed to implement the December 2002 IEP in this respect. A study skills goal in STUDENT’s partially agreed-upon December 16, 2002 IEP requires the RSP and general education staff to keep the parent informed through weekly progress reports. (Dist.’s Exh. 15, pg. 37.)(Footnote 3) Several District witnesses testified that weekly progress reports were not sent home to STUDENT’s parent because STUDENT never obtained the blank forms from his counselor and brought them to his teachers. (Testimonies of G. Romani, E. Poshkus, L. Isola, and J. Riester.) Additionally, STUDENT was not informed that he needed to obtain and deliver the progress reports and consequently, implementation of that goal was not carried out due to a misunderstanding on who was to do what. (Testimony of G. Romani.) The District took action, however, to remedy the misunderstanding by including a provision in its February 24, 2003 offer which would require a designated instructional assistant to procure and collect the weekly progress reports from each teacher and send them home with STUDENT each Friday or deliver by facsimile, if available. (Dist.’s Exh. 1, pg. 2.)(Footnote 4)

The Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to provide the parent with the weekly progress reports pursuant to the December 16, 2002 IEP. However, there was no convincing showing of harm to STUDENT or a showing that this failure seriously infringed on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process. Therefore, although the District’s actions in this respect constituted a procedural violation, the violation did not rise to the level of a denial of FAPE and additionally, the District took action to remedy the problem.

Substantive Appropriateness

The Hearing Officer found above that the parent’s procedural allegations regarding goals and objectives really concerned the substantive appropriateness of his program. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer addresses below Petitioner’s substantive allegations regarding the appropriateness of the program offered and/or provided by the District during the 2002-2003 school year.

Under the IDEA and Rowley, the District=s program must meet the following four requirements in order to constitute a substantively appropriate educational program: (1) be designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, (2) be reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, (3) comport with his IEP, and (4) be provided in the least restrictive environment.

What are STUDENT’s needs?

To determine the appropriateness of the District’s program offered and/or provided for the 2002-2003 school year, the Hearing Officer must first identify STUDENT’s needs as of the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year.

At the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year, it was undisputed that STUDENT qualified for special education services based on his identified specific learning disability. The parties did not dispute that STUDENT had some weak processing skills, including visual motor, auditory short term memory, visual perception, and weak attention and concentration skills. (Dist.’s Exh. 28, pg. 88.) The parties agreed that, as a result of his disability, STUDENT has deficits in the areas of mathematics calculation and written expression and that he needs extra time to complete his assignments and help to stay on task. To address these deficits, the parties agreed that, for math and English classes, STUDENT needs a setting smaller than the regular education class where the instructor can provide some one-to-one and small-group instruction in order to engage him.

STUDENT also needs assistance dealing with some of the behavioral issues that he has with respect to inattention and completing his assignments. STUDENT needs program modifications and accommodations that will address his inconsistent work completion, his need for extended time to complete assignments and reduced and/or adapted assignments, and instruction that includes repetition and explanation. Finally, the parties did not dispute that STUDENT needed assistance with monitoring his blood glucose levels when testing at school.

The parties differ, however, on whether STUDENT requires specific goals and objectives for his mainstream classes, whether he requires one-to-one instructional support for all of his classes and the amount of home instruction he needs during times when he is ill. In addition, the parties dispute the level of nursing support services that STUDENT requires and the appropriate placement to meet his educational needs. The Hearing Officer addresses each of these disputed areas below.

Was the District’s program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit with respect to:

i. goals and objectives for mainstream classes

Petitioner contends that he requires specific goals and objectives with respect to his mainstream classes since they are college prep classes. Specifically, Petitioner argued that he should have had goals and objectives for his regular education creative writing and science courses in the first term of the current school year because the classes were too large and the teachers did not teach at his level. (Dist.’s Exh. 15, pg. 40.) All classes have different learning objectives and, therefore, IEP goals are tailored to address the individual’s needs, not the specific class. The necessary goals and objectives are then implemented in the relevant classes. The evidence demonstrated that STUDENT’s goals and objectives, modifications, and accommodations were implemented in his respective general education classes.

STUDENT’s needs with respect to his creative writing and science courses were addressed by including in his IEPs specific reading and writing goals and objectives to help STUDENT improve his essay writing and his use of correct conventions, to improve his word attack and identification skills. (Dist.’s Exhs. 21 and 15.) Moreover, in the offer letter dated February 24, 2003, the District further modified the December 16, 2002 IEP goals and objectives that the parties agreed upon to add benchmarks that reflected measurability. (Dist.’s Exh. 1, pg. 5.) Additionally, all of STUDENT’s IEPs since he entered high school have included various accommodations and modifications, including adaptations to his testing and assignments by providing adapted settings to complete his work (such as the private room in his creative writing class and the resource tutorial room), additional time for completion of work, and reduced or adapted assignments. His behavior was addressed by teachers providing positive reinforcement and having private discussions with him. Additionally, class instruction was adapted to repeat and explain assignments or issues to him, allow him extra time to respond, and encourage him to participate. (Dist.’s Exhs. 21, pg. 64 & 15, pg. 38; Testimonies of D. Weber & J. Nicholas.) And finally, STUDENT’s creative writing and science teachers both testified that they implemented STUDENT’s IEP modifications and accommodations and implemented his goals and objectives in their respective classes. (Testimonies of J. Nicholas & D. Weber.)(Footnote 5)

Moreover, when it became apparent that STUDENT needed more assistance, the October 10, 2002 IEP team recommended that STUDENT transfer from a general education math class to a resource math class. When it became apparent that STUDENT was struggling in the Daniel Weber’s regular education creative writing class, STUDENT’s schedule was amended to place him in the resource English class for the second term of the current school year.

The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not have a need for goals and objectives specific to the content of his mainstream classes. STUDENT’s needs with respect to his mainstream classes were appropriately addressed by successfully incorporating accommodations and modifications into his program and by implementing goals and objectives to address his specific writing, reading, and math needs. In addition, the evidence establishes that key District personnel implemented the accommodations and modifications, along with the goals and objectives, in a coordinated and collaborative manner. The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that STUDENT’s program met his unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit with respect to his mainstream classes.

ii. one-to-one instructional support

Currently, STUDENT is enrolled in RSP math and English, health and safety, and physical education. According to Petitioner, he requires one-to-one instructional support for all of his classes. The District contends that Petitioner does not require one-to-one instruction and that his current placement in resource math and English classes with the modifications listed on page 10 of the December 16, 2002 IEP is appropriate to meet his needs. The District also offered in its letter dated February 24, 2003, to provide Petitioner with ongoing tutoring for ninety minutes each school day, where the teacher-to-student ratio is, at most, one-to-three, to help Petitioner when he misses classes or if he has difficulty understanding class assignments.(Footnote 6) The tutorial would be during fourth period at the end of each school day. (Dist.’s Exh. 1.)

STUDENT’s teachers’ testimonies demonstrated that STUDENT benefits from one-to-one and small-group instruction; however, none of his teachers indicated that he needed one-to-one instruction for all of his classes, all of the time. (Testimonies of D. Weber, J. Nicholas, & L. Isola.) Rather, it became apparent through testimony and documentary evidence, that STUDENT requires some individualized attention in order to make up work, have difficult concepts repeated and explained to him, and to help him stay on task. (Testimonies of D. Weber, E. Poshkus, L. Isola, G. Romani, & J. Riester; Pet.’s Exh. C-12.) STUDENT also works well when he has the opportunity to work in a structured environment on a specific assignment with the direct assistance of an instructor when he is struggling with difficult concepts. However, he also benefits from cooperative learning environments. (Testimonies of D. Weber & J. Nicholas.) Numerous progress reports completed by STUDENT’s teachers in junior high and high school indicate that STUDENT has a history of being off task, talking in class, often needing redirection, and not finishing most assignments and homework, even when given extra time. (Pet.’s Exhs. B-19, C-12 to15, D-17 to18.)

District witnesses also generally testified that STUDENT needed encouragement and someone close by to help him with the work and “push him along.” According to Mr. Weber, one-to-one instruction can help STUDENT at times. He did not believe STUDENT needed it all the time, but it could be used appropriately as an adjunct to his regular program. According to STUDENT’s previous tutorial teachers, although he may resist at first, STUDENT will work and complete his assignments when someone is sitting next to him and when his work is put in front of him. (Testimonies of J. Riester & G. Romani.) In addition, STUDENT’s former resource math teacher, Mr. Poshkus, testified that STUDENT did well in his class of 13 to 14 students with one teacher and one instructional aide because he and the aide had the opportunity to work with him and provide him with useful study aids. STUDENT’s math grade improved in the resource math class from an “F” to a “B-.” All of STUDENT’s teachers concurred that adding a ninety-minute tutorial class to his program with some one-to-one instruction would be beneficial because STUDENT needs more focused time to do his work and apply himself. (Testimony of D. Weber, J. Riester, G. Romani, E. Poshkus, and L. Isola.)

STUDENT testified that it was difficult for him to make up work after having missed school when he was sick. STUDENT stated that he believed he had good math skills, that he is a strong reader and writer, and that if he put his mind to it, he could get better grades. However, he also testified that he believes he needs more assistance with his class work and more help in his tutorial class than what was previously provided.

The evidence showed that the District addressed STUDENT’s one-to-one and small-group instructional needs during the 2002-2003 school year, but with minor deficiency. Soon after the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year, it became clear that STUDENT needed more assistance than the accommodations and modifications that included modified assignments and extra time to complete work. In response, the October 10, 2002 IEP team addressed STUDENT’s need for classes with smaller student-to-teacher ratios by recommending that STUDENT be placed in the resource math class (where the student-to-teacher ratio was thirteen to two). After the December 16, 2002 IEP meeting, the IEP team recommended that STUDENT be placed in the resource English class (where the student-to-teacher ratio is eleven to two). The smaller student-to-teacher ratio in both the resource math and English classes has proven to be beneficial to STUDENT because he is able to receive more individualized instruction, be redirected when necessary, and receive assistance with making-up missed assignments. (Testimonies of E. Poshkus & L. Isola.) More recently, STUDENT’s schedule was amended, with MOTHER’s agreement, to move him from Mr. Poshkus’ resource math class to Ms. Richardson’s resource math class, where she uses more of a one-to-one personal teaching approach using textbook materials. (Dist.’s Exhs. 12 & 13.) Additionally, in its offer letter dated February 24, 2003, the District offered to add a ninety-minute tutorial (as opposed to a forty-five minute tutorial) to his class schedule.

Notwithstanding the above services and provisions provided and/or offered by the District, the District only partially responded to STUDENT’s need for some individualized and small-group instruction. The District has not appropriately addressed in any of the IEPs the issues of STUDENT’s not bringing his work to the tutorial class and not knowing what work needs to be completed when he returns to school after being absent. Numerous District witnesses, MOTHER, and STUDENT all testified about STUDENT’s feelings of being overwhelmed when he returns to school after days of absences due to illness and not knowing what assignments are missing and having difficulty organizing and completing outstanding assignments. (Testimonies of G. Romani, D. Weber, J. Riester, & L. Isola.) Additionally, MOTHER testified that instead of simply furnishing STUDENT with packets of missed work or requiring him to get class notes from other students, she believed the tutorial class should provide STUDENT with the missed materials as well as the necessary instruction.

Although the evidence demonstrated that STUDENT does not require one-to-one instruction for all of his classes, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs the small-group instruction provided in the resource math and English classes, which are subjects in which he has identified difficulties. In addition, because STUDENT frequently has difficulty knowing what assignments he has missing and has trouble organizing and completing his outstanding assignments, STUDENT does require one-to-one assistance, in his resource tutorial class, to help him identify and compile course work that is outstanding due to his being out of school and to help him make-up the work that he has not completed.

The Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offer with respect to one-to-one instruction was not adequate, and therefore, STUDENT’s IEP must specify that STUDENT will have District staff provide him with one-to-one instruction during his tutorial class to ensure that his work is organized, that he understands his missed assignments, and to answer questions he may have about the content of the course work. Additionally, the IEP must specify that a District staff person will obtain and compile STUDENT’s make-up assignments for all of his classes, determine what STUDENT needs to do to pass his courses, and also assist him (through discussion, repetition, and explanation) during his resource tutorial class in completing the make-up work.(Footnote 7)

iii. home instruction

The parties do not dispute that during the current school year there has been a notable increase in STUDENT’s absences due to complications with his diabetic condition and the additional health factor of hyperthyroidism. Those absences have contributed to STUDENT’s missing assignments, which has consequently caused a decline in his grades. The parties also do not dispute that STUDENT requires some home instruction as a means of addressing the impact of his increased absences and missed assignments. The parties disagree, however, with respect to the amount of home instruction STUDENT requires and when it should be provided. Petitioner contends that he requires three hours of home instruction, starting the first day that he is absent. The District, on the other hand, argues that its offer of a combination of home instruction services, both during the school year and during the summer, along with the tutorial and weekly progress reports would address the impact of absences and missed assignments. (Dist.’s closing brief, pg. 4.)

MOTHER testified that the past month has been the most extreme in terms of the number of days STUDENT has missed from school. According to MOTHER, STUDENT typically misses two to three days a month, which is why she has always requested that STUDENT’s program include a plan for when he is out sick from school. However, since January 2003, STUDENT has missed approximately three to four consecutive days per week from school. (Dist.’s Exh. 79.)

According to the District’s offer, once STUDENT has missed three consecutive school days due to illness, the District would provide him one hour of one-to-one home instruction for each of the days missed.(Footnote 8) The District also offered to provide the same one-hour per day of one-to-one instruction during the high school summer session for up to six weeks, but on the high school campus. This option would be utilized if, at the end of the second term, STUDENT still had any “incomplete” grades that had not been converted to a letter grade by that time. (Dist.’s Exh. 1, pg. 2.)(Footnote 9)

All of STUDENT’s teachers who testified indicated that STUDENT’s absences have affected his grades. (Testimonies of D. Weber, E. Poshkus, L. Isola, G. Romani, & J. Riester.) His teachers have tried implementing various accommodations and modifications such as modified coursework with extensions of time granted; however, STUDENT’s missed absences still cause him to miss coursework, which causes the teachers to either fail him or lower his grade. STUDENT’s teachers testified that the District’s offer of home instruction both during the school year and in the summer, in addition to some one-to-one or small-group instruction in resource tutorial, would be beneficial for STUDENT given his excessive absences due to illness and his difficulty with making up missed assignments. (Testimonies of D. Weber, L. Isola, & G. Romani.) The home instruction and tutorial would provide him the opportunity to work closely with the instructor to make up missed assignments after he has been out ill.

Providing home instruction to STUDENT while he is sick would not necessarily benefit him; however, providing it one hour per day when he is feeling better, along with the other offered services, would be appropriate. (Testimony of D. Lasher.) Therefore, according to the District, the home instruction, plus the tutorial and weekly progress reports, would improve his chances for work completion. However, on some days, STUDENT’s health would permit him to do work at home and on other days it would not. Therefore, MOTHER believed that if STUDENT missed class due to illness, the District staff should collect his work and give it to him before he returns to school and also modify his grades. MOTHER testified that the District could fax STUDENT’s work to him under those circumstances, so long as it was not new material with which he would need assistance. Previously, some of STUDENT’s teachers were putting assignment packets together for him and providing them to the tutorial instructors. However, STUDENT did not receive that information until he returned to school. Under those circumstances, STUDENT becomes overwhelmed and then has difficulty completing the outstanding assignments. (Testimony of G. Romani & MOTHER.)

If STUDENT is not able to receive home instruction (at home) due to his health, then STUDENT would require some one-to-one assistance in his resource tutorial class, or one-to-one “home instruction” at school or another public location, as offered by the District, to help him understand any new course work and help him get caught up on any missing assignments.

The Hearing Officer finds that since STUDENT’s health-related issues have caused him to miss more school recently (since January 27, 2003) than he has in the past, it was appropriate for the District to offer home instruction in its offer letter dated February 24, 2003. Petitioner provided no evidence, however, as to why he believed he required three hours per day of home instruction, and why the District’s offer of home instruction during the regular school year and the summer, with the addition of the ninety-minute tutorial and weekly progress reports, would not meet his needs. However, the evidence does demonstrate that STUDENT may not always be well enough to receive home instruction and, therefore, providing him the opportunity to still take advantage of this service at school or during the summer is an appropriate manner in which to address his educational needs.

The Hearing Officer therefore concludes the District’s offer was appropriate in the amount of time of home instruction offered and the point at which the home instruction would be implemented because the evidence demonstrated that STUDENT falls behind in his work after being absent and needs additional assistance with making up his work. One hour of one-to-one home instruction for each day he is absent, as well as during the summer, along with the one-to-one tutorial instruction that the Hearing Officer has ordered the District to provide him during each school day, will meet STUDENT’s needs and provide him educational benefit. The Hearing Officer also concludes that the District’s offer must include sending homework/assignments home. STUDENT’s case manager should be responsible for coordinating home instruction and sending his work home, in consultation with STUDENT’s mother, who will be best able to assess whether STUDENT is medically able to participate in home instruction.

iv. nursing support services

STUDENT requires health care services at school because of his diabetic condition. STUDENT has been diagnosed with diabetes mellitus since he was three years old and his condition requires that he test his blood glucose levels during school hours. STUDENT also has mild hyperthyroidism. STUDENT has made great strides in managing his condition and is capable of independently monitoring his blood sugar levels. However, some oversight by a qualified health professional is required in order for him to receive a free and appropriate public education (FAPE). Accordingly, STUDENT has an individualized school healthcare plan (ISHP) designed to assist him in managing his diabetes at school and during school-related activities. (Pet.’s Exh. J-1 to J-3.) Under the pertinent provisions of STUDENT’s current ISHP and the corresponding physician authorization, STUDENT is required to check and record his own blood sugar and to report both sugar levels of less than 60 and positive ketone testing to his parent.

Petitioner argues that because his blood sugar level fluctuates from very low to very high, he requires an on-site nurse to be available to administer insulin or Glucagon to him and to monitor his blood glucose level testing. Therefore, he asserts that nursing services should be included as a related service in his IEP in order for him to benefit from his education. According to Petitioner, with nursing services as a related service, he would be able to increase his school attendance and thus be provided the same number of instructional days as his non-disabled peers. (Pet.’s closing brief.) In addition, understanding that STUDENT’s current ISHP does not authorize the District to administer insulin or Glucagon, MOTHER testified that she wanted STUDENT’s ISHP changed to state that a nurse could administer insulin to STUDENT. (See also Pet.’s closing brief.) However, before she obtained the doctor’s order authorizing the school to administer insulin, she wanted to be sure that the person administering the insulin was qualified.

The District argues that the school nurse is available in an emergency and consults with school staff on STUDENT’s health care needs. Moreover, there is no doctor’s order to administer insulin or Glucagon to STUDENT and the parent has not provided the school with the Glucagon prescription. According to the District, its February 24, 2003 offer of health care services, subject to the consent of the parent and STUDENT’s physician, was appropriate.(Footnote 10)

In addition to Petitioner’s contentions above, the District has also requested that the Hearing Officer address the appropriateness of its offer of health care services. In its letter offer dated February 24, 2003, the District offered the following health care services, subject to MOTHER’s consent and STUDENT’s physician’s authorization:

3.a) Supervision by qualified staff of STUDENT’s self administered glucose level testing before and after lunch, as well as when he comes to the special education staff room requesting such testing due to feeling unwell;

3.b) Training of staff by school nurse if needed, and ongoing consultation by telephone or in person from the school nurse as needed;

3.c) If STUDENT is not authorized by Doctor to self inject, Registered (RN) or licensed vocational nurse (LVN) will administer insulin following notification and authorization of mother, if glucose reading is above 300 mg/dl., and if glucose level does not lower following usual and accepted protocol. Said administration will take place within 1 hour of reading if usual protocol has not reduced the reading;

3.d) In the event of severe hypoglycemia (glucose reading of less than 70 mg/dl), parent will be contacted and appropriate treatment of low blood sugar will be provided by qualified staff. If administration of Glucagon injection is required due to STUDENT’s inability to take other treatments by mouth, a Registered (RN) or licensed vocational nurse (LVN) will administer the injection in accordance with the physician’s prescription and your provision of the prescription medication to the school, or emergency personnel will be summoned via 911. (Note: 911 assistance is only 4 blocks away and the response time is extremely fast);

3.e) In the event of hyperglycemia (300 or above) follow procedure as indicated in ISHP, to check ketones by student independently and call parent if high;

3.f) Parent to provide all necessary medications, including glucose gels, glucagon and insulin injections as would be specified in updated ISHP;

3.g) In order to assist STUDENT and the parent in maintaining balanced nutrition for STUDENT, the District will provide the parent with a chart of the nutritional breakdown of foods available through Foods Services. (Sample attached) The Director of Foods Services, Ms. Aulani Cler, will meet with the parent to choose a month’s selection of breakfast and lunch items in accordance with Child Nutrition Program. Those items will be ordered and provided daily to STUDENT upon agreement of parent and payment of student food service breakfast and lunch costs;

3.h) Referral to Alameda Behavioral Health Care Services for assessment for need for counseling services through 26.5. Dr. Bhatia, M.D., STUDENT’s Doctor at Children’s Hospital, has indicated that a teen diabetes support group is not available. It has been indicated that STUDENT may benefit from counseling to assist him in coping with the effects his illness is having and may have in the future.

Petitioner argues that there is no nurse on-site at the school to provide necessary health care services, including the administration of insulin and Glucagon. A review of the District’s offer reveals that there is no provision for a nurse to be on-site at SLHS at all times. Rather, the District’s offer includes qualified staff supervising STUDENT’s self-administered glucose level testing, training of staff by the school nurse, and ongoing consultation by telephone or in person from the school nurse as needed. The District has also offered, however, to have an RN or LVN administer the insulin and Glucagon injections to STUDENT when necessary. According to the District’s letter offer, the school nurse would administer insulin within one hour of glucose reading, if the usual protocol had not reduced the reading level.

School nurse Susan Blevins testified that for a high blood glucose reading, insulin needs to be provided within one hour, and in that case, it is not an emergency. Ms. Blevins stated that under such circumstances, she would be able to get to SLHS within one hour and administer an insulin injection to STUDENT. All school nurses are provided pagers and cell phones and it takes approximately ten minutes to drive from the administrative offices to SLHS. Moreover, there are three school nurses available to go to the school should STUDENT need a nurse to administer insulin or Glucagon injections.

The Hearing Officer notes that the District’s offer includes the administration of insulin or Glucagon injections to STUDENT by either an RN or LVN should his health needs require it. The Hearing Officer therefore sees no dispute between the parties with respect to Petitioner’s specific request that a nurse administer insulin. However, the District will not be able to implement the provisions regarding insulin and Glucagon unless the parent amends the current ISHP to include authorization to administer insulin or Glucagon injections at school. (Testimony of S. Blevins; Pet.’s Exh. J-1 to J-3.) The Hearing Officer is not persuaded by Petitioner’s claim that he needs a school nurse on-site at all times and there was no convincing evidence to support this claim. The evidence demonstrated that an LVN or RN would be available within an appropriate amount of time to administer insulin or Glucagon to STUDENT.

Although the District offered to have an LVN or RN available to administer insulin or Glucagon to STUDENT, the language of the offer letter had deficiencies. In reviewing the District’s offer regarding the actual administration of insulin, STUDENT’s physician, Suruchi Bhatia, testified that the wording in section 3.c. of the February 24, 2003 offer does not describe clearly enough what is meant by the “usual and accepted protocol.” (Dist.’s Exh. 1, pg. 3.) According to Dr. Bhatia, although section 3.c. of the letter states that insulin administration would take place within one hour, the appropriateness of that time frame would depend on whether ketones were present in STUDENT’s urine, how STUDENT is feeling, and the amount of time his blood glucose levels had been high. Dr. Bhatia testified that, in general, the “usual and accepted protocol” should be drinking water, moving about and exercising if levels are high. If the person is not feeling well, then this may be a sign of more complications and it is then wise to re-check the blood glucose level.

Dr. Bhatia also testified that sections 3.d, e, f, g, and h of the February 24, 2003 offer letter regarding what to do in case of hypoglycemia and hyperglycemia, the provision of medications by the parents, nutritional assistance, and counseling services, were all reasonable and adequate to address STUDENT’s needs. However, Dr. Bhatia did indicate that section 3.e should provide that the parent be called if ketones are “positive” not “high.”

The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of RN and LVN services for the administration of insulin and Glucagon injections was appropriate; however, the wording of provision 3.c must be clarified to identify the usual and accepted protocol and section 3.e should state that the parent be called if ketones are “positive” not “high.” As discussed in detail below, in addition to requiring that an RN or LVN be available within one hour to administer insulin or Glucagon to STUDENT, STUDENT requires qualified trained school personnel to assist him in monitoring his blood glucose level testing.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer now turns her attention to Petitioner’s claims that he requires monitoring of his blood glucose testing and his condition during school hours. MOTHER testified that there should be someone at school who would know what kinds of symptoms or conditions to look for in STUDENT because STUDENT will often say his stomach hurts when he is really not feeling ill and just wants to go home. Ms. Blevins testified that she trained school staff to monitor STUDENT’s blood glucose testing for high and low readings. According to Ms. Blevins, the trained staff has read through the diabetes manual she provided them and she checks with the staff weekly or biweekly to determine how they are doing. (Dist.’s Exh. 78.) Ms. Blevins testified that she has confidence in the staff who have been checking STUDENT’s glucose levels. Currently, STUDENT’s case manager, Gretchen Romani, supervises STUDENT’s testing because she takes her lunch break in the special education room where STUDENT tests his blood glucose at the same time that STUDENT tests. STUDENT’s resource English teacher, Lyn Isola, has also been trained and is also qualified to monitor STUDENT’s testing. (Testimony of S. Blevins.) Ms. Blevins testified that her training of staff consisted of providing them with general information regarding diabetes and demonstrating the glucose testing with the glucometer. (See Dist.’s Exh. 20.) Ms. Blevins also stated that she informed staff what to do in case of high and low readings.(Footnote 11)

According to STUDENT’s physician, Dr. Bhatia, adequate training of staff to monitor STUDENT’s testing would include having staff do the testing two to three times and look at the side of the vial for the color change. Moreover, Dr. Bhatia testified that a nurse would not need to monitor STUDENT’s blood glucose levels. Rather, his needs could be met if some other school staff member were trained to see if STUDENT was correctly performing the test and recording the findings. According to Dr. Bhatia, it is reasonable for STUDENT to test his blood glucose levels before and after lunch and as needed and to have a trained non-nurse monitor and record his blood glucose readings.

The Hearing Officer finds that although some SLHS staff have been properly trained to monitor STUDENT’s glucose level testing, the evidence suggested that, currently, there are times when a trained staff member may not necessarily be present in the room with STUDENT to monitor his testing and this could potentially pose a danger to STUDENT if he is in need of health care services. (Testimonies of D. VanValer & STUDENT.) Accordingly, although STUDENT’s current ISHP does not require he be supervised when testing his blood glucose levels, the evidence demonstrated that STUDENT’s health needs necessitate such supervision and, therefore, the District must ensure that a trained staff member is present in the special education room with STUDENT to monitor his testing and assist him if necessary.

Based on all of the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offer with respect to nursing support services was appropriate to address STUDENT’s health care needs and provide him educational benefit, except that the wording in section 3.c of the February 24, 2003 offer letter must be clarified to identify the “usual and accepted protocol,” and section 3.e should read “ call parent if positive.” Moreover, the amount of time listed in the ISHP that can elapse before administering the insulin must be identified and approved by STUDENT’s doctor. The District appropriately offered to have an RN or LVN available to administer insulin or Glucagon injections to STUDENT under appropriate circumstances. However, if the parent wants this provision to be implemented, she must first obtain the doctor’s order authorizing the school to perform this function. STUDENT’s ISHP should then be amended accordingly and signed by his doctor and his parent. In addition, designated trained school staff must be present when STUDENT tests his blood glucose levels in the special education staff room to monitor STUDENT’s testing and recording of results and to assist him with appropriate procedures in case he has low or high readings.

Placement

Petitioner contends that the District does not have the services he needs to succeed in his education and that he has not progressed in his current placement. Specifically, Petitioner argues that he should not be mainstreamed and that he requires smaller class sizes than those in which he is currently placed. Therefore, Petitioner believes he should be placed at Straunella Academy, a private school of six students with disabilities.

Under the District’s proposed placement, STUDENT would remain in the resource math and English classes, both in the morning, each for 90 minutes per day, with a break. As mentioned earlier, he would also attend a daily, 90-minute resource tutorial class in the afternoon in lieu of a physical education class or in lieu of another afternoon class. In addition, the District would provide home instruction as discussed earlier. STUDENT would participate with nondisabled peers in the general education environment for all of his other courses. (Dist.’s Exh. 15, pg. 30.) Additionally, STUDENT would be provided with study aids and/or manipulatives, accommodations and modifications to address his needs in all subject areas. (Dist.’s Exh. 15, pg. 38.)

As discussed in detail above in the sections regarding one-to-one instruction and home instruction, teachers who have worked with STUDENT concurred that STUDENT is appropriately placed in the resource math and English classes where the class sizes are smaller than regular education and where STUDENT can receive some one-to-one and small-group instruction. All of STUDENT’s teachers indicated that he is able to perform the academic work in their classes, with the accommodations and modifications provided pursuant to his IEP. (Testimonies of E. Poshkus, J. Nicholas, D. Weber, & L. Isola.) The evidence also demonstrated that STUDENT previously received low or failing grades not because he did not have the ability to perform the class work, but because he had difficulty completing and turning in the assignments once he fell behind after missing school. (Pet.’s Exh. C-12 to C-15; Testimonies of L. Isola, D. Weber, G. Romani, & J. Nicholas.)

STUDENT’s previous resource math teacher, Edward Poshkus, testified that there were 13-14 students in his class with one teacher and one instructional aide. Mr. Poshkus provided STUDENT with aids, such as a multiplication chart, positive and negative number strips, and a calculator, which he showed STUDENT how to use. Mr. Poshkus also took notes for STUDENT when there were difficult concepts. While in that class, STUDENT improved his math grade from an “F” to a “B-.”

The student-to-teacher ratio in Ms. Isola’s resource English class is 11 to 2. STUDENT’s teachers believed that he benefits from a class setting where the smaller student-to-teacher ratio allows him to receive more attention and the opportunity to have materials repeated and explained to him. (Testimonies of G. Romani and L. Isola.) According to Ms. Isola, STUDENT’s oral reading is very strong, with a great deal of expression. He is a good discussion leader and he is in tune with the class. STUDENT’s word attack skills are improving and his comprehension is very strong. STUDENT benefits when he is in Ms. Isola’s class; however, his absences affect his grades because he does not make up his missed work or bring it in after he has been absent. (Testimony of L. Isola.)

The evidence demonstrated that STUDENT’s learning disability, his frequent absences which lead to his difficulty in making up missed assignments, and his lack of concentration, all impede his ability to succeed in school and thus require a placement that can address these needs. Given this finding, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT requires the amount and type of resource services for math, English, and tutoring and the home instruction that the IEP dated December 16, 2002, and the offer letter dated February 24, 2003, recommend in order to receive a FAPE. This placement and class schedule are necessary to satisfy the IDEA requirements that STUDENT’s educational program be designed to meet his unique needs and provide him educational benefit in the least restrictive environment.

Although MOTHER maintained that STUDENT should be placed in Straunella Academy, a private school of six students, the Hearing Officer concludes that considering STUDENT’s disability, the offered placement (with the offered supports, accommodations, and modifications) would address his unique needs and provide him access to the general curriculum in the least restrictive environment. With the additions to the IEP as noted by the Hearing Officer above, the District offered and provided an appropriate placement for the 2002-2003 school year.

**** Conclusion

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District committed a procedural error by failing to implement the December 16, 2002 IEP with respect to the provision of progress reports to the parents; however, this procedural violation did not amount to a denial of FAPE. Moreover, the District appropriately responded to remedy this violation by offering to have an instructional assistant procure and collect the weekly progress reports from each teacher and forward them to STUDENT’s parent.

The Hearing Officer also concludes that the District’s overall program for the 2002-2003 school year did not substantively deny STUDENT a FAPE, except to the extent that it required the addition of one-to-one instruction in the resource tutorial class, along with the compilation and explanation of missed homework assignments. Moreover, the nursing support services were appropriate, except that the IEP must provide that a properly trained staff person always be present with STUDENT in the special education staff room when he is testing his blood glucose levels. Additionally, if the parent elects to obtain a doctor’s order to amend STUDENT’s ISHP to authorize the school (through an RN or LVN) to administer insulin and Glucagon injections, then the ISHP must be clarified to identify the “usual and accepted protocol” for responding to a high glucose level reading and also be revised with respect to reporting positive ketone detection.

ORDER

1. The District shall implement the December 16, 2002 IEP and its offer contained in the letter dated February 24, 2003, with the following amendments:

a. STUDENT’s IEP must specify that STUDENT will have District staff provide him with one-to-one instruction during his resource tutorial class to ensure that his work is organized, that he understands his missed assignments, and to answer questions he may have about the content of the course work. Additionally, the IEP must specify that a District staff person will obtain and compile STUDENT’s make-up assignments for all of his classes, determine what STUDENT needs to do to pass his courses, and also assist him (through repetition and explanation) during his resource tutorial class in completing the make-up work.

b. STUDENT’s case manager shall be responsible for coordinating home instruction and sending his work home, in consultation with STUDENT’s mother, who will be best able to assess whether STUDENT is medically able to participate in home instruction (at home).

c. Designated trained school staff must always be present with STUDENT in the special education staff room to monitor STUDENT’s blood glucose testing and recording of results and to assist him with appropriate procedures in case he has low or high readings.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

1. Did the District fail to allow the parent to participate in drafting the goals and objectives for the October 2002 and December 2002 IEP meetings and for the February 24, 2003 offer letter?

The District prevailed on this issue.

2. Did the District fail to provide the parent with weekly progress reports pursuant to the December 16, 2002 IEP?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

3. Did the District fail to offer and/or provide a program, including the placement, which meets STUDENT’s needs for the 2002-2003 school year with respect to:

i. goals and objectives for mainstream classes;

ii. one-to-one instructional support for all classes;

iii. home instruction; and iv. nursing support services?

The District prevailed on this issue with respect to sub-issues 3.i. and 3.iii, and substantially prevailed with respect to sub-issue 3.iv, except to the extent of the required amendments to the ISHP that the Hearing Officer identified in the text of the Decision above.

Petitioner substantially prevailed with respect to sub-issue 3.ii, except that he only requires one-to-one instruction during his resource tutorial class.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. (California Education Code §56505(i).) Dated: April 8, 2003 __________________________________ Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. The issues listed here differ in numbering and wording from those noticed by Petitioner before the hearing. Changes were made for purposes of clarification or for appropriate analysis. 2. The course of events leading up to the District’s February 24, 2003 offer letter included MOTHER signing the December 2002 IEP, but not signing in agreement with respect to placement, nursing support services, or one-to-one support. Then, by letter dated February 5, 2003, MOTHER filed a compliance complaint with the California Department of Education, and on February 11, 2003, the Hearing Office received Petitioner’s request for a due process hearing. There was no evidence that the California Department of Education had responded to MOTHER’s compliance complaint by the time of the commencement of the hearing; only the complaint was admitted into evidence. (Pet.’s Exh. A-1.)

3. MOTHER’s signature on the December 16, 2002 IEP indicates that she agreed only with the eligibility designation and the goals and objectives and disagreed with the program placement/services. (Dist.’s Exh. 15, pg. 33.) 4. The parent’s compliance complaint included a contention regarding the District’s failure to provide weekly progress reports. There was no evidence, however, that the CDE had responded to the parent’s complaint with respect to the progress reports. 5. Ms. Nicholas testified that she gave STUDENT more time to write assignments, allowed him to turn in modified work, and also prepared a lot of work for STUDENT to complete in the resource tutorial class. According to Ms. Nicholas, she invited STUDENT to come to her room at lunchtime for assistance. However, according to Ms. Nicholas, STUDENT did not turn in his work, missed his tests, and did not make up the work. Ms. Nicholas believed that STUDENT was capable of doing the work because he always had good facts to contribute to the class, he liked the projects, and he participated in the class. However, Ms. Nicholas also believed that since STUDENT missed so many classes and fell behind, it was difficult for him to later understand the processes of an assignment and make up the work that the class had covered over a span of a few weeks. Mr. Weber testified that they worked on paragraph structure, spelling, and punctuation. He shortened the essay lengths for STUDENT, gave him several alternative assignments that would be of high interest to him, and gave him extra time to complete the work. Mr. Weber stated that because STUDENT had absences and often had to leave the room for blood glucose level testing and to use the bathroom, he accommodated these situations by giving STUDENT extensions on due dates for assignments, working with STUDENT individually, and providing STUDENT with a private space in the classroom where he could work without distraction. Additionally, Mr. Weber provided packets of assignments for STUDENT to work on in his resource tutorial when he got behind in his work. Mr. Weber also testified that he has an emergency teaching credential and that his class is a regular education class that is designed to prepare students for college. 6. As will be discussed in detail in the next section, the District also offered to provide STUDENT with one-to-one home instruction if he is out for three consecutive days and summer school to ameliorate his absences due to health issues. 7. As will be discussed further in the next section, one-to-one instruction should also be provided (and in fact has been offered by the District) to STUDENT during home instruction. 8. The instruction would take place at home with the supervision of an adult authorized by the parent or at the school or another public location if no adult supervision is available at home. (Dist.’s Exh. 1, pg. 2.) 9. Although the District is designating this summer service as “home instruction,” in fact, it is one-to-one instruction provided on the high school campus during the summer. Nevertheless, the Hearing Officer finds that it is appropriate to provide STUDENT with the opportunity to clear up any “incomplete” grades that he may have at the end of the term due to his absences by way of one-to-one instruction during the summer school session. 10. Districts are required to provide health and nursing services to special education-eligible students who require such services in order to receive a free and appropriate public education. “Qualified personnel” must provide such services. (5 CCR §3051.12.) It was not disputed that SLHS school nurse Susan Blevins meets the state law requirements of being “qualified personnel.” Ms. Blevins is a licensed and registered nurse in the State of California. She has worked for over thirty years as a school nurse -- nine years in the District and twenty-three years in the Hayward Unified School District. Ms. Blevins has provided training to other staff members regarding STUDENT’s condition. (Testimony of S. Blevins.) The parties’ dispute with respect to health care services, then, centers on whether STUDENT requires school nurse services on-site to administer insulin or Glucagon procedures and monitor his blood glucose level testing. 11. Ms. Blevins testified that she has been a school nurse for over thirty years – nine years in the San Leandro Unified School District and twenty-three years in the Hayward Unified School District. She has a bachelor of science degree in nursing from the University of San Francisco, a public health certificate, and received her nursing credential in 1973 from the University of California, San Francisco School of Nursing. Her RN license is current.