California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 28, 1998
Student v. Cottonwood Union Elementary School District et al. (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 278-97, SN 239-97 · Hearing Officer JoAnn Irwin-Eshelman
Cottonwood Union denied FAPE by leaving Mental Health out of an IEP meeting; $154 tutoring reimbursed, mediated agreements enforced.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
Cases were consolidated May 30, 1997, separated on reconsideration June 24, 1997, and consolidated again July 28, 1997. The Shasta County Office of Education was dismissed as a party on August 13, 1997, subject to Stipulations 1 and 2. A California Department of Education compliance report (#I-294-96/97) dated August 1, 1997 was rescinded and replaced by a final report dated September 24, 1997.
Summary
The family and Cottonwood Union Elementary School District each filed for hearing. The cases were consolidated, and Shasta County Mental Health also took part. The 12-year-old was found eligible for special education as seriously emotionally disturbed in February 1997. The family argued he should have qualified in 1995-96 or earlier in 1996-97. The Hearing Officer disagreed. A 1996 school psychologist assessment and staff testimony did not show the required traits over a long period, to a marked degree, with an effect on schoolwork. His later decline was gradual, and the district was trying general education changes.
The Hearing Officer did find a denial of FAPE at the February 26, 1997 IEP meeting, on a ground the family had not argued. The parent asked that Mental Health be invited, but the district did not invite it. The resulting IEP had one vague goal and placed him in a county special day class at Live Oak School. His later return to a regular class with a 1:1 aide was appropriate. The Hearing Officer enforced the parties' May 1997 mediated agreements: Mental Health pays for a UCLA neuropsychological evaluation, waives up to $277, and resumes his care. Two named clinicians could not treat him, and sessions had to be at a neutral site. The district must reimburse $154 for tutoring and hold an IEP meeting within 15 days. Residential placement, payment for an independent evaluation, and compensatory services were denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO treated a district's failure to invite a mental health agency the parent had asked for as a procedural denial of FAPE under W.G. It also shows SEHO enforcing prehearing mediated agreements as binding contracts. It adjusted who could serve the student and where.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 1a. Should the District have found the Student eligible for special education services on the basis of serious emotional disturbance (SED) during the 1995-96 school year?
The 1996 assessment and staff testimony did not show any SED characteristic over a long period, to a marked degree, with adverse educational effect; one isolated incident and outside counseling were not enough.
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 1b. Should the District have found the Student eligible on the basis of SED before February 26, 1997 during the 1996-97 school year?
The student's decline was gradual and cumulative, and the district was appropriately trying general education modifications, so it had no reason to find him SED any earlier.
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 2a. Was the Student denied a FAPE from February 26, 1997 in his placement in the County Office of Education special day class at Live Oak School?
The parent asked that Mental Health be invited, but the district failed to invite it. That denied her full participation and led to a deficient IEP with one generic goal, so FAPE was denied (W.G.).
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 2b. Was the Student denied a FAPE in his return placement to the regular fifth grade class at West Cottonwood Junior High with a 1:1 instructional aide through the end of 1996-97?
The mediated agreement did not specify aide training, the aide was adequately trained and effective, and the student benefited in the least restrictive environment.
- Student prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 3a. Is the Student entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the March 1997 neuropsychological assessment by the UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute and related travel expenses?
The May 19, 1997 mediated agreement for Mental Health to pay $1,800-2,000 is a binding contract, and the parties must carry it out.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 3b. Is the Student entitled to reimbursement for the independent psychoeducational assessment completed by Dr. Komm?
The district's 1996 and 1997 assessments by a credentialed school psychologist were appropriate, so the independent evaluation is not reimbursable.
- District prevailedResidential placement for mental health
Issue 4a. Have the District and Mental Health offered appropriate mental health services to the Student for the 1997-98 school year (including whether residential treatment is required)?
Residential treatment was not shown to be necessary. The May 19 mediated agreement providing medication management and psychotherapy through Mental Health is appropriate, with minor modifications.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4b. Must the District and Mental Health fund certain mental health services requested by the Student, including those provided by a specific private psychiatrist and psychotherapist?
Ongoing services by the student's chosen private psychiatrist were not ordered. Services stay with Mental Health, but two named staff may not treat him, and sessions must be at a neutral, non-Mental Health site.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 5a. Is the Student entitled to reimbursement for tutorial services during March 1997?
Because the Live Oak placement denied FAPE, the district must reimburse $154 for tutoring from March 17-29, 1997.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 5b. Is the Student entitled to reimbursement for co-payments made for Mental Health services; private psychiatric services, medications, and other expenses; and private psychotherapy?
The May 19 agreement governs payment for the private psychiatrist and Mental Health's waiver of up to $277. No psychotherapy was shown, so that request was moot. No other reimbursement was ordered.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 5c. Is the Student entitled to compensatory education in the form of art therapy and related transportation, reimbursement for eyeglasses, counseling, parent training, recreational therapy, additional psychotherapy and family counseling, and additional recreational therapy for social development?
Because the student was not eligible before February 26, 1997, all requested compensatory services were denied.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 30 days, the District shall reimburse the parent $154 for tutorial services received March 17 through March 29, 1997.
- Within 30 days, the District, Mental Health, and the Student shall comply with term No. 1 of the May 19, 1997 mediated agreement: Mental Health payment of $1,800-2,000 for the UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute assessment, contingent on billing and verification.
- Within 30 days, the parties shall implement terms 3-8 of the May 19, 1997 agreement transitioning the student from private psychiatrist Dr. Powell back to Mental Health. Changes: a new date for the joint session, no later than 30 days from the order; Dr. Lynn Pappas and Dr. Robert Trustman may not be direct service providers; all transition and ongoing psychotherapy and medication management sessions must be at a neutral, non-Mental Health location.
- Within 30 days, the parties shall implement item No. 2 of the May 19, 1997 agreement: Mental Health waives up to $277 in costs for services already provided.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 days, the District shall convene an IEP meeting, including the Mental Health psychiatrist and psychotherapist and Dr. Powell, to develop an appropriate 1997-98 IEP with goals and objectives, consider James Norton's May 13, 1997 functional analysis recommendations, and develop a behavior intervention plan if appropriate.
- Order to provide or change services. The IEP shall include continued regular education sixth grade placement at West Cottonwood Junior High with an appropriately trained 1:1 aide (per Stipulation No. 3), plus medication management by a Mental Health staff psychiatrist other than Dr. Pappas and psychotherapy by Mental Health staff other than Dr. Trustman. The IEP team sets frequency based on John Simmons' May 15, 1997 AB 3632 assessment.
- The parties shall implement Stipulations 1 and 2 during 1997-98: no future placement in the COE special day class at Live Oak, and at least an annual COE assessment of the student's visual perception deficit as it affects his education.
Total: $154 ordered
Key authorities
Hendrick Hudson Central School District Board of Education v. Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees (9th Cir. 1992); Landgraf v. USI Film Products; 5 CCR 3030(i); Cal. Ed. Code 56341(c)(2); Cal. Ed. Code 56329(b); Gov. Code 7576 (AB 3632)
People named in the decision
- Dale Hansen, principal, West Cottonwood Junior High, Cottonwood Union Elementary School District
- Carol Nason, school psychologist, Cottonwood Union Elementary School District
- CeCe Walters, 1:1 instructional aide, Cottonwood Union Elementary School District
- Dr. Richard Komm, educational psychologist; independent evaluator and expert witness for Student
- Dr. Cheree Cuddeback, clinical psychologist (therapist), Shasta County Mental Health
- John Simmons, clinical social worker; AB 3632 assessor, Shasta County Mental Health
- Peggy Farver, art therapist, witness for Student
- Andrew Hinds, principal, East Cottonwood School
- Dr. Richard Powell, private psychiatrist
- Bonnie Ristagno, fourth grade teacher, East Cottonwood School
- James Norton, program specialist and school psychologist; functional analysis assessor, Shasta County Office of Education
- Donna Malloy, fifth grade teacher, West Cottonwood Junior High
- Todd Buck, physical education teacher, Cottonwood Union Elementary School District
- John Almond, superintendent, Cottonwood Union Elementary School District
- Maureen Coonfield, sixth grade teacher, Cottonwood Union Elementary School District
- Dr. Lynn Pappas, staff psychiatrist, Shasta County Mental Health
- Dr. Robert Trustman, psychologist, family and youth services, Shasta County Mental Health
- Maxine Wayda, program manager, youth system of care, Shasta County Mental Health
- Sheila Miller, assistant superintendent for student programs and services, Shasta County Office of Education
- Judy Tarkington, psychotherapist, Shasta County Mental Health
- Sara Darnley, psychodiagnostic evaluator, Shasta County Mental Health
- Dr. Jambur Ananth, private psychiatrist (second opinion), Harbor-UCLA Medical Foundation
- Dr. Deborah Lynn, evaluating physician, UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute
- Dr. Bryan Crum, eye doctor, Shasta Eye Associates
- Carol Purcell, compliance consultant, Quality Assurance Unit, California Department of Education
- G. Robert Roice, educational consultant representing District and COE
- Alan Swanson, counsel for District
- Catherine Pearl, Deputy County Counsel for Shasta County Mental Health
- Dusti Sutfin, advocate for Student
- Geralyn Clancy, attorney for Student, Ruderman, Varma & Clancy
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This consolidated matter was heard before JoAnn Irwin-Eshelman, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Cottonwood, California, on August 12, 13, 21, and 22, and September 30, 1997.
The Student was represented by attorney Bob Varma of Ruderman, Varma & Clancy, Attorneys at Law. PARENT, STUDENT's mother, was also present on his behalf. Attorney Geralyn Clancy, Dusti Sutfin, advocate, and UNCLE, STUDENT's uncle, were present for various portions of the hearing. The Cottonwood Union Elementary School District (District), and the Shasta County Office of Education (COE) were represented by G. Robert Roice, educational consultant. Alan Swanson, counsel for the District, John Almond, superintendent, and Dale Hansen, principal of West Cottonwood Junior High, were present on behalf of the District, and Sheila Miller, assistant superintendent for student programs and services, was present on behalf of the COE for a portion of the hearing. Shasta County Mental Health (Mental Health) was represented by Deputy County Counsel Catherine Pearl. Maxine Wayda, program manager for the youth system of care program, was also present on behalf of Mental Health.
The Student presented 14 witnesses: Dale Hansen; Carol Nason, school psychologist; CeCe Walters, STUDENT's instructional aide; Dr. Richard Komm, educational psychologist; Dr. Cheree Cuddeback, clinical psychologist; John Simmons, clinical social worker for Mental Health; Peggy Farver, art therapist; STUDENT; Andrew Hinds, principal of East Cottonwood School; Dr. Richard Powell, private psychiatrist; Bonnie Ristagno, fourth grade teacher; James Norton, program specialist for the COE and school psychologist; Donna Malloy, fifth grade teacher; and PARENT, on rebuttal.
The District presented three witnesses: Todd Buck, physical education teacher; John Almond; and Maureen Coonfield, sixth grade teacher.
Mental Health presented three witnesses: Dr. Lynn Pappas, staff psychiatrist for Mental Health; Dr. Robert Trustman, psychologist for family and youth services at Mental Health; and Maxine Wayda.
ISSUES
1. Should the District have found the Student eligible for special education services on the basis of serious emotional disturbance (SED) during the 1995-96 school year, or before February 26, 1997 during the 1996-97 school year? (Footnote 2)
2. Was the Student denied a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from February 26, 1997, when he was found eligible based on SED criteria, until the end of the 1996-97 school year?
3. Is the Student entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the March 1997 neuropsychological assessment by the UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute and related travel expenses? Is the Student entitled to reimbursement for the independent psychoeducational assessment completed by Dr. Komm?
4. Have the District and Mental Health offered appropriate mental health services to the Student for the 1997-98 school year? Must the District and Mental Health fund certain mental health services requested by the Student, including those provided by a specific private psychiatrist and psychotherapist?
5. Is the Student entitled to reimbursement for co-payments made for Mental Health services; private psychiatric services, medications, and other expenses; private psychotherapy; and tutorial services during March 1997? Is the Student also entitled to compensatory education in the form of art therapy and related transportation, reimbursement for eyeglasses, counseling, parent training, recreational therapy, additional psychotherapy and family counseling, and additional recreational therapy for social development?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
The Student's request for due process hearing (SN 239-97) was received by the Hearing Office on March 6, 1997. The District's request for hearing (SN 278-97) was received by the Hearing Office one week later, on March 13, 1997.
As a result of mediation on April 3, 1997, the parties entered into an interim agreement. The parties agreed that (1) Mental Health would complete an assessment of STUDENT pursuant to Government Code, Chapter 26.5 (AB 3632) by May 15, 1997; (2) STUDENT's mother would sign a release of information for all relevant data from UCLA; (3) the COE would conduct a functional analysis assessment of STUDENT (Hughes Bill assessment) by May 15, 1997; (4) STUDENT would be placed back in a regular education class with a trained instructional aide no later than April 18, 1997, and would continue in this placement until the IEP team determined otherwise; and (5) Mental Health offered medication management by a staff psychiatrist, but this offer was rejected by STUDENT's mother because STUDENT was being seen by a private psychiatrist. (Student Exh. pg. 5.)
On May 19, 1997, the parties entered into a further interim agreement as a result of mediation on that date. The parties agreed that (1) Mental Health would pay for STUDENT's UCLA Psycho-Neurological Testing Evaluation Assessment in the amount of $1800-2000 contingent upon receipt of UCLA billing from PARENT and independent, direct verification from UCLA on outstanding/or paid for billing; (2) Mental Health would waive up to $277 for Mental Health services already rendered to STUDENT; (3) Mental Health would pay the $420 billing from STUDENT's private psychiatrist, Dr. Richard Powell, with the understanding that STUDENT would transition back to Mental Health for future services, and subject to Mental Health's review and approval; (4) transition back to Mental Health would include at least one joint session by the private psychiatrist and Mental Health psychotherapist; verbal exchange of information between the private psychiatrist and Mental Health staff; payment by Mental Health for no more than three transitional sessions by the private psychiatrist; and parent not to seek reimbursement for the private psychiatrist's services prior to the transitional sessions; and (5) upon receipt of satisfactory information regarding curriculum vitae and verification of educationally-related services, payment for private psychiatric services to be made within 30 days. (Student Exh. pg. 10.)
On May 30, 1997, the District's request for consolidation of the two cases was granted by the Hearing Office. On June 24, 1997, the Hearing Office granted reconsideration of the May 30 consolidation order, and ordered the two matters separated. On the same date, the Hearing Office also denied the request of the COE to be dismissed as a party. On July 28, 1997, pursuant to an agreement by the parties, the two matters were once again consolidated by the Hearing Office.
On the second day of hearing, August 13, 1997, the COE's request for dismissal as a party was granted without objection, subject to stipulations one and two noted below. (Footnote 3) The parties resolved part of the issue regarding prospective placement for the 1997-98 school year by entering into Stipulation No. 3 below. The Student also withdrew two other issues in which he contended that he should have been found eligible as SED during the 1993-94 and 1994-95 school years.
On the last day of hearing, September 30, 1997, the Student requested to re-call Dr. Richard Powell and present his testimony by telephone because of Dr. Powell's appointment schedule. Both the District and Mental Health objected. The Student's request to re-call Dr. Powell was granted, but the request for telephone testimony was denied as Dr. Powell's office is in Redding, a short distance from the hearing location, and the Student did not establish sufficient or compelling grounds for telephone testimony.
STIPULATIONS
The following stipulations were entered into by the parties:
1. The COE's special day class at Live Oak School will not be a placement for STUDENT in the future. 2. The COE will provide, at least annually, an assessment of STUDENT's visual perception deficit insofar as that deficit adversely affects his education. 3. STUDENT's educational program for the 1997-98 school year will consist of (a) participation in regular education sixth grade classes, (b) 1:1 aide services from three aides new to STUDENT who are trained in positive behavior intervention and behavior modification techniques, and will accompany STUDENT to each of his classes, and (c) training for STUDENT's teachers and aides in accordance with the behavioral recommendations made by James Norton, school psychologist for the COE. BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a 12-year-old student who was found eligible for special education services as seriously emotionally disturbed (SED) on February 26, 1997. He also has been diagnosed with vision difficulties, which include bilateral amblyopia and astigmatism, and a slight hearing loss. Pursuant to Stipulation No.3 above, STUDENT is currently attending a regular education sixth grade class at West Cottonwood Junior High School, with assistance from 1:1 instructional aides. Because the mental health component of STUDENT's program is in dispute, he receives privately arranged mental health services from psychiatrist Dr. Richard Powell.
On February 6, 1995, during his third grade year, STUDENT transferred to East Cottonwood School in the District. He attended summer school the following summer and, during the 1995-96 school year, attended the fourth grade class of Bonnie Ristagno. STUDENT was a capable student, but had difficulty completing his work and was frequently off task during that year. (Testimony of Ms. Ristagno.)
On September 27, 1995, STUDENT was referred to Mental Health by the school principal for "becoming verbally abusive of teachers on the playground," problems in staying focused, non-cooperation with adults, and problems "keeping reality and fantasy separated." (Student Exh. 184.) He began weekly counseling at Mental Health with clinical psychologist Dr. Cheree Cuddeback in October 1995, and continued until Dr. Cuddeback completed her internship and left Mental Health in February 1997.
In November and December 1995, STUDENT completed several psychological tests administered by Dr. Cuddeback at Mental Health. The tests were given to STUDENT after he received his first report card and his fourth grade teacher indicated that he may have a "processing problem." However, in January 1996, Dr. Cuddeback recommended that STUDENT be re-tested by the District because an opthomologist had determined that STUDENT needed new glasses, and Dr. Cuddeback concluded that the prior testing was invalid.
In February and March 1996, at the request of both STUDENT's mother and Dr. Cuddeback, Ms. Nason did psychoeducational testing of STUDENT to determine if he had a learning disability. Ms. Nason assessed STUDENT's cognitive and academic functioning, visual motor skills, and behavior. In the area of behavior, Ms. Nason noted that, although STUDENT's problems were in the "borderline range of clinical significance," his behavior had "greatly improved" during the school year, according to his teacher. (Student Exh. pg. 102.) Ms. Nason concluded that STUDENT was performing in the average to above average range in all academic areas and made several recommendations for the classroom teacher to implement.
On April 4, 1996, an IEP team meeting, which included STUDENT's mother, was held to review the assessment results. The IEP team determined that STUDENT was not eligible for special education on the basis of a learning disability because his academic skills were in the broad average range and no significant discrepancy was found between his ability and achievement. (Student Exh. pg. 26.)
In late May 1996, there was an incident at STUDENT's school in which fecal matter was used to write an obscene word on a toilet stall wall in the boy's bathroom. STUDENT eventually admitted responsibility for the incident, and it was discussed in therapy with Dr. Cuddeback. (Testimony of Mr. Hinds; Student Exh. pgs. 116-118.) The school principal, Andrew Hinds, attributed the incident to "fourth grade exit year" stress because STUDENT was to move on to West Cottonwood Junior High in the fall.
In July 1996, Dr. Cuddeback referred STUDENT to Dr. Lynn Pappas, a child psychiatrist with Mental Health, for medication evaluation after learning of other behavior indicating that STUDENT had a preoccupation with sexual and elimination issues. (Mental Health Exh. pgs. 112-117.) Dr. Pappas diagnosed multiple symptoms of post traumatic stress disorder, depression, and anxiety, and prescribed medication for STUDENT Later that month, STUDENT's mother decided to get a second opinion on the need for medication and contacted Dr. Jambur Ananth with Harbor-UCLA Medical Foundation in Torrance, California. (Mental Health pg. 100-102.) Dr. Ananth recommended the same medication for STUDENT as prescribed by Dr. Pappas, and suggested that two other medications be added as well.
In August 1996, at Dr. Cuddeback's request, STUDENT underwent a psychodiagnostic evaluation at Mental Health "for the purpose of clarifying his diagnosis and identifying his thought processes, coping skills, ability to test reality and make judgments, motivation, and source of anger outbursts." (Mental Health Exh. pgs. 92-96.) Sara Darnley completed the written evaluation under the direction of psychologist Dr. Robert Trustman and concluded that STUDENT had "developed behaviors associated with the paraphilic disorder of Fetishism." She noted that "STUDENT has recurrent, intense, sexually arousing behaviors involving the use of soiled, disposable diapers as an object in which he invests sexualized energy." (Mental Health Exh. pg. 96.) She also stated that STUDENT is "currently experiencing significant situational stress that has become chronic and [sic] undergoing an episode of depression." In addition to the diagnoses of "Fetishism" and "Major Depressive Disorder. Recurrent," Ms. Darnley also diagnosed STUDENT with "Dysthymic Disorder. Early Onset, Parent-Child Relational Problem, and Attention-Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder. Predominantly Inattentive Type including sub-categories of Post-traumatic Stress Disorder, and Sexual Abuse of a Child: Victim." (Footnote 4)
In September 1996, STUDENT entered fifth grade at West Cottonwood and was placed in Donna Malloy's class. Ms. Malloy described seeing "two different STUDENT's" in her class that year. During the first part of the year, from September until late February when STUDENT left the class, he resisted completing assignments, was creative at being off task, was loud, aggressive, rude and "a good actor." (Testimony of Ms. Malloy.) Soon after the school year began, in September 1996, Ms. Malloy saw STUDENT scratch a girl in class with some scissors. Throughout the fall, STUDENT's negative behaviors at school escalated. On November 19, 1996, STUDENT was suspended for repeated defiance of his classroom teacher and writing inappropriate notes about the teacher. (Student Exh. pg. 291.)
On December 3, 1996, a conference was held at STUDENT's school to discuss his behavior and develop strategies for handling it. STUDENT's therapist (Dr. Cuddeback), the school psychologist (Ms. Nason), his mother, the principal (Mr. Hansen), the vice principal, and his teacher (Ms. Malloy) were all present.
In late January 1997, Dr. Cuddeback began to terminate her therapy with STUDENT, and eventually transferred him to Dr. Robert Trustman, staff psychologist with Mental Health, on February 11, 1997. At approximately the same time, PARENT requested that Mental Health refer STUDENT to the UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute (NPI) in Los Angeles for a PET scan and neurodiagnostic work-up. (Mental Health Exh. pg. 44, 42.) (Footnote 5)
In February 1997, STUDENT was again suspended from school, first for fighting, then for pushing a female student and causing her to fall and break her wrist. (Student Exh. pg. 290; testimony of Dale Hansen.) As he was being escorted to the office by his teacher after the pushing incident, STUDENT also pushed the teacher's arm away and attempted to hit her. (Testimony of Ms. Malloy; Dist. Exh. 2.) Following these incidents, on February 25, 1997, STUDENT was assessed by the school psychologist and determined to qualify for special education services as SED.
On February 26, 1997, the IEP team determined that STUDENT was eligible for special education under the SED criteria. The team recommended that STUDENT be placed at the COE's special day class program at Live Oak School effective immediately. (Dist. Exh. 8.) STUDENT received private tutoring for four days in late February before he began his Live Oak placement. STUDENT attended Live Oak for six days and was removed from the program by his mother.
On March 4, 1997, Dr. Trustman met with PARENT and advised her that Mental Health would neither refer STUDENT to NPI, nor pay for the evaluation she had requested. (Mental Health Exh. pg. 23-24.) PARENT became upset but indicated that she would proceed with the NPI evaluation which was scheduled for the following week. STUDENT was present outside Dr. Trustman's office when his mother came out crying, and also became upset because he believed "Dr. Trustman made my Mom cry." (Testimony of Dr. Trustman, STUDENT)
On March 6, 1997, an IEP team meeting was held at PARENT's request to consider an AB 3632 referral and other parental agenda items. At the meeting, PARENT advised the other IEP team members that she wished "to retract the IEP of 2/26/97." (Student Exh. pgs. 12-17.) In a phone call to superintendent John Almond, she also requested that the District pay for the proposed NPI evaluation. (Testimony of John Almond.) Mr. Almond denied the request.
On March 7, 1997, PARENT left a telephone message for Dr. Trustman indicating that she was terminating her son's services with Mental Health.
On March 10-13, 1997, the UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute and Hospital completed an outpatient neuropsychological evaluation of STUDENT In the written evaluation, the NPI neuro-psychologists concluded:
Overall, STUDENT's profile is consistent with that of a cognitively intact child who has severe perceptual abnormalities that significantly impair his social and emotional functioning. While perceptual abnormalities of this severity are relatively rare in young children, and typically present with significant impairment in academic functioning, STUDENT appears to be faring relatively well, intellectually. This ‘intact' cognitive and intellectual functioning is, unfortunately, very deceptive and may mislead his teachers and mother into believing that ‘all is well' when, in fact, STUDENT's internal world is full of terrifying, hostile fantasy figures who serve to threaten him. (Student Exh. pg. 92.)
The evaluators recommended that STUDENT receive continued pharmacotherapy (i.e. medication), weekly psychotherapy sessions, and that his mother and teachers remain "vigilant to any escalation of his symptoms." (Student Exh. pg. 92.) Dr. Deborah Lynn diagnosed STUDENT with Psychosis Not Otherwise Specified (NOS) and recommended ruling out obsessive-compulsive disorder. (Student Exh. pg. 140.)
STUDENT was also admitted to the inpatient unit of the Neuropsychiatric Hospital for observation from March 14-20, 1997. (Footnote 6) STUDENT received a trial dose of an antipsychotic medication (Risperdal) during his hospitalization, was given an EEG, which came back normal, and was discharged having displayed no psychiatric symptoms during his stay. (Student Exh. pgs. 123-156.) The NPI inpatient staff recommended that STUDENT continue living at home with his mother, continue taking the antipsychotic medication, and that he receive special education and mental health services in conjunction with an IEP. (Student Exh. Pg. 136.) The discharge diagnosis was the same as that made by the outpatient team, i.e. Psychosis NOS. STUDENT received no PET scan during his two weeks at NPI.
An IEP team meeting was scheduled for March 26, 1997, to consider the results of the UCLA/NPI evaluation, but proceeded only as a brief discussion or conference, because PARENT objected to the absence of STUDENT's classroom teacher. (Footnote 7) (Dist. Exh. 12.)
STUDENT received private tutoring for approximately two weeks in late March before he returned to West Cottonwood Junior High School on April 11, 1997, pursuant to the parties' stipulated agreement. When STUDENT returned to Ms. Malloy's class in April, he was "almost too good." (Testimony of Ms. Malloy.) STUDENT was quiet, kept to himself, was on task most of the time in class, and very kind to his classmates. STUDENT still had difficulty with homework, but would often complete his homework at school. STUDENT continued in Ms. Malloy's class with a 1:1 instructional aide until the end of the school year.
On April 19, 1997, STUDENT began receiving regular diagnostic and medication services from private psychiatrist Dr. Richard Powell. Dr. Powell also worked on relaxation skills and reality testing with STUDENT, but did not provide psychotherapy. Dr. Powell assessed STUDENT for obstructive sleep apnea, but final results from the sleep study were not available at the time the hearing concluded.
On April 21, 1997, Carol Purcell, consultant with the Quality Assurance Unit, Special Education Division of the California Department of Education (Department), notified PARENT and the COE that the Department had opened a compliance investigation (#I-294-96/97) in response to PARENT's request. Two alleged violations were to be investigated, but only Allegation No. 1 is relevant to the issues in this case, i.e. whether there was a "failure to provide a free and appropriate education in regard to costs for mental health related services." (Mental Health Exh. pg. 462.)
On May 13, 1997, James Norton, school psychologist and program specialist for the COE, completed a functional analysis assessment of STUDENT to determine if he needed a behavior intervention plan (BIP) as provided for under the Hughes Bill. Mr. Norton determined that, although STUDENT did not fit the Hughes Bill criteria, he could benefit from a behavior intervention plan. (Dist. Exh. 17.) Therefore, Mr. Norton made several recommendations for STUDENT's IEP team to consider.
On May 15, 1997, John Simmons, clinical social worker with Mental Health, completed an AB 3632 assessment of STUDENT Mr. Simmons concluded that STUDENT was eligible for up to two mental health contacts per week as determined by Mental Health, and that his eligibility for such services began on March 6, 1997. (Student Exh. pg. 67-76.)
On June 13, 1997, Dr. Bryan Crum with Shasta Eye Associates gave STUDENT a vision examination and confirmed that STUDENT still required eyeglasses for his bilateral amblyopia and astigmatism. In a July 9, 1997 letter to the District, Dr. Crum stated that STUDENT's vision problems could affect his academic performance and that he should be "encouraged to function as much as is tolerated by his vision." (Student Exh. pg. 300.)
On July 19, 1997, Dr. Richard Komm, an educational psychologist, completed a psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT Dr. Komm concluded that STUDENT is "clearly SED" and exhibits an "incipient schizophrenic process that appears to be developing." (Student Exh. pg. 60.) Dr. Komm recommended that STUDENT be placed in a residential treatment setting, and that he continue to receive appropriate medication.
On September 24, 1997, the Department issued a Compliance Report with findings regarding Allegation No. 1. (Footnote 8) The Department's conclusions were as follows:
The Shasta County Office of Education is in compliance; the agency convened an IEP team meeting to discuss the placement of the pupil, initiated a mental health referral and provided a free appropriate public education.
The Shasta County Department of Mental Health is in compliance regarding the allegation because a determination regarding the assessment costs [for the UCLA/NPI evaluation] has been completed in a mediated agreement and the issue regarding payment of psychiatric services is in due process. The Shasta County Department of Mental Health is out of compliance due to the [sic] referral for mental health assessment was made on March 6, 1997 and not completed until May 15, 1997, 19 days beyond the 50 day time line to develop an individualized program for the pupil as required by ED 56344.
The Cottonwood Union School District is out of compliance regarding the requirements of EC 56341(c) stating, in part, that ‘when appropriate, the team shall also include the following persons: (2) other individuals, at the discretion of the parent, district, special education local plan area or county office who possess expertise or knowledge necessary for the development of the individualized education program.' A representative of the mental health agency providing services to the pupil and that was requested by the parent to attend the February 26, 1997 IEP team meeting was not invited to participate. (Mental Health Exh. pg. 462.)
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The Student contends that he should have been found eligible for special education on the basis of SED either during the 1995-96 school year or earlier in the 1996-97 school year. He claims that his eligibility was established only when he became a liability risk to the District in February 1997. The Student argues that he was denied a FAPE from February 26, 1997 to the end of the school year because the Live Oak placement was inappropriate and was the only placement offered to the parent, and the 1:1 instructional aide in his second 1996-97 placement at West Cottonwood Junior High was improperly trained. He requests reimbursement for tutoring services in March 1997 as a remedy. The Student also claims that he is entitled to reimbursement for Mental Health services, private psychiatric services, and psychotherapy from 1995, when he should have been found eligible as SED.
The Student argues that reimbursement for the UCLA/NPI assessment should be paid by Mental Health under the interim mediation agreement of May 19. The Student also requests as compensatory education art therapy and related transportation, updated prescription lenses, and a number of other mental health related services.
The Student contends that neither the District nor Mental Health has made an offer of services for the 1997-98 school year, and that he is not appropriately placed this year because the stipulated educational placement at West Cottonwood has not been fully implemented. The Student asserts that residential placement may be appropriate for the 1997-98 school year, but, if not, he requests continuation of his private psychiatric services with Dr. Powell, and psychotherapy provided by a specific staff member at Mental Health.
The District contends that the Student was not eligible for special education services under the criteria of SED during the 1995-96 school year or earlier than February 26, 1997, and that he was not denied a FAPE during the end of the 1996-97 school year. The District argues that it is not responsible to pay for either the UCLA/NPI neuropsychological evaluation or Dr. Komm's psychoeducational assessment because the District's assessment was accurate and complete. The District also claims that STUDENT's current educational placement in regular education with a 1:1 instructional aide is appropriate for the 1997-98 school year and that "he does not require the myriad of related services that the parent seeks in order to receive FAPE." (Dist. Closing Argument, pg. 2.) Finally, the District contends that, because STUDENT was identified as SED at the appropriate time in his school career, he is not entitled to the compensatory education services requested.Mental Health contends that it has no legal responsibility to pay for either the UCLA/NPI evaluation or the evaluation by Dr. Komm, because the UCLA/NPI evaluation was not authorized by Mental Health and Dr. Komm's evaluation is flawed and unnecessary. Mental Health argues that it must be the sole provider of STUDENT's mental health services under the law, and states that the Student's various reimbursement requests for psychiatric, psychotherapeutic and other related mental health services must be denied. (Footnote 9)
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue No. 1: Should the District have found the Student eligible for special education services on the basis of serious emotional disturbance (SED) during the 1995-96 school year, or before February 26, 1997 during the 1996-97 school year?
Under state special education law, one or more characteristics, listed below, must be exhibited "over a long period of time and to a marked degree" for a student to qualify for special education services due to a serious emotional disturbance.(Title 5, California Code of Regulations (CCR) Sec. 3030(i).) The characteristic(s) exhibited must also "adversely affect" the student's educational performance. (5 CCR Sec. 3030(i).) The definition of serious emotional disturbance in federal regulation, based on the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), also includes schizophrenia, but does not apply to children who are "socially maladjusted, unless it is determined that they have a serious emotional disturbance." (34 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) Sec. 300.7(b)(9).) (Footnote 10)
The characteristics which indicate serious emotional disturbance according to state regulations are as follows: (1) An inability to learn which cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors. (2) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers. (3) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations. (4) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.
(5) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems. (5 CCR Sec. 3030(i).)
1995-96 school year
In February and March 1996, STUDENT was evaluated for possible learning disabilities as a basis for special education eligibility. As part of that evaluation, STUDENT's social and emotional functioning were also evaluated, although not for a suspected disability of SED. The school psychologist, Carole Nason, administered two behavior assessments, the Achenbach's Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL), parent and teacher versions, and Behavior Disorders Identification Scales: Home and School versions (BDIS). (Student Exh. pg. 102.) Neither the results of these assessments nor Ms. Nason's observations of and interview with STUDENT caused her to conclude that STUDENT fit the SED characteristics. (Testimony of Ms. Nason.)
On the CBCL, STUDENT's fourth grade teacher rated him as "very often arguing a lot, defiant, boastful, demanding attention, disturbing other pupils, talks out, stubborn and loud." (Student Exh. pg. 102, emphasis in original.) The teacher also rated STUDENT as "sometimes acting too young for his age, clinging to adults, teased, complaining of being unloved, not getting along with other pupils, feels others are out to get him, and not liked by other pupils." (Student Exh. pg. 102, emphasis in original.) In her report, Ms. Nason noted that, although these ratings were "within the borderline range of clinical significance," the teacher's self-report indicated that STUDENT's social skills and his classroom behavior had greatly improved over the past year. Ms. Nason reported that the assessment rating by STUDENT's mother "failed to indicate a significant problem scale." (Student Exh. pg. 102.)
Ms. Nason stated in her report that the BDIS assessment was specifically designed to document those behaviors most indicative of emotionally and behaviorally disordered students. The BDIS raw scores are converted into five factor scores representing the five characteristics of the federal definition of emotionally disturbed/behaviorally disordered--i.e. learning problems, interpersonal problems, inappropriate behavior or feelings under normal circumstances, unhappiness or depression, and physical symptoms or fears. (Student Exh. pg. 103.) The scores are scaled, with a mean score of 10 and standard deviation of 3, and scores between 7 and 13 are considered to be within the statistically average range. Scaled scores below 7 indicate a cluster of troubled behaviors which are more than one standard deviation below the mean. STUDENT's ratings by his teacher and his mother were within the average range, except for the learning, interpersonal and behavioral ratings of his teacher, which were one standard deviation below the mean. (Student Exh. pg. 103.)
Classroom teacher (Ms. Ristagno) Mother (PARENT)
SS SS Learning 6 Self-control 12 Interpersonal 6 Interpersonal 12 Behavioral 6 Behavioral 10 Depression 10 Depression 13 Fears/Symptoms 8 Fears/Symptoms 11
At the hearing, Ms. Nason testified that the scaled score of 6 on the BDIS is a borderline score. She also testified that she observed STUDENT weekly on an informal basis during the 1995-96 school year, and did formal observations of STUDENT two or three times that year. Ms. Nason knew STUDENT from a "CARE group" that she ran at school to help children develop more social skills. Based on these observations and the February-March 1996 assessment, Ms. Nason testified that STUDENT did not fit the SED criteria. Further, she stated that no assessment data from STUDENT's mother supported such a conclusion, and that STUDENT had made gains in the fourth grade and eliminated angry outbursts because he responded positively to Ms. Ristagno's classroom environment. Based on this evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the District evaluated STUDENT's behavior in its 1996 psychoeducational assessment, but that neither the test results nor observation of STUDENT provided grounds to suspect that he was SED at that time.
In addition to Ms. Nason, four other witnesses (Dr. Cuddeback, Mr. Hinds, Ms. Ristagno, and Mr. Buck) testified about STUDENT's behavior during the 1995-96 school year. However, none of these witnesses described behavior that would qualify STUDENT as SED. Dr. Cuddeback testified that she treated STUDENT for behavior problems relating to school and family settings. She stated that STUDENT's school problems included non-attentiveness in class and refusal to follow directions, but he had no problem forming relationships with schoolmates and family members. Ms. Ristagno testified that STUDENT did an excellent job in groups and that he socialized with other students in class. She stated that he got angry but never threatened others, and was no more rude than other fourth grade students. Ms. Ristagno did not observe STUDENT to have mood swings during the day.
That year, STUDENT was performing within the "broadly average to above average range in all basic academic skill areas." (Student Exh. pg. 105.) He was considered a very capable student, but his main difficulty in fourth grade was off-task behavior and not wanting to complete his work or do homework. (Testimony of Ms. Ristagno, Mr. Hinds, Ms. Nason.) Therefore, based on this evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that, although STUDENT displayed some behavior problems during his fourth grade year, there was no persuasive showing that he fit any of the five SED characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree, or that his educational performance was adversely affected.
The Student has argued that the fecal smearing incident that occurred at the end of the school year is the "key sign" to establish that STUDENT was SED in the 1995-96 school year. That incident standing alone, although certainly inappropriate and unusual, does not demonstrate that STUDENT was seriously emotionally disturbed. The Student has also failed to show how that incident adversely affected his educational performance, especially considering that he concluded the year with grades significantly better than those he received at the beginning of the year, and that the incident was an isolated one. (Footnote 11) (Dist. Exh. 36.) Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that, although STUDENT exhibited an "inappropriate type of behavior under normal circumstances" in the fecal smearing incident, he did not exhibit that behavior in several situations over a long period of time and to a marked degree, and it did not adversely affect his educational performance. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the fecal smearing incident alone did not satisfy that SED criterion and make STUDENT eligible for special education services.
The Student also states that it is significant that the District knew he was in therapy at Mental Health with Dr. Cuddeback and had been in the "CARE group" to develop social skills. The Hearing Officer agrees that the evidence clearly indicates that the District knew STUDENT had behavior problems and was in counseling at Mental Health during the 1995-96 school year. (Student Exh. pg. 184; testimony of Dr. Cuddeback, Ms. Nason, Mr. Hinds.) However, these facts do not add any real substance to an analysis of whether STUDENT qualified as SED in 1995-96, and also did not necessarily put the District on notice that STUDENT should be evaluated as SED. Many children are in counseling who are not SED, and many school districts work with children who have behavior problems but are not SED. Therefore, based on all of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the Student has failed to prove that he fit any of the five characteristics which would establish that he was SED in the 1995-96 school year. The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT was not qualified for special education that year on the basis of SED.
1996-97 school year
On February 26, 1997, the District convened an IEP team meeting at which STUDENT was found eligible for special education services on the basis of SED. In her psychoeducational assessment, Ms. Nason recommended that STUDENT be found SED due to his "history of an inability to build and/or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers, inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations, and indicators of a general pervasive mood of unhappiness." (Student Exh. pg. 97.) Ms. Nason also noted the steps taken by the District earlier in the 1996-97 school year to address STUDENT's problems in the regular education setting. She stated that, despite these efforts, "STUDENT's behavior has been erratic and success has been somewhat limited." (Student Exh. pg. 96.)
The overall picture of STUDENT's behavior during the 1996-97 school year, before he was found SED, is consistent with the school psychologist's observations and conclusions. STUDENT's behavior was clearly deteriorating at school, with increased incidents of defiance toward his teacher, mood swings, and verbal and physical aggressiveness. (Testimony of Ms. Malloy; Mental Health Exh. No. 1, pgs. 40-88; Dist. Exh. 2.) Despite these difficulties, Dr. Cuddeback's mental health progress notes concerning her weekly sessions with STUDENT and his mother reflect periods when STUDENT was in control and "doing well" either at school or at home. (Mental Health No. 1, pgs. 78, 76, 87, 46, 63-66.) The record also indicates that STUDENT's "acting out" was, at least in part, a temporary response to the issues he was facing in counseling and the death of his grandmother in October. (Mental Health Exh. pgs. 71, 40-88.)
Even though STUDENT's behavior was deteriorating to a degree, his grades do not reflect a significant change in educational performance until the second quarter in late January or early February 1997. At that time STUDENT's grades in reading, English, spelling, science, and social studies all went down, while his grade in physical education remained the same (D+), and his "F" in math went up to a "D." (Dist. Exh. 36.) (Footnote 12) Considering that STUDENT is of above average intellectual ability, this change was significant and indicates that his educational performance was declining by mid-year, near the time the District found him eligible. Further, STUDENT's behavior at school was also affecting his educational performance at this time, as he had two incidents of physical aggressiveness in February 1997. The first resulted in a one-day suspension on February 6, and the second incident resulted in the District assessment finding him SED.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's behavior and academic performance gradually began to worsen over the six months before he was found eligible as SED. The change in STUDENT's behavior and academic performance was not dramatic but cumulative. Because of this, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not have reason to determine STUDENT eligible as SED any sooner during the 1996-97 school year than it did because the three limiting factors (i.e. over a long period of time, to a marked degree, and adverse affect on educational performance) were not satisfied. The Hearing Officer also finds that the District was appropriately attempting to handle STUDENT's problems before February 26 through various modifications in the regular education program as required under California Education Code Section 56031. Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT was not eligible as SED before February 26, 1997, during the 1996-97 school year.
Issue No. 2: Was the Student denied a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from February 26, 1997, when he was found eligible based on SED criteria, until the end of the 1996-97 school year?
The Student contends that he was denied a FAPE in each of his two placements which occurred at the end of the 1996-97 school year. He claims that his placement in the COE special day class at Live Oak School was inappropriate because no other alternatives were considered by the IEP team. The Student argues that the second placement -- a return to STUDENT's fifth grade, regular education class with a 1:1 instructional aide -- was inappropriate because the aide was not properly trained. (Student's Closing Brief, pg. 11.)
Live Oak COE special day class
Under state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free, appropriate public education. (Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401(8)(A)-(D), Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56000, et seq.) (Footnote 13) This right includes the important entitlement to certain procedural protections during the process of developing an IEP and placement for a disabled child. (W.G. v. Board of Trustees (9th Cir. 1992) 18 IDELR 1019, 1021; Hendrick Hudson Central School District Board of Education v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 181.) Among the most basic of these is the parents' right to participate in the development of IEPs and placement decisions regarding their child. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56341, 56342; 34 CFR Sec. 300.345, 300.533.) When appropriate, the IEP team must include other individuals who possess expertise or knowledge necessary for the development of the individualized education program. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56341(c)(2).) The parents also have the right to consent or not consent to all components of their child's program. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56346.) The District must also ensure that a continuum of alternative placements is available to meet the needs of disabled children. (Cal. Ed. Code 56361; 34 CFR Sec. 300.551.)
The Student has asserted a denial of FAPE on procedural grounds when STUDENT was placed at Live Oak. However, the evidence does not support the Student's position. Options other than the Live Oak special day class were discussed at the IEP team meeting -- specifically the District's special day class for SED students, and regular education -- but discarded in favor of the Live Oak class. (Testimony of Ms. Nason, Mr. Hansen; Student Exh. pg. 20.) Further, the IEP document clearly indicates that PARENT consented to the Live Oak placement, and some evidence indicated that she wanted STUDENT at Live Oak. (Student Exh. pg. 19; Dist. Exh. 12; testimony of Ms. Nason and Mr. Hansen.) However, the record is unclear as to whether PARENT fully understood that the placement she was consenting to in the IEP was not the Mental Health program at Live Oak in which she was interested. (Footnote 14)
The Student also argues that the District admitted at hearing that the Live Oak placement was inappropriate. However, the Student cited no testimony or documents in support of this contention. The Student is apparently referring to Stipulation No. 1 of the parties concerning any future placement at Live Oak. This stipulation concerned prospective placement and was not an admission that the COE special day class was inappropriate for STUDENT some five months earlier. In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP team considered at least two other placements for STUDENT before selecting the Live Oak special day class, and that PARENT consented to that placement. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT was not denied a FAPE in his first placement at Live Oak on these particular procedural grounds as alleged by the Student.
However, the evidence indicates that STUDENT was denied a FAPE for other reasons not argued by the Student. In its final Compliance Report, the Department of Education (Department) made a finding that, although PARENT requested that a representative of Mental Health attend the February 26 IEP team meeting, the District failed to invite one. (Mental Health Exh. pg. 462, finding #5.) The Department found the District out of compliance with the requirements of Education Code Section 56341(c)(2) for this omission. (Mental Health Exh. pg. 462.) From the remainder of the record, it is clear that Mental Health was not only not invited by the District, but also did not attend the February 26 IEP team meeting. (Student Exh. pg. 20; testimony of Mr. Hansen.) Although the Student has not argued this particular procedural ground for denial of FAPE, the Hearing Officer will analyze it in recognition of the Compliance Report findings placed in evidence and the importance of full parental participation and procedural rights as recognized in Rowley.
In W.G., supra, the ninth circuit court held that the failure of the school district to secure the attendance of all necessary parties at a preliminary IEP team meeting denied the student a FAPE on procedural grounds. (W.G. v. Board of Trustees, supra at 1021-22.) In so holding, the court stated that "the Act [IDEA] imposes upon the school district the duty to conduct a meaningful meeting with the appropriate parties" and that the district's failure to do so denied the parent full participation in the IEP formulation process. (Id. at 1022, emphasis added.)
Here, the parent was denied full participation because Mental Health did not attend the meeting despite her request that they be invited. The need for Mental Health's participation at this preliminary meeting to determine eligibility and placement should have been obvious to the District. Mental Health personnel had been significantly involved with STUDENT through weekly counseling for well over a year, and had unique knowledge and expertise to contribute. The District had prior contact with Dr. Cuddeback and was well aware of STUDENT's Mental Health involvement. (Testimony of Ms. Nason, Mr. Hansen, Dr. Cuddeback.) Because Mental Health was not present, important information on STUDENT's mental status, needs, treatment program, medications, and current issues in therapy was not available for the team's consideration. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that Mental Health did not attend the February 26 IEP team meeting and that their absence denied STUDENT's parent full and meaningful participation.
The lack of Mental Health input is also reflected in the deficient IEP prepared at the February 26 meeting. Most glaring is the absence of meaningful goals and objectives. The single goal listed on the IEP document states, "increase assignment completion and positive interactions with peers and teachers." The related objectives provide percentages for increased task completion (75%) and positive interactions (85%). (Student Exh. pg. 21.) This goal could easily apply to a substantial portion of the fifth grade student population in any given school, and so provides little guidance for those working with STUDENT Under special education law, the IEP must include more than one annual goal, and show a direct relationship between the present levels of performance, the goals and objectives, and the specific educational services to be provided. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56345(a) (2); 5 CCR Sec. 3040(c).)
The IEP also provides for extended year services but indicates that STUDENT's placement in the special day class will end on June 1, 1997, with no reference to what services will be provided during the extended year session. (5 CCR Sec. 3043(f).) Elsewhere on the IEP, the team states that STUDENT "has exhibited assaultive behavior at Cottonwood. Will be observed by the Shasta Day School staff to consider the Shasta Day Program...." (Student Exh. pg. 20, emphasis added.) The meaning and relevance of this statement is unclear and suggests to the Hearing Officer that STUDENT's placement was not designed to address his unique needs but rather to simply remove him from West Cottonwood Junior High for observation.
The IEP team also noted that STUDENT was "receiving therapy through Shasta County Mental Health. Did take medications to control behavior." (Student Exh. pg. 20.) However, there was no testimony or other evidence to show that the team considered a referral for AB 3632 assessment of STUDENT for mental health related services on February 26, or even discussed coordination between Mental Health and the District or COE absent a referral. (Gov. Code Sec. 7576(b).) Although such a referral is not mandatory, it would seem an essential, obvious step for the District to take given that STUDENT had just been found SED, and was known to have been in counseling for some time with Mental Health.
Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that these combined deficiencies resulted in denial of a FAPE to STUDENT in his first placement at Live Oak School. Mental Health's absence at the February 26 IEP team meeting not only limited the parent's ability to fully participate, but also likely contributed to the resulting cursory and deficient IEP. (Footnote 15 The Hearing Officer is also concerned that the evidence suggests that the District effectively abdicated its responsibilities to STUDENT at the February 26 meeting by deferring to what it considered to be PARENT's wishes in making the placement. Although the wishes of the parent are an important consideration in educational planning, the district bears the ultimate responsibility to assemble the necessary parties in order to effectively plan and provide an appropriate educational program. (W.G. v. Board of Trustees, supra at 1022.)
In light of this conclusion, it is unnecessary to determine whether STUDENT was denied a FAPE on other grounds. Further, it would be rather difficult to evaluate substantive FAPE issues as none of the parties presented evidence concerning STUDENT's unique needs at that time and how the Live Oak class was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit.
West Cottonwood regular education class with instructional aide
On April 3, 1997, the parties entered into a mediated agreement which stated:
STUDENT will be placed back in his regular education class with an instructional aide. He will start this program as soon as an instructional aide is hired, but no later than April 18, 1997. This will continue until an IEP is held at which time the IEP team will determine the necessity to either continue or discontinue this service. (Student Exh. pg. 5.)
There were other provisions in the April 3 agreement, but this language includes the sum of the parties' agreement concerning STUDENT's educational placement. (Footnote 16)
On April 11, STUDENT re-entered his fifth grade class with an instructional aide pursuant to the parties' agreement. (Mental Health Exh. pg. 462.) The aide remained with STUDENT until the end of the year. No subsequent IEP team meeting was held, so no further changes were made in STUDENT's placement. (Testimony of Dale Hansen, Ms. Hansen, CeCe Walters.) The evidence indicates that the parties followed their April 3 mediated agreement and that the placement met STUDENT's unique needs as determined by the parties, and provided him with educational benefit in the least restrictive environment.
After he returned to class, STUDENT was quiet, not physically aggressive, was on task most of the time in class, and considerate of his classmates. (Testimony of Donna Malloy.) STUDENT's aide assisted him in class, often by directing him to a task. (Testimony of Dale Hansen.) STUDENT still had a problem with homework, but would often complete his homework at school with the help of his aide. According to Ms. Malloy's credible testimony, STUDENT's classroom behavior was essentially the same as any other fifth-grader. Mr. Hansen testified that STUDENT showed improvement with the aide's assistance. STUDENT's grades for the fourth quarter were noticeably better than those of his second-quarter grades, and reflected improvement in every subject. (Footnote 17)
The Student claims that the District was to provide a "trained one on one aide for STUDENT during the school day" and that the training of the aide who worked with STUDENT was inadequate. (Student's Closing Brief, pg. 11.) The Student has cited no provision in the mediated agreement of April 3, or in special education law, which establishes either the need for training or the qualifications required for an instructional aide in these circumstances. The Hearing Officer is also aware of no such provisions. The express language of the parties' agreement is silent on the question of the aide's training. Common sense, of course, suggests that an instructional aide should be trained and prepared to assist STUDENT in class.
CeCe Walters, the aide who was assigned to STUDENT, testified credibly about her background, training and duties. She was "briefed" for the job and came from Live Oak, where she was an aide and had handled children with behavior problems. (Testimony of Ms. Walters.) Ms. Walters stated that her duties at West Cottonwood were to assist STUDENT during the day, to monitor his behavior, and to be with him at all times. She was not asked to modify STUDENT's behavior. (Testimony of Ms. Walters.) Although Ms. Walters' training was perhaps limited, there is no evidence to indicate that she was ineffective with STUDENT. She testified that STUDENT was doing his own work by the end of the school year. STUDENT's grades indicate significant improvement in his academic performance during the fourth-quarter. Further, there was no evidence of negative behavior by STUDENT during the fourth-quarter when Ms. Walters worked with him. Ms. Walters testified that STUDENT did not want an aide and was somewhat confrontational to her a few times, but that he had no "incidents" of which she was aware.
Based on all of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the parties did not include the training and qualifications of the instructional aide in the express terms of their mediated agreement of April 3, and that the aide who worked with STUDENT was adequately trained. The Hearing Officer also finds that the aide carried out her duties with STUDENT effectively, as reflected by his overall performance in the fourth-quarter. Because STUDENT was placed in a regular education classroom with supplementary assistance for his entire school day, he clearly had opportunity for "maximum interaction" with nondisabled peers. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56031.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the West Cottonwood placement adequately addressed STUDENT's needs, that he received educational benefit from the program designed by the parties, and that his placement provided the least restrictive environment. The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT was not denied a FAPE during his placement at West Cottonwood Junior High at the end of the 1996-97 school year.
Issue No. 3: Is the Student entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the March 1997 neuropsychological assessment by the UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute and related travel expenses? Is the Student entitled to reimbursement for the independent psychoeducational assessment completed by Dr. Komm?
UCLA/NPI assessment
On May 19, 1997, the parties entered into a mediated agreement concerning payment for the UCLA/NPI assessment. The parties stated that they agreed to the following: 1. Payment by Shasta County Mental Health for UCLA Psycho- Neurological Testing Evaluation Assessment the sum of $1800-2000 contingent upon: a. Receipt of UCLA Billing to PARENT and from PARENT b. Independent, direct verification from UCLA on outstanding/or paid for billing from UCLA. (Student Exh. pg. 10.)
The Department acknowledged the existence and validity of this agreement in its final Compliance Report, stating that Mental Health is in compliance "because a determination regarding the assessment costs has been completed in a mediated agreement...." (Mental Health Exh. pg. 462.)
There was no evidence presented to indicate that this agreement was invalid, and nothing on the face of the agreement suggests that it is not a final agreement of the parties. Further, none of the parties has offered legal argument to show that the agreement is invalid. A mediated agreement is a binding contract between the parties and will be considered as such by the Hearing Officer absent evidence to the contrary. The purpose of prehearing mediation is to encourage the parties to resolve as many issues as possible for judicial economy. (Cal. Ed. Code. Sec. 56505(c).) It would be counter-productive for the parties to enter into a mediated agreement, only to have the Hearing Officer later ignore the results. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will order the parties to comply with the terms of their May 19, 1997 mediated agreement on this issue. Which costs will be reimbursed and what actual amount will be paid within the $1800-2000 limit is to be resolved by the parties in accordance with their agreement.
Dr. Komm's evaluation
Under Education Code Section 56329(b), a parent has the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil from qualified specialists, as defined by the regulations of the board, if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency. If the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent evaluation. (Cal Ed. Code Sec. 56329(b); see also 34 CFR Sec. 300.503.) The results of a private independent educational assessment must be considered by the school district in ensuring that the child receives a FAPE. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56329(b).)
The Student initially requested that Dr. Komm's assessment be reimbursed but did not re-state this request or offer argument in support of it in his closing brief. Thus, it is not clear to the Hearing Officer if reimbursement is still being sought by the Student or if the issue has been abandoned. In an abundance of caution, and because the issue was presented for hearing initially, the Hearing Officer will discuss and decide it.
Both Mental Health and the District argue that the Student's request for reimbursement for Dr. Komm's evaluation should be denied because the evaluation was completed, not due to disagreement with the District's assessment, but in preparation for hearing. Mental Health and the District also identify several ways in which they believe the evaluation was inadequate.
To prove that its assessment was appropriate, the District must establish that the testing and assessment materials were not discriminatory, provided in the student's primary language, validated for the specific purpose for which they were used, and administered by appropriate, trained personnel. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56320(b).) No single procedure may be used as the sole criterion for eligibility. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56320(e).) The pupil must be assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability, and any psychological assessment must be conducted by a credentialed school psychologist. (Cal. Ed. Code Secs. 56320(f), 56324(a).) Finally, the written assessment report must cover a number of specified areas and be prepared by the person who conducted the assessment. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56327.)
Here, the uncontested evidence indicates that Ms. Nason, a credentialed school psychologist with the District, assessed STUDENT in both 1996 and 1997, and prepared the assessment reports with her findings and recommendations. In 1996, Ms. Nason assessed STUDENT for possible learning disabilities using a number of standardized tests and procedures commonly administered to evaluate children with this suspected disability. She also observed STUDENT in class and in the testing environment. As discussed above, Ms. Nason assessed STUDENT's behavior at that time, and administered two tests for that purpose. In 1997, Ms. Nason completed an "addendum" to her 1996 evaluation, and assessed STUDENT for a suspected disability of serious emotional disturbance. In the 1997 assessment, Ms. Nason relied upon the psychodiagnostic evaluation of STUDENT completed by Mental Health in August 1996 under the supervision of Dr. Trustman. (Student Exh. pg. 96.) Although Ms. Nason's 1997 assessment report was brief, it was complete and covered the information necessary to provide an update on STUDENT's behavior and the legal basis for determining that he was SED.
The Student has not identified any specific deficiencies in either of these assessments by the District, and the Hearing Officer finds none. The Student's contention that the District failed to find STUDENT eligible as SED earlier than 1997 and the implied criticism of the District's assessment process has been considered and decided by the Hearing Officer in Issue No. 1. The Student does not dispute the conclusion that he is SED, and Dr. Komm agreed with this conclusion in his assessment. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds no evidence which indicates that STUDENT was denied an appropriate evaluation or psychoeducational assessment at public expense when he was assessed in 1996 and 1997. The Hearing Officer concludes that the Student may not be reimbursed for the costs of the independent assessment of July 19, 1997 by Dr. Richard Komm.
Issue No. 4: Have the District and Mental Health offered appropriate mental health services to the Student for the 1997-98 school year? Must the District and Mental Health fund certain mental health services requested by the Student, including those provided by a specific private psychiatrist and psychotherapist?
On the second day of hearing, the parties stipulated to the educational component of STUDENT's program for the 1997-98 school year, leaving only the issues regarding the mental health component of his prospective program for hearing and decision. (See Stipulation No. 3.) The Student argues that he needs residential treatment. However, the Student also argues alternatively that, if the Hearing Officer determines that a residential placement is not appropriate, he requires psychiatric services (i.e medication management) from Dr. Powell under contract with Mental Health, and psychotherapy from Judy Tarkington of Mental Health at a neutral site. (Footnote 18) The Student requests that these specific individuals be made a part of the order.
The District contends that STUDENT does not need mental health-related services to benefit from his education. The District points out that STUDENT has performed well without such services since he was found eligible for special education in February 1997. The District agrees that STUDENT and his mother would benefit from counseling, but argues that such counseling is not necessary for educational purposes. (Dist. Closing Argument, pgs. 12-14.)
Mental Health asserts that it has offered to provide services to STUDENT and that it should be the sole provider of the mental health component of STUDENT's program. Mental Health contends that, under both state and federal law, its services are appropriate and the most cost-effective. Mental Health also indicates that it will tailor its services to meet STUDENT's needs by assigning Dr. Trustman or Ms. Tarkington to provide psychotherapy and by offering therapy and medication management at a neutral site.
The Student has failed to prove that he requires residential treatment services to benefit from his education. Dr. Komm was the only witness who testified that STUDENT should be placed in a structured, residential setting. (Footnote 19) However, the Hearing Officer did not find Dr. Komm's testimony particularly persuasive because he did not adequately support his recommendation. He stated that the residential setting was necessary due to STUDENT's potential for "behavior breakthroughs" which could not properly be handled in an open setting. However, Dr. Komm made no direct contact with school officials, Mental Health, or Dr. Powell, STUDENT's treating psychiatrist at that time, to review the efficacy of this recommendation. (Testimony of Dr. Komm.) Dr. Komm also seemed unaware of many aspects of STUDENT's school experience during the 1996-97 year. Particularly troubling to the Hearing Officer was Dr. Komm's testimony that an aide would not be appropriate for STUDENT in an open setting. This testimony ignored STUDENT's successful experience with an aide during the end of the 1996-97 school year in Ms. Malloy's fifth grade class, as well as the parties' stipulation to such a placement for the 1997-98 school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the Student has not proven that he requires a residential treatment setting to benefit from his education during the 1997-98 school year.
The issue of whether the District and Mental Health have offered STUDENT appropriate mental health services for the 1997-98 school year, and the companion issue, whether STUDENT may receive those services from specific individuals, have already been resolved by the parties' mediated agreement of May 19. (Student Exh. pgs. 6-10.) That agreement provides as follows:
3. Payment for billing from Dr. Powell of current statement of $420 is contingent on SCMH's review and approval based on agreement that STUDENT's mental health services will be transitioned completely to SCMH: a. Whether it is established that Dr. Powell is a Board Certified Psychiatrist and that he is providing services related to STU DENT's Psychological-Medical services that are Educationally Related Treatment needs. b. SCMH must receive prior to approval or consideration of payment written report as to what Dr. Powell is treating STUDENT for and how he is actually performing the treatment i.e. what is being prescribed or done. c. If approved payment of current billing is forthcoming then SCMH will pay for up to three additional sessions to transition STUDENT's care to SCMH for all educationally necessary psychiatric services. Dr. Trustman will participate in three sessions held by Dr. Powell for the purpose of transitioning STUDENT back to SCMH. The appointment must be at a mutually agreeable time. 4. There will be at least one session with Dr. Powell and Dr. Trustman prior to June 13, 1997. 5. PARENT hereby gives permission for a verbal exchange of information between Dr. Powell and the SCMH psychiatrist. 6. SCMH will not pay for any services provided by Dr. Powell beyond the three transitional sessions authorized by this agreement. 7. Parent will not seek reimbursement for any sessions attended by STUDENT with Dr. Powell prior to the transition sessions. 8. Upon receipt of satisfactory information of Dr. Powell's curriculum vitae, and written report of educationally related services as noted in No.3 a & b of this agreement, the parties will submit for payment to be made to PARENT within 30 days. (Student Exh. pg. 10.)
Both the Student and Mental Health have argued that the May 19 agreement should be followed as to some issues and ignored as to others. It is not possible to have it both ways. As stated previously, this agreement is a binding contract between the parties. Although it is not artfully drafted, the agreement to transition STUDENT back to Mental Health has not been proven invalid in whole or in part. The Student claims that PARENT "rescinded" the May 19 agreement apparently due to STUDENT's threat to commit suicide if he had to return to Mental Health for services. (Footnote 20) However, the Student has also asked that the same agreement be implemented to reimburse PARENT for the costs of the UCLA/NPI assessment. The inconsistency in these two positions is obvious.
In the May 19 agreement, the parties acknowledged that STUDENT needs mental health services by delineating a transition plan to terminate his services with private psychiatrist Dr. Powell, and to return STUDENT to Mental Health. The parties provided for prospective services by an unspecified Mental Health psychiatrist and for transition services by a specific psychotherapist, Dr. Trustman. (Footnote 21) This acknowledgment of STUDENT's need for psychiatric services for medication management and for psychotherapy is consistent with the clear weight of the evidence at hearing. The evaluators at UCLA/NPI, John Simmons, who prepared Mental Health's AB 3632 assessment, and Dr. Powell, all recommended that STUDENT receive medication management from a psychiatrist, and psychotherapy. (Testimony of Dr. Powell, Student Exh. pgs. 66, 75-76, 91-93.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the May 19 agreement regarding STUDENT's prospective needs for mental health services, which include medication management and psychotherapy, is consistent with the evidence at hearing and appropriate.
In implementing their agreement, the parties must be particularly attentive to STUDENT's fragility. He testified that he would kill himself if he had to go back to Mental Health. The Hearing Officer takes this threat, and the trauma which caused STUDENT to feel this way, very seriously. Nevertheless, the Hearing Officer also notes that STUDENT's upset does not have to do with actual counseling or therapy provided by Mental Health, but results from his mother's dispute with that agency regarding referral and payment for the UCLA/NPI assessment. (Testimony of STUDENT, Dr. Trustman, Dr. Pappas.) This decision resolves that issue. Therefore, it is time for all concerned to move forward and focus on STUDENT's treatment needs in order to assist him in benefitting from his education.
The extensive testimony and documentation concerning Mental Health's decision (before the April 3 agreement) to deny PARENT's request for referral and payment of the UCLA/NPI assessment, indicate that STUDENT's suicide threat was precipitated by these events. Because two Mental Health staff members are particularly closely associated with STUDENT's traumatic experience, the Hearing Officer will order that these individuals -- Dr. Pappas and Dr. Trustman -- not be direct service providers to STUDENT This is in no way meant to impugn the quality of their work or the appropriateness of their actions in the past. It is also not meant to encourage such precipitous behavior on STUDENT's part, but to recognize his unique needs at this time. Dr. Pappas testified that there were four physicians who could handle medication maintenance for STUDENT at Mental Health. Dr. Trustman testified that he never saw STUDENT for a full session, and that it would be very difficult to begin treatment if STUDENT refuses therapy. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that, because of the trauma STUDENT has experienced as a result of his mother's dispute with Mental Health over the UCLA/NPI assessment, his unique needs require that the Mental Health staff persons associated with that event -- Dr. Pappas and Dr. Trustman -- not be his direct service providers. The Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT's unique needs require that he receive medication management and therapy at a neutral, non-Mental Health location.
The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT's mental health component as designed by the parties in their May 19, 1997 agreement will meet his unique needs, as long as direct services are provided by Mental Health staff other than Dr. Pappas and Dr. Trustman, and all services are provided at a neutral, non-Mental Health site. Although this conclusion will result in a minor modification of the parties' agreement (i.e. by removing Dr. Trustman as the psychotherapist to provide transition services), the change is not a material one. (Footnote 22) The agreement does not clearly specify which Mental Health staff person will provide ongoing psychotherapy to STUDENT, and the Hearing Officer makes no finding in this regard.
Issue No. 5: Is the Student entitled to reimbursement for co-payments made for Mental Health services; private psychiatric services, medications, and other expenses; private psychotherapy; and tutorial services during March 1997? Is the Student also entitled to compensatory education in the form of art therapy and related transportation, reimbursement for eyeglasses, counseling, parent training, recreational therapy, additional psychotherapy and family counseling, and additional recreational therapy for social development?
Because the Hearing Officer has concluded that the Student was denied a FAPE in regards to his Live Oak placement as a result of procedural violations at the February 26 IEP team meeting, he is entitled to reimbursement for tutorial services in March 1997. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District must reimburse STUDENT's parent in the amount of $154 for tutorial services during the period of March 17 through March 29, 1997. (Student Exh. pg. 433.)
The Hearing Officer has concluded that the parties' agreement of May 19, 1997 determined STUDENT's needs for mental health services for the remainder of the 1996-97 school year. Provisions for reimbursement for the private psychiatric services of Dr. Powell are contained in this agreement. The Student has not shown that he received any psychotherapy services during this time, so his request for reimbursement for such services is moot. In the May 19 agreement, the parties also stated in item No. 2 that "Shasta County Mental Health (SCMH) agrees to waive up to $277 for services rendered for STUDENT at SCMH." (Student Exh. pg. 10.) The Hearing Officer finds that this provision is a binding contract between the parties. Therefore, Mental Health must waive up to $277 for services rendered to STUDENT in accordance with its agreement of May 19.
The Hearing Officer has concluded that the District had no basis upon which to find STUDENT eligible as SED anytime sooner than February 26, 1997. Therefore, all the Student's requests for compensatory education remedies, namely art therapy and related transportation, reimbursement for eyeglasses, counseling, parent training, recreational therapy, additional psychotherapy and family counseling, and additional recreational therapy for social development are denied.
ORDER
1. Within 30 days of the date of this order, the District shall reimburse the Student's parent in the amount of $154 for tutorial services received by STUDENT during the period of March 17 through March 29, 1997.
2. Within 30 days of the date of this order, the District, Mental Health, and the Student shall comply with and implement term No. 1 of their May 19, 1997 agreement regarding payment for the UCLA/NPI assessment.
3. Within 30 days of the date of this order, the District, Mental Health, and the Student shall comply with and implement terms No. 3 through 8, inclusive, of their May 19, 1997 agreement regarding STUDENT's transition back to Mental Health services, EXCEPT that: a.) as to the date of June 13, 1997 in term No. 4, the parties shall establish a new date as soon as possible but no later than 30 days from the date of this order; and b.) neither Dr. Lynn Pappas nor Dr. Robert Trustman of Mental Health shall be direct service providers to STUDENT; and c.) all transition and ongoing sessions of psychotherapy and medications management with STUDENT shall occur at a neutral, non-Mental Health location.
4. Within 30 days of the date of this order, the District, Mental Health, and the Student shall comply with and implement item No. 2 in the May 19, 1997 agreement regarding waiver of $277 in costs for Mental Health services already provided to STUDENT.
5. The District shall convene an IEP team meeting within 15 days of the date of this order and develop an appropriate IEP for STUDENT for the 1997-98 school year. The IEP team shall include Mental Health, specifically the direct service providers from that agency (i.e. psychiatrist and psychotherapist), and Dr. Powell. The IEP team shall develop appropriate goals and objectives for STUDENT for the 1997-98 school year. The team shall also consider the recommendations of James Norton in the functional analysis assessment completed May 13, 1997 and develop a behavior intervention plan for STUDENT, if determined appropriate. Finally, the IEP team shall also specify STUDENT's special education and mental health related services for the 1997-98 school year. These services shall include: a.) continued placement in a regular education sixth grade class at West Cottonwood Junior High with the assistance of an appropriately trained 1:1 instructional aide, as per Stipulation No. 3 of the parties; and b.) mental health related services providing medication management by a Mental Health staff psychiatrist other than Dr. Pappas, and psychotherapy by Mental Health staff other than Dr. Trustman. The frequency of service and other related matters shall be determined by the IEP team in accordance with the recommendations in John Simmons AB 3632 assessment completed May 15, 1997.
6. The District, Mental Health and the Student shall comply with and implement Stipulations Nos. 1 and 2 during the 1997-98 school year.
7. All other requests for relief by the Student are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
1. Should the District have found the Student eligible for special education services on the basis of serious emotional disturbance (SED) during the 1995-96 school year, or before February 26, 1997 during the 1996-97 school year?
The District prevailed on both parts of this issue.
2. Was the Student denied a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from February 26, 1997, when he was found eligible based on SED criteria, until the end of the 1996-97 school year?
The Student prevailed on this issue as to the Live Oak School placement. The District prevailed as to the West Cottonwood Junior High School placement.
3. Is the Student entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the March 1997 neuropsychological assessment by the UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute and related travel expenses? Is the Student entitled to reimbursement for the independent psychoeducational assessment completed by Dr. Komm?
The Student prevailed on this issue as to reimbursement for the UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute assessment and related travel expenses. The District and Mental Health prevailed as to reimbursement for Dr. Komm's assessment.
4. Have the District and Mental Health offered appropriate mental health services to the Student for the 1997-98 school year? Must the District and Mental Health fund certain mental health services requested by the Student, including those provided by a specific private psychiatrist and psychotherapist?
The District and Mental Health prevailed on both parts of this issue.
5. Is the Student entitled to reimbursement for co-payments made for Mental Health services; private psychiatric services, medications, and other expenses; private psychotherapy; and tutorial services during March 1997? Is the Student also entitled to compensatory education in the form of art therapy and related transportation, reimbursement for eyeglasses, counseling, parent training, recreational therapy, additional psychotherapy and family counseling, and additional recreational therapy for social development?
The District and Mental Health prevailed on this issue except that the Student prevailed regarding reimbursement for tutorial services during March 1997.RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56505(i).)
DATED: January 28, 1998 ________________________________________ JoAnn Irwin-Eshelman, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES
1. Shasta County Office of Education was dismissed as a party on the second day of hearing.
2. In his closing brief, the Student, for the first time, asserted grounds for special education eligibility (i.e. ADHD and ODD) which were not previously noticed to other parties in his August 4 Statement of Issues or at the hearing. Special education eligibility may not be established solely based on the diagnosis of ADHD. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56339(a)-(b).) Likewise, ODD (oppositional defiant disorder) alone generally does not satisfy the criteria for SED. No significant evidence was presented by the Student in support of these alternative grounds, and, as noted above, these bases for eligibility were not properly noticed before the hearing. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer has not included the ADHD or ODD grounds in the eligibility discussion.
3. On the entire first day of hearing, August 12, 1997, the parties engaged in settlement negotiations.
4. STUDENT reported being sexually molested at the age of six years by a stranger he met in a park and by a school counselor--both in Oregon. (Mental Health Exh. pg. 273-276.) STUDENT later recanted these reports to his Mental Health therapist, Dr. Trustman. (Dist. Exh. 18.)
5. PARENT requested the PET scan because she had seen a television show indicating that it was a useful diagnostic tool for orphans from Romania who had been abandoned and later had behavior problems. (STUDENT was born in Guatemala City and abandoned by his birthmother for the first two weeks of life. PARENT found him there and adopted him.) PARENT had a sense of urgency about completing this test because she understood that the scan had to be done before the child was 12 years old, and because an earlier misdiagnosis of STUDENT's vision had left him with a condition which could no longer be corrected.
6. STUDENT's medications, administered through Mental Health, were discontinued in late February 1997 in anticipation of his NPI evaluation. (Mental Health Exh. pg. 30, 32.)
7. PARENT presented a document at this meeting (see Mental Health Exh. No. 8, pg. 446) which she represented as the UCLA/NPI discharge summary. In its final Compliance Report, the Department of Education made a finding that this document was not a discharge summary from UCLA/NPI and that the patient advocate whose name appeared as a member of the evaluative team was not a member of that team. (Mental Health Exh. pg. 462.)
8. The Department also issued a Compliance Report on August 1, 1997, but rescinded it after the parties requested reconsideration. (Student Exh. pgs. 361-366.) The Compliance Report of September 24 is the Department's final report. (Mental Health Exh. Pg. 462.)
9. Mental Health also contends that the parties' May 19 agreement is a valid settlement offer which should be considered by the Hearing Officer in determining prevailing parties under the newly amended IDEA.
10. See footnote 11, infra.
11. STUDENT's grades at the first grading period were five "Cs," one "D," and three "S'." His final grades for the year were two "As," one "B," three "Cs," two "S'," and one "U." (Dist. Exh. 36.)
12. STUDENT's other grades for first and second quarter respectively were: reading C+, D+; English B-, C; spelling A-, B+; Science B, C-; social studies B+, C-. (Dist. Exh. 36.)
13. The IDEA was amended on June 4, 1997 (Public Law 105-17), approximately three months after the Student and District submitted their requests for due process hearing. Because this case arises under the former law, the Hearing Officer will apply the prior law in effect at that time under principles of retroactivity. (Landsgraf v. USI Film Products (1994) 511 U.S. 244.)
14. The Department made a finding in its Compliance Report that the meeting was convened "to discuss the parent's request that her son be moved from the district elementary school to Live Oak School, a county-operated program where the Department of Mental Health also provides service to a Diagnostic/Clinical class for pupils with serious emotional disturbance. The parent disputes that she made the request, but acknowledges that she was interested in the Diagnostic/Clinical classroom." (Mental Health Exh. pg. 462.)
15. The Hearing Officer is well aware that there was a subsequent IEP team meeting on March 6 which included the AB 3632 assessor from Mental Health, and resulted in the team's recommendation that STUDENT continue in the Live Oak placement. The Hearing Officer is also aware that PARENT withdrew STUDENT from Live Oak after only six days of attendance. The Hearing Officer makes no finding as to the effect of these subsequent events, if any, on the denial of FAPE as a result of defects in the February 26 IEP team meeting.
16. The parties also agreed that "Shasta County Mental Health is offering psychiatric services in the area of medication management by Shasta County Mental Health staff. PARENT has rejected this offer due to the fact that STUDENT is being seen privately by a psychiatrist." (Student Exh. pg. 5.) STUDENT continued to receive private mental health services until the end of the school year.
17. STUDENT's fourth-quarter grades were: spelling, "A"; physical education, "B"; English, "B-"; and reading, math, science and social studies, all "C+." (Dist. Exh. 36.)
18. Judy Tarkington's name came up during Dr. Powell's testimony, when he testified that he was unwilling to work with Mental Health personnel except for Ms. Tarkington.
19. Dr. Powell testified that he recommended a residential setting to STUDENT's mother because STUDENT needs "consistent, constant supervision" and medication management. However, Dr. Powell also testified that STUDENT should first have a "trial" period with medication management and psychotherapy while living at home.
20. Even if PARENT did rescind the agreement, no evidence was presented to indicate that the other parties consented to such an action. (See Witkin, Summary of California Law, 9th ed. I Contracts, Sec. 874.)
21. Due to inartful drafting, the agreement indicates only that Dr. Trustman will provide transition services, not ongoing psychotherapy.
22. In its closing brief, Mental Health argued that Ms. Tarkington should replace Dr. Trustman, and that this change in the May 19 agreement is not material. (Mental Health Closing Argument, pg. 21.)
