California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 18, 2002
Student v. Santa Ana Unified School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 2759-01, SN01-02759, SN01-02676 · Hearing Officer Deborah M. Cooke
Santa Ana Unified must deliver missed settlement services and make a clear placement offer; Alex Center placement denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The decision notes an earlier due process case (SN 00-01460) dismissed under the March 15, 2001 settlement, and a CDE compliance report dated July 6, 2001. It holds that the compliance report has no preclusive effect.
Summary
A parent of a 17-year-old eleventh grader eligible under mild mental retardation filed for due process. She claimed Santa Ana Unified had not carried out a March 2001 settlement agreement and the IEP attached to it. The district filed its own case asking to have its January 31, 2002 IEP offer upheld. At hearing, the district admitted it had not provided school-year Lindamood-Bell reading instruction, most of the required occupational therapy (OT) sessions, or the promised assistive technology software and training.
Hearing Officer Deborah M. Cooke found the district also never worked on the student's cursive handwriting goal. She found it did work on his math goals. She also held that a promise of "up to 5 textbooks" per semester did not require any textbooks. She enforced the settlement. All missed services must start by the first month of the 2002-2003 school year, and the Alex Center must assess handwriting and OT needs. She denied placement at the Alex Center, a nonpublic school for students with brain injuries, because it was too socially restrictive and unrelated to the missed services. She found the January 2002 IEP's goals and services generally appropriate. However, it made no clear written placement offer, and keeping the student at Santa Ana High School was inappropriate. The district must hold an IEP meeting within 15 days to add OT and vision goals and offer a specific self-contained special day class.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO treated a special education settlement agreement as an enforceable contract that includes the IEP attached to it. It also shows that "up to" wording may create no firm duty. A district offer naming only a general special day class, without a specific program or site, failed the clear-offer rule in Union v. Smith.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedImplementation
Issue 1a. Did the District fail to perform its obligations under the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement and attached IEP dated March 14, 2001, with respect to working on Student's handwriting?
The IEP had a cursive handwriting goal that was never worked on, and the District did not prove it complied, so it breached the settlement.
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue 1b. Did the District fail to perform its obligations under the settlement agreement and March 14, 2001 IEP with respect to working on specific areas in math (including the claim that teachers and aides did Student's work for him)?
The evidence showed Student worked on his math goals, and there was no credible evidence that staff did his work for him.
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue 1c. Did the District fail to perform its obligations under the settlement agreement by not providing Student with textbooks at his ability level for social studies, science, and math?
A promise to provide 'up to 5 textbooks per semester' did not require the District to provide any textbooks, so there was no breach.
- Student prevailedImplementation
Issue 1 (conceded). District concessions: failure to provide school-year Lindamood-Bell services, failure to provide 24 OT sessions under the June 11, 2001 IEP (only 5.5 provided), and failure to provide assistive technology software and training under the October 10, 2001 IEP
The District conceded at hearing that it failed to provide these settlement and IEP services.
- Student prevailed in partImplementation
Issue 2. If the District failed to perform its obligations under the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement and attached IEP dated March 14, 2001, what is the appropriate remedy for Student?
The settlement was enforced and all missed services were ordered, but placement at the Alex Center was denied because it had no connection to the missed services and was too socially restrictive.
- Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE
Issue 3. Does the District's offer contained in the January 31, 2002 IEP constitute an appropriate placement for Student?
The goals and services were generally appropriate, but the IEP made no clear written placement offer, and the implied continued placement at Santa Ana High School was substantively inappropriate. The District had filed asking for its offer to be upheld.
- Not reachedIEP procedure
Issue fn13. Did the District fail to follow IDEA procedural requirements by not giving timely notice of the December 12, 2001 IEP meeting?
Not decided, because the IEP was ordered to be reconvened and revised anyway.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to assess. Within 10 calendar days of the decision, as the parties agreed, the District shall arrange for the Alex Center to assess Student's handwriting and any other occupational therapy needs.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to: (a) develop OT and vision therapy goals; (b) ensure social interaction with regular education peers; (c) determine Student's interests and long-term goals for the transition plan; (d) appoint a qualified individual to oversee implementation of the IEP; and (e) provide an appropriate placement to implement the January 31, 2002 IEP, with the Hearing Officer's recommendations, for the rest of 2001-2002.
- Placement ordered. The January 31, 2002 IEP may be implemented in a self-contained special day class on a District campus other than Santa Ana High School, or in another nearby district, through a specific formal written placement offer.
- Compensatory education. No later than the first month of the 2002-2003 school year, Student shall begin receiving the program and services agreed in the March 15, 2001 settlement and March 14, 2001 IEP, including occupational therapy, Lindamood-Bell instruction, and assistive technology equipment, service, and training. Lindamood-Bell services may not be provided at Santa Ana High School. The IEP team decides the timing and whether the extra 25% of services the District proposed is needed.
- When developing FAPE for 2002-2003, the District must account for implementing the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement at the same time.
Key authorities
Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; S.V. v. Sherwood School Dist.; Lucht v. Molalla River School Dist.; Weddington Productions, Inc. v. Flick; Corkland v. Boscoe
People named in the decision
- Cristina Bravo Diaz, interpreter
- Bobby Santillan, SELPA administrator / special education director, Santa Ana Unified School District
- Richard Erhard, assistant director of special education, Santa Ana Unified School District
- Melissa Ramirez, Regional Center case worker, Orange County Regional Center
- Donald Greene, Regional Center employee, Orange County Regional Center
- Karen Steadman, special education teacher (former case carrier, math and reading teacher), Santa Ana High School
- Robert Patterson, licensed psychologist; psychoeducational assessor, witness for District, Private practice; Regional Center vendor
- Sharon Grandinette, founder and director of nonpublic school, Alex Center
- Alex Center, nonpublic school for individuals with brain injuries; ordered to conduct OT/handwriting assessment
- Mr. Oaks, Lindamood-Bell instructor (after-school)
- Mr. Real, teacher to be trained in Lindamood-Bell, Santa Ana High School
- Ms. Davis, teacher/aide in math, Santa Ana High School
- Everlina Oliver, special day class teacher named in January 31, 2002 IEP, Santa Ana High School
- Assistive Technology Exchange Center (ATEC), assistive technology assessor
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in La Quinta, California, on February 5, 6, 12, and 13, 2002.
Petitioner STUDENT (hereafter, Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by his mother, MOTHER. Also present on the first two days of hearing on behalf of the Petitioner was his father, FATHER. Interpreter Cristina Bravo Diaz was present on each day of the hearing. Respondent Santa Ana Unified School District (hereafter, Respondent or District) was represented at the hearing by attorney A. Patrick Munoz of the law offices of Rutan & Tucker. Also present on behalf of the Respondent were Bobby Santillan, special education local plan area administrator, and Richard Erhard, assistant director of special education for the District. The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: Melissa Ramirez, STUDENT’S Regional Center case worker; Donald Greene, employee with the Regional Center; Karen Steadman, special education teacher at Santa Ana High School; Petitioner STUDENT; and MOTHER, STUDENT’S mother.
The following witnesses were called by Respondent: Robert Patterson, licensed psychologist; Sharon Grandinette, director of the Alex Center; Richard Erhard; and Bobby Santillan.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and oral closing statements were made by both parties. The record was closed on February 13, 2002.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
Petitioner alleges that the District failed to comply with provisions of the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement, which, in addition to other obligations, required the District to implement the IEP dated March 14, 2001. The Hearing Officer notes that the California Department of Education (“CDE”) previously issued a compliance report dated July 6, 2001, in which it made a determination as to whether the District failed to implement Petitioner’s goals and objectives related to arithmetic, reading and writing in accordance with Petitioner’s then-draft IEP dated March 14, 2001. The CDE found that the math instruction provided by the District did not reflect instruction that was congruent with the assessment of the student. The CDE also found, however, that the District was not required to implement a draft IEP.(Footnote 2) Notwithstanding the CDE’s review and findings regarding the District’s compliance with the March 14, 2001 IEP, a due process hearing, which involves the receipt of testimony and documentary evidence, and conclusions of law, was still necessary in this case in order to determine what obligations, if any, of the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement were not performed and what Petitioner may be entitled to as a remedy. It is noted that a CDE compliance report’s findings and conclusions do not have collateral estoppel or res judicata effect in a due process hearing. Following a compliance investigation, a party may still pursue a due process hearing on the same issues, and the hearing decision will prevail over a conflicting compliance report determination. (Lucht v. Molalla River School Dist. 57 F.Supp.2d 1060, 1065 (D. Ore. 1999); see also SEHO Order, Fremont Unified School District v. Student, Nos. SN 793-00/1770-00 (Nov. 13, 2000).
ISSUES(Footnote 3)
1. Did the District fail to perform its obligations under the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement and attached IEP dated March 14, 2001, with respect to working on STUDENT’S handwriting, working on specific areas in math, and providing STUDENT with textbooks at his ability level for social studies, science, and math?(Footnote 4)
2. If the District failed to perform its obligations pursuant to the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement and attached IEP dated March 14, 2001, what is the appropriate remedy for STUDENT?
3. Does the District’s offer contained in the January 31, 2002 IEP constitute an appropriate placement for STUDENT?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
First, Petitioner alleges that from March 15, 2001, to the present, the District failed to implement the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement and the incorporated individualized education program (IEP) dated March 14, 2001, with regard to the following: (a) working on STUDENT’S handwriting; (b) working on specific areas in math and without having others do the work for him; (c) providing Lindamood Bell (LMB) services two to three times each week, not including the services provided during the summer program of 2001; and (d) providing STUDENT with textbooks at his ability level for social studies, science, and math. Petitioner also contends that from June 11, 2001, to the present, the District failed to implement the June 11, 2001 IEP regarding the provision of occupational therapy services, and failed to implement the October 10, 2001 IEP minutes regarding assistive technology services.
Petitioner argues that because the District failed to implement the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement, he is entitled to compensatory education in the form of placement at the Alex Center for traumatically brain injured individuals, with services in reading, writing, and math until the age 22. Petitioner also requests that the Alex Center assess his occupational therapy (OT) needs and provide a recommendation as to the OT services he requires.
During the hearing, the District conceded that from March 15, 2001, to the present, it failed to implement the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement, except with regard to three allegations. First, the District argued that there were no goals in STUDENT’S IEP with respect to handwriting, only vague references to cursive writing. Second, the District contends that Petitioner’s allegations that math goals were not implemented and that others were doing STUDENT’S work for him were not supported by the evidence. Lastly, the District contends that although the evidence suggests that the District did not provide STUDENT with up to five textbooks as stated in the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement, the District did provide STUDENT with other materials.
Lastly, Petitioner contends that he was denied a FAPE because the District failed to provide his parents with timely notice of the December 12, 2001 IEP team meeting.
Regarding notification of the December 12, 2001 IEP meeting, the District argued that although MOTHER was not present at the December 12, 2001 IEP meeting, Petitioner suffered no harm because MOTHER subsequently attended the rescheduled January 10, 2002 IEP meeting and had an opportunity to participate.
Also still outstanding is the issue of the appropriateness of the District’s offered placement as noted in the January 31, 2002 IEP. Thus, the Hearing Officer will make a determination regarding the nonconceded issues and, additionally, will determine whether Petitioner is entitled to a remedy, and if so, to what extent.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a seventeen-year-old student with low borderline functioning and mild retardation cognitively and qualifies for special education services under the category of mild mental retardation. He has significant discrepancies between ability and achievement in all basic academic areas. He is a resident of the Santa Ana Unified School District and attends the eleventh grade at Santa Ana High School in the District. He has attended Santa Ana High School since the ninth grade and is currently placed in a special day class with designated instruction and services in the areas of occupational therapy, assistive technology, and transportation.
A previous due process hearing involving these same parties was initiated by Petitioner, but was ultimately dismissed pursuant to a settlement agreement reached by the parties on March 15, 2001 (SN 00-01460). The day before the March 15, 2001 settlement, the parties convened an IEP meeting and devised an educational program. This program was adopted the next day by the parties, pursuant to a settlement agreement. In addition to agreeing to implement the March 14, 2001 IEP, the settlement agreement provided for, among other services, STUDENT’S receipt of Lindamood Bell (LMB) services through an intensive summer program and continued LMB instruction taught by Mr. Oaks on an after-school basis during the school year. The agreement also provided for STUDENT’S teacher, Mr. Real, to be trained in the LMB program. The March 15, 2001 settlement agreement required the District to provide STUDENT with up to five textbooks per semester to supplement the books used in his program. Selection of the books was to be agreed upon by STUDENT’S teachers and the Orange County Regional Center (OCRC). Melissa Ramirez of the OCRC was to be notified by the District of all IEP dates and meetings. Goals and objectives were drafted for STUDENT in the areas of mainstreaming, reading and reading comprehension, written language, math, communication, self-help, motor, prevocational/vocational, and social/emotional. The parties also agreed that assessments would be conducted in the areas of assistive technology, occupational therapy (OT), and developmental optometry.
On June 11, 2001, another IEP meeting was held to review the occupational therapy and vision assessments that had been performed. The June 11, 2001 IEP team agreed to add occupational therapy as a related service to STUDENT’S IEP at the rate of one hour per week. Additionally, recommendations were made for reducing the classroom effects of STUDENT’S visual deficiencies, and goals and objectives were added to his IEP to help increase his visual perceptual skills, bilateral coordination skills, and upper extremity strength and dexterity skills.
An assistive technology assessment was performed on STUDENT by Assistive Technology Exchange Center (ATEC), and a report was later prepared on July 2, 2001. The ATEC report included recommendations with respect to specific equipment, software, and setup and training on the use of the software. At an IEP meeting held on October 10, 2001, the parties agreed to implement ATEC’s recommendations for assistive technology. The October 10, 2001 IEP is STUDENT’S last agreed-upon and implemented IEP.
On November 16, 2001, the IEP team met to write STUDENT’S annual IEP. MOTHER was in attendance and invited a news reporter and the president of the Santa Ana Republican Women Federated to attend. The District explained that the IEP meeting was confidential; however, the reporter indicated that MOTHER had given her permission to attend by inviting her to the IEP meeting. The IEP meeting continued with all participants present. The November 2001 IEP was not signed by MOTHER. The IEP document indicates that STUDENT’S then-case carrier at Santa Ana High School, Karen Steadman, advised MOTHER at the end of the meeting not to sign the IEP because Ms. Steadman did not believe the goals and objectives were complete or appropriate for STUDENT.
On December 5, 2001, the Hearing Office received a due process hearing request from STUDENT’S mother, MOTHER, on behalf her son. The request alleged that STUDENT was not receiving an appropriate education and that the District was not implementing the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement between the parties. MOTHER requested that STUDENT be transferred to the Alex Center, a private school for individuals with brain injury.
On December 12, 2001, another IEP meeting was held to discuss STUDENT’S goals and objectives. MOTHER did not attend the meeting, contending at hearing that she was not provided with reasonable notice of the meeting time. Notwithstanding the parent’s absence, the IEP team proceeded with that meeting and discussed MOTHER’s request that the IEP team explore the appropriateness of STUDENT’S placement at the Alex Center. An Alex Center representative was present at the meeting and expressed her views regarding the program offered there. The IEP team suggested that STUDENT’S former case carrier, Karen Steadman, meet with all of STUDENT’S teachers and review the draft IEP goals and objectives with MOTHER and reschedule the IEP meeting to January 10, 2002, so that MOTHER could be present and the IEP team could attempt to complete the IEP.
On December 18, 2001, the Hearing Office received a due process hearing request from the District, in which it sought an order from the Hearing Office confirming the appropriateness of the placement it proposes for STUDENT. The District also requested that its case, SN01-02759, be consolidated with Petitioner’s pending case, SN01-02676. The motion to consolidate the two cases was granted.
On January 10, 2002, the next IEP meeting was held and attended by the District members of the IEP team and MOTHER. STUDENT had previously been assessed in December 2000 by psychologist Robert Patterson, and during the January 2002 IEP meeting, the IEP team spent most of the time reviewing Dr. Patterson’s psychoeducational report and explaining the results of the assessment to MOTHER. As a result, the IEP team decided that goals and objectives on the proposed draft IEP would be reviewed at the next meeting because they had been unable to review anything other than Dr. Patterson’s report at that meeting. Another IEP meeting was scheduled for January 31, 2002.
MOTHER did not attend the January 31, 2002 IEP meeting, but forwarded a letter dated January 25, 2002, to the District stating that she believed she had been treated rudely and harassed by the District at previous IEP meetings, and therefore, she did not want to meet in IEP meetings with the District, but preferred to resolve any disputes through a due process hearing.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. Did the District fail to perform its obligations under the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement and attached IEP dated March 14, 2001, with respect to working on STUDENT’S handwriting, working on specific areas in math, and providing STUDENT with textbooks at his ability level for social studies, science, and math?
A settlement agreement is a contract, and its enforceability is governed by contract law. (Weddington Productions, Inc. v. Flick (1998) 60 Cal.App.4th 793, 810.) Documents referred to in the agreement, to be executed at a later time, are enforceable if there was a meeting of the minds over the terms of those incorporated documents. (Corkland v. Boscoe (1984) 156 Cal. App. 3d 989, 992, 995, 203 Cal. Rptr. 356.) In Corkland v. Boscoe, for example, the court specifically enforced a settlement agreement in a real estate case, stating “it is clear that the settlement agreement includes not only that document denominated “Settlement Agreement,” but the two promissory notes and deeds of trust executed pursuant thereto and later withdrawn by Boscoe. It is indisputed [sic] that there was a meeting of the minds of all the parties as to all material portions of the notes and deeds, and there is no substantial reason to further delay the consummation of the agreement." Such reasoning applies with equal force when considering settlement agreements in the special education arena. Here, the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement incorporated into its provisions the IEP dated March 14, 2001, which therefore requires the Hearing Officer to evaluate the District’s adherence to the terms of both documents as one binding settlement agreement.
At hearing, the District made the following concessions regarding its failure to meet its obligations under the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement:
1. Other than the LMB services provided in the summer 2001, the District failed to provide LMB services in accordance with the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement.(Footnote 5)
2. Pursuant to the IEP dated June 11, 2001, the District should have provided STUDENT with twenty-four sessions of OT since June 2001; however, the District has provided only five and one-half of the required OT sessions.(Footnote 6)
3. The District failed to provide assistive technology services in accordance with the October 10, 2001 IEP and the recommendations made therein by the Assistive Technology Exchange Center (“ATEC”). Specifically, the District conceded that it failed to provide the Write: OutLoud computer software and Start-to-Finish series of books. It also conceded that it failed to provide the six hours of recommended assistive technology training, which was to include the set-up and installation of the Write: OutLoud software at home and/or at school and training STUDENT, his mother, and school staff on the use of the software. (See July 2, 2001 ATEC recommendation, attached to October 10, 2001 IEP minutes - Resp.’s Exh. 29.) Both parties agreed that the District provided the recommended Show Me Math and Dollars & Cents computer software, but provided no training on the software.
Although the District conceded above that it failed to perform some of its obligations under the settlement agreement, still remaining in dispute is whether the District met its obligations under the settlement agreement with respect to handwriting, math, and the textbooks. Therefore, notwithstanding the District’s concessions as noted above, the Hearing Officer analyzes Petitioner’s allegations regarding these three nonconceded issues.
Handwriting
In the area of handwriting, the IEP dated March 14, 2001, includes a goal and corresponding objectives requiring STUDENT to practice and utilize cursive writing ultimately 100% of the time, unless an assignment requires him to use manuscript or some other mode of communication. STUDENT’S progress on this handwriting goal was to be evaluated by the special education teacher’s observation and by the student’s record and transcript. (Resp.’s Exh. 4.) According to STUDENT’S former case carrier, Karen Steadman, she has had very little opportunity to work on STUDENT’S handwriting because the appropriate handwriting books were not made available to her.(Footnote 7) Ms. Steadman testified that STUDENT needs handwriting books to be able to practice his handwriting in all of his classes. In addition, STUDENT testified that he had not worked on his cursive handwriting this year or last year.
The evidence indicates that STUDENT has a need in the area of handwriting and that the IEP dated March 14, 2001, included a goal and objectives designed to address that need. According to the testimonies of Ms. Steadman and STUDENT, the goal and objectives were not worked on from March 15, 2001, to the present. The District did not meet its burden of proving that it had complied with the IEP by working on the handwriting goal and objectives. The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that the District failed to implement the March 2001 settlement agreement with respect to working on STUDENT’S handwriting goals.
Math
In the area of math, Petitioner contends that the District did not work on specific areas in math as identified by his IEP goals and also argued that STUDENT’S teachers and aides did the work for him. The District argues that Petitioner’s allegations are not supported by the evidence.
The IEP dated March 14, 2001, sets forth goals designed to address STUDENT’S math operation skills with two or more digit numbers and time telling skills. The IEP also includes goals to help increase his skills in math operations using fractions, percentages, decimals, averaging, liquid and linear measurement, and basic banking concepts.
STUDENT’S math teacher, Karen Steadman, testified that she has worked on STUDENT’S math goals using manipulatives and books from the school’s math department. Ms. Steadman also testified that STUDENT’S mother purchased a computer program that STUDENT works on while in her class. STUDENT is currently in her math with business applications class. According to Ms. Steadman, this class is too difficult for STUDENT because the textbook used in that class is at a reading level much higher than what he is capable of reading. Ms. Steadman opined that STUDENT needs to work on math skills that are at a much lower level than those included in the math textbook. STUDENT testified that he goes to his math class everyday and stated that he has been working on fractions, decimals, telling time, counting money, addition, subtraction, multiplication, division, and measuring water. And although he was unsure, he stated that he thought Ms. Steadman had talked to him about percentages. STUDENT also testified that he plays math games on the computer in Ms. Steadman’s class. The Hearing Officer finds that although STUDENT may have had difficulty meeting his math goals due to the difficulty of the work, the evidence indicates that he has been working on the math goals and objectives pursuant to his March 14, 2001 IEP.
With regard to the allegation that STUDENT’S teachers and aides have been doing his work for him, when questioned about this, STUDENT responded in a confused manner, initially stating that on various occasions Ms. Steadman and Ms. Davis did his math work for him. STUDENT required a great amount of time to respond to this line of questioning and amended his testimony by later stating that each teacher only helped him with math work. The Hearing Officer gives little weight to STUDENT’S testimony on this issue because it was highly questionable whether STUDENT understood the difference between someone helping him with work and someone doing the work for him.
The Hearing Officer finds that there was no credible evidence to support Petitioner’s allegation that STUDENT’S teachers did his math work for him. Rather, the evidence suggests that STUDENT received assistance from his teachers and aides while working on his math goals and objectives. The fact that the math goals and objectives and the textbook may have been too difficult for STUDENT is not relevant to the question of whether STUDENT’S teachers and aides did his work for him. However, the evidence does indicate that the IEP team may need to review the appropriateness of these math goals and the textbooks used to teach him the work. The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that the District satisfied the math requirements set forth in the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement.
Textbooks
Petitioner alleges that the District has not met its obligations under the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement to provide textbooks in social studies, science, and math that are at his skill level. In its closing, the District stated that although there was evidence that it has not provided up to five textbooks as stated in the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement, it did, nevertheless, provide other materials, such as a computer, that were of benefit to STUDENT. The District also argues that there was no evidence of a denial of FAPE due to the lack of textbooks.
The March 15, 2001 settlement agreement provides as follows: “District will provide up to 5 textbooks per semester for [STUDENT’S] use to supplement the books used in his program. The supplemental books will be as agreed upon by STUDENT’S teachers and Orange County Regional Center.” (Resp.’s Exh. 4.) In addition, the IEP dated March 14, 2001, includes three reading comprehension objectives that require STUDENT to demonstrate certain reading comprehension skills by reading passages from the core curriculum “at his reading level.” (Resp.’s Exh. 4, pg. 8.)
The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s promise to deliver “up to 5 textbooks per semester” does not amount to a promise to deliver any textbooks at all. Rather, the terms of the settlement agreement indicate that the District may deliver up to 5 textbooks if it deems it necessary. Additionally, the District argued that it provided other useful materials to STUDENT, such as a computer, from which STUDENT benefitted. The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that the District has not breached any obligation to provide STUDENT with textbooks, because no such obligation exists in the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement.
*** Given the District’s concessions and the Hearing Officer’s determination above that the District failed to work on STUDENT’S handwriting goals, the Hearing Officer concludes that from March 15, 2001, to the present, the District failed to adhere to the terms of the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement.
2. If the District failed to perform its obligations pursuant to the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement and attached IEP dated March 14, 2001, what is the appropriate remedy for STUDENT?
The Hearing Officer concluded above that the District failed to implement the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement and incorporated IEP dated March 14, 2001, with respect to its conceded issues and STUDENT’S handwriting. Therefore, STUDENT is entitled to adequate compensation both as a matter of breach of contract and as compensatory education. (Student W. v. Puyallup School District, (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496; see also S.V. v. Sherwood School District 75 F.Supp.2d 1153, 1157 (D. Oregon, 1999).) Without some reasonable expectation that parties will be held to the terms of the settlement agreements they have entered into, parents and school districts alike will be loathe to expend the time, energy, and money necessary to informally resolve special education disputes. There are significant policy reasons that compel a finding that the District should be held to the express and unambiguous terms of the Agreement and be required to fulfill its obligations thereunder.
Having failed to provide the program and services as noted above, the District proposed at hearing to compensate STUDENT for the loss of educational opportunity in the following manner:
1. Provide STUDENT with an assessment by an occupational therapist through the Alex Center to specifically assess his handwriting and to assess him in general. The District also recommended that the assessment be reviewed by Dr. Robert Patterson, and OT services be provided by the District specifically for the improvement of handwriting and for any other areas needed as recommended by the assessor.
2. Provide the sixty-three hours of LMB services that STUDENT should have received pursuant to the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement, and the amount of OT agreed upon in the IEP dated June 11, 2001. (Resp.’s Exhs. 4 & 23.)
3. Provide the assistive technology services and equipment as recommended by ATEC in its July 2, 2001 proposal. The District generally agreed to fulfill its obligations under the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement. Additionally, the District proposed that it be required to provide an additional twenty-five percent of the agreed-upon LMB services and OT services.
Dr. Patterson concurred with the District’s recommendation that STUDENT receive at least the amount of services that the parties had originally agreed he needed. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by Dr. Patterson’s testimony, given his extensive experience in the field of special education and as a school psychologist.(Footnote 8) In addition, STUDENT’S parents did not disagree with the District’s proposal to compensate STUDENT by providing him the program and services agreed upon in the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement. The Hearing Officer concludes that there is no reason for further delay and, thus, the District must carry out all of its obligations under the settlement agreement, including the requirements regarding math and the textbooks, with which the Hearing Officer found the District to have been in compliance.
It should be noted that Petitioner requested as a remedy that he be placed at the Alex Center, a nonpublic school certified by the State of California serving students from ages five to twenty-one with brain injuries after birth, and that he receive services in the areas of reading, math, and writing until he reaches age twenty-two.
Sharon Grandinette, founder and current director of the Alex Center, Dr. Patterson, and Bobby Santillan, special education director for the District and administrator with the special education local plan area, all testified regarding the inappropriateness of placing STUDENT at the Alex Center. These three witnesses all believed that the Alex Center was too restrictive socially for STUDENT based on the population of students who attend the school, thus giving him limited peer group interaction and no opportunities for integration.(Footnote 9) Ms. Grandinette testified that STUDENT told her that he did not have many friends, and on the basis of that information, she believed that this was a need that should be addressed. According to Ms. Grandinette, a high school campus that meets all of his needs and provided special education services would be a more appropriate placement for STUDENT and would allow him to be around typically developing peers. According to Dr. Patterson, there are other avenues available to STUDENT for compensatory education.(Footnote 10)
The Hearing Officer finds there is no nexus between the missed educational services and placement at the Alex Center. The evidence demonstrated that the Alex Center’s program is not designed to meet STUDENT’S unique and individual educational needs, and thus is not remotely appropriate to compensate STUDENT for the District’s failure to perform under the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement. The Hearing Officer therefore denies Petitioner’s request that he be placed at the Alex Center.
The only issue remaining is a determination regarding the manner in which the omitted services of the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement should be implemented. Implementation shall be done in a very careful and educationally sound manner so as not to adversely affect STUDENT’S capacity to benefit from his education. In other words, the IEP team must take into consideration the fact that services will now be delivered by the District after more than a year has passed. In addition, the IEP team must integrate the omitted services into STUDENT’S new program in such a way that compensates him in an appropriate manner so that STUDENT does not become overwhelmed and/or lose interest in the instruction and services provided. The Hearing Officer realizes that since it is quite late in the 2001-2002 school year, it will be impossible for the District to implement the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement by the end of the school year. Therefore, such implementation must be spread out over the next school year and the IEP team shall determine the manner and timing of such implementation.
Regarding the LMB services, the Hearing Officer also finds that the District will have to make adjustments in providing the LMB program at a new location. LMB services shall not be provided at Santa Ana High School. Rather, the LMB services must be provided at either a new placement in the Santa Ana Unified School District or at one of the LMB center offices. The IEP team shall meet and determine the appropriate location for the provision of the required LMB services noted above.
Additionally, although the District proposed adding an additional twenty-five percent to the amount of LMB and OT services already agreed upon by the parties, the Hearing Officer finds that there was no factual basis for providing that additional amount of services. Therefore, the Hearing Officer leaves it to the IEP team to determine whether STUDENT requires an additional twenty-five percent of LMB and OT services to completely compensate any educational loss he may have suffered.
3. Does the District’s offer contained in the January 31, 2002 IEP constitute an appropriate placement for STUDENT?
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA (now IDEA ‘97). The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. (Id. at 200.) According to Rowley, the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available, or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. (Id. at 198-200.) The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Id. at 201.)
To determine whether the District offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE), one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s program. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).) If the District’s program reflected STUDENT’S needs, provided some benefit, and comported with his IEP, the District provided a FAPE, even if the parents preferred another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would have resulted in greater educational benefit. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.) Special education law also requires that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment, which, in this case, means ensuring that STUDENT’S education is provided in a manner that promotes his maximum interaction with children or youth who are not disabled, and which is appropriate to the needs of both. (20 U.S.C. §§ 1412(a)(5)(A), 1414(d)(1)(A)(iii)(III); Educ. Code § 56031.)
To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program must have met the following four requirements in order to have constituted a substantively appropriate educational program: (1) been designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs, (2) been reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, (3) comported with his IEP, and (4) been provided in the least restrictive environment.
What are STUDENT’S unique needs?
To determine whether the placement the District offered STUDENT from January 31, 2002, to June 14, 2002, would provide him with a FAPE, it is first necessary to identify STUDENT’S unique needs. According to Dr. Patterson’s psychoeducational evaluation and his testimony at hearing, STUDENT is performing on the cusp between low borderline functioning and mild retardation cognitively. Neurological screening indicated that STUDENT has moderate organic impairment, which is the basis of many of his learning disabilities. He has significant discrepancies between ability and achievement in all basic academic areas. (Resp.’s Exh. 1.) STUDENT has never performed above the third-grade level and lacks basic functional skills. According to the IEP dated January 31, 2002, as of October 4, 2001, STUDENT was performing at the 3.9 grade level in reading, 3.0 grade level in math, and at the 2.1 grade level in written language.
By report, the occupational therapist indicated that STUDENT has difficulty with bilateral coordination and synchronized tasks, visual perceptual skills, strength and dexterity. The occupational therapist recommended services to address those needs. (Resp.’s Exh. 15.) The vision therapy report indicated that STUDENT has reduced eye teaming and eye focusing skills that cause him to experience blurry vision, watery eyes, headaches, and red eyes when reading. Poor visual efficiency skills contribute to his difficulty remembering what was read and his loss of concentration when reading. STUDENT’S visual spatial judgments are poor and his visual analysis and visual-motor integration skills are also below expected levels for his mental age. Spectacle lenses and a vision therapy program were recommended, along with recommendations that could help reduce the classroom effects of STUDENT’S visual deficiencies, including use of a multi-sensory teaching approach. (Resp.’s Exh. 20.) And finally, the occupational therapist/assistive technology practitioner evaluated the appropriateness of assistive technology for STUDENT. The assistive technology evaluation revealed that STUDENT would not benefit from the use of technology to assist him in the area of reading. However, recommendations were made to use supplemental books for reading, a talking word processor for writing, and software programs to teach him functional skills in the area of math.
Both Dr. Patterson and Karen Steadman agreed that STUDENT requires a multi-sensory method of teaching reading and written language, such as the Lindamood Bell strategies.
In concurrence with Dr. Patterson, Ms. Steadman testified that STUDENT needs a functional program that provides hands-on experience in survival skills that will enable him to obtain employment and cope with life experiences that he will face in the next few years. According to Ms. Steadman, STUDENT would benefit from placement in a self-contained special day classroom as he has difficulty changing classes and becomes confused with having numerous teachers. STUDENT lacks the skills necessary to maintain organization between his classes and teachers, and has difficulty transitioning to a new schedule each semester. Ms. Steadman testified that STUDENT also needs to use manipulatives and a calculator, and requires a great deal of repetition and extended time to complete tests.
Dr. Patterson testified and reported that STUDENT requires a self-contained special day classroom setting with a limited number of students involved with specific remediation, but also with the development of functional skills in that program. STUDENT would also benefit from exposure to a program that would provide him with instruction relative to possible career and vocational placements, but done with a functional and applied type of teaching strategy. (Resp.’s Exh. 1.) The individuals who work with STUDENT need to determine his interests and goals and incorporate those ideas into a realistic transition plan. STUDENT does not have behavioral problems and he can function on a high school campus; however, he cannot carry on a conversation or do grade-level work. According to Dr. Patterson, STUDENT needs integration into the regular education program to the extent that he is not simply sitting in class and not participating.
The above summarizes STUDENT’S needs as expressed by the witnesses and in the documentary evidence. Given STUDENT’S borderline functioning, mild retardation, and moderate organic impairment, STUDENT requires a multi-sensory method of teaching, which can best be offered in a self-contained special day classroom with a limited number of students. The program should be functional and provide STUDENT with training in survival and vocational skills, and opportunities for integration with regular education peers. STUDENT’S motor and visual deficiencies also need to be addressed in occupational therapy and vision therapy programs. Next, it must be determined whether the goals and objectives, services, and placement offered by the District are designed to meet STUDENT’S needs.
Is the proposed placement designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs?
The IEP document dated January 31, 2002, states on its face that STUDENT would be placed in a public special day class and receive special services 83% of the time, including one period of general education each day, and five periods of special education each day. The IEP identifies Everlina Oliver as the teacher, who currently teaches at Santa Ana High School. The IEP also provides for designated instruction and services in assistive technology, occupational therapy, vision therapy, and the Lindamood-Bell program. The IEP services and modifications were to commence on February 1, 2002, and continue until June 14, 2002. (Resp.’s Exh. 68A.)
The District members of the IEP team proposed goals and objectives as noted in the IEP dated January 31, 2002, which address development of the following: reading, reading comprehension, written language, functional math skills, communication, and self-help. The IEP also includes an individual transition plan that addresses community experiences, employment and post school living, daily living skills, and functional vocational interests. Accommodations and modifications were also offered to address the instructional methods to which STUDENT best responds. In comparing STUDENT’S needs identified above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the goals and objectives are designed to meet his needs, except that there are no goals noted in the IEP that could be addressed during his weekly occupational therapy and vision therapy sessions. The Hearing Officer finds that the occupational therapy and vision therapy programs recommended in the respective therapists’ reports should be reviewed by the IEP team and specific goals developed and incorporated into STUDENT’S IEP. (See Resp.’s Exhs. 15 and 20.)
Ms. Steadman testified that she did not agree as a whole with the IEP dated January 31, 2002, particularly with regard to the amount of time that was allotted for STUDENT to complete the goals and objectives. From her testing of STUDENT and her work with him since the ninth grade, Ms. Steadman believed that STUDENT could complete most of the goals and objectives in less than one week, rather than the six-month-time frame allotted in the IEP. However, Dr. Patterson testified that although he believes Ms. Steadman is very sincere and has STUDENT’S best interests at heart, he believes Ms. Steadman has misinterpreted STUDENT’S skills. According to Dr. Patterson, there was a significant difference between MOTHER’s and Ms. Steadman’s scores in rating STUDENT’S functioning level. MOTHER’s score in 2000 was more consistent with STUDENT’S past history, whereas Ms. Steadman rated STUDENT as very high functioning.
Although Ms. Steadman expressed disagreement regarding the measurement of time given for STUDENT to complete his goals and objectives, all of the witnesses agreed that the goals and objectives in the IEP dated January 31, 2002, can be implemented in a small, self-contained special day class setting in which one teacher administers the entire curriculum. The District witnesses testified that the District has such a self-contained special day class on either of two District campuses, although the January 31, 2002 IEP does not so specifically state. According to District witnesses, a fully-integrated SDC that uses a multi-sensory instructional approach, teaches functional skills, and that allows STUDENT continued access to computers and software programs and to work on his written language would be an appropriate placement for STUDENT. Dr. Patterson also testified that the goals and objectives in the proposed IEP were highly appropriate and that the best placement in which those goals and objectives could be met is in a self-contained special day classroom, and eventually in an adult transition program.
Special education director Bobby Santillan testified that at the time the IEP team was drafting the January 31, 2002 IEP, the IEP team was recommending that STUDENT remain at Santa Ana High School. However, the intent of that recommendation was that STUDENT be placed in a fully self-contained special day class with one teacher providing all of the core curriculum. Such a classroom, however, would have had to be created at Santa Ana High School because it does not currently exist. (Testimony of Richard Erhard.) Currently, Santa Ana High School has a more inclusive, departmentalized program in which several of the special day class (“SDC”) teachers provide the curriculum in different subjects. It was not until the hearing in this matter that the District specifically stated that it intended to implement the January 31, 2002 IEP at either STUDENT’S home school, Valley High School, or Saddleback High School in the District, where self-contained SDCs already exist. (Testimonies of Bobby Santillan and Richard Erhard.)
On the basis of the testimony of the witnesses and the documentary evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’S continued placement at Santa Ana High School would not be appropriate for several reasons.(Footnote 11) First, the District witnesses indicated that Santa Ana High School does not currently have the self-contained SDC that STUDENT requires. Additionally, the evidence established that there have been major difficulties with the Santa Ana High School staff’s implementation of STUDENT’S IEPs over the past several years, and strained relations between school staff, administrators, and the parents continue to exist and hamper effective coordination of efforts. Therefore, it is not beneficial for STUDENT to continue his placement at Santa Ana High School, particularly since it is not his home school and it cannot provide the educational setting that he currently requires.
Although the District presented evidence at hearing to support its contention that a self-contained, learning handicapped SDC program at either Saddleback High School or Valley High School in the District would be appropriate for STUDENT, the IEP document dated January 31, 2002, does not reflect a clear and specific written offer to place STUDENT in any particular special day class program, other than one on a public school campus. (Resp.’s Exh. 68A; Union School District v. B. Smith (9th Cir. 1994) 15 F.3d 1519, 1526.) Dr. Patterson also noted the District’s lack of specificity in its written offer, stating that the IEP dated January 31, 2002, was not a “placement document,” but rather, a recommendation of goals and objectives that could be addressed in certain placements.
The District is required to exercise its professional judgment by selecting and offering a specific educational placement which the District's educational experts determined was appropriate to meet STUDENT’S unique and individual needs. Moreover, it has been concluded above that Santa Ana High School is not the appropriate placement for STUDENT under the IDEA and Rowley. In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's approach in offering a general placement in a special day class violated the intent of Union that a clear, coherent placement offer must be made. The offer must be detailed so as to demonstrate to the parent that the District has carefully thought through and selected a placement that, in its professional judgment, will meet the unique and individual needs of the student. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the District has not met the procedural requirements noted in Union that a district specifically state in writing the placement that it considers to be appropriate for the student.
Even if the District had fulfilled its procedural obligations, the District still did not offer STUDENT a substantively appropriate placement. In so much as the January 31, 2002 IEP document implied an offer to continue STUDENT’S placement at Santa Ana High School, for the reasons stated above, the Hearing Officer already found that such placement does not meet STUDENT’S unique and individual needs or provide him with educational benefit.
Notwithstanding the District’s failure to state an appropriate placement, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP dated January 31, 2002 is generally appropriate, with certain exceptions, which must be addressed by the IEP team when it reconvenes. As discussed above in the text, those items are as follows:
1. Implementation of the goals and objectives in the IEP dated January 31, 2002 2. Addition of goals and objectives to the IEP relative to STUDENT’S occupational therapy and vision therapy needs 3. Use of a multi-sensory instructional approach, including the LMB program and possibly the Earobics program 4. Provide opportunities for social interaction with regular education peers 5. A transition plan that also incorporates STUDENT’S stated interests and goals
6. Appoint a qualified individual to oversee the implementation of the IEP’s program and services, such as a staff person from another district, a Regional Center case worker, or Dr. Robert Patterson.(Footnote 12)
Although the District’s offer contained in the IEP dated January 31, 2002, fails, on procedural grounds, to constitute an appropriate placement for STUDENT, the Hearing Officer finds that the proposed program and services offered by the District, as amended above, are generally appropriate and the IEP dated January 31, 2002, can be implemented in a self-contained SDC on a District campus other than Santa Ana High School, or in another nearby district, so long as the District can assure that there exists the ability to incorporate the requirements noted above by the Hearing Officer.
Implementation of IEP dated January 31, 2002
The Hearing Officer orders the District to reconvene an IEP team to discuss the SDC program and school that would be appropriate for STUDENT and to make a specific formal written offer of placement to STUDENT.(Footntoe 13) That offer shall incorporate the requirements noted above by the Hearing Officer and identify steps to be taken to ensure that STUDENT is successfully transitioned into an appropriate self-contained SDC setting.
*** In summary, while the Hearing Officer found the program and services identified in the IEP dated January 31, 2002 to be generally appropriate, with the noted modifications, the placement offered by the District does not satisfy the procedural requirements set forth under Union and the IDEA. In addition, the implied offer to continue STUDENT’S placement at Santa Ana High School was inappropriate on substantive grounds. Therefore, the District’s IEP team must reconvene to correct that problem as noted above.
ORDER
1. Within 10 calendar days of the date of this decision, as agreed upon by the parties, the District shall arrange for the Alex Center to specifically assess STUDENT’S handwriting and any other occupational therapy needs.
2. Within 15 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to do the following:
(a) develop specific occupational therapy and vision therapy goals and objectives that address STUDENT’S needs in those areas;
(b) ensure STUDENT’S IEP provides for his social interaction with regular education peers;
(c) determine STUDENT’S interests and long term goals to be included in his individual transition plan;
(d) appoint a qualified individual to oversee the implementation of the IEP’s program and services; and (e) provide an appropriate placement in which to implement the IEP dated January 31, 2002, along with the recommendations set forth above by the Hearing Officer, for the remainder of the 2001-2002 school year.
3. No later than the first month of the 2002-2003 school year, the District shall arrange for STUDENT to begin receiving the program and services identified and agreed upon in the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement and incorporated IEP dated March 14, 2001, including occupational therapy, Lindamood Bell training, and the provision of assistive technology equipment, service and training.
4. When developing a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, the District must take into consideration the fact that simultaneously with the delivery of the FAPE, the school also will be implementing the earlier settlement agreement dated March 15, 2001.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement.
1. Did the District fail to perform its obligations under the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement and attached IEP dated March 14, 2001, with respect to working on STUDENT’S handwriting, working on specific areas in math, and providing STUDENT with textbooks at his ability level for social studies, science, and math?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue with respect to the handwriting. The District prevailed on this issue with respect to math and the textbooks.
2. If the District failed to perform its obligations pursuant to the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement and attached IEP dated March 14, 2001, what is the appropriate remedy for STUDENT?
Petitioner partly prevailed on this issue in that enforcement of the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement was ordered. However, the District partly prevailed on the issue in that Petitioner’s request that he be placed at the Alex Center was denied.
3. Does the District’s offer contained in the January 31, 2002 IEP constitute an appropriate placement for STUDENT?
Neither party prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (California Education Code § 56505(i).)
Dated: April 18, 2002 __________________________________ Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES
1. Case number SN01-02676 was consolidated with case number SN01-02759 by order of the Special Education Hearing Office. 2. The evidence in this hearing was unclear as to whether the CDE was provided a copy of the March 15, 2001 settlement agreement in its investigation. The March 15, 2001 settlement agreement required the District to implement the then-draft IEP dated March 14, 2001. 3. The issues listed here differ in numbering and wording from those noticed by Petitioner before the hearing. Changes were made for purposes of clarification or for appropriate analysis, and to reflect the concessions made by the District and the stipulation entered into between the parties during the hearing. 4. During the hearing, Petitioner made a number of allegations regarding the denial of a free appropriate public education (“FAPE”), and the District conceded that it denied Petitioner a FAPE with respect to all of those allegations, except the allegations regarding handwriting, math, and the textbooks. Therefore, the Hearing Officer addresses only those allegations not conceded to by the District in this regard. 5. STUDENT’S mother, MOTHER, stated that she agreed that STUDENT was provided with appropriate LMB services during the summer of 2001, but alleges that LMB services were not provided in accordance with the March 15, 2001 settlement during the regular school year. 6. The parties stipulated at hearing to these facts regarding the provision of OT services. 7. Ms. Steadman testified that although she currently is not STUDENT’S case carrier, she is one of his four teachers. STUDENT is in her class twice a day for math and once a day for reading. 8. Dr. Patterson testified that on approximately 100 to 150 occasions, he has consulted both school districts and parents on special education issues. He previously performed approximately 120 assessments a year as a public school employee, and currently conducts approximately 180 to 200 assessments a year in his private practice (sixty percent of which involves school matters). 9. The two eighteen-year-old students at the Alex Center are nonambulatory and both are in wheelchairs with limited speech without the use of assistive technology. There is also one fifteen-and-one-half-year-old male student who is limited cognitively, and a fifteen-year-old female student who has low vision, but is very astute cognitively. Both of the fifteen-year-old students are ambulatory. (Testimony of S. Grandinette.) 10. Dr. Patterson is a licensed psychologist, licensed educational psychologist, nationally certified school psychologist, licensed marriage, family and child therapist, nationally certified counselor, and a nationally certified gerontological counselor. He is a practicing school psychologist and presently runs a private psychology practice and is a Regional Center vendor. Dr. Patterson previously performed a psychoeduational assessment of STUDENT in December 2000, and reviewed and made recommendations to the proposed IEP dated January 31, 2002. 11. The District admitted at hearing that a problem exists at Santa Ana High School and that the bridge between the District and the parents has widened. According to the District, the real problem is the personnel at Santa Ana High School and the administration’s inability to make changes directly at that school. The District believes that Valley High School or Saddleback High School offer a new setting with new personnel and an appropriate SDC program that already exists. 12. The District stated at hearing that it would agree to appoint someone to meet with District staff on a monthly basis at the school site to ensure that the compensatory measures and the IEP are being implemented. As long as STUDENT is in high school, the District proposes that a Regional Center staff person or Dr. Robert Patterson be this designated person. 13. Petitioner also alleged that the District failed to follow IDEA procedural requirements when it failed to provide him timely notice of the December 12, 2001 IEP meeting. The December 12, 2001 IEP meeting did not result in a completed IEP document, but ultimately led to the creation of the IEP dated January 31, 2002. However, since the Hearing Officer determined above that the IEP dated January 31, 2002 failed to constitute an appropriate placement, and having ordered the IEP team to reconvene to modify that IEP, a determination regarding this alleged procedural violation is not necessary.
