California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 20, 2002
Student v. San Lorenzo Valley Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 2735-01 · Hearing Officer Trevor Skarda
San Lorenzo Valley Unified must fund The Bay School for 2002-2003 after failing to timely offer an appropriate ABA placement.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a ten-year-old boy with autism filed for due process against San Lorenzo Valley Unified School District. For years, his main program was a home-based applied behavior analysis (ABA) program. His mother ran it day to day, with four hours a month of supervision from an out-of-state behavior analyst. He also made short weekly visits to a second-grade class at Quail Hollow Elementary.
Hearing Officer Trevor Skarda found that the District denied him appropriate mainstreaming in 2000-2001. First, it did not carry out the IEP from his previous district. Later IEPs gave him no inclusion specialist to help him take part with peers. His 2001 summer program had no mainstreaming at all.
The mother asked for a school-based placement in June 2001, and the team agreed on goals in September 2001. The District did not make a specific written offer until February 26, 2002, and that delay denied a FAPE. The offer itself, a county special day class at Brook Knoll, was also inadequate. It gave only four hours a month of ABA oversight and 20 hours of start-up consultation, and the teacher had no ABA training.
The District must fund The Bay School, a certified nonpublic ABA school, for 2002-2003, both as a placement and as compensatory education. It must also add mainstreaming with an inclusion specialist. The District must repay the parents for Deanne Detmers' behavioral assessment, but not for Dr. Tina Guterman's.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO treated a district that relied on a parent to run a home ABA program. Once the parent asked for a school-based placement, the district had to make a specific, timely offer. The decision also found mainstreaming without trained inclusion support inadequate. Reimbursement for the two private evaluations turned on whether a district assessment existed for the parents to disagree with.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedImplementation
Issue 1. Did the District provide STUDENT with appropriate mainstreaming during the 2000-2001 school year, including the extended school year (ESY)?
From August 2000 to January 2001, the District did not implement the transfer IEP's four weekly hours of mainstreaming. From January to June 2001, the IEP lacked an inclusion specialist and so did not meet the student's needs. The District gave no evidence that mainstreaming was unnecessary in ESY 2001.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 2. Did the District provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education during the 2001-2002 school year, up to February 26, 2002?
The student needed a school-based placement. The District denied FAPE from September 27, 2001 to February 26, 2002 by not making a specific, timely offer after goals were agreed. Mainstreaming stayed inappropriate because there was no inclusion specialist.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. Did the District's February 26, 2002 offer of a special day class at Brook Knoll offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education?
The offer was not designed to meet the student's needs. It gave only four hours a month of ABA specialist oversight and 20 hours of start-up consultation, and the teacher lacked ABA training.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 4. Should STUDENT be placed at the Bay School, a private non-public ABA school, during the 2002-2003 school year?
The Bay School, a state-certified nonpublic ABA school, could meet all of the student's needs and was the only available ABA program in the area. It was therefore the least restrictive appropriate placement, and the District must fund it for 2002-2003.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 5. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
Funding of The Bay School for 2002-2003 was also awarded as compensatory education for the delayed placement offer. The District must also provide added mainstreaming with an inclusion specialist for two years of inappropriate mainstreaming.
- Student prevailed in partIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 6. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of privately obtained assessments provided by Deanne Detmers and Dr. Tina Guterman?
No reimbursement for Dr. Guterman's neuropsychological assessment, because there was no District assessment to disagree with when the parents obtained it. Reimbursement was ordered for Detmers' behavioral assessment because the District never assessed behavioral needs after the Diagnostic Center referral lapsed.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 20 business days of the decision, convene an IEP meeting. Representative(s) of The Bay School and Stacey Shook of NWBA must be invited, at District expense.
- Prospective funding of private placement. Amend the IEP to place the student at The Bay School for the entire 2002-2003 school year at District expense. This was ordered both as an appropriate placement and as compensatory education.
- Compensatory education. The IEP team must add appropriate mainstreaming services to supplement the Bay School program. The services may include public school mainstreaming, reverse mainstreaming, or other contact with typically developing peers, and must not interfere with the Bay School program. The team decides their nature and amount.
- Order to provide or change services. Provide the services of an appropriately qualified inclusion specialist, chosen by the IEP team.
- Reimbursement. Reimburse the parents for the cost of Deanne Detmers' assessment within 30 business days after receiving proof of payment. No amount is stated.
Key authorities
Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Burlington School Committee v. Department of Education; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Cal. Educ. Code § 56325; Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56505.2; 5 C.C.R. § 3043; 34 C.F.R. § 300.342
People named in the decision
- Mary Bevernick, director of student/pupil personnel services, San Lorenzo Valley Unified School District
- Stacey Shook, Ph.D., certified behavior analyst and home ABA program director; witness for Student, Northwest Behavioral Associates (NWBA)
- Ruth Strudley, second-grade general education teacher, Quail Hollow Elementary School
- Sue Procter, occupational therapist, San Lorenzo Valley Unified School District
- Megan Braunhut, speech-language pathologist, San Lorenzo Valley Unified School District
- Janice Parrish, school psychologist, San Lorenzo Valley Unified School District
- Fran Bussard, autism specialist, District IEP team
- Caryl Hogan, psychologist; District-proposed psychological assessor
- Katie Merchant, District-proposed neuropsychological assessor
- Deanne Detmers, private behavioral/program assessor, Behavioral Intervention Association (BIA)
- Tina Guterman, Ph.D., private pediatric neuropsychologist
- Grace Lee, 1:1 aide
- Linda Koval, special day class teacher (severely handicapped), Brook Knoll School, Santa Cruz County Office of Education
- Barry Morgenstern, director, The Bay School (nonpublic school)
- The Bay School, nonpublic ABA school
- Northwest Behavioral Associates (NWBA), private ABA supervision agency
- Behavioral Intervention Association (BIA), private ABA agency
- Center for Autism and Related Services (CARD), private ABA agency (prior provider)
- California Diagnostic Center, state assessment center (proposed assessment)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Boulder Creek, California, on March 26-28, and April 16-18, 2002.
Petitioner STUDENT (STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Kathryn E. Dobel. Also present on the STUDENT’s behalf was his mother, MOTHER, and his father, FATHER. Respondent San Lorenzo Valley Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Chad Graff. Also present on the Student’s behalf was Mary Bevernick, the director of student services for the District.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open for the submission of written closing arguments, the last of which was received by the Hearing Officer on April 29, 2002. After the parties' written closing arguments were received, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUES (Footnote 1)
1. Did the District provide STUDENT with appropriate mainstreaming during the 2000-2001 school year, including the extended school year (ESY)?
Did the District provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education during the 2001-2002 school year, up to February 26, 2002?
Did the District’s February 26, 2002 offer of a special day class at Brook Knoll offer STUDENT a free and appropriate pubic education?
Should STUDENT be placed at the Bay School, a private non-public applied behavior analysis (ABA) school, during the 2002-2003 school year?
Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of privately obtained assessments provided by Deanne Detmers and Dr. Tina Guterman?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a is a ten-year-old child who resides with his parents, MOTHER and FATHER, within the boundaries of the San Lorenzo Valley Unified School District. STUDENT was first diagnosed with autism at two years and nine months of age. Since he was three and one-half years old, STUDENT has received an intensive in-home behavioral intervention program supervised initially by the Behavioral Intervention Association (BIA), then by the Center for Autism and Related Services (CARD), and for the last five years by Northwest Behavioral Associates (NWBA).
For the last several years, including the entire period at issue (the 2000-2001 school year and the 2001-2002 school year) STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, has been the person primarily responsible for STUDENT’s home applied behavioral analysis (ABA) program. She has received only four hours of supervision each month from Stacey Shook, Ph.D. of NWBA, a certified behavior analyst and expert in ABA, who acts as STUDENT’s program director from her residence in the state of Washington. On a daily basis, MOTHER has trained and supervised STUDENT’s 1:1 aides who deliver STUDENT’s ABA discrete trial services, collected and organized the voluminous data, generally supervised the mainstreaming component of STUDENT’s program, and has assisted Stacey Shook with the development of periodic progress reports on STUDENT’s progress in his home program as well as with the development of new home program goals related to STUDENT’s ABA program. Testimony of MOTHER and Shook.
STUDENT entered the San Lorenzo Valley Unified School District in August 2000. District’s Exh. 9. Prior to that, STUDENT resided within the boundaries of the Laguna Salada Union School District in San Mateo County. Before STUDENT’s parents moved to the District, STUDENT’s mother contacted Mary Bevernick, the District’s director of pupil personnel services, and met with her to discuss STUDENT’s transition to the District. Testimony of Bevernick and MOTHER.
STUDENT’s initial placement in the District, which began on or about August 29, 2000, was a 30-day interim placement that was developed from the IEP of the Laguna Salada Union School District. District’s Exh. 6. The Laguna Salada IEP provided STUDENT with four hours of mainstreaming in a regular education classroom as well as 25 hours a week of the ABA program at home along with the related services of occupational and speech therapy. The supervision of the mainstreaming portion of the IEP was the responsibility of STUDENT’s classroom teacher. STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, was to supervise the in-home instruction with the benefit of only four hours of consultation with Stacey Shook from NWBA. District’s Exh. 6. The cost of STUDENT’s education was borne by the school district. The IEP notes with regard to mainstreaming that:
The team did not develop a goal for classroom participation but understands the intent of STUDENT’s home program is to generalize learning to the school setting.
District’s Exh. 6.
Despite the fact that STUDENT’s Laguna Salada IEP had identified a need for mainstreaming in order to promote generalization of STUDENT’s ABA program in a school setting, STUDENT was not mainstreamed in a regular education classroom during the first 30 days in the District. District’s Exh. 13. In fact, mainstreaming did not begin until October 2000 when STUDENT began to attend Ruth Strudley’s second grade class at Quail Hollow Elementary School. He was mainstreamed in the regular classroom for 50 minutes two times each week and participated in recess for two 15-minute periods each week. Testimony of Strudley and MOTHER. STUDENT’s interim placement continued until January 2001, when the District held its first IEP for STUDENT. Two “extensions” of the 30-day interim placement (which began on August 29, 2000) were agreed to by the parties. District’s Exhs. 13 and 14.
STUDENT’s first IEP team meeting convened on January 11, 2001. Occupational therapist Sue Procter provided an assessment report and discussed STUDENT’s progress on his occupational therapy goals and objectives from his previous district. MOTHER and Stacy Shook discussed STUDENT’s progress on his home program goals and objectives and presented a progress report. Speech pathologist Megan Braunhut reported on STUDENT’s present levels of performance in the area of speech and language. Ms. Braunhut’s report concluded that an augmentative communication assessment was required because STUDENT had received speech therapy for six years and had acquired only six sounds. School Psychologist Janice Parrish had observed STUDENT several times at his home and during mainstreaming in Ms. Strudley’s class. Ms. Parrish’s report states, in pertinent part, that “STUDENT’s mother stated that she would like to . . . have STUDENT participate in the regular classroom [two times each week] in order to see if he can transfer the information he is working on at home into the classroom setting.” District’s Exh. 17.
The January 2001 IEP team developed and accepted goals and objectives in the areas of speech and language and occupational therapy and two goals and corresponding objectives in the areas of “classroom participation” and “classroom readiness.”
Additionally, MOTHER and Stacey Shook presented the goals and objectives they had developed for STUDENT’s home ABA program. These goals were attached to the parents version of the IEP (Footnote 2). The ABA goals were not written on SELPA forms, the pre-formatted forms that districts typically use to draft goals and objectives. Nonetheless, they were implemented by MOTHER and the 1:1 aides. Testimony of MOTHER.
Overall, STUDENT’s January 2001 IEP remained largely unchanged from the one developed by the previous district that had been implemented up to January 2001. STUDENT’s OT and speech and language services were increased slightly, to 2 hours per month. STUDENT received 25 hours per week of 1:1 aide support for home and school with 4 hours per month of 1:1 aide training and “meeting” time and 4 hours per month of behavior therapist services provided by Stacey Shook of NWBA. All costs were borne by the District. STUDENT’s mainstreaming time, however, was reduced from his prior IEP developed by the Laguna Salada district from 4 hours to “2-3 hours/week.” Finally, pursuant to Ms. Braunhut’s report, the IEP team agreed to investigate augmentative and assistive technology to address STUDENT’s extensive communication needs.
Although the IEP lacked any specific information about how mainstreaming would be accomplished in Ruth Strudley’s regular education second grade class, STUDENT attended two times each week for 50 minutes in the classroom, and two times each week for 15 minutes during recess. Additionally, STUDENT began attending library time every other Friday with Ms. Strudley’s class, although his attendance was sporadic. Testimony of MOTHER and Strudley.
STUDENT’s January 2001 IEP, including the mainstreaming component, was implemented from January 2001 to June 2001. In June 2001, the IEP team met for STUDENT’s triennial review. Stacey Shook and STUDENT’s mother presented STUDENT’s Assessment of Basic Language and Learning Skills (ABLLS), an assessment, curriculum guide and skills tracking system for children with autism and other developmental disabilities. Petitioner’s Exhs. 5 and 6. They also presented STUDENT’s progress report from his home ABA program and presented new ABA goals and objectives. These goals and objectives were presented in the same format as the ones presented by Shook and MOTHER at the January 2001 meeting; that is, they were not on SELPA forms.
Sue Procter reported on STUDENT’s progress on his occupational therapy goals and objectives and speech pathologist Megan Braunhut reported on STUDENT’s progress in speech therapy. District’s Exhs. 22 and 23. School psychologist Janice Parrish also presented a recent assessment report based on her review of the ABLLS and her administration of the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales: Interview Edition (Vineland). District’s Exh. 24. Goals and objectives were developed and adopted in the areas of occupational therapy, speech and language therapy, classroom participation and “computer access.” Petitioner’s Exh. 7.
The IEP team also considered placement options for the following (2001-2002) school year. In that regard, MOTHER requested that STUDENT be placed in a school-based placement, in part, because she was “tired” and no longer wanted to provide the bulk of STUDENT’s educational services any longer. Testimony of MOTHER. Ms. Braunhut generally expressed the need for a school-based placement. She noted (following a visit to The Bay School) that STUDENT “needs to be more with other children in order to develop a stronger need to communicate, and this type of stimulus is not present in his current program.” District’s Exh. 23. The team considered a continuation of STUDENT’s home ABA program with mainstreaming. It also discussed placement at The Bay School, a private nonpublic school for students with autism that uses a strict applied behavioral analysis methodology. District’s Exh. 19. Mary Bevernick observed the Bay School after June 5, 2001, and discussed her observation at the June 15, 2001 reconvened meeting. Testimony of Bevernick. The IEP reflects on the signature page that STUDENT’s program would remain essentially the same, despite the general agreement to pursue school-based placement for STUDENT. The team agreed to reconvene to discuss placement for the fall of 2001.
For STUDENT’s extended school year (ESY) program the team agreed to 154 hours of 1:1 aide support during the summer of 2001, with 4 hours of behavior specialist services and 3 hours of occupational therapy, all to be provided at STUDENT’s home. The ESY program does not include mainstreaming in a regular education classroom or participation in recess. District’s Exh. 7.
The IEP team also agreed to pursue additional assessments. The IEP states, in pertinent part, as follows:
Team agrees to pursue assessment for autism and augmentative communication through California Diagnostic Center. Parents want to approve tools and process before evaluation. District agrees to assist parents. IEP team discussed assistive technology possibilities for STUDENT. The team intends to pursue borrowing hardware and software in order to determine appropriate devices. The team also discussed possible placement option of Bay School.
District’s Exh. 19.
The referral process to the Diagnostic Center had two components. Both the parent and the District were to complete a separate “referral packet” to initiate the assessment. STUDENT’s parents completed their packet on June 20, 2001. Mary Bevernick completed the District’s referral packet on July 19, 2001. Around that time, MOTHER contacted the Diagnostic Center to inquire about the status of the assessment and she was informed that the Diagnostic Center had not yet received the packet from the District. She was also told that STUDENT’s assessment would not be completed until the end of October because of a lengthy waiting list. Testimony of MOTHER, Bevernick and District’s Exh. 25.
STUDENT’s parents then withdrew their consent. They wanted STUDENT to be moved out of his home ABA program to a school-based placement at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year. They believed that the assessment would further delay STUDENT’s movement to a school-based placement (Footnote 4). Testimony of MOTHER.
In August 2001, Stacey Shook prepared a progress report regarding STUDENT’s progress on his home ABA program goals and objectives in preparation for the upcoming IEP team meeting. She reported that STUDENT had made progress in the areas of mathematics, spelling, general cognitive ability, and classroom readiness. Ms. Shook also invited the District to ask questions or examine the data collected by STUDENT’s tutors:
His home tutors collect probe data frequently and those data are available for your review upon request; please note that those data are kept in his program notebook.
Petitioner’s Exh 9 (Footnote 5) .
Ms. Shook also recommended The Bay School in her August 2001 progress report:
At this time, I feel STUDENT’s specific learning style and educational needs may be most appropriately met in an educational setting such as The Bay School. STUDENT has made consistent and significant progress in the four years that I have worked with him, but should be noted that his progress has been made with a highly individualized program and constant material and program modification. While I do not have direct knowledge of the level of behavior analytic supervision available to special education staff in the San Lorenzo Valley Unified School District, it has been my experience with other districts that certified behavior analysts are not typically available to monitor acquisition and behavior data on a weekly, and even daily basis. I feel confident that the staff of The Bay School under the direction of Dr. Barry Morgenstern could provide such consistent monitoring and revision. I look forward to continuing to work with the San Lorenzo Valley Unified School District and STUDENT’s family to ensure the most appropriate educational placement for him.
Petitioner’s Exh. 9.
On August 23, 2001, the IEP team reconvened. The District invited numerous additional individuals who had never been involved in the development of STUDENT’s educational program prior to that date, including a resource specialist, the SELPA director, the County Office of Education director, another teacher, and an autism consultant. The signature page indicates that there were 15 people present at the IEP meeting (Footnote 6).
At the outset of the August 23, 2001 IEP meeting, the District members of the IEP team indicated that the goals and objectives developed by Stacey Shook and MOTHER for STUDENT’s home ABA program needed to be revised. Although these goals and objectives had been presented at the June 5 and 15, 2001 IEP meetings, and had been implemented since that time, the District stated generally that they were inappropriate because they were not on SELPA forms. MOTHER agreed to take the goals and objectives home and transfer them to SELPA forms, which she did. (Footnote 7)
Also on August 23, 2001, more than 8 months after Megan Braunhut had recommended an augmentative communication assessment, STUDENT’s parents were finally provided with an assessment plan to assess STUDENT in this area.
The IEP team meeting reconvened the following day, August 24, 2001. However, placement for the quickly approaching 2001-2002 school year was not discussed because it was determined that the goals and objectives that MOTHER had placed on SELPA forms required still more revision (Footnote 8). The meeting ended and MOTHER stayed, along with Fran Bussard, an “autism specialist” (who had never met, observed or assessed STUDENT). Together they revised the goals and objectives for several hours. The re-written goals and objectives were given to Mary Bevernick who typed the goals and objectives on SELPA forms.
The team reconvened on August 31, 2001. The parents demanded that the IEP team immediately discuss placement. However, the District members of the IEP team indicated that the goals and objectives now needed to be discussed, revised again if necessary, and approved. Because the District members of the IEP insisted that the goals and objectives would first need to be discussed, revised if necessary, and approved before placement was discussed, the parents refused to proceed and walked out of the IEP meeting. The IEP document reflects that STUDENT’s placement at that time was “Stay Put.” (Footnote 9) District’s Exh. 36.
On September 4, 2001, Mary Bevernick sent a letter to STUDENT’s parents in which she indicated, in pertinent part, as follows:
The team agreed that we have done the major work regarding drafting of the goals. Once we agree to adopt them, we can move directly to placement. I believe that is the issue you wish to discuss.
District’s Exh. 37.
On September 17, 2001, Mary Bevernick sent another letter to STUDENT’s parents that states, in pertinent part, as follows:
I believe that we have developed a comprehensive set of measurable objectives that are worthy of the time and energy that was put into them. The purpose of doing so was to develop educationally sound measurable goals that can be a basis for placement. . . .
District’s Exh. 40.
On September 27, 2001, the IEP team reconvened for the sixth time since June 5, 2001. The goals and objectives that had been revised by MOTHER and Fran Bussard were accepted by all members of the IEP team. It is not seriously disputed that the goals and objective that were revised and agreed to at the September 27, 2001 IEP meeting are, in sum and substance, the same as those presented by MOTHER on June 5, 2001. Testimony of MOTHER, Bussard and Bevernick.
The IEP team finally discussed placement. The IEP team discussed possible placement in a SCCOE school-based autism class called Natural Bridges. The team also discussed moving STUDENT’s home-ABA program to a school site, Quail Hollow. FATHER and MOTHER reiterated their interest in The Bay School, but agreed to observe Natural Bridges.
Also at the September 27, 2001 IEP meeting, the team agreed to a psychological assessment to be conducted by Caryl Hogan. District’s Exh. 43. Although there was agreement with regard to the psychological assessment to be completed by Caryl Hogan, FATHER and MOTHER also requested an independent neuropsychological evaluation to be conducted by Dr. Tina Guterman, at District expense. District’s Exh. 44.
Ms. Bevernick wrote a letter dated October 3, 2001 to MOTHER. In the letter she indicates that the District was willing to do a neuropsychological assessment (and there was therefore no reason for an independent neuropsychological assessment). Ms. Bevernick enclosed an assessment plan and proposed a neuropsychological assessment to be conducted by Katie Merchant. District’s Exh. 87. She also sent to the parents the assessment plan for the assessment to be conducted by Caryl Hogan. District’s Exh. 44. STUDENT’s parents agreed to both assessments.
Thereafter, STUDENT’s parents obtained their own assessments from Deanne Detmers of BIA and Tina Guterman, Ph.D. Deanne Detmers conducted her assessment of STUDENT on October 30, 2001. She evaluated STUDENT’s current program and made placement recommendations. As part of her assessment, she reviewed records, observed STUDENT at Quail Hollow Elementary School and in his home ABA program, and she also observed the COE-operated Natural Bridges School. Ms. Detmers recommended placement at the Bay School and expressed serious concerns about the adequacy of STUDENT’s current mainstreaming at Quail Hollow. Petitioner’s Exh. 20.
Tina Guterman, Ph.D., a pediatric neuropsychologist, began her assessment of STUDENT on October 30 and completed it on November 6, 2001. Like Ms. Detmers, Ms. Guterman also observed STUDENT at Quail Hollow Elementary School and observed him in his home ABA program. Additionally, she observed the Natural Bridges School and The Bay School.
On November 5, 2001, STUDENT’s parents requested that an IEP team meeting to be held on November 30, 2001.
On November 20, 2001, Katie Merchant determined that she could not assess STUDENT using standardized instruments. STUDENT’s parents withdrew consent for the assessment.
On November 27, 2001, Caryl Hogan assessed STUDENT at his home. She administered the Psychoeducational Profile Revised (PEP-R), a psychoeducational test designed to assess children with autism, along with the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales. Ms. Hogan also observed STUDENT in an occupational therapy session and in his home program, spoke to MOTHER and Ms. Procter, and reviewed STUDENT’s file, including the ABLLS prepared by Stacey Shook. She did not review the data that had been collected by STUDENT’s tutors in his home ABA program over the past several years. Ms. Hogan felt that STUDENT attempted most of the tasks and that the assessments results were valid. Testimony of Hogan and District’s Exh. 57.
On December 4, 2001, the IEP team reconvened. District’s Exh. 60. At this IEP meeting, the IEP team considered assessment reports from Katie Merchant, Caryl Hogan, Tina Guterman, and Deanne Detmers. Not a single goal or objective was altered based on any of the assessments that were conducted. The IEP indicates that the team discussed placement options and the following offer was made, almost six months after the June 5, 2001 IEP team meeting:
San Lorenzo Valley Unified School District formally offers two placement options for STUDENT:
1. Santa Cruz County Office of Education Elementary Autism program (Footnote 10) with LSH and OT services and trainers and support from district to integrate COE program with STUDENT’s program in order to implement goals. (1:1 aide, Behavior Specialist Consultation) Augmentative communication assessment.
2. Inclusion in local elementary school with trainers and support from district to integrate STUDENT’s program in order to implement goals. (1:1 aide, Behavior Specialist consultation), OT, LSH and Augmentative communication assessment.
District’s Exh. 60.
On December 13, 2001, STUDENT’s parents requested a due process hearing.
On December 17, 2001, Mary Bevernick sent STUDENT’s parents a letter in which she restated the alternative placement offers contained in the December 4, 2001 IEP. In the same letter, Ms. Bevernick wrote the following with regard to STUDENT’s mainstreaming at Quail Hollow:
The district requests that MOTHER discontinue her practice of accompanying STUDENT into the classroom during his mainstreaming time. We want to offer STUDENT the opportunity to benefit from his education without being distracted by the presence of his mother. STUDENT’s needs can be met by one of his other aides. If MOTHER feels the need to be present on campus at the same time as STUDENT is attending school, the principal will help MOTHER find a volunteer activity on another part of campus. Upon receipt of this letter, we expect that MOTHER will no longer accompany STUDENT to Ruth Strudley’s classroom.
District’s Exh. 62.
On January 22, 2002, STUDENT’s IEP team met again, the eighth IEP meeting since June 5, 2001. Placement was discussed. In that regard, the IEP narrative states as follows:
The team considered placement options. A written offer of placement will be mailed to parents within two days. The offer will include: Special Day Class (SH) in a COE setting to which STUDENT’s ABA program will be moved. A behavior consultant will be contracted to oversee integration of school program & ABA program and train staff as appropriate. Consultation for ABA program will continue & [illegible] with district consultant. The team recommends that the parents visit several COE sites (Natural Bridges & Brook Knoll) with the purpose of determining feasibility of ABA program delivery. Once STUDENT is enrolled in SDC class, an APA assessment will be considered.
District’s Exh. 67.
The January 2002 IEP offers STUDENT a county special day class. It states that STUDENT would be placed in a “SDC-COE” staffed by a teacher of the severely handicapped beginning on February 11, 2002, for five days each week. Neither the severely handicapped teacher nor the particular county special day class is identified on the IEP. The SH teacher is responsible for small group, individual and “consultation” services, according to the IEP. It further states that STUDENT would initially receive “20 hrs consultation” from a behavior therapist. Also beginning on February 11, 2002, STUDENT would receive “2hrs/5 days/wk” of 1:1 aide support on the “bus or car” and five additional hours of aide support “to cover additional school time,” in addition to transportation to and from the special day class. District’s Exh. 67.
In addition to the special day class services described above, all to begin on February 11, 2002, the IEP provides for the following services on a “continuing” basis: occupational therapy for two hours each month, speech and language therapy for two hours each month, and four hours per month of consultation from a behavioral specialist. The IEP also offers extended school year services, twenty-five hours each week of 1:1 aide support in the home and school and “up to” four hours each month of 1:1 aide training, although there is no corresponding “start date” or “end date” for these services. District’s Exh. 67.
On January 24, 2002, Mary Bevernick sent a letter to STUDENT’s parents. The letter, which is purportedly an “offer” of placement, does not list a specific site. Ms. Bevernick essentially restates what was written in the IEP days earlier. Of note, the offer letter states that “20 hours of Behavior Specialist consultation to teacher will be provided by the district for the purpose of ensuring classroom integration of programs, staff training and for socialization” and that “visual schedules will be introduced to STUDENT.” The letter also discusses the mainstreaming portion of STUDENT’s program up to that point:
To date, STUDENT has been educated primarily at home, with only brief highly structured visits to school under parent-imposed restrictions that precluded classroom staff from being able to work with him . . .
District’s Exh. 68. [Emphasis added].
FATHER and MOTHER agreed to visit possible SCCOE sites, other than Natural Bridges, which MOTHER had observed in the past. One of the sites they visited was Brook Knoll. Testimony of MOTHER. On February 18, 2002, FATHER and MOTHER wrote to Ms. Bevernick and indicated that they had visited the possible sites at Natural Bridges, Brook Knoll, Westlake and Green Acres, and concluded that the District’s proposal would not provide an appropriate placement for STUDENT at any of those sites. District’s Exh. 70
On February 26, 2002, Ms. Bevernick wrote another placement offer (Footnote 11), essentially a transition plan, wherein over a period of seven weeks, STUDENT would be transitioned from his home-based ABA program to a Special Day Class for Severely Handicapped students located at Brook Knoll School in Scotts Valley, operated by the Santa Cruz Office of Education, taught by Linda Koval (Footnote 12). District’s Exh. 71.
STUDENT continues in his stay put placement, his current home ABA program provided principally by his mother, MOTHER, with four hours per month of supervision services from Stacey Shook of NWBA. He has continued to attend Ruth Strudley’s class for mainstreaming, and beginning in February 2002, MOTHER asked and was granted permission to return with STUDENT to Ms. Strudley’s class during mainstreaming in order to train STUDENT’s new 1:1 aide (STUDENT’s aide who had previously accompanied him to Ms. Strudley’s class quit).
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The 2000-2001 School Year, and Extended School Year 2001
With regard to the 2000-2001 school year, the Petitioner contends that the District failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE with regard to the mainstreaming portion of STUDENT’s program at Quail Hollow Elementary, in a second-grade class taught by Ruth Strudley. Petitioner’s primary arguments in that regard are that there was no supervision, no progress reports by the regular education teacher, and ineffective communication between the persons responsible for mainstreaming The District argues that the mainstreaming portion of STUDENT’s program was appropriate during this school year.
The 2001-2002 School Year
Petitioner contends that the District failed to offer a school-based placement in a timely manner. Petitioner also contends that the mainstreaming portion of STUDENT’s program during the 2001-2002 school year continued to be inappropriate for the same reasons as the previous school year. The District generally argues that its February 2002 offer was timely and that STUDENT’s mainstreaming program remained appropriate.
The February 2002 Offer of Placement at Brook Knoll
Petitioner contends that the February 26, 2002 offer of Brook Knoll is inappropriate because it lacks sufficient support from an ABA behavior analyst, the teacher is not ABA trained, and there is no room in the proposed classroom for STUDENT’s program. The District argues that its offer of placement at Brook Knoll is appropriate for STUDENT.
The Bay School
The Petitioner argues that the Bay School is the only appropriate placement where STUDENT’s ABA program and his goals and objectives can be implemented in the greater Santa Cruz area. Petitioner further argues that the Bay School will provide STUDENT with sufficient opportunities to interact with typically developing peers. The District argues in closing that the Bay School is inappropriate because it will provide STUDENT with insufficient opportunities to interact with typically developing peers. The District further contends that The Bay School is not available because it will not accept STUDENT.
Reimbursement for Independent Assessments
With regard to Tina Guterman’s neuropsychological assessment, the Petitioner argues that the “District should have reimbursed for Tina Guterman’s assessment when they learned that Katie Merchant would [not] be assessing by her own choice.” The District argues that reimbursement is not warranted because STUDENT’s parents did not obtain Tina Guterman’s assessment because they disagreed with the District’s assessment. The District also argues that Tina Guterman did not assess STUDENT, but rather, she only observed STUDENT.
Petitioner contends that he should be reimbursed for Deanne Detmer’s assessment because the District never assessed STUDENT’s behavioral needs. The District’s arguments with regard to Deanne Detmer’s assessment are identical to those regarding Tina Guterman’s assessment: STUDENT’s parents did not disagree with any District assessment and Ms. Detmer did not assess STUDENT, she merely prepared an observation report.
Compensatory Education
Petitioner requests as compensatory education in the form of one year at The Bay School for the District’s alleged denial of FAPE from August 2000 to the present.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Did the District provide STUDENT with appropriate mainstreaming during the 2000-2001 school year, including the extended school year (ESY)?
As developed above, only a limited portion of STUDENT’s program, which included extensive home-based ABA services, is at issue. At issue during the 2000-2001 school year is the “mainstreaming,” or “inclusion,” component of STUDENT’s program (Footnote 13). For purposes of appropriate analysis, this issue shall be analyzed during three distinct periods: (1) August 2000 to January 2001; (2) January 2001 to June 2001; and (3) the extended school year (ESY) of 2001.
August 2000 to January 2001
When STUDENT entered the District, the District was required immediately to implement STUDENT’s existing IEP to the extent possible within existing resources. California Education Code section 56325(a) provides as follows:
Whenever a pupil transfers into a school district . . . the administrator of a local program under this part shall ensure that the pupil is immediately provided an interim placement for a period not to exceed 30 days. The interim placement must be in conformity with an individualized education program, unless the parent or guardian agree otherwise. The individualized education program implemented during the interim placement may be either the pupil’s existing individualized education program, implemented to the extent possible within existing resources, . . . or a new individualized education program, developed pursuant to Section 56321.
The District failed to implement STUDENT’s existing IEP for the first 30 days of his placement – STUDENT was not mainstreamed for the first 30 days of the 2000-2001 school year. There was no persuasive evidence establishing an “agreement otherwise” which would account for the delay of STUDENT’s mainstreaming. The “time line extension” signed by MOTHER on September 29, 2001, states only that STUDENT had not yet attended the Quail Hollow Elementary school as of that date. Moreover, there was no evidence presented that the District lacked the resources to implement the mainstreaming component of STUDENT’s program during the first 30-day interim placement. The District had available placements, including Ruth Strudley’s class at Quail Hollow, where STUDENT eventually was placed for mainstreaming.
The District also failed to implement STUDENT’s interim placement through January 2001 (Footnote 14). STUDENT’s interim placement continued until January 2001. From approximately October 2000 through January 2001, STUDENT was provided with some mainstreaming, two hours each week, although his Laguna Salada IEP states that he was to receive four hours per week. Because the District failed to provide STUDENT with mainstreaming in conformity with the Laguna Salada IEP, it failed to provide STUDENT with appropriate mainstreaming.
In sum, STUDENT was denied appropriate mainstreaming opportunities from August 2000 through January 2001 because the District failed to provide him with mainstreaming in conformity with his Laguna Salada IEP.
January 2001 to June 2001
The District developed an IEP in January 2001. This IEP identified two unique needs of STUDENT related to mainstreaming, “playground participation” and “class participation,” along with corresponding goals and objectives. District’s Exh. 17. To implement these goals and objectives, STUDENT’s IEP provided him 2-3 hours of mainstreaming in the second grade regular education classroom taught by Ruth Strudley, recess, and “library” on alternating Fridays. The IEP identifies as the person responsible for implementing STUDENT’s “class participation” goal and objective was STUDENT’s mother, although Ruth Strudley testified that she was also responsible. STUDENT’s mother, STUDENT himself, and the occupational therapist were responsible for implementation of STUDENT’s IEP with regard to STUDENT’s goal and objectives in the area of “playground participation.”
The issue with regard to these mainstreaming opportunities, and the corresponding goals and objectives, is whether they were appropriate for STUDENT. Pursuant to the IDEA and State special education law, children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A “free appropriate public education” consists of special education and related services that are available to the child at no charge to the parent or guardian, meet the State educational standards, and conform to the child’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, provided at no cost to parents, that meets the unique needs of the child. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.
In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201.
In sum, pursuant to the IDEA and Rowley, to be appropriate for STUDENT, the mainstreaming portion of STUDENT’s program must have been designed to meet his unique needs, reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, and the services that were provided must have actually comported with STUDENT’s January 2001 IEP.
The first question is whether STUDENT’s January 2001 IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs related to mainstreaming. STUDENT’s unique needs related to mainstreaming, i.e., the reasons why the team decided STUDENT was required to attend Quail Hollow for two hours each week to receive a FAPE, were generally undisputed: (1) to generalize information learned in his home ABA program in a school setting, (2) to increase communication, and (3) for STUDENT to socialize with peers. Testimony of MOTHER, Shook, Parrish, Bevernick. STUDENT’s IEP indicates that two of the team’s primary concerns were “the need to expand on communication development, increase socialization with peers.” District’s Exh. 17.
While STUDENT’s unique needs with regard to mainstreaming were well known to his IEP team, STUDENT’s IEP was not designed to meet those needs. The IEP fails to offer the services of an individual with expertise developing and supervising the inclusion of a child with STUDENT’s challenging needs into a regular education environment, an ‘inclusion specialist.’ The services of an inclusion specialist, or similarly qualified person, were necessary for STUDENT to benefit meaningfully from mainstreaming.
STUDENT lacks a functional communication system and is unable to interact with other children without facilitation. Testimony of Shook, MOTHER, Parrish, Braunhut. Janice Parrish, the school psychologist who observed STUDENT on three occasions during between October 2000 and the January 2001 IEP meeting, prepared a report which was incorporated in the January 2001 IEP. Her notations with regard to her observations of STUDENT’s class and playground participation are telling:
During each observation, STUDENT was positioned with a group of peers at work stations during “centers” working with his mother using special materials. Although he was unable to participate in the class activities and skills with the other students, he was generally able to stay on task and maintain appropriate behaviors within the behavioral expectations of the classroom setting . . . During the 15 minute recess period, the other students in the class were willing and anxious to be included in STUDENT’s play activities which his mother brought with them to school. Communication was difficult for his peers since STUDENT is nonverbal and thus unable to engage in conversation with them . . .
District’s Exh. 17.
Ms. Parrish’s observations (although she concluded that it “appeared” that STUDENT benefitted from his interactions) illustrate the fact that STUDENT required the services of a third party with expertise facilitating interactions and activities of an autistic child like STUDENT in classroom and playground activities. STUDENT could have participated in class activities and STUDENT could have benefitted from peer interactions if they were facilitated by someone with appropriate expertise.
The two persons responsible for the implementation of STUDENT’s mainstreaming in the classroom were STUDENT’s mother and the classroom teacher, Ruth Strudley, and neither possessed the requisite knowledge to sufficiently design or alter classroom or playground activities in such a way that STUDENT could generalize information learned in his home ABA program in a school setting, increase communication, or socialize with peers – the goals of mainstreaming. Ms. Strudley presented as a caring, kind, experienced teacher who operates a highly structured classroom. However, STUDENT was the first student mainstreamed in her classroom with autism, the first with a 1:1 aide, and the first with no effective communication system. Testimony of Strudley. Although Ms. Strudley testified that she felt that if she had questions she could communicate with school psychologist Janice Parrish, STUDENT’s occupational therapist or his speech pathologist, none of the three are inclusion specialists, and none actually acted in that capacity during the period at issue, and none were responsible for STUDENT’s classroom participation goal and objective (Footnote 15). Similarly, STUDENT’s mother was sufficiently trained to implement and oversee STUDENT’s home ABA program with the oversight of behavior analyst Stacey Shook, but she too lacked specific expertise or training regarding how to develop and facilitate appropriate interactions between STUDENT and peers. Testimony of MOTHER.
Because STUDENT’s IEP failed to offer the services of an ‘inclusion specialist’ it was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, and therefore, the mainstreaming component of STUDENT’s IEP was not appropriate (Footnote 16). The District did not provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education with regard to the mainstreaming component of his program from January 2001 to June 2001.
Extended School Year of 2001
In California, a school district is required to provide a special education student with ESY programming when the student requires special education and related services in excess of the regular academic year or the IEP team has determined the need for ESY programming. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043; compare with 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(a)(2). Section 3043 of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations defines such students in the following manner:
Such individuals shall have handicaps which are likely to continue indefinitely or for a prolonged period, and interruption of the pupil’s educational programming may cause regression, when coupled with limited recoupment capacity, rendering it impossible or unlikely that the pupil will attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that would otherwise be expected in view of his or her handicapping condition. It is not disputed that STUDENT was eligible for, and actually received an extensive extended school year program during the summer of 2001. It did not include, however, a continuation of the mainstreaming STUDENT received during the regular school year. As discussed above, the purpose of an ESY program is to extend instruction beyond the normal school year to prevent regression over the summer months. The question becomes whether STUDENT required mainstreaming over the summer months to prevent regression.
No persuasive evidence was provided by the District that STUDENT did not require mainstreaming during the summer to prevent regression. The burden of persuasion is on the school district to establish that it complied with the IDEA. Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist., No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994). Because of the lack of evidence regarding whether STUDENT required mainstreaming over the summer to prevent regression, and because the District had the burden to establish mainstreaming was not required during the ESY, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide STUDENT with appropriate mainstreaming during the ESY 2001.
In sum, the District failed to provide STUDENT with appropriate mainstreaming from August 2000 to January 2001 because it failed to provide services in conformity with his Laguna Salada IEP. The District failed to provide STUDENT with appropriate mainstreaming from January 2001 through June 2001 because its offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique mainstreaming needs. Finally, it failed to provide STUDENT with appropriate mainstreaming during the ESY 2001, when no such services were offered at all.
ISSUE NO. 2: Did the District provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education during the 2001-2002 school year, up to February 26, 2002?
Petitioner argues that the District should have offered STUDENT a school-based placement prior to the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year. Additionally, the Petitioner argues that the mainstreaming portion of STUDENT’s actual program was again inappropriate. Each contention will be discussed below.
Did the District fail to offer STUDENT a school-based placement in a timely manner?
It is undisputed that MOTHER requested a change of placement in June 2001. At that time she requested The Bay School, a private, nonpublic school exclusively for children with the diagnosis of autism that uses a strict ABA methodology. Among the reasons MOTHER requested a change of placement was that she was tired of her role as the person primarily responsible for STUDENT’s education. She supervised STUDENT’s program, including his 1:1 aides, on a daily basis, with only four hours per month of behavior analyst support services from Stacey Shook, who resides in another state. MOTHER further explained that if something were to happen to her, STUDENT’s program would fail. She also stated that she believed that someone with specific training and expertise was needed to oversee STUDENT’s program, and that she did not feel she was appropriately qualified to perform her then-current role in STUDENT’s program.
It is similarly undisputed that the IEP team began to discuss school-based placements during the June 5 and 15, 2001 IEP team meetings, and that the IEP team finally agreed upon goals and objectives in September 27, 2001. Nonetheless, the District did not make a formal, written, specific offer of a school based placement until February 26, 2002 (Footnote 17).
Petitioner argues that the District should have offered a school-based placement during the Fall of 2001, to be implemented during the 2001-2002 school year. The District contends that after STUDENT’s parents requested a school-based program in June 2001, the District waited until nearly March 2002 to make an offer in order to pursue assessment information.
The first question is whether STUDENT required a school-based placement at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year. The weight of the evidence, including the testimony of numerous District and Petitioner witnesses alike, established that STUDENT required a school-based placement at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year. Testimony of Shook, MOTHER, Bussard, Bevernick and Exh 19. Although the June 5 and 15, 2001 IEP indicates that STUDENT’s program would remain the same (a continuation of STUDENT’s home-based placement provided largely by STUDENT’s mother), the Hearing Officer finds that this agreement was only a stop-gap while the IEP team discussed and explored possible school-based placements (Footnote 18). Every placement discussion recorded on the multiple IEPs following the June 5 and 15, 2001 IEP team meeting, and every “offer” made by the District, included school-based placements for STUDENT. Mary Bevernick testified generally that the primary reason STUDENT’s home ABA goals and objectives were placed on SELPA forms in August 2001 was because the team recognized that STUDENT’s parents had requested a change of placement, and therefore those goals and objectives needed to be rewritten so that they could be implemented in a school setting (Footnote 19).
Having found that STUDENT required a school-based placement at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year, the next question is whether it was appropriate for the District to wait until February 26, 2002 to make a specific offer of a school-based placement where STUDENT’s agreed-upon goals and objectives could be implemented.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District denied STUDENT a free and appropriate public education when it waited nearly an entire semester after the September 2001 IEP team meeting to offer STUDENT a school based placement. The IDEA requires districts to provide all eligible children with a free and appropriate public education. 20 U.S.C. §1400 et seq. The regulations accompanying IDEA define “free appropriate public education” as “special education and related services that . . . are provided at public expense, under public supervision and direction, and without charge.” 34 C.F.R. §300.13(a) They further define FAPE as the district’s obligation to provide these services “in conformity with an individualized education program . . .” 34 C.F.R. §300.13(d). When STUDENT’s mother requested a school-based placement in June 2001, the District could no longer shift its responsibility to MOTHER who had, up to that point, provided the “supervision and instruction” over STUDENT’s services (Footnote 20). Because it waited until nearly March 2002 – nine months after MOTHER made the request and almost an entire semester after all goals and objectives were agreed upon – the District denied STUDENT a FAPE. Instead, the District should have, at a minimum, offered STUDENT an appropriate school-based placement “as soon as possible” after the September 2001 IEP team meeting. The regulations accompanying the IDEA require districts to implement IEP’s “as soon as possible” following any IEP team meeting where an IEP is developed, reviewed or revised. 34 C.F.R. §300.342. The District could not implement STUDENT’s agreed upon goals and objectives that were revised so that he could be transitioned to a school-based placement until after it offered STUDENT a school-based placement. Therefore, the District was required to offer a school-based placement as soon as possible after all goals and objectives were agreed upon. The District failed in this obligation.
The District’s argument that additional assessments were necessary to determine placement, and therefore the substantial delay was appropriate, is unpersuasive. The District completed one additional assessment months after STUDENT’s goals and objectives were agreed upon, and the IEP team did not change or alter any of STUDENT’s agreed-upon goals and objectives because of the information obtained from that assessment. Moreover, the District’s action of immediately exploring school-based placements beginning on September 27, 2001 is inconsistent with its position 9 (Footnote 21). Again, exploration was not enough. The District was required by law to make a single, specific, appropriate offer of a school-based placement where STUDENT’s agreed-upon goals and objectives could be immediately implemented, as soon as possible after the September 27, 2001 IEP team meeting. Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert denied, 513 U.S. 965, 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994); see also 20 U.S.C. §1415(b)(3).
In summary, the District failed to timely offer STUDENT a school-based placement during the 2001-2002 school year. The District was required to make an appropriate offer of a school-based program as soon as possible after the September 27, 2001 IEP team meeting, which it failed to do. Therefore, the District denied STUDENT a free and appropriate public education from September 27, 2001 through February 26, 2002, when it finally offered the Brook Knoll program (the appropriateness of the Brook Knoll program is discussed under Issue 3, below).
Was the mainstreaming component of STUDENT’s program during the 2001-2002 school year inappropriate?
For the same reasons discussed above for the period from January 2001 through June 2001, STUDENT’s mainstreaming was inappropriate during the entire 2001-2002 school year. Because STUDENT’s IEP failed to offer the services of an ‘inclusion specialist,’ it was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, and therefore, the mainstreaming component of STUDENT’s IEP was not appropriate.
The District’s failure to offer an appropriately qualified inclusion specialist has continued to deprive STUDENT of appropriate mainstreaming opportunities during the current school year. STUDENT’s mother and aide testified that STUDENT has remained isolated in Ruth Strudley’s classroom and that he has been included in very few activities with the nondisabled peers. They testified that STUDENT works on “maintenance” activities related to his home ABA program by himself during his mainstreaming time. STUDENT’s 1:1 aide, Grace Lee, testified that mainstreaming was not useful and that it would have been better for STUDENT to remain at home where he could at least learn new information instead of doing maintenance work. Testimony of Lee. Ms. Strudley testified that because the structure of the class had changed (she no longer used “centers” where children rotate from activity to activity), it was difficult to include STUDENT in any activities. She further explained that her first responsibility was to educate the whole class, not STUDENT (Footnote 22). Testimony of MOTHER and Lee. Had the District offered the services of an inclusion specialist, STUDENT’s mainstreaming time could have been structured to provide him with the opportunity to generalize information, to increase communication and to socialize with other children (STUDENT’s unique needs related to mainstreaming) (Footnote 23).
In sum, the District failed to offer or provide STUDENT with appropriate mainstreaming during the 2001-2002 school year. It also failed to offer STUDENT an appropriate school-based placement in a timely manner, and thereby denied STUDENT a FAPE up to February 26, 2002.
ISSUE NO. 3:Did the District’s February 26, 2002 offer of a special day class at Brook Knoll offer STUDENT a free and appropriate pubic education?
It has been determined above that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE up to February 26, 2002 because, in pertinent part, it failed to offer STUDENT a school-based placement as soon as possible after the September 27, 2001 IEP team meeting. On February 26, 2002, the District offered STUDENT placement in a special day class at the Brook Knoll School taught by Linda Koval (Footnote 24). The issue is whether the offer of Brook Knoll placement was an offer of a free and appropriate public education.
The Brook Knoll offer letter states, in pertinent part, as follows:
The District is offering immediate placement for STUDENT in a Special Day Class for Severely Handicapped students located at Brook Knoll School in Scotts Valley. This program is operated by the Santa Cruz County Office of Education. The classroom currently contains eight students who are enrolled in kindergarten through 4th grade. The teacher has extensive experience working with autistic students and other students with communication needs. She has experience using a variety of communication technologies with her students. An individual work station will be created within her classroom.
The primary goal of the placement for the first two months will be to implement STUDENT’s home ABA program in the classroom . . . .
District’s Exh. 71.
The offer letter also includes related services which are not in dispute, including occupational therapy and speech and language therapy. Additionally, the offer provides for the services of a 1:1 aide for “delivery of his ABA program for 5 hours per day,” and “twenty hours of Behavior Specialist consultation to STUDENT’s teacher . . . for the purposes of ensuring classroom integration of the programs, staff training, and facilitating socialization.” The District also offered “to provide four hours per month of specific ABA Behavior Specialist consultation in addition to the Behavior consultation for program integration.” The offer includes a transition program wherein STUDENT’s ABA services would be gradually increased in the school environment. At the end of the eight-week transition period, an IEP team meeting will be convened “to adjust goals and program delivery if necessary.” District’s Exh. 71.
As discussed above, to be substantively appropriate, the February 26, 2002 offer letter following the January 22, 2002 IEP, must be (1) designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, (2) reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit, and (3) comport with his IEP. Each factor will be discussed below.
Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs
STUDENT’s unique needs are not disputed. Both the District and the Petitioner stipulated at the Hearing that all of STUDENT’s agreed-upon goals and objectives which address all of his areas of need are appropriate. STUDENT’s goals address the unique-need areas of math, life skills, functional skills, social skills, reading and language arts, articulation, visual-motor, classroom/recess participation, computer access and self care.
It is also not disputed, as the District’s offer concedes, that one of STUDENT’s unique needs at this time is the use of a specific methodology to implement his goals and objectives, ABA. The primary goal of the placement is to implement STUDENT’s ABA program in a school environment, according to the District’s offer, where his 1:1 aides will continue to deliver the ABA program STUDENT has successfully used for several years. The offer also includes the services of “specific ABA Behavior Specialist consultation” for four hours each month).
The Petitioner argues that the District’s offer of services was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, particularly his undisputed need for implementation of his ABA program in a school environment, because the offer contains insufficient supervision services from a behavioral specialist who is qualified to oversee an ABA program. He also argues that it is not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs because Linda Koval has no experience and little training supervising an ABA program.
The Hearing Officer finds, based on a preponderance of the evidence, that the offer of services of a behavioral specialist is inadequate and does not come close to meeting STUDENT’s unique needs. Again, the District offered only four hours of monthly oversight from an ABA behavior specialist. The support services of a behavior specialist with particular expertise overseeing an ABA program such as STUDENT’s is essential for his ABA program to be successful. Testimony of Shook and MOTHER. Previously, STUDENT’s mother micromanaged his home program, trained and supervised STUDENT’s 1:1 aides, supervised his mainstreaming, collected data, helped develop progress reports and draft goals and objectives with Stacey Shook. According to Stacey Shook, the primary problem with STUDENT’s home program is that because of the intensity of STUDENT’s needs, and the volume of his ABA program, changes need to be made almost daily by someone with considerable expertise overseeing the program. Testimony of Shook. MOTHER was not qualified to do this. Testimony of MOTHER. Four hours per month, as the District offered, is also inadequate to accomplish these informed, daily changes. To address STUDENT’s unique needs, the behavior specialist with experience supervising ABA programs must be reasonably available throughout the school day to intervene and provide guidance. Testimony of Shook. Moreover, when a new 1:1 aide is trained the behavior specialist must also be available for significant periods of time to train and observe the aide, which may take weeks. In sum, the District’s offer is completely inadequate (Footnote 25).
Along the same lines, the twenty hours of initial behavior specialist services is inadequate and inappropriate (Footnote 26). The weight of the evidence established that these initial services would be insufficient to train even one of STUDENT’s aides. Testimony of Shook and MOTHER. Because those twenty hours were proposed for the “purposes of ensuring classroom integration of the programs, staff training, and facilitating socialization,” in essence, to develop the entire ABA program at Brook Knoll, they are not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The Petitioner appropriately rejected this offer (Footnote 27).
Petitioner’s second argument, that Linda Koval is not appropriately qualified to act essentially as program director over STUDENT’s ABA program, is similarly persuasive. While Ms. Koval, by all accounts, presented as a dedicated experienced teacher with significant training and experience implementing the goals and objectives of students with severe disabilities, she has insufficient experience and training in the methodology of ABA to supervise STUDENT’s ABA program. She testified that when the parents asked her about her knowledge of ABA, she did not know what it was. She testified that she had limited training approximately 20 years prior related to something akin to ABA, but that she uses the TEACHH methodology in her class (Footnote 28). Because she presently lacks the training and experience to oversee STUDENT’s ABA program, the offer of Ms. Koval is not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique need for the ABA methodology.
In sum, because the District’s offer at Brook Knoll was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, the District failed to offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (Footnote 29).
ISSUE NO. 4: Should STUDENT be placed at the Bay School, a private non-public ABA school, during the 2002-2003 school year?
Having found above that the District failed to offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education in its February 26, 2002 offer of placement at Brook Knoll, the next question is whether the Hearing Officer should order the District to pay for STUDENT’s proposed placement at the Bay School during the 2002-2003 school year (Footnote 30). Hearing officers have the authority to award relief which is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA, which may include prospective placement in a private school at public expense (Footnote 31). School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 370, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985). Given that hearing officers have the authority to make such an order, the question becomes whether The Bay School is appropriate for STUDENT.
It was not disputed that the Bay School could meet all of STUDENT’s unique needs. Testimony of Shook, Morgenstern. No District witness testified to the contrary. The Bay School is a private, nonpublic school that exclusively serves children with the diagnosis of autism. It uses a strict, scientific-based ABA methodology, which is required for STUDENT to receive a FAPE, according to both the Petitioner and the District.
The District argues that The Bay School is not appropriate for STUDENT because (1) it is “unavailable” because the director of the program, Barry Morgenstern, will not accept students without the approval of the student’s local educational agency; and (2) The Bay School is not the “least restrictive environment” for STUDENT.
The Hearing Officer finds the first argument, that The Bay School will not accept STUDENT because it will not accept students who are not placed by local educational agencies, unavailing. This was not an accurate reflection of Mr. Morgenstern’s testimony. Mr. Morgenstern testified that although he preferred that all students accepted by The Bay School arrive through district referral, he also would accept a student pursuant to a Hearing Officer order. STUDENT’s parents seek just such an order.
With regard to the District’s second argument, in addition to the substantive requirements developed above, special education law also requires that STUDENT be educated in the “least restrictive environment” (LRE) and that his removal from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and the severity of his disabilities is such that education in regular education classes with use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Education Code § 56031.
The Hearing Officer finds the District’s argument unpersuasive; The Bay School is the least restrictive environment where STUDENT’s unique needs can be met. The District’s proposed placement at Brook Knoll was substantively inappropriate and therefore not the least restrictive environment. While the District’s offer of Brook Knoll was the only substantive offer at issue (the District made no other placement offer between February 26, 2002 and the last day of the due process hearing), there was persuasive evidence that the only ABA program available in the greater Santa Cruz area at this time is The Bay School. Testimony of Morgernstern, Shook and MOTHER. Because The Bay School is the only available placement that can meet STUDENT’s unique needs, including his current need for the ABA methodology, The Bay School is the “least restrictive environment” for STUDENT.
Nonetheless, the evidence established that STUDENT would have mainstreaming opportunities if he were to attend the Bay School. Testimony of Morgenstern. One of the other ten students at The Bay School is mainstreamed. There was no persuasive evidence that STUDENT’s Bay School program could not provide him with the same opportunities.
For the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that The Bay School is the only appropriate placement for STUDENT. It is designed to meet his unique needs, reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, it will comport with his IEP, and it is the least restrictive environment where STUDENT will be able to receive a FAPE. Because The Bay School will provide STUDENT with a FAPE, and because the District’s offer of Brook Knoll failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE, STUDENT shall attend The Bay School at District expense during the entire 2002-2003 school year.
Petitioner also contended that the Hearing Officer should award placement at The Bay School during the entire 2002-2003 school year at District expense as “compensatory education” for the District’s failure to make a timely, appropriate offer of a school-based placement in September 2001. “Compensatory education” is another form of relief that a hearing officer may award when it is appropriate. Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist., 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). The purpose of compensatory education is to “ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Id. Petitioner’s argument is persuasive. The District failed to make a timely offer of an appropriate, school-based placement and the delay deprived STUDENT of a FAPE from September 2001 through February 2002. Therefore, STUDENT is additionally entitled to attend The Bay School at District expense during the entire 2002-2003 school as compensatory education.
Moreover, both as compensatory education for the District failure to provide STUDENT with appropriate mainstreaming services for two school years, and to supplement his opportunities to interact with typically developing peers while he attends The Bay School during the 2002-2003 school year, the District shall provide STUDENT with additional mainstreaming services, along with the services of an inclusion specialist. The IEP team shall meet and determine the nature and quantity of these additional mainstreaming services, and shall choose an appropriately qualified inclusion specialist. Such opportunities may include mainstreaming in a public school, reverse mainstreaming, or other appropriate interactions with typically developing peers; these opportunities shall not, however, interfere with STUDENT’s program at The Bay School.
ISSUE NO. 5: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
It has been previously determined (under Issue 4, above) that STUDENT is entitled to placement at The Bay School through the entire 2002-2003 school year, at District expense, both because it is appropriate for STUDENT and as compensatory education for the District’s failure to offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year. It has also been found above that the District shall provide STUDENT with appropriate mainstreaming opportunities and the services of an inclusion specialist, both to supplement STUDENT’s program at The Bay School and as compensatory education for the District’s past failures to provide STUDENT with appropriate mainstreaming opportunities.
ISSUE NO. 6: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of privately obtained assessments provided by Deanne Detmers and Dr. Tina Guterman?
Petitioner seeks reimbursement for the assessments he procured from Deanne Detmers and Dr. Tina Guterman. Pursuant to State and federal law, a parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation from a qualified specialist if the parent disagrees with the assessment conducted by the local educational agency. If the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment was appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent evaluation. Cal. Educ. Code §56329(b).
The District argues that reimbursement should not be awarded because (1) the parents did not seek the independent assessments because they “disagreed” with the District’s assessments, and (2) the independent assessment’s validity was not established, i.e., neither Deanne Detmers nor Tina Guterman conducted “assessments.” Instead, according to the District, they both only observed STUDENT.
The evidence also established that STUDENT’s parents requested District reimbursement for a neuropsychological assessment to be conducted by Tina Guterman at the September 27, 2001 IEP meeting, and that the District responded by agreeing to have Katie Merchant perform a neuropsychological assessment. STUDENT’s parents agreed to this proposed assessment on October 9, 2001. They also agreed at the same time to another District-proposed assessment, to be conducted by psychologist Caryl Hogan.
Nonetheless, STUDENT’s parents obtained private assessments from Deanne Detmers and Tina Guterman. Tina Guterman conducted her assessment of STUDENT on October 30 and November 6, 2001. Deanne Detmers conducted her assessment of STUDENT on October 30, 2001.
Caryl Hogan conducted her assessment of STUDENT on October 29 and November 2, 2001, and she drafted her report on November 27, 2001. On November 20, 2001, Katie Merchant determined that she could not assess STUDENT using standardized instruments. STUDENT’s parents withdrew consent for the assessment.
Tina Guterman’s Neuropsychological Assessment
The District’s argument that STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Tina Guterman’s assessment because they did not disagree with the District’s assessment, is persuasive. STUDENT’s parents requested a neuropsychological assessment at the September 27, 2001 IEP team meeting, agreed to a District-neuropsychological assessment, obtained their own private assessment, and after that, they revoked their consent to the District’s assessment. At the time they obtained their own assessment there was nothing with which to disagree. They did not, therefore, obtain Tina Guterman’s assessment because they disagreed with the District’s assessment, and they are not entitled to reimbursement.
Deanne Detmer’s Behavioral Assessment
Again, as discussed above, parents are entitled to reimbursement if they disagree with a District assessment and the District fails to prove at a hearing that its assessment was appropriate. The evidence established that the District proposed a comprehensive assessment from the Diagnostic Center at the IEP in June 15, 2001. That assessment would have evaluated, in pertinent part, STUDENT’s behavioral needs. District’s Exh. 25. STUDENT’s parents initially agreed to the assessment, and then revoked their consent (after both the parent and district portions of the referral packet had been completed) during the summer because, according to MOTHER, they had learned that the assessment would not be completed until after the end of October. After that, the District did not pursue an assessment of STUDENT in this area, did not present another assessment plan, and generally failed to provide any evidence of its efforts to assess STUDENT’s behavioral needs.
Because the District failed to appropriately assess STUDENT in an area that it deemed necessary in the summer of 2001, and failed to explain at the Hearing any reason why it no longer needed such information, it failed to appropriately assess STUDENT in this area. STUDENT’s parents are therefore entitled to reimbursement for the assessment conducted by Deanne Detmers.
The District’s argument that STUDENT’s parents did not seek Ms. Detmer’s assessment because they disagreed with the District’s is not persuasive. The bare fact that they obtained their own independent assessment from Deanne Detmers after the District failed to assess STUDENT in this area established that they disagreed with the District’s action. The District’s second argument, that STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement because Ms. Detmer’s assessment was inadequate is similarly unpersuasive. There is no such requirement in the law.
ORDER
1. Within 20 business days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting. Representative(s) of The Bay School shall be invited and Stacey Shook of NWBA shall be invited, at District expense. STUDENT’s IEP shall be amended to include placement at The Bay School for the entire 2002-2003 school year, at District expense. Additionally, the IEP team shall amend STUDENT’s IEP to include appropriate mainstreaming services to supplement STUDENT’s Bay School program. STUDENT shall also be provided with the services of an appropriately qualified inclusion specialist.
2. Within 30 business after receipt of proof of payment, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the cost of the assessment conducted by Deanne Detmers.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
1. Did the District provide STUDENT with appropriate mainstreaming during the 2000-2001 school year, including the extended school year (ESY)?
-The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Did the District provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education during the 2001-2002 school year, up to February 26, 2002?
-The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Did the District’s February 26, 2002 offer of a special day class at Brook Knoll offer STUDENT a free and appropriate pubic education?
-The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Should STUDENT be placed at the Bay School, a private non-public ABA school, during the 2002-2003 school year?
-The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
-The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of privately obtained assessments provided by Deanne Detmers and Dr. Tina Guterman?
-The District prevailed on this issue with regard to Tina Guterman’s assessment. The Petitioner prevailed with regard to Deanne Detmer’s assessment.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Date: June 20, 2002 Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The issues have been framed to reflect the discussions with the parties and for proper analysis.
2. The District’s version of this IEP (District’s Exh. 17) does not include a copy of the home ABA program progress report or a copy of the home ABA program “New Goals” document prepared by Stacey Shook and MOTHER.
3. As the Laguna Salada District had done previously, the District generally attempted to fulfill its obligation to provide STUDENT with a FAPE by paying for 1:1 aides in the home program, Stacey Shook’s support services, related services, and mainstreaming. On a day-to-day basis, MOTHER remained the person responsible for the bulk of STUDENT’s program.
4. Again, as discussed above, MOTHER requested a school-based placement at the June 5 and 15, 2001 IEP team meetings, in pertinent part, because she no longer wanted to provide STUDENT’s educational services. She has continued, despite her request in June 2001, to provide STUDENT’s educational services up through the Hearing.
5. It was not disputed that, although STUDENT has been in the District since August 2000, no District employee or assessor, or anyone acting on behalf of the District, has ever reviewed the data collected by STUDENT’s tutors.
6. The parents felt that the District had invited the additional individuals to intimidate them. Testimony of MOTHER.
7. The District asserts that requiring MOTHER to put the ABA goals on SELPA forms was a necessary first step in the process of revision of the goals, and that the purpose was to change the ABA “jargon” to familiar terms so that those goals could be implemented in a school setting.
8. STUDENT parents believed that the ABA goals and objectives had been approved at the June 5 and 15, 2001 IEP meetings. The Hearing Officer notes that the goals and objectives presented by Stacey Shook and MOTHER at the June meetings were implemented during the extended school year. Testimony of Shook and MOTHER.
9. Technically, stay put only applies after a party requests a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. §1415(j). STUDENT’s parents did not request a due process hearing until December 2001, so stay put did not apply at this time.
10. It was not disputed that the COE program identified was the program at Natural Bridges.
11. The letter contains a similar, albeit toned-down notation about STUDENT’s previous mainstreaming opportunities in Ruth Strudley’s class as the January “offer” letter. It says that “STUDENT has been educated at home, with only brief, highly structured visits to school under restrictions that have provided him with limited opportunities for classroom staff to work with him.”
12. At the beginning of the due process hearing, the District stipulated that this letter constituted the District’s only “appropriate” offer of placement and as such, other offers that had been previously made or discussed since June of 2001 were not explored at the Hearing.
13. Both ‘mainstreaming’ and ‘inclusion’ were used interchangeably at the Hearing.
14. Before the expiration of the 30-day period (which ended approximately October 1, 2001), the District was required to hold an IEP meeting and make a “final recommendation” of placement. Cal. Educ. Code §56325(b). Instead of convening an IEP team meeting, reviewing STUDENT’s placement and making a “final recommendation,” the District obtained two extensions to the initial IEP team meeting from STUDENT’s parents.
15. Janice Parrish described herself as a “liaison” between STUDENT’s mother and the classroom teacher, whose relationship quickly deteriorated – principally because of their differing expectations regarding STUDENT’s mainstreaming program.
16. Because it has been determined that STUDENT’s program was not designed to meet his unique needs, it is not necessary to analyze whether it was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some benefit or whether his program comported with his IEP. It is also not necessary to discuss Petitioner’s other arguments with regard to STUDENT’s program, including the failure of the regular education classroom teacher to provide periodic progress reports.
17. Again, many school based programs were discussed and offered during the process; however, the District chose to provide evidence on the appropriateness of only the offer letter dated February 26, 2002.
18. The IEP states that “the team also discussed the possible placement option of Bay School. Team members will visit and team will reconvene to discuss placement option for fall 2001.” District’s Exh. 19.
19. The Hearing Officer also notes that in June 2001, MOTHER requested a change in placement, in part, because she did not want to be STUDENT’s primary educational service provider any longer. At that point, it was incumbent on the District to offer STUDENT a free, appropriate and “public” educational placement. While the IDEA anticipates that special education may be provided in the home (the definition of ‘special education’ includes ‘instruction . . . in the home’) the Hearing Officer is not aware of any authority for the proposition that an LEA may require parents to personally provide the primary educational services themselves unless the parents consent to do so. 20 U.S.C. §1401(25). Absent parental consent, such a program is not a “public” education, but rather an LEA shifting its responsibility to educate a child to an unwilling parent.
20. The District never really grasped its fundamental responsibility to provide STUDENT with a FAPE; it never assumed responsibility over his special education services, including his ABA program.
21. In Mary Bevernick’s letter to the parents written on September 4, 2001, (after the parents walked out of the August 31, 2001 IEP meeting because the District members of the IEP team refused to discuss placement) she promised that after the team agreed to the draft goals and objectives at the upcoming IEP meeting, “we can move directly to placement.” District’s Exh. 37. Ms. Bevernick also noted that “by stopping the goal setting process, you guaranteed that STUDENT’s current placement would remain in place . . . I expect that you will want to attend the next IEP meeting in order to allow the process to unfold so we can discuss placement.” Id.
22. STUDENT was not even greeted when he arrived for numerous mainstreaming visits, according to his aide.
23. STUDENT’s placement was also required to comport with his IEP. See, 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176. STUDENT’s placement did not comport with his IEP because the District excluded MOTHER from campus for two months. Testimony of MOTHER and Bevernick. Although MOTHER was not qualified to act in that capacity, the IEP identifies her as the person who was primarily responsible for the implementation of STUDENT’s mainstreaming program. Because STUDENT’s services did not comport with his (flawed) IEP, it was inappropriate.
24. In the period between September 27, 2001 and February 26, 2002, the District “offered” STUDENT multiple placements, however, at the Hearing, the District sought to prove only that the February 26, 2002 offer letter which followed the January 22, 2002 IEP team meeting, was appropriate for STUDENT.
25. The District’s offer cannot be “fixed” by ordering the District to hire a full-time, ABA trained certified behavior analyst (such as Stacey Shook), because there was evidence that no such a person exists in the greater Santa Cruz area. There was evidence presented at the Hearing that the only certified ABA program in the area is The Bay School, operated by Barry Morgenstern. Testimony of Shook and Morgenstern.
26. In the period between September 27, 2001 and February 26, 2002, the District “offered” STUDENT multiple placements, however, at the Hearing, the District sought to prove only that the February 26, 2002 offer letter which followed the January 22, 2002 IEP team meeting, was appropriate for STUDENT.
27. What the District’s offer amounts to is a proposal to move STUDENT’s home ABA program to Brook Knoll School, without the services of STUDENT’s mother, who was the person who micromanaged STUDENT’s entire program all day and every day. STUDENT’s program would fail for the same reason his mainstreaming program failed the last two school years – inappropriate and inadequate supervision by a qualified, trained expert.
28. Ms. Koval explained that she would be willing to receive any necessary training in ABA. There was no persuasive testimony at the hearing as to how long this would take, or if it would even be possible, given Ms. Koval’s schedule. She teaches full time at the Brook Knoll School. Ms. Koval is a sincere, experienced and dedicated teacher, and it is the opinion of the Hearing Officer that she would eventually obtain the necessary training and experience to supervise STUDENT’s ABA program on a daily basis in her classroom. However, the question is whether she has the appropriate training and experience to supervise STUDENT’s ABA program immediately.
29. Because it has been found that the District’s offer is not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, it not necessary to discuss whether the Brook Knoll offer was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit, or if the offer comports with STUDENT’s IEP. Nonetheless, the weight of the evidence established that the District’s offer cannot be implemented (and therefore does not comport with STUDENT’s IEP) because Linda Koval’s small classroom lacks an individual, separate space where STUDENT’s ABA program can be delivered by his 1:1 aide.
30. There was no persuasive evidence provided at hearing that there is an alternative District or COE placement available in the District where STUDENT can receive a FAPE. In fact, there was persuasive evidence provided at the Hearing that there are no programs or schools (public or private) anywhere in the greater Santa Cruz area which utilize the ABA methodology, which STUDENT requires to receive a FAPE at this time, other than The Bay School. 31. State law has an additional requirement regarding prospective placement – that a hearing officer may not order a placement at a private school if that school is not a State-certified “nonpublic” school or agency. Cal. Educ. Code §56505.2. The Bay School is, however, a State-certified nonpublic school.
